TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

· recording 2 hr 16 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

275 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

15:41 Okay, so we'll go ahead and call the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Meeting to order. Emily, do you mind doing a roll call? Present. Hello. Here. Here. All right, thanks, everybody. Appreciate some people filling in. I've been gone for the last...

16:15 Seems like the last six weeks and I appreciate a lot of the work that's been done and watching it from afar. So I appreciate the staff keeping me in the loop being out. We want to start with board member comments or any external committees that need to share anything. Anyone have anything that they'd like to discuss from the board position? I just want to say I'd like to repeat my request that at some point in the near future we institute a survey of TBID paying

16:44 Companies, actually, that literally starts an annual survey on how your board, how your tourism department is doing for you. Okay. Thank you. How would, you might ask me a question on that one? Yeah, please. We talked about that as with, when you originally had a contract of potential with hearts and minds. Do you see that as being similar, or do you see that as being a different request about being able to do a community survey in the community position that was originally discussed about a year ago? Yeah, I think I see that

17:15 I'm not sure if I ask. Let me actually phrase the response. I think whether it's part of that opportunity or if it's separate, I think that it would be important for us to have some kind of just understanding to at least establish a baseline for asking questions of what we could be doing better, what we're doing right, just of asking our... So a TBID pay survey monkey would fit your request if that was able to aggregate data?

17:44 versus like a full research project. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I think so. Just trying to clarify the request because I hadn't heard it specifically that way. Okay. Anyone else? Okay. How about public comment? If you want to speak publicly, please keep it to five minutes and address your name when you come up. No public comment. Just give you a quick meeting.

18:15 Minutes, so we have three separate minutes to approve, and I'd like to address each one of them individually to make sure that we cover those. The special meeting from September 26th, I was not present for that one. Did everyone have a chance to go through and look at the board packet and look at the minutes from that special session? I looked at them from Granicus, but I'm going to abstain from a vote just because I wasn't actually present for those minutes. Anyone have any questions about September 26th or any of the changes to that?

18:44 Scott, I think under the law, you don't have to be present for the meeting to vote on the minutes. You're a member of this board. Thank you. It may not be a rule, but it's... No, as long as you read them, you can vote on minutes. Okay. And as we're talking about this, I want to give kudos to Emily on the idea that if you guys have this digitally, the ability to click on your minutes or click on the highlighted links in the PDF to go right to something that's really helpful.

19:16 Anything on September 26th? Any motion to approve? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the special meeting on the 26th. Second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Unanimous? October 3rd, the regular meeting. Any questions regarding the October 3rd meeting? The regular meeting, as it were?

19:47 No questions or comments? Motion to approve? I do have one question, but it's more of a format issue. Is this the format that you were discussing in our workshop? As far as the way that they're listed for this meeting? You're talking about the October 3rd meeting? Yes. And I was not at that meeting. But I did watch part of it online.

20:19 So as far as I can see, they look really good to me. This is a format that I would be used to, but like I said, I wasn't at that meeting, didn't watch the whole thing, so I'm not sure if I missed anything. Right.

20:35 Form wise, though, that's the format that you're referring to that we drive consistency with the town council meetings as well as this meeting. I think you could even shorten it up a little bit, but we can talk about that later if you want. There's some things that could just be left off unless you guys feel that it's necessary. It sounds like that role has been approved to move forward so we'll actually have someone from.

20:56 Town that will actually be doing the minutes moving forward. Yes, absolutely. And those were done by Jamie, the October 3rd meeting minutes. So it makes sense that it's the same, right? That was my only question. Thanks. No, thank you for that, though. Okay. Motion to approve? Move. Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Abstain. Okay, unanimous. Abstain. Abstain for Cleland. And then we have the closed session October 18th.

21:28 I move we approve the meetings, minutes for the 18th. Okay. As presented. I second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Unanimous. Okay, thank you. Three sets of meeting minutes all approved. So moving to new business and we're going to start off with our committee assignments.

21:53 One of those things about when you aren't present, you get nominated for things. So I believe I'm now on the bylaws committee. It's nice to see. So bylaws committee we have, just to clarify, we've got myself, Brent Turax, Cleland Hoff, Paul Rudder. We're all good with that. The second one is we have the Mammoth Lakes, the MLT and Town of Mammoth Lakes contract. That again would be continuing to be myself, Paul, and Eric, if we're good there. On the TBID appeals panel, we need to assign a,

22:24 Three new volunteers for next week to go through and look at what has come in on TBID appeals. I believe, were you on the last TBID appeals? Yeah, Sean, Michael, and Paul were on the first committee. You can serve again. It's just that it is an ad hoc committee, so I just need three board members. Are there appeals? Yeah. Well, it's almost the renewal of the folks that were appealed for the first five years. So we just keep getting in the folks that had appealed the first time around. So the group that you saw last week was specifically who had come in by that date.

22:55 So what's the scope of, like, from a, since it's a one-time ad hoc, we have scope of work, can we talk about a couple of hours? No, no, God, no. I think we've probably got, I think we've probably got, for this one, we've probably got five or six appeals that should be pretty straightforward. So it's probably a half hour to 45 minute meeting. Okay. So. I'm happy to participate in that. I haven't been through that process before. Yeah.

23:19 John, are any of the appeals businesses that I'm affiliated to? No, the Mountain Appeals came in in the first round, so, yep. We decided against all of it. I'll step up. John, are any of the people appealing my tenants? That's a good question. I don't think so. Yeah, well, you know. Right away, someone's going to say, oh, you have a conflict. Yeah.

23:43 Any of the people appealing my constituents. Now you're going to be different. So is that, if there's no attendance, Paul, you're okay? If you need somebody to do it, I'll do it. I think that's...

23:58 McGuire, Clark, and Rudder. Oh, no, no, no, no. Michael has indicated the desire to... No, no, actually, I've participated, and I appreciate you stepping up, and I don't want to hog the committees. Which brings us to our next point, which is the Executive Director Performance Review, which was Morris, Turner, Clark, and Rudder in 17. So we need to have...

24:23 That was on that, wasn't I on that committee? Yeah, I was not on that in 17. No, this is for fiscal 1718. Oh, reviewing the performance of 1718. Correct. Okay, gotcha. And Michael, you were on the contract, not the review. I see, okay. At least that was the initial. So remember last meeting, we said it was going to be two executive committee, two non-executive. And so then what I'd like to propose is who's going to be

24:51 to go forward and do a review and contract simultaneously to simplify the communication process since they're overlapping and they're quite delayed. So I propose we have the same people do those two, contract and review at the same time if that's acceptable. So we consider them. Is that from an efficiency standpoint? Yep. So that we talk about reviewing the goals from last year, setting the standards for the goals for this next year for the contract based off of what we know today.

25:20 Given that we don't have a contract with town and there's some intent from town, it sounds like, to not have a long-term contract until we go through a destination marketing overview plan, then those goals, from my understanding, based off our board vote, would be directed by the goals that were set forth by this group, the 12-month financial plans, some of the things we've talked about in that area. So are you okay, Mr. Ledesma, with coming into that?

25:48 Yeah, you're saying take D and E and put them to smash them together? And basically have the same group and do them concurrently. So do the review, take what's come out of that review and set the goals and the contract for the next year. I'm in. So does that put six people on this committee? Two, three, four. No, I'm saying that I don't believe that that is... Some people drop off, right? Is that actually in current for your review today?

26:10 Was that approved or was that prior? That's what my question was. No, this is what was nominated last week to be the review committee. Sorry, I missed that. John Morris has offered to head that up, and I think that's the biggest challenge with all of these. I think we need someone of the board members to call the meeting for the bylaws. I think that's where we're not getting progress. So then you have Morris, Turner, Clark, and Rudder. You guys have already accepted to be on the review for last year. In the last meeting we did. Yeah, and Morris has said that he will coordinate it because

26:40 Again, there was nothing moving with it. Okay, my misunderstanding. Yeah, and then this was prior, and Colin Fernie was on this as well. If you want to try and combine these two, then that's fine. I think that that can go all right and just be the four people that are on the review committee. So with Sean and Eric and Paul, Sean's not here, are you guys okay taking on the contract component in addition to the review for that committee? I think that makes sense. Okay.

27:11 You just got a total pass. How did that happen? I'm stepping forward. So am I out or am I in? You're clear. I'm out? You managed to avoid all this. I'm taking steps forward here. So I'm not on this committee. That's correct. So the review committee will take on the contract as well. We're going to make it as draconian as possible. Yes, of course. And who would like to? I wouldn't expect anything less. And if Morris is leading that, then John will also take on the contract and calling that.

27:41 The lead for the TBID Appeals. Well, TBID Appeals, I think if we... That's you. Who was... You were going to be on there? Paul and who? And Eric. Paul, Eric, Scott. And then the MLT contract, I assume you'll take that one? Correct. And then bylaws, we just need someone to be the lead on that. Maybe the lawyer's a good one to have on that one. Paul, do you mind taking the lead on the bylaws committee?

28:10 You're on it, but you don't mind taking the lead on it and making sure that it gets scheduled. Can I get help from your staff to, you know, put out stuff and so forth? Yeah. Okay? Yeah. Okay, yeah, as long as I don't have to do it all on myself. Yeah, no, we'll work with you. Oh, don't worry.

28:26 Cleveland, I'm a professional worrier. And the TBD appeals panel doesn't need that. I'll send that info out. If you have something that needs worrying, just turn it over to me. The only other thing that I wanted to mention in this category, which doesn't need an ad hoc committee, is that we are, in working with the auditors, we're finalizing the annual audit. One of the things that we figured out during the process of the audit is that we don't have a current contract with the chamber.

28:50 The Chamber contract expired June 30th, and even though we've approved the funding and we've approved the increased funding for the Chamber, we don't have the contract with them, and I think that was held up because of our Town contract not being in place. So there's a little chicken and egg there. We do have it on next week's agenda for the Chamber, and Brent being the lead for that. We will review the contract at the Chamber meeting next week, and then Brent will bring that contract to the Board for approval at our December meeting.

29:19 Where does the committee for interviewing the marketing position fall in here? I figure since we're done with that process, I didn't put it on here. Okay. Yeah. But thank you to both you and Eric for being part of that process. And I think that really at this point, I just need to get feedback from the two of you. We've got our staff meeting tomorrow to talk about feedback from the staff. And I have feedback from Jeremy and Camille as well who were involved in the process.

29:44 Amanda's actually going to contact both candidates this week as well, and then hopefully by Friday we have a decision and a direction and make an offer. Okay. So thanks for being part of that. Can I make the suggestion that the three of us get together and we deliver that feedback in a verbal setting? Absolutely. Versus a form? Yep. Is that okay? Or would you rather? No, I would prefer that. Okay.

30:10 style as well. And my team has an evaluation form, kind of pros and cons on each candidate that I've asked them to fill out so that I can see the feedback prior to us getting together as a group tomorrow to talk about it. That's great. You want to talk about the TBID appeals? Yeah, the TBID appeals, so like we mentioned, last week we had a meeting with Sean Turner, Michael Desma, and Paul Rudder, and a lot of that group did a lot of the heavy lifting for setting up the future appeals.

