TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2017

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

· recording 1 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

110 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

5:34 Where's my TV camera? Is it going to be showing this? Is it going to be talking to the wall? How's it going to work? Okay, are we live? Yeah. Greetings and welcome. It's Monday morning. I hope you're all doing well. We're on TV land, so greetings and welcome. Rich Bocci, Executive Director, Matt. Quick intros around the room. Who are you representing? Hi there, I'm Kendra Knight, and I represent Lola. We're making, we're providing the opportunity.

6:27 I call them birthday books. We're the same birthday. He's had a couple years on it. We had the same birthday. Just a few. Just a few. Three. Okay. I was out of time with your office. Miss Dewey Ann. Thank you. And who are you and what brings you by today? And we have, we're making a transition with staff. Everybody knows who are you, young lady? Oh, I'm Wesley Ann Hoxie.

7:02 Leslie, you've been with us for 19 months now, and you're making a transition to Mountain Lab with Scott McGuire? Yeah, technically it's Fond of Bags with Scott McGuire, but German backpack making company. Totally cool. But I can still live here in town. And who's this new young lady you're going to introduce for us? This is Emily. I'm Emily Woods. I'm the new program administrator for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So we'll have an overlap of a week for the ladies here. Kind of get ourselves over.

7:32 Okay? So good morning, ingredients. We're going to start out, we're going to do three simple things today. We'll do a quick overview, MLR 15-16, our highlights, kind of paint that picture, remind people what we did and who we are. We're going to do a little bit of a quick, quick summary of the budget, because we're in the budget cycle right now. 15-16, looking projected 17-8. Monday, our board begins Monday the 6th, we have a conflict. We're going to start looking at the budget. Aquatic centers are deep right now. We'll workshop with USA SWIM.

8:25 And as Luke Robitaille has said to us that we visit with him at the LA Kings, one-time capital is a bit of a challenge, but the biggest challenge is on the list once you build a bar on you. So with that, let's roll through this. Let's start with a short little video here. All right, this is a quick little year in summary. Let me finish this first. That was our soft end-of-the-year campaign, raised a little less than $1,000. You know, as we transition, MLR has to begin to really focus on

10:52 Fundraising, fund development programs and projects. You look at the projects and what they cost out there, you know, it's going to cost some money. So you had a clarification of the comment, didn't you? Yeah, yeah. So you were saying that, you know, I just want to make sure that I'm clear. That Measure U and R wants to help capital capital. If we build it with R and U, we need to sustain it with R. There's only a certain number of projects that R and U can build.

11:25 Oh, okay, okay. It gets to the point where you spend, you can't, you can build it, but you can't sustain it. So it gets to the point to say, we're going to spend an X factor, there's going to be a Y factor to sustain one. We can't afford that. And you think about it, $1.9 million on an annual basis sounds like a lot of money. Oh, I just got that. Okay, so let's do a budget, give you an idea of how we spend this money. So our new budget, this is for 16-17, it's about $1.9 million on an annual basis. It's a tax base, a 4-H base sign.

12:05 Tourism, etc. Trails, it's about $300,000. It's about 16% of our budget. Admin, MLR, Stat, it's about $300,000. It's about 16%. Myself, that's Emily, Leslie, at this point, and Joel, our trails coordinator. Allocations is $1,000 for events we're talking about today. $115,000. It was $115,000 last year. $115,000 again. $25,000 and $25,000. So it's $165,000. That's about 9% of the budget.

12:43 It doesn't include special events. Town Council has approved $125,000 for special events. And that the town manager will be unfolded in the next couple of weeks. And then what's that? So that's what? $25,000. 10%. That's different. It's not. It's special events. So that's the name? So it's still the town. So the town has no end. So general fund. Correct. $100,000 this past year for the MAC design, which we've got. The town of Mammoth Lakes has ongoing costs.

13:19 The parks, transit, audit, processing applications, about $72,000, that's 4%. We spent $55,000 this past year to finish Trails End Park and give the bell-shaped parcel wetland delineation, which is about 3%. And about 53% is right now on capital reserves. For the use facility, about a $7,000, maybe $8,000 right now. I'm hearing it from $7,000 to $11,000. Gap on those projects, we've got to find a way to fill some. $7,000 to $11,000.

13:57 Seven to a million dollars. Oh, a million. I think it's a thousand. Yeah, yes, yes. I think it's a thousand. So it's a good conversation with that group. Okay, so that's kind of where we are. So I want to walk through, so far so good? Okay. I want to walk through this application, the timeline. As with anything, we're going to continue to modify stuff. You know, you learn things every time you do something. So how do you make this? First workshop, get some new information, second workshop, some good questions come up. Little by little.

14:30 So it's always a work in progress. So let's walk through this. I'm going to go through, I'm not going to read it to you, but we're going to go through at a pretty good pace here. Okay, the cover page really is the allocation process. As you're aware of, we did two allocations this year. We did one in September and funded that at this point. We realized last year that all of a sudden, it was Shura specifically,

14:58 That people are getting funded at the end of the year instead of in front of the fiscal year. So right now we did the first allocation in September, October, just got approved. That's for fiscal year 16-17, from July 1st, past July 1st, to this June 30th. Now we're doing this allocation process to start July 1st, 17, to go to June 30, 18. So we're trying to get you money in front of the curve.

