TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2017

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 57 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

255 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:10 High-level information on the development agreement, and then Rob will kind of jump into some of the details on the financials. And then we also have the applicant here to respond to any questions and to provide a little bit more information after we complete our staff report. So as an introduction, we're going to walk through the background of the project, what's currently approved for the project site, talk high-level about development agreements, what are they, how do they work.

3:38 And then focus in on this proposed development agreement, the Old Mammoth Place Development Agreement. So just to start, this is the project site. I think everybody's aware where it is on Old Mammoth Road, north of Sierra Nevada Road. And the current approved project includes a lot of different components. It's a six-story hotel with up to 343 residential units and a maximum of 488 rooms.

4:05 460 keys, lockable units, and site coverage of 48%, understructure parking for no fewer than 597 vehicles, mid-block connector, improvements on Old Mammoth Road, building heights up to 65 feet, and some additional uses including restaurant, retail, conference space, spa, and outdoor plazas.

4:31 Just to start high level, what are development agreements? The staff report has some details kind of generally what development agreements are, but basically they're contracts negotiated between project proponents and public agencies like the town. They're intended to provide mutual benefits to both parties, so both the developer and the town should receive benefits from the development agreement. The content of development agreements is mandated by state law as well as the municipal code.

4:59 So things that you have to have in development agreements, like the duration of the agreement, how long it will last, what types of uses are allowed, the density, those types of things. And the town currently has two active development agreements, the Interwest Development Agreement and the Snow Creek Development Agreement. Some advantages of development agreements is that it provides flexibility for us to impose conditions that we couldn't normally impose through the traditional entitlement process. So you can ask for additional improvements.

5:28 We can also require facilities or improvements to be constructed earlier in the process than we would normally be able to do through entitlements. Also, it freezes or vests rules and regulations, policies in place at the time, which provides certainty for developers as they move forward through the process or building the project.

5:47 Some disadvantages of development agreements is it does limit the agency's ability to change regulations. So if we have more progressive parking standards or something else, we really can't change that unless we mutually agree to change it with the developer. So it is difficult to change development agreements unless there's the mutual agreement between the two parties. And also it could result in unrealistic expectations for the project. So if we put a really high burden on the project, it could make the project infeasible.

6:17 So how DAs are processed. The Municipal Code outlines steps for processing DAs. So the applicants required to have pre-application meetings with town staff. They've been doing that with the town manager. We notify the town council when we receive an application for a DA. And then town staff and the applicant conduct negotiations. We're having a workshop here today to obtain initial input from the commission, council, and the public.

6:44 And then the Planning and Economic Development Commission would make a recommendation to Town Council. That would be a public hearing. And then the Town Council would hold a public hearing to consider approval of development agreement. Because DAs are approved by an ordinance, they require a second reading and then a referendum period of 30 days after the second reading. And then the DA is finalized at that point. It's just all the signatures that are completed after that.

7:08 So just walking through the Old Mammoth Place DA request, just a note that we are still working on the DA. All the final points haven't been determined yet, but we are very close, and we will have all of that information available for the public hearing, which we anticipate to be with the commission on September 13th. So to start the proposed term is 20 years from the start of the building process, building permit process.

7:33 And the town has the ability to terminate the agreement if the developer doesn't meet certain timelines. So if I could just interrupt real quick. So if you've, I'm sensing you've finished with the introduction, kind of the overview of the development agreement. I think the overview of the benefits and the proposals, I'm just wondering if there's any questions from members of the commission of the council, the general understanding of a development agreement, what it is, and any questions you might have on those topics.

8:04 Maybe over here. Okay, just a couple things with that. Typically when a developer wants to do certain types of work with the town, the time for the town staff and the work in these things is paid for by the applicant. Is that true in this case? Yes, it is. So all the staff work that's happening on this is being paid for by the applicant, correct? Okay, good. The second thing is, I'm wondering if you could just...

8:29 illustrate what is unique about the request for this development agreement as it compares to development agreements that Town has done in the past. So the two previous development agreements or the two development agreements that are in place right now were really intended to vest the rules and the regulations. There were also a number of public infrastructure improvements that were incorporated into the InterWest Development Agreement in particular. This development agreement includes a TOT

8:58 Okay. Does everybody understand generally what that means? Yeah. Okay. And finally, has there been...

9:26 Any third-party fiscal impact analysis or sort of impartial analysis of the value or the components of this proposed agreement, or is this purely representations from staff and representations from the opponent as of this point? It's just representations from staff and proponent at this point. So there's been no third-party outside analysis of the potential fiscal impacts, all that kind of stuff. We're just kind of flying. We're getting by on the numbers that are in front of us at this point. Okay. I just want to make sure you all... The numbers provided by the...

9:55 Proponent? Applicant. Applicant. Were worked up through an analysis of their own, but no independent analysis. There's been no independent analysis of the financial components of this. Okay, I just want to make sure we're all aware of that. Okay, so, sorry, so now we're going to move on to number five, is that right? The staff report? Right, we're going through the DA and all the different proposed terms in the DA. So the first is that it would be a 20-year term, and I think I

10:23 And that the town could terminate the agreement if the developer doesn't meet certain timelines. So there will be timelines outlined in the DA, timeline for pulling a demolition permit, timeline for pulling a building permit. And if they don't meet those timelines, then the town has the option to cancel the DA. Some other terms that have been proposed is housing fees, to apply housing fees at the current fee schedule rate. We've estimated those fees to be a little bit over $900,000 at our current rate.

10:51 The one that I just mentioned is the TOT reinvestment. That's reinvesting a portion of the TOT back into the project. This proposal includes a reinvestment of approximately $23 million. That's in today's dollars, net present value, over 20 years. The reinvestment amount would be capped at a certain amount, so it wouldn't go over a certain amount. But over the course of the period of the DA, it would be $46 million. And like I said, Rob will walk more in.

11:18 In that detail for everyone. Development impact fees, proposed to pay fees in place at the time of the building permit application. And there is a proposal for an enhanced recreation fee, a payment of almost $3,000 per room for enhanced recreation, which is about a million dollars total based on the number of rooms they're looking at building. Some other general DA requests is a gondola.

11:48 Clause in the DA that discusses a gondola and really what it says is the town won't object to the concept of a gondola from the project site to the village. There's no, it doesn't compel the town to do anything to build the gondola or fund it or anything like that. Just really that we won't object, unreasonably object to the concept of it. There is a term that talks about an enhanced infrastructure financing district or EIFD that the developer would consider participating in that if the town was to form an EIFD.

12:17 The EIFD could fund infrastructure, but not infrastructure that was required as a condition of approval or as part of this DA. So it would be something above and beyond that. And then housing for construction employees. The developer would provide 12 units of housing for construction employees. And then the developer would be prohibited from housing construction employees in our RMF1 zones. So really where all of our local housing is. The Sierra Valley sites is an example.

12:46 Some other miscellaneous terms. We would vest the rules in place at the time of the execution of the DA. The tentative track map would be extended for the life of the DA. And the developer could still request subsequent permits after approval of the DA that would be processed under the vested rules. And the developer has proposed that the town provide access to our town recreation facilities, like the future multi-use facility, at some sort of a set rate for their guests. We haven't...

13:14 I haven't finalized that language yet, though, but the idea is there would be a set rate, and the guests could come and use the town facilities. So talking about community benefits, did you want to talk about the terms, or do you want to... No, I think just for the benefit of everybody in the public, Sandra's going to give a kind of a brief overview, touch on all these points. Then we're going to ask for any statement from the proponent. Mr. Truax is here representing the proponent. After that, I'd ask for any sort of general public comment if you'd like to...

13:43 Weigh in. That's fine. But then we're going to start going through these sections that you're going over through point by point. And I'm going to be watching the clock and make sure we get done by five. But also we'll go through each section, let the council and the commission have their say, do what they got to do, turn to public comment after each of those sections and keep on track and hopefully get out of here by five. So I'm sorry. Continue. Thank you. So some community benefits.

14:10 These taxes like sales tax, property tax, transient occupancy taxes. The town, there's a provision in the DA to allow the town to use the outdoor plaza for 12 days per year at no cost. That would be for town events, those types of things. The provision of new public infrastructure as part of the project. Contribution of up to $100,000 for a new transit shelter that is not currently required to be provided by the project.

14:37 Under structure parking of 597 parking spaces, on street public parking, some water filling stations in public places around the project, 200 square feet of ground floor retail space at no cost to the town, so that could be a little area where the town could have town related information, where we could provide any different information to guests, visitor information, that types of things.

15:02 Eight days of conference facilities at no cost to the town, so the town could put on our events there, use their space at no cost. Twelve hotel room nights at no cost to the town, which would allow us, if we have consultants in town, those types of things, they could use the rooms there. The provision of a guest shuttle service for guests of the project to the mountain and to the airport. A spa and wellness center.

15:31 And constructing the project to LEED standards. They don't think the project will actually be LEED certified, but it will be constructed to those standards. So just a summary, I've completed my presentation. We have Rob who will kind of walk through the TOT. The applicant will give their presentation, and then we'll take questions and comments for staff. Okay, so what I'd like to do is, sorry, Dan.

15:56 Brent, go first before we do detail. Okay, so before we get to all that, is any, I think the public understands what we're trying to do this afternoon. Is there any thoughts or comments of a general nature of what you've heard about DA? I want to make sure there's an opportunity to talk to the individual topics as we get to them. Is there any public at this point? No? Okay, good. Thank you. So, sir. Why do they last 20 years? We'll get to that. That's a term to be negotiated, but we'll get into that. Anything else? Please come forward if you could.

16:28 We've got an audience at home to think of. Yes, Lynda Salcido. I just wanted to ask that when people are speaking, if they could use their speakers, it's really hard to hear in the back when you're facing the other direction. So I think a lot of it's getting lost for the public. So I think that'd be useful. Use the microphone. Okay. Okay. With that, I guess, Brent, if you'd like to say anything, please come forward. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Planned Development Economic Commission. Thank you very much for our time today.

16:58 I apologize. It'll be a little bit repeated what Sandra has, but I'll just go through my points and abbreviate a little bit of that as we get to certain criteria here. You know, the real question is why are we here today? If a project has been submitted, vetted, and approved by the Planning and Economic Development Commission, the Town Council, and the public, what more is needed? In order to strengthen the public planning process, encourage private participation and comprehensive planning, and reduce the economic cost and risk of development,

17:25 The legislature of the state of California enacted the government code, which is actually the development agreement statute. The development agreement statute authorizes the town to enter into a binding development agreement with a developer having a legal or equitable interest in real property, establishing certain development rights in such property. Such examples of this have been going to California, and I'll use some examples that are current. City of Anaheim, the lake project.

