TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2018

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 1 hr 37 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

216 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:02 Ready, let's get started. Good morning. I will call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, June 26, 2018. Roll call, please, Jamie. Commissioner Martin. Good morning. Commissioner Osborne. Here. Chair Truex. Here. This time I'll open the floor for public comments.

1:33 Not seeing any public nor any comments. I will close public comments and move to the consent agenda. Item number one, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 1st, 2018. I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of our regular meeting May 1st, 2018. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Motion carries. That will bring us to our presentation.

2:02 Thank you, Joel, for coming today. We have a presentation regarding the use of e-bikes in Mammoth Lakes presented by Trails Coordinator, Joel Rathje. Thank you. Good morning, Joel Rathje, Mammoth Lakes Trails Coordinator. We're going to have some fun this morning talking about the subject of e-bikes. This presentation in one form or another has been to starting with Mammoth Trails Committee, a consortium of user groups at the library, 35 to 40 people.

2:33 discussing this topic combined with a Mammoth Trails Committee meeting at the same time. Also took this presentation to the Local Transportation Commission, the Planning and Economic Development Commission Mobility Committee in the context of Walk, Bike, Ride, also Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board, and now to the Recreation Commission.

3:02 So this is basically an effort to get facts out there so that folks have an understanding of regulatory framework, also where we are in process on a couple of different things as this technology is introduced to Mammoth Lakes area. So I'm going to be navigating a PDF document with a lot of content.

3:29 So bear with me as I attempt to coordinate with this different mouse pad. But first off, coming out of strong consensus through the different groups and committees and also town council direction, I've submitted a formal request to Inyo National Forest to modify the special use permits for our multi-use pathway system. The modification

3:57 is to allow for class one e-bikes onto our multi-use pathway system. I'm going to explain a couple of different regulatory frameworks as that relates to that here in a moment. Also, we were directed to implement some regulatory signs to protect some non-motorized trail system infrastructure, namely trails like the Mammoth Rock Trail, Panorama Dome, Mountain View.

4:26 The new trails we constructed last summer, they are all non-motorized, designated as such, and they are system trails. That's another important phrase, system trails. So regulatory signs have been installed. Also, an information handout has been created. That was a part of the direction to get a nice one-sheet so that bike shops and places like the Welcome Center could have good, accurate information on one page.

4:52 Also, we're exploring the idea of a bike ambassador or a trail ambassador program. That's in the works. We're trying to get it funded by funding streams other than Measure R. As an example, maybe MMSA or some of the bike shops might pitch in people for bikes. We're also in talks with them. So I'm going to start with a graphic that illustrates.

5:19 California State Law as it relates to e-bikes. This is pretty handy. It is a nice chart in that it shows and defines the different classes of e-bikes and the different capabilities and some of the different regulatory things like helmets or not helmets. So I'm going to start with class ones. They can go up to 20 miles an hour.

5:46 They are pedal assist. You don't need a driver's license or license plate. And kids under 17 need to wear a helmet. In the state of California, they're allowed on class one bike paths like the ones that we have in our town. And they're also allowed on bike lanes, bike routes, and then roads and streets and such. Also in the state of California, type two e-bikes are allowed.

6:13 They can go up to 20 miles an hour and are typically non-pedal assist bikes, so just the throttle. Those are also allowed on multi-use pathways in the state of California. Type 3 e-bikes are not allowed on multi-use pathways in the state. They can go up to 28 miles an hour and are typically pedal assist, just more powerful, bigger, heavier bikes. But those would have to be used on roads, streets, or OHV trails throughout the state.

6:43 So that regulatory framework in the state of California came about in 2015, and the federal government has a different regulatory framework. Go figure, right? We're different from the feds. Again, so this is the, in 2016, Joe Mead with the USDA sent this memo out to all foresters across the country.

7:13 I'm not going to read it, but it is the backup. I'm happy to provide this to anyone who's interested to read it. One thing that really catches my eye in this is a couple things, but one thing is I can just read one sentence. It is essential that exceptions to the travel management rule designations not be made. So he's telling his rangers and his line officers, you know, don't make your own exceptions.

7:42 to these travel rules. Don't classify e-bikes as anything other than motorized. So to the federal government, a motor is a motor is a motor, whether it is noisy or quiet, it doesn't matter to them, it's a motor, and that's where current policy is. So our trail system, our multi-use pathway system, today goes through multiple jurisdictions, predominantly

8:12 Town jurisdiction, some county, and then Forest Service. So this map shows everything in green. If you can see the black lines on this map where they go over top of the green shade, that's all Forest Service jurisdiction. It goes through some of the MMSA permit boundary and then also town jurisdiction, jurisdiction along the town loop and things like that along the school.

8:42 Wrong Meridian there. So the problem arises today because the town does not have a specific ordinance regarding e-bikes, it defaults to state law. Okay, so class one and two e-bikes are allowed on those sections and then we don't have signs up where you enter Forest Service jurisdictions so people just seamlessly go on to Forest Service jurisdiction and they find themselves breaking the law unknowingly.

9:11 Some people think that e-bikes aren't allowed everywhere. Some people think that they are allowed everywhere on these pathways. And really, it's a mix. And we'd like to reconcile the issue here. So we do have the formal request into the Forest Service to allow for Class I e-bikes. So you might ask yourself, why not mirror state law and allow Class I and IIs? Well, in working with the different groups that we presented some alternatives to,

9:40 The recommendation from the Mammoth Trails Committee was to be consistent with MMSA. So about a month and a half ago, the resort and the Indian National Forest decided to allow Class I e-bikes in the bike park. So that was almost a first in the country, apparently at Durango Mountain Resort, Purgatory, near Durango. They have a program that allows e-bikes.

10:07 The reason why they were allowed to do that here and not set a national precedent was because the trails on Mammoth Mountain were found to be not system trails. Those are resort improvements. They don't have Forest Service numbers or designations in their database, and they were never part of public infrastructure. So they control those improvements through their use permit. So that seemed to make sense. Similarly,

10:35 The town has use permits for the pathways, and the feedback I've gotten so far from Inyo National Forest is that they are also not a part of their system. They are not in their geodatabase. They don't have assigned numbers or system numbers in the same way as the MMSA infrastructure. So the town has built a lot of these multi-use pathways and their special use permit, and the Forest Service never formally took them into their federal system. Are you with me so far? Yes.

11:03 I know it's a lot to take in, but I'm going to run through a series of maps that illustrates kind of what we're looking at. When I'm toggling on and off here, the multi-use pathways, these are all the dirt roads that we have in our system that currently allow all types of e-bikes, ones, twos, threes, motorbikes, side-by-sides, anything motorized. So that's interesting to people like me and people that want to take advantage of existing infrastructure.

11:32 There's the MMSA infrastructure you can see toggling on and off. This green loop that's toggling is called the NOLS loop. Looking at that as a good opportunity to point people to where they can go today legally and have a really good time on some dirt. So we have opportunities.

11:53 Here's our non-motorized infrastructure where we have all the regulatory signs up. They are temporary regulatory signs. Next season we'll be mobilizing a more comprehensive regulatory sign program. Most of you are familiar with the carcinite posts that have the stickers that Forest Service uses for things that are allowed and not allowed. You should expect to see those take shape over the next season or so. So right now it's critical that we let people know

12:22 That trails like the Mammoth Rock Trail are off limits to all e-bikes. I don't expect that to change at the federal level, and they are Forest Service System trails. We had some questions about sidewalks on Main Street in the past related to e-bikes. These things have come up. There was some disagreement on uptown-downtown, the public access part of that that connects to the village. We think that that's been reconciled. The Forest Service is going to be providing us with backup that shows.

12:51 that those two are non-system trails that MMSA chooses to allow the public to use. So they are controlled under the use permit, but they allow that lower loop to be used by the public with no fee. So we had some issues come up that I think we worked through. This was the formal recommendation coming from the Mammoth Trails Committee toward Town Council.

13:18 They had the choice of no action on the multi-use pathways, to say no to all e-bikes on pathways, and then the third choice was to allow the class ones, and the fourth would have been to mirror state law. So as I toggle this graphic, you can see the only cell that's changing is the yes to a no. That is how we will be different from the state. Everything else would be the same.

