TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 9 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

207 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:31:34 I reconvene the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting of May 11, 2016. For the record, the commissioners, town staff, three members of the public, we just went on a two-hour driving tour of the town of Mammoth Lakes. We viewed the various tentative tract maps and master plans, specific agreements according to the agenda. We also talked about

1:32:00 Current Residential Real Estate Trends and Commercial Trends. I think we all thoroughly enjoyed it and it was the most informative two hours. So with that, can I have a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Verruck? Here. Vice Chair Greig? Here. And Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag.

1:32:31 At this time we'll have public, in case you're wondering what I'm doing, there's one chair that's lower than the rest, so you usually always are looking for Council Member Bacon's chair because she's got the biggest

1:33:07 Highest seat of the chair. I'm really low today, so. I actually think I have it this time. You have it. Oh, there you go. This is uncomfortable. Official Paul, Commissioner Chang, Chair. Right. Next time. Okay. Sorry about that. At this point, we'll have public comments. Public comments is for anybody that'd like to speak on any item that's not on today's agenda. Good afternoon, Madam Chair.

1:33:34 Commissioner, staff, members of the community, Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. A quick update on the Outdoor Performing Arts Event Center. We have seven parcels in the running at this point. Sounds like Sam's Wood Site, there's some negotiations going on there. Sounds like there may be something moving forward fairly shortly. We're meeting with the U.S. Forest Service this Friday at 9.30 in the morning. Talk about the snow pit, RV Park East, and the Mammoth Park East project.

1:34:00 Mammoth Lake Foundation. Evan and I continue conversations about what this could possibly look like. He's a willing and able partner. He's here this evening or this afternoon to talk about the MAC, so that's his priority, but we're going to kind of move him along. Had a good conversation with Mark Brownlee and Bill Cockroft two Fridays ago about the use of the canyon facility. They're more than open for any kind of conversation at all. Anything from, we'll give you the facility for an X Factor, we'll manage the entire thing for you.

1:34:26 So they're very open for engaging in those conversations. And as you know, the bell-shaped parcel, staff, thank you, sir, has assured me that that's moving forward at this point in time, so we should get something back by the end of the summer. And so that's kind of the update at this point in time. Based on those, the outcomes of those conversations, the Forest Service this Friday specifically, we'll probably have something for Town Council, the Commission, probably that first week in June. Thank you very much. I'm available for any questions you may have at this point. I guess the only question would be, do you need anything from the,

1:34:56 Commission at this point. Not at this point, Madam Chair. Thank you. Thank you very much for your work on this. Thank you. Good afternoon. Sandra asked me to come in and just give you guys a little briefing on the MAC project, which has been in the works for close to 20 years. While we know, would you go back to the podium, state your name, and tell me what MAC is because we're on TV.

1:35:34 Hi, Evan Russell. I'm a new guy in town, so I don't know all the procedures here. And I'm with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And we own 40 acres in the South Gateway, which we have been developing as educational and cultural project. It's kind of interesting, when we started, you know, that was raw land, and we did a land exchange with the Forest Service, and we had

1:36:21 No college students. We had graduation last week and in the Eastern Sierra between Bishop and Mammoth we have close to 600 college students now and many in the high school taking classes. I'm not sure if, imagine you all know that we converted the Edison building to a theater about five years ago when the museum collection moved out.

1:36:48 And we've been trying to grow that program, which we have every year through Shara's work. But we've had this Performing Arts Center project in the works, and it's always been the center of the college campus. We thought we had money lined up for quite a few years, but the college could never figure out how to find the operating money to run a facility.

1:37:18 We're working on a similar agreement with the college that they did with the Mammoth Library. So it's a joint use and development agreement which allows them to prepay a part of the project. And then we've been quietly out doing some fundraising that we think...

1:37:42 We have agreements in place and actually got a pretty major gift a few months ago that would allow us to generate about $7 million now towards the project. So you know where the, does everybody know where the Edison Theater is and that parcel of land? So if you take that parcel of land and you take this dark blue piece in the center,

1:38:08 That's bordered by College Parkway. That's about nine acres of the 40 the foundation owns. So the Edison Theater, when you look at it, is to the left. We're proposing a new performing arts center that would be a 300-seat state-of-the-art facility. And behind it, we have a bowl out there that we think we can get probably five to 800.

1:38:33 People in. We would add additional parking. We have a placeholder for a potential fine arts center in the future. And then we add a small storage building, which would probably be like a butler building that gets concealed in the trees and is also used as a set construction shop and costume and things that go with the theater project.

1:39:03 So we're moving this along. If you go online and look at Mammoth Mac, and that's Mammoth and then M-A-C-C dot com, you'll see our business plan, our draft business plan is posted online. And we've spent over a year working on the business plan. We researched.

1:39:31 A half dozen other theaters and resort communities or non-resort communities that had things similar to what we do here. We hired a consultant to kind of analyze that and we took some of that information to create the business plan model that we're proposing. There's an overview. What would you like to know? So, and I'm not quite sure if the question is

1:40:05 For you, or for you, Sandra, ultimately, what will be the, as a commission, our role in this project? The commission would likely approve, go through an approval process for the project. I haven't had a chance to, you know, go through and take a look at what's proposed to see what other, if it needs to go to council as well. Okay. So there is a role for the commission. I'm just not sure what entitlements would be required at this point.

1:40:36 So it would go through some sort of standard approval process. I think so, yeah. It's an interesting project because there's school money going into it, and the college is requiring that this go to DSA, Division of State Architects, so it would not go through town planning. Okay. As far as the town approving that.

1:41:04 And DSA has a more stringent standard, probably much more costly standard. But I think because this is going to be a community facility, I mean, we certainly want to keep everybody in the loop and get everybody's comments as they go forward. So the project in our EIR was originally next to the college. It was the center of the college campus. And at the time, it was proposed at

1:41:32 About 25,000 square feet. And right now we're looking at about 14,000 square feet. So there's some gray areas here that Sandra and I are going to try to sit down next week and talk through so she can come back to you guys with some ideas on what the scope of this is going forward. All right. So my suggestion would be that

1:41:58 We'd actually schedule you as an agenda item, as a presentation in that way, then it's noticed and we can have a dialogue back and forth. I think it would be really worthwhile. I mean, it's something that's a great project and we certainly as commissioners would all like to understand more about it. Did anybody else have any questions at this time? I've got a couple of quick ones. Yep. The housing in orange, Evan, is it student housing or is it market rate housing?

1:42:26 To be determined. Got it. In our master plan, there's no entitlements for it. So if we bring back a plan that we have 20 acres that's gorgeous, it's right across from the trails out there. We've always had it penciled in as some kind of residential housing.

1:42:50 Could be a work in progress with Mammoth Lakes Housing or somebody else that would certainly try to benefit staff and people living and working in that area. But I think when we get to that point, we probably have to start talking about a general plan amendment to get entitlements for that piece of the puzzle. And the other really quick question I had, and I know this will be coming back before us, but the Events Center...

1:43:15 Could it also be used as meeting space or conference space? Absolutely. Yeah. Read through, when you get some time, read through the business plan. I think it gives a pretty good outline. But we see this as a community facility. And when we started looking at this, we decided, let's make this a project that's animated, that has a lot of stuff happening and going on.

1:43:45 We would have the 100-seat Edison Theater, we would have the new 300-seat Theater, and we would have a 500-seat outdoor amphitheater-ish, maybe more, that's wind protected by the height of the Performing Arts Center. Got it. Thank you. Well, thank you very much. It's very exciting, and we appreciate you coming forward. Thanks, Mickey. If only there was an ice skating rink close that they could use as additional facilities as part of the project and meeting space. Darn, what an idea. Anyway.

1:44:24 I don't think that was your item. You need to talk to the microphone so that the TV people... Yes. More importantly because...

