Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2017
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 20 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
315 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:02 Okay. Hear ye, hear ye. Hear ye, hear ye. All right. Thanks, everybody, for being here. Let's go ahead and call our March 8th meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board to order. Let's see, with a roll call, John Morris, I am here. Kurt Schaubmeyer is not here. Brent Truax is here. Michael Desma is here. Colin Fernie is not. Do you know if Colin's coming or not? Colin is not coming. Okay. Sean Turner. I am here. Eric.
3:30 Eric Clark is here instead of Eric Forssell. Interchangeable Eric. Paul Rudder is not here, and Scott McGuire, we're hoping to be on the phone shortly? Hope so. Okay. Very good. One, two, three, four, five. We do have a quorum. Excellent. All right. Any board member comments, reports, or agenda additions for this month? Yeah, I've got a question kind of in comments, and I know that we've got an event venue update a little bit later on, but just wanted to find out where we are.
4:00 You know, whatever happened with the event coordinator position that was supposed to be going forward with the town? That's still on hold at this point. Okay. I think there are a few different moving parts right now between MLR, the town, everything, so. There's discussion that's going on, but not.
4:14 Nothing finalized. Okay. I would like for this board to review taking that position back in-house. I have a feeling that's the direction it's going to go anyway, but we can have that conversation. Okay. Yeah, I'd like to get out in front of this, and I don't know if it's something that should be discussed at this meeting during that new business item or if it's something that needs to be agendized for next month, but I'd like to revisit that subject.
4:36 Well, I think that that could get rolled into that new business piece. Sure, we can talk about it then. I think kind of its events in general. Okay. And then my suggestion would be that we, from the board, develop a subcommittee to talk about the pros, the cons, the needs, the wants, the funding, all those different pieces. But I think we need to have a smaller group that's really focused on that. Excuse me. Okay. Thank you. Okay. We'll address it in new business when we get to it.
5:03 Anybody else? The only other thing I was going to throw out, oh, sorry, go ahead. Okay. The only thing I was going to throw out is I emailed you guys your Form 700s today. That needs to get done and sent back to Jamie. You sent us the electronic version? I don't know.
5:14 Change 16 to 17. Yeah, I don't own anything. That's super easy. Because we went over this last night with NLR because Jamie prefers electronic version now is what I'm told versus the paper version. So there's an electronic link which you can just fill it out online. Oh, I just emailed it back door. I just saved it and emailed it back door. But yeah, those need to be done by April 3rd. So please, let's make sure we don't have to chase everybody around for those. So on our staff, it's Whitney, myself, Michael, and Laura that fill those out.
5:44 And so we'll make sure we get those all done, too. I just got a couple things. Sure. One, from MLR. So MLR is starting to begin a national search for an ED. Rich Bacha has served as the starting ED, and we've reached a point where we need to change the role of that organization into a little bit more of a fundraising organization. And we're looking for somebody that will move that organization forward. Rich has done a fantastic job of getting us to where we are today.
6:12 But we're looking at the needs of the community of where we need to be, and we will be looking for someone to fill that position. So we're contracted with a recruitment, recruiting company out of Northern California, and they'll be the primary source for applicants for that location. Secondarily, also just announced last night, and Sean's aware of this too, Trails End Park received District 7 award for park, recognition for best park out of the District 7.
6:39 Fresno, Madera, I forget the exact counties there, but fairly large startable area as a park, and it's the second largest skateboard park in the country, if everybody's not aware. So it's a pretty significant park, and it's a job well done, and kudos to the town. And on a more direct note, I believe the rec commissioner, some Elizabeth Truex, got elected to the state board for...
7:04 State California Parks Recs and Stu Brown got elected to District 7 Board. That's great. It's good recognition for the town and we do a lot up here and people forget that with 7.7 million people visits in this town, there's a lot of people from Southern California that come here and it's about time that we get recognized for all the things we do.
7:24 Brent, I had a question for you. This is just germane to your business. I heard an interview the other day on the radio, and it sounds like you guys, sounds like Rafters is going to have more live music.
7:36 So I'm like a more, a new promoter, a new guy coming in to bring more live music down there. Yeah, we have a gentleman actually out of North Lake Tahoe, a company's called Dancing Shoes that's booking entertainment. So we're trying to do a little bit more regional entertainment. Some of the acts that are up in Tahoe that are some of the casinos that we can draw on a trip to Southern California. So we're trying to get a few bigger acts and we've got some great stuff that's going to happen on property this year.
8:03 From an overall standpoint. Cool. Yeah, I heard some of the names he was throwing around. I was like, I know these guys. They're named people. That's really cool. And same as John's aware of this in terms of event business, you get them when they're traveling, and we've had some that we thought were going to come in, and we lost them because they booked another gig. But still, we've got some great acts coming up. Cool. All right, that's all my plugging for Raptors. Any other public, I'm sorry, any other comments from board members?
8:30 You know, I actually did have one more, and you reminded me just because Recreation Commission. Something that I've been ringing up on Recreation Commission a couple times lately is that we as a group, and I'm referring to U.S. Forest Service and Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, can do a better job, I think, with regard to communication when Reds Meadow and when Lakes Basin is open. We've had issues in the past where they're getting information from the Visitor's Center, which is not entirely accurate when you actually get up to the gates.
9:00 So I've asked Stu Brown to make sure that they're coordinating with the Forest Service as much as possible. Just, you know, I get it. You can't open up the roads until the boulders are clear, the downed trees, the threatened downing trees are clear, the ice around the lake, they don't want to open that up until the ice has actually cleared away. But it's just very, very important, I think, that we as a community, as a group of municipalities, really do a better job in communicating with our public because when they get up here,
9:29 And they find out something at the visitor center which is not accurate when they actually get up to the lake space. And town of Mammoth Lakes is the one that gets blamed. I feel like, you know, that's the specific comments that I hear. So I just bring that up that, you know, obviously I know we share, tourism shares space with them that anything we can do to assist with regard to that communication plan. Yeah, I guess I'd be surprised that they don't have that because they've got, you know, we meet with the Forest Service in the spring and fall on the open and closure dates. And obviously they...
9:59 Very fairly wildly with the snowfall, but the Forest Service and the connection to the Welcome Center, I'm surprised that they would have any miscommunication, but we'll make sure that it's not. I don't know when, and Laura, I don't know if we have a, so we don't have a date for the open meeting. Yeah. Yeah. Running Tamarack, we see the same concern. And I don't think it's a, it might be a communication thing, but I think they actually.
10:32 When you assess the safety aspect, the trees and so forth, you don't know exactly when it's going to happen. We knew that it was kind of changing on a daily basis, but we never knew the answer. Yeah, and I know, and I totally get it, and it can change on a day-to-day basis, but it's just very important that we as a collective community do a better job than what I've seen in past spring openings.
10:58 Primarily. It's primarily the spring. It's not so much the fall. But just as far as communicating with our visitors. And we'll make sure we get that info. Yeah, especially, pardon me, with the snow, we've been getting a lot of questions from guests booking in April and May right now asking about, well, what about fishing open and what do you think? And, you know, yeah, it is a difficult, it's kind of a crapshoot as far as what's going to be open and what's not. But I remember last year there were...
11:21 There were some concerns. There were people that were told that they could go to Horseshoe and Horseshoe was clubbing. So there was kind of that disconnect and it seemed to happen during a couple of week period. So I agree. I think when we get into that transition period, it's really critical that we're giving or we're forecasting, we're getting accurate forecasts. So we're not telling people, oh, sure, come up and, you know, May 1st, this is going to be open. And that's what hurt us last year is the forecast.
11:45 It was forecasted for here, then it was moved out to here, then it was moved out to there, and then it was moved. So it was such a moving target that even if we had the forecast and said, yeah, we should be open by X, we weren't open by X. So if you're saying that we're expecting to be open by then and we're not open by then, then we're going to disappoint people. But, you know, we can only go off of what we were told we're expecting. But it's more of a we're projected open here, but check back.
12:07 And it's going to be another moving target this spring, no question. And all I'm going to say is that if we're still have snow up there for the marathon, if the mountain can loan me a snowblower, I will personally drive it up there and clear that out and get ready for the marathon. To that point, I actually spoke with the folks. As you know, we go to 120 as well. I know. I spoke to the folks from the half marathon the other day, and they feel that they have a good line of communication with the town and through Hayes about making sure that that, because one of the things when we first started the half marathon,
12:36 Marathon, we actually talked about the idea of it being a very novelty to have people start in snow banks and end in town, especially since people in San Diego are starting to get warm weather now. Two months from now, three months from now, they're going to come up here and run the half and they're going to start in snow banks. It's pretty cool. It's just a question of whether we can get all the powers that be, the Forest Service and the town to participate. But that's a big one. I mean, that's 2,500 people coming into town for the event.
13:04 Well, and just going back to kind of getting to Horseshoe Lake, I think that some of the confusion was that, yeah, you can walk to Horseshoe Lake from where the gates are closed, but I think these people had the impression they could drive to. So it may be just something that simple. I think it's a little bit more detailed than that. I get it. Things change on a daily basis. We just need to be as communicative as possible. Laura and I will take lead on that and just make sure that we get the information and that we are very much in their loop because we're not always in the loop.
13:34 Okay. Very frustrating, but anyway. All right. Good comments. Okay. Any public comment? And I wanted to just come in today. I had a couple of questions about special events. Utilize your resources to help market special events in town. Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation puts on a few events throughout the year. Hopefully you've heard of them through what we're doing now. Mammoth Invitational is coming up April 7th through 9th. We have in August, August 19th, the Wine Walk in the Village.
14:16 September 9th, we have the Mammoth Grand Fondo Road Bike Ride, and then September 14th through 17th is the Kamikaze Bike Games, which is four days of mountain biking. And I believe that all of those events are already on your online calendar. I think they're listed, hopefully, in the publication that you put out. And I just wanted to see if there's any other resources that we can take advantage of through you guys. We have applied in the past for funding.
14:45 Through the town or through Measure U, we were told we couldn't put marketing in those applications because we should go to Mammoth Lakes Tourism to help get funding for that and just get help in general. So is there anything else? What am I sort of missing? Can we get social media help from you? Is there any other publications? I've heard talk through the town that some of the banners that hang along Main Street, I don't know if that's you or if that's town, sort of what else can we be doing as special events to help get our word out there?
15:14 Yeah, I'll just talk to Whitney. Yeah, I mean, I just think having a one-on-one conversation with us, we definitely have some ways to amplify that message through our content. You know, we can definitely execute on social media as well as include in our blog content. And then, did you cover quite a bit of those with the pro athletes? Do you have some involvement in some of the things?
15:46 Yeah. About those events. Yeah. So, you know, there's always PR opportunities. Okay. And that, so, like, for our event with invitational fundraiser, we have our athletes who come for that as well. This year, it's a 1980s thing, sort of going long, Glen Plague, a bunch of U.S. ski team, mobile skiers, aerialists, various things. So, can I just get in touch with you as we sort of confirm all of those things and get it out there? And then,
16:13 Yeah, and if you've got access, so our community, everything on social media and our email marketing, that's for you guys. So, you know, anything that you can send us in addition to, of course, we have the information that goes up on our site on the event listing, but if you've got other assets, images, special updates, that sort of thing, send them my way. I'm Megan and Miranda. Yeah, and we're happy to continue to push those types of events on our social and email marketing. Okay, what kind of lead time do you need for things like that and even for PR?
16:41 I mean, if you have that information now, that's what I would recommend, and I'd always encourage you to just come in and talk to us one-on-one. We do work with Mammoth Mountain quite closely in the promotion, and so if we could just sit down, talk about what we've done, and lay out a plan. We'd like to get on it sooner or later because we plan out so far in advance.
17:02 Typically content-wise, we're planning stuff a month in advance, so all the social is usually scheduled. Not to say that there isn't space to get things in at the last minute, if something like, let's say, an event gets changed, and you really need to get the word out about a date getting changed. Of course we can do something at the last minute with that, but typically we're looking at a month in advance. Okay. Except when it's events, then it's earlier, because we want an opportunity for them to book. And so the blog content's going to come quite a bit earlier than that. So there's kind of there, so anyway. So there's kind of blog, social.
17:29 PR articles, things. PR things, like, the longer the better. Yeah. As well, but in regard to the crib, I would definitely like to talk to you about what you need to feel about. Okay. Okay. Great. Perfect. Thank you. I'll reach out to you guys. Thank you very much. Hopefully you've all seen our invite for the invitational, but I will leave some with you.
17:58 In case you'd like to attend. And Lindsay, just overall too, from Lodging Association, because we put up, we're always trying to draw people into the community. John Morris is the chair of Lodging Association, so I know we all get, I get emails and those type things. Yeah. But they're formatted to how we're bringing people in for the events a little differently. It's not just individuals. I'm trying to get people to stay here for multiple nights. I'm always open to those conversations as well. Great. And yeah, we've definitely had some. Not that Mr. Clark isn't as well either.
18:26 And we do definitely work with the various lodging properties for a lot of those events, and you guys are also very generous. Yeah, Lindsay, any time you, if you have something that you need me to blast out, I mean, you guys probably have the same list, but if you want to, just make sure you cover everything. I've got all the people in the Lodging Association, so if you want to send me anything, I'll forward it out to anybody, you know, if it's lodging related, whatever. Perfect. So, yeah, happy to. Excellent. Thank you very much. I'll reach out. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you.
18:54 Anybody else? I'd like to follow up on this subject, though, if I can. I know that we as a board have a policy that we are not supporting any specific individual events, and I'm hearing a lot of concern in the community that we should be mirroring what other destination...
19:13 destinations are doing with regard to events. So I'd like us to actually have a conversation along this. I guess I'm asking for an agenda item to discuss this. And I know that this kind of falls into events as a whole, but I'm hearing a lot from people that I represent, at least within the retail area on this board, that we should be doing a better job of actually maybe supporting individual events. And so I'd like to review that policy. Could we review what we currently do?
