Parks & Recreation Commission · 2017
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 1 hr 31 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
203 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:12 2017. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Present. Just as a point of order this morning, I will try to adjourn us by 1045. I know many of us would like to attend the memorial service for Debbie Freebolt. We certainly extend our sympathies to the fire chief. All right. So with that, I will move on to public comments. And this is the time at which anyone wishing to speak on anyone not on today's agenda may do so.
1:48 Morning, Mr. Patterson. How are you, sir? Morning, Madam Chair, Commissioners, staff, members of the community. Morning, John. Quick update, MLR board meeting tonight. It's board meeting number 23 for Mr. Baccia. One to go. We're covering a couple things tonight. Rob's going to do the same presentation on budget he's doing for rec commission at this point in time. I think based on our conversations in April.
2:18 My board is feeling, I think we can reach consensus and move this forward, so I'm kind of excited about that. And I'm looking at this as we've got those priority phase projects. Those are approved by the council in December of 15. Be nice to push those over the edge, close that, hit the reset button and start all over again. Kind of gives the new person coming in, you know, a fresh start on things. We're going to go through a feasibility study today. On your top and on the counter in the back, I put that document on your tabletop.
2:46 I thought we'd have a formal presentation today, but time is tight. So the purpose of the aquatic feasibility study, you see the document in front of you. Stu and Betsy did a great job of facilitating that USA Swimming Build-A-Pool Conference. One of the next steps was to do the feasibility study, and I would compare it to the wetland delineation study at Belshay Parcel. Let's do it. Let's compare the sites.
3:11 Snow Creek, Whitmore, let's make a decision, let's find out what we can and can't do. I know Ralph and his investors are excited about putting some capital in the game. So the question is how much, what does programming look like, etc. So if you look at the bottom of that on that agenda sheet, the essential elements, task 1 that needs analysis, you see the cost on this. Task 2, conceptual plan. Task 3, cost analysis.
3:34 Task 4, Economic Impact, Task 5, the Site Analysis, that's 47 to start with. Go to the backside optional. I don't think we need the marketing promotional at this point in time, 15 grand, but the travel expenses. There are three visits. I talked to Miklos out of Dallas. It costs about $3,600, so the total project on this is $50,600. That's going to be a line item in our projected fiscal year 17-18.
4:00 Budget Recommendation to Council on May 17th. We want to move that forward. Just get that rolling. And then the last thing would be our deliverables. I know that the committee's been meeting three or four times over the last six months. Stu is part of that group. Rob is part of that group this past Wednesday morning. Dan sent an updated version again this morning, so we'll bring closure to that. So that's a quick update from MLR. I thank you for the time and the opportunity. I'm available to answer any questions if you have any.
4:28 Thanks, Rich. Any questions for Rich? I just have one quick one. The funding source for this is Measure U. Correct. So that's the proposed funding. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, that will bring us to our consent agenda. Is there anything anyone wishes to poll? If not, I would entertain a motion. I will make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye.
5:03 Any opposed? Motion passes. 4-0. Okay. Item number three in our discussion items is a community multi-use recreation facilities update. Thank you, Chair. I'll just kick it off here for the benefit of the commission and our public. So we have a few items that are moving along, coming towards closure on our environmental impact report.
5:28 Process. We also have an update here from the Finance and Administrative Director on our funding strategies that the rich kind of front loaded that are going to be presented to the MLR Board today. So we want to kind of provide you with an overview and a presentation of what that looks like. So we're looking for some input from the Commission on that item. And then finally, Section C is regarding the current lease that we have with the school district.
5:52 And just really quickly, I think the narrative is pretty descriptive in regards to, we've had initial meetings, they're very open towards extending that lease, so we're kind of working towards a document that we can both present and review and have council and the school board ratify. So that's kind of the process there. What we wanted to do is just kind of bring you up to speed, and I brought Sandra, our community development manager, here to kind of give you a quick wrap on the environmental impact report.
6:20 There's a lot happening. There's a lot of information. And if you have any questions, please ask while staff are here. Thank you. Thank you. As it states in the report, we released the final environmental impact report document last week. That includes the response to comments. So basically, we took every comment that was submitted on the document and responded to that. We had 46 comments. And so it's a pretty.
6:46 Lengthy document with all of those responses. And so the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be considering making a recommendation to town council on certification of that EIR next week at their meeting. That's next Wednesday here in Suite Z. It starts at 1 o'clock, which is a special time. We normally start at 2. So once the commission makes their recommendation, it will go to council on Wednesday, May 17th.
7:14 6 p.m., their normal time for consideration of certification. So the Planning and Economic Development Commission is really looking at the Environmental Impact Report, that piece, not kind of looking at that broader piece of the project itself. So the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be making a recommendation only on the environmental analysis, and then the Town Council will be the body that actually certifies the EIR and then determines that the project would move forward at that time.
7:42 So that document's available on our website, the response to comments, final EIR. We send an email out to all the commissioners, so you should have a link to it. And I'm available for any questions that you might have on the process. Thanks, Sandra. Any questions? I just have some questions about, just for the benefit of the public, what we mean when we say not a significant impact. Because there's some...
8:09 Members of the public, in particular the residents living near that area, have been very concerned about the Riparian Corridor of Mammoth Creek, noise, and the EIR came back with no significant impact on all of those. So for the benefit of the public, can we all just get a good working definition and understanding of what that means and what the criteria are? So a significant impact is an impact that
8:35 Can't be mitigated. So basically, if there are significant impacts that can't be mitigated, the town council would need to adopt a statement of overriding considerations, basically saying that we know these significant impacts occur, they can't be mitigated.
8:51 But for these reasons, this project is worthy of moving forward. It's not uncommon for cities to do that. We've done that in the past here. But that will not need to occur with this project. So there are no impacts of this project that can't be mitigated. And you'll note that the final piece of the final EIR is the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. Basically, all of the mitigation measures that we need in order to move forward with that project listed out and who's going to handle all of those mitigation measures.
9:20 And with a timeline for all of those. So basically, that provides a guideline for staff. Once the project moves forward, when we're going through the grading plans, we check off and make sure all of the grading mitigation measures are completed, and then the building plans and so on. So that's really kind of our guideline. And that walks through each different mitigation measure and shows you exactly what we'll be doing as the project moves forward.
9:43 Does that help? Yeah, absolutely. And then my next question related to that is where do these definitions come from? It's state, the state law. Thank you. Laurel? No questions? Sean? I don't think so. Not at this time. Thank you. Sandra, I just have one quick question. I noticed that a number of the comments really don't pertain to the EIR. So of the 47 comments, how many of those would you say actually address environmental issues?
10:10 I didn't go through and look at all of them. There were a number of them that were really related to the project itself, and that's really something that we responded to the comments that it's really a decision for the town council to make. A lot of the comments that are related to whether or not we should move forward with this project, whether...
10:27 This project is better than having an aquatic facility or something like that. Those are the projects or the comments that the town council really needs to weigh as they make their decision on whether to move forward with the project or not. Thank you. Okay. I will attend the PEDC meeting on May 10th. So if anyone has any comments they'd like to pass along, please do. But I just think it's important to note that it is just their recommendation to council on the certification of the EIR itself and not a recommendation on the project.
11:01 And the staff report will be available on Friday. We'll send that to all of you. We'll send it out to our notify me list for everyone who's interested in this project. So everyone will have that in advance of the meeting. Awesome. Thank you. I do have a question with regard to the lease. When do you expect some kind of decision or when do you expect the negotiations with the school district to be complete? We had an initial meeting with the school district last week.
11:28 So at this time they're kind of working on, we are working on presenting them with an agreement for the respective supervisors, superintendent to review. And then it would be kind of a council and then a board of supervisors action from that point on. The lease expires June 30, 2017, so obviously we'd like to have something in place. The thoughts right now, I don't know if Grady wants to jump in, but the thoughts right now is kind of based on kind of a preliminary construction schedule.
11:56 Getting us all the way through this winter, next summer, and then at a point we would then transition and then start to work through what it means to leave that site and then what it means to transition to the new site.
12:11 Some good discussion here, and I kind of put it in there as well, is they have a state architect coming down to kind of talk about the daycare facility and what that would mean. So staff are going to be engaged in that conversation to understand the scope of their project and then to better understand what on that site they would like to use, leave or, you know, what could be retained, so to speak. So that's all happening in the next couple of months.
