Parks & Recreation Commission · 2017
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 5 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findings- Trails End Park: Phase 2 was budgeted at $1,561,068 in 2010; a 2024 staff report says the project was completed in October 2016 for $2.5 Million Parks and Recreation
- A 2026 staff report says Primary Concrete, LLC was awarded an annual maintenance contract for Volcom Brothers Skate Park repairs Parks and Recreation
Transcript
376 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:25 Morning, everyone. My name is Emily Woods from Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The other week, Rich and I attended the Youth Sports Funding Organization Funding Workshop, and something that was brought up was really interesting. It was looking at CrowdRise through MLR to help raise monies for the different teams, and we wanted to just check back in with the different sports groups and see if this is something that they really wanted to follow up on.
1:55 If so, we would love to set up a meeting with all the different sports organizations. A couple of ideas we had was one platform that would be used for all of the money to go into, say, for a field or ice rink, but I think that's
2:13 Something else entirely. Or we could use CrowdRise as a platform and have the different teams in there so people can go in and say, okay, here's volleyball, here's hockey, here's basketball, and they can donate to those individual teams. So these are just a couple of the ideas that we had. We would love to get the sports organizations back together again for a conversation to see what they would be interested in. Great. Thank you, Emily. Thank you. I'm sure our staff can help coordinate that.
2:43 With the organizations? We can talk about that during the item. Perfect. Any other public comments? No, that's on the agenda. So this is if you have anything that is not on the agenda. Is there a copy of the agenda? Are there some copies in the back? Yep. So on the back table, right? Back of the room. You're welcome. Just when you come in.
3:10 Thank you, and thank you all for being here. We just have a little bit of business and one presentation, and then we'll get to youth sports funding. Okay. Seeing no additional public comments, I will close public comments and move to the consent agenda. And I need to pull two items from the consent agenda. I need to pull the minutes from the March 7th meeting, and I also want to pull the director's report. I would entertain a motion on everything else. I will move that we approve everything else. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion?
3:43 All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Motion passes 5-0. What I wanted to pull on the March 7th minutes is that I just wanted to make it clear under the public comments section that all of the awards were in fact CPRS District 7 because there are also some state awards that hopefully we will be applying for in the future, but the awards that we won this time around were all from CPRS District 7 and not in fact statewide awards.
4:14 Okay, and then on the Director's Report, I just wanted to mention that yesterday the summer camp registration opened on ActiveNet and the process seemed to go very smoothly. Stu, did you have anything you wanted to add? Yeah, we did. Thank you, Chair. Yeah, so we kind of put together a program a couple of months ago to kind of launch these programs.
4:38 Based on kind of historical history of applications and trying to make it as equitable and as fair as we can. So we put in place an open house a couple of years ago. And the open house serves the purpose of really just providing that information to the public so they can learn more about our programs before the registration opens.
4:55 We also had the opportunity for those attendees to collect a 5% coupon in addition to their early bird discount. So if they registered when registration opened on the 3rd, they could actually receive a 25% discount on all their camp programs for the summer. So that launched yesterday at 8 o'clock. It was very hectic. I think most of the camps right now are actually sold out. Even Youth Theatre is almost sold out on the first kind of younger program. I think Escape Camp sold out in seven minutes.
5:25 So it was very, very, it was a crazy day, staff did really well, a lot of recognition to those guys, put a lot of work and effort into it, and we'll see how it tracks along in the next couple of weeks. Yeah, thank you. And just a brief update, you know, while everybody's here about the fields, you know, we are looking for everybody to really kind of help us.
5:46 Through this difficult time, summer's obviously, sorry, winter was quite unprecedented with the amount of snow we had and staff's working as hard as they can to get all the fields open. But very quickly, Warren couldn't make it today. Whitmore track is open, Whitmore synthetic field is open, and softball fields one and two are open. So both of those facilities and fields are open. The school's on them, Little League's trying to get on them. We've got AYSO using them.
6:13 And we've also got another program using it too, so it's very, very busy. Shady Rest Park will be a little bit longer, understandably, a little bit more snow forecast. So we're looking kind of at opening that park potentially in May, but, you know, we haven't really determined a lot of the damage and the...
6:30 The issues that the snow caused yet because everything's still kind of under snow. But anyway, so just really appreciate everybody's understanding with our fields and facilities and staff are working as hard as they can. We're pulling on seasonal staff now, which is normally what we wait till May, but we're bringing on staff now for the next period of time just to get caught up. So those are my comments. Thank you. Thank you. I saw Warren in the office this morning and thanked him for all their work down there.
6:57 Great. The only other thing I wanted to mention on the director's report is that MLR meets today at 5 o'clock and they definitely have some items up for discussion that are of interest to the commission. I plan to attend but I would encourage all of you to either attend or maybe watch on Granicus because they'll be talking about some funding options for capital projects as well as appointing to our joint ad hoc committee and also they'll be looking at their contract. So I just wanted to bring that to all of your attention.
7:27 Any additional comments on the Director's Report? If not, I would entertain a motion on the Director's Report and the March 7th minutes. I will so move to approve these items. I second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor of accepting the Director's Report and approving the revised minutes of March 7th, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
7:54 Motion passes 5-0. That brings us into our first discussion item and that is our standing item of the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Update. So I'll just kick it off. Thank you, Chair. Grady's here to answer any questions. It's back in the land of the living. We're just going to cover the EIR process first and you can see in the staff report and I'll kind of just go through it for the benefit of the public.
8:19 Staff has been working to finalise the response to comments with our consultant, Michael Baker, as well as BBK. We believe those will be made available to the public mid-April. So if you did provide a response to the EIR, that'll be available mid-April for review. Planning Commission, Planning Economic Development Commission is scheduled to consider that on May 10th, and then Council will consider that as well on May 17th.
8:47 So they're the dates that we're looking forward to. And you can kind of see the calendar running down here that I've kind of provided the commission as well. And that's really the update there. On the construction side, since our meeting, you know, community meeting on March 6th and our meeting on March 7th, no action has really taken place on the design itself. We're kind of waiting on this process to complete first, and then we'll kind of double back.
9:13 Move into kind of further design based on council action. So that's kind of where we're at there. And as the chair mentioned today, the funding scenarios is a big part of this picture. That presentation is in front of MLR today from the town and we hope to bring that forward to commission the following meeting with an update on that process as well. So that's all I have. Any questions for staff at this time? Any questions for staff? John? Yes.
9:44 Okay, so obviously this entire thing is contingent on the funding plan. That's where we're at. Is that a question? Yes, there's a question. How is our communication plan just as far as actually let me revise that question. What's the plan if it doesn't get funded? Well, the first discussion, Rob Patterson's before MLR this afternoon to lay out some of the alternatives for
10:19 Either a phase one or phase two or both in terms of some of the things that MLR can consider. They then would make a recommendation to town council. I'm not sure if they're prepared to do that this afternoon or not, but at least they'll hear from Rob and consider what he has to say. The town manager and finance director are fully engaged in checking out the options because when it comes to town council on May 17th, they want to present them.
10:45 A full spectrum of, look, this is some of the alternatives you can do, whether it's a phase one, phase two, or a full project. As Stu said, in terms of the design, we really haven't touched it since your last presentation you heard back in March. We could refine the cost, but really the bigger picture is do they want to go forward with the whole thing or not and when. No detailed update, but we are interested to see what MLR's comments are this afternoon. Okay.
11:15 Last month I remember that there were a couple of additions that were identified as far as being added. What is the current estimate for the entire thing? We actually haven't changed it other than what we talked about there. And again, I don't have that figure in front of me, but we...
11:33 have relayed to Town Council and in our reports and things that the estimate that we provided, we'd have to add, I think it was $130,000 for some other things, but we haven't formally updated any of that information. Basically, when we're doing an estimate at this level, as we've said before, the best estimate is when the bids are open, so it could be plus or minus 10 or even 15%, so we didn't spend the time to go back and
11:59 You know, tweak $100,000 out of a $6.7 or $9.7 million project. The push has really been, what is the financing plan? How can this thing get built and to finish the environmental work? Okay. You know, I started my conversation, or started by saying, you know, what's our communication plan? And I'm going to kind of get to that, but that's why I needed to back up and sort of ask this question, because I do remember at last meeting that my concern is,
12:29 That we've got a public that is rightfully so able to punch holes in the numbers just because, you know, it comes up at commission meeting as far as, oh, we forgot about this. Oh, we forgot about this. And I think that the most important thing we can do is really make sure that we are including all of the costs that are going into us. You know, I want us to be optimistic, but we also need to be realistic. Worst case scenario. So I guess what I want to...
12:56 What I want to ask is what is our communication plan going forward into MLR this afternoon? I mean, are we allowing MLR to determine, wait, we forgot about the contingencies, we forgot about some of these other things? I mean, it sounds like the budget itself hasn't been updated since our last meeting. Is that what I'm hearing? In terms of the detail, but we've, you know, talked to Rob and he knows that that, I think, again, I don't have it in front of me, but the estimate for phase one is 6.7. What we actually showed last time was a little bit less than that.
13:26 up the number without really detailing out the background because there's so much detail in there, everything could go up or down a little bit, but we've let them know what the full number is for what we consider a full phase one. Okay. I think the discussion is more to do with the funding scenarios, not so much with the individual kind of...
13:46 Finite amount of the project. I think that's the bigger picture to understand, you know, if it's 6 to 10 to 15, okay, but, you know, how do we kind of package this together and is it realistic for the community? So I think that's kind of really the topic of the discussion today is just really those alternatives. And looking at, you know, looking at that packet, it's really to do with, you know, the funding priority projects.
14:09 MLR have determined through council, you know, so how do they, you know, complete the MAC project, how could they complete, you know, this project and, you know, accommodate the trails request for additional funding too and so forth and leaving kind of money available for some, you know, other projects. I mean, that's really their funding scenario over the next almost five to ten years. How does that look and how do they plan for that? I think that's kind of the discussion, you know, today in that broader picture.
14:34 I understand, and I certainly am coming at it from, I personally am coming at it from that perspective, but we also need to be sensitive to really being able to answer questions. What is it going to cost? And, you know, I just don't want to read about it in the paper. Oh, geez, it's ballooned again. So in a lot of ways, I just want to make sure that we are being as realistic with our numbers as we possibly can, especially going forward. You know, this is a communications as much as anything. You know, this is what we want.
15:02 Let me move on from that subject and ask this. I also know that at our last month's meeting we talked about talking with the school board because it is all but certain, even if we got funded, that we're not going to be open by this winter of 2017-18. Where are we with our discussions with the school board?
15:24 From Public Works side, we have talked to Stacey Adler and others about the site itself and what they'd like to see when we leave in terms of improvements. We've actually given them cost estimates for removing the parking lot and the slab and everything. They're looking at it right now to see what they'd like to keep because if they do a daycare slash early start type facility, what they want to see there. In terms of the lease itself, I think...
15:51 I don't know that the town manager has addressed that with them yet, but I believe that it stands that they're more than open to running, you know, to the town extending the lease at least through next summer to make that work. They haven't said no. They're fully aware of our desires. I don't know, Stu, if you're aware of any other conversations with them, but it's, I don't know if there's been a formal written request or anything like that, but I think we're all comfortable that it'll happen.
16:17 Okay. I think that will be the end of my questions for now, but I just really want to encourage the town manager and staff to please make sure that that is proceeding. Agreed. Thank you. Any other questions of staff? I just have one quick question. So the commission next meets on May 2nd, and at that meeting, as part of your update, could you just let us know if there are any...
16:41 If the council needs to, or MLR needs to hear anything particularly from the commission so that we can bring that forward at the subsequent meetings. Any comments from the public on this item? Morning, Madam Chair, Commission and staff, members of the public, Rich Bacci and Mammoth Lakes Recreation. A little history. Town Council approved priority phase projects in December of 2015. As Stu alluded to, Multi-Use Facility, Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, Outdoor Performing Arts Center, and Trails Enhancement and Expansion.
17:21 MLR continues their budget deliberations as aligned with these projects. We started reviewing budget in February, conversations in March, and we'll continue again today in April and probably make a recommendation in May. Time Finance Manager, as you alluded to, will be presenting finance options to the ML Board this afternoon. There's something in the packet. It's very well done. I think we should be very impressed with what he's got done at this point. In my eyes as the Executive Director, I see these three options. Option number one.
17:50 We take no action at all. We continue to be indecisive. We roll over the $6 million we have in the bank right now and fund our annual commitments and continue the allocation process. Option number two, one and done. $6 million in the bank. I think we get 6.6 and change. Not quite enough to cover the 6.7 right now, but one and done. Do MUF, Multi-Use Facility, Phase 1, and then accumulate future funds.
18:19 That would be an option tonight. Option number three. And we're looking at this holistically. Broad coverage, as Rob calls it. This will require bonding. Five to ten years out. So you're looking at taking a decade of bonding, our new money, about $2 million a year. Ten years out is $20 million. What kind of bang can you get on that buck? Over these 18 months, by the time we get to June, it's 24 months, two years. Let's tackle something. Let's complete those four priority phase projects. Multi-use facility.
18:49 Arch and Culture Center, Trails Enhancement. OPEC, Outdoor Performing Arts Center, is off the list right now because we're working with Dirk and Sam's Woodside. That's probably good for five to ten years. MLT is helping support finances for the foundational, the infrastructure, not parcel. We're looking at other options, but that'll probably come back in the fall as the next phase of development. We're also looking at doing a million dollars to set aside for the outcome of the walk-bike ride.
19:18 and the downtown revitalization. There'll be other things that come to the table we need to be ready to roll on. So let's say we go long-term planning. Option three, best of all worlds, we get these priority phase projects done. Then what do we do with our developmental phase projects? That's the next phase coming up. You've got the aquatic center. We're trying to sit down with Ralph and find out where we're going as a follow-up with U.S. Swim. What do we do with biathlon facility? Panoramid Dome. Is that where we're looking at Clayton at this point in time? A field house.
19:45 You know, what other things are we looking at? And that would be the fundraising that will be inherent upon MLR, the Executive Director and their board to say we've got to raise some major funds. So those are the options we'll be looking at tonight. It should be a good public engagement, I would imagine, and we'll probably make a recommendation in May, make some decisions. We'll probably make a recommendation to Council, I think would be the 17th of May at this point in time, which is kind of in their budget cycle. So that's kind of where we are at this point in time. I appreciate the opportunity.
20:13 to provide a quick update, and I'm open for any questions you may have. I do, thank you. I will not be able to make the meeting this evening. Is there a staff recommendation between those three options? There is not. Okay. Can you speak to the status of the Outdoor Performing Arts Center? At this point, the whole process is on hold.
20:45 Pending the outcome, I think it's on the MLT agenda tomorrow afternoon, an update on the work that Dirk has done to close escrow on that facility. I think Mr. Erdi is going to make a presentation about what they're looking for in infrastructure and the cost that MLT may put into that. I know that Dirk has worked with the Planning Commission about some mitigation that needs to be done in that parcel. I think the general feeling right now is let's just tackle that piece, tuck it away so we've got that secured.
21:13 Catch our breath and then go back with that committee and look at the other two or three options we have on the table. So it's on the shelf right now. Okay. And then finally, you made comment that if option number three were to be exercised just as far as bond measure goes,
21:30 That the soonest that would be able to take place would be 18 to 24 months out. Is that what I heard you say? No, I would imagine that we would be able to get that if the council took action in May as part of the next fiscal year. I would imagine those wheels would be in process. That would align ourselves with the good point you asked about probably retaining the agreement with the school district for one more year, get ourselves organized and probably open the facility probably a year down the road at this point in time. But I don't think we've gone that far down the road. Okay.
