TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2019

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 1 hr 20 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

80 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

41:13 Involved. Oh, that's louder. And perfect, I can back it up a little. And so I think this is a great way, if in the future we felt like we wanted to become more involved in the parcel, we don't actually have any money for it. And kind of back to Patricia's things, we would have to then go to town council with a special ask for more funding. So I think this is a great way.

41:41 I think we have a lot to offer with Mammoth Lakes Housing's experience over the years that we can bring to the table for this, and I think the addition of Sierra Business Council is really exciting with what they can bring as well. So, yeah, sort of this wonder of it's kind of funny to be applying for something that we're named in, but I'm not sure now it's maybe a little different to the Sierra Business Council that we're just one piece of that puzzle.

42:10 I just want to say I think that your second comment answers your first question because while we do have some time that we're working on the parcel and getting updated by the parcel team so that we can bring information here and providing some limited information to them, an expanded role is not within our current work program.

42:33 That's something that I think we've all been struggling with. And so I think that this RFQ answers that pent-up frustration of how can we participate? Well, here's how we can participate. Thank you, Sandra. Add this to your many responsibilities with the town. Okay. Thank you so much. I think the other thing, too, is it's a request for qualification, which is going to be reviewed and considered by the town. So there may be other teams applying, maybe not. I don't know.

43:08 You know, I think at the end of the day, the town can make their own decision. But, you know, with respect to this body, I think it's certainly within our wheelhouse and what we should be doing. And, you know, I think, you know, I mean, you know, I congratulate Patricia for bringing this here to us because, you know, I think it's the right direction we need to go. You know, this community needs...

43:33 Housing, and we need to advocate and push in every direction we can to try to further that effort. And, I mean, to me, this, like I said, makes complete sense. Are there board questions before we move to public comment? Sandy? And Ken, too, maybe? I don't know.

43:52 Sandy Hogan again, and yes, Sierra Business Council has been around for a long time, and they have been concentrating up in Truckee, but years ago, when Andrea Lawrence was still here, I think her term as supervisor might have been over, but she was very active in getting them aware of Mono County, involved in a number of our issues down here.

44:15 And what's happened, you know, is over the years, Truckee's been moving forward with their housing, as you know, and I think Steve Fritchie is still the Executive Director, and I would say Stacey, maybe make some efforts to really make some more contacts with him and get him back down here and interested again, and Tom, if you've worked with him, anybody that's worked with him, I think it'd be worthwhile. I do want to compliment you and congratulate you, actually, on the intern.

44:44 That sounds, I couldn't hear everything, but now I can. So that's great news, getting the intern, and yes, going forward with any part-time help you can, because the Community Action Plan spells out that MLH should have three full-time people. And with Diane, I'm so happy to see her here. I know she's very capable and a great asset, and so any more you can add to it, because

45:14 We want to see Mammoth Lakes Housing playing a major role in the parcel. The other stuff too, yes, but the duties there when you look at the whole action plan, it's scattered around. There are a lot of things that have to come together. Kim knows. He's trying to pull some of those pieces together. And so, you know, it's going to be in fits and starts with that part. But the parcel hopefully is just going to keep going forward. That's why I say the updates are so important.

45:43 For people to know that we're doing that. And any way you can bring in SBC or anybody else, but they've got a great reputation. They have. And maybe it's more than 20 years. It's been a long time. You'd know, Tom. I was just reading what they said on their website. Sandy said 20 years. 20 years. Has a 20-year history in the region. Great. Any other comments? Ken? Tim? Sandra?

46:13 All right. We'll bring it back to board discussion. We have basically option one is to make a motion to direct staff to complete and submit a submission packet. And option two would be do not direct staff to do that. So let's open it up for board discussion. Anybody? I'd love to hear from somebody we haven't heard from yet, maybe.

46:38 Yeah, I just wanted to say that I'm in full support of this. I've heard personally and also people coming to our meeting stating that they are curious and wanting to see Mammoth Lakes Housing play a big role in, or just play a role in the parcel. And I've heard questions of wondering, where people are wondering where we are currently on it. And so I think this would show the community that we are trying. And I think it would be, I think we'd be really effective. So I'm in full support. Great. Lindsay, any other comments? No.