19:43 Could we put that on the agenda for next week or next month to be a review of what we currently do to support events? Because I think there might be a miscommunication as to how much effort and how much money, how much time, how much space goes to it. I think that'd be fine. And I think that this is going to be a much bigger conversation than anything that we're going to cover in business item number 10 here. So yes, let's schedule it for next month. Can I ask staff to put together at least a comparison of what other peer resorts do?
20:12 Can you send us what peer resorts you're referring to so I can go specifically to them and make sure is it indeed their tourism bureau that is doing that or do they have an event coalition or you know we can kind of get dig into those details a little bit further and any examples that you're referring to would be really helpful because I mean we have quite an extensive program so I just want to make sure I've got all the information we need for a good comparison and I mean I'll do additional work.
20:40 You bet. And again, I want to be clear that this is a conversation that... Can we move that to the May conversation? I think... I don't think I have the capacity to do that for the next one because we have a pretty heavy agenda for the next board meeting and I'm out of town for two weeks.
20:57 Well, we could certainly have a brief discussion on the, you know, without having all the data, as long as it doesn't get too involved, it won't take up too much time. Well, I think the concern, I don't want to run down the rabbit hole of looking at funding events without knowing what we currently do. What we currently do. I think it's too important to understand how much effort, money, and some of the challenges of starting to get into individual event funding could create, you know, with 100 events in town over the course of 365 days, it can get.
21:23 It could get pretty interesting. Can we make that the May presentation? Well, let me ask this question. I'm open to this as long as we are able to consider any kind of changes that we may do that can be discussed with regard to the next fiscal year budget. Yeah. So if we have this conversation in May, does that give us enough time to, if we do decide to make any changes, if, that we are able to incorporate this into the 17-18 budget?
21:53 I mean, we're developing budgets, you know, we're meeting with our agencies and developing those budgets, and so it'll be right around that time, so if we could, I mean, just to be realistic, we don't want to push it all the way for June because we're balancing quite a big budget. We also have some flexibility with budget right now, so that's good. True, true, yeah. Yeah, I'm open to this because, again, I want to make sure that, and what I'd like to do is come at it from this angle, is that if we choose to keep our current
22:22 Policy. Then I want to have a very good answer to be able to defend this board as to why we are choosing to go forward with that policy after review. We haven't reviewed it in quite a while, so I think that it's time. So I tell you what, I'll send you an example of other peer resorts that I'd like to understand what they're doing and understand some of their successes, and then let's review what we're doing. And it sounds like we're going to talk about it all during April or just save it all for May.
22:52 I think we're better off holding off until we have all facts. Yeah. Okay. Make more sense. Thank you. Okay. So we'll put that on for May. I'll adjust the budget review. We can potentially do that in June. Okay. Thank you. I'll move that down. Okay. All right. Any other public comment? Seeing none, let's go on to approval of minutes from the February 1st meeting. Do we have a motion to approve? Yeah. I'll move to approve the minutes from
23:24 February 1st. Okay. Second. Do you have a second? Anybody have any changes? All in favor? Aye. Anybody opposed? All right. Minutes are approved. Because Lara has to leave for an appointment, I want to see if we can do her PR review before we go into the presentation. Jump down into 7. Yeah, just quickly down to the PR update. 7.2. Okay. Yeah.
23:59 Starting to focus in on community PR efforts. We're kind of looking inward. We've been doing really well, you know, getting a lot of media exposure out in the world. So we're taking a look inward now, community PR, getting out and talking to the local businesses, how we can continue to help them, meeting with businesses, finding out there what's new, what's going on. We do a spring press release about what's new, what's coming up for summer. So getting people involved.
24:30 Just talking to them about how we can help them, you know, PR or even own content, just kind of making that effort to get out in public and, you know, make the rounds, and so that's a big thing we're working on right now. We're talking about doing, like, some monthly coffees with MLT, you know, get the word out we're going to be here on this day, and it would be probably me and somebody else from staff, maybe Whitney.
24:57 So people can come and ask questions, if they have concerns, just to kind of to, you know, people give us some flack sometimes, so give them a chance to talk to us directly, get out and friend them. We're also looking at reworking the format of our open house. We were doing those open houses, I think it's been a year, two years since we've done them, but the format was a little bit dry, so we're trying to figure out.
25:26 How to do those again, but make them a little more interesting and sticky so people actually are understanding the information and walking away with a better understanding of what we're doing. And we're also revamping the Industry Insider website and looking at ways to get people to use that more. I don't think a lot of people are going on there and using the tools that we have for businesses.
25:55 I've also been talking with Jessica a lot, how we can better work with the Chamber, just to, you know, your Chamber membership gives you this, your paying into the TBID gives you this, kind of helping people understand what they're getting, what schools are out there, for kind of the money that they're paying in, you know. So that's a big project for us right now. Additionally, the crib is reopening next week for the season.
26:23 So we are working on a press release about that for the local papers to let them know that that's going to be rocking and rolling. We are holding a kickoff party on next Wednesday, March 15th at the Burberry, the eatery. If any of you would like to come, we're inviting local athletes, any athletes that are visiting right now, just to talk to them, show them we appreciate them, working with them.
26:53 and talk to them about more content ideas about how we can work with them this summer and this season for the crib. And then finally, we had a really exciting week last week. Tom Painter is doing the snow observatory down at the airport. We had the New York Times in. They came out and went up in a helicopter with him to check out. They couldn't go in the plane, but they went out in the helicopter with him to
27:22 Kind of check out the snow levels. We're expecting a really big spread on this story, so if we were pressed, this was the year to do it. They got to go up there and see a ton of snow. So we're really excited that that all came together. Laura, when might you see that? Hopefully Friday. Oh wow, great. Yeah. And we were told that their graphics team was working on stuff, so that's a good indicator that it's going to be a decent spread. So we'll definitely send that out to you guys.
27:52 And when they flew in February, Tom sent me a text, the deepest point on the mountain was like 478 inches or something. And there were upwards of 50 feet in spots in the lakes basin. When fishing was there again? Yeah, August. August what? San Francisco Chronicle webpage is kind of my homepage. They had a satellite picture of, I think it was January 2014 versus January 2017.
28:23 One is brown and one is white. It's the two pictures. And just to throw out there, back on the community PR thing, if you guys have any ideas, please feel free to shoot me an email. You know, other ways we can get out and just talk to the community more and, you know, get their feedback on what we're doing and what's going on. You want to mention the meetings and events? California meetings and events? Oh, yeah.
28:48 Didn't we? I thought you said that. I did, but I want to make sure that the rest of the world that's watching knows. Yeah, so we were awarded Best Small DMO by California Medians and Events, so pretty big honor for us. Very excited. We just got a letter of congratulations from Senator Berryhill. So it was, there were two DMO categories. One was 25,000 people and less. One was over. I think LA won the big one. LA and San Diego tied. Yeah, and we won the.
29:18 Little guys. But still a really great honor. So we're excited. We just got a plaque. We've been hanging in the office. Congratulations. That's fantastic. Way to go. March it up and down Main Street. Get some exposure out of that. I'll take those when I go out to do my community. Exactly. We're just going to put this here. All right. All right, Whitney.
29:42 And I'd just like to add, congratulations, John, to you and your staff for that award. That's great work. I mean, there are lots of DMOs in Mammoth, in California, and it's great that, it's great for you guys to get that recognition. That's really, that's awesome. Thank you. We know how hard you guys all work. We appreciate it. So, you know, we appreciate the work you do. Yeah, did you want to mention the TripAdvisor that Michael Vanderhurst just sent us? All right, we just got another award. Awesome. For Best Adult Spring Break. I'm not going to go there.
30:12 Vegas. Okay, we're going to jump into the marketing update and what is our cutoff time? I wasn't able to take a look. You have a half an hour, so probably 20 minutes and then question and answer. Okay. Did you mean to make Jason? No, they're in a walk here. Good dad. All right, so what we're going to be going over today is we'll be going through our monthly reporting. We have a little bit of catch up with you guys since we were traveling for the last month.
30:42 And then I'm going to do a month of activities and review where we're going to go through everything outside of reporting and where we've been on the road and the projects we've been working on. And then we're going to finish up with a looking forward. Just to start it off, I just want to touch base on our paid media recap. This ends at the end of this month. And so we're going to be executing research today on that for the ad awareness and the ROI.
31:11 At the beginning of April, if not, I'll be doing the campaign recap and then the research in the following month with that event presentation. Okay, so continuing on to our website highlights, I'll have Megan take over. Hey, everyone. So we've had a couple of really exciting things happening with our website traffic. In January, we saw major, major traffic to the site. Our total visits were up 83% month over month and 80% year over year.
31:43 So people are coming to the site, people are excited about our content. A lot of this has to do with our really big numbers on social media, which you'll see later in the presentation, and the social media numbers are really driven by snow content. People are excited about the weather we've been having, they're coming to social media, they're getting all the amazing pictures, and then that's driving them back to the website. The nice thing is, too, we're also looking at a major increase in unique visitors. So it's not just people coming to the site and they're daydreaming at their desk and...
32:10 The same people over and over. These are new people, people that are getting excited and potentially new people booking vacations. We also had some of our huge winter campaigns, so you're looking at some of our paid promotional items that are then driving traffic to our site. That's up 522% over last year. Looking at February, some of our winter campaigns drop off in February, so we're seeing more of an increase in organic traffic. You'll see on our next slide that organic traffic is
32:38 It's more quality traffic. It's people who are searching for Mammoth Lakes and they know about us and they want to know more about us. And then we're also getting some really good referral traffic. This is stuff like PR posts, stuff from LA Times and also from Visit California. Looking at some of our goals for the website, typically we like to break them down into quality and quantity type of goals. Our quantity goals are the visits and the page views. That's how many people are coming to the site. And then quality for our traffic is bounce rate and time on site.
33:09 So bounce rate, somebody who's coming to the site and then just leaving quickly, and the time on site is how long they're staying there. So we want to take our bounce rate down and increase our time on site. So you can look at our combined numbers for February and January. The total visits and page views are raw numbers, so you could divide them and that is what you're looking at on a monthly basis. Bounce rate, a little higher than we were looking at, but it's definitely been going down. So with the increase that you saw in February with organic traffic,
33:39 Means that we're seeing a decrease in bounce rate. So February alone was a 51% bounce rate. This is an average from January and February. So you can see with more organic traffic, people are there and they're really engaged with our content. Same with time on site. This is an average for the two months, but February was at two minutes and one second. So you can really see the quality traffic. Then we can take a look at some of our top performing pages. These are the pages that are getting the most hits on our site. It's like I canceled. Yeah.
34:11 Yeah, the flight page, people, yes, of course, potentially looking at the status of their flight, but also looking on how to access Mammoth Lakes in our email marketing and also in our social media. We're really pushing the message, here, you know, you can flatten Mammoth Lakes, here's how. Sure. Question. So the number one visited page is the Fly MMH.
34:31 Yes, and that fluctuates from month to month. Some people see a lot of times the winter page might bump up one or two, sometimes the home page. A lot of it just depends on where we're linking. And usually to get those quality type of numbers with the bounce rate and the time on site, you want to be linking someone to something specific instead of just saying, hey, here's Visit Mammoth.
34:51 Here's our homepage. You want to link to something specific. Do you have any idea how much of those direct to that page is coming from paid electronic advertising versus free social media? We can definitely pull those numbers. Something I'd have to come back to you with. I can circle back with you via email. Okay. I'd be curious. Yeah, and we did have a strong push behind San Francisco this year. We really went after it this year, and then as Eric and I deal with on a monthly basis.
35:18 The more it snows, the last minute people start looking for flights because they know that it's going to be a good weekend, sir, good time to come up. So that's really why the generation of the traffic is. I get it. And again, you know, San Francisco Chronicle is my home page and every single page has got fly Mammoth. Don't click on it. I know, right? I'm coasting us. I'm sorry. But that's why I'm just asking. I'd be curious to know. And, you know, it may not be that important. Maybe it's, you know, that's a good thing that we've got so much coming from paid.
35:47 Advertising, but thank you. Yeah, I think it's too good. I mean, of course, you want people to be coming to that with our social media and our own channels, but I think it just does go to show that our paid campaigns are working as well. Our paid campaigns are driving that winter activities and no small adventure. The no small adventure is the campaign thing on number four. But as you can see, some of the other seasonal pages, like winter driving tips, and even in my mind, like, of course, this game is so great, but also lodging. A lot of times, that's people who are looking for stuff, like, right now. Of course, lodging pages will show up on their seasons, but.
36:17 Those are definitely seasonal items. Okay. One more question for you. These most visited pages, you know, like I'm looking down there at events, winter driving tips, I assume that that's just moving around within the website itself between the pages? I mean, no one's coming directly to events or winter driving tips, are they? Sure, it depends.
36:39 So, for example, with events, a lot of our social media and our email marketing does drive directly to the events page. So, for example, in May, when we come to present what we're doing on a marketing basis, that'll be something we can look at specific numbers and see where, you know, social media is pushing to that page, where email marketing is pushing to that page, and how we might be able to increase that for some of the local events in town. Okay, thank you. Looking at email marketing, this is, again, a combined numbers. So, this is email sent.
37:09 I think the total was five emails. And, you know, we kind of go back and forth. Usually we try to send out a monthly email that kind of goes through everything that's going on, and we also supplement with promotional emails. So promotional emails can be anything from we have a flight sale from LAX on Alaska. That was one of our promotional emails. So that was my promotional email in February about the trade shows that Mammoth Lakes was attending. So kind of get a mix. And the next thing about the promotional emails is a lot of times you do see a higher open rate and a higher click rate because it's one specific topic that people
37:39 can get really excited about, and it goes back to the quality thing. When they read the subject line, they know exactly what they're getting, and so they're more engaged with the content. So, just to go back on portion, so we sent out five emails, so we only have a database currently of 10,000? What's our current total list of emails?
38:00 I think our total is 30,000, and then it's segmented, so right now we're not talking to people who are on our fishing list, for example, we have a specific list for fishing, we have a specific list for fall colors.
