Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2017
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 9 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
5 findings- The Bell Shaped Parcel is Town-owned, undeveloped land of about 16.7 acres at Minaret Road and Meridian Boulevard with wetland features Bell Shaped Parcel (Meridian Boulevard / Minaret Road)
- A recorded 2004 transfer moved 87.04 rooms of density and 14,881.9 square feet of lot coverage from Mammoth Hillside to the East Village/South Hotel site Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
- The Mammoth Hillside project was first approved in January 2006 as a two-phase project with a 193-unit condominium hotel in Phase I Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
- A $5,586,000 in-lieu affordable housing fee was agreed in 2007-08; the 2015 amendment replaced fixed fee amounts with fees in place at permit time Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
- In December 2015 the PEDC unanimously approved amended conditions and a time extension to January 12, 2021 Ritz-Carlton (Mammoth Hillside / Mammoth Crossing Site 2)
Transcript
271 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:29 Good afternoon. I will now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, May 10th. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Vice Chair Everett? Here. Chair Callum? Yes. Michael, would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Absolutely. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
2:11 Okay, our first order of business is public comment. The public comment portion of the meeting is open to any member of the public who would wish to speak about an item that is not on today's agenda. Last call for public comment then.
2:34 All right, I will close the public comment period and we'll move on to our first public hearing. Item number one, consider recommending to the Town Council approval of the Mammoth Hillside project density and lot coverage increase, general plan amendment 16-001 and district zoning amendment 16-002. Our staff contact is Sandra Moberly.
2:55 Thank you. For this item, I would like to introduce Jen Daugherty. Jen was a planner here for the town for 10 years, and now she's a contract planner for us, working on the Mammoth Hillside project. So Jen will provide the staff report and available for comments and questions. Great to have you back, Jen. Hi. Thank you, everyone. It's really nice to be back. So today, the public hearing before you is the Mammoth Hillside site density and lot coverage increase.
3:26 Thank you.
3:57 Forested site, no development. So this application for an increase in density for Mammoth Hillside follows a request for a concept review application that was submitted and reviewed last year. That concept review discussed increased density for the site and was discussed at a joint workshop between the Planning and Economic Development Commission and the Town Council. That happened in September of last year.
4:28 And the closeout letter for that concept review stated that comments received during that workshop indicated support for the density increase. And based on the additional feedback received, the applicant moved forward with a formal request to allow for the modifications necessary to increase the site density and lot coverage, which require a general plan amendment.
4:53 As well as a district zoning amendment, which would modify the North Village specific plan. This site has a somewhat long and complicated history. It's outlined in your staff report, but I'll just hit a few of the key events here. Back in 2004, density and lot coverage were transferred from this site to the South Hotel site. That is the surface parking lot that's east of Minaret Road.
5:25 And that transfer included a transfer of 87 rooms, as well as about 15,000 square feet of lot coverage. And at the time of this transfer, both properties were owned by InterWest. In 2006, a condo hotel project was approved for the Mammoth Hillside site. This was considered to be phase one. It didn't encompass all of the approximately seven acres of the site.
5:53 In 2015, that condo hotel project was granted a time extension. It had not moved forward with construction, and that time extension approved by commission allowed these entitlements to remain valid until 2021. That project, the Mammoth Hillside Condo Hotel project, includes 193 units, valet parking, meeting facilities, restaurant, pool, and other facilities and services.
6:18 And then as I mentioned, we had the concept review application last year for the density increase. So the request before you today is a request to essentially restore the density and lot coverage that was transferred from this site to the South Hotel site. What that would do would allow this site to be developed under the originally intended or originally set for standards in the North Village specific plan.
6:48 That would allow the site to accommodate up to 404 rooms instead of the current number, which is 317, which is a reduction of the 87 rooms that were transferred. This would result in about a 2.6% increase in the overall density for the North Village specific plan.
7:08 And then the request also includes the lot coverage increase, again, about 15,000 square feet. That would result in about a 2.3% increase in lot coverage just within the Plaza Resort, so kind of the pedestrian core area of the specific plan.
7:26 This project is not changing any other development standards in the specific plan, so nothing related to height, setbacks, parking, affordable housing, design, anything like that. It wouldn't change any of those standards. It would not alter the current approvals for the Mammoth Hillside Condo Hotel Project. It also would not alter anything related to the South Hotel Project that's currently approved. And it wouldn't affect any other properties or parcels in the Northville specific plan or in the town.
7:57 So this is not a project level entitlement. This is amending standards that would apply to future development of the site. So we don't have any specific...
8:07 Plans for you to review of any project that would come forward. This is simply modifying lot coverage and density standards that would then apply to any future development on the project site. So what that means is if there were any changes proposed to the currently approved Mammoth Hillside project or if a new project was proposed to replace the Mammoth Hillside project, those projects would be subject to
8:34 The new standards, which if approved, this would allow for additional density and lock coverage. Again, any new development coming forward would be required to comply with the other standards that are not being amended. So if the project comes in with an additional number of rooms because of this amendment, parking would have to be increased to be adequate for those new units or new rooms as well as any affordable housing mitigation and so on and so forth.
9:05 Public comments that we've received thus far on this project generally comprise comments related and concerns related to project level detail. So things like the type of lodging, vehicle access, snow storage design of the project. And that's not in front of us today in terms of plans since this is a legislative type of request. So the general plan amendment
9:34 That would be required would need to modify what's identified as the maximum room count for the North Village specific plan. That would increase the room count by 87 to a total of 3,404 rooms over the entire North Village specific plan. We also looked at the build-out analysis because that would have to be modified to reflect this change in room.
9:58 Room Count. When we looked at the buildout analysis, we did identify an error in the conversion of units to rooms. So this is the buildout table that was just approved at the end of last year in the general plans. This is the first time I think it's being applied to a project. So we found a conversion error which we corrected. In your packet you do have a corrected buildout table that shows that. And then we...
10:22 added in the 87 rooms so you can see the build out with this amendment and because of that error this actually results in an analysis, a build out analysis that is 256 units lower than what was adopted so we're not seeing an issue there.
10:40 So when we have a project like this, a legislative request, one thing we look for is consistency with the general plan. That's one of the mandatory findings to be able to recommend and approve this project. And we found, the staff found the project to be consistent with the general plan for a variety of reasons noted in your staff report and resolution, but some of those include
11:03 The increased density being located in the high-intensity pedestrian core of the specific plan, which is accessible by transit to major transit hub, the gondola, sidewalks, pedestrian and bike facilities are there. That it provides additional opportunities for lodging products and associated facilities and amenities. It's an infill development. It's within a developed area of the town.
11:29 It supports the retail center in the village, and it's also responsive to the North Village District Planning Study. This study identified what were called fatal flaws within the current specific plan for the North Village, specifically related to what was identified as rigid density and use standards that were considered to inhibit
11:56 kind of the successful revitalization of the specific plan. So the increased density can be considered as contributing to a critical mass to help create a sustainable, vibrant evolution of the North Village. We also look at this...
12:14 The consistency with the applicable policy and regulatory documents like the North Village specific plan. As I mentioned, the amendment is only related to two standards, density and lot coverage. And in terms of consistency, the rest of the standards in the specific plan would continue to apply. And actually, this would just restore the density and lot coverage to that that's set forth in the specific plan for the zoning that applies to the site itself.
12:43 So you are seeing a density of 80 rooms per acre in Plaza Resort, lot coverage of 75%. You're not seeing those standards exceeded on a parcel or site-specific basis. Requests such as this are required to go through environmental review in accordance with state law. In this case, we have an environmental impact report, a subsequent...
13:09 Program EIR, S-P-E-I-R, for the North Village specific plan that identified the overall environmental impacts that would be potential to occur with a build out of the North Village itself. So this project coming within the specific plan was able to utilize what's called an addendum to that EIR, which analyzes whether or not the proposed changes would alter any of the environmental impact findings in that EIR.
13:37 We conducted an update to the traffic analysis to ensure that the increased density or to see if the increased density would have an impact on traffic
13:48 The traffic analysis, it did not. So it did not have a substantial impact. So we found that no further analysis would be required and identified 71 mitigation measures from the EIR that would apply to this project site. And those include mitigation measures related to aesthetics, bio, traffic, cultural resources, noise, and other issues to ensure that potential environmental impacts are reduced to the maximum extent possible.
14:19 So circling back to the findings that would be required to recommend approval of this project, we've talked about some of these already. These are the findings that are outlined in the town zoning code. This is what's set forth in terms of making recommendations to council and for council's adoption. And those findings are consistency with the general plan, consistency with the adopted goals and policies of the town. Here in this case, this is the North Village specific plan.
14:49 That the request would not be detrimental to public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare of the town. Here's a place where the environmental review steps in and is important where they talk about public services, noise, air quality, and those types of categories in terms of impact of the project. That it's consistent with any applicable airport land use plan. As you can imagine, we're far enough from the airport that we don't have any issues there.
15:18 That it's in compliance with CEQA. We conducted the addendum, and that was actually conducted by Michael Baker International. They're here for your next project. So we did have an independent contractor do that analysis. And then lastly, that the affected site is physically suitable.
15:36 for the alteration in the zoning standards. In this case, again, we are restoring the standards to that originally outlined in the specific plan for the project site. So on a site-by-site basis, it is not exceeding the envelope of what was initially outlined in the specific plan. So staff has made the finding in the resolution that that finding would be met.
16:03 And then lastly, as we outlined in your staff report, we do have a discussion about community benefits and the fact that none of these findings outlined in the zoning code specifically require community...
16:16 Benefits in order to approve an increase in density or to lot coverage. And so this may be a little bit different than what we've looked at in the past, where we had policies like community benefits and incentive zoning, which was a policy that was applied to projects like this, to legislative requests. Town Council has since rescinded that policy, so there now are no any kind of community benefit requirements or policies that...
16:44 I will have to say that if community benefits were determined to be necessary in order to make these required findings, that would be the case in which a community benefit could be required. Staff hasn't made that finding. We think that the findings can be made without that requirement.