30:40 We had a few things that we wanted to talk about. We did have 12 businesses that were appealing in that first round. And like I said, I think we have four or five, six that are in this next round. And some of the things we talked about at our last board meeting, if someone was exempt, a 501c6, 501c3 in the first go-round, are they exempt moving forward? The committee decided that, yes, they would continue to be exempt for nonprofits or service industry.

31:04 We also decided that the P&L reports are admissible for Tier 2 and 3 appealing businesses based on their gross revenues. We did have that with the Mountain. Obviously, you know, we really can't look at a tax return for the Mountain and figure out what the daily grind is in the big picture, so we really needed to look at the P&L on that. We also determined that service businesses with minimal retail

31:29 would be excluded. They would be considered service, not retail. And the example there are hair salons. You know, sure, they sell shampoo and conditioner, but not to the tune of anything that we really need to go even make them a tier three at 50 bucks a year. They are a service business. They happen to hold two licenses, a service license and a retail license, but the retail is pretty minuscule. So that was decided to keep them where they were from 2013 to 2018 as service, not retail.

31:58 And then we had a couple of businesses around in the 2013 to 18T bid that had collected data to show the majority of their business was local. And we've decided that we would continue to do that process where they will collect in the month of January, one of the busiest TOT months, and the month of May, one of the lowest TOT months. They will track every transaction.

32:20 Put down the amount of a transaction and then they will put down the zip code from that. So if it's $122, 93546, at the end of each of those months we'll figure out what the percentage local versus percentage out of town is and we'll determine whether they fit into that tier two category. So in the first go around we did it, it was four months that they needed to collect.

32:42 And we felt that that was a little bit draconian. So we decided that we're going to go to two months, but we're also going to make a 2019 collection. And then again, they're going to do it in 2021 just to see if their mix changes. Because obviously the goal of the TBID is to bring in more visitors, which should change some of the metrics. So the appeal panel decided that that was the direction to go with those businesses. And both of those businesses have been contacted. John, didn't we ever pay attention to the fact

33:12 That, for instance, as an example of Daily Grind, I understand it's a separate business, but I'm concerned about the idea that all of its revenues go into one tax return. You know, it doesn't feel like it's a separate business because of that. We had a few of those businesses, like Snow Creek, we had the Golf Course Pro Shop, we had the Westin with their little sundry shop that they have in the lobby there, so it's a bigger picture, but it's a smaller...

33:41 portion of their entity. I could give you a different way that it's bifurcated in the sense that we actually have to have a different doing business name for the liquor license. So it's actually a different name so that it can have the appropriate liquor license. So you're saying there's an independent entity that is holding the license.

34:05 MNSA or blah, blah, blah. It's some separate entity. Daily Grind has a license. Campo has a license. So there's actual entities that are set up. An actual entity. But that entity is wholly owned by the mountain. I mean, I'm not really concerned about being wholly owned. I'm concerned about if there's one tax return that suggests that it's not an independent entity. And I'm worried about somebody coming along and saying,

34:32 Why are you treating it that way? You see what I'm saying? I'd almost feel more comfortable if we referred to council and got an opinion. Your guys in Sacramento must have, you know. They don't because we're the only ones that are restaurant retail. Oh, right.

34:49 So they don't necessarily have a purview on it. We have to charge them for our opinion. That's right, exactly. We have to teach them what to do. Yeah, so we are, you know, in that sense, we are uncharted waters to a certain extent, but that's how we handled it in 2013 to 18 is that we had those, they were kind of subsections of a business that were separate entities on a business license. And would the airport concession be another? Yeah, so the three that we had for the mountain, we had the Daily Grind, which is the coffee shop at

35:17 Juniper Springs, the Village Honor Bar at the Village Lodge, I think, and then the hangar down at the airport. So, and the hangar, the hangar moved up to tier two, so you owe us 500 bucks now. You'll be making 100,000 any day now. I'm looking forward to that. Yeah, right. Yeah, so then, and I think that, I think that, you know, same thing with Snow Creek.

35:48 Golf isn't included as a service, but the retail store is included, and that's why they appealed on the retail side. I personally don't have any issue with it. I'm just concerned about, you know, in the future, if somebody comes along and says, why are you treating this as a separate entity? It's owned by the Mammoth. It'd be really nice to have an opinion of counsel in a file so we could say, listen, that question came up.

36:16 And here's how we dealt with it. We got this opinion and it says it's appropriate to treat them this way. Yeah, I just think the reason why it is being treated is we have to separate it for other laws that's related to liquor. And the honor bars are great. I mean, that's just in-room stuff that we do at the Village. So it is, I understand your point. I don't know the answer. But I also know that

36:43 There's certain laws that govern us to make sure that they're separate. And maybe that takes care of the issue. I'm not suggesting for a moment that it doesn't. I'm just a little concerned that we need something in off file that we can point to if someone ever raises a question about it. It's not an arbitrary decision. There's some guiding principle. Let's you and I talk about that and figure out who can give us that opinion because I'm not sure that Civitas may be able to.

37:12 But again, that's not their retail and restaurant and appeals really don't fall into anything that they do. No, I hear what you're saying. Let's talk about it. Because it's the kind of base you want to cover where somebody comes along and makes a big fuss about it and makes you look like you don't know what you're doing. Right. I can't imagine who that would be. We did, from finally on the appeal panel, we did have a couple of businesses that we went back to to ask more.

37:40 detail on, and they were businesses that appealed back in 2013 as well, so we went back for a couple of those businesses to say, they're both businesses that have big accounts in town, and so it's easy enough to show us what's your account revenue, what's your total revenue, it's more than 51% of the 93546 accounts. One got back to us, one has not. But we did go back and ask them, because we had one business come to us and say, we're appealing based on the same thing as last year. It's like, well.

38:09 Okay, we still need the numbers, because it was five years ago that the appeal happened, so we need to see those numbers, but I think we're fine with that. That's it. Good. Okay. Next up, then, we have a presentation from Marion Carson. Yeah. Dave, if you want to... I'd love to introduce our team here, so we've got...

38:28 Andrea joining us from SMARI. We've talked about SMARI quite a bit. They are our research and data company out of Indianapolis. We've got Amanda, as you've all met and heard on the phone or in person a number of times. And then Dave Maring is also joining us today to go through some of the partnership pieces that we've done over the last five years and looking forward as well. So with that, I'll turn it over to Andrea. We're going to talk visitor profile. Sure.

38:52 So I do travel and tourism research. All of my clients are tourism destinations. We use similar methodology that I'm going to go through with you today. For instance, we're doing a project right now for Gulf Shores in Orange Beach, Alabama, which is very different from you, but we use the similar methodology. We do research for Visit California, Los Angeles, Palm Springs, Chicago, Dallas, probably some places that you've heard of.

39:20 A lot of the methodology is very similar, even though the approaches, the marketing is different. We do visitor profiles, we do advertising effectiveness, and Marian Carson will talk more about the results there. As the name suggests, this is the visitor profile, which is a profile of your visitors. My goal here when I present research is to not put anyone to sleep, so I'm going to try to make it fun.

39:46 I could peek out on this, and if you have questions, I will try to answer them quickly without putting anyone to sleep. So one thing to keep in mind with visitor profile is that we're talking overall visitors. We're not talking about ad-aware and unaware, which they'll cover. This is just the entire group of visitors.

40:04 When we look at visitor profile, we don't do it several times a year. We do it every few years. It's a less frequent measure, and it's over a larger population. So the changes that we see from one visitor profile to the next tend to be pretty subtle. We look through a lot of the data, and it's not any different year over year because why would it be? It takes a long time to make changes in a larger population. So the things that I'm going to point out to you today are the things that are different because that's what's more interesting and more fun.

40:34 Our goals and methodology, we look at the visitor data so that we can hone marketing efforts because some of this you have some control over through your marketing. We look at exploring seasonal visitation and how it's changing, the appeal of the destination, why are people coming here, are they doing different things than they used to do, are they coming for different reasons than they used to? And some of the variables to keep in mind that have ongoing impact, as you all are very well aware, is the weather, which to my knowledge, we do not control, but we do have to respond to.

41:03 And then budget, which we have some control over, but that's also another explanatory variable that comes into play. Just a word quickly about the methodology. We did 1,500 surveys with travelers in California and Nevada, visitors and potential visitors. And then toward the end of what I'm going to talk about, we'll talk additionally about some surveys that we did specifically with air visitors. Okay? All right.

41:27 Everyone's still awake. Yay. Okay. Familiarity is growing and it's the first step to visit consideration. The reason we care about familiarity is because people seldom visit places that they have not heard of. So we want to keep our eyes on what's happening here. And again, I mentioned subtle shifts. So what we have, if you look year over year with Mammoth Lakes, you've got a subtle shift and it's so subtle that I used an arrow to point it out. People knowing a fair amount about the destination to knowing a lot about the destination.

41:57 And that's things like maybe someone has come one time, they've done some, they know one season, they have an experience of one element of the destination versus they are frequent visitors and feel like they know a lot. People who know a lot tend to be more engaged, they stay longer, they spend more, they explore more.

42:19 Can I ask a question then? Of course. Any idea why Yosemite and Bear Mountain would actually go down? Well, that is an excellent question. It may be relative to, particularly in Bear Mountain's case, their marketing. We don't know what their marketing is or where they're marketing. We're looking specifically at California and Nevada. Yosemite really didn't change a whole lot. It may be...

42:47 Familiarity with the destination itself. Maybe people know Yosemite, but they don't necessarily, your visitors in particular aren't exploring that destination. That's a good question. Okay. And you all may know more about that since they're proximate to you. And this is specific to our visitors. Correct. So it's not general visitors. It's not just any outdoor traveler. It's your visitors. So this is specifically Mammoth visitors, so that's why there's also maybe...

43:13 The Mammoth visitor may be less aware with fail because we're talking a specific person here. It's not all ski visitors. Right. Your out-of-state places are kind of staying low, which is good, right? It's good. I would like to keep that. In terms of visit intent, which is kind of the next step along the process, once you're familiar, then you have an intention to visit. We ask people, we say, okay, how likely are you to visit these places in the coming year? And we show them a five-point scale.

43:40 One is I'm not at all likely to visit. And as you can see, the top two boxes are very likely to visit in the coming year or I'm already planning a trip. So those remain very high for Mammoth Lakes. And you can see year over year they continue to lead. Every other destination except Lake Tahoe is on the decline. So this is a positive result. We do know that Tahoe is instituting a new marketing campaign. So that's why we're going to keep an eye on that. Don't know exactly which markets they're in.

44:08 Probably some of the same ones that you are. Looking demographically, last time to this time, again, a lot of this is the same. Gender didn't really change a whole lot. Your visitors have gotten somewhat older. Marital status is very similar. Your visitors have become better educated, which isn't to say that they specifically have become better educated, but the overall visitor population is better educated and more affluent. So this is a higher quality visitor.

44:37 That really seems to speak to the fall visitor, older, more money. Right. Yes. I'm just going to show you the data and then you can extrapolate back to your marketing since that's your strategy. But yes, that is consistent with what I'm seeing. What is the seasonality of the data sample though? We do actually three, or excuse me, we ask people over the whole course of

45:01 So we get people from all across and in a little bit I'll break out some things by season. Are you interested specifically in the demographics by season? No, I was just curious to John's point, as the 1,500 people that we asked, were they here in the winter or were they here in the summer to be as clear as possible? We have about a quarter of your visitors who come all the time. That's multi-visitors or two seasons or more. And then we pull those out so that they don't skew purely winter, purely spring, summer, fall.

