TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2018

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 44 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

363 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:01 Oh, and so when it's green, it's on. And you can turn it on when you want to talk or leave it on all the time. So, up to you. Just push there, yeah. Jamie, is it the camera working or the recording now? Awesome. Thank you.

3:34 Alright, you guys ready to start? I'm ready. Okay, I'll give them a minute to finish up. We'll go as soon as they finish. So, Stu gave me this package for today's meeting. Where normally would this come from?

4:16 This packet? So you'll get an email. They're always available by the Friday prior to our Tuesday meeting. And so you'll get an email that they're available to be picked up in the town office or they're also posted online on the town website. Okay. So the entire packet for today would be online? Correct. All right.

4:48 Good? Okay. Good morning. I'd like to call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, August 7, 2018. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here.

5:29 At this time, I'll open the floor for public comments. At this time, anyone wishing to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do so. Good morning, Commissioner Sandy Hogan. Longtime, one actually in a string of longtime Mammoth, the Community Center Park Mammoth Knowles volunteers and tennis club volunteers. And welcome, Dan. I know you'll be a great addition here.

6:00 Pat sent you some photos of our recent work day, and that's what I wanted to talk about a little bit and about some history. As I say, it's a long history here, but with the photos, we had our recent work day, oh, a week ago, Saturday it was, and it's really any more just some usually minor park maintenance and, you know, trash pickup, whatever, and this used to be done on the town cleanup day.

6:28 And then I think when we start putting the, making that a major transfer station, that was 14 or 15, something like that. And so then we switched our work day more to the center because we had done a lot of work in the demonstration garden long before the critters got to it and the drought first and the broken irrigation system. But anyway, so...

6:49 Now we have it mid-summer, and we just have a few hours, and so I don't know if you have your photos handy or whatever. The first one, you know, they're pretty self-explanatory. The second photo, though, this is kind of the trail work that we do anymore. A long time ago, in 2007, we did a major work day when Steve Spidell was here. He laid everything out, whatever, and we had...

7:15 In the same time we were having the parking issues and a lot of the employees, you know, from the parking lot would just, they'd go down any of the banks. And so...

7:24 By delineating and raking and using the pine cones, whatever, we've diverted the traffic from the old eroded areas, which are now pretty stabilized, even through that thunderstorm. So this kind of gives you an idea, you know, people rake and maintain, delineate with pine cones. The second one where there's a little, you can see this little stump, it's really...

7:46 A little more than a stump. We call it a snag in the Forest Service. It's a Class 5, ready to fall over. Very light. But what I'm pointing out there to Stan Eller is all the little birdie holes. In other words, snags are wonderful. There are hazard trees and there are snags. This one is probably not a hazard tree. It's soft. It'll probably fall over on its own in a good wind or snowstorm. But while it's up, you know, it serves some good purposes if you see all the little birdie holes in it. And some of the other ones.

8:16 Oh, that looks like the same photo, doesn't it? That main trail, this time, when I walked it a few weeks before, it was fine. And then, you can't see it down towards the bottom there, but that thunderstorm really did just absolutely eat it up. And so, and something like that, I already talked to Stu and Hayes about it. What we did is we gathered some rocks from stable places and put them in the ditch, probably, it's probably 12 to 15 feet long.

8:44 And the rocks should serve as energy dissipators if the thunderstorms come again just for the time being. But it probably needs a little more professional work from public works, maybe a little water bar or something like that. And some of the other ones are just looking at the park with some of our...

9:06 folks, and this one is the trail that goes between, it's the town lot, which is a very narrow one, and the little trail that goes up to St. Anton, and that one is one where it's between two houses and it's maintained by the neighbors. They keep a very nice job, and then last year, I think it was last year or the year before, the Knowles Association contributed money to the town, along with the town.

9:32 to erect a sign on St. Anton so people stopped cutting through other people's property. And two other signs were at the southwest portion of the community center directing people up to the playground, which is a nice one now. In 2007 it was falling apart so we had about 36 volunteers plus two contractors and we collected about

9:57 It was between $600 and $800, and we replaced all of the timbers and did a lot of work around the park at that time. But then a couple of years later, we got a nice standardized, beautiful playground. A lot of people don't know what's there. And then one of them is Greg Martino doing a little raking here. And Marty Cain, one of the neighbors that maintains everything there and talks to Stu regularly. So those are the photos. A little history of the park. It was the first one.

10:27 In Town remains the oldest one. The deed from BLM was originally passed to Eastern Sierra Development Company in 1969, and then Mono County, that was to Mono County, and then Mono County in 1971, in the 70s there, got it in 71, and I believe the Mono County Office of Ed opened the library there.

10:55 And I think, oh, can I go on a little bit longer? Yeah, go ahead, Sandy. All right, just for the history part, so you kind of understand your parks, how they develop. And Mono County, and I believe developed, I think they built a community center about that year. I'm not sure the exact age, but I think it was 1970s. And in the 70s, the playground, the original playground was built. There was an irrigation system in back. There was a lawn.

11:20 A lot of this we know because we have some wonderful volunteers that work with Stu probably, the Eckerts, do you remember those? Yeah, and they wrote a little history of it and they had a plan. This was in the 90s. In the 80s there was a lot of volunteerism again through the Homeowners Association.

11:40 And then 2007, our great big work day. But we did this over the years. Steve Spidell was here in 2007, did the master planning concept plan for that area, not because, again, it looked like the community center was going to move. And our association...

11:58 Put on the table, and I think still has on the table, an offer to replace the sign, you know, and I know I personally talked to Dan in about 2006, that's when I started getting active in it, and she said at that point they were going to those beautiful rock signs, and of course the cost was going to be really high, so we offered to match the cost, and I think that offer is still on the table, but I'm going to find out, because, you know, the community center signed in library, it's not there anymore. Anyway, so,

12:28 We have contributed financially and through our cleanup efforts. That demonstration garden was wonderful when it lasted. That was 2007. In the fall, Steve Spidell got Netfim to donate an irrigation system because we had our big cleanup day in the spring, replacing the playground. In the fall, we had a beautiful demonstration garden out front with a trail going through it, and we bought the $300 worth of plants from the Native Plant Society, and oh boy, it was great.

12:57 For a few years. And then, unfortunately, something went wrong with the irrigation system. The NETFIM is still there. Steve got it donated through Western Nevada Plumbing Supply and installed by a bunch of landscapers. And we planted first the irrigation system, but then that would have been okay because our plants were established, but the drought happened. And, of course, we had four years of drought. It got worse and worse and worse. And so at that point...

13:23 Now the demonstration garden, the good things, the bitter brush and the sage brush and all like those, those are established, but it could be re-established. So anyway, I just wanted to kind of give you an idea of what we work closely with Stu always to coordinate these. And we have a brief meeting after, a picnic usually, and a brief meeting afterward. So do you have any questions at all that I can answer? Any questions or comments for Sandy? Go ahead.

13:52 I'm brand new up here, as you know, so I'm just kind of listening and observing to get going. I don't have any questions at this time. Sandy, I want to say I noticed. I work right by there. I have office space right by there. And I noticed the little pine cone trail going up there. And I think that what you've done is wonderful. My only question is, do you have a request of the commission?

14:17 Not now. Just I'm going to check with my board to make sure that we still have that standing offer to at least maybe match the sign of a, you know, for a new sign. Because sooner or later it needs to be done one way or the other, just knowing that there's a park there. And so that's the main thing. And I think just always we do appreciate the...

14:40 The work, especially Tennis Courts 1 and 2, are wonderful. And we have a wonderful pro out there. And actually, I met a, there was a couple last Tuesday, or Thursday, that own a place in the village. And they said, oh, these tennis courts, this is wonderful, a pro, whatever. And they own a place, they didn't know about it, and now they do. So it can be a real attraction, the park. So I think that maintenance is really important. And we did, you know, try to.

15:08 Do some maintenance. The maintenance that we did several years ago to close the one trail that was eroding is holding up even through that thunderstorm. So that's pretty amazing. Thanks, Sandy. I just, you know, all I have to add is that, you know, those signs did go in last year. I think they still look great. We all really appreciate, I think, the passion that the Knowles Homeowner Association has for the park. That's the only park in that part of town. So, you know, I think, you know, the commission's very appreciative of all your efforts. So thank you. Thank you. We're happy, too. We love it.

15:38 And all the other neighbors, too. Thank you. Thanks, Sandy. Okay, if there are no more public comments, I will move on to the consent agenda. Item number one is to approve the minutes of the regular rescheduled meeting of June 26, 2018. Also move to approve the minutes of the rescheduled meeting of June 26, 2018. I will second. So all in favor of approving item number one, please say aye. Aye. Aye.

16:12 No one is opposed. The motion passes 3-0. Sean, I'm sorry you couldn't join us today, and Laurel will try to get here later. She just had some work issues come up at the last minute. Okay, so that brings us into the next part of the agenda, which is our presentation. Item two is the walk, bike, ride action plan. Sandra? Thank you. So Stu asked me to come and give the commission a brief update on walk, bike, ride, kind of how we got here and where we are now.

16:40 So just to kind of a recap, the walk, bike, ride work effort was

16:47 Intended to support a vision for Mammoth Lakes as a premier year-round outdoor recreation destination where residents and visitors can leave their cars and utilize a system of transit trails and shared mobility hubs to seamlessly access all key destinations. And I think that was the key kind of component of it is that seamless access of all of the destinations. The walk, bike, ride document, the final report was based on

17:14 A number of different previous work efforts that the town had conducted.

17:18 Including the General Plan Mobility Element, Trail System Master Plan, Pedestrian Master Plan, Devil's Postpile Management Plan, the Main Street Plan, and a number of other documents that really were kind of the key building blocks for Walk, Bike, Ride. The key deliverable of the project was the action strategy, action plan that's included in the Walk, Bike, Ride effort, which is what was attached in your packet.

17:46 And so I wanted to just hit, I'm happy to answer any questions about any of the action items that are on the list, but I wanted to spend a little time talking about the mobility hubs, and then I have Hayes here to talk a little bit about the wayfinding. So the mobility hubs, if you see on the note here, we were awarded a grant from Caltrans to conduct a mobility hub study.

18:07 The purpose of that Mobility Hub study will be to inventory the existing conditions, including parking spaces and land uses, and this is for our entire commercial zone. So it's all the way, it's the village, it's Main Street, it's Old Mammoth Road. It will also document existing traffic data and patterns, including transit use.

18:27 and analyze residential and commercial build out for that area. So looking at how that area is going to build out and when it builds out, where are the appropriate locations for these mobility hubs.

18:40 So ideally, at the end of the program, we would have a comprehensive mobility hub and district parking program. So with costs identified for land acquisition and construction, a plan to fund the construction and draft policies for implementation. So I think that at this point is one of the key work efforts coming out of Walk Bike Ride, in particular because we received that grant from Caltrans. We're still in the setup phases of the grant. We won't actually kick it off until

19:10 October, and then it'll probably be a year-long, a little bit longer effort to try to get through that process, mostly consultant-driven, so we will hire a consultant, a traffic consultant.

19:23 prepare all of this information. But we will be back to the commissions and to talk about this as we move forward with the project. And it will be a public process. So we will have public input. That's a really an important part of the grant with Caltrans is the public input. So that's kind of a summary of the Mobility Hub Program. Hayes, do you want to talk a little bit about wayfinding? Sure. On the at the

19:50 August 1st, Town Council meeting, staff provided a comprehensive presentation on the history and provided some recommendations for the signage and wayfinding program that is geared specifically for the municipal side of our program. The project was developed in response to the 2007 general plan recommendations and goals for a comprehensive wayfinding program.

20:18 In 2012, staff worked with MMSA, LTC, and Caltrans to put together the funding to hire Merge who developed the Municipal Signage of Wayfinding Master Plan. That was accepted by the Planning Commission and Town Council in 2012.

20:38 Staff used Measure U money to fund the engineering work to finalize the designs. And then, unfortunately, we were able to put together the remainder of the funding to implement the project. Fast forward a few years, been working with MLT to put together the funding to implement the project. They have committed $350,000 at this time towards the project.

21:08 messaging program and put together a new plan and we also developed a sign clutter program. At the presentation we also recommended to council that we work on a banner program on the corner of Old Mammoth Road and 203 in order to kind of formalize the use of banners on the intersection and just clean it up a little bit.

21:30 The direction from Council was to move forward with the project to work with MLT to close the funding gap and to come back when we can better articulate exactly what we can bring to the table as far as the final scope for the project. The schedule at this time is just to continue moving forward with MLT. We'll onboard some engineering services to work on the corner.

21:56 And to finalize the bid package, with any luck, we'll be out to bid midwinter, work on shop drawings, and then implement the actual program late spring, early summer. Thank you. So those are the two kind of highlights that we wanted to provide to the commission. Like I said, I'm happy to answer any questions about any of the other action items if you have particular questions. And we'll be back to the commission at some point during the mobility hub study.

22:25 to get input from the commission. I guess I had a question. Some years ago, I noticed that the town implemented a signage plan around town that includes like sort of rusted steel and has a whole sort of motif to it. Is that what we're talking about here, expanding that same plan? It is that program. So that was not, that program was never fully implemented.

22:56 There were some concepts that are around town, but the final plan was never fully put into place. So that is what we are proposing now using the funding from MLT is to complete that project and then pull down all the cluttered signs that have misinformation or older and don't look good just as an overall program for way of finding for the vehicular and pedestrian side of things.

23:22 And is it the same motif or design that we're looking at finishing? Correct. It's a core 10 steel post. It's a blue and green kind of colored. It's complementary to the trail system signage, but it's branded specifically for the municipal side. And you might have mentioned it, but I missed it. What's the funding gap?

23:51 Program is just a hair under $400,000. It can be broken up into various components. If you add in the banner program, we're about $100,000. Short. Short, yeah. Okay, thank you. Christy, any questions? Yes. A couple questions. The new sidewalk that went in on Main Street

24:15 On the north side of Main Street, was that under the Caltrans grant? I know that that was, I saw Grady out there and Caltrans out there. Is that part of this project? No. So that project was funded using state transportation improvement program dollars. This is being funded, the wayfinding program is being funded from Measure A through MLT. Okay.

