Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2018
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 41 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findingsTranscript
209 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:17 All right, good afternoon, everybody. Since it's now 2 o'clock, we will call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, August 8th.
0:52 Roll call, please, Sherene. Commissioner Burroughs, absent. Commissioner Chang. Here. Commissioner Eckert, absent. Commissioner, or Vice Chairman Vanderhurst. Present. And Chair Callinan. Yes. Paul, would you like to lead our Pledge of Allegiance, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible,
1:24 All right. Thanks, everybody. We'll start today's meeting with public comments. Anyone who would like to speak on items not officially on the agenda, please come up now. Good afternoon. Hazel Pays, engineering manager, just going to give you guys a quick update on construction-related activities around town.
1:52 As you may have noticed, we are underway on the replacement of the sidewalks out front here on Meridian Boulevard. That is also being coupled with some curb and gutter work further up the street towards Eagle Lodge under SB1 funding. We awarded at Council on the first the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. We are currently working on contracting that out, and we hope to start work within two weeks on that project. Just a reminder, that's from the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret to Mammoth Creek Park. It's a multi-use path.
2:22 We completed, or we are substantially complete with the first phase of the Main Street sidewalk project from Mountain Boulevard up to the brewery. We just have a couple cleanup items on there and then we're complete. We are out to bid on the second and third phase. We're actually opening bids this afternoon on the segment between 8050 and the brewery. And we will be opening bids next Tuesday on effectively everything else, which we call the Lower Main Street project.
2:50 We're hoping to start both of those projects just after Labor Day. We're going to kind of hold off on construction activity for the holiday. And then finally, we received direction of town council last week on the multi-use facility. Council has directed staff to move forward with development and construction in a phased approach, starting with what we are calling the rink and the roof component, which is the superstructure and the ice rink.
3:16 for a not to exceed price of $13 million. Staff will return to council on the 20th of September with a quick update with a couple options for a lobby space and some more community gathering areas, but we are planning to move forward and have already got HMC Architects and our team working forward on the development of those new plans. Thank you. Thank you, Mammoth. May I ask you a really quick question? Of course. Go ahead. No, I just said thank you. The Mammoth Creek Park
3:47 Gap closure project. I didn't nail that. You got it. Do you foresee that being concluded and finished by the end of this summer? Yeah, we think we'll knock that out in three to four weeks total. So we sometime early mid-September, we should be out of there. Got it. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? Okay.
4:16 Then we will move on to our first item. It is a public hearing to consider approval of variance 18-003 to reduce the stream corridor setback from 50 feet to 15 feet on the south side of the stream to allow for the replacement of the existing single-family residence located at 52 Alexander Lane. This includes finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to guidelines section 15303, new construction of small structures.
4:44 Our presentation today will be from Nolan. Great. Thank you. Variance 18-003 is a request to reduce the stream corridor setback from 15 feet to 15 feet on the south side of the stream for the replacement of the existing single-family residence. The replacement residence will have approximately 4,100 square feet of habitable area, a 500 square foot secondary dwelling unit, and a 500 square foot two-car garage.
5:16 The development area of the site is previously disturbed due to the previous development on the site. The structure will adhere to all other required setback, lot coverage, parking, and height development standards for the rural residential zone. The subject property is within the rural residential zoning district and is also within the open space stream corridor overlay zone. A branch of Mammoth Creek runs diagonally through the property, and therefore the town's 50-foot stream setback regulations are normally applicable.
5:47 The property has an existing 1,900 square foot residence that was constructed in 1985 and that residence is located approximately 14 feet from the stream bank. It is also in the area or in a portion of the area where the new residence is proposed to go. A variance was not previously required for the development of the residence since the stream setback requirement was not codified until 1989.
6:11 However, had that stream setback requirement been codified in 1985, a variance would have been required to allow for the encroachment. The area to the south of the stream, located between the stream and Alexander Lane, is largely devegetated and disturbed and lacks the vegetation diversity that the area to the north of the stream has. In the photo here on the lower right, it's taken from adjacent to the existing residence and you can see the dense vegetation that's on the other side of the stream.
6:41 The existing residence is nonconforming with regards to the stream setback and pursuant to the municipal code, a nonconforming structure that is voluntarily raised shall not be restored except in full conformity with the regulations or be approved for a variance, thereby granting concessions to specific development standards. A variance is a site-specific exception to a land use development standard in order to compensate for special circumstances related to a property which would
7:10 Prevent the property from being developed in a manner comparable to other properties in the same zoning district and the same general vicinity. The subject property is substandard with regards to buildable area due to the location of the stream and the associated 50-foot stream setback, the wetlands and heavily vegetated undisturbed areas to the north of the stream, the standard front and side yard setbacks, and the requirement for a 10-foot IOD to the town for roadway purposes along Alexander Lane.
7:42 All these factors equate to a special circumstance applicable to the property that deprives the property of the necessary space to construct a residence similar in size to others in the vicinity. Pursuant to Municipal Code 17.100.070, a parcel that does not comply with the minimum buildable area requirement, is considered a legal building site if the site was approved through recorded subdivision map.
8:08 This site does have a recorded subdivision map and therefore there has to exist a legal building site on the property. And with that being said, a variance is an allowable request in order to achieve a minimum 2,000 square foot buildable area. In reviewing a variance request, the project site is analyzed to determine if there is an alternative to the variance and if the request is the minimum departure from the zoning code necessary.
8:37 In the case of this site, there is no alternative location on the site which would allow for development without a variance. As indicated before, the existing residence is located 14 feet from the creek and would require a variance if it is constructed today. The area to the north of the stream is heavily vegetated and has numerous potential wetland areas. And the area to the north that is outside of the 50-foot setback area
9:04 And within the complies with the rear and side yard setbacks is to be anything constructed in the north is a small area on the northeast side of the property. With this, there are numerous other challenges to getting over there, including access to that side because they would have to cross the stream with enhanced vehicle bridge that meets fire code requirements and would require additional disturbance in and around the stream.
9:31 The proposed variance is the minimum departure necessary since it will allow for a legal building area that does not encroach any further into the setback area than the existing residence does and avoids any disturbances to the area north of the stream. Another finding that is required for approval of a variance is that the variance does not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity.
9:58 Since 1996, there has been seven variances approved for encroachments into the stream setback for properties surrounding the subject property, and therefore the grant of a variance for a similar site constraint would not be a special privilege. The encroachments have ranged from 40 feet to 17 feet for those previous variances. Variances are analyzed on a case-by-case basis.
10:21 The amount of departure from a development standard is based on the site specifics. In the case of the subject site, the 15-foot setback was requested because it is less than the existing residence encroaches into the setback, and the location of the structure allows for all the existing trees along the western boundary of the site to be retained. Additionally, the design of the proposed residence is narrow and long in order to work with the site constraints.
10:51 The project was found to be categorically exempt from the provisions of CEQA because the project met the qualifications for the categorical exemption afforded to projects that consist of the development of one single-family residence in a residential zone and none of the exceptions set forth in the CEQA guidelines are present.
11:09 Those exceptions look at any impacts that might occur to the environment as a result of the project and since the development will occur in an area that is previously disturbed and no new disturbances to the stream or other biological resources are anticipated to occur, none of those exceptions applied. The project was noticed in the newspaper for two subsequent weeks and notices were mailed out to all property owners within 300 feet of the project.
