TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2017

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 10 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

279 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 So let's see if there's something we can do.

0:27 Thank you.

0:36 Just don't say it.

1:05 Okay, if everybody is ready. Do I hit this first? Okay. We'll be calling to order the town council meeting. Hello, we are starting the meeting. Thank you. August 16th, 2017. Roll call, please, Ms. Jamie Gray. Here.

1:43 Here. Here. Here. And he is out politicking in Washington for us, so he is absent. So now, if we could have Shields Richardson lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Please stand and face the flag. Repeat after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible,

2:15 With liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Shields. And now is the time for public comment. So if anybody out there has something that they would like to say, please approach. Good evening, Madam President, council members, staff, members of the community. Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Witness Protection Program failed. Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

2:44 Word of thanks this evening for your support of the Belusa event a week ago that provided another economic boost to the community. The Woodside is a wonderful amenity for this community to be used as an outdoor event venue. We all look forward to working with the new owner to schedule the venue at reasonable cost to each of the producers. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation has a simple mission to support higher education and cultural enrichment in the eastern Sierra.

3:10 We appreciated the opportunity to partner with the Blues team in requesting donations for parking from festival patrons on Meridian Boulevard for the event. It also enhanced an element of public safety with the street being shut down with controlled access for festival attendees. That weekend, we raised almost $5,000 for student scholarships and high school sports programs in partnership with the Rotary Club of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lake High School Boosters Club. We are thankful to the community.

3:38 For their support of our organizations and our youth, and we remind ourselves that mammoth greatness is the only option. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. Thank you, Council, for giving me the opportunity to talk a little bit about accessibility in this community. Okay, excuse me, I'm sorry, what is your name? Stephen Cantu, C-I-N-T-U. Okay, thank you. And I've been coming up to the eastern Sierras for 20 years, and just...

4:09 Last nine years, bought a place up at the Lakes Basin. I've been trucking around this town the last few years in the winter and in the summer. And accessibility issues are something that I seem to be involved in for the 30-some years that I've been in a chair. And I've noticed in this town there's a lot of small things that would just make my ability to get around a lot easier. One of them is, of course, maintenance.

4:37 Trails and so on that I've seen. And after this tough winter, there are some issues, but you guys know that. And I've also noticed within the community, the different businesses that I go to, there are some very small fixes that can be done. And I would like to see or like the community to get involved in some of these things. In particular, maybe the council can start looking at a program where contractors who have extra materials and church groups or city groups.

5:07 Who have some volunteer activities can look at these successful issues and maybe work with some small businesses and mom-and-pop businesses who can't necessarily have the funds to do these things and just get some small ramps built. Start small and start chipping away at the issues. With the Wounded Warrior Program coming into town, it would be very nice, I would think, for them to look at this town and go home and say, look what they're doing.

5:37 This is really a high-class community. And we can get around, we can go to the restaurants without worrying about restrooms or not worry about being pulled up ramps or manhandled by staff who aren't trained for such things. And even some of the businesses that these people don't go to, like me as a homeowner up in the Lakes Basin, I go into different, say, paint stores or into...

6:07 Different centers in the high country. And there's always issues. And ramps are a big issue. And I understand the snow load and all this sort of stuff. But in a couple businesses in town, it's pretty iffy. And you guys really need to look at it and try to develop a program that provides accessibility for everybody. And being an aging community where we're all temporarily able, these things need to look at. Mom in a stroller.

6:36 Some worker pulling things up into a business or me in my chair. Once you get the ramps in, you get the stuff in, it's all that much easier for everybody else. So that's basically my mantra and I'll be happy if any city council member wants to go around town with a guy in a chair and point things out or even get into a chair and follow me around and see the issues, I'm available. So guys, have had it.

7:06 Thank you. Okay, thank you. Thank you. And my phone number is on the town website, and I would love to get a call from you at some point and go out and look. Yeah, she can give you my phone number. Or, yeah, if you want to leave your phone number, I'll do that. Thank you. Okay, do we have anybody else that would like to make a public comment at this time? Good evening, Council. Ken Bringle, Executive Director of the...

7:44 Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Wanted to make sure I reintroduced myself. Just wanted to say that the chamber's board has finished its strategic planning session and one of the things that came out besides continuing some of the efforts we're working on, which of course is customer service training, the business assistance.

8:11 We're also looking at more engagement from our membership. And so our third goal was to really start to capitalize on the human capital that is available through our membership. We have five committees now, and we are going to request our members to actively serve on each committee. And so we're in the process of putting that together. You'll see more about that in the near future. But the board is pleased with

8:40 The direction we're going. So we've got some good things that are hopefully going to move forward. So I just wanted to let you know about that. Thank you. Anybody else chomping at the bit to talk about something not on the agenda? With that, we will close public comments. And anybody, council, have any additions to the agenda? No. Okay. I have switched

9:13 A little bit, we're going to do reports from the department before the, from departments before the public presentation. So, that would be Grady, whenever you're ready. Thank you. Just real quick, the staff, Mike's not working very well, so I'll project as best I can and hopefully we'll get picked up as well. We'll do the best we can before it gets resolved. Staff actually asked if this item could be held.

9:41 Thanks, Grady. First, I'd like to invite all the public to a Red's Meadow Road Environmental Impact Report scoping meeting.

10:10 Scheduled for September 7th here at Suite Z at 5 p.m. We'll go over the EIR findings and so forth with the public. This meeting was scheduled over a month ago, but it turns out the timing was perfect. We received notice just the other day that the town is the recipient of $24 million in flat...

10:30 Funding to complete the restoration of Reds Meadow Road. We were here well over a year ago asking direction from Council to move forward with the application.

10:40 Through the hard work and dedication and commitment of our various partners, we actually came through and received the grant. There was something like $30 million on the table for California and we received $24 million of it. And I really need to emphasize how much we appreciate working with Eastern Sierra Transit, Mono County, Mono County LTC, National Park Service, and U.S. Forest Service. Without them, we would never have received this money.

11:08 Really want to thank them for all their hard work. The grant that was finally approved includes realignment and widening of the upper 2.5 miles. 5.8 miles on the lower section will be completely rehabilitated, removed, and repaved. The work is scheduled for 2022 as it stands right now. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Yeah. Wait, let me push my button.

11:40 In the interim, the five years prior to this, how does the maintenance and the open and close of that road work? Continue as the same with Forest Service? Nothing changes until the road is completed and...

11:59 And all the work is completed. We'll take over the road as part of our commitment as the grant. In the interim, we'll just continue to work with the Forest Service to clear snow, put band-aids on the road to keep it open, and do the best we can to allow the public down there as we have in the past. There is no changes in access perceived. If there's a catastrophic failure on the road, which could happen, is there a way to bring this timeline, an emergency or piece of it up to deal with that?

12:27 That's a question we're going to ask, but I do not know the answer to that. If we have a catastrophic failure of the road, we're going to have to work with the Forest Service to find a solution. Maybe there's an opportunity here, we don't know, but we do know after this last winter that we do have some serious issues on that road and some potential failure locations that we'll have to keep a close eye on, and that's a reality of where we're at with this road project.

12:53 And for both you and the Forest Service, I'm assuming that when the completion of the road is done, 23 or whenever in my lifetime, then the opening and closing of the road, does that continue to be a Forest Service or is that going to be a more collaborative? Right now it is up to them when it opens, when it closes. Is it Town Road? Does that change? Or are we still under there?

13:15 Direction in terms of when you can open and close. So it'll still be, in my perspective, a collaborative effort because everybody needs to be prepared for the opening. We will have more authority to do work on the road, maintain the road, open the road, do snow removal, things of that nature under the deed that we'll receive once we accept the road. Thank you. That's all from me. I just say great work. Thank you very much for making that happen. When I saw...

13:43 Thank you. Yeah, congrats.

14:00 Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. A couple quick notes. Tomorrow night, we will be having a housing tools identification and prioritization meeting. This is the Mammoth Lakes housing project for the housing action plan. So tomorrow night, they'll be looking at, like I said, the tools, the housing tools, and that'll be here in Suite Z from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. If you would like to review any of the materials for the meeting, like the...

14:30 Thank you.

14:47 From 3 to 5 here in Suite Z. This will be to discuss the draft development agreement for the Old Mammoth Place Project, which is where Rafters, Jimmy, and the Sierra Nevada Resort is right now.

15:00 And we will likely have consideration of the DA by the Planning and Economic Development Commission on September 13th at their regularly scheduled meeting. The draft DA will be provided to the Commission, Council, and the public next Friday, August 25th. And finally, there is another joint Council Commission meeting on Wednesday, September 6th at 3 o'clock to discuss walk, bike, ride action items as well as downtown revitalization. And that will be here in Suite Z as well.

15:29 Any questions? Thank you. Thank you, Stan. Good evening. Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation. It's been a little while. I'm just going to give you a brief update on the department. Very timely that school went back today, which kind of signifies the end of kind of our main parks and recreation summer camps and programs. We haven't really done a lot of the analytics yet and the numbers, but another busy summer. It could be record-setting. We'll inform you about that later. Pool visits were definitely up, so we saw a lot of visitation there.

16:06 Whitmore Pool closes. If you're still looking to lap swim or swim down in the pool, we'll close on September 1st. So that's just before Labor Day. And just briefly, a quick update. Also just running through the submittal of the Inclusive Playground Grant. We were able to submit that yesterday on time. Just want to personally thank our grant writing team of Chair Betsy Truax and Lauren Plum, our coordinator. We feel very...

16:30 Optimistic about the opportunity for the town to receive the funding. It's up to $100,000, and Stephen's here tonight, which is great, and that would be, if we do receive the grant funding, that would be a fully inclusive playground at Mammoth Creek Park, so that would be a great asset for the community, so we'll know about that on September 2nd. We'll come back then.

16:51 Deferred Maintenance Program, Council awarded upwards of $300,000 for that program. A lot of that money is being committed. You've committed previously to the Shady Rest Snack Shack, so that's going to commence work at the end of the month. Tonight you'll also look at awarding the bid for the concreting work, which is also Shady Rest Park, and also that is a big part of the Commission's focus and certainly their priority on compliance.