24:41 So with the mobility, are we going to be putting in more infrastructure such as sidewalks and bike paths and things like that? Most definitely. We actually have, we just awarded the multi-use path down by Mammoth Creek Park to close the gap between minaret and the park. And we are out to bid. We open bids for the segment of

25:07 Sidewalk between 8050 and the brewery tomorrow, and then next Tuesday we open bids for effectively the remainder of Main Street, so the frontage roads and the gaps on the north side between Sierra and Mountain. So we will be under construction on the remainder shortly after Labor Day. So I'm going to put on two hats here. I know that Council Member Wentworth talks about a dig once policy when we're putting in infrastructure. I'm going to...

25:36 Put on my broadband hat for a minute and ask, are we coordinating with the public works folks to implement a dig once policy where we can put in and upgrade any kind of technology or digital infrastructure or communication infrastructure that we would need while the grounds open and we're putting in some of these sidewalks and bike paths and things like that? A dig once program or policy is somewhat complicated and probably warrants its own

26:05 its own agenda presentation to discuss. What staff does in void of that is we just place conduit in the ground with our electrical system that we can use for a number of different sources.

26:22 It's complicated to try to leverage utility companies to implement a Dig One policy. It's something we've looked at, we've talked about at length. It's just somewhat complicated, and like I said, it probably warrants its own participation. But just to check for understanding, Hayes, what I hear you saying is you are definitely making it easier and paving the way for that to happen by placing conduit.

26:49 The best that we can. It may not be to their standards, but we'll do what we can within our resources to provide access to it or some conduit to bridge gaps when necessary. Thank you. And my last question is, you know, when it comes to...

27:05 Walk, bike, ride. And, you know, sometimes we have some conflicting information from folks about whether or not we should build more parking or we should try to push a walk, bike, ride policy. And I'm wondering if our partnership with MLT includes getting the message out to guests and residents that walk, bike, ride is the way to go in Mammoth Lakes. So the, you know, MLT is, we have a mobility committee.

27:35 And a representative from MLT sits on that committee. So the information is pushed out. I don't know if they've actually been pushing kind of this particular plan. So I would have to probably follow up the MLT to see if in their collateral materials, if they're trying to push that. Since they're the marketing experts, it might be.

28:00 Smart to have them involved in that conversation, getting the message out. Right, but they do participate. They are on our committee, so they are part of kind of the implementation effort for Walk, Bike, Ride. Thank you. Thanks. So my questions are, so as Walk, Bike, Ride is implemented, and, you know, it's great to have, you know, new sidewalks. It's great that, you know, we've got new mops that are out for bid.

28:25 Because the Parks and Recreation Department basically is responsible for maintenance and snow removal of paved sidewalks and multi-use paths in town, I guess this is a question for Stu in terms of what kind of resources will your department need with this additional infrastructure? I'll actually field that. Okay. That's a good question. Yeah, we've put a lot of new infrastructure in the ground over the last few years, and this is a common

28:57 Recurring theme is figuring out how we're going to maintain it. With respect to all the infrastructure being constructed on Main Street, staff has been working with Caltrans to develop a, frankly, a completely new memorandum of understanding on how this work will get done. There's a long history of agreements with the state on Highway 203, and we're effectively going to scrap them all.

29:26 Not to get too far ahead because the agreements have not been signed, but effectively the state of California is accepting responsibility for the infrastructure on the state highway. They understand that the town is using our resources to build it, but we're building it within their right-of-ways and they have a responsibility to maintain it and clear it of snow. How that actually happens, whether it's Caltrans staff or it's town staff being paid by Caltrans, we're still working through the details on.

29:56 But there will be funding sources and a plan in place moving forward for all the sidewalks on Main Street, which is a really good thing for the public to have pretty much a guarantee that these things will be maintained and cleared forever. Yeah, no questions. Fantastic addition. I just, I know that as we create more infrastructure, we create more workload for town staff. So, anything you'd like to add?

30:24 So, yeah, we've been tasked with working with Warren and Lon and engineering folks on what that means, right? So what is that kind of level of service that we're looking at? So a lot of the discussion is about that. So is it another machine? As you know, we run two trackless machines, and they're pretty much running the level of service that you currently see with the existing network that we have. So any additional network that we're running is going to decrease and lower that level of service across those other.

30:54 MUPS and Sidewalks if we don't receive additional equipment or labour to provide that. So that's kind of our task right now to look at is it an additional machine and then the number of hours, is it a person, full person, you know, what makes the most sense moving forward as this comes out I believe it's like a two-year project to kind of get this up or is it basically open the following year?

31:16 What are we looking at here? What's our timing on this little item? Obviously, we've completed one segment of sidewalk that we'd like to have open this winter. We intend to have an additional two segments completed before snow flies. So, like Stu mentioned, we've been going through this exercise to figure out exactly what we need moving forward. I believe Rob will be giving a presentation to town council with the budget update, with the staffing and resources that we believe are necessary to get us through this season.

31:46 We will only complete about half of the Lower Main Street project this fall. We will have some work to complete next spring. And that means that there will be another segment the following winter to work on. So we've provided information to Rob on the equipment and the staffing that we believe we need moving forward. And like I said, the maintenance agreements, we're still working through Caltrans and exactly how the money is going to flow. But we will have a plan in place for this winter. Super. I really appreciate that.

32:16 You're all addressing that and maybe just keep the commission kind of apprised of those discussions of, you know, level of service and any changes to, you know, our current work plan. So my next question is, so on page two, Sandra, it talks about recreation support facilities and no further action needed by the Mobility Committee. I'm a little bit curious about

32:39 Exactly what the town amenities are that are discussed in there. And I'm also a little bit, I know that council gave direction to MLR to, you know, kind of take a leading role in walk, bike, ride. But I just wanted to make sure, you know, when we're talking about town amenities first, I guess, could you describe what town amenities are referred to in there? And also, I think, you know, the commission would obviously be interested in anything that has to do with, you know, parks, facilities.

33:08 Obviously, you know, any infrastructure that the Parks and Recreation Department is maintaining. So I'm just looking up, looking up in the document here. It talks about, let's see, it doesn't really specify what amenities. It talks about trailheads, restrooms, kiosks, bike share.

33:38 So I think it was very broad. So I think it was just looking to put together an asset management plan for recreation amenities within the town's planning area. So I think this is probably...

33:52 outside of the urban growth boundary, including an outside, but kind of a broader look at that. And that, I think, comes back to those, you know, the issues that we've heard about Horseshoe Lake with the restrooms up there, some of the amenities, some of the restrooms and areas that we don't actually support, but that we could provide support for. So that's, I think, what it was looking for, looking at, I mean. Okay, thank you. Since it's a town amenity, I just wanted clarification.

34:19 So those are all of my questions. Any public comments? Sandy Hogan, the former chair of the Mobility Commission and a current member of the LTC, because some of those questions and comments were really good ones.

34:40 Sidewalks don't magically appear in a couple of years. I have to tell you, a lot of these, I was an alternate for LTC in the early 2000s, and a lot of these projects were on there. It takes a long time to get the state funding, and especially complication when our highway, the state highway, goes right through town, and so anything involving that, these guys have worked really hard. It's amazing.

35:06 But we do have some great projects going on. I do want to comment on one LTC issue that I can bring up and probably you can't, is on the November ballot, there's going to be a measure to repeal what's called SB1. That's the gas tax that a lot of people don't like. That gas tax means $30 million to Mono County, including Mammoth Lakes, over 10 years.

35:31 And if we repeal that, we don't get that. And those are the things that affect maintenance of, you know, just exactly what we're talking about. Caltrans maintaining and the county and the town. So I think I'm okay bringing that up, aren't I, Hayes? I hope so. I thought I'd get that plug in. The Walk, Bike, Ride is a great title.

35:53 for really what was presented as an incomplete document and accepted by the Council at that time as incomplete, unfinished, didn't include any of the public comments or whatever, but I know, Sandra, you guys were tasked with finishing it, and I think you did. Is that correct? I don't know, or if that's still in the works. It may be still in the works. The final document is available on our website.

36:17 With the public comments are on that web page that were provided through the process. And what the council, I think the discussion was, is to really, rather than kind of spending more time kind of churning on that document, is to focus on the next steps, focus on the actions, which is why we've really, we've focused on the action strategies and pushing it forward that way. Right, at the time I knew I was quite amazed that we accepted a consultant.

36:41 Giving us an incomplete document. And you use the term, it is general. And I don't think it has, unless you put those, you know, it doesn't even show in the village that the town has dedicated land for a parking garage. It's called, right next to the West End, it was called the Hillside Parcel. I know we just got plans approved until 2022 again, renewed for that garage. Plans that could be going out to bid if we had a few million, quite a few million dollars.

37:10 But some of the things that have come up in the Mobility Commission, I know, Michael Vanderhurst has mentioned twice, and I think it came up like 20 years ago, and even, you know, right about the time the village was, is collecting an in-lieu parking fee. And that's something that has to be done so that wherever we put parking, whether it's the village, whether it's downtown, here and there and whatever, any development should be paying into an in-lieu parking fee, unless they're covered.

37:40 But if they ask for additions like the, not to be confused with the parking, the Hillside Project, for example, a couple of years ago, if we had had a parking fee available in lieu, when they ask for additional rooms, additional employees, therefore, we would have had money to kick into a garage. So those are the kind of things. And I'm not sure when that mobility committee will meet again. Do you know, Sandra?

38:07 We don't have a date scheduled. What we've been doing is really scheduling those meetings as we have updates on the action items. So we said kind of a goal is a quarterly meeting, but we don't have a date set for the next meeting. So quarterly, probably, you think, September or October? Fall. Okay, great. Yeah, because I try to follow that, but it's not easy. Anyway, those were the main things I wanted to, you know, be sure that the walk, bike, ride, that is our goal.

38:36 The plan is pretty general, as you said. The action plan is what the Mobility Committee is kind of working on. And ideally, the mobility issues in there, I know one thing that bothered me about the plan was they showed the hub at the park, you know, the parking garage at the park. But when you had a dedicated parking garage spot right next to the west, and that was not even shown. So hopefully that's been corrected. I just wanted to bring that up.

39:06 Okay, thank you. Thanks, Sandy. If there aren't any more comments, I'll bring it back up to the Commission. Any closing thoughts on this? Well, thank you very much, Sandra. I really appreciate the update. I know the Commission's kind of just been curious about how this process is going, and congratulations on getting the grant. I also think it's great to be working with MLT on finally getting that wayfinding done. So thank you both very much. Thank you. So just one follow-up item. Chair, well...

39:36 The teams here, is there an expectation from the commission to receive frequent updates, regular updates, or as needed, you know, regarding this walk, bike, ride action plan and its implementation, is it? I think to Betsy's point, if it has to do with our budget and our responsibilities, we should be updated. Okay. I mean, how would you feel about that? I would agree. I mean, if there's...

40:00 Yeah, I concur. If anything impacts a decision here, then we should be updated. Yeah, I think just, you know, as needed, and again, you know, especially if it pertains to, you know, parks and recreation facilities or maintenance obligations, I think the commission would like to have an opportunity to weigh in. Great. Thank you. Good. Appreciate it. Okay, so that brings us to item number three, the first of our discussion items. Item number three is the annual selection of chair and vice chair and appointments to ad hoc committees.

40:30 And before Stu gives a staff report on this, I really hesitate to do this without all five of us here. I know that I had a conversation with Sean, and I also know that Laurel sent in some comments. So I think my question to staff, to Jamie and Stu is, is this something that we should consider tabling? And then I want to hear what the pleasure is of the commissioners as well. Yeah, it's really up to the pleasure of the commission.

40:58 Your current positions, being the chair and the vice chair, would just carry over. I mean, I don't think there's a trigger point right now that says at the end of the meeting at 11 o'clock, you're not going to have a chair. So I think it's very prudent and wise to carry the item. And you can certainly do that on the next item as well if you need to. They're kind of more administrative. And they were kind of established this way and scheduled this way to provide the entire commission and our new commission the opportunity to kind of weigh in on those administrative.

41:27 Item. All right. So thoughts from commissioners? I agree. I think we should have everybody here, especially with the ad hoc committee. Okay. Dan? I agree. Okay. Perfect. Do we need to make a motion, Betsy? I think we can just table it and re-agendize it for our next meeting. Yep. So thank you. And the fourth item as well? So item number four is our regular meeting schedule and annual recreation commission meeting and work plan calendar. So that can also...

41:56 Be tabled if that is the pleasure of the commission. Yes. Table away. Yes, so in that item, Chair, was the discussion 4-4 in regards to meeting time, so we'll just schedule the next meeting for September 4th at 9 o'clock. That's, well, I think you mean, okay, yeah, September 4th, okay. Yeah. Got it. Just to let you know, I won't be here in attendance. Yes. So I'll still be on holiday.

42:32 Approach Grady to schedule that meeting. As long as it's pretty clear and defined, we have our staff report, Commission's understanding of the item, then I think that should be sufficient. I think we'll muddle through without you somehow. Just making sure. And I do think it's great for the Commission to kind of take the opportunity to revisit our meeting time because community engagement is, I think, really important to all of us. So we can kind of take a look at that and just consider with our schedules.

43:00 At our next meeting, we'll bring that back. All right, that brings us to item number five, the Parks and Recreation Department monthly report. Thank you, Chair. So just a little update on what's been happening. As you know, it's an extremely busy time in August and certainly July. It's already August. We've missed July. July was a blur. So I provided just a little update here without a lot of information. I know kind of Lauren's here to kind of talk a little bit about.

43:32 July in our Park and Recreation Month celebrations and events and activities. So Lauren can kind of give you an update on that as we move through. A couple of other department news here. I did include the state-mandated ethics training. So I did want to make the commission aware of that. It's scheduled every two years, I believe, Jamie, and it's 1.30 to 4 o'clock on August 15th here. So that's something you can kind of schedule for your calendars. That would be very appreciative.

43:58 And then as kind of Lauren gives an update, I'll just kind of keep walking through the items that see before you. So maybe Lauren, just give them a quick update on July. Yeah. So July is National Parks and Rec Month. We had a variety of activities throughout the month that kept us very busy on weekends in addition to weekdays. We did an 80s roller disco at the Rec Zone.

44:27 We did a Wave Rave Adult Skate Camp. It was the first time doing that. It was two evening sessions. I didn't actually attend those. John did. But they were well received. We did two softball tournaments, one men's tournament, one co-ed tournament. We had 16 teams in the men's tournament come from down south and 12 teams in the co-ed tournament. So it was well attended and the park was heavily used for.