11:38 Staff has heard from three neighbors who had questions about what the residents would look like, but no comments in opposition or support of the variance have been received. The resolution makes all the required findings for the approval of the variance, and staff recommends approval of variance 18-003 with conditions as recommended by staff. With that, that concludes my presentation. If the commission has any questions of the property owner,
12:08 Or the architects, they're all present here today. Great, thank you. With the architect and the property owners, would you like to speak at all? I'm happy to say something. Okay. Would you mind coming up because we're being televised and recorded? Sure. I love the area. I love the area of Old Mammoth where the house is. I think it's going to be a beautiful house. Sorry, you're the architect?
12:36 No, I'm the owner. You're the owner. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. These are the architects. Okay. Bob and Lori Davis. I'm sorry. I'm Josh Bruinberg. I'm the owner. Okay. And we're just very excited. We feel privileged to be able to do the house. I think it's going to be beautiful. I think it's going to be great for the neighborhood. And I am very committed to not putting any landscaping in the backyard. The backyard is not going to be
13:06 And this is Bob and Lori and my
13:36 I think Lori's going to say a few words. Sure. So I'm Lori Davis, and I'm Davis Davis Architects. We are now in Colorado, but we were in San Diego for 25 years, so we've recently moved back to my husband's home state of Colorado. So doing a lot of work in snow areas, which has been something for us to realize, wow, you know,
14:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
14:35 Essential sustainable building is, so we really push that envelope when we can, and we will be doing this with this house, and as you heard Josh say, he's very cognizant of not creating any kind of pollution or unnatural landscaping in the rear of the house, so we're looking forward to moving forward, and if you have questions, we're happy to answer them. Thank you. Thank you.
15:07 All right. Any questions up here for staff before we move on to public? The sit-back requirement that's closest to Alexander Drive, what did you say that number was again? So the setback along the front of the property is, it's 25 feet for the rural residential zone, and then there's an additional 10 foot.
15:43 Area that the town's requiring to be an offer of dedication to the town for roadway purposes. That's for snow storage or future widening of the street because Alexander Lane's a substandard street. So Alexander Lane and then you have 10 foot IOD? From the property line. From the property line and then you have from that point on is it 25? Correct, 25 feet from there. Okay. Which is the rural residential front yard setback. Right.
16:13 Okay. Okay. Thank you. I just have a really quick question. Nolan, would you just mind repeating the summary you gave on the communication with the neighboring properties that you have had a couple conversations? Sure. So notices were mailed out to all property owners within 300 feet. Once they received those, I did get three phone calls from neighbors asking what the kind of design of the house would look like or the structure.
16:43 They didn't raise any support or opposition related to the variance request itself. Thank you. The seven other properties you have mentioned in your report, two of which I believe, or maybe three, were something that's going to be built in the future? No. So, as I said, these are the history of the seven variances I was able to find since 1996.
17:15 A, B, C, D, E, and G are all constructed. F is a vacant property, but that does have an approved variance. So if a project came in that conformed with what was approved by that variance, they could construct that without going through the public process again. Okay. Within this particular area, how many other potential properties parcel that could come in for us?
17:46 for this type of setback variance, just out of curiosity. As far as vacant parcels, I don't know about being out there other than site F that's a vacant parcel. Any property that has a house on it could come in if they wanted to rebuild a new house that was either closer to what that property was already approved for based on a variance or if it was a property that never had a variance similar to this that would then need a variance to rebuild because they're within that creek setback area or have
18:16 Site constraints on the site that create some hardship, either too small of a buildable area, lot width or depth, some of their hardship on that property. Thank you. That's all I have. Nolan, can you just go over again? I believe you were mentioning that the site of the existing house is already fairly disturbed soil, or there's been quite a bit of fill added.
18:47 With comparison to the other side of the stream bank, so the existing house is already sort of a higher elevation, is that correct? Correct. So when they built the house in 1985, they did fill the area that's to the south of the stream. You can see here in the aerial photo, this essential triangle of space, this is all the area to the south of the stream. And when you look at the photos here, you can see that the area south of the stream is all low-level grasses and is significantly different than
19:17 The heavily vegetated area to the north of the stream. Also the biological report done for it essentially said that it's ecologically isolated from the northern portion of the stream, that the vegetation types don't match on either side and that the area has received fill which changed kind of the dynamics of that portion of the site. Okay. And so that the, especially with the northern part of the site being a bit lower than the
19:53 The southern part of the site. If any, you know, flooding, seasonal flooding were to occur, reason would have it that it would more or less flood and affect the northern portion of the site, correct? That's correct. As well, when you're out there, it's evident the number of streams and kind of wetland areas to the north that have developed where you don't see any of that same evidence on the south side. Also, the house is required to comply with the town's
20:23 Floodplain Development Standards, which does require to be built one foot above the base flood elevation, which is required to be determined by an engineer prior to a building permit or grading permit issuance. Okay. So that's something that has to, that'll happen at some point in the future. Correct. As well as coordination with Army Corps of Engineers, the Regional Water Quality Control Board, and Department of Fish and Wildlife. Okay.
20:57 I don't have any other questions at the moment. Is there anyone in the public that might have questions or comments on this item? All right. Not seeing any comments or questions. We would give the applicant another opportunity to speak in response, but I don't know if you feel the need to add anything else here. We can go on to our deliberation here with respect to the findings that we have to make.
21:31 Nolan, would you want to maybe summarize the findings or would you like me to do that? Sure, I can quickly summarize the findings. The first one is that there are special circumstances, circumstances applicable to the property. The constraints to the billable area really are the basis for that special circumstance is that reduced billable area constricts
22:00 Or restricts what kind of residence they could build on the property. The next required finding is that this does not grant a special proof. Constituted granted special privileges inconsistent with other properties. The history of variance is approved for similar requests in this area. Prove that would not be granted special privileges.
22:25 The next one is that the grant and the variance cannot authorize a use that's not otherwise allowed in this zone. This zone is zone rural residential, which is intended for single family residential uses. Also within the open space during corridor protection overlay, single family residences are permitted outright. With regards to secondary dwelling units, the code allows those
22:52 In all residential areas, as long as it meets the requirements of the secondary dwelling units section. The next finding is that it's not detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare of the community. The fact that this property was previously disturbed in a vegetation tap, vegetation lacks the diversity that the remainder of the site does, and that no additional grading would occur on the site or in any recurring or wetland areas.
23:21 Also, it is required to comply with all the regulations of state, local, federal agencies for building safety. As far as being consistent with the general plan, it's within the low density residential one general plan area, which is intended for single family residential uses. And then back to the variance being the minimum departure from the findings.
23:49 Said this, um, the Grady of the Grady does provide that necessary space or necessary buildable area to construct a house that's similar in size to others in the area and avoids any impacts to the wetland areas to the north of the stream. The next one is that it is in the requirements of CEQA and is found to be categorically exempt pursuant to section 15303, which is for new construction of small structures. And then the, um,
24:20 The section of the code dealing with reductions of the stream setback area does have three additional bindings that have to be made. First one is that the entirety of the project is outside the 100-year floodplain. Since the project is required to be elevated one foot above the base flood elevation, that satisfies being outside of the 100-year floodplain area.
24:43 Next one is that the creek bank in the vicinity of the modification has been demonstrated as being historically stable. The existing residence has been there for 33 years and the site maps and surveys and others that have been provided show that the stream has not moved in that time. This is due to the stream being the existing root structures of the vegetation in and along the stream bank and the rocks that have been in place at along the river.
25:11 at and along the water's edge. And the third finding is that the riparian resources will not be significantly diminished as a result of the modification. Once again, since the development area has been largely disturbed and is de-vegetated, anticipated that no impacts to the wetland or riparian areas to the north would be impacted from the development.
