Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2017
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 1 hr 58 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
271 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 I believe so. Hi.
0:29 Something goes until 3. We don't have a workshop. No, we do not have a workshop. You can thank Kirk for that. That was a little confusing. How about yourself? Great, thank you.
0:58 Okay. Okay, I didn't even want to compound the question by asking. Compound the problem by asking. I spent a lot of time with his dad. Where is this not going? How do you know that? For eight years. I would guess, yeah.
1:20 What? We were on here, our discussion with Afia, with John. I don't know, I didn't ask him what he does. Just review your strategic initiatives. He played eight years on the tour. Do we have one? Do we have that on there? That we reviewed our strategic initiatives with John. No, you can do that as an ad. Okay, I'll just do that as a board member comment. Yeah, that's good. Because, you know, he's pretty intense. Phone's not dialing out to the conference for some reason. He wouldn't have had the option that Hayden had to not skate yet. Let's put it that way.
1:49 Hey, Bill. Okay, guys, let's get going. A lot to cover. We can actually start on time for once. I think we're already late. We are. I don't want to be any later. Come on, Colin.
2:18 Now, let's go. You're here? You're good? It's all good? I haven't got a corner, man. I got a, I got a, I got a, I got a, I got a, I got a, I got a strike while the iron's hot. It's all loaded up. Right, forward, left, back. I just wanted to make sure, like, we were all good. No, you're good. I got it. It's all good.
2:47 Alright, great. I'm gonna go ahead and call the meeting to order at 1.05. Yeah, 1.03. We're good. Alright, we'll be roll call. John, I'm here. Kirk? I'm here. Brent, we'll be late. Michael Adesma? I'm here. Colin? I'm here. Sean? Hello. Eric, we're trying to get on the phone. Eric, are you here?
3:13 Okay, perfect. Thank you. Eric's here. Paul Rudder is not going to be here. And Scott is not here. Eric, we're getting going. Can you hear us? Okay. Great. Right. Are there any, to get started, are there any board member comments, reports, or agenda additions for our meeting today? Just a general one. That sure was a lot of snow. Yeah. Business in the middle of it all. Yeah. Yeah. And I think we've all learned a few things about
3:46 The town and our businesses and the number or lack thereof of extra people there are in town to help out when we need it. So it was definitely challenging. I just got back from the ski trade show. Everything is alive and well in the industry. All smiles this year as opposed to other years.
4:07 You know, everybody's got great conditions and great snow. Utah's got a ton. Pacific Northwest's got a ton. Colorado's got a ton. But Word is definitely out. Anytime you tell somebody from Mammoth right now, they're like, well, it's got a little bit of snow, huh? So Word's getting around the industry. Everybody's doing really well. You know, kind of the mood is very positive in the industry right now. That's great. A couple of good years back to back. Anyone else? Product selling. I would just say that I've,
4:36 Got some really good feedback on JetSuiteX over the last three weeks. People that are flying up that want to, you know, just to recreate, but there's really, I think, a sector of people that commute back and forth. Either they live here and they work somewhere else or they have a second home. And I didn't see, I really didn't see it at first, but I think there's a lot of traction to be had there with people that fly frequently.
5:03 Can book out in advance, get the better rates, have the reliable service, and of course the non-TSA private experience. And I'm working, I have my first flight on next week, and I plan to talk to passengers and get more feedback direct from them, whether that's things that can be better or whatever they're over the moon with. And I'll report that back to the board next meeting.
5:27 I had just two things real quick. One, just from the lodging side, we had a lodging meeting yesterday, and one of the things we talked about was the, I think that in general, we are all, we're all pretty pleased with the way that most of the lodging people handled guests and the, and the, and the,
5:45 The difficulties we had during those few days where the roads were closed and so forth, I felt like a lot of people were very understanding and gave either half price for people that couldn't leave or really deep discounted nights or held money for future stays or refunded money. There was a lot of goodwill. People weren't like, nope, sorry, roads closed.
6:06 Too bad, you pay, we don't care, blah, blah, blah. I mean, I'm sure that there were, you know, probably a few people that did that, but I think by and large, the feeling was that everybody was pretty congenial about that. And that will, you know, we all know that that, you know, in all of our businesses, that pays huge dividends down the road when you're understanding. You imagine, you know, a family of four that has to get back to work, kids have to get back to school, they've just blown several thousand dollars here on a weekend, and the last thing they really need is to get trapped here for a day, and for us to gouge them for full rate for another night is pretty rough.
6:36 Everybody was pretty understanding with that, and that makes me feel good about where we are. That's a good thing. All right. Eric Forssell, do you have anything to add on the board member updates or reports? Okay. I do have one. Oh, I'm sorry. Go ahead. All right. I was just going to say, you know, just because it's almost promotion. Beluza Beluza tickets are on sale, and we're on track with previous years. Gates open in 26 weeks in one day. So we're already, you know, kind of planning on that.
7:06 And John, I just need to add the PR update under the department updates. Oh, PR, okay. The last thing I wanted to add was that John Urdi, myself, Colin, and John Wentworth met and we discussed, in a little more detail, we discussed some of our strategic initiatives and sort of how much the, sort of the funding that we had talked about as far as what was, you know, what was earmarked for which different things as far as the airport and the
7:35 Sorry, I just went completely. Thank you, Events Center and so forth. So we did, John just wanted a little more detail on what our thoughts were as far as financial commitments and so forth. And so we had a pretty good discussion about that. And obviously they'll, Council will continue that conversation with Council as things go along and get things to go down a little bit more. So that was good. Anything else? Any other comments? Okay. Any public comment? I thought Rich was going to be here, so I don't see that. Rich, okay.
8:04 All right, let's move on to approving the minutes from last meeting. This is the January 4th meeting. Do I have a motion to approve? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes. Do we have a second? A second. Any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Anybody opposed? All right, John, MLT presentation. I guess it's Michael.
8:35 Good afternoon, gentlemen. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Today I'm going to do a brief presentation on MLT's focus in really two specific Asian markets. That's going to be South Korea and China, two areas where we've gone in with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, with some contract services in those markets. But first...
8:58 I'll walk through both markets with a little bit of research that I blatantly stole from Visit California and parked on these slides and hopefully didn't take too much credit for. First, we'll jump into South Korea. So as you can see from the slide here, and this is all, again, on that printout in front of you so you can take it home and kind of digest it a bit at your leisure. But you can see the amount. South Korea is the second largest inbound market into Los Angeles, international inbound market behind China for the Los Angeles market. So it's a big market for California.
9:27 Visitors spend a little over a billion dollars. California market share is 27.4% of the overall visitation to the United States of America. So California gets just a lick below 30% of the Korean visitation into the United States.
9:42 Visitors to California, 440,000 in 2015. The forecast, these are all the latest numbers that Visit California has. These should be updated, I would imagine, within the next couple of months. But they were projecting a 17% growth in this year and a 59% or almost a 60% growth by 2020. So it's a market that travels a lot. If you look to the column on the right, you'll see the average length of stay, which is the number that jumps out to me, is 13.2 days.
10:11 in destination, which is a long stay. So not necessarily will the first time Korean visitor to California may want to spend their time in the gateway cities of San Francisco, San Diego, Los Angeles, but the second repeat visitor or the third repeat visitor, they're going to want to see things outside of the gateway. So that 13.2 day length of stay is going to translate very strongly for those folks coming up to visit us in the non-gateway parts of California.
10:41 A little bit about the lift, you've got 61 weekly nonstop flights into two gateway cities of California, LAX and SFO, so a lot of lift coming in to California, so a lot of opportunity there. Again, you can kind of digest this on your own when you get home, but on the column on the right, you'll see the bookings. There are 20 really high volume agencies that handle about 80% of the business.
11:08 Of those 20, 15 of them are located in Seoul. The other five are located in Los Angeles. So there's great opportunity for us to get in front of those decision makers and influence why Mammoth Lakes is a choice spot, summer or winter, for their travelers to consider as part of their itinerary. Competitive landscape for the Korean business. If you look on the left, you can see we're up against really Canada and Japan for ski.
11:35 Australia, New Zealand, nature, hiking, family. Europe is always going to be a strong competitor just because of the cultural heritage. And then they definitely like to go to the resort destinations, the Maldives, Thailand, probably put Bali on there as well.
11:52 And Hawaii would be the only U.S. state that kind of falls into that resort destination. California, when they come to California, they tend to move a little bit more. They're more mobile. So they're going from Los Angeles to San Diego to San Francisco to Mammoth, Yosemite to Death Valley, Palm Springs, another hot spot for those guys. Market barriers for the Korean inbound. There's some issues with the exchange rate with their currency.
12:18 They're always chasing new destinations. If you look on there, you've got Croatia, you've got Poland, Czech Republic. The weird one that kind of jumped out at me, and this was definitely reinforced when I was over there earlier or at the tail end of 2016, there's an unrealistic fear that the United States is a very dangerous place to travel because of our gun violence. So they honestly, there's a...
12:43 There is legitimate fear in that population that gun violence is rampant in the United States of America. Current political U.S. climate, I mean, everyone is abreast of what's going on right now. It definitely is filtering down to all of our international markets, including Korea and China. So I put that on there as a strong bullet point. Again, you guys, when I'm done, if you want to throw any questions my way, please do, but you have the opportunity to take this home. This is a super chewy slide, lots of information on there.
13:12 I may just leave this to you to read when you guys have a chance at your leisure. This is a little bit more of rounding out who the Korean traveler is, what time of year they go, what they like to do when they're not skiing or they're not visiting the national parks. Shopping is a big one. Luxury brands are a big one. They like to travel during their big national holidays. So there's a lot of information on there. And again, I'm available for questions about that.
13:41 The biggie for us when we started considering going into Korea with an in-market agency was the 2018 Winter Olympics. So the 2018 Winter Olympics are going to be hosted in South Korea. Pyeongchang is the name of the city. It's the first time Korea has hosted a Winter Olympics. They hosted the 1998 Summer Olympics. And this will be the third East Asian city to host a Winter Olympics behind two different cities in Japan.
14:09 Pyeongchang is a city about two hours away from Seoul. It's a very established and mature ski destination for Chinese, Koreans, Vietnamese, a lot of East Asian countries. But with the Winter Olympics coming in 2018, the national government has pumped a ton of money into further developing the infrastructure in this resort area, as well as establishing a ton of high-speed public transportation to and from Seoul.
14:39 So this area is going to showcase very well for the games. Obviously, we all know who Chloe Kim is. She's a big reason we decided to go in for this market for the representation. Besides being a Mammoth Resort-sponsored athlete, she's also an official ambassador for Visit California. And as you guys have all seen her, she's going to be...
15:01 What we think the takeaway star from the games. She's incredibly competitive. She's incredibly dynamic on TV, vivacious, all that kind of stuff. According to our Visa View reports, this is what the Korean spend has been in Mammoth Lakes. If you look on the left, you've got 2015 with a total of $40,000, a little over $40,500.
15:21 I broke it down to where they're spending that money or where they had spent that money in 2015. You can see the bulk of it is in lodging, and that lodging number does not include OTAs or online travel agencies, Orbitz, Expedia, that kind of stuff. So that number is probably small compared to what it would be if we did have access to that OTA lodging number. If you look to the right, you can see that that has grown substantially in 2016, and that number is just the quarter three.
15:47 So I don't have Q4 reports yet. If you look below the $65,000 bullet point, you can kind of see when they're coming based on their spend, Q1, Q2, Q3. So the majority of the Koreans now are coming into Mammoth Lakes spring, summer, fall, based on the spend in Q2 and Q3 as opposed to Q1.
