Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2018
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 57 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
250 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:10 Good afternoon, everyone. I'd like to call to order the September 12th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, would you like to do roll call? Mr. Burroughs, present. Mr. Chang, Mr. Eckert, present. Vice Chair Vandover, present. Chair Kellerman. I'd like you all to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Greg, would you like to lead us? The Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation,
1:43 Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, I'd like to invite any member of the public who would like to come up for public comment on perhaps a matter that is not on today's agenda. Please come forward now. Hi, my name's Don Condon. I'm a resident of Mammoth Lakes. I'm also a volunteer with the Ready for 100 campaign for Mammoth Lakes and also the Electric Vehicle Association chapter of Eastern Sierra.
2:17 Some time ago we generated a list of 10 easy lift items for Mammoth Lakes to move to more renewable energy. The Ready for 100 campaign basically is a campaign which aspires to the goal of 100% renewable electricity by 2030 and 100%
2:45 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:12 A list of 10 small steps that we submitted to the Town Council in August. And on the top of that list is to waive permit fees for renewable energy projects, including solar, geothermal, insulation, wind, any renewable energy project that we should be waiving permit fees for. This has already been done in Mono and Inyo counties.
3:40 They've already waived those permit fees, and I have the resolution that indicates that, which I can turn into the clerk so that she has that on the record. So our simple ask is this, that the town of Mammoth Lakes investigate waiving permit fees for renewable energy projects. Solar energy is now very competitive, roughly $3 a watt.
4:08 We should rather than discourage people from installing solar, encourage them, and part of that process would be to reduce those permit fees. It can cost anywhere from $400 to $1,000 to get a permit to install a solar system. And the same thing with electric vehicle charging stations. So basically I'm just here to ask that that be pursued and put on the agenda perhaps at some time to discuss in more detail.
4:37 Thank you very much. Anyone else for public comment? Going, going, gone. All right, I will close public comment now and we'll move on to our business matter. We actually have a pretty light agenda, so the business matters will be the next thing we tackle. And Sandra, did you want us to come down to...
5:04 Yeah, we thought that for this item, since it's a workshop, to have the commissioners come and sit down at this table here, we'll have our consultants here and staff will be here, so it's a more informal setting. Perfect. And I believe, Kim, you are our staff point person for this? I am, thank you. I'll just briefly introduce our CEPA team. They're the Community Planning Assistance for Wildfire group who head up this program.
5:53 And the town and the fire protection district jointly put in an application for this program back in October of 2017. And we were granted the full assistance, which is planning assistance. So it's not money where we go out and hire a consultant to help us with this work. We actually get the experts on our team, and they work with us for a year and provide their expertise in wildfire prevention and mitigation.
6:22 And they did their kickoff site visit back in April, April 3rd and 4th of 2018. And we met with local stakeholders to get local input on concerns and areas which the public had expressed interest. And we did site visits so that they could get a feel for our local conditions.
6:48 And then in May, they did an audit of all of our documents that are all our policy documents that would have wildfire or fire hazard mitigation policies in them. So they reviewed our zoning code, our general plan, and other applicable documents to identify opportunities and areas where we need to improve.
7:13 And so this is their final site, I'm sorry, missed one site visit, their last, their second visit was in July 26th and 27th and they gave planning staff a training, I think you were there Michael and a few of the planners from Mono County attended that training as well and we did some additional field tours of areas in town that we'll see development in the future.
7:41 And today is the CEPA team's final visit to the town, and they're going to present their recommendations. And the recommendations are in draft form, and so we're having this workshop to discuss them and provide any input or feedback that we can get. And I will turn it over to Molly Mowry. Well, I'm going to stand up here for the presentation part, but then during the workshop we'll be...
8:13 A little bit more interactive than standing at the podium. Again, my name is Molly Mowry. I am part of the CEPAW team. I am joined by Kelly Johnston and Aaron Fannin-Steele. And so you'll get to know all of us a little bit more throughout this afternoon's workshop. And right now, Aaron and Kelly are handing out just a summary of the recommendations, the draft recommendations.
8:40 And for the commissioners, the full set of recommendations for your reference.
8:48 So as Kim said, we CEPAW is a national program. We're funded by the U.S. Forest Service and private foundations. So none of our assistance comes at any charge to any of our communities. Our program was founded in 2014 by Headwaters Economics and the company that I founded, Wildfire Planning International. Headwaters Economics is a nonprofit based out of Bozeman, Montana, and they are the administrators of the program.
9:16 And so our team provides assistance to communities across the country. We've worked with 26 to date, and we look at planning challenges associated with development in the wildland-urban interface.
9:27 So as Kim said, this is our third and final site visit, and we're not finished yet, but we really wanted to use this opportunity to talk to you about our draft recommendations, get stakeholder input, and really make sure that what we're proposing is aligned with the interests of the town. So we've, you know, this is our third site visit. We've collected a lot of information to date, and today's objective really is to make sure that you have a voice and an opportunity to ask us questions too.
9:56 One thing that's important to note is that all of our recommendations are ultimately voluntary. So anything we propose based on what we've learned about the town and ways you might be able to improve the wildfire risk here, it's ultimately up to you. So anything we give is guidance and you can integrate it how you think is appropriate.
10:18 So what we always start out with communities is looking at both the challenges and the opportunities. And that gives us a lot of context for understanding where is it that we can make a difference. So I just wanted to share with you a couple of the planning challenges that we looked at on our field tours or that we talked about with staff or other stakeholders. The first one was this village in the trees concept. And it's very common, especially in ski resort communities, where there's a
10:46 An aesthetic preference, a lifestyle preference for how you integrate nature into the community and that's a good thing. However, we also looked back on the way that the general plan has referenced the village in the trees concept and really the oversight and meaningfully integrating wildfire risk reduction in that process. So we saw it as the need to reconcile lifestyle and aesthetic with understanding what is the wildfire risk though and how do you accommodate for both in the plan.
11:15 We also looked at existing residential and commercial development and in this challenge we found there's a lot of existing structures that were not subject to
11:28 Current WUI construction standards because they were built prior to requirements. And so some of these older structures that are constructed of wood siding and roofs that have not yet been retrofitted, they may be more susceptible to ignition through radiant heat or convective heat or embers. And so, you know, that's another challenge that we recognized. And again, this is very common in the communities that we work in. So Mammoth Lakes certainly isn't alone.
11:57 Another challenge that we talked about with the fire department and planning staff was just the sheer volume of
12:06 Visitors that you see in the summertime and how dispersed they are. And in some neighborhoods there may be a challenge with access in the event that there is a wildfire event. So there's some limitations on how quickly people could get in as well as how safely first responders could get to an area. And then we talked about campers or other visitors that may be less familiar with the local conditions and wildfire risk and kind of what that means for the town.
12:35 during wildfire season and how to safely evacuate large numbers of people.
12:42 On the flip side, we also talked about how many opportunities there are to advance planning for the wildland urban interface. So one of the key reasons why the town even applied was the timing of the general plan update and how the opportunity for upcoming plans really fits into the CEPAW process, you know, where we can actually make a difference. So it was exciting for us to work with the town and see the safety element, which we'll talk about today, was
13:09 was up and coming for updates and we wanted to make sure that we aligned our process with that opportunity. We also talked about on our second most recent site visit with planning staff some of the future areas of development, one of them being here, the shady rest parcel, and how that could be an opportunity for looking at it as a model of
13:32 Resilience and building in either regulatory or voluntary measures that look at best practices on housing and landscaping and access. So certainly, you know, we looked at there may be many areas that have been developed, but there may also be areas that are not yet developed where a difference could be made. And then one thing that we can never
13:58 Overlook, because this is such a critical factor in all the communities that we look at is here the level of collaboration and partnerships that is in place already is significant and helpful and we found that to be a really positive opportunity for any of the recommendations that we are going to talk about today there's a groundwork in place so between the planning staff, fire department staff, fire safe council, the stakeholder other state and
14:25 Federal stakeholders we've been working with has been a big boon for our own understanding, so I just want to give a special thank you to Captain Martinez with Cal Fire and Eric Vane with the U.S. Forest Service, Chief Freevault with the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department. All of these stakeholders have been really helpful for us in working with the planning staff and having these conversations, and so that already in and of itself is a good opportunity to move forward.