17:21 You know, with their bleachers, public safety, and again, accessibility. So that project is going to provide ADA access to all the ball fields, as well as a volleyball pit, full ADA accessible bleachers as well, and then ADA access to the pavilion as well. So very timely. So that's a big part of what the town's trying to do to keep up with our inclusive nature of our parks and programs.

17:47 Just a real brief commission update. The commission next regular meeting is September 5th, but we've scheduled a special meeting on August 25th. And that special meeting we're bringing in our recreation programming committee that work with us on the playbooks for the Mammoth Creek Park West project. So we're going to run through an update with that group, bring them up to speed on the project and encourage them to advocate as the project moves forward and help us, you know, get on the street.

18:16 Be good ambassadors of that program and that project. We'll also have a special meeting on September 7th, which is kind of our annual kind of focus groups with our community, touch base on how the summer camps programs went and so forth. And I think that's about it. All our parks are obviously still open, very busy, seeing a lot of runners. That's the type of the season, so Whitmore's still being frequented quite heavily.

18:39 As is all of other parks as well. So we have a full parks maintenance staff on schedule pretty much through the end of September. So any questions for parks and rec? Great. Thank you. Okay. Thanks, Stuart. Okay. Any more departments? We're good there. So now going on to public presentations and Sandra, I will hand it over to you.

19:17 Jen will be starting work on our 2019 housing element update next year. In preparation and to inform that work effort, we partnered with Long County to complete a housing survey. That survey was done over the winter. It was done by EDC Research and Consulting, Jen Garner. So Jen Garner's here to provide the Council the summary of the results and answer any questions you want to know.

19:45 Thanks. Good evening, and thank you for having me. As Sandra mentioned, I'm going to give you just a real overview of the study methodology just to refresh your memories and then a few highlights from the survey and talk a little bit about what our next steps are. So the scope of work that we developed for Mono County for the project, which you all joined, involved a number of elements.

20:10 includes an employer survey, a survey of permanent year-round residents, a survey of people who work in Mono County in Mammoth Lakes but commute in, living elsewhere, seasonal residents, including those who are

20:25 ...to work, as well as those who are here to recreate and stay seasonally, and it also will include an affordability analysis. So the study was designed, as Sandra mentioned, to inform both the county and the town's housing elements, but the findings from the surveys were also incorporated into the Mammoth Lakes Community Housing Action Plan. So we worked closely with Wendy and her colleagues to provide survey analyses that could...

20:54 Help move that study along and provide a consistent picture between the two. So this work is really meant to complement the action plan study and move forward for your housing element. And the survey itself ran from February through the end of May, really hoping we extended it so that we could try to capture some responses from parts of the county that really aren't open in the winter months.

21:24 The employer survey was meant to capture both current and projected job growth and needs and to really get an understanding of how the town and the county's housing market is impacting employers' ability to recruit and retain staff. And the survey was available online. It was marketed to employers by town and county staff. We had 41 employers respond.

21:54 And thanks to the work of staff, that strong showing included responses.

22:21 From the county's largest employers. So these results are inclusive of the mountain of the school districts, of government, state, federal, and local, as well as smaller mom-and-pop type operations. And the tables shown on the slide give you a sense of

22:39 The types of industries that are represented by the employer survey respondents and where the responses came from. And they're very reflective of the county business patterns overall. So getting down to it, how hard is it for employees to find a place to rent? The employers who responded, nearly 60% said very difficult. How difficult is it for employees to find a place to buy?

23:08 82% of employers said it's very difficult for their employees to find a place to buy. And to put this in context, when we asked these same questions in Sandpoint, Idaho 10 years ago, 26% of the employers there said it was very difficult for their employees to find a place to rent. So almost half the share in a similarly sized resort community felt that way. Same thing when we asked in Sandpoint about housing to buy.

23:37 44% of those employers said it was very difficult compared to 82% of employers here. So just to put that in context that this is how employers are perceiving the housing market. And so we wanted to know how does the housing market impact your ability to retain and recruit employees? And 69% of the employers who participated said in the last two years they've had trouble retaining employees.

24:06 Due to housing conditions in Mono County. And 87% of the employers who participated said they had difficulty in the past two years recruiting employees to their business due to housing conditions in Mono County. And I don't think that these results are any surprise to you. I think that there's been a sense.

24:28 That employers are having difficulty retaining and recruiting employees. This simply gives you a benchmark and a sense of the scope of the problem from the perspective of the employers who participated. So obviously they do have folks who are working here. So we asked employers, what are the most common ways that your employees adjust when they can't find housing that meets their affordability needs or their preferences?

24:56 And this slide here shows how employers think their employees are typically making things work. And the greatest proportion of employers, 61%, said their employees are picking up another job. So they're working on the income side of their affordability challenge.

25:14 55% of employers said their employees will pick up a roommate or they'll live in more crowded situations. So being willing to accept less personal space than they desire in order to live and work here. And the two in five employers have employees who are living in housing that's in poor condition or needs repair. They're compromising condition in order to make things work out.

25:43 One in three employers have employees who camp as a common response to not finding housing that meets their needs. And 30% have employees who will choose to live in their car when housing isn't available or doesn't meet their needs. And so really what this shows, I think, is the full spectrum of how...

26:06 Employees are responding to the marketplace and trying to piece together circumstances that work for them. And one item I want to note is when we ask those questions about who's having a hard time finding a place to live, finding a place to buy, we looked at that by job category and there weren't any differences. So what I had thought might be the result was, gee, this is probably really the issue with people who are in those

26:34 More low skilled, lower paid jobs. That's actually not the case, indicating that there is that supply constraint and affordability constraint really across the income spectrum for those who are working here in the county. So we also asked employers, so, okay, what policies would you support or see to change in order to increase housing affordability and availability? And we really gave them

27:06 Kind of the full laundry list of potential policies that either the town or the county has considered, is considering, perhaps has on the books. And I don't think it's any surprise that the policies that float to the top are the ones that to somebody who's not a housing developer, who's not in the real estate business, you know, instinctively think, yep, this could help increase supply.

27:29 We're really seeing a supply problem. And so half of employers thought that more development incentives for building affordable housing, including allowing more density, taller buildings, et cetera, would be something that could increase affordability and availability, followed by allowing small multifamily types in different zoning districts.

27:51 Including, you know, that would be compatible in a single-family home environment but allow that low-scale density increase, adding more zones for multifamily developments. But really the heart of the matter is that the business community is recognizing that there's an affordability problem, recognizing that there's a supply problem, and, you know, looking towards policies that could effectively increase supply.

28:18 And I think this is echoing what the gentleman from the chamber said, that the business community is hoping to get more involved. We asked employers, would you be interested in contributing to solutions? And by and large, the answer is yes.

28:34 That ranges from 10% of the employers that they'd be willing to contribute financially. 70% said, yeah, send me an email, keep me involved. But really, it's a starting place to ask for them to be a partner in whatever it is that you're going to do with your action plan. From the resident survey, just wanted to pull out a couple of key pieces. And the first is to look at

28:59 For those Mammoth Lakes residents who are living in either employer-provided housing or subsidized housing, I just wanted to get a glimpse of who are those housing types really serving. And for those who are in employer-provided housing, those residents tend to be more likely to be single or living with roommates than other county residents, as likely to have children.

29:24 More likely to live alone or to live in households of five or more, and I think that's reflective of the nature of a lot of the employer-provided housing. Those who are living in subsidized housing, which is primarily your Mammoth Lakes housing units, deed-restricted units, you're really serving families there. Folks living in those housing types are more likely to be living with a partner in children, more likely to have children, and more likely to be in a household with three or four members.

29:54 A little bit of data related to interest in assisted ownership. One of the findings of the overall resident survey is that

30:03 So among Mammoth Lakes renters, 40% would be very interested.

30:32 In buying an affordable home in the county with a deed restriction.

30:39 A slightly higher percentage than renters overall among the Mammoth Lakes renters who would be interested in that product. And that's a higher percentage than we typically see for interest in deed restricted homeownership products. And I think that that reflects an understanding of the marketplace that, you know, for certain folks at certain income levels.

31:03 Likely their only gateway into ownership would be through a deed restricted program. But one in four Mammoth Lakes renters in the past have seriously looked at purchasing a deed restricted product. And those who did not, most did not, because even at that affordable rate, they couldn't afford the monthly payments. And about 43% didn't have enough down payment to enter into that deed restricted product.

31:31 A smaller percentage but still a meaningful percentage didn't move forward because what was available was not their desired housing product type, perhaps an interest in a single family unit as opposed to a condo, and also that the products offered didn't have a garage. And part of that's probably influenced by when we had the survey in the field, including during your heaviest snowfall in 50 years, but also I think it's something that

31:58 The staff at both Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, and Mammoth Lakes Housing have heard about storage and garage spaces. So just a few highlights. Next steps for the Mono County part of this study, we are evaluating different policy options that they could pursue, and we're screening those that were identified in the town's housing action plan as a part of that process so that

32:27 Whatever work comes out of this study is complementary to that. About mid-September is when we're targeting having our reporting documents to the county as well as to you all. And the vision of the reporting document will be more of vignettes and pictures of for this type of resident, whether that's in commuters, seasonal residents, year-round residents, Hispanic residents.

32:56 Residents at certain wages, et cetera. Here is their housing needs and perspective so that it doesn't conflict or compete with the Housing Action Plan document. We really see this as informing it, particularly since a lot of this data was incorporated into it in the first place. Do you have any questions? Thank you very much. Thank you so much.

