Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 6 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
271 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:36 With that, I will go ahead and call the meeting to order. And with that, we've done the meeting for today. Thank you. Thanks, Brent. All right. I'll call. Let's see. Let's do roll call. Jim, are you doing that? No. We got it. Okay. I've got it. All right. Scott McGuire is not here. Brent Turex is on the phone. John Urris. I am here. Sean Turner. Hello. Kurt Schaubmeyer. Here. Michael Ledesma. Here. Mayor Cleland-Hoff.
3:13 Not here yet. Eric Clark? Here. Paul Reiner? Here. Excellent. All right. Any board member comments? Agenda additions? Let's go around the room. Kurt, anything from you? We're on that at this time. Sean? Yeah, I actually do have something. I actually have talked about this for a while, but I formally want to mention this during board comments that I'd actually like to see us put together a survey of TBID contributing businesses.
3:43 Essentially an annual survey to talk about the idea of how is your tourism department doing for you. I think I'd like to establish just kind of an annual survey and make sure that we're checking in with our TBID paying businesses and that we're doing what they would like to see us doing. I'd like to support what Sean says and I think that we should find any
4:12 Members of the TBID community that are complaining and require them to attend a board meeting. Put an end to that. Thank you for your support. Noted. Mr. Clark? None. Thank you. Mr. Ledesma? I do have one comment I want to make from the restaurant side of things. We have two amazing new restaurants in town that have been open elixir since.
4:38 Basically, July and more recently, Warming Hut. And I wanted to talk about both of them just really briefly. Carla and Charles, a longtime residence, opened Elixir back in July. Their hours are from 10 to 7 daily, and they are located right next to P3. If you haven't tried them yet, amazing, amazing cuisine. It's bowls and different types of shakes and cold-pressed juices.
5:07 The second one is the Warming Hut, which is in the old CJ's location, and that's owned by longtime residents as well, Alyssa, Moeckler Harper, and Paul Harper, and they are open daily, serving only breakfast and lunch right now. Dinner may come on at some point, and I encourage you to try the Warming Hut as well. Both restaurants are absolutely fantastic, and next meeting we'll talk about a couple of other new things in town as well. Great. Thank you. Great restaurants.
5:38 The only thing I have to add is unfortunately our golf course will be closing this weekend, although looking out the window right now, it might be a good thing. I think that's rain, but I'm not quite sure. So it is the season for the weather to be changing. So Snow Creek Golf Course will close, and I think also Sierra Star, I think we both close on Sunday. It's our last day of operation. So it's been a great season for both courses, and I look forward to seeing everybody next spring.
6:09 Okay, any other Board Mayor comments? Any agenda additions? John? Go ahead, Brent. John? Yes, go ahead. Just one quick one. From Wyoming, I just want to say I've been very impressed in rural area Wyoming. I've been thanked no less than two dozen times by people for being here. And just a reminder that small things matter. It makes me feel good being a small town, but just something that as we think about that going down the road in Mammoth as well.
6:39 The small things do matter. Thanks. Thanks, Brent. Go ahead, John. Agenda addition, we do need to get an ad hoc committee of appeals committee together for TBID. Okay. And so that's one thing I wanted to add is probably as new business, just to probably have three people for an ad hoc because we are starting to get the appeals in for the newly reformed TBID, mainly the businesses that appealed in the past. It's just renewing and approving if they're still qualifying.
7:09 All right. So we'll put that as under new business. Let's make that item seven, a TBID appeals committee. Great. Very good. All right. I'd like to open it up to public comment. Anybody in the public like to address the group? Mr. Green, step forward, please. Okay. Thank you, guys. I'm going to try and keep this brief. I've wanted to come for a couple months, and I know you guys have been busy with other things.
7:46 Kevin Green, I'd like to talk to you guys about events here in Mammoth Lakes and just suggest a clear path forward. I see you've got some stuff on the agenda. I know you've hired an event coordinator. I know you guys are embracing this, but I just wanted to throw my two cents in. I'm talking specifically here about paid ticketed events, and I'm using specifically music festivals since there's an abundance of available and credible data that exists with them.
8:15 So first, the good news. And everything I'm going to say is pretty much fact. I'll leave my opinion to the end. And it's from talking to event promoters. It's from the Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and Forbes. So 32 million people attended at least one of the 750 music festivals in the U.S. alone last year. That's 32 million unique festival visitors, more than the population of Texas. 14.7 million of those are millennials.
8:44 People travel an average of 600 miles to attend their festival of choice. People don't believe that when they hear it, but the Sasquatch Festival in the Washington Gorge had a half a million people at its peak, and it's more remote than Mammoth Lakes. Festival goers are one of the most loyal and predictable communities that exist. North American companies spent $1.5 billion on festival sponsorship last year. The bad news, we're 10 to 15 years behind our peer resorts in this endeavor.
9:13 Our peer resorts long ago established proven best practices for public-private partnerships. We're three years into a festival recession, having reached peak festival back in 2015, and attendance is down virtually everywhere. The Wall Street Journal published an article back in 2011 saying that we had officially crossed the mark of more festivals than headliners that existed.
9:38 People aren't talking right now about what the new cool festivals will be each year, rather wondering which ones will survive. There are two reasons why there's been this profound change. The first one is actually weather risk, and climate change being the biggest risk has pushed insurance costs through the roof, making most uninsurable, and that's for big city festivals in normal climates that are less affected than we are here.
10:04 And the second is a massive consolidation in the ownership of festivals in the industry by three players, AEG, Live Nation, and Lifestyle. They now own most of the biggest festivals, including Coachella, Bonnaroo, Austin City Limits, Sasquatch, and Lollapalooza. These are huge international sports and entertainment conglomerates with stakes in hundreds of sports teams and hundreds of venues.
10:28 Their size and buying power enable them to book talent for multiple events and offer gigs in venues from stadiums to smaller clubs. They spread the risk around many festivals so one bad one won't take them down. They are 100% vertically integrated, owning the venues, ticketing agencies, marketing companies, and 95% of the $1.5 billion in sponsorship money. They have economies of scale on production, staffing, marketing, and talent costs.
10:57 They've made it very hard. Can I continue for another two maybe? They've made it very hard, near impossible for independent startups to enter and existing ones to compete. Few to no real cash sponsors exist for a 1,000 to 5,000 person festival anywhere. So for a suggested path forward, and I see this is on the agenda today, would be that in addition to an event coordinator and a site,
11:26 and site infrastructure. We need to have a real plan. We're going to need town council to work closely with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the mountain. That's what it's taken everywhere else. So I suggest the following to help come to an informed, smart decision. One, something like, maybe less casual, but like an economic impact report should be done to understand the potential benefits to the town and related businesses. I have read many such reports dated in 2018.
11:55 for other towns that make excellent sense. Two, the total cost of a site and site improvements needs to be fully quantified. Three, the best practices of our peer resorts should be updated to fit within the times we're living in, implemented and likewise quantified. Banff, Telluride, Aspen, Jackson Hole come to mind. These resorts have successfully incentivized new event promoters through public-private partnerships with declining investment.
12:21 trajectories, and all now have multiple self-sustaining events. BAMF, I feel, is the best example of this, and it was done by a guy named Kurt Schroeder, who used to have a home here. They have 16 self-sustaining events now. Some form of matching marketing dollars should be given to incentivize festival promoters. This can be done potentially through MLT leveraging Marion Carson ad buys.
12:45 Our little yoga festival last year spent $30,000 and will spend $80,000 this year on marketing. If we had some help, we could bring that many more attendees to town. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to speak with you and I'm available to help in any way I can. Thank you, Kevin. Anybody have any questions for Kevin? Yes. Kevin, what in God name possessed 500,000 people to go to the Sasquatch Festival and wherever the heck it was? I don't know. It's down to 250,000 like most festivals everywhere now.
13:17 But, I mean, where is that festival located? It's in Washington Gorge. Washington Gorge. That does sound like it's out of the way. I was looking it up right now. It looks like it's not going to happen next year. The founder's stepping down. Yeah, it tells the success. That's why you used the... I did. It went from a half a million to 250,000 in like a year. I think they made the mistake by trying to put it into a couple different weekends and got a little greedy to try and...
13:45 Grow it, you know. Greedy festival promoters. That's the big problem. Well, Kevin, I'm not sure, listening to what you had to say, if you're suggesting that festivals have a bright future or a lousy future. I think that what I'm saying is festivals can't be something where let's just get a piece of land and a person and then we're in business. We need to...
14:19 You know, times have changed, and there are ways that independent festivals can join together, which we're doing now with our yoga festival, with 13 other independent yoga festivals. We're competing against Adidas, so is Wanderlust now. So there's things that we can do to be able to maybe get some of those marketing dollars, be able to leverage our talent buying. But it's a brutal business. By way of example, like the Squaw Wanderlust, they radius restrict every single person they have. They get all the best yoga.
14:48 People put them on the road and we have to be very creative to, you know, find talent. But there's ways that it can happen. I just think it needs to be well thought out. Like I said, I've read many good economic impact reports for other towns in 2018. I think it makes really good sense. I just think we need to stop, you know, and put some kind of a plan together and just understand it. And the marketing is the biggest help that...
15:18 You know, it's a ground war. It's just an all-out war in us being able to pull people or Sean's festival being able to, you know, pull people here. But the ones that will survive are going to be creative and work together. Thank you. Thanks, Kevin. Appreciate it. Anyone else in the public? Any public comments? Okay, with that, I'll close public comment. Next is approval of minutes. Let's see. I guess it doesn't matter which order we do this in, does it?
15:49 We can go ahead and let's approve first. Let's go chronological order here. The executive session, excuse me, minutes from August 29th. So hopefully everybody has those minutes, had a chance to look at it. We have a motion to approve. You know, it's funny. I actually reviewed these previously, but, John, we still have that monthly board meeting. Yeah, I know. I think that does need to be adjusted to be a special meeting. So if we change that so that it's clear that it's the executive
16:23 Committee. Right. That will change it. Okay. I'll move to approve the minutes as amended. Okay. Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Any discussion? Okay, motion passes. All right, next, let's... John, abstain on that minute. Thank you, Brent. One abstention. All right, let's...
16:53 Go to the minutes of the September 11th meeting. Do we have a motion to approve those minutes? I'll move. You know, the secretary, I've already reviewed this, so I wonder if it's better from somebody else, but I think you're well qualified. All right, so we have a motion. We have a second. We have a second. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Any discussion? Aye. Okay, thank you, Brent. All right, motion passes, so minutes are approved.
17:30 New business. First is air service incremental budget breakdown. Yeah, based on our last meeting, we had talked about the approval of the funding to go forward, the $400,000 to assist in fall, winter, and spring, and there was a request to come back with the breakdown of the winter number, the $370,000 plus number, and so we've got Amanda with us from Marion Carson. We're going to walk through the piece that was in your packet that really kind of breaks down where those funds will be going for this coming winter and then beyond.
17:59 Thanks everyone. Amanda, in person. Yeah, I'll keep it brief and honestly being in person is so much better, so.