13:49 But we would have to draft a specific town ordinance to say no to the class twos and above. So every jurisdiction in the state has the choice to modify what the state has provided and choose something that works for their community. This is the handout that was circulated last week. It's been vetted through the Forest Service stakeholders like Footloose and Kittredge and Wave Rave.

14:18 We've been meeting with stakeholders along the way. Some folks aren't very happy. And until we reconcile this regulatory framework issue between the federal and the bus, it's going to be difficult for people to feel solid on where they can and can't go. As you know, for years, people have been using the pathways with e-bikes.

14:45 I'm hoping that the Forest Service can turn this request around pretty quickly. We shall see. This is the temporary regulatory sign that was recommended by Region 5 Forest Service staff to use. And then here's a photo sim before we installed them. And here's what they look like out on the trail. They're very noticeable. It would be difficult to say that you didn't see it. And then lastly,

15:12 I wanted to point out one thing I'd really like to do is this is just an example of where they're pointing out recommended rides for people. This is a really, really fun thing to do. I've ridden on an e-bike twice. I had a smile ear to ear the whole time. It was unbelievable. So, you know, I want to be able to recommend something like an experience to go from Shady Rest to Inyo Craters to June.

15:39 Have a beer and a nice awesome Hawaiian soul food while my battery charges and then come on back. That sounds like a lot of fun. We have existing motorized infrastructure out there that can be improved over time. There's a few things we can really do today while we watch and wait for the federal government to adjust to this, but we can provide good signage to our north on the motorized network and we can improve the dirt.

16:08 We can do work that will improve the trail riding experience. Right now, there's a few loops that if we were just to install signs and then provide maps to the bike shops, that that would be a huge improvement. So on this sheet, they recommend the Downeyville Classic. Those are my buddies, and their single track has been moto-friendly for decades, ever since they built it.

16:34 This is an interesting nexus for me where we head toward a more multi-use trails program and try to incorporate as many users in the recreational spectrum as we possibly can. And I think that e-bikes are compatible with dirt bikes and they want single track and we want single track and we think we can share those trails well. So we've engaged with the Sierra Responsible Riders, a local non-profit here, and we expect to be

17:04 Applying for grant funding, for planning, design and construction between Shady Rest, Inyo Craters and beyond. And then really interesting development that allows us to work in those areas is a very interesting agreement is taking shape between Mono County, the town of Mammoth Lakes, Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest, and Inyo National Forest, where

17:29 It's giving us the tools to be able to work beyond the municipal boundary. And so you should expect to see this program go out to the Mono County extent on the map. So I think that is all I have for now, but I'm at your service for any questions that you may have. Thanks, Joel. Questions? I have some questions. Go ahead. Okay. I have a couple questions, Joel. Thank you for that.

18:00 Comprehensive presentation. I feel like I know a lot more now than I did. A couple questions that I have are, what are some of the safety issues that the committees have explored in terms of having e-bikes on them up or off them up? And in particular, because I live there, I think about

18:28 People on the road on Lake Mary, how tight that is. And I'm just wondering, is it actually just safer to have everybody be on a multi-use path rather than trying to disperse them out into the road with traffic? This sort of question comes up consistently. And it's all about speed, I think is what it boils down to. It's the physics of it.

18:56 So while the e-bikes have almost an identical, you know, architecture to a modern-day mountain bike, and some of the downhill mountain bikes are even, you know, bigger and things and heavier, you know, and here's another thing, we should expect the batteries to become incorporated into the frame as time goes over. You know, I know there's one right now, a prototype that's probably going to go on the market soon where you don't see the battery.

19:25 So I think it's about speed. The pathways, you know, they are signed. There is a speed limit of 15. Before e-bikes, there was a problem. I don't see that problem necessarily going away. It's one of those Darwinian sort of concepts. But yeah, it's a tough one. I don't see a real difference between how

19:55 We should be treating an e-bike versus a normal bike and the safety issue. I think it's an across-the-board issue to tackle. So signs are okay. You need to have them in place. Awareness is another key to that, the educational component. And so I think we can certainly emphasize more of a safety element on the one sheet that I have up for the bike shops.

20:22 We could place more of an emphasis on safety in those sheets. I don't know if I'm answering your question. It is. It's not a recommendation. It's just a question. Yeah, more like awareness to have it.

20:34 And then my other question, it has to do with disability and mobility. I hope I'm not stealing your thunder. But is that also something that's on the table with these committees and the U.S. Forest Service? Because it seems like e-bikes can provide access to people with disabilities, people with health issues, older people, to our public lands that they wouldn't otherwise necessarily get if they were forced to...

21:04 You know, pedal themselves or walk themselves, especially when we're at altitude. So is that also being addressed by committee? It is. You know, the committee has asked a question, or folks have asked a question, and it is specifically addressed in this federal memo. And it says, disability and motorized devices, questions have been raised in relation to people with disabilities requesting use of e-bikes as assisted device. The only exception for a person with a disability,

21:34 For use of a device that is self-propelled is if that device meets both parts of the legal definition of a wheelchair or mobility device as defined above in some code. I'm going to get to the chase here. Under that definition, any device that is both designed solely for mobility for a person with a disability and which is suitable for use in an indoor pedestrian area may be used anywhere foot travel is allowed.

22:01 E-bikes are not solely designed for individuals who have mobility impairments, and their suitability for indoor use would be highly questionable. Therefore, e-bikes do not qualify for an exception. Okay, thank you. And then last question in terms of Class 1, Class 2, and trails that are open to e-bikes and trails that are not open to e-bikes. Has there been any discussion about how that would be enforced? Comes up a lot.

22:30 A lot. And that's also, so I noted that we were directed to look into an ambassador program that starts to sound like enforcement if you call it a trail patrol. That's from the trail system master plan as a recommendation for a trail patrol. I've been through this before in the past and watched a volunteer trail patrol fail because they had no regulatory teeth. And a lot of folks were finger wagging and yelling.

22:59 And they had no badge and it became more of a social problem, a cultural issue. And so I'm really sensitive to it. The federal government, if they, you know, start to see things go that route where it's finger wagging, they pull the plug immediately. So it really does have to be more of a general, you know, trail ambassador type program, information only.

23:26 So we're treading lightly exploring this. We have to get the right people. So that would be more like, hey, I see you're on this trail. Let me point you in a direction where you might have a little bit more fun. Did you know that? Did you know? Yeah, okay. Thank you. And, you know, hey, no problem today, whatever. Just know that you're not on the right trail and that you could get a ticket. I'm not the one giving the tickets, but you could.

23:53 You know, there's no anticipation in the district that they're going to hire some people with badges, but that would be the regulatory place would be Forest Service. So that would be real law enforcement, not an ambassadorship. Correct. I gotcha. Right. So issue a ticket, you know, the person has to have that credential and the badge. Okay.

24:16 So this is tricky. We can provide the information and hope for the best, but it's analogous to a mountain biker that enters into the John Muir Wilderness today. Who's going to give them a ticket? Who's going to get them out of there? Do they know they're breaking the rules? It's similar. We're just dealing with another toy that can help people break rules. Thank you, Joel. Sure. Thanks, Joel. Laura? Joel, this is...

24:44 I was there at the Trails Committee Day, so this is a very good, succinct version of the presentation and even more clear. I see how you've been refining it as you've been presenting it to the different groups because there's a lot of information here and a lot of confusing stuff for folks. So thank you for continuing to drill down on that and making it palatable for folks so they can understand because they don't understand. Nobody's going to...

25:11 Want to do it right or know that they're doing it wrong. So thank you for your work on this because it is here and we need to address it. So really appreciate that. A couple of questions I had back to the ADA stuff. I know that there is a common misconception that it is, oh, it's ADA, it's okay. And I know not for the regular.

25:35 Two-wheeled bikes, but some of the recumbent bikes that are specifically designed for folks with disabilities, there is a misconception that it's A-OK. And so I think if you had something that you could help us at Disabled Sports distribute to folks to make sure that we are doing it right and not just, oh.

25:56 Yeah, and to be fair, you know, this memo, it does address...

26:25 The larger issue of evolving technology. And the federal government is open to change, but they're indicating through this memo that they want that change, that decision to be made at the very top. They don't want individual districts setting precedent.

26:42 Right, and just like what we're doing with the multi-use paths and stuff, we want to make sure we do it right so that we don't ruin it for everybody. You know, it might come, but it's not there yet. So thank you for that. How does the, you were referring a few times to Shady, to Inyo, to June, and I know that there has been a lot of old roads that were closed off in the travel management plan that.