47:11 Okay. I'm good. Thank you. Agnes? No, I read through the material and it looked pretty straightforward to me. Great. Richard? Let's do it. Okay. And I, well, Tom, I already heard from you, but if you have more to say, go ahead. I was just going to make a motion. Okay. I also, I just wanted to address Sandy's, you know.

47:29 You may not have been, this was pre-Mike's getting fixed, but Steve Frisch was one of the facilitators for our community housing action plan working group, so he's been very involved, and I know we don't call them consultants anymore, they're subject matter experts, but truly with this package, with a team of WSW, the other consulting firm that can't remember their name, SBC and Mammoth Lakes Housing, you have the entire

47:56 Needs Assessment Team and Community Housing Action Plan Team together. So you have the subject. There's no learning curve there. So I hope, and I would just also urge us, and I want the other comment I wanted to make in preparing this to work with the town and make sure that we're submitting a response that meets what they were looking for and what they have in mind. But it sounds great. So yeah, with that, if there are no other board comments, ready for a motion.

48:25 Okay. I'll make a motion that the board adopt option one direct staff to complete and submit a submission package in response to the town of Mammoth Lakes RFQ for affordable housing development expertise by January 21st. I'll second. Great. We have a motion by Tom, second by Lindsay. Any further discussion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Motion passes unanimously. Thank you. Thank you. Can somebody go get the council members?

48:56 Sure. I was going to say, all right. Go away. Go away. The amazing thing is that I can go home and watch this and find out exactly what happens. I'm not sure recusing ourselves does much good. We can't see your reaction. That's right. We can't see your body language, which was important. Oh, okay. I want to see you rolling your eyes and popping your head. Okay, we'll move to agenda item nine of the monthly

49:51 Mammoth Lake Housing Monthly Update. Patricia? Thank you. So, included in the monthly status report for Mammoth Lakes Housing, it seems to be growing in length, so please, if you have comments, let me know what they are, but I like all the information, so that's why it's in there. I had a couple of updates that are not included, which are that the town assistant clerk position, which Sandra filled this evening,

50:21 Closed on January 3rd. And so they'll be doing interviews and getting that new person on board. And my estimation, along with the human resources manager at the town, is that they would be available to start for Mammoth Lakes Housing at our March 4th meeting. So we'll see how that goes. My second announcement is that IMACA, as the

50:50 Local administrative coordinator for our regional continuum of care is organizing the annual point in time count of the homeless population for Inyo and Mono counties. And so IMACA and Mono County Behavioral Health are looking for volunteers to help during the afternoons of January 25th through January 31st to help count individuals that may be

51:21 Maybe living out of their cars. So to try to find those who maybe aren't self-identifying as homeless but maybe aren't actually living in a home. So if anybody on the board is interested in more information, please let me know and I can get you linked up with the right people. What else is in this packet? So we have our waiting list increased by two households during the month of December.

51:54 I provided, on page three, some website traffic information over time. Why did the traffic sound so much? I've been thinking about that, and I think our website was brand new when I started in 2013, and so I think it was really flashy and exciting, and maybe it's not as much anymore. Also, we don't generate a lot of content, new content, so it's...

52:21 I mean, that's something we could work on with an intern if we want to do more social media things or if we want to do more stuff that draws people to the website. I think that's somewhere we could grow. Meeting home sales prices, is that through December 3rd? Yes. I just wanted to announce that, so the home awards have not been made, and Mammoth Lakes Housing applied for a home award, and Mono County applied for homebuyers assistance, and so neither of those have we heard yet back about.

53:01 Is a government shutdown going to affect that? We're not sure. We talked a little bit about that today. HUD's open, right? I mean, I think they're open. I guess it depends on how the funds actually get from HUD to the state, because we apply through the state, so they may or may not already have access to some of this money. Treasury shut down, right? Treasury Department shut down. It will be shut down because the checks are going out. Right. Or the processing of... Thank you. Sorry. The processing of...