12:34 And I don't know how much of this you can answer because I understand it may be still in negotiation, but essentially are we asking then the lease to be extended through the winter of 1819? I'm getting my years right. So we're asking for it to be obviously 1718. This winter? All the way through the summer of 2018. At this time. At this time. Yep. And then essentially are we asking the lease to be extended until some point in the middle of the winter 18?
13:03 I think we can kind of finalise that with the construction schedule. So I'm not too sure where that end point. I think what we'll probably do is put some language in there that's agreed upon by both parties that with a sufficient notice, you know, we would be able to kind of notify the school that they're terminating the lease at a certain point. But we don't want to leave ourselves in a position we won't have a facility to operate or use. So I think there's a little bit of a...
13:24 Negotiation there with that school district. And certainly understanding what their timelines are as well. We want to be respective of kind of their needs of that side as well. So I think there's a little bit to go with that negotiation. And I'm not too sure we have all the information that we need just yet to finalize that agreement. Okay. And again, I know that this update was really about the EIR, but just in response to some of the Section B with regard to the funding strategies.
13:52 Has the budget changed since the last presentation for this event? Design work, has any different design work happened in the last month? No, we have not advanced it at all. We're just really focusing on the funding options. Okay. Okay, so with that, I'll turn it over to Rob to walk us through those options. Okay, thank you.
14:15 So just to start this presentation off, this is essentially a response from the previous presentation done to MLR about a month ago. We went out and just started some conversations to understand a little bit better and refine some of the metrics that we had out there or some of the assumptions we had. And this presentation is basically designed to do that, so it may seem like it's, I know it's the first time I've presented to you folks, but this is really an update for how we proceed from the last.
14:44 meeting. So this slide here talks about some of the key differences in things that we know now versus what we knew a month ago. And I will say that some of this data is still estimates because we haven't started any sort of formal process. It's really more fact-finding information.
15:02 But really, as we refine the process, this is what we've come to understand. So right now, we started with a 4% interest rate. We're sitting now at 3.5. We know it'll be slightly, we believe it to be slightly less than that. We're going to come in always with a conservative number, sort of giving a worst-case scenario. But in this particular case, it did drop half a point, which is going to save about $152,000 over the 10 years of funding, the life of the loan.
15:28 The other thing that happened at the last meeting that presented is that MLR made a decision on funding the $500,000 capital request for trails. That would come out of Measure R fund balance that we have today. So that sort of set that aside. The other thing we went through discussions was talking about the MAC ownership. That was a bit of a challenge since it is not owned by the town.
15:54 Pursuing a financing option, that would probably not work. So if we wanted to do anything with the MAC or contribute that $2.5 million requested for the MAC, that would either need to come out of Measure U's fund balance or for the fundraising activity that we're asking that folks actually come through with. So that leaves us with the Multi-Use Facility as being the primary funding opportunity.
16:21 Which means that the Measure R would be the source of the bond, and that would be the revenue stream would be bonded against just R, not R, and U combined, which we were talking about last time we discussed. This is maybe a phased or a combined approach where both of the funding streams could be used to secure this. But that's going to make Measure R pretty thin. You'll see that as we get through these slides.
16:49 It may mean that Measure U needs to support some of the ongoing expenses that R currently does today. And just for the benefit of the public, too, Rob, can you just confirm that it's because Measure R projects have to be town-owned or managed, whereas Measure U projects don't have that same?
17:06 Yes, that is true, but also regarding what Measure R, Measure U has more flexibility in what it can be used on, so recreation as well as the arts and culture elements, mobility elements as well, versus Measure R, which is a bit more restrictive. Thanks. So this screen just gives an image of what the financing looks like. It would be a $5 million loan.
17:35 $100,000 of that is closing costs and other costs associated with securing the loan, which would leave us $4.9 million of funds available for the multi-use facility. Again, 10-year loan term, and that's based upon the ability to pay. So we talked about a five-year loan that would exceed the revenue availability for Measure R, so it makes it a little impossible to do. But the $600,000, as you'll see,
18:04 It's pretty tight anyway. So payments are around $601,207 a year. For illustration purposes of showing it straight line, it's going to fluctuate a little bit as bond issuances do, but in a net number, that should be very close. Total interest over the 10 years is about a million dollars, slightly over. And again, that's on a 3.5%. I believe it will come in slightly less than that.
18:35 With, and I should have called this option one, but option one is a financing option. And so to perform the financing option, this would allow us to do essentially three projects, two of which are defined. One of them is not defined at the moment. The purpose of this slide is really to illustrate the current estimated cost needs as well as how the funding sources would be allocated.
19:04 So as we talked about before, multi-use facility being the one that we could bond against and actually use the financing for, that $9.5 million, I'm applying the $4.9 to that, leaving a remaining balance of $4.6 million. And from that, recommending that we use Measure R for $2.6 million from fund balance, Measure U for $500,000 from fund balance, and the rest
19:34 Coming from fundraising, which you could fluctuate that, that 1.5 million could actually float down to the MAC facility if fundraising was easier to perform for that facility, but that would simply just mean that Measure U fund balance contribution would have to increase to 2 million, but overall that would fully fund that project. The MAC facility does need to come from Measure U one way or the other, so it's Measure U or private funding.
20:04 But that's a $2.5 million ask. And then the third project is really, I call it a community project, to be decided. It's to illustrate really a complete package of three products here. And it's a million dollars, both of those coming from fund balance contribution. And this slide is designed to kind of illustrate where we are with fund balance in Measure R.
20:36 How that would progress through this next coming fiscal year, creating a new projected fund balance at the close of next year of $3.4 million in Measure R alone. And the two elements from the previous page we described, which was $2.6 million from fund balance for the multi-use facility, $650,000 from fund balance for the community project, would deplete that fund balance to the tune of down to $150,888.
21:07 I also wanted to illustrate, because this is important to discuss later, the measure, our ongoing funding. Currently, that's 570,000. That would increase by 75,000 in the year after this, in 2018-19, to support some staffing elements of the multi-use facility. But currently, it's 570,000, and those are the components.
21:33 Some of that may need to be supported by Measure U, and it's within the constraints of what Measure U can perform to free up a little bit of room in Measure R. Any questions so far? Yes. Yeah. Let me start with just a couple of questions here on this slide, and then I'm actually going to back up to just a couple of the other slides if I can.
22:02 $75,000 ongoing is going to need to be added to this budget. You said that was for staffing agreements with regard to the multi-use facility? That's for projected staffing needs associated with the multi-use facility once it's up and running. Stu may be able to add some content to that. Okay. And is that all of the O&M requirements that would need to come out of measure are going forward to support the multi-use facility?
22:30 That's the budget right now that we have based on the project as described. Okay. All right. But you don't, as of right now, you don't anticipate any additional. And this is, yeah, this is our fund that would get contributed to the current Melrose funding for that project. Okay. So currently right now the Melrose funding funds that project 100%. Okay. So what we're saying of the $260,000 we have in Melrose.
22:56 We're adding this $75,000 that would provide the annual operating cost for that facility. Okay. In addition to other revenue sources that would, you know, sales and so forth. And that $75,000 is anticipated to be ongoing? At this time. I don't know if we've actually put a timeline on it. Yeah, that was, I guess, my question. And this has come through MLR's process as well. I don't know, we've presented this to the Commission as well a few times.
23:27 Hopefully everyone has a good understanding of this kind of subsidy. Yep, just kind of coming back up to speed on it. I'm going to back up to the previous slide. The funding raising there, the $1.5 million in the proposed financing slide, is that required that it be raised through outside, I don't know if it's
23:55 Non-profit events or whatever the case may be, but I'm just curious if there's a requirement that that come from outside sources or what that requirement would be. My understanding the requirements are being placed primarily from the Town Council's perspective, saying that they want to not fully fund the projects from both fund balance and investment components, but have some skin in the game from the community to support those.
24:22 So it's not necessarily a requirement either for the bonding element. It's really more to get council approval. There's an element in there, and that's actually lighter than they would like, but it's, you know, there to illustrate a point. Okay, so we as a community are still going to need to raise $1.5 million in the form of bake sales or car washes or something.