16:10 And again, if you look at the bullet points down below, you'll see the majority of it in the lodging. The sporting good one kind of was interesting to me how it kind of dwindled from 2015. Sporting goods would obviously be if they're buying snowboards or hiking boots or poles or that kind of stuff. And then they're clearly renting condos and buying groceries. So that's another interesting little...
16:34 Profile on the Korean traveler when they come to Mammoth Lakes. I was just going to say, it'll be interesting to see what happens with the sporting goods once you add Q4. Yes, this is actual, this isn't research, this is data.
16:44 These are hard. Directly from visa spending. And this number, the Korean number is going to be more reflective of the actual spend than the Chinese because Koreans tend to carry visa at a much higher rate than the Chinese. The Chinese have their own credit card that, so the visa numbers won't be as true as this report here for the Korean number. But you see exactly what they're spending.
17:07 in our zip code, so in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and kind of see what time of year. But when we add Q4, you're going to more than double last year? Yeah, more than double last year when Q4 is added in, yeah. Is there a specific reason, I'm just curious why Q2 is bigger for them, April, May, June, and what sort of... I think right now we're known as a summer, fall destination, spring, summer, fall, so we're catching them on their way to go hiking or fishing or Yosemite National Park or Bodie or...
17:32 You know, maybe a little bit of spring skiing. There's actually a very strong Belize-er industry in Korea where people come to Los Angeles for work and then tag on a little ski holiday. You'll see a little of that in Big Bear as well for day trips, but we definitely get a little bit for spring skiing. Got it. Okay. Thanks. Any other questions on this one? Guys? Seems low. Is this, and I'm just asking as far as, you know, that's 40,000 or in 2016, that's total for the country.
17:59 Total for our zip codes. So not total spend for the Koreans in California or the United States. This is what they're spending in the 93546 zip code. And again, this right now is not a juggernaut of a market for us. There's no question about it. But we're zeroing in on this market for intense representation because of the buildup to the games and because of Chloe Kim.
18:26 We just, we want to, we want to ride that wave as strong as we can to get Mammoth Lakes established as a premier ski destination that you would go to, you know, on that 13.2 length of stay, days of length of stay, come to Mammoth Lakes and ski 10 days, go see a city, go see family, take care of business, whatnot. So the contract we signed with Avia Reps was for 30...
18:49 $38,000 annually. This company also has the Visit California contract in Korea, so we're definitely leveraging a much larger contract that the state of California has with them with a smaller contract that we have signed. We share that contract with Mammoth Resorts, 50-50. Messaging is year-round, so we want to be known as a year-round destination, but right now we're putting probably about 60 to 65 percent of our resources into the winter messaging.
19:18 Because, again, we want to parlay that enthusiasm about the 2018 Games and our association with Chloe Kim. Ski message is only focused on Mammoth Mountain. I think that's really important that we all know that. Mammoth Resorts has four different mountains. We didn't want to have our message necessarily diluted with Bear and Snow Summit, so the contract we signed with Avia Reps, their talking points are Mammoth Mountain and, to some extent, June.
19:48 But definitely Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Mountain. Contract includes travel, trade, PR, and social media components. We have a dedicated social media channel, so they're pulling all the feeds from all of our platforms, from MLT and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, translating them, and then pushing them out into the Korean market. So it has definitely a sense of legitimacy because it's being translated into the native language.
20:11 PR is pretty general. Again, it's translated, being pushed out to traditional print media. We'll be hosting bloggers. We'll be hosting writers. We'll be hosting videographers in the next 12 to 18 months.
20:26 Sales training. So we will be training their staff into exactly the talking points we want to have in that market. Between Nico, Kristen, and myself, we'll be going over there twice, if not three times in 2017. And again, to do, to hand sell Mammoth Lakes as a summer product, hand sell Mammoth Lakes as a winter product, and to train the staff that we have employed on exactly how we want them to present Mammoth Lakes, both summer and winter.
20:55 Any questions about Korea before I bounce into China? Yeah, I have a quick one. Fire away. So obviously the Far East market is one of the hot ones. Can you give us a little relative comparison to an established market that's already coming to Mammoth from Europe, say? In terms of numbers or spend? Yeah, I mean, I see the growth. It looks like it's double.
21:23 You know, 2015 into 2016, and I can see growth further 2017 and 2018, but in terms of spend, yes, is this, does this make you think of the German market or the Italian market? Do you see the same growth potential? I would say, yeah, I would say that the thing that kind of would strike me as a similar European market that we've,
21:50 that we've started pushing the needle with recently in the last couple years would be the Italian market. So the Italian numbers have grown year over year by double digit numbers. We started a representation service contract in Italy about three years ago, and since that has gone into effect, that relationship, that needle has moved at a much higher rate, much quicker rate.
22:13 And our Visa View numbers from that market have shown that as well, that year over year over year, that market has grown. A little bit of a larger investment here, we're talking $38,000, so MLT's portion is about, what, about $18,000, about $19,000, maybe $19,000. Our investment in Italy is a standalone contract with MLT, and it currently stands at $13,000. So they're kind of apples to oranges, but a little closer to apples to apples.
22:42 Thank you. Any other questions? No, I just want to make a comment. You know, I thoroughly agree with your strategy on focusing on winter at this time because of Chloe Kim and the upcoming Olympics. Otherwise, I would say, you know, let's focus on really building up the spring, summer, and fall just because it seems like that's a good time for them to be traveling and we already have a namesake for that. But I just wanted to say that publicly that I support your strategy because of Chloe Kim and the winter Olympics. Thank you. I appreciate that. Any other questions, guys?
23:12 Nope. All right, into the big market. So this is Visit California's research on China. Visit California has offices in five cities in China, so they have a huge presence there. They have an annual campaign in China of about $9 million. Out of $100 million...
23:31 budget. So about one-tenth of their resources are going to China. So that kind of tells you a little bit of the importance they place on China. It's the number one inbound market into the state of California, and the gap between one and two is light years, and one is running away. The growth of the Chinese visitation into California is exponential. Who is number two?
23:52 Number two into Los Angeles is Korea. Number two into California in general, I believe, is Germany, if I'm not mistaken. I think so. Yeah. But the difference between the two is massive. So a little under half of all the Chinese visitors that are coming to the US of A are coming to California. 45.5. So it's a massive number.
24:16 Visitors to California was a little over $1 million in 2015. That jumped 17% this year. That was their forecast. I wouldn't be surprised if that number was bigger. They're projecting an 83.78% growth by 2020 with an annual spend of a little over $4.5 billion. So it's a massive amount of money. They come for a little longer stay. If you look on the column on the right, almost 15 days like the stay.
24:43 Big stay. Everyone's heard about the visa waiver program. It may be in jeopardy. We don't know currently with this present administration. But currently, Chinese travelers have a 10-year visa, which means once they get that visa on their passport, they can come and go from the U.S. as much as they want in 10 years. So frequent visits are going to happen. Any questions on this slide, guys? I think one thing to know with frequent visits, too, is once they visit the gateway cities, they're going to start to branch out.
25:11 I think we've seen that already where originally they were coming for the cities and the shopping and now they're coming for Yosemite. They're coming for the Natural Wonders or Death Valley. Yeah. So I think we're starting to see that their repeat is coming back and expanding past the gateway cities. And just to layer in the different messages from the different agencies, besides our messaging as Mammoth Lakes and...
25:31 to some extent Mammoth Resorts. You've got the Visit California messaging, and then you have the Brand USA messaging. And the Brand USA messaging, they have just concluded about an 18-month campaign where it was 100% focused on the national parks. And Yellowstone and Yosemite were the two lead dogs in that messaging. So we're hitting these markets on different levels, different messaging points, but they all layer in very, very nicely.
25:57 Airlift, these numbers tend to be a little bit staggering. You have 110 weekly nonstop flights into California from mainland China. Three big gateway cities and San Diego is trying to acquire direct flights as we speak to be the fourth gateway city. A little over 3,000 seats coming into California from China, weekly, direct. Look on the column on the right, you can see they plan a little bit late. They plan their trip about two months.
26:27 to three months before departure. Main booking periods are listed there. And again, you've got 20 travel agents or 20 of the big, big players that are doing the bulk of the work inbound into the United States. Of that 20, I would say...
26:45 10 to 15 are located in the greater Beijing area, and the other 5 to 7 are located in Los Angeles. And this comes back to the conversation we had at the last board meeting about the receptives based in Los Angeles who do a lot of the heavy lifting in putting together these itineraries and getting rates from lodging, transportation, airlines. They put together a package. They sell it to the tour operators who turn and sell it to the consumer. So it's an extra layer of middle, ma'am.
27:16 Market barriers, obviously language. As John said, the first-time visitor tends to congregate in the gateway cities. The second, third, and fourth trip to California, they're moving out. The income of the Chinese visitor to California is one of the lowest, but they come again and again and again, and like I said, they're venturing outside of the gateways. So although on the rise, only 7% of the Chinese traveler, 7% of the Chinese traveler,
27:45 goes overseas, and the U.S. has 3% share. And of that 3%, so think of that massive market, only 3% of those people have been to the United States. Of that 3%, half have been to California. But that tells you we have 97% of that market who has still had a trip to the United States. So there's a huge amount of... It's something crazy, like 3% of the country even have visas.
28:09 Yeah, I mean, the potential... It's a small number of such a massive country, but it's... Yeah, the potential of what we can gain there in terms of market share and visitation, it's really staggering. But what about, let me just ask real quick, I mean, part of that has to do with the income level. I mean, obviously, I know there's...
28:29 2 billion people in China now, or one and a half, or whatever it is. So that's a massive number of people, but there's also an income level that's required for them to be able to travel, just like in any other demographic. So do you feel, is that, because it says in there the income visitor is second lowest, you know, limited. So how is that working in China? In other words, the potential for growth, we certainly see it, but are there currently enough people?
28:57 of enough affluence to make that much of a difference. I guess that's the question. Yeah, and to answer your question, John, I'll also come down to bullet point four just below it. So if you see how small a percentage of Chinese travelers have actually gone to the United States, it's kind of reflective that there's a very small amount of that population that is upper class or very, very wealthy, has the means to travel. But that number, that percentage is so large in terms of stark numbers compared to what it would be in the United States, it's still a huge number.
29:27 The middle class is growing at a very fast rate in that country, and the middle class aspires to do what the traditionally wealthy have always done, which is to travel overseas. California, the United States, Europe, whatnot. And with this big push internally within China to make winter sports and skiing, snowboarding, a mandate for all of their citizens, it's pretty easy to connect the dots and see that...
29:51 The upper class and the upper middle class and the growing lower middle class are going to want to start going overseas to ski. So, I mean, we're talking about, you know, 100 million people, something like that? I couldn't give you the exact number, but I'd be surprised if it was that low. A lot of bodies. I'd be surprised if it was that low. Wow. Cool.
30:08 Market insights, again, super chewy slide. You guys maybe can take this home and take a peek at it. Just tells you a little bit of the characteristics of the travelers coming, what Visit California thinks they want to see, what they're spending their money on, luxury, branded goods, that kind of thing. Gambling is another biggie with this market. They love Vegas. So just some interesting little insights there on the Chinese traveler.
30:32 Our competitors with China, you can see through the list there, outdoors, it's going to be New Zealand, Japan, South Korea. So if you kind of think of where China sits on a map, when someone does their first ski trip, probably going to be Japan or South Korea because it's short haul. They want to do a long haul trip. The easiest place to come to is going to be California.
30:53 Because going to Europe is a lot farther around the other side of the globe. When you come to North America, it's us or British Columbia, or they'll be the first two big things they're going to see. So California is uniquely situated to really, really gain a lot of that first-time long-haul ski traveler. You can see the top media spenders in market. You know, obviously, Grand USA should be somewhere in that list. They are not.