1:44:59 They're televised and they show up forever. I feel better wandering around. I know you do. Maybe you can arrange with. I'm so used to dodging rocks. That's the real reason. But anyway, in communities where you can afford a half million dollar house or a three-quarter million dollar house that are really nice, the main reason, the number one reason for moving there, it's not the area. It's not the trails. It's not the ski mountains. It's not the beauty. It's schools.

1:45:27 Schools as number one. Number two is the area. And it just amazes me over and over again how we neglect.

1:45:35 Building up our school to be the sort of school that's going to attract the families that can afford a $750,000 house. Now, our schools in Mammoth, if you actually look online at how they're doing, they're doing really well. Mammoth schools are in the top. If you actually remove part of the socioeconomic factor, the 30% that don't speak English, we're in the top 95 percentile of the state, so it's really good. But if you...

1:45:59 Can afford an expensive house, and you can live wherever you want, which these days, by and far, a person who can afford a three-quarter million dollar house doesn't need to live where the business is. They can live wherever they want. No longer are you relegated to living near your occupation. And they're going to be looking for a school that isn't just above average, just going to need to be schools that have all of the AP classes and all of the amenities that are desired.

1:46:25 We fail to see what that would do. Can you imagine? Some of you realize it was, what, 12, 15 years ago when a firm came to Mammoth and looked at moving 20 of its million-dollar employees. They looked all over the West, where to move these data mining employees. Mammoth was a stop. They chose Deer Valley, Utah. One of the reasons was schools. So I'm making this spill because as time goes on, I just hope we recognize as a community the value of building up our schools.

1:46:55 And what that would do for recreation, what that would do for the volunteers of the community, what that would do for employees to work in the community, it would be a huge benefit. And for years, many of us thought that just wasn't that possible because we didn't have any bandwidth up here and that would never happen. I was involved at the ground level at visiting the marine bases and the communities down south of Digital 395. Helped write later, helped campaign, went to Sacramento.

1:47:23 And we got that $100 million to put in digital 395. We now have pretty much infinite bandwidth. We do not have the problem that we had in the past of attracting businesses that need that. We have the area. We have the skiing. We have the trails. We really need to build our schools up. I wanted to make that a little spill.

1:47:44 I'm on, five or six of us joined what's called the Major S Ballot Initiative. We are a non-profit. We're not, by law, we can't be associated with a school district. So we're working on our own time trying to raise money and trying to politic for the pass of what's going to be Major S, Major G on the ballot coming up here. And this is the fourth time around. The last four times, last three times it was on the ballot, it was

1:48:09 We did it as a special ballot initiative rather than being on a general election. We did that back then because supposedly if you have a ballot major, that's the only thing on there. You generally get people who are pro showing up more than you would opposed. California, unlike most other states, it's very difficult to.

1:48:28 Pass any sort of tax measure because it takes 66%, which is kind of insane because it's hard to get 66% of anybody to agree on anything. So it did pass the last three times, four times, and this time it's on the June ballot, so whether or not it will or not, I don't know, but we really hope so. And aside from the need of the roughly $640,000 a year that it raises,

1:48:56 It's so important because the budget for the school district is about $11 million. So $640,000 is a lot of money for an $11 million budget.

1:49:07 And it funds, not teachers, it funds enhanced math and science, class, music, arts, and recent programs, extracurricular, athletic programs, small class sizes, as we all know, is essential for the younger grades, technology, we pay for a lot of computers with this money. This is part of that key that we need for actually making Mammoth Schools great schools, which will attract the families we really want to move here, not to mention that thing that maybe isn't that important, which is our kids, something very positive for our kids.

1:49:36 So I'm here to promote this and ask both that you support it as well as you tell your friends to support it. And we'll do a little bit of campaigning. In years past, some big guy on the mountain up there gave us about $15,000 towards this campaign. Though generosity prevailed, it was about a third of that.

1:49:55 We're in a lot of trouble for getting the money we need to continue our campaign. So donations are greatly needed and appreciated, of course, if you're not you or anybody else. Mailing is $2,000 alone, so we're about $6,000 behind where we wished we were right now. So I'll be pounding the streets looking for that, and I don't know if there's anything else I can really add to this other than it's $59 a year, this parcel tax. It's a huge amount. It's like going out to dinner once a year.

1:50:23 My only beef with this tax measure is it's too small. $59, come on, come on, my guys. The schools really need the help. They really need to be great. It really should be more than $59, and it shouldn't come up every five years for renewal. We really should be putting this on the ballot maybe next time as a permanent measure that doesn't have to come up for renewal and make it a little bit more reasonable amount. And down the road, I'm sure you'll see a bond measure for building a new school, and I hope that's supported because, again,

1:50:53 Not only do the kids deserve it, this area deserves it. Anyway, any questions? Do you have any questions, Commissioner? No. Thank you for supporting it. Thank you. Would you kindly state your name for your record? Right. Greg Newbery. Did you get it? Not here to fix computers today. I know. That's right. Thank you very much. And, you know, you are absolutely right about schools are extremely important. So we appreciate you coming forward.

1:51:19 And last, and most important, I think, is you guys are heroes to me. You guys are, you're volunteering your time. You don't get paid anything or very, almost nothing. And the amount of effort being on Planning Commission is huge. I was on the first elected town council. I was on the school board for eight years. I was on the water board for eight years. Arts council. And the amount of time you guys put into it, I just, you're heroes. So thank you for doing that. Well, thank you very much. Thank you.

1:51:47 We do get granola bars, though. Do we have to declare that? Maybe. Good afternoon. Jennifer Halferty. I learned. Mammoth Lakes Housing. I wanted to take a few minutes during public comment and bring you up to speed with what Mammoth Lakes Housing is up to with regards to the shady rest parcel. So our board met as it has been.

1:52:48 discussing the Shady Rust Parcel since about October and at our last meeting in April, we moved forward with hiring an architect and we've held a meeting with town staff and some of the NGO leaders and as well as a council member to talk, well he's our board member as well, Colin Ferney, to talk about

1:53:16 the shady rest parcel and how can we either possibly procure it or at least understand what can be done on the site and

1:53:31 We have, we've talked with the present owners and they're not interested in entertaining any negotiations at this point because they're waiting for the result of the Hart-Howerton plan. So we've reached out to them but that's not moving forward at this time. But while that's happening, Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing due diligence looking at the feasibility of to develop the plan, the site, excuse me, in accordance with the master plan.

1:54:01 Which, as we talked about today on the tour, is 172 units of affordable housing. That's, as it's outlined in the zoning, the affordable housing overlay zone, that's up to 120% of the area median income, so that goes above middle income, and then down to low income, and it does allow for, of course, the state density bonus as well. The town has a density bonus.

1:54:25 And so we're working with the architect, we're working with a group out of Sacramento that works in all of the western U.S. on affordable housing and water issues, RCAC.

1:54:40 to do a feasibility analysis on the site so that we understand if we should get into a situation where we're able to start negotiations, what is potentially possible on that site. It's just our due diligence. I've provided you with just a synopsis of the history. It's a pretty...

1:55:05 Interesting parcel. It's an interesting history that we've put together based on historical documents. I just want to mention real quick that there is a need for housing. I know that the state gives a number to the town every five years on a new number that the town must meet.

1:55:29 For the state's requirements, that's not a locally identified number. Locally, we know that our needs are greater than what the state identifies for five years out. We hired RRC and associates to do a study back in 2011 on our needs gap.

1:55:51 They looked at what do we need today in 2011 and then looking forward what do we need going through 2015 and that's accounting for growth in industries, job growth, loss of people.

1:56:07 And then also, you know, through retirement attrition of our current workforce back in 2011. And they estimated our gap in affordable workforce housing to be between 264 and 421 homes that would be needed by 2015.

1:56:26 You know, we've got that data. We've got anecdotal data that we're hearing from both employees and employers with the challenges of finding housing and their employees having challenges in finding housing. We have a wait list at Mammoth Lakes Housing. The Mountain had a wait list this past winter for their housing. And, you know, we're seeing these challenges.

