Parks & Recreation Commission · 2017
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 2 hr 10 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
298 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Good morning. I will call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, September 5th, 2017. Roll call, please, Jamie. Good morning.
0:47 At this time, I'll open the floor for public comments. This is the time during which anyone who wishes to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do show. Go on it, Mike. Go on it, Mike. And please just say your name for the minutes, Mike. You can go ahead. Michael Wellwood. Hello, my name is Michael Wellwood. I am the president of Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Club. I wanted to start by thanking Rich Baccia, all the Rec Commission.
1:21 Members of the Forestry and Mammoth Lakes Recreation for their continued support of the Mammoth Lakes first official disc golf course that will hopefully be coming soon. Some updates on our progress. We have raised 20% of the total cost of installing a nine-hole disc golf course in Mammoth Lakes.
1:48 Bad news, we have officially been denied the special use permit required to use the Mammoth Creek East parcel from the forestry. We can't use that area. So basically our main hurdle at this point, we have community support, we have some funds, we just need somewhere to put the course. Let's see.
2:13 I know the town owns some areas in the Whitmore area by the Whitmore track, also the bell-shaped parcel. Those areas, they just don't fit the disc golf need. You know, we need some trees, we need some different terrain, and the bell-shaped parcel just is going to require too much taking out and altering of environment, and I just don't see it as a good option.
2:42 I think our best option is the Shady Rest Park. Just because it's near park facilities, it already has trail systems and stuff going through it, I just see that as the best place to put a disc golf course. I've been in continued contact with Austin Montgomery from Disc Golf Park. They're the company that's kind of like the all-in-one.
3:08 Disc Golf Setup Thing, and so they've done thousands of courses worldwide. He's really eager to help and, you know, continues to support our project in any way he can. Some good news recently, we've been getting contacted.
3:27 On social media, Facebook, you know, Instagram, things like that with people that are visiting Mammoth that want to play disc golf. So they've been hitting us up and we've been taking them out and showing them our humble course in the woods out there. And they've been really impressed with what we what we have. You know, they'd like to see something more legitimate, but they've been having a good time. Yeah, playing with us. And yeah, that's kind of it. Questions for Mike?
3:58 Yeah, I want to ask. Yeah, so what's your plan B? Plan B, I mean, I've been talking to the golf courses. That's a new thing that's happening. It's kind of like a dual golf thing that's been going on. So golf courses to supplement income on maybe slower times. They can put up a disc golf course, you know, and charge us.
4:21 We'd make a tee time, you know, charge us hopefully a discounted rate, you know, compared to golf prices, and we could play on the course, you know, with the golfers side by side. Another option would be getting in touch with the mountain. I've tried, supposedly they have a three-year budget already in the books, so they can't take on any more projects at this time. But yeah, I think that would be plan B.
4:50 If we can't do shady rest, it would be hopefully getting one of the golf courses to help us out and put it on their land or going to the mountain and putting it on their land, yeah. You know, I can probably guess the reasons, but was there a specific quoted reason from the U.S. Forest Service for... Yeah, it was environmental and they saw some obsidian out there and, you know, not being archaeologists or whoever would do the...
5:19 You know, the surveys, they couldn't for sure know, but they said it could possibly be a cultural site, and that was their reasoning for denying it, as far as I understand. So I guess we'll just have you continue to kind of work with staff to see, you know, what we might be able to move forward. You're aware that Shady Rest is also Forest Service. I am aware of that, but yeah, I think we need to be able to work with the Forest Service because everything around here is Forest Service, so if we can't, you know.
5:49 Get together on something, then I don't know how else it will happen. So just a quick question for you. So you mentioned that you didn't think the bell-shaped parcel would be suitable because it would require too much alteration. Anything just...
6:02 Yeah, I went and walked around there, and yeah, the middle of it's got a pretty good creek going through it, which is fine, you know, we can figure that out, but I mean, there's sagebrush, like, up to your chest, it would just require, I don't know, a bulldozer or something, something serious to go through there and just make some sort of walking path, because you gotta figure, you're throwing a disc and it's gonna land in the sagebrush, and you might never get it back at that point, yeah.
6:28 Okay. We need some sort of, you know, low-laying. Got it. Well, thanks for continuing to work on this. Yeah, absolutely. You know, we'll see. I mean, the good news is that the bell-shaped parcel is a town parcel, so. Yeah. Maybe we can see. So, anyway, thank you. Thanks so much for continuing your effort. We're really supportive. Appreciate your time, Mike. So, Chair, staff's happy to put this on an October agenda.
6:52 I think that'd be really helpful. If you wish. I mean, we can start to look at, you know, the understanding from the Forest Service. A lot of their concerns was we couldn't demonstrate a need to utilize Mammoth Creek Park East when we have appropriate property, right? So I think they're coming back saying, you have property, we would be a willing partner, but at that point they felt that further exploration was not warranted.
7:23 So my recommendation is to kind of put it on the October agenda. We can kind of draft a little staff report for you and look at kind of some site selection, kind of what we did a little bit with, you know, a basic Mammoth Creek Park project. You know, if we want to kind of just explore and certainly the event venue kind of process, I thought it actually worked out pretty well, right? We can actually kind of look at a list. Let's kind of rationally go through them. You know, we have some preferred options. We have appropriate funding. We're really just looking for a site.
7:53 the Shady Rest Park parcel off, you know, would the Forest Service willing to extend a use permit for us, you know, or, you know, we're actually going to go through that process this winter with them. There's been a few changes in the Forest Service management, if you're not aware, but Ed Amenter has been replaced as a new Forest Service Supervisor and Margie is now the acting Mammoth Ranger Forest Service District Ranger as we speak.
8:23 So, you know, we're interested to kind of engage a conversation. So I'm optimistic that we can kind of put something together for the Commission for October. I think that would be really helpful because I think we'd really like to see this move forward. Yeah, correct. So do we. I've got some ideas, but let's save it for the October meeting. I think so, too. So I think if we can kind of structure something similar and we can kind of engage MLR in this process and see kind of how we move it along. But I thought the event venue process was a pretty rational way to kind of address this. Okay. Thanks, Stu. Okay.
8:52 Thanks, you guys. Thanks, guys. Okay. Emily. Good morning, everyone. Emily Woods from Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I wanted to formally introduce Matt McLean, my new teammate and co-worker, our new Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Yay. Yay. Welcome, Matt. Good morning. I just wanted to say hello and how excited I am to be here and working.
9:22 back in Mammoth Lakes to enhance our recreational opportunities and I look forward to working with everybody here.
9:28 Awesome. Thanks so much for coming today, you guys. Thanks, Matt. Can we just get a little bit of your background? Sure. Yes. Well, this is kind of my second time moving to the area. I moved to the area back in 1994 to work for the ski area. I worked for the ski area from 94 to 2001. Started off in ski school, worked a little bit in the host department, and then came inside, worked with marketing and sales.
9:56 Left as the Director of Sales, and then I went over to Telluride, worked as their Director of Sales and Marketing for a season, and then went and worked with the Surfrider Foundation in Los Angeles, worked with them for about 11 years, left there, and during that time I'd been sitting on the Board of Directors, a founding board member for Protect Our Winners, worked for them to help them kind of get over some capacity humps.
10:24 And then most recently I've been working for the Catalina Island Conservancy for the past three years as their Director of Sales and Marketing, helping them lead some fundraising efforts for some capital projects and trail expansion program. Very good. Well, welcome. Thanks so much. Thanks, Matt. Matt's officially here now. We actually brought up all his gear on the weekend, so wife's here, cat's here.
10:50 Awesome. And then Matt's going to stay for the discussion on the park project as well. Great. Kind of talk about our communication, fundraising plans and so forth. Good. Super. Thank you. Any other public comments? Okay. Seeing none, I will close public comments and move to the consent agenda. I do want to pull the department report, but I would entertain a motion on item number one, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 1st.
11:17 I will make a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 1st. I'm going to let you second that just because I wasn't here. Oh, sure. Second. All in favor, please say aye, and you may vote even though you are not independent. Aye. Motion passes 3-0. And there are a couple things I wanted to highlight on the staff report. So, Stu, I'll turn it over to you, but if you could just talk about the September 7th meeting as well as
11:49 Walk, bike, ride, and give us a quick update on the deferred maintenance program. Yeah, of course. Thank you, Chair. So we've scheduled a special meeting on Thursday, 4 o'clock in the community center, and that's just kind of our annual focus group discussion. So we do schedule it. We do want to make sure it's publicly noticed as a special meeting so you can all attend and participate. So that's going to be 4 o'clock up in the community center. We have seven, maybe more people coming.
12:19 That will be a good discussion. We have kind of some questions framed out from the survey already. So if you do want to request some information or a little detail on a little bit more information, we can send that to you. So just let us know. The deferred maintenance items, just kind of start on page two, and then we'll kind of double back with the September 6 meeting.
12:44 So just a quick update on the tennis court. So we did get a revised quote back from Great Western Recreation to do the tennis court rehabilitation project. I've also attached a memo in here at the end of the staff report that we pushed out on August 14th. Just to our tennis community, there was a lot of frustration expressed on Facebook and just word of mouth about the poor state of the courts. We absolutely agree.
13:10 I realise it's been a very frustrating process for all of us, but we do have a plan in place and we're looking at getting those courts repaired in the spring. The choice was to kind of look at either doing in the fall or the spring, and as you know, the fall is not a great time because it'll snow on it again. So we want to kind of come out of the gate with rehabilitated courts in spring.
13:30 So we have that kind of all lined up. The same crew that will be doing the tennis courts will also be building and installing the bleachers for Shady Rest Park as well. So we're not going to put out the new bleachers in the wintertime. We're going to wait again until spring. That's a big investment for us. That was a $30,000 investment with bleachers. But if you've been out there recently to Shady Rest, you've seen kind of the siding project underway at the Snack Shack. It's a great project. They found several bats.
13:57 Squirrels, Resident Wildlife, Been doing a great job, so that'll really help. So that was Shady Rest Park, so that's all happening, and then we completed the town facility condition assessment at Whitmore Pool. So Terracon came out on August 23rd, and they conducted a one-day, what's called facility condition assessment of the pool, and they kind of evaluate the current and future condition of the pool, mechanical equipment.
14:24 Sanitation System, and so forth. And we'll have their assessment report by hopefully the end of the month of October. So we can kind of bring that, sorry, end of September, we can bring that to the commission in October. And that'll be a valuable document to kind of provide some good insight into kind of what happens next at the pool. And then tomorrow at three o'clock, there's a presentation from three to six.
14:51 on walk, bike, ride and the downtown revitalisation project. So there's a 2.0 action plan that's been published. It's currently online. If you do want to have a look at it, I recommend you do come along and at least listen in or at least watch live on Granicus to understand what's being proposed.
15:09 Yeah, and on that, I just want to mention because there have been things proposed for both Mammoth Creek Park as well as the Community Center Park. So I think it's time for our commission to really start to engage with that process. So I will be there on Wednesday. But it'd be great if you guys had a chance to take a look and kind of see what the proposals are so we can weigh in. What time is it? Three o'clock on Wednesday. Okay. And Jamie, is that going to go all the way to six, do you think?
15:41 I recognize it's not up to you. Okay. Thank you. And I actually don't have that on my calendar. Where is that location? Right here. It's prior to the regular council meeting. Okay. I have a tourism meeting, so I will not be able to attend the first part of it, but I'll try and make the second happen. So you can just spend your whole day. Yeah. My excuse is gone. Awesome. Thank you. I was looking forward to it. Any questions for Stu? Yeah, I had a question.
16:15 The town-wide MUPS, what was going on with them last week? There was some repaving or some such happening up in the lakes basin. Yeah, they're just doing some, yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so that happened three days prior to, you know, the Labor Day weekend, so they just had some resurfacing up there as well, just to clean those MUPS up, get them done. That was really the availability of the contractor at the time. It's just getting, it's a very difficult time and there's so many projects going on.
16:42 That was that window of opportunity. So they got a good slurry seal up there. Great. I believe it was open by Friday because I at least walked down to the village on Friday. I just knew that we still had on the list that we were inventorying and seeing what needed to be done but had already had some work being done. So just wondering how that all worked in there. Thank you. And one other question. Is there any chance that you guys are going to put bat boxes or something like that on the snack shack?
