Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 16 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
154 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:35 and Economic Development Commission meeting for June 8, 2016. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Verruck? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, and liberty and justice for all.
1:17 If it's agreeable to my fellow commissioners, we've been asked to do a slight agenda change so that after public comments but before the public hearings, we would pull consent agenda item 6 and hear that first consent item 6 is tract map 15-003. It's just the final approval. That's fine with me. All right.
1:42 So at this time we'll have public comments. Public comments is this portion of the agenda where anybody in the audience can speak on any issue that's not on today's agenda. Good afternoon, Commissioner. Shereen Sanders, Code Compliance Officer for the town. I'd like to just give you a brief update about what's been going on in code enforcement. Most significantly, a couple weeks ago, we had a very successful town cleanup day.
2:12 We collected 43.79 tons of green waste, 3.6 tons of e-waste for a total of 110.43 tons total, which is pretty good considering we thought the weather was going to be a hindrance. It's a little cold in the morning, but otherwise we were constantly replacing the roll-offs at our two cleanup station sites at the community center and at 407 Manzanita. And the transfer station was busy all day as well.
2:41 Do you think that was a record? I don't think it was a record. I mean, maybe recently in the last few years, but not going way back. But anyway, I just want to thank everybody that came out and pitched in, Stu Brown, Grady, all the town staff that helped out.
3:03 We had volunteers from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors again. And without all those people, there's no way we could pull this off. So thank you all again. In other notes, we're in spring coming into summer, so I'm dealing quite a bit with flutterflies, temporary banners, signs, sandwich boards that aren't supposed to be there.
3:29 People forgetting or just trying to push it as we have all the snow melt. And then lastly, we just had the election last night. It looks as if today most of the candidates have taken their signs down, but there's a five-day grace period for those to come down per the municipal code, so we'll be looking into that. Any questions? No, but thank you again for all your hard work on Town Cleanup Day. It really makes a big difference.
3:59 Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, Madam Chair, Commissioner, staff and public, Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I'm going to work through, there's an agenda bill, some quick notes, an update for the public, the paper's on the back side on the tabletop. Back in December, Town Council approved priority phase projects for MLR, Park West Project, which you hear about later on today, the MAC, Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, Trails End Park, which we expect to get done by the end of the summer.
4:32 Mammoth Lakes Trail System and the Outdoor Performing Arts Center. Those are the top five. Today I want to give a quick update on the OPEC, as I call it. The goal of the Outdoor Performing Arts Center was to create a venue between 7,500 and 10,000 that can grow over the next 10 years. When you talk to different event planners, Rich, build it, we will come. How do we program it at this point in time?
4:54 Back in March, we met with Town Council. We started with 37. Hello, Hais. We started with 37 different sites. We're down to seven at this point in time. Sam's Wood Site, Mammoth Lakes Foundation, Mammoth Park East, the Snow Pit, Canyon Lodge, Bell Shaped Parcel, and RV Park East.
5:10 Town Council approved a wetland delineation study for the bell-shaped parcel of $12,000. Town staff has assured me that study will be done by the end of the summer, so we can actually figure out what we can do or not do with that facility at this point in time. Over these past six weeks, we met with staff on the Mountain staff, the Mammoth Lake Foundation staff, and the District Ranger to find out what the possibilities were. Some of these have been very active and animated conversations. Back side of this as you flip it over.
5:39 Sam's Woodside, as you know, is an escrow. There have been some conversations. Town Council last week specifically about a density exchange. I know staff says they're going to work with the vendor, the potential buyer, and we'll see where that goes. We're thinking that could be a short-term solution for us, but that's to be determined.
5:57 District rangers willing to consider modification to the special use permit at Canyon Lodge. That could be a good short-term solution because the infrastructure is there. They're willing and open to negotiate with us based on project specific. The third bullet, and I find this interesting, page 194 of the 1988 forest plan has this language in it. Speaking with the forest ranger, he's saying there's no way...
6:20 Public lands are used for recreational amenities. And he reminded me they're public lands. I reminded him, yes, they are public lands managed by the Forest Service, but they are public lands.
6:31 The first bullet, allow no federal land exchanges north of State Route 203 with the Mammoth Lakes community during this planning period. We know the forest plan revision is now open. There's a 90-day comment period. I think this is the appropriate time for us to weigh in as a community about how we may potentially use those public lands for recreational amenities. The second bullet, and I find this one to be interesting, allow development on national forest system land.
6:56 When it is clearly demonstrated that the infrastructure of the community can support the demands of proposed development and benefits from the development outweigh the adverse impacts on the community. Our OPAC committee truly believes that the snow pit property is the primary place to build an outdoor performing center. We lease areas to mitigate the great outdoors, the potential for camping opportunities as we look five to ten years out.
7:23 District rangers willing to look at land exchange on some of the other property or acquisitions. Those are long term, those are five to seven years down the road. Talked about the bell-shaped parcel and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation East property was put on the
7:39 Put on the tables a new piece of parcel that we should look at. So we're going to do some field walks in the next week or so. And the CEO of Mammoth Lakes Foundation, Evan Russell, is very much interested in engaging in conversations with us about the potential use of his property to build an outdoor events center. And you look at a simple surcharge of a couple bucks a ticket that could help provide support for maintenance and operation. You know, the committee is saying to ourselves at this point, we'd prefer to spend money on infrastructure and not
8:08 Dirt. If we're going to put $2 or $3 million into a project, you can build something nice versus spending money on dirt and now be cashless for the next couple of years. So looking at projects at this point, SAMS right now is probably our first priority in terms of short-term site, depending on where that goes. Canyon infrastructure.
8:28 If it works in that direction, the foundation, number three, because we're a willing partner, and we're going to continue to push for the snow pit parcel at this point in time. Probably come back to MLR board in July 12th, council on July 20th, and probably look at the foundation doing not just a wind study, but a wind mitigation study. What would it take to mitigate the winds on that parcel at this point in time? And then one other comment as I close.
