TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2019

Town Council

· recording 5 hr 24 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

731 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

4:06 Here, let me get my agenda packet out. That would be a good thing. That's a place to start. That would be the place to start. Blame it on MLT. Not mine. Don't need it. Okay. Okay, we will call the town council meeting for June 5th, the order. Roll call, please. Here. Yep. Here, all accounted for. And if we could have Stuart Brown lead us in the...

4:42 Pledge of Allegiance, please. Thank you. We're starting off with a really neat subject, council presentations. Oh, excuse me. Yeah, public comment. Anybody have anything that's not on the agenda, please limit your comments to five minutes. Thank you. Okay. Hello. Good afternoon. Shira Dubrofner from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation representing the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater and the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival.

5:31 Just a real quick on the theater, we have our last event of the season, our last production, which will be Hank Williams, The Lonesome Tour, and it's Jason Petty who's performed at the Grand Ole Opry and has been doing Hank Williams for over a decade and has won awards playing him. He has a one-man show February, I mean February, June 22nd.

5:54 And June 21st and 22nd at 7 p.m. at the Edison Theater. So hopefully, if you like Hank Williams, that might even bring Bill out. Please come out and support that production. We closed the film festival a week and a half ago, and each year it gets bigger and better. I'm really proud to announce some of our numbers.

6:17 We used a new platform called Eventive Ticketing Site, and it has great analytics that we're able to capture all the information of how many people are unique, how many people are unique to the area, and we have a total of, so through that system, we calculated over 2,500 tickets.

6:40 And had another 600 tickets that did not go through the platform for some of our parties. We didn't scan people in. So we had over 3,100 tickets. With that, you know, many people go to multiple events. And we had approximately 500 unique pass holders. That means with those 3,100 tickets.

7:00 At least 500 of them came to were individual people. We also, from the analytics, were able to find out that two-thirds of them were at least from outside the area. So we brought in a lot of people. A lot of people stayed at least four nights. So we're talking a few hundred thousand dollars in...

7:21 TOTs, I mean, not TOTs, but money spent in the community, which does go to TOTs. A lot of them have to stay at hotels and don't have kitchens, so they are buying food. We had a lot of partners with the film festival for restaurants that gave 15% off to pass holders, and they saw an increase in business. Even Kitchridge was saying that they noticed a lot of filmmakers in town from the festival that it's really grown.

7:48 What's happening is people are starting to see the difference in a rise of visitation specifically for that. We had a lot of people fly in. A lot of the flights were sold out. And especially midweek, we had people coming in on Wednesday and Thursday, midweek for that entire weekend.

8:07 More money that comes into the town because of the film festival. Also, we had, I got a phone call today. We had some great attendance. We had Variety here. We had Hollywood Reporter, LA Times. We had a company called A24, which is a major distribution company in the independent film world, which distributed and produced.

8:27 Moonlight, which was the Academy Award winning film for 2017 and took it away from La La Land, if you all remember that event that happened. And he sent me a really amazing email thanking me and telling me that he goes to many of film festivals. Most of the film festivals that they send him to are like Tribeca and Sundance and really big film festivals. And he said to quote, I've been to many a festival. Yours is top notch.

8:55 So that was a huge pat on the back. And I didn't ask for that. So that was unsolicited. And he wants to come back. And I think the biggest thing that puts film festivals on the map, it's, you know, it's great to have stars. And we brought these grounding alumni, which Sherry Oteri from SNL and Julia Sweeney from SNL and a few other people. But what really makes a festival make a difference in the festival world is having a sale.

9:22 That means having a film, an independent film come to your festival and it gets bought because of your festival. We do take partial credit for a film that got sold and is a hot film on Netflix which is called Abducted in Plain Sight that we premiered and nobody was playing that film until we played it and gave it an award and then that gave them the legs to go to other festivals and then get a deal with Netflix.

9:47 I got a call today from CAA, which is Creative Artists Agency, and they wanted to see three of our documentaries that we've screened. So I think that with us being so young and things like this happening is solid proof that not only are we creating a product that is viable and important within the industry, but it also is...

10:08 contributing to the economy of the community, and we are definitely climbing up the ladder very quickly. So it's something that I'm really proud of, and we will continue to stay on that track. And we brought in people from all over the world. We had another filmmaker already talk to Alicia Venos about

10:29 Shooting a film in the area. We also brought in people that, you have to remember, all these people are going on excursions throughout the day and taking pictures in our area and then posting on Facebook. So the amount of impressions and marketing benefits that we're getting from the film festival is priceless. John Urdi, you should, you know, split me something.

10:52 But on a serious note, it really is having a huge impact on all levels, and I hope that you can really truly see how the Measure U money doesn't just go to a program, but really filters and has a trickle-down effect into the economy. So I want to thank you so much, and I'll keep going. Thank you. Any questions?

11:16 No, but thank you very much for that. One question I did have, I did notice is that I know like Comic-Con sells passes, but then what has happened is that when the passes sell out that in other words, are you, is the film

11:32 Film Festival working to the point now that if you don't buy a pass that you may not be able to get in movies in the future? You don't have to answer that right now, but that was something that kind of went through my head. That's the goal. That's the goal that most festivals want. I mean, we're not at that point yet. Oh, okay. I mean, the fact that we bring in so many people from around the world and they're coming to this community just for the festival and then they're...

11:54 They're discovering this landscape for the first time is really what's kind of snowballing into another effect. But yeah, I think that... And also, you know, we got many grants and many supporters. The Tambor Foundation is the one that gives us a grant to house all the filmmakers. And so we spend a lot of money on housing them. And you see that in my budget, but it does come from the Tambor Foundation. Also, we...

12:22 Oh, my God. I forgot what I was going to say. That's okay. I'm sorry. Thank you so much, and that was wonderful to see, and I actually got phone calls about it as well, so thank you so much. Public comment? Oh, here we go. Haisal Pays, Engineering Manager, the Department of Public Works. Bear with me. I've got to get my visual aids up. I'm going a little bit out of order.

12:52 Because we're going to do department updates at the end. So I want to give an update on operations up at Reds Meadow Lakes Basin. And I'm joined with Gordon Martin Forest Service to kind of talk about the work going on. So up to the Vista, Caltrans, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area have worked together. They've been able to get all the way up to the gate, which you can see clearly here next to the Forest Service structure.

13:19 There's still a healthy amount of snow up there. We do not anticipate getting to work on that as a town anytime soon. We'll probably start evaluations next week, but there's still a good eight feet on the road. And we've heard rumors that it's starting to turn black down by Agnew. So we don't have an anticipated date on which we will be getting to work up there as there is a significant amount of snow. Our crews did start working today on the lakes basin.

13:44 I talked to Todd Murphy earlier today. He's got two blowers running right now. The snow, fortunately, is not full of ice, but it is extremely heavy, and the going is very, very slow. We think it's going to take a good week to a week and a half to get the basin just generally open. That would put us around, you know, end of next week sometime. While the road is going to be cleared and open,

14:09 We also, for the next couple weeks, want to let the public know that we are working back there with heavy equipment, and please do not go back there. In the five minutes I was taking two photographs and moving two cones, I turned away three sets of hikers that thought they were going to go back there and hit some trails. We put up a CMS board earlier today to notify the public that, you know, heavy equipment, snow removal operations, you know.

14:35 You know, probably not a safe place to go around. Now, obviously, we're not going to stymie public access if people want to, you know, walk on the snow and work around the equipment. That's their prerogative, but definitely want to bring attention to the fact that there are some operations going on up there. Even once the town gets the road open, it's actually the Forest Service that makes the decision on when to open the road. So I invited Gordon to come up and speak to that because it's really going to be his call as to when we swing the gate. I just wanted to let everyone know, as in past years,

15:07 Once the roads are clear, it'll be approximately two weeks, give or take, for us to get our infrastructure up and running. We have to get in there and remove the hazard trees. We have to get the water systems up and running and several other things, make any repairs to the road systems and other infrastructure that's out there.

15:35 That's about two weeks. So from the time that they finish their work, we might be able to sneak in a little sooner to start surveying for the hazard trees, but actually dropping them while their heavy equipment is in there is sort of contraindicated. Okay, so we're looking at two weeks out from maybe another week. So we're talking pretty much about three weeks is what it's looking like right now.

16:06 Three, three and a half, because they were talking a week and a half, and we're talking two on top of that, so. Okay, yeah. Well, thank you. I mean, it is what it is, and it's kind of a good problem to have in a way, so thank you for that update, because people are wanting to know that as well. Any questions? I'm sorry, I didn't hear that. The question from Mr. Boccia was, what is the impact on the half marathon? Oh, yeah.

16:34 I spoke with the half marathon folks and two years ago we ran a modified course up in the basin. The road will be clear and as a special event we'll be able to operate up there, but we will not be staging out a horseshoe like they classically do. They'll start somewhere around the Lake Mary Loop, run towards the horseshoe gate and then set a gore point and head back. So there's a contingency plan in place and I've been working with them on, you know, how we're going to set that up. Okay.

17:04 Thank you so much. Thank you. And thank you for those pictures. Okay, still open for public comment. Good afternoon, Town Council. I'm Patricia Robertson with Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I have just a couple of announcements. The first is that the Town of Mammoth Lakes was awarded a CDBG grant in July of 2018, and that grant was for homeownership loans and rehabilitation loans.

17:38 For households earning below 80% of the area median income, and that is $62,000 for a family of four. So Mammoth Lakes Housing, as the subrecipient, has been working with the town and the Department of Housing and Community Development to set up the grant, and I just wanted to let everybody know that we received authority to use grant funds recently, so those funds are now available to loan to the community. The rehabilitation loans are for health and safety improvements.

18:09 And there are a limited number of grants that are available to households that have where the homeowner is a senior, 62 and over, for households that are doing ADA improvements, and for households that are earning 50% of the AMI or below. So households that have extreme need for rehabilitation, there are some limited number of grants available through this funding.

18:37 Which was a total of $700,000. We are working with the town on a press release and an advertising strategy, so you'll be seeing that in the near future. My second announcement is that Mammoth X Housing was able to hire an intern through a collaboration or partnership with the California Coalition for Rural Housing.

19:08 So I'd like to introduce Jake Castro, who's our Rural West intern for the 2019-2020 program year. He's a first-generation college student who's currently studying liberal arts, math, and science at Cerro Coso Community College and pursuing a career in civil engineering. Civil engineering and affordable housing are particularly interesting to him because he's drawn to service and assisting others to achieve economic opportunity.

19:40 He's taking classes over the summer and hopes to graduate from Cerro Coso in December of 2020. He'll be working with us at Mammoth Lakes Housing part-time throughout the year, learning valuable skills in community lending, asset management, and affordable housing development. In addition, as part of the program, he will attend an intensive affordable housing training program at UC Davis, as well as professional conferences.

20:08 And so we're very excited to welcome Jake to our team. Hey, last chance for public comment. If not, we will go ahead and move on. Here we go. Mark's going to saunter up there. First time I've ever done this. I've been in Mammoth 37 years, and this used to be a church. Anyway, my name is Mark Coronado. You might have seen my plumbing truck running around Coronado Plumbing.

20:51 Every year I host a gathering of Porsche owners in Mammoth, and this year we're going to have, we started this group back in 19, let's see, 2010 I believe it was, and we started with four cars and we've grown to 100 cars now, so we're going to be hosting 100 Porsches.

21:22 Father's Day weekend. Yep. Anyway, I'd just like to thank, I had to write this down because I forget everything. I'd like to thank Cleland. I called her up and I told her we're growing pretty big and what can we do and she directed me to John Urdi and John Urdi directed me to Caroline Casey. I want to thank you all for everything you've done. I understand.

21:51 We used to display our cars as part of our show on the weekends, and we used to display them on the plaza at the village, and then they got pretty big, and then we could only allow 24 cars, and like I said, we had 100. So the town has been kind enough to close Canyon Boulevard from Hill Street down to the crossing.

22:22 From the Western. And they're going to close it, I think, for three hours, and we're going to display our cars. So it's going to be a public display on a public street. And I'd just like to thank you for allowing us to do that. Stu Brown also helped me out. Interesting thing about this group of Porsche owners, they come from all over. We had people come. We had a group.

22:52 A group come from Canada. We had a group come from South Carolina. A lot of them come from Las Vegas, Southern California, San Francisco. There's a Redwood region. There's about nine different regions that attend. It's about 100 people. And interesting thing that you might find interesting, I know I did. We had a big group and we asked.

23:17 The group, how many of you have never been to Mammoth? And half of these people raised their hands. They've never been to Mammoth. And I had one guy call me and said, what is Mammoth? And I told him it's a little town. He said, is there a place to eat or something there? He told me you have to come up, check it out. So anyway, again, I'd like to thank the council for offering to close Canyon Boulevard. It's going to be a great, it's going to.

23:45 Thank you very much. Thank you.

24:15 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

24:39 Oh, and Mark, really quickly, Mark, really quickly, could you just tell the date where people can go out and see the cars if they wish to? Oh, it's going to be Father's Day weekend. It starts on Friday. Saturday, we're all going to gather at 8 a.m. in front of the Base Camp Cafe. If you want to see all the Porsches, they usually go to that event because from there we're

25:09 Drive down the Highway 120, Benton Crossing Road. You go down and we go up north all the way up to the Mobile Mart, stop and take a break there. We come back down. We go through June Lake, come back down 395 through the Scenic Loop. And these guys, when you see them get out of the car at the Mobile Mart, they're just ecstatic. You know, they've never seen anything like this, especially as people from the cities, you know.

25:38 So if you want to see the cars, we're going to be on display on Canyon Boulevard, Hill Street down from 4 till 7. 4 till 7. Yeah, and it's open to the public. Okay. So you see a bunch of neat cars. Thank you. Any questions? You're done. Yeah, thank you. Good to see you, Mark. Okay, public comments still open.

26:04 And seeing no one now, I will go ahead and move to item number two, excuse me, one, 20-year service recognition award to Recreation Supervisor John Connolly. And I believe Stuart's going to be. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of council, staff, and our community members. It's my distinct honor and privilege to recognize John Connolly for his 20-year service with the town in the Parks and Recreation Department.

26:40 For over 20 years as a recreation supervisor, John had to write this down because 20 years is a lot, so I apologize. John has created a really fun, authentic and award-winning programming. John started with the town as a recreation instructor in 1995, teaching self-defense classes along with a myriad of other recreation duties. In 1996, John was promoted to the team coordinator recreation leader position and in 1999 began his tenure.

27:09 Originally envisioned as one to three weeks of summer programming, summer camps have grown dramatically under John's leadership. Since 2010, summer camp participation has grown by an impressive 168%. I know John's not a numbers guy, it's all people guy. With the department now serving over 600 children every summer. One of John's favourite and most successful summer camps is the Wave Rave Concrete Commandos.

27:35 Partnered with Steve Claussen, this camp offers directed supervision, skill development, and a whole lot of fun on wheels at the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park and throughout the Eastern Sierra. Participation in our skate camps has increased by over 800% since 2010. Thank you primarily to John's passion and dedication to not only growing the sport, but designing and building the Shady Rest Skate Park, we all know that one, and the recently opened Crowley Lake Skate Park.

28:03 Being physically active outside is therapeutic and necessary for a better quality of life. With our unique and diverse East and Sierra landscape, John created unique and memorable experiences for each and every child that they will carry with them throughout their lives. On behalf of the entire Parks and Recreation team and town organisation, I would like to thank John for his commitment to building the successful summer camp program we have today and for leading and positively influencing our valued, dynamic and passionate team of camp councillors.

28:32 So thank you. Yay. I was going to say a few syllables. I was thinking about, you know, maybe bringing some fun icebreaker games tonight. But I heard these meetings go super long. So I just want to say thanks for the memories. Oh, thank you. And, John, you know what? We want to come down here and we all want to get in the picture with you. So, yeah. Congratulations. I'm so happy for you.

29:08 Let's get the family film here. Oh no, we want to get a family picture too. See you in the man. Come sit in the man.

29:53 Boy, I tell you, 20 years, that's something to definitely celebrate, so big thank yous to John. Now we will move on to item two, proclamation declaring June 19th as Elder Abuse Awareness Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

30:22 And on that, and here, I'm just going to go ahead, while you're going up there, I'm going to read, well, you know what, I always do this, I get so excited about the proclamations. Should I read some of this, or do we need to go ahead and vote on it first? Okay.

30:46 I'm just going to read a portion of this, a proclamation of the Town Council designating June 2019 as Elder Abuse Awareness Month, whereas older adults deserve to be treated with respect and dignity to enable them to continue to serve as leaders, mentors, and volunteers who contribute to the vitality of the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

31:07 And whereas everyone can help in the campaign to eliminate elder abuse by watching for and reporting signs such as physical trauma, withdrawal, depression, anxiety, and fear of family members, friends, or caregivers, and therefore the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes hereby proclaims 2019 is Elder Abuse Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes and encourages everyone to recognize and celebrate older adults and their ongoing contributions.

31:34 To the vitality of our country. And I'll go ahead and entertain a motion, please. I will only appropriately make the motion to approve the proclamation declaring June 2019 as Elder Abuse Awareness Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Councilmember Selsinger? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pond Selsinger? Yes. Mayor Popp.

32:00 Yes, item passes 5-0. And now, let's hear. Well, I'm Krista Cooper. I'm a social worker supervisor for Mono County Department of Social Services. I work under adult services as well as children. And so I do want to thank you for accepting this proclamation. And we're doing quite a few activities this month. We're a purple day on the 10th and flag posting up in Walker.

32:29 So we're just trying to get more activities each and every year. So we're moving forward and bringing awareness to the community. So thank you. Okay, thank you so much. And here, I'm going to run down here. Can I ask just a quick question? Oh, yeah. Can you, what age, how old do you have to be to start getting respect for people? John wants to know if it qualifies. That's a really good question. Under regulations, it's age 65 and older.

32:59 It includes dependent adults, so there's some criteria around that, so age isn't in and of itself an absolute criteria. Okay, thank you. And also I think it's worth mentioning that there is an elder abuse hotline, and so elder abuse can consist of all kinds of things, including financial abuse, which is something that is not so easily ascertained, and this year's agency, Social Services, does a great job.

33:28 Thank you. With our seniors in the community. So thank you. Thank you. From another elder. But I don't get respect. Ready? And thank you very much for all of your work. Thank you.

34:05 We are now item three presentation regarding the town's new public engagement tool, Engage Mammoth Lakes. And I'm presuming this is you, Stuart, since you're up there. I am here. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. Again, I always wanted to know if it was Porsche or Porsche. Either is correct. Porsche. Porsche. Okay. Okay. You may have to fight Mark on that one. Thank you. So I'm here.

34:50 This afternoon, very briefly to hopefully present a high-level overview of the Engagement HQ platform. The Engagement HQ platform lives with the town manager's office, and we collectively work to enhance, expand, grow, learn each and every day the many capabilities of the website. So based on the project, each department would have a role to play in the platform itself.

35:16 I'm just going to kind of run through an overview, a high-level overview of the platform itself, where it started, what the capabilities are, and we'll kind of end with a project or some projects and show you the benefit of it for the community. So it was founded in 2007 by two very insightful Australians. And they quickly realized that the typical town hall style of meeting, which is pretty much like this, asking everybody to come up.

35:43 Have their say, participate in kind of a conversation or provide their input and feedback was really not very productive. It was very much unproductive. So they kind of set about developing this online engagement portal and it is now synonymous around the world with more than 10,000 public consultations in five different countries. So it's a large, large scale platform. Online engagement versus typical sit down public to public interaction.

36:13 Is really helpful in regards to reaching a wider audience. You know, just kind of covering these bullet points. Builds community capacity, develops a deeper understanding with the people that you serve in your community. Really enables and establishes and builds public interaction and trust. I think it's really important. And it's very much a litmus test for the in-person engagement. So that is the role of the online platform. Engagement HQ.

36:41 It has eight different engagement tools we'll walk through and 14 kind of communication slash participation widgets is what they're called. That's a technical term. The tools collect qualitative, quantitative and geospatial data from participants. So really the goal here is to elevate awareness and education of the project along with the opportunity to provide valuable input all in one place. It's really your one-stop shop for community engagement. The IAP2 spectrum of public participation

37:10 Participation, if you've seen this, it's part of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Community Engagement Plan that was developed I think about 10 years ago. This was kind of the platform that was utilised to engage with our community members. And really the spectrum was designed to assist the selection of the level of participation either from inform or to empower that defines the public role in any public participation process. So this spectrum

37:38 When they aligned it with Engagement HQ, looks like this. So they kind of took the model of the IAP2 spectrum and rolled it into their online model, which starts from listening, informing, measuring, and then building community capacity. The toolbox. So the toolbox has eight different tools, as we talked about, anywhere from what they kind of call an open environment to a mixed environment to a control environment. So you have three tools on the open environment.

38:09 Being forums, ideas, places where kind of the participants can engage with each other in a really non-threatening way. You have a mixed environment, stories, guest books and Q&As. And then you have polls and surveys. Polls and surveys are very much ones that, you know, very typical from a community engagement point of view and really assist in the decision-making process. The other ones are all about trying to get people engaged in the communication, engaged in the discussion and hearing their points of view. So there's eight tools.

38:38 This just kind of runs through, I know you have it in your packet, this just kind of runs through each of those eight tools, I'll kind of move through them quickly. Forums, as you can see, are very safe and interactive space, interactive space for your community to discuss and debate pertinent issues. So you can kind of jump on, have your say, see what everybody else is, you know, posting, and move along from there. So very much multi-threaded discussion, very rich conversations, ideas.

39:04 This is where you can kind of have your say, have your idea, put it out there, and the community actually votes on it. So it's pretty kind of cool. It's almost like a sticky note of kind of the online engagement platform. So Ideas is just kind of getting involved as they talk about kind of a virtual post-it note. The final one in this one is just kind of places. So when you're looking at...

39:27 Community engagement. And you're trying to say, where would you like to see X? You know, what should we do here in this location? The community has an opportunity to get online and post these little pins in these different locations. I want to see a dogway station here. I want to see, you know, this multi-use path fixed here. These type of things. So you're able to kind of use this tool to kind of gather that geo kind of technical data from the community. So very kind of user-friendly tool. Stories.

39:53 This is where you can kind of get in and you're really trying to add to the conversation. So it's to help people understand, empathize, really get to know either the issue, the problem, and someone can kind of post their stories about what they've kind of experienced. So it's a very kind of rich, very empathetic kind of tool around very kind of emotionally charged or complex issues. So it's a good way to kind of have your say in a very kind of safe setting. So that's kind of the story tool. Guest book.

40:23 You can kind of gather community feedback and ideas very transparently. You're just basically going to jump in, open up a little kind of browser and then fill in kind of information about the project. It's a moderated space and you can kind of just continually upload any comments on the guestbook. So you're really just trying to generate kind of interest in the project so people can kind of jump on.

40:47 Be a guest at that project, so to speak. Q&A, this is a great tool when you're developing kind of frequently asked questions. I know we always struggle trying to understand what's really going to be pertinent or important for the community. So the Q&A tool does this for you. So it really lets your community ask those questions. And you can do it before, during, and after the project launch as well. And each one of these tools are all moderated through the Engagement HQ platform.

41:17 Which is very important. Polls. We've got two more to go. So polls. Very simple. Ask a single question. Get immediate insight. So you can see it's kind of the radio button of do you want to see this? Do you want to see this? We did this when we kind of did your typical kind of survey. Do you want to see a stop sign here or a stop sign there or all those type of things? It's kind of really generating interest and generating understanding about a particular issue just through a very defined and definitive structured environment.

41:45 Very simple questions. Yes, no, where would you like to see it? And then surveys, you know, surveys is kind of your typical online engagement tool. This is just one of the eight tools that they use through Engagement HQ, but it's a great way to kind of gather quantitative data, you know, for more informed decision making. So these are the ones, these last tools are very helpful for decision making in the process, right? You can quickly get a good litmus test and a good understanding of where the public is on many of these issues or projects that you're putting forward.

42:14 So they're kind of the tools. For us, we have launched our engagement HQ platform. It's now live online. To get there, you're going to click on the little icon that says engage with us. Once you click on that little tab, it'll take you to our new portal. I can kind of pull it up here, but this is probably easy. I just took some screenshots of the page. So this went live several weeks ago, a couple of weeks ago, I believe. New graphics, new images. We tried to kind of integrate it.

42:43 Make it kind of consistent, kind of look and feel somewhat with the Town of Mammoth Lakes website, similar colours. So if people are on this site, they're not seeing something completely different or uncommon or indifferent to our website. The URL, if you do want to kind of type it in directly into your browser, is just engage.mammothlakes.ca.gov. So it's very easy. Right on the top there, you can kind of navigate to the Notify Me page.