17:11 Keep those bats around, keeping them eating the insects and keeping the bug population down. Yeah, worthwhile considering. We're just trying to stop them from getting inside the building. I understand that. There's a lot of OSHA stuff going on with that. Is that right? That was my first thought when you said that you had found some in there. Oh, well, let's make a spot for them. Keep the bugs down. Yeah. Yeah, I think bat boxes in the park would be great. Yeah. Cool. Any other questions?
17:37 I just want to say on the tennis, I want to really just assure the tennis community that, you know, the town is in no way trying to be negligent about the courts. It's just incredibly difficult to find people to come and do the resurfacing work at a reasonable rate. So I'm excited that that's going to move forward in the spring. And please take a look at the memo if you haven't already. Okay, so I would entertain a motion to accept the department report if there's no further discussion.
18:07 Also move. I'll second. A motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye of accepting number two, the Parks and Recreation Department monthly report. Aye. Motion passes. 3-0. That brings us into our discussion items. So are we expecting anyone from youth hockey? Or should we? Do you want to do the first one? Do you want to take it? We could take it out of order if we're expecting them to come.
18:38 Is that all right with you, Kat? All right. Great. So we'll take item three. We'll go ahead and move to item four in our discussion items, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Plan MCP Update. I will kick things off, and then we'll have Grady and his expertise give us an update. So just our monthly update on our Plan MCP project. So we'll run through with this update kind of an overview of the facility design.
19:19 Recreation Programming Committee, I've attached the meeting notes from that, if you're able to attend. We can give you a brief update and presentation on the Anaheim Ice Facility Tour. Then also, I just participated in this brief design review on Thursday last week, and then upcoming is the design review with the PEDC on September 13th. Grady's going to walk you through kind of the latest on the construction timeline and some cost estimates.
19:49 And then we have an ad hoc committee meeting running with MLR as well for the last four meetings. And we have kind of an outline of an action plan here that we want to present to you of what we're currently working on. And then Matt's also going to kind of give us an update on that as well. I'll just run through facility time and then Grady, you want to just jump in on construction.
20:15 We have a design set of plans right now, about 25-30%. If you're lucky enough to kind of see the virtual presentation, it was pretty enlightening here. Sorry, the late notice. We do have a little version here if you want to jump in and look at it after the meeting. It's kind of fun. But we also have an opportunity to kind of, you know, go through the plans, and we're really looking at ways that we've been analysing it based on the space, operational efficiencies.
20:44 of that facility. So we're still working through that design and really want to make sure that the operations is an effective way that we can kind of deliver that for the community. We presented that to our Recreation Programming Committee last week on the 25th and that was kind of our design plans on the wall which went really well. We had most of our design, sorry, our programming committee attend. Thought it was very beneficial.
21:12 We had some great input. That's attached to this document as well if you want to kind of go through those. But again, the goal there was just to kind of make sure that the programming and what we've kind of stated in the playbook still affirms the design of the facility. So we came up with some good recommendations that we'll consider in the future. Staff again with HMC on August 3rd, tour at Anaheim Ice Facility. So I've got those notes in there.
21:38 What's intriguing about that facility is it actually has both an NHL and Olympic size ice sheet and I've got some images back in there that kind of shows you the difference. So it's pretty good. It was good to see. We did get some good design elements from that facility tour and we continue to kind of look at facilities as we kind of move along. The Planning and Economic Development Commission meets on September 13 and that's kind of we believe at this time if they can kind of make the deadline.
22:06 Get Everything Squared Away. That'll actually be the official design review. It doesn't go to council after that. That's their process. And then I've just kind of provided some notes on what they actually will be looking at. You can see, A, does it still conform with the zoning code, general plan, design guidelines, colour handbooks, other applicable documents. The design committee actually met on Thursday, so we're actually participating in a conversation with them.
22:34 And then that's their official review and approval on the 13th. What we could probably do now, unless we want to kind of double back, but while Grady's here, we can kind of run through kind of construction timeline cost estimates, and then I can kind of jump up if you need to and walk through some of the designs if so need be. Sure. Thanks, Stu. I'm going to take this a little bit backwards. Item 2.
22:59 Let's say D is actually the timeline of the construction with Spees Construction. That project was awarded a few weeks ago. Originally scheduled to start work immediately after the Design Review Committee or the PEDC meeting, which was scheduled for September 13th. In discussion with Spees, they actually said, we haven't actually executed the contract yet. They're also doing, they did the work up at Lakes Basin. They're working on Upper Main Street. And their comment was, well, look, we could, we're,
23:29 Refined was starting in October and still finishing this year. And in fact, they had a slight preference for waiting if necessary until, say, February or March. As long as the site isn't covered with six feet of snow, they're confident they can still get the work done before spring. So we'll work that out with them. The second item is the PEDC meeting. We had a preliminary meeting last week with the design committee. They took a look at a lot of the color boards, a lot of the architectural issues. We didn't have all the materials boards available.
23:58 for them yet. And in a design review committee meeting this morning with staff, it was suggested that we move the PEDC meeting to October 11th. So Stu, you're absolutely accurate. It changed 15 minutes ago. Between staff and the PEDC members, they felt that that didn't delay the project whatsoever to get them a better chance to get everything together and meet on October 11th. So that design review will now be October 11th with PEDC.
24:25 The third item is really the cost estimates and 3A, I guess, is a presentation we want to do to Town Council on September 20th. HMC, the architects, has been working with a specific building contractor, building supplier named Butler Buildings for over a year on this project. They've gone through a lot of iterations. Unfortunately, and this is the bad news, about four weeks ago when HMC met with Butler,
24:54 and said, we're ready to sign the contract for the roof building. Butler came back and said, unfortunately, our cost estimates were off. We have our engineers involved, and we think the cost could be $900 or a million more than what is in our estimates at this time. The initial reaction was to, I'll just say, do terrible things to HMC and Butler. It's something that happens in the industry. It's more than extremely disappointing, and the level of...
25:23 Consternation that we had in the office, frankly, was, you know, it's hard to measure, frankly. We were extremely disappointed. We immediately attacked the cost estimates. Well, we found that there were three items, really, to talk to. One was the roof structure itself. Just, that's it. It's a million dollars more based on the current estimates. We started looking at ways to do it differently. We checked steel prices, all sorts of things. It's still going to end up in about that area. We've asked HMC to go back to the cost estimates using both the
25:52 Contractor that they used for cost estimating and the actual survey or construction estimator that they used, and they're supposed to get back to us this week with not just an explanation, which an explanation doesn't do us any good, it just makes us understand it better, I guess, but also some options and some things that look at the various building components to show us any other changes that have happened.
26:14 The second item in that was design contingencies. Their estimator continues to say, well, look, at this stage of the project, you guys should have about a 10% design contingency. We've frankly been pushing back against that because...
26:29 We believe that we can reduce the cost as to both increase them. And frankly, in the last month or so after the visit up to Ben and some of the operational things, we've actually decreased the size of the building and decreased the cost by a couple of hundred thousand. So, I mean, we're making good progress there, so we're not concerned with that. The bigger issue, frankly, that I wanted to bring up today and talk to town council about on September 20th is that from an industry standpoint throughout California,
26:56 At least, I can't speak to the rest of the nation, but throughout California, construction costs are going up because everybody is getting even busier than before. Now, we've been through these cycles before in other areas of the state. As you know, it's almost impossible to guesstimate or estimate a project in Mammoth Lakes anyway, and this is going to make it that much more difficult. We frankly don't know at this time whether that means the cost is going to stay flat or if it's going to increase based on this. We're monitoring it as best we can.
27:26 To give you an example, though, of two of the larger projects we've done recently, a road rehab project, which we know how to estimate asphalt. We've done a lot of paving in this area and in town. The road rehab project that's under construction, of which the MUPS were part, by the way, our estimate was about $1.3 million. The bid came in, the low bid at $1.33 million. So we were very close on that. The second bid, though, and that's what I want to point out, was $1.63.
27:54 So we had two bidders, and the variance between the two was well over 20%. We found the same thing on the police station. We had two bidders on that. The variance was over 20%. And that just, you know, talks to the construction climate in Mammoth.
28:09 Regardless, we don't know what's going on with the state except that the trend is up. The trend is that everybody's getting busy. So if in a normal climate that would make it competitive, we'd actually get better numbers. But once it gets to a point where the market is saturated and you just can't find subcontractors, that makes prices go up. So we are very concerned with this. That's why before we did anything else, we wanted to come here, give you an update. We were able to give an update to the funding subcommittee.
28:39 A few days ago, we want to get to two town council on September 20th with a full estimate and a full update on what that means to the project. That's really the, you know, that's really about it. Again, we want to get back to the September 20th and we'd welcome any comments you have regarding that. I wish I could provide you with an update and estimate today, but suffice it to say that it's at least a million dollars higher than we were estimating before and we are...
29:08 We are not interested, if you will, at least from a public work standpoint, we are not ready to recommend to Town Council that we start work on site until we have this meeting September 20th. That's why the PEDC delay also didn't bother us, because even if it was September 13th, we would not recommend starting on site until such time as we get back to Town Council and let them know what's going on. There are a lot of options, of course. We can still do the site work this fall and have it ready for whenever it starts.
29:37 I have expressed, however, before that we were, I guess not, uncomfortable isn't the right word, but we were not real happy about starting construction when we still had a million and a half gap in funding. You know, it was very clear that Town Council authorized eight million dollars, the million and a half gap needed to be filled. We were very comfortable doing the site work, but we wanted to see where that funds were coming from, whether it was guaranteed by Town Council on some other format or what before we started in earnest.
30:06 Last week at the Funding Ad Hoc Committee, one of the things that we explained to the committee as a whole, and it was the first time I'd had a chance to meet Matt and get to talk to him a little bit, is we let him know that on the 20th he's going to be one of the stars of the show, if you will. I realize he's been here all of how many days.
30:24 and trying to get up to speed, but I think he's done a great job in getting up to speed on some of the larger issues around the project, the design itself. He was able to go down with Stu and Colin last week to visit the Kings, and I think what Town Council is going to be looking for from that ad hoc committee is here's our program. That doesn't mean they have a million dollars yet or a million and a half or three million, whatever it's going to take. It also doesn't mean that Town Council is going to ask
30:52 this subcommittee to come up with more than a million and a half. Again, that's for discussion at Town Council on the 20th. But we did ask that he would be able to provide some kind of an update to Town Council on September 20th as part of our presentation, at least how the approach is going to be and kind of the program. We understand it's not fleshed out, but it's going to be a key part of that. So, Stu? Any questions for Grady on the follow-up? There might be.
31:19 I'm assuming. What I was going to do was just kind of walk through a little bit of the design changes. So we can either go questions now or after we kind of run through the design. The key point here is kind of showing you the changes we've made to the designs from kind of when we started with the preliminary designs, which is this version here, to kind of where our latest ones, which is right there. So, I mean, Grady kind of talked about a lot of cost savings, but also programming.
31:43 and operational changes as well. So I'm happy to... I do have some comments and questions because this is the first I'm hearing of this. Yep. But at the same time, it might be best for you to go through your items unless, Grady, you need to leave. Yeah, let's have Stu just walk through the design changes and then we can ask questions of staff and we can take public comment and then we can kind of deliberate because I'd like us to provide some input to council. And Jeff, just to let you know, we took your item out of order. So we'll come back to it if that's all right with you. Yeah, so this is kind of a...
32:12 Version that we came up with based on kind of the playbooks, designs, you know, and comments from our community and our first stab at it. So just really kind of quickly on the highlighting areas. I don't have a laser pointer. But the big change was essentially, you know, the site work hasn't really changed. You know, you obviously see the existing parking lot. We've still got 37 additional parking spots. Some of the changes that we can see here on the corner, if you go and you look right at the...
32:40 Community Centre here, this corner area, again, just from sizing, space saving, design, we've kind of eliminated that section, so it's one big consistent block now, you can see, so you can kind of see the design change there, so it was really a way to kind of reduce the footprint of the roof and try and reduce some cost, and we've made changes to still try and create that social and views of the show, and so we've kind of incorporated that. The other changes here is kind of this large
33:08 Patio area that I'm kind of pointing to right here is concrete area adjacent to the playground. You can see on the newer designs we've eliminated all this kind of concrete patio but we still have this main patio adjacent to the rink on this south side, east south side down here and you can still see we still have the same playground orientation.
