Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2019
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
· recording 2 hr 47 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
337 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:30 May 6th, the Mammoth Council Chamber, let's see, the regular Mammoth Lake Housing, mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economic and sustainable community. Do you want to do the roll call? Lindsay Barksdale? Here. Stacey Corliss? Here. Zariah Cruz? Here. Tom Hodges? Here. Giselle Kenney? Kirkstapp? Here.
1:04 John Wentworth. Here. Agnes Vianzon. Here. Richard Playstead. Here. Thank you. The podium is open for public comments. If there are no public comments, we'll move to agenda item four, which is approval of the minutes from April 1, 2019. Are there any deletions or omissions or corrections? Just in item 16, it minutes.
1:32 refers to a story that unfolds during the meeting that is not recounted, and it might be just kind of ridiculously confusing, so I'm wondering, I don't know if we can delete, just delete the comment, or I can add some text that would... This is under item 16? No, in the minutes? Yeah. Item 16. Your board report. Under my board report. So you want to delete board member Whitworth reminds the board, or what did you want to delete? Well,
2:02 I would like to either delete, I don't know from the minutes if you can delete something. Oh no, it's corrections. Yes, you can. Yeah, you can correct the minutes. Okay, so just, I would just delete. They haven't been approved yet. Okay, so I would just delete my board member report because to try to put the text in there to make it understandable would be kind of difficult. Okay. Are there any other deletions, corrections, or additions? If not, can I have a motion?
2:33 I'll move to approve the minutes from the April 1st regular meeting. As amended. As amended. Do I hear a second? I'll second the motion. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We will now move to agenda item 5, Latino Housing Coalition. Patricia? Thank you.
3:06 This item comes before us again after we saw it at our April 1st board meeting. Mammoth Lakes Housing received a proposal from Mono County Behavioral Health with some funding to staff a position to form and steward a Latino Housing Coalition staff person. The staff report outlines the need and then the
3:35 The financial responsibility for Mammoth Lakes Housing. My proposal is that we share the staff person instead of making it a contract position. Under the contract position, the staff person would solely work on the Latino Housing Coalition staff responsibilities, which include attending meetings, building a database of contacts, meeting with people, lots of organizing responsibilities. That staff person would...
4:04 Where that contract person would be housed under Mammoth Lakes Housing, and we would receive funding from Mono County Behavioral Health to fund that contract employee. My recommendation is that we share a part-time staff person. In that way, we can have that person work on some other things around the office, administrative tasks, including answering the phone, meeting with clients just to intake applications.
4:32 And things, marketing, and things that just, you know, that are overflowing a little bit in the office. The Mono County Behavioral Health would prefer that the position be an 18-month position, and so the financial responsibility for the part-time staff person for Mammoth Lakes Housing in this fiscal year
4:59 What in the next fiscal year would be about $12,500, and in the next fiscal year it would be about $8,000. All that is in the staff report, and because of board direction at the last meeting, we have Robin Roberts here from Mono County Behavioral Health to talk a little bit about how they came up with this idea and what they see for the position in the future.
5:34 Feedback. Good evening. How's your dinner? Mmm. Where's it from? Delicious kitchen. Oh, yes. Right downstairs. So I'm here mostly to answer questions. I can tell you a little bit about how my department, Mono County Behavioral Health, has been successful with our outreach to the Latino community, and that's some of where this idea came from. We have a cultural outreach committee that
6:18 Supports this idea. We have the Mono, so I'm going to get all these things mixed up, Mono County Behavioral Health Advisory Committee, which Stacey Corliss is the chair of. That committee also supports this idea. We had some grant money that we got through the state and wanted to use in order to support housing and to be able to bring more voices from the Latino community to the center of this conversation. But I'm here to answer any questions you might have.
6:48 I have a few questions. So this is a halftime position, as I understand the staff report, split between work specifically on the Latino coalition work and then like 60-40, 40% for that and 60% to duties in the office. Yes. Okay. And then I was curious on the wage rates, is that
7:18 Something that was analyzed in terms of the Mono County's HR department and like relative cost per hour for the type of responsibilities that were being asked for? I don't believe so. I believe this was all analyzed through you guys. We're supplying the funding. You're coming up with your wage as it fits into your structure. I see. These were just baseline administrative duties, salary.
7:47 Based on the experience of the employee. Okay. I mean, just reading the job description or the duties of the liaison work, it seemed like a pretty low wage. I'm just concerned that we won't find any qualified applicants, but I suppose we can float it out there, but it's a pretty nominal wage rate. I don't know what the board members think, but...
8:13 Because of the duties that you see from what we're requesting or because of the overall job description? Yeah, I mean, you know, I look at some of the requirements for the Latino Housing Coalition work and, I don't know, it's some pretty, you know, fairly demanding work, you know, in any event. I just, I guess suppose we can float the position out there and see what type of applicants we get. But I just, it might be a little low from a...
8:44 Tom, I would agree with you. I mean, I looked at that, I kept looking at it, and I'm glad you brought it up, because I think to get the work done, it's just to find employees. And somebody with bilingual skills and everything is in high demand. Yeah, yeah, I mean, just, like, again, scope of work there. So, I mean, is your suggestion to go out, see if we can find somebody, and if we can't, or we can't come to...
9:13 They can always bring it back to the board if there needs to be an adjustment on the salary. Yeah, and I suppose does the county have restrictions on their available funding for this position? I mean, is there some upset you have for the amount of money that you guys can fund? Well, I think I had some conversations with Amanda Greenberg, who's with Mono County Behavioral Health.
9:35 And we backed into the amount of the funding allocation, which is around $16,900, to try to figure out, okay, for an 18-month period, what could we afford? I see. Okay. Do you mean what could you afford to add to the position as an administrative assistant? No, just how many hours. I see. I see. Divided by how many hours they're going to spend over an 18-month period, what wage does that look like? Mm-hmm.
10:05 We could fly the position and then just see what's out there and then the board can make adjustments. We had to go from 18 months to 12 months and is that a deal breaker for the counter to go to 18 months to 12 months? So we could kind of adjust it. I think the reason we came, well one of the reasons we came up with the 18 months is to make this a sustainable coalition, not just to have it be specific to whatever staff member you end up with. The idea being that they're blending of adding people to your
10:32 Housing Coalition to your meetings, et cetera, would hopefully be one of the outcomes out of this position. Could you speak a little bit about maybe the both of you, but we discussed last time about what the sustainability component of this, like is the goal to have someone here staffed for 12 months or 18 months? What happens after that? How do we keep this thing going? Well, to be candid, I think that kind of depends on you all. I think it depends on, so I'll tell you kind of where we started with this.
11:02 Government can be a barrier as itself for people in our community. We have 37% of our community growing is Hispanic Latino. So one of the things that my department went
11:17 out to do is to be in our communities, in our native community, in our Latino community, and not look like government. And so we had to kind of look, figure out what it made, what made sense in terms of what people needed from us, not what we needed from people. And so just to have people's voice at the table doesn't mean, what I've learned anyway, doesn't mean that we show up, people will show up when, because during our government business hours, and then participate in the way that we're all used to participating.
11:47 And so what we did was we started to get a read on what people needed. And what they needed was to meet during non-county business hours. They needed to make sure that we always had child care available, decent child care, not just somebody watching over kids. If we could supply dinner, that was helpful. And then we've grown our 4-0 Latino to the last event that we had. We had 125 people show up.
12:11 So it meant we, as a government agency, I don't know how you all work, but we had to be extremely flexible around our workers' time. We listened to people and what they needed, and then we kind of grew it from that point of view. What that did then is make us look less scary and less like a government agency, and it kind of broke down the barriers, especially for us around mental health stigma, and we've been extremely successful as a result of that.
12:37 But what it means also is you have to fold in the voice of the people that you're trying to serve. And that voice, I think, is very dependent on whoever the staff person is. I would strongly suggest that somebody who's bilingual, bicultural, and from this area...
12:52 We've been very successful, again, in hiring staff members who are first generation, have grown up here in Mammoth Lakes, California, bilingual, bicultural, have some heart around social justice, and then have created jobs around them so that we can grow them through the county system so that they can stay in this area and have a living wage. And it's been successful. So how will you do that? I think it's very dependent on who you hire.
13:19 I think then that person, if they're getting the support that they need, then I think that you build a coalition that then people start to understand who you are and what the work that you're doing, and then they're much more interested in participating. So do you anticipate that this is kind of a sort of seed money to get something going, but then once it should be running on its own after that?
13:43 I'm not saying, you know, if it needs more money to continue after the 12 months to the 18 months, that's not a bad thing, but is the goal here to get something up and running and hopefully it's kind of self-sustaining after that? I would hope so, but I would also hope that you would, and again, I don't know, there are other entities in our town and county that have an interest in housing, so hopefully maybe what we could do is create a coalition around making sure that if there is need to have somebody beyond this grant, that we would be able to
14:13 Do some partnerships and figure that out. Yeah, obviously there's a need. The question is making sure that when we get that, when we make a decision, how do we get this thing going? The other question, Patricia, do you have the time to be able to nurture this the way that the problem is talking about? Yes, well, I think the staff person is proposed to be at least not maybe co-managed, but co- overseen by Mono County Behavioral Health staff and myself.
14:42 Yeah, could we talk about, that was my next question for Robin, how would this program integrate or interact with existing, successful existing programs like 4L Latino? Well, time dependent, I think what, depending on who this person is, and not to add meetings to people's lives because that's torture, right? But we do have, we have the Cultural Outreach Committee and then we have the,
15:10 The advisory committee. I could imagine that that person would sit, at least come to a meeting or two and kind of get familiar with what we're doing. I mean, we're a very small town. I can't imagine that there won't be, unless it's somebody who's never lived here before and applies for this job, there will already be some built-in overlap. And then, yeah, we have a variety of housing projects going on right now anyway, and so we could add this person into that process easily, I think. I mean, it would be up to,
15:40 You and them in terms of how much time we're talking. One, two questions that I have. If I'm reading correctly, the money from the county is $16,500, but it looks like at the 18th month position at the highest rate is only $13,728. What's the extra money? Or is there any leftover money?
16:10 15% administrative fee to Mammoth Lakes Housing for payroll taxes and oversight of the position. Perfect. Thank you. And I do remember reading that somewhere. The other thing is, in our budget agenda item, and I'm not sure if we're able to jump around, but to John's point, or John's question about longevity of this position, we do have
16:37 We are going to discuss adding some time to this position with some of our additional revenue that we had. So there is that chat that will come up later. And the requirements that we have related to the grant. So I can say we also fund other programs in the county through grants and through our Mental Health Services Act funds. So we fund the PPOD program at First Five, for instance. So I would imagine that this contract would look very similar to that.
17:06 The expectation through that fund, because we have to send those numbers up to the state, would be that we have some idea of people, we can come up with exactly what we need, but it would be a mild time study on a weekly basis, how many people are contacted, any meetings that happen, we have some requirements, but we have to prove it by showing the sign-in sheet and things like that.
17:34 We are government. All that record came is the responsibility of the staff person to be hired. And for reporting for the grant and all that, you can make sure that they're all lined out, these little things. And we can help with putting that together. It's not a lot of work. And so in terms of process, if we are directed to move forward, Mono County staff will work on the draft contract, which will then come back to the board for approval. And then it would go to...
18:03 The Motto County Board of Supervisors. Okay, and that contract would be between MLH and the county, right, because MLH is hiring the position. Correct. Okay. I was going to ask about, you know, who's at the table doing the interviewing? Is it solely us? Is there a component of you sitting at the table?
18:26 You obviously want somebody to work on your 40%. Right. I think it probably wouldn't be me, but it would be one of our support staff. We would be happy to participate. The time frame for the county to get all the stuff to the supervisors and approval and all that.
18:45 About 100 years, probably. You said that. Plus or minus. She didn't say that. Well, you've got to have time for the contract. So I spoke with county council this morning, and they're ready. They were waiting for this meeting to occur in order for me to do the go-ahead. We've already determined it would be based.
19:03 On the first five contract that we have already set up and then we'd be able to send it over quickly. Then it's just a matter of your approval and then getting it onto the board agenda. But I can overlap that. If I know when your meeting is, I can get it onto the board agenda. And you already have the money. The money's already there. Yes. Okay. Sounds like a great idea. Further discussion? Any more questions? There's an option analysis with a... And one thing, well...
19:39 Comments from the public? Sandy Hogan, and I spoke to this item at your last meeting, and as a former government official,
20:27 I urged you to jump on this last time around because to me, for what we need, and I'm talking about Mammoth Lakes Housing, to have somebody 60% of the time, well, 100% of the time sitting in the office, is that correct? In Mammoth Lakes Housing Office. But 60% of the time devoted to answering the phone in either language so that
20:56 Patricia and Diane can do their job without interruptions. And the intern, the coming intern, I hope, I mean, that's like a gift from heaven. And as a former government official, I would have jumped on it last time. And that's what I urge you to do. And I thank you for coming tonight, too. Because it is. I mean, what an opportunity. And not only that, the vision behind this to me, I see this position
21:25 And the people that follow it, who will be bicultural and bilingual, whatever, and will learn from this person, and I mean, the word will get out in the community. You know, I speak Spanish, not as well as Patricia, probably. I used to teach ESL. I did have some, you know, roots, sort of, as an Anglo can have a little bit. But, you know,
21:54 You need somebody like this. And I mean, this is a wonderful position. This could bring, start really, something we've been trying to do for so long is to engage the Hispanic, the Latino community. You know, it's really important. So I just urge you to not wait any longer and not let government, I mean, you've already talked to the attorney. I mean, it's ready to go. So the money's there, obviously.