53:35 People's, you know, this year's income. I just heard right before I came in here they said they were not going to delay the refund checks from tax returns this year in spite of the shutdown. So, go figure. Patricia, how do you track the apartment vacancy rate? You said you're going to start tracking that. How are you able to do that? So,

54:05 The way that we calculate the apartment vacancy rate is that we collect five weeks of the Mammoth Times and count how many multifamily apartments are available for rent. Is the Mammoth Times a credible local publication? Yes. I think in the past we've done both the Times and the Sheet. We could go back to doing that. That's just the way we've been doing it. You might do both because sometimes people advertise one, not the other.

54:34 So you just track the number that are in there against what you have as a record of an inventory of total? And you have a fairly good handle on that? We work very closely every year with the town to make sure anything that's been lost or anything that's been added is updated in the database. So that is tracked in some fashion? Okay. That'd be interesting to know. I would imagine it's about zero. Close to it. So when we're done with that, we'll provide...

55:07 We'll provide the report. 1%. It's zero. Effectively, close to zero. I know a lot of people kind of go through Facebook like Buy, Sell, Trade for finding places. Have you noticed that those places are generally also listed in Mammoth Times or is it just like a lot of people going on the back end side of friend to friend and if there is even a way to trace that? I think it would be really difficult to try to

55:36 Track the availability on Facebook. And this only tracks apartment vacancy, not condos. So any long-term rentals that are condos or other single-family homes are not included in the vacancy tracking. Interesting. Okay. I have seen people, though, that do advertise on buy, sell, trade. Yeah. Well, there's another, there's a group, another Facebook group, rent. Eastern Sierra for rent. Yeah, yeah.

56:08 We could talk to the town about trying to include those. Why is it just apartments and not condos or single family homes? Because it's the apartment vacancy rate. Is there a condo? Don't mess with the staff. No. No, it doesn't track how many rentals you have available total in your housing stock. It's for multifamily apartment units.

56:39 So it shows how many apartment units you have and how many are full. 100% are full, essentially. 0% are vacant. I'm not sure it would be that different if it were condos either for long-term rentals. And it would fluctuate just because each unit, one year it's long-term, one unit, who knows, it's short-term. They come and go so quickly, whereas apartments are available for long-term rent 365 days out of the year.

57:12 I don't think I have. Obviously, we're coordinating with the chamber on their housing program, and I think that's the most pressing thing we have. And we've been working on setting up the town's 2017 CDBG award, which has home buyer assistance and rehabilitation funds. So we're just continuing to work on that, and it's moving forward.

57:47 Patricia, I don't know if you want to just brief the board. I had asked Patricia a question. On the very last page, the staff coordinated with a private property owner on a potential CDBG application. I just asked her for an update on that, on the conversion of a commercial property into low-income rental units. Yes, so I was approached by the owners.

58:13 of a property on Old Mammoth Road regarding the possibility and what it takes to apply for some of these grant fundings for the conversion of commercial to residential property which is what we're looking at for 238 Sierra Manor Road and that project is behind Blue at the Mammoth Mall and so they are working towards potentially putting an application together for CDBG funding through the town

58:43 How does that actually financially work through? So they get a grant for $3 million, and what happens? So for CDBG funding, the jurisdiction is the recipient of the grant money from the federal state government, and then they utilize that money per the guidelines of that program to create

59:12 Programs or projects that will benefit low income individuals. One of the eligible projects types is conversion of commercial property. Then the private property owner would work with the jurisdiction on some type of loan agreement to access that grant funding from the town. And then either that would be a negotiation. So they would be long term? They would be long term, low income?

59:41 Because they would be forgiven the CDBG grant? $3 million grant for conversion? It's a loan. It's a loan that would be forgiven if they are deed restricted. The loan terms are negotiable between the jurisdiction and the developer, and I would recommend that the town require them to be restricted for as long as possible. And the town would be the applicant?

1:00:08 The town is the applicant with the developer as providing the information on the project. So that's all negotiable between the developer or the property owner and the town as to the parameters of the CDBG grant? Yes, within the federal limitations, and as far as I can tell, there aren't very many. Questions? It would be a good thing if we get a good...

