Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2019
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 38 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
77 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:09 I hereby call the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, May 8th, 2019 to order. Roll call, please. Commissioner Channing. Here. Present. Present. Present. Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Greg, since you're fresh off a trip to Mexico, would you care to... To lead us in a pledge of allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
2:42 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. I would like to invite any member of the public that would like to address the commission with public comments that are not related to anything on the agenda. Please come forth now. I'll start for public comments, and then Hayes can go next. So in our audience here, we have our new senior planner, Chandler Van Schack.
3:08 Chandler is replacing Ruth Traxler, so he'll be our senior planner, doing a lot of current planning, our most complex current planning projects. He'll also be the planner for the parcel. Chandler comes to us most recently from Denver, the city of Denver, where he worked for about a year, and then I think he was in the city of Boulder for about seven years. So Chandler has a, let me look at your, let's see.
3:31 A master's degree in city and regional planning and a bachelor's degree in environmental studies. He's definitely an outdoorsy person, climber. He's already been camping. He's only been here for a week and he's already been out camping and climbing and has a couple of dogs, a wife and a young baby. So I think they'll be out here in the next month or so. So just wanted to introduce you to Chandler and you'll see him around. You'll see him sitting here at the table with us. And I don't know if you want to say anything you're welcome to or not. It's up to you.
3:59 Look forward to working with all of you. I'm really happy to be here. Congratulations and welcome. I guess the most important question pertinent to today's agenda, did you find a place to live? Staying in the town condo for now. So still looking for something longer term. Good. Congratulations and welcome. Thank you. Look forward to working with you. Cheers. Hayes, would you care to... I'm sorry, Sandra, was there anything else? That's it. That's all I had. Alrighty, so just a quick update on...
4:30 A few things that Public Works is up to around town. So just maybe one second. We had this problem yesterday with the MLT board meeting. I think that mic has got, you just sound like you're really, really muffled. And I don't think it'll come through well on Granicus. Thank you, Jamie. Is that better? Much. Excellent. So just an update on some of Public Works activities around town. So you probably noticed we've gotten to work on construction projects on Main Street. We've already poured the retaining wall in front of the fund shop.
5:06 That has now cured. We'll start backfilling that in the next couple of days and then work to patch in the asphalt around it. We've got a railing to install some facing. The crews have started working on the lower Main Street, the big phase three, starting up top on the segment between Mountain and Sierra Boulevard. There's a couple of very large retaining walls that need to go in there, so they're starting that work first before moving into the areas on the frontage road.
5:30 They've got delineators up and they're cutting down trees right now and the earthwork will start in the next couple days and then we'll see our sub consultants doing the drill tech soil nail walls in the next couple of weeks. So we'll be pretty busy out there. Once that happens, we get the consultants moving forward on the soil nail wall, then you'll see the contractor move to the south frontage road, installing traffic controls and then doing the demolition work.
5:56 Our own crews are out doing a number of different things. We've got a lot of potholes to fill after this winter, a lot of damage that they have to repair, shoulder backing, also all the striping is gone. We do need good warm temperatures to stripe. Our crews are doing the best they can, starting with stop bars and crosswalks, and then they'll move to the linear striping. As long as we have good weather, they'll continue working on that as diligently as possible. Got it. Thank you. I have two questions. Sure.
6:26 The retaining where you're referring to in front of Fun Shop, if you were standing in front of it, in front of Fun Shop, where is that retaining where that you're referring to? Right in front of the Fun Shop. Right in front of it. But I thought that was, that portion is kind of a graded.
6:43 So there was a graded slope there. There's now a concrete retaining wall. It was constructed about a week ago. The right-of-way line is actually very close to the building frontage, and in order to get the right-of-way to provide 24 feet of travel lanes and 20 feet for parking, we need to repatriate that slope and move the southerly portion of the
7:14 Travel lane to the far edge of our right of way. In order to facilitate that, we need to put a retaining wall to, you know, put that cut in place and create the real estate to realign the road. So that retaining wall is facilitating all of that work and all the future work you're going to see this summer. And like I said, that wall is now in place. When you talked about striping throughout the town, I understand that most of the roads are owned by Caltrans, right?
