Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2019
Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 4 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
127 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:08 One minute to go, guys. All right. I'd like to call to order the May 15th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. We'll open with a roll call. Commissioner Chang, Commissioner Eckert. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Would you all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? Jessica, would you care to please? Sure.
1:14 Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. I would like to point out that Vice Chair Burroughs and Commissioner Chang will not be attending today because of a conflict with our public hearing matter. So at this time I'd like to welcome anyone from the public who would like to...
1:42 Come up to the podium for public comment, maybe on matters that do not pertain to anything on the agenda today. Please come forth. All right. I will close public comment and we'll move on to our first public hearing matter, which is consider approval of the Yotel Pad project consisting of vesting tentative tract map 18-003, use permit 18-005, and design review,
2:18 18-006 for a mixed-use condominium hotel project with 198 bedrooms within 177 units located at 6042 and 60 Minaret Road, including finding the project to be in conformance with the subsequent program environmental impact report that was prepared for the 1999 North Village Specific Plan Amendment.
2:46 Pursuant to the CEQIC guidelines, and I do believe that our staff contact today is Nolan. Great, thank you. The Yotel Pad Project site is a mixed-use condominium project proposed for three parcels within the North Village specific plan area. It's located at the northeast corner of Main Street and Minaret Road, and the overall project site is approximately 2.6 acres in size.
3:16 The project is bordered to the south and the west by State Highway 203, which does add an additional agency that they have to work with on the permitting and approval of the project. As noted, the project is within the North Village specific plan area, and within that it's in the Resort General or RG zone. The current uses on the site include a sales office, Nevada's restaurant, and vacant land to the north.
3:42 They are bordered to the north by the Alpenhoff Lodge, Petro's and Clock Tower Restaurant, to the east by Viewpoint Condos, and to the west is Mammoth Brewing Company, the Eatery and Fireside Condos. The proposed project is a new mixed-use condominium hotel development with a total of 177 units, and within those 177 units, there would be 198 bedrooms.
4:11 Our project includes 156 studio and one-bedroom units within a five-story structure, 21 two-bedroom townhome units within two buildings along the north and east sides of the site, approximately 4,100 square feet of restaurant and lounge space, a large outdoor patio area that can be used by the restaurant or the hotel project near the southwest corner of the site, understructure parking for up to 187 vehicles,
4:40 and nine oversized vehicle spaces along the north side. And also it has numerous pedestrian connections to Minaret Road and throughout the site and are proposing a new sidewalk along the western property frontage adjacent to Minaret Road. The project is branded as micro units meaning they have smaller living spaces that are then accompanied by a variety of amenity spaces throughout the site.
5:08 The application review process, the application was received by the town in November 2018. Staff's initial review provided some issues and other items they needed to address as provided in December of 2018. The project was reviewed by the town's advisory design panel at two meetings in January and February. There was also a public workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission and the public in February of 2019.
5:38 Since those workshops and ADPs, the APKIN and staff have been working on various issues and design features of the project. And now we're up to May 2019 with the public hearing before the PEDC. The project is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act and it was determined that the project was in conformance with the existing subsequent
6:10 Program Environmental Impact Report that was prepared for the 1999 North Village Specific Plan Amendment. A program EIR was prepared for that North Village Specific Plan Amendment and the purpose of a program EIR is to utilize that environmental analysis for future projects that conform with what was analyzed in the program EIR or to provide the opportunity to tier off of that EIR. Since this project is consistent with all applicable development standards of the NBSP,
6:39 And within the scope and intensity of what was analyzed in that existing program, EIR, it is determined that no new environmental compliance document is required pursuant to the CEQA guidelines. That analysis is detailed in the CEQA conformance review as included in the staff report packet. The project was reviewed for consistency with the town's general plan.
7:06 It was determined that the project is consistent with the general plan land use designation for the North Village specific plan because the project is a mixed use condominium hotel use that will provide resort oriented lodging residential uses and has a variety of amenities intended to enhance the visitor experience and support long term visitation. That is consistent word for word with the vision for the North Village specific plan area.
7:33 Additionally, the project was found to be consistent with all applicable general plan vision statements, goals, policies, and actions. This is detailed in the general plan consistency analysis included in the staff report. Part of staff's analysis included a review of the project's consistency with the North Village specific plan and all the development standards. The use, as indicated before, is a resort-oriented lodging project.
8:05 The number of bedrooms is 198 bedrooms and the maximum number allowed is 198.25 bedrooms. The site coverage is below the maximum permitted allowance of 75%. The proposed site coverage is 73%. The building area is significantly below what is permitted in the NVSP. The North Village specific plan allows a maximum 2.0.