45:29 And winter visitors are younger, more affluent, skew somewhat male. Fall visitors are older. The multi-visitors, I believe, are the most affluent. And summer tend to have more children. Those are just some data points that I'm... Remember. Yes. And Eric, we have that in the full visitor profile. So this is kind of an executive summary. We have the full profile that we can share with you. Yeah.

45:52 It's really long. It's really long. There's a lot of it. This is fun. This is fun. What? This is fun. And please don't laugh at my graphics, because I'm a data person, and those are my graphics, right? This is not the slick ad agency presentation. Okay. Another thing that we ask is your brand pillars. We ask these seven. We give them a five-point scale. We say, how strongly do you agree that Mammoth Lakes is a destination for outdoor adventurers?

46:22 Don't agree at all. Disagree strongly. Five and four are strongly agree and right below that. So you have 90% of your visitors who agree that Mammoth Lakes is a destination for outdoor adventures. And if you continue down the line, I mean, this is really high agreement even if you look at the very last one. Mammoth Lakes has an otherworldly natural landscape that's 78% of people agreeing. It's hard to get 78% of them.

46:43 People to agree on anything, as we know, from yesterday. But these are really positive results. So what this says is that your brand pillars are reflective of people's experience of the destination. They're consistent. They're in line. And this is my first visit here, by the way. And yeah, these are spot on. I was oohing and aahing all the way up the road yesterday. Looking at visit frequency, when we looked at your visitor profile in 2016, you had about half of people visiting one time.

47:11 About a quarter visiting twice. When we look now, you have a significant increase in one visit, 57%. Notice that the pie is bigger, so your one visit people are not cannibalizing your five plus visit people. Also keep in mind that 2016, the snow never stopped, so people just kept coming back, right? So what this shows, though, is that as you're broadening the piece of the pie, you're bringing in new people, which is good. So you're not driving away old people, you're bringing in additional people.

47:41 Do you happen to know anecdotally, I know we talked a little bit about this last night, that one visit and how that trends towards millennial customers versus non-millennial customers who are seeking more of a single experience and moving on versus... I can find that out, that's knowable, but I do not have it lodged in my brain. I can touch on that a little bit because we completed a millennial study a year ago and what the data showed, which was, you know, not...

48:10 Totally surprising based on what we've been hearing is that that audience, that particular millennial audience has a different kind of pattern than the generations that preceded them. So they're less likely to want to go to the same place over and over again. They are very big on if you ask them what they expect from their travel, they want new experiences, new exciting adventures. They want to try to go to as many places as possible.

48:37 You know, when I was younger, we would go to the same place every summer with our families and things like that, and that is not their pattern. And so what that means for you is as the millennial audience becomes a more and more important part of your audience, millennials today are the largest segment of family travel.

49:00 in the marketplace, which is shocking to me because I always still think of millennials as being, you know, young, living with their parents in their basements, but that isn't the case. They're having children and they're traveling as families. And so what it means to you is that you're going to continuously have to be expanding your audience because you're not going to get as much perhaps repeat visitation from the same people that we used to get in the old days. So the pie has to.

49:28 As she mentioned, the pie has to keep getting a little bit larger. And the other thing it says is that you have to continuously give them new reasons to come back. So it isn't enough if they come and say, I had a great time. It's going to be equally important to continuously say to them, here's something new that we're offering or a different type of experience that you might not have considered the first time. So it's a challenge, a marketing challenge.

49:55 If you're a restaurant and you've got someone that comes in on Saturday, you want them to come in on Tuesday and Thursday, but if you have a consumer that's like, I ate in your restaurant once and never coming back and you have to always get a new person to come to your restaurant, it's a totally different strategy. Exactly. I think that's something as an organization we're going to face over the next decade is that just based off of industry trends and market trends beyond our control, we're more likely to have this next generation of travelers come here, come in and be a one and done. They might come once a year or once every other year.

50:25 And that's going to be a different strategy than saying, how do we get that person to come up three times to come up six times? Yeah, and we're seeing this with, as an example, one that would be a parallel, I think, to you guys, is that we represent the city of San Diego, so San Diego Tourism. And if we look at our historical tracking of visitation from Los Angeles, which is our biggest, you know, pot to draw from, it used to be that you would see, you know, the average number of trips that somebody who lived in Los Angeles who was

50:54 inclined to go to San Diego might take three to four trips per year, you know, because it's easy, it's convenient, all of that. Nowadays, we're seeing that number drop to one to two times per year. So to your point, we've got to make up that difference, right? Like that's a big chunk of people. It's our number one feeder market and they're reducing their visitation by approximately 50%. So we've got to go out and find new customers.

51:20 To fill that gap. And it's a trend that we're all going to have to face over and over again with that particular audience. Dave, you've indicated that, you know, we need to offer new experiences to get people to be repeat visitors. Do we need to do something different in our marketing? No, it's more about the things that we choose to talk about. Yeah, yeah. It's not just, don't just keep saying the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result, you know. So it's constantly give them new things to see.

51:50 Talk about different things. And so much of that can be done on your website and through native and through social and all of that. It's really less about your big advertising and more about your granular stuff. And I think it goes to the first visit or the one visit people. Even though we may not get them back or they may come back cyclically every other year or something, or they may come back for a zip line or via ferrata or whatever's new events, we need to continue to offer something that they're going to come back for.

52:18 But the other side of it is we need to have them have the experience where they go home and they tell their friends that they have to come up. So they're helping us fill the funnel even if they're not going to come back. And I think that one visit, it'll be very interesting to see where we are when we do this again in 2020 based on Altera, based on the Icon Pass because you're going to have a lot of one visit people that are coming from Chicago or Houston or Colorado or wherever. And again, we want to get into their system. You know, when I worked in Colorado, you looked at Steamboat. Steamboat was an every three year.

52:47 resort. People would go every three years. Jackson Hole is the same way every three, four years. Vail is an every year resort. You know, we want to get into that cycle so that we get the people that are planning their trip out west and they're saying, okay, we went to Steamboat last year, let's go to Mammoth this year. Three years later, we see them. But again, having them have that experience and go back and say, you have an icon pass, you got to get out and see what Mammoth Lakes is all about. Or same thing in the summer, you've got to get out there and check this place out. That's the word of mouth that we need.

53:13 I had a quick question on that. It's also far more expensive to market a new customer than it is a repeat customer. I will tell you that roughly three times. But is there a wash effect, too, or is this all Southern California market? In other words, are there people from Colorado that have gone to Vail? Yeah, yeah, no. I think John touched on that. It can work both ways for you, right? So as an example, yeah, we may be able to not depend on

53:41 one particular market to feed us like they used to with the same frequency because that group, that millennial group is moving age-wise. Their earnings are going up. They're becoming more settled. And so they're going to travel more, right? They're going to travel more. So likewise, we should be able to generate more travel.

54:03 from that audience, from other places. Yes, absolutely, where they didn't consider it before because their same perception will exist in their market. They'll be like, hey, do you really want to, you know, we're going to go to Utah again? You know, let's try something different. And so that can work for you too. But it's still about getting new customers, yes. Because you have to market customers in Colorado. That's right, that's right. And the good news about that is that

54:31 You know, if there is good news, is that through digital, there's a lot of ways to reach those people that aren't super expensive. Like, in the old days, what that would mean is, oh my God, we have to go buy TV in a new market now. And you don't have to do that now.

54:43 Well, and the strong thing we are seeing about Mammoth Lakes as a whole, because of the board's decision coming together in May and making the focus on quality visitation, not necessarily over quantity visitation, as you'll see in the second presentation when we talk about the AdWare visitors, you know, the decision to dig into fall or the decision to invest more into summer is really also that opportunity where we can hit the millennials in the right seasons and then that older demographic who's staying longer, spending more. We're starting to see ourselves even out where...

55:12 That could be a challenge for some other destinations. But again, a great investment and decision really of this organization to plan for the future. You probably can take this information from the mountain, but I would imagine that you look at the behavior trends and getting someone that says, okay, there's a certain level of comfort, no Mammoth, but I want to come for different experiences. Like when I first came to Mammoth, people came and they skied for three days, bell to bell, and they went home and they came back two weeks later and they skied for three days, bell to bell.

55:40 That mindset has shifted. People want to come up and like, I'm going to ski for one day and I'm going to go dog sled one day and then maybe I'm going to go down the climb. And so having more seasons, our repeat customers are probably more likely to be, I came and skied for the winter and I'm going to come back and I'm going to do a photo program with Josh for fall colors and then I'm going to come back and I'm going to try fishing for the first time in spring versus, there is a cost to that. I think as we start thinking about long-term planning, like,

56:06 There's some things that conventionally as we think about our budget and how we spend, what that target is, it's not going to be as easy as like, well, we're just going to get, you know, we get this many people and if we can get them to come three times as much than they have been in the past, we're golden. Like that's, that era has shifted. That exact point, Scott, has allowed, we've been focusing on unique visitors. Where is our unique visitors and how are we increasing those because of those reasons that you just talked about? Well, I think that talks to our,

56:35 Local marketing plan is to get that merchandising out. We've done it with the events where we put up the

56:41 the 2019 event poster in November, so that when people are here in the winter, they're looking at it and saying, hey, we need to come back for Balooza, or we need to come back for Village Fest, this margarita event looks great. So I think that that's where our opportunity is with new visitors coming in the wintertime is to have them say, wow, I didn't know this place was so close to Yosemite, or I didn't know that you had a national monument here, or I didn't know you had zip lines and whatever. So I think there's that cross-marketing piece that back in 2010 when I came here, we had a summer visitor guide and we had a winter visitor guide.

57:10 We weren't cross-selling the seasons at all. Now we have the four-season visitor guide so that when the winter visitor is here, they see summer. When the summer visitor is here, they say, wow, I can't believe how big this mountain is. We should come back. Or that they're snowmobiling or whatever. So that is an opportunity. We totally commandeered your data. That's fine as long as you're awake. That's my goal. All right. So.

57:32 Visitor origins, we were just discussing this, so they're similar directionally, but we have growth from other markets, so that other DMA on the far end is now taking up a larger share of your visitor origins, and that group includes Yuma, El Centro, Bakersfield, Palm Springs, Monterey, and Chico Redding. So you're drawing people from other DMAs that you haven't been to the same extent. Visitation is evening out throughout the year, and so you see I...

58:03 Tried to make the bar bigger so that you see that you're not cannibalizing from winter into fall, but fall is taking up a larger share of a larger group of visitors, so you're spreading out your visits somewhat more evenly. Obviously, winter and summer are still your high seasons, but fall is making inroads. Good job, fall. Trip spending, over a third of trip spending is on lodging, and you can see that that went up year over year. The remaining...

58:32 Category spending decreased and your overall decreased. Do not panic. Do not panic. This is average spending and you have a broader visitor profile. You have a larger group with younger and older visitors. Younger visitors we know don't spend as much. So this is again, this is your average. It's actually not terribly different year over year. It's kind of in the same ballpark.