17:50 City of Palm Desert, JW Merritt Expansion. City of Garden Grove, the Water Park Hotel. Santa Barbara County, the Montecito Hotel. City of Enscadido, Spring Hill Suites. City of Durham, 21C Museum Hotel. City of Palm Springs, Port Lawrence Hotel. City of Wilmington, Westin Riverfront, Rivers Front, excuse me. La Quinta, California, Silver Rock Resort.

18:13 Such an agreement can require greater community benefit than under present zoning, such as needed facilities, improvements, or services. Each project brings to it its own set of unique benefits. In the case of Snow Creek Hilltop development in 2010, the developer was able to provide significant improvements to communities such as open space areas, public easements for fishing, hiking, and bike path recreational trails.

18:37 Plans for ancillary utility use and planned multi-use paths to facilitate the use of non-automobile forms of transportation and recreation, all consistent with the Town of Mammoth Lakes general plan. Developer agreements allow the developer and the town to detail the financial framework for the developer impact resolution and additional financial considerations that only a specific development and a precise location can offer. A developer should not proceed with the project without the town's assurance to set forth in a development agreement.

19:06 Specifically, these are the requests that we are putting forth, and Sandra has covered some of those, and I just want to go into a little bit more detail, because we've spent the last eight months working with the town staff, particularly the town manager, and we look forward to working with the town council and planning economic development commission to derive a development agreement that creates a benefit for both parties. One, the housing. Can you speak up in the louder, please, or use the microphone? Is that better? Yeah. Okay. We'll know when you're speaking. Okay.

19:40 We recognize the need for housing within the community. Is that better? Yes. We're looking to add to the payment of the existing in-lieu fee, and we talked about that. It's estimated $918,000 currently. But there's a housing challenge within this community. And we're saying that we'd like to add to that an additional 12 units. Those 12 units could house up to four people per unit. So you're basically talking almost 50 places for people to be here during the construction period. We recognize it's a need that we all have in the community in trying to do our part.

20:10 With that, as part of that, and we'll be going through these as each criteria, if we acquire those and we look to get rid of those, we'd offer those to the town for right of first refusal so the town could have those before they were put to sale. So if the town wanted to commit to those, or if we wanted to, we'd continue on with those as our own units if we wanted to continue to use them for our own purposes. Two, the TOT, and Rob's going to go through numbers on that, but, you know, in essence, we're looking to continue paying, even during construction,

20:41 What we're paying as an average over the last several years now. So we break down the product, and we'd still pay TOT during construction. It'll increase over the time, and when we get to the number of what we'll talk about in a little bit of net present value, that's the end number. We'll cap it at that number. If we do better, it's done earlier. So just, again, we'll be covering these individual points as we go through. We see the potential for

21:08 Improvements for the public gondola to provide visitors and residents with a unique transportation option that connects the town center from or adjacent to the project property to various destinations within the community. And we want to take a look at that and say, is that a process that we can look forward to? And we basically are really truly saying, we really want that to be a priority for the town.

21:29 That we would like to look at that, but we also want to make sure that is one of the destinations that the town wants to move in. So we want to look more properly to look at that and see is that an option to move forward with. The EFD is an interesting subject. I don't know how many people are familiar with that, but we look at it from the standpoint of, you know, the county gets most of the benefit of the property taxes. And the town could use additional benefits, whether it's transportation hubs, other things that exist within the community.

21:59 And if there's a way of taking some of that new incremental tax revenue and applying it to infrastructure within the community that helps both the county and the town, we think that's a good idea and we should pursue those type of options for everybody. Other than that, I just want to reiterate on the bottom in terms of recreational amenity fee. You know, we look at recreation as a key essence to what this community is. And we're adding to what we have already been discussing with our existing diff fees by saying that we do commit to $2,950.

22:29 Per hotel room as an additional recreational fee to be applied as the town sees fit. There's been questions in terms of what is the correct way. We see that as a way to put it to what the town decides is their needs and provides the benefits for the community that's coming in, both for residents and for visitors. In the end, I think that Mr. Demetriatus has shown through his continued commitment to the property and improvements done to date.

22:55 He's a resilience to complete this process and will continue to invest substantial money and effort in reliance upon the town's assurances that is set forth in any agreement and acknowledges the town would not enter into the agreement without assurances set forth and anticipated benefits to be provided in connection with the development of Mammoth Place. I look forward to discussion and thank you for your time today. Good. Thank you very much. Thank you. So next, Rob. Okay.

23:34 Got some handouts going around the room. This presentation is basically, and Brent, if we can get those up front here too. Really to kind of walk through this spreadsheet is the purpose of the presentation. I'm going to make it brief, but it's really to explain the key points as we walk through the TOT reinvestment component. So on the first slide here, it's projected TOT revenue. Now again, this one was, this is supplied by the applicant.

24:19 And talking to Dan, it was produced by some outside consulting firms and confirmed for their project. I would say when I said earlier not independently verified, that's not a physical impact report. In this slide, I'm showing that the projected room revenue and our existing TOT rate of 13%.

24:42 Once this facility is in operation, which we anticipate to be year three, we'll produce approximately $74 million in the 20 years of operation. The town guaranteed TOT. Of the $74 million in anticipated TOT, the town is being guaranteed payments on an annual basis, as Brent indicated, equal to or slightly higher than the amounts that were produced.

25:18 Prior to 2015, that would be starting at $375,000 a year, even while the facility is closed, and that would increase over time. The column on the far right indicates the remaining TOT, which is that we anticipate to be generated by the project, but not part of the guaranteed payment to the town. Those monies, that $65 million, would be either reinvested in the TOT reinvestment or distributed to the town.

25:50 The percentage of reinvestment on the first two years of operations would be 100%. So of the excess TOT dollars generated, 100% of those would be reinvested into the project. And that scale then declines down to 85%. And these are really tied to our TOT points. We have 13 points of TOT.

26:13 Basically drawing those down from 11 points to 9 points to 7 points. And you'll see that decline equates to 85, 69, and 54%. Those would be the percentages that are reinvested. Anything else would be paid to the town in TOT payments. So the projected TOT revenue, that shows the amount we would anticipate investing. Now, again, net present value we'll talk about shortly.

26:49 But we'll total just under $46 million, $45.8 million over the 20-year lifespan of the agreement. And that's how those distributions were calculated. Now, net present value calculation. So of the $45 million, net present value essentially is equivalent of time value of money, and money invested now has a certain earning potential.

27:19 Or is actually worth more today than it is in the future as payments go through. And in this particular case, we're using an 8.5 discount rate, which would be the earning potential of that money invested in a project of this size. The key thing to note here is we talk about a 20-year operational program. If that net present value of $23 million is reached earlier, then that would terminate.

27:49 The agreement. So in this case, I'm going to use an unbelievable case, but if all $23 million was earned in year one as far as TOT, that would be the end of the project. And I'm sure Brent would be very happy. So we also wanted to pull together a comparison to the existing facility. And in this comparison, we are showing $525,000. That's based upon a strong year of 2016. That was TOT.

28:20 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

28:50 28,983 total payments. So the benefit of the project itself is just under $13 million based upon this. Do you, Rob, you're saying that that 3% is conservative? In reality, it would actually be higher than that? No, no, no. I'm using this as a baseline for comparison. I wanted that number to be as large as possible. So I think 3% annually is a big number.

29:14 Yeah, sorry about that. It's extremely optimistic. No, I just needed to... Yeah, very optimistic. Yeah, I get the confusion. Also, I wanted to note here, in year 21, so after the operation, after everything is, the agreement is completed, we would expect that particular year to be in excess of $4 million in benefit that year alone. So once the reinvestment payments would stop, that would be the benefit we'd see at that point. That's really a quick review of the...

29:45 TOT investment component. And again, you have the spreadsheet to review. And if you have any questions, please let me know. Thank you. I think, let's see if there's any sort of, I don't want to get, this is a very technical, potentially very weedy kind of document. Is there any questions from the commission or the council just in a, that might help you for further discussion? Just the definition of guarantee to this, I mean. Payments that we expect on an annual basis regardless of.

30:18 How are they going to guarantee it? It's part of the agreement they'd have to make the payment. It's not guaranteed with a bond or a setup that way. It's just in the contract that says this amount gets paid at the end of every year to the town. It's not a guarantee behind it of a bank note or a letter of certificates or something. Any other questions on this? Hang on one second. Any other questions for you guys? For assumption purpose, the first two years are construction.

30:48 Or the project under construction? The third year is when the project starts to earn revenue? Correct. That's correct, yes. First year of operations is what I'm calling it through my document, but that would be year three from the proposed performance. And did the applicant provide any occupancies for any of these room revenue? There is. So we can understand the stabilization of the revenue period?

31:18 My understanding there is backup documentation talking about the occupancy rate. I believe it starts at 45% in year one of completed and then there's an average daily rate. I just wanted to see if there's some sort of data that we can look at.

31:42 Ultimately, the report from CBRE would be part of some of that analysis and be part of a final agreement. Sorry, report from who? Sorry, yeah. To be clear, this documentation and the backup associated with it were prepared by the proponent, correct? That is correct, and the proponent used a third party, which is CBRE, to provide the analysis and the documentation. But that's all been done and provided by the proponent. I'm assuming that the proponent is providing the town access to all the underlying data.

32:10 That's all available. But it has been developed, paid for, provided by the proponent. Correct. When they did the original project EPS on our, for the town, we viewed very similar data and was coupled with the process and the information. Right. But we're looking at a potential development agreement. And so far, the only data that we have to inform this has been developed and paid for by the proponent. Correct. But just to be clear that this, the document that CBR has provided,

32:37 It's nowhere close to what a fiscal impact report would look like. It's the economic analysis, not a fiscal impact analysis. There are two separate types of documents. So you're using 3% per year as a growth factor here. If we look at Mammoth over the last 20 years, or the 20 years prior to that, or the 20 years prior to that, what has been the average growth factor in Mammoth's occupancy?

33:04 I don't know the answer to that, but I did use 3% because that compared to the performance of the new project as completed and the work that was done by their analysis, trying to get somewhat of an apples-and-apples comparison. Right. I'm just over the course of the development that we've had in the last 20 years, which would be the village and the other things going in, what is the average rate?

33:30 Can I ask a question about the housing thing? No, we'll get that in a second. All right.

34:02 I told you never to tell me no. This may be the first time and it won't be the last. Okay, so we're generally good with this. Brent, anything you'd like to say based on the council discussion? Yes, just one follow-up with Shields' comment. The reality is that, well, there's no bond guarantee. The document becomes null and void if I don't make the payments or the product doesn't make the payments, so those benefits would disappear if we don't fulfill our obligations. Secondarily, if you're... That's why I asked. Guaranteed. Secondarily, if you...