22:00 Follow-up question to that, is May realistic for Town Council to be making a decision with regard to this bond? We'll make a recommendation. It'll be up to them probably to take it into consideration. You know, by state mandate, budgets have to be approved by July 1st, a new fiscal year, so they're going to make some decisions. And I would imagine we'll make recommendations in May. Let me get some pushback, go back and massage it.
22:24 MLR Board will look at it again in June, make any modifications, bring it back. So there's going to be some back and forth over the next couple of months. But I think we're far enough in front of the curve. The fact that MLR started budget conversations in February to say, hey, it's coming at us, March, let's make some recommendations. Rob is all ready to roll. So I think we're in good shape right now. Okay. And actually, just a question of process. Bond measures need to go before the public.
22:50 Referendum, is that correct? I don't know enough about bonds and the process of how that works. I don't know if staff wants to speak to that. If you have additional questions and comments, staff will be at MLR tonight, so feel free to maybe email them to Stu and maybe you can... I'll save those questions then. All right, any further questions for Rich? Thank you. Good morning. Good morning. Any additional public comment on this item?
23:14 Okay, thank you all for your patience. We'll now move on to conducting the 2017 Youth Sports Funding Recommendations. And before we start, Laurel, do you want to say anything? Yes, I'm recusing myself of this agenda item. Okay, thank you very much. I'm going to step out and we can text you when we're finished. Okay, awesome. Thank you. We can get in the Starbucks. Yeah, wherever you want to go hang out for a bit.
23:43 Okay, so just for the benefit of the public, so how this will work, thank you very much for your time today, and thank you for submitting your applications. We'll begin with the staff presentation, and then the commission will ask questions of staff. Then you'll have an opportunity to answer specific questions from the commission about your organizations. We'll do one at a time and have you come up to the microphone. That will be followed by an opportunity for public comment, and then the commission will deliberate and make our recommendation.
24:13 Sound good, everybody? All right. Thank you. Kat? All right. So today, with regard to the youth sports funding, staff is requesting the commission make two recommendations. Firstly, staff is looking to the commission to make a recommendation on the establishment of the youth sporting organization assistance program.
24:33 The proposal is to fund the program with an annual allocation of $2,000 from both town and county general funds. This is $2,000 representing the increase of Mono County funds from the 2016 allocation.
24:47 The Recreation Commission would provide oversight of the program with administration performed by Parks and Recreation Department. Organisations can make a request for the use of funds independently or collectively with the purpose of sustaining the long-term financial and operational functions of youth sporting organisations. The proposal was presented to the attendees at the Youth Sports Funding Workshop on March 21st and received positive support.
25:13 As such, staff is recommending the establishment of the Youth Supporting Organization Assistance Program. Are there any questions about that? I have one. What happens if this $2,000 fund doesn't get used for the year? Does it roll over? I think the idea is now that it would roll over until requests came forward to use the additional funds. Any other questions?
25:47 Moving on, the second recommendation that staff is requesting from the Commission is that they make a funding recommendation to Town Council on youth sport funding. The staff has identified five youth sport funding alternatives for 2017, which I'm just going to quickly run through now. These following recommendations are based on a total funding allocation of $34,800, so that is...
26:13 Without that extra $2,000 from Mono County, whether that goes towards a youth sports organization assistance program or not. So option one, okay, is that we recommend awarding the 2017 funding request by the youth sporting organizations. So you can see in the table here the 2017 requests in the third column along.
26:44 If these requests were to be awarded, the total would be $34,600, so there would be a surplus of $200 left over. Option two. So just quickly, for the benefit of the public, so we had how many funding applications? There were seven funding applications submitted. And then two, we did not receive any applications from Mammoth Youth Football and Cheer or, as you can see on that board, Mammoth Youth Hockey. So I just wanted to make that statement for the public.
27:22 Okay, so moving along to option two. Option two is perhaps a little bit more contentious. It would be to recommend developing an entirely new methodology for the allocation of funds. This is a process that's going to take a long time, I think. Possibly an algorithm exists out there to make it incredibly fair.
27:43 I don't know what that algorithm is. I don't know how we come up with that algorithm. It may look something like this. I'm not sure. But that is another option that we provide for funding alternative. Option three. So option three is staff recommends awarding a 35% increase across the board in the 2016 awards. So that would look something like this. Husky Club would receive their 6,000.
28:11 that they've requested, and the rest of the organizations would receive a 35% increase on their 2016 award. So that would get us to a total of $34,755, so there would be a surplus of $45 there. And then moving along to option four.
28:40 Staff would recommend awarding a 30% increase on the 2016 awards with the remaining funds, which would be $1,100 being held in reserve for existing or new youth sporting organisations. Once again, Husky Club would receive $6,000 and the rest of the other six youth sporting organisations would receive that 30% increase on their 2016 awards.
29:10 The idea with holding this remaining $1,100 would be to help any existing or new youth sporting organisations to either form or regroup. As Stu mentioned, two youth organisations did not submit applications this year. There have been problems with the boards there. This is potentially an issue that could perhaps beset any of you. We realise that you're volunteer organisations, you don't.
29:39 Always have, you know, a lot of time, a lot of financing, all of that kind of thing. So the idea would be to hold this 1100 as a sort of emergency reserve fund to help out any new or existing groups. Obviously there would have to be some parameters and some guidelines to distributing those funds. So whether there would be a timeline or sort of an end date by which someone would, a group would have to come forward to request those funds.
30:07 Whether they would have to be extenuating circumstances, that's something that we would be willing to discuss and try and come up with a set of parameters. But that's option four for you. The last option we have, option five, is we recommend awarding a fixed amount to each organisation. So that's basically taking the total sum. Husky Club would receive their 6,000. And then the other six youth sporting organisations that...
30:36 28,800 would be divided by six and you would all be awarded 4,800 to each organisation. So they are the five options, five alternative funding options that the town staff has come up with. The recommendation from town staff is option number four, a 30% increase on the 2016 award with those remaining funds of $1,100 held in reserve. Do we have any questions on those funding alternatives?
31:11 Do you have one? Not at this time. Okay. Christy? Again, if we go with option four and the $1,100 of remaining funds aren't used, what do we do with those? Do they disappear? Do they roll over? Do we build the kitty? I think they would roll over is the idea. Would that line item grow? So if it wasn't used, it would be $2,200 the following year.
31:37 Yes, or we could alternatively vote to put that towards the Youth Supporting Organization Assistance Fund, our program, so that there's a greater kitty there by which to sort of embark on some kind of communal or collaborative effort. Thank you. Any questions? I'm going to hold my comments for now. Yeah, I think so too. Are we going to hear from the public next or what's your process? Kat, do you have anything else?
32:02 No, I'm all good. Thank you very much, and thank you. I know it's your first year going through this process, so I really appreciate all your effort. Yeah. What I'd like to do now is we'll just bring up each group, and then the commissioners can ask if we have any questions about your application. So we'll just go in the order that the packet is in, so we can start with AYSO. Stu, if you want to come.
32:25 Maybe, I think we all know all of you, but just for the benefit of anyone watching at home, you can just introduce yourself and say a sentence maybe about your organization. Sure. I'm Stuart Need. I'm Regional Commissioner for Mammoth AYSO here in Mammoth Lakes. We have 545 kids, I think, this year. Yes, any questions? Brilliant. Thank you. Any questions for Stu? I actually have one question.
32:53 In your application, I saw that you give every participant a soccer ball every year. And do participants who were around last year and participate the following year, they get a second soccer ball? Yeah, we don't actually give them the soccer ball. We provide them. And we go through them pretty quick. Either that coaches still have them or we can't get them back. There are a lot of garages around town, garages, I suppose.
33:22 So, you know, and they just get old and we have to replace them. But it's every year I think we're not going to spend that much money on it and we always do just because, you know, they just get worn out. And so that allows them to practice and... Yeah, so every kid has a ball to practice with. Great. Yeah, yeah. Wonderful. Thank you. And Stu graciously answers that question every year. It's exciting to see. Some coaches still don't get the message.
33:49 Sure. They try. Okay. Any additional questions about the AYSO application or the organization? Just one more. What's your year-over-year growth for this program? Is it flat? It decreased this year. It decreased? It did decrease, yeah, by about 40 kids, maybe a little more than that. The U19 program, so we are Region 316, which is Mammoth, and then we have area, which we play all-stars, so that's Carson City, Tahoe.
34:21 Bishop, and the U19 program, because their high school program starts in the fall, our U19 program just doesn't have an all-star, so they go up and they either play Bishop, and Bishop last year, really, their U19 program kind of fell apart as well. This year, AYSO has changed their age group, so it's now a year instead of being the end of July. So they're asking us this year to put a U16, U14, and U12.
34:49 So that's what they've asked us. And hopefully we'll get a little more of that age group back in, not all of it. And then we'll try and figure out our U19 program. We did try and launch it this year. It just wasn't successful because it was a co-ed and the girls did not want to play with the boys anymore. So there was kind of a conflict there. So it just fell apart. So we'll try again this year and come up with maybe a better plan for them because there's a lot of good kids in that age group that are coming through.
35:14 So hopefully we can just get back to where we were. But yeah, we actually lost some players this year because of it. Thank you. No problem. Any additional questions? All right. Thanks, Stu. Thanks a lot, guys. Appreciate it. So we'll move on to Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra. Cara? Good morning. I'm Cara Leonard. I'm the Operations Director with Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra. And you guys are pretty familiar with our program, I think.
35:48 Specifically, we're asking for a funding request to help subsidize our local ski and snowboard PE program. I'd love to answer any questions. If there's time allowed for it, I'd like to just point out a couple things on our application that may have been overlooked in previous application processes. Anyway, I would love to answer questions. Yeah, if you can do that just real briefly.
36:19 That'd be fine. Okay. You know, one of the things that's kind of unique about our program, and, you know, again, this funding request is specific to our ski PE program, but we do offer all the sports in our program to all our local athletes, you know, both in Mammoth Lakes and Crowley, but also in Bishop and Lee Vining and kind of peripherally as well, is it's, this is their sports outlet. So when you, I was hoping that.
36:46 The spreadsheet would still be up here. But, you know, when you look at, like, soccer and, you know, I was going to use my kids as an example. You know, my kids do the swim team, cross country, soccer, and they used to do baseball, and they go to Husky Club. But the kids that do participate in disabled sports, that's it. So we provide all their sports outlet. So anything that they do, you know, whether it's biking, swimming,
37:16 Cross-Country Skiing, Alpine Skiing, it's all through our program. So if you look at some of the other sports clubs' numbers, they count a lot of kids twice or three times or five times. And our kids really just participate with us. So I just, you know, I can appreciate that.
37:35 the challenges of allocating a finite amount of money to a lot of really worthwhile clubs, but I just wanted you guys to take that into consideration that we are the only outlet for kids with disabilities in this area. Thanks, Cara. Questions? That was actually my question. She answered it, so thank you. You're welcome.
38:00 I just have one quick question, Cara. So in your application, so I know you mentioned Bishop, but these funds would serve your students from Mammoth Lakes and Mono County? Correct. Okay, thank you. Okay, thanks very much. Thank you, guys. Okay, next up, Eastern Sierra Nordic. Anyone here from Eastern Sierra Nordic? And anyone here from swim team? I'm here as one of the board members, the newest board member of the Mammoth Lake swim team.
38:45 We're going with option one. If you need a refresher as to what those were, that was the one where we get 100% of our funding. So Mammoth Lake Swim Team, 60-plus swimmers. We run a summer swim program from May to August. Swimmers travel and compete regionally. And our request is basically just asking for funding to be brought back to 2014 levels. That $6,400 number was the number that we used to receive from the county and town.
39:15 We got a lot of feedback from our membership this year that we were spending too much time on fundraising specifically to try to keep the program afloat, and we ended up actually digging into the reserves quite a bit even with all the extra fundraising these past couple years. Our expenses go up every year, mostly coaches' salaries. We've been putting off equipment purchases, so fins and kickboards are something that we really need to get replaced. Year over year, we had $6,400 from, as I mentioned, the county and the town, and
39:45 This past year we received $3,700 worth of funding, so we'd like to see that option one put through. Okay, questions for Jeff? You said that you're receiving complaints about your fundraising activities. Yeah, so we took a season survey and there was feedback that because we had last season duck races which take place at the village and the kids go out and basically you probably know what it's like. You hammer your parents, your family members, your neighbors, hey, buy these little duck.
40:15 Give us $3 and you'll have a chance for a raffle. Then we had bake sale, car wash. Then our biggest fundraiser, which is the one that we're going to keep this year, is called the Sharkathon, where, again, you hammer your friends and family and neighbors to give money for each lap that you swim at the pool. We worked to solicit sponsorships to try to get new lane lines. And so it was just a lot of work that isn't swimming related to try to fund the program. And again, it's not uncommon that other
40:45 Organizations have to do this. It's just that we got feedback specifically from the membership that said we're just spending too much time and you guys are nickel and diming us. So we really want to put it into one big fundraising effort, our Sharkathon, and then have you guys help us. Any other questions? Appreciate your consideration. I just have one quick question before you go. That's all right. So I just want to make the swim team aware. So I mean, I understand that you're looking for a return to 2014 funding levels and that would be great, but
41:16 In light of the fact that the county level, even though a lot of the funding has been restored from the county, not all of it has. So I guess my question to you is, you know, what is different about your program that would merit a substantial increase from last year, just in light of the fact that the funds are what they are and we don't have any. We tried to add a couple more weekends of training. So we train from, we're starting at May 9th is when the anticipated open date is for the pool. Obviously that's.
41:41 Contingent on some things happening. So we added a couple more weeks, and then we increased the contracted wage for our two swim coaches. And as I mentioned, we're also trying to replace the fins and the kickboards. That stuff's just deteriorating down there a bit more. So just one additional question then, because I think this fundraising issue is an issue for everyone. So Emily mentioned earlier the potential to do a crowd rise campaign. Yeah, I made notes on that.
42:10 Would you be interested in participating in something like that? Again, as long as it's not something that we're just hammering the membership for and, again, going back to the same well year after year because the parents and the kids and, you know, the friends and families of those people, they just get burdened by the fact that, you know, and you're doing the same thing with you've got to buy a thousand box of Girl Scout cookies and you've got to, you know, run a car wash for youth football or whatever it is that's going around. So, yeah, we'd certainly be interested, though. Thanks, Jeff. Thank you.
42:40 Okay. Little League. Oh, sure. We'll bring him up after Little League, if that's all right. Thank you. Hi, my name is Micah Geary, and I'm representing Monroe County Little League. This year, I am on the board. I'm the player agent, so show me the money. I'm also a coach. I'm coaching minor league this year. And I guess with the...
43:12 The main thing that we're concerned about in Little League is that the numbers are declining. So Neil McConnell and myself, who's president of the Little League, are coming up with some alternatives or some ways of increasing baseball. We think one of the issues may be that, you know, we have a very high-growing Latino community in Mono County that soccer is the big deal.
43:39 And rightfully so. It's an awesome sport. But we're seeing that, you know, maybe there's not that interest from the parents because, you know, obviously your kids are influenced by what parents are into and they're all watching soccer or all watching basketball or whatever the sport might be. But we're also noticing, too, that maybe some of the things that may be getting in the way is, you know, some of the equipment, you know, like a new glove or, you know.
