TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2017

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

· recording 2 hr 12 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

294 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Okay. You want to call Will for us, please? No problem. Take your time. We have new software?

0:29 Well, this is from the Board of Supervisors meeting, and I left it on. So while you guys are closed session, I'll probably try to see what I can do. I can't find the remotes either. Let's see. All right. So Shields Richardson. Here. Tom Johnson. Here. Gary Morgan. Yeah. David Page. Here. Drea Perry. Terry Stellick. Yes.

1:02 Brent Truax, Rachel Ashley, here, Heather Schwabmeyer, here. All right. Okay, thank you. So we're about to go into a closed session. We have about an hour on the agenda if we need it. I'll take any public comment right now going into the closed session for anything that's not on that agenda. Yeah, go on up and introduce yourself. Visitor for 25, 30 years.

1:40 resident for six months. I'd like to request that this and other boards in conjunction with the Mammoth Lakes Recreation on MLB board, excuse me, MLR board, have this communication out in a responsive versus an adaptive form in email, being the average citizen in the United States, I assume that's for Mammoth also, it's about 72%, to read

2:10 The agenda on a responsive basis versus an adaptive basis via email. Any clarification? I do. What does that mean? What's the difference? Well, as you know, when you click onto a link, adaptive is you've got to have your fingers spread to read, left to write. Oh, so mobile friendly. Versus responsive, which has been out for five years now, adaptive to user friendliness on a mobile site.

2:41 Many sites pop up and they say, for mobile version, click here. It's not expensive. It's just converting to responsive versus adaptive in this town. You want communicative communications to be more facilitated and user-friendliness? I'm asking for that. Our website is responsive. Our emails are responsive. We send the agenda as a PDF attachment. Correct.

3:09 So you're saying, and it's 76 pages. Correct. So you're saying you'd like an infinite scroll of 76 pages in a responsive, in one email. It's not 76 pages to be responsive. I think she's familiar with responsive, as I allude to the word, responsive versus adaptive. Yeah, it's, you know, he means, yeah, that's what he's saying is adaptive. You know what I'm saying?

3:38 User-friendly is you don't have to scroll left to right on your phone, which 72% of the United States reads emails today on their phones. For the Mammoth community, that it be responsive versus adaptive. I just want to go on record. The emails are responsive. What's that? The emails are responsive. The agendas are not. The agendas are not. It's the attachment. The agendas are not. But, I mean, I think it depends on your reader, right? Like your viewer that we're looking in right now,

4:08 Do you want to show him what this looks like? No, when I see it on my phone, it's adaptive. It's not responsive. I have to spread it and read it left to right. Yeah, well, I appreciate the comment. We'll look into it for sure. Thank you. It's not being critical. It's just being readable. Any way that we can communicate better is well advised. Thank you. Okay, so we're going to go into closed session now.

4:36 And we will return to the regular board meeting. So we adjourned the closed session. I believe it was 5.05. 5.11. 5.11. I thought it was 5.05. And we have no action taken in the closed session. So let's go ahead and start the open portion of our meeting. You want to call roll again?

5:12 Tom Johnson. Here. Gary Morgan. Here. David Page. Here. Dre Perry. Here. Shields Richardson. Still here. Heather Schwabmeyer. She is on her way up. She's here. Yes, she is here. Schwabmeyer. She's here. Okay. Eric. I'm here. I'm sorry. Yes. Eric. Okay. Any public comment on the rest of our agenda?

5:42 Or something that's not on our agenda. Excuse me. Okay. So let's move on then to administrative items. First one is to approve any additions to this agenda. Anybody need to see anything else on the agenda? Okay. And now I will take a motion to approve our last board meeting minutes of December 6th. I'll make a motion to approve minutes.

6:17 No, I made a motion. Gary has a move to approve the minutes. Gary seconds. Sorry. Discussion? All in favor? Aye. Opposed? I abstain. One abstention. Brent abstains. Okay, so moved. Let's move on to board member reports and just go around the horn. Gary, you want to go ahead and start?

6:47 Okay, so board member reports. I took John Wentworth down to see Andy Walsh for the performance optimization project at Red Bull last week, showed him around Red Bull and he got a good idea of what the guy's up to. And we've tentatively agreed a strategy for how to move the project along, which is roughly built around a three-year strategy where Andy advises the task force that we haven't set up yet to create a thought leadership around.

7:16 Human Performance Optimization. So that's anything that improves people's capabilities in music, arts, culture, obviously sport. And the idea that he would be in a parallel path for us. The idea that eventually he would try and move and grow an institute here. But the idea we thought was to, rather than create another facility, would just be to use the methodology and the training and bring in a very small conference, which we're talking to Red Bull about bringing up.

7:45 Maybe 20 to 50 people to talk about human performance optimization. They have two of these a year. They move around, so it'd be good to track one of those. And then to set up a couple of workshops, one for local athletes particularly, so Andy can work with them, so we can spread the word if you like. And then a for-profit workshop where we would – he does a lot of work with CEOs where he brings them in for what they call training in adversity. So if you're scared of water, it will make you go underwater with two minutes.

8:14 Very basic kind of thing. And that's where people pay a lot of money to be part of that. So we can see how the business model works. We can see how the community aspect of him working with our athletes works. And then we can try and set a very small conference just to create the idea that Mammoth's thinking in this way, get some publicity around it, and then just see how that rolls us forward. So that's a very basic way of doing it, of explaining it. We haven't really set up the task force yet. There are probably seven members of that. So if anyone here is interested in that, we can talk to you more about it. But we're going to try and pick people.

8:41 The specific attributes that can help move this forward, Mammoth as a community. The MLR hopefully will be leading this, but we'll be reaching outside of the board, mainly for the task force to get people in who can actually add to it. What can be your typical year of folks? Red Bull will be around May, and then it'll be just summer for elite athletes, and then May, and then the conference rather than May or fall, so it'll be short season. Okay. Because that's when we can get most out of the, out of the,

9:11 Accommodation. And then this summer will be the elite athlete training. Thanks, Gary. Shields? Nothing. I'm here at all at Council. Mine's simple. Snow, snow, snow. You know, one of the things that snow brings is everybody's on the mountain happy and people leave tired and exhausted but having a great time. And I will say, by and large, people have enjoyed their experience in Mammoth over the last month. I would second that. It was pretty amazing up there this weekend.

9:45 And the weather conspired to make it a good weekend. Had it been windy and difficult, we have 22,000 people up there on one day otherwise, but everything kind of came together and it was really so good. What's that? Yeah, I mean, our ops team was just 24 hours a day through the storms, just trying to dig out day by day by day and provide...

10:13 You know, a good offering, a limited offering. They're as good as it gets. And what it looked like on Saturday and Sunday was really something. Let me just back up and say something real quick. You know, I think our snow removal guys, road crews, did an excellent job considering the amount of snow, the type of snow we got, the rain. I mean, very, very difficult for them. You know, the privateers, the town, and Caltrans for the most part.

10:41 You know how to move a lot, a lot of snow and I thought they did a great job. We did have one issue though, something coming off the mountain on that Saturday was very difficult. You had an event up there, everybody decided to leave at the same time. It got down to single track and that was because between the village and the brewery, snow hadn't been removed and people were walking.

11:08 They're actually using that one lane to walk. So hopefully in the spring when we do build that sidewalk there at that old sternly. On the flip side, I was trapped in the odler for three hours. And how was that? It was great. It is interesting because Saturday we had that situation. Sunday I left at 3.20 and it didn't back up until well after the scenic loop. I mean it was...

11:38 Really speedy. So I think learning the lesson from Saturday. Well, Saturday, I mean, it was kind of the perfect storm where, you know, you have the big event up there, the fat bike race and what have you. Everybody left at the same time. And then it just kind of pinched at a couple different places there. So, you know, that's how we learn. So I will take my, Leslie Ann. You're not, sorry. Because I'm about to talk about you. Yes. So this is Leslie Ann's last.

12:05 Board meeting with us. She is moving on to a new opportunity. I just wanted to thank you for your service to the organization, from running the web for us, social, all the admin. It's been really great, and we've really appreciated your efforts. And I am hopeful that 20 years from now, you look back at all these sustainable facilities and programs, and you can say you were the number two employee of this organization.

12:33 We really appreciate your work. Thank you. And congratulations on your next position because that sounds like that's going to be a lot of fun. Thank you. Just super briefly, I was at Outdoor Retailer in Salt Lake City last week. A lot of great energy. All the brands are there. It's a big deal. A lot of nonprofits coming together. A lot of collaboration happening.

13:02 On the brand side, one thing that we heard over and over and over again and where they're investing a lot of money in the coming year is public lands to the extent that a lot of the big retailers are threatening to leave Utah based on their political stance, take their billions and probably go to Colorado. Probably not to Mammoth Lakes. We may not be ready to capture that yet. But they're moving and shaking.

13:30 Public Lands was a big one. Stewardship's another one. A lot of brands that haven't traditionally reached out and created cultures are really trying to get brand ambassadors who are involved in science and who are involved in stewardship and who are involved in creating impact on an environmental level because they recognize that Patagonia has kind of led the way in that and has shown all these multi-million dollar companies that that's the way to increase sales.

13:58 And to capture more of their demographic. Climate action is another one and moving toward renewables. Those are the big topics. So it's probably worth us thinking about where do we fit in that in terms of grabbing some of that money that they're laying down. A couple local announcements we are doing. I was just up at the mountain today working with our MMSA partners and friends of Inyo.

14:25 ESEA to map out our pilot snow school program, which is going to take place on Tuesday with 55 fifth graders. And because of the energy around it, the other fifth grade teachers are like, what about us? So we're probably going to do it a month later if it works out so we can get all the fifth graders. And Roseanne's super excited to have it be an annual thing. So it'll be like fourth grade is Sacramento, fifth grade is snow school.

14:51 And it's just, it's such a great lineup of instructors. I mean, Tom Painter's on board, Ned Baer, who's a snow scientist, and he's doing this whole, or Jeff Dozier is going to do, he's going to talk about the UCSB Snowtail Weather Station up there and talk about the making of crystals for Frozen and all that stuff. And a bunch, you know, four or five different organizations and MMS is fully on board and they're giving us gondola passes.

15:21 Yeah, it's super exciting. And there will be snow. And there will be snow. And depending on weather, we sort of have to, like, we have a plan C, like we pull back to Shady Rest if we can't get up to, but hopefully we can get up there because it was awesome punching around today. I think the kids are going to love it. And then Backcountry Film Festival on Thursday night. We had our screening in Salt Lake City. It was sold out. It's a great show.

15:49 So that's, again, with Friends of the Inyo and ESEA, and tickets are available on Eventbrite. It's $15, comes with beer. It should be a fun event at the Forest Service Auditorium next Thursday. Next Thursday, right. Yeah, a week from tomorrow. All right, thanks. I don't have anything. It's been very busy. I'm trying to keep my head above snow, work, everything else, and that's about it. Clear and snow. I don't have anything. Drea? Just as far as cultural events go, we've had some great ones.

16:20 At the Edison Theatre, Squeeze My Cans last weekend, and then just before Christmas, the Fantastics. So it's been great to see locals as well as visitors and enjoying the arts. As well as all the snow. So when I haven't been shoveling, I went to the ice rink between Christmas and New Year's and it was insane.