33:30 So it's still just over 7,000 square feet. So that remains, as does all the natural park and play elements as well with our boulders. So not much different there. As we move through some of this design here, I'm going to go through some key areas that we've seen some changes with. One is, as we roll down, a lot of the changes have been not so much with the design. We have two design changes, and that was really due to the roof designs.
33:59 That we came back with. So you can see kind of here the large entranceway, which is kind of that big atrium kind of lobby area. That was really scaled down a lot. That was kind of what we believe was a big expense for not very much functional gain. So we kind of reduced that, but also still trying to create that sense of arrival. So we're still kind of working with the designers of that. The roof structure design doesn't really change too much. We've kind of cleaned up a lot of the materials on the side.
34:29 Kind of colors, you know, bits and pieces like that. But really the bigger change is kind of this. If you look at kind of where we've started, I know this was a big part of our design and it was kind of where we really started from. It was kind of the look and feel we were looking for with that big open sense of arrival lobby space. That was around about two and a half thousand square feet of space. So if you look at the total square footage of the facility,
35:01 That represented a large portion and percentage of kind of the area. And what that space had to do was kind of congregate, serve skates, summer, winter, concession space, also had kind of restrooms, locker rooms, kind of had that fireplace, had the meeting area, you know, the social kind of interaction with also kind of a view of the facilities, view of the facilities. So it was really designed to work really hard, but our...
35:28 Site visits and our discussions with a lot of our rink operators was it's a very ineffective and very kind of underperforming area so we kind of made changes to that I'll go back with and then if you see in the newer design as we kind of scroll through this which is again on the wall we've filled in the lobby area so if you see what we have now little kind of different roof designs
35:54 So again, it doesn't look as appealing. We're still kind of working with our designer on that. But the purpose of this space here is to kind of be 100% operational for winter. So the challenge that we really believed that was going to happen was a 2,500 square foot open lobby area would act as a big breezeway. It's very cold. It's not heated. The challenge was going to be serving from the operational space.
36:21 Serving skates, rentals, hot chocolate. We would have to be in our little windows again so you'd have staff inside, nice and warm, and all the public on the outside, you know, being challenged with the weather. Great for summer, just very ineffective for winter operations. So what we did was, I'll show you kind of these next images. So you can see here, this is kind of the lobby space now. So as you walk into that space on the left, it's all very open.
36:47 So very, from a guest experience point of view, we think it's a lot more welcoming, a lot more interactive, a lot more engaging. Right on the left there is kind of the skate rental pickup or summer's, you know, equipment. At the end of that is our concession space. On the right we have currently showing some locker rooms and restrooms, but we're kind of reconfiguring that. The lobby area is now elevated, so it's 30 inches above the rink, and that was a big point of our discussions with certainly the pavilion, certainly with a lot of the comparable ice facilities.
37:17 That you need to be able to kind of look down on the rink just from a kind of a tiering of spectators and also kind of perspective. So as you walk down into this lobby space here, we have kind of a market table set up. You have this little bench tables and then we have like a little counter at the end with some kind of bar stools so folks can actually sit down, put their drinks, food, look down into the facility. And this is a big five foot high kind of glass window that collapses in summertime. So in wintertime it's sealed up.
37:46 But in summertime, we open it up. So again, we're still trying to balance that inside-outside. So wintertime becomes a very high-performing, functioning area, keeps everybody warm, engaging, very interactive. And then in summertime, we open it up, and you get that kind of summer feel.
38:03 So that was kind of the change there, and that was a big operational change that we made. We also reduced the size of that lobby space as well, so it went from 2,500 square feet to just under 2,000. It's about 1,500. But again, we needed to make sure that the community center space was not being shrunk with storage space. So a lot of the need that we determined from that.
38:29 Community was that community space was so valuable. So we wanted to make sure that the community center was two and a half thousand square feet. But what was happening once we added all the storage and the restrooms and all the rest of it was getting encroached upon and it was dropping down into a two thousand square foot facility. And that was kind of an area that we felt was kind of long.
38:48 Uncompromising. I think the goal is to try and keep that valuable space open and programmable. So we move the storage onto the rink. We move some other areas to kind of bring it back to the two and a half thousand square feet. And this is a great view. This is actually if you're at that kind of bar area, you're actually looking from the bar down into the facility. And you can see we've tried really hard and it's still a balance. It's still going to be a challenge. We understand with the views. So if I go to this next view,
39:18 You're now in the middle of the rink itself, so you're in the middle of Olympic-sized ice rink. You can see center ice is just above you. And we've kind of kept that openness. So we've really tried hard to, with the sloping roof, with these big louvers, these are big two-foot metal louvers that are angled. They're not going to move. They're a fixed louver, right? So based on the sun and the trajectory of the ice and the wind and whatever we're kind of forecasting right now, it's a fixed louver. And on the southeast side,
39:48 They're fixed louvers as well. They're about a two foot high louver that does the same. So again, we know we're going to still work with challenges with our wind and weather. But again, the goal from the design and what our community was really telling us was make sure this is, you know, has still those great views of the Sherwands in the area. That's great. I'd just like to emphasize that these changes were not what we would plan
40:12 Value engineering changes. These weren't driven by costs, very frankly. This was driven by some site visits and some great work by the team, again, to come back. And every one of these are enhanced to design. And really, again, we're letting the programming and the operations drive the design. So while we really like that large breezeway entrance,
40:33 Frankly, from the beginning, the architect said we should probably enclose it anyway. We pushed back against that. This works so much better from a customer standpoint and still affords the views to the south and still affords the openness that was in the vision for the entire project. So, again, I want to emphasize these are not cost-cutting measures by any means. It happened that they did reduce the size and did save quite a bit of money.
40:57 They were really driven by the programming, Stu. I mean, that was really it. And operations and your visit to Bend brought back a lot of good information. Thanks. Yeah, let me just quickly wrap up here on the site. So this is kind of a floor plan of that kind of community center space. And if you kind of where the original one was and how that kind of laid out, you'll kind of see a little bit clearer on kind of why these were really needed changes.
41:25 So this shows you the community centre space we had here on that large left. And if I'm looking at that right, that's just over 2,000 square feet. But what this shows was, you know, there's a storage, there's storage, there's sinks. And then we kind of had this open hallway that kind of gave you access to the restroom, janitor's closet, and some offices there. So on one hand, it was great from a...
41:52 A guest point of view, because they can actually just come straight in and move into the community centre. But the challenge was this space here was now so ineffective. It was just really not operational. We can't run 500 pairs of skates in the middle there, still run a concession booth and have staff and so forth supporting it. So that was a real challenge. This was the big open area here. You can see the challenge here that we had was once people came in, beautiful fireplace, but it took up so much of that space.
42:22 Where were people going to put their skates on and store their gear and so forth? And then you can see over on the left here we still have the restrooms and locker rooms. So that space now, I think that's the best one. Let me just see if I can find a better one that's not so dark. I think that's probably it. That does give you a highlight. So now you can kind of see that the space here for the community centre is all squared out and the storage is right here. It's actually on the rink surface itself.
42:51 This actually attaches to that community centre and it's a larger storage than we had and it's about what we anticipate being able to store all our tables and chairs and the gymnastics equipment. What we're still looking at over here is when you come in, we're still talking about designs and lockers and our feedback so forth. There's been, from a number of sources, four locker spaces. It's about the number for a one-eye sheet.
43:18 We're actually showing six in this design right now. So we're kind of looking at still kind of based on our programming needs, moving or re-kind of designing a little bit of those locker spaces. And the challenge here as well is that we're actually trying to find functional space for our staff. So we're looking at having an office space for both our recreation supervisors, program facilities coordinator in our office and our site staff as well.
43:44 Essentially what we see is kind of not only will be the hub for our parks and rec summer camps and programs, it'll be the hub for parks and recreation period. I mean this will be the go-to place for everybody in our community to sign up for programs, facilities and so forth. So we see this really doing double duty as well.
44:02 As you move into this lobby space, if I come in this way, which is where the guest comes in, now you can see they've got access right here to our rentals, areas, welcoming, concessions. We're looking at actually having a flow-through into the community centre, so if you are having an event on the community centre space, you'll be able to access or at least have the ability to utilise the concession space, either kind of that warming kitchen idea. There'll still be a restroom and we're looking at moving this office space to kind of create some storage.
44:29 For the Arts and Crafts and those type of programs. But here you can see all this lobby space is now fully functional and usable, right? So again, when people came in before, there was really no place for them to sit and really enjoy or watching the experience. So we've had all these market tables. That's the bench. It's elevated. It comes right out to the end. And on either side, you have sloping ramps that move down to the ice sheet itself. So as you kind of move down, you're away from the facility. If we move down to the next view,
44:59 Which I think actually you have to go up, which is this view here. Just really quickly, so you've come out of the facility. This is kind of where we're showing the full locker rooms down here. So what we're inclined to do here is add to these locker rooms. Neither we're talking about basic amenities, having kind of a restroom, or we're still talking about shower spaces and whatever that might look like.
45:20 But we've kind of developed this area over here that will be well-serviced locker rooms. So we don't or we're kind of resisting the urge to have hockey players and a lot of our kids and adults moving in and out of the lobby area space with their lockers or with their gear. You know, I think it's not a very good mix.
45:40 People, no offence to Jeff and his hockey players, but I think they really prefer to be, as they come in and check out, have their own area, and that would be the same for our summer camps and programs. As the kids come and check in to the camp in summertime, that will be their basic hub. So they would come in, you're in locker room A, go and store your gear, you know, go to the toilet, wash up, come out, and then they're on the either camp or utilising the facility. But again, we're kind of segregating, you know, a lot of our user groups based on the program.
46:08 This area will be developed here. It could be kind of coming around in a kind of a dog leg or a corner shape. So we'll have two locker rooms, two locker rooms, still kind of need our storage space. And again, this is our mechanical and Olympia Zamboni room as well. And then the changes as well you've seen is it's still Olympic ice sheet, but all the player boxes and the scorekeepers and the penalty boxes are all on one side of the rink.
46:34 So they're on this kind of westerly side over here, which leaves you full access on this side of the entrance side. And then we've built in kind of tilt and roll bleachers for the public on this side as well. So that's kind of your spectator area. This is the play area. We have either end.
46:52 Gates can kind of open up in summertime for either arena soccer or again the multi-use use of events and so forth and then we see once you've seen the designs all this on this side here will be opened up with kind of barn doors kind of gates so it'll be kind of opened up to allow inside outside movement from our guests either from an event point of view or our summer camps and programs because folks will kind of head out on this big concrete patio.
47:19 Which will be adjacent to the enhanced playground here on the side. So that's kind of how that design has changed. It's morphed. It'll still continue to kind of, you know, go through some tweaks and design changes as we move this along. But the goal right now is to kind of get it to a point where Grady is comfortable with kind of a cost estimate. We can kind of continue moving forward. There we go. It's my presentation from before and after. And we're really excited with it. We've talked to a lot of people. We've done so many side visits.
47:49 As I said, we were down with the Kings on Friday. They're very intrigued with the facility. Look forward to kind of, you know, furthering that discussion. But they have specific needs. To put this in play, if they really want to use this facility, we're going to have to have some discussions on what goes into that facility and has it going to impact the design and the cost and so forth. But that's an ongoing discussion that we're moving through right now with. Thanks, Jim. And that design. Yeah, just to wrap up on the design, this is...
48:18 Frankly, very typical if you're coming from, say, 15 or 20 percent design to get to full preliminary design. This is what you want to happen. These kind of refinements and, frankly, except for the roof, you know, cost reductions. But, you know, again, except for the roof issue, you know, we're very satisfied with the progress that's been made. You know, again, we're really excited about it, too. The cost estimates are the big issue. Just the roof itself, that's about 12 percent.
48:44 You know, again, that's within variance of what the bids that we see opened up on bid day, but that's not acceptable if you don't have all the money in hand already. So we're very concerned about that. One comment I will make is after we started looking at the prices of steel, instead of just using Butler, going to look at that. We're going to look at every avenue we can to get that down as well. I even ran into Jeff the other night, and he mentioned that the gentleman that suggested a certain steel roof and...
49:12 Providing that material is still interested, so we're going to reach out to them as well and say, hey, look, this is where we are on the design. Please give us your input. If you see anything, you know, all hands on deck at this point in time to try to solve that problem. So appreciate that contact, and we'll get back with them as well. Thanks, too. Thanks for the presentation. So what I'd like to do now is...
