TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2018

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 1 hr 36 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

222 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:19 Yeah, so the first couple of years were pretty hectic. But now you've got smooth sailing now. Yeah, two and a half years in, it was like, okay, I'm going to start taking some time off, some vacation, this, that. And yeah, the last couple of years has been pretty normal. Well, thanks for being here. We're happy to have you. So Christy is ill and won't attend, but the rest of us are here. All right, I'm ready to go when you guys are.

0:49 Okay. Good morning. I'll call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, September 4th, 2018. Roll call, please, Jamie. Commissioner Martin? Here. Commissioner Arner? Hello. Chair Tourette. Here. Although we have no members of the public present, do staff or any commissioners have any public comments? No. Okay.

1:23 Seeing none, I will move on to the consent agenda. Is there anything anyone wishes to pull? No. Okay. I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I have a motion. Is there a second? I'll second none. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor of approving the consent agenda, items number one and two, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay. Motion passes 4-0.

2:02 Okay, so that will move us on to the discussion items. Item number three is our annual selection of chair and vice chair and appointments to the ad hoc committees. So at our last meeting we tabled this item because we only had three of us here at the beginning of the meeting and then Laurel was able to join us.

2:21 You guys wish we can proceed with these. Christy, unfortunately, is ill and unable to join us, but she did text me a couple of items. So it's the pleasure of the commission, whether we want to proceed with this or table it until next month. Did she have any comment on the selection? Her only comment was that she would like to continue on the MLR committee. So anyone have any strong feelings? I can go either way. That one's not even on the...

2:52 List of ad hoc committees, or is that the program? That's the, yeah, the Recreation Project Committee. Project, okay. But we do actually decide the appointments for the ad hoc, correct? Correct. At present, it's Christy and myself. What other ad hoc committee appointments are there? I know I'm... The programming committee. Okay. Which is currently us. You and me.

3:18 So we're discussing whether we're discussing it today or putting it off until October. Correct. So we can either proceed or table it to next month. I guess I need a little more education about what these committees are and what's expected. So both are in the staff report. So we have, first of all, the appointment of the chair and vice chair, which I think are fairly self-explanatory.

3:48 Previous summer's programming analysis and to assist in the development of there's an annual programming calendar. And so typically that committee meets at most two or three times and then reports back to commission. We haven't really met very much, right, Sean? We meet a couple times a year and Dan, that might be something you might be really good at if I may actually throw that out there. I've enjoyed it and, you know, I'm not...

4:13 Walking away from it at the same time, I just want to say that that actually would be something that you might be a really good fit on because specifically it's working with Stu and staff on, you know, what are our summer camps going to look like? What's the recommended pricing on the summer camp? You know, obviously that all comes back before the recreation, before the commission, but at the same time, it's, you know, taking a look at everything that they do just on programming, whether it's winter, summer.

4:42 Yeah, and they also, the department also surveys all of the participants in all of our programs, and so that committee receives and reviews all of the surveys that come back in and can use those to, you know, kind of make recommendations to staff, which then go in the staff report that's reviewed by the commission. And then the MLR, Ad Hoc Mammoth Lakes Recreation Project Committee, is tasked to meet with staff and board members of Mammoth Lakes Recreation to discuss project ownership, tasks, and responsibilities, along with funding.

5:11 Fundraising Opportunities, Plans, and Implementations. I'm sorry, but Christy, and Christy is that? Christy and I sit on that one currently, yes. I'd be happy to participate on the programming committee. Okay, so before we do that, do we want to proceed with the appointments? Or do we want to wait till all five of us are here? I don't feel strongly either way. I feel like we're ready to, but I also feel like if we want to try to have all five of us here, I don't know of a strong reason not to wait. Okay. And that works for me too.

5:42 Okay, so then let's start with Chair and Vice Chair then, and we'll just kind of go through these. So thank you. Just hold off on that for a second. So I'm going to start with Chair. Well, if I may make, and I should be turning this off, a wholehearted recommendation that Betsy Truax remain Chair of this fine commission. That would be my... I would second that.

6:06 Okay. Thank you. Thank you. I am willing to continue for at least the next two years, and then, I don't know, it might be good to have someone else take over at that point. But for the next two years, I am in. Thank you. So I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion on the chair? No. Okay. So all in favor of appointing myself, Betsy Truex, as chair, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed?

6:36 I will abstain, so the motion passes. Three, two, one, abstention. Thank you very much. Excuse me. Okay, so next up is Vice Chair. Sean currently serves as our Vice Chair. Anyone wish to make a motion? Or should we have some discussion?

7:01 Do you want to continue as vice chair? I enjoy it. I've got to tell you, it's a pleasure working next to you, Betsy, on this. I don't think I have had to take over for you once, have I? Because really the vice chair is just really sitting in if you're not doing it, right? Pretty much. Yeah, and occasionally if we have to have a special meeting with staff or something, it's kind of the chair and the vice chair are the automatic. Other than I get the word vice in front of me, that's it.

7:31 So, okay. Is anyone else interested in serving? I mean, Sean's done a great job, so. If Sean was looking to step down, I would certainly raise my hand, but I am not looking to usurp any seat or anything like that. Just want to make sure that the commission is well served and you are doing.

7:50 Well, thank you. And likewise, I would be willing to, you know, I think in the next two years, I'd probably be willing to move on from that because I think it is important. You know, it was two years ago where I was, and I want to thank very much for actually encouraging me. There was a time where I was even looking at exiting the commission, and I'm frankly glad I stayed on. You know, I'm really glad to have Dan involved and Laurel and Christy.

8:18 Yeah, I'm comfortable with that for the time being. And then when we get to the ad hoc appointments, I definitely am willing to make some, happy to make some changes there. Okay, that sounds great. Well, I will make a motion to nominate Sean Turner to continue as vice chair. I'll second the motion. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Okay, all in favor of appointing Sean to remain or continue as vice chair, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed?

8:47 And I will abstain. Okay. Motion passes with three ayes and one abstention. So nothing changes there. It's interesting doing this to an empty room. I know. I mean, I guess I could ask the staff for public comment, but...

9:05 I'm assuming they'll leave or something if they have any strong feelings. Okay, perfect. And Laura, I would love to see you take a leadership role kind of going into the future. So let's definitely revisit that the next time we do appointments.

9:18 So the next one is the Recreation Programming Committee and the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Project Committee. And I have to say, I very much have enjoyed serving on the Programming Committee. However, in the interest of getting some new people involved, I am certainly willing to remove myself from that committee. I think especially in light of the fact that we have a lot more programming kind of for young adults, and I'd really like to see more commission involvement in that with all, you know, the...

9:48 Volleyball Leagues and things that are going on. So I could definitely see both Laurel and Dan doing a really great job on that committee. So, but I mean, if you're willing, I don't know what your thoughts are. Oh yeah, here's what I'd like to say is, you know, I think that in the past, Betsy, you and I have taken it on because you and I, not only for this reason, but because you and I had kids that were coming up through the ranks that were attending so much of the programming. Great, you know, very helpful, love being part of it, but I could easily step off for,

10:17 Both of you and Christy as well. Absolutely no problem. It's only a couple hours a year. Really, isn't it? Very minimal. Yeah. That sounds fine to me. I'm happy to volunteer. I would love to be a part of that. Great. Then I would nominate Laurel and Dan to be our appointees to the Ad Hoc Recreation Committee Programming Committee. And I will second that. Okay. A motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye.

10:46 Can we get away with it? Yeah, you guys will have to at least one of you. I abstain from the vote myself, but aye, Laurel. Yeah, I will do the same. I will abstain from the vote for myself, but aye for Dan. Does that make sense to you, Jamie? Yeah. Okay. Motion passes to appoint Laurel and Dan as our representatives with three votes and one abstention for Laurel and three votes and one abstention for Dan. Great.

11:14 Okay, next up is our ad hoc Mammoth Lakes Recreation Project Committee and Christy and I have served on this. I know that Christy is willing to continue serving and I am also very interested in continuing to serve on this. However, if someone else is really eager to jump in, I would, you know, that would be fine too. So is anyone really dying to serve on this particular committee? What is involved?

11:39 So most recently, this committee met mostly about the playground. So I think we were meeting maybe once a month. So there's two representatives from the commission and two representatives from MLR who have been Tom Johnson, the chair of MLR, and Heather Schaubmeyer from MLR, along with our staff. So Lauren has participated in those meetings. Grady has participated in those meetings.

12:09 Part of our strategic work plan is kind of better engagement with MLR. So that was kind of the first step that we took was just getting everyone together regularly. And we made it really project specific just because that seemed like the best way to engage. And then let's see.

12:32 So Dan, they were sitting down figuring out who's in charge of what and how are we going to be on the same page to message all of this and those kinds of things was what they reported back to us on, I should say. Yeah. And I'll say this too is that, you know, I honestly feel like MLR, if it is doing what it's supposed to be doing, can be one of the most exciting.