15:25 Okay? This way you can plan accordingly. Some of you guys are doing programming. For some of us that have been doing this before, you're not, you'll do the application, but you'll be asking probably for three years worth of programming. Year one, year two, and year three. So you're not doing the application each year. You're just doing the performance report. We've had these conversations, but I just want to keep that rolling. Kendra. Application do we need with this funding cycle?

15:55 Reapply again, or did we already get the three-year? This is now new. No, this is brand new. It's a new process altogether. So this time we do the three-year? Correct. Correct. Correct. And for the most part, the applications had some minor modifications, so the experienced people in the room have done this before. It should be, I think, a fairly painless process.

16:20 Okay? As we walk through this. Okay? So I'm not going to read this whole thing, but you begin to see the timeline on the leaderboard right now. It goes through when we debriefed, we revised the application, it went to the board in January, now we're sitting in February. Oops, scooted too quick on me. Now we're sitting in February. One of the challenges staff had last time was that it got turned around in 10 days. It was very, very difficult for us.

16:47 We're doing the workshops, engaging the community. We're recording this today. People can come back and look at it. Remember, this is for, and we'll look at the categories. It's not special events. Special events is unrestricted town general fund money that the town manager is going to work with those producers in the next couple weeks. There's a sense of urgency out there. The window will open February 1st, so it'll close February 20th. You have a whole month.

17:12 The sooner you get this stuff in, the sooner we can sit down on one-on-one to clarify things, to make sure they're clean. The biggest challenge, like with anything, is budget stuff. So we want to be in a position to sit down and produce a specific and say, you've done this before, this is what went well, let's regroup on some of this stuff. The month of March is when the board will look at it, the sub-committee will look at it, the board then will take action in early April, town council in late April, so we can start doing contracts in May, so you know how much money you have allocated, hopefully before we get to June 1st.

17:42 This part of the budget, the annual budget cycle, so you're good to go. I know what I got for July 1. I'm in front of the curve at this point in time. And for some of us doing the three years, you're saying, okay, this is what I'm going to get for year 1, 2, and 3. You can start doing some long-term budget planning, which we think is important for programs. Making sense? Okay? So that's what that cover page just said. Okay, so we're going to go through our next page here. Okay, scoot down. Radio check 1, 2.

18:17 Okay, so we're going to go to the application. I want to point us to, let's start on page two. We put in an executive summary, which is a cover page here. And as you're aware of, MLR has a strategic document.

18:33 The six pillars. As you look at your request for funding, make sure you're following those six pillars. Where does it fit within that strategic plan? People have great ideas, but if it's not embedded in that strategic plan somewhere, we're going to say great idea, but it doesn't fit the frame. I'm trying to be narrow. And more specifically, we have a broad objective for this allocation cycle. Allocations will be recommended or funds invested to create

19:00 Implement and support a branded high-performance destination that includes a thriving arts and culture community and enhanced recreation opportunities. That's the broad objective. I look at the people in this room right now. You folks have done a good job of being within that frame, so I don't think that's a challenge. Then we went through and looked at the allocation overview. I'm not going to read all those pieces, but you see the purpose. Talk about no supplanting of this.

19:27 General eligibility requirements. It's an economic opportunity for the community. Public use. Talk about some infrastructure. Align with the above stated broad objective. And we have three allocation categories. It's programming, capital projects, and special projects. It's not special events. Allocation submission. We're having this. This is our third workshop today.

19:50 The window will open on February 1st. It will be on the MLR website. It is a web-based application. We're not going to take handwritten stuff. You have a whole month. The sooner you get this stuff in, the sooner we can look at it, we can engage you to say, you know, please clarify. Go a little deeper for me. I don't understand this. You know, we're here to provide a service. How do we make this easier? And the four of us in this room in this application, we're on the block a couple times on this, so I think we're getting tighter on it.

20:19 Application basics. You know, we've got a checklist for you. We have one inclusion. We call match component this year. We're really trying to leverage these funds. Given it's a 50-50 match, at least 25% of the total must be a cash match. The other 25% may be in-kind. So if you want a dollar from me, you need to bring me a quarter, and you need to have 25 cents an in-kind match, okay? We're trying to really leverage these funds. Yeah.

20:57 But, no, at least 25% has to be cash. At least 25% of the request. Okay? And 25% of the request has to be in-kind. Some people come in and it's all in-kind. Some people come in and say, I don't have anything to match, I just want your money. We need to leverage this. Okay? So what happens to the other 50%? That's where MLR is going to fill in for you. Oh, I see. I gotcha. Okay. Okay.

21:22 Okay, so the match component and then the multi-year awards we talked about, right? A new program may not apply for multi-year funding until the second year producing the program. We want to confirm what you're doing, that it's working well. And a multi-year program must have been a performance report yearly, and you all have done the performance reports in the past. Contract reporting, performance report, it's now February. You're applying for funds for the next fiscal year.