1:00:38 A good negotiated deal with them, 11 units. 13. 13 units. And that's just phase one, they have a phase two, which is 13 as well. That's great. Upstairs and everything. That's fantastic. Add to our 11, that's 24 units. Yeah. Maybe next year. Yeah. Right? 24 units. That could happen within 12 months to a year. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to board member reports. Richard?

1:01:12 Yeah. So I've been talking to a lot of different people in the community on different issues. And one of the things that kind of keeps coming up to me is what are we doing in the short term to provide housing? It's all well and good. We're working on the parcel and all these things are going to take some time to manifest. But, you know, I guess getting back to the challenge that was

1:01:40 Put to everybody who attended the housing summit, you know, how we're going to provide so many beds this winter, which I don't know that we've made any progress on, particularly. I know there's some discussion about some roommate sharing facilitation, possibly. But something that was brought up to me, and I actually, I'm like, it's a good idea. Why shouldn't we entertain it? And I'll throw it out there for the board to think about, and maybe we can discuss it more at our retreat. But in the context of the development of the parcel,

1:02:08 25 acres, you know, we still got to figure out what it is we want to do there, but would it not be possible to take, let's say, five acres of that and put in a temporary RV park and make it, you know, we'd have to put in a road extension and spurs for trailers and utilities.

1:02:37 But, you know, my thought is that the parcel, again, being 25 acres, is going to get subdivided, if you will, into different development paths. And it's going to take time, as we said, to build out. So we pick a portion of that property that's going to be, quote unquote, the least impactful in terms of, you know, something that could stay there.

1:03:01 Longer, because we're going to maybe prioritize developing the stuff closer to the commercial downtown area, at least in my mind, that's how I see it. And so maybe the hinterlands of the parcel, the further out corner, maybe off of Chaparral that ends in to the top corner or southwest corner, you know, maybe there's an opportunity we could extend the road. We'd have to, you know, look at utilities, go through some feasibility analysis, but, you know, maybe this summer, I mean, come up with some money to

1:03:30 To build out a road, like I said, create a, I don't know, how many, I mean, I'm thinking 50, you know, 50 spurs for people to park a trailer and or, you know, also, you know, whether we look to buy trailers or something like that for people to use. You know, it's no different than a tiny home, but it's literally a trailer, a travel trailer. But, you know, a nice travel trailer, I mean, you can buy them brand new for $20,000, $24,000.

1:04:00 And that can, two people can live in fairly comfortably. I mean, and it's, you know, I mean, I'm, so other things I'm hearing is people are living in their car, sleeping in the underground parking at Sierra Center Mall. I'm sure there's people sleeping elsewhere. You know, and my mind is, you know, I don't know what all the zoning implications are and whether that creates issues with, you know, later saying, okay, you know, now we're going to convert this to housing and take it out.

1:04:30 But, you know, if it was something that would provide housing for 100 employees for five years, why wouldn't we do it? I don't know. To me, it seems like, why not? I mean, you know, they put people in FEMA trailers responding to, you know, natural disasters, and we're in a bit of an emergency situation here. And, you know, it's, in my mind, it's not, it's, you know, it'd be decent housing for a lot of people.

1:04:57 We'd be happy to have that. You could design it well so it takes advantage of some good solar access and give them a little bit of a paved out patio on the south side of their trailer so they could have a little outdoor living area they could enjoy in the summertime. And, you know, if you do it thoughtfully and correct and you've got full hookups and they have the ability to keep their unit from freezing, I don't know, to me, I think it makes some sense. So, anyway, these are things that people have been talking to me about and, you know, just like, hey, let's get creative.

1:05:27 That's my little diatribe. Thanks. Great. Some of us are meeting tomorrow morning at 8.30 with the Chamber Steering Committee group. And then on the 17th, I've actually met with these folks in this roommate, employer-employee sharing, matching thing. South Lake Tahoe, North Lake Tahoe, they're all deep in this. I mean, this is all happening up there.

1:05:58 And it's going to be interesting to see if we can pull this thing together. And one of the people that we'll be meeting with on the 17th, they're coming down here for a site visit, used to work at Airbnb. So they've got a platform that already exists that we can repurpose and use. I think it's a, to your point about getting some short-term stuff going, I think this is something that we could definitely get going on this thing. So pretty excited about that. Other than that, my house is still standing as I hope the rest of us are as well. After last night.