8:32 And the proposed FAR is approximately a 1.14. Additionally, the building heights are consistent with what is, or within, are consistent with the building envelope permitted by the NVSP. The setbacks within the NVSP are a little different than other standard setbacks and are measured along Minaret Road and Main Street from the center line of the street.
8:58 And then from the property lines for the north and east sides. And as shown here, they do conform with all of the applicable setback requirements. Parking for the project is required to provide at least 1.05 parking spaces per key. So that would require a minimum of 186 stalls. And the proposed number of spaces is 196 spaces. It is important to note that they are proposing to use valet parking for the majority of the parking.
9:28 within the structure and the site. And the project has satisfied their housing mitigation through the use of the existing housing credits that are associated with this site. Going into a little more detail on parking and circulation, as noted, they are required to provide parking for 1.05 spaces per key. The requirement in the North Village, when you look at the parking table, is one space per unit.
9:59 And that .05 is intended to provide additional parking for employees, other uses on the site, such as restaurant uses, as well as in the event that guests arrive with more than one vehicle. So as noted, the proposed would have 196 spaces equals approximately 1.11 spaces per key.
10:21 They are proposing to use valet services to park the hotel guest and the restaurant uses. And the parking plan and valet analysis was reviewed by an independent parking consultant. And their estimate, based on occupancy, how guests would be arriving and looking at other hotel projects they've done, is that there would be a surplus of 17 spaces during the very high peak periods.
10:46 A surplus of 116 spaces during the off-peak period with an average of 85 excess spaces during the peak periods. This is, again, because not all guests will be arriving by vehicles. Some would be arriving by flights and other means. Delivery truck parking is envisioned to be kind of near the northwest corner of the site with trucks would be...
11:12 Backing into this pullout area here and unloading their goods for the restaurant and the hotel. It is important to note the final delivery and operational plan is required to be reviewed by staff prior to building permit issuance for this. So they need to provide a detailed plan of how they're going to ensure that trucks aren't parked out on Minaret Road or otherwise blocking traffic. Bike parking is required to be provided throughout the site. There are short-term bicycle racks.
11:41 And then within their parking under structure, they have a storage area that during winter will be used for ski storage and during summer would be used for bicycle storage. Also important to note, emergency access for the site has been reviewed by the fire district and also reviewed with Caltrans for their sign-off. The plan would be for emergency access in the front of the site near the Port Cashier area to be
12:13 They would pull in here and approximately right in this area there's an emergency egress that'll be gate controlled with access. The fire district would have access to it. So they would pull out through that egress over a rolled curb out onto Minaret Road. And for the interior of the site they would be pulling into here and there's turnaround areas that meet the fire district standards located within the central common area.
12:40 Again, this was reviewed by the Fire District and Caltrans and they are good with the proposal. Tree removal and mitigation, the site, since it does require a large amount of excavation for the park construction and other uses, does require removal of the majority of the trees on the site. Based on their tree removal plan, it's approximately 114 trees.
13:06 Their preliminary landscape plan shown here on the screen right now is proposing approximately 50 trees throughout the site. An arborist did provide a report that he went out and walked the site analyzing all the trees on the site. And his recommended mitigation would be for 30 trees, the remainder being either dead, dying, damaged, or considered overstocked, meaning there's just an overabundance of trees. The final mitigation requirements are required to be determined by the
13:35 Director prior to tree removal. So we will look at taking into consideration the arborist report, the proposed landscaping plan, and come up with the final number that they need to mitigate. View analysis within the North Village Specific Plan, the North Village Specific Plan EIR as well as the general plan has a strong emphasis on protecting major view corridors and vistas. And those view corridors are identified as the Sherwins and the Knolls.
14:08 Alpkent did provide view analysis looking at four different locations along Minaret Road as well as the view coming up Main Street looking at it near the corner of Viewpoint Road and Main Street and then looking at it from the intersection of Main and Minaret looking to the northeast. The impacts of the Sherwinds as shown really because of the curve of Minaret Road and the location of the project kind of set back on the site.
14:35 Really have no impact on the views of the sure winds when you're right up against it. It will affect some of the views of the foothills of the sure winds, but the primary peaks and those remain unobstructed from the project. Also shown here on the right side of the screen is the view analysis at Viewpoint Road looking at the project site.
14:58 It is important to note that the general plan and other town documents only protect the public views. They don't take into consideration private views for the analysis of projects. Housing mitigation, as noted, the site has 40.41 full-time employee equivalent credits. This was provided...