44:57 Two Weeks Street. Can I jump in really quickly? So I do want to kind of recognize staff and Lauren for taking that on. So those two tournaments were run previously by Grover. SWCC. SWCC, probably for the last 10 to 15 years. So a very well established event. We were notified at the end of last year that he would not be continuing with the operation and the event and those tournaments. So we took it upon ourselves to continue those events.

45:26 What we didn't quite understand was the broad range of responsibilities, the time commitment from all of our staff, maintenance staff and so forth. You know, just the coordination with the umpires, you know, the crews, the fields, you know, it was a situation for the first tournament during that heavy rain squall. If you remember that on that Friday night, it was just, you know, as kind of Sandy mentioned as well, very intense. So Marco, our, you know, field maintenance.

45:53 Staff member at Shady Resh Park came to the fields at 9 o'clock Friday night, realized that three of those fields were underwater, went home, got his own sump pump, got his sump pump on and was there till 11.30 that night, making sure those fields were ready for the tournament at 8 o'clock the next day. So a lot of these, you know, above and beyond, you know, demonstrated by our staff was amazing, really great to see, and Lauren was there pretty much from six to six, if not.

46:22 Later. Later. So a lot of time and effort, but again, it's a wonderful tournament, brings a lot of business, you know, to our community, a lot of economic stimulus, a lot of TRT, a lot of restaurants, but just showcasing our wonderful parks and facilities and couldn't be more proud of our staff that kind of hosted those two tournaments and we've got some lessons learned that we'll kind of take into account for next year.

46:44 And they have a long history. I think the tournament started in the early 80s in Bishop and then moved to Mammoth in like the early 90s. We have people playing whose parents used to play in it who now run a team. They come up every year. It's a big kind of family reunion slash tradition for them. And they are really appreciative of us taking that one. Well done. Yeah.

47:08 We also did the second annual co-ed beach volleyball tournament last Saturday, I think. No, two Saturdays ago. We had five teams in there. Volleyball community is, like, super supportive of getting more volleyball on our agenda. We had teams out there raking the field every...

47:33 Every Saturday practicing for this event. It's our second time doing it, you know. So it's good. And then we actually have, we left the lines up and we actually have an impromptu league, drop-in kind of league going on Wednesday night that's completely like grassroots right now, but it seems to be growing and people really enjoy it and are appreciating the expansion of those.

47:59 Those courts. Yeah, it does speak to, I'll just jump in really quickly, it does speak to the maintenance again. So that was part of that deferred maintenance program and I have a new commissioner. So we invested around $200,000 in Shady Risk Park and the volleyball pit was that, one of those elements that was enhanced with, you know, full concrete curbing, additional ADA paths, a new ADA bleacher.

48:22 And then we do plan to kind of put additional sand in there and that kind of speaks to a little bit of the playground and the sand. So we'll kind of talk about that later. But again, it made a big difference. You know, I was up and down those stands. It was great. Yeah, they got really well used. Really well used and something to continue with.

48:37 And we wrapped up the Parks and Rec Month festivities with a free swim day at Whitmore Pool, which was also very successful. So great community events. Good to see everyone. Everyone thinks I live there now, but it was really well attended, and we look forward to doing it again next year. All right. Any questions for Lauren on Park and Rec Month? We don't have any questions, no. No.

49:06 Bravo. You know, every year these July events just keep growing and I just really appreciate all the time and effort and just going above and beyond the stuff. Continue to do. So thank you. Let's do keep rolling. And then we do Katrina Kelly, as you know, Recreation Supervisor. I had her child on late July, a couple of weeks ago. It's been a blur. So I do want to say again that, you know,

49:35 Staff really kind of came together once we were down a staff member to kind of put this on. And that's one of the reasons why we don't meet in July. You know, the staff are completely taxed. So we appreciate your understanding. Just talk a little bit about deferred maintenance program. Most of the programs are kind of all completed that we've got scheduled, that we had scheduled, sorry. We have a little bit of a balance left over, so I'm going to be coming to the commission, I think it's in October or November, with kind of the complete wrap.

50:04 of our program. So it'll be a good presentation, kind of showing the before and after, which I think is, you know, good to see and all the improvements that we've made. We have and we are scheduling right now some follow-up work at the Whitmore Pool. Our kiddie pool needs some updates, some mechanical improvements. So that's kind of the...

50:23 The second phase of the immediate work at Whitman Pool. So that's going to be scheduled this fall. And then we're looking at some ball field enhancements as well that we'll talk about. So our deferred maintenance program is almost complete. And as you know, that was a $300,000 investment by town council, which is very appreciative, in addition to the monies that we receive for the bleachers. So all in all, it's about a $345,000 investment into our parks and facilities. And you can see each and every day people take advantage of those enhancements.

50:53 So that was about it. You can see Lauren and John are still operating and supporting the men's and co-ed softball leagues. You can kind of see our standings there. Warren apologised, couldn't make it today, but you can see fields and facilities are fully open. It has a great team in place. Most of our staff will run through end of September.

51:13 into October and then we'll start phasing out our seasonal staff. We run about five seasonal staff in addition to Warren and Juan and Derek and then we receive a hybrid position. Commissioner O'Donnell here where we run a hybrid position with Zeke who is in public works in wintertime with all the snow removal and then he's with us in the summertime to run kind of our trials program and our maintenance special events and so forth. So we're very appreciative of that position.

51:42 That's kind of July in a nutshell. Any other questions? I just have a couple comments. I just wanted to say that everything just looks so great and it's such a point of pride on your behalf and as a rec commissioner to see so many guests and residents.

52:07 using the MUP in the sidewalk and Shady Rest Park, and it's just a really nice experience. It's not junky. They're high-quality facilities that we have. I do a walk on the MUP going down to Shady Rest every single morning, and I see everybody there, young people, old people, white people, Latinos, guests, residents, and I just wanted to say, it's working! Thank you so much for all of your hard work, because this really does allow

52:36 Anybody from any walk of life, any income, any socioeconomic background to enjoy all recreation all the time. So thank you so much. I'll pass it on to Warren. One take credit for that. Sam? I have a question. What's a MUP? It's a multi-use path. Oh, okay. That's a good question. I've been hearing this bandied about and I'm like, okay. Very good question. Typically they're eight feet in width.

53:04 Different than a sidewalk. Sidewalk is typically narrow at about six feet. So the mups are typically a wider path because of the multi-use. So they're all typically the asphalt paths. And we presented, thank you for the question, we presented in front of council. It was brought up by council member Stapp regarding the deferred maintenance and obligation that the town has for our 20 miles of mups. So we have an annual plan that we revisit every year with a commission.

53:30 to better understand the commitment that's going to be required to maintain those MUPS in a safe state. So we're returning in October, and we'll bring that presentation back to Commission before it goes to Council to make sure you're up to speed on kind of how we're going to approach the maintenance of those MUPS, which is, you know, Lakes Basin Path is, you know, that main one, and then we have our loop. So the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project that Hayes spoke briefly about today,

53:58 That really completes that gap in our MUP loop around town. So it's a critical component of our access and our recreation amenities. So the path that has the lanes going up to the Lakes Basin, that's part of that. Correct. It's not just a bicycle path. It's a MUP. Correct. So walking, biking, all of the above. Running. Running. Yeah. You name it, we do it on that trail. So it's a very heavily used trail.

54:28 Well, I use it all the time, and it's definitely something to be proud about. I mean, as community members, you know, ride up from my house, ride around the lakes, back down, and it's literally filled with what appear to be resort guests all the time, looking so happy, having the best time. I mean, it's really important infrastructure.

54:55 You know, we could use a little more of that, but it's fantastic. Good, appreciate it. Awesome.

55:03 So I just want to echo the comments about, you know, the parks look beautiful. You know, Warren and his crew have done an amazing job. As always, you know, we really have some beautiful things to be proud of. I know we keep talking a lot about the $300,000 and the funding for deferred maintenance, but I do think it's important for the community to understand that it's been many, many, many, many years since we've had those funds available to address some of these issues.

55:28 Just to remind everyone, Measure R can't supplant the town's general fund obligations to take care of things not built with Measure R funds. So it's really important that we continue to advocate for the allocation of those funds because we still have a long list of deferred maintenance obligations. I also have a question. So I know that we've been, you know, we're all dealing kind of with the smoke issues. And I just wanted to kind of ask,

55:58 For the benefit of the public, sort of, you know, how one, like how is our staff coping with that? You know, what modifications have you had to make to programs just in light of the health issues? Where do you start? So we track, I think first and foremost, we use source of information from the Great Basin Pollution Control District website. So we track that. It's on our phones. Staff are accessing that, those readings frequently throughout the day, if not evening.

56:27 So a lot of the day's activities planned around that potential smoke impact to the town. So for instance, look at Aquatics Camp. Last week, Aquatics Camp was scheduled to be in Mono Lake, Bishop, June Lake, around Mammoth and Convict Lake. Based on those readings, which was looking at the website, which is fantastic, we really appreciate it, we're able to modify, customize that schedule. So keep the kids out of those areas that would be impact or

56:57 You know, affect the kind of the operation of that camp, health and safety of our kids. So that's one example. Wilderness camp, you know, goes out today. So they basically, you know, again, where their smoke is, they'll try and go to an area where it's, you know, not as dense. So I think those kind of day to day.

57:15 choices are being made. The first week that we dealt with this, probably about a month ago, which is end of June, remember when the whole smoke started, we had a wilderness camp, mountain bike camp, and at that time we just chose to cancel those camps. We moved, yeah, sorry, we moved the wilderness camp indoors, we canceled the bike camp and so forth. So we are kind of making those choices.

57:37 We are working with the school district. When we talked about moving the camp inside, we're able to use the middle school gym and the high school gym based on availability. This week it's only available from 11 to 4 because they have the football teams in there and they've got some other volleyball camps going on. So we can access that. So it does provide some respite from the smoke. We have UK soccer camps, challenger camps. So they were getting inside as well. I think the first challenger sports camp, we were inside a whole week.

58:07 So we're adjusting as necessary. I think we don't hesitate to cancel the camp if we, you know, seeing kids are going to be in risk. If we're certainly in a stage two advisory, that's something that we take pretty seriously and we'll give those parents the option to refund, fully refund that camp experience and I think that's really important. So we will go above and beyond to make sure the kids are safe and the parents are, you know, satisfied with the delivery of these programs from the department. So hopefully that ends it.

58:36 I mean, my daughter was in aquatics camp and I just, I really appreciated, you know, the staff and the kids, you know, flexibility and, you know, just trying to figure out, I mean, it was challenging because they'd had such a great, you know, schedule set up and then the smoke totally impacted that. But, so I really appreciate all that. I really appreciate, you know, the attention to, you know, like the health and safety of our kids. But I also want to make sure we're taking care of our staff as well. You know, there's no place to really go inside at Whitmore Pool. There's not really any place to get a reprieve from this. So I just, you know, want to encourage staff to make sure.

59:06 That we're taking care of, not just the kids in the camps, but all of our counselors and our facility staff as well. And we certainly make it clear to them that they, if not comfortable and they don't want to be in that environment, then they don't have to come to work for that day. We would like them to inform us the day before, and we had a situation last week that that happened as well. But we're certainly not in a position we want to put our employees in any risk. Thank you.

59:35 Any public comments on this item? Eddie Hogan again, just some good ones about the tennis courts. The pickleballers are out. All winter long, they're at Snow Creek inside, but we know they're out because the neighbors have noticed. They're out in the mornings and out in the evenings. And then Kyle, the pro, tennis pro, lots of great comments from visitors and, you know, folks that live here. He had kids camp.

1:00:05 I think from six years old up to like 13. I mean, that's a big span. Plus adult camps. And then every Tuesday, Thursday, there are the tennis clinics, well attended. I think there were 14 last week on Thursday alone, something like that. So just some really good ones. And just a note on the MUPS.

1:00:27 The history of the MUPS, pretty much all but the Lakes Basin were designed by our late supervisor, Larry Johnston, back in his private consulting days. And then he pretty much laid out our loop, the town loop and the shady rest one especially and all of those. And it was pretty amazing before he became a town employee and then became a supervisor.

1:00:54 So anyway, his celebration of life was a couple of weeks ago at Shady Rest and very well attended along with a resolution from the governor read by Stacy Corliss, which is really nice. He was an amazing man. A lot of us just knew him from one, you know, from one dimension, but boy, was he something else. Okay, anyway, just my comments. Good turnout and those courts are nice. Thanks, Sandy.

1:01:23 Unless you guys have more comments, I will move us on to item number six, which is the Mammoth Creek Park Inclusive Playground Project Update. Thank you, Chair. So at this time what I'd like to do is just give you a brief update on the playground and the project, where we're at and what's to come. So we'll kind of talk about the ribbon-cutting ceremony itself, our community build project, our project reconciliation. I've got some information in there that I can share with you, donor recognition.

1:01:52 that Lauren can talk a little bit about Phase 2, what's to come, and then a little bit of discussion right at the end on our existing playground. So thank you for attending our 4th of July ribbon-cutting ceremony. I do have a print here that I'll kind of present at the end to the Commission. As you know, to get to that July 4th date was pretty monumental.

1:02:16 Herculean, I think is probably a word I used. So this was certainly the celebratory time. Again, just wanted to recognise our amazing army of yellow-shirted volunteers, what we call them. Ironically, Grady still wears his. I built a playground t-shirt.

1:02:32 Softball and gets a lot of great comments. It's his lucky T-shirt. It's his lucky T-shirt. They lost when he didn't wear it. They lost when he didn't wear it, so there you go. So we got his high visibility, you know, build a playground. So wonderful community pride. I think that's kind of what that speaks to in our community really coming out and rallying behind that project. Also on July 4th, you know, we recognized our many donors, certainly our supporters, our advocates were there as well that got us to the point, as you know, it was a five-year-plus project.

1:03:01 to get this inclusive playground in the ground. Our councillors, our mayor, you know, John Wentworth did a fabulous job. We had several other councillors in attendance as well. Local businesses, contractors, non-profit organisations. We had staff representing as well, which is fantastic to see. So just a great, great turnout. We were so thrilled to see everybody there. I included some images in the packet. We have several.

1:03:29 We have so many that we had from drones from Heather Johnson, which is thankful. Lauren was there with her drone. We had Matt out there with cameras. So we have a lot of great. Joel was there as well. So we had a lot of great photos to capture and memorialize the event. So, you know, wonderful, wonderful day. From the community build point of view, as I talked about, kind of a, you know, we put ourselves in a really difficult position. We knew it, but we did it.