44:02 That type of thing. One of the things that we came up with this year that we probably can implement next year is coordinating with Played Against Sports in Carson City to buy up their used baseball gloves and then offering parents a used glove for any new registrant, you know, the kid that comes into the program as a way of enticing kids to join baseball.
44:24 One of the things that we're also looking at, we're very interested in, is bringing in a coach's clinic this year. We'd like to do that this year. We'll see how it goes. But basically, we understand that just because a parent volunteers a coach doesn't necessarily mean they're qualified to coach. And not necessarily because of not knowing the techniques and the game, but I think we are also looking at the point of, you know,
44:51 Are these people, are all parents qualified from a psychological view to be coaching kids? We have really been taking a serious look at that. We think it's really important that we get back to the fundamental idea that coaching is teaching. It's not necessarily about the agenda of the coach, but the win of the kids. So that's another thing that we're...
45:18 really interested in doing, and I think it would be great if all sports did that, bringing somebody that can teach parents how to coach. So, that being said, we would like some money. Thank you. Thanks, Mike. I'll just have you stay there in case the commissioner has questions about your application. I just got out of bed. I just, I really shouldn't be here. I'm really sick. Oh, sorry. We won't keep you very long. Sean, any questions? No, well said, though.
45:40 Yeah, I just have one. You said that your numbers are declining. You're trying to figure out whether it's because of changing kid populations or equipment or lack of coaching training. Have you surveyed your membership or the general public to try to get some clarity on this? Well, not getting me nuts. We're just trying to get people to enroll. This year, for instance, we only have two major league teams. We have two minor league teams and one team from Lee Vining.
46:08 We have four farm teams. I think we got like six t-ball teams. But what's happening is we're noticing by age eight or nine, they start dropping off, and we don't know why. So we're trying to figure that out. We're trying to come up with a clearer view of trying to figure out what's going on with kids, why they're dropping out. Have you asked the parents? Well, you know, it's kind of hard to do it because, you know, we're, you know, like all these other sports, all of a sudden we come into the season, and then we're getting everything ready, and then, you know, six weeks later, the season's done.
46:37 You know, so it's not like we're, you know, have some kind of a call center to call up the parents and saying, hey, why isn't your kid playing this year? Although we have reached out this year and have called, and we were able to recruit a couple kids that were looking like they weren't going to play and talk to their parents and saying, you know, kind of saying, you know, this is good for the kids. You know, baseball is, I don't want to get into how I feel about it, but we're just not really sure what's going on with baseball. It's just on a decline. Okay, thank you.
47:07 Questions? Nope. I just have one super quick question from me, so I'll ask you the same question. And I think that's also kids dropping out of sports at eight and nine is kind of a national trend, too. It's not just local. Oh, is it? It is. In fact, it's something the commission's really been looking into. But so...
47:25 What you're talking about in terms of coaches getting some training and some support to better prepare parents to coach, that's something that we talked about maybe offering through if we form the Youth Sporting Organization Assistance Program. Is that something that baseball would be interested in participating in? Absolutely. And again, I think in this day and age of everyone trying to get their 15 minutes of fame on YouTube.
47:53 And I've coached all the way up. I coached snowboarding all the way to the Olympics with my kids. And I just see that sometimes there's such emphasis on this winning thing. And I think that if we bring in coaching clinics and stuff like that, I think we really need to bring in a psychological part of it as far as teaching parents the psychological part of what you're doing. We're just not trying to get a win here. We're trying to teach kids something that they can carry on in life.
48:22 And, you know, just to, you know, I've seen, I used to coach hockey in Minnesota, and that one little kid in the net, and the winning puck goes in, and that kid just goes off dejected, the coach makes a comment to him, like, you know, blah, blah, blah, blah, whatever it is, and that carries on in life. So we're really concerned, at least I am especially, about making sure that kids, when they go into life, become adults, and they become on your board.
48:48 They're really prepared mentally. They don't have to drag this other stuff with them. So that's my experience. Thank you very much. Okay, Eastern Sierra Nordic. We just asked everyone to introduce themselves and say a sentence or two about their organization, and then the commissioners will ask if there are any questions about your application. Sounds great. My name's Chris Thompson. I'm the treasurer of ESNSA, which is kind of a long acronym. It's the Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association. So we're the cross-country ski folks. We like our comments.
49:20 Promote healthy lifestyles and a stronger community through cross-country skiing. And the way we do that is to try to focus on the kids, starting at an early age, or as early as possible, elementary school age, through middle school and high school, and then hopefully up into adulthood as well. And I think one of the natures of the sport is it is one of those sports that you can do as an adult at whatever level.
49:44 Unfortunately, not necessarily at the level of a high school student, as I've found recently, but certainly something that promotes a healthy lifestyle, not just as a kid, but also as an adult. The way we try to promote this pipeline is to make sure that every kid who has an interest in the sport has a chance to take...
50:05 Take advantage of it. And this great situation here in Mammoth where we have a really excellent facility for cross-country skiing. So it really should be a good, strong Nordic community, and I think it is.
50:19 Provide funds for direct sponsorship for kids who otherwise wouldn't be able to afford the program, including ski rentals. As they move up into the racing program, we're providing uniforms, wax, tuning equipment. We coordinate the season-round coaching.
50:36 As the kids get into the high school age, it's actually a year-round type commitment if they want to compete at the national level, and our kids do. And they do quite well. The last two years, we've placed five kids in the national program, so it's not every child wants to.
50:54 Go to the Olympics or compete at the national level, but for those who do, there's an opportunity to do that. So we kind of hold that out there as a goal, which I think is a good role model for the younger kids to see the older kids being able to reach that level of competition. We're a long-term organization, and we certainly appreciate the financial help that we've received from the town, and we hope that we can continue to enjoy that. All right, thanks very much. Sean, questions?
51:20 Kristi? Just a point of clarity. Your organization is the same as the middle school and high school teams, right? You're not duplicating efforts? No. So we're pretty careful about how that's all coordinated. There's a high school team and there's a middle school team. There's also a separate club team, if you like, a comp team.
51:49 And the parents can't be required for the school age programs to pay for a school program. So it's a voluntary donation on the part of the parents to cover the cost of their kids to go up and have skiing twice a week or whichever program they happen to be in, say at the middle school level.
52:18 Not all parents can afford that. So that's where we step in. Okay. Great. Any questions? No. Thanks very much. Thank you. Okay. So that brings us on to club volleyball. I'm Heidi Presson. I'm the director of Mammoth Club Volleyball. And just in a brief sentence, our biggest challenge is we have a season that goes from December all the way to June. All of our competitions are in Orange County. We have really high tournament fees.
52:56 And we have a difficult time finding coaches that are willing to donate their time for six months and travel to tournaments. And also, some of our players have played three years of year-round volleyball now. They are needing better coaching than maybe those volunteer coaches are able to give. So we're always trying to bring in coaching clinics to kind of grow the coaches along with the players.
53:27 Thank you. Christy, questions? I can come back to you if you want. Sean? No questions. Great written application. Clayton? Nope. Christy, do you have anything? No. Okay. I just have one quick question. In your application, you mentioned that one of your goals is to support the town of Mammoth Lakes with our events over the holidays. Could you tell me what those would be? Well, last year we tried to do some fundraising efforts at...
53:59 But Christmas tree lighting and skating with Santa. And the way our fundraising works, I mean, our registration fees are really, they're really high. So we run our fundraising efforts a little bit differently. Our treasurer, Cindy, she's willing to, instead of a few of our players working their butts off to support the whole club.
54:25 Everybody does their own fundraising efforts, and she keeps track of what everybody's done. So if we do a seize candy sales, she will put what you earned specifically towards your registration fees. So we've had players that have paid all of their registration fees strictly with fundraising, and we've also offered full scholarships to, last year, three different players.
54:52 That needed it. What was the question? I just totally got lost. Oh, my question was just about the events over the holidays. Oh, yeah. So, I mean, we're willing to do that. We went to those, and honestly, it was not a moneymaker for those girls that wanted to donate their time, but we throw it out there and just say, who wants to go out and represent? And another thing is, I was hearing, oh, Jeff's gone, but...
55:19 You know, we all kind of are going after the same people to raise funds. Our players will set up a little bake sale at Vons and make like $800 in a couple of hours. So, I mean, and those aren't the locals, they're the tourists if you go on the right weekend. So that's just an idea for raising money.
55:39 I was going to say, it's the locals too, just so you know. Actually, we don't even put a price on the baked goods. We just say it's donations, and that's how people put 20s into your pot. So, I mean, but yeah, that is the key. How do we get our tourists to participate? And maybe it's, you know, what's that fundraiser that you were talking about? Oh, the crowd rise. Yeah, so we can get out-of-towners involved. So, I mean, that would be helpful. Thanks, Heidi. Sure.
56:11 Okay, Husky Club. Hi, I'm Sandy Hanover-Zeldes, and I'm the Program Director for Husky Club. And I wanted to explain to people who might not know, Husky Club is part of Mammoth Unified School District. They run our payroll and clean our facilities and things like that, but we are our own budget. The town helps us incredibly because
56:48 Our summer program is our outreach program. We serve twice as many children in the summer. And because we're a state-funded program, in addition to full-pay parents, we have specific health and safety guidelines. So, for instance, during the school year, we're mandated to have 14 to 1.
57:18 I don't think that's safe, and I try to get between 10 to 12 to 1 teacher-student ratio. But when we leave campus, it automatically goes 8 to 1. And when we go to the pool or water any lake, it's 6 to 1. So most of the additional budget that I need for my summer program pays for the school bus, because that's not...
57:45 Part of my program, I have to pay the district for the use of the bus and the driver, and then I have additional staffing requirements. On my budget, I didn't go into that, I have in the past, but I just wanted you guys to be aware. Our focus in the summer is, we still do academics, but our focus is sportsmanship and active students.
58:15 Mondays and Thursdays we stay back on campus and we have the activities like football, soccer is a big one. Our kids love soccer. And we have classes during the day for small groups. And then Tuesday we take a walking field trip to a park in the area. Wednesdays we take the school bus and we go somewhere and hike like McLeod or one of the other.
58:45 Great places this community offers. And then Friday is our water day. So every Friday we either use Whitmore Pool or June Lake Beach. The other thing I wanted to let you guys know is how much you enhance our program. We reach more children because of the summer camp vibe and we're really excited. I want to thank you. Do you have any questions for me?
59:15 I just have one. Because you're through the Department of Education, I'm assuming that you are required to have paid staff for... Oh, yes. Okay. Just making sure that... Yes. We have... All of our staff is paid and it goes through the Mammoth Unified School District hiring process. Right. So...
59:41 Everybody's qualified, and then I offer first aid, CPR, and all of that. All of my teachers are. So the children don't know, but for every teacher we have an aide. To them, they're all teachers, and I'm the boss, so. But yeah, they're all fully qualified. We offer opportunities for parents to come on hikes and participate in coaching and things like that. But it's very selective.
1:00:10 And given that half of my parents have to be working in order for their children to attend, that cuts down on my volunteer. No questions. Thank you. No questions. Thank you, Sandy. Okay. Great. So are there any comments from the public before the commission deliberates and makes our funding recommendation? Emily, go ahead. And please, you have to come up to the microphone, please, for the benefit of our home audience.
1:00:47 Hello again. Emily Woods from MLR. I just wanted to make one quick note based on a little bit of what I was hearing from the organizations, one of which was hammering people. The great thing about CrowdRise is that you can actually have a URL that you can put as an email signature in newsletters, social media, like Facebook, things like that. So this can be kind of a passive way of doing fundraising on top of your current fundraising events that you're working on, or you can actually use it saying, hey,
1:01:17 We have the shark event going on. So if you want to donate, you can go through CrowdRise and actually name the student that you are supporting. So just wanted to throw that out there that CrowdRise is really great for either passive fundraising or focusing on a specific event. So just want to throw that out so you don't have to hammer. Thanks, Emily. Heidi, do you have something? You have to come up to the microphone if you have a comment.
1:01:49 I just forgot to mention that I like option four, I'm supportive of that, but I also thought Kara had some good points because a lot of these kids are double dipping. So what about like option four with maybe giving some of that 1100 to the single dippers? Okay, thank you. Okay, any additional public comment? Okay, then I will bring it back up to the condition for deliberation. Who would like to start? Sean? Oh, man.
1:02:21 First of all, I just want to say that, you know, of all the work that we do up here on the Recreation Commission, I can take both sides of almost every single argument.
1:02:35 But this, every single year, is one of the most emotionally challenging, I'll call it, because, you know, I would like to fund everybody plus two or three hundred percent increase. I think that, you know, what we do here in the eastern Sierra is really promoting outdoor recreation is the number one commodity that we have to sell, tourism. And we bring people here for skiing, mountain biking, or fishing. And we get so many of our kids actually involved in this. So that's just a real quick just kind of statement.
1:03:05 Coach's Clinic, great idea, and that's actually something that, as far as talking about the assistance program, you know, I'm looking at the list of things that the assistance program would provide to the different entities, and I think Coach's Clinic actually is a great idea, especially just to make sure that the kids are experiencing a great time rather than just win, win, win. CrowdRise, take advantage of that. I think that, yeah.
1:03:33 As a parent myself, one of the biggest challenges is that, you know, almost every week it's coming home, hey, dad, can we, you know, do this, can we do this? And it is tough when you're constantly going back to the same well, so I hope we can take advantage of that. So, getting to as far as the, actually, applications go,
1:03:55 You know, very sorry that we didn't hear from youth hockey or youth football this year, but I understand the challenges. We all have day jobs, and so it is very difficult to also be involved in a board of directors on sports funding. My question as far as option number four goes is that, is that really going to leave enough money?
1:04:19 You know, I think we talked about a little bit about the opportunity that if some of these either football or hockey were to come back and actually apply for the funds, is that something that we can even allow? I mean, we set up a process here for awarding for this 16, 17, or 17, 18 year here. And is that something that we could even award later on in the year? I think that's a question for staff. You're the recommending buddy, so it's really your process.
1:04:50 Okay. You make the recommendation and council awards it, so that's something that, you know, you could state in your conditions when you make the recommendation to council for the funding. I'll just end my comments and questions with this note. Again, I would love to give everybody exactly what they're asking for and even more. With regard to this option four, I'm supportive of this.
1:05:15 But my only concern is that is, and that's after we fund the $2,000 for the assistance program is kind of the way that I'm going with this, but I'm just concerned that $1,100, I really want to see hockey come back. I really want to see the football come back.
1:05:35 And are we leaving enough money? And again, I hate to say it like this, but if we only increased on the 2016 award by, say, 20%, could we leave a little bit more? How realistic is that? I don't necessarily have an answer. I just want to say out loud that that is my internal debate going on. Thank you. Christy?
1:06:00 First, I want to just thank all of the volunteers in this community for all of the time and energy and fundraising activities that you do because it really helps us to expand programming for our youth. And I have some of the same debates that you have, Sean, and I just keep on coming back to it's about the kids, you know, in terms of hockey and football that if they're
1:06:28 Our sections of our community out there that still wants to participate in those sports, I'd like to hold that option for them. With that said, I also want to be fair to the people who did get their applications in in a timely manner and have made the point to show up today, including sick people. So I am leaning toward staff's recommendation for option four.