31:16 The state of California is spending over what Thailand spends, so I'm not really sure why Visit California didn't put their own number on there, but that kind of gives you an idea what the spend is in that country. Domestic skiing in China. Obviously, we talked about the 2018 Games in South Korea. The following winter Olympics is in Beijing. Traditionally, the two big ski areas are north of Beijing, and that is where the majority of the Olympic venues are going to be. It's a couple hours north of Beijing.
31:46 China is in the middle of a massive capital improvement project where all those base areas, right now, for our quality and qualifications, we would struggle to call them ski areas. Right now, they're pumping a ton of capital resources into them to build them into world-class ski areas, and they're building a ton of public transportation, high-speed rail, to get people to and from Beijing. Beijing alone has a city population of 33 million. So to get people to and from
32:17 Beijing into those areas. So airports being built from scratch up in these ski fields. So a massive amount of capital investment. The second bullet point is the one that always kind of gets me. The national government of China has issued a directive. Now, a directive in the United States means one thing. A directive in China means a different thing. They've issued a directive.
32:41 trying to make skiing and winter sports an institution within families in China. So they're trying to create 300 million new skiers from scratch between now and 2020. So the idea of there being 300 million new skiers anywhere in the world that are hungry for the sport, I mean, that's a staggering number. It really, really is. So it's going to be mandatory in schools. It's going to be mandatory for, you know,
33:09 Factory Worker Vacations. When they say directive, it's a directive. They're going to create this number of skiers out of nothing. You must ski. Call Trump. I'm happy to introduce that. Yeah, I'm sure you are. Introduce that, Bill. And again, this comes back to our visa view. This is our...
33:28 tracked spend in Mammoth Lakes. Again, this number is not a true number because not all of them carry Visa. There's a little bit of a cash culture there and then they also have their own credit card that has a relationship with Discover.
33:42 So we don't necessarily have an exact number on the spend. You can see in 2015 it was a little over half a million. 2016 just through Q3 it's already scratching half a million and I expect it to be somewhere in the 700 to 750 range by the time we get Q4 which should be in a couple of weeks. You can see traditionally most of our visitors from this market are coming Q2, Q3 so that's spring, summer, fall. Again it's
34:09 Mainly because of our proximity to Yosemite National Park, Death Valley, and all the things, Eastern Sierra. And I know you guys have heard me say this a million times, and I know Kirk knows this from experience. We're on that traditional itinerary from Vegas, Yosemite, San Francisco, Coast, Los Angeles, back out. So that's where we're catching them right now. Definitely trying to convert them into winter skiers and also building this number upon what we already have. Michael, to kind of dovetail off of Kirk's question, you know.
34:39 We've seen kind of two Visa View numbers for 2015. South Korea was like 50K. Yeah. China's 520K, which might even be light. Yeah. Obviously, 10X difference there. Where would like a well-established market like in Australia or a UK fall in specifically on Visa View spend? Is that like is China towards the top end? Yeah, China's towards the top end. And I think this next slide will kind of answer that. So this will show you what 2015.
35:08 The year-over-year growth in spend from country. Okay. So we haven't done, in 2015, we didn't really do anything to move the needle, other than me traveling at certain shows and talking to receptives and talking to tour agencies, travel agencies.
35:23 We're not on the aggressive path with this market, and still we saw just about a 50% growth in spend year over year in 2015. You can see how that paces with the UK. The UK is predominantly a ski market for us, so they're going to come when we have good snow. If we don't have good snow and Europe has good snow, they're going to Europe. You can see Australia had a little bit of growth. All these numbers are pretty pedestrian, and then you see that big Chinese number.
35:52 And it's, you know, it's massive. And I, you know, it's so easy to skew numbers when you say, oh, we have 200% growth and it's six people, you know, and all of a sudden you have 18. And this is not, this is a big number to begin with that this has a 50% growth on. So the fact that we have this kind of growth without doing any, devoting any resources to that market really inspires me to go after this as hard as I can. Do you have any idea, like off the top of your head on what a vis-a-view actual dollar spend would be for the UK?
36:21 I do, yeah, and I can definitely get that to you. I don't have it in this presentation, but I can get it to you. Okay. I'll just be curious. Yeah. Like something like that or Australia fits in. You can send the whole report. Yeah, I'll send the whole report. Okay. So we signed a contract with Avia Reps, same company that we signed a contract with in South Korea, different offices, different staff. This is the same company that has the contract for Visit California in China. So now we have offices in five different.
36:52 cities within China because we signed with this company. Again, we can dovetail into that California message and leverage that California spend, that $9 million spend. Our contract compared to $9 million is relatively small at $62,000, but we do split that with Mammoth Resorts, so our share is 50-50. It is our largest contract of all of our international agencies, so that kind of gives you an idea of where we put it in terms of importance.
37:21 Of the 62,000, 36 is for retainer or staff services, and then another 33,000 for in-market campaigns, FAM, sales, trainings, that kind of stuff. Again, contract shared with Mammoth Resorts. Contract is messaging for year-round, but we're focusing a little bit more on winter, probably the same percentage as we are with Korea, leading up to the 2020 winter games. 22. Yeah, 2020, I'm sorry. 2022, typo.
37:51 My bad. Ski message, again, with Korea is strictly on Mammoth Mountain. So we're not mixing in Big Bear or Snow Summit. That's actually written into the contract. Do you do that for some contracts? Include Big Bear and Snow Summit? Yeah. I don't prefer to. I prefer that the message is Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain. They do have standalone contracts where they talk about all four of their mountains and they have that right. But I prefer the message to be about our
38:21 Mountain in our area, Eastern Sierra. The other components that came with the Avia Reps contract, again, we have a dedicated social media channel, and we're going with Weibo. We actually have a dedicated person who's managing everything. We feed at them from MLT and MMSA, so there's a lot of content imagery. There was a killer black tie picture that went out yesterday. I'm interested to see how kind of traction that gets.
38:48 Everything's translated, so it has an absolute sense of legitimacy when it's hitting market and hitting ears and hitting eyes over there. We also, for the 36,000, besides a dedicated social media channel manager, we have a dedicated travel trade manager who is out there making sales calls in those 15 or 20-something offices in the greater Beijing area, telling them our talking points and our message about Mammoth Lakes for a year-round destination.
39:18 A little heavier on snow right now. They're also organizing FAMs into Mammoth Lakes and organizing sales missions for Mammoth Mountain staff and my staff to go over there probably twice, maybe three times in 2017. Again, so that we can train the trainers and also so we can get in front of the decision makers to let them know what differentiates us as a destination, summer or winter. Was there any questions about this last, with the contract?
39:47 I also, on your printout, I didn't include it on the slide because it was kind of wonky, but on your printout, you'll see the last page has an absolute detailed activity report for our services with Avia reps and our game plan for 2017, what we're going to do, where the money goes, how we're spending it. The last slide here is just a little call to action for you guys. So March 29th, we're going to have a Visit California China Ready Workshop.
40:16 here in Mammoth Lakes. Paul Rudder doesn't know it yet, but he's going to be hosting it at the Sierra Center Mall. Basically, it's the staff from Avia Reps in China coming here with Visit California, the people that handle the eastern offices. They're going to come here and tell us what they're doing with $9 million, how it's being spent, where it's going, why this market is so important to California, opportunities for us, how to train your staff,
40:46 to be more accommodating for this market, opportunities for them. Be completely free to the public. It would be a missed opportunity if business owners, senior staff, frontline personnel didn't have the opportunity to attend. So I'll be blasting you guys with tons of reminders about this as we get closer to it. We're co-hosting it with Mono County and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber. Any questions? Again, guys, you are more than welcome to contact me with any
41:21 Questions after you get a chance to digest everything I put in front of you. And I promise I'll get you that visa view. Right now I've got the 2015 summary and Q1, 2, and 3 of 2016. I'll be getting the 2016 summary in about another week. So do you want me to just wait until I get the two and then send them and you can cross-reference one against the other year over year? Yeah, that'd be great. Yeah, but it's a super interesting report. Yeah, that'd be great. Thanks. Thanks, Michael. That was great. Thank you. Appreciate it. Awesome. All right.
41:51 Why don't we have Laura do PR now? Sure. A little after that. Just real briefly. So January, just juggling media visits with the snow, rebooking and moving people around when they couldn't get here. Thank you everybody that has been so helpful and so understanding and letting us shift all that around. Crib content.
42:19 We've been working on a lot of crib content, winter content, and our social channel development. This month we've really been exploring what works on those channels. We had some goals of what we wanted to hit on each channel. We didn't quite hit them because we're still exploring that audience. It's really the first time we've put like a concentrated effort on those channels and started trying to figure out.
42:45 What that audience is looking for. So Josh has been doing a great job working on all that. We've also, we just had an athlete, well she's still in town, she's not staying at the crib, but we've been working with her, Des Linden, she's an Olympic athlete, and we just shot a video with her last weekend, so that'll be great. Her agent is Josh Cox, and she's been having a great time.
43:11 Enjoying the snowstorms, and she's also been tagging our channels, even though she wasn't staying there, she's been willing to work with us and tag Mammoth Crib and visit Mammoth, so that's been nice. Is she a marathoner? She's a two-time Olympic marathoner. Yeah, I know she is, right. She's formerly Des Davila. Right. And so she's, yeah, she's one of the top three U.S. marathoners. Yeah, so we should have that video ready in a week or two.
43:35 Send out there. And then we've also been doing some content creation for On the Snow, which I think I mentioned during my last report that they basically got rid of all their freelance writers on the West Coast, so opened the opportunity for PR people to write content for them. And On the Snow is one of the biggest ski websites out there. That's it. Any questions? Thanks. I promise you I will get you the
44:05 Crib dates more of them as soon as I can get them. No worries. So I know you probably have lots of interest for the summertime. Yeah. Oh, and that's one other thing we're working on to coincide with the crib opening this year, which is March 15th. We want to put together a little get-together party for any athletes that are going to be at the crib that time, but then also for our local athletes, just to get everybody together, find out how we can work more with our local athletes.
44:32 in the off times when we don't have people in the crib or the crib's not open and just show them that we kind of appreciate them too and it's not just about the out-of-town athletes coming in. We realize we have really great athletes living here too. So, cool. When was the up in the snow? So on the snow, you used to have staff writers. They got rid of them all. So what they're doing is they're sourcing it out to people, Laura, in destinations like this who were actually doing the writing. Got it. Yeah. And I think on that note too with the,
45:02 Kind of rolls into the marketing conversation. But with that, we had Tyler Wallish, who's a local, who's a phenomenal athlete, took over our Instagram account last weekend. And I think that was a great piece. And that does tie into our influencer program. You know, Tyler is a world-class athlete and happened to be home. And we got him to kind of run our Instagram channel for the weekend, which was great. So that's really where the influencer program is going, is to get things like that. On the marketing side, the digital display advertising is going very well.
45:31 The winter display campaign has produced about 30% better than what we were expecting on goal. The SFO, we put a strong push behind San Francisco this year with the idea of driving the San Francisco flight traffic. That's actually performing. It's pretty much doubled the expectations that we had on the number of sessions, which is great.
45:51 Our winter SEM campaign, so search engine optimization stuff has been very successful and the cost per session is about 30% lower than gold. So very efficient use of the money there.
46:07 We've had strong engagement and we have about 75% rise in the time on site. So people are coming to our website and they're spending more time, whether it's because of the snow and they're searching around and looking for all the different things that they want to find while they're here. Time on site is definitely something that's important because that's engagement. That's getting people interested in the destination. Facebook, average weekly reach of about a million. Josh has average engagement with fans of about 1,200 to 1,500 a week.
