TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2018

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 5 hr 0 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

295 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 10-5-0. Okay. Hey, Sharon. All right, good morning. You ready? Good, Jamie? I will now call this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission to order for Tuesday, October 2, 2018. Roll call, please. Commissioner Martin. Good morning. Commissioner O'Connell. Commissioner Osmore. Here. Hello. Here. Commissioner O'Connell is ill and sends his regrets.

0:34 This time I'll open the floor for public comments. This is the time during which anyone who wishes to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do so. Okay, seeing none, I will move us to the consent agenda. Item number one, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 4th, 2018. Does anyone have anything they wish to pull? I just want to amend the minutes slightly. Okay. It said that you motioned to...

1:10 Reappoint yourself as chair. And I had my notes say that I made that motion and Sean seconded it. I actually went back and watched it last night because I was like, did I nominate myself? And I did not. So it was actually moved by Sean and you were the second on that one. That's okay. Any other changes to the minutes? That's the only thing that I noticed. Okay. Entertain a motion to approve the minutes as amended. I will so move. I will second.

1:42 Okay, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 4-2-0. Okay, that brings us into our presentation, item number two, the Parks Maintenance 2018-19 Winter Snow Removal Plan presentation. Good morning, Commissioners. I'm going to use the new dice and put my tea right there. So before you is our little presentation on our winter snow removal plan.

2:21 is going to help me walk through this with you. We are also presenting some items tomorrow night to council regarding this particular item as public works. So I'll kind of get to that as we go through the presentation. And any questions, just feel free to ask as we go. The PowerPoint was in your packet, so I know you've kind of had a chance to see it. So hopefully there's no real surprises. Here we go. Any questions before we start? Okay.

2:53 Great. So this is kind of our route map, and this has been an organic process for the last couple of years. The way we prioritise our sidewalks and our multi-use paths, much like public works, is by priority. So kind of our main priority routes are the green routes. They're the main routes, and we'll talk about level of service and so forth following. Then we go to kind of our secondary routes, which are in blue. You can see we have our new routes highlighted in red.

3:21 Which you see happening right now. And our safe routes to school. Safe routes to school are obviously prioritised when school is in operation. Does that make sense? So you can see here just kind of rolling through our little map. This is a good go-to document for pretty much the entire piece. Main Street is a two-year sidewalk construction period. You can see they're working on the north side right now. So that's what we're addressing this immediate winter. And then you'll see we'll have those additional

3:50 Linear Feet for the next winter as well. You can see here we're adding the additional service to connect the Welcome Centre which is the secondary route. You can see the Mammoth Gap Creek project down here in red just below Mammoth Creek Park. If you've been down that path it's pretty much done. The path is in place. They're just going to be working on lights prior to wintertime. So the goal there is to try and connect

4:18 The entire Snow Creek Region all the way out to kind of the Snow Creek Athletic Club affordable housing area. So that's a bigger change than we've done in the past because now we have access through the Mammoth Creek Park Gap multi-use path and then along that multi-use path as well. So that kind of gives you kind of a general overview of kind of where the crew goes during wintertime.

4:44 And then what we'll kind of talk about now is kind of little bits and pieces as we talked about before, main routes, new routes, safe routes to school, secondary routes. So that's kind of what we've covered in that map. Level of service. So our main routes, we clear those with greater than two to three plus inches of snow, and that's twice in a 12-hour period. And that distance is approximately five miles. That's the linear feet.

5:11 And Warren, you can kind of jump in and just talk about what that really means, though. So it's not just the linear feet, just the way we have to maintain those trails. Quite a few people think that we just actually go out there and it's just, sorry, thank you, go out there and just plow this in one direction. No one actually realizes that on a track list it is only 60 inches wide. The paths are quite a bit wider. We try to make as much room as possible for people that are traveling the paths. And so when we do go out, we always have to do come back. So on

5:41 When we do have a current amount of miles or route miles that we work with, you've got to think that's actually doubled on what we actually are doing. I have to say, since I have been here, we have picked up a few of the routes and we have started a few new sections that we did open. Like over here at Mammoth Creek Park, we did go from Mammoth Creek Park back to the condos back there. And just that small little section was impressive, the amount of

6:05 People coming forward and saying how great that was, but, you know, to just get that access there. So I'm hoping with some current equipment that we can possibly gather here that it gives us a spare plus, get us to open some more of these trails and paths for people to use. I don't know if that's what Stu was looking to touch faces on. So new routes, Main Street. So we see that as a priority route.

6:31 So we're classifying that as a route that will be cleared greater than two to three plus inches of snow twice in a 12-hour period. I think that's the expectation of the community. And that distance is approximately two miles. Safe routes to schools, and that's include the new Meridian sidewalk here as much as we can. It is, I think, about five feet right, which is the width of the auger. The majority of it is, yes. Yeah, so that's part of our network as well.

6:58 Again, that'll be cleared two to three inches of snow twice in a 12-hour period, and that's about three miles, that entire network. And our secondary routes, which includes that new section over in Mammoth Creek, is cleared once in a 12-hour period, and that's approximately two and a half miles. So our current snow removal procedure, I'll kind of walk through it. Warren can kind of add anything as I go. We basically have two year-round parks maintenance staff, which is Derek and Juan.

7:27 And they also do that and also our ice rink, which gets kind of covered at the end of their shifts or at the beginning, depends when they're going. One operator is on duty typically in a 12-hour period, but Warren could talk about one and how he just wakes up and gets going. Routes typically require two passes, which we've talked about. And then Warren will assist as needed to cover sidewalks, no removal shifts. He helps out with parks, sorry, public works.

7:55 with priority emergency street snow removal efforts. So anything you wanted to add on that, little Warren? One of the biggest concerns with what we have going on right now is we do have currently two machines. The more and more that we take on, we noticed it a little bit during the heavy snow year two years ago, where we did lose a machine for a couple days. And in that two-day process, it seems like we did lose a couple of the routes, and that's kind of where we kind of finished off on those routes.

8:24 Possibly adding the extra piece of equipment that would give us a backup machine for sure and be able to actually have someone out there pretty much for the 24-hour basis. At times, we try to cover the 24, but it doesn't always work out that way. We try to have somebody out there for 12 and 12, but it's not always feasible that way. With having that third machine and being able to get another third guy out there, I think our expectations of removing the snow will be much higher and be able to

8:53 Accommodate people in town quite a bit more. And then Juan has this uncanny neck to just without even looking out the window and know how much snow is on the ground and he's going to be up and he's going to be plowing. So, you know what I mean? So the whole time is challenging. Anyway, we have some amazing staff. So what we're saying and what we're proposing, you know, with the additional linear feet of our sidewalk system and our multi-use pass is to add an additional employee.

9:23 So this is the proposal that we're bringing forward. Council are actually addressing this tomorrow night. So what we're recommending and what is in the recommendation right now is for Council to award an additional $25,000 of labour. We're about 20, so 2025 is kind of the number we're trying to still finalise. And then we have $175,000 set aside right now that Council is looking to consider.

9:51 Awarding for a new tractor to perform these services. So they're really kind of a critical component of the newer sidewalk snow removal plan and our multi-use paths. So what that would mean is that would get us an additional employee, which as Warren would say, then we could very much cover the 24 hours. And then one of the options is to actually run a three by eight hour shift, which we think would be far more effective to give us that coverage throughout the day.

10:18 So that's kind of what we're really kind of moving forward with. Warren kind of talked about the fleet a little bit. So we have two trackless snowblowers. You've seen them out there. Very efficient. They're 75 horsepower, five-foot wide auger unit. We have one machine's about 1,800. The other machine's about 860, which is our newer one. And we have a backup auger that's going to be reconditioned this fall.

10:44 As Warren said, the current concerns will add approximately 2 plus miles, 20-25% to the current network. We just don't have the equipment or staff to really complete the additional snow removal program of work based on the level of service. So we could perform that level of service, but we'd only be planning that route once in a 12-hour period, which is, I don't believe, satisfactory. Again, we don't have a backup unit. If something goes offline, major service impact during peak snow removal periods.

11:14 And then the other one too is sidewalk snow removal is subject to street snow removal. So what we're proposing for Main Street right now is we're going to be pushing all that snow from that street and that area down to kind of a snow storage area and then we'll be trucking it. So that's going to be the situation. So they're not going to be blowing it on Warren's path and Warren's not going to be blowing it back on the street again. We're going to be pushing it down to a snow removal area and then trucking it. And that's kind of the agreement they're working through with Caltrans right now.

11:44 Perform that service. In addition, what that would mean is an additional plow truck to the fleet for public works to be able to perform that service. So none of this is cheap, but we're trying to get ahead of it right now to make sure that we deconstruct these sidewalks, we can remove the snow on the sidewalks and allow our public to use them. So that's what that means. Our recommendation, which I briefly talked about, is to add about

12:11 900 to 1,000 hours for a seasonal employee, which is about 20 to 25,000. That's kind of what we're really kind of putting in as a recommendation. And again, that's just going to be for winter snow removal services. In discussions with Dan and Rob, you know, this is something we want to look at. We know it's going to grow over time. So this year, we just want to kind of get the program up, look if we can get the machine, get a driver as it becomes more

12:38 Either noticeable or it's something that everyone sees that there's a greater need for, then we can kind of reconsider or at least talk about the changes status of employee. But right now we're just looking at adding a seasonal employee just to get the program up. And then you can see here we're looking at a, and Warren will talk about it coming up in some slides, which is a new holder tractor. It's a different machine than we looked at in the past.

13:03 We're looking at a demo unit, and the demo unit means that we save about $10,000, and we can get it here pretty much immediately. It was here about six weeks ago. Warren can talk about it in a sec. So that's kind of what we're proposing to Council, and that's kind of what we're looking at tomorrow night. So before I hand over to Warren, this is basically the machine. These are a couple of slides.

13:28 And the whole key and why we're looking at this machine versus a typical trackless is its multi-purpose versatility. So we're going to kind of walk through that. Not only is it far more efficient for wintertime, just with its horsepower and its reliability and its engine and its performance, but also its use in our trail systems in summertime and so forth. So here we go, buddy. As Steve stated, we currently do run trackless. That's what they have been running over the...

13:56 I'd have to say the last 15 years. Definitely since I've been here over the last three years. We do have a current, as you saw, that one machine only has 860 hours, a pretty newer machine. The reason that we're kind of looking towards Holder is Holder was taken over by our old sales rep that had trackless, and he was very good with us. He actually got us all of our parts and took care of us all the time. The new trackless dealers, they keep on bouncing around. We're starting to have issues trying to acquire the parts.

14:26 So we're looking at the serviceability and being able to get the parts, and he's pretty much guaranteeing that. One of the other big factors on it, as Stu mentioned, trackless runs at 75 horsepower. Holder runs at 129 horsepower. Some of this new snow that we have up on Main Street I really think is going to be challenging for us because we are going to be getting all of Main Street over towards the sidewalk. They say they're trying to keep it off there, but I know that's most likely not going to happen.

14:54 So as you all know, when you plow your driveway and you try to push snow that's already been pushed around, it's pretty challenging. So I think having the extra horsepower would definitely work out pretty well. When they did bring the machine down, it does look quite a bit beefier than a trackless. I reached out to several of the private contractors in town that have Randholder in the past, and one of them just swore by it. He sat there and said it was the most comfortable machine he had and pushed him out.

15:23 Push some really good snow. So on that aspect of trying to get someone that actually does it in a private factor and they kind of tell you that kind of gave us a pretty good word for holder in itself. Other than that, I just think that the machine itself being the bigger horsepower and what we're going to try to accomplish on trying to keep some of these paths open that do get more snow would be definitely kind of a winning factor for us overall.

15:53 As Stu just brought up the pictures here and talking about the holder being able to accommodate other things that we do, as you can see in the pictures, there's sweeper aspects, there's mowers, the bed on the holder actually tilts and dumps. What one of the private guys mentioned in the fact is putting in an extra fuel tank on the back. Right now we currently sometimes run all the way back down to the shop to refill, which is

16:21 Time-consuming if you're all the way up at the village. So if we can actually acquire and put the fuel tank on there, he'd be able to fill himself plus the other trackless that's out there at the time. So I think that'd be a huge savings. The more and more that we sweep our trails and the more we have of trying to keep quality air around the area, there is a sweeper attachment that comes with this that you don't just push it out there in all the descos there were. It actually sucks it into the back and has a little hopper.