25:38 Great. Thanks, Nolan. I think your report has been very thorough and very clear. I very much appreciate that. And I also think your design is very, you know, considerate of the site and of the neighbors and of the town's goals in general. The only comment I have would maybe be for the finding stating that the variance is the minimum departure only because
26:07 You've chosen to locate the building an additional six feet from the side yard setback area, but in consideration of keeping the existing trees, to me, I think that's a small point that basically balances out the request for additional footage into the creek setback. So I definitely appreciate all of those and
26:37 I would be very excited to see a very green, sustainable, regenerative building, as you stated, go up here in town. I also very much appreciate the inclusion of an accessory dwelling unit, which I think we all can agree will be beneficial to the town. I don't have any other further comments or questions on the findings specifically. Paul, Michael? No, I'm inclined to support this.
27:07 I don't have any other comments on this.
27:41 Would anybody like to entertain him? I would like to make a motion that we pursue option one, which is adopt the attached planning, economic and development commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving variance 18-003, which I don't think we had any conditions. Is that? There are conditions. With conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Which is be by staff.
28:12 Just by staff and modifications. I'll second it. All right. Shireen, vote, please. Okay. So, Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chair Callinan? Yes. And Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Yes. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you all very much. Congratulations. Thank you, everyone. Good luck with that list of agencies you have to deal with after the town. That's pretty... We've done the work here. Got it.
28:44 Building of the Year by the AIA in San Diego. It's very beautiful, and I'm very proud of it. I know they're proud of it, and so we have very high hopes for this one. Fantastic. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm used to it by now. My entire life. Even my maidem name was a mouthful.
29:06 All right. Thank you all. We'll move on to our next public hearing. To consider approval of use permit 17-001A for a modification to use permit 17-001 to allow commercial cannabis manufacturing facility in the industrial zoning district. This is located at 160 Commerce Drive, and it includes finding the product categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to guidelines section 15301.
29:34 Thank you. Fluids Manufacturing Inc. is requesting approval of a modification to their current use permit, UPA 17-001, in order to pursue licensing for commercial cannabis manufacturing for adult use and medicinal purposes. The use permit modification process is necessary. Oh, okay. It is
30:12 necessary for fluids manufacturing ink to produce cannabis oil for adult use and medicinal purposes since the original use permit approval permitted a medical marijuana cultivation use which limits the use to producing cannabis oil for medicinal purposes and prohibited the use from operating as a for-profit business.
30:36 The Planning and Economic Development Commission approved use permit, UPA 17-001, on June 14, 2017. That use permit approval permitted Fluids Manufacturing, Inc. to operate a medical marijuana cultivation facility at 160 Commerce Drive. The approved operations for the facility include extraction of cannabis oil from dried cannabis plant material within a closed loop equipment system utilizing ethanol.
31:03 It also allowed refining-based cannabis oil extractions through a distillation process to yield desired cannabis oil properties and products. It allowed in-house testing of cannabis products created within the facility for quality, potency, and development purposes. It allowed packaging and appropriately labeling products.
31:25 As well as storage and staging of products for transportation to legal medical marijuana cooperatives and dispensaries in a manner consistent with state law. On March 27, 2018, staff held a meeting with the Planning and Economic Development Commission Design Committee to review a minor design review application for fluids manufacturing, Inc. for a 725-square-foot equipment room addition located at the east side of the existing structure.
31:55 It was determined by staff that the proposed addition was within the scope of the approved use of the site and the design committee did not express any concerns related to the proposed design of the addition. The minor design review was approved on April 10, 2018. And subsequent to that approval, the applicant submitted an addendum to the building permit application for the installation of equipment on the exterior of the east side of the structure.
32:23 The exterior equipment includes four ethanol storage tanks used in the cannabis oil extraction process. They resemble storage tanks used in brewing processes. Other exterior equipment includes a trash compactor, backup generator, chiller, and cooling tower. The exterior equipment installation is accessory to the primary use of the property and was found to be consistent with the existing approved use permit.
32:50 The building permit for the exterior equipment installation is currently in review. Since the time of approval of the original use permit, there have been substantial changes in state law concerning the regulation and permitting requirements for cannabis businesses. The town subsequently undertook the process of updating applicable town ordinances to establish an appropriate permitting process and regulations for allowing commercial cannabis businesses to operate within the town.
33:19 Staff did an extensive amount of research and conducted numerous workshops and public hearings to develop new cannabis business regulations and permitting processes. On March 13, 2018, the Town Council adopted Ordinance Number 18-02, which approved Zoning Code Amendment 17-001 and Amendments to Municipal Code Chapter 5.38.
33:43 This ordinance enacted the current regulations the town now uses for permitting and regulating commercial cannabis businesses. The conditions of approval for the existing use permit no longer reflect the town's most current regulations applicable to commercial cannabis businesses, which now treat adult use and medicinal cannabis business operations the same.
34:08 Specific conditions of approval that were included as part of the original use permit requirements such as operating as a non-profit entity are no longer applicable and should be revised as part of this use permit modification. Fluids Manufacturing Inc. submitted their application on May 16, 2018 requesting approval of a modification to the existing use permit to reflect the town's current commercial cannabis business regulations and to permit
34:38 The commercial cannabis manufacturing use to produce bulk quantities of cannabis oil for both adult use and medicinal purposes. The proposed operations are substantially the same as originally permitted and include the following activities. The extraction of cannabis oil from dried cannabis plant material within a closed loop equipment system utilizing ethanol.
35:02 Refining base cannabis oil extractions through distillation process to yield desired cannabis oil properties and products, in-house testing of cannabis products created within the facility for quality, potency, and development purposes, packaging and appropriately labeling products, and the storage and staging of bulk quantity cannabis oil products for distribution to legal commercial cannabis businesses in a manner consistent with state law.
35:29 The proposed operation qualifies as a commercial cannabis nonvolatile manufacturing facility as defined within the new cannabis term section of our municipal code. It's section 17.148.020. Commercial cannabis nonvolatile manufacturing facilities are defined as
35:50 A facility engaged in the compounding, blending, extracting, infusing, or otherwise making or preparing a cannabis product by means of chemical synthesis or by a combination of extraction and or infusion and chemical
36:04 and chemical synthesis using non-volatile solvents. This includes facilities that process, prepare, hold, or store components and ingredients used in the manufacturing of cannabis products and facilities engaged in the holding, storing, packaging, or labeling of cannabis products. The use does not include manufacturing of cannabis products using volatile solvents as that use is prohibited within the town limits. The application materials submitted for Fluids Manufacturing, Inc.,
36:36 Document the applicant's ability and intent to comply with the applicable municipal code requirements. The recommended conditions of approval incorporate all municipal code requirements applicable to commercial cannabis businesses as well as specific requirements applicable to commercial cannabis non-volatile manufacturing facilities. The application was reviewed several times at our regular development review committee meeting.
37:06 which included the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and the Mammoth Lakes Community Water District. Comments were received from the Police Department and Fire Protection District which have been incorporated into the conditions of approval and additional conditions of approval were incorporated in response to comments received from the Building Division and Public Works.
37:31 The proposed commercial cannabis manufacturing facility is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15301 existing facilities because the use will occupy the existing structure which has undergone tenant improvements consistent with prior approvals. Staff has not received any public comments regarding the application and based on the application substantial compliance with the applicable municipal code requirements, staff recommends a
38:02 The commission choose option one and adopt the planning and economic development commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving use permit 17-001A with conditions as recommended by staff. That concludes my presentation and I'm happy to answer any questions. Great. Any quick questions for staff before the applicant comes up? Doubt. No. No. Okay.