24:43 That's correct. Yeah, well. Well, I have a follow-up question to that for the fundraising because I interpreted that differently. Okay. We have Rich transitioning out of MLR and we're looking for a director of MLR that has specific fundraising skills. And so my question is, is how is that search going? Do we have a candidate pool that's qualified to do this level of fundraising?
25:10 MLR will have an update on their agenda this evening. I don't think we're going to raise $1.5 million in bake sales. Maybe the swimmers can. They're pretty good at that. This is why I'm asking some of these questions. And then I do want to just back up. Did you want to say something to that? The answer to your question is yes. Okay, good. Thank you. And I do want to back up one more slide with regard to the $100,000 in closing costs.
25:37 That seems high, but I'm not used to. Is this actually closing costs for the bonding measure or just for the loan? Just for the bonding measure. Okay. For the whole project, and it's an estimate at this moment. Okay. All right. Is that typical? Are there any standards in the industry for closing costs? I mean, I'm just asking the question because... So this would be my first sort of municipal bonding event.
26:00 My buddy Grady tells me that that's not bad. Sorry, I don't have a better answer for you on that. But I do know that these things do take a lot to get together from some of the work that we've done and some exploratory things we've done before. So it does not surprise me. Okay. Thank you for answering that question. I can anticipate some questions coming along those lines. Maybe not. Maybe that's totally typical. But that was just a red flag for me.
26:29 I may have more questions later on, but since you offered to stop at this time, I thought I might catch up with my questions. I will stop at each slide then. Can I ask a quick question about bonding? And this is for the benefit of the public and also for me as a commissioner in her first year. When I typically think about bonding, I think of school bonds, right? Like we want to build a school and then we go to the voters and we ask them to contribute some sort of self-assessment like a property tax hike or something to pay for the capital expense of building a school.
26:59 But from what I understand, this is different. We aren't going to the public and asking for money. We're financing funds that...
27:07 The public has already voted to allocate toward projects like these. Is that correct? Can you explain? That's correct. So the bonding element is essentially the guarantee comes from that public source of funds. So when you described what you do for the school board, the decisions were made from the voting public at that point in time. The voting public has already made a decision on Measure R. That is the source of the funding for it. That allows it to be the bond. So once that's in place, then...
27:34 You know, there's no adjustments that can be made to that revenue source, and it's fully committed to paying that first. So it's a pretty secure investment from people who would want to invest in that for that purpose. Thank you. Any other questions? Okay. I wanted to talk a little bit. Now, this is the same type of slide we had from Measure R, showing Measure U's details, where we are from a balance perspective, a fund balance.
28:08 Rich mentioned earlier about the Aquatic Facility Feasibility Study, the $50,600. I decided to put that in just as a commitment this year since that's coming forward. Again, we always want to present worst-case scenario or just more accurate, most accurate. This will give us an ending balance at the close of next year of $3.763 million, where you can see from the slide when we talked about the options for
28:38 for projects, the MAC at 2.5, Multi-Use Facility at 500, and then Community Project TBD at 350,000. That would leave about 413,000 fund balance in Measure U, and the current ongoing is around 171,220, so those would still be elements.
29:01 I'd kind of like to show those as well because in some cases you may think we're spending sort of all the fund balance associated with these as well as committing future revenues, at least when Measure R's perspective, but the ongoing activities do require some action and some decisions that need to be made. So it's not as though some flexibility with that, but as you'll see at the end, combined UNR
29:26 We'll have a pretty good amount of available funds on an annual basis, a little over $400,000 that can be allocated to future projects or that can grow, as they've done in the past year, into a fund balance that can be executed on a larger project. Any questions on this slide? Not yet. Okay. So this slide here is designed to show after, sort of after the decisions have been made and after the triggers have been pulled, essentially, on the projects that were described earlier,
29:57 The opening fund balance up there at the close of 6-30-2018 is $150,888 for Measure R. That's all the money essentially from that last slide. Projected income of $1.25 million. We're keeping that consistent with what we expect to achieve this year. So in my opinion, a little bit conservative on that. The ongoing costs of $570,000 we described on the previous slide.
30:24 And then there's the Multi-Use Facility Staffing Support, which is a new ongoing commitment of $75,000. We'll take that total up on an annual basis to $645,000. And then you see the annual debt payment there strictly in Measure R for $601,207. And since we had a fund balance of $150,000, I decided to show below that really the net out is about slightly less than $4,000 of available funds for Measure R.
30:52 on an annual basis with all those commitments there. So pretty tight. Measure U, a little bit more options over there. You can see we have a higher fund balance of $413,000 starting, our projected income of the $900,000. And for that one, we have our $171,220 of ongoing costs, but we've added to it now the MAC ongoing support, which is estimated currently at $300,000.
31:22 And that will be implemented, we believe, certainly after the facility is completed, but 18-19 would be as soon as possible. And that would take your annual ongoing from Measure U up to $471,000. But pretty much that's the extent of the impact on that particular fund. There will be no debt payments associated with that. That particular fund...
31:48 Revenues over expenses on an annual basis of $428,000. So there's some availability there. And again, some flexibility with that particular fund to be able to handle anything RCAN as well as things specific to mobility and arts and culture. Combined, RNU will have available funds on an annual basis of $432,579. Any questions on this slide?
32:18 I have one question, and again, this is just sort of a new commissioner, but Measure R and Measure U funds are secured, correct? Yes. So does that preclude our ability to shift funds from U to R as needed? How does that work? So two separate...
32:36 Funds that each have restrictions based upon, you know, what the voters decided upon for Measure R and Measure U to begin with. I don't have the exact details of that other than on a basic standpoint is I can't take Measure R funding over and cover everything that Measure U can fund. So moving dollars between those isn't really what we do because it's really, you can't commingle those.
33:00 But what we can do is Measure U can support some of the elements that R can. So it's really, it would be, we would take on some of the commitments that are currently assigned to Measure R, Measure U can handle those as well. Okay, thank you. Questions? Actually, I will follow up with a question. So after the 10-year, is that Measure R is going to have just under $4,000 for annual funds available for 10 years? Per year for 10 years, yes.
33:37 Okay. And then after that, we've paid off the bond, goes back up to whatever it is. Well, the $600,000 would drop off as a commitment. And, you know, I'm assuming over that period of time, the ongoings will sort of make some migration and some changes. The revenue streams could certainly change as well. So that's sort of as we sit today, this is what it would look like. Okay. So this is sort of the end of the funding element of the presentation.
34:10 The other question was for an option two was a one and done. And essentially what I'm trying to illustrate here, I'm not spending a lot of time on this because it's not my recommended approach for various reasons. When you extend out these projects, number one, it becomes very difficult to actually execute them because as time passes, more needs arise as well as things change. But also construction costs over time and things can change.
34:39 Essentially measure RNU without the funding aspect would have about $7.1 million available at the close of next year to fund a project. What I have here is a multi-use facility phase one, which is $6.5 million. And that's sort of the low bar, we think, for that facility, which would eat up most of that funding or, you know, which would eliminate any ability to fund MAC or the third project.
35:08 But that's sort of just to illustrate it is possible. And then you would continue to build, you know, the fairly high rate fund balance over the years to be able to execute either phase two of the MAC or, I'm sorry, of the multi-use facility or to invest in the MAC. But that would be delaying the projects. Okay. And you're saying this is not your preferred approach? That's correct. I would also like to make a request under option two, we call it,
35:43 Pay as we go. And I just want to make a small comment. I just got back from Jamaica last month. And Jamaica as a country doesn't have the ability to finance home.
35:54 Building, right? And so all of the Jamaicans literally pay as they go. And what that means is they build a little frame and a little shack and there's rebar sticking up out of everything. And then when they get a little bit more money, they put in a porch and a little bit more money they put on a second story or whatever. It's very ad hoc. And I just want to be really clear that if we go with a phased approach that this is a...
36:19 This is planned out, that phase one is planned and it's going to be paid for in one chunk. And that the distinction is, is we have the money in the coffers, that it's not this kind of a random, well, what are we going to do now? And I think that there's also some...
36:35 Emotional attachment, like, well, pay as you go is very responsible, and that's fine, and I don't want to overly leverage these funds so that we are hobbled for 10 years, but I also know that being able to leverage funds allows you to leverage better projects, more impactful projects, and so I just want to be true to what the option is under the
37:03 One and done or pay as you go and that is taking that phased approach. Is that something we can change in the documents? You're describing the one and done element? One and done. Certainly. Yeah. It's a phased approach. Okay. I mean, you tell me where I'm wrong. No, no. Yeah. Fine. Again, I haven't, yes, you're exactly right. Okay. And I can change that. Thank you. Well, the distinction is also it's one project.