16:45 Literally, I think there was an amount of adults and kids that were in there. It was awesome to see. Because I've been there in the past last year. You'd see, you know, four or five people. Like, literally, it was insane the amount of people that were skating and enjoying it. It was just great to see people doing other recreational things. With that being said, they also just got doing shady rest. I think three miles just got groomed. Another three miles are going to get groomed. Hopefully you start...

17:09 Putting that out to the public a little bit more once they kind of get that all finished and let everybody know there's other things to do when there's 22,000 people to get them out into other parts of our town. And I don't know where the forum is to put this out there, but is there ever a chance to get more buses in this town on a weekend? Because at 8 o'clock, Minaret in Maine was insane. There was cars down to the post office.

17:37 People trying to go around each other. I'm like, I don't know where you're going to go around to get around with anybody. And I think it's because all of our buses are just being maxed out, and it's awesome. I know it's hard when there's snow. You've got to be ready, right? I don't know if there's a way to talk to me about that. I think all the ESTA buses were maxed. As a matter of fact, they put four into service, four extra ones into service. They still couldn't keep up with them. Well, not only that. I mean, they're stuck in traffic, too. Yeah, yeah. There's a lot of parking issues this last weekend. Yeah, yeah. There were people.

18:07 Parked everywhere. Literally everywhere. So I think that's something that hopefully we can in the future try to do better with and try to get people to use more public transportation. I know it's hard to use because you don't want to stand in line because you're always standing in another line. But that's something I think we could possibly do better at. But other than that, I think it was awesome. I think it was definitely the busiest MLK that I've ever seen. Ever. Saturday's the busiest day I'm out in 11 years. Yeah, that's right. Wow. Yeah. I believe it. No, I think it was second.

18:36 I think we had one, like, almost 25 days. In that record, but really, I thought it was the second all-time. Yeah, it's in there. Something like that. Yeah, for sure. It's pretty big. Yeah, it's huge. It's a large amount of people. You reminded me of something else that I forgot.

18:53 The hockey tournament in between Christmas and New Year's. I went and saw a number of games because my nephew was on the Junior Kings and came up. And I also spent time with a bunch of hockey families who had traveled up from SoCal. I went to like a bowling party for the kids and was just around all the families. And I cannot tell you.

19:13 How stoked. They play indoors, in indoor arenas, and it's, you know, it's just a slog for them a lot of times, trying to find a nice time, bouncing around the town. To come to a place like this and have that experience, they were just glowing about how much fun it was for the kids and the parents.

19:32 So they like not having the roof? They like being able to see mountains. Yeah, they don't want to be... No, they didn't like not having the roof when we had to cancel some afternoon ones because it started... I understand whether there were 42 games or 47 games, something like that. Yeah, it was great. I mean, my nephew had a 6 a.m. game on New Year's Day. That's cool. 6 a.m.? I guess he was doing a... So my sister and brother-in-law were in bed.

20:01 Okay, so that'll do it for board member reports. Thanks, guys. Our Executive Director, I mentioned it at four, but he's sick and he is in LA and he's got a really bad case of the crud and is just trying to weather it and hopes to be back in town Thursday if he's able. So we will skip the Executive Director report and we'll also skip the finance part at the end of the meeting.

20:27 So moving on, then we have 30 minutes allotted to hear from Mammoth Lakes Housing, a presentation on the Shady Rats Parcel. Hi, thank you for having me. Jennifer Halfordy, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I'm just going to pull up my PowerPoint real quick. Hopefully you've had a chance to read the handout, which is a lot more

21:00 In detail about history and such. I'm going to go over some of it. And then you also have a handout, which we'll talk about as we go through as well. Two different really pretty glossies of the concept plan. So I want to start with why Shady Rest? Why now? Why are we talking about this? Shady Rest, as you may or may not know, is the only parcel in town that is zoned for affordable housing.

21:34 So it just made sense that when we started talking about cap-and-trade funds available through the state's auctions of cap-and-trade, they have a new program called the Affordable Housing Sustainable Communities Program that funds affordable housing, transportation, and other things, that if we wanted to do kind of a case study in Mammoth, how would this money play out in town, that we would look at

22:00 The one lot or the one parcel in town that was zoned for affordable housing since the funds are used to produce affordable housing. But there's also a lot of pressure, right? Our community is very busy. We were just talking about that. Our marketing is doing a great job. We're seeing great tourism figures and T.O.T. over the past few years, and that's putting a lot of pressure.

22:25 on businesses in the sense that they need more employees and we're hearing a lot that there's not a lot of housing options. That's a challenge. And then also we know that nightly rental is growing as well. And so that's eating up housing we're seeing and hearing.

22:45 And there's a demand for that. So we've got those forces. And then we just have this ongoing need of affordable housing that we've needed for a long time. So all of these things kind of came together in a perfect storm. And so we said, OK, let's do this now. We've never done this. We've never taken a look at Shady Rust to see if it's a feasible project. And given the new cap and trade, this is a good time to do that.

23:14 So we should talk about the need. What is the need? So by the numbers, in 2011, Mammoth Lakes Housing did their, let's see, third update to the housing needs assessment. We did one in 2003. It was regional. We did another update in 2006. And then we did another full study again in 2011. And so if you remember, 2011 was not the best time in Mammoth Lakes or even in the...

23:43 National or global economy. But we still had a need for housing at that time. And that built in a five-year projection saying, okay, based on, you know, assumptions of people retiring, assumptions of job growth, and current need for employees.

24:01 In 2011, we needed 170 more affordable workforce units. They projected going forward to 2015. We need somewhere between 264 and 421, and that all depends on, again, retirement, job growth, and such. And then, you know, we've been talking a lot about Hart-Howerton. That was a big thing that came out this summer. And then we're also talking about downtown visioning. And what does that mean? So Hart-Howerton,

24:30 Relied pretty heavily on the ERA study that the town commissioned years back, and that has actually in it some workforce housing projections of need. And so based on their estimates of growth in the downtown area, we estimate that there's about 600 additional workforce units that would be needed if that vision really folded out, rolled out.

24:56 And then also in 2015, we know that the town needs a nexus study based on changing their inclusionary policy, going to a fee-based policy. So when a developer comes in, they pay a fee. But to do that, you had to do a lot of research, and you had to do a lot of projections on what is the new development going to bring.

25:19 And that told us that, you know, 79 to 90 percent of the future jobs coming from development will be low income. So we know that, you know, a lot of this isn't rocket science. I think we all know what our economy is based around. It's based around tourism, and those tend to be lower paying jobs, service sector jobs. So that's where we see the need. How many people? Well, Mammoth has...

25:48 A household is 2.5. According to the census, that's the average size of our household is 2.5. So I would assume somewhere in there. So 1,500. The workforce is 1,500 there. Or no, that's families too. Well, you know, that's families too. The kids don't work and, yeah. Is that 600 on the field? There's our low income servicer. Is that 600 in addition to 421?

26:19 Right, right, because the 421 is based on what we needed in 2011 and attrition, retirement, and job growth through 2015, whereas this ERA number is really based on the build-out. So it goes further. The property, so it's got a rich history.

26:47 Some of you maybe know more about it than others, so I wanted to not shine over that. I wanted to really talk about that history. So in the early 80s, there was a developer that wanted to build some affordable housing, and we also needed the...

27:08 The business park and some school land. So they started to talk about a land trade. And they worked with the Forest Service and the school districts and Mono County to get that going. And those were the things they said that they wanted to use the land for. Affordable housing, municipal property, and schools.

27:36 That's when the trails was contemplated to be a workforce housing, affordable housing development. And so the county, this was before Mammoth Lakes was incorporated, went through the process of doing a specific plan which included calling out the trails for affordable housing and all that was done and in place. And then shortly thereafter that was in place, the town incorporated in 1986 and

28:05 You know, they got a planning commission, they got a town council, and pretty quickly after that, the planning commission decided that they didn't want to have the affordable housing at the entrance of town, and they changed the zoning from affordable housing to low-intensity residential.

28:28 And so then as the trails moved forward, the town said, well, we have to do something. We have to find a place to put the affordable housing. I think there was some hairs maybe standing on end back in D.C. from the Forest Service when there was a flip in the use of the land.

28:47 And so that got built into the tentative track map that, okay, you can do the 100-unit subdivision at the trails, but you need to come up with a place to do these 200 affordable units that we were going to get. And so that's when the developer went to the Forest Service and said, okay, well, I need...

29:07 More, I need some more land to put some affordable housing on. And then that started the ball rolling for the 24 and a half acres at Shady Rest, which is in the center of town. I'm assuming you all know it's not a park. Well, it is a park, but this isn't, what we're talking about isn't the park. We're talking about the property that's between Center, Chaparral, and Laurel Mountain. It's this big vacant land, heavily wooded.

29:35 They're in the center of town. So they start that rolling. Then in 91, the town does a master plan for the site and puts an affordable housing overlay zone on it to give some assurance to the Forest Service that there won't be another flip on this property like that happened before. And things started rolling pretty quickly.

30:02 With the owner applying for grant funds and really trying to get the property developed, and that scared some citizens. And so they went out and they did an initiative called the Heart of Mammoth. And they wanted not so much affordable housing. They wanted some more open space. And so in 1996, that was on the November ballot, and that did not pass. That failed the community. The majority of the community wanted to keep the 1991 master plan.

30:33 One of the things I didn't put on here, but I wanted to point out is that the land exchange, and it's in the report, but the land exchange didn't actually get finalized with the Forest Service until 2002, so it wasn't that long ago. I think that's just a testament to how long land exchanges take with the Forest Service, as I think we all know in this town. So it's not like this is really, this was done, you know, centuries ago. This is relatively current.

31:03 In our little town. I wanted to put this in here so you can see where Shady Rest is and how it's zoned. I love the zoning map, but a lot of people probably don't look at it as much as I do. But you can see Shady Rest is that little hashtag up there. White? Yeah, kind of white hashtag.

31:29 The blue off to the right of the map is the school district. A lot of what was traded back a long time ago when the trails was first contemplated and that trade happened at the Gateway Village, or Gateway Specific Plan is what it was called. So you can see also that the Sierra Valley sites is right next to it, which is a

31:58 Largely our workforce community because of the density and they don't allow nightly rentals in that zone. That's RMF1. The base zone for the Shady Rust parcel is the same as Sierra Valley sites. It's RMF1. And then it has this overlay which gives it that hashtag kind of look of affordable housing.

32:29 It's really, Shady Breast is kind of a natural extension, I think, of the community's workforce neighborhood. So we put together a team to help do this analysis. Besides ourselves, we took the help from Rural Community Assistance Corporation, also known as RCAC. It's a nonprofit that works in all of rural western U.S.

33:03 And then Community Economics, which is another nonprofit that works in affordable housing, and they help people put together the financials to do projects. And they work to get your syndicators, if you're using tax credits, all of these things. We hired Triad Homes and Associates, a local group here, to help us figure out how many linear feet of roads do we need and how wide do they need to be, what are the costs of those things in Mammoth. And then Dowling Group was our architectural firm.

33:33 That put these glossies together and worked with us to make sure we were allowing the right amount of acreage for everything that we have here. I want to talk a little bit about the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program, also known as AHSC, because that's the cap-and-trade funded program, and it's a relatively new program. They've only done two funding cycles. They anticipate doing another one this year.

34:03 You know, it's funded through cap and trade, so it has to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. That's really the goal is how do we offset the carbon emissions that these auctioneers paid for. And so this program sets to do that by integrating housing, transit, and, you know, mode-shifting behaviors for people so that they're not driving everywhere.

