TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2019

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 2 hr 7 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

268 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:04 I'll call to order the Board of Directors meeting Monday, June 3rd, Mammoth Lake Council Chambers at Old Mammoth Road. This is our regular meeting. The roll call. Are you going to call the names? Okay. Lindsay Barksdale? Here. Stacey Corliss? Here. Zariah Cruz? Tom Hodges? Here. Giselle Kenney? Here.

0:35 Kirk Stapp? Here. John Wentworth? Here. Agnes Fianzen? Here. And Richard Playstead? Here. Thank you. This is the time for public comments. If there are no public comments, we'll move to approval of minutes from the May 6, 2019 regular board meeting. Any deletions, corrections? Yes, I have one. Do you know the page number? Yeah, it's the comment I made in my director's report.

1:11 And the text reads, John says that Kirk and Patricia are on a different agenda from everybody else. And what I was saying was that the agenda document that you guys have was different than everybody else. And I think that's a distinction that I would like to make. I had underlined that. And I was going, okay, John, if that's what you said. I would like to have that distinction recorded. You can.

1:40 I was at the meeting, so to me, it appeared fine, but when Diane read it, she was like, what does that mean? Exactly. I read it and I went, okay, John, that's what you... The agenda page number. Yeah, the document formatting or something, whatever that was. PDF issues. PDF issues. Yeah.

2:05 I just had one change, the bit for my board member report. Right at the end, it says about her hometown of Meadow Valley, Washington and their housing committee. It's called the Meadow Housing Trust. It sort of just went with no ending there, with no period. Housing Trust. Are there any other corrections? I'll make one minor correction to my board member report.

2:34 Just clarify that I attended a affordable housing finance conference to distinguish from just a general housing conference. It was specifically focused on affordable housing finance. And we have three corrections. Are there any other corrections? If not, I move to approve as amended. Been moved. Second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye.

3:08 Motion, one abstention, and unanimous pass. The board will receive a presentation from the Inyomone Advocate for Community Action, Armaka, the Administrative Coordinator for the Regional Continuum of Care for Inyomone and Alpine Counties. So, yeah, that'd be great if you don't mind. Yeah.

3:34 I just provided some background information on IMACA, which is the Inyo Mono Advocates for Community Action, and Mammoth Lakes Housing has been working with them as of recently through the continuum of care process, which is a way to address homelessness, and our continuum of care region is in Inyo Mono and Alpine counties.

3:59 And I invited Larry Emerson, who's the Director of Housing Programs, to come and speak to us a little more about what that entails. So thank you, Larry. Thanks for the introduction. And thank you for the opportunity to talk about homelessness in the Eastern Sierra. Your staff report provides a lot of background information on AMACA. And so I have additional information here on the programs that we administer.

4:28 and as well a schedule of food distributions in Mono County if you're interested. So I'd like to focus a little bit more on homelessness. It's an issue that's been in the news quite a bit lately. You've probably seen articles about the increase in homelessness and I believe that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development plans on

4:55 releasing the 2019 point-in-time count results here shortly, and what it'll show, I believe, is that there's been an increase in a number of communities, including ours, in the number of homeless. So, I'd just like to provide a little bit of history on our COC, give you an overview of the current projects that we're administering now, and discuss future opportunities, as well as provide a summary of our most recent planning efforts in the community.

5:25 So back in 2013, AMACA conducted a needs analysis here in Mono County as well as Inyo County, and we found that there was a lack of services and assistance for persons experiencing homelessness. So we submitted a grant application to the state to

5:52 look at a way of providing additional funding and services in the community. And as a result of that grant, we had conducted a number of neighborhood meetings and community meetings to determine if there was an interest in establishing and operating a continuum of care in the community. And we talked to health care providers, the Salvation Army, education specialists,

6:21 Health and Human Service Departments, and other agencies, and we decided to establish a continuum of care for our service area. And that service area includes Alpine, Inyo, and Mono counties. And that was determined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Our area covers about 14,000 square miles. It's a huge continuum of care. There are about, there are 34 other, or there are 33 other

6:51 Continuums in the state of California and about 500 in the U.S. And what a continuum care is, it's a regional or local planning body that conducts housing and services for homeless funding and provides specific strategies to reduce the duration and incidence of homelessness in our community.

7:20 So, we established our COC back in 2014, and then AMACA began applying for funding that was eligible, or eligible sources of funding through the COC. And we have administered a rapid rehousing project, which is basically taking somebody off the street and providing rental assistance, deposit assistance, or housing. We've also administered a

7:50 An emergency shelter project, which provides hotel motel vouchers for people that are homeless. The idea there is to stabilize somebody for a period of time so that we can link them with the services they need and housing they need in order to be successful. Most recently we have been, we hired a street outreach specialist and she goes out into the community to encampments.

8:17 Places where people experience homeless and tries to engage them and link them to available services, including housing. Another component of the ESG program that we currently receive funding for is homelessness prevention. That's provided to individuals and families.

8:38 That are at imminent risk of homelessness. In other words, they've been served with an eviction notice. They're about to get thrown out on the street. They have no place to go. And we can provide arrears for a certain period of time. Unfortunately, both HUD and the state have reduced the amount of funding for homelessness prevention. It's only 10% of what we receive through the ESG applications. And HUD has no programs for homelessness prevention. It's only provided by the state.

9:08 And let's see, as a part of these programs, we're required to do a lot of reporting to HUD, to the state. We're also required to do what's called a point-in-time count of homelessness. And these are generally conducted, well, they are required to be conducted at least once every two years. We've conducted ours annually because we're a relatively new COC, and we want to establish a baseline of information and data that we can use to build on our programs.

9:37 So, for the last several years, we've conducted the point-in-time counts, and this year, we conducted our count on January 24th for the tri-service area, and for Mono County, the number of homeless increased from 47 to 73. That's a 55% increase. We think part of that's due to more volunteers helping out with the counts.

10:04 As well as an improvement to our methodologies. The Sheriff's Department's been great at helping us identify locations where we can find these people experiencing homelessness. For the overall, overall for the COC, there was a 36% increase. So we're not alone. I can tell you that the preliminary numbers indicate that, let's see, the San Juan, the Tuolumne,

10:32 Amador, Calaveras, Mariposa County COC, Central Sierra, they saw an increase of 130%. That's over a two-year period. Let's see, San Bernardino saw a 39.7% increase. Kern County saw a 64% increase. So I don't have the numbers for all the COCs. They haven't been released yet, but I think this will be, I think there's a trend here.

11:01 Especially in California. It may not be nationwide, but for California, we're seeing quite a few more folks. So what can we do to address the needs in our community? Well, the state has been proactive, and they're providing additional funding for COCs. And the programs that are being funded are more flexible than the federal programs. Most recently, last year, the state authorized

11:29 The Homeless Emergency Aid Program funding, and our allocation was about $590,000 based on our point in time count of 2017. They also approved the, let's see, California Emergency Solutions and Housing Program, PESH, and our allocation was about $410,000. And those sources of funding

11:58 allow us to be more flexible and innovative in designing solutions to end homelessness. For example, for HEAP, we can spend the money on capital improvements. We can actually buy facilities and improve them in order to provide places for homeless people to stay. The COC decided that that funding would be used for master block leases to lease properties for transitional housing.

12:28 We're also leasing units in hotels and motels, and we hope to find some additional places in Mono County to provide transitional housing as well as emergency shelter. The KESH program, we are going to use the funding for, we're going to participate and work coordinate with Mammoth Lakes Housing on a capital facilities count.

12:56 That you guys can use to help with your maintenance and other costs associated with affordable housing. There's a new program that just came out for KESH, or I should say it's the second round of KESH funding, and there's another $245,000 available for that, and we plan to submit an application by the end of June, which will include more funding for Mammoth Lakes Housing.

13:25 for the capital facilities. The HEAP program funding should also be, I think there'll be another notice of funding availability for the HEAP program. And our allocation will be more this year because it will be based on the 2019 count. And as well, the governor is proposing additional funding in that for homeless programs. So we hope to do quite a bit more with the 2019 funding.

13:55 And most recently, AMACA has applied for emergency shelter, or excuse me, emergency solutions grants program funding in the amount of about $300,000 for rapid rehousing, emergency shelter, and our street outreach programs. We hope to continue those in the next couple of years. So let's see, the other thing that we're working on right now is planning.

14:25 for the continuum of care, a requirement of the both KESH and HEAT program is that the continuum of care have a homeless plan that includes strategies or goals and objectives for ending homelessness as well as the strategies to achieve those goals. So we've been working with a consultant from Back East, the Technical Assistance Collaborative, and they have been providing assistance to help us develop goals.

14:55 And strategies for our homeless plan. Most recently, they were out here in the middle of the month to meet with us and have an on-site session to talk about the homeless plan. So we're making progress there. And I think the homeless plan is going to give the entire COC a focus on different programs that will help us with solutions to homelessness. We want to start tailoring our programs to the

15:23 The needs that we have in our community, the specific needs. I can tell you from the last point in time and count, for example, most of the folks that we counted were living out of their vehicles. I think in Mono County, I can tell you, almost all of them that we counted were out of their vehicles. Let's see here. There were 60, I think,

15:52 Total, let's see, there were 63 living out of their vehicles in Mono County. Three were in abandoned buildings and two were in encampments, outdoors, woods, Mono County. And I think that's pretty indicative of Inyo County as well. So we might want to focus on solutions that target persons living out of their vehicles as part of our homeless plan.

16:21 So we've got a lot of, we've made some progress and we've got ways to go, but I'm optimistic that we're seeing, we're seeing more and more cooperation from other participating agencies such as healthcare organizations, schools, the Salvation Army, the counties, housing agencies. So with that, I'd be happy to try and answer any questions you might have. Questions?

16:51 You said in Mono County, you count people living in their vehicles as homeless? We do. Okay. And you said that in Mono County, there were 63 families or people living in their vehicles? And what about Alpine and Inyo? We counted a total of 129 in Inyo County.