27:10 Had a lot of discussion and uproar a few years ago. And I've even been out on those trails off the scenic loop and have guys come through on dirt bikes around this time of year and say, oh, this trail was open last year. No, it wasn't. They closed it a few years ago. So are we going to be going against all that work that the Forest Service and Friends of the Inyo did on closing all those trails? And I mean, does this...

27:35 Wanting to expand these opportunities, does that get in the way of that travel management plan and how does that impact the town? It's a great question and a great segue into an area or a region that I'm really keen on optimizing and improving over time for outdoor recreation. There's still, with the closures, there's over 2,000 miles of dirt roads.

28:00 I don't see the closures as problematic. They were probably wise decisions. But even Inyo National Forest staff will tell you that it's very much a work in progress. They're fully aware that, you know, people get lost all the time out there. Some of the roads just don't function well as good, you know, experiences for people, for recreational experiences. You know, the development that I'm alluding to is a refinement of the travel management effort.

28:29 It's a refinement of it to look at it not as a system that has to be smaller and smaller because it's bad, but it needs to be improved because we want people to have fun in the right places. Right, not go making their own roads or taking it back. I've been through this before with a lot of different trail user groups, and the solution is always make more well-designed.

28:57 Facilities that are way more fun than the places where you don't want them to go. So that's the work ahead of us is to make things really fun, more sustainable so we don't have to spend money on maintenance. We know how to do these sort of things and we're going to have more closures coming down the pike but before we close something I would propose that we build something fun first and that's the direction we're headed in that area is think of the word optimize.

29:26 Instead of closing. Excellent. And I've been out there and seen those signs and my husband went, whoa, what is that? Does that mean I can't ride here? Oh no, it's got an E in it. So the signs are definitely noticeable and eye-catching even though they're only the temporary ones. And we understand the flaw, right? So an example, you go to the Mammoth Pass Trail up there at Horsery Lake and you see the no e-bike motorbike thing and you're sitting there with your mountain bike and you're thinking, oh, does that mean I can go through?

29:56 Yeah. So there is a need for a more comprehensive regulatory sign system that addresses all the different user groups. So we're actually doing that analysis this season out in the field. Okay, what do they need to say? Where do they need to go? That's happening this season, and we hope to be plugging them in the ground next spring. Excellent. I have one more question based on what you just said. So I guess I'm sitting here, and I was under the assumption that

30:26 For multi-use paths that would welcome cyclists, we are considering welcoming e-bikes as well. Class 1s. Class 1 e-bikes. But you said that there's e-bike access up to Mammoth Pass that mountain bikes can't go on? No, I was trying to illustrate the confusion that can occur with our temporary signs. That was a good illustration because I got really confused. Yeah, so, okay.

30:54 I just got off the trolley and I'm there with my bike. And I don't really know the system at all. And I look over to this wood sign and it says Mammoth Pass this way. And on that sign is this e-bike thing that says no e-bikes and no motorbikes. Right. And so... So the mountain biker says, oh, I don't have an e-bike, I can go. I don't have an e-bike and I'm not on a dirt bike. Right. Does this mean that I'm allowed in there? Right. And so that causes some confusion to folks.

31:24 And Christy, to be clear, the multi-use paths that he's talking about getting the permission are the paved ones. Yeah. The soft surface ones are still Forest Service making that decision. Yeah. Thank you. Well, it's funny because when you showed that picture, I was thinking, oh, I think there used to be just like a regular like no bike sign on that and now it's a no e-bike sign. Right. So you can see the need, right, for...

31:48 One of those brown strip signs with the sticker that has six different figures on it. Need more signs. It's that kind of thing, right? Signs are the answer. We're trying to remove clutter while we put better signs in. So many signs. So, Joel, I don't know if you can answer this or not, but I know there's been a lot of discussion about bike share with walk, bike, ride and trying to get bike share going. And should it be regular bikes? Should it be e-bikes? Do you have any update on that at all? Or if not, it's okay. I know that's not your...

32:18 Could we get an update? So this is coming out of MLR, an interest in at least exploring the idea of the bike share program. No decisions that I'm aware of have been made. It's more of an exploratory thing. How much is it going to cost? It's been expressed that it might not cost us anything. There's concerns about clutter all throughout the town. There's stories coming out of Seattle and other places where it doesn't sound so great.

32:45 The bikes have been described as uncomfortable and heavy, so that makes me think about 8,000 feet elevation and hills, so where are we going to do this? Is it basically Old Mammoth Road, kind of, where it's comfortable for people to go back and forth? That might work. To me, I have my own sort of personal thought on it. You know, if they're just regular bikes, I don't see it as that wonderful.

33:15 I think it would get used, but I also have concerns about the hubless, where, you know, where there's no stations, where they can just be anywhere. Yeah, I've seen that. Do we want to see that all over the place in our parks and trails? I don't know. I'm kind of not keen on, it's like grocery carts in rivers, right? I just don't want to see stuff laying around. So, but when it's presented as a potential e-bike share service.

33:43 It changes my thinking a bit in that it could change the dynamic of our parking problems. Potentially, that's just one thing it could start to change where it's actually really easy to hop on something and then zip up to the village. To me, there's a lot of value in that. I asked Joe Kittredge what he thought about. It's come up as like, is that encroaching on your rental business? And he didn't feel threatened at all.

34:13 Other folks may feel threatened, I'm not sure. But he sees it as a different customer, right? Like the person that just wants to zip back and forth from the village versus the person that wants to rent the mountain bike and go in the bike park. So he's looking at the bike park customer as opposed to the back and forth. So I see it as...

34:39 Sort of a game-changing thing. If I could freely ride an e-bike back and forth from work or here or there, I would choose not to drive. But that's just me. I see that a normal, heavy, uncomfortable bike share maybe just doesn't generate the kind of enthusiasm or solutions that maybe the more convenient electrical ones would. But I'm not aware of any sort of

35:10 Decisions or direction, clear direction yet on it? I'm just curious because I know just from some other commissioners around the state, there's different companies, different models, some seem to work better than others, so I'm just kind of curious what the status of that was. Yeah, you know, just our team is really leery of the clutter. Yeah. I guess that's based on that, that's my question too. It's like, okay, most municipal cities like share programs, they're

35:39 You know, heavy, uncomfortable bikes, but that doesn't mean we have to get heavy, uncomfortable bikes, right? Does it? I mean, is it like if you're going to have a bike share, you have to have this bike, and that's it. The end. No choice. Yeah, it's a good point, right? What about a better design? So far, the ones that are being mobilized, they're really cheap bikes. You know, that's why they're uncomfortable and heavy.

36:06 That's where they get left everywhere. Right. It's interesting, too, because, you know, there's one company that has this model that, you know, they actually, like, you know, get people to, like, go around at night and, like, collect them and plug them in at their houses and they, like, get a little, like, credit and there's lots of different ways to do it, so it's just kind of interesting. So, thank you. Interesting. Thank you. Joel, a quick question for the benefit of the commission. So, can you talk a little bit about the responsibility of the town on our MUPS?

36:35 as the e-bike kind of policy is revised, you know, what obligation, kind of what responsibility will the town have in this program? Okay, responsibility, I just first, good information, right, so people know what they can and can't do on the pathways, so our multi-use pathways, we're going to have to figure out what kind of sign you want at the entry points to the multi-use pathway system. You know, our,

37:06 My shop can certainly help with that, and I would recommend it to get messaging worked out and things like that, the graphics, that could easily come from my shop. So it's the signage. As far as enforcement goes, we have to talk with Al and see how he would want to handle doing anything differently than they currently do.

37:32 We currently have a regulatory program for our pathways with or without e-bikes. To me, it's going to be mostly about speed. So how can we mitigate speed issues better than we do today? E-bikes are a part of that, but just a regular bike, I think, can go as fast or faster downhill anyway than an e-bike. What's your sense of timing with this, Joel, in regards to...

38:01 You know, the signage and rolling out kind of the packages and obviously it's important to keep the signage consistent, you know, across the area. Is it something that you see happening kind of this year? Is it something next year that the commission will be kind of engaged with and the department in regards to updating the trails? First threshold would be a decision from the Forest Service, right? That would be the first. That's an unknown.