34:29 So when you put in an application for funding, you've got to demonstrate through these really rigorous calculations that you are, in fact, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and that you're building in things that will change the way people run errands, so to speak, or get to work, whether that's taking the bus, a bike path, a sidewalk, all of those things would demonstrate that, and you can do calculations on that.

34:56 This program funds more than just affordable housing. It actually also funds the infrastructure, which is not an easy thing to find money for, as well as transportation infrastructure and sustainable transportation infrastructure. It's very similar, but you're talking about bus lanes. You can even fund buses, bus shelters, anything that gets people out of their cars.

35:25 And limits greenhouse gas emissions. It does have some requirements on the housing side. You know, you have to do, in rural areas, a minimum of 15 units per acre. If you're in a city, it would be a lot more. Does it fund parking structures? No. They do not. Yeah, they don't even, they used to fund parking sites for your affordable housing, but they don't even do that anymore because they really, like, shun cars. They do fund bike parking.

35:55 And so one of the things that's really interesting when I started learning more about this program is that you have to have this what's called a qualifying transit in your area to even qualify for the program. And that basically means that during peak hours, so morning and night, you have at least two regularly scheduled stops at the same stop, like two buses going through that stop.

36:26 Mammoth is the only community in the Eastern Sierra that currently meets that requirement. So we are the prime candidate in this region, this huge region of California, to tap into this really amazing funds, these amazing funds. They allow you to apply for up to $20 million in each round. And I will just say that Truckee received $10 million for a project in this last round, and in the first round, I think that was $8 million they received for another project.

36:55 So it's not unreasonable to think that rural resort communities couldn't be competitive if you can put the project together with enough time because it takes a lot of preparation to get these together, these applications. For what? I don't think it changes the way people mode shift. I mean, you really have to think about how do you get people out of their cars and is it going to do that?

37:24 It could be an amenity on the site, but it wouldn't get funding. So we looked at the whole site and how feasible is it to develop it and thinking about that as your funding source as you go through. And so we said, well, let's do break it down and kind of really sticking with the master plan because that's what we have today and we don't think it's a bad plan. Maybe it could use some...

37:52 Environmental updating and such, but we don't think it's a bad plan. So we looked at that and we said, well, we could do three developments of

38:00 In phases that were apartments. So that would provide our rental housing because we know based on our needs assessment in 2011 that's really where a lot of need is and we're hearing that too anecdotally throughout the community. And then three for ownership because we know that there's a lot of people who also want to be able to buy a small single family home or townhome and we feel like there's space on this site based on our analysis.

38:28 So then we said, well, those would meet the requirements. We can chunk it out into six development opportunities with at least 15 units per phase. So it could be competitive for cap and trade because that's a huge requirement in rural communities.

38:44 And let's hone in on the first phase. So we honed in on the first phase and we ran that looking at development opportunity one. And this is what we came up with. And how we get here is based on competitive scoring and financial feasibility.

39:02 You tweak the unit count. You tweak the AMIs to get you the most money and to be the most competitive in an application. And that's how we got to 42 units and also working with your density as well. So you can see that development opportunity one is on the first sheet in front of you. It's the one without all the little houses on it. And that's the opportunity that's kind of up in the...

39:32 What is it? The northeast corner of the site. Some of the features that we built into it, and these are all included in the funding analysis, were things like the 42 units of affordable workforce apartments. You can see the multi-use trail. Hopefully you can see it on your screen.

40:06 Your paper, it's the little brown squigglies going through kind of the green space between the development opportunities. It does connect over on Manzanita. There is an easement through one of the parcels over there. I'm not sure it shows up very well on here, but that is built into it. It connects through over on towards Arrowhead and Chaparral.

40:34 Graciously thought that the mountain who owns that parcel would allow us to do that in this analysis. So a lot of multi-use trail in here. And it's just like the stuff we use all over town. It's that same width and materials and such. There's a community playground over here, kind of by the parking lot. You'll see it over towards the wetland.

40:59 Read this, but there is a wetland on the site. There hasn't been a delineation done recently. I know you guys just worked on one at the bell-shaped parcel, and it came in a lot smaller than originally, and I would anticipate this one's probably a bit smaller than the four acres we're guessing, but it used to be seven, so four seems like a quite, we don't really know right now.

41:25 So there's a playground over there. There's a 5,000-square-foot community center on here. And we had thought, talking with people in the community, there's a great need for better child care facilities and more child care facilities. I don't know. I have a daughter that goes to school at the high school.

41:46 If you've ever ridden the bike path there, you know that the Head Start program is right there on the parking lot and they have no soft service for their kids and they were kicked out of the elementary school parking lot and moved over there and talked with...

42:02 Molly DeValle, I think is how you say her last name, from Mona County First Five, and I know that they'd like to see more child care space. There's a shortage of infant care facilities in Mammoth, and really it spaces the issue as far as I'm hearing from her. So we thought we could build in the ability to do tenant improvements of 1,500 square feet there for that.

42:25 That child care facility would be for anybody in the community, not just the people who live at Shady Rest. There's an amphitheater on the other side of the wetland there, kind of adjacent to the playground. There's a pump bike.

42:45 Park, track, and I don't know if you guys know what that is. I didn't know what that was until we started talking with Rich actually about it, and he said that there's a group of people who would love to have one and a lot of momentum there. And I walked the site once this summer. A lot of people walk the site. It's a huge thoroughfare. And it looked to me like maybe there's already one there.

43:14 Yeah, so that's kind of back in the... Yeah, I mean, and it's great too because it's not, you know, there's no greenhouse gas emissions from that, so it probably scores well as a great amenity.

43:33 And also included in our feasibility analysis was all of these backbone streets. I mean, there's nothing there right now. There's no infrastructure connecting Center Street to Chaparral, the Tavern Road. And roads are expensive, and so that's included in here, as well as utilities, and that's another really expensive endeavor on such a large, raw piece of land.

44:04 It shows the structures that we had envisioned in each development opportunity. And you can see development opportunity one has two-story. These are garden apartments with tuck under parking and then some surface parking as well. Are you okay? Are you okay? I'm not going to say that. I'm not going to say that.

44:35 Being cognizant of the neighbors, we're envisioning single-family townhomes kind of around the buffer, creating a bit of a buffer where Shady Rest Tract is right now where it's that cul-de-sac you see in the lower kind of right-hand corner of the site or of the map. And then also up along...

45:04 Manzanita as well. There's also a 25-acre, or 25-foot, excuse me, landscape buffer, too, just to kind of create, you know, be kind to your neighbors and think about how we're integrating with our neighbors in this kind of analysis. I don't know if you guys have any questions on that. I've got a few questions. Yeah. So, is that...

45:36 With that map right there, are you showing maxes out to 172 that's currently allowed for a lot, or is that less or more? This right here is 192 with an average density of, I want to say 18 units per acre, which is about 1.6, the base density.

45:57 When you guys looked at this whole design, I mean, we went through this many, many years ago when I saw the Regional Planning Commission in Vermont, we were always trying to, how do you preserve open space, how do you do different things? I know there's been comments made before, but have you looked at more condensed village space and leaving some more open space within the parcel? Well, I think that when we looked at this... Yeah, there's a lot of different, you know, it's kind of like...

46:25 It's kind of like the far discussion a little bit. Like, well, you have that, but then you also have snow storage and you have setbacks. You have all these things you have to bring into play. And there is a lot of open space where the trail is. You can see that. So there is a bit of open space. There's actually the four acres in the northeast corner of the site. I don't know if you can see it. It's labeled number four.

46:54 So that's a huge section of open space there. So there was quite a bit of open space included. The wetlands is a big open space.

47:09 Yeah, we were balancing a lot of open space, actually, with also quality of life. You know, how many flights of stairs do you want to walk up with your baby and your groceries, or whatever, you know, considering that there would be some three bedrooms and such families. We have a lot of families in Mammoth, or, you know, two and a half family.

47:36 One-third low-income, one-third low-income, and one-third moderate. Is you still keeping that same model for, what do you say, affordable? Affordable is a very big term. Yeah, so it's workforce. Yeah, workforces, yeah. Yeah. Are you still looking at that sort of a range of, trying to visually understand what you're doing there?

47:55 Yeah, no, the range is still there. The ownership is, you know, within what's currently allowed. A lot of that is also set by the zoning. So the affordable housing overlay zone restricts 120 and below of AMI. So a little bit above, 20% above middle and then down.

48:19 The ownership is the 80 to like 120 probably, and whereas the rentals are probably more affordable, you're looking at 80 and below. Just last question, you had some numbers there, and probably that's having general partner and having limited partner. Are you, are you just trying to understand that? Oh yeah, let me get to that, I haven't gotten to that slide. Yeah, we should definitely, I mean this is the exciting part in the sense that

48:46 There's a lot of outside capital available. You know, 27, almost 28 million for the phase one with all of those amenities. We talked about the features, if you will, the bike path, the utilities, et cetera. And so the tax credits, I think you were asking about who they were.

49:10 So tax credits would be a key player. The Affordable Housing Sustainable Communities really encourages the use of 4% tax credits. Right now they discourage the use of 9%, which is just another funding tool that brings in more money, but it's more competitive. I don't want to get into a lot of the details, but so...

49:35 When you get tax credits for affordable housing development, there is...

49:43 organization, or a company, I should say. It's usually a bank or an insurance company that wants to buy tax credits so that they can reduce their liability on their taxes. And so they will pay money for these tax credits because they not only get the reduction in their tax liability, but they also get the write-down from the depreciation as well.

50:07 And so that person, or that entity, like Verizon or a big bank, will be the limited partner. So they have limited liability, but they get all of the credit. And then the general partner is the for-profit or non-profit, typically affordable housing developer, that actually does most of...

50:31 You know, does the work. But they just bring all the money. The limited partner brings a lot of money to the table. And so that's where that $8 million would come from, those 4% tax credits. So they get to depreciate the development? Yes. They get the tax right off of that. The limited. Mm-hmm. You said phase one. Development opportunity one, phase one, yes. Okay, so is this an all-encompassing budget?

50:59 For that development opportunity with those features that I talked about. That's development opportunity one, which is the right north. So that's not? Yeah, it's none of the other homes, but it is all of the roads. It's all the infrastructure. Yeah. Including the community center? Yes. And then how do you anticipate the other phases? Well, I think when, you know, let's say hypothetically that

51:29 Mammoth Lakes, the community went in for an AHSC application this summer when I anticipate them releasing their next NOFA, notice of funding availability, and they were awarded in the fall. That project isn't going to be ready for at least three years, if not four, depending on how everything rolls out in winters, right, because construction goes a little slower in big winters like this.

51:59 So, you know, you bring that online, you lease that up, and then you start probably working on your next application maybe in year two. You'd start working on another application so that you can cycle them through. You don't want to inundate the market. You know, you want to phase bring them on so that they could be absorbed. When you say middle and lower and 20% above middle,

52:27 Where's that number? Is that number coming off of just our local income base? It's not like a one that's for the state of California, right? Specifically for our area? Right. It's actually for Mono County because we're so small and rural. We don't get an AMI just for our incorporated areas. Big cities do. But we share with Mono County. So it's based on...

52:48 What the federal government tells us about Monokami specifically. Do you know what that is? Like, what is 20% above the middle? Just out of curiosity for financial, because I'm thinking about the people out there who make, you know, the $40,000, $50,000, sometimes I remember when I had the affordable housing, you know, 10 years ago, some people couldn't, that were checkers and bonds, like, I can't get it because I make too much money. Yeah. And I'm like, but you're making, you know, $14 an hour. Right, right, right. So...