14:52 And then finally, there's many positive examples. Whether they were done for fire specifically, or in some cases they were, or whether they were just best practices for home construction and following the code, we recognize that there are positive examples of mitigation that has occurred, and so we wanted to make sure that those can get used as examples of success.
15:14 So now we're going to just, I'm going to briefly at the 30,000 foot view give you the four recommendations in draft form and highlight them and then during the workshop we'll go into a lot more detail. So we'd ask that, you know, unless you have just a quick clarification question that we'll have plenty of time to talk about these once we get into the next portion of the meeting. So the first recommendation that we
15:42 Thank you so much.
16:04 It's not the best quality image, but it gives you a sense of one of those hazard assessments that was adopted by the town and what's in use right now. However, one thing we recognized in the recommendations, and Kelly will talk about this, that there's some limitations with just identifying a very small portion of the town as extreme risk. So our recommendation was a much more comprehensive approach to developing a wildfire hazard assessment that
16:32 Planning Department can use that has a much more detail and information that will guide what in the wildland urban interface should be subject to planning policies or future requirements.
16:45 This is just an example from another community of a type of wildfire hazard assessment that gets to a more stratified or more levels of delineation within hazard. So in other words, it's not just extreme or nothing. There's a lot more in between that we recognize that could be subject to wildfire. Second recommendation is to adopt new
17:11 Fire mitigation policies and the general plan safety element. Again, this was a core reason why the town applied because this opportunity was up and coming and the town recognized that the last time the safety element was updated was in 2007. Since that time, new requirements were enacted by the state that have changed what has to go into the safety element to address wildfire hazard.
17:35 So our team, in conjunction with what CAL FIRE had already done as an internal assessment, our team combed through what's in the safety element now and what should be in the safety element to meet those state requirements. So Aaron, during the next portion of this, he'll go into the type of the new policies that we're suggesting. And all of these policies are really based on what we learned from stakeholders as well as what our best practices for
18:03 Planning in the wildland urban interface. Another just point on this is that we also recognized it's not just adding new policies but how to resolve these policies is important with other existing policies in the general plan. So we'll talk a little bit about that as well.
18:19 Our third recommendation is to update and align site and structure requirements and guidelines. And really this gets at two different issues is some of the existing gaps in the permitting process where planning may be looking at
18:35 One issue, fire department is looking at another issue and we really want to connect the dots in the process, in the review process so that it's more aligned. We'll also get into the specifics of what this looks like but essentially what this recommendation does, it provides a lot more specific guidance on what the planning department can use in their review of applications that come through the door for instance for landscaping requirements. So right now there's a lot of gaps and we wanted to
19:05 How can we better, how can the town be more proactive instead of waiting on the back end and letting people plant the wrong things beforehand and later telling them, hey, you might have to make a change because it doesn't adhere to the code or to our defensible space requirements. And then finally, our fourth recommendation is to develop a local CWPP, a local community wildfire protection plan to identify and coordinate
19:34 Mitigation activities. So all of these plans work together. We did get a chance to look at the draft multi-jurisdictional hazard mitigation plan that's recently, I think, still under review and final approval with the county. And what we've encountered across the country is often the opportunity for the communities to look at developing even a more localized CWPP.
20:03 So CWPPs can be conducted at multiple scales, county, subdivision, town. It really depends on what the needs are. And in this case, we saw the need for...
20:16 Looking at how the town can implement these new policies that will go into the safety element and do that through a more localized community wildfire protection plan that could be an addendum to the county's plan. So the two will work together, but what we recognized is there's going to be a need for more refined and detailed planning that will come out of this process, and the CWPP is the logical place to do that.
20:42 Again, we'll get into all of these in more specifics, but that's just a quick rundown of the recommendations at this stage. And what our next steps are in this process will be feedback, so today's feedback, as well as the opportunity for any written comment. So after this meeting, if any of the stakeholders say, you know, I thought about this afterwards, I wanted to invite or
21:06 We all wanted to invite the opportunity to provide us with written comment. And we can do that in coordination with Kim or I'll provide you with my email as well. So we just welcome that opportunity by September 21st. And after that, our team will integrate all of the feedback we get today as well as any written feedback into a final set of recommendations that we'll deliver by October 31st.
21:28 And then that takes us really through this presentation and into the workshop portion. So Kim, I'll turn it back to you on that transition. Does the CEPA team want to go ahead and sit on this side? So Molly, for this portion, did we want to go through those recommendations and then invite public comment?
22:28 Did you have any other business that you wanted to take care of now, or did you want to just jump into that afterwards? We'll do it afterwards. The stage is yours, guys. Okay. Well, then we'll keep going. And I think we need to talk into the microphones, right? Yeah. Okay. So I just wanted to make sure that probably primarily for anyone in the audience that you had access to the public agenda that we put at the front.
22:57 So you kind of knew the flow of what we are going to present today. And what we're going to do is have recommendations one and four presented by Kelly. We won't be spending as much time on those recommendations. The two that we're going to focus the most on today are recommendations two and three.
23:17 So the site landscaping and the general plan safety element policies are the two primary ones and we'll explain why we're prioritizing a little bit more time on those. Then we will wrap up and turn it back over to Kim and Sandra for any other business that you might want to take care of at the CEPAW. Did everyone have a chance to sign in though? Because we can make sure we put that, we'll distribute or pass that sign in sheet around again. Okay.
23:48 So I'm going to turn it over to Kelly to lead the discussion on this next piece with recommendation one. Okay, as Molly mentioned, this is going to be a fairly short discussion just because what the process that's occurred with recommendation one, which is the adopt a new wildfire hazard assessment, and recommendation four, which is develop a more local community wildfire protection plan.
24:19 Both of those processes originally arose from the county level hazard mitigation plan and community wildfire protection plan. And in reviewing those and seeing what we were looking at for the town of Mammoth, we identified that the town of Mammoth could definitely benefit from a more
24:48 A finer scale hazard assessment, as well as a community wildfire protection plan that addressed actions that specifically arose from the general plan from a higher level. And so the other piece to the hazard assessment, the wildfire hazard assessment, is that the recently completed county community wildfire protection plan
25:17 adopted the wildfire hazard assessment plan from 2006. And as we can recognize, there's a lot that's probably changed in the forest, in the urban development, and in the general context of the community between 2006 and now, in 12 years. So we recommended that it would be beneficial to engage in an updated hazard assessment that would reflect those changes.
25:46 And so with that, the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District has moved forward with engaging with a contractor to achieve both of those recommendations. And so that's, they're moving forward and that's where we just wanted to bring that up, that they are recognized that we did recommend them and they are moving forward already with the local stakeholders already moving forward with them.
26:16 So it's a, is this on I think? Okay. It's a bit unusual in a good way that normally our recommendations are delivered and then months later we hope that the community acts on them. But in this case it's, you know, the timing was really well aligned and just want to give credit to the chief for taking action so quickly on a need and an opportunity that came out.
26:42 As part of conversations in this process, and I think conversations that had occurred prior to even CEPA coming on board to help the town. So. So recommendations one and four were actually moving forward to summarize. Correct. Well done, Chief. Good job. I have a quick question. I think it's a great idea to do a new assessment. I'm sorry.
27:12 Robert, if you want to just come up to the podium and just state your name because this is being broadcast at home on Brannicus. Okay. Thank you. And anybody else in the future, please just come on up. My name is Robert Creasy. I'm a board member for the Water District and I'm also an architect in town. Just wanted to ask the question, during this assessment, is there any consideration for the impact on homeowners insurance policies because that could be a significant expense to the community?
27:41 As we go forward, if certain assessment levels cause increases in insurance. Just that that be considered in the process and those impacts reflected in the final report. Thanks. So the hazard assessment that's currently being undertaken, the risk assessment, uses a fairly standardized approach.
28:13 That accounts for, for instance, the topography, the weather, the fuel conditions, and the position of the values within the community, so the physical values. And you bring up a good point that that's probably...