38:29 Point in time right now. But that would certainly kick us into gear. We can develop messaging and signage anticipating that to be ready. Unfortunately, you know, we have a lot of signs out there today. And so one thing I always dread is, oh, let's add another sign everywhere. So I would really want to try to see what we can get rid of in the process. Good. Okay.

38:58 And as far as fees, so that seems like something the town's going to be obligated to purchase, a lot of the signage and then installation and so forth, just as we normally are, right? I mean, that's consistent with your understanding. That's consistent with our use permit, which has an operating plan. We're the manager of the system. Okay, so it's just something we have to be aware of as it moves forward in regards to... There'll be an associated cost. Budgeting, yeah, dollars for it. Thank you.

39:27 Make that aware of what that would be. Thank you. Great. Thanks so much, Joel. Thank you very much. Anyone from the public have any questions or comments for Joel? Okay. Thanks. Okay, that will move us into our discussion items. We'll go to item number three, the Parks and Recreation Department monthly report. Okay. Thank you. So we moved this little department update to kind of more of a discussion item. It seems like it's, yeah, more of a discussion item than a consent item.

40:11 But what we'll quickly walk through here, obviously our playground went from a one-dimensional image to a three-dimensional image in a really short period of time. The crew over here thinks a little bit longer than kind of my understanding, but very impressive. If you've been out there, I know Laurel and the crew. I mean, it was absolutely amazing. Everybody came together.

40:37 Lauren and Warren were pretty much the team. They've got a little button they're going to make together here soon. And Sierra didn't accept her job. So, I mean, essentially it was an entire town project. I mean, you know.

40:50 With our public works and engineering, Hayes and Sierra, you know, from our public works staff to our parks maintenance staff to our staff. I mean, it was when I added up the hours last week just with our staff, you know, the week before was about 400 plus hours plus public works with two certified installers. And typically what happens, they'll bring 11 people to install that playground in five days and we were able to kind of do that same timeline. So really impressive.

41:16 So couldn't say enough about the overwhelming response of our volunteers, you know, the excitement, the enthusiasm. You know, we were in kind of awe of the, you know, the people just kept coming and signing up and wanting to really be part of this, you know, great community build. So I can't say enough about how well the staff did and how we all kind of kept ourselves going, you know, day after day. But, you know, we were almost there.

41:41 We have a crew back today. If you want to cruise over to the site, so Child's Play is back and they're finishing off the curbing. Also the accessible tile will go in and they're kind of making some modifications based on kind of accessibility, which is really good. A few other things they'll fix on the playground and then they'll go ahead and, you know, that's their final certification for that playground. Hopefully by Friday we're able to kind of, you know, secure that.

42:07 And move on. And we're on schedule for a ribbon cutting, as you know, July 4th. So 1 o'clock. We've actually scheduled a town council special meeting at Mammoth Creek Park at 1 o'clock. So I want to make sure you're all invited and are being part of it. And we're obviously going to be pushing out lots of emails and correspondence to all our yellow shirt high visibility folks to come on over and be part of that photo and the ribbon cutting.

42:32 If you saw recently, I know Matt's here, can maybe speak to it, but we'll meet tomorrow at the park to talk about it as well, but we're able to secure, is that public knowledge now, Matt, with our new partner? Not yet. Not yet. Okay, so we have a new partner, so that's kind of going to be a very large announcement that will enable us in the future to continue to expand the accessible surfacing, so that's something we're really excited about. So not only do we have the funds right now to finish the playground as we've designed, as on that little...

43:00 Couple of pieces of paper. But we're going to be looking to expand that over the next year. So we're very excited. So that's the big part of the playground build. We've also, as you've gone through this little list here, so, you know, we've wrapped up Town Cleanup Day. Fish stocking is, you know, well underway. We still only have the existing money that we had at the start of the season. I know Mammoth Lakes Tourism is looking to...

43:23 Expand, you know, some funding or reinstall some funding to grow that program. But right now we have six drops. We've done two. We have four more to go. Very successful day for our Whitmore Pool opening day. Everyone's, you know, very much enjoying the water, the beautiful pH, the clear, crystal clear water. Staff are doing really well. Cats running that team. Swim lessons are overwhelming.

43:51 Summer camp's kicked off. As you know, the big issue we're dealing with this week is certainly the Stage 2 health advisory, so we've kind of rolled camps kind of indoors right now. We've given options for our camp participants to either refund, try and come back another time, or stay with us, and we've kind of created a little hybrid camp that's kind of more in than out this week. So that's wilderness, that's bike, and we have UK soccer, so it's kind of a big week for us. But we've all pulled it together and see how we do.

44:21 Kat went to the Health and Safety Fair at June 9, Shady Rest Park, and then as you know, Betsy will kind of talk a little bit about in her department commissioner update on Park and Recreation Month, which is very exciting. Just really quickly on the deferred maintenance program, we had a really successful ribbon cutting and kind of walk around, walkabout, right, Shady Rest Park last week with council. So I think they were really excited.

44:50 Thrilled to see a lot of the enhancements that it has undertaken in the last couple of months, certainly. So Shady Rest Park, as you know, is probably where most of the majority of funding that was allocated, you know, just over $200,000. Still a little bit of work to do. We're missing a few pieces on the ADA bleachers, but, you know, everything's there. So that was very successful. Tennis courts have all been done, so that's kind of, you know, we're just tracking how that work effort is going to hold up to our seasons and so forth.

45:18 Volcan Brothers Skate Park, so we've had some work taking place down there as well, the expansion and also some maintenance work. Whitmore Track and Sports Field, you know, we put the two bleachers down there as well, so we've got an ADA and a regular bleacher down there, and the Whitmore Pool, obviously, updates we've talked about extensively. So, you know, with the playground and with all the deferred maintenance programs, you know, we're looking at about a three-quarters of a million dollars investment in our parks by the fall, which is pretty impressive in a year.

45:46 So I do want to kind of again thank you staff and thanks our Parks Maintenance Crew Public Works for everybody kind of helping us put this together. You know we have a lot of information here on Recreation Programming. Happy to answer any questions. You know we've updated everybody on our different facilities. I don't know if there's anything that staff want to add to a little update. So at this time we'll happy to answer any questions you may have on our busy time. Questions for staff? Comments?

46:17 That it was so much fun to work on the playground. I wish our events didn't...

46:23 Coincide for us to be there as much as we had hoped, but being there for the last day and putting the kind of little finishing touches on, but still feeling like we were being just as much a part of the build as the folks who put the pylons in and everything. It was really awesome, and it was extremely clear how much work Lauren and Warren and crew had put in, but especially Lauren and Warren. You guys worked your butts off, and it shows, so thank you for that. It looks great. Great job. Thank you. Christy?

46:54 Just a couple things, you know, again, just to echo Laurel's comments, I mean, just amazing, amazing job. I know you guys are out there, very long days, very, you know, hot weather.

47:06 Just super, super impressive. I'm sorry I wasn't able to spend more time there, but I was just incredibly impressed by the response from our community, all the volunteers, just see all the staff really come together. So really exciting, and it all happened so much faster than I think anyone really anticipated. So that was very exciting to see. Just a quick word on the deferred maintenance stuff again, just huge commendation to staff, a lot to manage, even in terms of just outside contractors along with just

47:36 Just regular opening things. I know everyone at the pool has been super happy. Everyone's really loving the new heater. The water is beautiful. The staff are doing a great job.

47:47 Thank you to that. And then at the ribbon cutting that we did before council the other day, it was just a really nice opportunity to, one, really thank this council for the support they've provided in terms of addressing some of the deferred maintenance. And also, I just really want our community to understand that, yes, we're very excited about our shiny new playground and our other projects, but we really want to properly take care of what we have. And so having the funds to do that has been really, really important and exciting. So that's been good.

48:16 The fundraising piece on the playground, the nice response to that has been good. So, you know, happy birthday to Stu. So, yeah, so thanks everybody. It's just, I'm just really awed by everything that you guys are doing in what also just happens to be your busiest time of the year. So, thank you. It's very, very noticed and appreciated.

48:41 Thank you. I've just asked Joel to kind of stay and maybe if he has a couple of minutes just update the commission on the disc golf course and how that's progressing through kind of a cyclical changeover with kind of our staff at the U.S. Forest Service. Thank you, Joel. Thank you, Stu. It's actually pretty brief.

