TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2017

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

299 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Business, you know, there is no business.

0:29 Nice to see you doing well. Very well, how are you? Well, thank you. All right, sit and listen and see what's going on. Check in. Talk about my duties again. Good morning, John. Oh, yes, sir. Nice to see you today. Good morning. And we'll call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, October 3rd, 2017. Roll call, please. Good morning. Hello. Present. Thank you.

1:25 This time, I will open the floor for public comments. This is the time during which anyone who wishes to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do so. Good morning, Madam Chair, Commissioner, staff, members of the community. Good morning, Matthew. Rich Botts, you have Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Quack, quack. Last year, we had our Ducks for Kids program. The 4th of July is just around the corner.

1:52 We will start duck sales in January. With a small group of people, over 30 days, we generated more than $5,000. So as a reminder, our rec commissioners, when our U Sports folks come along, say, go talk to Baccia. We got ducks. I'm wearing the rotary hat right now. It's a great cause. So good morning. Happy October. I look forward to hearing the conversation this morning. Thank you. Thank you, Rich, and thank you for giving our entire staff a heart attack to think that we're almost to next Fourth of July.

2:21 That means winter's already happened, though. Yeah, exactly. Wait a minute. Okay, seeing no additional public comments, I will close public comments and move on to the consent agenda. I actually have a couple of changes on the minutes. Do you guys have anything? No, but let's discuss them. Okay. Do you have anything in the minutes? No. Okay, we'll start with those and then pull the staff report. Okay. These are pretty minor changes.

2:52 I just have in item number three, I believe it's Recreation Supervisor Kat Kelly. And in item number five, the grant notification was delayed because of the extended deadline. If there are no further changes, I would entertain a motion. Betsy, did you say you were pulling the staff report? Correct. Okay. So we'll do the minutes first and then the staff pick. So I will make a motion to approve the minutes as amended? I will second that.

3:26 I have a motion and a second. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Motion passes 3-0. Okay. And then, Sean, did you have anything specific on the staff report? Well, I just want to confirm, and I was looking for it, that we talked last time about the contracts for the concessionaires coming up, and I just want to confirm that they were coming up next year. Is that right, Stu? That's our understanding at this time. Okay. Yep.

3:58 Do you know any further information as far as the contracts themselves come up and then they're awarded for the summer season of 19? Is that right? Is that how that works? I'm looking at Hayes over there. Hayes, do you have any update on that you want to provide commission on in regards to the Forest Service campground process or is it still? Hayes has kind of been our contact with the Forest Service on the process. Thank you, Hayes. Thank you, buddy. I don't have a ton to add that.

4:26 But we are working with the Forest Service on this opportunity and looking to see how we can take advantage of this working with some partners. I don't have a lot of details, but there will be something forthcoming in the next few months. Okay. Thank you for saying that. And I'll tell you why I'm asking. And, you know, this is something that I've kind of discussed a little bit. But I do like the idea of trying to get those campgrounds to stay open a month later or two.

4:54 You know, I get it as a business. They want to close down. They're concerned about freezing pipes, not enough customers. But we as, you know, the Recreation Department or Tourism or however you want to put it, MLR, whatever the case may be, I sure would love to, I don't want to use the S word, subsidized word, but I would like to really see those campgrounds. We get one freezing weekend and then it's gorgeous for another seven weeks.

5:21 And just from a tourism standpoint, a recreation standpoint, I'd love to see those campgrounds stay open later if we can assist in some way. That's my reason for asking. Thank you, Hayes, for keeping us updated. Thank you. Stu, I think you had a couple of things you wanted to highlight when you talk about the pool assessment. Yeah, so, you know, we just, I put a couple of images here of the Tales and Trails event, so that went really well. That was a good turnout. We're working with the Lions Club on a...

5:54 on the initiative for next year, and I think there's some good opportunities for us to create some goodwill and exposure in our community, so that really went well. Deferred maintenance program, just some updates here, I included some images of the new Shady Rest Snack Jack, the fascia of the pavilion as well, still a little bit of work to do on that one, and that small kind of storage building, so that was really well done, we've just got a couple of follow-up items with the contractor.

6:18 As far as the facility condition assessment, we got that back yesterday. We had one conversation with the folks from Terracon. We've got a few amendments to make, but it was very enlightening. So they've given us one is they categorize it as immediate repairs to the facility based on current conditions, codes, regulations, building.

6:43 Pool, Aquatics, that we have to kind of take care of before we really look at opening again. And then we have intermediate work items. And we have some kind of long-term energy-saving ideas as well. And they've given us a like-for-like and an enhanced option for that facility as well if we want to consider constructing or enhancing the pool at Whitmore. So a really good assessment. We'll be coming back to you, obviously, in...

7:11 October 31st, Halloween, with kind of a little work plan on that pool. So we'll kind of run through what we're going to look at and how it fits into the budget that we have with our deferred maintenance program. So that's the last little kind of plan. We do have a little bit of a plan and a discussion going at the ball fields with Little League as well. So that's the other one that we're looking at kind of finalizing a plan for. And then, you know, shady rest, a lot of that work is being pushed back from the fall.

7:39 to the spring. So essentially all the concrete work, all the bleachers, all the paths, all the bleachers will all be done kind of in the spring. So that's kind of the update there. And then we still have some work to do at Shady Rest completing those projects as well. So we're moving as fast as we can, but we're kind of moving in a hopefully what we see is kind of a strategic and well-thoughtful approach to these items.

8:08 That's kind of all I had unless Warren, did you have any updates on the parks at all? No huge updates. I do want to bring up the whole shady rest project. I mean, if you guys haven't been out there lately to see what has been done just to the snack shack and that small room over there, it has made a huge difference. Staff this year with those remodeling the poly cap, the front partitions to the older bathrooms, and then they spent quite a bit of time out there on reseeding the fields and stuff.

8:36 Sorry. And we've seen, we've had several people come forward and just compliment on how the park looks. So if you guys haven't been out there lately, right now is prime time for it. It looks great. And right now is the prime time. And it's great to see the kids out there playing soccer, you know, after dark, after dark. I mean, all the parks do look good right now. But I mean, with the funds that have gone towards Shady Rest, it has made a huge improvement.

9:03 It looks fantastic. Really great job. And I keep cornering people at soccer and being like, look, did you see how great this looks? So I wonder if I know that we won't be able to finish some of the work until spring, but I wonder if maybe we can do, I don't know, a press release or even just keep mentioning it at council just so the community really understands that we are trying to really address some of this deferred maintenance. So it's funny, actually, two of my friends who are from women's club were working in the snack shack on Saturday and I was like, so what do you guys think? And they're like,

9:31 Oh yeah, this is nice. Just reminding them, is that what you're saying? Well, I was kind of pointing it out. So it's only noticeable when it was so bad? It's so good that you don't even notice it because it's just normal now. That's awesome. Yeah, it's pretty cool. So nicely done. Yep, kind of sad.

9:47 Actually, I do want to ask one more question following up going back to the sidewalks. First of all, I'm very excited. I've never been as excited about a community project as seeing what's going on on Main Street right now. So Hayes, great job and everyone's team. It's just very exciting to see that. Can you speak to what sidewalk projects are coming up in the next year or more?

10:15 Yeah, we were scheduled to be in front of council last month on the 20th with an update on snow management and sidewalks. That was kind of pushed back. We now think it's October or later. But we have a presentation. I'm happy to kind of share it with you. And we could schedule that for October 31 if you want to look at kind of our outline. And what we've done is actually gone through and GISed all our sidewalks, which kind of describes, you know, the priority of those sidewalks.

10:41 The level of effort that we apply to those sidewalks. And I think it'll be helpful for the Commission to kind of hear that as well. And then if the sidewalk does get completed this year, it's something that Warren and his team will take on this year. I think the larger discussion is, you know, 2018, 2019, the other sidewalk projects, and how are they going to be kind of addressed as we move forward with kind of our staffing and our resources. And that's kind of that larger discussion that we'd like to have with Council.

11:10 I think it's a good idea that we can kind of bring that forward to you and kind of give you an overview of the sidewalks. Thank you. Yeah, I think it'd be great for the public to know what we're getting in the next year or three or five, you know, kind of what the long-term plan is for sidewalks. So thank you. I look forward to that presentation. Right. Awesome. And then the only other thing that I have is just the government officials' perceptions of parks and recreation report is a really good read. So take a look at that when you have a chance. Great.

11:42 There's nothing further. I would entertain a motion to accept the department report. I'll make a motion to accept the department report. I'll second. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Motion passes 3-0, and that will bring us into our presentation today, the Parks and Recreation Department 2017 Summer Camps and Adult Programs Performance. Good morning.

12:29 So Lauren loaded the presentation on the website too. So if the public want to follow along, if they're watching in Granicus, they can certainly do so. And certainly it's made available to public media and anybody who likes to or is interested in getting an update on our summer of camps, programs and events. How do I make it? Thank you. Got it. Oh my. Perfect.

12:58 Good morning. This is a brief presentation over our summer programs. I'm Lauren Plum, Recreation Department. So our goal for our summer programs this year was to provide residents and visitors with high-quality recreation facilities and diverse programming that promotes a degree of excitement, individual expression, exploration, pleasure, challenge, and accomplishment that can lead to an improved quality of life.

13:28 This is in line with our vision statement for our department to be the best alpine recreation community in the country, noble goals, and our department mission to provide multipurpose year-round indoor and outdoor recreation opportunities accessible to all residents and visitors. So summer recreation consisted of our ever-popular summer camps for youths, our adult programs, the parks and facility rentals,

13:58 So, like family reunions, church groups, that type of thing. The Whitmore Pool with swim team, lap swimming, swim lessons, community events, town cleanup day, our first ever Parks and Recreation Month. We have one more. What was the other one? And the Fourth of July Parade. Thank you. And then ongoing park maintenance and special event support.

14:29 So our youth summer camps, we offered 26 camps this year, which was down three camps from 2016. We did not offer next-level basketball camp this year. We had 624 participants, and we offered centralized drop-off and pickup at the rec zone. So we were a little confined to how many, because we offered centralized pickup and drop-off, we had a fleet of vehicles, but we only had so many seats in those vehicles. So we had to cap our enrollment.

14:58 Last year when people wanted to join into Adventure Camp or Wilderness Camp, sure, just drop them off here and it was fine. But offering centralized drop-off and pickup and providing transportation, we had a hard cap on those camps this year. As far as the wait list goes, we did everything we could to reduce them, which included transferring to other camps. So our Adventure Camp had the largest wait list.

15:24 It ran concurrently with the Girl Power Camp. So I contacted every girl within that age group on that wait list and was like, hey, I don't know if you guys knew this, but we also offer a Girl Power Camp. And with that, a lot of people enrolled in Girl Power Camp. They told their friends that we even had people transfer out of Adventure into Girl Power Camp. So we're working in any way we can. We also looked at age groups. So if they were like borderline age group and they could have fit in the youth group, they're pretty athletic, they have an older sibling, sure, not a problem.

15:54 With the Wave Rave skate camps, we were able to accommodate all of the people on our wait list. After the first camp or the second camp, we figured out that all of the skate parks and camp are pretty centrally located, so we just ran rounds. It wasn't confined to the fleet of vehicle seat numbers. We just kept circling. And so we were able to accommodate.

16:20 Anyone on the wait list for Wave Race Gate Camps. And with that, we did find our limit to be about 50 kids in that camp with 10 minis and 40 child youth age group. So you'll see our participation in summer camps has increased hand over fist every year until this past year. We've kind of felt our limits out. We do feel that the ratio of camp counselors, the campers,

16:51 Seem to be really good where we're at now. So we're providing good interaction with the camp counselors. Everyone feels safe. They're having fun out there. Then in adult programs, we saw a significant decrease. We have 597 adult participants in summer programs. Down 35% from 2016, which we had 904. Why is this?

17:22 So 86% of our adult participants are softball enthusiasts. Of those 597, 348 are regional visitors for a softball tournament. They don't live in the area. We have a men's and a co-ed softball tournament. The men's sold out with 16 teams. The co-eds had 13 teams, which is a little bit down from last year. And our league play, we went from 20 teams in 2016 to 13 teams.