22:23 But the opportunity for the actual blending or bringing in more of our, I was amazed with Photo Latino, 125 people now. Years ago, there were like 15. So, I mean, let's get this going. I mean, and this is the perfect position for the perfect place. So, anyway, just my comments. But I do feel very strongly that
22:52 It is so hard to bring our Latino community in, and this is one wonderful opportunity. Thank you. The podium is still open. There's no further public comments. What's the pleasure of the council or the board? Mr. Chair, I'd like to make a motion to direct staff to move forward with the development of the contractor shared staff position based on the analysis above.
23:25 Have my motion stand at allocating $20,500 of fiscal year 1819 revenue for an 18-month position, subject to further approval by the board based on the recruitment process. I'll second. I'll second that. It's been seconded. I've been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Yeah, a couple things. I agree with Sandy's point, but one thing I think we should be flexible on and keep in mind that the primary purpose of this action
23:56 As I understand it, the funding from Mono County Behavioral Health is the Latino Housing Coalition, not administrative assistance in the office. It'll be wonderful if it all works out. However, I think we need to be flexible because we do need the right person. If that person were only interested in doing a contract position to implement the housing coalition, I would urge us to be open to that.
24:24 and address the need for administrative assistance separately if we have to. So I don't know if we need to put that in the motion or we just keep that, if you all agree with me that we would just give that as direction and since we're not approving a contract yet, anyway. Well, it's been moved and seconded. I think that your comments are...
24:45 Very relevant. And so I think that's part of how we move forward. But I don't know if we need to put it into a motion. Yeah. Just want to make that note and hope. Yeah. I think it's very relevant. Yeah. I mean, I can just amend the motion to add contra shared staff position prioritized for the Latino Housing Coalition. If that's okay with you. At least it's in the motion and it's clear. The motion's been amended.
25:15 I'll second that still, yeah. So it's been amended and there's been a motion as on the floor as amended. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. Thank you.
25:35 It was nice to hear from you. That was one reason I personally waited last time was to have Robin or another wonderful representative. And I hope we would get updates on the progress of this and invite you back. Thanks very much. Thank you. We'll move to Agenda Item 6, consider and possible adoption of an organizational vision statement. Patricia?
26:01 Thank you. This item comes before you as a result of our strategic planning process that we undertook in January, February, and March. The board indicated that they may like to discuss more the development of a vision statement, which we currently do not have. I made a staff report and I kind of outlined the history of our mission to date.
26:32 So we have a charitable purpose, which is the provision or facilitation of the creation of affordable housing. We have a mission statement, which is that MLH supports workforce housing for a viable economy and a sustainable community. And we do not have a vision statement. I included in the staff report some examples from some other local organizations of their mission and their vision statements, which
27:04 May or may not be the best examples, but just something for you to look at. A vision statement can be important, and I think this is why the board wanted to discuss this a little bit more, because it really is part of our elevator speech to the community about what we do and why we're doing what we do, because we envision some future that includes affordable housing for our community.
27:33 Having a vision statement might help in developing new marketing materials and or during any fundraising campaigns that we might develop in the future. So our consultant solicited feedback from the board and came up with four vision statements that she thought we should discuss and see if any of them stick or strike a chord with us as a board.
28:04 And I wrote them down really big on this board so that you could see them. Bye! It's a closed session. So these are in the packet as well.
28:40 So some of the board members provided feedback to the consultant, which were mostly in paragraph form about the community that they envisioned in the future due to the work that we do as Mammoth Lakes Housing. And the consultant took all those mini paragraphs and found links and developed these four example vision statements for us to discuss. I think that
29:10 We can choose one of these vision statements, we can modify them or combine them, but we have to discuss it. The board is open for discussion, so I'll jump in. I prefer the original, Mammoth Lake Housing supports workforce housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. The mission and the vision are different. The mission.
29:41 So the vision is what we want to achieve from the work that we do, and the mission is the work that we do. So I like number two, two minor changes. That was my second choice. I agree with you. The change is pretty simple. One is a grammatical one, so it would read, our vision is for a strong, connected community. I would delete an economy because I think it's, we're housing focused.
30:23 In the Eastern Sierra, living in safe, affordable, quality housing near their places of work. The wording up there is a little different. I think it's a little better. I said where residents live. Okay. So you were smitted a little bit already? Yeah. That looks good to me. That looks fine. Yeah. Our vision is for a strong, connected community where residents live in safe, affordable, quality housing near their places of work. Yeah.
31:00 That's not bad. Do we want to add Eastern Sierra just to ground the community location? Sure. Connected Eastern Sierra community. Connected Eastern Sierra community. Eastern Sierra communities or community? Community. Community. I think it's the overall Eastern. I mean, we're servicing, we're servicing Alpine, Mono, and Inyo counties, right? That's it right there. Yeah. Eastern. Eastern Sierra community. Eastern Sierra community. Our vision is full. Further discussion?
31:47 What if they're not residents? What do you mean? Just say people? Well, I mean, it's sort of implicit if you're working here, you're a resident here, right? Sure. Even if you're seasonal, you're still a resident. While you live here? Yeah. I guess I'm connecting the first, you know, the first one is my preference only because it's more inclusive. So how do we... Where everyone... Right, because everyone has access.
32:23 So are we only serving people who, is that it though? You know, like we're not necessarily only serving or are we people who have a job here or are here for, you know, see all of the above. And how about if we change, because I like the first one better too, but I was rolling with it. But what if we took, you know, where everyone has access to and inserted that in there. And so where everyone has access to safe, affordable.
32:53 Does that kind of do it? Yeah, I like that. So who would we be excluding if we kept those residents? My only concern, and I don't want to speak for Agnes, would be that some people, they themselves may not consider themselves residents, even though while they're like seasonal employees and they live and work. I agree, but not to sort of put that label on it. Yeah. And so to say everyone.
33:23 To us means, I mean, everyone, is it guests who come for a weekend? Is it, but then we talk about near places of work, so that sort of excludes that, so then everyone still works. But our mission can be more specific, where we are striving to achieve this vision by supporting workforce housing. And I think if you take out this number two, you take out where residents were placed with everyone, because it says near their places of work.
33:51 It kind of takes out the idea we're just going to give everybody a place to live. And then has access to safe. Because some people might still choose to live in their vans. Right? I'm just asking it because Agnes and I were on the same page about the first one. But do you feel the phrase or calling out work limits it too much? But if not, I mean, if that's what we're really focused on is workforce housing.
34:31 I do actually. I liked the first one better as well. My comment would be that I really like the word thriving, and I would maybe swap out thriving for strong. Strong seems a little too general, but in trying to look up some other mission statements and vision statements, I looked up one from my hometown. They have a new housing organization.
34:53 Their organization also talks about retired people and ensuring that retired people have housing. It's not really something that we have talked about yet, but I did like that, that if we do want to have a really broad range of people living here full time, that that might be something as well. That it's just not necessarily work. And then, yeah, so then that work sort of takes... So are we suggesting changing the mission statement?
35:22 No, we're not talking about that right now. I know, but that, doesn't this have to go in congruency? No, our mission, well, our mission is that we support- At the end of the day, they have to be consistent. I mean, they have to be saying the same thing. Well, not necessarily. Not literally the same thing, but you can't say something in the vision statement that contradicts us in the mission. Right. But your vision could be that everybody has access to safe housing, but we're only focused on the workforce component. But we work with our partners to help
35:53 Other people achieve those goals as well. It can be more broad. So this is part of what I struggle with too. Which one is supposed to be more broad? The vision or the mission? The vision. Okay. Then I like that. I think especially if we're talking more about partnerships and working with other organizations in our greater community that leaving that broader to exclude work might be a great...
36:20 Leave us open to that, and then to Richard's point, that the mission then says workforce, and that's still what we're focused on. So, I think I will go with number one, too. Right, because we're trying to turn number two into number one, aren't we? I know. Just make it really big. Board thriving also, and then affordable, quality, and safe housing. Right. That's fine. I mean, I'm okay with number one. Yeah. As is, right? Yeah. Yeah, pretty much.
36:55 So leave thriving in? Yeah. Okay. Yes, Mr. Stapp, were you an English teacher? What are your thoughts? We envision community and these are thriving. I'm not sure. Envision thriving. Communities thriving. If you really want a wordsmithing. Communities thriving. You could, you could. Because you take out the preposition, if you want me to be an English teacher, take out the prepositional phrase.
37:27 And you have, we envision communities thriving. And then you have, we envision, could we say Eastern Sierra communities thriving? Communities in the Eastern Sierra thrive because everyone, so the vision is the end result. If you read, I always like visions like that that are the desired state, but, because you don't have that like, I'm open to whatever you guys are comfortable with.
37:55 I'm going to go with Stacy. I think it's important because I go back to the elevator speech. It's got to be something we've got to be able to say quick and thrive quickly. Communities in the Eastern Sierra thrive. Quickly. I like that. Our communities are going to thrive because you can paraphrase it. That's pretty good. You can see it on the brochure. No, that's much more. That's what I think about. Like, what's our baby's dad? What's our furniture? Definitely. Action. I think that's a better statement.
38:34 It's more emphatic. I agree. I like that. Further discussion? So we're going to accept the, as presented, communities in the Eastern Sierra Thrive because everyone has access to affordable, quality housing. Safe, affordable, quality housing. What did I say? Second. I'll second that. And move and second it. Further discussion? All those in favor?
39:04 Aye. Motion passes unanimously. Good job. That was pretty quick. That was really quick for a business statement session. I could have taken days. Chair, staff? It's me. Can I have someone, just for the viewing public, read? Because they couldn't see that, the way that was pointed. Do you want me to read it again? Yeah, I'm sorry. Can you just read what we approved? Patricia, you want to read it into the microphone?
39:37 I can see it here if you want. Okay. Communities in the Eastern Sierra thrive because everyone has access to safe, affordable, quality housing. Thank you. Thank you. We'll move to Agenda Item 7 unless there's public comment. No. We'll move to Agenda Item 7. Consider adoption of the Mammoth Lake Housing 2019-2023 Strategic Plan. Patricia?
40:14 So this is our final draft strategic plan. The board worked really hard on this plan during three strategic planning sessions in January, February, and March, and through extensive comments with the consultant individually. As you know, the consultant did a lot of research in the community regarding the perception of Mammoth Lakes Housing and what our goals should be in the future, and we came out with
40:44 I think there's five or seven strategic priority areas. I think it's about 27 or 30 pages long. And the board is asked to approve the strategic plan at this meeting with the incorporation of the vision statement that was just approved. Discussion? I think it captures, I look forward to seeing in case we missed anything, but I think it captures everything we did. Minor points. One is,
41:21 Making sure the photo credit is on the photo TV. And I wanted to see if you guys had any thought. This is obviously a picture of a Jim Luke. And it's not a bad idea to maybe have the caption read what this is of. Because we're obviously looking to reach more than just Mammoth Lakes. And so it may be nice to, you know...
41:42 Looking up towards Carson and Carson Peak and all that. Whatever the title of the photo or whatever the photographer want to call it, I think that's kind of a good thing for us because it speaks where our larger geography is. What might be nice in the future is to think about actually getting some photos of the housing that Mammoth Lakes Housing built and operates. I know a very good photographer happens to live in
42:10 And I would even make that suggestion to maybe, I don't want to hold anything up, but maybe to get a photo that's beautiful, but it's housing related. We do have a lot of stock photography of our projects that we procured a couple of years ago. The consultant didn't ask for any of those, and it hadn't come up before, but we could certainly try to incorporate some of those. This is a beautiful photograph. Do we have the right to this photograph?
42:39 No. This was from the consultant. Oh, okay. Well, we need to check that. Well, I think there's a statement. There is a statement. It is credited. It is on the cover. On the cover. No, but is it free? I mean, do we have to pay for the rights to use this? It's just her photo, right? I think she said it was donated to her by this photographer, by Grace and Howard. Okay. We may want to make sure we get a release or something. Yeah, and I agree. I think a few more photos there, a few title pages that seem like they could.
43:11 Have some pictures or just an actual photo spread at some point in it. Yeah, because there's that page. There's the other kind of strategic plan page. Yeah, good suggestion. Yeah, there's one thing I think really nicely comes through in the plan that it's focused on people, not just developing housing units. It's on people and communities. So some photos that reflect that would be awesome. And I think it's already...