49:04 Analogous to our trail projects, one thing that we always have to look at as far as resources go is heritage, cultural, archaeological resources. And out in the Shady Rest area, that's been the sticking point with the disc golf is first, can we identify an area that we can do something on? This has been the challenge. And where the existing course is, where people are using today,

49:32 Similar to, you know, illegal trails, when they go in, they don't know what they're on, and they're not in a great area today. We don't want people walking in that area playing disc golf right now for whatever reason that I can't disclose. So we've chosen an area working with Kerry Wood, who was the recreation officer on detail with us from New Mexico. He's now back in New Mexico. Last week, a new

50:00 Rec Officer came on board, another detailer for several months from San Bernardino National Forest. His name is Travis. He's going to be the lead on this project for us. He's not the holdup. Everything's pretty well written up for Margie. She's now Deputy Ranger again. And she's been working with us on this project as well with Janelle Walker, who has an archaeological background. We're trying to thread the needle.

50:29 between sensitive sites. That's where it is today. We're doing the same thing out in the Sherwins with the archaeological team. We're trying to thread the needle and not go through any sensitive sites. Difficult to give you a timeline on it until I see some sort of report generated from the resource specialist or some sort of decision from the ranger. So hopefully we could

50:58 You know, get started with a project physically in July, August. I mean, it's reasonable to think that something could get going. I don't expect the level, like an environmental assessment type level of analysis. I do expect a categorical exclusion decision memo out of the effort. The good news is, is that it is a project to this district. So, you know, it's in their queue.

51:26 So that's really solid news. It's not something that they're entertaining to do or not to do. It's something that we are doing. That's very exciting. That's super exciting news. Thanks, Joel. So Joel and I, just really quickly, so Joel and I are just trying to refine a scope, a fee, whatever we believe would be a cost to the project. And once we have that firmed up,

51:53 We can then look at getting back to Mammoth Lakes Recreation and updating them on the project. We've kind of been the project lead on it. We want to get it back to Mammoth Lakes Recreation, get it back to Mike, Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Club. And then we can kind of present a more defined and detailed scope of work, cost and potential expense. You know, from the town's point of view, we don't have any money.

52:13 identified, you know, for the project. We've just been kind of using our staff time and with Joel and his, you know, time and the trail system crew to kind of walk this along. So that'll be a decision point that we want to kind of get back to, you know, Mammoth Lakes Recreation and Mammoth Lakes Disc Golf Club and trying to finalize how we're going to, you know, if we still want to complete the project, make sure we have sufficient funding and so forth to, you know, move it along. And then once we can kind of refine that operating plan, we can kind of all...

52:40 You know, fill in the blanks too. Any guesses on when that might happen? I wish. Yeah. So that's kind of a... Just thinking terms of just budgeting cycles. Farming, exactly. Just being aware that that's coming. So as soon as we get noticed and we have kind of a little bit of a firmer document, then that's when we'll reach back out to the commission and Matt and his team to kind of get us on an agenda and present that. I'm good at nudging. I'll keep you updated. You're very, very good at that. We're very appreciative. Yeah. Thanks.

53:11 Awesome. The only other comment that I just wanted to make was just another piece in terms of the playground. Commissioner Osborne and I actually stopped by the playground last night, and there were some kids playing on it because it's pretty much impossible to close off, but MLPD did come by and ask them to stop way more effectively than we did, which was good. So I'm just curious in terms of...

53:38 You know, what kind of measures are we taking just safety-wise? I mean, obviously during the day when people are there working, it's an active construction site, but in kind of the off hours other than the barricades, is there anything else we can do? We're looping back in with MLPD doing the forms today and everything because it will be more dangerous with the wooden spikes and whatnot. So hopefully they can add it to their regular route.

54:05 I think they've been doing it, but just more consistently now that it is. I mean, there was a huge ditch there, so. Yeah, I think hopefully that will become more obvious. The only other thing I would maybe say is maybe some signage in Spanish, because all the park clotheslines, I think, are in English. Not that I think it's necessarily going to make a huge difference, but just maybe something to consider. I know lots going on, but hopefully not for too much longer.

54:33 Actually, the installers went by last night and actually noticed people playing on it, too, so they were able to ask them to leave. I was happy people are excited about it. Oh, when we were building it, we just kept playing with it. Kind of irresistible. Awesome. All right. Thank you. Okay, so if there's nothing further on the department report, then I will move us on to item number four, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Plan MCP update. Thank you.

55:05 Yeah, so we're here to just give an update on the project. It's been quite some time since we've been in front of Rec Commission with this project, so give you an update on what we've done lately, what Council said, and kind of what we need the Commission to do today. So we're going to go over the consensus we received on June 6th from Town Council. We're going to talk about what project sequencing would look like.

55:28 Discuss the impact to programming based on sequencing and then work with you guys to get some input for Town Council. So on June 6, Town Council consensus was to direct staff to bring back options for the project totaling no more than $13 million and incorporating comments given by council and staff that evening. And previously, the...

55:52 Second meeting in May, they had given us approval to move forward with the acquisition of construction management services through a request for qualifications, and we're doing that as a community project, including our partners at the school district, our partners over at the county, and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation to try to incentivize larger firms to come forward and propose on the projects we have for the entire community.

56:19 So when we talk about project sequencing, what we really mean is just breaking up the project into more digestible chunks that can fit within our budgets. The overall vision and goals of the project do not change. We maintain our overall aesthetics. It will impact programming as a function of the approach, depending on how we sequence it, but at the end, all the components of the project will be intact. And we'll be working...

56:47 Hopefully moving forward with defined budgets for each of the phases. Where we left off on the overall project costs. If you were paying attention to the last council meetings, we've been walking through this at every meeting. Working backwards from the low bid from Spees Construction, our architects have been contacting the subcontractors, the material suppliers and so forth to kind of figure out where all the pricing really landed.

57:17 And at this point in time, we have pretty good numbers to work from. We have a lot of confidence in a number of the discrete components in the facility. There are some components that we do have some concerns with, steel tariffs being the biggest one. Working backwards on what we think we can realistically carve out of the project and work with a construction manager to reduce costs on,

57:39 We realistically think that we're at about a 16-2 all-in construction cost, bringing the all-in project cost to around 17-7. We're assuming our construction management costs are neutral at this point. We do believe we would see, realize more savings, but to be conservative in this environment is probably pretty prudent, so for the sake of conversation, we're keeping that cost neutral. And that's for, you know, basically a full project?

58:08 Yeah, this is the full project. As it sits today, if you wrote a check, you know, this is what we believe the project would cost, all-inclusive parking lot, community center, all the components we've discussed and actually bid. So working with HMC, we created two alternatives to discuss here, which we think are a viable path forward.

58:33 We could break it down into a few more alternatives, but we really kind of came to the conclusion that every other alternative was just a derivative of one or two ideas. And working towards a $13 million project, these were just smaller chunks of the same concepts.

58:49 So alternative one we're just calling the covered ice rink. This is the roof and rink scenario we've talked about so many times. Does not include a community center, does not include additional parking spaces. We would replace the interface with the community center on the north with just solid walls. There would be no change to the existing floor plan within the footprint of the ice rink.

59:18 We would have to modify some existing storage rooms for temporary concessions and summer, winter, point of sales and rental spaces. And there would be some minor changes to the aesthetics initially. Long term, everything would fall into place, but initially we would obviously be hacking off the north part of the building, so it's going to look a little bit different. So this floor plan kind of just lays out the various...

59:46 You know components as they sit right now. We would be modifying some of the areas where there was ramps and so forth to become public space. The storage room that was supposed to serve the community center would now become part of the public entrance or a concession or rental area. One of the backups like skate sharpening type of storage rooms would become another location for either concessions or rentals. Again, we haven't worked through that detail. We do have plenty of space to work with. If we

1:00:14 Were to move forward with this alternative, obviously, we'd be going through a more extensive process to dial in exactly what goes where. And I don't know if you have any thoughts that you wanted to add on this particular slide. This was Stu's sheltered workshop slide, but this was a slide we presented to council. And a lot of the colors were really kind of describing and detailing kind of what the components and what the rooms were, what was the amenities, what was kind of really the amenity package. And you can kind of see the two.