43:08 Because we took that spot for this platform. We want to kind of really use Engage Mammoth Lakes as that kind of primary engagement platform. So Notify Me is a communication engagement tool. So it now lives within this portal. Okay, excuse me one second. Yes. I just tried to pull that up and I'm not getting to it. So you say it is online right now? Yep. So could you pull up Town of Mammoth Lakes website and just click on Engage with us? Well, I just put the Engage. Do you have it, John? You got it.

43:37 Good grief. I spelled it correctly. I capitalized it. I did everything. I can pull it up and show you too. No, that's okay. I was just double checking. Okay. Thank you for rolling through with me. That's great. I'll slow down a little bit. So right on the top nav bar there, you can see you have your homepage, typical navigation. Jump to the Town of Mammoth Lakes website so you've inadvertently clicked on this page and don't know where you are. You can go back to the Town website, notify me, which is that subscription-based opt-in communication platform that we manage.

44:06 And then the parcel, which is kind of our main project. As you move down kind of lower in the page, if you're there, Madam Mayor, did you find the page? You know what, it was not allowing me just to put it in. The URL. Yeah, but I didn't do www or anything like that. Should I have done that? You should do www.engage.org. I think it might be engage.townofmammothlakes.ca.gov. Oh, did I?

44:36 Miss do that? Wait a minute. So it's... If you go to the town website, how do you do it? Just go to the town website? No, I was just typing it in since you had it just right up there. Is it town of Mammoth Lakes or engage on that? I just typed in engage.town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay. My apologies. Okay. Messed up already. No, that's okay. So...

44:57 I'll just keep rolling through here. So as you get to that homepage, then you can kind of scroll through and see these other projects. So we have kind of the two parcel projects rolling out right now. We have the two surveys online. And then we have two little projects here that talks about what is engaged Mammoth Lakes and then what do you love most about Mammoth Lakes. And then right on the right there, you can kind of follow our Facebook page. A big part of the difference between this tool and kind of a survey tool is with a typical survey tool, you don't need to log in.

45:26 You don't need to create a kind of a profile. You don't need to kind of register. But this one we do. We really want to gather and we really want to understand who's participating in the conversation. So you will be asked to participate in an online registration process. And this really enables us to understand who we are. We can kind of look at using it to create some community, different groups, advanced user profiles. So if we want to go out and really be very specific with some communication.

45:53 We can kind of drill down and break down the demographics and the users to be very specific with our questions in our polls and the tools that we use. So you will be asked, so do expect to answer some questions. So this is a little planning engagement checklist that we use. So right on the left there, when we work with our engagement team from Bang the Table, they kind of provide this little checklist for us. So really what you want to do is start with the end in mind.

46:22 So you really want to make sure what outcome you really want to achieve with your engagement. And then you basically select the right tool or tools, the widgets, how you want to display it, and then you walk through your little checklist and implement it. And away you go. So it's kind of a very interactive, very engaging process on a very professionally looking website. We get great site-wide activity results from...

46:49 Engagement HQ, Reporting and Analytics is a really big part of it as well. So you can see just some of the screenshots we've gathered from them. So identifies project interest, identifies any critical issues you have with the project, and important community stakeholders. So it really gives you the information you need to make better decisions. So very good reporting. And I've got a good example coming up to show you specifically how we recently did the parcel. This is just an example to say, so with Parks and Recreation, we wanted to know

47:18 How do we in the community continue to provide multi-purpose year-round indoor-outdoor recreation? So one of the tools we would select would be the idea tool. So we want to kind of get out there and just ask our community, hey, what ideas do you have to, you know, meet our mission? So they can include images, media, they can take some, you know, photos, they can send it in, we can look at it, and then participants can like and comment directly on every one of those posts. So it's pretty cool. It's like that virtual post-it note, surreal.

47:45 You know, people I think are hopefully not so threatening. You don't have to write pages and pages of narrative. You can be very quick. Hey, I just want to do more volleyball. I want to, you know, recreate in my park. I want more trees. And then people can kind of, you know, get behind and support those ideas. So just a great way to kind of have the community tell us your big idea. As we move through on to the parcel. So the parcel rolled out their survey online in both English and Spanish. We've got some results coming up here.

48:13 So the parcel on Engagement HQ is another great form of communication, not only with the parcel website that we have, but if people are in this site, they can still receive that information they're looking for about the project, and it will serve as the primary engagement tool for the project. So we launched the surveys, which we talked about. This was kind of some analysis from May through yesterday. So you can just see here quickly on the...

48:42 The one on the right there, you have total visits 345. And then they have three different categories of what they call engaged, informed, or aware visitors. So the engaged visitor is that person who's actually participated in the survey or participated in the tool. The informed visitor is someone who's clicked on that page or multiple tools. And 272 visitors have read that page. So you've got informed visitors who've read it. They know what it is.

49:09 I'm sorry, where informed visitors have been a little bit more in depth. They've kind of, you know, drilled down, clicked down, got a bit more involved in the understanding and the project. And then 74 people participated in the survey. You actually have a breakdown from the 74 survey participants, 73 were responded in English and one was responded in Spanish. So you get some good information from that survey. I do have a whole summary report, if you really want to get into eight pages of what happened in the last month.

49:37 Unengaged, Town of Mountain Flakes.ca.gov, which I missed. Sorry about that. But anyway, but this is the information we can get from Engagement HQ, and that is my little brief presentation. To clarify, I just wanted to let you know I did type it just in the browser, and it did just come up without the www. But then, you know what, I'll bring it up later, but I do have some, maybe some things, maybe some tweaks.

50:07 I was trying to sign up also and having a little bit of issue with that, so maybe it's because of the rain, who knows. Sticky keys, but that looks really good. Anybody have any questions or comments? I will start this if you would like. Is this a moderated site or a live site? So when someone makes a comment here, does it come right up or do we have a moderator looking at it several times during the day?

50:37 To prevent. Moderated 24-7. Okay. Who's doing that moderating? Engagement HQ. Okay, so there, it's not. It's not a local here. It's not a local person, Mammoth Lakes. It's service they provide to all their subscriptions, yeah. So after that, I have comments. You want me to go ahead with those of you who want to continue with questions and come back to comments? We can go ahead and take questions or comments at this time. Okay. One of the issues, having been in positions myself where I was pushing certain.

51:07 One of the easy things to do with tools like this and with all the survey tools we've done is to do an email blast and skew what actual community input is. So I caution all of us while this is a great tool and we should use it and look at it, the most important tool to me and I think should be for all of us sitting up here is our personal community engagement to catch the pulse of what is really going on to keep

51:36 Thank you. Thank you. Questions, comments?

52:07 So you mentioned this lives in the town manager's office. Typically with a website, there's like a webmaster, there's a signed person who has the credentials. And I don't know if it's appropriate, Dan, but I'm wondering who owns this thing. Yeah, so in our office, they'd be running with a Pam Kobylarz assistant too there to be able to moderate that and sign that out. And then as a project comes in, there's a project lead in the department. And so they would actually then work with the

52:36 The coordinator on the site to really go, okay, here's what we're doing. But ideally on that, before that happens, there's some strategy layout, some discussion, asking the question, what are we after? Which tools do we want to utilize? And so there's that general on the front end, oversight and coordination. And then, okay, sounds great, you're ready, boom, let's put this on the site. So that still has some work to go in terms of that process, and we're kind of live launching in the middle of the same time. Is the parcel effort the first

53:05 Effort, is that the first project the town's going to use to try to use this tool? It's on there at this point in time, yes, it's that, and then we had the element on a little bit with the, let me just welcome, the other one was on the general stuff, Stu, right, the welcome one? Yeah, that's just what is engaged, Mammoth Lakes, and the other one is what do you love about it. So they're kind of just some soft ones that we wanted to try and just get some people interested in the portal and registering and getting online before we kind of roll out a larger project.

53:35 If you touch on the importance, Stu, if you would, and personally, if you would, on the importance of the sign-up and getting the information that we do gain, a lot of that helps with the analytics. Yep. So it's just understanding who your users are, you know, who's on the site, who's engaged, you know, I think it gives you a lot of opportunity to drill down. So to better understand, there's actually when you, if you've registered already, you probably registered.

53:58 Yes. Yep. So you actually go in and actually select an area where you live in town too. So, you know, we can look at who's responding based on where they're living in town, which I think is, you know, very helpful as we move forward. It's always difficult understanding what to ask, what not to ask. You know, when you go through these type of, you know, questions, we had a long debate and we're probably still debating how, you know, all the questions that we're asking. You can ask a lot more. We tried to come up with what we believe were fair and reasonable.

54:22 And would give us the opportunity in the future to kind of further understand, further break down, and further probably target and customise, you know, the communication and the messages to the participants, right? You don't, no one wants to see kind of a blanket email of the same thing of the, you know, kind of a vanilla, benign, you know, question. You know, they really want to know if they're really engaged in the upper side, in the Knowles, if Sandy's part of it. We have a breakdown of all the Knowles participants. We can kind of...

54:50 We communicate with the Knowles. We communicate with the Trails. We can communicate to anyone. Those type of demographic questions as well are also part of that. So it's just a way to kind of drill down and better understand the participants on the site. Who's engaging them? But the information, it should not be assumed. There's no disclaimer that says about anonymity or those kinds of things. I mean, I think just going through the registration process, I'm going to assume that whoever's monitoring this site is going to know who I am, how I'm engaging it, and all the rest of it.

55:19 It might be useful to make some sort of representation of people signing up for this thing what their expectations for privacy should be because it's not really clear when you sign on the site. Yeah, there's a little privacy policy right here at the bottom if you want to. Yeah, but, you know. Is it too? Yeah, and that's legally, that's fine, but we're living in a world, we all know the world that we're living in. Yeah, so it might be good to say just in layperson's language, hey, you can participate in this.

55:55 Whatever the appropriate response is to say. We're not going to sell your email. We're not going to sell your email, but, you know, if you're asking, is there a way to log into this thing anonymously and not provide that information? There may be people more comfortable doing that. It's just we're living in a challenging environment with these things. I understand. Thank you. How does this reach out to the Hispanic community, especially the parcel? Yeah, some demographics that...

56:23 Engagement HQ providers in regards to online, you know, engagement users, and they looked at the demographics and from Hispanics to white to African Americans. There's nothing in Spanish language. Yeah, that's Spanish right there. Yeah, that's what I'm asking. Can you show that? Yeah. Matter of fact, there's actually a little bit too much Spanish that I was going.

56:48 Where's the English words here that I can read? So I would have to say my initial response is it's very much very prevalent. So there should be no trouble with that. It's just I think the challenge is to making the Hispanic community aware of this platform, and that's kind of the outreach that's incumbent upon the town to do first, right?

57:13 So we still have to go through a lot of the traditional way of reaching people to make them aware that we have this engagement platform and we want you to participate. So that, I think, is going to be the challenge. Once we can get them here, you know, we hope they'll participate. I think, again, it's like anything, making them aware and how do we reach that level of the community. Thank you. Appreciate the question. I went in Friday and registered. How many people have actually registered, did you say, Stu? I had on the little survey,

57:43 I can give you this little handout here, I can tell you, but 74 people completed the survey, 88 new registrations in the month of May. Okay. So do you think that most of the people who made, what percentage of people who made contact with the website actually registered? Was there... We could probably drill down and get you that information. I think this...

58:08 The way people found about this was through the Notify Me subscription. Right, you sent out, right. Right, so we pushed it out through Townie News and through those channels. So that's belonging fruit, if you will. I don't think it was difficult to register. I mean, it took a few minutes and all that, and I understand the reasons for doing that. But, you know, I think always...

58:25 Sort of circling back to the fact that some people are, you know, don't want to register. Some people will start the registration and go, this is taking too long. If there's a little bit of glitch at the beginning, they'll go, ah, never mind. But okay, so you get the certain amount of people that come in and do register. There will be always, as we talk about, those number of people who are not going to do an online survey. What are our plans to outreach to those folks? You know, is that a priority to us to bring other people to the table to fill out a written, if you will?

58:55 How would we add that data into the mix? What is sort of our plan for that? Great questions. I haven't or wasn't come prepared to answer that. Okay, so we can talk about maybe during the discussion. Well, I think it's twofolds of that. One, it depends on what we're asking, what we're after. This is not specific to the parcel by any means in terms of using the tool. So, yeah, do you have a, do you back up with the written one? Do you have other types of ways? Do you outreach that way? Or in some cases, it might just be.

59:23 In a meeting, you could have a number of iPads or something available for people to sign up and do and go and great, and that's all we're after. So it depends on how we're trying to use the tool would depend on what other types of mechanisms we'd use to gather information. We can talk specifically. I think, Sandra, you're probably going to talk about that in some of the presentation. Yeah, we'll talk about it personally, but I think the tool allows us to do a lot of things. Oh, yeah. Like the on-gauge discussion, I think in like, I think was it the...

59:50 Mountain Venture Summit where they talked about the trucking when they did this, boom, a real quick survey and you only had a certain amount of time to fill it in and put it back. So again, that wouldn't be something that then you could go out and do paper to because it's a short snapshot in time. So there's different ways you can use the tool. I think we just need to keep in mind sort of the policy is that not every single person we want to talk to and want to hear from is going to access an online survey like this and what are the plans to do.

1:00:16 We can talk about that for the parcel, but some of the other ones, each one will have its own unique outreach capability, depending on what we're trying to do. I think the purpose of this platform is just the convenience, right? You can participate in this public discussion from home, you know, so you don't have to be in this kind of town hall setting. So I think it's, and to Council Sauser's point of view, too, it's a blend, right? It's the sum of all parts that kind of contribute to the discussion and the decision-making process. Thank you. Great.

1:00:53 Thank you so much, Stuart. I am going to have some questions about that. I think we could tighten up that registration for that. That should not be something that should touch more than...

1:01:10 Three minutes to do. Ten minutes. So yeah, there's just some minor things that I was going, well, this would be easier if it was that. So we'll go ahead and take it out to public comment. And if anybody has anything, please keep it to five minutes or less. That would be wonderful. And you may have to speak up if it starts raining again, because it was actually a little bit hard to hear up here for some reason. That was pretty good little.

1:01:32 Yeah. Shower. Yeah, for sure. Sandy Hogan, following up with a couple of comments from Councilmember Wentworth, first of all, about the privacy issues and whatever, and also from Cleland on the registration. You know, talk about elder abuse for some of us. I mean, I went into this about two or three times, and I'm impressed, Bill, by all of your knowledge.

1:01:58 But anyway, I did give in and whatever. One of my big questions, John, you mentioned the privacy issues and the fact that there are people and these were not Latinos that I talked to. They were Anglos, very well educated, whatever. It got to the point when they started seeing, oh, annual income, where do I live? These are the kind of things that stopped them. I was amazed.

1:02:26 But so some of those things are things that we really need to think about. How much demographic information do you want to get? Also your question, Kirk, about the Hispanic community. And I want to congratulate the town on the, you know, the plan your park part. But is the overall tool available in Spanish so that if somebody goes to the town website that they can access it in Spanish?

1:02:55 I'm not sure that they do. I would hope so, but that would be the whole tool is, oh, that's great, because I didn't check it. I did not check it. So that's wonderful. Also the forums, the gathering input for the guest book, the surveys, all of those are in Spanish, I take it then? That's good, because the word then is not getting out. If we've had 73 Anglos and only one Hispanic.

1:03:21 Access it. So we've got to get that word out somehow or another. But anyway, it sounds like that was my major question because it wasn't just the parcel that's in Spanish, but it's the whole tool. So that's good. Okay. Those were my comments. Thank you. And I am impressed. Hello. I'm Mickey Brown. I'm a semi-intelligent senior citizen.

1:03:53 I have to tell you, so I probably am a really good person, a test case, because I entered this totally cold while I received numerous emails about the parcel survey. I happened to click on the one that Amy sent out. It said, English survey, click. So I had no idea that I was enrolling in an online platform for numerous surveys, right?

1:04:23 I was really offended by the questions because I thought they were very personal and there was a lot of them and a lot of information. And if I hadn't actually put my real name, I probably would have clicked out. I only didn't click out because I figured somebody in Dan's office would say, oh, Mickey Brown can't even complete the survey. Okay. So I have to say, I really think that the

1:04:49 If you want that much information, especially about the parcel, that you maybe should be collecting your information after the survey. Because for me, I always hate to give a lot of information for something I don't even know if I'm going to really, what I'm answering in the first place. So I found the information pretty detailed and very personal.

1:05:13 You click finish the engage part and it clicks you back to the parcel page. So I'm sitting there going, well, what? I mean, it took me a few minutes to go, why am I back to here before I realized, oh, now I have to click into the parcel to take the survey. Once I got into the survey, the survey was fine. So I think you might just want to revisit the questions you're asking at the very beginning. That would be my suggestion. Okay. Thank you very much. You're welcome. I just saw that too.

1:05:42 No. I think you can skip them, too. Some of them. Ted Carlton. Two things. One, given the fact that probably all the town employees and staff were sort of mandated to sign up for this thing, do you have any sort of a non-government employee or non-.gov addresses that are actually signed up for this thing yet? And then two,

1:06:08 Since no one's going to ask, what does it cost? Is anyone curious about that or no? Cost for what? For the platform. Well, I mean, what's cost to monitor the thing? Do you have to pay whatever this engagement HQ is? Like, what's the... For the platform we're talking about. Yeah, what's the platform cost and then how much of Pam's time is devoted to it every week? Yeah, okay.

1:06:34 Yeah, I was about to say who wants to start. I don't recall the cost. The Stu would pull that. It was a one-time fee, I know, in terms of the setup on that, and then I think there's just an annual license fee as all, regardless of how much we use it, if I remember correctly. And, no, we have not mandated all the employees to go in and do it, do the survey or sign up. It's no different than any other agency. Yes, you may, but we have not mandated anybody to go in and sign up. But I don't recall the cost, Stu, unless you do back there. $8,000 a year. $8,000 a year.

1:07:04 Okay. Thank you, Stuart. Okay. Any more public comment or questions at this time? Okay. From town council? Okay. So hang on. I just, so a couple things. I think that the, I think that the comments about the questions that are being asked at the beginning, I don't think it's intentionally askew, but I think it represents a kind of a tone deafness.

1:07:33 The reality of the world that we live in, when you read every week about millions of people's private information being hacked and stolen and redistributed, I think in the online space there's a conscious effort by sites and platforms to anticipate that kind of concern, reassure people, we're not asking for, you can give information voluntarily if you want to, but we're not asking for where do you live.

1:07:59 You know, any kind of information, because what it does, I think to Mickey's point is, people go, I'm not giving you that. I don't want to give you that information. I had that same, I mean, I deal with this, we all deal with this all the time on the internet. Why do you want to even know my name? Why do you want to know my email address? I'm going to get spammed. I'm going to get all that kind of stuff. So I think there's a kind of a tone deafness there that maybe could be addressed going forward, and I think that may help a little bit. That's my thought. Thank you. Okay, thank you so much.

1:08:30 I would also agree with John and with Mickey. I opened that up and I was just putting blanks in. I wasn't going to answer any of those questions. I wasn't going to give that information, you know, to the town. I mean... Look, it's the world that we live in. It's not any aspersion against the town or the town. No, I don't give that to anybody. Exactly. If I may, I think on that part of that was like, especially in some of the surveys, if, you know, some of that information was...

1:08:59 Do you live in Mammoth? Are you a second homeowner? You know, that helps us if it depends on what we get for input or what we're asking for, if we're asking different questions of that nature. The other side of that was, as Stu mentioned, too, if we're looking at an area of town and we know that you had, you know, 90% of the respondents to the parcel all live in Sierra Valley sites, that'd be really nice to know that as the immediate neighborhood responding versus 90% of them responding from, you know, as second homeowners.

1:09:28 Again, I'm skewing those numbers, but that data and stuff is taking a look and say, what are we getting? It's like the example saying, do we want to know if it's Hispanic or not? And if we don't want to know, that's fine. We don't have to ask those questions, but we won't be able to give that information that how many have gone X, Y, or Z. I want to be cautious, too. I understand, but Mark Zuckerberg and the Facebook platform.

1:09:49 It's entirely predicated on data mining information for people. And I think all of us as citizens understand that someone is trying to get some information out of you for whatever reason. And I think it's as simple as saying, acknowledging that, hey, if you'd like to give us some information, we'd appreciate it. You don't have to.

1:10:08 You know, to anticipate those kinds of concerns because to be, to not be acknowledging that stuff, people are going to see it and going, I'm not going to give you anything. Yeah. My other concern was the absolute anonymous surveys are fine, but then we really don't know what we're getting and that's where you can have.

1:10:23 How many ever email addresses you have or more fill out a survey and we don't know if that's... These are the challenges of working in this space, in this time, in this country, in this world. No, we understand that. However, I would agree that I want to know where the individuals are coming from. I want to know if they live in Mammoth or if they work in Mammoth or if they don't. I don't think that's diving too deep. If we're asking personal questions, I haven't gone for the sign-up page. But totally anonymous...

1:10:51 As far as I'm concerned, it gives me no information, because that is somebody who just wants to get in and stir the pot, or that is, you know, purposefully skew the pot. I understand, but there's a way, just in the, when you're asking the questions, it's like, we understand, we're not, there's a way to ask, and a way to invite someone to provide. But it is important to know those things on this type of survey. Sure. It's a delicate world. Yes.

1:11:19 Very good conversation around that. Any more questions or comments? Okay, then that was just a presentation, so then now we will go ahead and move, and I believe at this point do we need to recuse Bill Sauser because he does live within the distance from this, the parcel. Do we have an estimate on this? Can I go to Bishop and back? Yes. Lone Pine. No.

1:11:45 So this is going to be the update on the parcel and we will wait for Mr. Sauser to retire to... I'm just going to go in there and go to sleep. You will know if you've been too long on this subject if when you call me back I am not there. Well, you know what, you can go on your phone and go ahead and sign up for and tell us what you think on that. Was that hail that we were, since I can't talk about what we're going on, was that hail or rain? Could anyone see out the window?

1:12:21 Really? Okay. There you go. Check to make sure my husband didn't fall down. Okay. And now with Mr. Salzer out of the room, we will go ahead and Sandra, I believe you're going to be working on this. Thank you. So as you know, this is our monthly report to Town Council on the parcel progress.

1:12:44 So just to kind of run through some of the items, some highlights from the staff report, I will kind of start with the responses to some of the issues that came up or questions that came up on May 15th.

1:12:57 One of them, kind of a high-level item was branding. So how are we rebranding or branding this process? And we've been calling it the conceptual land use planning process, but we're going to work to call it the plan the parcel, which is easier. It fits into kind of our standard conventions for different other processes. So correct me if I call it conceptual land use planning process again. And I think that that's more user-friendly and easier for the public to understand what we're doing. So it really conveys what we're doing with planning the parcel.

1:13:26 Questions came up about public engagement and our outreach. Amy Callanan is the lead on public engagement and outreach. She is out of the office this week or else she would be here today to talk a little bit more about it. But she will be here on June 26th and can provide some additional information on kind of what we've done and what we intend to do.

1:13:47 We are working on putting together the electronic media toolkit, which is something that was requested by council. That would include basically information, electronic copies of all of our marketing materials, our flyers, our print ad logos. In addition, all of the staff, the parcel staff, Amy in particular, her emails have the parcel logo as a tagline, and that is clickable. You can click on that and use that.

1:14:14 We're also putting together some postcards that we're going to be mailing out. We're ordering postcards right now, and we're going to deliver them to all 93546 zip code addresses, so that'll handle, you know, kind of basically our entire community. Those will be going out in the next week or so. That'll have all the information on the upcoming dates, information on Engage Mammoth Lakes, or, you know, information on how to get to Engage Mammoth Lakes. And we have been putting ads in the sheet, the register, sorry, the Inyo Register,

1:14:44 Mammoth Times and El Sol. So those ads are going out.

1:14:50 Actually, they'll be in Mammoth Times in El Sol on June 6th. But they were in the sheet and they need to register last week. So that's all kind of broad information about where we are in the parcel and how people can engage. And we did engage a marketing and outreach strategy expert. So this firm is helping us with all of our engagements. So they're helping us with social media. They're posting on Facebook. They're creating our Facebook events, posting on Twitter, Instagram. They are working to continue.

1:15:19 Can continually grow that follower base so that we can really get a robust outreach online. They are also working to help us with creative development. So developing, they are the ones that developed the logo for us, some taglines, fonts, colors, those types of things. And they are assisting us with Spanish translation in addition to the translator that we've hired particularly, especially for this.

1:15:43 They're also working to help us put together advertising, weekly ad campaigns, social media campaigns, website development, and community interaction. So they will be here for the Charette, the multi-day design workshop, in August, August 20th to the 23rd. So they'll be doing some creative ways to engage the public, including like live Facebook streaming, Instagram posting, those types of things.

1:16:11 And they're going to work to set up a community tour with the Chamber of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And we have some additional considerations that we're thinking about doing, and we haven't decided on these yet, but possibly promotional items or giveaways to get people to participate in different community events, possibly the surveys. And we're going to...