12:55 Parts of what's happening in this town. You know, I make this analogy kind of regularly, at least myself, and I don't know if many people view this, but, you know, if this town were a company, I really view the MLR more as the research and development arm of creating new opportunities in the field of outdoor recreation. You know, our job on the Recreation Commission job is to

13:17 Program that once it kind of gets taken over by the town. You know, hopefully ML Tourism is our sales department really out there pushing it. Chamber of Commerce is making sure people have good experience when they're here. So hopefully all of these, again, I'm speaking individually, this is how I like to view it. So I think it's really important that as a representative from the commission here that we'll ultimately be programming a lot of these things once they come online. I think it's our voice, our contribution to that organization is very important.

13:46 So, you know, I've enjoyed the report outs that you and Christy have done. So, yeah, I'm supportive of those two, of you two continuing to serve on those. And Betsy, correct me if I'm wrong, but is it both of you together or is one of you more of a backup? No, it's both of us. There's no alternate. Alternate, that's what I was trying to say.

14:15 Okay. Grady and Lauren, do you guys have anything to add about that particular committee? Okay.

14:22 One of the reasons that I'm particularly interested in continuing to serve on that committee is because I was on the formation board for MLR. And I feel really strongly about the opportunity for some fundraising, especially in light of our many financial needs. And, you know, as a dedicated nonprofit, it's not unusual for towns to have something like a parks foundation. I know that when I think about my charitable giving, the town of Mammoth Lakes is not necessarily at the top of my life.

14:51 list, but a dedicated non-profit has, I think, some other opportunities to engage in that work, and I would like to encourage that organization to really engage in that work, because that was a very critical piece of that formation. Anyway, so that being said, we could certainly appoint an alternate, should Christy or I be unable to attend, or we can just do it very casually, too, so that if one of us can't be there, we can just have Stu see if somebody else can come.

15:19 And so you're interested in continuing. I am, yeah. And Christy. Christy is as well, yeah. Okay. I'm comfortable making a motion that you two continue to serve on as that liaison ad hoc committee. I'm going to second the motion. Okay. And Dan, it sounds like that's something you might be interested in in the future. Eventually. Okay.

15:43 Sounds good. Again, we won't formally appoint an alternate, but we can certainly, you know, certainly if one of us is not able to be there, it's good to have commission representation. So I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? No. All in favor of appointing Christy and myself to the MLR Project Committee. Aye. Any opposed? I will abstain since it's myself, but thank you very much. I'm excited to continue in that role. Okay.

16:14 Okay. That was critical stuff. So, but yet nothing has changed. Right. Well, except for now we have two new appointees to the programming, which is great. Right. Thank you, too. Okay. So that brings us to discussion item number four, which is the regular meeting schedule and annual recreation commission and work plan calendar. So, Grady, do you want me to talk about this or do you want to give any kind of a staff report?

16:40 I have gone through the calendar, went through with Stu last week, and it looks like all the items are on here that we know about at this time. I'll expand on a little bit, but that's really part of item number five, so there's no real change there. It just looks good. So the first thing that we need to do is establish a schedule of regular meeting days and times.

17:03 And then approve the commission meeting and work plan calendar. So I know that we've had just kind of some more informal discussion about whether meeting at 9 o'clock on Tuesday morning best serves the community in terms of public input. And Christy did send me kind of her preferences. So does anyone feel strongly about either remaining or continuing in our current time slot?

17:30 I will just say that I prefer this time slot, but at the same time, we also need to weigh that with the needs of the community being able to attend this event because we don't have anyone in the audience. Would we have more in the evening? I'll tell you that when we did have it in the evening, it didn't feel like we had that much more participation.

17:50 So I think that it's critical that just when it comes, but I want as much, you know, I feel like I'm inviting people all the time. You know, but I understand, I also get it that it's important that the public understand what we're discussing so they're not too bored attending things that when something that doesn't interest them come before us. So I'm just going to say, I don't.

18:13 I don't know if there's been much of a difference when we had it at 5.30 or when we had it before from 6 to 9. Yeah, we had it at 2, and I don't think there was. Yeah. I mean, it was kind of the same usual suspects. So I could go either way. I'll tell you, I personally prefer this time in my schedule. Laurel? It's not about me. I kind of feel similarly. It works for me. I've made it work for my schedule.

18:40 You know, with rare exceptions during the workday tends to be better for me. But again, we rarely have hordes and masses here. So it'd be nice to make sure we are available at a time that would encourage that. But, you know, I tend to go with if it didn't work before, I'm not real sure it's going to work again. But that doesn't mean we couldn't try it again. Let's try a different time. I just know this room is kind of a hop.

19:10 Commodity and finding a consistent time slot might be tricky. Yeah. I don't know if there are any available other than this. Yeah, we'd have to look into that. I mean, I know that if we wanted to move from Tuesday morning to Tuesday evening, then we'd be running up against typically MLR also meets on the first Tuesday of the month at five o'clock. So we'd have to kind of look into what day of the month we met. Arm wrestle them for sweet seeds. Dan, do you have any strong feelings about our meeting day and time?

19:38 Well, it's interesting to hear that you have tried other hours, and it hasn't made much of a difference in terms of participation. Personally, my own schedule. Nighttimes, I typically work in the evenings. Nine o'clock is pretty early for me if I'm at work until 1 or 2 a.m., which means getting to sleep at 2 or 3. But I'm not...

20:07 Doing those late Monday nights that much anymore. So, you know, 9 o'clock, I mean, 1 p.m., maybe people would come during lunch hour, I don't know, 1 to 3, but that's just my thought on it. I'm fine with it the way it is, but that's my feedback. Okay, and what Christy said this morning was, Wednesdays and evenings are difficult for me. Mondays, Thursdays, and Fridays work best.

20:34 But she can continue to make Tuesdays work. Can we, and you've had your hand on the button. Did you want to see something? I just, whenever you guys are done, I just, a staff comment. I'm talking to Stu, this time does work. With council meetings, typically on Wednesdays, being able to at least get some input from Rec Commission, even if it's just the day before, is very valuable. And the morning is better for that, because if we got input at 3 o'clock and had to write something up for council the next day, that's a little more difficult. The other comment I had is that I,

21:05 My impression from staff and seeing the people here is it's not that they're bored. It's really, believe it or not, what I hear in the community is they really think you guys are doing a good job in handling it because they say, oh, yeah, the programming is great, so why should I go? So unless there's a specific topic, they don't come for regular business because they really, seriously, in being out in the community, they just think you're doing a good job. So it's not so much being bored. It's just, well, yeah, they're handling it. So that's all.

21:32 My personal preference is I prefer mornings. I found that when we met at 2 in the afternoon, it was very difficult because that's around the time kids are getting out of school. So I find that we have a little bit more luck drawing people in in the morning time, depending on the topic. You know, school gets out at like, what, 1.40, 2.45, and now 3.05 for the middle school, I think, right? So, you know, so those are, I find, kind of.

22:01 It would be challenging hours. So I don't know. It sounds like we kind of have consensus to really continue with this and maybe we revisit it in a few months. I'll make a motion that we keep it at the same time, Tuesdays, 9 to noon, first Tuesday of the month, except for when we need to make changes. That's my motion. Okay. I have a motion. Is there a second? I second the motion. Okay. I have a motion and a second on our meeting day and time. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye.

22:30 Aye. Any opposed?

22:33 Okay, motion passes 4-0 on that. The only comment I'll make on that is that, again, we continue to do, and I think we do a pretty good job, is that when big issues are coming up, whether it's, you know, like the youth sports funding or, you know, any kind of vote on a recommendation that we are going to be making on something as important like the MUF or anything like that, that, you know, we continue to advertise it as much as we can to the community, which I think we do a pretty good job on. The evening workshops that we do schedule every now and then, frankly, those are well attended.

23:02 When we need to have those. And so I think we've got pretty good schedule. Yeah, I agree. And I think doing things like the youth sports funding workshop in the evening has been very well received and very beneficial. So I think we can certainly have, you know, schedule meetings and workshops at those times as needed.

23:20 Okay, so then on the calendar, so I did want to talk about one item on the calendar, which is the October 6th special meeting. And I know Stu put out an email asking whether people preferred the 6th or the 13th, and then Paul Romero, the trainer from CAPRCBM, had a conflict and asked that we do it on the 6th. So I'm sorry, Laurel, because I know that was not your preferred day. But I wanted to just tell you guys a little bit about Paul and exactly what this is.

23:50 As members of the California Association of Park and Recreation Commissioners and Board Members, we are entitled to have this training at no cost to us aside from providing the lunch and refreshments.