38:36 Would you like to speak? You could introduce yourself, please. I betcha. I'm Mark Jolly. I'm the senior project engineer for the project. And I moved up here in November, 210 Crystal Lane, live up there by the hill. And I've really enjoyed it. I actually grew up in a city smaller than this in Idaho. I'm a farmer from Idaho, transplanted to San Diego.
39:06 And I'm not a user. I don't use cannabis in any form. And I got involved in the project because I was a scoutmaster in San Diego for 12 years, and I saw what opioids do to kids. And in particular, a suicide that we had. And, you know, we lived through that. And I've kind of made it my determination to help alleviate.
39:35 This problem that we have of opioids. And so when Stefan and Skyler asked me, I just got finished building a fish processing plant in Portugal. They asked me to come on board and help them. I did it because we have a great opportunity to attack this problem. And FMI is a world-class company. I invite you to come over and take a look at it. We're building a world-class facility. We've spared no expense to really do it right.
40:05 Hopefully, Brett was our latest visitor over there, but any of you are welcome to come over. We'd love to have a limited open house to show the public and dispel any questions or concerns that people have. The state has overwhelmed us with rules. There's over 700 pages of rules that we're trying to follow, and this application is due to that because the word
40:33 Just that word change in the state, we needed to have a change in the ordinance so that the state has the right paperwork so we're compliant. So that's the purpose behind this and Kim's done a great job but going through it all, it's been overwhelming. So yeah, that's why I moved here and that's why I took a pay cut.
40:54 to come to your great little beautiful town, and I look forward to becoming part of the community and helping us build a work class facility. None of the materials we make are sold here. You know, we're shipping it out to licensed facilities, and, you know, if you have any questions, myself or Robert, we're here. Okay. If you've got anything for me. Great, thank you. Thank you. Any questions for the applicant?
41:26 I don't at this time. I do have a question for either staff or the applicant. One of the documents here said the application material confirmed the company will utilize the compatible track and trace system as well as simplify software. Can we get a little more
42:03 information on this. May I? I'll let the applicant speak to the actual, I guess, interface for Simplifia, but they've indicated that this is a software program that assists them with complying with the applicable state laws. I see. Okay. So if you'd like to... No, that's okay. I just wanted to understand what the relevance of this information. Okay. Kim, you mentioned that... Sorry, I kind of lost my...
42:38 Place on this document here. You said the prior approval and this current proposed permit request, really there's no substantial changes to the actual business itself, right? Correct. So the actual uses that we would be permitting through this modification process are substantially the same. We've changed some of the terms.
43:09 to coordinate better with our current ordinance. So I think what you'll see in there is we've deleted some of the, well for this particular project the language that was included in the product, we included bulk oil.
43:38 So that's a minor change, for example, but they are substantially the same operations that we would be permitting. Now the additional equipment that was installed on the site, you said it was on the exterior of the building, right? Correct. So there has... Like additional 700 square feet, approximately? There was an addition to the structure. It's an attached...
44:06 Addition for an equipment storage room, 725 square feet, that went through the minor design review process. And then after that was approved, the applicants submitted an addendum to their building permit for that, requesting the installation of this exterior equipment. And that's still currently being reviewed through building and fire and planning. That additional equipment does not...
44:37 It doesn't really have any substantial changes as to what the initial approval that we had previously. Correct. So the equipment is for the same manufacturing process, the extraction process utilizing ethanol. We didn't specifically limit...
44:58 The type of equipment or the size of the equipment in the original use permit. So this would still be in line with that since there were no prior limitations. Okay. Thank you. And Kim, I just wanted to go over quickly the, in particular, the conditions and the resolution related to commercial cannabis and the special planning conditions that I believe were also part of the original use permit.
45:34 So would you say that there has been any issue in following up on the planning conditions from the previous use permit? So you're wondering if there has been compliance with the current use permit? Yes. Or is there anything substantially different in this use permit from the previous?
45:58 There are substantial differences in the conditions of approval because we've eliminated all of the prior conditions that were required for this medical marijuana cultivation land use which no longer exists. So there were specific conditions related to that land use that are no longer applicable that I've eliminated from the conditions of approval. And we've added a lot more.
46:27 Okay. And, uh,
46:58 Have you, the applicant, I'm sorry, Robert and Mark, thank you. Have you read and understand or discussed these conditions with staff and have any questions or problems with those? Okay. Have there been any, I guess, like security or fire concerns since the operation began?
47:26 So the operation has not begun. They've been working through their tenant improvements. So when you asked if all of the conditions had been complied with, it's a difficult question because they haven't begun operating. But they are in the process of installing all of their manufacturing equipment and getting their alarm systems online. I know that Brett Reed recently did an inspection at the site to review their alarm system.
47:55 So if you have any specific questions related to those sorts of operations, he might be able to speak more to that than I can. Okay. I don't know what to specifically ask other than does everything look like it seems to be in order from your perspective? Brett? Yeah. Please. My name's Brett Reed. I'm with the Fire Department Fire Inspector. Chair, Callanan. See how I did that, Mike? You nailed it. You nailed it.
48:30 Last week, I believe it was, went out and did an acceptance test for the fire alarm system. Everything went on without a hitch. The way we did it, we tested all the detection devices and all the relays. So from the relays, it goes to a monitoring system.
48:54 Monitoring Company and that company then relays back to our dispatch and our dispatch received all the notifications that we needed to. So from our perspective, they passed the acceptance test for the fire alarm system. Next will probably be the fire sprinkler system, I'm guessing.
49:17 We still have, as Kim mentioned, we still have the plans out to a third party plan review and we just received our first set of comments back from them and we'll kind of be waiting for that process to go through. So far, I would say as far as our conditions that we have been looking for, they've been very proactive.
49:46 in trying to meet what our conditions are. I gave them a pretty lengthy list at our last DRC meeting for what our conditions of approval would be. And at the acceptance test for the fire alarm system, they had already begun working on those and trying to check those items off the list.
50:14 Moving forward, I feel comfortable that we will get to where we need to be with this facility from a fire safety standpoint. It's, as Mark mentioned, it's a pretty impressive facility. It really is. And, you know, it's not something that I personally have worked on within the downman flake. So it's been a learning curve for us as well.
50:41 And I was really lucky to have taken it over right in the middle after Tom Heller's retirement. So it's been a big learning curve for myself, kind of getting thrown to the wolves, getting myself caught up. But they are definitely doing everything on their end that we've asked them to. So any other questions for myself or from the fire department concerns? No, no.
51:11 No, thank you very much. Pretty positive review. Thank you for that. Kim, I noticed there isn't a representative here from Mammoth Lakes PD. Would you characterize their review as positive as the fire department? I'm putting you on the spot. I really can't speak for them. But the only comments that I received from PD were related to the shipping and delivery hours that they wanted to limit for,
51:43 For this business, they, to ensure security, wanted to see shipping and delivery operations occur during the day. So 7 a.m. through 5 p.m., that was included in the conditions of approval, and that was the only request that I received from the police department. And the applicant is aware of that specific condition? I know this is beyond the applicant's control. One of the comments that I saw,
52:19 And the email was about the adjacent businesses are concerned about paying for additional insurance? That's for 219 Commerce Drive, so we can get to that with the next, that's the following modification. This business is in a standalone structure, doesn't share the site with any other use.