38:11 And a lot of the promotional emails are targeted, so we don't send a promotion about an LA flight sale to everybody. We send it, we geo-target it based on zip code, so that's only going to people within 100 miles of LA or 200 mile radius, something like that. Sorry to take it out of topic, but just our email database has not grown very much in the last three years. Social media has grown tremendously, website traffic way up there. Are we focused on that, or do we not see that as a priority at this time?
38:37 Our biggest way to grow the email marketing base is usually through these trade show events. When we're talking to someone in person, usually there's a prize involved and they're signing up. Because I think if you have an email base that's growing really rapidly and it's really low-ending fruit for someone to just sign up at random, a lot of times you're not seeing the engagement that you're looking for. So our email group might not be growing as fast as social media, but we are seeing a nice engagement.
39:01 People who are getting our emails are excited about them, they're opening them, and I get personal responses from people from emails. So I think I am happy with our engagement on that front. And we could certainly be doing more in the future to up that, but I think it's kind of a catch-22 because if you have a huge email list, you're not seeing the engagement typically. Yeah, we're talking quality versus quantity on this, and we are segmenting down to talk to fishermen specifically or talk to... Yeah, it just happens because I'm doing the same thing.
39:28 For property, but just the CRM and what you collect and profile of people and where you go to, I absolutely agree, but our list of 30,000 is a, for what we do for traffic is a pretty small list, particularly just even fishing traffic and the Fred Hall show and all these type of things, I would expect.
39:44 That we could potentially grow with us as we move down. My guess would be that there are a lot less people opting in for emails because they're getting 4,000 emails a day and that they're opting more for social. They're raising their hand more for the social than they are for the email. One of the things I really like to think about is how many big brands do I sign up for the email list? Maybe a lot, but then I definitely spend every couple of months I'm going through and unsubscribing from a lot of lists.
40:11 Because I get a lot of stuff, but there are a lot more brands that I'm willing to like on Facebook or to follow on Twitter in comparison to the number of brands that I actually stay subscribed to their email list. No, because I get the email dump alert and I always wonder why the Mountain Under reports are snow, so I'm always going to have to send an email to other people.
40:28 I'll leave it there. Come on. That's a whole other topic. Let's not get into that. That's right. That's me to segue. You've answered my question. I'm good. And just to give you an idea, the typical open rate for the travel industry is around 19%. So you can see that our average open rate is well above that. And likewise, for click rate, you're usually looking at like 1.3%. And we're also above that. So I do feel really good about the engagement with our audience.
40:58 Just to give you an idea of some of the topics we've talked about, and I covered this a little bit earlier, but looking at National Plan for Vacation Day, we talked about booking a trip to Mammoth Lake. Why now is the time to be planning your vacation? And just to give a little bit more detail behind that, that's a big U.S. travel push. They basically said that January 31st across the country, we were all, all of the DMOs, all of the states, everybody was going to push that this was the day to actually sit down and figure out your next vacation versus just waiting for it to happen.
41:26 And then talking about flights as well, we talk about how to fly Mammoth Lakes. That's included in every monthly email. There's a section talking about the different flight options. We focus on in-week deals, and we also have links to all of the individual events that are coming up on our calendar. So in our January email, we're talking about all the February and March events. In our February email, we're talking about the March and April events. Looking at our demographics for email,
41:54 Yeah, it's kind of funny to me because in the travel industry most demographics skew towards female. A lot of females or women in the family are making the travel planning decisions so they're the ones opening these kinds of emails and engaging with this type of content. But our demographic is typically skewed around 60% towards males. And then we're looking for our open rate at 25 to 34 is our age range for our highest open rate. But then when you talk about who's actually clicking on the different links, it's a little bit of an older demographic.
42:24 So Josh and I were looking to really see how we can kind of come to more 50-50 with the women and men breakdown for our demographic because we're seeing a really similar breakdown on social. All right. So for our social media section, we had some really exciting numbers in January. It was our biggest month to date on social media. Of course, we can attribute a lot of that to snow.
42:54 But we also have paid campaigns that are executing on social media, so you can't totally pinpoint it on one thing. You can see that our fan base is up by 5.7%. If you're looking at new Facebook fans, it's skyrocketing. I think Facebook is our most engaged audience. And so if you're looking at percentage of engaged fans, it rose to 47% this month, and usually we're kind of lingering in the 30% range. So it's nice to see people are
43:24 liking our posts, they're sharing our posts, they're clicking our links, and they want more content. Can I ask some questions about that, Paige? Oh, sure. I can figure out how to do that. I might be able to ask them about that. Okay. So we have 262 likes, or when you say fans, is that... That's what we said.
43:50 262. I'm sorry, I can't see, I need new glasses. 40,000? Yeah. So this is all new, so new Facebook fans, we've got over 2,000 new Facebook fans, and that's an increase of 262.8%. Okay. Over the previous month. All right, so I can't see. Wait, one more question, though. When you say, what is an engaged, what's your definition of an engaged fan? So an engaged fan is someone who...
44:19 Yep, liking, commenting, sharing. It kind of depends a little bit, and you'll see as we go through, it depends on the platform. So for example, Instagram, you're not really sharing, but a lot of people are liking. It's kind of a lower hanging fruit to be liking something as you're scrolling through Instagram versus Facebook. So we kind of add all those things together, whatever it means for each platform, and that's where you get our engagement number. And then impressions is the opposite. Impressions is someone who sees it, it's come across their screen, Facebook or Instagram can track that, but they haven't necessarily engaged with that post.
44:50 So looking at our January post, we've got our top performing post, back to talking about snow. And as you can see, our impressions, looking at who saw the post, not necessarily this specific post, this is who saw all of our posts. So then looking at engagements, that's who actually interacted with the post. And again, this is conglomerate for all of January, so all of our posts. What's really notable on that last slide is we had over 26,000 people.
45:20 Clip directly through to our website. That's a new metric for us that we've set up some goals for. And yeah, that's a really good number for us. We're really excited about that. So you start to see that in the reporting moving forward. Just to put it in perspective, we were talking about organic traffic versus campaign traffic. If it's a paid Facebook post, that would count as campaign traffic versus if it's just a Facebook post we haven't put any money behind, that's organic traffic coming to our site.
45:52 So if you're looking at Instagram, and again, the metrics are a little different for each platform, you're looking at over close to 3,000 engagements on each of these posts. These are our top Instagram posts. And then if you're looking at followers, we have close to a 2,000 increase in followers. Instagram has been one of our most successful channels. Of course, you get the engagement on Facebook because everybody's on Facebook, but as far as looking at growing our channels, Instagram has been a huge success in growing.
46:22 Well, and I think it's important to note that our Instagram channel's only been up for maybe two years, right? With Josh? Yeah, two and a half years. Yeah. And he'll talk about all those big wins in that next monthly presentation that we talk, we'll talk more historical and where we've come from and where we're going strategically. So another thing we've been working on, I think we've talked about it in the last couple of meetings, influencer posts on social media.
46:49 And so some of this is part of a paid campaign. In the past we've worked with bloggers or other influencers and we've actually had like a paid contribution to their work. It kind of depends on the way it's set up as to whether we're paying for them to come visit and they're posting on social media or if we're actually paying them for the work. But we've also had some non-paid campaigns. This is a pro skier who reached out to Josh.
47:13 He's excited about the following that we have, would like to connect with our audience, and so he did a takeover for our channel on Instagram, and we really can say that a lot of our engagement and our increase in followers for that month can be attributed to these kind of influencers. You basically get someone else's audience, and they're paying attention to you for an entire weekend or an entire week. On Twitter, and again, like I said, some of the metrics are a little bit different. So Twitter, you've got people who are following you.
47:46 You've got likes and you've got retweets. And that's how you're, and of course links to our site. So looking at links to the site, just under 2,000, but total engagements would also include shares and likes for our tweets. YouTube is something we're really excited about. We, I think this number just blows my mind, the 17,441 minutes watched on our YouTube videos for the month. Top performing video was snowshoeing in Mammoth.
48:18 One thing about YouTube is we started to integrate our videos into the site directly. So people who are watching these videos don't even have to necessarily click to our YouTube channel. They're watching them either directly in a blog post or even directly in an email marketing campaign. And so that's why we really kind of upped our engagement with YouTube. 9,000 views. Is that for just that snow showing in Mammoth? No, that's totally right. Okay. How many videos were in the month of January?
48:47 A lot of our content is evergreen. So you're seeing content that we spend a lot of time creating a lot of videos at once since we have a videographer that we hire out. And then those videos are just reposted and we talk about the same subject. So snowshoeing wasn't necessarily something that we just posted. It's a video that we're promoting a lot because it's something that's happening a lot right now. Thank you. It's our whole library. And then Bark Shop is our image database that we have available to all of the businesses in town.
49:17 And so it's something that we've been working on for about three years, right, Whitney? Yeah, since 2014. Since 2014. Something that we're really trying to, this goes back to the local PR, making sure that businesses know that this is a resource that they have available to them. So right now we've got 88 active users, it's January, and so the users can basically get a login, they can download images, and they can use them in their own marketing collateral.
49:42 And those are local businesses that are users? Yes. So, for example, we're talking about having, you know, monthly coffee, that sort of thing. That's the type of thing where we want to make sure when we're face-to-face with local business owners that they're hearing about this and that they know that they can create a login and use these resources for free. As you go down the road in terms of, like, we go there and look a lot, but it doesn't quite meet where we're going, would it be beneficial at times if we just said, let's say, hey, here's where we're going?
50:10 We're trying to get a little bit more lifestyle. There's lots of nature, lots of snow, lots of snow, lots of snow, lots of snow. So we're trying to show a little more people, like families and those type of things at certain times. Yeah, absolutely. I would say the best thing to do is always to reach out to Josh and see if there's anything specific because it does take a while to get the images uploaded to Barberstock. You have to go through and do a lot of, there's a lot of metadata that has to get entered.
50:32 And so sometimes photos that were taken from a huge snowstorm aren't necessarily up there the day after a huge snowstorm, but of course there's still something that are accessible. There's a lot of great photos, it's just sometimes you're trying to differentiate yourself a little bit and those type of things. Yeah, and I think the nice thing is it's of course lots of stuff is seasonal, so sometimes you don't want to be using...
50:51 This year's snow photos, if they're not really applicable for the level of snow we have next year, but the database continues to grow and nothing really disappears off of there, so you can continue to see more and more on Barberstock as the program continues to grow. Alright, so looking into February, well you'll see similar types of metrics throughout the entire presentation and just kind of able to compare. So still seeing an increase in total fans, which is nice, you never want to see a drop off in something like that, so I think that
51:22 You know, January, you've got the people coming in for snow content, and they're there. They're still staying. They're still listening to us on social media. Interesting that Instagram is increasing so much faster than Facebook. Yeah, it's new. Sorry? The Instagram takeovers. Yeah. We have another one for this month. Yeah, like we said, lots of factors that can go into it, but yes, Instagram is one of the most successful channels that we're seeing as far as growth rate.
51:48 And that's probably not just a trend here. That's a trend in general, I think. It is. It's worth my business. So looking at our top-performing post, this is actually a shared article. LA Times wrote an article about Mammoth Lakes. Our channel shared the post, and that was our top-performing post. So it kind of goes back to that high-level referral type of traffic. Ties in the PR aspect of things. It just goes to show that we're getting the word out on lots of different ways, and it's showing. Instagram, still on the snow.
52:23 And you can see that our engagement, we've reached over 3,000 in some of these posts, which that's likes, comments, that sort of thing. That's huge for us. And it's really honestly huge when you're looking at comparable Instagram accounts in our industry, not only DMOs, but also other influencers. That type of engagement is just really top notch. And I think the photo in the middle there is a perfect example of the influencer program. You know, that was done when Tyler Wallace was here and he owned the channel.
52:51 And that photo just got picked up all over the place. Yeah, so influencer and then another thing that Josh has really gotten into is user-generated content. So lots of people who are in town experiencing the amazing snow we have are tagging Visit Mammoth in their posts. And so he'll reach out to them and ask them if it's something that they would mind us reposting. So we're getting photos from kind of all over town, obviously with one person taking, you know, running the Instagram account and can't be everywhere and take photos of everything. So our user-generated content has been really something exciting to see grow as well.
53:22 Another Instagram takeover, we had Myles Weaver, he works up at the Mountain, and he did an Instagram takeover for our channel. Again, that's when you're reaching out to somebody else's audience and you have all eyes on you, it's a good way to really grow your following, and I think that's really responsible for our growth the last couple of months. And then looking at Twitter, again, engagements are different for each channel, so looking at likes, retweets, and profile clicks. And YouTube, this month we had the one that got away, so that's our video on Tim Alpers.
53:56 It's really exciting because we haven't had any financial push behind this video. It's just all been on our own channels and it's gotten really wonderful engagement so far. So we're excited to have that story really resonate with our audience. If you guys haven't seen the video, definitely check it out. It's a tearjerker. And then again, looking at Barberstock, increasing our active users. So really just working on getting the word out and making sure that everyone in town knows about this resource. Thank you. Yeah, you're welcome. Okay, so where have we been this week?
54:35 I'm going to start out with where we've been on the road, and then we're going to dive into our asset production that we're doing this month. Again, you know, we attend these shows every year, the Travel and Adventure Show, we're in the Bay Area in LA, that's when we do our Yosemite sponsorship. San Diego, we actually appear as part of the Eastern Sierra, Eastern Sierra Row in that location.
54:59 We gave away an eight-day, seven-night trip courtesy of Mammoth Reservations. A big thank you for them for pushing the envelope on that. It was really a great opportunity to show Mammoth Lakes as a destination. You know, we normally go out and try to get that four- to five-day giveaway, but the fact that they extended it to seven nights really resonated with the consumer. Like, oh, wow, you can spend a lot of time in Mammoth Lakes. Yes, you can. Come on over. Back to growing our email marketing, usually that giveaway is how we do.