1:03:56 Right? I think looking back, we would probably do things differently. Might not do that again. Look, honestly, you know, again, couldn't be more proud of certainly the team, you know, from Warren's point of view, you know, pulling his team together. What a great team building exercise for his parks maintenance crew with Public Works. And then Lauren, you know, we recognized on the day as well for kind of being the glue for the entire project from, you know, our volunteers working with Talo and Great Western. All our donors, raffle,

1:04:26 Suppliers and Sponsors, so our glue that held us together and kept us sane throughout that project, so thank you. So as you know, we kind of took on a project that was, one, to remove a playground in a four-week period, so we removed the playground on the Saturday prior to the work started on a Monday, so we cut it pretty fine, but again, we got the playground out. It's currently in storage.

1:04:50 And then over that first week, we had a crew of Enrique and Brian from Child's Play who I just thought were amazing gentlemen that were willing to work with a team of volunteers. But again, they had exhibited just immense patience and understanding and great direction. Enrique's name was probably called, I don't know, 50 times every hour.

1:05:16 You know, he'd stop what he was doing, he'd turn around, he came over, he addressed, you know, the teams, the volunteers, any of our questions, concerns, and just went back on his way, you know, building that playground. So, two amazing people that really helped us, so couldn't say enough about those guys. So, and he, I think the anecdotal part about that was, you know, what he was saying is they typically have a crew of about 10 or 12 that build a playground in a week. Professionals, right? Professionals that do this day in, day out.

1:05:44 Well, maybe they do. I'm not too sure. But, you know, amazingly, and to credit to our team, we pretty much pulled off that same schedule. I mean, so we, you know, with our volunteers that were in and out every four hours, right? So if you think about it, we have a new team every four hours that we're retraining. Yeah, putting in different tasks, dimming in the spiel, giving the hard hats, giving the shirts, here's your task, this is what you do. Pretty impressive.

1:06:10 So I couldn't say enough about our amazing volunteers. So that first week we got the structure up, as you can see, which is immense. We had a scheduling conflict, so we weren't able to get that crew back the following week. So we had a little bit of a downtime. We kind of released some volunteers. We spent more time and days where that volunteer is actually prepping the site. So we had crews coming in, shoveling, picking up rocks, right? With the soft surfacing. With all the soft surfacing, right? So they're basically out there with wheelbarrows, shovels, picking up any rocks, pebbles.

1:06:38 On that entire 7,000 square foot area, right? So, I mean, that's a lot of attention to detail. And they had no complaints. They're very happy. We kept them well fed. They got great prizes. But again, I mean, that's pretty impressive. So we got the surfacing done. The surfacing of our engineered wood fiber, it's kind of a technical term. It is a compliant material. As you know, it's not fully accessible. So we're going to talk about that later. But we were able to in that second week.

1:07:02 Install all the surfacing material. And then when the crew came back the following week, which was the third week, they were able to complete the accessible surfacing and the tile. And we had a few other pieces that we had to move around. And they kind of did the quality control. And I think during the first week, we were also able to get the playground certified with some changes. So we were able to kind of compact that all in in about a two and a half week period. All in all, we finished the playground build on July 3rd.

1:07:32 So the day before. 24 hours. The evening before. So again, amazing schedule. It does show that when you put a date out there, everybody works towards that. And really take a lot of pride in kind of delivering that for the community. So I do want to say that we, as you can see, we delivered the project as described. We delivered the project on time and on budget. So couldn't be more proud of our team at this time. So really amazing effort.

1:08:00 So that's our community build. Any questions on that one at all? I'll just keep going through and then maybe touch base.

1:08:07 I just have a quick comment. I just really want to echo, you know, Stu's comments about, it was amazing to see the community come together, just phenomenal, the amount of volunteers. I mean, it just, it seemed like every time I went by the playground, there were like more and more people. And I really was really pleased that at the ribbon cutting that, you know, Stu is able to really recognize Warren and Lauren especially. But I also really want to thank Stu who spent like every day, you know, gave up swimming for the course of the playground build.

1:08:37 And, you know, it was just really, really, you know, everyone was so dedicated to making this happen. So thank you. Yeah. Did you have something to add? You had a quick question. Referring to the community build, you said there's some things you'd do differently and possibly not again. Yep. What did you mean by that? We can talk more at the next meeting. I think the timeline, I think, was very aggressive, I think, in the end.

1:09:01 And I think the big question that we're working with our engineering staff is the way we went about this project. They feel that they would want to have a formal public bid process. What we're able to do through this process is go through a company called U.S. Communities.

1:09:19 which has that element of a public build, but it's actually, you know, contracted through multiple, you know, providers. So the town doesn't have as much oversight as really is required, and we believe the specificity of the agreement could have been a lot tighter, right? So there was a lot of kind of, hey, you're welcome, we're in the community build. Perfect.

1:09:41 So Dan, I think it comes down to the specificity of the agreement. So during the bill, there was like, well, who's responsible for this? Who's got this? Who's going to pay for the pump for the concrete? Hey, we added this bit here, but we changed this. Where's that really in the agreement? So when we get to this project reconciliation, there's an item there that was...

1:10:03 Cost it at 33. We settled on 29.9 because there was so much change to the scope, but there wasn't the language in the agreement that kind of provided us that opportunity to kind of work through that in a kind of a formal way, if you know what I mean. So it was a very kind of gray area that we found ourselves in. So the recommendation from our public works and engineering team is to kind of really build it into a public bid process.

1:10:26 And it's fully managed by engineering team. And this was kind of done in a very hybrid approach, which worked, but we'd like to see that tightened up in the future. So that was kind of some of those examples that could be improved in the future. Like with any project, right? You don't want to get who's paying for what, who's responsible. But we worked it out. We had how much staff we provided versus what they provided. You can see in the...

1:10:51 The little narration here in the staff report, I mean, it was 800 plus hours of staff time. I mean, that's an immense amount of staff time, plus 500 hours of our volunteers. So we put a lot of time and effort in there. And how is that factored into that agreement, you know, when they're providing two and we're providing all those staff time. So we really took, I think, above and beyond what was specified in the agreement. So I think looking back, that was probably our first and foremost.

1:11:18 And if we do this again or secondly for the enhancements, we're going to start to tighten that up and we'll do that in a different way. And did you say there was something you wouldn't do again? I don't know if we'd actually take on a whole community build project again. I think we'll just need a little bit of time to recover, I think. But anyway, no, great. It was a good community effort. Great, yeah. It was great to see everyone out there. People take great pride in that park now. They feel...

1:11:47 Total ownership over it. Good and bad. And, yeah. Well, maybe you make adjustments that side. Exactly. And I think that's what it is. Based on what you learned. Yeah. And it did come down to, you know, from a financial point of view, that was a decision that, you know, the commission made. You know, we weighed this up, you know, several months ago, and that was something we said, yep, let's get it done, and we delivered. You know, $84,000 cost to build a playground. And, you know, we paid.

1:12:16 You know, $10,000. If you look at all our staff time and labor time, it probably cost us $20,000, $25,000 to build. So I mean, we saved a considerable amount of money, and we're able to use that money that we saved in other elements, such as the accessible tiles and inclusive components and those type of things. So, you know, again, and this was, I think, when coming back to doing it again, I mean, what Enrique and Brian were saying, this is not a normal-sized playground. I mean, this was a big playground. So we took on a community build for a...

1:12:46 Large, you know, super-sized playground. So if we came back and, you know, did it again, maybe we wouldn't kind of select something so, you know, overwhelming. But we did it. So hats off. Welcome, Laurel. Thanks for joining us. Do you have any comments on Community Bill? We just spent some time thanking our army of volunteers and everybody that came along, and certainly DSES. We're a big part of that, and it was great to be there for the...

1:13:19 Yeah, I think I had to ask a gentleman, I had to ask a little kid three times to stop banging on the Jazz A minor while we're taking the photo. Still talking about that kid, that's so funny. So there's no more questions there. We'll just kind of roll into project reconciliation. I know we kind of briefly talked about it, but there's some items in here I'll just kind of comment on. So our budget for the project was $316,000.

1:13:50 Approximately $316,000. You can kind of see how we went with budget versus actual and a difference. I can kind of comment on, which I believe I did a little bit on, you can see the project to install the tiles and the concrete and so forth. $33,000 was kind of the budget cost in the letter of agreement. Actual cost, once we went back and forth with Tyler and Charles Play, the crew, over a month, we got it down to about $29,900.

1:14:19 But as I said, that was kind of a lot of the grey area in the agreement that we'd like to clear up and specify in greater detail in the future. But we reconciled that project, so that's been settled. Accommodation for meals, so as part of that we paid for those two installers and the meals. There could be some additional costs there for those meals, so there could be some reconciliation there still to do.

1:14:44 The engineered wood fiber, so what happened there in the end is we budgeted two full loads of engineered wood fiber that comes out of Utah, so that's hauled out of state. Some colorful characters that deliver those fibers. We end up having three loads, so we went above and beyond and added more than what we needed. We wanted to make sure the surface was entirely 12 inches across the total.

1:15:12 7,770 square feet. And then we also added, as you know, that area adjacent to the playground. We filled that area in as well. So that's kind of a full playground area that we can kind of look to enhance or utilize in the future depending on the multi-use facility. So we added, that was an additional expense that we didn't budget for. So you can see that's a $6,000 increase. You can see the community build costs were a little bit over there. We had to buy more.

1:15:42 Shirts. So we originally bought 40 t-shirts and I don't know how many we ordered in the end, it was probably like 200. So we obviously ordered a lot more shirts. We had so much donated through the community for our lunches, which is great, so we didn't have to buy a lot of our lunch costs, but just a lot of those miscellaneous costs, advertising, you know, all those type of costs that, you know, just...

1:16:06 Heat up a project. And then our project contingencies. So this is kind of where we set aside money for the additional concreting. The path, as we found out in the end, the install of the original playground didn't include the concrete install. So that was something that we purchased. So again, that's just some of those items that you think you have covered. But anyway, we got that sorted. And the path. So when you look at the path itself, the little asphalt path, the map that goes around that playground.

1:16:33 We came back and we saw cut into that and we cleaned that up, we patched that up so it butts up right adjacent to the playground. It's a seamless transition from the map into the playground, all those type of things, additional curbing. So we kind of added those elements during the project to make sure it was complete and safe. So just those items that it's hard to forecast when you're seeing the plan and what's in place on the site.

1:16:57 We're still a little bit under budget there, but you can see as the project will probably be right on or maybe a little bit over once it's kind of reconciled, but really good to see that project there. So any questions on that reconciliation at the time? Any questions for anyone on that? No. I think my only question is just so this does not include obviously, you know, the hundreds of hours of staff time. Correct. Which was, you know, more than anticipated. Yep. So donor recognition.

1:17:31 We talked about two types here. So we talked about during the build and post build. So I'll talk about during the build a little bit and then Lauren can finish that off and we can kind of talk a little bit about post build. So during the build was really kind of donor slash volunteer recognition. It's something that we felt really strongly about when we talked with the commission about incentivizing, you know, our community to come out and spend some time with us wearing a yellow shirt, putting a heart out and building a playground.

1:17:58 So a lot of the discussion back then was saying, well, let's kind of come up with some major prizes. So as, you know, every four-hour shift you work or a lunch shift you work, Lauren filled out the raffle ticket, put it in the little bin and each and every day we drew a name and, you know, they're one of those prizes, which was great. So that was kind of as it went throughout the process and then we had some major prizes that we were able to award, which is our TV, the Blues of Blues of Passes, which was wonderful, our pool passes, restaurant certificates and more. So that was something that we...

1:18:27 Believe, I think, added so much to the volunteerism and our community coming forward. The second phase of that, and I'll just start and then Lauren can kind of finish it off, is to look at producing this kind of welcome slash donor sign. I've got a little image here that we've kind of talked about this in the past. It's a two-sided sign.

1:18:47 So you can kind of see the front side would be, you know, welcome to Mammoth Creek Park Inclusive Playground. We would recognise our major donors and supporters of the project, which you can see here is the town, the Healthy Play Initiative, Mammoth Pacific Geothermal being all map. They contributed $75,000 to the project moving forward. Measure R, we recognise, you know, those funds, they purchased the accessible tile for the project, $19,750.

1:19:16 And then the Rotary Club and Mammoth Lakes came forward with a donation of $2,500 to the playground as well. So those donors will be recognised on the front and then you can kind of see we'll include kind of the playground hours to wrap up the front side. On the back side is kind of where Lauren's working on right now and the goal there is to kind of recognise essentially each and every person business that's been associated with that playground build and the project. So maybe Lauren can talk.

1:19:45 Yeah, so I'm working on, I've compiled a list of every volunteer, every business that donated to the project, our grassroots fundraising campaigns and birthday campaigns on Facebook. We have over 150 names on that list right now and I'm just going through them for accuracy purposes, making sure I'm spelling them right and this is how they want to be recognized. But we really wanted to...

1:20:14 Give recognition where it was due. And so everyone who came out or had a hand in this project in one way or another will have their name recognized on the back of the sign. So the intent right now is to not establish any kind of formal hierarchy for that list. It's basically alphabetized and everybody's in the same font size, you know, and we'll put everybody on the back of that playground. I really want to make sure that...

1:20:42 You know, we do recognize everybody for their efforts, and when everybody comes down to the playground, they can see the name and, you know, be part of that playground, because it was a truly... I helped build it, yeah. I built this playground. I mean, either time, money, donation, you know, whatever it was, you know, they were part of that build. So where we're at right now is Lauren's kind of finalizing that list. We get to design that in-house, so we'll do the two panels in-house, Heather Johnson.

1:21:07 We'll go ahead and kind of design that for us, which is great. And then we'll send that to Game Time, who are also providing a kind of discount for that sign as part of the project and our project sign. So I would say we would try and get this up in the fall. It would be kind of a realistic time. And right now it's going to be on that...

1:21:28 Corner. There's no corners in the playground, right? It's a rounded corner. It's a rounded corner. As close to the parking lot as possible where the other kind of park sign is, so it's going to be sitting out there where those kind of three concrete stumps as far to the side as possible. So, you know, you'll come up, basically all paths lead to that sign. So everybody kind of recognized right there. So that's kind of the plan with our donor recognition. How tall is the sign?