17:10 With that, staff's recommendations is that those findings can be made and that the Planning Commission adopt the attached resolution in your packet recommending approval of General Plan Amendment 16001 and District Zoning Amendment 16002 to Council with the conditions of approval as proposed or as modified by Commission. Thank you. Thank you very much, Jen. Would the applicant or representative like to say anything?
17:44 Good afternoon, Dave Harvey, Madam Chair, Commission members, staff. This is a bit of an unusual request that we come forward with and was given quite a bit of thought over the, oh, I guess last four years. And the process to get to this point has, it's been a long road.
18:15 The staff has done an absolutely incredible job of mapping out exactly what it is that we are coming forward with and to break it down, it's no more than just restoring the original density that was granted this parcel with the 87 units that
18:45 were taken away from the property back in 2004. And between 2004 and today, it's a new paradigm. It's a new world out there in development. And what we're looking for is to be able to start with the original densities, the original lot coverage, and to be able to go forward.
19:15 The property already has a entitlement on it. And that entitlement would be attractive to a purchaser developer. And that brings to point the issue for going through all of this exercise is that the current owners of the property are not builder developers.
19:48 As far as any benefit from that property to the town of Mammoth Lakes, such as infrastructure benefits for the North Village specific plan area, they're really non-existent at this point. When the property is sold to a developer builder, then in fact, we would like to offer that
20:18 Thank you so much.
20:55 Thank you. In just a moment, we'll have an opportunity for questions and comments from the public. Thank you. But first, we'll start with questions and comments from the commissioners, questions particularly for staff and for the applicant. And just a reminder that I think we should focus our questioning to issues related to the findings that we need to make, the CEQA findings and the municipal code findings.
21:27 So I'll start over here to my left. Yeah, I was just, I was wondering if Jen and Sandra and the staff could maybe just elaborate a bit more on the current relationship between community benefits and development, ask like this for increase in density and how the adoption of the FAR development guidelines have kind of altered that relationship and it's no longer directly connected, the two of them.
21:59 Thank you. So the general plan used to include policies that applied to the commercial zones, specifically that required if a developer wanted to exceed a density of 40 rooms per acre, up to 80 rooms per acre, that community benefits would be required to build up to 80 rooms per acre from the 40.
22:28 With the floor area ratio work that was adopted at the end of last year, those policies from the general plan have been removed. So I didn't mention that in the presentation only because this project's located in the North Village specific plan, so any of the policies related to commercial zones wouldn't have applied anyway to this site, even if they...
22:52 We're still in the general plan, but now even in commercial zones outside of the specific plan, if there are, you know, floor area ratio gets rid of your units per units and rooms per acre, so that's no longer a discussion or negotiation or debate about earning community benefits in exchange for density. Thank you. That was my only question. So in other words,
23:22 The North Village specific plan as it exists currently still holds to the old rooms or units per acre, which we have basically as a town decided in the commercial zones to move away from. Correct. The FAR work did not change, did not amend the specific plan. Okay. Just out of curiosity, do you happen to know what the density is at the Westin or at the Village?
23:53 Floor area ratio density. Well, we learned the floor area ratio density in our discussions about that, but do you know what it might be in terms of units or rooms per acre? I can look it up for you. I don't know off the top of my head. It's not critical. I was just curious. Was the North Village specific plan and the 80 rooms per acre cap was in place when those projects were built? Yes. So presumably they would have to...
24:22 comply with the 80. So they're at the 80 or 80 maximum as well. Okay. No other questions for myself at this time. Somebody, I noticed there was like three different covenant agreements, the transfer from Hillside to various properties. I don't recall those names individually. Are there any cases in North Village
24:59 We spent some time working with the town clerk to see what other agreements and transfers might be in place in the village that might be a similar situation to this. The only one that we've found that...
25:20 Would be considered similar is a transfer that hasn't yet been executed, but it has been approved. And that would be for the Inn at the Village project. That's the 8050C, you know, the third tower for 8050. When that project was approved, it included a 30-room transfer from the Mammoth Crossing site, where Mammoth Brewing currently is located. In that case, that was a situation where the same property
25:48 The Covenant has not yet been executed for that. Executed between the applicant, the landowner and the
26:19 The town. Well, the town is a party to those covenants, but it is between the property owners. The covenant would document, as you saw in the attachments, it would document the number of rooms going from which parcel to which parcel, and the town would just be a party in terms of ensuring that the transfer is happening in accordance with the North Village specific plan and we keep a record. If that does happen, the potential applicants, so let's say they sell off the individual parcels,
26:54 And those individual property owners potentially could come back and ask for a similar request to increase the density or restore the original density, original unit counts that they have. So potentially that could happen, right? I think they potentially could, but the difference between that situation and this one is there's so much time has passed that if the property owners in that case at 8050C were to ask for that, I think the town might say,
27:22 No, because the original rationale for requiring that transfer remained in effect. In this case, you might find or not find that so much time has passed and circumstances are so different that maybe it makes sense. But that is a distinction between the two. Thank you. When this comes up, whoever they sell this property to, they come forward with a development agreement. Can they try to take another bite of the apple to increase above this level of density if it's granted?
27:57 A developer can come in or property owner can come in and make those requests. There's nothing from the town to prohibit those requests from being asked, but we would be going through the same process of analyzing whether a further increase would be consistent with a general plan, with a specific plan, and what potential environmental impacts an additional increase could have. So we would be going through the same process to do that, but the town cannot
28:27 Mr. Morris can correct me if I'm wrong. The town cannot preclude someone from coming in and making that request. No, I mean, people can always apply for anything they want. Whether or not it's consistent with our standards is another question. Any other questions of staff at the moment? No. Okay. At this time, then, we'll move on to questions from members of the public. If you can come up, please, and state your name for the record. And if you could try to keep your speaking time to five minutes, that would be appreciated.
29:00 My name is Russ Stewart. I'm a homeowner at Mammoth View Villas. It's a property adjacent to the Hillside Project. Our one big question is, does increasing the density change where the lot lines are going to be, the build lines versus the lot lines? Do we still have the same amount of space between the original plan and...
29:29 More proposing. Would you like to answer? This request would not change any of the lot lines, would not change any of the setback requirements, would not change any of the height requirements. Those would all remain in place. Thank you. And in fact, just to kind of build on that, it doesn't actually change the design of the project that is currently entitled. It really just, is that correct?
29:55 Yeah, that's a great question. So it does not change the existing current entitlements on the site for Mammoth Hillside that were approved in 2006. If a new project was to come forward to be built under these new standards for density and lot coverage,
30:14 Most likely that would come back with a new design or any altered design would come back before the commission, go through the same type of review process where the public would be notified and you could actually see project specific details to respond and comment on. Thank you. Anyone else from the public? Okay, then we will close our public comment session for this item.
30:51 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
31:27 Municipal code findings as far as the general plan, the North Village specific plan. I would definitely be of the opinion that the applicant's request seems to be fairly reasonable. To me, they're not asking for anything that an adjacent property owner in that zone does not also have. And so I think that
31:54 And I think that the North Village Specific Plan and the North Village District Planning Study clearly state that this particular location, which essentially serves as a gateway to the North Village, is definitely an appropriate location for the density which we were talking about. Any other comments up here? I would agree with that. I'm very comfortable with staff's findings.
32:25 You know, as mentioned in the report, there are a number of fatal flaws with the village that increasing the original density and lot coverage that's being asked for today would go towards correcting. I would also like to point out that although there's no direct connection between community benefits and this request, there are clear secondary community benefits that will be bestowed upon the town if this
32:52 Partial of land is developed and that would be an increase in TOT to the town. It would be a pretty good size in lieu payment to Mammoth Lakes Housing at some point down the road and I would also like to say that would include increase the critical mass for the North Village which I think we would all agree is a much needed adjustment to what's going on up there so I at this time would be in favor of granting the increase in
33:22 In density as well as the increase in lot coverage that's being asked for today. Thank you, Michael. I think those are good points. Greg? You know, the one problem I have with this is the applicant is basically a packager. They're not a developer. And what I'd really like to see is that we are very friendly towards people who are actually going to do something with the land and put shovels in the ground, get people to work, and get us, you know, two years close to those COT numbers that Michael was talking about.
33:54 This particular applicant is basically trying to make his project more saleable. It isn't going to get anybody to work here. I would like to see these density bonuses, I'm not sure exactly how to phrase it, but to see this density increase, bonus is probably a bad word, go to the person who's actually doing the work as opposed to the person who's selling land. And I'm not sure there's a mechanism to do that, but...
34:23 And the other thing is we're sort of cleaning up a mess from somebody that should have not probably moved this density in the first place. And we're returning density to clean up a problem from the past. I would just like to have this precedent that we look a little more closely at any density transfers in the future. But overall, it's in. Thank you, Greg. I'm in favor with the request. I see this as a desirable property. This is a desirable product.
34:58 Unfortunately, something happened in the past. I don't think that's relevant at this moment. I would like to make a motion. I'm okay with that. I'd like to make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required CEQA findings, municipal co-findings, and recommended approval of general plan amendment 16-001.
35:35 And District Zoning Amendment 1602, with condition recommended. I'll second the motion. Jamie, can we have a vote, please? Yes. Commissioner Andrews? Yes. Commissioner Kelley? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you all very much. And at this time, we will move on to our agenda item number two, which is a business matter. To consider recommending to the Town Council certification of the Environmental Impact Report for the Mammoth...
36:12 Mammoth Creek Park West, New Community Multi-Use Facilities Project. Our staff contact is Sandra. Thank you. As you stated, the item before you is to consider making a recommendation on certification of an EIR for the town's multi-use facility. At this time, the commission is looking
36:36 Really focused on certification of the EIR, not really looking at funding of the project, project location, those types of things focused on the environmental analysis. We published the draft EIR last December. We provided copies.