1:56:50 All across the nation, of course, but we have to look locally and what is our need and how can we solve for it? And so this is our attempt to identify one possible solution. Any questions? Thank you very much. You're very welcome. So our next item on our agenda is a business matter. It's the appeal of the administrative decision of the Community and Economic Development Manager to deny the interpretation request from D. English.

1:57:42 property owner of 3183 Main Street, and our staff, is it going to be Sandra or Ruth? Ruth is going to do the presentation today. Thank you. This is an appeal of the administrative decision of the Community and Economic Development Manager to deny the property owner the English's interpretation request. Is your mic on? I'm sorry. It is. There you go. Better. Okay.

1:58:08 The appeal was filed on April 7th, subsequent to the decision of the town council to not hear the appeal. The commission's role in this appeal process is to consider the issue being appealed, determine whether the decision was consistent with the zoning code, and either affirm the decision or reverse the decision if the commission finds the decision was not consistent with the zoning code.

1:58:31 The decision being appealed is the denial of an interpretation request that sections of the zoning code's commercial zoning district's chapter be interpreted as not applicable to the subject property located at 3183 Main Street along the south frontage road within the downtown zoning district. The purpose of the interpretation request is to allow multifamily residential use on the ground floor of the subject property.

1:58:55 The central issue in this appeal is that multifamily residential uses, while allowed in the commercial zoning districts, are not permitted on the ground floor of buildings located along primary and active frontages in the downtown and Old Mammoth Road zoning districts. The basis for the denial of appeal is that zoning code figure 17.24.020 clearly depicts the south frontage road along which the property is situated as a primary active frontage.

1:59:24 Properties located along primary active frontages are not allowed multifamily residential uses on the ground floor. Accordingly, the property owner's request that the land use restrictions applicable to properties on primary active frontages not be applied to the property is inconsistent with the zoning code, and town staff cannot change, eliminate, or ignore any aspect of the code.

1:59:46 As an alternative, staff is currently working on a zoning code amendment as a part of the floor area ratio project that will allow 75% of the ground floor to be used for non-active uses, such as multifamily residential. 25% of the ground floor fronting the active frontages will be required to be commercial, active, pedestrian-oriented uses. Staff anticipates that this amendment, in coordination with the floor area ratio project, will be considered by the Commission and Council within the next few months.

2:00:18 Based on the analysis providing the staff report, staff recommends that the commission move forward with option one and adopt the PEDC resolution, denying the appeal, determining that substantial evidence exists to support the denial, and affirming the Community Economic Development Manager's decision to deny their interpretation request. Staff is available to answer any questions, and Matthew Lehman, representative of the applicant, is here as well. Okay. Did you want me to...

2:00:49 Pose some of my questions now, or did you? Well, do you have a statement? Yeah, I do. I have a number of questions, actually, and I'm assuming you probably can't answer all of them right now, but we would like to get some answers to them. I'm, again, Matthew Lehman. I'm here representing Dee English regarding this matter, and, you know, the overarching reason I'm here is, you know, Miss English really opposes the decision.

2:01:18 of this being denied. And she asked me really to help clarify some things in the form of questions. One, she spoke with a town attorney and apparently Ms. English recently told, evidently the attorney told Ms. English that neither he nor the town understands her request. So does, I guess the one question is does everybody, does the Planning Commission understand the request?

2:01:48 And if so, if there's any confusion, she wanted to clarify a letter she'd written April 25th, basically saying that for all reasons previously provided, we request the town interpret the zoning code's ground floor residential use prohibition as meaning ground floor located along Main Street, not ground floor located along the current frontage as said. And I'm not sure if you guys were aware of that or not, but I think

2:02:15 You know, looking at the Main Street plan, the longer term vision was to get rid of that frontage road. So it's now on a frontage road, will not be on a frontage road at a future date. So I saw nods, assuming everybody was aware of her interpretation of it. And two, is it correct to say that the only basis for the denial is that the code doesn't allow?

2:02:41 A ground floor residential use, and if not, was there some other reasons for the denial? Was it strictly just on the residential interpretation? And we prepared the letter, the letter that kind of responded to the request outlining the denial, but basically it is related to that figure in the zoning code that shows that it's the primary active frontage, describes

2:03:09 Primary frontages are described in the zoning code as well. So it's really, there's no latitude for staff to say that it doesn't have to comply with that requirements. Okay. And then, maybe you just answered this question, but what is the timing for enacting the promised amendment with the 75% ground floor residential and 25% commercial? Is that something that's coming before the Planning Commission in June, July?

2:03:37 It will come before the Planning Commission. The Environmental Impact Report is expected to be released in the next couple of weeks. Okay. There is a 45-day period, review period for the Environmental Impact Report. So depending on the level of comments we get on the EIR, that will depend on when it comes before the Commission and the Council. So likely mid-late summer. Okay. And then is there a 30-day wait period after there's an approval, like there are in some other? Right. Okay. Yes.

2:04:07 Plus, and then 30. Okay. And then what does the commission, you know, she's curious, what does the commission envision as being done with this vacant piece of property now? And I know some of the concerns are, and I think we addressed some of them in our tour today, but, you know, there's a lot of vacant property around Mammoth, and particularly in some of the larger buildings, larger spaces.

2:04:37 I think she's just trying to get some sort of vision as to what we're going to be doing to cure the problem. And, you know, a follow-up question is, what about the blight? How do we avoid that? You know, Main Street didn't have any vacancies on it, gosh, about a year ago. And now, you know, the Bank of America space is empty, and now this larger space is empty, and, you know, now Old Mammoth Road, we're starting to see Chart House go dark and a number of other places.

2:05:05 Now another restaurant on the Sierra Center Mall. So I think that her concern, my concern too, I think a lot of people's concern is we have to start, I think we better start trying to come up with some solutions to either drive folks here or come up with a plan to, I don't, you know, I don't know, maybe that's another discussion, but I think she was curious how, you know, the town's hoping to avoid that. I'm sorry, my time's running out. And then,

2:05:32 She wanted to know, has there been anything that's changed since Winter and Company had predicted or proposed a negative 2% return per year for the next 18 years for any development along these zones? And I don't know, again, is there something we're going to try to do about that given the situation or are we going to just wait for that to happen and leave some of the blighted areas there? I think it's of concern to her. So she's trying to really

2:06:01 Come up with and fill needs. We just heard housing say how much residential properties are in demand. And that's what she's trying to do is actually fill a need for a demand that's out there. And as we had proposed when we came forward, it really was to have the residential there for now and then have commercial go out in the front when that time's ready. When we do end up shutting that road down or putting animation out there.

2:06:27 You know, she's put several million dollars into the units behind there, so she's not someone that's just going to talk about it. If I could have one last question. Is the town considering changing the Main Street vision? When will it happen? And what will those new restrictions require? In the vision that we're talking about now, we're talking about how the entire town's looking for this whole new vision. And the problem she's having and facing is everything's a moving target.

2:06:56 You know, we had the main street plan, and she's trying to accommodate toward that, but the town doesn't even have a mechanism to put that into place. So she's really forced to, well, I can't go forward with the plan that you proposed, but I also can't come up with an alternative to fill my space. So I don't know if any folks are property owners, but it's a little bit hard when you're trying to sit there with an empty building, and you've got to carry that overhead, and your hands are effectively getting tied.

2:07:22 Those are some of the questions she has. I think she's looking for answers, too, in some form or another. And that's all I have today. And I don't know if there's anything I can answer from the Planning Commission related to this matter. Well, I'd like to answer initially some of your comments and your questions. Yes, we're property owners. Yes, we understand the situation on Main Street.

2:07:49 But, you know, the role is, in our role as commissioners is always a very narrow focus. And we are really here just today to talk about the zoning code. And it's really important that when we talk about this situation that we separate the zoning code from the main street because it's really two separate discussions. And regarding the zoning code,

2:08:20 You understand that commission is given the directive to initiate a zoning code based off of general plan. And that's basically what our zoning code did for the commercial update. And we, I think, worked very diligently.