37:33 And it's one, okay. That's what I wanted to be clear about. Yeah, one project. I can do phase one of one. Yeah, phase one of one. A bit of my humor, maybe it's not so funny, but essentially it is to provide clarity. Yeah, for the public's benefit, to provide some clarity. Yeah, so I'll change that for tonight, no problem.
37:56 So I just want to mention that I really wanted Rob to make this presentation to us even though he'll also make it to MLR this evening. MLR is the recommending body to council for measures R&U but I thought it was very important since the Recreation Commission has brought the project forward and are really champions of the project that we really understand the fiscal ramifications of funding it. So are there any more questions for Rob? No, I think I'm reading this correctly that essentially this would tie up R for the next 10 years. That's great.
38:27 Okay, so even though MLR is the recommending body, we as the Recreation Commission can certainly have an opinion. So what I'd like to do is get a public comment and then we can just discuss this a little bit. Thank you, Madam Chair. Rob, great job. Thank you, sir. Iterate my previous point. In my tenure with MLR, my first task is to evaluate all of the planning documents this town has had on the table since 1988. We begin to see this concept called a...
39:02 Ice rink some 20 plus years ago. If we look at the financing option, which I support, it allows us to pull the trigger on these things. You've had the multi-use facility concept, you know, in the mix for some time. You've had the Arts and Culture Center, the Performing Arts Theater in the mix for some time. We've taken action to enhance and expand the trail system with one-time capital and $300,000 of ongoing funding. MLT is picking up some of the capital for the Sam's Wood site for us.
39:31 Outdoor Performing Arts Center. We can then close these projects. I realize that there's limited funds at this point in time, but we've got to get to the point where the future's knocking on the door. Let's open it. Let's walk through that door. Let's get some of these projects done. And that's the reason for the feasibility study. With the Aquatic Center, it's the next phase project coming up the street. Let's line these things up and move these things forward. We could spin on this and say, you know, let's think about it. Let's reflect upon it a little bit more. And God knows how much longer we'll be.
40:00 We'll wait now. Who knows how much longer the expense is going to need to build these things? Probably 3 to 5 percent a year for the next few years. And we're still, you know, a year away of breaking ground on any of these. But I want us to support, make a decision to move this forward so that we're in concert with whatever recommendation MLR makes tonight, which I'm hoping is the financing option, the preferred. I'd like to see Council on the 17th, as we make that presentation, take action on this. And let's just bring some closure and move some of these things forward. Thank you.
40:29 So don't go away again. Any questions for Rich? Yeah, so I heard you say that you are supportive, that MLR is supportive of option one. I just want to be clear. Well, I felt in April when we had this presentation that we're ready to reach consensus on a financing option of some sort.
40:49 Consensus wasn't unanimous. We didn't take a vote, but there was a feeling it was ready to move forward. My one-on-one conversation with board members right now, for the most part, they're supportive of the first option at this point. They realize the time has come, let's move this stuff forward. We realize there'll be limited funds, but that was the purpose of earmarking funds over time, so when the time came that a project is ready to go, we've got the money to make this happen. And stretch this a little bit more. How many people own a home? Anybody buy that house on cash?
41:19 Right? Let's be real people. Okay. Thank you. And so MLR will make a recommendation on these options this evening? Correct. Any further public comment? Well, I'd kind of like to just hear from the commissioners, and I'll also be at MLR this evening, so if we have a strong opinion, I'm happy to share that in that item with them. So, Sean? How are you feeling? I'm doing fine, thanks.
42:00 You know, this has been a long process, and we're still not across the finish line. There are a lot of agendas, both overt and hidden sometimes, but I think that, you know, I guess let me just jump to the chase. I'm still supportive of this project and want to see it go forward. We've made it this far, and I feel that it is very important in this community to make a decision and stick with it.
42:29 You know, I will say that I think we found a good location. It was not my first location, but again, with the directive that was given to us by town council that it must be located on town property, I think that we made the right recommendations at each stage with the information that's been presented to us that we have been making the right recommendations to go forward. Now, throughout the time, you know, the budget has increased. Scope has not necessarily increased, but...
42:57 And then other options have come to the table a little bit late in the game. But I'm at this point where from everything that I am understanding that I am still very supportive of this project going forward. Thanks. Laura? I'm in agreement. You know, I definitely have had reservations from the beginning of tying up all of Measure R funds.
43:21 And you funds in something like this, but I think that the financing option allows us to leverage the funds a little more effectively into these big capital projects. It does close the door a little bit for the, you know, seasonal allocations that they have, but it seems, correct me if I'm wrong, Rich, but it seems like there haven't been any major things coming out except for these things that are on the table already. They've been small, small things, so I don't.
43:51 Forsee that being a big hindrance. So I'm feeling a lot better about my reservations there. And I agree that the site isn't ideal, but it's a great one for what we have. And I think that the...
44:07 As Christy has pointed out, being the best alpine recreation destination in the country, we need to have the right kind of facilities, and I don't think any of us would be satisfied with the phased approach, especially since we feel pretty strongly that the phased approach would be phase one, and that's it. So I am still very much in support of the way this is all coming together and would support this financing option as presented here. Christy?
44:36 I too am in support of option one. In terms of the location, I would propose that we as a community think about this. Locating the MAC over at the college and having that MUP path that connects the Mammoth Creek Park West to the MAC can animate that corridor.
44:59 to the enjoyment of everybody. The Hayden Cabin's there, so it can be a little cultural center. And also by having facilities on this side of town, it moves people and animates people across town. So right now we have the village. Soon we're going to have the MAC.
45:17 And then we're also going to have the multi-use facility. So I think that we're going to find as a community that our community is going to start to gel in really meaningful ways by the placements of these facilities. In terms of, you know, one and done, the MAC is going. I mean, they have the land, they're fundraising, and if we go with a one and done option, it really slows down that progress.
45:45 Progress, and I certainly don't want to suggest that we do that. However, this community is in dire need of not just a multi-use facility, it's not just a skate rink, it's a multi-use facility. We're at the point where we really need that as a community center as well. That when we talk about multi-use, we're talking about the ice rink, we're talking about summer activities, but we're also talking about a community center. And again, if you think about the location, we're starting to animate people across town.
46:14 So yes, I also support option one, but I also think that if we start thinking of what our town's going to look like if we, to Rich's point, pull the trigger on these projects, I think by and large we're going to be quite satisfied. Thank you. I don't really have much to add. I agree with everything that's been said. I certainly understand, you know.
46:40 Why people would be more attractive to the pay-as-you-go option when we're looking at spending public funds. That being said, my daughter just turned 10, and it goes really fast. 10 years in the grand scheme of things is not a huge amount of time. It feels like it to us. I don't know how many of us will still be sitting here 10 years on, but, you know, I think...
47:03 You know, you talk to people who've been in town over the past 10 years and, you know, and look at the projects that have come forward and, you know, what potential projects maybe haven't been completed because there is so often hesitation. But wow, I think about, you know, within a couple of years we could have, you know, a couple of really world-class projects. We have a huge need not only for the MAC but also for, you know, as Christy was alluding to, kind of this recreation destination. You know, we're not going to really be able to...
47:30 up our programming without this facility and without all the things that the community told us that they wanted and are in the playbooks. So for that reason, I think we have pretty good consensus that we all really support moving forward with the first option. So thanks. If there's nothing further on that one, I will move us to item number four, the fiscal year 2017-18 Parks and Recreation Department budget update. Thank you, Madam Chair. That was a very good discussion. Thank you.
48:03 Just really quickly, I wanted to bring this back to you. This staff report is in two sections. The first section is really just a snapshot, again, of the Parks and Recreation budget as it moves forward in the process to have this approved by Council in June. And the second half of the discussion is on kind of...
48:28 The kind of deferred maintenance issues, the couple of slides that I put in the last presentation talking about the budget and the issues that we have with our ageing facilities. And Rob's here again. He's going to kind of briefly give you an update on kind of the fiscal year wrap for the third quarter that goes to council on Wednesday night. And there's an item in there that we want to kind of address and talk about. But before I do that, I'm just going to quickly just walk through. And if there's any questions, I'm happy to answer them. But I kind of broke down the budget.