15:23 The previous owner of the site, they had developed and donated the land for the Aspen Village Apartments. In exchange for that donation of land, they were provided a number of housing credits that then were divvied up to that owner's property. So some went to the Snow Creek properties and this 40.41 went to this site. Town Council
15:45 is working to establish the value of these existing credits and they have reviewed a draft housing credit value policy. It's a little hard to see. I just put it up there more to show the complex calculations that were used in determining that value. It came up with at least initially a draft value of $14,571 per credit. So that one for the value of the Yotel pad credits would be a value of $588,814.
16:13 And if they were to pull their building permit today and pay the current housing fee, their housing fee payment would be $462,500. So there would be some remainder in their value, which then they would retain as credits an equivalent amount based on that $120,000 value. As credits they could then transfer or sell to another project potentially.
16:39 But I think the credits would be retained as FTEEs, not as a dollar value, right? Correct. So they'd be FTEEs because that value does fluctuate with as either the town's housing fee goes up or other factors in the table. If those change, it would affect that dollar value. For design review, the North Village specific plan primarily looks at site design and building design.
17:10 One of the important factors from that are the project was designed to take advantage of the natural topography of the site. The site slopes downward from the north to south. And so on the north side, the understructure parking is all subterranean with the building being right at grade. And then as you go to the south, there is a slight raise where the parking structure is approximately 10 to 12 feet above grade with then the building sitting atop that pad.
17:41 Also, the siting of the buildings, the lower townhome buildings are located to the north and east sides of the site. Those have a maximum height of 35 feet. That's designed to provide a buffer between the adjacent uses to the north and east. Also, the siting of the buildings with the main building going in a north-south configuration minimizes the shading to the adjacent areas within the project plans.
18:09 There's a shade analysis that shows throughout the year what the shading impacts would be to the site and off-site. Building design, the North Village specific plan encourages a varied building and roof forms, variation of materials, materials and colors appropriate to the mountain environment, and a mix of colors to create visual interest. As shown here on the building elevation, the building does have
18:37 Some building articulation of building setbacks and popouts to create that visual interest as well as changes in materials and colors throughout the project. The materials board is available up here as well by the table. Also, just to create some additional visual interest in the facade, they do have these angled pieces on the north and south ends of the main structure.
19:06 As noted, the project was reviewed at two ADP or advisory design panel meetings and the main concerns from the ADP were what the view is going to look like near the southwest corner of the site and how to reduce that impact or that visual impact at that corner. So they were really focused on how to bring the building or some elements of the building closer to the corner to create a more active pedestrian environment and also create a
19:35 A natural transition with the landscaping from the corner up to the site. So as shown here in the rendering, their plan is to really have the slopes of this going up to the site being very natural with a number of landscaping throughout. Then also with the restaurant area, there's a patio area as well as a lower multi-use area that can be used by the restaurant or by the hotel guests. So that's really intended to be a flexible space.
20:05 Thank you. Thank you.
20:33 Getting towards the end of my presentation, the required findings for the commission to consider approval of the project would be that the project's consistent with CEQA, the project's consistent with the state's subdivision map act, the findings for use permit can be met, and the findings for design review can be met. And staff's recommended action is to adopt the
20:58 Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution and approve the project with the conditions as recommended by staff. With that, that concludes my presentation. I know the applicants have a brief presentation as well for the commission. Thank you, Nolan. Before we ask the applicant to come up to the podium, do either of my commissioners have a question for Nolan or Sandra at this time? No. Would the applicant care to make a presentation or a statement?
21:49 Thank you. Any questions for the applicant at this time? When you have roughly 100 people working in here? When it's full? How many?
22:20 I believe we stated total staff would be potentially 34 at any given time would be in around 15 for the property. You have to remember this is a limited use or limited service property. We would have front desk staff and we would have periods of more intense staff within the mornings and afternoons with the maid service. But other than that, it's minimal front desk staff.
22:49 Minimal engineering staff, and then we would have staff, obviously, the restaurant would have staff, and then minimal staff serving at the bar, too. And, you know, if you're looking at a hundred people, you're looking at more of a four-star type of property. Jessica, any questions? At this point, thank you. I've got a couple of quick ones. First of all, in the presentation from Nolan, it sounded like you were factoring in
23:22 I do want to ask if you're aware of all the conditions set forth in the resolution.
23:51 Yes, we are. Okay. Specifically, I want to ask if you're aware of the condition concerning the hours of operation for the valet service. Okay. And the length of time throughout the calendar year. Yes. Okay. That's my only question at this time. Thank you. I appreciate it. I'd like to invite the public now to come up for any public comment they'd like to set forth. Full room and not a single opinion. If you wouldn't mind just...
24:31 Stating your name for the record, please, sir. Thank you.