8:57 I was down visiting with Dr. Andy Walsh at Red Bull two weeks ago tomorrow. You know, he's in charge of the Human Performance Division. And he's saying, Rich, we've been coming to Mammoth for a long time, high altitude training, United States Olympic Center training opportunities as we continue to engage in broader sponsorships outside, off the island, so to speak. And he says, we need a convention center. Red light is lit. You need a convention center, Rich. You give me a convention center with 200 rooms and 12,000 square feet.
9:26 I can have people rolling for you. I want you to know 12 months out of the year. And I've got to sit down and say, Mr. Hodges in the audience, I need to sit down with Rudy at the mountain and have some conversations about what you guys are doing, some of the things you're doing. With that, thank you for the opportunity to give you an update. I'm available for any questions you may have. Thank you very much. I just had a question, but it may be, are we as a commission going to do anything about the update of the forest plan? Or is it...
9:54 I mean, is there a formal process that we would participate in? We just participate in their individual? Yes. Okay. So I just think it's really important that everybody on the commission receives that information so that we know that we stay current on that. There is an ad hoc committee in place, which is an ad hoc committee coming together.
10:13 To talk about what that looks like for our region. At 6 o'clock Monday night in Suite Z, the Forest Service will be here to talk about the process. So I would invite members of this, people in this room right now and members of the community to join us to engage in that process. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. Thank you very much. Are there any other public comments? Seeing that there's no other public comments, we'll move to close the public comments.
10:42 And we'll move to our first item on our agenda, which is the consent agenda item, approval of tract map 15-003. Chair Brown, are you going to recuse yourself for this item? Yes, and then I just wanted to double check and make sure that everything was okay as far as the signature on the resolution. We haven't heard back from the city attorney on it, so we can fix that if needed.
11:11 Since I was recused myself for a business conflict on the original hearing, then I just have to recuse myself on this part of the consent agenda. Commissioner Vanderhurst in charge. Perfect. Hays, are you doing the presentation for? Okay. Is there a motion to approve the consent agenda for item five and item six? I make a motion to approve the consent agenda for item six. Is it also clear?
11:54 Is there a second? Vote, please. All in favor? Yes. Yes. At this time, we'll go back to our original agenda and we now have a public hearing.
12:38 which is consideration of an amendment to an existing use permit for the Mammoth Lakes Wellness Medical Marijuana Cooperative to allow cannabis oil extraction at suite adjacent to the cooperative use permit application UPA 10-003B at 3399 Main Street, suite Q-2. Great, thank you. This item is to consider a request to amend the use permit for Mammoth Lakes Wellness Medical Marijuana Cooperative.
13:09 This use would be accessory to the primary use, which is a medical marijuana dispensary. The request is to allow cannabis oil extraction to occur in the suite adjacent to the current cooperative at 3399 Main Street. This site is physically and legally connected to Mammoth Lakes Wellness.
13:29 Mammoth Lakes Wellness has been in existence since 2010. They previously amended their original use permit in 2013 to allow a medical marijuana nursery. The proposed use is consistent with the town's medical marijuana ordinance since it is legally and physically connected to the existing cooperative.
13:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
14:18 The suite does have sprinklers, but it will require some building separation improvements on the walls. Staff has made the determination that the project meets the findings required to approve the use permit amendment. With that, that concludes my presentation. The applicant, Robert Calvert, is here as well to answer any questions. Hello. Are you going to make a statement?
14:50 Well, I can. Good afternoon to everybody here, staff and commissioners. I just wanted to thank everybody that has worked on this. We've been working on this for about the last six months. I originally met with Chief Al Davis and District Attorney Tim Kendall, and we had put together this package that basically outlined our whole program. So there's been several copies that have been passed around, specifically with the town council members prior to today from Chief Davis.
15:18 And then after meeting with Sandra, and we decided to move forward, and this is the final step in getting this approved. So I think staff really did a fabulous job. Nolan, thank you. Sandra, thank you for your time and efforts in putting together the report. And as you can see, they're recommending that it be approved as we have met all the requirements. And so I'm ready for any questions if you have any. Okay. Commissioner Verruck, do you have any questions? No, I don't. Commissioner Vanderhurst? I don't.
15:47 Commissioner Tang, do you have any questions? My question is really just for the staff. This particular location, Zone 4, this location, Zone 4, what do you call this? Commercial. Commercial Zone District. Now, this particular process is a, I guess, technically is considered a manufacturing process? This extraction process? Initially, it would be refining, and could it be characterized as manufacturing?
16:20 Possibly, yeah. So if that's the case, can a commercial zone, a retail commercial business commercial zone, be allowed to have manufacturing production? It's more like research. I included pictures of the equipment that we're going to be using. We're not going to be doing like...
16:50 We're not going to have 200 employees with sewing machines in there and rolling in rolls of fabric and manufacturing. I mean, I'm using that because that's what I grew up is in a clothing manufacturing environment. But it's more like a laboratory, per se. And I have pictures. Actually, I included pictures in the application. I saw a couple of photos. It's a very clean environment. Sure. So we're not talking. We'd probably be one or two people in there at a time. So manufacturing, I think.
17:18 When I think manufacturing, I think large manufacturing. And I hesitate to use that particular term, but I can't think of anything else when you do any type of extraction. I sort of think of that as more of an industrial. We consider it to be part of a medical marijuana cooperative, which is a use that's permitted by a use permit in this zone. So it does fall under the category of medical marijuana cooperative, this extraction that Mr. Calvert's describing.
17:48 Okay. Thank you. Do you have any additional questions? No. Okay. Well, then, at this time, we'll move to the public. Is there anybody in the public that would like to comment on this application? Okay. Then we'll close the public comment period. Deliberations. Commissioner Verruck, do you have any questions, comments? No, I do not. Okay. Commissioner Vanderhurst? I have a really quick question for staff.
