Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2017
Mammoth Lakes Recreation
· recording 3 hr 53 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
411 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Shields Richardson. Here. Tom Johnson. Here. Gary Morgan. Here. David Page. Here. Drea Perry. Here. Terry Stellick. Here. Brent Truitt. Here. Rachel. Ashley Schreier. Coming. She's not here. And Heather Schottmeyer. She's not here, right. Okay. Public comment on anything that's not in the agenda?
0:28 We can have public office. Right? I mean, yeah, that's okay. So with that, I think we'll go ahead and move into closed session. So let's retreat to the other room. And I think we've allotted, how much time have we allotted? To five. To five, okay. 29 minutes, guys. Cool. Let's go ahead and we're officially coming out of closed session, so we'll adjourn the closed session.
49:56 So just to kind of report out of the closed session, this board has been talking a lot lately about making a pivot and what does that pivot mean? Our first kind of phase, we were really developing the strategic goals of the organization and spent a lot of time doing that and a lot of time kind of inheriting some things, especially in the allocations realm and really trying to put
50:23 a smart process together around the way we administer RNU. And that I would call our foundational phase. And this pivot is about turning and scaling the organization and also about fund development. And that requires a skill set that we, that in conversations with our founding executive director, we think we need to go
50:52 Outside into the world and find for this phase two. I think the board unanimously feels like we hired the right guy as our founding executive director. A guy who put us, got us a seat at every single table, represented this organization with pride and intelligence in all ways, and stepped up kind of in every area we asked him to step up in, and was
51:21 Somebody from the outside couldn't have done the work that Rich did, building the kinds of relationships that he did. We've had a long extended conversation for last month about direction. And true to Rich's own maturity as a leader, he's recognized that the next phase requires some deeper experience in some other areas that he just hasn't had experience with. So we came out of closed session, agreed to
51:50 Seek a new executive director starting at the end of Rich's contract, which is up in June 30th. And the beauty of this is that Rich is basically going to drive the search and pave the way for this next. It's very much going to be a part of Rich's legacy is kind of handing the baton off in an excellent way. So I just want to thank Rich for his service and also for the next.
52:19 four months of hard work that we're going to be engaged in. And you've been the rock of this organization, and I really appreciate it. And also coming out of closed session, we're going to form an ad hoc committee with myself and David Page and Brent Truax and a couple out community members to be named later as a search committee.
52:47 to figure out the process by which we'll be executing the search.
52:53 I think that's all I have to report out, right?
52:56 Have I missed anything?
52:59 Sound right?
53:00 Okay.
53:01 So with that closed session adjourned, let's move on to the open session.
53:08 Emily, another roll call, please.
53:10 Absolutely.
53:12 Theo Richardson.
53:13 Here.
53:13 Tom Johnson.
53:14 Here.
53:15 Gary Morgan.
53:16 Yeah.
53:16 David Page? Here.
53:18 Drea Perry? Here.
53:19 Okay, public comments. Any public comments on anything that is not on the agenda? Hello, MLR Board. Hope you're all doing well. Betsy Truex, Recreation Commission Chair. And I just wanted to quickly take this opportunity to just let you guys know some of what the Recreation Commission has been working on. So we meet tomorrow.
53:55 Because of last week's weather, we had to postpone our regular meeting to tomorrow morning, so we'll be here in Suite Z at 9 o'clock. Some of the agenda items will include an update on the Mammoth Creek Park project. We'll be recommending the Parks and Recreation Program and Facilities Manual and the 2017-18 fee schedule for Town Council adoption.
54:15 We'll be approving our 2017 youth sports funding application and process. And we'll also be reviewing the 2017 Parks and Rec Department work strategic work plan. The commission will also consider directing staff to bring forward two fairly small funding applications to your RNU funding allocations process.
54:37 And I just wanted to mention as well that at our last meeting on January 17th, the commission appointed Recreation Commissioner Christy Osborne and myself to the joint ad hoc task force that we all had discussed at our joint meeting back on November 30th. I met with Tom last week and we talked about hopefully getting that going in March with representatives from MLR and town staff as well as Christy and me. So we're looking forward to that.
55:03 We also, as most of you are aware, Drea may speak about this later, but the custom build a pool workshop with consultants from USA Swimming will take place next Wednesday and Thursday. We have about 15 very committed participants coming for full days Wednesday and Thursday. And then Thursday evening we'll have a reception at Rafter, so invitations will be forthcoming to all of you.
55:25 And finally, just I wanted to take this opportunity quickly to just commend the Parks and Recreation Department staff for all of their hard work with the snow situation. You know, they've just done an exemplary job. They assist the road crew with snow removal efforts. Warren, our parks manager, drives the big blower, so he's pretty much out of Parks and Rec when it's storming. They clear the sidewalks and paths, reopen the ice rink.
55:51 Repair and assess damage to our parks and other facilities. They distribute public information and coordinate other relief efforts. That's what Stu is doing right now. And I just really want to acknowledge their real dedication to our community. So thank you very much. Any other public comments? Okay. Let's move on to our administrative items. Any additions to this agenda?
56:21 Any proposed additions to the agenda? Nope? Okay. Let's take a look at our minutes from the last meeting. And I'll look for a motion to approve. Second. Any comments? Other comments? Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Okay. Motion passes. Minutes are approved. And on to board member reports. We'll just go around the horn. We'll start with Brent.
57:00 Anything? I'm just going to reiterate a lot of things going on with town, but maybe Sheila's going to bring it up with the reports, but town is collecting a lot of data on damage for properties for informational purposes as well as things down the road. My property as well as many others in town, it may not seem like much, but you start adding it up and you have $10,000 to $20,000 worth of repair.
57:20 Pretty quickly. So just reiterate that. Plus, I don't know about everybody else, but my carbon monoxide detector went off the other day. We had our roof shoveled. I do recommend everybody get the roof checked because tons of snow that came off my roof was a lot. And to the point where now my second floor deck is below snow in a cave. So, yeah. So snow is 25 feet tall or 30 feet tall, whatever it is. And the round on my house deck is
57:50 Fallen away from it, including the girl that was on it too. So that's all I have. Thanks. I just wanted to also acknowledge what Betsy was saying about the aquatics meeting next week. If anyone is interested in participating, it'll be Wednesday and Thursday, as Betsy said. Very excited about that.
58:11 Talking with other community members who are also excited about getting a pool built. I did get to meet with Rose, the theater consultant, when she was here a few weeks ago. And I think it was nice. I kind of got there after everyone else had been with her. And I actually kind of took her out climbing up on some snow piles to show her where the actual location was because I hadn't really been apparent where it was that they were going to build. And so I think one of my
58:41 sort of feelings about the site is to really look at it from many different angles about the way that it is going to be built and I just kind of shared some of those thoughts with her and also showed her, you know, where the Felici Trio currently plays and, you know, just kind of really thinking about this seater growing from sometimes 50 seats to 100 seats to 300 seats and I found her very knowledgeable and appreciated having that one-on-one time with her.
59:10 And also got to see a Felici trio play this weekend, and it's just always wonderful to be able to support the arts and everything that we have going on in town here. Thank you. Okay. I'm going to give you a little update on the town. It's funny, I was looking at last month's minutes, and I said snow removal guys did a great job given the circumstances. That was a long time ago. Yeah, it was a long time ago. And, you know, they're still doing that.
59:40 We're getting on the better side of things. It's the events that we've had this past month. They're record months. They're calling it a 50-year cycle. Some people are calling it a 100-year cycle. So we're going through it. And it's testing our resources. But I'll tell you what, everybody seemed to come together as a community. Yeah, there were issues out there that we had to take care of.
1:00:08 I'll tell you what, everybody jumped in with both feet. We got our fire department, the privateers, Caltrans, the Mountain, you know, all saying, okay, how do we start taking care of these problems? And it was great to see everybody coming together because we had some real, real problems there for a while. The least, if not, is the rain.
1:00:35 And I know rain's not a good thing, and it's definitely not a good thing when there's been a lot of snow beforehand, and it clogs up everything. So we had quite a bit of flooding, and to Brent's point, yeah, if you have snow on your roof, big piles of snow, get it off. We're having some real issues with that right now. And we have more coming. But I just want to applaud all of our partners for the collaborative effort.
1:01:04 Everybody's been putting in the communication. We're working on a program that, you know, will be one message going out, so you're not going to have all these different silos sending out messages. I think that confuses a lot of people, so we're working on that program right now. But anyway, thanks to all of our partners, and we'll get through this. And you know what? Hell of a winner. You know, 20 years from now, we're going to be talking about it. Any questions?
1:01:34 That communications audit was approved? It was approved. Yeah. Correct. It was approved. Good news. Yeah. Thanks, Shields. Two things I want to mention. One is I probably every week now have five plus people coming up to me telling me how great the offering out at Shady Rest is right now. So I just wanted to recognize that, that that's a real kind of jewel right now for winter recreation.
1:02:04 Although I did hear about a... I think we'll get an update on that. Are you going to? Well, Joel's talking. Oh, Joel's going to talk. Okay. Okay, kick that in. That's right, Joel. Interesting, the plot thickens. You want to just leave it where I left. And then also the Backcountry Film Festival was fantastic, right? I mean, it was standing room only. Actually, we sold out, right? So just...
1:02:33 Yeah, it was so wild, too. It was right after kind of, I guess, the last storm cycle. It was like an ice, you were walking through an ice sculpture in mazes to get, you know, from where the beer was served in the visitor center over to the...
1:02:49 It just added, and they put candles kind of all the way. It was a really neat scene, and everybody there was stoked, not just on the films, but just the way the community came together for that event. And what it does is it really tells me that there's opportunity over there in that venue, but also for more, you know, events like that that bring our community together. So just wanted to recognize that. That's awesome. Unfortunately, I don't have anything to report. I've been...
1:03:18 There's a property management and all hands on deck kind of keeping my head above all this and my properties above it. Yeah, and so anyways, I would love to get out there and recreate and do something else. So anyways. The time will come. Yes. Yeah, a couple things. Our snow school program was again postponed due to snow. Too much snow. But we're going to reschedule in March.
1:03:47 Fantastic crew of volunteers, and it's a great partner on it to come together. It just counts by red days. Yeah, I was going to mention the Backcountry Film Festival. I think that was great. And then on the heels of that, the allocation that we approved for ESEA, looks like there are three of the four nights are already booked. It's going to be starting March 9th. It's going to be, let's see, Steve Bungardner, who was here a couple years ago. He's the Yosemite filmmaker. He's got a bunch of great new footage.
1:04:20 Capturing big horn sheep and racing on Yosemite. Claire Gallagher, who won the Leadville 100 Ultra Marathon. Cody Tuttle, who's another local guy who spends half his year in the Himalayas. And then we've got one slot of three people talking about. Great series. That's it. A couple of things. Allocation. I believe the deadline for applications is February 28th, right? We just wanted to make sure that we're doing enough.
1:04:59 Outreach to make sure everyone knows about it. A couple of people who wanted to start new events and then some guy in A-Frame was asking me about it and he didn't have any idea. It doesn't mean we haven't told everyone, it just means he didn't have an idea. So I asked him to call you. But I just want to make sure. Send him my way. Are we doing enough outreach to make sure people realize? What are we doing, Rich? Can you roll through the outreach? For the allocation process for programming.
1:05:22 Capital, which we don't expect, don't expect to see new events at this point or new projects based on the capital we got in line and special projects. We did three workshops, Tuesday, Thursday, the past Monday, I think it was the 30th of January. We videotaped that one so it's on Granicus for people to see. We've done press releases, social media. We can do another press release.
1:05:45 Emily, let's make ourselves a note. Let's do one more press release reminding people we're halfway through the cycle. It's up and running. Go to the webpage. We'll kick that back out again. And if anybody has questions, that they should be directed to Rich and Emily. Remember, this is different from summer for special events. It's non-special events. That funding was allocated by council.
1:06:09 We'll pull in that group together, Dan and I, sometime next week. We're going to move that along fairly quickly. If we funded all the summer 16 events, council approved 125. If we approved everything, it's 113.2. They're probably two are not going to refund because they made...
1:06:25 A fair share of money. So if we fund the ones that make sense at the same level, it's $90,271.16. So it gives us a little bit of money to play with if anybody does have a new event. And I've already had four or five people come to me. What's the process? So Dan and I are trying to roll through that based on our breakfast meeting last week. And then the other thing is, as I mentioned... Just to clarify, I think the plan, I mean, it's not a finalized plan, right? No, it's not. Is perhaps doing an allocation where...
1:06:55 It doesn't really have a home, right? It's not like MLR owns it officially or it's with Chamber or anywhere else. We'll just handle an allocation and kick the can until the next year to find out, to figure out who eventually owns special events. So technically the town owns them at this point? Yeah, that's right. That's right. Okay. And then the other thing is, as I mentioned a bit earlier, the Red Bull Human Performance Optimization Conference should be on June the 9th.
1:07:24 And we've put in a bid now at Brent and a lot of other people in town, the mountain, put in bids for rooms, for holding events, all kinds of stuff. And we're coming out probably about $50,000 to $75,000 less than we paid last year so far in Santa Monica. So we've got pretty good, and that includes airfare. So... How many do you expect? He says $150,000. And then we were going to look at how we can bring sort of local...
1:07:53 Athletes in as well into the mix too so we can make it a bit more inclusive. So the idea would probably be they come in Friday afternoon for some Fear Factor stuff and they go, they'll do an event in the evening somewhere. Next day the mountain is going to be pretty much hosting everything. They've been really generous with offering everything free as long as they get some hotel rooms out of it. And they're going to lay on ski passes and stuff discounted. So all in all, I mean, the good thing is we can do it. It shows that we have the infrastructure actually here.
1:08:23 We're going to handle 150 people. So it's just up to Red Bull now to decide if they want to do it or not. Nice. Is there anything we can do to help that align? I think the minds should pull the contracts if they don't come. I don't know. I just said it to him yesterday. He's going to talk to his crew about it and then come back with questions. So I'm sure there will be stuff when that round comes through. Okay.
1:08:50 Thanks, Board. Rich. Good checking, guys. Thanks, Tom. Executive Director. Thanks for the kind words before. I appreciate it. We'll make this transition as smooth as possible. Talking of transitions, we have a new program administrator, Ms. Emily Woods. Emily, welcome aboard. Emily's got a background. She's a Bachelor of Arts from Environmental Studies from University of California, Santa Cruz. She's done some work as a sales associate with Carchielli Cellars, Wine 101.
1:09:20 She's worked with REI as an outreach program point person. And she's worked with Tech Shop out of San Francisco and St. Louis. She's a senior member ambassador, social media marketing manager. So she's got a good background. Tech Shop Incorporated in San Francisco. She was the education coordinator. She's done some conferences with women, female women entrepreneurs, symposia, social media and PR contracting. She's on the board of directors with Austin.
1:09:47 Ortistry Studios in San Rafael. It really works on increasing fundraising networks. She's our new program administrator. And right now, it's been an exciting week and a half. She's covered for me well when I had to go back east to spend time with family. She's a good communicator. It's interesting. She's got full bullets at the top of her resume. Tenacious work ethic, personal drive, highly effective interpersonal skills.
1:10:13 Direct, honest, enthusiastic, and approachable style. Excellent follow-through on directions and assignments. I'm excited about the transition. I'm excited about the energy. I like our daily check-ins at this point in time, looking at our priorities and accomplishments in the week. Let's think about this. Let's think about this. It's nice to have new fresh eyes in the house. In a new set of eyes, different lens, different perspective, it's healthy for the organization. So, Emily, welcome aboard. Welcome. Welcome. Thank you, Emily.
1:10:43 Made mention already of the allocation process. Right now, we will get something out again to remind people we're up and running. Now, we are, I started crafting before my trip back east a sample application for the committee to work through.
1:10:57 Budget, the filter, et cetera. I'm going to get that done tomorrow, get it out by Friday to the committee for you guys to flush out. We'll begin to see some of the issues and the challenges. We'll begin to work on budget development. It's a later agenda item. You know, we're in the budget cycle at this point. We need to begin to look at our expenses this year. What have we done thus far? What are our projects for next year's aligned with our priority phase projects and programs? Let's begin to project this out. I see tonight as more of a conversation. Let's look at some numbers, engage the public in this.
1:11:27 We're going to come back in March and make it a public conversation. We'll do a public hearing about RNU. This is how it's been spent. These are some of the recommendations based in alignment with the strategic plan, the town goals and priorities. Get the public more engaged in that process. Town Council is going to start doing budget workshops on March 15th.