34:31 Some other data in terms of as we go through, just want to make sure we request, but we can help with long-term data for the town. Star reports are pretty relevant, and I have a lot of data that we can add to if more data is needed to look at material. Okay, good. Thank you. Okay, so now what we're going to do is we're going to go through the staff report by kind of the high-level things, and this first one will be pretty quick. We'll get some public comment after that. This next section, the financial section, there's a lot of things in that, but we'll have a discussion up here point by point.

35:00 Give the public an opportunity to comment on each one of these sections. And so, you know, make your notes as you see fit. We'll go through these things to get your comments to go through it. So we'll get started with the first item, which is proposed terms and commitments. Yeah, if I may, just for the proposed term, we're looking, we reference a 20-year term, which is really tied to the financial contribution period.

35:26 Based on the information presented now, as Rob mentioned, if we hit the present value number that we're shooting for, the $23.3 million, that term could be shorter, but it will not be longer. So if we're short at the end of that period of time, then it still ends. And we didn't call it out on the fiscal year in the report on this. The first couple of years identified for construction, construction could take three years. If so, then that would have another $375,000 payment.

35:55 So we'd have to base that on the actuality of how long is the project actually not operational. And so we talk about a 20-year agreement based on an operational period of time, because your guess is good as mine for the construction season, depending on the amount of snow, et cetera, that we get. But we're assuming a two-year construction period from when they would cease operations to starting operations.

36:25 Term there of a 20-year term really relates to that operational period of payback. The total term could be a little longer based on the construction period. We're assuming they're going to take a year or two to get all the design work done, architectural work done, permits, polled, those types of elements. So that would be operating as it currently is today during that period of time. Okay, good. So any questions from up here for Dan about proposed term and commitments? 20 years. Okay.

36:53 I've got a couple questions. What if the proponent chooses not to build the entire project? What if they want to phase the project and build half of it? How would that affect? Currently, the agreement looks at a one-phase project. So if they don't build the whole thing, then they're in default of the agreement. Because we're doing it as a one-phase project. Okay. A second question, is there... I'm sorry, Amy, I thought you had a...

37:22 The question would be some of the TIs and stuff, but you'd be tying it to the hotel completion, the kind of hotel completion. It's not tied to completion. As we were presented to it, it was tied to pulling of a demolition permit. It'll be the, it's the, the terms would start with the C of O, so it's not just that one permit coming out and kicking it off. Yeah, that's not what we were presented with so far. So you're saying that it would be tied to a C of O? Correct. Yeah.

37:53 Okay. You don't want just a, here's a demo permit for one building. I know. That's why my question. No, you want to get the certificate of occupancy issued. That's the key element there. So during that time frame, you know, they're still paying, if you will. Is that clear? Well, no. Okay. So the term goes longer. Okay. Is it...

38:16 In terms of, I mean, this is over a 20-year term. Has there been any analysis done of what the viable life of the project is in terms of making these TOT estimates? I.e., you have a project, it comes online, it's brand new, it has a certain value. I don't know what the value of a project like this over a 20-year term looks like. Does it start to decrease? Has there been any analysis of that and how that might affect the value of the TOT coming out of the project? We have not done the level of detail at this point on the timeline for the project.

38:43 The two elements and the unknown on that is part of that being if it's a hotel, a condo hotel component, they're set aside money that goes back in to keep the product up to whatever your flag hotel is if you're going to have one. Just a straight hotel, then that's a different element. Again, if it's branded, they have requirements for the reinvestment of it. We haven't stood around and said, yeah, it's a 15-, 20-, 30-year life hotel. Okay. That's a question we can definitely ask. Okay, it depends on how it's kept up.

39:10 Yeah, well, that's the maintenance. Yeah. Another question is, is it clear what type of a product is this going to be? Is it going to be, is it, I'm not clear on the details. Is it condominiums? Is it purely hotel rooms? Is it fixed in terms of the expectations with projections what type of a product this is going to be?

39:32 They can have the applicant speak to it, but my understanding of the analysis was done based on a condo hotel. Okay, so all this economic analysis is based on this being a condo hotel. And is it within the purview of the proponent to change the condo hotelness of it? Right. Assuming they can have someone go to a hotbed hotel versus a condo hotel component. Sure, go ahead.

39:56 If that helps answer the questions. So our request at this point in time is a condominium hotel, but as we go forward, if the market is a hotbed hotel and it's 100 rooms that's put in and not sold, that does not really change the equation because financial institutions require you to put a certain amount of reserves aside for FF&E and reinvestment into the products so that if it's a condominium hotel, just like what the Westin does, they reserve a certain amount of dollars that are...

40:21 Kept aside because every seven years you're mandated to do a reinvestment into your product to keep it up to date. Financial institutions require the same thing for a reserve so that you're putting back a certain amount of dollars each year into your project as well. But right now what we're asking is based on the full potential of a coming project and as we come forward with the market we do have that ability to change that a little bit if we need to. Okay, but if that changes, is there been an analysis based on if it changes then it would, I'm assuming, change these numbers here too, right? No.

40:51 Okay. Because you're still renting the same number of units, so it doesn't matter for performance-wise what the TOT is not going to change for room revenue because you're still going to have the same number of rental units. So on that line of questions...

41:05 Then how do we guarantee that they are rental units? If they are a condo hotel, they are individually owned, just as with other condo hotels in Mammoth, and it is up to the owner whether they rent or not. Further, it's up to the owner whether they rent with you or not. Actually, we can require, obviously, in the CC&Rs that they can only rent through us because that's a problem you see in the community because, as you know, I'm very staunch on Airbnb and VBRO and those things are existing. You don't want that to happen because you don't want to dilute the brand.

41:32 And the viability of the product. Last thing you want to do is have people renting on their own in that product. You want to have a CCR say you only have to rent through one entity and there's only one rental entity for the whole entire product. And I'm going to ask our attorney about that at some point in time because it is my understanding from other dealings I've had, not with rentals but with other issues in my business life, that that is not a doable thing legally. Once it's sold, it's a private residence.

41:56 And CCMRs cannot force a private resident to rent. So that is a legal question for later. Let's make a note of that. My final question is, is a development agreement, I want to make a note of that, come back to that later. If a development agreement, if there's a change of ownership with the project, what happens to the status of the development agreement? Does the development agreement go with the property and go with the land, or is it associated with the owner or the actual proponent? How does that work? There's a whole section in there.

42:24 Cough off the top of my head that deals with that. What happens? Andy has been working on that to make sure that we have authority over that ownership issue to maintain the DA. So should there be a change of ownership, the town would still have authority over that development agreement? Andy speaks to the detail of it. It's something we're working on. I mean, I talked to the applicant's attorney today. The idea is that we want to have the entire project tied up.

42:51 For the entire duration of the development agreement, whether or not it remains in Jim's hands or is partially transferred to somebody else. What Jeff Harlan, the attorney, told me is that they are willing to consider a restriction that would prohibit a partial transfer of the project other than these individual condos. Bill, to your question, I think that you can

43:14 You can't force people to rent, but you can restrict their own occupancy. And that happens pretty regularly in condo hotel projects where the owners only permitted to occupy a certain number of days a year, which is usually 10, 15, something like that. So you can limit how much they occupy, which leaves them with no other potential use other than renting it out. And you can also, in the CC&Rs, say that if you're going to rent it, you have to rent it through a central management agency. You have a good point. They don't have to rent it. They don't have to rent it.

43:42 If you don't let them occupy it, then the only other thing they can do with it by implication is rent it. There's a lot of people out there that don't rent it. That's a fair point. They just sit on it, yeah. So if that's an issue, that's certainly something we can go back and negotiate. From my perspective, this development agreement is not fully baked. There are a number of unresolved issues, and certainly I'm interested in hearing the concerns about the council and the commission.

44:07 Give me a few more marching orders for things to negotiate. I think this is going to be, this is hopefully going to be a good and productive meeting. I will try to do some summary at the end of this, but I think we're all confident the staff is tracking and hearing all the points that are being brought up. There'll be some kind of a summary docket coming back to the commission, the council to say this is what we heard, because I think we want to make sure that we're expressing concerns and thoughts and ideas and not doing a, you know, a...

44:33 Point-by-point kind of summary of everything as we go forward. I think we're all taking good notes today. Good. Great. Thank you very much. I just had a quick question. Sure, of course. Brent, can you remind me what the total number of units is? So we're permitted up to 488 bedrooms, but right now we're forecasting 404 bedrooms at 338 units. Okay, so the bedrooms are the hotel?

44:55 Yeah, so you've got 338 units, and depending upon one, two, three-bedroom size, that would comprise 404 units. And there's a factor, I believe off the top of my head, that's about 8% saying that they will not rent. So that's already calculated into these numbers of reduction of rental units by 8% in overall. What is that based on? So that's CBRE's number in terms of looking at the market plus our brand of 9,000 comparable properties that they used when they compiled the data.

45:24 So we could have an industry average. Yes, an industry average. Industry ski average of destination resorts. Over what period of time, though? Is that an industry average for the last 20 years, which doesn't seem like it would be very applicable, or for the last five? I would have to look that up. I don't know off the top of my head. Yep. I would imagine the comparable that I use on those scales probably just within the last 20 years. I realize we don't have answers to all these questions. That's fine.

45:53 These are the questions that need to be answered as we hopefully, if we can, move towards some sort of an agreement. Okay, any other thoughts from the commission of the council? On what? On this proposed terms of commitments. Why 20 years? Who picked that number? We actually started to work through that in terms of the initial request was a lot more in terms of the front end of a lot more shorter term and a lot more dollars, if you will, up front.

46:21 So the element on that was working backwards a little bit looking at we wanted dollars to continue to flow to the town and not everything going to the project. We had one request, again, different hotel at the time, but the same issue was 100% of everything for a shorter period of time. That doesn't do a lot of benefit to the town in the short, you know, 15 years at 100% is kind of tough. And so it started to work through that to say that's why we looked at the net present value, never worked backwards. We're looking at that going.

46:50 Out of this time frame, there's a cash flow to the town. Break even is in the about after operationally within the first 10 years is kind of the break even number for the town. If we don't if we don't mind pushing that break even number out to like year 15 or better, you could you could shorten it and put a lot more cash out on the front end. We thought that would be more detrimental to the town actually in terms of cash flow operationally. And so the net present value number worked out instead of just saying it's a hard 20 years.

47:20 Either we hit that number and we're done or it runs to 20 years and we're done. So the term is really the net present value. Right. That's the term. That's what the applicant is looking for. The applicant is looking for $23 million in net present value. Correct. And this is how you and the town have so far to this point negotiated how that could potentially look. How to get to that. How to get to that over 20 years. You can reconfigure all these numbers and make it.

47:44 Over 10 years or over 50 years. Yeah. It's like a mortgage on a house. You could move. That's a correct statement except for the 20 years is the end regardless of whether the 23 has been achieved or not. Correct. There is an end date regardless. Or 23 million is the end regardless of whether that takes 10 years or 20. Yeah. Yeah. 20 is a hard stop. Okay. The 23 million. And 23 is a hard stop. So we have. What's the reason behind running parallel on the track map approval?

