Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2017
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 32 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
200 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:04 Good afternoon, everybody. I call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, April 12th. Roll call, please. Commissioner Hurley. Present. Commissioner Chang. Yes. Commissioner Eckert. Here. Vice Chair Vanderhurst. Chair Gallin. Yes. Jennifer, can you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Ready to begin. I have pledged allegiance to the flag.
0:36 Thank you. Our first item today is public comment. The public comment session is open to any member of the public who would like to speak about an item that is not on today's agenda.
1:01 Good afternoon, Madam Chair, Commissioners, staff, members of the community, Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, trying to keep up with the radio voice, the man of no one. Quick update on Mammoth Lakes Recreation priority phase projects. In December 2015, Town Council approved four priority phase projects. The multi-use facility, which is the ice rink and the community center. The arts and culture center, a 300-seat theater, an expanded and enhanced trail system, and an outdoor performing arts center. Those are our top four.
1:30 Developmental phase projects were Fieldhouse, Aquatic Center, Biathlon Center, those are kind of rolling up. Right now, we're about 16 months into my two years in this assignment. The Woodside is now closed with a gentleman named Dirk Winters. Mammoth Lakes Tourism is putting $300,000 into that facility right now for infrastructure. Looks like we probably had that for five to ten years, so that's kind of sit on the back.
1:57 Fence for a little while. We've done the wetland delineation study for the Belcher parcel. We're going to sit on that. We know what we can and can't do in the next five years, give or take a little bit. MLR is looking at financing options. If we bond the R&U money over the next five to ten years, we generate probably $10 to $15 million in assets. That would allow us to pull the trigger on these priority phase projects and make them move forward. So MLR will make a decision on May 2nd. We have three options, really.
2:25 Option number one, do nothing whatsoever. We have about $6 million in R&U in the bank right now. We can do ongoing commitments and some allocation, but we do nothing because we are not willing to make a decision. Option number two, pay as you go. $6 million through first phase of the ice rink at this point.
2:41 We're going to make some people happy and a lot of people not very happy. Option number three, move those other projects through the queue, move the aquatic center up on top. We had a good conversation with Ralph yesterday from Snow Creek talking about possible capital matches and capital campaigns. The goal would be to move those priority phase projects through the queue, through the budget process of the next two months.
3:04 Close that stuff so we know where that stuff's going and then hit that reset button and begin to think about the next set of projects. So I know you all will be involved in some of those things so I felt it was appropriate to give you a quick 30-second update. Any questions on my answer for you at this point? Good afternoon. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? Ruth Traxler with the Planning Department. I just wanted to give you guys a quick update.
3:38 and project status for the Glass Mountain Apartments. In 2014, the town was awarded around a million dollars to fund several different housing-related projects and homeownership assistance grants.
3:53 And one of those projects was for the Glass Mountain Apartments, which is a 26-unit affordable housing project on Mountain Boulevard. It's a former motel building, and it's fallen into kind of some significant repair issues related to electrical plumbing and some site improvements. So there were some revisions to the scope of work, which delayed the project a bit, but we finally gotten the
4:22 Report from our electrical engineer and we hope to start construction within the next couple months to put in a complete new electrical system and then if there's funding left over then we'll address some of the plumbing and site improvements that need to be done and we hope to have those completed by October of this coming year. Any questions related to that? Would you happen to have the address? I don't have the address offhand but it's on Mountain Boulevard. Mountain Boulevard.
4:56 Thank you. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? Sandra, do we read the letter or do you want to read this letter? We don't typically read letters into the record like that, but we received written communication from Ken Sample.
5:18 Property owner in the downtown area regarding minimum floor ratio. That's not an item on your agenda today, but it's provided for your information. Additionally, Council Member Wentworth, sorry, Vice Chair Wentworth, asked us to distribute this framework for sustainable recreation to the commission. So that's provided for you, and he said he's happy to come and give a presentation on this document at a future meeting.
5:48 We'll work to schedule that. Great, thank you. Can we encourage Commissioner Wentworth to email it to save some paper? Yes. Thank you. Okay, then we will close the public comment session and move on to our next item. We have no public hearings today, so our first item is a business matter. It's a presentation on Mammoth Lakes.
6:12 2011 Housing Needs Assessment Update and Housing Action Plan Scope of Work to be undertaken by WSW Consulting. Our staff contact is Jennifer Helfrey, but it looks like we'll have a presentation by our consultant. Okay. Yeah, hi. So I'm Wendy Sullivan. I'm with WSW Consulting. And basically I'm project manager and we have a team together that's working on this current update. But we just wanted to...
6:44 Talk to you a little bit about the study since obviously anything that comes out of it, especially when you get to the action planning phase, is going to be coming through you.
6:53 When projects start coming your way, et cetera. And so we just thought it would be beneficial to talk to you both about what we're planning to do in the study, but also get a little bit of feedback from you on some questions regarding locals housing in the area, challenges you've seen, issues of importance to you, et cetera, because that'll help us frame the report and produce the information that you guys need to give you the information you need moving forward.
7:21 And so basically, really quickly, I am Wendy Sullivan. I'm with WSW Consulting. I've been doing affordable housing work, particularly for resort community areas, especially mountain resort communities, for almost 20 years. I actually got my career start as a planner in Blaine County, Idaho, where Sun Valley Ski Area is.
7:44 Grew up in Colorado, worked through a private company for a lot of the resort areas there, and then went out on my own, gosh, six years ago, something like that, when we moved to California. So anyway, and so we've worked pretty much through every mountain resort community.
8:02 in the Mountain West have been involved in this area since 2005. I was involved in the regional study that was done for Inyo and Mono County back then on housing. We've done updates for Mammoth Lakes a couple times since then. And we're really excited about this study because what's been asked is not just to provide you with data.
8:27 on housing needs, but also help develop an action plan to help you know how to address those needs and move forward in your community with housing. And I'm Willa Williford. I'm assisting Wendy as a research associate on this project. My background is a variety of housing work in the public and private sector, mostly in Colorado, but I've worked in development, finance, and management.
8:54 Of course, in affordable housing and went out on my own as a consultant about a year ago when I moved to Crested Butte, another ski town. And so, you know, I'm very much looking forward to understanding the dynamics here and how we can support you in moving towards some actions that are meaningful for this community.
9:14 Yeah. And then just a few members that aren't here. One is Melanie Reese with Reese Consulting. She's been doing this for about 30 years. Pretty much has her hands in any program that's been anywhere in the West. And then also Christine Walker. She was the former director for the Teton County Housing Authority for about 15 years. So she's very familiar with development and operations and that kind of thing. So anyway, that being said, what we've proposed or what we're doing
9:42 Really quick for this study is both to update the housing needs that was done in 2011 so that you understand kind of the picture where you're at now in terms of what the market's providing for housing, what the workforce can afford, where the gaps are, and so where it might be necessary to try to fill some of those gaps. We're doing this through an intensive process of, well, both secondary data research but a lot of local interviews because really the only way that we can really know what's going on in any community
10:12 I'm sorry, I don't want to lose my question. Okay. Just real quick, you used the word secondary method. So secondary data, that would be like census data, stuff that's available that's just out there, census data, well, American Community Survey data.