33:36 Now we will move ahead to the consent agenda. Oh, sure. Sorry about that. No, no, no. Actually, I do have written down here public. Okay. Thank you. Jennifer Halferty, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I had the pleasure of listening to Jen's presentation yesterday. I think it's got a lot of great information in it. And as she pointed out, nothing too surprising. I think we all knew it, but now it's quantified as far as data people. But one of the things I just want to

34:09 Highlight is that tomorrow at 6 p.m. in this room we'll be doing the second workshop of the Community Housing Action Plan. That's where we're going to identify tools and prioritize them. So I hope everybody comes. It's open to the public. Thanks. Thank you. Do we have any more questions or comments from the public? Okay, we will continue on now. And consent agenda.

34:39 Does a council member wish to remove an item from the consent agenda? I'd like to pull item four, please. Okay. Anybody else? Okay. Any members of the public want to remove anything from the consent agenda? Okay. I will go ahead and ask for a motion for the remaining items.

35:12 I'll make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8. Before you do that, what we typically do is just read so the public knows what we're voting on. Okay. You know what? Thank you for that. On the consent agenda, if you're not following along at home, it's approve the minutes of the regular meeting July 19th, approve the meetings of the regular meeting August 2nd, approve, oh, we're taking out.

35:41 The number four, we'll go back to that. Number five, award the contract for the Meridian Boulevard sidewalk and Shady Rest Park improvements project to spice construction. Adopt the attached resolution designating Canyon Boulevard between Hillside Drive and Lake Mary Road is closed for the Mammoth Fall Century and Gran Fondo special event on Saturday, September 9th, 2017 from 5 a.m. to 8 p.m.

36:09 Adopt a resolution to approve the proposed debt management policy for the town of Mammoth Lakes and the Municipal Services Corporation and then accept the payment reports as listed. Thank you. Motion stands. I'll second. Okay. And pulling number four. Would you like to... I might want to call for the... Yeah. Oh, I have to do that on it? Okay. Roll call, please. Councilmember Ferney? Yes.

36:39 Yes. Yes. Yes. And now we will go back to item number four, which was adopt the resolution approving the budget amendment in the amount of $3,000 for Eastern Sierra Transit Authority to provide intra-valley shuttle service in Reds Meadow, Devil's Postpile, in September and October 2017. So the reason I pulled that, certainly have no issue with moving forward with this item.

37:10 It would benefit the council and maybe Grady, you can help enlighten us on this. But, you know, in lieu of our exciting news, we just received $24 million. We're going to be, you know, redoing that road. Presumably, we're going to start to talk in a broader sense about transportation in and out of that area, including the Intervalley Shuttle. You know, we approved this last year. So my general question is, we should probably have a conversation.

37:37 about whether we just add this into our transportation budget as opposed to having to do a one-off approval on an annual basis. But I'd like to look at that as a broader context of what we're doing down there, but I just thought that was worthy of consideration for the council.

37:52 From a staff perspective, we've already started discussion with Park Service and Forest Service about what else happens along with this FLAP grant because there are improvements to the Forest Service is already planning up at Minaret Vista. We've talked about the Devil's Postpile Management Plan and some of the things that are within that.

38:11 Post file and outside of that. So we're certainly going to have those conversations with all our partners, the PAC stations down there, access to the trails about how else we can enhance the experience for visitors down there in addition to just the road. It'll very much be a part of the discussion. And specific to this one, while we believe that this $3,000 will do it for the Intervalley Shuttle, none of us can predict really when the season will end, just as we didn't know when it was going to start either. It's very possible that the Park Service or

38:41 Resta might come back and say, look, we'd like to extend it another weekend. We'd like to add a couple more days. So we won't have that open for discussion. But very definitely, it'll be subject to discussion. And agreed staff would likely recommend in the future that if we're going to do this, it become part of the regular routine if there isn't other funding available. So thank you. If I may, if we're going to do that, and I encourage us to do that, I am glad you brought it forward that we need to look at this. Because I think there are ways of enhancing

39:10 Transportation in the valley overall. Right now we do a very good job of taking everybody to one or two spots. So we congregate everybody at one point instead of move them around. And since I believe we're using the small cutoffs for this service, rather than just moving from point A to point B, the ability and what it would cost, I would love to see us look at it, to go all the way into Agnew Meadows because the big bus can't. And that's where your main trailheads are, into Upper Soda or

39:40 Minaret Falls Campgrounds, because that's longer than walking distances for most people. There's no way to get day users in there currently. So I think that even without the FLAP grant, maybe next year, if we look at this over the course of this summer and next winter, there are ways to substantially enhance what we're doing down there, and probably at a fairly minimal cost.

40:01 Yeah, you know, I just thought it was worthy of kind of broaching that subject. I mean, I'm certainly comfortable moving this forward, you know, as far as approving this. But with the amount of increased visitation we're seeing in the fall, that's an area people are going to want to go down to. For the future, I just think we should start to think about how that kind of fits in the broader context of how we move bodies in our transportation system. So I'll go ahead and make a motion. I just want some edification on one thing, though. Sure.

40:30 $4 million or $24.5 million? It's actually $24,250,000. Yeah, we just kind of throw away $250,000 like it's nothing. Yeah. I guess the numbers are so big. I just wanted to make sure that I knew. It's a big number. Big number. There you go. Big number. So, yeah, I just wanted to kind of broach that, that, you know, staff, if you could just kind of be aware of that as we start to think about that conversation.

40:58 I'll go ahead and make a motion that Council adopts the resolution approving the budget amendment in the amount of $3,000 for Estra to provide Intervalley Shuttle Service and Reds Meadow from September 9th through October 9th, 2017. I'll second. And now moving on to... Roll call. Oh, roll call. Got to vote on it. Got to vote on it. Yes. Council Member Richardson. Yes. Council Member Souser. Yes. Mayor Pro Tempock. Yes.

41:34 And now going on to policy matters. Adopt the attached resolution approving the town of Mammoth Lakes Emergency Operation Plan. And Frank, I'm going to hand this over to you. And I believe we have a gentleman with you as well. Madam Mayor, Frank Frival, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. Okay, sorry about that. That's fine. It's your show.

42:10 The item before you this evening is acceptance of the emergency operations plan. This is a project we've been working on with LSE management consultants. This is Roger Mason. I'm going to turn over the mic to him for a brief presentation on that process. And then at the completion of that, if you have any questions that are specific to the plan, I'll have him field those. If you have any questions specific to its implementation and our future work with emergency management in general, I can field those as well.

43:04 Well, I'd like to thank the council for having us here today. It's been nine months that I've been traveling back and forth from Los Angeles. This all started about a year ago when I got a call from Frank Freevault. He said, I'd like to talk to you about a problem. Sure, chief. What is it? So I want to talk about our emergency operations plan and how we can develop a new one, update the one that we have for the city. So that began nine after that. We started about nine months ago. Since then, I've traveled several times to your city.

43:34 Been to every department in the city. I've seen a lot of your businesses, your recreation areas. I've been on a ride-along with the police department, and I spent three days during your snow emergency. So I got a chance to really see what goes on in Mammoth Lakes. And what we're going to talk about real quickly here is what's in your new emergency operations plan. And we have a new plan. I talked a little bit about that. We are a consulting firm. We're in Porter Ranch, California.

44:04 We're a woman-owned business down there, and we're just excited to be part of this process. Now, what is your emergency operations plan? Well, your plan is the template that you're going to use in Mammoth Lakes, whichever plan you have, for a variety of disasters and emergencies that you might face. Now, the chief asked me this question today. I told my wife that every time I see the chief, he always asks me a question.

44:31 See if he can stump me, and I usually have to go back and look it up. But he asked, he said, can you talk about our requirements for a plan? And yes, you're required to have a plan. The federal government, the Federal Response Act, and the Stafford Act say that local authorities are responsible to have a plan. So does the State of California Emergency Plan and the California Emergency Services Act. Where the chief got me is I could not remember 42 U.S. Code 5121. I did have to look that up.

45:00 Now, why does your plan have to be updated? What changed? You had a plan, 2005? Why do we need a new plan? Town's still here? Mountain's still here? Why a new plan? Well, there's several things. There's regulation changes, new FEMA requirements, changes in the town, and most importantly, coordinating the plan with changes that are going on in emergency management in Mono County. Now, how's the plan organized? There's three parts to your plan.

45:29 There's a basic plan. That's really the boilerplate that goes in the plan. Why do I call it boilerplate? Those are the things that FEMA and Cal OES require your plan to have. So, of course, that goes in the first section. That's your boilerplate. The second section is the emergency support annex. That talks about all of the emergency systems, mutual aid, things within, outside of the county, within the county that you may be involved in or need to draw upon for assistance during an emergency.

45:59 And finally, a specific hazard or local threat section, and that talks about what some of those local threats might be. In your basic plan, you're required to have general information about the city, about the town. Why is that? During a disaster, outside authorities from other agencies may come. They may grab this plan and use it to breathe themselves quickly about Mammoth Lakes. They could be called from anywhere in California and know nothing about your town. They'll look at this plan and can quickly go through it and see how you're organized.

46:28 You're required to use the standard emergency management system from the state of California, NIMS, the incident command system. You're required to have a threat summary, which I put in. The threat summary is based on the county hazard mitigation plan. Emergency operations concept, how will you be organized during an emergency? A big part of that was talking with your police chief and also talking on a frequent basis and emailing with Frank Freevault.

46:57 Who is your local subject matter expert and also mutual aid. Emergency support annex really talks about who's involved in Mammoth Lakes, protecting Mammoth Lakes. Well, you have public safety that's located in town, but you also have agencies from different groups, for example, like the Sheriff's Department, CHP, Caltrans, Cal OES, and then all of the other either private businesses or

47:26 Semi-public organizations, for example, Mammoth Hospital, Mammoth Mountain, Eastern Sierra Transit, the Red Cross, they're all part. If we had a disaster emergency, they would all be involved. So they're included in the plan. And finally, specific hazards. As I mentioned before, the hazards that are listed there come out of the Mono County Hazard Mitigation Plan. Some people ask me, did you put in things like really long-term threats to the county or threats to the town?