16:50 So actually the dust collection would be very minimal compared to how we sweep now. So I think that would be a very, what I want to say, a good attachment for the machine for the way we're trying to keep air quality in the area kind of cleaned up. But as you can see, there is several attachments to this, and it sounds like it is pretty much a multi-use machine that we could use personally, plus I think we could actually use it down at the airport when they're using some of their mower stuff.

17:20 And then that's our last slide. That was kind of Warren's photo from a couple years ago. As you can tell, we do get a little bit of snow. So the tracklesses do push some snow, as you can see by the picture. That was actually down there by the hospital. And that was in the big year, of course. But as you all know, we do have our big years and we do have our small years. So for years like that, our newest trackless took a pretty good beating on that year. And so it's definitely nice to have a spare when we do have that kind of snow around.

17:50 So there we go. That's in our presentation in a nutshell. Any questions on that? Thank you. I think we'll take questions from the commissioners, and then I know we have some members of the public who were here for the presentation, so we'll do questions from commission, then public comment, then come back for any comments or direction. Laurel, any questions? Yeah, I feel like at one point we were talking about, and then this could be a different position, but this being a hybrid...

18:16 Parks and Public Works position. Was that this one or was this somebody else that we were talking about? Yeah, we have a hybrid position right now, which is great. That's Zeke. So Zeke's with us in the summertime and he goes back to public works in the wintertime. Okay. So what would this person do if it doesn't snow? This would just be a seasonal. I just wouldn't be paid. Yeah, but actually in wintertime. In the wintertime, we actually still have

18:42 Plenty of snow to do. I mean, we maintain all the machines. We go out and repair trail posts. We can still go down on a very light year that I've noticed since I've been here. We can still do quite a bit of work down at Whitmore. All the maintenance, ball fields. We can do stuff around the pool, kind of getting it ready for the next season. So anytime there is downtime, there's plenty of stuff to do for us to acquire that. And then also, we have in the past when the road department's been shorthanded, and we've even given them a guy to help out also.

19:11 Yeah, there's plenty of work in the... It was a couple of years ago. A couple of years ago, we managed to fix the fence at Mammoth Creek Park and all these jobs that were just kind of so pushed back and deferred for so many years, so it really does give us an opportunity to kind of get ahead for many projects, yeah. Excellent. That's all. Sean, questions? Yeah, I've got some comments, questions. I'm jealous. These things are pretty nice in the yard. What's the average lifespan of one of these units? I guess I'm looking at the...

19:40 Two that we currently have at 1,800 and 850 hours. I want to say when I got here, the other machine, we had quite a few issues. We kind of replaced the tranny, some clutches and something else. It seemed like it was kind of every time we ran it, something was breaking with it. And I want to say when we got rid of that machine and traded it in, it had over 4,000 miles or 4,000 hours on it. So I think it had 4,100 or something. Okay. And this would be the first one that as you're calling it a holder, but I assume that just means it's got a bed.

20:09 In the back. That's actually the brand name of it. Brand name. Okay. Yep. All right. And you're calling them trackless. They have tires. Do we have any tracked vehicles? No, we don't. I didn't think so. Okay. Makes sense to me. And we're not proposing buying any of these attachments that were on this page at this time. Currently, no. Just the blower, though. The blower attachment would be a new attachment that came with it. So that would still, he would put the new one on there and that would still refurbish our other one.

20:38 So we do have a spare. That seems to be where the biggest issues come from and where the most damage comes from is in the heads itself. So to be able to have a spare head laying around is pretty nice. Yeah, okay. Are you getting the extra fuel tank? The fuel tank, the company that actually just took over Holder, this group, he's actually developed and made fuel tanks. So he's actually going to look into that and possibly see what he can do for putting one on the back of there.

21:07 Okay. So that's not included in this $197. That's not included in this price, no. Okay. And that was actually going to be one of my questions is it sounds like Town Council has already identified the money to be able to pay for this? Mm-hmm. Okay. Have we already talked about the fact that, you know, we will want a fuel tank or you will want a fuel tank? You know, just starting to at least prepare them for a future budget? I actually spoke with...

21:30 The holder rep and plus Lonnie at the town yard. The fuel tank would be next to minimal. It wouldn't be a huge cost savings to where they would have to get a whole bunch of money. It sounded like it would be less than $500. Okay. Well, great. I just want to make sure that we're, you know, letting everyone know ahead of time. I'm going to go back to the routes.

21:50 Frankly, I've never been more excited about a public works project than to see the sidewalk going up Main Street. And now that we're talking about doing that around the corner there from the village to Main Street, which is, I can tell you personally, is a very dangerous corner from people nearly getting killed and the additional sidewalks. So you're adding all that in. I think you said 22 extra miles were being added in. How long does it take to do two miles?

22:19 I don't really want to say for, on most of our snow with the track list, which is kind of a bonus, is it's just fallen snow. It's nothing that's been packed or pushed over. I think it's going to be a little more challenging with us on the 203 aspect because everything that is getting pushed over to the side has already been plowed and already been packed. So to really throw a figure out there without us having done it, I can't really say for sure. I do know the,

22:48 Up there in the village, just that front section on the front half where burgers and stuff is, I know the one guy can spend up to an hour and a half to two hours there just clearing that and getting it pushed back over by the time road department comes in and pushes it and clears it off. So by having that section on burger side and on the village side, he can possibly spend up to about an hour and a half to two hours right in that section alone.

23:11 Okay. Yeah, that does look like it's going to be a major challenge. You mentioned snow storage somewhere. Is this what you and Caltrans are working out? We're in the process of working on that, yes. Okay. Because, yeah, I can see one pushing it, you know, just back and forth. Can I ask where that snow storage is, or should we wait for details when you guys get it worked out? Majority of our snow storage right now on-site is just off the easement of the roads. Okay. Everything else that gets trucked out does go to the snow pit out.

23:39 where I'm sure everybody knows where the snow pit is off of 203. Okay, but for now, just pushing it off the easement? Off easement sections, yes. It sounds like they're in the process of trying to figure out where we're going to actually store that snow if we do, and the talk, we're still talking about that. Okay. That one sounds like the challenge. Yes. Okay. Thank you. That's it for me. Thank you, Christy. Those are great questions. I'm checking off all my questions as we're talking. Thank you, Sean.

24:09 The only question, oh, I have two questions. One is, and I think I know the answer to this, but just to get it out there, the holder and the trackless attachments aren't compatible, are they? Actually, the harness that comes on the holder, it's the same company as making it, so our current front attachments will fit onto the holder.

24:35 They will? They will. They will fit us? They're all interchangeable. Oh, that's outstanding. Thank you. That was one of the main reasons to, yeah. Glad I asked. Yeah. And then, are there any regulations that we should be aware of for putting a fuel tank on the back of that unit? There is. You can only get up to a current amount of gallons, and we're way under the gallonage for having any kind of hazmat or any kind of license for having to do that. Okay. Thank you. That was part of the OSHA training.

25:04 Good questions. Thank you. So, no, those were all great questions. I just have one question, and that is, you know, if this position, you know, is approved and we buy the equipment, any consideration in the future for maybe looking at doing another, you know, hybrid position or adding another parks maintenance position, just given all the work that we've been doing in parks maintenance of late? There has been, yes. But at this time, the budget and our recommendation is just to put in a seasonal. Okay.

25:34 And then we can kind of work to understand the scope of the program and kind of match it with the right kind of employee mix, so to speak. Thank you. You're welcome. Okay, at this time, I will open the floor for public comment. If anyone has any comments, if you could just come up to the dais and state your name. Seeing no, all right, seeing no public rushing for the podium.

26:02 I'll bring it back to the Commission for just any consensus, comments, or direction to staff. Christine, would you like to start? Yeah, just my comments are I benefit from this. I'm pretty excited, as Sean is, and when we had the big 2016-2017 winter,

26:26 The fact that you could clear that sidewalk going up Lake Mary Road made it safer for our workers and guests. And my only comment would be in that regard is that I'm very interested in hearing what Caltrans says about snow storage, especially in Old Mammoth, because that's where some of our workforce lives. And I'm very interested in making sure that we have a safe environment for both our residents and our guests.

26:56 And then the other thing I would like to comment on is we talk a lot about having a feet first community. And I strongly believe that the multi-use paths being accessible in both summer and winter can help our community achieve that feet first dream. So I think that we need to keep on prioritizing our multi-use paths year round. Thank you.

27:22 I agree with what Christy said. I think this is a safety and a commitment we need to make to our residents and guests. So I fully agree with everything that you guys have presented and hope that we get some snow. Not really, but I'm telling myself that. Sean? No further comments. My biggest concern is just do we got the money for it? It is important.

27:53 Has the money for it. I am all for this recommendation. My only comment is I just I feel that we have come so far in the past few years in terms of clearing snow from sidewalks, from multi-use paths at the same time that we're adding a lot of that infrastructure. I know that, you know, a few years ago we didn't clear, you know, the Lake Mary path at all and now we do and I see people using it all the time. I know you do too. So I just I think it's fantastic and I'm really pleased to see actually that

28:22 In purchasing equipment, we're looking at equipment that would also have some summer uses. And I would definitely, you know, urge the council to consider, you know, also setting aside some funding to purchase these attachments so that we're able to get, you know, the full use. This is something Bill used to talk about all the time is that, you know, why are we only, you know, why are we...

28:41 These things are available. Why are we only purchasing things that can be used in winter? So I think that's great. And I hope that we have lots of snow. I hope that we do not have so much snow that Warren spends all of his time over in public works clearing snow. But I'm really pleased. And I hope that we're able to continue to just keep up the good work that we've done on this. So thank you. Yeah, thank you. It really has come a long way, I think, in the last two, three years, especially. So I know Warren and his crew are doing an amazing job.

29:10 Absolutely. Much appreciated. Thank you. Okay. That will move us on to our discussion items. So we will move to item number three, the Parks and Recreation Department Monthly Report. Anything you'd like to highlight for us, Stu? Thank you, Chair. A couple of items here that you can see. Thank you, Lauren, for putting this together in Stu's absence. So Lauren and her team,

29:40 You know, wrapped up our adult men's COVID softball league, and you know, the tournament's concluded in July. We wrapped that up with a September 12th recap meeting, if you want to elaborate on that. But anyway, the takeaway from that is we have a lot of good feedback, information, and actionable items to improve the program for next year. So that was very helpful. We're kind of wrapping up our kind of our bread and butter, our staff evaluations.

30:10 You know, we're doing some nice thank you cards for our staff, just some personal recognition for their artwork, because as you'll see in the presentation, it was a pretty impressive and stellar summer. Thanks, Warren. Thank you. Thanks, Warren. The next big event for us is the annual Halloween Party Haunted Roll Rink, October 26, fingers crossed that we get some nice weather. So that one's coming up. We're planning for that right now. And then as Hot Shots Basketball gets underway, October 1.

30:38 Sorry, November 1, Registration, October 1. Anything awesome? Prop 68, I added the legislative update to the back of that packet. There was a program that just came out this week on Prop 68, so we're starting to see those grant programs get out and about. So the first one you can see is Prop 84, Continuation, and then the second one is a per capita program.

31:09 So we have, I think, a per capita program, grant program out right now. So we're evaluating that one for use. Some of the applicable uses for it would be conservation, water usage. But there also is the section in there on community amenities and activities and facilities. So we want to kind of take a look at that and see if that's something we can apply for.

31:35 I have a question on that. Yeah. So it talks in here about city, county, and district overlapping. Are we going to run into an issue where we're overlapping with the county? Yeah, that was some of the questions that we still have to ratify. And I know a lot of them have that underserved sections in them as well. And a lot of those are outside our area and actually more in the county. So again, it's something we'll have to look at. I think we definitely want to coordinate with the county. Good questions, yeah. Moving forward.