10:42 Which, well, if you don't know, so census data is the 100% census that's done every decade. And so the next one will be coming up in 2020. Obviously, 2010 was the last time the 100% census was done. That was a while ago. They do the American Community Survey in between, but that's a small sample of surveyed people. And when you get to small areas, particularly populations less than 20,000,
11:11 Thank you.
11:39 Oh, no, no worries. And then obviously economic data. We use state-level economic data and reports, speaking with a lot of local employers, and we are also borrowing upon surveys that are being done through a joint effort of Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes. So there's a household survey that's live for residents, and there's also an employer survey that's live.
12:06 But we're also speaking with the top 10 employers and we're having a group breakfast tomorrow with some of the smaller employers to understand their needs as well. So in terms of community outreach, we have done a kickoff with the council, gathered feedback from a working group that's made up of a number of stakeholders and we also have a website that over time, which you can...
12:32 Check out if you want to that will have updates on the schedule and places for people to comment and be engaged in the process of the study. So the first phase that Wendy's been talking about where we're really building the foundation of understanding the problems and the demographics and gaps will run through June and then an action phase will begin the next day and run and where we're working on what are the strategies and things we can do to actually move the needle on the problems that are identified.
13:00 Yeah. And through this process, there's a, right now we have a 17 member housing working group, which is a group of both involved community members, employers, elected officials, et cetera, on the working group, which are going to be intimately involved when we get to the planning phase for the action plan. And really our goal is to make sure that it's a community action plan and not the consultant's plan, because that's never good.
13:30 And so it's our job to pull together this group to help you guys figure out, okay, from your needs, what are your priorities? How are you going? What's the timeline you're going to be using to address these? And what are the best methods for you to get there? Is really what it's going to be doing. And assigning responsibilities. Because obviously it can't all be government, it can't all be private, it can't all be employers. It's got to be the community. I think to that we really...
13:58 Wanted to spend most of the time hearing from you. And so we just had a couple of broad questions that we hoped would stimulate that conversation. And the first of them is just to what extent do you feel like housing that's affordable to locals is an issue in the town of Mammoth? And if we could open it up, that would be wonderful. Yeah, I don't know. You're looking at me like, what? Do we have to talk? Yeah, basically to what extent you feel it's a concern. I mean, it...
14:29 Maybe or it may not be, you know, just kind of trying to get your perceptions. It's a huge concern, but one of my frustrations is always the definition of the word affordable. Okay. What people make here and what they pay here don't balance out very well. Right. Very true. I have a lot of experience. I've had rental apartments here for 30 years, so I'm probably a little prejudiced on one side or the other. But in that time, I've probably interviewed, I don't know, five, maybe 10,000 people to rent an apartment here.
14:59 And not one of them paid less where they came from, whether it was Visalia or Truckee or New Hampshire than they're paying for here. So what that tells me is our rents are low, but the affordability is bad because people aren't making enough money. And I'm wondering what, in your experience, especially in these other ski areas, not so much how many, you know, days a week people have to work to pay rent, but just in a flat-out number of a two-bedroom-one bath.
15:30 Where are we in terms of our rents versus others here? Yeah, and I can't answer that right now because we're collecting all that data still, but I will say what we have seen in recent years in other areas is, for example, a good way to compare you guys to other areas is this measure called Area Median Income. And if you're not familiar with it, it's basically HUD calculates for every county.
16:00 Region in the U.S. every year what the area median income is and so it is it allows you to and what it does is it would give you like for example at the hundred percent area median income it would look at a family of four and based on the income ranges in that area what you would need to make it to be at a hundred percent so it allows you a way to compare you even though your incomes may be
16:28 Say a lot lower in general than what they are in New York. If you look at the 100% AMI level, it gives you a comparison point of where affordability is to the 100% AMI household. So for example, what we have seen recently is where around the recession time when rents actually dropped in a lot of places, including here,
16:57 The affordability of rents at the market rate were anywhere between 60% AMI to 80%. What we've seen in recent years is most places that's jumped up to closer to 100% if not higher. Typically the standard rental market affordability point you like to see is at 80% because that's
17:22 Kind of the pivot point of where a lot of people are looking to get into ownership and step up. And so where your rents are higher than that, that shows that there's a big gap in between what your locals are making and where your rents are sitting. So I don't have exact figures for you at this point, but we will have that in the report. So we'll be sure to cover it. And just to add on to what Wendy said, part of the report will include a comparison of peer communities. So we're working on narrowing down the list of
17:51 I think another option or another problem out there that the residences
18:20 that the community finds is that there aren't a lot of options out there. We don't have a lot of housing, especially right now. My understanding is that
18:31 There's not a lot for sale and there's not a lot for rent right now. And so even if there is an affordable option, it may not be in an area that they want to live in or can live in due to where their job is and lack of transportation. So I think we really need to look at strategizing and finding ways to increase the availability of housing in the community.
19:02 I just had a question. The AMI that you mentioned, is that calculated on a countywide basis or town? It is. It's calculated on a countywide basis and it's what HUD uses for its basis for most of the federal, well, for the federal programs. How often do they update that? Every year. Once a year. Yeah. Yeah. Unfortunately, it does lag though. Yeah. It does. Yeah. Yeah. So is there, does, is there any way to see?
19:28 Whether there's any discrepancy between a town-wide AMI versus a county-wide, and a county as big as ours and spread out as ours and diverse, it seems to me that a county-wide number would be skewed. Yeah, yeah, and that's...
19:46 Unfortunately, the fact in most areas. The reason why the HUD standard is used is because, as I said, federal funding programs are based off of them. And so, unfortunately, when you go after that federal money, regardless of where your AMI is at,
19:59 You need to go off of that standard to be able to get the funding. And so, but being aware of that for your local community, yes, is important because it can get to the point of where, for example, when you're looking at affordability of a home in Mammoth versus what it would be to the county as a whole might be a little bit different. So you're going to want to structure your affordability of that program accordingly. That's actually what Breckenridge and Summit County area do. And it depends, you know, here I'm guessing because you have
20:28 I hesitate to call it a diverse workforce base, you know, or job base, but compared to the rest of the county, it's pretty diverse. And so my sense is that your incomes overall probably a little bit higher here. Also in speaking with local employers, they do tend to pay a little bit more here because of the housing cost already. And so I would guess that your incomes are skewed higher, in which case, you know, if your incomes are a little bit higher, you know,
20:58 Being able to use the funding, you'll be able to serve, I guess, more households with the HUD funding than you would if it was just based on your local income. But to get at that level, what you can...
21:14 To understand what your income is compared to others, one, it's speaking with employers, but two, there is some local economic data or state data out there that we can use. There's QCEW data that we have access to that we can use to differentiate between you and the county. And then also the survey data that we have because we ask what the household income is, we can differentiate those who live in Mammoth from the rest of the county. So those are really kind of the best sources we could use at this point for that.
21:41 Okay, so you will be kind of taking all that into consideration in your recommendations? Yes, definitely. Well, and yeah, definitely because we'll be looking at the affordability of homes to people that are making their living in the town of Mammoth. And so we'll be needing that information to be able to differentiate. Can you clarify what you mean by diversity? Oh, diversity of jobs? Is diversity of jobs? That's what I was saying to it in relation to was...