47:56 And I did not. I focused on the immediate ones because we have limited resources to respond and plan for these, so I focused on the ones I felt were most important. Now, who's included in this plan specifically for the town? Well, of course, your police department, your fire department, all the town departments are involved, the town administration, and you as elected officials. You have an important part to play. I'm sure all of you are very familiar with the California Emergency Services Act.

48:26 That lays out what the responsibilities are of local councils during disasters or emergencies, so that's included. The chief is asking me, he goes, you know, about your plan, how does it help our staff? What does it do, for example, for the department heads? I thought that's an excellent question. I added this slide, and here's five things. First, the plan specifies the goals overall for emergencies in our town, and then it identifies objectives for specific problems.

48:56 Large fire, an earthquake. It provides a common organizational framework that everybody can look at and say, hey, this is our game plan, and whether I'm in the finance department, I'm in public works, I'm at the police department, I can see how I fit in that plan. It has background information for the staff on how you're connected to mutual aid. That's very important. For the fire chief, for Chief Davis, that's something they deal with every day.

49:24 But let's say you're in a department that doesn't deal with it. You need a resource where you can see how are we connected, where's help coming from. The plan talks a little bit about contingency resources, things that we can use, appropriate, develop during a disaster. What are those tools to call upon and use? Finally, taking all this together, what's it really do? It facilitates problem solving. What's going to happen when you've got this plan?

49:54 What is this really all about when a disaster happens? It's problem solving. So the idea of the plan is it gives you tools to help your decision making and your problem solving. One of the things that was different for me is I've done several of these plans, but I've never done one that has an all hazards incident management team. This is the first city or town that I've done this before. And this is a new concept in California. Chief Freewald's been very, very involved.

50:26 In developing this concept in California, he's working closely with Cal OES to kind of flesh out what this would look like. But Mono County, as you know, the town of Mammoth, and the fire department have entered into this plan. It's a multidisciplinary management approach. It's a pre-organized unified command team, meaning we've got a unified command team for a disaster already trained and identified that can respond quickly.

50:56 They can function as a command staff. They can work in an EOC. And they can also provide technical support during a disaster. As I said, I was here for three days in February. The picture I took, that is a meeting that was held several days after the snow emergency was declared. And that shows the two chiefs, and I couldn't get everybody else. There's a bunch of people in that room.

51:23 And what they're working on is they're working on an incident action plan for the next two days of how to deal with the snow. And that's what this really does. Why is this change so important? Well, one thing, one challenge that you have at Mammoth Lakes, just like Mono County, is you're limited in your resources. Everyone here is aware of that. For example, public safety. You've got the sheriff and the undersheriff. You've got your chief of police. And you've got your fire chief.

51:50 That's your senior public safety leadership. I'm from Los Angeles County. We've got a lot of bodies and a lot of people. You don't have as many here. So you really have to rely on them. Another problem for Mammoth Lakes is because it's somewhat isolated, mutual aid can be delayed. When you have a disaster, the faster that you can inject positive decision-making into the disaster, the quicker you can have an influence on it.

52:23 A good example is a large fire. Now, we really don't need the fire department. Every fire will go out. We just let it burn out. Of course, do we want to let half the town burn down? No, that's why we have the fire department. The sooner the fire department can inject themselves in that fire, the quicker they have an opportunity to maybe stop it or limit it. This is the same with emergency decision-making, and that's what your incident management team does. The idea being is they can come together, respond quickly,

52:54 If it's to support Mammoth Lakes, it's to support the county. They can respond quickly and start making decisions or assist the town with making decisions or provide technical expertise that they might need very rapidly. So where do we go from here? The next step is to take our emergency plan and train the town staff. It's really important that everybody is trained. Now, what type of training will they receive?

53:22 All the department heads, all the people heading a department and their immediate staff, they'll receive one level of training, a little bit more detailed because they'll be managing parts of this plan. The rest of the staff, they'll receive introductory training so they know how they fit in. If you're working for Public Works, Parks and Rec, you might be a new employee. You're not a senior decision maker, but because we have so few people to call upon, you may be called upon to fulfill an emergency role.

53:52 So that training will give them some type of background so they understand how they fit in. By the way, we're working on a schedule right now to schedule that for October. So we want to get this done as quickly as possible. Why is that so important? We have no idea when the next disaster is going to hit. Now, I usually have a long list of frequently asked questions, but I was told my time was short. So I only put one. And this is a question I always get asked most. Have you thought of everything? Does this include everything? Have you covered everything? The answer is no.

54:24 The answer is no. What we have done, though, is at this moment in time, this is a snapshot of where the town of Mammoth Lakes is, where it needs to be, and what's happening in emergency management in the county. We've taken that, we've developed a plan, we can train people to this plan, and from here, then you can build on the plan. Train more people, as people retire, you can bring on new people and have some continuity as far as your planning and ability to respond to disasters.

54:54 So with that, any questions? And then of course we have our chief. I'll just make a comment real quick. I appreciate all the work that you put into this. I saw you, you know, in all those meetings when I was going into town offices, so I really appreciate it. Obviously we needed it. You know, one thing about the snow emergency, I've never had a client

55:23 Where, while I was writing their plan, they declared a local emergency. And my wife's our CEO, and so I get the email from Frank, he goes, it's pretty serious, we've got a local emergency. I said, well, we've got to go, Barbara, I've got to get up there, because it's ridiculous. They've hired a consultant for emergency management, and they're having an emergency? So, but it was really good. It was funny, because we kind of joked in November, they said, when it starts snowing, Roger, come back.

55:52 And you get a feel for the, it was the chief, the traffic management problems. Yeah, well, there was a lot of problems, including traffic management. But I just felt you hired us. We needed to be here. Thank you. On the education piece, so all current town staff gets educated, that I'm assuming we'll have some sort of a manual that goes with it so that as future employees come on, the training will be available for them.

56:20 On an annual basis? Or is there a refresher ongoing? How does that break out? So the training that Roger's talking about in October will be a terminal part of the scope of work that they're on now. Those do provide the training materials for future refresher training for people that stay and new people that come on. But also a huge part of the training going forward is this other piece. We talked about this incident management team approach.

56:49 And the, in fact, I just got a copy of that two days ago from Cal OAS. Essentially, there's three chunks of that training. There's training that's specific to incident management teams, specific to emergency operations centers. What I've challenged them with is I said, look, about 85% of these topics can crosswalk. There's very common material. I want you to identify those that we can take one class, get certified in both, catch either end.

57:16 And that really is the next piece of that. We'll only knock out probably one major piece of that training this fall, and then we'll start an earnest next spring. Plus, Cal OAS is, they're motivated for us to succeed back here. And so they're working on a budget not only to provide the training, but to provide it locally. That was one of my caveats. We can't be driving all over California. You've got to bring the training here. So that's our jump-off point. But make no mistake, we'll have ongoing training and commitment. The financial costs shouldn't be too high.

57:44 But the time costs are high. Our staff time is extremely valuable. And make no mistake, if we don't invest in that piece, then come game day, we're not going to do well. The incident management team will keep that training footprint smaller. But we need that group to be really on point. Did I answer your question? Yep. Chief, just to clarify, what's presented before us is a draft plan. We're asked to approve it.

58:10 You know, or make modifications. Assuming we approve it as presented, it will be codified and that's the document that will be used for the training? Yes. And I do need to clarify something. Technically, I'm the chief of the district. I've been asked to, by Town Manager Haller, to provide technical expertise and some guidance here. Both work closely with the consultant and then help follow on with the other training components for the interagency piece.

58:39 So yes, this is a draft. I've been through it pretty closely. I know some of the other departments have as well, including Chief Davis. I think we've got all the major pieces there. We might find some typos, but I'd say we're well past 95% on where we need to be with that document. Thanks. Chief, one thing about it. We wrote this plan. We finished it. You approve it. Two weeks from now, things could change. It'd have to be changed again. There might be a change in the county. So whatever you do approve,

59:08 It's not codified for all time. This document, because of the dynamic nature of disasters and emergencies, it's going to have to be modified constantly. But it'll be the framework for the training. But there'll be changes. For example, maybe the transit. Something changes for the transit. Something changes for the hospital. The plan reflects where things were today.

59:36 Three or four months from now. Something could change. We'd have to change that. Something could have to change. Okay. Thanks. Really the way to do that is no different than some of the plans we have. You look at incremental changes from year to year. It's part of your training cycle. And then, yeah, eventually you need to really probably dig in and do one over. But the key is annually. It's part of your training cycle. Give it a look. See if anything major has changed. Okay. Any comments from the public on this? Oh, Sandy?

1:00:14 Sandy Hogan. I just had a question. I noticed the Forest Service sitting here, but I didn't hear it mentioned in the presentation. And of course, we're four and a half square miles of urban area, totally surrounded by the Indian National Forest. And I kind of found it. I know that for many years, all of these agency heads and the Forest Service and the sheriff and everybody used to meet monthly so everybody would know each other's faces in case of an urgent

1:00:44 You know, an emergency, because this town's made of a lot of special districts. It's not just town staff. So I was just wondering, I'm sure it must be part of it. It was just an omission. Thank you. In the second part where I talked about the systems that you're part of, Forest Service is part of that. State of California is part of that. So that's included in that second section.

1:01:12 The emergency support functions, that's included in there. For example, under fire, U.S. Marine Corps, they've got a fire department. They're listed in there. They've got a fire department up at their Arctic Training Center. So they're listed in there. And just as a quick supplement, we have as the fire department a suite of agreements with our federal, state, and other local cooperators. And then we also have quarterly something called the Unified Command Meeting that we usually host here in Mammoth.

1:01:42 That's really the opportunity to pull all of our public safety responders, actually not just for Mono County, but at the state and federal level, those people that have regional responsibility. We're in Region 6 for Cal OES. And so that's probably our big get-together that we get them here regularly for about every three months. Does that answer your question? No. Okay. No, it's a great question. It's a great question. We need to be working together. Okay.

1:02:14 At this point, would anybody, oh, oh, okay. If you could come up and just. My name's Eric, actually, but I was wondering if there was, with you guys having all the training and if there was a major emergency, I thought maybe that there would be some kind of schooling for the locals so that if there was some.