36:56 at the library, town offices on our website. We had a 45-day public comment period from December 29th through February 13th. And this is just a flowchart showing the CEQA process and where we are in the process.
37:13 So we've gone through pretty much all of the process. We're down to the public meeting portion of the process where there's opportunities for public comment on the environmental analysis and the next step is to take this item to town council for consideration of certification of the EIR. So a quick description of the project. It's looking at a maximum of a 200-foot ice rink with a winter recreation event area.
37:42 which would cover approximately, I'm sorry, be covered by an approximately 30,000 square foot roof structure. It would include a 13,000 square foot complimentary community center, reconfiguration improvements to the existing playground, as well as accessible, I'm sorry, accessible interactive components and restroom improvements. 107 parking spaces would be provided for the project, and an active outdoor recreation area to the west of the new facility would be provided as well.
38:12 The project is located at Mammoth Creek Park West, 686 Old Mammoth Road. And this is just a map of the project site showing the additional parking to the north, the facility to the south. And the purpose of the Environmental Impact Report is to inform the public and our decision makers about the project and potential environmental impacts. We're looking to identify feasible...
38:41 Mitigation measures that avoid or reduce potential impacts. Disclose any significant and unavoidable impacts. This project does not include any significant and unavoidable impacts. All impacts are able to be mitigated. And evaluate a reasonable range of alternatives and provide an opportunity for public comment and agency input on environmental issues related to this project. So the scope of the ER, we included all of these items in the ER analysis.
39:11 And when we determined our draft EIR conclusions, we found that all of the impacts for all of those areas were either less than significant or less than significant with mitigation incorporated. So what we determined was with the incorporation of mitigation measures, there were no significant and unavoidable impacts, as I stated previously, for this project. We looked at four alternatives. We looked at a no project alternative.
39:39 We looked at an alternative showing this project at the Civic Center parcel, an alternative showing this project at the bell-shaped parcel, and a reconfiguration alternative. Ultimately, we determined that the environmentally superior alternative was the Civic Center parcel alternative. However, that would preclude any future development on the Civic Center site for any town facilities that could be incorporated and built there.
40:04 And our response to comments, Fennel EIR, was released on April 26th. We received 46 public comments on there. We provided respondents to all of those comments as part of that document. The document also includes the mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and it was established for the areas noted above, aesthetics, light and glare, air quality, biological resources, cultural resources, hydrology and water quality.
40:33 noise as well as traffic and circulation. And with that, staff is making a recommendation that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached resolution and recommend that the Town Council certify the Environmental Impact Report for our new Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Creek Park West new community multi-use facilities project and adopt the required California Environmental Impact Report findings and adopt the mitigation monitoring reporting program.
41:04 And with that, I'm available for any questions that you have. Also, we have Annie Morris, our town attorney, from Best Best Krieger, who's a CEQA expert. We have Grady Dutton, our public works director, and we have our environmental consultants here to answer any questions that the commission or the public may have on this project. Thank you very much, Sandra. I just want to, again, begin by...
41:31 Saying thank you all members of the public for coming. I know I appreciate that there's been a lot of public interest in this project. I also just want to acknowledge the fact that I believe that a lot of the public comments and questions have been related to very much more project and building design specific questions, which while being extremely valid at some point in
41:58 Down the road is not particularly what we are here to discuss. I just want to remind everyone that this is a request to certify the environmental impact report related to environmental and CEQA issues only. And so I would like to try to keep our discussion and our questions really sort of related to those issues which revolve around CEQA and the municipal code and the general plan. And not funding.
42:28 And also not funding and not the decision about whether this is a good project for the town to move forward with. That's really not our job here today, although it does not mean that it is an important question for everyone to consider. That is something that can be brought forward to the town council when they have this item on their agenda. I'd like to just start off with a question for
42:59 Sandra, or maybe it's our consultants, just a sort of general comment as to the overall EIR process and the way an EIR is conducted based on sort of a high-level review of a conceptual design and whether is that basically a standard procedure for an EIR for basically the building design to not be completed before an EIR, the certification of an EIR.
43:29 Just for our own sort of education. So, yes, so this is a project specific EIR and we do have the building design as you can see. We have the site design, we have the parking, we have all of that design, we have the height, we have massing established for the project. What we don't have is the design details, what kind of rock we're going to use, what...
43:50 Roof material. It's going to be those kinds of things haven't been determined at this point. We have some preliminary designs, but we haven't gone through that final process of design review. So I think this is a relatively typical process for a project-related EIR. Annie, did you want to?
44:05 Well, I was just going to say that CEQA requires that environmental review be undertaken in connection with the discretionary approval, and it is our determination that the Council's decision to award some contracts that are going to be on the next Council agenda would be the type of discretionary approval that requires CEQA review to be done at this point. And the way that the review works is you have to review as much detail as you can, as many of the reasonably foreseeable effects as you can, and if it turns out that later there are some environmental impacts that were not addressed at this stage,
44:35 An additional review would be necessary, but it's not uncommon at all for a project to be not 100% fleshed out. Normally what you see and what we work on for CEQA are private projects, which are essentially fleshed out at the time they come before you or come before the council because this is a town project with a somewhat different timeline and different set of approvals. That's why it's coming to you in a slightly different format than you would usually see or at a different stage in the process. Okay.
45:03 So it can be used as a tool for the town. The result of the EIR can be used as a tool for the town to make that discretionary decision of whether or not they should move forward with the project and put their time and energy and money towards further development of the project. Yes. Thank you. I thought you were going to have a long answer. That's the answer of the afternoon. Holy moly. All right.
45:40 There are, as is typical, I've seen in some of these EIRs, quite a few mitigation and monitoring measures. In your opinion, in your experience, and maybe this is for Sandra or the consultants, is there anything that you would deem to be unusual or out of the ordinary for what might be typically seen or typically asked of a project like this? No, I don't think there's anything unusual or out of the ordinary.
46:13 Anyone else have some questions at the moment? I don't, not at the moment. There's a couple letters here that relates to this project, specifically addressed the insufficiency of the study, specifically on the traffic study. And it looks like these letters were just received today, so I'm assuming that we haven't had a chance to respond to any of these individuals yet.
46:54 We haven't responded to the letters from today. However, there is a response in the stack that does address the traffic study. It's the one with the Michael Baker International heading on top. So there was a question about the traffic studies, and this was our response to that. So we have provided a response to that. And if you have any questions about these details, I would...
47:23 Turn it probably to Michael Baker, someone from one of the two members of the Michael Baker team here. Now, in this study, well, here, let's see here, one of the responses here, it talks about using the highest peak hour volume on a typical Saturday, winter Saturday, and is that sufficient enough for studying,
48:08 A true year-round Saturday traffic pattern? Or is this a typical how these traffic studies for secret studies are done?
48:30 You know, I'd actually like to refer to Michael Baker's response to that. That's an attachment because they went through in good detail about how we, while we do our studies, how the age of this one, how we select that typical busy Saturday, winter Saturday afternoon as not the peak. So maybe, you know, if you want to mention anything else about that. But in their response, they go through it in great detail.
48:53 To make sure that we could verify that, we actually went out and did an additional three-hour window on, again, another typical busy Saturday afternoon during the winter here. And, in fact, those numbers came in quite a bit lower than the previous study, so it was confirmed that looked adequate. But, again, they did address that in their response, so I'd prefer if you, you know, if you need more clarification that Eddie or somebody else from Michael Baker can respond to that. Okay. Did you want any further?
49:28 No, I mean, I'll just go through this document. Okay. Great. No questions? Okay. Any questions or comments from the public? Wow. Crickets. May I jump in here really quick? Yes, please. I do have a quick question of staff, if I can throw it out there right now. Can you just briefly touch upon why the shady rest parcel was not...
50:15 looked at as an alternative? Well, we don't own it, for one thing. We don't have any assurances that we would be able to acquire it, for another thing. This proposed use is inconsistent with the zoning for that site. That site's long been identified as a site for affordable housing. I don't think the zoning would allow for it. I mean, I'm sure there are other reasons as well, but those are the ones that spring to mind.
50:43 Perfect. Because that was summarized in the packet, but not everyone in the audience has had a chance to take a peek at that, so I wanted to get that out. Thank you. Well, okay, so just to summarize then here, we're being asked to certify the final EIR with the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and being asked to make
51:21 findings are the relevant CEQA findings and the relevant municipal code findings, which consist of consistency with the general plan and applicable zoning code. Sandra, there have been a little questions about the proposed project's consistency with the zoning and the general plan land use designation. Can you summarize the staff's position on that?
51:53 So there was a comment about the fact that this
51:58 This facility would be a commercial recreation facility and would require additional evaluation on the town's part. The town is considered this a park. That was provided, information was provided in the supplemental response to the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area letter, but it's considered a park and a playground. It's a public facility. It will be owned and operated by the town. The definition of parks includes
52:24 Picnicking, swimming pools, tennis courts, sport and active recreation facilities, which we've determined that this is an active recreation facility. This falls into that definition. So there is no use permit that's required for this. It really is just design review and the environmental analysis. So does that summarize kind of what you were looking for? Yeah. So possibly to clarify some confusion or just elaborate on some comments.
52:52 Although the general plan designation for the site is open space, my understanding is that that open space definition does not actually refer to passive versus active recreation, but rather references the town's desire to maximize any recreational activity on the site.
53:13 It allows, and additionally, it allows parks, athletic fields, golf courses, community gathering spaces, supporting facilities, so it's clear that the intent of the general plan is to allow this type of facility in the open space land use designation. Okay. And that even though, according to the zoning code, the parcel is zoned public and quasi-public, which there isn't a 100% correlation in the general plan, you feel that this is a suitable zoning.
53:42 And if I remember correctly that the current ice rink site is also zoned public, quasi-public, correct? That's true. Okay. I'd like to commend all of you for all the hard work that you've done on this. I know that it's been a very difficult project. It's been a controversial project to a lot of people. But it's also been a very looked-forward-to project to, you know, different constituency in town. I really don't envy the town council.