48:15 with the building process. Paul, let's get to that. I think that's down the road a little bit in terms of the staff. I think it is. I just want to make sure. Well, that's a standard issue in development agreements. That's one of the benefits from the development side. They can make the two of them tie together so they don't lose a tentative map and have an agreement that can't be implemented. That makes sense? Once the final map is recorded, then the tentative map is exercised. So they would have to record the final map before the final building permits, so that would

48:45 Really kind of occur anyways. Okay. And the 20 year starts when they pull the demo and the building permits or? Yeah, what we want to do is actually the 20 year we start, you know, you start to look at the time frame on that. They have a 48 month window and we do want to modify that from apply to issuance of a building permit. Right. That's four years. That's an issue I have. We can play as a timing on that. That's a good question. That's what I was trying to get at earlier. So you have an issuance of a permit.

49:14 To say, if you don't get a permit by that time, we have the right to cancel the DA. Correct? So we have the right to cancel that. So that it cancels unless they do that. Yeah. So let's say the way it's worded now, if we have the issuance of a building permit within 48 months and that has not happened, they'd have to come to the town and say, we want another 12 months or we've had whatever, we can turn around and say, nope, sorry, development agreement is null and void.

49:44 So the idea is we have a cancellation. Why 48 months? Where did that number come from? It was the issuance of the permit. So I'm assuming this will take a while to get done. They have to go through all the architectural work still, the building design, the development process coming through the building department in terms of getting the permit prepared and issued. And 48 months is generous, but that was the initial. Sandra, how does that compare to the current entitlement?

50:12 A current entitlement is only valid for a certain period of time. Can you remind us? So it's usually two years for the first period and they can have extensions. Two years plus extensions. Right, right. So having extensions of up to eight years. Yeah. So total. But this would allow them to submit their, they would have to pursue, I guess they would have their tentative track map would be valid. So they wouldn't have to worry about any more extensions or anything like that. It would be valid throughout the entire DA.

50:41 Time to put together the grading permits. They could submit that and then pursue the final math process as part of that so they could be doing those concurrently. Okay, I want to just turn to Shields. Shields had a question real quick. First, I want to preface what I'm going to say with I'm excited that we're here talking about this. Okay, it's been a long time coming that we can even start talking about development in our town again. So that's really exciting times. So we are here.

51:07 We're working through this first one. Hopefully it will set up future ones as we go forward. I've always been of the ilk that, hey, you know, to incentivize a development group or a developer to come into town, first guy in gets the best deal. Future development, you know, they don't get such a good deal. So the issue I have, and you brought it up, Amy, thank you, was the 48 months. If we had 48 months to this,

51:38 I mean, that takes it way, way out. So I would ask that we sharpen the pencil on that a little bit. I think that's way too far out if we're trying to incentivize. And this is what this does, and we still have to work through the minutiae of it, if you will. You know, it's about getting the shovel in the ground. What we want to do is start development in our town. And, you know, this is a great step forward. I appreciate Mr. Demetriatus.

52:07 Sticking with it. I know it's been a long, arduous process for him. And, you know, the finish line is there someplace. You know, let's get this thing going. So that's the incentive I want to provide to Mr. Fabiatriotis is to get a shovel in the ground and get something going. Good. Thank you very much. I think with that, I'd like to, I think I want to move on. I want to make a lot of other things. Sorry for that. No, it's fine. It's fine. Thank you. You have one other question. Okay, maybe say that for the wrap-up at the end if we get to that.

52:35 Because we've got a lot of stuff to get through. I want to keep... These guys got to leave five, so... If there's any questions from the public on just this first item, proposed terms and commitments. Seeing none, okay, we're going to move on. So, Sandra, why don't you... You had a question, please come up. State your name, if you want to. I'm not sure if it fits under this council, planning commission. My name is Kirk Stapp.

53:01 Just to clarify, because of the spreadsheet that was passed out, so over the term of the 20-year agreement, we are talking about $46 million worth of reinvestment. Is that correct or not? I'd like that to staff. Is that correct? That is correct from a gross number, yes. Yeah, for over the 20-year period. So my question goes to is... Provided it takes 20 years to hit the net present value. Yeah.

53:29 Okay, then my question is, in all your analysis and everything, have you bothered to look at what impact this will have on town services, police, parks rec, road replacement, all the different things that the town is principally responsible for? Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so let's move on to the financial section, and there are one, two, three, four.

53:57 Items within this, and Sandra, if you want to just give a quick overview of these items or not, and then I'll look to questions from up here. You can talk about any topic you want to. We'll do that for a little bit, and then we'll turn to the public. So go ahead. Walk through it again? Sure. So housing fees, current fee schedule, $918,000 approximately. Transient occupancy tax, as Rob elaborated on, it's a $23 million net present value, about $46 million over 20 years.

54:23 DIF paid our current DIF rates, the rates that are in place at the time of the building permit application, and then an additional enhanced rec fee of about $3,000 per room, which is about a million dollars total that the town would use to put into recreation for the town, recreation facilities. Okay, thank you very much. So we'll start with housing fees. Any thoughts on this? Can you just explain how what they're asking for?

54:51 Differs from what is currently included in the entitlement? It doesn't differ. It's what the current entitlement approved. So the current ordinance is tied to, well, is it not tied to the fees in place at the time of the building permit? It is. Okay. And so going back to the term that we just talked about, if a building permit isn't pulled for 48 months, the fees could change.

55:19 But you stated that they want to tie the housing fees to the time of execution of the development agreement. Well, it would be, so the fees, the estimated fees would be 918, and it's based on the calculation. Oh, yeah, you're right. So is it execution of the development agreement or is it pulling of the building permit? Right. There could potentially, the way it's currently presented to us, there's a difference. Sorry. I think what they're asking for is a calculation method is going to be what we're doing today.

55:49 So if we change the method of how we do the fees, the calculation of today would govern. But the actual fee itself can go up or down based on how we do development. Say it goes up 3% for inflation. We can do that. Let's say we go back and say, but we want a whole other fee calculation system. You've got to build 300 units on site. You've got to do all these types of things. Then that would not apply to them because they would be locking in.

56:16 Process of how the calculation works. But again, but to Amy's point, what date is that in effect? Right. So, the... Hypothetically, if we change the housing fee schedule in the next four years and they haven't pulled a building permit yet, if... They're subject to it. They're subject to the calculation as today, which is a fee-based calculation. So we get to go and change it to a, you must build on site. But the policy... But the policy structure that would be under, here's the fee that you pay in that...

56:45 Forget the number today, but 918,000 could be a million five. The actual fee calculation. I believe that was the intent with the discussion on that. They didn't want to come back and in two years have a whole new policy changed that says you must now do these things for housing. Okay. I just think we need to see a little bit more development. But they understand that if they don't apply for a building permit in four years from the time the DA has started.

57:12 That the inflationary rate, if you will, will kick that 918 up. It will not stay 918. The process will remain the same, correct? Correct. Yeah, yeah. So our inflation rate, we haven't applied it in the last couple of years. Right. That's all it gives fees, frankly. Okay. Any other thoughts on the housing fees? So, I understand your question, so we'll make sure it's clear. And those would be dedicated fees to Mammoth Lakes Housing, or are those going to general fund? No, to the town. They're general fund. Housing fund. Housing for housing.

57:42 Okay, so they are responsible. Okay, I have two concerns on housing as a general comment. It comes a little bit later. The first thing is I think that I'm not satisfied with the articulation of the impact of the construction workforce housing on the project while they're in town. There's language in here.

57:59 But I don't think it's sufficient. I think it needs further development. The second thing is I think that it would be very important. And again, I'm assuming a development agreement is agreement between two parties. I think that it would be in the community's interest to make clear that a significant portion of the housing for the staff is going to be run and operating this hotel to be provided on site. And I share this a little bit based on what's been coming out of the housing workshops, the stuff that happened up in Jackson Hole, and how

58:28 Beneficial that was for the project and beneficial for the housing situation in the community. So I would suggest that those two points would be considered as part of the discussion with the proponent. So you're advocating for workforce housing on site? Not for the housing of the staff associated with the project. Not for the construction, but for the operation. Yeah, the construction is one thing. I think we need to see a more robust...

58:52 Plan that says if this thing is going to be built over a period of two years, there's 150, 200 construction workers. I just don't know. There's no information in here. To make sure that that influx of construction workers is not going to further aggravate our housing problems. I think we need to see a much more specific and further developed plan.

59:10 To make sure we mitigate that. The second thing is that the housing on site is not for a general workforce concern. It's for the folks who are going to be working at, running, or managing this particular project. I think it's in the interest of the project to do that. I think it's going to make for probably more efficient operations of the project. And I think it could also help with mitigating the effects of the housing things in town. I'd like to see that idea explored. We can ask that question yet. Understood.

59:38 We're talking about a negotiating event between parties, and I think I'd like to see that explored as part of the discussion. I'd like to add something. Sure. I see that our two biggest problems in town is parking and housing, so I'll get back to parking later. But housing, I think that whatever deal you work out with them, that has to be a major focus. We need to have resources to help solve our hut.

1:00:04 Our housing crisis, not add to them. So I just wanted to add on to what you said. Okay. And that's, I think it's probably a general direction, what the specifics would look like, but I think that's a general sentiment from up here. Okay. Thank you. Any other stuff on housing? John, are you going to general next? Because you just segued the two and I was...

1:00:19 Being quiet on that. No, I'm sorry. I'm going to T.O.T. next. So we'll come back to the construction. We'll come back to that later. Okay. Okay. So T.O.T., any thoughts or questions from up here? We've had a presentation from Mob. Anything you guys want to add to that? Yes, Greg. Okay. So basically we've got a million dollars a year that after all is said and done is costing the town over 20 years. Why was this 20 million for 20 years and not 10 million for 10 years? How did we come up with this magic number?

1:00:46 Okay, and that was, I think Dan spoke with that a little bit, but I think that's something that for further iterations coming back, I think it would be helpful to have that methodology clearly understood. The one I'll only add to that is the 45 total, the larger number there. Part of the project, the whole project, will be a prevailing wage project also. So part of this, if you're looking at that offset and that upfront cost, the project will cost more than what a... Can you elaborate on what that means for the rest of the project?

1:01:16 Development Project get involved with prevailing wage. I think it's a good point because that did impact the number calculation. For that, you can thank your friends in the state legislature. What's happened is that the legislature has periodically tightened the prevailing wage laws to eliminate perceived loopholes. And the way they stand now, any private project that receives any kind of subsidy from a public agency like this one is required to pay prevailing wages on the whole thing. So if there's no development agreement,

1:01:45 No money involved. There was no money involved. This would not be a prevailing wage project for the county. That's correct. So what's the difference? Yeah, what's the difference? What's the markup? Prevailing wages are essentially union scale. So it depends on the trade. For some trades, there's a statewide rate that's union scale. For others, there's a Southern California rate and a Northern California rate. Mono County, I think, is in the Southern California box. But it's union scale.