7:44 Main Street and Old Mammoth Road and so forth? No, only Main Street is owned by Caltrans. What about in front of a village? In the village, that's Minaret Road, that portion of 203 is also Caltrans. All other roads are owned by the town. Okay, I see. And so when you talk about striping, you're not talking about Main Street nor just... We will probably help them out with some striping of the crosswalks for our pedestrian components down the town.
8:12 Maintains under encroachment permit. Our guys typically will do that striping for Caltrans. They are responsible for doing their own striping of fog lanes, bike lanes, and such on 203. Okay. Hey, is there any idea on the time frame or a guess when Caltrans would be on 203? Honestly, I haven't heard anything from them on the timing. It's always a surprise when they show up and get the work done.
8:39 We reach out to them and try to do our best according to them, but they've got a lot of land to cover and a lot of different priorities. So I haven't heard anything. I don't have an ETA when that work's going to be done. And I've got to put you on the spot with that one. So thank you. Thank you. Any other questions or comments for? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Hayes. Any other public comments? The one individual in the audience? No? All right. I'll close public comment now and we'll move on to our one and only business matter.
9:08 This is the opportunity for the public to provide public comment on the draft of the general plan housing and safety elements. And our staff contact today is Kim. Kim, would you care to take it from here? Sure. Thank you. So at your April 10th PEDC meeting, we requested the commission to consider an introduction to the general plan housing and safety element updates, which we refer to as the Resilient Mammoth Lakes Project.
9:37 We ask that you also provide any comments or feedback at that time. Today's meeting is intended to facilitate public comments prior to the close of the public comment period on May 10th this Friday at 5 p.m. And today is an opportunity for anyone that might prefer to provide oral comments instead of written comments on the draft documents, and it's an opportunity for
10:02 our commission to provide any comments or ask any questions on the draft documents and we can go through those. After that, staff will prepare responses to all of the public comments that we receive and we will include the comments and our responses in your PEDC packets when we bring this forward at a public hearing which we're anticipating on July 10th this year. We
10:33 We will also continue to accept public comments via email or letter until Friday. And to date we've held at least four public meetings for this project on April 10th. Let's see here. We held a public workshop on January 19th and at that workshop we set up different
11:03 And then on April.
11:30 10th, we had our PEDC introduction to the draft documents and we took comments at that time. On April 17th, we held a public workshop with the town council. Our consultant team attended that meeting. We have consultants from PlaceWorks who worked on the housing element and our project manager from Atlas Planning Group, Aaron Fannin-Steele, came to present on the safety element updates. And so that was a helpful workshop to have them there to kind of...
11:58 Describe the legislative requirements that we're now meeting through these updates. And now today we're opening this item up again for public comment and hopefully facilitating additional discussion. Just a note that we will have that consultant team here for the public hearings for July 10th when we bring this forward for public hearings. So if any kind of technical questions come up, we'll have the experts here in the room for that meeting. Great. Thank you.
12:26 Kim, no, I'm sorry, that backslide you were just on, how would you characterize the April meeting, especially the public, the workshops and the community workshop as well attended? The community workshop on January, I think it was January 19th, January 16th, that was well attended and we had a good amount of participation, really thoughtful comments we received at that workshop.
12:54 April 10th, I would say, was not very well attended, but we did receive some substantial comments from MLH and from Jennifer Halferty, her county supervisor, and today, not very well attended, but we have received additional comments on the safety element updates. Sandra and I both attended a Mammoth Voices meeting last week.
13:22 And kind of provided that opportunity for people to give us comments. And we have received a letter since then from the Sierra. I always forget if it's the Sierra Range of Light group or if it's the Sierra Club. But we did receive a letter from them as well.
13:39 And we have also pushed out this draft general plan housing and safety element to everyone who responded to the housing survey. We did a housing survey in 2017, which was really, really well. We had a lot of responses to it. So we sent it to...