1:11:45 So we're trying to get in the front of the curve on this in terms of what limited money do we have? What are the projects we want to tackle? You know, I look at a fair share of, you know, the responses of the EIR. I look at the articles in the newspaper. I look at my friends in the crowd. People want to get involved in the process. So our goal is to, you know, over these next couple of months, allow the public to, you know, a little deeper engagement. Tomorrow night.
1:12:08 As Betsy talked about rec commission tomorrow, we'll attend that. On your tabletop and on the back table is the rec commission staff report. It's an update. I don't need to read that to you guys. It's online, but there is a hard copy in the back. Town Council is going to approve the recent allocation as part of the consent agenda for the ECEA.
1:12:33 Winter Adventure Series and the town ongoing priorities. We're still working on two pieces, which was the transportation and the equipment replacement. Rob and I have had a couple of conversations, as has Terry. I've got to still tuck that in. Shadier-esque grooming, I think Joel can jump in or talk a little bit about that in a second. And I've already heard mention about the aquatic workshop next week. So that's kind of where we are at this point in time, Mr. Prez. Thank you. All right. Well, can I just say one more thing? Because before we actually start at the base of the Sherwins,
1:13:10 Digging out the avalanche beacon and the trailhead sign and it was overhead and they hadn't gotten to the bottom of the sign yet. So they're part of the trail system out there. I'll post that picture a little later when I hit a break. Two staff people are still out there. They're camping. All right, thanks, Rich. Next up, Joel is going to give us an update on trails.
1:13:54 Does it have a regular balance? That's all we have, brother. Okay. Yeah, my fingers are just PowerPoint. Opening comments by Rich on Joel. We are lucky to have Joel in this community. He's dedicated. He's passionate. He bleeds trails. And he wants to get the work done. And I appreciate our almost daily conversations. Joel, we're very, very lucky to have you, sir. Rich, thank you for your kindness. Thank you for your hospitality. Board members, thank you very much. I've been wanting to...
1:14:32 Present this to you for a while. However, I think this is the right time because we're about to start thinking about the next season. So it's pretty pertinent. Just wanted to basically give you a report out of some of the accomplishments. Started my position about a year and a half ago. We started real on the ground work in the dry season last summer. And first I want to touch base on
1:14:59 Mammoth Lakes Trail System. I want to define that for you and the public. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System basically represents a partnership between the Forest Service and the town. I like the word system because I walked into a system that's very precise. It includes planning, design, implementation, operations, maintenance, stewardship, marketing, and promotion.
1:15:29 I don't do marketing promotion. I feel like that category for us is, you know, the work speaks to that. So I don't expect the trail system team to do much marketing and promotion. But certainly planning design implementation is what I really am tuned into. Speaking about the system, this slide shows all of the projects.
1:15:58 That I'm accountable for. And you can see there's a project name, a contractor code, and then over here, TOML, Town of Mammoth Lakes, it's an activity code. So it's very well organized. So our file folder structure, all the way up to hierarchy of leadership, everything has a place. Everything I do can be tracked to these codes. We can track our time by the minute.
1:16:27 to these codes. We save everything digitally into folders instead of racks of things on shelves. This is a digital program. So it's very exciting to me. The most amount of time that I put in in this past season was on actual trail maintenance. Trail maintenance within the municipal boundary of the town. There's about 30 miles of soft surface trails.
1:16:58 And these are the trails that we worked on and the distances. It's about 30 miles and we did about half of it in a season. I was pretty ambitious heading into it thinking, oh, 30 miles, I've done that before in a season. Some of the problems that we encountered were pretty extensive. One example that I'll share with you in a moment was about a 250, 300 yard, just a ditch, a giant trench on the Mountain View Trail.
1:17:27 And we fixed it, but it took a lot of time and effort. I'm going to take us on a bit of a tour, if this works. We have cataloged, through data collection efforts, all the progress that we've made. So the trails that are highlighted in orange are the trails that were worked on. And I'll just, this is the Mammoth Rock Trail.
1:18:09 This was one of the problems we encountered. Can everyone see this clearly? You can see that there's erosion problems, exposed roots, trail that's eroding. You can see the bedrock coming through. It's decomposed granite. And here's after we fixed it. You can see the before and then the after. You can see that you've actually got trail tread.
1:18:37 For your feet or your bike tires or your horse. And we had to use a rock drill. We chiseled away all that rock with an electric rock drill, carried a generator out there with a wheelbarrow, chipped it all away until we established a full bench cut is the proper phrase to use for that. Just one example of many, but it was a good one. We did some rock armoring of sandy corners where a lot of people were complaining that when they
1:19:07 Went around the corner. They were just sliding out and having accidents. So the solution there was to take relatively flat, large anchor rocks and dig them in to the trail tread, especially on the outside corner. We left the inside corners soft for the horses. Here's a nice big rock. That was a big effort. Other items that we're really proud of are signs. So we installed 82...
1:19:44 New directional wayfinding signs. And here's one of them. And we've plotted them all into this nice GIS data set where we can keep track of the year it was made, the cost, what it says, a photograph with it so that when it comes time to replace it, we know exactly where to go, what it's supposed to say, and it's integrated into our system. Other items on this map are summer stewardship trail days.
1:20:21 Folks came out in large numbers to help us out. It was really great. I'm going to go back to the PowerPoint for a second. Okay, so another project that we're proud of, as I just mentioned, the signage and wayfinding updates and repair. We prepared a design and tent document that will go toward the Forest Service for approval and also into the Town Public Works Standards Manual. All of the Type 9A directional signs that I just shared with you will be integrated into the program.
1:20:59 College Connector Path, we installed all but two of the signs on that facility. That's been a long time coming. We're still waiting for two pieces of hardware to install the giant maps on that one, but it's getting done. The Lake George Path went in thanks to Town of Mammoth Lakes Public Works. A lot of hard work there. And the signs are ordered, so our crew did the design of those signs.
1:21:28 Sherwin's access egress signs, David just brought that up. We have three entries to the Sherwin's, the Sherwin's trailhead by the propane tanks, the Mill City Road closure on Old Mammoth Road, and also the boot pack intersection up at the Tamarack Public Access Corridor that we just dug out today. And also with the updates and repair manual, we have a new sign type, you know, trail crew at work signs.
1:21:59 We're needed. I have some numbers here. Oh, here is our team working with a volunteer on the first Summer Stewardship Day last June. This is a good example of what one of those signs looks like. They're nice oak signs, long-lasting, and scorched-in lettering, so that should last for quite a while. Here's a complete one where we have the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and the Forest Service logos.
1:22:32 embedded into the post. This I have in the slides, this was a great day. This was the day when we finished sign number 82 on Mammoth Pass, on the Mammoth Pass Trail. We came back to our vehicles, and at the time I was working with an inmate fire crew out of Owens Valley Fire Camp, Conservation Camp. So they're inmates.
1:23:01 Great working with them. I've worked with inmates for about 12 years on trails. You never know who you're going to meet. I've met a physicist, chemist, lawyers, lots of lawyers, accountants, accountants. I mean, you just never know. And so, anyway, these are good people that work hard for us. And to get this for them was just a huge bonus. It says, and I hope you don't mind if I read it, they found this on their windshield.
1:23:31 Just a quick note to the entire trail sign installation crew to say thank you for the hard work. You guys and your efforts are much appreciated. Hopefully the mountains get inside you on this journey and you visit again under different circumstances. Thanks again, Gray Bunny, whoever that is. But a really thoughtful, anonymous note is more powerful than anything, I think, to get that sort of kindness expressed. Made their day, made their whole season.
1:24:00 And that's how we build a team. So this is a slide of the summer stewardship trail days program. We had three of those days. The first one was at the Panorama Dome trailhead. I know some of you were there. Thank you very much for your service. We installed 11 signs around the Panorama Dome trail system, removed some trees that were down, maintained almost two miles of trail.
1:24:29 And picked up 300 pounds of trash. A very productive day. And that all happened in a half a day. So very impressive. And here's all the folks that showed up. Everybody's happy. The second day, we hosted an event along the Mountain View Trail, Uptown, Downtown Trail Facilities at Earthquake Fault. That was our staging area. That day was very productive. We installed 25 signs.
1:24:58 When it says berms watered, it was so dry last summer, we had constructed a number of enhanced in-slope turns, some people call them berms, and they needed water desperately, so we had a team go out with the backpack fire pumps to try to water them down, but it just seemed to soak in. We painted picnic benches, cleaned out barbecues, and picked up another 300 pounds of trash.
1:25:27 And here's the folks that showed up there. That was a very great day. The signs are great because it's so rewarding. You plug them in the ground and it's instant gratification. It's a great project for volunteers, I think. Lakes Basin Cleanup Day was the third and last day, September 17th. 400 pounds of trash on over 800 acres.
1:25:49 Again, I noticed some of you were out there to help. I want to point out and give thanks to Patrick. I know he's moved on, but the Westin Hotel was amazing that day. We were getting bombarded and attacked by yellow jacket bees. It was really bad. If you guys were up in the Lakes Basin in the fall, you would know you probably got stung. Several people got stung. We were getting ready for the lunch.
1:26:13 Part of the day. And they just came out in force. And Patrick volunteered to host a pool party at the Westin. So we all relocated to the Westin for that. And much gratitude for that. It turned out to be a great day. And here's those folks. And my poor friend Bill, all the way on the side, you can see him with the hat. His whole face was swollen up. He had been stung twice. And he just kept working.
1:26:41 I probably would have gone home and put ice on it. I don't know, but he just kept working. This is an example of a project. This slide represents a project that's really on the front end of planning and design. We are in data collection mode in the Shady Rest Inyo Craters area. It's been identified as probably the best.
1:27:07 Geographic opportunity to expand soft surface trails especially. It's in the rain shadow. Not a lot of wetlands to contend with. So I have a background in environmental planning. And what we're supposed to think about is avoidance. How do I avoid archaeological sites, sensitive plants, wetlands? Where do the critters live? Avoid that. And this is what I call high and dry.
1:27:34 Anywhere in the West where you have yellow pine trees, either Jeffrey or Ponderosa, it's the best terrain that I think is possible for trail construction and sustainability, most importantly. Every little pine needle is like a little check dam. And when those pine needles fall after you do construction, it's just like a road project where the road workers laid straw on the sides to prevent the dirt from eroding away. So many things work for it.
1:28:02 We don't have, like, big river crossings, so that means that we won't have expensive bridges needed. That's another consideration, right, expense. So we feel like we can develop a huge sustainable system in this area.
1:28:18 Where the season for trail use can be longer because it is in the rain shadow. It's in the 395 corridor, so we already have sort of an intensive land use going on. It's away from wilderness, so we think of it as a mitigation measure to offset some of the impacts to our wilderness areas. And so we feel like if we can build trails that are really, really, really fun to use.
1:28:45 That maybe there'll be fewer impacts up in the Lakes Basin and places like that. So this is a map of our data collection efforts so far. And you'll see this project revealed in different iterations in the coming months and years, actually. It'll take many years. This is a really exciting slide. We're going to build this next summer, soon. It's been exciting to work with Forest Service staff. They're enthusiastic.
1:29:15 They're ready to go. They understand that the community has been waiting a long time for new trail facilities. What we're looking at here is the Mammoth Rock Trail region. The disturbed area on this aerial photograph is where the propane tanks are. We're calling that the Sherwin's Trailhead. So you can start using that phrase instead of borrow pit maybe. It would be preferable. The Sherwin's Trailhead.
1:29:43 And so we're looking at a connector that's about a mile long in the sagebrush area, not in the trees. We're going to follow the ridge line out and really surf the contour. So it's not going to be steep at all. It'll be 5% grade or less. Very runnable, very rideable. A whole family should be able to use it. Some of the trails that have been created out there that connect today are very steep, hard for people to go up. When people go down, they can't stop.
1:30:12 It increases erosion problems. It's just not a great design of some of the trails that people just put in. So the proper definition of a trail like that is a rolling contour trail. Very descriptive. This is a two-mile segment that's the most exciting segment. It's beautiful. There's some very interesting features along the way. Big old-growth cedar trees.
1:30:41 And interesting rock formations. So this will create three miles of new single track multi-use non-motorized that will connect to the Mammoth Rock Trail so people will have the opportunity to do a nice loop. It should be rideable and runnable both directions, not intended for one direction. There's just an amazing photo of a sunset caught this year. I can't believe I live here. Thank you.
1:31:12 I want to move on to what we're doing now. As you mentioned earlier, the Shady Rest Grooming Program. This is a new sign that's out there. We created this recently. Very proud of the map and the messaging. And it's a new day for the Shady Rest Winter Grooming Program. It was not seamless to bring it online. Our usual contractor indicated to me pretty late in the game that they didn't have enough staff to run the program.
1:31:42 So, okay, what's plan B? We have an amazing community with incredible individuals that really care, that came together to make this happen. MLTPA became the project lead. Tamarack came for our rescue recently. Our equipment failed after the first day. And they said, well, you can have our Tic Tac, they call it. It's the grooming implement that you drag behind a machine. They said, well, you can use it. We're not using it.
1:32:11 Oh, great, let's go get it. Oh, it's under 20 feet of snow. So we dug out the Tic Tac. First, we had to find it with Avalanche probes, and we tried a metal detector, couldn't find it. It took us three hours to locate the implement, and then we dug it out, got it out, and it's operational. On Saturday, our Nordoni machine, which we rented, broke. Okay, what's our alternative?
1:32:36 Found out, okay, somebody has a utility sled we can use with the local mountain bike club, okay, but it's under 15 feet of snow. We went and dug that out yesterday, and then we were operating last night. So, you know, people are coming together to really make this happen, you know, to look at the machine under 20 feet of snow or the Tic Tac and think, oh my gosh, I have to dig that up myself. It's not going to happen.
1:33:03 But people are really coming together. So MMSA, thank you. Friends of the Inyo was gracious enough to rent us the equipment, even though it failed. Still, they came to the table and participated. The Forest Service staff really stepped up to help us with a challenge cost share agreement. So now the town has the entitlement to run this program. It really came together relatively short notice. And hopefully the public doesn't even notice.
1:33:33 What we're dealing with, right? They just go out there and they have a nice trail experience. On this subject, I want to bring up Saturday, we had an incident. ORMAT cleared a road, which was a part of our system, unannounced. We didn't get any notice. And they cleared to their USGS test well site. And so it was kind of a shock. But within several hours, we had a reroute in place.
1:34:02 The only unfortunate thing was that there were a lot of people out there Saturday and there's this giant blower blowing snow and it was quite an intrusion. I was out there with the ranger this morning surveying the area, trying to come up with some solutions. Long term, we think another trailhead is in order, a more functional trailhead is in order. The trailhead experience for folks is not working well.
1:34:32 The welcome center, we think, is a good place for the non-motorized folks to launch for this program, but the Shady Rest Park parking area is not functioning well. So the ranger agrees that we have to find a better solution. Here's Andrew. He's become a great friend of mine. He's a terrific person. He's such a hard worker.
1:34:58 Very creative thinker. So I got stuck three times with him in one outing on this machine, and we successfully got it out of a deep hole three times. It was our first pass when we were trying to pack down the snow. It was really deep, and it's not a great machine, but it's amazing what you can do with leverage in a brilliant person. So kudos to Andrew. This is a photograph of
1:35:27 One of the three Sherwin's Access egress signs. On the right side of it, you can see there's a beacon checker device for people to make sure that their avalanche beacons are operational before they head out and have an adventure. We're very proud of this new map. It took several of us with GIS and cartographic knowledge to put this custom map together. It's a beautiful hill shade. I specialize.
1:35:56 In things like Photoshop and Illustrator and GIS and had a great time coming up with something very custom, a very nice custom product. And I enjoy collaborating with other people like that. Here's a picture of where we were this afternoon in that hole. And that's about halfway down. It got deeper after that. This is Kelly Workman in the foreground. Very brilliant person as well. The team that's really been
1:36:25 Pulled together. It's amazing to have people like this to work with. Makes me feel confident and strong as your trails coordinator. It's a pleasure to work with these people. These things don't happen with just a couple of people or especially one person. Here's the Mill City winter access sign. Lastly, this is a real product. It's about to be delivered.
1:36:54 We have an arrangement with Mammoth Disposal to initiate a program. This is going to sound, it's the Pooh Fairy Program. So the idea, it came out of Great Britain some years ago. Is that the theme of our 4th of July parade? So in Great Britain, somebody came up with this gimmicky thing to get their neighbors to start picking up their dog's mess. We're going to try something similar here.