1:02:13 That's what it would be. And there are some procedure requirements to go with it. You'd have to hire a contractor that's registered with the state to pay prevailing wages. They have to submit certified payrolls to the state electronically. All the subs would have to be prevailing wage. So it has the effect of kind of encouraging people to use union contractors, though not requiring it. But potentially the labor cost could increase by 20 to 30 percent.

1:02:38 The initial estimate is it's going to cost an additional $20 million in the construction cost to pay prevailing wage. And you're asking for essentially $23 million of net present value worth of subsidy. Why would you just not value engineer $3 million out of the project? Well, at the end of the day, it's still $45 million.

1:03:02 $46 million. So you're really taking that $23 million. But the construction component of the cost can be considered relatively close to the net for the value. On the front end. Yeah, it's on the front end of that project, though. It's during the construction phase. Right. So that should be more to your benefit if you're saving it up front. Right. Sorry, I'm misunderstanding the question. Because you're going to pay more to build it, and then you're looking at how do you come back with that cost over time. I think it's a legitimate question.

1:03:35 In terms of there may be a way that the town could partner with the project.

1:03:42 In such a way that we don't attach prevailing wages to the construction of the project. Hang on, I'm not asking for any comment. I'm just thinking that that's something that the proponent and the negotiation could take a look at that and make it clear to the community that's a path they want to go down and what the value of that is. It sounds like the development agreement is supposed to be a benefit to both proponent and town. Correct. And that this $20 million in increased labor cost is totally a benefit to the employer.

1:04:11 Potentially. And if this is a true partnership, that somewhere in the middle is maybe what should be contributed by the town in terms of these breaks. Sure. So that's, I think it's a point for further discussion. I'll point out that I raised the prevailing wage issue with Mr. Demetriatus' attorney early, early on, and he was kind of shocked and appalled, and he was going to try to see if he could think of a way to get around it. I think he consulted with some people and concluded there is no way around it.

1:04:38 There are a few very narrow exceptions in state law for when you don't have to pay prevailing wages if you get a subsidy. It would have to be almost entirely an affordable housing project, which this is not. Or if the subsidy is small enough, like on the order of 1.5% of total project costs, then you can kind of fly under the radar. This is not that. So at the moment, neither the applicant's attorney nor I see any meaningful way for the town to encourage or subsidize the project that would not trigger prevailing wages.

1:05:07 Okay. Is there a way under the state law that we can mandate that the contractors used have some percentage of local employment? It seems like most of the big projects we've had over the years, we get a nice sky crane, we come in, we have all of our local employees aren't working any more than they were the year before, but all of a sudden we have this big influx of skinheads from Utah who were here for nine months. Not everybody from Utah has a skinhead. Many of them are. You can do that as part of the DA, yes.

1:05:37 Thank you. I think that's an excellent and important question. Just to staff, add that to your list. The other, quite the other, sorry, anybody, any other points or thoughts on this on the TOT? I would request, I think it's important, fundamentally, this is a, these are bodies of volunteers, community citizens who are stepping forward to provide.

1:05:59 You know, service on behalf of the community. I don't think any of us have the expertise, and I'm not sure the town staff would represent that they have the expertise to do the kind of fiscal analysis necessary for a deal like this.

1:06:09 And I would propose that a credible certified third party financial analysis be retained at the cost of the proponent to do the fiscal impact analysis of this TOT request. I was just going to say the same thing. Yeah, okay. And I think it needs to go through a formal RFP RFQ process. Excuse me? It needs to go through a formal RFP RFQ process. Yeah, whatever is the appropriate contracting thing. We have firms that have done work in the past for the town to understand it. That's great, but it still needs to go through an RFP RFQ process. Yeah.

1:06:39 Just so that the folks of us are making decisions, we don't, you know, we don't have the skill set to do this stuff. I think it'd be, I think it's in the proponents' interest, I think it's in the community's interest to make sure that we're dealing with third-party developed numbers and they could be very helpful. Point of order. Sure. I want to make sure a workshop here, so this is a request so we can go back and take a look at that because we may have data that... We're talking to our staff. So this is a direction we're trying to gather policy questions from this group to advise us. Thank you.

1:07:09 Okay, so that was TOT, so what's next after TOT? DIFF. DIFF. Any thoughts or questions on DIFF? I don't know. Anybody okay on this? Is this anything out of the ordinary compared to a normal entitlement? The only element on this one we talked about was painted at the C of O versus at the issuance. The issuance to be calculated.

1:07:37 The payment would be at CFO. We've talked about a deferment timeframe on the payment of just the town pieces, the others we don't control. Okay. That's just a time issue. But it's based on the dips at the time of... When they actually come in and pull the building permit, or they come in and... Did you want someone to do the calculation, right? Well, what we said was in place at the time of building permit. And we're looking at a 24-month building window. Timeframe now, a shorter timeframe potentially.

1:08:04 So they'd have that number. The request was to pay it at CFO versus... Can you clarify or provide some additional information as to how that differs from the standard entitlement? Right now they would pay it at the time we give them the permit. Right, but there's a number associated with that. It's the same. Yeah, same. There's no difference in the number of the calculation. Okay, so there's potentially two to six years difference. Well, they would pay the fees in place at the time they come in for the permit. Right.

1:08:34 Just like anybody else. Whatever it is at that point in time. Yeah, just like everybody else. They don't pay them until the building's completed. They don't, they wouldn't complete, they wouldn't pay it until we get to CFO, but it'd be calculated when they, when we do the permit issuance. Okay, so I'm trying to explain that a norm, or trying to understand if a normal project that isn't subject to development agreement would, the calculation and the payment would occur at the same time? Correct, right. Okay, so they're asking for an extension on the payment. Time frame. Okay, I just wasn't, that wasn't very clear. No, that's fine.

1:09:00 And these are the questions. These are the types of things to clarify. So there's a number associated with the value associated with the difference in the time of the payment. So we need to know what that value is. Yeah, these are cash flow considerations and things like that. They're getting an interest-free one. Yeah. Okay. Any thoughts from you guys on Diff?

1:09:27 The only point I would bring up is that the Council recently put in place a new set of diff fees that we hope and believe and desire are appropriate, obviously legal. We're going to have to keep a close eye on this and make sure that the diff fees that are charged to the project or any project truly mitigate the impacts of the development of the current project. That's just something that's on us as a general proposition. Correct.

1:09:54 Okay, so then we're moving on to the enhanced recreation fee. Any thoughts from folks on this? Can you just explain what that actually means? Basically, this is a non-diff fee. This is something voluntary that is not required by the town. Correct. If I understand correctly, they're going to give us $3,000 per room.

1:10:18 Bottom line, yes, if that's easy enough. Our issue has been is we look at some recreation projects coming forward. We have high costs with them. We have dollars involved. We believe it benefits the residents there as well as the rest of the community. And so what we looked at was approximately a million-dollar payment that would go into town recreational facilities. Would that be a restricted amount of money? Would that go into a restricted fund or is that general fund? No, it would go into four recreational facilities at the town. So restricted. Restricted. We wouldn't be using it. You couldn't use it for police.

1:10:48 So it would go to our type of fund? It could go to our rec zone we're working on. It could go to a community center. It could go to a playground. So it would go to a restricted fund. Would that fee be made to the town upon completion of the project or when it's pulled? CBO. CBO. Certificate of Occupancy. And real quick on some of that, when we talked about some of this stuff happening at the Certificate of Occupancy.

1:11:18 Part of that is done to say that's when you actually see impact from things because on the front end nobody's living there, if you will, so that's kind of the logic behind that. But in a project this size, this just needs to be understood that a lot of things can change in the town between pulling a building permit and actually getting that CFO. Correct. But I guess we're going to have projects that we'll need funding for. Okay, thank you. My comment about that is that it hurts my feelings that a million dollars for recreation and

1:11:47 Housing isn't, the fees aren't even a million dollars. That's my comment. Okay, it's an observation. Good. Okay, thank you. So any other thoughts on the HANS recreation fee? With that, I'm going to provide an opportunity for the public to comment on those one, two, three, four different topics that we just talked about. Please come up forward if you have any to, you'd like to comment or provide any thoughts on. Jeff, please, come on. Part of the purpose of an open meeting,

1:12:18 Is not for the public to participate, but for the public to watch you do business. That means being able to hear. So the sound system in here leaves a lot to be desired. I don't think many of us back there can really hear a lot. So I may ask a question at you that you've discussed and you've already discussed on. So if I do, I apologize for that. This is a very... Now, is this sort of open? I can give a summary or am I only...

1:12:44 I can only talk about a few of the topics. I'd like you to speak specifically to the four topics that this body just discussed, and we'll move through the rest of the agenda by the end if you have any general thoughts. I'll attempt to do that. It's a development agreement. Before we get started, we need to limit these comments to five minutes for each. Sure, that's fine. Yeah, right. It's a development agreement, very unusual.

1:13:06 The TOT portion of it, this seems like a totally one-sided development agreement because it's phase one is spent two or three years of building it. Phase two has spent 15 years putting $45 million back into the developer's pocket. It just seems highly unusual in the game of development agreements. Normally, their very long phase over a 20-year period means like

1:13:29 You know, the Dempsey Project, you know, all these projects, really a lot happens. It's very unusual in a small project like this. So I find that quite odd. Now, as far as the recreation fee, I assume that wouldn't go back in the project. That would be ice rink or someplace else. The commercial property, I mean, that's about the size of Minaret Village. That's already approved.

1:13:55 You know, via the zoning change. Now, if you do move forward with something as strange as a development agreement for a project like this, you can downsize it. It's an agreement between the project and you guys. So you're not really subject to the zoning. You can say this is too big for where it is within Mammoth Lakes. It's too much commercial for the size and what it is. It must be more vacant commercial given what it is. So you can actually, you have a lot to deal with here. You don't have to agree with what's being placed on the table in front of you. The parking.

1:14:24 I didn't quite understand from the report whether the parking was only that which would be required via the amount of units being built. Is that correct? You know, there's 338 units and 500 and something parking spaces. Is that just what the zoning would require?

1:14:42 Okay, so therefore there's no parking place being reported for the public, only allowing the public to park in it, sort of like Minaret Village does, so it's really not a benefit for the public. I don't see any benefit. It's a $45 million dog fountain. It's the only real public benefit is somebody to give the dogs, and it's $45 million. It just, to me, seems so very odd to look at this after years of playing with it and going, what the heck is this all about? I've never seen anything like this ever. Anyway.