24:10 And so to tell you a little bit about Paul, beginning his professional career in 1970, Paul Romero is currently retired from serving as the Executive Director of the California Association of Park and Recreation Commissioners and Board Members. Paul is a Park Commissioner for the City of Folsom, California, and in 2004 was appointed by then-Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to Chief Deputy Director of California State Parks. Prior to that appointment, Paul was Chief Administrative Officer of the Santa Clara Valley Water District Director of Environment.

24:39 of Environmental Services Agency for the County of Santa Clara, Parks Director for the County of Santa Clara, General Manager of the Riverside County Regional Park and Open Space District, Parks Director for the County of Riverside, and Adjunct Instructor at several California State Colleges and Universities. He is recognized as a leader in the Parks and Recreation profession and has received numerous state and national awards.

25:01 In 1993, he received the Distinguished Alumnus Award from State University, Long Beach University's College of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, and then a number of other accolades and things that you guys are welcome to read later.

25:16 So this training would be made available to all of the commissioners in the state who are members of CAPRCBM. Whether any of them would come, I'm unsure because we are geographically, I think the closest member to us is South Lake Tahoe. And Bishop is not currently a member, but we'd still invite them to participate.

25:38 So what appeals to me about this training, and the association very much wants to have a training in this part of California because they've had trainings in the Bay Area and in Southern California, but never any in Eastern California. And so some of the topics that...

25:55 We could have Paul address with us are the role of commissioners, funding parks and recreation, grassroots advocacy, the politics of parks and recreation, and working with elected officials. So I think these would all be very germane to us. And from my personal perspective, I know Paul, I've worked with him at CAPRCBM. He's very, very impressive. He's a very good trainer, very sought after in the state. And it would just, I think, be a nice opportunity for us to get a training.

26:24 from someone who has been a commissioner and been a staff member who really could, you know, talk about the commissioner perspective as opposed to the staff perspective or, you know, we all attend, you know, ethics training, now we have to do harassment training and those are, you know, kind of the state mandated, you know, trainings and to me I just think it's a great opportunity for us to be able to kind of have this commission engagement and also, you know, we've got a new commissioner, we have, you know,

26:51 A couple of newer commissioners, and I think it would be a good opportunity. So all that being said, how's that looking for all of you calendar-wise on October 6th? I'm actually supposed to be out of town that weekend. Okay. I can tell you that, you know, weekends are not my favorite time to do that kind of work just because, you know, we give a lot of public service time as it is. I understand that it's a statewide. We're inviting people, it sounds like, from around the state.

27:21 But just wanted to say that. Yeah. Unfortunately, Paul's only available on weekends because I had asked that, you know, we do something midweek and that was not a possibility. So how about you, Dan? How's that day looking for you? It's too far out in the future to know, really. Okay. But, you know, I'd calendar it and make it happen.

27:42 Sounds good. Laurel, I know you have a guest that weekend. I don't know anything about the itinerary of that weekend, so I will do my best to be available. Okay. So let's do this. I know the association really wants to kind of put this out and advertise it. And Dan, if you were willing to host it in your conference room, that would be amazing.

28:03 So this is what we were referring to earlier before we started. Yeah. So you and I, we can talk a little bit more about that. But what I'd like to do is go ahead and have them put it out so that we can see if there are commissioners from elsewhere who want to attend. And then, you know, if we don't have kind of a critical mass, we can always cancel. Does that sound okay with everyone? Yes. Okay. How many guests?

28:25 Approximately? Well, it really depends on whether or not we have commissioners come from elsewhere, if it's just us. I cannot imagine that very many people would make the trip, so I'm thinking it's, you know, the five of us, you know, Stu, and then, you know, at most I'd say we get another four or five people, so probably 10 to 12. Okay. That works. Okay.

28:50 All right, so with that, does anyone have anything else on the calendar that they wish to discuss? Just to highlight for everyone, December 5th, we have our joint workshop, our annual joint workshop with town council scheduled. No. And presumably at the December 4th meeting, we'll go over a little bit of an outline for that. Yes. We'll probably actually start in November talking about that. I see that on there, yes. And the specific items on here can shift, but we do try to put everything on the calendar so that we don't.

29:31 Miss anything as we go through the course of the year. When is Election Day this year? Do we need to be worried about November 6th? I don't even remember. 8th of November? Well, it's a Tuesday. So it doesn't even affect us. Okay. I'm fine with this calendar. Do you need a motion to accept it? Yes, please. I will move that we accept this meeting and work plan calendar for this fiscal year as presented. I will second that.

30:08 Okay, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 4-0 to accept the 2018-19 Commission Meeting and Work Plan Calendar. Okay, we're just cruising along today. All right, that brings us to item number five, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Project Update. Grady, thanks again for staffing commission today. No worries.

30:38 As it says in the very brief staff report on August 1st, Town Council voted 3 to 1 to direct staff to do really two things. One is to pursue the $13 million all-in budget for basically a rink and a roof and look at expanding the public viewing areas on the north side of the building. That's just it in general. At that time, they also directed staff to continue with the process to hire a construction manager to do this job for us. In other words, one of the

31:07 The advantages of having a construction manager is you know the cost early. You don't have to wait for a drum roll bid date out there and then have a hard bid. You can actually hire a construction manager at risk or a construction manager multiple prime, as it's called, and they work with subcontractors all along the process and the designer and come to a number earlier. That's the goal of this. We've actually advertised that a couple of weeks ago. We expect to get responses back within 10 days or so. I don't recall the exact date for that.

31:37 Town Council, most likely on October 3rd with a recommendation to hire a construction manager to get them to work. The idea then is to come back as soon as possible, and I say that, but also to make sure we take our time to do it absolutely as best we can. So while we would like to get back to Town Council on November 7th or November 21st, if you have the CM on board on October 3rd, that may be difficult to do and do it the right job. Let me put it that way.

32:05 Part of the reason for that is there are more than one option now. Town Council has directed us to look at the $13 million option period on site. In discussions with the town manager, he's asked us to look at two additional options. One, because of concern and interest he's had from the community and council members, is to stay where we are, to leave the ice rink where it is, put a very minimal roof on it.

32:29 Basically where we started was, you know, put some poles on it and just get some shade on it. That's one that he has directed staff to go ahead and look at again. The other is to stay where we are over at Mammoth Creek Park West, but do it with a $10 million budget. The reason I think he selected that number is that that's what the council has basically designated for the project to this point. Anything beyond, I think it's about $10.1 million, there are other funds and other champs.

32:57 Places we'd have to look for funding to get up to the 13. So he has directed staff to look at those two options. So when we come back in November, and again, it's looking like later in November because we don't want to only work on these for two weeks, basically we'd look at three options. One is the $13 million option that we were directed by town council, the other $10 million on Mammoth Creek Park West, and the other stay over on the school district property.

33:24 So right now, again, we're looking at coming back in November. I certainly would want to, I'll definitely recommend to the town manager that we come to the rec commission first, November 5th, and if not, then the December meeting to make sure we let you know what we want to show to town council before we show it to them. We get it a day apart anyway, but it'll be in the staff report. That's the report. I'm glad to take any comments or questions to the extent I can answer them. Okay, well, I know I have many questions, but who would like to start?

33:56 The three options that are being looked at, it's not completely clear to me. One is the current location, putting a minimal roof on it, is that right?

34:08 That's correct. Where we started three and a half years ago was just basically a shade structure. This wouldn't be that minimal, but it would be some kind of a metal building roof just to keep the sun off and keep most of the snow off. It would not necessarily be protected from the wind or anything. This is what, again, the town manager described just late last week as the first I'd heard it on Thursday, frankly. And then option two is Mammoth Creek Park West.

34:31 In what iteration? Basically, I don't know because the answer is here's a budget of $10.1 million money that we have currently sort of designated for the project, although even that's not been formal. What can you do for $10 million? And again, we heard this on the last Thursday. I haven't had a chance to even consider that yet. And then option one, it still involves Mammoth Creek.

34:54 Park West, though, is that right? Yeah, the first one is $13 million. The staff is confident that working with a construction manager, we can come back with, we call it a rink and a roof, but again, I want to emphasize this year-round program facility with a ridiculous amount of activity in the summer, but it's the project pretty much as designed without the community center portion and the lobby portion. Okay, okay, that's what I needed clarification on, that options one and two both involve the park. Absolutely.

35:24 And I would like to add, though, because I know you're very involved with the project itself and are very well aware of it. Being new to the commission, the commissioners have had an opportunity to hear this once a month for the last three years. So if you would like some extra time, an hour or two, be glad to do that and sit down and go through it with you in detail. The VR stuff was pretty exciting for everybody to see. And that's something you might want to take advantage of. But that's just an offer from staff. Thank you.