21:49 If you finish your program already, you would do the final performance report. You may still have a program or a project that's still in motion. You haven't closed it just yet. The whole program may not finish until May or early June. So you're going to give us a progress report. It's a simpler abbreviated performance report.

22:10 That goes back in reviews. What did you apply for? Everything's still the same. Give us a progress report. Where are you? What are you doing? Et cetera. This way, you'll submit that with the application. We say to ourselves, the application came in. They're not done with the previous year of funding, but they're requesting funding for the next year. Performance report looks like everything's good to go at this point. We look at it. Looks good. We put you in the queue. If it looks good, we put you in the queue. If it doesn't look good, we say thank you, but no thank you. Looks good, we put you in the queue.

22:40 When the performance report comes in, the final performance report comes in, we say good and we move it forward. Make sense? Okay? Because we realize that, you know, the budget cycle takes a couple of months. If we give you a month to do this, a month to look at it, town council another month, you're looking at three or four months. So if we don't start now, we're going to find ourselves behind the curve. Okay? Making sense so far, everybody? Yes, sir. Okay.

23:28 Funding cycle goes from July 1st to June 30th. If you did something Labor Day weekend and it's done, Memorial Day weekend, no, we're going to evaluate your application based on the progress report. And there may be some one-offs that we can't make the recommendation for funding until early June until the outcome of the performance report comes in. Good? Okay? Yes, ma'am.

24:02 Programming we're doing right now as well for the 15-16 that we just submitted this report since it's not done. Correct. Okay. You'll be doing, most will be doing progress reports right now. Okay. Right? You got funding for 15-16. Okay. Right? Now you're looking at funding for 16-18. Right. You got funding for 16-17. They're still in progress as this application window opens. You're going to give me a progress report with your application. Got it. Okay?

24:34 And since you guys are the senior experience producers as you do this, I'm sure there'll be a number of questions. Rich, I need an hour. Rich, I need an hour. Sit down and walk through stuff. Okay? Okay? Okay, page four. It's our application checklist. We try to make it easy for you. You know, it's like every time you look at stuff, how do we modify this process? So the checklist on page four goes through and just gives you the heads up on stuff. These are the things you need to do.

25:03 A little X, make sure you get it done for me. The section number, the pages, the title, and the special notes. Okay? There I say, please review the strategy to ensure your funding request meets the criteria. Application deadline is February 28th, 2017, at 5 p.m. Electronic submissions on the MLR website are mandatory. So that walks through, in terms of special notes, what we need to do. Okay?

25:32 Let's go to the strategy itself. Starting on page five. Page five, you'll begin to see. We're going to go, we'll start with, we understand that MLR has a strategic plan. There are six pillars. That's the bigger frame. Mammoth Lakes Recreation is a nonprofit organization that is committed to preserving and enriching the quality of life for residents and visitors by ensuring the strategic use

25:56 of measures R, U, and additional funding sources to develop and support recreation, arts and culture, mobility, capital projects, and special projects, and our broad objective. I mentioned this before, but I want to keep coming back to that. That's the tighter frame. Allocations will be recommended or funds invested to create, implement, and support a branded high-performance destination that includes a thriving arts and culture community and enhanced recreation opportunities. And then we get into our allocation categories. Number one is programming.

26:26 A. Support and increase opportunities for participation by diverse populations in recreation and arts and culture experiences. B. Support diverse recreation, arts and culture experience, including nationally known talent and emerging trends. C. Programming allocations may be considered for multiple years funding, not to exceed three years. Performance is reviewed on an annual basis for continued funding. D. Measure U funding for fiscal year 17-18 is $115,000 for programming.

26:56 That's our allocation. Same allocation as this past cycle. Capital projects. All phases of capital projects to support recreation, arts, and culture, and mobility, including planning, financing, construction, operations, and maintenance. Our capital projects right now, the multi-use facility, the ice rink, the community center, and the park, and we're probably looking at $7, $8, $9 million in that complex right now. How do we leverage our new sponsors, grants, et cetera?

27:25 Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. It's somewhere between $7 and $11 million at this point. Is there a capital gap that we need to fill at this point in time? Correct. But if the cost of the MAC is greater than $7 million, there's a capital gap. How are we going to fill that capital gap? Is the foundation going to come and say, MLR, will you help us with sponsorships, grant writing, et cetera, to fill that gap?

27:56 The Outdoor Performing Arts Center is another piece. You've got your short-term looking at Sam's Wood site. You're looking at Canyon. MLR Board will look at that, short and long-term, and then Town Council in March. And then the Aquatic Center is on the table right now, you know, looking at what do we do with Whitmore? Do we do something with Snow Creek? You know, what happens if Allen Walks in and he's with U.S. Swimming says, I want to build an aquatic center. I got $10 million. Let's build it. The question's going to be,

28:24 How do we sustain it? What are the operational costs? So all that goes into the equation. So that's the capital stuff. And then special projects. Special projects is one-time money. It's like seed money. I got a great, creative, innovative idea. I don't know if it's going to work, but it's got some merit. I've vetted it a little bit in the community, and I think it's kind of a fun thing to do. You know, I've got a bunch of guys working with a disc golf course. You know, they wanted to chat the other day. 42 of their best friends came to visit with me. It's like it has some legs on it.