1:02:43 That the town people wouldn't be freaking out, and you guys have all the trains, it wouldn't be so rough on you guys. So that if, God forbid, something did happen, and we would be all upset or not knowing what to do, and at that time when you guys are all training, helping us out, it wouldn't be so hard on you, that the town locals could be...

1:03:12 Schooled or some kind of training a class so it wouldn't be so hard on them when they're trying to help us out in a major catastrophe or something in that order. Just so that if something were to go wrong we would know what to do while they're helping us out. When they're helping us out and if we weren't trained that

1:03:43 It would be even harder if we wouldn't know what to do and being upset and not knowing what to do. Well, we do have a CERT team in town and that is something that is comprised of volunteers and that's some really good training. That's something you may want to ask and look into that. And other than that, in this...

1:04:06 Plan. It does address how we get the information out to the public and how to instruct them. I just didn't want to make it, if something were to happen, make it really hard on them. I mean, they do a lot for us. And at that time, being us trained to not be so hard on them while they're trying to help us out in a major sort of something going wrong.

1:04:35 Okay, well, thank you. That answered my question, something like that. Thank you very much. Oh, okay, good. Yeah, Frank could probably give you more information on that if you were interested. It's just too good of a lead-in not to put two shameless plugs in. Yeah, there you go. One is, in fact, the CERT program with Chief Davis. They just did a very successful meet-and-greet recently for recruitment for the next academy. And the second thing is the best firefighting that's ever going to be done in this town is going to be by our citizens just with defensible space.

1:05:04 You get us a head start on that, and some work around the house is worth having 20 people. So actually that's the best point of leverage. Okay, so any more questions or comments from the council? Okay, anybody want to make a motion? I'll move that we adopt the attached resolution approving the Town of Mammoth Lakes Emergency Operating Plan, or EOP. I'll second. And just FYI,

1:05:38 Can we include with typos corrected in there? Okay. And I've got them right here for you. So roll call. Councilmember Ferney? Yes. Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Councilmember Sousa? Yep. Mayor Pro Tem. Yes. With that, 4-0. Thank you. What? We are going to take a very short five-minute break. If I could have everybody...

1:06:08 Back here in a timely fashion, that would be wonderful. Thank you. So I go to play golf a little bit yesterday. Get out for five holes. I was out there yesterday. That's what you said. I saw Hank. You said, yeah, who is that? Is this a ride? I started laughing. It's the one thing I'm being allowed to do here. That's great.

1:07:09 With the blue flag so that I drive up next to the greens and all that other stuff. And of course people see me with a blue flag and get a ration.

1:07:18 We actually zinged by a group, a family group, had a great time, had no problem with that, you know me, I love to see people having a great time. We went by them and they had established about

1:07:47 We got a three-hole lag, so it was, it worked for us. I didn't, I joined, I joined the group on the sixth hole, because work kept me from joining that much. So we got there a little earlier in the house, we got there a little late. Yeah, well I started at three. I don't know, it was people teeing off at six when we came back in, a little after six. We were down. Hey Bill, how you doing? How you doing? Doing well. Thank you.

1:08:17 Are you Shields? Good to see you. Okay, excellent, thank you. Okay, I've passed this by several others, now I'm going to throw it by you. One of the most disappointing things that keeps occurring over and over in the last few years is a resort town. When we get to the holidays, there is no decorating going on, almost at all. And when I had it, it was up 30 years ago when they had a change in the height. It used to be that the town...

1:08:45 Dempsey, when he owned a snow cream, had all those trees that the golf courses look at. They're pretty, they're just pretty. They had a tree coming into town. The village still does a fair job of decorating. I don't think that. The town looks like a shit. Mike's still on. So, somehow, we used to do competitions.

1:09:12 All kinds of energy. You know, the energy way into it. It is the city of the decorations.

1:09:23 Well, the city had decorations for doing the town tree and that sort of thing. The banners on the poles. But in the past, the businesses, the malls, the lodges, the condos, have all posted their own money. You know, that's a great idea. Yeah, have all posted their own money to do. I certainly don't do what I used to do on my house, but mine is one of the only houses left on my street. You go anywhere else.

1:09:49 A lot of communities have, you know, residential. They're perfect.

1:10:18 I stop at Easter, I usually turn the timer off.

1:10:47 Thank you.

1:11:13 Okay, you got those legs stretched? Okay. Do you need more?

1:11:36 Okay, let me corral everybody back to their seats here. Yeah. Bill, do you need more water before we start? No, because this next part's going to go so fast. Lickety-split. Okay, here we go.

1:12:06 Okay. Just announcing. Type in before you can. Okay. Let me just get that. Do I hit the gavel and get everybody back here? Okay. So we're back now and we are on item 10.

1:12:25 This is an appeal of transit occupancy tax, tourism business improvement, district fees, enforcement changes, penalties, and interest due from Grace Clark. And I'm going to hand that over to Mr. Rob Patterson, please. And before we get going, and I do need to recuse myself, Grace is a good friend of mine, so I'm going to recuse myself from this item. Okay, thank you. I'll be in the back. You'll be in the back.

1:12:56 Don't let me forget you. Okay. This is a, I'll give a brief presentation about the TNT enforcement case. This was one of our straightforward cases. The enforcement team does do a lot of online research, came across an advertisement that didn't contain transient occupancy certificate or business tax certificate. So we started the enforcement case.

1:13:35 In this particular example, we had initiated it with a citation, which is designed to introduce it to the taxpayer and get the information out there. Ms. Clark did respond to that initial citation and came into our offices, had a conversation with us regarding the rental activity. This one is a revenue violation, which means that it's legally zoned for

1:14:04 For rental activity, but just not licensed in this particular case. So she began the process of filling out the paperwork to start that, and we began our enforcement case. After that, we had a bit of a challenge continuing conversations with Ms. Clark. There were some situations that were going on in her life.

1:14:22 We had ended up issuing quite a few citations. The citations were issued because the advertisement was still up and valid, and we still had evidence of people who were renting the property during the enforcement case, which is not allowed. During that process, we ended up issuing about $12,000 in citations. Those are $1,000 a day citations.

1:14:45 And really those are designed to get people's attention and to get them to communicate with us and to stop advertising and getting that process done. We've subsequently had a citation hearing and with information provided waived the vast majority of those citations so they're really not in play tonight for the discussion but I thought I'd add that component and in your packet I did provide you with the actual write-up for that one and a couple of others for examples on how those go but in this particular case

1:15:14 We had actually, for lack of communication, had issued an assessment, which is where we go through the process of estimating the amount of rental activity, and we'd submitted that. But Ms. Clark did bring in a detailed report of the information on her rental activity, and we used that information to produce a notice of determination. The rental occurred at the property for approximately 12 months, at which time about $40,000.

1:15:44 And gross income was received. The process that we use by using the owner supplied data is pretty straightforward. We know exactly when each of the rental activities occurred. And we have clarity around, you know, the penalties and interest is associated with our municipal code. In this particular case, there were no missteps by staff in the process. Everything was applied per the municipal code.

1:16:12 And we've kind of arrived at the point where the notice of determination was issued. Ms. Clark did actually pay that in total already. So the request here is, I think, to challenge the penalties and interest and request a refund on those if you so grant it. The reason for the payment of...

1:16:31 The penalties and interest tax enforcement charges is in order to begin renting. So now I believe business tax certificates and TOT certificates have been issued. It is a legal rental now. So everything's been done to get that in place, and I believe that they're moving forward fine. So this is just regarding the activity that occurred, and I think in particular the penalties and interest. Any questions from me? Nope. Okay. Any questions, Sheila? I have none right now.

1:17:06 Hi, Grace Clark. Is it essentially just kind of what happened from my side or what I'm asking and reinforcing what I'm asking you to have grace upon the situation? So I purchased this last year. We rented it out for, I'd say, about nine months because the first couple of months of ownership we didn't rent it out because I wasn't sure what I was doing at all and still wasn't.

1:17:30 Had no idea of the T-Bin and T-O-T because I was absolutely naive. I purchased it as a retirement fund for my mother because she has no retirement set ahead of her. So that's where all of the revenue is going toward for her future. So I essentially, I was completely naive. And this is the first time ownership. And when I found out about it, obviously, I am.

1:18:00 I did stop running, but I did voice to the town that I didn't deny the people who had already booked six, seven months prior for a night or two in the property. I didn't pull back from that just because I felt that I should stay true to my word for them rather than taking their...

1:18:24 You know, their rental away from them and making them find a last-minute place to stay in Mammoth during their travels. So there were a couple times in which I did rent it during that time, but there were no new contracted rentals whatsoever during that time. So I'm just essentially asking for grace on the situation. I did pay, like he mentioned, pay it in full, and I'm just asking for grace for the penalties.

1:18:52 Just for clarification,

1:19:27 And I, just for clarification, there were, there was $22,000 worth of penalties interest in citations issued, correct? Yes, when the citations were included on there, that drove the number up. So $11,000 now is around $23,000, just under that, in total originally with all the citations.

1:20:01 Okay, and what was the reason for bringing back down? In a nutshell, the citations, if people demonstrate a quick response to those, Ms. Clark was unavailable for the period of time and had some personal family matters that she was attending to. And when she became available, the response was pretty quick and immediate, and so we felt that it warranted.

1:20:30 Didn't justify the citations that were issued? Just to clarify, this is appealed to administrative hearing officer. Chief Davis functioned in that role, and when he's doing that as a hearing officer, he's not supposed to be kind of acting as a representative of the town. He's supposed to be completely neutral. So sitting as the hearing officer, Chief Davis decided that it was warranted to reduce those citations. So what you're telling me is they've already been reduced about $12,500.

1:21:00 We actually, there's $1,000 that were enforced, so $11,500 were reduced, yes. So he reduced the $1,000 a day citation. It was mailed to me every day. And prior to that, when I was leaving town due to the family emergency, I had informed Danny and requested him multiple times in person that first time.