49:34 Do questions of staff and then if we have any public comments and then we'll our direction is we can provide direction to staff by motion or consensus. So we'll do kind of a deliberation after the questions. I'm sure there are several.
49:49 Sean, would you like to start? Well, I've got to say, I'm very disappointed with the cost. And, you know, if this were a business move, we've based a business plan based on some estimates that we've got from a contractor, and I don't know. They've put us in a very difficult situation where we need to answer to the public, but at the same time, and we made decisions to go forward based on this estimate that we had. We paid for that estimate, didn't we?
50:15 So what kind of guarantee do we have that, you know, would they even do the work? I mean, I could have come up with a number. I mean, I'm sorry to be so, I'm really upset about this, just as far as what are we doing to get some kind of, these guys to take responsibility for this? Well, there's two things that we...
50:39 We can do. One is certainly we cannot pay them for the previous estimate, so we've already entered into discussions with them about that. In the last round, frankly, we had two estimates. We had their professional estimator, and we also had a contractor look at it to get where we were. And the only bust, if you will, and it was very grave, is the roof itself.
51:00 In HMC's contract, it actually has our overall cost estimate of $9.5 million in their contract, and if they feel at any time that the price is going to go outside of 10% of that, they have to do any redesign without.
51:14 Any further compensation? That's really kind of an industry standard. That's about all we can do. We can't make them work for free. We could fire them and start over again, which we're not recommending at this time. We want to see where we go in the next couple of weeks with cost estimates with the industry and see where we can go. But there's not as much recourse as we'd like. They're not going to step up and just give us a million dollars to solve the problem. Neither is Butler, neither are the steel manufacturers or suppliers. It's, yeah, I,
51:45 I share your pain, if you will, as best I can say it. Believe me, it's been a very difficult month to try to get this back in and try to analyze what happened and what we can do moving forward. Yeah, I'm really feeling bait and switched here that this is very difficult. Let me move on. I may come back with some more comments along these lines, but that's very disappointing. So what is our total budget these days then?
52:12 Well, it was 9.5 with the roof. It's a 10.5. Really, the...
52:18 The contingency issue and the cost escalation due to the industry in California right now is a difficult one. We don't know. I mean, that could add another million dollars. And we won't know, frankly, until bid day, you know, what that is. That's why we want to get back to council and talk about contingency plans and say, look, we're not just looking for a million and a half now. We may be looking at two and a half or to have a factor of safety, maybe as much as three million dollars over and above the eight and a half to make sure that on bid day we can open the bids and we can...
52:47 Can actually award the project, not have to make another decision at that point. Certainly we briefed the town manager, we briefed the finance director, a couple of council people, the funding subcommittee last week, as soon as we knew that this was real, in other words, we didn't want to just react the day we heard it, we did a bunch of research on it, and we'll come back to the council on September 20th, but we don't have a good plan moving forward yet in terms of the funding.
53:17 Okay, that's not going to go over well. Nope. How much do we have raised so far? I don't know if I heard that number. We're going to do a quick update on that after this video. All right. Let me move on to just some other things that you said. First of all, I have no problem with the open breezeway. As much as I liked the open breezeway, it was going to be cold. It could have been a wind tunnel. So that is entirely enclosed. Is that correct? Yep.
53:42 I would like to make sure, and I don't mean to be getting into design, now's not the time to be doing that, but I do like the idea that that room is being left open for future uses that we don't even know could become important to us here in the next couple of decades. The entrances to the ice rink itself.
54:06 We had talked about the opportunity in the summer, not necessarily in the winter, of being able to move in displays or equipment if there's, and I want to make sure, you know, we had actually talked about it being a showroom floor, perhaps a convention type space if that's where we wanted to go. I just want to make sure that that is still something that's available, that if we do have
54:32 You know, whatever the case may be, some kind of showroom that we're able to still drive vehicles or equipment or displays, be able to set up large displays in that area in the summer. I think that came up at the Programming Committee meeting, too. Yeah, so really the goal there, Sean, would become off this fire access road in through the back of the Zamboni room, the Olympia room.
54:56 That's a roll-up garage door, and you're actually going through a 14-foot wide gate, so we're actually going to, for some of the time, taking out elements of the dasher board to give us that width. So that'll give you in and out on either end. Again, this end here is kind of concrete patio, you really can't go too far on that end. If you're coming out here, can't get my little mouse, yeah, because you really can't be driving anywhere kind of out on that area there, and again, we just have to look at the integrity of the
55:27 The concrete surface itself, just on kind of a weight issue of vehicles and so forth on that area. Absolutely. I mean, that's really that it came up on that programming meeting. We talk about it a lot and we want to make sure it's used for that and hence the sport court material we're looking at now is kind of a more all-weather material. It has some, you know, high loading, not as susceptible to the wind and weather and it's easier to clean and take care of as well. So we don't see that being as kind of an issue.
55:57 Certainly encourage that. Height on the door is all good. Yeah, actually, the beauty of this roof design right now is actually it's a 30-foot high ceiling, so it's a lot higher than what it was before, so the additional money, we're actually getting five feet of height. It's not higher on the exterior. It's the same 35 feet. There's no change related to that, but on the interior, we've picked up some space. Right, so there's no, you know, you know.
56:23 height adjustment on the outside. It's really a 30-foot high ceiling on the inside. So it's 30-foot high to 25. So from that perspective and for summer programming, it's a lot more advantageous. Okay. Moving on to the storage area. So I heard you say that we're losing the one area, but we're gaining it elsewhere. How much is the storage area actually being decreased? Right now it's actually the same, but we've just taken it outside of the community center itself.
56:52 and put it kind of on the rink surface that is adjacent to the community center space. Does that make sense? So we've taken the, it's about 400 plus square feet of storage out of the community center, put it attached to the community center. So same amount of storage, it just doesn't take up the user, I mean the programmable space. Okay. I'd like to hear a comment just with regard to having the player boxes on the opposite side.
57:18 of the ice rink. I don't know if that's good or bad or whatever the case, but I'd love to have you comment on that, Jeff. Yep. Oh, okay, good. Glad we could incorporate that then. Okay. It's where the designs are going right now and it works out really well. Okay. Anaheim is intrigued, quote unquote. What can we do to firm that up and make sure that we don't have another situation here where
57:47 We're told one thing. We actually go forward with this business plan. I don't want to be switched on this one. I just want to make sure that we're doing everything that we can to make sure that they are more than intrigued. The kings? Yes. Yes. We have a follow-up again later this week, so we'll try and get something formal to them. Okay. So that's really the goal. We've had two meetings. We've had two dates. Okay.
58:14 So looking at furthering that relationship. Looking for our third date. You know, our indication, Matt can maybe talk about this too, but our indication is certainly worthwhile pursuing that relationship just to see kind of where we can really take it. But it was a great relationship from the point of view of, you know, potential sponsorship to all the way from bringing, you know, development teams, programmings, hockey camps and so forth. So I mean, we were looking, really looking at a broad gamut of opportunities with that organization.
58:44 You know, the ball's really in their court. But what it would mean for us, though, is we do have some design elements that we'd need to address if we want to further that relationship based on their needs. So that's kind of really where we're trying to firm that down right now. And hopefully we can get that kind of sorted out in the next month. I'm going to stop my comments there. Okay. But you may want to come back, as you said. Okay. Laurel, questions for staff? I'm also disappointed to hear the number jump. I know we don't need to beat that.
59:12 Over and over, but I just want to express that. I had some questions about the elevation of the lobby area and the viewing. I know it looked like you had kind of bar stool height chairs. What if somebody's sitting in a wheelchair looking out to the court? Right. And your question, make sure that they have access to the rink, right? Yeah, and I mean, even sitting in the chairs,
59:41 30 inches doesn't sound to me like you'll be able to see over the backs of the parents who are huddling right on the boards. Right. But I don't know. Yeah, we'll look at that. So just make sure that you're considering that. Maybe there's just one little section that's a little ramped up. I think that was a comment in the programming community meeting, I think, as well. I don't know if I made that, but I didn't think of it until now, that if somebody wanted to spectate in the warm area. Make sure they can see through the lobby space. Or was just a very short person. Yeah. Thank you.
1:00:07 But I made my comments mostly at that programming meeting. Thank you for continuing to work on it and to try to power through this latest hurdle that, yeah, the public is not going to be happy to hear about that, so let's figure out how we're going to address that before we message that out there. Okay, thanks. I have just a couple questions, and I like laurels.
1:00:34 Comment about that too because I've been a little bit nervous about the kids falling off the stools like they do up in the new Roma's room at the mountain. So yeah, I think it would be nice for shorter people to be able to see out as well. So Grady, so this is going back to the HMC cost estimator, is that correct? Is this going back to the HMC cost estimator?
1:01:01 It's going to the estimator and to the contractor, both that did the last estimate. So we have a couple of different ways to look at it. Okay. And when do we expect to have that? This week. This week. Okay. And then another question that I have is, so depending on when the site work happens, will that impact when the project goes to bid or will that process continue regardless of when we break ground?
1:01:28 If the council gives direction to do so, we can still break down in October. That's an issue that really it's up to them to talk about whether to start work on the site if all the funds aren't in hand already or not. In terms of the project going to bid, I've expressed earlier to town council and to this commission that we wanted to put the roof out to bid in January.
1:01:50 We don't want, from a public works standpoint, we don't want to have that advertiser bid unless the funds are already in hand. And that's something I expressed to council when they talked about the million and a half dollars being deferred, having to come through MLR's ad hoc subcommittee, how that was going to happen. And my comment was, well, unless it's secured, we're not going, we don't want to advertise it and we certainly won't award it. It's clear that you're not going to have that full funds in hand unless, you know, there's some
1:02:19 Pretty interested people in Anaheim or elsewhere, you know, by January or February, but that's really up to the council to say, look, how are we going to fund this, whether it's gap funding, however that's to happen between the time that the fundraising happens and the thing has to get under construction.
1:02:36 Even in the earlier discussions, MLR's comment was, well, we need a year to 18 months to get up to speed and find this million and a half to $2 million, and to do it in three months or six months was a tough challenge. And my comment, again, was it's up to town council to make sure the funds are in hand before it's awarded. Okay, thank you. Because it's my understanding, I mean, regardless of the estimates and...
1:03:00 We may or may not be good at estimating, depending. I mean, obviously, we're really good at, you know, with asphalt and so forth, but, I mean, there's not really a price tag until we have bids and have accepted a bid. Is that correct? That's correct. And, again, I'm just as disappointed, believe me, and if Stu has seen me talk about this in the last four weeks, I think he's gotten that message as well.
1:03:26 You know, and again, I'm not one to throw anybody under the bus either. This is something where Butler Buildings came back and, you know, what are they going to say? They're truly sorry they made a mistake. It wasn't intentional. It wasn't sloppy. It was just a bus. They stepped up and did it. But you're right, there's no recourse to them. That's the difficult part is, you know, you'd like to do something, and there really isn't one except to engage them to help.
1:03:51 You know, solve the problem and get the cost down as much as we can. So it's not a typical estimating error. It's a subcontractor error prior to signing the contract. So we did not have the recourse we normally would. Thank you. And then just to change direction a little bit, I have a question on, so now that we have a 30-foot ceiling inside, because we do have two open sides, I don't know if we're this far along in the design yet, but are we looking at some mitigation for?
1:04:18 Birds, I don't want to have the Shady Rust Snack Shack issue all over again, you know, with this ceiling, and then also really get some sound, you know, or really get for sound mitigation. Those are both something that is being discussed with the design team right now.
1:04:36 I'm frankly not as concerned with the birds as I would be in other areas of the state. I've dealt with them down south where that is a major issue. Pigeons are not your friend. Here we don't have the same issue. We'll still have an issue. We'll still have to look at it and do what we can to mitigate it. Sound's probably the bigger one that we're talking to them about, about how to dampen the sound, whether it's some kind of sound attenuation. I haven't gotten there yet, but that's definitely part of the conversation, so thanks.
1:05:00 Okay, thanks. So what I'd like to do now is just open up for public comment, and then I'll bring it back to the commission for, I guess, to give maybe some comments to the September 20th council meeting. So any public comments? Hello, everyone. I want to know, do you guys have any questions for me about ice rinks, since I've been around them quite a bit?