22:13 In most resort community, well, and that's why I said I hate to call, I hesitate calling your job base diverse, but I think compared to many other areas of the county, it is. In other words, you have a lot of different types of jobs here, more so than what other areas of the county might offer, you know, like Walker, you know, it has what, like a burger stand and it has a couple retail places, whereas here, at least, you know, you have like the water district, you have, you know, you have.
22:40 But compared to other resorts. Compared to other resorts. I would imagine we're very similar. Well, and that's exactly it. That's why I said for your county, I would say you're diverse. Compared to other resorts, no. You know, I think you're very similar. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Great. Any other thoughts on just like the general need? Or then what have been the primary challenges encountered with regard to addressing housing?
23:14 Some of you may have a long history with these type of studies and conversations. What do you see as challenges and hurdles in the past? I think we would be remiss if we didn't discuss short-term rentals and the increase in short-term rentals and the impact that it has had on the locals' long-term housing inventory. I think that that's what you've got.
23:41 Two sides of that because the town wants the short-term rentals for the TOTs to support infrastructure in the town. Very true. Yeah. But we also need those short-term rentals to also maybe make them into long-term rentals as well. So kind of balancing that and making sure that we have the revenue for the town yet still providing housing for our community.
24:08 I think that there is a deteriorating housing stock and a lack of really desirable places to live whether or not they're actually available or not. So from just physical condition to energy efficiency, I think we're in fairly poor shape when it comes to those things.
24:37 I don't think we've had a private sector apartment unit built in this town in at least 15 years anymore. And again, at $1,200 a month for a two-bedroom, you can't build a building. So any information regarding grant funding available for upgrades, whether they're for energy efficiency or other kind of structural and cosmetic upgrades, I think that would be useful information to have. Have you worked with low-income housing developers in the past?
25:13 I was one. Yes, and yes. And do you see that can be a challenge to engage those type of developers to come here? I mean, I think that you actually have a potentially compelling market for a developer of that, that would maybe specialize in the low-income housing tax credit, is that what you're thinking of? Right.
25:43 You know, if you had land available and wanted to do an RFP or something like that, I think that, you know, my sense is that the dynamics here where there'd be a very strong market for a product at that price point would be attractive. Does that have to be a public and private partnership in that the town would have to provide you the land? Not necessarily, but that's the most direct way to catalyze that. Okay. Yeah.
26:12 Otherwise, those type of developers, they would actually come in and make that acquisition through the tax credit source that they can go from essentially A to Z without the support or the help of municipality here? Generally, yeah, I mean, there's a lot of different roles that can take place.
26:44 So the idea of donating or reduced price land or fee waivers or things like that will make the project more competitive and appealing. I mean, this thing, I don't know, just show of hands, are people familiar with the low income housing tax credit? It is,
27:13 It's a federal program that gets at exactly what Commissioner Eckert was mentioning, that at the rents workers can afford, you can't afford the construction costs. So through a partnership with someone who needs a tax shelter, like a large insurance company or bank or financial syndication usually, they buy a 10-year stream of tax credits for participating in filling that gap between what you can borrow,
27:42 to build the project and what it actually costs to build it. So that is a really, I mean, that's a really great tool if you happen, if you have a need that fits well with what the federal requirements for that program are.
27:55 Yeah. So that's getting, I know technical, but we're a technical crew. Those are jumping way ahead to the action. But, well, and, you know, things to keep in mind, which we will be looking at here, too, is obviously there's been a big change in the administration, the federal level this year. You know, who knows? I mean, tax credit.
28:14 Program is one of the ones that's potentially on the chopping block, especially with the tax reform that's being looked at. You know, I think there's some big changes happening in some of these federal programs that need to be taken into consideration. There's also unique challenges in California. I know there's been some changes or additions to some of their competitiveness and how they determine who can compete.
28:36 Successfully took for tax credit and that's tied in with the cap and trade system and some of the sustainable communities development and so it has made it a little bit harder unfortunately for some rural areas to get access to those funding and so those are all things that we're going to be taking a look at you know I think basically kind of the gist of where a lot are right now is the more that you can
28:57 Find or turn to either local funding, local partnerships, or ways to do it in-house as much as possible, the better, because then you're not subject to the whims of what's happening at the federal level. Can you do it all through that? Probably not, but I think the extent that you can build your capacity to do that here is more local is of benefit, of benefit both in the income levels you're going to need to serve.
29:24 Because the federal programs are typically restricted to 60% AMI or below. Some will go up to 80%. But you're going to have a gap here that's, I mean, you did in 2011 that was up to 120, 140% of the AMI. So getting that middle group, you're going to have to be looking at creative kind of local solutions and partnerships to make some of that happen.
29:50 So, but I think, you know, what we've seen, I mean, you guys have some great opportunities that are coming to play, and you have a lot going on right now. You have the Connect Mammoth Lakes project that just went through with the visioning process downtown. You have some of the changes. You're looking at the zoning code. You have really big parcel in the center of town that's yet to be developed, even though it's been approved for a PD. You know, I think you have some opportunities here, and I think it's...
30:16 What we want to do is help you understand where the gaps are, what it is you need to fill, and then given the resources and opportunities you do have, how can you move forward to start addressing some of those? I think we have opportunities, yes, but at the same time, I think that a lot of times we address issues on a demand side. However, when we get to the supply side, it always comes back to funding source.
30:44 Okay. And that is the biggest issue that we have. So, you know, I think while it's great to address the demand side of things, we've got to address the supply side of things and look at creative, like you said, creative ways to get those funding sources. Great. Well, and that answers our last question, or one of the components, which was what do you most need from this study to help you move forward? That's one.
31:15 Funding sources, because we know, you know, like, for example, you had, I know you did some kind of housing planning work in the past, in 2015 and whatever, that really didn't move forward, and so what we're hoping to do is help you guys move forward, and so if you can help us help you do that, that's kind of where this question is going, what you most need from this study to help you move forward, kind of what's been the stopping point in the past.
31:45 Just kind of going back to the previous question, will you consider the cost of construction here relative to other peer resorts or with respect to the funding that you're looking for? Yes, yes. We'll be speaking with local developers. We were given two names that have done both market rate and affordable product.
32:07 Here. And so we'll be at least understanding the cost of development here for residential, you know, we know labor, materials, all that kind of stuff is an issue. So definitely. It's very much an issue. It costs a lot to build here. We're sort of a little island in the middle of nowhere. So I think that's been part of the historical obstacles in the past. I've asked this question at your initial meeting, your kickoff. Okay. At the workshop, your housing workshop. Data.
32:51 The origination of that data. How are you reaching Hispanic community assuming that is the primary in this town? I don't know if that's the primary workforce, but it seems that way. And given that most of them, or some of them, excuse me, may not be wanting to get online to look at, to click on the lane to go through your survey,
33:33 You're having the employer to be your sort of your champion to get to those individuals, but can they really get to those employees to make those surveys?