58:56 It's just amazing to see groceries actually go down. I've just never felt that myself. Dip kids. How do these trends line up with the other communities that you guys look at? Are they similar? In terms of share toward lodging, yes, absolutely. I don't have a trend of people are spending less or people are spending more. No, I don't think that... Well, overall, leisure visitation...

59:23 has waffled between 82% and 83% for the past couple of years, so that's remaining high. It went as low as 79% when everything tanked, but that's remaining high. I think the age and the stage of life of your visitors is impacting this, so people who bring kids, kids cost lots of money and you spend more when you bring them. Again, if you have a new visitor who is exploring and they've just come from maybe a quick trip, they're not going to spend as much. They may spend more per night because

59:53 Their lodging is a larger share of what they're spending. Drilling down by season, winter and multi-visitors continue to spend the most, which we know. And then fall is your next highest spending. And I have the lodging spend there because you can see, interestingly, fall visitors spend more than your multi-visitors, too. And again, the multi-visitors are those special people that come a lot. They're not like the others, so we pull them out independently.

1:00:22 We did see growth from 2016 to 2018 and fall in particular in terms of spending. And again, as you bring more people in and they're exploring and doing more things, that that result should continue. And just a reminder, fall 16 was the first time we started spending money, so 16, 17, 18, the three years we spent money on fall. Prior to that, it was just summer and winter. Right. In terms of lodging choice, hotel-motel remains the highest.

1:00:48 We added a home share this time around, which we didn't have in the prior measure, but your largest gains are in Hotel Motel. In terms of trip motivators, let me give you a little bit of background here. First, we ask people who have visited, we give them a long list of activities, and we say, what did you do? So, did you go hiking? Did you do this? Did you do that? Then the follow-up question, I'm sorry, I made it really small. I apologize.

1:01:18 Follow-up question is, of these things that you did, which of them motivated you to choose Mammoth Lakes as your destination for this trip? So, not surprisingly, winter. The highest motivators are downhill skiing, snowboarding, and then we have viewing mountains, lakes, etc. So looking at stuff. Sightseeing, nature walks, scenic drives, those can all be grouped into looking at stuff. That has grown.

1:01:45 Category as a motivator has grown since the prior measure. And what it's suggesting is that people aren't as laser focused. They're realizing, oh, there's other stuff here. Let me explore a little bit while I'm doing my ski. While I come for my ski trip, I want to look around. And then if you look at spring, summer and fall, that's your highest motivator looking at stuff. There was considerable growth in summer and fall year over year in terms of motivators. It's interesting that in summer, biking doesn't show up at all.

1:02:16 What does not? Biking. Well, we ask several different kinds of biking. We have mountain biking, road biking. That may be... Oh, because it dilutes it. Yeah, because we've subcategorized it, which I think we had done because there was interest in the different kinds of biking that people were doing. Yeah, we have the further detailed information on this as well. This is just the top ten. Yep. Okay, air visitors, as promised.

1:02:44 We know that air visitors don't only fly here. They drive on some of their trips and they fly on some of their trips. This is suggesting that air visitors now are flying on more of their trips to Mammoth, which is a positive result. We like air visitors to fly because they outspend drive-only visitors by 83% in every category. Let me just let you bask in those numbers for a moment. You can roughly double.

1:03:19 the number of air visitors as opposed to dry visitors in terms of their economic impact. Among air visitors, there's growth potential, so part of the goal is to get people to try flying and then give them more opportunities to do so. What we do notice is that new visitors tend not to be flyers. When you're exploring a new place, you may not want...

1:03:47 You may not want to invest in the flight. You may want to just kind of check it out first. And then as people are coming back more frequently, flights are a great option. The main motivator to fly continues to be to save travel time. It's more convenient. If you'll notice year over year, low prices, reasonable fares, that's pretty low. But as you can extrapolate from the spending, they're not price sensitive. So that's not the main concern. In fact, we do ask drive visitors, why don't you fly? And one of the things is it's too expensive.

1:04:16 A lot of people also say they enjoy the drive. That's part of their journey. So price sensitivity isn't part of it. Satisfaction results. Now, we ask people who flew, how satisfied were you with your flight experience? We ask a separate question, what's your satisfaction with the overall experience? And so we're drilling down specifically on flights. Extremely satisfied, that group increased somewhat, as did the kind of middle of the road, somewhat satisfied. Very satisfied, did not grow.

1:04:45 There's a little bit more polarization with this. We still have very few people who are somewhat unsatisfied, but we drill down with them and we ask, well, why were you not satisfied? And the same results that we got last time we see repeated, it's delays and cancellations. And people will say, I know it was weather related that it was canceled. I know it wasn't anyone's fault, but I still had to pay to drive back to the hotel and I still had to pay for the extra night at the hotel and it put me back a day. So that's just what it is.

1:05:15 Okay, takeaways. And everyone is still awake? Okay, again, year-over-year familiarity is showing a positive shift from knowing a fair amount to knowing a lot. People are continuing to want to come back, and high interest in repeat visitation, especially among your first-time visitors, means that you are delivering what you promised. They're having a good experience. They want to do it again. Fall visits are taking a larger share. They've grown from 13% to 16% of seasonal visits as you're...

1:05:43 Evening out visitation across the seasons, people looking at stuff, that's a bigger motivator, particularly in winter, summer, and fall, and then among your fly visitors, they're flying on a higher share of trips than they were previously. Okay? Any questions? Great. Would certainly love to get a copy of this. Okay. Absolutely. Make sure that with our members.

1:06:09 And I know that John posts it to the MLT industry site, but we can certainly make sure you get a copy of the... Well, we'll make sure you get the copy of the full... This is, again, this is the abbreviated version. The full detail is a lot more in-depth, so we can dig in a little deeper, too. I had a really quick question. The motivators versus what really happens are two different things, correct? Is it kind of like people that say that it's...

1:06:35 A motivator for their health club to have a pool before they join but then never use the pool. Is it like that where if you said 5% people it's a motivator to eat at restaurants but they might eat out every night while they're here? Does that make sense? Somewhat. Let me try to answer and then you can steer me in the right direction. So people are choosing this destination versus another because of those activities that you saw listed.

1:07:02 This data doesn't say they actually performed those activities. But they don't, okay, yes, they had to have done those things in order to get asked that question. Got it. Because first we said, what did you do? And then we show them why did. Yeah, to your point, they probably ate out.

1:07:18 Every meal while they were here, but it wasn't the motivator to get them to come here. Exactly. Except for your restaurant, of course. Except for yours. Biking came to mind as well. That's right. It might not have been a motivator, but they may have done it.

1:07:40 One point regarding your air visitor comment, which was related to that the person that comes multiple times is the person that will select the air more often. Obviously, given our previous discussion, that's somewhat of a concern. Since we're going to see more single visits coming up, it will be harder to continue to increase that air visitor. Well, and that's what we've seen in the current visitor profile. It isn't to say that you can't impact that going forward.

1:08:09 Currently, people who are single visitors are more likely to drive than fly. This would probably be the biggest motivator for people to fly. Interesting. That's a good point. We'll dig a little bit more into the ad side, but one thing that can be said is, you know, we've worked really closely with John and the team and even your feedback from the board to find the right air service programming. I mean...

1:08:34 It's not a perfect science. Let's all admit that up front. And as we partner better with, say, United and JetSuiteX, who we're co-oping with for the first time because we have these funds, we're really hoping we're getting more targeting and can at least help where we can with the ad dollars, knowing that we can't control service, we can't control the time the flight leaves and all those other things, but we can try as hard as we can to get the ads in front of the right people at the right time with the right offers.

1:09:01 Speaking of the single visitor, it's always been, Dave, it's always been our mindset here that the visitor who's been here before is more likely to be the visitor here coming here in the future. Yeah, yeah. Are you saying with these single visitors that that mindset should change? I'm saying that among a particular demographic group, that being the millennial audience, they share less of that mindset than the generations that preceded them. Yeah.

1:09:28 I mean, I used this analogy last night when we were talking. You know, we vacationed in Santa Cruz every year my entire childhood. You know, that's what you did. You went to Santa Cruz. You either went to Santa Cruz or Lake Tahoe, you know, if you live in Northern California. You just did. Nowadays, that generation is less likely to fall into that type of pattern. They're more likely to say, where would we like to go this year? What sounds new and exciting this year?

1:09:55 than the generation that preceded them. And so it's going to pose a challenge for all of us as we try to continuously attract new audiences. Okay, but in terms of the marketing that we do at MLT, I understand what you're saying about that single visitor, that millennium. But on the other hand, our marketing has got to be

1:10:23 Focused on those millennials, that's our audience of the future going through. I mean, they're the younger people who will potentially come back here over the years. So in effect, even though they may be greater, there may be a greater portion of them that are only one-time visitors, we've got to market to that group to have, because maybe Joe only comes one time, but his friend Bob is, you know. No doubt about that.

1:10:51 Yeah, and they're becoming the largest group. So, you know, that's the other thing. You know, you want to market fish where the fish are biting, right? So the truth is that is going to be the single largest group of people that are traveling. It already is now, has become the largest group. In fact, even in things that would surprise you, like affluent travel, they're becoming one of the largest groups within the luxury affluent travel market. You're like, millennials, you know? No, that's people.

1:11:20 50 plus who have all the money. It's like, no, this is, they, and they will spend money on travel. That's the other thing. Millennials are more interested in experiences and travel is one of the key experiences for them than they are in material acquisition. So whereas previous generations might have viewed what they purchased as a symbol of their success.

1:11:48 Millennials might look at where they have traveled as a indicator of their success and their ability to post on social media about it, tell their friends, share those stories has become a bigger and bigger part of how they communicate. So basically it seems like what you're saying is we still have to market to the millennials. Oh yes. But we have to be...

1:12:10 Savvy, particularly savvy about how we market the Millennials to deal with this changing way that they access travel. That's right. I'd say there's a second part of that though which is also not getting too caught up in the fact that the Millennials can be the shiny object because we still have the fall, older kind. Absolutely. There's not this 100% shift. I think that's where it's like it's telling but it's not tomorrow. It's going to be this...

1:12:37 intentional shift over the course of the next five to ten years. Because we still have legacy visitors, we still have an older clientele that comes in certain seasons, that's not going to change overnight. There's going to be a period. I think that's the organization today has to be able to say, what's the reality today? And then how do we slowly move to the new reality as it slowly changes? And try and keep at that same pace.

1:13:01 Then you're going to have another group right behind them that's going to start influencing. A whole different track. Exactly. To that point, really quick, that's the other reason why the pie got bigger. So we had more first-time visitation, but we still had those repeat visitors. And the one thing that Mammoth Lakes has, as opposed to its competition, is...

1:13:21 We really own in this destination our unique value in terms of what I personally like to call little pockets of wonder. But when we look at the trends, especially for millennial travelers who want to disconnect and experience all these different locations, Mammoth as a destination is not a Tahoe, a big lake, and you're there and you see it and you're gone.

1:13:42 I've been back six times now, and I still haven't seen all the lakes and done all the hikes and all the things. And so as we work really closely with our partners, such as Miles and Lyman and Josh and Megan and Laura and everybody that's here, we're constantly reminded of all the things that you can do and making sure we're weaving that in. And it doesn't have to be a bright, shiny object to the point it can be the reminder of that that also attracts, you know, those repeat visitors who are like, oh, I didn't do that last time.