52:58 I've lost track of where we are. Did I open it up to public comments or questions yet? Not yet. No, not yet. Okay. Do you have anything to add before we do that? Okay. Any comments or questions from the general public? Okay. Just had to make sure we did that part. Thank you. We'll close the public comment period on this item. And just any other further comments, deliberation up here? We should just touch on the...
53:29 Findings that we need to make, again, similar to the previous item and the previous use permit, we need to find that we're consistent with the municipal code and not detrimental to public health and safety. I think we've covered those items pretty thoroughly so far, in my opinion. I would make a motion if the chair is okay. Okay. I'll entertain a motion. Okay.
53:56 I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approve use permit 17-001A with condition as recommended by staff. I'll second the motion. Okay. Shireen, vote please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chair Kellanen? Yes. Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. All right. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you. Thank you. So...
54:25 Staying on topic, similar topic anyway, moving on to our item number three, consider approval of use permit 17-002A for a modification of use permit 17-002, also to allow commercial cannabis distribution facility in the industrial zoning district at 219 Commerce Drive unit number one, including finding the project category exempt from CEQA. And Kim again.
54:55 Thank you. And I apologize if any of this is repetitive, but I think we need to touch all the bases. So this property is also owned by Fluids Manufacturing, and they have requested a modification to their original use permit application, UPA 17-002, in order to obtain licensing for a commercial cannabis distribution use for adult use and medicinal purposes.
55:25 The use permit modification process is necessary to permit fluids manufacturing ink to operate a commercial cannabis distribution facility for adult use and medicinal purposes since the original use permit approval permitted a medical marijuana cultivation use limiting the use to storing and transporting cannabis plant material exclusively for medicinal purposes.
55:50 The Planning and Economic Development Commission approved use permit, UPA 17-002, on June 14, 2017. That use permit approval permitted Fluids Manufacturing, Inc. to operate a medical marijuana cultivation facility at 219 Commerce Drive, Unit 1. The approved operations for the facility include, one, storage of cannabis plant material within sealed containers. A common size would be a 55-gallon drum.
56:20 Packaging materials and transportation of containerized cannabis plant material between approved marijuana cultivation facilities in a manner consistent with state law. Since the time that the original use permit was approved, there have been substantial changes in state law concerning the regulation and permitting requirements for cannabis businesses.
56:44 The town subsequently adopted Ordinance 18-02 on March 13, 2018, which enacted new regulations applicable to commercial cannabis businesses within town. The existing use permit and associated conditions of approval no longer reflect the town's most current regulations applicable to commercial cannabis businesses, which now treat adult use and medicinal cannabis business operations the same.
57:10 Specific conditions of approval that were included as part of the original use permit are no longer applicable and should be revised as part of this use permit modification request. The application submitted on May 16, 2018, requests approval of a modification to the existing use permit to reflect the town's current commercial cannabis business regulations and to permit a commercial cannabis distribution use at the site for both adult use and medicinal purposes.
57:41 The proposed operations are substantially the same as originally permitted and include the following activities, storage of cannabis plant material within sealed containers, storage of packaging materials and distribution of containerized cannabis plant material between licensed commercial cannabis businesses in a manner consistent with state law. The proposed operation qualifies as a commercial cannabis distribution facility as defined in
58:10 In the municipal code as follows. A facility engaged in the procurement, sales, and transport of cannabis or cannabis products between state licensed cannabis businesses. This also includes facilities that offer storage only services for a licensed cultivator, manufacturer, or other distributor. The application materials.
58:33 Submitted by Fluids Manufacturing Inc. Document the applicant's ability and intent to comply with the applicable municipal code requirements. The recommended conditions of approval incorporate all applicable municipal code requirements applicable to commercial cannabis businesses as well as specific requirements applicable to commercial cannabis distribution.
58:57 The application was reviewed by our Development Review Committee, including the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and the Mammoth Lakes Community Water District. Staff has incorporated one condition of approval, as requested by the Police Department, to limit delivery and shipping activities to between the hours of 7 a.m. and 5 p.m.
59:20 The proposed commercial cannabis manufacturing facility is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to section 15301 existing facilities because the use will occupy the existing structure. Staff did receive two public comments regarding the application and they have been included in the commissioner's packets and are part of the public record. Based on the analysis provided in
59:46 The staff report, it is staff's opinion that the required findings to support the requested approval can be made and staff recommends approval of use permit 17-002A with the conditions of approval included in the resolution. That concludes my presentation for this application. I'm happy to answer any questions. All right. Thank you, Kim. Any questions up here for staff or Kim? No.
1:00:23 Any further comments that an applicant would like to make? Okay. On both locations, the security system is state-of-the-art, 27 cameras, sensors everywhere, keypads, limited access, very controlled by the state. The track and trace system is very detailed. It's not live yet. They're hoping to have it live in the next week or two.
1:00:48 We're building up to that. We've brought in two experts to handle that and make sure, because we have to track everything right down to the half gram. Over on 219, after Rob and I started working last year, getting ready for it, and in the spring, you know, we've made a decision to only store over there, not even take them out of the packaging, because we want to respect the neighbors and try and keep it real clean.
1:01:16 The loading of the containers will actually be done at the farms, at the licensed farms, and they'll ship in dornishes, so the drums will sit in a large plastic container that's sealed and locked. That way we don't have to worry about any loss or any open, so it won't even be opened in that facility. The closed truck will show up, they'll move these plastic dornishes in that have
1:01:44 They look like 55 gallon drums inside them. That will all stay sealed and locked until it comes over to 160 where the seal will be broken and everything gets entered into track and trace. But both locations are monitored. We've been live since March on the camera security. We've got some great photos of a bear going through the dumpster. I'm sorry. Any other questions? No, not for me. No.
1:02:18 Any questions or comments from the public on this item? All right, thank you. It seems to me that we covered the majority of the questions of the previous item, Kim. I realize that their uses are slightly different, but given the information that Brett gave us in the last item about security and fire and all the compliance or ongoing compliance with the applicant with the time's requirements,
1:02:52 I assume that all those are still the case for this part of their operation as well. I don't have any other comments up here. I have one really, really quick question to the applicant. Between the two facilities, how big of a workforce do you have? I guess I've got to do a rewrite. Sorry. Please. Yeah. Right. I think that's a good question because we're not sure, to be honest with you. Right now we have the construction crew. It's pretty healthy.
1:03:26 Trying to get this mechanically complete, which should happen in the next couple weeks. But I would say full-time staff, I would guess around eight employees, most of which are highly paid engineers and chemists. We've hired three local guys. We're still looking. If anybody knows people, we'd love to hire more local people and possibly
1:03:55 We're looking at adding some office, just office or renting some more office space so we can bring in more employees. We'd love to just give you a ton of money. Thank you. Great answer, by the way. Paul, were questions addressed or did you have a question about one of the public comments? Other than how did staff address the question with the
1:04:31 The neighbors. So one of the public comments that we received was for one of the adjacent, these are industrial condominium units, so one of the adjacent owners submitted a letter on behalf of the two other owners within the building, and their comments were really related to sort of the liability from the federal
1:04:58 enforcement of laws surrounding cannabis, and the town has included a section that we really cannot, we can't guarantee that the feds are not going to come and do a search or take any of the inventory that is stored in this facility. This is a separately owned condominium unit, so the other units are owned.
1:05:24 You know, individually. I don't think that a search warrant would apply to other individually owned units. But as far as liability for that, the town really doesn't have any assurances that we can offer. And I think one of the other concerns was related to a spike in insurance for insuring the building.
1:05:50 Based on the uses that are included within it. And again, that isn't something that the town can really have a say in. And we can't provide any assurances. So if the HOA wanted to take an action, I think that they would need to do that independently. Because there's nothing really that the town is able to provide in either of those cases.
