Town Council
· recording 4 hr 57 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
644 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
5:11 I actually tried to do a little hiking in the Alabama Hills walking. No problems with that. That's at 40,000 feet. Yeah, you can go hiking. Yeah, thank you. That counts. Fizzy. Can I call it backpacking because I carried my camera? Does it work? Mm-hmm. Okay. It is a steel-bodied camera. It's on the side.
5:39 The first couple of days we had to stay in Bishop because of wind and weather. You got stuck in Bishop? Well, not stuck, but the wind was really howling. And it rained when you guys had that snow up here weekend before last.
6:08 And we were scheduled to go to Lumpine on that Saturday. I'm not driving that big-ass rig down the road. 60 mile an hour winds.
6:17 Are you going to go down to the Esther meeting on Friday? Yes, I am. Do you have anything to do, or will you be coming right back? I am hoping to play 18 holes of golf. You know what? Do you golf? No, but my in-laws do. That doesn't do me any good. If you did, I'd say go to the Esther meeting with me, and we'll go golf. No, but you know what? I'm thinking maybe I'll go to the Esther meeting.
6:47 It was just in a state of constant demolition for a while, or stasis. Now we're making some progress. We've got the partners coming in now.
7:11 So did you go to, oh, I know what I'm looking for. Jamie's handy. Jamie's handy. Oops. Did you go to the housing thing? Mm-hmm. Yes, I'm one of the council members. That's right. Okay. So what did you guys talk about? And I was very, you know, curious as to why Jennifer always picked me, because I don't think she views me as a big supporter. Well, most everything else we're doing.
7:41 It's always good to have another side. Yeah. We just need, like, we need some help with, like, an overall theme. I think I have all this. Everybody ready? Just waiting on you, Mayor. We've all been here. Oh, sorry. For hours. You've been telling all your stories about when you were gone and how good the skiing was. Okay. Welcome to, uh...
8:09 Wednesday, March 15, 2017, workshop with the Planning Commission. Thank you all for being here. Jamie, can we have a roll call, please? Councilmember Ferney? Here. Councilmember Ferney? Here. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Here. Councilmember Souser? You. Mayor Pro Tempest? Here. Mayor Richardson? Here. Commissioner Burroughs? Here. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Here. Chair Callinan? Here.
8:37 We're all here. That's great. Hooray. Congratulations. I think this is the first time we've done a workshop with another commission that actually we've had 100% anticipation. So welcome, everybody. Thank you for being here. We're going to go through our walk, bike, ride draft 1.0. I believe Sandra is going to be leading us in this. So, Sandra, if I...
9:02 I'll turn it over to you. That'd be great. Unless there's any comments that the Planning Commissioner would like to make? Amy? No. All right.
9:11 Thank you. So the town has started a walk, bike, ride project last year in December, late fall. We hired Alta Planning and Design to work on this project. They're the consultant firm that prepared the town's trail system master plan. So they're familiar with the town, familiar with our challenges and opportunities here. So they held a charrette week in December. We met with all different public agencies.
9:41 We had a lot of conversations with a lot of different groups. We also held two public outreach meetings during that week, kind of a kickoff meeting and then a wrap-up meeting. And so what ALTA did was they took all of the information they heard from that week.
10:04 And put it into this walk, bike, ride draft 1.0 document. So we have Brett Hondorp here from Alta Planning and Design. He'll be walking through a PowerPoint that summarizes the recommendations and conclusions in this document. And then we'll open it up for commission council discussions and public comments. So with that, I'll turn it over to Brett. Thank you. Thank you. Well, thanks, everyone. Good afternoon.
10:42 I'm Brett Hondorp with Alta Planning and Design, so I was one of the authors of this plan. I was here in December during the initial week of workshops. Jeff Olson, who was also here, sends his regards. He is stuck in upstate New York in a big snowstorm, so I wasn't able to make it out here for this meeting.
11:03 So I'm going to run through a fairly brief presentation. Just want to keep it high level and sort of present the high points of the process and some of our recommendations and then really look forward to kind of digging into the document a little with you and getting your input. You know, I think the purpose of this is, you know, as we've called this draft 1.0, this is the sort of first cut. This is a pretty fast-paced planning process. You know, we would often...
11:29 Take a year or more to write a planning effort that comes up with similar recommendations. But I think the idea with this was given all the planning work that's been done in the town over the past few years to really not reinvent that process. You've been pretty heavily planned. And so this was really more of an action.
11:49 A focused document and with that kind of action emphasis wanting to keep the process a little quicker and more nimble and get towards some recommendations toward implementation. So we've kept the process pretty short starting in December really and ending up here in March. So we have this draft 1.0 and this is the time to see did we get it right, did we miss anything and kind of get this wrapped up and kind of set you on the next steps forward.
12:19 You know, this is the goal of the plan really is to sort of build on all these other planning efforts and I'd say to look at the planning through a bit of a mobility lens, right? I mean, you've done a lot of land use planning, housing planning, you've done parking and snow management, and this is sort of stepping back and looking at, you know, all the needs and uses within the town of Mammoth Lakes through this mobility lens.
12:45 And seeing how we can better connect and integrate things and support all this other development planning considerations that are going on. Because mobility, it's about moving people.
12:58 It's about safety, but there's also a lot of opportunities for placemaking, for enhancing the environment, connecting to recreation, and just kind of creating this whole experience. You know, we really think mobility is this thing that can kind of tie and weave all these other things together. So kind of maximizing the mobility choices and looking at a year-round destination for both visitors and, of course, residents of the town. So we had this kickoff.
13:25 A series of workshops in early December. We were here for about a week, meeting with, holding workshops and then meeting with stakeholders and then coming up with this first action plan.
13:36 You know, I probably don't need to tell you folks any of this stuff, but, you know, Mammoth has a lot of unique attributes that really make it a very special place and a place that I think is really conducive to a lot of sort of innovative thinking around mobility. You know, you have a very, obviously, like the town's recreation connection between not just the mountain, but all the front and backcountry experiences are really important and how do you connect those and connect.
14:05 People to those, both the residents who are very much drawn to that experience and coming to live here, whether that's full-time or part-time, and then all these many tens of thousands of visitors that you see each year, connecting them, whether they're coming from a car from Southern California or flying in or coming down from Reno, making sure that experience really reflects these attributes and that access to all these many amazing world-class destinations.
14:32 is a big part of what we want to take advantage of and draw on in our study here. We did a little bit of a peer review looking at similar mountain resort communities and some of their mobility planning.
14:50 Challenges and the solutions they've come up with as part of this. And so we have some information in the back of the study. I won't go too much into that, but looking at areas that have gondola systems and things we can draw on in some of those examples. How do they use transit? How do they use gondola to connect as part of the overall visitor experience? How does a visitor...
15:13 Visit, you know, the hiking and trail system. So we got some information about that that we presented in the study. And then this is just kind of overall, the overall schedule of the study going, starting in December and leading us to kind of this first 1.0 action plan here.
15:30 So we got a lot of great comments from the members of the public in our public workshops, which we held over that week, sort of the initial kind of brainstorming, let's kind of wide open was the sort of first set and then a couple more workshops where we refine.
15:46 And so we got towards some of these ideas, ideas that hopefully you see reflected in some of the early concepts. We had those. By the end of that week, we had some of that drawn out very roughly. And then we've taken the last couple of months to refine those a little bit.
16:01 And then I want to emphasize, in addition to the broader workshops, we had a lot of listening sessions with each of the stakeholder groups within Mammoth Lakes. So the Fire Protection District, the Recreation Commission, the Mountain.
16:18 Mammoth Lakes Housing, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and so forth. So we sat down in kind of small groups with them and met to hear their concerns, their needs, their issues, their barriers, and some ideas that they had around improving mobility. And so, you know, that's equally as important as these broader workshops was getting that kind of one-on-one feedback. And hopefully we've reflected a lot of that input in this plan today.
16:43 Hopefully things aren't quite this bad yet in Mammoth, but, you know, people come here for the outdoor experience, and when there's a lot of traffic, it really detracts from that, and this is what we don't want to have happening, is that sort of traffic as you get down from the ski area, people circling around for parking up in the lake space, and that's what we're really trying to achieve, is that...
17:06 You know, somebody can come here and experience the outdoors and not have to have their car be an integral part of that. And of course, for the residents, it's the same thing. You know, it's a compact town. The ability to kind of live and work here and access all these destinations and use transit, use a bicycle, walk to school, safe routes to school, all those things are an important part of what we're thinking of as we develop this network.
17:34 And you're in a pretty good place to start with. This is your existing mode share based on U.S. Census. This is far higher for walk, bike, transit than most communities in California and nationally. Most communities' walk share is maybe 3%, 4%, 5%. Bike share is like 1% or less. Transit, probably less than 10%. So you're doing really well. And these would be your residents, likely your full-time residents.
18:03 You're doing really well with this already, but how can we improve upon that? How can we take advantage of that, the small town size? And then how can we expand this to visitors? Because we know a lot of visitors are driving around to a lot of their trips when they come here and get them to use more, you know, use their feet, use transit more.
18:23 So we kind of broke the recommendations up into a couple tiers. Part of the challenge when you're doing a plan like this is how do you prioritize this? There's a lot of recommendations. We could sort of put this in a big spreadsheet, and it's a big list of lots of things with different dollar values. And so we tried to break it up.
18:41 Into a few tiers and thinking about how each tier would help you kind of advance your mobility and get more people walking, bicycling, connecting to transit, you know, basically anything but using a single private automobile to get around. And so we framed it somewhat like that, you know, in terms of how you can achieve those levels and then broken it up into just general, you know, categories of infrastructure recommendations, kind of program recommendations, technology recommendations, just as a way of organizing this, you know, and the next step is to really,
19:11 After we get this feedback from the meetings today and listen to your feedback, is that next level of really prioritizing that action plan moving forward? What are your really tangible steps to move forward? What are those short-term things you really want to push ahead with to start to see some real concrete action towards some of these recommendations?
19:33 So this map is sort of the overall proposed mobility map that encompasses a lot of different things. It's probably really hard to see at this scale. I think we have a couple of larger format versions here that we can pull up if we want to kind of get into the specifics. But, you know, the recommendations focus around three mobility hubs, this idea of these hubs where transit, where trails.
20:01 Where information and technology kind of all come together so that a visitor can come. If they're in a car, they can park that car. They can make their connections to where they're going. They can find information about it.
20:13 The reason people drive is because it's the easiest choice and they don't have information about the other choices available. They don't know when the next bus is coming. They don't know how to get a bicycle, rent a bicycle and get to a destination they might want to go to. So this mobility hub, information is a big, important part of that, is providing...
20:35 The ability for folks to go and receive that real-time information about other ways to access destinations around town.
20:43 And so we have those at the town center, sort of a gateway information center, something around what we're calling the town square, which is sort of this area here of town, and then another one around the village. And I want to be very clear, we've sort of shown these icons on our map of the mobility center, this blue, purple. Those are not intended to be specific locations by any means. This is all very conceptual for any of the recommendations here.
21:13 Really any of these lines on the map, the gondola routes. At this point, we're just trying to identify kind of conceptual broad brush lines. There'd be a lot of further feasibility and design work that would need to happen, particularly around identifying a specific site for anything like a mobility hub. You'd have to do a lot of site planning. But we wanted to say, yeah, this location around the, you know, main street entrance to town makes sense as a gateway, as a place to intercept people as they come into.
21:41 The town of Mammoth Lakes and say, come in here, leave your car, there's buses every five minutes and you can get to all these great places and you don't have to drive around. You can go shopping, you can go to the lake space and you can go to Devil's Post, you can do all that without having to drive and park five different times around town. I think that's kind of, you know, one of the ultimate goals we want to get to here.
22:02 So those mobility hubs I think were a big centerpiece of the recommendations. The trail system, which you already have a very well-developed multi-use path trail network. Just looking at filling in the gaps in that.
22:17 Making sure it really connects to all the areas of town. Looking at some additional recreational trail loop opportunities, this idea of the sort of soft surface trails around town, kind of circling the town and connecting into that sort of front country area. And then some recommendations for some enhanced or new gondola connections to increase the connectivity between the mountain.
22:44 In the town and allow some, you know, just better linkages. Visitors, again, could kind of leave their car, get up to the mountain, come from the mountain down into town, have dinner, and just be able to sort of get around on a very unique transportation system. You know, I think folks who have used systems in places like Telluride would say, you know, that's a really cool part of the experience of being there. You know, it's one of the things you really remember about that.
23:11 And you don't quite have that complete connection here in Mammoth. You have the gondola to the village. But to get that all the way into this sort of town center area, especially as that starts to kind of go through additional development through some of the planning efforts that have happened, would really create that unique experience.
23:31 You know, some consideration for that type of improvement as well. And, you know, this idea of really a feet-first town center, a place you could really walk around and get to places through transit, through gondola, through using bicycles and walking on the trail system. Stepping back a little more, proposed regional mobility. You know, these are some of the recommendations that involve a lot of the Forest Service connections, and so there'll be a lot of partnerships needed to accomplish these.
24:01 But these are, I think, looking at ways to, you know, drive visitors away from some of the real highly impacted areas within town to some of the other front country experiences that we know are available there. Make sure the mobility is there.
24:16 And use those resources, which now may be a little underutilized. And they're really opportunities to, again, just disperse the use that we know is very concentrated in a few locations now. There's a whole lot of great front country experience that visitors can have that are equally as interesting as the lakes basin or going over to Red's Meadow. And so making those connections and then linking that all back into that kind of urban.
24:43 Town Center map as well. So we've got that more regional scale. So this is the sort of hubs. We've got the kind of major three in town and then the airport mobility hubs that I mentioned. We have what we're calling our transit and trail connection hubs.
25:01 So those are those interfaces to kind of the recreational experiences at Reds Meadow, Shady Rest, the Lakes Basin, Mammoth Creek Park, areas like that. And those wouldn't be, you know, big parking structures. Those are really about where transit comes in, drops off, maybe there's bike share. Again, there's information, real time, so people know when the buses are arriving.
25:25 But the idea is those are sort of smaller, minimal impact types of hubs that are really transit focused. And then a few other minor transit trail hub connections to some other locations, Horseshoe Lake, Sherwin Creek, things like that. So we've got those identified. I kind of walked through the elements of the mobility hubs, but you can see here, you know, this is...
25:52 Just a photo simulation of the town center hub we have here are showing, you know, it's a pedestrian friendly environment. We look at the streetscape in a very pedestrian friendly way. We look at the transit connections. There's a bike share system. There's plenty of bike parking. It's linking to the trail system. Maybe there's car sharing, ride sharing. It's just a whole kind of menu of mobility options that you have at this location.
26:21 And some longer term parking as well for those visitors who might want to come in. Maybe they need to leave a car overnight. Maybe they're just in the day use. But again, they can just kind of park their car once and connect to all these other transportation options. Just a photo sim of what a transit trail connection hub would look like potentially up at the Lakes Basin.
26:47 This is one at Horseshoe Lake, which is more of a minor transit hub. Again, they sort of get smaller in scale depending on the location. And then the gondola system. We threw a fairly ambitious network, I guess I'll say, of gondola routes in here. And this is something.
27:09 That would really need to be scaled up. But if you wanted to really link all these areas, you could kind of bring that system down. I think clearly the one along Main Street towards the town center makes the most sense. It's kind of a first logical step coming from the village. But just an opportunity to really kind of interface that mountain experience right into this downtown center that's kind of going through some consideration for new development there.
27:37 The loop trail network here. So again, that's really taking your existing multi-use path trail, filling in the gaps in that. It's a fairly well-developed system already. And then connecting into some of the soft surface trails. So there's that, again, that mix of recreational opportunities, kind of focus on.
27:57 On city bikes or on electric bikes, on the multi-use path system, and then mountain bikers could use some of the other trail systems or walkers and hikers, of course, as well. Complete streets, that's just kind of an overarching concept I think we've tried to weave throughout this, reflected in the main street concept plan of just making sure as any of this development is happening.
28:22 Within the downtown area, the downtown core, that we're maximizing opportunities to build out the bikeway network, whether that's adding cycle tracks to Main Street, and that's already proposed in the Main Street plan. We just sort of illustrated, you know, what that could look like here. But making sure we're really fully building out bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure and kind of thinking big, you know, not going to the minimum, but thinking a little bit bigger. And I think that's...
28:50 For the bicycle infrastructure, especially as more electric bikes come into play, having a little more space is going to be important. You're going to have some speed differentials, and so the more space, the more separation you can have between the bikes and the pedestrians is going to be important as these new technology uses kind of come into play. That five-foot bike lane is going to start to feel really constrained if you have e-bikes alongside regular bikes in there. So some considerations. Is it time?
29:19 You know, technology recommendations, bike share, car share, you know, using apps and technology to be able to get that mobility information.
29:28 We call it a super app, but just a town-wide app that would have all that information, something that you develop that really is that one-stop shop for someone to come into town and understand all the menu of options for getting around. They could figure out when the next bus is coming, any range of options from getting from here to there, how much it would cost, how long it would take. That's a big thing. What's the actual time? For a lot of folks, it's travel time. That's very much an overriding...
29:58 Consideration for them. And if you can show that, gosh, by the time you drive, by the time you load all the kids in the car seats, drive your car, circle around for parking, if you wait five minutes for the bus, the whole trip differential is only a couple minutes difference. But people just kind of go for that natural thing. It's grab the car keys as they go out the door. So the technology can help get that information out there.
30:21 And then, of course, the operational elements, transit frequencies, just looking at opportunities to continue to enhance the transit systems, the network connections, the frequencies. And this benefits residents, of course, as much as it does visitors, is making sure there's good transit connectivity.
30:40 Looking at some shuttle opportunities. And then snow management. We've had a huge snow year, obviously, and with all of these recommendations around walking and bicycling, making sure that those facilities are kept clear year-round is important to provide that access, just like we do provide that access for motor vehicles, making sure that the pedestrians have that.
31:05 A clear space, they're not having to walk in the road, is important throughout that network, so we have some recommendations. Some policy recommendations around kind of moving forward with a mobility partnership to take a few of these elements forward, looking at some policies around electric bikes.
31:24 And then building on the great trail wayfinding system to do some additional wayfinding work and just overall signage cleanup work. Again, information. A lot of this comes back to presenting good information that makes it really easy for people to make good transportation decisions. We have some financing recommendations, looking at enhanced infrastructure financing districts and other types of partnerships.
31:52 Moving things towards implementing the plan here. And this is a great picture showing a few different modes here connecting, right? A trail, your multi-use trail that's being used as a cross-country ski trail in the winter next to a bus stop with a chairlift overhead. I mean, that's the sort of nexus of all these transportation modes kind of connecting, and that very much represents what we're trying to achieve here.
32:22 So a few kind of immediate steps to kind of take the walk, bike, ride action plan, you know, looking at adopting some of the design guidance towards complete streets. There's a guide that the Federal Highways Administration has just come up with called the Small Town and Rural Design Guide that has a lot of really good complete streets concepts. So that's something that you could, the town could kind of incorporate immediately looking at
32:52 Pushing forward with an enhanced infrastructure finance district in EIFD. And kind of looking to achieve some of those immediate benchmarks around bronze, silver, and gold. And this is just kind of a bit of a longer list of some of these immediate actions. You know, I think the kind of next step for us going towards version 2.0 is to get some of this feedback today and to refine this list of
33:21 Sort of actions into a few more priorities or tiers of priorities so you really have some clear direction in what you want to move forward. So I think that's all we have for the overview and we're happy to answer questions. Great. Thank you very much. Sure thing. Yeah. Great presentation. I'm sure we have some questions. Without everybody jumping at once, why don't we kind of give me an eye sign if you want to ask a question. I'll start.
33:54 You mentioned our percentage of drive was 51%. Uh-huh. Okay, is that, you said that's actually pretty good? Yeah, it's low, it's lower than most. I'd say it's 70, 80, 90% in some places, yeah. And what would you say we're trying to achieve? And now I know if we go all the gold standard, I assume, and I'm reading this right, down to around 25%. Of private vehicles? Yeah.
34:20 Yeah, I mean, that would be amazing. I mean, I think even in urban areas you're looking at, I mean, I usually sort of look at it the other way of like, what do you want to achieve in terms of your walking and bicycling and transit mode split? And yeah, if you could get those at 60, 70 percent, and then the other modes are kind of what they are. But I'd say you're at a very good starting point. And I think that reflects, you know, you're in a small...
34:48 You're in a small town and your residents are able to use these other modes of transportation, these other choices, but let's make it even easier for them to make that choice with some of these improvements. And another question, e-bikes. I mean, they're coming on fast. They've been around for a while, especially in Europe. And I assume that the policies that other
35:18 Yeah, I mean, it's definitely a changing environment with the electric bikes. The state of California now regulates them into different categories of bikes, and most cities are sort of just deferring to that statewide classification. Is that based on speed?
35:47 It's based on, yeah, there's a maximum top speed, and whether it's pedal assist or throttle allowed. So, you know, we're very supportive, I think, of the pedal assist bikes. It gives you kind of a boost without creating that sort of, you know, getting towards almost a moped type of a device, right? So, you know, I think that's kind of where most communities...
36:15 Currently ours looking at supporting that those kind of pedal assist with those maximum speed limits and then those can operate within standard, you know, on street bike facilities types without any sort of further regulation. We've got a, we can back this, we've got an e-bike working group that's been working, Sandra's been leading, we've had three or four meetings on that, there's some information coming that we can.
36:38 Also, the Forest Service, Dan and I, we had a meeting with the Forest Service Leadership Team, and they were very quick to present a memo from the Forest Service written by a guy named Joe Mead from the Washington office that very clearly lays out the federal regulations having to do with e-bikes. So they've been starting to address it. Oh yeah, they're way ahead of it. It's a national issue. And I think as we start looking with things like how do we get people who've come here from sea level from town...
37:05 You know, it's going to be a key part of our strategy. So we're going to have to really figure out how to do that right so we can regulate it properly. We're not going to be delivering hundreds of e-bikes out on the trails and things we shouldn't go. But there's a bunch of work already. Well, I've been to a few towns where they actually have racks of e-bikes you can rent. Yeah, I mean, e-bike rentals, I mean, that's starting to come in. E-bike share. E-bike share, yeah. Exactly, it's starting to come in. So, you know, and I think it's one of these things that...
37:32 You know, working with the Forest Service is going to be really important, and how those interface with the soft surface trails is a challenging one right now. E-mountain bikes, I think, is something that's very much a new frontier. Within the on-street environment, though, I think you just have to assume those bikes are going to become more prevalent.
37:55 You have to think about your design in a way that's going to accommodate them. I mean, it's why I made that comment about that width is really important. You're going to have more speed differential. And that's a good thing. Again, if that's getting somebody out of their car, that's a good thing. Allocate a little more space within the bikeway and just understand you're going to have a little bit of a wider range of devices out there being used. Well, I think with our trail system and what it's been doing the last couple of years, I've just seen a blow up of a lot of bike riding. Yeah.
38:24 And I just see the e-bikes, to your point, people coming from sea level going, hey, wait a minute, if I can bike around, that's great, and not be tired. Yeah, if you give them a bike without any assistance, they don't get too far. Right, right. And I think the district ranger was quick to point out that the multi-use path system that we have is under special use permit to the Forest Service, so there's going to need to be a very high level of engagement with our local district, which is fine, but we're going to really need to figure that out.
38:53 The policy from Washington is these bikes are not allowed on Forest Service System trails, and there's no wiggle room in that at all. It's like you can't take these things on the Mammoth Rock Trail, for example. And a lot of users in town don't want to see that happen. So we're going to have to really get into this and figure out a really effective management, you know, set of management tools to figure out how we're going to do that. John, is there an average width to the current network of bike trails we currently have?
39:19 Yeah, the trust plan, it's, I think we upped it in the latest iteration of the trust plan to think about 10 feet with shoulders on either side outside of that. But if you look at like the lake space and path, some of these were done to 8 foot. But if we start wanting to go to the Forest Service to say we want to put e-bikes like on the lake space and path, which might be a nice thing, you know, we need to have some real conversations about that. Because I think they're advising that they may have a regulatory interest in that.
39:43 And so we're going to have to, we're going to have to, you know, get together with them and get them really engaged and figure out how everything goes. I mean, eight foot is minimum and that's, you know, that's, that's four feet each direction shared with pedestrians. So you could see if you start introducing a bike that could go 25 miles an hour electric assist, you can have some potential conflicts in there. So I think you're talking about 10, 12, 14.