1:15:09 Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else listening to speak? Come on up on these first four topics that we just second these four topics we just discussed. Dan Leister. The original CEQA analysis on this was done a few years ago. Is that correct? Yes. Was the project description at that point similar to this? It is the same. The very exact same. So some of those impact analysis have already been done. Yes. Thank you. Anybody else?

1:15:52 Hi, Jennifer Halfordy, Mammoth Lakes Housing and Community Member. I wanted to find out, since we're talking about housing, how many employees will this project generate? That's an excellent question. Is that something, we probably can't answer that now, but... Okay, so that's a number to bring forward. And I would, just to follow up on that, how many...

1:16:16 Yeah, how many, what is the housing needs of this project for staff and associated operations, that kind of stuff? And at what point? Construction or operation? We would have a net number for operations and we would have a construction. Exactly. Okay, good. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, good. So let's move on to the next grouping. Sandra, just maybe just a quick preview of these three.

1:16:41 Gondola, we won't unreasonably object to the concept of a gondola. If we form an EIFD, the developer will consider participating. The EIFD could fund infrastructure that's not required as part of this DA or as a condition of approval, and developer will provide 12 units of housing for the...

1:17:02 Project. I'm sorry, for the construction employees and will not house their construction employees in our RMF1 zone, which is essentially the Sierra Valley sites. Good. Thank you. So, Don Law? Do you have a general thought? I'm just kidding. I do. Okay. Who gets to decide what unreasonable is? Me, I hope.

1:17:21 Yeah, I have the same concern. I mean, that word, there's got to be something else in there because what is unreasonable there? We all have our reasons and we all think we're reasonable. It makes absolutely no sense. And I'm going to follow up with that a little bit with Andy. I'm assuming this development agreement is a legally binding agreement, correct? It is, and I'm not sure that unreasonably it's going to stay in the final draft. I hate that term. Yeah. It seems awfully vague for a legal sign. Yeah. I think our goal was to stay in it.

1:17:50 I mean, it's not something we're saying, yes, we're going to go fund this. I think what the developer is looking for, well, if we propose the gondola in the front of the town, we're going to jump out in the front and say, no, we're not going to, we're going to oppose that day one. I mean, that's kind of one of those.

1:18:09 I don't know. If someone can find some creative way to write that into a legally binding document while still providing the community the full resources they have to engage with such a proposition, I guess you could do that. And to get off the lighter side of it, the community as a whole needs to decide whether or not a gondola going through the middle of the town is a reasonable thing or not. That is really not up to the proponent or even just the town council while we are the community's...

1:18:37 Voice. My ideas often change based on input from constituencies. So the gondola thing has been hashed around in Mammoth since I was a very little boy. And unreasonable needs to be able to be decided by the population, not by a developer. Unreasonably is not part of the current draft. We deleted that, I think, two drafts ago. It now says that if they propose a gondola, we don't have to do anything at all.

1:19:05 Jim's attorney included gondola language in his initial draft. The way he set it up, it would have obligated the town to take unspecified actions to support a gondola, and that seemed like it was going to be a non-starter.

1:19:34 We didn't delete the entire concept, but we shifted it from the town has to do something that's not defined to the town doesn't have to do anything at all. That just seems like an unnecessary complication. Just eliminate it. Why don't you just get rid of it? We can certainly delete that paragraph. They don't seem all that wedded to it. Yeah, just to make things, you know, you want your legal documents to be clear and straightforward and simple.

1:19:58 And I would go on, since you're standing there, Andy, to the next enhanced infrastructure financing district is basically the same thing. He will decide whether he will or won't. In that case, I'm not sure I need to even see the verbiage in front of me. So their initial proposal was that we would be obligated to form one.

1:20:20 With or without the county's participation. And if the county doesn't participate, there's not enough money in one to do anybody any good. So that was their initial proposal. We're obligated to form one. We're obligated to use the proceeds to basically pay for their infrastructure. That also seemed like a non-starter. So we watered that one down to say the town doesn't have to do anything. You could use an EFID, for example, to reimburse a development fee, which you could tie to go back against the obligation of TNT money. There's a lot more work, but you could use it as an offset. But we didn't want to be obligated to create one.

1:20:51 Which is problematic. And I'm not saying we should or we shouldn't. What I'm saying is that why am I dealing with something that basically says we don't have to and they don't have to. So if we want to negotiate that at some point, I don't see it having to be part of the DA. If there's consensus to take out the gondola and the EIFD, that's fine with me.

1:21:16 Dan DeSert. They make sense, but I just don't see them needing to be part of the DA. Good. So I think anybody get a thought on that? Actually, I was skipping up to the next one. Okay, hang on. Let's not do that. Let's wrap up. I'm assuming Gondola's done, right? We're done with Gondola. EIFD, any other thoughts on EIFD? My only thought to that would be I'll be very concerned about potentially coloring the perception of an EIFD that we're going to be looking to county, various districts to put together with some vague language in here that it's not

1:21:45 Clear what it means. I think, you know, the EIFD is going to rise or fall on its own merits, and I would just say that having sort of vague, non-committing language, unless it's something that's really important. And so would Gondola. So would Gondola. It's the same kind of thing. Yeah, I agree. The only other, I mean, on the EIFD, the only other issue on that, if you want this as part of the project and the front end to push it, it gets the values off of the incremental growth. Let's say we want one and we don't, we take it out, we deal with it after the project is...

1:22:14 Pretty much done, your value has gone away for having an EFID. Because it's the incremental value of the project that adds revenue to an EIFD. Yes, but that's true whether it's part of the development agreement or not. Correct, but the idea initially was, the idea here was, do you want pressure to take a look at one, bottom line? That's assuming that EIFD is currently underway, that we have. You have to have it in place before you get the tax income value. Dan, if we're going to say that, if this just says,

1:22:44 We will in the next two years look at forming an EIFD because you're right. It doesn't make any sense to do it after the fact. It has to be prior to construction. If you want to put it that way, that's fine. But to put it in here saying, well, maybe we will, maybe we won't. We don't know. It makes no sense to me. Should we look at it? Absolutely. This project is ripe for an EIFD regardless what we use it for. But does it need to be part of the DA? I don't.

1:23:10 So I would, I think you've heard, you've heard some comments here. I think it's something that we should look at to see if we can incorporate EIFD in here. Assuming, like I said, you know, we have the projects identify what, you know, the type of works that we need. But it's a, it's a. I'm not saying we absolutely have to have it. I mean, you can do it outside. If it makes sense that we can incorporate this as part of the. I think it benefits both parties. Correct.

1:23:41 We need to be more specific if we do it. Yeah, and the germane and the invaluable partners in EIFD are all the local public agencies. And a private development party is probably kind of an afterthought to hold that discussion. I don't think we want to. We need to prioritize. Because they're driving the increment. Understood. But we need to be conscious of the political will and the buy-in from the regional partners that we need to have to make this thing work. So I think I'm hearing consensus to strike both of those paragraphs from the draft.

1:24:08 In general, I guess. It doesn't mean he doesn't get worked on, but not in this agreement. Okay. That's what we'll do. Okay. Okay. So housing for construction employees. Thoughts? So it says 12 units of housing available. My first initial thought is we need to make sure those 12 housing units aren't housing units that are already in the rental pool or have potentiality for being in the rental pool. They need to be 12 units that are brought in.

1:24:37 To the rental pool that currently don't exist, however they achieve that. Whether it is through buying a condominium or whether it is through building a building, there is value in building a couple of fourplexes or three of them or whatever for both the town and them. So that's my comment. It needs to be absolutely new to the housing market.

1:24:58 Not a condo that's already being monthly rented or should be monthly rented, but a new product. You're looking into the long-term rental market, not short-term rental. Absolutely. So if it comes out of the current short-term, that would be acceptable. Right, as long as it comes out in such a way that it is going to remain a rental unit. I think we want to be clear. I think that there is a need for more fully developed analysis and program.

1:25:20 Associated around this construction employee issue. I think the issue is, one, how many units are we talking about? I mean, how many workers are going to be best? How many? You're getting to the bottom. Yeah. What is a unit? Brent said, you know, it could house up to maybe four people per unit. That's almost 50 workers. Sure. Is that what we're looking for? Twelve units that can house four people? I don't know. I mean, how many?

1:25:49 If there's 200, I mean, if you've got 200 guys or friends from Utah over here building this thing, is that a bunk house kind of situation? Do we have something in here that says that these 12 units can't be the last 12 hotel rooms they'd launch? Right. Right, sure. My point. They need to be new to the rental market. Now, I'm going to go back. I'm assuming that, for sake of conversation here,

1:26:13 That the 12 units could, in the end, be tied into this $918,000. So if they build 12 brand new units, the town could accept some of those units in payment or in lieu of payment of the $918,000? Right now we're saying it needs to be over and above the fees. Yeah, this is the additional benefit over and above. Right. In that case, as long as it's new. But there's nothing saying that at the end of construction, those 12 units are going to transfer to the town. This is just something that they're going to house their people during their construction. Right.

1:26:43 I'm asking for the guarantee that they remain deep restricted, if you will, as long-term rental units, not as short-term or any other use, so that they maintain that 12 units in perpetuity or whatever. So I think I'm hearing, what I'm hearing is a little bit of a more robust, this needs to be developed, I think, along the lines of what you're hearing up here, and that would be something that for you to talk about with the proponent. Okay, I think are we good with that one? Okay. Just real quick, on the construction employee housing.

1:27:12 If you can perhaps incorporate the health and safety aspects of this property as well. I mean, they'd have to meet the current standards or if they're by an existing unit, it would be what it is. That is correct, yes. So I don't, I understand the question. Well, if we're going to restrict that they cannot put, on one hand, Bill's saying that we want them to build three fourplexes. On the last sentence, we're saying, but they can't be in Sierra Valley sites.

1:27:40 Where are they going to put three fourplexes if they're not going to go on Sierra Lea sites? If they're going to be new, why can't they be in Sierra Lea? Understood. I think you've got some direction on this. I think we're good with this here for the moment. Any thoughts from the comments? I think it's a great point. Any thoughts from the public? Have you come forward? Hang on a second. Let me just get the public coming. Hello, Dave Harvey.

1:28:04 I follow your sentiments, Shields. It's about time. But there are, as you're discussing, a tremendous amount of details that have got to come to fruition here for this development agreement to be successful. The question that I had was, what impact is the development agreement going to have on a community facilities district, a CFD? Thank you. Good. Anybody else?

1:28:36 Please come forward. Kirk Stapp. In your staff report, it says the town will have first right of refusal to purchase any constructed worker housing after the project construction is completed. It doesn't indicate anything about deed restricted or the price. I mean, if we're just buying market rate units out there that house four people, I mean...

1:29:05 There's no benefit in that. I mean, we might as well just look elsewhere or it will compete against other units for sale. Thank you. Thank you very much. Quick. I'm just wondering where the 12 units number came from. Is it related to an estimated number of employees? Is it related to a dollar amount? Why 12 units?