25:57 to what the town regulations are. What a unique time for the town to listen to a developer who actually listens to what our regulations are. I think Chris and company are to be commended for that. We are concerned, we talk about views and we make believe that the mountains aren't the only views that we have. It's not true. We are a village in the trees. We need to maintain that.
26:29 And our biggest concern is the number of trees that will be taken down and what the replanting environment is going to be. We heard today about an arborist who has actually looked at and made recommendations. I think that's wonderful. That's the right thing to do. Now, we have 40 years of experience and viewpoint removing and replacing trees. We would like to participate in the process for that. So we'd like to review that arborist plan you talked about.
27:01 And I noticed in your review we talked about we're going to be replacing some trees with a two-inch caliper. I don't know what that means. I was hoping that would be explained here, but perhaps it could be explained outside this meeting, especially if we can participate somehow actively and proactively with the tree removal strategy. It is very, very important for a viewpoint.
27:28 We want to maintain the village in the trees concept. That is also why we ask for some views from what unfortunately the town interprets as private views. There's a misnomer here. Private view by your definition and my definition is a view from an individual unit. I agree completely with the proposition that private views need not be presented here.
27:58 What we're looking for is views from common area. The common areas are typically streets, and you would handle that, but we also want to see some visuals from common area, for example, our parking lot, where lots of people come, everybody comes to the parking lot, their first view of viewpoint is the parking lot. We'd like to see some depictions of what it looks like there, not because we're afraid of not seeing mountains,
28:26 We're afraid of not seeing trees. That's the reason why we have requested that kind of information. Second item we have concerns about is snow storage. Again, we would like to participate in your snow storage evaluation. Based on the information we have right now and our understanding, we believe that it's enough. There are mitigating circumstances which we talked to Chris about that we can do.
28:56 Okay, but we believe the current plan, I don't see how it's going to work. The statement made at the February 13th meeting was, we don't have a problem with snow removal because our flat flows, the snow is just going to blow over because of the southeast prevailing winds. That is true. It's going to blow over directly onto the location that we use for our snow storage. So it's a big issue for us.
29:26 Again, there are solutions. We just want to participate with the decision-making process in a cooperative and proactive way. That's all we request. If we don't want to challenge anything, just participate. I'm an engineer by profession. Another member of my board is also an engineer. And we have a lot of experience in construction projects with our operations manager.
29:59 We can, for the life of us, figure out exactly what the interface looks like between the Yotel Pet property and the Hughes property in terms of the retaining wall, the area that's going to be landscaped, the drop down into the hole where the patios are, and I have gone through the drawings as best I can. I requested a copy of the letter by 17, which Nolan was kind enough to provide me yesterday. I picked the dose. It is not.
30:28 We have a lot of confusion about that. I talked to Chris O'Reilly beforehand and we're going to get together hopefully at this meeting and we're going to try to clarify that.
30:57 But that's very important to us because that is the view that we are most concerned about. Not the mountains, village in the trees. From common area and from viewpoint road. There are no depictions. You have six items from Minaret Road looking at the project. You have one from Main Street. And you have none from viewpoint road and none from Alpine Circle.
31:26 Therefore, there's no way of confirming Village in the Trees with the existing visuals. That's a major concern of ours. Sir, I might ask that you maybe come to your conclusion. I have this one real quick. We believe the family parking philosophy is flawed. We believe that people are going to be parking on the adjacent property, including Viewpoint, including Alpenhof.
31:55 And we will all have to start taking protective measures against that, perhaps hiring guards, perhaps putting in gates or whatever. That is a significant thing for us. And that's basically what I have. But I do want to summarize. We want this project to go forward. All we want to do is participate in the tree removal strategy, participate in the snow storage and snow removal strategy, and talk about this.
32:28 Thank you very much.
32:58 Sir, I may? Thank you, sir. Any other public comment? I thought I saw another hand back there. Good morning, Kirk Schaubner from the Alpenhoff and your neighbors. To the other side, I'd like to key off of Commissioner Eckert's question, and that is my concern today. Chris, thank you. Everybody, thank you for the presentation. Very, very well done. And as I mentioned last,
33:49 Time we had a meeting. This is certainly a process and quite an undertaking that you're going through here. But I do have some concerns about the parking situation. And you had just spoke to limited services. What is your least common denominator when it comes to those peak times when you have?
34:16 Housekeeping, restaurant staff, maintenance staff on site because I too would echo Andy's sentiment about parking concerns. It's a problem as it exists right now with the village and it's only going to be exacerbated by the new project here. So I didn't know since the last meeting if there have been some measures to
34:46 Kind of mitigate that. Are you stepping back some of the services? But then that's not exactly in keeping with a four star plus concept to limit something, to throttle it back, if you will, to be able to give your guests what it is that they'd like. So parking, that's my concern. I think that's about it. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks.