33:53 We've done, well, a few different things. So there's two things going on. Like I said, there's the Mono County Mammoth Lakes survey that's going on. And so that's actually being done by a different consultant. They're doing a housing element update for Mono County. And so they are doing Hispanic outreach as part of that survey. Part of what they're doing for that is, as you said, through employers, and they're trying to use employers and other, I'm not...
34:20 Privy to everything they're doing, but other sources to get at least paper surveys and get some interviewers to some of the Hispanic community and the members. Jennifer with Mammoth Lakes Housing, they actually held a session with a group of Spanish-speaking
34:38 A group of Spanish speakers that get together at the hospital on a regular basis. And so they held a session with them and I gave them a series of questions to ask with that. We have a Hispanic Latino representative on the working group now, which is fantastic. So he will help us reach out to that community and help speak and give that community a voice. I mean, what you said, it's always a challenge to get them, you know, involved. We did also attend the El Foro group and I murdered.
35:07 That pronunciation, I apologize. But that was at the same day that we had the kickoff. And that's a large group of the Spanish speakers and Hispanic community with that as well to introduce the study and get some feedback from that. And so we are making effort to get that out there. It's a difficult environment, especially, again, with some of the administrative changes.
35:34 It's always been hard to get their voice in the past, and we've had interviewers go out to communities and do that and get as much input as we can. The sense is right now, with the immigration changes and things going on, they're even quieter than usual, and so it's unfortunate and it's hard. I guess my concern is that if that's the majority of the population in the workforce, representing the workforce,
36:04 You can't get to those people. Your data is no good. Yeah. Essentially. So you might as well. Well, we are getting to them. We are getting to them, and we don't have to speak to 100% of them to do it. And so we are reaching out to them. We're reaching out to them through the local organizations, the local groups, the school district, the hospital. The fire district had a meeting, or not fire, the police department did, but they, this year, people quit coming. You know, and so it is, it's just a challenge.
36:32 So I want to assure you we are reaching out to them and we are getting to them as well as we can. And then, you know, we absolutely work with methods like waiting to, you know, with the survey data and then being very aware of it and trying to do the proxies like you mentioned around employment or even, you know, today I was interviewing property managers and they had really good data on their population, their tenants and what was going on with them and so that's, you know, super helpful because they're on a day-to-day
37:02 The relationship. Right, right. So yeah, so everyone we speak to, realtors, property managers, employers, the public. Like I said, we have the representative on the housing working group now, which is fantastic. We really wanted that. It was hard to find. So yeah, so like I said, we're really doing what we can. Unfortunately, we don't have $100,000 to go out and pull everyone off the street, but we're doing.
37:29 As much as we can. I believe I'm trying. So, yeah, so, I mean, if you have other ideas of, you know, send them our way. If you know of, you know, like when, say, the church has a group coming together or something that would be open to having, say, Jennifer or Patricia show up and do a discussion, let us know.
37:59 I certainly believe this is community effort is not, you know, you can only do so much. I think the community here definitely have to make bulk of the effort as well. Yeah, well, and it is, I will say it is more definitely, I mean, you're.
38:17 A high percentage Hispanic Latino population here compared to the majority of communities we work in. And it's been that way for a long time. A lot of areas where we are now, it's been recent growth, but here it's been that way for a long time. So it is, I agree with you. I mean, it is important and we have to have their voice and so that's why we're really trying to get it. Okay. Great, thanks. Any other things, parting thoughts on how things you need from this study?
38:51 Do you also include a comparison of just overall cost of living? Not just income versus housing costs, but the cost of other everyday living expenses? Do you look at those items at all? We do include an analysis of HOA fees and utilities, which just on my review of the 2011 study are quite high here, but we don't look at other things.
39:20 Food and transportation and healthcare outside the scope of this, unfortunately. Okay. Any other comments, questions up here? Thanks for having us. Thank you so much. Thank you. Okay, moving on to item number two, planning and economic development commissioner appointments to the housing working group. Sandra?
39:52 So Mammoth Lakes Housing has requested that the commission appoint up to two commissioners to sit on the housing working group, so working with WSW Consulting on this project through June and then through the fall. So it sounds like between now and June there will be about one meeting, but then in the fall we'll have more meetings. So this is kind of a light assignment now, but...
40:16 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
40:49 June, and that'll just be a conference call with us going over the draft report after you guys have had a chance to review it. And so just making sure, getting comments, you know, making, you know, see what we've missed, you know, anything before final. And then we would ask that you be present for the final presentation. The part two is going to be...
41:11 We're gonna have four meetings, two hours each, that are gonna be intensive work sessions. And they're gonna be, one will be goal setting, so taking a look at what your needs are, figuring out what the priorities are for your community, and kind of establishing a priority of goals for housing and your community. And then another will be,
41:34 There'll be two sessions on strategies. One will be looking at both your existing strategies and kind of what's working, what's not, you know, what sort of tweaks, changes, additions might happen. And then the other one's going to be looking at new strategies. You know, what do you not have in place that could be helpful to help you address your priorities? And then the final one is going to be establishing the prioritization, the timeline, and the...
42:00 The responsibilities, who's responsible for different strategies that are in there. So those are going to be four two-hour work sessions spread out, I think in July there's two meetings, August there's one, and September there's two meetings. And then it would be, and so it would include that time plus prep time. You know, we're going to have materials that we would want the working group to.
42:28 Be able to go through beforehand to be apprised of the topics of the day and understand the information and data that we have on your place as well as some of the comparative information that we might have from other communities of things that have worked and have not, et cetera. So as far as full time, at least an hour, maybe two more if you want to dedicate it per meeting, prep time, I think.
42:57 Thank you. That's helpful. Thank you. So with that, it gives the group a good idea of kind of the commitment. Is there anyone interested in volunteering to serve on the working group? I would be interested. Okay. So we have Commissioner Eckert and Commissioner Chang on the housing working group. Thank you. Sounds great. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, Tom. On the need survey, Tom Hodges, VP of Development with Mammoth Mountain.
43:34 One other constituency, the other group, I just want to make sure that isn't overlooked is the seasonal worker, because it's not too likely you're going to get feedback from them, so I'm thinking of the minimum wage earner that's here just for the winter season. We accommodate a lot in our housing, but we don't meet the demand, we know that, and so I would just urge...
44:00 Your group as well as everybody else to be aware that there's a significant number of winter seasonal workforce here as well that has a seasonal need for housing. And I think we've all anecdotally heard about people sleeping in their cars and parking lots and stuff this winter and so forth. So I just want to make sure that that is not missed in the needs analysis and then in the action plan.