43:41 more inviting to read than a document with just a lot, which we've spoken about through that process and having it be this way. So yeah, I think the more that people want to pick it up and have it. Yeah. The way it's visual, it's simple, it's not wordy, it's well presented, and we can do a lot of work with it. And John, you just mentioned about if things were missing. Giselle and I were...
44:09 We met with Patricia to go over the committees, and we read through the document to make sure that we captured everything for committees, and we felt great about it when we looked at it from that perspective and remembering back, okay, what did we talk about during the strategic planning process, and was that captured in here? Giselle had questions about programming, and yes, we found that in there and different things, so I feel confident that it did capture what we intended.
44:36 Yeah, you gave a little test drive and it works. That's what matters. You came up with several different comments and lists. Are all those incorporated? In the committee agenda item? Yeah. Yeah, that mostly came from looking at the document. Okay, okay. Step by step, page by page, and pulling out the work, the suggested work plan for the committees as well was all from here. When I provided my comments back to Sean, I was kind of nitpicking on format.
45:06 And again, just for readability. And as I'm looking at the strategic focus areas, which is really the meat and potatoes that we did, and then I had suggested to her that she enumerate those areas, and then the goals and the objectives below that in order, just so that you could sort of create a list, if you will, for tracking purposes.
45:35 So, the only little thing is, as I put the initials on the six items here, it's A, B, C, D, F, E, if you go around a circle, if you look at the... But they're not in order. They're not. Yeah. So, either we flip-flop these two and make this E, make that one F, kind of minor. And I almost would rather see the initial next to it. Yeah, I was going to say, why not? A, B, C, D, because then it refers, as you get to the detail, and then it says...
46:03 Focus Area A, Build and Facilitate Community Housing. I like that, have the title right underneath, Focus Area A. ABCDE. It's nice to see it this way, it's visually, but for working things. Yeah, it's a strategy. Where are we on? Strategy A, goal 1, objective 2, task 1, whatever it is. Yeah, and then I think at least quarterly we go back and...
46:33 Track progress, right? Yeah. Because, I mean, this is what's informing our priorities in our work. Absolutely. And then the only other little nitpick is that the heading, the heading, the heading banner for the focus area is not bold type or large type. I just feel like...
46:56 Again, just from a, on any of the pages, the focus area, it should be, like the other ones are all caps and bold, and this one's upper and lowercase and not bold, it's like, it should be reversed or something, so it kind of reads stronger, because when I first read this, I kind of, yeah, it doesn't really catch your attention, even that's the headline, right? So again, that's just nitpicking format stuff, but.
47:25 Just think it makes it really a little easier. Maybe so. Yeah, I just feel like it should be stronger. Because it's the main strategy. But yeah, otherwise I'm...
48:00 Pretty happy with the list of, and then just again, everybody's okay with, basically you have your strategy, we're calling it a focus area, and then you have a goal, or two goals, or three goals, whatever, however many there are, and then objectives and tasks, just as far as the, I think it's fine, it just takes some discipline to try to use those right terms, because, right, yeah, right, which is, I mean, it's fine, I mean, yeah.
48:28 I think I've gone through a couple different strategic planning sessions recently, and everybody has a different take on the hierarchy of the definitions, but as long as it's consistent, I suppose it's fine. Yeah, I don't know, that's where I am after a few plans. Yeah, exactly. And one thing else, you know, it struck me reading through it again yesterday, and it really is a good plan, and I think I'm excited to talk more when we get to the committee item.
48:58 But one thing to recognize is some of the tasks are pretty simple and some are more complex, and I think that'll really be the work of the committees or whatever format we end up using there to develop our short-term work plan of how we're going to. But to have the realization that if you have something that's go to this meeting and the other thing is create this rubric, obviously those aren't going to.
49:26 So we have to always maintain the flexibility to come back and tweak and, you know, realize that these things are happening kind of on parallel planes, but not necessarily at the same exact speed forward. That's a great point, Stacey. And I wonder whether or not, and maybe this is at the time now as far as adopting the plan, but maybe at a subsequent board meeting, we do assign some time frames to these to some degree?
49:56 I have an idea about that for the next time. Otherwise, if we don't set a goal for getting the stuff done, it just kind of flounders and doesn't, you know. Well, I think we should use, I'll say, because of the work that Lindsay and Giselle did on the committees and basically making each committee go with one of the focus areas, I think that's how you get, because we have to do exactly what you're saying. We have to set timelines and deliverables, but I think that that would be what we have to do, that those.
50:25 Whether they're standing committees, we'll discuss that later, whatever the process and format is going to be, but short term, that's what we've got to figure out. Yeah, I mean, you can almost create a listing numerically, you know, in the hierarchical structure that we've defined with the calendar across, much like the community has an action plan that gets down to the task level and then it sort of identifies the milestones with the tasks or the objectives of getting those completed, I think, you know.
50:54 I think it's something we should strive for. Maybe that's not at the committee level for the individual committees that are handling these different strategies. But report back at the board level? Yeah, I think it'd be a good discipline, like at least quarterly we report back on the strategy status. Yeah, don't, from a digestion perspective, recognize that I think this is a very good plan because it's very rich. There's a lot in it. In a little box, there's a lot of stuff. And don't blame the plan.
51:23 If something takes too long, it's too big a deal. We have to be really conscious about, okay, this is showing up at a meeting. This is, oh my God, this is this. Yeah, and then maybe after a year, you have to tweak some of those tasks. You realize, oh wow, this task is actually a bigger objective, so let's... Right, break it down more. But defer to the plan. Yes, defer to the plan and trust the plan and set specific times to check back in and make those tweaks. You know, don't just...
51:53 Blow it up because we didn't, yeah. Yeah, certainly. Is there any other comments specifically other than Tom's as to formatting? I like the idea of putting photos in here. I like the suggestions that John made and Tom. The idea of
52:28 Of labeling these ABC, so it's easier to follow. Again, we're trying to make it as reader friendly as possible. So, build and facilitate, that would be A, build and facilitate, B would be, you know, the different ones so that it lines up better. Also on the formatting, the idea of maybe taking the black background out, is everybody kind of, because then it stands out. Bold and underlined.
52:57 Something like that. Well, underline, don't get carried away, Tom. Just bold. Bold is good. Underline, I don't know. Something just so that it... We can take a look at it at our next meeting, the changes that have been made. Sure, unless you want to adopt it with modifications. Do we want to adopt it now with the revision? Yeah, that's just formatting. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The text is there.
53:27 Then if you look at the motions that are available, do you want to make a motion, Lindsay? I would make a motion to adopt the strategic plan 2019 through 2023 with the addition of the vision statement adopted by the board on May 6, 2019 with some formatting changes that we just discussed. Headings, mostly headings. And photography. And photography, thank you.
53:56 I'll second that motion. I just want to make sure that, okay, the vision statement is what was put on the board, okay, just for clarity. Further discussion? Do I have a second? I'll second. I've been moved and seconded. All those in favor? Aye. Move to agenda item 8, which is discuss possible formation of committees and provide staff direction. Patricia? Thank you.
54:29 So this is an item that is an outcome from our strategic plan. We came up with one, two, three, four, five, six focus areas. And one of the focus areas was to strengthen organizational capacity. That's focus area F. And creating committees was an objective to achieve that focus area.
55:02 Provided you with some considerations to think about when creating committees. The committee purpose, the type of committee, whether it's a standing committee versus an ad hoc committee. Does it have long-term goals or short-term goals? How many board members should be on the committee? And are there staffing needs for the particular committee in question? At Mammoth Lakes Housing, we've used ad hoc committees in the past quite a bit.
55:32 For nominations to the board, contract negotiations, and things that are short term. Ad hoc committees must be comprised solely of board members and are not required to operate within the confines of the Brown Act, so the public meeting notice requirements. Standing committees can have outside members, but you need to notice the meetings. You don't have to have a specific
56:01 Regular meeting defined, but you need to notice accordingly like any other regular meeting. And it needs to be in a public place where the public can attend, obviously. I met with a couple of board members to discuss what types of committees they thought were outlined in the strategic plan with all the focus areas that we came up with. And I provided those initial committee descriptions in the board packet.
56:32 I'm going to actually hang them up on the board as well just to get a bigger visual of how many committees we're actually talking about so that we can get a sense of where we think the priorities are around what committees we maybe want to form immediately or maybe wait and then we can start the conversation. Thank you, Lindsay and Giselle for doing this work. This really helped and I like the way you broke it down to the...
57:06 Focus areas. That makes a lot of sense. Yeah, it was a good process with Patricia. If I may, well, Patricia's hanging those up. One of them that I believe is maybe not a focus area is the diversity, equity, and inclusion. And I wanted to speak a little bit, Patricia, I don't know if you had something planned to speak to that, but I believe everything else is referenced in the strategic plan, except for that one. And that one, a little bit,
57:36 Our thoughts were as we met and we looked through this strategic plan, it references a lot about the work that MLH does with and for the Latino community. And one of our thoughts was, currently we are not engaging that community very well right now. So on one hand, to do some outreach to the Latino community would be great. And then...
58:03 Also in the provide strategic discussion topics to the board, some of those topics were about sort of ensuring that we have a good board practice, that everybody gets to speak, and that everybody feels valued, and some of that. So it was sort of a two-part equity in our greater community and then within our own organization as well.
58:28 And I like the idea, you know, if we're starting this new program with the Latino Housing Coalition, having a standing, I think, and this is one I think deserves to be a standing committee that would show commitment by this board to, you know, submit to make this a permanent standing committee. And since if we're going to start this new program with the Latino Housing Coalition, having an extra layer of engagement and oversight, I think that would be really good.
58:59 And I, yeah, I don't want to jump around in our list, but I think with, and Stacey, you had asked a county person who was here about who really oversees and does things, and I wonder if we had this as a standing committee, is it, it may not make sense because some of it is internal, but ensuring that the county maybe is invited to certain meetings.
59:23 I don't know if you could do that. Or have them sit. And then maybe some of the stuff that's about our internal meetings, maybe they don't. But the other, I think that would be another, that would make sense for the Diversity, Equity, Inclusion Committee to be standing, would be that you could invite outside. I mean, not to get too far ahead in the discussion, because I'll see if I'm applying that the others I don't think need to be standing committees, but this one in particular.
59:48 And I support that, but I think we're a little ahead of ourselves. I'm very concerned about staff, because if you do a standing committee, they're going to have to be noticing. MLR has gotten, has sort of gotten drowned in standing committees. I don't think the others should be standing committees. They don't say that right now. I don't think they should be at them. I have a discussion about that to make, because I want to hear from Patricia and staff. What can we actually support and how are we going to do this? Yeah, just clearly. So yeah, I will just read the committee names that,
1:00:17 The group came up with. It's the Fundraising Committee, Programs Committee, Housing Development Committee, Executive Committee, Marketing Communications Committee, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee, and then I have space for Other as the conversation. That's a stupid question. The six that are in here, is the same six that are up there? Yes. You know, as I reconcile these against our strategic plan,
1:00:46 They all kind of line up with the main strategies, A through F, and I think that the Diversity, Equity, Inclusion Committee could possibly fall under C, bolster collaboration and partnership, although we didn't specifically call that out in our strategies and tasks under that particular item, but maybe that committee adds what's in our strategy C since it's
1:01:14 Kind of falls in that category. I don't know if I'm overreaching, but otherwise, everything else slotted in pretty cleanly into the rest of them. I'll just speak a little to the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee. Staff attended a training hosted by Mono County Behavioral Health on diversity, equity, and inclusion. Some of our board members were there, and the training covered
1:01:44 A lot of different things around diversity, equity, and inclusion from a personal perspective, from an institutional perspective. And I felt like there was so much there that we needed to have some of these conversations at our board. And after speaking with some board members, it just seemed like this conversation was ongoing and the committee description
1:02:14 Committee that came up with the descriptions felt like it was worth a discussion at this point. And you referenced focus area C foster collaboration and partnerships. There are some things about collaboration and partnerships in other committees. So I don't think, I'm not sure that we need to necessarily attach a focus area specifically to the committees other than pulling things out of the, for the potential assignments.
1:02:43 Give it a letter. Give it a letter. Because I do see, I got kind of, you know, in looking through this, I got kind of inspired thinking, okay, because I agree with Tom, with the strategic plan, we've got to work on even the short-term first-year goals and assigning timelines and breaking, maybe breaking down some things that are more complex projects. So if you had, and I would suggest.
1:03:08 Ad hoc committees. Basically, it's board members committing to work on them. For each focus area, that would make a lot of sense. But you would have to add C, I suppose, because you would need to get in there and break down some of those deliverables. That would be the only. But that, you know, that's still complex and kind of a lot of work. I guess you probably want to have more conversation around what can we actually manage.
1:03:37 Well, and also, I'm a little hesitant to put diversity, equity, inclusion into a committee, kind of park it over here somewhere. I think this needs to be informing everything that we're doing. And so I'm just wondering if this is the right way to go about doing this. I think this is more of a statement of real integration of values into how we do business. I defer to others, but I think I would hate to have it kind of parked over here in a committee.