40:07 What trails that you want to really be looking at if you're going to have those kind of uses, which is, you know, that is space, but it's just looking at those trade-offs within the road or within the system on how you get that additional space. Increasing the build cost. Yeah. I was just down in Palm Springs, and they have a lot of e-bikes down there. Sure, it's a lot of pretty flat, but the road share, you know, they really figured out that whole program, so they don't have to build new roads. They sign new systems.
40:44 Okay. Colin. You know, you touched on a couple of things like bike share, you know, ride share, zip car, those type of things. You know, typically, you know, my just overall experience with that is that a lot of those programs work better at scale. You know, that's, I think that's something that certain cities and municipalities and towns have found that like, you know, the larger number of people that you can draw on really make that those, those things function better.
41:16 You know, my brother was living in Valencia, Spain, and I spent, you know, 10 days over there with him and basically was on a rented bike share program the entire time I was there. Like, you know, that's all we did is biked everywhere. Theirs is subsidized by the town. It's called Valen, BC, and it's, you know, by the city does it. But what do you, for a small town like ours, I mean, what do you think the viability of some of those zip car and bike share and those type of programs are in a smaller population segment?
41:44 Do you have any thoughts on how to best subsidize that or get that to pencil? Yeah, I mean, I think given your visitor influx, you know, you're not talking about a town of, you know, 8,500 people. You're talking about, you know, whatever your maximum visitor or your sort of typical peaks are that you're really looking at. And I think that puts you well within the kind of density of usage, both for a bike share and a car share program to make those sustainable. I mean.
42:13 I would agree it puts us in that same level of usage. However, it doesn't put the income stream to the town in the same level as theirs. Our income stream is smaller than some of our peer resorts that are smaller population-wise than we are because we're so dependent on. So I would need to see more info on affordability, which I think was part of, and I can't speak for, part of the question. How viable is that for us? I mean, most of those systems are privately,
42:42 Funded, you know, there can be some subsidies up front for capital costs, but, you know, most bike share systems eventually go into just being self-funded. And visitors tend to be the least price sensitive, you know, they're here on vacation. For a visitor, whether it's five bucks to get a bike for the day or eight bucks, you know, they don't...
43:03 Care so much about that. So you can kind of add, you can sort of add that into your price factor and your financing plan in terms of making sure that it sustains through the slope, you know, slow periods where you're going to have less usage or through the winter where you'd sort of have to pull a bike share system, you know, off the street. But what you're essentially saying is even for a car share program like a zip car, you know, between our year-round population.
43:30 Plus our visitor influx that puts us in a ballpark where that's something that we can look at. I think so. And whether it's Zipcar or it's, you know, it's Lyft, you know, if it's car share, it's ride share. I mean, there's so much changing, I think, on those technologies. You know, I think even the transit system, I mean, if you look at the cost.
43:50 Per ride of operating fixed transit, you know, a lot of communities are looking and saying, well, actually ride share, a ride share model, a more on-demand model is actually more cost effective instead of, you know, a bus system, maybe $25 a ride to run a fixed route, you know, so that in a ride share, maybe $10 a ride, which might seem expensive, but when you look at it on a per ride cost, it's lower. So I think, you know, you have to come up with a financing plan, but I think there's enough
44:19 There's enough with the visitation to make those viable, certainly viable, and especially when you have that kind of mix of modes supporting one another. We're looking for expansion opportunities. Summer. Summer focus. Any other questions? I don't know, because I have comments and questions, Mr. Mayor. So how do you want me to go here? I say go for it. It's an open workshop.
44:48 I will say up front that after reading this really quickly, I got angry at several sections. This is another great piece that doesn't frankly produce what I was looking for and is going to be another great folder on Dan's shelf collecting dust if it doesn't include some other things. Recreation versus mobility, I was really looking more at the recreation side for this and it seems to be primarily a piece to try and get people out of their cars.
45:17 And as you've already pointed out, we're doing a very good job there, better than most of our peers at 51%. How much money can we afford to spend? How much more will that buy us? And answers to those questions I would like to see. Snow management. Alta's been here twice. I've taken them out on snowmobiles. Our snow is completely different from any of the other peer resorts in Colorado you're ever going to visit because of the consistency, the water to inches, the whole nine yards.
45:46 If our beautiful Main Street plan, which I view as almost undoable, were in place today, Main Street would probably still be closed because we have no place to put the snow as it snows. We'd be still bucketing out of there. So in the snow management, when I see things like snow brushes and blades on the front of trucks to help, our number one priority being that transit getting open, they aren't reasonable here. They aren't doable here. Don't belong here.
46:14 And I don't mean to be just negative, but I had several issues along those. Trailheads. And most of your things, maps, you're showing the recreational trails where they currently exist. And one of the questions I was hoping to have answered, are they adequate? Are they in the right places? Motorized versus non-motorized? We have a trailhead at Shady Rest, which has been forced upon the motorized public who actually pays for it.
46:41 That's failing completely for a lot of different reasons. How do we fix that? What are the solutions? We've got a lot of beautiful ideas here, but that's what they are. I'm hoping in phase two, you're going to have the suggestions for how we get there. The transit hubs are critical. We lost our main transit hub, which was at McDonald's, which no longer exists. Where should that transit hub be? These aren't locations. These are suggestions, and then we have to figure it out.
47:10 Man, I'd like a little help figuring it out. That's what I hope to hire a consultant for. Well, if I could just say one thing, Bill, I think you and I have both been through a lot of consultant-type efforts, and there's a point at which a consultant who don't live in the area can bring the kinds of tools to a community that say, look, these are the kinds of things that you could be doing. And I think in any process like this, there comes a time when you've got to really get it out of the hands of the consultants and get it into the hands of the local community.
47:37 And I would like to propose a part of this workshop that some combination of council and PEDC folks get together and work together for the next couple of weeks to go through this thing detail by detail, suss all this stuff out, see what's in here, and make some recommendations back maybe to the council and get them back into the next draft of this plan that it's based in local knowledge. It's based in the kind of knowledge that you have about the kind of concerns you've got. So we can really get this thing tangible and something that's going to be implemented.
48:05 I think that's eminently doable. I think the comment period for this is open until the end of the month, so I think I would just throw that out as a suggestion, Mr. Mayor. We can come back at the end of the meeting and see what's going on. I think it's a great idea. There's a lot of great ideas in here, and I think there's just a point where I understand it from the Bay Area, beautiful place. Jeff's from someplace in New York, great place, love New York. But at some point, this has got to be...
48:28 I think that it's probably now the time for us to step in a little bit. However, some of the information that we receive in some of these plans need to be more than what could be produced at the Wednesday night safety meetings over a cocktail. Because great ideas are great ideas. Implementable ideas need to be brought forward for the group you're talking about, and I am more than supportive of that group. Anyway, just a couple more, if I could, Mr. Mayor.
48:57 Transit-only routes. Great idea. The problem I have with the transit-only route in reds, which you use, is that what it has managed to do is concentrate everybody at Devil's Postpile. Instead of spreading them throughout the valley floor, there's great fishing opportunities down there. A family of four finds it hard to get on the bus and go fishing when they get dropped off a half a mile from the water source to go fishing. How do we deal with some of those things in transit-only routes? It has been suggested that the Lakes Basin would be good for transit-only routes.
49:26 It would be a catastrophe for recreation because of the numbers of people you would limit and where your drop-off points would be. Transit only brings things to a specific hub, and one of the problems we have because we have become so popular is moving the people out of those hubs and getting them, and you made comment on that earlier, getting them out.
49:49 Dispersing them. We have enough land to disperse the number of people who come here. We're doing a lousy job of getting that done. Most of our plans are concentrating them in very small spaces. Your similar communities aren't in California. Different funding, different opportunities, so great ideas. How do I bring that to fruition here with our funding? Streetscapes, I'll go back to that again. Great planning. Looks beautiful. My God, we'd be closed.
50:19 We have to have snow storage. You can't bucket the snow out during a snowstorm. It is an impossibility here with the kind of storms we get. So for weeks on end, there have to be places on the streets and now for the trails we want to clear, because I'm in support of trying to keep the trails clear. They can't be our number one priority because of emergency access and stuff, you know. There are other towns who close whole neighborhoods and groom the roads. I have no problem with that concept, but I don't think we can get our locals to agree to it.
50:48 So we need to be realistic, not just great planning efforts that really look nice, and here you go, we set them on a shelf. We need realistic for the area. Sorry, I go off sometimes. I'll stop now. I think those are all great points, and I think that's what they're looking for, saying, okay, you have local knowledge of some of the issues here.
51:13 And you need to bring up those issues so we can start working through those issues so we can bring forward an implementable program here. So I think to John's point, you know, putting this group together of PDC and town council people and coming back to the Alta people and saying, okay, these are the things that we see that we need to work on, I think would be very powerful. Yes, Jennifer.
51:42 I'd like to piggyback a little bit on what Bill said. We have all these great plans. I'd like to see a plan for implementation on the things that we select, and I would also like to see funding sources, because I'm sure I would hope that you would know of grants or specific programs that might help us fund some of these things that we're looking at, because we all know our town's pretty poor at this point. So I'd like...
52:10 To learn about some alternative funding sources. One of our huge problems in town is parking, and you have all these hubs, but there's not, I don't see anywhere on this plan where we're going to have parking for all these people to park their car so that they can take the transit. I really think that we need to work on identifying that as well, because without parking.
52:36 The parking would be at those transit hubs. You said that there was minimal parking at those transit hubs. At the smaller ones, at the larger, the three or four larger, yeah, the trail heads would have sort of limited parking because those are generally in kind of recreational areas where we don't have a lot of room to expand, but at those kind of three main mobility hubs.
53:00 There would be, there's some assumption there would be some longer term parking there. So define your three main mobility hubs. So we had those at the village, the town center, which is roughly Old Mammoth in Maine, and then here. Okay, so do you have a plan for parking at those areas? We've identified those as.
53:19 As sort of having a range of, you know, 150 to 300 spaces. So a parking garage, basically, at each of those locations. And do you have a way to fund that parking garage? We've, you know, it's the EIFDs. I mean, that's the...
53:36 That's the challenge is where do you take that first step. And again, you wouldn't implement them all at the same time. You'd phase that in. You'd probably build the first one. You'd have to tie that next to some development. You'd look at how that connects into other elements of the transit system. So it would have to be a phased approach. But that is where those enhanced infrastructure finance districts might come into play in using the tax increment finance to be able to.
54:05 Can I ask another question on the base of that? Wait, wait, wait. Sorry. Jennifer, I don't know if you're- I just have one more question. I see the gondola coming down into town. My concern would be that it would take away from businesses along Main Street. Is there any thought to that or is there any experience in other towns where business has decreased because of a gondola up to? I mean, I, we-
54:34 We think these kind of concepts would enhance business, and I think that's an underlying goal of everything that we're trying to do here is, you know, improve quality of life, improve the economic, you know, vitality by providing these, by basically getting people out of their cars and allowing them to walk around in these areas. I get that concern. I think partly the way we illustrated that gondola line is sort of a line from the village.
55:01 A single line to, you know, to the sort of town center. It actually isn't a correct version of what that would look like in reality because there would need to be different stations to make the turns there. So we've already heard a little feedback on that and we'll update that. So you'd have a couple of interim stations along Main Street so that people could get out. And I think that would enhance the businesses. People could come off the mountain and get out and shop.
55:27 Walk around, go get dinner. You mentioned Telluride. I mean, I know a few of us have been to Telluride. It's probably the coolest thing about Telluride. Yeah, it's very vibrant. It brings people from one mountain village down to the town and vice versa. So it does work. And you know what, Jennifer, I think you're absolutely right about the, you know, if you could bring back, you know, how do you, you know, EFIDs, as an example, different funding.
55:55 So the idea of parking around town, and I support parking lots and stuff around town, it's a great concept. The town does own one park and ride lot, park lot, with a bus stop and everything else there. It is not used. There are more Tesla people there putting electricity in their car than there are people parking at it.
56:19 How do you then get people to do that? If we're already at 51%, are we spending money to try to get people to do something that they just aren't going to do? Is this a can you can force? I don't know the answer. I just. And I want to clarify in the 51%. So that's a census number. So that's just your full-time residents. So I think a lot of what we're talking about in terms of trips, intercepting or changing trip habits is going to be around the visitor. You know, I mean, we certainly want to get that number higher for residents.
56:48 But a lot of this is intercepting visitors and having the visitor be able to come and park once. And if you're having tens of thousands of people here during peak periods, that's a lot of car trips. That's really affecting the quality of life, not just for the visitor, but for your full-time residents. So I think just to be clear on sort of those percentages, it all has to tie together. You're absolutely right. You can't just build a parking deck and not have good transit connections.
57:18 And expect people to use that and park there. You need a combination of the land uses and some of that density around that area. You need the enhanced transit connections. And you need that parking and information. I mean, it does need to connect together. And I think that's the next step is identifying where is that first step going to happen, that investment. And then some of those other things can fall into place.
57:44 Do you know where our parking ride lot is? Where the Tesla charging stations are? Yeah, yeah.
58:14 There's lots of big parking lots at the stores there. They don't need to park there. It's precisely the difference between the village and town.
58:22 I mean, people park in the Village Intercept lot because then you're going across the street to a pedestrian experience versus on Old Mammoth Road where there's nothing in conjunction with that that would entice somebody to park and walk. Absolutely. So, you know, that's precisely what you're saying. Yeah, exactly. It's, you know, just because you have a lot there doesn't mean that it has conducive uses around it. You don't have a lack of parking in downtown. You just have a very dispersed and fragmented parking. And I think the idea is that...
58:49 Over time, you want to condense that into some hubs as the redevelopment, but as new development is happening and some of that parking would go away because you don't need it as much. You've got these different hubs. And it's just, it's a better usage of the parking to consolidate it instead of having, you know, 15 different surface lots. I'd like to bring something up. Michael. I just have a quick
59:18 Comment and maybe a request for your 2.0 version that you're going to bring before us in the next phase of this conversation. I would like to see a little bit more emphasis on the impact of the wayfinding signage component. We currently have a product completed that's on the shelf ready to be implemented in the community and we're just looking for a funding source for it but I would like to see that maybe highlighted a little bit more than the brief mention it was given. Okay.
59:48 Paul, did you have a question? On the mobility map, on the existing versus the proposed map, you have identified transit routes for summer and winter. The proposed just shows the proposed routes. Is that for both summer and winter? And do you see a deficiency, more deficiency in summertime or in wintertime?
1:00:20 I think that we probably just generalized between summer and winter. I think in summer you have more dispersed usage. In wintertime it's more just concentrated towards going to the ski area, where in wintertime it's more towards the ski area. In summertime you have people going to a lot of different places, so that has to be a consideration in the routing. I mean, we can be more specific. I think we probably just generalized again.
1:00:46 We're kind of a bit conceptual here and not wanting to be too specific in saying this is a specific transit routing change recommendation. We kind of just generalized it to some proposed enhanced routes. I wanted to say that the park and ride was used a lot this winter because condo managers told their
1:01:14 Tenants to park in the park and ride, leave their cars there while they worked so that they could have the complexes cleared out. So they were used, but not for their proper use. Well, it's interesting. I mean, that memo went out saying... Oh, there was a memo about it? Yeah. It was very helpful and it was a good thing we had that.
1:01:37 I actually got a call from people about that, so I know it was used, just not for the right purpose. The other thing is I wanted to ask everybody in the room, who rode the bus here? Who rode the bus here today? Yeah, I figured you did, or you probably rode your bike, so mark in the back there. This is one thing I'm very concerned about.
1:02:03 I'm a local. I've lived here a long time. You're not getting me out of my car. Places I can't drive to, the village, I very rarely go. I'll take the bus if it's something that I know I don't have to be somewhere any particular time. Having a family, I'm not on the bus schedule. I'm not on a walking schedule. A lot of times it's flat out. I like having my car.
1:02:31 Is there any way that we can protect locals to have their vehicles and access the things that they need to do on a daily life? I have to laugh. You said going to Rite Aid and then going to Vons. And that's something that I'm not going to do.
1:02:51 My dad is a very hard ass, and I told him, I said, you know, they want to go to, you know, no cars, and he said, well, walk to the store. I said, how am I supposed to bring home three gallons of milk? He said, bring a little red wagon. So, I'm getting no sympathy there, but I haven't heard anything, and I'd like people who have jobs in this town, and I'd like people
1:03:17 Who have kids in this town, and I'd like to have people who are actually doing business and providing things for the town to pretty much have a good idea of how they're going to easily get to where they're working. Yeah, no, I mean, those are all very great, valid comments, and I don't think any of this is about taking away parking in front of a supermarket. I think it's about providing additional choices for folks.
1:03:46 So that driving doesn't have to be the only choice, which I think for a lot of folks, it's the first thing they think of. It is the way the land uses and a lot of the transportation network is set up. It's the most convenient way to get around. And for folks with kids, and I have two young kids, and believe me, there's plenty of times where...
1:04:08 You know, that car trip, despite the pile of bicycles in our garage, it's just, you just don't have the time to do it. And so I understand that completely from that perspective. But at the same time, you know, I think people, particularly as you're thinking about the visitors, they are coming here for a certain experience, and I don't think that is to drive around in their car to a drugstore and to a shopping center. And I mean, I use the comparison.
1:04:34 We go to Tahoe City in the summer and we stay in a place that's right on a bike path and we go to the Safeway and we ride our bikes and that's like when we go to the store it it doesn't take a half hour it takes us like three hours because the kids are there but that's just part of the experience we go to the down the bike path and we get our dinner and we go walk down to the lake and there's a playground there and that's the whole thing and I think
1:04:59 Being able to incorporate some of those opportunities is really what we're talking about here. It's just that the transportation and the mobility can be part of the experience and then maybe you can pick up your groceries on the way and you don't have to make a whole separate trip out there. It's not about you take away all the parking and everyone has to take transit everywhere. That's not at all what we're talking about. There's always going to be needs for accessible.
1:05:24 It makes sense, but I just I
1:05:50 Have lived here long enough. I don't see that quite happening. I do know that I live in a condo complex and people were leaving more cars than they were supposed to bring up and they were parking their cars. However, that just created more problems with the snowmobiles. So, you know, I propose you just build, we should just build a big parking lot right there off site and have
1:06:19 In the bottom of 203, leave your car here and come into town. Because it does feel like they're starting to get a squeeze on the parking. And I do want locals to just be heard and just going, you know, it's all fine and good. I'll do it if I have time off. But people in this town work too hard.
1:06:39 To have to micromanage their schedule getting their kids around town in an easy way at a young age. I don't think he's saying that. No, I know I get it, but I just want it out there when we're talking about this that, you know, frankly, you know, we're still back to walk, bike, and ride, which is still funny, but I'd love if we're going to go this far, I think it should be a complete accessibility issue for everything and everything incorporated with ADA.
1:07:08 And if we can do this, then we can do it so that people can, no matter what means they're using to get around town, they can get around town. Just not walk, bike, and ride. And that's going to become very important in the next 20 years. It is an interesting concept that comes up from that because having driven a loader for a number of years, you plow the condos when these skiers are parked at the mountains lot.
1:07:37 They plow their lot when the cars are parked at the condo. So something we will have to deal with in the future if we can be successful with this program is how do we move those cars around to do the snow removal when necessary? I think you'll figure it out. Kind of a funny... Do you remember your question? Yeah. Okay, good. When you had earlier 51%, and that's supposedly a good number. I think it was number two was other.
1:08:02 Is that the question that they were asked? Was it other or was that a compilation of a bunch of one and two percents? It's a combination of there are some others. There's taxi and there's motorcycle. So there's a few other categories that you can check and there's also a category that says other.
1:08:23 Which is, you know, hoverboard, paddleboard, whatever people, however, kayak, whatever. Yeah, so we just aggregated all of that. Can we get that broken down? I'd love to see what the others. In Mammoth, I'll tell you, skateboard is a big piece of it. There it is. Yeah, there's no skateboard category, so that would be under, that would be an other. But there is motorcycle, taxi cab, ferry. I don't think there's ferry service here. So there's a few other ones that apply.
1:08:51 In other places. And then there is in other. I'm happy to provide the details on that. John? I'd just like to bring it back a little bit of the conversation that we're working with the meeting day with the PEDC. And I know the PEDC is talking about minimum far issues. And we're talking about revitalizing our downtown. I think the question about where is the parking going to go? And I see Darren sitting in the audience. I know we've been trying to integrate this walk-by ride thing with the minimum far, in with parking, in with these kinds of issues.
1:09:20 I guess I would just encourage all of us to be, we sort of have a choice, we could say we're just going to stick with what we got forever, we're not going to, you know, change, we're not going to explore what we can do with these things to try to do some stuff with it.
1:09:34 And I think that it's going to be really important and interesting to look at what kinds of opportunities are going to come out of this process, but also the downtown revitalization process, to start looking about parking and mobility. The opportunity, I think, is to have a pedestrian-oriented downtown is the thing that we're trying to get to. It's not going to be easy to get there, but I think all these questions that we're talking about, you know, this study...
1:09:57 The things we're going to do out of this don't exist in isolation. They're tied into this downtown revitalization effort. I'd love to hear some things from the PEDC folks about, I know we've had a discussion about minimum far, and we're going to be talking about that at some point, but maybe how these kinds of ideas tie into the things we're talking about with that. Any comments? No, not on that. I have a separate question. OK. Do you want to ask your question now? Yeah, may I? You may. OK.
1:10:23 You've talked a bit about increasing transit service, and I assume you mean both in terms of routes and scheduling. At the moment, our transit service is free, but that money has to come from somewhere. We recently just had a transit route to one of the main primary concentrations of locals in town canceled due to lack of funding, and I know part of that has been brought back.
1:10:52 After a lot of protests, but in order to increase a transit service, would you propose a paid transit service, or do you find in your research that a paid service can work as well as a free service, or no? Yeah, I mean, most transit services have some paid element to them. I mean, none of them are fully fair box recovery 100%, so there's always some subsidy to it, but most transit
1:11:21 You know, urban transit services or suburban, you have to, you know, pay some fare of a, you know, $1 to $2 or something like that. So I think that, you know, that has to come into consideration. You know, I would say that the technology piece is something to consider. It seems like one of the biggest barriers to transit usage sometimes is just, you know, the kind of fumbling for the $1.25 kind of thing. And so having a, you know,
1:11:50 A monthly or an annual pass that's relatively affordable is an easy solution, right? For the visitor, it's something on their phone that they don't have to think. Again, it's like, gosh, I've got myself and another family member. We can just easily pay through an app. And again, the visitors tend to be a little less price sensitive. So if it's a reasonable cost and it's easy to do and they have good information about
1:12:18 The schedule, times, and things like that, I think it's important. I would imagine parking is under that. Eventually, yeah. Oh, paid parking? Yeah, I mean, it's up in the village, and I'll tell you what, on big weekends, it's packed in there, and all those people are paying. And it's not big amounts, but I'm just saying the nominal amount, and maybe locals get a break or something like that. Okay, so you don't necessarily see...
1:12:47 That a paid transit service or a parking service would be a deterrent. Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, paid parking is something you have to, you know, ease your way into. I think certainly in this setting, people are very accustomed to ample free parking. And so, you know, it's, I mean, I'm very supportive of paid parking. I think it's a very good way to.
1:13:11 To charge for the benefit that parking provides and fund the infrastructure improvement and also make people think a little bit about their behavior, like do I really need to drive for this trip or maybe I could bike over there. So yeah, that all should be part of the consideration with that and certainly a paid transit service is part of that conversation too.
1:13:36 Again, I think there's a balance between is having the free service, is that driving enough ridership that you're pulling cars out, and at what level do you sort of tip that balance over? Well, I mean, right now, it's not driving ridership because the scheduling and the routes aren't convenient to the majority of the people in town, I think. Okay, any other questions, comments? You know, I'd love to see if there's a study that's been done. I'm not asking you to do anything new.
1:14:05 Paid versus free lots and paid versus free transit, how it's affected retail and one of the benefits of parking is that people spend money in our stores and restaurants and I don't know the answer to that. It's something I would love to if there's available resources to tell us if there's a dip in sales when you start charging for parking versus it was previously free that would just be information that would
1:14:30 Help me a lot make these decisions. Lots of studies on paid parking. Yeah, I'm happy to provide you with those. Yeah, and the same with transit. Do people use it less and then shop less? Does it, you know, what kind of economic impact is there when we start charging versus not charging? It would be it. Well, I mean, up in the village, it was free parking for a long, long time. Right. And now it's paid parking. Mm-hmm. And I haven't seen a drop. Now, I don't know what...