17:52 We had a bunch of teams merge in the co-ed league, three teams merged into one, two teams merged into one, and one team retired. When asked what's going on, like, did they not like the program last year, the majority of the people said they're either working too much or they worked too much. They're tired from the winter or now summer is just rolling along, the economy's up and they, you know, everyone's short-staffed and they're...

18:19 depending on their regular employees, and they just couldn't get the time off to play. Can I have some follow-up questions specifically to the softball? Did we experience that same drop-off in softball play in the heydays of the 2007-8 periods, or were we doing it back then? We were doing it back then, yeah. It just kept getting bigger and bigger, and this is the first year that it's turned around.

18:52 When I talked to players, they told me they just had to work. It was too much work. That's too bad, but I get it. I know that feeling. Well, because if you look at 2010 and 2011, which would have been, you know, sort of similar. That was our last big snow year, yeah. But then we went into drought, so.

19:13 So just one more quick question, Lauren, and maybe you're going to get to this, but so does this include the volleyball tournament in these numbers, or is that in a separate section? It does not include the volleyball numbers. This is softball participants, tennis, tennis camps, drop-ins, and private lessons. So we did also see a decrease in tennis participation just due to the conditions of the court. We're trying to get the courts resurfaced.

19:42 At a reasonable price, as you know. And it was unfortunate we couldn't do it before this season, but we should be lined up before next season. But with that, a lot of feedback from the community. They just switched over to Snow Creek to play, and that's where they played this summer. I mean, our courts were still used pretty regularly. They just got a lot of feedback on their condition of them. Thank you.

20:09 Program metrics, you can see that the youth summer camp recovered 98% of their cost, and the adult programs recovered 115%. The town council approved subsidies for recreation programming, just stating that it enhances quality of life, provides a service, community benefit, and youth programs are subsidized 80 to 90%, so we're well within that.

20:37 Region, and the adult programs are subsidized 10 to 20 percent, and they've paid for themselves this summer. We're not losing any money, but we're spending all the money we can back into these programs. And just to clarify, this is direct cost recovery. This is direct cost. The indirect costs and overhead go into administrative costs, so the cost of the pool maintenance doesn't go into junior lifeguard camp. That's just...

21:06 in our overhead. Thank you. Any questions here? Okay, you look thoughtful. So, how did the community think we did? We sent out surveys to every enrollee, included it on our Facebook page, sent it out on a newsletter, it was on our website, and we received 101 surveys back. Last year we received 108, and the year before we received 87. I changed the settings in about mid-July when I figured it out.

21:36 where people can take multiple surveys. So we have 624 participants. Of those, 265 are individual children. So they're just re-enrolling over and over and over again. And there are approximately 174 families. I just did unique last names. So we're getting a good response from the community on how they think we're doing. And we have a lot of repeat customers. So our survey insights,

22:06 They felt like the registration process was improved. We rolled it out all on the same day. It was well advertised. It's predictable for the future. We're going to keep that moving forward. They also felt that we had improved quality instruction. Last year, some of the feedback we got from the surveys and from the focus group was that they wanted an older camp counselor set, and we accommodated that. It was a really great group. They worked well together and were well liked by the kids.

22:33 Improved availability of information. I emailed all of the participants the week before reminding them they registered for a camp. Here's the flyer. This is what you need to bring on the first day. This is what time and place we're meeting. And they really enjoyed that because they're registering beginning of April. A lot of stuff happens between now and then. We had an 8% increase in new participants. I think most of that is from the mini camps. Kids just rolling in, aging into.

23:02 Camping. We had a decrease in conditions of the fields and facilities, mainly the tennis courts that I spoke to earlier, and we continue to have high satisfaction of service. This is the actual survey results. This is from a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being poor, 5 being excellent. All of our metrics are between 4 and 5, somewhere between good and excellent. We decreased a little in customer service.

23:32 That was mainly when I dug into a little bit more tennis enthusiasts who felt like their customers too and were not taking care of their needs and conditions of field and facility. So those kind of went hand in hand. These are a general overview of comments. I can email you all of the comments after the meeting. Sorry, that wasn't in the packet. So basically people thought the...

24:00 Counselors were awesome. Climbing camps were really well received. They didn't really like camping at the rec zone. We'll get to that in a second. Please fix the tennis courts. Expanded pool programs. We also held a focus group on September 7th. All parents were invited to attend. They got this in a blast email. I also individually emailed parents who had already started to give us feedback.

24:30 or any individuals in the community that were identified by the chair or the director that they wanted included in this. We presented, just like I did, the survey results, asked them their opinion on why we got the results we did, and then we discussed our summer programs, and we did a little wrap-up, like a keep, stop, start, what they would like to keep moving forward.

24:58 What they want to stop doing in the future and what they'd like to see added. So a little summary here. They like the affordability. Of course they do. It's a very affordable camp compared to other Southern California summer programs. We did have a discussion on early drop-off and late pickup. We didn't feel like it was well utilized. It was something we added kind of last minute. But the parents that were at the focus group felt it was...

25:27 Really invaluable for them. So we're toying with the idea of like a free sign up the week before like here's your reminder. Let me know if you want early drop off late pickup and what time you're going to be there to better allocate for our resources. They liked the emailed reminder and flyer and they felt like that was a good program to move forward. The registration process, like I said before, is predictable. It was open to everyone. It's something that as we keep moving forward and keeping it consistent,

25:57 Everyone in the community can kind of get on the same boat and same program. They know, oh, that one Monday in April, I need to remember to register all my kids for camps. The quality of the camp instructors, like I said, we had a really great group, and it was noticed by the community as well. And keep addressing deferred maintenance projects. They didn't like camping at the rec zone. It worked out well for us this year.

26:24 With the group camp sites being under construction, and then with the late opening of the lake basin, like Shady Rust was heavily impacted early season, so I felt like it worked well this season, but next season we're going to try to go back there. And then what to start for next year, more training for the swim teachers. So we did get some feedback. Our swim teachers are young, and they have...

26:52 I think all teachers kind of experience this nervousness when they have a parent in the group with them. So it's just building that confidence in themselves and in their product. And we're going to provide more training for them and do more in-service throughout the year to build that confidence moving forward. Adjusting many age groups. The difference between a 3-year-old and a 5-year-old is pretty significant. So we're going to have to address that moving forward.

27:20 Our next age group is 6 to 9, so the difference between a 5-year-old and a 9-year-old is also significant, so we're just going to have to play with that a little bit. They were a strong interest in non-physical camps, like STEM, science, technology, engineering, math. I was like, what's that? Lego camps, art camps, more interpretive, like educational camps. Kat and I are looking into that now.

27:46 And then we got some feedback in adjusting the pool hours on Sundays, is it 12 to 5? Sundays was 12 to 5 and it was received that, you know, that's a lot of people's nap times. The toddlers that want to come to the pool, they take a nap in the afternoon and then it's dinner time, they would have loved to come earlier. So Saturdays 10 to 5.

28:11 Ten to five? Ten to four. I was just thinking. I don't think that's right. Ten to four. So they'd like to see that consistent through the weekend. In addition to that, we added the five-week swim lesson, which was really well-received. They just wanted to see a second rendition of that so you could do ten weeks of swimming throughout the summer. Moving on to facility rentals. Our revenue for rentals is up 50% since 2015.

28:36 As far as the facility usage hours, when I dug into it, it didn't seem like there was a consistent pattern of documenting the facility usage hours over the last three years. So we've set it up, Kat and I are working to clean it up, and next year we'll be able to tell you exactly how many paid rental hours were used, internal use for town use or camps, facility use agreements like AYSO or swim team, and then contract instructors.

29:05 who also use our facility for their classes. So we'll be able to break that out for you a little bit better. But I didn't want to present you with a graph that was all over the place, and I don't think we've had consistency. So we're working to improve that. Revenue has increased over the past two years. You'll see a big decrease in Shady Rest Park. We had one rental last year where they rented the entire park, and it was $2,000. So it was kind of a one-off shoot event.

29:34 It was great. I don't expect to see that year after year, though. And we're working to, you know, just advertise it better to the community. These facilities are available for your birthday party, your family reunion, your homeowners association meeting, whatnot. So overall, that's weird that came up like that. The red, let me go real quick.

30:03 The red is the Community Center, so here, and then the blue is the Shady Rest Park, and the other yellow part up there is the Whitmore Recreation Area. So Community Center, mainly because it's year-round, is holding its own as like a major dominant feature. The Shady Rest Park is just mostly the barbecue area.

30:28 And sometimes soccer fields or baseball fields, but those are kind of one-off things. And then the Whitmore Recreation Area has been increasing over the past couple years. I'm sure you've seen the onflux of cross-country teams every August. And they've found out that you can rent the track and get exclusive use of it. It's great. So they're starting to do that year after year. Do you have any questions? Yes? I do. Did we have any rentals for the new pavilion at Trails End? No. No. Yeah, okay.

30:59 But we're advertising that that's available now, right? Yes. I don't think it hasn't been out there that long. I'm just curious. Yeah. Any other questions? I'm going to save some for the end. Okay. Kat's going to talk about the pool. Thank you. Great job. Thank you, Laura. All right. Good morning. Kat Kelly, Recreation Supervisor. Nope. There we go.

31:42 All right, so Whitmore Pool this season. I think we had a really successful season down there. Some of the highlights from this year were that we actually had a site coordinator down at Whitmore Pool this year, so I think that helped with the operations down there, the smooth running of the staff, scheduling, that kind of thing. We also, at the start of the season, myself and the assistant site coordinator,

32:07 Went up to Reno and became certified pool operating, received our pool operating certifications. So that just allowed a few more people other than Derek to be able to administer the chemicals to the pool and be in control of that. We added the new six-week swim lesson program this year.

32:31 Previously, we'd only ever offered swim lesson camps, so Monday to Friday for one hour a day each day of that week. This year, we looked into offering a weekly swim lesson so that perhaps more local families would be able to attend those lessons just coming every Monday or every Saturday. That was really well received. As Lauren mentioned, we were asked if we could do another one as well, sort of if families were away at the start of the summer or the end of the summer, they were provided with two alternatives for the weekly swim program.

33:00 We also added our new Whitmore 50 Challenge, which was very well received by our lap swimmers. We had three participants swim over 100 miles this summer, which is great. Our chair, our director were also members of the inaugural Whitmore 50 Challenge Club, so I think congratulations is well-deserved there. Another addition that we had this year was the world's largest swim lesson, so this is a national...

33:27 A national event whereby we offer free swim lessons for a day. That was well received. We sort of came into that quite late in the running, so next year I'd like to see that advertised earlier in the season and really try and grow that event. I think that's really important with water safety and public safety here. We also launched our free swim Sundays, which were kind of in line with our free Friday skates at the ice rink.

33:55 Once again, that was well received. And we had another year of no mechanical closures at the pool. So I think that's a testament to Warren and her staff to be able to allow the pool to continue running or an older facility to run without any closures. So that's great. We did have a few more storm closure days this year with the afternoon thunderstorms we had rolling through late summer, but no mechanical closures. So that's great.

34:21 We operated for a total of 106 days this year, one more than last year. We actually operated on Memorial Day, which we hadn't done in the past. We were able to do that this year because we had a larger number of staff present in town before we actually opened for public rec swim. The average daily attendance rose by seven this year, so that's exciting that we're seeing more visitation to the pool.

34:47 Overall, we had a 24% increase of visitation to Whitmore Pool this year. I think a number of things helped out the increase in swim lesson participants. We also are a little bit better with tracking the swim team attendance at Whitmore Pool for their training sessions. Looking at who visited the pool, obviously RecSwim, our public swim time is still our largest percentage of visitors.

35:14 Lap Swim, though, and Swim Team are there pretty equal, which is great. Our swim lessons are improving. They were up from last year, which I think tracked at about 6%, so I think that's really important to keep pushing that program. We do have a lot of non-swimmers in our community, and I think being around a lot of bodies of water, it's something that we should continue to try and advocate.