1:21:20 And after that, via email, to please call me. If there was anything that was urgent, I wouldn't be here to accept mail, and I would be very limited in my email access, please call me. You know, I never received a call, and had I received a call, the clarity would have been there, and I would have never done that. We don't have the extra money to be playing with like that. So, you know, like I said, it was just complete naivety.

1:21:49 Apparently miscommunication in some way, shape, or form. So yes, it was the $1,000 a day citations that were sent to me daily that the chief of police reduced. And so what I'm asking for are the penalties and the late fees of the 14% per month, the penalties and late fees that were tacked onto that to be reduced or waived ideally. Do you have any questions or comments? Not at this.

1:22:23 Point. It's another one of those tough issues. Yeah, I mean, yeah, they're all tough. They are. And I appreciate your willingness to come forward and take care of stuff like that. But, you know, we have to consistently apply our laws and rules. If not, then, you know, you open it up for, you know, other people to take advantage.

1:22:55 You know, I look at it as, and I think the Chief did the right thing, by the way, by reducing it, because of, you know, your coming forward. I apologize, or not apologize, but I feel sorry for your situation. But, you know, I just feel that we have to consistently apply our rules. So, that's how I feel. Okay. At this point, we have...

1:23:25 Consistently. It is a hard thing to do, and I feel sorry for those that it affects, but the only way we're ever going to achieve compliance is to stay true to the course. So that's, I see no outlying reason here not to do so in this case. I don't really understand what you're saying, but at the same time, I believe that, like, when it doesn't mean as much to someone to come forward and ask for...

1:23:58 For grace on the situation in certain circumstances, I believe that there should be room for that because I am very law-abiding and I do want to do the right thing here. And, you know, like I said in our meeting with Al, there are plenty of people who advertise Airbnb on off office hours who are gaining revenue for themselves and not paying TOT or TBED. And, you know, any of us could do that.

1:24:28 If they were trying not to do the right thing, right thing, but I'm trying to do the right thing. And so I'm asking for there to be grace in a situation in which I am trying to be a law-fighting citizen and caretake for my family at the same time. So I don't believe that certain chance, like certain moments of having grace on one person is a sign of weakness in your chain or in your...

1:24:55 In your rules, I believe that it's a sign of strength and the fact that you can determine when there is grace to be had and when there isn't. My heart goes out to you because I have for many years been dealing with health situations with a family member. Unfortunately, I think that this could just happen to be an unfortunate...

1:25:22 Expensive learning experience for you. I am glad that Chief Davis did take off those fees because I feel that was the right move. However, to keep consistent and to keep the rules in place, unfortunately, it's something that is

1:25:54 The grace period has already kind of come and gone, and you were very good with your response. However, when it comes to giving back the money at this point for the penalties, and that is money that, on the bright side, it's going to a good thing, and it's helping increase our effectiveness with TOT, collecting money, and as I said, I

1:26:24 I think that this was I would like to keep to I would like to keep to a certain level the consistency of this. And as I said, I mean, this is heartbreaking for me to do. But I do think that I think I will turn it over now to see if anybody wants to make a motion. It just doesn't it doesn't.

1:27:00 Encourage those of us who do want to do the right thing and abide by the law. It doesn't encourage those of us to want to continue doing that, I guess is what I'm trying to say. When I know of, you know, 10 people I can count right now who advertise during non-town operating hours and they don't feel that they should pay the 14%, so they're not. You know, you bring up something kind of interesting, you know. Is there a...

1:27:29 Kind of a protection program if somebody turns somebody in that's... I was just about to say that. There's absolutely a tip line. I'm not going to do that, but I'm just... I'm not saying you would. I'm just saying. I'm just asking. It's kind of an interesting deal because, you know, that's what these guys are doing. They're spending a lot of time and effort to go find the bad guys. And we don't think you're a bad person. You know, we don't. And that's why you got the consideration you did from Chief Davis. And we all agree with that.

1:27:58 You know, just kind of an interesting, because I'm sure other renters know. We definitely have a tip line, and we do receive quite a few tips on that through the process, and we do hear comments similar to this when folks are in this type of a conversation, they bring up others. We did come across this, we did find this one on our own and bring it up. This was our sort of enforcement process. We are diligently looking, and even off hours, for folks that are out there, and we'll...

1:28:26 We'll get to them eventually, and when we do, they'll be paying or in front of you. Just out of curiosity, I'm presuming this is in the Westin. Number one, the paperwork should have been included with your purchase, and also, you've worked in that environment as well, so I'm keeping that in mind as well, that

1:29:00 You work there, and for you not to understand how the ownership of a Weston unit was working, I find that a little bit hard. Well, I was a server. I was in the restaurant, so we were owned by InterWest. We were nothing to do with the Weston. Right, a server, and you ended up investing in that project. Right.

1:29:22 I think I'm ready to, unless anybody has anything else to add, or Grady or Andy, if there's anything I need to. I will make a motion at this time to make a finding of noncompliance with the code and uphold the notice of determination amount due of $11,014.36. Which includes a penalty in interest. No, I'm not going to read that part. Okay. Well, then I'll second that. Thank you. Okay. And roll call, please.

1:29:55 Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Yes. Passes three to zero. Thank you. Did Grace leave already? Oh, okay. Thank you, Grace, for your time in coming in. Okay, and we're going to get Mr. Fernie back into the room.

1:30:30 And now we are moving on to item 11, consideration of drafting letter to forest supervisor and federal officials regarding fire management and smoke impacts on the town of Mammoth Lakes and support for the Mammoth Lakes Basin hazardous fuels reduction proposal to be submitted by the Mammoth Lakes Fire Safe Council. And, Frank, this is you front and center once again. Thank you.

1:30:58 Did you want to say something about this? Yes, if I could, please. When I reviewed this agenda item earlier this week, I realized it was...

1:31:06 They're two very related subjects. They're both dealing with fire. They're both dealing with those issues. But it became a little confusing for me to understand what was requested. So if you could look at both the title, the motion, and the background information, and where you see and in the middle, if we could address those as two separate items, I think it would be much more clear. And the more straightforward one, I guess, if you will, is the letter in support of the Fire Safe Council grant program. So with your forbearance, if we could, if we could address that.

1:31:35 Proposed a requested letter regarding the Fire Safe Program first and then move on to the smoke issue. Okay, Andy, is that good? So with that, Frank, the Fire Safe Program? Thank you. Madam Mayor, Council, Frank Freevault, Fire Chief, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. The item before you is a letter of support from one of a number of stakeholders. The same request has been made to. This is a Fire Safe Council.

1:32:03 So in its most recent restart, we've got a very strong base, and we're getting busy. This item is through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. It's what they call a Category 1 grant, where we could request up to $500,000 for consideration in support of fuels management programs. We'd like to put it in support of the Lakes Basin Fuels Project, which is one that's been on the books with the...

1:32:30 The Forest Service was recently reviewed. You should have those documents in your packet for detail. So essentially we've requested similar letters from the Water District, DWP, Mono County, obviously the Fire District would be in support of it. And it's just that it shows a broad-based need that fire in our area has a lot of different facets to it.

1:32:58 Sierra Nevada Conservancy and the funding for this grant has a watershed nexus. And so one of the things that we look at is what would be the effects on the watershed of a really catastrophic fire, you know, significant erosion, really deep, long, prolonged heat, etc. So that's why the broad range of support for the grant.

1:33:23 And working with Sierra Nevada Conservancy, they advised us to look at all these stakeholders as we put forth the request. Even though ours is much more humble than $24 million, the same alignment of stakeholders apply when you're looking for success with a grant like this. Questions? Comments? Atta boy. Go get it. Anybody in the public would like to address that particular issue?

1:33:56 Okay, I will entertain a motion. Okay, now, will I have to, we're going to rewrite this somehow? If you will allow me. You've got it. I will make a motion to draft a letter of support for the Mammoth Lakes Fire Safe Council's grant for the Mammoth Lakes Basin Hazardous Fuels Reduction Proposal. I'll second. And authorize either the mayor or the town manager to sign it? And authorize either the mayor or town manager to sign it.

1:34:26 Thank you. I'll second that, too. Okay, very good. So, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And that passes 4-0. And thank you very much, Frank, and the Mammoth Lakes Fire Safe Council. I'm just very impressed with what they're doing. So, have them keep up the good work. Okay.

1:34:57 So I guess you're going to stay up here for this next one, I believe, which is consideration of drafting letter to forest supervisor and federal officials regarding fire management and smoke impacts on the town of Mammoth Lakes. And the only introduction I'd have is that this item was placed on the agenda and it does come back every year in one form or another because of the smoke impacts we do have.

1:35:20 Everybody understands why we get so much snow. That's also why we get so much smoke. With that, it was just placed on the agenda. We want to hear from Council, the public, and the Chief, Forest Service is here, and then you can consider whether you want to draft a letter or not. If I may, I ask the Town Manager to put this on the agenda specifically. You know, we invite people to come here for high-altitude training. We have running clubs. We have tourists. We have people like myself with lung issues, and the smoke becomes a real challenge.

1:35:50 It hasn't always been this way. The Forest Service hasn't always dealt with fire in this way, with changing economics and changing spread of that tax dollar. Things have changed over the years. And I would love to have the chance to work with staff to draft a letter not only to the Forest Service, because ultimately this needs to go to our congressmen and senators who have budgetary...

1:36:17 Should we be just allowing, especially in the certain canyons, wildfires to burn just because they're in a wilderness area if it has major health concerns for the upstream or downstream partners? There's a lot of these questions that need answering. Should we be putting this much...

1:36:40 Greenhouse gas that we don't have to into the atmosphere. So we do ask for this every year. Normally we send a letter off to the Forest Service. In this case I would like to draft maybe a more complete letter for the Forest Service and the local politicians that have, not local, but federal, state, whoever, who have budgetary authority to maybe make this happen.

1:37:06 Fuels reductions over the entire forest are necessary. Our forests are grossly overgrown. Before fire can be used naturally again, the forests need to be put back into that condition. So I would love to have the opportunity to work with staff to create that letter. I agree. Thank you. That's a big job, you know, clearing out the whole forest.