53:15 A household income for, let's see, middle income, so this is the middle, 100%, is $78,500 for a family of four, according to the federal government. So it would be 20% more, would be $120. When did you say that this design was completed?

53:44 The fall, just this past fall. I'm just trying to square it with what I saw in the Hart-Howerton presentation and the way that the tract was kind of, you know. Yeah, I think there's some similarities and, you know, it's a palette and a blank palette right now. The schedule you have, is that the same one that's here? So the schedule that's on in the handout, it has the 42 units, is that?

54:12 I just want to make sure I'm clear. The 42 units, is that just what is in opportunity development number one? Yes, it is. What's the total number of units? 192. 192, okay. Okay. Can I just ask one thing that, I mean, this is great, super informative. For the sake of this board, it seems like the community center piece is the one that's relevant to our strategic vision, and I'm wondering, what's your vision for that community center? Is it just, it's kind of called out as a neighborhood?

54:42 Community center is, what does that 5,000 square feet look like in your mind? How does it impact the broader community? Well, I will just say that I think there's also places to think about partnerships with

54:59 Mammoth Lakes Recreation for the, you know, things like the pump track and the playground and even the bike trails and those kinds of things. So I think it's more than just that, but I think as far as that goes, we had envisioned, you know, the child care facility being a key component and then just the neighborhood, being able to use it for things.

55:23 That neighborhoods would want to like after school programming, a computer lab, those kinds of things that would be beneficial to the neighborhood. Hadn't gotten far into programming, but certainly, you know, things of that nature, but open to future discussions and ideas. I mean, this is just a concept plan. What's your board's kind of reaction to the idea? I mean, coming from Hart-Howerton and then in a lot of the conversations I'm hearing,

55:52 About how to make the deal work. More of an anchor amenity on that property in terms of the downtown redevelopment. What's your guys' reaction to kind of that talk and how fungible this design is versus something else? Well, I think that the board hasn't taken a position. There's been no formal position taken on the Hart-Howerton plan. We've had certainly discussions, so I could only...

56:22 what I've heard from those discussions and the catalyst really the community the neighborhood is the catalyst the people there is the catalyst we have a lot of vacant commercial we talk about this a lot when we do our downtown planning we don't necessarily see the need to put commercial here

56:44 But we know that if we have our community spreading this way towards this commercial corridor, it's going to do a lot to be a catalyst in an animating way. Yeah, the thing that's missing here is, you know, there's a private ownership. And the town wants to work with MLH and the owner to actually make something happen.

57:13 We're working on that. And then to Jennifer's point, it's a palette. You know, we're trying to figure it out. And hopefully we can figure it out relatively quickly so we can go to the funding sources that Jennifer's talking about. But a key component is whether the owner is willing to play ball. And so that's what the town is trying to work with right now so that we can report back to MLH saying, okay, hey, you know, these are the deal points that we're talking about. Does that fit in with

57:43 You know, what we're trying to do here. And, you know, we're trying to balance all three together. And so we're right in the middle of those negotiations. Nothing's happened. There's been no deals made. But at least we're in discussion. We're in negotiation. It's been sitting there way too long not being useful to our community. So hopefully we can get it out of that realm and, you know, into

58:12 The realm it needs to be. And have affordable housing, workforce housing, and hopefully some town amenity there. So that's where we are. Jennifer, thank you so much. Yeah, thank you for your time. I appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. All right, moving along here. Any public comment? I think it's great that we're finally talking about affordable housing. I don't really know anybody in this town who doesn't.

58:40 I believe that we really need affordable housing. And it's great, you know, as what Shields was saying, it's great to see something getting pushed forward and, you know, all these funds available to help us make it happen in an area that's already sound. Just keep their fingers crossed. Thank you for all your... Okay, moving along. Next on the agenda, we have an update, I assume, from Grady on the multi-use facility. Thank you.

59:11 I didn't bring the PowerPoint we brought to town council. That was December 21st. Hopefully everyone had a chance to catch up on that. What I'm here to report today is really what action they took on December 21st. I can answer any questions, what we did at the last meeting, and what you should expect in February. When I was last before you, I remember I sat down and shared, we went through everything in great detail, except for some of the costs and the detailed schedule issues. I want to hit on the schedule and the costs.

59:39 Most importantly, the EIR is out for public review right now. It goes until February 13th. I don't know if we've gotten any comments yet. Most of them come in in the last few days or the last couple of hours, but we do certainly expect to get comments. In addition to that, we've released an initial cost estimate, and it's in your packet. I think it's $10,800,000 roughly, $10,580,000.

1:00:05 We presented that to Town Council on December 21st, and we noted that we had not yet beaten that up. In other words, we got that from the consultant. We thought it was important to get it to Town Council, subsequently to this group and to the Recreation Commission before we did that. We're in the process of doing that right now. We have another conference call with our consultants tomorrow.

1:00:25 To work on that. The idea is to go through it, not only fine-tune the cost system, but also do value engineering. And when I use that term, I want to caution you that most people will think that means cut the project in half. No offense to these chairs, but buy these chairs instead of these chairs, that type of thing. What we're really looking at is somewhat of a redesign that keeps the brill.

1:00:48 Parts of the project that we really need and the community really wants, but does it at a lesser cost? We haven't gone through that exercise yet. We're doing that right now. The goal is to come back, or not the goal, but the commitment is to come back to town council the second meeting in February.

1:01:02 With an update that says, look, we've gone through the engineering again, we've gone through the design, we've gone through a phasing study to see what might a first phase look like. We've costed that out again. We've taken it back to Recreation Commission and MLR, which means please make sure this is on your agenda for February because we hope to get a packet out early in that month and to present it to both the Rec Commission and MLR on the same day, frankly.

1:01:27 and get your comments and then come to council about 10 days later and say, okay, this is what we've heard, this is what a recommendation is. Parallel with this, and it's something that I'm not working on directly yet, but Rob's here and the town manager, Dan Holler, will be working very carefully on some kind of a financing plan, in other words.

1:01:45 How much can we really come up with? What do we really think we can do in terms of cash? What is there in Measure R and Measure U and what other opportunities are available? We've discussed a lot of them yet. We don't have a detailed plan yet because we're not going to have $10.5 million for one thing, but we certainly hope to be able to have enough cash and enough financing to be able to go forward with the first phase.

1:02:09 Really, that's all I have today. The plan itself, the drawings you've seen before haven't changed. We're working on phasing to show as an example what does it look like if by December of this year now, it's now 2017, we want to just get ice in a roof. That's been the direction, a lot of discussion from town council, a lot of, I thought it was a very good conversation and very desperate views about various things. But one of the points was let's do everything we can to get ice.

1:02:37 Next December. They actually said Thanksgiving, and I cautioned them that was going to be very tough because various things going on, but the point is get it done and get it done right. So we're taking the design and the planning side of things, cost estimating, and try to see how far we can get. We'll be back to Council second meeting in February and before this group early in February with that. With that, I think I'd rather just answer any questions you have at all. The thing Council did, though, let me back up a second.

1:03:04 The action they actually took on December 21st. We laid out four options because certainly being about six weeks behind the schedule we'd hoped to be at a year and a half before, you know, in my view, we did pretty well, but still, it's not Halloween opening day, so it looks like it's later in the year, if not early the next year. So we gave council some options and said, look.

1:03:27 At the very minimum, what staff is recommending is that we spend at least $25,000 to go through the cost estimating and value engineering exercise. There are actually four options, a couple of hybrids, but the other extreme, if you will, was, look, authorized $250,000.

1:03:44 What that does is that allows staff to work with a consultant to put together the phasing plan and continue to work on the drawings, especially for the site work and the roof itself, which are the longest lead items. The site work because we could start it as early as May with how it looks now as early as June, thankfully. But also work on the roof structure itself because that's the thing that takes the longest to design. Council authorized us to do that. We came back at the meeting two weeks ago.

1:04:12 I actually made that budget adjustment. We're doing an amendment to the agreement with HMC to do that work. Having said that, by February 15th, we will not have spent that money. We probably will have spent a third of it, if that.

1:04:26 It takes longer to do that. If, however, we get good results back on February 15th and the council tells us to keep going, then by the time the EIR comes back for certification, which we're now saying is the second meeting in March, then we'll have spent more of that, but we'll be well on our way towards a project late this year. So with that, any questions at all? Generically, so the initial cost is $10 million. There's certain parts where you value engineer, but I know it puts you on the spot.

1:04:56 What are you anticipating as the value of engineering reduction of cost? And I know that's a very hard number. I've heard this question before. We heard it on December 21st. My answer was the same. I don't know. We're going to go through that process. I mean, the police station, we were able to take some things out. We were able to give the council a shopping list of things that were not necessarily essential but important to the project that they could choose and look at. I don't know. We have a goal, certainly.

1:05:24 It is what it is, frankly. We're not looking at it from a strict budget perspective. We're saying, okay, we need to keep the project, keep the value, keep the functionality of it, and see what it really costs to do that. Will there be an option to, so you've got the high end based on the drawings that you've shown us, then you have the value engineering end, which is TBD, and then will there be also kind of a low end, like just roof and ice cost? You know, frankly, we were asked,

1:05:53 Not to really look at that. We did take a very brief look, which means about two hours on what would that cost to put a roof even at the existing facility, which we know is not going to happen. It's not even an option. If it's just roof and ice, we'll have an estimate that shows that as a first phase. But in terms of low end, it's not going to be...

1:06:13 Just the metal roof that you saw last year as an example, we're not doing that. We're just reducing the scope to say it's a high-quality roof and ice, but this is what that might be. I mean, right now, if you add up the numbers in the estimate, I think it's 6.7 million for just that. So if we can get that down to, say, six, five and a half, now we have something we can be serious about and present to everybody. There's nothing in between for the metal roof.

1:06:40 That we looked at originally and the full building. That's where the value engineering comes in. Right now the roof itself is I think $1.9 million. Gary can look it up before I can remember what it is. But the idea is to get that cost down as well. There are certain things on the roof that are nice.

1:07:01 The shades around the top or on the outside that help block some of the sun. Maybe we can do that in a different material where it still looks good, it's still functional, but doesn't cost as much as having actual louvers and things like that. That's what we're looking at, but again, we're right in the middle of it. Is that where the best opportunity for value engineering is in the roof, or are you guys looking at everything?

1:07:23 The roof's the biggest number, so yes. The other one that we don't want to look at, but we'll present it to town council as an option because, yeah, that's our job, is the concept of Olympic ice is something that not only everybody grabbed onto, but then every other facility we've talked to has said, do Olympic ice. Don't short yourselves. You're going to wish you had, and we've heard that consistently. That's from the Kings, too? Is that their recommendation? Just about everybody we've heard says, yeah, do that.

1:07:50 That's $700,000 if we take it out and go to a regular size or an NHL size rink. So that's still something we have to consider, but it's something we're not going to put on the first list because seriously, everybody we've talked to said, no, the Olympic ice gives you so much more flexibility, winter and summer. Is solar a consideration at all? It's not really on the cost right now. It's not in our cost estimate, but it's something we're designing the structure to be able to hold solar, and that'll be something we'll talk about in the next phase.

1:08:20 The rules about solar and reimbursements change every year, and I frankly don't know where they are today, but we are going to be talking about solar for the building, certainly. It'll be designed to hold it, whether it can go on first phase or not. We'll see. And just to clarify, you expect in February to, by our board meeting, to have the value engineered design and the number? Is that what you're... Okay. That's correct.