28:51 That would be an example of one-time money for a special project. They're vetting it. They're going through the filter right now. So we've got $25,000 set aside for Measure U, $25,000 set aside for Measure R. That money is part of this process, but somebody may come up with another idea somewhere down the road. Say, I've got a great idea. I think it's a special project. They'll do an application.

29:14 The special projects can apply for, the producers can apply for funds not later than 10th of every month to the Executive Director for the following board meeting. We'll continue to allocate those funds based on the broad objective, based on innovative, creative ideas that people want to get some seed money to do some special projects. When that money's gone, that money's gone. Okay, so those are the three categories. Special events is not a part of this. That's town general fund money.

29:42 Town manager, myself, will be meeting with that group in the next couple weeks to kind of process that. Okay? Good so far? I'm going to go to page six. I'm going to keep rolling. I don't want to read too much, but I want to be fairly detailed on this stuff, especially since we're recording this workshop so people can go back and look at it. Page six, it talks about eligibility. I want to make sure we look at number five. No allocations will be awarded that may appear as a gift to public funds. Requirements.

30:14 Want to go down and remind ourselves requirement number five on page six. There's a 50-50 match for all categories with a mandatory 25% cash match. Another 25% maybe in-kind services. And then go to page seven. Question. Yes, ma'am. When we get to section five and six, I'll point that out to you. Yes, it is. Okay. Page seven.

30:51 Priorities given to but not required. Allocation proposals that are matching funds, sponsorships with quantifiable in-kind contributions, organizations, individuals that have proven history of effective and efficient delivery of program services. This is public money. It is public trust. We had one producer last year, came in, great ideas, but it just fell flat on its face. So we've got to do it. We need to be a little more diligent in our vetting at this point in time.

31:19 Proposed project addresses that identify public benefit for people living, working, or visiting in Mammoth Lakes. Projects can demonstrate strong community support and incomplete capital projects are aligned with the MLR strategy document. For example, an example of that would be we needed some additional funds to do the wetland delineation study in the bell-shaped parcel. We needed additional funds to finish trails end park. You know, those are examples of they fit within our strategies. Okay?

31:47 Allocation process, page 7. There's a mistype on that first bullet. It'll be available electronically by February 1st, not January 1st. So February 1st, email our website. This should be up and running. And the rest kind of explains the allocation process. Accountability, we talked about already. We've got the performance report on the progress reports and the funding disbursements. As you know, these are town funds. So once it is approved by town council,

32:15 Then Mr. Stuart Brown, who oversees the contractual, the creation of the contracts on these processes, then works with you as the producer to gather those documents. Okay? And so let's go to page 8 and 9. Page 8 and 9 really is the application. It's two pages. The other stuff is all the fluff stuff, making sure we understand where we're going. So let's go to page 8 and 9. Pull this up. Okay, allocation, accountability.

32:46 Alrighty, once again, applications are due February 28th at 5. All applications required to be submitted on the web-based application. Applications that are late. Just because you sent it to us doesn't mean we got it. So I would strongly urge. I sent it, Rich. Did you get it? I didn't get it. You know, don't wait till the last minute. You know, we'll be here at the 5 o'clock, but sometimes things get lost in cyberspace.

33:14 You know, it is an online web-based thing, but just, we sent it, we haven't gotten it, you know, whether we have to run something over, but let's make sure we get them in. Incomplete or not submitted to the web-based application will be not accepted for review by the allocation committee. I think it bounced off of some third world country and didn't get to us until well after the deadline. Okay, section one. Please select the one project category. I think for the most part here, you all look into category one programming.

33:56 Leslie, correct me if I'm wrong, but programming, there's a drop-down screen that'll say one or three years, correct? It should. Actually, it might be a second question that asks if it's going to be ongoing, but that question will only appear if you put programming. Okay. So I think that's what most of the folks are doing here because you've done programming, you've submitted programming before. Capital projects, we talked about that already, and then Category 3, special projects, one-time funding for an innovative project.

34:25 Basic information, name of the organization, lead agent or individual, name of the program or project, purpose of the program or project include a schedule, you know, what are you doing? What does it look like? What does it taste like? What are your stated goals for the project as aligned with the allocation broad objective? What are you trying to do?

34:44 What's the big idea? What are the four or five objectives you've got? What are your stated goals? Because as you do your stated goals right now, whatever it might be, when you look at the performance review, we're going to ask you to give us data, support. These are my five goals. This is what I've done to meet those goals. Performance indicators. Amount of funding request. The number of attendees from previous years and future anticipated attendees. This question came up, added to the application.