1:37:23 At two places to begin with, we understand there are probably 100 locations or more where we could use it, especially now. And here's what the sign says. There is no poo fairy. Please clean up after your dogs. Grab a bag, pick up after your pup, and return to waste basket below. Thank you. So we'll see how this goes. I think if we provide a facility for people to use that we should see an improvement.
1:37:49 It also gives people like me a place, like if I go out there with just a shovel, I'll have a place to put it. I don't have to take it in my car, in a bag or a bucket or something like we've done in the past. And Mammoth Disposal has a very trained staff that know how to deal with this sort of really a health hazard, and they're going to take care of the service for us at a very reasonable price. So we hope that this program really takes off.
1:38:19 And you'll see them soon. He's been struggling with the weather, as most of us have been, and he's had to prioritize other things, but you can see that the just about complete. All right. Any questions for Joel? Thanks for the update, Joel. It's my pleasure. It's really impressive stuff. Yeah. Outstanding. Thank you. I do have a question. On the ORMAT incident, I assume we've talked to ORMAT or started to coordinate with them? I've not.
1:38:52 Spoken with ORMAT, I think the proper protocol for me was to speak with the ranger and that he'll probably speak with the folks with ORMAT. My understanding is that ORMAT has the permit in place to do that. And we have to figure out a creative way of dealing with that impact. The first answer was reroute the trail. Second answer is, boy, this is like the Grand Canyon. Somebody's going to get hurt.
1:39:21 Maybe we need some signs or caution tape or something. And then the long-term goal is to get the OSV, especially that staging area, possibly in a different location. And I've spoken with Bill Souser about that. He has some good ideas. The Ranger has some good ideas. And in fact, the Ranger made a decision after an environmental assessment, and they chose a location for the trailhead. It's a bit...
1:39:47 Further out of town, I think, than some would hope, though. But there is a shovel-ready trailhead project that the Ranger has approved to relocate the OSV staging area for your awareness. And that's something that can be built without a year or two of environmental analysis. So we will see. And that's out the road past J.D. Rest? Yeah, if you keep going straight, if you keep going straight past the right turn. Instead of turning into a park? Correct. How far up? Yeah.
1:40:16 It's probably... Yeah, right, you'd have to be plowed and everything, but yeah. Yeah, so, I mean, at this point, the decision's there. It's quote-unquote shovel-ready. I think the archaeologist has an issue or two, but it's easily achievable. It's a matter of getting some folks to agree that that's the location. If that location is somehow changed, then we hit the reset button on the environmental assessment process.
1:40:44 So that's the drawback of choosing. Who are the folks that need to agree? User groups. User groups. The OSV users have to agree to that. And, you know, my friend Bill would need to really want that. Isn't that the same area? I mean, I think it's been on plans that's been one of the suggested areas for staging.
1:41:13 I think it's been there for a while. Is that the same area or has it changed? That's the same area. They were looking at several locations, but they came to one location for the environmental assessment work, and the other locations were not analyzed. Because I believe there were some issues with that as well as far as turnaround, parking, and things like that when they were looking at that area. I don't know if that's been resolved. Yeah, this past weekend was a real mess at Shady Rest, the park.
1:41:42 One, the ORMAT situation, they have encroached out into the parking lot a little bit with some snow banks. They want to protect their entry so that nobody parks there and blocks them because when the USGS comes in, they just want to be able to get in, do their work, and get out. And so the ranger was thinking, well, why did they do this? Well, it's probably because they want to prevent people from blocking the entrance. They didn't do it flush. They actually...
1:42:11 have sort of a half circle of a snow berm out into the parking area, and we sacrificed four or five parking spots. It also pinches the access a bit for folks, and it just, it's not functioning well. People aren't having a good experience when they go to recreate, so, and that's the goal. Yeah. Well, I did hear about that, about shady rest, but I guess that seems to be the,
1:42:40 Thought about the other space, too, is that they're going to have similar issues. So, anyway. But Shields, I really, I appreciate that question, and I think I'm really looking forward to, I think, it sounds like you're absolutely right, the protocol for this particular issue is to go through the Forest Service, but I think as a larger town recreation issue, I mean, we know that the Water District has issues with ORMAT, but I think, how do we, as a community,
1:43:10 Look toward improving our conversation and our relationship. It's a communication. But beyond just communication, if, I mean, they have these new wells, they're impinging on our recreation product. This is just, this is one example. And is there a way to improve our partnership, not just on the communications front, but how can they be better partners with our recreation product in this town? We've got to let them know. Yeah.
1:43:36 But I mean, but I guess, because I appreciate the way you framed that question, has anyone talked to ORMAT, how do we set it up so that the town and ORMAT can talk in a productive way on a number of fronts? Agreed. Thank you, David. I appreciate that, because a simple phone call a day or two ahead of time, and we could have mobilized to do the reroute before they made the cut, and we could have been out there notifying the public.
1:44:03 of what was going on at the time because the public's saying, what is this thing doing? It's a busy weekend. It's right on Saturday. Yeah. So even just a simple phone call would have sufficed, I think, and solved a lot of the agreed problem. Thank you, Joel. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. Moving on next on the agenda, we're going to take up the Forest Island Residency Program.
1:44:29 That's up. We're going to review and consider approving Measure U special project funding for that program. You have an attachment, attachment two in the agenda packet that relates to that. Rich, you want to tee us off? I mean, I know it came up before us before, and we had to change kind of the sponsoring agency and make a couple changes. Did we take any action when it came up?
1:44:58 Before us before with any contingencies or any? We reviewed it, asking it to bring it back. It is a special project. It's one-time funding. If it starts on page five with this document, Forest Island Project, it's being housed or hosted by Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Kevin Liam, who's the Associate Director for Mammoth Lakes Foundation, is with us today if any questions come up. It outlines it. The ask at this point in time is only $5,000.
1:45:23 Working with Kirsten, she's realizing due to the lateness of this that she can't possibly get the first spring resident artist program going. So she's looking at can she have some upfront funds to create the base for this, the foundation. Get all those pieces in place which are outlined starting on page, let's go to page, put page 12 in your packet. She's got spring 2017.
1:45:53 The original last was $8,600. She came back and she's downsizing to $5,000. Right now we've got $8,600 left out of that $25,000 we allocated under Measure U. You look at the administrative stuff, the things she's trying to accomplish in this round of funding. Get it off the ground, build the foundation, and then she's going to put an application as part of this special project or perhaps programming funding allocation process, which is open now, to come back and start looking at.
1:46:22 Look in the middle of page 12, you begin to see fall 2017, spring 2018, that's what she's going to come back and ask for in the future. So that's pretty much it, the nuts and bolts. 5,000, get it up and running, come back, request future programming at this point in time, and come back and do a future application. Rich, I guess my concern with this application is that it's, you know, looking at
1:46:53 Being a one-time funding, yet clearly there's already line items in the budget to ask for future funding. So I'm just confused what we're trying to do here. Her request from this board is a request for $5,000, one-time funding, special project, innovative program. She wants some seed money to get the frame, the foundation built. That's what she's asking for at this point in time. So the one-time funding is for the seed money.
1:47:23 Correct. But it doesn't fund any part of the program. This is strictly the website and the structure of what their program is going to be. Correct. Top of page 12, she outlines what she wants with a one-time budget for fiscal year 16-17, spring of 2017. Events and promotion, administrative stuff, website development, initial outreach, branding, graphic collateral, community network and resource directory, program coordination.
1:47:50 Application and Selection Administration, Event Organization. That's what she's requesting at this point in time. So this is an addition. Originally, she asked for $8,500. Correct. Expecting that she could do the spring three-week cohort, and she's realizing. The original one, she didn't ask for the $5,000 to prepare to spend the $8,500, correct? That was embedded in. It was embedded in the $8,500, but I'm not seeing $8,500.
1:48:19 Ask for fall? Correct. Then she'll come back in the next funding cycle from speaking with her. She's going to request program funding in the allocation process, and that window closes on February 28th. So am I the only one who feels like this is an extra $5,000 ask over the original program? I guess my concern with this is there's an ask to, I understand there's an ask to put the
1:48:50 Structure together, but then it's coming, then there's going to be another application, and to me, I think this needs to, I would think this needs to stand with all of the other applications that are coming forward, because if this part of the application doesn't move forward, then we're spending $5,000 that isn't, that we've kind of just wasted to my, you know.
1:49:16 And I think that, I don't think it's fair for us to say that yes, this, we're almost saying if we're going to fund this $5,000, you've got to fund the other part of it. And so I think that it needs to come back and stand with every other application that comes forward. And there can be two pieces to that. We're only talking about another two weeks. There can be two pieces to it where it's, this is the funding for the programming and this is the funding for, and I don't know that it could actually come as a special project and a
1:49:44 a programming application. I think it all needs to be all one, but I don't, I personally would have a very difficult time funding this without saying that we're going to fund the other, and I don't think that that's fair to any other program or any other application that's going to be coming forward to do this at this time. I agree. And I think the timing is unfortunate, you know, had this been funded and yeah. Yeah, I'm guessing so.
1:50:12 Difference in a different way in the fall. It probably would have already been approved and we would have already been underway. But I agree, you know, based on all the work that we've done with allocations in the last few months, you know, the way I'm looking at is I see 5,000 and then I see 8,500 for the fall and then 1,700 or 17,000 for 17,18. So I just feel like it's a hard
1:50:43 thing and it's not really fair to other applicants at this time. And the way I've, you know, I don't know if there's just some confusion, but the way I see one-time funding is it's one-time funding. It's not to come back and ask for funding again or to necessarily come back and ask for program funding. So I don't know, Rich, if you have some ideas on the way that this can be asked for just from a program funding in the get-go for this allocation cycle right now.
1:51:13 I think there's a lot of great ideas. I love the application. I mean, I think this would be an incredible asset to our community, but it just needs to be applied in a different way. The way I understood the special funding kind of mandate is that if something was a one-time project that required funding, or if the timing of its execution was such,
1:51:41 That it was caught outside of the regular cycle, that that would be an appropriate use of funds too. And I think originally this was, we felt like it had to get done in the spring. That's what we were shooting for. So the timeline made sense for the special funding category. I don't know that it does at this point. Yeah, I mean, as I understand it, that's kind of how it ended up in this situation, right? Because we looked at it when? In November, October? I think that's right.
1:52:11 And then had to rethink it, and then it got sort of stuck in limbo for months and months and months and missed our last meeting for extenuating circumstances. But I think one question I have is how big a gap is it in terms of when that check is cut between... So if it comes in as an application by February 28th...
1:52:37 makes it through the allocation cycle. When would the final, when would the town contract be signed with Mammoth Lakes Foundation? Well, February 28th, based on our timeline to recollect from what we did that presentation in January, January 4th, the committee's going to make some recommendations to the MLR Board the first meeting in April.
1:53:00 It'll go to town council the second meeting in April and then in May the contracts will be crafted so they're in the budget cycle for fiscal year 17-18 so our producers or applicants have funds in the bank order to go by July 1st that they can count on. July 1st. Correct. And would it be radically faster through special, I mean I'm not saying that it's appropriate for this special fund but if it were is that a
1:53:29 Radically faster process. I'm just thinking from the point of view of a producer, if you don't get your money till July, is that enough to get a program up and running in September? It's just a question. For this specific program, too, that has some lead time considerations that maybe some of our other ones don't. And it may, I wonder if, I mean, I think as we move forward, these are just questions we have to ask. Yeah, they're going to come up.
1:53:53 And since we still have this kind of onerous double process where the town council still has to approve, I mean, if we were able to say in April, these are approved, you may not get your check until June. At least the producers know it's approved. As it is right now, we can say, oh, MLR board approves this project, but it's still got to go through the council approval process.
1:54:17 It just becomes a very long drawn out for the producer. And the February window right now is for fiscal year 17, 18. Funding becomes available July 1st for the next fiscal year. We're trying to get in front of the curve. That's what we're doing two cycles. So just to come back to that question, if it were approved as a special fund project, how much quicker would that be, just out of curiosity? Special funds, we've asked applicants to bring things to the Executive Director by the 10th of every month.
1:54:47 to vet, bring to the board meeting the following month. If this were, let's technically, hypothetically, if this were approved today, it could possibly, if I went and did an agenda bill tomorrow, would make the consent agenda for the town council on March 1st. And then it probably takes town staff, you know, 14 to 30 days to do a contract, so you're probably looking at about April 1st. So it's probably about a six to eight week turnaround. Three months, I mean, it's significant. Yeah, it is. Yeah.
1:55:17 So, David, just from your perspective, if, you know, this were to go through the normal process of program funding, would the know that by the middle of April, Town Council approved it, would knowing that they would get the funding by the end of June, beginning of July, allow them to get something like this done, like, that they're going to get the funding slightly retroactively, but they could at least... Well, I'd like to, I'd love to hear from...
1:55:49 Kevin, see what his point of view is on it. But my, I don't know. I mean, my guess is that if you know for sure, if it's committed in April, that gives you some time, some lead time to build some things. I don't know exactly what. I've sort of recused myself from the project. What do we have available on the front? $8,600. So we couldn't fulfill the whole, the $5,000. Well, the biggest problem was that
1:56:14 That if we were to, because they were going to, the initial, what we said back in the fall was come back, come back at the earliest opportunity with a fiscal sponsor. They found a fiscal sponsor. They've come back at the earliest opportunity and they couldn't ask for the whole thing because it was too late to get the artist. I mean, they would have to spend the whole, all the money before the end of this fiscal year at this point, which was the plan originally in the fall. So it's.
1:56:42 You know, it's, this is a procedural issue that's delaying them. They're caught in it. They're caught in it. But does it, but you know, now, once, now that they've seemed to have gotten their heads around doing it starting in the fall, it sounds like good advice, even though it's, we're asking them to jump through a whole nother hoop and they're kind of on, on the cross of our own procedural difficulties. But it does seem like, ask for the whole sum for fiscal year 17, 18, and
1:57:12 Let it go up against all of our other projects. I think it's either that or if we wanted to do something in the other, in the special funding category, we'd have to do it in two steps and I don't know that we're comfortable doing that. Well because I don't think it really fits that special. So if they want, I think our solution is looking like going in the full funding cycle.
1:57:40 What's your feeling on that, Rich? I mean, you've been in the trenches with the project. I mean, the comment was made about one-time funding, special projects. It says one-time funding for a special innovative project. It's seed money. But we should know that people put money in the bank as a special project. They're going to come back now, put in a programming application in. They're going to build upon that. The purpose of the seed money was for people to come up with an idea. Does it work? It's working. Okay, now I want some program winner to make it work.
1:58:09 Or I gave you some seed money and it's not working. I think with this the challenge is going to be, go to page 15, in my conversation with Kirsten, you look at the application we've written now, you've got a 25% matching cash. So people need to be reminded of that because if they're coming asking for $8,600, they need to come up with 25% in cash match, which is what, 21, 21.50, give or take a little bit.
1:58:35 So that's going to further, I think, complicate some of these applications because people have been banking on in-kind and not cash because we're really trying to leverage these things right now. And if we're looking at her total ask, if I look at for this project, go back to page 12. At the bottom of the page, total fiscal year 17-18 MLR special project funding. It's not a special project anymore. That's going to be programming. And it looks like the ask may commit at $17,000. That's for the year.
1:59:03 That's for the year. Yeah, which was, that was what the budget was initially. That's for spring and fall. Correct. The annual program. So, direction. Can we hear from, did you want to say something, Kevin, while you're here? Well, in regards to, in regards to the forest island proposal of the conversation that just came in now, from Mammoth Lakes Foundation standpoint, we are the fiscal sponsor. We have all the processes and systems in place to
1:59:35 to take donations, to facilitate the, I guess you would say behind the scenes activities, but in my conversations with Kirsten and Rich and also hearing what's been said today, I think the ball's in your court and whether to, you know, when funds will be distributed, how, what kind of funds.
