TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 35 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

336 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

4:29 Economic Development Commission meeting for April 13, 2016. Roll call, please. Commissioners Chang. Commissioner Chang. Hello. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Here. Commissioner Verruck. Here. Vice Chair Greick. Here. And Chair Brown. Here. Thank you. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance, and Dawn, do you want us to lead us in the pledge? I pledge allegiance to the flag.

5:05 At this time, we'll have public comments. Public comment is that portion of the agenda where any member of the public has an opportunity to speak on any issue that's not currently on today's agenda. Do we have anybody for public comments? Okay.

5:39 If we have nobody to speak for public comment, we'll close the public comments period and we'll move to our first presentation, which is a status update on the outdoor events venue facility location search. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, Madam Chair, Commissioners, staff, members of the public, Rich Blatchier, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Quick update on where we are at the Outdoor Performing Arts Center. Quick history.

6:03 MLR started their due diligence on capital projects back in July 1st. We went back as far as 1999 and we found recurring themes throughout the documents. Town Council approved priority phase projects on December 16th. One of the priority phase projects is that of the Outdoor Performing Arts Center. We put a committee together. We started out with 37 different pieces of parcel. We got it down to six. We brought it to Town Council as expanded to seven.

6:31 And we're in the process right now of meeting with the town council next Wednesday, April 20th, to ask for the direction. So a quick summary of where we are on those parcels is as follows.

6:41 One of those sites is Sam's Wood Site. As you know, that property, we understand, may be an escrow at this point in time. We're looking at that as a short-term solution. Rumor has it that we may be able to use that as a short-term solution, perhaps through the summer of 2017. That would be great for some of the events that use that facility at this point in time. It gives us a little more time to get organized.

7:02 The Canyon Lodge facility. I've talked to Bill Cockcroft. They're interested in sitting down, once again, as a short-term solution, engaging in a conversation about the use of the facility. You know, one of the conversations is food and beverage, ticket sales, you know, how do the logistics works and pricing, et cetera. Any short-term solutions are probably two years, give or take a little bit. I talked to, let's do the easy ones first. I talked to Evan Russell over at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

7:32 Evan, as you know, is up to his eyeballs in the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. He's making an updated presentation to the MLR Board on May 2nd, trying to get him out in front of Planning Commission, trying to get him out in front of Town Council during late May or early June to bring people up to speed in terms we are, where he is. We're looking at a grand opening, probably December of 18, if those cards fall in place correctly. As Evan said, Rich, if we're still on the list, we'll entertain the conversation, but I'm fairly busy right now, so we're not quite sure where that one fits.

8:01 The parcel was the parcel we're looking at long-term, short-term. It was added to the roster at our March 2nd Town Council meeting. I think one of the rationale for that is it is town-owned property.

8:10 That's one of our biggest challenges. If I sit down with MLR and you look at what the price of property is in town, do I want to spend X on purchasing property or do I want to spend X on building an infrastructure that can provide economic development to this community and the shoulder season specifically? So a bell-shaped parcel would need to do probably a wetland delineation study. I've been working with staff, went over and saw Triad, Gary and Tom. The last time we did a study was in 2004. It was 12 years ago.

8:40 They recommended we do a new study. The town put an allocation request in in November. It's about $12,000, $10,000 of the study, $1,000 of contingency, $1,000 of staff time. MLR board approved it on April 5th. I'll bring that to council on April 20th. We'll try to capture that piece of data over the summer months. And then you've got the...

9:02 The public lands managed by the U.S. Forest Service. You know, we're challenging and sitting down and having a conversation with those folks about how do we make these things work. You know, it's not can we, it's more about how do we make this work. You know, some very strong relationships between other forest district managers and their communities and wish we could replicate some of those promising practices that they have. But we're looking at the Mammoth Park East property.

9:26 We're looking at the RV Park East property and the snow pit, which is up behind the visitor center. The committee that worked together, we started out with 42 strong, came down to a group that's about 12 that fairly met fairly often, kind of moved things along. I think most of us, you know, my own personal opinion, the snow pit is probably the...

9:44 Probably the number one priority at this point. We like where it is slightly out of town. We like the fact that you've got transportation drop-off at the visitor center. We can envision 10 years down the road the goal of this facility is to build a complex. They can house 5 to 7,500 people for an event, kind of where Bluza Palooza is right now. Probably 3 to 5 to get us off the ground. Do it in a place where we're not going to cause too much of an impact on this community. The snow pit is high.

10:10 You could put MUPS back there. You could extend campsites back there. It really could be a pristine site. You know, the night under the stars, listen to music, you know, all that kind of good stuff, camping opportunities. But we need to have the conversation with the Forest Service. So we're still working on those. So those are the seven. We know we need to do some wind studies. I talked to Howard Schechter again this morning. I talked to...

10:35 Chris Steincombe from NOAA out of Nevada. He's hooked me up with the University of Utah and Meso West. They do wind studies for us. Talked to another gentleman who'd do three wind studies for $11,000, which is, I think, affordable because he wanted $8,600 for one. I said, I'll give you $1,200 for three. So if it moves in that direction, perhaps we'll get there. But we'll do wind meters in area-specific once we hone this area down a little bit more. So that's kind of where we are right now.

11:05 I'm hoping that Council will give us a little more direction about where we go next, but the wetland studies up and running, we'll get that going, and hopefully we can engage the Forest Service in conversations about the reality of coming up with some kind of agreement, you know, how do we make this work? Not can we, but how do we make this work?

11:22 Perhaps we do have some short-term solutions with the wood site at this point in time that could keep us there for a couple of summers. It gives us a little bit of time to regroup. You know, once again, we prefer to find ways to invest in infrastructure versus purchasing land, land exchanges, because those take many, many years. And, you know, I think for many of us, it's a sense of urgency in this great place called Mammoth. So that's kind of a short update where I am. I'm open for any questions you may have for me.

11:48 So before we go to questions, I just want to kind of frame our conversation today. One of the reasons I asked Rich to come and actually be on their agenda is because I feel as planners that we can give some very specific feedback to council. So I primarily would like to talk about, you know, how these various seven sites fit into our planning matrix.

12:16 How it fits into our current zoning matrix. And then maybe we can go back and talk, you know, in our Dr. Sed's document, our destination resort document, that always talked about multiple event sites of different sizes. So I just felt that it would be really useful if we commented on those three things.

12:44 Or anything else that you'd like us to comment on. And then maybe we could give some, you know, you could give feedback in a consensus way from Planning Commission. Very good. Does that work? Very good. And let me just remind the commission, the role of this Outdoor Performing Arts Committee, Ad Hoc Committee, is to identify a parcel that could seat 5 to 7,500. Okay. With the option to grow.

13:07 Over time. Out of all those 37 parcels we looked at, we have many, many venues that are much small that have variations on theme for different types of groups. Okay. So you really just want input then on the large event parcel? Oh, that's the target of this conversation. Okay. If we could stay there, I think that would narrow the conversation. Okay. Please. Would you like me to...

13:32 Start there. Sure. Okay. So, from a planning perspective, one reason I had Sandra bring our district planning concept map, I think it's really important, it's a little difficult to see, or maybe it's just my eyes this afternoon, but, you know, we have our, a very well-defined downtown Main Street district, we have a very well-defined North Village specific plan, and then we have our

14:02 Secondary area, which is really the Mammoth Creek Park area. And if I think one of the statements that we would like to make, if everybody's in agreement, and certainly Sandra and Ruth too, if you have comments, is that I think what we really want to say from a planning point of view, that it's really, we would give priority.

14:25 Long-term perspective. Okay.

14:56 And don't forget to turn your mic on so we can ultimately hear you. Hear my words of wisdom. Anybody else have any comments about that? I just have a quick question for Rich if it's time to start bombarding him. Hey, Rich, what is your sense of when you'll have an idea of the short-term viability of the wood site in terms of summer of 2017? Is there any sort of negotiation or conversation on that at this point?

15:29 Quiet conversations between the folks that are negotiating for the purchase of the land. You know, that still is quiet. We're not privy to those conversations. I'm cautious about what I say. I've been told to, you know, not put my fingers on that just yet because it's still being negotiated. Got it. So to be determined. Okay. And then is there an ongoing conversation with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area about the possible use of Canyon Lodge as a short term?

15:58 Facility? Correct. We've been working with another group called Mountain Sports International. They're event management groups. I've reached out to three or four. And I'm asking them to bring me criteria for what is it going to take to bring an event management group into town to do events for us? What are the criteria looking for? Opportunities and constraints? What kind of venues? You know, for the most part, I'm hearing it's the great experience that Mammoth brings. They tell us we'd love to partner with you.

16:29 But give me something. Sell me that dream. I'm just not going to look at a parcel and say, yeah, I'm not going to build something for you. I'll partner with you. But we need to really come to grips with a parcel, begin some design work so we can say this is what this could look like, and then begin to take it out for programming. And then I guess my final question, Rich, was it sounded from your opening statement that maybe the bell-shaped parcel was not initially part of the final.

16:56 List of possible venues, and it was added in a little bit later. I'm wondering maybe what some of the reasons were the bell-shaped parcel was not initially included in that final list, some of the obstacles you see with that piece of land. So the committee talked about some of the potential mitigation measures. Is it wetland? How big is it? Number one.

17:18 My neighbors, I want to be cognizant of my neighbors and the types of noise mitigation, traffic mitigation, the types of challenges that would bring. We want to make sure we do our due diligence. We all have a smaller sense of community, but we want to...

17:35 Now, if I look at some of the planning documents I've seen so far, that was really zoned for open zone and kind of passive recreation. And if we're looking at bringing in three, four, five fairly large events with five to 7,500 folks a year, you know that it's not quite aligned with passive recreation. So we're being asked to step back and regroup and look at it a little bit more so it's still on the table.

17:55 So the ultimate goal of whatever venue, wherever it's located, is to program it aggressively throughout the summer and fall and possibly the winter so that it's in the black. Correct. Thank you. And any project we do at this point in time, you know, we look at business plans, you know, working on the Park West project, you know, what's the recovery rate?

18:16 You know, I probably looked at, you know, not going too far sideways, probably looked at, talked to 40 different general manager ice rinks around the, around the West Coast, you know, and most of them are privately run because they want to make profit on it. The ones that were run by towns, they weren't making money. Not that we have to make money on everything, but we can't be, we can't be subsidizing things to the...

18:35 To the 80%, 90%. We just don't have that kind of money. Right. So we've got to look at, you know, it's a business plan. How do we program it? How do we minimize the recovery costs on this? And what's that gap going to be? That if we're building with measures on money and we're leveraging some of those funds, it's going to be on that plate, restricted funds for the duration of that project. Thank you, Richard. I think there's a little bit of a connection between what Michael was talking about with the bell-shaped parcel and the difficulties.

19:06 That you were saying the reasons why the group originally eliminated it and how that relates to the possibility of locating a big, a large events venue at one of the three key gateway areas, Mickey, that you were talking about, primarily being proximity to neighbors and to residential areas. Just looking at those three areas, it doesn't...

19:33 I mean, it's a difficult choice. I mean, the snow pit is really not exactly close to one of those, although it's not, I'd say, far from our main gateway. Well, no, so far as being close to key centers, you know, I think, obviously, the wood site and I think the snow pit, I mean, could be workable. And then you have the RV Park East. RV Park East. Right.

20:07 And then, in my opinion, then maybe like Canyon Lodge, as far as a planning standpoint of view, gets like a half. Right. Well, just because there's so much transportation infrastructure built into that. Sure. And it animates one of our key economic areas, right, when that gondola's. So maybe it's three quarters or something. Okay. I mean, that was kind of how I saw the planning part.

20:32 The zoning, maybe Sandra you can expand a little bit more on the bell-shaped parcel as far as the current zoning of that.

20:40 Yes, so the bell-shaped parcel is currently zoned open space. That was changed in 2010. It was zoned resort prior to that. Okay. However, the northern portion of the bell-shaped parcel, the northern about eight acres, was acquired through condemnation. And when you condemn a property, you have to condemn it for a certain purpose. And so it was condemned for recreational and or performing arts use. So that was the purpose that the town said there is a need for this.

21:09 And what happens, in your opinion, if you do a water...

21:38 Delineation study after four years of drought. I mean, granted, this year is a little bit better, but. Yeah, I think, I mean, I think it probably differs every year. So I think that the scientists would take into account the drought, take into account that as they do their analysis. Right. Probably looking back at the documents that have been prepared previously. But it's certainly a factor, I'm sure, when they're going to be looking at that property. Okay. All right. So then on that short list,

22:06 So the wood site, what happens as far as zoning on the wood site? The wood site is a zone North Village specific plan. I think it's the SL zone. Do you know? I think it's SL. Yeah, so I think that performing arts type uses are permitted there.