1:06:28 Thank you. One thing, the Board of Supervisors, you know, is still in the process of working to sell the county-owned property on Davison Street as community housing, and I just wanted to provide the Board with a little clarification. There have been a couple of, in my opinion, kind of nasty letters to the editors, and then a couple of much better-tempered responses.

1:06:57 But the original letter writer who submitted a bid to purchase the property made some pretty erroneous representations in his letter, so I just want to clarify a couple things. The main thing that the Board of Supervisors was trying to do is make sure that the Davison House property is community housing.

1:07:27 So if we were to just sell it to the highest bidder, which we, through this really weird process where people, oh, you open bids in a meeting and there's a little bidding where, you know, it's very formal and not something that happens at the county, you know, very often. No one, I think, in the room could remember the last time it had ever been done. If we had just sold it to the highest bidder, that property very likely would have...

1:07:55 Turned into short-term rentals. It's zoned. It's in a place where it could be short-term rentals, where it could be vacation rentals. It was important to the board that we try to preserve it as community housing. Its purpose before that was as a program space, a sober living facility. It was community housing. And we were going to develop it as permanent supportive housing. We weren't able to do that. So that was really why we

1:08:23 took the direction we did. And we navigated into uncharted waters by doing that. There's a provision in the government code that says we can restrict its use for affordable housing. But what exactly affordable housing means was something we had to really look into and see. So we're working with the, like it was three developers who submitted viable affordable housing bids.

1:08:49 The county staff is still working with them to make sure that their proposals actually fit within whatever requirements are in that section of government code, so it's still out there, but that's what we're trying to do, not trying to stop development, but very simply, as our Community Housing Action Plan instructs us, responding to the clear needs identified in our needs assessment here in Mammoth, we've got to preserve what we can as affordable housing, and one tool in doing that is

1:09:16 Yeah, through deed restriction or restricting the type of development that can be done there. So stay tuned. We'll wait and see what happens when we come back. It's a complicated process. So easy to misunderstand. So if you have any questions about that, please let me know. I'll direct you at our county council or try to answer them as best I can. But stay tuned for the outcome of this. And I'll be sure to update the board. Hopefully in February and March we'll

1:09:46 Beyond to the next step. And I just wanted to add on to what Patricia said about the point in time homelessness count that's coming up later this month. This is a very formal process directed through housing and urban development. What's really important about it, last year was the first time, in Mono County at least, that we made that our social services, behavioral health, IMACA, continuum of care staff, made a really...

1:10:13 Mammoth Lakes Housing, a concerted effort to actually try to count homelessness on a night in January in Mammoth. HUD dictates that it's done within, I think, a two-week period in January. It works better, I think, in big cities because people are seeking shelter. Somewhere where we have no homeless shelter or real facilities, it makes it a little more difficult. But nonetheless, we're trying to follow the pretty strict parameters.

1:10:39 Get a better idea of how many homeless people we have in Mono County so that we can then apply through the continuum of care, which is run by AMACA. We can actually get funding to address homelessness.

1:10:52 Our continuum of care has gotten funding through HUD this year, and it's restricted on how it's used. It might be good, Patricia, I was thinking maybe Larry Emerson from IMACA could come and give this board a report on that. It's more short-term housing. I don't want to say transitional because that means something else, but I think it's intended to be more short-term housing. They were going to look, for instance, could they rent an apartment or even a motel room?

1:11:21 On a long-term basis to put people experiencing homelessness in there on a short-term basis before they find permanent housing. But that type of thing. But I was thinking, like, Tom, I like to get creative. Could we use it to rent campsites or improve dispersed camping that we know we have going on outside town? Could we put porta-potties in dumpsters?

1:11:44 You know, out beyond Shady Rest Park. So I think those are all ideas we should explore, but I think it would be great for this board to learn more about the continuum of care. So, thanks. Sorry to go on so long. You didn't mean to say Shady Rest Park, right? Shady Rest Track? No, I mean Shady Rest. Out on the forest lands in the area we called Shady Rest, there are...