2:00:03 But as the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, as the Forest Island, their mission, residency, our program, it is right up the alley of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. So we are fully behind this project and I will just wait to hear direction from the MLR Board. Thank you. Okay. You know, I guess looking at the application, you know, on page 12, I think the thing that caught me
2:00:36 was that it said fall MLR special project funding. So that just needs to get changed to programming. Yeah, that's right. I mean, yeah, I kind of agree. If we're able to seed something like this with a one-off fund, I think that's exactly what we've told people we want to do. And this is a pretty well thought out proposal. And they've jumped through hoops first, as you said. So from that point of view, they've done everything right. However, I don't think we can commit to the ongoing funding at
2:01:06 The 8,000 and the 17,000 level matching. And that's the thing, as you just said, I think they have to jump into the ring with everyone else at that point. But I'm not against seeding them to see if they can stand their own feet. I'm not either. The only problem is we only have $8,600 to do so that we've earmarked. And to complete their fall, they need, what is it, $13,500. But this is the funding we're talking about now is this fiscal year, $16,17.
2:01:34 That sunset's 130. Oh, yeah, so they couldn't ask for the 8,500 anyway. So there's always going to be this two-step. This is very much just about the $5,000 to get going. Yeah. Yeah, I get it. And I guess as Rich kind of what he said earlier is that seed money is to give somebody that first-time chance. Does this program work? Does it not? And unfortunately, this isn't even putting the program on, so we would be funding a $5,000 but still not know whether...
2:02:03 The program works, yeah, exactly. It's strictly the structure of that program. That's what seating is. Yeah. Well, except for... We don't know whether it's going to work or not. Well, I know, but this isn't even part... This isn't even funding the program. I guess that's what I'm saying. Yeah, it's not like we're getting a pilot, you know, one-off event that indicates a longer-term project. Seating would be funding that program, and then you would evaluate...
2:02:32 Did that program work or not? We don't have anything other than a website to evaluate if we see. But if you look at the events and promotion on the top of page 12, they've allocated $1,000 to do a simple little artistic workshop just to bring people in. I think just a local artist, she wants to do an event and promote this of some sort. So it's not bringing people from the outside. It's not putting people up. It's a simple little thing just to test the water. So I think we probably could get some kind of taste of this.
2:03:00 Based on what they're doing right now. And if I look at the people involved in this project and the types of things they're doing, and you look at the potential partners, I go back to page 11, some of the people involved in some of this, we've got some pretty powerful people here. I love the program. I do too. I think it's worth seeding and I want to see it succeed. I just, it's really a question of how risk averse are we with this, with a $5,000 ask without being able to see the full program.
2:03:30 Well, I mean, there's a lot more detail in here than most people who apply for funding. Yes. I think this looks like a fairly solid MLF behind it. It's got a pretty good chance of kicking off and seeing what happens. I think this is one of those key projects that is actually worth funding as a seed money to test. Now, whether we can afford the whole five or not, it's a different manner, but it seems like they're in the wheelhouse of where we ask people to be. And I would agree with that, too, but does it come forward with...
2:03:58 Special project funding or does it need to come forward with all the other programming? That's the real question is about lead time. Do they have enough lead time in the regular process to actually do all this prelim stuff they have to do? Branding, website, all this stuff. I'm guessing that the reason that they went this route was that they felt they needed that lead time.
2:04:19 And that's the purpose. This is one-time money out of this fiscal year for a special project. And you think about timeline that came up before. I don't believe we're going to be in a position to have the allotment of time to bring another project forward, to go through town council approval process before we get to the spring and we're at the end of the fiscal year. We're four months out at this point. So I'll go back to what I said that couldn't happen, but in a situation like this, could there be
2:04:49 This seed money, they could go file for the next application process. That goes through everything else. If that is approved, then there could be the $5,000 that could come out of that special project that could come forward to start with as long as the actual program is going to be funded moving forward. And so it would be kind of two steps. Does that help their timeline at all?
2:05:17 So basically you delay the special fund application until the other one's approved. So if their actual program is approved, then you could do that, except for the fact that it would not have to wait until the next fiscal year. That $5,000 could still be spent in this fiscal year because it would be approved if that program, and then the actual program would be funded in the next fiscal year with everybody else.
2:05:44 That goes forward. How much time would that save? Let's kind of sketch this scenario out. If it went through, if it came back, and town council approved it the second meeting in April, this would come back to us, our first board meeting in May, then it would probably go to the town council, second meeting in May. By the time they got the contract, it's going to be early June. So it's a month. Yeah. This is replicated after the Anderson Ranch scenario.
2:06:15 Very powerful program. We are vetting public funds. It really does support the creation of a thriving arts and culture community. You've got people that have done a pretty darn good job of vetting this project at this point in time. There have been some things that have been out of our control in terms of who owns it, budgeting, et cetera, the timing. But at this time, I think it does meet the criteria for a special project. It's one-time funds for an innovative project. It's seed money.
2:06:44 Right? If they do a simple little event promotion for $1,000, it gives them a flavor of how this is going to go. We get a taste of it at that point in time. It is a fairly big chunk of change, $5,000. But you think about the amount of money we've allocated for other projects and programs, you know, we look at the bang on the buck. I think the foundation, I think we would all agree that the foundation for this is ripe for moving to the next level. Honestly, I think we'll be able to tell a lot from the
2:07:14 From the materials that are created. I mean, the website, the branding, the whatever collateral they build, the kind of network, the outreach they intend to do. I think we'll have a set to evaluate. Anyway, whether that satisfies everybody or not is another question, but there'll definitely be some good work there to look at. So, kind of also going back on what I've said, you know, looking back to where we were.
2:07:43 Were a few months ago and wanting to support this yet not being phrased and promoted correctly. Position. Thank you. And I think if we were to fund this as a one-time funding today, it would allow the group to get something done in the next couple of weeks, whether it's a logo, a little bit of website time.
2:08:16 As well as ideally to put in an application within the next two weeks for fiscal year 17-18 funding. And, you know, one of the things we ask for is a, I can't even remember what we named the report, but a performance report. Was it performance? So it would be a performance report. You know, what have you done with this? And, you know, and that could be done.
2:08:46 Progress, thank you. It's a progress report. So it could be looked at when we are actually reviewing these sometime in March. Or, this just occurred, if we approved tonight for $5,000, it could be contingent upon that full cycle application.
2:09:05 Being approved. And then that money can literally be released on that day. But then aren't you committing them to spend $5,000? No, no, they can't start until we won't release it. We'll get it into the process. I don't know that that changes anything other than from... Because I guess I look at... It buys them a bunch of money. I'd say just do it or don't. Well, yeah. I guess I would see that, you know, if...
2:09:34 If this comes through, if this is a project that we approve from the application in April, it goes to Council in April, and we can, I mean, if it's going to come to us on April 1st, it can come to us in two parts. It can come to us as an application that went through the process that we're approving, and there could be that additional, that one-time funding because they need that sooner.
2:10:03 Then the actual program was going to be funded. Does that make sense? Yeah. But that's what Rich said would save us like a month, right? But it seems to me like we should be able to save at least two to three. So the producer's going to put in two applicants. It's going to put an application for funding for special project, one-time money, and then programming. Yep.
2:10:28 But the special project would be for this fiscal year, and the programming would be for the next fiscal year. But what you just sketched out for us was a June check instead of a July check. I think we could get that sooner. Well, if it's going to us in April, it goes to council the end of April, why wouldn't that go to somebody in May? So it's May by the time town staff gets it. It's probably two to three weeks. It's probably early May they get a check.
2:10:56 Sorry, just quite listening not to some of this, but just, really, to me, it's down to one thing. Do we, it sounds like there's a general sense that we like the general idea, but do we put it as a special or do we just put it as a roll into a normal? That, to me, is the only decision on the table because I recognize a two-part process or a six-part process, it doesn't really matter. We're trying to give initiation. I have another question for Kevin, though, in terms of if we, you know, what's the timing of getting work drawn around? This is...
2:11:22 We say it's a complete project. Actually, I'm missing a bunch of stuff here because I have a timeline. But I don't know if they're going to approve it today. Does it work at the beginning of tomorrow? Does it work at the beginning of two months from now? We don't have anybody even on that side where it's going to begin with. Because right now, I'm favoring Warren just say, hey, just follow the regular cycle. Let them ask for money, and let's get them as fast as we can. I think that's what we've been talking about. I think the problem is we're afraid they don't have enough time to execute the program.
2:11:53 I guess my concern is, you know. Yeah. Would you clarify your question? So if funding is not, if you don't receive actual funding until July 1st, does that still allow you enough time to do a fall program? On our side, yes. I think, I mean, it seems to me that that question falls more for Kirsten and her team because we have all of our,
2:12:25 Staff, our accountants, our systems, QuickBooks in place. I've briefed my staff already in the last three months. So we're ready to pull the trigger as soon as Forest Island is. So you're ready to go? Yes, sir. And I think they are, too. I mean, they've been at this since October. There's a lot of energy behind it. I agree with, I mean, I feel like there seems to be consensus that we like the project, that it fits with our mission.
2:12:56 I wonder why we wouldn't invest in it in the most expeditious way we can, given the history of it. Maybe that's where we are right now, is do we have enough people who think that it's okay to... I mean, it's not as if we're setting some precedent that's gonna... And just see where we stand. And I think we can fund the 5,000 now. The question is, how much are we going to be able to allocate for programming?
2:13:21 Mr. President, in terms of protocol, Mr. President, I would call for a question, see if there's a motion, see if he gets a second, and go from there. I will take a motion now, actually, one way or the other, preferably to... There's eight and a half grand in the special fund. Are there any other proponents going for it at the moment?
2:13:51 Okay, how they like to be? We don't know. That's going to take a while, isn't it, if someone comes in and proposals on the level. Oh, I'll motion to seat it. Second. Four or five thousand. Okay. Further discussion? I'm leaning towards not going on motion because we're so close to the nervous cycle and that's my biggest challenge. If it was two months ago, I'd probably have been like, yeah, let's get this thing going. And I hate to say that because I want to move things quickly.
2:14:18 Our goal is to be fast and nimble, quick organization. With a cycling deadline just around the corner, I probably don't know on this because we're so close to the cycling. Well, they're going to be going through the cycling. Yeah, they'll still be going through it. They're still going to be going through it. But I think this, what we're finding is, or what I'm hearing, and I'm on council, so I don't know when we're going to first start. But it seems like they'd be a quarter of a year ahead.
2:14:47 And their funding, which is quite a bit of time. Must have been good since October. You know, look, I think there's a good argument, a strong argument either way. I think the people who want to put it through the normal cycle and have it as a complete project, there's a great argument. The people on the board who want to take a risk and go ahead and fund $5,000, let's just put it to a vote and see where we stand. You know what, you know, the...
2:15:12 The transparency is just not something that I can deal with. I think that, you know, I think it is a great program. There's a lot of great programs out there. So, you know, I guess, you know, if this was coming forward as a two-part cycle when it comes in two weeks, you know, I would be more apt to look at it and say I would be happy to fund the $5,000 up front if it meets
2:15:40 up with all the other programs, and it would float to the top. When you say transparency, you can call for a vote. As much as I think it's a great program, too, and I would like to see it move forward, I would probably have to say no. In what you're talking about transparency, I do detect a situation where this maybe sets them up in a different way with the competition for the full cycle. We've already invested in them.
2:16:09 $5,000. I mean, are we more likely to approve their, you know, application or? We shouldn't. I mean, they have to go through the process. They do have to go through the process. Let's go ahead and try a vote here. So the motion is to fund them out of the special funding category for $5,000. Just a one-off payment. Just a one-off payment.
2:16:38 for the scope of work that is in the application. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Okay. Motion passes 2, 4, 6 to 2. Okay. Let's go ahead and raise to make sure. Yes, sir. All right. So now we are... Yeah, thank you. We are to review and consider approving recommendations of parcels.
2:17:30 For future study for an outdoor performing arts center. We have four attachments here. You want to tee us off? Let's start on page 16 of your agenda packet. Then I'm going to go to the leaderboard here and pull this up. Quick background on this to remind ourselves and the public. The town council approved Mammoth Lakes Recreation priority phase capital projects in December of 2015. That included the multi-use facility.
2:17:57 Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, and an outdoor performing arts center. Those are our top three at that point in time. In January of 2016, we, MLR, put together an ad hoc committee. We had 42 people engage in that process over the month of January and into early February. And we reviewed 37 different potential sites and made recommendations to the town council in March of 2016. So we got through quite a bit of stuff. Let me see if I can pull that up my eyes here.
2:18:27 People in the public that don't have a packet. Okay, and I'll kind of scroll through that. In March, the Town Council added the bell-shaped parcel and requested a wetland delineation study. The final, we approved final funding for that in September of 2016, and Town Staff presented that report to the Town Council in January 2017. So it's taken us about a year to get here at this point in time. In the packet, which you found online, are also the documents of the wetland delineation study.
2:18:56 All those other documents the town provided. The ad hoc committee, which is made up because that was a question I had, was made up of John Urdi, Colin Fernie, Bill Taylor, Robert Richards, Brian Knowles, Dan Holler, Sean Turner, John Morris, Amy Grahek, Sandra Di DiMizio, and Gary Morgan. We started with 42, but that was the group that pretty much stayed tight over the next year. There's probably a good 12 that were fairly consistent in coming.
2:19:24 And we started going through, and I'll start walking you through now that agenda packet. Here's the recommended action just to review and make a recommendation for further study by the town council. The background information, are you going to be stubborn on me? Here we go. Background information, I'm not going to read that to you. I'm going to go down to the top of page, the bottom of page 17. We talked about
2:19:48 Created an initial matrix that included those 42 different parcels and based on our study created two tiers. Not all the parcels made it to the tiers. A tier one parcel was already an element of the HVS study which was done on April 2013. It was an outside consultant that came in and reviewed selected parcels and or this or other committee work because some of these parcels have been reviewed by other folks. We've seen this in the past but I'm just doing a quick recap.
2:20:17 Tier 2, parcel needs further research and analysis to determine feasibility. So if you go to page 18, which is the chart you see on the screen right now, and you guys with x-ray vision can see that, you see the Tier 1. On the Tier 1 were our bell-shaped parcel, Mammoth Creek Park East, the snow pit, RV Park and RV Park East, the wood site, the Mammoth Lab of Ancient site.
2:20:43 Canyon Lodge, Whitmore Complex, Shady Rest staging area, and Carey's Meadow. Tier 2, we looked at those, but we determined that they need more investigation at this point, and we said we're not going to look further into those. You see the legend that we used to weigh the work. It was the weight, it was a committee ranking, HVS study ranking, the variance between the two. The HVS study did not review this parcel.
2:21:11 The name of the venue. So we kind of put a coding together. So we begin to walk through these. And I'm not going to walk through all this because we spent almost a year going through this, these hieroglyphics. But the main categories were site considerations. You begin to see the weight and the types of elements. Urban impact on page 19. On page 20, begin to see the access and the weighted statements on that area.
2:21:36 On page 21, you begin to see the financial considerations. At the bottom of page 21, you begin to see our coding on this. The green, which was the Whitmore site, excuse me, the wood site and the Canyon Lodge were considered short term. The blue was long term and the red was not to consider. So I'm going to go to page 22 in your packet and do a quick summary.
2:22:07 Now part of this, we realized that the committee agreed that there should be many scalable parcels in town for events. I mean, there's always animation in town. How do we make this so it's year-round animation? What does it look like? What does it taste like? So we said to ourselves, our first, for short term, something we have our hands on right now, is Sam's Wood Site. And you look on page 22, number one, a little background on why. We realize it is a venue right now.
2:22:37 We're looking at just the four acres, give or take a little bit. It may not be great for the larger venues, but we have it. It's something we can work on, and we know we're in negotiations with a potential buyer at this point. There have been some good conversations. We said to ourselves, what's the backup if Woodside falls out of the mix?
2:22:55 We say Canyon Lodge. We say Canyon Lodge because they've got infrastructure. You know, we've met with the staff, MMSA staff, anything from you guys can control the whole thing to we control the whole thing. You know, so we needed a backup at that point. So that was the rationale for short term. And we got into long term. We had four long term. The snow pit, bell-shaped parcel, Mammoth Lakes Foundation property on the RV Park parcel.
2:23:21 We realize the snow pit is managed. I'm on page 22, long-term blue, number one. It's managed by the Forest Service. And we know there's a magical line down the middle of Route 203 that says nothing can move north of 203. But we believe the snow pit has tremendous potential in the long term for mops.
2:23:42 Camping, really extended stays. The stars, I mean, just tremendous potential, but that is a long-term adventure we need to pursue. Number two, the bell-shaped parcel. We'd be remiss if we didn't leave this on the list. It's a town-owned parcel. We own that parcel at this point in time. If that were to move forward, there would have to be a very public, transparent process that would take multiple months.