22:27 You know, so it's a lower density than kind of the core of the North Village specific plan. But other uses that would be permitted there are hotel, transit, rental, those kinds of things. So there's kind of a broad range of uses that are permitted there. If there was a use that was contemplated on that site that didn't quite fit into one of the use categories, staff would probably bring that to commission for a determination.

22:50 to see whether the commission felt that it did fit into that category or it did not fit into that category and then the applicant, the property owner would have to move forward depending on how the commission determined that.

23:01 Use. But it wouldn't be a DZA. It would just be an interpretation? I think if there was a use that was kind of close to one of the uses that we thought might fit in there, we could do an interpretation to say this is very similar to this use that's listed as a permitted use and you can move forward with it in that manner. We did that with the brewing company, Mammoth Brewing Company, in their current location. So it's not something we haven't done in the past. Okay. What about the Mammoth Lake Foundation site?

23:31 I'm not that familiar with the Mammoth Lake Foundation site. I think that they, performing arts is, I think it's public space, public quasi-public out there, and performing arts is a permitted use out there, and I'm not sure if they need a use permit or not off the top of my head. Okay. But I know that that location has been contemplated in the past. Okay. And then your other, so then the Mammoth Park East, the Snow Pit, the RV Park East are all Forest Service, right? Correct.

24:01 Well, technically, I guess Canyon Lodge is Forest Service. Correct. It's under special permit. Okay. All right. Okay, and then you basically, so, do we need to, like, summarize, basically, what we just said about zoning, or are you? I heard two pieces here. Okay. Your priority would be on the North Pacific plan, which is kind of around the village, correct?

24:36 And the downtown to be your priority items. Right. And then we talked about staff, Sandra just talked about Belle Shea Parcel. Right. How the zoning is at this point in time. Those are the two major points I've heard thus far. Right. I think our biggest challenge is we're very limited in space that we have for opportunities for this. Right. You know, what kind of player, what kind of negotiations, what kind of conversations can we have with the Forest Service? Okay. Are they open for, you know.

25:02 You know, a special use permit, one time, short term, et cetera. You know, I've reminded our forest ranger that, you know, when you guys do events or activities, you get 5% of the gross. And he reminded me that he gets an X factor from the feds. And that if he encringes on that or encroaches on that X factor by getting other funds from other places, it's decreased, which doesn't provide him with the opportunity for entrepreneurship whatsoever. You know, which I think we've got to look at how the...

25:29 Maybe looking at policy decisions down the road and maybe looking at some of the forest revision plans that are going on at this point in time. Well, I think I'm too old to take on Washington, D.C. Oh, yeah, Mickey, you're never too old for anything. You rise to the occasion, you fight the right fight for the right reasons, and you keep going. All right. Yes. Just a couple of questions. Based on what you just said, I just want a little bit of clarification on that. So you're saying that the Forest Service, depending on the...

25:58 The stream of revenue that any of these given events that's tied to the Forest Service, potentially their income, if you want to call it, diminish? That's what I've been told, correct. I see. And a lot of their funds that are generated, from what I understand, don't stay in the local zone. They go back to D.C. for reallocation. Got it.

26:21 It doesn't provide them with, as I said, the entrepreneurial spirit. You know, how do you work with the community to generate revenue? I mean, you look at, you know, some of the work we're doing right with MLR, and we're doing a challenge cost share agreement with the forest to put $80,000 of our funds in the trails maintenance this summer. I felt like we were twisting arms. You know, we're willing to work. We're not giving you the money, but we'll do the work to clean up your trails. You know, how do we engage in more of those partnerships where we leverage funds to do things that are in the best interest of the common good?

26:53 Another question on the parcel, the Bell Shade parcel. Other than the wetland factor, what other factors that are important based on your 2004 study versus the upcoming study you might be doing? Well, I think, you know, looking at the parcel itself, I think that what Rich would say is looking at, there's adjacent.

27:22 I think our biggest concern was making sure we're being good neighbors, working with the neighbors,

27:52 In that area, there are 11 single-family homes for our full-time residents. There are 11 condo projects, 11 homes. All those are secondary homeowners. So you've got limited...

28:07 You know, homeowners in that area, but still we want to be cognizant of the impact. And if it was a one-time event, you know, the comment was made at County Council meeting on March 2nd, well, you do blues-a-palooza, you know, it's only once a weekend, but people know it's coming. They realize, you know, the activity, the animation that that event is going to create, so a lot of people leave town. If we were to do four or five events like that, of that magnitude on that parcel, I'm sure we'd have some pushback.

28:34 So in a small town like this, we need to be good neighbors. We need to respect one another. We've got to be visitor-centric and local-centric, what's good for the citizens. We've got to take care of our own, and we want to support some of the things we're doing. So as we look at this venue, where's the best place to put this that's going to least create, you know?

28:52 Chaos, as I call it, controlled chaos, regardless of the economic impact. We've got to find that balance. We've got to find that balance. And as Joe Bacon said on March 2nd, Richard, this has been easy. We would have found a solution to this 10 years ago. I know. And that's why we're struggling with it right now. You know, so we'll see where it goes. You know, you go through the process, you have the conversations, you build the partnerships, and at the end of the day, you know, it'll land on the ground somewhere. And with that, I thank you for your time. Well, and then let me just...

29:20 And then we should just, is there anybody in the public that'd like to give us some comments? I know we'd like us to increase you from three quarters to like $99. I can't speak to Canada. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. You know, I just would lend a few comments to the discussion. You know, as you look at these sites, I think you have to, you really have to think about how you're going to stage 7,500 people.

29:54 to a site. How are they going to get there? So a lot of people want to drive and park, right? And you start adding up how many cars that would be to have, you know, half that number of people show up in a car, in a vehicle if there's, I don't know, I mean, for the ski area, we figure two and a half people per vehicle for arrivals as our metric for staging for vehicle access.

30:20 But, you know, I look at, you know, like a site like the snow pit, I just wonder, like, how are people going to get there without having to build a gigantic parking lot that probably isn't realistic? And then, you know, a bus can handle 45 people if it's full, and you just start doing the math, and you go, my God, there's just no way you can stage some of these locations.

30:41 So I think that's, and I certainly want, the point where this thing actually gets some wheels and starts going, you're going to have to go through CEQA or CEQA-NEPA or whatever it's going to be, and those things will be analyzed in traffic analysis. But it might be something to consider up front, Rich, that you really think hard about, okay, how are these many people going to arrive there? Ideally, everybody could walk there, which then would imply you want to have it close to your hotbeds and your lodging.

31:09 Densities, you know, where you have the most density, and I think as Chair Brown pointed out, the village, and certainly has a lot of bed density in that vicinity. Ultimately, the village will have 6,000 pillows, so there'll be a lot of bodies there. Access by the Gondola Canyon makes some sense, right? We can get 3,000 people an hour up the gondola. Not to mention there's also transit access there as well as parking.

31:37 You know, other sites in town, they start to get difficult, but the other thing I would mention, and Chair Brown, you've mentioned as well, I mean, you know, how can you leverage this facility? The town's going to spend a significant amount of money on this capital improvement, and where's it going to be located where it's going to create synergistic effects on other commercial operations and activity? And certainly proximity to the downtown makes a lot of sense in that respect. It also will give you an opportunity to

32:07 Share parking, for example. You know, if there's a parking structure I'm thinking we can use for this event. Let's just say, for example, that the site is at the RV park. Town's contemplating a shared parking structure with the hospital on the municipal site there by the courthouse. Perfect opportunity to use probably fairly empty parking in the weekend to cross-utilize it for events.

32:30 I think one of the other things that I recall reading in one planning document, I don't recall which one, was that there was a notion that trying to combine the performing arts venue in conjunction with the outdoor event site together so that they could share common facilities such as concessions and bathrooms and stage and everything else.

32:52 Not a stage. I mean, obviously, you're going to have an outdoor stage for an outdoor venue, but if it's connected to the building, that's the indoor performing arts venue, that's a 300 or 400 seat venue. You know, they can certainly share bathrooms and concessions and those kind of things. So, you know, you don't have to build it twice. You know, sites like the college site, you know, again, I just have concerns about how people are going to get there. You know, it's not really walkable from any bed base, particularly.

33:19 And so they're going to have to go either by private vehicle or transit. And then how do you stage multi-thousands of people to a location like that? I just can't. In my head, I just can't see how you can achieve that. So those are food for thought. It's a challenging task for sure. Oh, one other thing I was going to mention to you that I've been working on some of this community planning stuff and was going back and rereading some of the documents that already exist.

33:47 That the town's prepared and the Main Street District Plan actually identifies Mammoth, excuse me, RV Park as a site, as a logical site to locate this. And they also, if you read the ERA report that was prepared in 08, it made mention that, hey, if you can locate some of these key amenities, particularly things like this that are going to be appealing to our visitors, near the bed base, near commercial cores, you can actually leverage

34:17 The amount of revenue you're driving on those locations by as much as 25%. So in the example of if it was at, say, the RV park, in somebody's lodging in the downtown, in our redeveloped downtown where we have a mix of commercial uses and lodging, those people can walk there, for one. They don't have to get in their vehicle and create other additional impacts with vehicle miles traveled.

34:44 Go out to dinner beforehand because they can walk to a cafe and then they can walk to the venue and go to the show and afterwards they can go out for drinks. If you go to a site like the snow pit or the college, what's going to be your path? What are you going to do?

35:04 Get in your car. You're going to have to drive there. So you might go out to dinner before. You go drive there. Then you might be too tired to go out afterwards. In any event, you know, if it's convenient and it's in a good location, you're going to drive additional revenues, by the way, of additional commercial sales and so forth. So I just don't think we can underrate the effects that these projects are going to have on the community and our economic growth. So as you guys are the Planning and Economic Development Commission, you need to consider all those factors.

35:33 I agree. Thank you very much. All right. Does anybody else want to comment? Yes, sir. Architect. I think Tom made some great points. Just a couple overview things. I mean, there used to be this event at Canyon a long time ago. The town bought a tent that they ended up throwing away after how many years? That was it.

36:03 Quite a debacle. But the event site was good. I mean, you could go there and it was a good experience. The Bell Parcel, yeah, I think there's concerns with the surrounding neighborhood for noise, that type of thing. The Bell Parcel history, at one point, Players Club was going to put a bowling alley there and do that.

36:31 Certainly familiar with that project. And what the town does with it, if they don't do the event or do something with it along this line, that's a pretty interesting question at this point. Maybe a smaller venue site, like you said, large venue site versus small, probably not a large venue site. Sam's Woodside, same problem. Access is horrible.

36:58 You clog up one of the primary streets in this town, and now that pushes all the traffic around to Old Mammoth Road. I think from a circulation point of view, it's not very good. Certainly from a location point of view, as far as bed base, where you could walk and access it, I think that part's definitely great. Both the snow pit RV park sites,

37:26 For a large venue seem to be more interesting. As Rich said, as a destination and something that you could go to if you needed to get 7,500 people there with noise, it's not near anything. That seems to have some logic behind it in my sense of things. Getting people there, you could still use the town trolley shuttle.

37:55 Besides cars and maybe encourage people to do something other than just drive. But when you get 7,500 people, that is a lot of people and a lot of transportation to get there. I've been to other sites and other projects like this back east of Wolf Trap Foundation, the only performing arts theater that's owned by the National Park Service.

38:21 You could talk to them about how that works in their relationship. And it's probably about that size. Might be a good study, case study to use for here. Anyway, those are my comments. Thank you. Oh, you're breaking my rules. No. I was just going to mention something that people might want to take a look at.

38:52 For a good example, I think, at least because I've done a little research as well, is Bend, Oregon, Les Schwab Amphitheater. Take a look at it on Google Earth. It's really cool because it's, I forget the name of the river. Is it Williamette River? It goes through town in Bend or something? Deschutes River, yeah. In any event, it's on the west side of the river, but then they have to actually build a bridge, a pedestrian bridge across the river, and it connects to this downtown commercial redevelopment zone that they did.

39:20 And there's limited service hotels. There's theaters there. There's like a 10-, 12-screen theater complex. There's a Hilton Garden Inn. There's a Hampton Inn. And then there's a bunch of retail shopping right next to the venue. So, you know, I think I'd be curious to talk to their planners at Bend and see what kind of issues they had with it. But it's real similar in size to the venue we're talking about.

39:45 From what I've seen. And they've had major headliners there like Dave Matthews Band and Coldplay has played there and just as an example. So it might be a good model for us to take a look at. Thank you. All right. Rich, did you have any other concluding comments or you're good? All right. Thank you very much. Remember, if it was easy, we would have answered this.