1:06:21 Okay. The insurance portion, I think they were talking about a cancellation of the insurance policy because of this business, right? I understand that is not our problem or that's beyond the scope of control of the applicant and also control of the town.
1:06:52 But are there really instances like that that actually have happened in the past? Would you mind coming up, please? Good afternoon. I'm Robert Calvert, representing fluids manufacturing. I've been working in the cannabis industry for the last eight years, specifically here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. We have had insurance policies. It hasn't been a problem. I have directed, had communications with the other two owners, with the other two units. We have addressed it, and we have worked it out, so.
1:07:26 It's at this time, I'm not aware that it's any concern. And if it is, we've had a very good relationship with the neighbors. So we mitigated any issues. And I see Lisa Walker is here. She's the owner of the unit that we rent. And I don't see any problems. But I assure you that everything's fine. Well, that's comforting to hear. I'm glad that you've worked everything out.
1:07:53 Thank you for trying to be good neighbors. And I'm imagining they resubmitted their letter just as an extra safety cushion on their behalf. And I think everyone realizes that that is beyond the jurisdiction of the town and of us as a commission. Thank you. Thank you. I don't have any other questions. Would you entertain a motion? Absolutely. I would like to make a motion to take option one, which is adopt the attached planning and economic development commission.
1:08:28 Resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving use permit 17-002A with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second that. All right. Shireen? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chair Kellinen? Yes. And Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you all. Thank you. Thanks, guys. All right. We'll have to check it out. Yeah.
1:09:02 All right, we have one more public hearing continuing in the cannabis train here. This is number four, to consider approval of use permit 18-001 to allow ESHD Inc., DBA Green Mammoth, to operate an adult use and medical cannabis retailer business at 94 Laurel Mountain Road, Suite 204, including finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA.
1:09:28 Pursuant to guidelines section 15301 existing facilities. And we are going to listen to Nolan again. All right. Thank you. Use permit 18-001 is a request for a use permit to operate an adult use of medicinal cannabis retailer. The proposed business is required to operate in compliance with all state and local laws pertaining to cannabis businesses, which include obtaining a use permit and state licenses for all the proposed commercial cannabis activities.
1:09:59 The proposed cannabis retail location will be operated by the same entity that operates the existing Green Mammoth Medical Marijuana Cooperative and will be in the same commercial space on the second floor of the building. They are not proposing any changes to the facility other than what is required by town and state regulations. The original use permit for the Medical Marijuana Cooperative was issued in 2012. The business has remained in good standing with the town and the police department since they began operations.
1:10:28 If approved, use permit 18-001 will supersede the previous use permit, which was UPA 12-004. A new use permit is required since medical marijuana cooperative uses are no longer a use as recognized by the state or town regulations, and the updated cannabis regulations contain additional regulations applicable to commercial cannabis businesses.
1:10:54 is currently authorized to operate as an adult use cannabis retailer under temporary authorization provisions that are in the town's updated cannabis regulations. Those regulations allowed existing cannabis businesses that are in good standing with the town and were in existence prior to January 1st, 2018 to obtain a state temporary license prior to approval of a new or amended use permit. The regulations require the operator to sign an affidavit acknowledging that they are only being approved for $100
1:11:24 100-day temporary license from the state. The town was under no obligation to issue a new or amended use permit. Green Mammoth submitted the signed affidavit on July 11, 2018 and were issued the state temporary license on July 23, 2018. They began adult use sales under that temporary license on August 1, 2018. The staff report describes the project's compliance with the general plan and the municipal code.
1:11:53 The project is consistent with the general plan because cannabis retailers provide a commercial service for residents and visitors and the existence of a cannabis retailer that is legally allowed to sell cannabis to those 21 years of age or older will protect the public safety of the community by reducing the demand for illegal cannabis in the black market.
1:12:14 The project is consistent with the municipal code because the project is required to maintain compliance with all the regulations for cannabis retailer specified in municipal code section 17.52.085D. The staff report provides details on how this project is in compliance with each regulation. Additionally, the retailer is required to obtain and maintain the appropriate state license for a cannabis retailer and obtain an annual town commercial cannabis permit.
1:12:43 Cannabis retailers and all other commercial cannabis businesses in town will be subject to two audits of the business on an annual basis. One of those audits is for compliance on a regulatory side and the second is for financial. And the operator is responsible for payment of those fees associated with those audits as part of their annual permit.
1:13:06 As part of the annual review of the commercial cannabis permit, staff will review the results of those audits to ensure that there are no major violations or issues with the operation of the business. Staff determined that the required findings for a use permit and a commercial cannabis business use permit can be made and recommend approval of use permit 18-2001 with conditions as recommended by staff. Once again, that concludes my presentation.
1:13:37 The operator of ESHD Incorporated, Dawn Wright, is here if anyone has any questions. Okay. Great. Thank you. Would you like to speak? Yeah, Dawn Wright, Green Mammoth. Ever since August 1st, it's been really busy. I dropped off a sales thing from the 1st, and I'm definitely going to have to hire more employees. If there's anything,
1:14:22 That I would maybe address is changing my hours if I could stay open with the town's hours if I get to that point. Not much to say. So this information came from you? Yeah. Okay. And this is just? Seven days. This is seven days. Okay. And yeah, I had to
1:14:56 Changed from the non-profit to a for-profit. Just named it ESHD Inc. Doing business as Green Mammoth. Went and got a bank account somehow again. And trying to set up all my new POS system to work with QuickBooks. And I love my new point of sale system. It's not a nightmare like my old one. So I'm sure...
1:15:25 HDL companies will be really happy and probably have the audits be easier on them. And found some problems in July, like going through, like when we would do multiple discounts, sometimes it would just take, you know, like we'd give someone a new patient discount. For some reason, instead of giving it 10% off, it added 4%.
1:15:50 Emailed the company that makes the software and they were not able to give any answers to my mom about why it was doing that. There was also sales where you'd give a discount and it added $52 but I can't watch over every employee and every discount that goes down every day. So I told everybody watches a little bit more but this new system's really awesome. Don, how would you
1:16:20 This is kind of an open-ended question, but what percentage of your walk-in customers now for recreational are, would you characterize as adult use, would you characterize as visitors versus people you recognize from around town, local? I mean, hard to say with just seven days and blues-a-palooza. That's a really good point. Yeah.
1:16:46 Yeah, there's definitely a lot of locals that have come in and just like, finally, I'm happy to come in here without a license. We're not really, I mean, hard to say. I could, the software will do analytics and I could pull it off of, you know, zip codes and find out we're locals to non-locals, which I'm going to try and do to
1:17:18 See where I'm at with the T bid. But as far as like signing people up medically, we just haven't really been doing that because there's not really a point unless someone's going to buy over an ounce of marijuana to sign someone up for medical because there's no difference in taxes, there's no difference statewide in taxes or locally because it's all 21 and up whether you're medical or recreational here in Mammoth.
1:17:51 And I'm also thinking that the state will probably change something where it'll be medical only with you having a state card. We'll see what happens when their final regulations come out on that. Dawn, can you clarify what you meant by you want to work with staff or request staff for something about hours? I was confused about.
1:18:16 Sure. So the town's regulations allow cannabis retailers to operate 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. In his original submittal, he listed what his proposed hours were, but the condition of approval in the resolution just requires compliance with that section of the code. So as long as he's operating between 9 and 9, then he's in compliance, and he can adjust his hours accordingly within that area.