1:00:42 Orange, kind of shaded areas adjacent to the public space there. So as Hayes alluded to, we would lose that viewing area. We would also just eliminate the ramp. So that whole gray area is really just that public space, right? So if you're looking at what we would lose in that community center area, which is about 2,000 square foot of lobby space.

1:01:04 Plus the community centre had 2,500 square feet. So a lot of the original design was that complementary integrated use. So we want to make sure that there's sufficient space to still manage 300 plus people, either for recreational skate during holidays or for tournaments and so forth.

1:01:24 You know, the configuration doesn't change over the roof and the Olympic ice sheet. Still has the four locker spaces, still has all the restroom, the shower, all the existing kind of storage spaces in the far left-hand corner there. Also has kind of the snow pit. And it still has the chiller package that we originally talked about that would give us the capability to make ice, you know, September through, you know, April, May. So it has...

1:01:48 All of the amenities that we still desire to program as we've discussed in the subsequent slides, you know, we'll talk about it. The facility entrance you'll see will come from, you know, the playground side. That's kind of why we, you know, reorientated the playground. And as Hayes said, that first orange building, that little space on the right would be kind of the skate rental area. And then the orange space down the end of that public space would be kind of the concessions.

1:02:13 So, you know, we'd lose a little bit of economy of scale, but we think that's probably the best mix right now, and we've only just started to really get into it. HMC hasn't really dug into a lot of detail. This is just kind of us putting together an alternative. And as Hayes goes through the subsequent slides, we'll kind of show you kind of the impact of programming. So here there's no impact whatsoever to winter programming. Still all of the desired programs through the playbook.

1:02:42 They're still able to be delivered through the Olympic ice sheet that we've discussed. Again, the issue just would be the number of complementary spaces that were able to accommodate these kind of larger groups. But in essence, everything or the majority of the items are still retained. And then the next slide, summer's the same. So we still have the Olympic ice sheet. Again, it's reconfigured with kind of a sport court, gives us all of the year-round kind of amenities that we've kind of talked about.

1:03:11 Which would be our volleyball, basketball, you know, futsal, arena soccer, you know, pickleball courts, you know, all those activities, leagues, drop-in plays and so forth are not impacted. And as, you know, we're finding now having kind of a applicable space for our parks and recreation facilities is, you know, more of a priority than ever. You know, we've got so many kids on our waiting lists and the issues that this would really kind of solve that problem. So that doesn't change. And then the next slide, you can see now we obviously eliminate the community centre.

1:03:40 And then the next slide, we eliminate essentially this space, the lobby, the counter, the office space, and those restrooms. So again, we'll have to figure out how restrooms are managed in that facility right now in the rink and the roof concept. There's essentially one gender restroom. So how do we start to kind of address that as we move along? Because we're losing a lot of this complementary space. OK. Thanks, Stu.

1:04:10 So the other alternative we think is viable is what we're just calling the community center with modified rink. Again, no additional parking and no roof over the ice rink. We would have minimal support structures for the ice rink. Many of the facilities that were the Zamboni garage storage and so forth, these are non-structural elements. They're all sitting underneath the superstructure of the steel roof. So we would have to figure out how to

1:04:40 provide these amenities and facilities to complement the ice rink. That may require the use of temporary facilities and may require us relocating some of our existing structures over at the old ice rink to the new ice rink on a temporary basis until the superstructure is completed. We would put in the foundations for the future ice rink where necessary so that we don't have to rip up the work that we've already done.

1:05:07 And we will have to revisit the EIR for mitigation because we won't have a rink, so we have potential noise issues. There could be some timing issues and so forth, or the time of use issues and so forth. So we'll have to go through that exercise. And I'll let Stu walk through. So again, the same diagram. It's essentially as with, you know, design and laid out. It just doesn't have a roof.

1:05:33 So it has everything that we've talked about with the vision and with the goals. Hayes talked about some issues that we'd have to address through the structure not being there. But again, you can kind of clearly see that I've identified all the different spaces that we have, storage, restrooms, and everything in this diagram that just doesn't have that roof. And then as you go through the subsequent slides, this is the impact of programming, right? So now we're back to winter programming is certainly impacted.

1:06:03 Like we're experiencing, again, summer programming's impacted. I mean, if there's no roof, we're back to kind of managing kind of what we have. We do have the Olympic size, so we have the greater area. Now we have a sport court material. We can still do a lot of that, but again, it's going to be impacted by, you know, the heat, the weather, the sun, and so forth. Conversely, though, you know, the community centre programming is retained. And the next slide, you know, we still have, you know, the lobby, the restrooms, and those type of scenarios are still in place.

1:06:34 And then that was kind of that last slide you can kind of talk about the derivatives kind of based off. So to kind of give an idea of what the overall site plan would look like for alternative one, we actually, this is a much, much older topo, but it kind of demonstrates what the overall site would look like and the basic footprint for just the roof and a rink scenario with no additional parking. So when we kind of looked at this, you know, trying to get,

1:07:07 Two input for council. These were the original project goals from two and a bit years ago. So I think there's a good opportunity here to have the commission kind of wade through, provide some input on the project goals. The next slide. This slide's an interesting slide here. This was kind of one of our early presentations. It talks a lot about the discussion we had. I know Sean was certainly part of that as well about the social space, the complementary.

1:07:35 The integration, you know, we originally started this project to relocate the rink and then put a roof on it. That was, you know, where we started. And as the discussion evolved and the public input, you know, it moved into a larger complementary based facility that was able to, you know, integrate a community centre with the social space and with the restrooms.

1:07:59 Rink to really kind of provide this, you know, what we believe was that all-in-one recreation destination that would encompass, you know, a lot of the needs that came through the community public process. So this is another slide that we can kind of double back in and just see how we're still meeting, addressing, or kind of, you know, phasing these or sequencing these needs. And then the last slide is kind of where we want to kind of, you know, focus our discussions today, and that's kind of looking at input on the

1:08:28 You know, preferred alternative, you know, talking about the programming inputs, talk about the programming, you know, versus design, you know, programming integration, and then, you know, anything else that the commission, you know, wants to talk about. I know Hayes hasn't really talked a lot about the budget, about the dollars. I mean, is it, I don't want to give him kind of a bit of a sense of that or as you move through, but that's kind of our presentation. I'll have Hayes wrap up and then we can kind of turn it back over.

1:08:55 Thanks, Stu. So the two alternatives are in line with the council consensus to move forward with a 13, not more than a $13 million project. So we work backwards from not only the estimates that were created by our outside consultant, but the low bid. And by carving out square footage costs and known components of the project, we were able to, for both alternatives,

1:09:20 We're very comfortable that we're under actually a construction budget of around $11.5 million. We actually have invested money into mass grading, permitting fees, the architectural, so a $13 million project needs to include those costs. So our target is really around an $11 million construction budget, and both of these alternatives are within that number.

1:09:47 So like Stu was saying, we're looking for council input. We'll be back before council on August 1st, I believe it is, with the presentation updates. Our hope is at that time that we have kind of decided on a one or two preferred alternatives. We have some clear

1:10:07 Decisions for Council to make. We hope to be well down the road with the acquisition of a construction management team so that if we do receive direction, we can marry our architectural team with our construction management team and work towards a contract with the CM firm for the delivery of the project for a set price. Which means we'd not be going through a public bid. I mean, I don't know if you need some more information from Hayes on that, but that's a big decision point.

1:10:37 We want to bring in front of council and council has given us that direction to move forward with that concept. Thank you. There we go. Thank you. I think the one thing that I would want to add, which I heard very strongly from the council, was that they really want this expedited. They want this brought back.

1:10:56 They want a recommendation. They want to know, you know, what we can do with, you know, with $13 million. And because my sense is, is that, you know, if there's a lot of wavering and questioning that, you know, we don't know, you know, I don't know what they would choose to do, but their direction was very clear that they want something brought back as soon as possible. So thank you for putting this together.

1:11:21 So with that, I'll take questions for staff and then any public comment and then we can just have a little deliberation if that sounds good to everyone. Questions? I don't think I have any questions right now. Okay. Christy, questions? I have some questions. For the construction management services, I actually work in, currently working in a field that touches that and I can see a lot of economies of scale when you're building, you know,

1:11:54 A lot of stuff all at once. My field is right now master plan communities, which is a little bit different. But do you know what we anticipate the economies of scale to be if we start bundling these projects under a single construction management company? It's really hard to say. I think where we've landed is not really trying to figure out exactly what the dollars are going to be. There's a finite number of resources here in town. And if we have multiple

1:12:23 You know, multi-million dollar projects between the county, the town, the school district, and the foundation. We're all going to be competing for the exact same pool of resources. If we were fortunate enough to find a common construction manager to work with all of our various agencies, they would be able to coordinate those resources for the benefit of all. And I think that's really when we're talking about the economy of scale. That's where...