55:28 Collect emails, that sort of thing. So you're getting face-to-face with that person while they're signing up for email. So I think how we set this show up, and I'll just have to send you guys these videos, is that we've gone through the Google Drive and we didn't have request access because we're on like a foreign server here. But I have a great media clip.
55:48 courtesy of Megan Miranda's mother who took an iPhone on the television because we haven't been able to get the clips from the organizer yet, but I'll be sure to send that out with you. And you can see Megan and Eli, the camel that traveled all the way from Wisconsin. Did you have been for camels? I was going to say. Didn't spit on you. No, didn't spit on her. Well trained.
56:13 Wanted to spit at me, but didn't want to spit at me. Front Hall Outdoor Experience, we go to the show every year, and we are a show sponsor. This is a Long Beach in San Diego location. We include it in that. We also have a seminar area, floor decals. We have our big fish prominently displayed next to the seminar area, the ketty corner from our booth. And then we, too, also represent our representatives, the US 395 corridor at that show. So it's a great...
56:42 Representation of the region. Josh Ray was our media contact for this show. He's on a live broadcast with a studio audience in the Hyatt Hotel in Let's Talk Hookup. That'll be played in San Diego. Again, we had the same giveaway, the eight-day, seven-night trip. And a great video of what that sponsor of State looks like. When is that event? What's that? Last weekend. It was last weekend. Last weekend was Long Beach. Del Mar is coming up at the end of the month. Yeah, so we have one more and then we'll be able to.
57:12 Betray chose bed for the year. Part of our travels this year, we had two industry meetings. Most notably was the Cal Travel Rally Day, and you guys would have been really proud of Josh and Megan. We were double booked for representatives, Tom Berryhill and Frank Bigelow. So I went to the Tom Berryhill meeting, and Jason, or Jason, and Josh and Megan led that Frank Bigelow.
57:37 meeting with our representative, incredibly impressed, and you can see Howard in the middle here who came up to me and said, where did you get these two? And we'll take them. Like, no you're not, anytime soon. At this meeting, this is where we really talk to our representative about the importance of tourism and looking at legislative initiatives from that tourism filter. I think you all remember a couple years ago when we were talking about cutting state funding for parks.
58:07 specifically to Mona Lake and Bodie. Well, that would have really damaged us economically because that is our tourism asset. So to look past what the expenditure is and what they're getting back at tax revenue. And so it just kind of opens up that conversation to get them looking through this filter. Frank Bigelow here is a ranch, ranching man. I don't know if you can tell by the cow skin rug and his cowboy hat, but I just wanted to pull that out that, you know, we're the first ranked.
58:33 industry in this county, which is 10 times larger than number two, which is agriculture. Also talked about how tourism dollars contribute 72% of our general fund. Tourism Business Improvement Districts was another topic of conversation, just so he could understand exactly what that meant and the financial impact that's been so critical in growing our town budget. And then filming in California, I'm not sure if...
59:01 This room knows we have up to 70 productions in Mono County annually, which results in a $1.5 million in direct spending. So just really supporting filming in California. A lot of people are leaving and going to Georgia, Canada, other places because they have tax credits. So supporting those efforts to keep those people here.
59:20 Both representatives are interested in having an open house here in Mammoth Lakes and meeting their local constituency, so our office will be working with them and we'll keep everybody posted on that. Our second industry meeting was the California Welcome Center annual meeting and it was my passenger torch to somebody else as my role in chair. I've been in that position for four years and
59:47 You know, it's just really a good lesson on keep working the problem because there were three years where, you know, we really wanted to take this organization into a specific or particular direction. Everything happened in this one year, which is quite a bit. We put together a three-year strategic plan as a group for buy-in. We created the mission statement and defined our success.
1:00:11 And all of that is now in this document that you can see on the left-hand side there. This was passed out to the Board of Directors for Visit California. We were able to institute a group retail buying program among the 17 centers so they can get discounted rates because they're buying as a group now, which means extra revenue for tourism and visitor tools.
1:00:33 I'm responsible for the value proposition document for these California Welcome Centers, and I'll be working with Dan Michelle, who is the Director of Insights and Statistics at Profit VCA, and we're going to be working on an intercept survey where we're actually breaking down the economic value of what it means when someone visits that Welcome Center, how much more they spend in the area, because we're not leaving any money on the table, because they've...
1:01:00 Have that connection and they're aware of additional resources. And then as well as redefining the leadership roles for the chairs for this group. Moving on to owned assets. These are the things that we developed this month. The first and far most you guys are really excited about. Virtual Reality. It's our 360 degree video. This will be our new engagement piece. That video is really cool. You guys will see that in an email.
1:01:28 This filming for our winter portion of our video took place last week. If you can believe it, Mother Nature was nice enough to provide us five full days of clear blue sky and no wind. A couple of things that are definitely notable about this is this is really a historical project in the making. I just want to put that out there. It really...
1:01:50 aligns with our reputation in the industry to push the envelope. And this is the first time that you've seen a custom rig heavy lift drone at this altitude with this kind of camera rigging and the 360 degree capability. The five camera rig is known as the dark corner. And to our knowledge, nothing's been flown at this altitude like I mentioned. Something of this magnitude can be flown at speeds of 50 miles per hour at
1:02:19 C-level, but at this level, we could max it out at 27, and then the batteries would go like that. We hired one of the best, we found one of the best drone operators in the world, his name is Davis DeLillo, and he said this was by far the most challenging project he's done to date. He actually created this drone with a 3D printer.
1:02:42 He developed it and built it himself because the pieces aren't available yet. Secondly, we're including world-class sound design, so we'll have immersive sound that was recorded by leading industry leader John Hennicott, who will actually be talking about this technology as a guest speaker at SXSW, which is something technological conference. South by Southwest. What is it? South by Southwest.
1:03:08 Oh, that's what that is? Thank you, I'm glad you're here. I thought for sure it was a tech thing. All right, so cool film techniques, to our knowledge, will be the first ones who will be adding animations to a 360 virtual reality video. So that's really exciting. We'll be taking our campaign elements and adding them in there. We also have a 360 time-lapse of night shots, which...
1:03:33 have been rarely done. And then we also shot some key scenes at 120 frames per second, allowing us to transition the viewer into slow motion for illustrated scenics and big air jumps. So it's really exciting and just some latest industry news. Google is now confirming that the staff of 360 ads are actually now outperforming standard banners. So we are...
1:03:58 We're going to be right in time to be able to pull this in. One is our video, but two to be able to break these out for ads. This is great. I do have a couple of questions on this. This is great. This sounds like it's very cutting edge. I'm looking forward to seeing the video. It sounds like you're going to need to email it to us. Yes. Okay. Well, it was just a picture of the droid. Oh, okay. It's not the droid excuse. When is the, so has the video already been created or is it done yet? It's been shot. We were filmed last week. It's all wrong. Okay. Last Monday through Friday. How often, what's your plan, how often to do this?
1:04:27 Not very often. Yeah, I was going to add, that was going to be my next question is, so I assume this is coming out of our budget as far as paying for it. I mean, it's great. It sounds like it's very cutting edge. I'm just... Well, it's also where the ad survey purpose is going. So, I mean, it's just, you know, we are in a destination that has a lot of different difficulties, right? And so people have been implementing this technology at sea level. It's just a mountain destination.
1:04:53 And we're trying, you know, we have to be competitive in the marketplace when Google is saying that virtual reality 360 ads are outperforming your standard banners. That's just where the entire world is moving to now. I believe it. You know, but it is, we always film everything to get maximum use out of it. You know, we have our branding campaign that went into place almost three years ago, four years ago, and it remains relevant, and we're going to hold on to it because it takes a lot to get into that development.
1:05:21 And we'll be able to splice this video. It'll be, I can't quite recall, I mean, it's under two minutes, but we'll be able to splice that down and take chunks from it to keep it relative to the season or to that specific campaign. Okay. Do you have a strategy or a plan for how often you're going to be doing these, or is it too soon to say? Are you going to check out the first one and then make that decision? I mean, what's the context that you're asking? Well, I guess I'm just asking, are you planning multiple videos, or is it just the one?
1:05:52 It's the one video, and it will show a winter to summer transition. So this is one half, and we'll utilize the winter portions of it, but then we'll have a summer. And the whole thing will take that viewer through what that year-round, again, reinforcing that year-round destination experience. And it's quite the storyboard behind it. It's not like we're just going outside and taking a picture of what you see here. It's going to be an entire storyboard.
1:06:18 messaging, and you're going to be listening to people, and the talent will be calling you in, like, come with us, and it will provide adrenaline transitions, you know, where it's like a little video game, really. Grace, this is a major undertaking, and I think to what Megan was talking about before, we talk about evergreen content, this is something that will live for quite a while. Is that what you mean by historical? Like this altitude, and operating at this altitude. You know, the,
1:06:48 The technology is, you know, this is all just starting the last few years, you know, and so it is all quite new in general, and the fact that they were filming at these altitudes, his network wasn't that helpful, because they were like, we've 95 million, that's all we've got. I don't know what else to tell you for 3,000 more feet, so. What's our release date, or what's your schedule?
1:07:11 So it takes three months to process something like this, and so we'll be pushing that for the winter, and then we'll have the summer and the winter portion ready to go for our experiential purposes, our trade shows in January. Okay. So you're looking at this for next year? Well, we're looking at it for, yeah, we're looking at it for the fall of next year, but really. Fall of 2017. Correct. But then the trade shows of 2018, which we just finished, so January through March.
1:07:39 And having it be, and I don't know if you want to describe what that is potentially looking like at trade shows, where it's not just the one person typing a VR. Right, and you know, right now the standard is that someone is either standing at a trade show and they have the goggles on and that's it. This will be a pavilion-sized experiential area, like a 20 by 20 with a big screen where you can see what is occurring, so it's engaging for the crowd around them.
1:08:08 In addition to the goggles and audio so they can hear it as well. So it's a fully immersive experience. So instead of one person enjoying it at a time, you can do 200 people. Yeah. So this is sort of like the Disneyland thing way back when. One person at a time. Circle theater and you stood in the middle and you got the feeling that you were flying in a high altitude. It sounds like that. Yeah, it is similar.
1:08:38 I think I remember this before. Disney Land. Remember the Disney Land? California Adventure? Yeah. Yeah, it kind of reminds me of like the California Adventure or the new minion rides where you just stay there and you're like, whoa, we're going downhill. Anyway, small update on the digital asset management. I've been having some ongoing conversations with our town lawyer to make sure that...
1:09:02 We have some contracts in place that are highlighting or that are inclusive of the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so I just wanted to describe exactly how our photo-video library is laid out. We have a three-tier system that Josh Ray is the asset manager for. In tier one, which we've already discussed, that's a shareable library, launched in 2014. And those pictures are taken by our in-house photographer. And those are definitely open for town of Mammoth Lakes use.
1:09:30 our use for the community use and promotion and amplifying the Mammoth Lakes destination brand. By the time we get this next batch up there, we're having a little bit of hiccup on the administration side. We'll have approximately 3,000 photos and then this will continuously be updated on a quarterly basis. This will be the poll that will be from our library that we're putting in there for our social capture.
1:09:57 Tier 2 contracts, these are contracted photos where we've hired out photographers, and these are done in batches, so we're receiving these and we're getting, you know, we have a total of 365 of these. This is the contract that I'm working on with Andy to make sure that our contracts aligned and do include the town of Mammoth Lakes. However, in our original creation documents, it says that it would be in perpetuity and they could resell these images.
1:10:25 That's the language that we need to come to a compromise on because that would be a financial obstacle. That would be cost prohibitive. We want to be able to extend those rights. And so those are, that's a meeting I still have to have with him about discussing that and putting an addendum to those creation documents possibly. Not quite sure how that looks. But he's open to that. He understands the financial obligation of it.
1:10:48 And then tier one is our campaign photos, which are just single photos and are by far the most cost prohibitive because we are acquiring one photo for this one campaign. And so we'll have a discussion about that as well. We have our new digital guide online for our visitor guide. It is now mobile friendly. As you can see in the middle there, you can also search in multiple languages. We have a new platform for it.
1:11:17 Exciting stuff for Whitney Lemon, the visitor guide girl. We can also see content and advertiser preview easily just by the click of a button. You can see content highlights on the left. Those have to do with like our blogs and additional storylines that we have and then the advertisers are on the right. And then we also have online sharing of the individual pages and the opportunity to include notes as well. So you can see on the right-hand side you can either share these.
1:11:45 in your social channels or via email and you can pick specific pages that you want included in that. Looking forward, and I'll hurry, industry website, Laura already touched on this, we are in the middle of a site refresh, we're going to be pulling a brand elements for the visit mammoth.com website for a more seamless viewing. We're talking about changing, we're changing the conversation. Right now, this is a website where you can come and get information.
1:12:16 Past reports, what we're doing on our campaigns, we're going to change that now to answer the question of what are you doing for me as a business community member where we're really highlighting those tools up front, our free tools, like our free content to use on your social web and newsletters, including the photo assets and so on. VisitMammoth.com, we just launched our first, we're launching on Monday our usability study to make sure we're
1:12:46 Doing it right. Where that is, we have a group of 12 people who will come in and we'll give them tasks to do and we can see if there's any blind spots we may have with the website so we can improve on those. The second wave will actually be a Mammoth Lakes current visitor because now this is our end destination resource to tell people like where to go eat or how to get an activity and so there'll be a second wave to that. We have already started
1:13:14 Our fact checking, we do this on an annual basis. This is getting to be a pretty big project now that we have such a large website. But that kicks off, and so be expecting those people to contact you for your details for your businesses. A couple of other additions that we've added to this website, probably since we've last spoken about it, is the Google Translation. You can see those flags at the top of the website.
1:13:39 We do still have primarily people coming from other outside of the country who are actually searching in English, but it is being utilized. We have a high altitude website integration. We have a first review of that at the end of this month, so it's really exciting to pull that online. We also have a pilot program that I'm just telling you guys all about right now. As you can see in this lower right-hand corner, it has a flight sign that comes up.