35:38 Our swim lesson participants up this summer, as I said, predominantly that was in the group swim lessons and I think that was the addition of the weekly swim program. So allowing people to come once a week for their swim lesson throughout the course of the summer. So we'll definitely include that in our program next year and like I said, we'll look at offering a second six-week weekly swim program. And quick question on that, Kat, that's just our adult swim program, right? Not the ones done by Tri Club.

36:08 Yes, correct, yeah, sorry, there we go. So the revenue this year, like our visitation, we were up again this year, up by 19%, so that's great. Admissions, obviously, are our primary revenue source, they're at 30%. Our facility rentals are starting to climb as well, as Lauren mentioned, we are getting more and more

36:34 Rentals of the Whitmore Recreation Area. We have quite a few tri-clubs now that are coming up from Southern California that will rent the Whitmore track and the pool exclusively for a weekend so that they can hold training sessions at both. So we've developed some good relationships with a couple of clubs down there that look like they'll continue into the future and hopefully they'll bring more up to our high-altitude training facility that we have here.

36:59 And that, sorry, is pretty much it for the pool. Does anyone have any other questions regarding how the summer went there? I have some questions, but it's kind of on the entire present, and I may need to pull. Oh, there she is. She's going to have a little chat about the community events that we ran this season. I guess we can... Then I'll wait for that. Great. Perfect. Thank you, Kat. I do want to compliment all our team.

37:30 Spent a lot of time working on these numbers. And in the staff packet, you know, we don't go through a lot of immense detail on a PowerPoint, but that's in your packet. So if you do want to look at each and every camp, broken down by revenue and cost of labour and so forth, that's in your packet. I'm just going to quickly run through community events. These are the main ones that we kind of do in summertime. Obviously, we do several more. We have the Halloween event coming up October 27th.

37:56 But Town Cleanup Day is always a big undertaking. It takes the whole community, so we're a big advocate. We're a big supporter. Fourth of July celebrations, as you know. Rotary is just taking over the town, doing a great job. Thank you. Parks and Recreation Month. Staff wanted to make sure that I did cover all these little events that we did, and it's something we want to really kind of keep top of mind with our community as we move forward. And we kind of focused on an event at each of our facilities or our camps and our programs.

38:21 In addition to free skate night at the rec zone, that's kind of how we kicked off Park and Recreation Month. We had the men's and co-ed softball tournaments on those two weekends at Shady Rest. Those two tournaments, Parks and Rec is going to take over next year. So the person who's been doing it for 17 years that John works with will take those over. So that's a big undertaking for us. We did the first annual beach volleyball tournament, which is great. We didn't include those numbers in adults because there was a lot of mix of kids and adults.

38:50 But again, it was just another way that we're reaching out to the community, so we're really excited about that. And with the enhancements, next year will be, I think, an even more popular event as well. And then our free swim Sunday at the Whitmore Pool. And I think one of the things we'll look at, and the goal of this presentation is to come back to the commission early December with kind of our program and our recommendations for next year. So any comments would be great for that. Just really quickly, special event support. It's a big undertaking, the department.

39:19 is responsible for, we permitted about 34, or exactly 34 special event permits this year, and then we coordinate with a lot of our jurisdictional partners in the community, we manage a lot of our facility and equipment reservations as well, it's a big undertaking, Warren and his team take on a big role with that, as you know a lot of equipment comes and goes every week, so we have a great

39:44 New enhanced process that's helping us keep an eye and can track of that equipment. So we'll continue to improve and refine that process. Mammoth Lakes Recreation, with a lot of our funding and support, and then obviously we do the contracting with both Measure U and Town General Funds. And for the benefit of the community, we're working with a little task force right now with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on a special event position and a scope of work for that position and how that position

40:11 Integrates with our responsibilities at this time. So that's something we'll work through the next couple of months. And I know Sean will kind of speak to that as it moves along. Just a quick summary on a deferred maintenance program. We have that available balance of about $300,000. When I say about, it's going to fluctuate here and there. So we're getting kind of close to these are the committed projects that either have taken place or a plan to take place. The number here you want to look at there is...

40:39 185,000 plus is already kind of committed or has happened, which leaves a balance of about 114,000. The 114,000 has to take care of the deferred maintenance at the pool, which is kind of the facility condition assessment work that will come back forth. We have a little bit of work to do at the bore fields at Whitmore as well, and then there's still quite a bit of work to do at Shady Rest. I can talk about that further if you wish, if you have any follow-up questions. And this is just kind of what's included in the packet that I've kind of covered.

41:09 So tennis courts is next spring. Shady rest, we talked about. Shady rest, all the concrete, all the work, all the paths, all the bleachers is next spring. We've already done the snack shack. And here's the snack shack project. So for the amount of money, which was just over $38,000, we completely recited and sealed the snack shack so it's no longer a wildlife sanctuary.

41:34 We did the fascia on the pavilion. That was something that people didn't realise we did as well. So the two ends, that's been replaced. We have a little bit of work to do on the roof of that facility. We're getting there. And this little shed was kind of a little league shed that was used by that club. So we recited that. So that's going to give us a lot more time to kind of use that facility. We think we can get the last one. I think it was built in 1994. So we see this kind of enhancement giving us another 15 to 20 years at least.

42:04 Very popular, as we talked about Whitmore Track and Sports Field, a few enhancements to do down there, and then as well we talked about the facility condition assessment. And that is our presentation. So again, thank you for the staff, for a lot of work. I'll just get here and press a few buttons. Questions? Before you do ask questions, we're going to plan to take this to the council, probably in a revised format, probably for their November meeting, their November 1 meeting. We can kind of give them a quick...

42:33 overview of kind of how we did this summer as well. So thank you. Thank you. Nice work, everyone. Questions? I have mostly comments. First of all, I wanted to go back and say awesome job on cleanup day. For a couple of months now, that's been in my mind that we didn't see and you guys really, really took it to the next level this year. It was

42:55 A huge undertaking, the cleanup after this winter, and you guys are actually in my neighborhood helping me clean up, and it was amazing how good the town looked after that, so thank you guys for that.

43:07 I'm sorry I took a couple of months to say that. So I heard a lot of anecdotal good things about the summer camps this year. And an interesting segment of the population that I never really thought about before is folks that come just for the summer. They're transitioning between places or maybe seeing if they can live here. And I heard a lot of folks in that situation saying how good it was.

43:31 To be able to access these camps and have these resources for their kids. They even talked a lot about the arts camps as well. So it seemed like there was a really good offering this summer, and you seemed to be really responsive to the comments last summer. So from an anecdotal standpoint, I heard that from the community as well. So great job on the camps this summer. Talking about swimming lessons a little bit, I know you had talked earlier, Kat, about the family swim lesson aspect.

44:00 I noticed your adult lessons went down, didn't seem like you had a real response to that. Have you thought about trying to do an adult lesson in parallel with those weekly kid lessons? Yeah, so I think that's some of the additions that we're looking at next year. The adult lessons that were up there is mainly the stroke improvement classes, so that's predominantly lap swimmers that are already swimming, you know, that just want to improve their strokes and get more efficient.

44:27 What we're looking at or what I've been looking into is particularly with trying to encourage more swim participation, particularly within the Hispanic community. A lot of the literature on that suggests that often parents don't swim, so therefore children aren't put in swim lessons. And one of the ways down south that they've looked at trying to combat that is by offering a free adult lesson with

44:55 With the children at first, and then sort of, you know, once the adults get in the water, having the kids enrolled in a program and then trying to get the adults enrolled in a program themselves as well. So that's certainly something that we'll look at next year, particularly sort of trying to...

45:10 Move towards that kind of family involvement, so having the family lesson, having everyone there, having that free lesson. That's where I think as well the world's largest swim lesson, we could really use that to try and broaden our reach with who's getting in the pool because that's a great opportunity to kind of have everyone at the pool. It's just a matter of registering for your free lesson. Everyone gets it.

45:31 20-minute free lesson, regardless of their ability, but it is directed more at non-swimmers and trying to get them into the water. So yeah, that's something that we'll look at for next year. Yeah, I was just thinking if you had such a great response to that weekly lesson format, maybe, you know, kids get 45 minutes, mom gets half an hour, drop the kid off and have a few minutes and then get yourself in there.

45:53 Right. Yeah, definitely. You know, just keep thinking of things like that. I think that's great to keep expanding the options and seeing what might work as the desires and needs of the community changes. Yeah. Yeah. So, great job, though. Sounds like it was a great summer, and like I said, I heard a lot of anecdotal good things about it, so. Great. Good job. That's all. Sean? Okay. Yeah, just kind of going back on a couple things. First of all, I noticed that Faisha on the...

46:20 Roof there, and not just because I know about it, but I was there for my son's soccer practice. I thought, wow, hey, that does look much better. So I just really want to say, and I hear these comments kind of regularly from the community about...

46:33 When are we going to improve this or that or the pool? And I just very much appreciate how you, the staff, and we take the time to prioritize what needs to be addressed with regard to the deferred maintenance because we only got so much money. And I'm able to articulate with the community, I feel like, because of these presentations of, hey, we're working on it. And, you know, the snack shack was more important than dealing with this, and it kind of works out along those lines.

47:02 I'm kind of going backwards. Yeah, Stu, you and I are sitting on this ad hoc committee? Yes. Okay. Yes, with regard to the events position, and I can tell you from putting on an event myself how much I very much appreciate the support that the town gives special events when it comes to you need to make sure you're doing this, filing this form, you're working with the transit authority, you're working with the waste disposal company, you're working with all these different

47:30 All these different agencies. And, you know, here in the Eastern Sierra, too, when it comes to private contractors, there's only a limited resource. You know, there's not a lot of competition out there. So you got Bill's or Mr. K's when it comes to towing. You've only got Mammoth Community Waste Disposal when it comes to outhouses. So I appreciate very much, you know, the work that you do. And that, I think, will guide us in the Ad Hoc Committee as we look to what other this is going to.

47:57 Support. And I'll be giving a presentation tomorrow during public comments at town council, kind of about Palooza Palooza wrap-up. You mentioned about the tri-clubs that are coming up here to work with us. Lauren, whoever presented that. Sorry. How do we get more of them? And that's a, you know, don't need to necessarily answer that now, but I love that, you know, from the tourism

48:24 standpoint that we are really branding this area more and more as high altitude training. And so putting on my tourism hat, I'll say, how do we get more of them up here? Recreation hat, you know, I'll say, how do we provide better facilities? That really encourages them to bring it up. And, you know, likewise with MLR, where do we make the investments that really encourage this?

48:47 I was going to ask a question following up on what Lauren said about with regard to our adult program as well as our youth program. Did you say or do you have any data on how many are out-of-towners versus locals who are participating in our camps? I do not, but I can pull those numbers as well and email it to you.

49:09 I'd be curious to know if they're increasing, decreasing, because something I want to say is that, yeah, we're a destination mountain resort community. And we offer, we have the ability to offer some camps that you can't offer in LA or San Diego. And John Connolly, to you, I want to say you are the best. I am, with regard to this specific experience that I had with you, I dropped off my kid for a day camp overnighter.

49:37 And I got to tell you, we were showing up really disappointed that we were going to be camping on concrete at the daycare. And I walked in with another parent who wasn't out of town or who likewise was walking in just really disappointed. And you turned us around. You know, you just really right away kind of jumped in and said, hey, it's going to be kind of fun. We can stay up a little bit later. We got the lights. We got all the kids contained. It's a little bit better.

50:05 You know, I want the kids to be camping on dirt so that they can have a campfire. And so definitely, let's address that for next year. But I just got to say, you did a great job in these people who are walking in with concerns and really kind of turned them around for that. Definitely when it comes to 2018, I sure would like to see us taking our kids out to camp on dirt. But I just got to say, that was well handled for the challenge that it was.

50:33 Thanks, and we'll definitely be back out of the campgrounds that are just closed because they had contaminants in their water system. We closed the whole group campground all summer. So I thought, what are we going to do? You know, we're just going to camp the zone. I saw some other parents, too, and I saw them talking, and they're like, we're not going to have our children spend that year. And I approached them, and I'm like, look, your kids are really going to want to, you know, kind of turn me around.