2:08:42 Both in private workshops, a public workshop with the applicant to say, okay, here are all the things that you can possibly do with your building and gave her a series of alternatives and then we even went one step further and said that, you know, you will be able to in the very near future to convert part of your downstairs to residential and leave part of it.

2:09:11 Commercial. So, I mean, we're really here only to talk about the zoning code. Today, we're really not here to talk about Main Street, about visions, about future economic growth, because that's not really the point of the appeal. It's really to talk about the zoning code. So I just wanted to kind of make those comments about that. Okay. And I understand that. I think part of the problem, speaking on behalf of a

2:09:41 Person from the public and not dealing with this every day. Part of the frustration is, I think, really not having a clear vision of what she can do and can't do. I mean, certainly there are uses that are outlined of what she can and can't do within the code, but unfortunately, that's not where the demand is right now. And I think she was, you know, also, you know, if she had that latitude to go out and conform to the Main Street plan, which would have been tailed.

2:10:10 Putting commercial out front or something along those lines, then she would be able to convert this over to residential. But there's really just not a way or a mechanism for her to do that, even though that's part of the town's plan. So I think part of what I'm expressing on her behalf is some frustration, I think, in trying to really just try to adapt an environment of demand for the market today. And, you know, she's kind of got her hands tied in a number of ways, it seems like.

2:10:40 And I don't know, you know, I've spoken, I think, a piece on her behalf, and I don't know, she may have some more questions, and I may need to get some specific answers for her on these. I can submit the questions to you if need be. But that's all I have, unless there's any other questions anybody else had. I have a question. Yes. I know staff have offered an alternative solution.

2:11:12 Yes, and I think it was some sort of, it was a 25% and 75% mix on. And there's your client, Ms. English. I'm sorry? Does she, how does she feel about that particular proposal? Well, I think she's, I think is a secondary alternative. I mean, it's something she's going to think about, obviously, but that's why I was asking the question, when do you think that.

2:11:42 The plan that we have moving forward that's going to be presented hopefully in June or July will be enacted because as a backup. I think she's trying to time when something like that's going to be possible for her versus carrying the note on this thing for how long is it going to be? Is it going to be a month, a year?

2:12:02 What's the timing look like on that? And I think that's why she was asking the question. It's not her first choice, obviously, because, you know, one, if I say she puts commercial in there now, there are some pitfalls to it because the property does slope upward somewhat. And I think, you know, for example, she tried to, you know, 25%, she was thinking of putting, you know, a Starbucks in there. They were talking to Starbucks at one point. But Starbucks didn't want to deal with elevation grade. And that's kind of a challenge, I think, for the building.

2:12:31 Commercially. So, you know, eventually, the other thing is you put it in there, you spend a million dollars in your build out and then when the frontage road finally goes away or there's a, then you got to tear everything apart and now you can't have two layers of commercial. So, you know, it's just, that's part of the problem. So, the other thing is, you know, you got a 4,000 square foot building there. You know, is she supposed to dump, you know, however many hundreds of thousands, millions of dollars into this?

2:12:59 Only to find out later that, you know, okay, now the town will be ready to get rid of the frontage road, and then what? You know, now you've got a commercial here, and then you want to move something more forward to be on the animation, what happens? So I think it's a lot of this is timing concerns and issues for her, and I think it's just a matter of, you know, trying to figure out how does she proceed and go forward, or does she just leave this building empty on Main Street and join the rest of them on Old Mammoth Road?

2:13:30 Sandra, would it be possible or appropriate for you to comment on the town's work towards an implementation plan on the Main Street plan? Yeah, so, thank you. Sandra, I'm not really sure. I mean, I think it's really important in this part, interrupt you, but I think it's really important in this conversation that we keep the Main Street plan separate from the, we're only talking about a zoning interpretation at this point.

2:13:56 Because, and the reason I think this is really important that we separate the two is, is that the applicant's representative at all of the workshops on Main Street said that he never wanted to relinquish the frontage road, and Nori Winter, our consultant, went through a whole charade of how

2:14:17 That property could always be maintained in its present condition when all the other frontage roads were relinquished. So I really feel really strongly that this is not a Main Street conversation. This is a zoning code up conversation. I really don't want to. I think it's very important that we don't combine the two subjects. I'm sorry to interrupt. Okay. I understand what you're saying, but I also think it helps answer.

2:14:46 Or just helps inform the question as to how do any of us start thinking about the future. I know the Main Street plan is not adopted by the town. It's not part of the code, but it was used to inform the update to the commercial zoning code. And I understand the frustrations and the confusion that the applicant and other commercial property owners may have. And I just thought it would be useful to have a comment on what

2:15:17 sort of work the town is doing, but if that's not appropriate, then I don't know. I mean, I'm happy to just briefly summarize the Main Street plan and kind of the steps that occurred after that. I wasn't looking for a description of the plan. No. The question is, how did the town go from where we are now to where the plan? There has to be that mechanism that Matthew was talking about, this implementation plan.

2:15:49 I was under the impression that it's something that the town is working on or will be working on. Right. So kind of setting aside the zoning code discussion that we're having, the Main Street plan has a number of projects, a number of items that it looked to accomplish. What we did is we took information from that plan that was accepted by council. We wove it into the commercial zoning code. Some of the requirements that...

2:16:15 You know, apply to this property came from that Main Street plan. And we also, the idea of getting rid of the frontage roads wasn't considered through an environmental document. The Main Street plan didn't have an EIR. So we did, we are considering eliminating those frontage roads or the option of eliminating those frontage roads as part of the floor area ratio discussion. So that EIR and the mobility element update will include that. And that's the process that the EIR will likely be.

2:16:44 Be released in the next couple of weeks. So that's kind of coming forward. Additionally, the town is working on a policy to determine how to convey those frontage rows. So those kind of other things are going on. While, as Chair Brown mentioned, the focus today is really on the zoning code interpretation and whether or not the town can interpret this very specific requirement in the zoning code as to not apply to Ms. English's property.

2:17:11 Thank you. Now for clarification, I just want to say that the applicant is concerned about timing with the alternative options that we have offered, that staff have offered her, and that can't happen until the EIR report is studied up and completed and evaluated and adopted by the Planning Commission.

2:17:41 And Council. And Council. So there is a process, right? So the EIR, like I said, has a 45-day review period, and then there's a time period in which we respond to the comments on that. And then once we've responded to all the comments, so it kind of depends on how many comments we get on the EIR, how long that process takes. Then it's scheduled for Planning Commission and then Town Council. So it's likely Planning Commission later in the summer, likely more like August, Council in September, and then like you mentioned, Matthew, the 30-day.

2:18:10 Period after that. Okay. And I guess, just one last comment, you know, referring back to this winter and company, you know, I think one of the frustrations she's experiencing is, you know, if our plan is to go along with part of this Main Street vision and we've got a consultant that was hired by the town and the consultant came back saying we're basically any new retail or anything like that that's proposed moving forward,

2:18:40 is going to give a negative 2% return for the next 18 years. I think if we stick with the plan, we really have just set ourselves up for an 18-year failure. So, I don't know. I mean, I don't know if what we have on the books is the right thing or not, but I think hopefully, you know, as this zoning code moves forward, we have a mechanism to allow some of these people to change and adapt to the market because

2:19:10 Right now, we see what's going on around town, and if we don't change and adapt, we're just going to kind of keep going down that road of failure and vacancy and blight and everything else in town, and we don't have what we used to have in the way of, you know, redevelopment districts anymore. So we're going to have to come up with some sort of plan, and I think the property owners and community is going to look to you and the council.

2:19:37 for some answers on that hopefully soon, so, but that's all I have, unless anybody else has anything. Do you have any other questions, Commissioner Brewer? I don't. Any other questions? All right, thank you. Thank you. Do we have any comments from the public? Thank you, Madam Chairman, Tom Cage. I have a business and property across the street, and I'm here to just ask the commission, you took a tour today of town in some areas. There's purple do not cross tape.