46:35 On Snapchat, we have a filter on there for the Grand Prix for this coming weekend. We've got Grand Prix filters on there, so that'll be good to see people using those. And then the following week as well for the President's Week holiday. Our PTOMG campaign that we talked about last time around, that's launched and proven to go very well. Yesterday was National Plan Year Vacation Day.
46:57 That was something that U.S. Travel decided to come out with on top of this PTO message. So Project Time Off is trying to get people to take their time off. Yesterday was really a push nationwide by people like ourselves and all of our counterparts around the country to tell people, start planning your vacation. You know, you're always wondering when you're going to start planning your vacation. Do it today. And so there was a big, big, big push nationally behind that yesterday, and that was very successful. Our website activity is strong. We had 209,000 page views last month. Average time on site is two minutes.
47:27 And Whitney couldn't join us today because she's actually out with a virtual reality company that is going to be working on some different experiential things for us. So when we go to trade shows, we'll actually have VR capabilities. The hope is to have that in the Welcome Center as well when people come in. And also it's...
47:46 It's moving fast enough that it's not just the Oculus glasses or the setup that you can actually do things on the websites and you can do things on phones. So this company came to us from a connection with Eric and Mammoth Mountain. They did some phenomenal stuff with them. We met with them last year and they're going to shoot. They're here scouting right now and they're going to shoot the first week of March for the winter content.
48:07 So that's all exciting stuff on the marketing side. And summer marketing, we're in the process of planning stages right now. Even though we have a ton of snow, we're still going to plan on going out with the April launch on that because we keep finding that at least people are going back a little bit further to their planning stages. So we want to make sure that people are still planning their summer vacations, even though we recognize that the passes and golf courses in Lakes Basin, if we're lucky, they'll be open by Father's Day. And I think that's if we're really lucky. So that could be a big challenge.
48:36 Chamber update. Craig finished his service up with us yesterday. Yesterday was his last day. He starts as the director of the South Tahoe Chamber of Commerce next Monday. Wish him well up there. He's done a great job. We hired him with the idea of building the infrastructure for our chamber. Our chamber prior really didn't have the infrastructure that needed, and chambers in general have always just been kind of social clubs. It's the after hours and the luncheons and those things.
49:05 We brought Craig on. We have a very strong tech assist program with businesses. We've got a strong service program out there, and we continue to move forward with membership. You know, we're up over 200 members now.
49:16 The search is on there. We are using Headhunter to assist us with that. And we have, we've received a lot of good resumes at this point, people with a lot of good chamber background experience. So we've got people from Los Gatos, we've got people from Jackson Hole, we've got people from other places that would definitely understand the resort community and I think take what Craig has built and expand on it. And that's really what we're hoping for. On the air update, I think everybody knows we had a very challenging month.
49:44 Probably even more challenging than I would have ever expected. San Francisco, out of 31 round-trip flights, we had 17 of them cancel. That's 55%. That's an unacceptable number. Of that, we lost about 1,500 travelers going each way. Were they canceled before they took off? Some of them were. Some of them were, and there were a few cancellations that didn't have to do with our weather. It had to do with weather in their system, meaning that whatever plane was supposed to get to San Francisco to come here,
50:13 Got stuck somewhere else. But there were some cancellations that they canceled prior to, well in advance of coming over because they knew we were in the spot that we were. We also had the airport, I don't know if everybody's aware of this, we had the airport closed for Monday and Tuesday last week. So when the highway was closed, the airport was closed, the airport workers couldn't even get there until Tuesday. I drove by it last Monday and it was kind of eerie to look at the airport and just see a field of snow. There's no runway. And so,
50:43 They couldn't get there until Tuesday. They took all day Tuesday to move the snow to get it open for Wednesday. It was a Herculean effort. Brian and the crew down there did a fantastic job, but we did lose two days. Now the good news, if there is good news, is that a lot of our service, like JetSuite and San Diego, are four days a week. So in the grand scheme of things, where we lost 17 flights in San Francisco and we lost 18 flights in Los Angeles in January, we lost four flights in San Diego.
51:07 Because of the timing, and actually one of those was a crew timeout, which was the same sort of thing. A delayed flight comes in, they get towards the end of their scheduled workday, and they can't work past a certain amount of hours, so they end up canceling our flight. Unfortunate, but that's what happens. LAX, we were just shy of 2,000 lost passengers, inbound and outbound. And, you know, it's really frustrating, and I think when we look at these things, San Francisco's 50% origination and 50% fly-through.
51:36 How many of those people on January 2nd were trying to get here from Chicago? And we didn't fly in here again until January 17th or something. So it's really not where we need to be. And I think we're going to talk about that a little bit later as well. So the bookings for right now moving forward, obviously all of the snow has made the phones ring. So we are looking fairly good moving forward.
52:01 I misspoke on the number, but if we canceled, if we didn't have one more cancellation for the rest of the year, which is highly unlikely, we would be at 12.2% cancellation for the year. That's if we had no more cancellations whatsoever through April. The month of January combined ended up being 38%.
52:19 It's really difficult. Los Angeles, because we have two flights a day for a good chunk of that, was 36.7%. San Diego was 26%. Even though we only had four cancellations, we only had 15 round trips. Like I mentioned before, San Francisco was 54.8%. And even Burbank with JetSuite was 22% cancellation. They had one day where we've got to give them a lot of credit. They flew up to Bishop. It was during one of the really windy days. They couldn't land.
52:49 They went back to Burbank. They looked at the radar and they said, God, I think we have a window. Let's try it again. They flew all the way back up to Bishop again, still couldn't land. But again, the fact that they flew it twice at their, frankly, at their own cost to try and get it to work.
53:07 is pretty huge. Other than that, they had a couple of cancellations. The Monday that we had the airport closed and the road closed, obviously they didn't fly up, and they had two other cancellations that were just extraordinary weather, both here and Bishop. So that service, for the most part, has been doing well. The RNP, believe it or not, even though we had a 36% cancellation in Los Angeles and San Diego, the RNP got probably 10 flights to land that wouldn't have landed last year. That's great.
53:37 So, in the grand scheme of things, RNP and JetSuite are the two pieces that are working. The rest of it right now, I think, are not working, and I do think that we need to reevaluate kind of what we're doing and take a good look at air service. John, I had a quick question, just going back to marketing, and this is just something I remember from earlier in the month, regarding the Influencer Program. What was that little scuttlebutt about that was something that was something inappropriate that was forwarded? I mean, it was like really... Well, it's just people not understanding what it is. What's going on, right, yeah.
54:06 Okay. Anyways. Yeah, that's kind of what I thought it was. That's exactly what it was. Okay. So, Teton Gravity Research out of Jackson Hole did an article and it was meant to kind of poke fun at the amount of snow that we had here and what was getting posted and tagged with Mammoth Mountain. Ah, gotcha. It had nothing to do with Mammoth Mountain. It had nothing to do with us. It had nothing to do with the town. It was just people that were here doing stupid things, tagging Mammoth Mountain and they went in and they filtered it and they said, okay, here's a picture of a girl in a bikini standing in a snowbank.
54:36 And for some reason, locals thought that that was our influencer program. And it had nothing, absolutely nothing to do with our influencer program. And so it caused quite a stir out there and it got shared a few times. Of course, I always get tagged in these things, so I have to go in and respond. And as much as I responded saying this has nothing to do with anybody, it just...
54:56 perpetuated and got people up in arms about what we weren't. It's just the world of social media and the way it works, right? It is. Thank you for bringing that up. A lack of understanding of how the world of social media works. Right. And I would add to that, so it happened like the weekend after I gave my presentation, and the Sheik had reported that we had a digital influencer program, so I think people just thought digital influencer in general.
55:21 Right. That's what we were doing. Laura's bringing in girls in bikinis and putting them on the site. Great. That's perfect. So, and I think that the example that we had this past weekend with Tyler Wallace was a really good example of an influencer. And another one that's not on our payroll or not, and I don't think we did anything for Tyler other than giving the keys to the Instagram account. And the same thing with Glenn Plake. You know, Glenn is an influencer for the mountain. And Glenn...
55:47 The Mountain posted pictures with Glenn shoveling out cars, the first storm, and he posted pictures tagging Mammoth Mountain doing flips off of his bus, and he's an influencer. He has thousands and thousands and thousands of followers around the world, and he is out there promoting Mammoth Mountain. He went out with Christian Pondela and took some amazing shots on the mountain, and that's what influencers do, is they show off what this place is all about. Thank you for bringing that up, because that was something that came up in the last month that was...
56:15 Fairly absurd, but people perceive things as what they do. I mean, anybody can tag Mammoth Mountain. And none of them were tagged Visit Mammoth either. They were all tagged Mammoth Mountain. People see what they want to see.
56:30 Take a photo of yourself in a bikini and you happen to be in Mammoth. Nobody can control that. Why did you post that? What was amazing is that we don't support that. There was talk about objectifying women and all this other stuff and one of the responses was a woman who tagged her friend who was one of the girls in the bikini and she said, I don't feel objectified. It's a picture of me. I think she said, like, I'm a 36-year-old mom. I'm lucky I can wear a bikini. All right, whatever. But it was a lesson in
57:00 It was a lesson in just how social media can get out of control pretty quickly as well. Got it. Okay, financial reports? Yeah, on to the financial reports. The month of December numbers came in, and we are, once again, we set a record in December. Right now it's about a 1.5% record, but last year was such a phenomenal number, it would have been hard to really keep the double-digit growth that we had into that.
57:25 We came at $2,317,000. It's not an overall record. Next month, last year, January of last year was the overall TOT record of 2.37. I think that we should beat that in January. I know there's some concern because of all the snow that we didn't have the numbers in January that we'd want, but I actually think that we will end up with those numbers. So that puts us here to date $1.78 million ahead of budget, and more importantly, it puts us
57:55 I think we're about 11 or 12% ahead of the previous record year. So we're ahead of last year's pace for the first six months of the year, which is pretty phenomenal. And I think looking at the remainder of the year budget, based on what we have for momentum right now, I would be very hard-pressed not to see us get into the, again, the $14 to $16 million budget or actual range. So we could break the all-time.
58:21 Again. I think we could. I think we could. You know, because I think that January, February, March, and I think April, which March and April last year were excellent, but not on the charts. I think this year it'll be on the charts. And part of that is that Easter this year is April 16th. Yeah, April's going to be big. You know, Easter is, for all intents and purposes, for the general skiing public, Easter is kind of the last hurrah. The diehards stick around. The mountain is announced. They're going to be open until July 4th, which is frankly a
58:49 That's a huge selling point for April and May because if we're announcing it now and not waiting until the last minute, people will know about it, people will book it. So April, as we've talked about, April will very much more than likely be well over a million dollars. In our grand scheme of 10 months of viability, that's great, but it's probably not a sustainable million dollars.
59:09 Every year if it doesn't snow, you know, April's not going to pass it. Plus the fact that you need, you know, you need the combination of a late Easter and a killer winter. Early killer winter and late Easter. Those two things line up to have a really good April. You know, if you have either an early Easter or you have a, you know, combination of the other factors, it's not as good. You're right. It's not something that's as reliable. Yeah, and last year was a perfect example. We had Easter was March 26th and we...
59:34 Kind of after February, we really didn't get a ton of snow to keep the momentum. And April was still strong at 830,000. It was the third best April ever. But I think this year you've got the perfect storm of the amount of snow that we have and Easter falling perfectly. That's a huge windfall for us to get compared to last year to get another three weeks of the ski season is pretty massive. The risk or the downside of it.
59:59 Is that May and June, you know, May may still continue to be strong because we'll be skiing, but, you know, June we won't have passes open, we won't have golf courses open, we won't have Lake's Basin open. Fishing opener will have nothing to do with Mammoth. It'll be everywhere else in the county that is even potentially open. Hopefully we get Convict and Crowley and some of those places.