51:03 Yeah, I know. And it was a challenging situation, and I thought you handled that very, very well. I just wanted to make that comment. But at the same time, I would love to see us out on dirt. Have we already made those reservations? I know that those campgrounds, the group have reserved a full year in advance or something, right? Yeah, they're a full year in advance. I haven't made them yet because we haven't set the schedule. But usually we go in January. Okay. And we can still, you know, get in at that time.

51:32 Okay. It's better. Sooner is better. Good. Yeah, that was a biggie. I just want to say, you know, it was a bummer, but at the same time, I thought you handled that very well. Question, what was that one-off rental in Shady Rest Park last year? Was that you or Shady Rest Park? It spiked our numbers. Yeah, it was a group from Mariposa. They did the skate board park, both soccer fields, the picnic shelter. It was just a huge...

52:02 Group of people that came up for the weekend and rented the entire park. Okay. I don't mean to be a harpy on something that are going back to 2015, 16, 16. But did that negatively impact any of our other programs going on? Did it fit in well? No. July is typically our busiest season out there.

52:24 There could have been people who showed up that wanted to use the barbecue pits that maybe they were occupied, but that happens if you don't reserve them occasionally. I don't believe it negatively impacted our local community or visitors alike. It's not something I'd want to do all summer long, for sure. For sure. That's open to everyone, but a one-off, I'll consider it. Yeah, I thought it was good. I mean, it was small numbers. I mean, I know it was a double spike on small numbers, but still I thought that was kind of interesting.

52:54 I think that's everything I had. Thank you. Okay. So I just have one question and a bunch of comments. I really want to say great job. You guys really killed it. And it was really great to be at the focus group and hear how pleased people were. So nicely done. What is our potential to acquire more vehicles so that we could increase our capacity?

53:17 Yeah, I mean, it's not so much the vehicles. We have the vehicles. It's the drivers. It's licensing the drivers. So we actually have two additional vans. So we can have a fleet of four. I think Kyle just got his endorsement yesterday. So he's close to. So that's really the challenge that we have. We're addressing that. And there's some options that we also did with vehicles as well. So we actually rented for the Aquatics camp, I think. Right. And with regard to the licensing,

53:45 I've been talking with the HR manager. We're looking at trying to get someone from Public Works licensed so that they can be a licensing examiner for the DMV. Currently that's what happens at ESTA. They have their own internal process for licensing. It's a quicker process. It takes less time. There's actually been talk that the Class B licensing is going to be removed from Bishop anyway, and so you would have to go to Ridgecrest, which is...

54:13 You know, when we're looking at, you know, it's great that, you know, John, myself and Lauren are going down to do our licensing in the next couple of weeks, but we really need the camp councillors to be licensed. It's difficult with them, though, because they're not always going to be returning, so if we can get a process in place where it's an internal licensing procedure, then we can sort of have our camp councillors at the start of summer go through that rather than having to go through the whole DMV process. So that's what we're looking at now to kind of make that a little bit easier for next year.

54:42 Great. No, thanks for working on that because I did think it was a really good tradeoff. I know it brought our numbers down a little bit, but I think just as a parent who has a camper, it's so much easier to just drop your kid off at the rec zone and pick them up there every day versus driving them wherever. So I did think that was great, but I think there's probably some opportunity to increase our capacity. So thanks for that. One thing I wanted to say just to kind of follow up on Sean's comment is, you know,

55:07 Our department does a lot. Our Parks and Rec department does a lot of things that are not affiliated with traditional Parks and Recreation departments. For example, I bet very few people in town know that we coordinate the fireworks at Crowley Lake. And I just want to mention just what a great, great job you guys do doing all of that stuff in addition to, you know, regular programming and facilities.

55:30 Just want to point that out to the community. And I want to say great job on the focus group. I thought that was really well received. So thank you for that. Nice work. As far as cost recovery, the reason that I brought that up is because in the past we've had a lot of conversations about direct cost recovery versus indirect costs, which I understand are really difficult.

55:51 So our cost recovery looks phenomenal, but I also just want everyone to be aware that that's not including some of the indirect costs like facility maintenance, administrative salaries. So I think that's just really important to keep in mind because it's still really important that we keep those camps affordable even though the cost recovery numbers look good. We got a lot of good feedback on that from the community. Let's see.

56:14 Oh, and just in terms of if we're going to be able to, it was great to have the pool open on Memorial Day this year. We just need to make sure that next year all of our advertising and collateral reflects that. And what else did I have? Oh, and then the reason that I asked about the volleyball is because...

56:34 I think it's also important that we continually evaluate our adult programs. I know softball has been really popular. It certainly makes sense that we saw a decline in those numbers, but I also want to make it clear that it's great that we're introducing things like the volleyball tournament and just kind of keeping up on all of those trends in terms of what adults in the community are looking for recreation-wise. So nice work on that. And we may want to, I know it was a mixture of adults and kids, but I just want to make sure when we take this to council that they understand that we're trying to offer diverse programming and serve as many.

57:03 People as Possible. And then finally, my last comment is just, I appreciate, Kat, your comments about trying to build confidence in the staff, particularly at the pool, but also just in the regular camp counseling staff as well. I think, you know, it can be a little bit difficult when you don't have kids of your own and you feel like you're younger and you're interacting with parents, but I think, you know, parents are not as terrifying as we sometimes appear, right, Sean?

57:30 So I think it's just great to kind of give them the confidence. And particularly like with the, I think that some of the pool staff were surprised this year that we had adults sign up for the world's largest swimming lesson. They were kind of like, but they're adults. I was like, no, it's, you know, we serve everybody. So I want to make that clear as well. So I think that's a great direction to go in with that. And finally, just phenomenal job. I just, I couldn't be prouder of just the programs and that we offer from this department and the, you know.

57:56 Condition of our facilities given all the challenges. I see Warren at the pool at 6.30 in the morning all the time. So just really cannot compliment you guys enough. So great job. Any comments from the public? Summer programs? All right. I just want to throw out, Kat, I'm always happy to talk about swimming lesson stuff with you if you ever want to pick my brain. Can't really, you know, make them be older and in that sense more mature.

58:27 There might be some tricks that we can get into their tool bag that will help them get that confidence. Parents are scary. No, I know. I remember being a teenager teaching parent and child swim lessons, and yeah, I didn't think I could tell them anything. Then when you get on the other side of that, it's kind of interesting. Yeah, I bet. Yeah, Laurel for sure is a great resource with all of her background in swimming, so awesome.

58:53 All right. Thank you. Well, that brings us into the discussion portion of our agenda, and we will move on to item number four, our Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Update. Do you have a staff presentation? Yeah, thank you, Chair. So I'm just going to run through what you have in your packet just really quickly. So attached is the staff report that Town Council will be reviewing considering tomorrow evening. It's an item that they're also...

59:21 discussing and taking action on. In addition, they're also taking action on an item, I think it's item number 14, on debt financing. So they'll cover this introduction first. They're looking at some recommendations, not only from the Commission, but also Mammoth Lakes Recreation on this discussion. And then they're going to consider the debt financing for the facility as well. So we'll kind of cover a little bit of that.

59:46 In the staff report, it's kind of broken down into seven categories. Consistently, we have consistently provided updates to the commission on these items. So programming, design, cost, construction, project schedule, funding, strategies, and then recommendations. So we'll kind of cover that today. Grady is out of town, but Hayes is here this morning to kind of run through the public works side of it. So he'll jump in at kind of a little bit of the cost estimates and the design.

1:00:16 But the staff reports essentially just an overview of kind of where we've been. You know, we consistently bring it to the commission. It's been to council obviously several times. We provided a kind of a little bit of a background, you know, in regards to the CEQA. It's been approved. We're moving forward. The site work has been approved by council. The contract has not been executed. So we're kind of pausing at that time to kind of get some clearer direction. And then the project overview.

1:00:46 The rendering's on the wall. We want to make sure the community's clearly understanding what we're proposing to build at Mammoth Creek Park. And you can see the project. What we talk about here is the building has three major components, but the park itself has five major components, right? So it's got the natural play area. We'll talk about the playground coming up. So that's part of this discussion indirectly. And then certainly the three major components.

1:01:10 Of the multi-use facility itself is the 2,500 square foot community centre, the summer rec zone operation and the Olympic sized ice rink. So those three components is what we're talking about with our project. As far as programming, you know, the last kind of programming renditions that we went through was...

1:01:29 Displayed on the wall. So that was kind of in August. We presented those plans to the kind of Recreation Programming Committee, which we did in August, and we've kind of been through that process. We haven't revised any of the designs right now until we get further direction through commission and through the council. As far as design, it's the same. You know, they're at approximately 25% to 30% design. You can see through A, B, and C.

1:01:55 C is essentially a presentation to the PEDC in regards to the design review. That was previously scheduled for September, and as you know, we moved that back to October 11. That is still scheduled to occur, and that's presenting this complete proposal to the Planning Economic Division Commission at that time. In regards to cost estimates, Haisl will kind of jump up and kind of walk you through kind of where this started and kind of where we are now.

1:02:23 To kind of summarize, I know Grady's kind of covered a lot of the increase in the roof. Also a concern is kind of our industry, you know, escalation and those type of things. So we're kind of working to provide our advisory bodies, MLR and our council with the best estimates we can on kind of the project. And then after Hayes will kind of run through that, we'll kind of run through kind of four or five, which will be kind of construction and schedule.

1:02:51 And then we'll kind of discuss a little bit of kind of the funding strategy. I don't know if Matt's still here. Yeah, Matt's hiding behind the tower. So we can kind of provide the Commission with a little bit of an update on that ad hoc fundraising committee and kind of what our accomplishments there are. And then we'll kind of wrap up with some recommendations that we're presenting to Council that we're very interested to hear the Commission's thoughts on as well. So thank you.

1:03:15 Sure. So I'm not going to belabor these points because you've heard them all before, but I'll just kind of summarize where we are today. So back in May of this year, we had a final construction estimate of $9.5 million. And as you know, just before, the day before actually, we were about to sign the contract for our roof structure. We were notified that they just couldn't get it done.

1:03:39 And so we went back to the drawing board, worked with our architects. We're going to have to do a one-off custom roof structure, the cost of which is going to be about a million dollars more than what we had originally anticipated. That brings our construction budget to right around $10.5 million. And Grady and I feel pretty confident in that number. However, we are hearing from the folks down south that they're seeing

1:04:04 Large increases in construction variability in cost. And so they're warning us to be prepared for cost escalations just due to the bidding climate. And so what you see in the staff report is kind of acknowledging that and kind of preparing the council for the possibility that our budget could increase just based on those variables. And it's really a wild card. I spoke with the architects today and the report came out.

1:04:33 just about a week ago that Los Angeles last quarter increased 8% construction cost. So in three months cost increased 8%. So that's a little nerve-wracking for us talking with local contractors that are not really seeing that but it's something we need to be prepared for because 8% on a $10 million project is a significant amount of money. So what you see in the staff report really just kind of acknowledges that in summary it's

1:05:02 Preparing Council to add an additional $1.5 million for industry-wide cost escalation, bringing the total estimate to $12 million. As far as phasing and so forth, as Stu said, we have a contractor on board ready to start the mass grading work. That was awarded at $486,000. That is included in this estimate. We've been working with that contractor to put him on hold.

1:05:31 He's local, so he understands what we're trying to do here, and he's willing to work with the town on whatever our timing may be, depending on what the council decides. If everything was to come together, we still believe that we could get an ice rink open in November if we're able to get some grading work done this season and get ready for construction starting in the springtime. November 18? November 18. Ice rink only. We wouldn't be able to get the whole building.

1:06:00 If we were fully funded with the community center and so forth, we would reprioritize and focus strictly on the ice rink portion of the building and then dry in the community center and work on that over the wintertime. And just to clarify, that's always been the plan, right? That we'd be skating in November, but that the community center, even if it constructed concurrently, would come a little later. I'm just reiterating the fact I don't want to have any false expectations of what we think we can accomplish in one year. Exactly.

1:06:29 Well, to be clear, we were talking about November 17 originally. Sorry, I just need to be clear. But here we are looking at November 18 with a roof and ice, and that's if everything goes swimmingly here. It would have to go absolutely perfect. Is that locker rooms or is that moving the trailers over in the meantime? We would have restrooms and probably just very bare-bones locker rooms.