1:04:06 and not seeing this be part of everything that we're doing. I would like to see some clarity as to what this means as a committee would approach. How does a committee do this? Or what are they doing in this committee to fulfill this diversity, equity, and inclusion?
1:04:26 I think that the idea around the committee was that they would help staff bring some of these topics to the board to discuss and institutionalize those values, that they would help play that role. I've got an idea. What if we did this as an ad hoc, so it doesn't have to be a standing committee, but the committee looks at how we incorporate diversity and makes a recommendation back to the board, how do we bring best practices of diversity, equity, inclusion?
1:04:54 I think I'd like to go through each box with all of the five considerations to sort of make sure we're on the same page for everything. And as far as your thought that the diversity, equity, and inclusion committee would sort of be...
1:05:20 Parked over somewhere. I actually feel the opposite. I think that committee keeps things rolling, sort of like Patricia said, bringing it back and in the potential assignments that are here, define meeting agreements. That's something we talked about. There's some specifics about understanding what that means. And rather than setting up something so we're doing business and then something is kind of lobbing things in from the side, I think it's of such value and so important that it needs to be something that's overarching.
1:05:50 And really is informing all the things that we're doing from that lens and from that perspective. And it infuses everything that we're doing. Rather than having a committee goes off down a track and then you've got a committee over here saying, well, that's not going to work. It just might not be efficient doing it that way. Isn't this kind of the role of the executive committee? I don't know. I think it's sort of in the values of the organization. I would think the executive would.
1:06:17 It's a rich topic. It's a rich subject matter that needs
1:06:49 An ongoing presence is important, but how we go about doing it, I think, is kind of a question. This is the one I would make a standing committee, I'll say that again, because that, first to me, that demonstrates organizationally a more solid commitment to this concept, because I think there's a lot of work to do. I also attended the training, which was incredibly valuable, and I hope we can do more trainings with that.
1:07:19 Subject matter and content, but it's a practice. It's, you know, it's not just sort of a, like, we will, you know, we want our community to thrive, you know, overarching vision. There's a, there's a practice underlying it, and I, and I think if we had a committee dedicated, dedicated to giving our organization opportunities to learn that practice, it would be a really
1:07:47 Good thing for the organization. So that's one aspect, but I'm looking through the box, the description of this committee. Again, I really think having this committee provide strong oversight of the new program we are creating with the Latino Housing Coalition, I think building a structure in there where there's responsibility for oversight would be valuable. Creating a new program is a lot of work,
1:08:18 And I can, our folks at Mono County Behavioral Health do a great job, but they've got a million things going on. It's going to be a lot of work for Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I think this new staff person is going to need a lot of support. I attended the training as well, and it's rich. It's deep, and it's just the surface. And I would just caution the board. I would see if we can find a way to get the entire board trained or to go through a similar experience.
1:08:47 So we all kind of understand what this world is, what this practice is all about. So the board's not going to be surprising itself. There are not going to be things coming out of a committee that can be challenging. They're not going to hear things like, I've never heard that before. I have no idea what you're talking about. I think it's important to establish a level of literacy with the board. The committee's great. I mean, if that's the direction that folks want to go, that's fine. But I think we should all together go through a training of some kind.
1:09:17 So we all know what the hell this is and what we're talking about. It's incredibly important. It's incredibly rich. So maybe this committee has purpose at the beginning to get us up to speed and practicing like we should be or we want to be motivated to do and then at some point maybe cut that committee out or any of the other committees out if and when we deem it necessary to it's not necessary anymore.
1:09:43 Or maybe that committee just meets, I mean, maybe that committee is just going to have less and less to do as we go further down the road. Not if we're creating a whole new program that they would be overseeing. Yeah, in which case we would keep going. Well, I would be willing to see it, see where it goes, and see, you know, how powerful or useful it can be. Should we go through all of it?
1:10:12 I think it sounds like maybe that's what the board wants to do is go through each committee and decide priority level. Sure. Real quick, I wanted to get the board's feedback or thoughts on, I'm just kind of doing the math here and going, okay, there's six committees proposed. If there's three board members on each committee, that would mean 18 divided by nine, it would mean each board member would.
1:10:40 Try to be on two committees, right, to kind of share the workload, if you will. And I'm just trying to get a sense of what everybody's availability commitment, you know. Well, and I'll just say at our April 1st board meeting, I recommended three committees to start. I don't know if we have staff capacity for much more than that. Maybe that's a baseline for the discussion. Okay, so then really what we're saying is.
1:11:09 We'll go through these and then try to prioritize which committees we should form for the moment. And then between, another question for you, between standing or ad hoc, the work level, I mean, you know, the meeting noticing, staff participation, what does that, what does that mean to you? I think if we start with three, I don't see a problem with either. It just depends on where you want to go from there. Adding. In terms of staffing, do you, I mean,
1:11:37 The town provides staff capacity for our meetings. That capacity, if you set up a standing committee, would that capacity come with it or no? I believe it would, but I'm not necessarily sure that we need it. Well, if it's a Brown Act, I just, I ask. Well, Mammoth Lakes Housing Office is a public place, so we can hold committee meetings there. We don't have to meet in here. And I think in terms of scheduling, in terms of administration of getting a meeting scheduled and having staff attend, it's going to be more cumbersome.
1:12:07 Honestly. Yeah, the standing committee. No, just using town staff resources. Oh, I see what you're saying. So to clarify, a standing committee, we would need to have it, we would have to have Angie or someone actually taking minutes and creating a report? No, our staff can do that. Standing, you can do that. Yeah.
1:12:29 You just have to notice. You have to publish 72 hours in advance. Right. So that's the only thing. Let's say I'm on the Committee for Development. Tom's on that committee. It's just the two of us. We decided to meet for coffee to discuss something that just came up. If we were a standing committee, we would have to publish notice and then wait and then have that meeting. 72 hours and then post it. And we'd have to be in a public place. So how careful do I have to be talking to my counter?
1:12:58 Committee person to not discuss business because they're so afraid of Mr. Brown or Mrs. Brown, whoever this Brown lady's person is. Ralph M. It seems in my picture a good idea, but in practicality it seems kind of silly to be able to. Yes. To be able to. So then do ad hoc, make it ad hoc. And so we don't have a problem necessarily doing it ad hoc, even though the committee may go for a long period of time. Is that the definition of standing an ad hoc? It has to have a state of purpose and it has to end at some point.
1:13:27 My suggestion would be for these, like I said, I would probably do all of them and having them match the, because I've got to organize things like that too, having them match the focus areas that are in the plan and create an ad hoc committee for each focus area to flesh out a timeline and a work plan for the first year. And then come back and say, okay, what needs to come back as a standing committee so that you guys, you know, so that we... That would make sense. Yeah.
1:13:57 So we don't do standing committees out of the box. Except my suggestion would be for DEI. And that would allow a non-board member to be on a standing committee for the diversity, equity, and inclusion. That would be, in my mind, the one difference. Okay, let's beat through. So, Patricia, real quick, the notes.
1:14:20 That are underneath each one of the committees, are those in our agenda as well, those reports on the... Yes, these are the notes we took at our meeting when we went through the strategic plan, and I typed those up and provided them in the staff report. That's right. It's just for visual. I want you to see how many there were all at once. On yellow. Right, on orange paper.
1:14:48 I guess I can just, so the first committee is the Housing Development Committee. This was a committee supposed to create the development rubric with different development opportunities in the service area that we serve. It was to help with the development of our 238 Sierra Manor Road project, to promote collaboration regionally, to create a strategy to engage the development community, and to identify capital sources to fund potential projects.
1:15:21 Do you want to speak to one each individually? Are we assigning people? What are you asking? I think it would be good to just quickly go through the considerations. Is the purpose there standing versus ad hoc long-term or short-term number of board members and staffing needs I think would be good to talk about. I'd also like to add to this one.
1:15:48 That I think the Housing Development Committee, when or if it is created, should participate in any needs for the parcel development. I would add that in there. Oh, is it number six? To be a number six in there. I don't know how we would say it, but to participate in any needs of the process for the parcel development. To stay up to date. If we have a development committee, that's a big development.
1:16:18 Specific people that are staying, really making sure that they're in the know. Not necessarily town staff specific meetings, but any part of the public process or MLH's role. I want to be clear about that because the town has a staff team that's working on this that Patricia attends. So what you're talking about is the public.
1:16:40 Whatever the public side of this, that's what these committee members are making sure they're going to those things. Maybe recruiting people to come, spreading the word about the public process things. They're our board parcel experts. Yes, I like that, that they would be our board's parcel experts. I love that. We're not on time council. The only thing I'd add to this is, and we spoke with this at the council meeting a while back, is
1:17:05 It's, as a council member, it's unclear to me what is happening with real estate development in this community. I just, I just, I don't know what's going on. And I think that it would be important to not make any assumptions that the kind of the historic assumptions that, oh, development's going to happen and things are going to come out of it. I'm not, I'm not, I personally am not seeing that. So I don't quite know what's going on. So parcel expertise is great. And I think having people on there who,
1:17:35 Aren't making any assumptions about what's happened with real estate development in this community and how housing is going to relate to that. It's open-minded. It's like, who knows? We don't know what's going on here. I think we have our first volunteer for the committee. Well, I want to say one thing. I serve on this board, and it's a great board, and it's amazing how much progress this board has made. I'm really happy to be part of this. I'm appointed by the town council, and those appointments will be coming up for review, I think, in June.
1:18:05 June or July. So I don't know if I'll be on this board after that. So I will, you guys put me where you want me to go. I'm also, but I may not be here after that. So I just want you to know that. Thank you. So just to be clear here, we're going to go through each of these just quickly and look at the.
1:18:30 Scope and then come back and talk about prioritizing. Yeah, and it seemed like Stacy's comment was that she thought each one should have an ad hoc committee at this point to define the first year timeline and work plan for any standing committees that we would want to create. Yeah, it's just hard because these are all parts of our strategic plan, so how do you prioritize one or the other? That was what I struggled with. We could dive in a little bit and figure out what's going on. Yeah. Okay, so, go ahead. Just...
1:18:59 No, you're good. Go ahead. Okay, so then there's Programs Committee, which is supposed to work on property management program research when that time comes, community housing action plan analysis, streamlined referrals for other housing programs in the community, annual outreach to existing communities that we service, rental inspection program research, which is another new program.
1:19:28 Chamber program participation, middle income down payment assistance program, and then these were just some side notes we had in our strategic plan about things we might think about in the future, legal clinic hours, real estate services, small business loan program, and then helping to better define the fee-for-service program. So that's kind of a lot. That's a lot. I think what strikes me about this is, on the development side,
1:19:57 Not a whole lot's happened in the private sector. We've got the parcel. We've got Sierra Manor Road, so those are those kinds of projects. But on the program side, we've got a lot of stuff in there, which is good. I think that's what we wanted. And my question then, sort of because I'm not as familiar with ad hoc versus standing committees, is something with a lot of tasks. Should that be a standing committee so they get a regular meeting on the books so that they're able to work through?
1:20:25 Work through the tasks? I would just defer. I think Stacey's suggestion is an excellent one. If this was, if all these committees, unless we decide otherwise, are ad hocs, folks can sit down and start to prioritize, okay, what do we, this is all the stuff we've got from the plan, and come back to the board with a recommendation that says, look, these are all the things we've looked at in detail. These are the things we think we should prioritize. And then if you want to make a standing committee, you can do it, but at least you take that first look at it and report back to the board. Yeah, and you're really, that way you're really sure that you're basing,
1:20:55 The committee work on what's in the plan and not, because it's super easy to come up with another good idea. Right. And yeah, the programs section is rich. One of the other things, sorry, that I do want to make sure we talk about is, is there a reason that Patricia or Diane, in these first two that we've talked about, housing development or programs, is there a reason they need to go to those meetings? Or could it just be two or three?
1:21:25 Board members who then maybe type up a quick, even if it is ad hoc, type up their quick report that'll be at the monthly meeting or the quarterly board meeting, but it goes to Patricia and Diane first just to try to take a load off. Yeah. Yeah. Because you don't need any staff support. Perfect. You just sign a couple members, you guys go beat this thing up, figure out what you come out with it, say, Patricia, we've got something ready now that there's a report back to the board, then the board can discuss it. Okay.
1:21:51 I like that ad hoc as well. Do standing committees have to have a staff person? Or they just have to have this, could a committee secretary take notes? Yeah, but you've got to notice it, you've got to write an agenda, you've got to have minutes, you've got to go through all that stuff. Okay, and then we have fundraising committee, which was tasked with developing the ask and identifying donors and strategies, thanking donors, researching new revenue streams.
1:22:22 Some technical assistance on donation receding process, defining the donation use policy, helping with the land asset donation process, researching tax measure, lift ticket tax, VRBO tax, and other possibilities, and then having some research and discussion around board donations. Okay, and then we have marketing and communications. They would assist with
1:22:58 The development of the roadshow, discussing whether or not we should hire an agency to help with graphic design and marketing, possible name change, helping the board define and communicate the vision, mission, and the message, and then making sure there's a budget for marketing and that the budget for marketing meets the needs that the committee has identified, ensuring that we have an online presence,
1:23:29 Participating in coffee talks or whatever that turns out to be, helping with educational materials, ensuring that marketing is inclusive, and partnering to disseminate information. And then we have an executive committee which would be made up of the president, the vice president, and the treasurer. Is that already existing? Do we have any committees existing right now?