1:14:07 There's a couple different things with this pilot program. This has been offered to us for free. It will run for 60 days. But it's a new research tool that will track the interest in flights, where people are coming from, and then they can actually book through this. It's a little glitchy. We're trying to work on it for when you're searching for this area. As you can see, Reno. It picks up Reno when you're in Mammoth Lakes at quite a high cost. But besides that, we've already had a couple people book through it.
1:14:37 I'll let you guys know the details. We'll be getting like a 30-day update in the next week. And then lastly on that is we do have our planning session to talk about strategy for the next annual 2017-2018 with Miles and Marian Carson at the end of this month, which will also affect how we're utilizing this site.
1:15:00 Another addition or the next way for completion in this website is the wedding section. Again, we have the fact checkers who are going through to pull more data, have a larger database of information on here. I'll be meeting with wedding partners in town to identify the priorities for a wedding segment to create a one to three year strategic plan. And then lastly,
1:15:27 We just went over 10 minutes. Lastly, in our April presentation, we will be going back to the Winter Campaign Report, which is quite extensive. But we're also going to be doing an in-depth view of strategies and key performance indicators of our own channels. And that really will be specific to our social channels and to our newsletters. We've integrated a new software program that really takes a deeper dive into the research and the reporting data that we're really excited about.
1:15:55 I just want to make sure it's on everyone's top of mind how critical that those pieces are for us. I've got a couple and they may be more social media oriented. Great, glad we're promoting winter as much as we should and obviously now's the time to be doing it. I'm curious, we talked previously about kind of interspersing summer activities in the winter and winter activities in the summer. Yeah, we have a year-round campaign.
1:16:24 Okay, just want to make sure. We do have specific winters. We always lead heavier with whatever season we're in, but we're always talking year-round because the planning is the planning process and or what they call the dream. There's some like really cute word to it. People are always looking for their next trip. It's like a dream plan go type of concept.
1:16:45 And it's year-round. Just curious if there's a time when you really start switching over more towards summer, spring, summer activities, you know, is it before Easter, after Easter? Paid is mid-April. What's that? Paid is mid-April. Everything else lives, again, evergreen. Summer, winter, always. But I guess with regard to social media, do you start interjecting? Yeah, start to transition. And just to give you an idea, so when Josh and I sit down, I work on the...
1:17:12 social media content that is related to our website. So we've got a certain percentage of content that links to blog posts, a certain percentage that links to events, a certain percentage that links to home pages of certain sections on the site. And so that's all planned out ahead of time, and Josh goes ahead and schedules it every month. But then the other half of our content is stuff that's happening right now in Mammoth Lake. So you'll see about 50% of the content being a here's what snow is happening, here's
1:17:40 Something new and exciting that's going on. And then the other 50% is scheduled out. And the scheduled stuff is usually when you see us looking further ahead. So we're looking at events that are coming up down the line in the summertime, that sort of thing. And we'll break down those strategies in the April meeting. Okay. One last question. And again, with regard to social media, is there a hashtag that is used more often than others?
1:18:03 No Small Adventure. Okay. And the reason why I bring that up is just, you know, I use Mammoth Stories, and I don't know, is that a mountain? That is the mountain, yep. Okay. Is there any reason why we can't use Mammoth Stories as well as no, and I know it confuses the message, but I kind of feel like we're competing with the mountain when it comes to those kind of hashtags. And looking at those hashtags, by the way, No Small Adventure has just under 8,000 public posts. Mammoth Stories has 108,000.
1:18:32 So over 100,000 more public posts with regard to the Mammoth Stories. And I'll just tell you that at least on Mammoth Brewing Company, we use Mammoth Stories pretty regularly because when you click on that hashtag and go there, I'm amazed at the amount of people, you know, whether they're on the mountain or whether they're in the summer, they're
1:18:51 Backpacking, that kind of thing, that are really using, you know, they love to tell their story. So I just, I do see that success, and I don't necessarily want us to be competing with another entity, and I don't call it competing, it's obviously very cooperative. Complimentary, I should say. It's a different strategy and a different brand, so it's not really a best practice to use other people's hashtags and promote them along with your primary. So I think the answer would end up being twofold. If you're looking at the option of, let's say,
1:19:21 You know, let's say we decide that Mammoth Stories is more successful. That's something that we have to work with the mountain to make sure that we're not stepping on anyone's toes. You can't just come and do your hashtag. You know, and then the other side of things is just it's all about the local PR, right? So your business using Mammoth Stories, maybe it's something that we decide that we want to continue with No Small Adventure. That's something we need to use in our local PR information to make sure that local businesses know that that's a hashtag that you can use year-round for all of the
1:19:50 MLT type of stuff. So, in my mind, it's a conversation, a bigger conversation, and I could go either way on it. Is that something to talk about? I would add, too, that we've been using that campaign for over three years now. So, we've had it out there for quite some time. I don't know how long No Small Adventures has been. It has been, but it hasn't been. Two years, maybe? The Mammoth Stories has been a marketing campaign itself. Yeah, exactly. Those are all the tags that we typically have in every Instagram post.
1:20:20 Great. Okay. Thank you guys very much. Appreciate that. Thank you. All right. Let's move on to department updates. Yeah, moving on. Yeah, we'll move fairly quickly through here. Michael, last weekend, went to Scandinavia to meet with our agency that we hired over there and to do some of the media trips and to meet some of the...
1:20:39 Wholesalers, and then he moved on to ITB in Berlin, in Berlin, Germany, which is one of the largest trade shows in the world behind Pow Wow, which Kirk has participated in a number of years. And so that's a massive event. He'll be back in town on Monday.
1:20:56 On March 29th at the Sierra Center Mall, we have the China Ready event in conjunction with Visit California. The goal is to host potentially up to 200 local business owners. And really what it is is with the influx of Chinese coming to California, California is the number one destination for the China market. 25% of all Chinese coming to the United States are coming to China. It's one of our fastest growing markets. And this seminar that's going on with Visit California, it's a couple hours. What are the times, Jessica?
1:21:26 9.30 to 12.30, and it's really an opportunity to learn what the opportunities are with the Chinese market. We have hired agency in China, and we met with them last week down at the Visit California Outlook Forum, and feel that we're on a good path with, it's the same agency that we hired in China and South Korea, so feel we're on a good path with that. I spent the weekend in Italy.
1:21:51 Very short trip. I was invited over to speak at the University of Trento in Northern Italy. They had a Green Week conference, and part of the Green Week conference was a day on the bike economy. And it was really interesting because they had everything from operations to marketing and economic impact. And it was...
1:22:12 It was a really cool event. It was very, very well attended, and it was interesting to see that they're building a 678-kilometer bike trail from Torino to Venice, and they're anticipating it's going to be $130 million, which is nothing. So a 450-mile trail across the country. A lot of those sections are in place. It was just really interesting to see what they were doing. I had a chance to, in the two days that I was there, go up to a ski resort called Paganella.
1:22:38 Dolomiti Paganella, and look at what they're doing from a mountain bike standpoint, but also from just a ski area and a village standpoint as well. The executive director for the DMO there was also speaking at the bike economy event, so that was very interesting.
1:22:55 I think they were interested in what the town and the mountain have done in the world of biking. The town has spent upwards of $20 million on paved paths. The mountain has spent upwards of $30 million in the past three decades. So really, we are leaps and bounds ahead of a lot of these places. They started really focusing on biking in 2012.
1:23:16 You know, Bill Cockroft started focusing on it here in 1985. So just really interesting to see how that all works. To speak to the website translation, it was great. On Friday before the seminar, I had a meeting with, so Trento is the region, it's like Mono County, and there are 15 DMOs that represent different destinations within Trentino. And it was great because I could bring up our website, I could go to our biking page and click on the Italian translation and show them exactly what we had.
1:23:46 What was somewhat funnier was that when we were doing the presentation, the DMO from Paganella, his video was in English. They figured they have people coming from all over Europe. English is the most standardized language that they could possibly put it in. We also, I didn't have a copy of it, but I saw a copy before we went over talking to our Italian agency, Masters.
1:24:08 Down at the Visit California meeting, we had a nine-page article in Bicicletta magazine, which is the biggest bicycling magazine in Italy, and it was a combination of Mammoth Lakes and the Bay Area. And so, still don't have a copy of it, but it was great to be able to bring that up and let those folks go take a look for it. So, that's the international side. Moving on to chamber update, just quickly, I want to just let you know, we've narrowed our search down to three candidates for the chamber director position. We're bringing those folks in.
1:24:37 in the next couple of weeks to meet with them, meet with some of our local business owners. We'd like to try and get some folks to meet all three candidates. So if you're able to meet one, I'd like to have you meet all three so that we're not judging based on just knowing one. We've got one from Florida who is very strong on the membership side. She's very dialed into.
1:24:59 growing membership and wants to take the next step into an executive director level. We've got one gentleman who has been in the chamber world for quite some time, has a lot of great experience, has been a consultant to chambers, has a lot of great accreditations and comes with quite a pedigree. And then we've got a gentleman who has been in the chamber world for just a few years. He was running the Los Gatos Chamber of Commerce. Prior to that, he had started the California Brain Tumor Society.
1:25:27 And he built that himself and raised millions and millions of dollars towards brain cancer research. So very much a self-starter, a lot younger, just very professional, very polished individual that could definitely bring some good business practice in. And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Brent just for some of the changes we're looking at with the chamber. Yeah, so as part of our conversation in the last chamber of the board meeting was, how do we engage the business community and how do we be better business opportunistic individuals?
1:25:57 So, we're looking at our staffing and saying, depending on where it goes with the executive director coming in, we would like to expand the staff out a little bit so that we actually bring on somebody that can be business point central. We really feel that it's something that's been discussed about in many different areas within the community but has not had a champion that can take that on and push that forward. Business what? Business central. So, for instance, one of the things that we want to tackle is somebody comes in and is trying to do a business within the community.
1:26:25 How can we help them get something done? How can we help them to improve the process, work within the community and with the town with Sandra and some of the other planning commission of town PDEC so that we can say, what's that process? How can we, rather than just, because the process has been for many businesses, you want to do something, oh, I'd like to do this. No, come back with a new solution. We'd like to open it up to dialogue so that, how do we have somebody come in and say they know the ground rules of what's going on? How do we go out there and say to somebody, maybe this is the right opportunity for
1:26:55 Small entrepreneurial type business in a local mall that wants to do small day business and high-end electronics communications so you can operate your office from outside the area. These things always seem to take time within this community. How can we have some of the champions working with the town, working with the businesses and getting those things to actually happen? So basically we're looking to add another position to the chamber.
1:27:21 That's a little bit too to be defined, but because this board here funds the staffing, the chambers make an official request saying we'd like to add another position to the chamber, and that person will be business focused on bringing new businesses in and helping the business environment in terms of working with the town and community, getting those things to happen if they can.
1:27:40 We're not there to guarantee anything. We're there to say, we want to help you guide through that process and move that forward. What we saw with Craig was, Craig had a very strong sense of talent in certain areas, but there's only so much an ED can do. You look at John and what he has and what he has staff. John's great because he has a great staff. We all give John credit. We've got to take his staff. It's not me. No, but he's hired great staff and he's filled around that to fill a need that we've had.
1:28:07 And the chamber looks the same way. It's time for us to step up a little bit more and take this on and make some of these things that we want to have happen. So in general, we have one and a half positions right now currently with the chamber. We're looking at creating or making that two solid positions and backfilling the admin position, basically. So much like the event coordinator position we've talked about. Exactly. For business. Exactly. That's what we're trying to do. That's great.
1:28:36 Right, and I think that the conversation moving forward with the event coordinator now as we start to talk about the chamber, when we had the town workshop with the council, one of the things we talked about was we don't have a strategic development agency here and really trying to grow into that. So then this event position fits well into the chamber of commerce model and it can be part of that as well. And it's still within Mammoth Lakes Tourism, but it's another opportunity down the road. What percentage of businesses are chamber members? We have 203 out of
1:29:05 I think we're at 2-7, aren't we? I think we're at 26%, and the standard is, I believe, what was she saying, the ones, we're pretty good. But remember, we've got a lot of people, business licenses that do, like, nightly rental, TOT for one condo unit. I mean, there's a lot of small things out there. So the goal is to get to 300 members, so we're at 2-0-whatever now, and the goal is to get to 300 at the end of the calendar year.
1:29:35 And obviously it's one of those things where it's critical mass that the more members that we have, the more members we can talk to, the more we can actually make things happen. And what Chamber's looking for is approval for this board to create that extra position, but leave it a little bit open from the standpoint of get the ED hired, and that ED has to be a critical component of defining and finishing up that position to come back through, because depending upon their skill sets, they may want to supplement a little differently than where we started.
1:30:05 So basically what we're looking for is this board to approve because we do fund the chamber to the extent of the staff, the benefits, and we do a very small operational. I think the operational budget right now is not on the table. We'll talk about that at later meetings. But the idea right now is to look at funding, replacing the ED, probably comparable at the level we were at, and then taking the half position, making it full, and replacing that, backfilling that with a true admin.
1:30:31 In the past we've hired very, very talented people like Jessica and had opportunities for her to move up and we're looking truly for an admin that can help us on our day-to-day versus someone who's going to necessarily move up into a marketing manager position. Do you guys have a number? I mean, do you have a, you know, if we're talking about funding, do you have a number you're looking at, an increased number above and beyond what's what we're currently funding? Right now what I would say is that it's probably in the, just from the staffing standpoint, it's probably $50,000 to $60,000. But is it half of that though?
1:31:00 Because you're only backfilling half of it, right? No, this is for the full position. This would be... It's all the same budget, so it doesn't... It's basically... But half of that's already approved in the funding. Correct. Yeah, so I've taken that into account where we are, where we're going to go, and then... Right. Yeah. And then we can talk about, you know, once we get an ED on, that can talk about where the chamber should be going.