1:14:54 Well, of course, we've also seen a huge increase in tourism over the same period, too, so. That's true, but I'm saying, you know. I think you would see a difference in the demographic that uses the parking. I think that paid parking is a huge deterrent to the locals, but I think that the tourists wouldn't necessarily care. Exactly. I don't park in the village parking lot anymore because it's not free, but I can also walk there now from my house. Right. So, I'll walk there. Right.
1:15:21 And that's a perfect example of changing your driving habits. You're changing your pattern. I think it's, you know, without getting into granular detail, I mean, simplistically put, it's a deterrent. So, you know, if we're trying to deter people from using transit, charging them for using transit is somewhat of a deterrent. If you're trying to deter people from driving and parking, charging them to do so is somewhat of a deterrent. I feel that somehow there's got to be some kind of happening to you.
1:15:49 Use the transit. That's what I'm saying. So, you know, if we're trying to incentivize transit usage, probably wouldn't make sense to go first in on the charge with transit. We'll give a freebie on parking if they use the transit. Yeah, there's a lot of, there's a lot of. But I mean, you know, having businesses be able to validate, right? I mean, there you go. You're driving customers to.
1:16:15 Okay, now I should go shop in this business. I mean, so you make that connection there. We're not reinventing the wheel here. No. No, no, and I'm not saying we should. I was just saying it would be interesting information for me. Yeah, we can certainly dig up some studies on that. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I've got a couple of comments. Yes, yes, John. Just a couple of general observations. I think one thing that's missing is the node at the transit hub that takes
1:16:44 The loading of the buses down to the Reds Meadow area. I think it kind of fell through the cracks. The one at the main lodge there? The main lodge. And I think it's going to be really important. There's a land exchange going on with the mound. I think it needs to be clear as part of this effort, where is that? Is that node going to stay there? Is it going to go somewhere else? I think that that needs to be included back in the study. I would encourage, as we go forward with this, to do kind of a, if we get this working group together, to do kind of a bifurcation.
1:17:11 of the urban area, which is all the stuff that's within town, versus all the stuff, the more far-reaching trailheads and those recreation destinations. That's a whole different bunch of stakeholders, a different bunch of authorities and land management folks. I think it would make sense to be looking at those things in parallel paths, but not, I think the challenges of all this stuff in the urban center with all the private property is going to be kind of unique and take a lot of work.
1:17:35 That may be a different thing to do with that. I think also, obviously, to start engaging the federal land managers, the Forest Service, the Park Service, I think this thing is at an appropriate level of kind of altitude that they can kind of see the kinds of things we're talking about to start figuring out what kind of partnerships, how we expand on the things we've currently got to do some good things with that. I think there's a toolkit that we've put together that I think is very helpful, but I think it's not sufficiently developed.
1:18:03 Again, this goes back to this working group. Yeah, they're granular about this, where you've got a box where it says technology on the top and technology on the bottom, and, well, they meet, and technology says hello to technology, and it's like, well, that's nice. What are we going to do with it? I think this discussion about passes for parking and for transit that could be on some sort of a device or something like that, a scan pass thing, that could be a great tool to get these things going. But we've got to get these things granular and something that we can actually implement.
1:18:31 I think also when we start working with this working group to come up with specific recommendations, we've got to start looking at really baseline infrastructure in terms of the implementation program that we haven't really addressed. I think I would be talking about something like that cycle cross thing that goes up Main Street. You know, I look at that line for the gondola for the village to town as being, it's the articulation of a need to connect those two things. Now, whether we do it with a gondola, whether we do it with a dedicated 14-foot wide
1:19:00 You know, bike, pedestrian path. We have got to do something to connect that village down to this town. Agreed. And these are the kinds of sort of baseline infrastructure projects we can start identifying that we need to start moving forward with. I think also I brought a document which I'll hand to the chair of the PDC. I think that, you know, there's something called sustainable recreation, which we've talked a lot about. It's in the new revision of the forest plan.
1:19:27 With what is being promised by the president in his new budget in terms of funding of federal departments, the Forest Service is in line for a 15% to 20% cut, across-the-board cut. And this is to an agency that has nothing to give. We're getting into a triage mode. The way that we're going to be able to succeed and survive is using these values of sustainable recreation. So Amy, if it's okay, I'll give you a copy of that, but maybe we can share that with the commissioner.
1:19:54 This is the language that we need to really start talking about on a daily basis when we talk about solutions to these kinds of problems. So I'll share that with you and we can start talking about what that means for these kinds of issues. The e-bike issue, I think we talked about that a little bit, that's very important. We're going to have to talk, we're very closely with the foresters on that to figure out how we're going to make that work. And the snow management thing, Bill, I'm very glad you're bringing those kinds of things up because those are going to be critical to these kinds of efforts, to the minimum fire issues, all these kinds of discussions.
1:20:24 Great, thank you. Well, to bring up your point about a working group, Dan, I don't know, point of order here. Can we put together an informal group of two council people and two PEDC people to report back and by the, what, April 5th meeting? How do we do an informal, can I?
1:20:55 I don't know. So we can't today say. It's not on your agenda for the action. Okay. Okay. Also the comments. Darren's got a great comment on the website. Just sort of bringing those comments into the comments. Amy, why don't you and I get together and just talk about. Yeah. With that, are there any comments from the public?
1:21:39 Please step forward, state your name, and only say nice things. I get the negative today. Afternoon, Mr. Mayor, council people, commissioners, staff, members of the community, Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I'm from New York. I'm a little slow. I can do five things at a time. This way it's an inch wide and a mile deep. Not a mile wide and an inch deep. We've got limited resources. We've got limited human capacity.
1:22:13 If I look at Chapter 8 and implementation, this gives three high points, talks about, you know, our funding levels, gold, silver, and bronze. Great stuff. Dreams. Dreams are great ideas, but they're not implementationable unless we've got money. I see on the Town Council agenda tonight, strategic alignment goes through February of 2017. When do we get to the point where we say we're only going to do five things and we're going to do them well? What does that story map look like?
1:22:40 Go back and look at all the goals and opportunities we've had in this town over the last seven years that I've been here. You go back 20 years. Great ideas. But when we get to the point with all these great ideas here, downtown revitalization, our strategic planning, when we step back and say, you know what, guys, this is going well. This is not working at all. It's got to go. Let's modify this stuff. And the challenge right now is you're in the budget cycle. How do you get to the point we step back and look at this stuff and we agree as a community? Common good.
1:23:09 The greater good that we can execute with a passion for excellence and say, these are the next five things we're going to get done in the next decade. Those are our priorities, and that's where our budget's going at this point in time. And it may be number one, but we can't afford it, so it drops off the list. I'm just concerned. This is great stuff, great work, but once again, we're a mile wide and an inch deep. And we'll go deep on some of these things. Thank you. I'll speak to that real quick. I'm a true believer in...
1:23:37 So, you know, I like to look at the whole plan and say, okay, what can we implement within that whole plan? So, you know, I think it's very important that we have a plan. We have a plan that integrates with our revitalization.
1:24:07 Integrates with our Main Street plan. It all ties together. And then we start figuring out, based on funding and all the other different issues that we might have, which ones do we start to implement. But we have the plan. Which is that holistic approach to the greater good that you've been talking about for some time. How do we get there sooner than later? Because process will get us going, and before too long, we're going to do another budget cycle, another year, and we're...
1:24:34 Behind the curveball again. Right. Thank you. Any other comments? Questions? Tom. Tom Hodges with Mammoth Mountain. Just a couple observations. It was a great conversation. A lot of great ideas. And, you know, we did weigh in. I weighed in with Brett on the gondola idea of Main Street. And I just wanted to let you guys know we've studied that in pretty fine detail. I mean, haven't had a...
1:25:06 An actual design, but we've looked at it from a mapping standpoint. And, you know, it is achievable. In the right-of-ways, it would appear, with, you know, you could have, you're going to have to have one turn station on that alignment to get to the village and have a landing point about where the old Inamono title building is, the dentist officer, where your wife's offices are, Shields. You could actually land there and then
1:25:35 Leave, as a pedestrian, walk over to the village gondola up to Canyon Lodge, which then in the future we're planning to connect, extend that gondola up to the top of Chair 15. So the idea is to try to get, move people through because we have all the people from the village loading the mountain as well as the people from Canyon Lodge. So, so any event, I mean, I know it's a, it's a, I don't say a wild-ass idea, it is a wild-ass idea, it's an expensive idea, but when you, to Bill's point, you look at
1:26:01 Where we were this winter with the stranglehold the weather had on us a few times there. I remember driving up the Main Street after that first atmospheric river of three storms in a row and coming down Main Street and one complete lane was completely stacked with, you know, stored snow, right? And stayed that way for a couple of weeks and it was difficult to get around town a few times. Yeah, that's part of the other ski. Yeah, that's the ski back trail, right? Maybe we should just groom it and call it ski back trail.
1:26:30 But the point being is that, you know, there may be some merit to the idea. It's certainly not a cheap endeavor. But I had the good fortune of going on a trip to Austria recently and looked at a lot of gondola networks over there with Doppelmayr. And they're doing some amazing stuff in South America, actually, in some of these very old towns in Venezuela and Bolivia and these places where they're building complete.
1:26:58 Transit networks with gondolas. And so it's being done, even in third world countries. And, you know, it's certainly a high aspiration. I'm not quite sure where we get that money. But I don't think we should discount it. Some of the other alignments may not be so realistic, but I think the one on Main Street is a possibility. And then there are just in terms of the other conversations going on currently with respect to minimum far and
1:27:25 You know, I think it's, I see things are coming up over and over again, or, you know, the notion that, hey, we need public parking, we need pool parking, and it's going to become more and more a necessity here. It's, you know, in my opinion, it's, you know, one of the highest priorities of the community right now, probably behind housing. So, you know, it's certainly, I think, as all these things started coming together, coming to a head all together this early summer, hopefully the...
1:27:50 I think it's all going to become very obvious that these are the priorities that we need to follow. But all these ideas, the transit hubs and so forth, are going to require that we take advantage of the density that we put into our codes and our general plans. And having redeveloped and revitalized downtown is going to concentrate that economic activity and make these things work much better.
1:28:16 You know, the proof is we see it at the village, even though we have a temporary solution on parking. But to your point, Shields people are willing to pay to park and they're getting out of their cars and then they'll walk and spend a couple, three hours in the village. So it works. We know it works. We've got an example right here. So, but the point is that we've got to believe our vision and we've got to be willing to back that up with, you know, implementable actions. And so, and then funding keeps coming up.
1:28:43 How are we going to pay for any of this stuff? In the notion of the EIFD, we've been in, you know, in the prior efforts that we did with Winter Associates and Jamie Licko and so forth, that we were looking into the EIFD. It seems like a very viable potential funding source, but, you know, we know there's some hurdles there because we've got to get the county to join that discussion and believe the fact that a rising tide is going to raise all ships. But just...
1:29:12 I would definitely like to participate in that effort as, you know, representative of the mountain because I did spend quite a bit of time on it before and I think it is potentially achievable and it really could be a real source of some serious funding for us and there's a lot of flexibility the way that law is drafted that you can make it work. So, anyway, those are just some quick observations, guys. When you had the previous plan for the gondola making the turn at Indyamono Tile,
1:29:34 How many places were there an opportunity for people to get off and shop downtown in various places? Or was it just a one shot from Old Mammoth Road to Minerva? So again, it's just a very preliminary study, but started at the intersection with Maine and Old Mammoth. The turn point would be about where Norco Goodyear is. It would actually cross the highway there and turn, and from there it would be a straight alignment to get up to the village. So, yeah, I mean, obviously I think you'd want to have a couple of midpoints on there for people to get on.
1:30:02 And, you know, maybe it would be at A-frame liquor, for example, or maybe a little further down, you know, somewhere you split the difference between that turn point. The turn point's going to be a terminal no matter what, because you have to detach and terminal through the connection. So, but yeah, there's some great stuff going on out there in new lift construction that's amazing, and the capacities are as high as, you know, 4,500 people an hour, and it's a pretty amazing way to move people, but not cheap.
1:30:31 Can you give us examples of these places in South America or some of the things that Doppelmeyer's working on just to get some kind of the data about how many people we can move around and those kinds of things? Can you provide some links? Yeah, yeah, I can do that. Sure, Hoffman, we can figure that out. Well, Telluride's gondola is, they paid, that was solar dollars, the state paid for it. It was the state of Colorado. The state of Colorado, right. So there's,
1:31:01 But it's got a continual funding mechanism that's done by Mountain Village, too. Like all the HOAs up there pay for the continual maintenance of it. Yeah, there's a lot of, you can't under, you gotta understand the O&M cost of that infrastructure. And, you know, you need a parking garage to park and maintain the cabins and so forth. And you need a gondola meister to take care of everything. So, you know, there's definitely an expense associated with that. So, you know, again.
1:31:28 Those things got to be looked at closely and see whether that even makes any sense. And we weigh it against all the other priorities of the community right now with parking and everything else that's on our list. But it's a notion. How people are using it is not as a ski area tool, but as a mobility, how to moving people around. Yeah, I think they said their Western Hemisphere business, their biggest business has been in South America the last several years with these incredible networks they're building down in these locations, you know, in Brazil and Venezuela.
1:31:58 Towns in South America? Rio de Janeiro actually has quite an extensive one that actually connects the low-income areas, the ghettos, for lack of a better word, from hilltop to hilltop to hilltop. And most of that has been funded from a federal level rather than a municipality. I think that might be one of the bigger differences we're talking about. Potentially, yeah.
1:32:20 Yeah, I'm not sure of all the specifics, but they made the example that it was one of the guys that we were with, one of the engineers, he's like, yeah, I was riding the gondola, and this woman took her two hours to get to her work every day, and now it only takes her, you know, 10, 15 minutes on the gondola. So if you could provide that information, that would be great. Yeah, yeah, of course. Any other questions for Tom? Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry, quick comment. This relates to parking and transportation.
1:32:49 I know Breckenridge had passed a measure, a ballot measure last year to tax ski lift ticket for about four and a half percent and that will contribute to their parking and transportation source and so I don't know if this, everybody, if town or the mountain.
1:33:13 Well, the balance is currently contributing, John, I think it's a million dollars annually to fund transportation through effectively a tax on our lift tickets already. They may not be aware of that. Plus the 2% T-Bid. Plus there's T-Bid, exactly. So that's already in place as far as underwriting the help with transit. So that's probably another conversation to have about whether we burden it again for parking.
1:33:43 To Tom's point, a lot of these things are sort of theoretically coming together in the coming months at some point, but I think that we're going to have to do a lot of cross-pollinating because a lot of the capacities, like S's capacity, how they work, how they're financed, you know, how we're currently doing all this stuff, we're going to be looking at this stuff holistically and get out of the kind of the silos of this being here and that being there and start to figure out how we're going to, what is going to be the right instrument to try to start doing this. Certainly, and I wasn't trying to suggest that that's the methane wool.
1:34:11 The path that will take, but that's just something that I saw that was a possible avenue. Real quick, I'll just mention to you guys that ERA study that was completed in 2008 or 2007, I think it was 2008, that's on the town's website. There's some great examples. They go through a pure example, pure resort example of three different resorts, I think Park City, Jackson, I forget the other one, where they talked about how they achieved their
1:34:41 Public parking and so forth. And so there's some great, you know, examples you can see what our other peer resorts have done to achieve some great solutions. And if Mountain's not the player, can we have other players, you know, that can have some sort of partnership with the town? Sure, sure. Absolutely. We've got to look at all options. The AFD thing would be the ultimate partnership. Right. Absolutely. Any other comments, questions? Hello there.
1:35:10 Good afternoon. My name is Pat Agnich. I'm a resident, and I think a lot of these ideas are really terrific. It's great to see what other communities are doing so we can kind of glean from them the best of the best. I kind of agree with Rich that maybe getting focused is a good idea because there's probably limited dollars, as we all know. As you know, I'm passionate about recreation and our parks, so I was happy to hear that the Village Mobility Hub might just be kind of a placeholder.
1:35:40 Because I saw it, of course, on the community center park parcel. And that concerns me. Because I've been reading a lot about studying the North Village specific plan. And in that document that was adopted by council and amended a couple of times, focuses on the mobility hub being on the corner of Minaret and Main Street. And that to me makes a lot of sense if you're trying to get people transiting up to Lakes Basin and other destinations.
1:36:10 As opposed to being kind of tucked away on the one side. And then also in the North Village Pacific plan, it does talk about the hillside parking area as being designated for parking. And I know we have a temporary solution there, but I would like to see a permanent solution there as well. So hopefully that's, I don't know if that's something that the consultant really looked at or not. And then it's also, I'm also
1:36:36 It's my understanding that the Mammoth Crossing project has given 100 public parking spaces on the corner of Minaret and Main Street where those hotels were taken down. And 100 parking spaces could be a good footprint for a structure there. So that's hopefully something that I hope that the council and the planning commission and the consultant has given some thought to.
1:37:04 And then I also thought it was mentioned, too, about traffic congestion. Having a parking structure in the vicinity of Forest Trail and Minaret, I think, could really have a huge impact on parking. And as a mountain lodge host, periodically I have an assignment to work down at the village, working with a red line, trying to get all of the skiers and the guests kind of organized onto the shuttle buses.
1:37:32 Just spending a couple of hours down there on a weekend is pretty eye-opening to see what kinds of traffic is happening there. And there's been a lot of improvements recently in the last couple of weeks, couple of months, and that's great. But just seeing what happens there is an eye-opener. Any questions for Pat? Thank you. Councilmembers and Commissioners, Darren Dinsmore, as you know, I'm working concurrently on a
1:38:06 Plan to help revitalize downtown and not a plan, but basically action strategies and, you know, how do we do more with less and where do we put our investment? One thing that was exciting in looking at the plan is some work that the Urban Land Institute is doing on trail-based economic development and real estate development and basically showing that revenues increase by two to three hundred percent.
1:38:36 Those types of facilities. And I think we should look at that in the workshop next month. Okay. That's good. I just point out that in the trail system master plan, there is a chapter about trail-oriented development. I don't know if you guys have seen that yet or adopted it yet. I can send you the link to that. But that's something that should be integrated, I think, into the program. It's an adopted plan of the town. There's a whole section about trail-oriented development in the trail system master plan. And just to point out that there's an online tool that people can
1:39:05 Go through, peruse the plan, provide feedback. And we'd like to direct people to that on the website, connectmammothlakes.com. Good afternoon. My name is Mark Davis. I am a 35-year residence. And for the past five months, I've been nearly totally dependent on your public transportation. There has been dark and light in this. I do remember when this town did not have public buses, and we have made a lot of progress. The big gap, I hate to point out the elephant, but I think it's important.
1:39:46 Main Street is still our biggest restriction. It has been nearly impossible to catch buses. You've had to stand in running water in the street. There's no bus stops headed toward town. It's better going toward the mountain. But for bicycle use, for pedestrian use, and for the bus use, Main Street is still our biggest blemish, our biggest challenge, and a place where some energy and money needs to be spent.
1:40:15 Maybe we need to reassess. I understand snow removal. The eighth priority is bus stops. Maybe the most cost-effective way to improve bus use, and we're doing well, and it keeps growing. But quite frankly, if the Main Street thing forces you to stand inches away from traffic, sprayed by the water, storm days have been exceptional this year, but it's a life-threatening experience. Not even...
1:40:44 It's just not doable and we need to maybe reassess especially our principal transportation corridor and I know Main Street's too big a problem to get all at once but work on the bus stops a little bit and one last request. Why don't we have a shelter at the hospital? That stop is really a lot of mobility challenged people and I'm speaking from personal experience.
1:41:13 Have been left in the gutter with running water. It's been very unpleasant. A standard bus stop there is not adequate. The snow removal is not adequate. That needs to be seen as a more important hub, please. Thank you, Mark. Good input. Okay, any other comments, questions? Okay, I'll bring it back to our little group for any last comments. I thought it was a great process we went through, a lot of great comments.
1:41:46 I think we have some direction of the working group going forward. I think that's great. But Amy, do you have any comments or questions? Only that I would tend to agree that working towards focusing a little bit would be to our advantage. And I'm not saying that at the expense of looking at the big picture. But within that big picture,
1:42:14 Really identifying what is achievable within the next year or two. Yeah, and I agree with that. And really focusing on that to make something happen so this isn't just another plan that sits on a shelf and collects dust. Right. And if implementing the wayfinding and signage plan that has been sitting on a shelf collecting dust for six or seven or so years is part of that, then all the better.
1:42:39 Well, I think just at that point, in the walk-by-gride, there's a specific language about that, and I think staff has been working on some ideas about combining the whole wayfinding program, and I think that that's something that would be really good to move forward on. Any other final comments? Parking. Parking is the key to everything. It really is. That was our biggest takeaway from the conversation yesterday with the minimum FAR. Well, yeah, I'm a big believer in shared parking going forward.
1:43:11 Me parking my car on yours? Well, you know what? If you have to. But I think shared parking is the way to do that. I'm not about making more driveways in town. I think that's counterproductive. It has, you know, that's the problem we have right now. I think there's a better solution out there. But, you know, I think all this is going to ferret out as we go through this process. So, if there's no...
1:43:39 Other comments? I'll adjourn our meeting. Thank you very much, you guys. Thank you. Look forward to going and making this thing happen. Thank you very much. Thanks. I'd like to call to order the Wednesday, March 15, 2017 Town Council agenda. We've already had a workshop earlier. It started at 4 o'clock to discuss the walk, bike, ride draft 1.0.
1:46:57 But I don't think anybody's left, but would you do roll call again, please, Jamie? Here. Here. Here. Here. Mr. Ledesma, would you please lead us in the pledge? Nice. Got a first timer here. Nice. Good. There we go. To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation.
1:47:37 Thank you, Mayor. Okay. That'll take us on to what we call correspondence. There's a letter to the community signed by the police chief, the town manager, and myself regarding the town's immigration policies. So I just want to make note of that.
1:48:08 If there's any public comments, if anybody would like to come forward to address the council, please come forward to the podium, state your name, and tell us what you want to talk about. Perfect. Nothing? Come on, Rich. You've got to say something. No? All right. With that, we'll go on to council member reports. Are there any additions to the agenda? None? None from staff. Okay.
1:48:46 Very good. Bill, can I start with you? You can. Today, most importantly, you attended a housing needs kickoff meeting, and I thought a lot of good information was coming out. I should see that getting off the ground. We'll see where it goes. I don't normally give personal information here, but I will today. I spent the last eight days down camping in the Alabama Hills. If you haven't spent any time down there, I encourage you to do. Cell phones do not work.
1:49:17 Perfect location. And I want to commend another one of our town and county staff, the IT department. I was having some issues yesterday, and I called, and the gentleman was busy, and I don't know what his name was, that's terrible, Sauser. And he actually called me back at about 8.30 last night and solved my issues. That's above and beyond. That's the kind of staff we have here. You guys should appreciate that. So all the departments worked out hard, but I am appreciative of all of them.
1:49:48 Keeping me going as they do. Thank you. Okay, Cleland. Let's see. Yes, I was at, well, no, I wasn't at that meeting. I walked in and I saw so many council members I freaked out because of the Brown Act and I left.
1:50:04 Just in case. On Saturday, I did attend the open house across the street at the Sierra Center Mall for Mammoth's new co-working space, and that was really neat. If you didn't get a chance to go by and see it, I encourage everybody to go by there and see what they have to offer, including a very cool table tennis table when you need that much needed break from your computer. And then on Sunday, Tesla was in town, and I did...
1:50:34 End up test driving the Tesla Model X, and it was, the technology behind these vehicles are just mind-blowing, and so I didn't really care about it, but then after I drove it, I found it fascinating, and I look forward to their future of sustainability in green, so, and then, yeah, the meetings today. That's it. All right, thank you, Cleland, and I will concur that Tesla, I didn't,
1:51:04 X test drive also. Pretty nice. Colin. Sure. You made it back to town, by the way. Yeah, thank you. Not much to report. I've been out of the country for the last couple of weeks, so I apologize for missing the last meeting. I understand we got out before 8, so maybe I'm the problem. Just saying. Yeah. Thanks for carrying the torch for me. You know, I did attend.
