Town Council Special meeting
· recording 4 hr 20 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
550 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:12 Pledge on there, but you can do it if you want. I know you're not contagious, but just in case. Jamie, you ready? All right. I'll call to order the special meeting of Town Council for March 22, 2017. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. All accounted for. Rob, I'm going to ask you to lead it.
4:48 Lead us in the pledge, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Rob. Okay, now's the time for any public comment. If anybody would like to approach the podium and state their name. Hearing none, we'll jump right into the budget discussion.
5:28 Dan, I'm going to hand it over to you. Thank you, Mayor, members of Council. The budget process this year has taken a little different tact, if you will, than we've had the last couple of years, in part as I think we believe we have a little more revenue this year, and we haven't, normally we've come in at the beginning of this process and really kind of narrowed down the revenue.
5:48 Projections and then budget the expenditures to those. This year we've kind of modified that a little bit. We've actually asked the departments to walk through their budgets, look at what they believe they need in terms to meet current operations as well as additional expectations. So the discussion today will primarily be focused on the expenditure side. We'll definitely touch on revenue. But the first several presentations, really some of the departments going, here's what we're doing, here's how well we're doing it or not doing it.
6:17 And to be able to walk through that needs and those types of elements there. We tried to kind of do a rating, you know, like a scoring on the various services in the one staff report you have in front of you in the bottom there. Kind of an ABC level. I won't walk through those, but kind of setting kind of some standards there, a little bit, you know, subjective, obviously.
6:39 The other side of that is we really didn't go through a normal school setting, if you will, A through F. We figure if we're doing below a C, the question is why are we doing it and or it really doesn't have a priority. So let's have that discussion if that's the case. You'll see kind of an outline of the budget presentation we'll be going through there. Lastly, I just want to touch quickly on a few of the budget assumptions that did go into the preparation of that. One, we've left the REU alone. We have not touched the reserve. It's at $3.4 million.
7:07 The budget does include all known employee-based costs, contractual costs, those things that we have commitments to, but you don't have the authority to modify them, if you will. They're by contract. We have other stuff like rent and insurance and those types of things. There is a funded contingency proposed at $100,000. That came out of the previous discussion on reserves. I can be open for discussion as need be.
7:35 We have an operating reserve based on the last action the council took, currently sitting at $180,000 is all. There is no additional addition to that at this point. Again, we haven't modified any of the NGO partner allocations, kind of getting outlined for what those are in here. We haven't made any adjustments to those, so it's still based on the historical allocations for that. And then limited planned use of reserves. We have one or two areas where we have
8:03 For example, in debt service, there's a $200,000 planned use of reserves. Otherwise, we're not using reserves in any of the other funds in terms of meeting ongoing obligations. And then off and on, we'll discuss it more today, but dialing in what do we have to put into our road projects to keep our roads updated. As with last year, the proposed budget has $580,000 in it. We will be making some recommendations from additional one-time funding to assist with projects there.
8:33 As we walk through that, we will focus mainly on those funds that are related to operations. If you can flip through the staff report, you'll see a whole bunch of funds that we'll not be talking about today. Our community development block grant funds, trust and agency funds, we have a number of assessment districts. We have not gone through all that level of detail. Some of the discussion today and direction may impact some of those funds, but for the most part, we'll be focusing on the general fund, the gas tax fund, which is basically roads and
9:03 Snow removal, the airport, debt service, our vehicle service, and then be talking about our capital projects fund and some options under that. So a little different from the last couple of years for those who sat through those. It's not quite as revenue constrained on the front end. So with that, we can dive in unless there's questions on it. And I would encourage the council, this is kind of set up to be a dialogue, so feel free to interrupt and ask questions.
9:31 After each department head goes through, I suggest if there's public comment, you open up and allow that discussion. If something is confusing and not being well understood, please ask Rob. So with that, we'll kind of have it broken up by department head, so we'll be going around walking through the various core areas that we oversee. Ready? I'm ready. So, all right. You guys ready?
10:00 And this stuff was being prepared up until about 20 minutes ago, so sorry for not having some of this out in advance of the meeting. So it will be a little cumbersome maybe walking through some of the items. First area is look at administration. It's kind of the direct departments under the town manager and or directly above the town manager being the council and the town attorney.
10:22 I've asked each department to kind of touch on some of last year's accomplishments. As we do a budget, it's not done in a vacuum. It builds off of what we've completed and the things we've worked on, some which are still in process. So just each department to touch on a couple of those. You know, we have the strategic alignment goals and objectives out there. We've had a number of projects undertaken moving forward. We completed employee negotiations. We've updated our municipal code.
10:48 We've implemented different technology upgrades, both in the room here as well as with our agenda system. We continue to work with the Inyo National Forest, our trails program. We actually had a lot of maintenance work done, new signage put up, and looking forward to that. The other thing is we had a real-life emergency operations plan exercise in January and February, so meanwhile we're also updating that plan, so it was kind of an interesting process in looking at that.
11:15 We'll spend a lot of time walking through those, but I think the council's aware of a lot of the elements that you have worked on and been involved in. Kind of for this section, be looking at town council, town attorney, town manager in the departments under that, and then kind of the bottom line there, each of the departments, department heads will be doing a presentation specifically to their department. This will begin to follow the
11:40 Detailed budget, kind of skipping over the revenues, so if you go to page four of 33, that'll be the town council budget. Did not give you a service level grade, I figured that would be up to the five of you if you wish to consider you're doing A through C level work. Let's stop right there. The council budget relatively thin, the
12:09 You know, operationally for the council, obviously. And then there's some community support funds in there. This has been historically carried through here. We have a 15-5 for the Historical Society, Pops in the Park at 3,000, and Town Cleanup at 2,000. So as you look at this, you'll see some highlighted numbers on the far right. Most of those made a scenario we just wanted to focus on briefly at least or to raise a question on that. There's a couple other places where we have some of the town activities for July 4th.
12:37 Fishing Derby and things like that within our budget as well, but these have been historically funded by the council's priorities, so assuming they still are as we move forward. The town attorney's budget, it'll bump up a little bit. We have both from our town attorney, Andy Morris, as well as BBK in their contracts. There's a CPI bump in that. Figured that'll probably move the budget about $10,000. This is always really rough. This budget ultimately depends on the amount of legal activity.
13:07 The most difficult one is to tell on legal actions in court. They can run a few grand to several. So that's kind of the unknown on this budget. There is some, I want to say a cushion in there, but it's kind of based off historical trends. I'm trying to interrupt, but I'm assuming you don't want any comments or questions as these patients, would you take notes? Yeah, take notes right now, then we'll stop at the end of this and come back on this particular grouping. Real quick also, I just...
13:34 Forgot the note there, and you'll see the actual 14-15 numbers in your chart. You'll see 15-16 actual. Then you'll see the 16-17 adopted budget. That is still being amended, so the actual isn't available at this point. And then obviously the preliminary 17-18, and I'll call this initial preliminary. We're anticipating this will go through another round of review before it's full preliminary. We'll move through a tentative or a manager recommended, and then to a council adopted budget. So you'll be seeing this at least three more times.
14:03 On the town manager, really it's a town manager and the town clerk's office kind of grouped together here. There's three staff, myself, the assistant two, and town clerk who's busy managing your meeting. The area there, the budget, for a lot of it's kind of a rollover component. The areas that we've added in on that under contractual services, two areas that
14:31 We're trying to improve in terms of part of the service levels, really deal with some of our leadership and management development. There's $15,000 in there. We had money in there last year, and the majority of that, in fact, all of it went into the strategic goals and alignment process, plus we had additional funding into that. If you look under, that's the highlighted account at $83,400. There's some other smaller items in there that are contractual in nature. The other piece in there,
14:59 That has been a priority unfunded at this point has been on economic development. There's $25,000 in there for that. We've been approached by a few different folks of looking at some funding related to the technology side and the technology strategies adopted by council to look at some resources and hopefully partnerships in terms of moving that forward. So out of that $83,400, top of page 5 of 33 would include that.
15:28 15,000 for leadership management staff development and the 25,000 primarily for economic development. I would say the economic development has been a high priority for the council with very limited resources put into it. So it really hasn't been a high area of focus from that perspective. The rest of the budget is quasi rollover and a number of different operational elements we can address as may need be if there's questions on the numbers. The town clerk
16:00 Budget is probably the simplest. You've got one position and then basically the legal mandated stuff that they do. The clerk does oversee our employee engagement process and looks at some of the different activities that we do from our employee side. As we look at our employee engagement communication for that, as we look at some of the management of the departments, be that office updates and stuff like that, that kind of gets overseen through the manager's office through that process.
16:30 The one question there, it's not in the budget. It deals with elections. You'll see $9,000 for election. Basically, we fund that over a two-year process so it doesn't get wild swings. We do $9,000 a year based on some historical averages. It can be as low as maybe $12,000 and high as in the mid-20s. All depends on number of offices and activities going on there. The one item that will be a policy discussion for the council is whether or not
16:57 To do a special election regarding Prop 64 and tax on cannabis. We've had some discussions with the county. We'll see what they want to do for sure, whether it's a joint election or not. Our recommendation would be to look at that this November versus potentially waiting until June because of the state regs that get kicked in January. So we don't know yet if that would be a shared election or it would be one if we do it on our own, assuming you want to ask the voters regarding taxation on recreational marijuana.
17:26 So that would be a question for a funding rough number, $50,000. The Major Z election was just over $51,000, I think. So that's where that number is coming from. The other side that between actually the clerk, myself, and the town attorney, a lot of the legal processes, we make sure those are followed, public records requests, Brown Act, publishing things, maintaining proper records, claims processing, our insurance elements, and those types of
17:56 Issues there. We look at our general services side of that. We actually have a department just brought out general services. We carry a lot of different one-time elements in here. The amended budget, for example, will have the walk-bike ride and the downtown revitalization dollars in here. So this one will see swings year-to-year pending on activity. It does include
18:21 In contractual services is a holding spot for that, $125,000 for special events. We've committed in moving those out of Measure U to come back and support that through the Town's General Fund. Last year we did a one-time allocation. This time it's built into the budget accordingly based on the commitments we've made to those various event organizers. And so that's sitting in the account here. The two other bigger numbers identified there, one is for insurance premiums.
18:50 One is just it's a large number for liability property, et cetera. We have not gotten our preliminary numbers from CJPIA yet. They won't come out probably until end of April, 1st of May as they look at it's looking backwards to go look forward. So my guess is that number will change. I can't tell you which direction. Last year we had a 50,000 property insurance based on some changes we did. My guess is liability will go up a bit this year.
19:18 The other piece that spread through the budget that they will give us is the number for workers' compensation. Sure. Okay. You start to answer it. What are the insurance premiums? Yeah, it's liability. It's property. Pollution. There's a crime bond. And then there's workers' comp that gets spread across the departments. That's based right down on 5% of salary. We'll see if that holds. That's been kind of a historical number. So obviously the difference between the actual and...
19:51 2014, 15, 16, went down substantially, almost $200,000. Correct, and some of that was how workers' comp was originally captured here and then spread later, like the $811,000 for last year included workers' comp, and then it was spread. Yeah, for 16, 17, workers' comp was in that number of about $300,000, and then it was spread out throughout the year. This year working out. It's not in that number this year. Yeah, this year just. So it's another.
20:23 It's sitting in the various line items for workers' comp. You'll see in the various departmental budgets. I'll walk through in a minute how the salaries are so calculated in that whole process that we go through, but workers' comp is an element in there. You'll see it as a line item at the top or near the salaries. The amount isn't gone from the budget. It has just moved to a different line. Correct.
20:46 You're hiding it from me so that I can't understand what I'm seeing. Is that? Oh, no. Yeah, that's it. Actually, it's better reflecting where it should be captured versus waiting to year end and moving it. I see how it's going to be. Yeah. Then the other one is just the facility lease here on the Minaret Mall office space, the $339. So that has a standard 3% increase over year over year on it. Right off the fractional mode.
21:17 That was an Adjustment 15-16 where we had a loan between the General Fund and the Melrose District, which we could not recover, so it was a write-off from a General Fund supporting program there. If you remember a while back, we went through several of those, doing some cleanup in that area. The other piece on there is our IT department. That's a contract with Mono County.
21:46 I think at times they're treated as a regular town department and sometimes that's a reminder that they're actually, we're a client and they're our contractor. Sometimes it works the other way around. But overall they do a good job for us being, as far as responsiveness, really troubleshooting in that. Now and again you're waiting. At times it'd be nice to have your own IT person sitting there and that would probably move the service from a B to an A, but that's probably not financially viable.
22:13 In order to have that level of staff there. They have some very talented individuals in the Mono County IT, and we work that deal to actually have them in our building in part to enhance the level of service. And then we also, through there, you'll see it sits under utilities of $16,000, but that's actually our purchase of digital 395 connections for broadband. That deals with our computer systems and our new phone system was implemented this last year. Is that one time? No, that's every year.
22:42 It was previously located in the line below equipment maintenance agreements. We just decided that it's really more public utilities than anything else. A lot of the process through what we've gone through here is if there's an opportunity to clarify and fix the way things are reported, we'll continue to refine that because we want that clarity to be there on us through exactly what those charges are. So that's part of the process we've done. Do you have all those notes someplace?
23:13 Yeah, I've got notes for the rest of our lives. Working through that. Otherwise, again, the information systems, a lot of that's rollover budget as it deals with a lot of our hardware, software, maintenance, and those types of elements. The hardware capital part of that is for ongoing updates of our computer systems. If you recall, at mid-year, we also ask for dollars to be set aside for future technology upgrades. That includes actually system upgrades, software upgrades, and replacement of computers.
23:42 A few years back, the town was several years behind and had a large catch-up to do. So we're trying to maintain that as we go forward to work through some of those elements that way so that we don't fall behind. And then I won't be able to read that probably from there. But lastly, as we look at a lot of this stuff, is ultimately how does it ultimately tie back to the 2025 strategy that the council adopted along with our NGO partners and looking at those various things that we're shooting for.
24:11 For that 2025 Vision of Greatness for Mammoth Lakes. With that, most departments, I'll pause, and if there are particular questions in some of those line items or work programs, we will respond accordingly. John, do you have any questions? Nothing yet. I know it's a lot. It's a lot of digest, and we expect questions to come later as well. A lot of bites of this out. Right.
24:47 We did get up late. Do you have any questions on what you're seeing? Something's popping out. Any clarification? That's what you want to ask. Go ahead. Dan, looking at page one, trending of revenue. I know we're not supposed to be focusing on that, but actual 2014 requested 2017-18. Right. 24 down to 19 to 21. So what's...
25:17 What's attributable to a $3, $4 million drop? That's where you have those actuals are the year in adjustments where you have, hey, we saved $3 million or we brought in excess TOT or other revenues. They're all added in, so those are the actuals. If you walk through some of those, like, for example, 15-16 TOT was $15.7 million. We budgeted $11.6 million and we're looking at $12.8 million initially for next year.
25:46 So that's a big swing just in that number alone. And you'll see some others of those if you kind of walk through where those will hit that way. Some of it's one-time money as well. And you do end up with some one-time grant money. I think 14, 15 we had some.
26:01 You will see some differences in those. We wanted to show the two budget columns, which are the two on the right. We wanted to show the initial budget from prior year to the initial budget from this year so you have some comparability. If we would have showed adapted, all the activity that we've done this year so far, as far as your council decisions, would have been included in those. And we think that would have blurred the lines a little bit. So we wanted to start with apples to apples comparison. Adopted to adopted.
26:26 We'll come back and spend a little time on the revenues at the end of the process here. Okay, sounds good. So that was just a general question. When we come back with the actuals for 16 and 17, I'm assuming that those numbers are going to look more like the actuals for 15 and 16. Correct. Instead of 19 and 7, we're talking about 24 cents a year. Most likely. That's another great way to put it. I would ask that you provide also what our budgets were for 14, 15, 16. The adopted? Yeah. Yeah, we can do it. The approved.
26:57 Yeah, we could go adopted to actual, adopted to actual. That would be a better feel. You'll see some of those changes that way. On page three, actually, not just adopted, but what it was in those years, then what the adopted budget became. So, I know it changed. I think that adopted to actual is really a good comparison. I would like to have the actual budget. Yeah, because that's... I'd like to start with the actual budget, then with the adopted budget.
27:27 Well, we'd have adopted, which would be the, that's what you started with. And then the actual, where we ended. The original approved budget. Correct, that's adopted. Okay, not, okay, the adopted. That's council adopted. Maybe it's a system. Yeah, so council adopted budget. Because we changed the budget throughout the year. Throughout the year, you end up with this actual number. That's called amended. So you have adopted, which is the first one. Yeah. And then you have an amended budget, and then you would have actual.
27:57 Yeah, you'd have three columns on those, but. All right. Yeah. Page three. Health insurance premiums for Council 75880 is requested. I think that's based on the current request. So our number for 1617 is going to come in lower than the approved budget.
28:31 Yeah, I think that's when we had a change in the council there, so. So that 75 number is more accurate to 15, 16 actual? Because everything we're seeing is trending up in health insurance. I was just curious. Yeah, it's a change in what people select with the change in the council. Okay. Also on that line item, I'm just, you know, we can come back and circle back this at another point, but.
28:59 I just think that if we're going to clean things up, maybe a community support fund would be a better line item elsewhere. Everything else looks to me like an actual council expenditure. I feel like that might be, you know, we can have the discussion, but I feel like that might be a better place elsewhere. And we can do that. They were there because those historically were very specific council funded items as an option and not necessarily staff driven.
29:24 I just find that peculiar that we threw a couple items in as a council directive on the community support fund. Otherwise, I'd drop those in the general services. That would be my suggestion, but I think we can circle back and discuss that. It's the same for contractual services in here, too. Well, contractual services is more for special projects with council, so that's what you guys request, something in particular, a small dollar amount. That's all I have so far.
29:55 Nothing. Before I begin, I want to kind of talk about a couple of elements of the budget process that we go through that are critical. Number one, I'd like to thank my partners.
30:19 Director Lovell here, as well as my staff, because a lot of effort was put into it in a very short period of time, and I know they all have day jobs, but there was a tremendous amount of work and support that went into this, so we got it done pretty quickly, and I'm happy at the position of where we are with the budget so far. In particular, I want to talk about the salaries and benefits and that component. We have a number of complicated spreadsheets. We start out with every employee of the town, their pay rate,
30:46 What their selections are for healthcare and all of the benefits that are associated with their particular job as well as special function pay if any of that exists and we roll that all together into one sheet. The department heads then take an allocation of that especially Grady and Stu have employees that cover many areas of this budget and so a percentage of their time is allocated to those areas of the budget and then we'll go through
31:15 And run that allocation out there. And so that's how those calculations are made. So you'll see some variances year to year and some things that, you know, look a little bit odd. Sometimes, you know, we had a lot of moving parts this year because of our contract agreement. We had about 2.35% reduction in some of the contribution we were making, which was in the salary lines. But then, you know, we always have some increases in health care and such. And Colin, you're very astute to know that that definitely is going up.
31:43 Across the board, we just had, you know, just a different mix, as Dan alluded to earlier with the councils. So those are all put in and worked and cleared. There are a couple of instances as the staff goes through if there's a request for those. We've highlighted those in the gold, I call it, because they give us an opportunity to pause and talk about those. Those are also areas where you guys kind of should be asking questions or maybe, you know, wanting to give input.
32:10 I know this was late in getting to you. My intent for this process was review, walk through, question, share your thoughts for certain direction would be helpful on next steps, but this is step one of a couple before we're getting to the end of the process on that. We try to distill it down. Dan mentioned earlier about some of the big rocks. I kind of call it gold mining a little bit or gold panning. If you've ever done that, you've put a bunch of material in your bowl and you take the big rocks out that are really...
32:39 You know, of no value. In this case, there are things that you can't really adjust or touch and all those committed activities and things. So we kind of get down to the nuggets of what we really can work on and where we have opportunities. So that's just a quick about the process a little bit, about the document, and we're walking through that. So I want to start talking a little bit about my section of the process, talking about my staff. So these departments would include
33:09 Human Resources, our accounting department and our revenue team. So those are the ones that are direct reports to me, as you can see on the screen there. And those all are just, that's the number of people associated with that. This particular, I'm going to kind of move pretty quickly through this because I don't have any asks, essentially. It's really just going to be, here's the process of what we go through. But it's a good exercise to talk about some of the things that
33:35 We could do some of the service level elements and just for an educational piece. I'd also like to talk a little bit about there's some it's going to be a little bit blended between next year's budget and then third quarter adjustments which are coming up to you at a normal council meeting where we'll talk about excess TOT for the year. We'll talk about the needs we need from a budget perspective from
33:57 Costs of snow removal and other excess areas that we have, and we'll have some recommendations of where to fund that excess. And looking at the TOT numbers, even for February, which are hot off the presses as of yesterday, we're going to set another record at $2.4 million. So we're, you know, in advance of that. You look at this budget of $11.6 million, and we're going to be four and a half to five north of that. So good numbers to project.
34:26 So I want to talk a little bit about, so you can see the major accomplishments of my team for this year with human resources. Mainly we're talking about training focus. We're trying to develop an overall training program that really focuses on sort of leadership. It focuses on the needs of the department specific and then what can be brought across the base. We did a survey to see what are the needs out there.
34:52 And then we're sort of pulling that together and going to have a recommendation. You'll see that for next year's goals is that we kind of roll through that. We have to be cognizant of the fact that training is expensive not only to conduct, but also in the labor side because you have to, those folks have to go do that training. So this really is requiring, it's a fine tuning and a management through the process, but it's important to do that.
35:11 Policy updates. We have a number of policies throughout the town that we want to update on a regular basis, and we have a goal of every two years that we roll through those. And Cassie's an army of one who's working through that now. We, you know, sort of Dan and I are the ones that review and kind of maybe hold that up a little bit, but that's the process of getting through those. Hiring processes, we've definitely tried to enhance customer service. That was one of the things that I had kind of brought to my...
35:37 Main topics and goals is how do we improve our customer service and responsiveness. In this particular area, I was just adding more to that. But the other thing I want to talk about, family culture. That is important to me. We want to develop a very strong culture within the town's staff community. And that's from the police to the folks out in the yard to folks on my team.
36:04 All of those people are in the same family, on the same team, and that's something that we are really stressing and really driving, and we'll continue to do so. Revenue team did a number of process improvements, and you folks have seen that as we've tried to bring that forward in what we do with how we handle accounts, how we process customers, and our approach to that, as well as account cleanup, so that's really mainly around, so we've got excess balances or something out there, we need to clear those up.
36:33 Get all the money collected that's out there if there is anything and work through that. I guess we have two processes improvements because I put it on there twice, but it is important to know we're working hard on that. And then team building. So that's a small group, but they really, we're really starting to coalesce a little bit and get better at our work. And that's important across all the board. I'm trying to get that backup support and that really that team atmosphere and we're doing well with that.
37:01 The accounting team, it's really been around Cassell refinements. We're trying to launch that. We've launched the program. We're trying to refine how we work through it. And that's been pretty good. Reporting, some of what I've shown to you guys, we're going to enhance that next year and improve that. But that's something that we were able to do this year is really how are we going to do a report in a way that's really easy to follow in the processes as they go through.
37:27 Again, process improvements for the accounting team. It's really around evaluating the way we do things and is it the most efficient way? Is there a better way to do those? And so we've focused on that. And then staff communication and support. We have regular team huddles, meetings, things like that. So everybody's on the same page and there's no confusion. Service level, just want to throw those in here. And these are really, you know, an example of...