2:24:08 To talk about what do we see on that parcel. And that's something that I'm sure is going to actively engage the community. And I don't know if that's something we want to tackle at this point in time based on all the things we've got going. But if I look at this map that I call, you know, the Mammoth Lakes campus, which is four square miles, if you look 10, 15, 20 years out, master planning, where does stuff go? What does it look like? So that's why that's on there.
2:24:36 Mammoth Lakes Foundation, you know, talking to Evan, he'd love to get involved in this. He's putting a surcharge on a ticket. It would help defray the cost, the ongoing cost for the MAC down the road. So it is a viable option. You know, we talked about win factors once again. One of the strengths of the foundation is that we wouldn't be purchasing property.
2:24:54 We could be spending a fair share of money on doing some kind of wind mitigation. How many trees are we going to plant? You know, Colin Fernie made a recommendation that we start planting those trees now. We can probably get some good trees at cost, you know, and begin to think that through down the road because that is a wind tunnel. And then the RV park and the RV park east. You know, some of us had mixed motions on that. We left that on the list right now because you look at the work that's being done with the downtown revitalization plan. Where does that fit in that corridor?
2:25:22 Let's leave it there for further consideration as that unfolds. And you look at some of the conversations that have been had. You know, what happens at the RV park? Welcome to town. You know, do we have athletic fields right there? Do I do, you know, a turnkey project that I set it up for two or three events a year? Do I have a shell that I can do in the winter so we begin to maximize winter programming at the same time? So that's the rhyme and reason we left the nose line is long term. Making sense so far? Okay, and then we looked at not recommended.
2:25:51 Whitmore Complex, on page 23, those are my red highlights. It was a great group to work with. I mean, the 42 kind of sauntered its way down to eight, but it was an active group. On the Whitmore Complex, we felt it was just too far from town. It might be best served for expanded recreation complexes of some sort. Shading Rest Staging Area, it came up. It's a shorter distance from town. You heard Joel kind of make some comments about that. We're not quite sure where that fits, but maybe it should be reserved for another project.
2:26:21 Kerry Meadows, my friend from the Chamber, Sandra, loves the site, all the things up there, but just the access, the Forest Service land. You know, we think it's a great way to use that. It's already being used for other special events under a special use permit. And then the Mammoth Creek Park east, down the road, we may want to look at that as land acquisition as part of the Townside Act. You know, does it make sense because it becomes part of a recreation destination based on the projected project on the west. So at this point in time...
2:26:50 That ad hoc committee that's been meeting over the last year feels very comfortable in our dynamic conversation recommending our analysis of the short-term, long-term, and not recommended to town council. I'll probably take this forward on March 1st. Since March 15th, it's probably going to be a busy meeting at that point. Remember, we're a recommending body. We don't make decisions. We just make recommendations, but I'm very comfortable with it.
2:27:17 How well this committee vetted, especially the capacity of that group, 42 strong to start with. You know, looked at 37 different sites. So with that, that's my presentation, my report. I'm open for questions you may have running me perhaps in public comment. Thanks, Richard. Go ahead, Chef. You mentioned the shady rest parcel on there, and I didn't see it on your analysis.
2:27:44 Here. That's, you know, it's into play. Shady rest parcels in town. Yeah, but did we, what was that? It's approximately 25 acres right in the middle of town. No, no, but why is it on the list? It's not on the list here. I don't think we looked at it on the list. It was on one of the tier two. Yeah. I think that's why. Oh, yeah, it was tier two shady rest parcel. Correct. Yeah, that's, yeah, what was the,
2:28:15 Thinking around? Did you guys spend no time? I don't know that they had the information at the time. And, you know, it's written, we'll call it negotiations right now. May or may not happen. But if it does happen, one of the concepts above and beyond for affordable housing, which it already has an overlay on, and workforce housing.
2:28:42 It does have a component there that is town use. And right now we're looking at anywhere from, you know, four to six acres in the trees. It hasn't been decided what that means, but I think for the short term, I mean, it should be considered to look at. I think that brings up one thing as well.
2:29:12 Although we're looking at recommending further analysis of certain plots of land, which is great. But this all buys into the fact that we've got the town council working on the story map. You have the mountains redevelopment plans. We have the revitalization plan, which connects Shady West Parcel down to the RV park. John Wentworth's working on the modality of how to knit Mammoth together much more effectively to walk or bike.
2:29:39 It just seems that, although this is long-term anyway, and so we have to look at them now, we really need to understand what that design for Mammoth is as a whole. It's going to also skew which way we look to do this. How it all fits in, right. Yeah, and I think that's, it's, obviously we have to look at these places now, but is there any sort of update on when you think that kind of design? We're inching up on it, step by step.
2:30:06 But no, more and more information is becoming available as we get farther along with certain negotiations. I think the picture will become much more clear. Well, and this recommendation wouldn't preclude the council from looking at other, or even us looking at other parcels that suddenly come available.
2:30:29 Seem to work. Maybe without it just gets moved off of the absolutely not list. Yeah, because I think when we looked at Shady Rest Parcel, I think when we looked at it was housing and there wasn't any other discussion about it. And an amenity. I don't know that any of the conversations I've heard were thinking of outdoor venue there. Actually, that brings up a question. When you guys were doing your work,
2:30:51 What sides of a venue were you considering? 2,500 to 5,000 people, right? 75 to 10,000 people. Oh, 75 to 10. 75 to 10? Yeah. We're looking at it. I mean, that's blue as a blue as a. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that brings up a question that I continue to have. I mean, I love this matrix, and I can see you guys put a bunch of work into it, and it's cool because it makes it seem scientific, but it's probably still fairly subjective.
2:31:19 And my concern is that, I mean, I was only at the original 42-person meeting, so I missed some of the process thereafter, but I wonder why, I mean, to me, at that level, 7,500 to 10,000 people, it seems to me that a number of these, a number of the venues on our list are immediately discardable.
2:31:43 Because of that. Because there's no parking. Because of the neighborhood impact. Whereas in this matrix, the neighborhood impact is only one line. It's only rated at four. Whereas you just can't have 10,000 people on some of these parcels that we're talking about because of the impact. You can't have music past 10. You can't have a place to park. So that it's only one of the things. It seems like we, I don't know. There are those restrictions, no question about it.
2:32:14 It's not to say, I talked to an event promoter, and he said, well, you know, kind of like Coachella, where they have different stages. Sure. Okay. They want to get 10,000 people to buy a ticket, but they've got three acts going on, as an example. So if you could have 3,000 at each. So you're saying you want to have Coachella on the bell-shaped parcel? Why not?
2:32:44 Five times a year. Is there something wrong with it? That's not what's being said, Mr. Page. I know. I'm just putting words in my mouth. And you think about the Mammoth Jazz Festival over the years, you know, Jazz Jubilee, that's what it was. You had 10,000 people in town that rotated through different venues. So I think what we have to do is look at all these different venues, to your point, that could house, you know, however many people.
2:33:08 And based on the information that is now available to us with the shady arrest parcel, you know, this group would have the option to say, Rich, add that on to this at this point in time. And part of this is if we're going to move this forward, we're not the authoritative source. You know, the question came up from Joel before, who talks to who? You know, then it's up to town council to take action on which parcels, what's their timeline, then to have staff begin to move this stuff forward. But I just, I do feel like if we're going to approve a recommendation, I'd like to make sure that it's the best recommendation possible.
2:33:37 Sure. From our board. For further study. Let me just finish. Can I just finish one thing? Sure. If we're going to do that, there's this great matrix here, which, again, gives the veneer of scientific analysis. But then when we do the analysis, there's no reference back to the matrix. So we're making a recommendation that basically does not even look at the matrix.
2:34:06 The things that get thrown out aren't because of the matrix. They're thrown out for different reasons. The things that we're recommending for long term, those numbers aren't there. If you're going to go through the exercise of having the matrix, it should be referenced as one of the recommending points, it seems to me. That out of the 10 that we looked at in this matrix, here's what its score was, and therefore it... Matt, I'm here. Yeah, but then when your ultimate analysis, which is what everyone's going to look at...
2:34:35 Doesn't reference the matrix at all. It references the, well, I think it's a green, the color code references the point score. So short-term green is these two. Okay. And then they're the four, the blue ones. Is your point, David, that like, you know, for instance, which one is this? Thank you. One of the excluded ones. I'm having a hard time following that.
2:34:59 Mammoth Creek Park. I just heard David. Oh, it's Mammoth Creek Park East scored 182. I mean, it's the second highest score on the list. And yet it gets, yes. And it's discarded for another reason. It's discarded for another reason. So that's not part of the nature. The higher score, the higher the score is, the less likely we wanted it, right? So it's the lower the score. No, the higher the score. The higher score is the. And remember, we want. We're not doing the English.
2:35:24 This is the imperial system. We went in with the assumption our goal for this committee was to identify a parcel that's scalable up to $7,500 to $10,000. What are those big events that down the road we may want to bring in? Yeah, I'm not questioning the process. I just think the presentation, if we're going to make a recommendation to council and you guys did the work of making the matrix, I would just reference it as part of the rationale for
2:35:54 Either discarding or... Which we could do. That makes sense. Yeah. If I can just segue along those lines. I mean, for me, Mammoth Creek Park East, you know, how it scored, and when I think of that site, and I think if we're trying to build a recreation area there with Mammoth Creek Park West, it seems natural to me to explore Mammoth Creek Park East as a possible events venue.
2:36:24 So my question is why are we taking it off? I think there were some actually, to David's point, there were some arbitrary points to some of this as well, like Bellshire Pass originally was taken off because the likelihood of litigation was so great that it was felt that it wouldn't.
2:36:43 Easily put, and the car parking, I think. I think on Mammoth Lakes Foundation, although it scored probably slightly worse, it was, it's an obvious place to have it. So there was a certain amount of science, there's a certain amount of, well, yeah, we should put that back on anyway. Because, you know, there's only a certain number of sites you can actually look at with any degree of certainty that something could be done at some point. I guess, I guess from an outsider perspective, like, Mammoth Creek Park East is Forest Service, it's south of 395, it's...
2:37:12 Open, I mean, it's, we, it has an operating permit, we can put things on it very simply as long as they're not permanent structures and they don't, you know. I think, again, I think the point with that one was the size was considered too small to house 10,000 people. Well, then we can take a lot of the sites off. Well, that's the, yeah. Can you change the conversation just a little bit? Yeah. The portion here, I'm reading this, the request is to recommend.
2:37:40 That town staff can provide with authority to conduct further analysis. All right, so we're ready to hand this off? Well, I think that's the conversation. That's my question, because before we get to all the little sites, because we're still talking about certain things there, at the end of the day, is it town staff can only negotiate? I recognize there's a certain protocol overall, but to me, is it part of our job to have these conversations with landowners to see where certain things are? I don't really feel like I'm ready to hand this off. That's my problem.
2:38:09 I feel like our job as MLR is to keep vetting the students and say, okay, we've had these conversations, great, but could I have further analysis? What analysis? But making them more viable? Yeah, like RV park, that's an A, getting it to D, or whatever it is. It doesn't make that part of a recommendation, but right now, if I was town council, I'd say, so what do you give me? You want me to tell the staff to go and do more recommendations on them?
2:38:34 Carcels that you've already been talking about, but you need to reanalyze some of this other stuff that's going on. I don't feel we've done our job. Not fully. I think we've done a lot of work to it. And lastly, I would say, Drew, you should go to the meetings to talk about the sites that bring some of these comments up. We're kind of circling again, and we have all these people show up. We need to be part two. If you don't partake of it, to me, you've got to close your mouth and say, if I don't vote for president...
2:38:59 No, but I think it's a fair point. Before we get into all the subsets of parcels, are we ready to hand this off before we start saying we want to make a recommendation? I'm not ready to say we're ready to hand it off. I think there's still some stuff here that we need to conclude before. So you're essentially, this is asking us to recommend for further study. You're essentially saying we should own the further study. Yeah, I'd say why not.
2:39:23 I'm curious to hear what Shields thinks about this because you bring up a great point because all the council's going to do is go, okay, that's great, guys. You know, you've done a lot of work. But, you know, we're going to put you on the back. Throw it back at us. Throw it back at you. Which is, which it works if you give us the authority then to begin to have these conversations. Because right now we are not the authoritative figure. So what if we change the ask?
2:39:49 To, here's the work that we've done, give us the authority to do further research. Including pockets of the ABCs or owners of the market. Yeah, and to build some real market research, to build some real... That's where I'm going. That's what I would like to see. I think that would be a good ask. I think it's a great ask. Because the work's been done by everyone. Why hand it up to people who are going to start again? We're just going to start all over again. We should be doing some more work.
2:40:15 I like it. So then the question on top of that is do we even need to send up a list? Are we just making a request of town council to grant us the authority to pursue? Well, I would, I mean, I wonder if it isn't part of the negotiation of our next contract with the town, that this is the kind of service that we would like to provide and we need to be able to
2:40:40 We need that safety net to know that this organization is up and running and that we can build staff accordingly in order to deliver the service that we think we would like to provide for the council. Because I'm not sure we have a specific ask at this point, other than... This is where we are right now. Is it okay to move forward and talk to these folks? Where, for example, would be really helpful is a lot of these properties depend upon the Forest Service meeting is talking to us. We've had one meeting so far where we were like a side...
2:41:10 The side angle to the whole meeting. We didn't really get to say anything, and it was like a shutdown. But then there was no more exploration with it. So it would be nice if a group of us would go in and say, okay, what are the real chances of any of these happening and talking to them? And there's where maybe it's a question of the town council giving us and the town staff authority to work together to vet these projects. Yeah, on that, you're right. So that with the Forest Service we can go in with Dan.
2:41:37 We can go in with the town and MLR and have a real frank discussion about the possibility of these venues. I think that starts to sound a lot like our mission. I think you're right, Brent. I think that's it. And we're the ones calling the meeting. Yeah. We're taking the lead. We can drive the agenda. Okay. I don't want to overstep our authority, but it seems to be that. No, I mean, we're asking for that. We actually asked for the authority. I think that's... You said right. Yeah. So long as you get the approval, right? Yeah.
2:42:07 Yes, Mr. Mayor. So then are we taking a list to them? Are we saying, hey, these are the five sites or whatever it is that we are asking? Based on, see, my portion of these saying, these are where we're at currently. As we contact, this may change accordingly as new information comes about. And that's part of our process is to reevaluate everything that comes up because something may change between now and six months from now. But we'd say, Town Council, we'd like to make sure you're copacetic with us.
2:42:35 We can ask the appropriate agencies and owners to look for the analysis of these parcels, and here's what we've done so far. I'll second that motion. Okay, so hang on. The list, the list. We should add Shady Rest. Should we just, because we've got a phase two here, should we add Mammoth Park East End and Shady Rest and then present six and just say we want the authority to continue to do some work around these? Is that what we're doing? I think so. Okay.
2:43:04 One question. The RV park is in both columns, Tier 1 and Tier 2. I saw that. Okay, I'm on page 22 and 23. These are our final recommendations at this point. This is what the committee's come up with. So I'm asking for direction from you all in terms of what stays where. I think we're taking those four long terms and adding. So short term we're good with right now. Right.
2:43:30 Yeah, I was thinking more of the long term. Yeah, short term, everybody can be okay with it. And I go back to the authoritative, I go back to the authority at this point in time, because we know what Sam's Woodside, that's already being negotiated with the town manager. So we got to make sure we're all on the same page and not going sideways. So are we just focusing on the long term list? I mean, I don't know that we're thinking of going in and...
2:43:53 Cutting a deal at Sam's Woodside or going up to Bill Cockroft and negotiating. We looked, if you look at our long-term budget five years out that we talked about, we talked about allocating funds to support an outdoor performing arts venue. Right. Or center, excuse me. So as we look at this stuff, we're going to start putting money into these things long term.
2:44:15 Or long? Okay. Okay. You look at Mammoth Lakes Tourism right now, they've already approved $300,000 for infrastructure on a wood site. Assuming. Assuming it's moving forward. I think short term is in the works. I don't think that we have control over what's happening in short term right now. I think that's going to play out, and then that may come back to say, okay, what partner are we as far as that goes? I think we are really looking at more long term.
2:44:44 My only concern with that is if you're not looking at the short term at the same time as long term, we could be planning something that's completely different to people on the short term. Guys, right now, things are very dynamic. I think we at least have to have a say or voice in there. I don't know that we have any... Again, that's where asking direction from council right now is a good idea, I think, because town can say, the council can say to us, you know...