1:24:06 Just the ad hoc contract negotiations committee. That's in place right now and ongoing, right? It's in place until the contract is executed. This committee would work on the partnership agreement and matrix, work on the evaluation process for the executive director, discuss term limits for board members.
1:24:32 Review the bylaws and articles of incorporation, define board governance calendar, and define strategic discussion items. And then we have the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee, which would help to define the meeting agreements, enhance Latino community outreach, provide strategic discussion topics to the board, work with the Programs Committee to host events, and provide oversight for the Latino Housing Coalition staff person.
1:25:10 The Executive Committee, again, was President, Vice President, and Treasurer. But we don't have a Treasurer. We do not. So it could be, potentially it could be another Board. We talked about that last time that there isn't really any reason it couldn't be another Board member, the third spot. Yeah, or we could call the Committee something else and then it wouldn't be, it could be any Board member then. So I'm just going to throw something out just for the purpose of discussion.
1:25:42 I would oppose that we set up a ad hoc committee for programs, an ad hoc committee for marketing, a standing committee for DEI, like we talked about a little bit further, and a standing committee for the executive committee. What about the other? The other ones for now, just leave them aside for the moment. I mean, this is, again, I'm very concerned about taxing staff. So that's just setting aside the housing development and the fundraising, if I heard you right.
1:26:12 I mean, that makes sense. There's only so much in the plan. You're going to... Yeah, these ad hocs, we can set a time, report back, hopefully in a reasonable period of time, and then see what they can do, see what we can digest, and get a report back from staff as to, okay, we can handle this, or we can't handle this much, or we can handle more, or something.
1:26:33 Yeah, I think the only thing in our discussion that came up with the fundraising committee, now that we do have our donate button online and we're potentially going to start taking cash donations, we just have to be conscious of tax receding rules that we're giving people proper letters with the proper language in a timely fashion. So just making sure that that happens. And then it can just be maybe something that board members are tasked with if we do get donations.
1:27:02 A nice thank you call from a board member. Some things like that that just hopefully we get lots of donations rolling in soon. Just to be clear, we're 501C3 and we have accountants. Yes. Right. So if a donation comes in, that should be like almost an automatic process. Do the accountants send letters to donors? No, not yet. No, they don't do that. I mean, they're not set up to do that. They can send just the legal notification to say.
1:27:30 Thank you for donation. We're a 5-1-3. Thank you very much. Just illegally, we're good. But if we want to do something more, if a donation comes in, Patricia can say, hey, we had four donations this week. Let's write a letter. Yes. Currently, the account is not set up to do that. I just wanted to make sure that that doesn't fall through the cracks. But yeah, those would be kind of my two out of that to make sure that it doesn't fall through. Only other than in the housing, we talked a lot about the development rubric.
1:28:00 To make sure that the whole community is on the same page with who we think is doing what. So that might be the only other to sort of task either staff or to get a few people to just. I'm going to take public comment. John, what was your, you said the focus should be on, what were they for? You mentioned four of them. Yeah. Programs would be an ad hoc committee. Program ad hoc. Go ahead. Marketing would be ad hoc.
1:28:30 DEI would be standing, and the executive committee would be standing. Do we still call it executive if it's standing? Yeah, both executive committee. Executive would be standing as well? Yeah. Sorry. And so online, we would have on the fundraising committee, just basically our webpage. Yeah, no, I understand that. And marketing could tackle a little piece of it.
1:29:07 Yeah. Well, it's got to be always there. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, any one of these ad hocs could be saying, well, we've got something set up over here. We really need to prioritize getting, because we're seeing a bunch of work over for that committee. We really think we need to get that thing up and going. I see a hand out there. Well, I will just say, and this will come up in the 238 Sierra Manor Road update, is that we will need some board participation in some of the ongoing.
1:29:36 Process for that development. And so that would be an ad hoc committee. Then maybe that should just be the hassle. Yeah, I guess I know we can't necessarily prioritize like one, two, three, four, five, six, but it definitely seems like DEI and Executive are a priority on its own. And then it seems like secondarily, you know, not combining, but fundraising, marketing sort of makes sense to go together as development and programs. Not that
1:30:07 And that's sort of three categories. Sort of. Yeah, that would get us through most of the plan. Yeah, and it doesn't mean that you're going to tackle all these potential assignments, but it could mean we're like programs housing development for that bunch, we're going to come up with the priority list or like the timeline or what, you know, does that make sense? So you combine those two? Combine them just to come up with a timeline.
1:30:37 Or to come back to recommendations. Yeah. Okay, sure. Right, like just two tasks for both of those. Yeah, sure. So you're saying programs and housing and development. That's what you're saying. Yeah, programs and development. So programs and development. Well, I want to throw caution on the table that of all of these things, all of these committees are tasks that need to be done. Which one has the longest lead time to actually accomplish a goal?
1:31:03 And from my point, I think the housing development is going to take the longest period of time. And so, you know, the sooner you can start creating community meetings of developers and getting that slowly rolling, it's going to take a while. I would say I don't think everybody's going to jump on. Well, I would say one thing to that, which is on the private side, the private sector side, that's why I've said, like, I don't know what's going on out there. A lot of that,
1:31:33 Would be coming from the private sector. And so someone's going to come to the town and put an application or Tom's going to be able to, you know, something's going to be happening. There's, at least what I know, there's not a whole lot happening in that space. So things that we know about are, we know about the property that we own, we know about the parcel, we know the hotel is kind of doing something, but beyond that there's not a whole lot. But if you, I think if Agnes' suggestion, if you lump these things together,
1:32:00 And we sort of said, hey, we need a report out in two meetings or something like that so it doesn't go off forever. And the report out is specific to each of the two committees. Yeah. I think that's a way to kind of digest it. We can start getting our hand. I think that's a really good idea. Yeah, and really being, having so much discipline to focus on what's in the plan. Like, is that an objective in the plan? Is that a task? Oh, I see that's under future goals. We got to leave that aside.
1:32:28 For now, and focus on, you know, really trying to implement this plan. Because that's where the danger well-meaning board members tend to get into. So I hear maybe some consensus around a Programs and Development Ad Hoc Committee and a Governance Committee, which would take on the Executive Committee and the DEI Committee, Ad Hoc Committee. And then...
1:32:57 I thought DEI and Executive Committee were separate or standing. I thought you had combined them. Well, I combined them as like priority. Like I see those as the two priority committees. Oh, okay. So three committees. Yes. Well, I don't know if we... I get what you're saying. Should I arrange the boxes? Yeah, maybe. Go re-tape the boxes.
1:33:27 So a DEI standing committee, a governance standing committee, a programs and development ad hoc committee, and a marketing ad hoc committee. Marketing fundraising. Oh, that was where it was. So then I wonder, we're just combined, I mean, we're giving, we're making fewer committees but giving them more tasks.
1:34:00 Seems to me keeping them separate, you're able to focus a little bit better on the work. But maybe it makes it, I just feel like you're going to now have longer meetings. You'll have fewer meetings to attend, but maybe longer meetings. I don't know. But the thing is, we don't have the bandwidth to do everything. So I think if you put them together and you say, look, you've only got two meetings from now, you got to report back out. So you will spend three weeks meeting and figuring that you can. But the idea is just keep it high level.
1:34:29 Touch on everything and come back with a recommendation for the board of the two individual committees that you're working on to make a recommendation for where to go. Yeah, I mean, the reality of it is you could have separate committees, but very likely it's going to be the same people. Right. And I want to maybe make sure that we're all on the same page, too, that these assignments
1:34:54 Are things that this committee does that we don't say to staff, oh, hey, we think you should prioritize the roadshow. Okay. Perfect. That we're saying like that the committee will take on this. There's no commitment of staff time. Perfect. Until it comes back to the board. Perfect. And we, because we got to allocate resources. Yeah. The board can't talk to the staff. Yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, we would, the end of the process would be, okay, we're going to come together. Each, each of the committees brings their recommendations for.
1:35:23 The timeline and, you know, sub-priorities under what's in the plan, and then we vote on that as a whole. I'm going to allocate our resources. I'm going to allocate our resources. Sandy had her hand up for a half hour. Yeah, sorry, Sandy. This is so complex. I know you did, frankly, and I hope that half of you are, too. Because what I propose is that you come, set up all the others as ad hocs who have interest for now.
1:35:53 And let them get together as an ad hoc and see what fits in their interest or not. Maybe it's just a couple of people. And other ones, and then the, probably, I like John's actually original statements. I'm getting lost here because you said some of these are just really ways of doing business.
1:36:15 Good practices. In other words, yeah, bolstering the collaboration and partnerships, things like that, that's a way of doing business. And, you know, and the result out of that will be your, I think your diversity, the one you were talking about, that's a way of doing business. You don't have to have committees. I mean, that's segregating even more. That's putting it into silos, you know? So maybe segregate those things out. I see each of a committee
1:36:46 You know, if people that have an interest and probably a specialty knowledge or whatever, and maybe take all of Patricia's hard work and a couple of people, you know, get together, the rest of you is ad hocs that have the interest, talk about it, figure out just what you were saying, well, maybe this one goes over someplace else, and then come back or submit your notes to the XCOM, you know, and have them look it over and then have Patricia
1:37:15 Maybe put it together, but I just see Patricia doing more and more and more work on this, and I heard all sorts of different things here, and I don't know quite what the outcome was. So if you can simplify it at first, you know, just look at the ways of doing business, and you can have ad hoc committees of a couple of people getting together, want to do fundraising, or marketing, or they want to do fundraising and not marketing. You know, you've got to kind of sort that out, and then they can come back, and you make it a better discussion.
1:37:44 But I don't know, maybe you guys are all on one page, but I'm just going like, I don't think I understand. Anyway, let's just, you know, simplify first, and this whole business of ad hocs and standing, oh God, it is hard. It is hard. But if the ad hoc committee is to figure out what the, you know, what that particular committee should do, then that's an ad hoc, that's a task, and you can bring it back. Just suggestions.
1:38:15 Been a long discussion. Patricia, do you want to try to summarize where we're going from here? I always put it on her. Yes, I believe that we are going to go through the process to create two ad hoc committees. One is programs and development, and one is marketing and fundraising. Programs and housing development. Yes, that's right. The reason, sorry, that I bring that up is in sort of non-profit.
1:38:42 World, there's often a development position and title, so I want to be sure that it's housing. And then two standing committees, which will be DEI and Executive or Governance Standing Committee. For a total of four committees. Two ad hoc, two standing. Yes. One thing, the only request I would make is that for the DEI standing committee that whoever the town council appointee is, that that appointee be on that committee.
1:39:16 Sorry, say again. Say that again. I would request, however we're close to a motion, that whoever the town council representative is to this board, that that person be on that DEI standing committee. How will we know if they will bring expertise to that committee? Well, if they don't have the expertise, they need to learn. And I think the importance of the DEI is such that it needs to be, people need to learn this.
1:39:45 And I think it would be very valuable for the council, for the community, to have that person engage with those issues and those topics. I think also if we could add sort of an assignment written out, because I think we're getting, in my mind, I'm getting a little confused, the language in the title means something different than the actual assignments. The assignments are sort of, I think you're, this diversity, equity, inclusion is a
1:40:12 A way of doing business, but then what is the specific task associated with that? Because the tasks right now are really Latino community outreach and ensuring that our board has topics and meeting agreements and things. So if there's something that we could put into words, maybe for what you're voicing.
1:40:35 I don't know if that makes sense. You get oversight of the housing coalition once that employee is on. I think that's going to be a big part of it. Yeah. Yeah, and I would add to go with that is I think that maybe not part of this, but I think that to find a way for the board to be involved together as a board with the DEI training effort I think is incredibly important. And I don't know if that's part of this. That's kind of a different topic. So that we all...
1:41:03 Have a basic understanding of the language, the semantics, what we're talking about. I think that that's going to be incredibly important. I'd add exactly as you said that bring DEI training to our board, to the board in whichever way, shape, form that committee sees. And as far as having the town representative on there, I don't see any issue or reason why not or why they should be on a different.
1:41:35 Committee, other than personal interest or expertise. So I'm not sure. Yeah, I just think that that's such an important area, and I think that would be a very important point of liaison back to the town. But if it's a bad idea, it's a bad idea. I mean, I think one of the assignments is adding just that, not just the training, but like what else should be an assignment of this committee. Yeah. I mean, to start at the top.
1:42:06 Yeah, not to say that these are the only assignments, for sure, that Orange Committees meet. Yeah. For any of the committees. So I'd make a motion. That's appropriate. For the discussion? Are we, the way that this is written, are we actually assigning people? No, I think you can give staff direction to continue the process to bring the creation of these committees forward at the next meeting. Oh.