35:54 Do you have any other questions right now? No. Those were good ones. Thank you. And I feel like you should be able to jump back in, but I'm going to climb up on a soapbox for a minute if I can. You know, and I'm going to speak to Granicus and all the people in the audience at the same time. You know, I'm just really disappointed where we're at right here right now. And I think everyone in the community is. At the same time, what I'm going to say here is that

36:19 I just want forward motion, and I want to get this thing going. When we were originally tasked with coming up with recommendations to town council, we were told that it needs to be on town-owned property. And so the whole point of moving the multi-use facility to a town-owned location was really directed to us from the town council at the time. I get it that there is some real opportunities by just keeping it where it is. You know, the school district, everything at the time, there was not.

36:49 As the kind of working group that it sounds like there was, I should say there was, this is my impression, that there was not the coordination and collaboration at the time that was going on between the school and the town as there is now, so maybe conditions have changed, but at the same time I sure would like to choose a direction and go forward with it. The one point that I want to say over, I'm going to say this many times, is this is not about hockey rink.

37:15 Yes, hockey rink, and I've had numerous people come to me and say, you know, why are we taking care of such a small contingent of the hockey players?

37:24 It is not about the hockey as much as that is a great opportunity for us as a town. We have talked about this being a true outdoor multi-use facility that has a roof over it. Look at the summer that we talk about all the programming. I got to tell you the thing that excited me the most about having a roof over a multi-use facility is it opens up a world of opportunities to do things in the summer on this giant rink.

37:54 Olympic size. Maybe I should even back up further and say that from an emotional basis, I want this project. We'll talk about finances here in a minute, and the town council is the one that's going to have to make that decision at the end of the day. We're only making recommendations, but from, you know, I can think of lots of financial reasons not to do it. I can think of lots of financial reasons in my personal life not to do things. But from an emotional

38:18 You know, desire that I want to see this town accomplish something and have a real showcase facility, which is what we have been talking about. I'm excited about the opportunity of having it include solar panels and wind and renewable surfaces, creating something that is the envy of other mountain towns.

38:42 Creating something that brings people to town from a tourism standpoint. Think about the tournaments that we can have, not only for hockey, but also whether it's indoor badminton or indoor soccer matches. I love the opportunity of being able to program something on an annual basis for all four seasons if we get a roof over it. Now here we are today, 2018.

39:12 Disappointed that we got that, you know, there's so much. Maybe there are other opportunities right now that we can work with the school district that I hope that they see the value in this, that we've got it so close to the schools. Yeah, great opportunity.

39:28 But we've got to make a decision. We've got to go forward. And I think that, again, my comments here is that I'm looking forward to coming back with the presentation because it sounds like all we're discussing today is the calendar of what's going to happen next, excuse me, that has been directed to town staff by town council, town manager. So I hope that we are still involved in the recommendation. I expect to still be involved and would insist on still being involved in the recommendation.

39:57 Recommendation process going forward. But the thing that I just want to say is I want this. I want this facility not just for the hockey players, not just for winter ice opportunities, but for programming for the entire town. And sorry, I'm actually going to back it for just, you know, I hear the, I want an aquatic center too. I want that as well. We've got one right now, even though it is antique.

40:24 Which makes it kind of valuable and it's, right? Vintage, right. Vintage. You know, it's woefully not up to date. I get that. But at the same time, we've got an opportunity here that really makes it such that we need something for our youth, for our adult, for our community that has got a roof over it. Thank you very much. Do you want to jump in? You know, I'm itching to say something.

40:53 First of all, I agree entirely. And you weren't here at the last meeting where I touched on a few concepts related to the Rec Center. I don't like to refer to it as the multi-use facility because I don't like the acronym MUF. Yes. I can't stand the way that's been used negatively in connection with the project. So what I said last time was, number one, what you don't know and what I told...

41:19 Council during my interview, and they asked me what we don't know is that at my business, I speak to many, many guests, resort guests, and they say, this is fantastic. We love what you've done. Mammoth needs more things like this. That's number one. I also hear, you know, Sun Valley's got a great ice rink. North Star has a great ice rink. Why doesn't Mammoth have, like, a first-class ice rink? This is coming from the public, resort guests.

41:48 And so it's as much or more about resort infrastructure as it is about a small constituency of a few hundred hockey players. It's really not even about that. Now, I'm not an ice skater, but when I go to...

42:08 When I used to travel to Switzerland regularly to visit family, we'd go ice skating. It's the only time I've ice skated in my life because we're on vacation. We're not skiing every day. We want to go ice skating. It's an activity for the resort guests, which is very important to keep in mind. Now, versus a regular-sized rink or Olympic, from what I understand from

42:37 From Stu Brown and people in the department, we need the Olympic-sized rink to do the extra programming in the summer. You need the size of that rink. So that's crucial. We shouldn't compromise on something less than that. Otherwise, it doesn't have its multi-use capacity that's intended. Whether you do it on leased land or owned land, there's a problem with leased land by

43:08 The government. If it's a privately owned property, a commercial property, people, they're in the business of renting it, and they don't want to lose the tenant. But I've often referred to an analogy with the beach club in Santa Monica, the Sand and Sea Club, and they had an opportunity to purchase the land. The city of Santa Monica was leasing it to them. They decided to continue with the lease, and 10, 15 years later, the city of Santa Monica said, you know, we're going to put this to a better use for the public.

43:38 We need it for better beach access, and there's no telling when the school district might have a better use for it for school purposes, and you can't argue with that. So there's a lot of risk in continuing to lease the property from the school district, and to invest that much into it just doesn't make a lot of sense, and people keep referring to that in the public, but you don't want to take that risk.

44:06 The land is owned by the town. It should be done on town-owned land, period. End of story, in my opinion. Now, I was going to, in the report section, talk about something that's related to the multi-use facility, the rec facility. I don't know if I should wait or continue on right now. What would you prefer? Because it's kind of what we're talking about. If it's germane to this, you should talk about it now.

44:32 So I had a customer in. As usual, I was speaking to him, and he was very much opposed to the ice rink, as he was calling it. He asked why we were in the town, was contemplating this when 80% of the population is against it. And I said, well, I don't believe that to be true. Otherwise, it wouldn't be happening. He said, you know, if you did an aquatic facility, a swimming pool, you'd have the reverse. It'd be 80% in support of the facility.

45:01 And I said, I don't believe that to be true either. But, you know, I'm willing to listen. He was opposed to the cost at $19 million. I said, well, that's not happening. You know, I don't even agree with that. But it led me to some germane thoughts on the whole project. And I told this customer that in my experience in Southern California with youth soccer at all levels from little girls through U19 elite club soccer,

45:32 All over Los Angeles, all over Southern California. I've been to Southeast LA, South Los Angeles, East Los Angeles to some very underprivileged neighborhoods. But what does LA have in all these neighborhoods that we don't have? And it's LA Parks and Recreation Facilities. And I said to this customer,

45:56 Can you imagine what that metropolis would be like without this infrastructure? It's for the health and well-being of communities. And even in disadvantaged communities, they have gymnasiums, they've got soccer fields, tracks. Communities, cities, towns need this infrastructure. And the juxtaposition of what Los Angeles has and the priority placed on these facilities compared to what we have,

46:26 is really striking to me. And I don't see why we can't strive for similar facilities, or at least a commitment to our community and the health and welfare of the community, plus resort infrastructure. That was the first thought that galvanized. The other one for me was this pool versus the facility for multi-recreational use.

46:52 I can envision having an aquatic facility indoors and an indoor basketball court and gymnasium and what we're discussing right here. But there's priorities, and the pool would be much more one-dimensional. Plus, there's higher upkeep and costs versus, you know, an ice rink, which is only part of the year. A swimming pool is very expensive, and you're really only appealing to a small constituency there. Swimmers.

47:22 And it's great, but it's just not a priority in my mind. And, you know, as a resort guest, I didn't search out swimming pools when I went on vacation to Switzerland and other ski resorts, but we did look for something like an ice rink to use. So I don't see that the aquatic facility, in terms of priority, serves a greater purpose of combining resort infrastructure along with community needs.

47:51 And then third, the thought that came to mind after this conversation with this customer of mine is that we really need to conduct some sort of an effort toward communications and public relations related to this project. You know, I don't know if it's something we purchase in the sheet for a period of time, maybe every few weeks, and we just publish facts versus myths, something like that. I don't know what it is. It's just sort of in it.

48:20 its infancy as far as I'm concerned. And those are my comments. That's what I was going to report on. Thank you. And so I'll be done with my report. I won't have anything to add after this. Thank you for your time. Thanks, Dan. Those are good comments. Laurel. Well, kind of follow up those two. Thank you. I think you guys said a lot that I agree with, so I won't beat those dead horses.

48:49 Have talked a lot about the need to get the public perception on track with where we're going and what we're doing and all of that. My question is for Grady. The timeline you described sounds like there's a good chance that you guys won't get all the ducks in a row to have it for our October meeting before you bring it to the town council. Is that correct?