17:21 And 85 of those were living out of their vehicles. There were none counted. My question was a little bit along those lines. If there was a definition of homelessness, and my question was originally about if people living in cars, and if that counts, and is there a certain amount of time that people need to

17:52 Be homeless before they're eligible for services, or can they sort of come in and say, this is my situation, what, you know, how quickly is help available? The definition of homeless, according to HUD, is anyone living in a place not meant for human habitation, includes encampments, campgrounds, vehicles, does not include people that are couchsurfed or doubling up because they're sheltered.

18:21 And services are available to anyone who is homeless. It doesn't require any length of time. There is a new HUD definition of chronically homeless, and that does require someone who has been either continuously homeless for at least one year with a disabling condition, or somebody who has had at least four episodes of homelessness.

18:50 Over the last three years, and with a disabling condition. And I will point out that we have a number of chronically homeless in our community. And that will be a need identified, I believe, in our homeless plan as we move forward. I'm curious a little bit on the distinction of the homelessness with the vehicles. I mean, are people specifically asked if they make a conscious decision or choice to live in their vehicle? No. Or just the fact that they're in a vehicle?

19:18 Because I do know, I actually know personally a couple people who are living in their campers, you know, when they're on the pickups, where they're doing it because they want to save money and they don't mind the lifestyle. So are they still considered homeless? Yes. Yes. And that's an issue that the COC has been grappling with too. How much time and effort do you put into helping folks that choose to be homeless? Camping on public lands.

19:45 But, you know, I will say that, you know, based on my experience, it's not everybody. There are people out there that if they had quality housing available to them, affordable housing, they would take that over being homeless or living out of their vehicles. And as you see the population aging, I expect that you're going to have people that have health issues, they're going to choose a shelter over being homeless, living out of their vehicles.

20:14 Would you consider somebody living in the industrial park in one of the units down there, which are, you know, for heavy industry and light industry, would you consider them homeless? I don't think that meets the definition, the HUD definition. If it's an abandoned building, it would meet HUD's definition, but if it's shelter and it's adequate shelter, then it probably would. Does it have running water?

20:44 Restroom facilities, it probably would not meet HUD's definition. It's a gray area. Thank you for this presentation. It's good information and such important work that you're doing. We heard about this at the Board of Supervisors recently, so I'm ahead of the game a little bit, so to speak. But one thing you brought up at the Board, or that we talked about at the Board, was the need for

21:16 I guess not emergency shelter, but rapid rehousing locations in Mono County. You know, motels, so down in Bishop and Inyo County, you're able to find places, whether it's a motel room or an apartment, to do these long-term leases. Tell us the situation or what you've encountered up here and how we might be able to help you. Sure, that's great. It's a segue into our needs up here. I've contacted a number of hotels, motels, to

21:45 I've worked with us in issuing hotel vouchers, and I haven't had any luck in engaging any of the motels. I've also talked to a number of landlords about renting rooms for us or units to place homeless persons and families, and I haven't been very successful with that. I haven't been successful at all, actually.

22:14 Focus our efforts up here and try and find additional housing for folks. I will say that over the last couple of years, AMACA, let's see, I think I have some numbers here on the number of people that we've actually helped here in Mono County. And I would say that most of the folks that we help out, usually we have to provide housing down in Bishop.

22:42 area because that's more available than it is up here and it's more cost effective. So let's see here I think we've helped out about 33 folks over the last couple of years and most of that has been with rental assistance and deposit assistance through our rapid rehousing program and several of those folks have been provided with emergency shelter as well. We did have a contract with Motel 6 for a while.

23:13 to provide emergency shelter, but they haven't re-signed with us yet. When was the last survey that you did for Mono County for, I mean, for Mammoth Lakes? I mean, January 24th of this year. Further questions from the board? One more, sorry. Do you collect when you're doing the...

23:47 Those counts in January, whether people are employed or just living situations. Just the living situation. However, we are required as part of these programs that I talked about that we administer through HUD and the state to collect detailed information on individuals through what's called the Homeless Management Information System. And we have to report on this data to both the state and to HUD annually.

24:15 So we have quite a bit of detailed information that's available and that will help us plan for future projects. Yeah, I was just thinking with that in regards to some of your rapid response housing and needing to place people in Bishop if they're employed in Mammoth or somewhere else outside of there. I don't think we collect information on specifically where they're employed. What we measure is increase in income.

24:44 And that's a performance standard required by the federal government. I just wanted to make a comment about living in your vehicles. Part of the count is the service-based count, which takes place seven days after the initial count in the field. And that's seven days where homeless individuals, if they're accessing services at partners through the COC, that we would count them and they would fill out a survey.

25:13 And this year at Mammoth Lakes Housing, we encountered two homeless individuals living out of their cars who needed housing and weren't living in their car by choice. It's just that, you know, if you did the survey in January, obviously more people are going to be living in their cars in the summertime, in the wintertime. Right, right. So I don't know if you're interested or not, but the federal government provides an explanation.

25:43 of why the point-in-time counts are required the last 10 days in January. I'll just read it to you because it's pretty concise. This is their official position. The pit count is low by design to a degree. HUD requires that the count be held during the last 10 days of January so that it can account for people who cycle in and out of homelessness and may be unable to pay for temporary shelter at the end of the month.

26:11 It also says that holding the count on one of the coldest nights of the year can be very effective in raising public awareness of the challenges faced by homeless people without shelter. This also makes it easier to recruit volunteers to conduct the counts. Are you aware of what Ben Carson just published or hopes to have enacted that's impacting the Hispanic community? Ben Carson just

26:44 There's a proposed rule to change the Section 214 requirements for immigration status at Section 8 properties. And is that going to impact you? And how will that increase homelessness? Hmm. I don't know. We certainly want to do more outreach in the community to Latinos and others.

27:13 You know, I'm not sure how that's going to impact our programs. You are aware of it. Yes, but I just really haven't thought about how much it's going to impact our programs. I don't expect that it will too much, to be honest with you. We actually do help, but we do help, I will say, a significant proportion of folks who are Latino or Hispanic, especially up in this community.

27:40 So I think probably what it will do is those funding sources won't be impacted by the rule change, but those families that are impacted may become homeless, which then in turn would lead them to seek emergency housing solutions, which are not restricted by immigration status, most of them. And if they're state funded, then they would have lower restriction level than federally funded. Yeah, thank you for that. Our programs are not.

28:08 Affected by immigration status. But you're right. You might see more people that become homeless as a result. That's true. I would agree with that. Designed. Further questions? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very, very much. I thought it was important that our board hear firsthand the work that IMACA and the COC are doing. It directly impacts the need for housing in Mammoth.

28:36 Thank you. Thank you very much. And we are a partner in the continuum of care, so if you ever want to get another update, we're happy to do that. We'll move to agenda item six, consider approval of Mammoth Lake Housing.

28:59 Inc. Resolution 9001, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc. approving the creation of the following standing committees, Governance Committee and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusionary Committee. Patricia? Kirk, if I could, I have a public comment. Oh. That I wanted to introduce our intern.

29:23 I don't want him to sit here the whole meeting without having introduced him, if that's okay. Introduce him. I'm really sorry. So this is Jake Castro. He's our intern for the June 2019-2020 year through a partnership with the California Coalition for Rural Housing. He's a first-generation college student, and he's studying liberal arts, math, and science at Cerro Coso Community College.

29:48 And he hopes to transfer to a four-year college to earn a degree in civil engineering. He wants to pursue civil engineering because he's drawn to service and assisting others in achieving economic opportunity. He's taking two classes this summer and expects to graduate in December of 2020. He'll be working in the office about 20 hours a week. He started today at 2 p.m. on a variety of projects.

30:18 Including 238 Sierra Manor Road and deed restriction stewardship. So I just wanted to say welcome and introduce him to the board. Welcome. Welcome, Jay. Excited to have you. Thank you. Okay. We'll move back to the agenda. We apologize for not introducing you. I apologize. I should have picked up on that, too. I just thought you were part of the public. All right. We'll move to agenda item number six.

30:49 Patricia, staff report. Yes, thank you. So this item is coming back before you this evening after direction at our May meeting to create some standing committees around governance topics and diversity, equity, and inclusion. I've attached the resolution which establishes these committees.

31:14 We decided that we wanted two or more board members to be on the committee, but less than a quorum. They can include members of the public if those members are appointed by the full board. And these committees would be subject to the noticing requirements of the Brown Act. I'm happy to answer any other questions you might have.

31:40 So this agenda bill established, are we appointing people? Yes, the next item would be the appointment of members. So they're two separate items. And this resolution you would adopt through a vote. Questions? Comments? I have one question. With these committees as well as the ad hoc that follow, is there an issue of one board member?

32:07 Member being on two of each, or is that not important? I don't think that should be an issue. Okay. Further questions? I had a question about the constituents of the community being voted on or allowed or whatever confirmed by the board. For what purpose would we want or have a need or for members of the public to be on committee? So I believe that this

32:38 But couldn't they come to the meeting and

33:06 Speak as a public as opposed to being a member of the committee. Brown Act is setting this up, right? Yes, it's a requirement that, well, it's an option that standing committees can have members of the public and it's in our bylaws and ad hoc committees cannot. I think those two options that you provided just have different levels of participation. So a committee member you would invite to the meeting and solicit their input, whereas

33:38 A community member would just arrive and comment. Yeah, I would add to that, ostensibly, I would think these committees are providing direction to the full board, so having, you know, that member of the public as a full committee member weighing in on whatever recommendation it is, is important. And I can say at the county, that's been an effective way to engage people, and as Patricia said, people who are subject matter experts who you want involved in.

34:09 Whatever that topic or decision is. And it's not a requirement, it's an option. That's a good question. Further questions? Discussion? I guess I just have a question as far as, like, you know, we're going to approve or not approve the resolution, and then we're going to appoint members for just these committees, and then we're going to move, and then we're going to go to approve or not approve the next resolution for ad hoc, and, like, should that all be separate?