18:05 The memo in front of you. Oh, actually, first I want to add something myself. This morning we got really great news that Mammoth Lakes Tourism won two more awards for their campaigns with the W3, which is the Excellence in Digital and Web Awards. We are now among big brands such as Kellogg's, Google, Samsung, Hilton, Fiat Chrysler, Delta, UPS, and NBC Sports who all won awards this year. So we're in great company and it's super exciting for us. So I thought that was some really good Wednesday morning.
18:35 And one was gold for the 360 video and one was silver for our fall campaign. Yeah. So we're really crushing it and we're going to keep doing that for you guys. That being said, I'll be really brief with this memo since we went in depth with it last board meeting and please note what was shown to you on the presentation screen was actually meant to be a printout for you and so if you want more details on the specific planning, it's...
19:00 It's available and I'm happy to reshare it. But just to quickly go through the request to break out the budget on the second page of the memo, you'll see how the budget is being allotted by market as well as by media partners specifically.
19:14 And so this $400,000, we are making sure we're using our best performing media partners for this space. So again, we go through the specific breakdown working with display advertising, search engine marketing, Facebook, as well as, as I said, programmatic display to have our most optimal performance. And all of our targeting hits people that are searching to buy flights for Mammoth Lakes. So we want to make sure your dollars are working as hard as possible for you here.
19:42 So I'm more than happy to take any questions. I guess just one other opportunity coming your way in the next month is an opportunity for our resort partners to work with us and expand our marketing dollars in this space. So knowing that your money is going to go a lot farther.
19:58 And additionally, we are still in talks with JetSuiteX and United, and both are sounding like because of our incremental contribution, they are going to add additional dollars to support. So at least on JetSuiteX side, we've got them to secure an additional $30,000, which is great. They're also looking to include us in their California campaign, which...
20:20 touches a bunch of markets in the Burbank area as well as Orange County. So I can certainly come back with what that looks like. But this money is really what made them tip the needle. And then Clint, who is our air service partner with Embark, is currently in discussions with United. So they sound very promising as well. And we're just excited. So any questions, I'm more than happy to answer them.
20:44 I've got some questions. Sure. So Sojourn Display, you mentioned your most effective partners, our most effective partners. Tell me a little bit about Sojourn Display. Correct. Sojourn works with 65-plus travel data partners. That means when people are searching search engines, when people are going on OTA websites like your Expedias, when people are going on tourism sites, when people are looking on airlines to book hotels. In real time, Sojourn's able to tell what people are looking at what sites and serve them America.
21:14 Mammoth Lakes ad, as opposed to working with, say, one partner. I'll use an example. Say we partner with USA Today on their website to specifically target ads. We're just hitting everybody. We're not hitting people that we know for certain are further down what we call the funnel to book a trip to Mammoth Lakes. That way, every single dollar we're using is against an actual prospect and not just a top-level person who hasn't even started considering traveling to Mammoth Lakes.
21:40 Okay, so this is actually, this is a digital display, not print? Correct. Okay. That was the question I had, and John, just to be clear, this is for this winter campaign only? Correct. 400 grand? Yep. Well, and there's 31250 for fall and spring, and then 337 for winter. So the fall, spring's not broken out in here specifically, but it's summer basically? Yeah, we...
22:11 Our summer-spring campaign, we kind of flow together. That's fine. Yeah. Just didn't see the word spring in there, so. All right. Thanks. Any other questions for Amanda? All right. Okay. Great. Thank you. Well, I look forward to seeing you all next month. We're going to come and share some of the great things that Mary and Carson has partnered with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to accomplish for you all, the board, and the community, and we're very excited about it. Thanks for coming down, Amanda. Thank you very much, Amanda.
22:49 I lost at trivia last night at the brewery. That's a good loss. You lost it at the brewery. Well, there you go. You will be the first. That covers A and B, right? Yeah, because it was approved last month, it was more just to give you the breakdown of what was approved.
23:09 Okay. All right. Moving on. 2018-19 winter air service schedule. Yeah, the air service schedule is pretty easy. There are two documents. One of them is a little more in-depth because there are some schedule changes throughout the course of the winter. So there's a scheduled arrival and departure sheet, which is the more detailed piece.
23:26 It talks about the Denver flight and from certain dates to certain dates it's one time and then it does move times throughout the course of the season. It also gives you the day of week that it's flying so you can see with both airlines what we have for service, when it's coming in and then also when it's going back out. The easier one to follow is really the ramp chart which is the colored one there.
23:46 With the yellow blocks, that really shows when the planes arrive and then when they turn around to head back out. So you can see that we don't have too much overlap. We do have planes coming in and leaving at close times, but it's really not a big issue, especially with JetSuiteX not going to the commercial terminal. So they go over to the FBO, so they don't conflict at all with the commercial flights coming in.
24:12 I just wanted to give you guys that update. We are loaded and booking on JetSuite X. We are still waiting for the final contracts for both airlines. I think we've discussed that being fairly normal that we don't even see those for a little bit here. But that's what we're working on right now. We're working on the ground handling side, especially with JetSuite X.
24:30 Pat Foster at Hutt Creek Aviation went down to Burbank today to just observe their operation and see what they can do and also looked into purchasing of some of the equipment, the belt loaders, the tugs, the carts. So if they end up doing the service that they can handle that. And then we do have a SkyWest. We do have our station manager down at the airport is someone who worked on the flights last year under Dina.
24:56 With Alaska Airlines, he's going to be staying on as the station manager, Chris. So we have some continuity from last year, which is good. Is the Denver correct? It looks like, if you look at the notes on the bottom, it says 105, and then up here it's 1236. Which one of those is it? What's the question? Well, because it changes flight time. So if you look at the other sheet, it'll show you the difference in flight. So there is a 105 flight, it's just a different.
25:26 If you look... Some days it's 1.05? Yeah, there's a certain time of year. Let's see here, Denver... So it looks like an early and late season it goes at these times. Yeah, and the times may be off slightly, but I think that that's... The bigger grid gives you the actual times. So... It's around 12.30. Yeah, it's not... Yeah, it's... I don't know why that wouldn't match exactly, but...
25:55 Things move around quite a bit with these guys. That's the unfortunate thing. So that's also why we don't necessarily list a lot of the times on the site because they do change quite a bit. I think it's within a half an hour, though. Yeah. Yeah, and the good news is we don't have a ton of overlap. So these dates on this sheet are just for their, for instance, starting flights on December 19th out of Denver, but just between 1-7 and 2-14, the times are different. Right, and like I said, if you look at the more in-depth sheet,
26:26 And it gives you the actual, so from December 19th to January 6th, it departs to Denver. And the other thing is you have time change too. So it's a two hour flight, you just have a time change as well. So it comes in here at 12.36 and then departs again at 1.12 and gets into Denver at 4.20 based on their time. And then obviously it shifts once the season progresses.
26:55 And then again, as we've mentioned, right now we're only contracted through March 30th, but the goal is to look at that. We've got Easter very late this year, so to look at where we potentially want to take some of the flights. Obviously LAX is seven days a week year-round, but if we want to extend San Francisco, we've talked about it, we're not sure, we're probably not looking at extending Denver out, but I think we are looking at at least extending San Francisco so people can go Denver, San Francisco, Mammoth.
27:24 That's still to be determined, but right now we're at least locked and loaded until the end of March. Is it possible, John, to consider San Francisco for the summertime skipping over the shoulder season? Does that not work? Well, for the summertime, I think we would have to look at the risk, because right now we're still floating summer about $850,000 on the summer subsidy, and that's kind of maxing us out on budget. So if we look at going to San Francisco,
27:54 Would they let us look at July 4th through Labor Day four days a week? And what's the risk there? Is it $300,000? Is it a quarter million? Is it $500,000? And then we would have to budget for it. Right now we're still only budgeted for LAX year-round. The one thing that we aren't necessarily fully budgeted for is the fact that we're going to seven days a week in the fall period. So like right now with Alaska we fly four days a week. And we always have for the fall. We've always had that kind of four-day-a-week block. Moving forward that's going to be seven days a week.
28:23 We probably have a couple hundred thousand bucks potential additional risk to be seven days a week next year. I would add, Paul, that it's hard for the airlines to increase flights in the summertime. That's their highest demand, so it's really hard for us in a small market to...
28:40 To find like a four day a week flight. Especially in the summer. Because it's not, the plane's being utilized in other segments. But it doesn't mean we can't. Well, I think there's a flip side to it. And, you know, I'm not the marketing guy here. You guys are. But it seems to me that marketing Mammoth for the winter season in San Francisco and then letting the summer go, you kind of lose some momentum.
29:07 In the spring, and you have to pick it all up again in the fall, whereas if we had more of a year-round push for people to come here winter and summer from that San Francisco market, it might in the long run be of something of benefit to us. I think ultimately that would be the goal is to expand our summer service. Right now still costs escalating and numbers staying flat. I think we're bumping up against some pretty hefty numbers for the summer subsidy.
29:37 I think until we can get that down a little bit before we start looking to new markets. Well, and I hear what you're saying about that. I think that to a certain extent the air service may be putting a cart before the horse. First we'd have to figure out what would attract people to come here in the summertime from San Francisco who usually vacation in Tahoe for various reasons. But, I mean, I think we have a lot more.
30:02 In terms of outdoors to offer, then Tahoe in some ways. I mean, Tahoe's crowded in the summer, and we are not. Although there are people... Some people would argue... Yeah, people would argue that. But I think we have something to market to San Francisco. If we could figure out how to do it, the whole thing might make more sense and might, you know, give us another market to draw from besides LA.
30:26 Well, we've also had the conversations about, you know, what our next step in summer would be, and one of the questions we've had is whether it's a second LA flight, so you have multiple time slots there, and I think that we've talked about San Francisco. I think that it really comes down to the budget and the risk that we're willing to take, and then, like Eric said, in the wintertime, it's easy for us to work with the airlines because they don't have the planes flying as much. In the summertime, they're high demand. We pay more for the flights in the summer because of the fact that the planes are in high demand.
30:53 Well, for what it's worth, I'll just throw this out. If we had consistent weekend high-level entertainment on the order of a bluesapalooza once a week, we'd create attractions in San Francisco that would resonate. Right now, it's pine trees versus pine trees, and that's a tough sell. Blue sky versus blue sky. Green pine trees, blue sky. Yeah. Well, sometimes we have.
31:22 And then there are times where we don't. But you see what I'm saying. Like I think Kevin was just saying during a public comment, we need to look at beefing up what we offer because otherwise we're in competition with a whole lot of other places and entertainment could be that focus that would give us an edge that we don't have right now.
31:51 Is there the same kind of demand for JetSuite planes in the summer? You know, you said that, and I get it, major airlines have a lot more business going on in the summer. Is that the same case for the private airline? I would assume, just given the overall demand, but I actually don't know. I haven't asked JetSuite that question. Because we have explored, you know, going over to that exact market with them.
32:20 That would be a way to explore it as well. It's a good idea. I'm interested in that industry just because I'm hearing more and more about specific, those kind of people traveling to Bluza Bluza, and specifically, and that just seems like the way of the future in a lot of ways for air. Well, I think the JetSuite X is a little bit different too because they only fly to a couple of resort areas. I think a lot of what they're flying is business traffic, so I'm not sure they see that fluctuation seasonally.