49:16 Yeah, on October 3rd, basically, we look to go to Town Council to award the contract with the construction manager to get them started on pre-construction services, and we can report that the day before, but there won't be a lot of meat there, there won't be alternatives yet, none of that. We'll just be beginning the work at that point in time. Just to Sean's point about staying involved in the recommendation process, would there be an opportunity, if needed, to do a special meeting on that, and how would that fit in with

49:46 Brown Act, you know, advertising. Well, I think based on the schedule, though, that it looks like we would be able to come back to the Rec Commission in the November meeting with a pretty solid update. And again, it's my recommendation to the Town Manager that we definitely involve the Rec Commission and the Programming Committee and everybody because you've been the recommending body. That's your job to recommend to Town Council at all these points in time.

50:13 All right. So I guess I wanted to state my willingness to, if it's outside of our meeting timeline, to keep our finger on that pulse and make sure that we know what's going on. Absolutely. As an example, if we were to miss the November 7th, Town Council would be going to the 21st. I might come back and ask that you have a special meeting just to get briefed on it so you can give input before it goes to Town Council. Again, that's my recommendation to the Town Manager, which is, yeah. Thank you. Thanks.

50:42 Yeah, because I think that's the important piece that, you know, again, momentum going forward, that we're providing these other opportunities, these facilities, but also that we're staying with our finger on the pulse as the project.

50:53 Project is moving forward. And if I could add, as soon as we get the construction manager working with HMC, as we did in the past with previous iterations, you know, we would ask for input either from the programming committee or however the commission sees fit to sit with that design team and actually work through some of the options because we intend to, whatever recommendation we make, if it's a smaller project or whatever, the whole point is what effect does that have on programming?

51:19 Programming drove the design. If we're going to shorten the design up, we need to see what those impacts are. And that's where this group is absolutely essential to have that input because just an example, and again, personally, yes, I think Olympic rink.

51:35 That size facility is so important because of the summer programming. If that's one of the options is to shorten that up, that significantly impacts the program. We want to make sure that we give town council every bit of information we can so they can make an informed decision. And that summer programming is so important because there's waiting lists now for the summer camps. And in this altitude and the sun being as strong as it is,

52:04 You know, you need to get the kids out of the sun. I mean, it just blazes. They need a covered court. So, Laurel, do you have other questions? No, no, that was my main point. Like I said, these guys said a lot of good things that I second. Okay. Sean, did you have something? No, I'm going to ask Matt some questions. You haven't spoken yet, so I definitely want to. Thanks for having the audience. Yes, thank you. So I have some questions.

52:33 I don't necessarily expect that staff are able to answer them, but I want to ask them. So I have been present or watched pretty much every town council meeting over the past however many months. So I did not hear council give this direction to the town manager. So did I miss something? No, but basically what the town manager's job is, of course, to do is to leave with the town.

53:05 Council, and he does have regular meetings with them one-on-one and others. He doesn't share information between those meetings because that would be a Brown Act violation, so he's careful not to do that. Having said that, if he gets comments from Town Council members between meetings, and he, in his, you know, believes that the best approach is to look at alternatives, he's fully free to direct staff to do so. We don't have a direction from the five members of Town Council.

53:32 to change the direction and do anything except for the 13 mayor option. These are coming from the town manager, but again, that's something that's within his purview as town manager to direct staff as he sees fit. Thank you. At the last council meeting where this was discussed, it was my understanding from council that there was some urgency in bringing this item as discussed at that meeting back, and I forget the exact date, but...

53:59 Back for review. So is there any impact to the need for that urgency with looking toward hiring a CM and coming back with something later on? I understand it's a very busy time of year for engineering. It's always a balance of taking the time to make sure that we get all the information. I really appreciate and like the idea of bringing the construction manager on board, having to meet with HMC, with the architects, and keep it moving.

54:25 The Town Council had one session to talk about goals and priorities a couple of weeks ago. We didn't really get into the priorities. We didn't get into the projects. It was a good conversation about overall needs. On October 3rd, they'll be talking about some budget issues and close out of last year and kind of a projection looking forward. If there's an urgency, this is this staff members.

54:49 Recommendation to Town Manager is that while this is going on over the next two or three months, that we preserve the funds that Town Council has discussed using for this facility. Right now, it's my understanding that the Town Manager has identified approximately $10.1 million that can be used for design and construction of the facility. And my strong recommendation along with Stu's has been, okay, well, while we're talking about this, don't let that erode, okay, hold that line.

55:18 And keep that in place for this time. Staff will not recommend to the town manager that any of those funds be redirected to other uses at this time while we study the rest of the options. So that's, again, that's this staff person's strong recommendation to the town manager is that while this is going on, and that is a sense of urgency, the concern might be that

55:42 On October 3rd, Town Council says, well, gee, you have general funds over there set aside or designated for the multi-use facility. We could use it for something else. This is just, you know, Rec staff and Public Works staff saying, hold that line, recommending to the town manager, keep those funds in place while we study it, give it its due diligence, give it its opportunity to play out. So that's the sense of urgency that I have is that that might change on October 3rd. Okay, thank you.

56:09 Have negotiations been reopened with the school district to remain on the property there? I'm not aware of any formal negotiations or discussions between the town manager and the school district. There may be some informal conversations that I'm not privy to that the town manager or others may be having, but there are certainly no formal negotiations and no direction from town council at this time. Thank you.

56:41 $5.5 million of the funding for the project is bonded Measure R monies, and I know that Measure R funds need to be utilized on town-owned or managed property. Does anything preclude those funds from being used on leased land? I've actually posed that question to the finance director who's going to look at the bond documents, and if you like, I can get back to you very soon on that. He's going to actually look at them. We're not aware of a restriction.

57:10 Again, it needs to be town owned or managed, but I do not know the details of that, and I turn that back to Rob Patterson to give me a precise answer, but I can get back to you fairly quickly on that.

57:20 Thank you. Okay, so my last question, and then I have some comments. So at our last commission meeting, it was the request of the, and I think at the prior one as well, it was the request of the commission that we have, as Dan spoke to, some effort to better communicate this project to the public. There seem to be a lot of incorrect facts and misperceptions about it. Has staff been directed to engage in any of that work?

57:47 You know, that one I cannot answer. I don't know if, Lauren, you're aware of anything that goes down specifically. I'm not aware of any public outreach. Okay. Thank you. I do agree it's necessary, essential, in fact. Okay. But, yeah. Not even, yeah. And just on that subject, you know, some time ago I wrote kind of a, just a, you know, basic Q&A about the project, and I don't know whatever happened to that, but I'd certainly be happy to help update that as part of that effort.

58:12 So my comments, and these are my personal comments. One, I agree with everything everyone up here has said. I find the timing of this quite fascinating because obviously this direction from the town manager, and that's certainly his purview, but I find it very interesting that this all came out immediately after the commission's packet was complete. So I'm very disappointed that no one has come to me as the chair, to Sean as the vice chair, or, you know, I don't know.

58:39 you know about other conversations but I'm you know we are the council's appointed advisory body for parks and recreation and I would I would hope that you know this commission will be engaged in these conversations going forward to speak briefly to the question of aquatic center versus

58:59 The park project, because I agree, I also dislike the acronym. This is not an either or proposition. If we move forward with this project, nothing other than finances precludes us from also moving forward with some type of aquatics facility. That was why we had the workshop with USA Swimming. I think it was two years ago now. Believe me, no one in this community wants a year-round pool more than I do.

59:24 So I just want the public to understand that that's really a false dichotomy, that if we don't move forward with building this project, we are most likely not building an aquatic center either. Again, that's just my personal opinion, but it's pretty strongly held.

59:40 And finally, I just have to say that from my point of view, I understand funding. I understand that we have a new council, and it's certainly within their purview to redirect general funds. But this remains a much-needed project in the community. I still feel very strongly about that. I think everyone on the commission does. We've just had a very, very busy summer with camps and other activities. I continue to maintain that we are facilities deficient for the needs of our community.

1:00:09 I have a lot of concerns about trying to simply put a roof on the existing facility, which includes the condition of the slab, the condition of the outbuildings. You know, there's a trailer over there that can't be occupied when there's snow on the roof. So to me, this community deserves a lot better than that. I'm sure Christy would be jumping up and down saying the same thing. Were she here?

1:00:31 And I would hope that we would have a very serious conversation with the community before we were to move down that path. I also will say that it was my understanding, and I think the commission's understanding, following the last round of confidential negotiations, that that was a non-starter, that that was not something that was going to be reopened or rediscussed. That's why we moved forward with putting the project on town-owned land, and I agree with everything Dan said about that. I think the Santa Monica story is very compelling.