2:45:09 We got shady rest and we got the wood site handled for now. We want you guys to be thinking long term and here's what we'd like you to produce. Okay. So in terms of the list then, are we all okay with these four long term plus Mammoth Creek Park East and shady rest partial? Okay. Well, the only question I'll ask because shady rest to me could be a short term partial. I don't know what happens.
2:45:39 It may not be long-term. It's going to fall in there someplace. Well, again, I would ask for input from the council, too, if the council wants us to look at others. And, you know, with some of these things, it may not be, it may be a parcel that's good outdoor venue, but maybe it's, as Shields was saying, it's scaled back. Maybe it's not the $7,000 to $10,000.
2:46:05 Person parcel. So maybe we start looking at that because we are looking at having different things going on. So maybe it's, you know, there's different types of events that can happen on that parcel and then we're looking at the other one as a larger parcel. Yeah, there's nothing wrong with Mammoth being a multi-event. Well, because another outdoor events venue that isn't even on this list is the Forest Service Amphitheater Outdoors that has parking and holds maybe 200 people.
2:46:33 It would be perfect for certain events, but it's not perfect for Bluza Bluza. Remember, the charge of the committee was 7,500 and above. That was our criteria. So as we're moving forward, is that something that we need to look at? Because there are definitely events that are not the 7,000 to 10,000 people events that we need to have and I think are extremely important to our community. So that's a different charge and a different committee.
2:47:03 So I'm hearing... I'm going to try and get a motion, then I'll be taking some public... But I'm hearing right now, long term, though, I'm hearing four plus. I'm taking Shady Creek Park East, even though the committee recommended not to move it forward. We'll put that on a long term. And I'm hearing Shady Rest Parcel also. Is that what I'm hearing? Yeah. It's already on long term, isn't it? East? You can even put parcels of interest as opposed to just taking them off the table and saying not interested and see where they fall, you know?
2:47:39 Well, that's, yeah, I like the tier two, you know, it's like, it's still on there. It needs further research and analysis to determine feasibility. I'll try this. Okay. I'll start with, you know, how would I start with this? What's here to inform town council on current status and the motion be looking for the agreed upon direction to work with town staff on the short-term sites and be the lead body to engage owner agencies to conduct further analysis of identify at long-term sites. I like it.
2:48:14 Okay, say that in slow motion so Emily can capture that. He's got the two pieces. Emily, capture that for me, please. So we're looking for the agreed direction to work with town staff on the short-term sites and to still be the lead body to engage owners slash agencies to conduct further analysis. Anybody? What do you mean by agreed direction?
2:49:09 So basically, my first part, I'm just trying to go, because our negotiation went on a short-term site, saying that we agree that we'll work with town staff for the short-term, but for long-term, we'll be the lead body to take over the direction, working with the owners, and to come back, basically, at a time for more direction and information as we filter through these parcels. Should we word smith it, or, I mean, it's got all the elements there. Yeah, no, I'm...
2:49:39 I'm willing to second the spirit. So we have a second. Let's get some public comment. Anyone from the public? Ms. Cooper? I've written, I have a copy of my statement. My name is Stephanie Cooper. I own a home in Mammoth and have for 20 years. And I just, I'm not going to go through this word for word. And I can tell from this conversation that you know the bell-shaped parcel means trouble.
2:50:13 And so I just want to say that there are a growing number of people who are very concerned about talk about 7,000 to 10,000 people on that piece of property, that we're concerned with the study that was done by the town and we're looking at it, that the Corps of Engineers will have final say about whether that is or isn't a wet land, and if you don't know, not only surface water but groundwater can be considered.
2:50:40 When wetland studies are done, and that parcel has a very shallow water table. To change the zoning on that parcel will take the Corps of Engineers, the Regional Water Quality Control Board, the Department of Fish and Game, a CEQA review, and you haven't even got to the neighbors yet. So I just, it's, I don't think it's an appropriate
2:51:10 property for this, and I don't think it ought to be on the tier one list. I know the town owns it. There are a lot of people who like what it's owned for now. And I just think, you know, spend your time on the good stuff, because the bale-shaped parcel isn't one of them. Thank you. Thank you so much for your input. Well, I think that, I mean, to me, that reiterates the...
2:51:39 The importance of communication between ourselves and the council and who is the lead on this so that we don't get into doing a bunch of market research and making recommendations and taking into account all of these things only to have the council doing its own work and the staff doing another set of work. And then, you know, I think this is an important step forward from a municipal...
2:52:03 Government and NGO standpoint. How do we vet these things so that it isn't just done because that's all we have or for whatever reason? I think that's a strong comment. I think that's a little bit of what we've been talking about with Rec Commission. Yeah. Kind of what does that workflow look like? Right. That's what that new committee's going to try and solve is kind of let's put a process together that you can really plug any kind of search or project into.
2:52:37 The stages will at least be the same and the roles and responsibilities will be the same. But I think you're right. This is a perfect test. And I think with the right kind of direction, if we have the specific direction to go out and find facts on this and make a real well-vetted presentation and not colored by, oh, well, throw that back on or do this or somebody's personal thing, we really do an isolated, in-depth study of these sites.
2:53:05 I think that's a service you can really provide. I think we should. I think that's what our role is. It's time to step out into the light and say, yeah, we're going to take more analysis on these and come forward. We may find some things that even in the high-graded sites that we're like, you know, for other reasons, whatever. It may not work. Or maybe come up with something else. I think we've got to come up with a full proposal and say, here's where we see it going. Here's what we recommend. I'm just saying, okay.
2:53:37 Could I make a comment? Absolutely. Please step up. My name's Malcolm Clark. I've lived here for, what now, 12 years, I guess, only. I am the vice chair and conservation chair of the local Sierra Club in Inyo and Mono County, but I am not.
2:54:07 I am not, again, speaking for them, but I am here in a sense to observe what they have to say. I do like the direction that your comments are taking in terms of what it seems like you're going to do. I basically support what Stephanie had to say regarding the bell-shaped parcel of the four sites. The bell-shaped parcel, to me, clearly has the largest negative environmental
2:54:36 It is the least disturbed of the four sites, and as a large site, there's likely significant wildlife, I should have said wildlife and flora and fauna presence perhaps, but I don't know as much about flora, whether or not there are any endangered species. Of the four sites, it seems to me it also has, now I guess we're talking about six, of the four sites it also has the greatest potential impact on
2:55:02 Nearby residents, this is from limited look at the proposal and so at the issue. The noise issue would also seem to affect more people at this site than other sites. Because of the wetland presence, as Stephanie said in more detail, it is likely that the environmental approval process would be long and expensive with potential for lawsuits.
2:55:32 I will also note the following sentence in the DEIR, whose comment here concludes today for the multi-use facility at Mammoth Creek Park West as to why the bell-shaped parcel was not recommended for the multi-use facility. Quote, the bell-shaped parcel alternative would be environmentally inferior to the proposed project regarding
2:55:57 biological resources considering new potential impacts to wetlands at this location. It seems to me that if that is true for the Mammoth Creek West, it is perhaps even more true, or at least equally true, for the bell-shaped parcel. My personal preference, last point, would be for the snow pit of the
2:56:22 I haven't looked at all of the detail of all of them. We lived previously in a county in Indiana, north of Indianapolis, that had a major music performing arts outdoor center, which was on the circuit for all the major music performing groups. Deer Creek? Is it Deer Creek?
2:56:43 Is that the name, sir? I grew up in Indiana. I think it changed. Verizon sponsored it at one time, and it had more of the Verizon name, I think, at one point also. I've seen a lot of shows at that venue. Yeah, okay. And this was intentionally located in a rural area, not adjacent to any nearby group of residences.
2:57:04 And I believe this is where, for the sake of residence, such a venue should be located if you're talking about the number of people you're talking about, not the smaller events. And I think the snow pit of the suggested sites is the closest we can come to such a venue. I appreciate all the work you've done, and thank you for letting me speak. Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome. I think we should point out also just the history of the bell-shaped parcel being included. It was originally...
2:57:32 Excluded from the list, from the committee, right? Correct. And then it was placed back on, and I think a lot of the people who, I think when it came to our board, we just, it was more about just kind of some due diligence about a town-owned piece of property, less about a serious enthusiasm to put that venue there. Tom, if I can just comment on that. I felt like when it was brought to our board,
2:58:02 It was a year and a half ago when we first talked about it. It seemed like it was added to the list. The town wants to do a wetland study and a wind study. Yeah, that was March of 2016. That's right. Just about a year now. It was added to the list and it was just like, yes, let's have MLR pay for it really so we can just get it off the list. That's...
2:58:30 A conversation I remember having with someone. Or just have some knowledge, right? It was basically knowledge of where the wetlands are, so we have the ability to look at it for whatever it might be in the future, whether it's this, whether it's something else, whether it stays the way it is. But we would know where the wetland delineation is so that we could have an intelligent conversation instead of just going, well, we don't know until...
2:58:59 We have this information. And I think just one point I want to say a little bit of my frustration is if MLR paid for it back in December. Measure R paid for it? Yeah, okay, sorry. Measure R paid for it. Mammoth, MLR approved, Measure R paying for it. I'm just a little frustrated that we didn't get the presentation on the wetlands study because it was told that MLR would get that presentation in January and I did.
2:59:28 Talk to Rich about that. And it was, no, we weren't going to be having it. I did get to see it on Granicus as it was presented to town council on January 4th. But I think that's an important step if we're approving the funding that we also get to see some of those reports. And if we're supposed to consider these things, that's knowledge that we should have. Sure, absolutely. And that's part of that conversation about who's the lead on these. Yeah, I think that's a fair. Okay. So we have a motion. We have a second.
2:59:57 Further conversation? Any other public comment? Any other public comment? So let's think about all those in favor of the motion? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Moving on now. We are at number eight on our agenda. Review of 16-17 R&U budgets and projected 17-18 R&U budgets. I'm pleased with the fact
3:00:43 It was a challenge for the allocation committee this year to do two allocation cycles, but it gave us the opportunity to backfill and then get in front of stuff. I'm hoping as we go through this process in the next couple of months, we can get in front of stuff. So when council begins their budget deliberations in March, we can step up and say these are some of our recommendations as aligned with our strategy, our programs, our projects, etc. I think if we bring the public in in March and say this is kind of where we're going, give us some feedback.
3:01:11 We need to do a good, transparent process of inviting people in so we have some people in the House. I think it helps us get in front of the curve. So what I did is I've got two things for you here. On the left side, I've got Measure U 16 and 17. And I want to thank Rob Patterson. I did a Sunday communique. I think my last paragraph was, Dear Shields.
3:01:34 I got a phone call or a text within 10 minutes after I sent that out. What do you do on Monday morning at 8 o'clock? So Rob and I sat down Monday morning at 8 o'clock and kind of went through some numbers. So we believe these numbers to be very accurate. Our projected ending balance of the last fiscal year, which ended June 30th, $2,185,274. Our projected fiscal year 16-17 income.
3:02:00 We believe that's up probably by 8% to 12% at this point in time, but I'm going to go with very conservative numbers because the baseline data they've been collecting for a number of years, the average has been about $800,000. Okay, so we believe our projected working capital for this fiscal year was $2,900,000 change. I looked at our approved budget items. I don't know how many more budget items are coming our way at this point in time. We're halfway through. We're beginning to look at closing the window at this point.
3:02:27 You know, I usually found myself in my previous life in the schools that when I got to April 1st, all my team members knew that we closed the budget for the year. Figure out what you need to close school, open summer school so it's done at this point. We know exactly what we got when we close. So if we look at what we spent money on this year, and this is the allocation. For example, the MAC design, we allocated $100,000. Doesn't mean it's all been completely
3:02:54 Expended or encumbered at this point in time. So working with Evan to say, what's it going to cost for some of your design work? Special projects, 25. They think on, I've got, we're not going to eat all that up at this point. So we're going to have some more rollover, which I can continue to refine for us. Transit services was 18 last year. Remember that they, they're not going to use all that. The process agreement, 72. Equipment, 2.
3:03:20 Audit Services 4, Arts and Culture Programming 115. Didn't use all that. I think the allocation on program is 113.2. So we're picking up some nickels and dimes. So the max on this encumbered is 271. So if I take my encumbered, the 271 from the 29, I have an ending balance of June 30 of 2,004. It's cash reserves at this point.
3:03:42 Now what I'm looking at is we get into the next agenda item. You know, the council said we'd like you guys to begin to explore some bonding options, which was something Dan presented to us on August 24th. We had a conversation and now it's back around again. So I did something called A minus B. So my A factor is the projected fiscal income, which is $800,000.
3:04:05 I'm looking at the encumbered base on these for this past year is $271. So $800 minus $271. We get about $528 sitting there right now. So we got more money coming in than going out at this point in time. We were very strategic on that because we wanted to make sure we had a bigger picture of where we're going.
3:04:24 We're trying to save some money for a rainy day as we look at town priorities. I think if we'd done this probably seven or eight years ago when we started this process, we'd probably have some pretty good money in the bank as aligned with the priority projects. So based on that, does that make sense so far? Mm-hmm. Clear? Okay. Then I did projected draft measure U-17-18. Okay, so now I'm taking my projected ending balance of 2-4.
3:04:48 Same 800 in. It's probably an increase of, you know, 8 to 12 percent, you know, so we're not going to plug that in just yet. So we've got working capital for the next fiscal year of about 3 million, too. And projected budget items. And I pulled over things, like I pulled out the MAC design work. At this point in time, that design work should be done.
3:05:08 Are we going to make a recommendation? These are the questions we're asking ourselves as we begin this process. Are we recommending $25,000 again for special projects? Is the town going to come back and still be wanting $18,000 because they'll come back with a new ask for transit? Are the agreements still $7220? They're much smaller. It should be a lighter fee at $360,000 a pop. The equipment replaced in $2,000. The audit service is $4,000. The program in $115,000. By the time we come back to you guys in March,
3:05:36 As Terry alluded to before, Andrea, we'll know how many applications came in. Guys, we've allocated 115, but we got $375,000 in requests. Do we want to modify this at this point in time before the committee starts to dig in in March? I want to put that out there just so we're coming back all the time and looking at this stuff. So if I look at, and then the MAC ongoing support. Evan and I were supposed to meet a week ago tomorrow. Snow got in the way, and then I had to go back east. So we're trying to connect this week.
3:06:06 The 270, what is the appropriate number right now for ongoing? Does that include the repertory theater? Is that involved in that? Is that part of that? You know, we need to have those conversations. We talked about, does the 270 embed the 60 that was going for that staff position at this point in time? We still need clarity on that, and we need to engage in that. If I take these numbers, this is 441. Excuse me. My uncovered is 441.
3:06:35 So if I take my A factor of 8 minus 441, we've got about 358 based on that. So all of a sudden, if we were looking at these numbers as real, okay, that's for you, you know, the next part of our conversation is we want to begin to look at bonding, and if so, for what? You know, we're looking at priorities as we get down the road. Making sense so far? Mm-hmm. Okay. Let me go to U. Just my, that was U. Let me go to R. I was already on off U, okay?
3:07:04 Same process, right? Two sixes are ending balance. Projected income is 1-1. Operating capital for this year is about 3-7. Our approved items, I'm not going to read them. You see them, but that's 6-32. If I take my 1-1, which is my A-line, minus my B-line encumbered, it gives us 4-68, okay? In terms of what we've got. So if you could take 4-68, once again, we are bringing more money in.
3:07:36 Then putting money out. Trying to find the balance based on that Mammoth Lakes landscape. Who are we going to be when we grow up in the next 10 years? What goes where as part of that story map is Shields and Gallery referring to. Then you look at projected. So at the end of the year, our beginning balance as of June 1st with the projected income is about $4.1 million. We got cash in the bank at $3 million at the end of the year. Beginning to look at just rolling stuff over.
3:08:04 Trails, MLR agreements, special projects, Trails End Park Project Maintenance, Whitmore Park Maintenance, equipment, all this town of Mammoth Lake stuff, these are the things that came back at us for the request for ongoing funds based on that system we put in place. I'm imagining, based on where the multi-use facility goes, conversations I've had with town staff, that they may be requesting $75,000 for
3:08:31 Two seasonal part-time workers to support the multi-use facility. That's the only thing I've heard from town staff at this point of looking for new things. They may come back and look at some other stuff. They'll talk at rec commission tomorrow. That encumbered, including, you know, our line items is 645. So 11, which is my A minus my B, gives me 455. So if I look at projected, you do the 455 from R.