34:41 Like in terms of process. Each motion, you mean? Well, I know each motion is separate, but in terms of like how it all fits together, like should that be part of our process? So you want to discuss six, seven, and eight as to who's assigned? I don't necessarily, I just want to, I'm just asking like as a board how, you know, like it's all, it's all laid out in the agenda, but to me it's sort of like I see again, you know, we're going to

35:12 Approve the resolution or not, but then in appointing members, who gets appointed to the first two standing committees, does that matter who gets appointed to the next two? I don't think there's any technical support. Yeah, sure. And I think if we set the committees up as we talked about last time, but then as we get an appointment, let's make sure that... Yeah, that's really what I'm getting to. It's like the balance between all four committees. Yeah, have that as one. That makes sense to have that as one discussion.

35:42 We can do the resolutions. Maybe just get those out of the way. Get the committee set up and then have a discussion. So, Mr. Chairman, I would move that we run item number six, that we adopt resolution 19-01 in the Standing Governance Committee and the Standing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee. I'll second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item

36:13 Seven, board members to serve on standing committees. Is that what you're talking about? Maybe we go to nine? You want to go to nine? Eight, I mean, sorry, eight? And then to seven? Okay, so this is just a copy of the resolution forming the ad hoc committee's programs and housing development committee and marketing and communications committee.

36:46 So these are ad hoc committees that will consist of two or more directors but less than a quorum, will not have members of the community and will not be subject to the noticing requirements of the Brown Act. Okay. I'll make a motion that we adopt resolution number 19-02, resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing Inc. approving the creation of the programs.

37:13 And housing development and marketing and communication ad hoc committees. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We'll move back to agenda item 7. Appoint board members to serve on the standing committee, governing committee and diversity, equity and inclusionary committee. Mr. Geek, plan implementation action item. How do you want to move forward?

37:45 Since you took the lead on this. I didn't say I wanted to take the lead. I know Zariah wants to be on, I know Zariah expressed in last month, expressed interest on being on the diversity, the governance. I just wanted to put that on the table. Those are two separate ones. I think in the last meeting I was interested in having whoever the town council appointee to the MLH board be on that.

38:15 I was really interested in being in the diversity and equity and inclusion committee as well. How many can we have on this committee? No more than four. That's three so far. And anybody else for other committees? Yeah, exactly. Can you refresh your memory on the duties of the governance committee? The duties of the governance committee are to do the meeting agreements.

38:56 The evaluation of the Executive Director to evaluate any company policies that may need to be revised, and also board development calendar. And that's President and Vice President? I think we changed it to be open. Okay. It says President, Vice President, and two other. Okay, that's what it says. So it's required that the President and the Vice President be on the committee.

39:32 And then we don't need to have anybody else unless they're interested. I'd be interested in the governance committee. Well then, do we have enough for the government? So it would be the president, vice president? Yes, and Agnes. Do we need a motion to establish that? Please. Do I have a motion? So moved. So moved. Second? Second. Second. All those in favor? Aye.

40:10 And can we do the same for diversity, equity, and inclusion? Yeah, so right now we have Zariah, Giselle, and the town council appointee, which at our last meeting, it didn't sound like we thought we wanted to appoint that person because we didn't know if they would be an expert in that area, but if that's the will of the board, that's fine. Without knowing their particular interest or strength, and if that's

40:47 I think that makes sense. Make a motion, but I don't know what I'm supposed to say for that. To appoint Zariah, Giselle, and the Town Council appointee to the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee. Second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Since I wasn't here at the last meeting, I was just curious the reasoning behind having the Town Council person. I think it's, and I,

41:24 As I participate in these discussions, I'm going to be participating, I am the Town Council appointee now. Yeah. So I'm going to be making recommendations for that position as opposed to an individual. Okay. Right. I think it would be beneficial for the Town Council to have that, whoever that person is, be exposed to those discussions and those issues and those concerns, what that's all about, I think it would benefit the Town Council and benefit the community. Okay. And I'm not appointing myself. I don't know if I'll be on this.

41:56 The town council's got to go through a process that's coming up pretty soon. But you might be. I have no idea. I mean, that's up to a whole rhythm roll that I have no control over. So we'll see. So you'll ask the town manager to put it on an agenda for discussion? What's that? The appointment of a town council person for this? No, no. I mean, there will be a town council appointing back to the board. Yeah. And so, but whoever that person is. We'll be on that committee. We'll be on that committee. Okay.

42:26 The council appointment shows who's going to be the council appointment. Yes. Not what committees are going to be on. If we started doing that. Oh, gosh. Thank you. Yeah, sure. So what's our status? Motion and a second. Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. We'll move to the next, the program. Programs and housing development. And there's also marketing and communications. I have a question, if now is an appropriate time.

43:09 From what I originally remember was that programs and housing development were going to be separate. Just the thoughts of combining those I'm just curious about. I'm trying to reduce the number of committees basically. Oh, okay. That makes sense. So these are ad hoc committees who are tasked with going through the strategic plan and prioritizing the work program essentially and then presenting an outcome to the full board.

43:35 And then they would dissolve at some point in the near future and perhaps be replaced with a standing committee if at that time it seemed appropriate. Got it. Okay. I'd like to volunteer for the Programs and Housing Development Committee. I'm also interested in the Programs and Housing Development Committee. I don't really have a preference, so I've kind of been holding off. I'm happy to go wherever, but I'm leaning toward that.

44:07 I'll join the programs in housing if they'll have me. That sounds like we have three volunteers. Do I have a motion? I nominate them. So I'll second that nomination. There you go. So it's been nominated and seconded. All those in favor? Aye. And we'll move to the marketing communication committee.

44:46 I open it for public comment, board comment, or volunteers. Again, if you could refresh your memories on the duties of the marketing and communications. I think marketing and communications was the initial, part of it was the initial thinking around what our fundraising initiatives might look like, but this would be the first step, so it would be really aligning some of our marketing materials.

45:15 Making sure, thinking about whether or not we need an expert to do some of that for us. Developing some marketing materials for some of our programs. There's a lot there. There's a lot in the strategic plan around these two things. We don't have to point. I mean, it can be kind of a needs-based thing. We've got the committee. We don't have to jump right into it. It may be useful.

45:44 Just from the council's, the town council's perspective, to wait after these appointments are made and then have some new members that might want to join in. And maybe some of these other committees are going to identify a need. It's like, you guys just start working with this other stuff. It's like, man, we really need this. I'm okay with that. So for this one, was this going to be the committee that also kind of built the information builder so anytime that we went to a certain event, we had all the materials ready?

46:18 Yes, kind of talking about where in the priority ranking were coffee talks and roadshows and things like that. Is anything like that coming up soon? I haven't developed any roadshow schedule for us yet. Okay. Overwhelming amount of interest for this ad hoc committee, so at least it's just we got the committee and then next meeting figure out what to do with it. Further discussion?

46:55 It's not, yeah, just table. Good observation. Yeah, I think it takes to the fact that it's a lot, you know, if you join one committee, you might be hesitant to take on more work, and there's only so many of us. I mean, everyone is on a committee right now. So, yeah, maybe this just has to be general board work, right? Yeah, everybody is, so. I will be on this committee. On the marketing. Yeah, I'll do the marketing and communication. Okay, I'll join you in that committee.

47:28 As long as I'm here. And then we'll see what happens. I don't know where we're going. Life is an ominous proposition. You know that. I think we do it in June sometime. Our next meeting is in July. Right? The next MLH board meeting is in July. Right. So I think we may have, before our next meeting, we may have those assignments figured out. But if you want to get together and we can start talking about that, that'd be great. Yeah, and then at least we can figure out.

47:55 What is needed, and then if it changes, yeah.

47:59 You know what, I don't join the one meeting.

48:01 Oh, good.

48:01 I did.

48:02 One meeting.

48:05 We don't go in one meeting.

48:09 Tell everyone.

48:11 The one meeting committee.

48:13 Uh-huh.

48:14 Now that you say that, maybe I don't know.

48:18 What looks like, do we need a motion for Giselle and John to be on the, Stacey. Pardon? Stacey. And Stacey, oh, Stacey, I didn't hear you. Just, she's only committed to one. Yeah. Super ad hoc. I'm going to nominate the members of the super ad hoc. Marketing and communication. These three right here are nominating themselves to be on the super ad hoc. Second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All in favor? Aye.

48:48 Wow, thank you so much. All right, does that, go ahead. So now that we've done that, how do meetings take place? What do we need to do, like the standing committees, because they need to be, they have a different, more formal process. Everything you need to contact Patricia, she needs to agendize it. So the standing committees,

49:21 If it's the will of the board, can meet in the near future, and I will notice, I will send out a request for your availability, and then I will notice the meeting. If the committees don't think we need to have a meeting right away, we can wait until we think we need to have a meeting. But you only have to notice the first two. The governance and the... That's correct. The standing committees. We just get together. Pizza. Yeah, make a ruckus.

49:48 Could you maybe send, I don't know if other board members feel okay with this, but just sending around a list of contact information, maybe with phone numbers and emails, because I'm not sure that I have individual information for all board members. Yeah, that's a good idea. Board roster. Yeah, board roster.

50:18 I like that you said pizza. I'm on your committee. Pizza committee. All right. So, appoint board members to serve on the ad hoc committee. We're done. We're done. We're done. Okay. Ten. Agenda item number ten, Mammoth Lake Housing, town contract update. Patricia? Thanks. I provided an update here because

50:47 I was expecting that we might be able to have the contract at this meeting, but we don't have the contract at this meeting. I had added some language regarding compensating Mammoth Lakes Housing if there were a case which has happened in the past that we're spending more time than we're being paid for under the contract.