44:26 You know, we certainly advocate that there is a component of the solution that addresses that constituency of sort of a seasonal demand housing, whether that's hostile style housing or whatever it is, because it all equates to meeting the demand and taking pressure off the other available housing in the community and so forth. So just want to make sure that's not overlooked. And then as this moves forward into sort of the action plan and strategies, you pointed out there's the
44:54 You know, the funding's limited as you get past the sort of the available federal grants of 60% and below and so there's that missing middle that we've always talked about that there's limited opportunities for funding and maybe we have to be self-reliant to achieve those type of solutions and I would just say I recommend that as we approach those discussions that we think about kind of reverse engineering what the missing middle can afford and then come up with potentially
45:23 Development solutions that would be affordable based on their income levels. I think one of the things that's never been done in this community is like, you know, have we ever built, you know, 800 to 1,200 square foot type units, you know, that can be built affordably and be affordable to people in those income ranges without subsidy if it's done correctly and thought through properly. So, I know Paul's shaking his head, but I, you know, you know, it's just,
45:52 There's a lot, if you can really think about how you can build an efficient unit, and I'm not necessarily talking modular or whatever, but there is a way to create economy of scale and to create affordability and build a property-sized unit that's going to meet the needs of a four-person family in this community. I'm convinced that it can be, we'll see where the numbers shake out, and that's what the needs analysis is going to do, and we'll define what those values are, but that's why I'm saying, let's kind of reverse engineer and say, okay, well, what could be affordable? What could we build if we can build something for,
46:22 250 a foot, I don't know, you know, it's, you know, in the end, the rubber's going to meet the road, and we're going to have to come up with solutions that we can, you know, that are going to be buildable, and we don't want to just have a bunch of ideas that we can't implement, so, anyway, thinking a little bit ahead, but we're, the mountain, as you know, is helping to fund this.
46:43 needs analysis in the action plan, and you know, we're excited to participate in it, and we certainly see it as an urgent need of the community, probably number one priority for you guys, as well as Planning Commission, and you know, just in view of the news today of the announcement of Mammoth's sale, I think you probably, most of you heard about that, inevitably that's gonna...
47:05 Result in some real estate speculation and inevitably prices are probably going to start to go up. So, you know, there needs to be a laser focus in this community on this issue. And I think we all need to really, you know, look to this to create tangible results in a realistic implementable action plan that we all need to work together to achieve. Thanks. Tom. Thank you. With the sale of the mountain, and you may not be able to answer this, but.
47:34 Do you know if the new owners would like to continue to partner with the town in this? You know, I think, understand that it's not, there's not going to be a material change, particularly from the outside looking in at the mountain and, you know, Rusty's still going to be at the, you know, at the helm of the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. There's, so in some ways you just have to look at it as it's kind of the recapitalization of the company.
48:02 Yeah, we're fully committed to all these initiatives and, you know, and the funding of this study and the action plan. And, you know, absolutely. We're, you know, we're community members. We're active participants. And we have every expectation to continue that fully into the future. So. Thank you. Does that answer your question? Mm-hmm. Okay. Thank you. Thank you again. Okay. So I think we're all set.
48:38 With our appointments. Correct, Sandra? Okay. So then moving on to item number three, considering approval of time extension request 16-001. Should that be 17-001? No. When it originally came in, it was 2016. Got it. Okay. For the North Village parking garage entitlement. And Nolan. Great. Thank you.
49:04 The town is requesting a six-year time extension for the North Village parking garage entitlement, which approved an approximately 300-space parking garage in the North Village area on the town-owned parcel at 99 Canyon Boulevard. Currently, that site is developed with a 38-space surface parking lot. The parking garage project was approved in 2007, but due to extending...
49:29 Extenuating circumstances that affected the town's financial situation, including the economic downturn, the airport lawsuit, the four years of low snowfall, the project has not been built. Approving the time extension does not guarantee or provide any assurances that the project would be built, but rather maintains the approval as one option for improving the parking situation in the North Village.
49:56 Currently, parking for commercial uses is provided via the 38 space surface parking lot, on street parking, and the East Village surface parking lot. It is important to note that the East Village surface parking lot does have an approved entitlement for a hotel project, and it is privately owned, and that they have no obligation or requirement to provide parking for the village commercial uses.
50:22 While this project would be expensive to build, there is value in preserving the entitlement so that if funding were to become available or some alternative funding mechanism were identified, the project could move forward. The estimated cost to build the project when it was approved was $17 million. Additionally, should the town elect to move forward with a slightly amended project and
50:47 The entitlement is still valid. The town could come to the commission and ask for an amendment to the approved project rather than starting over with the whole new entitlement. In order for the commission to move forward with time extension, the zoning code does require certain findings be met, including one, that there were extenuating circumstances that prevented the town from moving forward with the project.
51:15 The project is still in compliance with the general plan, zoning code and any applicable specific plan and that the conditions of approval that were originally there are still adequate or modifications to those have been recommended to remain in compliance with the zoning code. It is staff's opinion that the findings can be made for the time extension and do recommend approval of time extension 16.
51:45 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
52:11 Thank you.
52:39 Necessarily applicant for the project. It was the town. So this extension would go beyond the expiration of the original development agreement? Correct. Correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding is when that development agreement expires, we have a tenuous commitment as to whether we even build on it after that. Up until that development agreement expires,
53:12 The town has agreed that it will only be used for parking. But when that development agreement expires, that condition goes away. Is that accurate? The development agreement gave the town an irrevocable offer dedication for that parcel, and it was intended for public uses. Parking was just one of those public uses that could go on that lot. So that would continue past the expiration of the development agreement. That is tied to the land.
53:42 And the IOD was accepted by the town? Yes. In this case? So the town, yeah, has full ownership of that parcel, and again, it was said it was written in a way that it was really just public uses without kind of specifying that this could only be parking. Parking was just one of those public uses it could be used for. But this extension is specifically for parking? This extension is for the entitlement that was approved. Of the parking. So the parking garage entitlement.
54:24 Exactly. It doesn't prohibit the other uses. It doesn't prohibit the town from coming in with a whole new project on it that would then supersede that entitlement, whether that be a parking garage or another public use. It just maintains this option of approval for that specific project. I know it's easy just to say yes on this. You know, perhaps not much of this, no discussion or not much of this discussion is needed, but
54:55 Given that the last 10 years of the town through various problems that we face, the bottom line is we have no funding for this building. We have to construct this particular building would be very cost prohibitive from the previous discussions that I've heard. And while this is the town's parcel,
55:33 Um, um,
56:08 It's important to hold on to this entitlement so that we can be prepared for the future. We do not know what the future holds. I don't believe $17 million is cost prohibitive, depending on your partnerships, depending on the opportunities at the time. That's just what it costs to build this structure. We built a smaller structure this last summer for $600,000 to meet the immediate need.
56:32 Doesn't mean that that could change. A partner could arise that would want to participate in the construction of this project to the benefit of the public, and that dollar amount just doesn't seem so large anymore. So it's important to keep this entitlement to be prepared for the future. Hayes, do you have, just out of curiosity, do you have any idea what an updated construction cost might be? I haven't taken a look at that, but I would guess it's, you know, it's increased. Land prep, utilities, the compaction,
57:11 They've already done to get the lighting and the parking lot up there. How much of that would be coming off of the 17? Yeah, we'd be able to utilize the bus shelter, the sidewalks. We would obviously reuse the lighting. There's a lot of things that would be salvaged. Some of the retaining structure, that is modular. The retaining wall is not cast in place. It can be relocated and reused.
57:36 That was done intentionally. So we would lose, obviously, the asphalt and some of the stuff that we would have to remove, but a lot of the infrastructure we developed could be salvaged and reused for a future development project. Now, at this time, there's really no talk, no talks of... At this time right now, no. Like nobody wanting to have any type of partnership, right? At this time, no. Tom, can you raise your hand? Yeah. Go ahead, Tom.