28:31 Probably a topic that could be addressed in the CWPP as that moves forward, which will involve some involvement from the stakeholders, addressing some of those other risk elements that feed into that beyond the actual kind of physical elements. Thank you. I'll just add to that because this is a conversation that has come up frequently and one thing we've often recognized and I invite the chief to just echo this quickly or add on to this, but insurance
29:05 Companies use their own assessments to inform the level of exposure and risk that they're willing to take within a community. So we would make that assumption in this case as well, that they already know what kind of risk that they're assuming based on their methodologies and internal information. Chief Freevault, Mammoth Fire. That said, almost a year ago now,
29:39 came to the realization that actually our best practices with defensible space in California, it's 30 years. I found out through doing a little research that the variables used in one of the primary insurance carriers underwriting recommendations, that software didn't recognize those best practices as part of the evaluation. And so through a former association, Western...
30:07 Fire Chiefs Association out of the International Association of Fire Chiefs that I'd sat on some years ago. We had tackled this on the structural fire protection side as well, that the ratings of local communities' fire departments were based on things that were archaic. I was pulling things out of the museum case to put on the engine to get credit. And so going back to some of those previous relationships this past winter in, I think it was January,
30:35 The Vice President from Insurance Services Organization flew out here to meet with myself and the Chief Executive Officer from the Western Fire Association. We're presently underway with a very small and fairly confidential group on really working at the alignment of risk factors and mitigations that go into evaluation of risk from the insurance side. So there's not a direct relationship to the CWPP.
31:04 You know, translating in recognition of the homeowners. But we are actively engaged at this level in this community with, I think, the right people at the right levels. And they understand, you know, there's legislation that was offered last session. The California Director of Insurance, that's probably not his proper name, but they put out a scathing report in January of this past year.
31:32 on the cancellations, the non-renewables, and so, you know, it's that basis that's the nexus for the work we're doing with CWPP. That's really the best answer I can give you. Mr. Eastman, I might ask, unless your question revolves around Recommendation 1 or 4, that maybe we can go through the summary of the other two recommendations and then open it up for public comment, or does your question... Mine will be quick, and I think it's relevant considering the discussion we've just had. Please.
32:03 John Eastman. I thought Mr. Creasy's question was hit the nail right on the head because as homeowners, as all of us know in this room, in a mountain area, we have trouble getting insurance for our homes anyway. And if we come out with any wording that says, you know, the community of Mammoth Lakes or sections of the community of Mammoth Lakes are particularly high fire risks, we risk
32:32 Putting in jeopardy for fire insurance for homes for people in the community. I appreciate what you said. I also have experience not with fire but with flood zones in Mammoth Lakes. In Old Mammoth, a big portion of that area is in a flood zone. And if you're in that flood zone, then you may or may not get insurance. And I speak specifically of Snow Creek 4.
33:02 Which the flood zone, probably from Tom Dempsey when he was here and developed the property, the flood zone just coincidentally goes around the entire project of Snow Creek 4. So the project is outside the flood zone, but everybody around it is in it. So I'm just saying this because I think we need to be particularly careful with any wording that we have that could be looked at by an insurance company.
33:30 to deny insurance for homeowners in the community. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Just a quick response on that because this issue comes up a lot. We know it's sensitive. One thing to keep in mind, and Kelly might want to chime in here too, is that producing a comprehensive hazard assessment allows you to actually address the hazard and proactively take steps.
33:59 to reduce the hazard. And so that's our goal here is to give you the tools, recommend the tools that will enable you to make those changes for the better. And without that information, it's hard to know that you're making any meaningful progress over time. I think the addition to that too is when we specifically talk about the insurance industry is typically the insurance industry applies a broad brush.
34:28 And those, what we found is when that broad brush approach is applied, the
34:55 Those mitigation efforts aren't reflected in that broad brush approach. And therefore, a localized hazard assessment or risk assessment, you can actually affect change in that assessment to actually reduce the hazard or risk well within your realm of control. And so we're seeing that certainly where in some of those broad brush approaches on the insurance side of things where communities
35:23 Have not been able to change that outcome with the best practices that are based on science that have been and are being proven through case studies and incidents, wildfire incidents that are being proven as effective. So that's what we're trying to align all of that at the right scale so that hazard can actually be addressed.
35:52 By the community and by the residents of the community and therefore reduced. I'll try to quickly add a little bit of depth to that. Mr. Aceman, your question specifically was one that I addressed simultaneously to Cal Fire, Representative Captain Martinez here today, and to the CEPAW team who's familiar with the vendor and the software products that we've acquired.
36:24 The hazards, the fuels, the winds, the topography, those are the same. They don't change. What we believe this CEPA vendor and methodology will allow is greater recognition for the mitigations and the policies that we plan to employ through here and actually have those show that there is therefore less hazard in the ones that we can change. I don't know if Captain Martinez has any additional comment on that, but it was a specific question I asked him.
36:53 Can we use these maps instead of a kind of a broader level statewide CAL FIRE generated map, which is a great product? We just believe that this may provide more accuracy and granularity on the mitigations we're taking. And that's the old map. All right, I guess we'll move forward. So I'm going to...
37:29 My name is Aaron again. I'm going to cover the recommendation two within our recommendations document. And as both Kim and Molly had indicated, part of the audit process was really to understand the community and understand the framework that the community and staff at the town level are operating under from a planning and engineering and design standpoint.
37:55 And through the audit process what we recognized was there's definitely some opportunity to expand and really integrate fire risk reduction into the town's planning documents and planning framework. And so as we recognize that it really came down to
38:19 And so what we identified were the need for
38:49 Two potentially new goals that we thought were lofty and hopefully kind of set the tone, the big picture tone for how to address wildfire at the community level. And then 11 particular policy recommendations. So we'll walk through those pretty quickly. So on the screen you see the two proposed goals. They're also in the document. And one of them really focuses on this first one, S7, that wildfire does not care about jurisdictional boundary.
39:19 addressing wildfire needs of a community is a much bigger effort than just the town trying to address it on their own. So we recognize that it's really about collaboration and coordination with the U.S. Forest Service, Cal Fire, the town, and the Fire Protection District, and that all four working together, you'll have a much better opportunity.
39:45 to address wildfire effectively, efficiently, and probably do a much better, have a much better proactive approach to address these things before they turn into actual issues or unfortunately disasters. So this is one of the first recommended goals. The second was really about how do you promote resilience and integrate many of the plans that we identified.
40:13 Local Hazard Mitigation Plan, your community and wildfire protection plan into the general plan. What Cal OES, California Office of Emergency Services, what Cal Fire, what the Office of Planning and Research, all these three state entities, they're really focused right now on getting all of your different plans working together, and they view the safety element as one of the best locations to do that.
40:41 We do too. So this to us seemed like a no-brainer of really making it very overt that this is a goal. We want to make sure that all of these plans are working together in concert so that instead of trying to implement three plans, it's really about implementation of just one. So those are the two lofty goals. Any questions or thoughts from commissioners on that before we move on to the actual policies?
41:09 Okay. And we hope they are, because that's really our goal as well. All right. So we've identified 11 policies to try to keep it simple. I've broken it down to four per slide. First one's about adopting a wildfire risk assessment to identify areas of the town that are at risk to wildfire. So we've talked about that. That's one of our key recommendations. You know, what this really does, though,
41:36 And why I have it in there is required as when you look at the government code and when you look at what CAL FIRE is going to look for in your safety element when they review it, they're going to look for something like this. CAL FIRE is already putting out mapping. They've had it out for a number of years that identifies your very high fire hazard severity zones. And that's really the trigger. If you have one of those zones in your community, then they have the...
42:02 jurisdiction and oversight to review the safety element and ensure that it gets adopted by the Board of Forestry. What we also know is that the mapping and the modeling that was done is not up to par with kind of current standard of practice. CAL FIRE knows this. CAL FIRE is in the process of updating the maps. But you also have the ability, as Chief Rivald had said, to update your own and do your own assessment.