51:16 So we had added some language that said if Mammoth Lakes Housing is spending more time on this contract than the $3.30 amount, we would be compensated at an hourly rate. And the town, I felt we needed to add that because there's some concerns around the work, the schedule of work items required by the town under the contract and that items are being continually added.

51:45 Without additional compensation. So I felt like we needed to protect ourselves under the contract in case we weren't able to perform all the items listed in the contract that we had some protection there. The town is taking that language back to their attorney and then that hopefully will come back at our July meeting. That should be the final comment. Is this a time and materials contract? Or is it a flat bid? What kind of a contract is it? I mean in terms of compensation.

52:18 Are you documenting hours and billing hours? Yes. It's a flat rate, but with a very specific deliverable list. I'm assuming you guys have a billable rate and all that? Yes. Okay. And I think just to add maybe to your point, Patricia, that it's a three-year contract. So a lot of things can come up in three years, potential big projects, things like that. So just having that.

52:51 I appreciate this addition just because since we are as a community trying to grow housing programs, one of my concerns was if we were locked into a three-year contract, how if we were to add a program through Mammoth Lakes Housing to assist the community that the town wants us to add, but there wasn't a way to add compensation for it if we got locked in. So I appreciate that there hopefully can be this amendment where we can grow our agency and

53:21 To help the community and not just have to wait three years before we renew a contract. Right, but I'm assuming there's a scope of work in deliverables in the agreement, right? Yes. So that the annual, is it 300,000 years or something? Whatever, it's tied to specific deliverables and things like that. Yes. So it announces we want to do something additional. It could be, okay, well, here's our global rate. We want to do that and then we can add to it.

53:44 Yes. Historically, it hasn't always happened that way. That's why I'm adding, we're trying to add it in. Sure. I mean, we shouldn't do work. If the client wants to add an additional deliverable, you have to negotiate and say, okay, you want to do this, this is what's going to happen. By the same token, there's also a clause in there that allows MLH to go, there's no restriction on us going back to ask the town for additional funding to support other initiatives that may come up. Yes. Which, like, for example,

54:16 A couple of meetings ago, a couple, two months ago or so in the council when you guys approved the money for, oh, for the, those positions or what the heck was it? The middle income or the, yeah, the chamber, the chamber in the, yeah, yeah, yeah, any event. So, I mean, the point is that, you know, we, you know, if we feel so charged that we, you know, there's something comes up that's important that we want more money for.

54:46 You know, funding for the architectural fees for the 238 Sierra Manor Road, or whatever it is, right? I mean, we may feel like, hey, that's something we should propose, and you know, we're, there's no restrictions in the contract that doesn't allow us to pursue the council for additional funding, so that's just my point. That's a good point. So, I'm hoping that we will have this contract language available for you for a final review at our July meeting.

55:13 And that it would be approved at the following town council meeting. I'm not sure what date that would be, but probably not the 4th. One thing, I'd like to request an item for the next agenda, which is for all the new board members to have town staff, maybe Sandra, Rob, or someone, give an overview of Measure A and how the allocations for Measure A work to housing, transit, and marketing, and what the relationship is between those

55:44 allocations to those program areas and to the contractual services that the town has with MLH, ESTA, and Mammoth Lake Services. There's some language in the agenda bill that is not consistent with how I think it works, but I'm one-fifth of expertise being a council member, and I think it'd be very helpful for this board to understand how that allocation process works so the expectations are kind of set.

56:13 I think that's a great thing to do. I think with that as well, I would just add there is language in the draft contract about us giving back, and it's this last paragraph in here, if we have any carryover money that's not spent from the $330,000, you can only retain a certain percentage.

56:41 And then you have to give that back, but that that goes, I'd like, I'd just like to hear town staff as well explain that publicly, that we then, and it's kind of to what Tom just said, that we then just request money if more programs come up. I feel like that's kind of what's going on. Well, that's the whole discussion about, so in Measure A, the amount of money going to housing is a million, going to housing is about a million dollars annually. And what we did a couple years ago in the council was to make sure that each contractor, MLH,

57:09 MLT or ESCO was guaranteed to contract them out, irregardless of what happens with TOT. So if TOT came in really short, the town's like, we're going to honor them, we're not going to come back and say, oh my God, the TOT came in short, you're not going to get your contract money. It's there. But then any dollars that come in, in addition, whether it's MLT or MLH or whatever, it goes into these reserve accounts that then MLH and the town can work together to say, hey, we've got a worthy project, here's some money to bring to these things.

57:38 And I think as well then to see how that reserve money is being spent. Yes. It's coming from this chamber. And without getting into that, I think the town staff, Rob, can give a very, very good at giving these nice dry but subtly entertaining presentations that really lay out all this stuff so that it's clear to everybody how all this works. Because it is a system, it does function and work. We'll be talking about it on Wednesday. You've asked to kind of go into that.

58:05 It's really important for everybody in the community to have a certain fluency about how this stuff works so that we all know what we're doing. It's not that it's restricted. Yeah, that it's structured and it's balanced and there's opportunity to move things around. But I think for all the new board members, it would be really helpful to get a presentation. I think that's a great idea. I was just going to make a historical note that

58:30 Historically, Mammoth Lakes Housing received 1% of TOT, and during the settlement, we got cut down to $330,000. Mammoth Lakes Tourism still receives a percentage under their contract, and we still receive $330,000. So that...

58:49 It's just part of the history, and it was part of the recalibration to bring all of the NGOs into alignment, but I just don't think that that's necessarily alignment. Right, and I saw this comment in the agenda packet, and I've served on this board for I don't know how many years I've been on here, and there's been a lot of issues or discussion around grievances and the past and history, and I think we've really made a lot of progress to move past that, and I would really hope that going forward with the new board and the new strategic plan...

59:16 That we could get a presentation from the town that lays out how this program works, and we can all be looking to the future and how to take best advantage.

59:24 of these funding resources that we have. Yeah, I totally agree with your point. I totally agree with your point, but I think it's really hard for us, and especially as staff, because we get comments from the public saying, Mammoth Lakes Housing used to build housing, what are you doing? And we have to answer to them. And so I think just being honest about

59:46 The funding streams and how they've changed over time is important to inform the community about how we get $330,000 to do these things, and that is what we're doing. Right, but also be able to make explanation that in that measure A allocation that's going to housing, which is about a million dollars, the town is doing a lot of stuff with money. Right, yeah. And to not have this thing in the public's mind that, well, all that measure A money is necessarily going to MLH.

1:00:13 It's going to $300,000 is going to MLH under contract. There's $600,000 or $700,000 other dollars that are going to other projects. MLH is working with the town and other partners to really address the housing problem. Well, and I think it's a strategic discussion for the board to have about why some NGOs are receiving a percentage point and why some are not. Well, but again, I don't think that information is accurate, and I would really like to have the town staff make a presentation. You guys can figure it out if you think that's something to...

1:00:43 I think and under this contract item it's

1:01:05 Particularly pertinent when we talk about adding workload and receiving the same contract amount for the past six years and asking for more and more work, it's pertinent to our contract and how we want to commit for the next three years to the same amount as our expenses are increasing. But it's a standard issue in any agreement. You have deliverables and you have a contracted amount. If your client asks you to do more work, it's a simple thing to say, fine, if he wants to do more work, we need more money.

1:01:32 It doesn't need to be perpetuated into this thing of, oh, poor MLH and all the rest of the stuff in the past. I'm just hopeful we can find a way to move past that. I think it's going to be in the best interest of the organization to do that. And I just want to add one concluding comment or a couple comments real quick on just the contract amount and so forth. The analysis that we did in evaluating the amount of the contract, if my recollection is correct, I'm going to be...

1:01:58 Plus or minus here, but my recollection was about 80 to 85% of staff time was utilized to administer the contract. So it didn't leave a lot of extra bandwidth for other stuff outside of the town's contract. I mean, it ate a vast majority of your time, you know, four more days out of the week, four out of five days you're working on a town contract related administration of those things that are identified, the deliverables. So, but by the same token, you know, I think

1:02:28 As we start to build more capacity here with these ad hoc committees, I think it's going to be helpful as we, you know, it's clear to me as we start to identify new projects, 238 Sierra Manor Road being, you know, an MLH project, so to speak, at this point, you know, there will become a need that, you know, we're going to need other supplemental funding to get that thing off and get some legs on it.

1:02:51 Whatever, you know, whether you're paying an outside consultant or it gets to a point where you feel like you've got enough work, we need to have a staff member, you know, at that point, then that warrants going back to the council and saying, hey, we got this great thing, we're going to create these beds and it's a worthy, you know, effort and that we need, you know, additional funding. So, so again, I don't think the board should ever not think that there's the ability to try to obtain more funding.

1:03:18 You know, from the reserves or whatever it is. I think it'll be real beneficial to understand how that works and what the amount of the reserve funding is and what other projects that the town's looking at pursuing as well. And, I mean, I think at the end of the day, you know, I think we all want to get more workforce housing built in the community and available for our workforce. Yeah, there should never be an expectation that MLH is not being paid to do the work that it's being asked to do. Yeah, no. That's not, that's just...

1:03:48 We should take that off the table. I would also point to the things that are going on. I mean, seriously, if MLH is, no one should be asked to do work for free. I mean, if an organization is being asked to perform services, that's what a contract's for. You lay it out in the contract and you do the things you gotta do, you get compensated for it. I would encourage you to look for things that council's been doing with MLT. We've had a couple items that have been coming up through this joint reserve bucket. The signage and wayfinding piece, the destination management plan that kind of got tabled.

1:04:16 So that's the process that's already in place to do these kinds of things. And to your point, things start coming up, the board makes a recommendation, hey, there's money in the reserve, we think this is an important need, get in front of the council, have the discussion, and there's more money to do stuff. Well, I will just say we did participate in that process and not get any additional funding for our staff time. Which process did you participate in? In requesting reserve funds. Well, it doesn't mean that just because you asked it, you're going to get it. Right, well, that's what I'm just saying. That's asking us to do more work for free. Well, no, again, I...

