TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2019

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 2 hr 40 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

321 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

9:09 Roll call. Lindsay's here. Stacey, do we want, oh, you want to call roll? Yeah, thank you. Oh my goodness, very formal. Lindsay Barksdale. Here. Stacey Corliss. Zariah Cruz. Tom Hodges. Giselle Kenney. Here. Kirk Stapp. Here. John Wentworth. Agnes Fianzan.

9:44 Richard Playstead. Yellow. And we now have John Wentworth and Stacey Corliss. Here. Where's the voice of God? Thank you. Now, I'm going to do the bathroom. Make sure that's in the minutes, okay? Yes. Okay, roll call. The podium is open. Agenda item three, the podium is open for public comments.

10:17 Good evening, board. I just wanted to introduce our new assistant clerk, Angela Delisle. She comes to us to help with all the clerking duties for all of the NGOs. So this is the first MLH meeting she's been doing. She's been doing wonderful. She's worked for the town for a couple weeks now, and she's newly engaged to one of your board members. Yay! Oh, congratulations. You can still make that.

10:43 For full disclosure, she's my fiancée. Congratulations. Full disclosure, okay. The podium is still open for public comments. If there are no public comments, we'll move to agenda item number four, which is approval of the minutes from the January 7th regular board meetings. Any deletions or corrections? For all of the board meetings? Or just the January 1st? The January 7th one.

11:15 We had a typo on one of the board members' names throughout the document, which we'll revise. So we have made the correction on Barkless.

11:41 As amended. All right. There's been a motion to approve the minutes as amended. Is there a second? I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item number five, which is approval of the minutes from the strategic planning special meeting of January 31, February 1, 2019, and the regular meeting of March 4.

12:10 2019. Are there any deletions or corrections? Stacey, were you at the last one? I wasn't at the last one. I think it says you were on this. Oh, okay. Maybe, was it, because I was at the first two, just now. Yeah. Okay, maybe the. I thought it said. Oh, yeah. Good catch. Members present, Stacey Corrales. Yeah. So we need a correction on the March 4. If I can have a motion.

12:43 I'll move to approve the minutes with the strategic planning special meeting of January 31, February 1, and the regular meeting of March 4, with the correction as noted. I'll second. I'll move and second. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item number 6, review and discussion of Mammoth Lake.

13:11 Housing and Sierra Housing Advocacy, LLC, Fiscal Year 2018-19, Second Quarter Draft Financial Statements. Staff? Thank you. So we haven't had a really regular meeting in quite some time, so these are our second quarter financials for the period ending December 31st, 2018. On the first page, I just wanted to note a couple of items. Under

13:39 Fixed assets, we added new computers during that period, so our fixed assets increased. And then under the HBA Cal Home loans, that increased because we made a loan to a household to buy a manufactured home. So are these on the books, I'm sorry, are these on the books of MLH as the foundation or on the other entity?

14:10 Starting with the financial statements for Mammoth Lakes Housing. Okay. So even though we're looking at the Sierra Housing Advocates financial statements, the computers you mentioned are on the books of Mammoth Lakes Housing? No, we're looking at the MLH financial statements, the statement of financial position, the first page of the financial documents. Okay, so when it says MLH and Sierra Housing Advocates, aren't those two separate entities or no? There's other pages.

14:38 Yes, those statements come after MLH. Okay, I see. I'm sorry. Are there any other questions on this page? The second page is the forecast, which shows our activity, the actuals to date through the second quarter, and then what included is the forecast for the next two quarters of the fiscal year, and we've added in what we project to accrue in revenue as well as in expenses.

15:07 I had a couple of notes I wanted to mention.

15:39 We project cost savings and payroll expenses due to having one staff person for four months and then the transition of the Executive Director. I also wanted to note that we have some additional expenses and you'll note that in the actual, in the last column of the worksheet, actual versus budget, we spent more in board development this year for the strategic plan, so you'll see that line item increased as compared to what we budgeted. And then

16:09 Our expenses are going up, so our professional insurance is more expensive, and I project that our HOA fees will be going up. So we'll see those projected in the draft budget, which will be presented at the May meeting. And you're on page 12 of the PDF, is that correct? Yes. Mammoth Lakes Housing, fiscal year 2019 forecast? Yes. And that $97,880, that's the anticipated surplus? Projected, yeah, at this point, but it's only halfway through the fiscal year, so.

16:40 But that's projected for the whole fiscal year? Yes, projected, yeah. Okay. And then the next page is the statement of cash flow, which shows our activity, investment activities, and then at the bottom shows the cash that the organization has. This cash line item includes our reserve for economic uncertainty, our Cal Home loan amount, that reuse amount that we've been committed to reuse to loan to individuals.

17:13 Our Star Apartments Reserve, our 238 Reserve, and our tenant deposits is all in that line item. And then I've added a schedule here. So on the balance sheet, which is the first page, you'll notice at the bottom there's a line item called unrestricted. But some of those are actually restricted. And I've been working with the accountant to get some of the items pulled out so that we can see what they actually are and see what's actually restricted.

17:44 So the last sheet here for Mammoth Lakes Housing is the CalHome Program Reuse Schedule, which shows payments made on CalHome loans to Mammoth Lakes Housing that we're obligated to reuse those amounts to loan to another individual. And so we made a loan in the last quarter, and the balance currently is about $10,000. And if there aren't any questions, I'll move to Sierra Housing Advocates. So when you talk about restricted,

18:17 Will you be able to tease out, like, it's restricted by either board action or by contract or by grant, those kinds of things? Yeah, so at this point in time, I don't think I'll be pulling out anything else besides the CalHOME amount. But when the board restricts funds, if we do restrict money, I'm assuming that will be, you know, we'll be able to be restricted for this purposes. Yeah. We can move those around, but it's just good to know what things we've restricted for our own purposes. Yeah, and these funds are restricted by the grant that we received, so.

18:46 Okay. But yeah. There hasn't been any activity in Sierra Housing Advocates except for Sierra Housing Advocates purchased the board dinner at one point in the last quarter and so you'll see a charge for $108. That's totally unacceptable. So thank you for that. Thank you. Thank you. And then you just see the change of the 108 throughout the statements.

19:17 And Sierra Housing Advocates has a balance of $42,000. And again, can you speak to how that's restricted or not restricted at this point? Those funds are restricted to the charitable purpose of the organization, and we use Sierra Housing Advocates for the purchase and sale of property. So from the board's perspective, they're basically not restricted? Except for the charitable purpose of the organization. Which is, that's, I mean, that's not restricted. That's, I mean, in other words, funds that are consistent with the mission of Mammoth Lakes Housing, correct? Yes. Okay, so they're not?

19:49 From a board perspective, I don't see those as being restricted. We've chosen to restrict them. Yeah, they're not. And we, even as a board, we haven't said of those money, we have discretion there to do things with those money. We haven't said what they're for or what they're not. So it's basically unrestricted funds at this point. You could call it that. Okay. And I don't have anything else. Questions to staff?

20:13 If there are no questions on staff, we'll move to Agenda Item 7, the draft strategic plan update. The board will receive and update it regarding the 2019 strategic plan. Agenda Item 7. Okay, so we were expected to adopt our strategic plan at this meeting. I've had some back and forth with the consultant on

20:39 Just minor corrections, some formatting. It's moved into more of a visual format, so we've had some problems just fitting a lot of the information on the page, and so we had some absences this evening, so I felt like it was appropriate to make sure that the board had adequate time to provide feedback on the draft that has resulted from your comments at the March 4th meeting.

21:04 So that the consultant can incorporate those so that it'll be ready for adoption at the May meeting. I checked in with her today and I didn't get an update, but if you haven't received the draft today, it should be forthcoming. And then she requests that you provide your comments to her directly and she'll incorporate them and then we'll get that draft at the May meeting for adoption. And our next meeting is May 6th? That's correct.

21:32 And then I just wanted to note, since I missed the March meeting, I'm going to actually do a phone call with her. That's okay. Yeah, so she can bring me up to speed. So I'll be looking forward to it. Thanks for all your hard work on that day. I'm looking forward to seeing it. Thanks. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to Agenda Item 8, consider approval of Mammoth Lake Housing.

21:58 Inc. Resolution 1901, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc. approving the creation of the following standing committees, Executive Committee, Fundraising Committee, and Development Committee, Strategic Planning Implementation Action Item. Staff? Yes, thank you. So, despite not having adopted our strategic plan, I believe it's the will of the Board to create these standing committees.

22:25 In an effort to increase capacity at Mammoth Lakes Housing. So these committees would be tasked with their specific roles more in an advisory capacity to the full board. They might be doing some research, some outreach, coordination with the Executive Director, and other tasks as they arise.

22:53 One of the strategic priorities that the board identified was to strengthen organizational capacity and the board felt like this was one of the primary ways we should begin to do that since it didn't take additional resources. I have provided a resolution and a description of the committees as I see them and how they work.

23:20 An executive committee, which would include at this time the president, the vice president, and the secretary, which is also the executive director. A fundraising committee to help develop whatever that fundraising plan looks like and then bring that to the board for input. And then a development committee, which would help define the development rubric that we talked about during strategic planning and the different roles that MLH would play.

23:50 They would have helped develop how that looks. For example, 238 Sierra Manor Road, MLH developer, Mammoth Mall, MLH facilitator, or whatever that looks like, and that would be the role of the development committee to bring that forward to the board for input. So it's part work program. Yeah, yes. And I'm recommending that the board approve the resolution and we start working on these committees.

24:22 One question I had about the committees, would there be any sort of a time limit on committee participation? And is that something that goes in the resolution or is that just sort of what we know amongst ourselves? You mean in terms of time commitment? Yeah, maybe the committee stand for two years or something and whether that's even an important.

24:47 Okay, so the standing committees would be standing committees, and each committee, I think, will define their meeting schedule, whether it's every other week or every other month or once a quarter, whatever they feel like they need. That meeting would need to be canceled in accordance with the Brown Act if they're not going to meet, and then if they want to disband the committee, the board can do that at any time.

25:14 And can you change, I guess my question more is, can you change committee members on a schedule or something?

25:22 You can set up the committees however we want. So if it's a two-year term and then a change or an extension, I mean, however you want to set up the committees, it's the board that decides. So the executive committee could be three people and then it changes to the next three people or they stay on and it just simply, sometimes it's just a discussion of who wants to volunteer because these do take time.

25:51 Yeah, so I hadn't set it up with a term limit, but I thought that if you wanted to switch committees or stop being on a committee, we could have that conversation. So in the strategic plan, I'm seeming to remember that we talked about more than just three committees. Am I wrong about that? There is one other committee that is not on this list, and it's a marketing and outreach committee, which I didn't add at this time based on staff capacity. What about the committee?

26:22 Oh, sorry. Wasn't there also one for developing, like, new programs, or do you think that's going to fall under one of these three? That might be under Executive Committee, right? Like, looking at kind of organizational structure and governance? In the latest draft of the strategic plan, I did not see a programs committee. Maybe that's a comment for the consultant. Okay.

26:49 I'm just wondering if it doesn't, I just throw this idea out there, if it might make more sense to be doing this when we've got the full strategic plan in front of us, just so we can understand if there's committees we're missing and we can kind of look at this and say, well, because I'm sure the strategic plan says more about what the executive committee is going to do and we can really kind of have a better understanding of what these things are all going to do and I just throw that out there. Yeah, I do think though, from what you were saying, Patricia, is that because

27:18 You are planning to attend all of these meetings. We just, we may not be able to have as many committees right from the outset as we originally wanted. Well, that's fine. But as we're kind of prioritizing which committees we want to do, I mean, we may look at this and say, well, the strategic plan recommends five. We might want to say, hmm, well, what are the, if we can only staff or support three or two or even one, which ones we want to pick that we think are most important? Can you fold some of them together? Can we fold some together or something like that?

27:46 So that we can be strategic about, because this is going to be a big burden on staff to do this kind of stuff, to make sure we're allocating this time we've got to do what we want to do. I think, well, I guess you have a question about programs. Because I think we know right now the thought was that there were only four committees recommended. And my only thought is, do we need to start working on some of this without waiting until the next meeting? And then if we still have more revisions for the strategic plan, then it's another month out. And are there things that we could just get started on?

28:16 Now, before then. Well, I agree, because I think we need to identify the work program. What are they actually, each committee going to do? Begin to break it down into its component parts or its, you know, responsibility. The executive committee, I assume, is going to be looking at the executive director's contract and performance and that sort of thing, bringing stuff back.

28:42 Fundraising Committee, I mean, that's new. So, you know, that's going to be pretty broad. And then Development Committee, you know, I'm not sure exactly how that fits into the work program. And then reaching outside to work with private developers. We have somebody, you know, that obviously is interested in looking at some property and working with that.