1:14:11 by age. So it's just an indicator of what is happening within a particular large growing segment of travel. We target by passion and pillar and activity. So you could be a 32-year-old and you might share the same passions as a 62-year-old. It's quite possible and we would want to try to reach both of you.

1:14:38 Because we're promoting that particular passion. But it is just something to note. You know, I think that the point is well made. It's being able to look down the road and say, this is happening. How do we address it in our plan and be pragmatic about it and be thoughtful about it? Because you can't just do what you used to do before. It's going to be different. Well, Dave, in that regard, I've talked to a lot of our winter visitors.

1:15:05 And I have found, and maybe you guys will disagree, but I have found that a majority of our winter visitors have never actually seen the Mammoth Lakes. They come here to ski. Well, they're, they're, they're mysterious. They're, yeah. So, that goes back to the crosshale.

1:15:21 That goes back to the cross-sell that we need to make sure that we have. And that's what I'm saying is I think it's critical that you as our advertising people, marketing people, understand that we've got this huge group of people that come here in the winter who you would think would be the most likely group to come here in the summer and most of them never have. Right. And that's something that we, that's a huge part of everything we're doing now which is to try to, you know, as John mentioned, this used to be a one to two season sell.

1:15:49 And now it's a year-round sale. And so what we're trying to do is find those pivot points throughout the season that would get somebody to say, God, I came in the winter, but I never thought of coming in the summer. I'm in a mountain bike and hike and do all these other things because I'm an outdoor enthusiast. Or I never thought of coming in the fall when it's beautiful and we're just going to sightsee and walk and hike and do things like that. So, yeah. Absolutely. Yeah, I think if you looked at the profile of our visitor, that is the profile of our visitor.

1:16:19 How can we get those winter people to come here in the spring, fall, and summer? Well, and vice versa, because spring, summer, fall, we have more visitors than we do in the wintertime, more unique visitors. So how do we influence them to come back in the wintertime? But right, the cross-merchandising is good. We've got to keep going, right? Okay, I'm Dave Maring. I think you guys know that. I'm the CEO of Maring Carson, and I want to thank you guys for having us here today. I appreciate it.

1:16:46 We're going to walk you through the brand program accomplishments. I want to say right up front, these are not Marion Carson accomplishments. These are the combined accomplishments of everybody. This is the board and the board's directive. This is the staff and MLT and their leadership. This is our partners at Miles, you know, are the great insights we glean from SMARI. So these are really the brand program accomplishments, not our specific accomplishments.

1:17:14 A little bit about us, though, to start. We've been around since 1985. That makes me very old. Yeah, I'm not a millennial. But I have several of them. Fortunately, none of them are living with me anymore. We've got about 85 employees. Over the last 20 years or so, we've really become known as experts in the travel and tourism category.

1:17:43 The largest piece of business we have in that area is California. We've been doing the marketing and advertising for the state of California, which is referred to as Visit California now, for 20 years. When we picked up that account, it was a $2.5 million piece of business, and today it's about a $75 million piece of business. We market California all over the globe.

1:18:08 Including seven international markets that we handle the marketing and advertising for beyond the domestic market here in the United States. We've been working with you since 2014. At some time or another over the course of a year, you guys will touch about 45 different members of our staff. They might come in and out of your business. They're individual experts in little things, and we utilize them over the course of time.

1:18:38 Quite large, extended team that works on your behalf. In the last four years, we've put in about 18,000 hours of time supporting the staff at MLT. And we're proud to say that the program is very successful. It can always be more successful, of course, but we represent a lot of different travel and tourism entities, many of which are in California.

1:19:06 And I can say without exaggerating that your results are better than most of the other results that are happening in California. Everybody's doing well. It's been a good six, seven year run pretty much for everyone in the travel and tourism business here in California. But you guys, your results are actually exceeding most of the other destinations here in the state.

1:19:30 We've been involved with helping influence 750,000, what we call ad influence trips. That means SMARI tests that and says, did the advertising influence your decision to come to Mammoth Lakes? And over the course of that four years, that's 750,000 people have said yes. Awards don't put butts in beds, but they are a great indicator.

1:19:55 That your work is being viewed by people within the travel and tourism industry as well as people in the advertising and market industry is best in class. And you guys are winning a tremendous amount of awards. In fact, more awards than any of our other clients within travel and tourism. Moving on, we're going to talk about paid campaign performance. And just so you understand the distinction there, paid campaign performance means things that can be directly attributed to paid advertising. OK, so you ran an ad, something happened.

1:20:25 Earned, which is public relations. Owned, which are your own channels, right? Like your website, things like that. Your own Instagram pages and such. So just a refresher, this is our brand platform. This was developed back in 2014. This is not a consumer-facing document. This is the document that we use to build all of our marketing and advertising from. My analogy of this is this is the foundation of the house.

1:20:56 And if you have a bad foundation, the house is probably not going to be very good. But the house is the fun, exciting, sexy stuff that goes on top of the foundation. So the next slide shows the house. So this is the creative solution that spawned from Mother Nature's Adventureland, which is our platform. And this was the creative solution, our tagline, No Small Adventure.

1:21:21 The look and feel that you've grown accustomed to over the last four years. We'll talk about that in a minute. And really our evolution from being a winter primarily focused destination to now being a four-season destination. So what Dave had mentioned in terms of all the people that are working on the account on a day-to-day basis, not just in Maren Carson, but I mean I give Megan and Josh a lot of credit, the Lyman team.

1:21:48 Miles Partnership. You know, we've developed over 500 assets, unique assets, content, creative, photography, videography, B-roll, things of that nature in our partnership together. And it's really been a partnership in order to pick the right things and make sure we're selecting the right creative and working together. And so being able to kind of show that roundup to...

1:22:13 you today and know that it's certainly always something we're optimizing and working towards when we have that No Small Adventure campaign. It's not just the end-all, be-all of it. We're continually evolving it and tweaking the creative. I mean, we've learned what pictures don't work. We've learned what pictures do work, and that affects our performance. So we're always doing that, and hey, here's to another 500 assets to come.

1:22:36 And then when we dig into really the paid media specific side of things and the impact we've been able to make, we just wanted to show a quick roundup because yes, the campaign is really important and the media impressions and meaning who's seen the ad or all of that is really important, but it's the overall results, which we'll get to in the second half of the presentation, but it's still good to know, you know, in the lifetime performance of this No Small Adventure campaign, we've been able to get

1:23:02 The word out there in mass quantities, specifically with our out-of-home placements that we continually do, especially good for the summer season since we're trying to push that so hard now and being able to mass reach people in San Francisco and Los Angeles where some travel brands can't even do that. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, of course, can and that's very exciting for the brand. And even with our No Small Adventure video that I know you've all seen,

1:23:27 It's so much more than just the video completes themselves. What that actually means is 200 million people watched a 30-second video. 20 million people. Sorry. I wish it was 200 million. 20, but still, 20 million people.

1:23:43 Watched a 30-second video in completion. And the thing to keep in mind when we talk about Mammoth originally being a winter destination is this video covers fall, this video covers winter, this video covers summer. It's one of the first pieces of creative that a person sees who may be unaware of the destination, and we're showing them its breadth of offerings. We're not just going gung-ho in one season. So when this ad runs in fall, people are being reminded that Mammoth exists in summer and winter too. When it runs in winter, it's being reminded that summer and fall.

1:24:13 All exist. And these people have finished this video, and it's really pushed the holistic viewpoint of the destination consistently for this destination. Also, just another important part of the paid marketing campaigns is working with outside online and some other what we call native content partnerships. More so than ever, people want to consume content as a way to learn about a destination, and we've been able to afford to do some really amazing programming for Mammoth Lakes in particular.

1:24:43 One of them being the Outside Online Partnership where we ran custom content about what you can see and do in Mammoth. And again, something that focused on year-round opportunities, not just one season or another. People ended up spending about four minutes on average with this content, which in an industry average is around a minute. And that's telling us that people are engaged and people want more. And so that was a really big learning for us because, yes, we're placing social and digital ads and those are super important.

1:25:12 tested a bunch of partners, but we've really worked closely, again, I keep saying Megan and Josh and other people, to perfect who we're working with, right? Because it's not always a perfect science, and certainly this is one of the pieces of our program that has grown with our relationship with Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

1:25:29 And then also, as I had mentioned before, the social and display ads that we create together, this is one of those pieces of the programming where we are working really closely with Miles Partnership. So being able to drive web sessions, about 30% of the people that are going to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism website are through paid advertising, which is...

1:25:48 A pretty substantial chunk. We have to work in concert with all the other agencies and internal teams because an ad is only as good as the place you landed on on the website. And we give so much credit, really, to the day-in, day-out optimizations that Miles and Megan and Josh really make. So we create ads and then we keep people engaged on the website. And it's just such great news to know that we're going to just continue to push the level of that.

1:26:18 One of the new things that we introduced this past year is a dashboard. It's a dashboard that combines all of your different programs into one place. It's called DNA. It's a proprietary dashboard that we created with Origami Logic. And it allows us to look at how your campaign is doing in a snapshot at any given moment at any given time. These were things that used to take

1:26:46 We would produce a report and it would come out quarterly or it would come out monthly. Now our team is looking at this on a daily basis and you can see on the next page what that looks like. So this is your homepage on our DNA campaign overview. This says the summer campaign overview and as you can, you probably can't see the detail but it's each individual campaign.

1:27:11 that you're running. So it's the 360. It's everything. It's our display. It's all of it. And it's all there for us to look at. And what our team does is they look at what's working and what's not, what's working better, and they optimize. So they'll say, you know, this one's not working so well. We're going to get rid of that. We're going to move our money over here. And they'll continuously do that.

1:27:35 And it's a very time-consuming process, but it makes your campaign more and more efficient as time goes by. This is great. Actually, if I could go back to that last slide, I just wanted to ask the question, you know, as so many of our businesses here in town want to make sure that we are mirroring and paralleling your efforts. Is that something that we can, that businesses can view?

1:27:59 That would not be my decision. I think there's a lot of context that needs to come in it, and I think that one of the problems is if it were to then be viewed by people who are in a competitive situation, we certainly would not want people who are looking at that who might share it with other people to have access, you know, pass codes and things like that.

1:28:23 That's not my call. The other piece of the puzzle, and I know we talked about it in May as well, in the second half of this presentation, is there's four key objectives that we've been asked, you know, as a group and by the board to really focus on add impact.

1:28:37 Awareness, perception, intent. And when we get too granular, focusing on the nitty-gritty of campaign, we want to make sure we're not losing sight of the bigger picture. So this is holding us accountable as the paid media agency and for MLT and for us to work together and really push the needle on how the marketing's going. But at the end of the day, it's a mix of all of this stuff. I know I'm like making hand movements here, but somebody may see a...