1:37:37 Somewhere the budget has to start to give our federal agencies an opportunity to go in and do the thinning that used to be done. It's not like it's rocket science. It's not like we need to change the scope of the world. It's different management. I'm very supportive of having that letter written. My question about this is, so Bill can work?

1:38:13 With staff or provide staff, how does that work if it's an individual? Can he do this as a town council person or is this something that he needs to do as an independent, as a person? Thank you for that question. It depends on the council's preference. If the council feels comfortable having a letter drafted with participation of Councilmember Sauser and staff to go out, signed by the mayor, the town manager, on behalf of the entire town, you can do that.

1:38:42 Or if you would rather that Councilmember Sauser send a letter, perhaps with help from staff, but signed by himself, not in his official capacity, you can do that. There are options available to you.

1:38:54 If I could, before you consider that, we do have, there may be members of the public here that would like to speak on this, and then we have, as I said, Chief Free Vault and Forest Service here to answer any questions or to respond to any concerns, voice, so you can have a full slate of information. In terms of the letter itself, we would suggest that if you do decide direct staff to prepare a letter, we can do that in an urgent fashion, or we can draft something and have it come back to you for review, because it is a very complex matter.

1:39:23 Makes sense. Well, I would suggest it needs to come back for review. I would be uncomfortable helping pen a letter and then just having it sent off. So I would want that to come back. So would I. Yeah, thank you. I'll just add that I think that's a good idea because it's a complex issue and we want to strike the right tone and hopefully not offend our partners of the Forest Service who just helped us get a $24 million grant, et cetera. I was just about to say I really don't want to kick anybody after they've

1:39:53 helped with bringing in that kind of money for that flap grant. So that's a hesitation on my part right there. John, it looks like you would like to speak if you would like to come up. Thank you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem and fellow council members. I agree completely. It's, you know, go ahead and let a council member draft with staff.

1:40:20 Some verbiage and bring it back to the council for either approval or changes as necessary. It's easy right now, today, to kind of feel more carefree that, hey, the smoke is not as bad as it was before bluesapalooza and so forth. And yes, we have some smoke out there this evening. Depends on the wind direction. But it's not as bad as it has been and it's not as bad as it could have been.

1:40:51 If there is no Council input,

1:41:22 On this resolution, then the council and the community can fully expect nothing to change. Federal agency fire management policy changes periodically, and we're in a situation right now where the lands management for fire management policy is if something starts in a wilderness area, designated wilderness, then it's allowed to burn naturally.

1:41:51 It's referred to as, I'll come to that in a little bit, I'm sorry, but the equivalent of letting a fire burn naturally is a let burn policy. These federal agencies will argue that that is not the case, but they argue it because they took so much heat in the past over the term let burn, but the verbiage that they use today translated is code for let burn.

1:42:22 Yes, they fight it at some level, but it's essentially let burn. We have been having smoke for the past approximate two and a half weeks from a number of these let burn fires that were lightning strikes that were allowed to get larger and create more smoke. In the past, in the old days, if there was a lightning strike, the land managers would send out a fire crew, small fire crew.

1:42:52 And put the fire out typically within a day or two at a low cost and to contain that fire within a one acre plot of land. All of these three lightning strike fires that are burning today are in hundreds of acres, if not thousands of acres. And the cost in helicopters, airplanes dropping retardants, or instead of a five man crew, a crew that might be in the hundreds,

1:43:23 The cost is much greater to allow a fire to burn. Yes, yes, the fire, allowing the fire to burn creates a healthier forest in that area of the burn. Yes, we want a healthier forest. So that's a good thing. My issue is twofold. One is these federal fire management agencies have chosen the health of the forest.

1:43:54 Over the health of you and I. Because there is a direct impact with the additional smoke on the citizens either living or recreating in the eastern Sierra from the smoke. The other thing, we spend as a community, we spend $8 million a year in promoting our community. I don't know if it is this summer. I don't know if it is in recent years.

1:44:24 But typically the busiest month of the year has been August. We are getting the reputation from people who visit Mammoth in August, whether it's the runners, fishermen, campers, whomever it may be, bluesapalooza, village fest events, but we're getting the reputation of having fires and smoke in Mammoth Lakes in August.

1:44:54 If you get that reputation, our visitors have an opportunity to go elsewhere where they don't breathe this kind of air. I think I'm telling the council some things that they already know, so I apologize. I'll stop with that. If you need another example of a federal agency that may not typically care about the issues in a local community, a small community like Mammoth Lakes,

1:45:26 All you need to do is to look at our local post office and see what the federal agency there has allowed to happen to our landscaping at the post office. Okay. I'm going to grant you one more minute if you could wrap this up. That was getting a little off topic, I think, with the post office. The quote on the lightning strike fires are that the agency in charge of the fire says,

1:46:00 A lightning strike fire within a fire adapted wilderness area is to allow the fires to burn naturally. Okay, so that's let burn. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I believe that that's all that I had for right now. I encourage the council to consider a resolution, send it to these federal agencies. We don't know if it'll make any difference.

1:46:45 But at least we can try and at least the citizens of Mammoth Lakes will understand that the town council and the town itself is trying to make an effort to reduce the smoke impacts in our community. Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much. Coming up from the audience.

1:47:05 Hi, I'm Margie DeRose. I'm the acting district ranger here on the Mammoth and Mona Lake districts. On the Inyo National Forest, I just want to kind of speak a little bit to what the gentleman was talking about with reference to fire management. Our number one priority in fire management is life, and that includes firefighter lives.

1:47:30 Public Lives. Our second priority is property, and our third is natural and cultural resources. So we've really seen an increase in wildfire behavior with 100 years of fire suppression, and one of the challenges is we put firefighters in positions of risk.

1:47:56 Where we've never seen these types of fire behaviors. And so one of our goals is to have every firefighter go home safe. And I understand that not only are we concerned about life in fighting the fire, but...

1:48:16 Also health impacts to communities. Just to give you a little bit of perspective on the national level, right now we have about 20,000 firefighters fighting fires as of this morning. And a little over 800,000 acres are currently burning. So if that gives you a little perspective about what we're trying to manage,

1:48:46 And as far as our management of wildfire in the wilderness, every single variable is considered when we make a decision in fire management. And one of the things that you should consider, and if you do move forward with a letter, is, you know, where are the impacts coming from? What is our, as the Indian National Forest, ability to control a fire burning on another unit?

1:49:16 Or in the National Park Service. Depends on where the fire's burning and what the strategies are, what's at risk, what the resources on scene are. For example, the Indian fire, which is burning on the southern part of our forest, is burning in an old burn scar. And there are dead standing trees that pose a big risk to fighter, fighter, safety. And so we're choosing not to put people...

1:49:45 In harm's way to protect life. That's our number one priority. So if that gives you a little bit of perspective on what our national goals are and what we're trying to do, I hope that helps in your decision. Any questions? Okay. Thank you. Chief Frival, Mammoth Fire. I think the idea of sitting down and really refining the thoughts is a good idea. I can't speak to

1:50:19 Federal or national policy. I do know that firefighters are never happy, right? If it's a dry year, it's going to be bad fire season. If it's a wet year, it's going to be bad fire season. But it's true. In the drought years, heavier fuels, the window for forest fires is very wide, much longer period of time. Wet years, it's grasslands and front country, and that stuff is, you know, is to our west. Something that I've not seen...

1:50:45 And a long time happened a couple weeks ago. I was contacted by Cal Fire. They were so drawn down on resources, they actually hired us as a contract engine for about three days, a separate engine altogether staffed out of Mammoth. That doesn't happen very often. So it's an indication to the Forest Service point that right now nationally things are very much at a drawdown. And so this is a pretty acute situation. I think a thoughtful letter that really...

1:51:12 Balances all those needs is probably going to be received. And if there's anything I can do to assist in that, let me know. I love another volunteer. Pardon me? I said I always love another volunteer. You know where to find me. Okay, any more questions or comments? No questions. I just, you know, I think it's, as has already been very well articulated, it's a highly complex issue. We have, you know, very overgrown and unhealthy forests, which are

1:51:44 Partially a result of 100 years of immediate suppression tactics. I know that that has shifted as a national policy. We're also seeing a lot of impacts of climate change and global warming, beetle kill, these type of things are impacting. So I'm not going to pretend to sit up here to be any sort of expert on this issue. I think that...

1:52:06 We do have a lot of issues with overgrown forests, and returning them to a more natural state makes sense to me philosophically. At the same time, as a resident in town, I'm not happy when I'm cooped up and can't be outside running and biking and those type of things because of smoke impact. So I think it's a delicate thing. Bill, you're a very articulate guy, so I think we trust you to...

1:52:31 Come together and I think it's appropriate for us to weigh in on the conversation. But it makes me comfortable to have it come back before council to make sure that we've achieved the right tone. It's not too heavy handed and it understands, you know, the nuance of what we're dealing with here, which I think is a really difficult thing. So I'm totally comfortable with supporting putting together a letter. And as long as we get to see what the final product is, I'm good with that. I want to make a motion.

1:53:01 Sure. Now that I'm talking. I would make a motion that Council authorizes Councilmember Sauser to work with staff on drafting a letter to the Forest Supervisor and federal offices regarding fire management and smoke impacts on the town of Mammoth Lakes. And once that letter is drafted, to come back to Council for final approval and signature by either

1:53:33 Town Manager or the Mayor. I'll second that. Okay. And roll call, please, Ms. Jamie Gray. Council Member Ferney? Yes. Council Member Richardson? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yep. No. And that goes three to one. And on to the item 12.

1:53:58 This is adopted an urgency ordinance amendment to the town's transient occupancy tax ordinance section 3.12.150 to allow disclosure of tax records in the insurance issuance of bonds or completion of other financing arrangement by the town. I'll take this one.