1:06:57 I'm also leaning toward, I have been debating about leaning toward option one in terms of just funding the request. We have the money for it. Our organizations know what they need in order to be solvent and successful this coming year. And I'm entertaining that notion as well. And then the last thing that I'm thinking about is just, and this just comes.
1:07:25 Just this is just me as the marketer. There are market forces out there. And if we're seeing there might be a national dip in participation at the eight and nine year old stage. But I also think that if we are seeing some natural dips in.
1:07:46 Some sports and natural increases in other sports, there are some market forces at work there that we need to pay attention to and increase funding for those.
1:07:58 Those activities that are that have the most interest. And then lastly, I just want to say that I am very, very sensitive to what Kara said about disabled sports being the only outlet for our disabled kids in our community. I just want to give a shout out to the volleyball team for being collaborative and community minded. So thank you very much. And I'm definitely leaning toward making sure that disabled sports has the funding they need to make sure that our disabled kids have that outlet.
1:08:29 Green? I feel like we have a pretty well-established process for the youth sports funding applications that we've been doing. I really have some concerns about holding money in reserve for organizations that may come back as far as setting a precedent for now we're doing this process twice a year or, you know, what have you. As far as
1:08:59 Across the board increases. I have some concerns about accountability of funds being used for awarding any organization more than they requested. To that end, it seems pretty easy to me to take the easy win on option one and move on. Anything further? No. Okay, thank you.
1:09:31 So, again, I just want to echo everyone's comments, but we just really appreciate your participation in this process. We know it's the very least of what you do for the youth in our community, so thank you, and thank you to everyone who attended our workshop and our Recreation Open House and submitted their applications, and it's here today, so we really appreciate all of your time. I am not in favor of option one, simply because I really respect that
1:10:01 A lot of the organizations recognize that this is a limited pool of funds and without a substantial change in their program from the prior year. I just really appreciated the organizations that recognized that and were very realistic in their funding requests. I don't necessarily think it's right to award the organizations who perhaps applied for a large sum of funds without substantial changes in their program from the prior year, whereas other organizations were...
1:10:28 Cognizant, I think, of the amount of money that we have to award, and yes, we all certainly wish it was more. Option two, I'm not in favor of for this year, but I'm certainly open to looking at for next year. Option three, I really prefer option four because I'm concerned
1:10:47 There was some conversation at our workshop about maybe getting a flag football league going, and I think it would be nice with Mammoth Youth Football not coming back to apply for funds. I would like to have some funds available.
1:11:00 Flag Football is able to transition into that nonprofit or to form a board. There hasn't been a lot of time for them to do that, so I didn't really expect them to be able to participate in this process. There is no board for that yet, but I think it's a great option. I think we heard a lot of support from everyone at the workshop for that. I'm also just, you know, just have concerns about, you know, the boards that do run into challenges because, you know, everyone in this room, including the commission, you know, we're all volunteers, so I think we understand that.
1:11:27 And then I'm simply not in favor of option five just because everyone is serving a different audience and a different number of kids. And we always, I think, struggle with this funding recommendation because everyone does such an amazing job, but it's really hard to directly compare your organizations to each other. And I'm also very sensitive to the fact that the SES serves kids that no one else really serves, or they make it possible for kids to participate who wouldn't otherwise. So just in fairness, I personally am in favor of option four.
1:11:56 The other thing that I want to add is I'm very much in favor of the sporting organization assistance program. I think we're very sensitive to the fact that everyone struggles with fundraising. I think anything that, excuse me, we can do to relieve that burden or make it simpler and less time consuming is fantastic. I really appreciate MLR's willingness to come forward with that. And finally, I just, I also really like, I just really...
1:12:21 We do see national trends where kids are, you know, because in some sports there is a lot of emphasis on winning and so you do see kids, that's not necessarily what they're looking for and so 8, 9, and 10 are really critical ages that you kind of start to see declines in participation in organized sports. So I think that anything that we can do to provide support for your organizations to help address those issues I think is really critical. And finally the last thing I want to say is that
1:12:47 You know, our department does an amazing job, but there is no way that we could serve the kids that you guys do. So we're very appreciative. We're very well aware of that. And just thank you again for being here today. So what I have heard is I've heard Sean asking if it's possible to leave a little bit more than 1100. Just saying that was more of an internal debate. Internal debate? Okay.
1:13:14 And then so I also hear Christy saying she's supportive of holding some of those funds, but also wanting to be fair to the organizations who got their applications in, but you're also maybe interested in looking at option one. Yes, that's true. And in terms of option four, I'm on the fence about that. I'm willing to...
1:13:34 I'm willing to go with that. I would just like staff to give us some direction moving forward about how we would structure allocating those funds, rolling over those funds, and all of the details regarding managing those funds. So really quickly, I'm happy that you're considering that. We like it because the organization's very dynamic. I mean, you know, they come and go. I've been on those boards. I get it. A lot of challenges.
1:14:04 Our proposal would be somewhat with conditions of whether we establish a deadline for those funding application. I would assume that each of the organizations, whoever's available, I would really kind of target the existing organizations first. I would probably put the emphasis on those two. Coming forward at a certain time, they have to apply, you know, go through the process. We can establish when that would be, but again, that's difficult with some boards. But again, at the end of the day, I'd like to probably consider a date.
1:14:33 Then it kind of puts a bit of ownership on those organisations to really, if they're really serious about, you know, providing a great or an enhanced amenity for our youth, because that's really what we're trying to do here. Let's maybe establish that deadline. Could be November 1, you know, could be that meeting, could be October. If it's really the fall program for, you know, flag football, then it could be June.
1:14:57 You know, so we really want to kind of maybe, you know, talk about those conditions. If those funds aren't awarded, then our proposal would be that they roll into the Youth Sports Funding Assistance Program, which has the benefit of all those groups, you know, utilizing those funds. So that's kind of how we see it right now, but happy to kind of engage in a discussion with the Commission on that. Thank you. Stu, is there any timeline for us? So we're the recommending body to Town Council who makes the final determination on awarding these funds. So would that have any determination on what that date?
1:15:27 Should be if we went that route? So we're proposing to present this to Council at their next meeting in April. I believe it's the 19th. So we really want to kind of move that timetable up so we can get the money to the groups as soon as we can. As far as the second round of funding, it just would be in your recommendation if you make to the Council at that time. So, you know, happy to...
1:15:51 You know, go through that discussion with you, but I would probably recommend a timeline, right, moves that along. If it's not applied for, there's no applications by that deadline, the funding just automatically rolls over in the assistance program, and then away we go, working with those groups like these great programs that we've talked about. Okay. Can I be, can I just be more firm on my support of that then? Okay. Okay, great. Thank you. Sean, did you have a question? Well, no, I didn't kind of really comment earlier and wondering if we should say more, but hearing that
1:16:19 Option, and I hear Clayton's comment very loud and clear that, you know, we do kind of need to stick to a process, and as much as I really want football and hockey to continue going forward, I mean, our multi-use facility is built around hockey in a lot of different ways, the programming thereof. Some of the best money that could be spent is establishing this assistance program, youth sports organization, and so perhaps that $1,100 should be going towards that.
1:16:50 As opposed to setting aside funds for a yet-to-be-determined process of actually awarding those. I was just going to say, my concern with that, though, is what we're looking at is we're looking at the fallibility of adults, not the kids, right? And so if the board implodes somehow, then all of those kids are out of this programming because their board
1:17:19 Couldn't get their ducks in a row. And so that's just really where my concern is, because if somebody does step up in this community, one of these great volunteers does step up and says, you know, we have this.
1:17:31 All these kids that want to play hockey, I'm going to take responsibility. And $1,100 is not a lot of money. And so part of it is, you know, all these people sitting in the audience are getting quite a bit more, might be getting quite a bit more than $1,100. And so I think that there's some checks and balances there by keeping the money low and letting the adults just really hustle, but also creating an environment where the kids don't suffer without this programming for a year because a board failed.
1:18:01 Sorry. That's all right. So I just wanted to mention, so Clayton, what I heard from you is, and I certainly agree with your concern about holding funds when we do have a process in place, the people who are here today got their applications in, their boards have everything together. And I also understand what you're saying, too, about the accountability of public funds and just whether we should just award people what they requested.
1:18:30 Yeah, please. I just wanted to follow up on the Youth Supporting Organization Assistance Program, and I think I expressed a similar sentiment in the last meeting. I think it's a great idea. However, I would challenge staff to find an alternative funding stream for it. When I see that we have an already limited supply of funds for direct support of community youth programs, I'm hesitant to...
1:18:57 Tap that, even though it is a supporting program. I feel that it's something that could be funded outside of this process or funding stream. Okay. So, is anyone interested in making a motion? Yeah, I'll make a motion. Okay. I will make a motion that we adopt. Let's see. Am I making a motion? I'll make a motion to the establishment.
1:19:32 of the Youth Sports Organization Assistant Program for $1,000 and option number four, which is just a straight up increase of the 2016 awards by 30% to those organizations that applied with the remaining funds of $1,100 to be held in reserve for existing or new youth sport organization funds in a process to be determined.
1:19:59 So can I just ask you a clarifying question? You said $1,000-ish for this Youth Supporting Assistance Program? Did you mean $2,000? I did mean $2,000. Thank you for clarifying. So you'll amend your motion? I will amend that motion. That motion. Thank you. Okay. I have a motion. Is there a second? I'll second. Any further discussion? Okay. So I will take a roll. So I have a motion and a second.
1:20:22 For option four, recommend awarding a 30% increase on 2016 awards with the remaining funds of $1,100 being held in reserve for existing or new youth sporting organizations with the Husky Club to receive $6,000 and formation of the Youth Sports Organization Assistance Program at a level of $2,000. And since this is a financial recommendation to Council, Jamie, I'll take a roll call vote, please. No. Aye. Vice Chair Turner? Yes. Yes.
1:20:51 Motion passes three to one. Thank you, everyone. With that, I will take a five-minute recess. Thank you. Yes, we can go get Laurel here. I'll text her. Is she in there or did she get in on Starbucks? I think those are some good points and I think we can definitely re-examine this process next year. Betsy, do you have a minute away from the mix? Yep, leave it.
1:21:51 No food in the house, so we had to go to the grocery store, and I kept running into all these people I know and feeling a little bit guilty, but I was like, I have no food in the house, I'm not going to do well if I can't feed myself, but 10 o'clock on a Thursday morning is kind of when to go. It totally is. All right, I will reconvene us. Next up, we have staff presentations. The 2718 Parks and Recreation Department budget introduction. Thank you, Chair. You're welcome.
1:22:22 The presentation I'd like to present to you today is what I presented to Town Council in a workshop format a couple of weeks ago. So it kind of gives you an introduction into the department, talks about our vision, mission, strategies, what we've just accomplished, which Council were very impressed with, by the way. And also kind of gives you a structure of the department if you're not familiar with it. And then it kind of runs through kind of a budget overview and then certainly kind of a little level of service presentation slash discussion. So I'll kind of run through that.
1:22:52 It's probably about five minutes. Any questions at the end? Where this leads to is obviously budget deliberations with council as it moves along. The opportunity for the department heads to get in front of the council was very appreciated. It was a great open format. It was a good dialogue. It wasn't threatening. It wasn't really challenging. It was really just a matter of this is what we do.
1:23:17 And these are the funds we need to provide that service. And then it got into a little bit of a deeper discussion about level of service, right? So I'll get into that because it'll be a good discussion. So this was just an introduction. We try and keep it really simple. You've seen probably a lot of this information, so I'll kind of get through it. If I'm going too fast, just let me know. A lot of it should be very well known to you. This is certainly that slide that kind of describes and characterizes kind of what we do. And the key words here is obviously high quality.
1:23:46 Diverse and, you know, really enhancing quality of life. And what I kind of call it the big C in the big C. Big B in the big C, right? Building community. I think that's really kind of the essence of what we do. This is our shared vision that we're all achieving and striving to achieve. Our mission has not changed. And that's really, I mean, it speaks to everything that we do, right? And I think it spoke to, you know, that community discussion we just had.
1:24:12 I mean, this is something that we are committed to, to provide multi-purpose year-round indoor-outdoor recreation accessible to all residents and visitors, and that's exactly that program we just completed. The Department Values, People Parks Programs, hopefully that's familiar to everybody. Organizational chart, I don't know if you've seen this for a while. This was kind of part of our reorganization that we went to about 18 months ago. We kind of formalized this last year that I'll kind of get into.
1:24:41 No real surprises here, I don't think. You know, Warren and his team starting kind of in this left-hand side here or the right-hand side above me. You know, Warren oversees two parks maintenance workers with a full-time. We have temporary seasonal parks maintenance positions. That's typically about five to six employees seasonally. And we've got a couple of those coming on. We've got three of those staff coming back.
1:25:07 We're looking at bringing Michael from the ice rink. If you remember Michael, he was our assistant site coordinator. He's going to work with us this summer on a seasonal basis on our parks and then see if we can get him back to the rink again. So, you know, things that we're really looking at to kind of recruit and retain our staff. On the middle side, you can see we reclassified Lindsay's position to kind of what's called the program facilities coordinator. That was from kind of a general town staff assistant position.
1:25:36 So Lindsay kind of splits her time between both of those responsibilities. So one supporting parks and certainly supporting kind of our recreation programming and our facility operations. And then on the recreation side, we have that vacant position, which is kind of the recreation manager. That's essentially an unfunded position, just moving forward. Underneath kind of that structure is John and Steph, John and Kat, sorry. Kat, Kat, Kat.
1:26:06 John and Kat over there. And then underneath there, you have on John's side, you've got coordinators, senior rec leaders, recreational leaders, which is all the hiring we're doing right now, and sports officials. So on that side, under John's side, is about kind of 30 seasonal staff. And under Kat's side, we have facility site coordinators, assistants, attendants, and lifeguards. And we have almost about the same on that side, about 25, 20 to 25 people. So the size of the apartment is very scalable, you know, total staff when we kind of ramp up.
1:26:35 Fully kind of in a summer situation is about 55. So that's a big operation. Any questions on the org chart there? Strategic work plan, again, council was very impressed. And the way we were kind of identifying and using the strategic work plan, it's really driving the budget discussion, right? It's really driving where the funds go and where we're allocating them. So I'm not sure I really need to spend too much time here.
1:27:04 But these are all very familiar tours, a great discussion. And then you can see we added Embrace Emerging Trends right on our org structure. A few major accomplishments we kind of listed here. Reorganisation was formalised last year. Our summer camp participation increased by 24%. Pool visits were up 21%. Rec zone by 17%, which again, that was primarily due to our summer camps themselves.
1:27:30 So that was really kind of the focus on driving our parks and rec camps, using that as our hub, and that will obviously be the plan this year. We executed the joint use agreement with the school district, which was great, replaced the 1991 agreement. We secured the Volcom naming rights agreement. We conducted that extensive outreach for our plan MCP project.
1:27:53 And then we were awarded the District 7 Outstanding Facility Award for Charleston Parks. So those were kind of our major accomplishments. Just want to make sure we always keep that at the front of what we do. These are our functions for our department. You can see we have five primary functions, recreation programming, facility programming, administration, parks maintenance crews, and recreation management planning promotion. And then we kind of divide, conquer, based on those functions.