1:12:06 Probably 100 people, you know, in summer, definitely 100 or 200 people living out between Shady Rest and the Scenic Loop area, so. Lindsay? Nothing at this time. I had a really good conversation with my dad who recently, his unit that he has, he rents, he does Airbnb through it, and he did it because he moved.

1:12:39 Down south to take care of his parents, but he wanted a location he could come to regularly to visit his kids up here, and he got a bigger unit, it's like a four bedroom, three bath, and he's noticing it's not as profitable as he thought it was. He's noticing that the Airbnbs that are most profitable tend to be the smaller unit ones, but he doesn't necessarily want to let go of the unit because interest rates are high, so right now isn't a very good time to sell. But I was talking to him about

1:13:09 Hearing how some employers are trying to get units to rent for their employees and like Shields Richardson and Colin Fernie. Thank you. I can't believe I forgot his name. And so kind of that idea and I brought it up to him and he seemed pretty interested. He's still kind of like seeing what the winter will look like, but he thought that it was a pretty awesome idea to, you know, convert his big unit.

1:13:35 into something that can allow employers to still use it, and it's still something that could bring him money in, and then he can either rent places when he comes up, or whatever it may be, but he's coming up less and less so. But it was really awesome to hear someone be really interested in that, especially since his unit is so big and isn't as profitable as he originally thought it would be, and there's possibly others out there who may see the same thing, but that they're not actually...

1:14:03 You know, seeing what they were originally anticipating. But it could be at least a like a consistent cash flow and something regular that he could depend on as opposed to something that only brings in money during the holidays or whatever it may be. Yeah. Well, I kind of went through my list already as to my concerns. It's not a concern. It's just that all these different programs keeping track and making sure that

1:14:32 That, you know, whatever we're investing, because we have a finite budget, what is producing the greatest number of units? So I have gone through that. I think the idea is correct. We should keep our eye on the parcel, but then look at all these other programs. So maybe that does need to be, you know, just to...

1:14:56 You know, as well as the housing action plan, you know, especially the first 10 items on that. So we're keeping track and saying, wait a minute, you know, why is this falling through the crack? Or do we need to put funding to this? If the staff is hiring two individuals, are they looking at these different projects or vehicles for getting housing? So that's my only comments. Do I have any other?

1:15:27 Sandy Hogan, a late public comment, but actually Giselle's comment brought up something that I met a young woman, oh, a week or two ago, and she is renting part of a house, just like you're talking about, a bedroom plus shared facilities up in the Knolls, and I think before it was one that

1:15:58 Sandra, this is you for to mention to Danny Earls that he probably banged him a few times, you know, cited him, whatever, for illegal short-term rentals, and now this owner is actually renting to about four, and I don't know if they're all men or women or whatever, no.

1:16:18 Women or some men, whatever, but it's working out pretty well. She was very happy with it, very nice, you know, somebody I'd be happy to rent to also if I were. So those are the kind of things that maybe to alert Danny to that, you know, the enforcement efforts, especially in residential areas, perhaps, especially some of these big homes, might be turned into.

1:16:43 Employee housing, whether it's seasonal, you know, renting the rooms out or whatever, and reserving a room as your dad does and kind of, you know, the ability to be there. That's another solution and Ken, I know you're taking notes on it too because there are a lot of moving parts in the housing action plan and I think as these arise, you know, these are the kind of things to, oh, that might be a solution. So, anyway, I just wanted to mention that and thank you for bringing that up because I just realized.

1:17:13 It's a success at least in one area. Further comments? Looks like we are adjourned. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Yes? No, no, you, no, you wanted dates. That's a fallback. Okay. The fallback is the 24th. Okay.

1:17:57 Thank you.

1:18:06 Yes. It's a beautiful Starbucks Conference Center. It's going to be really exciting. I can only stay for about 25 minutes. Yeah, I mean, we got going pretty quick.

1:18:36 Last time? Yeah. Yeah, I just really, I want to, we'll talk about getting that, when those people are now on the 17th, get that one figure. Yeah, yeah. That have the ability to. Yeah, to start getting this thing going. Yeah.

1:18:51 No, no, no. No, no, no.