1:05:27 I know you mentioned the benches. Yeah, open-ended questions, you know, just an open-ended question, what are we forgetting? That's my concern, is that, you know, we're going to get into this, and oh, you guys didn't think about birds pooping on the... I didn't think about that either. I didn't either, so, you know, this is something I just... We don't have the Whitmore birds up here, do we? Those little nasty ones? I don't know, but again, we are going to address that, but we don't expect to have a huge problem here compared with other areas of the state or the country, but we will look at it.
1:05:56 You know, I don't mean to get away from the question because thank you so much for showing up here today and making yourself available to answer questions because I am concerned about what we're forgetting. But, you know, Grady, I just don't want to explain to town council, you know, we didn't think about this and it's a million bucks more than we thought it was going to be. You know, I just I don't want to be telling the public anymore that, you know, we're confident on this and then we're not. And so I just want to make sure, you know, we're not reinventing the wheel here.
1:06:26 We just want to make sure that we're covering everyone else's mistakes. You know, other municipalities that have built ice rinks. What are we forgetting? I think it's awesome, actually. I don't think you guys really forgot anything. I mean, you might, you know, maybe the storage thing there always comes up.
1:06:45 As far as it sits right now, I mean, you've got plenty of room on this backside for random stuff, you know, like the sled hockey stuff you want to put over there. You can put your curling stuff on the other side. All right, as for Tahoe, I forgot my tooth, my whistle. Okay, you look like a good hockey guy. Yeah, I look like a play like one. But around the rink to storage that they use, like behind where the Zamboni doors are, you come into Zamboni, and then everything over on this side is hockey nets, tires, cones, all the crap you need for hockey.
1:07:14 And then on the other side of the benches is everything you need for sled hockey, curling, the broomball things, and then on the other corners where they have the pads. So, I mean, I think you've got plenty of storage for that. And as far as kids falling off the stools, kids, they're not there. They're either crushing nachos or they're running back and forth in the ring. They're not. No one's sitting there. The kids don't watch the game. And if they do watch the game, they're on the glass like this.
1:07:42 So I wouldn't be concerned necessarily about that. As far as handicap access, sure. You may want something like that. But I think you guys did a hell of a job. It's set up great. I wouldn't be concerned about that whatsoever. And the Kings, I was contacted by one of Brian's buddies, who actually Luke Fortune was talking to Luke Robitaille.
1:08:07 Hockey meeting or whatever. And they want to set a film crew up here to film pond hockey because he's absolutely blown away that there's pond hockey in California, as 99% of the people are. They don't realize that we have high altitude hockey here. And they want to film the rink. And we are also pretty famous with Jeremy on howtohockey.com. He's an internet celebrity.
1:08:27 Hockey coach. He came out last year. They filmed a little pond hockey session, and they filmed the kids at the rink. So, you know, I'm constantly getting hit with, like, oh, my God, we want to come out to California. Oh, my God, we want to come out to California. Like, I've been hit up by teams from New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Like, this, I know it's going to cost more money, but the money can be made. And I know you guys are, like, the, you know, the whole return on investment is different with you guys because it's a town facility. But this is, this is going to be huge for us. Because it's...
1:08:54 You know, I mean, Tahoe is big, but they have a bigger population. They have different schools that come up there. There's actually some drama going on, which you don't really need to know about, but someone else is trying to take over the rink. But, you know, you can do a lot with what we have because people do, Patrick says it a thousand times, people want to come here, people want to come here. They do want to come here. You know, we have a tournament coming up in December and we're almost full. We need one more team for the sport division and we're full.
1:09:23 And we're barely charging anything at that rink. At this rink, you can charge a fair market value for the ice. And I don't know where I was going with that. I kind of got sidetracked. But yeah, I don't know. If you guys have any questions, I don't think ice rinks are very good for anything. I mean, it's tough to put the sound. You guys are going to have to work wonders with sound. It might be different without the walls. But when you're in an ice rink, you can't.
1:09:53 You can't really hear anything. It's just all echo. It's very hard to, like if, I don't think you could have a concert, even the music, when they play music out there, it's not very good. Anaheim's nice, but they have, it's all wood. So, I don't know, that would be a concern, would be noise. Well, I think it would be worth asking the question, you know, whether it's baffles don't necessarily make sense, I don't think, but, you know, can we hang flags from the ceiling?
1:10:19 Okay, let's have that answer because, you know, when our hockey teams start racking up those championships and we get to hang the banners, right? You know, I just want to make sure that we are asking every single question we can about what if. The what if questions, you know, can we do this? Because that would be something that we may get into and we realize, oh my God, this sound is really bad. Or, you know, the comment I made earlier about making sure that
1:10:47 Future trends that we're not even thinking about are available for that open space that if we want to plug in the latest, greatest thing into that lobby area that at least we're leaving room and enough electricity or whatever the case may be. If I could add to that.
1:11:04 This is the time of the project when all those questions come out, and I really laud Stu and his group's efforts to go to Bend, to go to Anaheim, to see all these facilities and walk through them. When they came back from Bend, they had a list of 10 or 15 things that the folks from Bend said, we screwed this up, we didn't do this right, we have too much space for this, not enough for that, and it was very heartening, if you will, for them to come back and see that we have...
1:11:29 We'd eliminated three quarters of the errors that they made already. In other words, we are way ahead of them in design where they finished their construction and they're having to deal with it. So we are constantly asking those questions. And the number one thing about this is flexibility always. We don't know what this facility is going to be used for in 20 years, not the community center, not the different events out in the larger room. So we are asking those questions constantly. And I think we're, as you said, we're way ahead of Bend.
1:11:56 Is that fair? You went, I did, and Stu, is that fair from what they had to say? Yeah, I think all this is coming down to, and I know, you know, Commission, this is really what we're here for, right, programming and forms design, and I mean, I'm going to echo Jeff's comments. I mean, we were down in the Kings, and we talked to a lot of people. I mean, this facility is going to blow people's, you know, minds. I mean, it's amazing. Typically, you know, Southern California rink anywhere, it's an industrial park, it's four walls, it's...
1:12:21 It's so bland, utilitarian. It has no design elements, and it's certainly not in Mammoth Lakes. So a lot of people are getting very excited. I mean, I really want to say that. I think the cautionary point on design is we want to make sure we're not just designing it for our needs right now, but making sure we're designing it for the future needs of the facility. So if we're looking at attracting professional teams and their needs, they're going to have pretty specific requirements that we need to kind of consider in our design.
1:12:46 considering our costs. So when we really get down to it, we're trying to design this that it's fully scalable. You know, we can use it for a multitude of reasons. But one, we're building an ice rink, and it has to function as an ice rink first, right? And then we can kind of look at the summer programming, which I think would be great, and then the community center space and the park setting in general. And that's kind of the reason why we're really selling this as kind of as the park, because it's all inclusive. It's not just one facility. It's all going to work. It's all going to be complementary.
1:13:15 And I think there's some really interesting points. But, you know, what we're really hearing and from our design and, you know, Brad, our consultant, actually, who's the president of American Skating Entertainment Company here overseas, 13 rinks, one in Houston, not doing too well. He's very excited about the design and he's got some specific comments and he's really helping us a lot. So we're trying to get this to as many people as we can. So really thank you for your comments on making sure that we're looking at not only now but in the future.
1:13:43 How this kind of facility can really, you know, get us where we want to go. And what we're hearing, it makes us pretty excited. You know, we just don't. We really have very little idea of this potential because we have an outdoor rink that's really non-functional. But I think once we can actually have a roof and an Olympic-sized ice sheet and it's going to be reliable and dependable, this will be really impressive for the community. And it's probably our role right now to really start informing.
1:14:13 Kind of, you know, with Matt and what we're trying to do with our communications plan to get out and get in front of the community and tell them, wow, this is a phenomenal facility. Look at everything that we can do. And I think that's really kind of the discussion we want to have next. Okay. Thanks, Jeff. Thank you. Yes. And the Truckee Tahoe Arena, too, they're going through a process to build an outdoor rink with a roof on it. Kind of deja vu.
1:14:40 And we're actually inventorying our equipment right now, and they're interested in probably either looking at surplus or, you know, taking our existing, you know, rink and reinstalling it at Truckee. So, I mean, there's some potential there as well. And I think the point that Jeff made too is that, you know, South Lake Tahoe, Truckee, and then Mammoth, there's three great facilities, you know, in kind of our northern, you know, Southern California area that I think will really grow the sport as well. So it's just something to keep in mind. A lot of communities are looking at rinks.
1:15:09 Like the Great Ice Facility in Anaheim, if you've been looking at that one, it's a $100 million facility. You know, that's got four ice sheets, a great park setting. I mean, there's a phenomenal amount of, you know, sheets of ice being built in Orange County and Southern California, but really, you know, not many up here apart from our three. So the sport is growing and becoming very attractive. And Reno too. There you go. Yeah. Okay. Matt, did you want to add anything on the fundraising strategies and the communication plan? We're still taking comments.
1:15:41 So bear in mind, again, that I'm still kind of ramping up on a lot of this, but I would say that from a nonprofit development standpoint, I'm liking what I hear kind of certainly going on today. I think everything's kind of in the right direction. I think that the questions that we're asking are good questions. The more that we can poke holes
1:16:06 in this project now at this step of the process when we go out to do communications and fundraising, now's the time to do it because we want to have as tight a package as possible. So, I mean, we're going to run into some variables. I think, you know, just from experience, we were in the middle of a capital project when I was with the Conservancy on Catalina. Building on an island presents its own challenges as it does in snow country. We ran into cost overrun. So, I think that
1:16:35 Some of those things, while disappointing, I think aren't entirely unexpected. I think kind of people are like, oh, here's kind of the reality of these things. So my goal with MLR is to try to work with our partners here to stay in front of it as much as possible. The two areas of focus, communications and fundraising, I'll go for fundraising first.
1:17:06 From my perspective, I think our biggest opportunity is going to be from Southern California. I think that there's obviously a lot of wealth down there. Southern California, Mammoth is, they consider it part of Southern California. We talked about this when we were down there with the Kings because we had talked about other possible venues, whether that's Park City, but Southern California,
1:17:30 Generations have grown up coming up here to Mammoth. They feel like it's their backyard. There is such affinity and love and connection there. I think that when we have an opportunity like this, people are going to gravitate to that. And so our job, ours being MLR, is to go down there and identify those opportunities. So what we want to do is as we sort of work through and get some clarity and get some
1:17:57 Firming up of the plans, the designs. We've done such a great job already. And, you know, it's evident, as Stu walked me through these last week, you know, seeing how much thought has gone in on the front end to kind of take programming into consideration. These are the things that we're going to go out and communicate and put in front of funders. I think the, you know, the fact that, you know, having such a, you know, putting a priority on the community aspect of it.
1:18:25 to make sure that we stay to that 2,500 square foot space that we're not compromising because that would have been an easy choice to say, okay, we're going to, you know, reduce that size. But having that kind of commitment to that, I think, is going to really allow us to maximize the venue, which, again, when we go down there, we're going to be talking to donor advice funds.
1:18:47 We're going to be talking to different groups of donors hosting salons. We want to get in front of the people that can help the people with wealth, influence them, be the decision makers to guide their money to us. So I think that's really the strategy. That plays into the communication side. I think what we need to do is take this information as it becomes evident and more solidified and get it out in front of our community here. I think it's one of the things, that line of communication between Southern California,
1:19:18 and Mammoth, you know, used to, back in the old days, take a while, right? Now it's instantaneous. Something happens up here, phone call away, internet, Facebook post, people down there know. So, and that works positively and negatively, but I will tell you that if we can get advocates in the community, I mean, it's impossible to listen to Jeff speak and not be excited about the project, right? If we can find that same kind of advocate who will speak on behalf of the rec zone, in front of the community programming.
1:19:46 I think that as we go out and start soliciting funders, potential funders down there, and they're coming up and the first thing they're going to do is pick up the phone and say, hey, have you heard about this project? What's going on in town? If we can get town here as excited about that, we're going to build that buzz down south as well. So I don't want to come in and just paint this big rosy picture, but I am excited about the opportunity to do fundraising, certainly for this gap.