18:23 There wasn't any letters of opposition in our packet. Have you received any subsequently? No, I got one phone call. They were more questioning about the nursery part. They thought that it was going to be an outside growing operation, and I indicated that the existing nursery is all indoors within the other suite on the other side of the cooperative, and that this use permit for the extraction is all, again, indoors.
18:51 Basically contained in lab equipment so there wouldn't be any uses outside or behind the building. Thank you. Any comments, deliberation? No, I don't think so. I think for the most part it seems like it's a pretty simple process and a safe process. Initially I was concerned about safety given that you do have using
19:24 Additional chemicals too. Anybody comment on that? Certainly. Yeah. So there's a couple different types of extraction that are going on, and this is specifically the CO2 extraction. The other type of extraction uses butane, which is very volatile. So that at this point is illegal, and we are not using that. Right. Being that we've addressed this with all the local authorities. Correct. Yes.
19:51 Especially the DA is very, very aware of it and the chief and staff. So being that it's a CO2 system and what we're using, very safe and you don't have the condition of volatility that's used with butane. Thank you. Okay. I'll just make the quick comment that Mr. Calvert has proven to be a very responsible business owner up to this point as well. So I think that needs to be taken into account. I agree. All right. Can I call for the motion? I make a motion really quick.
20:26 I make a motion that we adopt the attached planning and economic development commission resolution making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings and approve the use permit amendment 10-003B. Do I have a second? I second. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vandehus? Yes. Commissioner Verruck? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. The motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much and thank you for working on that.
20:59 Okay. Thank you. We'll now move to our first business matter. Our first business matter today is the scoping meeting for the town multi-use facility, and our staff contact person is Sandra on this. Thank you. So, as you stated, this is a scoping meeting for the new community multi-use facility project.
21:25 Which is located at Mammoth Creek Park West. The purpose of today's meeting is to take comments from the public on the scope of the EIR. So if there's comments from people that they want us to focus on certain items in the EIR, this is the time to give those comments. However, the comment period is open through the end of the month, through July 1st. So we take comments written through email, and comments can be provided now.
21:55 So the project location, as I stated, is Mammoth Creek Park West. It's 4.9 acres, and it's on the west side of Old Mammoth Road, south of Chateau. The project includes a number of different concepts. First is a community center with year-round programming, 13,000 square feet.
22:17 Would include two large rooms, some kitchen with concession space, office space, meeting rooms, multipurpose rooms, as well as locker rooms, restrooms, and a mechanical room. There is also the ice rink, which is for winter programming. The ice surface is 100 feet by 200 feet, and that will include skate rental, restrooms, a viewing area, bleachers, lockers, garage, and a mechanical and storage room.
22:46 And then there's the Mammoth Rec Zone, which is the summer programming for the facility. And it's really the hub for our parks and rec summer camp programs. Would include court sports and a climbing wall. And then there's the existing park playground out there that will remain. We will be providing enhancements with inclusive components. And then the existing bathrooms will be updated so that they can be used year-round, because right now they're closed during the winter.
23:15 As well as an active outdoor recreation area to the west of the community multi-use facility. That would be used for some sort of an active recreation. We're not sure yet, but that could be a dog park, a BMX track, sledding hill, and or a community garden.
23:31 And then finally, we have the parking at the site. So we have existing parking of 44 spaces. We will be adding 107 new parking spaces on the north side of the project. So those will extend westward on the project site. So this is the preliminary site plan. I apologize that it's...
23:49 It's rather small, but it shows the parking to the north of the facility, the ice rink, which is in kind of the light gray, the multi-use community center, which is in the darker gray, some active outdoor recreation areas in the orange, and then the playground in the green there. So the purpose of CEQA, just to kind of walk through, is to disclose information about potentially significant environmental impacts of a project.
24:18 To identify ways to avoid or mitigate those impacts, to enhance public participation in this planning process, and to foster interagency coordination in the review of these projects. So as I said earlier, the purpose of today's meeting is to inform the public of the proposed project and that the town intends to prepare an EIR for this project and to present an overview of the environmental review process.
24:45 And review topics that we will be studying in the EIR and take public comments or concerns regarding the topics that we're going to be studying. So the overview of the CEQA process, we're at the beginning right now. The initial study, notice of preparation, this really kind of kicks off the CEQA process. We have a 30-day public review period. It started on June 2, 2016 and ends on July 1, which is a Friday.
25:11 at 5 p.m. And then once we receive the comments on the scoping, we will prepare and then publish the draft EIR. Once the draft EIR is published, there is a 45-day public review period, so the public has an opportunity to review the EIR and provide us comments on the EIR.
25:30 Once the 45-day public review period is completed and we've received the comments, we will respond to those comments. And then the final step is to present the final EIR to the Planning and Economic Development Commission. The PEDC is actually the final decision-making body on this project, so you will be certifying the EIR.
25:49 So topics requiring further environmental analysis. Because we are preparing an EIR, we didn't actually scope any items out. So we will be looking at all required items under CEQA as a part of this EIR. So the items are listed here, but we welcome any input from the public on items that they think we need to do further analysis on. But this is the comprehensive list that is required by CEQA.
26:18 So we're right at the left-hand side of this flowchart, initial study of notice of preparation. Next step, like I said, is the draft EIR and that there's an opportunity for public review. We will respond to their comments and then we will publish the final EIR, which would be considered by the commission and there is an opportunity for public comments at that time as well. So written comments on this notice of preparation are due by July 1st.
26:46 This year at 5 p.m., so that's a Friday, and they can submit the comments to me. My email address is there, or they can mail the comments in. And that concludes this presentation. I'm available for any questions you have. Also, we have our consultants here from Michael Baker International, who will be preparing the EIR, and then Grady and Hayes also to provide any comments or questions. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, did you have any questions at this time?