1:12:50 We really see the focus and the impact. And I really can't put a number to that. I think everyone involved that sat at the table and talked about this kind of agrees that there's value in it. It's just really difficult to put a number to it. That's fine.

1:13:07 I don't want to make any assumptions when we talk about sequencing because I was the person that was against phasing this project. Is there a difference that we should be aware of between sequencing and phasing? And where the root of this question is, is does each sequence need to be formally approved and come before commission and go through council? Or are we looking at we're approving

1:13:36 an entire project and then we'll just take it one step at a time. Is there any real difference between sequencing and phasing? No, there is. Okay. We're saying the same thing. Okay. All right. So we're all on the same page as the euphemism. I think that those were my only two questions right now. Thank you. What's the status of the lease with the school district for the current facility? June 30, 2019. And then with

1:14:07 Conversations with the school district, they've indicated that they're willing to extend that for year by year, but there's certainly, I think, a renewed interest to move forward or at least to plan for that childcare facility on that site. So we believe we're in our location at this time, without being confirmed and in kind of a formal document, June 30, 2020 is kind of our end point that time.

1:14:36 Thank you. Any comments or questions from the public? Okay. Seeing none, I think there might be some more comments and deliberation. So, Laurel, did you have? Well, I'm glad we are still looking at this project and still moving forward. Gosh, it's frustrating, as I'm sure it must be for you guys to keep coming back to this.

1:15:05 You know, I've been in summer mode, so I haven't really been pulling constituents as to what the public is feeling, and I don't want to drag this on, but I'm kind of feeling like I could say what I think, but I don't feel like I'm necessarily representing the community if I do that. So it's hard to say one or two has more merit to me at this point.

1:15:34 Definitely there is the historical knowledge that this whole thing started with looking at putting the roof on the rink, and so there is the argument that we should look at that first. But again, the people that I talk to are not necessarily the hockey community that are keen on the rink, so I don't know how they feel about that. I very much feel your...

1:16:03 I very much feel what you are feeling there in terms of community outreach and input. So, but Christy, I'll let you make some comments. Oh, I have some comments. If we are talking about phasing and sequencing being the same thing, I am deeply moved to make sure that we are creating the most community impact with this project.

1:16:31 With the phase that we're looking at right now. Because it is my feeling that with phasing and the process that we go through, which is a good public process, that we might not be looking at phase two. And that's been my concern for this entire project.

1:16:49 And so I'm deeply concerned in the interest of the public interest and the public has given us feedback in the form of multiple outreach that's informed our playbooks.

1:17:04 Absolutely against cutting, especially summer programming, because we are so impacted with these camps in any way, shape, or form. I'm against expanding winter programming for both of our guests and residents, and so any alternative that starts to cut into this department's programming is a non-starter for me. Am I bummed that we're looking at possibly losing a community center?

1:17:30 I absolutely am, but I do not believe that in the public interest, as laid out for us through the community outreach we've done and the playbooks that we have put into place for programming, I do not believe that Alternative 2 is in the public interest. Thank you. Anything else? I think that was enough. Just checking.

1:18:05 Just a couple comments. One, I'm happy to see the Olympic size retained in the proposal because I've felt very strongly one of the biggest things that we learned touring other facilities, talking to other people is just how critical that size difference is in terms of summer programming. So I'm pleased to see that that and kind of the outdoor aesthetics are retained in both options.

1:18:34 I think for me, I'm very concerned about losing an amenity, just given the status of the current lease and that I don't think that can go on indefinitely. I would not want to lose having an ice rink in a resort community. I think I've been very clear about that from the beginning.

1:18:54 I share, however, you know, Laurel's concerns in terms of outreach to the community. We all know this project is not well understood in the larger community. I think that is something that we absolutely must combat before we move forward.

1:19:10 Really know what the best way to do that is. I hope you will all kind of give some thought to that. I hope all the commissioners will give some thought to that. It's been a while now since the playbooks were developed. I think they absolutely still stand.

1:19:25 The last thing that I would want to do is move forward with what I believe to still be a very valuable and valid project, but without kind of a critical mass of community support. So depending, I think, on the direction from council on August 1st, we really need to figure out how to deal with that piece. So that would be my direction and my recommendation to staff.

1:19:48 I certainly do have an opinion on which of these options I prefer. I think that just given what we're looking at without, I mean, I don't want us to create what we have now, which is a facility without a roof. We all, I think, know the limitations of that. So as much as I strongly desire to have the entire project, which is not viable for what.

1:20:12 Funds we have. I think we first need to look at how we can serve the most needs, as Christy mentioned. So I'd be supportive of that first option. Yeah, I agree. Can I continue to deliberate? Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I'm okay with continually going back out to the public, absolutely. I do wish the public would show up at these meetings. But at the same time, we,

1:20:43 As a department and as a commission in a town are wrestling with real programmatic problems right now. It's not, does the public think we're wrestling with these programmatic problems? We are as a department. It's not up for debate. It's not a false news or fake fact. Like we are buckling under the strain of demand for our programming as a recreation department.

1:21:10 I would say, you know, yes, as we go out and it's printed in the paper or whatever, and we talk about, you know, what alternative is best for this community, can we stop talking about it being an ice rink? This is a facility that we need to address real programmatic problems in this department.

1:21:33 The end. And we've been aware of these programmatic problems for years. We have gone through years in phase after phase after phase of public outreach and getting public input to figure out what programming this public wants. And this is how we've constructed this facility. So while I am absolutely open to continuing that

1:21:59 Conversation with the public. Please, public, show up to these meetings. I also want that public to really deeply understand how we have hit capacity with this department. And if we do not have a multi-use facility to handle our expanding programming needs, we are doing a real disservice to the public here. I'm very passionate about this. Good, thank you.

1:22:30 And I think maybe just to define that a little bit more for anyone who is actually watching is, I mean, how many kids do we have on the waiting list for summer camps? I mean, like we had 200 at one point, I think. So I think kind of the need, you know, the fact that, you know, our camps have reached capacity and so how do we, you know, how do we serve the entire community in terms of our summer and winter program, I think is kind of the main goal of this project.

1:22:57 It's interesting when I talk to people because when I talk to people about that and kind of get away from this idea that we're just building this hockey rink for a handful of hockey players, lots of people do come to kind of a different conclusion about it. But I think regardless of our past efforts to engage the public, I think we just have to continue and we just have to keep pushing and we have to make sure this project is well understood. Can I deliberate more? Sure. One last point I would make is

1:23:26 We live in a resort community where many of us are making far less, many residents are making far less money than our counterparts in the city. And there's a lot of quality of life perks that go along with that, you know, like walking outside of Sweet Z and being able to look across the Vons parking lot and see our mountains, all of our mountains. But I also believe

1:23:55 You know, being raised in a working class poor environment myself. It was public facilities, parks, and recreational programming that democratize quality of life for other segments of society other than wealthy people. And when I sit up here and I think about the public, those are the people I'm thinking of.

1:24:18 Our kids camps and our recreational programming and having a facility that people can come and play safely at at a low cost for people, all working class people and poor people in all socioeconomic segments of this community, I think is worth considering as well. I know it sounds like I'm preaching at you. I'm just very passionate about this. I think it's very important not to let go of programming. I think those are all good points, Christy.

1:24:47 Thank you. Thank you for saying that. So in terms of direction to staff, so you'll go to council on August 1st with these options, and I think we kind of have a consensus on where we all land as a commission in terms of our recommendation. And then depending on council direction, then you'll kind of go back and refine these with HMC. Is that correct? Yes. So first, if I may, can I take an attempt at distilling the comments into

1:25:18 Input. I heard a lot of things. I want to make sure I'm capturing it accurately. We have unanimous consensus for option one. And to also, the council needs to manage public opinion and press the point that this is not just a hockey rink.

1:25:44 Thank you. Would that be a fair...