1:51:31 The Housing Needs Assessment Meeting earlier today. The only thing for me to report as my role as a liaison for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Lakes Tourism recently received an award, so I wanted to mention that. It was named the Best Destination Marketing Organization by California Meetings and Events Magazine, so it was an award that Director Erty received, and I just wanted to commend.
1:52:00 MLT and their staff on that award. So that's it for me. Okay, Colin. Mr. Mayor Pro Tem, John. Thank you, sir. March 2nd, I attended an e-bike meeting. I want to thank Sandra and staff for pulling these things together. Very interesting stuff that folds right in his walk, bike, ride effort. On March 6th, I met with the regional forester in Vallejo.
1:52:30 And I shared with him and members of his staff the projects that we're working on here in Mammoth Lakes, including the Reds Meadow Road project, the walk, bike, ride project, which they were very interested and very enthusiastic about. Also advised on the amount of resources the town has to put into the trail system, which we have an MOU with the Forest Service to do.
1:52:53 Also advise that Mammoth Lakes Recreation is in pursuit of a new executive director, and this may involve a nationwide search, and we're very excited about what those opportunities might look like. And finally advise that, as they know, this community is well-versed in the values of sustainable recreation, which is in our forest plan revision. These are very important things because this agency is potentially facing a 10 to 15 percent across-the-board federal budget cut.
1:53:19 And the only way that we're going to really move forward and succeed on behalf of public lands in our community is using these values of sustainable recreation, all the great things that are happening in Mammoth Lakes. This leadership team is coming over to the eastern Sierra in the first week of May for a general management review. I'm anticipating the town may be participating in those conversations as a partner with the Forest Service. That was all very interesting. I attended briefly the rec commission meeting up at the...
1:53:45 In the North Village area, and it was a very interesting meeting. I just wanted to make sure that folks understood that the council's likely to be looking at the multi-use facility as a holistic part of a variety of different solutions in town. I attended the MLH board meeting, and we had a good discussion. And then on March 9th, I was at the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. Mammoth Lakes is now the chair of that district, which is kind of interesting.
1:54:15 The effects of the big winter on the Owens Dry Lakebed, and they're having a lot of issues down there to deal with. Also, there's kind of a tangential relationship between the Air District and things happening out at Shady Rest. It's tangential. We'll get to that in a second. Attended the LTC meeting on March 13th with Shields. Shields, we talked about the California Transportation Commission that's coming to the Eastern Sierra in September. It's going to be kind of a big, high-profile gathering here.
1:54:41 Encourage members of the commission to get engaged with the walk, bike, ride process. Share with them the link to the pages. It involves the county and a lot of the stuff. And also we've talked several times about the debriefing effort that's going to happen among these various agencies about this big winter. What happened in the town? What happened with Caltrans? What happened with Mono County? How do we communicate?
1:55:04 I think, Bill, to your point today about the snow, all the snow issues, this is going to be a lot of very important and valuable information to come out of this winter. Then I had a conversation yesterday with representatives of BLM and the Forest Service about shady rust. There's some things I think we did
1:55:24 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:55:48 A couple final things. There is now an effort in the state legislature to advance the idea of establishing a California Office of Outdoor Recreation. And some folks have requested a letter of support by March 22nd, which is before our next meeting. And I'm wondering, Mr. Mayor, if I can get a draft of that letter. We can run it by you and the town manager to see if it's appropriate to sign to maybe get in there to indicate that the community of Mammoth Lake supports the state establishing something like that. But I just got that today.
1:56:18 We'll see what to do with that. Okay. And then tomorrow night, all those of you who have not gotten your fat bike on, tomorrow night is the night to do it. Tamarack, the Sierra Eastside Mountain Biking Association is hosting an event up at Tamarack to ride fat bikes for races and demonstrations and things like that. I know we're trying to work something out with the Forest Service. We haven't quite got there yet, but there's going to be an event up at Tamarack tomorrow night.
1:56:45 It's going to be warm. Maybe the conditions are not ideal, but I would encourage everybody to turn out. What time? It's about, I think it's about 5.30 or 6. There'll be a race. There'll be demos after that, so you can try it out. It's great to ride those things on a nice wide trail and kind of see how they work and a lot of fun. And then next Monday, of course, we have this Reds Meadow meeting, two meetings, a meeting in the morning, and a meeting in the afternoon on the Reds Meadow Road project, which will be interesting. That's it.
1:57:09 Thank you very much. Thank you. I just want to add to your LTC comment. One of the things that's coming forward, and we're actually going to be talking in item number nine tonight, is the transportation funding and how that's going to go forward with AB Bill number one. There are some other things in there. I think Dan might talk to that. So thank you. MLR. Had a great meeting on March 7th.
1:57:38 Measure our special funding. We decided to fund, there are three things that came forward. One was the curling project, the other was the disc golf, and the other was park in a cart. And we decided to fund the park in the cart, not saying that we didn't like the curling and the disc, it just, we were, needed some more information and we thought the curling
1:58:07 Funding would be a little premature since summer's coming up. And then I have a little presentation. The California, and I want to get this right, it's the California Parks and Recreation Society District 7. I gave some awards out. Now, I know it's been in the paper and a few other things, but I want to...
1:58:39 Recognize both Stu Brown and Betsy Truax for their tremendous work in all that they do for recreation here. And for that, they were recognized by District 7. And so if you guys would come forward. Outstanding full-time employee, Stu Brown. And this is what they received.
1:59:08 So I'm going to come down and present it to them, but I'll tell you what, it just shows our community is doing great work, and it's because of you guys that it's happening. So thank you. Somebody take a picture. Oh, Joel's on it. Absolutely. Right in the back there. I was about to say, where does that go? Good job. Okay, good. Wall of honor. It is. It's fantastic when our community is
1:59:58 Being recognized by the state for these things. For good things. Yeah, it's a big thing. With that, we'll go on to reports from commissions or departments. Sandra? Thank you. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just to report that the Planning and Economic Development Commission had their March meeting yesterday on a special day. Normally it's on Wednesdays. They did review the minimum flurry ratio.
2:00:31 Discussion. They had a discussion on minimum flow rate ratio and provided staff with direction to bring back minimum flow rate ratio language for consideration at their next meeting in April. So we'll be bringing that back to them. They had some other information. We'll be drafting that language for them to consider at their April meeting.
2:00:50 If there's a recommendation to council at the April meeting, then it would come to council the first meeting in May for consideration. They also approved a variance for a reduced setback for a driveway and conducted design review for a new business in the village called Shelter Distilling, which will be distilling spirits in the village.
2:01:10 And that's all I have. Any questions? All right, any questions? Just a quick question. The minimum far, are we in the ballpark of talking about a number yet, or are we still doing more discovery? It's to, it's, we'll be providing options to the commission of a .5 and a .75. Okay, so. It's in range. They've established a range. Right. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:01:35 Good evening, again, Council of Betsy Truax, Chair of the Recreation Commission, and I know that the proposed multi-use facilities are not on your agenda this evening, but I do just want to report on a couple of items out of commission. As the Mayor Pro Tem mentioned, we did have a very successful workshop at the Community Center on March 6th, so thanks very much to all who attended and staff for putting together a really great presentation.
2:01:58 Then the commission met on Tuesday, March 7th. This is a standing item for us, and we did have an update. Just to let you know that we did ask the staff to speak with the Mammoth Unified School District about extending our lease with the current site to support our summer programming. And the commission remains strongly supportive of the project. So I'm sure you're all very aware. I've spoken with some of you about that. And in addition to that,
2:02:23 The commission accepted the Parks and Recreation Department's strategic work plan for the year. Some very exciting things ahead for Stu and his team. We're very excited about all the great work the department continues to do. And on Tuesday, March 21st at 5.30 here in Suite Z, we will hold a workshop with the youth sports funding recipients. We're very excited to have a really productive discussion about how these organizations can work together and be supported by the town and not just...
2:02:51 Not just be part of the competitive funding process, but we really want to have a really robust discussion with them and also talk about just some of the additional funding that we have this year from the county as well as the town. And finally, I do just want to thank you for all of the kind words at your last meeting. We were in Sacramento at the Parks and Recreation Conference. It was fantastic. So I really appreciated the opportunity to attend with some of the staff. And Stu left his plaque at home, but I was very honored to present him with the Outstanding Full-Time Professional Award for District 7.
2:03:20 Thank you. And I think I forgot to mention, didn't you can maybe mention it, Stu was nominated to be on the board, is that right? So Stu has been elected to the District 7 California Parks and Recreation Society Board, which is comprised of four counties. We are the only county on the west side, or on the east side. The other counties are all on the east side, so we had a very fun trip over to Hanford for that. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:03:51 Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers, staff, community members. I think because we were there, I think we were the person they needed on their board at the time, apparently, but anyway. But it's an honour to serve. Well, congratulations. Thank you. Yeah, I'll take it. We have not been represented before on CPRS, which is great.
2:04:13 There is a commissioner organisation that Pat Agnich has been on and now Betsy's on, but this is the first time we've had representation from kind of the east side, so looking forward to kind of being more engaged in parks and recreation issues and concerns for the state. Just really quickly, we have a couple of events coming up. We have the annual, actually it's now the third annual, Summer Recreation Open House. This is your one-stop shop for recreation this summer.
2:04:36 So if you want to book in, meet all the recreation providers. So it's not just the Parks and Recreation event, we're just hosting it. So we're really just providing opportunity for all our community members to come along and learn, register and hopefully get engaged and be part of our summer programming. Mammoth Elementary School, Tuesday, March 28th from 5 to 7. And we have several bilingual flyers in the back.
2:05:00 Following right on the heels of the open house is April 3rd. April 3rd is an important date because that's when we open all our summer camp registrations. 8 o'clock, April 3rd. I'll keep promoting it. So everybody, all at once, good luck. Those fill out very fast. So I just want to make sure that you have that date memorized. Staff will be able to support anybody that comes in, that calls or wants to do their registrations online.
2:05:26 April 3rd. Just really quickly, we closed the ice rink. It wasn't here on the last meeting, but we did close on March 5th, that Sunday. We kind of eked a week out of it. And ironically, looking at the numbers, we actually did better this year than the previous year. So go figure. Just really quickly, we operated for a total of 69 days. Half of those were half days, about 28. Visits were up about 7%, but revenue was up over 20%.
2:05:56 So, you know, considering, you know, heat wave, snow, Armageddon, it's not easy. But anyway, staff did an amazing job, very proud, very diligent, very passionate. Mammoth, sorry, May 8th is the official opening for the Whitmore Pool. All right, so less than two months away, we opened for lap swim and swim team, fingers crossed. A couple of other things that we want to talk about just on the public information side.
2:06:23 The Mammoth Biathlon is at Panorama Dome this Saturday. That's an event that the Parks and Recreation Department permits. So that's all ready to go. So that's up at the Dome. Definitely want to get up there and watch some great biathlon action. The other event this weekend on Saturday on the same day is the first one they've done. And it's the Mammoth, if I get this right, Backyard Rail Jam. It's going to be in the Sierra Nevada Resort parking lot, that area there. So that's kind of rolling along.
2:06:49 From three o'clock is kind of most of the competitions get underway through that evening. So we've got two major events this Saturday and I'm thinking if I've got everything and I think that's right. Just a quick update on a couple of agreements that council authorized a few months ago. One is the Memento Creative Agreement. We have a final agreement. We're working with Memento on. We hope to get that finalized shortly.
2:07:15 We're looking at hopefully beginning of April rollout for that project. The other project that's going to run kind of simultaneously with that project is the Civic Plus website redesign. So that's looking at an April 5th project kickoff meeting with our project team for the staff, and that's about a six-month process. So that'll kind of run us through fall. But anyway, both of those programs are kind of ready to go. And any questions?
2:07:40 That means the new redesign of the town's website, correct? That's correct, yes, absolutely. Stu, you mentioned 69 operating days for the rink, that's out of how many possible? 100. So, it's not bad. So, total of 100, we operated for 69, which isn't too bad, but 28 of those were half days. So, you know, we took a while to get going, or the snow was there, and we opened for maybe three hours or something in the evening, or an open pocket.
2:08:11 Good effort considering, I think. Right. Staff worked above and beyond. Thank you. Happy to do it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you, Councilmembers, Mr. Mayor, Joel Rathje, Town Trails Coordinator. I just have a very brief update on some trail-related programs for you. Our Shady Rest Winter Grooming Program is running. It has been groomed. We are using currently some alternative equipment. We've had some equipment failures. The equipment is being fixed.
2:08:47 So it should be optimized maybe next week, but the trail network is being groomed. So that's great to have alternatives. Also, as you know, we started a poo ferry campaign or at two locations, not necessarily a campaign, but two facilities for dog waste have been placed at the Mill City, Sherman's Access Point, and also the Sherman's Trailhead by the propane tanks.
2:09:15 And we weren't sure what to expect. It is a pilot program, so we expect to learn things. And one thing we've learned early on is it's very popular. A lot of people are choosing to put their animal's waste into the waste facility. So that's great news. It's a unique design. If you haven't seen it, I would recommend going to these locations, checking it out. It's much cleaner than it was last winter.
2:09:40 It's not completely clean, but wow, it's better. So what we found is that, and I've been working with Mammoth Disposal on this, Rick Voll, and met with him this week on Tuesday morning. We're going to increase the frequency of pickup service at the Sherman's Trailhead to accommodate the enthusiastic people who are using it. Mill City seems to be operating just fine at the frequency of once a week.
2:10:07 So we're learning and already we expect to expand. We're going to have two more facilities fabricated and place those out at the Shady Rest Park area. There's already some town facilities out there, so we want to complement that effort.
2:10:25 And put them in strategic locations for people to be able to take their dog, walk their dog out on those trails or snowshoe with their animal and then try to provide some convenient locations for them to get rid of the bag so they don't have to carry it around with them for too long. So that's going fairly well. Also, I would like to announce that the Forest Service has signed a categorical exclusion for three miles of trails for this summer to be built.
2:10:54 It's on the Schedule of Proposed Actions page for Inyo National Forest. You can find that there today. So we look forward to working with our strong partners, the Mammoth District and the Inyo National Forest, to implement that project this season. That's all I have. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer. Are we going to need National Guard trucks for the food parry? Yes. Which is an offer. Well, all of those...
2:11:22 Very eager citizens looking forward to playing baseball at the Shady Rest Park ball fields. You're going to be praying for that poo fairy. And it's great to have this program getting started, but I think it's going to need... It's a great program. And we're going to need to put these things all over the place. Organic fertilizer. Yes. Yes, exactly right. Call it what you will. The three miles of trail, Joe. Where and what type?
2:11:47 I'd be happy to share a map with you so you can really dial in the project with me. So at the Sherwin's Trailhead is the point of origin for these trails, and they will connect. There's two alignments that will connect up to the Mammoth Rock Trail. So you'll be able to have a loop experience. I know today there are a couple of segments that go down the hillside.
2:12:08 To connect, they're not system trails. They're a bit steep, hard to use for a lot of folks. And the design that we're going forward with sticks to a 5% or less grade. So we expect to see them usable, but most importantly, sustainable. They shouldn't turn into ditches after a season or two. Correct. Multi-use, non-motorized. Correct. Any other questions or comments, Richel? Thank you very much. Thank you.
2:12:40 I have something, of all people. Oh, great. So Betsy's comments on the multi-use facility reminded me that it has appeared up until now that Councilmember Hoff might have a conflict on that because of the proximity of her residence to the park, but we have asked the Fair Political Practices Commission for a formal opinion, and they duly issued one in writing. I have a copy if anyone wants to see it, finding that there is no conflict and that Councilmember Hoff can participate in all the discussions about that facility at that location.
2:13:08 Good. What? You guys are clapping. Oh, good. Great. Congratulations. And you know what? We went about it the right way, so that's great. Yeah. All right. Any other commissioner reports? That will go on to public presentations. I have a certificate of appreciation and a proclamation to read. Hopefully the organizers of Elevation are here. Hi, guys. See you back there.
2:13:39 I'm going to read each one. This certificate of appreciation to the organizers and supporters of the 15th annual Elevation event. The Elevation event celebrates the diversity of our visitors in the LGBT community, bringing thousands of guests to Mammoth Lakes over the years with 2,500 attendees expected for the 2017 event. And here's a mayor's proclamation. We're declaring March 15th today.
2:14:08 as Elevation Day. Whereas Elevation Mammoth, an annual event held in the town of Mammoth Lakes, has shown its dedication and loyalty to our town by choosing to organize and promote this event year after year for the past 15 years. And whereas Elevation Mammoth has a direct impact on the diversity of our guests in Mammoth Lakes and successfully increased interest in our town as a travel destination, not just during the event, but year-round for members of the LGBT community all over the world. And whereas Elevation Mammoth
2:14:37 is set to celebrate its 15th anniversary of the event and anticipates 2,500 guests to attend this season, setting the stage for the highest attendance since the origin of the event. And whereas Elevation Mammoth is an event which the town celebrates, supports, and will continue to support, and whereas Elevation Mammoth, the event organizer, the guests of the community of Mammoth Lakes, all share the common goal of enjoying the beauty of Mammoth Lakes, the Mammoth Lakes area, and not all it has to offer.
2:15:06 Now, therefore, the mayor of the town of Mammoth Lakes proclaims March 15, 2017 is hereby recognized as Elevation Day, celebrating our community's diversity and growing tourism. So please come forward. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Can I say something about that real quick? Sure. Tom, congratulations on that. 15 years ago on your first...
2:16:02 I was a reporter and I did an interview with you and I knew you had it and just thank you for coming back every year. I knew you were right on the money with bringing everyone into town and so thank you. Thank you. Okay, with that we'll go on to item number three, a presentation of Footsteps to Brilliance program presented by Dr. Stacey Adler.
2:16:43 Monroe County Superintendent of Schools. Thank you. Good evening, Council Members, Community Members. Thank you all for letting me be here today. Jamie showed me how this works. Oh, you have to use the mouse. Okay. I get that. I do that all the time, switching from my... Okay. All right. So... Okay.
2:17:15 So I'm here tonight to share with you a program called Footsteps to Brilliance, and this program is going to be the cornerstone of the County Office of Education's literacy initiative, which we're calling Trails to Literacy.
2:17:31 We'll talk more about that later. But Footsteps to Brilliance was a program that I came across about a year and a half ago. It was presented at a California County Superintendents' meeting by the Napa County Superintendent of Schools. And I was so blown away by the power of this program. I've been thinking and thinking, I've got to bring this to Mono County because it's so needed for our communities.
2:17:59 I'm very excited to share it with you all tonight. So this is a very accessible way to bring early literacy to our communities and especially to our families that might not have access to literacy. So I'm going to show you a quick video that was done by the Calusa County Office of Education who's just implemented this program. Jamie said it would work.
2:18:33 Clouse County is very rural. We're very wide open. In our county, we have a 22% high school dropout rate, mostly because of the illiteracy. And with that, we also have the highest unemployment in the state month after month. Because of these challenges, our students from rural areas and low-income families struggle, and in many cases, they come into school sometimes years behind other students that have access to those early reading options.
2:19:04 The students that we're working with are digital natives, and digital natives need to have that blended learning opportunity. Footsteps to Brilliance gives us an opportunity to provide that tool that's needed, not just for our digital natives, but also for our parents as well. I think our parents really appreciate the fact that Footsteps to Brilliance can engage with their children because it's something that their children are enthusiastic about, and they can go home and they can read through the books, again, in Spanish and in English.
2:19:35 Me da mucho gusto que ella esté aprendiendo nuevas palabras en inglés, pero también en español, ya que yo no le puedo ayudar tanto porque el inglés es mi segunda lengua. Y además yo no necesito estarlas forzando, diciéndole siéntate a estudiar o ponte a hacer esto, porque de ellas mismas nace el querer aprender porque para ellas es un juego.
2:20:01 My favorite part of the Footsteps to Brilliance program is that it's interactive. Every book on every page you can touch and something moves or something makes a sound or it names the object. They just loved it. They were engaged and we found that our older kids, our second and third graders love to hear their own voice.
2:20:29 You have to ask them to get off the footsteps for brilliance. They never want to. They love it. Children that are engaged in education at a young age, they want to read. They want to show you they can read. They want to read to you. Then when they go to school, they want to learn. And they have a definite advantage over children that haven't been given that kind of a program.
2:20:56 The tablets that the students bring in, we are able to download Footsteps to Brilliant so they can work at home as well. And that is the magic. They don't have to have connectivity at their home. They don't have to have internet. They just bring their tablet into school and we can download it for them and then it becomes for everyone. My background, I was without a computer for a number of years and one of our big tasks back then was to try to integrate technology.
2:21:24 Footsteps of Brilliance is one of those programs that allows all of our children an opportunity to increase their reading comprehension and vocabulary as they come into the K-12 system. We want them to enjoy and understand the joy of reading and being able to see how
2:21:54 So we'll be making one of those videos as well. So maybe some of y'all will participate.
2:22:41 In it, I hope. So as you heard them say in the video, you only need Wi-Fi or Internet to download this program. Once it's downloaded, and it can be downloaded on Android phones, iPhones, Kindles, iPads, regular computers, it can be used in any kind of electronic format, then once it's downloaded, you don't need to have Wi-Fi to operate it. So we all have, well,
2:23:11 Cleland, I know we have made trips to Costco or down south with our kids in the back of the car and anything that you can get to entertain them so you can get to where you're going safely is a great thing. This is a perfect way to bring literature and literacy games and skills to our kids while you're just driving in the car if that's what you're doing. So let's check out the app.
2:23:42 It's really fun. I played this, I had my, I teach a class at Mammoth High School, juniors and seniors. I showed this app to them. They were over, they loved it. They were so excited about it. They wanted to know, why didn't we have this when I was a kid? And 16 out of 19 of them are English learners. So they really thought this was great. And so when they go down to the elementary school, they want to know why it isn't.
2:24:11 Why aren't we doing Footsteps to Brilliance now with our kids? Well, they're having that opportunity now. So this is loading. The other nice feature about this app is that any device you load it on, it looks the same. The interface is always the same. So kids are familiar with it. They know exactly where to go. And if you've ever seen a kid with a piece of technology, they're not afraid of it.
2:24:41 They come out of the womb and they're ready to just type, where's my iPhone? You know, right away. So, um... I.T. had to come to my rescue, it's true. You grew up with an abacus, admit it. Yeah. And I still know how to use that abacus. That's a good thing, too. Okay, so what you're seeing now, this is the first login page.
2:25:11 And it's very easy to get into. I'm going to log in right now. And every student gets a super secret code. And they're always called super secret codes. There is no Spanish for super secret code. So even in Spanish, that's what it's called. And that's their own personal code. The codes come in pictures of animals. So kids don't have to remember letters. They can just remember my code is panda, camel, rabbit.
2:25:53 Goat. Sorry. Cow. You'll see at the side of the screen, there are red, yellow, and blue. Those are the levels of the program. We don't assign a grade level to this app. It's more like reading level based. So the red is the emergent literacy. It's the very beginning levels for kids that may be.
2:26:17 Don't know their ABCs or, you know, they can't read at all. They can't sound out words. The yellow level is for your beginning readers, kids that know their letter sounds or, you know, almost learning all of their letter sounds. And then the blue level is for you're not quite fluent readers, but they're almost there. And so the content in that level is quite a bit more than at the early level.
2:26:47 I just, I have to show you. So in the early level, the red level, they have karaoke nursery rhymes. And research shows that kids who start kindergarten knowing eight nursery rhymes have a better chance of being on grade level at the end of kindergarten. So we want to make sure that kids know eight nursery rhymes. This is what a library page looks like. So there's a whole bunch of different nursery rhymes.
2:27:16 I'm going to choose The Itsy Bitsy Spider because it's my favorite. There are always four stars under every book at every level that read a book. The book buddies is the comprehension games that go along with that story, which are leveled and progressive as kids learn more. There are games that are all tied to that story that are literacy-based games. And then there's a create a book where kids can write their own story.
2:27:45 But I'm going to just show you this right now, very quickly. So this is the Itsy Bitsy Spider. There's my little microphone. The Itsy Bitsy Spider, illustrated by Jamie Weinbaum. Okay, so you get the idea. Now, what if I realize, oh my gosh, I don't speak English.
2:28:32 Because we all just realized, oh my God, we don't speak English, we speak Spanish, so I'm going to click on this button right there, and now we're going to sing in Spanish. Okay, now.