35:25 Commissioner Sandy Hogan, local resident, and one who's very happy to see this development. Starting on the east side, I know that, you know, we've had half a village and they've been carrying the load for a long, long time and doing a very, very good job of it. And I am familiar with the North Village specific plan. I am. I do apologize. I did not read the resolution and the constraints on
35:54 Parking. So therefore I'm speaking not knowing exactly what's in there and I apologize for that. Parking is also a big issue everywhere in this town. And I know the presentation and the consultants have done their very best, you know, to comply with the North Village requirements, the North Village plan requirements. It's very obvious
36:25 For all of us that have been there, and I participated in the original North Village planning, not, you know, as much as now, but, and I totally supported the idea that transit would solve everything. I still believe that transit is a huge, wonderful thing that we have going for us, although it's still incomplete.
36:52 Years before, I lived in South Lake Tahoe for many years, and if any of you have ever been up there and watched the valet parking in the casinos or used it or whatever, I have some questions because when the staff was mentioned, I did not hear of any valet parkers. That's a great job, but one person can't do it 24 hours a day.
37:18 I don't know how many will be on in the peak period, but those are more employees that need parking, especially after we cease our transit service. And of course, I know that you guys are constrained by the plan. The plan is the plan. That's what we have. And I'm going to make some long-term comments because we need to do a couple of things before we move forward with anybody else asking for
37:48 You know, the parking that is inadequate. We need to start with a nexus study for, to collect fees, and I know Michael is well aware of this, we've talked about this briefly, and I'm sure Greg is, whatever, and I'm not sure, Jessica, I hadn't met you yet. We've got to do a nexus plan for parking, and just as we have for housing, we need to start collecting fees when we have inadequate parking.
38:15 There is inadequate parking for this site, even though it complies with the plan that you are, you know, constrained by. That shows that there's a great need for revision of the North Village specific plan specifically for parking. It only requires one parking spot for a gondola employee. Yeah? I mean, read the... Go back and read the parking. It is...
38:43 Absolutely inadequate. And we have already approved the hillside project to the southwest side to add additional employees, additional units, but not additional parking. We keep adding to the problem. So there are things that we need to lay down first before we develop the rest of that village, which we want to develop. But we need to make sure some of these holes are plugged. And listening,
39:13 You know, to the Alpenhoff, and I know the problem they've had, when you have to put on a guard during peak hours, that's an additional employee for them in parking requirements. So, you know, you have to look at it in the same way for viewpoint. Andy said that they had to put, you know, a guard on. So, well, I really applaud the project and all the work that's gone into it. I hope it's...
39:41 You know, who knows, maybe you folks will be employed for, you know, more projects. Parking is a problem. We can't ignore it anymore. So I urge you to take into account how many valets are going to be needed. Are they your, you know, 24-hour? What if I were staying there and I couldn't, I had to leave at 3 o'clock in the morning, can I get to my car? You know, those are the kind of things that valet parking has some real problems.
40:10 If you don't have valets, just go to the casinos up in Tahoe, you know, park in casino parking and see what happens, how many there are, how fast they run. It's a great job to keep in shape. Anyway, thank you very much and I hope we can solve this parking problem because it is...
40:34 Horrific and going to get worse if we don't start taking the stop. One reminder, the town owns the lot, the 38 space lot next to the Westin. We have approved plans for 300 spaces there. That's why we need to start collecting money now. That's town owned and ready to go if we just had the money. Thank you.
41:06 Anyone else from the public care to make a comment? Good morning, Commissioners. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. Yeah, we obviously support this project. We think, you know, it's a project that is certainly accomplishing the goals of the North Village Specific Plan where, you know, we want to focus our hotbed base. And, you know, just as a reminder to you guys, there's
41:43 Total, I think, its densities in the village is defined by rooms, and then if you equate that to beds, there's roughly, we always think in beds, in terms of beds, because that generates skiers as far as, you know, skiers that we have to deal with at the mountain. And the North Village specific plant area generates 6,400 pillows. And presently it's about, somewhere in the neighborhood of 40 to 45% developed.
42:11 In terms of the overall density that's defined in North Village specific plan. And this project will add 177 units, keys, and I didn't do the exact math, but it's, you know, it's going to yield 500 people, something like that. And I just wanted to let you guys know, I mean, right now with just current levels of business that we have at the ski area, you know, peak days, we're hitting 19,000 skiers on a holiday.