32:49 You know, whether they're flying LA to San Jose or, you know, so I think that might be a difference, but we'll ask them, we'll ask them what the flow is, because that could be a way for us to dip our toe in the Bay Area, going to San Jose, or to Oakland with them. Keep the marketing going for, you know, think of Mammoth in the summer, but I really think entertainment is critical to that.
33:10 I mean, if you're in San Francisco and you're going to hop in a car and be, you know, in the Tahoe area in a relatively short period of time. Or Yosemite and then come over. Pardon? Or Yosemite and then come over. Yeah, or Yosemite. But you need a little something more to pull you over. And I think that's what entertainment represents or could represent for us on a much bigger scale. Is there enough, I'm just curious about this, you know, post March 30th from Denver.
33:39 Is there, I mean, I realize that because of our altitude, Mammoth is relatively unique. A lot of the, probably a lot of the Colorado ski areas start closing down a little bit. That's a little early, isn't it? I mean, so I guess what I'm saying is, would there be enough demand for people to fly from Denver to Mammoth late to get our good spring snow rather than staying in Colorado? You know, would that, is that a consideration? I mean, when you're, or is part of this a function of waiting to see what our snow is like before we ask the airlines, or is it just simply
34:09 You know, timing on that as far as extending it out. John, I'll jump in and let you know that, you know, as we look at the Colorado market, we actually took that question into consideration. And although it's hard to be specific to measure the demand, the Colorado market, the spring market dies off. There is ski resorts that are open late, especially with Easter being, you know, so late this coming year.
34:35 Winter Park will be open well into the end of April. A basin will be as well. So there's alternatives there. But what we've seen in that marketplace is that there's not as much demand for spring skiing as there is actually here. Interesting. And from our marketplace, where we actually do get a good demand for people to come up in and enjoy the spring skiing from Southern California and even some people from Tahoe.
35:05 Icon Pass hopefully changes that. And that's where it's a little unanswered as to what the demand will be. But the market itself in the springtime in Colorado goes away. Got you. Eric, I heard what you just said, but what I didn't get was which is the chicken and which is the egg? Does the demand fall off because their snow is crappy in the spring? Or does the... No. Is it...
35:32 What you're saying is that doesn't have anything to do with whether they have snow or not. Right. They just don't want to go skiing. That's right. I find that hard to imagine, to be honest with you. It's a fact. I lived there 10 years in Summit County in Winter Park, and we just couldn't quite get the people up that you see here. I can't explain it, but that's...
36:01 It's a fact. Okay. One thing I'll just throw out, and I don't want to hold up the meeting, but March is a month when people think about traveling. Because you think of January and February as being so stormy, you want to go skiing somewhere else, but it's hard to get there, and the storm's getting away, and then when you go skiing, you know, you can't because there's big storms and all. So early March is a popular time to go skiing elsewhere.
36:30 And maybe that would work in the opposite for people in Colorado where the skiing is petering out and that's some of our best skiing. March is not what I'm referring to. March is an extremely high demand month in Colorado. I'm referring to the end of April. Oh, the end of April. Yeah. Oh, okay. Well, then they don't have any snow. Of course they don't. Well, they do, actually. It's called mud season there. Well, I rest my case. Thanks, Aaron. Yeah.
37:00 All right, any more comments or questions regarding the winter air service schedule? Okay, we're going to move on to contracts. Okay, you know, basically with the LA Kings, we have an agreement with them and we have been asked to pull together a point of view from Marion Carson just to make sure that we're spending the dollars right. And so what you have in front of you is the point of view. This was not included in the original agenda packet that's posted online. It will be posted as soon as Emily's back from
37:29 Her sales mission that she's on. But basically what it comes down to is we look at the market. Obviously LA is a huge market for us. The people that are attending those games are definitely right along the index that we want to see coming to Mammoth Lakes and have a higher propensity to ski. So the feeling was that the primary reason for it is to increase awareness. Not everything we do has a direct ROI associated with it. A lot of it has to do with branding and awareness and recognition.
37:57 And that's why we feel that this is a worthwhile venture for us to continue. We'll continue to reevaluate it every single season to make sure that it still is hitting the mark that we want to hit. But right now, the recommendation is that we still move forward with it. I did talk with the Kings this morning. We are, Amanda will be reaching out to them because I think there are some opportunities for us to add some additional value.
38:20 to the program. But right now, between what's going on with Mammoth Mountain and their efforts, Icon Pass separately has come in. I believe it's separate. There's a Mammoth Mountain deal and an Icon Pass deal with the Kings as well. And it all ties into our messaging as well. So as it works right now, the first two thirds of the season are promoting the Mammoth Mountain side and Bear Mountain. And then what we'll...
38:46 Pickup is the last 14 games like we did last year. We sell a four-season message, so we're still continuing to talk about the spring or the skiing, which is still kind of the March timeframe, March-April timeframe. And then we're also talking about the mountain biking and the hiking and the fishing and all those other pieces. So our goal is to have the mountain take on the heavy lifting with the winter message. And then as we get closer to the close of the ski season and the close of the NHL season, we start to shift gears and talk about all the other opportunities that are coming up here in the winter.
39:16 And to be clear before we get into questions, this is the report that we had that Brent Truax asked to bring forward and was emailed separately, so. It was emailed separately to you, yes, and that's why I said it'll be posted to the agenda after the meeting, or like I said, when Emily gets back, because I have no idea how to post things to the agendas. And that'll be added to that piece. Okay. Any other questions on that? Okay. Yep.
39:48 I read that online document that will be posted to the agenda after the meeting is over. It sounds a little bit, you know, like, hmm, okay, well, if you say so. But we didn't have it in time to post on Friday. No, I hear you. But that aside, there was a recommendation from Aaron Carson saying something, and perhaps you can interpret it for me, John, about the change in branding in the middle of the season they didn't think was effective.
40:18 Did you see that there? It was in the last page. I think what we're looking at is looking more to partner with Mammoth Mountain to actually do some possible cross-promotion versus having it just be cut and dry that this is Mammoth Mountain, this is Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I think that might be what you're referring to? I think so. I'm kind of reading between the lines. It wasn't that clear. Yeah, so while...
40:44 We do own the final third of the buy. What is good for the brand to extend and increase our impact is for that clarity of message. So when we're going into market first with Mammoth Mountain.
41:00 Then we're kind of doing the break and going back with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. If we find ways to integrate throughout that whole time, we're helping brand awareness on both sides of the fence. People are seeing a more consistent message from a united brand front. And then that will carry us into the summer months. So our recommendation, instead of completely keeping it super separate, is to build brand equity longer throughout the season for the destination.
41:30 Mammoth Lakes Message, but blend the Mammoth Mountain image into that later.
41:39 Well, I'm saying, yeah, what we would want to do is work very closely with the mountain on a way that, one, helps represent the destination as a whole while still working with the mountain and what they're looking to accomplish out of the partnership. And then through some of our added value efforts that we would look to negotiate even further with the kings, because we're very certain our media team feels they can get more out of this for you, is to find other opportunities to integrate some of the other resort partners and partners in the destination so that it's a more holistic opportunity for everybody.
42:09 Resort partners you're referring to here in town? Correct. Good. Yep. The whole point of these sponsorships and, too, when we talked earlier about events and stuff,
42:20 is to give a voice to everyone and make sure everybody is incorporated in that for the destination. So that's what we're looking to achieve in this new year with the Kings. That maybe leads into some of the questions that I had, because I was seeing the same thing, and I remember last year when we were looking at this. Frankly, I agree, it was a little disconcerting to see MMSA advertising, and then all of a sudden it's tourism, and as much as I want us to be advertising tourism in town,
42:49 Mammoth Lakes. Now, this is a great opportunity for MMSA, and I think that the brand awareness, my concern is just that. I think that you read into that as well, that it's almost like we're presenting two different messages when really we should be keeping it one.
43:05 Is that what I was reading in from that report? I think we want to keep them, I think we still want to keep the messaging a little bit separate. I don't think, I think the point of us buying in was to continue that momentum of what they had done for the first third of the season, but switching gears to be able to talk about the four seasonality versus just the winter message. But I think what we're talking about now is integrating so that we can still go back to what you're saying, so we can go and have the strength of both partners throughout the course of the partnership.
43:29 I'm not sure that we fully know what that looks like, and I think that we don't want to lose our brand identity, and we don't want to confuse brand identity, but that's really, the Mountain's focus has been solely on the ski season. Ours takes the shift, and it still has ski season pieces to it, but then it really talks about the spring, summer, fall opportunities, so that folks are kind of shifting gears to think about the next seasons with us. I get it, and that's actually, I'm...
43:53 I think we may be saying the same thing because I want to see that continuity of message, you bet, especially when it comes to the Kings. I'm glad that MMSA is advertising as much as they are specifically as you are. And then I just want to make sure that there is a transition and that we are representing all businesses here in Mammoth.
44:16 MMSA is a major destination reason why people come to town that we are being fair with other businesses. And follow-up question with what you're saying then, when you're talking about other brands, I mean, are you talking about specifically taking in other businesses to promote down there or just...
44:32 More of the natural resources that we have. Sure, I can give an example. So what we would look sometimes to added value giveaways where instead of necessarily being Mammoth Mountain stay or this or that, it could be the Sierra Nevada Lodge and that's where the stay is and some other places. So you're getting brand recognition. In Arena, we have social media posts. We get e-blasts where we can start being more direct in terms of itineraries and things that people can do in destination and list out all those.
45:01 locations instead of it being more brand awareness. We want to be really smart with all the assets that we get. And part of that is for Maren Carson to have a larger role in this process this year, speak directly to the kings and really work our magic to get some more of those opportunities within the contract. Okay. That leads to just a couple more questions. One is going to be, oh, geez, how do we determine, you know, whether it's Sierra Nevada Lodge or Snow Creek Resort? I don't know or, you know, any others that are out there.
45:32 That's an open-ended question that I don't think I forgot. Yeah, I don't know. We're certainly very fair. We work very closely with Megan and Josh and the content, and we know the key partners, and we'll make sure that everyone is represented equally. And we also do have representation for everyone on the website so we can pick and ensure people are being driven to the right places so that it's an equal playing field. Second follow-up question on that is,
46:02 Tourism, we've done this contract with the Kings this last year. Correct. And was that a direct contract with us? Marian Carson was not involved in that. No, the contract's still direct with us, with the Kings. Marian Carson just helps us with all the creative. We provided the creative fulfillment. Yeah, Marian Carson got involved because there was a request for the point of view on whether this is the right thing for us to be doing, and that's where they're involved here, and they're obviously involved in the creative.
46:31 Okay. The contract is with us, and it's also signed by the town manager because these are joint bucket funds. Okay. I may ask further questions on that, but that satisfies me for now. One question, Amanda. Is it true that the Mammoth Mountain ski instructors this year won't be wearing jackets, they'll be wearing hockey shirts? Oh, I don't know. That sounds like a fun idea. That's untrue. Apparently that's untrue. Oh, man.