1:01:00 So I will just conclude by saying that I hope when we meet in October there will be some more details fleshed out on this. And I would also very much like when we meet in October to have a better understanding of the finances that have been set aside for this project and what the status of those is, especially going into that October council budget meeting. So I will get off my soapbox now.

1:01:29 Does anyone else on the commission have anything to add before we bring Matt up? I know Sean has a couple questions. No, you know, we're going to be saying the same things over and over, but I do have some questions for Matt. Okay. Anybody else? I have a question about financing and whether anybody has explored possibly MLT funds in light of the fact that this is not just a community project, but something that's

1:01:58 Hopefully designed towards resort infrastructure. I'm aware that MLT has put money for purchasing the crib, a condominium for track runners, you know, which has a tangential, I suppose, resort advertising connection. This might be heresy, I don't know what I'm just thinking about, but, you know, you have to win a race and then say, go Mammoth Lakes, I trained there.

1:02:27 And then isn't it true that some funds were proposed for Sam's Wood Site as resort infrastructure? So has anybody ever pursued this? Yeah, I'll speak to that. I definitely brought it up.

1:02:45 A couple times, you know, that I personally, and again, I'm going to speak as an individual board member on MLT, is I would not be opposed to this. I think that this does create, it does contribute to the infrastructure that creates a tourist attraction as well as serving the locals. Yes, we did purchase the crib, which actually gets a lot of great direct.

1:03:06 PR, some of these influencers, whether they win or not, they got the followers on all these social media channels. The crib was a great purchase for us. I do believe that. We got a good value on that. Yes, likewise with the wood site. There was an arrangement that was made there that theoretically is supposed to be for the benefit of the community as far as infrastructure goes.

1:03:31 So I look at this, and then we're also, we have money that is set aside and designated for wayfinding that looks like may actually be going forward here shortly, which is great. So glad to see what I view as tourism dollars being spent on infrastructure which is tourism related. And I can certainly tie that in with this facility, again, for the tourism reasons that I made clear.

1:03:58 that I've talked about beforehand. So I've brought it up. I will say, let me put it this way. I think that there is less resistance to perhaps looking at some of those MLT funds. I'm speaking as a board, I'm speaking as an individual board member. But at the same time, I think we've got a lot of convincing to go there if that's actually to come.

1:04:23 And that is going to take some convincing of the other, my fellow board members. I will tell you that I personally don't have a problem with that. I'm not going to say whether I'm for or against it at this moment until you actually get into the details. But I am wide open to that opportunity because I do see it as a tourism-related infrastructure. I mean, it seems to me, if you can make the argument that the Crib and Sam's Wood Site weren't MLT funds, then certainly this.

1:04:50 Huge piece of a resort, you know, ice skating rink does as well, logically. Can I follow up with a question to Matt, kind of along these lines? Sure, the only thing I wanted to say, and I don't want to speak for MLT, but MLT was very willing to partner with, you know, the advertising and sponsorship deal for, you know, with the LA Kings that would have directed some funds toward this project. That's exactly where I wanted to go with Matt, if I could. Grady, do you have anything to add to that question? Okay, all right. Matt, would you mind if we,

1:05:20 Brought you up to answer a couple questions? You're welcome. Thanks. Thanks, Matt, and thanks for showing up. Yeah, this is one thing that I just, you know, kind of want to speak to, but I want to ask you some questions. You know, we had a great opportunity, it seems like, and with regards to in the community that we were going down a road that actually would help us really fund this, and it was going to pay off in tourism, it was going to pay off in our association with such a big name, and

1:05:51 Essentially, it sounds like it did not happen primarily because of what did not happen between Altera Ski Resort and the Kings. Is that correct? No. Can you clarify what happened or why it didn't happen? I can give you what my understanding of the situation was. I think there was some dynamics that were going on.

1:06:19 As we got closer to sending the project out for bid, there was conversations with Altera, there was conversations going on with the Kings, but I think that coming right up to that deadline, I think everybody was kind of landing in the same place. I think really what happened was that we just, you know, the bids for the project came in significantly higher than anyone had expected.

1:06:44 So until we had answers, I think the conversation just kind of stopped there. It was almost a moot point to continue moving forward on a project that, you know, we had a funding gap that was so large. Okay, thank you. I really want to get that clarified because I know that there's, again, these are, it's a lot of misinformation that's out there in the public. Was there, so...

1:07:06 With regard to MLR's participation in or even the Town of Mammoth Lakes, we did not end up committing any money to the King's deal. Is that correct when I say we, the Town of Mammoth Lakes? Not to my knowledge. Okay. Not to my knowledge. No, I think that, to your point, I think that MLT, both staff and the board, I thought were very generous and gracious, you know, with their willingness to entertain and commit.

1:07:35 to that ad buy. That was something that, sure, would have helped the town, but again, I think if you talk to them in their grand scheme of things, they have a plan, a campaign plan, or a media plan that they are working towards, and I think that would have been an adjunct to it, and it would have been a pretty significant adjunct. Again, there's not to say that it wouldn't have been beneficial for them. Sure, it would have been, but it probably wouldn't have been as high on their priority list. So I think there was a willingness there for them to kind of

1:08:04 Helps shoulder some of that load. Same thing, I think, for the Mountain as well. I think that they're obviously working already with the Kings. They continue to do so right now. They're getting ready for the startup of next season. You know, the question for them was, did they want to do a commit to a five-year buy or just kind of go by their current deal? And I'm not sure if that's a year-by-year or if it's a shorter, like, two- or three-year deal. I can't answer that. But, you know, I think what

1:08:32 The Kings were asking for was a longer committed ad buy, and that was something that, you know, they were wrestling with as well. So I think that, you know, the appetite was there. I just think putting all the pieces in place, there was some dynamics going off those conversations, but as far as I was aware of, I think everybody was swimming in the right direction, and we just, you know, hit this wall, so to speak, with the bids coming in higher, and so now everyone's gone back to regroup, and I think for...

1:08:59 Our part, certainly, and I'd imagine our potential partners' parts, we're just waiting to see where we land with a project. I mean, I know that we just had our executive committee meeting last week. We're going to have our board meeting next week. And we're eager to start fundraising, but we need a very defined project to fundraise for. And that's kind of been the challenging part. I share all of your guys' frustrations. When we spoke in front of the town council to give our recommendation,

1:09:26 I mean, we were pretty candid by saying we weren't really happy with either one of those alternatives. We supported option one because, you know, we trust our staff and they felt that that's the best one. But I think, you know, what we want to see is the same thing, the things that you guys want to see. We want to see a recreation center, an amenity that we can all be proud of that services this community as fully and robustly as possible. And right now, I think the direction that we're going is kind of opposite of that.

1:09:55 And so I think what we need to do is just, you know, it really comes down to managing expectations. And I understand that we have budget constraints and understand that there are expectations in terms of prioritizations. And I think Becky pretty much, I'm sorry, I hit the nail on the head when she said that if we don't get this rec center, if this park project doesn't go through,

1:10:21 There's not going to be any appetite. There's not going to be any political capital. There won't be anything left for us to go and build an aquatic center. I think that we really have to show this community that we can fulfill on our obligations and our intentions. And so Mammoth Lakes Recreation is standing by to help do that any way that we can. But I think there's challenges that go along with that. As we shrink that project, eventually it will get down to a point where

1:10:48 It's going to get small enough where we're competing. I've said this very often. My goal is to try to raise money outside the community because my view is that any money that we raise inside the community, it's robbing Peter to pay Paul. We're taking away from another opportunity that's probably just as equally deserving. And so if we can raise money outside that community, that's additive, right? And so that's something that benefits the community. We're not sacrificing something else. But in order to do that, we need to have an amenity that rises.

1:11:16 to something that people can stand behind, especially if they live down south, whether they're second homeowners or they're just guests to our community. But the smaller that we get, it now starts to get paired up with things that are happening in everybody else's community. I'm sure Redondo Beach has some kind of amenity they need. Maybe it's a new community center. I'm sure that San Pedro needs a new swimming pool. I'm sure that Newport Beach wants new soccer fields or something.

1:11:43 And so in order to raise money down there, we have to have something, you know, as we get smaller, it actually starts to compete with money that they're going to spend in their own backyards. So we need something that they know when they come and they recreate here, they stay for a week, whether it's over the winter holidays or summer, that they can enjoy with their families. And so I think we have to keep that in mind as well. Yeah, just to follow up on that, and by the way, that actually was a great opportunity for MLT to be participating in a way that

1:12:12 While the two projects, it was a marketing deal and it was a sponsorship of a facility and they were two separate deals, correct? Do I just want to make sure I'm saying the correct things? Yeah, well, and there was some overlap, right? So I think that there was the ad buy. Again, that was something that both the town and the mountain were going to come in and partner with. Contingent on that ad buy, the Los Angeles Kings organization was going to...