1:31:22 We can have presentations to say that in order to get to here, we need to have this funding, and we can explore that at a later date, but at this point, I don't want to just throw an arbitrary number out into operations. And the goal is to get the chamber to be somewhat self-sufficient, but I don't think that it's realistic to think that we're going to get it to be fully self-sufficient. Right now, with membership, we do about $35,000. We have a few events that make some money, but I think that those are some of the things we need to kind of rely on the ED as well. Craig brought in the $50,000 FDA grant. There are some other opportunities there.
1:31:52 And the way I look at it, just like we're talking about event position, we need to focus on it. We've talked about it, even on this board, Paul's brought it up before, everybody, oh, we're going to go get businesses, oh, the chamber was going to do that five years ago. Unless there's a champion, it doesn't happen. We need a champion. So are you looking for a motion at this point? I'm looking for a motion to move into that direction of adding a second full-time position with the chamber and backfilling the admin position. The final number to come from.
1:32:17 Once ED is on board and define that just a little bit more overall, but we're talking that 50-60 range that we can move ahead because the chamber would like to start looking at that position and start thinking about how we can fill that as well. Do you need a motion first to hire the ED at the same? No, we're backfilling the ED position. The ED position is, so it's really just the change in a full-time status for a second position and then backfilling the admin. Gotcha. So it would basically be taking...
1:32:42 Taking Jessica, moving her into a full-time position and backfilling the admin. The admin becomes really the new position that we need to fund. I've got a comment before we make a motion because I'm not opposed to this. But if anything, I'm actually...
1:32:57 You want to support the chamber even more. You know, I think some of the big challenges that we've got here in this town, and I think we've all heard this, is that we're doing a great job of bringing people to town. We need to make sure that they're having a good experience when they're here, and whether that's the ambassador program or actually looking at other events, activities that are going on in town. I mean, we still, and I know that this is probably a general fund issue, but we still have our Christmas decorations up on all of our light poles, at least the ones that haven't been blown off.
1:33:27 Yeah, so, you know, if anything here, it sounds like if we've got a pretty high percentage of our businesses, at least comparatively, that are members of the Chamber of Commerce, I'm not, it's great, you know, obviously we need to strive for the most amount of participation from our businesses as possible, but I definitely like the idea, I always go back to MLT's job is to get people to town, Chamber of Commerce's job is to make sure they have good experience when they're here.
1:33:56 So I feel like where some of the areas, you know, MLT is doing a good job of getting people to town. Some would even argue too much. Let's, you know, those voices. But anyway, what I want to make sure that we're doing is having a, so we may even, I don't want to just be throwing money at this. I'd like to actually be taking a look at these positions in context of the larger budget that we're considering for 17 and 18. So if we're going to make a motion right now. Okay, that's fine. We're just trying to see, can we move forward in this direction so that we can,
1:34:26 I think go towards where you're looking at is how does this all relate together? I'll even make the motion that we go forward with this with the understanding that we are going to be able to review what the Chamber of Commerce budget might be in a big picture context before we get into 1718. Absolutely. And I think that's the general plan right now is to look at it and that's why right now we, Mammoth Lakes Tourism funds the Chamber to the tune of $25,000. It's really not a big thing.
1:34:51 Once we get the director in and they look at all of these different programs that we're doing, Eric and I are part of the service committee and we look at the costs of the service programs and what do we have to do next and what do we do to get that to the next level, the new ED may come in and say, in order to do this, we need to do this sort of monthly newsletter, we need to do this sort of advertising. So I think that that's where, just like when...
1:35:13 When the original board hired me here, they didn't give me a plan, they just said, okay, this is where we need to go, come up with a plan. We're looking at the exact same thing with the ED. So if we can bring someone on, the goal was April 1, it's pushed out a little bit now, but if we can bring someone on with the idea of the 100-day plan, falling kind of around our fiscal year start, it'll be a little bit past that. But if they can come back and say, okay, in order to get this accomplished, this is where I think we need to go. And I think that to the point that we had with the council workshop, talking about
1:35:43 The focus on strategic planning and helping people through the process. I just came from a meeting with a bunch of local stakeholders about the new tech creation workspace, the accelerator, and I'm concerned that we're going to bring people up here to work, we're going to bring people up here that may want to open a business, and they're going to run into roadblocks once they hit the town. So the major, major focus of this expansion, and something that frankly Jessica is very passionate about, is making
1:36:10 This is making this process as simple as possible for people. So instead of it being four weeks, it's 48 hours. And I think that having that dialogue, you know, Sandra Moberly from the town is very excited about this new opportunity. Jessica, I think, is really poised to take this to the next level from her position. And if we have a strong executive director, which the three that we're interviewing are very strong, I think that we really can take the chamber to another level and then we can reassess.
1:36:35 Whether it's the event position living in there, whether it's a $100,000 operating budget because of X, Y, and Z, whatever it is, it's just right now the first step is to transition the staffing level so that we at least have a focus on it. And I agree that we're still probably low. In the grand scheme of things, normal marketing and sales, general administrative cost is 25%. We're at 12. So that's our staff and our benefits and our overhead. We're at 12% of our total budget. Normally it's 25.
1:37:05 woefully understaffed, but I think to your point, if we want to get to the next level, we probably are going to have to look at something in the chamber is probably one of the biggest pieces because if we keep inviting people here and our staff in town isn't fully trained or that we don't have the housing issue figured out, you know, if we have all these other challenges, we're wasting money.
1:37:23 I want to make a point on that, because you're talking about inviting businesses here and making sure their experience is a good one, which I think in turn then affects what you were talking about, Sean, the people that are visiting here. If we have better services, better businesses aligned to meet the needs of our guests that are coming, I think that too serves the purpose. So I was just connecting those two dots. I was just going to ask if you saw the position long term as kind of revenue positive.
1:37:52 As opposed to neutral or even negative. I don't think this person will bring drive revenue. Honestly, it'll drive revenue to the town because the hope is that we increase our businesses with the community. As far as driving revenue, the chamber is going to be incremental because there's only going to be small dollars back to it. But I think we'll see a bigger impact on our customer service as well as what those businesses within the community start to generate. I would say it would be revenue positive by guest retention, guest and business retention. I think big picture, yes. And I think to your point, I think that the one thing that I don't want to do is I don't want to bring in
1:38:21 Director, and say you need to be revenue neutral or positive because I don't want them focused on a golf tournament. I want them focused on business relationships and business process. And I think that's where this board comes in to say in order to have that focus on business retention and expansion, we need to make sure that it's got funding and it's not running around after a $5,000 golf tournament.
1:38:47 It's going to take everybody's staff time for two months. No, those value propositions are real and they're meaningful. They're all people that would look at that as loading up G&A versus, okay, what real value does this bring to the community economically? And it sounds like there's a tremendous... And I think it really is the guest experience because right now if we don't solve the service challenge, if we don't solve the housing challenge, if we don't solve the process of starting a business here...
1:39:15 You know, we can bring as many people here as we want. And you saw, we have a lot of unique people coming here. We have a lot of first-timers coming to the mountain in the winter. We have a lot of individuals coming in the summertime that if they have a bad experience, they're never coming back and they're going to tell 10 people it sucks here. So we need to make sure that not only we're bringing them in, but we're also getting them to come back. So I think that's the easiest way to explain why we would be supporting this as a...
1:39:37 As a cost center. Well, given our general fund is 72% tourism, I would think guest experience matters. It does. You're looking for a motion to? We're looking for a motion to add the positions, to add a second full-time position to the chamber. So moved. I'll second. Any other discussion? And to backfill the admin, if that needs to be part of the, that needs to be part of the.
1:40:06 And the admin at this point, right now the admin position is half and half chamber in MLT. It's likely, it may stay that way, but not necessarily as a plan. It just may stay that it helps both organizations. Okay. Anyone, all in favor? Aye. Opposed? Okay. One more thing, chamber portion. So, doing this time frame, though, we're searching for ED, I just want to recognize Jessica's done a fantastic job. Absolutely. I mean, it's been...
1:40:36 Stuff to kind of throw a little bit. She's going through it. And I just appreciate that she's just tackling things head on and moving the organization forward, not just holding it still, but moving it forward a bit every day while we've been searching for an ED. So appreciate all your work, Jessica, and thank you. Okay, just quickly on an air update, I'm going to hand out the latest.
1:40:57 Exciting cancellation report. Where's the big red number? I was going to say, what's the number? I guess the thing is, and I hate to start it off with a negative conversation, but I think that the biggest thing is right now that our load factors are good. Once we do have, you know, we have planes coming in, load factor is good. People are here. Oh, here. No, it's good.
1:41:16 So the one thing that I've added to this, this is all part of a much bigger spreadsheet that I share with the air group, but one of the things that I've added, you can see each market has a cancellation rate, but they also have a total number of passengers canceled. And right now, inbound and outbound, we have more than 7,000 passengers that have been canceled in and outbound, meaning that...
1:41:40 You know, it could be 3,500 in and 3,500 out, but it's a huge number. And it's unfortunate because, again, a lot of these folks, we don't know whether they're coming from Chicago and they're getting, they're getting stranded in LA or, you know, we had...
1:41:52 A stretch in January where we had 11 out of 12 days cancel in San Francisco, so it's not like you could just take the next flight. So the cancellations continue to be a challenge. We are still working on that strategic plan. I'm working on the RFP to do a 5- and 10-year strategic plan to really figure out what we need to do from an air service standpoint because we need to solve this problem. If you look at the cancellation rates in San Francisco in January, 55% cancellation rate is not good.
1:42:21 And, you know, I think that the challenge we face is if we continue air service this way, it's going to be the first time person is going to take the flight, but anybody that gets burned on it is likely not going to take the flight. So there's just a lot more funnel to fill. And it's hugely significant that, I mean, if I'm looking at this right, that 83% of all the cancellations we've had are weather-related. Yeah. That is something you cannot do anything about. And I just added that column today because that's another piece. Not with our current location.
1:42:48 If I'm not mistaken, Aspen is like a 12 to 14% cancellation rate on the annual period as an overall. And with the biggest winter we've had in a long time.
1:42:58 I know we talk about cancellations, but it's really not, given all things considered, I don't want to be landing in a plane when the wind's blowing 100 miles an hour. No, but we need to find a solution as to what can land. And so, you know, you bring up Aspen. I run a report every month on cancellation rates around, basically around Mountain West destinations. And Aspen in January was 12.9%. Jackson Hole was 3.4%. Vail was 12.5%.
1:43:23 Steamboat was 6.9, Durango was 4.5, Telluride was, Montrose was 4.4, Sun Valley was 16.3. Normally, normally Aspen, Sun Valley, and Mammoth Lakes are comparable. We were at 37%. So, I mean, we obviously had a, we had a little bit of extenuating circumstances in January and February. And that Telluride number was Montrose. That's Montrose. So that, and I think it's important. So Montrose.
1:43:48 So Steamboat Airport's in Hayden, it's an hour away. Vales Airport is in Eagle, it's an hour away. Aspen and Sun Valley have the same problem with us being in the mountains. Durango is a major commercial airport. It's Mollos. Mollos? You've got to get the T out of there. Mollos, yeah. In Jackson, what, 45 minutes away? Well, in Jackson, and Jackson is probably 45 minutes away from the village.
1:44:10 You know, so it's just, it's something where, it's something we have to figure out because we cannot continue to do this. We can't continue to invite people to fly. It goes back to our guest service issue. You know, even looking at JetSuiteX, which has been a great solution to the cancellations, JetSuiteX can't land in Bishop when 395's closed. Pointless. It really is. But 395 closes for three to five hours at a time. Not, I mean, I think we had one. Right.
1:44:39 Now, okay, sorry, go on, didn't mean to interrupt. I've got a lot more, so whatever you want. Okay. But even Jet Suite X had a 22% cancellation rate in the month of January. Right. And if you look, but if you look at the number of flights that they fly, what, 18 flights? 11% overall. Yeah, good point. And also, I guess I'm looking at just the number of passengers. Yeah. But so for this winter, I'm reading 7,000 people were canceled. Yeah. Ouch.
1:45:08 So if I can just interject, so I think the gist of this is, again, we want, we're commissioning an outside agency to really dive in and tell us what we need to do, because none of us are the experts. I mean, everybody's got a lot of expertise, but specifically on the operation of an airport and the best location, the best way to do it, obviously there are issues, and before we commit a 10-year TBID and a lot of money towards air service.
1:45:33 We've got to be going down the right path. Speak to that process if you could. What is, or is that where you were about to go? No, it's not. Let me just interject because the fine gentleman from New York. Brent makes a good point. Compared to industry standard, you know, we're actually doing better, especially in this year, than some of our peer resorts. But I would like for us to consider that that shouldn't be the metric that we use. We should...
1:45:59 We should try to get 7,000 more people here in this season times multiplier of the spend. Right. That's a lot of money. Well, 2688 a person. So I think from a global perspective, I think we have to look beyond what our local airport has, you know. Possibilities. So we're going to do the research to figure it out. I think the last thing I want to mention on here is that while we've lost 7,100 round-trip passengers,
1:46:27 Actually, compared to last year, we're behind about 4,000. So that tells you that we actually have been successful. Unfortunately, we've just lost. So we're only 4,000 behind last year, even though we've lost 7,000 this year. So the load factors have been strong. We've had, in fact, most of the flights that have been canceled, unfortunately, have been pretty damn full. Just one more thing with that portion. This is not the only airport. I've flown out of Reno quite a bit recently.
1:46:52 I've gone back to the hotel in Reno because it canceled because I couldn't fly to LA. So they wouldn't even let the plane take off the ground. And to Michael's point, I mean, again, we're looking at growing this. And that's the stumbling block is if we have something with these cancellation rates.
1:47:07 We're blocked. And so I agree with you that this whole air service that we want to grow, we want to make employment, we want to have more flights and so forth. But before we go down that road of we need to make sure we're in the right place, doing it the right way. Yeah, no sacred cows, right? If Bishop was the airport, how many of those flights and passengers would have landed? I'm not selling Bishop. I'm just saying we've got to be open-minded. And that's part of the whole process. Yeah.