46:57 Well, I'm from Philly, and so I'm a Flyers fan. And you saw our weird new mascot, so. Yeah, good luck to that. So creepy. All right, we'll move on. We all saw it, though. We did all, yeah. It's good for, it's good in the back market. It was creepy. We'll go on to part B of contracts, and then it's quick. There was a request for, to have the entire, the entire board have the Marian Carson contract for this year.
47:23 I had gone through this with Scott and we had fixed a couple of pieces that he had concerns about as far as there was mention of Marian Carson being exclusive in the agency world for us. Obviously, we use other even smaller, much smaller agencies to do certain things and we wanted to make sure that that was clear. So we pulled that out and then there was a question mark of the assets and who owned them if we change agencies and so that's been adjusted as well.
47:50 I did send this to you in the agenda packet, so if there are any questions about it, we can move on from there. If not, I would look to see a vote to accept the new agreement. Okay, do we have any questions? Yeah. We're just full of questions, aren't we? Well, that was actually going to be one of my questions, because looking here in paragraph one, it looks like the advertiser agrees not to engage the service of any other advertising agency. And that's what my question specifically...
48:21 And it runs, I think, counter to what you just said. Well, we took out in that, in that, it had said, it had said advertiser agrees to retain and appoint agency exclusively to represent them. I think you're right. I think it does still read a little bit off that we can't go out, but it is meant to say that we can. We can look at that again and see if it can be reworded. Okay. I think it's exclusive though. Do you?
48:54 Well, it certainly, the language seems to import that, but I think to understand the meaning of the clause, you have to be familiar with advertising agency practice, what's normal and what's taken, you know, what's understood and so forth and so on. Not an area where I have any expertise.
49:21 John, is this Section 102 Sub-A, what's the concern here? I mean, if we're going to have Marian Carson do all this stuff, do they have a legitimate concern that we'll use some other agency for something else? No, and again, I think if you read the whole thing, it does talk about the fact that we're not going to go out and get somebody else to do the same things that they do for us. So we're not going to go out and hire a new branding agency. We're not going to go out and hire a media buyer for us.
49:51 Yeah, we already work in partnership with Miles and Lyman, who are two other agencies for PR as well as for the website team. So by no means are we restricting Mammoth Lakes Tourism from hiring another agency. To John's point, we are the ones that have been hired to work through the paid media stuff. So in terms of that...
50:12 relationship together. We would expect to be the owners of that within our contract together. But I believe a good example John put forth was, say, you wanted to hire a social media agency. Of course. I mean, what we're looking for is more partners and the right mix of people to get the work done for your organization. We're not looking to hinder you in any way from what needs to be done to, you know, accomplish what the destination needs.
50:35 So it's basically things that they may not offer us. Again, if it's media buying, they're our agency of record, they do our media buying, we're not going to go out and contract a separate media buyer. And I guess the question is, is that arrangement standard, you know, in the relationship between the agency and an organization like ours, is that arrangement the norm?
51:03 It has been in my experience, yeah. So Maren Carson works with Visit California, Visit Napa Valley, Tahiti Tourism. Great. So Visit California uses you exclusively as their media buyer? Yes, they do. They have Time Inc. I just want to make sure that, and that probably makes sense. I'm just wondering, does it preclude tourism from
51:32 You know, contracting its own advertising. You know, I understand that, you know, for instance, the sheet may be in markets or not necessarily advertising tourism in local newspapers. But does this mean that we cannot do any of our own buys? And would we want to? Well, I think on the local side, it makes sense for us to do the local buys. And I think that on a bigger scale, we don't, they're going to be contracting, if they're going to be contracting with outside magazine online.
52:00 If we went to them, if we went to outside directly, we would pay $10,000, they would pay $7,500. So, I mean, they've got the buying power on a much grander scale, so I think we wouldn't opt to do our own placements because they've got that bulk buy, but on the local level, it's not going to make any sense for them to place a $500 ad for us. So there are places where we will maintain that local or smaller buy piece.
52:23 And obviously, even if we go and look at a social agency, we're going to work with both Marian Carson and Miles Partnership to say, hey, we're looking at this agency to do X, Y, and Z, and then we can get their POV on that as well from whether it's the right agency for us to go with, but we can contract it directly. Again, if it assists in the big picture. Okay. I just want to make sure that the language in here does specify that. That's why I had a question with that. I was going to look to you for your opinion on that.
52:50 And then also I want to make sure that essentially is this saying that Marian Carson and your vendors, it's not the right word, third party is doing all the content creation.
53:09 So within Maren Carson, it is a holdings company. They do have an art studio. We have a production studio. We have a lot of assets that we can provide Mammoth Lakes Tourism outside your standard agency, and we have about 35 people in and out of a weekly basis working on this account. I'm technically a Maren Carson person, but...
53:29 At any given day, I'm working with somebody who's a part of our studio and technically the way the company's set up. So that's just what that's referring to. We may contract with our production company because there's a lot of cost efficiencies, time efficiencies, budget efficiencies by utilizing all of these great resources that we offer in-house. Okay. All right. And then the final question I think I have on the contract was agencies shall not incur any obligations in excess of $2,500.
53:59 Without first paying written approval. That seems like a low number, actually. Right. That's page four. Prior approval by advertising. Is that standard? Well, we just... Which is fine. So we sign off on the estimates. I got an estimate today for...
54:15 adjusting our error message for the fall, and the estimate was $1,500. It's meant to say that we sign off on things so they're not just running out doing different projects that we may or may not have approved. It is a low number, but it's something that we want to just stay in touch with. It's out of respect to your organization. $1,500 estimate today.
54:34 Yeah, yeah, exactly. And we want to be respectful of your, it is your budget. And we make recommendations, but at the end of the day, you're our partners we work with to make the final call, and this estimate practice is putting that into practice. I get it. I'm just asking. Sure. There aren't many at that level. I'll say that. The estimates. Oh, yeah. There are many that are that low. Okay. And I guess I was saying that that seems low, you know. Yep.
55:00 If we are entrusting Marian Carson to do our advertising buys, are we really needing to approve campaigns as low as $2,500? Again, it's just a check and balance for us internally to make sure that it's better safe than... Actually, I do have one more. Failure of suppliers to perform. You're not held responsible for failure on the part of people that you contract?
55:26 So when we're working, we're under contract with Mammoth Lakes Tourism for those media buys. So, I mean, this has not happened to us at all, really, and we work specifically with partners. But, for example, we could be working through a partnership, again, I know this would never happen under John's watch, where we're following up to get content, the media partner needs to go live on the 7th, and we can't get it, and so the partner goes, I'm out.
55:48 Marin Carson isn't held liable for that. We will always do everything in our due diligence to ensure a partnership goes through. And honestly, we're always doing, we'll always look for a make good and not put the organization in that position. Okay, I'm not sure if we're saying the same thing. I'm actually saying, aren't you responsible for subcontractors and suppliers? Well, we contract them, yes, correctly, on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Okay. Mammoth Lakes hires us to sign.
56:15 Again, I'll go back to Outside Magazine Online. If we have something that we need to deliver to them and we don't deliver it, it's not their fault. Totally get that. I'm actually, the way I'm reading this is that subcontractors, you know, perhaps if you've got a design team that you've contracted to create a design for us, campaign for us, and they don't perform, who is held accountable for that?
56:38 Our team takes responsibility for the work that we owe to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And we can fix the verbiage to make sure that sounds right, but this is in reference to the partnerships that we sign on behalf of the organization. When you guys are requesting work from us that we need to deliver upon and have made a promise on, we owe that to you, and that is what we do. Okay. What she's really saying is that we're marrying Carson subcontracts with a third party.
57:08 And that third party fails to perform. Marion Carson is not going to take the hit for that. If we had paid, say, some outside photo agency $3,000 to go take pictures of something, and they just didn't perform, the pictures were terrible or whatever, we can't look to Marion Carson to give us the $3,000 back. We've got to go directly against that third party. You know what I'm saying? Even if they were hired by Marion Carson.
57:36 I'm not sure if I'd, you know, in a private business professional setting, I don't know if I'd accept that. You might not. Well, so again. Is this typical for the way DMOs do it?
57:47 This is a standard contract we use with our tourism partners, and again, we can use outside online, it's a good example, but in that case, and again, with the estimates and the checks and balance, this is why that's in place, that we are never going to a contractor that Mammoth Lakes hasn't bought on for those reasons, which is why that clause exists. Everybody's fully bought on everything we do. We don't go rogue, we're very respectful of the partnership, and again, would never put Mammoth Lakes Tourism in a precarious situation. I get it.
58:16 If, Paul, you're accepting of this, you know, I'd have a look. Here's the thing. It can be a source of friction. And if it is, that would reflect itself a year from now in our negotiations with Marian Carson. But to attempt to, you know, you can't nail everything down in a six- and seven-page contract. You just can't. And part of it depends on how well you work together. You know, we're going to depend on Marian Carson.
58:45 Pick subcontractors who will perform. If they had a track record of picking people who didn't perform, that would be a topic of discussion next year before we contract with them again. So this is the kind of thing that Marion Carson's attorneys have stuck in there to make sure that they don't get hung out to dry if someone doesn't perform. But it's the kind of thing that you look at in a broader sense in terms of how
59:15 your organization and your contracting party work together over a lengthy period of time. You don't get hung up on something like that. And it hasn't been an issue in our first five years. I'm not saying that it could be an issue, but... I'm just, you know, and I'm going to defer to the legal expert here. It's just, it was one of those things that made me that, you know, if one of your subcontractors didn't perform, but you're not being held accountable for it. So...
59:43 Am I reading that accurately? I mean, I'm not trying to be... No, no. I wish I went to law school like my husband. I'd love to be super detail-oriented on that. But what I can say to you, again...
59:55 To the point, it is our standard contract. It's actually the standard contract that has been signed by Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the past five years. We have never run into this as a problem whatsoever, and we are constantly and always on a case-by-case basis evaluating it and, again, would never put Mammoth Lakes Tourism in a bad position. Our agency upholds ourselves to the highest of standards and, again, would not let that happen.
1:00:20 Okay, thank you for saying that verbally. We've got a written one here. I certainly get it, but I will say, just in terms of situations, you can see it on either side of the fence, and I would say the most relevant example of this happening is we are contracting, say, a partner requested by Mammoth Lakes Tourism for us to sign on behalf of, and again, something goes awry.
1:00:44 Maren Carson can't be held responsible for that. So if we need to get more detailed in that language, it is by no means a problem on our agency to go in and elaborate on that. I'm going to let this go because, again, the thing I've learned about law is we could get into all kinds of what-if. Exactly. It was all about, right, the what-if situations. So if you're comfortable with this? Well, I am because in working together, there aren't guarantees.
1:01:15 We each have to work together well, and Marianne Carson and our organization have done that. If there was friction over something like this, that wouldn't be the only thing. And it would lead to us leaving our contractual relationship with Marianne Carson and finding somebody else. But the reverse has happened. You know, we spent five years with them, it's worked out okay. They don't want to get hung out to dry on some small thing. This would be a small thing.