1:12:38 commit a certain amount of money back to the park project. That's right. And so they were two separate deals, but they were contingent upon each other happening. Yeah. And so, you know, there was a great opportunity to go forward. Now, we do need to take some responsibility when it comes to that, you know, unfortunately, we set up the public for perhaps a budget that was here in the actual...

1:13:02 Price came in here. So, you know, that's unfortunate. And I remember Grady talking with, you know, what is our timeline that we going forward and if we can take any lesson away from that is under promise and over deliver.

1:13:17 and just making sure that we are almost prepping the community for what the true cost of this is going to be because it is pricey and that's a valid concern. So anybody who comes forward and says, oh my God, that's a lot of money. Yes, it is. It's not the 19 million. Unfortunately, there is some misinformation out there. I think that there is opportunities to get...

1:13:38 Money, you know, we were looking at, was it one million bucks I think that they were going to be contributing towards the project? That was, yeah, one of the numbers that we were talking about. Yeah. So, you know, yes, the MLT and MMSA was going to be contributing money towards the marketing, you know, so it was all going to be a great, in my opinion, it was going to be a great little partnership that happened that kind of fell out and it's too bad for whatever reasons that it did and we do need to take some responsibility for, unfortunately, it coming above and beyond that.

1:14:08 A question, I know you've got some comments as well. Is that deal dead in the water? Is there any way that we could go approach it when we do have our act together a little bit as far as what we're going to build? No, you know, again, I'm not as close to it as some other people are. Stuart's put in a lot of work on this. I would say Stuart Brown's probably the closest to this. I know that the mountains certainly are continuing their relationship. So I wouldn't say that it's...

1:14:34 Dead in the Water. I think the parameters, I would imagine, probably would change if the size and scale of the project changes. But I can't speak directly to that firsthand. So certainly I think that relationship continues to exist. As long as the mountain is working with the kings, I think there's always an opportunity. I don't want to speak for MLT, but again, I found them to be very open-minded partners who I think do have this community's best

1:15:03 Best welfare in mind. Thanks, Matt, and I appreciate that you share our frustration. Grady, can you just speak to, I know there were some town, not nearly as large as the MLT or MMSA portion, but I know there were also some town funds allocated toward that deal. Were any of those expended? Yeah, and if I could, I have a couple of comments. As I just told Lauren, this is where Stu usually kicks me and tells me to be quiet, but he's not here. He's on a plane, so go for it.

1:15:33 Specifically to the Kings deal, Stu doesn't say this in public because he will not do that, but it only happened and it only will happen because of him and his involvement and his relationship with the Kings. You may have all heard that individually, but it wasn't going to happen. The relationship that he's built over the years with people that have come to Mammoth and the work that he did with the Kings, with other people going with him down there, very frankly, but he deserves all the credit for that.

1:15:59 And having been in some of those meetings down in L.A. and up here in Mammoth Lakes and also being on the telephone recently with the Kings, they are still extremely interested. They are still extremely interested in the project that we're proposing now, the $13 million project. They want the rink. They want locker rooms.

1:16:17 The list goes on from there, but that's what they want. If they want an ice rink, they'd still prefer the NHL size because they just don't really care, but they're fine with Olympic. That's not a deal breaker by any means, and they're very interested. They need locker rooms, restrooms, and ice. That's it. They're very interested, and basically their last comment was, hey, let me know when you're ready, and we'll start our discussions again. In terms of why it didn't happen last time, it's that...

1:16:44 $1 million that the King was going to donate was basically gone or off the table for a while long before we opened the bids. That had nothing to do with it, really. It was the end.

1:16:55 Altair was very clear about this. We're not going to sign a five-year deal. We're not going to do that right now. They had some communication issues internally, whatever. It doesn't make any difference. I completely respect their opinion, their decision. It's their money. Why would they do something they didn't feel good about? But they made the decision, as Matt said, not to sign a five-year deal. Therefore, the kings weren't going to move forward as it was. Will they consider that in the future? I think Altair has learned a lot about.

1:17:22 Altera itself. They're constantly expanding, as we see all the time. The icon path is expanding. They frankly don't know what's going to happen this winter. We don't know how many visitors we're going to get based on the path. There's a lot to learn, so I think the door's still very open. I think Mr. Brownlee's been very open with, no, we'll talk in the future. We absolutely want to talk, so I see a lot of opportunity there as well. In terms of the project itself, I agree that having a community center or something else with the

1:17:52 Recreation Facility is valuable. Having said that, if it's a year-round, full-time recreation facility that handles the kind of programming that this group has come up with, and in the winter it's an ice rink, and it works, and we have the opportunity to host tournaments, it's going to be something we're proud of. The architecture is going to work. The building is going to work. It's not something that we're heading in the opposite direction.

1:18:21 By any means. If the community center doesn't happen now, fine. Maybe it happens someplace else. Maybe it happens here later. But the key part of this is 30,000 square feet under a roof that can be used winter and summer for the benefit of the community and for the tourists. So Stu wasn't here to kick me, so I went a little further than I normally would, but that's okay. Thank you. Are there any other questions for Matt? What's your role?

1:18:51 And with what organization? Oh, I'm sorry. I apologize. It just came on up. I'm the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Okay. Very good. Sorry, Dan. I should have clarified. Matt, anything else you'd like to add? No. Thank you very much for coming today. I really appreciate it. Sure. Thanks for your work. Thanks. Okay. And Grady, I appreciate those comments. Stu's certainly done.

1:19:13 Very, very commendable job on that relationship. Can I ask one follow-up question? You actually mentioned something. Yeah, so with regard to negotiations with the school district, as of right now, aren't we supposed to be off that property by June 2019? I believe that's where the negotiations ended last time. We got an extension through June of 2019. And again, I don't know what individual conversations we've had so far, but we have not yet been directed formally by town council to reopen that.

1:19:44 I feel like we've also been told that there's potential to keep that going for a little bit, because I think we asked Stu if that's out-out, or what if we're not ready yet? Yeah, I seem to remember something along those lines, because I remember we had a hard stop of June 19, but yeah, that's what I don't remember with the final. Yeah, my understanding had been that there was some flexibility to remain, but it was not indefinite.

1:20:16 That was at least my understanding. Any other comments from staff? So we're not, this is just an update? Just a discussion item. Okay. Okay. Thank you. And obviously we'll bring this back in October. Okay. So any other comments on this item from commission? Any other members of the public wish to comment? Good morning. Okay. And I will move us on then to commissioner reports.

1:20:50 Dan, sounds like you've already given yours. Anything else you'd like to add? No, that was all related to this discussion. I just, I can't say enough about this realization that came to me about parks and recreation in LA in underprivileged neighborhoods and the importance of that in any society. And if they've got gymnasiums and pools and fields, why cannot we have the same thing here?

1:21:21 That's just as important for the community. Thank you. That's my final comment. Thank you. Laurel? So I actually have similar comments. So I went to a wedding back where I grew up a couple of weeks ago, and this is in suburban Connecticut, and went to the park where I spent my formative years both growing up playing and my early work years as a lifeguard pool attendant, et cetera, bounce house attendant, all those things.

1:21:51 It was amazing to see. Okay, so the amount of people still playing on the playground that I helped build 30 years ago, even though they're about to redo it because it's that old pressure-treated...

1:22:04 Bad for you, lumber stuff. But that was, I mean, just the fact that they were still playing on that playground was pretty awesome. So the playgrounds that we build today will be still played on 30 years from now, hopefully. But the long-range vision of my longtime boss there, the Parks and Rec Director, was finally coming to fruition. And so it kind of made me realize how much that even if we spend three years talking about the same facility,

1:22:32 When we get that facility built, it's going to have that long legacy and will be there for future generations to come. And I mean, I was just overwhelmed by the importance and the need for parks. And, you know, the suburban Connecticut community is a lot different than rural Eastern Sierra California community. But the parks in...

1:22:57 That community, everybody else in the surrounding communities came to because they were so good, and they're still doing that. And so if we build it, they will come. Even though it won't be from the suburban moms around the towns, it'll be from folks coming on vacation. I think we've got to remember, again, what vital, important things the parks and facilities we create will be for this community for many, many years to come.

1:23:25 Hopefully Stu won't have to, you know, be beyond the pale anymore when some of these things come to fruition. Some of these things didn't happen until my former Parks and Rec Director passed and, you know, they were able to raise some extra funds and name it in his honor. So we will hope that that will not be the case here. If it does, it will be in 30, 40 years. But again, importance of parks has driven home to me. Thanks, Laurel. Let's keep up the good work.

1:23:57 Awesome. Okay. I got a couple of agenda items, but I'll save that for that. Yeah, I just want to speak about a couple things. Summer camps. You know, I know we still, are we done with summer camps? Yes. Okay. Everything I saw, just from my kids' eyes, and, you know, his friends, looks like it was a great summer. And I look forward to a report, which I guess is going to be next week, or next month. Correct. And I just, and I'm.