1:16:34 Develop and foster partnerships with the chamber, Mammoth Lakes Housing to really get this stuff out. We are working on that as well, but they'll be helping us with that. And talking about, we've talked about going out in the community and doing a community tour. So we are going to be posting all of the...

1:16:51 Posters, all this material at a variety of places in town, but also just kind of getting out and talking to these different businesses, agencies to really get more input and more participation on that. And I think that we discussed the survey pretty thoroughly during Stu's presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about the survey. And we're working right now to put together the June 26th.

1:17:19 Council Commission Joint Workshop. So that's really our focus right now. The survey information is going to feed into that workshop where we'll be talking about development objectives. So that's going to be kind of the first big check-in with the Town Council on here's what we've heard, here's what the consultants put together, what do you think? And that's really going to lead into the next steps, which is the development of rough preliminary designs, which will be available to the public.

1:17:48 And the Council in late July. And so I'll just kind of make some points about what those rough preliminary designs will be. So it'll be based on the development objectives the Town Council discusses on June 26th and agrees to on June 26th. So there'll be maps showing existing conditions, which we've seen some of our existing conditions out there. Some context maps, looking at the parcel.

1:18:10 In context with the adjacent properties, looking at the policy relationships between the parcel and some of our other policy documents like walk, bike, ride, downtown revitalization, and guiding principles, considerations for those guiding principles that the council adopted. And those will help set the framework for our multi-day...

1:18:34 Land use planning process. And just as a note, the rough preliminary concepts will not be land use bubble diagrams, block diagrams, street diagrams. So we're not going to have that. We want to preserve that public process and to really preserve that planning process in August, August 20th to 23rd. We're not going to put that stuff out in advance because we aren't considering that stuff in advance and we want the public to really have input during that planning process.

1:19:03 As we know, the process on August 20th to 23rd will be the consultants coming here and really working. So we have kind of our existing conditions, we have our concepts, we have our development objectives starting at the beginning and coming to some plans at the end of that process. So it's really a very quick, fluid process and we want the community to be engaged in that process. Do you have any questions at this point? Would you like me to just continue through my presentation or do you want to ask any questions on these points so far?

1:19:33 Just finish up? Yeah, I do have a concern is that where does the finances, the financials, the tax credit to have with Trump reducing the corporate tax credit from 35 to 21 percent, I mean, we're not going to be able to have as much access or there's more competition for those dollars. So when do...

1:20:00 When does the finances of this begin to enter into, and when the public participates, you know, they have to be, you know, they have to be informed that there's going to be a certain amount of pushback by the finances. So when will that take place? I'm looking at your October, November, it's a prepare final concept land use plan and narrative, and I assume that would be, the budget would also be included in that.

1:20:27 So during the multi-day design workshop, during that August 20th to 23rd, we're looking at kind of what we want, what's going to be there, what's it going to look like, and then once we have those ideas, once we have kind of those concepts finalized, we can say how we're going to pay for it. So, and the consultants, the financial team, Novin Development, who they've built affordable housing, they know affordable housing, they'll be here during that charrette process. So that's the point of having kind of all hands on deck, having all those consultants there, because...

1:20:56 We can say, somebody can say, well, why don't you guys build a, you know, apartment building? And Novin can say, well, the funding for that is this, this, and this. Maybe we could consider this component. You know, so that's the point of having that fluid process where we can have the input, have the ideas, and then talk about how we could fund those. You know, so that's that process. But then ultimately all of that funding will be available after that conceptual, after the multi-day design process in August. Thank you. I have a question and it's somewhat related.

1:21:27 In the same vein as that, zoning. If we get everyone together and they come up with these ideas that would necessitate some zoning adjustments, will that be talked about during the planning process or will we sort of gather stuff regardless of how things are currently zoned? How will we handle that piece?

1:21:52 I think our goal is to make this process as open as possible and to look at what we really want to see on that site and not be restricted to kind of all of that zoning, the setbacks, the heights, those types of things, the development standards. So really kind of saying, well, you know.

1:22:08 For example, maybe there's a 50-foot setback on X Street. Well, we want to maybe come a little bit closer because it works well with these other uses. Okay. So I think that's what we're going to do during that process is say, okay, well, this might not meet the setbacks, the heights, those types of standards, but this is appropriate for this site. So really, ultimately, what we'll have at the end of this process is a package of, if needed, any changes that we might need to make to those development standards or anything else. And same way, sort of around the AMIs?

1:22:37 Same kind of process, look at it in sort of a more global way and then drill down later into the AMIs. I think we'll be talking about that during that design process. I think the design process is really designing the site, looking at land use, planning, those types of things, but that definitely will be a conversation. We know what the requirements are, the current restrictions are on the site, so we will be talking about that through that process.

1:23:08 John, anything? I'd like to hear the balance of the presentation. I'll finish up. It's brief. So I think I mentioned at the last meeting that we are putting together an application for SB2 grant funding. The town has an allocated amount from the state of $160,000. We've gone through one round of review. We're putting that together, and we're going to submit that next week. So we anticipate that that funding will fund this.

1:23:32 Plan your parcel process. And so the next steps, just looking to really publicize the survey. And so some questions came up at the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting about how we're getting this out. And I think we are trying to work to get it out as much as we can, but we need everyone else to help us too. So we don't have all the connections that everyone has on Facebook, so share it on Facebook, share it on social media, help people.

1:23:56 It's very easy to get to that spot. You just tell them to go to the town website and click on the engage button. So that's the easiest way, I think, just to tell people if you're just talking to them to get them there. But we're all trying to work to promote this and get this out and get people engaged.

1:24:14 Let's see. We are working continuously on our biweekly meetings. Mammoth Lakes Housing participates in those biweekly meetings with a consultant. And we continue to brief the town manager on a weekly basis so that he can pass information on to the town council. And with that, I'll pass on Grady's comments. He's not able to be here, but he said, we are excited. Let's get this done. Go team. And that's all I have. Okay. Would you like to go ahead and dive in right now?

1:24:42 Well, are we doing technical questions or community? Are we doing public comment? I'm going to do public comment, but if you have a question right now. No, I don't have any technical questions. I look forward to hearing from the public. I do have some comments and thoughts to provide direction to staff. Questions at this time? Okay. With that, we will go out to public comment. Please limit your comments or questions to five minutes, but right now you do have time to speak up. Thank you, Mickey.

1:25:15 Hello, I'm Mickey Brown. As most of you know, I am so excited to have this opportunity to participate in this planning process. I really feel...

1:25:26 I'm here. I have just two comments I'd like to really encourage. I know we've talked about this a little bit, but in the charrettes,

1:25:56 I really believe that part of our planning process should really be that formation of place, creating the center of town. Where is our year-round community going to gather? One of my favorite blogs is Strong Town, and they have this little saying, you know, if the revolution came to town, where would they gather?

1:26:20 I mean, it'd be pretty sad that they gathered at Vons, right? So, I mean, and so while, you know, maybe our center of place, our community is not necessarily on the parcel, but it certainly has to be adjacent to the parcel, and it's this ideal...

1:26:40 And the way it ties into our walk, bike.

1:27:08 It seems like a long time ago, lastly.

1:27:33 But in November, we did a wonderful housing summit. I know that there's people in our community and people in our press that were not there. We did fabulous videos of it. The videos, especially on Friday and Saturday night, are on the town website. You can just type in Mammoth Lakes Community Housing Summit. Go to the evening sessions. I encourage everybody.

1:27:59 to watch three sessions. One was what they did in the town of Breckenridge, presented by Lori Bess. One was what they did in the town of Boulder, that was presented by Cindy Brown. And three, Wendy Sullivan did a complete peer resort.

1:28:17 Thank you. Thank you. Madam Mayor, before the next speaker speaks, I know I'm just

1:28:47 Worried about a technical problem. That microphone seems to be distorting really badly, and I don't know if that's being, if that's what's going out to the public. Maybe we could swap that one out. I know there was a bad microphone here for a while, and it's sounding very distorted for me. I don't know if there's a way to... I don't know if that's going out to the public, but to err on that side of caution. Thank you very much. I'm sure someone will send me a text if it's sounding strange. Thank you.

1:29:15 Yeah. Okay. Public comment on this matter? Okay. I will go ahead and, John, would you care to make some comments at this point? Sure. So I think that, as Mickey indicated, and many people in the room indicated, this is probably the most important thing this town is ever going to try to do. And I think we are all committed to making sure this is successful. So when I look at

1:29:47 I appreciate the schedule, but I think we're trying to get a lot of very important work done in a very short period of time. And when I look at what's in the outreach plan, the conversation with the consultants, I think we're in danger of heading into a charrette, a planning process in August where everybody's going to show up and it's the first time they've ever seen or heard about any of this stuff.

1:30:15 And I think that we need, we're spending a lot of money on this, and I think we need to think about redirecting some of the money that we're spending. And I'm thinking we need to start doing some pre-charettes. And what I say about that is the Community Housing Action Plan process. We had some of the best housing consultants in the western United States. There were how many meetings were involved in that process. Eight, ten different, with a group of 25 different stakeholders. This is enormously technical stuff.

1:30:42 And I think that I would want to make sure that if we're going to be driving the public to these four days in August, that we do what we need to do to make sure that the people show up at these charrettes, which the community hopefully will be showing up. We've done the homework in advance to introduce them to the concepts of AMI, zoning.

1:31:04 Financing. The kinds of issues that are technical and very complicated so that when we gather everybody together, everybody's got a certain level of literacy so we can have good, intelligent conversations. I don't think at this point relying on an online survey tool, which is great, and a planning and economic development joint meeting with the council, and the next thing we do is go into a four-day planning charrette, I don't think we're doing, we're serving the public in the way that we need to to be

1:31:32 Overextending ourselves to make sure that that's going to be a successful four-day meeting. And looking at the detailed agenda of the meeting, it's like the first night's kind of a welcoming thing. There's like two days of working. And then the Friday afternoon, when the concept gets rolled out, as many of you know, I grew up in Washington, D.C. When people publish documents on a Friday night, it's called a document dump. It's intended to bury things and have things disappear. They'll never be heard from again. These are the kinds of things I think I'm not...

1:31:59 No one's intending to do that, but I think we need to anticipate that, and we need to front load this process so that we have two or three informal, I know Mickey,

1:32:10 Going to raise your hand again. The work that went into that housing summit, the kind of capacity we were able to draw, I think we should get some resources from the town to start to work with the community to get people ready for the kinds of questions, the kind of things that are going to be involved in that charrette so we're not just dealing with the four of us and a couple people in the community who understand all this stuff, but we can truly get

1:32:36 The sentiment of the community and what they want to see around these questions in a way that's going to be meaningful. So I have a significant concern about that. And I think, you know, people, the community pulled together that housing summit.

1:32:48 Some of the best people in the country do show up and put that on. I think we need to find a way in this process to front load and preload so that the community has an opportunity to get up to speed and all this stuff. So it's not, you know, seven or eight walks that show up that have been going over this the whole time, that we truly get the community sentiment involved and represented in these discussions. So if someone can show up and say, look, I...

1:33:15 We have so many people in my family. I want to live in this place. They're not going to know what AMI is. They're not going to know all these technical questions. But we can translate what they're saying into the values that are going to go into the design and layout of this project. And I'm concerned that we're going to miss that. And I'm substantially concerned about that. So I defer to any conversation with you guys. But I think that we cannot miss this opportunity. We cannot have a charrette in August that's happening. And we have people showing up who just

1:33:42 Don't have the basic level of sort of technical literacy or whatever to be able to have a good session out of this. It could go, the first day is kind of great. Oh, did you hear about this? And then all of a sudden we're rolling out plans and people are saying, well, I didn't know anything about this. I didn't show up to it. We can do it. I think there's a way to do it, but I think we have to front load it, seed it, get people ready and amped up. And so when they show up for this thing, they know what they want to do and they know what they're going to have to say.

1:34:10 To push out education through all of our outlets, we can do those kinds of things, but I don't think...

1:34:16 From a town perspective, we're expecting everyone who participates in the Shred to be an expert or to have, to be at a certain level of literacy for this. I want to encourage anyone to come and to say, hey, I want to see a dog park there or whatever it is. I want, we want people to come and to participate and I don't think we need to make, I don't think everyone needs to be expected to have that level, but I think it's a good point that we can be pushing those things out. So I think when we talk about our outreach, maybe part of our outreach is an educational component every week or. Well, I just think that like.

1:34:45 Supervisor Corliss and I have been doing community conversations for the last four years. I think having some informal gatherings, get the consultants up here, just have informal get-togethers, bring the public in and say, look, this thing's going to be happening. What do you need to know? What kind of questions can we, what can they expect when they show up at the Charette? I think doing three or four of those things over the course of the summer would be a smart thing to do.

1:35:10 More than willing to offer my services to help out. We've got a lot of things to work from, but I think that's something we should be doing in advance of this thing. You know what? I appreciate where you're coming from, but every...

1:35:22 Aspect of life in Mammoth. We're living in Mammoth Lakes. We're not living in Utopia. So for everything that we ask of the public, I think that there is an expectation from the public that we get some things straight presented to them. You know, if they choose to show up, I think that's a great idea. And the summit was awesome. And what Mickey was bringing up, it's online. Have I gone back and watched them? No. Do I have time?

1:35:49 I frankly don't have the time. They were great, but I have to take what I retained from last November and move forward. I think that's a big ask of a lot of people, and I think people would rather see this go.

1:36:05 I think people would like to see it move a little more quickly than hear from everybody because I can guarantee you we can have 20 meetings between now and something is going to happen and then we'll have people who come here and say, well, I didn't know about this or, you know, I, you know what, I hate to say it, but how many people are here just to get the parcel update? I mean, I just think that that's a great thought, but I think you're putting a lot on people too.

1:36:33 To be an expert in a field that they're not going to. Right. I'm not saying that people have to show up, but I think that it's incumbent upon us as the leadership in this community to make sure we provide sufficient opportunities for people to be engaged. If people don't want to show up, that's fine. But we cannot minimize the kinds of decisions and the choices that we're going to be asked to make in December, November, December, January around height. Linda brought up the zoning issues, AMI issues.

1:37:02 The riparian areas. I mean, this is the most significant thing this community has ever tried to do. And I think it's incumbent upon us. We've got money. We've got consultants. We've got a great team, staff team to work with. We've got some people in the community who probably want to help pull these things together. And they just get a couple events in advance to say, look, this thing's going to be happening. Is this on your calendars? Are you going to be showing up? Because I certainly don't want to be sitting up here making decisions about zoning and height and land use in a vacuum.

1:37:32 And not having known that we could have done everything we could to give the public an opportunity to be engaged and get their voices heard. I think it's irresponsible if we don't do that. Okay. I do appreciate that. I've been told to be educated on a lot of things today. So thank you for that. Any other comments at this moment? Yes, I would like to just give some sort of a frame about what we're dealing with.

1:38:03 We have 25 acres. There's probably three to five acres of wetlands there. It's currently zoned at 172 units. We can do double density. Well, if we want to change that zoning, we're going to, because of density or anything else, that is something that this council can have the authority to do. The needs assessment, which could drive the changing of that zoning, is that

1:38:30 There's two ends of our needs. We have people down at 30%, 80% of AMI, and we have people that have needs that are at 180% of AMI. So there's two different needs groups out there. The bulk of it is obviously those people at the 30%.

1:38:49 The 50 to 80 percent below 120 AMI. So the rezoning discussion is going to be, I think, pretty robust. And we look at that in August. The financing of this is going to be incredibly difficult because the...

1:39:09 State as well as the federal. The federal money comes to the state and the state allocates it. So it's going to be very difficult to actually finance that because it is subsidized housing. And then you have the management and then you have maintaining it. So I'm trying to be very concrete about

1:39:29 You know, this is going to be a difficult project, and we've got some real hurdles, and there's going to be some financial issues that will be coming to the surface that this community, this council is going to have to struggle with. Yeah. And I think these are fundamental and critically important questions, and again, we are representing the community, and I'm just hoping that we have the input, the engagement, so that we're doing what the community wants.

1:39:57 And we're representing their values and we're not having to sit up here as electives and try to make it up on our own. Well, John, you and I agree on this. I mean, it's those needs assessments we did that are targeting certain audience that is going to drive a lot of the discussions in the future. So yeah, the charrettes are really important, but we need those fundamental documents and those fundamental pieces of information that will

1:40:26 Inform the discussions, which are really, really important. So you're just not looking at a blank, you know, a blank checkbook and a blank piece of property. It's not. And we've got outside forces that are very much impacting us, especially today. I just am happy to say that, yes, I agree with everything we've said here. There's no reason for me to reiterate.

1:40:52 Anything, but I think that we need to stay with the positive, enthusiasm, opportunity, really the getting behind this. I see the staff is working really hard to make this happen. I think there's a multiple way of reaching out to people by computer surveys and other

1:41:15 Hard copies if we need to. There's lots of ways to educate people, some of whom, you know, people will access, some of whom won't. But getting people to the table and understanding that this is just the first. There's a lot of technical things to continue on in the zoning, the finance, the planning, others. Multi, multifaceted. One step at a time. Have some fun along the way. Make this something we can all be super proud of at the end of the day and feel like we left.

1:41:41 Everything better for when we got here. So we're all on the same page, and I think that's an important point to make. Yeah, absolutely. It's a huge opportunity. Okay. Any more questions, comments? Okay. With that, we will go ahead and invite Mr. Salzer back in, and then we will go to the consent agenda.

1:42:12 You know what, we're going to go ahead and take five minutes while Salzer's coming back in, and we shall return. We invite you back into nothing. We're going to come back into session, please. We are back in session. Just to let you know, in the back of the room, we can hear you speaking. Just FYI, for some reason, it travels up. I noticed in this meeting for some reason, so if... Shut up.

1:42:54 I'm not going to, I don't, that's a bad word. That's easy. I'm going to say, please, yeah, keep it to a dull roar. Okay, we are now to the consent agenda. We have item 5, 6, 5, approve the minutes of May 15th. 6, receive and file the Interwest Development Agreement. 7, adopt the resolution authorizing a temporary closure of Canyon Boulevard. Item 8,

1:43:20 Adopt the resolution authorizing a road closure for the half marathon. Item 9, adopt the resolution for closure of parts of Old Mammoth Road, 4th of July. 10th, adopt the resolution of closure on Canyon Boulevard. Item 11, adopt a resolution assigning funds from the town's tourism reservation, reservation tourism, reserved to complete the town's wayfinding project and Mammoth Lakes tourism request for two years of special event funding.

1:43:49 And item 12, accept payment approval report number 19-50 through 19-53. Would anyone care to remove something from the consent agenda for further discussion? If I may, I need to pull item 7 for correction just on a date. Okay, so 7 is going to be pulled for date. Anybody else?

1:44:21 Okay. So I'll make a resolution to approve the consent agenda items 5 through 12, omitting number 7. Second motion. Yes. What did I say? A resolution. Reservation. Reservation for 7. Actually, a motion. Approved. Second. Okay, roll call please. Council Member Salcido? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Temer? Yes. Mayor Pro Temer? Yep. Mayor Pro Temer?

1:44:49 Yes, item passes 5-0, and now we will go to item 7, and if you could give us those corrected dates, please. Yeah, just a real short, the resolution and the report reference to the event for the Modo Bash going on June 22nd, it'll be June 29th, so if you could approve it with that amended date, then we will get a corrected resolution for signature accordingly on that, but everything else is correct in the item, it's just the date.

1:45:16 Uh, instead of June 22nd, is June 29th.

1:45:19 So then the motion would be to adopt the resolution as corrected.

1:45:24 Correct.

1:45:24 Noting that that date will be June 29th.

1:45:26 Okay.

1:45:27 Yes.

1:45:27 2019.

1:45:28 So moved.

1:45:29 Second.

1:45:29 Roll call, please.

1:45:31 Councilmember Salcido.

1:45:32 Yes.

1:45:32 Councilmember Staff.

1:45:33 Yes.

1:45:34 Councilmember Woodward.

1:45:35 Yes.

1:45:35 Councilmember Woodward.

1:45:36 Yes.

1:45:36 Councilmember Souser.

1:45:36 Yes.

1:45:37 Mayor Fox.

1:45:38 Uh, yes.

1:45:38 Item passes 5-0.

1:45:41 Uh, now we will go ahead and move to the, uh, to policy matters.

1:45:46 Um,

1:45:47 Item 13, Community Recreation Center update and recommendation. And Haislip, are you taking this one away? I am. Thank you. So we are here this evening for an update on the Community Recreation Center. If you saw the presentation to the Recreation Commission, it's going to be very, very similar. And I'm sure everybody watched that, so it's going to be pretty repetitive. So

1:46:11 We're going to go over a little bit of background, talk about the last directive from Town Council, look over some analysis of a couple of alternatives as developed by Town Staff, Vanner, and HMC, talk about programming and the alternative impact on what the programming could look like, talk a little bit about budget and schedule, and close out with a recommendation. And then, let's see, so on February 20th, we were here with...

1:46:41 Seeking direction from Council to move forward with the project, we kind of refer to this as the $13 million question. Staff was basically asked to figure out what we could do for $13 million. Shortly thereafter, we were back at Council

1:46:56 Looking for authorization to finalize an agreement with Banner Construction for the construction management services for the project. And I'm joined this evening by Rob Nash with Banner Construction. His team was instrumental in development of these alternatives and these estimates. We really appreciate the hard work he put into it. We know there was a lot of late nights and weekends. We gave him a pretty difficult and challenging assignment to work on, and we really appreciate your hard work.

1:47:25 The analysis started with reviewing the project as bid, and this is just for a reminder, it's inclusive of the community center, the parking, and all the pertinences that were designed and put out to bid last year. We started with an independent cost estimate by Vanner. His estimators started effectively in a vacuum with a set of plans and bid the project. And they came in within a few hundred thousand dollars of the actual bid, which validated the bid.

1:47:52 But also provided some credibility to his estimators because the numbers were in line. So we met as a team in this room and started going for an exercise to reduce costs. And this was a deductive exercise to begin with, looking at what we could eliminate from the project, parking, community center, mechanical finishes and so forth to try to bring the costs down. And the best we could do, working from the original design,

1:48:18 It was to bring the price in about $18 million for construction costs. And that just was not viable. That is not answering that $13 million question. We identified the biggest issue, and this has been brought to Council before, is the superstructure. The steel alone, $6 million in the roof, is just prohibitively expensive. And just for comparison's sake, the blue area is the footprint of the community center and the ice rink. That gray shaded area is the parking area.

1:48:47 And this was broken into two components with the community center to the north, kind of showing orange, and then the ice rink facility to the southerly portion in blue there. So to move forward, we tasked Banner and HMC with kind of two tracks. One was called the Rink and the Roof, and the other was just an alternative structure. The idea was...

1:49:13 Knowing that the superstructure and the steel was going to be prohibitively expensive, if we can't figure out a solution just to put a roof on this and focus on that component, then the project is not viable. So we just picked that apart and said, focus on putting a rink and a roof. Ice rink, roof, no support structures, no restrooms, no bathrooms, nothing. Just focus all of your energy on figuring out how to put a roof on this structure, on the rink, excuse me.

1:49:40 We went through a couple of different alternatives, and we pretty much landed on a construction estimate of between $14 and $15.5 million for just the rink and the roof. That's no support structures. The lower cost is using a manufactured roof structure, and the $15.5, the higher estimate, is using off-the-shelf girders and kind of standard construction. What that looked like.

1:50:06 As a footprint, it was very similar to just the baseline. We never deviated from using the Olympic... I agree. Deviate from the Olympic ice sheet because the programming was driving the design. And then for reference, I have the gray area for the parking also shown on here.

1:50:28 This is just kind of a footprint of what we designed, too. This is just an Olympic sheet. We put in some buildings on the south just to understand what that would look like, but that is not included in the estimate. A couple of renderings. Pretty bare bones. This is just off-the-shelf steel. This is really moving away from kind of that iconic structure that we had designed. Simple pitch roof. Still walls on two sides for noise.

1:50:55 Again, no support facilities. We have the bathroom shown there because that's what would support the structure. So we started to look at alternatives because we knew that this was not viable, not answering that $13 million question. So we talked about prefab steel. We talked about wood. We talked about glue lambs. And it's just very difficult to span 130 feet for an Olympic sheet and still hold literally millions of pounds of snow.

1:51:24 So we started looking at some other alternatives, and it came up of using a tensile fabric structure commonly referred to as a manufacturer's name as a sprung. And after a few days in our, Stu and I's immediate knee-jerk reaction to the alternatives, our consultants came back and said that they could buy that structure for under $1.5 million, which got our attention. When we're dealing with $6 million plus in just superstructure,

1:51:52 And we found an alternative where we can build that for a million and a half. It kind of made us think, okay, we should probably look into this a little bit further. We spent a healthy amount of time looking at the facility as a whole. And what we have estimated is a complete programmable facility that includes pretty much everything that was in our original project. Lobby space, restrooms, locker rooms, storage spaces, concession spaces.