1:20:11 And then we're going to also be looking hopefully beyond that. Because everything that we can do above and beyond that 1.5, I think is just going to enhance this project and our ability to build out the project that we envision. Thank you. Any questions? Any questions? Any questions for Matt? Okay. Thank you very much. Okay. Well, I'd like to just bring it back for some...
1:20:36 Well, if I can just ask, you know, Abigail, I don't mean to call you out specifically, but I want to make sure that we're answering any questions that the public might have. From your perspective, you know, is there anything that we can do to make sure that, because this is the first time I heard about this today, and I'm just curious if, you know, obviously you're going to be reporting on this, and I would just would like to make sure that we're answering any questions that you think the public might have.
1:21:05 Yes, I am calling you out. Well, yeah, if you're going to talk, you have to come up here, but I just... Yeah, I think from the public standpoint, I guess I can't speak for everybody, but the biggest question I have is, moving forward, what's the recourse with a contractor if they don't follow through with their contract? And I know, Grady, you kind of spoke to that a little bit and said you're working through that as staff.
1:21:41 But I do think that might be a big question that people have, is what can we do to ensure that we can get back what we've already invested in getting good information? And I also think people might have questions about other numbers in the project if they see that that wasn't clear. And maybe people who have worked in development and have built projects like this and worked in public works would understand, contractors would understand,
1:22:12 There are things that change, but I think from, that's what I anticipate, and that would be maybe my biggest question is coming from the sheet, but that said, I definitely would love to have a follow-up conversation with staff to clarify that and make sure that anything that we report on is accurate and up-to-date, so. Thank you. Thanks, Abigail. Then I'll ask that question if I can. I don't mean to be, but you know, what can we do to prevent this?
1:22:37 You know, it is a very exciting project. I'm all, you know, I think we've had the vision because we've been involved in these meetings from day one, trying to create the showcase facility that we've got. You know, we see the population base, but at the same time, you know, there's a lot of people out there that are unfortunately going to be focusing on the negative. And this is a big, see, I told you so opportunity for them. And I would like to be mitigating that going forward. Can you answer that question just as far as what?
1:23:06 Do we do with contractors who come in with a number and then later on increase that? Well, versus a definition standpoint, difference between a consultant and people working for that consultant, including cost estimators and a contractor. The contractors, it's...
1:23:23 Very, frankly, a lot more simple because you have a contract with somebody, they're going to abide by that contract. On the various contracts, you know, we've had cost overruns, we've had contractors come back and say, gee, we need a change for X, Y, and Z. Usually we just tell them no because we read the contract, they were supposed to produce a product, that's it. On a consultant basis, it's much more difficult. Certainly I've done a lot of projects and had a lot of cost variations and things that happen. The two items on this,
1:23:51 Project that we're dealing with, though, frankly, staff has almost no control over. We questioned the Butler building idea. We questioned whether we should go to a straightforward, different design rather than purchase a building. We questioned it for the entire year because we wanted to make sure it was the right thing, and we were satisfied that we got the answers.
1:24:13 That we needed. The fact that Butler changed that at the end, and, you know, I'd welcome everybody to, not everyone, but we'll have a further conversation with HMC and with Butler as well, and we're perfectly happy to pass on that contact information. They just made a mistake, and they didn't follow through with their commitments.
1:24:33 And again, from a staff perspective, that's extremely difficult. What recourse we have is the only one that I can see so far is HMC just is required to continue to design this facility until it gets down to a certain amount or do everything they can without further compensation. That's really all we have at this point in time. In terms of other issues, everything else, everything else except for the idea of
1:24:59 You know, where the entire market is going in California, which again, we can't control that, is going as we thought it would and going extremely well. We're visiting other facilities, we're reducing the size of the project, we're making it more efficient, we're making it operationally better, more flexible, reducing costs. So, I mean, it's just more than extremely disappointing that everything else is going so well and this thing with the roof came in and the cost escalation in the industry is something that happens every...
1:25:26 You know, seven to ten years, it goes up and down, and we're just in a tough spot right now. And it was not possible to see that coming a few months ago, because who knows what the economy was going to do and what it's going to do in a year from now. That's really difficult. All I can tell you is we are asking all the right questions, and we are just as disappointed, if not more so, in terms of the issue with the roof. Okay. Thank you.
1:25:54 Okay, so seeing no further public comments, do you guys have any, I have some comments, but I want to hear from you guys first. I think it's important that we kind of give some, I think staff understands where we're coming from, but they will go to council on the 20th, so I'd like to hear your thoughts. Well, first of all, what are we being asked to do? Is this just an update or are we being asked to? This is an update and we can just do, we can just.
1:26:24 Give consensus comments that I can take to council on the 20th. And then if there's anything else we want to see come back from staff in October, we can ask for that as well. And I think it would be great, actually, if several of us went to council on the 20th, because that's going to be an important, I think, meeting. Well, yeah, I got a couple of comments. And, you know, Matt, your comment, just as far as we're doing everything that we can to predict what the costs are, you know, in some ways I want to push back on that comment because we're not.
1:26:54 You know, we came back and all of a sudden it's a million bucks more than what we expected. I know how difficult it is doing business up here in Mammoth Lakes. It is like being on an island. And, you know, you can't count on shipping. You can't count on cost estimates half the time.
1:27:08 And I don't want to be having that buffer in there that's so high that then people go, oh, this isn't worth it at all. Obviously, the goal is to be as accurate as possible. But I think we are going to need to make sure that we are, as Abigail said, you know, making sure that we are just answering every single question. And my concern, too, is, you know, well, then what else are we forgetting?
1:27:30 You know, it plants that seed of doubt. So just everything we can do as far as reporting out to town council and to the public that we are covering absolutely everything. I did want to ask a question about the timeline. Are we still on track for opening this thing here in Halloween 2018?
1:27:49 Again, it comes back to the same question and response. Is the funding there? If the funding's there on September 20th and we can do the site work either this fall or even in February, March of next year, then the answer is yes. But it's really Town Council's decision if the funding is assured, then yes. Okay. And I won't push that any further just because I know that that's a timeline that I'll come back and ask you again after we get to that stage. Backup.
1:28:19 How are we with their MUSD contract lease agreement?
1:28:27 We did extend the lease through the not just this winter but next winter as well, correct? Again, that was something that already has occurred. So we're good there. We're actually meeting with the school district about a future dare care facility and what else they want to have on site. And they're starting to come up with a list of what they'd like to remain. They kind of like the building that the Olympia is stored in. Right now they're looking at the slab and saying they think they could use that for their future facility. So we're having constant conversations.
1:28:56 with them at least every two weeks or so. I think there's a meeting either later this week or next week too. End of the month, I think. Yeah, so there's another meeting in September with them to keep that going as well. So we're good in terms of the lease and we're working with them in terms of the site conditions and what they want to keep. Okay. We all want this, you know, Halloween 2018, but it sounds like you've got the contingency for another winter just in case. Okay.
1:29:21 And part of that too is that we'll need it for the summer while the construction is being completed. Yep. Okay. Just one last comment and then I'll be done is, you know, again, I think that fortunately we've all had the vision here in this room of what we're trying to create.
1:29:39 And that there's a lot riding on this just in the sense of bigger picture of what tourism has been talking about, what economic development town is talking about in creating Mammoth as a destination for high-altitude training. This is a sport that, as we've talked about, is not really being capitalized. We have an opportunity to be a leader in this not only
1:30:03 This particular sport, but also just as far as developing a high altitude training area. And there's a lot riding on this. And not to keep the pressure on, but kind of to keep the pressure on, is that we want a showcase facility that is something that we can afford. And so, you know, I want to keep pushing this forward. I'm still very supportive of this.
1:30:30 Huge disappointing news with regard to this cost over underestimation. But at the same time, I just want to leave it at that. Okay. Thanks, Son. Thank you. Laurel? I basically ditto. You know, I agree that we want to make sure that we do this right and as affordable as possible. And, you know, it's been a while since I looked at the numbers, but I don't remember.
1:30:59 What, if any, contingency was part of the budget if maybe we need to go back and look at those numbers as well and make sure something else doesn't come up and bite us and surprise us that, oh, now we got to go out and get more money. But I think addressing the problem head on and keeping the whole process transparent and open and doing what we can to make sure that we have the right.
1:31:25 Contracts and Agreements with these guys when we move forward to protect ourselves so that we don't get slammed. I think that's important. Okay, thank you. Okay, so I'll just be pretty brief.
1:31:41 Let me start with just one thing I want to just clarify is that the MLR and commission ad hoc is not solely about funding, although that's been a lot of our discussion. It's just it's also an ad hoc about kind of how we work together. And I think when we have our monthly update come back in October, I'd love to see, you know, a specific funding discussion because I'm hoping that by then we can kind of hear from, you know, we'll continue to hear from Matt about plans and moving forward and how the commission.
1:32:10 You know, we're certainly not the lead on fundraising, but I think we're all, you know, it's all hands on deck. So I'd like to kind of have a discussion about that.
1:32:17 One thing I want to add, too, is that I thought it was great when we met with the program committee. They were very receptive to the changes in design. They all understood them. I was a little bit concerned about how they would go over, so I was happy that everyone seemed really pleased and really continues to be excited about the project. So that was really great. And then I think their comments were all really useful in terms of we want to make sure that programming continues to drive the design of this facility, not just programming for the day it opens, but whatever the programming may be going.
1:32:46 into the future. And finally, I'll be very anxious to see how things go at Council on September 20th. I'm a little nervous that if we try to do a groundbreaking in February, we will guarantee ourselves another tremendous winter. But I do understand from staff that that's still, you know, that would not change.
1:33:06 The current schedule at all. And then finally, I just, you know, I want to echo the comments about disappointment because we talk all the time and I know staff talks all the time about managing public expectations and this makes that extremely difficult. I think, you know, all of the commissioners, we've really put ourselves out there in support of this project. You know, we're working with the same information that you guys are and, you know, we just, I'm pleased that everyone wants to, you know, wants to continue to move forward and figure this out and find the funds because I think it's an incredibly important project.
1:33:36 for our community, but it is exceptionally disappointing. So I will just end on that note unless anyone has anything further to add. Thank you. Abigail? Yeah, you can come on up to the mic real quick. With regard to funding, I remember there was kind of a deadline or a schedule that was put in place and talking about taking out bonds for this project. Would this sort of new additional cost...
1:34:12 Does that potentially threaten the ability to move forward with the financing on that schedule? And I'd be happy to follow up with you later if that's off topic, too. Two things. One is I'd be happy to have a follow-up conversation, answer as many questions as I can. I will say that you've probably heard 99% of it already because, again, we are very transparent and you heard exactly what I know on all these things. In terms of the bonding, though,
1:34:37 I haven't talked specifically to Rob Patterson about that. I don't believe that that would impact that because it's an issue of a certain amount. We're not going to suggest that the amount of the bonds that would be sold be increased because it was based on a certain level of funds existing in Measure R already. So I don't see that changing, but that would be a question for Rob probably as we move down the road closer to September 20th. Okay, great. Thanks, Brady. No problem. Thanks, Abigail.
1:35:06 Okay, I will move us on then to, I think this next item should be fairly quick, number three, the youth sports funding application from Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey. I will recuse myself. Oh, that's going to create an issue. So, do we need to bring this back in October when, because we'll lose a quorum when Laurel recuses herself? I don't know if it's, you need to recuse yourself from the point of view, it's, you're just considering
1:35:35 Funding a specific application. Yeah, it wouldn't really have an impact. No impact to your organization. Because the DSES funding is already awarded. Yeah, I don't see there's a direct conflict in this instance. You've already made that recommendation. As long as you're comfortable, I think we can proceed then. Okay, super. Thank you. Okay. Great.
1:36:02 So the update to our youth sports funding is that Mammoth Youth Hockey came forward on August 25th with a funding application. They've requested $1,200 in funds. Currently we have $1,900 remaining in the youth sports organization assistance program. So right now staff is recommending that we award Mammoth Youth Hockey the
1:36:28 The $1,200 they are requesting, that would leave the assistance program with $700 remaining.
1:36:36 Like I stated last month, we haven't had a particularly large response to getting our sports organization leadership involved in the League Director Training and Membership Program. We're still pushing forward with that. Currently at the moment, the NAIS League Director Training is being offered for free for each organization, so that would be at no cost.