32:04 Yeah, I agree with that. So that's something that we'll be coming up with and we'll certainly talk with, I know Matt's not here, but certainly have Matt's insight on that as well. Deferred maintenance program, that's something we'll be bringing back to Commission on our next meeting, so we'll talk about that at the end of the agenda, but that's kind of our deferred maintenance program presentation, so we'll have that to you. In addition, I also wanted to say that Council are also considering an additional $100,000 for our deferred maintenance program.

32:33 Tomorrow night. So that's something that we've been working on phase two. Warren and I had some brief conversations before I left and he left. So if that is awarded, we'll be able to kind of look into that phase two program and get that back to you next month as well. So that's great news. So it seems like we really address a lot of these deferred issues in our parks. And then we're really just rolling into not only the Halloween event, but winter.

33:01 So the Multi-Use Facility is scheduled to open November 23rd, not that long away. So we're already kind of rolling along with our schedules. Kat will be before you November 6th, we think. We hope. Fingers crossed. If not, Stu and Lauren will be doing that for you. But that will be the Mammoth Ice Rink Operating Plan. So we'll kind of get you showing that one as well. And then you can see that we're starting to, and if Warren was here, to tell you that they're essentially winterizing.

33:30 All their facilities right now. I'm looking at some freezers coming in later this week and the weekend, so we'll have to keep an eye on that for our pipes and our irrigation systems. It's too early, obviously, to shut it off, so we've got to keep an eye on those. But we will be taking down the shade covers from the new playground, hopefully this week. Most of our staff kind of wind out this week. I think Marco's last day is Wednesday? His last day is Friday. Friday, yeah.

34:01 Pretty much everyone's last day is Friday. I know we might have one employee that will kind of stay with us, so we're trying to get through most of those projects. So we're kind of going into this, you know, slower phase, if you will. So that's the legislative update. That's just something for your information. I'll try and include that with this packet as it comes along. It's just something that we track and we watch through CPRS, so always good to keep an eye on. That's all I had. Do you have anything? Lauren's been.

34:27 running pretty much the department for the last month. Thank you, Lauren. I hope that you too get to take a vacation. And one thing I wanted to just add on the legislative updates is those are also tracked by our Commissioner's Association and we meet later on this month. We'll be going down to Orange County for our meeting. So if you have any strong opinions on any of the legislation that you would like me to...

34:48 Make any recommendations because like CPRS, CAPR, CBM also weighs in on pending legislation in Sacramento. And we also work with the CPRS lobbyists too. So there's that. So any comments or questions on the staff report from commission? I just have one. What's this weekend that says the LA Kings hockey camp? Yes, Mammoth Youth Hockey.

35:15 Worked in partnership with the LA hockey development team and scheduled a camp. We had one scheduled a couple of years ago. Couldn't pull it off because it snowed. And also, the cost was inhibitive at the time. So what we're doing is Mammoth Hockey working with the development team to provide a lower entry point for the camp. So they've got, I think, 25 kids right now. I don't know if you've heard any latest as well.

35:44 So they're looking at about 30 plus, which will be great. So it's an excellent program, you know, great quality program, and it's a way for them that they want to kind of kick off their winter season, you know, with a high professional camp from LA Kings. So it's very exciting. Most of those we've got scheduled in. As you can see, it's not full and complete, the schedule, but we've got that camp locked in. We've actually got the hockey tournament. It's actually the weekend following now.

36:08 And then the Calder Classic is back. It's a seven-day event. They were looking at kind of shrinking to four. What they're going to do, though, is flip the schedule. So they'll have the older kids first and then the younger kids after. And they were doing that. I'm not too sure why, but we'll see how we go. But anyway, so that's all locked in. The only changes this year to the ice rink were, I think, some modifications to the fee schedules. But other than that, we're just kind of...

36:36 Trying to expand and fit in our expanding curling league, you know, so we're looking at a couple of nights for that. So we'll have that scheduled to next month. Any other questions or comments from Commission? No, I'm going to ask my question about just the Lakes Basin. Although all the campgrounds are closed at this point, is that right? I have not been connected, Sean, so I haven't seen anything via email to tell me that they have or they haven't.

37:05 Okay. Is that something that we can ask them to report out, the Forest Service? I mean, I know they do, but again, I just want to make sure that we are communicating with us. We usually get that State of the Inyo report, too, so I just haven't seen that for a while, so I'm always kind of relying upon that to, you know, pass that information on to you. Okay. But I will follow it up, and I will get it to the Commission. Thank you very much. I understand, I think, some of the challenges, and thank you for me to ask that question.

37:34 Then along those lines, Stu, do you have any updates on the hiring of the Joint Recreation Coordinator position? Matt alluded to that in our last meeting. I haven't. So they've had 80 plus applicants and they had a pool of nine I think they were interviewing. Yeah, so a lot of good candidates. We're also, I mean, back to Sean's point about the Forest Service, we'd have...

38:02 Preliminary conversations with Margie and her team about how do we provide additional services in the Lakes Basin. So it's a bit premature right now, but there is an opportunity for the town to be part of that solution. So we might be looking at some options. If they have the funding, we can maybe provide that service. So that's something that Warren and I will be talking about and hopefully bringing it forward to commission.

38:25 Great. And I think, you know, if you have a chance to, could you also push out that article that we both just read about municipalities filling in funding gaps on federal land? It was very interesting. We're obviously not the only community in this position, so I think it's something you all might find to be a good read.

38:46 One other thing, so hopefully with the colder weather moving in, this won't be quite as much of an issue, but there, and I meant to mention this to Warren while he was still here, he probably knows, but there are a ton of bees on at least the first, the U-12 soccer field at Shady West. He's aware of the bees. They're just attracted by water. Yeah, exactly. They've been trying to deal with any sort of pooling out there and whatnot, but... Honeybees are like yellow jackets.

39:14 They're more yellow jackets. They come out of the ground. Yeah. They've definitely caused some interruption in play. Thank you. Can I, back to Sean's point about the lake space, and I've been hearing anecdotally of some challenges by day use folks trying to access things like Duck Pass Trailhead when the Inyo Recreation folks are blocking off the campground.

39:40 Them almost belligerently saying, no, I won't move that barricade so you can drive out and people having to squeeze their cars through and things like that. So if we can just keep the forest accessible to all when it's allowed and keep involved in that conversation so things like that don't turn folks away from using our resources. Wow, thanks for that.

40:05 And then I'll talk, since I know Sean's headed out of town this weekend, so I'll talk about our Saturday training when we get to commissioner reports, if that's okay. So we can just keep moving. So, hey, anything further on the staff report? Any comments from the public on the staff report? Thank you very much, and thanks very much for putting this back on discussion items, because I know we were always pulling it, because we were very interested and supportive of everything you guys do. Welcome.

40:35 All right, that will move us on to item number four, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Update. Is it the year-round recreation center? Yeah. Yes, which is what we're supposed to call it now. Just want to confirm we were talking about the year-round recreation center. Year-round outdoor recreation center. Perhaps we would like to talk about that in his report. Yeah, the current, yeah, anyway. Moving on.

41:03 The Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Project update. So I'm just going to cover kind of facility design and then second part of that is kind of our community engagement public outreach efforts. So the first section of this is facility design. I know you discussed this item when Grady was here in September. I wasn't absent. I'm not going to get into a lot of that. I wasn't part of that discussion. I was briefed on kind of what took place.

41:33 What we're really going to cover here is essentially the construction management services request for qualification. So this was posted by the town. You're more than welcome to look at this document. We received, I think, about eight or nine submittals for those construction management services currently where we have a kind of internal and external team reviewing those proposals.

41:59 So the goal of this process is to identify a construction management firm. With that, there won't be a fee at that time. It'll just be basically who's kind of our bench, as Hayes would say. If Hayes was here, that's what he'd say. So who's kind of our bench of construction management services and firms to be able to provide a broad scope of services to the town. So as you know...

42:25 You know, what we're really looking at as you look at this document, it's representative of not only the town but also the county and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. As we understand, there's a multitude of projects being planned for and funded for over the next decade here in our area. So this CM services team is going to be quite instrumental and critical in delivering.

42:48 You know, these projects to the community. So what we're looking for here is a firm that can kind of assist us in not only our year-round recreation centre, the parcel, the Mammoth Unified School District project, the county jail building, and also the multi-arts and cultural centre, or the MAC, at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. So if you add up all of these projects, you know, it's 100 plus million.

43:11 That's going to be part of this package. So it's a large undertaking. And as you know, it is certainly, and what we've kind of determined through the public bidding process, this is certainly a smarter and more strategic delivery method than what we've tried in the past. So a lot of this verbiage is taken from the previous presentation that we made to the commission that kind of Grady put together.

43:38 And that's really that a construction management firm will work directly, you know, with and engage with HMC. So they just want to make sure that, you know, what they're producing in the package, the materials, components is consistent with and complements the current bidding climate and available resources that they can provide as well.

43:59 We'll also be able to kind of look at a broader scope as we talked about. So once we have this kind of bench team of construction management services, the goal would be then to kind of partner back with HMC and to look at these alternatives that council have directed us to do. So our plan right now is to come back to council in November with one a construction management firm or firms and then a scope of services to

44:27 kind of lay out or our path forward for the year-round recreation centre over at Mammoth Creek Park and that would consist of what the direction has been that council has provided us and that's kind of looking at that rink and the roof concept, removing that community centre, how does that look and any other alternatives that council would direct us to at that time. But right now the direction from council is to, as they've directed us to from June 6th, is to bring a bench team together

44:57 Work with HMC, provide a scope of services and come back with kind of an estimated cost of what it would be to kind of move this project forward. As a case in point, HMC have been working with the town over the last, you know, several months on kind of forensically analysing, right, the project, what happened, where we were, and I know Hayes has made, you know, so many presentations before you and certainly the council, but any work moving forward with HMC would be for additional cost.

45:25 So what they committed to was just kind of what they delivered with that package. So we want to make sure everybody's clear on that, that whatever the CM firm and HMC work together on to revise the direction from council, that would be at that additional time and cost. So that's something we want to bring to commission, make sure everyone's aware of that, and certainly to council in November, and to get clear and concise and articulate direction from council at that time with this project.

45:55 That's basically the presentation. I'm happy to send this around if you did want to look at this. I know some of the team reviewing is Mammoth Lakes Foundation have the CM proposals. We have them internally as well. I haven't checked in with Hayes yet, but I know they're very eager to kind of get going on selecting that firm. So here we go. Do you want to stop there before we move on to community engagement? Yes, I have stopped there. Okay. Thank you. Questions for Stu from the commission. I have one. Does anyone else?

46:25 No questions but comments. Okay, well, I'll have you hold those until after we take any public comment. Christy, Laurel, any questions? No. I have a quick question, Stu. I know that Grady alluded at our last meeting to the council budget discussions tomorrow night, and Sean and I also had a meeting with the town manager and Grady and Councilmember Sauser, and...

46:50 Can you just tell us if there's anything that we need to be aware of going into those discussions related to this project? For tomorrow night's meeting? Yeah. As you know, I've been a little out and about. So at this time, all I know is that the items before council is what's kind of in front of me and what is articulated in the council packet. And there's no funding in those documents that's allocated right now for that project. Thank you.

47:22 Sean, did you want to add anything in about our meeting? No, just convinced me. Well, I'll save that comment. But, sorry, when you said funds allocated for this project here with regard to the outreach? No, no, just with the project in general. So tomorrow night council, you know, is making the funding recommendations of some of the surplus from the current. Okay. Or, sorry, the last year, last fiscal year. Right.

47:52 Council in front of me right now is just these funding items of these incidentary items. I don't know if there's going to be a formal discussion. I believe they will bring it up and talk about it because it's certainly in their purview to do so. I'm just not aware of any amount or discussion or what it's going to be. So I apologize. I'm not able to give you any insight of how this is going to go.