1:08:48 The exhibits might not be as pretty as they get over the next two weeks, but the hard numbers is what we're really focusing on is the cost and the schedule. And that'll be the phase number too. That's correct. Anyone else? Any questions? Could you just repeat that number for the roof itself? That's in the 5.4? Probably, right?

1:09:12 Oh, you can read it. Yeah. Ice shrink rec zone 5.0. Later on, I actually broke out the roof later. I'll have to look that up. So it's part of the 5.5? That's correct. The 1.9 for the roof? Is that right? I want to look that. Okay. Thanks. I thought I heard six months. Other questions? Comments? I'll make a comment. Absolutely. Speaking again as a citizen, I hate the word value engineer.

1:09:44 The IntraWest value engineered the village. And I just, that's a tough one. If we're going to do it, let's do it right. I like the idea of phasing. Makes a lot of sense. So hopefully they come back with a phasing project that is worthy of what we're trying to build here. Value engineer it. But let's do, the things that we're going to build, let's build right. Let's not do it a third time.

1:10:12 This will be a bid project. Definitely the one thing we're considering not bidding out is the roof itself because there is a nationwide contract with Butler Roofing that has been bid nationwide. I've heard that it's really competitive. I'm not convinced yet. So that's one of the things we'll come back with in February.

1:10:43 Bid nationwide. I do it for, as an example, well, I'll use an example of trucks. There's a thing in California, also nationwide, where they'll bid a certain kind of F-150 truck, as an example, all over the place, and everybody can take advantage of that price. So it's already engineered? Yes. For this building, of course, they'd have to engineer it specifically for this, but in terms of unit costs and things, it's already been bid out. It has proven to be effective nationwide. I'm just not convinced that it works for us in this.

1:11:13 Environment. So that's one of the things we're looking at. Okay. Thank you, Grady. Appreciate it. I'm trying to look up the cost of the reference. Definitely get it on that. Okay. What we did was, I'll forward you the agenda sheet from January 4th, because we actually put more detail and information in that and included it in that packet, so it might not be in this one. When would you have to get started by, let's say everything fell into place and the stars aligned and everything, to get it, have ice with a roof on it in December?

1:11:43 We'd really like to start site work in June. The bigger issue that's out there, frankly, is the issue of a possibility of a protest on the EIR. And if that occurs, it's just not going to happen this year. That's all there is to it. But really, that's why we want to get the site work started. So if nothing else, we can be out there grading and get that going while everything else is happening. Are you using any of the existing tubing, chillers, whatever, from the current site so that...

1:12:14 If this happened and we had ice in December, we would not have ice until this one opened? Is there going to be a lapse of ice for a period of time? One of the things we're looking at is best how to do that, frankly, and that decision probably couldn't be made until sometime after the EIR is done and after we're...

1:12:34 We're busy doing the design because we would definitely be using the existing chiller. Our chiller maintenance guy has gone through it and says that it probably has at least 10 more years of life, so it's worth moving over. And there was even comment at town council from Mammoth Hockey who said, look, if you're not going to have ice in time, fine, we'll deal with it over there. You know, let us stay over there for another year. Use that chiller. So they're cognizant of that as well. I guess that was my point is it might be better to...

1:13:04 Wait another year instead of during the busiest time that you're not going to have ice. And that's one of the things we're looking at in the phasing too is when can we move that chiller? And at any point can you turn around and let's say you don't keep that thing, can you sell it and recoup some costs and get some money out of it to tell somebody else who wants it? It's not something you're just going to like throw it into the trash. I don't know who's asking. You mean the chiller itself? Yeah. Everything comes over there. When they break down that ice rink, all that equipment, does it just go?

1:13:32 Is it the old dump or is it something that you can then sell to somebody else? We'll try to sell it. I think the plexiglass is probably going in the trash because that's not doing too good. Okay. Some of the boards and things, there will be somebody who wants them. I mean, we wanted them, right? So somebody else will. Going to Olympic Ice, they're a different shape, different size. There's certain things in the design, but we're doing more efficiently. We're actually, there are other...

1:13:57 Things over there, including the slab itself and the parking and the building that the Olympia is in and everything else. We're looking at those as well because one of the requirements of our lease for the school district is, frankly, it says when we leave, we clean up the site and leave it not as it was before but pretty close. We realize that they're not going to ask us to do that. That's not in their best interest, frankly. We're going to have a meeting later this week, frankly, having nothing to do with the lease or negotiations but having to do with, hey,

1:14:26 When we leave...

1:14:28 What's your first thought of what you want to see there? We're not going to go into a great amount of detail yet, but we want to at least get an idea. Because if they say... Those outbuildings too? Pardon me? That includes the outbuildings there. Well, those are ours. And we can take the trailers if we want to, if they're still functional. The Olympia building, we could relocate it. We normally have a use for it at the new place, but maybe someplace else. But we're going to look at all those things. But we don't know yet what they want either.

1:14:58 We're just starting that conversation. Any other questions or comments? Okay. Okay. Thanks, Greg. Thanks. See you in February. All right. Moving on. I believe Rob Patterson is going to talk to us. And we have a, this is an item for a potential action review and consider approving the town of Mammoth Lakes request for ongoing funding for programs and projects. Rob.

1:15:27 Yes, thank you. Let me pull this up real quick. I put together a PowerPoint presentation so we could look at this very quickly. Okay, and you guys have in your packets, you have the agenda action sheet as well as the recommendation and the staff report. I will say that going through this process was very educational for me. I got an opportunity.

1:15:57 What I did was I reconciled the actual spend on an annual basis for all the activities that we do for both 215, 16, and 17. Those are funds within the town's budgeting system that are designated for either Measure R or Measure U. Measure R funding 215 and 216, and then 217 is all Measure U.

1:16:22 The process was really educational for me, giving me an opportunity to look at all of the details of every charge that's posted to those funds on an annual basis and review what the expectations were, but also what the cost was. And Stu and I worked very closely on this because Stu's been instrumental in tracking these expenses before I arrived. Once I arrived, I've started to receive all the invoices that come through for those, and I review, sign off, keep copies for my own reconciliation purposes.

1:16:51 A good job was done of tracking that before my arrival, and then we kind of continued to build and expand on that. So through the reconciliation process, and we sort of looked at the needs and the things that were out there, Stu and I had walked away with a thought that, well, we know costs are increasing. We want to kind of come in and say, we're really going to need more funds for maintenance and support. We're really probably going to need some more funds for other activities that we want to do. But when we approached Dan Holler with that approach, he said,

1:17:20 He really did not want to kind of continue to saddle RNU with additional sort of ongoing expenses and try to minimize that. I think as demonstrated in prior years, we've cut down our requests for funding from you in certain aspects. So he kind of said, you know what, do what you can with the funds that are given to you.

1:17:41 And we'll absorb the additional costs. So I think you'll see that in this staff report and this recommendation request that for the most part we've sort of drawn down a little bit. There's some areas where the costs have increased, but we can discuss that. But the overall intention is that the facilities maintenance, at least, will become a part of town's responsibility in the future. And we'd like to free up some more of the funds available for RNU for future projects.

1:18:07 Because I think that expanding the use of those funds is what's intended. So what I have on the screen here right now is just a slight recap of, on top, it's what we're requesting this year. As comparison to last year, the second set of boxes down below is last year's request. And so you can see that we have some increases in some places, and we'll talk about those. But for the most part, we're reducing our request by approximately $1,000 across both funds.

1:18:37 For 2016-17 versus what we did in 15-16. And looking at the Fund 216 Measure R, this is the expenses reconciliation, so this would be where the ongoing funding is there to support. One of the items that we had, you'll see a couple of those we overspent this year.

1:19:01 And that has actually been refunded based upon our mid-year presentation to Town Council when we were going through our overages. We decided to request those funds from General Fund Balance from last year, and those monies were approved by Town Council and paid back to 216 and 217. So while they show shortfalls here, this is just in the reconciliation purposes, we've now made those whole, if you will.

1:19:31 And the fund balances have actually increased for 216, 217 based upon those adjustments. So looking at trails, parks, and building maintenance, this is the one that really thought we were going to come in for an additional request. This one is funded in two components. It has $25,000, which is for the Whitmore Park maintenance.

1:20:01 I'm sorry, $12,000 for Trails End Park and $25,000 for Whitmore Sports Field Maintenance. Having those two sort of designated separately, as you saw on my reconciliation sheet, they're actually in Trails Park Maintenance, number one, that $37,000 is the budget. That's both of the numbers combined. As our staff goes around and works on the fields and the preparation, they have to go through and allocate their time specific to each one of those, and it's a bit of a challenge.

1:20:28 to designate those out separately when we know we just have a certain amount of money to spend. So I'd look to reduce complexity in the separate coding that we're doing as well as separate budgets to add that complexity and combine that into one number, if you will, rather than 25 and 12, but simply 37.

1:20:49 We did last year purchase a snow pusher piece of equipment that will clear the sports field and allow it to be used in more circumstances than we had in the past. So we anticipate the usage of that field to go up because it's available for more time, and therefore we thought the expense of the maintenance was going to go up. So we anticipate the total maintenance for those facilities to be around $42,000 annually, but we're...

1:21:14 recommending that we stay at the current 37 and that we support those from the town's general fund even though we have increased expenses. I talked already about the town philosophy to absorb these rising costs in our budget so that you freed up funds for future projects and again that anything that we spent over in 2015-16 were refunded by town council during the mid-year review.

1:21:43 So my recommendation on this particular one is no change, which would leave that at a total of $37,000 for the Parks and Building and Trails maintenance. Equipment replacement. So this is an incremental request. Last year we had a one-time funding of, I believe it was $2,500 from both Measure R and Measure U to support the replacement of equipment for special events.

1:22:14 And this, we believe, is something that we need to have on an ongoing request, so I'm putting it into the annual funding request. And we would reduce it a little bit to $2,000. And that would allow us to kind of make sure that as, you know, either equipment disappears or needs to be replaced, that we have funds to do that and not have to come back to the board or request those additional funding.

1:22:41 And that we really would not have to come back looking for any of these equipment components unless we had some kind of a significant change or there was another venue or something like that that we were supporting where we needed those things. And that would be like a one-time request. So the recommendation that I have here is a total of $4,000. I'm combining both $216 and $217. Each of those funds would supply $2,000 to support this particular item. Equipment maintenance.

1:23:10 In this particular one, this is the ongoing maintenance that we've had for both equipment and tools and products that are supporting those facilities, not necessarily just the playground equipment and such that you would have for the prior funding item. So in the last year, we overspent. That has been refunded. We believe that a good baseline is $2,000. We would just concede that consistent. And it would be a target that we would have to shoot for.

1:23:38 And sometimes equipment that needs to be repaired or some kind of maintenance costs on one single item can exceed $2,000. But we think that if we have that baseline limit as a solid factor and we know that's our limits, that we'll sort of work around that. And we'll do an annual evaluation to make sure that we're not costing $4,000, $5,000, or $6,000, and that will really request additional funds if needed.

1:24:06 But right now we want to keep it at a consistent $2,000, so no change on this particular line item. Audit services. So we expanded the scope of work this year on audit services, and this is kind of across the board, which is more test selections and additional review that was performed by our existing auditing firm. These folks have been with us for a number of years, and we think they do a very good job. They've been no increases in their fees over the last six years.