42:28 And so the next recommendation is looking at
42:56 Not only current, but future land use. And what this really focuses on, and again, this is something that Cal Fire looks at, is are you allowing new development in areas where you, it's known that there are high hazards, or hazards of concern. Cal Fire, of course, is concerned about wildfire. Most communities, when they're doing this process,
43:22 are also looking at a number of other hazards like flooding, earthquakes, and there are federal and state requirements that you have to address all of those things and they're spelled out in the government code. This is really taking it a step further. If you know that future land use is occurring within a hazard zone, a wildfire hazard zone, ensuring that you have
43:44 The appropriate measures in place to regulate that new development effectively. Are they gonna comply with the updated elements of the building code or updated elements of the International Fire Code? So this is really about having the ability to ensure new development coming in is not gonna develop in a way that 10 years and 20 years from now
44:11 We have significant issues because they're still using wood shingle roofs or they're still using open eaves or other elements we know based on studies and based on the science are ways that structures catch fire and fire hazard zones. Recommendation number three, and this again is a required element based on CAL FIRE's criteria, it's really about linking your land use planning activities
44:40 to your hazard plans. And again, this is part of that looking at future uses but also looking at current uses and looking at are these different planning focused exercises informing each other and making sure that your future decisions are decisions that are making the community better and safer and less risky. And then the final one on this slide.
45:08 Identify neighborhoods with limited access that may require secondary routes for first responders and the public during a fire event. So this again is that access and evacuation concern that Molly had identified in her presentation. It's also something that CAL FIRE is expecting communities to look at. Now they're not saying you need to eliminate all of your cul-de-sacs, but they want to know what is going to be done.
45:35 to address some of these concerns. And they recognize, having the luxury of working with Cal Fire staff through these reviews in the past, that you can't fix the problem in just a day.
45:49 And sometimes it takes a significant amount of time to really create the resilience you need in your community from a circulation standpoint. And they recognize that. And so oftentimes what this really turns into is starting to identify where maybe some of the potential deficiencies and then what are some of the potential solutions, you know, whether it be a temporary solution until a permanent one is created or a new development standard to ensure that you're not propagating this issue.
46:18 Further on into the future. Any questions on any of those? Hopefully, again, pretty straightforward. And Aaron, one thing I just add, too, which I think might be helpful for the benefit of the commissioners is that these policies which you're reviewing are
46:37 Very specific to needs that arose during discussions that we talked about with stakeholders. So on the one hand, they respond to what the requirements are. We also try to integrate some specificity so that these aren't just generic.
46:53 So hopefully that comes out too.
47:23 in this process. Yeah, that's a great point, Molly. Thank you. All right. So recommendations 5, 6, 7, and 8. Again, these are actually mostly optional from the standpoint that when you look at what CAL FHIRES is going to be looking to when they review the element, these are not necessarily elements that they are constrained to review.
47:53 For the government code, but there are definitely elements that they'll be glad to see. So this recommendation five, consider wildfire as part of trails and open space planning activities. You know, this really came out of discussions with town staff that, you know, there is a significant push to have recreation year round and that trails and open space
48:21 uses within the town are very, very important. And so what we recognized here was, you know, this is also an opportunity. If there's a look to expand the trail network or to improve the trail network, that this can also be an opportunity to improve fire resilience as part of that effort. And what our hope is, is this is not adding something else onto someone's plate as much as just
48:48 Looking at what you're doing already and seeing can you add a minor element that actually has a significant benefit to the community in whole. The recommendation number six, identifying fuel treatments that will reduce wildfire threat to the town. This is, oh, we did identify as optional. This is definitely something that CAL FIRE would be concerned about. They definitely focus on fuel breaks.
49:15 But this is really about, again, like we had indicated, it's not just the town that's focused on fuels treatment. It's not just the town that's going to be responsible. You know, fuels treatment is really a consortium between the Forest Service, between Cal Fire, between Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, as well as the town itself. And so, you know, this is really where that CWPP comes into
49:40 to play and to practice in ensuring that you can do this effectively, efficiently and hopefully have this economy of scale when you're working in a larger group. Chief, did you have something you wanted to add? Just real quick, two quick examples of getting credit for things that are already out there. One of the things already shipped off to the vendor were essentially some shape files for where the ski runs are on the mountain.
50:08 Those wouldn't show up necessarily in other products, but they drop in and now show these are areas with no vegetation. They count towards potential areas of control. And we're going to explore that with the trails process as well. Joel Rathje sees a trail and I see an anchor point. And so those are some efforts that we're already doing. Those are the kinds of things that we want to get reflected in the overall mitigations that we're working on. Those are things that are already done. We're just trying to figure out how to get
50:38 Excellent. Thank you so much. Recommendation number seven, policy about updating your landscaping requirements and review procedures to streamline your approach with fire review. And so this is, again, one of those things. It's partly required and partly optional. And the optional piece is really about how town departments are working together effectively to review development submittals that are coming in.
51:08 One of the things we also recognize, too, is that
51:38 There's a body of knowledge when it comes to landscaping and that body of knowledge kind of grows organically in a lot of communities and sometimes we have to infuse an education about specific species or specific treatments or specific techniques to ensure that that body of knowledge actually can
52:02 Keep up with the changing understanding of ecological understanding as well as just landscaping understanding within the development realm. So this is really getting at the heart of that and ensuring that you are able to reinstate kind of where is what's safe and what's not and how do we ensure that
52:24 Moving forward, we're moving in the right direction of keeping our communities safer with how we plant and how we treat landscaping. And then recommendation eight, insurance construction methods for new and existing development reduces wildfire risk. And so this is really getting at, again, a lot of the structural hardening that existing structures can and should do to reduce their risk as well as the
52:52 Thank you so much.
53:22 But we want to make sure that you have the tools from a development standpoint to reduce some of the inherent risk associated with development in general. Any questions on those particular requirements or policies? I'm sorry, recommendations. Okay. All right. So the last three here, nine, 10, and 11. Nine is required. And again, this is something that
53:49 You know, Cal Fire is going to look to when they review the safety element. It's really about reviewing and mitigate critical infrastructure for wildfire vulnerabilities. They want to make sure that infrastructure that town operations and functions rely on as well as residents and businesses are not unduly susceptible to vulnerability. You know, putting a water pump station and not...
54:15 Ensuring that it's hardened and that it has some backup generation is going to be critical to ensure that you have adequate water supplies so that the chief can have the water he needs to fight any fires he might be dealing with. So this is really, again, about making sure
54:35 You're looking at your assets, looking at what drives the community and making sure that moving forward you're hardening it and relocating it if necessary so that it's in a place that's safer or less vulnerable. We know we're not going to eliminate the hazard. What we're trying to do is eliminate the ability for the hazard to unduly affect town operation and town function. Recommendation 10.
55:06 Collaborate with local, state, federal fire protection and land management agencies to advance wildfire mitigation and safety. And again, this is all about, you know, it takes a village, as they say. And so this is really focusing on participation of fire safe council meetings and activities, making sure that that gets ahead of steam and can actually really push forward on a lot of the fire mitigation that can occur within the community. You know, working
55:35 And continue to work closely with the Fire Protection District, you know, basically as a department of the town, in essence, you know, obviously your partners in the Forest Service and Cal Fire and really treating it as, you know, how do we ensure that we are living cohesively and symbiotically in a healthy forest environment.
56:01 You know, because we know that there are some elements of the forest environment that are unhealthy and need our assistance. And then the last one, this is really kind of looking at some of the secondary and tertiary effects of wildfire. And it's about, you know, the water and air quality impacts associated with wildfire hazard risk and mitigation. And that, you know, after a large event, depending on where it occurs,
56:31 Is there potential to impact town's water supply? We know after a large fire you have the extreme possibility of mudslides, landslides, and if that degrades water quality and the water bodies that the town relies on, then what does that ripple affect? How does that impact the town? And so if you are focused on how different
56:59 Parts of the ecology of the town, earth, wind, fire, are working together and addressing them efficiently and effectively. The hope is that you have this greater beneficial impact to ensuring the town's water supply is protected in the future and that wildfire hazards are reduced and air quality issues hopefully are minimized as much as you can control.
57:30 That's those last three recommendations. This basically is the rest of my discussion. This is really now an open to questions, answers, and discussion. And we've got about 10 minutes or so. I'd like to go back to number 10. Okay. Everything that I've heard today has been about hardening our resistance to wildfire, planning ahead so that it doesn't come into town.