48:58 that we oversee and the Commission advises the Parks and Recreation Department on. These are the funding sources that we have and the respective programs that we provide with those funds. So we did talk a lot about level of service in our last introduction in our slide. I'm really not going to get into this right now, but needless to say, you know, looking at the bottom line, the budget last year was just over 1.48. This year we're at 1.58.
49:25 There's an increase there of about $100,000 for the Parks and Recreation budget across all these items. And you can kind of see the percentage change in those programming and the level of service. Hopefully we're able to increase. Just really quickly, Whitmore Recreation Area, the big change there is that we haven't been providing sufficient funding and resources for that facility. It's really increasing its use. If you're down there, it's quite significant. So we're allocating, and we're not...
49:54 Really saying there's additional money. We're actually moving money from other sources to cover that as well, but there is some additional funding that we did request from Town Council. So that's really that 12% change. The parks maintenance change, again, which is the biggest number there. We do have that position that we talked about last time at that introduction about a hybrid position. So this would be a joint position that would be shared with Public Works.
50:17 The public works position would be housed or the home would be with Grady and his team. Their primary responsibility is a winter snow removal operator. But again, it would be that same person that we really want to make sure we're adamant on that would be supporting parks maintenance efforts. So it's really that one position, that one person that's committed to public works to remove snow, which is a really critical element we just kind of experience. And then we pick up 990 hours.
50:45 of an additional employee that we haven't had before, which is a year-round employee, which is significant for us. So that's the big change in the park's maintenance budget there. Trails End Park, and you can see we actually have two funding sources, and Rob did touch on those just briefly, but we do receive funding from Measure R for Trails End Park, and we also receive Mella Roos funding.
51:09 for Trails End Park. So they're the two funding sources that we use and they're represented there by the fund number. So 858, just for your little edification, is the Melorus account. 216 is the Measure R account and the 100 accounts are all our general fund accounts. So you can see the Parks and Recreation budget has various revenue sources that contribute to providing the level of service for our community. And you can see I just provided a little pie chart there of kind of where those funds go.
51:38 And this is kind of a dynamic process. I mean, it does change year after year. We do revisit this with Warren. And again, part of our plan this year is to get Warren to the Parks Maintenance School.
51:50 which is kind of an increase in some of these funds, so we can actually better identify our assets, the frequency, the maintenance and so forth, and then match those with the fiscal funds that we have to maintain them. So again, it's a very dynamic process, but this is kind of what we're presenting to Council as it stands. Anybody have any brief questions on this part before I jump into the second part?
52:16 I have a couple of quick ones. By Whitmore Recreation Area, you mean both the track area and the pool area? That's correct. So this is some of the cracked concrete and blah, blah, blah. And then the multi-use facility, is this as it stands now? Yep. And can you just explain that being the only reduction there, why you think you need less there this year? Is that because we're not going to have it open to the public in the summer? Thank you. Thank you.
52:45 Let me just touch base on Whitmore because that's a really interesting point and I forgot to clarify that with the Commission. So that's two elements. That's the ball fields on one side of Benton Crossing Road and the Whitmore Pool. The Whitmore Pool is about a $90,000 to $100,000 operation and the ball fields about $125,000. So that's kind of a split. We do receive a reimbursement from the county, $0.50 on those dollars. So again, that's a contribution that we receive as a revenue source from the county to provide those services. So I just do want to provide that clarification.
53:15 And again, the multi-use facility, as Commissioner pointed out, Martin pointed out that we are not operating that facility to the public this year. It's really just going to be specific towards our parks and recreation programs. It'll be that hub for our camps. And as you can see, you know, on our first day that we, I think I talked about the last meeting, I mean, we pretty much sold 75% of our camps and programs in the first day. So we have a real capacity issue.
53:43 Right, so I really want to kind of re-emphasize the point that the multi-use facility is not just that one-dimensional ice rink. I mean, it really will enhance and meet.
53:54 The growing needs of the recreation community in regards to our camps, programs and activities. And I think that's a really key point for that facility. Why it went down a little bit, you know, we actually increased the contractual services, you know, by $10,000, which is the snow removal, some chiller maintenance. But other than that, you know, with the labour costs came down, it actually reduced the expense.
54:14 of that facility for the year. And again, there's zero general fund support of that facility. It's completely funded by Melrose. So I think that's a key point. So with the $75,000 we receive from Measure R in the future, that would give us a healthy fund balance to operate that new facility. But that new facility is going to be operating essentially $365,000.
54:37 And I think I have a follow-up question because I was going to ask that going back to the previous presentation. You've set aside $75,000 for ongoing staffing, not necessarily operations and maintenance of the multi-use facility. That's what was presented to us previously. This number is 243, 240. So does that mean that this number would go down to 75 or this 75 is going towards this number?
55:07 And do you expect this number, then, the 240-ish, when we're in the new multi-use facility, to go up or down? So the budget projections that we presented, I believe a couple of months ago, showed an operating, annual operating cost of about $500,000 for that facility. So the funding sources for that is made, contributes from Melrose, contributes from Measure R, and contributes from revenue from that facility. So that's kind of the big picture. That's our best budget.
55:35 Right now until we kind of get further into the design and the timeline for the facility. But that kind of gives you a brief snapshot. And I can talk about that another time as we move forward with the project. Let's talk about that another time. Maybe I do want to make sure that we as the commission understand what that ongoing staffing, operations, and maintenance cost is going to be and where that money is coming from. That's a key point. And we really are. And that's part of our work plan is this moves forward.
56:03 with Grady and his team to once the design, I mean right now it's a 10%, 20% design? Maltese? Yeah. About 30%. About 30% design. So we've got a long way to go. So I think as the design moves along, and as we've talked about with this program, programming really is informing design. And I think we're really working well with Grady and his team and HMC to make sure that's the case. So as this moves along to 60%, 70%,
56:27 We'll have a better idea of really what we're looking at. And if we really understand now that we have a $9.5 million budget for that facility and we're completing that budget as a whole so I can get to operate the community centre, the multi-use facility, the ice rink and all the support facilities required to make it work, it's a pretty exciting project. But again, I just want to be realistic and I do want to point out that yes, programming is important, but finances have to match that level of effort.
56:54 The expectations of the community. It is an exciting project, and if anything, I want to make sure that the public is aware of just all the options. This isn't just an ice skating rink. This is not just a winter amenity here that we're creating. At the same time, I also want to make sure that we get into this new facility and, oh my, we decide that we want...
57:17 some new equipment, new play equipment, because it just would fit perfectly in this multi-use facility that we are at least having some funds set aside for any kind of future programming or ideas that we come up with. And I know that that may not be relevant to this specific discussion here, but that's something how I am approaching this. Yeah, good point. Thank you. You're welcome.
57:38 I think, too, I think it's important for people to kind of understand the limitations of our current facility versus our proposed facility and that this is the budget for the 17-18 year and hopefully we'll be looking at just a spectacular year-round facility when Stu makes this presentation a year from now. It is and I'll say, you know, I was actually in a, I don't want to say heated, but it was animated conversation with somebody from the public yesterday about this and I really don't
58:05 And it is. These are difficult decisions, you know, if we're going to make it. But at the same time, I think it's very important that we as a community just make a decision and go forward with it. And I think we've chosen a good one. And I think that there are a lot of elements here that are not necessarily being discussed in the public that is going to contribute to the community. Any other questions for Stu on this part of the report? John, did you have anything you wanted to add just from a staff standpoint? Okay. Thank you. And that's a key point.
58:39 I'm glad John's sitting here because in a lot of our camps and programs, as I said, they're really sold out, right? So unless we really can find a new home for our programs, we're really at limitations. So it's a really, really key point. So the second half of the conversation I want to just present while Rob's here. Rob's just going to kind of walk you through. This is a pretty large review of the third quarter.
59:06 Rob can kind of give you a brief overview of it and then there's an item in here that we want to touch upon and that kind of speaks to the deferred maintenance issues that we have in our parks and facilities, the ageing facilities, not meeting the needs of our community and certainly our vision. So when we do get to that point, we'd like to kind of briefly discuss that with the Commission and then I have a kind of a brief presentation about that too. Thank you, Rob. Thank you.