54:20 I feel that it is clear that without any
54:49 Oh my gosh. What's the word? We don't have any excessive significant and unavoidable impacts. Yes. Thank you. Significant and unavoidable impacts. Yes. And as far as the environmental analysis is concerned, I feel comfortable in recommending certification to the Town Council.
55:23 I feel comfortable as well. I think the town's findings have met the requirements of the final EIR, and I would like to echo your comments on the amount of time staff's time and resources have been dedicated to this, so thank you for that. ...the debates on this, and it's hard to not to, it's hard to be objective on this, especially, you know, there's so many opinions out there on this.
56:06 And we all, you know, love the area, you know, love the area that we live in here. Unfortunately, I think, you know, our task, you know, we're tasked, you know, simply to evaluate the study, the Environmental Impact Study, the CEQA study, and nothing more to that. So, I can't say that this study was, there's any, like I said earlier, any deficiency that would cause this study to be...
56:41 To be valid. So I think I would say I would agree with the members here. I'm glad this isn't my fault. The environmental side of it, the staff's report is all pretty straightforward. I think that what we have to do here today is extremely simple compared to, I'm not sure that I'm doing the same way if I'm going for it if I was on a different board, but for this one it's pretty simple.
57:14 Thank you. You can pass the buck, so to say. So do I make a motion on this? You may. Okay. I'd like to make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, recommend Town Council certify the Environmental Impact Report for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Creek Park West New Community Multi-Use Facilities Project and adopt the required circle findings and mitigation monitoring and reporting program.
57:47 I'd like to second that motion. Thank you. Jamie, can we have a vote, please? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you all very much. I think we're in good shape. It's only 2 o'clock. Moving on to business matter.
58:29 Item number three on the agenda, workshop to discuss potential changes to municipal code requirements regarding residential lofts. Our staff contact is building official Tom Perry. Good afternoon, planning commission, Tom Perry building official at the town of Mammoth Lakes.
58:50 I'd like to start off today by giving you, discuss a little background with our loft and also the purpose of our meeting here. The purpose is kind of a workshop to be able to get comments and suggestions and opinions from the Planning Commission and also from members of the public that are interested as to our proposed solution and what we have in mind to remedy the problems that we have with the very many lofts that we have here in town. Just a brief background of how we kind of got to where we're at.
59:18 Both town staff, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, pretty much on my very first day of work last April when I took this job at the town, let me know that there's some real issues and real fire life safety issues with the hundreds of lofts that we have in our condominium units here in town. Some of these issues are, you know, include but not limited to hazardous exiting conditions, head clearance issues, and no emergency escape rescue openings and things like that.
59:47 Exiting would be mainly stairs. You need a set of stairs from any kind of occupiable or habitable space. Ladders have never been allowed. We have a lot of ladders that access these lofts that we have in town. Head clearance, it's always been a minimum of seven feet in a loft. We have some lofts that's literally four foot. You have to crawl around or duck down to negotiate your way through these lofts, which is no question a hazardous condition. And then also a mercy escape.
1:00:15 Rescue openings has been something that's come up time and time again with these. That's something that's separate than your actual regular exiting components like stairs in the front door. It's usually a window in a bedroom that allows for a last ditch escape from an occupant when a building's on fire when they can't get down the stairs and get to the front door and it also allows a firefighter to get in when they can't get in through the front door and use stairs. The other concern too associated with these lofts are that we do now have a town to administer transient rental.
1:00:45 Program through our quality of life ordinance. So we're formally issuing business tax certificates that in writing allow people to use these lofts on a transient basis on an overnight use. And the concern is what position does that put the town in if we're formally allowing these people to use these units, some of which have very dangerous loft sleeping conditions. So those are some of the concerns. Many of the lofts that we have
1:01:12 Were either constructed illegally, the so-called bootleg loft where somebody just went in and did an illegal conversion or alteration. But we also have a lot of lofts that were built at original construction that were never in conformance with the building code or uniform building code standards that governed construction back then. And I've had a lot of people ask, well, how did that come to be? And just from my experience being in the area for many years and having worked for the county for about seven years,
1:01:40 I believe that we just didn't have a consistent inspection and plan review process in place at the county level, especially in the 1960s and 1970s that would have kind of caught this thing. It just wasn't there. And finding documents and records to look at the plans or any kind of approvals, they're far and few between. These documents just are gone. A lot of them are. So that's kind of what we have as a background with this.
1:02:06 We do have lofts and condos. These are specifically relegated mainly to condos. We really don't have a lot of issues with lofts and single-family residences, but these are really with our condos that we have here in town that were built between the 1960s and the 2000s. All told, we have 6,180 condo units in town, so we have a lot of condos. And of those, it's anywhere between maybe, best guess, I've talked to people, 700 to 900 of these units have lofts.
1:02:36 And we don't have a number on how many are bad lofts, quote unquote, but I would think a lot of them. So maybe we have a potential of a couple hundred lofts out there, give or take, that have some pretty glaring safety issues. We do have language that's been in our Chapter 15 since 1986 addressing lofts. The building at the time, even in 1986, recognized we already had a bunch of lofts that were dangerous, and he wanted to get direction from town council to see what to do about these.
1:03:05 Long story made short is we have what we have on the books now for lofts is what we've had since 1986 and it really falls well short of addressing the hazardous conditions that we find with these existing lofts. So if anything, there needed to be some addressing of this as a generality. So briefly touching on the process that I've used to tackle this issue.
1:03:28 It became evident to me that it really was going to involve a lot of scope and vetting with the public on this. There's a lot of stakeholders in the community that are affected by whether you can or cannot use or rent a loft on a transient or a condo with a loft on a transient basis. I started off with having extensive meetings with the Fire Protection District, with Chiefs Freevault and Heller, because they seem to know a lot about what was going on, especially Chief Heller being in the town for many years.
1:03:56 We, after that, I formed a loft task force that was comprised of several members of the public, a lot of these stakeholders, a member from the Board of Realtors, a member from the Blodgett community, the Contractors Association. We had a local architect representing the design community. We have a private inspector that represented kind of the private inspection business, which is a part of the quality of life structure of the ordinance.
1:04:21 We also had Tom Heller from the Fire Protection District and we had invited a few members of the Planning Commission for that too. After we did that, we had that meeting, got a lot of good feedback from these people, rolled a lot of those suggestions into what you see here in front of you with the flowchart and the notes. We then had a meeting with our building advisory group who also serves as the Board of Appeals for the building department and for me.
1:04:45 And presented this to them. They had some good insights, some good ideas that I rolled into here too. After that, I met at least twice at the regular monthly meetings with the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association to get their feedback, and they had some good ideas and suggestions. So we got a lot of good ideas and a lot of eyes looking at this, which really helped. I think it was a good process. Very productive. And finally, we're here today.
1:05:12 One of the final steps in the public scope and embedding process is bringing it before the Planning Commission for your consideration. And once we're done here and we have any suggestions from the public or from the commission and we put that in the flow chart notes, then the last step in this process is bringing this in front of Town Council. I have a couple other changes proposed for Chapter 15 that I'm going to include with the loft language.
1:05:38 That'll probably be mid-summer, give or take. I have a consultant right now working on something unrelated for, they're evaluating our snow, wind, and seismic criteria, because that's very outdated, so they won't be done until June, but I want to get all this and package this up for the town council, so that'll be the last step in the process. So, having said that, I just take a few minutes here to walk through the flowchart and the notes. Hopefully this was fairly straightforward, and hopefully you can understand what I had in here, but
1:06:07 Starting from the top, does the dwelling unit have a loft or mezzanine used in it for residential sleeping purposes? Pretty straightforward, it's either yes or no. It's worth noting that footnote one will, you know, says that the code recognized term for a loft is a mezzanine, so if you hear the term mezzanine, it's the same thing as a loft. But also, kind of more importantly probably is how we enforce these standards here. And so the gist here is to, the enforcement from the town is only going to be for,
1:06:37 Applications for a business tax certificate where somebody wants to rent one of their units out on a transient basis as part of the quality of life ordinance. I and other people didn't feel it appropriate that we'd start chasing lofts through town as a generality. It didn't seem appropriate. So really this is going to be confined to, for enforcement purposes, for when we inspect and look for condo units or units that have lofts for a business tax certificate as part of the quality of life ordinance.
1:07:05 Tom, can I interrupt you for a second? Yes, please. Do the business tax certificates pertain only to homeowners wishing to rent on a transient basis or would someone wishing to rent long term also need to apply for a business tax certificate? You need a business tax certificate if you have more than two rental units. So if you own one and you're just renting it to someone, you don't need a business tax certificate, but if you have more than one, then you need a business tax certificate. So there could be cases where long term have a business tax certificate. Okay.
1:07:36 Yeah, good question. So, yes or no, if you don't have a loft, not a problem, we're done. If it does, then I just go down the flow chart here, then we go to kind of like the bigger, the bigger ticket issues, I call them, kind of the big items that really affect life and safety in a loft, is the loft have compliant existing stairs, handrails, ceiling heights, guards, and floor areas, and footnote two is basically going to prescribe standards that
1:08:03 It's really just, I picked and pulled from several prior older uniform building code standards.
1:08:33 to put that together, and I really just kind of went through and picked the most lenient items just to provide maximum flexibility for these existing lofts. So we have some standards, but they're code recognized, and they're definitely more lenient than what we're finding today, but they were the standards back when. As we go down, if you don't have those compliant items, then the loft can't be used for overnight sleeping purposes.
1:08:57 Alterations would be needed to bring these specific items to compliance with current codes. And as part of that, I have footnote 3. And I have also footnote 10 with that. Footnote 3 is a distinction of when you do an alteration or you do some remodel work. Current existing building and residential codes are pretty clear that the standards we find in the codes today govern those alterations. So they'd have to abide by those standards for if they wanted to remodel or alteration or addition work.