58:00 Trying to make sure that we don't have, say, a house fire get out into the woods. But in addition to being a planning commission, we're also an economic development commission. And we are a tourist town. And if all this stuff works absolutely perfect, and we don't get a speck of ash or fire inside our town limits, if everything around it is an ashtray, we're supreme. And what I would like to hear is how can we
58:29 We can't dictate, but how can we encourage that some of the local regional fire policies are geared more towards keeping fires down near urban areas, whereas there's not a universal forest-wide policy of lightning, let it burn. If it's lightning and it burns here and it comes over that hill, it's a lot different than if it goes over the backside of Colville.
58:59 Kelly, do you want to? Yeah. So that, I mean, that's a really good comment and question. And I'll first start by saying that I'll start with the answer. The answer is actually in your community wildfire protection plan. That is the vehicle for addressing your neighboring land managers. If you meet the requirements of the community wildfire protection plan,
59:26 Particularly when you're adjacent to federal lands, that compels the federal agencies to become part of the solution in that respect. Now we'll back up and talk about where you guys are situated. You're situated in a fire-dependent ecosystem. There is no way you're going to eliminate fire from the surrounding area. This is how this ecosystem evolved with fire.
59:55 That said, what's happened over time with this ecosystem is as humans, we stopped or we interrupted the natural process of fire, which in this ecosystem was typically low intensity fire that would burn regularly and typically wouldn't result in devastating loss of landscape, resulting landslides, things like that.
1:00:25 So the objectives for the overall landscape and land base would be to try and get back to that point. Unfortunately, we've been moving away from that point for just over 100 years right now. And the policies on the forest management policies have swung from
1:00:54 Total exclusion of fire, which we realized after almost 100 years of trying to do that, that that's not possible, to now allowing fire back into the ecosystem, recognizing how important it is. It's a bumpy road to try and switch directions like that. And so again, going back to that community wildfire protection plan, that's...
1:01:21 That's why it's important to be able to have that voice as a town. When your plan meets all the Healthy Forest Restoration Act requirements, then as I said, it compels the federal land management agencies to become part of the solution. And so that is your vehicle for that. Unfortunately, it is not going to happen overnight. It's going to take some time.
1:01:50 Totally agreed, and that's one of those risk factors that we spoke on a little bit earlier. You have a very large investment in your tourism and your aesthetic values of the surrounding area. And, you know, part of that, though, is being a village in the tree. Part of that is understanding that being a village in the trees, in these particular trees here, that wildfire.
1:02:18 does play a role in making sure these trees are the way they are. So that somehow has to be brought into it in a way that it doesn't impact you. So definitely a larger discussion through the Community Wildfire Protection Plan process. Jen, any questions? Go ahead. No, I was going to open up to the... Oh, okay. Well, I wanted to ask Frank, because for me, this is pretty straightforward and a lot of common sense in here. Sorry.
1:02:48 So I wanted to ask you, Frank, do these policies make sense to you? Is there anything that you would want to add to them? Or do some of these not work for what our town needs? We've been, the fire district has been one of the stakeholders at the table early on. There were, early on in the discussion, there were a few things that we, you know, joust over.
1:03:20 And all appropriately. Each community is different. The expertise of the CEPA team could bring some alternatives. Whenever we came into those, usually we'd settle on something you'd already seen. I'm not sure we've actually come up with anything that was totally unique to Mammoth. We might have had a couple close calls. So overall, yes, these all appear to be in alignment. The real question is, what is our local level of discipline to go for the long game here? Because it will take
1:03:48 Time to do this. I see two distinct areas that we've got to show commitment to. One is the local community. To your point, how do we not just keep it from burning down, but how do we make sure that the economic engine works or we have failures that way too? We also have to look outside of our area, and a lot of times it's places we have no direct authority whatsoever. But I'll give you one example. We have our...
1:04:16 Actually, our Fire Safe Council is represented here as is the Forest Service. Forest Service had a fuels reduction plan up in the Lakes Basin. They had it on the books. They'd done all the work. They were just waiting for the funding. Couldn't come up with the funding. We then, through the Fire Safe Council, which is made up of local stakeholders, put in a grant to essentially fund their project. And so that was accomplished, and we're going to go after that.
1:04:48 That level of collaboration and commitment to look at the long game and then also do some local quick things. Hardening of the structures I think is going to continue to emerge as one of the fastest, most efficient ways to make us resilient over the short period. And then this idea, I'll be the first one to say, I'm sure I'll take some beatings on this, but at the end of this fire season, by the time you add up past fires at the head of the
1:05:16 San Joaquin drainage. We now have an outstanding buffer for the next probably 30 years, 40 years. It was terrible this summer. I hated it as well. You know, you can't see the trees. I'm finally enjoying the view. That said, as Kelly mentioned, there is no future here that doesn't involve fire at some level. We keep suppressing it locally to no fire. Eventually it becomes irreconcilable when it does start. There's no
1:05:46 No level of effort we could put at it that would change it. So I think this represents both some short-term and some long-term goals. But the real question is going to be after CEPA leaves, after everybody's forgotten about it, do we have the discipline as a community to stick with the long game? If we don't, I fear for our future. Thank you. I have one other question for you. I saw somewhere on here that we were talking,
1:06:16 It alluded to the Valentine Reserve as being a possible issue and I know that when we had a red flag warning there was a concern that a fire might come down through that area. They're very protective of their reserve and have they been a stakeholder in fire management in our town? Yes, with the arrival of the new director who herself has, I understand she's present, maybe I'll let her
1:06:51 answer that. My experience has been the answer is yes. Please. I didn't mind coming to the podium. Thank you. Hi there. Carol Blanchett, Director of the Reserve. We've been in discussion with Captain Freevault quite a bit about fire. We're really concerned about fire. I sit on the Fire Safe Council as well. We would be more than happy to work with
1:07:21 Anyone here who would like to work with us to come up with a project, a fuels reduction project that we could get funded and move forward with. So it's on our agenda. We had a Bren Masters group, a group of Masters students from the Bren School at UCSB.
1:07:40 Just completed their master's thesis project, basically looking at Valentine Reserve and Sedgwick Reserve, one of the other UC NRS reserves, and looking at fire management. So we now have their plan. Again, nothing surprising. We do need to do some work in there, and we're actively trying to fund that. So I, again, think this is a great process.
1:08:03 Really happy to see particularly the work going into the number one, the new mapping. I think that's going to be really useful. I would just also add that I think based on what the Bren students have looked at too, there are a number of variables that go into those maps. I would also encourage everyone to think about the time scale.
1:08:27 Over which those variables change and create something that's really dynamic and layered. You know, just a static map with colors is not that useful, right? These things change constantly. So having the ability to see the different variables that go into that can also, I think, incentivize members of the community to change and change their color from a red to a yellow or a better color.
1:08:56 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for being part of the solution. Any other questions, Jen? No, thank you. Would anybody else in the audience like to come up with a question or a comment concerning recommendation number two? Please. Hi again, I'm Robert Creasy, board member at the Water District. And to Mr. Eckert's question.
1:09:25 And also addressing number 10 and 11, the idea of collaboration and protecting the community around us or the forest environment around us. The Lakes Basin is kind of our primary recreation area. And as Chief Freeval was saying, we have the FireSafe Council got some grant money from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. It turned out it wasn't quite enough to satisfy the Forest Service's needs.
1:09:49 And so the Water District, under the idea of number 11 of protecting our water quality resources, has just recently approved applying for another grant with the Sierra Nevada Conservancy to augment that grant monies that hopefully can satisfy the needs of the Forest Service to address that hazardous fuel reduction program. In a perfect scenario, does that project happen this fall?
1:10:19 The fuel reduction up in the lakes basin? If I could, I'd ask Eric Vane to speak to that. He's present. Thank you, Robert. Yes, I'm Eric Vane. I'm the vegetation planning manager for the north zone of the Inyo National Forest, which includes the Mammoth Lakes area. We were actually on a site visit today with our contractors who are...
1:10:46 bidding for the contract to do fuels reduction on the lakes basin today. We're looking at a timeline of implementation beginning September of 2019 and extending through 2020. And we're restricting the times where they can operate to after Labor Day due to the high recreation use and some of our limited operating periods for wildlife and other concerns that occur in the spring.