1:07:01 Happy to answer any questions. Thank you. I think there's a little more staff presentation from Stu, and then we'll do questions and then public comment and then come back for some consensus comment. Yeah, so, I mean, page 50 of the staff report, I think, is kind of where Hayes left off. You know, that does talk about kind of the construction start. You know, we did kind of, you know, cover that.

1:07:27 We kind of worked through the schedule in regards to the site work. You know, the funding sources is part of this discussion we'll kind of touch on in a sec. Cost escalation was very clear. And then lease extension, you know, we have a hard lease with the school district, Monty County Office of Education, and that's June 30, 2019. Right, so we've got essentially that deadline to kind of work backwards from. And then as you know, they're moving through, and we met with the architect last week.

1:07:56 at that site. So they're already into preliminary designs. They're looking to kind of build. They have to go through the DSA process, so it is going to be a little bit lengthy. But they're optimistic and ambitious, but they'd like to kind of have something in place by 220, and that would be enough availability for 138 children in their childcare facility. So that's kind of that hard deadline as well that we need to kind of make sure everyone's aware on.

1:08:26 In regards to number six in the funding strategy, you know, we've met several times. We have an ad hoc committee meeting. It kind of started as a project kind of group and now it's kind of morphed into a fundraising group. But, you know, we continue to kind of work on these items. I'll quickly kind of run through these and then if Matt's able to jump up and kind of talk a little bit more about that effort, then that'll be really helpful for commission. As you know, MLR is kind of our lead. We're all kind of working to support.

1:08:56 their efforts. So that kind of covers number one. We are also working with MLR on kind of this outbound communication public outreach plan as well with this fundraising framework. So we're kind of really trying to identify these bigger buckets that we want to kind of focus on. We have completed the kind of prospectus piece right now. It's kind of a custom piece that we have ready to go. We presented that to

1:09:21 LA Kings about a month ago. And then with that, we can continue to kind of customize that per or for each individual kind of potential donor. So that's kind of that update there. So we have that piece as well. We have a shared Google Drive that we're kind of sharing documents on. We've gone through and identified all our kind of fundraising inventory, kind of what we're looking at for winter and summer. So we have that identified.

1:09:48 That's kind of plugged in, ready to go in an implementation area. As we move forward, Matt's kind of working on his lead list and kind of, as I said, working through those buckets. And then we've got kind of a repository for our facility documents, budgets and plans that we're working through. So Matt, I don't know if you wanted to jump up and just give Commissioner a brief update. MLR also had this same item tonight as well at 5 o'clock.

1:10:14 So we want to make sure we get enough information to Matt and his team for MLR tonight. So thank you. Thanks, too. Matt McLean, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So as Sue's mentioned, we are currently working through some scenarios that will play into our fundraising strategy. Right now, we have been pursuing relationships with a major sponsor. Those relationships are ongoing. We are having dialogue.

1:10:44 Right now the plan is to kind of stay the course with that. We have talked about contingencies. So the idea is that as we continue through this initial process with pursuing this partnership, once that kind of clarifies itself and we'll be able to come back to town council, then what we'll do is we will get an idea of what the bridge might look like and we can backfill onto that.

1:11:11 I would say right now things are looking good in terms of productivity and just will continue moving forward. Thank you. Any questions for Matt? Yeah. To be clear, how short are we on this project? Right now we're estimating with the current cost of about $12 million, we have about eight.

1:11:39 available to us. If we do do the debt financing, that will probably climb up to about 8.5. So we're looking between a delta of between three and a half and four million dollars. So if we are successful with a partnership, we think we can close that delta down to about 1.5 to 2, which MLR thinks is posable. Okay. I'm going to follow up on a couple of these questions. Let me ask questions about the debt here in a few minutes.

1:12:08 You know, I know it's tough to say, but what's the optimism level on this sponsorship? I would say it's pretty good. I mean, the partners that we're talking to have been responsive. I know that Stuart sent out a communication to them, and the response back was within the hour from an appropriate person. And so, you know, I think we just, we've been very thoughtful.

1:12:33 in our communications, and we feel that what we're offering and what they're seeking is there's good alignment there, and I think it works on many levels. The great thing is that we have, it's not just MLR and Rec working on this, we have Mammoth Lakes Tourism is involved, the mountain is involved, and so I think that coming at this with all of our community stakeholders and partners,

1:13:00 for me is encouraging because I think we just have that much more to leverage. So what we're talking about for this partner works on many levels. It's not just, you know, a feel-good thing. I think it makes actually good business sense for them. And so I think it's encouraging. Yeah, good to know the Mountain was involved. I don't know if any other businesses are involved, but agreed. Is there a plan B if the sponsorship falls through?

1:13:30 Well, there are other sponsors of that level that we can talk to. We haven't spoken with them yet because we want to exhaust this opportunity, but there is some potential there that's going to add on some runway or some time. But outside of that, those are kind of the primary ones that we're looking at.

1:13:53 I want to come back to this delta here in just a minute, but going to the overall project design cost. So we're tacking on $800,000 as a contingency? Is that what I'm seeing? You've got a design contingency and you've got an industry cost escalation. That's kind of an estimate right now. It's that 1.5 that Hayes was referencing. Okay, so those combined is taking us up to $12 million. Correct.

1:14:19 Unfortunately, we've had an issue, and that's why I need to ask this question, where, you know, we had an estimate before and we fell short. I don't know how to ask this other than, you know, how confident are we this time that that $12 million number is going to be the ultimate number? That's probably a Hayes question. That may be. I'm looking around the room. Hayes, it's too bad Grady's not here. But, you know, how do we give the public

1:14:49 Some confidence that we're not going to go over that number. That's a great question. You know, we can forecast based on historic numbers and what we've seen in town. We can forecast based on what the cost estimator has seen regionally on the west coast. And that's what we've been using to baseline our numbers. The real wild card is the cost escalation due to the, you know, what's in

1:15:16 Called a boom down in Southern California around the coast. And, you know, like I said, we feel pretty confident in that construction number, but I can't forecast the unknown. It's so difficult to get bidders up here that if we don't have a significant amount of competition, it's not going to drive our number down. And that's really the variable that we're concerned about, and that's why we're asking or recommending some contingency to compensate for that. Yeah, okay.

1:15:45 Because I, you know, want this, I really am, and I just want to say this, you know, I'm for this project. It really is town council that needs to make the decision of, do we spend money on this or do we spend money on this? And, you know, everything we can do to just give them the most important information, you know, all this as well. I'm just trying to avoid the see I told you so's out there in the community that I just don't want to hear that. You know, I really want this to go forward as much as possible.

1:16:11 And who knows? We may be experiencing a boom here in the next couple of years, which will further complicate things. That actually may be an advantage. If we had more contractors in town with that level of capacity, it may actually help us out. Like I said, there's so many ways this could play out, so many variables that it's really difficult to forecast past what we know to be those baseline numbers. I have a couple more things.

1:16:40 I just want to make sure we hold off on deliberation until after public health. Okay. Any more questions for Hayes? Not of Hayes. Matt, I did want to ask you just as far as what is the plan? I believe MLR is working on really what a detailed plan is going to look like to raise the, well, I guess if the sponsorship comes through, we're looking at a million and a half short? Yeah, we're looking between 1.5 and 2 would be our estimate.

1:17:09 Okay. I'm anticipating that that's going to be the next series of questions I'm going to get from the public is, okay, great, you know, we got the sponsorship or we're not even sure if we got the sponsorship. What are you guys doing? And it's always kind of aimed, it's always kind of directed like that. And I know that's referring to everyone in this room kind of.

1:17:27 But what are we doing to raise that 1.5? How can we give the public some confidence that, hey, we're going to hit those numbers? And to be clear, this does include the sport court, for instance. It does not. So there's going to be, and what I want to be very clear here on is that, you know, look, it's going to cost us $12 million to build the structure. It's going to cost us another.

1:17:50 X amount that's going to have the programming needs that needs to go in there to make it fully functional. And I just, I want to make sure that the public doesn't feel like anything is being hidden. What is our detailed plan for raising that shortfall? So, you know, if we can get that delta after sponsorship down to two or under, MLR feels

1:18:17 Reasonably confident that, you know, we have, there's enough of a pool, especially in Southern California, where we can go out and start working our major gifting networks, working through our donor advised funds to raise that sort of capital. I think it gets substantially harder once you get past that $2 million threshold, just because the amount of people that either have a vested interest in

1:18:42 The region or that particular sporting interest becomes smaller. But I think that if we can keep it under two, then we'll just kind of work through our, you know, the traditional major gifting funding networks and then, you know, close it from there.

1:19:02 There's also, if we are able to secure this partnership, that's also going to open up the door opportunity for subsequent partnerships within the sporting world. So we are talking with some advisors who can maybe kind of open up some of that money as well. You know, it's just, it's right now, it's a little bit hard to say specifically until we kind of get a little bit further down with those conversations.

1:19:32 Okay. And I do have several questions. I hope that's not going to answer the deliberation. And this is a big project, so I want to make sure I'm trying to answer them all. And if there's any others that maybe the press or public needs to ask, please do, because I want to make sure we're getting this vetted as much as possible. Timing. Currently, you know, we're trying to be open here in one year and one month with a roof and a rink. Yep. What's your confidence level on getting back to raising that $2 million? Can you do that in a year?

1:20:03 That's where we have some challenges. So raising the money is, I think the amount is not where I get nervous. The kind of runway that we need to get there is probably where I'm less confident. I think we have to go down there and build some of those networks, in some cases from scratch. So having been through similar processes, I would say

1:20:32 A typical runway for a capital project of this size and the amount that we're looking at usually is about 12 to 18 months. That would normally be what most projects we consider the silent phase. You're going out there and trying to build those networks and raise some of that large capital. So I think that...

1:20:54 That's something that I'm working very closely with the town manager, working with Parks and Rec, working certainly having dialogues with our board to try to see, you know, what a time frame might look like for that. Okay. Yeah, because I know that's a biggie, and then, you know, I'm even going to ask some questions just about the overall project timeline. Now, we know we've got a drop-dead date of June of 19, correct? That the school district has said...

1:21:20 Thank you very much. We want to do something with this property and good for them. I'm looking forward to seeing what they are looking at what they're going to be putting on that project. We're trying to be open in November of 18 and I would love to hit that timeline. It's nice to know we've got a little bit of a cushion there but I just want to reemphasize it sounds like we got a hard stop of June of 19 just as far as getting this up and running and I don't want to see our summer programming affected by this. So I just

1:21:49 I guess I just wanted to make sure I understood that correctly. With regard to the debt, and this is something that I want to ask, is that Town Council needs to make a decision here pretty quick, just to be clear. It's on the intended for tomorrow. Yep. And that, should we talk about that right now, or can I ask questions about that? I can have questions. Okay. Just to clarify that what we're looking at is a bond measure that would be with Measure R? Correct. Okay. Yep. Correct.

1:22:19 Yeah, Measure R is the security for that bond measure. It's proposed to be a 5.5, which is kind of what Matt commented on. It's $615,000 annual debt payment for a 10-year term. Okay. Okay, I think I'm going to stop right there and save anything else for deliberations after I just have a chance to talk. Stu, do you have anything else to add from the staff report? No, I think we'll get to...

1:22:47 Probably when you get to public comments, you know, the recommendations is here that we can kind of cover on and what kind of we're looking at the commission to provide some feedback, comments, direction on, which is kind of A through E of the staff report on page 51. Thank you. Laura, any questions? Thanks, Matt. Thanks, Hayes. Hayes, I have a quick question. To take this project to bid,

1:23:15 So Matt was talking about, you know, 13 months is pretty tight in terms of a fundraising portion. So can you just remind me of the bidding process and that you need to have all the cash in hand or if you go into more of a phasing you could bid different parts of the project at different times? Can you just explain that to me, please? Yeah, there's a number of ways we could deliver this project. Just like we...

1:23:41 carved out the site work separate from the project to try to get that component done separately. We could phase the project a number of different ways, and we've spoke with our architects on some options on how we could do that. So we have a couple.