2:29:07 If Bill decides he wants to record himself because he's having a Grammy winner moment, he can click on the red microphone button and press that and he can record himself singing or reading right along. That recording could be emailed to his family members or his teacher or whomever.
2:29:36 So they can hear them read. It's a great thing like for parent, you know, parents can email the grandparents. This is your grandchild reading, all that. The other piece that's really nice is that the pictures are animated. So if I'm going along and I want to see what each piece of the picture is, I can just go back to English. Also, if I want to
2:30:11 I know how to read. I don't have to have them reading to me. I want to sing it by myself. And I get to, let's see, the itsy, bitsy, and then I don't know this word. I can click on it. I don't know why it's not. Well, I can click on it when it's working. And it highlights the word and says spider. And it tells me that word. And then I can just go along reading. So that is just an example of how this works.
2:30:44 Now, do I click the X? Okay. Okay. So that's just a brief demonstration of the app. Other states across the country have already employed and implemented this program. In North Carolina, they've had tremendous results. First grade word recognition increased by 40% of their first graders using this program. Fluency increased and reading levels increased.
2:31:16 In Manassas Public Schools, they did this, that's in New Jersey, they used this program for 20 minutes a week, and their kindergartners exceeded proficiency level. For the economically disadvantaged kindergartners, they exceeded proficiency level by 42% at the end of the year. So tremendous growth for those kids.
2:31:41 And Napa County was the first county in California to implement Footsteps to Brilliance. That was back in 2011. All students who used this program, and they implemented this at the preschool level, increased from 11% at the beginning of preschool to 76.4% at the end of the year in their comprehension, their reading comprehension. And their first graders also had much...
2:32:10 Higher achievement levels. Other counties in California that are using this program, you saw Calusa, I mentioned Napa, San Bernardino is one of the newer implementers, Santa Clara and San Benito are also implementing this program. We have started training our teachers in the county, Mammoth Elementary School, we...
2:32:33 Well, when I made this presentation, we had six teachers trained. We've trained two more since then. Bridgeport, Lee Vining, and Antelope Elementary, all their K-2 teachers have been trained and are using the program. I want to show you this because it's quite amazing. So one of the pieces of this program that we pay for is the data.
2:32:58 So because I'm the superintendent of the county, I can see all the data that's being tracked by this program of how it's being used, not only in our schools, but by our community members as well. So I can pull up this report, and I've been doing it every morning because it's so much fun. Sorry, I have to go through this again. Oh, good. Okay, so down here...
2:34:07 And this is just for the administrators and the teachers, obviously. There's an administrator's resources tab. So all I do is I go to find my schools. This gives me the overview of the whole county. So I can see everybody who's using the program in the county. Now I want to point out that we just trained teachers the week of March 6th. That's not that long ago.
2:34:34 Bridgeport Elementary School has already had students read 512 books. Mammoth Elementary School was trained on March 7th and March 8th. They have read 365 books already. The kids who have read those books have been exposed to 103,000 words that they might not have been exposed to otherwise. It's pretty amazing.
2:35:03 Because the group that we're trying to hit is we're trying to hit those groups, those kids that are maybe already behind in reading and maybe who don't have access to literacy at home. That's really our target population. So it's pretty amazing. People are community users who have signed up for this program. I signed up a couple people at Gary's office last week.
2:35:29 And the community members who I've signed up have already read 95 books. It's really kind of an addictive program to use, and it's quite a lot of fun. But this is how we can track, is this program being successful? So this program...
2:35:53 As an educator, I feel it's a game changer. It's a game changer for our families who otherwise would not have access to literacy. It's a game changer for our kids that maybe just holding a book is not doing it for them. We live in the 21st century now. Our kids are used to using technology every day, all the time. We can put something in their hands that's going to improve their literacy abilities.
2:36:22 Which in turn is going to improve their education and then improve the quality of their life. I hope you will see the value of this program like I do. I gave Jamie a copy of the How to Get Started if you want to register yourselves and play around with this app. Jamie has a copy of How to Do That. It's very simple. Oh, and I forgot to mention the best thing about this. It's free. It doesn't cost.
2:36:53 Anything for people to use it. Families can have up to, well, three licenses per parent in a household. So they could get all their kids licenses to use this app. They can have it themselves. And that's another brilliant thing about this program.
2:37:15 I'll use myself as an example as a parent. So my younger daughter was in the dual immersion program at Mammoth Elementary School. When she got into fourth and fifth grade, they were doing content in Spanish. So lots of academic language in Spanish. She's a skier.
2:37:34 So she would miss afternoon instruction during the ski season two days a week, and then she'd come home and say, Mommy, I have to do my science work in Spanish, and threw me into a panic, because I speak great Spanish for going to a restaurant and ordering a dinner, but I don't speak academic Spanish. If I had had this program, I could have used that blue level.
2:38:03 To look up books in the content area, which would have helped me help her with her Spanish instruction. In the same manner, if we have native Spanish-speaking parents who aren't literate in English or maybe aren't even literate in Spanish and they have young children, they can bring their child up to the couch with them, put on this app in Spanish and have the
2:38:32 App read a book to them. And so they're learning while their child is learning. And that's just great for everybody. So that's my presentation. Do you have any questions? Thank you, Stacy. That was great. I think it's above my grade level. I was hoping you were going to get up there and sing.
2:39:01 Is there any hardware that's going to be provided through this program? Are there specific units that they make for their product? This is an app. So it's just an app? It is just an app. And one of the ways that we are going to try to help...
2:39:20 People in the community to access the hardware that they might need is that we're going to be asking for donations of people to give us their old phones or their old iPads that they're not using anymore. Once they're wiped clean, which my tech department will take care of, this can be loaded and then they're free to be handed out to use as people need them to. So look for that gas gun, buy, sell, Mammoth.
2:39:49 My understanding is there's a grant. Yes. Yes, sir. Thanks for asking. So this is a grant-funded program, and we received the last grant that the Obama administration gave out, and literally the last one. We were working with the attorneys right up to December 31st to get all of the contract language dialed in that everybody felt comfortable.
2:40:18 The grant, we are responsible, Mono County Office of Education is responsible for paying for 750 licenses, which costs a little over $300,000. With that also comes the training, support materials, media assistance if we need that. The data piece is all a part of that cost.
2:40:47 The grant pays for all the rest of the licenses for anybody in the county who wants to access it. And the only requirement is that you have to have a Mono County zip code. And how much is the grant for? It was $5 million. $5 million. Yeah. Right. Yeah. We were very, we were competing with four other counties. So we were really lucky. Yeah. At that last minute.
2:41:15 Because at this point, it's all up in the air, what's going to happen. And how, is there a time? It's for five years. Five years, okay. All right. And how many licenses does the 300,000 get? 750. And that, those for our kids. Those go, those kids have the priority for that. How's that? For five years. Oh, so that's 370 per year, or? No, no, the, the,
2:41:45 We, our cost is $300,000 for the five year, you know, over the five year period. Over the five year period. Gotcha. But it's 270 licenses. 750. I mean, 750 licenses. Yeah. And how many students are falling under that right now? Well, that's, oh, right, we're going to get everybody. Oh, okay. We're going to train everybody. We're just doing it piecemeal. Okay.
2:42:11 Stacey, if you touch on that, though, there's additional licenses for the community. Correct. So I'm playing with one. So like Dan has a license. So his license is covered by him. He has it. Look at it. He does. And I checked his date. I can drill down so far that I can see what Dan is doing. And Dan's read a lot of books. He's improved a whole level already. Fabulous.
2:42:39 Yes, the grant picks up all the rest of the licenses in the county. And as I said, it's not just the licenses, but it's the data processing. It's adding the content all the time. The website's being updated, or the app is being updated all the time. Collecting the data, reporting the data.
2:42:58 The Footsteps to Brilliance people are located out of Washington, D.C., and so we had two of them out here for a whole week, the week of March 6th. They're coming back April 10th, and then they'll be back again. We're hoping to do the, or we're planning, not hoping, we're planning to do the big community rollout on June 3rd at Shady Rest along with the health and safety fairs. So they're helping us.
2:43:28 Plan that and all of the promotional materials and all of that stuff. That's part of the fees. And so I assume you're looking for financial partners? Yes. Let me speak to that as we've had different discussions on it and I was introduced to the program a while back and then some of the strategic planning and follow-up and been able to go on and play with it. So I'm a big video game guy. This is kind of...
2:43:57 Anyway, the element on that was a couple things. One is because of what the school's funding for the students, but also to get the community-based part to where everybody in Mono County can log in and have that. And the whole goal on that is how do we connect the literacy activity with these children tied in with their families and see that connection of literacy. I don't know how many of you grew up with reading books or library read programs, et cetera, and you had access to this material.
2:44:25 Some cases we don't have access in the community. Other times there's language barriers at the adult and children level. And the nice part about the program is it really transcends that issue. Also saw it as an opportunity for us to add maybe another little element into some of our own rec programs. If we have that need, here's a way to help during the summer, if you will, or other elements. We do other types of game issues. Here's something, different elements that the town has to roll on that.
2:44:52 The other side of that was how do we do the outreach into daycare, into at-home schools and things that maybe not be as connected into the school district, if you will. How do we do that outreach? And while we're more Mammoth-centric on this, frankly, the outreach throughout all of Mono County is really powerful in terms of what it can do. Like the fact that you can actually download the app, you can go spend two weeks in Mexico, you come back, once you hook the Wi-Fi again, everything uploads and the data is all there for Stacey to look at.
2:45:19 You don't have to be connected to do that. So there's some powerful stuff there. I think it links into a number of things the town's been working with. One is just the digital and technology component, digital need 395, et cetera. How are we utilizing that in our community? How are we connecting our families? We have a lot of discussion on how do we outreach, in some case, to our Hispanic population. This is one avenue for us to do that through some of our programs as well as the school systems of that nature.
2:45:48 It seemed to be a natural marriage between the work that the school district is doing and a lot of things that town is engaged in in some of our other program areas. The request basic is looking at help with the grant match requirement. We talk about leveraging funding for, I think it was $370 for the community side for a $5 million grant and stuff. It seemed to be a pretty good leverage in terms of dollars.
2:46:10 The request that we talked about, frankly, for the town would be looking at a $50,000 one time over the five-year period. It's not $50,000 a year. It's a confusing part of the staff report. Or like $10,000 a year for five years, basically. So what we'd like to be is to have that come forward as part of the budget discussion with the town council. Understanding what the program is here I think helps that discussion down the road so we're not playing itsy-bitsy spider for you, although we'll be glad to do that. I haven't.
2:46:38 The other element to that would be looking at that and the option for the council obviously could be a one-time here's a $50,000 commitment or here's a commitment over five years of X dollars and that could move around from that perspective. But in looking at the program, I'll look at a lot of these and some are really powerful. This one was really unique, I think, in how it connects beyond the school district into the community. And so that's one of the reasons we're here to...
2:47:06 Present the program and to, you know, unless there's no desire on the council to look at as part of the budget process, we would incorporate that into that funding process with the budget, either one-time dollars or commitment over time. Is the county going to be involved in this at all? Mono County? Yes. Yes. There's other partners that are stepping up already, I think.
2:47:28 So you can speak to that. Yeah, so the fire department is one of our supporters. Right now is kind of like my road show, going to everybody. We have already met with the mountain.
2:47:42 And we're waiting to hear from them. I'm meeting with the Indian Colony in Bridgeport in two weeks. I've met with Leslie already, Chapman, to talk with her about this. So the hospital, Gary. So we're really reaching out the school districts, of course. So we're trying to leave no stone unturned. Right. Great. I mean, I think...
2:48:10 Yes. I was just wondering, and I understand why with the English and the Spanish, but can this be modified in case if a child wants to learn another language, or is it just Spanish-English? Right now, well, the app is created by the folks in Washington, D.C., and it's just Spanish and English right now. I wouldn't be surprised if they're looking at adding more languages down the road, but right now they want to do this, and they want to do it really well.
2:48:38 And they want it to be seamless. And one of the really nice things about this is, and we had several native Spanish speakers comment when they heard the Spanish that's used in the app, how it is a native speaker that's singing the songs. And that's really, really important. So the Footsteps to Brilliance people are going to continue what they're doing for now.
2:49:06 So they really do it well. And they don't leave any, they don't want any glitches. And so somebody else asked me if this is going to be expanded to also for higher levels of reading. And the response was the same. We want to do what we're doing right now really, really well. And they really are trying to meet that need of early learners and kids who might not otherwise have access.
2:49:36 Colin, do you have a question? So Dan, just to clarify, that's what we're being asked tonight, is whether we're willing to engage in this as part of the budget discussions. Budget process, yeah, that would probably come back to it. It's not about funding, it's whether we want to put it. So if you want to discuss as part of the budget, yeah, if you don't, then I would bring it forward.
2:49:56 I'd like to see it discussed as part of the budget process. I'm good with that. I think everybody, I think we have consensus to do that. Thank you all. All right. Thanks for your time. Thank you very much. Any comments from the public on this? If any parents want me to sign them up, I'll meet you at the computer. I'm signing up right now, but can I use a different name so you can't track my progress? Yes, absolutely. Whatever you're comfortable with.
2:50:25 All right. Thanks, y'all. Appreciate it. Thank you very much. Thank you. All right. Yeah. Great program. Okay. With that, we move on to staff presentations. Jennifer, I believe you're up. It's Mammoth Lakes 2011 Housing Needs Assessment Update and Housing Action Plan's scope of work to be undertaken by WSW Consulting. Oh.
2:51:16 I don't want it to. Oh. Then I'll never get it on my iPad. Hi. Thanks for your patience. Jennifer Halperty, Mammoth Lakes Housing. So I want to introduce WSW Consulting. That's Wendy Sullivan. But first I just want to just talk real briefly about the endeavor. And we had a really successful
2:51:41 Workshop today with our housing working group and a lot of public. It was great. Well over 30 people attended. We have probably about 14 people on the housing working group or so. Great representation from throughout the community. We still look to expand it a little bit, trying to find a Hispanic, a Latino community member to serve on the housing working group. Otherwise, I feel like it's pretty well-rounded. So that's a great success. Great feedback.
2:52:11 What we're doing is, you know, you probably remember in December, Rusty Gregory came before you and Kirk Stapp and said, well, let's look at a way to do some studying of what's going on and some strategizing on how to solve for our affordable workforce local housing conundrum that we find ourselves in this winter. And so part of that is updating the 2011 workforce housing needs assessment.
2:52:40 Wendy was involved in that, and Melanie, another consultant on the team that's working on the current update. But a lot of things have changed since 2011, and I talked about that today. We're grappling with a nightly short-term rental explosion that we didn't have then. Our economy has changed a lot since then, so there's a lot to look at.
2:53:06 To update and really solidify what our need is. And then the second phase that we will start right after we finish the needs update will be an action plan. So identifying the need is great and really solidifying that and getting community involvement in identifying that need is one part of it. But the more exciting, well, it's all exciting, but the part that we haven't ever done before is coming up with this strategy that has real actionable items.
2:53:35 to solve for the need, and that will involve a lot of community participation, but I'll let Wendy talk more about that. I know she wants to go over the scope with you, but with that I'll hand it over. Thank you. Thank you, Jennifer. Thanks.
2:53:54 Yeah, thanks, and you can thank me. I'm not going to sing my presentation. And I know some of you were there this afternoon, and so this is really going to be the Cliff Notes version of what you heard earlier, since we have even less time to present the 15-page scope that we put together. But I do want to introduce myself and the team a little bit, and I want to say, too, if I can figure out...
2:54:22 I want to say, too, that we are very excited for this go-around of this update. As Jennifer mentioned, we have been involved in helping you identify housing needs in this area really since early to mid-2000s. The first study we did was a regional study for Inyo and Mono County, looking at their housing needs and the housing needs for the region. The next update we did was of the housing survey that we had done for the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:54:48 And then we did the housing needs update for the towns, specifically for the town of Mammoth Lakes, or focusing on the town in 2011. In all of those instances, really what was asked of us was to provide you the data, provide you the information of what are our needs. What we're really excited about this time is that you want to take it the next step and identify a community housing action plan to actually
2:55:15 Address those needs and figure out the steps you need to take to make it happen. And as I mentioned before, or this afternoon, we do this work because we want it to be used. And we design it to be used. And we design it to have an impact. And so the fact that you're looking to move forward and implement it got us excited to do this again. So anyway, I just wanted to mention that. And to say I am not
2:55:44 The only person doing all of this. We have a team of, we actually put together a team in light of wanting to do the action plan that retains our core analytical and technical skills of identifying the housing needs, but supplements that with people that are very knowledgeable of housing strategies and implementation, that are very knowledgeable of
2:56:07 Running and operating affordable housing programs as well as developing affordable housing because we felt that was important to have the practical experience as well to help you carry forward. We also have a facilitator for this process because we do have a 14 person potentially to be larger working group that we are working with and so having a facilitator to help coordinate communications and meetings is going to be is
2:56:36 And that's Steve Frisch with the Sierra Business Council. He's actually at the El Foro meeting right now, so he wasn't able to be here tonight. But that being said, so myself, I've been doing this for almost 20 years, focusing primarily on mountain resort communities in the Mountain West.
2:56:58 And resort in high cost communities. Melanie Reese of Reese Consulting, she's been doing this for over 30 years. For some communities, we've been helping them develop their housing programs for a couple of decades. So it's been great to be able to see programs as they evolve and know what works and what doesn't. She's actually, Melanie's going to be, her core role is going to be looking at your existing housing program.
2:57:27 Understanding how it's operating, how well it's working, where challenges are, where opportunities are, so that that will help feed into strategies moving forward on what's working and what changes might be needed. She's also going to be helping with a peer community comparison section, which I will talk about as well. As we said, we've worked in most of these communities, so we have a lot of knowledge that we feel can benefit.
2:57:55 Willa Williford, she actually used to work for the Boulder County Housing Authority. She helped manage the programs and also do outreach for their programs. And so she's really going to be helping with outreach for this project as well as helping with the core research and analysis and strategy development. And then Christine Walker, she was...
2:58:15 She's the former housing director for the Teton County Housing Authority in Jackson, Wyoming. They have a very complex program, but she was in charge of managing projects as well as developing them, and since she's been on her own as a consultant, she's worked with both private developers and non-profit and public developers to produce affordable housing and housing for locals.
2:58:44 So really quick, we already pretty much brought up the purpose of the study. One is to update your housing needs, and so we'll be doing that in phase one, which is what's being kicked off today. That's really looking at more than just your needs, though, which is what we did in 2011. We'll also be looking at your accomplishments, your opportunities, and constraints in the community. That will all feed into part two, which is where you look to the action plan. In the action plan,
2:59:13 We are going to be helping you with the help of the working group establish housing priorities and goals for the community so you can track progress over time in meeting those goals. Prioritize strategies and policies according to those goals that you need to meet. Financing options. What kind of opportunities are out there that you can look to help finance each of those strategies. Responsibilities. Mammoth Lakes Housing can't do it all. The town can't do it all.
2:59:42 Employers can't do it all. But working together, you can address a lot. And so it's really going to be identifying who's going to be responsible for what components. And then a timeline. Some things can happen fast. Some things are going to take a while. So understanding what your priorities are, what you need to start doing first, what can happen now, and what's going to happen down the line. So in part one,
3:00:10 What we're doing first and foremost is updating the 2011 Needs Assessment. So as we did in that study, we will in essence be identifying what your housing needs are for locals based on income level and ownership and rental. And we'll be looking both at the low income, middle, and upper income levels. And really what that, what will shift is because, well, we're going to be looking at the changes in the market since 2011 to today.
3:00:38 Housing prices have gone up since then, so chances are that the affordable point at which the market is hitting has gone up. We will adjust the income levels accordingly to where that gap is that's not being served by the market. Beyond the needs assessment, because we're going to be doing an action plan, we're doing several other components. We have the short-term rental impacts, which, as Jennifer mentioned, wasn't a significant concern in 2011.
3:01:09 And so we're going to be looking using existing data and town data, TOT data, and also some data scraping that they're going to be doing to help map where those units are, help you get an initial inventory of where your short-term rentals are, and understand in general what the impacts have been on the community in terms of units lost, et cetera. We are going to be borrowing, excuse me, on data from a concurrent
3:01:36 Mono County study on housing that's being done. They're doing a survey, both of Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes, and some of those questions will help us feed into some of these impacts as well. We're going to be looking at the existing housing program and policies, in-depth analysis of the programs and policies and housing units with Mammoth Lakes Housing that has on the ground, IMACA, taking a look at employer units, et cetera.
3:02:06 That kind of thing. So we understand what you've done and where you need to go and what more you might need to do. We'll be looking at the housing resources, opportunities, and constraints. This involves looking at the land capabilities and capacity, so build out capacity of the community. So we'll be looking both at vacant land redevelopment potential under current zoning as well as potential annexation.
3:02:36 So that we understand where some of the opportunities are to produce more housing. Also be looking at your capacity in terms of organizations that are currently in place. I mentioned a couple. As well as existing staffing and financing that you have.
3:02:53 We'll also be looking at your development environment. This includes looking at your current development requirements, codes, and fees, speaking with developers, stakeholders, and the town to understand the constraints and opportunities developing particularly locals and affordable housing in the community. And then finally, we've proposed to do a peer community comparison, taking a look at in-depth at the housing programs that are in place in up to five
3:03:24 Peer Resort Communities. And we presented a list of eight that we are initially starting with at the town this afternoon to get an idea if there's additional that we should add. But basically what we're looking at is areas starting out like Breckenridge, Telluride, Park City, Jackson, Vail, Steamboat.
3:03:53 Communities that are in Crested Butte, communities that are in like resort, primarily resort areas that have very much of the same housing issues and problems that you're encountering. What we like to say is every community is unique, but no community is alone. For any problem that you have in your housing, you can find another community out there that's struggling with the same thing. And so we think there's great opportunity that you can look to others and how they've addressed it.
3:04:23 To get ideas of how you can address it here. Of course you'll have to change it. Of course you'll have to tweak it. But at least it'll help open the box to concepts that are out there. So then the Community Housing Action Plan is what will kick off after we've collected the data, analyzed the data, understand your needs, your opportunities, your constraints. And so we'll go into depth in more detail in this when that kicks off.
3:04:54 In essence, it'll have a kickoff session that explains the process. And we'll have up to four work sessions that are going to be two hours each with the housing working group with a couple of weeks in between so that we can do data processing and set up what's needed and the research that's needed to set the stage for the next policy or the next work session. But basically, as I said, we'll be establishing policy goals and objectives, taking a look at your existing policies and strategies.
3:05:23 Figuring out what's working, what's not, what might need to be changed and what the priorities might be. Looking at new policies and strategies. Where are the gaps? What are you not serving today? What can you do to help serve that tomorrow? And then establishing financing, timeline, and responsibilities for achieving each of those identified strategies. So as I mentioned, we're going to be using a housing working group.
3:05:53 It currently has 14 members of key stakeholders in the community. We're looking to add a few more. And through data collection, we're doing extensive interviews. We're going to be doing focus groups with realtors and lenders and property managers, interviews of employers, stakeholders, town, county, et cetera. We'll be looking at other studies and data that you already have in the community.
3:06:24 A big reason why we didn't propose a survey as part of this process is that, as I mentioned, there's the Mono County study going on, and they're doing a survey of your residents. You start getting too many surveys in the field, you compromise response on all surveys that are out there. People can get inundated.
3:06:45 With questions. And honestly, they've answered questions on housing a lot. You also have the Connect Mammoth Lakes that recently did a survey that asked people housing priorities and housing needs. We are going to borrow on all that information because that's important outreach that should be used. And we can use it in this study. We'll also, of course, be using local information, assessor and GIS data, planning and building department, the TOT data.
3:07:13 Secondary information to the extent that it's usable and reliable for this community. American Community Survey is not, depending on the measure, is not terribly reliable for small communities. We never like to rely on it. That's why we do so much local outreach and trying to get the local tempo of what's going on because that's really how you figure out what the data and information is telling you. And then, of course, employment data.
3:07:42 We also have a project website that will kick off, and I have some postcard handouts that will kick off next week, and that will really be mostly for information about
3:07:57 Thank you.
3:08:22 And then media outreach. So we're going to be doing at least three newspaper and radio postings in English and Spanish throughout phase one and the same through phase two. Really to promote the study, let people know we're out there, give interim information on what we're discovering, and then advertise the website and solicit input. So this doesn't happen overnight. We're kicking off now.