1:09:25 I also have footnote 10 in here, and this is what we call the net neutral revenue option, which essentially is if you have a loft that's noncompliant and people who can't do a remodel or alteration or it's infeasible, they can get those two people that would normally sleep in a loft like they do in a bedroom, and those two people could be relocated or redistributed somewhere else within that dwelling unit.
1:09:51 Other than loft, say another bedroom or maybe a living room or something such that there's no net decrease in the occupants that could stay in that unit. And the hope and the goal is that there's no loss of revenue because it's usually based on how many people you can get in a unit. So the number of people remain the same. But if we have a really bad loft or one that is illegal, those two occupants who would normally sleep in that loft would be redistributed somewhere else in that unit. So it's kind of a catch-all flexible.
1:10:20 So people aren't just precluded from using that unit or having a decrease in the number of documents that could use that unit. And it would just be on good faith that the loft is not being used for? No. Well, as we go on here, there's some more language that addresses that. If it came to be and somebody wanted to use that option, the fire protection district would put some signage up at the loft, kind of indicating that the loft can't be used for overnight sleeping purposes.
1:10:50 That would be noted in our records, you know, with our inspection records that we used to issue the business tax certificate. So it would be notation of that and some signage indicating that. And then they could continue to do that. And if they wanted to remodel or alter their loft so they can have a permanently safe or good loft, then they could, of course, they could do that when they're ready to do that. So you'll see footnote 10 kind of repeat here in this document as kind of a go-to or just another option for folks to be able to.
1:11:17 Not have a net decrease in revenue and headcount in their unit that they want to rent. So, it either does or doesn't have complying, you know, stairs and that kind of thing. If it does, or if it doesn't, you know, if it does not, then you have to do alterations or use the net neutral revenue solution. If it does and you move on, is there a room, the next box says, is there a room in the loft? Now, I had to roll this in because a lot of our lofts out there, I noticed when I looked at these things,
1:11:46 A lot of them have a room that's accessed through a loft. And it's been my observation that a majority of these lofts that have a room that's accessed through a loft appear to have been illegally bootlegged in. The most classic example is where somebody cuts, they have a loft and there's a wall and they know they have some dead space or some attic space and they'll cut in an opening and there you go, you have a room and they start using it for usually sleeping purposes. And the issue is that it's, you know, there's no escape rescue.
1:12:15 Among other things, you don't smoke detectors, that kind of thing. So it presents a hazard to life and safety. So I rolled in footnote. Is there room in the loft? No. You move on. If there is, then I put footnote five is criteria that kind of distinguishes what constitutes a legal bedroom versus a storage area. And this was kicked around some with the public vetting groups to see what is or what is not acceptable criteria for a bedroom.
1:12:42 Or storage area. You have some areas that are rooms that are used for storage. You have some little like nooks and little crawl spaces that are kind of used for storage. So I kind of made a distinction about what constitutes a storage room or sleeping room. As we move down, does a loft have a compliant escape rescue opening? This topic of an escape rescue opening seemed to be kind of a real sticking point initially with these lofts.
1:13:12 Do you or don't you need a window in these things for escape rescue? Well, the code does recognize a certain safety feature with the openness of a loft. Unlike an enclosed bedroom, a loft is open to below where the occupants have the ability to, with sight, smell, and sound, detect a hazard such as fire. They can smell the smoke. They can kind of see what's going on down there.
1:13:32 They can more readily hear things that are going on down there as opposed to an enclosed bedroom. And that's actually a code-recognized safety feature specific to mezzanines. So I keyed in on that and rolled in this prospect or this aspect of having the loft open to below or not. So if you do have an escape rescue window opening, your loft is okay. You have enough criteria to make it good. If you don't, then we start to look to see how open this thing is.
1:14:01 Half. And I chose half because through the 40 years of code development, lofts weren't required to be open. And then through the course of time, they were required to be open. So I just kind of chose 50, which is between 0 and 100. So if these things are 50% or greater open to below, if they are, then your loft is okay because there's other safety features that we have in there to make this loft safe. If not, then we go down the flow chart here.
1:14:29 And we start to look at other fire protection systems such as a fire sprinkler system. If it does, your loft is okay. That's the best fire protection system going is a residential fire sprinkler system. But a lot of condos don't have those. So if the answer is no, then we start to look at other fire code-recognized safety features. And street frontage, compliant street frontage, footnote 7 describes that in some more detail. That's the ability for a fire department truck or fire department
1:14:56 Vehicles to get close to a building, to use their hoses, to put a fire out, and to use their ladders for rescue. If they do have that compliant street frontage, then we've rolled in two other features that will make the loft safe. A reduced travel distance of no more than 100 feet, which is half of your code maximum allowed travel distance in a non-swinkler building. If you have that travel distance, and it's described more in footnote 9, combined with
1:15:24 Wireless or hardwired interconnected smoke and carbon monoxide sensors, the loft's okay. But if you don't have that travel distance, then the compliant escape rescue window would be required or the loft would require the removal of enclosing partitions to get you to that 50% of greater openness. I'd also mention that a lot of the lofts I looked at, a majority of them,
1:15:46 Looked like they were originally constructed and designed to be opened, but people through time came in and put these non-bearing, non-structural partitions into and closed them, maybe for privacy purposes or something like that. A lot of these folks could make their loft compliant by removing those partitions, and if they're non-structural, it's a pretty easy demolition thing to do. So I think a lot of lofts in town would benefit.
1:16:09 Benefit from the removal of those enclosing partitions to give you that openness, a lot of them would be legal just by doing that. So that was one of my discoveries when I was looking at these lofts. And I looked at, by the way, when I first hired like in May, almost a year, just about a year ago, I went on a tour with the fire department and also somebody from the real estate community and we looked at, I must have looked at the better part of 50 of these things since I've been in town. So, but that's been my observation. If you don't have street frontage,
1:16:39 Then you got the bad loft. You don't have much going for it. You don't have an openness. You don't have an escape rescue. You don't have a fire sprinkler system. You don't have street frontage. That's when you would need the escape rescue window, the removal of the enclosing partitions, or, again, we're back to this concept of using the net neutral revenue solution where you could redistribute those two people from that loft to another area within the dwelling unit. And so I hope
1:17:09 This all made sense. And that's pretty much what I have. And I'd turn it back to the Planning Commission for your comments and suggestions, if any, that you may have. I just initially want to, first of all, thank you for the work on this. And thank you for being so inclusive with the business community, the lodging association, the fire department, in putting this all together. Clearly, you've put a lot of time and effort into this. And, you know, from a person who
1:17:39 You know, maybe doesn't know if their loft is compliant or not. It's a pretty easy flowchart to follow. Yeah, I'd put it in a flowchart format for me to get my arms around it because there's so many moving parts and things going on. How do you tie all the stuff together? I just have a, I'd have a, I like looking at plans, that's what I do. So I like to see a graphic representation sometimes I think. So, so yeah, it really helped. Yeah, it's very intuitive, the process of following it down through to determine whether or not your loft is legal or not.
1:18:08 Job well done on this. Thank you. Yeah, I agree with Mike completely. I think this is a very, seems like a very well vetted kind of plan or document. The only question that I have is sort of related to the 50% openness. And was, did you have any discussion or thought as to how that really is treated differently for, you know, a loft that's 50 or 60 feet wide versus a loft that's 20 feet wide? And perhaps you need to, we need to add a,
1:18:38 A minimum or an up to number to give the owners a little bit more functionality. A minimum dimension. Yeah. That's a good thought. You know, it really wasn't addressed or brought up by any of the groups that we brought it up to. I just, it just seems like if there's a certain level of openness to the area below, if you got half, then
1:19:03 That seemed to, in our minds, represent a minimum degree of openness, no matter what that dimension is, so you can detect a hazard. So, was the thought, though, like, if you have, like, a really, like, short dimension, it should be open more, or, you know, there's... Well...
1:19:22 I don't know. I haven't been to see nearly as many of these lofts as you have. I mean, I can't imagine someone trying to rent a loft that's only 10 feet wide, but maybe you've come across something like that. I don't know. Where a five-foot wide opening would be the 50 percent, is that enough or not, in your opinion? Versus, you know, I have had the opportunity to actually work on a project where the loft is about 50, 60 feet wide, and in order for us to comply,
1:19:49 to the minimum openness, we needed to create an opening that was 25, 30 feet wide, which is pretty substantial and might be prohibitive to certain homeowners' desires. I don't know. Yeah, no, that's a good thought. You know, with the small lofts, you're gonna get to a point where, like the 10 foot wide loft, and it's in the footnotes here, but you need a minimum of 70 square feet.
1:20:15 Usable floor area minimum. That's been a code minimum for many years. So you get these little small offs. You know, you might have issues other than openness that could come into play if it's really small. Sure. But yeah, you get a big one, though, and it's like 40 foot wide. You got to take 20 feet out of that. Yeah, 50% openness could be a burden at that point. So the thought would be to have another alternative size opening. Because that's what we had in our original ordinance.
1:20:44 See, with the original ordinance, it's kind of ironic because that original ordinance called for at least 50% open, but it's for an entirely different purpose. It was for people to egress out of the loft in the event of a fire. And so our rationale was, if your stairs that get you to loft are completely consumed in flame,
1:21:03 We're pretty confident that the whole lower level there is going to be in the same state of fire. It's going to be engulfed. So it didn't make a whole lot of sense for someone to jump down to an area that's completely engulfed in flame. Okay, so the openness is not for egress or firefighter access. It's for detection of hazards. It's a different purpose. For perception of the... Correct. It's for detection of hazards, which is a completely different concept than what's been in our local code for years.
1:21:28 But yeah, I mean, and then in there too we had a 25 square foot opening. It was either half or 25 square foot minimum of an opening, whichever is greater. Unfortunately, that criteria came from natural light and ventilation requirements in the code. It had nothing to do with fire life safety or egress. But no, that's a good thought. That's something to consider about, you know, having like a minimum or an alternative size that would provide an equivalent that could be certainly discussed with folks.