40:15 Thank you. Okay. We will now move on to our second presentation, which is the Mono County Office of Education, and our contact is Stacy Adler. And I'd just like to say that personally I'm really pleased that we're doing this. Part of the problem with our, well, except for one commissioner, is that we're not really tied into our school district because our children are grown.

40:42 And so we know you're true. Or. I got us covered. The whole commission. You've got one free time. But we really believe that, you know, our education is just key to our whole community. So we're happy you're here. I appreciate that. And I feel the same. And I'm happy to be here today. And, Sandra, thanks for reaching out.

41:03 Appreciate that. So Sandra contacted me and asked if I'd come and present to you all about our workforce education program that the Office of Education started a year ago. And it actually came about as a product of a conversation that I was having with Kathy Peterson, who's the Mono County Director of Social Services. So they had some funding and we had capacity.

41:32 The two entities came together, and Department of Social Services actually funds this work that my office does. The purpose of this program is to help people who are entering the workforce for the first time, such as maybe some of our high school seniors, and those who've been out of work and who are re-entering the workforce for various reasons. Either they've had some...

41:58 Legal troubles or they've been raising their kids and now they're ready to go back to work or for whatever reason they're re-entering the workforce. So some of the participants that we have in our program are mandated by social services because of the various entitlements and things that they're receiving require them to have some education component and so this program provides that. All the classes and materials

42:27 In these modules are free of charge to anybody in the public who wants to attend. We have classes that we're holding here in Mammoth Lakes twice a week, and then we also hold a class once a week in Walker, in the Walker area. How it works is we offer this program twice a year.

42:48 Once in the fall and once in the spring. We're currently in the middle of a spring module right now. There are four components, four classes to the program. Those classes or those modules are career development, job search and resume writing, interviews, and professionalism. And the classes have been fairly small, so we're really able to...

43:13 tailor the curriculum to the needs of the people who attend. People are welcome to take all four classes in the whole module and if they complete everything they do receive a certificate that is recognized by the Chamber of Commerce here in Mammoth. Or if people feel they just need to get help writing a resume or

43:37 Learning how to search for particular jobs or how to do an online job application, which is a relatively new concept for a lot of people. They can just come and attend those specific modules. So it's very, very flexible.

43:53 There are homework and tasks assigned if you attend each module. And as I said, participants that attend all four modules and complete all of their assignments are given a certificate and are recognized by that certificate.

44:12 Like I said, we've been working with the Chamber of Commerce that all the businesses that are a part of the Chamber recognize this certificate and give some preferential, not, just some preferences when they're interviewing for positions. So we're hoping to do, that that comes about. And we do have regular, almost about,

44:41 Bi-monthly meetings of the Workforce Education Collaborative that involves my office, Department of Social Services, probation, the chamber, Mono County Economic Development and Tourism.

44:58 The Mammoth High School principal, Chris Powell, sits on that committee, and we meet to evaluate how the program is going, what is our outreach looking like, how can we do better at bringing people into these classes, and continuing to work with the local businesses to help promote the certificate and people joining these classes. We also try to keep it tight.

45:26 Connection on what are our businesses really looking for when they're hiring people, what skills do they want them to have so that our classes are constantly evolving to better meet those needs. So that's the Workforce Education Program. Any questions about that? You all have flyers? We would really love to see...

45:51 More high school seniors participate in the program, and we do run it during a weekday afternoon and on Saturdays here in Mammoth to encourage students to attend. Do we have any questions? How is the program going? It's going well. We've had four people graduate with certificates, and this is our third cohort that we're in the middle of right now. So we'd like to...

46:21 Gain more popularity. We've also worked with the district attorney's office for them to, and we're working with probation also to add this program as a component of people's probation or programs if they are adjudicated in any way that this is mandated as part of what they're assigned to do. And what's the bilingual?

46:50 Component of this. We do offer translation. If somebody is non-Spanish speaking, we bring an interpreter with us to the class, and they can have the class in Spanish. So, yeah. We try to reach as many people as we can. Don't want to leave anybody out. We have a couple of other programs I'll just share with you really quickly, if that's okay.

47:17 Adult Education. My office is responsible for adult education and recently we received a large grant from the state of California for adult education. We had not received funding at all for adult ed for several years and operated programs in parenting and basic skills and English as a second language out of our general fund.

47:42 And now we received $185,000 from the state in ongoing funds to provide adult education, so we're very excited about that. Part of that funding, we are charged with cooperating with Cerro Coso Community College to offer basic skills classes, so those are classes for people who want to go into the community college system but aren't quite ready.

48:09 for that and whether they're newly immigrated here or high school students that don't quite have the skill level for community college, that's what those classes are.

48:20 The folks that those classes are targeted at. So we will be offering basic skills classes in English and math through our office. We will also be offering English as a second language. We'll be continuing to offer that as we have in the past. And we're very excited about two new classes that we're working with Mammoth, well, this first class we're working with Mammoth Unified School District, Cerro Coso Community College, and possibly, well.

48:49 That's all we're working with right now, that's all I'll say. To have welding classes. So we're very excited about that. And we'll be operating concurrent enrollment classes on Mammoth Unified High School's campus. And they'll be for high school students during the day and then adults through adult ed.

49:11 In the evening. So we're hoping to kick that off some point next year. We're also bringing in a translation and interpretation class. So what that will provide people is people who already have bilingual skills can come and attend this class. It's a 40-hour class. It's going to be taught by Catherine Allen. And that class will result in a certificate where

49:39 Whoever participates can obtain a position as an interpreter or a translator for meetings in the school district, for social services, in all areas except the courts. The courts have a different

49:56 Class, but this is a certificated class, it's not offered very many places in the state, so that we can have this program here is a really wonderful thing, and it will be offered at no charge to people who want to come take it, so it's a really wonderful opportunity for people, we think, and that class will be available to anybody who's 17 or over. Oh, great. Yeah, so we're very excited about that.

50:22 And then this summer, our Mammoth Lakes Library will be running their summer reading program for students. Michael, I hope your kids will be there.

50:32 All three of them. So the students, we ran that for the first time last summer. We're expanding it this summer. The students who participate in this program will continue to be able to continue their accelerated reading program, which they read and take a test and earn points and keep their reading levels high all throughout the summer, and they'll earn prizes.

50:59 Get to participate in other activities at the library during the summer months, so there isn't that summer drop-off that teachers like me just tread. So those are a couple other programs that we have going on. So any questions? Any questions?

51:17 So I'm sure you're aware, you know, our meetings are televised, which means they run constantly all month long. And while we often don't have many people in our audience, I mean, it's really a great forum for you to be able to spread information about what you're doing. And you're always welcome whenever we have time in our agenda to come or anybody else from your office. Wonderful. I appreciate the opportunity. Thank you. We'll take advantage of it. So thank you all very much. Was everybody in front of the public had any questions or comments?

51:48 Okay, thank you very much. Thank you. Now we'll move on to our third item, which is the status update on the community multi-use facility at Mammoth Creek Park West.

52:55 Okay. I would assume so. Faulty drug. That's good. You have this in your packet. It was just the most recent site plan for the multi-use facility. And I believe at least half the audience has seen it previously as well. It didn't like the one I put it in. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra. There we go. Thank you. What I'd like to do this afternoon is give you a brief update on where we are with the planning and programming process for the

53:51 Multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. This item will go before Town Council on April 20th. We're basically going to ask them to let us keep going, if you would. I was going to prepare a staff report for this for the Planning Commission packet as well, but we actually had our last program meeting last night here in Suite Z, so it was kind of tough to have that meeting and get it to you last week. But very briefly,

54:16 The Town Council authorized us on January 6th to have a consultant agreement with HMC Architects for preliminary design and some planning efforts and with Michael Baker for the environmental work for Mammoth Creek Park West.

54:30 On the next Monday, we got that whole team together to start the process. The key part there I want to mention is that we got the environmental consultant started at the same time as the architect, the planner, because we really are sensitive to the site itself and the comments we've heard about the neighborhood and the sensitive nature of this and the activities we want to plan on the site. So we want to make sure that we can mitigate every possible thing we can with the design.

54:56 The first thing, Michael, that HMC did was they came up with three alternate designs. And all this, by the way, all this information and a vast amount of other information is available on the town website at planmcp.com. We've been combining everything there since the last three and a half months, frankly. So there's a great deal of information there.

55:16 On January 29th, we presented three alternates to the community right here in this room. It was not quite standing room only, but it was pretty close. We had a good crowd, got a lot of good positive input, a lot of negative input, which is also very informative about things we need to look out for. After that, we got more input by letter, by email, by phone call, you name it, things, people submitted stuff to the website.

55:42 We also met with the environmental consultant and had them take a look at what we were doing to say, look, where can you see right away, without doing any analysis yet, where can you see things that we might want to begin mitigating immediately? We also started a separate process, which, well, not exactly separate, but let's say concurrent for the programming effort.

56:03 The Recreation Commission actually formed a recreation programming subcommittee, including two commissioners and several other stakeholders from here in town. And they had a series of six public workshops to look at all the aspects of this project. And by programming, I mean what do people want to see or what would they like to do on the site, whether it be volleyball, whether it be ice hockey, roller hockey, excuse me, ceramics, Zumba, you name it. It went on and on and on. In fact, the wrap-up last night,

56:32 Which again, a lot of this information will be posted on the website. Had another 15 or 20 people. In fact, over 20 people there. And the list covered most of that wall. I mean, it was a big workshop, three tables full of people going through the kind of things that they're interested in seeing happen on this site. With the information we got from the first couple of...

56:52 Programming workshops and her architect. We then came up with a preferred alternate, which is the one you see before you. We then brought it back to the public on March 18th and had another workshop here, probably had about 20 people there. In addition to, by the way, of having these workshops, were both held on Friday late afternoon of non-holiday weekends. We wanted to give the people that don't live in Mammoth year-round the best opportunity to come if they wanted to come and voice an opinion or have other input.

57:22 Excuse me. We had that on March 18th. We had actually sent notices out to residences within, I think, about 500 feet, so it covered most of the condominium complexes in the area, and we did get some pretty good response from that. We presented this one, and we also presented three items I want to share that aren't shown on here that we will be updating before we go to town council on April 20th.

57:45 Through the input we got and through a visit that some staff members named down, went down to Los Angeles and visited some other facilities, we found that three things might be important in the future. If you look at the upper left-hand corner of the buildings there, you'll see a kind of a brown oval.

58:02 One comment we had is that if we are to attract more hockey tournaments, as an example, or other indoor soccer tournaments during the summer, they're going to need more facilities and more lockers. So from a CEQA perspective, one of our goals was to basically create the largest footprint.

58:18 You know, as opposed to minimizing, we wanted to create the largest footprint so that anything we studied through CEQA would hold over time. In other words, we didn't want to come back in 10 years and say, gee, we want to add 3,000 more feet and have to start over again. So we're creating the largest footprint, not saying at all what we think the first phase is going to be yet, but we wanted to analyze as much as we could. So we may expand those buildings out to include, kind of square that little notch out of it off, if you would, and that's what you may see on April 20th.

58:46 Two other comments that don't really affect the CEQA process that will be changed is there was a great interest in having the community facility portion above the ice rink or multi-use facility portion by three or four feet. The reason is that if you glass in a portion of that as a

59:06 A couple people said their grandmother could sit up there on the parking lot, or others could sit there and not be cold. They didn't have to be down on the ice. A comment received from the public. They could be up there in a nice warm environment and watch rather than have to be outdoors, really, because this is an indoor-outdoor rink. It'll have a roof on it. Two sides will be open to the elements to an extent. So we want to do that to at least provide a viewing opportunity. The other is there were a lot of comments that we should consider an Olympic size.

59:35 Olympic only means that it's 15 feet wider. That's it. A standard NHL rink is 85 by 200. Olympic is 100 by 200. The great difference there is it opens us to the whole world of more professional or more serious ice skating because

59:53 Ice skaters need a certain size period because they're going to practice their routines, they're going to do things that mean a lot to that. In addition, we think that larger size would help provide better activities in summer and winter because if the boards are there, it makes it 15 feet longer to the north-south, a lot more flexibility. And that's one thing we've stressed to the public and to the architects all the way through this is flexibility. We don't know what we're going to be using this for in 10 years. There's other activities we don't know about.

1:00:19 Pickleball may have been around a long time, but I'd never played it or heard about it until last year, so the thing is there's something else could come around, and we want to be ready for all those things. The green blob, if you will, on the exhibit is the playground. It's reconfigured for two reasons. One is we wanted to get a little bit further from the multi-use facility, so right now it's showing at probably 50 or 60 feet from that wall. We didn't think it was appropriate to have a playground right up next to a 35.