1:52:19 We added bleachers, and it still has an Olympic ice sheet. It does not include the parking, and it does not currently include the option for a mezzanine, and we'll talk a little bit about that later. The construction estimate came in at $11.3 million, which included $1.1 million in design contingency and the purchase of the sprung. So that is an all-in cost. So that actually answered the $13 million question. We can't afford this. It all fits within that $13 million budget.

1:52:50 Just for comparison what that looks like, this structure is a little bit longer. You can see the original footprint we took out. The community space is now kind of in line in that rectangle and not kind of off to the north. That shaded area to the north is the parking area. It actually allows us to design a little bit more better-flowing parking.

1:53:11 The design included just really using an off-the-shelf sprung design and just kind of carving out the chunks of space that we felt were necessary. If approved, we would go through an exercise with Vanner, our partners at the Kings, HMC, to really dial this floor plan in. But the idea was everything fits, and everything fits really quite easily. We had our consultant do a couple renderings.

1:53:41 We understood the programming pretty early on was going to work out quite nicely, and we felt that our challenge would be, you know, really having the conversation with the community about the aesthetics of the building. So we tasked HMC with just doing a couple of renderings just to show what could be done. Stu and I have done a lot of research on what other communities have done, and we learned what we have here in town are not the best examples of what can be done with the sprung.

1:54:10 We wanted to provide some alternatives to the community so that we can see what could be done. Just a quick kind of analysis of these alternatives because, you know, I think that sprung structures in this community kind of have, I don't know, a misnomer. They kind of already have a reputation, let's say. Stu and I initially thought that these were temporary structures and we have learned that that is actually not the case. Their life cycle is about 65 years.

1:54:41 The aluminum is warrantied for 50 years. If you replace the panels about every 25 to 30 years, which is recommended, it's an indefinite lifespan. They are actually a permanent structure if you do the regular maintenance. Opposed to the rink and the roof, steel structures, the framing, 100 years plus. I mean, there's tons of examples of structures that were built with steel that were well over 100 years old.

1:55:06 And the roofing would need to be replaced every 40 years. So thinking about some of the overall maintenance, it's actually not that different when you consider that you actually have to do regular maintenance on the rink and the roof. Construction cost, $11.5, $11.3 million, compared to $14 to $15. Support facilities for the sprung, they would be complete. And as we have talked about, the rink and the roof had none.

1:55:32 The planning and environmental, it's under review. The rink and the roof, we are complete. We have had a couple conversations with our consultants at Michael Baker and our legal counsel, and we think we have an understanding of the path forward on environmental. And along with the planning, have had some conversations with Sandra and her team, and we think we understand what that's going to look like as well. It is complete for the rink and the roof.

1:55:58 Programming, as Stu will talk about, has actually expanded with the sprung structure, and it's limited with the rink and the roof because it is open and doesn't have any support facilities. We spent some time talking with our consultants about delivering the project. Constructibility for a sprung is incredibly easy, and as we all know, the steel structure is somewhat difficult as we went through that exercise. Construction time for sprung is very short. They're basically on a shelf in a warehouse. They're available.

1:56:27 Right now. Raking a roof is spanning multiple seasons, spanning winter, so it's a little bit more difficult. Management. As we're buying the superstructure and it comes with a construction manager and that price, Town of Mammoth Lakes can manage this project. If we were going with traditional construction, we would lean on Vanner to be our construction manager and our lead to help us through that project. And as we are buying the superstructure,

1:56:57 And a lot of the support facilities that go along with it, the bid risk is quite low. And as we know with our previous experience, the rink and the roof, that steel structure, the bid risk is pretty high. We're at the mercy of the market and tariffs and a number of other things that we can't control. So before the next slide, so sprung is alternative B and rink roof. Help me out there. Sprung is alternative A and alternative B is rink roof? I didn't.

1:57:27 Define them as alternatives. Okay. Yeah. It's just sprung versus rink in the roof. Got it. Okay. Thank you. As I mentioned, you know, we learned that the programming early on was going to work great, so we started asking questions about the aesthetics, because, you know, Stu and I were really not, our experience is a white, you know, pretty vanilla facility, so we said, hey, what can you do with it? So we put together a couple images just to demonstrate, you know, what other communities have done.

1:57:54 And we actually incorporated a number of these alternatives into our budget, including these roll-up doors. That's included. We thought that was a great amending to kind of keep that indoor-outdoor feel. Also helps with our air handling and so forth. Inside the facility, it's really no different. Functions just like our previously bid project would have. And these are just a couple more, you know, alternatives. In our bid, it does include...

1:58:24 Putting color on the fabric and logos and whatever we decide. We'll talk a little bit more about the recommendation. None of this has been decided. None of this has been vetted. We understand we will go through a process to figure out, but we tasked the architect with just demonstrating that you can do something different with the structure itself. So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Stu to talk a little bit about the programming. Steal the microphone.

1:58:52 So programming has been a three-year process, as you know, with the department and the Recreation Commission. As part of that plan your park process, that was how we developed the playbooks, and that was the desire of the community to see all the types of programs being daily, you know, weekend, season-long, special events, conferences, those type of things that were identified. Very lengthy process, you know, that's nine workshops, 170 people.

1:59:21 Lots of email comments, you know, 33, I mean, anyway, so it's very extensive. So the playbooks really dictated the design of the facility. That was kind of really how we wanted to start out this process. So programming and for design and the design of the ice rink itself. So what should be in the ice rink? How many locker rooms? How many spaces? How much storage do you need? You know, we're expanding on curling. Curling's a big deal, right? We need to get into curling.

1:59:48 We also looked at the summer rec zone. So the summer rec zone, as we all know, we've been through some presentations on our summer camps and programs. That is really the highest need that we believe we need to meet right now. So the summer camp wait list is growing. People have such affinity with our camps and programs. They want to be part of it. This facility can kind of provide that opportunity for that recreation. So we're really more excited about the summer opportunities because we just don't have that amenity right now.

2:00:18 And then the community centre was always a big part of how we kind of connected that ice rink, summer rec zone with the community centre, so making sure it's complementary, it's used for not only enhancing the existing events that we would have at the facilities, but also a standalone community centre that we know has high demand and a lot of use and a lot of needs. So there's a lot of complementary integration between all those. We talked about efficiency of staffing levels, that was very important, equipment and utility costs.

2:00:46 I provided in your packet a pretty extensive 12-page analysis. If you've had a chance to look at that, I've condensed it to one slide. Makes it easy, hopefully, for everybody. But the original exhibit had a lot of detailed information. If you look at all the different programming opportunities for the ice rink, all the different programming opportunities of the summer rec zone and how they compared to each other.

2:01:10 What we've done here is just provide you kind of a really high-level snapshot of what the existing ice rink currently provides to the community, what the multi-use facility, the bid project, was projected to provide, and what the Community Recreation Centre is projected to provide as well. So, you know, just right off the top there, length of season, we average 68 days. So, you know, over historically a five-year period, we're at 68 days. We estimated 173.

2:01:39 For the multi-use facility, we can get up to 196 with the new sprung structure because it's fully enclosed. We actually control the humidity levels and the air of the inside temperature, so the ice is a lot more efficient, less drain on the chiller and so forth. So we believe we can extend the length of the season.

2:01:58 Here's some really high level numbers. You know, we average about 7,500 visits our existing ice rink. That's about 110 a day. You can extrapolate that out and it gives you 19,000 to 21,000 visits in those duration of time. Revenue per season, same calculation. We average about $8 a visit.

2:02:15 And that's 60,000 currently up to 152, 172. These are just high-level numbers, not a high degree of analysis. I'm just running through some basic scenarios to demonstrate the different facilities and the choices. Reliability, right now, obviously, as you know, very inconsistent. We spend more time shoveling it than actually operating it.

2:02:34 The multi-use facility was probably about 90% reliable in regards to its uses because it did have the two open sides. But this new kind of sprung, fully enclosed facility would be 100% reliable. So that's a big call. Number of skaters, anywhere from 250, again up to 300 because you've got the Olympic ice sheet. That's 15% larger. Summer operations. So we only open that rec zone now for four public days.

2:03:00 Which are our kind of free skate nights in July is Parks and Rec Month. But you know, it's the summer camp, summer hub for our summer camp program. That's really where the greatest growth is. So those kids are there from eight o'clock in the morning to four o'clock in the afternoon when they get picked up. So there's a lot of opportunity to provide not only enhanced service for our camps, but also for our drop-in programs. Some of the programming we're looking at is kind of that free four to six drop-in period of time for our kids in our community. And then the evenings we'll start up kind of the adult leagues and those programs.

2:03:29 So again, you know, we're looking at length of season for the summer facility at 125, for the multi-use facility, the community recreation centre at 132, a little bit larger. Number of courts, here's an interesting number for you. Currently, believe it or not, we actually have the availability to run eight and a half kind of different court configurations. The half is the half court basketball compared to 23 on the Olympic sheet.

2:03:52 On the Olympic size in summer. So 23 different courts and opportunities for programming is quite considerable. And this number here, number of people for special events, this is 20,000 square foot of an Olympic sheet versus 17,000 for a NHL rink and it's 10 square foot per person, gives you the calculation for a special event.

2:04:15 About 2,000 versus 1,700. So again, just a very high-level analysis. We can go into a lot more detail in the attachments. And in the attachments as well, a lot of visual images of kind of what the interior would look like. But really, this is more about the functionality of the facility. So from the inside perspective, it provides more programming opportunities than where we were with the multi-use facility and considerably more than the existing ice sheet itself. So thank you.

2:04:47 I will go ahead and, oh, oh, go ahead. Sorry. Almost. Oh, okay. Sorry. Only a couple more slides. Almost there. So, thank you, Stu. So, just quick budget schedule and then finally our recommendation. So, just to recap, the budget, $13 million includes the sprung structure, the ice rink, lobby, bleacher, restrooms, everything that we showed you before. Includes a healthy contingency.

2:05:11 We do have built into that overall budget cost for bid documents and some additional environmental work. What it does not include is the mezzanine, that second floor community space, which I said I was alluding to. We started getting into this and talking to some members of the public and rec commission, and the idea that we could put community spaces, community center, hangout spaces on the second floor of the lobby, which could be as much as 6,000 square feet, was really appealing.

2:05:40 So I had our architects meet with their structural folks and just give me a baseline number for what it would cost to put the structural components so that at a future date we could add staircase, a lift, and then build out that second floor. So we're looking at about an additional $300,000 to put the structural components in. That doesn't include any of those spaces because we don't know what those are yet. We'd have to design them and then put an estimate to them. But to be able to do it, to have the structure in place, about $300,000.

2:06:10 Talking to our consultants about environmental, it's pretty critical that we provide adequate parking. I mentioned that this facility actually allows for a more efficient parking design. I did a quick quantity takeoff using some recent bids from our current projects. We're looking at about $650,000 to $750,000 for 100 spaces. And I was talking to Grady about this last night, and I think...

2:06:34 Just thinking about it as a parking lot is a lost opportunity. With all the work we're doing with walk, bike, ride, and this mobility hub study, I think we would probably want to take a step back and think about this a little bit differently.

2:06:47 This site really kind of marks the south, you know, easterly corner of town. It's a crossroads for a number of multi-use paths. It's a starting point to connect to our community corridor in Old Mammoth. So I'm thinking about this more as a hub, and I'm excited about using some of the resources we have for our...

2:07:07 Mobility Hub Study to kind of look at what else we could bring. We're required to do some electric charging under green building code. Maybe there's electric charging for e-bikes, you know, and kind of expanded services, put in some transit mansions and really make this a little bit more robust transit hub. So I'm going to recommend, and I'm going out on a limb here, that we maybe do a project study report for this and utilize or

2:07:33 Explore the opportunity of using STIP funding, which could be available as early as next season with the unallocated pot to support this project, or alternatively backfill road rehab dollars, get some road work done, just timing and money, moving some stuff around. So Warren's another conversation and a little bit more work, but I just wanted to plant that seed. And then a lot of our imagery shows the sport court.

2:07:59 And Stu has identified $200,000 in Prop 61, excuse me, Prop 68 per capita funding. That would basically pay for all the sport court. Because it's inside, we would actually get that maple-looking sport floor, so we're pretty excited about that opportunity. So that kind of covers that gap in the budget. As far as schedule is concerned, I mentioned that building a sprung structure is pretty easy. It goes up pretty quick.

2:08:25 We do have some work to do on the front end. We do have to go back, do some plans and specifications, do some design work. We need to look at the environmental disclosure, make sure that we have that done appropriately. Work with Sandra and her team to make sure we've done our planning review, including the overall review of the aesthetics of the project.

2:08:48 We think that we could probably get to a final design for the structure, the look and feel of it, and a foundation-only type plan by this fall. We've kind of discussed the idea of going out with the most expensive components as one, as the first sequence. So that's the foundations, the ice rink, town purchasing the sprung, putting in the utilities.

2:09:11 Because once we have that baseline number, we'll know exactly how much money we have to spend on the interior, which could include the mezzanine or additional spaces. So we want to understand that, have that dot number in advance. If we can make that happen this fall, then we'd have this winter to kind of design the other spaces, really start working on the award and kicking off construction in spring 2020, purchase all that stuff at the same time, and we believe we could be operational for the winter of 2020.

2:09:41 So with that, we took all this presentation to rec commission. They had a couple of specific comments. They were concerned, as staff, was about the aesthetics. They want this to be a building the community can be proud of. They want us to spend money on the exterior design and the facade. They want us to create a sense of space and provide landscaping and connection with the playground and the park. They want it to be fully functional.

2:10:08 They really gravitated to the community space and the mezzanine and that concept. Provide quality lighting and sound so it can provide all the stuff that Stu was talking about. Be energy efficient. With the Sprung, we do lose the ability to put solar panels on the roof, so we'll have to look at some other alternatives. And then really look at the design of the HVAC and AC system, which we don't disagree with at all. This is a completely different facility.

2:10:34 And Van and I have talked about that. That's going to reward a lot of work. So with that, recommendation. My last slide, I promise. We're recommending that the town move forward with the project expeditiously. Time is money. Like I said, we're looking at cost escalation. The more time we spend discussing it, the higher the price is going to go up, about 5% a year. Proceed with design and development of the fabric tensile structure. Update the EIR if necessary.

2:11:03 Submit to planning any modifications if necessary. And then we're recommending that the final design review be a joint rec commission in the design review committee process. And then return to town council when we're ready to award a contract. With that, that concludes my presentation, and I am happy to field any questions, comments, concerns at this time. Okey-dokey. With that, I will go ahead and open it to questions. Oh, okay, go ahead.

2:11:34 I just have one question, and then there'll be a lot more, I'm sure, but all of these designs that you're talking about, Haislip, this included the roll-up doors? It did. Okay. And as the doors roll up, then there's egress into the space through that also? Correct. And we'll need to go through that design process to figure out what that overall plan to get people circulating, but we did put some placeholders in there for doors and such. That's all I have right now.

2:12:06 My only quick question is the mezzanine. If through the process we find we cannot include it in the initial, does it cost us more to add that later than it would cost to build during the process? And can we still get the necessary equipment and stuff in, with all the roll-up doors, I'm assuming we can, to do the build in place if we don't do it immediately? I think it would be somewhat challenging to add that at a later date because those are structural components that are going to be built into the roof.

2:12:36 We could always look at trying to span it. We talk with the architects about buying a prefabricated kind of industrial mezzanine that they use in like storage facilities and maybe spanning it. But that would be something we would have to consider quite early on. And that's why we're recommending kind of that two-sequenced bidding process so we can understand our financials going into the design of the interior of the structure. Because for me, that's a very exciting prospect that is twice the size of the community center we had planned.

2:13:06 Roughly. So I... A couple questions. Can you speak a little bit about the timing of the... It's an SB1 grant for the Transit Hub Studies? Yeah, we have that grant right now. We are actually scheduling interviews with consultants to select who's going to be working with us on that project. So, and I think we've got...

2:13:34 Two or three years to expend that money. So it's reasonable to expect that the walk, bike, ride framework, that this thing could fit into that with that grant as part of that whole thing. Yeah, I think it's an exciting opportunity to discuss that. Yeah, I would agree with that. I think it's extremely important. The Prop 68 money, the per capita money, does that require an application? I mean, that's an allocation from Prop 68 per capita.

2:13:58 Yeah, that's part of the non-competitive. It's non-competitive, right? That's right. Prop 6-8 non-competitive. Yep. So that's just submitting an application saying this is how we propose to spend the money. We've already submitted the initial document for that. Good. Excellent. Thank you. How much is that against you? That's $200,000. Yeah. The county's awarded $400,000. Right. But we get word in line. We're allotted with $200,000. Okay. Does anybody want to say anything about the LA Kings? Not you. I got to ask these guys first. Sorry.

2:14:30 So our contact is actually with the operator, American Sports Entertainment Company. So that's our contact. So Brad is part of the design of the facility. So that's where our conversations have been. We haven't engaged the King's organisation since the previous bid process. So they certainly are aware of what we're doing. We haven't had any formal...

2:14:55 I'm waiting for some direction from us to figure out if that's a conversation. Correct. I think it's a bit premature right now. But from a design perspective, they're understanding what we may need. Okay. And finally, this is something that, in terms of the transit hub and those kinds of things, that could be something to head to the LTC with. Yeah, I don't want to dive into that rabbit hole, but yeah. You don't have to. There's a process there, but the timing does work out. Okay, good. Thank you. Okay. Kirk? Yeah.

2:15:24 I didn't, I mean, this is the first time I've seen this presentation. It wasn't in our packet. So, you know, I'm kind of struggling to keep up. So, we're talking about $3.8 million out of general fund dollars to meet the $13 million. Is that correct? Because we have R and U dollars there? Yeah, there would be, in the packet information, we'd be, at this point, identifying about $3 million. We've identified only $500,000 of that as general fund.

2:15:54 That would put us about $12.1 million. So if we need to go over that $12.1 million, that could be either, depending on timing, some additional other funding and or general fund dollars. But the majority of the gap has been, is recommended to be closed as presented, which would be R&U, the fractional Belarus money, the general fund and capital project dollars that are there.

2:16:17 So the general fund is $3.8 million. No, the general fund is $500,000 at this point. At this point. And if we have a little bit of a gap on top of that, it would be another $1 million. So $1.5 million would be the maximum general fund. And where do the other funds come from? You're going after STIP. Measure R. Measure U. So now we're going from $6 million, the bonding.

2:16:42 The 5.5, we're going to go back to Mammoth Lake Recreation and ask for more funding. Official reserves out of R&U, correct. Okay, take those reserves. Correct. That's one of the funding options, yes. One of the things in the presentation was there was nothing about rehabbing the existing site. Do we have any kind of, you know, cost analysis, estimates as to, you know,

2:17:11 Taking that site out because the school district wants us to put it back into its original condition. We had that conversation. We have an idea of what that would cost. We have had a discussion about what they might want to keep. So I think, you know, a worst case scenario could be, you know, we just took everything to the dump. It would be a few hundred thousand dollars. If they wanted to keep things, I mean, that diminishes or changes.

2:17:39 It warrants additional conversation with the district about what they want to keep on that site. And so the operational, if we go forward with this structure, the operational is about $550,000 a year, and the income would be about $300,000? So that's the pro forma we put together, you know.

2:18:04 Several times over the last couple of years. I know we have. I keep going back to it. Okay, what's it going to cost? So the numbers that I've kind of provided you in this presentation here is a lot more expansive than the previous estimate just because it's a longer season.

2:18:22 You know, we can operate that ice rink for a longer period of time than the other one and certainly the existing one. So to give you a definitive number right now would be difficult, but we estimate it's around that $550,000. We believe we can bring in the majority of that money with, you know, very little obligation of the general fund to subsidize that program, subsidize the facility. So our kids would still get an 80% discount? The kids are going to be free from four to six every summer and $2. Because, I mean, we have our fee schedule.

2:18:50 And we try to make sure that our kids can utilize that at a minimum cost. But you're saying it'll be completely free? Yeah, so from $4 to $6 in the summer and $2 for our school kids right now, that's kind of pretty consistent with what we've been doing. Yeah, we take a look at that cost of the kids, but that $2 or $3 for skating would still be retained. No, I want to keep it as low as possible. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, we want to keep it down there to where it's...

2:19:15 Very affordable for any kid to utilize our facility. And so adults would get a 20% discount, the leagues and the hockey leagues and everything else. How is this going to work? We have a lot of detailed information, so I don't know how much time I can kind of spend on it tonight going through it with you, but our typical subsidy for our facility is, you know, 80% subsidy to any of our recreation facilities. That's kind of how we do it from a programming point of view.

2:19:44 Typically, as you said, it's about a 20% cost recovery for adults and an 80%, sorry, 80% cost recovery for adults and 20% cost recovery for our kids. So typically how we do it, again, we can kind of continue to look at this facility and come back with some more detailed numbers. But I think the pro form is, you know, reasonably accurate. It's been vetted by, you know, the groups that we've been working with. Happy to continue to explore. And if we do get a go ahead, we'll certainly get in there and start running those numbers again.

2:20:13 I'll get back to you with additional information as we move along. Because I'm trying to get caught up on this because some of this is new to me. Mammoth Lake Recreation has committed. They have directed the council to utilize those funds. Not the remainder of the funds yet. We've put them on notice. We've given them a copy of this report. But until the council gives direction, if you want to move forward, then we would have to get a formal recommendation from them.

2:20:42 And then it would come back to Council again. Correct. It would come back to you if they recommend all or a portion or none. That would need to come back to the Council based on their recommendation as well. But we didn't want to prematurely go tell them, hey, we're doing this until we get direction to move. It's got a little chicken and egg with the back and forth process. Yeah, I think it's a good process. Yeah. So we want to make sure that they're engaged on it and they are aware of the ask that was presented tonight.

2:21:07 Well, again, if I could get a copy of this, it would be very helpful. Yeah. And we will provide everybody with a copy. We just actually just finished, frankly, as we were starting our meeting. So we will get a copy out and put a copy on the Granicus website. The agenda bill says authorized staff to proceed with the proposed community recreation series outlined in the report. And it's got two different options there. So what?

2:21:33 What is the real recommendation? So the recommendation is to move forward with the design and development of the fabric tensile structure. Which is option B. Yes. And to follow up on what Kirk was saying is that without the information, you still want us to make a decision tonight without this information.

2:22:01 If we get to go ahead to do that, then we will bring more information back. We'll work through that in terms of some of the financing. We weren't spending a lot of time updating some of the financials. Again, it was how much time do you spend on a yes or no, whether or not we have a project or not. So I think we have a pretty good number on the construction cost number.

2:22:24 And so to get to go ahead to move forward, then that would also then give Stu's team again to go back in and do some hard review of the operating cost. We think we'll have both a little more cost but more revenue also because of the type of facility coming forward and be able to move that forward with the actions identified here to be able to make that happen. But I mean, it's been otherwise just kind of circular.

2:22:49 Yes, we may like this, but go back and do a bunch of work. We'll come back to council and say, no, we don't like that. Go do work on this. And so we'd be going back and forth again as we have. I'm trying to short-circuit that process. It's been before us several times with the yes and no vote. Generally, it has been yes, and then the financials come back, and then all of a sudden it's no. Historically, that is the way it's worked. So that's something that... Correct. And I do have some questions if you guys are...

2:23:16 Done with questions? Okay, go ahead. Where in this do we account for the bond repayment? Remind me where that is. The bond repayment is coming out of the Measure R budget, so it'll be sitting out of that budget and those tax dollars that would come in from Measure R. Yes. Okay, thank you. Okay. So I'm looking, well, the summer operation, yeah, I'm actually looking at summer operation right now. When you've got the, for the sprung structure,

2:23:45 There's a few things on here that I have a question for. So the way that you're looking at it right now, in the wintertime it's going to be an ice slab. My first question is, is that slab for hockey or for ice skating? In other words, what density of ice are you using? Has that been decided yet? So I'm just going to...

2:24:13 Highlight the attachment if you wanted to kind of look at that. Yeah, let me go back to the winter because it's, that's a minor part of my question there. That's okay, but. Is it hockey ice or is it ice, figure skating ice? Everybody's ice. So nobody's going to be happy. So we can actually, with it, because it's an indoor facility the majority of the time, it's reliable, you control the humidity in the levels because it's, you know, enclosed, we can actually dictate the hardness of the ice, right? So we can change those configurations with that chiller.

2:24:42 Okay. We didn't have the opportunity with our current chiller. In the summertime, what you have listed here, some of these sports I'm not familiar with at all. Sure. So I'll pick on tennis because I am familiar with tennis. Yep. One thing that worries me here, so in the summertime, is the entire rink going to be a concrete slab?