1:29:28 Why not 10? It was a smaller unit count and looking at some level of impact for workers. So it wasn't tied hard to a number. We know there's going to be worker impact. We believe it's rough numbers, but I think probably the minimum number on site would be in the 40 range at any given time of workers. It could be as much as 200. I mean, depending if all your trades are in town at the same time. But it's going to be a real up and down number. The idea is this would not house every worker that they bring into town. If you're using a lot of local employees.

1:29:57 Assumption is they have housing, so they're not going to stick them in these housings. So we don't know how much of the actual employment is coming from out of the area versus in the area. And so the idea was to look at units that could house more than one person that we hadn't written in. It will be a maximum of four, minimum of two, or anything of that nature yet. But you guys have direction to further develop this idea? Right. Okay, good. I want to move on. We only got a half hour left, and these guys got to get out of here. So not yet.

1:30:23 We got it. Let's move on here. I'm sorry. Point of order. I just want to make comment back on the server. Should we not still part of the advocate to make comment on that? Please go make a comment. I just want to say, just ask and request that you rethink about the EIFD and the however it is that we can really work a potential language. I believe that this is the time if we're going to do an EIFD, you look at it now because after the project is done, the revenue is done. If there is a potential.

1:30:50 I would just ask you to look at language on that to see if there is something that would be amiable to everybody. Staff has direction and there will be further conversation on that. Okay, so now let's move on to these other development agreement items, these four bullets here, Sandra. So just vesting the rules in place at the time of execution of the DA, extending the TTM tentative track map for the life of the DA. A developer may still request subsequent permits.

1:31:19 This is the kind of last outstanding item is that the town would provide access to the guests of the facility, I'm sorry, of the hotel to our recreation facilities. Thank you very much. Any thoughts on these four bullets here? Let me highlight the last one real quick on the town recreational facilities. The whole idea there is if you go to a lot of places, they have a visitor card.

1:31:46 Element or something. So at the hotel, if you come in, you're going to pay $10. That gives you two visits to the ice rink or a visit to the swimming pool, whether you use it or not. And then there's a split of that cost between the operator and the town. It's a way of generating revenue for town operations if you that way, whether people take advantage of them or not. It's your classic gym membership. We want 100 people to sign up and three people to use the gym if you're an operator. So anybody ever do that?

1:32:12 Anyway, so the idea on that was this is a revenue generation operationally that the visiting side of the house could bring to play as a visitor card example to begin a different revenue stream in operating some of our rec facilities. I think it would be helpful if you could quantify that financially in terms of dollars and cents. Yeah, the real question there would be the number of people that opt in and opt out options and you have to structure it that way. You're talking about offering guests who stay at the condo hotel.

1:32:39 A buy one get one free card or a family of four comes and you're trying to incentivize them to take the whole family to the ice rink and only pay for three of them instead of four. Something like that. Something of that nature. And then the idea is to incentivize them to. If they don't use it, we get paid anyway. We'll get the revenue whether they use a facility or not. Sounds reasonable. I just think some clarification on what that actually means and what kind of financial.

1:33:04 Yeah. Number we're talking about. And I think it would be helpful to also look at this as a town-wide program. Ultimately, I think it should be. So I think that needs to be built into this as it's a scalable program that could be used throughout a variety of properties across the town. Okay. Any other? Yeah. Yeah. Any other thoughts on these four bullets here? Is there anything different than, what is different here than normal projects? I guess my question is the term of the tentative map for the property.

1:33:34 Right, so it extends that life through the life of the DA, but like I said previously, when they record their final map, the tentative map is basically complete. So they have to record their final map before they pull building permits, so that really is not that much of a benefit if they're moving forward quickly.

1:33:57 The DA becomes null and void if they don't pull a building permit within a certain period of time. So why does this need to be? It would go away. It's a request. The applicant side will not be right. It may not have that value to either side. If it goes away, we'll have the tentative map to the timeline. Reverse back to this. Reverse to whatever the timeline. Right. Okay, good. So this doesn't help or hurt really us at all. Good. Thank you. Any other thoughts or questions from the public?

1:34:35 Tom Heller with the Fire Department. Could you please just define what the rules are in item number one and the subsequent permits in item number three, what those are returned to? The rules in place at the time are the Clearwater Specific Plan, the specific plan that governs the site, the municipal code, zoning code, and then the...

1:35:03 Second question was, I'm sorry, Tom. Subsequent permits. Subsequent permits. So that would be like building permits, grading permits, sign permits, special event permits, those types of things. So it's basically, it's reaffirming language. It's already in the project as approved. Yeah, there's nothing exceptional about this. But it wouldn't allow them to increase the size of the project and include that automatically.

1:35:29 Should another parcel of land be purchased, it would have to have its own DA or a renegotiation of this to... Oh, yeah. Okay, good. Thank you. So now moving on to these are the community benefits and there's a fairly long list. I guess, Sandra, do you want to just maybe touch on these real quick? Sure. And then just take your notes and we'll just...

1:35:52 Address them as needless. Sure, correct. So, yes, increased taxes, and then the town is able to use the outdoor plaza for 12 days per year at no cost. New public infrastructure, the contribution of up to $100,000 for a new transit shelter. Like I said previously, that's a transit shelter not required by the project. Under-structure parking of 597 spaces, on-street public parking.

1:36:18 Water filling stations in public places throughout the project. 200 square feet of ground floor retail space at no cost to the town. Eight days of conference facilities, 12 hotel room nights at no cost to the town. Guest shuttle service, spa and wellness center, and construction of a project to lead standards. Excellent. Thank you very much. So this is a long list, but with a limited amount of time. I'll just throw it open to anybody who's got a thought on a question on any one of these things. I've got a couple of really quick questions. I just want to throw up real quick.

1:36:51 Can you give me an idea of the transit bus shelter that was recently constructed across the street from the village? Any idea of Ballpark how much that was? Just so we have an apples to apples comparison.

1:37:07 Go ahead. That shelter and stuff on Hillside, the total for the shelter itself is a little over $100,000. It turned out a little bit more. The thought of putting $100,000 in here gave a cap or sort of a number to the applicant to be able to look at. The actual cost would be possibly between $200,000 and $300,000 actually because we'd have to acquire right away. We'd have to push out the curb, create the stop, and do the transit shelter.

1:37:32 So the actual cost of one across the street from this development would be between $200,000 and $300,000. So the $100,000 cap would be on the applicant? Yeah. If other funds would come out of town? Exactly. That's correct. Because we're looking for a contribution toward that as opposed to trying to guesstimate what it would actually cost to get the right away and everything. So just give us a contribution. We'll go out and get it done. So just so everybody knows, I'm going to, at 5 of 5, just call for a wrap-up.

1:38:00 And we're not going to get everything covered, but Shields, go ahead. Yeah, I noticed it said up to 597 parking spaces, and what I'm reading here, it says consisting of or containing 597. It is 597 parking spaces. Okay, so it's not up to. But that's what's required. That's not really an additional benefit. It is required. I just said up to. So I brought up earlier my concern was parking, because obviously that's one of our big problems in town.

1:38:30 Huh? Yeah, I just want to make sure the number was solid. So, I would like to see some more contribution of parking spots. I don't think that's enough to help solve our housing or parking crisis in town. If I remember correctly, the project was short.

1:38:50 On required parking. So the $597 is actually less than required by company. Correct, correct. There is a condition of approval that they pay an in-lieu fee, and that's a condition of approval on the project. So for the remaining parking spaces, and I don't recall off the top of my head how many parking spaces they need to provide, but they would need to pay an in-lieu fee that would be equivalent to construct those parking spaces off-site. That still stands.

1:39:11 Correct. We didn't identify that in Luffy in the conditions of approval because we don't really know where we would construct it, how much it would cost. That all would be determined as they move forward with the project. So do we look at these parking spaces as a public benefit because they are open to the public when the facility is not at max capacity?

1:39:31 I think one issue with the idea of what the applicant wants to represent as being a, quote, public benefit, at some point the applicant can say, we believe these are public benefits. It's going to be up to the town and the committee to decide whether or not we believe that's a public benefit.

1:39:45 So there may be, you may have a question about things like that, but that ultimately comes down to the final determination of whether in total the community and the council believes that this thing is a public benefit or not. On the parking issue, I would just add that whatever parking solutions are arrived at through the in lieu and the rest of this kind of stuff, that it is integrated into the walk, bike, ride program as the town develops that going forward. So whatever that's going to work in with that program as we develop that going forward.

1:40:16 Sir? Is there anything in these, you know, 12 days here, four nights there, in terms of scheduling it? You know, does this mean that they're going to provide the second week in October and the third week of May, or is there some scheduling priority affixed to that? Any blackout dates? Yeah, we'd probably end up being some exclusion, like for holidays, unless it's unbooked. There would be some limits, most likely, on what we could go in, you know, take, cherry-pick all the...

1:40:43 Most popular days. So there will be some limits on that and on the hotel stuff. We could use any time based on availability, but there would be some that they would have priority use over the town. I think as a general comment, it would be helpful to put, because the fundamental thrust of this is a TOT, it's a financial dollars and cents investment, and I think it would be helpful if staff...

1:41:05 And the proponent could put a specific dollar valuation on these things so we know what the value of this stuff is. How much is 12 nights? What is that actually worth? What is access to the plaza? What are the dollars and cents value of that? I think that would be helpful for decision makers to weigh the relative value of the product. Because the $46 million isn't penciling out for me. All this doesn't seem like a benefit.

1:41:28 To us. Yeah, and let's get all the dollars and cents, and then that would be helpful for you guys to maybe get a sense of words. Let me just answer a little bit on that, because some other fun of this, it's not set up to be a straight dollar-to-dollar match. It's not designed for that. No. We want to get closer, but it's just, I don't understand what you're saying. It's really way out of proportion. I get that it's not supposed to match up. I understand that. The other side of the coin is if there's no development, we're sitting there.

1:41:54 We have what we have. $375,000 a year. And we're looking at increased sales tax and increased spending at other facilities in town. Are those considerations something that would be part of an independent financial analysis? Is the impact of the people visiting this project throughout the rest of the town? And some of that analysis is what is the total...

1:42:18 Imported revenue to the community, if you will. A part of the public benefit is, is it a far better project than what currently exists on the site? Does it have the capacity to fill some of the needs that the town currently doesn't have? I don't want to start arguing for or against it because there's a lot of work to be done here. I think it does for locals especially. A town with 20,000 plus rental beds that can't accommodate a user group of 200.

1:42:44 It's pretty abysmal. Well, this gives us a place to do that. So there are public goods here that are pretty tremendous. That doesn't sway me one way or the other, but I'm putting that as part of that dollar figure of yours. Does it make us a better resort in the end? And that really is the important thing, and a better place to live, work, and play. Yeah, so from my financial perspective, there's things in here like...