13:55 About 400 email addresses last week, and I only got a couple of bounce backs. So it went out to a lot of people. MLH has sent it out to kind of their email group. The Chamber sent it out to all the business community. So this is kind of out there, and hopefully we'll get some more comments before the end of the comment period this week. Got it. And just to reiterate, the public comment period closes this Friday, the 10th. Correct. 5 o'clock. Correct. Thank you.
14:21 Right. And then so what we'll do is right now we're in that gathering phase, as Kim said, we're kind of gathering all of these comments. And what we'll do is take all of the comments and respond to them in writing. So when you get your public hearing packet in early July, it will have a table in there that has every comment and a response to every comment, either how it was incorporated or the answers and those types of things. Thank you. Thank you. Other than the two feedbacks that we've received from county supervisor and MLH.
14:53 Did you say there was only a couple other ones that came in, that trickled in? Just the Sierra Club. Yes. So we actually got two different letters from MLH. And then, so four letters total that we've received. At this point, I would like to ask if anyone from the public would like to approach with a comment. Sir? Donuts. No.
15:21 Is it time, is your presentation concluded? Yes, I was just going to kind of go through the next steps. Currently, HCD is reviewing the housing element update. We expect that their review will be completed by June 21st at the latest. And CAL FIRE is reviewing the safety element updates to ensure that we are meeting the SB 1241 requirements for addressing wildfire hazards. And we know that they are...
15:48 Working on that, and we are planning to schedule our public hearings for July 10th for PEDC and August 7th for Town Council. That concludes my presentation. Thank you, Kim. Thank you. I'd like to open it up to the Commission. Are there any questions for Sandra or Kim? Is there any reason why it seemed like all the workshops we had, there were zillions of people, and yet we don't, we have four letters? Is that unusual? Maybe we actually,
16:22 Captured all of their comments in the draft documents. Possibility. We may get more comments by the end of the comment period, and who knows, maybe when we actually come forward for public hearings. Sometimes when it's a workshop, people aren't that interested, but when it's actually the public hearing, that's sometimes when people come out of the woodwork. Although this has been very well published, it's been in the newspaper. Today's date was published in the newspaper for three weeks in a row. We sent it out to all of our, you know.
16:50 Email list, like I said, you know, so it's pretty, it's pretty well out there. So, you know, it may just be that, you know, people aren't interested in this at this point. I'm not quite sure, but I'd like to think that we just captured all their comments in these draft documents. I'd like to think that too. Yes. Any other comments or questions for staff from the commission? I have one. Oh, I'm sorry.
17:22 You mentioned that the state has the housing element draft. Did they provide any feedback? Not at this time. We're expecting to have a phone call with the Department of Housing and Community Development here in the next couple of weeks. I forget the exact date that we were planning. I don't think we have a date yet. We don't have a date set. But it should be in the next couple of weeks, we would anticipate, and their review should be.
17:54 Completed by June 21st at the latest. So we do expect to get some comments from them, and we'll have a good idea of what those are in, I would say, the next month. And then we would incorporate those comments into the public hearing, the draft that we bring back to the commission in July. So in our consultant, the consultant that we have for this project does housing elements across the state, so they're kind of really in tune into what the HCD.
18:21 comments on so they've been working with us to try to make sure that we're kind of answering the questions that they've heard on other housing elements in this draft document so but we don't know what the comments will be from HCD but we would we would incorporate those and then we submit once the once the projects once the
18:37 Housing element is approved by the council, then we submit it to HCD for final approval. So right now they're kind of looking at the draft and then they get the final. And as long as the final document that we submit to them after council approves it is substantially compliance, it's usually not an issue for approval with HCD. If we make big changes, if something kind of really big changes, we would just explain that to HCD, talk through that with them to see if we needed to kind of go back and go back through, you know, a process with them again.