1:04:45 I have just a problem with that. If you, again, as an organization, if the client is asking us to do work, we're not being paid for it, that's a problem. And I would recommend to the governance committee or somebody to take a look at that because we shouldn't be in that situation. If that's true, I mean, that's not, you know, no, you should never be in a situation like that. Well, maybe if this is an issue that the contract committee hasn't been able to resolve, it seems like something might be appropriate for the,

1:05:16 A discussion of the entire board with the town manager. So he's taking whatever direction, maybe it sounds like you have something else on your agenda around measure A. I'm not sure what it is on Wednesday. I perused the agenda. It's not a decision point. It's a discussion or a process thing, but how to potentially consider reallocating things. Yeah, but it seems to me we're speculating a lot here and kind of going around in circles.

1:05:41 If we need, if the full board needs to have a discussion with the town manager about this contract or some of these issues, you know, I would recommend we do that. I, you know, I think it would be helpful to have, you know, it's great that Sandra's here, but I doubt she wants to step into this trade. No, we should not be approving a contract. Again, I'm not involved in this at all, but just from a general proposition, the board should not be approving a contract with the likelihood that the

1:06:07 That the organization is going to be expected to spend money without being compensated for it. So, yeah, and so I'm hoping that the language that we've included will be acceptable to the town attorney, and as soon as I hear yay or nay, I can move forward with a meeting or we'll see the contract on July 1st. Yeah, I mean, that's, you should not be signing a contract. Further discussion? I'll make a comment.

1:06:40 It's been 10 years, kind of a history of some pretty difficult times because of the airport litigation and everything else and the funding. And we also had TOT that was at about $10 million a year. And it's only been four years since it jumped up to $15 million. And we actually were creating that actually John and John worked hard on this.

1:07:07 created a budget that basically had TOT revenues and staffing and community services at a $10 million level. It wasn't until four years ago that it jumped up to $15 million and all of a sudden there was $4 million in excess TOT that was able to go to roads and all kinds of things that had been postponed. So there's a history of what's the relationship and everything else.

1:07:36 And yes, Mammoth Lake Housing, part of the airport litigation, those funds were diverted for other purposes. The town was in a desperate need, so it had to be done. June 2017, John and Cullen did a reallocation, and those tried to reestablish. And so, in that, they took 0.15%.

1:08:05 For the airport litigation of one point of TOT that went to marketing, housing, and transit. So that money helped pay for that as well as they took the business license tax, which is about $350,000 to help. And again, that was to stabilize government.

1:08:28 Snow removal and buying equipment and everything else and asphalt replacement and it's expensive and we had gotten behind and now it's a catch-up time trying to, you know, when you think of roads, we need to be spending about a million dollars a year on roads because we have over a hundred miles of it and if we're not overlaying it, we're going to get behind and then there's going to be a huge problem.

1:08:57 So the 1% point of TOT, that's about $1,300,000, but a .15 of that goes to the airport litigation. Then you have right now, and again, I go back to the reallocation, and then how we move forward. So Mammoth Lake Housing has a $330,000 contract. The town has moved those, the other,

1:09:27 One percent, about a million dollars, $900,000 for staff to work on the parcel. Now that is housing, but it does conflict with the original, we have to go all the way back to 2002A, there is a conflict with what people were told how the one percent would be utilized and how it's being utilized today. Lots have changed. So there's lots of ground to stand and say, hey,

1:09:55 This needs to be looked at again. We're veering off. Yeah, I think it's important. It is, but I think it should be agendized with some materials and, you know, so that everybody can participate. Okay, we're going to do 2002A? Okay, that's fine with me. I was back to what I requested before. Yeah. So we don't get into this whole discussion. Have it with the proper materials and have the town staff do that. Then we can then... Yeah, with somebody with the...

1:10:24 Town manager ready, you know, prepared. Sure. And we'll have a lot of conversation. And that can engage the rest of the board, too. Sure. That makes sense. Further discussion? Or no further discussion? Not on that. So if there's no other updates on the town contract, Patricia, any other comments? No, thank you. I have that agendized for the next meeting. Yeah.

1:10:51 We'll move to agenda item 11. This is considered authorization of a joint letter with the town of Mammoth Lake to the Department of Housing and Urban Development regarding the proposed rules that would evict thousands of mixed immigrant status families from subsidized housing. Did everybody get a chance to read this? It's incredible. I think it's unconstitutional. How in the heck can you go in?

1:11:21 If a police officer comes up to you, they can't, they can ask for your driver's license, they can't ask for your birth certificate or documentation for citizenship. But that's what this is doing. So I think this is going to end up in court. Probably I'll go all the way to the Supreme Court, the way things are working these days. Did everybody get a chance to look at the letter? So, go ahead. So this is a proposed rule, correct? Yes, comments are due July 9th. Okay.

1:11:50 And do you have any sense of what the retroactive effects of this would be? Yes. So there are no public housing or Section 8 multifamily properties in Mono County. However, there are approximately 14 Section 8 vouchers which would be impacted by this rule.

1:12:20 Those vouchers are used by individuals or families to secure housing in the open market and then that HUD pays the difference between 30% of their income and the market rate rent and that's how you create the subsidy. We only have about 14 of those in the county. I think there's greater concern that individuals and families won't know

1:12:50 Yes, just those vouchers. Yes. Thank you.

1:13:21 And it could impact future developments depending on whether or not they choose to use these subsidies or not. So that's just in Mono County though, correct? But since we also service Inyo County, is there Section 8 in Inyo County or any of these programs that will be affected more directly in Inyo County? Yes, Inyo County also has Section 8 vouchers probably around the same amount. But they don't have like the Section 8 housing? Correct. Okay. And then I think...

1:13:53 Just thinking in the long term, if this interpretation passes, I think that there is room for additional interpretation regarding funding sources that we have utilized in the past. There's some vague regulations around immigration status.

1:14:20 For the current funding sources that we've utilized in the past, and so there is room for somebody to go in and update those regulations to change that. Just one other question then, is the state of California weighed in on this yet? Yes, and so I provided a lot of backup information, and I had intended to provide the draft comment letter, but the draft from the...

1:14:44 National Housing Law Project was 19 pages, and I didn't think that was something we were interested in reviewing at this time, but the state, some congressional electees have submitted a letter which came out today, and so I do have copies of that for everybody. And it's not 19 pages. Does this HUD money go through the state and then the state distributes out? Is that how it works? I believe these HUD programs are directly funded through HUD.

1:15:14 Two jurisdictions. It doesn't go, it's not like. Two housing authorities. Yeah. Okay. So it doesn't go, it's not like. So our Section 8 program is administered through the Stanislaus County Housing Authority, and that's the same for Inyo, Mono, and Alpine. And so they get the money directly from HUD. Okay. One comment I had, there was language in there that the.

1:15:42 The tracking of immigration status would fall upon the local jurisdictions. And I just thought it would be maybe in one of our comments something about it just seems like quite a burden thinking about our office if in the future we did need to track this. That's a lot of extra paperwork to do for what I assume could be small offices. And I don't know if I read that correctly, but I was trying to think of how does this actually play out.

1:16:10 in tracking, and it just seems burdensome, right, to enact. Yeah, I think a lot of non-profits and public housing authorities have voiced concern over the administrative burden. I don't think we would have that at this time under this specific rule change, considering we're not affected by the funding sources, but I think it's something that could impact us if it did extend to other.

1:16:40 Well, I think your point is really important that even if this doesn't, even if this just affects one program out of 10, it could prevent many families and individuals from seeking assistance for the other nine just because of thinking that they're going to be tracked or someone in their family, like even if they're documented, if someone in their family isn't, they may have fear.

1:17:07 of going in because it could potentially put their family member in danger. So I think it's, even though it may not directly affect us, I think it's important for us to vocalize the harm that this could create, will create, if passed. I think it's a pretty nauseating proposition. It's consistent with the tactics of the current administration to do just what you said. Find some little technical thing, take a stand on that, and then the collateral damage is just, you know, you don't even know what it's going to be, but it's, it's...

1:17:37 It's consistent with their tactics and it's nauseating and deeply cynical. I would add that as well. Deeply cynical, nauseating and ridiculous. We should maybe join with the town and send a letter to Mr. Carson. Maybe we'll read it on his new dining room table. I think what's interesting about that is the impacts that it will have to other programs which are not impacted by this.

1:18:04 Rule, including all of the emergency homelessness programs. So the emergency programs aren't impacted by immigration status. So now if all these people are homeless, now you're just funding emergency solutions for them through another funding source. My neighbor across the street works at CARA, which is a California Resources Board. They're deeply involved in a whole other thing, which is the Trump administration's war in California.

1:18:33 Fuel Emission Standards and all the rest of it. And the tactics are very similar in that you find something that's sort of a technical thing and you go after that and it's going to create a cavalcade of consequences. To your point, they're going to start hitting in all kinds of different directions. That's intentional. That's their purpose. That's why they do these things. And another interesting point I just want to point out is that this would impact...

1:18:57 Rural Development Through the USDA, which has funded farm labor housing. And so I think that has huge implications for California and other places as well. But when I picked up my packet on Friday, Patricia, you had just received a call from a community member. Do you mind just sort of letting everyone know? I just feel like we need to address their concern about the idea that maybe government

1:19:28 Funding should not be a resource for certain people who don't qualify for people of certain legal status. So we had a public comment from a community member that was asking whether or not in our community non-citizens are receiving public benefits and I don't have the data to explain the answer to that.

1:19:57 But what I do know is that under this program, currently non-citizens do not receive federal public subsidy. They actually pay more in rent. It's just that their citizen family members get the reduced rent. And so if they change that, then that non-citizen would have to leave the unit. And I think there's concern, obviously, that then not receiving that higher rent is going to put the entire property at risk.