48:20 Okay, good. And that was a good meeting. Wouldn't you agree? Oh, yeah. No, it was a very good meeting. Okay, good. Any comments from the public on the facility design? Okay, seeing none, I'll move on to the community engagement section of the item. Thank you. So, as you know, we began planning for this project several years ago, 2015 to be exact, and we...

48:45 started with kind of our mission, and our mission is, you know, as for the Recreation Commission in our department, is to provide multi-purpose, multi-generational, year-round, indoor and outdoor recreation that provides accessible recreation opportunities for both our residents and visitors. So when we started this project, we developed, you know, several goals. As you know, it's been on our website, and that's been something that we've been integrating, immersing, and kind of advocating for throughout this project.

49:14 And they are really to, you know, create a venue that encourages and facilitates social interaction, enriches quality of life, and through enhanced and innovative programming, promoting our healthy and active lifestyles. That's kind of what we're about. So where we are now, I think, is at a point that we have a real opportunity, and this is something that, you know, I think the Commission's been pretty strong on consistently, you know, certainly over the last three years and certainly in the last, you know, six months.

49:42 The last couple of months as we've been getting closer to these detailed discussions and financing and the challenges that we're experiencing, that there seems to be an opportunity to provide some more clearly defined descriptions of the project. So there's clearly, as we know, I don't have to talk about it too much, but there's a lot of negative, there's a lot of misinformed rhetoric in the community about what the multi-use facility is.

50:11 So what we've kind of put together here is a recommendation or an option for the Commission to kind of embark on a kind of strategic, integrated, and I would say probably at this point a pretty expedited public outreach campaign. I know we've talked about it, ad hoc committees with our friends at Mammoth Lakes Recreation. But now more than ever, as we're getting closer to...

50:36 These decisions, decision points that Council have been making regarding these additional funds and these projects, I really believe we need to kind of take it upon ourselves to communicate to the public clearly what we're proposing. As we know, it's not just an ice rink, right? It's not just for hockey players. This is a year-round recreation centre. We see, as you know, this is more of a facility in summer than winter.

51:01 This is not only for our programs, it's also for our events. It's not only for our recreational skaters, it's for a lot of our community members who just need a place to either interact, just need opportunities to have a place to...

51:20 Enjoying the wintertime during, you know, heavy snowfalls or in summertime to get out of the weather and those type of things. So it's really what we see is this kind of, and what we've talked about consistently, you know, over the period of time is this recreation destination that we really believe the community needs at the park, right? That's kind of the way we've been kind of promoting this project. The playground is just one element of this park project and this is that, you know, major other component that we believe will add so much more of what we've talked about with our mission and then the goals that you've defined.

51:49 So what we're really proposing here, as I've kind of stated, is to kind of work through a really kind of focused communication plan, see what we can kind of get out there. A couple of the deliverables, I know we can kind of talk about this, but making sure that our, you know, communication on our websites, if you've seen New Mammoth Lakes Recreation website, making sure that, you know, whatever's going out on that and whatever else on our website is consistent. You know, an FAQ document that we've kind of thrown around, we've tried, you know, but now I think there's some real opportunity. Some fact sheets that are bilingual.

52:19 Print ads, notices, subscriber lists, you know, some, some, is it a targeted social media campaign that we can kind of push out there that really kind of, you know, works to turn this negative rhetoric around or this mince information about the project. So what I'd really like to do is kind of ask the commission to support, obviously, this, you know, endeavor. I'm prepared to meet with Matt on Thursday. I believe the chair will come along to that meeting as well.

52:46 Vice Chair if needed as well. I know we can only have two in those meetings. And then we'd like to convene that ad hoc committee and see if we can get some traction. I'd like to see if we can kind of, you know, do this in a coordinated manner and approach. And is there an opportunity to look at, you know, a third party helping us, you know, with this effort? You know, so there's kind of my thoughts and comments. I know that the Commission would like to kind of weigh in on it as well. And that's all I have at this time. Thank you. I'm sure we would. Thank you.

53:13 Questions or comments on this community outreach plan? Sean? Yeah, this is where I want to say my comments. And, you know, everyone knows that I'm a strong supporter of this event. I like the idea of really referring to it as exec. I like the year-round outdoor recreation center in that it really does capture this.

53:35 And as I've said, and I think many people have said, that this is not a hockey rink. It is also a hockey rink, but I want to be clear that it is not first and foremost a hockey rink. Frankly, ever since we've been discussing this, I've been more excited about the summer opportunities for it than the winter, especially watching how many youth

53:54 Participants we have in our summer camps who are currently having to meet in that exposed area right now, being able to have a covered outdoor recreation center that is truly outdoor with the kind of views that we're talking about at Mammoth Creek Park West. I think that one of the best things we can do right now is explain to our community why we want this and why we are recommending it so much and that it is not so much of a winter.

54:22 Facility as much as it is a year-round facility. I just want to highlight a couple of sentences that you say in here without overstating it, that this is a multi-generational, kids, adults, all ages, multi-purpose. I can think of dozens of uses for this arena, for this center, and probably many more that we haven't even considered. Year-round.

54:49 Indoor and Outdoor Recreation Opportunities. I'm just very excited at the potential for this. And then going back to the next steps, I think that this is most important. We will certainly provide comments as we're doing here and direction, but really the goal here is to communicate just what this multi-use facility is.

55:12 Even though that's not the name of it, for what we're going to be doing. I like what you've outlined here. I think it really is important that we, I will get involved in private conversations with my community members and explain some of the things that I truly know about what the potential is for this site, for this facility and what we're going to do with it.

55:34 And just to be clear, the funds that we are really looking at, and I know that this will go into more detail with town council, the funds, these aren't funds that can be easily shifted to other projects. It's not like we're stealing from other projects to make this a possibility within the town council's general budget. And Stu, I just wanted to confirm that that's my understanding, that this is not...

56:02 These are not funds that are easily being taken from somewhere else. Yeah, so the Measure R bond, as you know, is a $5.5 million bond, and then I think we're still sitting on that $3 million of Measure R, Measure U money. So the budget right now is about a $9 million budget. I know council is kind of looking at that $13 million number, but there's, you know, $9 million set aside specifically, which is special use tax money, you know, recreation, trails, parks, arts and culture and so forth that can be used.

56:31 This facility, right? So the additional monies can either be looked at, you know, those special use taxes again, or which is really the discussion about, you know, what is the obligation of the general fund to this project? Fair enough. Thank you. Those are my comments. Laurel? I think that we have been saying here for months, all of us independently, that we need to make sure that the public understands this process. So I think that that is a...

57:01 Primary objective, and I agree that she needs to be expedited because, you know, we've already moved on to the next big thing or whatever, and I still constantly have conversations with folks where they're saying, no, no, that's not happening, or information that is just not correct. So I think this is a very much-needed effort, and I fully support that, moving forward with that, getting the right word out. Very timely, isn't it? Yeah. Thank you. Christine?

57:35 All I have to say, Stu, is obviously I do this for a living, like communication plans are my bread and butter. Unfortunately, I don't have a lot of time to jump in and get my hands dirty with it, but if you need any templates that I use in terms of marketing audits, marketing plans, you know how I set up my...

57:57 Editorial calendars already. I'm available for that. The only other thing I would say, just given the climate, not just locally, but nationally in this country and how we speak to one another online, I would like to recommend that you have a good comment policy that would guide how we treat one another online.

58:26 And the only other recommendation is you have a great FAQ. Make sure that your channel manager has access to that FAQ. And think of your FAQ as sort of a place where you can pull information to answer questions in a really consistent way. But I know that sometimes we don't talk to one another with respect and dignity, and especially online, even in this town, which is odd because I'm like, I'm going to see you in this.

58:55 Post Office, for crying out loud. Like, I know who you are. You know, make sure that you have a very clear comment policy that also conforms with federal guidelines for governmental entities. My only comment before I go to public comment, and then we'll bring it back up for the commission to take action on the staff recommendations, is that, wow, I'm really glad that this is finally happening.

59:26 You know, I think it would have been helpful to have done this some time ago, but I'm glad that it is the staff recommendation and that we are certainly all in support of this. I think we've been looking for this for a long time, so thank you. And with that, I will go to public comment. Good morning, Michael Baker, resident. This is impromptu, but just understanding and watching over the last couple years the multi-use, now recreational facility.

1:00:01 The communication to the community as I try to stay connected, whether it be the social medias at large in the marketing realm, it's not clear. There sounds to be a wealth of information in use for this facility, but without studying it and just listening and doing readings and staying in touch with social media, the cascading in the communications can be better. And Sean, you were just sharing the elements, or you could think of,

1:00:31 A couple dozen reasons or purposes for this facility. Where are those? Has there been links? I know watching from afar, not immersed in the committees and the councils, there's just too many separate silos. I mean, from a social media standpoint, I don't understand why there's not more links. If this is important to recreation,

1:00:58 Why don't you see it through, whether it's the tourism side or M.O.R., all the sites, having that for linking to information somewhere near the homepage. I don't know if you agree from a marketing standpoint, but the cascading of communications to this community is to the value that R&U is feeding for this center, the purposes of that center. I don't think it's been heard very loud. You know, for the few that participate, like two of us in here today,

1:01:27 I think the communications can be better and improved without an expense as much as just partnering and sharing communications between the silos. Thank you. Thanks, Michael. Does he have a marketing firm? Ted Carlton. Two things. One, and I know this is not someone who's in this room today, but when Matt McLean was hired as a head of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and I just read this, I just came across this story the other day,

1:01:58 It was promised that he was going to raise $2 million over three years. And I would like to ask you all how much public money has been raised to date for this very, what you insist is a very well-supported public project, Stu? Seven grand? Six grand? Three grand? Okay, I don't even need to, you get my point. The second point is if you're going to do public outreach, and I'm sorry, I have plenty of

1:02:29 Ability to make public comments. So I don't normally make public comment, but I look at this agenda bill and it does sort of, you press my button and I'll come up here and I'll speak. When you promise at the outset a nine or ten million dollar project, then it comes in at 18 or 19, and then you come back and say, no, no, no, we got it back down to 13, first of all, you have a believability issue because no one believes, when you say a number, no one believes you, not a bit.

1:02:59 So I would get realistic and say, hey, I got a 15 or 16 million dollar project. I'm not going to lie to you. I'm going to put the number up here and I'm going to say, hey, and these are the things that we're going to do to get to that number or get to that point. I know you have eight or nine or 10 already there. Okay. But to simply blame it on, geez, you know, you got bad press or

1:03:27 Ted said some not nice things about me or, you know, we couldn't have anticipated the bid would come in at a number that if you talked to John Hooper, he could have told you that number from the very outset. If you're going to do this and start over, this is not the document where you're going to cast blame on all your detractors. Thank you. Thanks, Ted. Is that what we're doing? We're just taking public comment right now.

1:03:57 Good morning. I'm Sharon Clark. I want to thank you, Commissioner Turner, for talking into your microphone. I can hear you so well. But the two ladies at this end, please use your microphones. And I can hear you, Lauren. I'm very concerned about an ad hoc committee doing this work. I would like to be noticed when the ad hoc committee works.

1:04:27 Please. And you talked about a development team. Is the public aware of all of that? And how do we hear about what goes on in those meetings? Since there are no minutes, there's no information, really, until it comes back, and then it's a slam dunk. So I have problems with that.

1:04:56 And I think it's going to take all of us working together to get what we want. And I just hope there's some way for us to be more involved. Thank you. Thanks, Sharon. And Stu, maybe you can speak to that. I know that we typically report out the when the ad, because Sharon, the ad hoc committee most recently met a lot on the playground. And then that was reported out in at least our staff reports.

1:05:24 Yeah, and the ad hoc is not subject to the Brown Act, as you know, but really the purpose is just to kind of add that nature from a project-specific timing section. So we're just going to plan to meet once, you know, that both organisations can understand kind of the scope of what we're really trying to accomplish, come up with a plan, and then we're just going to work off and implement that plan. So I don't believe that that ad hoc committee will meet.