2:20:06 Helter Skelter at the top of the stairs. There's the wall where the sign was of the prior business that's a different color. There's no parking signs, kind of Helter Skelter on the building. Mr. Lehman talked about blight and her concern about blight in the building. I think they could do a lot just on a first step to remove some blight. It looks absolutely horrible. And to me is an opinion that she really doesn't care what Main Street looks like or what her property looks like. And it's just disgusting.

2:20:35 Matthew is right. There's empty buildings, empty properties, chain link fences now on Old Mammoth Road and things like that and we can start by just making things look a little bit better. As far as driving tourism, the MLT has seven plus million dollars. I think if they can't drive tourism here, nobody can with that kind of money. A rebound after the last four years is going to take some time.

2:21:00 And I think the lack of planning on someone's part doesn't constitute an emergency on your part. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments? We'll close the public comment period on this. Commissioners, comments? I would just like to say that it seems pretty clear to me that the Frontage Road, as being designated as a primary active frontage in our zoning code, I...

2:21:41 It seems pretty clear to me that we have our hands tied as far as any request for an interpretation here, or reversing the denial, rather. So, Commissioner Chang? I do have to agree. I know there's probably several discussions that we have to have in the future in regards to the related topics, but I think for this particular purpose, we are really, we can really deviate.

2:22:19 from what we have at this moment. Commissioner Farouk? Yeah, I also agree. I think in reading some of the issues and concerns that Ms. English brought up, there's inconsistencies with some of her statements, I find. So I think that we need to just, today, as the code stands today, the zoning code stands today, I think we need to just support that and move forward. No comment.

2:22:52 Yeah, I agree with my fellow commissioners, and, you know, the only comment that I would make is that I do agree that it would be a worthwhile, a future agenda item with our economic development hats on to really talk about what we want to do to stimulate Main Street. Do you have a motion? I'll make a motion that we adopt Planning and Economic Development Commission Resolution 16-

2:23:28 No number, 16, no number. The number's not assigned until it's actually approved, so I just referenced the resolution. Resolution, denying the appeal, determining that substantial evidence exists to support the denial, and affirming the community and economic development manager's decision to deny the interpretation request. I second it. Second. Roll call, please. You have to call each person. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:24:04 Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Our next matter is to consider approval of design review 16-001 and adjustment 16-002 for the Hillside Highlands Project located at 150 Hillside Drive, 130 Hillside Drive and 110 Canyon Boulevard and our staff contact person is Nolan. The Hillside Highlands Project is a three unit

2:25:05 There's three three-unit apartments on three adjacent parcels on the corner of Hillside Drive and Canyon Boulevard directly west of the village. The project is within the North Village specific plan area and design review and approval by the Planning Commission is required by the specific plan for all new projects and development plans. The project also includes an adjustment to increase the maximum lot coverage from 60% to 63%

2:25:34 An exception to the public works standards for residential driveway width to increase the driveway from the maximum 24 feet to 30 feet wide. Each unit will be approximately 3,000 square feet, with the exception of the middle unit of each triplex, which will be approximately 3,500 square feet. All of the units have an oversized two-car garage and one additional unenclosed parking space in the driveway.

2:26:03 Driveways are located off of Hillside Drive for all three parcels. All three properties have a significant downward slope and the building foundations are stepped down the hillside to achieve a level building base at street level. The structures are 24 feet high when measured from the garage roof as allowed by the specific plan when all or a portion of the building sits above a parking garage.

2:26:30 The project meets all of the design guidelines of the town and the North Village Specific Plan and all of the development standards of this specific plan with approval of the adjustment. Additionally, the design committee of the PEDC reviewed the project and were supportive of the design. Materials include textured cement board siding in brown, exposed heavy timber trusses, Corten steel, standing seam metal roof in brown, and natural stone.

2:27:00 These materials are shown on the materials board up here on the corner. Adjustments can be granted when there are special circumstances applicable to the property. The subject lots are all substandard in size, which qualifies as a special circumstance. Additionally, adjustments can be granted if a significant public benefit will result. The driveway and parking areas at street level occupy a significant portion of the lot.

2:27:30 However, this design is far superior to the alternative design which had numerous safety issues related to the steep downward sloping driveway. In exchange for the increase in lot coverage and the driveway that is wider than town standards, the owner has agreed to construct a sidewalk between Forest Trail and Canyon Boulevard in front of this project. The sidewalk is considered a significant public benefit. In closing,

2:28:01 Staff has made the determination that the project meets the findings required to approve the major design review and the adjustment. The exception to the public works standards has been granted by the public works director as required by the municipal code. With that, the applicant, Elliot Brainerd, is here to answer any questions that the commission might have. Do you want to make a statement? Elliot Brainerd, an architect for the applicant.

2:28:39 First thing I'd like to do is just thank Sandra and staff and the commission for a great tour earlier today. I think it was a lot of effort put into it, and I think we all had a good time and learned something along the way, so I think it was great, so thank you. And thank you for inviting me along. Yeah, just briefly, Hillside Highlands, it is for rent.

2:29:06 Project is not a condo for sale project. The owner is planning to own this long term and wanted to do something high end in the more luxury market. He doesn't believe that there's really that many great nightly apartment, larger unit rentals in town. So all of these have easy access.

2:29:33 Thank you.

2:30:03 The Commission, and your thoughts, anything I can answer for you. Commissioner Veruck, do you have any questions? No, I don't. A couple of really quick questions, and this may be staff more than you, Elliot, and I apologize for that, but who's responsible for the snow removal of the sidewalk? For the sidewalk itself, I'm assuming the town, even though the client's going to build it, and it'll be built to the standards, of course.

2:30:35 But yeah, I believe that ongoing maintenance, it's still a town. Town responsibility. Got it. Thank you. That's my only question at the moment. Commissioner Brick? No questions. Thank you. Commissioner Brick? I had the opportunity to participate in one of the architectural review meetings during Commissioner Brick's absence. So I notice in exchange of

2:31:09 The previous design, you simply just added the driveway, or the applicant decided to just pay for the driveway, I mean, excuse me, the walkway, and in exchange, you have increased the driveway space, the area. The width of the driveway. Okay. Was the snow removal or the area of snow removal, was that problem resolved?

2:31:40 Because I know there was some issue of there might not be enough area for snow removal. Yeah, so the requirements for snow removal, it's 75% of the required driveway and parking areas that's on the site. And so the decks actually encroach or stick out further. So a good portion of the driveway and parking areas are actually covered. They're not uncovered. So then it decreases the overall.

2:32:10 Area that snow removal is required for. So the areas to either side of the driveways is adequate space to meet that 75%. 75% of what? I'm sorry? So it's this area here, there's the, let's see if this works. Oh, it does. That's the line of the overhang. So this line here is the line of the overhang. Okay. And so then it's 75%.

2:32:41 of the area kind of outlined here that's on the site is required then to have snow storage areas. And so those areas then are on both sides of the driveway here and over here. And note these areas do slope down, which also further increases the actual volume that can be stored there since when you start it's going to be down lower and build up.

2:33:08 And this is the same as other properties that have this similar design with the driveway kind of bridge coming in. Okay. Thank you. So I just have a couple, more of a comment along the stage. Maybe we can go back a slide. To the site plan or the elevation one? The actual elevation. Well, I wanted to go back to where the dumpsters were actually in that one.

2:33:43 First of all, my overall impression, it's a beautiful project. I really like the architectural lines. Commissioner Gregg explained at our pre-meeting that you did some things with the back elevations to give it a better presence towards the village. I just think over the years, sometimes we've sold ourselves a little short on snow storage and on our dumpster enclosure, so we take this beautiful project and

2:34:11 Then it gets down to the practicality of stuff. So I just, you know, I'm just a little concerned about where we show those dumpster enclosures, if they're going to even work because of the angle and with the snow storage areas. So I just didn't know if he had given it any alternative thoughts or plans or if that was pretty well the limitation of.