1:21:58 I don't know the exact specs, but it's large. It's probably at least six foot, a good six foot sign. It'll be matched the same paint burgundy color as the playground as well, and it'll be blended in, colorful, both full color panels on it. It'll be distinctive, I think. We're not planning to put lights on it or anything, but I think it'll be pretty distinctive there from the playground and certainly from the parking lot. I wonder why you didn't solicit donations from

1:22:29 The Bowling Center. I know the business is always willing to provide donations for prizes, gift cards, things like that. We might have. I can check my emails. We are still taking donations, so it's okay. They had a pretty comprehensive list. We certainly are, and I'll talk about that in Phase 2, if that's okay. I can kind of talk about what we're coming up with and kind of what that still means for the project. So we are not done. So you still have time to...

1:22:57 Excellent. Be part of it. Absolutely. So the second half of that as well is to, you know, recognize, you know, donors and supporters kind of in a more personal way as opposed to a sign. So what we've done is we've drafted several of these kind of canvas prints. We gave one to our outgoing Mayor John Wentworth, which is kind of the ribbon cutting photo that we have. And this is kind of our general...

1:23:26 You know, not so much general, but I think it's our proudest photo that's represented of our park. So as we talked about here, you can just kind of see the little list. We presented one to Warren already and his crew. We're going to present this to now the Recreation Commission. We're actually also going to send it to Stephanie Stevens, Executive Director of the California Parks Recreation Society, with some photos as well, because they're actually doing kind of what they're doing is their kind of park tour.

1:23:53 So all of these recipients that receive those funds through Game Time and CPRS, they put together a little roadshow and they're travelling around the state, you know, recognising those playgrounds. They weren't able to get to us because we're on that funny side. Funny side of the Eastern Sierra. We'll present one of these to Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:24:14 We'll also send the ribbon-cutting one to Paul Thompson from Mammoth Pacific Geothermal and then to the Rotary Club of Mammoth Lakes. We'd like to get to those meetings. So just a nice, hopefully, personal item that they, you know, feel proud of being part of and hang up somewhere in a prominent place. So I'm just going to come up and give this to the chair right now as the commission. Do as you will. Yes. So there you go. Congratulations. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. Have a nice film for this.

1:24:46 So thank you very much. Welcome. It's such a great picture. Fun photo. We had lots to choose from. So again, if you want to go through them, let me know. So I'm just going to move on to phase two, playground enhancement. So I have a little budget here of kind of what we're looking at. I'll talk about a little bit of the funding here. So we have a $75,000 pledge right now. We haven't received those funds. So right now we're in the planning phase for phase two.

1:25:19 We believe we'll have a budget of around $83,000. So that includes, you know, as we talked about the money before from the Rotary Club, which wasn't originally part of that budget that we talked about. So the 316 was kind of a separate budget. So these funds are all part of the next phase. We had a number of birthday fundraisers that kind of Lauren mentioned, Betsy and myself, you know, we...

1:25:43 It was fun. It was getting it out there and raising money for some great projects for the community, so that was cool. So we think Mammoth Lakes Recreation has about $5,000 to $7,000, you know, through those fundraising channels. So, you know, right now, once we get kind of a budget solidified as about $83,000, I'm putting together a kind of a scope of work at about that same amount. So you can kind of see what we're looking at here. You can see the playground welcome donor sign is about $2,500.

1:26:12 As I said, they're giving us a $500 discount on that sign, which is great. We've received some scope of work and estimates of cost for the concrete work. So what we're looking at here is to enhance the playground with additional accessible surfacing. So what we're looking at is adding the accessible surfacing from the existing kind of rectangle past the sandpit and around the merry-go-all.

1:26:39 So that merry-go-all is, as you know, is the highly most visited, most used apparatus on that playground. So we want to make sure in those areas there that anybody in a wheel device can get to that merry-go-all and get to the sand pit. I think that's a big part of it. And then the second phase of the accessible surfacing is coming off the back end of the park towards the restrooms where you'll be able to, in a wheel device, come off that multi-use path into the swing sets. So you can kind of wheel right up to those swings.

1:27:07 and Access the Swings, which again is a really popular amenity. So that scope of work we believe is about $74,000. That's kind of where we're at right now. We actually have a formal estimate of that work, so we believe we're pretty close. But again, what we'll probably do is look at publicly bidding that concrete work. And then we'll just go ahead and purchase the tile. We're also looking at those playground benches. As you can see, there's two trees that we've...

1:27:37 Left in the playground, which is great. So we want to put those benches that go around the circumference of the tree. Right now we've got a park bench in there, which is not the best, I believe, for that playground. So we're going to be looking at installing metal, formal, nice, long-lasting benches around those trees. So in those shaded areas, the parents can kind of be in those places with their child and kind of watch more secluded, hopefully in a shaded area.

1:28:07 We're going to be looking at adding an inclusive swing to the swing right now. Obviously, you see that down there is used every time, not appropriately, but we'll try and add an additional inclusive swing and the straps. That was something that we've received comments already, so we'll go ahead and put two sets of straps on those devices as well so the children can be secured to the swing itself. So that's around $82,000. Again, we're going to further refine the scope of work and the cost as this moves forward.

1:28:36 In regards to time, if it's part of a public bid, it does take time to put together. So best case scenario, depending on when we secure the financing and the funds from ORMAT, we could start this project in the fall or it could just be a spring project that we can kind of look at getting done at that time. Spring's always a little bit awkward because you just don't know how much snow we're going to get and how long that season is and those type of things. And then what we're also curious to know about is

1:29:04 which we'll talk on the next item about the multi-use facility and what that schedule looks like with that project. So we want to make sure we're all coordinating who's working when in that park and what's the best time to do these projects. So there will be an opportunity for additional donations that we'll be soliciting for for the second phase.

1:29:26 We'll always be willing to enhance that wonderful playground. So that's kind of where we're at with the playground enhancements. So really it's just putting it before the commission and just providing some comments, direction, or any thoughts you have on kind of what our phase two is. If you believe that's sufficient or you'd like to see more or some changes to it or timing-wise, any questions? Yeah, what's the plan for the extra wood fiber that you had to get that now you're going to remove?

1:29:55 Yeah, so that brings us up to the existing playground discussion. So we have a couple of playgrounds. One's in a storage container, and then we have the surfacing project at Shady Rest Park. So what I'd like to do is to, with, as we move into the new fiscal year, with the new reset of our funds, we can look at taking the excess from Mammoth Creek Park. And then with the sand, so sand is a compliant material, but it's not the greatest.

1:30:22 at Shady Rest Park. So the plan would be to remove the sand from that playground, put it in the volleyball pit, and then completely provide new surfacing at the Shady Rest Park. And that would, I think, add a lot more to that amenity over there as well. So that's kind of that second phase. So it's all kind of linked together. So that makes sense. Yeah. And I also feel like you maybe should have in the back of your head where you might put a second merry-go-all if it's that popular.

1:30:53 We've got that other little space right now, so that's something we... Yeah, absolutely. I think there's some opportunity in that area, just depending on what happens as we move forward with the Multi-Use Facility. And we did program it that way to provide us that opportunity, so if we don't have something happening for the next couple of years there, and we receive some donations and some funding, absolutely, that would be a great opportunity to add that, because it is extremely popular.

1:31:21 We could probably add one right now, but we'd probably have to take out those little bouncies. Can't get rid of that. I just can't see people being too willing to take out the bumblebee and the, you know. Those are classics. Yeah, exactly. Any other questions? Yeah, just out of curiosity, Stu, you know, when we were first looking at this playground and making some decisions about the EWF,

1:31:50 Rather than the accessible tile, we ended up taking away some accessible tile for cost savings, and that was a very difficult decision to make. If we take the EWF out and put in that accessible tile, what percentage of the playground becomes accessible at that point? We're providing accessibility to the inclusive elements that we believe will enhance accessibility, I'm saying that word.

1:32:20 Too many times, but you know what I mean, to those playground components, right? So the inclusive components was a big part of that playground, so we want to make sure that first and foremost we're providing accessibility to those inclusive components. That makes sense? The structure itself I don't think is a full requirement, you know, to having surfacing around the entire, but wherever there's an inclusive component, we want to make sure there's full accessibility. So as far as a percentage, it's probably a good third. You know, I don't know if it's up to a half.

1:32:50 I think it's a little bit more than that. Probably more than a third. That will be the, like, when phase two is done, we will have more than a third of the playground accessible. That would be my guess. I don't think so. My other guess would be that the other parts of the playground don't have play components on it, necessarily. So it's 7,770 square feet. But a lot of it is, you know, wood fiber connecting all of it.

1:33:20 So, using the multi-use pathways. I'd say it's a little less than that. I'm just so pleased we can roll into phase two so quickly. Right. I think, too, just to sort of follow up on that, it'll be nice also to have a little separation with the sand pit from the wood fiber. Right. With the addition of that tile, because that's a little challenging. Messy. Yeah, and we've had some, you know, if you've been down in the playground, a lot of use in that sand pit. You know, the accessible,

1:33:51 Digger is one of the bolts, you know, fell out a couple of times, so I, you know, take care of that. And then somebody thought it'd be great fun to empty the elevated sand pit, so, you know, they took out the bolt and the plug and, you know, did all that. So, you know, people are, you know, using it. So we're fixing those issues. And really, honestly, depending on how much we can get for our investment, you know, we would certainly just keep adding tile.

1:34:17 I mean, I think that's the goal with this project, right? So, you know, if we can extend the $50,000 cost that we think right now for the concrete base and just a little bit of history there, we originally had that pour-in-place material and we made that decision, right, not to pursue a pour-in-place because we're very concerned of its longevity and its reliability in our environment. So we went with us certainly a more what we believe long-term, you know, less maintenance, heavy.

1:34:47 Material with that accessible tile, and we can replace that accessible tile if we want. So if we want to come back in a few years and replace it with different color schemes, you know, we can certainly do that as well. I have a question about that as well, and I know, you know, with kind of moving to a public bid process for phase two, it becomes a little more challenging, but it's my understanding that the Mammoth Unified School District is looking at doing some tile to resurface their playgrounds. Will there be any opportunities for, you know?

1:35:17 Cooperation with that? They're in about a two-week window. Okay, guess not then. Yeah, we did originally talk about that. I thought that was a good opportunity, but based on where we're at with our timeline, I think we're... That makes sense. I did think it was kind of interesting that, you know, they took note of our use of the tile, so that was great. Yeah, so that project is they're going to replace all the pour-in-place materials that they have around their playground sites with this kind of concrete and accessible tile, so I think that's a good move.

1:35:46 And with ongoing maintenance, we might be able to pull our resources a little bit better in the future. Cool. Thank you. Do you want to talk a little bit about item number six? Yeah, so just six. So that, you know, we've mentioned it a few times on this item about the relocation of the Mammoth Creek Park playground. It's not something we're asking the Commission to weigh in on today, but certainly for a future item. Keep it in the back of your mind. We have done a little bit of enhancement down at Whitmore.

1:36:17 If you've been on the west side of the track, on the elevated area between the track and the baseball field, we've added some trees, some new benches and cleaned that area up. So it's kind of that default picnic area, which is the kind of a location for a playground. So when we did the original conceptual design, there is space for a playground there. So that's an opportunity that we can look at.

1:36:41 in the future for that site. And then certainly as the parcel discussion progresses, if that's an opportunity that we want to weigh in on relocating the playground there as well. So there's, I don't know if there's a sense of urgency or timing with the playground, but we probably would like to have something not in storage for several years, but I would think probably a, you know, 12, 18 month.

1:37:06 Kind of decision time and then we can start to talk about implementation. I think that would be a good thing to do. And then we briefly talked about Shady Rest Park. So that's kind of the plan to recycle the existing material, enhance that playground and then again enhance again the volleyball pit with additional sand because it requires a lot more than what we have. So that's item six. So again, fantastic project. We're so proud of it.

1:37:35 As I said, it's heavily utilised every day. We're not done. We're still going. We're very excited about the future and certainly excited about that park as a whole. I mean, you can really clearly see it's re-energised, you know, a lot of excitement. People will come to that park. It was already a great park and now we're just, you know, really making it better and there's great things to come. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions or comments for staff? I have just some...

1:38:01 Final comments. I was getting my nails done the other day, and my nail girl is talking about how she's rotating through all of her friends with kids so she can borrow kids to take to that farm. I mean, people are losing their minds over it. And I just want to just remind...

1:38:21 Thank you and praise you for all of your work and also remind the community that this is an example of the excellence that we're looking for. And to Sandra Moberly's comment at the beginning of this meeting, we're starting to see in town and on our commissions a culture of action. And I think that there's a real shift in how our community is starting to function and starting to make bold moves to make

1:38:48 Really excellent things happen. And this, I just want to remind everybody that this is kind of a scary number for a playground. It's a $300,000 playground that came together from the political will of council and the commission, from grants.

1:39:06 Thank you, Betsy and Stu, for working on that. From volunteers, which not only represented a cost savings, but also a pride in the facility and buy-in. And of course, major donors and other donations.

1:39:21 I understand that the new facility, which we're going to segue into, isn't going to be like the playground build, but there are some elements in there that I would love for the community to remember that sense of place, that pride of excellence, the community buy-in, and the will, the willingness to take bold action. And I just want to commend

1:39:48 Staff in particular and also Town Council and the political will to make this happen because it is something special and it's what we're going for when we talk about being the best recreational destination community in the nation. So thank you. Thank you. Well said. Well said. There's nothing to add to that. Why give those speeches every single commission?

1:40:15 It's part of my personal brand. Usually positive, occasionally reminding us why we are here. Just a quick question. Just being new here, what parcel were you talking about? Yeah, so Council, in an ad hoc way, the dais renamed the Shady Rest Parcel the parcel. So that's the new parcel of land we bought with the 25 acres in town to develop.

1:40:45 Workforce Housing. So they've renamed that The Parcel is kind of its working name right now. So formerly known as Shady Rest, now known as The Parcel. And a lot of that discussion, I don't know if we want to get too far ahead of it, but there is, you know, what does that look like? You know, how is that coming together? What type of general recreation amenities are we really talking about? So it's just kind of on a radar right now as it kind of moves along in a three to five year timeline.

1:41:14 That's kind of how we're approaching that. We'll be kind of tasked with that, you know, moving forward. So it's just kind of a top of mind item that we, you know, want to be aware of as it moves forward. Well, I think, too, I really concur with your statement that our goal with, you know, recreation equipment is not to have it languished in storage. So I think, you know, the sooner we can bring that forward, I think, the better. So, and just amazing.