1:11:13 I do want to add, in addition, we're currently in the planning phases right now and doing surveys for a fuels reduction project in Red's Meadow as well, and we're collaborating with the Devil's Post Pile in order to do some fuels reduction work down there and create defensible space along the road system and around the...
1:11:35 The Reds Resort and the campground. So this is definitely something that's on the Inyo National Forest radar and we are actively moving forward to do some of these fuels reduction projects in the immediate vicinity of Mammoth Lakes as well to try to preserve that economic engine for the local area and also obviously to protect life and property.
1:12:01 Yeah, we're really excited about the collaboration that we've had ongoing, and we're very happy to have that interest in the community. Thank you. Would the Reds Meadow Project also be in September of 2019, fall of 2020? No, the rough timeline for that is we're right in the middle of doing surveys with our specialists, and then we'll write up the...
1:12:24 Environmental Analysis, the winter, we hope to have a decision signed by our district ranger late winter, early spring of 2019 and then implementation would begin 2020 and we're still exploring avenues for funding that whether it's grant monies through CCI through the state of California or S&C or something else in addition. Thank you. Eric, has there been any look at having
1:12:53 Those areas open to public fuel, wood gathering, they're free. The perennial question. So if you're familiar with the Lakes Basin, do you know the borrow pit area or the horse trailer parking kind of up by Horseshoe Lake? We're planning on taking, doing forest health thinning treatments on 60 acres within the Lakes Basin and the merchantable
1:13:21 Material over 8 inches in diameter, between 8 and 24 inches in diameter, will be decked there for public fuel wood cutting in the, probably beginning in early 2020. Red's Meadow, it's right now, it's written in the proposed action, we would also open up areas of Red's Meadow for public fuel wood cutting. Thank you. Thank you. Please, Mr. Eastman. Thank you. One quick comment and two thoughts.
1:13:54 First of all, I do definitely support the use of fire retardant, non-fire materials on construction, whether it's single family homes or commercial. We've seen more and more in the community where people are building homes and they're using metal, not only for metal roofs, but also metal as a part of their siding.
1:14:22 Rocks on the lower level of homes and cement siding so I and there's some beautiful homes in the community that are using those types of materials I want to point out to what I think might be conflicts one of them is between the town's current code as it relates to tree removal as opposed to the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department
1:14:48 And I don't want to speak for the fire department chief, but the fire department would like people to clear back away from their home, their single family home. And I don't know the distance, but it's reasonable to think maybe, you know, as much as 20 feet away from the home. But I think that the town's current code doesn't allow for tree removal except for something that's close to the home.
1:15:15 Is that correct? We do allow for tree removal in conjunction with fuels reduction like that. So that is permitted. Okay. But I just, I'm seeing in the past, people wanted trees at their home to the point where they wanted a tree right up against the roof or right up against their deck. And I think as time has proven, that's not such a good idea.
1:15:45 Clear back away from the home substantially where there's not a tree next to their house. The other thing is in fuel reduction or thinning of trees on a property, which I think is a goal of all of ours, that the town current, I don't know if it's code or ordinance, one of the two, you can't fall a tree of a certain size
1:16:16 Bigger than a certain size. And I know in previous years the fire department had personnel that would go around to a property and identify trees that could be thinned. All I'm saying is there might be a conflict between the town and the fire district. If there is, I think we should try to clean that up because I would encourage tree thinning on properties within the town.
1:16:39 Well, you're ahead of the curve here because we're just about to talk about that in our next recommendation. Okay. So thank you for preempting us. Thank you. The final thing real quick is where we might, and I don't know, Mr. Creasy might know with the water district, water is very precious, of course, for a whole bunch of reasons in our community. So there's a decreased emphasis in the use of sod.
1:17:09 on landscaping, on properties, and yet sod might be one of the better tools that we could use in landscaping, probably sod and cement or even asphalt to create fire breaks around properties. So there might be a conflict in types of landscape that could be used. Thank you. Any other questions or comments concerning
1:17:40 Recommendation number two. Well, with your permission, then we'll transfer in or segue into recommendation three, and we'll be handing out of materials for that. Okay, so right now you guys are getting a summary document that's entitled the summary of recommendation three, and it focuses on the update and alignment of site and structure requirements and guidelines. And so,
1:18:28 Thank you.
1:18:57 So I wanted to start with just, you know, why this actually matters. And we heard a lot about through the policy, the general plan recommendations that we're really focusing on, as the chief aptly stated, we're focusing on hardening the community. And I say that in parentheses.
1:19:27 Quotes, because we're not trying to paint a picture of, you know, a hardened concrete urban environment. You know, it's a matter of trade-offs here and there on trying to still achieve that forest, that community in the forest feel. And so when we talk about that, we're really looking at really four aspects. We're looking at
1:19:56 We're looking at the structures and how they're designed and what they're made out of. And that's just one piece of it. The next piece is what's directly adjacent to those structures, meaning the built fuels, if you will.
1:20:23 The decks, the arbors, things like that. And how do they contribute to the susceptibility of the structure to wildfire? And built into that or closely related to that is the landscaping. And we heard about the trees and some of the vegetation around there. As we know that vegetation burns, we've all seen it around here.
1:20:51 And then the fourth piece is the topography and terrain that we're in. And, you know, unfortunately, we can't typically change the topography or terrain. I mean, we have in other places in the world with some significant engineering feats, but it's probably not something that you would want to do here or would even be economically or socially feasible.
1:21:19 That puts us back on the numbers 1, 2, and 3. And because we can't change the topography and terrain, we have to rely heavily on how the structures are built, what they're built out of, what immediately surrounds them as far as built materials and structures, and what kind of vegetation surrounds them.
1:21:43 When we talk about that, all of that, we call it, we refer, it's commonly referred to as the structure ignition zone or the home ignition zone. And it's really, it's been researched quite heavily. It's been researched to the point that we've got some pretty strong guidelines that have a lot of science backing them on how the structure should be built.
1:22:10 And what kind of fuel structure should be surrounding that structure? And so that brings us to just looking at, well, what do we need as standards as far as the structures are concerned? And what do we need as standards as far as the landscaping is concerned? And lucky for you, there's actually a California state building code that outlines the standards for the structure.
1:22:38 And that's currently in the town of Mammoth. That's currently enforced, as I said, through the building code. And the enforcement comes out with respect to the certificate of occupancy. So when someone builds a house, they're supposed to meet all these building code standards, and the building inspector says, yep, you've used the right materials and the right design.
1:23:06 That's done. But that still leaves that immediate surrounding area of landscaping that is still very important. As I said, you could go to a further extent on the building side to accommodate for the landscaping around the structure, but essentially you would probably end up living in concrete bunkers with no windows. And that's probably not a
1:23:35 An aesthetically pleasing or desirable condition in this area, basically on what we heard. So the vegetation does have to be addressed. And currently in the town of Mammoth, the landscaping is not being addressed on the front end during the building side of things with respect to wildfire. It is being addressed with respect to
1:24:05 Water use in some cases and different zoning requirements for requirements of landscaping planning. The way that the landscaping is being addressed as far as wildfire currently in the town of Mammoth is kind of on the backside with the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District folks going out and doing parcel level assessments for existing structures.
1:24:35 And informing the homeowners and requiring them to undertake mitigative actions as far as the vegetation around their structure. So this leads us to a bit of possibly backstepping where homeowners are moving into structures or building homes where it's either as it is when they buy it or they're
1:25:04 Or they're building homes and they want certain types of landscaping features that currently aren't being guided by any sort of standards with regards to wildfire at the building stage. And then sometime after that, the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District arrives with their concern of trying to reduce the wildfire risk.
1:25:33 Now those, now enforcing some very good standards, but after the fact in some cases. In many cases where homes were built years ago, then it's definitely necessary. So that essentially sums up where we sit with, there's a number of standards in place that are very good that the town has for water use.