1:00:20 So I think we've talked about it the last couple of years. I would gladly give up a couple hundred thousand dollars in May and June to get the couple million dollars that we will over the four months of winter that we're kind of set up for right now. So that's the good news. It would be interesting to see, to go back and I don't know who would have these numbers. I guess we all individually have them. Maybe the Mountain does. To see how that translates, you know, how business overall in town translates when you have a really a huge winter.
1:00:47 In those months, in April, May, June, because it seems to me that my recollection that we still did pretty damn good in those months, even when we had really big winters, even though some other things suffered, like you said, some of the other things suffered, we still, for whatever reason, visitation was still really strong. Yeah, and May's always been one of those months where either we have snow and it's good, or we don't have snow and it's good. It's the same number, it's not necessarily good, but it's fairly consistent whether we have snow or not, because it's an in-between month. You know, June might be a struggle.
1:01:16 We're really going to have to look at the half marathon and see how that's going to work, you know, as far as starting at Horseshoe. Run some circles around Horseshoe. Well, when they first approached us, we thought, you know, this would be kind of a great novelty to have, they approached us after the big, the first big year, the 2010 that I was here, and thought, okay, it'd be great to have this at the end of June and have people starting in snow banks and running into town. Well, the concern now is, is the road even going to be open by June?
1:01:42 18th, 19th, whatever the date is. And will the loop around Lake Mary be open? And what's that going to do to the entire course? Are they going to have to really figure out a new course? Are they going to have to cancel it? I don't know. So obviously there's a lot more snow to fall, so it'll be interesting to see where that all comes out. Well, golf certainly doesn't drive the TOT that mountain biking does. When did the mountain bike park open last year? Does anyone remember that?
1:02:08 They opened in May. In May. Memorial Day weekend? Before that. Before that. Mid-May, I think. Yeah, that ain't gonna happen. Yeah, it was like the 17th. Got it. So there's a lot of risk there. There are a lot of risks, and I think that's where, you know, and it's not like it's epic winter skiing and we're gonna see 10,000 people a day on the hill. Right. So it's not gonna offset some of those losses. So that's why I say May and June are the two months that we stand to risk. But again, the risk is probably a few hundred thousand bucks. Whereas right now, with the amount of snow that we have, the next three months, we're probably gonna go...
1:02:37 Two plus three million dollars over budget. Not over last year because they're going to be very comparable numbers to last year. They're probably the way the budget is set up. January is budgeted at 1.8 million. Last year we did 2.37. I'm going to guess we're going to be probably that or better this year. So that's going to be 500 grand right in January above budget. 500, 600 grand above budget. And as far as golf goes, I mean, Memorial Day through the second to third week of June is really...
1:03:03 Honestly, it's pretty light. It's mostly locals and pass holders and stuff like that, so it doesn't really start kicking in until July and August and mid-September. That's the main golf season up here. If there's snow on the lakes basin roads, 203 up there, 203, Lake Mary Road, up there, and the forest service can't open it, could we plow that and open it if we paid for it? The town does it anyway. The town does the plowing anyway. It's just a question of when they can get up there to do enough plowing to make it work.
1:03:32 The flip side is that typically there's also a time frame in the spring where they allow snowmobiles up there and that may end up being a longer period this year. In the past it's kind of conflicted with getting the road open and fishing opener. I think there's so much snow open up there they may actually look at doing it more. I don't know. But the opportunity for fishing is much greater than snowmobiling.
1:03:53 But there's not going to be, I mean, the lakes are going to be covered. They'll still be frozen. Yeah, the first year, in 2011 fishing opener, which was my first year, we didn't get the lakes basin open until just before 4th of July. And Tioga opened, I think, June 24th. So it's just, it's tough. And then the other side of it comes down to people talk about ice fishing and the Forest Service doesn't like the risk involved with that. And so, you know, it's really, it's going to be a tough one because the town does plow the road and the Forest Service.
1:04:21 We have opening and closing meetings about it. And all the businesses up there obviously want to get open as soon as possible. But it really comes down to when they can get in there to make the difference. Is it typically timed with when the lakes are not frozen? Is that the timing of it? I mean, there's no plowing demand in May. It is. This came up in the recreation commission last week.
1:04:41 month and I asked for it to be brought forward as an agenda item this coming month, this month actually, talking about what the communication plan is specifically with the Forest Service because we've had issues before where I feel like recreation gets
1:04:55 Blamed, local town gets blamed when there's communication coming out of the visitor center here saying, yeah, the roads open going up there and of course they get up there and it's blocked. Forest Service generally doesn't, this is my understanding, doesn't even like to really open up the roads up there until ice is clear from the bank because people try and walk out on the ice.
1:05:17 So, but, you know, this is something that affects tourism as well. And I think that we, in our communication with the Forest Service, just need to be on the same kind of strategy of what we're communicating to our public. And we are. So the Forest Service calls a meeting in the spring and fall, and it's an opening and closing meeting. So I'll shoot John Regalburg a note to find out when that opening meeting is going to be. But it's the mountains involved, because it's basically the opening of Red's Meadow and the opening of Red's Basin.
1:05:46 And we get reports from the Park Service as to how much snow is down there. They talk about the damage that's up there. Part of last year was the road didn't get open because the Forest Service were doing a lot of tree work. And so while the roads were fairly clear, they were doing this tree work and they didn't want to open up the road. But these opening and closing meetings are very interesting and it would be good to have a recreation commissioner there.
1:06:13 But it's the, you know, it's Don Barrett from Lake Mary, it's some of the properties up there, it's the mountain, it's the Caltrans guys, it's the town guys talking about the plowing. So it's an important meeting and typically it's something that'll happen in February or March, early March. And I think that this year it'll be a very interesting meeting to find out just how much snow is down there. Usually the park service will go down and take some pictures down at the Reds Meadow and show that the snow is over the cabin.
1:06:41 And that kind of gives you an idea of realistically what to expect. But yeah, that's a big thing. What about TBID? TBID is doing well as well. I think, you know, we're pacing ahead of our forecast. You know, it's not crazy ahead because we forecasted a little bit better or a little bit higher this year. And so we are probably $300,000 ahead of where we want to be.
1:07:06 Cash flow right now, the Measure A checking account has $1.549 million in it. Of course, we do have a lot of our winter bills coming due at this point, so a good chunk of that's going to go right back out the door. Savings account has $5,738. TBID checking has just over a quarter million at $761. Again, a lot of that will go out the door.
1:07:29 TBID checking has $5,004, and then the CDs that we have, which is our combination of our reserve and also the funding that we've set aside for specific projects, the event venue, et cetera, are in that $2.5 million. P&L reports, I don't recall if we got those out to you guys. We'll have to take those off to get back with Sarah on those. I think our timing is good as well.
1:08:01 We typically see our quarterly true-ups with the town. We haven't seen a quarterly true-up, and I'm going to have to follow up on that one because we should be seeing a true-up from earlier July, August, September timeframe. Once they close the quarter, we typically see something 45 days after. I don't know if they're planning on doing a biannual true-up, but there is some money that will be coming in that way as well. So the last one that we've seen was the end of September? We have not seen a true-up. Okay.
1:08:32 Yeah, so the July, August, September would be the first true up, and then typically, yeah, for Q1, it's a few months after they close the books, but typically we should see that by now, so I need to follow up with that. Okay, gotcha. All right, and let's see, Michael, did you want to address the TBID renewal process? TBID renewal process? Yeah. You bet. So far we've brought in just over 61% of the necessary support.
1:09:02 for the TBID. Rather than submit in the near future here, we've decided that we're going to hold off a little bit and just do a little bit more of an analysis and a little bit of a deeper dive into air service. Part of what John was saying about service this year and just long-term strategy. So it's all moving ahead nicely. We just need to do a little bit more research there before we submit it to the council.
1:09:33 All right, Eric, do you have an MMSA update? I think I heard him drop off. Did he drop off? Eric, are you there? Yeah, sorry about that. No worries. Do you have an MMSA update, Eric? Great. Thanks, Eric. Thank you. All right, on to new business, event venue and site discussion. This is part of the discussion that we had with both with John Wentworth and Colin and John Urdi and myself and also a conversation that
1:10:47 John and I had with Dirk Winter yesterday? Was it yesterday? That was a long day. So we just wanted to go over that. Basically, when we met with Dirk, he wanted to know very specifically, you know, what sort of the components, what the metrics were, what the constraints were that MLT was willing to, you know, the dollar amount and also what we expected to see.
1:11:13 for that $300,000 that we were willing to commit to infrastructure and sort of what the parameters were of the site. So I think they're all basically listed here is that it's the $300,000 commitment off the bat for support construction and infrastructure. So whether that's electrical, whether it's pathways, bathrooms, whatever it is, we're willing to
1:11:35 to commit to that. John, just to be clear, Dirk Winter is in escrow trying to purchase a portion, one of the two pieces of the Sam'swood site. The Walker-Hartman portion, yeah, not the Odaker portion. Yeah, not the Odaker piece. At this time. Yeah, at this time. The site must be committed to a special event venue for at least 10 years.
1:11:55 site must be available at no cost for up to five non-profit events annually. Now right now I think we've got arts, we've got Shakespeare in the park. I think he said there were two. I put the five in there. That's something we need to discuss here as to what we want to hedge to make sure that if there's something else that wants to utilize the site then.
1:12:14 You know, right now, I think he seemed to think there were two with the arts and Shakespeare. I don't know if there are other nonprofits that perform down there. I don't know if we want to pad it and say up to three just to be safe, if we want to just say the existing events. But what we want to do is whatever you decide on here, we're going to put into an agreement with him, with the idea, again, that if it's not an event venue for 10 years, the money comes back to us. If the infrastructure...
1:12:39 that we're supporting isn't in within a certain amount of time, money comes back to us. So I think we're kind of protecting ourselves as much as possible. Again, the five that I put in there was because I wasn't sure exactly where we had and what we should put in there. Yeah. Well, maybe we should very briefly discuss this. I mean, what do you guys think? Because obviously... We want to discuss A through D then? Yes. Okay. So...
1:13:02 Yeah, I guess we'll just go through all four of them and then go back and start at the top. And then D would be that the site must be available for anybody who would like to rent it, provided that the space is available. So those were the four things. Open to the public. Yeah, open to the public if somebody wanted to rent it out. So I guess let's just go through this one at a time. I believe we had discussed the $300,000 for infrastructure, again, specifically infrastructure improvement, not for down payment.
1:13:29 or anything else, but specifically for infrastructure. I don't think we want to name specifically what that infrastructure is, because you can use it. I mean, the electrical alone could be $300,000 to make the improvements there that are necessary. But the idea was that if that did not happen, I guess one thing we do need to do is decide on a time frame. So from the time that the property closes escrow, what time frame do we...
1:13:57 That $300,000 commitment we want to give, when do we want to see the infrastructure completed? You know, do we want to do, I mean, Sean, you probably know more about the site than anyone. I mean, is it fair to put a one-year, a two-year, or what sort of time frame seems reasonable once escrow has closed? And again, realizing if escrow closes next month, you know, nobody's going to start working on an electrical panel in March.
1:14:23 Well, I have a lot of comments on this, and I'm not sure at what point I need to recuse myself. I mean, are we trying to make a decision today? But you're informed, you know, since you are familiar with the site, I think it's pertinent. Okay. Didn't you recuse yourself when we talked about the $300,000 commitment? I can't remember. I think I did. I don't remember either. Because we've already made, what commitment have we made, actually?