1:01:44 The contracts we're talking about are a few thousand bucks. I mean, you know, and I understand where Marian Carson's coming from. What they're saying is if we hire someone reckable and they go south, you can't blame that on us. And what this young lady just said a moment ago is we don't go rogue. We're not going to hire some outfit from, you know, left field that you've never heard of because then if they did go south, you'd be upset. So we're not going to do that. We work with you to hire people that you already like.
1:02:13 And that, you know, if those people should, for some reason, you know, something falls in a crack and it doesn't work out, that's not our fault. And they're right. It's true. So that's the protection they have there. I don't think it's unreasonable. Okay. All right. Good. So are you satisfied with the language, I mean, in the explanation, Sean? Yeah, I think so. We should probably move on. Anybody else have any questions regarding the contract language changes, anything like that? You should probably put this to a vote.
1:02:42 Where's the paragraph that says that when we give them all this money, we'll get a whole lot of new tourists? That's the general scope. Oh, it's implied. I can't wait to see it. There you go. So do we have a motion to approve the contract as amended? Move to approve. Do we have a second? A second. All right. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Any comments? All right.
1:03:13 Go ahead. Motion passes. Contract is approved. Thank you. That was either Brent or the alien number one. That's something strange going on. All right, moving on. Special event policy. I'm not sure what that was. I think that was another aye. Brent, you're kind of coming across with a bit of a twang in your voice. Yeah, that's because he's annoying. I'm not even in the south. Special event policy discussion. This has just come up in the last couple of meetings, and I think the
1:03:42 What I would like to do is we do want to have the board conversation on this and discussion. I think with Caroline coming on board in a month. She comes on, well, not a month.
1:03:53 Two weeks. She comes on board October 15th. I think she and I had a good conversation this afternoon. She stopped by to pick up her new hire paperwork, and we did talk about some of these different policies and pieces, and I think having a dedicated director of special events will help clarify a lot of these things and then obviously be able to look at peer resorts and a lot of what Kevin had to say and just looking at what can we do for the economic impacts.
1:04:15 We even talked about things like does she need to put together a street team so that she has people going out doing the surveying at events during the summer so it's not your responsibility or your responsibility to add that to the list of 500 things you have to deal with. So I think when we start to get into this, I think it's really going to come into her world to develop the guidelines and then obviously have feedback from the board to determine whether we're headed in the right direction.
1:04:37 And feedback. So what you're saying is we'll hear from her next month? It probably won't be next month. I think that would be two weeks would be a hard piece for her to pull something together. But I think she's going to be, you know, we talked about her kind of first hundred day plan. I think we'll present that probably at the December board meeting. But I think what she's going to do is come in and do a lot of that fact finding, looking at even the current process for
1:05:00 Grant funding from the town. If we feel we need to do additional grant funding, how those are handled, if the process has worked, if it hasn't worked, things that are repetitive, just trying to clean up all those different pieces and then come back to the board with a recommendation of this is how we should move forward. Well, John, could I suggest that you have her make an appearance next month, if only briefly, just to kind of, you know, give us an idea where she's going and start a dialogue.
1:05:25 So the board needs to get to know her and vice versa. Absolutely. And my conversations with her today, one of the first things she wants to do is get out and meet with the event people and really kind of reform the coalition so that there's a lot of feedback. Survey the event producers to see what's been working, what hasn't been working, and figure out what to do from there. You know, I think it's one of those things where, unfortunately, without having that position, it's been kind of a...
1:05:52 You know, we've been kind of deciding things on the fly. I think now having that position, we have a lot more formality and I think we have a lot more policy procedure and process that we can have moving down the road. So she'll make a point of speaking to Sean and speaking to Kevin and getting their input from the special events. Yeah, and she's actually, even though she doesn't start until the 15th, she's already started having conversations with different folks around town as to what, you know, what kind of the feedback is, what the feelings are, what the opportunities are.
1:06:20 And we even talked about some different events that are out there that we could potentially try and attract for end of October. So, and I even said, you know, I think if you're coming on at this time frame that realistically we're looking at kind of next summer events and she still thinks there's opportunity for this winter. So I'm excited to see where we go with this one. I just want to address some of the things around this. You know, I think that this is a direct, this discussion is a direct result of
1:06:48 You know, kind of learning that we are supporting the half marathon. And to be clear, MLT has not financially supported any other event. So I'm glad that we are going to be putting policy and process around this. You know, there has been discussion just in the last month about what kind of policy and process we have in place. And I can tell you that when recreation used to review this, and even just as far as youth sports funding goes, you know, it's a big deal.
1:07:18 $50,000 ask, and there's $35,000 that we got. And so if we as a board determine that we are going to be allocating so much money to events, and there's going to be a lot of discussion around it. And there's a lot of opportunities in events, whether they're musical music or lifestyle oriented events like.
1:07:37 Bluza Palooza, sporting events, we have great opportunity with regard to branding ourselves as a high altitude destination. You know, something I've been saying from the recreation side is that there's tremendous opportunity for all the tournaments that come to town that frankly could probably put more heads in beds on an annual basis than Bluza Palooza does. And as Caroline has said, you know, the low hanging fruit I think is tremendous. I'm a big advocate for that. But what I want to make sure is that we are having
1:08:06 A open and transparent policy and process for how MLT, if we are going to be awarding money, how we go about doing it. And I will tell you that it is cumbersome. It is difficult sometimes to have a dozen or more event groups come before you saying, hey, I'm worthy, give me some money. And so I do want to make sure that we are putting together some definitions and
1:08:33 or defining some sideboards around how that works. The timeline, obviously this is the time of year when event producers are looking at summer of 2019, how are we going to be putting together our budgets, what kind of sponsorship do we need to go out there and seek? So I think the best thing that we as a board can do right now today is say that we are reviewing this process. I'm excited to have Caroline come on board.
1:08:58 Put this together so that we can outline in an open and transparent way exactly what we are going to be doing if we are going to be supporting events. Good point. And I think, you know, definitely we need her to get on board and get her comments and her thought process going forward so we can also formulate those opinions. So we're not telling her what she should be doing. We need to hear from her to an extent first. So I agree. All right. Any other comments regarding the special event policy discussion?
1:09:29 Okay. All right. Executive Director Annual Performance Review. You want me to handle that? Yeah. Okay. So, basically, John needs to have his review done for last year. The recommendation from Scott is that that be done by the Executive Committee or members of the Executive Committee. So, we need to make sure we have a Performance Review Committee. We need to formulate that.
1:09:58 The recommendation is that that be made up of executive committee members. That's open for discussion. I don't know if anybody has an issue with that or not. John, how did we do it last year? I came on and so I wasn't quite familiar with the process. Last year, I believe it was myself. It's been an ad hoc committee in the past. It's been people raising their hand. You mean, yeah. Brent was Michael Brent and myself.
1:10:26 That did last year. All members of the Executive Committee, right? Yes, we were. I don't think that was by design, but it just worked out that way. Yeah, gotcha. Anyway, is there any objection to having to be members of the Executive Committee? Got a concern with anybody? No? Okay. You're not intending to make it. John? Yes, go ahead, Brent. So the only thing that just be cautious of is if it's the Executive Committee, those will be noticed meeting. We'll have to notice meeting with John because that's the Executive Committee.
1:11:03 created an ad hoc review committee. Are we going to run into Brown Act problems with four people of the executive committee doing this? Well, you run into following Brown Act because of the fact that it's a set committee, not an ad hoc committee. Yeah. Even though it's less than a majority of the board. It's a set committee that's ongoing. So maybe we should make it ad hoc. It can continue to be an ad hoc committee. We should have an ad hoc committee to avoid that, but maybe we should have
1:11:46 Three people who are on the executive committee and one person who is not. It doesn't need to be more than three people, does it? It could be whatever you want. I'm reading between the lines here as far as Scott's recommendation. I don't think he was saying that it has to be formally the executive committee that does it but members of as an ad hoc committee. I guess that's maybe the recommendation. Yeah, I think his recommendation was that it was the actual executive committee.
1:12:12 Well, then that's the item for discussion. That would be a standing meeting. I would agree that I think it's worked well as an ad hoc committee in the past, and if that gives us a little more flexibility, that's probably a good thing. And the ad hoc committee's responsibilities would be to get the information out to every other board member, and they fill out the evaluation form, bring it back together, talk about it, and then present the findings to the entire board? Correct.
1:12:43 Yeah, that's what we've done in the past. So, all right. If that seems kosher with everybody, I'm certainly willing to be part of that committee. We should have three people, I believe. Sorry, are we deciding that it's the executive committee or it's an ad hoc? Can't be the executive committee. Yeah, it should be.
1:13:07 Members, you can have members of the, you can't have the executive. But not the executive committee. Okay, I'll make a proposal. I would propose that we have, that it be four people in this ad hoc committee, two from the executive committee and two who are not. Just to clarify. Yeah, I mean, are you saying that it has to be two from, or no more than two from the executive committee? Because I don't know if we necessarily want to bar anybody.
1:13:32 I'm just saying, you're making this more complicated than I think it needs to be. Two people from the Executive Committee, two who are not. Okay? Period. Okay. I mean, I think we can live with that. Can't we? Yeah. Please? John, I'll be the second person. There's no objection. I'll be the second person from the Executive Committee if that's okay. I'll move that Eric and I be the other two.
1:13:55 Congratulations, Eric. Is that okay with you, Eric? Are you good with that? I'm in. Okay, so John, Sean, Paul, and why did I miss one? Eric, sorry. Eric, okay. Ooh, so quickly they forget. Yeah. That's because somebody else is playing there. We shall serve as the union motion. So yes, so there's a motion. That's a motion. Okay, do we have a second for that motion?
1:14:25 Second. All right. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Any other discussion? Aye. All right. You're good with that? Great. All right. Motion passes. So John, Sean, Paul, and Eric are the executive, excuse me, are the ad hoc committee for the executive director annual performance review. All right. Moving on to more.
1:14:50 Item six is MLT bylaws for review attached. And before we get into this, I'd just like to say that what we want to do here, because we do not want to spend a lot of time on this right now, there is a recommendation that, again, we should have another ad hoc committee, which we have had in the past. It's been a few years. But we should have a bylaw review committee, which
1:15:18 I believe also, yeah, so a bylaw review committee look into this, because this can get pretty complicated. If we do this as a board, we'll spend a whole meeting talking about the bylaw. So it's probably a better idea to have a B&O committee, which reports back to the full board for discussion. Absolutely. Does that make sense? That being said, comments? Can I ask a question? I don't see any mention of an executive committee in here.
1:15:52 As to what? In the bylaws? Yeah. Well, we've talked about the officers being an executive committee, and I'm just, you know, one of the reasons why this came up was, you know, I was one of the ones of asking, what is the powers, roles, and responsibilities of the executive committee? But, well, assuming that they're not there, that'll be discussion that this ad hoc committee can have and come back with recommendations. Perfect. Correct.