3:08:57 We will have a draft report submitted in about three months, which is quick, actually. We'll have that done in June, early June, and that will be presented. The final report, the draft report will be reviewed by everyone in the working group, get feedback and finalize it. We will be presenting that in a public presentation in July on the 19th. The day after that, we will be doing the kickoff for phase two.
3:09:26 So July 20th. And the reason why we want to do that is we want all the data and information to be fresh in people's heads when they start into the planning process. Because if you delay that knowledge, you have to fill it back in. People tend to forget what the data said. So this way they'll have the information and then we can move immediately into the kickoff for part two to start talking about what we can do about it. And then part two again.
3:09:57 Thank you so much.
3:10:33 Mammoth Lakes regarding housing in three words or less, which I thought was great. But really, you know, it would be helpful for us to understand from each of you to what extent you really feel that this is a problem in the town and then what you really need from this study to move forward. Thank you. Do you hope to get that tonight? You can email me.
3:11:04 Post it on the website. So let's go to any questions for Wendy or Jennifer. Okay, I'll just, a couple things. My name is John Wentworth. I'm the Town Council Representative to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. Just so you know, I'm going to give you some expositional stuff so you just kind of know some background kinds of ideas. Very concerned about the workforce housing issues.
3:11:33 A couple key points, just this may be stating the obvious, and I may speak a little bit for the council in terms of some expectations, but I think a primary goal is going to be that when we're done with all this, that we're not, that we have beaten every, we have unturned every rock, every corner, we've used every possible creative tool that we have to come back with something new.
3:11:59 We can't physically
3:12:27 It's unrealistic to say, talk about physically growing. So repurposing our physical environment is going to be a key challenge for this community for the next 100 years, next 500 years. We have to turn the soil over. I just want to make sure that you're aware that that's a key constraint. It may be an opportunity as well. Number seven in the scope of services, part one, talks about the short-term rental impacts.
3:12:53 With this, it's looking at short-term rentals, but it's also really getting to the question of the housing stock. And that's a key thing that I think we've talked a lot about, is understanding what is the housing stock that we have available to address these issues, which gets into repurposing those other kinds of issues. But I think this is another thing. And its utilization. And its utilization. I mean, this is a new, this is a sort of a new concept we're bringing to the table at this point.
3:13:18 What do we do with the housing stock that we got? How can we repurpose that and do those kinds of things? The connection with technology with number seven, the town is going to be maybe considering some robotic tools that could provide you another data source that would help. It ties into the TOT compliance stuff. There may be a good nexus there of some data development. The federal landscape, I think it's going to be very important. Things are going to be changing over the next six months.
3:13:48 The thing that I heard is that the new head of the Housing and Urban Development Department, they want to cut $6 billion out of the budget. And I think some of the grants, I mean, it's been sort of an adage in this community, oh, we'll go get a bunch of grants for this. I think it's going to be very important for everybody to understand that all those grants may be evaporating. And I think the issues of self-reliance and the issues of us being able to turn to our own resources to make these things happen, you know, these are the kinds of...
3:14:13 Things that we need to come back to us. We can figure out what we're going to do about them. But I think that within the six months of the study, we're going to know where the Fed's going with all this stuff. And if those things are evaporating, OK, we've got to know that and figure out what to do about it.
3:14:27 And finally, we talked a little bit about entrepreneurship, and I sent you an email about that. But I thought about that a little bit afterwards. I would consider anybody in this town who's working more than one job as an entrepreneur. And what that person is trying to do is that person is trying to cobble together enough income so they can live in a unique and beautiful place, which is Mammoth Lakes. The business that they're investing in is their own.
3:14:51 Participation in this landscape in this place. And I think we can work on further defining that, but I think...
3:14:57 We talked a lot about not just hearing a top-down articulation of what's needed, but to really talk to the local community, the workforce, who is, they're putting together two and three jobs to make this work, but those people are entrepreneurs. And the degree to which we can give them a place to land and live in this place, they're going to create the new businesses, they're going to create the economy and the culture and the future of the community. So just, we can talk about that further, and I think I've got some, a lot of good information at Telluride that can help with that. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. Anybody else?
3:15:27 Yeah, I just, I will reiterate real quick what I said earlier today. We have a huge housing issue, so it's very important to me. I don't think we can solve it all within the bounds of our urban growth boundary. So this is for those of you that weren't at the meeting today, for me to get your opinion on that. I think that this cannot be restricted just to the town of Mammoth Lakes. We have to look at solutions outside. There are even some properties that we have control of that are outside of our...
3:15:56 And I think it's very important that that is included in the overall picture. It is not just a mammoth-centric problem. Properties can be less expensive elsewhere. All of the peer resorts do it. So when you look at other resorts, I would also want to look at how they are using
3:16:18 Resources outside of their own town in doing that. And if Council can... If I did one thing to that, the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments has been exploring a variety of regional initiatives, and I think that...
3:16:31 If in the analysis that you guys get to the kinds of things that Bill's talking about, I think that there's a receptive and willing audience in that Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to start looking at these regional things, to start getting some real regional buy-in to address some of these things. So I would echo what Bill's saying, but also understand that there is an audience and a destination for these regional things.
3:16:53 That has its ears tuned to this that may be helpful to say. Well, it's a regional problem. And it is not a funded thing by the town of Mammoth Lakes or Mono County specifically. It's actually a mountain funded thing going on here. They donated the money. They don't have to be restricted to just in the town limits. We can look at the broader picture for once and fit it all in. Well, their employment base comes from all over the county. Absolutely. Yeah. Colin.
3:17:22 Just, you know, just a couple of general comments, which will kind of somewhat echo what's already been said, so it's nice that great minds think alike, or maybe feeble minds, I'm not sure. But, you know, just a couple of comments in general.
3:17:38 You know, one of the things that I'd be looking for out of this, you know, we talked a little bit earlier at the meeting about kind of the differences and nuances between, you know, different towns or even different states. You know, for example, Aspen has one of the largest affordable housing annual budgets. They were able to sneak a real estate transfer tax into, you know, their codes prior to that now becoming illegal in the state of Colorado. It's also the same in California.
3:18:06 You know, so they have certain tools maybe that we don't have, but we also have some statewide or maybe national-wide tools in this particular case, you know, cap and trade in the state of California.
3:18:16 AHSC funds, those type of things are unique to the state of California. So I think as part of this action plan, it would be really helpful if you guys as the experts on this could kind of just give us a better sense of what's the larger landscape, you know, as John was kind of alluding to, you know, what is happening with available funds in the state of California? Are those things, you know, increasing?
3:18:40 I think that would be a really helpful thing for us to get out of this effort. You know, I think secondarily, I just think that we're acutely aware here of what our land constraints mean. And so I think we really have to be thoughtful and creative about how we utilize our existing land.
3:19:09 Even if we were to take every inch of available land in this town and develop it with housing, it wouldn't be enough to house our projected needs at build-out. So we have to look at how we repurpose, potentially go up in stories. I think downtown revitalization is a really big opportunity for us as we look at available land and repurposing that land for housing opportunities.
3:19:34 So I think just getting a sense from you guys as far as experts on what's kind of going on in the broader landscape and then thinking about what makes us unique. And I think a big piece of that is our urban growth boundary and our land constraints. The last thing is you were kind of asking earlier about how to kind of tap into some entrepreneurial groups or those type of things. One thing that I was going to mention earlier and I can mention now is we do have...
3:20:03 A semi-dormant young professionals group here that kind of meets periodically on certain things and initiatives. So that might be a good way to kind of tap into the younger kind of business professionals in the town. And you had mentioned when you come back in April, if we kind of had lines in on some of those things. So just contact me on that. I'll see if I can.
3:20:26 You know, stimulate some interest to maybe, you know, get that group together. Sometimes, you know, 50 people will show up to a meeting. So, you know, that might be a good way to tap into some kind of the young entrepreneurs in town. So, just touch base with me on that and I'll try and give me a little lead time and I'll see if I can get that together a little bit. Yeah, the beauty is Colin lived it for a couple of years, right? Yeah, for sure. Yeah, great input.
3:20:50 I just have a question about evaluating the housing problems experienced by the workforce housing. Where are you going to get that information? Oh, and forced to commute? I think some people like to commute. Some don't. Yeah, exactly. So I'd be curious, I mean, is that all going to be broken down?
3:21:16 Yeah. With whom will you be speaking that have housing problems? Do you have a game plan for that? Yeah. So, well, for that, we'll be using a combination of sources. So we'll be using, well, both, so the needs assessment that was done in 2011 will be a base. We'll be doing interviews with employers, which are always a wealth of information about commuting and changes in those issues, primarily focusing on the larger employers but getting some of the smaller guys.
3:21:44 The reason why we like to hit the larger ones is because you can get, you know, talk to 10 people and you have 50% of the workforce that you're kind of accounted for in that, so it can be helpful. But don't forget, there is the Mono County Mammoth Lakes Housing Survey that is being fielded. That is asking questions like, where do you work, where do you live? That's going countywide. We're borrowing that information.
3:22:08 And we're actually going to have a meeting with the consultant that's doing that study next week to target how specific that information is going to be and how much is going to be available for the town. Ideally, we would have that information be representative of the community and the town. If we were doing the survey, that would be our goal. And that's what we did in 2011. We primarily used survey data to understand what commuting patterns were. And in that, you ask in-commuters,
3:22:37 Where do you want to live? Do you like, you know, where do you live now? And what is, if you could, if you ignore housing affordability, you know, if you could afford to live anywhere, where would that be? And so we got that number in 2011 from, and I don't remember what it is, but, you know, say, you know, 50% said, well, yeah, I'd rather live in Mammoth Lakes if I could afford it. You know, so that's where we get the information from.
3:23:04 Mainly is asking them, you know, and so, like I said, so we'll be using a combination, well, and there is secondary information out there on commuting patterns. Again, the challenge is that you're so small. Secondary information based on American Community Survey is just based on a small sample of residents in a large area. And so when you start drilling down to less than 20,000 people in a community, the accuracy tends to jump.
3:23:33 A lot. Or the inaccuracy does. And so we don't like relying on that. That's why we do so much local outreach. So it'll be a combination of secondary sources, local interviews, local information, using the 2011 survey and information where we need to, where we don't have something to change it or supplement it, and then using the survey that's being done for the Mono County Mammoth Lakes survey to the extent that we can to update that information.
3:24:00 Okay. And I'll go ahead and answer B right now. I feel housing is the utmost importance in Mammoth. And not just for people to buy houses, but to be able to come in and rent a house that fits their budget fairly well. They're able to work and spend a little time here to see if they want to make that commitment to buy.
3:24:25 Or if they're unable to buy to be able to rent and have some stability of life in this town. John, you had a couple. Yeah, just two quick things. I'm assuming that you'll be looking at EIFDs as a possible financing source. EIFDs. EIFDs.
3:24:48 Enhanced. Enhanced increment financing districts. Enhanced, okay. It's kind of the replacement for redevelopment agencies. We've had a number of other projects that may be heading for something like that. I think it would be very helpful for us to understand the viability of that and how that would fit into the mix.
3:25:04 And the other piece is, from an outreach perspective, who is the point of contact? Who do we send people to? Who do we get in touch with? Is it you? Is it Jennifer? Who is the identified point of contact for this project? So Jennifer is going to be the manager kind of between me and everyone else. So if I have information to get to you, she will do the send out to all of you guys. However, that being said, we will most likely be interviewing most of you.
3:25:33 As part of this process, in which case that would be us reaching out to you or vice versa. Or, you know, obviously if I specifically ask for something from you, then we'll just communicate directly. Well, if Colin's got an entrepreneur's group or some of us got a bunch of people, who do we put them in touch with? For the entrepreneurs, actually? Well, for anything. I mean, if we get, if we all of a sudden, the Hispanic community shows up tomorrow, we've got 45 Hispanic people that want to be engaged in this process. Who do we reach out to to say?
3:26:00 This is the person to get in touch with, and that person will reliably follow up with you, and they will engage you with the process. Who is that person? Reach out to Jennifer first, Jennifer and Patricia at Mammoth Lakes Housing first, and then if it's something she needs to field to us, she will do so. Okay, so Jennifer, Mammoth Lakes Housing, it's all going to Jennifer at Mammoth Lakes Housing. Okay. Thank you, I'm sorry. No, I'm very proud of the rest of council here. I think we're all...
3:26:27 On the same page there as far as our needs. We know that it is an issue, not just here, to your point, it's in other communities too. But, you know, we want to be proactive, and I think we are, and I think it's, you know, something. But I just, all I'd say above and beyond all that was said right here tonight is when you go out and get that information, make sure you get the diverse side too.
3:26:56 Because we need to know that side. Okay. What's good, what's not good about, you know, the development that's been done in the past. And so, no, I appreciate you doing this. I look forward to, you know, getting the data, the results, and figuring out, you know, how to move it forward. And I believe everybody's in consensus up here. We want to move it forward. So, all right? Good. That motivates us. Good, good. Because we want to move forward.
3:27:26 Is there any comments from the public on this? Any further comments? Please step forward. Brandon Brosha, short-time resident. I had a great experience yesterday in the building meeting that went down, talking about the FAR. Obviously, it was the big topic. I think there's a lot of tie-in here, and I really want...
3:27:56 Council to really look at this in depth. One of the big issues that came up, and I thought it was a great presentation, Sandra and their team did a great job, and I think it just needs to really be weighed with issues like this. When they're talking about the only way to develop with the FAR conditions that they're getting ready to impose, which it sounds pretty positive it's going to go in.
3:28:24 You're talking about $100,000 parking spaces underneath new development to create this underground parking, to create this bar. That does not sound like affordable housing to me. And I don't care what kind of commercial tenant you put on the base floor. When the cost of that building is at that level, you're looking at basic rentals.
3:28:48 For over one night stays, two night stays, three night stays, that's what the developers are going to be looking for, just like in the village. That is not going to benefit housing, affordable housing. And I get it, I love the image that we're trying to go for here. And I love the fact that we're talking about, let's develop up, let's build up. I think it's all great. But I think that there's a little equation there that's being...
3:29:15 Kind of overseen. There was a lot of discussion yesterday in that meeting about parking and a lot of demonstration of that parking being underneath these buildings, and it doesn't add up. I mean, it does not add up. You're looking at millions and millions of dollars of underground parking that do not translate to affordable housing above whatsoever. I know it displaces maybe some of the housing that's already in town, but at the same point, I didn't see that.
3:29:45 So I really want this issue. I think they all come together. I'm sure they're going to be looking at it on their side, too, when they start developing this. But I know there could be some overlap here because it sounds like this is going to come to a head before they come up to their conclusions. So I think as town council, you guys, you're going to be the stopping point on all this. You're going to be the ones that say yes or no, right?
3:30:13 I guess so. Well, I would just, but I would really encourage you that these efforts that we've launched, the walk, bike, ride piece, downtown revitalization, and this, you know, there are not silos. These things are all interrelated. Okay. And we are relying on the community and the public to help, you know, connect the dots, tie all these things together, because they are all related. Right. And we're not, we've had silo problems in this community, and we gotta, we gotta. But, but, but to your point, you know, you're right.
3:30:41 Underground parking is very expensive, and, you know, it'd be great if they did, but there are other alternatives there, shared parking and what have you, and that's what the walk, bike, ride is all about, is creating that vision of shared parking areas, so first community. And that's my point, is if you guys are under the understanding that the underground parking cannot be taken into that equation.
3:31:06 I hope you guys are looking at other parking solutions. I think we're pretty cognizant of that. For sure. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Brandon. Any other comments? All right. Thank you very much for the presentation. Thank you. Thank you. Good stuff. All right. We'll go on to item number five. Dan? Yes. Status update on strategic alignment goals throughout quarter three ending February 2017.
3:31:36 Yeah. After the Town Council and a number of our NGO partners and our JPA partner, ESTA, went through a process of strategic goals and alignment, laid this out, one of the elements on that was some ongoing reporting updates back to Town Council, so that's why it's on the agenda here. I don't plan to read through all of these, but touch on a couple of them.
3:31:56 But also just also we identified a lot of elements by quarters. Obviously things are sliding, some up, some back in terms of that capability to be able to move stuff forward. Also just unknown things coming up, kind of like the snow for January and February kind of changed everybody's focus for a little while. But there have been continued improvement and movement in a lot of the different areas. So I'm just going to touch on a couple and then open up for questions in there.
3:32:23 As we start to look at our airport and air services, it's continuing looking at employments, it's looking at seats, it's looking at funding for the capital projects in there. Some of that has been, you know, tied to FAA and some issues there, and then we've also started a regional discussion through ESCOG and others looking at airport services. One thing I will note for Q3 was new technology to decrease cancellations with the RNP.
3:32:50 I forget what that stands for off the top of my head here, but the... It's an approach deal. Yeah, it's reduced and required at just how they land electronically, you know, in terms of visibility and issues like that. We know there's been several flights that have landed that a year ago would not have landed without that. So that piece has been moving forward and is in place and is actually working.
3:33:12 You know, increasing our TOT shoulder seasons. Last year we had a record year in TOT in some months that were up that we were shooting for. We're on track again this year. It's amazing what 500 inches of snow will do as you look at those. Discussions obviously related to Mammoth Creek Park and some of the elements there. They're in here and some of that's moving forward. Again, that process has taken longer than anticipated, so some of those pieces will slide and move around a little bit within those elements.
3:33:42 We've also looked at how do we look at some of the economic elements in town. The economic study for MLT was completed as part of the TBID. That needs to be reviewed and integrated in some of the other work that's been done by the town to actually begin to look at those areas. We've also initiated and started to get a move quick and slowing down back and forth in some of the regional work with the county relating to trash, solid waste, and stuff. That's still...
3:34:06 Out there plugging along. It hasn't been coming back to Council yet for action, but work is happening. Solid Waste Task Force will be meeting in April and be some information going to them at that point in time. So there's a lot of headway in different places being made. Obviously, we set this a while back in time, and so reality of issues are pushing and pulling and moving them around accordingly.
3:34:28 With the last financial update, we begin to look at some of our reserves and those types of things, which was a financial policy strategy for the town. Coming into our budget process, that'll be a whole other discussion again of hitting some of those particular goals that council set for the town side. So those are just some highlights. Real quick, walking through that, there's a lot of detail in here, the various NGOs that provided input and stuff. There's some reps in the audience for those as well.
3:34:55 If you have questions, we can address those. But otherwise, we're trying to provide you at least, you know, here's a report, take a look. If you have questions, let us know type element. But we do want to maintain that ongoing periodic reporting element back to town council. All right. Any comments, questions for Dan? Oh, John. A couple of quick questions. I don't want to get into the weeds and all that stuff. There's a lot of them. No, that's not what we're going to do.
3:35:27 Questions about the next time we revisit this is probably late this summer, is that correct? Yeah, I mean, this is an 18-month program, so it'd be kind of falling into, you know, that tail end of this expiring, we'd be looking at an update. Okay, so I just want to make sure that we allocate enough time to review these things in a way that we kind of get everything up to speed so we get a baseline of things that there's a consensus for each one of these things.
3:35:54 Right. It's a quarterly update, right? Yeah, we bring a quarterly update in, but ultimately the sixth quarter here would be that September, November, so that time frame would be coming back and going, okay, what type of update do you want to go through? What type of process? Yeah, but I'd like to say, you know, at the end of June, first part of July, you know, where are we? Because I think there's going to be a lot. End of summer. Yeah, I think probably. End of summer, I think.
3:36:19 Good time. I'd like to make a point on that, on the whole thing, actually. Sure. This was a piece of work that was done by a previous council before two of us were here. And while I appreciate the work, and it was a lot of work for you guys, and I paid attention during it, it is still not something that was produced by all of us. If it's going to continue to be an accurate document, every time the council changes, there should probably be a workshop on it.
3:36:44 To make sure we were all on the same page and that all of these things should still be moving forward. For me to get an update and approve work that I wasn't a part of in the first place is a little odd for me. So rather than just the updates at some point, I would think we would need some sort of a workshop for us to go through the thing, not reinvent the wheel, but make sure that these are still the goals and objectives of the entire council. That's kind of where I was headed instead of waiting until September.
3:37:13 We can do that earlier. Let's do that earlier. Okay. I think it's going to take, that makes total sense. It's just a question of, it's going to take a little bit of time to get the representations in here to be accurate. That's going to take some time. And then this was not, this is not sort of a council workshop kind of a process. It's a little bit more involved in that. So I would assume after we get through the budget process, that's kind of digested. We've got a little bit of, I think probably sometime, whenever that window opens up. Yeah, I think.
3:37:42 Maybe towards the end of June. We can look at a time frame and meeting schedule. Right. And then what we'll do is, you know, at the end of September, at the end of the 18 months, you know. We'd have a new one. We'd have a new one. Right. So that sometime between June and September in that. Right, right. My comment really isn't for today. After the next election, I would hope that we would deal with it in a quicker fashion.
3:38:09 So that whoever, unless the same people are on. Right. And I think a lot of work has already been done. Now we just have to keep it going. Absolutely. But there needs to be an education process and a buy-in on whoever the new bodies are. Chances are in two years, it's not going to be all the same bodies sitting here. Colin? No comments? No comments? I'm on board with everything. Good. Cleland? Nothing to say.
3:38:35 All right. The second point is a key part we talked about was the integration of these efforts into the contracts of the NGOs. I know we haven't gotten there yet, but I'd like to know when do we think we're going to start doing that and what that process is going to look like because that's the council exercises its...
3:38:56 It's priorities, it's strategies, it's ultimately it's authority through those contracts with these NGOs. And I think we need to, we don't have to do that tonight, but I'm looking forward to understanding how that's going to work. Yeah, that's a great point. You're on MLH, right? You're on MLT, Colin? Right, yes. Okay, and I'm on MLR, I think it's. And has done a lot. Right, so I think it's tantamount upon us to keep pushing that forward. Yeah, right. Right? Yeah, sure. Right.
3:39:27 Anything else on that, guys? No, I think, you know, June, July timeframe, spend a little more time on this. Sounds good. All right. Good enough. Thank you. Well, that will move on to consent agenda. Oh, pardon me. Pardon me. We have a comment. I'm sorry. I have a comment, Mr. Mayor. Yes, please. Council, staff, members of the community. So how does this process with the strategic planning fit into the budget cycle? If these are our town priorities at this point in time, this should drive budget.
3:39:57 We're in the budget allocation cycle now, that holistic approach. If we're looking at these as priorities, there's got to be funds attached to these priorities. If we wait until after you do the budget allocation, where does this stuff fit? So my question is, what's the process in aligning funding with these strategic aspirations at this point in time? Thank you, sir. All right. I think they're listed here, and I think they should be very aware.
3:40:30 I think as we go through the budgetary process, I think each NGO has to look at
3:41:01 What the strategic priorities are, how they fit into them, and then how to fund these things and bring that back to Council. So that would be part of the budget cycle over the spring. So the NGOs then should look at their deliverables, put a dollar amount to it, and bring it back to the Council for consideration and recommendations. I would say so. Yeah, it's, I mean, from a work program, we have that with the town side of it going, hey, these elements get built into that. Some of it's not a hard dollar amount or they're.
3:41:31 Ask in some cases to exceed our budget. But I mean that process of knowing what those priorities are. We're giving dollars there. These should be put into those dollars going, yes, these are the priorities you've asked us to work on. Yes, we're working on them. If the issue is you've asked us to work on these priorities and you need to fund us up to work on it, then my question is what are we funding now that...
3:41:54 That internal shift, we've done that at the staff level, count at town level, is how do you take that and say, well, these are the priorities and we shift our work program accordingly to hit those versus just asking, because we did, we didn't, in fact, the beginning of this idea wasn't to pile on and be additive to a lot of work, but in some cases shifting things to a lower priority to move these up to a priority. I think that's, I think it's, and the NGOs can do that as well. Upon the NGOs to tell us.
3:42:20 And I just ask that question, not as an answer right now, but to begin to think of, you know, as I said earlier in the day, an inch wide and a mile deep versus a mile wide and an inch deep. What are the priorities going to be? Limited funding, limited human capacity.
3:42:34 How do we make that process work? So I've got some direction. Thank you. Richard, if I may, I view this a little bit differently. I think we put such a long and drawn out and comprehensive effort into establishing these strategic priorities that these are going to be the things that inform our budget discussion. And that's what I'm saying is whether we need to reevaluate that moving forward in the future, but this is an informing document to make sure that the budgetary decisions that we make
3:43:02 This spring aligning up for next fiscal year are in line with our strategic priorities. NGOs have to come back to us and have, you know, have to have input on saying, okay, are our budget numbers right? Right. You know, I don't want to say, hey, you get $12.15 to do this. You know, you have to come back and say, okay, if we're trying to achieve this, it's going to cost us this. So. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Appreciate it. Thank you.