19:06 Usually it's just as long as you're in substantial compliance, it's approved by HCD. Is it possible to get for us to review, to see the couple of additional comments that came in from like Sierra Business Council or is that the name of the entity? Sierra Club. The local Sierra Club. And then two from Mammoth Lakes Housing. I think we're the two. Because I think we just have one from Mammoth Lake Housing on April 10th. That was the letter that we received, but I don't recall receiving another one.
19:36 I thought that Jennifer Halperty had asked me to circulate her letter to you, and I believe I did forward it to the Commission. So that's from the supervisor. Right. So you're saying MLH. She used to run MLH. The two from MLH, one is from Patricia, one is from Jennifer. No, we had one from Patricia on April 10th, and then we just had another one from Patricia.
20:03 Last week, I think. So two comments from the same person, and then also a comment from Jennifer Halferty, and then a comment from the Sierra Club. And we're happy to email those comments out to you. They will be in your packet for July, so all of the public comments will be included in that packet, along with a summary sheet that explains how we're responding to all those comments. If I may, I would like to see the additional comments made by MLH.
20:30 From Patricia specifically? Just MLH comments to you? And also from Sierra Club. Okay. We'll send all the comments out to you. Okay. In Section 5 of the housing element, you have a bunch of tables. You had a table of 5-47, and there was things that were either amended, deleted, or included in the 2019 housing element update.
21:03 When you say deleted, was it deleted from what exactly? It's just referencing the previous housing element to the current housing element. So it's, I think what it's saying is that it's something that was, yeah, that we're saying amend, delete or include in this.
21:21 In this next housing element. So if something has already been done, so if it's an action item that we've completed, we're saying delete that. You don't need to include that in the next housing element because that item has been completed. That's what that means. Okay, I got it. All right. And I'm going to move to the wildfire document. What is this? The safety element. The safety element. On page 40 of 51.
21:55 And that is tips and resources page. So are we talking about the CEPA document or the vulnerability assessment? This is... Which attachment, Paul? Attachment three or four? 2018, final recommendation for Town of Mammoth Lakes, CEPA for a while. It was prepared on October 31st, 2018. And I just lost my place. So I think attachment three. Yes. Page 40 of 51. Maybe I'll go.
22:57 We're just pulling it up as well. You said attachment four? Three. Attachment three. Attachment three, page 40. Okay, we're there. In your first paragraph, at the end of it, you said, some of the resources listed below may already be
23:52 In use by local stakeholders. And I was confused by this. They either have or they have not. So are we just... I think that's just a disclaimer because the CPOC group is identifying sources and resources for funding any future projects. And I think what they're saying is, you know, we've listed these items, but some of these might already be... But what I'm saying is if...
24:26 CEPA, the group itself, they would know, right, that we have utilized these various entities, grants, organizations for their purpose, so either they have or they have not. So they're saying, so when they say may already be used as if they don't know whether, which organization they have work with. So CEPA was a grant to the town.
24:55 And they helped us organize all of this data. But what they're saying is that the town, MLFPD, and other local partners, so kind of a broad list of local partners rely on this grant funding. So they didn't go through to the town, MLFPD, and all of our local partners to determine who's using what grants. But they're just saying these grants are out there. Some of you may or may not be using these grants now, but be aware that these are grant opportunities. I think that's what that's trying to say. I see. Okay.
25:25 All right. And when did you say Cal Fire is going to provide their feedback? I don't know what the deadline is or when Cal Fire is approved. They have a 90-day review period that they get. So from what we understand from our consultant is they don't usually take the full 90 days, but we did build that into the time frame, and they've started their review before April 10th.
25:58 So, you know, their review would have to be completed before we... Before our July meeting. Right. Got it. Okay. But we're not certain. We haven't heard back, you know, when they anticipate completing their review. Okay. But we've worked with CAL FIRE as we've developed this document, so I think we anticipate if we do have comments that they would be minor in nature. Okay.
26:26 Because Cal Fire participated in that whole CEPA program. We actually had a Cal Fire staff member who was here who attended all of the meetings and helped us formulate all of these recommendations. So this has been a really integrated process with Cal Fire. So I think we don't anticipate any major comments from them. Okay. All right. That's all I have. Thank you. Greg? Jennifer? I have a quick question on the housing element. And this, I apologize, may kind of come out of left field.