2:34:36 Well, a lot of it's the limitation of the property itself because it's downsloping. In one of the design review meetings, I think it was with Amy and Paul, we talked about potentially connecting the dumpster to the side of the building, actually incorporating that in the front elevation. Right. But that actually pushed it down the hill further and made the access for both snow removal and

2:35:03 The dumpster service a little more difficult. I did go spend time with Michelle at Mammoth Disposal about this for access, dumpster size, all those kinds of things. And so this is what she preferred in this location. I mean, I agree with you from an aesthetic point of view. It's not anybody's favorite to have it right out there in front. The goal will be to landscape around that, obviously, as much as possible.

2:35:31 to hide and screen those. Also in this scenario, in this picture, you'll see that we actually on the middle and north property, we backed up the two dumpsters and the shelters for those. So there are only two dumpster sheds for three properties. So we tried to minimize the number of them at least. And if you think that they should be separated into three smaller ones,

2:36:00 That's okay, too. We were just trying to see what might look best and minimize that number. But that's how it developed. Well, more of my question, and I'm really sorry that I didn't pose this to you beforehand. Can't we treat this more like a residential property, and then they wouldn't have to have dumpster enclosures, and then they can just take their trash to the transfer site like a single-family home would?

2:36:30 So the North Village specific plan is silent on what triggers on the dumpster enclosures. And so for those instances, we refer to the municipal code, which then has the requirement for multifamily developments with three or more units has to have a dumpster enclosure or a dumpster on site. I mean, I think that's a good comment if they were monthly rentals, but they're nightly rentals. And so I think it's really difficult for

2:37:01 Somebody that comes to town, what do I do with my trash? So it becomes a problem. They don't know where to go. They leave it in the garage. I mean, all the other things that happen, it probably creates a bigger problem overall. We also did size these. Michelle said for this size unit, they only needed the two-yard dumpsters, which are small. So we actually sized these if they can put the next size up or even the next further size up without.

2:37:29 Doing any modification. Because I'm not sure that from a practical point of view that really that little dumpster is really going to be adequate. So at least there's an option that they can go bigger without changing this.

2:37:44 Okay. I mean, I understand. It's just that I see the dumpster as the focal point of your piece of art, you know, in essence. Yeah, I agree. You got an option. I'd love to look at it. You haven't been able to figure it out that it makes any sense. And access for the truck always drives a lot of things, unfortunately. And access by the car, too. So it always seems to drive design a lot. Okay. And then I just had two.

2:38:15 technical questions for staff in reading the conditions. So there's this condition in 33 that says if any of the apartment units are used for residential occupancy for periods of 30 or more consecutive days, et cetera, et cetera. Can you expound on that condition, please? Sure. Since these units are being built as apartments, they're not being built as owned condos. The rules for condo conversions

2:38:47 Would apply to it if they're rented for a period of longer than 30 days. So then they become essentially part of the existing rental unit stock. Okay. Since they're being proposed that they're going to be short-term nightly rentals, it's likely that that condition will never apply. It's just in there that in the event they were to switch to long-term, the owners are aware that they can't just then split it into condos at their free will.

2:39:16 Okay. All right. And can you explain condition 37? Sure. And what, I guess, are your specifics? That one, it's really coming from the fire department. That was one of their conditions. And so that's related to just materials and fire code and building code as to what the construction would be on it. And have we ever seen that term, the wildland-urban interface, before?

2:39:47 Yeah, it is a common term. It's, they often say wooey when they talk about it. But yeah, it's in the current building code for new construction as well as the fire code. And it really has to do with kind of materials on the outside and then the combustibility of it. So this one is being proposed that's core 10 and the textured cement board siding. Neither of those are combustible materials, so those do comply.

2:40:14 And then it goes further and has requirements for gaps on the exterior of the building. I think it's an eighth-inch gap. It's a whole list of items that if you want, after we can, I can send you a list or have Tom Perry, the building official, can elaborate further as well on those. Or Tom Heller. Yeah, to clarify that, actually, WUI came about really after the Tahoe fire, where the state of California divided.

2:40:43 The state into different fire districts and zones, and some are a higher risk than others, and we're obviously one of the higher risk zones in the state, and so there's a whole list of requirements, like all windows, all windows now in town of Mammoth have to be tempered glass, you don't have that option anymore, non-combustible building materials.

2:41:05 There's a whole list of assemblies that are required. And it's really strange as you go to work in other areas within the state how they interpret WUI differently and their requirements are different. Okay. Good. Thank you. And then my only last question for you, is the owner aware of all the conditions and they're agreeable to him? Yes. I actually emailed him the staff report the day before yesterday.

2:41:35 emailed him again earlier today to make sure there weren't any outstanding issues that, hey, are you okay with this? So we could always go back and change something, but I'd rather deal with it up front right now instead of doing that later. So he said everything looked good. He didn't have anything that jumped out at him. All right. Do we have any public comments? I've got a couple more questions. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. That's okay.

2:42:04 Relates to item number 33. I just want to make, to give some clarification. You said that earlier, it's not possible for the existing design to convert into a condominium unit? That's incorrect. It is possible. There is a, the whole section of the code that's referenced in that condition deals with condo conversions. That's going from an apartment into condominiums.

2:42:31 One of the initial requirements is to look at the existing housing stock and the vacancy rate. And in the code there's a whole section where I believe if the vacancy rate is less than 5% within the town, then you can convert the condo without having to do these additional steps. If it's below 5%, which historically it has been right now, I think it's about 2%,

2:43:02 Then you have to essentially leave those units vacant for a period of two years or not use them as a rental unit for a period of two years before you can then convert it to a condo.

2:43:18 Originally, it was designed as an affordable housing mitigation measure so that people wouldn't take rental units and make them for sale units. It's a little different in this situation because you're talking about a high-end product. But there's a possibility that this property, that the individual units within each building can be converted to condominium. At the current time, it's not the owner's intent.

2:43:48 To convert them, he, but in the event, if they never rented for over 30 days, if they're always nightly rentals, five years from now, he decides to convert it, he could come in and apply for a tentative map, and those vacancy rate things would not apply since it was never included as an existing rental unit. It's only if it's rented as a long-term unit, longer than 30 days, and they want to convert it, that that would apply.

2:44:16 Yeah, you'd have to submit each building to it as a conversion, so not just one unit within a building could be converted to a condo. Correct. So each property would have to be submitted separately to the state and processed that way. Right, got it. Last question, the color that's represented here on the screen, I noticed the exterior.

2:44:44 Any other questions?

2:45:15 Nope. Okay. We'll close. Thank you. Thank you. We'll close public comments. Deliberation? Commissioner Chang? No comment. I mean, I would move. Do you have any comments? Just to say that I think that this is a fantastic project and a much-needed product here in town, and thank you for bringing it forward to us, Commissioner Vanderhurst. I'll echo Commissioner Gray's statement that I think it's a fantastic product.

2:45:49 It's a T.O.T. generator. It's going to help with the critical mass of the village and the animation of the village, and I think it complements the development that is currently being completed across the street by Mr. Hooper, so thank you for bringing it forward. And then are there any comments about the request for the adjustment as far as the coverage, site parcel coverage? No, I think it's...

2:46:21 Completely reasonable, inappropriate. We need that sidewalk to be completed, and I completely understand why they need a wider driveway. The sidewalk will be a great public amenity. Somebody would like to make a motion? I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolution 2016 making that requires sequel findings and municipal co-findings and approving major design review DR16.001, an adjustment.

2:47:11 $16.002 with conditions as recommended by staff. And do we have a second? I'll second. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Vice Chair Gregg? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Commissioner Burke? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you very much. We'll move on to our consent agenda. And the first item on our...