1:43:09 The 200 square feet of ground for retail price, what is the value of that? Some of them we can value out. What's that? Some of these we can value out pretty easily. Yeah, the water fountains, things like that. I mean, it's just, this is a, this is a ultimately financial calculus and I think it'd be helpful to have. Yeah, same with the conference room space and the hotel room nights and, and it would be interesting to know, how does that actually compare to the town's needs?

1:43:33 I mean, it's all well and good if they're offering us 12 hotel room nights, but if the town has absolutely no need for those, then how can that be considered a benefit? I'm sure they do. We've got consultants that come in all the time. Okay. Any further thoughts on any of this? The last three things on the list, the shuttle service for the guests, the spa, and potentially the LEED standards, if not actually certified, don't seem to need to be a particular public benefit unless you've got some additional information about those.

1:44:02 The issue on the LEAD side, I mean, I understand why you don't, it's just it's expensive to get a LEAD certification. I know. But the idea there is we want them to build up with those types of standards in place, whether that's a public benefit or not, I think they're planning to do that from a project benefit regardless. So that's more on their side. Right, so unless that could be quantified or it can be certified and we can find a way to use that certification from a marketing standpoint in town, I don't know how that can be considered a public benefit.

1:44:27 The other question I had a little bit is about the conference center. I don't see that mentioned in here anymore. I know that was a topic of conversation. Yeah, it's truly part of the project itself, and that was one of the issues for the modifications. We did that, so it wasn't called out here specifically, particularly as a facility for the DA, but it is a value-added element of the project. Right. I think it's still not the usage. We talk about it, yeah. Yes, it is. We would be able to use it. Okay. Well, although it is hugely

1:44:58 important to call it out. I think in the DA that it's not going to be smaller than what currently is in the, although they would have to come through and re-ratify the whole plan, but that is a huge piece of public benefit as far as I'm concerned. 14,000 square foot. It's actually a bigger public benefit than the spa. Sure. By far. Yes.

1:45:24 Yeah. Yeah, some of us, some of us have had our, you know, chest racks, I suppose. In relates to these benefits? Yes. In general. Yeah. I have a few thoughts. Okay. But not relates to this specific. Okay, good. We'll do some wrap-up at the end. So, public, any thoughts from the public on the, just come on, come on, come on up here, on the,

1:45:53 Identified community benefits. Just one thing real quick. I don't see any benefits compared to what the losses are, but if it goes forward with the so-called TOT reinvestment, I would just humbly request that the referendum period be extended to 60 days so we have time to get it on the ballot. You can do that. State law says 30 days with an agreement between the proponent and the town. You can extend it to 60. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? Yeah, come on up.

1:46:25 Not today. There's going to be time. Not today. We're agendized for one specific topic. Well, yeah, we'll get to that in the end. We'll have five and we'll do a couple minutes in the end. So anything else on this section here? Please come forward, sir. I'm Jim Clark, a resident close by to the development. I'm curious as to where this mid-block...

1:47:02 The connector road is going to go and what's it going to connect with and to. Okay. And, Sandra, that's an approved part of the project, correct? Correct. So it's at the northernmost part of the project between the project and the Mammoth Mall. Okay. So if you look at that map there, it's at the northernmost part of that project. Okay. Jim, can you see that?

1:47:29 Right here, where the cursor is going. It's basically the current hotel driveway. Yeah. Where the bear sign is, where the bears are climbing up the sign, that driveway. Okay, good. Any other comments from the public? Seeing none, I'm going to bring it back up here for anything that we missed, anything that I know, Cleland, you had a thought. We'll just do a kind of whatever.

1:48:00 Left hanging. And then with the time remaining, go back to the public, any final comments, and then we'll wrap it up. So who's got a thought that didn't get aired? I just maybe possibly tied to the whole transit concept. I know that in here is the section about the contribution to the transit shelter. But at any time, was there a discussion or could there be a discussion about contribution towards the actual transit system? We can. Yeah, we can do that. It's a question ongoing.

1:48:28 Or one time. One time. Part of the TOT goes into that. So in one sense they are. TOT, we commit to transit. TOT, there's a percent. From a political commitment. So as part of the analysis, can we include? We could ask for that transit. Something different on that. The question becomes it would end at the termination of DA normally. So if you're going to have an operating subsidy that I'm hearing.

1:48:53 Or additional buses or additional... I just didn't know if there was ever a conversation about an additional contribution towards funding the actual transit system in addition to a transit shelter. Just thinking of our actual town needs right now as we have hundreds and hundreds of more people visiting town. And that could be part of the walk by, maybe it's part of the walk by ride, a way to invest... I think you said that earlier. Operations versus infrastructure is what I guess is my bottom line question.

1:49:20 It could be either, I think. I think both. Because they have some additional infrastructure they have to put in as part of the project. Okay. You had a thought. I just have some comments, if that's okay. Number one is we need to take this so seriously because, face it, town has got a really crappy track record with DAs. And I've been asking people about DAs and I realize nobody knows about DAs in this town. And that's why we need to be...

1:49:50 Especially diligent on this. Number two is I'm very into development. However, we need to leave wiggle room for future developers. I don't see the public benefit. The housing is going to be a big issue. And when I read this, I just felt that this was the biggest overask I had ever seen.

1:50:14 And I need a lot more of these questions, but I don't want these to come out. I think we need to take our time and dig in and do this correctly because this is not something that I am thrilled with to get the first copy of it. Thank you. Anybody else? Any thoughts? I guess the point is any further direction to staff based on what we've heard today? I wanted to follow up on something Shields said earlier about

1:50:44 It being nice to see we're having some development come forward, but that in having an ask from any proponent or developer, if what we're trying to do is kickstart the cycle or get things moving, that whatever timelines we have should be way far on the short end of the scale as opposed to stretching it out. I mean, if we're essentially giving any concessions that are based on

1:51:12 A public benefit of increasing the development cycle or accelerating it, that those benefits should expire on a very short-term basis. Not four years, not six years, like two years. This has already been approved for two years. So saying that they have to go another four years before they gain drawings done or anything else done, what have they been doing the last two years? You know, this isn't really starting from zero. This has already been going on for two years. The other thing I would add to that is

1:51:40 The recitations from the proponent about other...

1:51:45 Projects that have happened in other markets with this kind of TOT investment that I would encourage staff, the proponent, to analyze the relative unique characteristics of a community of 8,000 people with a limited development space and how, you know, what this type of investment, what it means on the scale of things. I think if you're doing something like this in Los Angeles or in a very large market with thousands of hotel rooms, that's a different kind of proposition when we have a very limited...

1:52:11 Potentiality for this kind of stuff, and I encourage you to provide some framework or some sideboards and that kind of thing. Okay, anything else from you guys? We're kind of good? I'm going to go, Brent, I can give you a chance if you have any closing thoughts. Paul had some comments earlier. Did you get those out? Not yet. Okay, do you want to go ahead? Please. Okay. Just looking through the staff report, a couple things came to my mind, and the first is,

1:52:41 When I look at the language and this particular proposal, first thing that came to my mind was the developer's profitability of this project. Is that why the developer is coming forward to ask for this? In addition, developer may be using this particular method to promote the desirability of this project to sell to the next party. And how is that going to affect us in the future? And if that's the case,

1:53:12 We need to consider whether we want to continue to move forward with this or not. Last thing is the message that we are creating here for the rest of the future development that's going to come forward, or that currently have the entitlement approvals, does this mean that we're going to start giving TOT? Yeah, and I think what I've heard today is a very intelligent, focused,

1:53:44 And a forward-looking set of ideas and thoughts coming from everybody here and the public about a proposal like this. But I think we are all interested in setting a foundation for a lot of potential future development. I think we want to make sure we're working with true partners. People are not going to entitle and sell things and do that kind of stuff. We want to work with people who are going to invest in this community. Actually put a shovel in the ground.

1:54:07 And put a shovel on the ground and make this stuff happening. I think we're all aware that this community has now crossed over a threshold where the principal employer and business driver in this community is no longer locally owned and managed. This is going to be driven out of a place called Denver, Colorado. And we're all very much looking forward to standing up and putting our big boy and big girl pants on, as someone has referred to recently, to be really a community.

1:54:32 In and of itself with its own destiny, its own vision well in hand and articulating that and making that happen. And I think that any developers listening to this conversation, watching this process develop, we're very much looking forward to working with good, effective, forward-looking...

1:54:49 Developers that can line up their vision, their project with the vision and mission for the town. So I think those are very good comments and thank you. Finally, Brent, is there any closing words you wanted to add? Then we'll go for some final public comments. I'll just make it very short. I just thank you for the time. I look forward to working with the staff and everybody to follow up on those questions and comments that have been brought forward. I think there's some documentation that we can bring to the table that can help answer the questions. And I'm just going to answer Paul's question, even though it wasn't directed to me. Mr. Demetriatus could have easily sold that property many times over between now and overall.

1:55:18 If you can tell me who else has hung in there over the ups and downs and still here trying to do something in this town, I'd like to know that. But we look forward to moving forward and we thank you for your time. Thank you very much. Finally, any final thoughts from the public? I'm going to tell her it's your time. Is it germane to this project, this development agreement? Okay, yeah, please come on up. My name is Lee Gosch. Affordable housing has been very important to me.

1:55:53 I feel that the town has created much of the problem of affordable housing. When these developers come forward, they were to put some on the project, and I have never seen one put it on the project yet. They should be. When they say they don't want to see the people mingle with their guest, that's an insult to the working people. We're fine people. We are hard workers in this town, and it's degrading to the working people.

1:56:20 Because you're not putting it on the project, you're coming up short with affordable housing now. People don't mind staying in places like that if they're up here for the season or something. I've talked to a lot of people. They're not like, well, I have to live in the middle of the town. I have to live by the stores. I have to live by bonds. It's not like that. People are willing to stay where they can when they come up to ski or for the season or for the summer. But please don't degrade the people like that. Mr. Demetriotis at first was going to put it on the project, and I was very proud of him.

1:56:49 And then when I heard he was taking it off, it really hurt a lot of us. You know, the working people, we wonder why. Why does the town do that? Why do you say we'll do it in lieu of and give it to affordable housing and we don't even have the land to put it on? It's something to think about. He needs to put more on the project and there needs to be more affordable housing than what he has. Thanks. Good. Thank you very much. Anybody else? I'm seeing none. So with that, I'll thank everybody for participating in this. I'm going to ask that staff...

1:57:20 There will be notes. Staff will prepare notes from this meeting that you will share with the commissions, the comments on the public, just to make sure everything got captured. I'm assuming if something was missed, we can provide the comment back to staff. But thank you all very much. Thank you for running the meeting so efficiently. Oh, thank you very much. We appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. We are done.

1:57:40 Walk by the road next week. See you tomorrow. See you tomorrow.