1:20:31 So they're under this rule change. The current rule is that they're not receiving a federal public subsidy. Thank you for clarifying. Well, I know that kind of goes across the board too. I mean, like I know with food stamps or WIC, any of those, if you're undocumented but your child isn't, you receive those benefits for the child. It's not for you. And similar to this is it's not

1:21:00 For the undocumented person, it's for the family members, and they pay regular rent. So I think there's a giant misconception that even if you're undocumented, you get all of the public benefits that we have, and that's just not true. Despite paying taxes? Yeah. In a lot of cases. So this item is just...

1:21:23 So I'm asking the board to consider whether or not they would like to write a joint letter with the town of Mammoth Lakes in opposition to this rule change. And I don't have the draft letter language this evening. I'll have to continue to work on it with town staff. But we could have it at our July 1st meeting in time for the comment deadline, which is July 9th. And if there are specific comments you'd like me to add into the letter, I'm happy to take feedback. Discussion?

1:21:55 Yes. Signing on. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. I will move. Is this a motion? I think it's a staff direction. Okay. Oh, it says action item. Oh, well, I thought I was going to have a draft letter, but I guess I don't. Sorry. All right. Then it's a staff direction. If we have comments on or things that we'd like to maybe keep.

1:22:24 From this letter, can we just email you individually? Yes, please do. If you have specific comments or stories from your neighbors or community members or yourselves, then please share those with me so that I can make our letter really compelling. Thank you. Further discussion? We'll move to agenda item 12, which is 238 Sierra Manor Road update. Patricia? Okay, so I have our monthly 238 Sierra Manor Road update. And

1:23:05 I guess on January 7th, the board authorized spending up to $40,000 on some of our readiness components for some grant applications that will be coming up in August and September, I'm hoping. I'd like to just note that we received a copy of, well, I guess I'll just go down, readiness component number three.

1:23:32 We interviewed two architecture and engineering firms today and the team selected a firm and so we'll be notifying them first thing tomorrow and hoping to work expeditiously with them to get the components ready that we need for the grant applications which are coming up quickly. There will be public meetings as part of that so I'll keep you posted. Readiness component number seven is the market study.

1:24:07 Which we received today. So we'll be reviewing that, and I think we have some comments for the consultants. So we should have a great draft of that ready for the grant applications. And then we got our lead, mold, and asbestos report, which is item number eight, completed in May. So we're making good progress. What about item number two? The funding commitment, it says.

1:24:36 The USDA RD 538 request submitted May 14th. Yes, so, yeah, I've been communicating back and forth with the broker for the RD loan, trying to get our pro forma underwritten by their finance committee, and there's some few things I need to tweak.

1:24:57 To see if it's going to work out for them. And then I'm also going to get in touch with Cal FHA to see if they have some funding for multifamily development, which may or may not be a better option, but I'm still researching. California Housing Finance Authority. Thank you. Yeah. And so that funding, that loan funding,

1:25:35 Would, and a lot of it's still up in the air right now because the amount would actually be different depending on how much grant funding we receive from the next two applications. So if we get one of the applications and we have a bigger gap, then that loan amount is actually going to be more than maybe what I'm thinking it is today. So there's a lot of moving parts still.

1:26:07 There's not actual construction cost estimates, but we do have a rough estimate. Is that this 5-9-3-17-192? Oh yes, I forgot I included that. It says total development. No, that includes the land, the loan that we currently have out on the property, so that's total development cost. So it might be helpful just to have something that it's the estimate, there's a cost estimate of what it's going to take to do the project and other town council.

1:26:43 Set aside some money to start looking at some opportunities. And I think it would be helpful if there was something that's a basic, look, it's going to cost this much money to do this project. That might be something that the town might want to take a look at and start finding a better partner, which may be, I mean, I think it's $2 million that we've got kind of set aside to do some work with. And so if there was just a cost estimate, if the estimated cost to redo this project is X, I think that might be something to start talking to the town about.

1:27:14 If I could add to the conversation. So we had our ad hoc committee meeting today, as Patricia noted, talk to the architects. So a good group out of Southern California that's done a lot of affordable housing projects, seemed like a really good fit, and they gave a pretty reasonable number to do what I would consider sort of a conceptual planning for us within a budget that we've previously approved as board, which will

1:27:43 Much better inform our ability to put together a cost estimate for it. That said, the property's 9,700 square feet. It's going to be a pretty extensive gut renovation and redoing exterior skin, maybe having to rebuild the roof potentially, and then obviously restructure the interiors for apartments. So, you know, my guess is it's hard construction costs are wild.

1:28:12 Ask, you know what, guess is probably three to four million bucks. Something like that. So, in any event, my point is though, I think with this architect was available to do the work in pretty short order so that we can have enough information to put it together for the CDBG grant cycle in August and September for your home or vice versa. So, at that point, we should have some pretty good information which we could

1:28:42 Solicit somebody from outside to help us prepare a more accurate cost estimate. I think it would be really helpful if the board just have a cost estimate. Look, we're in this ballpark, we think it's going to be this. And I'm assuming these folks you're talking to, they're aware of like all the town's structural, shear, seismic, all that kind of stuff. Well, I mean. Because you open it up out a window and you're going to redo a shear wall and all of a sudden you're in. They're competent architects from what I gathered talking to them today that they understand the building code and so forth.

1:29:11 They haven't built anything in Mammoth, specifically, but I think with our advising them, I think there shouldn't be any issues. Just send them so they have the property that they know where they're working from. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and Patricia and Diane did a great job putting together the RFQ package for that. I helped them with that. And they did a really professional, great job of packaging all up and getting the solicitation out, getting the proposals back. So I think we're on a really good track on that.

1:29:41 You know, I think we're going to get a lot more information here in the next month or so as we, a couple months as we prepare this information and then at that point we can hopefully have a lot more traction on it. One thing just a little bit of a point of order though, I think if when these committees like the contract committee or this whatever committee that you were working on that did this, maybe we could assign them to the agenda also so it's like Patricia gives kind of a staff report committee report a committee report that's there so that we know what LO committees are doing and we take advance in information. Yeah, that's very helpful.

1:30:11 So the last page on this item is just a preliminary project timeline, which I thought would be informational to the board. You know, in an ideal timeline, we're looking at leasing up in December of 2012. So I wanted to just throw that out there. Further questions? If no further questions, we'll move to agenda item 13, which is a parcel update.

1:30:52 Mr. Chair, I apologize, but I need to leave the meeting early, so I may sneak out here in a minute. Our action items are all done. Why did you come? She's on two committees. She bails.

1:31:19 All right, we're on agenda item 13. I'm not sure what Stacy's going to do. Patricia? Okay, thank you. I just have a quick update here about MLH participation and involvement in the parcel development. I've been responding to miscellaneous requests from the town and the consultant regarding costs at our current properties, prevailing wage questions.

1:31:49 Questions about how to contact the editor for El Sol, just lots of different things. So I'm trying to get to those as quickly as possible so that they can get that information. I've attended a couple of biweekly parcel team conference calls and provided comments on the preliminary interview.

1:32:17 Review document which will come forward at the June 26th Planning and Economic Development Commission Town Council workshop. So that was good. I attended the stakeholder interview. We hosted Spanish interviews at the MLH office. I think that's everything that happened in May. This week we're going to, we're helping to solicit

1:32:47 Survey participants, so there's a survey that's live for the community to get involved in, and we're accepting hard copy surveys in the Mammoth Lakes Housing Office in both English and Spanish for those who may or may not have access to the internet or prefer to provide their comments written down. I had some comments to the town regarding the registration process for the survey online. It seemed a little

1:33:17 Burdensome for some participants, especially our Hispanic community who may not want to register on a government website. But I was informed that the collection of the data is really a priority, despite, I think, that giving the community an opportunity to express their comments should be the priority.

1:33:43 But the survey is the main, the online survey will be the main way that people can provide their comments during this time before the Charette, which is forthcoming in August. So survey responses are due, or I guess they're not due, but the survey's live, so everyone should participate and tell everyone they know to participate, and then those comments will be summarized and provided at that joint workshop as well.

1:34:13 I wonder if you could maybe do the board a favor. There's a series of links, the Engage Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Parcel webpage, the Facebook page, all these different things. If you could maybe just put together those links and send it around to the board so that we can all use that to amplify and send it out to our networks. I think that would be helpful. Yes, I will, yes. There's an email I can forward to you with all that information. I can forward to the board. I can send you, I've got the links, so I'll just send them to you. But I think really helpful for all of us to be.

1:34:44 Sending it out to our networks and our groups and all the rest of it. Yeah. But the survey is the main feedback tool, right? So really need to encourage people to... But also know where that parcel page is. I started, I'm guilty, I started to write and I'm like, oh, this took too long, I got a phone call. Put the Facebook page, look at that, get some feedback on that, get some activity going. We'll send these to you, Patricia, just you got a moment, please. Perfect, thank you. With the hard copy, for your concerns about the registering,

1:35:15 With it being cumbersome and especially individuals who may not want to register on a government website, would the hard copies kind of circumvent that process or do you have to fill out special things? Yeah, so I have the hard copy surveys in the office. It's just that our office is the only place you can access a hard copy. But could that be something that gets spread out to more locations so that more than just Mammoth Lakes Housing is an opportunity to fill those out?

1:35:46 Yeah, it provided that feedback and suggested that we could help facilitate that, but it was decided that the online registration is really where they want to collect their data in lieu of receiving more responses. The survey, can we send that, similar to kind of John's question about sending all the websites and different things out, can we forward the survey to anyone who is

1:36:17 Who we think would be interested in filling it out? I mean, like, my husband got it, he forwarded it to me, can I send it to my parents who are second homeowners kind of thing? Like, is, I haven't taken it myself, so I don't know what information it got. I haven't taken it either, but I know during the registration process, there's things like, do you live in Mammoth? How much money do you make? So I think it might take you, it would filter you out, maybe. Or it would just filter you to a different group. Yeah.