37:53 How we go about measuring the performance and what it would take to do that. So as preparing new and updating town policies, as you see on your scale, we're about a B plus on that. To get an A, we would require some part-time support, but we're not requesting that. Recruitment and employee for all open positions, we're doing excellent on that. No changes. You know, conducting the training and things that we're getting through. It's really...
38:17 Not a measurement of our performance on that, but really the funding that would be necessary for those training programs. And so that's kind of an example of where resources could be allocated to it that would enhance that process and that service. And then the standards that we use, you can see those are clearly stated there. Finance. And so finance, we've got opportunity, and I think we've got some things that we can do.
38:44 With existing staff, so no resources are requested, but it's really more refining processes and focus. We are working through, I like to put on there that if we wanted to improve our reserves, which as you guys know is important to me, it'll be coming to our council meetings in the near future, we allocate more money to the reserves and we get in a stronger position that would improve that function. TOT collecting, you know, we have
39:12 We have to implement the audit program. That's kind of where I'm not very strong in. We've got opportunity with perhaps an online support system that's coming up. I think enforcement, we're doing really well on that for what we have. In administration, that's good. Becoming a tax collector is a tough job. You get to answer a lot of questions and a lot of calls, but I think we're doing pretty well on that.
39:36 One of our goals is no errors in the process. As you guys know, we've set up for that with our new procedures where we're going to forgive P&I if we don't follow through on our steps. So we're sort of enhancing our accountability. Enforcement actions, we're actually launching those within two days of finding that, so that's pretty close on that. Staff fully trained, we're working on that, as you'll see in the next slide. And no errors in payroll processing.
40:05 CASEL is kind of a challenging system to work with at times. There are some things that make it very difficult, and so we're learning through that process, and there's opportunity there. And one of the main goals with CASEL is, number one, let's get that ship right and set and functioning so that these guys can rely on that, and we'll focus on their training and going through it. Looking at the focus for the next year as we're going through that, leadership training, really more heightened focus on that.
40:34 We want to work on our employee evaluation process. We're already right now highlighting that. We've had some things that are not really followed through on a timely basis, and we're making sure that that's done, taking ownership of that. The Civic HR, which you guys approved, we're implementing that process. And then that family culture continues. That's going to take probably a couple of years to fully vet through and get on the ground, but we're going to continue with that.
40:58 Revenue team training. I mentioned that earlier. We're going to do baseline as well as specific. So it is what do we need to cross all revenue specialists and then what would be a specific one that we would do for individuals. The online rental search engine, which would be the STR helper possibly or host compliance, one of those. I'll talk a little bit about those in the budget process. And then we're launching the audit program this year. It's going to take a little bit of time.
41:29 And then I want to define or refine our process for stopping the zoning violations. It's a very challenging thing because it's so lucrative, but that's one of their biggest headaches and things that we really want to focus on. For the accounting team, we want to start to develop a longer range view of the budget. So we work through that process. There'll certainly be refinements to my approach to this. This is my first attempt at the budget. I'll be able to go through that process and make things a little bit easier and get ahead of it and especially help out the team.
41:58 We're going to update the cost accounting system, setting the fees out there, making sure those are up to date. When we talk about regular monthly, quarterly, and financial processes we find, it's really that system, how do we do things. And then reporting and enhanced work with the NGO teams, it's really getting that, you know, we're getting closer together, and that's a good thing, but we'll improve on that. So page eight of your packet is where my presentation begins. And I really...
42:30 You know, everything's pretty much straightforward on here. I don't have any more incremental asks slightly in training. Everything else is sort of a role. We expect consistent from one year to the next. And the finance team would be the revenue team as well as the accounting team. Next page, we have 417, which is CASI, and that is human resources.
43:00 Managed to get out of whack here. Again, no real training, no real changes on that except for some of the training elements that we're going to do. You'll see the numbers fluctuate around a little bit from the comprehensive leave. That's that minor adjustments that I talked about year over year as things change. And that you'll see that across the board on any department's presentation. And the next thing to on page 10.
43:32 Is where we get into some of the other areas that I was going to cover. So TBID, for example. TBID has a couple of different components. Certainly there is the tax that comes through. We're budgeting that at $5 million. You can see the distribution. I used actuals 15-16 as my basis for distribution. That $5 million is probably a conservative number. We have, we collected $5.3 million in
43:59 Well, 5.1, as you can see, for 15, 16 actual, so that's a very close number. Down below that, we have $100,000. That actually comes back to the town as an administrative, since my team does all the collection for that, all the calls and all the background. We get 2% of the total, and that comes back to support admin services that we provide to do that. And so you'll see the pass-through that goes to MLT is 4.9 million. That's their net.
44:29 Budgeted number as we expect to see. And the next section is Measure A dollars. That's something that would be a fund contribution from the general fund. And those are set at $2.4 million. Those two numbers combined gives you a sense of what we're budgeting. Expectations going to MLT, about $7.5 million for this year.
45:05 Rob, can I ask a question on that? Yep. So this is projected, actual 15, 16 is the actual percentage of TOT that went to them? Because we budget a certain amount that's going to go, then the excess over that, when we have a bit busier than normal, we hold that in a reserve, or we send that? We actually transfer 100% to MLT to them. Right. Yeah, it's at 2.5 points of the 13. Right. Less.
45:32 $215,000 or so. So like last year, it was just over $3 million that went based on actual collections. And that's everything except for interest penalties and that component. But whatever we get actually in the tax, be it through enforcement or payment, they get their share of that tax. Right. But the interest and penalties that we collect, that goes to help pay in the finance department budget, I'm assuming, pays for those services. It stays in the town budget too.
46:00 But we really don't budget those because they're volatile. And if we depend upon those, then, you know, we would get into trouble. So those sort of become excess fund balance potential things we use for capital at a later date. To clarify that measure eight dollars, 2.5 percent. So it's not 2.5 percent of the total. It's that two. If you have 13 percent of the tax, it's 2.5 of that number. So it's a pretty big, pretty big number percentage of it, if you will. And then for 15, 16 actual that.
46:30 3-1 number. Does that have multiple components to it? For example, business tax cert, is that included in that number or is that separate? Yeah, business tax, the $250,000 and that is included in that number. That's in both of these numbers. It's also on the budget. Can we get that broken down in a future iteration? Sure. We could show that as a note. Just a total line item with the components.
46:53 Yeah, because that's not related to Measure A. No, the business tax was a commitment to Councilmember, so that's still in here. That is rolled up in this budget. That's in that 2.4 in that 3 million number. I'm supporting what Colin's saying to split these things out. You can show those two. Okay, thanks. Next on page 11, looking at Department 990 debt services, and that's really a place where we transfer funds to pay all of our debt services, and you'll see we have a $200,000
47:24 Fund balance built into last year's budget, and then we have a $200,000 deficit this year. That's an example of using the fund balance. We have a $400,000 payment. It's the final payment that we need to make on a loan. So in this particular case, we're allocating just the needed funds for that, and that shows when we show the payment without the revenue, that's where it shows that deficit.
47:46 But we have, you know, all of our debt service, all of our debt payments are located in this, so it's very easy to follow exactly what we're paying out debt on. And some of it's external, some of it is internal. We have a loan to the garage service. We pay $340,000 a year. We're going to pay that for another 11 years to repay a loan we took a few years ago. And then the final one, the interfund transfers, 599.
48:19 At the very bottom, that $5.91 million, that's to record activity of what comes out of the general fund and goes and funds the other departments or other aspects of what we do. And you'll see the transfer in across what these guys are doing, so roads, tax, and certainly our debt service is a big component of that as well. But that's where those funds are coming from. Basically three in there, one for the airport, one for...
48:47 Fund 210, which arose in snow and in debt for that 5.9 million transfer out. So it's a little bit of apples and oranges. What do you mean? Last year, is that 13 million? That's what we moved a bunch of money out of roads back into general fund and back into capital. So sometimes you'll end up counting it back that direction from the accounting side as the money moves through. Yeah, you can end up doubling up some things here because it's really tracking the movement of the funds. And so you...
49:22 Dan just alluded to, if you transfer a lot around, it's going to show up in there. Okay. I'm just saying this. Yeah. We need to count for it accordingly as it ends and outs. That's accounting. The budget. Yeah, the budget, the 5.9 is a hard transfer out to these other departments starting. Yeah, the departments would dictate what is pulled, and this number just matches them up and makes them whole. And you'll see some variances if you see revenue and...
49:51 And expenditure differences as you go through. I mean, this is sort of preliminary. We're still refining elements of that. So there'll be some true ups and some adjustments that go on to this. Are there any questions about... I'm going to elaborate on Department 590, some of the debt services. So specifically looking at things that are, you know, fiscal year 1670. We have the garage service loan of 340, which I'm familiar with.
50:18 Debt Service SWRCB of 78987. Yeah, that's a state water resource loan we took out to do a major drainage project several years ago. Okay. There's a couple, I think there's next year and the following year that that loan will actually be paid off. Okay. I think there's two more. And then lease revenue bond 2015-315-709 for 16-17. That's the police station.
50:46 And then MLA. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions on my section? Before we get into the next, any public comment questions so far, which is basically administration? Mayor, Councilmembers, kind of a refresher on the organizational chart and how we're set up. So currently it's the chief of police and then reporting directly to me is the executive assistant for the chief.
51:32 Then I have three sergeants, supervisors, who work three different shifts, which leaves a vacant one shift in the evenings where I don't have a supervisor in charge, so we have officers in charge. And they share responsibilities supervising different programs within the department, including patrol services, as well as a detective who we have assigned to MCIU, Mono County Investigative Unit, part-time. Due to staffing levels, he's there currently.
52:00 Three days a week out of four in the future because of staffing needs, it's going to be two out of four. We also have senior community services officer, she's kind of a jack of all trades, as all my civilian staff are. She's parking records, not records, but evidence, various different things within the department. And then Crystal Stewart, who also is a record supervisor, but again, does a whole variety of things. We currently.
52:27 Have no reserve officers. We had a pretty good contingency before. Actually, Mike Braun is still a reserve officer, but is injured. Dick Wooster just resigned, and he's going to take a position with the Mono County Sheriff's Department down in Crowley Lake. We typically use reserves to help staffing levels, and we keep trying to get more reserves, and there's three different levels of reserve. Level one, which is a full-time police officer status, can go out by themselves and work.
52:54 A level two goes out with a full-time officer, and a level three is really something we don't look at. So that's currently our current staffing levels. But our accomplishments this year essentially have been we've been able to survive and provide a basic level of service. Of course, our staffing levels are low anyway, but with injuries, we had two officers out at the same time due to injuries, and then we had a couple of vacancies, one due to
53:21 A retirement that we anticipated with Sergeant Moskowitz and were able to eventually fill in behind him. We had a couple others that had to be let go and again we had to hire people and bring them in behind. So we've hired two new officers this year and as well as a sergeant as we've moved forward. Due to the staffing levels one of the biggest things that has been a burden has been the excess overtime the officers have had to work.
53:47 Anywhere from, you know, a normal work shift is a 10-hour shift, but they've been up to 16, 18 hours. And 16 hours is a typical number of where we want to, you know, stop due to liabilities, fatigue, everything, poor decision-making that comes as a result of that. So that's been one of the biggest things that's really impacted the department this year, as well as having to move our detective out of MCIU, Jack Lower, back to patrol to cover staffing levels.
54:14 So with that, we've been able to provide services at a basic level throughout the town, but not by ourselves. Luckily, Mono County Sheriff's comes in and helps out. CHP helps out. So we're able to conduct a basic level. We're not able to be proactive in a lot of things other than what I hear about is parking. Everyone thinks we're super proactive, but with parking is the only thing we're able to really be proactive about and try to help change the way we move forward.
54:41 But again, we want to be good partners within the community. We want to be able to say to the MCIU, to the county, that we have a full-time officer there all the time and they can rely on that and not worry about our staffing office. So that's where we're going. So I would say our overall rating from a basic standpoint is a B plus within the department.
55:02 We've been able to respond and handle most incidents with current staffing, but again, we've had a lot of times where we've had the assistance from outside agencies and without the assistance and helping, we might be dealing, two officers dealing with a nine car crash in the middle of the storm, the Sheriff's Department comes in and handles and deals with others, the same with CHP. So luckily with them, we're able to provide. So it's not just us, MLPD that's providing that.
55:29 The future goals, obviously, is to be able to staff up NCIU, be proactive, have everything working correctly within the department, and be able to be proactive from a community standpoint as well as from a crime standpoint. But we're kind of in the basic, just plug the holes as we can as we move forward. So essentially, I'll kind of go through this year's or my request for the budget. Obviously, everyone knows we need additional staffing, so part of that is I'm requesting an additional staff member.
55:59 But my specific request is a lieutenant. And the reason I specifically ask for a lieutenant is, one, it's a management level position, which removes that position from the POA and separates the conflict that kind of happens within that. It increases the oversight from day to day that I'm not able to do over not just the sergeants, but the day to day activities within the department. I'll talk quickly about three instances within the last year that are glaring instances where
56:29 We didn't have supervision on hand at the time and we had an officer in charge and those are the decisions directly related to not having a supervisor and one was an arrest that was improper and basically I'll say really bad and the liability associated with that poor decision making at the officer level could have cost six figures easily in a settlement phase and not even a trial phase and it could have crossed over from state to federal
57:00 Court, so the liability aspect from that one is huge. We had two other incidences where an officer in charge decided not to do any investigation, follow-up reporting, and later found out that these could have been potential homicide investigations had the person actually died. But the level of investigation that wasn't done at the time really could have hampered future prosecution or anything like that.
57:28 Supervision is an absolute need within the department and by adding a lieutenant, it would be a day watch lieutenant who could oversee the day-to-day, supervise activities, also respond to calls and essentially be an additional body on the street as we need, but also give me the go-between at a management level and help change the culture within the department. And I think since I've been here, it's been pretty obvious that I'm trying to change the culture and a culture from entitlement to involvement throughout.
57:58 My organization, that's a key person that would help me continue that culture change and make everything better throughout the department. So, overall, the actual cost, the real-time cost of the position is about $250,000, but through the budgeting process with Rob, it actually looks like more of a $100,000 increase to my budget from a staffing level, from the regular salaries.
58:28 Other things within my budget that I'm actually asking to increase or decrease. One is special operations, kind of a catch-all fund. I need additional $3,000 in that fund because some of our TASA devices, which is the portable output sensors, especially for DUIs, those are antiquated, falling apart, breaking. They were originally purchased with a grant from Office of Traffic Safety. That grant's not available currently, so.
58:57 That's a request. Looking at dispatch services, let me go back up to the contractual services. My budget last year was $40,000. I've exceeded that budget and that's been from several outside sources that I've had to utilize to conduct some investigations internally. So that number's gone up on basically $20,000 over what I requested last year. Dispatch services, do we have a
59:26 A contract with Mono County Sheriff's Department, and it's based on, they provide our dispatch services, but it's based on total cost of the employees, which are 4.2 employees and one supervisor to run their dispatch services 24-7. We pay a percentage of that based on the number of call cards or calls for services that we get versus Mono County Sheriff's Department and Maniflex Fire Department. It's traditionally been going up. Part of that is
59:53 Increase in calls for service on our part, lower in calls for service with the sheriff's department, and personnel costs. So we don't have a hard number on that, but we just added a 15% rub to that to the last year. 35,000. So we don't know the real number on that yet. Training, education, conferences, part of that is there's several required trainings that we have to do within every two years. We're starting to a point where
1:00:22 I'm only increasing that $5,000. We're at a point where several officers have to increase their training. And with new officer hires and new sergeants, there's additional training that goes along with that that I need to make sure they get to. Facility lease. We're hoping for half. Definitely half, but that's where we're at. For sure, half the year should be once we've moved in the new station. Our lease ends in December of this year. So it's half of which.
1:00:51 We've been paying traditionally for every year. And then communication equipment, I have failing, you know, 10-year-old radio, portable radios that I anticipate having to replace as we move forward. I'm trying to find other ways, which currently there's two separate Homeland Security grants that will work with the county, their state funds, that I'm able to purchase new body-worn cameras. Ours are becoming obsolete because of software internally within them.
1:01:18 So we're able to get that funded through them, AEDs for all of our vehicles, some portable lights for different events, as well as major incidences that we could use, and spike strips. And the spike strips are basically everyone knows, but to try to stop cars when they're running from the cops. And there's a good chance that CHP or Mono County would be chasing someone they might drive into town, and we can provide those. Essentially, that's all my increased requests.
1:01:45 Happy to answer questions about any and all of it. Thank you, Al. Could you go back to the personnel? Because we can't really see that. The red would be the requested position. Right. No, I know I get that. I just can't even see the name. So I see that we, okay, are we going to have Eric and Rick around for a while? Are they looking to retire anytime soon? We just got Joe Vedder. The other names underneath there, are they currently?
1:02:17 Pardon? That's all the officers. That's all the officers. So we're down to seven officers, three sergeants, and you? Yes. And then you said, okay, the reserve officer is not filled right now because we just lost a dick. So why did we give him a bird? So he flew the coop. Because he kept us afloat last year. Oh, okay. And then he flew the coop. So the bird was quite a bird. Actually, the bird went to Jack. Oh, it went to Jack. Oh, okay. The other person. Okay. And then what's...
1:02:49 Okay, so then you have Carrie and Crystal down as the staff. Right. And one of the things you brought up, you know, whether people are going to be around, and there's no known anticipated, but there is definitely we're looking ahead to vacancies, either retirements or other reasons. And last year we began a really good working relationship with human resources to provide, to recruit and hire people. We did an officer process and a sergeant process.
1:03:19 And one of the things that are kind of lost in the recruitment process is how long it actually takes. Usually we fly the position for three to four weeks. Then it takes two to three weeks to set up the oral interviews and testing that might go along with it. Then we'll make a decision on who we want to hire. And then we have to do a full background on it. It's required by the state, California Post, Police Officer Standards of Trading.
1:03:42 And that can take anywhere from six to eight weeks. Karen Smart's been doing a great job, former sergeant with us, and really pushing along and getting us ahead sooner than later. But then you offer the job that could be a two to four week window from the time you offer the job to when they actually get on. And then when they get on, we've got anywhere from a two to six week window of training and updating them within. So that's forefront of our minds, thinking ahead and having it.
1:04:09 Ongoing list and application process with Cassie receiving applications and that's where we're at. So if there is a position that is allowed for next year's budget through council, our ask is that you allow us to start that process before the end of this year and before we, you know, next year actually starts because the process does take so long. So we're looking at five, six months? A fast one would be three months. Okay. And that would just be four?
1:04:38 The lieutenant or just police? Anything. Anything. It looks to me, if you don't get another police officer up there as well, you might as well, like, invest in a psychiatrist because that's not a lot of people covering the time needed. And you can't anticipate injuries and, you know. Yeah. Just tell people to stop getting hurt. That's right. And if you recall, we service, you know, not quite 24 hours a day.
1:05:06 Well, I'd like to get back to the 24 hours a day eventually, so that's what... I don't know, we have a three-hour break in there. Yeah, but... Any other questions? No, can I have another police officer? No. No, no question. Well, and essentially a lieutenant would be an additional police officer filling a position, but obviously... Not so much on the road. We want to get to the point where we can...
1:05:31 You know, have an additional three, four staff members or members of the department so that we can be good partners within the county and provide the services that, you know, so we can actually investigate our own cases with MCIU and potentially start working some narcotics related stuff with them. Yeah, so I know you're at 11 sworn. You kind of talked about, you know, two general issues at that staffing level, one of which is
1:05:58 Not being able to provide 24-hour service, which is a concern I share, as well as, you know, kind of rampant overtime and fatigue. I know you're asking for one position now. I mean, how many positions realistically do you think will change that scenario? Board positions would be ultimate for me to be able to staff up. We could look at 24-7 coverage as well as being able to provide services, you know, within the county. And we peaked at 17?
1:06:27 I think it was 28. It was authorized. It was in the upper 20s. It actually filled, I think, was in the low 20s. Okay, so low 20s. And then during the recession, it dropped to 17. That's what I'm thinking about. So 17 was the number it was. Now you're down to 11. And your hope would be to get up to 15. But your current request is one additional to 12. Correct. And then you mentioned that it would be an additional 100K to your budget.
1:06:56 But that that's a $250,000 position. Is that savings in overtime? Or how does that break out? It's actually reflective of modifications in some of the salary structures with new versus previous police officers on, if you look at kind of that roll across. It's the same as what you talked about with other departments, how you have those adjustments. For example, the MOU, there's some moving parts in there. It's around 2.3%. And so these guys have high salaries, so those adjustments show up.
1:07:25 A bit clearer. I'm assuming part of that is the half lease over the full lease because the new facility is a CIP project so it doesn't show up in the police budget. Is that correct? Yeah, because that lease is now at the debt service payment. Right. I'm having a hard time following that. We already went through employee negotiations and established an MOU. So how does hiring a high-level position
1:07:50 Reduce our employee costs for COPS. In a comparison to prior year budget. What's that? In a comparison to prior year budget. So prior year budget had old, prior to the MOU application, those rates were associated in the prior year budget. And so when he's talking about an incremental, it's...
1:08:10 When you're looking at... It's not a pure apples to apples comparison of what the costs are... Right, but when we went through the MOU process, there was not a significant savings moving forward. It was kind of a wash, and you'll see it in different places here just in terms of... So the problem with a wash and an additional $250,000 position, I'm failing to understand how that's a $100,000 net. It's not just personnel, as Bill mentioned. If you look at the total budget of a one... What was it? Sorry, I just...
1:08:36 I mean, I can give you, we can go, officer, by a few minutes. It's just important for me to understand what's going to be the net additional cost. I mean. The total budget went from 3.7, adopted to 4 million. So it jumped up. You had a retirement. Yeah, we had a retirement here. We backfilled here. They left here. We brought in a pepper employee versus a classic person. It's a total budget adopted to adopted goes from 3.68 to 4.
1:09:06 Oh, so, because there are other savings outside. Which is not 100 grand. No, it's a higher budget. Al was talking just to that personnel. Just that one particular line item. But to answer your question, Colin, it's 200. The cost of that is $250,000. The cost of adding this is $250,000. If we didn't add it, we would have a savings over last year's budget of around 150. That's the difference. I'm just, I'm going to need further articulation of that because I'm having a hard time following it. Sure.
1:09:37 Very good. Bill. However, I would say you're giving yourself a B plus and your officers do a great job. If I was in your shoes, I wouldn't give them a B plus because to me B plus would have to almost have 24 hour service. So you said going in basic level of service that you're providing. To me, basic level would be a C grade and we need to bring that up to the B grade. So that's the only real
1:10:08 Yeah, so as we talk about new positions, what is the minimum annual
1:10:33 Length of commitment do you think we would need to make in order to do this in an effective, intelligent way? In terms of growing overall bodies? No, in terms of if we're going to go out and recruit somebody, we're dealing with year-to-year stuff. I think the challenge for the council is how do we get sustainable revenue streams over time that can support getting at the level of service we want to get to. So if we're talking about one position...
1:11:01 Is it, are we offering it for a year? We're offering it. I'm just thinking for the recruitment process, we are avid, are we stipulating it's only going to be for a year? Okay, so then where's the money going to come from for all the subsequent years? Yeah, so the assumption on the bodies in here, would that become a permanent part of the budget that we would have to deal with year to year? It wouldn't be, here's the one year offer about, you'd get somebody coming in at this level for that. I think it's a good question as we look at... Right. The revenue, yeah.