1:28:22 And our staff are kind of prioritised based on those functions themselves. So if we get into kind of recreation programming, what we do here is kind of describe the goal, the service standards, so how we're actually evaluating the level of service we're providing. And then we kind of came up with a grade. And this is something we did collectively as staff. So you can see here, we're all very familiar with our programming goals. Our service standards were really aligned to the customer survey.
1:28:50 Our focus group. So these are all very quantifiable metrics that we're able to kind of utilize year after year to kind of evaluate our standards. So you can see it's diversity, number of age-appropriate programs, our process for registration, value for money, quality, service, our counselor participation ratio, our waitlist utilization. We always want to try and decrease the waitlist and increase the utilization and availability of information. And we kind of graded that as an A minus.
1:29:18 The way that we would like to increase that is through, as we talk about the budget coming up, is really adding more seasonal counselors into that program to provide that better kind of ratio, the better quality of service, and really expand and move deeper into kind of broader programming. So we really want to kind of establish more adult programs, you know, more senior programs. We really cover the three to five, I think, pretty well.
1:29:44 We've got the 6 to 9 totally own that market. You know, the 10 to 14 teens who obviously still want to do some more with, but that's really kind of related to facilities. So that's kind of why it's really an A, A minus. Any comments on that? Well, I want to ask questions about the grids, but I think I'll wait till the end. Okay. Sounds good. Budget implications. So what we were requesting in our budget was the addition of two senior recreation leaders, which I just kind of talked about.
1:30:13 You can see kind of the cost increase for those staff, and you can see the benefits of adding those staff. And you can see, based on yesterday as well, it's not just a fly-by-night type of increase. This is something that's substantial. It's going to continue, and it's something we've been dealing with, you can see, since almost 2012 when we just started to take off.
1:30:36 And we're doubling and tripling our numbers, you know, over a five-year period. So, you know, there's going to be more and more kids. So we just have to be smarter and more strategic in how we kind of meet that capacity. And that's kind of a lot to do with the strategic work plan. So that's a very modest increase. So really all we asked there for our seasonal staff request was about $6,000 from last year. Programming, multi-use, sorry, multi-purpose year-round indoor. That's kind of our mission there.
1:31:05 As it relates to facility program. Service standards, again, very similar. Because really what we're doing here is just providing programming in our facilities. So that's the Whitmore Pool, that's the ice rink, that's our community centers, that's our parks. So very similar as well. But what we're talking about here is condition of fields and facilities. And really because of that, I believe the programming is certainly elevating.
1:31:30 Providing broader, more diverse and I think more specific programming for our age appropriate customers. But because of the deferred implications of the facilities, it's really kind of a B plus. So that's really how we kind of, you know, have defined and graded that level of service. Budget implications for our recreation programming. We're really looking at just adding additional funds for enhanced programming, few supplies, needed facility updates. It's really kind of a
1:32:00 It's kind of more paint than really kind of any structural improvement to the program there. But again, what we're really trying to do is make sure we can increase our Learn to Swim program. So Kat will talk about it, you know, coming up a little bit with our operating plan for our pool. But you can see they're drowning second leading cause of injury death for children 1 to 14. And really in our community, there's so many backyard pools, so many community pools. How do we make sure that we're really reaching out, making sure everybody has the opportunity to be water safe?
1:32:29 Provide animation at our ageing facilities. And then provide lockers. And this is kind of getting a bit more specific at our pool. Lockers for staff, paint, shower curtains, office functionality, et cetera. So nothing big. Just to try and maintain what we have. But you can see certainly the pool. And this is the history of the pool visits per day. That little graph there, you've seen that before. But we're slowly starting to increase that visitation again at Whitmore Pool. From the administration point of view,
1:33:00 This is kind of combined with what kind of we all do collectively as a department. And you can kind of read the goal. Our service standards, again, very similar to what we've established in the survey. But here we actually start to look at communication plan. How do we measure that? Oversight of web-based reservation systems, financial management, special event support. So that's kind of our broad functions of administration. And we're kind of, you know, rating that with a grade of an A minus. But there's no budget implications for it.
1:33:30 that administration. Parks Maintenance. So that's our goal of our Parks Maintenance team. That's really to enhance existing and to accommodate the community needs. Obviously, as you can kind of get a sense of what's happening in our community right now with our sports groups, a lot more need and certainly the challenge that we have at our facilities right now. So there's obviously more demand than we can kind of really manage right now.
1:33:58 And again, this just talks about how we're kind of evaluating that. So it's effective, efficient maintenance of our parks, trails, facilities, parks management condition of our fields, which we use through our surveys, special event support, parks admin. And this is really kind of a C plus. I mean, it's pretty straightforward. If you really read this kind of fine print here.
1:34:18 You know, Warren was pretty honest about this too, right? So I mean, it's not reflective of the quality of work that the staff are putting in or the professionalism. It's really just due with the fact that, you know, all our facilities require significant investments in funding. Public work support. So this is kind of the other half of what Parks Maintenance do. And this is specifically our winter sidewalk snow removal. Our maintenance of town, which you know is challenged. Or building grounds maintenance.
1:34:48 We also maintain the Visitor Center, the Tourism Office, which is falling apart. We look after the street lamppost banners and then they have a lot of community event support and we rated that a kind of a B minus.
1:35:01 Again, we would like to, an A service, if you look at kind of sidewalk snow removal, would be kind of an additional staff, which is kind of what we're looking at in a second, additional equipment, you know, managing the mups in a winter fashion, you know, is that something we can kind of clear or pack or maintain in wintertime? So that's kind of where we see it's almost an A service versus a B service right now.
1:35:23 And this is these graphs that we presented to you last year, you know, talking about demand over year after year, I mean, Shady Rest Park, I mean, that's just a staggering increase that we're seeing at our facility, so we're very challenged. This is a list of all the assets that we do have that we oversee, a lot more than everybody thinks, so that kind of gives you a bit of a breakdown there. And this is just a very, you know, matter-of-fact slide that we just need to be aware of, right?
1:35:54 And I think it's really to Commissioner Osborne's point, you know, that last commission meeting, you know, we truly want to be, you know, this community, realise this vision that we've stated and we've firmed. The way we're going about it is not going to deliver that vision. So, there we go. And this was, I think, the pool in 1939. Bill's maybe in the photo somewhere, I'm not too sure. You said it, not me. Yep. Actually, I said that at the same meeting, but...
1:36:22 Life expectancy of that Whitmore pool is 60 years, we believe. And that was in, I think that was 2000. So we're about 17 years over the life expectancy of that pool. So if everyone talks about how many more years do we have, well, we're way past it. Okay, so that's our challenge with that. Same exact pool. I thought it seemed like the exact same pool. Yeah. Budget implications.
1:36:47 So really, for us to address what we're saying here is the growing and expanding deferred obligations to town, we have three kind of strategies that we're presenting, and it's what we discussed with town. So it's really staff equipment funding, right? It's not too surprising. So what we proposed in the town budget was a new kind of full-time, what we're calling kind of the hybrid public works parks maintenance position.
1:37:11 So it's adding an additional 990 hours, you know, to our total hours we have to maintain the facilities. So we go from 5,000 to 6,000 hours is what we do in summertime. But essentially in wintertime, this would be kind of a full-time winter snow removal operator. So it adds to their capabilities in wintertime. And then we get the 990 hours on the summertime as well. So towns presented that. Council are very receptive to that.
1:37:39 So we'll see how that moves along. But that's something that we are very interested on advocating for is certainly from town staff. Ideally, it would be great to have these two separate full-time positions, right? But again, understanding the fiscal challenges that we have as a town, we came up and that was really Grady and I sitting down with Warren and Todd and kind of running through if we had, you know, in a realistic setting, can we make this work?
1:38:06 We really believe we can make this work and be successful and fix some of our deferred issues. Or really the issue now is that really the staff are maintaining what they have. They really can't get to really improving anything because of the limitations with staff. Equipment. We've proposed to replace a mower that we think is about almost 30 years old down at Whitmore.
1:38:30 And that's actually part of our vehicle replacement fund. So that's probably not going to be a major impact on the budget as a one-time cost. That's just money that we've been setting aside. Town staff also have requested a vehicle replacement for one of the new loaders and blowers. One of those pieces of machinery, it's a loader plus a blower. That's three quarters of a million dollars. So they've requested that as well. And we're just asking for a mower. But you can see they're very important. They're all in scale.
1:39:00 We don't technically have an aerator for our parks and facilities, right? So we have some different things that we use, but we don't actually have an aerator that kind of maintains and adds to the integrity of the soil and so forth. So that's something we're looking at as well. Currently, we use a Ford Ranger, which is kind of a vehicle up and down our MUP system, which is challenging, right? So if we've got a Ford Ranger going up and down Lakes Basin Path...
1:39:28 It's really not probably the preferred piece of equipment. So what we'd really like to look at there is, you know, replacing it with one of these pieces of machinery here. And so we're really kind of exploring what that looks like. Is that something can be used with Joel and his trails maintenance crews? That could be a joint Measure R funded type of thing. But again, how do we just do a better job and more efficient job of maintaining what we have?
1:39:49 And then funding. So you can see here we've had that discussion about our MUP deterioration. We have about 20 miles of MUPs around town. We did this one section down here last summer. We're going through pretty well and a comprehensive evaluation of those MUPs this spring, if we ever get spring. But that'll kind of give us a scale of the 20 miles, you know, what mileage needs to be kind of either replaced or repaired or what type of treatment are really looking at to maintain those MUPs. And that could be anywhere from kind of $200,000 to $1 million.
1:40:18 You know, we don't really know, right, but that's a big number. Obviously, multiple facility repairs, additional fertilizer. We really only fertilize once a year in our parks, right? It would be nice to get that up to a higher level, and that's going from a level C to a B. We've trialed some organic fertilizer at Shady Res Park, and we'd like to kind of broaden that across the other parks as well, but it's a higher cost.
1:40:40 Baseball infield mix. You know, this is something that, you know, we're really challenged with. Our baseball fields, softball fields require a lot of attention. We really like to get some expert advice to come and help us, tell us if we can do those better or more efficiently in a different way. Skate park repairs and professional development. So there's this maintenance management school, something we want to send Warren to. It's a great, it's actually a five-year program, but you can just do it one or two years. But really what that kind of puts together is a parks maintenance plan.
1:41:10 Based on the assets that we have, the activity, the frequency of the maintenance and so forth. And it would really help staff and the commission. We would basically come forward and say, based on what we currently have, which is why we're at sea level, the amount of hours required to maintain what we have is X and we've only funded to Y. So where do we bridge that gap in the discrepancy?
1:41:32 So really this tool is to help us more effectively manage the assets that we have based on our financial constraints. So that's kind of the purpose of that school. The last category here is our Parks and Recreation Management. It's again, it's kind of the majority of kind of what we all do. You can see it's a pretty broad goal. You've probably seen that before.
1:41:53 And then really three service standards. One is really Parks and Recreation Management, which is really staffing our commission and our support, our planning and our promotion, and then finally kind of the public outreach or kind of the communication. So that's kind of our service standard and we're kind of at an A, A- for that right now. We can go on about that a little bit more, but I think that's it. But that's kind of our presentation to council. Any questions on the presentation?
1:42:23 Thank you for the time. Hopefully that was valuable. Thank you. Welcome. Laurel, would you like to start? Since you're back. No questions. Okay. Christy? I have a couple. One with the MUP deterioration. Can you just explain to me, because I honestly don't know where the NGO MLTPA fits into this, because I thought...
1:42:51 And I might be mistaken, but I thought that they were the NGO that sort of catalyzed the MUP build out, and I'm just wondering if they are still involved with maintenance or if they're just capital improvements in that regard. Yeah, so they're primarily focused on their soft surface trail system, and these are all our hard surface trails, so much like the sidewalks and the MUPs. These are all town-owned and managed, so as far as kind of measure R, it's almost a supplanting concern regarding.
1:43:19 Okay. And then also just kind of similarly the other NGO, MLR, has stated that the MUP is a priority project. So I'm just wondering, are there any synergies between us and NGOs to help with this maintenance? Because I'm so proud of our MUP, but yeah, if we don't maintain it, it's not going to be anything nice. Yeah, so the effort that we're going to conduct actually in spring,
1:43:49 Again, on that is kind of utilizing a lot of Joel's technology and a lot of our technology. So we're both engaged in that process. So I think that's kind of where the synergy lies. I think that the delineation is really the funding source, though.
1:44:04 It's a town obligation, so the town needs to make sure that we maintain what we have. And then my last question is, one of the things that I'm really concerned about as a commissioner in general and really pleased about as a commissioner is our youth participation in the sports and how we can accommodate them and programming, not just with staff, but facilities.
1:44:25 Do you have any projections on if this is going to continue to grow at this rate based on increased in visitation and also youth population? Like, do we have a whole bunch of babies in town that are going to need this in five years? Yes.
1:44:45 There are a lot of babies, but actually in my Nutrition and Physical Activity Task Force meeting, the birth rate in Mammoth actually fell last year. I'm just concerned looking at this. We really need to start thinking a long-term strategy about accommodating our youth programs with staffing, programming, and facilities. Thanks, Stu. Yeah, it's a great point. It was kind of the strategic alignment, I think, regarding that
1:45:15 Strategy. And that's a big part of kind of what we're trying to do here. And that's, I think it was number three. Yeah, align resources with demand. I mean, this is an ongoing, you know, situation. You can see the graph. It's, you know, identified. It's just off the charts. And if it's anything like yesterday, wow, I mean, we could probably take double the amount of kids in these programs, right? But how do we, you know, from a realistic point of view with capacity and fiscal restraints and our challenges, you know, meet that demand?
1:45:44 Something we're very interested, you know, work with the community with. And I think that's the whole premise of the discussion with that youth sports funding. That's why that funding is there because we just don't have the resources and the capacity to deliver all those great programs that these groups do. And I think that's why I really believe strongly in that program and that assistance program that we can kind of all help us, you know, grow these programs. And what I'm really looking forward to and something I didn't mention, you know, on the budget implications for the parks maintenance is something we've pushed forward to.
1:46:12 With Council, and they're interested in talking to us as well, is that if we keep adding all these maintenance costs to the budget and so forth, one, there's probably not enough money to really kind of get caught up, but is there a sum of money we can kind of allocate right now over two years that could address these major deferred problems that we have in our parks and our facilities that, again, is not a structural change or a structural deficit to our budget as it moves on, right?
1:46:41 Right now, the non-discretionary part of our budget, which is all our staff and the wages, just keeps going up and up, right? So there's a lot of, you know, demand and stress on, you know, just getting enough revenue to cover that. So is there an opportunity with kind of a year like we've had, with kind of a surplus discussion to saying, can we allocate a chunk of that money, assign it to kind of the Parks and Rec Department through the commission, and over two years we can actually utilise those funds to address those priority lists that we've identified?
1:47:11 Because it's the only way we're really going to get caught up. Because I just don't think the budget can withstand $100,000 each year over the next 10 years, right? We're not going to get caught up. But if there's an opportunity for us to advocate for a chunk of money for the commission, then I think that's pretty valuable. And the council are receptive to that. So that's part of the budget discussion coming up. So I'll keep you posted on that because I think that's a great, great thing that we can actually get done pretty quickly. And then we can use those funds.
1:47:40 To leverage our youth sporting groups, you know, like Little League talk about enhancing the fields. Well, here we go. So the town's in. Maybe we can get to that shack, the snack shack at Shady finally, right? So, hey, had the town's willing to put in this 50,000, how can you kind of leverage that to kind of enhance that facility? So, good discussion. We're interested. Christy, anything else? No, thank you. Clayton? Well, I'm certainly glad to hear that the growing deferred maintenance liabilities are coming to the top of the heap.