1:36:47 of data. So yeah, I would say, even if it's doubling up, to send it to people that we can't get it out to everybody, send it to everybody in the universe, and get people engaged, however they want to engage in it. I mean, you know, we're certainly, as the council, very concerned. We're going to have to make some very important decisions about land use and zoning and height and all kinds of different things, and we need, we want, I want to make sure, I know I'm sure none of the trick does as well, that we've got as much engagement and output with

1:37:16 I have an idea. I promise I'll take the survey. Don't leave yet because this involves your new committee, the marketing committee. If we're worried about having not enough hard copies, is that something the marketing committee would like to sort of take on helping with something, whether it's emails or hard copies? I'm thinking like burritos at the Latin market and you have hard copies for two hours.

1:37:45 Encourage people to sign up. Yeah, have a table at the, you know. You have your phone, I can email the link to you right now or you can do a hard copy here. There should be every channel you can possibly think of. Well, I've raised the option of us helping with hard copy distribution and that was not accepted. So maybe then it's more just the information booth, may I email you a link.

1:38:08 Or do you want to take the services? Or here's the website, pull it up on your phone. Yeah, the parcel, the page, there's a page on the town's website you can get on the list. It's the town's list and all communication of the town's in the action. But if you go to Engage Mammoth Lakes, you can take it there. That's exactly, that's another one. There's a bunch of different places to do it. And what happens with the hard copies? Are those inputted or those go to the town? Those will be input, I think, by the consultant or town staff, I'm not sure. You're collecting them.

1:38:37 We're collecting them and we'll drop them off at the town. I have copies. So the town has an update at their meeting, which will happen on Wednesday, and I brought copies of the town staff report for everybody because that's where the real information is. And that's an attachment.

1:39:15 I think it's at the beginning. It's what? It's in the beginning. It is in the beginning? Okay, good. Patricia, I know you didn't know that, but when it does the survey close? Well, I think technically they will be consolidating results up until June 14th, but that it's, I think it will remain open, but it's unclear. Okay. But encourage people to do it soon then. Okay.

1:39:45 I have a question about- If they don't attend the Charette or a public town council meeting, this may be their only opportunity to comment. I was just wondering if there's any, like if for the survey, if you know, if anyone's reached out to maybe like Imaca or Wild Iris or any of those non-profits who work with a lot of homeless individuals, well, not just homeless, but individuals who live here.

1:40:12 Maybe it could be a part of while they're working with clients to see if their clients will take the surveys, if the clients are willing. I don't know if that's been discussed. Yeah, I think that's a great idea, and I also think that the Cultural Outreach Committee through Mono County Behavioral Health is a good idea, and I've passed all of these comments on to the consultant team, and I'm not sure the status of what the outreach they're doing actually is.

1:40:37 But I think that, I mean, there are very specific things that are supposed to be happening. One of them is there's supposed to be a card, which I'll be getting. It's got a QR card on it that we should get all members of this board. You can just hand out to people and say, oh, you want to get in? Because, you know, cameras and phones these days, you don't need a QR code reader. Just point the thing at it, take a picture of it, and it goes. So there's going to be every method you can think of. And I would really encourage you to make sure that get in touch with

1:41:04 Grady Dutton is the lead on this. And send these comments and have you send it directly to the town. Is Amaka distributing this to their lists? And think of every single community organization that maintains a list of people for things related to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Is this group amplifying the message that the town's putting together? And whose role is that? All of us as citizens to get in touch with the town and say, hey, is the MLT email list?

1:41:34 Getting a link to this page to sign up to be notified and get on that list. Every single list on the MLTPA's list, we're going to send it out to our people. Go, hey, want to be involved in housing? Right here. Sign up here, get on this stuff, and make sure you're being made available. But MLTPA is doing that because you're involved in that, and you're passionate about that, and you know about that, but I don't know if IMACA is doing that. Well, then someone needs to call IMACA and say, hey, we need you to do this. Right, the lead of the project.

1:42:02 Whoever's deleting the outreach component, which I'm not sure who that is, needs to be doing that. Well, Patricia, Patricia, I can give you the link to the town's webpage where people go to sign up for this thing, and you can send it over to Omaka, we can send it to all of our different communicators, and say, hey, please send this link out to your folks and get them signed up on this list.

1:42:22 Right? I just thought that's what the consultant was for. Well, the consultants are nice and they do nice things, but at some point citizens have to stop and say, oh, we've got an opportunity to do this kind of stuff. Let's all get this out to all of our networks. And I just sent you the links to the various pages. Send that to all the board members and say, look, these are the places that people need to go to sign up. Has it gone out to our MLH newsletter? Yes, it's gone out on our newsletter and it's gone out to our applicants who are on our waiting list.

1:42:53 And saying get to the board, we'll all send it out. Yes, and I will send it to the board. Yeah. Yeah, even HOA. Everybody. HOA email lists for different housing. This is a huge deal. Yeah. Amplified. You're on the marketing and communications. Well, there's beer in Kansas, so I'll, you know. No, we're going to raise, we're going to do amazing things in a 20-minute meeting. You watch. 20 minutes. You are going to be in a 20-minute meeting, John. You talk for 20 minutes.

1:43:25 Well, yeah. Put that on the internet. Yeah, I'll email them out and see if they can send 10 employees. Exactly. All the employees should know about it. And the other thing is there's the charrette. What are the dates for the charrette that's in August? August, yeah. Okay, so that's a, that's, those dates need to get out to everybody. Yeah. And I know this summer, everybody's booking their little summer programs for the whole summer, but there's four days in August, the end of August, that...

1:43:52 And I'm hoping there'll be child-friendly activities so that families with children can come to those events. Have we, have we, do we know of the actions that are being taken to really try to engage the Latino community? It hasn't, like, is there, like, anything that's been listed as to, like, to really make sure? That would be, the council, I'm sure, there's contracts with these consultants, and I'm assuming that there's going to be a report out.

1:44:27 Of the outreach program, all the specific steps that were taken. That's right. Because again, when we have to make decisions about stuff, we're going to need to know, was this incredible, was the outreach thorough, did it penetrate and get to every place it should have gotten? And so I don't have the answer. So the survey is available in English and Spanish, and we are going to distribute the survey link to 82 apartments.

1:44:55 That we have a relationship with. And then the consultants are proposing two Spanish community meetings to hold during the Charette time period so that the Hispanic community can provide comments. But I'm also concerned about whether or not we're reaching out to the youth of our community. How are we involving them? So from the town's perspective, Grady Dutton is identified as the lead.

1:45:26 A woman named Amy Callinan. She's in charge of the social media outreach program for the town. I'll send those email addresses over. You can reach out to them and ask those questions to them. They should reply to you. They should respond. They should be giving you all the materials that you need to get out to your networks to get the word out. I hope we have a minimum survey response that we would be willing to accept from both English and Spanish speakers.

1:45:56 As a, what do you call that? Baseline. Statistically relevant. Sure. I mean, the town, the community is investing a lot of money in this. And we want to make sure it's successful. We want to make sure that we get out to every, you know, we need, again, consultants are nice and they do great things, but we need the citizens to get this stuff out there and get it out to folks. We'll talk about it in a minute. Yeah. For the discussion on the parcel.

1:46:27 If not, we move to Agenda Item 14, Mammoth Lake Housing, Monthly Update. Patricia? Thanks. I don't have a lot of things. On page 2 of 8, we have 75 households on our low-income housing waiting list because Diane processed seven rental applications last month. Awesome. We didn't fill any units, so there were no vacancies in our apartments.

1:47:03 On page 5 of 8, I have created a table here showing all of our down payment assistance programs. Hopefully this is a little bit easier to read. So we currently have home funding through the town for low-income households to purchase a home. Mono County was awarded home funds, but that's not set up yet, so that's forthcoming.

1:47:28 The town has CDBG funding, which is now available for down payment assistance, and also for rehab loans, and so we'll be meeting with town staff on Wednesday to talk about that process, since we haven't done a rehab loan before. But we have all of the process and the documents, and Diane's been working really hard on it, so we'll be able to walk the town through that process and hopefully get ready to go and do some rehab loans.

1:47:59 Maybe some new fireplace inserts or weatherization. We have some begin reuse funding, which is for households up to 120% AMI. It's only about $100,000, and that's available now for eligible units, which there's one at San Joaquin Villas and there's one at Aspen Village. We have the moderate income program through the town, which the town approved up to $100,000.

1:48:29 And that program will be available as soon as we execute the contract with the town. Yeah, so that's a lottery, and so we will have to implement that lottery system after we execute our contract with the town, so that'll be exciting. Was that the $100,000 that we were discussing that there was our expenditures, so it was not $50,000 for each, it's like $47,500? It's actually $50,000 because the town...

1:49:02 Staff wanted to take it back to town council for town council direction on whether or not we could do that, and I didn't want to hold it up, so I said, we'll just bill it under the town contract and see how that goes. And then we have some Cal Home Reuse funds of about $12,000 to loan to households to buy manufactured homes in mobile home parks. That money is currently from four different loans which are being repaid over time, so that amount goes up every month.

1:49:34 That's just an estimate about what we have. I guess under item G, there are no deed restricted homes currently on the market, but we have interested parties who are interested in buying deed restrictions. And then we have some owners of unique deed restrictions that are in mixed use properties who are trying to feel out the value of their homes. They don't have a

1:50:10 They don't have a prescribed resale value like our other home ownership restrictions do. So I've had a lot of calls from real estate agents trying to understand those deed restrictions, which are a little more complicated than our traditional ownership restriction. And then I'll just go to the market analysis, which shows that the median home sales price year to date

1:50:44 For a condo is $444,500, which is a 10% increase from last year. And for single family homes, it's $799, which year to date is negative 13%. But we're only not even halfway through the year, so that doesn't really mean anything. But the price means something because we haven't seen a ton of interest in our down payment assistance programs.