1:11:31 Sure. We'll get into that. It just goes back to the fact we still have a structural deficit and if we're going to start taking on multiple year commitments, that adds a challenge to it. That's understood. We've got to be able to sustain the position and that's like even looking and getting grants to pay for positions, a COPS grant, a federal grant. I've applied but we haven't got them. Those are only three years.
1:11:58 Position, but they're a portion of the salary. So even with that, you have to have a commitment in the fourth year, you have to keep them on. So it's up to the town to figure out how to continue. So you're not going to make any proposal to hire an officer or a staff person for a year, right? The lieutenant, if it's authorized by council, that would be, ideally would go out that recruitment for, I'll say, July 1st. We'll probably miss that date, given the timelines. But it would be...
1:12:25 If it's approved, it would go into the next year and it would be here. I'm going. I'm going. Okay. Thank you. So. And that goes back to the fact that I appreciate you looking at the five-year budget outlook instead of just because that answers your question. You'd be able to see that extra officer projected out into that five-year budget projection. So that, to me, that five-year budget projection is huge. Right. Okay. Good. Thank you. All right. Great. I'm good.
1:12:54 So one last question. The new website that the town is going to do, it was sold, it's going to do something for the police department, correct? Yes, it will. They'll actually get them on our website versus the state. Okay, and that's not, but that's not in your budget, that's living somewhere else, but that's going to help to enhance your communication skills? Our current website is antiquated and we can't really change much in it. If you notice, David Scobie stole the picture on the top and I've asked for two years to get it. It's old.
1:13:23 So we could screw off the ground and we have a great wazoo site. Thank you. A lot of work on that and an ongoing contract for that is actually sitting in that IT budget. Yeah, I figured it would go on services. Yeah, I'm assuming, Chief, that we are trying to find reserve replacements. Yeah.
1:13:44 And there's thoughts, there's a couple different ways of looking at it, maybe trying to recruit from retirees from down south to come out periodically and maybe have a second home. And then there's the retired annuitive program that maybe, you know, there's cops up here that want to work a couple days a month or something. But yeah, we're trying to figure, you know, find people that are, you know, interested in being up here. And I know my guys are. Rick Moberly's seeing people on the mountain and talking to them and say, hey, you know, at least come up and be a reserve. And even full-time officers.
1:14:14 Thank you very much. Thanks.
1:14:40 The next one with the public works will be a longer presentation if you want to keep rolling or if you want to take a quick break. Public comment on PD if there's any. Yeah, if there's any public comment on PD. Yeah, like anybody from the public is going to say something. Are we good to do it? Not quite. Grades will be a longer, so you just want to take a break before that.
1:15:04 Well, also I can add, too, ours is broken up into four sections, so as an example, we could do airport, which might be shorter, and take a break, or we could do another one, so we'll have opportunities there, too. Yeah, let's take a five-minute break, but I haven't heard you. So let's get back here in about a little 22F.
1:15:34 In terms of staffing, we don't want to get in a position where two staff people or three staff people are managing 50 consultants as a team because you just run into yourself a little bit thin and that's where mistakes are made. So we'll look at that in the future.
1:20:13 Major accomplishments. You know, every time we go through everybody, I'm going to mention snow. Everybody knows that it was a pretty insane year, but everybody did a great job. It was the first time that at least Brian, who's been here for 10 years, can remember we couldn't get to the airport for two days, and when we got there, it was covered with six feet of snow. That was highly unusual, and I just want to mention they did a great job, aided by Todd's crew, who came down with our most...
1:20:40 Our most aged blower, which actually works much better at the airport than the equipment that they had before. And it made a significant difference, not just in what they can get done, but how they do it. And I want to thank Todd again for giving a tutorial on that piece of equipment. And it really made a big difference. So again, sharing things back and forth.
1:20:58 Snow Management, Jet Suite X Service Startup, again, we facilitated that, but it wouldn't happen without the efforts of our staff down there and working with Pat over at GA to make sure that that could happen. And overall, we think it's been very successful. The Alaska Airlines RNP, again, it's not something that we did, but we certainly facilitate that. It had a lot to do with that, and it's also made a big difference over this winter. Other than that accomplishment, it was just keeping the Terminal and Apron Project going and keeping our relationship with FAA.
1:21:28 Up to speed. I mention it because even though it's ongoing, that can turn left and go south at any minute, so it's something that we really cater to them and do whatever we can to keep FAA happy. Core operations. To digest all the activities of any of these groups into just a few.
1:21:46 Items is a little tough, but I ran this past these guys and they agree. Number one is always safety at the airport. That Part 139 certification or annual inspections for safety and for security are always number one in everything we do. Second, landslide operations dealing with all the airlines on the land side of things, the rental cars, transit, GA, the tent structure, everything else that we have there. And then finally, the airside operations.
1:22:16 Our standards, how we assess that. Number one is obviously safety and that Part 139 inspection was key. But second is we really want the airport to be ready to receive any aircraft that can't physically land there at any time. That's really it because that's what FAA has mandated as well. If you're going to be in the airport and we're supporting you, your job is to let airplanes land and that's what it is to us. So that's really something that we can measure ourselves against. We can measure that our staff is well trained.
1:22:45 And our equipment is in good working order. We can measure whether our land site facilities, whether it's the tent structure, the baggage claim, whatever it is, is in good working order. And we can really measure our relationships with TSA and FAA, basically just through the communication that they have with us and to make sure that works. Our assessment, again, related back to that core operation, safety was an A. We've got, we had one item on the letter this year.
1:23:12 Yeah, and it was cleared up in a matter of days, and that, as I mentioned before, it's very unusual for an airport to have such a short list on their Part 139s. An airport of any size usually has at least a page and a half of a lot of detail. When I was in San Diego, we had items that had been there for eight years, and we just couldn't get to. F.A. understands that. They didn't have a problem with it. The point is, they were on the list. Here, we don't have a list. We really are up to speed with our Part 139. Land site operations.
1:23:41 We, and again, when we started talking about ratings and how we do that, Dan mentioned to us, well, there's a different rating from the public, from town council, from the town manager, from the department head. Everybody has their own rating on how we do that. So it's obviously highly subjective. The way we rate things internally is how are we doing with the resources that we have? And frankly, across the board, you know, I give everybody here an A because with the resource that we have, it's been...
1:24:09 You know, quite phenomenal in some ways. Having said that, land site operations, we'd really like to have the rental cars organized a little bit differently so it works a little bit better. It worked okay, but we have a big open area and hard to do. Anytime we can tweak it to make it better, we're doing that. So we'll continue to try to improve there. We would love to have the concessions inside the sprung structure to have a little bit more variety.
1:24:33 We talk about that to Eric Clark with MMSA all the time because they provide those concessions. But I also understand that's difficult because it's, you know, three, four times a day for 20 minutes you have people there and that's it. But between MMSA and MLT, they do recognize that sometimes that's people's first exposure to town. If they get there and their ride isn't there or their taxi isn't there, they walk in the sprung structure.
1:24:59 You want it to be a good impression. So that's why we rate it even a B, just because we're doing well with what we have, but we'd like to see it better. And this is discounting any impacts of the new terminal and everything else. Obviously, we'll do a much better job then. But right now, we're continuing to look at ways to improve that. Air set operations, again, it's an A. Every aircraft that wanted to land here did. A 737 was here last month. They called and said, can we land here? No physical reason why not, as long as they had a place to park.
1:25:29 So we cleared it immediately and it just wasn't an issue. I mean, that wasn't a physical issue, so we did that. And that's really our goal, such that no aircraft comes here and they can't land because of something we're doing or something lacking in the facility. So again, we thought that was an A. For 1718,
1:25:48 Same again, continue to have no cancellation of delays caused by airport facilities. We can't do anything about the weather. But every place we can, we're at least trying to improve that with the RNP and some other things. So anything we can do. We are going to build a new fence. We're under-designed very shortly on the final design. Excuse me.
1:26:09 So we'll get that done. And the last is just advancing the new terminal in the apron. Again, we really do believe FAA is going to release this very soon, and that will start gaining some momentum and take some staff time, which I'll, again, address a little bit later. Budget issues. Staffing, you know, we're doing fine with what we have. We, you know, we actually look, and I test Brian all the time, gee, can we make do with less? Can we do this? Can we do have more? To manage the current flights that we have based on the time of day,
1:26:38 We need four staff people. I mean, that's just all there is to it. It's just a scheduling issue more than anything else. And certainly the Part 139 and everything else shows that we are putting those guys to good use when there's not an aircraft on the ground because we are able to keep everything up to speed. Another thing we did this winter, we just, we kind of started toward the end of the season, but we are continually going to cross train our, even our seasonal guys at the airport. So if we have
1:27:06 If this year is a new normal, we will have some more help coming up from the airport as necessary to keep roads open when necessary. So that's kind of a constant conversation amongst all public works is cross-training. How can we help each other? Because we will run out one place or another as time goes on. Equipment.
1:27:27 The only thing we're doing is that blower that went down there temporarily this year, we want to leave it at the airport. It's really good for the airport. That piece of equipment works well, and I think you've already heard us mention that we're putting together numbers to order a blower for town, and I'll get into how old those guys are when we get into equipment later, but that's the only real change there. A smaller one, we have looked at a walk-behind striping machine for paint stripes, about $20,000, right?
1:27:56 Even though we have a new piece of equipment in town, which is going to be great this year because the stripes are all gone, by the way, except scenic bypass, they're gone. You can even see the old ones in Meridian, by the way, Hayes, the ones that Mark painted over and stuff, those are coming through with all the plow action we've had this year. The airport has a different situation. One is they have to do it when they can.
1:28:21 Obviously around flights and things like that, so it's tough to schedule with the town forces. In addition, they have an unusual requirement that between each double yellow, as an example, we have to paint black in the middle. That's not something that we can do with our town machine.
1:28:37 We really believe if we get this one piece of equipment, we'll be able to be more effective as staff. We can do that. And as well as we won't have to advertise it. We just did a new striking project just two years ago, correct? Correct. Do you remember the dollar amount on that?
1:28:53 Costs about $160,000. And we really think that if we have a machine of our own and we have the staff there, we can keep up with that on an annual basis and on an annual basis reduce those costs significantly. So that's all those reasons. It doesn't, you know, $20,000, we do watch every penny, but we think that has a significant advantage in how we get our business done. If you look at sheets 15 and 16 on your handout, that's the airport.
1:29:23 15, Rob, is pretty much the revenue side, correct? And I haven't, frankly, looked through that in a lot of detail, so if you have any questions about that or the one highlighted area regarding inter-fund transfers, I'd ask you to ask that at this time. Yeah, the inter-fund transfers is basically what is required from the general fund to support and to balance the budget at the airport facilities. And you can see, at least from a comparison to prior year, it's up about $200,000.
1:29:54 In support. The other note on that one, as you go back to 15, 16, we'll probably see it again this year, we've been doing additional transfers to build up the capital side for a future grant match, and so we have been continuing to move dollars over there. The current transfer number there is just, at this point, to meet the operating needs of the airport and would not add any additional capital improvement program funding. As we get into mid-year, that'll be another request, most likely, for $250 or half a million.
1:30:22 As we begin to look at matching the future terminal grant. What is that fund at currently? About just a hair under $1.1 million. $1.08 or $1.09 for the replacement. $1.80. Yeah. So this is all revenue coming into the town? Yeah, it comes into the airport. The two pieces on here that offset the capital would be the grant entitlement money.
1:30:50 And the passenger facility charges. Second item down. Second item down. Of $100,000 down below $361,000. The two of those would be offsetting the capital of the same amount. How did we get $3,000 from shot.net? We have a fee they pay, right? They pay us a fee. They pay us a fee. They have an antenna on. Okay. Okay. QR lease.
1:31:19 Thanks. Now what our goal is for the next couple years at least is for our PFCs, which are unrestricted facility charges to really help us absorb some of our grant side of the funds. We have applications in for $560,000 roughly for the preliminary design. I think we've actually lowered it down a little bit to four-something preliminary design at the beginning of the environmental work.
1:31:44 Most PFCs should cover that, but again, there's still an inter-fund transfer that comes from the general fund for typical things, but we try to cover those costs with the PFCs. Yeah, just real quickly, airport improvement plans here, that's just, you can go over that again. Where the revenue side, the airport plan, the various numbers, those are all the grant applications versus spelling, well, you would have enough room, but each one of those,
1:32:15 For back to a particular capital project funded by the FBI. Yeah, so it's a one-time. Yeah, one-time shot of dollars. Those are grants we've received, right? Correct, correct. Right. And applications. Yeah, that's right. Correct. Yeah. We've received them. It's revenue. Right. But it's one-time, so it's something that, you know, if you're just looking at bottom lines, it skews the... Exactly. You almost have to look at that operational above the grants to get kind of an apples-to-apples on revenue.
1:32:41 Like number 31 was the West GAA, correct? So there's a million three in there. Our share was 130-some thousand roughly, so it looks big, but as in most things we do in public works, it's step-funded, grant-funded funds come from out of town for most of these things. And for the airport, we retain capital in the airport fund for accounting purposes versus transferring it out like in the other departments to a fund 300 in capital projects. So the airport will have great big swings given
1:33:11 The grant funding and the projects. So it's not a good bottom line comparison. It's difficult. Yeah, that's right. Thank you. Yeah, we can. All right. And I did, I did to get offered to each of the guys overseeing these areas to give them an opportunity to say whatever they like. So Brian, can you vote for two minutes? I don't know if you need it, but you want to explain? Well, you know, I just, what I'd like to do is say that over the last 10 years, we've,
1:33:41 You know, we have essentially a new runway, a new taxiway. We've reconstructed or rehabilitated the whole ramp. So we have airports in very good shape. These projects that are coming up, the fence project is a project that's very dear to me. It's something that I wanted to do. And previous, Pat can attest to this, that previous.
1:34:01 Airport managers have wanted wildlife vents there for years. It's a real safety issue. I'm very excited about that. And that's going to benefit the whole airport, both general aviation and commercial. And the terminal project, obviously, the terminal will create a level of service that we don't have right now. It'll allow for scheduling. It'll be very helpful. But let's not forget that we're going to have additional commercial ramp that will allow.
1:34:27 The GA ramp to take back some of its space and that will help things like Jet Suite and other, you know, general aviation activities. So these two projects that we have coming up are probably, you know, they're just wonderful projects for the airport as a whole for both general aviation and commercial. So we have 1.1 currently in the match account and the goal is...
1:34:53 Three and a half? I think a minimum of three if it's a $30 million project. We've talked to more three to five because some elements we've looked at won't be eligible for grants. Sure. So if we do that, then that bumps up that cost. But I think your minimum is three and then above that gives us some cushion to actually do different things out there. And when we do start that project, by the way, our main and most urgent goals, one is clearly do preliminary design to...
1:35:21 to back up the NEPA process, because that's really what FAA's interested in paying for, do the design to back up the environmental review process. But the two things, the things we want to come out of it is a good cost estimate.
1:35:33 As quickly as possible to have something that we can rely on and then a funding strategy so we can identify just what our match really is. You know, is it 10%? Has FA given us excellent amount in discretionary? How much entitlement? And really figure that out. So that'll be right out of the box. If we're able to start this summer, we'd hope to have that answer before the end of the year or very early next at the latest so that we know what we're dealing with before we get that far down the design process.
1:36:00 Just one quick question. What is the relationship between the airport expansion and the annual federal budget? Well, there is a relationship. Everything has to be allocated on the federal side. For instance, right now, I know that while the FAA and the regional offices have all their grants ready to submit to the federal government, they have not yet submitted them.
1:36:23 Because the federal side hasn't approved it yet. So, you know, we're... So is the money, is the money, the potential funds for the grant that we're going after, has that been programmed? Is that... Oh, yeah. It's sitting there, right? It's programmed, but not allocated. It's not there, but it is definitely programmed in FAA's five-year capital improvement program. Okay, for sure. Okay, any other questions? Yeah, so the tourism group in the mountain are questioning whether our current direction is the proper direction.
1:36:55 And they're questioning whether to redo the TBID and use it as airport subsidy or whether we need to do something else. And I don't know exactly. I'm not privy to all those discussions, but I know they're discussing it. How does that affect? And are you guys talking to them about how that affects potentially the airport expansion? If the TBID were to go away and we stop doing air services, we do it today.
1:37:22 Does the expansion, is the expansion still necessary? Do we need the terminal building? And I know we really can't answer those today, but I'm hoping that we're staying abreast of all of this and trying to communicate so that we know the direction. If air service ends tomorrow because we quit subsidizing it, which could happen, where does that leave us with everything else? And what's the timeline on that so that...
1:37:51 We can tell them to make their decision in such a timely fashion that we don't get stuck with egg on our face. From a staff perspective, we think this terminal is necessary with existing traffic regarding expansion, more flights, more air service, whatever this terminal is, is necessary because, you know, we've all talked about the crowding and overcrowding and FAA absolutely agrees with this.
1:38:15 From a staff perspective, we also think there's some value in continuing to talk to Bishop about the airport or to Inyo County about the airport down in Bishop because we believe there are some relationships that can work better for all of us. Having said that, certainly if the subsidy goes away, Alaska goes away, we have a whole different issue. We do talk to them on a monthly basis. We have our air service group meetings where we talk about opportunities for other routes and things like that. I would hope that if they are going to get
1:38:44 Not even serious, but if MLT Board, as an example, would like to begin discussing those kind of options seriously, that they do come to staff and ask for some facts that will help them in the decision meeting rather than talk about it amongst themselves or what they hear from the industry. Because we have been running an airport, you know, we have some experience that we can share with them about the what's and why's. They have not done that, but we'd hope that if they get into that conversation as a board that we'd be part of that staff.
1:39:14 If I may, I think the request was to look at reliability of air service and do a study on that to bring that forward. I don't think the TBID will still be there because it's marketing and promotion. And so the question came in on, I think, on that. If I hear you, if I heard it correctly, was if we lost commercial air service and
1:39:44 Assuming at that point we'd go back to just a general aviation airport, would we need a new $20, $30 million terminal? No. If you had no commercial air service, we wouldn't be in that boat. So, if that was the question you were... Yeah, well, at what level of commercial air service? I mean, if it's gone... Is it necessary, currently with all the flights coming into Mammoth? Yes. However, if it was decided that Bishop was going to be the terminal, or the main terminus for these flights, then...
1:40:12 Do we still build that terminal or is what we have adequate? Those are questions that have to be answered at some point. I think it drives the bigger question, do we stay at commercial airport? If you stay at commercial airport, I think the answer is yes, you need a new terminal. If you're not going to be commercial, then that's a different discussion. Transit is, again, pretty straightforward. We have a relationship with ESSA.
1:40:48 What we do as a town is, between Brian and Vince, they, one, coordinate with Estev for services and things like that. They take care of our OR town facilities, our bus stops, all the signs, which you're going to have a lot of signs to replace. There's some art projects out there that used to be transit signs. And then coordination with all the events and special events that Stu oversees a bunch of those to this point in terms of permitting. Excuse me.
1:41:15 In terms of major accomplishment, it's really, we implemented route and stop changes as new facilities came online. You know, there's a new shelter on Hillside Drive, just the changes that had to be made temporarily on Minaret while the new shelter was being built. I did want to mention that we responded to writer concerns regarding Old Mammoth Road, and you'll see in a second why I've graded us the way we have in terms of what we've done to better facilitate that. Probably one of the things that keeps Brian the busiest, though, is just
1:41:45 When does the Lakes Basin service start? When does it stop? What do we do at Resmetto? How do we help those? And frankly, we've been extremely responsive. I think ESTA especially has really stepped up and been flexible to do what we can to provide that service. In terms of core operations, really, one, maintain our facilities in town. That's something that we physically do in terms of bus stops and signs. Second is coordinate with ESTA, and third is coordinate with special events. So that's really all of it in terms of
1:42:14 Transit service. Some of our standards are our facilities well maintained, cleaned and ready for service. The second is
1:42:23 Is our coordination with Estes seamless and responsive? In other words, can they call on Tuesday morning at 9 and we can get them an answer very quickly. And some of these things, frankly, we've done as staff, taken them to the town manager and say, hey, look, we need $7,000 more to go down to Red's Meadow. You know, we approve that at that level and we'll let you know later because it's a minor change, but we need to be able to respond in a matter of days or hours versus waiting for the next meeting. And the other one is coordinating with special events.
1:42:51 In terms of how we consider our performance, maintaining transit facilities, you know, I sort of shot it as a B in the summer and C in the winter. The only reason it's a C in this winter is because of what this winter was like. I mean, we ended up having, you know, the California conservation crews out, fire crews, you name it, getting the ice and snow away from shelters so people even find them. I mean, along Main Street, it was 20 feet sometimes.
1:43:17 Over a four-foot burn that Caltrans provided to get to a bus shelter, that wasn't safe, so we actually got a lot of help this winter. But having said that, it was still down quite a bit. Some of our side streets, you couldn't find bus stops, signs, nothing. I thought the drivers were very good, by the way, about pulling over when they saw somebody, because they knew you didn't know where the stop was. It wasn't fair to a visitor in town who was trying to find a stop when it was buried in snow.
1:43:43 In terms of the group modifications, I said a B- because what we did with the gray line, while technically it was correct and technically we got the information out, I agree that we either could have done or pushed ESTA harder to do a better job than we did together as a team, and so we'll take part of the hit on that. We facilitated, John, coming before yourself and the ESTA board, but I told Brian there we could have.
1:44:09 We could have stepped up even more and said, okay, we've got to remember this. Every little change we make affects somebody and get the word out. So I've turned this down a little bit. On special events, we really thought it was an A in terms of responsiveness. Having said that in coordination with Stu all the time, there are things we can do to help the event organizers to be better organized. We didn't get as many calls as we got the year before at the last minute.
1:44:35 Because we pounded on them pretty hard. If you think you're going to need transit, tell us. The year before, I think we got more last minute. Oh, wait a minute. I forgot about the buses. So it's been getting better. We want to continue to improve on that part of it. Staffing, again, it's really airport staff, which is transit staff. Whatever we need to do, they come into town, take care of it. If they have special needs, they'll call Todd. And if we need different kinds of equipment, the coordination is there. It's working fine.
1:45:05 And we suggest no changes. Under equipment, I put coordination with walk, bike, ride because we don't know yet what's going to come out of that process. We want to be able to respond to it. There may even be budgetary concerns. One, it's a very small thing, but something that I've been a proponent of for some time is even in the bus shelters having some kind of audio. My description to the guys is if you're up at the main lodge and you're waiting for a bus for 40 minutes, you don't really care that much because you probably went inside and got a...
1:45:34 A cup of coffee or a beer and you're standing there anyway. If you're standing on Main Street and a bus goes by you, you want to at least hear something. And even the distraction of having music makes the time go faster and the customer service and the whole experience of a visitor is different just having that reminder. Even if it's just a loop that says, yes, a bus just passed, go too swiftly on your phone and you'll see when the next bus is coming. It's a pretty small thing.
1:46:00 I'm hoping something like that even comes out of walk, bike, rider, and we can implement it, but there's no budget for that yet because we don't know what's happening. We're in the middle of that right now. If I can add one thing on the transit. You mentioned earlier, I'll call it the major A dollars, but we have the political commitment of 1% of a TOT minus a dollar amount. So when this budget is structured, it takes those dollars go into this.