1:05:52 You know, again on any scheduled basis because it doesn't become an ad hoc committee at that point. So we're just going to make sure that both of these organisations who are responsible for, you know, this project for the community are on the same page, know what they're going to be doing together and then they can implement it in a cohesive manner with all the information coming back, as you know, every time at this commission meeting. And that's something that I think we've strived really hard to do to make sure that during each and every commission meeting that we have an item that we discuss.

1:06:20 You're able to come along and talk about. So I think that's really the goal of this committee. I think it's trying to be as transparent as possible. I just think we just need some cohesiveness and some traction, and we need to kind of get this done. And I appreciate Ted's comments as well, and I'm certainly going to be leaning on Ted and certainly on Michael, you know, and our community to kind of help us in this endeavour, right, because it's really a community amenity, and I think we're all advocates for it, you know, one way or the other, you know. So anyway, that's my comments. Thank you.

1:06:49 Can I just say one comment, following public? Great comments from all of you. I mean, sincerely, Ted, thank you very much for bringing that forward. I'm sorry, is it Mark? Michael. Michael, okay. And Sharon, thank you very much, because I think all your points are well taken, and I'm not going to try and refute them. I think we need to, want to, do a better job of truly explaining what the benefits, what the costs, accurately, ahead of time. And that's what we were talking about. That's where I was kind of...

1:07:19 Referring to the holder vehicle earlier is we need to be very proactive in saying, eh, it could be this much. Being very accurate as best we can, proactively. Thanks, John.

1:07:32 And I would add, you know, also thank you all very much for coming. We really are appreciative of hearing your comments. And, you know, Ted, I would also just add that this really has nothing to do with anything you've written in the sheet. I just think that the public doesn't really have a great understanding of this project. And I tell people all the time, I say, you don't have to like the project, but you do need to understand what it is. So I think we can do a much better job of communicating that. And certainly the next agenda item will help you. That's why. Absolutely.

1:08:01 Thank you. And there have been some funds raised through the Raise the Roof Tournament and through some other efforts, so I'm sure that Stu will get together with you to give you those details. Thanks. Okay, so the staff recommendation is for us to provide consensus comments or direction to staff and then also to direct staff to schedule a meeting of our ad hoc committee with Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:08:31 comments on these items. I'll say this. Please proceed. I think that the sooner we can have this kind of meeting and that frankly some of the issues that Ted Carlton brought up specifically with MLR should be brought up and let's get this thing going. So I don't know if you're looking for a specific motion but I will certainly provide my consensus that this needs to go forward as you've outlined. Got it. Christy?

1:09:04 Yeah, I think it's a great idea to have a communication plan. Yes, and I guess also I know that I'm sitting up here sort of feeling a little guilty because I am a marketer and it's pretty easy for me to do this. It takes me, like I said, about 20 hours to do a full audit and then a marketing plan out of it. And I understand that it is...

1:09:33 I believe in a free and independent press. I believe in the public's being able to participate in all of this. And I think it's good. I think it's fine when the public gets disenchanted or angry. I think it's fine if the newspaper asks hard questions. And in the midst of that, I think that you can hold space for

1:10:03 Whatever detraction or disenchantment that you might have as the public, and thank you for coming. And at the same time, you can hold space for the fact that this is a volunteer commission.

1:10:17 And many of us are still in our working prime, so we're not retired. There may or may not be a lot of free time to spend. And also, these are staff members that are juggling a lot of balls. And so I would like to say I'm sorry, as the marketer sitting up here, that I haven't been more involved in a communication plan. I could have taken more responsibility for that, and I'm sorry that you're disappointed, understandably disappointed.

1:10:44 We're trying to correct that. And like I said, you can continue to be disappointed and we can hold space for that. But also please hold space for the fact that this staff is limited and they're not professional marketers. And so if we've fallen down, I'm sorry is the marketer and please have a little bit of grace for our staff. And I don't think, Christy, anyone holds you responsible simply because you work in marketing for a living. Well, I'm feeling very guilty up here.

1:11:15 I am also in support of moving forward with the outreach plan or whatever, communications plan. And do want to thank everybody for coming and speaking today because we often sit up here and want feedback from the public and we don't get it. So thank you. We really appreciate you paying attention and caring about your community.

1:11:44 Giving us feedback so that we can do a better job to make sure we are meeting the needs of all aspects of our community. So thank you for being here. Okay, thank you, everyone. So it sounds like we have consensus to move forward with the recommendations. Is that sufficient? Yeah, so what I'll do is I'll meet with Matt and staff, and as we talked about with our group on Thursday at 1.30, and then we'll look at convening that little ad hoc committee. I know that ad hoc committee is the chair and Commissioner Osborne. Correct. It's okay, so at least we can kind of convene that committee.

1:12:15 Get kind of a plan of attack going along and then we can kind of get some direction for staff to kind of move on and I would hope to try to, you know, pull an outline together prior to our next meeting. You know, we need to kind of get something, you know, going in a scalable, you know, fashion. So that's kind of our path forward at this time and certainly be kind of a key component of the monthly update.

1:12:39 I actually have two audits I'm doing this month, so as I go through those, I'll try to create a checklist for you. Okay, great. Wonderful. Get into my mind. Be a great team effort. Yeah. Thank you. Perfect. Thank you. Okay. I will move us on then to item number five, the Parks and Recreation Department 2018 Summer Camps and Programs presentation. Yeah. Vice Chair Turner needs to leave in about 35 minutes. 35 minutes. Yeah, thank you. Keep moving.

1:13:28 Good morning. I'm Lauren Plum, Program and Facilities Coordinator. We're going to take a look at our summer of recreation and then a brief look over the year as a whole as well. So what are we doing? Why are we here? Our fundamental purpose is to provide residents and visitors with high-quality recreation facilities, diverse programming that promotes a degree of excitement, individual expression, exploration, pleasure.

1:13:59 Challenge and accomplishment that can lead to an improved quality of life. This is what drives us in our programming efforts and our thought process and everything that we do here at Parks and Rec. Our vision is to be the best alpine recreation community in the country. Always reaching for the stars.

1:14:21 And our mission is to provide multi-purpose, year-round, indoor and outdoor recreation opportunities accessible to all residents and visitors alike. So apropos after our last presentation. So summer recreation, we had our youth summer camps, we had our mini camps age 4 and 5, our child camps age 6 to 10, and our youth camps age 11 to 14. We also had adult programming.

1:14:48 We did parks and facility rentals. We operated the Whitmore Pool. We did a large amount of community events and then ongoing parks maintenance and special event support for our community members. Summer participation, we had 612 youth summer camp participants. We're down 12 from 2017. We're going to go over that in a little bit. And we had 660 adult program participants, which is up 63 from last year.

1:15:21 We offered three more camps this year. We were able to add Aquatics Camp 2, which is a camp that we were able to add in July just to kind of help alleviate some of that demand. We were actually able to execute Husky Prep Tennis Camp, which is a camp we had to cancel last year due to low participation.

1:15:42 We're able to do that by combining it with an adult camp, actually. And we added Mammoth Adventure Camp 2, and that is due to an extra week in the school summer schedule that we did not have last year. So our dip in participation, sorry, we had 12 less participates from last year, even though we added three more camps. We faced some challenges with air quality. We had to cancel one week of camps.

1:16:10 Where we moved all the camps indoors, that was Wilderness Camp 1 and Mountain Bike Camp 1. We offered a full refund to everyone who participated in that. A lot of our youth participants did take us up on that offer. You know, they're a little bit older and can stay home, but we're very aware that for some of our parents that this is their child care option for the week and they plan ahead, so we didn't want to just cancel the camp outright. Moving forward from there,

1:16:39 Our air quality was kind of low overnight, and then by 9 o'clock it kind of pittered out a little bit. So we let the parents choose whether or not they wanted to participate in the camp that day or that week. We did have some people cancel last minute, not due to air quality, and we're going to look at possibly over-enrolling some camps for next year in anticipation of those last-minute cancellations.

1:17:07 And then if we get hosed, we'll just figure it out as we go. Just so we can ensure that the camps are full because there's such a demand for them. As you can see, our participation has plateaued since 2016. We've kind of hit our capacity. We did centralize the camps pickup and drop-off locations.

1:17:31 or drop-off and pick-up locations, so we're a little bit constrained by transportation needs. We have four buses, but we only have a certain number of seatbelts, and we need everyone to be safe. Some of the camps we're able to run circuits in the morning, fill up a bus, drop it off, fill up another bus, drop it off, but that's not available for all the camps that maybe go up to, like, Lee Vining or down to Bishop.

1:17:56 Our adult participation is at 660. Our peak was 904 in 2016. It's about a 25% drop-off. We're back at 2010 levels when I talked to Bishop Parks and Rec.

1:18:14 They had a similar drop-off in their softball participation since 2016, about 20-25%. So we're seeing it around the whole region. It's not just us. That kind of made me feel a little bit better. And softball is about 80% of our adult participation when you combine the tournament and the league that we run. So adult program highlights, like I said, 80% is softball.

1:18:45 We took over the men's and co-ed softball tournament this year, completely us running that. We had 332 majority regional visitors that came from all over Southern California come up for two weekends in July to have a softball tournament Saturday and Sunday. We also saw an increase in tennis. They love the new tennis courts. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Everyone raves about it.

1:19:13 Kyle is amazing. So our drop-in tennis sessions increased. Our socials, camps and socials with Kyle also increased. Private lessons increased. And they all love it. They want more tennis all the time, as you can imagine. We had the same number of softball teams as we did last year, eight co-ed softball teams and five men's softball teams.

1:19:45 So our camps are a little, like we have an ordinance to subsidize it. Youth camps are subsidized 80 to 90 percent and adult programming is subsidized 10 to 20 percent. These are our numbers for this summer. The youth summer camps pulled in 70,000. The total cost, which is seasonal labor materials and supplies, is about 67. We had a cost recovery of 104 percent.

1:20:14 And on our adult programs, we had a cost recovery of 140%. So that's mainly due to the increase in profits in tennis and the softball tournaments. We were close to 100% last year, but not quite. And these cost recovery numbers do not include administration, is that correct? Correct. So this is just seasonal labor, supplies, and materials. And then it doesn't cover the cost of maintaining softball fields.

1:20:44 Providing the ice rink, or I'm sorry, not the ice rink, the year-round recreation facility that we currently have. My time, John's time, Kat's time, Warren's guys, they're not included in this. This is a good point. Thanks for bringing that up. So this is consistent with how we've kind of tracked it year after year, so it's really just direct expense. It doesn't include, as we talked about, all the administrative costs and facilities.

1:21:08 I just don't want anyone looking at our youth summer camps and being like, oh, you guys have full cost recovery because that's not necessarily the case. Our customer satisfaction surveys over the full year, this year we were able to collect 164 surveys. In the years past we've done 101, 108, and 87. So we saw a big increase. That's mainly due to adult participation. In the past we've only emailed like

1:21:40 Team Managers and asked them to distribute it out, but this year I hand-typed everybody who gave me an email, including the 332 participants from softball tournaments. So we were able to boost those numbers a little bit. Insights, consistent registration process. It's not the best, but it's the beast that we know.

1:22:02 I think I don't envy a new parent that's coming in trying to register their child if they didn't register a mini, but I'm happy to sit down there with them and do mock runs with them before the first Monday in April at 8 a.m. when we open for registration. April 1st. I thought you were looking at me. I'm not looking at you. I'm not looking at you. I was going to say new parents. Sorry.

1:22:30 We did increase our customer service. We had improved availability of information. We had an 8% increase in new participants and rave reviews on our conditions of fields and facilities, mainly due to the tennis courts and the improvements out at Shady Rest, and consistent high overall satisfaction. These are our survey results. This is on a scale of 1 to 5, 1 being poor, 5 being excellent.

1:22:57 We're somewhere between four and five in everything. You can see overall satisfaction has maintained over the last three years. I'd really like to boost that up. But as I got more and more participation, it was just like teetering back and forth. So we'll see how it goes. Survey comments, most of them are really positive. We always get a little bit of constructive criticism on how we could improve.