58:14 Tom Hodges again. A couple things. I think that there was a phased pricing in the prior entitlement that was sort of a stripped-down version of it that didn't include the facades and so forth that reduced the cost fairly significantly, if my recollection serves me right. I want to recall that. Yeah, phase one was really just the shell of the structure with none of the...
58:42 Architectural treatments added to it, and then phase two is coming back in, and the completion of the project, so all the architectural treatments, and the landscaping of the site. And I think restrooms as well. Correct, and restroom facilities. Right, right. Point being is you could build this incrementally and implement, I think it was four levels is what I recall, and
59:06 You would have to excavate to your lowest anticipated level and start building up from there, but you could potentially, you know, leave out a deck or two initially just to keep, make costs more affordable and provide, I think it was over 300 spaces. 302. 302. So, I mean, you could achieve 150 spaces, something of that nature, and have a significant impact on the demand for what's required for commercial parking. A number of spaces required for commercial parking in the village, I think, is 298 at build-out.
59:36 If all 80,000 square feet gets built out in the plaza resort zoning of this specific plan. Currently, there's 60,000 square feet built. So the current demand is a little over 200 spaces, I believe. We're under by 247 right now. Yeah. And then again, the world's changing. I don't know if you guys realize what the significance of this sale is, but it's going to
1:00:06 Create the opportunity for Mammoth to have access to capital markets that we haven't even dreamed of up till now. And, you know, this Mammoth's being combined in an entity that includes Aspen, Ski Corps, you know, Aspen Resorts, Squaw Valley, Alpine Meadows up in Tahoe, and then the Six Interwest Resorts is the other part of this that it was announced on Monday that
1:00:34 Is also being acquired. So that's Winter Park, Steamboat Springs in Colorado, Blue Mountain in Canada, Ontario area in Mont Tremblant, and Snowshoe, and Stratton Mountain, and the East Coast. So you add that all together, that's 13 resorts that are going to be under one entity.
1:01:01 You know, it's enterprise value today, that's three and a half billion dollars. And so, you know, the ability to aggregate that as one entity to obtain low cost capital is going to dramatically change the outlook of Mammoth moving forward in the very near future. So you guys are going to hear about a lot of stuff going on in the next six months of people, you know.
1:01:29 The interest in Mammoth is going to go up exponentially. So, yeah, I think it's absolutely warranted to retain this entitlement. It doesn't prevent the town from changing it. It just keeps all that work, and I participated in that effort before. It was a nearly complete set of plans were done on this. If you guys looked in the staff report, it was very well thought through.
1:01:54 You know, it was vetted out with parking consultants and structural engineers and Bruce Woodward locally did the architecture on it and, you know, it was really close to pulling the trigger and then the whole world fell apart and it didn't happen. But, you know, it's all still very legitimate work and I think it's really just a question of maintaining all the expense that went into obtaining that. There's no harm.
1:02:17 You don't jeopardize anything moving forward. All your options are on the table. It just preserves that. And, you know, you don't want to have to go back and spend the soft cost of all that effort was, I don't know, in the time it was, you know, I mean, to do it today would probably cost you multi hundreds of thousands of dollars. So, so might as well maintain that expense. It's just, you know, there's nothing lost. There's no, there's no gamble here at all. So. And I do want to say that. Thank you, Tom.
1:02:48 By raising that question, it's not because we don't, I don't want to, I'm not in favor of it, because like I said earlier, it's easy just to say yes, and then we can go on for another 10 years to 15 years and nothing happens again, right? It's no different than when we have these discussions about the FAR discussions where we pass a maximum FAR discussion, maximum FAR,
1:03:20 And then when we got to minimum FAR, then we realized, wait a minute, during the maximum FAR working group discussion, no one really talked about the parking. And you can see, you know, there's just a lot of shortcomings. And so are we going to continue the path of saying, okay, yes, we have a space, yes, it's dedicated for that, but we may not have the funding for it. I think it's just, it's more for
1:03:54 Free for thoughts than simply to say that I'm not in favor of it. Thank you. Any other questions for staff? No, I'd like to make a motion though. Okay, before we do that, I just want to state, you know, for the record that the findings that we need to consider are related to the extenuating circumstances surrounding the
1:04:25 The ability or the, I suppose, lack of ability to have the project move forward over the past 10 years, the finding that it is still concurrent with the general plan, municipal code, zoning code, what have you, and that the conditions of approval do still apply. So if we are all in agreement on those, then we can entertain a motion.
1:04:55 I'll make a motion to adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and improving time extension request 16-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second it. I'll vote. Commissioner Burroughs? Aye. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Chair Callahan? Yes. Motion passes 4-0.
1:05:29 All right, and our next item is the 2016 Town of Mammoth Lakes Annual Planning Report. We'll hear from Nolan again. Great, thank you. I just went through and provided a quick kind of...
1:05:42 status update on some of the projects in the annual planning report that came to the commission in 2016. So the police station, which the commission approved the design of in early 2016, is currently under construction. That construction, at least last, is expected to be completed in summer 2017. Hillside Highlands, three
1:06:10 Three, three-unit apartment project located in the North Village. The design, again, was approved in early 2016. That project is currently in plan check. We haven't heard of a set construction date, but I believe they're planning to start construction this summer. So that's for the three parcels on the corner of Hillside and Canyon, kind of directly across the street from the surface parking lot.
1:06:39 Next up, the surface parking lot was constructed in 2016. The commission approved the design of that. Again, I believe it was February or March of 2016. They also looked at the East Village parking lot expansion. Some grading work was done in summer 2016, and they hope to complete that this summer if they can get asphalt material. The parish hall project,
1:07:05 Again, it came in as a design review. That is also currently in plan check. Canyon side, it was a two-unit plan unit development project in the North Village, was approved in 2016 and the construction was completed. Gray Bear 2 and 3 subdivisions came to the commission.
1:07:24 In 2016 and early this year, currently nine of the 33 residences have been completed, seven are under construction, the remaining 17 are in plan check. Plant to product marijuana cultivation facility, they're currently in plan check for their tenant improvements.
1:07:43 And then just a few other kind of highlighted projects from last year, pedestrian improvements in the North Village area, including ADA improvement, sidewalks, a bus shelter, and installation of a high-intensity pedestrian-activated crosswalk, began in summer 2016 and were completed in early 2017. And then kind of an exciting project that I think
1:08:08 Coming forward this summer is the Forest Service approved two new multi-use soft surface trail sections to be completed in the Sherwins area. These will connect to the Mammoth Rock Trail and then into the kind of lower meadow area making a kind of a new loop that hikers and bikers and runners can utilize. This will improve some of the existing kind of
1:08:35 Form trails in that area, but it will maintain 5% grades throughout all that area. So that's kind of some of the highlighted projects that were included in the annual planning report. Like that, I don't have anything else unless the commission has any questions. Is the multi-use facility part of your report? The multi-use facility, I mean, work began in 2016 on the environmental work, and then that is obviously moving forward with the
1:09:09 EIR draft being released in the near future and then at some point the design will come to the commission as well. The final EIR. The final EIR, sorry. Was Old Mammoth Place, was the revision to Old Mammoth Place also in 2016? Yeah, so the revision did come to the commission and council for the Clearwater Specific Plan.