26:58 I haven't had a chance to dig into it as extensively as I plan to by Friday. I'm wondering, though, I did not notice anywhere in there, and I'm wondering if it's applicable, some of the affordable housing credits that are out there in the undeveloped commercial lots in town. For example, the one with the Yotel that was inherited from the Interwest previous ownership. Is there a place for that to be built into? I know you've got a couple of...
27:27 Tables that list the summary of affordable housing, different places in town where affordable housing can be built in the future. I'm wondering if there's any way we can get a handle or an idea or just a basic number on the amount of credits that are still out there.
27:44 I mean, we have all that data, and I can send that to the commission on what credits are out there. And I think it's a good question for our consultant, though, about we have these housing credits, should that be included in this document. But I can send the housing credit information to the commission so that at least you have what's out there. I can't remember off the top of my head how many credits we have, but there's a significant number of housing credits out there. And just to note that those housing credits were...
28:12 Generated by construction of affordable housing units or donations of land. So projects that have occurred and have been on the books and functioning for years are what generated those credits. So it's not just like these are just kind of, I mean, they are numbers out there, but they are numbers that are tied directly to the provision of land or units. But I will send you the information on that so you have that. Got it. Thank you.
28:39 Yeah, and also the response from the consultant. I'd be interested to hear if it lives in this dock or if it does not live in this dock. We'll include that as a comment that will be in the comment responses section to the July 10th packet, so we'll include that. Okay. I'm sorry if I have just no problem because you just mentioned about affordable housing and I recalled in the page 124,
29:09 of the housing element. It talked about MLH and the type of programs, housing that they have provided. And I don't recall this particular document talk about the, maybe not deficiencies, not the right word, but some of the de-restricted units have been, we have lost track of some of those units that we don't know where they are.
29:44 Even in terms of ownership? Correct. And so we don't know if some of those de-restricted units have since become a market rate housing. So is that something that we should incorporate in this document? As you know, that's clearly, you know, we funded those, we funded those housings.
30:15 For the community, however, I guess it's been many years, I guess, from what I heard was that we don't have, we don't have our hands on what happened to those de-restricted units.
30:28 And there is, and I don't know the exact section, but there is a section that talks about the deed restrictions, talks about the actual, the language in the deed restrictions, ensuring that those, and it might be an action or a policy item that talks about maintaining the current deed restriction language so that people can't get out of those as easy as they had in the past. But we can include that as a comment and include additional information or respond to that as part of the final packet. Okay. Thank you.
30:58 Senator, do you remember just a rough percentage of how many of those deed restricted units were lost to people removing the title? I don't know off the top of my head. I don't think it's a big percentage. My guess would maybe be 10%. And that was really due to the market, the shift in the market, that ultimately those deed restrictions were when the market...
31:23 Tanked that the deed restriction, the cost of the unit was higher than the market rate. So I think there were issues where it basically flip-flopped with those deed restrictions that were built and deed restricted at a really high market value. And then the tenants, the owners said, well, we can't even sell it at that. We've got to sell it at even lower. So there were some issues with that. There were some issues with the way the deed restrictions were written that allowed people to get out of those deed restrictions.
31:49 More easily. So, but, but I would say as a guess about 10%, but we can look into that number and have that number for the final document. Have the ones that were written at the same vintage been modified or addressed?
32:05 So as they come up on the market, if we have ones that were of that vintage, we do record new deed restrictions when they're sold. So if a unit comes up, MLH has the first right of refusal for those units. That's part of the deed restrictions. And so the town works with MLH to use our revolving loan fund to purchase those units back to preserve that deed restriction. So basically we would purchase, use the first right of refusal to purchase that deed restricted unit and then record a new deed restriction when it's resold to a new owner.