1:51:16 Low-income households qualify for so little in a primary loan that even with the down payment assistance, they're not reaching the purchase price. So that's a problem. And then if we're not successful at spending our grant funds, we'll be less competitive in the next round. So advertise and market. Could that shortfall be subsidized by a grant from the town housing reserves?

1:51:49 Yeah, I think it could. Because, I mean, I'm just trying to, you know, in the struggle to define housing for people and residents, right? I mean, what's the, certainly not cheap to build new housing. So, as much as we can get people into existing housing, even if it requires a subsidy, it's still a better deal than trying to build new. So, I'm just wondering, you know, if, and I don't understand all the, we'd have to work out the, the math of the whole thing of the equation, but,

1:52:21 You know, if it takes just a little bit more subsidy from the town through some of the housing reserve funds that we could get all of a sudden 10 more people could qualify to buy an existing home. We could certainly layer funding. We've done that in the past with grant programs. And so I think this would just be considered another grant program. And we just need a promissory note and a deed of trust. And maybe if we wanted to require a deed restriction or whatever we wanted, we'd add that in.

1:52:50 For this agenda item for the next meeting, just have the town spell out how issues would need to get into that discussion for a joint, I think it's called a joint bucket discussion with the council. How does that process work? Because we went through a process with MLT about laying out how that works, so you guys will understand how things come through. Certainly, it's like citations of the community housing action plan, those kinds of things that are, here's a rationale, here's a program that's in place, and see if there's some way to

1:53:20 Yeah, I mean, like, hypothetically, I'm thinking, again, as you mentioned, and I know that there's going to be more funding from excess TOT potentially funneled towards housing in general, but, you know, in the near, again, in the near term where it's going to take a while for new construction to actually manifest and be out there and delivered. In the meantime, if, just, again, hypothetical, say,

1:53:48 You needed $50,000 per family to get them over the bubble so they could actually acquire an existing condo. You know, half a million bucks, that's 10 households, right? So that's a significant impact. So, you know, it might be lower hanging fruit. And, you know, I think at the end of the day, you know, affordable workforce housing has to be subsidized. So it's just a question of how do you subsidize it? Where do you subsidize it from? And I think we all recognize that

1:54:22 Mammoth, as a community, will increasingly need to step up to the plate to self-fund programs and or new development to make it happen. So this is just another version of development, in my view, delivering units. Under Partnerships, Item C, Town of Mammoth Lakes, I just wanted to give you an update on the Chamber of Housing Program, since we haven't had a Chamber of Steering Committee meeting in a while.

1:54:53 They decided to hire a new staff person, and that person started today. And that's all I know about that. I'm working with Bono County Behavioral Health regarding the Latino Housing Coalition staff person, so they're still drafting the contract, so I'll bring that back as soon as we get it. And then under other...

1:55:17 I attended the Continuum of Care Strategic Planning Session, which was very good, talking about the process from contact with the homelessness person all the way through permanent housing and where in the process people get back into the cycle and how can Mammoth Lakes, you know, I was there, how can Mammoth Lakes Housing help support getting people into permanent solutions. So I thought that was really...

1:55:44 A great meeting. I met with two private developers interested in creating workforce housing. I wanted to let you know that our final strategic plan is on the website. I didn't provide a copy in the packet, but it is on our website. I will email it to the board, and then I will be setting up meetings with some of our partners that were contacted during the process to let them know that it's been finalized and that we're excited to work together.

1:56:12 And then the last thing I had is I have a copy of the Measure A staff report that's on the agenda for the Town Council to talk about on Wednesday, which I thought was relevant to the board. So I have some more paper. And I think that's all I have, unless there's questions. Questions of staff? No, we'll move to board member report. John?

1:56:46 So, uh, I was involved in the interview process for that person that MLH hired, and I was, uh, The chamber. I'm sorry, the chamber hired. As a town council representative. Yeah, and then also, we had set up a meeting this last week to meet with the guys with the people on the website up in Tahoe, and there was some, uh, meeting ran late, and the guy, apparently they don't have cell phone service in Tahoe, so that means that you don't have scheduled.

1:57:16 I would again, as I mentioned, I sent a packet of links to Patricia for all those different things associated with the parcel. I think I'm looking at the meeting on Wednesday, it's been kind of a kickoff for this effort, and I'll do everything I can to, if you have any questions, as a council representative, what can I do to facilitate and get the word out to do these things and make all that happen? I, as a member of the newly formed Communications and Marketing Committee,

1:57:45 I'm concerned about website traffic statistics. I'm hoping that we can bring that out and figure out why they're falling like that. And maybe it's a common issue, I don't know what it is, but I think that's something we should talk about because if you look at the numbers there, that's just not pretty. I think we could maybe figure out some way to do that. And if it's my last meeting, it's been a pleasure. If it's not, I'm looking forward to the next one. So thank you.

1:58:15 Can we vote on that? Angie and I closed escrow on a condo two weeks ago, so we're no longer long-term renters. Unfortunately, where I was living as a long-term renter was being sold, and it's probably going to turn into who knows what. So we have a net loss of zero because...

1:58:40 I promised Angie I'll live till I'm 83. And so the house is locked, or a condo's locked up till then. Perfect. Congratulations. Congratulations. I participated in the town council, or excuse me, the parcel interviews, which was, it was great. It was well organized, good information. I thought we had a good conversation with the consultants. Tom? Yeah.

1:59:10 I, as well, participated in an individual interview with Lisa Weiss Consulting Group on the parcel, which was a very enjoyable time, actually. Got a lot of information. I got to download at least a lot of my thoughts about it to them. Those of you who aren't aware, the Yotel had a report on this last month. The project was approved in terms of their entitlements through Planning Commission action. So that's...

1:59:40 Approved Project now. My understanding from the developer is that it's gotten too late this year for them to break ground. They're going to actually, which originally thought they were going to break ground this year. It sounds like it'll be next year now. Early next year. This time next year, as I understand the construction schedule. So, and then I did, I've as well been approached by some private developers.

2:00:09 Different folks about the Mountain participating in their development of workforce housing as such, and both on sort of a master lease basis and or equity participation. And all I can say, generally speaking, is that the costs are very high. The cost to construct and develop is extremely high right now. And I think there's actually, I think there's a lot of unknowns about

2:00:38 What it really is going to cost to build things. The general sense is for feedback is that it hasn't gotten cheaper to build in Mammoth. So that's a challenge. And I think it just stresses even more the need that, particularly for, per se, you can't go out to private development and say, go do a workforce housing development that pencils. It doesn't pencil. It doesn't cash flow with

2:01:07 The rental income you get from the property to cover the cost of development. So it requires subsidization and I would say fairly substantial subsidies to make it work. And I think we all know that, but that's the reality. And so again, I can't stress enough the importance. I think we're weak, all of us, the community, the town, Mammoth Lakes Housing.

2:01:34 myself, on just, you know, how do you structure financing these projects? And I think we need to come up with a more robust approach or network of people we can work with to assist us in other ways to structure funding for housing. And I actually came across an article in a professional journal I get.

2:02:00 And it's an article about Freddie Mac, who has a new affordable housing investment fund, a low-income housing tax credit investment fund. And they actually, this is articles from October of 18, so last fall. And this sounds like a, it says, we're pleased to announce our first LIHTC fund in nearly a decade. Our investments will provide highly targeted and affordable housing to some of the most underserved communities in the country.

2:02:31 Called out a particular project that they funded in Summit County, Colorado, where they provided funding for 40 new apartments for people at AMI levels between 30 and 60 percent AMI. So kind of a peer area, Summit County, right? Ski resort area that was able to secure LIHTC funding for a 40 unit apartment. So I'm going to pass this on.

2:03:00 To you, Patricia, that maybe you could chase down this fund and see whether there's any potential for Mammoth to, you know, maybe even on the Sierra Mammoth Project, who knows? But I think it's going to take layers of these kind of things to make these things work, and I think we're going to have to start getting pretty aggressive about trying to contact these people who specialize in this stuff. Again, this was a little bit, oh, I learned when I went to that conference in Las Vegas is there's multiple layers of funding that go in putting these projects together.

2:03:30 LIHTC combined with other grants and local funding all goes to work towards, you know, creating funding the gap, if you will, to subsidize the construction of this stuff. Yeah, that's about it. Thanks. I have nothing to report. Angie? Agnes. Agnes, what did I say? Sorry. That's okay. It's okay, George. Yeah, that's what that's for.

2:04:03 I just wanted to say welcome to Jake. I did get to, there's been a couple showings now, The Quiet Force, I don't know if anyone else has gotten to see it, but I went to the middle school one, and it was worthwhile to see, and then the small panel discussion with David Page and Sheriff and a few restaurant business owners.

2:04:36 I hope it shows again if you haven't been able to see it. Yes, I've just been doing some informal surveys of people living in the cars and even out in the parking lot here, they seem to be clustering now. Vans and a bunch of motor homes and I mean it's pretty incredible. Also at the athletic club, the number of people that are coming in that are living in their cars.

2:05:12 just seems to be increasing. I do have, I do want to, and John has mentioned this before, so I'm hoping I can partner with him on looking at the town council, a funding mechanism for workforce housing to partner with private development. I mean, that would be, it would have to go out for a vote and everything, and there's no, nothing locked in or anything like that, but I think

2:05:42 Partnering with private developers are, we need a more funding source because the staff is focused on the parcel. We're maintaining a lot of different units that we have now and if those come online those will be transferred over to Mammoth Lake Housing to deal with. So I look at

2:06:04 You know, the capital projects, there's going to be a challenge for the town council to look at and prioritize what's first on these capital project lists. What needs to be addressed first and where does the funding, what gets funding first? So I'm hoping that we can engage, at least begin that discussion and maybe move something forward to an election.

2:06:33 So I think that's, I just think that that's the only way we're going to be able to achieve and address some of these issues that are coming forward. It's going to be a robust debate, I've been told. And that's all I have. Anything else? Otherwise, we are adjourned. Thank you.