1:23:26 Things for the public. Primarily they'd like the toddler swim lessons, just those instructors to have a little bit more structure, the parent-child classes. It's tough when you have a parent in there and a kid that's never seen water before. But we worked on that this summer. We saw a little bit of improvement in our other swim lessons, but we just need to focus more on that age group. And then

1:23:53 They want more tennis, more softball, more of everything. If we could extend summer a couple more months, that would be great. What are we going to keep, stop, and start? We did this with our staff and from our surveys. Everyone loves the affordability of our camp. We are very affordable in comparison to our Southern California competitors. The staff really appreciated the 830.

1:24:22 Drop Off and the 4.30 pick up. Last year we did 8 to 5 and they weren't able to have a time to meet in the morning to like recap the day before or recap the day of if anything came up. A couple staff people were always distracted by whoever was super early or whoever was super late. So they really love that timing. I'm not sure if parents really love that timing. It's not great if you're working 8 to 5.

1:24:49 For our staff, they were able to get a focus all together at the beginning of a day and recap the end of a day. The quality of our camp counselors this year, we had an amazing team. They went above and beyond, had a ton of experience with kids, really engaged with them. Fingers crossed for next year. It's a really fun job. Apply early. Hopefully we get the same quality back. And we had a strong returning team as well.

1:25:18 Then keep addressing a deferred maintenance project. It sounds like that might be a reality, but they got rave reviews on everything that we've done to just step up our current facilities that we have so far. The counselors don't think dodgeball is a great activity for downtime. I would agree with that. So would my daughter. Yeah. So we're going to nix that.

1:25:44 What we're going to focus on for next year, more training for toddler swim lessons. Like I said, we discussed doing a mini garden at the rec zone for the little mini camps. New hikes and adventures. We've kind of recycled the same itineraries the last couple years. We're going to try to mix in some different areas. We have a lot of returners. They've been to Heart Lake like 10 times, you know, so try to mix something else in there.

1:26:12 Better product descriptions for camps and swim lessons. Our camps are pretty good when you read the itinerary. Not everyone does, so they're surprised you have to bring a bike and their kid doesn't know how to ride a bike on Wednesday. That's okay. We make it work. It's totally fine. But in the actual description, we'll try to include a little bit more information as well as what level swim lesson would be appropriate for your child. Shade sales at the rec zone.

1:26:40 We need some shade out there or a roof or something. It is quite exposed. We try to minimize our time that we're there, but we are there at the beginning and the end of every day. More themes for mini camps. It's just the same as the other camps. We're just trying to get some new ideas, fresh ideas in there. Like I said, softball would like to extend their season or make it earlier.

1:27:09 as well as tennis. Facility rentals, we issued 147 permits. That's an increase of 20% over 2017. I think that's just people are aware that you can rent those facilities, which have done a pretty good job.

1:27:26 of doing. We've streamlined that process. We're up 46% in gross revenue from last year. And Kat and I implemented a new system to better allocate for facility usage. It didn't seem to be any sort of consistent tracking in the years before. And we couldn't split it out between facility use agreements like swim team or AYSO or something like that versus an actual facility rental that

1:27:52 For Profit, like a member of the community for private rental. So we're working on that and excited to see how we can track it next year compared to this year. As you can tell, we've just had steady increase across all facilities with our random rental at Shady Rest in 2016. That was $2,000 alone. So that's kind of our outlier. But all across the board,

1:28:21 All facilities have increased in profitability. The facility revenue and usage, the revenue is on the left, the usage is on the right. They don't necessarily coincide since we have a facility use agreement with some of our youth recreation providers. But Shady Rest remains our most impacted park, followed by Whitmore.

1:28:50 The Community Center. So moving on to the Whitmore Pool. Cat's not able to do this portion, so you'll have a poor man's cat with me. We had a new site and assistant site coordinator, Brian Bartolucci, and then Hayden Manager stepped up for the assistant site coordinators. All of our staff were Title 22 compliant, which was a huge hurdle to get there. This is, you know, required, and it was just,

1:29:22 Like a huge monster to get them all trained. So I'm glad we finally got that checked off. We had outstanding staff performance and life-saving skills. I think we had three incidents at the pool where they had to jump in and save people. They knew their training kicked in right away. It was more instinct than anything else. And they were able to execute their duties great. Our swim lesson program took off. We sold out.

1:29:51 Of our swim lessons, especially that six-week program, it was, I had said, sign up on the wait list, we'll do everything we can to accommodate you, and then all of a sudden our wait lists were like monster huge, just like our regular camps, and it was, we need four instructors on every day instead of two, but it was good to know that the demand was there. We didn't have a realistic expectation for that because

1:30:18 People just saw it was sold out and then didn't actually add themselves to the weightless in the past. So now we have a better gauge of what our demand is in this community for swim lessons. Our summer is so short, and that is one of the only public pools that allows kids that aren't putty trained. So if you want your kid to learn how to swim before they're three, this is one of your only options.

1:30:43 We had significant improvements in the facility. We had a new heater installation in the big pool, a mechanical room refurbishment, automated chemical controllers in both pools, and we resurfaced the waiting pool. Stu can talk more about that if you guys have any questions on that. I'm not super familiar on the upgrades there. So we operated for a total of 104 days, which is two days less than 2017. As I mentioned before, we had some air quality issues.

1:31:12 this summer, which just might be a reality for us moving forward. And then we did close a couple afternoons due to thunderstorms in July. Just unfortunate. And then we had an earlier, or we had a later start to the lap swim due to our facility upgrades. I think we actually closed for a couple days to install the heater. Yeah, at the beginning of the season. We did close for a few days as well.

1:31:38 This is the breakdown of who visited this pool. It's split pretty evenly between lap swim and swim team. Our camp's made up 18%. Those are our camps and groups that come in separately. Go ahead. Sorry, I actually want to go back to the last slide. I wanted to ask you a question.

1:31:58 It says 104, but I'm not sure what the chart is that says 55. I'm sorry. Yeah, that is our average daily attendance at the pool. Sorry. Thank you. Yeah, I had to look that up myself. So this is a breakdown of who visited the pools. Camps and groups make up 18 percent. Swim team, 22. Swim lessons, 8. Lap swim, 22. And recreation swim, 26 percent. Just kind of a cross-section of who uses our facility.

1:32:30 As I mentioned, we just blew up in swim lessons this summer. We had 166, which is a 19% increase. You can see the jump there. And this is how it broke down between youth, adult, and private lessons. Whitmore Pool collected $21,000 in program revenue, which is about equal to last year. Given that we were closed a few more days, that's pretty good.

1:33:01 And then the graph is a breakdown of that financial breakdown. Community events. Parks and Rec, we did community events all summer long. We started with Town Cleanup Day. We did that inclusive playground build in the majority of June and the beginning of July. Fourth of July celebrations. And then we did Parks and Rec Month, which is a huge undertaking. It's two to three events per week in the month of July.

1:33:32 When we are operating the pool and in full swing with our summer camps. So it's a really big undertaking, but we did it. We get great feedback on it. And then we also participated in the Kids Fishing Festival at the end of the month. Special event support. We issued 39 permits, which is last year we ordered issued 36. This takes coordination between us, MLPD, MLFD.

1:34:02 LA Department of Water and Power, Caltrans, the county, depending on the scale of the event. That's probably the worst of it. That's Gran Fondo. But it just takes a little bit of coordination. And then we also issued 35 permits for special event equipment. That's just the barricades and the cones that you see out for different events around town. And contracting of Measure U and town general funds.

1:34:31 Fund some of these events, and they're required to report back to us on their events. And that's all I have for you. Do you guys have any questions for me? Awesome. We'll take public comment after we do commission our questions. Okay. Okay. So. I have a question for her, too. Okay.

1:35:03 It only says revenue, but it doesn't say what it costs to operate. What it costs to operate the- Whitmore Pool. Oh, sorry. I do not know what it costs to operate the Whitmore Pool. Yeah, so the whole Whitmore Recreation Area is about $210,000, $220,000. And we received 50 cents on the dollar from the county. So we just did that financial breakout. And is that for the fields as well? Yeah. Okay. Yep. So everything on the left side and the right side of Benton Crossing Road.

1:35:34 We can. It's about 100,000. It's actually pretty evenly. Ted? The reason I would say this is because when the community has discussions about, well, geez, do we want an ice rink or do we want an aquatic facility, for example, it would be great to be able to say, geez, this is what the ice rink does in the winter, this is what the pool does in the summer, this is about the participation level, and you can have some sort of idea unless you're completely wedded to the

1:36:03 Multi-Use Facility, rink option, but I know that there are people in the community who might say, well, how come you're not looking at that? I'll make a comment because, frankly, you beat me to the question. And we've discussed it before. We know that the pool operates at a loss. And my understanding is that that's pretty typical for municipal.

1:36:25 Pools, is that correct? Yeah, we bring in about $24,000 in revenue and it costs us $100,000. Yeah, and that it was $100,000 for the, this is what I'm remembering just from previous presentations, is that it's $100,000 for the fields and then $100,000 for the pool. And I'm going to ask you some more questions too, Lauren, just so you know. Okay.

1:36:42 And I was going to bring that up as well. You bet. Unfortunately, this does operate, and that probably doesn't even include the administration costs as well. Is that correct? Or the upgrades. And point well taken, because I've heard those comments in the community as well, is what's more important, a year-round recreation center or an indoor or at least an in-town swimming facility. And my quick comment on that is I want both.

1:37:09 Plus an event center. But, you know, that's my wish list, and I'll just state it like that. I mean, as Stu well remembers back when he was at this meeting, we talked about having the joint aquatic facility because there were synergies related to the electric use on these facilities, which would make sense. I mean... Point taken. Can I ask some additional questions? Yes. Okay. Of our visitors, or, I'm sorry, of the youth...

1:37:42 Camp and of the adult camp. Do we have any results on what percentage are not locals versus locals? You asked me this last year. It's my tourism hat that I'm putting on.

1:37:57 I can get those numbers to you. That'd be based on the address that they provide in their profile. Some of them are second homeowners and use their address here, so it will be an estimate at best, but I can run those numbers for you. You know, I really would like that, and I think that that's an important question for this survey going forward, because again, I'm going to take this back to tourism and say, look, we can offer summer camps that a lot of other communities in this state cannot.

1:38:25 That's true. And frankly, from a tourism standpoint, bring your kids up here for the summer. You know, I understand that, you know, you never know what you're going to get, smoke or rain. You know, you could easily find those down in Southern California. So, yeah, I would love to keep track on an ongoing annual basis of what percentage have addresses from out of town versus in town. I get it with the second homeowners.

1:38:49 But again, second homeowners come up here and eat in our restaurants. They're like permanent tourists. They're like permanent tourists. So if we can encourage them, you know, in my neighborhood alone, I'd say 25% of the houses are...

1:39:01 Year-round occupied, so let's get them more up here during the summer. And that being said, I know that local parents often feel some frustration in trying to get our local kids into these programs, and we've gone back and forth about ways to do that, and so that's why it's really important that we spread the word that April 1st will be our initial registration period.

1:39:24 Because I'm sympathetic to that as well. I hear you. And, you know, that's just one more reason to be supporting this program more and more. Because you're right. We need to take care of our locals. April 1st being the deadline. You know, considering my... First Monday in April. First Monday. Okay, thank you. I know, but it's only April 1st next year.

1:39:45 But I just, you know, aside from my glitches that I had in registering my kid, I heard nothing but great things about how we're able to register our kids. And, you know, that was one question or one comment that you brought up with regard to not having enough buses, not having enough equipment with this. Well, it's a combo buses and people who are licensed to drive buses. Okay. Oh, yeah. Well, good point there. I heard about that as well.

1:40:12 So, again, I think that this is one thing that as we look to expand this camp program, and I hope we do, you know, sorry about the decrease, but it wasn't much, but, you know, I just want to make sure that we are looking out in the future that we really can grow this for locals and visitors alike. We can. Our wait lists are pretty extensive, and we do have families that just come up.

1:40:36 For the summer camps, the mountain bike camp in particular, it's not something that's offered a lot of other places. I had a lot of strong interest early, like before registration on tell me more about this mountain bike camp, what do you do, where do you go, that kind of a thing. And we had, you know, that camp only holds 12, so we had a handful of kids like make a whole vacation out of it.