32:36 In the language that's written in the new document, I'm assuming that it's more uniform. There is no continuity between these housings, these units, even though they may be located in different parts of the town. Yeah, I think generally the language is the same. There may be something with HOAs if there's something a little bit different, but yeah, the general language is the same for the deed restrictions. Thank you. That's all I have.
33:09 Anyone else in the commission? Any questions for staff? Last chance public, public comment. All right, I'm going to close public comment on the draft general plan housing and safety elements. Thank you, Kim. We'll move on to the consent agenda. I believe Sandra has...
33:29 Oh, yes. So we are requesting to pull item two off of the agenda. We will reschedule that for another meeting date. It's not a public hearing or anything, so it doesn't need to be renoticed. And likely we will include it on the special meeting that the commission is having next Wednesday, May 15th. On that consent agenda, we'll add it to that item. Okay. So that leaves the minutes of the April 10th meeting the only thing on the consent agenda. I will honor a motion. I'll make a motion to approve.
33:59 The minutes of April 10th, 2019, of our regular meeting. I'll second. Vote. We're all in favor? Aye. Aye. Closes a consent agenda. Any commissioner reports? Start from the far right? No. Well, Jennifer and I had the opportunity to take a look at the upcoming Project 540. I think that's the name of the project.
34:29 for the purpose of design review, and overall, it was, you know, we have consensus as to, you know, what the products should look like, and at this moment, the applicant is making some additional modification to it, and we'll be hearing, I'm sure we'll be hearing the project probably in May, in June, or? June. Okay. Forgive me, but where is the 540 located? Right between...
34:56 Is it Oak House? It's Sierra, right next to Sierra Center Bar. Got it, got it, got it, got it. The snow storage lot. Got it. Yeah. Matt nailed it. I have nothing to add, Paul. Summed it up pretty clearly. Okay. The Mobility Committee has not met recently, so I have nothing to add there.
35:19 A couple of personal things. I'll just say that I believe the mountain, Mammoth Mountain, has shifted over to spring hours of operation, opening at 7.30, closing at 2, if I'm not mistaken. The latest date I've heard for the lower section of the zip line is the 25th of May. And Little League, Mono County Little League Baseball has started. Go out and support the kids. It's a nice afternoon. So that's my commissioner report. Thank you. Thank you.
35:48 Thank you. So for a director's report, a couple of items. As I mentioned, the commission has a special meeting next Wednesday, May 15th at 9 a.m. Since due to some conflicts on the Yotel pad project, we had to reschedule that item. So we'll have that meeting next Wednesday.
36:05 And then I did send an email out and also a meeting request for a joint meeting with the town council on June 26th. So I've heard back from some of you that some of you can make it, some of you can't, so just keep that on your calendar if you can make it. And the purpose of that meeting is to get an update on the parcel progress and to talk about the development objectives for the parcel. So we've kicked off the conceptual land use planning process for the parcel. We've hired Lisa Weiss Consulting. Jen was here.
36:35 I think at your last meeting and had a couple comments during director's report. Jen's actually here now conducting interviews for interested parties. So kind of a variety of different people in the community are participating in these interviews, government agencies, schools, hospitals, those types of things. And we are kicking off, we have a new tool on our webpage called Engage Mammoth Lakes, and it's a public engagement tool. So we'll be kicking off that engagement tool in the next couple of weeks.
37:04 So we'll be sending that out to the Commission.
37:20 So you can participate. And then basically on the 26th, you'll hear results of all of those questions, kind of how that went, the next steps, we'll be talking through all of that. So I think it'll be an exciting meeting on that project. Any questions on that? None from me. And then we updated you on the sidewalks, and I think that was all I had on my list here. If I might ask, which commissioners can't attend the 26th?
37:50 On the 26th. Well, Greg is conflicted out of the parcel. Got it. So can't attend, and then Commissioner Chang, I think you're not quite sure at this point. Maybe at this point. I got it. I responded with tentative. Right. Got it. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. With that, I'm going to adjourn the May 8th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, and our next meeting is May 15th, next week, 9 a.m., same place, here in the Sweet Z. Thank you. Thank you. I hope we all make it.