1:00:49 Foot-Tall Building. So we wanted to push it east, but also we want to take advantage of current technology and current facilities that are available. We've engaged some playground experts, if you will, who are looking at the accessibility. The current playground, I want to note, does meet ADA standards. It is accessible, but there are things you can do from an inclusive standpoint. We're not talking about a full Shane's Inspiration, you know, that you may have heard about before. That was actually 20,000 square feet when we did our research.

1:01:17 We found that even most Shane's inspiration parks were anywhere from 5,000 to 10,000. This is 7,000 square feet, but we'd really like to include some more apparatus and some more opportunities for inclusivity. Where we're going from here is we're going to go to town council on April 20th. We're going to describe in great detail. I'm trying to hold the staff report to four or five pages, but we'll give a much longer presentation about some of the detail that we went through and the intense amount of community.

1:01:46 Input. And we're going to say, look, you authorize us in early January to hire an architect, hire the environmental consultant. We told you, and the rec commission, we told them on December 1st that we would have community meetings in January. We would have a preferred alternative for the community to look at in March. We would back to council in late April. We've done all those things on schedule within a day or two on schedule every time. We've made a commitment that if the funds are available and the town council is willing to, you know,

1:02:15 Make those happen, that we can open at least the ice rink on Halloween of 2017. That still holds. What's changed, however, is the project is not now just relocating or reconstructing the existing rink over here. Where we started was, let's move the rink, try to save the boards and put a metal roof on it, move the trailers over and open it. Through all the community input, it's clear that while there's a certain part of the community that would

1:02:44 Be happy with that. By and large, you're saying no. If you're going to do this, do it right. Have the right facilities. Have the right support facilities. Have more community space, more community rooms. So what we'll do once the environmental process starts, and where that would start as long as town council tells us to keep going, is, of course, notice of appropriation, scoping meetings often probably in May, but as soon as those things can happen.

1:03:08 Where it'll start as that's happening is we will go back and look at phasing. We'll look at detailed cost estimates for how we might make a facility and design a facility that works. It works on day one and everybody will be happy with. We're not going to kid ourselves that everybody would be happy if we just grabbed the old other rink and brought it over here because we'd get a lot of complaints.

1:03:33 We also are very realistic that we don't think we can afford, frankly, to build a new multi-use facility and 10 or 15,000 square foot of community space on day one because that's, you know, that's a pretty big undertaking. The town manager is already beginning discussions with Rich at MLR and with the town council to say, okay, what is the commitment? What is the level of commitment we want to put into this for phase one? How we want to get that done? That'll happen after April 20th and long before this comes.

1:04:02 Back to this body, hopefully in January is what we show on the schedule for consideration of an environmental document. One thing I will mention before I just open it up to any questions you may have is we have had comments that everybody wants to make sure this is a transparent process and includes everybody. We've had two mailings to the neighbors, two well-attended public meetings. We've had

1:04:29 Five individual workshops on various components of the project. We've had an all-hands workshop to summarize those. We even had a separate hockey workshop that was hosted by Mammoth Brewing Company. This has been before you before with brief updates. It's been to town council at almost every meeting, or at least mentioned at every meeting. It's been at every recreation committee meeting for the last several months. And I just would challenge and ask that if anybody in the public...

1:04:56 Hasn't been to the website, hasn't read the information, hasn't been to a meeting. We are not going to apologize for that because we've made, you know, to great extent, I mean, over dozens of meetings for people to have an opportunity. So if you hear of anybody who doesn't know, direct them to the website, tell them the CEQA process. Hopefully we'll just be starting and guess what? There'll be another round.

1:05:18 Public meetings and opportunity for input there. So it's completely been open book. Our intentions have been open book. And the fact that we don't have the money to build it all yet has also been very well stated. So that's it. Do you have any questions? Questions? Based on what your description, speaking on the economic side, you're thinking to expand this further?

1:05:51 And to have a world-class, Olympic-sized ice ring? Larger than this? Well, two comments. One is on the expand this further. We want to plan the buildings to be a little bit bigger, another, say, maybe 2,500 or 3,000 square feet. That doesn't mean we can build it today. But if the opportunity arises to build it in 10 or 15 years, and we haven't done the CEQA analysis of that.

1:06:19 We'd have to step back and start over. So the idea is to create the largest footprint that we can see happening in the next 30 years, get it on there and analyze that so we make sure we've got all those bases covered. In terms of the ice rink, what it really means is right now on the south side of that you see that long tan area. That's a 30-foot setback from U.S. Forest Service land. We really only need 20, correct, to meet the zoning requirement. So basically the roof would be 10 feet wider.

1:06:48 The boards then and the ice would be 15 feet wider. In terms of the overall size of the project, that's not significant. Yes, it is more money. In terms of you to say world class, the rink now is an NHL sized rink. That in itself is...

1:07:05 Fairly unusual. A lot of them are a lot smaller than that. By adding just 15 feet onto that, and yes, there will be some additional cost, we open up a whole different venue and opportunity for that that people are very interested in, if we can do it. And I'm assuming that there are probably talks during all the study sessions that you guys have that there are a lot of interested team players that wanted to come up and train up here? You know, I didn't, I wasn't at the actual meetings, but

1:07:35 Rich is still here, so I'm going to let him, if he would, please give 30 seconds on your trip down to Los Angeles, Rich, because it was very exciting. We're not convinced that the LA Kings is going to write a richer $1 million check, although he did ask for one, but they have offered some expertise. Only one, yeah. They have offered some expertise, and if we can get them involved even in name only or to give us a little bit of help, that brings some attention to it, so thanks, Rich.

1:08:00 Thanks, Grady. The first conversation with our partners down south, and it's about building partnerships. You know, they've done this before. They're excited about building our new ice rink in Mammoth. They love the experience. Everybody loves Mammoth. Ninety-one percent of our visitors come from Southern California. It's their playground. You know, talking to Brad Berman and Luke Robitaille. Rich, we'll help you design it. We've got the expertise. We'll help you program it.

1:08:22 We'll help with construction. But the biggest piece is programming. Because the worst thing we can do is build something in five years. It's dark. They're excited about it. And I step back and look at the larger picture for the vision for Mammoth. Who are we? Where are we growing? What does greatness look like? Really, we're trying to create a human performance environment in a natural setting.

1:08:42 What does that look like with Olympic training site aspirations? You know, they said to us, look at the Olympic ice because you're looking at, you know, USOC certification. What kind of venues do you have that meet international and international parameters? So we're not looking at competitive facilities, so we don't have the venues for it, but we're looking at training sites. You know, I'll go sideways for a second. I was down in Chula Vista at the USOC site this past Friday. You know, that's about an $8 million operating budget. NGBs pick up $5 million for athletes to train and live there.

1:09:11 International athletes, international NGBs bring in foreign athletes or international athletes to train. They're closing that facility. It's going to a third-party vendor. Talking to Alicia McConnell, who does the application process, what is the USOC looking for that I can craft my application to meet those parameters at this point in time? Part of that is the ice. We're looking at, is it Olympic? Is it NHL? Is it figure skating? Is it curling? What are those Olympic sports we can look at at this point in time? So there is interest.

1:09:40 Same thing, you don't ask, you know, I said, Luke and I were kind of going back and forth, he played for the Rangers, I'm a New Yorker, I said, Luke, I can make this easy, just give me a check for a million dollars when I get out of your hair. And he says, no, we want to make this work for you. So we're trying to build those relationships, you know, it's a good friendship right now.

1:09:56 We're continuing, you know, I met with Stu and Betsy this morning. You know, Stu's doing an email to their King's leadership team to say we had a conversation last night. This is where we're going, our next step in the process. We want to build those relationships. So we're looking for sponsorships, you know. Biggest challenge right now is, you know, when do we get these conceptual designs so I can build a perspective so I can go sell that dream? You know, people want it, but they want to see it. They want to taste it. You know, so those are some of the next steps we're doing. So if you have anybody out there that's interesting in, you know, becoming a part of this dream,

1:10:25 And you want me to talk to them, please feel free to send them my way. Thank you. Thank you, Paul. Thanks, Rich. Commissioner Rick, did you? No, no, I think nothing to say. I don't. Exciting, though. So, just to clarify, so basically when you're going to do your CEQA, you're going to do it on the largest footbit imaginable, right? I mean, that's...

1:10:51 That's the purpose of this whole hard-skate plaza. Am I reading this correctly? I just want to make sure I got your message correct. Correct. Okay. And then I'm assuming then you also would have the flexibility in this if we ever wanted to be totally enclosed to do it versus just covered? Correct. Correct? Okay. All right. And then it seems to me that, you know, the one comment

1:11:16 And I certainly haven't been through all your public processes. But the one comment that I had really heard initially was the concern about noise of the ice skating ring with the neighbors. But it seems like between the setback and the permanent building, I mean, this design pretty well solves that issue, do you think, right? One thing I mentioned is when Michael Baker looked at Alton today, they said, look, we haven't, again, we haven't done the complete analysis yet, but everything you've done. Right.

1:11:42 has lessened any potential impacts. Everything we've done, and specific to the noise, you'll see that the west side and the north side of this facility is basically walled off by buildings. So the noise from inside that multi-use facility would either stay inside or be focused to the south and east. So that's probably the biggest one. There was even a comment about the chiller, and if you see in the lower left-hand corner it says mechanical room, that means chiller.

1:12:08 Michael Baker commented that if they were in the player boxes at our existing rink, they couldn't really hear our chiller from that distance, and it wasn't even enclosed. So they're very happy with where we've located it, and they think from a technical standpoint, it won't be an impact. Now, perception is also part of what we're looking at, so we're going to enclose it, we're going to do some other things, but again, we're trying to solve those things with the design.

1:12:34 And then I'm assuming we have no issue with height, right, based on our height standards, is that correct? It's going to meet the height standards for that zone. Okay. So what would you like from us, Mr.

1:12:51 It really is just an update. Okay. And, you know, if you have any comments, we'd love to hear them. You know, we've been reaching out to, as we said, hundreds of community members all over the place for information. If you look at this at a later date or you see the packet, please feel free to comment. If you know anybody who's commented on this in the past, tell them to show up. Get them out there. But I did want to alert you to the fact that we would come back again. The scoping meeting and stuff will be back later, hopefully.

1:13:17 sooner rather than later and we'll update you along the way because we think if we get to a point of certification of an environmental document, you're much better certified if you've heard about it along the way rather than just have it drop in front of you. So we just want to provide you that information. Yes. I would imagine you probably have additional traffic studies.

1:13:37 We will certainly be looking at traffic settings. I mean, all those things that will come out through the scoping meeting. And now, in addition to the environmental, of course, there is an economic development impact to this as well. We hope to draw more visitors to town. We hope that this will spur even the possibility of some additional development on this into town. There are a couple of empty lots. There are some buildings that could be redeveloped. And we hope that this spurs some more activities that you'll hear about as well. So it's all related. Anybody in the public like to make any additional comments, questions?

1:14:11 All right. Well, thank you very much. You bet. We appreciate your hard work on that. Thank you. We will now move to our fourth agenda item, Discussion of Potential Zoning Code Amendment to Section 17-140, Additions and Alterations to Non-Conforming Uses and Structures. And our staff contact is Ruth on this. Thank you, Chair Brown. It's a hard act to follow the exciting ice rink and the Performing Arts Center, but

1:14:47 We'll switch gears here and talk about a potential amendment to zoning code section 17.100.040, additions and alterations to non-conforming uses and structures. And this item was discussed at the February 10th commission meeting, and I provided a summary of the comments made at that meeting in the staff report.

1:15:12 So the current language in the zoning code restricts additions to nonconforming structures to 25% of the existing floor area, excluding garages and decks to once every three years. Nonconforming structures are structures that were legally constructed before the adoption or amendment of the zoning code, but do not comply with the current development standards. So examples of nonconforming structures are a house that doesn't meet current setback, height, or density requirements.

1:15:39 This language limiting additions to 25% of the existing building for area was incorporated as a part of the comprehensive zoning code update in 2014. The perspective at that time was that reasonable modifications and upgrades to non-conforming structures and uses should be allowed while still working to achieve the stated goal in the purpose section of the non-conforming chapter of eventual elimination.

1:16:02 It was determined that limiting additions to 25% of the existing building floor area was a reasonable yet somewhat conservative approach towards meeting this goal of eventual elimination. Since the February 10th meeting, staff has completed additional research on this issue, including review of the American Planning Association's perspectives on additions to non-conforming structures and uses, as well as a comparison of the town's codes with those in other peer communities.