29:06 Obviously, deed restrictions are going to come along with that if that goes forward. So there's a lot of component parts to each one of these. Because it might be kind of interesting to take the strategic plan and say, okay, each one of these committees, your assignment, you're going to get assigned this, this, and this. I think they need to be tied together. So do that next month when we have the plan. Yeah, I think you're right. That makes sense. Yeah, I think so. Just because that way we keep it, it's efficient. It's like we look at the strategic plan.

29:32 These are the things we're trying to achieve. Okay, we'll put these things over here and put these in. That way the committees know what they're supposed to be doing. They can look at the strategic plan and saying we're supposed to do this, this, and this. But the descriptions came from the strategic plan. Yeah, and I kind of, you know, we've done a lot of work on the strategic plan and I had the sense that these committees were a high priority and also staff's been working on a lot of work programs that need guidance from these committees.

30:00 Sooner rather than later, especially on 238 Sierra Manor Road. We're releasing the RFQ for architectural and engineering services tomorrow, and we'll need the development committee to participate in the interviews of those firms in mid-May. But I guess we could do it at the May meeting. So the direction would be for staff to bring back the strategic plan and let's look at the responsibilities in the plan and then begin to line them up. And if we need a...

30:31 A fourth committee, then they might want to consider that at that time. Yeah, so even go, maybe go as far as, I mean, it's a little extra work, but polling board members, you know, board members to see what they're interested. I mean, I have a, I have an idea who might want to be on the development committee. And also we are missing board, looking ahead to the next item since we're missing a few board members.

30:58 Did you get word from them on which committees they would want to be on, the board members who are absent? Yes. Tom Hodges said he would like to be on the development committee, and Agnes said that she's happy to serve on any of the committees. Do you feel that since a lot of the board wants to see this alongside with the strategic planning, that you're saying there's some things that are coming up that do require them, that maybe we should hold a special meeting for once we can get the draft to?

31:30 You know, accept the strategic planning and then also to assign the committees? That's a good question. I don't think we'll need a special meeting for this item. However, I think we've all seen the draft strategic plan. There's not a lot of guidance around what these committees will do. I think it's what the committees want to work on. It's really going to be committee-led. And so I'm not, it's the pleasure of the board, but I don't know, however you want to move forward.

32:01 Depending on what time, you know, how big of an agenda we have in May, I mean, maybe we could spend some time as a full board flushing out some of the committee deliverables and then send the committees off to do the work. I just think it's so important because one of the beauties about strategic planning is how it is scalable, but the way that it's, the value of it is you're connecting it all back to fundamental statements of goals and objectives.

32:31 And those kinds of things. And I think it would be a little bit of a missed opportunity if we just start diving into something and we can't say, okay, committee, X, Y, or Z, you're doing these things. It's really clear. Because when that work is done, it's building on the steps that's in the strategic document. So when we bring it back, we also need the responsibilities of the contract with the town and also our Sierra Manor Road.

33:03 Project, so the Chodo, how all of this, all the pieces work together, but John, you're correct, when I said the driving force should be the strategic plan. Yeah, it's just. But we need those other elements involved so that we're recognizing what people are going to be, what committees are going to be working on. The podium's open. Further discussion from the board? Podium's open. Sandy Hogan.

33:35 It just seems to me that you keep putting off committees. That's just a, you know, you probably already have people who know who want to be on what committee and they could bring to the exec, to the whole board what they think they should be doing rather than throwing it back on staff. You only have two staff right now, Kirk. I mean, and the whole, everybody. Why something like this? You've got the,

34:04 Draft Strategic Plan. It's not going to bring you anything more information on who should be on what committee and what committee should be doing. You know, maybe the two agenda items are out of order. I don't know. Since both go with the resolution, probably not. But I think I've heard at the last meeting that you have people who know kind of what committee they want to land on.

34:31 And let them flesh out what they think should be done and bring it to you. And if it sounds like they're missing something, well, then stick it in there. But otherwise you're just stalling a decision and putting it off on your executive director who has plenty to do. Anyway, just my comments. Further discussion? Yes. I really like, Stacey, what you were saying about

35:01 At the next meeting, maybe going through a bit of deliverables for the committees as a whole group. What I'm wondering is, because as I look at these committee descriptions that are in the board packet, they came from our discussions from the three strategic planning sessions that we had. I would actually be in favor of putting people on the committees now. I don't think putting anybody on there changes the work that they'll do. And what I actually like is the committees could get together.

35:31 Talk about some of the deliverables that they see and bring them to the meeting. I would be nervous of starting a meeting fresh with brand new committee members in the room saying, what do we want to do? That might take more time than we have at our regular meeting. So I actually am in favor of passing the resolution, putting people on committees, meeting between now and May, and coming to the meeting prepped with some information.

35:57 That would be my suggestion. Doing that before the committees embark on a program of work that the whole board gets an opportunity to get it. And I do agree to Sandy's point. I don't believe that the strategic plan, the draft that we'll receive back, has different information than what we have seen, but it's formatted differently. I'm not sure that the core items that are in there are different, and we should be receiving that at any moment.

36:26 And couldn't, I mean, if there is anybody who's a little bit hesitant on what committee they want to join because they want to see more information or wait for next meeting, couldn't we partially, if people know now, people can decide, like, vote for who, where, people can decide what committee they want to be on and then work on the deliverables and then if someone sees that they're actually liking where that committee's going and they think they'll be a good fit, they can join at the next meeting as well, like, it could be incremental.

36:54 Also, because the committees that I'm looking at the draft strategic plan are reminded there's a communications committee, which seems to be really important. So it's not, again, we're not getting information of how many committees are actually in or going to be in the strategic plan. So it sounds like there's a communications committee. And what was the other one that's not in the list of three right now? Marketing, but isn't that with communication? I don't know. It's marketing, communications, and then...

37:20 In the latest draft I saw there was not a programs committee, but I think that's a comment for the consultant. But wasn't there a reason of not doing all four right away that these three are the fundamental ones for organization and increasing efficacy and then the other ones can be added on later? Yeah, it's my opinion that these were the most important at this time.

37:44 Based on what I remember the strategic planning process, the communications committee is probably one of the most important things we want to do. And I want to have a discussion again with the board members to look at these things and say, which ones do we really think we want to do? Again, look at strategically to say, where do we want to start investing what we're doing? Because if we're, I mean, the communications was something we came back to over and over and over again. I think in terms of the community, it's really, really important to be able to clearly define who we are, what we're doing.

38:11 So it's not an argument for tonight, but it's a discussion I'd like to have. One question. Could the fundraising committee be linked to the communication one, since the fundraising is reaching out people to get funds? Yeah, and you have to have, if you're reaching out to raise money, you've got to have a story to tell. Right. So they're linked. But these are the kinds of discussions I think would be really important to have. Well, Agenda Adam, we've been...

38:39 Touching on agenda item number nine, appoint board members. What is the pleasure of the board? Do you want to appoint members to the Executive Development and Fundraising Committee this evening, or do you want to postpone that, look at the strategic plan, and agendize it for the next meeting? Well, the way the resolution reads, it's...

39:05 Specific to committees, or does it just say? It's forming these specific committees. Yeah, so it does name them. It doesn't just say three committees. Well, it's not all talk at once. Do we have to vote on it? No, it's a staff direction, and we, I mean, it is not. For the resolution? Yeah. I mean, we can create the committee. Yeah, we can either.

39:33 You know, take action now. Recommended, the staff recommends that the board appoint two to three members of the board of directors to serve on each of the three committees. And if we want to carry that over to the next meeting, we can. But kind of in regards to what Sandy was saying as well, I mean, this is a question for staff. If we do put this off next month, is this going to be cumbersome? Is there anything that's coming up that's going to make it cumbersome on you two if these committees aren't formed right now?

40:04 I think it would be fine if we passed the resolution and formed the committees at the May 6th meeting. It might be a big meeting. We have the strategic plan. We might have a strategic discussion around the CHOTO status. We'll have some strategic discussions about what these committees look like. That would be my only concern. I do also really like what Lindsay said about possibly the committees meeting before and kind of like not just

40:34 Being able to discuss things before the actual meeting to kind of get an idea of what they're looking for and bringing it to the board and seeing if the board agrees with what the committee's thinking. Yeah, I just think all these things are going to be really important and the things to do, but I think if you're in a committee and you've got your strategic plan with you, you've got somebody to reference, so everybody's kind of working off the same page. I mean, the resolution right now, there's a fundraising committee, but to your point about the fundraising and communication.

41:02 I mean, that may be opportunity for us to form these committees around what our real priorities are to make sure we go out of the gate with a solid foundation. And we don't have to go back and redo it all again if we have to. We could do some things tonight and then, oh, hey, we want to change it all the next meeting. I think that that could be more of a burden on staff than just maybe waiting. And if there's things, obviously, if there's something coming up with Sierra Manor Road or things like that you need, you can talk to the president of the board and tap a couple of board members and deal with those things as we need to.

41:30 Well, I think we, even if the committees aren't formed tonight and we don't appoint people, we can still do some of the work you're talking about, Lindsay, if you're interested in being, you know, bring your ideas to the meeting and be ready to discuss them. Yeah, and it might even make sense to put together a little working committee around when the draft strategic plan comes in, which hopefully is going to come in, you know, in the next week or so, that Kirk, you could tap a couple board members and say, let's look at this thing. We know how to set some committees up.

41:57 Get that kind of lined up, make it, and then come back with a recommendation of the board that says, okay, here's the strategic plan. We think these are the committees to hear the things that we want to do from the strategic plan, and we can really hit the ground running. I think that's a good idea. Also, maybe the board members that want to be in the development committee, they know that they want to be there, and they can be the ones going to CURSTOP so that they can discuss the Sierra Mentor, and they'll be more prepared.

42:25 Yeah, just informally. Informally, before we get into the whole Brown Act structure, they can start just working consistent with the Brown Act, but work with staff and Kirk and start getting those things figured out. Do you think you have a direction? If someone could just clarify the staff direction, I'd appreciate it. That was a good discussion. Now, where do we go from here? I would suggest that staff direction is that we postpone passing

42:56 Resolution 1901 to the May 6th meeting, at which time we also appoint members to basically at the May meeting, let's create the committees and appoint members to the committee. The only problem being is the resolution is specific to committees. So if we want to have to rewrite the resolution based on our conversation, can we

43:26 Have a resolution in here, and when we pass it, it's with name changes and different things and things like that? I'm just a stupid question. Why do we need a resolution to do this? Is it a bylaw thing? Yes. Because this is a standing, not an ad hoc committee. Yes. Okay. We passed a resolution for our ad hoc committees as well. Oh, okay. But we could have a resolution to your point where it's got some blanks in there and say the committees.

43:53 Fill them in with the motion, with the resolution, with the membership, fill it in with that, we could do something like that. So without saying, yeah, the resolution would just say the creation of standing committees to be decided. I do think it would be a good idea once we do get the draft strategic plan for if there are a few of us who could get together and kind of look through that to kind of do some of the heavy lifting before the next meeting.

44:28 Yeah, so we show up prepared to get it together. That could even be in the agenda packet. It could be the recommendations of the president of the board and various board members hear the recommendations for the committees, hear the recommended assignments, and we just start like that. You would like me to convene that meeting? To convene an informal pre-committee committee? A discussion group? A committee for the committee. Okay.

44:58 Yes, please. Thank you. Well, before we move off this agenda item, let me see, and I know we have two people missing. I know Tom wants to be on the development committee, and he'd be excellent because of his experience and everything else. So let me put people on the spot. Yeah, development. Do you want to be on the development? I'm interested in communications and fundraising, but because I am, you know, the town council assignment, if

45:32 The president or members of the board want to put me somewhere else. I'll go wherever you want me to go. John, you're very good at that. And I totally support it. Okay. Thank you. You being on that committee. Good. That's of real interest to me. Well, the way I read this is vice chair, I'm on the executive committee. Yeah, we're both on it. Okay. Yeah. Are there any... I'm happy to serve on, by the way. I enjoy talking about governance and...

46:00 Performance evaluation, all these things. So, yeah. I had a question following that. So, is that, for the Executive Committee, are those the only people who can serve on it, or can anybody else be on the Executive Committee? It's our discretion. Two or more, as long as less than a quorum. The description in the resolution described it as the officers, so it would be the President, Vice President, Treasurer, and the Secretary for the Executive Committee.

46:30 And nobody else? Correct. What's our quorum? Five. Five. Okay. I'm sorry, say again the Secretary and the Treasurer. Did you say the Executive Director is both? We don't have a Treasurer. Okay. And the Executive Director serves as the Secretary and is a non-voting. Right. Executive Director doesn't count for the quorum. Committee? I would be interested in the Fundraising Committee.