3:43:29 Any other comments? You just, however, point out my point that two of us didn't make these priorities. Now in the budget process, I have to determine and go through this, are these my priorities when I'm looking at budgetizing the funds? Right. So it would be better to preload this in the future than... Any other public comments? CNN will move on to consent agenda. Excuse me, Mr. Mayor? Yes. If I just want to say something about...
3:43:58 The consent agenda. I want to give a compliment. Okay. On one, do I have to pull it or can we just go on? Well, you can make a statement if you want. Oh, okay. Just on number eight, the 2016 annual planning report, I would just, I think Nolan did that. I would just like to thank him because what you were talking about, Bill, that we weren't here for six months, I found that a really good document to look back and see where
3:44:28 The current town council or the past town council had what they had actually done and achieved. I would actually like to pull that item. Okay. Now that I've said something. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to pull number nine, please. Thank you. I was going to pull number nine also. So, Bill. Well, and then I'll make a comment without having to pull it off. I would also like to give a compliment on item seven.
3:44:57 You know, that's something we discussed, and, you know, town staff, particularly Rob and his department, was able to turn that around really quickly. You know, I thought about pulling it just to call it out. It was a very positive direction, but I think we can move it forward on consent agenda. I just wanted to thank town staff for pulling that around so quickly. I think that's a positive direction for us. I concur. Okay, I'm going to read the different ones.
3:45:23 Number six, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of March 1, 2017. Number seven, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance to amend Municipal Code Section 3.12 to allow a tax collector the authority to modify calculated penalty and interest under certain circumstances.
3:45:42 Number eight, acceptance of the 2016 Annual Planning Report. Number nine, authorize the mayor to sign a letter in support of Senate Bill number one and Assembly Bill number one regarding transportation funding. And number 10, accept payment approval reports number 17-07 and 17-08. We have pulled number eight and number nine.
3:46:06 So I will entertain a motion on 6, 7, and 10. I'll make a motion that we 6, 7, and 10? Yes. No, 6, 7, and 10. Second. Yeah, there you go. We have a motion and a second. It's good to go. Roll call, please. Yes, with an abstention on item 6. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The motion passes 5-0.
3:46:41 Number eight. John, you pulled it. Yes, I just had one. I second Cleveland's comments. I thought this was a very good, very easily readable report. Thank you very much for that. I just wanted to point out that looking ahead for major projects in 2017, the first item, continued work on the amendment to the North Village Pacific Plan regarding an increase of density for the Mammoth Hillside project. This was news to me. Maybe I missed something. But I just wanted to, if staff could give an update on what the status of that is.
3:47:13 Yes, we received an application for an amendment to the North Village Pacific Plan for the Mammoth Hillside project, and staff is working on that. We expect that to be before the council in May. Okay. So that's an applicant-funded project. And that will go through the PEDC first? Correct. Okay. And in terms of other, are there other updates to the North Village Pacific Plan going on as well? It's just the only one at this point? This is the only one at this point. Okay.
3:47:41 Thank you. That clarifies it for me. That was my question. Yes, thank you. So I'm prepared to make a motion that we accept item number eight, sorry, item number eight, acceptance of the 2016 annual planning report. Okay, I have a motion. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Two seconds, actually. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Bill, you pulled number nine. I did. Thank you, by the way, staff. Yeah, thank you.
3:48:11 Number nine was just asking for a letter of support for a Senate bill and in reading over some of that, and certainly I have not read the whole bill, part of what it's calling for I'm not sure that I am in favor of. It's asking for increased taxes basically to help fund the highway system and while I am in total agreement that the highway system of California, which used to be the gem of the nation, is in huge disrepair before I want to put a letter out there to approve
3:48:41 A 12 cent a gallon tax gas increase, which is what it does, partially, we should understand the effect that that could have on our own economy. We are primarily a drive economy, and the other side of it is until the state wants to pay back the money that they have absconded with from the dang accounts that are supposed to pay for our highways and start spending the full amounts that should be allocated today by previous
3:49:09 Tax measures, I'm not real willing to give them an increase of taxes that are going to affect primarily the poor and the driving tourists. Bill, you need to run for governor. Thank you. I would love to. Would you finance my campaign? Maybe this bill will. Yeah. Dan has some further.
3:49:32 We discussed this at LTC. We discussed this at every LTC meeting. I'm sure you may want to go first. No, I'm going to. And before, Dan, if I may, you know, just to piggyback on that, I also had a problem, you know, again, I haven't read the whole thing, but, you know, it's proposing a vehicle registration fee on zero emission vehicles. I'm not sure that's something that I support as well, you know, to me, if we're going to kind of move in that direction.
3:49:59 I'm not supportive of disincentivizing that. So for that reason, I was going to pull it myself. I think what we have through the legislature, there's a number of competing bills coming in for transportation. I think the key element here is the legislature is actually recognizing that they need to deal with transportation funding, whether or not they'll be able to.
3:50:25 I don't think it's been assigned a number yet, but AB Fong had a bill come out that really didn't deal on taxes, it shifted dollars. The governor's plan is similar to what a couple of the others are, but there are some differences. Then AB1 from Frazier and SB1 from Yale are similar, but there are differences. So this will be a classic, I think, watching sausage be made at the legislative level. I think you have a couple of options based on the comments.
3:50:51 One is just to take a position, the League of Cities will do this on issues, okay? This is an issue we're very concerned about. I didn't see anybody saying we don't need to invest more dollars in transportation. The question has been, where do those dollars come from? And then how are they allocated ultimately down to local levels and state levels? So you can take what the legal do on these types of bills at times, take a position of watch so they don't have a formalized position one way or the other, trying to figure out
3:51:21 Where is it going to land? You can also do a letter that would be more of a generic support letter for transportation funding. Maybe you want to see that done in limited tax elements, but the fact that it does need to get addressed, you know, I'm not sure we're going to have the biggest voice in this discussion regardless, but kind of looking at LA, San Diego.
3:51:46 Some other elements that way. So I think you can go either way on that. As we saw this come forward, there's been ongoing push at various levels to say, how do we fund transportation? There were bills last year that this was going to be a big push and failed in the legislative process. So there's a number of different elements out there. LTC had a separate bill, not so much with funding, but with assigning a rural person to the California Transportation Commission. That would be one we could bring back for support.
3:52:16 Also, just adding to the environmental review, there was a bill proposed to add wildlife movement across transportation infrastructure is one of the key elements you have to look at. Obviously, that would pack anything on 395 through here with the deer migration, et cetera. So some of those can be good elements, but they're going to impact communities differently across the state. So my guess is you're going to have a lot of diverse opinions coming in, tax, no tax.
3:52:41 The no-emission vehicles is a classic one. Yes, we want to push people toward those types of uses and drive that. They don't pay for the primary issue we use to fund our roads, so what point do we have? This isn't unique. We have a conflict in overall goals. Move away from fossil fuels, but that's the primary funder of this. So if we're really successful in doing that, then our roads, so.
3:53:07 There's going to have to be a whole lot of other debate on this. So I guess my question for the council would be, simplest, you could take a wait and watch and see what kind of comes out as maybe some commonality to the legislature and then determine whether we want to support, oppose, or be silent. Or you could have a letter that goes in, we support looking at enhanced ways to fund transportation. However, we have concerns in these areas. Right. So. Well, you know, this was brought up at LTC. It's a broad issue.
3:53:36 Originally, the LTC agreed on the AB1 and SB1, and that's why this letter was written. But it came up at the LTC that the FONG program, you know, it's different. And I think what you're going to see is you're going to see changes to a lot of different potential bills coming forward and, you know, trying to get it right.
3:54:04 Actually, I prefer the Fong bill, but I don't know if that's where it's going to end. I don't know your point of view. Well, the issue is that this is a fundamental institutional articulation of complete dysfunction at the state level. And so it may be better for us to take a wait-and-see attitude. I don't have a problem with that. But to send a letter of encouragement to the state.
3:54:33 I think more and more is going to come out as this moves forward. Yeah, they're going to get to something.
3:55:03 If they don't, then we can fire them. I think we acknowledge that our letter of support or being agnostic on this is really not going to dictate what comes out the back end. Oh, Colin. We have five differing opinions up here right now. If we're not emphatic about our support of something, it doesn't seem to me to make sense to do anything. I don't think we have five different opinions. I just don't think we're...
3:55:32 Let me rephrase that. There's not five people in support of this necessarily. That's the beauty. We're all in agreement. We're all in agreement. So why would we not move in a wait and see capacity? Well, I think it's wait and see or write a letter saying, hey, we believe transportation is a critical point. I'm good with either one. At this point, I'm good with just nobody making a motion and let me die.
3:56:01 We don't have to put a letter out there. We don't have to. We're saying there's probably 120 different opinions in Sacramento right now, the number of legislators we have. So, I mean, either one of those I'm comfortable with sending a letter saying, you know, we need to address this issue or just being silent for now. Do you think if we're silent on it that they're even going to notice that? Yeah. Yeah, we're high on their list. The one body that someone might pay attention to is the LTC, and the LTC voted
3:56:31 They did their thing, and I think if we're taking a sort of wait-and-see attitude, kind of deferring to the wisdom of the LTC at this point, I think that that's... I concur. I prefer wait-and-see. Okay, we're going to do wait-and-see. You have a motion to act on, so don't act. Yeah, a motion not to act. Okay, we'll move on to... I have a comment on this item. Oh, pardon me, yes. I'm sorry.
3:57:00 I think it's great that you guys are talking about these bills. I was just in Sacramento last week. I actually had the pleasure of listening to Jerry Brown talk about some of the bills and housing at the 50th anniversary for the Western Center of Law and Poverty and lobbying with Barry Hill, Senator Barry Hill, no, Senator Bigelow and Assemblymember Barry Hill's staff.
3:57:26 On about some housing bills and learning about what's going on in legislation. They're moving very quickly right now on a lot of bills. They're beyond where they would normally be this time of year. There's over 100 bills on housing. And the SB1 that you're considering tonight is part of a package of about six bills that the Senate President De Leon
3:57:48 Introduced called California Rebuild. There's actually two bills in there for affordable housing, SB2 and SB3. If you're considering bills on infrastructure,
3:58:00 I would encourage you to consider bills on affordable housing. It's also something that needs to be funded, and we should be sending a message. So if you could look at those, I'd be happy to meet with you and talk with you about those. No, it'd be great. If you have recommendations, policy recommendations from Mammoth Lakes Housing, that'd be great to get them to the town, and we can entertain those. And then recommendations from Mammoth Lakes Housing to the town council. Great. As an advisory body, I think it's part of what we're supposed to be doing. Okay, great. Thanks. Thank you, Jennifer. Thanks. All right.
3:58:30 Any other comments? I apologize. Okay, that'll move on to policy matters. Number 11, resolution authorizing funding for Mammoth Lakes Recreation related to recruitment and selection of a new executive director. Tom, are you going to do this or Dan's going to leave it off? I can kick it off and hand it off to Tom. This is coming before you. As you're aware, the Mammoth Lakes Recreation is looking at a shift in their...
3:58:59 Focus on their Executive Director level. We've had a variety of discussions, and one of those elements was to move forward. The use of Measure R funds is probably not a legitimate, you know, proper use of those dollars to go out and do recruitment work. That's not one of the identified elements for that, so we're very cautious about doing that. In order to, if you want to go out for recruitment level of a firm, then that would require
3:59:23 If you have other funding, if you will, and so that request came through the town to take a look at that, and we've been part of the creation and ongoing work with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So I was bringing this forward from a policy item was to turn around and say, have Mammoth Lakes Recreationally speak to, and Tom can do this in terms of the need and the focus where they're shifting to, but then if we really want to have that type of level of recruitment activity, it probably should be funded out of non-measure R funds, and therefore the request before the town council.
3:59:53 All right. Thank you, Dan. Tom. Tom Johnson, President of the Board of Directors for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers, we are coming to the Council to basically assist us in a pivot that the organization is making. And I want to say from the outset that searching for a new Executive Director is a piece of that. But I want to say that that is not a reflection.
4:00:22 On our current executive director and our founding executive director. I want to make that really clear. Kind of Rich has done a great job getting our organization off the ground, building a solid professional foundation for us to kind of build on, bringing all of the kind of disparate stakeholders in our town that relate to recreation and arts and culture into a more professionalized conversation in an organized way.
4:00:52 Bringing real budget discipline to the way we're managing and allocating measures R&U. So we unanimously as a board are appreciative of the job he's done over the last couple of years. And this move actually comes from some conversations that Rich and I started back in November. We basically were asking the question, are the resources available to us?
4:01:19 And the skill set that we have within the organization, do they align well with the deliverables that we need to meet contractually with the town and also our larger vision? And the answer we came up with was no. We have, like I said, done a great job kind of in our silo, in the town, building partnerships within the community and managing the small pie that we have.
4:01:49 But fund development is one of our contract deliverables. We call it leverage funding in the contract. And let me just kind of give a little context for how we think about fund development and why we think it's an important part of MLR's mission. When MLR was chartered, becoming revenue neutral was on the table as well. And that is something we've talked about. We have made no progress in that.
4:02:18 Partially because it was a matter of focus. I mean, getting the allocation process cleaned up and off the ground and just organizing ourselves with our relationship to our municipal government took a lot of time and Rich showed a lot of expertise in that regard. But what we're looking for, the candidate profile, is somebody who has experience building a basic fund development platform,
4:02:48 And scaling a non-profit. And so why is this important? Right now we receive $200,000 a year from Measure R and U for operations and administration. That is money that's being taken away from programming. We have a lot of capital requirements that are going to come down the road for Measure R and Measure U.
4:03:13 And we believe that an NGO like ours and that the town in general needs an investment vehicle. And our point of view is we're not really good at that right now as a town, and we certainly don't have that expertise within our organization. We're very good at writing checks. We're not so good at receiving them beyond the checks that the taxpayers are all going to write next month.
4:03:42 And the playbook's out there. I mean, we look around at other communities and we look at other NGOs, thousands of NGOs, and building a very basic fund development program is absolutely within our reach. These conversations around fund development can kind of get out of hand quickly. I've been in these chambers a number of times where someone has said, well, MLR will go out and raise a couple million dollars for this project or that project. I believe that our town,
4:04:11 We'll develop that capability in the future and can develop that capability in the future. But it absolutely will not happen unless we make some very basic investments in basic fund development capability. And what are we talking about? At the outset, we're just talking about kind of raising our own operating costs. And we're asking for $20,000 basically to invest.
4:04:40 In our ability to drive investment. So for me, it's a really low risk investment for the town. We also are looking for somebody with a national profile at best. That would be ideal. We are kind of, as I said, in a silo right now. We're doing a great job within the community.
4:05:06 One of our deliverables was to build a communication network. Well, we've built it. We need somebody to come in and be able to plug a network into that. And on top of that, I would suggest, and I can kind of walk you through the group that we're looking to work with, the forest group.
4:05:27 I think they're the perfect choice in this search. They're out of Northern California. Adam Forrest leads the group. They're called the Forrest Group. He himself has been the board president of the Conservation Alliance. He is the current board chair of 1% for the Planet. He's been on the board of Leave No Trace. They've done a bunch of searches for organizations exactly like ours. So we think this was kind of a...
4:05:54 No risk investment really at the end of the day to get the right kind of person at the head of our organization for this next step. And because we're investing in fund development, the money will come back. Again, even in the worst case scenario of becoming just revenue neutral, if that's the best we can ever do, raising $200,000 a year, there's kind of a double win there. That's $200,000 of
4:06:24 Unrestricted funds that come into the organization that we can more efficiently manage. But it's also $200,000 that goes back to measure R&U. So I'll kind of stop there. That's the genesis of our decision. And I'll answer any questions you guys have. Tom, thank you very much. Bill, do you have any questions? Love going to you first. I don't have any questions other than I think that we're premature here.
4:06:55 We don't have a scope of work completed yet. We're going to go out and spend $20,000 to look for somebody who's ostensibly going to raise funds for. We don't know what that scope of work is. I would love to see us finish that scope of work, and I think there's a lot of work left to do. You know, MLR started out as a baby, and after two years and however many hundreds of thousands, we've gotten to the point where we can roll over.
4:07:24 And now we want to fund somebody so that we can go from the rollover stage to the jogging stage and we haven't gotten to walking yet. I would love to see us get there. There has been no local fundraising, no membership, no 100 for 100, an awful lot of the things that were talked about when we formed MLR. From my position initially with MLR, it was a lot more than just fund developing. It was taking care of all recreation outside of.
4:07:53 Municipal Recreation. So far, I have seen no effort to go down there, and I know some of my colleagues are going to disagree with me there, but for those reasons, is this where we need to go in six months? Boy, maybe, but I don't know yet, because we haven't gotten to the walking stage, and I'd like to get there. I'd like to see something happen, so we are getting buy-in to the program by getting local memberships, by getting more buy-in. I am concerned.
4:08:23 So I just, I'd love to see the MLR succeed.
4:08:53 I just think we're premature. I think we have some work left to do before we get to the point of hiring a nationally known man and bringing him in and telling him, well, what we want you to do is raise your own income and that's it. Because that doesn't make sense to me. We need a better defined scope of work and recognition or recommitment from the MLR board or whatever it is to fill.
4:09:20 What we were hoping for, you know, somebody at one of the meetings explained it as a child, so that's why I use that analogy. I don't think we're there yet. I would love to see us continue as we are and get some stability and get some actual deliverables that make sense on a broad range. And then who's the best person to bring in to fill those? So I would just respond. I agree with you. I would...
4:09:48 In terms of how we get there, I would respectfully disagree. I think we're at the stage that you suggest, but to even get to walking in terms of fund development, that takes a skill set that we don't have. I mean, we've been beating our head against a wall, and it's not just unique to MLR. We have a fundraising deficit in this town in general. I think we have a history of walking into projects.
4:10:15 Spending money on consultants, spending money on feasibility studies, getting the project understood, and then we don't find the money. We need the money. And the same goes on the programming side. If you look at the facilities that we're looking to build, as a board, we've gone and looked at, done comp analysis for performing arts centers like the one we want to build. The level of programming that we need to grow to is,
4:10:45 We have a lot of work to do. Same with an aquatic center. Same with the rink we're talking about. Those are pressing needs. And I don't think we should be waiting to make an investment like this. I think the skill set to build a 100 for 100 campaign, the skill set to do some very basic fundraising, is a skill we need to import. We don't have it in the organization right now. And again, I don't think we really have it in very many pockets of our town.
4:11:15 Again, I think this is an investment that quickly pays for itself pretty rapidly. And to get to the point you want to get to, I think this is the time to do it. Thank you. Cleland. Don't take this out on the table tennis table later on. I'm not in favor of the position, kind of where you're talking about the walking. However,
4:11:48 I'd have to say that I don't have your faith that somebody will be able to come in and actually fundraise money. I've been hearing it for 25 years, and I've met all sorts of people, and nobody can bring the money to town. And I'm a little concerned about spending this money. You're going to be paying some money.
4:12:14 Not that much money. I mean, I guess maybe they get a percentage of what they bring in and maybe that's an incentive for them. But I think that it sounds a lot easier than it is. And so at this point, I guess I'll just say it, I'm not in favor of the $200,000 to be taken from the general fund.
4:12:34 Oh, I don't think that's what's the question. Oh, no, but it is coming. It's 20,000. What did I say? 200,000? Oh, okay, sorry. I'm thinking big. No, with the 20,000, I'm not. I've been looking at some numbers and I feel like every meeting we're just bleeding out a little more money, a little more money, and we're not seeing any results. So while I think this is something that I could come around to, at this point I would like to see.
4:13:02 As Bill stayed a little more. I understand the concern, and I think that's a deep concern in the community, is we talk a lot about fundraising, and there's a lot of doubt that our town could have success in that area. I believe... Can I stand around for a second? Just a point of word. Are we deliberating, or what are we doing here? We're supposed to be asking questions. Okay.
4:13:29 Oh, sorry. I just want to, I don't want to, this back and forth is not, it's a little awkward. Okay, sorry. I would just, I would just, the one thing I would say is, I think it's a defined skill set that leads to fundraising, and it's something that we do not have. So if that is a deliverable, then we need to align that skill set with that deliverable. And that means the first pennies.
4:13:54 That we raise. That doesn't just mean some number that seems unattainable out there. That means building a foundation. I mean, you don't just create a logo and put your sign up and all of a sudden you can raise money. You need somebody who has experience doing that and knows how to leverage a local community and get partnerships. And it's not just going out and getting money from individuals. We don't even have the right grant mix right now to support our organization.
4:14:25 That is a fairly, that's a skill set that's widely available out there. But we don't have it in our organization right now and we don't really have it in the town right now as it relates to recreation and arts and culture. All right. Do you have a question? Well, yes. What skill sets do you guys have? The board? Yeah. I mean, well, we need somebody who can do this as a job. I mean, we're a volunteer. Yes, we bring
4:14:55 Whether it's marketing expertise, communication expertise, we have people who are involved in recreation advocacy, we have our own board level networks, but we need somebody on the ground to actually build that capability. I mean, if anybody's been involved in fundraising before, it's a on the ground, press the flesh, build your network kind of operation. And for me,
4:15:23 I believe it's short-sighted not to make an investment like this in that capability. Because just to cover what we're talking about here, all it has to return is $20,000 just to cover what we're talking about tonight. That is far from the vision we have. But you have to get there first. And if we keep kind of kicking the can down the road, then especially once...
4:15:49 This pie, right, the measure R and measure U becomes more constrained because of potential capital expenditures over time. I mean, right now we're funding about half of the requests that come in for programming. I mean, we don't have to be talking about massive capital campaigns to see success for this particular investment. We can be talking about tens of thousands of dollars.
4:16:17 Hundreds of thousands of dollars. And it returns back to our programming portfolio, which we also need to build up to support the kinds of ambitions that we have. So again, I understand the concerns, but I would argue that it's a very low risk investment, not just in a fundraising capability, but in a human resource. We want to get the right kind of person in this position.
4:16:44 To meet the ambitions that we've set for ourselves. And Rich has done a great job, and again, working in the allocation field and keeping our community kind of aligned and growing, we've got it. But that's not the vision that was originally set out for MLR. And again, this is a...
4:17:09 I mean, $20,000, I don't mean to call it a small investment, but because you're investing in an investment capability, it seems like a low risk one to me. So my next question. Yeah, I need to understand what we're doing here because this is not, I don't think this is how we're supposed to be doing this. Yeah. Okay. You had your time, you had your time. Colin, do you have a question? I do not have a question at this time.
4:17:34 Okay, so I have a question, and then we'll come back and deliberate, correct? Okay. Tom, is there a reason why the job description that's going out to this firm is not included in the agenda packet? It's, well, we have crafted a rough job description. Part of the service is creating a recruitment portfolio and a profile. And so they take our rough job description and work it into a polish, not just...
4:18:03 To attract candidates, but also to align the job, to better align the job to our goals and objectives. Okay, and if we approve this, I'm assuming that that document will come back to the council as an informational item or something like that. Absolutely. Okay, can you advise the council this evening how much money has come into MLR in support of some of the programs in your portfolio to date?
4:18:27 I have numbers in my head. I know what they are. I hope you can provide some numbers. You're talking about unrestricted dollars? Unrestricted dollars that have come in in specific support of the projects that are part of the MLR portfolio. In terms of leveraging within the outpatient? Cash. Cash. Actually, Rich could probably talk to it better than I can. Rich? Let me pull it out. Okay. As we're waiting for that. Sure. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
4:18:52 Bill, if you have another question. I do think my final question is because we keep talking about $20,000 and Cleland mistakenly said $200,000. Yes, sorry. What kind of first year income package are we talking about for the individual? Because that's really part of the package we're talking about here. It's not $20,000. It's a minimum of a first year's income package plus the search package. So that would be the retirement, the... We're talking in the ballpark of our existing executive director.
4:19:21 It's a replacement. Possibly a little more. The process, and I would just also say, part of the benefit of going through an executive search like this, especially with a group like the Forest Group, just in the conversations that we've had to date, have been illuminating and have, for me, given me an example of why we need somebody in our organization at the helm.