1:23:56 Alternatives that we could present if it was the council's decision to kind of get the project moving and then see what happened and give us some flexibility to adapt to whatever the budget may be. It would be staff's preference to have all the money up front so that we could probably, you know, get the best bang for the buck on the contracting by putting the whole project out. But we have some alternatives that will allow us to be a little bit more nimble in that environment. Thank you.

1:24:27 Any comments from the public on this item? Yeah, come on up, Stacey. I need you to just come up to the, oh, can you come up to the microphone, please? Thanks. Thank you. Stacey Palves, Mammoth Times. I just wanted to know who this sponsor is. Are you allowed to tell me, us, that you were talking about your? It's a major league sports franchise. That's all you can say? Or you'd have to kill me? I'm still negotiating, so. Okay, thanks. Thanks, Stacey. Any other comments from the public?

1:25:05 Come on up, Abigail. My name is Abigail Giles, and I'm with the sheet, and I'm wondering if the project does proceed in a series of phases, understanding that no decisions have been made yet, how would that affect, well, how do I want to freeze this? Would, how would that affect, like, the sort of public process for selecting

1:25:42 Individual contractors to be part of that. I'm thinking about large projects are bidded differently than, say, you know, smaller ones that fall under a certain amount. Like, would the project from a bidding standpoint be treated as a $12 million project or would there be, you know, many, many installations awarded? I'm sorry, I'm being unclear. I'm thinking about the proper way to phrase this.

1:26:16 So what are you asking about, for example, because there would be a different contractor for site work, roof, different components? Is that your question? Yeah, exactly. I think I understand your question. Okay. I'm sorry. It's rather, it's kind of a complicated. Thank you. Thanks, Hayes. Thank you, Hayes. We have not identified the final delivery method. And if I start getting too detailed, just yell at me. So we're looking.

1:26:46 Most likely at a design bid build, a classical delivery method. This is the same delivery method we would use for a simple sidewalk project or a road rehabilitation project where we will have our architects put together the entire package for the entire project and we will bid that one project.

1:27:06 Alternative delivery methods where you can go out for bid for a, and I'll just kind of paraphrase this and not get too technical, a general construction management firm. That construction management firm would hire all the subcontractors and they would be responsible for running the job. You can do lease back options where you would basically lease the land to a contractor and they would be responsible for delivering it for a set price.

1:27:32 And we don't take delivery of the project to the very end. All of these have variable costs that have to be weighed. And Grady and I have kind of looked at these different alternatives. Obviously, we don't have a lot of those types of contractors here in town locally. So it would be something that we would bring in that may have cost savings or could cost more. So we're evaluating all of those options to figure out what would be the best methodology to bring this project to the public.

1:28:01 Right now we're kind of leaning towards a classic delivery method because it's one that we know does work in town. That doesn't mean that we couldn't carve out various components and I'll make some stuff up. We phase it out, we do the whole roof and then we don't do the community center, it's just a shell. And then six months later...

1:28:20 Stu gets another sponsor. It's decided to do that. We would bid that separately. So there are a number of ways this could play out depending on the budget and how the council wants us to proceed. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for answering my very unclear question. Thank you. Any more questions or comments from the public? Thank you. And thanks to you guys for coming up to the microphone just since we're recording on Granicus.

1:28:50 Okay, so before I bring it back to the Commission for Deliberation, Stu, do you just want to kind of remind us what you're looking for? Right, so page 51 on your staff report there is kind of recommendations, and this is kind of what we're proposing and seeking direction from Council on, and it's A through E. So we're looking at, you know, commencing the site work, obviously supporting and continuing with our fundraising efforts.

1:29:18 Completing the plans and specifications, which is what Hayes is talking about for a phase project, which would include deductive and additive alternates, right? So how can we kind of build this out on a schedule? Advertise the phase project, and then that kind of fits in with the timeline that Sean's referencing, right? So we're still looking at building a kind of rink and a roof by November 18.

1:29:42 And then E is Phase 2 of the project would follow based on funding availability, which is kind of where we've talked about as well. So that's kind of the recommendation. I believe we've covered a little bit of the debt financing. There's a couple of questions. I think you can phrase two of those questions is, one, is it better to wait a year or two until the money is secured before you begin kind of working on the project?

1:30:09 Or do we kind of commit with what we have and build what we can and then with the fundraising and the rest of the efforts continue to build out that project and complete it at a future time? So that's kind of the two questions that you can kind of frame, but that's the questions that we're asking and the direction we're seeking from Council tomorrow.

1:30:33 Which two questions specifically? Whether or not to proceed? A through E is really kind of the recommended phased approach. And then option B is to say, well, we're not interested in phasing. We're going to sit and wait until we get all the money at hand and then build one complete project at one time. Okay. Did you want to speak at all about the playground? Because I know there were some concerns there. Yeah, we have that in a separate item, but a few. Okay.

1:31:02 Yeah, just really quickly, it's coming up next, and the playground discussion is we are trying to just finalize the design. We will reach out to the community, engage our community, and then present a kind of a design alternative to Great Western as part of game time. Then we'll actually get a fixed cost of kind of what we believe the estimate is for the playground. But the goal is to get that underway and to get that new inclusive playground built at the park, regardless of this schedule.

1:31:32 Right? If the project moves along, Hayes assures me that we can kind of build. We might have to close the playground for a period of time while they do heavy construction and whatever, but the plan at this point is to kind of move forward and commit that playground to the community and get that playground up and open next year. Yeah, sorry, I didn't mean to get ahead of myself, but actually, I think that's good news, just the way it all works in, and so that's where I kind of think it kind of plays here. Great. Okay. So just kind of before we get into those couple of questions, I just...

1:32:03 I want to ask Hayes, so what is your sense, and obviously you don't have a crystal ball, but if we were to wait until we had secured all of the funds for the cost estimates for this project at this time, what do you think the chances are that those costs remain the same versus declining or escalating? And I won't hold you to it.

1:32:29 If I had that crystal ball, I'd probably be in Vegas gambling right now. I honestly...

1:32:36 Don't know exactly what the future holds, but based on the guidance we're seeing from our architects down south and similarly with our cost estimator is that they want us to be prepared for cost escalation. And if we wait, they're telling us the project will probably become more expensive as time goes on just because of the variability in the construction climate, if you will.

1:33:04 But I don't know if that's truly the case. These things are cyclical, and it could be a boom and bust, and it could be cheaper, or the price of steel could go down, or the price of steel could go up. I just don't know. So we're just working off the guidance. We're being provided by the experts and leaning on them to give us the best information based on the data coming out of the various companies that maintain it. Thanks for answering that for me.

1:33:33 Okay, so who wants to start? I'm just kind of, I don't know if shocked is the right word, but we're talking about $12 million and we're still talking about phasing. And I don't know if that's semantics, you know, rather than just it being taking a long time or we're going to do this and then when we get the money we'll do this. Because it sounds like the latter, that we've got money for the roof and the rink or we think...

1:34:04 You know, with all of this, roof in the ring, but the rest of it still doesn't fit in there, and I thought we had gone back and forth and back and forth, and this number was including at least the building of the community center and stuff, so I, okay. The 12 million is for everything, all in. Eight five is just the roof in the ring, correct? Eight five is what we have to work with if council approves the bond, is that correct? Correct. Okay.

1:34:31 Does that clarify at all? I think so. I don't know, again, if it's semantics or what, but I think if we say phasing, there's going to be a huge outcry that I think the public is going to be not happy with that. That's not going to be what they've been asking for and saying. So just even that language is concerning to me when I read this last night. I definitely want to see this project happen. I want to see it happen right. I just worry about these escalating costs.

1:35:07 Some of the things that I've been reading in letters to the editor and things about, are you just going to start it so we have to do it and things like that. It's, you know, have some valid points. So do you have a sense of, do you have an opinion on whether we should proceed with the project with the funds that we have now and do what we can and phase the rest or wait until we have all the funds in hand? You know, I...

1:35:36 Again, when I read through this last night that the fundraising timeline being so much longer than the construction timeline was concerning to me, you know, having background in fundraising, I know that that's pretty good estimate that 12 to 18 months and that's a lot of that is just the building relationships, no dollars in hand. So I think that's a very realistic timeline that may or may not mesh with this.

1:36:04 So I have some concerns, but I'm not real sure how I feel yet. And the reason, I guess, that we're asking these questions at commission today is so that we can give some input to council tomorrow with their decision. And Stu and I will also get an MLR later today, too, to let them know kind of where the commission is coming from on this. So I think those are very valid points. You're like ready to dive into it. Should speak.

1:36:36 Well, the first thing I want to say is that I am still very supportive of this project. And, you know, I'm even going to say that going into it, I was initially a little cautious going into it. I wasn't sure if the location was right, the project. But I got to say there is great discussion out there, and I am frankly thankful to the press for asking a lot of the questions that are going on because I get in healthy debates with people regularly.

1:37:05 And I even come out of those debates still even more supportive of this project than I was even going into the debate. I thoroughly hear the concerns about, you know, the money that we're spending on this. The C, I told you so's, unfortunately, were...

1:37:22 Well-founded in the sense that the timeline got pushed back. The cost is now up. And unfortunately, now we're even being told that, you know, if we don't start soon, that it could go up even more just because of these cost estimates, the construction contingencies that are going on. As a business person, if this were a business person, I must say that I would probably want to wait until I had more confidence in the securing of funding.

1:37:49 If this were a business decision and a business owner were having to make that decision, I am going to say that. But at the same time, and I know that really it's town council who needs to make the decision. They're the ones that are weighing this project with all the non-recreational needs of this community. So it's not, you know, as far as the recreation...

1:38:13 component goes. You know, I consider this being the flagship of what we are trying to create that really is going to set us on the West Coast specifically and uniquely that we are trying to build a world-class recreation facility. And with all the investment that I hope is about to happen in this town, the momentum that is happening on with the purchase of the ski area by Aspen KSL,

1:38:40 I feel that now is the right time and that looking at a recreation project, I'm even more convinced that this project needs to go forward. I made my comment with regard to the funding that, you know, as a business person, it might be more prudent to wait on that, but at the same time, I really want this project to go forward. So how is that for as ambiguous as possible support? Thank you.

1:39:11 So Hayes, quick question just on the estimates. So the estimates, and Stu can chime in on this as well, but I just want to make sure that we're being clear that the $12 million estimate includes the site work, the building, the appurtenances to operate the ice rink, but it doesn't include things that would be considered FF&E, like sport court flooring, chairs and tables in the community center, all that stuff.

1:39:37 Correct. That's an all-in cost design, all those other items, construction based, and I forget the exact date when they kind of drew that line in the sand. It's a timeline moving forward. All the work previous to that time had been under a different budget, but does not include a lot of these, you know, sport court and, you know, basketball nets and things of that nature. That would be second to this contract. Thank you. But it does include the complete Olympic-sized ice rink. Yes, it does. Right? So all the mechanical, all the glass.

1:40:06 Boards, everything. So it'll stand up with the budget we have and operate with what we need based on the timeline and what we have so far. I don't know if she was going to ask this question or not, but what was that number again for the supporting equipment? It's about $100,000 to $120,000 for the support court and the equipment required to support that activity in the summer.

1:40:30 And that's for the rec zone. It's for the summer rec zone. The rec zone, and that's essentially not just the sport court, but there was, yeah, volleyball. Nets, posts, exactly. So 120 grand. Yep. That's easy. I don't mean to discount that so quickly. That's great. Sean's got that. Mammoth Brewing County. Are we on Granicus? But I do want to be clear, you know, it's that, you know, I do kind of consider that easy when you're looking at a $12 million project, right?

1:40:59 But at the same time, I guess what I was trying to say earlier in my comments is that it's these big numbers that just have me a little bit concerned. Yeah. Stacey, I don't know if that was your question. No, my question was, Betsy asked about the tables and the chairs and the sports core flooring. Does the $12 million include a new Zamboni, or are you going to be using the one that you guys have? We still have the same Olympia at this time. Okay. Yep. Okay. Thanks. Thank you, though.