47:03 And then also I had thought about the executive committee, but if that is full, then I'm happy on the fundraising committee. Fundraising. I am not sure yet because I was really interested in the one about like getting programs up and running since I think that's where I have more specialty in. So I would like to wait until next meeting to see if that's actually something that comes up and if not, then I will join a different one. But you're interested in having a programming committee, it sounds like.

47:35 Well, I just remember we had discussed if we were going to do the management program or all these new programs that we were thinking of adding to Mammoth Lakes Housing and so having a committee kind of form those and I would be really interested in doing that. But if that doesn't become a committee, for whatever reason, I will figure out a different one.

48:00 If there is, it sounds like there is, you know, interest from other board members serving on the executive committee, is that something you want to think of since we don't have a treasurer, so there would effectively only be two board members on the executive committee, would we want to add a third board member? I'd vote to kick Lindsay upstairs, you know. Yeah, I think, I think that's probably acceptable according to our bylaws.

48:25 According to our bylaws, we have an officer position, we just don't have anybody allocated. And these aren't standing assignments, I think. No, no, no. We're just talking, we're beginning to formulate. No, if you want to change later, I mean, that's fine. Okay, further discussion on agenda item number nine. Patricia, you have anything else you want to add? Because it actually is both of the eight and nine.

48:58 Slipped over. I don't have anything else, thank you. Does the board have anything else they want to add? No, looking forward to this. I think it's going to be a lot of fun and really interesting. And to make sure we have time in the next meeting to kind of flesh all this out, get everybody where they want to go. Yeah. Okay, we'll move to Agenda Item 10, Mammoth Lake Housing Monthly Update. Patricia? Yes, thank you. This is our monthly update, which includes data for January, February, and March.

49:31 I have a couple of highlights if there's no questions on how many people we've spoken to, the rental waiting list or the website. With the rental wait list, do you know of why the wait list went down?

49:48 Yes, yes. So periodically we get the property manager sends us a processed wait list and sometimes people are no longer reachable via their cell phone or their mailing address and so we delete them from the list. And so that number reflects that process including the additions of the new people that we process during that time period. Thank you.

50:22 There's a lot of information in here that you've already seen, and so I wanted to highlight some items under number six, which is page five of the staff report, under additional funding opportunities. I just wanted to announce that Mono County was awarded home first-time homebuyer funds in the amount of $500,000, and that's the result of a grant that was applied for in coordination with Mammoth Lakes Housing. So we'll be working to set up that grant with Mono County.

50:52 And then hopefully have it set up for lending, ideally I want to say in the next couple of months, but it could be up to six months before those funds are available. And those dollars could be used for? First-time homebuyers to purchase a home within unincorporated Mono County for 80% AMI and below. And then I have an update on the home grant that Mammoth Lakes Housing...

51:23 Application that we submitted for 238 Sierra Manor Road for $1.9 million. We weren't awarded in this round for that grant opportunity. As the board knows, we authorized the expenditure of some reserve funding to get ready for the next rounds, and so we're working on the architecture and engineering services. We're in the process of getting some lead and asbestos reporting done so that when we have all these things checked off the list, we'll

51:52 Be able to score higher in the next round. And the next rounds for CDBG and home will be in August and September. So it might not seem that soon, but we're in a little bit of a time crunch. That's what I have for those items. Oh, I did want to mention for 238 Sierra Manor Road, IMACA had submitted a California Emergency Solutions and Housing application for the continuum of care, which is

52:25 In our region, it's in Yomono and Alpine counties. And they had included $30,000 for operating reserves for our project in the grant application, and they were awarded. So this is our first funding partnership that we've been successful in achieving for that project. So that's really exciting. Is there a time limit to use that money? Yes, and it's usually three years. So there's another race to the finish line. So we didn't get the...

52:56 The funding, the 1.9, what feedback did they give you specifically as to why the application wasn't accepted? So our application didn't meet the point threshold, so we were missing some of the criteria, which would have been... What were the point areas that we lost point? Plans, 50% complete plans. We don't have 50% complete plans. A lead and asbestos report we didn't have at that time.

53:26 We didn't have a market study. All these things were points and they were included in our last staff report where we asked for the allocation of funding to procure some of those things. So did we know those criteria before or do we didn't know that now? Was that a surprise? Yeah. No, it wasn't a surprise, but you don't really know what the other people are going to score. So there is a self-score sheet which we completed.

53:54 We actually self-scored a little bit lower than the points that they gave us, so that was good. But you just don't really know what the other people are going to score. So now we kind of have a sense of where the other applications we're scoring. We'll have a better sense in the next round. So is there anything else in addition that would help us than what you just mentioned having done or completed by then? The physical needs assessment or that.

54:20 Is that part of that? Yeah, there's like some studies and professional services that we have to procure. Most of the ones that, they were all listed in that staff report that we provided, so it was those items that I think will get us more points in the next round, if we choose to apply. So, Mr. Chairman, on this topic, I think it's important to focus in on this.

54:46 And I'm hoping that we can maybe start having this item as a, this project as a regular agenda item, because this falls within our responsibilities at Choto. And on this topic, so the town manager of the town has put together a, it's a modest group, but Sandra Moberly has been appointed to be the point of contact from a staff perspective to MLH. And myself as the council representative, so

55:13 So Patricia's got, we've all got a reliable point of contact with the town. And so on behalf of that, I would like, I think it's important that we start really focusing in on this project. And we start doing whatever we can to start getting this thing ready to get people living in it. And in conversations with the town manager, at least, we discussed the two $50,000 things, the deed restriction,

55:42 Those two pieces, that... That $101,000. Yeah, that chunk of money, that from the town's perspective, if that money could be redirected and could be useful to go into the further development of 238 Sierra Manor Road to help advance that project and get it down the line to get it closer to being ready for occupants, that's something that the town would certainly be interested in considering.

56:09 There wouldn't be any problem with the town if the board wanted to go in that direction, because we're talking about two units versus potentially 11 or something, right? And that might be something to take a look at and to consider, and I think it's, I think, to go back to leverage, again, leverage our choto to go back to those funds if we want to go back in August or something like that to do the work necessary to check those things off.

56:30 And maybe try to help position that project. So I bring that forward just to the staff and the board to say that that's something that the town would certainly be interested in pursuing if that would be the will of the board and staff here. Well, I think it goes to Patricia. I think it's a good suggestion. And the question is, do we have the wherewithal on the Sierra Manor property to keep moving forward? It's eight months out. Do we want to sit on that money for that length of time or utilize it?

57:00 Yeah, I would, again, I defer to staff, I'd say if we could put that money to work, if the grant application's back in August, you said? That's not that far away. Yeah, but we could take that money, flip it around right now and start pointing it at that to say, look, let's start spending that money to get that thing ready for another run at that grant application. Don't we need to wait to talk about that money and tell our agenda item about that money? I don't know if we have an agenda item for that money. We have an agenda item about the middle income.

57:30 Oh, okay, I'm sorry. Okay, yeah, we could do it that way, sure, if you want. Because I'd like to have a much more thorough discussion about that. Perfect. Okay, I brought it up as part of this discussion. But I do, I support this concept that we have, a standing agenda item about this, about 238 Sierra Manor. So that, I mean, to me, yeah, this seems like this needs to be an organizational priority. I'm sure it is in this strategic plan. But, you know, that we have the space to talk about it and give guidance and if there is a way to...

57:57 You know, prioritize, you know, focusing on that rather than creating new programs, then we do it. How much money did we allot to 238 Sierra Manna Road in our last meeting, if you remember off the top of your head, to work on the $40,000? $40,000. Okay, so we have given a chunk, but not as much as $100,000. Okay. Well, it's a budget priority discussion. We're to move the dollars, and that is an ongoing issue. Sure.

58:29 Further discussion? I have a couple more updates. Under item 7B, I just wanted to note that condominium median home sales prices are up about 6% year to date, and that single family home prices are down about 13% year to date. Just up above that, about the SB2 planning grants? Yes. Just for my own education, don't the four examples that are there, like buy right zoning?

59:00 And what is that? That would be if you wanted to do an affordable housing development in a certain zone that you would have that availability and it wouldn't be at the discretion of the jurisdiction. Thank you. Yeah, I just had two more updates which you might find interesting. So I'm continuing to coordinate on the MLH town contract.

59:32 The attorneys spoke, and then there was some additional back and forth. I'm waiting on the revised comments from the town, and then I believe we will have the contract ad hoc committee meet to discuss those comments, and then bring that final draft back to the board. Patricia, was it unexpected that there was this, that it took this long, or that there were such extensive comments? Yes, so, yes.

1:00:05 Our committee had some concerns about ownership of materials that we produce and then the restriction on the 10% reserves that we can retain. Those are some I can think of off the top of my head. I haven't seen the comments back from the town. And so I think I'd just like to

1:00:32 Update the committee on what the results of their concerns are and then have them present that to the full board. So this would be, this is the contract correct with the town? Yeah, I was going to ask about that. So can we have that as an agenda item for the next meeting? Yes. The status of the contract? We have to approve it. Right, but it's been, I don't understand why it's not done yet, but I just want to. Yeah, I thought we had the 10%, I thought we had come to terms with that. But I think that, I think our lawyer.

1:01:02 Had questions about it as well on a higher law level. So but that could be agendized on the next agenda? Yes. Okay. Yeah, and so and then it also did take a really long time for the attorneys to talk. So and then I just wanted to give an update regarding our internship availability for that staff position. We've had some interest in the internship and we'll be scheduling interviews in the next couple of weeks.

1:01:31 So that's very exciting. Yay. I had one question on the Mono County potential for 2018 CDBG application for 238 Sierra Manor Road. Yes. Do you have any more details on that, or it's not due for a while, so maybe? No, we'll be waiting for the notice of funding availability to come out, which I believe, well, I don't know, but it might come out in May.

1:01:59 And then we'll see what the requirements are for the shovel-ready components or if it might be different. And then we will approach Mona County to see if they would like to partner. So would that be just in addition to the, I guess my question, what would that fund for that project?

1:02:20 So the total development costs for that project are approximately $5 million. In the last round for CDBG, the total you could apply for was $3 million. So I think we'll just apply for CDBG and for home and see which ones we get. Yeah. And they can work together if you get, if you're funded. That's correct. That's what's good, yeah. Will the projects that we're working on that we found out with the home grant that we needed, are they similar to what we will need?

1:02:47 For CDBG, or do you think there are other for points and things? Are there other things we should be looking at before August to complete? Yeah, the criteria are similar, and we had looked at that before asking for the funds for the readiness components in the last budget ask. I had a question about the rehabilitation programs. Sure. I was just curious how someone's eligible for those programs.

1:03:17 So for the CDBG rehabilitation programs, you can be an owner-occupant and you need to be low income, so 80% or below AMI. And that's a loan program. And then you could also be an owner-investor and own rental properties, but your tenants have to be low income. And then you have to agree to, depending on how much you borrow, you have to agree to a rent limitation agreement to serve

1:03:48 So let me be blunt. If somebody has a fourplex and it's run down, if they borrow the money, if they're renting it now and it's open-ended, but if they borrow the money, all of a sudden it becomes restricted. They can upgrade their building, but then we begin to say, wait a minute, the rent is 120%. So we don't get a lot of takers for this because the fact is that

1:04:18 Somebody that owns property doesn't want that restriction. How long is that restriction for? How long is it? Yeah, like if we, if someone does utilize that money and they become restricted, is there like, it's restricted for 10 years or is it for until the, like, are, do you want to answer that? Do you know? I don't remember the, it depends on the dollar amount that you've borrowed. So I think if you borrow up to $37,000, it's five years and if it's more than $37,000, it's 10 years. Yeah, so it's not forever.

1:04:50 But we haven't had any takers. Further discussion? I've got a little topic. Yes. So, last week, I was on a chairlift with some people, and they are, huh? Yes. And these are housing folks from Oakland, and they're, let me just start talking, and I advise that the town owns 25 acres in the middle of the town. They perked up, and they're very interested in finding out about the project.

1:05:22 And this is a challenge that falls on MLH a little bit, but probably more so on the town. The town put together a program called Momenta, which was intended to properly integrate and prioritize what web pages and web content the town owns has got the proper information. So I told these people about the project, shared some names and emails. They went off and got on Google and they searched it. And they came up with the Shady Rest.

1:05:50 Page on the MLH website took that as being that that is the current status of the project in the town. And I just say, oh, no, actually, that's not, you know, you know, it's blah, blah, blah. And I think I'm hoping that we can get Patricia and town staff to start working to get a credible front-facing page on the project so that, I mean, MLH can keep, you can keep the page under the things we've done in the past, but there's notification that says, for the most current information on this project,

1:06:20 Please go here. And we've got to start working with the town staff to get that page up so that when they're, this is a very compelling story that this town's got these 25 acres. If we've got developers, designers, architects, people who want to work on this project, to be able to send them to a webpage on the town website that gives them the information that they need, and it's designed to be front-facing to the public, to interested parties.