1:21:58 Yeah, I made a note, yeah. No decision that you're going to make right here, but just something to think about. Yeah, I'll have to give it a little thought. This whole project has involved a lot of thought, so, yeah. But good point, good point. Thanks. How does compliance work on this, in terms of, do we, does it, building safety, then just start inspecting all the units and start issuing letters and say, okay, this is out? Not necessarily.
1:22:29 The process we have now is that when somebody applies for a business tax certificate to rent their unit on a transient basis, we have a private home inspector that we have on contract do that inspection. So the inspection process is independent of building staff with the town. The home inspector basically goes out with, you know, we have all this criteria that they check for.
1:22:52 And if some of the criteria is not met or there's deficiencies, they usually have that in an inspection report. And then they submit that to us and we do not issue the business tax certificate until the home inspector basically gives this unit a clean bill of health by way of a successful inspection that's passing all the criteria. So it's really kind of on an application basis where people are applying for business tax certificates to rent their unit.
1:23:20 And if it meets all the criteria, then they could use it. But no, building division staff, fire department staff aren't going to start going out and looking at these units and writing letters. I think that may have was happening maybe initially when this whole thing kind of broke, but that's not going to happen. That's not proposed at this point. I understand we're trying to be flexible, what you came up with here. It doesn't seem intuitive to me that
1:23:58 If we know if there are plenty of mezzanine levels that are not in compliance according to this particular standard that you have here, whether it's rented or not, they're not in compliance, which means it's a health and safety issue. Shouldn't we do something about
1:24:32 Trying to correct those issues, even though it's... So expand it beyond the quality of life ordinance? Correct. No, it's... Because you're saying that it's applying to... for transient overnight stays. And on top of that, it's if you have one unit you live in and you rent the other unit out, that doesn't apply to those guys.
1:25:02 Only for people that have two units, if you're renting both units out, right? Sandra, is that what you said earlier? Well, the question was about long-term rentals, right? But whether it's short-term or long-term. Yeah. So short-term rentals all require a business tax certificate, regardless. You may be just for one unit. Right. Correct. I think the question was about long-term. So it's a little bit different for long-term, but I think the focus is really probably the transient rentals. I guess what I'm saying is health and safety applies to everybody.
1:25:33 It's not just apply. It shouldn't apply just for the transient renters. Yeah, good point. And I'm not saying, and I understand, you know, certainly the financial impact or the manpower that's needed for something like this. But that's, you know, I feel maybe perhaps there's a way to resolve that, solve that problem in the future.
1:26:06 Right. That's a good point. I mean, you've got the same hazards that apply in a long-term rental or somebody who's not renting, just using it with their own family and friends. You know, you could have the same hazards do exist, or they can. The thought was that I think what really triggered this whole loft thing to start with, because these lofts have been out there for a long time, and people, you know, whether it be town or fire department staff, have known of some of these bad lofts, as we call them, for a long time.
1:26:35 It seemed that what really brought this to a head was us formally allowing people to use these lofts, where outside of or exclusive of the business tax certificate and the quality of life ordinance, people are just kind of doing it on their own, and we're not formally letting them use this unit. So it seemed to be kind of the consensus with the groups that they wanted this to be limited to the quality of life ordinance.
1:27:05 So are you sort of creating some connection to potential or perception of liability? Town's liability. Perception of town's liability where they have, you know, agreed to a business tax certificate to a certain place and they've come in and inspected and they've said, okay, you can rent this place. Should something happen in the future? Something, you know, try it.
1:27:31 Yeah. Something happened in the future. Is this sort of where this came from? There's a concern on that front, yes. There's a concern on that, yeah, yeah. If that's one of the concerns, well, why don't we just have the applicants sign, you know, as part of the application, sign an indemnification agreement of some sort. It's no different than when we pass the marijuana on-site grower, growing facility,
1:28:02 at the, in the commercial, in the commercial district. Mm-hmm. And we signed, the town, executing an indemnification agreement with the applicant that if the, you know, if somehow the, the feds decide to make a move. Ah. And that would alleviate the liability on the, on the town's part. Mm-hmm.
1:28:31 So the indemnification, if I could understand that, the indemnification would be an additional means of protection, or would that supplant or replace the inspection process? Yeah, essentially, for anybody who was applying for the application. Yeah, we had that at the county, actually. We didn't have an inspection process for our transient rentals there. It was basically a form that had all the conditions that you had to abide by, and then somebody would sign, I swear that I'll, you know.
1:29:02 Do X, Y, and Z, and A, B, and C, and then that was that. It's my understanding that is it went through the process here at the town. Maybe Sandra can comment in more detail because this all went down before I was here, but it sounded like the council may have wanted a higher level of scrutinization on that. Yeah, the council was clear as we went through the quality of life ordinance process that they wanted inspections to occur because we suggested originally to have something similar to the county where the applicant would just sign.
1:29:30 Kind of sign off saying that they comply with the requirements and the council was clear that they wanted inspections to occur. So that's why we have the inspection process and that was really, as Tom stated previously, kind of what started the discussion on lofts because we got out there and started seeing a lot of these lofts that didn't comply. So being related to the quality of life ordinance, it's really an effort to, I don't know if guarantee is the right word, but
1:30:02 The quality of a product for which the town is granting a business tax certificate, I think that that then could give a potential renter a level of assurance that the town has enforced their quality of life ordinance and that this potential renter is getting a product at a certain level. Yeah. Which is not related to the liability issue whatsoever. Yeah, it's really, I'd say it's more that.
1:30:30 It's just kind of ensuring that what we're formally allowing people to use is meeting some minimum criteria for safety. You know, with the liability thing, you know, as building official, I could come up with what's known as an alternative method, means of construction. I'm allowed to prescribe an alternative to what maybe you find in the black-white language of the code. It just happened that what we have on the books now is really just, it just really didn't address a lot of the stuff.
1:30:58 But I'm allowed to do that. So yeah, beyond liability, I think more so than liability, it's just delivering a safe product to the public that we're formally issuing a license for them to use. How many applications are out there? Oh, I don't know. I couldn't tell you that right now. I don't know. But I do get calls on it. I get a lot of calls, actually, from realtors and homeowners kind of asking questions about lofts. So they're out there.
1:31:24 They don't hesitate to call, and it's my pleasure to answer the calls, but I can't tell you how many applications we have issued this year or how many we have pending, I don't know. Thank you. Did you find in the units you've looked at so far, whether it's due to the original framing or whatever, that these tend to be concentrated in certain condo complexes versus others? Not certain complexes, but a certain time frame, the 1970s. But the vast majority of condos were built in the 70s, and it seemed like
1:31:55 There's like, I want to say 2,000 plus condo units that are built in just the 70s alone. Almost half. And a lot of them, I'll tell you, I mean, I've seen a mishmash of like what appears to be bootlegged and original, but I walk in a lot of units and I gotta duck so I don't hit my head on a ceiling beam. A lot of these have exposed, you know, sawn lumber roof beams.
1:32:18 And some of them are really low. I mean, you have to, you either have to duck or be like a five-year-old kid to be able to safely negotiate your way through them. Some I've seen have carpet wrapped around the beam so it just doesn't hurt as much when you hit your head on the beam. Literally, I've seen that more than once. So, yeah, you have a lot of originally constructed units that were built that way and it's frustrating. You know, it's, it is why we have an inspection process. I mean, just to kind of, if anything, catch some of this.
1:32:46 Real straightforward fire life safety stuff, but yeah, a lot of them were built originally and primarily in the 70s, but no real, not concentrated in certain units. It seems like a time frame more so than really kind of location. Any questions or comments from the public? Yeah. Do you mind stepping up to the podium so those of us who are watching the recorded session can hear you? And state your name, please.
1:33:21 Debbie Crowe. I just wanted to know how often are the inspections done or is it strictly done on new applications? So if you've been in business for decades and you applied years ago for your business tax certificate, you know, are those inspections being done regularly every few years or only for new ones, applications? Thank you. Good question.
1:33:50 I'll have Sandra back me up on this, but I want to say it's a one-time deal through our inspection process where they come out and do the inspection one time. They might do a re-inspection if you have deficiencies, but once those deficiencies are, once they have compliance with the stuff that's on the checklist or on our criteria, that's pretty much it. And then they issued the tax certificate, and we typically don't go back. And then...
1:34:15 The Fire Protection District, and this is real normal for fire departments, but they'll do periodic inspections once every couple years on units just to kind of make sure they've got the basics.
1:34:26 Beyond that, no, we don't have a recurring or repetitive inspection process of the town for these things. The trigger, so just to clarify, the trigger is the business, a new business tax certificate. So if you've had a unit for 20 years, you've been renting it, you're just renewing your business tax certificate, that wouldn't trigger an inspection. If you transferred, maybe if you had someone else represent you, where they had to get a new business tax certificate, TOT certificate, that would trigger that. So we do have a clause in there that limits it to only one inspection every three months.
1:34:55 So if someone moves around and has different people representing them over the years, we would only trigger that inspection once every three years. But that's really when it's triggered, is at the new business tax certificate time. No, no further questions up here. I think you've done a great job. I think it's very useful. Thanks. And I'll take your points. No, I'll definitely consider your points. I thought they were a good one. So I'll definitely consider those and have a discussion with...
1:35:32 The various people that have been involved in the process, so thank you. So what is your process then from here? Does this? It'll be, the town council's the next step. Okay. What I'm going to do is I have this and then I have to put the language in chapter 15, which the footnotes are really going to help be. I mean, I kind of did two things at once. The footnotes help explain the flow chart, but it.
1:35:58 A lot of ways in the footnotes will probably appear as amended language in Chapter 15. And so the next step is to bring that in front of Town Council and have them consider it, and they'll either adopt it or they won't. But it'll be for a formal adoption process with the Town Council. That'll be the next step.