1:16:16 And I think that is a big piece of it as to what the roles responsibilities of the board members are, what the roles responsibilities and I guess the power of the executive committee. I think those are things that we want to get definitions down for so that it's comfortable with the rest of the board. Then you've got four people that are considered the executive committee to make decisions as needed. I think that given that we are regulated by the Brown Act,
1:16:43 We have to have, we have to be very clear on what an executive committee meeting an executive session can and cannot do. And we may have to consult with Andrew and or Tim in that regard because that's now become much more important than it used to be. So would the, I can, is it safe to say that the
1:17:09 Pleasure of the Board would be to have an ad hoc committee that would review the bylaws, and one of the main functions of the bylaw review would be to discuss the executive committee powers, et cetera. Does that make sense? Yeah. You want to rephrase it any way you want? I think we need an ad hoc committee to review the bylaws. And, you know, within the purview, that would cover anything and everything that are in our bylaws or need to be in our bylaws.
1:17:40 All right, that being said, you probably need a committee of, I would say, three, minimum of three. Do you have any volunteers for that committee? I'm going to nominate Cleland. Part is because she's not here. And Brent Truax. Part because she's not here, but she's also... Hey, I'm on the phone. She's versed in the brown eye, or so it seems to be. Brent, since you're on the phone, do you have any interest in serving on such committee?
1:18:13 I would be more willing to serve on such committee. Though I do think we need just think about giving a little direction to have committees formed. Do we want to detail everything or do we want to also more detail the set of policy that will detail everything? So the current trend in many boards has been making it policy not to review the bylaws because remember when we redo it, they can be reviewed back to state, et cetera. That committee is. What he's saying is it's not a slow process or it's not a fast process because there's a lot of back and forth to bring things back.
1:18:52 Can I ask a question along those lines then too? What is our status? We've talked about having some kind of alignment with the town council to make sure that the ultimate goals of tourism or meeting what they want to see us be doing, that kind of thing. I'm not sure if the bylaws would specifically play into something like that.
1:19:14 Not really. Bylaws tend to be the operating principles for the company. And to your point, we have that meeting on the 17th with them to talk strategy. But this really talks about the organization, the board. And it does talk about the responsibilities of the officers. It doesn't call them an executive committee. But on page 5, Article 6, it talks about the responsibility of chair, vice chair. But I do think we need to expand on those as well and what the capabilities are of that group. Okay.
1:19:46 Thank you for answering that. Yeah, we have that meeting on the 17th from 3.30 to 5.30. Well, trust me, I'll remind you guys a few times. I think Scott should be on that committee, not just because he isn't here, but because he's evinced an interest in that in the past. And that would be three people. If you want to expand it to four, I'll volunteer for it, because I think to...
1:20:19 A certain extent, you know, a legal background is going to be helpful. Well, and I would also suggest that once we get down to a final draft, we do run it through Tim Sanford as well. Oh, yeah, no, we should. But at this stage, we need to be sensitive to all those things without getting hung up by it. Is there any reason that Cleveland couldn't or shouldn't be involved in the bylaws, being a government official? I mean, is there any... I think...
1:20:43 We should give Cleland the opportunity to draw that conclusion. That's something that she's sensitive to. And if she draws that conclusion, then, you know, she could draw it. And we'd respect it. Yeah. I'm going to move that we create an ad hoc committee to review bylaws. And that committee is going to include Paul, Brent, Scott, and Cleland. Okay. Do we have a second? Second. All in favor?
1:21:13 Aye. Anyone opposed? Any discussion? Aye. Thank you, Brent. Motion passes. Excellent. And while we're on the subject of committees, we added item 7, that's TBID Appeals Committee. John, you want to go over that briefly?
1:21:28 Yeah, so basically what we've done in the past, so when we had the first round of the TBID from 2013 to 2018, we initially had the opportunity for business to appeal, and they could appeal based on their annual gross revenues being below $50,000 for Tier 3, between $50,000 and $150,000 for Tier 2, and then above $150,000, it's just paying the monthly TBID for your business. It's restaurants and retail, it's not lodging or the ski area that can appeal.
1:21:54 And the other reason that people could appeal was that they do more than 50% of their business from 93546. That first pass around, the intent was that we would review the appeals every year, but we didn't have it written in the bylaws. So once people appealed that first year, they actually were carried through the full five years. The way that we've written it now is that those businesses need to appeal each year. And so I've sent out the notices to the businesses that had appealed in the past.
1:22:20 And actually do have one business that has gone above the tier two mark that we'll be starting to remit monthly at this point. But one of the things that we need to do is we just need to have the appeals panel available to review the documents that I'm getting in from people, as well as any in-person meetings that we may need to have. And there are a few.
1:22:41 Caveats to it that I'd like to have a committee that can talk about and discuss how we handle certain situations, but the plan is that we will appeal every year kind of in that mid-September to end October time frame, and so hopefully we'll appoint an ad hoc committee whenever we need it at this point. I think if we can have a group that's willing to sit down probably next week sometime and talk about kind of our current...
1:23:07 process and make sure that we're in the right place and then we can also start to review some of the documents that are coming in. Then as documents come in when we're further down the month here we can take a separate set of three people to review those as well. So I guess the question would be if there's anybody willing to be the first kind of three, the first group of three to review the current process and then the ones that we have coming in right now.
1:23:36 I'd say that we probably have, and there are things like we have the exempt businesses, like the disabled sports. So the question is, do we need to go back and do we need to get them to prove that they're still a 501c3? Or if they were exempt before, do we consider them exempt moving forward? People aren't going to change their status like that. So with that, we would review the top, excuse me, the tier two and the tier three people. And it's probably at this point, 25, 30 businesses.
1:24:05 It's really not a huge amount. And I've noticed them all to say, hey, here's where you were last time. And if you can still prove that you're doing this much dollar or this much business from 93546, then it should be pretty easy to sign off on. But there are a couple of things we just want to touch base on. John, you mentioned next week. What's the time frame looking for this committee?
1:24:32 Well, I think the initial group I'd like to meet one time next week. It's probably, it could potentially be two meetings in the next month just to review what's coming in. I think if we can get everybody to submit their information, I think we'll be good. This first meeting there will be a little bit of heavy lifting because of the fact that we do have some question marks, you know, things like hair salons. Hair salons aren't part of the TBID because they're a service, but they do sell a limited amount of retail. Do we just lump?
1:24:58 salons into, as long as they're under $50,000 in shampoo and conditioner, that they're tier three and they pay $50, and then the rest of their business is exempt because they're a service industry. So there are some of those hybrid businesses that the town has asked me to identify or to define, and I think that's where I want the committee to help define that and set those parameters. Yes, I recall, I guess, we were on, was it, it was you, me, and I think it might have been Brent.
1:25:26 Okay, Brent. Maybe. Well, we rotated through the committee. It's not a standing committee. Yeah, you were on that, too. Yeah, Michael was involved. I mean, I think every board member was involved because they're ad hoc, so they tend to move around. Obviously, the appealing businesses are restaurant and retail for the most part. So we're basically looking right now for maybe three people for the initial group, right? Yes. Okay. I'll volunteer myself. I'll be happy to serve on that committee and meet a couple times. Not before. It's pretty painless.
1:25:53 Anyone else? Come on, Michael, you and me, let's step forward. Gomez is on that list. I may need a tier two. I may need to recuse myself. Are you not for problem? Yeah. I'm in. I'll help you guys out. Okay. I'm in. Who was the third? Sean? Sean? Yeah, retail and restaurant. That's why, yeah. So we've got one in front of each of us. Yeah, and I think unless there's any. I think if there's any sort of Sean Flick.
1:26:17 that you need to step out of, that's fine. Sean Flick? Sean Flick. Or John Flick. It could be a Sean Flick or a John Flick. I think this initial meeting, we just have to set a lot of the ground rules, and we will have some to appeal that have sent in info, but, you know. So do we? I think what Kirk might have been getting at that I have to get at, too, is that next week, with the fall break, we're out of town for most of the week. Oh, that's right. Yeah. Thursday, Friday, there's no school.
1:26:45 Yeah, so we're leading Tuesday. Wednesday. I don't know these things. I'm sorry, I just have kids in the system. Yeah, you do have kids in the system. So I say Friday off next week? Yeah, correct. Wednesday's a half day. Oh, good. So it means you get pushed for a week. Awesome. Cabo will never be the same. So then do we have a motion to appoint that such committee? Do we have a motion? We need a motion. Anybody want to make a motion? Motion.
1:27:12 All right. So we have a motion to appoint an ad hoc TBID appeals committee, which will be made of myself, Michael, and Sean. Second. Do we have a second? I'll second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. And opposed? All right. Aye. Thank you, Brent. It takes the most voice. It's a delay. Very good. All right. We are through all of our committee appointments. MLT team presentation. Laura, thank you for waiting.
1:27:42 Here we have a schedule, right? I'm trying. We have to tell 3.30. Yeah, we may actually. We have practice at 3.30. We may actually be right on time. He's wandering around, Mammoth, and AFR. Where is your microphone? I don't know. Yes? They're good. Start working on your divorce papers now. Get ready. Look at that picture. Okay. So, as I'm sure none of you have forgotten, we purchased a condo.
1:28:15 Back in February for the Crib Program. And we opened it to athletes on March 10th. So we wanted to come before you now and give you an update on how things have been going. In the past, we've run the Crib from March through October. So we're in the month when generally we'd be wrapping things up. But now with the full-time condo, we get to be open year-round, which is pretty cool.
1:28:43 Working on a few things for the winter. It's completely full this month and completely full through November and starting to fill up for December. So things are on a roll, which is great. So far, since we opened on March 10th, we've hosted 34 athletes and one member of the media. She was a writer for Outdoor Sports Guide magazine.
1:29:11 We've started decorating a little bit, personalizing it in there. We got jerseys from people like Dina, some of the cyclists we've had in there. Got those framed, hung them up on the walls. And it's been cool. We've had some good feedback. Some of the other athletes that have been in there got inspired by that. And Katie Hall, who I'll talk about.
1:29:35 One of the cyclists we had in there, she just donated a jersey because she thought it was so cool that we were doing that. So that's another great aspect of owning the place. We can really make it feel like an athlete house. And we've also been, I was just talking with John before the meeting, it's been a little learning curve with managing the unit. We've been working with Perfect Clean to kind of
1:30:02 You know, keep it clean, be our emergency contact. We've had a broken fridge, a broken sink, mice, a few little hurdles, but we've figured it out along the way, so it's been great. So these are some of the successes from our athletes so far this year. Obviously, 2018's not over. Des Linden, who...
1:30:30 Hasn't stayed in the new crib, but we worked with her before. She won the Boston Marathon. This year, we were able to capitalize on the video that we had put together with her. It got picked up by Women's Running. She's talking about training for the Boston Marathon in Mammoth Lakes. So that was a huge win for us back in April. Katie Hall, who I just mentioned, has just been crushing the summer cycling.
1:30:56 She's been first overall on the Tour of California, Tour of Gila, and the Joe Martin Stage Race. She is Olympic hopeful for 2020. We just shot a video with her. She was here a couple times throughout the summer and then just came back in September talking about her training here and how she's hoping to make it to the Olympics. That video we'll use now to send out to media, but that could be a critical piece if she happens to go.
1:31:25 does well. We can shoot that back out again, remind everybody that she trained here. Tom Scudins, who has stayed in the crib, has also had quite a few successes this year, Tour de France, King of the Mountain, stages five through nine, Tour of California, King of the Mountain, and stage three winner. And then Kun Nairt, which he is one of our international athletes, so is Tom's.