2:25:03 No, so we talked about that previously. Remember, we wanted to look at exploring the sport court tiles, you know. So that gives you the opportunity to program that space so the tile would get laid down after the conclusion of wintertime. It would stay up for summer. It already comes pre-striped. So we dictate, and the little template is actually in this attachment that I think we've seen before. So you can actually look at the sport court configuration.

2:25:26 And then you have the opportunity to put the dividers in between each of those courts. So you can kind of run. One court could be volleyball, one is basketball, one is futsal. When you look at tennis, tennis is the 60-foot court. It's the pop tennis court. It's not the 72. So it's really looking at that to kind of grow the sport with our kids and the community. The full tennis courts will still provide that full experience. But for summertime, that's the way it's kind of being set up, which is something we don't have right now. Okay. And I don't know off the top of my head,

2:25:56 It does kind of worry me under tennis that you have regulation courts. I think maybe you're just referring to the size as compared to the quality of a court. There's probably 10 different types of courts you can have. I really don't see how all of these sports are going to be compatible with one type of surface.

2:26:24 And I know in the past when I brought it up with the tiles, it's just like, well, it's not really meant for the serious tennis players. It's just for people to start playing tennis. Well, I mean, that's fine if you're going to get people starting to play tennis, but then where are they really going to go to to play tennis on a real court? That's like saying, excuse me, you'll get a chance to talk.

2:26:52 These are just questions that I have and I have every right to ask them. So the fact that you have a regulation court down there is a little bit disturbing to me because since I don't know about these other ones when it says regulation, is that just size or is that surface? Is that with what you have here, you would not be able to have a USTA event?

2:27:15 Yep. There, so why are you even including the word USTA in there? I mean, that's like saying, I don't know of a good hockey analogy, but that's just like, okay. And so the other sports, when you're talking about all of these sports, I think that's pretty ambitious. I mean, that's good that it's available for all of those things, but say that

2:27:42 You know, people want to, you have a wedding and a party and a party and a wedding over a weekend. Does that mean if someone is going to rent the, you know, half the facility, the whole facility, they get to rent it for a few hours? Does that mean the kids don't get a chance to go out there? I'm not really sure how that works. I'll answer the USTA. So the 60-foot court is a USTA regulation court.

2:28:08 Size. Size. Size. Yep, and that's why it's USTA, and that's a program that we've started with Patrick. He's here this evening, but Patrick started that. Wonderful program for our kids in our community. Get them involved in tennis, and that's really the purpose of the...

2:28:21 We know we're not going to replicate because being a tennis player, everyone wants to play on that, you know, hard surface, you know, post-tension concrete court. We have some, you know, reasonable asphalt courts, but this one is just really to introduce the kids to the sport. So when we're running our summer camps and programs and our drop-in programs, you know, in the afternoon, we can provide that experience, you know, for those kids, you know, introduce them to these different sports. And these sports that were identified here were just through the community's playbook.

2:28:48 So these are all the activities that we have tried to fit within this facility that can work. Will one court surface be perfect for everyone? Probably not, but will it satisfy the needs of all the activities? Yeah.

2:29:01 So, you know, we believe the programming is definable. In regards to programming it, that's something that we would love to have those problems dealing with. Someone wants to come in and would they take precedent over, you know, different activities and programs? We actually have a priority schedule right now that's through council endorsed. It's in our parks and recreation policy manual. So we would just kind of follow that kind of prioritisation policy already established.

2:29:26 So that's kind of how we manage a lot of our facilities right now. Okay, so the main focus of this entire is for kids to get used to playing all these sports. It's not for people to, because on one side you're saying, oh, well, we need it so our kids can be, you know, Olympic or, you know, NHL hockey players, but you're saying all the other sports are kind of like, well, you'll get a taste of it, but you're not going to get the full experience of

2:29:55 The proper floors. And, you know, before you think I'm going off on this, the high school gym floor has been replaced three times in the last 15 years. Well, it was the floor, it was replaced, and then it was replaced again. Because the flooring did not keep up with, it was hard on the kids' bodies at one point. They put in the, you know, the latest, greatest topping. It didn't work, and so then now they have the latest rendition of this. And so it's just very hard for me to

2:30:25 Understand that there is one surface for all these other sports. You know what, I tell you what, I'm going to have some more questions, but I'm going to go ahead, I'm going to open this up to public comment, but I'd like to point out a couple of things. I have received a lot of emails about this, however, I just received them in the last three, four, five hours. I've been in a meeting since one o'clock.

2:30:53 That didn't give me any time to review what people had written in. I did get some emails beforehand, but strangely not in support of that. So I want to let anybody who wrote know that your email has not been read yet. In public comment also, if you are just agreeing with someone that's...

2:31:17 Spoken before you, just go ahead and say, you know, I concur with this person. We don't need to hear the same comment because you do have five minutes to comment on this. Please respect that five minute comment. There will be a buzzer. I will stop you within about 30 seconds after that buzzer goes off. And I think that we've got some people who would like to speak up on this. So I will go ahead and open it up for public comment.

2:31:46 You can, we like if you state your name. It's good for the minutes, but you don't actually have to. So with that, I will go ahead and open up public comment. Hello, Council. Thank you for having us. My name is Paul Jeffrey. I'm a relatively new member of the community. I've only been here for a couple of years now. But I'm actively involved in the Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey program and just want to state a couple of things. This year we lost, I want to say, 15 days of our season because of weather.

2:32:31 And so an indoor rink in Mammoth is absolutely crucial for us just to continue to grow the program. It's been growing at about 30% a year. The kids love it. As you can see, they're all ready to say some things about it. In terms of the facility, everybody makes sacrifices because we're trying to make a building that's going to be good for our community on the whole. We're not going to have NHL players coming out of this.

2:33:00 Because it's an Olympic-sized rink, right? So even on the hockey side, we're still making sacrifices and we're still making compromises because if we had our weight, we'd make an NHL rink because that's how, you know, the bulk of the people in our community play.

2:33:19 Nobody stood up, so I came up before I actually thought about what I was going to say. Way to take the hit. Yeah, exactly. Just get it right off the bat. Anyway, I just want to pledge my support for this. I think the fact that the community center we could build, as Bill pointed out, is twice as big as the initial plan, is incredible. Having our kids have a central hub in town to come and be and congregate is huge. And in terms of the aesthetic,

2:33:49 The Pasadena Ice Rink is the same sprung structure, and it's beautiful. I don't think anybody has to worry about this being some big white eyesore in the middle of town. I think it can be something everybody can be proud of. And more than anything, I'm just tired of talking about this. And I think everybody in this room is. Like, it's been, what, six, seven years now that we've been trying to get this thing off the ground? So even before I lived here, I heard about this rink that was going to happen in 2017.

2:34:18 I would just urge everybody to sort of take a step back from the details and look at what this would mean for our community as a whole. It's going to benefit a lot of people, and I think it's a wonderful proposal, and these guys have done a lot of work to figure out how to bring it in on budget. So I just support the project, and thank you very much. Thank you so much. Public comments still open. I want to indoor ice rink because I'm usually really cold when I play hockey.

2:34:50 That's why I would like one. Thank you, young man. I want an ice rink because I hate that we have to stop in, like, the fall and spring. And I really like playing hockey because it's really fun. Thank you. I want to have an ice rink because I like playing hockey.

2:35:25 I hate that we have to stop really soon and I want to play all year. Thank you. That's it. Move forward. Hi. My name is Gosha Sur. I wrote a letter to the council. I don't know if you get a chance to read it. I am a former professional ice skater with many years of experience. I'm competitive and...

2:35:58 Just, I guess, entertainment side of ice skating. I also play hockey as an amateur and as this gentleman, I was very cold playing hockey last winter here in Mammoth Lakes at the league.

2:36:15 And I'm here to fully support the building of Nice Rink or Recreation Center here in Mammoth Lakes because a community like that really deserves one and the kids and adults and families, I think they would benefit greatly from having a facility like that here in Mammoth Lakes. That said, I just want to offer a few

2:36:41 A few thoughts on the two options. To me, the first option, the roof and rink option is really a no-go just because from a skater perspective because you would still have to deal with the wind and the snow and maybe hockey would be possible and much better in those conditions than just an open ice rink.

2:37:08 But figure skating, that would be very unpleasant, plus you'll get the noise, and you'll have the wind and everything, and exposure to elements. So the option B is a much better option in my view. My only personal drawback is that it lacks seating, bleachers, and it doesn't really, which limits really on the choices, how you can use such a facility.

2:37:37 in terms of having ice shows, competitions. I wrote in my letter, I think, that an Olympic size does allow for international competitions, ice skating competitions, and there are lots of different types of ice skating events now out there, such as generating tremendous support, actually, and participation from the community as adults.

2:38:03 Adult Figure Skating. It's not competitive. It is competitive in a way. It's ice theater that draws, I don't know, hundreds of people, participants at a time. It's precision skating or synchronized skating, what they're called. And again, a team of 20-some skaters. Many teams come in to compete at the same time. So you really put Mammoth Lakes on the map here as sort of destination for skating events.

2:38:31 For people to come in and compete and skate and enjoy the beauty of this town, of this region. So if, I don't know, I understand the budget constraints and the issues, but maybe I encourage Stu and his team to look at, to work with the designers to see if there's a chance to increase that seating capacity for the spectators. I mean, you can work around it by putting some seats on the ice.

2:39:00 And actually increase the seating, but then you would reduce the size of the arena, maybe to the NHL size or maybe smaller. So there are different options. Maybe it's the mezzanine option that you can use to kind of to add more seats. But in my experience, competing and skating all over the world, I think 3,000 is probably 2,000, 3,000 is the minimum that you want to have for

2:39:29 You know, to put together like a nice show that people, tourists and, you know, local community can come in and enjoy. Yeah, and just again, providing opportunities for local skaters, local communities to, you know, participate in skating shows. It's not only some people come in and perform, it's involving the kids who live here who enjoy ice skating, you know, having

2:39:57 Establishing a tradition of having ice Christmas shows here. It's all possible with proper facility. So again, you have my support and if you have any questions, I'm here to answer. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Hi, I'm Mike Coco. I'd like to thank you all for your time and effort and leading the council here as well.

2:40:25 I want to circle back to some things too. It's not just an ice rink. Keep the focus on the community rec center that we're moving forward with. Whatever you want to call it, epicenter of awesomeness comes to mind. There's so many good things that can be done with it. And Stu and Mr. Hayes worked really hard on meeting the $13 million question as you referred to it as. They've kind of brought forth everything everybody needed to see to a point.

2:40:47 And I think it's time to move forward on option B. I hope you could get behind that. Earlier in the meeting, there was a nice thing for John Connolly. And let's get behind that gesture by giving him a place to move forward with the programming he's done a great job at working with. Give him a place to have that continue to grow. And also to Mr. Wentworth's comment on.

2:41:09 Moving forward with things not being properly vetted. This has been before the community ad nauseum over the last years. This isn't done in a vacuum, I think was your words you used earlier. So it's been seen as a need and a fairly high priority need. I'd like to urge you to get behind this program. So thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Public comment is still open. Ned Baer. I've been in Mammoth since 2003.

2:41:42 And I remember playing in the Raise the Roof Tournament in 2015. This is my daughter, Chloe, who plays in Mammoth Hockey. And I think council is a really cost-effective opportunity here. And I think the ice rink can be a community space that will be the largest enclosed space that we have.

2:42:10 It's a lot more than just ice. This town needs to be about more than just skiing and snowboarding. We need opportunities, recreational opportunities for our kids in the summer and the winter. And we have bad weather here, so we need a roof over it. And I think right now we have a chance to make this happen. So I hope that the council will vote in favor of this. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you.

2:42:41 Good evening. Thank you, Council, for continuing to persevere on this everlasting issue. Staff, thank you. That was an awesome report. Very clear. I followed very clearly. It was awesome. Sounds like you might have actually, you know, you know.

2:42:59 You got the Holy Grail. You got the $13 million question answered. Listen, I wanted to mention just a couple things with regards to hockey itself. I just read something from USA Hockey. It just talks about the stats of participation among youth.

2:43:20 And this is from 2016-17. California saw the largest increase of 8-year-old players in its history, up 25%. And participation among girls was particularly impressive, jumping 49%. So that was two years ago. And it has been on the upward trend for the last 10 years. So hockey is really becoming a favorite of kids.

2:43:46 And we can see right here that we have a small handful here. If you've been down to the rink during our crazy cold winter nights, you'll see 40 young kids out there getting dressed in a blizzard outside. They're awesome kids. They really want to do this. And it's not just Mammoth. It's supported on all of California. It's taken off. One last.

2:44:14 Sentence in this article. It says, the USA Hockey's data has consistently shown that the growth among players ages 4 to 8 have a positive impact on retention in the larger group ages 9 to 14. So what that does is it's just further...

2:44:34 That underscores the fact that, you know, our youth even is, you know, going all the way through high school are very into this. I wanted to also add into, you know, if all things were equal and we ended up with a, with an Olympic rink, I know that as a hockey player you want to be on an NHL rink, but our daughter who now plays, you know, national tier one level hockey.

2:44:58 Half of her games in tournaments are on an Olympic-sized rank, and they do just fine. They complain a little bit, oh my gosh, got to work a little bit harder, but the playing field is level. So Olympics is okay for hockey in general if we're trying to save some money. I'm in favor of NHL, but I think it impacts our other programming, which is to be considered. So furthermore,

2:45:27 Sport court. So we have a number of volleyball, club volleyball teams in town, you know, from different age groups, right? Including Anne Bishop as well. These girls travel all the way down to Anaheim probably four or five or six times during their season to play in tournaments on sport court, okay? So it is, and they run 10,000 or

2:45:57 Tens of thousands of athletes through their facilities every year. This sport court is legit. It is not a compromise surface, okay? Maybe it's not the French Open's clay surface, but it is definitely suitable for certain caliber of tennis players. But for basketball and for volleyball, it is the court.

2:46:26 Material of choice. So that's all I got to say. Thank you. Thank you. Public comment is still open. Good evening, Council. I've got a little bit of a different take on this. I'm a grandpa, and my grandson started playing with the Mammoth Youth Hockey League here. Last year, he played for Bishop High School as an eighth grader. I went to all of his games. I've seen seven or eight different rinks.

2:47:03 And they're in towns that have no winter sports connection, no summer sports connections per se, but they have rinks and nice rinks at that. Just a couple of things, and I realize a bishop is a different thing, but they would practice here, I know, this would be their home rink, probably. In the fall, they went to Lake Tahoe because there's no rink here in the fall.

2:47:30 Batau has a year-round rink there. That's a three-and-a-half-hour drive. For their home games, they went to Valencia, California, a four-and-a-half-hour drive. Stayed overnight, played the next day in one of the other rinks of the seven teams that are in their particular league. These kids put a lot of time and effort into this. This is something Mammoth needs.

2:47:55 As I went around to these rinks, I said, I wonder about Aspen. I never heard anything said or read about in the paper about Mammoth Mountain being involved in this. And I realized that's over and done with probably at this point. So I went to look at Aspen. They have three ice rinks. I don't know if any of them associated with Aspen Mountain, but they now own the mountain here. I'm thinking they've got three ice rinks. There's not a major ski area that I could find. My wife put me to this test.

2:48:25 That didn't have an ice rink associated with it. As far as the Olympic rink, I think that's great. All of your foreign players play on Olympic rinks. Everybody coming here from Russia, from Europe, in the professional leagues plays on Olympic ice on that. I just think it's, as I say, it's something Mammoth needs to be a complete both winter and summer town.

2:48:49 You can't be a winter sports town without a decent rink for these kids to play in. And I think you're a judgment about going up to 300 people from 250, whatever that slide was. I don't think you're taking into consideration this figure skaters here. You have people coming up here to run. Why? Because it's high altitude. Why wouldn't you have figure skaters coming up here to tune up on that? I think there's just a multitude. You could go curling.

2:49:18 I've never curled myself, but I know of people that have. But you've got a lot of opportunities here to bring people in. So that's just my perspective on it. I hope you all vote for it. As I say, I think it's something that's really needed in the city. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Sophia Geffrey, and I'd like an indoor hockey rink because I don't play hockey, but my little brother does.

2:49:53 I know all of the players don't like having to stop in the middle of the year to have to stop playing hockey because the ice will melt. And another reason I like an indoor hockey rink is because I go to a lot of my brother's hockey practices and I stand with my mom and we are really cold and

2:50:23 And we want to go home. But, yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, any more public comment at this time? Sandy Hogan. And I'm going to come at this a little bit differently. You have to bear with me. I've got maybe two stories. I moved to South Lake Tahoe in 1970 and used to travel back and forth.

2:50:52 You know, to Utah a lot. And a lot of us would kind of joke that the only permanent-looking place in the state was Elko. Of course, we didn't go through Reno or anything like that. So we kind of laughed. But now I live here on the edge of the Great Basin, and I appreciate Nevada an awful lot more. It still has a lot of insubstantial cities, ones that look kind of temporary.

2:51:19 I came here in 1995. That was about the same time that the environmental group burned two elks up at Vail. Beautiful, fabulous, luxurious structure. Environmental groups burned it. So to rebuild it, they got a sprung structure and called it One Elk, affectionately, which we all did. And they rebuilt it. And then once it was rebuilt, they sold One Elk to Mammoth Mountain.

2:51:47 And guess where one elk is today? It was the town gave a temporary permit, and I signed the Forest Service permit as the authorizing official in about 1998 or 1999, something like that, for this temporary structure. Now, there's another elk over there. There are two elks there, separated. And, of course, we have another structure.

2:52:16 That's temporary down at the airport, another sprung structure. Now this one, and I want to thank the staff for doing some really good work in coming up with the idea of the sprung structure. It's functional. These are really good structures. And admitting that this will be a 65-year permanent structure. We're not looking at temporaries.

2:52:45 I don't know what the mountain is going to do now that we've got Altera, bought it. I know that that permanent structure over there, that lodge, was scheduled to be built in a, you know, planned in about 97, 98, 99, but it got out of the queue, and so who knows? But I guess my point is, you know, we may become the town of sprung structures.

2:53:11 And that's okay. I won't be here and you guys won't either when it's still there. My worry is the budgeting part still because what I see is the number one priority theoretically is housing. If this becomes the number one priority, every little bit of extra general fund or other money will be taken from housing and it'll go towards this. And our long term, you know, the long term revenue

2:53:41 You know, stream and all like that. We'll only know once we get into it. We all have our doubts or whatever, but I think we are still at 9.1 million, and we're talking about a building that's under 13 million. That's a pretty big gap. And while I want to commend everybody for the work, because I know you guys just keep going back to make it work, to make it work, and you have, I mean.

2:54:09 Up to a certain point. But the budget is still the reality. And I just want us to use our TOT to build things that we will be proud of, short term and long term. But if we want another sprung structure, that's the council's decision. Or if you want to think about it and see more about it, I would suggest that. Because we just keep going on. And as somebody said, it's,

2:54:40 Been going on a long time. I was very supportive of that roof over that rink over there years ago, and I still am, because our kids that are growing up will sooner or later leave here and go play hockey elsewhere maybe. It's good that we do have a nice rink, but it's not great. It's true. I just want you to think about what we're replacing it with.

2:55:10 And that's my comment. Thank you. We are still open for public comment. Hi, my name is Gretchen Seibert, and that's my son, Vincent, and he loved playing hockey this year, and there were lots of days when we were standing out there in the cold, and we were standing out there in the snow, and there were kids out there pushing the snow off the rink so that they could continue playing, and it was...

2:55:35 Very awesome to see, and it's a beautiful, beautiful rink, and it was beautiful with it snowing, but it would be really nice for us to be able to go and have regularly scheduled practices and be under a roof and be inside where the family members can come and be warm and not be wanting to go home because they're cold. And so I'm full support of this, and I think it was a great presentation. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, everybody, and thank you for your time. It's always appreciated. Dan O'Connell, Recreation Commission.

2:56:10 Let me share with you my initial reactions to this when I met with staff privately. The mood was very upbeat, so I expected some very good news, and we opened the page to the $14 to $15 million roof of the rink option, and I thought, oh no, you know, this is not good. This is not viable. We can't spend that kind of money on something that's so one-dimensional and really wouldn't serve the purposes and the programming needs that we have.

2:56:41 That staff seemed upbeat, so we turned the page and we get to the tensile structure. And I go, oh no, there's got to be something else here, right? But there were only two alternatives. But I have to tell you, it only took a few minutes of looking in the details of this for me to be enthusiastically supportive of it for many, many reasons. It serves all the programming needs that we could possibly think of.

2:57:10 And some. It has an approximately 2,000 person capacity. Now, we've never had any space in this town for conference kind of events. It's been something that's been talked about. And I would think that John Urdi and MLT would be all over this ready to promote it. As many people have said, there's so many programming needs that we can put into this and serve.

2:57:40 It's a management issue, as Mayor Hoff said. How do you juggle all of this? But I have a lot of confidence that staff will manage that well. When I was the owner of the bowling center, I'm no longer the owner anymore, but we managed all kinds of various events at the same time, upstairs, downstairs, in different spaces, bowling, and you just have to have a schedule and abide by it and juggle these different balls at the same time. It's a management issue.

2:58:10 Do that. I know staff can do that. I'm confident of that. So to your concern, I don't think that that's something you should be overly worried about. It's within budget with a $1 million contingency. And I asked Hayes at our rec commission meeting yesterday, I said, is that high? It's about 9.7% of the budget. And in my experience with construction, 5%.

2:58:37 Three to five percent is safe. That's what we built into our project. And so this is a very healthy, very conservative, large contingency to deal with things that are going to come along that are unexpected. My biggest concern the night after meeting with staff before the rec commission meeting yesterday was the aesthetics. You know, am I personally going to be responsible for putting something over there that people are not going to like?

2:59:08 And so that's one of my greatest concerns. And I think that that can be addressed as well, very competently. Even the briefest examples that they threw into this presentation, they just threw something up on the facade, and it looks great. And I think it can be done better even. And that's a process that we haven't even been through yet. So the aesthetics are very important, plus the mezzanine.

2:59:38 Very, very important aspect of this. You could have yoga classes or martial arts classes up there in that space, the windows looking down the ice, there's ice skating going on down below or in the summer, sports activities, so you have this dynamic multi, you know, experience going on. So the vision is there.

3:00:04 And we should take advantage of it. I see my time's running out. I have one other concern that I wanted to raise that Councilor Stapp raised, which is always the funding. And I just want to remind Council that communities don't build recreation infrastructure because it's a revenue generator that's positive or negative. It's for the health and welfare of the community. This is what LA Parks and Recreation does. They build...

3:00:30 As I think I've mentioned to you before, in every community, whether affluent or underprivileged, they have gymnasiums. And that shouldn't be the focus, whether it's a profit center or not. And those are my comments. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer any based on our meeting yesterday. I did watch the MLH meeting, so I have not gotten to the MLR. I guess this presentation was...

3:00:58 Given to MLR yesterday? Parks and Recreation. Parks and Recreation. Okay, that's right. I'm sorry. So I didn't get to see that. But I do just have a question. Say, theoretically, that this was something that could go into Mammoth Creek West, where it would be right by the back of your great facility. What would be your thoughts on that one aesthetically?

3:01:27 That's a good question. It's Mammoth Creek Park East, though. Oh, I meant. But I understood what you were saying. I just wanted to clarify that we were on the same page. I usually do left or right instead of. You know, I'm not an owner anymore, so I don't have any official opinion on that. But I would say that I would trust that the town and everybody involved in the planning would work with us.

3:01:54 You know, I would work.

3:02:20 As a hypothetical, I would work with the town and everybody involved to make sure that my concerns were met as best as we possibly could, but I would have to live with whatever the decision was, and there's pros and cons to all kinds of decisions that are made. I'd be happy with the proximity of it. Hopefully it wouldn't block too much of the view, the upstairs view from the restaurant I doubt would be impacted at all. So it would actually be kind of an exciting

3:02:50 Dynamic having those two facilities near each other. And where it is now actually still, you know, creates this very, you know, exciting dynamic environment where people can walk to Salsas, they can go to the Tavern, they can go to the Bowling Center, they can walk to Vons to get their Gatorade to bring back for the tournaments that they're playing in. It's close to everything.

3:03:18 But we're not here really to discuss location, so I'm digressing, but I'm trying to answer your question. No, no, I realize that, but you've got to, you know, realize that some of the other things that have been brought up. But my answer, the simple answer is, I have confidence in the town that they would work with me as an owner of my business to manage my concerns. Okay. And I'd have to accept whatever that was, you know, whatever the ultimate decision was. Okay, thank you. I didn't know that wasn't your...

3:03:44 Business anymore, so sorry about that. No, no, it's fine. Okay, thank you. Got a new business plan. Okay. I don't doubt that. Anything else? Thank you. Thank you, everybody. Good evening, Council. Betsy Turex, Recreation Commission Chair. I want to thank you for starting your meeting early because obviously we have a lot of people in the community interested in this issue.