1:47:31 So the thing that I just handed out to you here just shows you the subsidy over the course of the summer for the last five years, or four years. And one of the things that we've been talking about is, you know, last year we took the spring-summer-fall service down, or excuse me, the spring service to match the fall service down to four days a week for April and May with the idea that we had a lot of sucking sound on the Tuesday, Wednesday, Saturday flights, and we figured we'd try and fly Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday.
1:47:59 You can see on the column there that talks about the 2016 number. We saved $91,000 last year on the subsidy during April and May. We lost 1,100 passengers. So I think the comments that we've had from the board level over the past year is...
1:48:18 that we'd rather have the 1,100 passengers than the savings of $91,000 because if they're not, you know, if you look at 1,100 passengers at $2,688 in spending, give or take, we lost money. So I think that the piece that I'd like to propose to the board here is that for now we're looking at, and Eric and I work very closely with our air consultant on this, we're looking at the significance of April this year.
1:48:45 For snowfall, I mean, for skiing, and we think that we'll have very little risk in April that we can continue to at least have decent loads. And I think the consistency of allowing us to talk about the fact that we have seven-day-a-week service, so if you want to fly out of here on a Tuesday in May, you can do it. The real risk factor is potentially that $100,000 that we saved last year. Again, $100,000 versus 1,100 passengers getting here. I think that to take that just a little bit differently, John, my point.
1:49:14 And this is me personally, I want to take $1,100 and get that to $2,100, $2,500. I think that's where I'm really focused is I'm not looking at reducing air service. I'm trying to say these people that decide to come up by air service, spend so much more, bring so much more to the community and spend that we should be doing a better job at getting those people to here. We have 23 million people down south. Why can't we fill every plane? And I think we have to be honest in terms of how do we make that happen.
1:49:39 Well, and I think the suggestion is that we go back to seven days a week in the spring and potentially in the fall so that we can say that we've got daily service, we've got access on a, you know, summer. Summer doesn't affect us as much on the cancellation side. We're typically four, five, six percent cancellation. So it's not...
1:49:53 You know, there's not the perception that we don't have consistent service. And I'm actually 100% in that direction. I just want us to relook and say, how do we market these flights and how do we get in there because I think we can improve on what we're doing. We should be self-realistic and say, okay, what's our challenge and how do we improve on that? And Whitney and I are working with a company called Embark to work on our summer program just with the idea of, you know, we've struggled with it. We don't really know why we're not seeing the numbers in summer work better.
1:50:19 We have lots of reasons we think it could be. It's people that are flying in internationally that fly into a gateway and drive up. People are bringing paddle boards and mountain bikes and golf clubs and everything else. It's families traveling, and it's cheaper to bring your two kids up via car than it is to fly everybody up, plus you have your cooler and everything else. We have all those reasons, but there's still a market out there that should fly, and so we're going to work with this company to see if they can put together a plan that can help us. What does Embark do? Embark does.
1:50:49 Planning for airports. Okay, so they are an outside consultant. And it's Clint Osler who used to work with Alaska Airlines. I don't know if the company was started by Alaska Airlines, former employees, but it's something where they've approached us to see if they can help us. Have we engaged them yet or going to? No, we're getting a proposal from them to figure out what we can do. Okay. Yeah. I don't know if you were going to say something, but what I want to say with that is that it seems like our product, i.e. the airport,
1:51:18 Seems to do fine in the summer. We don't have that much cancellations. No, not on the cancellation side. But the numbers have been flat. The employment numbers are flat. So that is something that from a marketing perspective, if we've got a great product, I'm all for marketing it. I brought this up before that just as a business owner myself, if you have a product that isn't really making it like our winter service, then you've got to change the product. No amount of marketing is going to help it. So it sounds like what I'm hearing here is that we've got a
1:51:48 Winter product in the summer. So yeah, let's figure out whether, you know, if Embark can help us as far as marketing goes. Because to Brent's point, it's not that we want to get back those 1,100 people so that we can spend that $91,000. We want to get rid of that subsidy altogether because we are so popular that we don't need to subsidize anymore. That's the goal. I mean, I think we want to get the service so that it's at least growing.
1:52:13 You know, everything else in summer is growing. We're beating TOT by 30% a month, and air employments have been flat at 13,000 to 15,000 each summer. So it's challenging. It's true. The argument's the same in the winter, too, unfortunately. I mean, even with all that cancellation that we faced in January, we see average occupancy at the highest rates. Yeah.
1:52:34 than I've ever seen. Well, and the planes when they land are, you know, we're at 72% in Los Angeles. I mean, that's pretty strong. So it's just a challenge to Sean's point. The product isn't living up to what people want. The demand is there for winter air service. It's just not living up to providing assistance. And after a while, anybody who...
1:52:52 Gets canceled once, maybe they try it again. If they get canceled again, forget it. And it's fine. If we have one family that makes it in successfully, great. They're probably not going to have a bad experience, but the bad experience is what's killing us. And we have to go back and backfill everybody every year to get new people to come in and take a risk on the flight. We have to understand the customer, too, and what their needs are, because the same person that flies here in the winter and rents gear and skis may not.
1:53:18 Maybe in a travel trailer in the summer and flying isn't even an option. Sure. So I think that if we look at it, what we're asking for right now is we're looking to add service back to seven days a week in the spring.
1:53:30 And we're going to review the fall and consider the same thing for the fall because we do have a big marketing push behind fall now. We definitely want to make sure. And I think that that seven-day-a-week messaging, seven-day-a-week year-round is a big message for us to market. I have a quick question regarding fall. I was just looking at these two numbers. So in 2015, the subsidy was $121,000, $122,000. In 2016, it was $204,000 for the same period of time. And I'm assuming that's with the same service for two years? That is the same service.
1:53:58 We lost a whole lot more last year with the same amount. What's the theory behind, I mean, I get it, but if we go back to now expanding, that's even a bigger subsidy. So, I mean, the gap, obviously, there was a savings by reducing, we could see that there was a savings of $91,000 by reducing air service, although we brought less people, which is not good. I guess what I'm going is...
1:54:24 Why would there be such a big $80,000 increase in the subsidy? I mean, is it just less people? Well, we were down passengers in September and October last year, but we also had, I think we had some additional costs. We had an increase from Alaska. They bumped it up 5% due to the profitability that they have throughout their network.
1:54:46 So we saw a cost increase as well. Okay. Just curious why those numbers are so, are different by, by a pretty big factor. Right. Given the fact that the service was the same over the two years. Passenger loads were comparable, but the costs were higher. Got it. Okay. So, so that would be where we're at with the seven-day-a-week service. I'm thinking that it's a better, it's a better, it's a better marketing message for us as well from a seven-day-a-week standpoint. And all I'm saying at the end of the day is I'm supportive and I don't want to.
1:55:11 Create new committees, but I'm supportive of a group that's focused with your team saying, okay, board members, how are we going to help with this? And we may not be, I'm not an expert on air traffic promotion, but I think there, Embark's one, there's a couple others, but are we moving in the right direction? And what is that plan? Because I do think we need to show more so out of what we spend in our marketing to actually promote the airport. It's there a lot of times, and I think we have to define it a little more, and as we're pushing that, how we're pushing, not just, oh, you could have flown here by now, which.
1:55:40 May have a message, but is that the right message? I don't know. Well, and we do, and we can, again, we've said that to you guys before, but it's, you know, nearest airport to Yosemite, all these other pieces, but I think that if we can move forward with this, we're willing to take the risk on the potential for the additional cost to have that consistent messaging and to also have that, you know, gain back the $1,100 and plus. Yeah, I just want more. I think we have an opportunity, and I think we're missing something. I don't know if we need a motion or if we just need to.
1:56:10 Give us direction. We're talking about specifically the fall? Well, we're talking about spring and fall. And the mountain does not contribute any of the subsidy? That's correct. During this time. So this is all us. Yep. Yeah, I think we need to increase our service. I mean, especially during the summertime when we only have one flight a day. We need to be able to get here every single day, you know, all year round, some way or another. But that's not just private. Is there any swag on what that budget, what that subsidy increase will be?
1:56:40 Probably between $100,000 and $200,000 per both spring and fall. For each? $100,000. No. $100,000. Because we saved it last year. Yeah. To the reduced schedule. Should we talk about finances first?
1:56:55 Just kidding. I think it adds reliability and, you know, you can make plans around it. Consistency of service. I also think that you mentioned customers, which is a good thought. I think that our business community looks at that and will use it more as well. So it'll be outbound.
1:57:16 If there's more reliability to it, we understand what it is. Going late, obviously. Yeah. For people doing business, too, we've got to have the ability to get them any day if you need to. But, John, so do we need them? Well, I don't know if we need a motion or if it's just staff direction. I think we should make a motion because it's... Yeah, make a motion. I've got just another question. I sure would like to hear what Embark has to say before we...
1:57:46 Make this decision. No, we're not going to know that for two months. By the time we get them hired and we have time to put something together, we're probably not going to have it. So essentially what you're asking for on this motion here is that we are willing to increase our subsidy so that we're providing year-round service, but we don't necessarily have a marketing plan for what that's going to look like. Well, we have our normal year plan. But above and beyond what we're doing right now. No.
1:58:16 I do not. The strongest argument being that it's just a consistency issue for the guests, correct? And business community. The difference this year is we're going to have snow.
1:58:29 Well, that's it. I think spring is less of a risk. I mean, I'd like to say Tiger Pass is going to open on April 30th. Well, I think spring is less of a risk, and I think the effort that we put into fall last year produced some good numbers, and I think that we can encourage the fall traffic to fly as well. Yeah, I mean, fall's been building. September and October have been building every year. So there's really, in theory, there's no reason why we wouldn't think that, but we do need to see those air numbers increase along with the increase in gas. We do. So that's a marketing issue. It's a huge marketing issue. Well, yeah, go ahead.
1:58:58 Well, I don't know. I'm just, like I said, I'm hesitant to be making a vote on this, but I understand that the need is now because April is next month. Well, we can table the fall if we want to table the fall, but I think that the spring is very little risk. I mean, we're talking about two months. April is going to be, actually, it's not even two months because we're flying, winter flies through April 18th. So we're talking basically 12 days of April and a month of, you know, it's 42 days. And of that, we already were flying four days a week. So I think it was like...
1:59:26 18 additional operations or something that we're risking. We've also got several months to figure out the fall marketing. If there needs to be a fall marketing campaign for air specifically, you've got several months to figure that out between now and then. So we can go back and do the seven days a week in April or April-May and address the other later. I would, me personally, I would lean more towards focusing on the spring and then addressing fall a little bit later, not in an effort to put it off, but fall suffers from the same summer.
1:59:55 Scenario, which could be gear-related or whatever, and if its embark has, you know, an opinion on that, maybe a little bit more time to think about it. With April having a late Easter, I think there's maybe potentially more to gain and less to lose. Less risk. Yeah, the mountain's going to be 100% overall. Versus an early one and a late fall, or rather, a late pass opening. Are we talking from...
2:00:24 One market, only LAX. That's it. Got it. I'm on board with it. Somebody want to make a motion? I mean... I'm a little bit... We're making a motion to increase air service. But are we... Before I make a motion, consensus seems to be as a little bit start with spring and come back and visit fall. That's fine. Is everybody... I'm fine with that. So I move that we would...
2:00:56 Authorize MLT staff and the associate parties to commit to daily air service from April 18th through June 1 to supplement our four-day air service that we currently have to make it every day. I'll pause that and I'm not going to add to the motion, but I still am going to push very hard that we need to change how we're marketing.
2:01:20 on this. I'm going to push very, very hard. I'm not happy to sit down with anyone who's smarter than me, but I'd love to push this even some more because, again, I may not have the answer, but I think there's an opportunity here. I just know with this type of traffic that we see and activity, there's going to be a way that we can be better. I'll do that. And I'm not making part of motion because I just feel that we can do better. Do we have a second? I'll second.
2:01:46 As I recall, I do have one more question slash comment. What kind of load factor do we need to have? What is the, to avoid the subsidy? It really depends on the price of the flights. I mean, typically it's going to be like winter, winter it's 70 to 74 percent is kind of the break-even. It depends on the cost of the flights, you know, how much people are spending. For this April, May, you don't know that load factor, you don't know that percentage? It's probably comparable. 67 to 70 percent would be my guess.
2:02:16 Okay. Yeah, I'm, you know, I don't know if this is something that just adds on to the motion, but, and probably not, but it, but, you know, I'll support this, but yeah, we've got to have marketing that really does. Yep. Okay. Again, we're. I know, we've said it three times. I'm sure you've heard it by now. I got it. Okay. All right, we have a motion on the table. We have a second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Okay. Okay, let me just run through a couple things quickly. We are probably going to have to, the event venue update is going to have to get tabled, I think.
2:02:47 TOT and TBID, I just handed out the information. The information at the bottom of your agenda is not correct. It's actually been upped a little bit, but very comparable. So January was $2,633,000, which is our largest TOT month ever. It exceeded last year's largest TOT month ever by almost $260,000. So that's a huge...
2:03:13 Huge jump, which means we're 34% ahead of budget, and to me, more importantly, we're 12% ahead of last year's record year. So we're $1.1 million ahead of last year's record, and we are $2.6 million ahead of budget for the year. And again, $2.6 million with town keeping 71% of that puts them right around $2 million back into the general fund.
2:03:36 And I'll just add that January we had some significant snowfall and storms, and we still had great occupancy. Same thing with February. February's going to come in huge. So I think that those are all positive numbers. You have the handout there. Please reference that. Again, being up 34% to budget's great, but again, 12% to last year's record is even better.
2:03:56 Cash flow and CDARS, right now, just we need to report this, but Measure A checking is $1.72 million. Measure A savings is $5,000. TBID checking is $960,000. TBID savings is $5,000, and we still have the money secured in the Certificate of Deposits at $2.5 million. Again, that's our reserve, and that's our contingency plan for other projects as well. And that's at $2.5? $2.5, yeah. Okay.