1:46:26 Plus, we have a transit fee, about $100,000 is collected. So the two of those ultimately fund this budget. And to the extent that this budget is not fully utilized a year in, those dollars are put into a separate reserve for transit. I think it was either last year or two years ago, we also moved some of that over for replacement funds to start to identify match dollars, hopefully for grants to ultimately upgrade the fleet.
1:46:54 The other piece, and Grady will touch it under our maintenance side, I'm assuming, but the work on the buses and the types of buses that we're getting, the changes are harder and harder to work on. So, and they took a pretty good beating this winter as well, so we will have some impacts there. Yeah, this is meant to be a short summary, so there's a ton of other things we're doing all the time. One thing we're talking just about is their buses, their vehicle replacement, looking into the future, what we can do. We talked to NMSA about what they provide, because they basically fund the red line during the winter.
1:47:23 I think they write a check for about a million three, something like that. And that's significant. And it's also reflective because as we've said many times, nobody knows when they get on a bus here and there in town who's in charge. It's just, it's always the town. It's always somebody. And if, as an example, if MMSA stood up or got stepped up and thought it was reasonable to do so and bought another bus and funded another driver.
1:47:51 We would all look better because the headway in the morning would be 10 or 15 minutes instead of 20 or 30. So those are just things ongoing that we'll just continue to talk about and see how we can improve things, again, related back to walk-by. And the fleet that we have, there was a significant federal investment in a lot of the new buses, is that correct? Yeah. So I'm just wondering in terms of federal replacement, is the federal...
1:48:14 Government may be changing their attitude towards things like this. I'm wondering if we're exposed to things. John Helm could probably answer this better than I, but my understanding of that is yes. And the last two buses actually has to purchase those, trolleys, I should say, and they did those with grants. Actually, one was ours and one was John's. There is a capital replacement fund that Esther has allocated. It's a separate account.
1:48:39 You know, they've got all those buses kind of on a timeline in the schedule of necessary replacements. So I think they're at least aware of that and hedging bets that some of that federal funding may be going away or at least isn't a certainty. Usually there's a match requirement. We're trying to set some dollars for that as well on the town piece.
1:48:57 Brian, did you have anything to add on transit? There's a shorter subject so you get less time. I know, and this is just very brief. I want some of my goals are to try to increase the scheduled service to parts of town that haven't had it before, or Lakeview, Meridian Boulevard. I'd like to see reduction and duplication of service and expansion of service, and I also want to work on the transition from winter to summer, summer to winter with the ski area. Because it changes every year,
1:49:26 It's always a little problematic, and we want to continue to provide service to places like, say, Lakeview or Meridian Corridor continuously and not have service gaps. That's a good point, because last year, as an example, the blue line, they closed Canyon Lodge, so they quit paying. Right. But we couldn't let the blue line go away. There were too many people that wanted to move around town, so we ended up, so like $9,000. Yeah. It happens every year. We coordinate as close as we can, but we never know for sure.
1:49:57 Yeah, so that's kind of some goals that I have for transit, to continue to see it improve. On the equipment side, a lot of the buses and trolleys were bought with federal grants by the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'm assuming we've been moved that ownership over to ESTA? Some of those are still in the town name, actually. Some of those are where on the hook to replace, and some of them... Well, ESTA sets aside some, and we put a little bit aside to help down the road.
1:50:25 Ultimately, I think Ashton's doing the reserve fund for the whole fleet, including the ones that we've purchased. The other question, which has nothing to do with this year's budget, I know the company that, or I don't know, I've been told, the company that made our trolleys is no longer in business. The trolleys themselves are part of the attraction of our, I would hate to go to the small buses or the big buses because it just, it's not a tourist driving thing. The trolleys are great.
1:50:54 So how do we replace it if that company's out or do we just go to Velocity TV and have the crew build it? I think there's other companies that are building it. Yeah, go ahead. Both companies are still in business and we buy our trolleys on. The original Supreme trolleys, our original six, kind of geared towards more of the gas driven motorhome chassis. We've gone with a different, more of a truck bus chassis now and then we're using a different vendor for that. But they both still are in business and we'd still get it.
1:51:24 Service for both companies. Perfect. I love to hear that. And I'd just like to add that our goal is to have more trolleys. We'd like to get three or four more trolleys. Yes. Because remember that in the summer, we actually have all our trolleys out on the road. Yeah. And then we have special events. And special events prefer trolleys. So we're moving away from the cutaway for most routes, and we're moving towards the trolley, and that will make people happy. Make me happy.
1:51:53 All right. We went out of order a little bit here, so you started. Any questions? No, thanks. John? Just a kind of general comment as we go through this. I think that there's a lot of things...
1:52:13 That are involved in the budget that are outside of what we're talking about. I appreciate we're doing this as a family, as a family approach to the town's budget, but I think there's a lot of their, each item we get to, there are outside partners and resources that perhaps as we do this again, we sort of make note of, okay, this piece is contingent upon this partner. This is contingent upon something going on over there. Just as an observation. No, you're absolutely right.
1:52:44 Any other? Maybe I'm out of understanding of expenditures. If you could break out for me into the regular salaries are. The regular salary issue, that's the portion of our staff that's allocated in this budget, primarily Brian's time. Okay. Portion of Brian. As an example, what I went through is I went through every staff person and every one of us is allocated differently. I'm on.
1:53:18 About 10 different areas. Because even if I don't charge something to it, part of my salary gets allocated to that. Done the same with Brian's in very specifically for transit because Vince is more likely the guy in the field. And Brian's coordinated with ESTA and then Russ as well. The actual ESTA service is that contract service number. That's also, I'll say to the extent that we have X amount of TOT money and X amount of fees once we back out the staff cost.
1:53:47 All of it gets put into that contract line item. So the contract itself may be a little different from that, but that captures all of the dollars in the department. So you're saying it probably captures about 90% of the... Yeah. Yeah. Major portion of it. Correct. And so that's sitting there and then, so if that isn't all utilized, it stays in transit and doesn't get eaten up somewhere else in the budget. Okay. And then a street sign replacement. That's all of the, you know, all the bus signs around town and the actual signs related to the buses.
1:54:17 Okay. So we do that work on their behalf. I assume that depending, you know, with the type of winter we've had, that those are better signs than the rest of the signs that I see broken out there? Yeah, ongoing. We have some of those we need to change out. Yeah, I'm just wondering if it might be in a different place in our budget. There is other stuff for the street signs that are our street signs.
1:54:43 This here relates only to transit. We can't use this money. So those transit signs are... We have to do that. Because we're not replacing any of those signs. We start a replacement on the bus signs. And these dollars can't be used for our speed signs or other things. This is transit. So we're saying $5,000 is enough. That's actually $10,000. I mean...
1:55:09 Estapes half. It doesn't show up on the budget. Yeah. So there's more money in there than it takes for months. And the question on salary, 10% of it, or on the time, 8% of the nuclear government is workers' time. Okay. I'm in charge of that salary. Sorry. Thank you for the clarification. Yeah, sorry, $5,000, yeah, we lose a split.
1:55:28 All right. And the one thing I can tell you about allocations is we're always wrong because, I mean, we make our best estimate based on experience, but depending on the weather, depending on how many signs are broken, you know, it's our best shot. So this is the best. It would be amazing, yeah. Right. Okay. Lon, you can come up to the table, too. Thank you. Sure. Thanks, Brad. Good questions. No. Good. Okay.
1:55:59 Thank you. Gas tax and garage service. That's right. And basically, again, as I call it a mission, the garage provides.
1:56:07 I call it seven days a week, 24 hours to support the town because it's not just eight to five and it's not just during the winter. They get a call and a couple of buses have gone down at 10 o'clock on a Friday. We bring somebody in because we can't have them out on a Saturday during the summer, as an example. So we provide that service, whatever it takes. Our main clients are ourselves and the police department, the fire department, the school district, and ESTA. Our staffing level, just in that second paragraph,
1:56:35 If you look at the italicized part, we are not suggesting any changes this year, but we are giving everybody a heads up that as two things happen, one is Estes sleep ages and the town's sleep ages, but also the buses they're buying are more difficult to maintain than the old ones. Even though they're newer, and Long will talk to that in a minute, they're much tougher to maintain. They're more expensive, they take more time, there's more often they have to send things out.
1:57:05 So that's going to be tough. In terms of major accomplishments, again, the job that the mechanics did in jumping in on the snow management was nothing short of ideal. Every chance we got, we were there. They did incorporate some new lift equipment, which you haven't seen that. It's really nice.
1:57:28 It basically changed their lives. It wasn't just an edition, but we'll talk in a minute about how we want another one, because it wasn't just a matter of, okay, it only takes me 20 minutes now. It changed the way we're doing business down there, and again, I'll let Lon explain that in a little bit more detail in a minute. And second, we did get new software to help us with our fleet management and our parts supply and everything else. We haven't fully implemented that. That was something that was Lon's number one priority for the winter.
1:57:56 We didn't get to it. It just didn't happen. Hopefully it'll happen this summer and we'll get him some intern help to help implement that and that'll help things when we get to it. There's no comment. We're going to get to it. It wasn't a priority over this winter. We did other things we needed. In terms of our co-operations, there's really two. One is vehicle and equipment acquisition and maintenance and the second is snow management. That's really it. That's our two big pieces in terms of
1:58:25 Excuse me, core operations. Our standards, clearly, are our vehicles being maintained at an acceptable level in a timely fashion? We can't have ESTA buses down for three or four weeks at a time. We can't have a snow plow down. You've heard earlier that we lost hydraulic systems on the blowers this year. Three of them. Three of them. The average downtime for those was how much? 24 hours. A $30-some-thousand-dollar piece of
1:58:52 Just the hydraulic equipment to remove that, R&R, replace it, and get it back in service. We can have a complete turnaround in 24 hours on a blower. That's two mechanics, two shifts, and up and running. And we, that's our standard.
1:59:09 Yeah. And the reason that's so essential, clearly, is that if we have three buses sitting in our yard or two blowers sitting in our yard and we have a storm, we have a problem. And we don't think that that's an option of not to do that. You know, we didn't call the town manager when the third hydraulic system went down. Okay? It doesn't happen. We had talked before. Something like that happens in the winter. We don't have any choice. We just had to do that. And the only...
1:59:35 The only part that softens it is, as I mentioned it before, as snow goes, TOT, we like to see goes up, and therefore, we have a buffer there. We have to spend the money, but at least there are some funds there that can backfill that if necessary. Not that we're spending that money, but just in terms of our mindset, we have to do that work. So that got done.
1:59:57 In terms of our assessment, our vehicle equipment acquisition maintenance, I call it a B- just because there were times where S-the buses had to go down to Bishop or had to go up to Reno and we weren't satisfied. I mean, Alon wasn't satisfied with the service he was able to provide. There are some things we can do to change that.
2:00:16 We have actually worked really hard with ESTA about regular maintenance, as an example, and scheduling it appropriately. A few months ago, they would just kind of stop in, or they'd wait until a bus was way overdue, and then it became an emergency. I think you've made some real headway with them on making that better. Yeah, we've had a lot of work with them on scheduling and prioritizing, and they've really adapted to it, and it's made my job a little easier. I don't get that emergency call anymore. This bus is out of service tomorrow. I get a week's advance, and then we can schedule it in.
2:00:46 And they're better at breaking and taking it offline and having it ready for us. Before we'd go to pick up a bus, well, they just took it out. You know, Michael shoots our whole day down. So they're actually working with us a lot better to be more efficient. So how we move that B- up to an A, one is we have better coordination with ESTA and they do a better job letting us know when something is broken rather than wait until it's out of service.
2:01:10 A little bit lighter winter would help certainly because that changed our priorities entirely. A lot of our administrative tasks and things like that just fell by the wayside. But it was a different kind of year. So we actually expect it to be much better than that next year. But I think, again, we rated it ourselves. With the resources we had, yes, it was an A. But we want to look for how we can do things better in the future. The lift that Lon will talk about will help that as well. In terms of our goals,
2:01:39 It's going to be a big deal this summer in terms of rehabbing, rebuilding our blowers. And when we ordered the new one, which is on the schedule and absolutely necessary, just building that thing, we are going to be looking for outside help to do that, whether it's another garage or another mechanic that we, again, it's on a contract basis. But we're not sure right now when winter is over, as an example. It was snowing a few minutes ago. Hopefully there's not too much.
2:02:07 But we really need to get back and do a real good job on all the equipment because it's not in the best shape right now. You took a pretty good beating this year. I want to mention right now that we have had a request from Mono County to talk about Tioga Pass and getting the road open down to the gate.
2:02:25 We think that our priorities need to be the Lakes Basin and Red's Metal Road when we're asked for that. In addition to everything we have in town, if we for a second send a piece of equipment or something down there, one, that's a much different job than we normally do. There's going to be a lot more ice and a lot thicker drifts and things like that down there. And while we would love to help.
2:02:47 At this point in time, you know, our recommendation is, you know, our priorities are elsewhere. It's been a heck of a winter. We have our own issues with Lake Mary and Reds Meadow. So we'll pass along at this point that, you know, we're not able to help. If things change, it'll change. But right now, I think between Todd and Lott, they would chase me if we send a couple pieces down there for two weeks. That job alone is probably a month. I don't know how much work they're going to have to do, but I just don't think we're available to do that.
2:03:16 When did they want you to send down the equipment? The other day at the Town County liaison, they had asked that question about could we have any assistance in that. They start their avalanche training at 28th, it's mandatory, work up there, working with the ski area as well for things. But the question there is, yeah, we'd take a look and see if we have anything that could help. And the answer is, frankly, no, we don't, with the broken and the other two areas here. But they would like us, they're up, it's up to Caltrans to get them up to the gate.
2:03:45 And once that's open, then they can start on some of that. But they have some pretty large drifts they're going to have to work through. 50, 60 feet. Have we provided that assistance in the past? Todd? Have we helped them with Tiger Road in the past? Do you know how long ago that was? Yeah. It's been, um, probably been 15 years or better since the last time we were up there. I think the last time we were up there, I'm not sure if it was the last season or we did a season after when that park employee passed away from the avalanche.
2:04:15 That happened up there. The town kind of bowed out then, not only because of the commitment that it was, but the danger. In terms of the budget issue, staffing, again, we're not suggesting any changes, but we're going to continue to reassess and talk to us about their fleet. I don't know, and Rob can probably help me on our billable rates through the garage. We think we're very competitive with other garages.
2:04:47 Because a private garage is an example. You go in and you're going to get an oil change. Well, that's that price. That's that price. It doesn't really matter how long it takes. You know, there's prices for certain things. We work on an hourly basis. And we would contend that if you add up our hourly charges, we're probably cheaper than a private garage. And we have a very specialized, you know, a set of things that we deal with anyway. Basically, it's $95 an hour. Yeah, that's what it is.
2:05:14 So we think if we add another mechanic, does it really cost us money or gas tax or any of that money if we're billing that time out? We're not sure of that and we're not suggesting we add one now. I'm just saying in the future as if lead ages and the things change, we really are going to be looking at that hard. So that's a next year kind of a discussion. And even on the administrative side, ESTA creates a tremendous amount of paperwork and record keeping for myself. Everything's DOT, everything's all regulated by CHP.
2:05:44 They create a huge amount of workload on the administrative side also. In terms of equipment, we already mentioned the blower, and that's not really necessarily the subject of the discussion of the budget. It's just, you know, we have the vehicle replacement money there. It's necessary. We need to do it. And we need to send you a note on that. We'll show you the age of the other four blowers. According to the schedule of replacement in 15 years, they should all be replaced by the end of the next five years.
2:06:14 Depending on the snow loads and how much we work them, they might last longer. They typically do last longer. The one you want to replace now, is that a 2,000? 2,000, yes. So it's 17 years old and that's about ready to go, so 15 isn't too far off. That's actually the blower we're going to put to our backup blower, the one that we're moving to the airport to 1983? 97. 97. 97. That's 93. Happy to have it.
2:06:44 So the issue there is just a reminder, we will be buying... Well, the loader's 83, that's what was in my mind, the lower is the 97, and it's a 94 Kodiak that we're going to take out of service that's done right now. So we'll end up with about a $400,000 piece of equipment being purchased. I would like Lon to go ahead and describe what the difference that that one $40,000 lift has made, though, because it was much more than he even thought it was going to be.
2:07:13 Well, when we added the, um, the ESTA buses into our fleet 2012, they're what they call low-lying buses. Long story short, about eight inches off the ground. So we didn't even have a jack to get underneath it to change a tire without backing it over lumber, putting a jack in there and lifting it. Well, in addition to these above-ground hoists we've got, we can actually put 45,000 pounds up in the air now. So we can put them up under a wheel, lift the bus completely off the ground.
2:07:40 Mechanic can walk under it, do whatever he can do. We can drop it out on jack stands, pull wheels. It took probably a four-hour service and turned it into a two-hour service when we do an inspection on it. It's probably a two-hour service now, being able to get it up and down, up, do it, complete it, compared to four hours. So it's cut the staff time in half and the safety issue. Driving up on two-by-fours, four-by-fours, crawling underneath it with the jack, lifting it. I mean, it was just...
2:08:10 Insane that we did it for as long as we did. And adding these four hoists in there, now I'm getting to the point where I've got buses stacked up, one mechanic's got the hoist tied up, and I've got four more buses waiting on it. So that's why we're asking to do another set in there. How much is that hoist? About 40,000. It's actually four hoists. Four pieces. Four pieces. Is it a four-poster? Yes.
2:08:34 And it's really cool. They talk to each other. Yeah, they're all wireless. You put all four of them up for each wheel and you program them and then it lifts up and no cords. It's all wireless. But it was neat to see the difference. It made a bigger difference than any new mechanics thought it would. They thought, oh, again, this will be good. But it's, I mean, even changing the tire before was a very long operation and now it's not at all mass. It's made a huge difference. That's not in here right now. It's greatly needed improvement for the shop. Our technology in the shop was, you know, 10, 15 years old.
2:09:04 We hadn't had anything new in that long. Well, now I need these newer style buses. And the note on that, that's currently not in the budget, the $40,000 for the lift. That's correct. So, yeah. That would be an addition. A lot of this came together the last couple of days. We wanted to, you know, anything we... So we want to make sure that's where the department's request of. Not everything that's requested is currently funded. But that $40,000 wouldn't need an addition moving forward in the five-year projection.
2:09:32 That would be a one-time purchase. It'd be one time, but then you start doing replacement funds for when it works out. So it does have an ongoing cost. It's a cost up front, then a depreciation cost. How are we going to break this down? Because we have street maintenance, summer street, snow removal. You kind of hit the summer garage, summer winter. Any questions you have on this? Any questions on the presentation?
2:10:03 My only question is, we looked at the, I've talked to you before, temps in the wintertime, how important I feel that snow removal experience is. Have we thought more about the potential of doing a full-time by splitting it between departments? We have, and that's actually in the next grouping, which is road maintenance. I'll shut my mouth. There you go. You're just, you're anticipating. John.
2:10:33 Yeah, I'm just assuming that all the, that you're requesting the money that you guys think you're going to need to fix and band-aid and repair everything that got beat up this winter. Correct. I think the whole idea of what we're talking about here is how do we get Mammoth back to, you know. Well, we have that and we'll have another, yeah, we'll have some additional dollars coming in saying here's what the event did to us. Yeah, looking forward to it.
2:10:55 Don't look at my budgets right now. Or especially after January. We have to see much. We did set records on fuel cells and stuff like that. Since I've been monitoring the fuel, 25,000 has been my highest diesel dispersed, 40,000 gallons just in January alone. That's between January alone. My highest month up to that date has been 25,000. We've done 40,000. That's snow removal, ESTA, everything I've dispersed. Do you have any problems like...
2:11:24 We've spent some money on our system in the last couple of years cleaning our fuel, treating our fuel.
2:11:43 Doing some work to our systems and we're going to be doing more. Does it always help that we go through it really fast too? It actually helps? Well, it's just they tend to get water and fuel here. It's underground and we've had a program, we've done it twice so far. So you put your own additives in there?
2:12:00 We put some in and the suppliers put some in. Yeah. Well, that's, I guess, one of the issues I was talking about. I think cleaning the fuel was probably the biggest because where we see our fuel failures is ESTA because their bus sits outside. They sit out all night long. You get up in the morning and half the buses wouldn't start. We had zero problem with that this year. Oh, okay. Is that condensation and stuff? Condensation and just the nature of it being on the ground. You know, the holes there on the ground, the water.
2:12:28 Drains off into the fuel. My fuel monitoring systems will show me how many inches I have in the tank of water. I was running three inches at a 12,000 gallon tank. That's quite a bit of water in there. How do you purge that? A company comes in and they have basically a big pump and filters and they just cycle it through. Once we started doing that, I said, it's got to be cheap.
2:12:52 I think there was about $5,000 in cost of maintenance and what it did for our fuel just knocked it down. And we did have the problems. We've had problems, especially with everything that sits outside. The buses are a big example. The way we focus on all this stuff, it's not like we're the shell station where we can say, well, we're closed. Sorry, you have to go to Chevron. We're closed. You just, you're done. So we take additional measures and things because we know it's an essential service for everybody. I'm assuming we're also using a different...
2:13:21 Biofuel product than what the state was using this year. We don't put as much. We did away with our bio program about five years ago. Bio doesn't like cold and altitude. Any alternative fuel don't like cold or altitude, and that's what we have, and it just didn't work. My understanding, those were the big problems that Caltrans was having this year because that was a state-mandated thing that they had to go to. It does not work up here. Now they know it doesn't.
2:13:50 That's the thing, we could be on a lot of these subjects for a long time, but the National Guard show up, and how many of their trucks wouldn't start the next morning? At least two of them we had to work on just to get them going, because their whole fuel system, they were not ready for this. They just weren't. Anything else on the budget sheet?
2:14:13 So how are we going to go through this? Let me come back to page 18. I just want to make one highlight there. This is on the revenue side for all of this. We'll still have a more detailed discussion on the street side. But as you look at the garage services also has charges to other departments and stuff where they end up getting funding from. But the revenue there for...
2:14:36 The 210 fund, we've heard of that. That's the 210 fund is the separate fund because of the state restrictions on the use of gas tax. So that's why it's sitting there. You'll see the numbers there in terms of gas tax revenue projections at this point. Those will be updated in the next couple of months. We usually get a thing from the state and the League of Cities that do a statewide allocation that balances around. The snow removal one, we've bumped it up. It's highlighted there.
2:15:03 Dollars for next year will be based on the activity of this year. What we did not want to do is overestimate that next year and you inflate that up. That means your general fund support and other support goes down. So then we end up spending that elsewhere in the following year when we don't have the gas reimbursement dollars. Then we have to refund back up and we kind of get a double whammy. So we're cautious on that. To the extent that more dollars come in than we have budgeted, great, that allows us to leave some dollars.
2:15:31 In the gas tax slash road fund, if you remember, that's frankly how we were able to fund old Mammoth Road and some elements there. So we've bumped it to 1.4 million. We will probably get more than that. Right. Based on all the gas we use. But what we don't want to do is then, well, let's reduce our general fund transfer and put more money back in the general fund for other things. And that creates a problem the year after. So we try to smooth it out, if you will. So that's, yeah.
2:16:01 That's why I wanted to highlight that. It's a little bit low probably. And then we also, part of that snow reimbursement, Cindy, I don't remember the percentage. A chunk of that goes back to the assessment districts. It's not all town revenue fuel. I don't recall the allocation process, but it goes back into those great pieces. I do it based on each of the assessment districts and the town. And there's a percentage. I have a calculation that it goes through based on administration.