42:41 You know, in peak weekends in the middle of ski season. And we operate the bed base in the village, you know, the hospitality management at the west end and the village proper, as well as Juniper Springs Lodge over at the Eagle Base area. And, you know, on those days where we're, you know, hitting 14,000 plus skiers, we're maxed out on our occupancy. We're 100% booked. So I just wanted to...
43:08 Let you guys know, as much as you are the Planning and Economic Development Commission, you know, this project is vital to our economic sustainability and future and the needs for accommodating our guests, our visitors to the resort. And, you know, these are, you know, very needed units and we'll certainly, I think the project, the applicants done a terrific job of responding to
43:37 The concerns that were raised by the Architectural Review Committee, I attended those meetings, and I think they did a wonderful job of improving the project overall, and I think it's going to be a real complement to the village as a whole. And again, I think the beds are very needed at this point. So, you know, some of the other benefits of the additional bed base obviously is going to be additional bodies in the village, which is going to help support the commercial businesses that are in the village.
44:06 Critical mass there in the village that's contemplated in the build out. So that's a good thing. I've mentioned before that this project has the potential to generate, you know, probably a million or even more than that in TOT annually, incremental TOT to the community. You know, this year we might hit 19 million in TOT revenues. We've been...
44:27 The last few years we've been hitting close to $18 million. This year will be, I think, a record year. This project will add another $1 million. So as we start to talk about these additional public needs for the community, I think the parking discussion, it's clearly the applicants meeting the requirements of the North Village Pacific Plan. I think the parking discussion is a bigger community-wide discussion that I think we're starting to address in the mobility initiatives of the town's walk, bike, ride.
44:56 I think it's clear the times come where the community's got to step up to the plate and start funding public parking and the development of structured parking in our key commercial corridors to support development that we want. And by virtue of the fact that we're going to be generating incremental TOTs with these type of projects, I think there's a case to be made that we can start directing.
45:22 Some of that, quote unquote, discretionary revenue we're generating now towards these important projects like public parking. As Sandy pointed out, the acre that's over there on the hillside and canyon, there's a plan that's been approved. I participated in that one as well that can accommodate up to 300 cars if we chose to build that. Not a cheap thing to build, but again, if this community wants to support our vision of our general plan and our specific plans.
45:50 You know, we need to participate in that investment and show the outside, you know, investors and people who are interested in developing our community that we're partners in this. And, you know, I think stepping up the plate to build public parking is a big part of that because those are always problems to get these big projects built. And you can't build parking for Easter Sunday and individual projects. It's just a failed way to plan and build your community. Let's see.
46:22 Yeah, I think that's all my comments. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else from the public? I will close public comment at this time, and before I pass it off to the commissioners for questions through either staff or the applicant, I'd like to invite the applicant, if you'd like to address any of the issues raised during public comment, this would be an opportunity. You're not required to by any means. Okay. Then I'll pass it over to my fellow commissioners for questions of the applicant or staff.
47:00 Jessica? Sure. Back to the parking issue, I'm not sure if this is a Sandra and Nolan question or for the Alpenhoff and Viewpoint folks, but for the point of comparison, do you know the parking density at the Alpenhoff and at Viewpoint Condos? Are they 1.05 or above that? The Viewpoint Condos is actually outside the North Village specific plan. I don't know offhand if they were to come in now, they'd be subject to...
47:29 Are mixed lodging residential zoning designation parking requirements, which look at number of bedrooms in the units. It's generally, yeah, Sandra's going to pull up the parking requirements for that use for residents. I just can't remember offhand. As far as the Alpenhoff, again, it was, I believe, correct me if I'm wrong, developed prior to at least the current version of the North Village specific plan, and I don't know offhand what their actual number of parking spaces are. But they obviously were subject to a different set of standards when they
48:01 Originally built. And the Westin is above the one point, or it's right at the 1.05? The Westin was actually approved slightly under the 1.05. The commission on the time looked at it and said with the valet operations, they were comfortable with approving it slightly under the 1.05 requirement. Okay, thank you. I'm not sure if this should go to staff, I suppose so, but the problem I've got with all this valet and all the parking and the
48:35 Agreed upon, you know, set in stone North Village plan is anybody that walks through the village any, you know, half the time knows that what we've got up there might meet the law, but it's inadequate. And, you know, I've done snow removal at Helios, Whiskey Creek, Novato's. They've all had to, you know, pay money out of their pockets to police their properties from the inadequate parking in the village.
49:02 And this is, to me, just extending that out for another, you know, that's a wonderful chunk of property. I'd love to see this thing developed. You know, that's probably the best piece of property in town. But making the parking up there worse is not where I think we need to go. And the idea of having 100% valet parking, I just don't think it's practical at all. I can't see it working.