1:16:30 And what we found is that this goal of eventual elimination is really not applied in the other community's codes in the context of additions to nonconforming structures. In those codes that we reviewed, and there's a summary in the staff report, additions are permitted of any size so long as the addition meets current development standards. In regards to the American Planning Association's perspectives on this issue, they draw a distinction between benign and detrimental nonconformities.

1:16:59 Benign nonconformities, according to the APA, are those that are a result of changes to the development standards, and detrimental nonconformities are typically related to nonconforming uses, which really aren't the subject of today's conversation. This week, we did also receive comments from the fire department, which requested that we clarify that any addition to a nonconforming structure is subject to current building and fire codes, and is also an opportunity to bring the entire structure into compliance with the applicable building and fire codes.

1:17:30 They also noted that we may want to consider amendments to the code which would treat additions to nonconforming commercial structures differently than we do residential structures. Staff's recommendation is that commission consider the goals or the goal of eventual elimination and whether it may be appropriate to take a less restrictive approach to additions to nonconforming structures. It is not proposed that changes or additions which would increase the nonconforming aspects of the structure be permitted.

1:17:56 Discussion questions were also included in this staff report and may be considered by the commission. And should the commission provide feedback in support of an amendment to the zoning code, staff will return to the commission the next meeting or two with specific language for those amendments. And I would note that I believe there are several members of the public here to speak on that issue, and I'm here to answer any questions as well. First of all, do we want to start with any questions? Any questions? Commissioner, should I have questions?

1:18:29 Sure, I have some. Yes, I... You mentioned that the current code states a limitation of addition of 25% every three years. I don't think we had a chance to talk about that every three years stipulation. Is that something that was found in other cities, other peer cities at the time, or do you have any idea where that came from?

1:18:54 That may have been something that was found in other communities. Again, I think the goal was to allow small changes as needed on a somewhat regular basis, but in a way that doesn't really encourage a major overhaul of the property or, again, sort of helps enforce this goal of eventual elimination.

1:19:20 And I think the previous code, the non-conforming section, related the addition to the valuation of the structure. And I believe there was a time limit as well when it was the valuation. So I think it was 100% of the assessed valuation of the structure. And I think it was every three years, but I don't.

1:19:37 I think you're right. So I think we carried forward that time because that was what was in the code previously. We just changed because there was an issue with the valuation. If someone had owned a property for a long time, their valuation might be very, very low versus if they sold the property, then the valuation would be high. So it wasn't a fair thing. So that's why we went to just a square footage number, which made it fair. It didn't matter when you had purchased your property.

1:20:06 Can you talk a little bit about what sort of an impact or what percentage of parcels throughout the town do you think fall into that category of nonconforming structures? Sure. I think, you know, that's difficult data to collect.

1:20:27 But I think we can safely assume that a vast majority of the properties which were constructed under the Mono County Code, so prior to the Townsend Corporation in 1984, the Mono County Code had reduced front setbacks and side setbacks of five feet, and I think we can guess that the majority of those properties would be considered non-conforming today. There's also issues of properties which were not built according to the site plan that was submitted or approved.

1:20:56 There's also issues that our surveying technology has improved and properties may have been thought to be built with respect to property lines which may be resurveyed in different locations today. So it's really hard to guess a percentage. We could do some analysis and look at year built of structures across the town and try to come up with an approximation of

1:21:26 of how many structures in town, condos, and single-family homes were built prior to that 1984 date. Okay. Yeah, I agree. It seems like difficult data to collect, but if what you're saying is that the majority of structures built prior to 1984, that seems to me that could be half the houses in town. It may be. Maybe. Yeah, it may be. Okay. It's good to just keep...

1:21:59 Have that perspective on what we could possibly be talking about. Okay, we'll look into that. Okay. You're saying that we're allowing a limitation of 25% of the total gross area if they're looking to do modification to the non-conforming structures, right? Correct. And it seems a bit contradictory to me that

1:22:32 While we're trying to, the goal is to the eventual eliminations of the non-conforming structures, but then at the same time we're saying that you can build an additional 25% to this non-conforming structure. And that was a point made to us or that has been made to staff. Right. So I thought,

1:23:04 I mean, I can certainly understand. I mean, if you're going to try to move the entire house back by 10 feet, I mean, that's just not realistic. Well, I think that's something we'll be part of our discussion question. I mean, that's going to be probably our key discussion question, what the goal is. One of the statements that I saw in the document was that the California Supreme Court case talked about using

1:23:34 A reasonable amortization period for the purpose of eventual terminations of the non-conforming use. And the staff have recommended not to use that method. Can you kind of walk through how that method works and why you don't feel it's necessary to use that method? Back in, I think that was 2011, the document that I saw,

1:24:06 I believe the amortization was in regards to non-conforming uses and not non-conforming structures to allow businesses which may no longer be permitted uses in a zoning district. I'm trying to think of a use that was permitted in the previous code that's not now like a dog kennel.

1:24:30 Yeah, or like an auto repair, maybe in the commercial zone, like a heavy auto repair that might have been permitted previously. And I believe that the discussion at that time was whether or not those uses should be allowed to continue, but only for a certain period of time before being required to be used for a purpose that is permitted by the current zoning code.

1:24:55 I don't believe that that amortization was ever discussed in context of nonconforming structures specifically, but in regards to nonconforming uses. Does that sound right, Sandra? I think so. Do you have any other questions? Are there any other questions, Commissioner? I don't have any. All right. So I think what we'll do is we'll take public comments, and then we'll just go down the list of the discussion questions. Do we have any public comments on this topic? I'm Elliot Brainerd, architect. First, I see at the end.

1:25:38 Staff's done a really good job in trying to analyze this, and it is a little bit tricky, but a couple things I think came out of the research from the other municipalities and places similar to us like Big Bear, Truckee, South Lake Tahoe that are listed in here, and none of them have a code anything like this, like we have, nothing like this.

1:26:04 A couple things that came out to that and I think might be a helpful way to approach it, as Ruth just mentioned, is residential versus commercial because I think they're two different, completely different situations. I think eventual elimination may have made sense more in the commercial application and not the residential application.

1:26:31 Because what happened in the 2014 code update that the commission made, as we talked at the last meeting about a lot of downsloping lots that were built, they were approved and under an old code, they were conforming. Now they became non-conforming. So I don't think the intention of commission and the town was to start to eliminate.

1:26:59 The residential houses because the code changed after they had been built as an approved structure. That just doesn't make any sense. Where in the commercial zones,

1:27:13 You could see where that could happen. When we want to redo parts of town or there are old uses that are no longer viable in certain locations based on the goal of what the town is to make the zoning better. That makes total sense. So I would like to say that it would be better to look at those in two different venues. On the residential side, you have a lot of people right now that

1:27:44 Have invested in Mammoth and have been invested in Mammoth and houses for a long time. They're at the point right now as the economy's turned around to upgrade those houses. And just as an example, I have four houses right now that only one of them is non-conforming because of the code change, but we're talking about remodels on some of those houses that are in excess of $2 million. I mean,

1:28:13 Thank you. Thank you.

1:28:42 The entire structure up to code. And that's not anything to do with the state interpretation. That's just building code requirements. So you could do that other than probably fixing the nonconformity if it's placed in a setback as it was approved originally. Most of those that you see as nonconforming, as Amy mentioned,

1:29:11 Those were probably upsloping or downsloping lots. That's where that exception was made in the Mono County Code and the town, Mammoth adopted the Mono County Code when it incorporated. So that's what you're seeing on the residential side of most of the nonconformities. And again, most of those people, if they've owned those houses a long time or they've re...

1:29:38 Purchase them recently. They want to upgrade them. They want to fix them. They want to make them better. And I think that that's a huge benefit to town instead of trying to discourage that person to investing here and upgrading those buildings. But it's here right now. Those are my main comments. And I think it's an interesting discussion item on both sides. But especially the...

1:30:07 The eventual elimination, to me, applies more towards the commercial. You mentioned earlier that none of those towns that was listed up there have codes like ours. Correct. Specifically, what were you referring to? What type of codes are you... To the 25% limitation. Okay. All of them can add on to the limits of the code, which there are lots of factors when you're...

1:30:38 Talking about additions, I mean, there's lot coverages, there's height limits, there's setbacks. I mean, it's not just one aspect as a 25% limitation that governs that part. Also, you mentioned it's not gross square footage, it's only habitable square footage. Livable area? Livable area, correct. Thank you. All right, I think we're probably good for right to second. And did you also?

1:31:10 Have comments? Anyway, I didn't know if you had any other questions. No, we'll probably get back to you with some questions. Let me get the comments first and then. Hi, Martin Kleinbart, resident and contractor. Good afternoon, commissioners and staff. I guess I have a multi-part question, and I guess it goes to the spirit of this code section, which has been stated a couple times already, that

1:31:43 The eventual elimination of nonconforming uses, I mean, to me that seems very confusing. I mean, is the intention in the future, sometime down the road, to eliminate all applications for variances? Because generally a variance would be a condition that's approved by application.

1:32:10 to do something that's nonconforming, whether it be a use of a structure or the structure itself. The multi-part question, the second one, would be how is this goal to be achieved? I mean, are we going to start issuing new laws that give a time base that somebody has to reduce their setbacks or their building gets condemned?

1:32:41 As Amy stated, in the residential districts, it could be almost 50% of the homes that don't meet today's setbacks but were built legally conforming at the time when they were permitted and inspected and built, including my house. My house has got five-foot setbacks on one side, and I don't know if I meet 20 on the front.

1:33:08 But certainly I don't have full setbacks on one side. And I don't think you can go move my house and make it work. I mean, that would be ridiculous. And then my third question, which I hope can be answered, is Ruth had stated that their, I guess the fire department has notified something that when additions are,

1:33:38 I guess the biggest elephant in the room is,

1:34:08 How is this goal, however it gets ironed out on the particulars, how is this goal going to be met to achieve elimination of non-conforming uses and structures? And one other thing before I close, and re-looking at the general plan, because I remember being quite involved, going to all those meetings and hashing out the bargaining process of who get, you know,

1:34:36 went on and on and on, but the only thing in the general plan that talks about non-conforming uses is only commercial zones. It doesn't apply to the elimination or the rehabbing of the residential structures. So I don't even know how that even got in to this whole general picture of even residentials. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments? Yes.

1:35:08 Again, Elliot Brainerd. Typically, on the fire department side, fire marshal Heller kind of gauges the size of the addition or renovation. A lot of times, we'll do a house that maybe, for example, 25% of the addition of the livable square footage is what's being added. So at that point, Hugh will usually only have you fire sprinkler that portion.

1:35:39 And not the entire, go back into the existing structure. It's not until you really get to a larger renovation or addition, probably close to, like I said, the 50% or greater that you'll have to do the entire building or house. So I have a question. So does the fire marshal have discretion or is there an established fire code that, like the building code?

1:36:04 There's some discretion as far as how much of the building brings up to code as far as fire sprinklers. Typically the minimum thing is they'll have you add smoke detectors, LPG sensors, things like that that houses don't have. That's the minimum basic. And under the new codes where every new building in California, even if it's a 10 by 10 building, has to be fire sprinklered.

1:36:33 So he's trying to get closer to that requirement, but he's also trying to be reasonable at the same time. Okay. Thank you. So what I'd like to do is I'd like to change the order of the question slightly, and I'd like to start with question number two. Should the stated purpose of eventual elimination be revised for benign, non-conforming structures? And then talk about the issue about commercial or residential purposes.

1:37:09 So anybody like to start that comment somewhere? Well, I'll start since I was on the zoning code update committee. I think elimination is kind of, you know, I mean, it's always really interesting and you'll all find this as you write zoning code updates and you think you really like encompass all particular circumstances and situations and initially you're really proud of your work and then over the years you start going, wow, how did I do this? But I would say

1:37:42 That being part of the original zoning code update committee, I think elimination has kind of taken on a life of its own here. I mean, I don't think we ever really envisioned when we wrote this eliminating all non-conforming uses in the entire town. I mean, Sandra, you can correct me, but I don't think that was ever truly our intention. I think really our intention, and this is why I like

1:38:06 Talking about, ultimately talking about detrimental and benign. I mean, more our concern was that there are certain non-conforming that are really detrimental. And when you have certain non-conforming uses that are detrimental, and you have certain non-conforming issues that are really truly safety hazards. And I think that was much more our concern than to bring everything in the town up to conforming standards.

1:38:36 I don't know, Sandra, if you have any comments on that for the commissioners about how you feel about.

1:38:43 The intent? Yeah. So I think, I was just kind of going back and reading the purpose of the chapter, and the purpose basically says the intent is to encourage the continued improvement of the town by limiting the extent to which non-conforming structures and uses may be, continue to be used, expanded, or replaced, while allowing for reasonable improvements for appearance, maintenance, and safety. So I think the intent was really that let's look at these non-conforming structures, let's allow them to be, you know,

1:39:09 upgraded a little bit, but not so much that the structure would stay forever. So that ultimately, just through...