2:16:33 And everything else. And so I work with the state when they're, you know, it's roughly a little over $100,000. So it's a shared resource that goes back out to those other areas. Based on the amount of snow removal they did in each. Just to kind of highlight that, then the general fund support is that interfund transfer of the $2.2 million there? Yeah. So that's the general fund dollars coming over that makes up the difference when we do the balancing of the budget between the gas tax and the snow removal.
2:17:13 That comes in. Yeah, ins and outs. They balanced. If they don't, then we've got an accountant to work with. Yeah, because I'm just looking at the revenue specifically for the gas tax. Yeah. Yeah, so if we were doing our road budget here in our snow removal, we're relying just on gas tax revenues, $2.2 million would have to go away and we would not be doing much of anything in roads. I understand. So I think that's a good point. Gas tax is not funding our road maintenance.
2:17:47 You know, from a practical standpoint. All right. Thank you. Any questions on that? And then, okay. All right. Well, when we get to streets, we just want to touch on the road maintenance and issues there. Your last word, Lon, you've already participated quite a bit. I just want to thank Grady and you guys for letting us grow our fleet and expand.
2:18:16 Keep up with technology. We've had such an old fleet, and with what we've done lately, we've been able to expand and move back up to the 20th century, and it's been really nice. How long have you been with the town now? This December will be 17 years. He's told a story several times this year that I'll throw on in terms of technology. He was actually on the cutting edge, and he did an interview here at the town. They asked him what his most important tool was, and he said a laptop.
2:18:41 17 years ago, and they all thought he was crazy, and they kind of tripled that. And they did, and then it's been proven out that that's really the difference. You can't walk up to a machine now without a laptop. Yeah, so that's where we are, and that's where we continue to head, and we continue to...
2:18:57 To modernize as best we can and keep up with it because a little piece like that can make a vast difference between mechanics working in the shop. Most of the software and the requirements require training. We constantly send guys to training just to purchase and update our software. It's constantly evolving. Thanks. Don't go far. Nice job. The other piece in here real quick on the snow stuff, it's on page 21. You'll see that summer equipment garage and winter equipment.
2:19:24 We break that out because then that's when we're doing the charges and stuff for reimbursement back to the state. We start with the process with an estimate of how those are going to break apart because the summer stuff we get no reimbursement for. The winter stuff we do is we make a break on that based on historical trends and elements and that helps us in our... So the summer equipment for garage, the item there.
2:19:46 We get, that's not just our cost, no reimbursement. The winter equipment garage, we break that out, we have those costs here, and that's one of the eligible reimbursement costs. So we break those two, that's why you'll see winter and summer through here break out, it's for that reimbursement process.
2:20:16 Otherwise, it'd just be one department. Thanks. In terms of road and facility maintenance, I'll touch on facility maintenance real quick. Really, we have one staff person, another half-time custodial, which does that, and we'll touch on that a bit later, but there's not a lot to talk about there. Really, road maintenance is the key. And really, what Todd's group is charged with is maintaining everything within the town right-of-ways.
2:20:42 Everything, whether it's a street sign or whether it's the striping, the curbs, the gutters, the drainage facilities, everything. And our outlook for this next year is really getting ready for this summer and next winter, and that really begins now because we're already assessing the equipment and the people and what we need. It's going to be a shorter summer than usual to get things done because the snow is going to be here longer.
2:21:04 As Lon said, a lot of equipment has taken a beating, as have some of the staff, frankly, in terms of the hours worked and everything else. So our big push now throughout the summer is just to get ready for next winter. In terms of our major accomplishments, again, a lot of the snow management efforts, and we'll talk about that again in a few minutes.
2:21:29 We have incorporated some more technology again with our GPS between Chris and Hayes and engineering. We've worked hard to identify the facilities around town. We have a good handle on all the signage, all the storm drainage, and a lot of the other materials, and it's already making a big difference just knowing what we have. Without the implementation of this third bullet of the stormwater management plan, we use the technology and the vector truck we bought used a couple of years ago. Without that, this winter,
2:21:58 Those first drains would have been even worse now, I'd say, because we were ready for it as best we could be. All the drains were clear. And it was a combination of the technology and just a vector truck that made a difference. So it takes both. In terms of core operations, maintain facilities within the town right-of-way in a manner consistent with a resort community.
2:22:20 That definition is also up for grabs. We can talk about Main Street at Old Mammoth Rose as an example, which is really Parks Maintenance does more of that than Public Works, but regardless, you know, is it dirt? Is it turf? What is it? How is it maintained? We just basically try to keep things looking and working as best they can. We'd like to put more money into it, and you'll see in a few minutes what we're looking to do that, but just trying to keep the appearance and the functionality as good as it can be.
2:22:50 Second is really work with Lon's group on maintenance and acquisition of equipment like the blower, like the vehicles. I mean, you've heard a joke about the vehicles out in the parking lot and it's, you know, it's not really a joke. They are pretty scary sometimes. So we did sign up, I think it's three vehicles for Public Works and one for Rec that we're ordering as soon as Lon gets a chance, but they'll be ready for summertime. And some of that equipment is in the 250,000 mile variety.
2:23:18 We don't judge equipment based on mileage or years, by the way. If it works, it works. We know that little blue truck and some others, they still work fine. We'd rather have nice new vehicles, but that's not a need, and we're focused on what that need is. Third is perform seasonal non-snow repairs and maintenance, which we're going to have a much longer list this year. And then clearly the fourth core operation is perform snow management operations. Our standards.
2:23:47 Are the facilities maintained appropriately? And what does that mean? Well, you know, we'd like it to be even better. There's a couple of cross cutters and there's some curbs around town that are just plain scary. There's a sidewalk out here that we didn't build on the south side of Meridian here that is in our program. We'd like to replace it next summer because you need hiking boots to get through part of that. You know, it's a serious state of disrepair. But that's part of our responsibility and the snow management itself.
2:24:16 In terms of our assessment, in terms of maintaining the facilities, again, I will consistently say based on the resources that we have, we think we're performing at a very high level in terms of what we'd like to do and what we'd like to see. As an example, the banners just came down on Main Street. I've got three calls on it in the last week. We happened to be doing it before I got the first call, by the way.
2:24:38 Would have been nice to have another piece of equipment and do that a month ago. They were looking pretty tattered, but we focused on the priorities. And again, I'll let Todd address that in a few minutes. But we're doing what we can. We'd like to do more. So internally, yes, we're doing great with the resources, but our standard is higher. So it's continually frustrating that we can't get to something. It's not a matter of, well, we don't have the money, so we don't care about it. It's like, no, we still care. And that's the frustration. It's not being able to have the staff equipment to get there.
2:25:07 To piggyback on that, we talked about grading ourselves. Part of that was, okay, what's our departmental standard looking at? Okay, part of that, here's what we can do with what we have. What would we like to be doing when people drive into town? We'd like to see everything cleaned up and spruced up and nice. You know, we do a big push on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street for July 4th. Guys get out, paint, do everything. Part of that reality is we're not going to meet all those expectations because we do not have the resources to do so. So that was kind of this.
2:25:33 Here's the expectation we put on our sales. Here's what we'll do with what we have. And that's where you kind of get this grading, this little different. If we wanted to hit all that and meet all those what I'll call public expectations for look and feel, you know, throw another four or five people at it and the necessary equipment and we can probably meet those expectations. But given the scope, especially this year with the amount of damage to signs and snow poles and other things, that's going to be a huge cleanup effort that will put a lot of effort into.
2:26:01 It'll need to balance off with the important things, blowing out drains and getting things ready for other elements and then actually the work products on the ground work. Is there a way to put a number on that to say, hey, you know, we've had a lot of damage to signs, banners, streets, all that type. You know, first impression is a big thing. Right. How do we get it back to that presentation, the first instance? Yeah, we haven't really...
2:26:32 Financially put that out. I can take a look at that. I mean, the hard part of that, it's bodies, people, and equipment, everything. It wouldn't just be a, here's a part-time person who will work on it. So, you know, it's hard for that. Right now, we're not sure what we have because it's, I mean, there's now a new little, you know, a sawhorse with a stop sign on the intersection by my place because the stop sign finally melted out of the snowbank and fell over. It was in there and I saw it for a day and the next day it was laying, the next day it was laying down and we had a sawhorse.
2:27:01 There's a lot of those around. But that's going to be our number one goal in front of a lot of other things is just repairing those things that are functional but also cosmetic so that there is a good impression when people come to town. So we'll bounce that off of the crew. We can take a look at that and say, if we had, what could that do? The hard part is getting somebody in trained. If it's equipment needs, then that's on top of getting somebody in to do the work. And how does kind of rehab of our landscape medians fit into that conversation?
2:27:30 We actually are talking from an engineering standpoint. We look back again. We've had discussions every year about Main Street and the parkways and then Old Mammoth Road, those narrow parkways. We have a lot of ideas about putting concrete in them and things. You know, they're on our list in terms of priorities.
2:27:49 My comment to staff right now is that will probably drop because there are so many structural things that are going to be wrong out there. And when you see the project list later, you'll understand that. We haven't eliminated it. But one thing we have done is we at least started estimating what it would cost to on a more frequent basis. So maybe it's once a week. I'll say Manny Scrooge because he's the one who had the contract lately.
2:28:11 Come out once a week, knock down the weeds, rake the dirt. I know it's just dirt. It looks like heck, but it's a lot better. The complaints we get all year long are there's two foot tall weeds there. They don't seem to comment to the fact that it's not turf or something better, which we want to continue to address. We'll have that public meeting this summer as an example. We're not sure what we'll do with the information yet. Once you see the list of projects, you'll kind of understand that. But right now, we're at least going to make it clean.
2:28:37 That's all we can commit to without getting into the budget issues of what we're going to have time to do. Very brief discussion with the water district, but at this point they're not necessarily saying, yeah, go ahead and water Main Street again. So that's not a hack on the table yet. Understood. And, you know, I recognize that we have to kind of look at it as a broader budget discussion, but, you know, my initial inclination would be maybe to not push that towards the bottom. I mean, I think...
2:29:06 The community was pretty understanding of the fact that we were going through some significant water issues, but it's now been two entire summers, you know, and I think it's time for us to look at addressing that as a community personally. And we look at Main Street and Old Mammoth Road separately. Main Street is an example. We're going to be doing the Upper Main Street sidewalk. Sure. Which will make a big difference. There is still STIP funding just a couple of years out.
2:29:31 For Lower Main Street, which will change the significant portions there. So yeah, we will definitely look at that from a planning and design standpoint during the summer. I just can't commit to how much we can get done. Old Mammoth Road is different. We actually got a lot of good ideas last year about do we do concrete, do we do stamp concrete and all those things. And when we go through the list, yeah, we'll definitely come back and prioritize those and give you a recommendation before we do that. But we know it's a priority. I just want to comment that as a minimum.
2:29:58 As a bare minimum, we're going to make it look better, whether it's just cleaning it up and making sure the weeds are out or whatever that takes, because that was a big complaint. But we'll continue to do that, and we'll have another public meeting with the business owners and stuff and try to keep it moving. Turn with goals, incorporate and train staff, including cross-training. Excuse me.
2:30:26 Perform repairs and maintenance within the town right away and continue to identify ways to increase effectiveness. In terms of the technology, one thing we've talked about for the winter especially is we've heard that Truckee is an example as of where's my plow app. That's really nice. On the other hand, the comment is how many more phone calls is that going to address? Well, you know, unit number 13 is not on this street. Yesterday it was here at 3 o'clock. It's now 4 o'clock.
2:30:55 We're ready to address that, but there is a level of technology we'd like to implement regardless, which is really GPS and including our storm drains, there are certain drainage areas, there are certain things we just want to know where they are, and it might help the drivers to be able to see that in a live screen as they're driving, so we are looking at that. Thank you. It's family culture.
2:31:21 In terms of staffing levels, we have been talking about that, and it's a little bit hard to read, so I'm going to read through the lower portion of that. I'll try to keep this moving because it's already a quarter to four. Sandra needs more than three minutes, right? Yes. One, in discussions with Parks and Rec, we are suggesting what's in the budget, frankly, is one additional year-round road maintenance worker.
2:31:50 That's where they would be located, public works, maintenance, working under top. The hybrid part of it that we've talked about comes in that during the summer, we would basically work together, which we meet on a bi-weekly basis already, and this winter it worked seamlessly with Warren jumping across and helping us with everything else. In the summer, basically, one of the road guys would be assigned to parks, whether it's a month at a time.
2:32:13 Two weeks at a time as to a specific job or project that they're doing. But the idea is it helps us to keep somebody year-round that can be trained for snow management because that training and long-term stuff is absolutely important, but it also helps us in the summer. And we've talked a lot about our crumbling infrastructure both on the roadside and on the parkside.
2:32:38 I think together we've all recognized the Parkside has suffered more than most. So we think having an additional summertime worker in the parks can make a big difference. The second is... Real quick on that one, though, to Bill's question earlier. We're looking at that as a new position, not consolidating part-time positions to fund that one. So we left our part-time fully funded and adding a new position that creates this dynamic workforce. That's right.
2:33:06 The biggest need is in a season like this, we needed somebody out there in management, and for a regular summer, you know, we could use them in the road department, but the biggest need was parks. There you go. Never mind, we're going to keep it. It has worked. Next is a summer seasonal maintenance worker, which I don't believe is in the budget calcs yet. It is not. Because the more it melts, you're right, there are more signs, and if...
2:33:34 If we did nothing but fix signs all summer and do the striping, we'd be about it. So if we don't get some additional help, we're going to have a problem. In addition to that, you have to keep in mind that during the winter from November 15th roughly until about now, we hardly let these guys go. I mean, the last couple of weeks has been great. You've got quite a few guys a few days off, but they were seven, eight weeks on end where there wasn't a day off hardly. And that means that we also have a policy.
2:34:03 Which was just renegotiated about how many comprehensive leave hours somebody can have on the books. So we have to encourage people to take the time. We want them to be healthy for the summer. We want them to be healthy for the winter. And to balance that is very difficult. That leads me to the third bullet point where we don't have an additional maintenance worker in this budget on top of the one I've already talked about.
2:34:26 You know, and I'll let Todd talk to this in a second, but he really believes looking forward, we really need to start considering another body there. We understand all the budget concerns, it's not something that's not an essential service, but to balance that with the summertime time off and everything else, we're actually going to do some data on it, but if we have, say, six full-time, it's actually seven year-round maintenance staff other than Todd, there might be two or three of them gone at the same time all summer long.
2:34:55 That's what we deal with. They're gone for two, three weeks at a time. And that means, because we can't let them go in the winter, that just means we're at really enough staff effectively over time. So we'll continue to look at that. In terms of equipment, the only equipment we've really talked about is the blower, which I've already mentioned in two other areas. I don't need to rehash that. What I would like is for Todd to go ahead and talk for a couple minutes about what he sees and how they're doing business.
2:35:25 And one of the key things that I'm sure he'll mention is about training. We have seasonal guys that come back for four, five, six, seven years waiting for that full-time job. They're well-trained. We're having trouble finding those guys now. So go ahead, Todd. Whatever you want. I'm just going to touch base on our staffing levels and our shifts that we had run this year just to give you an idea of where we stood. Basically, our day shift for our winter snow removal this year consisted of four people.
2:35:55 That was one guy in a blower when needed and three guys in motors. Throughout the year, we lost different people. We had to move one of our lead workers to night shift because of the loss of Aaron Willingham, who was one of our season blower operators. So obviously we get more of our snow blowing done at nighttime than we do at day. So that was about the best choice that I could make from there. And then we had to swing.
2:36:27 One night shift guy to the day shift to make up for the loss of Lance Miller coming over to our thing. So we were definitely shorthanded throughout the winter. Throughout a big month and a half of snow, I think we performed decent for what we had, but I think the town's snow removal efforts should be a lot better than what we saw right there. And to be able to reach those goals and get back to where we used to be, it's going to take employees.
2:36:54 What I really want to see at some point is us get back to five employees on the day so we can run four loaders throughout the day trying to keep up and plow the roads and have the fifth guy as an optional loader operator or blower operator to play catch up for the night shift that doesn't get all the blowing done. Our night shift consisted of three blowers and five lower loaders.
2:37:19 It'd be nice to have the fourth blower like we used to have in the past to get the majority of town done in a shift. The loader guys is probably close to sufficient with five, but with all this different stuff that we're taking on with North Village and having to move snow and push snow and go in different areas and with this new Main Street project, it's just taken away from our residential power routes and blow routes so the residents here are suffering. They aren't getting service like they used to.
2:37:49 I only see it getting worse, if anything, you know, just because we're spending more time away from, you know, residential areas. We're out at the tank farms on Sherwin Creek Road all the time because of the wind when it snows. Completely blown shut. Myself, I spent four hours one day opening that road to get cars out of there and propane to the community. That is a waste of time to spend four hours on one stinking road when it could blow a whole area of town. So staffing.
2:38:19 Would help. Seasonal staff. I know we supplement our short staff of full-time guys with seasonal. The issues we're having nowadays with seasonal staff is that nobody wants to come to work anymore for the money that we're paying them. And so people are going elsewhere and we're having a really hard time recruiting. And then I personally don't think we treat them good enough.
2:38:46 I don't think we pay them enough. I don't think we give them some of the perks that us full-timers get. They just get small pieces of it here and there, and I think we need to sweeten the bot up a little bit if we want to try to get these people, because the wintertime, they're a huge, huge part of our plan here, and they're a lot cheaper to have here than they are full-time guys. And this year we had that open all winter, and we were still one short. We did, yeah, we still were one short. All winter. All winter. And that was just barely staffed at that.
2:39:12 You're talking just part-time? Yeah, just a part-time guy right there. We never even filled the sixth position that we had. And then we lost a guy mid-winter, too. He was having a little issues with the snow, had never seen quite that amount of snow, and he just left. So we went and had to go the rest of the winter without him. So it was a tough winter all in all. Not to ignore the summertime. The summer is going to be incredibly busy for us. I mean, we have...
2:39:40 Between our striping, I'm sure you all have seen the potholes that are developing out there. We haven't seen potholes like this on these roads for probably 10 years, you know, 8, 10 years because our roads are in such good shape this winter with all the equipment on them and everything that's wearing them thin. So our summer is going to consist of a lot of pothole patching, a lot of painting of the roads, sign replacement, obviously, everybody's seen the signs too. And don't ignore snow poles. Our snow poles are hammered.
2:40:08 We typically order between $300,000 and $400,000. $300,000 and $500,000 would be about the average. I anticipate a thousand pole order, no problem this year, and that's probably on the low end of it right there, depending when the snow starts melting. So that's pretty substantial at $38 a pole right there. Now they're in snow removal and stuff, rolling into the summer to get back on the roads and stuff, our $580,000 is not nearly enough for our road maintenance budget to keep this town's roads looking to where they should be.
2:40:38 So I think we really need to start considering bumping that around up. And our B roads rated in this town are going to be going to a C and beyond. If we get more decent or average winters, the roads are just falling apart. We need to start putting more money. I'll talk about that in more detail, too, because we'll transition from a road rehab budget that's in the road department versus that money really ends up in the engineering side for an actual capital project and why. But I'll address that when I get to it in a couple minutes.
2:41:11 It's about its staff. Okay. That's really it. It helps us do our job. While we like this much snow, we are hoping this is not the new normal. I mean, we're used to this in Mammoth anyway, but the last three years have been a beautiful study, and two years ago we had 140 inches of snow or something like that. Last year was kind of an average in terms of everything, and this year just knocked it out. So the key thing is we...
2:41:43 Train everybody. We try to get our equipment up to speed and try to be as flexible and reactive as we can because that's all you can do in this environment as anybody here who has a business in town or anything else does. That's what you do. I think the new normal is there is no more normal. So I think that's a simple answer. I've been here 60 years and there's never been normal. And we recognize the manner of extremes. It always has to. It will continue to be. And our mantra, if you will, is just do what we have to.
2:42:12 Don't spend money we don't need to because we're going to need it for something someday. An example in the road rehab budget, we have $500,000 in $16,000, $17,000 we haven't spent yet. It's like the year before because we recognize we don't know how much money we're really going to have until March. But everything is like that. We just try to be as flexible as possible, do what we need to. Todd, you talked more on the staffing side, but...
2:42:36 You know, there's kind of the equipment side of things too. Do you feel like the equipment fleet is sufficient to do the work you need? I think this blower, doing the new blower replacement is going to be a really good addition to the fleet because the blower that will run into the backup, that'll be our backup one if we give the existing one that the airport has to them, it'll be a lot nicer, a lot more productive than what it is. The breakdowns are going to be...
2:43:05 You know, much less. So I think our productivity as far as snow removal and blowing is going to be really good, really good. And then to have a backup blower of that quality is going to be real nice too because it can do so much more than what that one that the airport has now as far as...
2:43:22 It's not, it was never really a real safe blower for town here. They were happy to have it. So, yeah, it's perfect. Don't beat on it too much. The way it was designed, the visibility that it is, it's almost a liability, you know, because you can't see, hardly see where you're going in the thing, and it was, it's going to be really good. Our loaders, you know, all the stuff are coming up in the next couple years too, and I think for a replacement on a couple other blowers within three years or so, three or four years.
2:43:51 Lonnie could probably know what our next one was. I wanted to say it was 05, you know, so 20 would be another one. And it's, they're expensive. But the newer ones, 400,000 on a blower. About 750,000. For everything? We have to buy a loader. Yeah. Oh, if you got a new one, yeah. About 750,000. Two pieces. And we're going to have to start looking at loader needs to, you know, to be able to, some of our loaders are carrying.
2:44:21 Thousands of hours on them too. So that's why we have a replacement, I believe, of 10 years for loaders and 15 of blowers. So as far as, you know, the request coming forward for this budget cycle, it's really just the one blower on the equipment side of things and then the secondary issue around the staffing. Yeah, exactly. The blower would be the biggest equipment thing and we have some little stuff, but a couple of my guys as of recently with our...
2:44:52 Shoulder repairs that we're going to be having to do a lot with from the flooding this year and the rain runoff, we're going to have to concentrate quite a bit on shoulder repairs too. There is an attachment that I was looking into for our new skid steer that we purchased last year. We don't have an attachment for that, so that would maybe be something I would include in there too to help speed out the process and be a little bit more productive rather than use our motor grader out there in the semi. You can do it a little better with this attachment that goes on.
2:45:21 Front end of the skid steer. But I don't think they're significant. They're under $20,000 probably for something like that. Nothing. But I do believe, Rob, do we know what our numbers are for the replacement for it? So we definitely have the funds in the vehicle replacement fund, so that's clear. The only thing that could impact us in the future budgets would be as these vehicles exceed the years that they described. So 15 years would be the life cycle we rebuild that in. And after that, we stop.
2:45:52 Accruing funds. So when we replace that vehicle, we'll begin accruing again if it has stopped. So that could be the only incremental. Otherwise, the funds are definitely there. Are you talking about a loader and blower purchase or just a blower? A loader and blower. This year? Yeah. So you're talking about a 750? Yeah. Well, it's one piece of equipment, though. The blower. Yeah, once they're attached. And that's all it does. No, you buy a loader. We'll need to look. We'll figure out what we're buying this year.