3:04:11 I'm not going to reiterate the points that Hayes and Stu and Commissioner O'Connell pointed out coming out of the commission, but I do just want to add a couple of things. First, I want to thank all the people who are here and who have taken the time to speak with and email staff, the council, and commissioners. I personally wasn't really sure how this option of the sprung structure would be received by the public. In fact, I was pretty sure people wouldn't be crazy about it.

3:04:39 That has not been the case at all. I've just spoken to a number of people who are very excited about the possibility. I want to say thank you to Vanner and particularly our staff. Our staff have come back again and again to commission, to council, and I just want that to go, I just want that to be mentioned because they worked very, very hard, and we really as commissioners appreciate that.

3:05:03 So for the commission, this project has always been about meeting the needs of the community from the very beginning from Plan Your Parks to Plan Your Park to our three years working on this. So obviously we need a quality facility for everyone. We need something reliable.

3:05:20 And, you know, summer and after school programming to supplement our camp programs are a very important component of this. Personally, my daughter is a ski racer, so I don't have a ton of sympathy for people who get cold at sporting events. However, my daughter is also in middle school, and I would love for her to have a place to go after school that's safe, that has, you know, programming provided that's affordable. And so those are the things that I think staff and the commission have really had top of mind.

3:05:49 Through our public input process and through our own deliberations. I do just want to comment briefly on kind of the multi-sport thing because I know it does look like an overwhelming amount of programming in the non-ICE season.

3:06:03 Stu and Hayes traveled to the pavilion in Bend, Oregon. I traveled there with my family on vacation at my own expense. And this works very, very well at that particular facility. They're able to do all these different things. And the playbooks actually outline some different kind of, you know, priorities and how often those things will happen. So a lot of thought has gone into that. And one of the reasons, sorry guys, the reasons for making it Olympic size is to accommodate that non-ICE programming.

3:06:32 To get those three full-size courts, to get that variety, because that was a piece of advice that the folks in Bend were very clear on. Make your sheet big, because you're going to have more use than you anticipate. So just to wrap up the commission by consensus, we're highly supportive of staff's recommendation. Our direction to staff is really...

3:06:57 Focused on the design and aesthetic. Let's make this look really good, something that our community can be proud of. Let's look at some energy efficiency. The mezzanine community space is very, very important to the commission. We would really like to see that happen. We would really also like to preserve that indoor-outdoor feel with those roll-up doors. That's something that we really heard from the community. It's something we hear a lot from visiting teams who are here playing in tournaments. A lot of these kids play in Southern California inside, and they really like

3:07:27 That feeling. We really want to capitalize on the viewshed we have of the Sherwins, but it's also very exciting with this option that we can then fully enclose the facility so we will have that reliability. And that's really all I have. I'm happy to answer any questions coming out of our meeting yesterday. But I just want to say that all five commissioners are very, very supportive of staff's recommendation. Thank you. Still open for... Oh, I don't know this guy, but I don't really know if...

3:07:58 Good evening, Council. Nice to see everyone. It's interesting to be on this side of things speaking. So first of all, I'm going to apologize for adding to the litany of comments on this issue. I'll also apologize for anything that's redundant. And also because I think my thoughts are a little jumbled on this because I'm a little bit torn on this particular issue. This is something that's been pretty near and dear to me in the most recent iteration. I know.

3:08:26 Paul kind of mentioned this is something we've been working on for a few years. This is actually something that this community has had as a high recreation priority for almost 40 years. And so when I heard that we were proposing potentially a sprung structure for this facility that me and a lot of people in this room have worked really hard on, my initial reaction was certainly that I was disappointed.

3:08:54 The council has two options in front of you. Option A, I would agree with everything that's been said, is not a viable option. From a programming perspective, it just does not provide any functionality that we need, and it would be a step in the wrong direction. So focusing on option B, I want to commend staff for the effort that's gone into this. You know, I think...

3:09:18 There's been a lot of different iterations, a lot of different efforts, and I appreciate the creative solution that's come up to meet within budget. I think that is a position that council has put staff in. When towing a hard line on budget, it's really kind of put the staff in this position of this is really the only viable option.

3:09:41 I'm not sure if that's exactly the perspective that I would take in sitting on the dais, but I recognize that when I stepped off, I relinquished that control, and I respect how hard all of you guys work at this. So, you know, my focus, like has already been talked about a little bit, is really if this is the direction that we're going, and I've been around this long enough to know when the fix is in, that if this is the direction that we're moving in,

3:10:05 I just want to call attention to the fact that when we started this most recent effort, the predominant goal was to provide a facility that this community can be proud of. And it's something to step our game up from an amenity standpoint.

3:10:26 The frustration, I suppose, with this option is that I think it's not befitting of this community. When we talk about being the best high alpine recreation destination in the country, I don't think that a sprung structure fits with that. I think it's actually the antithesis of that. And so that's part of, on the negative side for me, is I think if we looked at a lot of our peer resorts, as we're already articulated,

3:10:54 All of them have this as part of their recreation amenity set. And I would be hard-pressed to think that a community like Telluride or Aspen or Steamboat would even be considering a sprung structure for kind of their cornerstone recreation facility as we move into the future. Those are kind of on the negative side of things. On the positive side of things, and I think there's a lot of positives here as well, from a programming standpoint, this absolutely meets our needs.

3:11:23 I think this facility comes in.

3:11:27 On budget and provides a ton of programming opportunities and really fits the bill there. I think when you're in a facility like this, somebody that played the sport of hockey for my entire life, I've been in a lot of different rinks, a lot of different structures, a lot of different materials. I don't think anybody cares when they're in the facility what the superstructure is made out of, whether it's steel, whether it's wood, whether it's a sprung structure. That really has no impact on the functionality of the facility.

3:11:56 So I think from a programming standpoint, there's a lot of positives here. And again, I commend staff for coming up with a creative solution to get us there. My concern lies around the aesthetics and whether this is really a facility that we can be proud of. And so I've seen a number of these structures in a lot of different places. There's a pretty wide breadth.

3:12:19 There's, on this end of the spectrum, there's the boring vanilla white tent. We've got three great examples of those in town that I don't think anybody's proud of. And I've seen some that are very well done.

3:12:32 And so my question, my concern, my charge to council is if this is the direction that we're going in, we are having a tremendous cost savings in moving this direction. So we need to pour that money and that effort back into making this the best facility that it can be. We need to look at roll-up doors. We need to look at a mezzanine. We need to look at a facade. We need to look at, you know, kind of a...

3:12:59 An entranceway that has some gravitas to it. I mean, these are all things that we can do to dress this facility up so that it not only functions for the community's needs, but is also something we can be proud of. So thank you again for your time and good luck. Thank you. It was good to see you. Good to see you. Public comment? Okay. Seeing no one jumping into action here.

3:13:30 You know, I have to thank all the kids also for speaking. It reminded me of about six or seven years ago when the question was about getting a swimming pool for everyone in town, the kids in town, and having people speak on that. That said,

3:13:52 I guess in a perfect world I kind of see and maybe this is not something that would ever do. Can you ever put an ice rink and then close it and then have a swimming pool and then close it and have an ice rink? Has that been done ever in any place or is that inconsistent? I know you've got basketball, of course. I was just asking, does anybody know?

3:14:21 Thank you. That was just kind of where my brain was going. I was thinking about all the kids that wanted a swimming pool, and I was thinking, wow, that would be good. Now the public comment is closed. I'm going to turn it back over for comments.

3:14:51 From Town Council? Okay, there you go. So I'm the budget person, or at least a curmudgeon. So RNU is $2.2 million, and then the general fund is $1.7, and then the operations is $550,000, and then removal is the $200,000. On the positive side, we've done really well with our...

3:15:21 with our TOT, probably about 4.5 million in excess TOT over the budget. So there's a lot of competition for those dollars. So I do want to continue to move forward, but I mean, there's going to have to be some discussions about where, you know, what's the priority. So let me give you

3:15:44 We have the, and Dan, this is, you know, if I look at this in isolation, that's one thing, but if I look at it in relationship to the parcel, to Trash to Nevada, to an IT program for,

3:15:57 For public safety, $5 to $7 million, deferred maintenance, which we're getting on top of. Town staff is doing a good job on that. There's a lot of competing needs for this. So I don't look at this in isolation. But I do look at it as something that we need to keep working on to try to move it forward. And that means, and John and I are supposed to sit down at some time, actually last week, and try to figure out.

3:16:24 You know, some funding tool, which means we might bring something before the whole community to vote on as to a funding source, not just for this, for recreation, but also for housing or some of the other needs. People don't like to talk about that, but, I mean, it needs to be put on the table. And if the people vote it down, then that makes a statement. And if people support it, that means we can move forward. Okay, thank you.

3:16:55 I really support this community recreation center. I profoundly support this thing. And a couple reasons. For those of us back with the Measure R and Measure U efforts, there's a lot of reasons why a lot of us worked really hard to bring those things forward and to get the community support for those measures. And it was a lot more than just building the infrastructure and building facilities and doing these kinds of opportunities. But it was to galvanize this community.

3:17:24 To be able to embrace and to own its future. And after a lot of work, a lot of setbacks, a lot of effort, the hustle, the grit, the persistence of the town's professional staff, but the volunteer members of the recreation commissions and all the advocates been supporting this thing, we're at a point now where we can address and meet the needs of the community. That's where it clicks for me. And it's going to bring these things together.

3:17:54 So, I support it. And I think the comments that were shared this evening, ex-Council Member Fernie, former? Yeah. Retired. Retired. I think we can call him finished. Finished. Well, not for now. We're not so sure about that. I wouldn't count them out. But that, all of the aggregate of comments here, I think,

3:18:20 Whatever motion comes forward, I would be supporting the aggregate of those comments. The aesthetics are important. Transit hubs are important. All these things we've got to do. But I think in this work, we're over the hub. And the connection of this to satisfy the community's needs is the paramount concern. And I think the issue of having something we can be proud in. I'm a big fan of Buckminster Fuller's. I'm sure you all know who Buckminster Fuller is. Buckminster Fuller would not be poo-pooing this kind of a structure. He'd be applauding something like this.

3:18:49 And the needs that it serves. So those are my thoughts and comments. Thank you. Okay. I was about to say, yeah, I know what you could say, but that's okay. Well, I too am going to say I wholly support this facility. I will agree with Colin that when I first saw the idea of a sprung structure, it did not appeal to me. However, part of the reason that we're here is because we have overlooked at and overthought out

3:19:19 The previous structure, the previous structure could have at the time we initially started this been built for 10 or 12 million dollars. Now it's a 22 million dollar figure. If we wait to see what happens in the future here, we're not going to be able to afford this either. I agree we have a lot of other needs. However, if I, and first I have to say the figures that have been thrown around up here versus what I'm getting from staff are two different numbers and I agree with staff's numbers coming forward. I won't belabor that too long.

3:19:48 If I look at all the possible future expenses that this town has, I'm going to be completely paralyzed to move forward the things we need to move forward today. Yes, housing is incredibly important. It is not the only important thing we have. The health and well-being of the people already living here and our children living here is of paramount importance. The town has needed a place for kids to drop into since me and myself and the county helped do the first...

3:20:17 Children's Center in Mammoth 40 plus years ago. So this is huge to me. The aesthetics may not be what I want, but I couldn't be more pleased that we have found something that we can do today that we brought back in the budget that this council asked for that can go beyond the building we were planning in terms of functionality. There is more seating alongside the rink.

3:20:43 There, if we can, not if, that mezzanine has got to go in. There will be a glass wall viewing area that the kids can sit in in complete comfort without getting cold and watch their siblings play on the court below. So I'm really excited by this. I think that we get too negative. We have too many things that the community needs. We cannot forget the community needs to satisfy our future housing needs. We have to move forward on more than one front.

3:21:13 Your turn. Those were three really excellent statements made by my fellow council members here. I don't have a lot different to say other than the community value of this, I think, is something that can't be understated. Our children, having raised a family here, it is not always easy. The activities that are available, if you're not a...

3:21:35 Downhill ski person have always been a bit limited. I think this provides great opportunities for our community, not only for the winter, you know, sorts of thing, but the year-round. I was thinking the other day, if you roll those windows up and you have concerts, you know, how good Felicity Trio would sound there with the sound coming out into the, you know, into the open. So I think there is opportunities for this we're probably not even fully realizing right now.

3:22:05 And I am so impressed with our staff. I mean, I've only been on council a year, but, you know, the fact that you've been slogging along with this for years and years trying to get this to the right place is just amazing. Of course, there are, you know, definitely competing priorities. And I think it's possible to hold priorities equally important at, you know, at the same time. There's no doubt that we cannot continue without addressing our housing needs. That is...

3:22:33 But the fact that there are already funds committed to this out of our R, out of our U, out of the bond that we've already, you know, generated, I think that we're really, really close to that, and I'm willing to work hard in looking at all possible avenues to make this happen. I think that it's the time, I agree with Colin, when I first, you know...

3:22:56 Saw this as kind of like, but the fact that I've been in some of these and some of my family in the Midwest play in, you know, structures like this and speak very highly of it, I think we can make that really nice if the priorities from this council, as we've already said, that the aesthetics of it are important and I think there's no one on staff that doesn't also agree with that. So thank everyone for being here tonight and continuing the interest and the...

3:23:24 And I think we, when we decide this, we should embrace it with great enthusiasm, with great pride that we're able to accomplish something and that, you know, good on all of us for hanging in there and making it happen. So thank you, everyone. Okay. I also would like to thank everybody for coming out and speaking, but on the other hand,

3:23:48 I do want to let you know a lot of people do not come out and speak up in these meetings because they know that they are going to have an angry group of hockey people saying and having to look at the kids and then go, no, you can't have that. That's very difficult for people. I do get the emails.

3:24:06 But for people to come up here and give a different opinion has been tough for people, especially from some of the responses that have happened in meetings. So I do want to point that out that also I am very worried about the money on this. I think that this is something that

3:24:28 When we first got the bids back for $19, $20 million, I think everybody was a little bit floored. I wasn't quite as... I figured it was going to be about $18 million. The fact that that bid came in so high really just kind of solidified in my brain that I don't want to make a decision until I really know what...

3:24:56 What we're looking at cost-wise. The sprung thing, no, I don't think that that fits in this town whatsoever. You know, people say that, you know, it'll last 65 years. Well, guess what? People keep telling me we should ban bottles because they last in a landfill for 120 years. So, you know, let's make it out of plastic bottles. I don't think that that's, just because it's got longevity, it doesn't mean necessarily that it's going to have the look. And I'm very worried that it will be something

3:25:26 That is going to be, yeah, well, you can get a sprung shelter, sprung building for this price, but it's going to be something that aesthetically is not working. As I said right now, ice skating is the really hot topic. Years ago, it was swimming. What is going to be the next thing? We're going to have a bunch of kids going, oh, you know, I wish we had a bigger library. I know that's not going to happen in Mammoth, but that's okay.

3:25:56 So at this point, no, I'm not 100% behind this. When I was running for office, I was very clear that I think we have to have our growing food before we have our candy, and I do kind of put this in candy. Yes, you know what, physical activity is important, but we do have a lot of people that have physical disabilities in this town that just this won't be an option because it's...

3:26:20 It's very targeted towards some certain things. We don't have maybe the population base that would allow it to have tennis courts where you can take wheelchairs on or something like that, just for an example. So I appreciate everybody weighing in on this. I appreciate all the work that's going on. Yeah, it's dragging on and on, but I think my first...

3:26:49 My first priority is to make sure that this is something that we can financially afford. And I just, I'm going to be honest with you guys and let you know where I stand so you can write me letters later on it. But I'm not really comfortable with this because, frankly, I just really don't know what this is going to look like, bottom line, all in, with the cost.

3:27:19 So if we don't have any more comments, I'll turn it over for... I would love to make a motion, Madam Mayor, if I could? If I can make one last comment. Sure.

3:27:32 I'm going to probably vote no on this, not because I oppose it. It's just that the council hasn't talked about a priority of the other list. And I think that we need to do that because we do have, you know, housing and IT and all of those other things that are on this list. So I support it. But I do want to send a clear message to the hockey players and everything else. In the bottom line, we might have to not.

3:28:00 Fund this. So it's not that I'm opposed to this. It's more that I'm worried about the community to the town's budget. Thank you. Sorry, Bill. I didn't mean to interrupt. No, that's fine. And I would go off on to diatribe now on what you just said, but I will not. I will make a motion to authorize staff to proceed with the proposed community recreation center as outlined in the staff report option B. I'll second that.

3:28:30 Further discussion? Yeah, I would just add to that that from a priority setting session, I go back to this. Make sure you're taking a look at this. It's not in, you know, it's not ranked order, but these are the priorities of the council. Housing is there. That's in no particular order, number one. Just if I could. I know you can, but I'm just letting you know it's not in order. The community understands that this council established priorities.

3:28:58 And I'm not serving on a council that can't walk and chew gum at the same time. And I think it's our goal to balance competing priorities. And I believe that this is something that we can do while we're putting a lot of effort and a lot of time and a lot of money into housing. And I think we can do all these things at the same time.

3:29:15 We do our homework, we establish our priorities, and it fits within that, so thank you very much. Thank you for going on for me. Okay, and you know what, I'll go back and hold that up, and I will tell you that I think that that was something that we all did set our priorities. We had some conversations, but then that list actually stems from information that was taken from us each individually.

3:29:42 Yes, it was. Each individually to rank priorities. So while that is on there, that wasn't what I really received from the conversation, so. So just, Madam Mayor, going forward, these are the priorities that I'm working for. Okay. Madam Mayor, I call for the motion, please. Yeah. Okay. No, the motion's been made and seconded, so roll call, roll call, please. Yes. No.

3:30:11 Yes. Yes. No. Motion passes 3-2. Thank you very much for your attendance. I'm going to go ahead and take a break and so we can let the room clear out because I don't think anybody's going to really be sticking around for the rest of the meeting. But we will be talking about TOT revenue. Please don't do that again. I was finishing up my business. Thank you.

3:31:13 Okay, we are now back in session. We are to item 14, discussion and possible action regarding allocation of transient occupancy revenue based on current and past political commitments. Dan, I think you're going to take this one. Oh, and this was in reference to questions from Councilmember Stapp.

3:31:43 So I guess I'll start with you. Yeah, I'll kind of walk through it and then open it up for council's direction, comments, et cetera. And I appreciate the information and the request. If I can interrupt. I provided to council this, but the town manager informed me that the questions that I proposed at the end, probably because it hasn't been agendized, can't be addressed. So I'm not too sure how the...

3:32:12 Council wants to move forward. I think those questions are important, or at least I, you know, from my point of view, I'd like to pose them to the council. So if I can ask the town manager, you know, to, and I do want to back up one question. I thought Rob's analysis was very good, but there was a lot of political commitments along the way. So I just wanted to interject that this is my

3:32:43 Understanding, and it's not part of the discussion. Okay, wait a minute. So point of order, that means that whatever questions he had posed, we... In the written response that was put out, and I can address, there's some questions for council, and it came up earlier in terms of long-term funding for elements that deal with TOT and others. The council can request a future agenda item where we can lay all that out, and that...

3:33:10 It is more than appropriate to request that particular issue as we get into the Councilmember reports and requests going forward. But a number of Councilmember Stapp's questions are not really related to TOT allocation as such as it's currently agendized. And that's why I think to really properly discuss those would require agendizing it for a future meeting. And I think under just right to that point,

3:33:38 Two elements here. One was the report coming back with a lot of discussion about the T.O.T. allocation, the political commitments, past and present, and I've had some discussions with Member Stapp on this. He's got a lot more history on this than I do, frankly, and working through some of the historical elements of the T.O.T. commitment. So that actually has been healthy. As we look at overall funding going forward for other elements within the town,

3:34:06 As outlined in the comments from the member staff, that item would need to come forward as a separate agenda item and request it accordingly. The item before you walks through some of the history, at least as I understand it, again, a lot of this is before my time and elements there and how we laid that out and the whole multiple major A's and a major T in terms of the allocation of TOT revenue.

3:34:33 So I was trying to go through a lot of this. We had the original political commitments that were, to my understanding, dealt with how we funded marketing and tourism. I'm not going to spend a ton of detail on this. You've got the report to read. We had stuff for transit, for housing. And I think that as these came forward originally, it was Mammoth Lakes Tourism. It was Eastern Sierra Transit Authority and Mammoth Lakes Housing is those elements.

3:35:03 Not always those dollars always going 100% to the agencies, but those agencies were identified in a lot of the political commitments. At the town level, there was two pieces. One when I call for the general fund and also one for community facilities, 1.5 points of our 13. The 1.5 points was suspended in 08-09, and I'm not sure we ever fully levied that amount. I couldn't see that in historical budgets, but that amount may have been spent.

3:35:32 So we've done a couple adjustments to political commitments in the past. One was on that, the 1.5. That was the council's direction looking for that for community facilities. The other one was really with the whole bankruptcy filing and the lawsuit settlement. There was a lot of elements moved around in that, and I walked through that in the staff reports. I'm not going to walk through each of those items, but the readjustment of the TOT at that point in time, 11, 12, 12, 13.

3:36:00 Very significant impact there. More recently, the end of 15-16, going into 17-18, Councilmember at the time, Fernie and Wentworth, went through a process that said, we want to take a, the term we use is recalibration of the TOT allocation. It's a re-looking at the political commitments. One of the primary elements for that was to put more money back toward housing. Seeing that need coming, seeing the challenge there,

3:36:30 And so we went through a whole process looking at what would it take to do something different there, not handicapping the town too badly regarding its ability to operate. Again, same thing with our tourism dollars and the issues there. But the goal was how do we get it back on a footing that says at least there's a percentage allocation to housing, there's a percentage allocation to transit and to TOT for tourism marketing dollars.

3:36:59 And I think it was an ambitious goal to say how do we reset our allocations but not substantially impact other operations. And I think that goal was achieved for that process. The report outlines, if you are looking at, I used a 17-18 year because we have a hard dollar amount of actual revenue that came in. So if we were to reallocate that revenue based on the original clerical commitments, it's page three of the staff report.

3:37:28 Walks through and says, here's what would happen there. You know, tourism would get $3.7 million. That would include our business license tax and the share of TOT. Transit, 1.4. Housing, 1.3. And the town, 11.5 million, roughly in those numbers. As we came back into the B calibration with the MLA settlement, that

3:37:57 Chart on page four kind of lays that out. There was a number of adjustments made there, who got what. I won't read you what's in the staff report there. But the two elements in there that I just note in the text, one was on the housing side, the town continued to make a commitment to pay debt through some of the loans and stuff over there that we needed to honor that. We didn't want to have either MLH upside down with those loans and or the town being impacted through not maintaining our commitments through that.

3:38:27 Which was a couple hundred grand a year. The first year, closer to $273,000. The other element, I didn't put it in here because we borrowed a bunch of money from our vehicle reserve account. We're paying that back over time. That would add to the overall debt. It had a different term than the settlement numbers. But all of that comes through that process. So we tried to take a look. And this really started the discussion on.

3:38:52 How do we look at a reallocation of dollars based on all these different moving parts? So a lot of effort and time went into that. And frankly, we ended up, this is page five of the report, of where we are today. And there's a couple of key elements in there. One was getting things back to a percentage base, but also tying it to budgeted TOT versus just all the dollars passing through automatically to the various areas of...

3:39:17 Political commitment being the tourism marketing, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, transit with ESTA, and housing with Mammoth Lakes Housing in the town. So each of those elements walk through that. The other key element there was tying it to a budgeted number, then you do end up with this reserve categories by those areas of commitment. And I know that's been a little, that's probably the biggest uniqueness of the recalibration.

3:39:47 Getting back to the various areas I think has been helpful, but we did come back in and say, you know, there's going to be a different way of handling excess revenue, if you will, or unanticipated revenue through that. I think the other key takeaway as we walk through this, and this is on page six of the staff report, but was looking at in those areas, the

3:40:09 Net reduction in the area of tourism based on what would be a total of $18.1 million was about $325,000. So MLT did take a net loss, plus we have the reserve number. So you may look at that as a double whammy from the perspective of some of the partners that we have funded. Transit, just about $70,000 reduction. And then the town itself, about $359,000 reduction.

3:40:39 And those things were able to refund into the housing category then, $754,000 back into housing increase-wise. So we actually were able to get more dollars back into the housing category as a priority without really gutting any of the groups, but also not making the town take the large hit either in terms of being able to operate. So there was a number of goals, I think, that were achieved through that process.

3:41:06 And given the fact that we've walked through these, all the various ballot questions, and I know there was a number of political commitments made for the ballot questions, the various fundings, I know there was political agreements made, you know, with the community and the council to do those things. All the ballot questions, though, do put these funds into the general fund for governmental purposes, legally. Morally, we have a commitment made by previous town councils.