1:06:43 So I'm hoping that we can kind of work together to get that in place. Because there are a lot of talented people that are interested in working on this thing. I think we seem to get to make sure the communications are in place, consistent with the community housing action plan and all the rest of it, with the town being the lead developer or whatever. Yeah, I really appreciate that comment, John. And I've been doing some website upgrades in the last couple of weeks, and I did see that on the page today. And I'm like, okay, I need to deal with this. Where can I put it? How does it go?

1:07:12 And so I appreciate you reminding me about that. But I am constantly working on updating the website. We've got a newsletter, sign up for our newsletter now, and we're also getting a donate button. So just baby steps. I understand. It's a lot of work. But also I'm a little concerned that the web traffic coming to our site, it's just falling off a cliff. And that's something that maybe the fundraising communications...

1:07:37 Committee, if we get that together, maybe that's something that from the strategic plan, we could put that in there and start looking at that and figure out. And again, I would defer everybody to this momenta plan, which is a town the town council adopted a couple years ago, and we still haven't implemented it yet. But that's a great framework to work from to start figuring this stuff out.

1:07:55 Just a note, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department, we do have a webpage for the parcel on the town's website, and it does reference the MLH. It has as background kind of all of the planning projects that have been done. So I'll give you, so it does have your work as a background in the background section. So I'll send that to you, and we can maybe kind of work to make sure people are out of the right way. Yeah, and I just, and I...

1:08:20 Again, the idea that it needs to be a front-facing page. Because if I go to the town's website and search the parcel, I'm getting like five or six different pages. I think it would be a great idea to put an icon or a logo or something on the landing page of the town website so that, hey, go to the town of Mammoth Lakes webpage and then click on that button and you go right there.

1:08:40 Because otherwise you end up just searching through an archive of hundreds and hundreds of documents. And again, a developer, someone's excited. They're not getting the information they need that says, I want to be engaged in the process. But that's something we could work on. Okay. Thank you. John, does the town have an IT department or people person that works on the website? Or is it just for this woman? Well, from the IT side, yes. I think, but I'm not sure exactly how the town organizes the content around the website. Okay. And I think this is the kind of thing that

1:09:08 If Council's making a suggestion, look, give us a nice page that if Kirk and I, we run into someone and they want to know about this project, hey, go here and they'll get that kind of, we can figure it out, but I think the staffs do it by department, by department, I just, I don't know. Okay. I think so, the department kind of does its own thing, but Sandra, she could help us if we can figure this out. Yeah, there's not one person that we could go to to say, because I know at one point we talked about making sure that...

1:09:32 Everything looked the same. Maybe that was through that moment. The momentum project. I think at this point we just talked with Sandra and Patricia figured that out, how to make sure that we can tell the story of what we're done. Thank you. That's it. All right. We're agenda item 11, Mammoth annual report, agenda item 12, the annual regional point in time count. Patricia?

1:10:08 I like it. Yeah. Sorry. Sorry. I jumped ahead. I don't have a copy. The annual report. Oh, yeah. Sure. So this is our annual report. It's usually issued at the end of the calendar year. So here it is in March. Or what are we in? April. I think some highlights for me are the first-time homebuyer loans that we were successful in completing.

1:10:41 And the quote from the Zubiati family about how excited they are to have an affordable home. And then remembering Larry and Bill, I think was a highlight for me. And I'm just excited to share it with the community. Questions? Do we print hard copies of these and distribute, or how do you distribute to the community? So I sent an email to all the homebuyers that we served in 2018 with an attachment.

1:11:14 I sent it out on our listserv. It's on our website. I put it on Facebook. There's hard copies in the back for the public this evening. I will probably provide public comment at town council on Wednesday. And we have hard copies in the office. That's great. Thank you for producing this. Just the kind of information we need to communicate and get the word out about what all the great stuff that Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing.

1:11:49 Agenda item 12. We'll move to annual regional point in time. Thank you. I just provided this item as an informational item to the board. The annual point in time count is a count of both sheltered and unsheltered homeless persons on a single night in January, and it's administered and coordinated by IMACA, who is the administrative entity for the regional continuum of care.

1:12:24 which serves the region of Inyo, Mono, and Alpine counties. IMACA has been really great at coordinating or making sure that we have a coordinated effort in the region and so involving partners like Mammoth Lakes Housing, Mono County Behavioral Health who offers a lot of services and other volunteers and others to make sure that we're accounting everybody. Not only do

1:12:57 Does the count include the work on the night of the count, counting actual people who are homeless, but it also includes a service-based count of people who may enter a service entity like Mammoth Lakes Housing looking for services who are homeless. Those people are also included in the count for the seven days after the count.

1:13:22 Mammoth Lakes Housing staff encountered two of those individuals during the week after the count, and we included their surveys to IMACA with the rest of the surveys. I just provided a little graph here about the increase in homelessness over the last year has been 36%. And then in image two, I think there's a typo under 2019, sheltered, I believe it should be 17 individuals instead of 15.

1:13:52 And then I just wanted to note that IMACA estimates in areas that were not surveyed due to inaccessibility in the region that there are an additional 52 homeless individuals. What made them inaccessible? Was it roads or...? Yeah, usually it's capacity to get to places, maybe not enough police officers to accompany volunteers.

1:14:21 So they guessed. Yeah, it's an estimate. I mean, it doesn't take it or leave it. They maybe go at a different time. And so I just provided IMACA's report that they produced as a reference for the board, and that's all I have. Questions? I just want to make a couple of comments on it to first thank Patricia and Mammoth Lakes Housing staff for participating in this.

1:14:55 You know, the increased number, obviously we, I don't think it's any surprise to anyone that homelessness is on the increase everywhere, including Mammoth Lakes and Mono County and the Eastern Sierra, but the intensified effort by the continuum of care to actually go out and count.

1:15:16 Really has paid off. We're getting a better understanding of how many people are out there experiencing homelessness. It is more than a guess. It was a guess probably back in 2015 or 16. But having a better idea leads directly to more funding from the federal government for this. And I think I've advocated for having Patricia present.

1:15:42 Present this report to our board, because I think we should be thinking about how programs, speaking of programs, Giselle, how COC programs or potential programs that we would want to create can work together, you know, to, COC will get people, we hope, you know, in immediate short-term housing perhaps, and then how can Mammoth Lakes Housing then, you know, bring them through to get them permanent housing.

1:16:11 You know, in a stable situation. But we all should really be thinking about this. It's going to be difficult for the continuum of care to find places to temporarily house people experiencing homelessness. It's hard enough in big cities, you know, to find hotel rooms. You know, I think we can all imagine, you know, here in Mammoth in the middle of winter, you're probably not going to find a lot of hotel owners that want to... Question?

1:16:40 Although, I have an idea about that. But I think we should all just be, so I encourage all of us to just think about that. And if we have any ideas of any type of housing, whether it's motel rooms, rooms in houses, I mean, we know it's tough, but the continuum of care has funding to pay

1:17:08 Hotel owners, landlords, homeowners, you know, to secure basically a space in their property for people experiencing homelessness to get them out of their, in our case, usually not off the streets, out of their cars and into sheltered situations. So I think if, you know, if there were any desire by this board for follow-up to have the, have Larry Emerson or somebody else from the COC present, but I mean, here's the basic.

1:17:36 Stats. They're working hard to try to, you know, find some kind of housing. If we're not really successful in locating anything, you know, here in Mono County, in Mammoth, it'll probably, you know, they'll end up spending the funds in Inyo County, which is great. I mean, we want, at least the money's there, and we want it to get spent, we want people to get housed, but I would love to see us actually do something with this, you know, respond to this in a way where people are actually getting housed.

1:18:04 In our town, in our county. I'll just give a little bit of an update. So I have been trying to coordinate really closely with Larry, and so we did get that $30,000 for our project through funding that is from homelessness programs, which is awesome. And Larry's encouraged us to maybe submit and ask for additional money in the next round, which just came out.

1:18:29 And so Larry will be coming to speak at our board meeting, not in May, but in June. Great. Can you just a little bit of background on the funding for the COC? Is it federal money that goes through the state, or is it state money? Federal money, right? It's both. It's both. I'm just wondering, because with what's going on the federal level with these kinds of programs,

1:18:53 They may not belong for this world, but I know it's a very high priority in the state level. Yeah, I'm not sure exactly. They have access to a lot of different program sources, and I don't know exactly which ones are federal and which ones are state, but there's like a six-page document of all the funding that they can access. But is CSC, is that a state agency? It's a regional agency. Through the state? It's my understanding. It's designated. It's a high program. Yeah. Okay.

1:19:22 They often fund the state, and then the state, you know, the feds are funding the states, and then the states are distributing the program. Yeah, the states are running the program. So just, any other information you got from a county level, what resources are you funding for the state? Well, I think maybe when Larry comes, he can give us some of the technical details, but I could, you know, they have a website. I don't have it right in front of me, but...

1:19:45 We could send that around, and that could probably answer a lot of your questions, how the funding flows in. But it's just, this is really, I think, Patricia, this is the first year our continuum of care has received funding, or at least maybe, it's a substantial amount of funding. More than. Yeah. And a limited, as you mentioned before, a limited time in which to spend that funding. So I feel pretty motivated to get, let's get out and try to help them locate some places.

1:20:15 My one question about just about the emergency shelter hotel motel vouchers. What how many nights is that? Do you guys will find that out maybe in June from? Yeah, Larry could probably give you the details on the program, but I don't think it's very many. Yeah, just a couple of. Yeah, I think to me, it seemed he can elaborate on this, but the big focus was to try to.

1:20:42 They have enough money to secure longer term leases on places. So say it was a motel that the COC would rent out two rooms permanently, basically, you know, for two years while they have this funding and, you know, to house people, maybe different people. Yeah. Okay. Interesting. Just one comment on that. I'm sure it's been investigated or even known about, but Sandy Hogan, I'm sorry.

1:21:12 In South Lake Tahoe, you know, in a resort community, the problem with hotel rooms or motel rooms in a resort community is that they don't want to give it up because they get more from tourists. But in South Lake Tahoe, and I wish I knew more about the background, but I knew a little bit about it, it's something called the Warm Room, and it is a facility that is designed to kind of operate like a

1:21:37 For those of you that were in Europe many years ago, youth hostels, you know, you had to be in by 10 o'clock and out by 8 in the morning, but it allowed people to come in and get out of the weather without inconveniencing motel rooms and, you know, owners and things like that. So probably if, you know, I'm sure that behavioral health or some of the other departments probably know about it, but it'd be worth looking into how they

1:22:07 What they did, or did they, I don't even know if they leased a facility or what, but it's something worth looking into because I know that that is housing, you know, in South Lake Tahoe, there are a lot more homeless than we've had, I think, but the same types of weather. So anyway, just a comment. There was a similar thing, Sandy, this winter in Mammoth, in the cold spell that we had, I believe it was January, February sometime, at the high school. Right. In the gym.

1:22:36 Put out, and it was a similar thing. You had to be in by time and out. Right, right. And I think this one's more permanent. It's open only in the winter, not in the summer. But anyway, yeah, that's right. I did read about that. Thank you. Just a follow-up comment. The high school opened the gym, which was great and everything. It's just getting the word to those people. Yeah. That's the hard part, getting the word out there to those people that are homeless or living in the car. Any other discussions or questions?

1:23:10 Then we'll move to, it's interesting that some of the comments I underline in this is that, you know, on the notes, no couch surfing in Mono County this year. But I know somebody that allows people to sleep on their couch. I don't. You did. When? A while back. So, yes, I do know people then.

1:23:35 That allow people to sleep on their floor or their couch. I think with that it's probably finding those people in the right period of time. And the other thing is that I have to agree with the comments over here that advocates and service providers argue that scheduling the event in the winter creates an undercount. And I think that is so true. I mean, it's just so hard. They did, you know, it's just... There's a lot of people that are here in the summertime and they can...

1:24:05 Yeah, then you can find out. Then the account's going to go way up because a lot of people are camping, living in the woods and cars and everything else. Let's move to Agenda Item 13, Latino Housing Coalition. Thank you. I have brought this item to you this evening by request from Mono County Behavioral Health who has approached Mammoth Lakes Housing to help

1:24:36 Host, I guess, a staff person so that they can develop a Latino housing coalition. Mono County Behavioral Health received a one-time allocation of homeless mentally ill outreach and treatment program funding from California, the state, and the staff have identified the need for this coalition to provide a forum for underserved and underrepresented members of the community who are struggling with housing and mental illness.

1:25:04 As we know, housing is a critical factor in people's mental health. People with housing instability are at a greater risk of mental health and substance abuse problems. And good quality, affordable, and safe housing is a vital component to our community's mental health and our ability to serve our visitors. Mono County has proposed to allocate a one-time commitment of approximately $17,000 to fund this.