2:47:46 Well, if it's a consent agenda, we just approve it, right? The commission can approve the consent agenda with one motion, unless there's an item that you want to pull to discuss. So does anybody, can we just approve the consent agenda, or does anybody want to pull any items on the consent agenda? Can I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I would like to make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I second that. You don't have to do a roll call, you can just. All in favor? Aye. All right, the consent agenda is approved.

2:48:18 We'll now move on to commissioner reports. Do we have any additional commissioner reports? From a design committee standpoint, our most recent project was the Hillside Highlands, which we just saw, so I don't know that we have anything further to comment on in that respect. Thank you for putting the time and effort into that. I think the project's going to be, like I said, a really nice compliment to the village. Don't let Hayes leave there.

2:48:53 Can I throw something out there, Chair? One second. Can I just get clarification? Since we didn't talk about Old Mammoth Road and public comments. We can do it under director's report. Okay. And then you'll just do that? Hayes can, I don't know all the details about it. Okay. Hayes can speak. Just because I do think it's important for the commissioners to hear. Okay. Yes. Yeah, I think my commission report would be that

2:49:20 The official relaunch of the visitmammoth.com website is now live. It's a beautiful site, if you haven't had a chance to jump onto it. It's much more built around imagery and inspiration, so you'll see some big, dramatic, sweeping images that dominate the pages. There are listings for everybody who has a business license within the town of Mammoth Lakes, and each business owner or official...

2:49:49 Representation can go in there and enhance their listing as much as they want, add as much information, images, websites, social media, that kind of stuff. So it's an amazing tool for business owners. It's an amazing tool to inspire people to come to Mammoth Lakes summer and winter. And we're hoping it's an amazing tool to prolong the length of stay in destination from smaller visits to longer visits. So take a peek. Visit mammoth.com.

2:50:19 So I'd just like to dovetail on that. I also went to one of the training sessions. And I think what's really important is that each individual business owner develops their landing page. That's what's going to make a really big difference. And Mimi's Cookies have done a tremendous job of doing that. And everybody was salvating to eat.

2:50:38 Cookies, but it's a very visual site. I think the two examples, one would be Mimi's and the other one would be the Westin. The Westin also has done a great job where you go from the visitmammoth.com site to the Westin landing page or to Mimi's landing page. And so you go from this very rich, fulfilling experience on visitmammoth.com to Mimi's, which is another very rich, inspiring landing page. So if you just went from one to a very uninspirational page, I think.

2:51:07 The emphasis on the business owner to make it a parallel experience. That's good. And do you care to comment on the tourism numbers? Unfortunately, I don't have numbers in front of me right now. Oh, and they're big. They're big. They're big, big, big. Okay. And I don't have an estimated opening date for Tioga Pass as well. I know the 16th is when they're talking about reopening the road to the gate. No, tomorrow. Tomorrow, okay. Yeah, the 12th, okay.

2:51:35 I read it was the, oh, they're hoping for the 19th is what the amount of time is. That's what they're hoping, yeah, they're hoping. So, unfortunately, I don't, we don't have, or Mono County also does not have a heart date. Okay. All right. Do you have anything to report? No, I do not. I think that concludes our commissioner report, so we'll move to director's report. So, just to dovetail on what Commissioner Vanderhurst was talking about, I happened yesterday to be on the outside dot.

2:52:04 or outside.com website, and I clicked on a video and I got to see like a three minute commercial for Mammoth, and I didn't even realize we had those commercials out there, and that was, talk about inspiring, that was really inspiring. Yeah, thank you. It looks great. So another item is your June meeting, which is June 8th, is looking to shape it to be a pretty big meeting. We have two zoning code amendments that you'll be considering, one for the water efficient landscape ordinance update,

2:52:33 The non-conforming structures update, two parking lot projects in the North Village, an expansion of the Mammoth Lakes Wellness Medical Marijuana Cooperative, and the multi-use facility EIR scoping. So it's going to be a pretty big meeting, and I wanted to see if the commission wanted to try to meet a little bit earlier that day, or...

2:52:57 Just due to the big agenda. So I just wanted to poll the commission, see if there was any desire to maybe meet, start at 1 o'clock, start earlier in the day. I'm not sure what your schedules look like for that day. And you don't have to give me an answer now. I can send out an email, but just maybe planting the seed that it's a big agenda and we may need to try to meet earlier so we can be done by 5. Are we all able to give a response now or do we have to? I can give a response now. I could meet earlier that day on the 8th.

2:53:26 I can meet earlier as well. I can meet earlier as well, but, you know, that just seems like that's a lot of items for us to consider, you know, given that, you know, I'm sure these are very important items. Is there something that can come up? We may be able to push the Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance Item.

2:53:56 It's really something the state has required us to do, and because we haven't updated the ordinance, we're really just operating now under the state's ordinance, so that's something that we could consider pushing. The non-conforming structures, we'd really like to get that one moving forward, just because there's a lot of interest from the public on that item.

2:54:15 And then the hillside parking lots, there's the town hillside parking lot, and then the East Village parking lot expansion. I think those are two kind of priority projects that we want to get done this summer, so I don't think we would want to push those. The Mammoth Lakes Wellness expansion, I mean, that's a pretty minor project, and I think that it is subject to the mandatory processing time, so we wouldn't want to process that.

2:54:42 As quickly as we can. And then the scoping meeting, the multi-use facility scoping is really an opportunity for the public to provide comments on the EIR. So that's a really important date for us to meet because we're on a timeline for the multi-use facility to try to get that completed quickly. So that one can't be pushed either. So I think we could probably push one item, but I still think it's going to be a big meeting. And do we have an applicant coming forward?

2:55:11 For the multi-use facility? No. For Mammoth Place. For Old Mammoth Place, we do have that project. That likely won't go on June 8th, only because we need three commissioners. Two of the commissioners are conflicted out, and Commissioner, Vice Chair Grayick won't be here. So we will be contacting the three non-conflicted commissioners to try to set up a special meeting date. That's Commissioner Verruck, Chair Brown.

2:55:40 And Vice Chair Gray, we haven't figured out the date, and I don't know if we've had any discussions with the applicant at this point on the date. No, we wanted to kind of pool the commissioners to see when they were available, and then, so we had that to then go to the applicant with, saying these are the options. So we do have a date, so we have a June 3rd, which is a Friday. That date is a possible date, and I think we've talked to three of you about that date, you talked to Commissioner.

2:56:08 Okay, so June 3rd is one of the dates we were looking at for Old Mammoth Place, and we were going to contact Commissioner Veruck to find out if you were available that day. If not, it could be later in June, but we're really trying to kind of work with the applicant to see what their availability is in the commission to try to schedule a special meeting for that sometime in June, just because they have to have three, you have to have a quorum.

2:56:32 And due to the conflicts, it's just, it won't work for June 8th. Well, the reason I ask is if we're going to have a special meeting, if there wasn't something that can be moved to the special meeting, I mean, that was one. Oh, yeah. Okay. Okay. And then, Commissioner Vanderhurst, when are you no longer conflicted out on that project? 14th. Of June? 14th of June. I actually think I might be conflicted out on that project.

2:56:56 Well, and then you need probably to contact the town attorney about your current situation and what you're conflicted in and out of. Okay. Okay? So there's a process that we can go through if three of the commissioners are conflicted out. Right. We'd have to draw straws. Commissioner, do you know how long you're conflicted? Is it one year or two years? One year. And when does that expire? November. Okay. So I guess,

2:57:29 Commissioner Veruck, if you could follow up with a town attorney and see, and then once we know that, then we can determine the process for that and try to get that scheduled. Because I know that's a project that the applicant really wants to push forward as quickly as possible. All of our projects are. Michael is free. You're free after the 14, why can't you just wait until then after that? We could, if that timing works for the applicant. And do you know when you'd be available in June, back available? I think the only, I'm just,

2:57:59 Unavailable from the 5th through the 10th, I believe. So maybe that following week. I mean, we try to have our meetings on Wednesdays. The next Wednesday is a town council meeting date, but it's, you know, the 15th, I think it's the 15th. 15th is, yeah. So it is a council meeting day, but that's not a problem because we meet earlier in the day. So we'll follow up on that. So we're not in a position to schedule a meeting for June 3rd.