1:39:19 I guess time, those structures would just kind of go away and be replaced with structures that comply. So there was no plan when we discussed this to go through and try to proactively eliminate non-conforming structures or uses. It was really that as time goes by, those structures would just kind of on their own either be demoed and rebuilt, that kind of thing. But it is a huge number of structures in town. So, I mean, is that really reasonable? We really didn't have this discussion back.

1:39:48 Back when we originally talked about this, is that is it really reasonable to think that possibly half of the homes or some large number of homes in town are going to be demoed in a short period of time, in the next 10, 20, 30 years? I don't know. So we didn't really have that discussion back then. And don't you think we could change the intent pretty easy of the chapter to address detrimental, non-conforming issues? It seems to me that I'm in agreement with,

1:40:19 What you're saying, Mickey, that we can't just lump all of these nonconforming uses and nonconforming structures into the same category because there's a vast spectrum of where all these potential buildings might fall. I see obviously a difference between detrimental and benign and then possibly also a difference between commercial and residential. And thinking about the goal of eventual elimination of a nonconforming

1:40:48 Of a detrimentally non-conforming commercial building? Absolutely. But of a benign non-conforming house, just because we changed the zoning code and they're five foot over their lot line set back, to me doesn't make any sense at all. Right. So I think it makes a lot of sense for us to reconsider what we're really striving for and to clarify. I think any changes that we make in the future,

1:41:22 For this purpose, the article that you have provided, I think that's a great source for us. When you talk about making changes on this, I think we need to focus on health and safety and public welfare. Those are the principles that we should use. And just because they're a non-conforming product,

1:41:51 Doesn't mean that they can continue to increase the size of the structure. I think we need to take that into consideration as well. Just because they have the lot size and maybe they're just sitting at a different position. We can't say, well, because it's benign, but because you have the additional lot size, you can continue to increase the size of it.

1:42:20 Wait, so if it's a benign nonconformity, are you saying they can or can't? I don't think they can to increase the size of the structure because now you're putting the other structures, the newly developed structure, out of disadvantage. So let's assume just hypothetically that you have a law in Old Mammoth and the

1:42:54 The lot only sets back like 12 feet from the street, but it's a quarter acre lot. Okay. Okay. So they don't want to change the 12 foot set back. Right. But they want to add. In the back. In the back. Correct. Okay. And there's no detrimental impacts. But we haven't defined detrimental. But just assuming there's no detrimental impacts. So would you be, you think that's okay or not okay? I don't.

1:43:20 In my opinion, it's not okay because that's an economic impact to your neighboring property. If your neighbor was, their property was built recently and after 1984 or 2014. Right. And then they have the, you know, you have the same size lot and then, but their bill, their setback is, you know, they meet the 10 fee requirement versus the old one have five fee requirement and they can't.

1:43:49 You know, they're truly at a disadvantage. You have to remember, though, that any addition to a non-conforming structure has to be conforming to the current building code. So any addition would have to still conform to the current 10-foot side yard setbacks and 20-foot front yard setbacks and have to conform to a percentage of lot area coverage. So the only...

1:44:13 The only disadvantage from an existing non-conforming structure to a recently built conforming structure would be that component of the building that is already non-conforming. It wouldn't be, just because it was originally built with a five foot setback, you can't continue to expand your building with five foot setbacks. I think maybe you're thinking that they can build their addition to the code that was in effect when the

1:44:43 When the building was built, which isn't the case. As if it was grandfathered in, I think that's what Paul is. But I would imagine that, you know, there's some allowance that they can continue to build further in the vacant area. Well, so like if you had, I mean, maybe we should almost even draw, we could probably draw a diagram of this. Okay, so if the nonconformity was the front setback. Elliot's diagram actually can't be helpful.

1:45:12 And they want to do additional side, they want to do an addition on, okay? And if, well, because I'm already doing, but basically, okay, let's say the nonconformity was the, it was a five foot setback, okay? And it wasn't a detrimental to have a five foot setback. Then what we've said is, is that the addition has to be 10 foot, it has to, you can't continue the nonconformity. Okay. Does that kind of clarify? Yes. Okay. And then I will say,

1:45:44 From, in my opinion, from a real estate perspective, that any time somebody improves their property and ultimately has that property have more value, then the neighbor properties also improve. Versus if you have a, you know, it's the old progressive-regressive. I mean, if you have a regressive property next to a nice property, if they ultimately improve that property to the standard of your property, you're going to increase all the neighborhood values.

1:46:14 Keeping that in mind, it seems to me that the existing requirement or limitation actually in the code is sort of doing the opposite of what we want it to do. If we want to promote continuing improvements to the town, especially if we're thinking primarily about benign, non-conforming residential structures,

1:46:43 This limitation in the code is really preventing people from doing exactly that. That's why I think it's appropriate for us to, you know, to categorize those things and then to say, okay, residential is one thing and commercial is another. Right, absolutely. Yes. I think, first of all, we're all in agreement on that, right? So we can, we're all in agreement that we should get between residential and commercial. So that means we can take that one off the, okay. Thank you. All right. What's your feelings, Commissioner Verruck, about

1:47:14 Our original stated purpose of elimination. Oh. Of non-conforming, benign, detrimental. Elimination? Yeah, because elimination was kind of... Is that... Yeah, I don't see how that's even possible. Okay. Yeah, I don't see that that's pragmatic at all. For the residential? The residential. I would argue for the commercial. For the commercial, yes. It is possible. Yeah, let's just talk about residential for a second. Okay. Yeah, no, I see there's no way that you can dictate something like that.

1:47:46 I agree. Okay. All right. So does that give you enough input on that question? Then commercial, but commercial, I guess we ultimately want elimination, but maybe we just have to really think through that and make sure we don't have any unintended consequences with that. I think there might be a thought about differentiating between a commercial non-conforming use versus a commercial non-conforming structure. And then obviously...

1:48:21 There's a spectrum of detrimental to benign within that too. It's sort of like one of those big charts where your dots can fall. And if your dot's up here, then your goal should be for eventual elimination. But if it's a fairly benign, non-conforming structure, even if it's in the commercial zone, maybe it's not an issue. I don't really see it as a black and white at the moment.

1:48:51 Although, I guess, in order to codify it, we have to sort of make it a black and white. Well, I mean, I think with regards to the distinction between residential and commercial, I think we have enough direction to at least draft some language that would remove that goal of eventual elimination for nonconforming residential structures that have benign nonconformities and then to kind of look into further how we might approach that with

1:49:21 Commercial structures and see what we can come up with. And I don't think we're not talking about addressing nonconforming uses at all as a part of these amendments. I think staff supports the language that's currently in the code with regards to nonconforming uses. So I think what we really then need ultimately to do is to define benign and detrimental.

1:49:51 And so, and what is very problematic about all of this, and we kind of touched about this the other day, is I feel really strongly that lack of snow storage is a detrimental non-conforming use. Okay. Then, for lots of reasons, and we have big areas of that, and then the problem is that

1:50:22 If you go and start adding up up-sloping and down-sloping lots, you know, there's a large number of those up-sloping, down-sloping lots that are short on snow storage. So I think as...

1:50:39 You know, maybe on all the detrimental uses, but certainly the detrimental use of snow storage on upsloping, downsloping lots. We probably should form some sort of working group with the practitioners in the community and see what we can possibly come up with as a practical solution. I mean, that would be kind of my thought on that. I don't know. There's, and someday, what we're going to actually talk about this, our driving tour, you know, but there are certain streets.

1:51:07 That in the winter, it's really difficult. What did you think about doing? I think it's a great idea. Okay. All right. And I would note that in regards to snow storage, you're right that there may be existing lots. For example, I don't know, you know, like this John Muir lot, which right now doesn't adequately provide for snow storage.

1:51:36 But as a part of any addition or building permit, we are going to require that they comply with all applicable development standards, which includes snow storage. So sometimes additions are an opportunity for us to correct a snow storage issue that may have not been correctly planned for at the time the original house was constructed. So as a part of this building permit, Elliott will be required to provide

1:52:04 The snow storage required for that lot and the size of the property. Right. So, I mean, if we say a detrimental nonconformity is snow storage, but they have a way to solve it somewhere else, or a potential detrimental is snow storage, but they have a way to solve it somewhere else on the lot, then I think we're all good with that, right? Exactly. Okay. All right. So, let's go. Should nonconformities at a result of changes to development standards be considered benign nonconformities?

1:52:35 Exist examples are residents with five-foot setbacks on down-sloping lots. So I think we've kind of answered that. That's going to be really based on our list of what's benign and what's detrimental. Okay, we're good on that. And then question three, should additions to non-conforming structures that do not increase the non-conformity be allowed with or without limitation? Well, this is basically the question about the 25%. In the three years. In the three years. Commissioner, do you have any comments on that?

1:53:06 So you basically think we should just eliminate the three years and the 25%? Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yeah, it's kind of a tough one, though. I mean, I guess we don't want to put it in a situation where we're taking it on a case-by-case basis. That's the responsibility of, you know, that's Pandora's box. Well, I think it goes back to the, I think it probably goes back to the question is, if it's a benign nonconformity, are we fine with no limitation?

1:53:47 No time limit. No time limit, but the additions to the non-conforming structure would be in compliance with whatever code is in place at that time. Correct. That's what we're saying, right? Right. I'm fine. I'm fine with that. A benign non-conformity, okay. And then, of course, if it's a detrimental, then what are we going to do if it's a detrimental? Well, I think we can talk more in regards to what...

1:54:14 Detrimental nonconformities are. But in reviewing that APA article, it really references detrimental nonconformities in regards to nonconforming uses. Right. And if we're talking about residential structures, we're not really talking about nonconforming uses. Right. And so if we are being specific and creating a distinction between residential and commercial, we may not need to enter that conversation about what a detrimental

1:54:44 Nonconformity is, if that makes sense. Okay, all right. Should an increase, pardon me, I'm sorry. I was going to say, my initial inclination would be to remove both limitations, both the timing and the percentage of square footage. However, and I mentioned it, I think I mentioned it at the last meeting or two before, that if there was a reason for us to consider keeping at least some kind of limitation,

1:55:18 On an addition that we might consider relating that limitation to the lot size rather than the existing square footage of the existing building. You mean the lot coverage or the lot size? The lot size. The lot size, I think, is what I'm thinking. I'm just trying to think of a, you know,

1:55:46 Typical 0.2 acre lot in town that may only have a 1,500 square foot building on it with a two story building with a relatively small footprint to me maybe shouldn't be limited to an addition that's associated with its existing square footage. Maybe it should be associated with its lot size. Keeping in mind that it would still have to conform to the building code setbacks.

1:56:15 And maximum lot coverage. It would just be something that we'd have to look further into and analyze to see if that actually made any sense. And maybe we can just come up with a couple hypothetical examples. And I agree to simply just eliminate the percentage. I don't think that would be helpful in what we're trying to accomplish. Yeah, and if we go that way, then the lot size doesn't even come into two.

1:56:46 So would the commission like us to provide some options like looking at no limitation and then looking at a limitation of lot size? Is there consensus either way? I thought I heard consensus for no limitation, but then I hear the discussion about limiting it by lot size. Well, maybe you can provide us information in both ways. Right. Okay. It does seem like so far four out of the five commissioners are in support of no limitation, but we can...

1:57:19 Right. I'm saying, I think I'm in support of it. We just want to make sure there's no more information. Okay. Yeah, no, I want to make sure there's no unintended consequences. Can you, maybe you can look into see if this issue has really come into play in any of the property additions that have occurred in the last five years or so, or any other projects that might be currently being planned, just to see, because I think it really helps to see some actual or hypothetical examples. Some additional examples. Okay.

1:57:49 I mean, here's one example. I know, this is a good one. Yeah, just one second. So, okay, but then as far as additional research, so I would really, because I'm always asking this question and I can never quite remember the answer and get clarification, I'd really like to understand when building code comes into play and when fire code comes into play. And then if I have a written report, then I'll...

1:58:22 Promise I'll carry it around forever and laminate it. Never ask you again. And we have a wonderful new building official who can now help us research that issue. Okay. All right. That'd be great. And I think California Building Code is changing in 2016? It is. And it's changing. So don't really learn the old one. We've got to start learning the old one. No, I thought it's January 1st of 2017, right? Right. Yeah. So, okay. All right. And do you have anything else for feedback on this? No.