1:25:36 Staff position to work to develop a Latino housing coalition. I just wanted to note that the Latino community makes up 27% of Mono County's population and 37% of the population of Mammoth Lakes. So their staff identified this as a need and felt like this allocation of funding would help address that need. Their original proposal was that

1:26:08 Mammoth Lakes Housing would hire a contract employee that would work solely on this project for approximately 18 months. And it was after some conversations I had with Amanda Greenberg that I proposed that perhaps we could share this person and grow some capacity at MLH as well. That is what the staff report describes for you this evening.

1:26:36 Mono County would pay Mammoth Lakes Housing 15% of their contribution for the administration of that employee, so for the payroll taxes and the management of that. And then Mammoth Lakes Housing, if it's the pleasure of the board, would pay for 60% of that employee. It's proposed to be a part-time position, so it would be approximately 20 hours a week, and the staff person would be required to track their time.

1:27:09 Per project so that we could bill Mono County appropriately. And then Mammoth Lakes Housing would pay for the time spent on Mammoth Lakes Housing projects. I provided some information about our financials which you just reviewed. We have some, we're projected to have some budget savings. We'll get the final numbers at the end of the fourth quarter and we'll have a more in-depth discussion around how to utilize those funds. But so because we have some

1:27:40 Revenue from property management, transition of staff, having lowered staff capacity and low expenditures in deed restriction retention, we have some cost savings. I provided two scenarios for costs. Discussions with Mono County Behavioral Health and myself have estimated that this person might make between $16 and $20 an hour.

1:28:12 And so I provided the breakout of what that would look like. If it's not the board's interest at this time to grow staff capacity at Mammoth Lakes Housing in this way, Mono County would still like to use their money to start up this Latino housing coalition and have that staff person housed at Mammoth Lakes Housing. So they'd still like the board to consider Mammoth Lakes Housing hiring a contract employee and Mono County would give Mammoth Lakes...

1:28:43 Housing, the money to pay that person to do that work. The management of the employee would fall on Mammoth Lakes Housing primarily, however, Mono County Behavioral Health still wants to play a pretty big role in the contract deliverables that that person would be providing. So there'd be some meetings between that staff person, MLH, and Mono County Behavioral Health to keep them on track.

1:29:11 I've provided the draft position description, which includes input from Mammoth Lakes Housing, Mono County Behavioral Health, and their cultural outreach committee who reviewed the draft description. It's come a long way from where it started, but it probably could use a little bit more work. And Amanda's on maternity leave, but she'll be back next month, so we can fine-tune the position description if there are comments from the board. I think that's...

1:29:42 That's all I have, and I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions? Comments? So how would this position benefit you in the office by creating this coalition? Well, I think that the coalition is a really necessary and ambitious idea. I think we've needed one for a really long time. I would hope that this person would be successful, and if funding didn't...

1:30:17 If there wasn't funding to continue the position, I hope that they would develop it in a way that it was sustainable somehow into the future. I think that I advocated for MLH staff time because we need it. We've added a lot of work programs to our current town contract for the same amount of revenue. With these cost savings, I think it's a strategic move to add a little bit of capacity.

1:30:46 I think answering the phone, just greeting people at the door, intaking applications are all things that this person could help with and take a little pressure off of Diane and myself. I think the position is this need, addressing this need has been there for a long time. And so I think moving forward with it is the right direction. I completely agree. I think it would be a good use of our funds and I think it would, you know,

1:31:20 It's a good start in building our partnerships with other people or agencies within the community and it's addressing a really important need. I also agree that it's a good idea, especially if you're going to have funds from the health department and you won't have to pay. Yeah, because we're really talking about the projection for 18 years, 18 months.

1:31:48 At the highest wage, $20,592. The question I kind of ask myself is similar, John, with you talking the homebuyer assistance money, is it better spent elsewhere on different things? And if we do have leftover money, how do we best use that? And I sort of came up with, well, would we want to save it and put that toward 238 Sierra Manor Road or put it toward the homebuyer assistance program to boost that, things like that. But then I came back to if we don't have staff time to

1:32:18 Work on those projects. It doesn't matter how much money we have. So I also would agree that I think at this time getting another body in the office to help to free up, exactly like you said, free up Diane, free up Patricia, seems like it's worth it for me right now. So I agree with the consensus. I think it makes sense. I'm a little concerned that the scope of the deliverables is a little fuzzy.

1:32:47 And I think that they definitely need some tightening up. So that, Patricia, you say that this person can help in the office doing those kinds of things. I don't see that in there right now. I see a lot of organizational development, which is important. These things need to be happening. But I think I'd like to see this come back with a much more specific focus on exactly what this person is going to be doing, but also talking about in terms of the, and to value and to prioritize the on-the-ground efforts that I think that we're trying to get at in terms of outreach, in terms of communication,

1:33:17 Doing things rather than just kind of building another kind of sub-organizational structure. The second piece is I'd be interested in understanding the sustainability piece of this. So if we're building databases, if we're building outreach programs, if we're building, which is all good stuff. I mean, it's one person and not get a whole lot done. But to have it represented in this as to, okay, when the position runs out, where's that going to live? Who's going to own this stuff? And I don't mean to put it on the county, but I'm hoping the behavioral health.

1:33:44 You know, it's nice to be able to kind of offload and say, well, let's let the non-profit house position, that's fine, but over the long term, that the things that this thing is going to produce, it's going to have a home down the road. You know, it's not going to be like the position stops and then it's, well, now what do we do with it? It's like we start laying out it. So in your discussion with modern county behavioral health, figure out, okay, what's going to happen after 12 months or 18 months so that we're building a program that's going to have some legs over time.

1:34:10 Just to address some of your comments and maybe get a little more feedback. So part of the position description is to, and this came from Mono County Behavioral Health, is to define a sustainability plan. But you think that should be already defined beforehand? Yeah, I think, I mean, I don't see how it's that hard to do. I think that if behavioral health is putting some staff on that, you work on this, like in a first initial meeting, you should be able to say, if we're going to produce

1:34:41 Outreach materials, contact lists, and things like this, and make sure it's clear, okay, where is this going to live when this is done? I think that, I don't think we need to spend 18 months trying to figure that out. Well, I think that their hope is that the coalition would sustain itself. How? From leadership. Money. I mean, seriously, I mean, who's working in money?

1:35:01 Yeah, I mean, where's the money going to come from? How are we going to do this? Yeah. Who's going to own it? Yeah, exactly. I think that, you know, if they're going to take it and we're going to be a partner with them, but they're going to be the leadership organizing the meetings and everything else.

1:35:16 Oh, and then just quickly, the second work program item is office administration support, which includes answering the phone and application intake, outreach and marketing, et cetera, as needed, but you think that should be more specific? Well, just to support MLH staff. Yes. So it's very clear that this person is helping you guys with, and I already put in so many how many hours a week or what percentage of time, so that's clear. Thank you. Sorry. Yeah.

1:35:44 I absolutely support this concept, but I think we're a ways off from approving anything. I think we need to hear more from our behavioral health department about what the goals are for the, and the, I mean,

1:35:58 Let me give them a plug. They've done incredible work. The Cultural Outreach Committee, they've been very successful in building, in taking state funding and mandated programs and doing creative things that have turned out to be successful and sustainable. So no doubt that they could do this, but we need to understand what, you know, what is, what is the, better, what is the goal for them? You know, the county.

1:36:25 I think everybody's aware the behavioral health has a permanent supportive housing development concept in the works here in Mammoth. How does this all fit together? How does the Latino Housing Coalition help us meet our goals in the Community Housing Action Plan to make sure we're effectively reaching out to all members of our community? I mean, we don't have to have all these answers, but I think we need to have a...

1:36:51 Discussion probably with this board and with behavioral health department leadership in really understanding what it is we're trying to do. Absolutely, whatever we add on needs to build capacity in the office and help you get your work done. Especially in this area. Yeah, absolutely. But I think we'd have a better idea of what we're doing if we...

1:37:17 Meet with Behavioral Hall, you know, understanding Amanda's out of the office. But I think we need to flesh this out a bit more. Yeah, I think also we could go back to one of the committees and then say which maybe it fits in with the purview of the committee that could help with this. But I really appreciate you bringing up the Community Housing Action Plan to get this. Look to the Community Housing Action Plan, find a citation in there that this supports and say we're doing this because it supports this. So again, it will help maintain focus.

1:37:46 Further discussion from the board? Yeah, I just, I mean, I understand we need, no, I don't actually, I don't, there are 16 line items in the job description of specifically what that person would do. I think it's fairly clear, and the money, I guess there's two things here, the Latino Housing Coalition person,

1:38:11 Is not funded by MLH. So as far as going back to the Community Housing Action Plan to ensure that that's part of it, it's not, I guess for me, behavioral health can do what they want. They're just asking, because it's a housing person, to sit it in our office. Well, they're asking for some money from us to... But only for, they're only going to give us money for this for one time, so that's... Yeah, a problem.

1:38:38 Yeah. But also, again, if we're developing things like outreach materials, communication, things like that, and that serves the identified goal or objective of the Community Housing Action Plan, let's make that nexus. Yeah. Because that may lead to more support down the road. So I'm just looking for opportunities to make sure that we get to sustainability. This thing's going to be able to stand on its own down the road. I think to remember, though, that if the wages we're looking at is for the full 20-hour-a-week person. So if we pull that back to be eight hours a week,

1:39:08 That money out from our end goes way down. Is that, am I reading that correctly? That we're, I mean, I just want to make sure we're clear. To me, it seems like that when you really read the 16 items, it's pretty clear on what they want that person to do. Yeah, I would just say that this. I don't know how much we need to go back and get more information. This has been really well vetted at Mono County Behavioral Health and Kathy Peterson has weighed in and Amanda's really stewarded this very well through cultural, the cultural outreach committee.

1:39:37 And they are excited to offload this money. And I think that, you know, the plan was that I would bring it this evening, we would discuss it, and then move forward with the contract. I'm going to defer to Stacey a little bit on this. Yeah, I just think it would be nice if our board got a presentation about, if the rest of the board wants to move right ahead, but I think we do, what happens after 18 months? So you bring somebody on staff, what?

1:40:09 Yeah. I think that's a strategic conversation we need to continue to have because we have grant sources that come in and out, which is why we haven't expanded staff capacity in the past. And if we have these small allocations and we want to do project-specific, Latino coalition, do these things, then I think we need to start taking some risks and hire people with limited funding. Right. I think we can do that, but I think a basic sense of

1:40:38 Okay, how do we take this risk? How does that risk lead to something that becomes sustainable? I think that's a reasonable thing to look at. We're not talking about approving a contract tonight, but I do think rather than just bringing a contract back to this board, having representatives from the county come and give a presentation, that's just, I mean, this is...

1:40:59 We're holding these public meetings. This is going to be an ongoing issue. 18 months and all the issues you've brought up, we're looking at a position that needs to be sustained. Further discussion? I'm not sure that it needs to be sustained. I bet these two on your staff would be very thrilled to have an 18-month person, bilingual.

1:41:27 Who can handle the phone calls that come in that Diane has to pick up and interrupt Patricia so that Patricia can handle it and it may not be much of anything. This is supposed to be bilingual. You know, I mean, answering the phone and taking messages and meeting somebody at the door that speaks their language, our clientele, let's face it, is...

1:41:53 More than 37%, I'm sure, for Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I just have to tell you, because I'm kind of rusty anymore, but I have helped people to take them to the town offices, and there's no one there that speaks Spanish. And, I mean...

1:42:14 It's so much interruption. Diane's got to do grants and monitoring and all sorts of stuff. I looked at the work plan, and Patricia does too. If you can pick up somebody part-time, you know, for what, 18 months or 12 months or even a few weeks that allows them to get on with their work. Plus, you have to understand, in this community, having somebody

1:42:39 That is a member of the Latino community in that office. The word gets around. This is a very small community we're talking about. And, you know, one or two people who are in the Latino community, not just speak Spanish, but that's in the community, that helps get the word out, explains stuff. It means so much more to your organization than you even understand because

1:43:06 The only one that speaks Spanish probably here is Patricia. Nope. Okay. Maybe a couple more here. And me very rusty. But this is part-time help, guys. This is not somebody that's going to bring in, write grants and do this and that, whatever. This is taking messages, answering the phone and greeting people at the door.

1:43:30 And allowing these two to get on with their job. There are only two of them right now. And if we get an intern, we'll be lucky. And the intern may not be Spanish speaking. This is required to be. And I mean, it's a wonderful link between Mono County and Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so I guess I'm just telling what I feel like from the heart, because I think you guys overload them.

1:43:56 These two, you can't let them do their jobs if you keep overloading them, and if you get somebody that can greet people in their own language, take the message, do a callback, answer a question, you have really done a service, and it's only, what, 18 months, if we're lucky? It's not, you know, one of these management positions that we're growing people into. Thank you. Discussion?