1:48:13 Could you elaborate more on the metrics and process for the grading system that you had on some of the slides? So a lot of it's based on, as I talked about, the first two are really kind of on our, you know, if you look at these two, Facility Program and Recreation, I mean, those are based on the current customer surveys that we receive. So we actually rate.
1:48:42 And we grade all of those metrics. So that was kind of how we were kind of establishing those numbers. A lot of it's probably anecdotal. I'll admit that. A lot of it's kind of a discussion that we have as a general group. So between some quantifiable metrics that are kind of year over year and some anecdotal discussions and kind of the issues, that's really that metric. I would love to kind of develop a more robust way to do that, but it's probably going to look like Kat's algorithm she had up there, right?
1:49:11 But I think it gives you, as a starting point for discussion, I think it's a fair representation and characterization of the status of kind of our parks, fields, facilities, programs, and so forth. Fair enough. There you go. Thank you. Good question, though. Anything else? No. Sean? Yeah. That's what I was going to ask about was the grading as well. And, you know, frankly...
1:49:36 Stu, actually, even before I go into that, I've got to give compliments to you and your staff for developing for the entire strategic program we've got here. I know we had accepted it there in a couple meetings ago, but I very much appreciate that you and your staff, first of all, came up with this strategy all the way around as far as just strategic plan.
1:49:59 The work plan going forward. And I think in reviewing that, it really does keep your head kind of at that 40,000 foot level when it's so easy to get caught up in the weeds of having to deal with just, you know, the maintenance that goes on. So thank you very much for reviewing that and making this presentation. And even before I say anything about the grade, the one slide that's just after your first grade is the budget implications. Yeah.
1:50:29 Hover on that in front of town council for a while. We just got out of our youth sports funding award and our amount has changed the same for the past seven years and what is that, a triple increase in actual participants?
1:50:46 So it may be at a time where a point where town council does need to consider significantly increasing the youth sports funding. Now, where is this money going to come from? That's always the big challenge that we face on that, and that's town council's job on a lot of that. But, you know, that slide right there I just think says so much, especially coming out of the process that we just did. With regard to the grading,
1:51:11 You know, in some of these grades, I would have given you a higher grade, especially considering with the facilities that you guys have to work with. The fact that you've got equipment that is as old as it is, Whitmore Pool, you know, all these different facilities. You guys do a very good job, in my opinion. We do a very good job as far as the programming goes. The only comment I would say there is maybe to answer the question of what are the parameters, what are the guidelines that you come up with. You may want to stick in the word self-grade.
1:51:42 A minus, just so it's clear. But, you know, because that's what it was. A lot of it was anecdotal. Maybe worth that. But again, you know, as a commissioner, I would say you guys even deserve a little bit higher grade. So I just, let me just run through my notes. Oh, on the budget implications, slide number 16, I think it is. You know, I noticed that two out of these three increased fundings are going towards
1:52:13 The pool. But if we go to this slide number 20, as far as the park and facility reservations, you know, I just see a lot of the increased demand going towards the reservations. And I guess I'm kind of using that slide as a comparison with regard to the facility programming where we're going with that. I think more than anything that just says that, you know, we need a new pool.
1:52:46 But again, I keep saying these things of it's only money, right? I think that's an interesting point. The other half of that discussion, too, is aligned resources with demand. And the challenges at Shady Res Park, all of those are big numbers. When we did that CIP major maintenance list, I mean, there's $100,000 and $200,000 of deferred maintenance just at that park alone. So what we're really talking about on that previous slide is that's just a couple of thousand dollars.
1:53:16 Yeah. And that's all the budget allows, right? So, I mean, that just speaks to the elephant in the room about that massive number of deferred maintenance. The budget just structurally won't be able to handle that kind of increase year after year that we need to get done. That's why we're really kind of pushing for this one-time, you know, funding source that could help us address this, you know, like now. Yeah. Because it'll just get more and more expensive. Yeah. Fair enough. Yeah. Just make sure. These are just notes, I think.
1:53:46 Oh, the CPRS Maintenance Management School. Have we attended that before? Has anyone from your staff attended that before? Well, great. What a great school. I'm supportive. Absolutely. Thank you. That's great. And that's a big part. I mean, it speaks to that strategic work plan again about professional development, recruiting and retaining, and providing the tools necessary for our staff to be successful. And I think that's brilliant. I mean, it's something I'm a huge proponent of. Yeah. Yeah.
1:54:14 Great. It's a great, great school. And it's very limited, too. It's only 30 applicants. And it's about a $1,300 school. Okay. Well, that would probably be money well spent. For a parks manager, it's, yeah. Okay. And actually, staying on that page there, I know that this budget implications is specific to the outlook, but the outlook contains everything else that we're doing. And with regard to those four points that you're saying there,
1:54:44 Can you answer the question, is this what it would take to increase your grades? Yes. Absolutely. Thank you. That's the answer I wanted to hear. Because we would be, you know, struggling to get to a B, I think, right, if we don't get the, you know, staff equipment funding, right? It's, you know, it just rolls along. I mean, I just, all we can really do is maintain. We can't really enhance and fix, right?
1:55:10 That's our problem that we have right now. So, you know, like this longer term proposal would really kind of give us those, you know, fundings necessary. And hopefully with some enhanced staffing, we can actually get some of this stuff done. I'm a big advocate of, you know, training your employees, training staff like this. So $1,300 investment in, you know, not having to reinvent a wheel, essentially, I think is well worth it. And I do like the opportunity of, if you guys are going to be giving yourself a self-grade,
1:55:40 Also providing a plan to improve that, and I think you outlined that well on that page. Thank you. I will say that just for the benefit of people who don't know, an aerator is kind of key in this environment. It basically punches little teeny tiny holes into the ground, and it helps with like absorbing rainwater and fertilizer and stuff like that. And since we're so dry, if we don't aerate our lawns like this, you know, the grass can die.
1:56:08 Earth becomes more compacted and hard, almost as hard as concrete. So just in terms of safety and quality of these lawns, I don't know how you've been going without an aerator in this environment. They've been very resourceful, but... And I think it compresses the problem, too. Yeah, from... So now, for instance, yeah, the cleats. So now, for instance, you know, we're going to get to Shady till May.
1:56:34 Right. And it's June and everybody's going to be trampling all over that. We're going to try and close some areas off to re, you know, regrow the grass and rejuvenate and everything and fertilize and then soccer starts in September and we're done. I mean, it just, I mean, anything we can do to kind of enhance the integrity of that turf is, it's got to be, you know, a primary concern for us.
1:56:53 I think along those lines, too, when we were at CPRS, I think Warren and Stu kind of, I'm not sure if they impressed or horrified some of the, you know, professionals who were there with some of our limitations and some of the fixes that we have to resort to to maintain our facilities. So, yeah. Laura, are you still good? Do you have anything you had? No, I'm good. Okay. I just have a couple things. So, one thing I just wanted to jump in, just sorry to mention on the birth rate.
1:57:21 I've been really interested because I've been on the school, the community facilities recommendation for MUSD. And so both their numbers and the county's numbers do show that population in Mammoth is expected to remain steady with occasional bubble years. And so I think that fact that we really have pretty much a steady and sometimes declining youth population really speaks to the quality of the promotion that we do with our summer camps. I remember a couple years ago, you know, we would have people like...
1:57:49 prorating for a day or two, and now it's like we have wait lists on, you know, by noon on registration day. So I just think that, you know, the quality of the promotion, doing the recreation open house, social media, I think all that communication has really played a big role in growing those programs to where they are today. So just to check for clarification, what I hear you saying is our youth population is flat, but we are able to reach a higher percentage of that population with our programming right now. That is correct. Awesome.
1:58:17 So the other thing I wanted to ask is because I heard a couple of the council comments on this presentation and I know that it was very well received. But I wanted to ask because I know that they're a little bit hesitant on funding new positions. And so can you tell us how much of Warren's time we lost to basically him performing snow removal this past winter as opposed to being the parks manager? So it was probably two months. Two months.
1:58:45 So that's someone I'm interested all the time. Yeah, exactly. Two months FTE, full time, two months, like 40 hours a week, two months. Yep. Yeah. He was driving for essentially two months. Probably longer because he took time and they just, but so we essentially were just down to two staff just running the sidewalks and we just kind of lucked out because we replaced that, you know, trackless a couple of years ago. And fortunately, no, you know, Juan and Derek didn't get sick or injured, right? Because then we would have been down to one, right?
1:59:14 So we're, you know, we're just kind of hanging on. It was a very stressful, challenging year. We did it, but I think the lessons learned is kind of how do we just do this in a better way. Yeah, and the reason that I wanted to bring that up is just because I'm very much in support of the hybrid position proposed. I just, I think it's really critical that we have, you know, someone who can, you know, do snow removal for public works and then, you know, when the weather is better can be working in our parks. I just, I'm...
1:59:41 I think that's really critical, and I'd like to see the commission advocate for that with council. And so that brings me to my next question. So what are, so Stu, will you just keep us surprised at kind of the dates of upcoming council budget workshops and as this is coming forward so we can make those comments?
1:59:58 Okay, cool, because it is part of our responsibility in the Municipal Code to kind of review and make recommendations on department priorities to the director, and it's been a little difficult the past couple years just in the timing of the budget, so I'm really grateful to have this brought forward, so thank you. Thank you. And then one final question, so can you also tell us about the status of the communications audit since we do have the PIO position in our department? Yes, so that's with Mementa.
2:00:23 We received an agreement from a mentor and then after we kind of reviewed that we went back and actually used our own agreement. So we're in the final kind of process of executing that agreement. So it's probably about a week away from getting done. So that's another program. And then we have our kickoff meeting tomorrow for the website redesign. So that process starts. So that starts and it's about a six-month process, as you know. So we'll have two of those running parallel, which is really the council's goal.
2:00:52 You know, so one doesn't get ahead of too much, you know, of each other. So when those recommendations come forward from the, you know, communications audit, they can be kind of dovetiled in and integrated into kind of the, you know, the website platform and so forth. Thanks for keeping us surprised with that because you've also spent a lot of time this winter being the PIO. That's right. Which is a little bit of the grade there too, right? So there's a way for actually us to increase that grade if we want to focus on other ways that we can kind of perform public outreach. But again, it's just...
2:01:22 It is what it is, and we're willing to discuss it, but that's good. I think that was a good starting point for Council to get kind of an idea or a baseline of kind of where our departments are, and each department had the opportunity to do that. There weren't actually many A's out there, right? There were a lot of, you know, a few C's, B's, but the majority were kind of right there on the B's and B+. We've got some work to do. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Anything further on this? Okay. Awesome. Thank you very much, Stu.
2:01:49 All right, we will move on to our next presentation, which is the 2016-17 ice rink season presentation. Oh, I'm sorry, I forgot to ask for public comment. Jeff, did you have any comments on the budget presentation? Do you have any comments on the budget presentation? All right, you might want to comment on the next one. It's just a presentation on the past season.
2:02:21 Yeah, so we're just taking a quick overview of the season here, the operations, the highlights, visitation, revenue, expenditure, that kind of thing. I think we all know our vision and our mission statements pretty well. You should all be able to recite them without looking at them. But moving on to the season highlights for the rink. Obviously, we had some rather unprecedented weather conditions this year.
2:02:47 They were the complete opposite of the 2015-16 season where sun and melting of the ice was a problem. This year we had an issue with snow, obviously. January, a record of 246 inches. I think everyone's pretty well aware of that. The other thing I think, though, which everyone tends to forget, December we had a lot of problem with rain as well. We had a week there of...
2:03:12 Pretty heavy rain, which caused us to have to repaint the rink and reflood. So we almost essentially had to start again in mid-December. So that was, I don't know whether we'd call it a highlight, but it was certainly something that affected the operations at the rink this year. The live, real-time Google Calendar, I think, was something that helped us a lot, particularly with such an unpredictable season. In the past, we always had a...
2:03:38 A schedule that was published in the brochures and on the website, but the schedule obviously changes daily according to the weather here. So just having that Google Calendar and being able to update, have the staff update in real time, whether the rink was going to be open, closed, when perhaps it would open, whether we had a special event on, I think that made a huge difference to the public and the information that was getting out there as to when the rink was open or closed.
2:04:04 And promoting that as well on the website, you know, please go directly to the Mammoth Ice Rink website in our brochure as well. So that was really helpful.
2:04:14 We had very hardworking, friendly and professional staff this year. A new record at the rink, we had no patron or staff injuries requiring medical attention, so that was quite exciting. I'm told in the past there were sort of people triaged there waiting for the ambulances to arrive and cut them to the hospital, so we're quite excited that we had no injuries this year.
2:04:35 The staff were amazing during the holidays, particularly during the Calda Classic when we were operating from 6 in the morning until 10pm at night. We had no sick calls, no shows. It was great. It was very valuable, I think, having Mike, who's mentioned before, coming over from Yosemite and another one of our...
2:04:56 Coming from the sort of now defunct Yosemite ice rink, but that sort of brought a lot of new knowledge for us and a valuable sharing of knowledge. So that was great. The quarter classic tournament this year was expanded again. There were 16 teams. It ran for a week. It was incredibly successful. We managed to get off every game. So we were really happy about that. There were a couple of days where we had to sort of close in the middle of the day due to sun, surprisingly, not snow at that period. But we were able to run games at night.
2:05:26 And we made it work. So they were certainly really happy with the outcome. We were happy with the outcome. Enhanced concession sales. I think, again, during the quarter classic this year, we really reached out to try to provide sort of breakfast amenities as we were there from 6 a.m. So every day we're going and picking out bagels and croissants and pastries and things like that. So that helped a lot. The staff became really involved with trying to expand concessions and come up with better ideas.
2:05:56 Noodles in a Cup and Pizza Hot Pockets and stuff at night time which tended to go quite well and are quite easy things to make in our limited concession area at the ice rink facility. So that was great. National Skating Month in January.
2:06:10 Went well again. We had our free learn to skate sessions every Friday evening. I think one of the biggest highlights from this season was the curling exhibition that we held at the end of January. Granite Curling Club came down, provided the stones, the hacks, the brooms, and they instructed a group of about 30 people turned up to learn how to curl and then participated in some curling games. There seems to be a lot of support in town. Hopefully in May we're going...
2:06:37 Sorry, excuse me, going to MLR to request funding for some curling equipment for next year. So I think that's something that everyone was really excited about and we certainly have a lot of community support and people, you know, continually asking us what they can do to support curling growing in the community. So I think that's great. All right, our brochure from 2016-17, pretty standard. Like I said, in the past...
2:07:03 On the left-hand side was where we used to publish a schedule. I think not having a set schedule in the brochure this year resulted in not having as many conflicts with people turning up to the rink and demanding it was open because the schedule stated we would have public skate at that time and not really appreciating the weather realities that we have to deal with in this town. So I think sort of removing that set schedule off the brochure was great. Advertising, you know, we ran stuff in...
2:07:29 We sort of limited our radio a little bit this year. Surveys from summer suggested that not a lot was coming from radio, so we looked more at sort of...