1:37:00 What we're probably looking at with that remaining $700 is offering help with translation services. The town's currently looked into getting some quotes for Spanish translation for our waivers. It's coming at about $40 a page, so we're looking at offering the sports organization those translation services so that they can translate their concussion waivers, their regular waivers, that kind of thing. The other option with that remaining $700
1:37:30 Would also be the team management apps that we've been looking at. They sort of range from about $100 to $300 a year membership. So it would be a subsidy program if the teams were willing to or are interested in looking into those management apps. So it's kind of where we stand at the moment. Thank you. Any questions for staff? Did you want to come up?
1:38:01 We can ask you any questions about your application, if there's anything you'd like to draw to our... The best I can. Okay. So if anybody hasn't, this is not my job usually. That's okay, we understand that. So any questions for Jeff on the application or about youth hockey? Okay, thank you. I do want to say that I spoke with Melissa Carpenter, who is the president of Bishop Roller Hockey, and we're going to work with them this year and hopefully get ice time for them to get these...
1:38:29 The 700 kids they have in their roller program up to the ice so they can kind of learn the differences in the games and to try it out. As far as I'm concerned, I'm not even going to say that because I don't want to be quoted anymore. But anyway, if we can roll with Bishop and Mammoth hockey programs, it's going to totally sustain what we have here. And we're in talks with Bishop High School.
1:38:55 About continuing the high school program. We can't start. We can, but we shouldn't start a Mammoth high school hockey program. So we're going to go with an Eastern Sierra high school hockey program so anyone can play, which is very common down south for people to do. So we're going to do that as well and run through Bishop High School and hopefully have a competitive program here in two years because they've already have it established, but a lot of their kids are growing up and getting out. And with this rink over here, we're going to run it super cheap and try to generate enough interest and get this place going.
1:39:25 For the full program, ready to go. So that's what we're going to use the money for. Thanks. Thanks, Jeff. Thanks for your continuing work on that. You said 700 kids? Yeah, that's what they say. They say 700 kids play roll rock down there. Wow. I didn't even know there were 700 kids down there. I didn't know.
1:39:51 You know, just kind of one other follow-up question then. As far as the sport court material that we're talking about, is that something that roller hockey blades work on? We will move. If the street hockey really goes, you know, the direction it wants to go, we just pull the sport court, which is kind of what we talked about with our programming. So we would run the sport court all the way through kind of Labor Day, mid-September, and then just pull it. And then it just becomes a month roller skating venue.
1:40:20 And then Jeff's already Facebooking and there's interest. It seems like we can kind of start a fall, you know, inline skate program as well. So we're very interested in doing that Wednesdays. Seems like what he wants to do. And I think the other comment here on the application was USA Hockey. Jeff, was that kind of the big change? So you're with AAU right now and you're looking at going with USA Hockey and that change because that's a big part of our budget. Currently for this season we're going to run with AAU insurance at that rink, but we're going to form a new board.
1:40:47 Which is going to be strictly USA Hockey. So when we go into this facility, we're USA Hockey affiliated. That way we can host USA Hockey tournaments. We can kind of do it here. But when we go here, it's going to have to be full USA Hockey, which is the governing. It's like AYSO. But yeah, I'm sure they're the same in the Little League. But they've got a big plan. The ADM development and all that. And there's certain rules you have to follow. And it's kind of a...
1:41:16 Kind of a junk show, but. Well, there you call when you guys started. You started purposefully with AAU so you could get going, but always with the intention. Because it's cheaper. AAU is way cheaper. It's like, I don't know, 15 bucks to join. USA Hockey's 44 plus California Amateur Hockey Association is $10 fee. So you're at 54 bucks per kid, per coach, anyone affiliated with it. And you've got to go through SafeSport and the background check and all that other good stuff that goes along with it.
1:41:43 And there's just, we, right now we couldn't go USA Hockey because we just don't have the parent involvement. You have to have, you know, two parents outside the locker room, you know, during practices, you know, and make sure all the kids are gone. It's a scene, but it's, you know, we have to do that to bring it, like, if we're not USA Hockey, we can't host tournaments here. So we have to be a USA Hockey affiliate rink, and then they will come, they check out the rink, make sure everything's cool, and then you're set, and all you do is, you know, put it on the Kaha webpage.
1:42:12 And you can host as many tournaments as you want. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Any further discussion? The only comment that I want to make is I'm glad that as we look at funding this, there's still some funding left in the assistance program. I feel like it's kind of gotten off to sort of a slow start despite staff's efforts to engage with the groups. But I would like us to bring that group back together prior to the next funding cycle because I just want to make sure that we're continuing to engage with them.
1:42:44 I think there's still some really valid reasons for having this funding, and especially now that they've kind of, you know, gone through another year. So I want to kind of continue to look at that. Does that sound good to you guys? Okay. So that's all I wanted to say. But I'd entertain a motion if anyone has a motion. I move. Where's the wording? Do we allocate $1,200 to Mammoth Youth Hockey for the entirety of their 2017?
1:43:16 I'm trying to read from this. I'm not doing a very good job. Yeah, I'm moved that we... All right, that's this one, sorry. Yeah, that's... Okay, that's what I did start on. Okay. I move that we allocate... Yeah, the entire... Yeah, I'm not sure if I'm saying it right, but the entirety of their 2017 request. $1,200. $1,200. Thank you. All right. Thank you. I think I have a motion. Is that a motion? I hope I... Yes. I will second that.
1:43:53 Okay, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Can we do a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Since we did that for football. Yes, aye. Yes, motion passes 3-0. I'm going to take a five-minute recess, and then we'll move on to item number five. Thank you, Jeff, for being here. We'll be right back.
1:44:29 Next one? Check your voicemail before the next one. I've been texting Tyler. Got nothing.
1:45:02 I know, I was kind of waiting, and then I was like, we'll do it at the end, that'll be fun. Just a quick question, then. Take a picture or something. Yeah. Do we really only have, we're just talking about this. Yeah, this is our last item, and then, yeah, and then I'm just to wrap up stuff, so, and this should go pretty quickly. Oh, that's so annoying. Okay, are you guys ready? We'll keep going. Okay, I will call us back to order and move us on to
1:45:32 Item number five, the statewide healthy play training and funding initiative. Well, thank you, Chair. As of 1049 a.m. September 5th, there's been no update. It was posted that it was going to be notified on September 1st, but it's been a few days. When they'd extended the original deadline. But anyway, so we've provided some updates to you at the bottom of the staff report.
1:46:00 If the application is successful and then subsequently if it's not successful. So optimistically speaking, we'll start with a successful application. It means we'll just be returning in October, again with a detailed plan and timeline for the purchase of the equipment, if that is the case. The application itself is based on the cost of the playground structure, not the surfacing or any other additional installation fees itself.
1:46:28 We would just be making a decision based on the size of structure we'd like to put on that site. We have two designs from Great Western that they provided for us. So we can have a choice of those two. Or further, we can kind of look at enhancing those designs as well. So that would be kind of really the process. In October, we'd come forward with those designs. And perhaps there would be an opportunity for kind of some community engagement at that point as well with all those folks that were part of that playground application.
1:46:58 The great side of it. And then we would have to then identify and certainly go back to council and the commission would certainly be able to weigh in on this in regards to those matching funds. So, you know, identifying the source. There was three options identified by the town manager in the last staff report. I've kind of included those there, which is kind of utilizing the general fund operating reserve, using the funds from the deferred maintenance program.
1:47:24 Or, you know, subsequently looking at a Measure R, Measure U application. If the application is not successful, then we would still return in October with a plan to kind of relocate the existing playground based on the timeline of the project, right? So we wouldn't obviously be reinstalling that playground until the project is complete and so forth. And then we'd also look at some options in regards to purchasing some inclusive playground components.
1:47:51 They'll identify it in the application itself that we have a cost on some of those pieces of equipment, you know, estimating around, you know, $30,000 for the playground components and some surfacing. So that was kind of the phase two, which is kind of identified in here. So again, we'd have to look at how we would, you know, secure those funds to purchase that equipment. So that'll be kind of the next discussion in October.
1:48:18 Do want to thank very much Betsy for all her time and effort. Your chair pretty much wrote this grant application. With assistance. With assistance, right. Me just a little bit and then Lauren, our program facilities coordinator and staff had a lot of, you know, input as well. But really, Betsy did a phenomenal job. I've attached it to your application. I know, Laura, you're able to kind of look at it and provide some review. We sent it to...
1:48:45 Some peer reviews as well. They gave us some good insight. We really don't know how it's being addressed. We do know there were two or three other applications in our same district, District 7, Region 3. But this would be the only one in Eastern California. So we really think that's a strong value proposition for the grant. But again, grants are funny things. Sometimes you think you've got a great application.
1:49:12 You get nothing. But anyway, so we're very optimistic, but we'll let you know as soon as we do here. I mean, we're waiting, as we know, any time. But that was kind of our presentation, too. Any questions on that? Great job, guys, on putting this together. I know it was not the most extensive grant app ever, but I know pulling all the pieces together is a pain in the butt.
1:49:38 Let's talk absolute worst case scenario, which we are not recommending and we don't think is going to happen, but say the rest of this project goes belly up. Is getting this funding and getting this playground done contingent on that? No, not at all. Absolute worst case scenario, this goes belly up, we could still get these funds and do this project. Great. That was a little unclear when I read the app before.
1:50:08 Because it is such an integrated part of it, you're not going to present it as a separate piece. I just wondered if that was a contingency piece of it. That's great. Fingers crossed. We were just talking about that this morning in terms of, you know, do you explain that it's part of this larger project and does that help? Does it hurt? So we just figured we'd just do full disclosure.
1:50:30 I just want to quickly thank Lauren for all the research and all the review, and I also want to just thank Stu for identifying the grant and our really fun trip to LA. So I think the one question that I do have is, so if the application is successful, identified in here is potentially
1:50:54 Using the match from the deferred maintenance funds, but that seems less than ideal since those funds really should go to deferred maintenance. Is that going to add anything on that? I'm kind of hoping that you've spent that money by the time we find out. From staff's point of view, you'll have the facility condition assessment of the Whitmore pool in October at the same time. Okay. So that will clearly spell out immediate updates and requirements to the pool.
1:51:23 From either a health code or construction, CDC, with kind of a short and long term plan. And then it'll also give you kind of a like for like replacement. So you get a lot of good information. So I think that'll kind of steer and certainly guide that allocation. Right now we've committed about $180,000 of that $300,000. So we're waiting on this facility condition assessment and also waiting on some input from Monon County Little League on what field enhancements, rehabilitation.
1:51:53 Maintenance is required on Whitmore to kind of turn that into kind of a little league field. So they're kind of the outliers at the moment in regards to allocation of those funds. So I'm really looking at the Commission to make sure that we can kind of protect that money and make sure it goes into that purpose. Thanks for the clarification because I think we all feel pretty strongly about addressing the deferred maintenance of our existing facilities and parks. Any other questions of staff or comments?
1:52:21 Once we have no more public. We're just waiting for an answer at this point. Yeah, at this point. We're not going to take any action at this point. No, it's just a total update. I guess the only other thing I'd add is that if the application is not successful, I mean, if we're looking at raising, you know, potentially as much as $3 million for the project, I don't think it would be out of the question for us to raise, you know, funds to do the full-on playground versus just a couple of components, too. So I think that would be something to consider if we're not successful. Let's cross that bridge when we get to it. Fair enough. Okay.
1:52:51 Okay, does that provide sufficient direction for you in the absence of a decision? Yes, thank you. Okay, I will move us on to Commissioner Reports. Laurel, other than everything we've already talked about from the programming planning committee meeting, I don't think I have anything to report. Okay. Sean? Yeah, I've got a couple of comments. You know, this is my first time here at Recreation Commission since Palooza Palooza.
1:53:22 So I just want to report out real quick. First thing, and I want to say this, and I can't say it enough, I want to thank the town of Mammoth Lakes very much for their assistance this year. I think that it was one of the most, it was the best executed event that Mammoth Brewing Company has ever done. Every single year, you know, we get better and better. And I've said this many times before, I'm not an events guy. But boy, have I learned over the past decade, you know, how to put on events.
1:53:53 You know, there was that fire festival that you heard about in the Caribbean where those guys made a big plan and just nothing happened. And, you know, I see some of these crash and burns that can happen with events. And frankly, I think for a beer company to put on the event that we do, I just cannot thank my entire staff. And I want to say this publicly to this room full of people that I just...