49:31 And I don't see how this project isn't going to make that whole area up there worse. Do you have any questions? Any other questions for staff? Staff, is there a way that we can address valet parking now or in the future?
49:53 The resolution includes conditions of approval that require valet service, and I don't recall the exact condition of approval, but we require valet service most every day of the year for, I think it's from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m., is that correct? Correct, for Sunday through Thursday and 6 a.m. to midnight on Friday and Saturdays.
50:15 And then during those times when they don't have a permanent valet person, they would have the front desk people train to be able to go retrieve cars. So if someone, I think there was a comment at one point about someone leaving at 3 a.m., the front desk people would be able to go retrieve the cars for someone who's kind of leaving at off-peak times. So valet has been something that has been approved, as Nolan mentioned, for the Westin, for other projects. And this project does meet all of the minimum parking requirements, regardless of the valet.
50:44 in the parking garage. So I think that the valet service is just going to make it more efficient for people coming to the project. And just to respond to the previous question about the parking requirements for viewpoint, if they came in now, it's basically a sliding scale of parking based on the number of bedrooms. So for a one-bedroom unit, they required one parking space, two-bedroom units, two parking spaces, a three-bedroom unit.
51:10 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
51:42 The arborist report that comes in, the suggestions, how does that look and feel? Sure. So within the North Village specific plan, it talks about a one-to-one tree mitigation for trees over 12 inches diameter breast height. And then on top of that, it talks about, though, any trees that are being removed based on the recommendation of a qualified professional arborist.
52:13 That are either dying, otherwise damaged, such as beetle infestation or other damage, or what's known as overstocking, just more trees per what that area can handle, do not have to be mitigated for removal. And so we look to that, utilize the report provided by the arborist that says, based on my expert opinion, these trees are, there's...
52:39 X number of trees that are dying, X number of trees that are damaged or otherwise unhealthy, and then X number of trees that need to be removed just for overall forest health. And then that number we'll take into consideration, so we'll look at what they've provided, also look at what the North Village Pacific Plant as well as the Environmental Impact Report talks about for tree retention and replacement, and determine what the adequate number for mitigation is.
53:07 Responding to the earlier question about what a two-inch caliper is, that's the minimum requirement for replacement in this specific plan. So a two-inch caliper would be the width of the trunk of the tree at the height that's going in. We do have a condition that if they do come in with substantially larger trees, that on a case-by-case basis, the director can require less trees, meaning we want them to encourage to put in as big and healthy trees as you can obtain. Also, there's some challenges on
53:36 Getting those here and what you can physically buy and plant. But it does have that condition to encourage larger trees be planted. Got it. I guess my question was, when that arborist report comes back to staff, does that come back to the commission or is that an administrative decision on your side? Currently it's written as an administrative decision that we would review and determine that final mitigation based on their recommendations and then the plan.
54:04 Is there an opportunity for public review of that in any way? We can coordinate with members of the public. The decision, though, is an administrative decision by the director, so we're happy to talk to members of the public about it and work with them on that. And the director's decision is appealable to the Planning and Economic Development Commission, so if we met with the member of the public and they had some concerns about it, we made our decision, they could appeal that decision to the PEDC.
54:33 Got it. And that same process goes for the snow storage and removal? Correct. The final snow storage plan, their plan is to do interim snow storage for the driveway and port cashier area and then haul it off-site. The final plan does require a review by planning staff, public work staff, and Caltrans for that final plan to ensure that it's not going to impact the state right-of-way and it's going to function at the overall site.
55:01 And same process, though, for staff approval and any appeal. Got it. Okay. Then my last question for staff, and it goes back to the housing credit. So the remaining housing credit that this project is not using, you had mentioned that that could basically be sold like a commodity? Yes. To anyone in town? Are there any restrictions on that transaction? No. None. Okay. Thank you. Any comments, suggestions, deliberation?
55:37 Start that way. Actually, I was disappointed when you said there's only going to be 30 people working here. We're not just a Planning Commission, we're also an Economic Development Commission. And what we really need is more employees. We don't have, there's going to be more TOT, but how much of that TOT is going to be offset from someplace else to here is debatable.
56:06 And the way this project is designed, it's extremely efficient, but I don't see it providing a lot of local work. There's going to be a plumbing contractor, there's going to be an electrical contractor, they're going to string all these boxes together. But in terms of local workers here putting this project up, I don't see that much benefit. And I just can't get over the parking thing either. I really want to see something happen here.