2:07:39 Our poster advertising and the poster down at the airport, the sheet, Mammoth Times. We're actually just investigating now as to whether or not we can perhaps set up some display cases in the bus shelters, seeing as the town owns the bus shelters and people spend a lot of time waiting there. So I'm currently looking and just seeing if we can get display cases, at least in the park and ride in the village and the major ones, and put up some of our recreation stuff in there, whether that be summer Whitmore pool stuff or winter ice rink stuff, depending on the season, obviously.
2:08:08 The new thing we did in advertising this year is we included a coupon in the Mammoth Coupon Book. So basically outside of holiday periods if you brought this coupon to the rink you could get free skate rentals.
2:08:22 I think it did quite well. Unfortunately, in terms of tracking it, some of the staff were not necessarily hitting the coupon button when we were receiving these coupons. They were just sort of going straight to the skate only. So it's difficult to kind of track. But we know for sure at least 70 people use the coupons. So I think it's something that we should continue to do and move forward with. And I think it's just sort of general. It's another way of advertising. So that's great.
2:08:50 The enhancements that happened at the facility this year, obviously we didn't really do a lot. We're kind of in limbo at the moment as to where we're going and what we're doing. We did install a new outdoor brochure display case on the exterior so that people could or were provided with information about the rink when the rink was closed. Certainly a lot of them went. We had to restock that brochure display case on a regular basis, so that's good. Probably our, well, certainly our biggest
2:09:17 Investment this year was extensive chiller maintenance, which we included the chiller malfunction alert system so that if there was a problem with the chiller, Warren or myself or the rink site coordinator would be alerted and we could go and work out what was going on.
2:09:36 The investment, I think, was great because we did not have any malfunctions with the chiller this year, so that's exciting. And, you know, we also, as you're all aware, received a lot of information about how the chiller is something we can definitely move to the new facility now that we've invested this money and this maintenance into it, so I think that's a positive thing. We also purchased...
2:09:55 A fleet of new bobby seals, which are the plastic ice skating aids, which certainly have paid for themselves. We have a new rental program with them now. That was sort of a no-brainer and they're doing really well, along with our new hot chocolate machine, which also pays for itself because hot chocolate is our biggest commodity at the ice rink.
2:10:15 Operating days this year, surprisingly we were open for a couple more days than last season. 70 days this year, 64 in 2015-16. I think something that we just want to draw your attention to though is that of those 70 operating days, 23 of them either opened late or closed early. Some of them, when I say open late, you know, they opened at 6.30 at night to get...
2:10:41 Mammoth Hockey or Adult Pickup Games on and that was it. That was all it was open for for that day. So we didn't really track that in the past. But yeah, so, you know, almost a third, well, a third of the days that we were open were very limited open days. So that's something to keep in mind. We had, we were up by 400 people in terms of visitation this year.
2:11:03 January, we were very snow affected and the rink was closed a lot. I guess last year in February it was very warm and the rink was closed a lot during the 15, 16 February. So, you know, we're up a little bit, which I think is good. Obviously, just because of the fact that we're saying we're open more days this year, we're down a little bit in skaters per day. You can have a look there at the visitations over time.
2:11:32 Obviously they correspond with when the mountain is perhaps not receiving a lot of snow. The Mammoth Ice Rink does incredibly well. When the mountain is getting lots of snow, our visitation tends to decline. Obviously having a rink is something that may help that. We reached 89% of our revenue projections this year, which I think is great if we have a look at them a little bit more specifically.
2:12:00 Our ice skating fees were 73% of the budget, obviously being closed for so many days affected that. Our food and beverage was up. We did great there. And our facility rentals this year...
2:12:12 We're 141% of the budget. A lot of that was due to the Calder Classic and their expanded tournament. So I think the fact that we can run tournaments successfully at this venue is very promising for if we move into a new venue, and that's something that we need to certainly focus on. You can see the revenue product mix there. Like I said, food and beverage was up.
2:12:41 From last year, facility rental as well. The rest of those product mixes were pretty much the same. It's our core ice rink products. Surprisingly, you know, adult skate with rental is our most popular product. So, you know, it's almost, you know, well, it's one and a half times our youth skate with rental. So I think that's, you know, something that we...
2:13:08 Need to remember moving forward with promotional stuff as well that we're not just targeting a youth market that obviously adults really enjoy skating at the rink. You can see there is some metrics with the adult skate with coupon and youth skate with coupon but unfortunately we weren't able to gather all of that.
2:13:27 Certainly the student, $2 student with ID, skate for Mammoth Unified School District students is very popular. So that was up by about one and a half times what it was last year. Our midweek special declined a little bit this year. Once again, I think that was due to the fact that we often were open late and we sort of missed that midweek special time.
2:13:50 Facility rental, so obviously the Calder Classic was our big winner there, 66% of our facility rental, so that's great. Youth hockey, we were able to this year provide a little bit more, not necessarily regularity, but we were in closer communication with Bishop hockey, so we were able to provide a lot more catch-up sessions when they missed their regular session due to snow, so you see a little bit of an increase for them this year.
2:14:20 Ice hockey, we were up with our adult drop-in hockey this year. Our youth hockey passes are similar to last year, as is the youth hockey tally. So, you know, that's something interesting to take in when we look moving forward as to, I guess, where Mammoth youth hockey is moving and what they're doing. But certainly we haven't seen a major decrease there. Like I said, adult hockey is up, so that's good moving into the new facility.
2:14:48 Lesson programming. This is kind of difficult. You know, we had a very small lesson program running at the ice rink this year.
2:14:57 Something that makes it difficult, I think, is that our ice skating instructors come from Bishop. You know, they are only available in a very limited amount of time. So we're certainly looking into trying to find some more locally situated instructors that could potentially, I think, also be more helpful with private lessons on demand, particularly during the holidays.
2:15:19 You know, in a similar sort of style to perhaps the ski mountain and stuff, you know, just parents with kids, you know, hey, cool, I can give my kids a private lesson for an hour. So that's something we'd like to move towards is trying to find some more centrally located ice skating instructors so that we could perhaps provide that and grow that program a little bit. Food and beverage, you can see that hot chocolate is our winner. But certainly this year with our expanded options, you know.
2:15:47 The combos and the cookies. Like I said, the staff at the ice rink were very into trying to promote their concessions. They had a sandwich board. They would draw artwork on it every morning. They would push and promote their combo deals. So I think this is reflected in the food and beverage sales this year. Retail sales. The Bobby Seale rental went up astronomically. So I think that was a great investment that we purchased those Bobby Seales.
2:16:15 Typically before that, skate sharpening had been the overwhelming retail revenue, but this year our Bobby Seals is up, so that's great. Our expenditures at the ice rink are currently 86% of our 2016-17 budget. You can see here the expense categories. Where we're really going over, obviously, is the contractual services, so that was...
2:16:42 Up to 293% of our budget, so that was the additional chiller maintenance that we submitted an additional request for and received. These figures are the original budget, so they don't include that revised budget with the extra $32,000 that we received from Council for the chiller maintenance. You can see the major expense categories there.
2:17:07 Our lease and utilities are significant, wage and contractual services are our top three. So moving forward, the Mammoth Rec Zone this year is going to be the hub for our summer camp program. We're not going to operate it as a drop-in facility like we have in the past. It is still going to be available for private rentals. And then obviously it will be the hub for the summer program. In terms of...
2:17:34 Programming the venue. We're looking to maybe do a couple of pop-up events there. We're kind of working on this idea of having a recreation summer fun series and programming a pop-up event at each of our facilities just to kind of advertise and promote our facilities. So perhaps something we're looking at for the rec zone is to do an inaugural cornhole tournament or possibly lawn bowls or something like that and then we would sort of follow that series up with having an event at each of our facilities around town.
2:18:02 So yeah, that's us. Any questions on the ice rink? Nice job. I don't have any questions, but I wanted to share a fact that when I was crunching my number of stats comparing to last year's, it's really apples and oranges. This year was just unprecedented different in the way the weather came down.
2:18:24 And surprisingly, when you call Mountain Operations, they don't have a metric for how many days the lifts are closed. They don't have that. But I went back and just, you know, totally qualitatively counted my days. I counted 19 days in January and February that I called the lifts at Main Lodge, largely affected by weather. So I would say your number had to be in that ballpark.
2:18:48 As well, because those were the white-out days that were just totally shut out down here. So apples and oranges definitely when comparing year over year. But I think it's amazing the numbers that you guys were able to do and the amount that you were able to get open with that weather. So kudos to you and your staff for making all that effort, especially with all the conversations that were going on and the tensions and everything that we all had.
2:19:15 Shoveling, shoveling, shoveling for our entire winter. Good job. Sean? Okay. Who's going to see this presentation? Is this going before Town Council or is it just for us? It's just for us. Thank you for putting this all together. So the big question just is if we had had a roof, how many more days would we have been open?
2:19:42 You know, I guess obviously you have to think about the prevailing wind and things like that and how much is going to come in, but a significant number of days we would have been open. You know, I think we can clear a lot easier. A lot of these storms came in and cleared for a little bit, which if we hadn't had sort of four feet on the rink, we would have been able to get cleared and opened a little earlier.
2:20:05 I mean, I can't definitively say, but, you know, a significantly more number of days we would have been open, yeah. Yeah, no, I know. And, you know, this is part of the communication plan that I kind of talk about a little bit, that in case the press should ever ask. Right. You know, I like the idea of having some kind of answer that we can readily give because, you know, we are, this is a unique facility that you can't have in Bishop. You can't have in other parts of the world, but we can here in Mammoth Lakes and will truly set us apart.
2:20:34 So I like to ask that question about how many more days of the year could we have been open? I mean, in answer to that, we potentially could have been open 100 plus days. The facility was scheduled to be open for 100 plus days. We only made 70. And of those 70, 23 were very minimal in the time that they were open. So, you know, having a roof.
2:20:56 Huge difference. Yeah. And even on those days when it's blowing sideways, I want to kind of understand how well, you know, can we get that cleared? I know it makes a big difference just having the roof. So I'll just leave it at that. The only other comment that I had was with regard to the average skiers per day, essentially, coming down off a year of 14-15. 14-15 was the really cold but no snow year. Is that right? Yep. So like I said, it corresponds great with, you know.
2:21:27 Lower visits to the mountain means higher visitation to the ice rink. Yeah, you know, again, I look through this and I just see more and more reason why. It would be fantastic if we had a roof and higher visits to the mountain corresponded to higher visits at the ice rink and other facilities in town. You know, I think that's something that having a roof, you know, obviously more visitation is going to be great. It would extend the season too.
2:21:51 For sure. And we would have a five-month season as opposed to a three-month season. I mean, we pushed, we extended the season for a week this year just to make sure we could try and, you know, get the last few ice skating lessons in and things. You know, it was open sort of just at nighttime, really, and we really pushed it to get that, to keep it open then. Yep. Okay. Thank you. The interesting number there, too, in 2011-12, you know, which is that bigger number, I don't think we even opened until, like, mid-December.
2:22:20 Right? I mean, we've only been opening, like, at Thanksgiving for the last couple of years. Yeah. Right? Just because we've been pushing on it. But, so again, you look at that bigger number, 11,000, that's in, like, you know, 10 weeks. Yeah. I mean, and that's when it was, you know, zero snow, perfect every day. Yosemite was open. Exactly. That's right. Yosemite and Tanaya. You know, so the potential is there, right? I mean, you can clearly see, you know, you know, weather dependent with a little weather protection, there's demand for that, for this product. Clearly.
2:22:49 Yeah. Cleen? I didn't see any breakout in here for snow removal expenses this year. We are at, I can tell you. Is that part of the contractual services budget? Yeah. I don't have a breakout. In terms of the contractual services budget, we, sorry.
2:23:20 So just jumping in. Okay. 25,000 was what we spent on the chiller for the maintenance and so forth. And then we added the 32,000 for the modified budget. So it was up to 52,000 minus the 25. Plus we've added probably an additional 8,000 cents for snow removal. So run those numbers and it's 30,000 plus. Yep. Yep. Gotcha. Thank you. Thanks. Anything else? Nope. Christy?
2:23:49 Yeah, I just want to, I don't have a question so much. I do want to share an anecdotal experience from my part. I was using your Google Calendar and then also calling your staff and under some of the poorest conditions anybody could experience, they were always very friendly and also quite empathetic.
2:24:09 So just kudos to you for keeping morale up and having great training for them. I also want to just sort of underscore Vice Chair Turner's roof-in-a-rink statement that yes,
2:24:25 I can see how we would have more days, extend our season. It rounds out the resort experience. But I also want to just underscore the what's next slide and remind the public and the press that our current ice skating rink really is functioning as a multi-use facility right now and that what is next is the Mammoth Rec Zone will be a recreation hub for all of our 2017 summer camp programs, which means our ability to
2:24:53 Serve this community and program recreation is dependent on having a facility. So I would just love the community to remember that we're not always just talking about an ice rink. We are talking about a multi-use facility that will operate year-round and will be programmed year-round. Well said. Thank you. Yeah, just a fantastic job. I mean, I'm just going to talk about...
2:25:17 Trial by Fire. I mean, you really thank you for stepping up this winter and just really making this thing work under incredible conditions. One thing that I just wanted to maybe add to your season highlight slide is we also had a record grand opening. The night that we opened the ice rink, it was just, it was phenomenal. You had, you know, all your staff there and, you know, just like ice skates, like just.
2:25:38 Constantly turning over and just running out of skates. And so just, you know, again, just really great job with, you know, not just, you know, operating and maintaining, but also just promoting the facility. So thank you. Okay. Any public comment? You want to say anything? Jeff, you're looking like a real hockey player now. I forgot. I left my teeth at home. Because my dog ate the last one, so I put it in a case down.
2:26:03 And I just, I forget. I don't have it. Whatever, you've been busy. Congratulations to Will and the Grizzlies. Thank you very much. And I do want to say you guys, I wasn't there a lot this year because I was just absolutely crushed busy. But you guys killed it. And we started off rough. But how, like, I got texts like, hey man, you coming to play hockey? And I'm like, yeah, right. No way the rink's open. And they got it open somehow. I showed up the one day when you sent those photos with, like.
2:26:30 The bench is buried, like, do you need any help? You're like, yeah, come on by. And there was, I saw, I don't know who she was, but like, high school girl out there with a blower, you know, you don't, God bless you, you guys killed it this year, and in the past. I know I've been a complainer forever, and, but I do want to let you know that with this little ice rink that we have, there are five kids from our area that are California state champions.
2:26:57 You know, that did learn how to skate on this rink, learned how to skate in the lakes. This is all their first year playing organized, really organized hockey, like in a program. And they won the Bantam-level state championship and peewee-level state championships, which has never been done before in California amateur hockey, where two teams from one program won two titles. And it started here. And you guys are also...
2:27:25 On the map for hockey, whether you like it or not, whether you want to call it a multi-use facility and all this. I wear a Mammoth hockey hoodie at every time we go away, if I have anything that says Mammoth hockey on it, people are like, oh, Mammoth, oh, we want to come there. Who do we get in touch with to have a tournament? We want to come up there and play. They absolutely, I mean, every place we go sucks compared to here. You go to Oakland, what do you do in Oakland? You know, we go to San Jose, you sit in the hotel, the kids play at the pool.
2:27:54 That's where they run around ding-dong ditch or go to Marshalls. You know, I mean, there's really nothing to do where we go. Vacaville, same thing. Roseville, same thing. People want to come here. And when they see Mammoth Hockey, it's like, wow, you guys, you know, not to mention the outdoor rink, of course, because that's, you can't get that down south at all. But, you know, here we have it. I mean, people want to come to Tahoe. And most times, everyone books early. All of our home games up there are early, like October, November, and early December. I think we had one in January.