27:16 I do have a couple of questions, but I would like to hear some public comment first before we... Commissioner, Bruce, do you have any questions? No, I don't. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Not at this time. All right. I'm going to open this up for public comments. I would just like to preface this that, you know, in our role as planning commissioners, and certainly when it comes to CEQA, we have a very narrow focus today. This is just really a scoping meeting about CEQA. It is not really...
27:48 Ultimately, if the center is going to be built, not built, it's not even if everything that's currently shown on the footprint is going to be built. But, you know, what we have to do is say, okay, what's the maximum footprint that someday the center can have and then do our sequel on this. So I just wanted to make that little comment. I mean, I know there's...
28:09 Many facets to this project, and we certainly can talk about all sorts of different aspects of it, but this is just really as it relates to CEQA today. So at this time, if anybody in the audience would like to come make any comments, please come forward. Rich Bacia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. We are excited this day has come.
28:34 We're excited about moving this project forward. Staff's done a great job of prepping this. Stu and Rec Commission on the program and in the playbook. We look forward. We've communicated to the public to get this project up and running. Ribbon cut on an ice skating in October of 2017. So let's roll on, people. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other comments? I notice we have a couple of members from the Recreation Department. Do you have any comments?
29:12 Wow, a call out. I know. The first. No. This isn't the only opportunity to provide comments on the scoping, so people, like I said, can provide them in writing, in email, so this isn't the last opportunity to provide comments. Okay. If I could, because, you know, you...
29:38 Close it that way. On behalf of the Rec Department and the Rec Commission, I just might say that we continue to welcome public comment. We've had more than 15 publicly noticed and advertised meetings on this project already. We've got a lot of input and we welcome more, the more the merrier, because we want to hear what everybody has to say. And that's my only add to that. All right. Then I'll close the public comment.
30:04 For today, for this hearing, and the only suggestion I would make, Sandra, that if people are going to write to you, you might just put your mail in the address. We know how the post office wouldn't know where the town of Mammoth Lakes is. All right. Questions, comments? I'll just make a quick comment that I'll echo Rich's sentiments that...
30:34 Exciting as a community member that this project is moving forward and that we're being responsible patrons of that land and this community. So thank you for that. Commissioner Chang, did you have any questions or comments? I'm excited about the multi-use facilities and when I look at this and perhaps I don't know if this is the right platform to talk about this but since you just mentioned that this is kind of a narrow
31:08 perspective for our purpose, from what we can do, but the current layout, is that the maximum lot coverage for the building itself? Well, Sandra's going back to that exhibit, the idea was to
31:33 We plan this project for the maximum square footage, the maximum uses. We don't know specifically at what phase one is going to be. It's going to be phased. We're actually going to work on that in the next 45 days or so and give that information back to the environmental consultant. The only comment I might have on this exhibit is that in the write-up, it talks about a 13,000 square foot community center, community facilities. We actually, and I apologize for not.
31:59 Catching this, but if you see the notch in the upper left-hand corner of the exhibit where the one brown oval is, that 13,000 square feet actually fills in that notch. And that was, we had an exhibit that came after, right just before the council hearing last time. So the exhibit could be changed slightly and we'll make sure we get that information to everybody. And it's not significant, but the idea is maximum square footage, maximum use. I made the comment too at the MLR meeting the other night that we are...
32:28 Talking about the possibility of a BMX, like a practice type track, like you could see down in the corner a few blocks away, not something where you'd have races every weekend, but something for kids and younger people to learn things. That's probably the noisiest thing we could think of to put there, because again, we want to show the maximum we might do in the next 20 years. I'm not sure we'll do that, again, as we've said, but we want to show the maximum square footage, maximum use, maximum occupancy.
32:56 So this site plan that we're looking at is not the most updated one, right? There's an updated version. Just very slightly. The text is correct in saying 13,000 square feet, but in the upper left-hand corner, instead of a notch, it'll be squared off at some point in the future. And I'm assuming this is single story. That's correct. Is there a possibility of having a second story?
33:21 We are not planning for that at this time. The ice rink roof or the multi-rec zone roof would be about 35 feet high at its peak, which is within current zoning. And the rest of it we think we can create the spaces we need to respond to the programming needs of the rec department without doing a second story. The reason I ask is because based on the description of all the activities that you have incorporated,
33:50 It seems like there's a lot of activity you're trying to squeeze in this particular area. And it seems like we, is then a higher facility or maybe larger coverage would facilitate that? We actually started out with the likelihood of a 5,000 to 10,000 square foot community facility adjacent to that. And in doing the programming, we found that
34:22 We should probably increase it to 13,000 square feet of usable active space. That 13,000 does not include the building where the chiller is going to be as an example or the Olympia, the ice grooming machine and some of the storage. So overall square footage will be larger than that. So we really believe that we've...
34:41 We captured everything we can in the programming for the next 20 years. We wanted to be reasonable and push it out. We do not believe we can build the full 13,000 square feet as a phase one. We'd love to do that, so we'll be phasing it, but we really do believe we've captured it. Could it be even larger? I mean, you know, we could do even more lot coverage, but again, we want to be reasonable and responsible to the site and to the neighborhood. Now, ultimately, you're going to have at least one to two phases?
35:09 of construction. Is that why I saw the construction period looks like it's at least five years? That's correct. In fact, when the consultant asked for a phasing plan, there's really a lot of things that depend on that. The programming is one thing, but also the funding and when that money becomes available. We're trying to come up with something that we believe is reasonable without overstating it. So our best estimate at this time is that
35:35 At least 5,000, maybe a little bit more square footage in a phase one, plus of course the multi-use facility or the multi-use thing and the ice rink as a phase one and the other we put within five years. We don't anticipate it happening sooner than that. It may be later. But again, there's a lot of things dependent on that. But as a community, we can use the facility within the five-year period. It's not like we...
36:03 Absolutely. In fact, the most recent discussions we've had is that our goal, if you will, is to open the, well, not the goal, the statement, the commitment is to open the ice rink and have a ribbon cutting, as Rich pointed out on Halloween of next year, of 2017. That would not necessarily include the community facility because it's just not time to design and build a project like that. It may very likely be under construction. We'd love to see that.