2:46:23 $400,000 or $750,000 is a big difference in terms of, we have about $2 million in that fund, so that's 25% more than that. $6 million. So, cash. So, they just gave me some information on that, so I'll get it to you soon. $6 million, $3 million. Okay. Let's go to Council. Are there any questions on the budgets as you see them here? I didn't see anything.
2:46:52 We highlighted one in the snow removal. This is page 20 of 33. We highlighted that because that's where that body was, that dynamic body between partly snow and partly Parks and Rec. Right. So that's why that was highlighted there. The 580 on page 19 is the road rehab budget. We'll have some more discussion on our capital, actually looking at not waiting a year from now to spend that money, but actually trying to spend it this summer.
2:47:24 Along with the current year money so we can actually do a significant project. That'll be under engineering and under capital. It's highlighted a reminder of at one point we're trying to get that to a million and we're a long ways from that, from road maintenance, but trying to do a large project this summer. Let's move on. Okay, one more. Thank you. From an interim standpoint, we deliver infrastructure projects to support the community and
2:48:05 Also execute our strategic plans. You know, we have the process to plan our sidewalks, the plan, we have lots of them, and we actually are implementing those. The second bullet point there is actually the capital improvement program. We came before you in December with kind of a preface to that. I'll show you one of those documents in a couple of minutes, but...
2:48:28 All of these things, when the priority is set, we'll go back to that capital improvement program and get you a final document on that. The thing I want to mention right off the top is that based on the list of projects, the ones that are funded, not just the ones that aren't funded yet, we need some assistance and specifically an additional intern and then maybe some contract staff, but I'll get to that in a second.
2:48:56 A bunch of major accomplishments. Dan asked for, you know, zero to three major accomplishments for each group. I couldn't leave out many of those projects that happened and got started last summer because they were all significant. And there's an interest in, depending on who you ask in the community, you know, which one is more important, the police station, the Hillside Drive, the Lake Bridge, Lake George Path, you know, everybody has...
2:49:21 Their own interests out there in the community as well. So I wanted to go ahead and list the major ones we had. As I do that, I want to mention that the reason we do wait until now to make these decisions and know how much money we have is three of those three biggest ones weren't on that list at this time last year. In February of last year, there wasn't a hillside parking lot, a CFD project, or Old Mammoth Road. So we are, again, we build into what we're doing enough flexibility to be able to react.
2:49:50 Having said that, when I get the list of projects earlier, I have some specific ask for the authority, as you know, we will do is move forward with design on some things, otherwise we won't be able to do them this summer either. So you can read the accomplishments. It's really just a list of capital projects that we talked about earlier. In terms of core operations, one, we do a lot of development, review, and permitting.
2:50:11 Hayes and Jamie and Sierra and everybody really participate a lot in our DRC process and review of walk, bike, ride, review of the CEQA documents, you know, we participate in that. We also support the planning department and support delivery across all departments, you know, whatever it takes, you know, we're involved in a lot of different things and provide that support. And the last thing was implementing the capital improvement and major maintenance programs themselves.
2:50:37 What's the current timeline as far as completion of the police facility and move-in date and all that stuff? Based on giving them some extensions due to the weather, we're looking at August. Is there a specific date? We've asked them for an updated schedule based on the weather delays and we have a meeting scheduled for next Tuesday to go over that. But ballpark is right around August. So you'll be able to give an update at the Town Council? I will not be here.
2:51:06 I'll be out of the country, but know somebody who can. If we have an updated schedule, we can. Chief, you said your lease is up in December of 2017? Yeah, we built in a couple of months of overlap. The process, you know, hope to move in August, September time frame and kind of have that overlap of the... There's not a lot of stuff to move in. I mean, whatever we move, it'll be... We actually had a meeting just, was that yesterday?
2:51:33 Yeah, the chief's assistant came over and sat down with Hayes and went through in excruciating detail the checklist of things that need to be done for them to actually move in. So we're on top of that, but it is looking like sometime in August. Yeah, and the move-in process will be parallel with the completion of the building. There's some overlap there. We'll be moving things in while we're tidying things up. Okay, thank you. In terms of our standards, you know, it's pretty easy to look at the development review if we get a...
2:52:02 A grading permit or some other application that Community Development wants to look at, we turn around the next number of days if we're meeting that standard. I think we've done fairly well. Some of the larger documents have taken longer. Some of the traffic studies and things for the FAR, you know, that just happened while we were extremely busy with some other things. But overall, I think, you know, we've done well there. Second is support for other town activities. And again, if we get a request from another department, we just rate whether we respond to requests.
2:52:31 In a timely fashion or not. The bigger measure is capital and major maintenance projects, and we'll talk about that later. We'd like to set a cost and a budget for something, move forward and get it done in accordance with that. If we meet that, that's good. But again, it changes every year and changes every season what we're actually doing. In terms of the goals, there's a number of them. Some of these...
2:52:53 Ones that have been identified, we're going to finish our parking and signage program. We've committed that that will come back to you at some time in the next couple of months because we want to implement this summer so that next winter we're ready for that. The second one has not been on the list before but it's become very evident this winter. We want to update our snow management policies and it's not just the way we do our work which will have minor changes. It's really the fact that we probably lost
2:53:19 30% of our snow storage in town due to people parking wherever the heck they wanted to and I walk past a bunch of them on Pinecrest on my way to work sometimes and there's a single family house with six parking spaces carved out up front. That's great for them and they spent a lot of money doing it on the other hand.
2:53:39 Four of those spaces are where we're supposed to be able to put snow. So it's really hamstrung us and it became, it was no less evident than this year. It was just absurd. It was just all over town and it's an issue that we're going to address this summer and with, you know, Town Council support and setting policies, make sure everybody knows before it starts snowing next year that that's not, we just can't do that again because that costs us not just money but our efficiency of our crews, you know, moving snow was.
2:54:06 It was terrible sometimes. You know, you have the blower and what do you do? You stop for 60 feet. Then you add a little bitty area where you have to chunk it up and over or you put it across the street. It just doesn't work. And I think a major culprit was that parking issue. I don't know if you have anything to add to that, but Kari's very aware of it. She's helping us by taking photographs, code enforcement involved. So it's really a team effort of, you know, five or six people in this room that will come before you later with the...
2:54:32 Some policies. A lot of them are already on the books. We just haven't been enforcing them. So, you know, we'll revisit those and we're not going to go out to the public and just blast them without all being on the same page and giving them a chance to comment. In terms of budget issue, for the last how many years? Well, you started as an intern, so at least 10 years we've had interns, right? At least one intern in engineering. Been very effective, cost effective. Last year we had...
2:55:03 A young man who did a great job for us up in Lakes Basin and a couple of other spots. We paid a reasonable rate and they love working here and it's very effective. We absolutely have to have two this summer. We're going to be doing Upper Main Street. That's a STIT project. It requires an RE, a resident engineer, which means we have to have somebody sitting there all the time. Somebody just takes a body and they just sit there. It doesn't matter what they're doing if they're just sitting there with a clipboard, but they have to be there full time.
2:55:31 So you'll see in the list of projects in a couple of minutes that if we don't have that intern, there are just some that won't get done. And I'll describe to you what those might be. He's also listed a shared municipal intern to try to start digitizing more of our records. And I'll let him address that in a couple of minutes about the problem of cost. That is not in the budget at this time. And we need to estimate what that might cost and see whether we have a way to pay for it and how effective that's going to be.
2:56:01 The last one really is also key. If we launch into the list of projects, there may be a point where we just need a contract engineer, somebody from out of town to help us with resident engineering and get it done. And you'll see why in just a second. I'll go ahead and briefly go through the list. First of all, the basis goes back to the CIP, goes back to the diff study, goes back to everything. So everything ties together in terms of nomenclature, in terms of how things are addressed and how things are titled.
2:56:31 This actually was a slide out of the CIP presentation. Most of these are already ongoing. These are not new projects. Clearly, the police station will be under construction until sometime in August. Upper Main Street will be all summer long, June through October, to get that project done, $2.6 million roughly. We started an old Mammoth Road assessment district project with some sidewalks last year.
2:56:58 Ran out of time and weather before we could finish that. The main chunk that's left there is just a sidewalk just to the south of the Vons parking lot on the east side. I don't remember the name of that little center. That's an asphalt path, if you remember, right there on Old Mammoth Road, and that's going to be a sidewalk. Glass Mountain Apartments is a grant that, a CDBG grant that we obtained a couple of years ago, and we are going to move forward with electrical upgrades in that building this summer.
2:57:27 That can be very intensive in terms of staff time because we're going to have people in and out of that building on a constant basis, so a lot of supervision required there. We've already mentioned the parking and signage program. I want to mention road rehab specifically now. It is correct that we didn't spend much of last year's road rehab budget, again, intentionally. With all the damage, we have a report that Ron Fansler, our head inspector,
2:57:57 Does in terms of a pavement management system. And they coordinate with Todd and get his anecdotal stories about what the roads are doing and everything else. But he actually gave me a book of options of, okay, if we spend $500,000 a year for 10 years, what do the roads look like in terms of the assessment? It changes every year. These numbers aren't perfect. We assess it every year. But basically from here forward, if we spend a million and a half for 10 years, we'll begin to catch up. We'll actually be looking in pretty good shape.
2:58:27 From a public works perspective, our request would be that in our usual budget, we keep it at the 580 to 600 level, but the discussion is that we understand that, but we really need a million plus, and we would request council consideration of when funds are available, that that's one of the first things that happens every year. That's why we've listed this project. We've listed it a million five, and we actually have in your handouts. Right now? I didn't need to look through the handouts yet.
2:58:57 This is the handout of the road project? There we go. Thank you. Second page, this sheet right here, that's on the separate handout. Just after page 24, a couple of copies of the PowerPoint slides, and there's a road project in there, 1.6 million. Yeah, it's probably just after that, but yeah, there it is, right there. Basically, what we did is we had our inspector go through the pavement management system and talking to staff and say, okay,
2:59:26 What would a project look like this year? What's your number one priority? The first one is Upper Hillside, Hillside Street Place and Court, which we actually had on the books to do last summer, but Old Mammoth Road took its place, that had to be done. The second thing is a microsurfacing project to do about 1.3 million square feet of paving in town, and why don't you describe what a microsurfacing is, Hays versus...
2:59:51 It's a heavy slurry seal with chips of asphalt that are sealed into the surface. So it's not quite an overlay and it's not quite a fog seal, it's right in between. An example of project number one, when you remove and replace, we anticipate the life of that project to be 20 to 30 years. A micro seal is more in the 10 year range. The next one down, fog seal for the Lake Mary multi-use path. And again, we don't want these to be degraded to such a point that they have to be rebuilt and this is the
3:00:21 Most important up in town, very frankly. And we think we need to fog seal that one now to extend its life. But that's a three to five year, you know, process. You know, we do that and we don't have to do it again for three to five years. The last ones are additional slurry seal on the, more of the mop down near the skate park and then a portion of Chateau Road up near Minaret at the curve. That also needs to be reconstructed.
3:00:49 What this is meant to represent is our first shot of what our project can look like. And the reason we wanted to be this specific with it is this is March. Okay? We're not asking for a commitment to spend $1.25 million today. We don't even want you to get into that detail. The answer is yes, we do, actually. I do. Here is my point. We need you to say...
3:01:14 That's entirely possible. We need to start design now or it's not going to happen this summer. So after today, unless you tell us otherwise, frankly, I'm going to direct Hayes, okay, start design on this. We're not advertising it yet. We're not awarding it yet. But we need to get the design going because if we wait until the end of the budget process or even the third quarter discussion and it's late May and you say go,
3:01:37 We don't have time to do it. We barely had time to do the ones we had last year, so that's the real ask. Yeah, so the real push on this, frankly, is one is to take the half a million sitting in the current year budget, basically half a million out of what would be the July 1 budget, and a half a million of what we'll call our third quarter update excess TOT dollars, and actually look at doing this project. We need that go ahead at this point to say go get it designed now that...
3:02:06 The number will probably change somewhat as we do that so it may get modified. But if we wait until we know what all the numbers is, then we'll leave a discussion. We can have it next October because we won't have time to get the project ready regardless. And we have to decide how we package these up in terms of bids and we'll also have bid alternates so when we have a budget we can hit it. So the goal there would say is can we do a fairly significant road project this summer? My request would say what do we got on the books?
3:02:34 Here's 1.6 million of road work. Whether that comes in at 1.4 or 1.8, I couldn't tell you from a final design and bid. But if we don't get it designing now and ready to go, pick one of these and the rest of them will get pushed out until next year again because it's time it takes to develop them. But I think given what we're seeing out there on the roads, saying wait another year, I think hillside will turn into a gravel road.
3:02:59 I don't live on those. It's okay. There you go. One of the things to add, too. I think we want to be able to move quickly, and that's what I guess what I'm saying. I think we have the revenues to do that and support that work. And it's been a priority, again, not just to this council, but previously even to say, how do we get reinvested into our roads and get them caught up somewhat is to make one step in that direction. Go ahead. And the reason, again, you know, Todd mentioned the road rehab budget of 580.
3:03:26 In years past when we had a crew of 12 or 14 during the summer and we had a paver, we would do a lot of those projects in-house ourselves. The law changed a number of years ago where public works can't do an overlay greater than an inch and a half. That's just, that's state law. And that was, I'm sure it was the granites of the world who lobbied and got that to happen. Some more work was farmed out. That's okay, we recognize that.
3:03:51 We still want to keep it as a road rehab budget in that group so that we can identify and say this is what we're putting into the roads. Having said that, it will turn into capital projects and go over into a 300 account. But again, today, unless we hear otherwise, we're going to start design. We need to. And then the final decision on the final number can come at a little bit later date. But we have the budget numbers already for a million dollars worth of it between this year and next year. And, you know, we really are looking at that.
3:04:21 We'll start that design. That will be one coming out today. We'll charge ahead and get that design done and start that way. Otherwise, again, we miss our window of construction. Some of the others we're looking at, though, on this list. I think it's very important to do what you're doing, identify these things that are maintenance or existing infrastructure and things like that. These are things that, from a policy perspective, we're just talking about budget numbers and resources. There's some other things in this.
3:04:51 Presentation, again, to airports, new projects, questions about feasibility, there are new things, that I think we just want to be very clear that if we need to have a policy gut check and direction on those things, just to make sure that those are clearly identified. Yeah, just to break those apart. Yeah, I'm more than happy to say that existing stuff, let's get going, do the things we got to do. Absolutely. Things that may be accruing costs, may be adding to our structural deficit kind of issues, I think we want to make sure that the policy piece doesn't...
3:05:19 Yeah, we absolutely, yeah, we understand and agree. That's why our only, if there is an ask so far, it's just we need to get started designing and that's, that's all we understand. And my only concern is as long as we don't get so rigid that we can't segue if necessary after a winter like this and the groundwater being up where it is, we don't know what roads are going to blow apart. There may, we may end up with a bunch of roads that are far worse than what hillside is because of the water coming up from underneath and blowing apart the...
3:05:47 Substructure and it's, you know, we've seen it before, but. That's effectively what happened last year. We had no intentions this time of year doing old, doing old Mammoth Road. It started to delaminate after the winter and we had to react. So we, we are prepared for that. Right. We do our best case scenario based on our, our pavement management system, follow the algorithms, put the treatments where they're going to be most effective. You know, we have a strategy to utilize the funds to their, the best that we can. But to your point.
3:06:17 The road blows apart because of something. That's going to be the priority. At this point in time. That's what I'm talking about. At this point in time. That's today. Today. Today. Also on the list, too, the very next one, storm drain system, we found some deficiencies in our system this winter. Not fair? A couple of odd things out there that we changed right away. Probably the worst one was up on Joaquin and related to that, believe it or not, far downstream was over at the Visitor Center.
3:06:47 In that area. And we're right now just assessing and trying to figure out what we have and what we're doing there. But the same kind of thing. We'll look at that. We may or may not start the design in the next 30 days, but we'll be back to you in short order with a projection of cost for that and what we think it's going to take and how we might be able to fund that. But it's, you know, it's an odd time because this is March. It hasn't melted yet. We don't know what we have, but we know the things we need to get started on today. Anything next?
3:07:16 Curbs, gutters, sidewalks, rehab used to be part of the road rehab budget, and we never did any concrete work, so we really believe we need to start doing that. We just put a placeholder budget in there. We're not asking for anything at this point in time. We're going to go through and assess what we have, prioritize it with the pavement. Maybe that becomes part of that million-five pavement project. Maybe it's in addition to. We don't know yet. I just want to make sure that's part of the conversation because there are some,
3:07:46 Gutters on Laurel Mountain, that sidewalk out here, some curbs that are frankly a liability that we need to start taking care of and that's not been part of our program in the past. I did put the multi-use facility on the list because if that gets approved to move forward in late April or early May, that'll be something in our work program. The next page, a minaret sidewalk step, it's still a design process but this is the one up.
3:08:14 Between 8050 and the brewery, correct? Correct. And that's a project that we would not construct this summer, but most likely the summer after, is that correct? Our plan right now is to prepare the bid packages and bid the project this summer and immediately put it into winter suspension so as soon as the snow melts we can tackle it so we have the longest construction season possible and it's the same for the project right below it. So you're talking that's about a year lead?
3:08:44 Right. Right. Yeah. That's exactly what we did with the upper Main Street sidewalk. We did it last summer. Now, real quick, I didn't do this as I went through it. I wanted to add a column, didn't run out of time, though. Police station, that's already funded. We may be looking at some contingency dollars in discussions next month because right now we have zero contingency in there. And we're, I think we have about $5,000 over right now in a $3 million project, which we think we can find. But it still...
3:09:12 It's frightening to go into the last two months of a project like that with zero contingency, thinking that if we found something that was 10 grand, we'd have to come back to council. So that discussion will be forthcoming. But mostly it's funded. Same with Upper Main Street. There will be some things in the third quarter that we talked about there. The next one's funded, Glass Mountain's funded. The parking program is pretty small, but we, you know, we'll get the money for that. Road rehab, Dan just talked about the way we can handle that.
3:09:39 I'm not sure about the drainage. Most of those, in other words, are already, the funds are already there moving forward with their STIP funding or already set aside. Same thing for Minaret Road sidewalk, Lower Main Street sidewalk. Again, we're still in the design and environmental phase, but that's in the STIP for 2019, 20? No, it's 17, 18. For the design and stuff, but construction is right after. No, construction is 17, 18. For the Lower Main Street. Yes. That's right, it moved a couple of times.
3:10:07 Part of the issue, we identified it. Even with LTC and all those discussions, it moved back and forth. That was a discussion you just had on Monday about that project. It's like, we can't keep up with it. We added Mammoth Creek Gap Closure. Again, that's an ATP grant, so that is also funded. The point is that what we're really talking about here is staffing to get these things done because these aren't, well, they're still discretionary. As an example, Mammoth Creek Gap Closure, if we don't do that, that money will go away.
3:10:36 Right, so therefore we have to, you know, that one needs to keep going if we want to do it. Town County, we understand that's just, that's not even at the decision point yet as programming, but if that project becomes real in the next six or nine months, even from a planning standpoint, that will take engineering staff time and community development staff time to advance that from a work program standpoint. And then the airport work, again, it's...
3:11:02 We can't assess precisely how much time that's going to take, but that's significant on it. We're not going to go through this. This is the CIP list that I showed in December. Suffice it to say, though, that all but one project that's like a $150,000 project that's on that list in the first three years is moving forward right now, and we do have funding for most of them because they're on that list I just showed you. So when we come back with the CIP after we prioritize,
3:11:30 It's all happening. It's working in accordance with our best estimate. These are things we don't know what is going to happen. We're not sure what work program might come out of walk, bike, ride. We've heard rumors that there is some funding for signage and wayfinding. Whether that happens this summer or next or ever, we don't know, but it's just kind of a heads up. If that happens, that's significant staff time. And then when Stu does his, and I'm almost done.
3:11:56 We do the parks and recreation. We've talked about the recreation commission and their very significant list of deferred maintenance and infrastructure needs. Well, those are great, but if there are funds to do those, it comes back to staff ordering stuff and engineering, writing specs and getting them done so it doesn't just happen. So when we come back later and say, okay, do these, our first thing may, okay, but here's a priority.
3:12:25 These can't happen this year. These will definitely happen because we're already spending the money, and we will let you know as soon as we can assess that. But some of those, we just don't know yet what's in those. So with that, I'm going to give Hayes his two minutes and answer any questions yet. Two. Two? That's it? Yeah. Jamie, two minutes for Hayes. That's terrible.
3:12:51 The first thing I want to say on behalf of the other public works managers is actually thank you for this opportunity. We've been here a year or two, and we've never had this opportunity to get in front of you and give you our perspective on what we need to perform our jobs. I want to thank Rob and the council for giving us that chance. The second thing is even though we went through this budget discreetly in silos, we all work together as a management team.
3:13:16 We are sharing resources. We're communicating on a daily basis. And there's a lot of things that we do together. Every one of us has a very specific, unique skill set. And everyone has something to bring to the table. And we have to leverage each other to make Public Works function. So in that vein, you'll actually notice a common thread in all of our conversations. And that's maintenance. Lon needs a piece of equipment to maintain his fleet. Brian needs a striper to maintain his airport. Todd needs everything.
3:13:46 Engineering is looking for funding to maintain our assets that are now degrading because we have not invested in them over time. So I just want to bring that home and kind of wrap this up is what we're really looking for is the opportunity to maintain what we already have. Did I get that in two minutes? Yeah. Good job. All right. Okay. Any questions for Haislip Grady? No. Thank you for the presentation.
3:14:18 Great. Any public comment, questions? Somebody. Thank you. And if I may, just given the time frame, we're going to flip Stu and Sandra. Okay. She starts on page 31 of the detail. Okay, so community and economic development. Tom, did you want to come sit?
3:15:11 So Tom will help fill in building division items. But just to start our org chart, I think everybody's pretty familiar with it. We've got the official. We still have a senior planner position in there that's vacant. It's unfunded, but it's remained in the department. Tom supervises Shireen, the code enforcement officer, Diana, and then Tom Malloy.
3:15:38 Diana usually supervises our interns, so we have an intern who comes in and does scanning for us. The town collects an archiving fee, and so we use an intern to kind of do all of our document archiving. So right now we don't have anyone in that position, but looking to have someone come back and continue to help us with that. And then Ruth supervises the two assistant planners, Kim and Nolan.
3:16:05 So some of our major accomplishments this past fiscal year, we completed the general plan zoning code update to implement the maximum flow area ratio. We completed a comprehensive update to the mobility element. We worked with Public Works on that as well. Three updates to our zoning code for water efficient landscape regulations, non-conforming structures, secondary dwelling units.
3:16:30 We also updated Chapter 15 to implement the 2016 California Building Code. And Tom really worked a lot on research and public outreach on this residential loft issue, which has been a big issue over the past year. And a lot of his time has been taken up doing that. And Tom can talk a little bit more about it after I get through this.
3:16:55 So department operations, so our service level, when we look at building permit plan check, check rent B, I think, you know, we do send out a lot of our larger permits. We see a lot of requests from the public to keep plan checks in-house. So sometimes when we have a lot of requests to keep these plan checks in-house, it takes us a little bit longer to get to those plan checks because we have a lot of them.
3:17:22 And some of the plan checks we don't want to send out because they're so minor, you know, that we don't really want to send those out to an outside plan checker and take all that time and funding. And then in our service level for major, minor planning projects, we are currently on this level of service B. The state has mandated processing times for planning projects. It's 30 days for the first review. And we meet those currently.