1:36:16 Just to clarify, only the zoning code requires a recommendation of the commission to council, so changes to other sections of the municipal code can just go straight to council, so that's what we'll do for this one. It'll be a public meeting in front of the council. Great. I'd also mention, too, now that I think of it, that a change will have to be made to the quality of life ordinance to reflect the net neutral revenue solution, because right now it's not structured that way. It's only two and a bedroom plus two additional.
1:36:44 So that there's going to have to be a modification of the quality of life ordinance to affect that because that's not in place right now in the ordinance. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. Moving on to item number four, business matter to consider approval of time extension request 17-001 for the Tejana Townhomes entitlement. And our staff contact is Nolan. Great. Thank you.
1:37:34 Time extension request 17-001 is requesting a six-year time extension for the Tijana Townhomes entitlement, which was approved by the Planning Commission in January 2008. The Tijana Townhomes project
1:37:48 Located at 48 Lupin Street, proposed to subdivide the approximately half-acre parcel into nine planned unit development units for the construction of nine residential units within four townhome structures. There would be two parking spaces per unit in understructure parking and five guest parking spaces for a total of 23 spaces.
1:38:08 The property owner recently purchased this property and the adjacent property and has requested the time extension to allow them additional time to determine what type of project and design best suits the subject property and have been doing their due diligence in researching all available options for the site, including looking at the project approved by the Tejana Townhomes entitlement. The entitlement for this project included a vesting tentative tract map,
1:38:35 which provide certain vested rights, including the vesting of the development standards and policies that are in place at the time the project application was deemed complete. Those vested rights remain so long as the project entitlement remains valid, which means if a building permit plans for the approved project were to be submitted and the entitlement was still valid, they would be reviewed using the standards that were in place at the time the project was originally approved.
1:39:02 Additionally, pursuant to the California Government Code, subsequent time extensions for a vesting tentative map are afforded those vested rights, and in order for the local agency to deny or impose additional conditions, the local agency would need to determine that one, failure to deny the extension or impose additional conditions would place the community in danger, or two, the condition or denial
1:39:30 and is required to comply with state or federal law. Neither of those conditions are present for this request. Staff has determined that the findings required for the time extension request can be made and recommend approval of time extension request 17-001 for the Tejana townhomes entitlement.
1:39:52 This approval would extend the expiration date of the entitlement to January 23, 2023. No additional time extensions beyond that date could be granted. With that, I'm available for any questions the commission might have. You said the applicant had just purchased the property? Yeah, within the last year they purchased the property. It was right at the end of kind of 2016. That group...
1:40:23 Has built other projects in town, and they really specialize in affordable and mixed-use residential development projects, so something similar to what this entitlement approved originally. I'm not sure when they purchased the adjacent property. I don't know if that was at the exact same time or after. It wasn't before that, I know, though. Was our applicant here today? Is this your project? No, he's here for the next one. The applicant was unable to make it.
1:41:05 The applicant is looking to move forward? From what I've been told by Mark Carney, he's the attorney representing, they are actively looking and studying the market, what makes sense for this project, so from what I can tell, they have every intention of building something on this parcel. I understand that because this is a vesting tentative tract map, that
1:41:41 It was approved based on the codes and policies in place at the time. Correct. So it's based on the codes that were in place when the application was deemed complete, which was March 2007. 2007. Just out of curiosity, can you tell us what, if anything, has significantly changed since then that would affect this site? Sure. So for this site, they had...
1:42:08 There are two municipal code sections that have changed since it was approved. One at the time, studio and one-bedroom units in this zoning district were counted as a half unit for density, meaning that for this site they're allowed 12 units per acre. Using that half unit, this project is considered to be 12 units per acre. Where under the current conditions,
1:42:38 I didn't do the math, but I think it would be, no, so it would be approximately 15 units per acre, if my math is right, or 18 units per acre under the current code, because all the units would be counted as one. Okay. And then the other change is. So they took advantage of that and proposed some studio one bedroom units. Correct. So they did take advantage of that.
1:43:02 Allowance for the half unit of density. And the other change is for how height is calculated. When this was approved, residential multifamily structures with understructure parking were allowed to go to 45 feet. And under the current code, understructure parking up to a height of 7 feet 6 inches is basically excluded from the building height. So under the current code,
1:43:29 This project would be, I think, at 39 feet, and it's 35 feet is what's permitted under the current zoning. 35 is? What's currently allowed, and this would be considered to be 39 and a half feet. Okay. So they're at a slight advantage as far as density and height because it's a vesting tentative tract map. Correct. The vesting locked those development standards in place.
1:43:54 And the intent of vesting is so that there is some guarantee for developers when they move forward to know what standards they're going to be held to. So in this case, it's one of those examples where when standards change, they're still able to use those standards that they design their project to. Okay. But that only applies to the TTM.
1:44:14 It applies to the vest, any, the kind of entire project entitlement, because essentially the vesting map is at the top, and then the subsequent approvals fall under that vesting tentative map. But that doesn't apply to building codes? No, building and fire codes are not vested, so any project that came in has to comply with all the building and fire codes that are currently in place. And can you just explain for us, since I don't think we've had a vesting tentative tract map in a while, what is difference?
1:44:43 What the difference is to the applicant for the process of vesting a tentative tract map versus not? I can start and then I might ask Sandra to provide additional input. So really the vesting, it's one, they have to request it. Then as far as the review and stuff and the analysis, it's really looking at what those standards are, if there's anything that might change in the near future, but it's...
1:45:10 Not necessarily held to a higher standard, but it does get scrutinized further up by staff. So we can put additional requirements on the map as well. Usually those are public works requirements. So there's things that you're limited to when it's just a tract map. Certain things you can't condition, can't require. And the vesting allows the town to place additional conditions, additional requirements on that map.
1:45:38 Because the life of the map is, or because it's vested under our requirements. And I don't know, Public Works isn't here, but I'm not sure if there were any conditions that were placed additionally on this project that wouldn't have been placed on it if it was a regular tentative tract map or not. Okay. So it's possible that there were some additional conditions, but you're not sure right now. That's really what the, yeah, what the difference is. Okay. Okay. Has staff received any public comment?
1:46:14 We have not, no. Application was submitted and no comments. It was routed to the groups and nothing was provided by any of the agencies that normally review projects. I have no additional comments. No? There's no comments from the public? Okay. I'll make motion. That sounds great. You're the motion man tonight. That's right.
1:46:51 I'd like to make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approve the time and extension request 17-001 with condition recommended by staff. I would like to second the motion. Vote, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much, Nolan. And moving right along, item number 5.
1:47:24 Considering approval of time extension request 17-002 for vesting tentative parcel map 10-001 and use permit 10-001. And once again, Nolan. Great, thank you.
1:47:40 Time extension request 17-002 is requesting a six-year time extension for VTPM 10-001 and UPA 10-001, which was approved by the Planning Commission in May 2011. The project approved the subdivision of a 4.39-acre parcel into four lots for the future development of single-family homes. No structural designs were proposed as part of the project.
1:48:08 Additionally, the use permit was required because a portion of the property is located within the snow deposition design avalanche overlay zone and the conditions of approval are meant to alleviate any impacts or hazards with regards to avalanche danger as a result of this project. Due to the uniqueness of this project, there are numerous conditions of approval imposed on the project in order to enhance access to the public lands adjacent to the project and improve the general circulation in the area.
1:48:38 Thus far, the property owner has provided funding for transit stop improvements in the area, built a protective fence around the historic cemetery headstones, constructed a temporary four-foot-wide public path, and submitted draft plans for the permanent 10-foot-wide public path, and protected the adjacent property from damage by constructing a retaining wall along the property lines.
1:49:03 The applicant has continued to work with staff on the remaining subdivision improvements and requests the extension so they can continue this work and move towards actual construction of the project. Again, since this project included that vested tentative map, it is afforded certain protections and guarantees as far as the rights with development.
1:49:27 Different on this project, none of the conditions or requirements for this zone have changed since the project was approved, so there is nothing unique as far as that approval goes. Again, though it does have that protection as far as imposing additional conditions on the project, where we're really limited in what, or pretty much can't impose any additional conditions unless it's required by law or required to protect the public.
1:49:55 And then staff has determined that the findings required for the time extension request can be made and recommend approval of time extension request 17-002 for the project entitlements. This approval would extend the expiration date of the entitlement to May 11, 2023. Again, no additional time extensions beyond that date could be granted. And the applicant, Josh Plum.
1:50:22 He's part of the property owners, is here to answer any questions. Okay. Do you have anything to say off the bat here? Okay. Any questions? Greg? Are we, when it was first considered the parcel one, as we're not under any liability, is the town saying that that's a viable buildable parcel if it's in an avalanche area? No. So this map, when it came in, included
1:50:58 Studies done by avalanche experts as part of the use permit looking at, one, the hazards associated with the area and building in that area, and then again, similar to, I think, Commissioner Chang brought it up earlier, the town basically removes all liability as part of the conditions from impacts or hazards from that avalanche or any guarantee that it's buildable in that area.
1:51:26 So we essentially indemnify ourselves or indemnify the town as part of that condition. And how does that 10-foot pedestrian access or non-motorized access, how does that line up with what people traditionally used in the past? I might let Josh talk further on this or I don't know if Hayes. Hayes was going to step in as far as any public works items. So currently the four-foot path, when you go out there, kind of snakes to the...
1:51:57 I'm not positive if that is going to be the alignment of the permanent 10-foot path. I'm not sure if you know Josh. I'm Josh Plum. So basically you can kind of see on the eastern edge of the property is the roadway, which is a private driveway. And the multi-use path, the permanent one, will lie inside that.
1:52:28 Private driveway. And it's pushed all the way to the east to get it out of the avalanche zone as most as possible. So that deposit people onto the next property, approximately where the current... It connects the... Because we actually, we own the two adjacent properties to the north that connect to Tamarack Street. So the whole project, we're actually building one handicapped spot.