1:24:24 I can tell you already that I'm, you know, from everything I've seen, I'm very proud of, you know, what our department, what the Recreation Department has done as far as managing our camps. They continue to get, from my just anecdotal perspective, continue to get better, and I'm really looking forward to the report next week, or next month on that. Events, I want to talk a little bit about that, because it is unfortunate that it sounds like the wood site may be going away.

1:24:49 And there is discussion out there and it sounds like it's starting to be reported on and certainly there's more discussion that will come out of it. I got to say this one thing and this ties into the final comment that I'm going to talk about which is with regard to misinformation again around the multi-use facility. It is so frustrating when I hear my colleagues in this community who I have so much respect for who seem to be quoting facts and figures that just

1:25:17 Go out of control. I've heard this $19 million number thrown around, and it was never, what was the highest number that we ever, what was the highest number that it got to at one point? There was a low bid at that number, but it was frankly unrealistic, so yeah. Yeah. It was nice. So, you know, we're not going forward at that. I don't want to hear any more about how this is for the hockey players only, because it's not in our role sitting here, and I hope that the programming does continue to,

1:25:47 Drive the Design. You've said that from staff, we've said that, and I try and communicate that with other people in the community, is that the reason why we were looking at this facility is because we were looking at the programming opportunities that go well beyond hockey and actually take it year-round.

1:26:06 Unfortunately, I do continue to hear misinformation from otherwise very well-educated, informed, and smart individuals that I hope that we can do a better job of just putting out there some of the facts that are true surrounding this. And it's too bad where we're at right now. It's a big decision. We're not trying to minimize the decision.

1:26:29 At the same time, I want to make sure we're all talking about the same facts. And I just want to say something with regard to the events is that, again, I've seen some great events happen this summer. Palooza Palooza was a success for the most part. I know, and I'm talking only from a programming standpoint and my role here as a commissioner on this, as a recreation commissioner here, is that I would love to see more events in this town, period.

1:26:56 I'd like to see them outside the village in a true venue that we as a town can collaboratively work together as, whether they're outside promoters or local promoters, whether we're growing our existing events or bringing additional events to town. I've heard the comment made, wouldn't you rather have an event site than a multi-use facility? And my immediate response is, no, not necessarily.

1:27:24 I want both. And I also want an aquatic center even beyond that. I think this town can afford these multi, several different facilities, including an outdoor events location, as well as a multi-use facility. And, you know, let's prove, let's get our success with those and then look at aquatic center or even other options that we haven't even considered yet. So I just want to be clear that when, yeah, an event site might be less expensive. Indeed,

1:27:53 I hope it would be, but that does not lessen my desire for this multi-use facility. Thank you. Thanks for that, John. Okay, so for myself, I don't have a lot to report other than I did listen to and then attend a portion of the Council Strategic Priorities Workshop on August 22nd. It was very interesting, very nice to see Michael Ward. He's done a lot of consulting work for the town, so it was a very interesting meeting.

1:28:23 And on Friday, this is super fun, so on Friday morning I attended the Whitmore 50 Challenge Breakfast. Thanks very much to the staff for organizing. I really appreciated that Kat actually came down from maternity leave to work on that, so it was great to see her. And I am just amazed at how far people swam. How far did you swim? I swam about 55 and a half miles, which is vastly eclipsed by your...

1:28:51 Over the course of the summer. It took me all summer to do that. But Laurel's colleague Maggie from DSDS swam like 114 miles. Her husband Jim swam 90. He started tracking late apparently.

1:29:06 He looked exhausted by the end. Bea, our very loyal swimmer, she swam over 100 miles. I think she got to like 103, 104. So my only real claim to fame was that I actually got to 50 miles before Stu did, which never happens. So that was very exciting. And it was really only because of extenuating circumstances. But anyway, it's a really nice breakfast. And I have to say people really, you know.

1:29:30 People really have embraced that program. People really love that facility. I appreciate everything that Warren and his team have done to keep it running. It's certainly having a vintage pool certainly poses some challenges. So anyway, so that was really nice and just a really nice little event on Friday. So thank you.

1:29:50 And I have to echo also Sean's comments about camps. You know, my daughter did a couple of camps. There was one that she was really kind of not that enthusiastic about. And she and I was like, well, you're going. And she had a great time. So we by all appearances had a phenomenal staff this summer executing those programs. So thank you. And that's all I got.

1:30:11 So request for agenda items on our schedule for October 2nd is the 2018 Summer Program Performance and Customer Survey Analysis, the Winter Sidewalk and Multi-Use Path Snow Removal Plan, and our standing item, the Plan Mammoth Creek Park Update.

1:30:31 Sean, did you have additional items you wish to request? I did. It's that magic time of year where I'm going to channel Bill Sauser and say I would love to get an update on the Lakes Basin opening and closing. I know that we can't, you know, those decisions are often made with regard to when the snow starts to fly. But at the same time, specifically, I'd like to find out, I know that the U.S. Forest Service contracts with the concessionaires, the campground concessionaires was coming up.

1:30:59 Could you find out when those contracts were going to be due? And this is something that I know that MLR is not in the business, nor are we in trying to manage campgrounds, but I will speak from a tourism standpoint that it is frustrating, just as what I see from my role on the board of the tourism.

1:31:23 is that it's frustrating that the camps close down. It feels like early to me. And they do so because they don't have business. I get it. They don't have enough campers coming up to make it worthwhile. Now, we as a tourism, I will say in my role over there, I feel that our goal is to try and get people coming up even when we get those Indian summer weekends going into September and October. You know, I get it. We get the threat of a freeze in late September.

1:31:50 Warms up for a couple of weekends in October, and I would love to see a little bit more emphasis placed on what weekends are determined, or the closing of the Lakes Basin is often determined by the U.S. Forest Service or by the concessionaires, and I'd love to have us as a town a little bit more involved in that decision if there's any way that we can.

1:32:15 And I don't know what that process might look like. Or if there's ever, if there's even any kind of precedent for municipalities running the U.S. Forest Service campgrounds from a tourism standpoint and then from this body from a programming standpoint. But I would love to see us really making sure that we are making the most out of the lakes basin up there.

1:32:38 You know, whether it's the restrooms still being open, do we put up some porta-potties because Forest Service wants to close down the pit toilets up there? We as the town get blamed when the pit toilets are closed. And it wasn't, but it was a U.S. Forest Service decision. So again, I'd like to discuss that as best we can. Sure. Please. So that's some good feedback. A couple of things. Regarding kind of the long...

1:33:13 I think that's going to be something that the new

1:33:43 Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation position will be a little bit more hands-on in as well. I know there's been a lot of talk about trying to address some of the facilities needs. I know that there's issues, existing issues with waste and trash, existing issues with bathrooms, especially kind of out of town, but I think they're all going to be combined together. So if you guys have specific concerns, I know that our next meeting

1:34:11 which is in October, Grady, is that for the, but the next meeting for the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Rec Position, and I'll get that to the board, is going to talk specifically about tasks. So if you'd like to kind of come up with some concerns, if you want to forward those to me, I'll make sure that those get voiced at the meeting when we sit down with the county and start saying what are our prioritization lists and what are our areas that we want to focus on right off the bat.

1:34:35 Great. Well, you just heard my comments, and those are the two, is that I would love to see the campgrounds open, or even just one or two of them open a little bit longer. I get it from a financial, you know, private enterprise concessionaire. I might be doing the same thing, but from a public standpoint, I'd love to see those open, and then also the facilities. So those are my two biggest concerns. I think it might.

1:34:58 Just be interesting. I don't know if they could help or not, but it might be interesting to maybe loop in ECI on that, at least just because they're pipelined in. Their sole purpose is to represent Forest Service. Matt, just while we have you there, what's kind of the timeline on filling that Eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator? We have scheduled interviews, I believe, for the 21st. So we had an applicant pool of about 80.

1:35:26 Applicants, which is one of the larger responses that the town has seen in recent years. We managed to pare that down to about eight candidates. I would say the pool, by and large, had some really good people in there. The eight candidates that we have narrowed down to, those were reviewed by Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, and there was quite a bit of overlap. So I think that we're all kind of looking for the same thing, which is great.

1:35:54 The Forest Service is weighing in on that. So we're going to have a panel interview that takes place on the 21st. I would say that we'd like to be in a position, hopefully, to maybe make an offer sometime in mid-October, I'm guessing. Thank you. Any other requests for agenda items for October from the Commission? Okay. So if there's nothing for...

1:36:21 No. Okay, so seeing nothing further, I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting, which will remain here at 9 a.m. on Tuesday, October 2nd. Thanks, everybody. Very good. Thank you. Well, that was a short meeting. Yeah. Wow. We haven't had that kind of... Be efficient.