3:09:00 And the U of 358, make that 350 easy numbers for the kindergarten teacher, and 450, all of a sudden you get $800,000, you know, if that's something we want to do. We're asked to explore this option, so we're coming back to look at it again. So I want to go back to, let's start with R again. Let's have a conversation. These are expenses thus far.
3:09:26 These are expenses we're going to begin to see that are coming our way that we need to say to ourselves, make a decision in March and go to council as they begin the deliberations in March and finalize hopefully April and May. These are our recommendations. Remember, we're a recommending body at this point. So I'm going to open the board up, open the conversation up about these numbers on the side. Thoughts, comments? Back to you. Yes, sir. You it is.
3:10:00 We have about $6.2 million in cash at the end of 18. Between R and U. Between R and U. With about $500,000. Some of you guys have better than I am. I'm just putting the numbers out there if you guys are beginning to analyze. You made some assumptions there. We go both ways. It could be $900,000. Your $900,000 of technically available funds. Plus, we'll have some other stuff. If we have new product comes on, there's probably some expense with those facilities.
3:10:44 So let's start with our thoughts on what we've got at this point in time. This is making sense. I think it's clear. Concerns, issues. I guess the question for me is, how do we frame a budget conversation around this? Like, you asked the question, hey, we spent $115,000, or we allocated $115,000 on programming through Measure U, but we had...
3:11:14 What was the number in requests? 365. So that's it. So do we want to, you know, is that fair? Is that what we want to do? But how do you answer that question without the capital context, you know, in this discussion? I think that's my problem, is not knowing what we're going to do with bonding or anything like that on the capital side makes it really difficult.
3:11:42 to answer these kind of micro questions about line items. No, no, you go ahead. See, Beth, this goes back to the original framework when we started two years ago, and my question was, we should be saying, we're going to take 30% or 40% will be to capital projects, and here's what we do, and then that kind of finds your conversation. And now we just, we're doing it all background again, because we're asking ourselves, how much money do we have? What if you bond the whole money? What if you don't? How much money do we have? You had to come up with, well, when you had to understand what your budgets were.
3:12:12 How much you're actually ending up with, I mean, consistently. I mean, and I guess we did, Brent, what you suggest with the kind of the ceiling for the allocations. So we did do that work, right? Nah, we voted against that and we said no.
3:12:30 We said we were going to do that. We said we were going to see everything goes. We didn't set any framework for capital at all. We had a hard limit on how much we were going to spend on programming, but I don't think that we derived at it by any percentage. I think it's a great point, and I think now that we've got a little bit under our belts here as far as budgeting goes, why wouldn't we add a line item now so that it isn't just, hey, this is some abstract surplus for a rainy day. This is a capital.
3:12:58 30% capital contingency fund or whatever it is that then we begin to put that money toward it's one of our line items and we have to now get strategic about how we're going to use that. And actually if you look at that we do actually have monies that have been set aside for capital that are not in there that are actually categorized for an allocation.
3:13:21 That goes to the $300,000 for a roof. I think that's in the cash now. I think we've actually moved that over. I think Rob's cut. But we haven't, and that's the problem. And they were allocations that were made that went through a process and that are still supposedly being held in something, but there's not showing it here. I don't know, but I think it is reflected in the projected ending balance of the $3 million. Well, it is, but it's projected ending balance. But if I look at that, I say that I can spend that money on anything I want. Where it actually, there are...
3:13:51 Things that it's been allocated that it specifically has to be used for capital projects. Right. Yeah, and I would call it a capital fund rather than a contingency fund. It's a capital fund, yeah. It's all about what you're able to fund. Yeah. What your income is going to be year in and year out that you'll be able to put towards.
3:14:20 Because I think our, and you know, we have far more money than that, but, you know, our was, you know, $400,000-some-a-thousand, and the other was $300,000-some-a-thousand. They don't care about that. They want to say, okay. Yeah. So, going back to your point, Rich, from that standpoint, as far as the $17,000 gut, it makes sense. $17,000, $18,000 makes assumptions. I don't know about the city, $5,000 yet, but at some point in time, down the road, the MAC facility is still unknown. It still gives us a scale for what we have to work with.
3:14:55 What you're talking about, Rich, is approximately, using 30%, based on these numbers, is approximately $250,000, $260,000. Well, combined, it's $570,000. We'd break it down for both sides. Huh? It's $1.9 million is what you get between both. $800,000 and $1.1 million and the other.
3:15:18 So there's 1.9 at 30%. It's just showing 600,000. No, but you're spending some of it. Oh, you're taking, no, I'm taking by the gross of. I'm not taking the gross. I'm saying, hey, the dollars you have left over is $800,000. Gotcha. But if we're saying 30% would be 600 of it, that leaves us the 200 is our contingency and 600 is capital fund if we're going with 30%. However you want to frame it. I'm saying, okay, that's the money the bonding guys are going to go, okay.
3:15:48 How are you going to make the payments? Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I think it's great that we've been working at it from both angles. I mean, it's important to be able to say these are the expenditures that we've been seeing for two years. Right, right, exactly. History. And, you know, I'll go back to the Measure U, where we're looking at $270,000 towards math, and we have $115,000 towards programming. That's 48% of what your money's coming in is for arts and culture.
3:16:18 when it's a three-tier measure. So I have a hard time just saying just because we have poor things coming in that we increase that amount. You have to make those decisions. You know, if we're supporting MAC to this degree, there's not much... Well, but again, maybe that MAC OG support would come then out of that 30% capital fund rather than coming out of the rest of it. That would get moved into that.
3:16:44 I mean, when that ask comes forward, it's considered for that 30% capital fund, not for the whole one point whatever. We're not just allocating.
3:17:15 I don't know. So, I'm sorry, I'm interrupting you, but when you're looking at that, you have $6 million in the bank, so we're going to put a 20-year bond out there to fund $5 million? When you have $6 million? Well, I think it would be a combination of things. You pay it down and then have to bond the remainder, possibly. I mean, there's options, is what I'm saying. I wouldn't say, hey, yeah, okay, we're going to use bonding money to fund something.
3:17:46 But so for the, just for the sake of what sort of action or what's driving this conversation, the point is to lay this out, to begin thinking strategically, to bring this back at our next meeting with some, some. Yeah, I think you have to strategically, you know, say, okay, how are we going to use the money? But, you know, the numbers are what the numbers are. Right. You're not going to change that. Well, no, but as we look forward to our projected.
3:18:12 Measure U and Measure R recommendations for this coming fiscal year. We do, you know, we're going to say, hey, do we need to amp up the trails budget? Do we need to diminish? Do we need to move the MAC OG support into a different line? I mean, ideally, is that the goal, Rich, to then at our next meeting, basically, to come up with a budget that we will present to council as this is our strategic recommendation for these funds?
3:18:42 Moving this forward, correct. Yeah. And we've still got to go back and, you know, we've talked about priority phase projects. We don't know what the capital gaps are at this point in time. Right. You know, we came in thinking there was an X factor in a multi-use facility and that X factor may become X squared. Yeah. You know, does that remain on our list of priority projects? Right. Do we want to invest money in that? The MAC right now.
3:19:05 You know, we understood that it was coming at about seven. It sounds like it's closer to 11 million at this point in time. They may have a $4 million gap there. So all of a sudden, we're looking at the land acquisition. You know, until we can only identify what these capital gaps are, you know, I'd rather hold the money in the bank if we possibly can before we start saying, let's just, you know, drunken sellers on a Friday night in port. But again, I think it's a huge step forward to take that.
3:19:30 Maybe it's not 30%, whatever that is, let's say 30% for the sake of argument, to be able to say that that's what's at stake for these capital projects, rather than the whole R&U, which up until now, it's kind of been that. Well, at least you have some strategic plan of how to move forward. And we know the things that in the short term we need to be able to fund, or that we want to be able to fund. So we only have X amount left over for the 11.
3:19:58 So we've got $26 million over 20 years or whatever it is. Here's what it is. Here's what we can do for and recommend as an overall funding as we then go back and look at the projects.
3:20:28 And part of this is hospitality industry. As we put this in context, everybody at this table understands what our priority phase projects are. We'd have to use those as basic assumptions.
3:20:49 Try to find out what those fiscal gaps are, capital gaps are, as we move this forward. It would be much more thorough, as you made the recommendation for further analysis on the land parcels, same thing here. These are our strategic aspirations. These are our adopted priority phase projects. Here's the capital gap. Is that still remaining there or not?
3:21:08 We need to be in a position when we get to March to say, okay, you know, as I feed you guys more stuff, yes, no, or indifferent, you know, and what I'd like to do is not to put fuzzy math in this, but I'd like you to go to page 41 for me for a moment. I want to combine agenda items eight and nine, and I want you to look at page 41, and we have three essential questions as we begin this process.
3:21:37 Because this is going to start focusing my Sunday communiques on in terms of guys giving me some feedback on stuff. Number one, after review of the measure R&U, fiscal year 16 budgets, and potential projected 17-18 budget, does the board want to explore a variety of financing options to support our priority phase projects?
3:21:57 So I think we need to be in a position. Go to page 42, 43, and 44. Page 44 specifically begins to show and reminds us of the conversation and the presentation Dan made to us back in August. So that's question number one. Question number two.
3:22:14 If the board wishes to explore options, what is the level of funding that the board wishes to potentially designate for bonding purposes based on the still-to-be-determined capital costs for priority-phase projects, and are they going to continue to be priority-phase projects? You know, what's the bang on the buck at this point in time? And then number three, what do we want to do next?
3:22:37 You know, where do we go with this? I want, this is more of, I'm not trying to frustrate us, but. Yeah, no, I think what you, I think what this is demonstrating is kind of what you said. You made a comment about, hey, I just prefer to keep the money in the bank until I really know what the heck we're spending against. And that goes for that capital fund, too. I mean, 30% is arbitrary until we know, you know, what it is we're.
3:22:59 Raising that fund for. And the same with the bonding. I mean, I think we've got to get some clarity into what the gaps are on those capital projects. And to your point, are they still, you know, our priority phase projects or not? And kind of in the absence of that, sock it away, you know. Knowing that the capital projects are there. Yeah, that there's going to be some way that we're building. We're going to be leveraging the money in some way.
3:23:30 Against what and for how much? It's just tough to say. Well, I think also we have to look at that town agreement, that $200,000 agreement. What is that? What are the deliverables on that? To what extent does this further research that we'd like to do on outdoor events venues fall within that $200,000? Is that enough for that kind of research? You know, we've been really focused on the fundraising piece. That's a really good point.
3:24:00 Kind of back to town is how, you know, we've got the next steps to try and figure out what capital projects to execute against and where, what do you need? And how do we pay for it and get there? And are we a body that can kind of take a next step there? Well, and I go a little bit back to town council, this is normally saying, okay, so let's just say we have a multi-use facility that comes back at $6 million. How much do we need to raise?
3:24:30 We've got $6 million, we've got to direct your $6 million check, but is Town Council looking at us to raise half that price? I think there's deliberation on Town Council on how they would accept that. I know how I'd do it. Because if you told us one thing, that changes our amounts of dollars, because we need $3 million, okay, now we take $3 million out of that, and we've got to raise $3 million, or if we don't raise $3 million, it doesn't happen, whatever the scenario. Okay, then you've got the next project.
3:24:58 I think you have to look at everything in totality. I mean, you can't just say individual projects. No, but I agree, but where I'm pointing to the same, as we're moving forward in the direction of MLR, so we've got $6 million at the end of next year. We've got a raise in a million dollars in this organization, we're raising two, so now we've got $8 million. Okay, that's our resource pool. And we can bond, okay, for $200,000 a year, we can bond, okay, with $6 million, I got it.
3:25:28 I was going to say that was a really fuzzy map, man. I loved it, but I loved it. But, you know, that's our total resource available. So at least we start with a number saying this is what we have. But if we wait another year, we've got an extra $1.5 in the bank or $1,800,000 in the bank. So every year we'll get another $800,000 if that's what we want to do. And if I may interject there, Mr. Truax, I think part of this exercise is to begin to look at we're an advisory body to the town council. The town council.
3:25:57 Is responsible for all the public funds. So at the end of the day, we look at, you know, that long-term story map, that community vision. What funds are available regardless of where they sit at this point in time? And we all agree this is priority one, two, and three. And you begin to maximize the leveraging of those dollars. Is it, you know, a transition in one leadership position that we're now charging one organization to raise money?
3:26:23 Or is that really a town position? They're really looking at economic development. Who's selling the town? Who's outdoing that? But that's a much larger conversation than we're having now. Agreed. Yeah, it is. And it needs to. David, to answer your question, yeah, I mean, somebody's going to have to do the work, you know, do the analysis.
3:26:52 I think this is the body to do that for this particular type of stuff. I think so too. We haven't yet crossed that bridge. When the town does that kind of work, there's a billing strategy. We put a certain number of staff hours, it's worth X amount. We haven't done that. We just take that work on. We need to figure out what that costs our organization. I think you guys are the body to do it. Apart from an ED salary and a program administrator.
3:27:18 I think one of the calculators we need to do is see how much the repayment on the bonds will drag down our balances every year. So we get an idea of repaying $300,000 in 15 years as opposed to $1.1 million every year. We need to see how negative that impacts our ability to function. We need some forecasting. Yes, for sure. Great to lead some analysis here. Yeah, right. Well, what are we trying to accomplish here? So this is what I think I've heard so far.
3:27:46 I'm just trying to put numbers in front of you so you begin to see, okay, this is where we are, this is where we're going, just to start the conversation. I want us to be aware of it because I don't want to be blindsided at March 15th at council meeting and we're not able to step up and at least say this is the scope of the conversation we had, these are some of the ideas we're having right now for us to move our budget recommendations forward. We need from you one, two, and three because otherwise, you know, we were dead in the water at this point.
3:28:13 So I disagree slowly on that one because our job is to say this is where we have funding and sources from. And our job is to say we have a certain amount of dollars that we recommend in this category going forward. We may not spend a dime. We may say we're recommending Town Council. We'd rather hold and pay as cash as we go and not DuMond. But I think we've got to be a little better recommending than saying you need to give us your 123. We need to say how much money. So I'd be more specific on my 123. What's the capital gap on the multi-use facility?
3:28:42 Once we know what that is, because that's got to come from town staff, once we know what that is, then we can sit back and we can begin to gnaw away at that. Okay, we've got to come up with, it's going to cost us $5 million in addition to what we have. And we've got to come back and say, is that still a priority phase project for us, and then how are we going to raise that money? See, I see that's a secondary conversation. To me, it's about, all right, here's six scenarios. Look, you know, we just keep the cash, we put our bond, our cash. Okay, there's how much money we got over this period of time. Take away our operational.
3:29:11 Expenses, right? Okay. That's our first money. That's what we've got now based on conversations because if Town Council comes back to us afterwards and says, okay, multi-use facility, we'll put $4 million in, you guys go raise $3 million. Okay, that may change priorities and how we can do certain things, etc. But I think it's our obligation to go to Town Council and say, there's so much money we have and this is how we're recommending in a general scope how that's utilized and available so we can say we've got $20 million. I know.
3:29:37 I think we're saying the same thing. The fact that we get so much cash in the bank right now, we're not going to make a recommendation for anything besides ongoing expenses until we have more information. Let's take the multi-use facility right now as an example. We have a funding gap of $11 million. I was going to say, does the town have any funding for any of these projects? Right now, no, because it hasn't identified it. But based on what was presented, it's about $11 million.
3:30:07 Okay, now what we've asked Grady and the crew to go back and do, say, hey, okay, can we phase this? Is it going to always cost $11 million? Which is the staff report that's going to recommission tomorrow on the tabletop for you. Yeah, or can we get it down to $8 million? Now we have an $8 million gap, okay? What are the different funding sources to make that $8 million gap happen?
3:30:35 And so that's when we start the conversations with our partners. So are you, I mean, I guess what I'm hearing is Rich is saying, essentially, we need this Grady's work to be done on the MLTU facility, that team's work to be done to know where we stand, to have that conversation from town council about, hey, what are our possible funding sources?
3:31:00 Before we can really reasonably do anything here, what I'm hearing you say is, no, we can go through and kind of say, here's what the pot would look like. Well, I think what you can do is you can say, hey, okay, when the town council or Grady comes back and goes, okay, we need X amount of dollars, you go, hey, you know what, we're willing to be partners on that. We can do $4 million.