36:30 You know, and again, a configuration of maybe 5,000 square feet plus some restrooms and things, but not all the funding's been identified yet, so that's what we're going to work on the next 60 days or so as they're beginning the environmental process phasing. Thank you. Any other questions? Sorry, this one. Okay. Any other questions? Nothing. Did you have one?
36:51 Comment you'd like to make? Comment to FMA? Yes, sir. This is on parallel tracks. Get the EIR going, give me some design, give me some funds, generate what it's going to cost for this project. Our main responsibility is to go find funds to support this project. And number two, doesn't Park West sound much better than Muff? Until you come up with names for this, let's call this Park West, and I look at my EIR friends here. Park West versus, I mean, it's got a romance to it, versus
37:21 Multi-use facility. Thank you. It will now become PW. All right. Well, there's no other comments at this time. I would just like to thank the consultants and thank Sandra. You were very proactive in saying we wouldn't even do an initial study, that we were just going to move this forward to the EIR to give everybody a fair opportunity to make their comments.
37:49 So I think you've done a great job of setting a stage up so that everybody has the opportunity to comment on this. And do you need anything else from us at this point? No. Thank you. All right. Thank you very much. So this item is closed. There's no motion on this.
38:07 Our second item was the East Village parking lot. That has been pulled. So we're going to move to our fourth, or was our second business item, our third item agenda. So we're going to move to our fourth agenda item, which is to consider approval of design review 16-005 for the town hillside parking lot. And our staff contact person is Hayes on this. Thank you.
38:33 The proposed project, the town hillside parking lot, is requesting design review approval. At the direction of the town council, the town of Mammoth Lakes Department of Public Works proposes to construct a new parking lot at 99 Canyon Boulevard. The site is vacant with the exception of Gondola Tower 3, which exists in the southeast portion of the property. The proposed project will provide 38 parking spaces that will be available year-round. Pursuant to the North Village Pacific Plan design guidelines, the area will be paved.
39:03 The impervious surface will account for approximately .3 acres of the 1.1 acre site. Travel lane widths, turning radius, and town parking stall dimensions will comply with all standards for the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. No restrictions to parking duration have been determined at this time other than those required to facilitate snow removal operations. Unpaved areas of the lot will be used for snow storage and stormwater retention.
39:31 And create an open space buffer from the adjacent uses. The project will provide street and parking lot safety lighting. Street light fixtures will be to town standards and will be consistent with those found in the North Village area. Additionally, the project will improve pedestrian connectivity in the area with sidewalk connections. The project also proposes construction of a bus turnout.
39:54 That will provide year-round access to transit services. The bus turnout will be connected to the parking lot and Canyon Boulevard by a sidewalk. Transit shelter is also being designed for the project and will be constructed if funding is available. In addition to the evaluation of the design, staff prepared an addendum to the original mitigated negative declaration and found no new significant impacts or a substantial increase in impacts would result from the proposed project.
40:21 Staff has made the determination that the project meets the required finding to adopt an addendum to the mitigated NGDEC and design review permit and is recommending approval of the project. This concludes my presentation. The applicant is here and available to answer any questions. I was looking out at the audience looking for the applicant. All right. Commissioner Chang, did you have any questions?
40:55 For clarification, when I was looking at Exhibit E on the development agreement, I mentioned Canyon Boulevard site. This is not the same. It is the same. Because when I looked at the map, it looked slightly different. No, it's the same site. It is the same site. Yes. And the existing lot, it's pretty much the same as what's showing on the Exhibit E.
41:29 As well, right? Yeah. For the initial, I mean, excuse me, let me, the conceptual site layout that was done by the, I think it's RBF consulting firm, previously? Yeah, the previous, the conceptual designs that were done back in approximately 2007. 2007, 2005. Yeah, the current design is consistent with one of those concepts. Okay. So they do look similar. Except their access,
42:04 Is on Canyon and yours is on? Yeah, our access is off of Hillside. Okay, so the, yeah, the access is proposed is off of Hillside Boulevard, not Canyon Boulevard. So I was looking at this previously. We didn't move forward. This was because of the cost. I guess it was prohibited, and it looks like it was going to range around $50.
42:40 $657,000 per space. What's the cost on this one? We have initial estimates in the neighborhood of $600,000. Total? Total. And that includes the sidewalk and the other infrastructure for drainage and lighting and retaining walls and so forth. Signage. And this is for 38 space, right? Correct. I see. And there is no possible way to extend?
43:12 To expand this any further, right? Yes, but we can, but the price goes up per space. So this is the most efficient design for the money. I'm really glad to see this. I know we need more. Previously, has anyone even looked at using this particular site to build a mechanical parking tower versus a traditional parking tower?
43:42 No. It has been looked at other sites in the North Village area, but not this one specifically. For mechanical parking. For mechanical. I see. And I guess that wasn't feasible either? It's just cost prohibitive for the amount of money we have to make something happen at this time. And this is a temporary site, so how long were you looking to... This is a town council question.
44:13 Little column A, little column B. It's temporary until a parking solution is determined for the North Village specific, for the planning area. So if something else was to come up in a different location that met the demand, then this one would no longer be needed. And just for the record, for the commissioners as well, it was very insightful to look at this particular study.
44:45 Public Works and staff have done. And also, I know there is an agenda item for East Parking Village, East Village Parking that just got pulled. I think as commissioners, we need to really focus sooner than later because I think this also relates to the North Village specific plan. And given that the recent meeting,
45:18 that the town manager had with the town council's density related issue. I would like to suggest that we really look at this specific plan a little more closely if that's a possibility. And I do have one last question. If I could, I would like to mention that a town council meeting
45:50 Two meetings ago. The council had asked us to look at parking solutions around the area that the town does control. So in addition to this lot, we also looked at seven parking spaces across Hillside Drive to the west from this lot. We found them to be cost-perdivative. There were about seven spaces there. You'd have to build a retaining wall. It came in at about $25,000 apiece. We said we do not recommend that.