1:26:11 You said it so calmly. Okay. Thank you. So what we will do is provide this input to Council on the first, which is our first real meeting we can get in front of Council because they're being seated on the second meeting of July and we probably shouldn't hit them with a $13 million decision on their first meeting.

1:26:37 So we'll provide these alternatives maybe a little bit more refined, provide this input, and hopefully get a decision at that point. Okay. And then, yeah, and then we'll meet in August after the council meeting, so we'll be able to distill that. So, okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. I really appreciate you putting the presentation together. Will we be able to put that on Granicus so that it's available for people to look at? Yes.

1:27:05 We've been working fast and furious, so our last few presentations were, we were working on them to the very last minute, so sorry, Jamie, that's on us. So Chair, if I may, I don't know, I know Matt's sitting in the audience, I don't know if there's any comments from Matt and how this can kind of move through kind of Matt's organization support or interest or how... Yeah, I was actually just texting my chair.

1:27:32 Thank you. About the same thing. So the reason we're not commenting, I think for reasons that Laurel and Elizabeth articulated that just seeing these now, there's compelling reasons for both alternatives. We need to take that back to our stakeholders. And I certainly need to discuss that with our board. So I just will text you guys and see if you can attend our meeting on the 10th, July 10th, make that presentation before our board. And then we can kind of deliberate on it.

1:28:02 and be prepared to, if we have recommendations, make those for Council on August 1st as well. Great. Thank you. Thanks, Matt. Okay. Yeah. It seems like that's sufficient direction, so. Thank you. Good. Super. Okay. That will bring us into Commissioner Reports. Who would like to start? There we go. Mark? So.

1:28:30 I helped with the playground. I think I said all I needed to say earlier there. Great job, everybody, and really fun. I'm really excited to see that in the community. So it's very exciting. And as evidenced by how many people want to play on it, it's going to be very well received.

1:28:47 I also have been spending a bit of time out at Shady Rest and noticing all the hard work that's been going on out there, the new bleachers and everything. It looks phenomenal. And again, everybody is using it, so they're taking advantage of the resource. And that's great to see your hard work paying off because that's what you want, right? Pokes to play. I also spent the last two days out there doing an ICP Level 1 Ride Guide course, formerly an IMBA course to be a mountain bike guide.

1:29:16 Say enough great things, not only about being able to use Shady as a resource for that, but the course itself and the content of that would be great. So I'd love to talk to you guys about, you know, it's a very small course, but really easy to communicate with them and try to bring them in to do this. And I know there's a lot of interest in this.

1:29:38 Aspect, leading rides in the community, but not necessarily a lot of weight behind spending money on getting a certification to add credibility to what you're doing. So I'd love to talk to you guys about possible grant opportunities or something like that to bring folks in to just raise the bar for our summer camps and things like that. And while we were out there, got to see all your great camps going on yesterday, and it was really, again, awesome to see.

1:30:07 So many different folks in the community coming out and participating in the camp and rolling with it as the smoke came up and down throughout the day and everything. So kudos to your crew for not only putting on such great camps but rolling with the atmospheric conditions as they change. And then lastly, I wanted to say thank you to the entire community that came out and supported our Wounded Warriors Operation High Altitude the second week in June when they were here climbing and biking. And again, we use Shady Rest as our meeting point.

1:30:36 All the great trails that it accesses there. So thank you everyone who supported our military athletes and their families to get a little therapeutic recreation here in the Sierra. Thank you guys. Awesome. Thanks, Laurel. Nothing to report. I've been out of town. Okay.

1:30:56 I have lots of things to report, so please bear with me. On May 19th, I attended the California Association of Parks and Recreation Commissioners and Board Members Meeting, CAPRCBM, Jamie, so you don't have to type it all out, in South San Francisco.

1:31:11 Which was a really great meeting. There was actually quite a bit of conversation about, at that time, Prop 68, which has since passed, which is great news for all of us. And there was also a lot of discussion about kind of, you know, bike share, e-bike share, scooter share. And so I kind of was able to collect a lot of information from commissioners in other towns and cities, which I'm happy to share and pass along. So that was a good meeting. It's always great to talk to other commissioners.

1:31:40 So that was good. Mammoth Lakes Film Festival at the end of May was a great success. Really enjoyed attending that, working on that. That's good. On May 29th, I attended the Latino Outdoors event put on by MLR, which I thought was really well done. So thank you, Matt and team. That was a really, really interesting evening. And I thought a lot of points well taken about, you know, meeting our community members where they are. So I enjoyed that.

1:32:08 Was able to kind of stop by, although not fully participate in the playground build, but I think I've said just about everything there is to say, but again, just so amazing, very exciting, and I've heard a lot of great comments in the community, people very excited about the playground, and assured people a little bit about, you know, what will happen with the old equipment, no, we haven't just thrown it away, no, we can't sell it to you unless you want to give us a lot of money for it, so.

1:32:34 So that was good. I volunteered for the half marathon, which was chilly. So congratulations to all the runners and all the people putting on that event. And finally, I did attend the shady rust ribbon cutting prior to council last week. And then Stu and I were very excited to accept the official proclamation from town council that July is Parks and Recreation Month. And Stu, I don't know if you want to speak any more about that.

1:33:02 Very exciting to recognize just the value of Parks and Recreation here in our community because that is what we are all about all the time. Some great events you guys put together for the Parks and Rec Month. It'll be a fun month. Great, yeah. So, good job. Okay, so that brings us on to agenda items. So, what are we looking at, Stu? We will not meet in July other than the playground ribbon cutting.

1:33:29 Right, so our next regular meeting is August 7th. So at that time we'll have new commissioners, or a new commissioner. The interviews are July 18th, and then council will be appointing commission members later that evening. So that's kind of when the interviews take place. So our meeting August 7th will be to appoint our chair and vice chair.

1:33:57 Which we do, and also we'll be looking at kind of our annual calendar. It's kind of our kind of internal work project that we kind of take on. Also looking at a walk, bike, ride presentation from Sandra. We kind of alluded to it a little bit here with e-bikes, but it's a larger, broader discussion, so we want to make sure that the Commission's up to date, up to speed and knowledgeable about walk, bike, ride and the progression of that plan. We'll also be back, obviously, regarding the park project.

1:34:23 And then we'll look at kind of wrapping up the playground project. So we'll kind of come back and kind of give you an oversight of how it went and what happened and how we did. And then we will also be back probably in, I'm thinking either September, October. And that's with kind of a total kind of presentation on all the projects that have been going on.

1:34:44 this summer and then certainly last summer. So really looking at the deferred maintenance program, you know, what we did, the before and afters. Council were kind of very interested in kind of, you know, seeing that as well. So we'd like to present that to you at that time, which is again just a great way to kind of showcase, you know, what we're doing each and every day for our community and how we're building community through, you know, the power of play and the quality of life. So that's all I had, unless there's something else you'd like to see for our August meeting.

1:35:12 Based on all my time spent at Shady Rest lately, I was wondering if we could talk drones soon. I think there would behoove the public to have some clarification on what's allowed and what's not allowed and where we are on that. I think Commissioner Turner shares that desire as well. We went back and forth. We had a couple of follow-up items, so we bought those two ordinances before Commission. Direction at that time was to further understand

1:35:40 With drones, you know, what other communities and how they're addressing it. And we've got some information from Joel on the Forest Service and how that impacts us as well. So we'll certainly bring that back again. And the other one was the user conflict with the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park. You know, there was trying to get an understanding of scooters versus skaters. So internally, what staff are looking at doing is working through kind of a little survey, not so much a survey, but really kind of a

1:36:09 Park Analysis. So we'll actually send staff down there, you know, once a week and we'll actually be counting scooters in the Volcom, Little Brothers and so forth, skaters, you know, try and get a sense of what we're really dealing with here, you know, look at numbers, look at kind of any concerns, issues, anecdotal comments, you know, those type of things. So when we bring that back again in September, October, they'll come back together and we'll hopefully provide you with some kind of, you know, quantifiable data that you can actually look and understand.

1:36:36 Make a hopefully a more informed decision at that point. So that's kind of our item that we'll have back to you probably I would think either September or maybe October. Yep. Thank you. Welcome. Okay. Well, if there is nothing further, I will adjourn us to our regular meeting on August 7th at 9 a.m. So happy Parks and Recreation Month, everyone. Yay. Thank you.

1:37:10 I was like, where did that come from? I was at June on Sunday.