3:31:26 So I think we can do both things. I agree. I don't think it makes sense to run out weird scenarios like if the multi-use facility hasn't got us. I'm not serious at all. I'm just saying given, because for me to calculate this out, I would add in some additional costs because there's going to be something else that comes up that we'll pay for. Or lower that $800,000 to $700,000 or whatever it is. Not necessarily what it looks like over time to create. This is our buildup of assets.
3:31:55 So it's a total of the day. Well, you're only taking 30% of the remaining funds, correct? Is that what you're talking? Yeah. Yeah. So we're not really talking about much money. It's not talking about a lot of money. Yeah, and they're saying, okay, here we go. Town Council, this is what we have in total. Right. So as you bring forward and recommend to us for whether it's multi-use facility or anything else.
3:32:14 This is what we're kind of headed down the road of, what we have for available funds. And I think it's important to show the devils in the detail, this is what we're committed to ongoing funds for, to see what that looks like. Right. I think that's the piece where we spend our most time. I mean, we say, okay, this is what we have for capital, and when the capital projects are developed to that point where we can actually look at the financing and the business plans and all that, then this is our...
3:32:36 Fine. But what we know as an organization and as a board is those other line items, and we need to be thinking strategically about 17, 18. How much are we putting into programming? How much are we putting into, I mean, outside of that 30%, what are our priorities? And then I would love to get to a place before they have their budget discussion where we can say, you know, these are pretty hard numbers here for 17, 18. And, for example, the programming allocation, please approve it and let us just
3:33:05 allocate that money without having to come back to you. And then we'll report to you at the end of the year about those things. And just for the record, I think the 30% is just a placeholder. Yeah, right. No, no, no. Exactly. We just throw them, we needed to start someplace. Yep. I'm going to go back and pull all my town council resolutions to look at the one-time set-aside because those one-time set-aside for capital projects may be 30%. I don't know. I'll pull those out and see. I know we don't.
3:33:35 I know we've done some redesignation to the general fund. It was kind of like, okay, we have this much left over this year, so let's put it in. So next steps, solidify these numbers we have right now to confirm these are accurate, but I believe that they are, so I think I've got a good foundation to start with. Work with town staff on the...
3:33:59 Capital cost for the multi-use facility, which gives us an idea, because we come back and start looking at, you know, is it still a priority phase project for us? We need to have some numbers on this. One time and ongoing. Looking at Kevin over my left shoulder here, making sure we get a hold of Evan and confirm what our number is on one-time capital and ongoing cost. Sounds like the...
3:34:21 Outdoor Performing Arts Center piece right now may get pushed back down the road in terms of long term, a little more research and evaluation. This stuff is more short term, so I think it will help us begin to think about what are our priority phase projects. Down the road, the Aquatic Center is going to come to the table too at the same time. And then number two, I would go to page 41 again. It sounds like we can't answer these questions about bonding until we have some stronger numbers, some accurate numbers.
3:34:49 And once we get some accurate numbers, then we're willing to step back and say we will consider, but we need X to make that happen. And I think in our transparency with our community that we need to show that, okay, if this project's moving forward, it's putting these other projects on the back burner or off the table. And so, you know, that's where we have to set those priorities. What are those ones that we want to move forward?
3:35:12 And how much information do we need in order to be able to make that decision? To be able to make that decision. Yeah. Yeah, and I'm kind of doing a reverse with Dan presented to us by saying, okay, if 30% is pro side, in reality, we've got $5.5 million that we can bond. That's it. So it's not a lot of money. We're already down the road just trying to show we don't have $80 million. That's where the other funding. That's where we need to do fundraising, and we need to do that. But you also need to have...
3:35:40 The realistic numbers and projects so that we can, yeah. Exactly. Okay. All right, guys. So we know where we're headed. I got some ideas. And I want to thank publicly Mr. Mayor, Rob, for the work he's done to really confirm in some numbers. Yeah, we're really, really thrilled to have him. Yeah. He's doing a good job. I mean, I'll sit down with numbers and he's a good communicator, makes it simple for me. It's understandable. He's patient when I ask silly questions.
3:36:07 Thank you, Rob. Thank you. That's a big upgrade. Yeah. Okay, on to committee reports now. Fund development and communications. We haven't met. So no report there. Allocations and reconciliation committee. Basically, the process is moving forward. I want to get the allocations committee to actually go through and test out the scoring.
3:36:37 piece before we actually work through all these applications. So anyhow, hopefully next week we can do that. Friday I'll have something out to you guys to look at and then we can go from there. Okay. We've got a big trails report today, but Mammoth Trails Committee, anything? No, I think Joel covered everything. Okay.
3:36:59 I think Joel has done a fantastic job. Yeah, yeah, I agree with you. He just takes it to heart. Absolutely. He gets it done. There's some efficiency there that I would love to see spread throughout our other endeavors. And that's the conversation I've been having with Joel right now. The contract that the town signed with the contractor allows the opportunity to extend it for one or two years.
3:37:24 Extend without going through a new RFQ or an RFP. So I started a month ago with Joel. The allocation is $300,000. What do you get for $300,000? If you want to do X, Y, and Z, what's it going to cost? $300,000 plus X, plus Y, plus Z. Give me a base on $300,000. Don't come in the back door and say, well, I need an X factor. And I said that to him and Rob last week. I said, it's kind of like, you know, I remember my daughter Mary in 11th grade. She wanted to go to the prom and she needed to have it.
3:37:54 A prom dress. I'm like Mary. We're not getting that prom dress. We're not going to spend that kind of money on the prom dress. She pitched a fit. I said, I guess we're not going to the prom. So we need to be in a position right now. What are we getting for $300,000? What's our base? And we can begin to add back, especially as we begin to look at some of these numbers. And the same thing with the talent contract on the allocation for $200,000 for MLR at this point.
3:38:19 What's the ask for? It was $300,000 two years ago, but we realize that we're, you know, be penny wise and pinch pennies right now, you know, be really transparent with the money. We need to begin to really think about those things, and that's the purpose of these conversations. What's it cost to do business? And in the context of committee report, that is work that we're doing this week. We're starting on Monday.
3:38:39 To look at, okay, here's what $300,000 has been getting us since we've had a trails coordinator and do we need more or is that enough or, you know, let's look at the projected projects within the trail system. So I hope that by our next meeting we'll have a line item there that's very directly linked to the actual projects on the ground that we're... And I reminded Joel that the trails agenda should be published this week for next week.
3:39:06 So we got to move along fairly expeditiously on that. Yes. Okay. We're meeting Monday, I think. Thank you. Performing arts ad hoc. Dre has already given us a report on that. Okay. Financial reports. Let's go to... No, I'm good. I need to go relieve somebody for dinner that I should have already allowed to go. So I need to get going.
3:39:38 I'm going to cast our attention on instead of every line item. Let's go to page 48. I want to do a mid-year check-in on this. This is July through December 2016. I'm on page 48. And on page 48, income, you look at our individual contributions, some of the fundraising we've done this year, limited, but $27.75.
3:40:10 The government grant, which is that 16 and change we get. Fundraising income, 2441. So we brought in, you know, a few thousand dollars, you know, in the first six months. Expenses, we got into this because of the candidate search. You look at line item, 6,100 business expenses. Candidate search, we only allocated $150. You know, we spent most of that between working to find the Miss Lovely, Miss Woods, and also board members, we did advertising.
3:40:39 Contract services, $6,200, nothing really exceptional there. You know, we may not be spending a lot of that money. We could probably redirect that. Office supplies in $6,300. We haven't spent about 50% of that when we're halfway through. But the insurance this year is costing us a little more than we anticipated. Our directors and officers, it's $19.41, and that's an annual cost. Liability service.
3:41:06 Insurance 2386, Workman's Comp 1140. We projected 2,500, so we've got to make sure we regroup on that. That's an annual cost, but it's twice of what we anticipated. Payroll expenses breaks it down in terms of where we are in terms of payroll for two staff people. Organizational growth on 6,600. Discrepancy between budget and actual.
3:41:35 Benefits, that was you front load the Executive Director's all his vacation time up front. All that PTO is up front and it burns so it becomes zero at the end of the year. My contract says you've got to use it by the end of the year. There's no carryover, no buyout. Contingency, look on page 49, the 69-100. We've got 64, 68 in there in contingency.
3:42:03 That could be used as something arises such as a search. Probably could use maybe some of that. And your fundraising income from $4,400 and the individual contributions, all of a sudden you've got $10,000 sitting there. That probably could be redirected if we found ourselves. Remember our conversation with Friday Breakfast. I approached MLT to see would you be interested in helping a partner program to conduct a search. It was a smile and that was about it.
3:42:33 So we've got to figure some of that stuff out still. I had similar reactions. Yeah. But total expense right now. Go to total expense. See the 92, 309, 66, third line from the bottom on page 49. Okay, we budget 101.
3:42:50 So 92.309.66 times 2 puts us at 184, our operating budget being 200, so we're still operating below the allocation at $200,000 just for administrative costs and organizational expenses. So that was the one big thing I wanted to point out. One thing I'd mention, and David's brought this up before, I think we should be, we've allocated money for copy editing, graphic design, website development.
3:43:19 These things. I mean, it's a few thousand dollars, but I think we need to be, you know, I mean, if you're telling me we don't have any work to do in that regard, I think we need to have a conversation. We think we should be spending the money. Emily's in the process right now of working with Christy Osborne, looking at our communications plan. They'll begin to dig in. Emily's found some good things right away. We could do this. We could do that. So we'll dig in a little bit deeper there. There may be some expenses down the road.
3:43:48 On graphic designs, we spent a little bit of money on that end of the year poster. Probably spent a little more money on that, making hard copies, getting up around town. When we start looking at a membership campaign, bring something back. Excuse me? Why are we doing a poster and putting that around town? There was the end of the year report that we put together that we emailed out to everybody. Nice little video, a nice little poster. We did our soft campaign at the end of the year, so we want to take some of those.
3:44:16 Posters that Aaron cleaned up for us and post some of those up around town. Tell the story. Okay. I guess I'm trying to figure out why we're doing that in a poster. So anyhow, I would assume we do it electronically. It is done. It's been done electronically. We did press releases. We've done web postings. We did an email. And we did a soft end of the year campaign. And we want to do a hard copy. So when people walk into The Good Life, you know, they see it on the bulletin board. They're, ah.
3:44:45 More visual stuff. That was the purpose of the poster. I don't know. Okay. Seems like... Yeah, I mean, I would like to see us start to use that strategically and to say, like, looking forward, okay, we've just committed ourselves to a certain amount of due diligence on outdoor recreation venue, for example. There's a place where we could use some copywriting. We could begin to put together a proposal that looks good, that makes sense, that has...
3:45:15 That's a place where we can outsource and find, you know. And I guess I'd like to see, you know, where should we be putting that information to get the word out as to what we're doing? Choosing the channels as a board? Well, I don't know. I guess I'm having a hard time with a poster. It seems like money that we're spending. What was the cost? $90. Okay. For people who we don't already have in our database. Okay.
3:45:45 I think that's one where I just want to trust staff and have a committee, a communications committee kind of look at. But I do... But I understand your point. I do think it's, as you said, I mean, we haven't met as a communications committee in a long time, and that's probably something that we should put on an agenda and say, hey, what can we do with this money in our next fiscal year? Absolutely. And bring it to the board. Just show.
3:46:13 And just looking at this with some of our hard costs, accounting is over. You know, as an organization, we're now, you know, a couple years old, so some of those things, you know, we kind of picked a number thinking that this is what it was going to be. So I guess looking at things like that, were there expenses in there that were kind of outside the ordinary or is this going to be kind of the ordinary amount that we're spending each year so that we can better budget these numbers? So, anyhow.
3:46:39 And year one, I watch it, so I try to build year two based on what I saw on year one. But the insurance, I put an email into salary today when I started digging up the package. What's the difference? She hasn't got back to me just yet, but I don't think the cost has been that much greater. But, okay. Yeah. So, other questions on it. So, we're $143,000 in the road budget right now, and that's mostly due to contributions. But what I'm going to do is the next.
3:47:08 Six months. And that whole budget in front of me, that's why I'm asking you to reach the question, are we okay with our expenditures, because did we plan on using some of this towards operation, or do we have enough money? We have enough money. We're good. Just trying to make sure we're... Yeah. We'll be able to cover our bases. Yeah. If we say, as we are right now, based on the government grant, Solamente, that our end of the year, expenditures would be 184, 613, 32.
3:47:37 On a budget of $200,000. So we'd have $16,000, $14,000, $14,000, $14,000, $14,000, $387,000. And we can carry over up to 5%, to me 15% of the allocation of the $200,000, which is $30,000. So we'd have close to $15,000 in carryover. All right. Any other comments, questions about finance? Okay. Let's see.
3:48:11 Richard, are you done or do you want to go to another attachment? I'm good at that point. Okay. So now we are at the end of our agenda here. Town Council liaison request for information to report back to Town Council. Yeah. What do we want Shields to bring to his people? What I have down is I have, we went through a budget review. We're getting ready for the town of Mammoth Lake's budget discussions and we're including the capital.
3:48:43 Project spending in that budgetary process. I don't know. Is it appropriate to do that? I mean, we're going to do a press release, right? Press release, pretty much saying what I said before. Press release, thanking the community for the work. You know, we're evolving as an organization at this point in time.
3:49:07 And we really need to, as we evolve as an organization, as a community, we really need to have somebody that's got more experience in this role, somebody that's, you know, well-connected with the outdoor recreation industry. It's a multi-billion dollar industry in this country. Somebody that's got experience in nonprofits and somebody that has got major successful experience in fund development in programs and projects.
3:49:31 I'll leave it to Rich, actually. Yeah, I don't think that's where you would put that in. Well, except that, I mean, in the context of what Rich just said, we're talking about going full-court press into a search, and we're going to need council's support and connections, and we need to get that word out publicly in every venue we can. We want to be transparent. It's not like we're hiding something at this point.
3:50:01 Somebody from the board at public comment. Okay. And something. Okay. And then I can expand. I mean, do you have a, is there a moment where you do a report, like an MLR report out? It's just during my council member reports. Or maybe it's a joint thing. I don't know. Was that something you want to put out there? Like, you mean us go? The two of you together. I think, I think might be, maybe part of public comment. Yes.
3:50:36 It's so good. I mean, surely this is quite a pivoting point for MLR. As an NGO of the town council, the message to the town council is, we're just leaving. We need the scope of work, and we need the money to find the guy that we're all saying we're looking for. And those are pretty damn urgent requests. So this is a pretty pivotal moment for Rich to be leaving. And that has to be, the town council has to understand that this is the time to act. Right. I think it would be.
3:51:05 Best if somebody from the executive committee would come and say, you know, we're doing a pivot, you know, everybody's, uh, it's already been vetted out and we've discussed it, uh, with our founding executive director and, um, just want to let the town know that we are going to be going through an executive search. As the hush comes over the crowd.
3:51:29 I don't know, can you make that? Would you be able to come and stand with Rich and maybe stand side by side? Yeah, we can make some comments together. I mean, I want to be sensitive to Rich and you kind of tell me what you want. I do agree that we should probably have some public declaration of our intention and our direction. But in a quiet setting, people watch town council much more with all due respect than our board meetings.
3:51:56 And then put town council on notice you're coming after them. Yeah, and this is what the pivot includes. The organization realizes a sense of urgency to accomplish our mission. This is mission critical. Our executive director realizes he doesn't have the skill base to move this organization to the next level. We've got a good foundation in place. We're moving this forward.
3:52:20 You and I have gone back and forth this a couple times, so we'll figure it out. We'll be fine. We'll be fine. Yeah, yeah. It'll be fine. Thank you. Thank you, guys. Thank you. Yeah. Okay. Anything else? When will the press release come out? I'm finalizing it. My lawyer looked at it when I was out of town. Sent it to me Saturday, Sunday. I haven't looked at it yet. I'm going to take his responses, clean it up a little bit, and get it out. Press releases are due at 4 o'clock tomorrow to the press for publication of the paper.
3:52:49 Can you send an exec committee for what? Yeah. So we should look for that tomorrow? Yeah, probably tomorrow, tomorrow morning. Okay. A little book tomorrow, so I'll do it the first thing, 6.30, 6.45, get it out quick. Cool. All right. With that, I will ask for a request for any other future agenda items for our next meeting. Anyone have anything they'd like to see in the agenda? No. Okay.
3:53:20 So let's adjourn the meeting then. Thanks very much guys. That was a marathon. That was actually a marathon in the new.