1:52:57 at the top of Tamarack Street, and then it's an ADA compliant trail that goes all the way from Tamarack and connects all the way to the south to the Forest Service lands. Is that clear? I just want to make sure you weren't going to end up. No. It changes a little bit from where the temporary path is now, but it lies within the roadway. Great.
1:53:29 Any other questions for me? I know that you've executed some of the items in the last several years, but it sounds like your plan is to continue moving forward? Yes. Okay. Great. I'm happy. We put a lot of work into this. Great. Appreciate it. I don't have any questions. I don't either. All right. So I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PEC resolution making that requires SQL and municipal code.
1:54:01 findings, and approved time extension request 17-002, with conditions recommended by staff. I'll second the motion. Jamie, another vote, please. Mr. Chair? Yes. Mr. Chair? Yes. Mr. Schroeder
1:54:29 To our consent agenda, which consists of minutes from the meeting of April 12, 2017, minutes from the meeting of November 9, 2016, and the final tract map, 16-002 for Gray Bear 3. The only thing I noticed, Jamie, I just wanted to mention real quick, at the very beginning of the minutes for November 9, 2016, there's some confusion where it states that Michael was both present and absent.
1:55:01 Just want to confirm, Michael, that... Evil twin. I was absent. You were indeed absent? On the November meeting, correct. The rest of the minutes reflect a 3-0 count, so I think we're okay with those. Does anyone have anything they want to... No, I don't. ...pull or discuss? Okay. Would you entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda? I can do that. I would like to make a motion to approve the consent agenda, items 6, 7, and 8. I'll second it.
1:55:34 All right. Roll call vote. All in favor? Aye. That's your job. I'm sorry. I did. My mistake. All in favor? Aye. All right. Consent agenda is passed. All right. Commissioner reports. Greg, do you want to start with any comments? I stopped going to Denver last week and I stopped coming back in Breckenridge, Aspen, and Snowmass and talked to there.
1:56:10 Were there common problems that you saw thread their way through each
1:56:41 Peer resort. Not enough dirt, not enough wages. So not enough space to build? Not enough space to build, and especially, you know, like the problem we have here, there's business owners and service people, not a whole lot in between. So it's kind of hard to find a soccer coach when you're. Dishwashers working four jobs. Right. Yeah. So that sounds like it's related to the work on the housing. I don't know if it...
1:57:12 Task Force is the right word, but the committee or? Yeah, just try to get some background on other folks. That's great. Well, thank you for reaching out to them. Great. All? I'll just jump in really quick. I don't know if you all saw the video that was bouncing around town yesterday, the Caltrans video of the plow, the progress of the plow of Tioga Pass. It definitely lent some perspective to the job they've got ahead of them.
1:57:45 The date I'm hearing is probably a little bit closer to the beginning of July than the end of June at this point. Now, having said that, June might turn abnormally warm, might melt that off a little bit quicker, but they're dealing with issues besides just the snow depth. They're dealing with structural damage to the road, debris, backflows of avalanches that are coming down behind the plowed areas.
1:58:11 You know, obviously the opening of Tioga Pass is a very, very big deal to our summer and fall business, and there's a lot of lodging partners out there that are seeing a large amount of cancellations because of the closure to Tioga Pass, but we've created kind of a one-page handout that we've given to lodging and to our business partners here in town, as well as Mono County, and to visit California.
1:58:38 Stating what we think would be a little bit of a silver lining with Tioga being closed at the moment. It lets you go on an alternate route to Yosemite. It may add a little bit of time, but it'll let you see some of the other highlights on Highway 395 as you go north, explore some new and different parts of California to add to kind of an iconic California road trip. So we're hoping it is a lemonade out of lemons kind of situation, but we'll see.
1:59:08 Ben, any discussions amongst, from the town about possibly being involved in clearing the snow or maintenance? That would be a little bit more haze, I think, than me.
1:59:23 Hayes left, or he's not here, but I think that we had talked about it, but I don't think it's something that we can do. We're going to be tied up trying to clear the Lakes Basin. Right. And the Reds Meadow Road. I know it's Forest Service. Right. I think Mono County may be able to provide some assistance. I think I've heard that. I don't know if that's for sure at this point. We're going to be up there Monday for some sort of behind-the-gate tour.
1:59:51 Hard hats and goggles and the whole thing to kind of get a bird's eye view of what's actually going on up there and the reality of the challenge of moving all that snow. So it should be interesting. But as you said, just getting the Lakes Basin access roads clear is going to be tough as well. I know some of the Mammoth Mountain snow placement crew did participate in at least a preliminary meeting with the National Park Service about the possibility of assisting with
2:00:21 It's not our removal. But it wasn't quite clear whether that was going to move forward or not. I don't know. Tom, do you know anything about that? Okay. I did hear from several sources that Caltrans didn't want our help. But that's fine. Just let them do their thing. Yeah. Yeah, after the gate. So we will see. It's an interesting year.
2:00:54 So I don't think we've had a design committee meeting since the last commission meeting. However, we do have one scheduled for tomorrow morning, first thing, to discuss the potential grocery outlet project on Old Mammoth Road across from Wright-Aid. And in addition to that on the agenda is the new sign for shelter distilling at the village. So they are moving right along with their application and trying to get open.
2:01:25 Gosh, other things going on, just my general sort of professional experience seems like it's going to be a busy construction year around town here, not just because the economy is, you know, slowly but steadily improving, but because of our record winter, we've got a lot of damage, a lot of maintenance that's going to need to be done.
2:01:52 If you have any projects that you have in mind for your house or for your business or whatever, start talking to a contractor now. Because they're likely all booked through August anyway. But that's good news, I think, for the community. That's about it for me. Next week we'll have some more info about the design committee meetings. Sandra?
2:02:18 So the multi-use facility EIR will go to the town council next week on May 17th. And the only other item I had was the minimum flow rate ratio was somewhat on hold. We're waiting for direction from the council to bring it back. So originally it was going to go in April and then it was going to go next week. So we'll let the commission know when we do move forward with it. But at this time it's on hold.
2:02:46 And that's all I have, unless there's any questions. On hold, meaning the next council meeting is not going to be on the... No, it won't be next week. So we're waiting for direction from the council. Because where we left it at the joint meeting was there were some requests from the group, some analysis that was...
2:03:09 requested information that the group needed, and the council asked for us to bring kind of a summary of all of that and ask for direction from the council on moving forward with that. At this point, we haven't received additional requests from council to bring it back, so we're kind of in a waiting pattern on minimum flow rate ratio. Okay. What's our schedule for June? Let's see.
2:03:36 There are a couple items. The grocery outlet will be coming before you. It's design review. We think we may have two use permits for medical marijuana grow in the industrial park down in our industrial area. So there's two that have been submitted. We're working to see if we can get those to you in June. So it should be a normal meeting, I would expect. A few other applications that are coming in for on-site.
2:04:03 This is for, yeah, down in the industrial bark cultivation. So extraction or grow, like? I think it's, the applications just came in, I haven't had a chance to look at them yet, but I think it, I'm assuming it is related to extraction as well, right? Now, I know a few months back when we heard that case, the wholesale cultivator, one of the, I believe one of the commissioners here talked about the number of
2:04:40 Growers that we can have in the wholesale growers that we can have in that in that district and and that we would maybe we would look to town councils to see you know if there's any feedbacks on that and given that we currently don't have a limit we have limits for two dispensaries here in town but we
2:05:12 Don't have a limit for wholesale cultivators. Or we don't have a limit for recreational outlets. So in other words, if somebody wanted to open a recreational marijuana store, we currently have a cap on medical at two. We don't have any sort of cap on recreational at this point.
2:05:38 Is that correct? Yeah, in the town, we conducted a public, some public outreach a couple weeks back, got some input from the public, and our intent is to bring, bring that back to the commission, and I think that's in June. Nolan, now that you're back, the status for the medical marijuana, or I'm sorry, just marijuana, recreational marijuana changes, are we going to bring that back to the commission next month for a workshop, or was it July?
2:06:08 I need to look at the final kind of schedule and timing and whether I'm going to be in town in June or not, but come to a workshop and then likely probably public hearing in July with council in August and then full adoption in September. If it does go public workshop, then hearing it all get kind of pushed back one month. So then the commission public hearing would be August and the council public hearings would be September. So we will be bringing it before you as a workshop to discuss.
2:06:37 Providing you with the information that we heard at the public meeting and then getting your input on how we should craft the ordinance. So is it prudent for us to consider those two applications in June? Right now our code, we can't hold them to future code changes so we have to...
2:07:00 Process them under the existing code requirements that we have in place right now. So we can't push them and not process them. Similar to kind of the grocery outlet, we're processing the grocery outlet under the standards in place at the time. And, you know, at this point, minimum FAR is kind of pushed, but there were some concerns, you know, that minimum FAR, when would that be triggered and those types of things. We could do a moratorium, though. We could do a moratorium? To postpone the tenure rules.
2:07:30 That's true. We could do moratorium. The council could. The council, right. Okay. Do you have any idea when the arts, the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center might come to design committee and commission?
2:07:50 Have you heard anything? No, I mean, I think they're still looking for funding. We've been talking to them about the environmental process, those types of things, but at this point we haven't received an application. I think they're trying to firm up all of their funding before they submit to the town and incur additional expenses preparing environmental work. Okay, so you haven't received any documents or reviewed their design for compliance with the code or anything yet? Okay.
2:08:18 This is just on the wall. I know Bruce is familiar with the town requirements, so not too worried. And then should the town council certify the FAIR for the multi-use facility and give staff direction to move forward with the project? Is the next steps on that coming to design committee and commission?
2:08:42 Yes. Yeah. Design review. We'll put together grading plans, probably concurrently as with the design review. And then once the design review is completed, we'll move forward with building plans, construction plans for it. Okay. We will see. Great. Anything else? Okay. Well, with that, we will adjourn our meeting to our next regular...
2:09:11 Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting to be held on June 14, 2017 at 2 o'clock p.m. here in Suite Z. Thank you all very much. Thank you. Thank you.