2:28:23 Because, you know, ski season, room rates are through the roof and whatnot. But people do know Mammoth, and they know that we have the rink, and they want to come here to play because there's other things to do. And the Calder Classic this year, amazing. You guys, I don't know, I mean, usually I'm running around like a maniac trying to get things done, trying to get donuts out, trying to help this guy with this, kind of get the stage up, and I didn't have to do anything. I just showed up and sold sweatshirts, which was nice.
2:28:52 And one suggestion for the snack shack? Hot pretzels. Soft pretzels. We'll kill it. I must have eaten three a day over in San Jose. But I was all over the map with something. Oh, and if you did have a roof, you could be open year-round. But yeah, and also, I mean, think about, like, this whole east side. I know we're the town of Mammoth Lakes, and we should be focusing on our kids and whatnot.
2:29:22 But if we could pull kids from every single little Levining, June Lake, Bishop, because we're the only ice rink, and Bishop has an ice hockey team. And I talked to Heidi Thompson, who's the athletic director at school, and she said it's just a huge pain to start a new program. She's like, you're better off just running through Bishop, and we'll just do like an east side hockey high school team, which you will have in two years whenever the rink's going to open. I'm on a two-year program.
2:29:50 You know, we're going to have, we'll have a high school hockey team with Bishop. We might even have a JV team and a varsity team. And if we have a rink with a roof and guaranteed to be open, people come here instead of going down to LA to play or Anaheim. Actually, I think they're going to LA now. So, you know, more heads in beds and whatnot. And I don't know, you guys are on to something, then don't, don't discount it. It's going to be, it's going to be big because people do want to come here because we're centrally located.
2:30:20 We're basically six hours from San Francisco, San Jose, down south. We're at a central located meeting point, and there's stuff to do here. So you can have games in the morning, half off in the afternoon, play games at night. Everyone's happy. Everyone's spending bucks. I spent $90 on a hoodie that says Champions. I pay $11.99 for that hoodie. I know what it costs. He gave me the price. I almost died. I was like, $109 what?
2:30:48 Two hoodies and a V-neck for $195. Ridiculous. But what do you know? But just, you know, keep up the good work and hopefully I can be around a little more this year. Next year, I'm going to try and get the whole business thing set up where I have employees, but I'm just broke. And all the traveling. And I want to stay here, so let's do spam with hockey here. Because a lot of kids want to play. It's just tough because it's so...
2:31:14 You know, well, it snowed this week. You know, it snowed, you know, whenever. And Christmas time, we're not open. And then it's morning time. But everything will change once we get a roof and everything's more consistent. So, and we got to think of the little kids. Kids, your kids' age, right? Yeah, because my kid's done. So, it's the younger kids. And hockey's huge in Bishop. I know kids all play in June. You know, there's kids from Bridgeport who go to Tahoe to play. So, and it's growing. It's huge.
2:31:43 And people know. Like, oh, Mammoth. I was walking through the other day, like, hey, you're the Mammoth guy. And then they're actually coming out this week. We're going to go skiing. So, I don't know. Just keep up the good work, and thanks for everything you guys do. Thank you, Jeff. Thanks, Jeff. It'd be great if you can come see that at Council on May 17th as well. What's that? Yep. Yep. Thank you very much.
2:32:09 Okay, so just quickly moving on to our 2017 Whitmore Pool Operating Plan. Kat, can you just hit the highlights for us? Sorry. It's as quick as we can. Okay. All right, so the operating plan for Whitmore Pool this year, we'll just really quickly run through the highlights or the changes, I guess. I'm sure you guys are all familiar with it. We're open for lap, swim and swim team.
2:33:16 May, full operation, sorry, begin on Saturday, June 17th, and they'll run through until, the schedule closes Friday, September the 1st. Currently, we have an aquatic site coordinator, Sydney Nadler, who's coming back from last year. She was the assistant site coordinator. We just held interviews for the assistant site coordinator role last week, so we'll be making a decision on that in the next couple of days.
2:33:45 Once we've done that, we pretty much have all of our staffing in place for the pool, so that's great. We're ahead of the game already, which is awesome. Looking down at our rates, we just made a few minor adjustments with the ages to align them with the camps and the rinks. The adult pricing went from 16 plus up to 18 plus. The child pricing went from under 5 to 5 and under, just so it aligns a little bit better with our age groups in the summer camp programs and at our other facilities.
2:34:14 This year we're going to try a couple of new special promotions. The first one is the loyalty card program that we're going to introduce. You all know how a loyalty card works, but basically after five admissions, patrons will receive their six admission free. The card will be redeemable at both Whitmore Pool and the ice rink.
2:34:36 Be not just a seasonal card. It will cover both seasons. So admissions at the rink counts towards those five admissions, admissions at the pool. It could be redeemed for that sixth free admission at either the rink or the pool. It is just for the admission. It doesn't include rentals and things like that. But the idea is to kind of cross-promote our facilities a little bit. The next promotion we're going to implement is the Whitmore 50 Challenge. So this is for our lap swimmers.
2:35:02 The idea is to, you know, it's a self-directed program intended to encourage people to regularly exercise and track their progress in the pool. The participants will enter their swimming distances and it's going to be updated by our pool staff. It'll probably be posted weekly.
2:35:18 The idea is that once they achieve 10 miles, 25 miles and the ultimate 50 miles, they'll be recognised. We're probably looking at something like a water bottle when you reach 10 miles, 25 miles or five swim pass to give away to a family member or a friend and then if you reach that 50 mile goal, you know, a swimming cap and a t-shirt that says you're part of the Whitmore 50 Club. So that's something that we're looking to do this year and hopefully some of our lap swimmers that are in here.
2:35:47 We'll be striving for that 50 Club. The other thing we're going to implement is the Free Swim Sundays, which is kind of off what we did at the rink this year. We had first Friday of the month free skating night, so we're going to do the, sorry, it's the last Sunday of the month free swim Sundays. So that just sort of aligns us a little bit more with that one. Moving down to the special events.
2:36:16 Similar to a lot of the things we held last year, the swim team will do their Sharkathon fundraiser again. We haven't got a date for that yet. They'll do their Splash Bash Meet and Greet event and they'll do a home swim meet on June 29th.
2:36:33 Two of the additional events that we're going to add this year, USA Triathlon is putting on a splash and dash event. It's in conjunction with USA Swimming. It's directed at youth, sort of 16 and under. The idea is that they use the pool to do the swimming component, and then probably we're looking at Whitmore Track to do the running component.
2:36:53 There was talk of using the trails. If we use a bit more track, it kind of makes it a little bit more inclusive and hopefully we can have some of the DSES athletes participate as well. So we kind of like that idea of using the facilities and to promote the facilities. The other thing we're looking at doing kind of ties into that Summer Fun Series.
2:37:13 So holding a one-off pop-up event at the pool. We're looking at possibly doing an inner tube water polo competition. So that's something we kind of need to see in training. We'll get the staff to participate that and see if it's something that's a feasible option. But we certainly want to come up with some kind of Whitmore event for our summer fun series.
2:37:35 Moving on to our swim lessons. We're going to offer the week-long swim camps like we have in previous seasons, but we are going to make a little change. We're going to offer a weekly swim program as well on either Monday afternoons or Saturday mornings. As a parent, I just thought it might be difficult for you.
2:37:57 Some parents to get their children out there every day for that week swim program, whereas just getting out there once a week for six weeks over the summer might be something that allows more kids to participate in swim lessons, so we're going to trial that. We launched that along with our summer camps and registration for that on Monday, and we've already had quite a few sign-ups for the weekly swim lessons, so hopefully that goes well.
2:38:20 Another thing there, just on the swim lessons, I just heard back from the hospital this morning and they've given us permission to put up some of our pamphlets and brochures in the pediatric clinic at Mammoth Lakes Hospital. So I'm just getting a Spanish translation one done as well. We're going to start with putting the swim program up there. As Stu mentioned, it's the second leading cause of injury death for children under 14 in America. I think it's 10 people a day drowned in America.
2:38:49 So, you know, we really want to push that program. So I think to start with in the pediatric clinic, we'll put up the swim programs and one of our brochures. But as we move through the season, as we come up upon soccer camps, things like that, we can kind of change the programming brochures that we have up there. But I think that's a good option. In some of the research I did with Hispanic outreach, that was one of the points that was highlighted was that the Hispanic community is really starting to tie in recreation with the health benefits so that if you can promote through local medical clinics.
2:39:17 And doctors and hospital facilities, that's something that really helps engage the Hispanic community. So we'll try that and hopefully that works as well. Moving along, I think we're pretty, so that's kind of just explaining our swim lessons and the levels. They haven't really changed from last year, so that's all the same. We're still using the Red Cross swim program.
2:39:47 Okay, we're conducting the two camps again this year. So the aquatics camp, which is kind of like an all about water camp, and then the junior lifeguard camp, these two were launched on Monday as well. The aquatics camp's already half full, so that's great to see some interest there.
2:40:05 And then the last thing I just wanted to touch on was some of the facility enhancements. Stuart, he spoke briefly about that in terms of budget implications. We're looking at getting the potable water source done before we open, obviously. So Warren is currently talking with contractors about getting that started on. So I think in the next week or two, we should be starting on that. We've purchased banner flags for the sort of big, tall banner flags for the entrance, which will kind of just be more inviting as you arrive at the Whitmore.
2:40:34 Pool Area. We're looking at doing a little bit of painting there, painting the pool deck with a non-slip surface around the edge there, putting up some privacy screens in the locker rooms, that kind of thing. In terms of our strategic plan, I guess we're going to be focusing at Whitmore on the idea of operational excellence. So for us down at Whitmore, that's kind of touching on scheduling and making sure that we're really...
2:40:57 We're putting out a schedule in a very routine manner, sort of a week ahead of time. A lot of in-service training, so at the two conferences that I've attended this year, we've looked at a lot of in-service training ideas and things, so just keeping the staff motivated, focusing on customer service, obviously, and probably a little bit more clarity with job descriptions, defining them a little bit more, so there's a little bit more accountability down at the pool. Everybody's clear of their role and aware of what it is they should be doing.
2:41:27 So that's Whitmore Pool. Anyone have any questions on that? Questions? Maurel? Yes. I'm curious about the fee structure. What it's based on. Do you have a X percent raise in a time frame or anything like that? Same rates as they were last year? Yeah, they are the same rates as last year.
2:41:58 Yeah, they're all the same rates as last year. We haven't made an increase there with the exception of the season passes. We did have an early bird and regular season pass price last year. We've taken away the early bird and we just have a set regular season price. And typically if we were, if the staff were to bring forward price increases, they'd be based on the CPI and we do that through our process. Yep. And then
2:42:28 I'm wondering about in-service training. I'm really glad you mentioned that. Again, I have a huge background in running lifeguard teams and things like that. So hearing you emphasize what you did is exactly what I wanted to hear. But I didn't hear anything about the swim instructors. And I know that was a big feedback point in the surveys that was extremely concerning to me in particular. Do we have any plan to address that?
2:42:58 Yeah, I think certainly, I think this year as well, there seems to be an interest of a few people that just specifically want to do swim lessons rather than having the sort of swim lesson lifeguard combo that seems to have been run in the past. We have a few employers that have expressed a specific interest in just doing swim lessons and are keen to sort of be trained in being instructors and going through.
2:43:23 Going through the progressions and stuff of the swim team. We also have, we've been looking at advertising and recruiting through ski school as well, so possibly potentially trying to hire people that have already been involved in an instruction process and understand progression and that kind of thing. So yeah, I think, but definitely in terms of the swimming, swim lessons, there'll be a lot of focus on that in terms of the in-service training. Good. Sean?
2:43:53 One question, one comment. One comment, one question. First of all, I love the fact that you guys do goals for yourselves for improving. Again, I just want to say that publicly. Thank you very much for continuing to do that with regard to the special promotions. Question. Why are we not open on Labor Day weekend? Have we been open on Labor Day weekend before? Okay.
2:44:14 I guess I'm just noticing that. So we're closing the pool on Friday. Is there a reason? Can you just answer why we're not open that Saturday, Sunday? I can understand the Monday maybe, but... So we actually close for public operations the weekend before, and then it's open that final week just for lap swims. And the lap swim only functions Monday to Friday. So that's why we close on the Friday, September 1st. All our staff is gone.
2:44:39 Okay. And they all, yeah, they all head back to college or high school, so it makes it difficult. That's a real challenge. That's a resource issue in summertime. I was just about to say, that's the labor challenge of the Eastern Sierra. In summertime, absolutely. Okay. All right, thank you. Great job. Thank you very much. Very excited for May 8th. Okay, that brings us to Commissioner Reports. So, Laurel? I went to the Mammoth, what was it? The first meeting of Mammoth Trails for 2017. And this is,
2:45:13 A group that has kind of come and gone. There's been really good Mammoth Trails momentum for the last approximately 10 years in town, but the Mammoth Trails specific group has gone up and down and it was just really good to see how many different groups and individuals came out to hear what Joel and the team has been doing and see the work that has been going since the shark started eight years ago to get some of that stuff actually happening on the ground.
2:45:42 See folks in the crowd wanting to find out what volunteer needs were and things like that. So it wasn't just we want to come and complain about things. We want to get involved and help make them keep getting better. And so I was really excited to see that there's a lot of potential possibility. And one of the big things they were talking about was an emerging trend, the fat bike option. And when you mentioned earlier the MUPS, I think that if that pilot program gets going and
2:46:11 Hopefully is successful that that might be a great way to extend the network of the trail and bring that emerging trend into our umbrella as well. So it was really, really neat group get together the other night. Awesome. Thanks for going to that. Yeah. Sean? No comments. Okay.
2:46:35 The only thing I wanted to say is just I attended the Recreation Open House. I thought everybody did a fabulous job. So very nice work getting a lot of diverse organizations to come as well as ourselves. And just really great to see some of our staff there available to answer questions. So thank you. Agenda items. Stu, what do we have for May? Sorry. So I just want to thank Kat for doing that because Kat's basically not here in May.
2:47:02 She's travelling. So that's kind of why we pulled up the pool operating plan early. That was actually going to be the following meeting. So what we kind of have right now is our kind of budget and our plan MCP update as well. So they're kind of our two items for May at this time. We would have been bringing forward the rec zone operating plan, but that's, I think, as we know, headed in a little different direction for us. So that's all we have at this time. Anyone have any requests for anything else for me?
2:47:32 I just want to say thank you for the paragraph in the staff report about Lakes Basin. Let's continue to keep us updated. I think that's the perfect place for it. Thank you. Great. Welcome. One thing that might be helpful is, I don't know if we need to hear the whole presentation that MLR will hear, but it might be good to hear about some of the funding options that are being brought forward, specifically for the multi-use facility. Kind of here have an update based on what we hear in MLR tonight, too.
2:47:59 And then the other thing, too, that we could probably also, we might want to have an update by then since MLR is making appointments to our ad hoc, so maybe we can try and get that convened between now and our May meeting, Christy and me and whoever MLR appoints. Yep, okay. All right. Okay, well, if there's nothing further, I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting on May 2nd. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. I'm sure I've got that down. They found you a gavel. No, a strike plate. Yeah, a strike plate.
2:48:34 I love that Christie knows what everything is called. Yeah. May 2nd is our next meeting, right? That is correct.