1:42:36 Yeah, I don't think it needs to be in a motion. I think it's just a staff direction at this point because we've certainly modified the agenda bill. Okay. I think that'll work moving forward. Now people can think about what those committees are and their interests. The point is that we're going to have to make choices. And it's like we got everything in there. We're going to touch everything. But at the end of the day, there's only so much money. We're going to have to come together and say, hey, this is a priority.
1:43:08 Care, we can have, what, four people on a committee? Yes. Do we care what number of people are on any committees as long as it's no more than four? I don't think we should. Four or less. We can have four. Maybe a minimum of two, so it's not just a committee of one. Yeah. It'd be a lot easier to meet. Yeah. To Sandy's point a little bit, self-selecting through staff is probably the best way to go. Yeah.
1:43:38 Okay. I think that's it. I mean, we didn't talk about short-term or long-term, but I think we had plenty of discussion. Sounds like it'll be fairly long term. That's a very good point, though. I think the standings, I mean, they're forever until we decide not to do them anymore. But I think the ad hoc should be reporting back within two meetings at the second or in a reasonable period of time. That's not true. You want to get...
1:44:12 Report out from those groups so we can start prioritizing where to put our resources. But do we actually have to put a hard... Yeah, July, yeah. Do we have to put a hard end date? I would put a hard end date on that. And it's just July? That doesn't sound like that's far enough out to do anything. That's fine. No, just a first report out. Maybe not that it's... But then do we have to create another ad hoc committee? No, no, no. Just a first report out. Right. Because they'll get really formed in June and then the next month. Okay. When do we need to say when the...
1:44:41 Hard stop for ad hoc committees. Not yet, but we'd have to, I don't know, it's a brown act question, but we'd have to say it at some point. Okay. I mean, because if anything, I would say link it to the strategic plan and make them go to 2023. Well, what's more important is the purpose of the ad hoc has to be defined. So it has to be clear what it's doing, and then from that, you can figure out how long it was going to take to do it, and then they come together. We complete our mission, it's over, and it's done. Okay. Sounds good. Great.
1:45:12 Thank you. Thank you. Long discussion. Good discussion. We'll move to agenda item nine, which is review and discuss the Mammoth Lake Housing, Sierra Housing advocacy, or yes. Okay, so we have our third quarter financial statements. The first page is the balance sheet for Mammoth Lakes Housing, which is our overall financial picture. At the top, you'll see our assets, including our properties that we own.
1:45:43 And in the bottom, you'll see our liabilities, including the loan that we have on 238 Sierra Manor Road, and you can see we're making payments on that. And then the top and the bottom are in balance. I provided the forecast, which projects our expenditures through the end of the fiscal year, which ends June 30, 2019. And everything looks pretty good to me.
1:46:14 You'll note that we spent more in board development than we had budgeted for our strategic planning this year, but everything seems pretty reasonable. I just wanted to note that at the bottom under 238 Sierra Manor Road project, we're projecting to allocate approximately $20,000 in net proceeds to the reserve for that project.
1:46:48 And then the same for Star Apartments. We'll allocate a percentage of rents to the long-term reserve for that project for capital improvements. And then the next page is the statement of cash flow or transactions from investment opportunities. And you'll see that we received some payments on CalHome loans that we have in the community. And there's a net change in cash of about $8,000.
1:47:25 Yeah. Oh, the last, well, the last schedule for Mammoth Lakes Housing is the Cal Home Program Reuse Schedule. So currently this reuse program is allocated under unrestricted reserves, and I'm working to move that to a restricted account. We have approximately $13,000 to loan towards the purchase of a manufactured home in a mobile home park. So that's what that money is for.
1:48:02 And then Sierra Housing Advocates, nothing has happened. We haven't done any real estate transactions. And so this looks the same as the last quarter. I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions from the board? I have one question on, maybe in the mortgage agenda, I get a little confused. PDF page 56, draft Mammoth LDS housing. It's after, it's after the Sierra Housing Advocates statement.
1:48:39 Yes, that's the draft budget. Oh, that's a typo. I'm so sorry. Further questions? Do you need a motion, Patricia, or just accept this as information? Just informational.
1:49:04 If there are no questions of staff, we'll move to agenda item 10, review and possible approval of Mammoth Lake Housing draft 2019-2020, physical year budget. Patricia? This is the first time you're seeing this draft budget for the next fiscal year, which will start July 1st, 2019. So I'll just try to go through it and be as thorough as possible.
1:49:33 The first page is our projected revenue for the year July 1st through June 30th, 2020. We have the town contract services. Then we have other contract income. This line item includes contracts with other organizations, and I've included...
1:49:52 The income we're expected to receive for our intern through the California Coalition for Rural Housing, and then also the income from Mono County Behavioral Health for the Latino Coalition staff person. There's property management fees. I've added a line item for fundraising with a projected revenue of zero. That's conservative.
1:50:19 And then most of the other things here at the bottom are grant revenues. Grant revenue sources aren't guaranteed sources of revenue, so just because we have an open grant doesn't mean that we'll be able to access that revenue. I've tried to be as conservative as possible. We could get more income, we could get less income, so this is my best estimate. On the second page... Real quick, is this page two at the bottom?
1:50:52 Yes, page two. Page two at the bottom. Is the next page I'm going to now. It starts the operating expenses for Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I've combined some items just to streamline the budget process. Advertising and marketing are one line item. Board development, we budget $3,000 annually for board development. Obviously this year we spent more.
1:51:24 I've added a line item for software, which includes the new database system for deed restriction stewardship. This has a one-time onboarding fee of $3,500 and an ongoing annual fee of $2,500. The annual fee increases at increments depending on how many deed restrictions you're stewarding at any one time. I just wanted to note that our insurance costs are going up, and then I'll go to page three.
1:51:58 I've got a question, if you don't mind. Yes. With the potential two new positions, bodies in the office, do you have adequate computer stations, hardware available for them? Or do we need to think about buying some additional workstations? Yes, so we had to buy a third computer for the intern. We tried to salvage the old computers, but they're operating so slowly it's impossible to...
1:52:26 Replace, we authorized replacement books. Yes, so we got two and we just purchased a third for the intern who will start June 3rd. Okay, so we have three new computers. And I'm not, we don't have a computer for the Latino Housing Coalition person. I presume we'd have to buy another one. Okay. Is that somewhere in the noise here you think you got it covered or? I did not allocate funding for that in this draft budget. Add a couple thousand bucks or?
1:53:03 Two, yeah, two office supplies or something around there. And then on page three, which is the final page of the budget, I've included some... Oh, and don't... Yeah, go ahead. Do you guys have a desk or a place to... Because I think it's sitting on balls and stuff. Do you need to buy a desk chair? Is there just a few things like that? Just, you know, make sure you anticipate a, you know, a reasonable, ergonomically correct spot to work. Okay. I will.
1:53:42 So we should just throw a few bucks at it. Thanks. Okay. I appreciate that. And so does the staff. That ball paralyzes my back. I'm sorry. The ball chair. In some of these line items, I've anticipated an increase in the budget. So I'm anticipating an increase for our HOA fees at the office. And then under salaries and wages, I've included the...
1:54:11 The two part-time staff and the two full-time staff positions. Our accounting and auditing is projected to go up. And then you'll see the increase in the travel and training, which the board discussed at the last board meeting. So the end result is a deficit budget, which implies the use of net income in this fiscal year towards the budget in the next fiscal year.
1:54:44 So I'm sorry, real quick, maybe I missed this. In the professional fees, the consulting went up by $10,000. What's that for? Well, in the last year's budget, we had budgeted $20,000. This could be used for advertising and marketing. It could be used for, I'm trying to think of another example, board governance trainings like this fiscal year. We did strategic planning, which we only budgeted $3,000. So there's some wiggle room there.
1:55:14 Okay, so you're putting that wiggle as in consulting, right? Well, and the budget for last year was $20,000 and we only spent $2,500. Oh, I see what you're saying, okay. So the actual total professional fees line item went down. Okay, I guess I'm sorry. And one thing I did want to note at the end of my presentation here is that you'll see depreciation at the bottom here above net assets.
1:55:43 We don't, we haven't been budgeting for depreciation in the budget, in the operating budget. It's something I've been thinking about and would like the board to maybe have a discussion about whether or not we should be depreciating our office assets so that we have revenue to support new technology and things like that in the future. That number would be less than this number. This number includes all of our assets.
1:56:10 For the next fiscal year, it would be, I think the total is $7,000. I think especially with the kind of, with the computer, the IT situation, I don't know, the depreciation schedule is maybe a little quicker than just what it is for normal assets. Mm-hmm. Right? It's five years, I think. Yeah. And so there's money, if we wanted to do this like a DEI training or something like that, that would come out of consulting or something? Yes, it could.
1:56:51 I'm happy to take any questions or comments or add revisions so that the board can adopt the budget in a timely manner for the next fiscal year. Further questions and staff? For, kind of back to the consulting fees, as we proceed with 238 Sierra Manor Road, do we need more consulting type things that would come out of that budget or is there anything else?
1:57:26 Accounted for for 238 Sierra Manor Road in here. No, so the way we've been operating is using the reserve account for that property to spend money on consulting for that property. Thank you. But if you bring in the CDBG grant or whichever, then that would fund projects. Project specifically, you would fund through that grant money if received. Yes. To really move the needle on that project forward over and above the operating budget. Yes.
1:57:58 Further questions? Just an observation. I know the council is a different can of worms, but we benefited, I think, mightily from budget presentations that are kind of easy to digest. And I'm going to defer to staff, Patricia, on what the recommendations you're making here, but I think that there may be a way down the road, maybe the standing executive committee could find a way to make the budgeting and the request of things like that a little bit easier to...
1:58:26 To digest. And so from the policy perspective, the policy goals, if you come out of the strategic plan, it's kind of easier to understand what's being presented, what's being requested, and what the budget's actually going to achieve. It's just an observation. It may be useful going forward. Do we as a board feel comfortable with the deficit budget this year offset by the overage, or excuse me, the deficit budget projected for next year offset by
1:59:00 This year's overage. And thinking about that next year, we won't have anything left over. I mean, I just want to make sure, like, as we go in a cycle. Well, to your point, Lindsay, I know where that deficit has been accounted for. Yeah. But I think, again, there's, I mean, there's so much detail, and this is such a complicated program, that it's hard to tease those kinds of things out. And it's, I know you've got plenty of other things to do, but if there's a way to,
1:59:31 You know, dumb this down a little bit. So for the board, it's easier to understand kind of we're status quo. We're basically doing the same kind of things. It might be, I don't, that might be helpful going forward to tease some of that stuff out. Further discussion? And there's a question too for the contract committee. There's no concern about adopting a budget before the contract's actually in place because the dollar amount isn't projected to change. No. Yeah.
2:00:05 I sit on that committee and I don't perceive there being that concern. That's a good question. My only question is, did you want me to increase the deficit by adding the new technology needs, or did you want me to balance it in by taking money away from another area? I think if we're adding a few thousand bucks, I just would add it personally. Because we have how much?
2:00:40 90 ahead or something this year. Mm-hmm. So, I mean, we're not a for-profit. So, it's not like a spot, right? We've got programs that we're going to be developing and donations and I think it's not excessive. In this agenda item, don't we need to speak about the next page as well with some of the recommendations for potential net income allocations? Yeah, I did just want to speak briefly to that.
2:01:10 We have some, based on the quarter three projections for quarter four, we're projected to have $105,000 in net income for a variety of reasons and there we can allocate those to the deficit. Obviously part of that is the Latino Housing Coalition staff financial responsibility of MLH. I can add in the deficit or the
2:01:36 The depreciation for office expenses, if that's the will of the board into the budget. And then I just added some other discussion items. We can allocate resources to 238 or to ongoing funding for the coalition staff person, or we can talk about it again later. You want us to take action on each of these?
2:02:05 No, this is just for the board to discuss, and we can either adopt the budget with staff direction, or we can look at it again in June. If there's no questions, then I think we should approve the adopted budget, or the budget that has been presented, unless there's any modifications. Tom? Well, again, I was suggesting we add a few thousand bucks to office equipment, or whatever line that would fall under.
2:02:43 So that's your, you need a motion. I'll make a motion. We approve it with the modifications of the 2000. I'll second that motion. Further discussion? Yes, please. The suggestion here to add money for the Latino coalition staff person is that it says fiscal year 2021. That was just so that, so never mind, excuse me. So that's not in here. That's.
2:03:14 Thank you. That's looking at my mind next year's budget is. Yeah. Perfect. July 1st. Yes. Okay. And I will add in the office depreciation into the budget. Everyone's shaking their head, so yes, that's what I'm going to do. For the discussion? Yes. And then the rest of the reserve of the net income from the year.
2:03:47 Do we need to allocate that? We don't have to do that in this? No. That's not this budget. Okay. So it's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We'll move to agenda item 11. The board will consider providing comments to the town of Mammoth Lake, town council on the housing element. John, I think we need to step away from this. It'll come and we might be voting on this. I don't know. I was thinking about it all day.