59:30 So I just want to start off by saying that Stu's sort of a superstar when it comes to the budgeting process from my perspective. He does a lot of heavy lifting for us as well as a strong advocate obviously for his area, but he knows all the aspects of it and does a great job to support what I need to do as well as what you guys are doing. So thank you, Stu. We budget on an annual basis fairly conservatively because of the sort of volatility of our revenue streams for our town.
59:57 So we budget our revenues in a conservative manner so that we don't get ourselves in trouble. So at the third quarter of every year, we get to discuss, hopefully, overages and revenue. And that's the purpose of the third quarter budget adjustments is to really, by that time, we've gone through March from a TOT's perspective, TOT being 60% of our revenue stream.
1:00:24 We get a sense of where we're going to end up the year. So that was the start of the process, and I'm projecting that we're going to hit, and again, this is, I believe, a conservative number, $16.6 million for TOT this year, which will be an expected budget variance of a little more than $5 million. So that gives us an opportunity to have those one-time funds and to spend those on projects, things that are not necessarily ongoing budgetary elements.
1:00:52 At the same time when we go through that process, we have to look at where some of the elements we've overspent from an expenditure budget perspective. Things related to snow, obviously we had some strong events this year. We are still pursuing some FEMA money from that, but we are not essentially relying on that because that's scarce to begin with. But anything we do get back from FEMA would definitely go into the fund balances for the respective areas.
1:01:19 But when we went through that process, again, we had $5 million to work with. We identified expenses around $733,000 in expenditures over budget for snow-related activities. And this is, again, across all town departments. We also had another $112,250 for operating expenses. And these are just budgetary items throughout the process where we've had
1:01:47 More than we expected from expense perspective. And then we have political commitments. So whenever you have things that are tied directly to performance of TOT, then when it exceeds budget, you certainly have to pay those commitments as well. So that's about $974,000. So of the $5 million, $1.8 of that is already committed to either spent items or committed items. These are just a little over $3 million that we can pursue.
1:02:17 from a project or one-time element. So staff starts this process by really identifying what are the core needs that are out there. We started through the process. We certainly have infrastructure investment needs, so we sort of try to lay out here are some of the elements we have with those. There's about $1.6 million in projects from an infrastructure component.
1:02:43 And this is not necessarily recommended. This is really considered like a menu of options. We have identified from our perspective around $5.7 million that we could spend, almost $6 million for the 5.1. So there are definitely decisions to be made throughout the process. But the group two was town facilities. And number one in that one was deferred maintenance on parks and recreation.
1:03:12 That $300,000 that is recommended for that is sort of a drop in the bucket, but it's certainly a right direction to go. And that would really just to begin the parks infrastructure repair. Stu and team have provided a number of images and things to share through the process, but really it's going to be prioritized by this group as well as Stu's team to really decide if that money is allocated. Conversations I've had, there's very strong support for it.
1:03:42 And so I don't anticipate a challenge with this coming forward from tomorrow night, but essentially we'll need to figure out exactly what the prioritized projects are for that $300,000, but that's the intent is that it's on the list and highly recommended, if you will, from that perspective. But there are several other options, and we do have community projects and other things that we can go through, but I don't think that's the intent of what you guys want to hear or talk about today, perhaps.
1:04:12 I'm available for any questions through this process. Tomorrow night is going to be a lot of finance presentation. We have a reserve policy. We have a third quarter, and then we have a budget update. I'd also like to say that this hybrid position, it's a dynamic staffing position, in my opinion. It's very important for us. It's a test process that we're going through. So if you think about just-in-time sort of inventories, this is sort of a just-in-time staffing needs where we
1:04:42 We're dynamic and we fluctuate throughout the year. It allows us to have the best bang for our buck from an employee standpoint. It's our biggest cost essentially as a town by a long shot. But it's strong sort of a test to that and we're really working hard on it. Not only these two gentlemen but Todd and Warren as well as the whole administrative team. So excited about it. Questions?
1:05:14 Anyone have questions for Rob? I do want to kind of just sideboard this, that he's making this presentation to council tomorrow night, so I don't want to delve too deeply into things that are perhaps not our purview, but there are a lot of things on here that are. We're not being asked for any kind of action on this. This is just an update, is that correct? This is an update. I will be at council to give a commissioner report tomorrow night, so we may perhaps, we've always been very strong advocates for...
1:05:40 addressing our deferred maintenance issues, and certainly we have our own process that's informed and will inform if this is approved what projects happen, so we may want to just make some comments on that. Okay, yeah, no. Laurel, any questions? No, I think this would be a worthy investment for this overage this year to pick off some of this deferred maintenance. I would love to see that happen. Christine? Oh, yeah.
1:06:16 Yeah. Nobody likes junky things. I'll go on record saying that. Well, so I'd like to say, well, first of all, thank you so much, Rob, for your time today. I really appreciate you coming and talking to us. I think your presence in the town has just made a tremendous difference in how we all understand, you know.
1:06:32 What funds are available and what we have to work with. And thanks, too, for calling out Stu's really extraordinary abilities in putting together this material and really understanding it. I don't think I would if he didn't explain it to me. So one thing I do want to say is that $300,000 doesn't get us very far in addressing our, you know, I mean, it's a start and I'm thrilled to see it. I want to make that really clear. But, you know, that's just the beginning, I hope.
1:07:01 One thing, Rob, I did want to ask is, so, and obviously the available funds, great as they are, exceed the proposals here, but there's a million dollars on here for implementing a community project, which could maybe be a walk, bike, ride, or the downtown revitalization. So would you envision that, if council decides they're interested in that, would you envision that as being in addition to the R&U funds that are also identified for an additional project?
1:07:31 Yes, I do. I wanted to put that in there as, you know, giving folks options of where their, you know, vote where their heart is, essentially. I think we as a group go out and test and perhaps are criticized for doing a lot of studies that we don't actually leave the starting line with. And so the intent from our perspective is to, when we have opportunity, put it out there to...
1:07:55 Make sure that we have funded the opportunity to do those things and then decisions are really made. So that's kind of why that's there. It's, again, a menu option approach. Okay, thank you. Any further discussion on this? I think it'll be a very interesting discussion at council tomorrow evening. Stu, anything you'd like to add? I do. Thank you, madam. Yeah, so, I mean, obviously staff is thrilled. I mean, this has been a long time coming. I mean, if Dennis was sitting here, he'd be falling off the chair right now, right? I mean, he...
1:08:28 For 25 years, I mean, Dennis, you know, oversaw and was steward of our parks and facilities and he did an amazing job with very little. Warren stepped in and pretty much everything, you know.
1:08:39 is a real challenge. So our approach with this is one, certainly advocating very strongly for the funds. I think this is a long time coming. I think council are very supportive. You know, we made that presentation a month or so ago and there's a lot of nodding. We've spent considerable time as a commission going through our CIP major maintenance list. I mean, that's something we've been doing for the last, you know, several years. As you know, the list just keeps getting bigger.
1:09:02 So this is a way to really kind of hopefully what we see is identify really those priority projects. We've kind of put together a little kind of a strategic approach to these funds. We're going to bring it back to you in June. We've already started working on it.
1:09:18 Right now. But really quickly, you know, the way we want to attack it is really to kind of use our major maintenance list that's been prioritized by the commission. We know they identified projects. We'll sit down with staff, kind of go through it, understand if anything's changed on needs or, you know, any changes.
1:09:34 And then we're kind of establishing some criteria for how we want to kind of move this forward. And a couple of bullet points, you know, we talked about here is just obviously replacement of broken, non-compliant, any projects or items that pose a health and safety risk or inefficient or ineffective, right? That's probably clear, right? So there's a lot of those items that we have in our parks. We also want to understand that what we replace won't have a significant impact to the current budget, right? So we want to make sure that, you know, it's going to have a little or, you know,
1:10:03 No increase to the finance obligations. We want to make sure we're being good stewards of that budget. We also want to kind of make sure that the projects provide the greatest impact for the most community users. I think that's kind of inherent in what we're doing. I think it's pretty clear we really know where our users are. I mean, there's certainly a Whitmore. That's kind of what we're seeing with our budget. Shady Rest is a big user. So with those high visitation areas come high, you know, maintenance costs and obligations. So I want to make sure that that's clear.