1:54:17 I am so proud of the independent contractors that we hire both locally and out of town that assist us with building a village for up to 6,000 people for one weekend and then we have to tear it down. And for us without the infrastructure that, you know, we normally, that a lot of other organizations in this town might have, I just...
1:54:40 Cannot say how thankful I am to so many different partners in this town, the town of Mammoth Lakes, all the vendors. It takes a community to come together. This is the busiest weekend of the entire year. And so to expect vendors, volunteers to come out. I am going to...
1:54:59 Talk about this for just a minute, but hey, it's a commissioner report. We're estimating that between the seven nonprofits that were involved in this event, they made a combined total of over $50,000.
1:55:13 Yeah, and I just, I gotta say, between five of them are local, one of them is out of town, but is donating all of their proceeds to the music program in the school. The other one that's out of town is the California Craft Brewers Association that Joyce and I are very involved in, and just that the, that there were seven non-profits that were involved that we are expecting that they'll be able to make $50,000.
1:55:41 Again, coming back to the community members that come out and support their non-profits, whether it's on the street parking between the boosters and the Rotary Interact Club or the three non-profits that were running the different bars. I know how difficult it is to get locals out to assist us, but we could not do it without you. So to the public, I just want to say thank you very much for helping us put on this event.
1:56:07 And then to their paid staff and independent contractors, you did a great job. We've done the best job that we've ever done. Having said all that, here we are already starting to look at 2018. This is the first year that Mammoth Brewing Company has not put our...
1:56:24 Or I should say Bluza Palooza did not put our tickets on sale for 2018. And I got a report out that we had a lot of people coming up to the ticket booth that was reported to me by the ticketing agency that mans our ticket booth. How disappointed a lot of attendees were that, again, I'm reporting this out secondhand, what the ticketing agency said is that people were reporting to them that it's our tradition.
1:56:52 We buy our tickets for next year's show. We book our lodging properties. So to the lodging association, I want to say, you know, unfortunately, we were not able to put our tickets on sale for the 2018 event, and that did have an effect. We traditionally have sold 5% to 10% of our tickets a full year in advance by people who are committing themselves to come next year for this event. And part of that...
1:57:18 The reason why we did not put our tickets on sale is because we do not have a contract in place with the current landowner at the wood site. And there's a number of circumstances. I'm not placing all the blame on the property owner at all whatsoever. But what I am saying is that there are so many considerations in business with putting on this huge event.
1:57:42 and looking for it a full year in advance as far as what we are looking for, for infrastructure on the property, the improvements that are going to be made, whether with the town, whether with the public money that was contributed towards seeing that, or what the property owner himself might be doing. We, I can tell you that as a business person, I want to see more events at that site, and also as a member of this commission, as well as the tourism board,
1:58:11 I want to see other events. And I would like to encourage, he's got my support, the property owners, and my full-on support to bring other events to that venue. I know that we as a town want to see more events brought to that venue. And I just want to say this publicly, that Bluza Bluza spends an incredible amount of money.
1:58:37 Starting off with just clearing the site of slash and downed pine cones. We estimated that we had over 80 man hours just preparing the site for whoever is going to be using it. Between the Labor Day Arts Festival or Shakespeare in the Park, whoever is going to use it, each year needs to be cleaned up from the winter. Then we start looking into the next kind of level of infrastructure that goes onto that site, which is the fencing.
1:59:07 The infrastructure for a lot of the lighting that goes up in the trees, the electricity. This is equipment that most events would need to have on that site. And then we get into the really specific needs of an event of our size that builds a huge...
1:59:29 Sound, Stage with sound, lighting, the video component. I hope everyone likes the LED walls. We introduced that in 2016. We had a real internal discussion as to whether or not we were going to bring that back because it's expensive bringing back that video, the giant LED wall. We chose internally to go forward with that because not doing that would be a step backwards in our eyes.
1:59:56 And not only are we trying to grow the brand that I call Bluesapalooza and the event itself, but also, again, I'd like to see other large events, whether it's the mountain or whether we're successful in bringing in other event companies that can use that same stage. All of a sudden, maybe my cost goes down by a third just because I'm able to share that stage with whatever event is happening the weekend before or the weekend after.
2:00:24 So I just, I wanted to kind of report out all these things with regard to Bluesapalooza and the success that we had with regard to the execution of the event versus, you know, just kind of as far as what the financial numbers are going to turn out. It kills me that we've had one of the hottest, driest summers in my memory, and yet on the two busiest days of Bluesapalooza, we had rain, you know, Friday and Saturday.
2:00:53 And I can tell you that that has affected our financial and I'll be doing more of a full-on report out to the town of Mammoth Lakes on what that exactly looked like. That's the nature of doing business here in Mammoth Lakes and I will tell you that we spent extra money on making sure that we had that rain roof.
2:01:12 That we had the transportation in place. That we ordered extra rain ponchos to be sold at the merchandise booth. Again, you know, there's so much planning that goes into it to make sure that you're prepared for all of these contingencies. So I want to say all these things, but Stu, I wanted to ask you if you can report out. I doubt that the special event permit has been pulled for the winter activities that are planned on that.
2:01:39 But I don't know if you can report out on any kind of plans that you've heard of for what that event is going to look like or anything that you can report out with regard to what the 2018 season is looking like for that event site. So we haven't received a special event application permit for Christmas in the woods yet, I think is kind of what we're talking about there, right, which I believe is from Thanksgiving through to Christmas.
2:02:08 I know they're actually actively promoting that throughout the community, the sponsors and so forth. We haven't seen any applications, so curious about that. I did hear that Mammoth Lakes Tourism was actually looking at funding a position as well. Yes, and we're having a discussion about that tomorrow. Yeah, so that's great news. We're very much into that. I was invited by John to sit on that kind of committee to kind of put that kind of program together. Yes, you were. Are you going to be on that?
2:02:35 Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so I think it's a big part of the town is absolutely events and how we can kind of collaborate with other organizations to really enhance events in our community. So I'm looking forward to that. We are still wrapping up our summer events calendar. We've got Grand Fondo to go and, you know, Kamikaze bike games and so forth. So it's been, for us, a really busy summer. And as you know, summers just keep getting busier and busier.
2:03:01 But good, that's all I had. Okay, and again, just to follow up, you know, again, I can't thank the town of Mammoth Lakes enough. The community as a whole pulled it off amazingly every year. I kind of get to the other side and say, God, you know, I can't believe we did that. But just as far as getting ready for 2018, again, I...
2:03:22 It's not just Bluza Bluza, it's all events. I want to see us grow with these different events that really provides live music for a local. That's what I would love to see, as well as, you know, our economic vitality as far as bringing people in from the outside. So, good. One of the, just comment I'm going to say about that, and then I'll move off on events, is I did just come back from Burning Man, you know, and I've been a couple times, and again, I just,
2:03:52 And I'm one of those persons that I'm kind of looking behind the scenes at everything that goes into an event like that. And considering that they had 75, 80,000 people there, you know, so 12 times the size of our event and the amount of preparation that goes into something like that. But I want to say this is that, you know, I had the opportunity to go in 02 when it was only 35,000 people.
2:04:20 And in the course of 15 years that they're able to more than double the size of that event, given the space that they have, it does go back to, and this is said before, that it's often easier to grow existing events rather than necessarily bringing in. And I don't mean to say that we shouldn't be trying to focus on bringing other people in.
2:04:41 But again, I'm just blown away by the professionalism of these different events that happen in other communities, other towns that if we can do that more and more, I'm really excited about the opportunities that tourism is really trying to sponsor in this events position. So anyway, one last thing I want to ask, and I'm not sure if this is a request for agenda items, but I did want to ask, you know, I wasn't here for the August
2:05:10 Tourism meeting, we didn't have a July one, but I do remember asking about, Commission, sorry, Commission meetings, about the Lake Basin, if you can report out anything with regard to the Lake Basin closing or the contractors who are running the camping sites up there. I know their contracts were coming up soon. They have another year to run. I'm sorry? They have one more year to run. One more year. Yep, correct.
2:05:38 When does the U.S. Forest Service start entertaining contracts? It's part of our actually discussion with the Forest Service, so we're meeting regularly about that, so it's on kind of an agenda for discussion this fall. Okay. Yeah, so I'd like to report out when I have that information to you. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. I am kind of curious what that process looks like. Absolutely. Thank you. That's everything.
2:06:00 Thanks, Sean. And congratulations on a great event. You know, I got really excited about it early on when I was, you know, writing about it for the tourism blog and then had a great time. And I have to admit, my heart really did just kind of break for you when it was like the one rainy weekend of the summer. So, but I was there on Friday night. It was just, it was amazing. So, congratulations. So, and thanks for making it back from Burning Man. Yeah. Tell me about it from across the country.
2:06:23 Oh, did you go see so-and-so? Yeah. Words out there. It's just a phenomenal event. And to your point, too, about growing existing events, I think we really saw that with Rock and Ride this past weekend. I mean, that event has grown tremendously. It's really nice to see. For my own commissioner report, so I attended the town pool party on August 10th. On August 11th, I went to the coffee chat with Assemblyman Frank Bigelow, who's here.
2:06:52 Thanks to the chamber for organizing that. I did speak with his staff member who also works for Senator Berryhill just about our support for AB-18 and the per capita provision especially, which he was very cognizant of because the Senate bill does not have the per capita provision and so he was very clear that yes, obviously just given the constituency they would be supportive of including the per capita provision and whatever.
2:07:19 Bill ultimately goes to the governor for signing, and that's in progress right now, so we'll keep watching that. On August 26th, I was at Shady Rest for the opening day of AYSO soccer, which was great, and then I also stopped by the Wave Rave skateboarding contest, which was awesome. I just want to say thanks to Wave Rave and to Steve. He's just been an amazing partner, and I think we're really fortunate to have that relationship, so that was a great event.
2:07:48 I also met with a homeowner from the Knolls with Stu over the weekend. So I just want us to, and I assured her that the Recreation Commission has not really, you know, weighed in yet on walk, bike, ride, but that we're very cognizant of, you know, potential impacts to our park. So if you guys could take a look at that, that would be great. And then finally, on September 1st, it was very sadly at the closing day of the Whitmore Pool lap swim. So huge thanks to all of.
2:08:13 Our great community of lap swimmers. Thanks to staff for an amazing party. Thanks for the cake. And finally, thanks to my awesome swim partner, Stu, because I don't know if either one of us would have made it to 50 miles without each other. So that was a really fun thing to do. And yeah, so thanks. Thanks for the awesome t-shirt.
2:08:33 Do you want to give Stu his name? Yeah, I guess on that note, because Stu was down in LA, he wasn't there to receive his Whitmore 50 Challenge swim cap, which we now have five members of the Whitmore 50 Club and his t-shirt too, which Betsy is apparently sporting right now. So there you go, Stu. Congratulations.
2:08:56 We actually started, we saw this at Bakersfield, like pool, and we're like, oh, 50, that's going to be, yeah, we can do that. That's like two, three miles a week over all summer, and then all of a sudden you're in the last couple of weeks going, hmm, we've got to swim a lot. How are we going to do this? I think I swam like 20 miles in August, right, just to get the number, so. Yeah, we swam a lot in August. Great program, but wonderful program, and I know the numbers are in here, but it really did kind of bump up our visitation and interest and excitement for our facility, so a really, really good program, but thank you.
2:09:24 We did have two people swim over 100 miles, which is just mind-boggling to me. And then I think, too, next, just talking to everyone, kind of, you know, this is sort of a first year, but I think next year we'll have even more participation now that people kind of understand what it is. So, yeah, very cool. And I sent Stu a picture of our trip to Bakersfield, and I was like, this didn't seem this hard back in February. But it was a really cool thing, and it was definitely well-received. So thanks to staff for organizing it.
2:09:53 That concludes my commissioner report. Request for agenda items. So we have disc golf coming back, Stu, our monthly plan MCP update. We should know soon, maybe today, about the playground. And then I think we also have summer programming. Correct. October. So is that it? That's it. Okay. Anything else anyone wants? And I still continue to put the Forest Service meetings into the staff report as well as kind of if you could keep updating us on the events.
2:10:22 Absolutely. That would be great. Well, if there is nothing further, I will adjourn us to our special meeting on Thursday at 4 o'clock at the Community Center for our programming focus group. Thanks, everybody. Good job. Okay. Well, there we go.