1:54:25 Thank you, Andy. So you'll recall that Rob and Dan are working very hard on a big thing which is being able to issue some bonds to refinance the airport litigation debt which will save the town money which is a good thing. The bond financial advisors who are advising the town have said that they would like to be able to go out to the bond market and show

1:54:43 That the town has a solid revenue base. Because the town's revenue base is heavily TOT focused, they'd like to be able to disclose to the bond market where some of our TOT comes from. So they'd like to be able to talk about some of the big TOT generators in town. At the moment, our TOT ordinance does not allow TOT returns or the identity of TOT generators to be disclosed in that way.

1:55:06 They can be disclosed for a few other small narrow official purposes, but not this particular one. We've been told that if we can't get that information out, the bond market is going to be a lot less impressed with our potential bond issuance, and so it's going to cost us a lot more money to try to refinance this debt if we can at all. So the ordinance before you is an urgency ordinance because we're trying to price these bonds fairly quickly, and it would...

1:55:29 Slightly tweak the TOT ordinance to allow disclosure of TOT remitters and TOT returns in connection with the issuance of bonds or other things like COPs or other more esoteric financing arrangements. That's all it does. Helps save us money while still preserving a lot of confidentiality and preventing staff from just disclosing everybody as TOT all around the community. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. My first question. The remitters that are going to be

1:56:00 Now, exposed in this way, have we talked to them and gotten any feedback from them? While Rob is ascending to the staff table, I will notice that because this is an urgency ordinance, it would require affirmative votes from all four of you to pass it. So the answer to your question, Mr. Sauser, is no, we have not communicated this to the community, except for the notice on this particular meeting to request any feedback on that. So is this kind of like

1:56:36 The T-bid deal that we send out, or the sales tax deal that we send out, who the biggest remitters for those particular taxes are? I think sales tax is confidential. Yeah, we don't share anything via sales tax. There's property tax. It must be T-bid then. Well, we get the quarterly reports of the top 25 sales tax remitters in the town. It doesn't say necessarily how much they remitted.

1:57:05 That is the top 25. Right. So this would be an additional degree of detail because the bond council and financial advisors have said they'd like to be able to show the bond market not only who the top permitters are but how much they're generating for the town so as to show that our TOT base is stable. And would it be, would this ordinance change be very narrow and specifically focused to only allow this release of information in the event of

1:57:36 A debt refinancing or a COP or something like that? The way that I worded it, it's bonds or other financing arrangements, so COPs or anything else like that. It's not in connection with issuing the town's budget or press release or anything like that. It has to be something basically where the finance market demands it, where it's deemed necessary, I think is the way I wrote it, in connection with a financing transaction.

1:58:01 And so help me play that scenario out a little bit. So let's say we did go to the bond markets for a debt restructuring. There was the top 10 remitters were released in that specific case, you know, names, exact dollars. I mean, how does that then live in the public ether? I mean, is that something that...

1:58:21 That's a great question. The way it's been explained to me, the way that they would need to release this information, or they would like to release this information, is through including it in what's called the public statement, which is kind of like a solicitation of interest in asking people to buy our bonds. So that would become public, but it's not going to be in, for example, the newspaper. It's a document that's out there that most people would never be aware of.

1:58:50 You know, people could get if they wanted it, but most people aren't even going to know it exists. It could show up in a Google search, though, for example. It could. I don't remember if I've actually ever seen a public statement show up that way, but it could. I'm not necessarily sure. So I can give you an example. We're working on this. It's a preliminary official statement. It's 84 pages long.

1:59:11 And there are several schedules within that. This is, you know, deep into page 27 of that particular form. I know that currently those documents are shared with a select group and they are downloadable from a site. They're not necessarily just published out anywhere. And that's the current statement. I've never been through one of these in its entirety to know how those officially end up once they're finalized. I know it will be something that is brought before town council. So in that regard, it could be, you know, a bit more official.

1:59:40 I can say, though, that I've exhausted everything I can think of to not proceed with this by providing the schedule of here's a range of percentages they provide, here's information that should be enough. But in each case, it's been made clear to me that that's pretty much necessary to pull that forward. In addition to publishing this top 20 remitter report that's requested in this particular statement,

2:00:09 They've asked us to write up information about the top four and say, you know, this is the information that's publicly available about these entities so that folks really understand how solid they are. So it's a really important part of it, and that's why we've kind of had to follow through on it. I do share concerns about, you know, pushback on this particular item, but I think it's been made clear that it will make a significant difference in our approach to the refinancing.

2:00:39 Doubt that it will make a significant difference, but saying that, we are a community that relies so heavily on TOT, and that's the reason they're asking for it. If we had, you know, multitudes of different funds coming in from different areas, it wouldn't be an issue, I don't think. The other point that I should have pointed out before is that

2:01:06 There's nothing in the Public Records Act that makes TOT information necessarily exempt from disclosure. So the way things stand now, anybody who wanted this information could probably get it from us anyway. What the Public Records Act says is that you can protect information that's obtained from a taxpayer in connection with local taxes if the disclosure of the information to other people would result in unfair competitive disadvantage. And I'm not sure that we can necessarily say that.

2:01:33 People, hoteliers and lodging operators wouldn't necessarily be happy about it, but I don't know that we could really say that it would result in a competitive disadvantage that would allow us to withhold it. So I think that the status quo is that anybody who wants it can get it. Okay. It's just that we have an order, under state law, it's just that we have an ordinance that says no, but if somebody wanted to make a public records request, that would supersede our ordinance and...

2:01:56 Anyone could get it. And would it be fair to state that the reason that our ordinance is written the way it is currently was to protect people's confidentiality around those numbers? I would surmise that's the case, yes. Okay. I have a question, but I'm not sure what I meant by this. I wrote down who bids and what rate. So I just, never mind. I don't know why I wrote that down then, I guess. Anything from you, Bill?

2:02:36 Anything? No, no. The fact that probably a public records request could get the same information sways me greatly in being able to vote for this. Otherwise, without going out and actually talking to some of them, I would have had an issue. But knowing that probably these records could be obtained by anybody that really wanted to anyway lessens my concern.

2:03:06 Any questions? And it is a noticed item on the agenda, and it says what it's for, and there's nobody here. Well, there's somebody here. They might be behind the wall. They could be. Yes, indeed. Yeah. Are there any comments or questions from the public at this time? No? Okay. So I would make a motion. I just want to clarify something. And you said it has to pass 4-0.

2:03:35 That's right. Because this is an urgency ordinance, it doesn't require two readings plus 30 days. It has immediate effect. The law governing those says you need four votes. Okay. And Rob? It could be a 4-1, but based on the fact that we're in November, yeah. Yeah, right, right, right. I said tonight. Yeah. Yeah. And then our bonding group is looking for this information by when. I mean, they're out there.

2:04:03 Yeah, we expect to publish this document mid-September, I think around the 17th. So they're, you know, they're looking for moving forward with this. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions or comments? I would make a motion to adopt an urgency ordinance amendment to the town's transient occupancy tax ordinance, section 3.12.150, to allow disclosure of tax records in the issuance of bonds or completion of other financial arrangements by the town.

2:04:35 And I will second that. And now, roll call, please. Councilmember Ferney? Yes. Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Rock? Yes. That passes 4-0. And now, we are going to go to Councilmember Reports. So, shall I start with you, Shields? If you would like. All right.

2:05:12 Breathing some smoke. No, actually, we've had some really incredible festivals in town, so I want to give kudos to all those people that are involved in the festivals. A lot of happy resort goers, if you will, especially when they drink tequila and beer. So, a lot of good times I had out there. I did attend the LTC meeting this Monday.

2:05:40 The big announcement, of course, was the Red's Meadow. We all took time to congratulate everybody on that. And then the other big item of note is SB1. I think that's going to change the monies that are going to be coming into the transportation. So they feel pretty good about that. They're already getting ready to go forward with a couple of large projects.

2:06:09 Freeman Gulch, the first part of that, which is down by the 14 and 395. So things are starting to move again. So that's a good sign. So that's all I have. Very good. Bill? Attended the ESTA meeting two days ago. What day was that? A couple of days ago. Yeah.

2:06:37 And really, that's about it. Not a lot to report back out of that. We had closed session, which we can't report on, and that's about it. And it has been smoky. Okay, and Colin. Yesterday, I attended the Chamber Power Lunch up at Lakanuki. We had a speaker from the California Chamber that came to kind of talk about what they're doing around the state and

2:07:06 Largely their role is an advocacy role for small businesses and chambers around the state. So they have a lobbying team of 14 people and they spent a lot of time kind of focusing on state bills and how they will impact the small business community. So that was a good, informative, interesting power lunch.

2:07:31 On Monday, August 7th, I did attend a special MLT meeting that was called specifically to do some further review on the Air Service RFQ that's out right now. And just to clarify, we have...

2:07:47 Two essentially that are out there currently. One is an RFQ for consultants design work on the ACIP actual terminal out at the airport. So that's running on kind of a separate but parallel track. This was kind of floated by MLT specifically to look at a regional air service strategy over the next 10 years and what does that look like in this community. So we had a number of firms that responded.

2:08:16 And the special meeting was called to have a couple of members of the MLT board really dive further into that set of RFQs and make a determination. So we did approve a contract with Meet & Hunt, which is going to be the company moving forward that's going to help to provide.

2:08:35 It's similar to the housing action plan. It's going to be a strategy for air service for the region, reliable regional air service over the next 10 to 15 years. So that did get approved. That's moving forward. And hopefully we can implement that information as we move forward with the plan. Is there a time when that's supposed to be brought forward?

2:08:55 That should be coming back to us by the end of the calendar year. So they're looking at kind of starting to get some work done in September and we should have something back by November, early December at the latest. So that'll be good information for us as we start to kind of plan moving forward. That's it for me. Okay. And I attended the ESTI meeting on Monday and there was nothing to report.

2:09:25 And that was it. So with that said, at this point, we are now going to adjourn to closed session for items 13 and 14. Do I need to hit this little thing again? Go ahead. Okay, I'll do it just for kicks and grins.