1:41:30 Warren assures me it's going to survive. The chiller is still under debate. And for $2,000, someone could wrap that with their company logo. Yeah, it looked great with Mammoth Times logo on it. Another question. Go ahead, Abigail. So I just wanted to be clear, look, you know, as sort of in line of, you know, what we had talked about earlier with regard to phasing, if it did come out as a phased project,

1:42:02 At this point, HMC has not been selected to be the one-and-done overall architectural firm doing the whole project. They're still just doing the cost system and conceptual design? No, they're on board for the whole project. The whole project, okay. Sorry, I was a little unclear about that. Thank you. Okay. All right, so I guess I just have a couple of comments here. One, I want to echo what Sean said in terms of I do support this project.

1:42:34 I want to make it clear to the community that I don't support this project just because I would support it at any cost. And I think it's, you know, we should just go forward regardless of, you know, cost escalation, fundraising concerns, et cetera. I support this project because I see a real need for it in our community, not just for the hockey community. Hi, Colleen and Jay. You know, not just for, you know, an improved community center, but because this is really...

1:43:02 This project is intended to be the recreation hub for our community. And, you know, we heard earlier about the product that our staff delivers and I just, it amazes me to think of how much we can enhance that.

1:43:16 Product with this project. I just, I think about, you know, having a home for all of those things and how when I visit other communities and if I want to go and talk to the Parks and Rec people, I generally don't go in their municipal town office or city office. I usually go to their facility because that's where Parks and Rec people live.

1:43:34 So I think it would be a huge opportunity for our community to have that and to be able to deliver that. And I look at the struggles that we've had trying to operate not just our ice rink, which is extremely challenging. I think we spent probably...

1:43:48 As many resources removing snow last year as we did delivering programming, which is not acceptable. But I also look at just our challenges in the summer with trying to operate the rec zone. And it's, you know, we've tried and tried and our staff has done a great job with a challenging facility. But I just, I think there is so much more to offer there. In terms of making a recommendation to the council, it's going to be a really tough call.

1:44:11 And, you know, I don't envy their need to weigh this project against the other needs of the community. So I guess I just want to say that I see this project as a strong need of the community.

1:44:22 And my hope would be that just given the cost escalation, given that, you know, if I had to make a guess, I cannot recall a project that Parks and Rec has been involved in that had declining costs over time. I just, I don't remember any ever. I think just on a more micro level about trying to complete, you know, the park at Trails End Park and how, you know, in very little time, just costs increased. And that was...

1:44:48 Before we had a huge construction boom and that whole situation. So I guess that my personal recommendation would be...

1:44:56 That, you know, we go ahead and I would hope that the council would look at bonding the funds from Measure R. That was a long time discussion prior to the formation of MLR just in terms of how we could be the most impactful with those funds because we are very fortunate as a community to have those funds. And just given their opportunity with the interest rate, I think, I hope that they will give that serious merit and proceed with that. And then I guess I would like to see

1:45:25 These recommendations from staff move forward. I would like to see, you know, site work begin, fundraising efforts continue, completing the plans and specifications for a phased project. I think it's going to be hard for this commission to make a strong recommendation one way or another until we kind of see what the plans and specs with those deductive and additive alternatives look like. So I think that's why we're struggling a little bit today.

1:45:55 But I certainly do want to see this. I really do want to see us ice skating over there in November 2018.

1:46:04 You know, I think in terms of Matt and his efforts with the fundraising, I think, you know, the more runway that we can kind of give him on that, the better. I do think that, you know, we're having some good conversations right now about fundraising, but I think there are opportunities to raise funds kind of after we start disturbing the ground because I think some of the, you know, I think I hear two things from the community. I hear that, well, you guys are just going to start, you know, tearing up the park so that then you can't stop. But I also hear, well, I won't believe this until I see a shovel in the ground. So I hear that.

1:46:33 Very true. Balanced pretty equally. So I guess my recommendation would be I would really like for staff to bring back and tell me how this sounds to you guys, but I'd like staff to kind of bring back, you know, let her see if that's indeed the direction they get from council. I'd like for us to maybe see that, you know, as soon as possible. Our next meeting is October 31st, which is a pretty short window. And then I would really like to see us proceed with building what we can with what we have. And that's just my personal opinion.

1:47:02 You guys want to add anything to that? Yeah, I think you're right about the once things start happening, I think that will help with the fundraising efforts. I think that will help with the community buy-in. And I do think the bottom line that you guys have said is what my gut is telling me is that this is a great project. We want this to happen. We just want it to happen right and not to, you know, like I said, don't envy the council for weighing those things against the community.

1:47:32 I think it will be a great project. We can work out the numbers. Yeah, and if I can just kind of clarify some of my comments with regard to having the funding. Yeah, I'm thoroughly supportive of this, and I think that the town should go forward with the bonding measure of Measure R. My comment with regard to the waiting until you have all the money, I didn't mean to say that. I think we're...

1:47:56 If I did, I apologize. I guess what I'm saying is that I need to know that the bonding money is there, that we can get this done. I would like to see it built, not necessarily in phasing, you know, only having a wall for the community center. I'd like to see the entire thing built as one. But I just would, you know, at the same time, I must admit that if, as a business person having to make this decision, that I would want to have very strong confidence knowing that the money is going to be there to complete the entire project.

1:48:27 I hope that helped. No, that's good. So I think the message that we want to take to MLR and then on to council is that the commission still feels this is a great project. We do want it to happen, but we want it to happen right. Is that our consensus? Okay. And then does that give sufficient direction to staff? Yeah, so to clarify, you would consider, and I guess with your letter C, really interested to see a kind of building schedule slash phased approach, right?

1:48:56 You know, we wanted to commit to the money that we had, then there's an opportunity for you to kind of, you know, see what that's like and, you know, keep the project moving forward. I think it's what you're saying, right? So supportive, want to see it happen. We are pushed back with timelines with obviously some lease, you know, so if we keep, I guess my concern is if we wait and wait and wait, then, you know, what's really happening? So I'm hearing that you're very supportive, want to see it happen and are looking at,

1:49:25 Considering the phased approach, which is letter C, right? Yeah, I think that's accurate. I think it's just hard for us to say phase or don't phase without kind of having a better conceptual idea of how that looks. So does that make sense? But I think we're saying proceed. Because I personally don't want to slow the project down. I don't want to slow down the project either. You know, and the other thing that I will say briefly, though, is that

1:49:56 Because this is a somewhat politically controversial subject specific with regard to the timeline, you know, I sure do want to under-promise and over-deliver. And, you know, a November 18 timeline, God, I want to see that. But at the same time, I want us to be realistic and I do want us to under-promise and over-deliver. I'll just leave it. Another ambiguous comment there like that.

1:50:26 And I guess my comment is, you know, we've been working on this for a long time. This is a long time identified priority and I just want to deliver something really fantastic to the community. And I would encourage if it is just that, oh, we have to stop because it's the winter and so it's just an ice rink now that maybe we don't use the word phased. So I think that gets some hackles up. It's just a longer timeline. It's a building schedule. Yeah, exactly. This is the schedule that we're proposing and this is how it looks.

1:50:58 Yeah, no, we prefer that kind of language as well. Yeah, yeah. And that was originally how it was going to be built. Remember, I mean, the community center was always going to be following the rink. Exactly. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, everybody. Hais, thanks for being here. Yeah, thanks for coming. Awesome. Do you guys want to take a short recess or do you want to keep going? I need to use the restroom. I'm going to call us into a five-minute recess. Thanks, everybody. And again, great. Hais, great job on that sidewalk on Main Street. I'm really excited about that.

1:51:31 Call us back to order, and we will move on to item number five, the Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Course. Thank you, Chair. I'll just provide a brief update and just run through the recommendation that we have. So, as you know, we've been working with Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Club for quite some time. They originally came forward in February to request the funding from Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:52:06 to move forward to install a professionally designed nine-hole golf course, as you know, at Mammoth Creek Park East. We've spent the summer negotiating and talking and discussion with the U.S. Forest Service about Mammoth Creek Park East and in your packet is a letter stating that that is not available for use. So what we're proposing right now is to schedule, which is right at the bottom of the opening page there with next steps, is to kind of form an ad hoc committee

1:52:36 The purpose here is really to regroup, get all the folks in the room at once. Now that we know kind of what is not available, let's go back and identify one where we think we can kind of propose to site the disc golf course, and that's kind of in the site selection process. So that could be looking at town-owned parcels, which is essentially the preference due to the challenges with our...

1:53:03 National Forest System, LAN. The ad hoc committee would also look at kind of running through the required planning environmental process. The planning team has already looked at kind of what that process would curtail, what it would be part of, how long it would take, potential cost and so forth. So we would have kind of planning and also public work staff on this ad hoc committee that would kind of help us walk through.

1:53:30 The required planning environmental process if required. Programming, again, we have conceptual master plans for four of our parks, including the bell-shaped parcel in Whitmore, so we kind of know what the community has identified and what they look at using those parcels for, so we have that information. We'd obviously like to finalise the cost of not only the equipment which we have from Disc Golf Park, but also understanding kind of what the installation cost is, required site work,

1:54:00 Any parking mitigation, environmental costs and so forth. So I really kind of understand the entire scope of the project. I think that's really important. And again, working with our parks maintenance team on, and certainly the Disc Golf Club on the required level of service required to maintain that facility as well. And any other questions, including funding, as you know, Mammoth Lakes Recreation set aside $7,320.

1:54:30 for this effort. So we really need to determine if that's still realistic or it's not. So the purpose of this committee would be to meet, I would think, one to two, maybe three times. We would try and get this done in kind of October based on everybody's schedule and then get back to the commission at the end of the month in October 31st or the latest beginning of December with the recommendation to move forward or consider some other sites for further review. But we'd really like to kind of work

1:55:00 and meet with this group. I've kind of scratched down kind of a list of potential participants. We have public work staff, so Sierra would be available to sit on that, Dolan from the Planning Department. I'd be able to represent Parks and Rec. We'd also have some other staff support as well. I'd like to consider Mammoth Lakes Recreation as part of the discussion as it involves funding. We'd certainly invite Mike Wellwood and a representative from the Disc Golf Club.

1:55:29 And would certainly like to have commission representation on that committee as well. So that's kind of our recommendation. Looking for any comments and direction. Thank you. So just one quick question. In addition to the funds allocated by MLR, they've also raised a pretty significant amount of money, right? Who did? I wanted to acknowledge that. The Edges Golf Club. Okay. They've got $2,000. Yeah, their budget's probably about $7,300 from MLR. Budget's probably about $10,000.

1:55:59 Questions for staff? Questions? I think Christina and Clayton would be great on this. Clayton's already declined, actually. It's funny that you bring that up. Seems like it'd be up his alley. Anyway, any comments from the public on this? I'm getting ahead of myself there, sorry. Matt McLean, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So we met with Mike Wellwood last Friday. Had a great conversation with him.

1:56:32 I think there's a general willingness on his part to go out and look at alternative sites. We made a tentative plan to kind of do that. So I think any way that we could be involved. And I think there's, as I said, a willingness to do that. I think it could be very productive. So we look forward to that effort. Great. Thanks, Matt. And I think it would just be helpful to the process to have planning and public works involved just so that we don't get ahead of ourselves. So, okay.

1:56:56 That all sounds good to me. Laurel, Sean, do you guys have any interest in sitting on that ad hoc? Stacey has a question. Oh, sorry, Stacey. I have a question. So that piece of property that Inyo National Forest owns north of Mammoth Creek Road east of Old Mammoth Road behind the bowling alley, they're holding on to that piece. They didn't want the multi-use center.

1:57:28 The Multi-Use Facility be put there. They don't think it's appropriate for a disc golf park to be put there. Why are they holding on to that? For what purpose? I mean, it's a beautiful spot that the town can use for everybody, and I just don't understand why the International Forest is reluctant to let the town use that piece of property. Am I missing something? I don't believe there's anyone in this room who can speak for the Forest Service. Okay.

1:57:57 Thank you for the question, though. Yeah, I think the comment, you know, it's stated in the letter from the acting district range. It's in the packet, Stacey. It's kind of in the third paragraph. So it says, although the application was very complete, the town did not make a compelling case that national forest system lands are required for this project. So we have alternative sites that we own. So until we kind of fully exhaust those alternatives, they're not willing to consider the use of that land. So you're welcome.