1:44:27 I just wanted to provide Agnes' comments on this item she sent via email. This is from Agnes Vianzon. I would like to express support for working with Mono County for the development towards a Latino housing coalition as a shared staff person helping to further achieve our mission while assisting with staff workloads. This is a great example of being able to serve our community in a more inclusive way. So even as a contract employee, it's a benefit to our community. Consensus with the board?

1:45:02 Well, this is a discussion. Yeah. So I'm hoping, I don't know, that unless you need any more specifically, you can synthesize everything you've heard. We're not taking any action on this tonight because it's only a discussion item on the agenda. Yeah. But maybe bring it back with, I don't know, whatever you've heard and then maybe get some folks in Morrow County Health to speak to it directly and something that we can take some action on. I think it's critical. I mean, this has been an omission.

1:45:31 We've always tried to hire somebody that had Spanish skills, speaking language skills in the office because this has been an area that we've always tried to address. So that was part of the hiring qualifications. So, yeah, I very strongly support it.

1:45:54 Staff recommends that the Board of Directors discuss the proposal and provide staff direction. Do you have direction? Do you think you, I think you've got complete support. Yeah, I have some comments regarding the deliverables for the staff person and then a request for a meeting with Mono County Behavioral Health. And certainly in response, I mean, yes, it's 18 months, but obviously we're looking ahead.

1:46:21 And that's probably a lot of the comments that we're looking at. I mean, we'll 99% chance jump on the 18 month and move forward, but also keep that door open or keep moving on a long-term relationship and funding. And this specific capacity we're talking about, this has got to be built right into the foundation of what we're doing. Yeah. And that's a question, like, how do we leverage this opportunity into...

1:46:48 Something that's going to be ongoing. We're not going to run that 18 months and go, well, gee, now we've got to find some other way to do this. Let's build this right into the core of what we do. It's not like the issue isn't going to go away. It isn't going to go away. I have a question just for clarification. The 16950, is that for just a 12-month period? Are they willing to go up higher than that if it goes to an 18-month? They would like it to be an 18-month position.

1:47:15 But I think it depends on how much time it takes the staff person to develop the program up front and what the wage is. But that's the total amount that they've allocated. So one final question, kind of from an agenda perspective. In this item, we're talking about allocation of anticipated surpluses, correct? Is the next item going to involve that discussion?

1:47:43 Okay, because I'd like to have that maybe, again, come back to the board in terms of if we are anticipating surpluses so that, you know, obviously we're always going to have competing interest for money. And if it's a way to be able to look to the board and be able to look at, well, we've got these opportunities. So if we want to make decisions about how we're allocating funds, I think that's probably a good thing to be doing. We will look at the draft budget for the next fiscal year at our next meeting, and I can bring that item as well as a projection of what the estimated...

1:48:12 Save cost savings are. Yeah, and I think also to have, from a financial perspective, provide the board with, these are, here's an estimated surplus, we may have some money to work with, this is where the money came from, so it's clear how that's all going to work. And then, Lindsay, as you mentioned, like how do we, what are our priorities, where do we want to put money into things to grow things going forward? So it'd be helpful to have everything on the table at the same, if we can, so we can make those kinds of decisions at the right time. Further discussion?

1:48:40 If not, we'll move to agenda item 14, homebuyers assistant program. Patricia? Okay, this is an update regarding the middle income down payment assistance program that the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board recommended to the town council at their regular meeting on December 3rd. The board requested that the program include the requirement of a deed restriction and then some procedures to address potential short sales.

1:49:19 Those have all been included in the draft guidelines, which I didn't provide this evening. The Town Council voted unanimously at their March 6th meeting to partially fund the program for $101,000. I provided some background information about the need for the program and the community input around that there's a high desire in the community to have this program. And then I provided the income limits so this program would serve

1:49:53 Up to 120% of the area median income. So for a household of four, that's approximately $97,000 gross annually. I provided the original budget for the program, which included two loans up to $50,000 each, service delivery fees of $4,500 per loan, and a budget line item for outreach and marketing of $1,000.

1:50:22 And then I provided some financial considerations for the board to think about. I outlined the work that is anticipated to go into this program based on historic loans that we do through our grant-funded programs. So we would develop and implement a marketing plan, open a lottery and start answering the phone, basically.

1:50:51 Income qualify every single applicant that comes in during the lottery period. So if that's a lot, I don't know. If it's just a few, I don't know. But it takes approximately, I would say, 12 to 15 hours per application to process those. Then we would make a selection from the lottery and inform all of the participants.

1:51:15 And then processing loans takes between 40 and 70 hours, and so that's an average of 55 hours per loan. In partnership, Mammoth Lakes Housing had offered to monitor the new deed restrictions free of charge to the town of Mammoth Lakes annually in perpetuity. So that's two new deed restrictions to monitor every year. We normally charge about $250 per unit per year.

1:51:47 We also included in our proposal that we would answer calls about refinancing and maybe I want to do improvements to my unit and what does that look like and that we would do all of that just as part of our daily operations. I included an estimate of what I thought the staff time to do this based on the $9,000 we requested in service delivery fees and that estimate is about $49 per hour.

1:52:18 So a pretty reduced rate for operating this program for the town. I wanted the board to know that, and the town, to know that we did not propose to hire a new staff person with $9,000. Really along the same lines that John mentioned about, well, this funding isn't in perpetuity, how would we keep this person employed? But it was meant as a service delivery fee to

1:52:51 Increase our revenues so that we might be able to increase staff capacity utilizing additional resources or purchase the database that we need to purchase, which would be an ongoing cost. And other ways that we might be able to think creatively about growing incrementally and slowly because we're not going to grow overnight. In the town's approval of the program, they

1:53:19 They underfunded the program by $9,000, which is the amount that was for the service delivery fees. I provided a few options to the board for them to consider about how we want to enter into a contract with the town to provide this service. Option one is that we could include this as an additional service in the current draft contract with the town.

1:53:47 This would be adding additional work for the same contract amount that Mammoth Lakes Housing has received at least since 2013, but I believe since 2011. Additionally, in that draft contract, we've already agreed to do additional work, and so I did provide the MLH draft work program for the next fiscal year for the board to review. The other option is that we could enter into a separate agreement with the town to operate this program.

1:54:18 Knowing that we're not receiving any additional fees to operate the program, but perhaps we could find another partner who maybe wants to help facilitate with the program, or maybe we just extend our staff and we just get it done and that's fine. That's fine in this pilot program, but then we continue to think about how we're going to make changes in the future. It could, if, yeah, I guess.

1:54:52 I guess that's a good description of that option. The other option is that you know of other options that I don't know about that we can talk about. Because I really racked my brain on this one, so. If I can make them comment, I thought the intent. Before you start, just to be clear from a parliamentary perspective, this is listed as a discussion item, right? So we're not taking any action on this. Is that your understanding? Yeah. Yeah, okay. But I would like staff direction.

1:55:23 Right, but it's kind of laid out like there's options for voting or something. I just want to make sure it's clear that it's only a discussion item. Well, I thought the intent, and John, you can correct me, I thought the intent of the 101,000 was to capture two units. Sure, yeah. And it seems like we've mixed a whole bunch of things in here. And so, you know, the way it was brought to Council is that the 101,000 was to, again, capture two units, not to

1:55:53 Look at all these different options. So the council direction, we have a 296 unit shortfall right now, and it's going to grow to about, in three more years, to about 590. And so this was just simply council saying, we need to do something. And so, you know, the direction from council, and I don't want to get cross-weighted unless you want to go back to

1:56:18 Council and asked, okay, do we want to look at all these other options as expenditures? I'm not, well, it seems like you've mixed up a whole bunch of things. Well, the budget for the program included $100,000 to capture two units. $101,000. No, $100,000. Okay. $9,000 for the fees to Mammoth Lakes Housing and $1,000 for marketing. This is a strategic discussion of the board to figure out how we're going to add additional work program with not additional revenue.

1:56:47 And what the preference of the board is for the contract with the town to deliver the services? One of the things that really came for me out of the contract negotiations with the town is that we cannot continue to add work and not have it be paid for or not have it be staffed appropriately. So right now, as far as we are going forward, if we don't have the time,

1:57:20 To do it, then we can't add it. It's not so easy as saying we have $100,000, let's go give it to people. It's not as easy as just writing a check. And so I think that's the idea behind some of this other information is how do we actually go about getting that money to people if we could.

1:57:41 You know, the idea originally with the $9,000, maybe we save that up, we get some other grants, we get more and more money, maybe we can then eventually add an additional person. Some of my, couple of my thoughts on it, the way that the money was given by council and the way that that was worded.

1:58:03 Can we change the award amount? Right now it's for $50,000. Could we drop it to $45,000 and have some of that money to cover staff time and to cover to sort of then have for an additional person as we need? Going back to the previous item, if we are thinking about adding a part-time person, maybe we can then have nine extra $1,000. That person gets an extra however many hours.

1:58:30 So I thought that, you know, in sort of thinking outside the box, that was one of my things. Does the grant need to be $45,000? It's written currently as 10% or $50,000. Can we change the dollar amount? The other is we have not signed our contract with the town yet. And are there things that we might just want to take out of the town contract?

1:58:53 to free up some staff time to plug this into it so that we have more time available if we think that this is such a priority. I think my concern is that we don't, if we're looking at it as a board, and I feel like, Patricia, by reading this the way that staff is looking at it, is we are being contracted by the town to provide a service, and do we want to set a precedent that we will do those services for free?

1:59:22 Or do we want to say that we need to be covering some of our, whether it's staff time or just staff time? Yeah. And to kind of follow up with that, I think, you know, from what I gathered from the town council meeting and is, okay, if this isn't necessarily the most appropriate, like, a way of asking for additional funding for staff time, but we have these three-year contracts, like, I want to know how, if we're, because we're planning on slowly becoming a

1:59:52 Like incrementally bigger in the programs that we provide. And if some of them are going to be through the town, do we wait until we sign a new contract to add those programs? Or is there a way to add them mid-contract but to make sure that we're still getting paid for more staff time to go towards those programs? I feel like that's something that we need to figure out between the town and our board of how to best communicate that. Well, I think...

2:00:18 I mean, that's the contract committee can figure this out. I think it's important for all of us as a board to understand the nature of the contract we have with the town. It's not a time of materials contract. You know, it is a contract for services. And I've not been involved in those discussions, so I don't quite know how that works. But I think it's very important because this evening we've heard we have a $90,000 potential surplus. And part of the discussion that went on with the council is in order to make not just this item work, but an item work with the Chamber of Commerce, we had the little

2:00:48 Horse trading with the money to figure out how this could work. So, hey, let's just take nine grand from our surplus, put it on this thing, let's get on with it. That would be my suggestion. But I also, at the appropriate time, have a discussion about, because, you know, as a board member, I was not aware of the status of the CDBG grant with Sierra Manor Road. The home grant. The home grant, I'm sorry. That, and in my conversation with the town, understanding now that that, gee, if I...

2:01:15 You know, defer to you guys to say there is a willingness on behalf of the town to say, is there more value in terms of getting more people in units if we were to take that money and start looking at putting it into that project? I don't know the answer to that question, but in terms of the goals of getting housing and units for the community, what's going to be the biggest and most significant bang for our buck? So I want to, I don't have the technical information for that, but the town is certainly willing to look at something like that, and maybe that's something we want to think about. Yeah.

2:01:45 As far as the, because I do think that's a crux, I mean, we've already had the meeting and the discussion about do we want to ask town council for this money, and Richard, I think it was your comment months ago saying $100,000 for only two units, and I could be, I don't want to misquote you, but that's a lot of money and that's been the debate for a long time, so I don't know if we go back now, we've had the discussion, do we go back and say, well,

2:02:12 Maybe we don't actually want to use to do this. I would advise that it's a staff discussion. Patricia, is she going to talk to the town manager and see how to proceed with something like that? Well, I think it's more than a staff discussion. I think this board has to provide some direction. I hope this will be easier for us when we have our strategic plan approved and in place. We continually need to go back to that.

2:02:34 And to, you know, guiding documents like the Community Housing Action Plan to guide our decision making. This was a great program idea, but maybe the timing of it wasn't right. You know, we didn't have a plan in place. We put this together. It sounds like it might not work. It sounds like it could be burdensome in terms of staff capacity. You know, I'd rather have us focusing on the things we have already.

2:03:03 in play like 238 Sierra Manor Road that we that seem to require more resources than we originally allocated to them and something like focusing on again our our board and council a few months ago wholeheartedly unanimously gave direction to get the basic

2:03:28 Contract in place. We haven't been able to do that yet, so I'm very hesitant to open that back up and try to throw this new great concept of a program, but totally untested, unproven. It's just a great idea. We're all getting the ideas out there to get more units in play, but maybe we need to go back and just focus on the things we were already doing and not implement a new program like this right now. The council voted

2:03:57 $100,000 to get two units. And, you know, if it's $45,000 instead of $50,000, then that's fine. The goal, the policy direction was to capture two units with that $100,000. So if it's $45,000, if this is the cost, I mean, I really don't want to bring it back to Council and say, oh, well, it's really $45,000. That's my question, is do we have to do that? Good point.