1:24:37 So we have, with the expectation there's going to be a slight increase. We do have a report on the compliance that's required for Measure R and Measure U, which has been consistent with what we've done in prior years, but in this case with the additional testing and review, the cost has gone up $500 on each of the audits. So total audits are $8,000 and it's $4,000 for each.

1:25:04 Measure R and Measure U, which is 216 and 217. And this is a look at 217's reconciliation of expenses, and you can see that we actually had some funds that were available and not spent in a year, which is good. We will continue to strive for that. In this case, you'll see at the end of my recommendations that all of the funds that we do not spend that are budgeted,

1:25:33 Do remain with these specific funds. So fund 216 and 217 get to retain all of the budgeted dollars that are not spent. And it goes into what's called fund balance. So those are available to be allocated in future times. So we do encourage things that are not spent to the right level or to the budgeted level, I should say. One key item on 217 that was under was transit services. We had 24,000, I believe.

1:26:05 For budgeted for transit services and not really evident on this because it's not in the details of contractual services. But we had $25,000 budgeted for, $24,000 budgeted for transit services and we spent $64,000, $62,000. And although that $64,000, $62,000 we realized through review of prior years before even $15,000, $16,000, that that number had declined.

1:26:35 And so we had a little bit higher and we're a little concerned about reducing it too much. One thing that the reconciliation did prompt is a good conversation about what is an event that's funded by these transit services in 217. And to tell you how the invoices come to me from ESTA, I'll get an invoice that says here's the event that we supported, here's the number of hours that we did, we have a set rate per hour, and then we sign off on those.

1:27:02 It really comes down to the review of those invoices and the proper coding of them. So through this process, we've kind of discussed that which events are actually supported in the staff report. You'll see the ones that we had listed there for 15-16. But what I'm looking for, and we've had some conversation, is really what is that list, and we'll have that consistent list of events, and we'll be able to know, certainly when I'm coding the invoices, what we're assigning to

1:27:30 Measure U from Transit Services. Can I just ask a quick question? Sure. That's the only real area that you've really changed is that expense. And I notice in the years past, for instance, like Math Marathon was on there, and it doesn't look like it's been on there for the last couple of years for expenses for transportation. Maybe go back to the coding, but it looks to me, when I look through that, that there's stuff I've coded to events isn't getting coded to the events. We've gone up from 6,000 to 18,000.

1:27:58 We think that's, I mean, I know we don't want to go down and you're trying to moderate, but that's a 100% jump in expense. More than 100%. From 6 to 18,000. So it's a 200% jump is what it is. Yeah, I think by getting the list of events that we really want to support from this function, we would have a better understanding of that. So coming back in the following year, I think we would have a clearer picture.

1:28:28 You'd illustrated some of the items that you'd seen in prior years that were not coded there last year. If they were not, then they're being billed to transit services that the town's supporting. So I think that getting that consistent list and getting those numbers, I don't see it as hurting anything to leave it at 18.

1:28:48 Terry, do you have a question? I was just going to say if it's not spent, then it just goes back. But I know as we're trying to budget out with all our projects that it's nice to get a little closer. But we also have more programs and more events that are going to continue going on each year. So that number is going to keep going up. One of the things that I had, and this was part of our conversation, I have a concern about is some of the things that have been funded through this. So I did pull up.

1:29:17 The initial application, which was for a special event trolley. And it was not just a transportation transit expense. It was specific as to what it was being spent for. And I think that as we're moving forward, that's one piece. This one is, it needs to be clarified as to how is it that an event is approved.

1:29:46 To go into this and that money's coming out of here. What's that criteria? Yeah. So that whoever's approving these items has something to follow and go by. You know, because if you're just looking at Measure U, any of these things would be fine. And it's not that they were spent incorrectly. If we went by the actual application, which was a multi-year application, and that's what's been...

1:30:13 renewed year after year after year. Some of these things probably are not appropriate. So I think that we need to clarify, and this is one piece that we really need to have that criteria. So town knows what, ESTA knows what they're funding, and, you know, we all know what's going into that, and so does the community. As the person who approves the invoices, I would appreciate that. Yeah. So that's one piece on this. I don't have a problem with $18,000 because

1:30:43 You know, we might, as we go another year, be able to reduce it, but I think we need to get a, we're just finally getting a handle on the reconciliation. So I think that it's not a matter of we're giving the money out and it disappears. It's still there. If it doesn't get spent, it just goes, rolls back into the fund balance. But I agree with you that there has to be some check to be sure that that funding matches up with our allocations process, for example, that there's public benefit to each of those.

1:31:10 And just somebody comes and says, oh, we're having an event that benefits nine people and we need transportation. Yeah. So is there some kind of criteria we set out ahead of time or is there some kind of review? I think we can approve this with that caveat that we're going to come back and bring criteria back to the board that can be here and then it can be presented to council and then can go to the town.

1:31:37 But I think we can go ahead and move forward with approving these things with that caveat there. And so, and I think the question about intended funding, one of the areas on this contractual services here, and I didn't pull the reconciliation out entirely, and I basically broke out of all the budgeted items exactly what was spent, and so it was, you know, of all the different funding sources that you guys approved allocations to, that made up the budget amount and then the actual spend.

1:32:06 Was associated with each one of those. So I was able to tie those all together very nicely, actually, and 217 was easier to do. But there's a lot of spending, but we were matching it to the panting on that. So I'm pretty happy with that aspect of match. And, you know, as Terry said, the funding does come back. So if we did that list, I mean, I don't think there'll be maybe some minor reductions from that. We had a couple of events last year that were funded.

1:32:32 That shouldn't have been, but then we might have had some that should have been that were not. So overall on that, I don't anticipate a big change, but this is definitely a request. I do need that. I would like that input and definitely can handle that. But again, what I don't want to do is cut it down to the point where we have known events and things that we have that I don't have the funds allocated for. That would be my concern.

1:33:02 A kind of rolling fund to replace equipment, to buy new equipment, I think, especially philosophically, you're talking about, you know, are you maybe not responsible for escalating maintenance into the future, but buying equipment, replacing equipment makes a lot of sense to me, to these funds, so I like that. But then the question is, what kind of an equipment category are we talking about? Is it related? Kind of the same question with transit, too. So maybe we'd...

1:33:31 We'd have some kind of criteria where it's not burdensome to you guys necessarily, but you just know what kind of equipment qualifies. That's fair enough. So process agreements is another line item on the budget for 217. And this is based upon the number of agreements that the town staff reviews for Measure U. And in prior years, our total contracts were 18.

1:34:02 There are $380 per contract. Currently, we only have six. So that's like $2,200 in review funds. We do have a request of $7,200, which was at some point a baseline number. In talking to Stu, he said, you know, although we only have six, more can come throughout the year. And so I think that I would recommend we leave that alone, but that may be another one. Go ahead, Terry.

1:34:28 I was just going to say the 18 was when we were doing special events and programming. So the reduction is because special events has been taken out of this. Yeah, so I was a little bit surprised when I said, give me a list of contracts, and there were only six. So it is entirely possible that we come back next year with a request that right sizes this to really what we expect in contracts. But for right now, I think leaving it at the 72 is probably okay.

1:34:57 Once again, it doesn't go anywhere. It just rolls back into the fund balance. Then just a request, a recap of our request and a reminder that the funds, again, unspent remain in the accounts. This is the total that we would like to receive for ongoing program and maintenance funding. I appreciate your comment about reducing complexity and combining Trails End and Whitmore, but it sure is nice to look up there and see.

1:35:29 Precisely how much each costs to maintain. So it's kind of a complexity versus clarity kind of thing. I think that's more of a comment than a quick question. A quick question on the audit. Yes. You said you increased the scope of the testing. Did something come up that triggered that you felt you needed to increase that? Was there some risk? Not to my knowledge. So was that just something you wanted to increase it, or did they recommend it? I think

1:35:59 Again, I wouldn't be speaking from my own knowledge at that point. This is something that had either occurred or was planned before my arrival. It was my understanding that there's going to be a report that's going to be produced so that we can actually kind of see where we stand on it. We should have an audit report. So that's been delivered to... Is it just the audit report that goes to the town or is that a separate one for Measure R and Measure U? Separate for Measure R and Measure U and that has been delivered. It has. Yes. So the audit...

1:36:29 Increase is about 15%. Yeah, that's 500 mH. Huh? That's quite a bit. So if that's been proven, because I thought that was going to be different and there was more, kind of a more in-depth report that was happening. If it hasn't been, then that seems like a pretty big, if it's already been, those reports have already been being produced and that's not changing, that seems like a pretty hefty increase.

1:36:55 But it hasn't increased over many years. You said it hasn't increased over six years, but I was just a little concerned that they felt like they needed to increase the testing because that sounded like maybe something came up. I think with the nature of these funds, it is prudent to do a significant amount of testing. Right. But when it increases from one year to the next, it's usually if you have findings, in my experience. So I just wanted to make sure that it was... Can somebody clarify what testing means in this context? It's a sample. You take, like, you do 10%.

1:37:25 So you'll test expenditures to make sure it has proper support when it was spent on what the restricted funds were supposed to go towards? Sample set, yeah. Sample size increased. Sample it, and then when you find something's an error, you increase your scope of what you test, you have to test more. So that's usually when. So that's just an ongoing? It's an audit, yeah. It's all based on materiality. Yeah, that's exactly correct. It's a function of the audit where you have a sample size.

1:37:54 That will give you a good sense of feel on how things are working. And if you have a concern or fear, usually you expand that. That's one of you. Good question. Just one more quick question on Woodmore. By funding Woodmore maintenance in this way, the county pays half of the maintenance. This doesn't affect that half. We aren't paying more than that. This is just part of the finish of our path. This is just for the track. This doesn't have anything to do with ball fields or the pool.

1:38:22 Right. Sports field. Yeah. And the county does not pay for any part of the track, to my knowledge. Not in that. Yeah. They only pay half of the ball fields in the pool. Further questions? Yeah. I think what we're talking about here is maybe I'm looking for a motion to approve with those two, I guess it was. To bring back some criteria. So with that, again, to.

1:38:57 That we would bring back what some future, how do we want to word it? I would move that we approve continued support for ongoing expenses as outlined here with the two caveats that criteria be developed for the nature of events that are funded for transportation and the nature of equipment that are funded. That's my motion. Okay. So, okay, we have a motion. Do we have a second? I'll second that. Okay.

1:39:28 Any other comments? All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Any public comment? Correct? And I just want to thank Rob. Yeah, thank you. This is kind of the most clarity we've had in this past. It's far more information than we have. Thank you. Really excellent. Okay. Okay, next will be...

1:39:56 A review and consideration for approval of the final draft of the allocation application process. And I'm looking to Terry to kind of walk us through. Or you tell us how you want to have this conversation. How do you want to have this conversation and what outcome? Well, you know, there's not really a lot that has happened since the last time we met. Some of the verbiages.

1:40:25 You know, we've tweaked the things that you guys had talked about and that has been tweaked. Rachel brought forward a project-specific budget. All of this kind of came to us, you know, right at the last minute. Rachel's had personal things going on and I commend her for even getting this to us. There was some information that I have a concern on as far as the budget itself goes.

1:40:55 We've always wanted to kind of know more what admin is. And so just putting stuff in an O&M, we need to break that down a little bit more. But I think that we can do that. I don't think it's going to be a real major thing because I think the actual scope of the budget and how it's put together, how it functions, works quite well. So I think we just need to break it out a little bit more. And I think that's about it. I don't know how we had asked for some testing to happen. I guess that did happen.