1:31:51 Kuhn is from Belgium, and he was first in the European Marathon Championships this year. So, pretty good so far. We've received coverage from these different media outlets. Like I mentioned, Women's Running picked up that Des Linden video. So, again, so far this year, we've received 13 placements, either athletes talking about training here, coverage of Mammoth as a high-altitude training center.
1:32:21 This translates to 62.9 million impressions with an ad equivalency of about 188,000. So one of the things we've really been exploring with the new crib is connecting with brands. We've started, when we have an athlete come in, we ask them who their brand sponsors are, we ask them if they can connect us to their social media managers so that we can cross promote.
1:32:52 with their sponsors. That helps them. That helps us. We reach more people. So these are some of the brands we've worked with. And I'm going to show a little video. Generally, a lot of the videos we've made for the crib have been highlighting the athletes. But we did have Velocio Clothing Company come in and do an ambassador summit. Uh-oh. Now it's not playing.
1:33:25 The Velocio story is an attention to detail. Business is really what sets Velocio apart. And I think that's a big part Brad worked so hard on is making really well designed that serves a pretty important purpose of making us happy as we ride on the bike. Like, we all just want to go out and ride in our kit all day long. Ambassadors and friends and, you know, kind of this extended Velocio family across the country, it was important to bring them together in a place that we could do a litmus test and look at, you know.
1:34:15 Do other people feel the brand in the same way that we do? We have an experience where we were riding every day, riding in a beautiful place in this convivial way and hear what they had to say. And we talked about those things. We talked about the sustainability initiatives, the fact that we're members of 1% for the planet, that some of our product comes from recycled Lycra. We talked about where the brand is going from a cultural perspective. Anybody who wants a better cycling experience to see this brand and to feel like they can be a part of it. It's been a really cool mix of everything.
1:34:48 It's first and foremost the camaraderie, getting the group together, hanging out. Just spending time together, riding together. Oh, there it goes. I heard it. Oh, I love you. Great food. We've had Chef Matt Agarino from SBQR. He's in town cooking up a feast. There's something that happens, you know, special on the bike when you're two by two going in on clothes. You're talking about the nuances. You're talking about, you know, what really works for you. And sure, you can have that interaction with Brad via email, via text, via phone call, but to do it.
1:35:25 You know, when you're live and in person, there's just something really special that happens. Hearing their perspective on everything from design to community engagement was incredibly beneficial. Getting to spend time together in a place like Mammoth Lakes and watch Brad, the CEO, like riding a bike like he was a little kid because he was just so happy. I'm proud to say that I'm a Velocio Ambassador and I'm proud to try to get other people in it because I know
1:35:55 Once you're in the clubs, you're going to love them. It's not just a sales pitch for me. It's really about passion and community. So that's just something else we're exploring with the crib is working with brands where Mammoth is kind of the background for their adventures.
1:36:37 They mentioned Mammoth Lakes briefly, but all this beautiful scenery. Just a way to expand our awareness that we are this high altitude training center. Let's see. And then in terms of social media, we've really found that having the athletes do takeovers when they're here increases our engagement on our social media channels dramatically. And these are separate social media channels from
1:37:09 The Visit Mammoth channels, just as a reminder, we have specific Mammoth crib channels. So since the crib opened in March, we've had 12 takeovers, total of 55 posts, and athlete followers reached was over 100,000, 109,000. So that's kind of been our...
1:37:30 Big approach on the social media channels is really getting the athletes involved, and they really seem to enjoy it. They have fun with it. They do their Instagram stories and show what they're cooking for dinner and why other things they're doing outside of their training here in town, like where they go and do their ice baths and that type of stuff. So it really seems to engage the audience. So in terms of this winter, obviously Mammoth Mountain has
1:38:00 corner on the ski and snowboarder market, so we don't want to reinvent the wheel or anything. We're looking at targeting some Nordic athletes. We have runners interested in coming in the winter because even if it's snowy up here, they can stay in Mammoth, they can go down to Bishop and run if the trails are too blocked with snow, but it's a real benefit to them to sleep high and train low.
1:38:27 Ski mountaineering is another thing we're exploring. Again, brand teams and athletes. We've also reached out to USSA athlete and coaches, and we've been talking with Ty Walker, who she was at the Sochi Olympics. She's a snowboarder. So in terms of this outreach, we are talking to some ski and snowboard.
1:38:51 coaches and athletes, and she's very interested in coming out this winter in January with several other of the Team USA athletes and staying at the crib, so we're currently figuring out the dates for that, and they're totally excited to create content for us and do, you know, what the crib program is all about. And we've also been talking with the Solomon Nordic team to potentially
1:39:18 Bring a group of athletes, their athletes to the crib. And again, create content around that, share on their channels. A publication that we've been talking with, it's called the Inertia. They're a surf, snow, and outdoor magazine. Again, they're very interested in working with us to create content to, you know, share our message. So a couple of things we have in the hopper. Right now, like I said,
1:39:46 In October, we have three Brazilian runners, female runners in the crib right now. They are pretty well known in Brazil. We're working on shooting, they don't speak very good English, so we're shooting a video with them in Portuguese that we're hoping to be able to share with the Brazilian Sports Association, do a partnership with that. So Michael's been helping us with that, talking to our Brazil agency and
1:40:16 Kind of seeing where we can go with that. In November, we have some Adidas athletes that they're coached by Terrence Mahone, which was Dina's coach. So they'll be here for all of November, more runners. Yeah, so things are progressing, and I think the investment was worthwhile. But let me know if you have any questions. Yes. I have a question and a comment. The comment is, wow, this is,
1:40:47 Personally exceeding the expectations that I had set forth for what this could mean to not only MLT but to the community and our reputation with these types of athletes. And I think the earned media speaks for itself. Great job. That's just amazing what's going on there and what you portrayed in the video. And I would just say in the winter it seems like you're going to have less demand on it because it's not so much the running sports.
1:41:16 Is that the endurance sports? Is that a fair? It depends. Because we're tapping into these other markets, I could see it definitely filling up. Maybe not totally full this winter, but as the word spreads. A lot of the athletes that I've talked with are really excited. They have never heard of a program like this. So it's just spreading that word. As this gets traction, I could see even demand on the second unit two years from now if it gets that much traction.
1:41:45 And gets so popular. The only kind of idea I had, and you guys are doing a great job, it would be for maybe to get, like have a, you know, of course if Eric's team could get their head around this, to have like a local ambassador day where you had, for example, let's say, Kelly Clark, Chloe Kim, and Maddie Mastro all there for one day, cooking, talking, snowboarding. That's a great idea. And all their channels involved and they do a takeover each one of them. I love that. Maybe we can.
1:42:15 Talk to Lauren up at the mountain. I know sometimes those guys are so big they're hard to wrangle, but I love that idea. Michael, to your point, I think that even though it's winter, I think we're in that part of the reason that we're such a successful high altitude training location is that they can stay in the crib at 8,000 feet or 7,800 feet and go down to Round Valley and run. So I think we still have the triathletes, the cyclists, the runners, but now all of a sudden we have the skiers, the snowboarders, the endurance winter.
1:42:44 crew, whether they're snowshoe racers or, you know, skier, snowboarders. Right, and tapping into their sponsorship products is brilliant. That's just brilliant. Nice job. Thank you. I like the focus on the Nordic.
1:43:01 I think that that's very brand specific and it has a lot of opportunity as well. We've seen some local Olympians that are part of Tamarack and could do something similar from that perspective as well. Yeah. I think that that's a really good focus for the winter as well. Yeah, and like I said, we kind of just with MLT and MMSA in general, how we try not to like overlap too much, you know, it's like you guys are doing ski and snowboarders.
1:43:30 Well, we don't need to step on your toes. Yeah, but I think it's a great suggestion that we ought to follow up with, you know, through Lauren and see how all those other athletes want to participate as well. But the Nordic for me is exciting to see on there. So I think it's great. Thanks. Any other questions for Laura? Thanks very much. I think I'm up next.
1:43:57 John, do you want me to just stay here? Just spin around in a circle. There you go. Yeah, go ahead. So just for communications and general PR, the SATW conference that we hosted in June, in the past two months, we've started seeing some great coverage from that. The September issue of Westways Magazine had a piece on Devil's Postpile that came from
1:44:25 The keynote speech that Deanna Doolin gave at that conference. So I was really excited. I ran into John and said, we just paid for the conference because the ad equivalency for that is about $53,000.
1:44:39 We've also been in the San Jose Mercury News, East Bay Times, and there's more in the works. Generally with these conferences, we see coverage for like a year, so this is just the beginning. So very excited. Once again, it's paying off. Fall coverage, we've had several media visits in September. We've also had coverage from LA Times. We just had a piece yesterday from NBC Bay Area.
1:45:09 So this comes from not only our agency, but also our partnership with California Fall Color, John Poymaru. Josh Ray goes out and takes photos and sends them out to the media, sends them to John Poymaru, and that kind of piques their interest, and they do a bunch of pieces on where to go now for fall color. And check out our Visit Mammoth Instagram page. I don't know if you've even seen it, but Josh got...
1:45:38 An amazing photo of the fresh snow with fall colors that's just like blowing up on our Instagram channel. So really good stuff. Michael, I wanted to go back to your comment at the very beginning about Elixir and the Warming Hut. We put together every winter and summer, we put together a What's New press release in conjunction with Mammoth Mountain.
1:46:05 So in this winter's What's New press release, we listed Elixir and Warming Hut, as well as first chair of food truck. And that got picked up by the LA Times last week. So we're already seeing some coverage for the new restaurants in town, which was, it's always exciting. And we've got more media visits lining up for the winter. We have a couple of people that we're putting on the first Denver flight. We have two at this time that we've booked.
1:46:36 Any questions? Thank you. Thank you, Laura. That's great. Ken, chamber update. Ken Bringle, Chamber of Commerce. Well, we've got a few things going on, so we're trying to keep up on. On October 16th, we'll be having our power lunch, and...
1:47:10 Don Condon with Ready for 100 and Regina Fellows with the Electric Auto Association will be talking about, you know, the Ready for 100 is trying to be like Aspen, 100% reliant on renewable energy as a community. And of course, there's an effort right now to do some additional charging stations for non-Tesla.
1:47:37 electric vehicles. And so they're going to talk a little bit about that on the 16th. And then the big meeting we have coming up on November 13th and 14th, Dave Meltzer with Sports One Marketing will be in doing our customer service training. We'll start with a luncheon. That will be from training for management for customer service. And then that afternoon, 3.30 to 6,
1:48:05 will be the frontline training, and then the next day, the 14th, will be, we'll do 9 to 1130, again, frontline training on customer service. We did have just got permission to release that we did get a USDA grant for $40,000 that will help us with our customer service and our business assistance programs.