2:58:31 Right? No. Okay. But, and will we even make our notice requirements for June 3rd at this point? We could? Mm-hmm. Okay. So is there, so then is there an item that we could, to today, could say we can push to a special meeting? Or do you want to just say we're going to start at 1 o'clock to make it date and time certain? Why don't we look, so you don't actually have to make the decision to start at 1 o'clock.

2:59:04 Today. It just has to be noticed that way. So when we notice that planning and economic development commission meeting, it has to include that on the notice. So it is nice to provide the public with, you know, the advance warning that it's going to be a different time. But what I think we can do is maybe go back and look at some of these projects. I'm not sure the timing on the parking lots in the village, whether they could move or not. But maybe we could take a look kind of at all the agenda items and see if they could move and try to kind of split these items into two meetings. Okay.

2:59:34 Do we need to work also on our priorities as a department's priorities and to get feedback from the commission on that? You mean the department's work program? We usually bring that. I think it would be good to bring that forward after the town council has adopted their priorities. Okay. But that's not technically true because they've been very explicit that their priorities do not relate to anything that currently is on a work program.

3:00:04 So, I mean, that's what they've said over and over again, that if it's already on a work program, they're not putting it on their priority list. Right. I think we brought the priorities to the commission. I don't think it was that long ago, but we tried to bring it like twice a year to the commission to have a discussion on it. Okay. So we could bring that back maybe at the July meeting. Okay. Well, that would be at your discretion when you thought it would be appropriate for us to look at it. I just want to make sure we allocate the time necessary. Right. All right.

3:00:31 So the other item I wanted to, and we discussed it at a previous meeting as well, but three of the commissioners are up for reappointment at the end of July. Vice Chair Greg, Commissioner Chang, Commissioner Verruck. So I just wanted to kind of give you a heads up that the council will likely be conducting interviews on July 20th.

3:00:55 At that council meeting, and then the commissioners would be appointed at the first commission meeting in August. So just so you know, that's kind of the schedule for the commissioners. And we'll go through the same process as last year? Yes, yes. Unless there's only three. So if there's three vacancies and only three people apply, they usually don't go through that process, but it kind of depends. But usually they do have the interviews, so the interviews would be on the 20th.

3:01:26 And that's all I have. Oh, except for my report on Old Mammoth Road. I'm sorry. Thank you for waiting. Oh, no problem. Okay, just to quickly revisit the scope of the Old Mammoth Road Rehabilitation Project, we'll be grinding two inches of asphalt from Main Street all the way down just past Mammoth Creek Park and replacing that top two inches of asphalt with new AC.

3:01:58 Removing and replacing and correcting all the pedestrian ramps to be ADA compliant. We will be removing the concrete crosswalks that are across Old Mammoth Road, not the ones that are parallel, and just replacing those with asphalt. We have contracted with West Coast Paving.

3:02:19 Town Council has approved that. Contract is in place. Contractor expects to begin working on the concrete ramps and the demolition May 23rd. That work will continue that week. The following week, the plan on starting to grind the asphalt, and they will do that in two sections to be determined in which, how they're going to coordinate its means and methods, so they will tell us and we will approve it. And then the following week, they'll finish the project.

3:02:47 Two weeks after that, they will be lifting, through the next two weeks, they will be lifting utilities and concrete collars and completing the striping. All the work is scheduled to be completed by June 24th, but the most invasive, the asphalt and the paving work will be completed by June 10th. I have a really quick question about that. Hayes, does that affect the traditional course for the half marathon? We're going to have brand new asphalt for the half marathon. Got it. So the finish line will still be right there on Old Mammoth Road?

3:03:17 That'd be all buffed out. Perfect. Thank you. I have a question. Sure. Can they put a stop sign at the intersection of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret? What? Where the traffic light is? No, Old Mammoth and... Old Mammoth. Oh, out at Snow Creek. Yeah. Oh, out there. Oh. Well, you know, that just, that would be, if there was, whenever there's development, that would become part of the development of that area. You put a stop sign.

3:03:47 Besides, it helps you work on your LA driving skills. That's also not within the extent of this project and would require additional engineering studies to evaluate. All right. Can we get a street sign on Oak Tree Way? That we can probably do. All right. So let's go back to Old Mammoth Road because I think this is important. Would you comment on...

3:04:10 Our Spirit Only Dig It Once program and what you're working with the utility companies and how you're working with the Digital 395. I think it's really important that everybody understands. Yes, absolutely. So Digital 395 actually runs within the project extent from approximately Mammoth Creek Park down to Meridian.

3:04:31 Past Meridian, the backbone of 395 is down Sierra Park. So most of the businesses and residences that are gaining access to digital 395 are laterally accessing it down Sierra Park Road or Tavern Road. To access it, to create a Dig It Once conduit program along Old Mammoth Road and place that would be very difficult because we do not know ultimately where those connections need to be.

3:05:00 And you would have to place vaults and barrels and access points along the way and provide enough capacity for what we really don't know what's going to happen. So it's actually easier just to directional bore or trench in on the laterals to access Sierra Park. We have placed conduits in each one of the concrete sidewalks.

3:05:24 There'll be sleeves that'll be placed for smaller, you know, electrical lines or irrigation lines so we don't have to trench across those for, you know, town uses and so forth. But for things as large as digital 395 or water or sewer, it just doesn't make any sense to do it on that scale. Okay. And because there's a lot of questions about that, so I just want to make sure. And then you have a more, the utility companies are all working frantically now, right, because there's a moratorium once they put the new road in, right? Correct.

3:05:56 So you'll see a lot of action on the road right now. Okay. Hello, Mammoth. Right. How long is the moratorium for once? I believe it's five years. Is this the part of the project that involves replacing the eight-inch wide grass strip on the sidewalks? No. That's a later project that's attached to the assessment district. All right.

3:06:21 And then lastly, can you comment on making Old Mammoth Road ultimately a shared road? Correct. So what...

3:06:29 Madam Chair is referring to as complete streets, AB 1358, where the town is required to provide multimodal transportation methods on reconfigured streets. We are constrained by the curb cuts. We have only 39 feet of width to work with, and we have to provide three 12-foot lanes and two 10-foot bike lanes within there, which the math just doesn't work out.

3:06:54 So we've vetted a number of alternatives and actually sent this out to some consultants to see if they had any ideas, and it just does not meet any of the MUTCD requirements for dimensions for lane widths or bicycle lanes. So what we're considering is a share-the-road situation, which is commonplace in larger cities where the bicycles have the right to use the full

3:07:21 Lane width, and it is signed as such that the bicycles within that corridor have the right to use the full lane and vehicles have to follow the typical vehicle code, three foot for passing and so forth. So that is the solution that we are vetting right now. And then most likely then...

3:07:45 Part of that solution then would be is that we would really have to promote our alternative multipath uses so that if you're out with your family and you don't want to use Share the Road that you have an alternative. And it is pretty easy to do actually if you know the different paths. The Share the Road program is really more of a commuter-based program or, you know, for the...

3:08:09 The cyclist that is comfortable using the roadway as a means of transport. We will have some directional signage to kind of get people to the multi-use paths and some of the more classic bike lanes. But we will try to do that within the confines of the manual and uniform traffic control devices. Now that program is, I'm assuming it's most useful during the summer season and fall. In the wintertime it's...

3:08:38 Probably not. It would be applicable to both seasons, but we do see heavier uses in the summer, that's for sure. All right. Any other questions about that? No. All right. Do we have any other comments on any director's report? Thank you for staying and sharing with us. Thank you. All right. Then I move that we adjourn our meeting to June the 8th at 2 p.m., possibly subject to a time change. We'll meet.

3:09:13 Suite Z at Old Mammoth Road. Thank you very much for coming. We're up for, it depends. Up for debate. It depends if.