1:41:39 Amazing playground. You know, a highlight of my summer was that, you know, I think most of you know my daughter was gone for most of the summer and when she came home and just being able to finally take her, you know, to the playground that, you know, we've worked so hard on and so she was very excited. So I assured her that I said, see, I said all the meetings I go to, sometimes you get something good out of it. So that was great. Any public comments on this item? Sandy Hogan and I just have to echo, I mean, Christy's comments really summed it up. I mean, it's...

1:42:08 It's amazing. I just walked around it and kept looking at it and just going, wow. And I hope someday we'll see that in all of our parks. This is a wonderful one for our community. I mean, it does focus on our community. But again, I think about someday when the community center is moved, and it will be someday. We've talked about it off and on over the years. What an attraction.

1:42:35 For our visitors to have something like that that they can see. They don't even know that the tennis courts or the nice playground we have up there is there. But if you can imagine someday having that up front and center, it would be just like that couple I told you about that owned a place in the village and just discovered the tennis courts after I don't know how many years. I mean, that is the kind of thing that really would...

1:43:01 Balance the Town and then maybe someday in Trails End when you swap out that, you know, or Shady Rust or whatever. But anyway, nice comments. They're right. Right on. Thank you. Thanks, Sandy. So just so you know, Laurel, we actually tabled items number three and four until we can have the full commission next month. And I will now move us on to item number seven, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities. Welcome back, Hais. Thanks, Betsy. So.

1:43:31 We went to Council last week on the 1st, gave an update on the project. There was a comprehensive presentation that I will just surmise shortly. We reviewed the Council direction from May 6th. That was, you know, a commitment to move the project forward to maintain all of the features of the project, maintain all the design aesthetics, not make any compromises on the programming.

1:43:58 and to continue looking at the alternatives through that lens. On June 6th, the Council directed us to come back with options for a project totaling no more than $13 million and incorporating comments given by the Recreation Commission and the Council that evening. We spoke about the project at our last meeting last month. We provided two alternatives because with the

1:44:25 The brackets of not changing the project, not changing the aesthetics and making it a $13 million project, there really aren't a lot of alternatives you can come up with that meet those parameters and anything less than 13 is just a derivative of the two alternatives that we provided. Council, we provided those same options to Council. We reviewed those in detail. Staff made a strong recommendation and I'll just quote it here.

1:44:55 If I can find it. I know it's in here. It's in your packet too. Everybody got that? The last slide on that presentation, which is the recommendation. So the staff recommendation, and council voted to approve this 3-1-1, was to proceed with development and construction of the multi-use facility, implementing a phased approach, beginning with the rink and roof alternative.

1:45:26 for a not-to-exceed cost of $13 million. Council also added to a return on September 20th with some options for a lobby, a lobby space to see what we can do there.

1:45:40 That's a pretty tall order considering we were ordering at $13 million, but staff is going to work with the architects to see if there is something we can do to add some more community space and some more restrooms back into the facility and kind of create that gathering space that was originally envisioned in the project. And Stu and I have talked, we've got a couple of ideas, but making that all fit for the price tag is going to be a challenge, but we'll give it our best and we'll be back at council to provide our findings.

1:46:09 That's just a quick summary, and I'm happy to field any questions you may have. So, Hayes, is it the expectation, I know our commission meeting here is on the 4th of September, do you think at that time there'll be anything for the commission to review a way in on, or is it really just... No, I mean, the council direction was clear as to, you know, onboard the CEM and move forward with the development and construction of the project, adding potentially some space for lobby or bathrooms or whatever components we discussed on the 20th. So,

1:46:38 Direction given to HMC Architects to start working on those plans, get geared up for onboarding a construction manager, pairing those two teams together and putting a path forward and hopefully by winter we'll be able to execute and not to exceed construction contract to, you know, get to work on the implementation of the project. And the direction at this time too was to maintain

1:47:08 The Olympic size, or if you want to just call in general terms, the programmatic, right, elements that we've gone through for the last several years, you know, through the commission with the playbook. So, you know, we are trying to retain, right, that Olympic size ice rink slash rec zone slash space that would enable us to deliver all those playbook components. Now, the discussion, I don't know, this time is to, you know, keep that whole.

1:47:34 I don't know, as this moves along, based on the $13 million in the direction from Council to add more space, will that, you know, cause a reduction in other sizes and spaces? And that's something that we're just not... We're not prepared to discuss. We're not prepared there yet, but, you know, that's going to be part of this discussion as we move through over this next, you know, month to bring back to Council, to fit within that budget. I think that's kind of the direction. So that's our goal as staff, and then we'll hopefully be able to kind of deliver that. Right?

1:48:04 I mean, we're not trying to touch any of those elements as best we can. Well, I think it's better characterized is that the council direction was to not touch those elements. We were directed to retain all the aesthetics, all the programming, all the design features with all the elements of the project and provide a phased approach to implementation with the first phase not exceeding 13. So staff has been working within those tight parameters to provide, you know, options to deliver the project.

1:48:33 And there was discussion, too, Council had on the community centre. So the community centre at that time is not part of this, you know, approach. Still considered as part of that phased approach, but as far as the rink and the roof concept, which kind of really comes back to where we started. So if you think of where we were, you know, three, four years ago, through this process, that was really the direction at that time to, once Council made that determination not to continue with the...

1:49:01 The school lease property and building a roof over there. You know, they went through that public process and the community efforts to identify Mammoth Creek Park. And then it was all about, you know, what can we deliver with this rink and the roof? And then as we worked through, again, that project, it expanded into a community centre. That was really speaking about the complementary nature. So that does, that project is still whole. It's really just kind of taking this in more bite-sized chunks is kind of where I believe the council's at right now.

1:49:30 to deliver that core rink and the roof concept if you want. It's not so bare bones that it's just the rink and the roof. It still includes all the amenities. It still has the four locker rooms. I know there was some narrative on the weekend in the paper about two locker rooms and whatever this. It's still the same that we've designed. It's still got the four locker rooms. It's still got the two restroom spaces between those locker rooms. It still has a family restroom in that building. The direction kind of spoke to a little bit about that, the social space.

1:49:58 The restroom and those kind of support amenities for that building, there's still a large 150 to 200 square foot public space, you know, under the rink for the public to use, which is adjacent, which is the prime, when you look at a, like an ice rink in winter or a rec zone in summer,

1:50:16 Prime viewing areas between the two blue lines, you know, it's kind of the center of the rink and out, so we still have that space available for that viewing area, we can still put bleachers in there, we can still kind of create that, you know, great viewing kind of social space as well in that area. So, you know, we're pretty close, like everything we've talked about, currently the chiller package, so we still have that upgraded chiller package in the design right now, so we're still able to look at

1:50:44 Making ice in September, if that's something that we move along, we make a decision with. We've had preliminary discussions with the Kings in regards to where we're at. They were aware of where we're at with the project. They were aware of what Council's direction was on August 1st. And they've committed to, with Brad, through ASC and his company, ASCC, to be part of any design input.

1:51:08 Through this process as well. So they're kind of, you know, informally involved, happy to kind of, you know, see something move along in this area. You know, where that goes, I'm not too sure, but as far as that kind of relationship, I think is still an opportunity to exist. So for right now, we're really focused on getting back to council with a project that we can kind of build for the price that they've given us, if that's a good summary. So with that, we'll send it back to commission. Questions for staff?

1:51:39 I just have some comments. I'm going to ask you to reserve your comments so that we can do questions first. Okay, questions? Okay. Any questions? Everything's a little quiet today. I've been noticing, Sandy, it's not just you. And since they made the adjustment at the beginning. Yeah, well, we can move them a little closer anyway. Sure. Thank you. Sure.

1:52:02 So this summer has been a little bit unusual for weather and smoke and things like that. And I know I've heard anecdotally that you guys have had to make some adjustments and things like that. How has the existing rec zone met or not met those needs? Have you felt a lack of having an inside gathering space for your camps that are punting during the smoke? That kind of thing. I'm just wondering how that has affected and how that will affect the programming.

1:52:32 Aspect of the design. Yeah, we briefly talked about this. The chair actually asked a question about how we've been kind of handling our camps. It's been very difficult. We're able to utilize the high school gym and the middle school gym when it's available, you know, based on their schedule. So, you know, it's not all the time. I think moving forward, you know, by having a roof is a big deal, you know, by dealing with a smoke is a little bit about this discussion that kind of we're approaching, you know, perhaps with a

1:53:02 I don't know if it's a fully conditioned space, but it's, you know, a space that's kind of enclosed that would provide that opportunity. So I can't speak to that, you know, specifically. But as far as, you know, the way the rec zone's functioning and the whole purpose of this, you know, building being the hub for our parks and rec camps, I think that's, you know, more than ever needed, you know, than what we've experienced in the past. How it deals specifically with smoke is... Right, I think some of the earlier summer weather was a lot of sudden thunderstorm activity, so a roof would go a lot to...

1:53:31 to help that out. I was just wondering how that, you know, this new normal that we have will play in. Yeah, and honestly, the Rec Zone primarily is that hub in summer will be a base camp, right, so all the kids will come and then go from there, but the opportunity exists to provide additional programming for those kids that, you know, don't want a full camp experience but just want to be able to kind of do a drop-in play or a kind of supervised activity.

1:53:58 That'll still be available and I think that'll be kind of well maintained and provide that opportunity. So that's kind of a big part of it. And then the afternoon drop-in free session for our kids I think is a big part. So once the kids come back from camps, they're still able to stay as long as the parents are willing to leave them with us. So none of that has changed from the playbooks.

1:54:22 Christy? I do have some questions. And I just want to preface my questions with some of these are just check-in questions. I know that we've discussed them before. And I just want to check in to make sure that the information is still the same. That is what it is. Because you know I'm apt to sometimes change my mind when I get new information. One of the questions I have, you know that

1:54:45 That my priority as a commissioner is year-round recreation for both guests and residents. And that year-round component is very, very important to me. And it drives a lot of my decision making. You also know, like Betsy, I'm a writer. So words matter very, very, very much to me. That's why I asked about phasing and sequencing. Like, what's the difference? There's no difference. Are we really looking at a roof and a rink with alternative?

1:55:13 One, or is this a rec center? Well, I think you're describing the physical infrastructure, which will operate as a year-round recreation center. Yes. Yes. That is correct. Yeah. So we're not just looking at an ice skating rink. Correct. Thank you. Can we start calling it a rec center? I already got beat up for the name at council, so we'll work on that. Thank you. Second question is, it got brought up at council about this thing between Olympic

1:55:44 Or NHL size? Are there potential cost savings with the NHL size? And also, would that affect programming? Would that affect our EIR? Would that affect our expense with having an architect go back and re-blueprint out everything according to an NHL size? Want to tackle that one? Yeah. So there would be some cost savings going to a smaller rink.

1:56:14 We've provided some estimates on what we think that could be, but it's a broad range because it would require redesign of the entire superstructure, redesign of interior spaces. So we think that could be anywhere from $500,000 to a million. Unless we do some really detailed analysis and structural work, we won't know exactly. Yes, that would impact the playbooks, the programming dramatically.

1:56:42 The whole idea of the Olympic ice is it gives us three courts cross ice, however you describe it, and all of that, we would lose all of that. And the direction from council was not to look at that direction. I know it's been discussed a lot by a number of parties and individuals, but the direction from council was not to evaluate that.

1:57:06 As far as fitting it within the EIR, as long as we're fitting within that box, that footprint, we'll be fine as long as we're not exceeding the dimensions or the offsets that were provided or anything that impacts the noise or visual or any of those various components will be fine.

1:57:26 And then my final question is, I just, you know, Stu, you talked a little bit about the King's involvement with being committed to part of the design. And one of the reasons why my comments were such about the playground is I understand and so appreciate council and the department's prudence with banking on money and grants that we don't have. But we've been in talks with the Kings for a very, very long time.

1:57:55 Their commitment to support this facility at a more monetary level could really help to offset the costs of building out a lobby. Otherwise, we're going to need some money behind that statement from Council, which is going to be part of my recommendation. Where are we on talks with Kings and their sponsorship commitments?

1:58:22 Pretty preliminary right now. So we've just kept the relationship and the contact with that organisation. They're aware of kind of what we're doing. I think that is a larger discussion with Ulterra, Mammoth Lakes Tourism again, to reinitiate those conversations. So that would be part of that sponsorship commitment. I do want to say that the Skiri is committed to a two-year sponsorship commitment right now with LA Kings. And Mammoth Lakes Tourism are looking at kind of a year-by-year.

1:58:52 Understanding kind of where we're at with the joint funds that they have. So that would have to be a decision. Once we get a firm, you know, I would say green light to go on the project. Once Council is satisfied with the project and then we are executing those agreements, then that's something that we would be moving forward with, I believe, in the future. So I don't know about a time frame, but

1:59:21 What I do know is that they've always been willing to provide any input and direction and I think a consultant such as Brad can provide any insight I think is highly valuable to us. They're also very much aware of all the other rinks that are going on around in Reno and Truckee and those type of areas as well. So they're still on our radar. It just depends on where the...

1:59:47 Where our project really goes and can, based on what we're designing, fulfill the demands and the needs of that organization. Thank you. Welcome. Did you have any other questions, Christy? That's it for questions. Any questions, Dan? I have a question of you before I get to the others. Is there an order in which we ask questions so I don't, like, jump in ahead of somebody? No, we just kind of skip around. So if you really feel, like, always feel free to just...

2:00:17 Dive in a few. I tend to, I usually, I go last. Okay, all right, good. Otherwise, it's pretty open. Step outside of any protocol here. No worries. So the first question I have is to clarify, do we need the Olympic-sized rank to put the center to its highest and best use as a multi-recreational facility? Is that larger rank needed to implement?

2:00:47 You know, the fullest amount of planning that you have in mind? Yes. Okay. And also, is it possible to, or are you already considering designing this so future needs and future development can be fully integrated into the rec center and the roof? So, is it being designed so that a lobby?

2:01:15 And maybe, you know, exercise rooms or whatever, you know, you might want can be added on incrementally. Yes. Okay. That question actually came up, Council Member Stapp asked that question about, you know, what is this wall? You know, originally when we had the social space, you know, coming into the recreation center, you came down some ramps into that space.