1:58:28 What's the date of that? This letter was August 9th. Yep. Okay. Okay. And, Stacey, there is a contact person for follow-up questions if you wanted to reach out to them directly. Margie. Got it. We'll continue on. So. I definitely support their efforts. I just don't know if I have time in the next month. Okay.

1:58:55 That's totally fair. In and out of town a lot. And it would be unfair of me to commit time. I just, my time is unavailable right now. I would love to be on this as a... Sure. Okay, well, so as mentioned, Clayton has also indicated he's quite busy this month. I can make myself available and then we could check with Christy. Okay. Maybe Christy's the backup maybe or... That's, yeah, so... Well, either or. Well, do we need two or just one is sufficient? I was looking at an alternate if you wanted to.

1:59:25 Yeah, I think, yeah, Christie is the alternate spine, so I'm fairly flexible in October, but depending on when the meetings are figured out. But I do think it will be a good process, and I think it will also be a good process to go through this, you know, with MLR included. I think that will just be really fruitful. Do you mean anything else from us on that one? Nope. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. We'll move us on to item number six, the statewide healthy play training and funding initiative. Thank you.

2:00:02 So if the community's not aware, we were successful with our 2017 Healthy Play Funding application, and that's the initiative on the website just up there. So it was a statewide initiative to offer funding to parks and recreation communities to install national demonstration site playgrounds in their communities. So it was a very competitive process. They had 31 applications.

2:00:28 They awarded funding to 24 of them, and our application was, the indication that we received was in the top three. So really well received. Again, I want to recognize our chair for spending an inordinate amount of time on that grant, and certainly Lauren, Kat, and our team contributing their time to that application. So just a wonderful, wonderful recognition for our community. So we are very excited.

2:00:57 to get this in the ground for our community. So what we're proposing here is essentially, again, I know we're kind of into these little ad hoc committees, but one, I think this level of award deserves kind of a little community outreach. So what kind of staff are proposing is to kind of schedule a presentation or a little workshop with our community, invite the community in to really understand what this means. We've had a lot of people over the last three or four years

2:01:25 Work with us that have been so passionate from a multitude of organisations including the county, the Husky Club, Disabled Sports Seeds in Sierra. There's a multitude of...

2:01:37 Letters of Support that we received that was part of the application, which is kind of why we really believe it was well received, because we were really able to articulate the need in our community for an inclusive playground. So we're very excited. So we really want to kind of get out to the community to make sure they clearly understand what this means and the benefit it will provide for the community. So we want to kind of schedule that and with that group finalize the design of the facility that we're proposing. We have two alternates that are attached to this staff report.

2:02:06 You can kind of walk through staff and Betsy and as much as we can spent some time working on this for submittal. It is not certainly the final design, but they would like to get some indication from us as a community of what kind of components, you know, we'd like to see. We've provided some and they've kind of given us their best kind of recommendations in the design plan.

2:02:27 So we'd kind of like to walk through the inclusive components. It's going to be part of the playground. Surfacing, there's a surfacing mix. You know, right now we have engineered wood fiber. You know, is that still, it's still compliant for an ADA use, but is it really kind of accessible? Can you get everybody there? So we'd like to talk, sorry, talk about surfacing. Shade, the playground does come with some shade components. So again, let's, you know, review that.

2:02:49 How that would work, it would stay on, potentially come off for wintertime, those type of things. And then confirm the required site work and the grading and so forth. And then we need to get that final design back to Great Western for them to provide us with an overall cost of that project. At this time, Council, as I know, is supportive of the project. They have committed up to $100,000 in matching funds.

2:03:14 But, you know, basically adding the surfacing, the installation, and the removal, we need to get that kind of cost estimate confirmed, and we'd like to have that by November 1st for council and their discussion. So that's the proposal at this time. So what we're saying is we'd like to kind of push out a presentation to the community. We'd do it in Suite C, and then we'd form kind of a small working group to kind of finalize the design.

2:03:38 Get it back to Great Western, and then finalize the cost. And then again, we can kind of firm up the project schedule and the installation and the ribbon cutting, most importantly. So that's our recommendation. We do also walk through kind of the matching funds discussion here in the staff report. I can kind of provide additional information on that as well. We talked about playground installation. And the last section here was on the removal and the relocation of the existing playground. So we can kind of walk through that.

2:04:07 Commission has any follow-up questions on that. Thank you. Welcome. That's all I have.

2:04:14 One thing I just want to say before we continue is that, you know, yes, I spent some time drafting the grant and I attended the workshop with Stu, but I wanted to just say that, you know, this is really the culmination of many people's work over the past three plus years. And so I just, I really want to acknowledge people like Mike Ramirez who came forward during Plan Your Parks, all the people named in the grant application, which was in our prior packet, certainly, you know, the staff.

2:04:43 and Stu for identifying the grant. And it was just, it was very exciting. Tyler from Great Western has just been amazing. I look forward to bringing him back up here to work with this group. It's just really exciting and just, you know, a lot of people really deserve credit for this. So thank you. Welcome. So, question. So can this community kind of workshop and design, could this be agendized in such a way that the entire commission, can we just publicly notice that so that

2:05:13 Versus trying to find two people to be an ad hoc that we all have the opportunity to participate. Okay. I think that would be good. That kind of gives us some flexibility there. Okay. Do you guys have any thoughts? No, I'm very much in support of this and would love to be a part of it. Great. And I'll just echo Becky C. Thank you so much for the work that you put into it, and Lauren and Kat as well. Thank you. Any comments from the public on this? Okay. Very exciting.

2:05:48 And I think this will be really good. So do you need a recommendation from us on matching funds? Do you want us to have a discussion on that? I think right now it's probably a little premature only because we don't know exactly what the total project is going to cost. So we have, and just to be clear, the matching funds is just for the structure. So, you know, we picked a really good structure. So the matching funds are pretty much all of that.

2:06:17 So the $99,000 of matching funds goes towards a $200,000 play structure, which is significant. In addition, as I said, we'd be looking at the surfacing, the removal, the installation and the site work and so forth. So that's kind of what we need to firm up through this process. But really all we want this kind of community workshop to do is just affirm the design or provide us with recommendations on other components and surfacing for that design. Because I think the designs that we have also include a couple of additional components. We did, yeah.

2:06:47 And some of those recommendations go back to our workshops that we had during Plan Your Park. So I think it would be great to include those if possible. Yep, we have all that. And then just D as well, you know, the removal and relocation. You know, we can kind of work out how to kind of remove that playground based on the schedule. And then I think the discussion moving forward for the commission is where would we like to see that go?

2:07:13 You know, we did some work with the Plan Your Parks. So the conceptual master plan for Whitmore identified kind of a playground area as well. We have a playground at Trails End. Bell Shaped Parcel didn't recommend having a playground there. And Mammoth Creek Park already had the playground. So that was kind of our first kind of...

2:07:33 Research and analysis into the relocation of that equipment. There's a play structure over by the tennis courts now, right? Yeah, we put that in there several years ago. It's kind of the challenge with that one. It's a little hidden. I don't know if a lot of people really know the playgrounds there. So, I mean, we'd like to make that more visible. So that's certainly something we can talk about. Well, I think that was an excellent opportunity for our press to make that clear to the public, since we have both newspapers here, that, you know, not only is that facility there,

2:08:02 Over by the tennis courts. But also, I've got to say, you know, again, congratulations to everyone involved in this because this takes a little bit of the sting out of the park with regard to the multi-use facility that we've got this option here that's able to go in. So I think they really all fit very nicely together. I think it's really exciting. Thank you for helping us let the public know about that.

2:08:29 And so on the relocation, I think just for now, I think that probably will come back to the commission, but I certainly want to make it clear to the public that we're not just ditching our seven-year-old playground equipment at Mammoth Creek Park. We will utilize it. And it's my understanding, too, that Tyler and the group who are coming back to do some work on the bleachers also have the capability to help us with some of that work, which is great. That's correct. They're actually doing the tennis courts as well and the bleachers and could remove the playground.

2:08:59 Very timely. Big fans. Yep. Okay, so then it sounds like we just need to basically put together kind of that community workshop slash celebration and then from there work on finalizing the design and then costs and after that and I also just really appreciate Public Works and Hayes being willing to work with us to meet kind of as best we can the needs of the grant but also to just move this project forward that's such a big community.

2:09:29 Need. Okay. Yep. Thank you. Welcome. Perfect. Okay. Thanks, everybody. That brings us to commissioner reports. Sean, anything to report? Well, let's see. What month is this? Is that over still? Yeah. No. You know, I don't think I really have any specific commissioner report. I will say it's interesting watching what's happening with the wood site. Obviously, I have a vested interest in that location.

2:10:03 But I really do wish the very best with Dirk Winter in trying to his event that he's going to be having this winter and that that site continues to be used for special events hopefully for years to come. Thank you. I just wanted to say thank you to everybody who helped out with the Gran Fondo. It really was a really awesome kind of end of summer culminating event.

2:10:31 Something like 1,500 people out there on the road, and we had nine adaptive cyclists, two of which completed the whole piccolo, one completed the medio.

2:10:43 Excuse me. Two of our local athletes completed the PICO. We had actually seven complete the whole thing. So it was really great for our guys to be out there with the community and just seeing all the different organizations come together. It's a great opportunity for everything from the Little Leagues to the Search and Rescue and a lot of groups that are connected with Recreation and different ways to come out and be a part of. And it was a great event. And thank you to the town for helping to make that happen and you guys for any roles that you have.

2:11:12 We played in that. It went off really well. Stuart wrote it. Did you do the 100? 102? 70? Very thankful just to get off my bike at 70. He's spent a lot of time swimming this summer. Mine is just really short. So on September 27th, I attended the MLR Allocations Committee meeting. It mentions in, I think, our staff report that the request for curling is coming forward at their meeting this evening.

2:11:45 And...

2:11:47 I also sat on the community interview panel for the new police lieutenant position, so I appreciated the opportunity to do that. And I just want to, Friday was the Husky Pup Fun Run at the Mammoth Elementary School, and I just want to really commend all the organizers. That was a great event, and this was my last year as an elementary school parent, so. But it's just a great event, which it just happened, was started by our former Recreation Commissioner, Teri Stehlik, so amazing to see.

2:12:17 It was the 19th year. So just really, really great event. Just exciting to see something healthy, kids out, active, running, having fun, and really just taking a lot of pride in their school. So that was great. That's all I have. Request for agenda items is next. Stu, do you want to remind me what we were doing on October 31st? Yeah, so we moved the November meeting up to Halloween.

2:12:43 Very exciting. So we'll have a similar update on Plan MCP. Obviously, we'll follow up from, you know, the Council decision, and again, Council will be taking action on, I believe, the same item on November 1st as well. So we'll have an opportunity to weigh in and provide some comments. We'll provide an update on the Disc Golf Committee and any work that's been accomplished. Again, our goal is to have this playground design kind of completed.

2:13:11 And then we'll have an operating plan for the ice rink in front of the commission at that time as well. No meeting in November and then December 5th is kind of when we start to review the strategic plan for the year, how we went. We'll provide you with a kind of a report card from staff and how we did. We'll also at that time kind of present the 2018 summer programming menu. So your comments today and all the analysis we've completed.

2:13:37 We'll provide a plan and menu for next year, calendarised out from registration opening. And then we get into the maintenance, the CIP plan and that type of stuff. The deferred maintenance is kind of an ongoing update I'm just providing through the director's report. If you want something pulled out specifically, I can do a special presentation, but that's kind of how I'm presenting updates at this time. So we'll just continue to do that.

2:14:03 If that's okay. Maybe an update at the end of October just on what we got back from Terracon for the pool. Yeah, yeah. So we'll add the facility condition assessment. So it'll basically have a work plan with a budget that you'll be able to see that Warren and his team will be able to kind of get going on. It's a very detailed list, so we'll be able to kind of walk you through that. So it's very good. Okay. That's all I had. Okay. Sound good?

2:14:34 Both of you? Just updated my calendar. Excellent. Thank you. Okay. Well, if there is nothing further, then I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting on Tuesday, October 31st. Thank you very much. Thanks, everyone. Thank you, Stacey and Aberdale, for being here.

2:15:35 Thank you.