46:15 If you recall, the four time parking spaces right in front of the village on Canyon Boulevard, we have a plan to add nine or ten spaces in that location to take it to a total of 13 or 14. Council had a couple of questions. We'll be responding back to them. It's not before the commission today, but just so you can see, we are looking at it as best we can. We do expect those to go forward. In addition, probably the biggest change in that area is that
46:40 There's approximately $675,000 in CFD, Community Facilities District, funds that need to be spent by October 1st of this year, or at least obligated, and we actually have already come up with a preliminary design for that and expect to advertise that sometime this summer and get it under construction in August or September, which would...
47:00 Go from about where Burgers is to the north. It would close the driveway into the existing East Village parking lots. They would then access off of Berner Street. Add a few parallel spaces along Minaret in keeping with the North Village Pacific Plan, which talks about parallel spaces and it talks about short-term parking. It would not be long-term. And also has a bus pull-out and a bus shelter.
47:23 Where if you're here in the winter, everybody who drives by can see there's a lot of people standing there around the rocks right there near the crosswalk. So we're looking at that as well, but also included right turn lane. So we looked at everything that the town controlled. We were able to do this lot. We were able to do the CFD improvements, add a few other spaces. But I agree, there's the long-term stuff as well. If we have enough funds available from the CFD, we'd actually...
47:47 Go ahead and go around the corner on Forest Trail as well and add some parking spaces. I'm just not, we're not sure yet how far 675,000 is going to go. So, again, that was a council item a couple of meetings ago. It's in that agenda packet if you want a little bit more detail. I'm sorry, go ahead. No, I just had a question. But on this short-term parking on Hillside, no CFD funds are going to that, correct?
48:12 That's correct. None for this parking lot. If we are able to do the bus turnout and the bus shelter on Hillside, that may involve CFD funds. But that would be a permanent structure because it would serve the west, correct?
48:32 That's correct. We've already talked to ESTA. They can change their route. Right now, they come down Lakeview, but they have no problem just coming down hillside instead and having that. One quick comment on that, since you mentioned it, one of the concerns from Council was to make sure there was good pedestrian access from this lot and from a potential bus shelter back down to the village in various directions. One of the ideas that we've actually looked at is taking a walkway, whether it's an asphalt walkway or a sidewalk, out the back of this lot to the southeast and connect over to the
49:02 The stairs of the stairs in that location. So we'll continue to look at that. Again, it's not essential for today's action because it's not parking, but we will be talking to the Weston about the possibility of that and doing a cost estimate for it. The Weston stairs. Yes, correct. I didn't want to have to say stairs of death, but everybody else knows about that, so I'll go ahead. We understand. And they're under repair right now, but we will be talking to them on that because that's a concept, again, just...
49:27 Enhance your pedestrian connectivity. Now the CFD fund, when you say you need to spend that money, are you saying literally spending that money or reserve for it? We are confident that it at least needs to be under construction before October 1st. Whether every piece of concrete needs to be in the ground or not, we're researching that, but we can do it either way. Just one last question. The existing community center. Yes.
49:58 I see the publics are using that as well sometimes. Yes, they do. And can that space be expanded temporarily for people to park there? The reason I say that is because I noticed the East Village parking currently has been closed. And do we know why it's closed? I mean, I know it's a private land, but...
50:24 On the community center, I can say that we're looking at that lot to see if we can add some spaces. We think we can get maybe three in there, possibility of four. That's about it. Because if you look to the west, that's actually not community center. That's the Forest Service land, that forested area. So we don't really have much room to the west. It looks like it is, but that's not our property.
50:44 So we're going to try to squeeze in as much there. In terms of the East Village and the pulling of this application and the closure, that's a discussion between the property owner and everybody else and not something we can really address. Thank you. Grady, in a perfect world, if you guys can maximize the funding and the weather holds and construction season is really, really good.
51:13 The highway up to Main Lodge and up Forest Trail, how many parking slots are we kind of talking about? I'll comment on the 38, adding 9 at the time spaces on Canyon Boulevard, 3 at the Community Center, and I'm not sure if we calculate the number of spaces, somewhere between 10 to 12 spaces along Minaret. Again, those would be short-term spaces, but that would be from Burgers to the north. Got it. Thank you.
51:40 We actually looked at the possibility of diagonal spaces there. Caltrans was clear to point out that we could do diagonal spaces only if they were back in. We thought that it's not going to work on minaret at that location, so we declined and went back to a parallel. There are some places it works great.
52:00 I'm not there. A social comment, I have never stopped in Bridgeport since they put back in spaces because I'm always afraid that I'm going to get hit trying to back. All right, Commissioner Farouk. Well, I just had a couple questions or comments. I guess, you know, I know that parking is so, it's so important to have, especially at the village, but I feel like the 38 spaces is not a lot to accommodate.
52:27 Which is just a comment, but then after, if this is just a temporary parking lot, surface parking lot, what would the use be if in fact later on down the line there is a permanent structure or lot or the built, you know, the east parking? There's a lot of variables to that question. The DA allows the lot to be used for public purposes and it specifies
52:54 Parking as one of those uses, but it could be used for, you know, any public purpose afterwards. We don't know what the future holds for parking in the village, and until the long-term solution is found, whether it be on this parcel or another, it's temporary in nature. Okay. I've got kind of a weird question, and I don't know if it's maybe for you guys on staff or maybe for one of our only audience members out there. Has anybody thought or talked...
53:22 Have you talked about maybe using the parking lot of a canyon and animating, turning on the gondola to bring people back down to the village in the summer? That's really not within our scope of our, because we're technically talking about design. We'll have to do a workshop on that. We should really do a workshop on parking, just to have a time to talk about it. But we're really kind of like pushing a little bit, okay? Good idea. To be discussed later.