1:48:33 And what that helps is with that money and then with what the funding we have from MLT, we're going to be able to put together, we think, some really good seminars now with Cerro Coso Community College that we can use their long distance learning and some other and be able to hopefully be able to use some of their expertise on management training, leadership, you know,
1:49:02 financial training, marketing, so forth. So we're really looking at kicking that up a little bit. Jeremy Goico with Black Tie Ski Rental is our chair of that committee. And we're currently in the process. We started September 25th, I think, and we've been advertising, we'll advertise through the end of October. We're doing our
1:49:30 Our third iteration of our virtual job fair, where we're doing it through Facebook and Indeed.com, both in portions of Southern California, Reno, and Tahoe, because we're really talking about a lifestyle purpose here. So we're getting that put together. I want to thank Mr. Rudder and his lovely wife Kathleen for
1:49:56 Being our newest President's Circle's member, because we're using the Polo Conference Center at Main Street Promenade, or do you call it Promenade at Main Street? I don't know what you... We don't care what you call us as lawyers. Call us. Okay, pass. But that's where we'll be holding most of our...
1:50:20 Power Lunches, then on December 6th, we'll be doing our Business Awards Gala there and may even end up doing a full sit-down dinner and stuff. And with that, we figure we can hold up to 160 people. So if we can get 160 people out, we'll be extremely excited about that. And if you have people you don't like, you can put them on the second floor.
1:50:45 You know, we've got some of our members have talked to us about the outside on the east side, the fall campaign, and we really started talking about it, and we haven't had a chance to vet it out with John and the MLT staff yet, but maybe that's something we as a regional chamber group could do, work with Lone Pine.
1:51:06 Bishop, Independence, even the volunteer chambers in Bridgeport in June to talk about how we're involved and promote that for the fall. And as you all know, Jessica, her last day was last week. And we went through and had a number of people, quite a few local that we have gone through.
1:51:35 I have made a selection for the membership and marketing manager, but I will not be able to make the announcement until next Monday. But we'll be moving fast and furious with that in the near future. So that's all I have. Thanks, Ken. Thank you, Ken. Congratulations on your grant. That's great. Thank you. That's great. Just a quick staffing update. Obviously, Ken just filled in.
1:52:04 Board that we do have a replacement for Jessica, which is great. And again, we've talked about the fact that Caroline will be joining us on October 15th. And with Whitney's position, we had more than 120 resumes come in from all over the country and frankly all over the world looking at the opportunity. What I did was I narrowed that down to about 18 that I considered that had some sort of hospitality background, tourism background.
1:52:30 So there was some direct tie to what we do here. And from that 18, I whittled it down to seven for first interviews. I did those up, finished those up on Monday. And from that, I have really a group of four that I'd like to see second interviews with. And what I'd like to do is similar to what we did with the directors of special events position, is I'd like to have a couple of maybe three people that are participating in the second interview process with the goal that we either have a
1:52:58 A clear direction where we get it down to two where we can bring some people in town to not only see the area and understand what it's all about, but also to meet the team and talk with the team. So I'd be looking for a few people. I think at this point I'm looking at Skype interviews and probably looking towards
1:53:16 Maybe the tail end of next week based on people's time to be able to get together and meet with those candidates and then hopefully get it narrowed down and be able to bring them out sooner than later with the idea of having that position filled by November 15th. Our agencies have been phenomenal, both really Marian Carson and Miles Media have been very, very helpful in the process and Megan and Josh have taken on a bunch of new opportunities in the last couple of weeks with Whitney gone and we'll continue that process until we fill the position.
1:53:46 We do have four very good qualified candidates. A couple of them are very familiar with the area. Not from the area, but a couple are familiar with the area. And then a couple are outside of the area that bring a pretty amazing pedigree. So I don't know if there are a couple of people that would like to volunteer to be part of that process because I think it's just a good way to go through and get some additional eyes on the candidates. Again, it would be Skype. It would just be probably in our conference room. Scott has...
1:54:14 Scott has asked to be part of that panel, obviously with his marketing background. I think that's a good piece. So if there are a couple more people that would be willing to give us some time, I don't think it would be, my guess is it's four one-hour interviews at this point. I'd be honored, John. Okay, thanks. I'd be interested, but that's not mandatory for me. I did want to recap something that I thought was interesting in the bylaws. It says contracts for all such personnel need to be approved by the board. I don't know if I want to be approved.
1:54:44 Reviewing and approving contracts, but just those of us who are going into the bylaws review, that might be a sentence to be changed in the future. John put me on the list for that as well. However, I am again out this next week. Right, I can adjust to that. With this school break. School just started. What's that? School just started. Don't even go there.
1:55:14 Let's see, do you have an update for Mr. Vanderhurst? Oh, sorry, so we have Scott, Eric, Michael, and did you? Yeah, please. Are you in or are you an alternate? I'm in. Okay, so I don't have a problem with four being part of that as well. Okay. Yeah, just Michael's traveling in India and South Korea this week with the Visit California sales mission, and he'll be back Friday. So traveling all over the world.
1:55:43 And just quickly, because we're headed into executive session here shortly, or closed session, the TOT and TBID update, I think you have the TOT info in front of you here. Since we last met, July has exceeded the previous record, which is fantastic. You know, it's a small increase over last year, but an increase over last year nonetheless.
1:56:03 And we have one more fairly sizable outstanding account for August. So right now we're about 7.4% behind. And my guess is we're probably going to be closer to 5% behind in August, which in the grand scheme of all the smoke that we had and all the issues that we had, I think that that's kind of a victory for us at this point. September, you know, we obviously won't have numbers for September for quite some time, probably a month, but I think that we had some good traffic. And actually October numbers looking at the occupancy report for this week.
1:56:32 It's been pretty busy. And I think we can stand to see some good numbers for October as well. The TBID information that I sent out to you last week was flawed. The town basically sent us the same information they sent us for July. Thank you, Mr. Clark. I just got the numbers from the town for August. And so July, we were about 76,000 ahead of the forecast. For August, we were about 24,000 behind the forecast.
1:56:57 So we're still about 9% ahead for the year, about $51,000 ahead in the expectations. So TBID and TOT are both looking good right now. One of the things I wanted to mention was the joint bucket funds were at $175,000 in the reserves for tourism right now. We're only $115,000 behind last year's.
1:57:22 TOT numbers for July and August, and we're almost a million bucks ahead of what was budgeted for those two months at this point, so that's a good way to start off the year. Cash flow, CDARS, we still have the $800,000 in Measure A and $2 million in the TBID CDARS. We have been invoiced by the Mountain for the winter, last winter's air subsidy, so we'll be cutting a check for $1.3 million in the next AP to cover that winter subsidy.
1:57:51 And that was money we took out of the CDARS for that. You can see the checking account balances there. Again, the joint bucket funds right now for the fiscal year, there's $175,000 in the bucket. And when we add the $370,000 that rolled over from last fiscal, it puts us right around $550,000 into that account. On the P&Ls, I did send those out, but obviously with the new numbers coming in from the town for the TBID, I just got those in my email right now.
1:58:20 So I'll make sure I get those out as well. Great. John, I just want to add, you mentioned invoice by the mountain. That invoice is cost from United in Alaska. It's a pass-through. And they were really late in getting us the information. So it was for last winter air subsidy. And we've finally gotten that reconciled. So therefore, we were able to submit the invoice to Mammoth Lakes Tourism.
1:58:51 Eric, do you have a quick update for you? Yeah, I have a quick update for you. One canyon is coming along nicely. For those of you that are aware, we have three escalators installed there. We lost one of the escalators on the road, but it is on the boat and should be here right around October 15th or 20th. It rolled in Mammoth.
1:59:17 in between the scenic loop and coming down to town, rolled over, hit a tree, and so we had to get a new escalator. Jesus. It's a bad story. Yeah, it's a bad story. It's going to have a good ending. Oh my God. This thing traveled all the way around the world and it crashes here. That's right, yeah.
1:59:36 We got our... Less than a mile from where I was going. Were they delivering something at Main Lodge and then going to Canyon? You know what? I actually don't know the answer if they were like coming down from Reno and came over the scenic loop or if they were lost and went up to Main Lodge and then came back down. I don't know. But you're still going to have at least two escalators open. So we have, there's four in total because there's two in each level.
2:00:04 And so all three are placed that we have right now, and we're just waiting for the next one. Once we get that in, we can button up the outside. We have a little extension on the outside of Canyon Lodge that will be more of a glass room, different sense of entry. And we're able to do the grading and all that work out in front.
2:00:26 But, you know, it's a two-year project. We've got a lot of the renovations inside. We'll be doing it after this, so that will be next year. But that's coming along nicely. We've got pavement down this last week, which we were excited to see, so it's a little different. We'll be able to open that up here shortly, the parking lot and the road.
2:00:47 And then the zip line's moving along as well. There's actually what they refer to as a chalk line pulled for the lower zip where you can actually see it's pulled to bring the rope, but you can see the trajectory and you see what's happening there. Anticipated opening? Anticipated opening would be October 20th.
2:01:11 So from last meeting, we haven't pushed that back yet. Who knows? We want to make sure it's safe. But we absolutely plan on opening it prior to as we want to get up and running and test it out and do all that. Eric, this is very exciting. How much will the mountain be charging for a ticket to the escalator?
2:01:34 Whole new attraction. Well, for locals, it's a different price. Will there be an escalator icon, Beth? Senior's going to get a discount. Oh, yeah. Oh, seniors need a discount. Seniors need a discount on that. Seniors have to pay extra for the escalator. Any other questions? Are we waiting for Tim? Yeah, we're waiting on Tim, so I guess I'd just go through. The key takeaway is, obviously, look at those. I do anticipate...
2:02:03 Danny Earl is getting me an updated report because, like I said, I'd like to see this bullshit being only 5% off in August, which would be phenomenal. But those are the numbers as they stand right now. On the future meeting dates, our next board meeting is November 7th. The one thing I didn't put on here for a future meeting date is that October 17th Town Council Strategy Session, and that's from 3.30 to 5.30.
2:02:25 530 on the 17th here. So I would just, I'll send out a reminder on that, but I'd love to have as much more participation as possible. And that's really us talking about kind of our current mission and then just to see if there are some adjustments moving forward as to how we can help the town achieve what they need to achieve through our organization. So. It starts at 3. Starts at 3.30. 3? You guys ask for 3.30. 3.30 to 5.30. And I have, and you.
2:02:52 You do have a meeting request in your email somewhere. Again, I'll resend it just to make sure everybody has it. And just to be clear, sorry, October 17th is which? October 17th. Yeah, 3353. I got that one. For the November 7th, will you be sending out a meeting invite or should we plug that in now? I'll send you. All right, with that, I see our council has arrived, so we will now go into a closed session.
2:03:22 John, before we do, if I can just say I will be recusing myself for this because I am actively pursuing a contract with the property owner for 2018. It's totally noted. All right, with that, we'll go into closed session. And Brent, I'll just call you on my cell phone. Okay. Okay. Thank you. All right, I'm going to go ahead and hang up on you. All right, thanks, John.
2:03:55 All right, so we are coming out of executive session, out of closed session. We have nothing to report from our closed session. That concludes our meeting. Do we have a motion to adjourn? Motion. Do we have a second? Second.
2:06:05 All in favor? All right. Anyone opposed? Thank you very much.