1:14:49 Well, it's just been verbal. It's just been a conversation. It's been a conversation. Well, yeah, and I'm not sure if you want me to kind of go through these in different ways. Let's just go like A through D if we can. It'd be easier if we just go through them one at a time. So the commitment, you know, the general commitment of 300,000 is an initial commitment for infrastructure. Are we...
1:15:15 Is that a number that... Is there a budget that was shared with us that shows total infrastructure and what percentage that might be of that budget? I'm quite sure that over... I mean, basically, Dirk's plan is over many years to probably spend a million, I mean, a lot of money on infrastructure. And it's not to say that MLT couldn't commit future dollars, you know, to infrastructure year two, year three, whatever it may be. But this was just sort of to get things off the ground to kind of make... Is he talking about something that would resemble kind of a finished product of what...
1:15:45 Current events used in there, for example, Blues and Palooza, where there's a permanent stage and some infrastructure, electrical, water, and maybe bathrooms, and that's it, and it stays a wood site, or is it like a structural, you know, is there an amphitheater going in there? It sounds more to the first part, kind of maybe a hybrid between those two. Again, there are a lot of moving pieces, and I think the idea was that MLT wanted to be supportive.
1:16:13 to help make it, get this thing done and going. Exactly what it's going to look like, I think there's a lot more conversation that Dirk needs to have. I actually spoke with him today. You know, I think that what he's looking at is he really is just looking at for some of the basics. I mean, we operate that site with a fire hydrant. We bring in all the electricity for the most part. The few panels that are there are very dirty in that it crackles a lot, so we can't use it for any kind of stage. What he's been looking at is really the electricity.
1:16:42 More than anything, you know, that's kind of what we're talking about. I think that's one of his number one priorities. I think that he's got some concerns with regard to, you know, bathrooms. Are they going to be required? I'm not sure that's the best use of infrastructure dollars because you're talking, you know, to make it 88, you know, there were some concerns about that it needs to have bathrooms just to comply with various things. And because it's a special events site, I'm not necessarily sure that, you know,
1:17:09 Building with bathrooms in it, and I think this is some of his concerns, is the best use of some of the infrastructure on it. So in answer to your question about how soon can you move on it, you know, I'd love to see it happen as soon as possible before August, right? Just, I mean, as far as electricity, but I don't know if that's realistic. I certainly think that we should...
1:17:30 You know, put some parameters around it within a year or by summer of 2018 that maybe we'd like to see some of these. It might be a good idea to identify exactly what those if in structure improvements are going to be.
1:17:46 I know that he's been talking about wanting to put in a pathway there, which would be great for his event, but not necessarily for the others. It actually may even impede what some of the other events do. But then again, it's also his property, so we can't dictate too much what he's going to be doing, but we certainly can with these dollars that we're talking about.
1:18:06 The only other concern that I want to say, and I know that he is committed to really kind of growing the site, but, you know, again, something with regard to Bluza Palooza, we have grown that event so much on that site that unfortunately now we're having to scramble for our staging location. You know, we used all of Uller, White Stag, and the church lot, and I'm even looking for additional parking.
1:18:32 You know, for just our stage. So, you know, I'm really pleased that this is going forward, as I've said before. I'm approaching it from a business owner's perspective that I just need stability as far as where I know my event is going to be located for the next three to five years. So I'm really glad that we've got a partner here that is very interested in working with us on this. And to be clear, the $300,000 secures us a place for a decade.
1:19:01 An outdoor venue. And it's open to anybody from nonprofits, Shakespeare in the Woods to Bluza Bluza. So basically, it basically secures that space that we've been looking at for a decade. Right. And we can talk about the, you know, wanting to lock in a number of nonprofits versus, you know, it being available to anybody who wants to rent the site, given availability. So those are two different kind of two different components. What he wants to do basically with this infrastructure is to more formalize what's there.
1:19:31 You know, because right now it's a temporary event site. You pop up a stage, you bring in generators, you work off the fire hydrant, you bring in porta-potties. I think what he's looking to do is get that, and probably the biggest thing, and as John mentioned, the clean power could be $300,000. But the clean power is probably one of the biggest challenges that these guys face, whether you're bringing in generators or not, and that may eat up the entire $300,000. But even if a lot of the other infrastructure that we're talking about doesn't happen, that's a huge piece.
1:19:59 You know, I don't know. Dirk also doesn't seem like he's gearing himself towards a permanent stage because it doesn't necessarily fit his model. So, you know, that's another piece that's something that I'm not sure $300,000 would go almost nowhere to build a permanent stage. But, you know, that's another piece of the conversation as to whether there should be a permanent stage. So, but I do think that... That's probably where you get into permit issues in bathrooms and so forth. If you start building permanent infrastructure versus variable... It's a number of days.
1:20:28 Randomly used. Is that what it was? Yeah. So then really from our perspective. Number of days it's being used? Correct. Days of utilization annually. Nice. Is where it triggers that permanence. And what is it? Is it like 100 days or is it? 180. Oh. Or 120. Yeah. I'd love to say we're going to get anywhere near that. Yeah. Programming wise. Everybody, do you have a comment? It's in the middle. I was just going to interject and say that, you know, I guess from our perspective then.
1:20:56 This $300,000 is going to go towards the least common denominator. I mean, what's good for all of these groups? You know, I'm sure Mr. Winters hasn't been operating in a vacuum for all these years, and he's got extensive event experience, from my understanding. I mean, has this, the wood site is nothing new to him, per se, but that yet, do you think?
1:21:22 That said, do you think it's going to take him a couple years to fully vet his process out to say, well, what is it that he would like to see above and beyond to save these walkways?
1:21:33 You know, I mean, because this is a business decision. I mean, whether it's for his own things or for leasing it out, what's the best use of the property? Well, I mean, there's a lot of different moving pieces here, and I think there's also what the council wants to see, potentially, or what the town wants to see as a sort of a phased project. He talked about that a little bit, and I know you guys have had conversations about that. So there's, you know, what's year one to year three? What's year three to year six? What, you know, what are you planning to do during those time frames? So it is, the whole thing is a wee bit of a moving target.
1:22:02 As far as exactly, but I think that from our standpoint, at least for now, without getting into too much detail, we're really looking at, you know, supporting it. Again, it would be the board's decision of what we, if we wanted to continue to support in the future, you know, if we want to put more dollars towards it in future years. But really, this is, we all know that we don't have an event center. This is an excellent opportunity, and this really kind of, basically what, essentially what Dirk has said is that this helps them get it done.
1:22:31 Putting this money to infrastructure will allow him to fund the project and get it going and then use MLT's money for infrastructure to get it rolling. So we will have a site. Exactly what it looks like and exactly who's going to use it, there's going to be a lot of determination on that down the road. But I think it's pretty safe to say it will fit into all the various things that we've talked about given the capacity of the site. And, you know, he hasn't submitted any sort of formal plans to the town at this point. So it's really difficult to, like, pigeonhole.
1:23:01 Any of those specific infrastructure things because a site plan hasn't been laid out. You know, as John mentioned, like the structure of this deal is essentially a multi-year earn out. So I think there's going to be multiple different iterations to it. But, you know, what I think from my understanding of speaking to him is he's basically looking to bridge a financial gap. The purchase price is X and what he thinks he can actually make pencil is Y.
1:23:29 And so trying to find a way to kind of bridge that gap, pull the density off of it, retain it as an event site, there's got to be some sort of recouping of that gap between X and Y. Let me just throw out a number to you guys. Would we feel comfortable if we were to say we're willing to support infrastructure improvements up to $300,000, provided that that money is used by July 1st of 2018?
1:23:58 Does that seem like a reasonable time frame? Or is that too short? Should it go to the end of the summer of 2018? Again, I want to be careful on how I reply. Well, I know where your event lies in that whole grand scheme of things, but I'm just saying, you know, again, what's a realistic time frame of him being able to get $300,000 worth of infrastructure done, given the nature, the fact that he's not going to be able to do anything on it until probably June, July, this year, that gives him a summer.
1:24:26 And then into the wintertime to some degree, would it be more appropriate maybe to make it go through the summer of 2018 to kind of ensure that, or do we want to kind of hasten it? It sort of depends on what...
1:24:39 What the money is going to and how much he would have to subsidize that. In other words, if it goes to electrical and the electrical is $290,000 total all in, I would say make it as short as possible. Because we're spending the money, there's nothing inhibiting it from his side. If it's $700,000 and we're putting in $300,000 and he has to come up $400,000, you probably need to consider more time for him to capitalize that. But I'm with Sean. If we agree to do this, the sooner the better.
1:25:06 I mean, we could, you know, we could say, we could say July 1st of 18, and then if he came back and said, well, here's what I want to use it for specifically, but it's going to probably take me a couple more months to get this done, and it's specifically, like you said, it's going to be this improvement. We'll say, okay, that's like matching funds, basically. Okay. But I think, yeah, I agree. I think putting a shorter time frame on it is better. Just so I'm clear, so I toe the line as a council member, this is...
1:25:32 This specific dollar allocation will not come back before council for allocation? No. No. Okay. So I can vote on this. This board's decision. Okay. I can vote on this as a board member of MLT and not have to worry about precluding my vote. I don't know the answer to that, but yeah, I think so. All right. Oh, go ahead. No. I was just going to say I think
1:25:53 Without knowing specifically the infrastructure, it's hard for me to tie a timeline to it. I think putting something in as far as an urgency clause of, you know, maybe July or summer of 2018 or something like that, but as long as there's some language in there that says that, you know, he could essentially petition for an extension, you know, that the board can grant based on the nature of what the infrastructure is.
1:26:22 There's probably 100 little things that would need to be addressed. The top three for me would be how the money's spent, what it's spent on, and I would probably follow how a commercial lease works. You can't spend, you get tenant improvement money, you can't spend it on marketing, right? You can't spend it on certain things. You have to spend on infrastructure, and that infrastructure has to be approved and the receipts have to be presented. Second would be a guarantee on that 10 years, some kind of a second mortgage or a lien that would...
1:26:51 Put us in the position to execute on that if we got somehow, if they somehow didn't work out the way we had hoped. And then third would be, I think, who sells the events and at what cost and what price. That's another area of vulnerability, I think. We want to make sure that, you know, that doesn't turn into, and I trust that the person buying it for events, location, has his own event. It would, the free market system would seem to support.
1:27:18 Selling as many events there as possible. However, without any checks and balances, you know, your price could triple overnight for Puzapuza. I've considered moving there. It could be way out of my reach. What is the pricing? Is that something that's determined out front? Is it something where the towns or MLT sells is the event coordinator? Yeah, I think that's, I mean, at this point, that's going to be up to the owner.
1:27:46 Really. I mean, it's going to be his piece of property and how he wants to do business, really. So it's, there is, I guess there's some assumed risk there. So if I may, for the sake of moving things forward, D probably seems to be the easiest one to tackle. Can we all, I would support the idea that the site must be available for anyone who wants to rent it. Do we have any issues or discrepancies with that as a board?
1:28:13 No, but I think that Michael's question is fair. It does kind of even tie into the available at no cost to five non-profits. I'm trying to just get... I know, you're trying to get past it. But at the same time, the reason why I'm saying that it's not entirely that easy is because, sure, it's available to anyone who wants to rent it at what price. And I, you know, I...
1:28:38 Trust Dirk. Sam has been so generous over the years in letting us use it. You know, God forbid there were any kind of situation where this event organizer wants to do it for this or, you know, I'm in charge of this guy this price and this guy this price. You know, something I've been saying for years is that I would love to see other events go on there because...