1:26:01 for certain types of zoning for landscape standards on certain sizes of properties, none of which right now address wildfire mitigation. And where we've recommended to move forward with is first of all to develop a streamlined approach of addressing the landscaping. Where the
1:26:32 First of all, there's some standards in place that address wildfire mitigation on the front end side. So when someone applies for a plan review or a development permit. And as well, the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District is part of that process right at the beginning. So they're providing their guidance or the guidance that the town in the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District
1:27:01 aligns at the very beginning. And so when we look at the specifics of what kind of guidance that might be, as I said, the structure itself is currently being dealt with through the California Building Code. So we're looking at the building envelope out from the building envelope out. And so the first piece is
1:27:29 that we found very important that the researchers and some of the follow up post fire studies have found is that the first five feet around a building is very important. It's so important that there shouldn't be any combustible materials within that first five feet surrounding a building. And it's been proven
1:27:55 Several times in California in some areas where that immediate space around the building, if there's combustible materials there that provide a radiant or convective heat problem to the building, there's a fairly high chance that the building is going to be impacted by wildfire. The next piece is the relationship between buildings. The idea that if there's buildings within 50 feet of each other,
1:28:24 The 30-foot area.
1:28:51 We have to remember a forest does produce a significant amount of heat or can, but it's for a very short time period. When a building burns, it produces a significant amount of heat for a much longer time period, somewhere up to an hour compared to less than 60 seconds. So moving forward, the non-combustible area should be free of vegetation and any combustibles.
1:29:20 And then we start to bring into the current standards that the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District is enforcing on the backside, where there's a 10 foot minimum distance between individual tree crowns and horizontal distance between tree crowns and all conifer trees within 30 feet horizontal distance of a structure. Okay, there's that 30 feet. And the 30 feet distances, we've seen,
1:29:50 There's been significant research backed up by actual fires where if the 30 feet around a structure doesn't have crown fire or fire up in the tops of the trees, then the structure itself has a pretty high probability of survival. Moving along, again, the 10 foot horizontal distance between the habitable structures,
1:30:22 So, being able to retain
1:30:53 A lot of those big, beautiful trees is not necessarily a conflict with trying to achieve these goals. What we're looking at is those trees in between and getting some spacing between those trees themselves. And this sort of aligns with what I talked about earlier with trying to bring the forest back to where it used to be, where there was
1:31:23 Frequent surface fires, we don't want frequent surface fires in your house, but frequent surface fires and rarely crown fires because of the structure of those trees. So you're working, you have an advantage with the structure of the trees with this. So the other pieces to this include managing all those understory areas, the grasses and weeds within that 30 feet, and all the surface litter and organic materials within that 30 feet of a building. This includes
1:31:53 The landscape, the landscape materials that you plant. And we're actually, we've actually talked about this earlier, we're actually moving to a place where we're having, making that easy for planning, identifying the specific species that are more flammable and the species that are less flammable and engaging in an education program too.
1:32:18 And then moving forward to the
1:32:52 The landscape, the idea of the planning application, the plan application and review, the idea that the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District is part of that initial review, there's some set standards like the ones we just summarized in place, but if those set standards for some reason don't necessarily work,
1:33:20 For the specific situation, then there's the ability to appeal that and apply a performance-based approach to it. So in other words, have a professional look at it and design some sort of outcome that will meet the same standards. And so there's the prescriptive approach that everyone can just very cleanly follow. And if there's a problem where that runs into, there's a suggestion that
1:33:50 There would be a performance-based approach alternative that would meet the same outcome. So I hope that with our discussions that talks about addressing the regulatory conflicts. We did hear a little bit about the conflicts with the tree preservation and removing trees. We understand that the town actually works quite heavily with the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District in identifying those
1:34:19 Those trees that are necessary for removal for fire risk reduction. But just the idea of in the standards, just placing a simple line in there where you identify where the wildfire risk reduction on private lands is specifically identified and through the direction of an authority like the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District or the town manager or a designate.
1:34:48 would help clarify things. And finally, updating that, in just summarizing the update to the plan submittal and review process, looking at making sure it applies to new development, new building construction, and external structure, external modifications that require building permits. So anything that triggers a building permit or a plan review, really.
1:35:19 And implemented by adding the requirements of wilder mitigation plan and prescriptive standards. And then really, again, the biggest gap we saw was making sure that there was that, that the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District was involved right from the beginning. So with that and that summary of that, I open it up to questions for... Jen, do you have any questions about recommendation number three?
1:35:50 I don't necessarily have a question but I would like to stress that this recommendation clearly emphasizes that the fire department needs to be included in our codes and I would strongly encourage the town staff to work to ensure that our codes are amended to include wildfire mitigation plans as well. Sorry, I know you don't have enough staff but I think it's important. Great.
1:36:22 Anybody in the public would like to come up with a question or comment, concern, suggestion? Good afternoon. My name is Dave Harvey. I also do sit on the fire safe council. There's some issues here. Maybe, Sandra, you could help me a little bit. How many vacant single-family lots?
1:37:01 Are still existing approximately, I don't know, hold your feet to the fire there. I don't think I know. Rough estimate. A couple hundred, I would say. Yeah, I think we're in that number somewhere. And how many single family products have been built? Gosh. Existing homes in Mammoth. I don't know. I think we probably have 6,000. I was going to say seven.
1:37:35 But I think we're in the ballpark. Do you see where I'm going with this? And we may see an acceptance of going in this direction and spending monies that we have to spend on good, valid products, be it in the Lakes Basin or Red Tomatoes or Valentine Reserve or any of these other.
1:38:08 Places we're all familiar with. But when we have an area such as Old Mammoth and we have houses that are 10 feet apart, not necessarily 50 feet apart, we have been a village in the trees. And I can just, without thinking, next to my house I've got
1:38:36 Three or four others that are just right there, and they are tender boxes. They have trees growing, rubbing their eaves. It's just, it's the danger that you talk about. It's very clear and present in the old mammoth area.
1:39:06 I hope as we go forward and as your reports are coming to those that will be making decisions, there may be or should be room in there for financial assistance to houses that are already existing and if
1:39:35 If we can address this in that manner, I think we'll get a lot of acceptance. A lot of times homeowners are just looking for a little something to help the pain. When you have a tree on your property and it's obvious that the tree is dead and if it falls, it's going to hit your neighbor.
1:40:06 It's been my experience. You will have a neighbor knocking on your door asking you if you have insurance for trees falling for widow makers. So I understand the regulation that we need and the prescriptive approach possibly for new construction of single-family homes. Absolutely, I understand that.
1:40:37 I think the buyer of that home in today's environment is going to be a little more well-heeled to be able to absorb those costs into his building, just like commercial products are going to have to do the same thing. But there's a whole group of people, approximately 7,000 out there, that are living in homes that were purchased or built.
1:41:05 As far back as, I'll go back as far as you want, but let's say from the 60s on up. And that's a group of people that it's going to be difficult to just throw regulation at them, but creating a solution and a way to help fund those things that you want done.
1:41:35 I think would be very prudent. Thank you. Thank you. Could I respond to that quickly? That's an excellent point that came up many times in our conversations about existing development. And one of the things we didn't have a lot of time to get into today was some of the detail that Aaron presented on the policies and the actions that we proposed to come.
1:42:00 to implement the policies, one of them being how to support existing development and whether that's through retrofits to the structure itself on the property or to other measures regarding landscaping. So it's not resolved, but it was a recognition that I'm looking at the chief because he's one of the main people that brought this up.
1:42:23 Utilizing the Community Wildfire Protection Plan in the future to really dig into how you can identify opportunities to fund exactly what you brought up. So we can't solve that necessarily through CEPAW, but we tried to figure out ways to support it and lay some groundwork for that and recognizing there's only so much mitigation that can occur through new development.
1:42:51 And that's exactly why the regulations, the proposed or recommended regulatory changes are focused on new development. Recognizing that the Mammoth Lake Fire Protection District already has a program in place for vegetation management and compliance on existing development. And then also recognizing the financial hardship and
1:43:18 Almost impossibility of asking, going to someone in an existing home and saying, now you have to update your home to these new standards. Yeah. So those are definitely recognized as part of the implementation and those are items that, as Molly mentioned, would probably be further explored within the community wildfire protection planning process. Yeah.