1:09:36 Those amendments were approved and that's kind of as far as the project has moved along. I haven't heard any update from the project proponents other than what you read in the newspaper as to their status. Understood. I can't think of anything else. So this may not pertain to this particular report specifically and I, Nolan and I had a conversation briefly about this and
1:10:16 Thank you.
1:10:53 The finite resources, resource that we have here. Can you just speak a little bit about why would people feel that planning, through the planning commission, through the planning check process, why they feel it takes, why they feel it takes so long for them to get stuff done? Perhaps is...
1:11:24 On their part, they're not getting the conditions done. They're just not revealing the conditions correctly. They're not using expediters. I mean, what is it that they would have that perceptions?
1:11:39 Speaking from my perspective, I think it's probably a variety of things. You know, so when applicants submit a complete and thorough package, it's usually relatively quick to get through the planning process and the building process. But, you know, a lot of applicants maybe don't spend the time in advance to put all the items together or they're on a time crunch, they want to kind of submit a...
1:12:05 You know, something that may not be complete. So we tend to go through, you know, our first planning process is a completeness review. So do we have everything we need in order to analyze the project? So we usually start some analysis in the beginning as well if we have enough information. But so the first kind of check is did you provide us with a site plan, floor plans, elevations, all those things that we need for whatever project they're submitting.
1:12:29 So I think, you know, from my experience, a lot of times it's when they don't have all of the information when they're submitting. Maybe they're not aware of what the information is. I mean, we're always happy to help people walk through projects with people, even for building, just building permit items we, you know, we offer up. If you want to come in just with a, you know, a piece of paper with kind of some...
1:12:53 Just general markups, we can try to help you and make sure that you have all the information you need. So our goal is to try to get people as ready as possible when they submit to get through the process. But, you know, people don't always take advantage of that. So, I mean, that seems to me to be the biggest concern, you know, or issue that we have is incomplete plans for both building and planning. And then when we provide comments,
1:13:20 We expect them to respond to those comments. So sometimes they don't respond or they provide a partial response. And then we have to ask them again for the same thing. So I mean, I don't know if you have other experiences that you want to share or things that you think. No, I mean, I think that really is the biggest delay on projects is submitting either incomplete or ones that don't address comments that are provided. I mean, a few projects we've had provided.
1:13:49 Pages of planning comments and they resubmitted the exact same thing they submitted the first time and ignored all the comments. So it just, I mean, it adds time onto before they're going to get an approved project. And as far as building goes and fire goes, I mean, the building code and the fire code is pretty black and white. And so the plan, when the plans checkers are reviewing those against those codes, it's either you comply or you don't comply. It's really, there's not.
1:14:18 Much gray area that they have within those codes. And when you look at, I mean, the comment letters from the building division, they're very specific, calling out the exact code section and what change needs to be made to correct that problem and get past that point. Are these applicants just not hiring the right consultants or not using anyone at all?
1:14:49 It's a combination between people not yet hiring the correct ones or those who aren't either familiar with California building codes or the local codes here. There are some specific local codes related to fire and building that are specific to here. So I think it's a combination of either an experience or utilizing
1:15:18 developer or designers or architects or engineers from out of the area or out of state. And I think that's why we really, anytime we talk to anyone on the phone about a project that they're thinking about moving forward, we always offer, you know, we have a development review committee we meet every Tuesday. It's, you know, building, planning, public works, fire, water.
1:15:38 So we all sit down and talk about every project that comes through the town. And so we always offer that to someone. If you have plans that are kind of, you know, somewhat developed, we're happy to sit down and you can just, you know, present your plans, get input from, you know, everyone at the table and at least kind of have some feedback on where do we see issues or concerns. So we try really hard to help people up front. But like I said, not everyone takes advantage of that. And I just want to say thank you for, you know,
1:16:11 Thank you.
1:16:42 Just from experience, I mean, there are things that you just can't get, you can't get anything done, period. You know, you don't even have the option of meeting with planners and building staff and things prior to your submission. I agree. Thank you for all your hard work. You're welcome. You did a great job this year. Thank you. Great. Thanks. Anything else up here? Questions? Okay. Oh, Tom. That's okay.
1:17:22 Sort of a quick comment. I did want to acknowledge the great work your staff's doing. I think now more than any time that the town's got a great staff in place and particularly I think Public Works is doing fantastic. I think a huge improvement over in the past. Some of the past struggles getting through plans and stuff. A lot of times things seem to languish in the Public Works side. I think that's gotten behind us. And also I think
1:17:51 You know, now that the commercial zoning code has been updated, I think that should streamline reviews considerably, particularly, you know, in those zones that before every time it was a, any submission was a, was a, had to get a variance because it was such a terrible code before. So, I think, you know, the community as a whole has done, and staff in particular has done a fantastic job of cleaning up the zoning code and, you know, I think the table is set for
1:18:16 Streamline development to a great extent. And there's going to be quite a bit probably coming up in the next year or two. So I know in the past you guys had like a package for new development that Mark Warlaw put together. Might be a good time just to review that and just refresh it and go, yeah, this all looks good. And so that when people do come in, you can just say, this is the flow chart and the sequence of stuff that needs to happen. And I think that was a real helpful.
1:18:45 document at the time, and it kind of led expectations of what the process was going to take, but we haven't had much going on in the last 10 years, so probably a good time to dust that one off and look at it again, but you guys are doing a great job. I think the staff's fantastic, and I think we're in good shape. Thanks. Thank you. Okay, then we'll move on to our consent agenda, which consists of minutes from a few previous meetings. Any discussion on those items, or are we...
1:19:23 Ready to just go ahead and make a motion. Okay, I make a motion to approve the minutes from the September 14, 2016 meeting, the October 12, 2016, November 9, 2016, and March 14, 2017 meetings. I'll second it. All in favor? Aye. Motion passes 4-0. Moving on to commissioner reports. Greg, do you have anything you want to add? No.
1:20:01 Okay. Let's go down the line, Paul. I had the opportunity to meet with a couple folks who relates to minimum FAR and the FAR discussion, the maximum FAR discussion, or the maximum FAR that was approved. And, you know, I think everybody is very passionate about this topic. And I'm going to try to continue to seek out those individuals, property owners.
1:20:38 Hopefully within the next couple weeks. Great. Sounds great. I don't really have anything to add. Sorry. I went to the housing workshop. Paul was there as well with the new consulting group. And it was really nice to hear from members of the community that showed up. And we're really passionate about trying to improve our housing here. And so I look forward to the work that you guys are going to do on that committee.
1:21:20 The housing workshop? Mm-hmm. Well, I look forward to seeing what the various workshops have to, or working groups come up with. Okay, moving on to the director's report. So quickly, just following up on minimum floor ratio, after the joint meeting, or at the end of the joint meeting, what we said we were going to do is come back to council. So with summary of what we heard and then request for direction and next steps and timeline for that project.
1:21:53 So we were going to bring it to the council next week. However, we don't have a full council next week. Council Member Ferney will be absent. So we may bring it to a future council meeting to just make sure everyone is in agreement on the next steps that we need to take and then the timeline. So we'll update the commission at your next meeting if we have a council meeting. If it's on the May 3rd meeting, we'll be able to provide you with an update of...