3:41:33 How we continue to honor those commitments, I think, is important. But it does give Council flexibility, and so in terms of walking through this, I wanted to just provide a report. Here's how we got to where we're at today. If that's working for everybody, great, boom, we move forward, we continue to do it. If Council wishes to modify it, you can go back to the original commitments and say we want to reinstate that, we want to do something different, we want to handle different pieces differently.

3:42:00 There's a number of policy questions there, and this really is a matter of a policy discussion by the council, so staff is not necessarily making a strong recommendation one way or the other, other than if you make dramatic changes, it will impact the next items on your agenda related to the budget. To do that, I think to member staff's comment, if we want to look at a much broader level of funding elements for other priorities for the town,

3:42:27 Then we need to bring that back separately, which can include re-looking at how we allocate TOT again. But there's a number of other elements there, whether it's a ballot measure or other options for funding a litany of priorities that the town has identified. And some of those costs and stuff that are coming forward, they're going to come regardless. It's not just a matter of a priority. There are other elements that we have to deal with. So what I was hoping from the report here is that

3:42:55 Kind of for the council, you're new in terms of the majority, in terms of getting to this point. You all have an element of history in this. But if it's working, then we continue. If you want to adjust it, give us that direction and we'll do that. If it's more of a desire, no, let's bring back a broader policy matter. I'm going to suggest probably one of our August meetings if we want that. Then we can do that. But this here was to try to set, here's how we got to where we are today. So hopefully that's clear in the report.

3:43:25 I'll stop at this point. I can answer questions, and then it really is a matter of council policy of how and where you want to take this. Thank you. Okay. We'll go ahead and open it up for questions. I have no questions. I think this report was done extremely well, and I am completely comfortable in the current allocations of these. While we have strayed from the original political commitments, times have changed. We have put money where we need it to be.

3:43:57 We have spent far more on some of these things than what the numbers here show already, and I'm very happy with the work that we have done as a council, and I am more than ready and willing to move this forward as is. Questions? I don't have any questions currently, but having the person probably with the least long-term memory of this, because everyone else has been doing it longer, and Kirk longest of all,

3:44:33 I think I understand the sort of saga of this topic. Your staff report, which I appreciated, kind of once again spelled it out. Just for clarity, Kirk was a person who first explained this to me back when I decided to run for office, so I have his point on it too. I understand the recalibration and thought that that was a good move, very thoughtful.

3:45:00 The way that that was addressed in reallocating the points of TOT, so I think that seemed to be well. That is only two years in operation. And while I always have some questions about how to receive some of the input from Kirk, I think I understand where he was going to. And the discussion going forward, particularly around housing, is...

3:45:24 Where do we go and how do we get to a sustainable funding source for housing? And all the other list of outstanding and potential debts, some of which I don't necessarily agree completely what that might be, but there is a list of things that are going to be coming at us as time goes on. So for the moment...

3:45:49 While I feel that we need to have that conversation very soon about a sustainable long-term funding source for housing, I don't think it's tonight because, number one, I'm not prepared because the questions that are brought up, I don't have the information on to even begin pondering that tonight. I think that the recalibration is running.

3:46:14 And I think I want to see where that goes. And I do want to get into the housing after a bit and really look at what actions we might take to secure that. So for the moment, I'm happy to proceed as we are now and bring it back sort of after the budget is approved and we're moving further on into looking at what the actual cost of some of the parcel work is going to be.

3:46:45 So that's where I am tonight. Yeah, I tend to agree. Are we deliberating now? No, I was just asking for questions. I don't have any technical questions. Oh, okay. It all makes sense to me. The rest of us deliberating, so go ahead. Yeah. Well, so, yeah, I'm happy. I'm okay with where things stand for the moment. I think what's been interesting is that MLT...

3:47:19 Here's the first thing. It's important from my understanding of the Measure A and Measure T is we're talking about commitments to program areas, right? We're talking about commitments to housing, transit, and marketing. We're not talking about commitments to individual organizations. We're not talking about commitments to MLH or to MLT or to ESTA or anything. We're talking about the money that we have, which I think is consistent when Colin and I did this work with the political commitments.

3:47:49 That were made when these things were voted on. When I went back and read the resolutions, what the questions put in front of the town, I don't recall seeing money going to MLT. MLT didn't exist at the time, I don't think. Or money going to MLH. It was consistent with the law. It was two program areas. And I think that Colin and I, when we worked on this, we wanted to honor that, those political commitments being to those

3:48:17 Program areas. I think that's an important distinction. If there's a question about that, I'd love to hear about it, but that was certainly what we did looking at the original legislation, what the voters voted on. It was two program areas. The second thing is watching this being implemented. I think Colin and I wanted, I think that previous council wanted to get more money to housing, which is the net effect of what this did. It's not going to address all the issues. To your point, Linda, we don't quite know what we need yet. We need to get that understood.

3:48:47 But we went through a process with MLT and the MLT board on those reserve funds of how the MLT board or one of these organizations working in a program area could say, hey, you know what? We think we see some things that are consistent with the voters' intent around marketing that are important to our board. We want to have a discussion with the council about allocating some of the money in the reserve funds to these program areas. And we did that with the wayfinding thing and some other things. We had discussions about this.

3:49:17 As an MLH board member, Monday night, we talked about this, but MLH is still not clear as to how that, the MLH staff is not clear to how that actually works. And I think we requested Rob come back and give a presentation to the next meeting so that there is a process there, which is if MLH in the housing area were to say, we see a need here, we want to talk to the town about tapping that reserve bucket, bringing that question back to council.

3:49:45 That can happen. But I was, you know, it's confused. They're not quite clear how that works. And that would be very helpful to help them to understand, hey, there's money in the housing reserve. We see need. Here's something we want to do. Vote on it as a board. Bring it back to the council. We can talk about it. So I'd like to see that get fleshed out so people understand how this whole thing works. But for the time being, I agree with.

3:50:08 Member Salcido, Member Souser, I'm okay with things as they are at the moment. I think we're going to have to find revenue sources for housing, most likely, but I think we've got some discovery and technical work to do to figure out how much money are we talking about, what kind of an instrument do we want to use to bring that question to the public so it's going to directly address the questions that we're going to need to solve, and I don't have information yet. I don't know how much we're going to need or what it should look like or how we should structure it.

3:50:38 I think coming through this housing with the stuff with the parcel, I think these questions are going to start coming to the surface pretty quick. Question or? No, comments. Oh, okay. I was going to, I know I've got a public comment. I'm going to let council finish because we are at our choice chance. Okay. Well, yeah, if you've got a comment, go ahead with it.

3:51:04 Oh, gee, thanks. I scratched my head with this finger, not the other finger. I put this on here because it's been brought up several times at several summit meetings and everything else that, you know, hey, you know, there's going to be a need for extra dollars for things like, you know, the parcel and all that sort of thing. And you look at some of the other costs, you know, I mean, the town's budget isn't going to be able to carry all these things as they begin to hit us.

3:51:33 So I, you know, in the discussions and the things that I've participated in and everything else, that's why I put this together. We're not supposed to be able to, or at least I was told by the town manager, because my six questions aren't agendized.

3:51:48 That we can't really delve into those. I think it's a council discussion. That's all I was looking for out of this. Let's talk about these things and figure out where we're going to go. Are we going to put something on the ballot or not? I mean, that was the question. And also, I tried to give just the history, where we are now.

3:52:07 That's what my memo, you know, and I'm sorry it wasn't included. I thought I got it in. I tried to get it in as soon as possible. But that memo just is part of the history. And then where we are at the particular moment, I thought Rob did a good job on that history. And now where are we going to go? And when are we going to have that discussion about, you know, we've got a whole bunch of things that are slowly coming at us.

3:52:36 My goal was, and partly because of the summit and everything else and some of the consultants that have brought up issues as to how these things are funded. We have the low interest tax credits with the Trump moving the 35% corporate tax down to 21%. They're not available. The competition is so much stuff, it has stiffer now.

3:53:05 So we've got some real issues, and council needs to be able to engage that, you know, not just from an agenda, but from a discussion point of view. Well, I'd just say two things. One is I think that in the team that the staff has put together around the parcel, my understanding is that there's going to be some expertise in there once we get to a pro forma, once we go through the charrette, once we understand what the community's values are and what kinds of things we want to do.

3:53:33 Then we're going to be able to get some advice that says, okay, your community wants to do something that looks like this. And in order to do this, to finance it, it's going to look something like this. And then we'll have some information and then we can start figuring out, okay, what are we going to do about this? And the second thing, Kirk, just with all due respect, when I get those things in my box from you or from any other council member, I tend, I have Brown Act concerns, I have other issues about that, so I don't read them.

3:54:01 And I defer to that just because from Brown Act issues, I appreciate the effort and the passion and the energy put into those things, but I don't read them because I'm concerned about Brown Act issues. And I pass them out and I don't talk to anybody on council.

3:54:16 About any of the memos that I've provided you, I've never talked to one person about, or one council person about any of these. It's to provide information and my thoughts, and as long as it's a one-way communication, I think it doesn't violate the Brown Act. No, actually, that's not correct. Well, and that, what I wanted to mention is that what it feels like to me, and we're kind of going off topic here, so maybe we shouldn't even talk about, but that when I read this,

3:54:43 It's as if you were telling me something and then I feel weird than talking to one other person about that in a give and take. I don't talk to anybody about these. These are my thoughts. I think that's where Andy's going to. Providing your thoughts to the council outside a meeting or outside the meeting packet that's then shared with the public is not permitted. Even if you don't talk to them, providing your thoughts to them, the majority of the council, or in this case all the council, has access to your thoughts on various topics.

3:55:13 Brown Act doesn't allow that. So what you could do. If I gave this to the newspaper, it's okay. And they publish it. That is different, yes. What if Kirk brought this with it and then just basically during a conversation told us this while we were here, we'd all hear it together. That's different, right? That's okay. Yeah, that's okay. All that can't be done is communicating with other council members outside a meeting. I cannot talk one-to-one. One-to-one, yes.

3:55:42 One person. One. And I cannot, because you and I would disagree on this, you know, to put something in a newspaper or to hand something, as long as I don't, as long as I don't confer with any of the other council person, you're saying that that's a Brown Act violation. Yes, a clear one. If you provide something reflecting your thoughts to more than one other council member outside a public meeting, the Brown Act does not allow that.

3:56:11 But there's no communications back because I don't allow it. It doesn't matter. They become aware of your thoughts on a topic. The Brown Act says that that's a serial meeting. Which is fine. We just got to get to agendize item and then you bring up your, as long as, you know, we get something on the agenda that's the appropriate topic, then we deliberate and we can share ideas at that point. But I've been, I've been, you know, I get them. I say, I don't know what to do with this because of what he just said.

3:56:38 Because I'm sharing that with you now so you know. This is news to me because I certainly read, I read the Brown Act, I read the different caveats and the, you know, things. I was trying to be very careful not to violate the Brown Act. And I've done this several times and nobody's brought it to my attention. We're doing it now. We're doing it now, yeah. Well, and I view an article in the paper the same way. It appears that what you're trying to do is skew the

3:57:09 Outcome prior to the council meeting where we're talking about it all together. Well, my articles about Trump are definitely trying to ask you. You keep writing those. You keep going with those. Those are fine. Thank God you write those. So I read your history, but I didn't read your questions, so that was my loophole there, so thank you. Okay, so getting a little off topic, I'm going to go ahead and get public comment on this item, please.

3:57:38 I saw your eyes light up earlier, so I figured you were ready to talk. I thought you were asking questions, then you went to comments, and it was like your deliberation, and so I'm going. A little off track there, but that's okay. Okay, Sandy Hogan, and I think what I heard from Linda is that, and I think what I heard from, maybe not from John, but almost, but that at this point,

3:58:06 Rather than change things right tonight with the budget, that this is something that for the time being, keep it the way it is, but definitely this is something that we need to have a discussion on. I heard that from Kirk, I think. I think I heard that from you. Did I hear that from you? Okay. Okay. So, you know, because that was actually when I read all of this, and it was well put together. Thank you.

3:58:33 The one thing that I have seen, because I've tracked this carefully, and I was a voter back then, and I know what the intent was, and it wasn't a program. It may have been a program attempt, but it wasn't once MLT was created, ESTA was created. Actually, we tried a little bit with the lift here earlier, and that didn't work. You'll remember that, Bill. And, of course, with MLH.

3:59:01 Each of those was created specifically to fulfill 2002A. I can't remember if it's 2A or A. And that worked for a long time because the money went there and things happened. I think MLT was probably first, John would know, basically because we were separating recreation and...

3:59:27 We had to wait for ESTA, but that was in 2007, I believe. MLH, I mean, with these MLT and MLH, the money was given to them and said, let's go. ESTA was the only one under contract. In other words, the board and their executive directors were trusted to get stuff done.

3:59:54 And in those years, that's what happened. What I have seen, and that's what I hope that you will, in your big discussions, discuss two things. One, the recalibration, because I think what a lot of people like me are worried about, that all of a sudden the housing money is going back into the town, and I see MLH hobbled, frankly, with a contract that allows them to do administrative work, some of it from the town.

4:00:23 And does not allow them to really get out and try to do stuff. And that is the result of the recalibration and the reserve policy. I think that should be reviewed because what I see is the town taking control again of something where the public said, create these organizations and let them go and let them operate.

4:00:50 Basically, we had that going for a long time. With MLH, as I say, I've seen it strangled over the years, and I see them right now able to do basic administrative work, and maybe not even that. And then they have to come play Mother May I. That didn't happen in the past. There was no, you know, run to the board, get the board okay, then come back to the council and play Mother May I. Uh-uh. So I guess what I'm saying...

4:01:18 Please review that reserve policy in your discussions, and let's talk about it, because either you trust our organizations or you don't. Now one of the things that I did here in a very heated discussion, I see Tom here, the last time when Mammoth Lakes Tourism had to come play Mother May I, and that was an appropriate time because it was kind of a brand new program and brand new things, and so in that sense I can see with the reserve how it worked.

4:01:47 But that was a heated discussion. So I think, you know, further discussion on some of these is really merited. And the one thing I did hear was that I think people have been asking for a potential decrease in the TOT that goes to Mammoth Lakes Tourism because they now have the T-bed. I think...

4:02:12 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

4:02:35 You know, or with budget amendments as you go through this year. Anyway, so those are just my, I would oppose a ballot measure at this time, at this time, I'm saying, but I don't, you know, ballot measures, if you don't need them, you don't need them right now. Okay, any questions? No, but thank you. We serve food on that counter. Tom Cage. So,

4:03:14 Your policy matter, discussion and possible action regarding allocation of TO, of transient occupancy revenue based on current and past political commitments. I think Bill said it well. Things have changed. Times have changed. There are a lot of different things than there were when we passed Measure A back in, I don't remember the year. 1997 is the first one. 1996, actually. So, you know, 20 plus years ago. So, you know,

4:03:43 I think the Council has done a good job with staff, obviously, on budgeting, being conservative, shifting around some of the allocations. So I think it's given you, the Council, more flexibility to have money available in more areas to move things around where needed. So I hope that you continue on that course. But I think in these agencies, MLH,

4:04:11 ESTA is a contract, so it's a little bit different. MLT, I think you really need to look at and add to the discussion of your policy what is their financial condition. Because if MLH is just doing administrative work, why? Why are we spending any money there? They've got to be given the funds to be able to accomplish things. So don't hobble an organization if you trust them.

4:04:40 Give them the ball, let them run with it. On the flip side of the coin, what are the rules, as an example, what are the rules on the additional TBID money that MLT has been able to attain this year? Do those monies get set aside in a reserve? Do those monies, are they able to be spent anywhere? How much are those monies? So I think that it would be important to include those in any policy discussions.

4:05:10 With reallocation of any percentages. So to summarize, don't hobble any of the organizations. Give them the ball, let them run with it. But they've got to have the funds. If not, then go the opposite way. Bring them back in-house. Otherwise, administrative duties, for the sake of administrative duties and not accomplishing anything, is a waste of money. In organizations where there's a lot of money coming in, they need to be monitored.

4:05:38 And that needs to be brought up and put on the table as far as how much is there and how much is reasonable moving forward. And I think you've got the power to do that. There are restrictions on some of the T-bid money, granted, we know that. But what happens with the excess? What is their reserve? Should some of it be shifted into other areas?

4:06:02 And you have the power to do that. And with the housing need that we all know is there, and they're working hard at addressing that, I just hope that we work hard with a very defined deadline of we are going to start building March 1st, April 1st, 2020. And I haven't heard anyone say that. I haven't heard anyone commit to that. But that needs to be, you know, the Kennedy speech. We will put a man on the moon in this decade.

4:06:28 You know, we need to have that speech and we need this council to get behind that speech to where we will start implementing what the experts say and what the community wants by a certain date. Otherwise, you're going to be looking at this in 2021 and hopefully start building in 2022. That'll be a travesty if it takes that long. Thank you, Tom. Public comment is still open. And seeing none, I will boot it back over for deliberation.

4:06:58 From Council? I have some questions of Andy. Andy, dyslexia. How does a council person communicate or provide? Does this, do I go to the town manager and say I want this included in the agenda bill? That would be a way to do it because that way the council is seeing it at the same time members of the public are seeing it. Okay. And so that's your recommendation is that when I have something like this I need to get it to the town manager and include it in the packet?

4:07:29 That's a way to do it. Or as some of your colleagues have suggested, you could simply raise your questions at the meeting. For the record, I don't mind. If there's something in the packet, then that works for me. As long as it's clearly stated what the source is. Yeah, but that just makes it a little bit easier if anything's in here. Okay, well then, any further questions on this item? Comments on this item?

4:08:03 I'll put it in the next packet because I want to be able to ask you guys how to move forward with a different funding tool because I think we're going to need it. So unless somebody has objection, I won't put it in. But I want to, I mean, part of it, John, is...

4:08:20 You know, those summit meetings and everything else, those new funding tools that I think we're going to need on not just the parcel, but on IT and on trash to Nevada and all of those different things that are slowly coming at us. So I think we need to have a robust discussion about those. So my understanding is that the town manager has direction from us to be working and developing a revenue measure.

4:08:47 You know, ideas for revenue measure associated with housing. Is that correct? Correct. I mean, you look at the housing action plan and those elements that were in there and stuff. I think Kirk's asking for a little broader level discussion, which I think would be healthy. So we need time to prepare that. But we would lay out these items for the housing in particular, though, if you want a tax measure of A, B, C, or D, or you want to re-look at how we allocate current dollars. All that would need to be put on the table if that's...

4:09:14 If we keep it focused, start to the Community Housing Action Plan, which is that recommendation within that, and again, encourage staff to start bringing us some options on that, and I'm pretty sure that we can cover a lot of ground within that agenda item to discuss a lot of the things I'm hearing you talk about now. And I think that I would certainly support to further direction to the staff to, consistent with the Community Housing Action Plan, bring us some ideas, or

4:09:44 Some framework or discussion possibilities for revenue measure for housing. My thinking on that is that I want to wait until we get a little bit further down the road with the parcel process so we've got some good technical analysis coming out of those people that say, this is my whole point earlier about the charrette, so that we really understand what the community's values are, what the community wants to do with that piece of property.

4:10:14 Right? And then the consultants can translate that into, okay, that's going to look, from a funding perspective, it's going to start looking something like that. And then we've got something to really talk about and get specific, give some specific direction back to these guys to move the thing forward. Okay, I do want to go back to the item at hand. There is no motion. I would make a motion. Yeah. Well, I still have some deliberation. Oh, okay, deliberation on. I still have just a little.

4:10:43 What I'm hearing are really two things. I'm hearing that there's sort of a big global elephant with all these price tags everywhere. First of all, I want to know if those price tags are accurate or not. And secondly, that's one discussion. The other discussion I hear is that discussion around funding stream for housing. That, I think, is kind of a separate piece in that we identified

4:11:12 Things in the Housing Action Plan. It would be nice to come back and address those particular things with staff reports speaking to those items. Like what would it mean if we talked about raising TOT? What would it mean if we did that? And look at those like that. So I really see two specific discussions about that, not all kind of rolled up into one. One I'd like to define better. And maybe you have that list, Kirk, of all the things. I'd like to...

4:11:40 Get staff input in those and maybe identify what would be an agreed upon number that we all sort of agree on. And because that keeps floating around. And then the other thing is a distinct conversation about funding stream for housing. And just one thing to that is from a Brown Act perspective. So we've talked about this. We know there's going to be some staff that's going to do some work on that. It's appropriate for an individual council member to say to the town manager, look, I've got a couple.

4:12:09 Ideas or things that I would like to have part of that discussion. Can you please make sure that you frame the agenda item in such a way that can accommodate the conversation we want to have? Yeah, that's completely appropriate. Okay, so that's, so if there's some general sense that we want to see something coming forward, we can all talk to the town manager, say, look, this is how we want to, this is the agenda item we want to see to have this discussion, then you've got to figure out how to, whether it's, you know, Linda, two items, three, five items, whatever, it's up to you to figure out how to.

4:12:39 Put that together, get an agenda so we can have these conversations. Well, and if we're going to have a big general discussion, and I said this last time, perhaps we look at what the different discussions are, because it's more than one discussion. Sure. And we come up with a true price tag. I wouldn't want to go out to the general public on a vote on anything without having some specificity as to what we were doing. But perhaps a workshop with just counsel.

4:13:07 Makes more sense than sitting up here at the dais where we can talk a little more free flow to get the ideas out. And then if that brings us to any kind of perceived consensus, that can go as an agenda item and come back for action at the meeting. So we're not taking up a whole meeting having another discussion like this one. That would work.

4:13:32 That being said, if I may, and if no one seconds it, that's fine, I would make a motion to make no adjustments and direct staff to continue work under the current allocation process as included in the proposed budget for 19-20. I'll second the motion. Roll call, please. Council Member Salcido? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Webber? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Seltzer? Yep. Mayor Popp? Yes. Item passed is 5-0.

4:14:01 And we are now going to go into our public. Oh, excuse me. We're still in policy. Oh, Rob's coming up. Everybody's going to leave. I know. I was about to say. Public hearings. Yeah, public. Okay, we are at public hearings. Bye, children. Bye, kids. Have fun. Okay.

4:14:27 So now we were on item 15 of the agenda. This is a public hearing. I will open the public hearing for this is the fiscal year 2019-20 master fee schedule update for the town of Mammoth Lakes. And Rob, I'll put it over to you. I will take it away. I'm just getting up to get something to drink, but I'll be right back. Oh, sure.

4:14:58 Staff has the opportunity, we take the opportunity on an annual basis to review our fees. Throughout the year we capture just different things that are going on through the normal course of business, things that have been identified as a need to be adjusted. Sometimes they're based upon different policy changes. Sometimes they're based upon things that we've come across. In this particular case we do review these on an annual basis and we bring them forward as part of the budgeting process for this public hearing.

4:15:27 There is a great deal of detail within the staff report that talks about the way that fees are calculated and how the town must go about the fee calculations and the limitations that we have. When we do sort of go through, the department heads go through each of their sections and come up with the fee adjustments, we'll put those into a book, put them on the counter, allow people to review them, maybe ask questions about them.

4:15:55 What I'm going to walk through just here briefly is just the changes that we have identified for this year in brief. The one key item, starting with the financial services section, is we've had the minimum charge for enforcement charges of $500. It's been on our enforcement fees. Throughout our municipal code, it identifies the fact that we can charge enforcement charges. But it wasn't...

4:16:23 It wasn't listed as a specific dollar amount. So what I took the opportunity here is to say the minimum that we want to charge based upon the cost of incurring or doing the enforcement is $500. But we also established a process by which we may incur cost in the act of enforcement. And if we have incurred cost in the act of enforcement outside of those that are identified in the $500 charge, that we would be able to charge for those as well.

4:16:51 So that's on the finance side, just sort of establishing that component and with the resolution that we have attached to the fee schedule tonight, that will be helpful for us going forward. Within the community development section, there is actually some work going on currently on sort of the large building development projects and Sandra and team are working through that. I think you can expect to see some recommendations coming before council.

4:17:20 By the end of this calendar year because there's a great deal of work to be done on that and they're working through that diligently. So right now we just have some updated construction costs based upon the International Code Council building valuation tables. Those are just changes that are made on an annual basis based upon almost like a CPI adjustment. So there's cost adjustments to those. Public safety, we've made some minor adjustments to fingerprinting services and then we reduced actually the

4:17:49 Concealed Weapon Permit charges based upon some limits that were set within the penal code within the last year. So those are types of adjustments that are made. The airport, we added some cost-accounted fees related to asphalt damage. Again, these are sort of hard knocks that you learn throughout the year, and then opportunities come up to identify fees for those. Public Works, we had...