1:58:53 Okay. Is there, just going back to my initial question about, you know, quantifying the number of properties that this might affect, is there any, what kind of time and research would be necessary to, I don't know, just to collect some kind of tangible data so that we can have an idea of what we're talking about? Is it a completely unreasonable request? Or is it something,

1:59:25 Maybe that, maybe Triad has some documents that could help us answer these questions. I have no idea. I don't think it's unreasonable collect data on the year that residential structures were built. Right. But I think it is not feasible for us to take a look at site plans for every single residential lot and make a determination as to which are conforming and which are not.

1:59:50 So we could say, I completely understand. Yeah, some of them were just built long enough ago that they would have to hire a surveyor to come out so we would have something to review. Because they don't, they have plans to still exist. Yeah. But we could say if X number of homes were built prior to 1984, which should be easy, which I would guess, my guess is 150. That's my hunch. Then we could say out of 150.

2:00:17 Ruth, I'm just, Ruth's like, I'm going to put that in the notes. Write this down, okay. Okay, I'm going to say 174. Okay. And then we can say, okay, well, if that's the whole size of the universe, then what do we think? Maybe, you know, 50 or 75% or whatever. I mean, but it would kind of give us some parameters, right? At least getting that kind of information would be great. Okay, then we'll take a look at that. Would anybody in the public like to guess?

2:00:47 But I know you had a comment. I thought it's more. I know you had a comment. I thought it's a lot more. I thought it might help you. Okay. I know you're going to want to do this part formally, even if it's not a hearing, but Elliot Brainerd again. You made a couple comments, and I would still say the code is a living document, as staff has always said. Right. And so you start with one thing, and you try to make it work, and we adjust as we go along, which is great.

2:01:15 You mentioned something about building code updates. The building code changes every three years. It doesn't matter. It can be fire. It can be building code. It can be California green code, energy code. I mean, there's a bunch of codes that are changing all the time, and it's a very complicated process to try to keep up on all of this, not even including local zoning, which is completely different in every place you go to.

2:01:45 But one of the things, Amy, you mentioned about lot size. I don't think you would really do it that way because lot coverages are limited in the code by percentage. Right. So in the single-family residential,

2:02:01 Zone, it might be 40%. In the rural residential zone, in Old Mammoth, it's 30%. And so the lot sizes are bigger typically in Old Mammoth than they are in other parts of town as one example. So your lot coverage percentage is always going to limit you no matter what the size of the lot is to where you could go with it. That makes sense. And without kind of having all the data, I was just sort of hypothetically thinking.

2:02:30 Does it make sense to look into that at all? But if we just eliminate the limitation. Yeah, for example, on a small lot, you couldn't build a huge house on a small lot because it would be limited. To the setbacks and the lot coverage. Yes, exactly. And height limit as well. I mean, it's a box or a volume that you're trying to work within to make it all fit.

2:02:59 You said building versus fire code, Mickey your question, they're not mutually exclusive, so one doesn't really govern over the other, but they overlap, depending on what you're doing. They all have, everything you do has to comply with all of it, not just one or the other, if that helps you. That's really how it works. Yeah, okay. And so snow storage, you made a comment.

2:03:28 I think the biggest problem snow storage-wise is our upsloping lots. I mean, they got nowhere to put snow. On downsloping lots, in this example, you can always push snow downhill, and there's usually a place to put it. But the upsloping lots are definitely more of a challenge, without a doubt. I guess one last comment. Sometimes

2:03:53 In cities and plans, I mean, you'll notice in older cities where there are nuances in the city planning fabric, we call it that, the old buildings that didn't conform to something and they become iconic sometimes and I think there has to be a little bit of thought about that.

2:04:16 Maybe, I don't, I can't think of any off the top of my head, I don't know. But if there was something, maybe there's some benefit to it. I don't know. But it'd be really helpful, and, you know, I apologize for being a little short the last couple months ago, but, but the thing is, is, I mean, we need.

2:04:44 You know, commission, staff. We need people like yourself that are out there doing this, not just to come in and say, oh, you know, we don't like this code, but, I mean, we have to come up with a workable solution, and these upsloping lots, you know, I mean, it's a huge problem, you know, and we have to figure out, and the downsloping, I mean, we can identify easily enough the streets that we're talking about. How are we going to solve that? Because it's truly a safety thing.

2:05:12 It's very challenging, absolutely, and I'm always happy to try to help. I mean, this came up as a specific job, but it also opened a discussion, which I think is a good one, to address problems that are going on like this. I mean, I always try to be available as much as possible. I was on commission for six years, and I'm still on building advisory for the last 20. But I'm happy to do whatever, even

2:05:42 Even when you go on your field trip, I'd love to go. And let's look at things that are working and not working. Why are they? How could you solve them? I'd be happy to volunteer in my time to do that. Thank you very much. All right. I saw on the document that was Amendment 3 or Attachment 3 on page 3 of 15.

2:06:15 I talked about there are nearly 30% of our zone parcel are nonconforming. And so this document was prepared by Pam, the previous. Parcels, right? So it's looking at parcels, not the lots. So they're simply just parcels only?

2:06:35 The homes on the parcel. Okay. So it's easy, I think it's easier to run through GIS, the parcel sizes versus the zoning. So we can run the zoning, run the parcel sizes and see that the 30 percenter, but to look at the house on the parcel, where it sits, you know, with the setbacks and everything, that's much more difficult. Got it. Yeah. Thanks. Okay. All right. Did we give you enough feedback? Yes. Thank you very much. Thank you.

2:07:05 All right. Agenda item number five is the Town of Mammoth Lakes 2015 Annual Planning Report, and our staff contact is no one on this. All right. Thank you. This item is really just an informational item. This report's required to be filed to the state housing and community development, as well as the office in planning research annually by April 1st each year. And it really just summarizes

2:07:34 The past year's planning activities, so it takes into account all the new projects that have come in as well as ongoing projects. And so again, it's really just informational for your enjoyment to read and to kind of get a snapshot of everything we worked on as staff as well as the commission reviewed in the previous year. And did the commission have any questions? I don't. I don't have any questions. Commission.

2:08:15 I just had, but I wrote myself a note, and unfortunately I didn't do a page reference on this, about the public art fund. Do you have to remember where this was in this document? Probably in the art section. Right. It looks like page 16 of the report, 24 of the packet, I believe. Okay, so, and this is just,

2:08:50 More as far as, you know, our priorities in future work programs. I think it's really, I mean, we were proponents, the commissioner was proponents of eliminating the public arts fee because we felt that the way it was currently stated didn't work, you know.

2:09:11 But I think it's really important that still the emphasis is that we believe in public arts, especially since we've taken on the duties of public arts, and that I believe that there is still money in the public arts fund. And so at some appropriate time, I think we should allocate that money and to write, because the ultimate objective was to write a comprehensive

2:09:39 Public arts document. Well, what do we really want our public arts to look like and how are we going to fund it versus just out of every development project there's going to be another fee. So I just think I had kind of heard other comments where we don't really have public art anymore and I don't think that was our goal. It was really our objection when we eliminated it was the fee. So I did want to... Now the funding you're referring to is Measure R?

2:10:05 No, okay, so at one time we had a public arts fee that every developer when they built something had to contribute a percentage of their project into this public arts fund. Okay, and when we disbanded the development fee, there was still money in that fund that was never spent on public arts.

2:10:25 Do we know how much that is? It's about $50,000. And just so you know, the public art fee is suspended for two years. So at some point in the next year and a half, we would come forward with an amendment or, you know, kind of a clarification to the municipal code section to just determine whether or not we want to continue to charge that fee, should it continue to be at the level that it's...

2:10:47 It's shown in the Municipal Code. Should it be lower? So I think there's a whole analysis that is going to go along with the public arts discussion in the next year and a half or so. Okay. So that was one comment. And then I wanted to ask a little bit about regional housing needs. I know this year Mammoth Lakes Housing went directly with their plan to council.

2:11:15 And it didn't really come before the Planning and Economic Development Commission this year. Their yearly update or just the commission? Because, you know, I mean, it's still, in essence, part of the general plan, too. I mean, I didn't know what's in here is kind of separate from what Mammoth Lakes Housing is reporting or is this strictly?

2:11:34 Your assessment of the regional housing needs. This is the regional housing needs that's basically assigned to us by the state. So Mammoth Lakes Housing may, they have their own analysis that they have performed on a needs assessment of the community that's really a little, it's different than this, than what's assigned to us by the state. Right.

2:11:56 If it's something that, I mean, I can ask Mammoth Lakes Housing to come to the commission to give a presentation on what they had presented to the council, if that would be helpful. No, I just wanted to see how this tied in, that's all. So really what theirs was looking at like.

2:12:09 Asking people, what do you need? Like people in the community, like what kind of housing do you need? This is more like the state saying, based on all these numbers, here's what you need. So that's kind of the difference between the two documents. And this, the RHNA table here corresponds with what's in the housing element as well in the same five-year cycle. Okay. And then underneath planning applications, I'm surprised at how many building permits.

2:12:41 Is that up? 654 requests, 587 approved? I think it's pretty consistent. It might be a little bit low, I think. We go through, we do a lot of like woods, you know, smaller permits, wood stoves, you know, heater changeouts, those kinds of things. Okay. Yeah, that is about consistent with 2013 and 2014. It's right around that, about 650. I know at least for 2014. This year, can't say really if it's on the same.

2:13:11 Trend yet. Okay. So we're really just coming into our building season. All right. And then my last question was, why are we updating the sign code again? It's on our work program. I know, but it's like, are you sure it's left over from previous years? Well, there are things in our sign code. So basically, you can't regulate sign content. You can only record.

2:13:44 Regulate time, place and manner of signs, the way signs are placed. So you can't say what someone can put on a sign. So right now our code has some provisions that don't comply with that. So right now we regulate political signs. So we say only political signs can be out, can comply with these, but legally that's not, you can't do that. So we need to go back and rewrite that political sign section to be

2:14:11 consistent with the time, place, manner regulations. So that was really brought up to us after the sign code was updated the last time by the city attorney. So it's something that we need to look at. I don't think it's a huge high priority item, but it is on our, you know, work program to do because it's something that we need to do. This is corresponding to California code or? No, federal. Federal? Yeah.

2:14:36 We're just going to put signs all over town that just says Paul Chang, nothing else. That's okay. I'm happy to see that the municipal trails signage and wayfinding is on here. Does that mean that we could possibly stand the chance of finding some funding for the project that's already been approved? I mean, it's something that we, you know, it's a major project that we have on our work program, but yeah, we have to identify that funding.

2:15:03 Public Works has been trying to program, find funding through, whether that is through one of their STIP programs or one of the other programs, but it's still at this point unfunded, but they're hoping to get it at least on the radar. Was there anything else? Oh, sorry. Can we request a donation from some rich benefactor and then put their name on the back of all the signs? The Kings, maybe the LA Kings.

2:15:34 Get it done. I know. We'll talk about that in a little bit. Was there anything else you wanted to point out about? No, I thought it was a really good summary of everything we've done. It really provides, you know, if people ask you, what did the Community and Economic Development Department do? What did the Planning Commission and Economic Development Commission do? This is like a really good snapshot. And so normally we give it to you just as an informational item, but we wanted to take the time to kind of, you know, talk about it a little bit. No, I appreciate it.

2:16:03 Any comments? Okay. Well, thank you very much. Thank you, Nolan. Thank you. Thank everybody on the town staff for everybody's hard work. It's good. All right. So can we have a motion regarding the consent agenda? I'll make a motion that we approve the consent agenda and the minutes of the February 10, 2016 meeting. Second. Aye. All right.

2:16:39 We'll move on to commissioner reports. You have anything? No design? We've had a design committee meeting since the last meeting. That was over two months ago, right? Yeah. Or at least two months ago. Yeah. That was the meeting that I went to. Right. Yes. Okay. Okay. And I'm assuming that you have the time now to be formally back on the design committee. Okay. We're happy to have that. All right.

2:17:13 Did you have anything to report as a commissioner? I actually do not. I don't have anything to report this time. Okay. Nothing for the winter? Yeah, I don't have any new numbers to throw at you guys. We're expecting a TOT and a TBID report probably within a week. So I just don't have anything that's new and exciting. I'm happy to be here. I've been on the road quite a bit lately, so I'm happy to be home. You are.

2:17:42 Telling the world about this. Telling the world about, and hey, what a great segue that is. I will pass these out. These are our new vacation planner. This is kind of the sleek, sexy piece that we disseminate around the world to tell the Mammoth Lake story, why people should come here as opposed to Switzerland or Vail or Las Vegas, any of the above. And one of the big components that we kind of, this piece is a little bit more, it's about 70% summer.