3:17:51 In the past, we'd had quicker turnaround times. There were times in the past when we had a 10-day turnaround time for the first planning review. So that would be something for like a tentative track map or, you know, any of those use permits, those types of things. That's also, it's our time, but it's also tied to other departments. So, for example, Public Works also looks at those major projects. We rock them to the fire district, the water district. So it's really...
3:18:15 We're a part of it, but it's also getting those other reviews done within that period of time. So for code enforcement, we're currently at a level of service fee. We generally, life safety concerns really trump everything, so we respond to those immediately and try to resolve those within that day as soon as possible, if it's a life safety or an attractive nuisance, those types of things. General code enforcement concerns like lighting,
3:18:45 You know, things that aren't life safety, our turnaround time is about two weeks. And that means two weeks to get to those, to contact the owner, to send them a letter. But resolution of those sometimes can take a lot longer because it's really kind of that, you know, really kind of keeping up, talking to the people, trying to get them to comply. And then customer service miscellaneous, I think we're currently at a level of service of B+. We do provide quick responses.
3:19:12 And it really kind of depends on the complexity of the project. You know, oftentimes we have planners who are assigned to the counter. Diana is really helpful at the counter for building questions. So a lot of the questions, if they're kind of simple in nature, we can respond to those in 10, 15, 20 minutes at the counter. Sometimes we have to come back and do some significant research, so that takes longer, but I think we're doing pretty good at that.
3:19:36 And then housing administration, I think we're at a level B, we meet all of our deadlines for grants and those types of things. And so I kind of already walked through it, but the standards to grade our department is, you know, response time for building permit plan check, response time for completeness review for planning projects, building permit inspections, we typically complete those within the very next day, the next business day.
3:20:02 So I think that's a pretty high level of service, something you would see from a much bigger building division. But we're out there. We have Tom Loy who helps out building permit inspections. We also have a contract inspector who comes in and helps us. And then counter questions responded to within a reasonable time period, depending on the complexity. And then code enforcement complaints, as I outlined earlier.
3:20:27 And so I kind of tried to align our goals with the Town Council priorities. So some of them don't really align with the Town Council priorities specifically. So those are just kind of our staff work plan. These are projects that have been submitted. So one of them is an amendment to the North Wiltshire Pacific plan for the Mammoth Hillside project, design and environmental analysis for the Mammoth Creek Park West project.
3:20:52 And then under the Council's priority of providing economically and demographically diverse housing opportunities, we are continuing to work with Public Works on the housing, affordable housing project to improve Blast Mountain. We're participating in the Community Housing Action Plan, which just kicked off last week. Continuing to administer our grants in conjunction with Mammoth Lakes Housing in Amaca.
3:21:16 And then under effective municipal services, which is kind of a lot of what we do is trying to make things better, easier for the public, improving issues where we see them. So one of them is a goal is to update the sign code. There's currently things that are in the sign code that don't meet state law or national law. So we need to get those kind of up to date, updating the municipal code to be consistent with our diff study.
3:21:43 Public Scoping Process for Lofts, Updating Chapter 15, and that's really kind of a broad update looking at lofts and then also the local design criteria like wind, snow, seismic, frost depth, and then
3:22:00 And one of the other goals is to engage a contract to engineering consultant to evaluate our current design criteria. That was something the council asked us to go out and do. We've received some bids on that. And it looks like it's going to be about $16,000, I think, to have a consultant come in to do that. So I think that's something we're going to move forward with, get that data, and then feed that into the code update. And then just continue to work on policies. So, you know, Tom attends every contractors association meeting.
3:22:29 He chairs the Building Advisory Committee. So those are really opportunities for us to get out in the public, hear what are the issues, concerns, and try to resolve those as we move forward. And then Tom's worked a lot on public outreach events. We've had a couple of public outreach events over this past fiscal year, and we're looking to have a presentation on the 2016 California Codes soon. So just to let everybody know, kind of here are the major changes, here's what you need to be looking for.
3:22:59 And then we're also looking to kind of split out the way we charge our fees. So we break the building permit fee into plan checks and then inspections and the actual building permit. So that way we can restructure our contracts with our consultants so that they're all consistent and they're based on that early plan check fee. And then just continue working on the EIFD as we're assigned and then the airport terminal planning and environmental review.
3:23:29 So that kind of runs through the summary. And then our items are on page 31. And one of the things that, so if you look at the first item is the planning division. There's not really very many changes in this piece here. There is an increase in the training conference meetings, and that's due to putting planning and economic development commission training into this budget. So having some money to do some training for the commissioners.
3:23:59 There is the increase of records management. That's really kind of a re... It was in the budget previously that it wasn't in this line item, and that's the money that we... Was that under professional services or... It wasn't... Before we had the records management, it's restricted money, so we have revenue and then an expense. Most likely that would end up being an intern or part-time employees. Those dollars will move up to temporary wages. We weren't sure, so...
3:24:25 We also make sure because it's restricted money by fees, revenue and expenditures match up for that particular piece of the funding, and so then we'll put it where we need it once we figure out how we want to do the service, whether it's a contract service and do stuff, or we've had a, before we've had a gentleman, a young man coming in, actually doing the work and so it's temporary salaries. So we'll figure out the best way to utilize that. Okay, quick question.
3:24:52 Obviously, professional service and congressional services, big light items and actual budget. Those are usually based on projects that come forward. There's other dollars that go with them. I.e., if someone wants to come in for a project and we say, great, that would be a $10,000 deposit, so then we're going to go hire somebody with it. But we don't put a bunch of dollars there day one because we don't know what's coming into the planning department. So you're saying...
3:25:22 Most of those monies were paid by outside. So $726,000, $800,000. Some of those would be grants or potentially. We did a Main Street project at it, I think. Right. But it's essentially a pass-through. Yeah. It's a grant program. Not even paid for it.
3:25:42 And then the professional services, that line item was the FAR sequel analysis. That was that line item, which is why it's blank now, because there's no, we completed that project. But so one of the things that I wanted to talk a little bit about, I guess we can walk through all the budgets and maybe then talk about, yeah, so for building.
3:26:05 Not a lot of changes here. Tom, I don't know if you want to talk a little bit about, it's really very similar. The only increases we're looking at is the increase in advertising and legal notices and then some additional money for training that would cover all three building division employees. Correct, yeah. So, you know, with regard to memberships and advertising and training, that kind of thing, pretty modest increases.
3:26:32 There's a few decreases and increases. So there's a decrease in memberships and dues and publications because I had to have more money last year for code books because we have new codes every three years. We have to have code books. They're not cheap. This is the way it is. And then there were more costs than I anticipated or known about for advertising and legal notices. So whenever we brought forward the new codes, that kind of thing, there's some costs associated with advertising and noticing.
3:27:00 That kind of thing. So that was bumped up a little bit to cover those anticipated costs. I do anticipate going in front of the council a few times this fiscal year coming up for things like LOPS, and I have a number of other items in Chapter 15 that I believe that have to be revised and updated that will have to go in front of you. So, and then with regard to travel and training, that's for all three building division staff. That's myself and our plans examiner, Tom Boyne, Diana Jacobson, who's our permatech.
3:27:29 We're mandated by the Health and Safety Code through the state to have a certain amount of 45 hours of community education for every three years. So we have to follow that mandate. So there are specific events that are programmed to establish that number. But a lot of the increases I've noticed from last year's budget to what we have proposed now, really, the majority of our regular salaries, health insurance premiums. That's the majority of the increases that I'm seeing from what's proposed now.
3:27:58 To what we had last year. And then no real changes to the code compliance budget. So one of the things I wanted to just talk a little bit about is in our department, we really don't have any administrative support. And that's something that's been that way, I think, for probably the past five years, I think we had administrative support.
3:28:31 So in the past we had a healthy, thank you, Stu, a healthy level of administrative support. And so one of the things we wanted to present to the council for consideration or discussion is looking at getting some administrative support back to our department. There's a lot of different things that we aren't doing or we are all doing our own administrative support. For example, Ruth and I sent out 1,600 stuff, 1,600 envelopes for the FAR.
3:29:00 Public notice or public hearings that we had last year. So that's something that all of us are sitting down to do. And if there's other staff, everybody's always super helpful, you know, will help out. Everybody kind of teams up to do that. But it's something that really, I think, having some administrative support would allow us to do more complex projects, more kind of focus more on our assigned projects. And just looking at some possible duties they could do is...
3:29:26 These were what administrative support did in the past. It's processing some of our minor planning applications. So things that don't really involve a high level of discretion. It's really just doesn't meet this. Yes. And then, you know, issue the permit. Helping us log some code compliance complaints. Providing support for our community and economic development CASEL module implementation. So that's the building permit portal. And that's one thing that CASEL is...
3:29:53 It's supposed to provide to us that I think is really going to need some support from our end to really help get that through. And then just continue to get the invoicing with Cassell kind of up and running with a CED module. They could also help with electronic archiving for building planning, code enforcement, processing resolutions, committee development, director of determinations, public hearing notices, and kind of a variety of other things. One note,
3:30:21 On the very last bullet is that currently Shireen does all the Planning and Economic Development Commission packet preparation, so that takes some time. It's gotten a little bit easier now that we have this new, we have a new agenda management system, but it is time to take to put those online, print those packets, and that's something else that this person could do. So I think it would allow us to have more time to do additional work, and I provided you with our work program.
3:30:48 There's a bunch of different things on the work program, but one of the things I think it would allow us to do is to really kind of take some of these things that have been on our long-term work program for years and years, things that are in the general plan that we're tasked to do that we just haven't had staff to do, this would allow us to kind of move forward with some of those. And some of these are on the work program items like, you know, climate action plan, you know, helping to streamline our filming permits, just general updates to clean up the general plan.
3:31:16 So some of these things are just kind of placeholders right now, but they are in the general plan that we're supposed to be kind of moving forward with these things. So, and Tom, I don't know if you want to kind of elaborate a little bit more on how it can help your group. Yeah, there's a few things. You know, it's a big deal for permit turnaround. It's a big deal for public and to us both. It's an important function to do. So a lot of permits that we issue are same day over the counter-type permits, and getting those issued the same day.
3:31:44 I think it's just a standard we need to maintain. So what happens is that we get so busy when we have vacations and stuff like that that sometimes we have to cover the front counter and then I have to be permatech or maybe no one has to be permatech. And I know how to do it because I have to know how to issue building permits on the captain of the ship or building. But I'm not nearly as good as Diana is, neither is no one. So we get through it.
3:32:09 It's not quite as good as a seasoned permatech or somebody who does it more often. Plus, it takes away from our duties that we normally do. So having this admin person get trained to do some of that permatech stuff when Diana's gone or she's not available would be, I think, a big help for the department and the public. Also, I'd also add that we have a lot of older permits that have just been sent around, and we have to do something with those. We have to address those, try to get those.
3:32:36 And that could be a pretty time-consuming process. So this person could definitely help with that, too. And I know that would really free Diana's time to do other things. So that'd be a real help. And then I just would generally say, yeah, I agree with, you know, we can keep this person busy full time. What we do is a very labor-intensive, kind of service-intensive operation. So having that person to assist would be... This would be kind of the same question.
3:33:06 As was directed to the chief, is this a, what, what, this would be a position to add to the department, this is not for two years or three years or five years, this is just think that doing the course of, to get the business done, the public, it's not a temporary thing. And we looked at, we just kind of compared the compensation based on our current, we have a staff assistant, their current salary and benefits, it would be about $63,000 a year to have that position. Is that in here or no? I don't think it made it. It's in there. It's in this. Okay.
3:33:35 It's not in the budget. Okay, the second question was about the, we had a lot of discussion, I guess it was about a year ago, six minutes ago, about processing permits, turnaround, all the rest of that kind of stuff. What is your sense, I haven't heard from folks recently about any of that, but we're just about getting ready to get into the summer building season. Do you anticipate that nothing has changed and we're going to hear the same level of discontent and all that kind of stuff? I would say lesser discontent, I think. On that note, when I first came here, I noticed a few things. One,
3:34:04 We were using a couple different outside plan reviewers, so there was kind of a few different ones, but there wasn't a consistent outside plan reviewer. I noticed that our plans examiner, Tom Malloy, and then my predecessor, Steve Sokes, were spending a lot of time in the field doing inspection. And I didn't think that was correct. I think they needed me in the office more to do those internal plan reviews because you get a ton of these little submittals for, like, condo renewals. I mean, a lot of them. So, like Sandra said to her point,
3:34:31 It makes a lot of sense to keep those in-house. It just is a better, it's a quicker turnaround and I think more a more transparent, more accessible type of review. But I would, so having said that, I got, you know, I got us down to one outside plan reviewer in the West, where I used the county, who really came through for me, who wasn't like Shunskota, who was issuing these really egregious plan review comments and generated a lot of complaints, but they're also a good plan reviewer such that they do their job and they catch stuff.
3:35:00 So I was able to kind of get rid of another plan reviewer who was generating to me an injectable amount of complaints. And then there's another reviewer that I'm not using anymore that was charging almost triple of what NOS charges. And I cut that off immediately because that was just too expensive. So with the one singular reviewer, we're able to keep it consistent. And we're also able to keep tumbling myself in the office a whole lot more to do internal plan reviews. And along with that, we use our contract inspector a lot more than we were using before.
3:35:30 That keeps us in the office more to do that kind of stuff. So I think it's going pretty good generally with the plan review. But the challenge is always trying to get these internal smaller reviews done quickly. We get a lot of them. So with just kind of tumbling away and myself doing them and us being pulled in different directions, that could be a challenge. But I would anticipate we'll be able to keep up with it. Right. And you're looking at this administrative position would be something that's going to help.
3:35:58 Facilitate the direction that you're going in so we can improve, maybe not, you know, dramatically, but continue that improvement going forward. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Thanks. Thank you. All right. Any questions? Thanks. We have Parks and Rec left if you want to dive in or do you need a quick break? Let's do it. All right. I'm going to set up quickly so it could be a couple of minutes. It's going to be a couple of minutes. I'm actually going to, if that's okay, now I'm going to stand up and...
3:36:35 Do a little presentation up here. It's going to take you a couple minutes. Jamie, will you put Stu on the clock? Two minutes. Take two minutes to get back because I have to be gone. Thank you. We didn't want to be totally dumb.
3:37:08 Do we own the glass mountain condos or something? How many are there when they're talking about glass mountain? Glass mountain is one unit. It is a recommended hotel. It has 26 units in it. Oh, okay. It's the one there by North on Main Street. Oh, okay. So, but now.
3:37:38 So what you're saying is we purchased people, have they bought them or are they renting them? I guess what I'm saying is that if they already need $400,000 just to get it up to code for electrical.
3:38:05 What other problems are we just still throwing money after a building that should have been torn down? No, for the price, for the amount of people that go in there, the income level of people that go in there, people that are living there are probably in the 30% of...
3:38:24 So they just didn't have any, they don't have any contingency plan for anything that crops up, like they need new roofs?
3:38:53 I can give you the whole story on this thing. Oh, okay. Yeah, because I was just really ignorant about the whole glass mountain and how much shit. There's no loan on it. I don't know if they're hearing a note on it right now. I don't know if they're hearing a note on it right now. I don't know if they're hearing a note on it right now. The money's not going to pay.
3:39:19 Well, no, I realize that. We're actually just administrating this report that this was a partnership grant. Okay, that's... Right. They just don't have the experience. You ready?
3:39:47 Thank you. Appreciate your time. The best go last, right? Excellent. If you're following along, it's page 25 to page 30. And I'll kind of stop and prompt you as well. So this presentation we kind of modified from the season ending presentation in October. So you've seen a little of the few slides before.
3:40:17 I've tried to use, because it's late in the day, a few less words, more graphs, more images. Sorry. You guys are way too clunky. But anyway. So again, you've seen this slide before. We know what we do. This is really describing the essential services that Parks and Recreation provides. You understand our vision. This is our shared vision as a community. That's the mission of our department. Pretty clear. I think we're all following along on that. We have our department values, people, parks and programs.
3:40:49 If you want me to spell them out, I can, but I think you've seen it, you're comfortable, stop me at any time. Organisational chart, I'm going to stop right there, thank you. I didn't quite get the chance to throw it in, but I'll just kind of walk it through with you here. You can see, so one of the milestones that we achieved last year was the reorganisation. So this is kind of what you're seeing here is the parks and recreation. So you can see we have a director position, we have a parks manager, which is Warren.
3:41:18 And we have a recreation manager position, which is kind of vacant at this point. On the left-hand side of the screen, I think it's that side, we have Derek and Juan, who are full-time parks maintenance workers, who will be augmented by the proposed budget introduction of that full-time employee. And the way Grady and I have worked it out is probably 53, 54% will be public works, 46%, which is probably about 900-something hours in parks maintenance. So those hours are being allocated here.
3:41:47 And we have five seasonal workers on that parks maintenance site. On the other side of the fence, we have right in the middle, our program facilities coordinator, which is Lindsay Lyons. So she kind of splits a time between kind of all of our program deliveries. And we have John Connolly and Kat Kelly as our supervisors. And underneath those guys, we have about 45 to 50 people every year, right? So we have a big department that we have a lot of people in.
3:42:17 It stresses Cassie and her team a lot, but that's about 12 ice rink staff, 10 pool staff, 20 to 25 summer councillors, programmers, operators, umpires, and so forth. So quite a large department. Any questions on that? Great. I'm going to go back to the presentation. Moving right along. There we go. Thank you. So directing the budget and certainly our work plan for the year is this strategic work plan that we've put together.
3:42:50 We presented it to the Commission in February. You can see they actually accepted it on February 14th. And this plan is derived from four documents. One was the strategic alignment document that Council are working off, which is the goals for 2025. And ours were the integrated sustainable recreation within the region and certainly looking at expanded and enhanced facilities and programs. The other document it references was our vision strategic direction document that was...
3:43:17 Approved in 2014. Our Parks and Recreation Master Plan, which is our really guiding document, and the Chapter 2.40 of the Recreation Commission. So really what these five strategies is really kind of guiding our work plan for the year and subsequently the budget. I can read those along, but I think you're kind of moving along with those. So this is when we get into, so this is really looking at parks maintenance and the work we do on the ground. This is really looking at kind of
3:43:46 Enhancing our infrastructure, providing new infrastructure for our community, enhancing what we have, which is kind of the deferred maintenance issues that we're dealing with, and delivering best practices and being good stewards of the environment, right? Really quickly, this is a long-standing strategy of the department, and that's really delivering innovative and now what we're really calling age-appropriate. So we're moving from just general kind of programming to really being as specific as we can. So that's 3 to 5, 6 to 9, 10 to 14.
3:44:16 Teens, seniors and up through the age spectrum. You know, it's just 3 to 99 plus. So that's programming and that's really talking about aligning resources with demand. That's really important that we kind of grow exponentially and scalably and through scales, scalable. And enhanced communication. So that's websites, that's communications, that's emails and so forth.
3:44:37 Four and five is our organisational systems, kind of our operational excellence mantra, which is kind of what we're introducing this year. Really making sure we have good systems and making sure we really have good, well-trained people to run those systems. We've talked a lot about culture here today. That's something we're really focused on as well. That's our team capacity, organisational culture, employee knowledge, professional development. It's something that's really been, I think, lacking over the last several years as we've gone through some difficult times with the town.
3:45:06 You've probably seen a lot of that through all the departments. Everybody's trying to make sure that we're providing the tools and training necessary for our employees to deliver the best services we can, recruiting and retaining the best, and then embracing emerging trends. Just really quickly, a major accomplishments. I was before you in October with the presentation, so you've seen some of these before. We've talked about the reorg, summer camps up over 20%. Pool visits up, rec zone visits up, you know, it's busy.
3:45:34 We've got a lot of people coming and going, a lot of people enjoying our services, a real strain on our services and our capacity, but we're enjoying the challenge. We executed the joint Town of Mammoth Lakes Mammoth Unified School District joint facilities use agreement, which is a big deal for us in the community, which means we both have access to each of our facilities, and that was replacing a 1991 agreement. We executed and secured the Volcom naming rights agreement. That's originally a five-year with a 10-year option.
3:46:03 We conducted a lot of the community outreach for the Plan Your Park project over at Mammoth Creek Park West. And as you know, it was great to receive the award from District 7 and from the Mayor last week for Trails End Park. Thank you. I should have thanked a lot more people when I was up there, so I apologise. But it was certainly an honour receiving it from a previous Recreation Commissioner. So that's our accomplishments. Moving along to functions.
3:46:32 Much like Grady mentioned, we have five primary functions that we break our delivery down to with our department. That's our recreation programming, facility program, administration, parks, maintenance, public works, kind of combo, and then planning, promotion, and management. So what I've done, I've kind of gone through goals, service standards, and kind of where we see with grades. We've all kind of wrestled with this evaluation of our grades. It's not easy. It's kind of difficult.
3:47:00 We've used some quantifiable numbers. We've had our customer survey data. We've had our focus group data. We've had some internal discussion. These are all vetted by our staff as well. You know, recreation programming is all over the shop, but mainly being because it's either three to five, six to nine, you know, whatever those age groups are. So we have different kind of standards for all those, but really what we're saying is we're about an A minus on our recreation programming right now. We really would like to see more kind of adult senior programming.
3:47:26 You know, some more enrichment classes for kids and so forth. So that's kind of where we're at. And you can see right there on the bottom, service standards, how we evaluated that metric. Am I going too fast? Am I good? You're good. You guys are good, right? Okay. Budget implications. So this is where you'd look at page 25. Our budget 100432, which is that fund, is our kind of recreation programming budget. This is where we kind of deliver these services. You can see really, I mean, it's quite clear.
3:47:57 Camps are growing exponentially. Everything's increasing. There's more demand for staff, resources, money, time. So really what we're looking at here, you can see the little highlighted gold section, is just additional funds for a senior rec leader and two summer interns. So, you know, it's just under a $6,000 increase. And this is really assuming that we can recruit those people, right? I mean, it's so competitive out there right now to try and secure these people for our program.
3:48:26 For instance, we had all but one of our pool staff return, and right now we're looking at about a third of our councillors returning. So we have a lot of people to find in a short period of time. So anyway, this just gives us an opportunity. If we do get to fill these positions, that would be great. It would improve certainly the overall quality of instruction, reduce the councillor-participant ratio, lower the wait list, right? Our wait list keeps on growing.
3:48:52 And it helps us manage, obviously, the demand for our services. So that's it. Facility programming. So this kind of speaks directly to having programming provided for the community at Whitmore Pool, the multi-use facility, the community centre, Shady Rest Park, Mammoth Creek Park, you know, those facilities. We see ourselves as kind of a B plus there. And that's really not so much kind of the effort from the staff, but just the facilities that we have. Right. So that's kind of where we see kind of a B plus.
3:49:22 You can see there we're looking at the same number of metrics that we're kind of evaluating this standard on, but we're about a B plus. So budget implications for that is really just kind of looking at just minor additional funds for enhanced programming, supplies, and just updates. So this is a little graph of the Whitmore pool. You can kind of see that we've kind of, over the years 2008, we've gone up, we've come down, we're trying to get us on the right trajectory again.
3:49:50 But again, increased funding, quite simply, teach more youth how to swim, right? I mean, that's a big need for our community. If you can really see that small print there, that's really just for me, but it basically tells you that drowning is the second leading cause of injury for death of children aged 1 to 14. We just don't have enough. Look at all the backyard pools in our community, a lot of lakes.