53:54 Because we're being asked just to approve the design, you're not really talking about parking, so I don't want to get too far, way too far off the agenda. All right. Okay, but thank you. All right, so do we have any member in the audience that'd like to comment? Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. So again, focused on the narrow scope of your discussion, Grady, you mentioned about having, potentially using CFD funds for a bus stop.
54:32 Adjacent to the parking on the hillside, the proposed temporary lot, for possibly having a bus shelter or bus stop there. And I just, I'm a little confused because I don't really see the viability of that bus turnout anymore than just coming, because they're going to make a right-hand turn down canyon and then go to the bus stop that's in front of the, down in front of the village, right? And I know on that downhill side of canyon,
55:01 On the bus stops, there's no bus shelter on that side, whereas we do have one on the uphill side next to the gondola building. It just seems to me like there's limited utility to having another bus stop up by the west, and when everybody's coming down the stairs to the village anyway, why don't we just put the money, again, this would be the CFD funding, to build a bus shelter on the downhill side of Canyon at the existing bus stop at the main area of the village.
55:29 If I may, we're very careful looking at the boundaries of the CFD, and while it can be used on the east side of Hillside Drive in that location, and there's already a stop on Lakeview over there without a shelter, we'd like to provide one here. I don't think it can be used on the west side of Canyon Boulevard at the bottom of the stairs. Well, I think the west is all that property is included in the boundary of the CFD. We'd be glad to look at it again, but there's our understanding that it can't.
55:57 In addition to that, we were actually in design for a bus shelter at that location on Canyon Boulevard using a grant funding source. So with any luck, we'll actually have a bus mansion there by this fall. Well, I guess, so then I would just advocate this a little off topic because you guys were considering the design review of the parking lot, but then with respect to the funds for the CFD, speaking on behalf of the mountain, we would rather see that money go towards further improvements on the East Village side.
56:27 Much rather see you add additional parallel parking along Forest Trail, for example, than build that bus shelter because it just seems like it has limited utility. And we are looking at a variety of funding options for that. Our first goal is to try to make the best use we can of the funds that are available. Forest Trail is probably a better option. The other item that somebody, again, this is off topic of the...
56:51 But I did want to respond to the bigger picture. Another thing that we're looking at is the possibility of doing an actual pedestrian crossing. What do you call it? A hawk. A hawk. At the existing crosswalk in front of the village on the east side so that it's pedestrian activated.
57:10 A certain amount of time they can't just keep pushing the button and be nothing but pedestrians. But we're looking at that as well. If that fits within the schedule and the cost, we think that'll make a big difference in the circulation in that area. So we have a lot of pieces moving, and we'll be able to come back in three or four weeks. I think we would support that too, because that's probably the biggest problem area with downhill traffic. Absolutely agree. And we usually, on our cost, we'll post a crossing guard down there to control the pedestrian crossing. Otherwise, you've got a pedestrian crossing every three seconds.
57:39 Traffic will just back up the mountain to the main lodge. And for the commission, the point is that, yes, we are looking at all the solutions, not just this lot. We think if we can implement the closure of the driveway into the East Village parking lots, a right-turn pocket, and a hawk, that could change things dramatically in that area. I mean, it could make a big difference, both coming down the mountain, from the mountain, going up, turns onto and off of a forest trail, all those things could be improved. So we're trying to get everything we can. Thanks.
58:08 Okay, thank you. Any other comments? Nope. Call for the motion, please. Let me get to that page. Pardon me here. I'd like to make a motion that we adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA findings and the municipal code findings and approved design review 16-005. I second that. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes.
58:47 Commissioner Veruck? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Congratulations to the town of Mammoth Lakes. And then, assuming that you'll probably be leaving, maybe in July, I don't know how big our July agenda is, Sandra, but maybe we could just do a general conversation about parking and all these things that are going on.
59:12 So if nothing else, it really just helps us when people ask what's going on in the community that we can just answer it. So then we can talk about some of those bigger things. Okay. So on the consent agenda, did we approve the minutes or do those minutes need to be approved? They need to be approved. Okay. So I need a motion to approve the minutes. I make a motion to approve the minutes of the May 11, 2016 meeting. I'll second. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes.
59:48 Commissioner Veruck? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Now we'll move on to Commissioner Reports. So the first one is the Design Committee. Commissioner Gregg and I met with town staff and the applicant and architect were on the phone for the Old Mammoth Place project. And just I wasn't involved initially in the first phase when they were
1:00:18 They were initially discussing things like height and the concerns that the commission brought forward. So we just discussed those items and they did address everything that was of concern in the past. And I guess that's something we'll be discussing next week at our special meeting. And that was really it. Commissioner Vanderhurst.
1:00:44 Yeah, Mammoth Lakes Tourism is hosting a riders' conference as we speak. It opens today, and we'll be going through Saturday. Society of American Travel Riders, probably expecting, I believe it's the Midwest chapter, probably expecting anywhere between 35 to 45 riders coming into destination. We're doing that in conjunction with hosting it with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.
1:01:11 And lodging partners here in town, Mono County as well. The idea is these people take our story back to their outlets, their publications, their blogs, and tell our story in their own words. So it should help increase visitation going forward, and we're pretty excited about it. Oh, great. Yeah. I have a request when you do your future reports.
1:01:35 Can you perhaps talk a little bit about employments? You know, we get a pretty plain vanilla report on employments, which are, they look, the employments look a little inconsistent unless you factor into, John was telling me, unless you factor into how they've changed the routes and the number of seats. Right. So maybe when, you know, you're giving us your updates on tourism, you can just kind of explain to us a little bit about, not today obviously, but employments and about how it really compares.
1:02:04 To the number of seats we have. Are you looking for year over year? Are you looking for... Whatever is easiest for you. I mean, because you get the reports from the town, right? I do, yeah. Okay. So... Okay. I'd be appreciative. Okay. Did you say employment? Employments. Employments. Okay. Got it. Do you have anything you'd like to report on, Commissioner Tim? I don't have anything specific for reporting purpose. I would like to make a comment about...