1:18:44 And are you saying that you want to extend the hours or you want to shorten? Oh, no, not extend them, just operate within those hours. Because currently you're operating within the hours that the state has. Well, no, I'm operating within the old town's regulated hours from 10 to 6. When it used to be you could operate from 9 to 7. And I just do 10 to 6 because that's an 8-hour day and I don't want to hire more people. But if it's going to be this busy, I mean, might as well stay open.
1:19:14 You know, have a 9 to 3 staff and then a 3 to 9 staff. Okay. The state actually allows them to go, I think, 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. for cannabis retailers. During our discussions with kind of cannabis working group and development of the regulations, we selected 9 to 9 as far as the town's operating hours for cannabis retailers. Okay. Or the allowed hours. And then one other clarification I was going to make based on what Don said was with regards to medical,
1:19:45 The state restricts adult use cannabis sales to one ounce per day, but on a medicinal patient with a valid physician's recommendation can buy up to eight ounces per day. Which is ridiculous.
1:20:07 It'll never happen, so you just sign everybody up as adult use. Unless someone really wants to go, I mean, and it could happen, you know, someone from Bishop or Lone Pine that doesn't want to make a drive up here for, you know, a small amount, they want to stock up, I could see it happening in that aspect, but I wouldn't see it happening that much. I'm sorry. No, go ahead. I don't have any concept as to
1:20:37 Looking at your gross sales relative to the traffic pattern, the frequency of visitations of people frequent your store, does that mean there's a lot more traffic coming through that area? Yeah, there's a lot. So is there some sort of traffic impact in that particular neighborhood? Vehicular traffic.
1:21:04 Pedestrian, just, is that what you're talking about, traffic in the neighborhood? Oh. No, so this being a retail business, it's looked at just on a general retail use. It's not looked at as a specific cannabis retail. It's, so retail services are also anticipated to have increased vehicular traffic than, say, a residential neighborhood would. So in that case, it wouldn't be to say that it's exceeding any of the VMTs for that neighborhood or that street.
1:21:34 Our traffic analysis for, this is in the downtown zone, right? Our traffic analysis considers full build out along Laurel Mountain Road and I'd say we're substantially less dense than that at this moment so you can't imagine we could be getting anywhere close to traffic impacts at full build out. So that traffic analysis did include full build out which includes Old Mammoth Place Project.
1:22:04 We'll be out of the commercial zones, you know, throughout the downtown zone, both on Old Mammoth Road, Laurel Mountain and Main Street. So one business here is, he's busier than he was when he was just medicinal, but I don't imagine it's anywhere close to what the traffic can handle there. Certainly it's a good problem, so.
1:22:29 Part of the original approvals were related to an audit process. You mentioned an audit process. Did you mention whether one of those audits has been conducted? Yes. Both the medical marijuana cooperatives that were in existence had a hybrid regulatory and financial audit done. I'm not sure the exact date. I'd say within the last six months.
1:22:58 Recently got those results, or the Finance Director did, and reviewed those. They're not a public document that can be shared, but there weren't any major red flags or issues that were identified in either of the audits from either business. Okay. That's good news. Now, my understanding is with this, given that now it's adult use, that it's not a requirement anymore, right?
1:23:26 I mean, the previous audits under the old regulations were intended to ensure that the business wasn't making a profit, that they're operating as a true non-profit. Going forward, the audits are to ensure that on the regulatory side, they're complying with all the regulations of the town and the state, and on the financial side is that they're not diverting money or diverting product and that all the taxes owed to the town and the state are being paid and tracked accurately.
1:23:56 So it's related to the tax? The financial aspect is related to the taxes? Primarily, yes. Okay. All right. Don, have you read and understand all of the items in the conditions of approval? Do you have any questions about that? No. Everything makes sense? It's been going well so far? Sure.
1:24:24 Overall, yeah, I will. Yeah, I will. Overall, I think your report, again, Nolan, is complete. Thank you, and to you again, Kim, for all of this very detail-oriented staff reports this time around. So, sure, go ahead. Okay. I'll make a motion to adopt a PEDC, attached PEDC resolution, making it require CEQA and municipal co-findings and improving use permit 18-
1:24:53 001 with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second the motion. And one more vote, please. Okay. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chair Callanan? Yes. And Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Great. Motion passes 3-0. Thanks, Don. Thank you. Thanks, Don. Thanks again, Nolan. All right. That wraps up our public hearings. We have one business matter which is related to selecting officers up here.
1:25:26 So we will need to select a chair and vice chair and discuss the committee appointments. And just as a note, I did communicate with both Commissioner Eckert and Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Eckert said he didn't have any preference about being on any of the committees.
1:25:45 and was fine with the status quo. Commissioner Burroughs said that she is fine staying on the design or mobility committee. However, she's happy to step down if someone else has an interest in one of the two committees. So just to pass that along to the group. Thank you, Sandra. I would like to just propose for a conversation that we consider retaining Amy as our chairperson. I think she's done a very thorough and admirable job.
1:26:16 leading this commission. It's probably a black hole of her time that she would rather have back, but she serves with admiration. So I would be more than happy to have Amy as our chair. I second that.
1:26:34 You spoke awfully quickly there, Paul. Are you sure? Does this go to a vote? It's just consensus. Consensus? Yeah. Paul, are you sure you don't want to feel the weight of the gavel in your hands? I feel it right here. My osmosis. And then I'm more than willing to retain the Vice Chair unless you are interested, Paul. No, I think both of you have done a great job. Thank you. Thank you.
1:27:04 I believe that's consensus. That's consensus for the chair and the vice chair. Unless we need to do something different. Okay. I think we're good to go. And then the design committee? Design committee. Currently it's Commissioner Burroughs and Amy. Would you like to give the design committee a try, Paul? I think you might have some interesting insight.
1:27:35 If it was something you'd be willing to consider. First of all, I think housing has concluded. Is that correct? Mm-hmm. The housing working group concluded. Yeah, I think so, yeah. Yeah, okay. Correct. Just so we know we're not, like, completely burying you. No, not at all. In subcommittees. Not at this moment. I think I'm okay, you know. Just that arm a little bit. I think you would bring a pretty educated eye and an interesting perspective to design, but I'm going to respect your opinion.
1:28:08 No, I think, you know, both you and Jen have done a great job, so. And we meet, we only meet probably once every other month, I would say. It's not a kind of a, it's not a ton of time. It's not a big time commitment. Just so you understand the kind of meeting schedule. It does give us an opportunity. I really enjoy it, so I'm happy to stay. Yeah, so I think that's good. That's it.
1:28:37 The fact that you enjoy, I think this speaks volume a little bit. It doesn't mean that you couldn't also, there are two spots available on the design committee. Well, currently Commissioner Burroughs sits on design and mobility, so I think her, we're kind of overloading her a bit. And I would be more than happy to share the mobility with Jen, but we're wondering if you would like to...
1:29:02 I'm shaming you for at the moment. That's what I'm doing, Paul. Twisting your arm a bit. I'll be happy to assist. But I just, you know, I didn't want to take the position away from anybody. So if you'd like me to jump in to assist. I think that would be helpful. Was that to replace you or is that to replace Jen? No, no, no, to replace Jen. And then we, Jen, can focus on mobility committee. And we can spread the...
1:29:31 Yeah, no, certainly. Responsibilities. Responsibilities. I wasn't trying to... Is that consensus? Yes. Sandra? Yes. Okay. Okay. Boom. Done. Thank you. Thank you, Paul. I think in there we agreed mobility would remain Jennifer and Michael. And that's all we have for committees. Yep. Correct? Right? Yes. I think we do have a meeting, right? A joint meeting of some sort?