1:41:25 But I haven't heard anything about how that worked with this. Did it function? Were there any issues? I don't know. I would have to ask Rich. I guess Juliana? So the online application part? I guess so, yeah. And I tried to blow up the budget template a few times. So it's been sort of tested, but I wouldn't mind another set of eyes to throw stuff in. And so I don't know, maybe Leslie Ann can help and explain anything. Yeah, Juliana, we had her review the application.

1:41:54 Then we met with her to discuss like any, you know, any problems that she saw with it. And mainly it was just kind of like some word choices that were, you know, that she felt were kind of confusing, especially how we asked certain questions on the progress report that we say that should be copied from the original application. And so it was mostly just kind of making sure that those, the language in both of those matched.

1:42:20 You know, because if we're asking for something in here, then it should have the same exact verbiage over here. I think that that was kind of the main thing that, you know. Did she actually go through and fill it out? Yeah, yeah, she went through and kind of filled it out, but not for, you know, or she mostly just kind of, she just kind of.

1:42:42 Filled it out in a vague way, not specifically for Eastern Sierra Symphony, which is who she'd be selling it out for. And so then after we went over the adjustments with her, we've asked her if she'd be willing to try to fill it out again under the idea that she's doing it for Eastern Sierra Symphony. Yeah, because we really were trying to get some testing done and then actually maybe then take that and do it.

1:43:09 Mammoth scoring. Did you guys, did you guys, uh, kind of, why don't we let her, can we let her go do that? I, I don't know. Yeah. I don't know if time-wise we have enough time. I don't know. Give her a weekend. We have, um, the, she printed out a form and, you know, kind of filled out some stuff and I think Rich has that. Okay. So, I guess what we're looking to do then, it sounds like, is to get that feedback, Rich, to incorporate it, I guess, into the documents and get it back to you guys, right? And then, it,

1:43:38 It makes sense. If you're looking for more testing, like for people to really put projects through, let's just get some producers to say, hey, why don't you fill out your application now? Way early. And it'll stand as your application, maybe with a few tweaks. Yeah, we were trying to do that and then to actually then take our scoring process and, you know, does it jive? Does it work?

1:44:02 And so we haven't done that at this point because we haven't gotten any of this back. And so our biggest problem is timing at this point once again. So if we don't take this now, it can be approved with, you know, maybe those caveats and then we're going to have to go back and do this because we are going to have to, this opens up to the public in February.

1:44:31 I mean, I agree. I think it's fundamental that we do some testing. I can see it would be difficult for any producer to put in the upcoming project as a test because that seems scary. But could one of our producers from the past put in last year's project? Just look for a couple volunteers to do. I'll do one. I mean, I'm just, from the producer's point of view, I'm just saying why ask him to do two.

1:44:56 No, no, I totally agree. That's what, but I, but I would be, I think I would be reluctant given, I mean, some of our, some of the contention that's happened. Yeah, just maybe the way it would be circular. Yeah, like, oh, well, I put it in and then I wasn't approved. Was it because I tested? Was it because? I'll leave my last year's application. But that's what I mean. So somebody's willing to do last year's and run it through this. I'll throw it in and you guys can come back. Then we can bring it in for, in February meeting for. Yeah, just throw it at me and I can do it for the week.

1:45:22 Well, it's supposed to open up, so the intent, if we look at the timeline here. February 1st. Is that January, that Rich would be talking to the applicants and kind of going through that this is what we're going to expect from you. My understanding is he was starting to do that. Yeah. And then as of February 1st that it would come forward. So, you know, I guess the basic application.

1:45:50 As long as everything tests and everything functions, you know, can be moved forward. Feels like we're like 95% there. Yeah, we are. We've just seen a couple little sets of eyes. You guys went out and asked for comments and we gave some last time. I think maybe what we're driving to here is an approval.

1:46:09 With approval, with some testing still to be done where there might be some small, because really it's going to be small tweaks. I don't think there's going to be any major, overall it would be some small tweaks, probably in language, maybe how something is organized in there, you know, something like that. I'm perfectly fine with that, an interesting allocation committee to kind of see it through. Do you want me to do it as a first year event or a repeating event? Does it make a difference?

1:46:34 It does make a difference. You can do it. Would you just stick things in both? I have. Your one and your two because I want to see it. Okay. Okay. I can do it like everyone has a Tipperfest and one is Rock and Ryan and put them in that way and you can see how they feed out. Yeah. We can take the scoring process too and work through that. Got a motion on the table. We have a second. Actually, can I just ask one more question of Lesley-Ann? Lesley-Ann, do you, I know there have been some limitations with the program. Do you feel like applicants can

1:47:02 Fill it in and just as long as they save their information in like a Word document or something on their computer, their answers, that it would be okay. One of the issues that apparently happened that we have not been able to fix is that you can't save the application if you're in the midst of working on it. Right now it's set up where if you use the same computer in the same browser,

1:47:33 And so your application accidentally closes. It should be still saved on there. But you'd have to, you know, you can't, like, change your location or whatever. So there's kind of a save right now, but it's not total foolproof. Last meeting about investigating a solution to some of those problems with maybe, I mean, I think I remember a comment saying, God, there's a bunch of these out there. Yeah. There's a lot of other.

1:48:00 forms out there, and they're fairly expensive in comparison to what we have going on right now. And even with that, it's like not...

1:48:14 Yeah, it's just kind of like, is it really worth spending a couple hundred, you know, a hundred bucks a month or a couple hundred bucks a year for, you know, something when, you know, a hundred a year, I think definitely a couple hundred a month. A couple hundred a month doesn't start. Yeah. Well, but if, I mean, assuming that we don't have the bandwidth and the timing to get that set up, let's just be sure that we make a note at the very top of the form. Which we have right now.

1:48:40 You know, do your application in Word and then paste it into these forms so that if anything happens, you've got it. Yeah, that's what I have on there that, you know, it's advised to fill out the form in Word first and copy and paste your answers into the application. You know, but there is kind of a little bit of a fail-safe where it's like if you start filling it out and everything closes, you should be able to open it up and have things saved, which, you know, a couple people, that was really their only issue last year was, you know,

1:49:10 They would close the browser accidentally and then their, you know, information was no longer there. Thank you. So I'd be willing to second that motion and then... Okay, so we have a motion, we have a second? Yeah, the only thing I would say is A, fantastic work and this is great and I think that, you know, the more that we can communicate with our stakeholders and the public that this is still an ongoing process because I would like to see in the coming years, I think this is terrific for fiscal year 16, 17.

1:49:42 And I would love to see in the coming year establishing what we just did with the town having a rolling fund so that it's much more streamlined so that the timeline can be narrowed so that it doesn't have to go back to council for approval. And I think we need to begin to rebrand it as a granting process so that we have a grant fund. Because I don't think...

1:50:05 I don't think our grantees need to be so in the weeds with what is the allocation thing. I mean, we should have a pretty simple grant application. We should be able to go through it as an allocation committee and give grants. There is some type of problem with the word grant in our application, and that has to do with both measures R and measures U. We may not use that word. That's fair. So in any case, somehow I think there's a way to brand this in a way that's simpler, that people get, that we can bring more stakeholders into the fold.

1:50:35 But I'm not saying we need to do it now. I think the work that's been done is terrific, and let's ride it out. Can we make the motion? Shields did. And David seconded. Any other comments? Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Okay. Motion passes. Moving along. Okay. Next is review and consideration for approving Measure U special project funding for the Winter Adventure Series program.

1:51:10 You've got the application in the packet. David, do you want to take us through this or who? So Jonathan Silva told me that he was the one who put this in. This is, I mean, essentially it's very much like what we approved but then had to change due to conflict of interest. I think the timing is now very tight. I mean, we were looking at this back in December.

1:51:38 So I think the dates on here are probably a little unrealistic. I did talk to Jonathan today to see if indeed he thought he could pull off four nights at this budget for this season and he felt like he could and I would be planning on helping him to book some of those events and they have a new ED who's fired up and he seems very on board with it. He likes this program and wants to run it and it fits in their wheelhouse. So I think

1:52:08 It looks to me like the way, I mean, I just saw this earlier today for the first time, but it's basically the same budget, the same parameters as what we talked about before, so I'm guessing that out of this we would get four to six nights of programming in that auditorium, probably February, March. Some public nights on Wednesdays or Thursdays that would be open to the public.

1:52:38 I mean, would the dates slide a little bit? I think the dates would slide. I think it starts, well, it was initially framed as starting with the Backcountry Film Festival, which is next Thursday. So that's happening. And that would be the platform where we would say, okay, we have funding, we're going to be doing these nights, you know, we'd set the nights, and then we'd book those nights, and it's doable. Start letting people know about it. Yeah. And there's budget in there for marketing, and these guys are really good at it, and I mean, Jonathan's...

1:53:09 It was a sold out event, the last one. I think this next week will be sold out too. Reminder that we've already looked at this in one version. So I'm open to taking a motion. This is a special project. Yeah, this is a request for $7,950. Oh, and that's the other part. And we're giving, I mean, what the recommendation is to give half of it. That's right. And ECEA would come in for the other half.

1:53:39 Yes, so I guess that was going to be my one question, is that 50% match. So you see a match between the in-kind and the in-kind. Thank you for that. So it's only $3,900. $3,900 out of our special project fund. Yes. So I'll entertain a motion. For Measure U. For Measure U. Okay. Gary, so moved? Okay. Here, a second. A second.

1:54:10 Rachel seconds. Any further comments? No, just want to make sure, you know, when we do it this quickly, it's going to be successful. I kind of feel like we're just real quick hard, and it's just kind of last minute, and I recognize this is our special nature, but a little bit more breathing time. For sure. And to be fair, that breathing time was compressed because of that conflict of interest, and that's something that we shouldn't encounter moving forward. Yeah, I mean,

1:54:42 I think we saw both the conflict of interest and the factors at any time, which were the two issues. It was a straight ask. I don't have a problem approving it, but I think that we should ask for what those programs are going to be and make sure that they will be delivered so that we can approve this now upon the programs.

1:55:08 You know, that they are going to be able to pull off this timeline, I guess, and that this is the programs that they're going to deliver so that those come forward. So you're saying contingent upon seeing the schedule of events, essentially? Performance report. Well, no, because then that means they've already done it. That's after the fact. Well, the one thing I would say is I think if you, at this late stage, were to put that caveat that somehow this board, when in three weeks, has to see that line up.

1:55:36 And the idea of booking those acts without knowing that you have the money in order to show the board. No, that's not what I'm saying. No, I'm not saying that at all. I'm just saying that we're going to approve this money, but you're going to have to bring forward that you're going to be able to bring these programs forward. So if it comes down to the fact that, you know, I'm only going to be able to bring one that's just too tight, then no. So this money, the...

1:56:05 Total allocation is contingent on delivery. Delivering. Set events. Absolutely. Four to six events. Absolutely. And I'm planning and will commit to sitting down with Jeff with the new ECAED and with Jonathan who will be running the program and spelling that out and saying, look, let's make sure.

1:56:26 Before we take any of this money that you guys are able to pull that off. And that they're the type of events, the quality events that you're looking at, not just throwing something. Yeah, well and ECS certainly has a vested interest in continuing this relationship and expanding and so they're going to face the music too and say, you know, yes we can or can't in this timeline. And then that's when the performance report would come in and if we didn't pull it off and obviously it affects them.