4:19:52 Who has other connections to other NGOs in terms of just modeling and scaling the organization. Part of this process is aligning that executive director position with the program administrator position and crafting and making sure that they align with the deliverables. And so I feel like out of this process, we're going to have more of a honed understanding of our organization.
4:20:20 So, you know, in their process, they'll bring in what they call a calibration candidate. That's somebody that we interview and we look at as kind of a model. And then we will ask the question, is the salary aligned correctly? Do we need to throw another $10,000 to the package? What else needs to be included to attract the kind of candidate we want?
4:20:48 The process is helping. I mean, and we've already done an executive director search. We did one. Rich was available, and we knew that we needed somebody when we kind of launched that already knew all the players and all the politics. It was critical. But that search was rocky. I mean, we struggled a little bit, and part of it was we just didn't have the network to really execute it well. So this search is, we believe, critical to our ability.
4:21:19 Tom, I got a question. You mentioned the Forest Service group here. How many different groups did you
4:21:50 We looked at, I personally was on four calls with other groups. I don't know what our total was, Rich. About half a dozen. And I would also suggest that this $20,000 is half to a third of the cost of our other favorite search firms. And the reason for that is some of it's timing. They had a big
4:22:19 2016, where they were kind of clobbered with work, really, and they took a strategic breath as a group coming into 2017, so the timing is perfect for us to slide into their portfolio, and also I think Adam is passionate about our group. I mean, he's been on boards like ours. He knows about MLR already, and he knows all of...
4:22:48 In our kind of internal network, we've gone out to some other people in Colorado who are involved in state recreation in Colorado and Washington, D.C. He knows all of them better than we do. Another question. Who was on the committee to find the different search groups? So it was myself, David Page, Brent Truax, Gary Morgan from our board, and then Scott McGuire.
4:23:18 And John Wentworth was on the committee too. I mean, this is a selection committee as well. So this ad hoc would continue during all phases of the search and would be instrumental once we get to the candidate stage. And was Rich involved? Rich is leading the search. Oh. And I want to emphasize that just on a personal level.
4:23:45 Like I said, this decision came out of conversations that Rich and I had and the kind of professional maturity and leadership that it takes to lead the search for your own replacement. I can't tell you enough how appreciative we are of that and how appreciative we are that Rich is at the helm of this search. I think it's critical for our current staff to help pave the way for this transition we're trying to make.
4:24:13 John, you asked a question. Rich, do you have the answer? Mr. Mayor, I'm looking just for this first half of the fiscal year, July 1st to December 30th. We allocated about $30,000 in funds of R&U. It generated $94,000 in cash and generated $15,000 in in-kind. So it generated between cash and in-kind $109,615.
4:24:53 All right. Thank you very much. Is that the number you're looking for? That's a perfectly appropriate number. Thank you very much. Good enough. All right. With any further questions? No? I'll go out to the public for any questions for Tom or Rich? Seeing none. Tom, you sure you don't have any questions? Okay. Okay. We'll come back for deliberation. Mayor, please just want to add one thing.
4:25:26 Andy, I were talking about some other recruitments that are out there. I know Trekkie's looking at one another's. From a cost number, $20,000 is little to the low end for professional search firm. Trekkie's looking at one that'd be about $35,000. I know historically doing some others, $25,000 to even $40,000 is not unique in terms of a professional level search firm. So just still a policy question of the dollar amount, but it's not an exorbitant amount in terms of a professional level research.
4:25:53 Search firm at this level. My understanding, though, the search is actually costing a little bit more than $20,000? Yeah, it'll be $20,000. $20,000 is the fee of the search firm. Yeah, but then you have to pay. Then we have to fly candidates in. And that's being provided by internal funds? By the funds that Rich just mentioned. Okay. We have enough unrestricted money in the bank to be able to do that. Very good. Just to add that our second choice was $50,000.
4:26:23 Right. All right. We'll bring it back for deliberation. I'll go in the same order I did. I still have the same concerns. I have heard everybody say that we have never brought money to town. We need to bring somebody from outside to bring money to town. Our entire MUP system and most of our sidewalks in town have all been...
4:26:45 Paid for with grant funding that staff has applied for and gotten. So to say we don't have the skill set or can't find the skill set would be inaccurate. If what we're looking for is to raise funds for all the projects that Tom mentioned, and it's my negative day today, guys, sorry. Those are all municipal projects. Would we be better off, and we haven't had the discussion, to spend the $20,000 and hire that fundraiser?
4:27:11 Within the town to fund all of these projects rather than fund another nonprofit and they're just, I'm not saying I'm not willing to go there. I'm saying that I haven't bought this package yet today. I think we're premature. I don't, that's just where I'm at. Okay, thank you. Cleland. No comments. All right. Colin.
4:27:42 This is a difficult one for me. I'm kind of torn. I'm kind of looking for some direction from the rest of the council and figuring out where we go here. First and foremost, I have no issue with the $20,000 ask. That is not an issue for me at all. I think if we're behind the direction in general,
4:28:08 Then I don't think it's an issue to go out and invest in the future of that organization to that tune. That being said, I'm not 100% certain in the direction. I think, as Bill kind of alluded to, I've had some thoughts and conversations about do we have a broader fundraising need in this community? And I think we do. So I'm wondering if...
4:28:37 You know, an executive director in this capacity is the right role for the community's fundraising needs. You know, I would respectfully disagree with the fact that we can't bring money to this community. I think we absolutely have the ability to do so. You know, we have a lot of high net worth individuals that visit here, have second homes here, you know, make this their permanent home.
4:29:01 And a lot of other communities have shown a real propensity to go out and generate that kind of connection to the community that makes people want to open up their pocketbooks. And I think that we really have that ability to do that here. You know, I'm really sitting on kind of the 50-50 side of things here. I think there's a significant role out there.
4:29:30 For an executive director in that capacity. And I'm not sure that going after somebody, you know, purely with a fundraising skill set, if those two kind of buckets are going to coincide well.
4:29:43 But that being said, I know I can really understand the genesis of this because there's been a lot of focus from day one in the creation of MLR to really push fundraising, fundraising, leveraging funds. So I can't say it's a surprise that this direction has come up. You know, I think you articulated well, Tom, you know, are we...
4:30:06 Are we in a position to deliver on the deliverables that have been put in front of us? And, you know, it's my general philosophy to not micromanage. I think we have a council liaison on that board. You know, it's a board that I sat on. It's a group of people that I think are intelligent and hardworking. So, you know, for me to kind of get in there and meddle with the direction that the current board, which I no longer sit on, feels is important.
4:30:35 You know, I have a little bit of a struggle with. So, you know, like I said, I do have some concerns potentially about whether this is the right direction to go, whether it's the right fit.
4:30:46 I do hear the concerns of will this lead to a larger compensation package in the future? Is this going to lead to necessary additional bodies in the organization to handle all the kind of operations type things that I think are incumbent in that role? So I share those concerns.
4:31:06 I'm kind of looking to hear a little bit from John, you, and Shields as well to kind of where you're coming from. But those are kind of my initial thoughts. Before I vote, I'm a little bit torn. But overall, I want to be cognizant of the fact that I don't think it's our role up here as a policy board to micromanage our NGOs or our employees. And we're really about making policy direction. And I don't have an issue with the ask that's come before us. Fair enough. John.
4:31:36 Good. Thank you very much. So a couple things. First, I'm a little disappointed in the staff report. I think that we're having this wandering, meandering conversation because I don't think we have the kind of information that the council needed to deal with this in an efficient manner. Second thing I want to say is that I thank you, Rich, for the representation of the dollars. I think that it's clear that I think where MLR has been failing a little bit is not
4:32:02 Advising the community, advising the council of the work that you were already doing, the resources you were already leveraging, you know, maybe it's not, you know, home run kind of money, but it's happening. I know there are a lot of people who are donating money to the MLR program, and I think it's very important to make us all aware of that. Thank you for doing that. So it's clear, obviously, just in six months, I mean, this 20,000 is covered. I share your concern, Bill, about...
4:32:29 Salary creep, staff creep, the rest of that. So as we get to a motion or consideration of this, I think it needs to be clear that as to understand like what position, if you look at a home loan or if you have liens or things on your property, what position
4:32:48 Is the funding of the $200,000 was for the executive director or MLR operations. What position is that in relative to the money that they're raising? So, and this may be something the council wants to get involved in to say, okay, if the first dollars that you raise, it's all going to go to pay for that, or do we want to make a decision to say, look, we're willing to pay that person because that person is generating enough money that's paying for other programs.
4:33:11 So I think it's unfair to be having this conversation absent some direction from us, which I think we need to step up and figure that out. Because I share your concern about sort of getting creeped and backed into that corner, but I think we can clarify that based on our conversations up here. That may be a future item, I don't know, but that's something that we can clarify. I need to say that I think MLR is fundamentally ripe for this. I know that the work that Rich has done is he's basically built an institution.
4:33:40 The institution is in place. Whoever is going to be hired for this job, and I hope the search committee knows what they're doing, they're going to be implementing Mr. Botch's program.
4:33:51 Now, they may not know about small-town California government. They may not know a whole lot about MLRs and council meetings at whatever time of night it is and all the fun things we do up here. That person's going to be sitting where Mr. Botch is sitting. He's going to be implementing that program. That does not go away. We have to double down and invest in all the great work that's happened to date. So I'm very confident where MLR is at and where the MLR needs to go. The second thing is that
4:34:17 This conference I attended in Telluride, we heard a lot about what's called the second homeowner audience. And Telluride has done, they have millions, millions of dollars that come into Telluride. The classic example, it's a box canyon, and there's a whole big open space at the bottom of the canyon. And the person who owned the property said a fax was leaked to the wrong party.
4:34:44 And the word got out that, oh my God, the person that owns this land is going to develop the most beautiful greenway in our town. Community went crazy. Got all rallied up. Found a way to get it stopped. Put the thing in place. The one detail they forgot to understand was they were going to need $56 million in three weeks to satisfy the obligation to get that established as green space.
4:35:10 In three weeks, Meg Whitman stepped in, wrote the check. That's Greenspace. That's the second homeowner audience. We are in a position now to give to MLR the greatest asset that we have, which is our place and the experiences that people have here to let them have a way to invest and be part of this community, even if they have to live in some god-awful place like Southern California. They know that their heart is here. They know that their spirit is here.
4:35:40 MLR, we are giving to MLR that audience and saying, let these people participate in the magic and the beauty of our community. It is a classic and fully enriched fundraising opportunity. So I think that we would be crazy if we did not put somebody in a position to reach out to those people, $5 checks, $10 checks.
4:36:02 Oh, we have a dog problem. We have a canine problem. I want to be part of the Mammoth Canine Club to start cleaning up all the dog poo that's about to drown this place. These are the kinds of things that the second homeowner audience wants to be involved with, wants to engage with. We're absolutely perfectly primed to do those kinds of things. I think also with the walk, bike, ride, if you look at how we're looking to expand our scope, and we're looking to get into public lands conversations, which I think you and I hold very dear.
4:36:30 We need someone, and again, I hope they get the right person because these are the things we're going to ask them to do, to be involved in the public lands conversation, to realize what's implied in sustainable recreation, to fully realize the Mammoth Lakes outdoor recreation experience to the extent as it's being defined in this walk, bike, ride process. And I think we absolutely need to have someone. I hope they have public lands.
4:36:54 I hope they understand what NEPA is. I hope they know how to work with district rangers and forest supervisors because we are going to be asking that person to be involved in these things.
4:37:03 And to be delivering those benefits to the community. I know that the national conversation is about, specifically about these topics. And if we can get the right person here who's doing that on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes, that's going to put us on the map in a way that, we're on a lot of maps, but it's going to put us on that map. And that's going to be another source of funding and capacity we can bring to this thing. So I'm, you know, babbling on, it's late.
4:37:29 But I think the time is now. I think that $20,000, they've raised that in the last four or five months. But I do agree with you that we need to give them the clear direction to understand, with this position, what is the funding obligation going to be over time? Let's get that cleared up so we're not wondering about all that stuff. But I think the time is now. I'm done. Thank you. I appreciate the crazy comment. Thank you very much. We're all crazy here.
4:38:00 You know, there's not much I can add. I sit on the MLR board. And Tom talked about the pivot. And there is a pivot going on. And, you know, spent two years writing the Constitution. How many different iterations of that? Nine of them or something like that? 37. Yeah, something like that. And it is time to pivot. It's time to, you know, start doing what MLR was supposed to do two years ago. Your comments about Rich?
4:38:30 They're greatly appreciated by me. I share them. He's the guy that created the foundation. His future, you know, his name on the plaque, so to speak, is going to be there forever. He is the founding ED. The beauty about it is Rich is actually leading the search. That's what I'm excited about.
4:39:01 He knows what MLR needs. And, you know, if it's just, you know, one of the board members leading the search, I don't know how to be so gun-ho on it. But because Rich is leading the search, because he knows what MLR needs, and he takes input from everybody, you know, I think that's very positive. Cleland, just to answer your question, we've done quite a lot of fundraising in this town.
4:39:29 Wait a minute. Hold on. I didn't say that we haven't done fundraising, but what in the past, Bill did bring this up. We have been told a lot of times so-and-so is coming in, they're bringing money. The MAC, a couple of million dollars has been donated to that.
4:39:51 I used to do fundraising for, I mean, I threw my birthday party. I know, but what I'm saying is it's not just this. All I'm saying is sometimes it does take an outside person to fundraise. And we've been successful in that actually in the last couple of years. National Wounded Warrior Center, Disabled Sports, the MAC. Thank God Kathy decided to move here from some, oh yeah, she was here already.
4:40:16 I got it. See, Kathy is a great example. So you set yourself up for that one. Yeah, you did. I'm on the board. I'm on the executive committee. We hired an outside fundraiser, and he's the guy that went and found the guy to give over $4 million. So Kathy is great. Don't get me wrong. She's a dynamo. She's a force of nature. But it takes sometimes the outside person to do that, and we hired that person to do that.
4:40:45 And it's been successful. So anyway, I think you can all tell I'm very supportive of this. I don't think it's a big ask. I think it's the right ask at this time. I think we are walking, Bill, to your point. I think we need to start running a little bit. So I think now is the time. I think the ask isn't that much, to Dan's point. Most of these...
4:41:12 Executive searches cost a little bit more than $20,000. And again, I appreciate Rich leading the charge on it. So with that, I will bring it back to Council for further deliberation or a motion or? I'm prepared to make a motion.
4:41:34 All right. So I would move that the council authorize funding for Mammoth Lakes Recreation related to recruitment and selection of a new executive director and that staff will bring back to council for council's consideration and a decision to establish the town's financial involvement with the salary of the MLR executive director going forward and its relationship to funds that may be raised by MLR. I'll second that.
4:42:04 Okay, we have a motion to second. Okay, roll call, please. Yes. No. Yes. Yes, motion passes three to two. Okay, we'll move on to item number 12. Adopt a resolution issuing a legislative subpoena for records related to unpaid...
4:42:29 Rob Patterson and I are going to present this. I'm going to kind of explain what this is, and then Rob's going to explain the details of this particular case. So normally if you think about a subpoena, it's something that's issued by a court, or at least in connection with a court case, but the government code does allow the town council to issue subpoenas. The town has not done this very often. The last time we did this was in 2012, and you can, and what we're asking you to do tonight is to do this.
4:42:57 Is to issue a subpoena requiring a property owner to turn over all of his records relating to the rentals of his house. This is a house that is single family, so it can't be rented legally. There's a long rental history on this house. We've been having, Rob's had multiple discussions with the property owner. I've had multiple discussions with his attorney. We've been asking for records and asking for records and not getting the records. Monday this week, we got fragmentary records.
4:43:26 And I'll let Rob explain what's going on with this. But in any event, the law is very clear. There are cases upholding the use of the subpoena process in connection with TOT records. And it's not something that I would recommend that we do every time with every property owner. But in egregious cases where we're just not getting any cooperation after multiple attempts, I think it is proper and appropriate. And the documents that are attached consist of a resolution.
4:43:52 Okay, thank you.
4:44:13 So my team has been working very hard on this case. We've actually started this back in early October. You can see a lot of details in the staff report. I won't go through all of them. But essentially, this particular individual, this is a second offender. So someone that we've caught before who was performing rentals not zoned for such. And during that process, went through and provided some documentation, was issued penalties and interest, paid those.
4:44:40 And then proceeded on and picked up the business again shortly thereafter. So the team did come across him again. I had, like Andy said, a couple of face-to-face meetings with him discussing the process and telling him exactly what we needed. The information provided to us was incomplete. And in fact, in
4:45:08 I don't want to say manufactured, but it appears to have been manufactured to deceive us through the process, meaning that he gave us 11 partial long-term lease agreements that would be legal for his particular area and stated that that was the process that he was using. Also parts and pieces of several different bank account information, but all of them were simply, but none of them substantiated the long-term leases.
4:45:35 It was after we kept on, which I have to commend my team. They do an excellent job of really making sure everything lines up and the facts seem to be believable. We do that by requiring either rental calendars, bank statements, and tax returns that should corroborate the same story. In this case, it just seemed to get more and more obscure as we went deeper and deeper.
4:46:02 We did finally, with Andy's help, we did, working through Mr. Ford's attorney, get admission of several transient rentals. So they gave us a couple of calendars. And by the way, in those calendars, every one of the short-term rentals, I'm sorry, the long-term lease agreements were proven to have had short-term rentals during those lease agreements. So it was clear that the information provided was either false or a very interesting situation.
4:46:32 So based upon that, we were not willing to take the rental calendars provided because they were simply Excel spreadsheets of the activity as face value and say this is all of the picture and this is what we're going to use to go forward. We needed the corroborating evidence that would prove and support that information. We had repeatedly asked for bank statements. And in this case, there are four that we had.
4:47:00 We had visibility on four bank accounts involved. When we got the information on the spreadsheets, there was a fifth bank account that was involved where these monies were deposited. And when I say for bank accounts, we're looking for deposit records that will substantiate activity. In this case, we just want to look through and make sure there isn't any other activity that's not being reported on those spreadsheets.
4:47:24 At the time I wrote the staff report, we had not received any information. As Andy alluded to, we did receive some the other day. But they're heavily redacted and not usable, fragmented data. So they're really not supporting that. And it's partial information as well. It does not include all of the bank statements that we've requested and all of the time frame that we've requested. So the subpoena will help us.
4:47:51 Secure the records that we need to get the proper amount of tax penalty and interest associated with this transaction and hopefully get this completed. So what we're asking for is formally asking for all bank statements, accounts owned and controlled by the covering time period of October 1st through February 28, 2017, including all deposit detail activity along with supporting documentation for those deposits.
4:48:20 As well as rental lease agreements and other documentations relating to transient rental from October 1, 2013 through February 28, 2017. And all records that are required to be kept by the owner. And this is per our code. We have three years of time with which you need to maintain all of your transactional records in case there's an audit or something else to substantiate your activity.
4:48:45 We are pursuing that information. One little piece I will add, this is one of our tougher cases, one of our more challenging cases. It's been demonstrated throughout the process and by the documentation provided that this individual is collecting tax in the name of tax, not just rental income, but actual tax that was not being remitted to the town. So in that case, we're adding an element of fraud to this.
4:49:13 Through the process. So it'll be substantial in as far as the penalties are as they associate with that. But we really need to get all of the information in order to determine the full scope. All right. Any questions for Rob or for Andy? John? Real quick. How many hours of staff time do you think you've spent on this case? This one has not been the most labor intensive. I would say that we've probably spent somewhere
4:49:45 In 80 to 100 hours on this particular one. Okay. And I'm hearing things that sound like, they sound like they're criminal activity. I mean, is that... Well, if he collected tax and didn't pay it. Yeah, I just... That can be treated as fraud under our code and it triggers penalties. There are some cases out there holding that collection of tax and then failing to remit it is a form of embezzlement. So...
4:50:12 In cases, if we come across a case that's particularly egregious, we could talk to the district attorney about bringing criminal charges. We're not there yet, but that is something that we're aware of as a possibility. Okay. And who would be serving the subpoenas? How would that work? We'll figure that out. Okay. That's it. Thank you. Cleland, you have a question? You guys feel really just solid with all the background that's been done on this and that...
4:50:43 Everything is T's crossed, I's dotted. Is there anything that would be, yeah, well, this kind of happened, or do you feel completely great with all the research? No, I'm very solid with the research that we've done, the fact that this is completely illegal activity, and our efforts in this case are trying to determine how much in the volume of that activity, and so we're following the standard procedures and processes. It's been well documented.
4:51:13 One of the things that Andy talked about in egregious cases, I guess it could be more egregious than this if they were refusing to talk to us. In this case, Mr. Ford has reached out to us and been willing to work and come and meet with me and talk through some processes. It's just the follow through has not been complete. So as we've worked through this, I don't think there's been any missteps on our part. We've actually just not been willing to take the bait, if you will. And we just keep digging until we're getting to the bottom of it.
4:51:42 And I'll point out that this doesn't have any penalties associated with it. This is just a subpoena. It's ordering him to give us the records so that we can review the records and then determine what the dollar amount owed is. So the subpoena to me is really just an information gathering step. Cool. Thank you. Bill? You know... Question. Yeah, it is a question. Whether it pertains to this case or not, I don't know.
4:52:08 It pertains to my profession and how I deal with these things. When someone is locked out of a rental, often illegal, and I ask if they belong in the house that they want me to let them into, all they have to produce is an electronic contract on their telephone. Do we ask for that type of information in these cases as documentation of rentals? Are we able to get that? Would we have to subpoena that?
4:52:37 We get the statements that are provided to the person conducting the rentals. So they'll show us their monthly statements that show the amount of activity and the deposits that are made into their account. We can then go see the bank account and confirm those deposits. And so that's the type of information. It's not the individual contracts that we look at. It's the activity provided by like VRBO or Airbnb to the homeowner.
4:53:06 And that's the information that usually we'll get to that point for sure with our activity and our efforts. They'll come forward with those. We've had people come in with laptops and say, here's my login, take a look at my entire account. Those have been good cases and swift cases. But that's the information that should be available to us, and that's the information we request when we talk about rental calendars. It shows the entire landscape of their rental activity.
4:53:33 And actually, the Municipal Code does require all operators of transiently rented properties to maintain the rental agreements, and we're entitled to the rental agreements. So even if you're renting through Airbnb or VRBO, there's something, there's some rental agreement that you would have access to as the property owner, and we're entitled to that, and the subpoena covers that. Which was my question, does the subpoena cover the electronic transactions? Colin, do you have any questions? No questions.
4:54:02 Rob, you mentioned that this is the second time. Can you kind of go through the first time and the period? This was back in 2012 was this time. The activity that was provided, the person walked away with about a $3,800 penalty and interest. They did provide long-term
4:54:30 Leases as a defense at that point in time. And they were not pursued deeper. And they weren't the same ones. That's one thing we did confirm. But it was the same type of an approach that they took this time. And I think the consensus was that the approach was different back then and we were really looking for the volume and the financial impact of getting and collecting that information.
4:54:59 It was something that I think was a little easier for this particular person to deal with before. And he paid it? Yes. Okay. Any public questions? What are we looking for here? Can I make a motion? Is there any deliberation to go through? I think this is pretty cut and dry.
4:55:33 So, yes, please. I would like to make a motion that we adopt a resolution issuing a legislative subpoena for the requested records related to the property from the owner. I did that under options. Is that okay? Well, maybe it'd be better if we just read the recommended motion. Yeah, recommended motion up front. Recommended motion. You know what? I don't think I get that on my... Here. It's clearance on the item title of your action.
4:56:03 Okay, I say we should adopt a resolution issuing, oh, that's the same thing, a legislative subpoena for the requested records related to the property located at 1498 Forest Trail from Robert Ford, Trustee of Ford, Declaration of Trust, 1-13-14, I guess that's the date. Okay, I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second. Can I have a roll call, please? Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes.
4:56:32 Yes, motion passes 5-0. That will take us to our closed session. Do I read off what we're going to do in closed session? Yeah, you don't have to read every word, but if you could just sort of read in general what we're doing. It was on the cover sheet. We're actually going to flip these around. But number 13 is we're going to discuss.
4:57:00 Special terms of purchase for a piece of property. And number 14 is discuss existing litigation. Do I have to name the case? John Hobb v. Sound of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. And we'll report afterwards. I need to talk to you about the next meeting that I go. It came up last meeting about...
4:57:43 It's something you know a lot about, I know nothing about. It's the new, where you are the alternative.