2:01:43 You know, was that a solid wall, permanent wall, whatever? Well, it's just going to be a wall that is, I believe, is flexible enough to be removed and repurposed and then to provide additional access to that facility. And there's also, I mean, it's a steel structure, so it's pretty broad, you know, in regards to it uses. So if there's a discussion in the future about how we want to, you know, petition it, seal it, whatever that discussion is, we talk about solar, you know, a lot of people talk about that kind of sustainability from that point of view, then

2:02:12 Those opportunities are available. So, you know, a lot of those are being taken into account. Yep. That's all I have. Good. So, any public comment before the commission kind of moves to more comments? Yes, Sandy Hogan. And I do have some public comments. I want to clarify a few things. I know that were in the paper and questions that I asked, and I asked Hayes and Grady afterward. The issue of alternatives.

2:02:45 I was assured that only two alternatives were possible, and yet maybe I come from an old school where I was formally taught that you always have as many as you can, including the no-action alternative. And I heard Jeff Posey propose the NFL-sized alternative, and every alternative has trade-offs, every alternative.

2:03:09 And the cost, and Dan would know this, I mean, Dan can ask some really good questions, having been built the Rock and Bowl, and I was told by somebody who had been on the Planning Commission a while ago that that was the only building they've ever passed the Planning Commission without change, and it was done perfectly, something like that, okay.

2:03:33 It does need a lot more questions. And I started hearing some of those from Christy, from Laurel. The trade-off, you know, proposed by Jeff Posey, one of the original ones pushing this, going to NFL size, maybe some of the program, you can't have everything. For less than 9.1 million is what we have. I'll talk about budget. The other four is hopeful. From who? We don't know.

2:04:03 Could be Kings, could be Measure U. Does that take away from more cultural activities? Recreation has always got the majority of Measure U. I'm sorry, I used to be on that committee too before it was dissolved and given to, you know, something out of sight of a lot of the public. These are the kind of things that it's wonderful to dream and then dream big. And we've all said, and I've heard you say it, do it right when you do it. And now I'm hearing it piecemealed.

2:04:33 And, you know, and Kirk abstained. I didn't, I went, why would he abstain? Because the first alternative was not good as written. And you do have to go back and add bathrooms, for instance, for the public and for, you know, not have them go outside. There were a lot of good questions. And I think with two new council members presenting that question to them, I think Kirk probably abstained because he couldn't really see it.

2:04:58 You know, as a lot of people can't. So your job is to ask the hard questions, not just serve as cheerleaders. Ask the questions and recommend trade-offs when you have them because we can't have everything. That is reality. The last few years people have been saying, oh yeah, we can do it all. Well, we can't. And now I've heard the community say our number one priority is housing. So that extra four million, I can tell you where I'm going to be coming from and a lot of them is not to

2:05:26 Plop it here or there. We've already mortgaged our Measure R, you know, bonded, I should say, and we're paying interest on it. So the longer this goes on, more frustrated the hockey people get. I feel so sorry for them. Yeah, a lot of their kids are going to be going to college, you know, before we get to this. The budget, you guys were given a hard time, a hard task. Get this under $13 million and still do it right and be sure we can add things on.

2:05:54 Put the restrooms inside, do the concession, and we don't have $13 million. We have $9.1. So you know budgets. And I guess what I'm saying is ask the hard questions now. That's what good commissions do. They don't just cheerlead it. We all want it. We all think that it should be done right. But how? It's the how. So anyway, that's all I'm saying.

2:06:21 I think a lot more public input is needed. I think you're right. The Rec Commission, before Dan was on it, even said, you know, maybe there's, I think one of you were quoted in saying you need more, we need to have the public really understand now the new alternatives and the budget and things like that. That means delaying it, yes. But it's better to do it right rather than piecemealing it. And now we're into piecemealing. So, and I heard that from MLR also.

2:06:51 I heard those comments. They supported Alternative 1 because Alternative 2 didn't give them much choice. But if you watch that on TV or the Granicus, you'll see there wasn't a lot of enthusiasm there. They recognized staffs being required to do something or asked to do something, you know. And Linda's direction was not, it was a direction to have the community center elsewhere.

2:07:20 Anyway, that's all. I'm just trying to clarify a few things. We just can't have it all. It would be wonderful to do it. To me, you know, Posey's alternative, the NFL size, or NHL. Sorry, wrong season. It's okay. Anyway, or looking at the existing site, which I know nobody wants to do. Okay, thank you. Thanks, Sandy. I appreciate your time and comments.

2:07:46 So before I bring it back to the Commission for comments and some deliberation, I know that this is a discussion item. So is staff looking for direction? Are you looking for comments to take back to Council? Kind of what are you asking of us? I think we're good. Yeah, so let me just look at the item here. I think it's our standing update, and then the action is really just to provide any, is what we say, any consensus comments or directions, right? So it's really up to the Commission in regards to the item. It is a discussion item.

2:08:17 Able to make any recommendations and direction to staff. So at this time, I think it's pretty clear what we're doing as staff to kind of keep this project moving forward. If you have any considerations you'd like staff to take into account as we move forward over the next month, what you'd like to see on September 4th, like you said, I'm not here, but it'll just be a standing item as well. So staff will be here. Hopefully Grady's here as well.

2:08:46 You know, talking about the item. So it's not going away. It's right in front of you. So whatever you're happy to provide at this time. All right. Who'd like to start? I actually have one follow-up question. What's the per square foot cost of the facility right now under alternative one? I don't have that with me. I could email that to you.

2:09:14 And is the per square foot cost the same for alternative two, basically? It would have to be, well, I don't know, maybe not. It's apples and oranges. When you're comparing and contrasting the two alternatives, it's not really the same. We're not looking at the same thing with the square foot cost. One is a building with an open, you know, center with foundations. The other one is a steel superstructure.

2:09:45 Thank you. I also have a follow-up question, if I may. Yes, go ahead. I was under the impression that we were going to have locker rooms and restrooms and a family restroom in Alternative 1. No outside bathroom going? Because that would be a mess. The plan is to winterize the existing restroom in the park. Okay. So it wouldn't be in the building. It would be just right there. Okay. I'm just trying to make sure that there are restroom facilities that would be available under Alternative 1.

2:10:22 And the answer is yes. And that was the direction again from Council was to further investigate additional restrooms and lobby space. But people aren't going to just go dig a hole out in the field. Correct. Okay, thank you. Well, let me ask a follow-up to that. The plan has always been to winterize the existing restroom as part of this project. Is that correct? Correct. So I would appreciate it if you could provide me with some square footage.

2:10:52 Cost, you know, somebody coming from the private sector that's built a large facility, you know, that's one of the most important things that we looked at. And I sometimes have a hard time being new to this process and as an outsider seeing why things cost so much when the government builds something. You know, we built our project for $234 a square foot. I just looked at the numbers again, and that includes a lot of expensive kitchen equipment.

2:11:22 Also, all parking, decks, patios. I remember reading some time ago in the sheet about the cost of a proposed government building, and I was kind of shocked at like $500, $600 a square foot, which doesn't include a lot of expensive, you know, interior design, kitchen equipment. So that's something that's important to me as somebody new to the commission.

2:11:49 to look at, and if I could get as much information on that as possible, it would be helpful. I would suggest that we find some time to sit down and talk then, because I'm going to provide you numbers and I'll need to translate them. Work in the private sector does not directly translate to the public sector. We have a lot of rules, regulations, prevailing wages, things that would not be readily apparent. There's a reason work in government costs so much more.

2:12:16 We just have a different set of guidelines, and we don't have the flexibility that the private sector does. So our costs are generally going to be higher. So I'm happy to sit down with you and walk you through that so that you have an understanding of why these things are and how we arrive at that. We have a lot of information, a lot of data, a lot of bid alternatives and tabs that we put together to kind of derive these numbers. So I'm happy to find some time and sit down with you. That'd be great. I'd appreciate that.

2:12:46 A greater cost. Sometimes things can be moved into other areas and kind of massaged a little bit so you get more bang for your buck and somewhere that's more appreciated by the public or by the planners. So that would be helpful. I'd like to see that. Yeah, along those lines, not to belabor this point, but that's why the staff is recommending the acquisition of a construction management firm.

2:13:14 They have a little bit more flexibility to navigate the environment than we do. We're held to a low bid in a competitive bid environment, which doesn't provide a lot of alternatives when we're trying to find a way to bring costs down or acquire resources or bring trades to the city. So that's one of our solutions is to onboard a company that can actually do that for us. But we can talk in greater detail.

2:13:43 Offline about that. Thank you. I know there's something we can provide Commissioner with. HMC did a quick analysis I think on the floor, sorry, in the site plan of the pavilion versus our kind of design. So there's been some numbers that they, that third party, did some analysis on to show where we were compared to their project on square footage cost and those type of things. So that might be helpful too. Okay, any other questions? Comments?

2:14:20 Christy, like, I'm ready to go. I've been ready to go, huh? I had a feeling. I have to say I agree with Sandy Hogan in that we can't have everything. And I, two years ago, one year ago, when I sat up on this dais and said we're going to do it right, we're not going to do it at all, that was my feeling, I still feel like that. However,

2:14:44 You all have seen me change my mind up here before, and I'm going to show you again, I'm going to change my mind. My mind has been changed by the playground example. It was so gut-wrenching to be looking at building an inclusive playground and not having accessible tile going to everywhere it needed to go. And yet, after the playground build, after taking bold action, after making some hard decisions, we're rolling right into phase two.

2:15:13 So I'm no longer convinced that phasing this project is a bad thing. And now what I'm looking forward to is how can we not compromise and sacrifice on programming and the integrity of this building as an excellent facility in phase one and then trying to set us up for phase two. I believe that the toughest question we can ask ourselves right now is if we are brave enough to take action.

2:15:43 Because it's really easy to, when things get scary, ask for more questions, ask for more options, abstain from making a decision. And I think that we're really in a place where we need to decide whether or not we're going to spend our time and money on creating alternatives, or if we want to start moving forward with a building that we have decided is exceptional.

2:16:11 If these bids came in two years ago, they probably would have come in around the $13 million mark, right? We've been thrown a curveball with tariffs, rising construction costs, natural disasters in California that make things expensive, whatever it is. But we decided that this was an excellent building. And then we decided that in order to maintain the excellence, we had to phase it. And what I would encourage council to do is to

2:16:39 Take bold and thoughtful action. I feel like with this particular facility, we've already taken thoughtful action, and now we need to take bold action. But that's going to require us to get real.

2:16:52 I love that Council wants to include a lobby and additional locker rooms and bathrooms, and I also want to know how much that will cost so we can be grown up about maintaining the integrity and excellence of this facility and not, to Sandy Hogan's point, start piecemealing things together and tacking things on and pulling away from different places.

2:17:16 I believe that phasing can work. I believe that we can have an excellent facility. But I also believe that, to Sandra Moberly's comment at the beginning of the meeting, that we need to continue to pursue that culture of taking action that we've already demonstrated with the playground. Not hide behind, I need more information, more budgets, and I'm going to abstain from making a decision. Let's take action.

2:17:44 Now, on building a facility we know maintains the excellence and quality we're looking for. Thank you. Who wants to follow? Christy. Okay. You're brave, Dan. You're having a great birthday. I've lived here for nine years now. It's hard to even imagine that. And I take a lot of pride in this community like so many other people do.

2:18:13 And when people come to town and visit me now as a resident, I take them on tours of the town. And there's certain things I show them, and there's certain things I don't, because I'm very proud of Shady Rest Park. I discovered that on my own, just driving one day when I was new here. Found this oasis out there. It's beautiful. It's fantastic. It meets all the standards of excellence that Christy's talking about.

2:18:42 I show them the library, the skate park, Mammoth Creek Park West before it was even renovated recently. One thing I don't show them is the community center. It's a tear down. There's nothing to take pride in over there at the community center. I've been in it for certain things. It's a worn out, tired old facility that we cannot really take pride in if we're aspiring to something better than that.

2:19:12 And the ice rink is nothing I've ever pointed out either. It's just nothing to write home about. If it's going to be done, it's got to be done right, and it's got to look great, and it needs to be something that we can take an enormous amount of pride in for a lot of reasons, for the local community members and also as resort infrastructure. I think the community doesn't understand the fact that this isn't just for a few hundred.

2:19:42 Hockey Players. It's for all the camps during the summer for our residents, but also for the resort guests that come here. And what people don't know, when I had my interview in that room, I was asked, what don't we know at the end of the interview? And I said, what you don't know is what I hear at my business. And that is that I meet a lot of guests, and they come in, they say, this place is great, and I hear it over and over again. I can quote it verbatim, Mammoth needs more.

2:20:12 Things like this. More infrastructure. There's a nice ice rink in Sun Valley. There's an ice rink up in North Star that's nicely located. I don't know if it's a great ice rink, but it's properly located. So we need to take this action forward. And now what is the best way to do it? And some people, I think people are confused about the fact that phasing and piecemeal seems like

2:20:42 It's just not the right way to do it because it's not going to be something that we can take pride in. But I think that if it's done right as an individual piece that is planned to be integrated with future development, I think it can be done perfectly well and it won't seem like some ad hoc piecemeal, you know, that's sort of a derogatory term, element to the community. If it stands alone and looks great,

2:21:11 With a future built into it, I think it can work just fine. You can look at the park as it is now with the playground as just the beginning of a greater park and nobody would know the difference because it looks great as a standalone element. So I support the phasing aspect of this having thought a lot about it. You know, we want the Porsche but we can't have it right now. So let's...

2:21:39 Buy something that's great and serves our purpose that then can be augmented later in a responsible way. As far as the rink and the roof or the rec center and the roof versus an open ice rink, I think that completely defeats the purpose of the original idea, which was to just put a roof over the rink. I don't think you can not have a roof over the rink.

2:22:09 It'll defeat the whole initial concept. So I support the alternative one if it's done right and it can be integrated well as a standalone project with future development. Thank you. Laura? So I agree with both of you guys, both your very well thought out comments there. I would, however, add to Sandy's point. Sandy, thank you for being here and always keeping us.

2:22:39 Moving forward and thinking thoughtfully about this stuff, that going back to what we said at our last meeting, the public, I don't think, is understanding all of these pieces. So while I don't think I need to see eight more alternatives, the public might need a reminder about why X, Y, or Z is not really a viable option. Keeping it there, not on the table anymore, is my understanding. Am I wrong about that?

2:23:06 We're not able to keep it where it is right now. That's not on the table is my understanding. I don't think the public understands that. So the original put a roof on it can't happen. What are we going to do? So I think...

2:23:21 Again, I think we need to, as we're moving forward, make sure we are engaging the public in an educational way and making sure that everybody understands what we're doing because, like you guys, I initially heard phasing alternatives. We don't want to go there. But I bought an empty sprinter van. I couldn't afford the sportsmobile. I didn't need all the bells and whistles of the sportsmobile. But I might end up there 20 years down the road when I've figured out, yeah, I do want.