1:43:48 Anybody else? I thought I saw. My question relates to Dave's and the previous presentation, number two, talked about the grants and funding and taxes supporting free removal in the forest, basically. And it sounds like you're thinking about funding it like on private property if a home needs trees removed.
1:44:22 I manage condos and some of the trees have cost $3,000 to remove because they're big ones but then big ones don't burn as well or as much and stuff so some of that I'm I guess I'm hoping to hear that okay there's private land that needs help you've addressed really well the public lands that are getting grants and everything
1:44:43 I agree with Dave. I mean, I have hardy plank on my siding and metal roof and that kind of stuff. I'm not worried about my house, but then there's some massive trees and stuff. It's like, oh boy, that's a chunk. And so that's my question. And then my other follow-up question is, is there seem to be three really big matches in town. You've addressed Valentine, the town 25-acre parcel. I could not believe how many dead trees are on the affordable housing parcel right now.
1:45:12 That's a huge match. And then the hillside that I see every day going home below the bluffs. There's over 50% dead matchsticks up there. That's a huge match. So urgency or any timing to remove some of the fuels and make fuel reduction in some of those areas like the bluffs and in the town and that type of thing and funding seems to be part of my question. Thank you.
1:45:42 Sure, thank you. I think it really underscores the point that we made at the beginning of why it is necessary for the town to develop a local community wildfire protection plan because those exact questions would be addressed and resolved through that plan. So we are big advocates of having that level of detail, not in a general...
1:46:06 Plan policy, but in the Community Wildfire Protection Plan, which would match with the comprehensive wildfire hazard assessment. So the two are really coupled together, which are both moving forward. So the good news is those exact questions can be answered over the coming months as this new contractor is on board to develop that plan. Does that align, Chief, with the timing of what you've...
1:46:35 talked about with the contractor for the development of the CWPP. Actually, the timeline for the CWPP is to be completed no longer than March 15th. A linkage, and back to your question earlier, are these efforts aligned? So an example is that for us to competitively bid or apply as a grant applicant for fuels management support, specifically the
1:47:04 Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District just about two years ago closed out a multi-year grant process that had gone for about five years that did a 75-25% grant match to private property homeowners doing exactly what you're asking about. It was for a certain geographic area in the district and it was for a certain period of time. That grant closed out and we're now reapplying for similar grants that would essentially be throughout the fire district.
1:47:32 But to be competitive, you have to have a very well-written and recent CWPP. The fact that we can also align that CWPP with local hazard mitigation planning and the town's policies makes your application very strong because it shows that your solution is integrated. So we're in the process of applying for some of those, both through our Fire Safe Council and also through the district itself.
1:48:01 As is the town. In general, I don't want to commit the town here, but Dan Holler and I spoke that it made good sense for structural hardening. Those are grants that the town should probably go after. They're more on the building official side and code side, whereas the fuels management and defensible space piece is probably a better fit for us. So I don't have an answer for you today. We haven't been awarded the future grants, but we do have applications in the pipeline that would
1:48:30 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:49:01 Could the paper, homeowners groups, et cetera. And specifically what you want to show is, look, there's usually a period of performance. You have to complete the work a certain period of time. But we've already worked out a lot of the administrative processes through the previous grant. So I think our reflex time to implement would be shorter. That said, one of the things that, and it was just brought up, one of the
1:49:30 One of the choke points in this process is going to be the availability of vendors to do the work. The state of California unleashed a massive amount of money for key counties that had the highest mortality. And one of the narrowing points there was they just couldn't get enough people to do the work during a period of time. So we may well be competing with that, too. The actual private part of the picture here may have to catch up on
1:50:00 The ability to do the work. So there's a number of things we've got to knit together, but I believe we have, I call it the conveyor belt, I believe we have the conveyor belt in process. Any other questions, comments, suggestions? Molly, do you want to take it from here?
1:50:26 Sure, I think our main closing point would just be thank you at this point for all of the input. As I've mentioned, we've been here several times and we couldn't do our process without the input of stakeholders. Our next steps to recap will be asking for any additional comment. We will be also working with the staff and...
1:50:49 In a more detailed capacity tomorrow morning to get any other feedback that you have or questions for us. So we're looking forward to that conversation. And then, you know, Kim, I would offer that if you want to remain the primary point of contact for any of the public stakeholders for comments by September 21st, then we can feed that into our process. Sure. That's not a problem. Anybody can send their comments to me by email or written comments submitted to the town. That's fine.
1:51:21 So again, we'll turn it back to you, but thanks for the time and the questions and the opportunity to present this today. Thanks for your work. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. So I think if we wanted to relocate, we can continue the meeting here or you can sit back up there, whatever you'd like. Thank you everyone for attending and providing us with your feedback and questions and suggestions. I think next we'll move on to the consent agenda. Did anybody?
1:52:27 Look over the minutes or have any modifications or do I have a motion? We weren't here. We weren't here, so I think we have to abstain from the minutes. You can vote on the minutes even if you have, even if you weren't at the meeting, you can still vote on them as long as you've read them. Okay. Then I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. Roll call. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Mr. Eckert? Yes. Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Move to Commissioner Reports.
1:52:57 Greg, do you have anything you'd like to report on? Well, I wasn't here last month, but spent quite a bit of time in July and August talking to people about the sidewalks that are going to be going in on Main Street. And we're going to have work beginning here in the next couple of weeks, I think. Yes. On the north side. And was pretty distressed with the amount of surprise on some of the...
1:53:28 Main Street homeowners, property owners parts as to what's actually going to be going to concrete in the next couple of weeks or starting in the next couple of weeks. And had a few meetings with staff and didn't get a lot of traction on it, to be honest with you. But I would encourage you guys to really look at those plans and see what's coming because this is something that has come out of staff and through a
1:53:58 Pretty tight discussion involving the public. And I think that when things are actually sitting concrete out there, there's going to be people asking how it happened. Jen, did you have a... I'm just surprised by that because it hasn't been a secret. It's been out there for a while that these sidewalks were going in. I would say we've been talking about them for over a year. So I'm a little surprised by that. But yeah, it'd be great if people would...
1:54:32 Like to be more informed about what's going on around them. I didn't have any committee meetings. I don't know that that meeting that we went to is really a committee meeting. I don't believe so. Okay. So I don't really have anything to report. All right. I don't either. Maybe we'll move on to director's report. Yes. So just a note, the Public Works Department, kind of following up on Commissioner Eckert's comments, has put up a web page that has an interactive map.
1:55:02 That allows the public to see all of the public works projects, see the construction period, the funding mechanism, and different information about those projects with contact information. So that is up on the webpage. We push that out to the chamber, and so people can at least kind of see what's happening this year, next year, and the following year. So at least that's out there and made available to the public.
1:55:27 So since neither of the commissioners that are on the design committee are present, I will quickly recap. The design committee met on August 28th. They did review a proposal for a project called a Yotel. It's a hotel project at the northeast corner of Minaret and Main at the Nevado site. It's a new hotel. I think it's a little bit over 100 rooms.
1:55:56 And they provided some pretty good feedback for that project. So it's just a concept review at this point. We expect a formal submittal shortly. I believe the property closed escrow last week. So I think they're moving forward with this project. And then the committee also reviewed some material changes for the previously approved Manzanita Creek condominium project.
1:56:20 And then just a note to the Commission, I think you're all aware that our next meeting will be October 11th, which is a Thursday at 2 o'clock, so when we adjourn, we'll be adjourning to that meeting. Got it. And that's all I have. The concept review for the new hotel on the Nevada site, does that include food and beverage as well as lodging? It's just, it's lodging with a restaurant. Got it. So a restaurant would be incorporated in the project. Talk about Nevada as being the restaurant.
1:56:48 They didn't bring any, got it, okay. But no retail or anything else, just other than like, you know, retail oriented to hotel guests, like just little items, but there wouldn't be any kind of fronting retail on the road there. It would just really be restaurant, hotel. Got it. It's a pretty cool thing. Check out Yotel Park City. I did. Sandra shared the link with us. It's pretty interesting. Yeah, I look forward to seeing the official application.
1:57:15 All right, so if there's nothing else from the three of us, I'd like to adjourn to our next meeting, which is on October 11th, 2018, 2 o'clock in this room. Thank you very much. Thank you.