35:14 One of our council members is saying, well, you're giving a lot of money to serve a few people. How do we look at a big bang on the buck? If you're going to give an X factor, how many people is it actually going to affect? If it's only going to affect a small handful, does it become a priority project? We're looking for public benefit. There is no ratio. Just looking at, let's look at what kind of money we allocated and what's the outcome? How many people are they going to touch?

35:42 Is it a smaller group? Is it a bigger group? If I'm going to do an X Factor, it's going to hit thousands of people. An X Factor, it's going to hit 10 people. You're probably going to have more, a higher priority for the people that's having a greater impact on people in the community. Brief description of scholarships. That may not be applicable, but some people provide scholarships. You know, it's part of your matching, part of your sponsorships. You know, because we're trying to make sure if you look at the next question.

36:07 It's accessible to all potential participants. People that want to participate, we want to make sure they have the opportunity to participate. These are public dollars. We want to increase accessibility. We want to enhance programs. We're not trying to deny access. And if they're not accessible to all participants, why not? What kind of program are you doing that may not be appropriate for somebody? Is this a one-time funding request or ongoing?

36:35 You know, timeline for the funding requests. And some of the folks here, the Air Rich, MLR, we're going to be coming back and we're looking at three years worth of budget. This is what it looks like. These are the programs we're doing. That allows us to begin to look three to five years out in the R&U funds and say, okay, we know this is how much money is coming in from X, Y, and Z for programming. We need to begin to build that into the budget down the road. What does that look like? And we've got to get to the point to say, you know what?

37:01 We can't afford all this stuff. And what's that X factor? But if you look in three years out, it helps us with projecting budget over time. And then did you get funding in the past? And how much? Just the historic piece here. Section three, producing entity and contact information. Fairly simple. Responsible party and title, organization mission statement, organization website or social media. You may not have a website. You may not have a social media site. That's okay. Just saying that applicable. Business address.

37:31 Mailing address, office phone, cell phone, email. Okay? So far, so good. The enthusiasm on a Monday morning. Section four, organization tax status. We'll start getting into Juliana's question there. Are you a non-profit, 501c3? What's your EIN number? Not-for-profit, 501c6? Are you a for-profit? Or are you something else altogether? Who knows what that is? But who are you? Section five, financial documents required.

38:01 Please provide financial documents for the entity or agency. So if you are whatever the organization is, that's your umbrella budget. This is who we are. We want to see the financial health of the organization. That's Section 5.

38:18 I want to see a 990 form, spit it out, Rich, 990 form that shows you are a valid nonprofit by the state attorney's office in the state of California, and that we want your year-to-date financials, including your balance sheets and your financial forms. We're cleaning this up a little bit. We had a conversation with somebody else the other day, so this will be a little clearer. For a for-profit, your year-to-date and prior year financials, including your present financials forms.

38:48 What we want to see is what's the financial health of the organization. Are you financially healthy or are you just now starting up? I have no umbrella organization that's taking care of me. I'm just a standalone and I'm only going to be submitting section six, which is project specific. So if you're doing a budget, is my umbrella organization, is the financial health my big picture? But I want money for this piece of that umbrella. So it's specific.

39:18 We're trying to make it a little bit clearer. That was some of the confusion we had last time. Some of us may be doing multiple programs, and you're looking at multiple documents, but I think that's more of a conversation with a different producer. Let's talk about that privately in terms of what that looks like, right? Because some of these applications are more complicated than others. Some of us may be doing a seasonal series of things.

39:40 And that seasonal series then becomes I'm doing a seasonal series of music, you know, whatever those, the symphony or whatever it might be. Okay, Juliana? So if we know we're doing this, we can't provide that, we certainly can't provide that. Bless you. One of the challenges we realize is we're trying to get people to look into the future. If we're going to fund stuff, we need to know that, you know, we're going to do a fall, winter, and spring series. Give us a window for opportunity.

40:24 We realize you probably can't do that for year two, year three, based on reality 101, but paint us the picture in terms of the general themes of the year, the seasonality of when you're doing some of these programs. Fall concerts. That works. Versus, we're going to do concerts in fiscal year 17, 18. Yeah, that's too broad for me. Right? Got to be semi. You know, it shows us that everybody in this room is organized and articulate.

40:54 You're visionary people. You've got great programs. You've got your fingers on the handle on these things. But some people walk in saying, well, you know, I'm thinking maybe I will do something in a year. It's got to be detailed. You know, we had that one individual, did a great idea, but it fell flat on his face. You know, it's like, wow. You know, so it's public money. It's public trust. We've got to make sure we vet this. But as you get to know the producers in the room, you know who can do what. Okay? Make sense?

41:26 Okay, so five is the health of the organization, six is project specific. And number seven, this is your public benefit. You know, why are we doing this? You know, what is the public benefit to this community to have arts and culture? You know, how is, what's the public benefit of the programs you're doing that really creates a thriving arts and culture community? What's that public benefit? What does it look like? What does it taste like?