2:04:18 Just be comments. It's just going to be comments. Okay. I mean, I just, I wanted to make sure you put it out there for discussion. No, I appreciate that. And I thought the same thing, but I think that it's, these are comments from the board. And I think, just, we're not, we're not in any Brown Act violation. You and I are discussing these comments. Yeah. Comments come forward. I think we're okay. Unless someone has an idea about that. Dan's scribbling, you know, it's paying attention. So I think we're okay.
2:04:50 Okay, Patricia. Thank you. The town of Mammoth Lakes released the public review draft of the housing element update for the period 2019-2027 at their Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting on April 10th. And I just wanted to note that this is an important document since it will guide the town's housing work for the next eight years.
2:05:17 The housing element is a mandated component of the general plan, and so the state requires that all jurisdictions plan and create strategies to create housing for a need that is identified by the state. So we have a local housing needs assessment, which says we need around 595 units. Well, the state also does an analysis and says how many units they think that the town should supply.
2:05:47 In this time period. The public comment period will close on May 10th, which is this Friday. I provided extensive comments to the town on the administrative draft when the town staff was reviewing the document, and a lot of those comments were incorporated. And then I also provided public comment to the Planning and Economic Development Commission on April 10th.
2:06:20 I provided those comments for your review, but I had heard from a couple of board members that they thought we should provide comments and so I provided a draft letter for the board to consider. Many of these comments are the same as my previous comments and I'll just go through them briefly. Comment number one is that
2:06:44 That it's not clear how the housing element relates to the housing action plan, which is our local document that was created through extensive public outreach in a 22-member working group and has different strategies than are identified in the housing element. And so how do we prioritize these different strategies with limited resources? And is there a way to reconcile that in the document so that it's clear to the community? Number two is that I thought the document needed a definition section.
2:07:14 The Housing Working Group talked a lot about what affordable and workforce really means and came up with their own definition of community housing, which means housing that is intended to be affordable for and occupied by residents of the town of Mammoth Lakes and workers employed in town. And so I thought at least a definition of all these terms, if they're going to be used throughout the document, would be appropriate.
2:07:39 There was also no definition of seasonal housing, which was unclear whether that meant it's managed for seasonal employees, so a six-month lease only, or if it's a certain type of housing. And so I thought the addition of a definition section would be beneficial so that we can achieve the strategies so that we know what they mean. Comment number three was a comment about data.
2:08:05 I think that some of the seasonal job transfer data might be a little bit outdated considering we've had some of our highest summer seasonal employment ever. And so I think if we're going to use this information for the next eight years, we should try to have the most recent data possible. Comment number four was about a strategy that prioritizes the development of seasonal housing.
2:08:36 And my comment was just that there should be some reconciliation between strategies that want to create a year-round economy and strategies that are promoting seasonal housing and that maybe there needed to be some reconciliation around those strategies. Number five is the creation of a long-term rental inspection program.
2:09:03 You may have noted in my monthly staff report that tenants' rights inquiries were up last month. Tenants just really struggle with finding quality housing. And this program would be something maybe similar to our nightly rental inspection program, which requires that nightly rentals be safe and we should have the same thing for our long-term residents. This is a strategy in that housing action plan, and so it should be maybe...
2:09:31 It would be good to incorporate it into the housing element. And then comment number six, which is the last comment, is another action plan strategy, which is an affordable housing overlay zone. The comment is a recommendation that research around what this zone could do or where it could be located should be a strategy in the housing element.
2:09:59 An affordable housing overlay zone could provide incentives to private developers to include affordable housing in their developments. And those incentives could be defined through the research and creation of this strategy. Those were all of the comments I included in the draft letter, but if the board has other comments, I'm happy to update the letter, or if the board chooses not to send the letter, that's okay, too.
2:10:33 I think they're all really good comments, and I'm going to report on my board report here. I did attend a affordable housing finance conference that caused me to miss our last monthly meeting, but it was real clear to me there that the definition that these people from across the country are using is that affordable housing is 80% and below AMI, and then everything above that is considered workforce housing, so for what it's worth.
2:11:04 But I think your thought that it should be clarified and defined is important because it gets very confusing. So it should at least be consistent in the document. So I think it's a good suggestion to have that defined. And then zoning for affordability, I think the point would be is that it should include, so there's an affordable housing overlay, but then I think what we're talking about is an affordable housing
2:11:35 Incentive overlay zone, right? I think it implies that incentives is how I read it. I just don't know what you're going to say, in all caps, affordable housing incentive overlay zone, or the inclusion of that, and suggest that it should be included in the housing element. Because again, this was, like as you mentioned, in the housing action plan was one of the strategies that would be overlaid on the commercial zone, but that it would be an incentive overlay, not a mandated, right, I guess is the point.
2:12:03 I mean, you're saying that. I just think that we should, that we would suggest that it should be. Yeah. Yeah. I see what you're saying, but, yeah. Then you say affordable housing, I would just say it on that second paragraph, second sentence, affordable housing incentive overlay zone, place an additional layer of zoning over the base zoning designations that encourage production, because it includes incentives. So anyway, it's just a.
2:12:32 But the word incentive should be in the title of the? Yeah. Yeah, that's what I'm thinking. Okay. Because that's really what's different with what the suggestion is versus the parcel site. Yeah, I think the parcel site was a result of the condition in which that parcel was traded and that there was this overlay laid on it for affordable housing. Has to be. Right. And you're, yeah. Right.
2:12:58 Yeah, I think generally that the affordable housing overlay zone is an incentive program, but I think maybe in our community it could be confusing because we have one already. That's not an incentive. I thought all your comments were excellent, and I'm very much looking forward to getting these questions. So I'm hoping if we can approve this and it goes to the town when it comes back to the council for adoption that we can get some answers to these questions. Thank you.
2:13:30 Well, the one that bothers me is the seasonal employees and seasonal housing. I mean, that is really difficult to deal with. And so, you know, I don't know how to put the priorities or those things. And it's not just the mountain with its seasonal employees. I mean, it's throughout the community more so now. And we are moving towards some more year-round employees, you know, where they're
2:14:00 Where there's summer work, a lot of that, I think, I have to give credit to John, has done a lot of focus on, as well as Mammoth Lake Tourism. But I worry about, you know, the priority needs to be our full-time employees, you know, year-round employees. And so when we start putting seasonal in there, that might compete against that as development as to the parcel or anything else, then I began to say.
2:14:29 I'm just putting it out there that I've got a high level of concern that we focus as a council and as this board, we focus on year-round employees having the first priority. And I'm not saying that we ignore the seasonal. And obviously we have a seasonal issue now with people living in their cars and everything else. So we've got to, that issue is coming forward. Yeah, I think in Mammoth historically the idea of seasonal may be kind of a left and
2:14:59 I don't want to say it's a leftover idea, but certainly the trends of where we're going is year-round. It's changing. Yeah. It's changing. You need to have the seasonal, sort of a leftover idea all of a sudden become this prioritized thing that we've got to deal with when we're trying to get to what you're talking about. Yeah. And if you look at Mammoth Lake Tourism and their incomes and the T.O.T.
2:15:23 Trend lines have filled in those shoulder seasons. So that tells me that the employees, it's sending a message that, hey, we've got employment year-round now. And that's what it looks like on those trend lines. Yeah, definitely there. But again, I do, you know, I just think the priority is, again, and the number of seasonal employees is decreasing.
2:15:52 Because of the year-round employment availability. So there's a lot of trends that are taking place out there. So those are my, I just wanted to make some comments. I think that the, that I agree with all these comments here. I'm still watching the seasonal issue. Patricia, in your public comments for the Planning and Economic Development Commission, your first section,
2:16:24 About public outreach. Did a survey end up going out in Spanish to the community? Because that's not in the letter. It did, because where I live, we all got a letter in Spanish and English. Sorry, I don't know if I understand. Was it asking questions about... For feedback on this? I think that was about the parcel development. Oh, okay.
2:16:53 So I don't think a survey ever went out in Spanish, and we were not able to get hard copies to distribute to community members, but the town did do a survey in coordination with Mono County during the needs assessment update, and so they're going to flesh out some of that outreach in the public outreach section of the housing element document to show that there was more outreach.
2:17:23 Thank you. So that's why you didn't include it in? Yes. Further discussion? I just wasn't sure if Kirk and John wanted to be signatories on the draft letter. Yeah, that was my question. I think you should, if you agree with it. No. We can be... Yes.
2:17:56 Compromising, yeah, we're saying we're going to vote for this. You have to ultimately approve the housing element. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, we'll just abstain. Yeah. Recuse or abstain. Just abstain. Yeah, abstain. Yeah, and just, and then your names wouldn't be on the letter. So I'll just update the letter to include the incentive overlay language.
2:18:29 And then, Stacey, if you wouldn't mind signing it. Do you need a motion to approve the letter as amended? Yeah, that'd be great. Okay, I just made it. I'll second it. Oh, I gotta do, sorry. It's your turn. All right, we have a motion and a second. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Oppose? Abstain? Abstain. Okay. Motion passes with two abstentions. Thank you. The next agenda.
2:19:06 The next agenda item is 12, the 238 Sierra Manor Road. Any information item? Patricia? Yes, so this item was requested as a standing item to get an update on 238 Sierra Manor Road progress. On page 2 of the staff report, you'll see some of the progress we've made after the board approved spending some of the reserve funding in January.
2:19:37 Item number three is the procurement of architectural and engineering services for the project. We released the RFQ at the beginning of April and responses were due today. We had two or three responses come in at five o'clock today. That's good. Yeah. Nice. Sounds like mammoth time. Three or four. So I'm really excited about that. I think we should award this to the people that got in early.
2:20:04 Yeah, they were like a week early. A lot of work, they're no good. And then on page three, you'll see item number seven, we've procured the market study and expect it to be available around June 1st. And then the lead, mold, and asbestos report was completed on May 1st. Sorry, just real quick, did we skip items, a couple items? Yeah. We skipped 12 and 13.
2:20:34 This is 12. This is 12. No, this is 238 Sierra Manor Road. This is 14. I got it. I got it. You might have the wrong agenda. What do you have? This is wrong. Yours is different than mine. Oh. I have a different agenda. The email one should be right.
2:20:59 This is the printed one from the town. Yeah, right, this is it. What's your agenda? You have... I'm just going to ruin the front.
2:21:07 I think the one from the town website is wrong. How many total do you have? You have 17? I have 16. I have 16. He's lacking the town contract. I have 17. I think I had to go back. Oh, I see. Yeah, it's in the front. Yeah. Well, let's stay with, why don't we finish this, and then I'll look on Tom's, and since he has, you have 17? You have 17. Let's finish Sierra Manor Road.
2:21:35 Information item. Okay. As number 14? It's number 12. As an item. Okay, yeah. Whatever item number it may be. Yeah. Okay, so then I have some next steps outlined. I'm expecting the NOFA, the Notice of Funding Availability for CDBG this month. We will be evaluating the responses to the RFQ and potentially interviewing possible
2:22:05 And executing a contract in early June for those services. We'll have public meetings and meetings with the board of the A&E team hopefully in July. Then the home notice of funding availability is expected in July and those applications will be due in August and September. I think that's all I have. Questions of staff? So we had applied for a grant.
2:22:35 Yes. We didn't get. Yes. Because of certain items. Yes. And we have now fulfilled or fulfilling those certain items to be completed to resubmit again. Yes. So we've done everything that we should be doing at this point to get a better standing for the next grant. Yes. Any other questions? If not, we'll go back to the contract update. I don't have that item on my agenda.
2:23:07 Okay. So we'll move to parcel update. Yes. The parcel update. This is a standing item on our agenda. It updates you regarding what's happening with the parcel. I just wanted to note that in April we delivered 82 bilingual letters to all of our apartment buildings soliciting
2:23:32 Participants to participate in interviews with the consulting team to get feedback on their needs and what they see the needs in the community for affordable housing. We got four respondents from those letters who are native Spanish speakers and we are hosting a Spanish focus group tomorrow night at Mammoth Lakes Housing which is a
2:23:59 A place that our community members feel comfortable going with an interpreter and the consulting team for the town so that they'll be able to provide that feedback. I just wanted to also note that the public charrette dates for the parcel have been finalized and they will be August 20th through August 23rd. So if you were planning a vacation. And then I provided the town staff report from May 1st.
2:24:33 If you wanted more detail on what the town is doing in their proposed timeline. Questions? Yeah, how did you find out about the dates for the public charrettes for the... Oh, from the consulting team. Okay, because I haven't. Have you guys heard about those dates? Well, I think they just went out, like... You have not heard about it yet, John. This is the first you'll hear about that. Okay, I'm just... We've had a long discussion at the last council meeting about public outreach, so I'm just checking. Questions?
2:25:18 Oh, it's at 615 in the Mammoth Lakes Housing Office. If you'd like to join, or you have friends or family that are interested, you could send them along. Please do, because I'm worried that the people who RSVP might not show up, so. Podium's open. Thank you. I'm Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Director. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about the town staff report, but I just wanted to show you some collateral material that we just produced.