1:29:01 See an outdoor out of home and then see a digital ad, see a social ad, and that has really changed their impact to go to the destination and something this granular will never be able to truly communicate that in the proper light for how successful the program is or what changes need to happen. Probably it's the level of sophistication to understand. Absolutely. I do think, like we were talking earlier about the ability to have a

1:29:26 Kind of case studies within the greater organization and how we can take those case studies and those learnings and maybe it's through the chamber or through people who are going to take it and be able to come back and say, in general, here's some things we've learned about what's happened in the community. Here's what we've learned about advertising. So if you're a hotel or you're a restaurant or you're someone that's part of the community, here are some even like a quarterly guideline that could be able to come back and say, here's some things you might want to think about. Like, we learned this. We learned that fall colors doesn't resonate if you're talking to people under the age of 45.

1:29:54 And so I think probably maybe those larger key insights that would help people influence there would be more actionable than giving people data. We've got to be like 45 people that's... Perhaps I should have phrased my question differently in the sense of should we be sharing this with our member of businesses because I want to make sure that we're the marketing message. And it sounds like the answer is, I think you answered it, is that this is too granular. It is really granular and it takes, you know...

1:30:24 You've got to really know what you're looking at when you're looking at it to draw the right inferences. Because you could look at something and say, well, this thing doesn't seem like it's performing very well, but you might not even know what its intent was. You know, it might have a different intent than the thing it's being compared to. So it requires a lot of, you know, we've got one, two, three, four people whose job

1:30:44 That's all they do is look at dashboards and make subjective determinations based on the performance data that they're seeing. And so what happens is this data is used to make a final campaign report, and that actually does give you those usable insights, and those are published to the MLT industry site, and we can certainly work.

1:31:04 even closer with Megan, and maybe there's an e-blast or something that goes out, alerts people when those insights are available, and to Scott's earlier point as well, I mean, I believe we're really into the idea of assisting and pulling in our partners to figure out ways to bring outside thought leadership with advertising programs to the destination. I mean, Visit California alone, we were able to have access to Facebook and Google and some of these other things that if we

1:31:32 You know, make even more of an effort to prioritize that knowledge. It's just going to really help the whole entire destination as a whole. For sure. That's my question, and I think, yeah, this is something that I got ahead of myself. Oh, yeah. No, it's great. It's great. It's great. Actually, a great question. Yeah. One of the other things that we're very proud of moving forward here is the new campaign. We refer to it as a new campaign. It's been in the market for two years now.

1:31:56 But it's this idea of really trying to build up the fall season, this season of awe. It's funny, that title, the season of awe, that actually comes from a trend and insights that are out in the marketplace where this word, awe, is actually becoming part of the vernacular. When they're asking people to describe what they want more of, they're actually using, I want more awe. I want to see things that are more amazing and more incredible.

1:32:24 So we came up with this idea of the Season of Awe. You saw the results earlier. I think it's a highlight of what we're trying to accomplish of making this a more evened-out season destination. And as you can see, 177,000 incremental trips as measured by SMARI. They are the biggest Attaware spenders, which surprised us a little bit.

1:32:51 And the campaign has already been awarded with multiple awards. And again, you know, that's great. Pat us on the back. But the more important thing is 177,000 incremental trips. That's the one that we care the most about. This next project. So this is the trials and tribulation of the amazing 360 degrees of adventure. So this was a project that we took on with the MLT staff.

1:33:18 And we embarked on this thing not really, you know, fully understanding the depth and complexity of it. It was humbling to me. I think we projected that we would put in about 400 or 500 hours on this project, and it ended up being double that. It was a year-long project, you know, because we wanted it to cover all the seasons, so it was something that we had to come back and film after the winter season. We came back and filmed again.

1:33:47 And I think we had over 70 cuts of this piece. We kept refining it and refining it. It was difficult. We all learned a lot on it. But in the end, I think the thing that's most amazing is just how it turned out and how it's performed. We've got 15 million video completes, which is about 50% above what we had hoped for. It's been very successful at the trade show. People love it. They love getting into the VR aspect of it.

1:34:16 and being engulfed in the destination. We've heard nothing but tremendous feedback from the trade show side. And I think one of the areas here that was what made it so difficult, anybody can do 360, and everybody does. You can see it on anybody's website. You can go out there, see lots of beautiful aerial photography of 360-degree views. What we set out to do was to say, how do we do 360?

1:34:46 But how do we make it uniquely Mammoth? How do we bring the brand into the 360? How do we make the story come to life within 360? Tone, look, feel, the established feeling that we've created for you and all your other assets. And nobody's doing that in 360. 360 is pretty much just, you know, look around and see things.

1:35:10 And that's what we set out to accomplish. And so we're going to show you now, I think many of you have seen this, this is a little highlight reel of the 360 degrees of adventure and it's pretty amazing. So that piece of content has been cut into about 25 different size units and displayed in different ways. So it isn't just a 360, you know, thing that a trade show, it has become

1:36:32 One asset that has morphed into about 25 different individual assets. And so it's really been an amazing piece of content. And, you know, we've heard nothing but rave reviews from MLT staff at trade shows as well as the industry itself who, you know, it ended up competing in New York at a film festival of all things against Google, Chipotle, Audi, and somebody else as the best piece.

1:37:02 of video 360 content produced. Yeah. So very, very, you know, hats off. I mean, we were shocked. Hats off to you guys for being brave enough to embark on this journey with us and to the staff for the 500 phone calls we had on the 70th revision of it. It's all been worth it in the end. And how it runs right now, just as a caveat, when we're running it in the winter.

1:37:27 You're still seeing the summer at the end, and when you're running the summer, you're still seeing the winter at the end. So no matter what, this asset helps us market the destination year-round as well. So just cruising right along, this is just showing, again, when we're working with our advertising, our AdWare visitors are showing they're flying more in our ROI study, return on investment of our advertising.

1:37:49 Another thing to just state here too, as I had said earlier, this has been a learning process on the right placements and ways to serve airline advertising. And so it's been a really interesting year and we're really excited about the approved co-op dollars and to see the results we have working more directly with JetSuiteX and United to see if we can continue to push the needle there. And then just overall, this is just a quick snapshot lifetime.

1:38:15 808 million impressions got the number right that time, showing you that we're really hitting those key spot markets, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and San Diego, but at the end of the day, and as you saw in Andrea's visitor profile study, we're starting to expand the amount of markets we're actually reaching people in, and we're continually working with John to tweak where we're targeting and why we're targeting, and that'll certainly be something as we continue to talk about the next couple of years, where we want to go and why.

1:38:43 This will be an important part of it, those markets. I beat this horse to death. We can move on there. And then, as I had stated before, these are really what we think about the four key things to be measuring the success of the campaign on. This is like, this is the holy grail. So the campaign's only as good as its final success, awareness, perception, intent, and add impact.

1:39:06 And so you can see in the past four years, the industry growth has been incredible for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, 68%. We're currently set at 62% for ad awareness of our campaign. But what's more interesting is this next slide where our friends at Samari, they won't tell us now, but...

1:39:24 In terms of our comp set, if you see where Mammoth Lakes sits in terms of awareness of our campaign versus some of the others, may or may not be Tahoe and Breckenridge and a couple others, you know.

1:39:37 We're doing really well. And in terms of the efficiency of the campaign, we can say that as well. And so the thing about this particular metric is you don't want to be too low and you don't want to be too high. You want it to be just right. And we're making sure that we're investing your money wisely. But like, for example, D is so low, that person could just be buying search engine marketing ads that nobody's even engaging with. So we're making sure we're hitting the right places at the right time for the right spend.

1:40:07 A, has got some issues? A, I feel bad for A. They're either not very efficient or they have a very different goal. You know, their goal isn't based on, you know, it's probably a small, expensive market to reach. There you go. The luxury market would be an example.

1:40:24 And so you can't get people to want to come here unless you start shifting their perceptions. I won't belabor this because Andrea already covered it, but just showing from 2016 to 2018, we are continually shifting perceptions of what people want out of their vacation destination. I think the one that means the most to you should be this slide, which is the 600% increase in intent. That's something that you can say.

1:40:52 Okay, that's great for now and that's great for the future because the way people plan now, they're not going to just see an ad and come. They're going to think about it. It's got to get on their list. They might already have their next year's trips planned. But if we've increased their potential desire to come by 600% over the last two years, then that bodes very well for the future for us. And you can see.

1:41:20 That of the people who are influenced by our advertising, that's very hard to see down at the bottom. And we'll share it out. Every category is dramatically up. If we're showing in our ads, it's what's influencing people to go to Mammoth. It's a really great correlation. We've had 750,000 new trips that we can directly attribute to advertising and counting. You might be looking at 16, 17 and say, why did we go down? That was the...

1:41:49 You know, incredibly extended ski season that came with the huge dump of snow that carried you guys all the way into July. As you can see here, the good news is that we're impacting the right people. They're staying in hotels and motels. They're spending money in the right places. And they tend to stay longer and with larger travel sizes. And that's even more critical.

1:42:18 These issues that we face with overtourism and people's concerns about that, it's always great if the people that you're attracting are a better qualified customer and not just more poorly qualified customers. Yeah, we're not just focusing on quantity. So while ad influence trips are super important and we want to make sure we continue to bring in people with our advertising, the quality behind it.

1:42:43 That's a huge number, 2.2 more nights. 2.2 extra nights. That's amazing, actually. Their ad spend, that's really what we want to be focusing on. Right there. There you are. So they're spending, you know, you're getting increased spending. So, you know, if they see our advertising, they're more likely to stay longer and spend more money. And the economic impact that that has, of course, on the community is, you know, something that has grown dramatically in the last four years.

1:43:11 That then correlates to the next slide, which is the tax impact. So these are all very positive things. One of John's goals that he set out for us three years ago was I want to get to a place where we have 10, he called it 10 months of viability, I believe was the term. And that was he wanted to see 10 months where the income was over a million dollars. Is that right?

1:43:37 TOT income. Yep, TOT income. And you can see that we've gone from seven to nine. So we're almost there. We're getting close. I hold great promise as the fall season continues to grow that we can eventually get that October month to flip.

1:43:53 Yeah, and even there at the top, you can see the bar got bigger because we've got more people and they're spread out more across the destination. And again, as we decided at the beginning of the planning cycle, the focus was going to be on that quality visitor, not just the quantity and not just all the people in the winter.

1:44:10 Been really successful. Even, I mean, shout out to the Mountain and other partners as well in understanding where the advertising dollars are going and how we can impact everybody in the destination instead of just, you know, going for what's the most, going for, you know, what's sustainable. So there you can see, we checked all four of those boxes. Hopefully you would agree. And then, you know, there's always a lot of questions about us. You know, we're probably one of the largest, if not the largest contract that you have. I understand that.

1:44:41 The way to really evaluate it, you know, in the old world, you'd look at your spending and say what percentage of your spending goes to your agency because we all lived in a world where 15% commission was the way that you gauged it. It doesn't really mean anything anymore. You can take on projects that are 90% time to expense. What really matters is how much time are you putting in and what is that time worth? And as you can see here, we've continued to invest more time.

1:45:10 in the account. Everything takes more time these days. As everything was supposed to get simpler with the internet, everything has gotten more complicated. So we spend more time analyzing data. We have more data than we know what to do with. Everybody wants to know what the data means. So this is why the time keeps going up. You do see the aberration there in 1617. That was the...