41:53 Through all the, whether it's my youth, whether it's my adolescence, you know, whether it's my seniors, you know, how does, what's the public benefit? And you all in your applications have done a good job of that in the past. And, you know, these things don't have to be chapters and verse, you know, they can be, you know, somewhat limited in some of the, some of the stuff we put together. Okay, that's the application. Make sense? Okay. Okay, let's, we're going to go, we're going to come to Appendix A in a minute. That's budget stuff.

42:24 Working with our MLR Treasurer, Rachel's done a great job putting a document together. I think it's probably going to be the most challenging, so we'll probably spend some time on that. But here's your Appendix B is your performance report on page 10. Appendix C is your progress report. I'm going to imagine most people in this room are going to fill out a progress report.

42:45 For funded, for fiscal year 16, 17, the money you just recently got through this June, you're going to fill that progress report out, give us an update on where you are with your program as you do your application. Okay? No, keep asking. As you said, so we, I submitted a performance report for this summer activity because that was required for the second series of funding.

43:23 Do you want the progress report for the 16, 17 years to embrace everything that happened in that capital, that 12-month period, even though we already did a report on one? Or is it just for the second half allocation? Depends on your program. Some people did not submit a performance report for anything they did effective July 1st on this previous funding. Some people didn't request.

43:51 Funding. They had funding from last summer that didn't touch what you did this summer. So for your example for you, you wouldn't need to submit a performance report for that. You've already done that. That's done. That's water under the bridge. So just do the fall and spring. Fall and spring. That'll be progress. Okay. Good. Appendix D on page 12 talks about the ordinances, what the purpose are.

44:19 Page 13, Appendix D, talks about the gift of public funds, the use of Measure R, funds, the legal opinion, and what we can and can't do. So let's go to page, and we're now redoing these pages a little bit with some page numbers. All right, so those are being cleaned up a little bit. So we're going to go to, okay, I want you to, I want you to go to, back of 15 is page 16. See page 16? It doesn't have a number on it.

44:59 But page 16 says, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Proposed Project Budget 3 Year Summary. This is an Excel spreadsheet. You're not going to fill this sheet out. You're going to fill out, if you're year one funding, you're going to fill out year one. Whatever you put on year one, year two, and year three is going to show up on this budget sheet. Okay? So you're going to go in year one, because you're filling out year one. If you're doing year two and year three, right?

45:29 You look at those. Okay. It'll backfill for you. Okay. The summary will be the summary. What you put on page one, two, and three, for you all, you're doing three-year requests. It helps us build a three-year program. We can begin to project what these are. What you put on year one, year two, and year three is now going to get backfilled into the summary sheet. Okay? Make sense?

45:59 Okay, so you'll see, for example, A, project costs, cash, right? Remember we talked about that at 50-50, the cash match. You're looking for operations and management, describe the use of the funds. Professional services, who's doing what? Equipment, materials, miscellaneous category. I've got a cash donation for 25%.

46:23 That's where that cash, that's where the cash match would go. Begin to identify what this is. We're trying to give you a sheet to fill this stuff out that makes it this way. Remember the last budget cycle? We were comparing apples and oranges. Now we're comparing apples to apples. We're trying to be in a position where, okay, an apple is an apple, right? So we're all on the same page. That was one of the biggest, I think one of the biggest challenges for all of us. And we try to clean that up.

46:49 You look at B, the middle of the page, in-kind contributions. What are your in-kind? You guys had lots of in-kind stuff in the past. And you had cash stuff too. But once again, operations and management, professional services, equipment, materials, and miscellaneous. What are the others that you've had to do? Okay? Make sense? Yes. Okay, so you fill out year one. That shows up on your summary sheet. If you're going to do year two and year three, you're going to guesstimate this. You're going to project what your expenses are going to be.

47:18 You know, and I think as we look at this as more business, you know, if we're looking at doing long-term funding allocations, you know, what's it actually going to cost? Okay, make sense on that? Okay, so that's, we have found that probably one of the challenge areas. Within this, you'll see the Measure U, Measure Y, Measure U style guide. We need to make sure we get R in there also. Okay, now I want to go to, so budget.

47:47 We know it's going to be a bit of a challenge. Okay, oops. I'm going to come up with here. So we're going to go to, this is, we're going to start with the end in mind. I'm going to kick this up a little bit so you can see it. Let's go maybe to 150. Let's go to 175. Let's go to 200. Okay, so I'm going to put this up on the board. That's nice. Okay, this is the evaluation rubric.

48:26 We think it's important because in the past you guys would submit something and how do I know how you're evaluating these things? This is the evaluation rubric. Not all the elements here are going to be specific to your project. Remember, this is an evaluation rubric probably as we become more refined in this work over the years. We'll probably do one evaluation rubric for programming, probably one for capital projects, probably one for special projects, probably a separate one since it's general funds for special events. But at this point, it's all inclusive.

48:57 We will develop, we'll mature as time evolves. So we'll go in, you know, we're looking at a three-point scoring system, zip, not at all. One is fair, two is good, three is exceptional. We're not going to get into a 2.5 or 1.75, you know, and then we'll have to get into the definition of what is good, what is exceptional. You know, we'll ground a couple of these things as we know we're grounding, you know, student work papers, applications. Okay, so the project category, the project location.