2:04:22 And chances are when we get through the spring, we have not seen, we're supposed to see true up checks from the town every quarter. We have not seen that. It's not like we're hurting for cash, so we're not pushing it. But right now, again, being $2.6 million ahead of budget, that's $520,000 right there that should be coming back to MLT on top of.
2:04:41 So chances are we'll be putting more money into CDARS just to protect it as we move forward. And TBID is up $415,000 over projection and it's ahead of last year as well. I'd just like to reiterate what John said that that number above budget of $1.9 million.
2:05:02 Just to say it for everybody who's listening, I know there's discussion of reallocation of Measure A dollars. The best thing right now is to let MLT keep doing what it's doing, keep making money, bringing in money for the town, because the money that we're spending is making a ton, and that's really important for everybody to understand. So I just want to reinforce that. And then the last thing I think would just be any questions on P&L. Yeah, question. What is this $5 million? You know, I'm seeing this $4.9 million, but I think that that actually, if I'm...
2:05:29 Reading that correctly, I mean, what I really should be looking at is at the credit, is that correct? Yeah, so what you're looking at, John, oh, no, I'm sorry, Mr. Morris, so if I understand what you're saying correctly, rather than money grab a couple of hundred thousand dollars from a budget from MLT, take the 1.9 million, there's more. Yeah, I think that, I mean, I understand the idea that there is, you know, there, the theory is that there's a lot of Measure A dollars now that can be reallocated somewhere.
2:06:00 But the idea that with the money that is coming to MLT and what we're using it for is generating a lot of money on top of what the expected budget is, which in my opinion is a grander pot of money than if money is taken away from MLT with less ability to make that extra. I mean, it is an economies of scale thing. And I would just add to that that not every year is going to be a good snow year, and we spent a lot of resources in the past and scraped by a couple times with what we had.
2:06:29 So, just saying. And at this point, last year, we did $15.6 million. My guess right now is that we'll be at $16.5 to $17 million this year. What for $17? $17 and $17. $17 and $17. It's going to be massive because I think, you know, we look at February is going to come in. No, it's going to be huge. Huge. And the other thing, the really important thing on the bottom of your sheet there is that we are $1.3 million away from hitting budget for the year.
2:06:58 So through January, all we need is $1.3 million more and we'll hit budget for the entire year. So that means that February will probably come in at least $2.3. So there's a million ahead of budget right there and then gravy for March, April, May, and June. So everything we make in May through June is going to be on top of that. So I do think that we're really looking at $16.5, $17 million. You know, I want to see this in response to what you just said as far as the discussions that are going on with reallocation.
2:07:26 Measure A dollars. And I understand, and I will be very protective of MLT dollars still going towards marketing. What I will ask that we have a discussion on is what is marketing. And, you know, I know we've talked about tourism's job is to bring people to town.
2:07:46 Chamber of Commerce is to make sure that they have a good experience when they're here. I will say that, and I'm hearing this from a lot of people around town, that we're doing a great job of bringing people to town. What we need to do is a better job of making sure that they have a good experience when they're here. So to that point, you know, you can actually argue that some of these things would be, you know, there may be some benefit in focusing on the banners that are supposed to be on our street poles out there, just to use an example right now.
2:08:16 Well, I'll be protective of the funds that tourism is utilizing. You know, I do want to have a discussion with regard to especially the 17-18 budget as far as how we are using those monies towards what purposes. Sure. And we had that discussion when we had that one discussion in the West in that time. We talked about banners on the streets. We talked about wayfinding and that signage and that sort of thing. And I do feel like that goes into guest retention and guest experience. I agree with you on that, that it's, you know, that is somewhat within the same pot.
2:08:45 of things that are marketing and guest experience. I mean, you can get out there pretty far, but I do agree with you that we need to look at that. I think the point that John was trying to make was that if the town is coming after the Measure A funds, they need to realize that if we end up at $6 million ahead of budget, that's almost $5 million that stays in the general fund that should be used for.
2:09:06 The housing, you know, the challenge with housing or, you know, some of the other things that people think that when we're $6 million ahead of budget that it all comes to MLT. No, when we're $6 million ahead of budget, we end up with $1.2 million, which is still huge, and this board has said that we want to see money go towards infrastructure that supports visitation. I think that the risk we have right now is the potential of having money just taken back.
2:09:32 For other purposes. Then I'd like to propose this in future discussions is that we are proactive in getting out in front of this train because it's not just town council and staff that's looking at it, but it's a lot of the public that puts pressure on our elected officials. So I would love to see us actually be much more proactive in proposing some of these solutions.
2:09:53 I don't want to call them cures, but I do want to call it something along the lines that, you know, whether it's infrastructure or whether it affects the customer experience who's here in town, that I'd like to actually be proposing that agenda rather than others coming to us saying, hey, we want money for this. Well, and I think the board, hopefully everybody remembers that I did present a proactive plan that was shot down.
2:10:17 I presented the proactive plan of capping ourselves at $2 million on TOT with the idea that anything above and beyond, which this year would be a huge amount of money. Last year was about $1.5 million. This year would be about another $1.5 million or so to protect ourselves. Now I'm just afraid that instead of capping ourselves at $2 million, they're going to come back and look at us to go to $1.25 million in Measure A and get the rest of it back. So I tried to be proactive with the idea of protecting us proactively, and I think that now we're getting to the point where there's potential that we could lose more.
2:10:47 Well, there's the issue of diminishing returns, too, and I think that until you get to a point where you really see diminishing returns by putting, you know, okay, if we spend X amount on marketing, we're making X. If we increment that another 50%, we're only making 20. Well, then you start getting diminishing returns.
2:11:05 For all the years I've been here, I have not seen that at all from anything that we've done. I can see it continues to grow and it continues to get better. Obviously, given weather factors are a huge thing in economic, there's some things you can't control. But it has always been that it is the top of the funnel. And it's important to be able to keep that funnel. I agree with Sean from the standpoint of if there's a committee that's been formed to review that's been to town council members, which is not a...
2:11:30 A full-time committee. So no one else is pointing to that committee at this point in time is my understanding. We are. We have two seats at that table. We do have two seats at the table? Okay. So but politically it probably behooves the board to figure out how we best can communicate back to those individuals on that committee to express what we believe is the right way to utilize dollars. And that's where I'm calling on the board because obviously we...
2:11:52 I don't have a say in this because I'm singing for my supper. But I think the idea is not that we have a ton of money that needs to go to certain things, but that we're raising a ton of money for the general fund that needs to go to things. And we're still, you know, housing, I'm 1,000% behind supporting it. Am I 1,000% behind supporting it with $2.5 million of our budget every year? No. But I think that that's something we have to figure out what that is. Maybe it's $500,000 a year. But again, I think that when we talked about
2:12:20 The TBID initially, we even talked, I had conversations with Rick Wood about potentially capping us at $2 million with the idea that we were going to make a lot of money for this town and that they would reap that benefit on top of the normal benefit from increased visitation. So this board needs to go back and really figure out how to fight the fight that says that if you're going to take money out of the top of the funnel, in the long run, you're going to not have it out of the bottom of the funnel. You know, if they want to take $2.5 million out of our marketing budget and we're only up $300,000 over budget,
2:12:49 Then there's no windfall for them every year. It's great that they're budgeting conservatively. You know, 11-6 is conservative. We're going to hit budget. We already hit budget by now. Right now, the discussion has not said we're targeted. Obviously, we are. But from a moral standpoint, it's just looking at what is that expenditures and where does it go measure A at this point in time? Because there are other measure A dedicated expenditures.
2:13:12 Well, if I can make this suggestion, you know, first of all, I feel like the past couple of meetings, board meetings that we've had, we've gotten to some of these critical issues that are at the bottom of the agenda. We just haven't had time to get to them. So I want to make sure that in our future meetings that we are, you know, the events, I really did want to hear the venue update, and I really do want to talk about the event coordinator position. It sounds like we're going to discuss.
2:13:33 You know, what our strategy is for events back in coming up in May. We're coming up on review for the 17-18 budget. John, I'd like to hear your proposal again, you know, as far as being proactive, getting out in front of that so that this board is not, that we are really driving the train, that we're not coming others, having others coming in trying to hijack it. I agree. So I'd like to be as proactive as possible with that.
2:14:00 If I can just suggest this, I know that you've got a TBD for the marketing presentation in April. You know, we may want to make sure that we, God forbid, I can't believe I'm going to say this, either extend our meeting time or just make sure that we've got proper time to really talk about this. Yeah, and I think we can keep the marketing succinct.
2:14:19 in the next go-round as much as possible. I mean, the challenge is, it's funny, because this board has oscillated behind different things where we've put marketing at the bottom and never had enough time to talk about it, now we put it at the top and we talk about it, now we don't have time to talk about this other thing. So I think we just need to figure out exactly what's important. Maybe we take out the department, maybe we take out the departmental updates, even though they're not, you know, very time-extensive, but maybe we have to take those out and just have the presentation be a department update each month. I think there's a marriage there because I think
2:14:48 I have two of them. I'm curious on the Ben's position as well, but I think the Department of Updates have served a valuable purpose to not inform us, but the public. Hey, I'll tell you what we do on the Recreation Commission, and I enjoy this very much, is it's typewritten, and it's part of the consent agenda that, you know, everyone needs to come in and read it. We pull it if we have any questions. You know, I mean, I don't know how much time you're talking about. Well, actually, we do spend a fair amount of time, and knowing you guys, God bless you, you probably want to pull it just to ask questions. I know I would. Well, I think, too, when there's a presentation, it's a lot easier to,
2:15:18 When questions come up, when you're reading something, it's like you kind of gloss over it, but when it's actually being presented in front of you, things pop into your head, I think, a little bit more. I mean, I would split the difference, go two and a half hours. If we don't need it, we don't need it. I mean, I know it's only once a month. I mean, we all have things to do, God knows, but it's once a month. So we go two and a half hours and try to minimize some of the other stuff and make sure we have enough time to get through everything.
2:15:39 And the conversation about the event position needs to be with the board. It needs to be, you basically need to tell us what we really want to do, what direction we want to go in. You know, you've heard my thoughts on it ad nauseum, and I think that right now I've, you know, I'm kind of under the understanding that if, I hate to say it this way, but if we want it to get done.
2:15:58 We're the ones that didn't get it done. And I know that that's where you were. I guess I had a little more faith, and I guess you're smarter than I am. You've been here longer. You know what? I just want to say this. You know what? Let's address this. And I'm a big advocate of, in the absence of, what's the, in the absence of leadership, vacuum fills, something, I don't know. There's a saying. But, you know, I just want to make sure that.
2:16:22 That this is really being driven forward and it sounds like it fell off the radar altogether because of... Yes and no. I think with some changes in MLR, I think that it's... Initially when it fell through with the town, it was getting picked up by MLR. MLR's in transition. As far as I'm concerned, we can't wait for them to pick it up. I do think we need to pick it up. We need to figure out where it lives. We need to figure out is that something within the chamber?
2:16:45 Frankly, I think we need the space back that MLR is renting from us right now, and I think that becomes the chamber office with director, assistant director, and event person. I mean, I think we have a lot of big discussions to go through. Well, and just to add to that, because our next board meeting, I would like to bring up MLR from the overall standpoint as representing MLR from this board. Where do we want to go? Because there's lots of questions. What's the productivity? What do we want to see as the end result? And I'd like to have a voice back as a, I don't want to say a mandate, but a directive this board so I can go back to MLR and say,
2:17:14 This is what we want to see done by this. I'd like to see you bring back that proposal on the cap and then excess funding, too, because I think there's this misconception and perception about perhaps we're not willing to share money, and it's not about that. It's a classic sales engine, governor scenario that I've, in the private sector, I've lived with my entire life with partners that don't understand.
2:17:41 The sales, you know, and it's the same at the federal level too. The greatest economy we've ever had and revenues to the federal government to the extent that the budgets balanced and the deficits paid down wasn't because of increased taxes. It was because of economic growth and the taxes that came from the growth. And the community will benefit the same way. We're talking about giving more money to the town than we are hoarding money from the town. And it'd be helpful if they could understand, everybody could understand that messaging.
2:18:11 And I think there's a concern right now that we're playing with the town's money. You know, we have this money set aside. We've got a million bucks, million and a half set aside for visitation-based infrastructure and that we're giving it back to the town.
2:18:28 with the direction that we want to see it do X, Y, or Z, whereas there are some council members that want the money back to do whatever they feel is appropriate with it, not what we feel is appropriate with it. And granted, you know, you could make it tomorrow that you want to increase our air marketing by a million bucks and we can use that money, you know, put it back into marketing. Well, let's bring it forward and let's make it, let's dedicate some time to that discussion then.
2:18:53 Yeah, we'll try and pare down the, we'll look to extend the period for just a little bit, and then we'll also look to pare this down as much as possible and keep as much of the reports to five minutes as we can or the presentations to the true half an hour. I mean, there's no fat in here. I mean, there's nothing more disgusted. No, but I think we also lose, I think if we go to three hours, we just start to lose focus, brain cells.
2:19:16 Real quick, Eric, did you want to give a quick MMSI update? Yes, certainly. I just had one item I wanted to share with the group. As you guys know, we've committed to staying open until the 4th of July.
2:19:32 And as of recently, we're also very committed to keeping Canyon and Eagle open through the 23rd at this point. 23rd? Yeah. After Easter. That's awesome. That's awesome. So there's... Make sure Cheryl knows that. Of June. Yeah, let me be specific. Of April. Of April. So there's rumors out there that the mountain is planning to stay open through August. That rumor is substantiated at this point in time. Okay. You can confirm it. Thank you, Mr. Spicer. I cannot.
2:20:02 That's great news. All right. Wow. Very good. Motion to adjourn. Okay. Thanks, everybody. Thanks, guys. Yeah. Thank you. Good for other properties, too, hopefully.