1:10:30 We also want to kind of reach out to a lot of our user groups because I think there's a good opportunity for leveraging. You know, we've sat down with Little League, you know, we've talked to the school, we've talked to, you know, these larger youth sports funding organisations that come forward and I think there's a really good opportunity there for us to kind of leverage some of these funds and, you know, provide more for the community. So I think that's really important. And I think the overriding criteria here is just making sure that these items or projects assist in the more efficient delivery.
1:10:59 of our existing scheduled parks maintenance work efforts. I think that's got to be pretty clear right from the start, right? So whatever we can really kind of identify will help our staff be more efficient and effective with what they do. So there's some of the criterias. I think the plan here is to kind of create some project work teams. So once we identify some of these high visitation areas, we'll bring in these groups, kind of sit down, walk through them, you know, what their kind of needs are, where...
1:11:23 Our identified needs are and come up with kind of a scope of work. We then kind of look at kind of a short term, long term, so what could be done in kind of year one or two. I don't know if these funds really have a sunset, but we're really just setting aside right now. Year one funds are really looking at kind of what projects and items we can kind of do immediately. We have those, we have that list.
1:11:43 I mean, right now we started to put water in the pool. Pump was giving us problems. We're working through that. We hope the heater's going to work, right? That heater's 22 years old. We've got some items right now that can kind of really help, you know, our facilities. On the other half of that, you know, it's going to take us a little bit if we look at some of these items that have a larger kind of work ethic and scope that we need to kind of work through with the public works team.
1:12:07 Right, so we really see that as kind of a year two effort and making sure our projects link with the work plan currently undertaken and committed to by public work. So that's kind of a year one, year two scenario. So I think that's important to understand. And then really kind of look at and consult and bring in some professionals in those areas of expertise. I think that's really important for us to kind of consider that as it moves forward, right? So we think we might know the best way to do this, but let's get some professionals in and kind of provide that additional expertise.
1:12:36 So I think that's really important. And then we'd bring that back to the commission. Again, I see this as kind of an ongoing item on our agenda. We would bring this and just have this ongoing. Here's the update. This is where we're at. And then we're just going to go get it done. So that's kind of the approach that we're kind of taking. We'll present this in a little bit more detail in June. Hopefully we'll get the support and approval from the council.
1:13:00 Wednesday night, and we can kind of get some of these items taken care of. But again, thank the Commission for their support of our infrastructure. It's a great need, but I think we have a great opportunity here to make a big impact and a big splash with our community, show them what we can really do, that we do really want to take care of our facilities and make sure that we provide the expectation that the community really desires. So that's all I have.
1:13:25 Thank you. I would just urge all of you as tremendous recreation advocates for our parks and facilities to certainly be in touch with your council members and just make sure there's an understanding that this is a really important allocation. I will be at council. I probably won't still be there for this item. So if any of you would like to come and speak to it, that would be awesome. But I will certainly mention our support in my commissioner update. I have a quick question, Stu. I noticed that the bathrooms of Shady got crunched.
1:13:55 This winter. Where does something like that fall? Where is our snow damage? Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. A lot of our items are just coming to light. That's a good way to put it. I do know that Warren has a dream bathroom. He's actually picked out a new replacement bathroom. That's what I was thinking as you were talking. How do we turn this into an opportunity? Yeah. You know, the big one out there is really that snack shack. I mean, that's...
1:14:26 You know, what we kind of refer to as our wildlife sanctuary. And I think that's a real concern. We have a strong community need to kind of take care of that. I think the restrooms are another part of that discussion too. And I think this fits in to exactly these kind of project teams for these parks. So absolutely, we're all kind of prioritized on needs. So if things are, as we kind of talked about, either broken, non-compliant, pose a health and safety risk or inefficient, then they're on the list.
1:14:52 And if Shady Rest, as we know, is a high visitation and certainly traffic area that sees a lot of visitation, then it's got to be one of those items that gets addressed. You know, we can get through this $300,000 pretty quick, so I think we have to be really strategic with it because a couple of these projects could take a third or half of that funding straight away. So again, that's why we want to kind of look at kind of a holistic approach and make sure our user groups are part of that discussion. But yeah, I need restrooms.
1:15:19 Well, I mean, just fixing it so it can open this year, it's a challenge right now. Yep, it's going to be a challenge for sure. From what I can see. And a lot of the staff right now, too, honestly, are really focused on Whitmore. Yeah. That's our priority. I mean, we were laid out of the gate down there, and I'm sure we have the majority of our seasonal staff on right now, and they're pretty much all at Whitmore with the pool and the ball fields. I mean, they are, if we were down there for Little League opening day on Saturday, and, I mean, you had all three fields being used, you had the track being used, you had the soccer field being used, and then dog agility is still trying to figure out.
1:15:48 Had to get down there as well, right? And then, you know, we opened Monday at the pool. I mean, so it's a real, real demand, but great need, so. And especially with Shady Rest been available, Whitmore is just totally hopping. It was there at 5.30 yesterday, and there were just people everywhere. Yeah. So, great. Good. But thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Very exciting.
1:16:09 Okay, that brings us to our final discussion item, number five. Support the California Clean Water, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access for All Act of 2018. And thanks again, Rob, for your time. Stu? Perfect. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. So I don't know if you've been following this item, but again, it's...
1:16:31 Pretty exciting in the world of Parks and Recreation. So as you can see here just really quickly, it's been 15 years since Park Bond has come through the state. This one is large. You can see it's not only a Park Bond, but it's also the California Clean Water, Climate, Coastal Protection and Outdoor Access for all Act of 2018. It has a $3 billion...
1:16:55 Tag to it right now. You can see what we've kind of provided is a little kind of framework for those allocations. You can kind of see the author and the advocate for this, Assemblymember Garcia, who actually spoke at our CPRS conference, very passionate about this park bond. He's a real champion for low-income areas, you know, recreation, providing parks, you know, access. So it's really creating quite a lot of momentum.
1:17:24 You know, this Park Bunsa, we're very excited about it. What they're asking for right now is really just letters of support for organizations, you know, around the state to make our assemblymen, congressmen, anybody, senators, aware of kind of what we have. So really what we're asking for, and I actually have provided, just before I jump on the, actually have provided the assembly third reading.
1:17:50 And it gets in a little bit more detail about how these funds are going to be allocated. But again, a lot of the park bonds that we've received in the past helped our multi-use facility. So this is something that will really kind of help our community. There's a lot of information here. You might have had a chance to read it already. It's moving forward. It'll be on the Senate floor in the next several weeks, as we've stated there. And this is hopefully be on the June 2018 election.
1:18:18 So with that, I know the Chair would like to kind of jump in and say a few things as well. But really all we're asking for here is just the support of the Commission to direct the Commission Chair to sign a letter of support for the passage of this bill. Thank you. Thank you. So without going into any great detail, obviously if this were to pass, it would then go to the voters.
1:18:47 Potential approval for a bond measure. So if we were to express support for this, we wouldn't really be committing to anything other than that we really feel passionately about having parks and recreation initiatives on the ballot and just the fact that it has been 15 years since a parks bond has come forward. There was a lot of excitement about this when we were in Sacramento. One thing that I do want to point out is that I believe that we are neither
1:19:14 Classified as a disadvantaged or a severely disadvantaged community. However, the bill that's going, I think, I think that's one of the bills actually has some per capita language in it that would be very helpful to a community like ours. So I kind of like to hear from all of you about whether you're sort of interested in pursuing this advocacy as a commission and sending this letter. The town council does monitor legislation going.
1:19:42 through Sacramento and supporting with letters and things. This did come up at a council meeting and they were generally supportive of putting a question like this to the voters. We can take action either as a commission with a letter that I send along or we can also additionally too take action as individual commissioners. One thing that is in Stu's staff report is that this is very strongly supported by both CPRS and CAPRCBM.
1:20:12 which are the state professional parks and recreation and commissioner organizations. Thoughts? Questions? Yeah, does this have to, does the actual bill law have to pass by two-thirds of the voters in the state of California? This is a decision made by the voters at two-thirds? If it goes on the ballot, yeah. It needs two-thirds of the majority.
1:20:38 And then can we, as a Recreation Commission, if we give our support to Betsy to write it on behalf of the Recreation Commission, is... What's that? It's in the packet, though. No, I know, but yeah, I saw it. But my question is, does Town Council need to approve a recommendation coming from the Recreation Commission? I don't think so. We would... I'm going to just seek clarification from the Town Attorney on that, and that could be...