2:04:27 That's not about the staff discussion, is whether or not a consensus from us between staff to staff, the town manager could say that doesn't have to come back to council. It's in the discretion of the intent of the council. Sure. Capture two units. Sure. That's what it is. And, you know, I agree that there might need to be a discussion, but again, I don't want to go back to council and say, well, maybe we need to move this money over Sierra, you know. So let me... But, you know, this is what...

2:04:55 This is what's on the table. And I think that's what we need to do. The whole discussion about the 11 units over there, you know, again, how many months out before we're going to know when we give the specifics on the Sierra Alpert property, then we'll know if we have that. So let me make it, so maybe part of it's a direction to staff to say, can staff ask

2:05:23 Council, is it okay to take it from $50 to $45 so we can cover our costs? Yeah. Second question would be, is it even within the realm of consideration to be able to take the two units and the money for those two units and point it over that way? Or is that going to get... Sort of plan A, plan B? Yeah, plan A, plan B. If it does get in to bring back the council, we won't do that. But if it is within the discretion, if the town manager says, no, that would be an appropriate use of money, then that would be something for our next... We could come back and say, well, hell, we've got an opportunity to put...

2:05:52 You know, $100,000 into that versus the two units. But if not, then that's okay. But I kind of, I worry, the Sierra Manor and this project are two totally different projects. Because Sierra Manor is going to be low income since it's funded by home, possibly, or CDBG. And this was the idea of starting something new that could, yeah, it's only two units now, but it may grow into something more. And that's, our community in the Community Housing Action Plan wanted us to create these programs. Sure, good point.

2:06:21 Sure. I know I want us to be strategic with our money, but I don't want to lose this project because it's... Yeah, it goes from 11 units. If we put the $100,000 there, then there's 11 units there. If we put the $100,000 into two other units, now we're up to 13 units. And that's a big consideration. And I think with that as well, to both of your points, that this...

2:06:49 Middle income, 80% to 120%. There is no government funding available, which is really why we came to this. Agreed. My only other outside-the-box thought, because I sort of had my fundraising committee hat on already trying to think of things, is in this, would this be something that we fundraise money for? That we can figure it out, and before you shake your hand, is...

2:07:17 It seemed to me that the business community was the community that really wanted, in some of the discussions, wanted this sort of middle income grant. Is it

2:07:28 Important enough to the business community to keep their middle managers, middle range, mid-range level employees that we could ask them for some money to say, listen, we went out and outsourced $101,000, but we are $9,000 short. And that to me is what the fundraising committee would do. And if it's that important, because I do like this idea now that if we have...

2:07:50 A person coming in that's only working 20 hours per week, only 12 hours per week on Mammoth Lakes Housing, we have a body that we could just add hours to if we had the money. So whatever $9,000 works out to at their hourly rate, we get that additional amount for 18 months or for 20 months or something. And to that, that's great thinking. On that, I would say, let's see if we can do it for $45,000. We can get it going.

2:08:17 And then, but the communication, we're going to have to start, we can point to a success and say, this is moving, because for fundraising, we're going to have to start building relationships, that's going to take some time. And so, and that's exactly the right way to be thinking. And I think you made a great point. I mean, this is exactly the kind of program for which we have to start doing with our own local resources, because there's not going to have any state or federal money for it. I do want to be clear with that thought of $45,000 that it's not.

2:08:45 Only getting $91,000. And it's still getting $101,000 for Mammoth Lakes Housing to put together and run, administer this homebuyer assistance program. That we're not changing the dollar amount that we would receive. Is that the understanding by you?

2:09:05 My understanding, the council's action was $101,000. Yeah, and we work with that. We just take with that and we adjust it. This board works with that. Perfect. I just want to be sure that we're clear. It doesn't go back to the contract. We're not getting into all that nonsense. We're going to take the money we got and do something. That, I hope, is totally off the table. I do think, John, I mean, sorry to keep going on it, but I was really undecided how I felt about this coming in, this idea that we do have some additional funds.

2:09:35 I don't know. Do we use that to be able to give a bigger loan? I think my concern is if this program works, if it's really successful, we get two units out of it that we then can sell it to Mono County, to Inyo County, to the City of Bishop, to Alpine County and say, here, we have this program, but we cannot sell it to them without money to pay for it for the administration. Sure.

2:10:04 So that's kind of in my setting a precedent. We have to decide, I think, as a board, if that's important to us or not moving forward. Well, I think if we can take this and launch a program and get it going, let's get it going, and then, as you say, as we're going out to other opportunities, say, actually, the cost of doing this is going to be this, and then we do those kind of things going forward. And we'll know our hourly requirement with that, too. We'll know how much time it took. And that was the spirit of approving this and how it went to council as a pilot program.

2:10:34 The pilot program with the funding coming from the town, the idea, we've been doing this program, Homebuyer's Assistant, I mean, and you've got how many, 66 people waiting on that list? That's the rental list. That's the rental list, wait list. Yeah, and if we're going to raise it up, then that's going to create another, a whole.

2:11:03 Demand, if you will, to be on that list and say, wait a minute, if the town's going to do this, which is be really critical in the sense of knowing how many people come in and say, wait a minute, you're now doing it above because we've been turning people away for years. You're making just a little bit too much, so therefore you don't qualify for the 80% and below. Yeah, you can definitely have the possibility to grow into a positive trust fund.

2:11:32 The business community needing these kinds of employees, this has the potential to really grow. But as you know, even fundraising and managing donations is its own program of work, right? Going back to that, I do not want to connect communication and marketing with fundraising because they're separate beasts. Well, let's go back to our committees. Let's get that all figured out because these are all important. We've got to figure out how we're going to do these things.

2:12:00 Going forward, though, kind of similar to what Lindsay was saying about setting a precedent, I do think it's really important for us to figure out how to, if we are going to do these as a fee for contract or like fee for service, and if whether it's the town, the county, or anybody else who just gives it the money to the program but not necessarily for the staff time, we can't work for free. We can't.

2:12:27 You know, spread them even more thin. So we need to, I want to know how to best communicate with town and also with the county and how to make sure that we're getting fully funded for these programs. Because it sounds like, from what I understood, it wasn't the appropriate time to ask for the $9,000. I think that was Linda's comment. And so when

2:12:48 When do we need to ask for the additional staff time for new programs? I think, but I also want to add, we've had a great, in our strategic plan thing, we talked a lot about, I think we talked about entrepreneurship and finding solutions. And I think if you looked at what happened with that council agenda, again, it was, the money was about, well, how do we do this, but then how do we also do that? And so the council was kind of constrained. And frankly, we're in a position where I think we can come up with a solution. To Kirk's point, we can go to 45.

2:13:14 We could tap some of our 90,000 and, okay, we're going to use that to help do it. So, okay, it's not 100%, it's maybe 90%, but good, we can make this work and let's move forward with it. And then each one of these things is going to be a little bit different. I think, obviously, if this was something that was truly onerous, that was going to cost us money, it was going to be undoable, then we'd say, look, we can't, this is crazy, we can't do this. But we can make this work. And I think we're all very aware of what you just said, that we're not going to get ourselves into a trap.

2:13:42 We're not going to do things that's going to undermine our financial, you know, viability. But I think we can make this work, you know. My thoughts. Further discussion? Then the direction is, you know, I guess there's two parts. One is go back and, Patricia, to go back and talk to make sure that we're not crossways with the council or the town manager's understanding.

2:14:13 of this $100,000 and how it can be expended and have that conversation and also to do the lottery if the $90,000 is available. And part of it is that we keep modifying the contract with the town and Mammoth Lake Housing. That is an evolving issue as to defining

2:14:39 What is being paid for and what isn't being paid for? And that's why I think this is a good agenda bill in the sense, hey, there's impacts. And so those impacts have got to be paid for. I'm going to follow up with Stacey a little bit. I think that I really hope we can get this contract done. Yeah. You know, I've been involved. I don't know what's going on, but let's hope to get this thing locked in. And I think just in general for us as an organization, the point I was trying to make, this is a good example of, you know,

2:15:07 It's exciting. We want to create these new programs. We want to get those two other units, but we have to really, it will always carry an administrative burden. So are we willing to scale down a little bit and still implement? Is that the highest priority? Or do we need to say, okay, well, let's just focus on what we have going on. I mean, that'll always be kind of tension and struggle, but just for us to be aware of, you know, when we're making these decisions, that's kind of the context we're in.

2:15:38 So do you have a direction? Yes, thank you. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to agenda item 15, which is a parcel update. Okay, so I don't have a lot to report on the parcel. Most of this you have seen before. On page 2 of the staff report, there's an update under next steps.

2:16:03 regarding the RFP that Mammoth Lakes Housing submitted a response to as part of a team that included the Sierra Business Council, WSW Consulting, who worked on the Community Housing Action Plan, as well as Cindy Brown, who worked on the Holiday Neighborhood in Boulder, Colorado, and spoke at the Housing Summit on the parcel during her keynote presentation. The team received a letter from the town that

2:16:31 The town had determined not to move forward with the affordable housing RFQ based on the skill set of the consultant selected to fulfill the land use RFQ and additional staff capacity. So MLH and the team were not awarded or interviewed as part of that process, which

2:16:53 ML, the board thought that that would have helped with some strategic alignment with MLH in the town and also potentially some capacity. That's the only update I have. I was going to attend the parcel team update last week, but I think it was canceled, so I don't have anything else. I have a question. I remember last time I spoke to Grady Dutton, he mentioned that the town is planning on doing like

2:17:24 Events for the community to come together and comment on what the parcel and what they're hoping to see. I was wondering if those have been organized or if we know when they're going to happen. Glad you asked that. On the council meeting agenda Wednesday night, there's a very robust and there's another word that went in there somewhere else. Item that speaks to that and perhaps someone from the town staff could give maybe a little preview of what that.

2:17:52 of what that's going to look like to get exactly to what you're talking about. I don't know if Sandra or Dan wants to. I apologize. I haven't eaten. Let me get you your hand. No, no, no. I'm focused on our agenda. Really? Trying to be. So just a quick, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department, a quick update on the item.

2:18:17 For consideration by the Town Council on April 3rd, we have selected a consultant, Lisa Weiss Consulting Incorporated, and that contract is on the Council's agenda for consideration. Lisa Weiss Consulting is a small firm out of San Luis Obispo. The lead planner on the project will be Jen Daugherty, who was a planner at the Town for almost 10 years, has worked on the parcel before when it was Hidden Creek Crossing, has a lot of experience.

2:18:46 experience with, obviously, Mammoth Lakes and with this property in particular. And she brings with her a team of other consultants, Optico's Planning out of San Francisco. They're a pretty well-known firm. And I've seen their presentations at APA conferences and have been impressed with the way that they, you know.

2:19:09 Explain their concepts, get consensus, and really have a very graphic way of representing.

2:19:18 Representing projects. So I think they'll be a really good addition to the team. They also have a firm called Crabtree Engineering who has experience in sustainable engineering practices. So really kind of looking at integrating green infrastructure into projects. That's kind of their specialty. And then lastly, Novin Development Corporation. So they're a firm that works on affordable housing projects. I can read their little spiel.

2:19:47 They're a privately owned real estate development consulting and brokerage company. They have a $40 million portfolio of real estate. They're involved in acquisition, entitlement, construction of over 1,500 multifamily units and over $500 million of development throughout California. So they have a lot of experience with affordable housing development. And so leaning on them and then leaning on town staff for looking at grants and fulfilling those

2:20:17 That portion of the contract is what we're looking at. So I think when we saw this proposal, we saw their experience, and we are adding a housing coordinator when we had first gone through the RFQ.

2:20:29 We weren't sure about adding a housing coordinator, and that's obviously in the works right now. We're working on that staff capacity, so I think that we feel that we'll have the capacity in-house and through this contract to fulfill that. The contract, the proposal's available on the town's website, so you can kind of see what the proposal entails, but...

2:20:50 It is a heavy public outreach contract. So a big portion of this contract is really getting the public's input, getting the council's input on development objectives, on conceptual land use plans. This includes development of three, up to three conceptual land use plans for review by the public. It includes interviews. The consultant will be interviewing, conducting up to 15 interviews with different groups. So we'll work with a consultant to select those groups clearly.