3:50:11 We really think this is a really important program and a service we need to provide the community, so we're trying to enhance and provide additional learn-to-swim times for our community. Provide animation at our ageing facilities. More things for them to do. Provide lockers for pool staff. We actually don't have lockers. Their little locker space is in the office, which is our concession building, which is our staff building, which is our...
3:50:38 It's difficult. Paint, shower curtains, office functionality, just basic stuff. So it's really not a lot of money, but it goes a long way. Administration, this is our kind of third function that we provide. Deliver exceptional customer service. You can kind of read that using technology, best practices with the goal of really increasing efficiency of our operational processes. So our service standards, you can kind of read there. Registration, customer service, office management.
3:51:09 Development and implementation of our communication plan. We have a 12-month communication plan that we implement. So it gets tracked. Everybody's managing that. Oversight of ActiveNet, which is our web-based reservation system. Financial management and special event support. Just quickly, special event support. We now have migrated the fill-in forms to an online form. So if you want to complete your special event permit application, we do about 35 to 40 a year. That's fully online now.
3:51:38 So we think that's a great benefit for the community and be a lot more efficient for staff. So we see ourselves as kind of an A-, A- in that category. No budget implications there. Parks maintenance, you know, this is something that we have come a long way, I believe. Dennis, you know, Mr. MacGyver, Mr. Maffixit, duct tape and everything else, you know, that just doesn't work anymore. I mean, that equipment, the maintenance, the deficiencies are that great.
3:52:09 That we are really kind of running up against some problems in our facilities. So we're basically a C, C plus. I mean, that's kind of where we're at. I mean, Bill, you probably agree with that pretty clearly. And again, I do want to point out that, you know, Warren and his team, I mean, they put in, you know, 120%, you know, it's not reflective upon their work effort.
3:52:30 Their productivity or their professionalism. It's really that our facilities require, you know, significant investments in funding. I mean, we all get that, right? I mean, they're all deficient. I've got a slide coming up that shows when the, an image of the Whitmore Pool was built in 1939, I think, Bill. The expectancy for that pool was 60 years. We're 2017, so. Did you work on that? I think Bill actually was the first one in that pool. I can't remember, but.
3:52:57 But, you know, we've missed that by 17 years. I mean, so, you know, these are the things that we're dealing with. So we're doing the very best we can and we're kind of being more reactive than proactive. So I guess that's kind of where we're coming from. So our service standards here, effective, efficient maintenance of our, you know, town parks, trails. There are multi-use paths. There are hard surface trails, facilities. This is really describing the activity and frequency. So what we're doing and when we're doing it. And I'll talk about that in a little bit as well in a little bit more detail.
3:53:26 But that's a C plus. Public work support, and I'll get to budget implications on the next slide. Am I okay, five o'clock? So we provide some support to public works, certainly through, pardon, he's gone, but Grady and his team. And, you know, I would have to say over the last year and a half, two years since Grady's been here, I mean, the communication, you know, the collaboration is
3:53:54 Exponentially grown between our two departments, right? We're not siloed anymore. We're working together. We're getting so much more done together. The example of that, it's really that hybrid position. I mean, we need two positions, right? But we've kind of sat down and we've kind of worked out the best way that we think we can kind of deliver these services for the community, being financially responsible. So I think that presentation for that employee is really kind of a reflection on how well we are working together with public works and maintenance. We have to do it together. I think you found the right employee.
3:54:23 Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. We've got a great team. So this includes kind of our winter sidewalk snow removal. What made the big difference recently was the replacement of the upgraded trackless machine. Again, we stayed on top of our vehicle replacement. If we approached the winter without that kind of newer trackless machine, it would not have been what it was.
3:54:47 Right? Grady's shaking his head, right? I mean, they go down, they went down, but we got them back up. You know, we got them out of there. We're able to provide some good service. Where we were challenged with, it was really, you know, when we lost the sidewalks. And I think what we're going to be looking at in the future is as more sidewalks are installed, how are we going to manage that? So that's a discussion as we move along. Hard surface maintenance of our trail system.
3:55:13 Our goal this spring, if we get a spring or if it's summer, is to really conduct that level of analysis of our MUPS and our hard surface trails, and they'll come back and actually give us a metric of where our priorities are and how we kind of address those. So that's something we really want to get to. We do manage those street lamppost banners that, as you know, have all gone, and we do a lot of community event support.
3:55:38 So that's B. Budget implications I'll get to, but this is a little graph showing you that everything's increasing. All our usage is growing. Everything's expanding. This was Shady Rest Park. I showed you this slide in October. That's 3,899 hours versus 1,300 before. So a lot more visitation. This is a list of our community assets.
3:56:03 I don't need to kind of describe them, but there's a lot of those. What we'd like to do in the future is kind of come back and actually show you kind of an asset management tool in a systematic way that we can kind of match service levels with budgets and constraints and those type of things. So that's something that Warren and I are working on over the next year to kind of really get down to that finite detail. It'll give us a lot more specificity of how we can best manage these assets. So, you know, here's just a quick slide. There's Bill in the pool.
3:56:32 Opening day, 1939 Bill, was that one? That was Whitmore Bill. So, you know, again, this is what we're faced with, ageing facilities, you know, stagnant funding, growing deficiencies, we're not going to be able to, you know, achieve our vision that we've set for our community. I think that's really important for us. If you were at the commission meeting last week, I mean, Commissioner Osborne said it, you know, that clearly, so we really need to address this.
3:56:56 Budget implications for parks maintenance. Again, we've talked about that position, but we're approaching it three ways. So we're approaching it through staff, which we've talked about. So we're adding 990 hours, roughly, to our programming and summer equipment. So we're really looking at replacing probably a $15,000 to $20,000 mower. It's not the $750,000 blower, but again, we think there's sufficient funding in our vehicle replacement to get that done.
3:57:25 We're looking at aerator. I mean, we don't have an aerator for the town. If you didn't realize that, Warren never told me that. So we just get out there in the summer and throw some fertilizer down and away we go. We used to use something along to somebody else. That was something else and punched holes and it didn't, I mean, borrowed stuff. I mean, it worked really well. Yeah, not really.
3:57:48 But here we go. So we don't have those type of equipments. A trail workman, right? We use a Ford Ranger to maintain our hard surface trails, right? I mean, it's just very inefficient with the equipment. We just don't have the right equipment to do the job necessary. So we're really looking at how we can either rent, lease, pay, buy, replace, any capital purchase options, you know, the equipment required to really maintain these assets.
3:58:13 Funding is our third one, so really looking at MUP deterioration. Like I talked about, we want to come back and give you better metrics on that, but we're putting in budget numbers for that right now. You know, multiple facility repairs, additional fertiliser. We do maybe fertiliser once a year. Wow, can we get that up to twice a year? We've tried this new organic fertiliser. We'd actually like to use that across all our fields and facilities. We tried it at Shady Rest. We want to move to Whitmore and so forth. It costs more money.
3:58:39 But, you know, in the long term, it's going to give you that, you know, better route system, longevity, and so forth. Baseball, baseball infield mix. I mean, this is a big thing. We went to a presentation a couple of weeks in Sacramento, and then he's the guy that's been maintaining professional baseball fields, and it's like, okay, well, that's that level, and what do you guys use? We just do, oh, right, okay. So it was really, it was really highlighted the challenges that we have with maintaining our field. So we have a lot of work to do on our softball baseball fields.
3:59:07 Skate Park Repairs, that's not only Volcom, that's the one at Shady Rose Park. And then Professional Development. So, you know, this maintenance management school here, this is a CPRS, it's our California State Association, that we'll actually send Warren to, it's about a $1,300 school. But this will give him the skills necessary to kind of, you know, better maintain our facilities in our field. So that's something we really want to make sure we can commit to.
3:59:35 This is a big slide with lots of words, but basically saying that parks and recreation management, planning, promotion and public outreach, we think is about an A, and this is a lot of the work that I do in partnership with a lot of the team that we've talked about today, so with Sandra and Grady and his team, so we think that's at that level. That's the end of my presentation.
3:59:57 I didn't really cover too much of the budget. I don't know if you had any questions. We touched really briefly on page 432, sorry, page 25 through page 30. I can kind of walk you through it in more detail. I guess the big question is that... Yeah, yeah. What we had in there, I mean, let me hit this real quick on that. It's on page 26 to 33. You'll hear kind of a common theme for a lot of the departments that when do we, you know, update and replace equipment.
4:00:30 When do we add new equipment in terms of efficiency? The $30,000 in here is focused, I believe this was on a lawnmower. That's just the replacement model. We think that's going to be a vehicle replacement. We may be able to get this out of vehicle replacement and replace that. The other issues, you deal there, you deal with the aerator, you deal with the workforce, et cetera. Those are new additions to the maintenance board. So this year may already be covered in equipment stuff. We're also working through our whole equipment.
4:00:57 Program there, a fleet management of what things belong there, which ones don't. A lot of stuff, if it's in there and you buy it this year, then every year you're adding dollars in to replace it future, but we have some very small stuff that are used to carry weed whackers and other smaller stuff that just needs to go away, frankly, as a consumable lawnmower versus depreciation. So that's a lawnmower and the other one is a what? The 20,000. I believe that's the aerator workhorse. Yep.
4:01:26 And that's budget 438. Is it for both of those? Yep. We think so. Again, they're just preliminary numbers. We've got a lot of work to do in regards to if we kind of we can look at leasing one, trying one, borrowing one, see how it works, and then look into what's the best way to really kind of, you know, provide that maintenance for the fields. But certainly that workman is very helpful, and it's something that we think would have some value to Joel and his crew as well.
4:01:53 Like in a soft surface trail kind of scenario. I would encourage us on that workman to look at several different things. There's a lot of OHV product out there that I think is superior to that, that they actually make tracks for. It could replace that stupid piece of equipment that we try to groom non-motorized with now. So it could be a true winter-summer piece. Oh, you're talking about the Nordoni. Yeah, the piece of junk that we, I mean, wait, yes, beautiful Nordoni.
4:02:22 That's Joel's new hobby. Yes. But I mean, hopefully you and Joel are working close together on this stuff too because I believe there is a way to fulfill that need for the summer maintenance equipment with the little dump bed that can carry things and everything else and perhaps do trail maintenance on the trail side as well. So I hope that when we're looking at this kind of stuff, we're looking at cross-purpose and how we can get the biggest bang out of the buck.
4:02:50 And you're hearing a lot of that discussion in general with really having to turn as much with the dynamic workforce. How do you start sharing staff? How do you start moving people? Again, there's some other challenges with that down the road. Beginning to look at that, and again, ultimately the same way with equipment. You know, you can't, it's hard anymore to buy just a single-purpose piece of equipment. Our motor is our snowplow. A skid steer, I think, has got two or three different attachments to it, and now maybe another.
4:03:18 So we have a lot of that type of stuff. So I think you're right on track with that in terms of looking at how do we enhance our usage of that equipment that way across things. The other thing, again, kind of walking back through a lot of those areas is we see a lot of the equipment needs. That's going to have to be prioritized down. You're not going to get everything that's out there.
4:03:40 This last couple of years, we really focused more on very kind of soft into some of the soft costs, getting back our staff training development, some of those areas and some of that still need some work. If you go back a few years, 07, 08, with the economic downturn, budgets took a big hit. The settlement issues coming out of the lawsuit, 12-13, massive hit. Then it kind of bumped along the bottom the last couple of years. We haven't seen that in these last two years where we've seen our revenue come back.
4:04:10 The themes of this coming through is, hey, we have some money, but is it sustainable? So we really want to come back and see how much this should be one-time investment for efficiencies, how much it comes in becomes ongoing costs as we look at bodies and other things. So ultimately coming back, and we'll probably run out of time here this evening, but looking at that revenue side, what does look like a sustainable capability that the council is comfortable with? And we might bump something up for one time and we...
4:04:39 Buy it later in the year. And if the money comes in, great. We do it. If it doesn't, those are easy things. So then not, dollars not there, we don't buy them. So just to, if I could follow just a point. Yes. Mr. Mayor, I would request that we find a way to put a policy discussion on an agenda going forward that is going to address what Dan's talking about. Yes. And it doesn't have to be the silver bullet to be able to say, okay. It's sustainable now.
4:05:07 Yeah. So we, okay. You know what I mean? So we can, so then everybody understands what the thresholds we're going to set for, what's one time, what is something that we think we can take on. I think that would be helpful to. Right. And we really need to, we want to get a good feel for one, for the cross work that's going on, the requests and the needs out there. Then ultimately, we'll come back and go, here's the finances we have to live within. So what does that mean for these reasons?
4:05:36 Request pot. And then get the envelope position of working and pushing those together. And some of that's in the budget, some of it's not. Well, we will have some changes to this. If this was a final budget, we'd be walking out feeling really good. We got a little bit of a surplus. Actually, that'd be kind of nice. But obviously this will change. I'll come back to the revenue numbers. And this doesn't fund a lot of the one-time. This has been a great start. Yeah.
4:06:05 So I'm hoping the council has a better feel for just what the budget is. Feel free to walk through numbers. If you've got questions, we will provide a copy of the PowerPoint out to all you guys to take a look at. Walk through those things. And so just part of a regular agenda item, we'll probably put on some of the budget work in terms of just the revenue side. It's a little more focused and easier to walk through. We need to get some comfort levels there, both still on our side as well as your side in terms of that. We do want to come back to the first meeting in April and talk about
4:06:34 Kind of one-time dollars that we're seeing right now because that allows some of this stuff to either go forward or like in the case of public works it's either this summer or it doesn't get done until next if at all and so some of that's a little more priority wise so we'll be bringing that forward and that that'll end up laying into some of these elements as well and some other items in that where you'll have the options to right now on one-time request we have more than we have dollars.
4:07:01 It's about seven or eight million requests and you probably have maybe four or five to play with at the most. So, big gap. So, we'll begin to work through that and lay some of that out for you to have some dialogue there as well. I did have one question, Israel. Good, thank you. 100 for community page 27, regular salaries over actuals in the past.
4:07:35 And that's a lot to do with just allocating, which I think Rob touched on before, so that's just allocating staff to the right funds. And then previously we had a superintendent in that mix back then with Dennis, and we have a newer position with the parks manager, so it was quite a bit of a change in salary there. The increase in Washington this year is that mixed shared position hybrid.
4:08:01 I've read position. Just from the 90s. You were looking at news before, yeah. And I think in those, one of the other year's allocations on that, but I think it's also with the low snow year, we had a lot of our public works guys working on facilities that didn't charge their time here because it wasn't appropriate to charge it. Obviously the snow budget when they were painting the community center or doing that that way. So we had some allocations that way that impacted that as well. Which is not really budgeted. We don't. Right.
4:08:32 Budget that that's just kind of going from Grady's budget to my budget. And we want to keep them busy and we'll move general fund back over, but we want to keep our guys working, so. And it's a need we have, so. Okay, Councilor, I'm going to ask a question. This has been a lot to absorb. Yes. Everybody's presentation, I think, gave us a good idea of, you know, what everybody's going through. Start tidying it up and put it in a little box and get the question.
4:09:06 I just have a request. If there's any way that we could get a list of all the little trees that showed who works for what department, what their title is and everything, I would just help me. That's going to be the handout. Yeah, we'll bring out everything that you saw today. We'll get a package of all that. I just want to know the people. We'll package that up. I think this is extremely helpful and I appreciate the fact that we're going to have multiple cracks at this.
4:09:38 You know, I think just to kind of forecast, you know, I think where I'll be at personally, you know, we kind of, we had a great year last year, fiscal year, but I think myself and, you know, the broader council was really reticent to raise our long-term encumbrances and our staff costs based on the volatility that we're seeing.
4:10:05 You know, I think the way that we build it in the past, which would be my suggestion for kind of how we look at things moving forward is I feel relatively secure and stable with our summer revenues. So I think that those numbers we're going to see relatively flat or maybe increasing. But I still think that we have a large degree of volatility in the winter. So as we look to build out what that number that we're going to be comfortable at, you know, I'd like to see it be a combination of
4:10:33 Kind of flat or stagnant or maybe slightly increased on the summer side and then looking at a pretty light winter. Yeah. So, you know, I think we kind of towed the line at 11.7 this year. You know, I'm relatively comfortable with an increase to that. But the big question is how much? You know, I have a broader concern, you know, that's been built out of...
4:10:58 You know, kind of this first crack here. I mean, it's 33 pages of increasing budgets. So, you know, we just went through this process of kind of towing the line around, you know, our structural deficit. And, you know, I see out of this entire 33 pages, I only see a couple of departments where there's not significant increases from fiscal year 14 through proposed 2018. So I just kind of want to forecast that.
4:11:27 That I'm going to be much more apt to approve one-time costs than long-term encumbrances. And that if we are going, you know, I'm hearing a theme of need for deferred maintenance and additional bodies. If that's a direction that we're going to have to move in, we're going to have to find some other areas of savings. And, you know, we know that retirement and health costs are going up.
4:11:54 So we're going to have to be creative to find other ways to make sure that everything is just not on an upward trend. Yeah, budgets will slowly inch up just in the other areas. But you're right, last year when we came in, we'll do that similar analysis for you, but we kind of did a low, mid, high on TOT revenue and here's why and here's kind of how those numbers came together. And that would be one of those would be to look at, here's a number we think is sustainable. Right.
4:12:18 And then here's probably a number where if you want to utilize it, frankly, but it's one time, and then if it doesn't come in, some stuff is delayed, so it automatically gets cut if the rubber isn't there. So there are ways to kind of balance that out. I think they hit both things you're talking about. What's that? And back to John's comment. What's as sustainable as we add into versus, you know, if we buy a new lift, it's $40,000, but that makes our existing people more efficient. It's a one-time shot outside of the appreciation.
4:12:48 Stuff like that, if I'm hearing you correctly. Yeah, absolutely. If we're looking at significantly increased staffing costs based on overtime, it would be really good to understand if we're able to interject another body, how does that offset those overtime costs and what's going to be the net cost for additional bodies. I just think that we have a long track record of not having...
4:13:11 Any money ever allocated to capital. And that's why we're in this position that we have where we have insufficient facilities, a bunch of deferred maintenance, things that are falling apart. You know, one of the great things about our last budget is we actually had additional dollars that could go out towards one-time capital investments. And I'm going to continue to push for that, that if we have a great TOT year this year, which we're going to.
4:13:37 If we can invest that in our product and our capital facility as opposed to tying that up in long-term encumbrances, that's something I'm much more comfortable with. Other general comments like that from the rest of the council? I would echo a lot of what he has to say. However, I do want to start out on a bright note, which I try to do. Kudos. If we go back to the lawsuit years and the decline of the economy years.
4:14:04 We have backstabbing and everything else going on throughout our departments because people were worried about losing their jobs and they were siloing and everything else. The gains that I am seeing in that and the comfort level of the employees we have. And by doing that, the better productivity with the cross-pollination, if you will, of departments and everything else. And I was talking a piece of equipment that can be used for trails and everything else.
4:14:31 It heartens me to see that this is finally going on because we can accomplish a lot more with the same amount of money with this kind of cooperation than we did in the past. Along with Colin, I agree that I am much more comfortable on one-time expenditures. I would like to see us get better at predicting what our surpluses are going to be and planning that out rather than saying, okay,
4:14:58 Let's go hire a consultant because we like this new blue thing. The deferred maintenance and everything else that didn't get done in last year's surpluses bothers me some. So I really want to see us take a closer look at what our deferred issues are and how we can use some of that one-time money to bring those up to snuff so it doesn't cost us more in the long run. That's huge. That being said, I am very comfortable. I am very appreciative of the previous councils.
4:15:26 Sticking to that $11 million budget. That was very, very necessary. I am comfortable in increasing that to a certain degree just because of inflationary and because probably we aren't going to have another three years of drought back, back, back as we did. So I am comfortable in lifting. I'm telling you, it won't happen. Good to know. Age of experience. That is what it is.
4:15:53 So some of the increases I'm comfortable with, we do need to start bringing up our levels of service and our productivity and getting back to where we can best serve the public. Thanks, Bill. John? Yeah, a couple things. If staff could provide the calendar for the budget process, we've talked a lot about some sequencing issues. It would be good to get integrated into that so we can hit those marks. I think this sustainable revenues...
4:16:22 Thing is very important. I think it's also important for staff because if you know the policy of the council at least the next couple of years is going to be like we're only going to increase our budget to deal with like mandatory like CPI kinds of things that we have to deal with then when you're thinking about.
4:16:37 CIP to do something to cause of living stuff, inflationary kinds of things. Then when you're thinking about, okay, if there's going to be a surplus, if I can get a piece of equipment or something that's not going to encumber stuff, and you guys are thinking along those lines, it might be helpful.
4:16:54 I think that there are a number of variables that we have not included yet in this conversation. There's things like the regional efforts that we've got going on around a variety of different efforts. We've got this Measure A thing going on. There's some talk about Forest Service stuff. Some contracts, sort of minor contracts are kind of flitting around that I want to make sure that I've got some notes on these things I can get them to. So that we're looking at the budget inclusively. We're bringing all that.
4:17:23 All that, you know, everything's in it. I think that the LTC discussion about the lessons learned from this winter is going to be enormously important, especially to your stuff, because when we're hearing things like Caltrans is down 20 people, they're not going to, they don't anticipate getting those 20 people back. I think the snow management plan, there's going to be a lot of things going into that, and I would want to make sure that...
4:17:46 We get enough resources to staff so that everybody can sit down and do that stuff because these are things that are going to affect the budget going forward in terms of how we're buying equipment and what Caltrans is going to do or not going to do for us. We need to know these things. Well, just to sum it up, again, great job. I appreciate the council's comments on the expense side of things. They're great. We have to really kind of get in there and play around with that.
4:18:16 I want to start focusing on what the revenue side can be. Yeah, and again, we flipped this year on purpose so we could have this type of dialogue and not being necessarily constrained by the revenue. Right. So freedom to say, here's what I really need. Great. I brought it up. Now we'll come back. About the summers. Yeah. I agree with, you know, John's assessment. But, you know, what are the things that are actually, we can do and spend money to increase revenues in our town? We're increasing revenues, our budget goes up.
4:18:47 You know, we are constrained by that $2 million a year. Damn, I wish we had it. You know, we wouldn't be here, you know, playing this game of, you know, you know, the shell game where we're going to put the dollars. But we are. And so the reality is, is we've got to go find revenues coming into this town. I think there's strategies to do that. So, and it's, you know, and we're all working on it. We're all working on it.
4:19:11 We've just got to be really efficient. If we can identify what we think those things might be, then that also goes to staff to say, okay, look, we think this is going to work, the degree to which we're investing in those things and the revenue's coming, that can help all of us, but we'll have to figure that out. And the last piece on this, just keep in mind that this whole discussion here was on, you know, $21 million out of what will probably end up being about a $30 plus million budget.
4:19:40 So you've got a whole other piece in there, probably less control, if you will, because a lot of it's legally restricted and committed. But there'll be a whole other piece as we come in with what I would call a true preliminary budget. You'll have a much bigger picture to look at. I mean, Major R&U, for example, all the assessment districts, the other various trust and agency funds, there's a lot of other pieces that'll move through that that you'll get to look at. Here's kind of the...
4:20:05 Truly the nuts and bolts, I think, of the services we provide out there that touch our residents every day. Right. So, thank you. Good shot. I really appreciate it. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everybody. Thanks. Thanks. Adjourned. Thanks. What do you need there, Grady? I'm still not happy.