2:18:12 And fall focused and about 30% winter focused. But one of the big components that we added into it this year, the goal is to have people make Mammoth Lakes their hub and explore the region coming back to Mammoth to try and increase the length of stay and destination from one night to multiple nights. So we built some itineraries and trip ideas in there to facilitate that. And I think it came out quite well, so I'm pretty happy with it.

2:18:40 This will have a shelf life of about two to maybe three years, depending on the air map in the back. Yeah. Nice looking piece. Very cool. I like it. I just want you to know that when I travel abroad, I try to market our town as much as we can. Anytime you want to come by, Paul, and grab a handful of these and take them with you. Thank you. There you go.

2:19:10 So I had three things I wanted to mention. I have met once with Council Member Wentworth and Fernie on their Town of Mammoth Lakes Strategic Alliance document. I'm going to be meeting with them again on Friday. We're just really meeting, trying to get clarity and understanding of what their purpose of their document was.

2:19:37 and how it's going to work going forward. So if anybody had any explicit comments that they would like me to take, I don't know if you've spent any time looking at that document or not, just email me, preferably before tomorrow, so that I can send this off. I mean, I'm sure ultimately there's a big part of it that in that document, wherever it refers to the town of Mammoth Lakes, it also refers to that part to the...

2:20:03 Commission, you know, so that's not just Town of Mammoth Lakes, that's us. Right. So there's, at some point, that document will come back to us. But I just think it really needed some clarity. One of the clarity items I'm working on is, I'm always saying, well, why aren't the Main Street short winds and the wayfinding on here? And they said, well, because it's on the...

2:20:27 Department's work program, but the reality is it's not in the department's work program, it's on a department's funded list. So I'm trying to get them to start this new category, work program, funded list of completed programs. But trust me, every chance I get, I bring that up. So I really, any feedback anybody has, be sure to just let me know. I want to ask you, especially Mammoth Lakes Tourism, you,

2:20:54 All of us, we work so hard at promoting our town, and I think the short link right now is Vons. I stand in that checker line, and I'm horrified how they describe, do you want a grocery bag? Well, it's going to cost 10 cents because of the town ordinance. I'm like, 25 cents if it's plastic. I know, right? But it's like, the town is going to charge 10 cents, you know? And then it's the same way they explain TBID, you know?

2:21:23 So, does anybody, do you, I mean, so I just think maybe we should go to the chamber. Somehow, I think we really, there's some sort of outreach we could do to really educate what was being said. Right. Because every person that comes to our town goes to Vons, right? And if that is our weakest point as far as marketing the town, I mean.

2:21:48 Let's not even talk about staffing the grocery store, right? But just what the checkers say. I don't know how you feel about it. Maybe it's not part of our jurisdiction. But it always makes me cringe. I think it would land squarely in the realm of the chamber. Right. As opposed to tourism. Overall customer service. Yeah. Okay. Does anybody, well, maybe what I'll do, I'm going to see Nicole Gathoy tomorrow. Unless you, I don't know how much interface you have with the chamber.

2:22:18 They have an office in our building. Okay. So I see Craig daily. If you want to kind of mention it, then I'll mention it to Nicole tomorrow. Absolutely. Okay. Because Nicole's on the board as we speak. They are. And my wife is the president of the chamber. She is? Yeah. So just a little bit. Do you think you could talk to the president of the chamber? We'll see if dinner gets done and the kids are in the bath. I know. You've got to get your priorities. No, I couldn't agree more. I mean, the way it's being described at lawns is.

2:22:47 Is definitely an Achilles for the guest experience. Right. Not to mention the local experience, but the TBID thing is a separate kettle of fish, and that's been problematic for a while. Right. And I believe there's a Facebook I heard. Oh, yeah. About the interaction with Vons. Oh, yeah. Oh, fantastic. That's more about how busy it is at any given time. It's pretty amusing.

2:23:14 I know people walk around their GoPros, you know, and it's like, okay. The easy way to spin, to turn that around is, you know, it was an ordinance that was put in place to help beautify our community, not to be detrimental to the guest experience. I don't know how to use the word ordinance. No, I know. No, but I'm just saying, I mean, that, you know, it was meant to help our environment and help the community itself, and so. Which kind of segues, you know, I went to the,

2:23:43 The Recreation Summit, which was excellent. And there's some online links, and then ultimately we're hoping to get that whole presentation that they did on the Colorado recreational element, and maybe we can watch as a group. But one of the things that...

2:24:00 The gentleman from Protect Our Winners was saying that as a recreational community, we have such a wonderful opportunity to promote what's happening in our climate and our environment. And he was all about doing this really positive. But he said, you know, here you've got everybody on vacation, you know, they're thinking a little differently and they see all of this, right? So what a great, I mean, especially like...

2:24:23 What a great opportunity to say, well, look at, you know, have you ever thought about what all these plastic bags do? I mean, right. So anyways, so that was kind of my thought on that. My last item, and I will not do this justice, I do not even know how to really describe this, but Mammoth Mountain Ski Area built this snowboard park next to Chair 4. That's the most amazing thing I've ever seen. Have you seen it, Tom?

2:24:52 Everybody needs to go see this. South Park? Huh? South Park? Would you call that South Park? South Park? No, because it's actually like, because the runs here, I mean, it's not like way over there, I mean, it's kind of where they used to do their vans, but every, it's all built out of snow, it's built to make it look like the skateboard park, there's no like rails, okay, and

2:25:21 My understanding is it's an invitational event for elite snowboarders and they just go in there and they practice. But one of the things that they have is all made out of snow is a circular element just like they have down there at the skateboard park. The cradle. Okay, thank you. Oh, cool. It's really, I mean, I'm telling you, it's fascinating and it's really a work of art. You had to like...

2:25:47 Freeze it or something and keep it on you. And they must have spent a phenomenal amount of time doing it. And I think the event is called the Holy Moly, right? Right. Well, you wouldn't want to. Yeah, right. I thought you were going to tell us you. No, but it was actually funny because there was these, we wanted to see when the elite writers were going to start doing this. So I asked a host, oh, when does it open? They go, oh, this isn't open to the public. I go, well, I wasn't going to go out there.

2:26:22 But it's really, I mean, it's a, in the world of creating parks, I mean, this has to be, like, one of the most amazing things out there, so. Yes, have you seen it? I saw photos of it. Oh, yeah, it's pretty cool. Anyways, so, that's all. All right, we'll move on to our director's report. Okay, so quickly, the FAR EIR draft will be out next month.

2:26:48 We're reviewing sections right now. So we're reviewing each section and then they put it all together and then we have one administrative draft we'll kind of take a quick look at. So we're hoping to get it out before the end of May. We hired a new building official, Tom Perry.

2:27:03 I think I might have reported. No, I don't think I knew at the last meeting. Tom Perry was the building official for Mono County. So he's lived in this area. He knows the area. He knows the contractors. And he hit the ground running on Monday. So we're really, really happy to have him here. And I think it's going to really help us to provide you with more information on building, fire codes, some of the questions that came up today. He'll be able to help us answer those questions. So we're really excited to have him here.

2:27:32 I and the Fire Chief Frank Freevault met with the Lodging Association to talk about lofts. There's been a lot of discussions about lofts, conforming lofts, non-conforming lofts. So we spent about an hour and a half with the Lodging Association.

2:27:46 Question and answer, talking about lofts, talking about what's allowed, what's not allowed. Our current code has some exceptions for lofts that don't have an egress window, so that's still in compliance. I think that there was some confusion out there that the municipal code section wasn't allowed anymore, but we haven't made any changes to that, so that's kind of what we're telling the public, and we have a meeting with the Board of Realtors on May 5th here in Sweet Z.

2:28:16 At 11 o'clock, just to basically the same question and answer thing, talk about lofts, talk about their questions. And our intent, as Tom Perry gets settled in, is to look back at that section and see if we need to make changes to make our loft safer in town. But that would be a public process. Ultimately, we would have to go to the council for approval.

2:28:38 Just so you know, we are out there talking about that. And we can come to the commission if you'd like to have a discussion on it, like to talk about that. Maybe at some point, you know, as we move forward with changes to the municipal code, we can do that. Or if we want to have a Q&A discussion about lofts before that, we're happy to come and talk to you about that. I'm not sure if that's something that... Probably it impacts me more than anybody else, and I'll be at the other. Okay. Because they promise.

2:29:06 Margaritas, Cinco de Mayo. We won't be having any. A non-conforming loft at the time of sale, change hands, do you have to make it conforming? No. No. Okay. This is really, this issue really came up with these transient rental inspections, some miscommunications about what's a conforming loft, what's a non-conforming loft.

2:29:32 so it's really we're just trying to kind of straighten out we have a current code section that has an exception to the

2:29:40 Window requirement basically just says it kind of has to have basically open to below. And a majority of the lofts in town meet that requirement. But there's been some disagreement with the fire district on whether or not that complies with the building code. So that's the issue that we're going to iron out. But that exception has been on our books for 30 years. So it's been something that's not something that's new. But we're looking at it again and seeing whether or not we need to change it or do something to make lofts safer in town.

2:30:07 So that's kind of the path that we're going on with lofts. Well, you know, this would be another good area to use the definitions of benign and detrimental. Yeah. Because if a loft has a big opening downstairs, you know, I mean, and not an outside window, I mean, it's a totally different situation than if, I mean, some of these lofts have like one foot wide stairwells that go up spiral and then you have no one. I mean, so I think.

2:30:37 Once, you know, I've been using those terminologies. I mean, obviously, they'll have different definitions. It'll be really a good thing. But, I mean, I'm really involved in this. I don't... I am. I mean, it concerns some of my clients. So, yeah, so maybe just on May the 5th, you might just want to come. Yeah. So, it's because we're going to do it after caravan. Okay. Okay. All right.

2:30:56 And then the last item is that it was mentioned earlier, a Planning and Economic Development Commission tour of projects. So what I thought was I'll put an item on next month's agenda so we can actually talk about where we want to go. In the meantime, if you want to, what we'll do is we'll write a staff report. We'll kind of suggest some sites. We did a tour with the commission about 10 years ago, so I can kind of look back and see what we looked at. We looked at the good, the bad.

2:31:21 The ugly. So I can kind of look back. We'll put together a little report and see if those are where you'd like to go, and then we can pick a date at our next commission meeting for that tour, whether it's for the June meeting or whether it's a special meeting date in May. We can talk about that at the May meeting. And that's all I have. Okay, so we know we have the CEQA coming up from far. That won't be on the May commission.

2:31:50 Agenda. And where are we as far as, let's see, Old Mammoth Place? Old Mammoth Place likely will not be on the Planning Commission meeting in May. But you're still working on it? We're working on it. Oh. Okay. So probably in May it wouldn't be a very big meeting? I think it's pretty light. I don't know. Right. So if it's a light meeting, then would, in theory, would we want to just go on our tour, like have our meeting and go on our tour? Because one, it's daylight savings time.

2:32:21 We can just schedule the tour and, you know. Yeah. Sure. Okay. And then, I'm sorry, what's the date of the May meeting? I know I should know this. It's May, it's on our agenda here, May 11th? I do have it in here. Yeah, I'm here, so. Okay, good. All right. So we can all email the group and we can coordinate whether we want to, we'll look at our agenda and see what we've got on there. If we don't really have anything, we can start the tour at two.

2:32:51 Right. And then come back here to take care of our items or vice versa or whatever works these years. Probably we should do our items first just in case the public comments or whatever. And then if anybody would like to join us, I mean, we'd really be helpful to have the input. And you did volunteer. And you did volunteer. And we can get a vehicle and a driver. Yeah, you hope you're not the bad part.

2:33:22 So, and Tom, you know, if you have time, it'd be nice to have you also, so. Can you clarify with regard to the 5th, where that is and what time? Oh, so. Aren't you recruiting for any place? Oh, yeah. It's here. Sweet Z. It's been forever. Is it 11.30 or 11 on the 5th? 11. Well, it's supposed to be 11. I'm setting it for 11, but my guess is that the realtors won't be here until 11.15, so. Right, because Caravan technically goes from 9 to 11. Okay. Okay. Commissioner Chang reminded me that,

2:33:52 Bob Nevins, our senior planner, moved back to Colorado. The one that was just hired, right? The one that was just hired. Uh-huh. So he no longer at the town. So what we did is we reorganized the department a little bit. Ruth is acting in more of a leadership role. She's still an associate planner. And we will be filling an assistant planner position in the department. So we'll have an associate. You will not have a senior planner anymore. So we'll have an associate and two assistants.

2:34:22 Thank you for reminding me. That's all I have. That was painful. All right. Any other comments from anybody? And hopefully it doesn't impact your schedule too much. I think we're on track with all of our projects. Ready? We adjourn to our next regular meeting to be held May 11, 2016 at 2 p.m. in Sweet Z. Thank you, everybody. Thank you.