49:25 Okay, so there are going to be some yes or no questions that could make or break the bank. Number one, alignment with the strategic, MLR strategic plan. Read the plan. Make sure you know what's in there, those six pillars. If it's not, thank you very much. Everybody in this room has done things before, and it has. Number two, alignment with the allocation strategy, broad objective. Yes or no? No, thank you very much. You all have successfully gone through this process before, so that has not been an issue. Number three, align with one of the funding categories in our objective. You pick one.

49:55 You don't pick two or three. Just pick one for me. If you pick more than one, I'm going to go, Alan, which one are you working on? You know, be specific for me. And we're here to coach. We want you to be successful. Number four, does it meet the 50-50 match component and not exceed the 25% in kind? Yes or no, right? Number five, previous measure, are you?

50:19 That doesn't really matter, but just gives us an idea. Yes, people that have, we know that they've been successful. We remind ourselves, yes, this producer's done multiple applications over the years. The events have been successful. They've exceeded standard. So we begin to look at the seasoned people in terms of how do we continue to work with you to refine your documents. Number six, project readiness. So this is where our categories begin here. Okay. So the first area is...

50:48 Project readiness. And as I said, not all these are going to be specific to your application. It may be for more capital, but, for example, does the schedule appear feasible? That could fit for you all. You may be coming in and saying, okay, I want funding to start something July 1st. And we're going to say, okay, it's feasible, but it's going to be, it may be tight. But is the project feasible? I'm going to do 20 weeks of programming.

51:19 You know, the program makes sense logistically in terms of performance, human capacity, logistics, venue. People may come up with this great idea, but this is just, it's going to be very difficult, a challenge to pull off, so feasible. Project ready to be implemented. Is your program ready to go? Is it likely to be finished in the allotted time? Am I going to be able to do my three programs, fall, winter, and spring? Yeah, probably so.

51:50 Has the planning been issued and completed? Yeah, based on what we've seen so far, and based on the history of that project or that program, they've been successful. We've seen marketing materials, and we've seen some of the stuff they've done. Is the property under control, right? So if I'm going to be using the Edison Theater, do I have permission to use that? You know, so it's a mixed bag. Some does, some doesn't. But I would say yes to project readiness, program readiness. In fact, we should make that project program readiness. Okay?

52:20 Number seven, community need. I still get that squishy thing that I can't read. I think, does it, is it something, we still got to clean that one up. And it doesn't meet the broad objectives. Were public meetings held to involve local citizens in the planning? That may not be applicable. I don't need to have community meeting about some of the programs I'm doing, so that's not applicable. Will the project provide a public benefit for the community? Doesn't encourage local population to take part. Does address the needs of the population of concern.

52:54 Right? Our people want to get involved in this kind of stuff. Can I ask a question? Sure. So, because you said it's web-based, so when we go into that, it'll open a bigger situation for us to write a bunch of stuff. You're not going to, that's not, no. The evaluation, no, yeah, yeah, the evaluation team. I want you, yeah, I want you to know what we're looking for in your application, right? I'm sorry. This is what we're looking for in the application. So if you look at your, your broad goal.

53:23 Your goals. But I do have a question relative to this. Because if you're talking about, let's just talk about programming. And as you said, some of these work for programming, some of them don't. But is there a way for you to indicate which should be filled out by programming? Because otherwise, if you're waiting answers and

53:51 All the programming people do not do all the same categories. Are you going to wind up punishing someone because they didn't get 60 when in reality it's a good program because they didn't fill in some of those pieces because they didn't think it was necessary? So, I mean, how much is this document? Is this going to be a plug in the numbers? They got 60, they got 20, 60 gets funded, 20 doesn't? Or is it a tool to help people?

54:20 And, but back to my, so that's the second question. The first one is, can there be some way, if you are programming, please complete the following? Because that way, everyone's on an even basis. Great questions. My previous comment was, down the road, there will be a separate filter for programming, capital, special projects. We're not there just yet. But you could use this for that. We could, but we're not there just yet.

54:47 So yes, this is a tool. At the end of the day, I like to think that something called common sense weighs out. There are a number of people, there are a number of, the fact that the folks in this room, all four of you have been involved in programs and projects, we are very familiar with who you are and what you do. It's little Richie walking to the door that's got a great idea, we've never seen him before, scratches it up on a piece of paper, that we're going to sit down and say, little Richie, we need to have a conversation.

55:16 So you begin to common sense at the end of the day. And once again, as you see this process becoming more refined, it'll continue to be more refined as time zoomed forward. So just it would be some common sense. And as your application comes in, we're going to start looking at this and say, okay, you know what? I need a little more here. I need a little more there. We want you to be successful. We're here to support you. Economic impact. Some of this stuff, because not all the programs and projects drive.

55:45 You know, economic development. You know, that's not what this is all about. These are programs. These are programs that help enrich this community, that thriving arts and culture community. But some of this stuff may make a good cause for serving economic development needs. You know, you're bringing people in for Daniel to do some things, right? You're bringing people in from the symphony. So there may be some economic development based on the programs that you're doing right now. Not necessarily so. It's not a requirement, but there may be some economic development.