2:21:20 Mammoth Lakes Housing, some portion of the board or staff or both will be part of interviewed as a part of this process. So the intent is to really, I think that I was somewhat inspired by your strategic planning that you did and having those interviews conducted in advance of moving forward with that process I thought was really helpful with your strategic planning. I thought you had a very successful strategic planning session and I think part of seeing that as a part of this contract I thought was

2:21:50 It was helpful. And so I think having that kind of baseline knowledge, now Jen obviously brings with her a lot of baseline knowledge, but having that kind of other baseline knowledge to help inform this project I think will be helpful. And town staff won't be part of those interviews, this will just be conducted by

2:22:08 By the consultants, which is the same thing that you guys did as part of strategic planning, and I thought that was really helpful. And so it would be kind of the same process where they take that information and provide it to us kind of without names and assignments to statements. So I'm happy to answer any questions you have about the process, but we intend to kick off the process as soon as we get the contract.

2:22:32 Approved by Council. And the contract is scheduled to, the work product is scheduled to be completed in November of this year, November, December. So we're looking for a quick process, which doesn't sound super quick when it's, you know, nine months or so, but for this type of a project, I think it's very quick, which would then lead town staff to updates to possibly, we don't really know at this point what changes we might need to make, but updates to the general plan possibly.

2:23:02 Zoning Code, Shady Risk Master Plan, Environmental Documents. So all of that information, we'll be kind of thinking about all of that as we go through this process. So lining us up to then immediately starting with entitlements for the parcel. Sorry, go ahead. Sandra, just so that I'm clear, the companies that you listed all work under the one person's consulting company?

2:23:32 Right, so it's LWC with subconsultants. And then she hired. Yeah, so she's the main point of contact and then she has those subconsultants. And the affordable housing RFQ that you're sort of rolling into the land use RFQ. One thought I guess that I have, you named off the company that does have affordable housing. Are they familiar with?

2:23:59 Have they gotten a lot of grants? I know you listed some dollar amounts, but I may just not have gotten it as you listed. They don't list the grants if they've applied for or received grants as a part of this. They've worked on putting together different packages for funding. It might be in here, but I didn't see that pop out at me. But they do have experience with funding.

2:24:25 A variety of different funding options for projects. Also, we do have Kaiser Marston, who's already on retainer for the town for this project. They have experience with tax credits, a lot of the common funding programs for affordable housing projects. Okay. Thank you. Sandra, just one question. Is the zoning going to be changed? I don't know. I don't think we know that answer at this point. I think that's the part of this conceptual... You're opening the door for that.

2:24:55 Well, I mean, I think that through the conceptual land use planning process, we would look at the preferred plan, and that plan obviously is vetted through council, through the public, and if the public and the council all are supportive of a plan that requires changing the zoning, I think then we'll move forward with doing that. And what impacts will this have with the governor and what he's doing with San Jose? We're way ahead of those guys. We're not ahead of those guys. He put his foot down on them. San Jose or Huntington Beach?

2:25:25 Pardon? I don't know if it's appropriate for you. I don't know if you and I can talk about it, but we can talk about it on Wednesday night. I'm just saying that we have an issue with housing in the state, and our governor is saying, hey, your general plan...

2:25:47 Your housing element is up to speed and he's stopping people. Well, if I could, and I think this is appropriate, is that the grant that we have through SB1, where we're updating our housing element, our safety element, the Technical Advisory Council I serve on for the climate change thing, there's folks there from OPR that does all the general plans in the state, Cal EPA, and folks from SMUD, Sacramento Amuse Utilities, all these regional things in the state. We are, you know, years ahead of LA County.

2:26:17 I mean, we are huge... I'm talking about San Jose. I'm not talking about... Well, I'm just saying. I think when you start exposing us to the policy objectives of the state, I think we're pretty well positioned. And I think one thing I would add to that also is this walk, bike, ride thing. Because the VMT piece, which is becoming the critical piece in reducing vehicle miles traveled, in the climate change program, everything's going relatively well, except for the VMTs are just climbing like this.

2:26:42 And I think the fact that we have a plan that we can integrate a way to reduce vehicle amounts of travel potentially into this development, that's another thing I think is going to help score well first. That I think is probably the most driving element. It'll be balanced against the idea of the general plan, the housing element, meeting the housing need. When we're talking about three, four years out, needing 590 units.

2:27:10 I worry about, I worry about the governor. It's worth concern. I hope he's got bigger. Well, the governor's got a lot to worry about. He's got a lot to worry about. He's got a lot to worry about, but he's making an issue out of housing. Oh, yeah, absolutely. He's focused on it. Absolutely. So, I feel like, Kirk, you just opened a bit of a can of worms in my head, talking about rezoning. That's huge for this, for this.

2:27:34 Well, I think one thing to keep in mind. Yeah, if you could address that. Yeah, is that the goal of this item is to really go out to the community and to say, look, we own 25 acres. Now, what are the values that you want to see in this development? Do you want to pave over the wetlands? Yes, no. If you don't want to pave over the wetlands, that means we just lost some percentage of the site. Okay, are we willing to go higher?

2:28:01 To pick up those units. Or do you want to keep it all low? I mean, these are the values that the community needs to express. And I'm hoping that through this process that's rich and robust, that there's a consensus that comes back and says the community that owns this property is interested in these goals and objectives looking this way. And at that point, because this is the community's property, and if the public and the community can articulate that and come back and say, look,

2:28:27 This is what we want to see with this land base. Then at that point, the council would weigh or consider whether to make any changes. But I'm hoping that, I'm very much hoping that the desires and the aspirations of the community get reflected in the work that these folks do. And so then whatever decisions the council would make is based on the goals and aspirations of the public. I think I just would

2:28:51 To our two council members, and again, this is maybe, I guess it is kind of in our parcel, but I would just be hesitant when we're talking about the will of the community, that the community is actually represented, because I feel like we have a lot of meetings. I've been to various, my experience being recreation meetings for ice skating rink, swimming pool previously. It was a very segmented part of the population. It was not diverse, and that is my concern.

2:29:19 With that is that if it's sort of how I felt in the last agenda item about this middle income loan that got the most votes of the community housing action plan, that those people who participated in that were middle income people. And of course they want money for middle income loans. So I get nervous that we're going to take our parcel that there's even any talk about rezoning. Well, I would just...

2:29:42 To say to that, if this process is going to happen, if the council votes for it, we would probably spend a significant amount of money on it, it's incumbent upon all of us to drive people to those meetings, to drive people to those sessions, and make sure that what we all hear and see that happens in this process ends up getting reflected coming back the other way. It's one of those things that... And that there are things beyond meetings, which it sounds like they are. I was just going to say, then let's be sure that we take those meetings to the people. Oh, absolutely. You can't drive people to meetings when they need to be at work.

2:30:09 Or with their families, you need to take those meetings somewhere where they can attend. That makes me really nervous. And I would personally, to staff, if you could really keep us informed about anything you hear about zoning so that we could be on top of it. Because that, for me, as a board member, I want to make sure that we're making decisions as our board to give advice our boards. And again, the zoning thing is, I mean, that's, this is way, this is.

2:30:36 Way in the future. It sounds fairly thought out already if you're thinking about it. Well, I'm just thinking, as one count, from my perspective, is that we need to get, we need to have confidence that this process reflects, and the outcomes that come at it reflect the desires and will of the community. And if it can, then that's something that we can, maybe we act on. If people don't have any faith in it, we don't think this has worked, well then, I don't know what happens. To change the zoning.

2:31:04 Does it have to go to a vote of people because that's how it was something I feel like in our previous meetings? No. Okay. It doesn't have to go to a vote.

2:31:15 Yeah, it doesn't have to go to a vote of the people to change the zoning for that. But let me just kind of preface what I'm saying is I'm not suggesting we're going to be changing this and I'm not making any suggestions. As a staff member, I'm really trying to go into this with an open mind and I would encourage, I think, everyone to do that. And so we're providing the consultant with kind of all the previous planning work that's been done on that. But we're kind of saying that's all been done in the past, right? We're kind of starting now here where we are. Use that for information. Use that to help kind of inform your process.

2:31:44 This is the process that we're going through now, and I have no idea. I wasn't trying to suggest that we were going to change the zoning. We're just going to, through this process, we will identify what needs to be done. This is going to be a very public process. The key for this contract is the public engagement, not just meetings, but online engagement, public engagement through that bang the table program that we have. So, I mean, this is really intended to be a very well-vetted

2:32:11 Very public process where no one in the public should feel like they didn't know that this was happening or that they kind of, you know, their voice wasn't heard. So, I mean, I think this is really the intent of this process. So, I'm not trying to suggest that. I'm just saying through this process we'll be identifying what, if anything, needs to be changed with any of the planning resources for this, or I guess requirements for this property. It may be nothing, but we don't really know that until we get the final conceptual land use plan.

2:32:40 Yeah, I mean, I'll just say it sounds like there have already been a lot of discussions about it, and I just want to make sure. Kirk and I have not talked about this. I've read the document. I'm very excited that the community has an opportunity to get involved in articulating what it wants to see, and I'm excited about that. I think that this is a huge opportunity. The community owns this property. This belongs to the residents of this town. Let's get everybody to whatever process they come up with.

2:33:10 Nothing has been prejudged. I'm just excited for the opportunity that we have for this thing going forward. I changed my thought on the Latino coalition person. We need to get that going right away. Because that needs to happen now if things are happening quickly. Sure. Oh, yeah. Any other questions for me? No. Thank you. Thank you. Sandy Hogan, I'm with you, Lindsay. That's exactly right.

2:33:37 Sounds like there have been a lot of private little conversations about zoning and changing it. We had an election in 1996 about this because we had folks who wanted to change the zoning so that it wasn't affordable housing and that went down to defeat for people who were not here in this room. And if it takes another election, so be it. But the changing of a zoning, that's affordable housing. It has been.

2:34:07 I was involved with that since 1995 and had been going on before I ever came here. And I can tell you, there are people who would not even stand for that talk. And exactly right, Lindsay, you can't, I've heard these, everything's been vetted, it's going to be well vetted. We've all heard that before. That's how we would, you, the council,

2:34:36 Would lose the trust of this community by even talking about that. It's meant for affordable housing. We hope it will be high density. We know we can get that. And we hope that that's what the highly paid consultants right now are actually helping to illustrate and tell us what it's going to be. But I'm just one voice in this community. But I've been around a while and I know how it feels.

2:35:05 And you hit the nail on the head, Lindsay. Thank you. Any more discussion on the parcel? If not, one, sorry, just one last thing. The, that question about the website and the webpages, I think, again, if we could, if you could be talking with Sandra and Dan around this little momentum thing so we could, as we move forward, there's a really an easy place to find that people can get the information that they want. That'd be helpful. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to board member reports. Richard.

2:35:42 Nothing to report right now. John? I told you, I shared with you my chairlift story. I did show them the last remaining powder stash on Lincoln Mountain that morning. I'm a friendly council person and that's all I have to share. Thank you. No report. I have nothing. Nothing to report. I was in Tahoe this weekend and I talked to, like when I was taking Ubers and stuff, I was talking to a bunch of the people there about

2:36:14 Since they just overturned nightly rentals, I didn't realize how expansive it was. I didn't know it was the entire city limits that they overturned. And I remember Sandy mentioning how some of those homes were built just for it, and we stayed in one of those homes. So I'll be interested to see what happens. And I know it's kind of tied up in litigation. But it was kind of really interesting. I know people don't like change in general.

2:36:40 Everything's, but it seemed like a lot of people weren't necessarily for it. So I'll be really interested to see how that turns out and what the effects of that are. So this, is it the city that's driving the, trying to overturn the zoning that the people voted for? So the people voted for it and the city's now trying to represent it, but now I think private homeowners are. Oh, so it's individuals. It's individuals that are. Pardon? Board of Realtors or something like that.

2:37:08 It was private interest. They sued. Okay. Airbnb and VRBO, they're behind it. Okay. And I'm working, I actually work with the guys in the City Council of South Lake Tahoe and I'll talk to them about it. Maybe I can get some information to share. Yeah, let us know. I had no idea how expansive that was. Like I knew it was a big chunk, but the whole city limits, I was shocked. It's a very interesting case study. Sandy knows a lot about it, but it's a very interesting case study in Knightley Reynolds. Yeah. It's idiosyncratic, but it's very interesting.

2:37:36 So it'll go to the California Supreme Court? I don't know. I didn't get that far into it. I haven't, I just got back yesterday, so I haven't researched much yet, but I'll be interested to see what happens, where it's going to go. Yeah, because it's individual property, also zoning. What can you do with your zoning and the power of zoning? Well, on the foundation, it predates the technology. So all this stuff got put in place before the technology happened, and all of a sudden the technology just,

2:38:06 Just poured gasoline on the fire, and it's interesting. Oh, I was left for a year. I'm not a board member. Yeah, but we like to hear your comments. Okay, board member reports. Do we have closed session? Yes. All right, so we'll move into the back room in there. It's going to go to the bathroom. All right.

2:38:52 Yeah, we've got to go in there.