2:25:55 Produced this right last Wednesday, so we don't have a QR code on this handout yet, but our next run will. We've just ran 100 of these, so I can hand these out to you if you want to take one and pass it around. It has information about the parcel. It's what we're going to be using tomorrow and Wednesday for our interviews, just to give people those cards so they have that information. So it's English and Spanish, and so we'll run another set of those.
2:26:22 Council Member Wentworth requested that we have a QR code on there so that people can easily kind of get right to the webpage, so we'll add that to the next run so we have that for easy access to those web pages. And as Patricia said, the...
2:26:38 Community, the Charette is August 20th through the 23rd, and we just found out those dates, so we'll be pushing that out shortly, sending an email out to council members tomorrow. Can we update that with those? Yes, we will. Yeah, so that's kind of our first draft of that, but we wanted to get them printed so that we can give them to the people that we're interviewing tomorrow and Wednesday. And I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about the town staff report.
2:27:04 It's attached. It's in the packet. It's in your packet. It's the same report you received last Wednesday. Oh, okay. Yeah, it's just a copy of that. Why is it rotate for the Spanish version? I'm not sure. I don't know why. I didn't work on the design. I think we worked with the designer, and it might be because of what it says there that maybe it didn't lend itself to being bulleted. I don't know. And maybe the map?
2:27:36 It's not a bad thing. Oh, this one right here? No, I'm taking this. So there'll be a QR code next to the Parcel website? Yeah. And is there a Spanish language page for those? It's just the Google Translate with our website. We haven't created a web page in Spanish. But then the Notify Me and Engage Mammoth Lakes, those are both, if you hit the QR code, go to that page. Questions? Thank you.
2:28:13 Sure. I'm going to get this back. When's the real production money going to happen? Probably in the next week or so. Okay. Why don't you keep it if you have any other comments? Yeah, yeah. Okay, sure. Thank you. We'll move to Mammoth Lake Housing Monthly. If there are any questions on the parcel, then we'll move to Mammoth Lake Housing Monthly Update. Okay, if you could, because I'm working off a different agenda. Yeah.
2:28:55 We're going to the regular MLH monthly update, which is number 13 on my agenda. Is there an item after that, or is that the last one? Well, I have a, on mine it's 14, and then board member reports, so this is the last item. I have the packet, it's in there, but yeah. Well, this came from the packet, this is what I was emailed, so I'm just taking it off of that. Does somebody need a hard copy packet? No, it's okay, I'll figure it out. Okay. Okay, so this is just our monthly update.
2:29:27 I previously noted that tenants' rights inquiries were up in April. We had six. We've had some increase in traffic to our website, I think, because I'm trying to do some more social media outreach and using our newsletter. We also added a sign-up for our newsletter on our website, which has increased subscribers. So I'm trying to inspire them with actually communicating with them.
2:29:58 Which hopefully they like. Under item two, which is page four, we've been really busy. Diane processed seven rental applications last month, and we filled two low-income units with single parents, one working in retail and one working in IT. I have a quick update on the moderate income down payment assistance program, which
2:30:26 which we are partnering with the town of Mammoth Lakes on to help households between 81 and 120 percent of the area median income purchase homes and then secure new deed restricted units. We requested that the town give us some feedback on whether or not we could give smaller loans and then charge the service delivery fee.
2:30:51 And I was advised that the town would need clarification from town council. And in an effort to just keep things moving, I just figured probably don't need to take it back to town council. I don't want to hold it up. But the town does want to finalize the MLH town contract before they let us proceed with this program.
2:31:18 So that's, we're working on the contract and just the details around that, but that should be quickly forthcoming after our contract is executed. I don't think I reported this in our last staff report, but the apartment vacancy rate has been finalized for 2019. We collect this data during the month of January, and so the vacancy rate for this year is 0.1%, and the three-year average is 0.25%.
2:31:50 So, how many? How many?
2:32:19 Because that's just apartments. It's not pure vacancy. How many apartments are there, roughly? There's around 900 apartments. And that includes accessory dwelling units that are restricted for long-term rentals. I wanted to note that we provided some assistance to the town preparing a planning grant under SP2 funding for the parcel.
2:32:53 And so we're working with the town on that. There are two homes that are eligible for begin down payment assistance. And one is in Aspen Village townhomes, and it's a two bedroom, and one is in San Joaquin Villas, and it's a three bedroom. On page seven, you'll see the median home sales prices. And 2019 year to date, condos are up 11%. And it looks like single family homes are down 13%. Just take one.
2:33:31 Missed the peak. Missed the peak. And then I wanted to note that we helped an owner sell their home who had an employee, employer loan through the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so the owner closed escrow and repaid the town back $74,000 of their down payment assistance loan. And that money will go back into the housing fund at the town for housing programs and projects.
2:34:01 The Mammoth Mall application did not succeed in getting funding through CDBG. And staff is participating on the Chamber Housing Committee. They interviewed candidates for their position on Friday, but I don't think any of our committee members were invited to participate in the interview, so I'm not sure what's going on with the steering committee. I was there participating. Oh, that's good.
2:34:34 I have a contract update. Our ad hoc committee met with our attorney. We thought that there was more room for negotiation in the town standard contract language, but so we had to revise some of our comments and they're back with the town attorney at this time. It should be able to be finalized soon. We may need to just get staff together in one room to hammer out the final details, but it shouldn't be long.
2:35:06 And then I wanted to say that we hired an intern who will start June 3rd, so he will be here at our June 3rd meeting. Oh, and then I took the annual report on a little road show and I attended the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments meeting on April 12th and the collaborative planning team meeting on April 23rd. That was very exciting and people seemed interested, so.
2:35:44 I was happy about that. I have a quick announcement about this movie that there's a free community showing of The Quiet Force, which is a movie about our Hispanic community members and how policies at the national level are affecting their ability to stay in our communities. And so I wanted to just pass out flyers to everybody. It's happening on May 14th.
2:36:12 And it will be at the middle school. So I've just got a question about the red traffic. I hope I'm working off the right document. But what I'm seeing is that it's just plummeting. Well, it was up. Was this question? In April. Yeah, well. That's what I'm looking at. Let me double check. Yeah, the chart, not the graph, like it showed it. This? Yeah. No, but that's over the last. Yeah. So why was this?
2:36:54 Oh, maybe I didn't update the chart. It didn't, because it's like a thousand more views over. That's right. Is the table accurate? Yes, the table is accurate. The chart is not. Yeah, you might be right. Well, it's also, the chart is year to date, not month by month. Yes, so it's like an average, you might not see it. So that's a lot, but I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions of staff? If not, according to my agenda bill.
2:37:36 That was the last item, unless there's something, we have board member reports on. Yeah, I have board member reports, but it, did you have anything we missed? Well, what I had, and again, I don't know, you need to figure out what happened, but I had the town contract was an individual update item, and then the monthly update, and then, I guess, I don't know, but the town contract was,
2:38:07 That's probably the thing that was different, because you included that as part of your report. On this agenda, I have it, it was its own item. Is there additional documentation for the town contract? No. Okay. It's just an information. So we're at agenda item board member reports. John? I don't have anything specific to report. I think it would be good to get this, whatever happened with the agenda. It's important because obviously we're paying, we have a town staff person here, so the purpose of having this is we don't.
2:38:35 I don't know what happened. Yeah, just, we just figured it out because she's working for all the different NGOs. We'll get that resolved. I'm concerned about the contract. I hope this is just lawyers wasting everybody's time and money and that's over with and we can get the contract done. It's just been going on for a really, really long time. So I'm concerned about that. But other than that, I don't have anything. Tase?
2:39:07 As I mentioned earlier, I attended the training, diversity, equity, inclusion training. I was allowed to see many of my fellow board members and Mammoth Lakes housing staff there. That was the beginning of April and just wanted to note that Mono County is set to adopt its 2019 through 2024 strategic plan tomorrow and housing is
2:39:38 A major, addressing the housing crisis is a major objective under, we have five strategic focus areas and housing is something we're addressing in those. That's it. Yeah, as I mentioned earlier, I apologize for missing last month's board meeting, but I attended a three-day conference in Las Vegas for a housing finance conference. It was actually,
2:40:11 Really educational for me and informative. As much as there's, you know, people who dedicate their careers to that subject matter, and it's clear that there's a lot of knowledge you need to have in that field if you're going to be successful. So I think the message that I gained out of it, well, I got a lot of good contacts, and I shared those with Patricia and gave her some leads on some people, I thought, in case, you know, certain projects we have, people she could call that might be able to help us with.
2:40:39 Low-income housing tax credits and other types of loans that are available out there in programs. So yeah, I got a lot of good contacts, but it was real apparent to me that putting together funding for any particular development project is equally as time-intensive and complicated as putting the plans together and that those efforts should probably begin concurrently.
2:41:05 You know, if you wait too long, and I think I made mention actually to the town council that evening I got back from that conference, I said, hey, you guys should really look to start engaging on the financing plan for the development almost concurrently with the conceptual planning, because it could take, you know, a year to two years to line up financing for a project of that scale and scope. And, you know, because there's funding cycles that you have to coordinate with your development cycle.
2:41:35 So on and so forth. And so there's a lot involved in that field and that effort. And I still have a lot to go learn about understanding low-income housing tax credits. But anyway, great event. They do that. They actually hold another similar event in November, I think it is, in Chicago, or October, November in Chicago that apparently is much bigger.
2:42:03 More widely attended because there's a lot of people on the East Coast who engage in. There's a lot more housing going on apparently in the East Coast than there is in the West Coast from what I gathered and there's a lot of people in that area of expertise and there's a couple or at least a thousand people attend that that fall conference so it might be something you might consider attending Patricia. And then aside from that I attended our contract committee meeting on the 9th or 29th.
2:42:33 With Patricia and, you know, I think, you know, a few of the comments were kind of legalese contract issues that they're going to, you know, talk to Andy again. Our attorney would talk to Andy and hopefully work through those issues. But I didn't see anything there that was especially any kind of a deal breaker. I think hopefully one more back and forth when we can bring this back to the board next, next board meeting for approval. Have a great time in June. Yeah.
2:43:03 Yeah, I think the goal would be to have it adopted before our fiscal year starts, right? So, so next board meeting. Didn't seem like that was going to be a problem. And, yeah, and then just real quick, you know, development-wise, you know, my understanding is that the Yotel pad is proceeding. They've got planning commission next week for their final entitlement approvals, and they'll be proceeding with starting work this summer.
2:43:35 And, you know, the best information I have is that they're intending to break ground and get started going into construction this summer. So, it looks like that project's going to get going and that'll be a good telltale to the health and vitality of our private development market in the community. There's other people out there kicking the tires, so there is activity, just not manifesting yet into active applications, but...
2:44:03 There are things going on. So I would say there's definitely increased interest in Mammoth for commercial resort development. That's more than we've seen in quite a few years. And that's all I got. I don't have very much to report, so I'm going to... Nothing further for me. In looking up some of the vision and mission stuff, I was looking at the website for...
2:44:34 The Metau Valley Housing Trust, that's where I grew up in Washington State, and they're a new organization, but they just, one of my friends sits on their board, and they just moved in their first homeowners in their very first project that they've built, the thing that stands out, they used all private donations. They didn't use any grant funding for it, and it was pretty interesting, so. What was the, how much, what are we talking about?
2:44:59 I don't know the exact numbers, but it was a million something. But they're getting, they have on their website, they list at least four different chunks of land that have been donated. And then they used, they also, they were very proud, they used all local builders and local people. So it just, for me, thinking fundraising and committees and things, it was pretty impressive with that. And then a couple of the other things that also stood out when they talk about their deed restrictions and getting people in.
2:45:28 One of the things they limit is the personal assets for people. And I don't know if we've done that before. So they limit... We've looked, yes, we have. I mean, you can't get into an affordable housing unit or purchase something if you've got three, own three other houses. Okay, okay. Yeah, no, that is part of it. The way they list it just says personal assets cannot exceed 80% of area median income. And yeah, so I think we limit it to...
2:45:55 Homeownership, but I'm not sure anything else. So, but anyway, either way, yeah, I thought that was just an interesting one. And then they also, like I said earlier, they talked a lot on their website about retired people. So I thought that was pretty, just an interesting thought for the future as we're thinking about expanding geographically, maybe also sort of demographically, if that is the right term. And then the other thing, and I need to look at our website better, but they,
2:46:25 They list their community partners. I know we talked a lot about that with Shauna in our strategic planning. So they have a very tight community partnership. And then they also list business members. And they say their business membership is three years for an $1,800 commitment. And then that's in there, too. So just, again, in the fundraising aspect of things and what they're doing. So in terms of our homebuyer assistance programs, and I believe this is in the moderate income guidelines as well.
2:46:54 And this is what the state and federal programs require, is that your assets are converted into a cash value at a passbook rate of 2%, and that goes towards your income, and then your income can't exceed the income limit for the program. But you're not required to liquidate your assets in order to purchase a home. It was just interesting to see what they're doing. Nada. We are...
2:47:27 Unless there's any other public comment, adjourned.