1:22:20 What the council directed us to do. And also just a heads up, the multi-use facility environmental analysis will be on your next meeting of May 10th. The final EIR? The final EIR response to comments. So what we would be asking from the commission is a recommendation to town council on that EIR, whether you recommend to certify or not certify the EIR. So that will be going to council then the following week of May 18th, I think. May 18th is the next council meeting date.
1:22:50 No, May 17th. So just a heads up, we may ask to start the meeting early. We'll kind of see what items you have on your agenda. So we may be reaching out in a couple weeks just asking if the commissioners can meet maybe at 1 o'clock instead of 2. But at this point, we'll just adjourn to 2. But we may need additional time. And so that would be pertaining just to the EIR, not to any design elements of the building or anything like that? Right. Right. And that's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Yes.
1:23:21 Please would like to give a public works update. So just a quick update on Reds Meadow Road. We will be, staff will be at Town Council on the 19th with a requesting approval to move forward with a FLAP application and executing a resolution adopting. Can you explain what a FLAP application? Federal Lands Access Program Grant. It's a federal grant program that will secure the funds to do the reconstruction.
1:23:49 We'll also be asking them to sign a resolution taking responsibility for a number of items, and I don't want to be the spoiler here, but I'll touch on kind of highlights and then town council. We'll have all the details. On the 13th of March, ESTA authorized a $1 surcharge, up to a $1 surcharge on adult fares.
1:24:13 Going down to Reds Meadow. That is to help offset the long-term maintenance costs of the road. On the 20th of March, we had two public meetings that were attended by Federal Highways, CH2M Hill, the Forest Service, and the public. And we went over all the details of the project and gave the public an opportunity to ask questions about the details of what we were trying to accomplish.
1:24:39 On the 10th of April, the Local Transportation Commission approved the application. There was a good discussion about using state transportation improvement program funds to add to the match. There's an 11.47% match that the town will be required to be responsible for. I think that's about as much detail as I can go into. I can field some questions if you have any. Just sort of curious with the overall
1:25:14 I mean, is the overall idea just to sort of patch and repair? Or is it more of a rebuild and widen and improve? Or what's your thought? So the Forest Service Federal Highways and CH2M Hill came up with about four realistic alternatives. The town will make a decision on...
1:25:34 which alternative we want to move forward with. At this time, Public Works is recommending a two-lane alternative on the upper 2.5 miles where it's currently one-way passing with passing areas, and then a removal and reconstruction of the lower 5.8 miles. I like that idea. It's pretty sketchy. Yeah. It's a big project. Yeah, the estimated cost right now is $23.5 million.
1:26:04 And is that something that could conceivably happen this summer or spring? Unfortunately, no. The programming, if we were fortunate to be awarded this grant, the earliest we would see funding would be 20 or 21. 2020? So what happens in the meantime? Does our road fall apart? The Forest Service is still responsible for maintaining that road. The Forest Service is. And are they just responsible for it or do they have an obligation?
1:26:33 They are responsible for it. No, no, no, those are two very different things. They are, and I'm tap dancing. No, the Forest Service, even if we sign a resolution.
1:26:51 Accepting this road as a highway deed or some type of other instrument to secure the authority to maintain it, that would not go into effect until the day we, the town, accept the final project as complete. So this is a five year project? It could be, yes. And in the meantime, once the snow is cleared and the Forest Service can assess the status of the road, it's...
1:27:22 Up to them to decide what, if anything, to do? Correct. And the town has historically done what we can to help them out. We do clear the snow. We do help with patching. We do lend them our equipment. So we suspect that we will continue to be a partner in the interim if we are fortunate to get the grant funds to keep the road functioning. Okay. Is it going to be operational today? I mean, this summer? I don't see why not.
1:27:50 May be opening a little later than usual, but they do plan on getting it open at some point. I think it's a great idea, a great project. I hope everything works out. Does, does ESTA anticipate starting their $1 surcharge this summer? If we are successful in the grant, they will start the $1 surcharge next summer.
1:28:13 And the idea is we front load the first four years before we take over the project to build a war chest, if you will, of maintenance funds so that we, the town really never has to dip into its own pocket to maintain the road. My understanding is that they haven't increased their rates in almost 10 years. Yeah. So they're due for an increase anyway. Okay, great. Thank you. I got a question for staff. Is it really true that I heard that there are 30 plus buildings?
1:28:44 Red tag, due to snow, damage risk? No, we've gone out on a lot of damage assessments, but red tag is really when the building is not, you can't occupy the building. Like the one behind Roberto's? Roberto's, yes. So there's only, I think there was only maybe four of those types of buildings. With two of them, the red tag was removed quickly, as soon as they basically shoveled the roof.
1:29:10 And then obviously the building behind Roberto's needs to be completely rebuilt. And there was a building on Mountain Boulevard, which I think they're working on.
1:29:20 Fixing a couple of the units there. So it's only been a handful that actually have received a red tag, but we've gone out on a lot of different, and I don't know how many calls total we've gone out on, but a lot of different calls where, you know, beams are kind of bending or there's some concern. And I think really what the building official has stressed is shovel your roof, you know, when he goes out there as if that's really the solution to all of those issues, you know.
1:29:48 Keeping those roofs shoveled. And, you know, I think next year everybody will hopefully be more proactive early in the season so that we don't end up with some of the situations that we've had this year. What do the landlords do or what did they do to handle the displaced tenants? I think all the tenants in the building, the Roberto's building, have moved to other locations because that building is not going to be rebuilt soon. I think they're in for plan check.
1:30:15 I think they're in for plan check for rebuilding portions of the roof and that kind of stuff, but I just don't think that building's going to be ready to be occupied anytime soon. Some significant work that needs to go into that building. The fire department had a program set up to work with displaced residents on ones and twos and so forth, so while we had to red tag a couple, only a few buildings, there were places for those folks to go.
1:30:43 And we had, during those really heavy snow periods, we actually had shelters open in case something did happen and we did have to relocate a number of families, we had a place for them to go. Where was that shelter? The shelter was at the middle school. High school, yeah. Middle school, you said? The high school. High school, okay. Thank you. Does anyone have any official information about the structure fire yesterday? I don't have anything.
1:31:16 Official. Nothing official. I saw a photo on Facebook. Is that official? I don't buy it. So what I saw was pretty official. And I don't want, I can't, you know, say for certain what the cause was, but I think, rumor has it, there was a propane buildup or leak.
1:31:42 What was the first thing you said? There was a very early shilling, avalanche shilling. Oh. There was three propane explosions. Propane, right. So just a word of caution to everyone. Keep your propane tanks shoveled and check your gas lines and make sure your appliances are turned off. Two houses were completely destroyed yesterday. Luckily, nobody was occupied. Nobody was occupying them. These are single-family homes? Yes. Anything else? Nothing else here?
1:32:15 So with that, thank you. We will adjourn to our next regular meeting held on May 10th, 2017 at 2 p.m. or pop. We'll follow up. We don't have to decide right now. We'll follow up with the commission and then we'll notice it.