1:41:00 Parents even volunteered and joined in one of them, signed all our paperwork and went off and helped with the camp. So I do think there is a potential for growth there. I am concerned about our locals and making sure that their needs are met as well. Well, again, and that's why I think a survey of knowing who are the locals, how many locals we had and how many visitors we had helps us identify if, you know,

1:41:29 Visitors are taking away spots from locals. And I don't want to phrase it like that, but at the same time, I think some empirical just data. It's going to be one way or another. Right now, our registration is as fair as it can be. It opens to everyone at the same time on the same date. Yeah. Okay. The final comment, and then I'll be quiet, is I just very much appreciate staff.

1:41:51 You know, every time you guys come to us with staff reports going into these meetings, I very much appreciate that we are reminded of exactly what our vision and our mission is. And, you know, it gives us guidance. It gives the public guidance on why we do the summer programming that we do. And the Recreation Department, Commission, staff, our goal really is in the programming. And MLR, build us the projects that we can program.

1:42:18 Tourism, help us bring people to town that can fulfill some of this. But our goal here is to provide, as you say right here with the mission, provide the multi-purpose year-round indoor and outdoor recreation opportunities accessible to all visitors and visitors, residents and visitors. And if that's going to change, then let's have a public discussion about that.

1:42:40 But I like the idea that our mission is to provide these things for visitors and locals alike and let's keep growing this and I thank you very much for reminding us both in the spring as we're going into the season as well as coming out of the summer that this is our goal. These are our missions and this is some of the things that is driving our programming desires.

1:43:08 for the year-round outdoor recreation center that we are considering. Thank you. Thanks, Sean. Questions or comments from Laurel or Christine? Sean asked some of mine, but one of my questions was if we've looked at any of the school trends when looking at the kids and our participation. Like, is there a bubble moving through the schools local?

1:43:37 I haven't compared that. I could compare class sizes. I do get that distribution list every year. Our most heavily impacted age group is 6 to 10. Like if you have a 6 to 10-year-old, be there at Monday at 8 a.m. If you have a youth or a mini, you're probably going to be okay for a couple days. But that might help inform the planning for each year, you know.

1:44:04 If you know you have a big group of kids coming up, you might want to offer another at that level. Right now, we're at capacity. We can't offer any more than what we're offering. We were able to add one camp, and that was a miracle based on volunteers that came forward. We didn't have the staff for that. It's my understanding that school enrollment is pretty flat.

1:44:26 On average, probably about 100 kids per grade. And, you know, obviously you extrapolate that out. We're never going to be able to accommodate, you know, all of those kids in our camp. So we need to look at some alternatives like the facility. I have a lot of comments on this, but in the hope that there will be ad hoc programming committee meeting coming out of this, I will save those for there. But I do want to make one comment that I have.

1:44:55 As you know, I teach swimming lessons. And last summer, they all came to me. This summer, they all went to you. So that's awesome. I'm really, really glad because a lot of folks talk to me about the value of what you guys offer. Thank you. And that is, you are the only ones offering that. In this area, yeah. Yeah. So I think that we are continuing to put energy and attention into that is important for our community, for safety. Absolutely. We want a water-safe community.

1:45:24 But I had someone who has been talking to me about teaching their child for years who doesn't like to do anything. The kid does not like anything. Went to aquatics camp this summer. Now he really likes to swim. Oh, that's awesome. I wanted to pass that along because I know that there's been ups and downs with some of the instructors there and turnover and all of that. And you guys turned on a kid who doesn't like anything and now he likes swimming. So good job. Thank you.

1:45:53 Cool. Christy? I have a couple questions, one of which is how many Hispanic kids are we enrolling in camps? Very few. Okay. Not so much swim lessons, but camps, very few. Okay. And I know that we've been talking about this and staff has gone

1:46:21 and done some research and some additional outreach. I do remember that the research that Kat yielded said that Hispanic parents might not feel comfortable dropping their kids off to strangers. I also remember that when we did bilingual outreach for the ice skating rink, our Hispanic participation went up.

1:46:44 pretty significantly. And so I think moving into additional summer camps, if we can keep kicking that can down the road, because to Laurel's point about the composition of our school, including our elementary school, I believe we have almost a 50% Hispanic population. So if not higher, so I'm really interested in the

1:47:09 And, you know, sort of on the opposite side of Sean's coin, I'm very interested in making sure that our public funds and facilities serve our residents as fully as we can. And then the second question I have is, can you please explain to me, I know you've done it before and I just, I guess I don't want to believe it because I can't remember the answer, but why can't we have local residents pre-register for camps and why can't we subsidize locals more than we?

1:47:38 That's something that we're going to talk about in the Ad Hoc Committee. We've kind of bounced around different fee structures, more so than registration. I think our mission says residents and visitors alike. So I think we've discussed keeping registration the same, but we're...

1:47:55 Open to changing the fee structure? Because one of the things is if we're getting some cost recovery, I'd like to see that better subsidize locals because I did see in some of the comments that even though we are subsidizing our fees for kids camps, it's still, it's expensive to live here. We have super high cost of living. Every time I have visitors, they're shocked in the grocery store at how much we pay just for food, just basics. So if we can get a little bit more help to local.

1:48:24 and encourage more local participation, especially our working class and working poor. That would make me very happy. And then my final question is, do we have a problem with the temperature of the pool or what? It's the nature of the system. Stu and I fight about the pool temperature with lab swim every morning. Regardless of whatever the pool temperature is, you'll always get some comments regarding the pool temperature.

1:48:54 Okay. Okay. We did get a lot of feedback on the temperature of the pool, particularly with kids' lessons and lap swim. Yep. And here's the real situation that we have is, as we all know, you know, to teach swim lessons, be more on a therapeutic type of setup, it's 84 plus. To lap swim and provide a recreational pool, it's 80 to 82. So we can't really, yeah, we can't really

1:49:23 Manage that. That's a really disparate kind of range in a temperature setting. So we do the best we can and try and keep it at 82. Some days we get there, some days we don't. We're working with a new mechanical system that we believe we will be able to get there. We just had a lot of changes in the pool in one year that we're trying to, you know, better manage. But anyway, that's inherently the challenge. So as the pool and the swim lesson program expands...

1:49:50 They're the type of situations that we're going to be, you know, dealing with. That's funny because 82 is trunk weather when you're surfing, right? Yeah. That's pretty warm. Yeah. To us, that's pretty warm. Just making sure. Just making sure. So we're, you know, we're doing a lot of, and that's kind of what we have with our facilities, right? We have a, we have all our facilities that are deficient, right? We all know that, right? I mean, the multi-use facility, the rink, no roof. I mean, it's outdoors. It's summer. It is what it is, right? We make the best we can with it. The pool.

1:50:17 You know, built in 1939, it's, you know, integrity is challenged, we're updating as best we can, but we're using one body of water for a multitude of purposes and it's, we're really pushing on our programming and the facility is just not built for that. Right, so that's inherently where we are and I think that's where everybody understands why we've been looking at these newer facilities because there's so many more, you know, needs and demands and opportunities that the community want to use them for, but that's what we have and I think that's...

1:50:45 Pretty clear for the commission. I think we'll understand that. No surprises to anyone. Thank you. Thank you. Welcome. I can talk about the pool temperature all day long. I bet you can. And Sean, I know you need to take off, so go ahead. So I'm just going to try and keep this brief because I think these have been good questions and good comments. But I wanted to ask Lauren, the cancellations, were they primarily due to air quality? Yes. I'd say that one week we kind of took a hit.

1:51:15 You know, I probably refunded 12 participants. That's like half a camp. So it's a lot. And then, you know, the handful of other cancellations we get are unanticipated. People get stuck or they forget they registered for camp. You know, that happens. Yeah, I think it's probably a good idea to consider over-enrolling some of our camps just because, you know, there's inevitably going to be a kid that gets sick or... Right. And we'll look at the percentage of the dip and kind of...

1:51:44 Extrapolate out there maybe like two, maybe two to three kids more per camp just to anticipate that sort of cancellation. They're playing the airplane game. I know, right? That's what I keep thinking and I don't want to make that analogy. You do it all the time.

1:52:00 I'm sorry, we're going to have to bump you from this camp. That's right. But we'll offer you a future camp for, yeah. Upgrade you coupons. We do the best we can. We have people show up the day of in hopes that people don't show up. That happens as well. But seeing the trend over the last couple of years, I think we can do a little bit better. And along those lines, how many, would you say how many kids ended up kind of on the wait list? How many kids are we not serving that we know of?

1:52:31 I know that's hard to just come up with a number. It depends on the camp. So some camps we have two to three, some camps we have 25. And we try to address and communicate with the wait list more frequently at the beginning of the season, just like, you know, you're still on the wait list, are you still interested? Because what happens is we'll get a cancellation and I'll call 10 people and everyone else has already made plans or not interested out of town. And it's just a lot of staff resource.

1:53:00 At that point. Yeah. I think the number was about 200. Yeah. 200 plus on our wait list. Total. You know, Ted just texted me a question about, you know, so if you look at the year-round recreation center, what that would do for our summer programming, right? So really, probably on a summer camp perspective, probably marginally.

1:53:18 Right, you know, because we are kind of capacity with a number of kids in camps and, you know, if we get more vehicles, great, we can do that. But really the benefit is these kids that can't get in the camps, you know, we can now provide a scheduled, programmed activity, either a three-hour, half-day, you know, all-day drop-in activity at that facility that they can kind of be supervised, you know, provide an activity for, you know.

1:53:40 General kind of outreach, educational, interpretive type of opportunities. And that can also be a very low-cost alternative to a full camp as well. And I think that type of drop-in availability and family programming, as you alluded to with the Latino community, I think that's all really important. One thing I wanted to ask is...

1:54:03 So have we ever had a situation where we have kids who don't have bikes and kind of how do we accommodate that? Because I know that that tends to be a component of camps. We have kids that don't have mountain bikes or non-functional mountain bikes. They receive a discount through Footloose that we arrange at the beginning of the season for a rental if they are still interested.

1:54:25 Come up with all sorts of random things. Kids don't have skateboards for skate camp. Usually there's an extra deck lying around and we can get them out there. I know Steve's been really good at that, but I know I was frantically making sure my kid's bike still fit her to just go to adventure camp when she came back after being away. So I just want to make sure we're kind of aware of that and maybe just have a couple on hand just to make sure we can accommodate everyone without making anyone feel left out.

1:54:53 I wanted to say that I'm really, really pleased.

1:54:58 You know, to see all these great comments about our staff because I know, Lauren, you do an amazing job. You know, you spend so much time making these programs successful. It was great to see the comments about Kyle, about the tennis courts. So I'm really, really pleased to see that recognized by, you know, our constituents. That made me really happy. I was really surprised there weren't any, and maybe it's because I didn't fill out my survey, but I really thought we'd see more comments on the Latin market food truck. I thought that was really awesome. I don't get any comments on that.

1:55:27 Yeah, so anyway. Passé now, just expected. Yeah, well, consider that like my comment. I really like that that was opened up to kids from other camps and not just the skate camps. I thought that was really cool. I wanted to ask, why was it that we had to take over the softball tournament? I couldn't remember what had happened. The guy who's been running it, it's been running it for 15 years. He kind of wanted to bow out. He wanted an entity to take over it that would ensure its longevity. Okay. And so he reached out to us.

1:55:56 Rather than an individual. Fair enough.

1:55:59 Another comment that I have is I know that every resort community really struggles. I've been talking a little bit to Lauren, who's the Recreation Superintendent in South Lake Tahoe, and this balance between serving visitors and second homeowners and serving locals. And everyone I've talked to is pretty averse to doing kind of a local rate or a local priority because it's just so hard. And you'll always have second homeowners argue while we own property, so that makes us locals. So I think it's really difficult.

1:56:28 But I do think that doing the Summer Recreation Open House prior to opening enrollment, I know it's a lot of work, but I've heard really, really great feedback on that from local parents. It just helps kind of get that awareness out there that the registration date is opening. You know, you get a small discount with the coupon if you attend. So I think that is, you know, at least a start in addressing some of those issues. So I would recommend keeping that.