1:30:00 Yes, the workshop with the town council. I don't think I replied. I'll talk about it during my director's report. Okay, so I think that's it for officers and committees. We do have a consent agenda consisting of the minutes from last month's meeting and final tract map for the Manzanita Creek condominium project. And we can approve that by consensus unless anyone wants to pull or discuss anything.
1:30:32 It's a motion. I don't, but I would like to make a motion that we approve the consent agenda for the August 8th, 2018 Planning Commission meeting. July 11th? Well, the consent agenda, I think, can we just make a motion to approve the consent agenda? Yes, you can approve both items, unless you want to pull one of the items, yes. Which I think was the motion. Yes. All right, and we can just do,
1:31:03 Voice vote. All in favor? Aye. Motion passes. Consent agenda passed. All right. Commissioner reports. There's another one. No, that approved both at once. So we just approved the entire consent agenda. Oh, I see. So both items within the consent agenda. So Haste doesn't have to provide his report? You're right. Okay. Got it. Okay. Got it. Okay. I don't have any. Is that okay? I mean. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:31:38 I'm good. I'm good. And I don't have a report. I don't believe the Mobility Committee has met since our last meeting. Is that correct, Sandra? No, you haven't. Michael, let's see. Oh, since our last Planning Commission meeting. Planning Commission meeting. So I don't have anything to report then. All right, that sounded fine. I don't have anything to report either. I don't think I really have anything to report. We haven't had a Design Committee meeting. I guess we will be having one to consider.
1:32:07 Let's see, Ruth emailed me, and now I can't. Sam's Woods. The entrance, little kiosk at the Sam's, we should probably not call it Sam's Woods anymore, at the Winter's Woods, at the Woods site. That's the proper name now? It's called the Winter Woods? No, no, no. The last name of the owner is Winter Woods. I don't think there is a proper name right now. Oh, I see, just the Woods site. Just the Woods site. Woods site, yeah. Woods site, okay. All right.
1:32:36 That's all on the horizon. Oh, I think you mentioned upcoming second meeting of the ADP, possibly in September, except I will not be here for half of September. Right. You're out the 8th through the 26th. Yes. Right. So, yeah, we will work to try to schedule that around your schedule so that we can make sure that you're able to attend that meeting. I think that'd be great. Yeah. Okay. Director's report.
1:33:04 So just a quick item. I emailed the group about the joint meeting with the town council. They've requested September 5th at 4. I've heard, I think, from all of you, and the only commissioner who can't attend is Commissioner Chang. So I'm maybe...
1:33:23 A discussion as to whether the commission would like to move forward that meeting without you, or if you would like to try, staff to try to reschedule that meeting. Your calendars for the fall are pretty busy, at least from the group that I've heard from. Greg is out mid-September, and he's also out after October 18th. And Michael, I have your schedule.
1:33:50 So I'm just kind of wanting to know what the pleasure of the commission is. If you'd like us to try to schedule it, then all five commissioners can be there. We're happy to do that. Is there any chance that we could find a date that all five of us are actually here? There's probably a chance. I don't know when it would be, though. Do you have days on either side of that 5th that you would be available? I'm gone 5th, 6th, 7th, at least those three days. What about the 4th?
1:34:23 It's a Tuesday. Fourth is a possibility. That's the day after Labor Day, I think. It is. Just as a note. I'm here on the fourth. And the commission or the council usually tries to schedule it before their regular meetings. So that's what we would probably try to look for first is to have it on a regular council meeting the first or the third Wednesdays of the month. But that wouldn't be, it doesn't look like it would be September.
1:34:55 They meet twice a month though, right? They meet the first and the third Wednesdays of the month. So September, it wouldn't work for all five commissioners because I have most of your schedules. Possibly in October it might work. The 24th is what you're thinking? No. Of October? No, it would be the 3rd or the 17th. October would be the 3rd and the 75th Wednesdays. 3rd and the 17th, right, right, right. And we were also going to ask the commission about rescheduling.
1:35:21 Just as another note, the October Planning Commission meeting doesn't work for town staff. We're all going to be at the APA conference. So we were going to ask to reschedule that meeting possibly for October 17th, although I need to confirm that this room is available. But that might be a good day. If the commissioners are all available, we could have a commission meeting. No. I am not available on the 17th or the 18th or the 19th. Of October. Of October. Okay. I'm pretty much gone that entire.
1:35:51 Okay. I'm sorry. No, it's okay. It's fine. Yeah, the schedules are, so it sounds like what I'm hearing is that we would like to try to schedule the joint meeting for when all five of you can attend. I mean, I think, of course, that would be ideal. Yeah. But if, I think council needs to consider having a meeting on a non-council meeting day. Otherwise, it's not going to happen. It's very unlikely that it could happen. Okay.
1:36:27 So if they'd be willing to meet on, if they want to meet soon, then maybe if they'd be willing to meet on the 4th of September, maybe that would work. What about our September meeting? I won't be here. September meeting, I'm sorry, what is the date on that? I will be here. But Amy will not be here. But Amy will not. Okay. And I think it's important the chairperson. It's important the chairs should be here. I'll talk to the town manager.
1:36:53 We'll put together some, maybe I'll put together like a doodle poll so that we can get, you know, some dates that work for everyone and then work to schedule that. Cool. Thank you. That would be great. Thank you. And that was all I had. Could you update us on whether you have been successful in finding a Civic Spark intern application? Oh, I forgot about that. A Civic Spark fellow? Thank you. We have one application so far.
1:37:23 for the position and will likely interview that person this week or next week. The Civic Spark group is still trying to push this out so we can get some more applications. They usually like to have a couple of different applicants to interview so that you can kind of make a decision comparing kind of that group. So the position was scheduled to start on September 10th, which is
1:37:53 Pretty soon. And so the Civic Spark Group has told us that we can have six weeks after September 10th to start someone. And then after that, we can't start anyone until next year. So we're hoping that we can push it out a little bit more, get some more interest in it. We've been trying to kind of send the application out to different groups.
1:38:15 And it doesn't necessarily need to be someone who has a lot of housing experience. It's really someone who has gone through some level of college and wants to go through this program. The program is a specific program. It's not actually a town employee. They're employed by Civic Spark or by the state. So it's kind of a unique...
1:38:39 Position. So we're going to keep looking and keep sending it out to try to find someone to fill that position and really, really hoping that we can do that because that would add a lot of capacity for us in implementing the housing action plan. And kind of on a similar note, we have the town council authorized staff.
1:38:59 For $80,000 to hire a contract housing coordinator, someone who would also help implement the housing action plan and would help Mammoth Lakes Housing, provide some assistance to Mammoth Lakes Housing through this transition period as their executive director is now a supervisor for the Mono County. And we had that RFP out and we received one proposal. So we extended the deadline until Monday.
1:39:28 We're hopeful. We've pushed it out a lot more, so hopeful to get a couple proposals to review. If we don't get any more proposals on Monday, we'll have to probably kind of maybe think about crafting that RFP, interviewing that consultant, talking with them who did propose. But same thing, we would like to have a number of consultants to look at and compare.
1:39:51 to choose something like that. So both of those are kind of out a little bit, but we're trying to be optimistic that we'll find somebody to help us through this time. Any other questions? I don't. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. You're welcome. All right. Well, I guess that concludes our meeting for this afternoon, and we will adjourn to the next regularly scheduled meeting on Wednesday, September.
1:40:23 12th, I think we just said, at 2pm. Correct. Thank you. Thank you.