56:18 Does it lend indirect support to area businesses? Well, people coming out for concert, they're going to go out for dinner thereafter. We're not here to measure all that specific part of this. Long-term partnerships. Of course, the more partnerships you have, the stronger the application. Increased length of tourist visit. Does it bring people to town for a program specific? The film festival in May. That brings people to town. That brings people to town.

56:47 Sufficient evidence to support these claims. You know, you're not out there trying to, you know, we got to figure out how do we measure? What's the rubric? What's the evaluation? What's the metric we're going to use? Don't, let's not get caught up in all that stuff at this point in time. That's a much larger conversation for, you know, our area. Long-term costs to sustain, ensure sustainability. As I said before, once you use R&U to build it, okay, you got to continue.

57:14 All of a sudden, we're using an X factor to support your programs and projects. Can we sustain that over time? How are you guys continuing to leverage funds, create partnerships, leveraging the grant writing you're doing? How do you continue to do that? This is enhancing public facility. My program's got nothing to do with public facility. So that's not applicable. This has got nothing so that it's not held against you. Common sense, once again.

57:42 Because we know what your programs are. Long-term capital investment, that would be specifically for if I'm building something. If I'm looking at the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, the multi-use facility, Outdoor Performing Arts Center, you know, so that would be once again applicable. You know, so you take those off the frame when you're doing the calculations at the end of the day. And no, it's not clear-cut. Alan, you got 61, I got 60, I get all the money, you get nothing. You know, it's common sense, right? Common sense.

58:11 Number nine, recreation, arts, culture is planning for future facilities. Okay? This is probably not applicable to you all at all. Right? Because you're not looking at, you know, a facility. So that, at this point, for most of the programs, you guys aren't even going to be part of that conversation. Somebody may want to come in and build something. And we'll go through the filter. This is a separate filter for capital projects. Has it been vetted? What's the feasibility? What's the business plan?

58:46 Future, yeah, future facilities, right? Allen's coming in with $10 million in Aquatic Center, okay? We're going to go through the process. There's a filter, the feasibility, long-term sustainability, okay? That is mainly for facilities, okay? Improved access. Access is important. We want to make sure that we're enhancing opportunities for people of all ages and abilities to participate in programs and projects. You know, that's what...

59:14 We're proud of what we can do for our stakeholders, you know, for the people to live here and for the people that want to come visit. And if it's good for the home base, it's good for everybody else. Will it connect recreational areas? Given the project's location, does the applicant make the case that the infrastructure will get real use? You know, that may not be applicable for programming, you guys. Will the project grant real public access, ADA accountability?

59:39 Project duplicate or other facilities. Somebody want to come in and want to, I want to build another ice rink. So we've already got one in town. We don't need a second one at this point in time. It's a duplication. One hands public transit, you know, estimate, come in and do a project of some sort. So this would be limited in terms of, you know, access with facilities. And the bonus section.

1:00:00 Does the project have partnerships? Does the project demonstrate coordinated partnerships among various groups, federal agencies, state agencies, local governments, non-profit groups, community volunteer groups, etc.? You know, that's your bonus section. From what I know you all, you all are leveraging community resources at this point in time. You know, congrats, keep those things going. Regional special considerations. Will the project improve opportunities for our youth?

1:00:26 Minorities, veterans, or families, or visitors. You know, look at the programs and projects we're doing right now. We have three weeks of snow. As a school guy, I looked at my Safe Schools stuff. When it was snowing out, kids found ways to get themselves in trouble. How do we create programs to keep them out of trouble? Protect them from themselves, so to speak. The economic considerations. You know, are there opportunities for sponsorships?

1:00:50 And then does the project help alleviate issues for community youth who find it difficult to get outdoor recreation amenities because of distance and transportation? So that's starting with the end in mind. That's what we look at, okay? So at the end of the day, well, I've done a good job on programs before. What's your big idea? What are your goals? Keep it simple. Three, four, five goals to your project specific. And then make sure you're collecting data in your performance report to say, this is how I know I've met goal one, goal two, goal three, goal four, goal five. Keep it simple.

1:01:20 You've all done a great job with applications in the past. This is a little more detailed. I think we're refining this a little bit more. I would strongly urge you all to process your applications. They go online February 1st. Try to get them in the first couple, three weeks. This way we can sit down and say clarity, clarify. In fact, we may want to sit down and talk maybe before you do an application based on some of the complexities of the application we've had in the past and go from there.

1:01:47 Save ourselves the blood, sweat, and tears before we get off the ground. So with that, that's kind of the overview of what we're trying to do. We anticipated about an hour, so I appreciated that. Okay, did I miss something that I didn't answer, or is there something else you might need from us? Make your life easier. That was great. Excellent, thank you. And with that, it looks like people are ready for a cup of coffee on a Monday morning. Okay? So, thank you. And with that, good morning, happy Monday, and enjoy the week, everybody. Thank you.