1:56:55 And then, you know, it's funny on the pool temperature, I just wanted to say that our friend Bea, who swam over 100 miles this summer and complained pretty much every morning about the pool being cold.

1:57:05 Stu and Warren took so much abuse from Bea. But, you know, she had a little wetsuit that she wore. So I think that there are ways that, you know, kids, obviously, they're smaller. It's not like a thermostat in your house. We can't bump up the pool temperature for swim lessons, bump it back down for lap swim and swim team. So, you know, it's just that's going to be an ongoing challenge while we only have one pool. Body of water, yeah. Yeah. So, anyway, I think that's it. Just I'm so, so proud of, you know, of these programs, of everything that.

1:57:34 We do in the summer. I just think you guys are amazing. So thank you. And, you know, from a parent perspective, just great experiences all around. So thank you. I appreciate it. I just want to thank Lauren for putting this all together too, right? So, you know, a little 30-minute presentation that took basically six weeks? It took less than that, but...

1:57:58 Well, while you're doing everything else in the department. Anyway, so it takes a lot of time. It's a lot of data. And if you see, you know, the spreadsheets that we've attached and provided you, there's a lot of detail that goes into these numbers, you know, on that Excel spreadsheet. It's a lot of detail. So we really, truly want to understand, you know, who's in our camps, you know.

1:58:16 We do the best we can. We have different activity codes for all our different camps and programs. We're tracking all our expenses and labor. We're trying to be very frugal and transparent with our community about what it costs, but also the benefit that we provide. And I think our department couldn't be more prouder of the great camps, programs, and events that we do and the great staff that we have. So it's always an honor to be here and promote it. And we look for...

1:58:41 Opportunities that we can continually advocate for in the future, and I know that's why we advocate so strongly for our facilities and amenities, and that's why it's great that we are truly seeing the council, you know, taking some steps to advance and improve our facilities. I mean, what we've just invested in this last year, as you know, I mean, we're coming back in November with our deferred maintenance program. I mean, last year and this year, this year in particular, you know, was about, what, three quarters of a million dollars.

1:59:10 Parks and Recreation amenities, playgrounds, pools, facilities. I mean, that's, I don't know when that's ever happened, right? Across the board of our facilities. So thank you for your great advocacy. And I think there's great things and opportunities to come because you've got a great team that can kind of deliver that to you. The action item that Commissioner brought up was the convening of the ad hoc programming committee. So I do want to kind of see if we can kind of pull that together.

1:59:38 And again, the goal of that committee is to kind of at least meet, provide some, you know, insight, direction, you know, talk about these ideas about, you know, our locals, residents, other programming ideas. On page 4, actually page 43, page 4 of the agenda, there's a little table there. So that kind of gives you an outline of kind of where we are in this process in regards to April 1st, because I know that's such everybody's.

2:00:08 Top of mind, it's all about April 1st. So October... Monday in April. Yep. It's my parents' wedding anniversary, April 1st. Yeah, I think it's my parents' the same. October 2nd is today we want to convene that meeting and then we would then work and take all that input to develop a draft of next year's menu. And with next year's menu does come all these recommendations, whether they be...

2:00:33 You know, fee schedules, whether they be policy, you know, whether they be these other, you know, recommendations to improve our camps. So we'll bring that to you on December 4th. January 8th is kind of when we typically approve that if needed. If the presentation is accepted by commission, good to go December 4th, we'll start rolling it out.

2:00:54 But the more lead time we have to make that April 1st rollout is critical. It takes us three months to kind of pull it together, not only kind of build the program, the facilities, sorry, the brochures, the fee schedules. We have to then revise the program facilities manual, all of that. So that kind of gets us to April 1 or the first meeting in April. So I know the committee is comprised of Laurel and Dan. Dan's not here, so I don't know if there's any dates that you'd...

2:01:23 Recommend, or we can do it on an email after the meeting if that's preference. Yeah, I think email since Dan isn't here to weigh in. Is that okay? Yeah, but I think you guys have some good ideas. Great, we really appreciate that meeting. I think Sean and I are very excited to hand over the torch to Dan and Laurel, so thank you for taking that on. It's really fun work. Yeah, so we're trying to, I think it's typically been like an hour and a half, two hour meeting. Yeah, it hasn't been. Yeah, typically it's just that one meeting.

2:01:49 We can do it over lunch if you need to or any particular time, mornings, evenings, so we'll schedule that with you. So that's all I had for that item, so thank you. I think we definitely recommend convening that committee and following along on this timeline. Sound good to hear, Christy? Great. Okay, so that brings us to Commissioner Reports. So, Christy, would you like to start? Sure.

2:02:13 I had the opportunity to attend Interbike this year. It's moved from Las Vegas to Reno, and they had their demo Dirt Days at North Star, which is a phenomenal mountain. It was a little tricky coming back and riding a Mammoth mountain, but I felt like a more skilled rider because I'm from Mammoth. What I want to report is I had an opportunity to demo both a mountain e-bike and a commuter e-bike.

2:02:42 insights and anecdotes that came about that. One, I was really impressed with

2:02:51 How well the mountain e-bikes handled. They handle a lot like an old school downhill bike. You know, it's a 50 pound bike, but it's got full suspension. And so, you know, if you're used to being on a full downhill bike, it's absolutely fun and super, it's as safe as any other downhill activity. So I was really impressed with that. I'm so proud that Mammoth Mountain as a resort has that.

2:03:17 Available to our visitors and residents alike. I also got on a commuter bike. There's a bunch of different commuter bikes. I think we're renting turns here. Wave Wave might be renting turns. And again, we brought up some safety issues and this and that, and they just seem very safe, very solid, and very straightforward for a variety of different users and riders. The second thing I wanted to share about e-bikes is...

2:03:44 Couple of anecdotes. We went to lunch out at Red Truck at the Truckee Airport, which is near North Star, and there was this very, like, ridiculously fit triathlete-looking guy with this old hippie-looking guy, and the old hippie-looking guy said, we just rode cross-country for four hours. I'm on an e-bike. I did pedal assist at 30%. I wouldn't be able to hang out with my friend without this.

2:04:09 Then to that point, I've seen a bunch of visitors on the multi-use path. When my brother was in town, we went on a road bike, actually on the MUP, which was a lot of fun. He commented how much safer it is climbing on the MUP than it is climbing on a road with no margin, and he really liked that safety aspect and that natural aspect. But I saw a number of riders where you would have

2:04:37 Somebody on an e-bike and somebody on a regular bike. And it really, when we think about access, we oftentimes think about access in terms of able-bodied people and disabled people.

2:04:49 But there's really an access issue with our allowing for e-bikes on the MUP and on some of our trails in that couples can enjoy their time together in the mountains. And then finally, I tried to rent an e-bike while I had guests in town, and I called four different outfitters, and it was like no-go. Unless you got on the phone with them, it's like trying to get a Colorado River permit. You're calling and calling and calling when you used to get cancellations.

2:05:18 This allows visitors to access our...

2:05:22 Not just our parks, but also recreation and the outdoors and nature. They come up to altitude. And this is not an easy town to cycle. It's like this. I did a 20-mile ride through town on the map with my brother, and we had a 2,000-foot altitude gain in 20 miles. So when you're talking about 1,000 feet per 10 miles, that's considered strenuous cycling. And so this isn't an easy town to cycle because there's so many hills and it goes up and down and up and down.

2:05:52 Very long sustained climbs. And so I was just really pleased to see that as a community, we have these e-bikes available that allow people who aren't used to altitude or who aren't as fit and is in shape as maybe some locals to start accessing recreation in a way that they never had before. So I just wanted to say.

2:06:13 I love the e-bike thing in all ways, and I think we're on the right path as a recreation department and as a resort for allowing for e-bikes on our paths. Thanks, Christy. Yeah. Laurel? I didn't think I had anything to report, but since we're talking e-bikes and mountain bikes, Disabled Sports is in the process of growing our mountain biking program, and we will have a...

2:06:39 Soon to have a fleet of adaptive mountain bikes, both hand and foot pedaled, that will enhance the offerings that the town has to make sure everybody can get out there and enjoy. And we're very excited about getting on board with the mountain biking growth and trend right now. And, you know, it's been my summer of mountain biking.

2:06:59 All excited about it. Will they be like mostly recumbent bikes or are you going to do e-bikes as well? Most of them are recumbent that we're getting. Some of them are foot pedaled and some of them are hand pedaled. And I believe everything that we are shopping for has an e-assist option. Awesome. That's awesome. Yay. Yeah. That's great. So we're very excited about being able to expand as it is growing and blowing up here in town. So awesome.

2:07:29 Okay, so the biggest thing in my commissioner report is I've been working with Paul Romero, who's the trainer for CAPRCBM, on our training for this Saturday. Sean is going to be out of town. I know you have a friend in town. I know that the timing was unfortunate that he couldn't do the weekend. That was more convenient for you after we asked which was more convenient. And then, Christy, are you going to be available on Saturday? Yes. We're heading out of town for Tahoe. Sorry.

2:07:59 The challenge with this is that this is an opportunity we won't get again because Paul's retiring. And so we have right now, so Laurel said you try to attend. I'll be there. Dan will be there. He's actually...

2:08:13 Providing the room for it at the bowling alley. Loretta Herron, who's actually going to become president of CAPRCBM, is coming up from Orange County for it. I've extended an invitation out to Bishop and to South Lake Tahoe. They both thought their commissioners were interested but don't know yet if any are attending, so I need to follow up on that and just make sure that Paul and Loretta, you know, still want to travel for a very small training. So I will kind of try and get word out by tomorrow about whether or not...

2:08:41 We are able to proceed. So I know it's tough to ask people to give up a Saturday, but I think that it's just, you know, kind of in our current political climate, this is a really cool opportunity. He did just present this training at the National Park and Rec Conference. So anyway, so I will follow up on that with you guys. Probably have Stu push something out tomorrow.

2:09:00 So thank you. The only other thing I had in my report, I won't bore you with all the things I've done, but I did attend the harassment training, which is now required for commissioners. So I'm sure Jamie will follow up with anyone who is not able to attend that training. Warren and I kind of freaked out the trainer. It was fun. Is that also just like ethics training? Is that available online for certification? No. So I'm going to have to find a place to do it.

2:09:30 Is that in the state of California? It was good. I was glad to go. It was funny because I said to Jamie, I was like, we've never had to do this before. She's like, that's right, it's a new law. So now you have to. Okay, so that brings us to a request for agenda item. So, Stu, would you mind reminding us what is on our agenda for November? Okay.

2:10:15 Maintenance Program Presentation with you on a nice PowerPoint. We do want to kind of include past and kind of future. We do have a scheduled workshop for the Town Council on the 5th of December, so we'll have an agenda to kind of talk about those items, what you want to cover in that time that you have with the Council. It's just for one hour. It'll be five o'clock. We'll have our standing communities multi-use facility project slash URAN Recreation Centre update.

2:10:47 There's something else I'd like to do, and that's provide just an update on Joel is actually working with us on a signage upgrade plan for Multi-Use Facility Pathways, so I can kind of give you an update on that. Yes, please. If there's any update on the next summer's work in the lakes basin, we can kind of cover that as well. And then we'll most likely be able to kind of report back on our ad hoc committee meeting and kind of where that is. So we might just probably have a little item on that too, on our programming menu.

2:11:17 Because if there's any items that we do really want to address, we need to address as an advisory body itself. So we'll do that as well and I think that's it. Okay. That sounds like a pretty full meeting. Yeah. Fun time. Yeah. All right. I can't imagine there's anything we could really add to that, but any requests?

2:11:39 Okay. One thing I do want to mention is that MLR does have their workshop tomorrow with Town Council starting at 4 o'clock, so you may want to check that out. I plan to attend. So if there is nothing further, I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting on November 6th at 9 o'clock right here. Thanks, everybody. Yeah, that's my hope for Saturday, assuming it still goes, is that I would be able to...