1:29:01 You know, for years past, I've been the one going in, I'm the only one that's spending money to cut down trees, which have to come down. The fire marshal says that's a dead tree, it's got to come down. No one else is paying for that. I sure would like to share that cost with some of the other events that are going on. Now, you know, this year I think we've got that taken care of, but, you know, just trying to make sure that it's fair in a sense going forward. But to answer your question, just for the sake of moving things along,
1:29:29 Yeah, I think that that needs to be a prerequisite. And I think we can ask, I think we can ask the proposed pricing, I think we can look at the annual increase limits. You know, annually it can increase no more than 5%, whatever the, if it's 10,000 bucks to rent it for a weekend, it can only increase by 5%. I think also on the non-profits, the more I think about it, I think what we have to say is that we have to say that it's free to the non-profits existing in 2016, what was already there. Because you're technically a non-profit, right?
1:29:57 Or are you? I mean, there are a number of events in town that are non-profits that... I will be... I'm evolving towards 100% non-profit right now. It's a non-profitable event that... Not intentionally non-profit. Yeah, that is shared with a non-profit in terms of organization. But I think there are a lot of non-profit events in town, and if we say that there are five, who's going to determine who the other three are? Yeah, I agree. I would say that...
1:30:21 I mean, essentially, the existing, as of the ones that existed in 2016, at that site, because I think that's two, and in that way, it's just, okay, your grandfather, then that's it. And if you're a non-profit, you can lobby him to get it. Because then it becomes extremely unfair to Sean or Michael or anybody else. It's like, okay, well, I've been paying X per year, now everybody gets to use it free except me. That's wonderful. That's not really very fair. Are we okay with that? Non-profits, the current non-profits that have been using it versus expanding it?
1:30:51 Just keep it clean. Yeah. Yeah, I think that makes sense to me. Okay. So maybe we need to add E in as well if we want to get into deeper details on the actual pricing. E? Yeah. So add that? Potentially. I mean, if that seems to be the way the conversation is going is looking at some sort of. Or we could just say site available to anybody who would like to rent it and then add it to that, a discussion of rent limitations.
1:31:19 Yeah. Something like that, pricing, pricing increase limitations, something like that. Sure. Yeah. You know, I mean, again, I think we want to be careful on the one hand, we don't want to scare Dirk off completely and say, you know, put too many constraints on his property once he purchases it, but you don't want somebody coming in and saying, oh, now it's four times what you paid for last year. Right. That's really not the, I mean, that could cripple the availability of being able to put on events there.
1:31:47 Because we're not just, you know, we're not just thinking about this from the standpoint of, oh great, now AEG is going to come book the whole thing all summer long. I mean, in a way that would be great if that happened, but I think that's probably not going to happen for quite a while, if anything. So I think we're, are we pretty good on C and D and with a little extra language on D? Just a little bit of an understanding of sort of the price. The site must be available to anyone who would like to rent it, you know, permitting space available.
1:32:19 And then some additional language on discussion of? Fees. Reasonable fees. Reasonable fees, yeah. And increases, year over year increases. I'm okay with that. That sounds reasonable, Sean. Yeah, I think so. You know, again, as a private business owner, I don't want to be, you know, what if he does have somebody coming in? But let's have that discussion. Okay. I think that's what you're asking. Okay, yeah. C, site must be available at no cost for existing non-profits. Got that. Okay. I'm comfortable with that. And then we,
1:32:50 Okay, we good with that? Yeah. And then B, 10-year commitment? Right. How does this affect the other processes that are going on parallel in considering the other event sites? And he asked us that yesterday. What's that? He asked us that yesterday. Okay. And I think that the response that we had was that even the other venues that we're considering or that may have made the short list, most of them are at least,
1:33:22 Five years away. And even, I think, the bell-shaped parcel, which MLR thinks is less than five years away, I think once you start getting into challenges and possible litigations and things like that, I just, I think that there's realistically working with the Forest Service that we're not looking at anything in the very near term that's going to displace this. Plus, we kind of explained to him yesterday that if all this infrastructure work happens to that site, it may end up being the preeminent site.
1:33:49 You know, you and I talked yesterday about the fact that we, if we build an event site for 8, 6, 8, 10,000 people, realistically, with what we have for traffic coming through in the summer already, where we're hearing people say that we have too many people, the opportunity for an event like that is probably June or September, when we actually, one, need it, and two, could actually accommodate it without displacing the normal traffic that's coming through. So I'm not sure that if we get to that size event site,
1:34:17 Is it your event and one or other event a year? Are we talking getting it used 50 days a year? Well, plus the fact that if we do enter into a situation where the wood site works really well and other events besides you or Sean become established and continue to grow and it shows a need for, wow, we have six events now that really can use 5,000 plus 8,000, 10,000. If we really get to that point, then I think that the two sites sort of
1:34:46 Play well off each other because one establishes the new events and then the other one becomes ready a little bit in the future and can take on those events once this 10 years is up and those things can continue to grow and flourish and so forth. It may be the case where we see in five years that we don't have a need for something for more than X number of people and that this site works well and we really don't need to have another site, although this is a 10-year thing. But like we said,
1:35:15 It's going to be, we all know, it's going to be a minimum of five years before anything. I mean, unless somebody, unless Bill Gates drops out of the sky and says, yeah, here, I'll buy this and let's call it good and builds it tomorrow, which could happen, but, you know. Sounds subtle now. Yeah. So that's kind of, I think, where we're at with the 10-year deal. So I don't think, from Dirk's perspective, from the wood site, I don't believe that it's endangered by the fact that we're looking at other sites for more permanent long-term. I don't think that those two things conflict with each other.
1:35:45 And I think if we put in a 10-year payback clause, if it doesn't last a venue for 10 years, I don't think we're going to have the power of $300,000 to put a lien, but it's just more of a payback clause that if it doesn't, either our infrastructure doesn't happen by a certain amount of time or the site isn't made available for the 10 years, that it's a repayment. Or it doesn't meet some of the other requirements that we've put in there. Could I request that before we finalize anything, we take public comment on this one? Yeah.
1:36:14 Sure, we can do that. There's one comment on, Colin had some language there about, you know, having a site be available for, what if you have the area nation wants to kind of rent the place? It seems like there should be some discretion on Mr. Winner's part to decide who he'd like to rent his private property to. Well, I think that's the point, is to make it available for people to rent it, and he can determine who that is, as long as it's made available.
1:36:47 And he can make the determination. We're not going to make the determination. Right, as long as it's equal opportunity. Absolutely. Anybody can go to him. He can decide who he wants. We're not guaranteeing a group like, hey, well, since we give this $300,000, that means any group can say, yeah, I want that spot. I think that's probably one step further into the actual contract of the money. It's a valid point to consider, but I think we're just trying to put some broad parameters there.
1:37:14 We would hope that wouldn't be a group that would come and request it. You can see these loopholes and say, hey, this property, they say it's open to everybody. Let's do it. I don't know what sort of, I mean, honestly, how much pressure or how much constraint we can put on a private landowner, even though there's a gift of funds, basically. I think the game changes a little bit when there's a gift of public funds. I mean, I don't want to meddle in...
1:37:43 You know, private transactions to whatever degree we can stay out of that. But I think there's, you know, things do change when public funds have been gifted. Fair enough. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So I think we got through DC, B, everybody seems pretty comfortable with the 10-year time frame. So it's just really A. Yeah, it's the main thing is what...
1:38:07 How does everybody feel about that time frame? I mean, do we feel like if we say the $300,000 needs to be used for infrastructure by July 1st of 2018, that pushes things a little bit? And then if Dirk comes back with a petition for an extension based on something concrete that he's doing, we can discuss that? Does that seem reasonable? Everybody?
1:38:29 Can I jump back to the point that Ted made? I think that if we were to say site must be available for consideration to anyone who wants to rent it. Consideration. Does that work? Because I think that then at least it's saying you can apply to rent it. But you might not. It doesn't mean you're not going to get it. Yeah, okay. Or it doesn't mean you're going to get it. That's great. Consideration, I think, takes that up. John, it feels like $300,000, $30,000 a year for 10 years, and that $30,000 is going into infrastructure to solve our events.
1:38:59 Problem for a decade. It seems like a real value. And again, it's the board's discretion depending on, you know, future funding ability. You know, we may get to this point next year where we've had a good year or we have additional funds. You know, we have this, you know, we have our strategic initiatives that we have putting money towards.
1:39:19 You know, it may be the case where Dirk comes back and says, well, here's my plan. I want to move on this. I can get this done so we can have X, Y, and Z done by 2019. Okay, we have another $300,000 or $200,000, whatever it may be. So, yeah, this is at least a starting point. But no guarantee of future, you know, of future funds. I certainly haven't had the conversation with him, but I know that his marquee event is like up to a million lights.
1:39:47 It would seem reasonably logical that maybe the first thing out of the gate would be electric, right? But I have no idea. And that's probably going to be $300,000. Yeah, I mean, I have no idea, but, you know, I'm sure there's plenty of things between... There are LED lights that run off a D-battery. They're good for 30 years. You know, I think, you know, he's got pathways that he's talked about. He's got, you know, potential permanent bathrooms that he's talked about.
1:40:15 Electric, water, all those things. There's certainly more than $300,000 to be spent. So however he wants to slice up the whole pie is fine. So the point that was made before, though, if he provides us with a budget for electricity is going to be $500,000, we can say, okay, we want $300,000 to go right to that. Or if he says that electricity is going to be $100,000 and paths are going to be $50,000, and we can go through and say that this is where our priorities are. So to Sean's point, if...
1:40:43 If we don't think that paths are for the greater good, they're good for his event, and granted it's his property, he can pay for the paths. But we have the things that we feel are good for the greater good, which would be water, which would be power, which would be some of those other, more of the basic needs, not the nice-to-haves. You know, path is nice to have, a stage, frankly, is nice to have, but power and water are probably necessities, and I would like to see our dollars go to the necessities of getting the site usable for multiple things versus specifically Sean's event or specifically his event.
1:41:13 I don't want to pay just for things that are going to benefit his event if they're not going to benefit Shakespeare in the park or they're not going to benefit anybody else that wants to rent the site. They're going to say, we'd love to rent the site, but you don't have power. Another comment that I know he's looking into is Wi-Fi. And I brought this up, I think, in a previous meeting before Blues Blues last year, is that all of a sudden you've got 6,000 people who are all wanting to take pictures of a stage that says Mammoth Lakes behind it and post it.
1:41:41 But they can't even access the internet because there's 6,000 people on site. You know, there might be some things, too, that would be of benefit to tourism, like those temporary towers. I can't remember what those are called. Yeah, I think in the discussion with him, part of it was...
1:41:59 That he's going to have further discussions with promoters, with event planners, and so to get a little bit broader list of some of the other things that might not be on his radar of things that are going to be required to make, and that's a good point, you know, something like that, a temporary Wi-Fi tower, whatever it may be to facilitate that sort of thing. So I'm sure there will be, you know, going forward, there will be plenty of discussion about that sort of thing.
1:42:20 Because everybody sort of has a little bit of expertise on things. And again, it's prioritization of what's going to be necessary. And I wonder if there's opportunity for us with this to say, like even with the Wi-Fi, you know, we've been working with Jeep. Is this something that we can say, hey, Dirk, we're going to pick up the tab for the Wi-Fi. We want to make sure that people, that Jeep has representation as providing the Wi-Fi. You know, I know you're not a huge fan of sponsorship, but this is how we get things done in the world. I understand, and I am softening my position.
1:42:50 Yes. And so I think it might be something that we could even get a deal for. It's something where we could actually potentially get other people's money to put towards this as well. Okay. So does there need to be any additional language on, like, discretion as far as how the dollars are allocated? So I think what we need to do is we need to go back and we need to ask him for the infrastructure projects and the estimated budgets so we know what we're buying. We need a menu. Sure. And we can go back. And I wrote down, I think...