1:56:52 In the future, so. And David, on your food and beverage budget, you should just add a zero and move a decimal over because $150 is not going to get you food and beverage. It might be even cups and napkins, but it's not going to get you beer and wine. Well, it's going to be donated beer. So it's all donated, so it doesn't matter. Okay. Okay. That's all I wanted to make sure. So I'm okay with that. I just, as long as they are able to pull off a quality event. So, at this short, that's key. Cool. And David, just a quick question to you.

1:57:22 Seed cushions, I think that's a brilliant idea, and using them for all six events. What will happen afterwards? Will it get donated to ECF for future events? Do you know that, or is that too much of a... I don't know that, but if that's in the budget, I'm assuming that that would go... For next year? The idea would be that it's an investment that would be ongoing for that facility. I think we're trying at every juncture to invest in that facility so that it's...

1:57:47 I think that's my own, so I'd be happy to sell them. You can rent them. You can buy them and rent them out. Seriously. Yeah. Okay, any other comments? Questions? Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. I guess I should abstinence, probably.

1:58:12 I like it. Yeah, great idea. All right, guys, we're closing in on the finish line here. Committee reports, we'll just go down the list here. Fund development and communications, we haven't really met. I don't think there's any. Yeah, we're in a definite holding pattern right now. We talked a lot about fund development in those sessions. Allocations, we just heard from. Do you guys have anything else you'd like to share?

1:58:41 Okay, trails committee. Yeah, trails committee, the biggest thing, there was a lot of work done over the last month by Joel and a lot of the MLTPA staff wrangling all the different agreements to get the winter trail grooming project up and running. There was a last minute district ranger.

1:59:10 Up against the wall kind of thing that seems to have been ironed out. The trails are being groomed now, weeds, but it was a complex negotiation between four different organizations and the Forest Service, and amazingly, they got it done over the holidays, and it's up and running. So, quick question. Yeah. Is the same people actually grooming are still responsible for grooming, or has that changed? That has changed. It's now MLTPA is responsible for the grooming. They're renting the...

1:59:39 Dean from Friends of the Inyo. Yes. And there was an insurance piece that had to be covered. There was an employee that had to be trained and hired. There was the permit with the Forest Service that had to be done. The other... Go ahead. Because Forest Service used to go to that big machine first and then come back to the other machine. And also another thing that's shifted is the permit with the Forest Service used to be with Friends of the Inyo. Now the permit is between the town and Forest Service, which gives us some more...

2:00:09 The only other piece of that that I think is important to note that along with that negotiation, a formal request was made to allow backbikes onto those trails. As you will recall, MLR signed onto a letter to the Forest Supervisor and somehow the District Ranger didn't hear about that.

2:00:37 So we needed to open up a line of communication with the district ranger as well, and the forest supervisor was copied on that, so we'll see how that plays out. But ideally, I mean, what we'd like to see is some fat bike grooming that would be contiguous with that Nordic grooming. And the only other thing I would say is let's try and use it because I think if we demonstrate use, we have a greater leverage to move forward and to maybe expand that facility and move it elsewhere.

2:01:07 It's a very inexpensive program for the town. It's a great amenity. I did get to use it on Saturday over at Shady Rest, and I guess only one of the trails had been groomed at that point, and I went in and spoke with the visitor center, and they sort of mentioned the complexity of the agreement, but I think it's wonderful to have free cross-country skiing for a community, especially in a year like this where we have the snow to do it. One thing I think would be fantastic is if somewhere on...

2:01:36 Whether it's the MLTPA website or our website, but a grooming report. Yes. So you can see, oh, it's been freshly groomed. So we had a conversation about that, and there is, we should be able to develop that. That's something I've given. So our go-to Mammoth Lakes Trail System, it's mammothtrails.org, should be the clearinghouse for all information to do with the trail system.

2:02:02 And if you click on the, if you go to the homepage, mammothtrails.org, and you click on Trail News in the upper right-hand corner, that has a recent update about skate skiing and grooming and such. And we did talk about trying to post a very specific grooming report on that page. So we're on it. Fantastic. You know the kind of apps that they have, like live interaction, where like, I was just on this and it was just done, that's the minute you're talking about.

2:02:32 Oh, nice. It should be really cool. Nice. Yeah, I know it's for the trails that are groomed for snowmobiles, they have like a live webcam, it's not a webcam, but like a live, you know, a live feed where you can see actually where the groomer is. Yeah. So. I don't know if we need it to that complexity. No, there's a lot of that kind of capacity with the web-based, it's very mobile-friendly, the mammothtrails.org, so if you get, like, I was skate skiing out there.

2:02:59 on the snowmobile trails over the weekend. And you can, you know, you can find yourself, you can see exactly where you are, you can look at the system, it's pretty sophisticated. So, and you did that through the mammothtrails.org? Website, it's on my phone. David, was there any discussion about the hoop perry? There was, indeed. The what? The hoop perry. Yeah, we upped the line item in the budget. There's some work toward...

2:03:27 Providing, I think for two of the trails, for Borrow Pit and maybe Mill City, I can't remember exactly what all of it was, but there's work being done on providing some bags and some receptacles and there's aggressive work happening there. It was bad out by the propane tanks. It's bad out by the propane tanks. And then I proposed, I don't know if it's going to happen, but I asked if we could do a kickoff.

2:03:55 Kind of like, hey, you know, President's Day weekend, get away from the crowds, come out to a party, shitty rest, and kick off all the grooming that they've done out there, but we'll see if it can happen or not. And we can run it through the elementary school in the middle of the junior high and promote it that way, but we'll see. And we're working with, we're trying to develop some trail host programming. We've got the beginnings of that going on this winter so that there are people out there mentioning, hey, is your dog?

2:04:24 I was going to say, how do you, with the receptacles, who's emptying this? It would be with Mammoth Disposal. There's a, there's the talk about doing some kind of, I don't know, $40. Yeah, I don't know the, I don't know the ins and outs of it. Yeah, we're trying to do that. But we've recognized that you can't just put bags out there. You have to put bags and a place to put them. Oh, because they just, yeah. And, and you have to. Even if you do that, you can still leave the bags. Exactly. Exactly. Amazing. It's a start. Yeah. It's an educational process. Yeah.

2:04:53 You know, that needs to be a public announcement, too. You know, you have to be common sense, but please pick up your dogs. Right, right. Because it's interesting, I mean, I think... And don't just leave it in the bag. I think a lot of people don't think, like, okay, well, you know, the bears, the mountain lions, everybody does their business out here, why can't my dog? And I think that there needs to be education about it getting into our water table, and I think that's what people don't understand. Oh, and the, you know, right now, there's no, you know, there's very few places for when dogs go out.

2:05:22 Walking. A lot of dogs are going into people's driveways. Yes. And then the bobcats and snow removal equipment are just spraying all into all of our neighborhoods. And on that note, it's something that I noticed when I was in Salt Lake City last week. Up Big Cottonwood Canyon and Little Cottonwood Canyon, which obviously see much greater use than we do, dogs have been prohibited in those canyons.

2:05:46 And that was a forest order with the water district because of the impact on the watershed. So that's something we can have the carrot of, you know, here are the bags and here's the receptacle and the stick needs to be there that, you know what, we could shut this whole thing down and no pets allowed. Great point. Yeah, because that would be awful. People need to be responsible. So that's trails committee, I think. Thank you. You know, one thing I think we need to do,

2:06:24 Hunting around our website, and it's, we need to have a direct link, I mean, we have a link to the mammothtrails.org, but it's, it's under, it says lead agency, and it says Joel's name and title, and then it has just website. There's no real portal that says, hey, want to get out on the trails, want to learn more, come here, and it should be on our homepage. It should be. That's something, I'll talk to Rich about it, and we'll make that happen.

2:06:51 And it does sound like, do you want to give a report on the communications audit? That's something that's coming up, right? The website. Yeah, like the various town websites? Yeah. The whole idea is, you know, to create consistency among all the different websites. And so we'd have all the nomenclatures the same throughout all. And we're trying to find the platform for that. John Wentworth is actually heading that up.

2:07:19 So, it's going to be a contractual arrangement with all the NGOs going forward, just to let you know, be part of the future contract, that we are consistent in the way we present things and the information we put out there from the town website and all the NGOs. So, I mean, that's basically bottom line. That's great. Yeah, I just think that's smart. The problem is, you know, you've got four different websites going on, and they're

2:07:50 And it's really a big deal as it relates to the trails because the Forest Service has requirements. We're all partners. And that's a great point and that's why this audit will be really important because the MammothTrails.org site is approved. Every page on there, every piece of information is approved by the Forest Service. So that's the one that most people should be linking to for trails information.

2:08:22 Just Leslie Ann's putting up a piece that staff and Aaron Decker, our kind of resident designer, put together, and David and I had a little editorial input. Just an end of year review, kind of what we've done, kind of look back. You guys will see this. They'll get it out on social and everything, but it's pretty cool, and it really details all the work the trails committee's done, this in the field section.

2:08:51 All the excursions, like out to meet the Kings, to meet Andy Walsh, and all kind of that, to expand our exposure. So it's a pretty good piece, a good wrap-up, and it'll start getting pushed out through our channels. Great, perfect. I feel like we probably should put the shipping off sooner, so let's return to that. Right. Okay, well we can still admit it. Yes, for sure. That's a good point.

2:09:19 Okay, and then final committee, performing arts ad hoc? Yeah, there hasn't been much over the holidays, but I did get an email this morning from Evan Russell. The only really substantive piece of information was that indeed Rose Steele, who was the consultant that they were looking at, who's a theater consultant with pretty significant theater experience, they're going to hire her. Mammoth Lakes Foundation will hire her.

2:09:48 Her four main objectives are, one, determine critical physical characteristics needed for an optimum facility, analyze budget costs for building and operations, modify budget and building to align, and review programming and uses to establish a baseline for design. So what I hear in that is them moving toward answering some of our concerns about it.

2:10:10 Feasibility and the appropriateness of this structure. And she is scheduled now. She was supposed to be here last week and got canceled because of weather. She's scheduled now to come to Mammoth on Friday, January 27th. So those of you who are interested in this should schedule that. They're going to schedule a series of meetings with stakeholders and resident artists on Friday, January 27th.

2:10:34 That will discuss the current concept plan, sample design additions to improve function, space allocations, analysis of design function versus budget. That's the update on that. That's cool. Okay. Thank you. All right. Folks, that's it. We're not going to do the finance reports this time around. Last item is town council liaison request for information to report to town council. What do you want me to say?

2:11:06 Yeah, right. Well, we're trying to move fast on some of this. Where are we, how far are we getting on with the idea of the overall messaging? Are you going to do that?

2:11:27 Well, we actually have ongoing meetings coming up with Darren Dinsmore, who's coming into town the first week in February. There's a stakeholders meeting going to be happening, the first part, I think it's February 1st, actually. So things are moving forward, it's kind of...

2:11:58 Behind the scenes right now, everybody's talking. One of the key components, of course, is the shady rest parcel, you know, and how that plays out in the revitalization. So, yeah, there's a lot of stuff going on in the backgrounds right now. Hopefully, in the near future, we'll be able to report out. All right, so I was hoping for two hours in the public.

2:12:26 I missed it by 19 minutes. All right. Pretty good. Well done. So let's adjourn. Thanks a lot, guys. Thank you. And I'll communicate with everybody about the kind of upcoming schedules and stuff. Okay. Cool.