1:45:35 Project I discussed earlier, the 360, and how much time ended up going into that project, which was a phenomenal amount of time. So, in closing, results we've talked about, a lot of campaign awareness and impact. We are invested in your business very, very heavily, all the way from myself, all the way down. We see ourselves as extensions of the MLT

1:46:05 team and staff and it's a large group that extends your team and you know we're going to keep moving forward this is not a program that's going to sit on its laurels that isn't our way of doing things it isn't you know you don't keep the California account for 20 years if you're sitting around resting on your laurels so we are currently in the process of looking at your existing creative work.

1:46:29 And looking at how we might evolve that in the future, that's going to be something that's going to happen in the next few months. And of course, we'll continuously be adapting our program, looking for new markets, addressing these shifts in the millennial audience, et cetera. We're not going to sit back. We're going to continually get better and more efficient. So with that, I'm done. Thanks. Thank you. I have some questions of Dave and Amanda. There's a lot of information there. I have some questions, but...

1:46:58 First off, thank you very much. Really appreciate you being here today and presenting the information as well as the success that we've seen out there. It's a great job and certainly is exciting to see where we're going. And I, too, look forward to the future because I know that we'll continuously get better, especially if we continue to partner the way we've all partnered. Thank you.

1:47:24 You referred to the video a lot, and especially how long that video takes to make over a thousand hours. Is there a shelf life on that video? How long do you plan? You had some goals as to your visitation of it, but...

1:47:40 Is there a goal as to how long we use that video as well? You know, I think that goal is subjective, to be honest with you. I don't know that I could put an objective goal on it. One of the ways that you can determine that, of course, is through its continued performance. If it continuously performs and if when you look at the video you feel it's still reflective.

1:48:00 of the campaign and where you're at, then I would say that you keep using it until such time that you begin to see a decline in the metrics of it, right? Like it's not getting the views anymore. They're not going to completion. The look and feel of our campaign is evolving away from things. I don't see that happening in the immediate future, but I think it's something that we'll keep an eye on over time for sure. Yeah, the reason why I ask is when do we need to start thinking about the next video, right? And there's ways, well, first of all,

1:48:30 It would not take a thousand hours again to do 2.0 because, you know, what that really was was a partnership where we said to the team, you know, this is going to be a new experience for us too and we're going to go in this together. You know, we're going to embark on this together and we know we're going to commit a lot of time to it. We know that isn't time that we're going to get reimbursed for, but we want to do this.

1:48:53 So that was the program. We learned so much over the course of the year about what you can and cannot do with 360 and how to make the process go much faster, much easier, and probably less expensive. So yeah, I think that I'm very excited about it. And I think that it's performing.

1:49:13 Better than we anticipated. So if we ended up wanting to expand upon it in a year or two and go to 2.0, I think that would be great. And we're just really quick. We are running it. It's its second year. And the way they filmed all the footage is so we could recut it at any time. And we are currently reconcepting.

1:49:31 Working on what the evolution of that No Small Adventure, that 30 second spot that shows all three seasons. So whereas 360 may not always be the go-to unit, it's still a supportive unit and we are looking to, like I said, take the campaign to the next level. Great.

1:49:47 And then that's another question that I had that is a good lead-in to. We've always talked about how long a life does a campaign have, right? And you mentioned the foundation of our house. Is there a life...

1:50:04 time period of where we need to really revisit the foundation of our house. I mean, obviously, we're successful right now, but when do we need to get ahead of that? Yeah, I think so. I mean, I think for sure, because it's a market that's changing rapidly these days. What we've found, though, is when we've gone out and retested positioning, is that it rarely changes very significantly, because your positioning, if it's done right,

1:50:30 Should be a true reflection of who you are and what you're all about, right? Like it shouldn't be a, it's not, it's not a fashion, you know, it's not, oh, this is what's fashionable this year, this is out of fashion next year. Your campaign may change, but your positioning should be fairly solid. As an example, we've retested San Diego's positioning three times in 10 years, and it has not changed, like at all.

1:50:55 We haven't even bothered to touch the board. The board's still exactly the way it was. And that's very extensive testing in lots of markets across the country. And so that hasn't changed. The campaign itself, we chatted about this earlier, and my philosophy probably harkens back to a famous saying in our business, which is right about the time you're getting tired of it, the consumer's starting to pay attention to it.

1:51:22 And that's because we live in a world where this is also present for us. We see it all the time. John has to stare at those posters in his office every day. And at a certain day, he's going to go, this is so boring. I'm so tired of this. Can't we do something new? Well, consumers don't react to advertising that way. You're lucky to get them to pay attention at all.

1:51:45 Let alone that they spend a lot of time thinking about it, going, gosh, I really wish Mammoth would change their campaign because I'm so bored with it. So the way I look at it is if it's still performing, and certainly the metrics today show that the campaign is not only still performing, it's performing at a very high level. And there's another thing that I want to note, and I'm not saying that we can't change and that we won't evolve, but

1:52:13 I think that one of the challenges for us when we took on this account was how do I make a mountain destination look different from any other mountain destination? Because you don't have a picture that I can't duplicate somewhere in some capacity. You just don't. You know, you got lots of beautiful shots of lakes and people paddling.

1:52:37 I can find those in Colorado and I can find them in British Columbia and Utah and Montana. They're everywhere. Beautiful mountains with lots of snow. I can find those anywhere, right? So I can duplicate your visuals in your competitive set, right? How do I make your destination look and feel different from all of those competitive sets? And I would say that was a challenge that we embraced and one that we delivered upon because your ads.

1:53:06 Don't look anything like anybody else's ads. They have a very unique look and feel. The type is very unique. The illustrations are very unique. They capture the essence of the brand of this otherworldly place. And so I would just suggest that before we grow bored or tired of seeing the same things over and over again, that we remember that there are

1:53:36 Real advantages in standing out, breaking through, and repetition. There's companies that have stayed with the same campaign for 20 or 30 years. So we're going to look at it. We're doing it right now. We're going to be presenting to the team soon and say, minor evolution, medium evolution, full on, we call it hop, skip, jump. So here's just a little step forward. Here's kind of a...

1:54:05 Standing broad jump, and then here's a, you know, the full-on jump, right. And it'll be up to us all collectively to make that decision. But, you know, I would say that...

1:54:16 That, I firmly believe in that old adage that, you know, we grow bored with it right about the time that other people are starting to pick up on it. I'll give you a quick analogy that some members of the audience will recognize this, and that is that we have a Apre ski event that's the Woolies Parade down in the village, and the people that are putting on the village, that...

1:54:39 Particular event, you know, want to do something different all the time. But the guests that come there are enjoying that event as it is. And we see that in results of our net promoter scores and our events as well. So I understand getting bored. Yeah. We all have short attention spans now and the world is getting shorter and shorter and, you know, especially young people. So it's understandable.

1:55:05 One more comment for me, and that is the enthusiasm for fall. When we look at your data in terms of Smeary and your own personal experience of coming up here right now during the fall here, is that of there's so much opportunity for it because everybody wants to come and view lakes and drive and visit and be here to take in the awe.

1:55:31 And we're seeing that we're moving the needle, but it's such a great time to do it and to do it with, you know, the demographic of the person that is spending more, it's older, it's a whole different demographic for us to bring in during that time. They have more free time. There's just so much capability there that it's exciting to see. Well, and it's a trend, too. That's the other thing that's good is that it's actually a trend that's happening in the industry right now.

1:55:59 You know, these scenic drives and what did you call it? Leaf peeping? Leaf peeping. I'd never heard it before. Leaf peeping. Apparently leaf peeping is... There's not that many leaves. Yeah. Well, we saw a hell of a lot of leaves on the way here, I'll tell you. It was sensational. She was like this all the time. It was amazing how beautiful the colors were right now. It was incredible. It's a trend. So it's like you're on trend, too. It's not... It's good. Thank you. Thank you.

1:56:27 Any other comments? We do need to get to closed session. So if we have any other questions, comments, if we can keep them brief, that'd be great. So from the agenda point, we're going to take a break. We'll do the financials and the staff reports after closed session because Tim's here and we want to keep that on track with timing-wise. Does that work for everyone? Yeah. And we can table staff reports. Sorry, staff. Again. Next month. Why don't we have you come up and, well, you don't have a microphone. Yeah. Yeah. Why don't you come up and introduce Emily?

1:56:58 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome.

1:57:35 Okay, we're going to, we'll break through. Thank you. Thank you, guys. And real quick, just to be clear, I'm going to recuse myself, but I'm going to stick around for the financials afterwards. Okay. Yeah, very nice meeting. This is your first time. Closing remarks here. Yeah, I've got to coach soccer, too. Are you leaving? No? Okay. How much time are you? Just getting to be 15 minutes. Five, we've got to go to 15.

1:58:00 Okay, we're live. So we're coming, we're back on, back out of closed session, nothing to report out of the closed session, and we're going to continue with our regular session going through. We've decided to delay the staff reports, and we'll do financials. Yeah, financials, we have the TOT information attached. September has come in just shy of a million dollars, and it's about just shy of 7% behind last year's record.

1:58:29 August has continued to kind of reduce as well. It's only 4.7% behind. For the year, we're 1.253 million ahead of budget, and we're 141,000, 142,000 behind last year, so about 3% behind last year's record, well ahead of the budget. On the TBID side, we just got those numbers. Apologies for not getting them out before the meeting, but we got those late. For the month of September, we had a budget of 230,000. We did 229,000.

1:58:58 Year-to-date, we had a budget of $838,000. We're at $914,000, so we're at $76,000 ahead on TBID, which is about 9%. And then the month was a little bit behind last year. It was about $15,000 behind what we collected in September of last year. Update on the bank numbers. The CDAR's numbers are the same, about $800,000 in Measure A and about $2 million in TBID. The Measure A checking account,

1:59:28 When I printed the agenda with 749, we did get a check for Q2 TOT, so we're at $1.205 million. Measure A savings is still $5,011. The TBID checking count is $810,000. We did pay the big bill for last winter's air subsidy, and that was a big chunk out of there.

1:59:50 And then the TBID savings is at $5,007. The joint bucket funds, which is also listed on the transient occupancy tax piece, year to date is $226,666 through September, and that makes that about $596,927, including the rollover of funds uncommitted from last year. We all know that the King's funds are committed, so that's $596 that I would consider as usable funds from that account.

2:00:18 P&L reports, again, I apologize, we got those to you late yesterday, and we didn't get those from the town until late Friday, and I was out of town, so I got them to you a little later than I had hoped. And last thing that's not on here, but is we are expecting a draft of our financial audit in the next week or so, and historically we've run that through, the draft has been run through the chairman and the treasurer for review, and then we'll present the full audit to the board probably

2:00:47 Potentially at the December meeting, but it may not be until the January meeting. That's all I got. As it's related to the joint bucket funds, so after our joint session with the town council, I kind of came out of there with the perception that if we had a good idea with that money, we should present that. As simple as that. I know that that's simplifying it too much.

2:01:13 Curious as to, in the past, we had identified some extra marketing money when we were in a situation of drought or something of that nature to, if all of a sudden snow came, we really put the gas on the pedal and had some money and spent it. Any interest in looking at that kind of scenario for this year that you guys and gals would consider?