56:36 We need a stimulus. We need to get the ball rolling in town, but I'm just not sure this one's it. Jessica? I appreciate all the comments from today. It's been really enlightening and learning about this project over the past couple months has been a lot to figure out, but I feel like we're getting there and I appreciate Sandra and Nolan and the staff's time figuring this out. I do think that it was revealing to me.
57:05 To know that the Westin's parking garage comes in under this amount and I personally haven't had issues with parking at the Westin. The village is definitely a challenge as a local to get up there for things but on the other hand I very rarely take the trolley which is a fantastic system so my own fault a little bit there. I am somewhat concerned about the parking more so on the side of
57:28 Having worked for the Chamber of Commerce, finding employees is by far the biggest issue that businesses here face, and I hope that you're able to find the right employees to do the valet parking and have that be a consistent thing. But I think if it works as planned, then it can be a similar situation to the Westin, and I like that aspect of it. The only other note I want to make is, I think, to Mr. Ott's comment about the village and the trees.
57:57 I would encourage the town and all of us to consider, as he said, that it's not just the mountains, it is the trees and the forest aspect, and that's what draws a lot of us to this community. It's not just those mountain vistas. Otherwise, I am looking forward to seeing this project and encourage the Yotelpad folks to work closely with Viewpoint. I think it's a small mountain community.
58:21 The benefit of working together as a community is the only thing that will make things happen. And so don't burn any bridges and keep things civil and work together. So that's all I have. Thank you. Yeah, I would like to commend the applicant. I think this is actually a project and an amenity that this town needs. I could say that from direct experience. I'm one of the people responsible for marketing and promoting this.
58:48 Destination around the world and I will say that a property at this level of quality and price point is something that we are definitely missing and we lose a lot of visitation to our competitive peer resorts around the world because of that. We have a lot of other properties and hotels and motels at different price points so I'd like to see something like this project and I like it where it's coming in.
59:13 I'd also like to commend the applicant for the work you've done with the advisory design panel in kind of amending your project. I think that speaks volumes to your willingness to be part of this community. So I compliment you on that. I'll echo what Jessica said. I would highly recommend that you continue to work with your neighbors, the viewpoint, but also your neighbors on the other side, the Alpenhoff. I think they have a legitimate concern about people
59:42 In essence, poaching their parking. So I'd love to see a strategy that you guys can come up with together with neighbors on both sides. I do want to say that the North Village specific plan, it does sound like it probably needs to be addressed and modified and updated. However, this applicant and this project is meeting the requirements laid out by the North Village specific plan. And I think you're actually 10...
1:00:08 Parking stalls above your minimum requirement. So it doesn't sound like a lot, but you're not completely lowballing coming in at the bare minimum. So I thank you for that. That's it for my comments on this project. If anyone is interested, I would definitely entertain a motion. So moved. Do you need to read it? Let me find it. It's up on the screen as well. Oh, brilliant.
1:00:40 I move to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA Subdivision Map Act and Municipal Code findings and approving vesting tentative tract map 18-003, use permit 18-005, and design review 18-006 with conditions as recommended by staff. Jamie, a vote? Can you get a second, please? Oh, my bad. Second. Mr. Eckert? No. Mr. Kennedy?
1:01:12 Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. So just to clarify, because there's only three of you sitting up there, I did follow up with our city attorney, Andy, and a two to one vote does approve the project. So there are different rules for town council versus Planning and Economic Development Commission, and a two to one vote results in the approval of the project. So the project's approved. The project is approved. Yes. Congratulations. Thank you for building it in our community. We appreciate that. That was it for
1:01:48 Public hearing. We now will move on to the consent agenda. So if the commission has any questions about the consent agenda item, we're happy to speak to it, but you can approve the consent agenda as just all one item. I do not have any questions on the consent agenda. All in favor of approving the consent agenda? Aye. Aye. Cassette agenda is approved. Do we need a motion? How about a motion to approve?
1:02:37 Second? I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you, Jamie. Commissioner reports. I know we kind of went over this last week. Jessica, you weren't here last week. Do you have any report you'd like to put forth? No report on my end. Thank you. And I hit mine last week. And I think, Greg, do you have anything you want to add to last week? Just people commenting about this. Director's report.
1:03:05 The only item I have, it was an item I mentioned last week, is that we have a joint town council meeting on June 26th to discuss the parcel. Commissioner Eckert is conflicted out of that item, so he won't be attending that meeting. But it sounds like we have a quorum, and we're just waiting to hear from Commissioner Chang on his availability for that day. So that would be in addition to your regular meeting, which is June 12th, I think. Right. Okay. That's all I have.
1:03:32 I will conclude that with closing the Wednesday, May 15th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Thank you for attending.