1:02:41 A specific agenda item that Town Council was hearing on the 1st. Last week, last Wednesday. Right. Yeah. I was a bit perplexed at the agenda number 9 that the town manager had presented a specific case about having a private public hearing, I mean a partnership, excuse me, and giving, and I want to make sure I summarize this correctly.
1:03:19 To have some sort of a density bonus or a density, exclusive density rights. And I don't believe that we were, and then again, you know, I sent an email to Mickey and Sandra saying, you know, at the risk of sounding arrogant on this, is there a reason why the commissioners wasn't approached, you know, for input? Because I thought that was quite
1:03:55 No, and I think it's noted, I mean, as you know, I wrote a
1:04:33 Substantial letter, and I attended that meeting, and it's probably, I mean, I don't know if that's something you will report on during your director's report, so we'll let Sandra then report on it, what happened at that meeting on the director's report, but your comments are noted, so. And then I have no commissioner's report today, so we'll move on to the director's report.
1:04:58 Thank you. So just following on the item that Commissioner Chang brought up, the council considered the Sam's Wood site on June 1st and basically looked at different options for allowing that site to be retained as an events venue.
1:05:19 In the end, the council provided staff with direction to come forward with an amendment to the North Village specific plan to allow transfers of density from the specialty lodging zone to the remainder of the specific plan, which is not permitted right now.
1:05:33 So that's a relatively minor amendment to the North Village Pacific Plan that would come before commission for consideration. You would make a recommendation to council. The other item that the council requested staff to look into is to consider transfers of density from the specialty lodging zone in the North Village, the location of Sam's Wood Site, outside of the North Village Pacific Plan to the remainder of town, possibly to other master plan areas or specific plan areas.
1:06:01 So that's something that I think needs a little bit more work, and we would likely will go back to the council just with some more information on what it would take to do that to make sure that the council is aware of the effort it would take to prepare that. So just as an informational item, but staff will begin working on that shortly. And have we had any indication from the applicant that he wants to move forward on this?
1:06:27 I believe the town manager is meeting with the applicant later this week. Okay. So I think next week we'll know more. All right. And then what would be the process as far as the applicant being able to build the venue that he wants to build on that property? So the process would be a use permit. The North Village specific plan has a number of different...
1:06:50 Use is described in there. His use is a little bit different than, it doesn't fit exactly into the uses that are described in the North Village specific plan, so likely what we would do is once the applicant made an application, came in and formally submitted something, we'd likely come to the commission with a check-in meeting just to let the commission know that we think it meets, you know, falls into this use description.
1:07:15 Does the commission agree? And just to make sure that we're all on the same page about what we're going to call the use, because it's a little bit different than an events venue, and it's a little bit different than, I think, a public or private recreation facility. But I think that would be kind of our first step, but that would go kind of in the process for a use permit. Both of those uses require a use permit, so we would likely process that, which would be considered by the commission. Are there any other questions on that process? No, this time.
1:07:46 Anybody else have any questions? Okay, so just a couple other quick items. There are three commission seats up. So Commissioner Greyhack, Commissioner Chang, Commissioner Verruck. So we would encourage, I think Jamie Gray sent out an email to the three of you with information and application information on how to reapply. So we would encourage applications from the three of you. And likely, I think she put the dates of the interviews.
1:08:15 Mid-July with the seating being at the Planning Commission, Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting in August. So just so you're aware. Also exciting news, we hired an assistant planner. Her name is Kim Cook, and she starts on Monday. So we're really, really happy. She's local. She lives in Swalmeadows. And I think she's going to be a really great addition to our team. So we'll bring her and introduce her to you at the July meeting. Congratulations. Yeah, thanks.
1:08:43 Thank you. Thank you. We're very happy. And another item is the floor-air ratio mobility element EIR. It should be published in the next two weeks. So we will be providing the Commission with information on that. If any of you would like a hard copy of the document, we can provide that to you. We typically provide CDs or a link to the website. But please let me know if anyone would like a hard copy. It's probably 300 or 400 pages.
1:09:12 Seeing no one. Well, let me start with a link and then see how I go. Let us know if you do want a hard copy. And then finally, just a... Can we go back to the timing on that? Yes. Okay. So the item, so the EIR... The final revision. This is the draft EIR. No, no, the final revision of our timeline.
1:09:31 It is the final revision of our timeline. Okay. And then once the draft EIR is published, it will be a 45-day review period. Okay. So we're expecting a planning either the September or October Planning Commission meeting to consider the changes to the general plan and the zoning code for this project. So it's really exciting. It's been a long process. Yes. And then finally, just a reminder that next week we have a special Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for the Old Mammoth Place project.
1:10:00 1230 next Wednesday. I sent an email out to the group about a meeting with staff prior. Please let us know if you would like to meet with us, and what we'll likely do is try to have two commissioners at a time to prep for that meeting next week. And that's all I have. Okay, so while we're talking about being paper-friendly, so I still have all the schematics from when they were...
1:10:27 Before us, last time on Old Mammoth Place. Concept review application last year. So do we, I mean, are those still all valid? I mean, we're not going to print all this out again, right? We are going to print the new plans out for you. Yes. So those old, so those have changed. So we will be printing the new sets of plans for the meeting for next week. Okay. I don't, I can't find the email that you send out. Because I didn't send it to you because you're conflicted out of the item. Are you still conflicted?
1:10:56 The Old Mammoth Place Project. Oh, yeah. Sorry. Apology. Okay. Sorry. How much longer are you conflicted? Until November. Okay. Unless something happens. All right. Anything else? Nothing. Okay. So, I move to adjournment to a special meeting to be held on June 15, 2016 at 1230 in the Council Chambers. Maybe you can give us a little reminder about 1230.