1:43:19 From what I'm hearing here, I think our focus or our priorities are power, water. And I agree with Wi-Fi for the reason of more people out there tagging Visit Mammoth or tagging, you know, Bluza Palooza. It's hugely beneficial for us. And I don't know what the cost is to get the site completely Wi-Fi'd up. I mean, we looked at doing the whole town a few years ago for 60 grand or something. So it's probably not insurmountable. But again, it gives us something to even go back to a partner and say,
1:43:47 What can we do to potentially get you involved in this? And do we... Maybe just some language about ultimate discretion on what infrastructure projects... Well, he offered yesterday to give us a list of kind of the infrastructure that he would... I don't know how precise he has pricing on it, but he can say, yes, we want it, we need to do the clean power. He may have an estimate of that. He may say, instead of a fire hydrant, we need real water lines coming through there, and it's going to cost this, and to do this, it's this, and paths is that, and stages that.
1:44:14 Bathrooms or that or whatever. Because he may, regardless of the requirements, he may say, okay, I'm going to build four permanent toilets. And then the rest of whatever gets needed for Blues of Blues, it comes in in blue rooms. So are we good though with, is it really comfortable with the July 1st, 18th date as sort of pushing things along and then we'll see what his reaction is and maybe have a little bit of wiggle room there? With the language that Mr. Furney threw in there, yeah, I think that's reasonable. The language of the extension to extend?
1:44:44 Yeah, exactly. So it's not carving stuff. I've got it. So I guess we'll draw that up and discuss that at the next meeting, kind of formalize it. Well, I think what we need to do is go back to him and ask for some of these things. Right. And then, yeah, we should formalize it at the next meeting and get that agreement with him figured out. I just wouldn't be vague on what it can be spent on. I know you're throwing that out there as ideas, but I would be...
1:45:08 Very specific on what the money can be spent on. Well, and that's why I think if we get this menu, if we get this menu, we can then prioritize it. Okay. It's true because we have nine different opinions coming to the table here too, I'm sure. Or more if we have multiple personalities out there. Well, as John said earlier, some things, pathways could benefit some events, not others, but there are certain things that are just foundational for any of those. And that's why I worked on the power of water. Yeah, I think just...
1:45:35 We could even make it broader than that, that we have ultimate discretion on where, what infrastructure projects we want. Our money. Yeah. Yeah. That makes sense. Perfect. I think it's going to be pretty obvious when it finally does come up, but, you know. Well, and again, I don't, like I said, I don't know if power is 50,000 bucks or if it's 500,000 bucks. I have no idea. Yeah. I have no idea what to take. And so that's why I think that if we, if we look at what is going to benefit the majority, if not everybody, power is probably one of them.
1:46:03 Water is probably a very clear number two. And from our standpoint, from a marketing standpoint, Wi-Fi is, you know, a pretty big one. So thanks for bringing that up. Okay, great. We'll get that drafted. All right. So part B of this, and I think, John, I'm not sure, correct me if I'm wrong on this, when you were talking about it, was it the Mammoth Lakes film?
1:46:23 Festival? Or was it the Foundation? Well, it's the Foundation's Film Festival, yes. So obviously at the last meeting, the folks from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and the Film Festival came to us and asked for funds for various different things. And we listened and we didn't really make any discussion at that point. So that's an item for discussion. I would just say before we start, or part of that discussion is we've been very specific up to now that, or through this process, that we certainly market.
1:46:52 All events. But we have not funded individual events. That is not something we've been doing. Nor have we marketed specific events. Specific events. We market in general. So you bring us... We've marketed specific events through our owned and earned channels. So social media, emails, things like that. So two weeks out from your event, we're talking about what's coming up. Yes. Okay. Thank you for the clarification. We don't buy media for any specific event. We...
1:47:21 We do the posters, which are a collaboration of all events. We do the brochures that are a collaboration of all events. We do the website, which is a collaboration of all events. But then the social and the owned media, things that we already own, or PR that goes out to say, hey, you should come in July because these are all the things going on. So my comment would be, my comment personally would be, if it's a great event and the film festival is a wonderful thing and so forth, but we will continue to support it in the ways that we do, but we're not going to cut a check.
1:47:49 As we continue to expand that, we did the live interviews with you, or the live, the Facebook lives with Josh last year, we did them with the film festival. So, I mean, we're expanding what we're doing through our own channels, and so we're getting the word out through a lot of those, far more than before. It's pretty important that we stay consistent with that, because obviously there's a hundred other people out there that are looking for the same thing, and we get into that big mess again. I would say just as, you know, people working on the content, I think that the more that...
1:48:18 events like that reach out to us, the more play we're happy to give them. A lot of times everything's kind of getting equal play, but we're happy to have someone reach out and say, hey, we'd love to be interviewed on a Facebook Live. That kind of stuff is really easy to get going and free on our end. Okay, great. Discussion on that? I can't say I disagree. I think we already have a funding stream in the town that supports a lot of that stuff.
1:48:48 Okay. I think we're maintaining our position. Okay. I don't know that, I can't recall what the timeline was. I don't think they've gotten back to you or to me. They'll come, I think, in the minutes, they said they were going to reach out to me and ask. Yeah, we can just follow up with them and let them know that we moved in that direction and continue to turn focus. Okay. Great. Hey, wow. Ten to three.
1:49:19 March 1st. Sorry. Thank you. Yeah, yeah. Next meeting is March 1st. March 1st. And John, did you want to go over the key takeaways that you want us to? I will be missing that meeting on the 1st, just if I... Okay. Yeah, the key takeaways are just what we went over with the year to date. So we're 29% ahead of budget at $1.7 million. And again, I think if I did the math yesterday, if we just hit budget for the rest of the year, we're about $13.5 million.
1:49:49 So that's roughly $2 million ahead of budget. And that's only if we hit budget for the rest of the year. At this point, January, February, March, and April, I anticipate being well above budget. Again, I don't know how much, I think they'll be comparable to last year. I don't know that they're going to blow numbers away. Like December was only up 1.5%. I think January, if we see a 2% to 5% growth on those huge numbers from last year, that's good. And then just the fact that
1:50:19 We had a record number for December again. I think we've missed, I think we've only missed two months that weren't records last April and this past November. The rest of the months have been records since June of 2015. John, what was the final TOT number if we just hit budget? If we just hit budget, it's 13.5. Okay. So for where we are right now, if we just hit the next six months of budget, like I said, January's budgeted at 1.8, we're going to do 2.4. Sure.
1:50:47 So, you know, we're going to add on to that. So if we just did budget conservatively, you're looking at $13,500, which is $1.9 ahead of budget. So, and then lastly, just the fact that we are, more importantly, I think to even budget, I think to talk about the fact that we're $800,000 ahead of the previous record.
1:51:05 That's still mind-boggling. We're six months into the year, and we're ahead of what was a ridiculous record last year. That's the big number. Colin, you can tell me this. Is the budget, actually, I know I should know this, but was the fiscal year budget for this year, is it similar to what was last year, or did you bump it up? We bumped it up a bit. Still under 12, though. Okay, so if we do equal last year.
1:51:31 last year's TOT, then that means that there should be an additional, if a math is right, about $3.1, $3.2 million, $4 million, to go specifically to the general fund. Oh, yeah, $3.1. Okay, so above budget, about $3.1 million goes to the general fund of the town. I just want to make sure we say that so people understand it if we do wind up equally above budget, which is great because obviously there are plenty of projects that...
1:51:59 The town needs to get done, and that's excellent. And that's, I think, what we're always trying to say is we're always trying to drive that engine, and to the extent that we can continue to bring in that TOT, it just, it goes to the general fund and helps everybody. You know, I think that's, you know, we're going to start to have some budget discussions over the next month, but, you know, that's the struggle that council has is kind of towing that line of we definitely have needs and infrastructure, and, you know, we could certainly use bodies in certain areas.
1:52:28 So, you know, it's balancing that act. When our budget does this all the time in those bad years, it's catastrophic. It's slash and burn. And so, you know, I'm very cognizant of not tying up a lot of long-term encumbrances. I'd much rather, you know, tie a tighter budget line and then have those overages that can go into capital infrastructure where we're so deficient. But that being said, I think we are growing sustainably. I mean, I think summer is pretty sustainable growth.
1:52:58 You know, fall and spring. I mean, those things have come up from even where we were five years ago. So maybe our sustainable budget is a higher number than it was two years ago. Yeah, it doesn't have to be out at the park. Yeah, I mean, we don't have to just go out and say, all right, we're going to budget at 15 million bucks now. That, I think, would be irresponsible. But if we bump that up to, you know, 12, 12 and a half, I mean, I have no idea what the council is going to arrive at.
1:53:22 Would potentially create some room for an additional police officer, for example. You know, that being said, our costs are going up at an astronomical rate. If we don't add a single body, our costs went up $500,000 Y over Y. And that's purely on health benefits and PERS and all that. So health costs and PERS. So that's something that's a really terrifying thing that, you know, even if we toe the line, it goes up.
1:53:51 half a million bucks or we have to start cutting services. So, you know, that's kind of what we're playing with is where's the right number to say, hey, we can maybe provide some incremental services and incremental body here and there, but not tie up a bunch of long-term encumbrances that we're then going to dip down below.
1:54:08 Well, last year, I think you did the one-time things. You put another $500,000 towards the police station, $500,000 towards the terminal, the parking lot at Weston, the Old Mammoth Road, the parking lot. I mean, all one-time things. And I think that's exactly, you're absolutely right. Don't assume they're coming, but I think if you budget conservatively enough, you mentioned you.
1:54:27 We're sustainable on the growth to a certain extent, but I'm not saying that I'm not going to guarantee you $16 million next year. Right. But I think that $12 million is definitely something that's sustainable. If you look at three years ago when the mountain had their worst winter ever with 800,000 visits, we missed budget by 2%. Right. We had an 11-6 budget. We did 11-2-7-1. So I think that you're right. Summer has rounded out that. We're not the one-trick winter pony. Sure. And then fall this year, the effort that we put through fall this year.
1:54:55 I expected to see the results this coming fall, and we saw them last year. I can only hope to see what we see this fall. Like I said, I think October, within two years, will be a million bucks. Yeah, I mean, it's great to see that, it's great to see the difference, and I think what we're all getting to is the difference between an awful winner and a great winner be, you know, 10%.
1:55:15 difference in the total budget rather than 40% difference. Yeah, that's the thing that we all want to get away from, which is great. All the other things we're doing, all the other sustainable year-round, 10-month, all that sort of thing is moving towards that. And that's kind of where we arrived at the budget this year. We said, let's take basically last summer, which was a great summer, and say we'll either be at last summer or maybe a little bit up even, which I think is relatively conservative.
1:55:41 and then tack on a terrible winter to that and see where it puts us up because winter's still volatile. And if that number shakes out and a number that we feel comfortable at, you know, then maybe we can budget there. Yeah, and even the summer numbers were pretty conservative, which, again, I have no problem with that because it's always nice to have the windfall versus figuring out what you're going to cut. Sure. Which is good because it's always volatile. Yeah. No matter what the season. No matter what. Yeah. I mean, July at 1.25, we did 1.7. Yeah. Good.
1:56:11 Any other comments before we wrap it up? We have a motion to adjourn? I will so move. Do we have a second? Second. All right. We are adjourned. Thanks, guys. Thank you. Who seconded that? Sean motioned. Who seconded? Oh, Colin seconded, I think. Thank you, Eric. Got to get those. Talk to you soon. Thanks, Eric. Get the wax out of your ears.
1:56:48 This was at, I meant to mention that she's at the, she's at the, no call.
1:57:23 Hi there. What's going on? How are you doing? Is it charging? Yeah.
1:57:55 Yeah, they are.
1:58:17 Thank you.