1:21:04 Some of the direction too, I think that we can ask Town Council to further support as well. Okay. You know, if we want them to, you know, send a letter in support of the bond as well. But, you know, this first action is pretty standard, you know, for most advisory bodies. We would like to probably seek just that advice from the Town Attorney if the Council needs to kind of ratify this letter. I think that's appropriate, but I can certainly do that for you.
1:21:34 Well, my comment is that I am for this. I do enter into any kind of decision-making whenever there's money involved, wanting to scrutinize it a little bit more, but from what I know of this bill and the fact that there hasn't been one in 15 years at the state level that I am supportive of having you sign this letter. Christy? I agree. I'm in support. Laura?
1:22:02 I in general agree as well. I have to confess I skimmed all this bill language. I was not able to wade through it all. Is there any like weird writer or whatever, you know, the border wall or something sneaky in there just to be silly about it? Did you read the full letter of the language and know that it's all about parks? I did read this synopsis, although this is not the actual.
1:22:28 Language of the bill because the Assembly passed its bill and then the Senate has one of slightly different language. As they move forward, they'd have to kind of work out the language between them and then the governor would have to sign it. So I did not see in this synopsis nor have I heard any major concerns. I'm pretty sure there's nothing in there about a border wall. Just to make sure it's all about parks and not, you know, so. Well, parks and also there's some clean water and, you know, climate provisions, so. And we would apply.
1:22:57 for funds, right? It's not like they're just going to descend into Mammoth Lakes and say, no, we're going to do this. No, we're going to do that. No, it'll be very competitive. And I think, you know, this legislation, I really appreciate Assembly Member Garcia bringing it forward because we're not the only community in California that just has these tremendous deferred maintenance issues. I mean, parks and recreation budgets all over the state have been cut and have really been impacted by things happening in the economy. So I think, you know, the recognition of the importance of...
1:23:25 All of our parks and facilities to the state is really critical. Yeah, I think this is an important language, the synopsis that I read, and I think it'd be foolish of us not to support something that we would be able to apply for and fill in some of the gaps that we've been having and leverage that $300,000 that we're going to get into so much more. Absolutely. Be good timing.
1:23:49 I mean, just the little bit that I skimmed last night and seeing again today, there is a lot of potential here for a lot of the things that we've been talking about and struggling over for the past 10 months that I've been on the commission. It was nice when we were in Sacramento. We definitely heard some very passionate advocacy from the legislators who are bringing this forward. So it was just nice to see that support because obviously there's a lot on their plates besides parks and recreation. So to see that recognized was pretty cool.
1:24:19 Yeah, I'm in support of us sending a letter. Does that give us enough consensus? Absolutely. Yeah, page nine, if you do want to kind of just get down to the mitty gritty, it's the second last paragraph there. It talks about kind of the allocation a little bit. And I think what's relevant to us is, you know, $30 million for local park rehab, $20 million for rural parks. There's actually an allocation there of $25 for trails programs as well. So there's some opportunity for MLR to consider some funding.
1:24:49 And then $100 million for state parks. And obviously state parks are very much in need of funding. And you can see the rest of it's really allocated to water quality, groundwater protection, you know, those type of things. But I think that's specifically, you know, what we would be targeting through a competitive process to try and acquire some funding, you know. Right, but I think we could get creative even with that. We need some groundwater protection here. Right. Yeah, I think there'd be definitely some partnership opportunities. All right.
1:25:22 Anything further on this? I have my first board meeting of the CAPR-CBM board on Saturday in Sacramento, and it's one of the items on our agenda, so if there are any updates, I'll bring them back to our next meeting as well. All right, so that brings us on to commissioner reports. Laurel, anything to share? No, nothing to report. Sean? Gates open on Blizzapulizza in 12 weeks and two days. Awesome.
1:25:57 Nothing related to reporting. There's nothing else going on here. I have one thing. I just want to give a shout out to our youth sports teams. One, I saw my husband buy a $5 cookie from the volleyball girls because they...
1:26:15 They just asked for a donation. It's just so great. So all the other youth sports teams that are thinking about awesome fundraising, don't set a price, not 50 cents, not a dollar. Ask for a donation. He's paid $5 for a little cookie. And then the second, just a shout out to AYSO. They have their banners up at the post office, both in English and in Spanish. And I'm just so grateful to the youth sports teams and all of the work they do in this community and just watching them hit the ground running. So thank you.
1:26:44 Hear, hear. Okay, so just a couple things from me. I attended the Easter Egg Hunt on April 14th and would like to just really commend staff for a fantastic event at a new location. It was pretty fun watching a bunch of toddlers try to run over stew. But just a lot of excitement, really great turnout, beautiful weather, great, great new venue. I just, I thought it all went really extremely well. So, nicely done.
1:27:11 And then on April 25th, I attended the Mammoth Unified School District Facilities Advisory Committee. There are some interesting proposals they're working with HMC to bring forward some updates to the local schools. So we'll keep you apprised as those come before the public, but some very exciting things and just really appreciative that they invited the town and the public to participate in that committee. I think there's been some really valuable feedback.
1:27:40 So that's it for me. Request for agenda items. Stu, what do we have on our June agenda? We'll have the standing Mammoth Creek Park West project, and we're adding the deferred maintenance program. That's kind of two standing items that we have. And then, you know, we start to move into kind of operational mode, so we tend to go lighter on kind of agenda items in summer, June and July.
1:28:09 We'll also, I don't know if we've considered kind of moving. I know the July meeting was, I think, the second, but I think we've actually moved that, so I'll have to check on June about when that happens or if we need to have that meeting in July. Yeah, we often don't meet in July. That's correct. The staff's busy delivering program. So I just don't have it in front of me, but I'll kind of bring that forward in June just so we get a good heads up of kind of how summer's looking. And the first Tuesday is the 4th of July. Yeah, that's what I, right, so there you go. So I think we actually bumped it to the following Tuesday.
1:28:38 But we'll kind of come forward in June and just provide a recommendation of whether we need to host that meeting at all and just be back in August. But it's going to depend on a couple of these projects that we have running. I do want to meet in June just to kind of get us going on this maintenance program. I think that's really important. Absolutely. And then you're also kind of reaching out to the – Council did approve the sports funding package, so you're kind of reaching out to those groups to follow up on some of the workshop items that came up, correct?
1:29:06 Yeah, Kat's in Australia right now, so when she gets back, she'll be kind of jumping on, obviously, the pool, which will be a big part of the operations, but it's certainly kind of working with the youth sporting groups on the assistance program, and then see if we can kind of reinvigorate a couple of the organizations that we have. Are we going to try to do the meeting with Emily for the crowd rise and all that stuff, or is that... That's exactly one of those items that we want to kind of get going. Right now, I'm kind of overseeing the pool ops, so I'm kind of... We're all a bit busy and... Underwater.
1:29:37 We're rolling. But anyway, we have those items and we do want to provide an update too. I'd also ask that in our Plan MCP update in June, we talked a little bit about some, you know, just depending on council actions this month, that maybe we talk about some public outreach because I, you know, I too have had a lot of conversations about, you know, this project despite a lot of effort is still in many ways not necessarily well understood. So if we can maybe talk about that as part of that item, I think that would be helpful.
1:30:06 Anything anyone else would like to add to our meeting next month? I did have one thing really quickly, probably not relevant to the item, but it was in your staff report just quickly about Lindsay. Her last day will be May 12th, if you did read that with the town. So she's moving to the Forest Service. So we're currently recruiting for a new program facilities coordinator. I saw that, but I didn't know that. Yeah, that was just kind of in that attachment there. So we're moving as fast as we can.
1:30:35 Well, big thanks to her for all of her efforts. And she did. And she's done a tremendous amount of work, you know, with binding that program facilities manual. I mean, there's so much kind of work that she's put together. And we did compliment Lindsay on, you know, that opening day of our programs. I mean, I think from year over year, that was probably the most successful we've ever had, launching all our programs in one day at one time. And it went really, really well. So I do want to kind of compliment Lindsay on everything she's done for the department.
1:31:03 Wish her well in her future endeavors. Absolutely. That's all I have. Thank you. Let me say that. Thank you. Okay. Well, on that note, I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting on June 6th right here. Thanks, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. It was impressive. Hour and a half. Thank you for starting.