2:01:41 It's only an idea. Yeah. I'm with you on that one is that given that we've had a delayed start and given some concerns around, you know, media, especially in California, people talking about weather and where it's at, that being able to take some of those dollars and you mark them that when the snow does come to really be able to ramp up because we have a soft start and people are very aware of it. Right. I think sending some of those funds aside for that purpose makes a lot of sense. You know, I don't think our, I don't think people in Colorado or the farther afar know that

2:02:09 It's been a slow start year, but I worry about Southern California where people are still sitting in trunks that they might tune out.

2:02:18 Before the holidays to the idea of snow. And if we get something in three or four weeks, we're going to need to ramp up. Well, and they're seeing five feet in Breckenridge and Telluride. Yeah. Yeah, they're opening terrain there. Brecken, Copper opening a long time. But I think you're right. I don't think they see us as really having a low year yet. But if we do have a big snow, it gives us the opportunity to really ramp that up. I'll quickly from decision two.

2:02:44 Great question. Well, there are a couple of things to keep in mind. How quickly can we get with Council to say, sure, let's put $300,000 into a contingency bucket for emergency winter marketing, get that approved, and then I think Marian Carson could deploy it pretty quickly. Because I think we would know the best uses of digital to be able to do snowstorm alerts or whatever we need to do to get out there and

2:03:14 Like they showed with the dashboard, we can tweak it consistently. And we all know that we can change within 24 hours. We could have six feet of snow. And last November, we had the 80-inch storm that dumped the top of the mountain. That's the sort of thing that we need to be prepared for. It's just more of a question of how quickly can we get this approved through council? Do we have to have a special meeting of some sort? And then I think that we can alert Marion Carson to the potential of this so that they at least have a straw man of what they could do with the funds.

2:03:40 You know, immediately, outside online, things like that, that we know we're going to get a good response from. That's a good point. Obviously, we have to, it's earned, but I'd like to make sure that some of that's earmarked for efforts for Laura with, you know, bringing press up, like, the it's on so that when, you know, LA Times is talking about how warm it is right now, that we get writers and some of that earned media investing, coming up and seeing that change firsthand as well, not just digital. Yeah, right. Like that two-pronged approach. Yep. And then...

2:04:09 I think the worst case snow doesn't come and we have to like shift from that message to say here are all the reasons to still come to Mammoth even though it's dry in December. And we're already answering those questions and he's getting calls on a daily basis. Footloose brought their bikes back out. So, I mean, it's real. Footloose brought the mountain bikes back then. Yeah, because we've been getting calls when people want to get out and do things.

2:04:36 So I think we'll follow the process just to see what we need to do to get that approved. And then, like I said, I can talk to Marian Carson after this meeting and just say, hey, if we had X to do X, how quickly can we deploy it? So I think the process, not knowing it, but I think we need to come up with a number that we're comfortable with to present to the town council.

2:05:00 You know, not to find it enough to what Scott just did, even though we'll need to once it's been approved, but to say that emergency marketing fund, I think if we allocate that and allow us to go spend it once the snow hits, would be the request to the town council. Okay, yeah. And that's one of those things that, you know, even build a contingency when we ask councils, I think you go back and say, you know, we want to earmark this, we want to set aside, we want to commit these funds.

2:05:28 If this thing doesn't happen by this day and we don't use it, then we're fine with it rolling back in. So the council has that comfort level. It's like, look, it's gone from the bucket. We don't want to come for anything else. And if we get a huge dump by Thanksgiving, we'll move that back. I think that's a way to proceed. Or we'll continue to throw gas on the fire. I think I'd rather see us, if we get something, that it still is a message. Because we're that far behind right now that we could use that big time.

2:05:57 Okay. So I would say right now we've got $596,000, $597,000 in the joint bucket combined last year's rollover and this year's funds that are in there so far. Some of that we had talked about for the signage program. Well, the signage program is out of our Measure A reserve. That's $350,000. Okay. Now, if we wanted to put more out of the joint bucket for wayfinding, that's a different story. This is Measure A reserves you've already allocated to wayfinding to the,

2:06:28 Convention Center to some of those things. So those are already blocked. I think we need to revisit that whole thing anyway, another meeting. But for now, you know, the question is out of the roughly 600,000, what do we want to shoot for to make a splash? I'm going to leave that to the marketeers. I don't know. What would you recommend, John? You know, I think a couple hundred thousand bucks is really what's going to make a difference. I don't think it needs to be much more than that. But again, it's probably 99% digital just because of the fact that we can change the messaging.

2:06:57 Immediately. I'd support that. I don't want to pull out from the wayfinding. No, that's a separate, that's what I'm saying, they're separate. Nor did I. I wanted to keep that in there, actually. And on this note, you know, the wayfinding is a completely separate bucket. So this, if we did this, it would leave $396,000, $397,000 in the joint bucket still, which is still a fair amount of money without us cutting too deep if we decided to go back to that other.

2:07:27 If we wanted to put another $100,000 to wayfinding, whatever it is. Thank you, Paul. Do you support this strategy? I'm interested in hearing some more about it, maybe not necessarily today. As I get where you guys are coming from, but then if it's the emergency bucket, I could see changing the message if we're not getting snow. However, I think I would probably,

2:07:59 Be comfortable, personally, that if we do get snow, that maybe some of that money can be returned rather than putting the fuel on the fire because I think if we do get snow fairly soon, I would rather save that because what if we use up emergency funds and then we end up having a really bad fire year and have to push the message?

2:08:28 We're always going to be going back to the emergency bucket. So I see where you guys are coming from, but I do have some questions that are bubbling in my head. I personally would love to see if that's going to come before the town council, ask for a special meeting or, God forbid, an emergency meeting. I don't know if it would fall underneath that.

2:08:55 I don't think it would. I think a special meeting is fine. So yeah, a special meeting, I know that as far as myself, I'd be glad to meet whenever you guys did want to meet on that or present that. I think that would be really important. So personally, I'd like to see money going out of it, but then if we start recouping, it's a good year.

2:09:21 I don't so much think the fuel in the fire may not be, and I've got to stop saying that. Well, you know, I think every day that it's 65, we're losing future bookings, and it's going to start really hurting. My milestones that I always work off of are November 15th, Thanksgiving, December 15th, and then after that, if we don't have snow, we're in deep trouble. Okay, but at that point, then it would be like, okay, well, you have to change strategies. That would be an appropriate use for changing the message.

2:09:48 But if we do get the snow, I think we have enough and there would be enough information going out there that we wouldn't have to spend $100,000 just to remind people that we do have snow. I think people would be very aware of it. Given that, I'd like to make a motion that we allow staff to draft a plan and that as an organization here, we say that staff has approval from this board to allocate up to $250,000 out of the joint bucket as a request.

2:10:15 And that staff will craft a strategy to present to council based on that number that says, you know, however it works, right? So it's going to be up to John and his team to be able to say, this is the best way we think it should work, whether it's paced, whether it's not paced, whether it's all done at once. But this board says that would be an appropriate use of those funds and how that gets delivered and how that gets approved by council is going to require some input. Maybe it's flow, maybe it's all at once, but that's going to be...

2:10:39 We should leave that to staff to execute on it. But this group would say, we're giving you the permission to draft that plan for this number and go ask that from the council. Okay, so let me hear your motion. So my motion is that we approve staff to allocate $250,000 out of the joint bucket for emergency marketing around snow and to go request those funds from the town council in a special session. I second that motion.

2:11:14 It doesn't. Yeah, that was a nice long motion. Yeah. It doesn't commit us to, it's not an immediate action, it's the putting us in a position to take action. It's giving staff that ability to go do that so that, you know, how that happens, what's the function of how that happens, how does it get approved by council, what's the right allocation of dollars, is it digital or not, we're not going to try and decide here in the moment. We're saying staff, yes, the board agrees.

2:11:42 It's appropriate. Here's a number. Go ask for it. And John and his team have to be aware that when they go ask for it, they're also going to have to have a plan that's going to be acceptable to council. So there's going to be some input that's going to be required to make sure that it goes through there because we can't just solely allocate those funds. But we're saying as a board, we have support this as an idea given the current state of where we're at and what potential risk is to the community. Got it. My second stance. Okay. All in favor?

2:12:12 Aye. Aye. Okay. Passes unanimously. Okay. I'll work on that. All right. All right. I think that was it. Eric, you got some comments for us? You know, the operations team is, as always, trying to make as much snow as possible and open as early as we can. Unfortunately, it won't be tomorrow, but we'll continue to work to whatever we can and get open as early as we can.

2:12:41 Just like we always try and stay open as late as we can. So just wanted to pass that message on and hopefully it'll be very soon. I'm sure it was disappointing, but I was personally have to say I was quite pleased to see that even with the new ownership of Altera, that the mountain was taking the more cautious approach and not...

2:13:04 Not jumping the gun just for the sake of a date. I was encouraged to see that personally. You know, the feedback we've gotten, that is evident throughout a lot of different circles and a lot of different groups that the exact same kind of sentiment, that they were pleased that we went in that direction. With the exception of my friends in the orthopedics. The orthopedics were like, come on, this is going to be a banner in November.

2:13:32 I don't know where Mount Rose is. They're kind of open and closed. Yeah. Mount Rose would be the one that. Canada's got snow. Wyoming's got snow. Colorado's got snow. Idaho has snow. We're kind of in the pocket right now. New England has snow.

2:13:59 We went through the financial takeaways. Next board meeting is scheduled for December 5th. I think that we need to, before we get that locked in, we're going to need to convene and look at your travel schedule and what that looks like and make sure that we have a quorum for that next board meeting. So I'll look, John, for you to be able to send out a request. But I think that, you know, given that schedule, whether it's some other time that week or the following week. Yeah, the following week we have the 10th and the 13th are available here, Monday the 10th.

2:14:28 or Thursday the 13th? Is that what it is? I would only be able to do the 13th. I'm traveling the 10th through the... Okay. What we'll do is we'll send out something that asks for one to three on the 13th, see how many people we get back, because that might work. I don't anticipate it being a, you know, too detailed meeting, so I think we can keep it pretty simple. So we're talking about not having it on the 5th? Correct. Yeah, I'm out of town the 3rd through the 7th for a conference. Okay.

2:14:59 Okay, and as far as future meeting dates go, I do ask at some point. I know that there's probably some thinking behind this, but if people could maybe later after the meeting explain to me why we do meet on Wednesdays on a Town Council Wednesday.

2:15:14 Just because I can spend four or five hours talking to you guys about some of these things, like we're having to truncate the meeting today because of meetings that are piling up. So that's just something later on if someone could let me know and if we can change from the first and third Wednesdays. I think that it helps with reporting out from town council to MLT and vice versa. So it gives me more time to let people know.

2:15:43 On both sides what has happened. The original reason was because it was on the council meeting so that you could take from this meeting to the council to report to the public. But the council rep can do that. Yeah. That's been the, and then we've got rec commission here on Tuesdays. We've got chamber meetings the second Wednesday of the month. No, I do realize that, but I just, I do see a little bit of, it's, okay, I'll take that in too.

2:16:13 And normally our one to three meeting, I don't think we've been going over because of, I think, closed session more than anything else. And typically that's one to three has been sufficient. Okay. Then I'll just have them change the town council meetings. There you go. Now we're talking. Okay. Any other business? Okay. Then I will call the meeting adjourned at 345. Sweet. See you in December. Thanks, guys. And if anybody wants to stick around, there is...