2:23:50 You know, the cushy, cushy stuff. But I'm going to build what I need, and it's going to be very functional and usable and look really good because I was sick of driving the van again and it breaking down all the time, to Christie's point a few months ago about throwing more money after bad about your car. So I think that there's, I support the alternative one. I support moving forward with this project, but I again think we need to keep that.

2:24:15 Public Engagement and Education Aspect forefront of our mind and make sure that we are responding to what's being put out there in the papers and things like that so that we are staying a part of the conversation on all levels. I think that's going to be an important piece of this success. Whether or not the money comes together and how we phase, I think the public perception is a huge piece of this project.

2:24:40 Regardless of the programming, I would just say the rest of the world. It's not an Olympic-sized rink. It's an international-sized rink. That's what the rest of the world plays on. Are we just mammoth just here? No, we want everybody from all over to come here and use our facilities. For me, that's just a little piece of it. And it was driven home at the Olympics this year. That's what everybody else plays on. That's what everybody else is used to. Thank you.

2:25:07 I really appreciate everyone's thoughtful comments, and I agree with absolutely everything that has been said. I do just want to mention a couple of things, kind of putting things back into context. So the reason that I will always continue to support the international-sized footprint is that when we first started talking to Bend, Oregon folks about their project, the Pavilion, which is very similar to this one, when we asked them,

2:25:35 What's the number one thing you would do over? They said we would not build an NHL size sheet. It doesn't meet our needs. Our summer programming demand far exceeded our expectations. Don't do it. And I think, you know, we have all very much taken that to heart.

2:25:52 And I also want to mention that I think we've had incredible, not to mention free, you know, support, analysis, plan review from Brad Bierman at ASEC. I feel very strongly that, you know, there's expertise that's been made available to us that we're incredibly fortunate to have. And I think that's phenomenal that Brad remains willing to analyze, you know, whatever the next fate, you know, whatever the next design looks like.

2:26:22 So I also just I want to say that I feel like personally I feel like parks and recreation projects in general people because everyone in the public has a stake in what we do and feel such a sense of ownership and these are you know

2:26:42 In ways that, you know, the Planning Commission has a different kind of constituency. Our constituency is a lot of people that are not necessarily ever going to come to a meeting in Suite Z, but I think there are very strong feelings about our facilities because they're public facilities, and I think that's why, you know, sometimes this debate about this facility has gotten, I think, really heated and really personal, you know, in a way that I think has been difficult for us to deal with. I personally consider the commissioners to be advocates, not cheerleaders.

2:27:12 I think we do try to ask difficult questions. And I really want to echo Laurel's comments about the public understanding of this project. That's something I talked about at our last commission meeting because I was at council and just listening to some of the public comments, listening to some of the council member comments. We have got to do a better job of helping the public understand what this project is. I've had so many people ask me in the last week why there are no longer interior bathrooms or locker rooms, which is not the case.

2:27:40 And so I think we really need to do a better job of getting ahead of those kinds of questions as well as addressing the perception that this is just for a small percentage of hockey players. So I hope that when staff takes something back to the council in September...

2:27:56 And I know that HMC will, you know, take a thoughtful look at this. I know that Hayes is really devoted to making sure that, you know, we get what's needed out of this project. And I echo all of Christie's comments in terms of the facility and Dan's comments. And I really like the analogy about, you know, the sprinter van. Because to me, you know, I continue to advocate for this project because the needs that we identified haven't gone away. And if anything, they've become more intense.

2:28:24 I really want that message to get out there. So when we come back to council, I really hope that the council members understand that, yes, absolutely, we do want the lobby space. We do want some of these things. And I hope that staff will speak thoughtfully to why we've made the decisions that we have with the resources available. And that putting back some of these things, yes, absolutely, we all want that.

2:28:53 I think the important thing right now is to move the project forward and hopefully be able to come back and revisit those issues. I think with every project, I'm sure Dan has had this experience in terms of figuring out what to do once you're actually open and operating and what things could be changed and addressed as needed. But unfortunately, adding $3 million to this project is not an option that I can see.

2:29:19 I disagree with that. I think that if we have the political will from council, right, like they make the budgetary decisions and hand them down. And I think to Sandy's point about piecemeal, and I'm sorry, I'm like, you know how passionate I get. I agree with you about this. When we add requirements, it's going to cost more money.

2:29:43 So if council wants us to build additional interior locker rooms and bathrooms, I say, awesome. You know me. I want it to be the best. But where we're going to start to run into Sandy Hogan's concern about piecemeal design and also Dan's concern about piecemeal design is when we start adding things without adding budget.

2:30:03 So I would say to council, and I would also say, you know, if we can give direction to staff, if council is directing for additional lobby space and additional bathrooms, I want to know the additional cost. Because right now we have a good plan with alternative one in a phased approach to build something excellent and then build another thing excellent and have an excellent project. And the problem I see right now with this situation isn't that it's going to cost more money, it's that we want more without paying for it.

2:30:33 Sorry. I always feel like I'm yelling at you. Well, it's not good. So if council says we have an additional $3 million, we'll spend it on lobbies and bathrooms, right, if that's what they want. So let me pose a question to you. Yes, please. There's not an additional $3 million. I personally don't think the political will exist to make this a $16 million project. I think we've heard that strongly from the community, strongly during the election.

2:31:00 What you're saying is that, yeah, like, you know, the council should find the political will. What if they can't or don't want to and it stops the project? It shouldn't stop the project.

2:31:10 This is what I'm saying. If we want to stop the project by BSing around with additional budgets and piecemealing, tacking things on without growing up and giving a budget, then that is the will of council and of this, maybe of this community. But I'm here to take bold action with a facility that we've spent a lot of time thinking about how to make it great for this community. And yeah, if we're going to get...

2:31:36 Direct new direction from council that new council needs to have more money to give to the project, right? And if they don't have more money, please trust the work that has gone into this project for the past two years with me on council and more with the rest of the council and trust the process. Trust the process that alternative one is what this community and rec department needs and I trust.

2:32:02 In my heart of hearts after seeing the playground build that we can pull off phasing in this community because we have become a community of taking action. But yeah, if new council wants to just throw it all down the crapper because they want it all and don't want to pay for it, well, let's see what happens. I don't agree with it. And I think you meant to say commission, not council. Council.

2:32:31 I think this is a big deal. I think this is a big deal and it requires passion and it requires action and it requires some bravery. Dan? I think it also requires a little more information. This is why I'm asking about per square foot construction costs because certain things cost more than other things to build and I just don't accept these generalizations about it's going to be this much money to build something because if we, you know, you can research it.

2:33:00 Cost per square foot is, and I'm talking private sector, so let's just assume it's going to be more expensive for the government. You can research what it costs to build a warehouse in Los Angeles. It's about $100 a square foot. It's just four walls, a couple doors, and a roof. You can research what it costs to build a commercial kitchen, what commercial construction is versus residential, high-end homes versus middle versus low-end homes.

2:33:29 And I'd just like to know what each feature of this project is going to, because it can't be broken down. A lobby should be not that expensive. But tell me where I'm wrong. You're talking about a budgetary alternative, which is different from the programmatic and project alternatives that I've heard people calling for. Asking for additional, you know,

2:33:53 You know, an additional scope to the project, additional functionality, additional facilities is a project scope. What you're asking for is how is the budget going to shake out in these different scenarios, which I don't disagree with. But let's not confuse asking for budgetary alternatives and asking for project alternatives because they're two different things. No, I would agree entirely. I'm just saying that I support moving forward with

2:34:20 Alternative 1, as you want to do, as we move through this process, I would just like more information about how this is being priced out under any alternative. And if we're going to phase in a beautiful new wing to the project that's planned ahead of time, I'd like to know what that's going to cost and why. Reasonable. But still, I would say, and I know that this is a little bit outside of our normal protocol, but I would say to the public, to

2:34:49 Commission to staff that I don't disagree with asking for budgetary alternatives or square footage or what it would mean in cost savings for a construction management project. But when we get feedback saying, you know, we want alternatives for placing it someplace else or a different type of building or this or that, or we want more than two project alternatives.

2:35:18 I am philosophically and fundamentally at this 11th hour against going back to the drawing board as a commissioner. So I think that goes back to kind of, you know, Laurel's point and my point and I think all of our, you know, some frustration, frankly, you know, the lack of understanding of the project, you know, in the public and that's something that we've asked council to address, we've asked staff to address. I would encourage every member of the commission as well as any interested member of the public, absolutely seek out staff because I think that Hayes can answer.

2:35:47 Every question that you're asking. He's been great about sitting down, reviewing plans, and I think staff very much values our input and expertise. So I would encourage everyone, also in the public, to take the time to do that. If they have questions about the project, the staff has made themselves very available. So I think we've made our direction fairly clear. Thank you. Very good. Thank you very much. Can I make one more point, Betsy?

2:36:13 I want to dig deeper into what you said about the playground and seeing as now it's happening, this second phase. So in fundraising, we talk about this mystery four million, where is it going to come from? A lot of times you don't get it until you've got it. You know, you've got something on the ground that they can tangibly see. So I wasn't involved. I don't know anything about those ORMEC conversations, but...

2:36:36 They might have said, hey, here is something tangible we can put our stamp on. And so once we start this project, that might be the impetus that needs to happen for MLR or whatever, however it works out, to go secure those, oh, now Bill Gates is going to give us $4 million to put his name on it, you know, or whatever it is. And Matt McLean has said that in past meetings. So I think that's important to remind, again, the public and...

2:37:03 Everybody who's, where's this money coming from? I'm not saying it's there yet, but I'm saying that a lot of times in this world, you won't see it until you've already got something happening. Yeah, I think that's a really good point. I think that's definitely was our experience with the playground. Okay, so I'm going to move us on.

2:37:21 There's more? Yes. Aren't you glad we tabled a couple of items early on? So our next section for Dan's benefits is Commissioner Reports, and this is the Commissioner's opportunity to mention any meetings they've attended, any things they've noticed at facilities or parks, relevant conversations with members of the public. So this is your shot. So, Laura, why don't we start with you?

2:37:46 Great. So I want to thank all of the town staff and chamber folks that made such a great Fourth of July parade. I was in the back this year, so I didn't get to see all of it, but I had heard great things, and it was really well done. So thanks to everybody who made all the Fourth of July celebrations great, but I participated in the parade. I also want to thank everybody for your support of the Sierra Cycle Challenge last weekend, two weekends ago now, that did a great ride around the area in very smoky conditions, but we had

2:38:15 Police Escort, In-N-Out, and lots of folks out there cheering for us and a lot of community donors, so thank you to everybody who participated in that. And a recurring theme in my reports, I attended the Trek Dirt Series up at the mountain.

2:38:30 Excellent mountain biking camp. I highly recommend anybody at any level of mountain biking seek out one of their camps. It's a great experience. But it reminded me how mountain biking is such a great sport for all shape, sizes, and ages and that we should keep enhancing our community biking options in this town. So we can all get out and enjoy with the e-bikes and everything. Just I think it's a great thing. So next park? Question mark?

2:39:00 Fabulous. Thank you. I'll have Christy go next. I attended the MLR meeting, was it on June 27th? With Betsy, Chair Truax, and staff, Director Stuart Brown. I also attended the playground opening on the 4th of July, which was just amazing. And then I also, last month, met with incoming Council Member Linda Salcido, and also

2:39:30 Scott McGuire from both MLT and MLR to actually get feedback about and discuss some of the alternative options for the Rec Center. So we had some good conversations and some catch and pitch for questions and asking some questions of each other and batting around some ideas. Thank you. Pam?

2:39:57 And it's okay if you don't have anything to report. I don't have anything to report. You got appointed to the commission. That's a pretty exciting thing. Other than I'm happy to be here and to be involved. Great report. Thank you. We're happy to have you. We're really pleased.

2:40:13 So I don't have much to report other than what's already been mentioned. So thank you to everyone. I have been having some conversations with Paul Romero. He is the trainer for the California Association of Parks and Recreation Commissioners and board members, the board that I serve on.

2:40:34 And that organization has never done a training in this region of California and has quite an interest in offering one. So we're actually looking at some dates in October that I'll have Stu send out to everyone. So think about, you know, if you have an interest in this type of a training, commissioners from all over the state would be invited to attend.

2:40:57 Cost to us would just be providing lunch and refreshments. So we can have some more conversations about that. But we could also consider bringing in MLR. So I think what I'll do is have Stu send out kind of some information about what this would entail. And you guys can decide if that's something you'd like to move forward with and which of the two proposed dates in October we could have the most commissioners attend. So that's kind of the main thing.

2:41:22 From my perspective. So I will move us on to request for agenda items. I know that Stu will be not here in September, but we do have a couple agenda items to have. Yes, so we'll be scheduling items three and four with our full commission. We'll have our monthly report. We'll certainly have the multi-use recreation facilities update. That's just a standing item.

2:41:51 And then as needed, we'd bring back the playground. I don't know if that might be a bit premature at that time, but that would be as needed. So that's kind of our agenda at this time. Okay. So during this section, the commissioners can also request anything that they would like to appear on future agendas.

2:42:11 How heavy the agenda is coming up. It might be on the next meeting. It might happen further down the road. So that's a pretty full meeting, I think, especially since we'll most likely have Grady Staffing Commission that day. So is there anything anyone would like to look at adding for a meeting not in September? Yes? I'm just curious about our disc golf update. I know that we've had some good news and we have a very...

2:42:38 Collaborative for a supervisor now, so pretty excited to hear if there is any update on the disc golf. I could tell you at 2 o'clock. We're actually meeting the new recreation supervisor at 1 o'clock. Wonderful. With Joel and our little team, so we'll see kind of where we're at. It's exciting stuff. Yeah, we'll do. So that'll probably be just part of the monthly report, if that's okay. I can kind of add a section there for you. That's fine. Great.

2:43:07 I just want to reiterate the couple of things that were on our minutes from last meeting, the deferred maintenance drone discussion and user conflicts at Volcom Skate Park. Make sure those don't fall off the radar whenever they can fit in. I don't think any of them are urgent, urgent, but thank you for the maintenance. Thank you. Okay. That sounds good. So if there's nothing further, I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting here on September 4th. Thank you. Thank you all. Great meeting. Yeah.

2:43:44 You like that? Yeah.