4:18:13 Some fees for snow storage on town properties. That was the right of entry fee, I believe is what it's called. So we've updated that. It's $1,000. And that's pretty much it from the extension. So I did provide you with a list of all the fees, which is great. This time of year we can review those. I've highlighted them in kind of a bright red to see the adjustments that were made. We'll talk a little bit about the parks and rec fees.

4:18:42 Stu brings those forward. I believe it's February, March of every year to talk about the upcoming season and the cost changes that need to be gone through. You guys have already reviewed those and made determinations on them. So I'm just wanting to bring them forward as, yes, these were decided upon and highlight those as well. I will also make reference, in addition to the resolution adopting these fees for the year, we are

4:19:08 Continuing the public, the suspension of the public art fee through June 30th of 2020. Something that Council's waited on before and so we're just continuing that through as a recommendation and there's a resolution attached to that as well. Any questions on fees? Madam Mayor, do you want us to adopt all the fees in one motion? That would be it. Because I agree with all the fees except for the development impact fee schedule so I just wanted to

4:19:41 To note to the rest of the council if I vote no on this or if you want to take it separate because I disagreed with the council previously or I just want that in the record. Sure. My only question would be if Sandra would be willing to speak a little bit. Rob, you mentioned about the fees around development projects. I know we haven't had any major development projects in a while. I'm interested. You've intrigued my curiosity.

4:20:06 Yeah, so we were looking at the fees for major development projects, and really it's based on that valuation basis. And so for a project that's maybe a $20 million project, the fees would be like $900,000, which is pretty expensive and probably exceeds our cost to provide that service. So what we're looking at is separating out, creating a flat fee that covers our town costs, like Tom Perry or permit tech, but then looking to charge all of the inspections and plan checks.

4:20:36 on a cost-accounted basis. So that's kind of the preview of what we're looking at, but we need to do some analysis to come up with that flat rate, so it's just going to take us a little longer and we weren't able to do it. Would that be scalable from a staffing perspective? So if all of a sudden five projects showed up, we could contract it out or do whatever? Yes. So you guys would be okay?

4:20:56 Right. We have contracts, on-call contracts with five different companies that provide plan check services, but they also have inspection services as well that's optional. So what we have done in the past, like, for example, for the Westin, we hired a contract employee, basically, who worked for a different firm, but was here at the town offices, functioned like a town employee, and did all the inspections just for the Westin, so that was his job. So I think that we would probably likely do something similar to that, hire one person to, you know,

4:21:26 handle all the inspections from start to finish as much as we could. And all that's on the dime of the developers? Absolutely. Thank you. Sorry to bother you. No, it's okay. Sorry to bother you. No bother. What say you? Anybody? I will make a motion. If I may, it's a formal public hearing, so we need to go through that process regardless of if there's any public comment.

4:22:05 You're done with questions right now. I'll go ahead and move for public comment. Seeing no one, I mean, seeing nothing, I will go ahead and I don't even have an applicant. Just close the public hearing. Yeah, I guess I'm just going to close the hearing and now we've got deliberation and comments. I would just make a motion to

4:22:34 approve the attached resolutions establishing and updating the schedule of fees and charges for town services. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes, with no on development impact fees. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0 with one abstention on. One no vote on the different fees. One no vote on the, but just on the portion for the developer impact fees. Correct.

4:23:06 Okay, and now we are going to continue with the second public hearing. Open it. It is item number 16, approval of appropriations limit, investment policy, debt policy, reserve policy, and annual budget for fiscal year 2019-2020. Rob, I will pass that back over to you. Oh, I'm sorry. Did I miss something? Don't we have another resolution?

4:23:32 Oh, we had the resolution in the fees. Sorry, yeah, for waiving the public art fee. I know Bill just mentioned the first one, setting fees. Oh, wait a minute. I'm sorry. If we want to include the suspension of the public art fee resolution as well. Thank you. Sorry. As part of the fee, you made the option to approve the resolution, approving the proposed fees.

4:23:56 And there's a second resolution that would continue the suspension of the public art fee. Oh, that's right, okay. Public hearing covered both of those resolutions? Yes, they were both in that. Then I'll make a motion to approve the resolution, temporarily reducing the public arts fee through June 30th, 2020. Yeah, to zero. If you would need to clarify that, that it's reducing it to zero. Okay, yeah, right. Thank you. I'll second the motion. Roll call, please.

4:24:26 Yes. Yes. Yes. No, motion passes 4-1. You know, and I would, just as a comment on a side here, I would love to see that art fee come back to us at some point in time. I always thought that the 1% was extravagant, but the need for something like that in our future, especially if we're doing things like the...

4:24:51 The parcel and things, the need for some sort of public art fee is important to me. So at some point in the not too distant future, I would like to bring that back for discussion and perhaps just reset that percentage. It'd be great to have a draft program to go with that. It would, yes. Okay. Thank you. I was just going to say no and not give my background reasons, so thank you for that. So moving on now, we are still in, well, moving to 16.

4:25:20 Public hearing is open. And Rob. Yes, thank you. So I'm going to walk through. We have, as you mentioned, several of our policies to walk through and discuss. And this is the time of year where we're really reaffirming them. There are really no changes that we make or that we are recommending for this fiscal year. We did make a change in prior year on a couple of them. But this is just really to reaffirm them, give you guys the opportunity to review those.

4:25:50 Those policies as they are. So each one of them have been provided in your packet, along with the proper resolutions and such to go through them. But I'll briefly mention, talking about the appropriations limit, that's basically to control the size of our budget on an annual growth basis and make sure that it can't grow beyond what would be deemed reasonable based upon the population of the county and the per capita income changes within California.

4:26:18 We're well below that. Our current limit, which each year the limit increases. So, you know, builds upon the prior year's limit. So last year our limit was $25 million, $242 million. This year it climbed just 1.03% to 25, just under $26 million, $25 million, $999. With our general fund budget of $23 million, $238 million, $960 million, we're, you know, a couple million dollars underneath that number.

4:26:46 We're not in any danger of doing that. If we did end up going crazy on our TOT at some point and pushing that number up fairly high, then we could run into that number. But at this point, we're in pretty good shape on the appropriations limit.

4:27:00 On the investment policy, this is one that we did change, I believe, last year when we wanted to expand our investment in Mono County's investment pool. We had some limitations that were lower than what we anticipated getting into for our Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, which is the dollar amounts that we hold in the county's pool. So we increased that to $5 million. We are, and I'll talk more about this later when we talk about the reserve policy,

4:27:28 We're potentially coming forward with some changes in the reserve structure, which could increase the REU to a number getting closer to the $5 million, but right now we believe that we'll be adequate with that for this year, and it's something that we may readdress next year. So the investment policy we believe to be good. The next item is the reserve policy. And so the reserve policy, you know, we kind of built that up pretty strongly in 2016-17 when

4:27:58 We came up with a three-piece structure, which was the REU, which was already in existence. We developed an operating reserve. I'm sorry, the REU is funded at that time 16% of the general fund's revenues. And we developed then an operating reserve, which was 9% of the general fund revenues. Combine those two are 25%. So when we have completely on policy, we would have a reserve structure of 25% of our operating.

4:28:28 That's a pretty good number. I'm fairly happy with that. We've been on point with the reserve policy. We've been fully funded for that this year with our general fund revenue getting up to that $23 million. Our target is $3.720 million. We're above that because

4:28:48 The last year we've had very strong interest revenue, and that interest revenue is retained within the same area that we keep. For example, if we have the REU out there, we just roll over any interest earned on that into the REU, and that has been strong, and I have to keep that in policy, and we've been doing pretty good. The operating reserve, as I said, was 9%. The target for that, based upon the general fund revenue, is $2,092,000.

4:29:17 About 89% of that right now. If you remember in the third quarter we went through and you guys added some dollars to our $1.6 million, now we're at $1.864, and that's 89.1% of the REU. We are looking at some changes which we would possibly bring forward in the next couple of months and during the fourth quarter, if possible during the fourth quarter review of 18-19, our current fiscal year.

4:29:46 Which we may make some recommendations to Council on that, but right now, for the budget purposes, we're happy with the way we have it structured. And the third component is the contingency reserve. This is really a budgeted item. So on an annual basis, we do have $100,000 that we budget to contingency. And this just gives us the opportunity to, you know, take it.

4:30:09 If we have unanticipated costs that we incur or we have some kind of a shortfall we need to pick up on a capital project or something like that, we have some available dollars to make that determination and that's at Dan's discretion as well as council. So in this particular case, and it is included in the budget as you have it before you tonight, but those are the three components of our reserve policy and at this point we're looking to keep those intact. In the staff report I did give you

4:30:38 A good indication of what the target is in the current funding structures, so you can get a little bit more in detail on those. Any questions as I've gone so far? Okay. Rolling on into the debt policy. Debt policy is something that we, as we went through and had refunded the settlement debt last year, we adopted this debt policy, and

4:31:06 It's adequate for what we need to do. We have no recommended changes for the current fiscal year. And it's something that was put together with our bond council. It's a pretty robust program, as you guys were able to read through. And there's no adjustments made for that. So that's really the policies that we wanted to reaffirm as part of the budget. And so we'll kind of roll in now. If I may, before we dive into the budget side.

4:31:29 Up to the Council, but if you wanted to actually take action on these policies and they're set and to the extent if you want to modify them and they impact the budget, then we need to address that accordingly. So you can wait and take them later, but if there's no issues, you can take them at this point. And then if there's a change to those, then we would need to reflect that in the budget. So that's why it's kind of the structure of it. Or we can wait until the end and do them all at, I still take them individually, but you could do them all at the end of the budget presentation as well. Do you want to do the first four?

4:31:57 Yeah, I'll leave it to the will of the council, but I think perhaps. Okay, so I'll make a motion. If we have a, is there any public comment versus any public hearing, then we could come back. I've got a technical question. So, real quick question. What is the town's bond rating right now? The A. Are there any anticipated

4:32:23 implications or effects to our bond rating with these policies that we're going to be approving? No, in fact, I would say just the opposite. Having good policies on the positive side is good. Actually, you have a reserve policy and we're moving toward fully funding it. We have a debt policy as required. We deal with an investment policy that meets or exceeds state standards. All those things work to our benefit as we look at any type of future.

4:32:48 Review of our bond rating. I bring this up to our conversation on revenue going forward so we can be teed up. So whatever revenue thing we want to get into, it's going to tie to hopefully get to an A plus. That'd be nice, yes. And part of the timing a little bit too, potentially having a review of our bond rating in September because that would be the time frame based upon that large debt reinstatement that we did. So that's coming up and that's part of the reason why we would.

4:33:14 Time to touch on the reserve during fourth quarter because we were trying to get into 100% compliance at that point, which as stated would be very good. So if you want, I would be comfortable if you want to make some motions for these things now. I am going to go out to public comment. Seeing none.

4:33:35 That would be on items one through four is the recommended. This is for item one through four, but then I don't close the hearing, correct? Correct. Okay, I just keep a public comment. Okay, back to the council for deliberation. Do you want me to call these out or one through four? Yeah, if you call them out equally, each would be nice. Okay, so I will make a motion to one, adopt a resolution establishing Town of Mammoth Lakes appropriation limit for fiscal year 1920.

4:34:04 Number two, adopt a resolution affirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes Investment Policy for Fiscal Year 2019-20. Number three, adopt a resolution affirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes Reserve Policy for Fiscal Year 2019-20. And number four, adopt a resolution affirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes Debt Policy for Fiscal Year 2019-20. I will second. And just a point of clarification, you were saying reaffirming, correct? Yeah. The title of the resolution. Reaffirming.

4:34:35 Thank you. Okay. Any further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0. And now we will move on to the fifth recommendation. Still open in public hearing.

4:35:08 I guess, Rob, you'll take this one away? I'm taking it away. So this is sort of the culmination of a lot of hard work, as well as some good presentations and discussion from the council in the development of our budget. And so we're bringing this thing to a close tonight, and hopefully we'll adopt the budget to move forward. We've provided a lengthy staff report. Hopefully it was comprehensive enough to answer any questions that you may have had.

4:35:36 We will walk through a presentation as well as you will receive the line item detail of every fund we have. So I'm particularly happy with the results of the budget. As I stated in prior, we're going to do it a little differently next year. But again, the end result is the end result. So to kind of launch into this real quick, the fund balance reserves...

4:35:59 I think this has been an important aspect from Council's perspective. They want to really know, you know, where are the reserves? And these are reserves that are, you know, set aside for particular either out-council direction or due to policy or due to restrictions. But this is how we have to keep track of the funds separately and we hold them.

4:36:23 In their individual fund balances and report them as such today. These are estimates, and I say that because I'm estimating the ending fund balance as of June, so we still have a little bit of time left in this particular process, but I'm also estimating the budget changes in the second column over to the center column there based upon next year's budget numbers.

4:36:51 If you looked at the combined fund statement, which we'll talk about here shortly, the difference between the revenues and expenditures are the change in fund balance. And so that's what's illustrated on this particular page is where we're ending it. I wouldn't like you guys to take any of these things to the bank because they're really truly an estimate at this point. And I'll focus in on the general fund, for example, right now. Those operating reserve, housing reserve, transit, tourism, and undesignated, those

4:37:20 Also have a component of an estimate for the fourth quarter of the current year, so the one we're currently in. And I'm estimating another $1.5 million in TOT at that point, which is allocated into those separate funds. So you'll notice the undesignated general fund of $3 million, just over $3 million for the year, includes the $2 million that we have set aside for short-term housing projects, but also another million.

4:37:44 And some that we anticipate for the fourth quarter. So again, lots of estimations going on there, but just gives you a sense of where we believe this to be and how it flows through. And so I'd like, you know, memorializing it by putting it on the page, but just being cautious that understanding there's quite a bit of estimation going on here, conservatively, but estimations. Any questions on these two items?

4:38:10 And again, you guys saw these during the debt fund obligation through March 31st of the current year, which is more actual based. But these are, again, estimates. Looking at the total revenues, primarily we talked during our budget discussion around general fund revenues. This particular one captures a bit more than that. It talks about wherever revenues would come through our

4:38:40 All of our accounts that we have or all of our funds that we have within our combined fund statement. And so with that, it just gives you a sense of, I try to capture across the fiscal years what the actuals have been, how we've adopted budgets for the prior year, actually, I'm sorry, the current year.

4:39:00 And then what we're projecting for 19 and 20. And the variance column on the far right-hand side is just to give you a sense of the change between this year's adopted budget or proposed budget versus prior year's adopted budget. So if there's something in there that kind of sticks out at you as something to discuss, there's reasons behind each one of them. But a lot of them, I mean, the two that stick out to me the most are airport operations and capital projects. And both of those variances really have to do with the

4:39:29 Sort of volatility or the volume of capital project work that's being done or proposed. Airport operations last year we had a little bit more proposed in capital projects. And again, these are, as they're set and proposed for the year, they may not be actually what we have achieved in those particular areas. But that's the revenue. And again, we'll wrap this all up on the combined fund statement here in just a few minutes. What was the jump in general, other general fund revenue?

4:39:57 In other general funds, the $285,000, I'd have to, I don't have the details on that specifically for what we're heading, but I can pull that together for you. Any other questions, ones that maybe I can answer? Now you're confused, you really stopped. I'm sorry. Keep going, Rob. You're doing good. Keep going. Don't. Don't confuse a bunch. Quiet. Okay, I'll almost anything.

4:40:33 And sort of Linda, the reason that that's not as simple, most of the other ones are larger components of that, where we have like the one line item or two line items, that one's probably made up of maybe 15 or 20 different smaller items, and it could be quite a bit. My guess is it's the one-time money, the repayment of things and interest earnings that have both been up. Yeah, and it's probably actually grant revenue, to be honest with you. That was the first thing I thought.

4:40:59 Just looking at it off the top, I don't see it. There's not a grant revenue section on there. And I know we do have a couple of elements in there, one being the tobacco grant, which is fairly sizable, $175,000. And then there's the Caltrans Climate Adaptation Grant that's in there as well. So those are two numbers. Yeah, that's good. Okay. Appropriations, all funds, again, same concept. It's just giving you a sense of...

4:41:26 All of the funds and the expenditures as we have them. And really, again, the comparison across years is really the primary component of the charts and showing you the transfers in and out, which we'll talk a little bit more in detail about those. All that culminates into this very large sort of combined fund statement for the year, and that shows you all the revenues on the left-hand side and transfers in.

4:41:54 All the appropriations on the right-hand side transfers out, if you will. And in the far right-hand column is the change in fund balance. And so that's how those reserve accounts that we first started with will change throughout the year based upon the budgets we have. Now, it's strictly based upon the budget, not necessarily the actuals. So those numbers will certainly be different. But it's really the planned use of fund balance or the planned accumulation of fund balance based upon how we've developed the budget.

4:42:20 I'm pretty happy with, again, how this rolled together and where we are as far as a sound budget. Entertaining questions if there's anything. Looking at the employees, all funds, employees, and again, we do charge employees across most of these funds.

4:42:42 And we'll talk about them in detail here in a minute, but they're not just all in the general fund or all in gas tax. There are pieces and parts of individuals that are charged across our funds because they are doing work that addresses the needs of those funds. And so we'll have a percentage of time for an individual who may be a general fund employee.

4:43:05 That's spending time over in capital projects. So a percentage of their time is charged over there, and so we'll talk about that in just a minute. But looking at the full-time employees, we have 74 in this budget. That's up eight positions from last adopted budget because we've added positions last year. We're adding positions in this particular budget, although the hiring for those positions are on hold.

4:43:33 Really just showing you that we are kind of growing this. Our full-time employees increased by eight positions. Our full-time equivalent of part-time employees increased by 1.5 compared to prior year. And the staff report included the positions that were added during the current fiscal year as well as what's being added in this budget, which we have a slide on what we're adding in this budget coming up. I talked about how all funds, the labor is distributed across

4:44:03 The different funds as an allocation of labor. And department heads get together. We'll take a stab at it, looking at what was achieved in the prior year and what work was performed. And then the department heads will go through and say, these are the changes that we expect to have. And so from that, it's really based upon a percentage of individual employees and then either temporary wages over time, the comprehensive

4:44:30 Comprehensive Leave Components, those are all attributed to that percentage of that employee, and that's how it's distributed out. In general, showing you, you know, this is the first section, this is the last half, that's all of the labor charges across all of the funds. The total labor costs, $12,152,000. That's fairly significant when you think about our overall costs and appropriations of our operating budget.

4:45:00 That's a fairly high percentage. We'll get to that here in a few minutes. Last year, this number was $1,073,000 less. And again, that's a combination of the employees that we just talked about that were added that increased at 9.7%. But also changes in really the retirement program, the unfunded liability increases that we've seen. Those have been some of the biggest impacts of coming from the unfunded liability, which are impacting in retirement.

4:45:29 But that's fairly sizable. When you talk about our concerns over growth of the budget, right now we can live within our revenue means keeping it at $13.5 million for TOT. By adding all these positions, we've gone up $1 million since last year's adopted budget, fairly significant. That will grow as we go through this process, and that's going to naturally push up.

4:45:56 Challenge our conservative estimates and our conservative approach to budgeting. But that's the fact of what we have with the cost of labor, and particularly in California, mainly in retirement. So it shows you an indication of the labor costs at $12,152,000, how it's distributed via part chart, salary and wages, 7.1 of that, health care and costs, which they change on an annual basis.

4:46:25 Detailed discussions on that. I think it was in the last presentation we talked about over the last four years how the health care increases have changed. Our PERS retirement, which does include the unfunded liability component, $2.5 million of that cost. So that's a good breakdown of our overall labor expenditures. Switching gears now.

4:46:48 And I wanted to do a little bit of a deeper dive on labor, something that we did in prior years. It's important. It's our biggest expenditure, so it's good to talk in detail about that. But now we'll switch gears and kind of be just walking through some of the key components of those funds a little bit deeper. We're jumping now into the general fund, which is our biggest fund where most of the revenue comes into it. And that shows you really how we break down

4:47:18 You know, where our biggest revenue components come from, you know, certainly no transient occupancy tax, and that one's budgeted at 59.2%, but if we come in this year at 19.5%, that number's going to be, you know, quite a bit higher as far as a contribution to our overall revenue. Property tax, really good on that number. We got final estimates literally Monday on that, and the difference between where we are and the final projection, it's $22,000 higher.

4:47:46 In the final projection, so I feel really comfortable. There's some tiny bit of room in that number, but it's less than 1%, so we're pretty tight on that. Sales tax, again, HDL provides us that information, and they've been pretty good on that. They actually added their own level of conservative estimates on that, so the sales tax we believe to be pretty strong. So in all cases, I don't think we're going out anywhere risky on our revenue expectations.

4:48:16 I mean, it's just been what we have, how things have flowed through in the prior years, and what we see forecasted coming up. So $23,238,960 is our revenue. And that's, again, the basis of our reserve policies that we talked about earlier. Some folks like graphs, so I'll give you a little graphical representation of those, as well as calling out some of the housing transit components that are really a part of the TOT, but just showing them as separate components so you can see them.

4:48:45 Here in the process. Now diving a little bit into the general fund expenditures for employees to give you that sense of how things have changed across the years and really the variance in the budget. Again, for the general fund alone, it's up $940,000, so that's the bulk of what we saw in prior labor cost changes. Draw you particularly into the PERS retirement at $295,000, 17% of that difference.

4:49:18 It's fairly strong. So we're going to keep an eye on that. That's something that's going to go up over time as the unfunded liabilities change based upon PERS's expected return of investment. They're ratcheting that number down. So over the next couple of years, that will actually still climb a little bit more on us. In looking at the general fund expenditures by category, this is showing

4:49:44 The way I achieve this is basically take all the departments within the general fund, I pull out the like kind, we use the same expense accounts across every one of those funds and just pull the details out of those. It doesn't tell us a great deal because like in contractual services we do have variances annually based upon either construction work or other components that we have going on or for example the housing

4:50:13 Budgets that we have for, I think it's LWC contract. That could make some significant swings within like contractual services numbers that are there. But trying to just get into a larger bucket of review, see how they go across the fiscal years to see if it brings out any questions about, you know, how our expenditures flow and how they change over time and what may drive those. So nothing really stood out.

4:50:40 For us on this, for me anyway, as looking through it, but I do like the ability to see how things change over time or remain consistent, if you will. This particular one then gives you just a sense of the overall cost of the individual departments. I think during the last presentation, the question was brought up about the police and why they had such an increase over time. The police from 16-17 through our budget of 19-20 have increased.

4:51:11 $892,000. And looking at the salary, other benefits and retirement costs, the salary went up $283,000. There's two positions in that, as well as the overall increment of people going through their steps. The other thing is the retirement component. The retirement went up $435,000. That shows you the impact of the unfunded liability.

4:51:39 What's the name? It's not called security. What's the name of the PERS component for safety? Oh, the safety component. Their retirement is 3% at 50, and so that number is fairly significant and moves quickly when you talk about an unfunded component, so that's why that number is so much larger.

4:52:04 But this particular look gives you a sense of how changes occur within departments. And again, as staffing, as individual staff that may be within those departments are charged out to other elements like capital projects, there'll be some variability within that. And that's where most of the changes occur. But these are built in with the positions that we'll talk about here in a minute, as well as the ones that we talked about earlier, the total of eight new full-time positions. And there's a graphical representation. I think you guys like pictures. Is that a true statement?

4:52:36 All right. Interfund transfers. When we talk about, I actually get most of the questions about this because this is one single line item within our budget and it's one of the biggest ones. So it's really just a representation of how we're transferring general fund monies out to cover the debt service payments because debt service payments live within their own fund and that's just good accounting practices so that we can see the ins and outs for those.

4:53:04 In this particular case, as you know, we actually came to Council with a question on did we want to transfer out a full $2 million for the settlement payment even though we've refinanced that to a smaller amount? And you'll see that later on we're going to grow a future capital component to about $125,000 based upon that savings that we're seeing for this particular year. But that's where the bulk of it is transferred out. We have general gas tax.

4:53:33 As you know, has a fairly significant contribution from General Fund. It's actually pretty flat, within $39,000 of the prior year's adopted budget, so pretty good, pretty consistent year-over-year comparison. As you know, we do not budget within gas tax for significant winners. We try to get a natural winner in there, and we'll make adjustments as we go through the year. The only thing I'm noting on here is that General Fund's support for trails. We did make some staff.

4:54:03 Sort of contribution or staff changes this year and where we were billing them. That's kind of for a better way of saying it. We used to have a percentage of our trails coordinator's position coming out of the trails budget and a portion of it coming out of public works budget. But now it's all sort of living over in trails and the general fund is supporting some of that through trails transfer. So that's what you're seeing on that. That's something that's new this year.

4:54:32 Speaking about gas tax, this is, again, you've seen this a couple of times because we talked about it even last time that the manager recommended. There have been no adjustments to this since the last time that you saw that. This particular graph gives you an indication of where the revenues come from and talks about the different components that are of gas tax, the snow removal one.

4:54:56 We have, in this year, it's almost $400,000, $390,000 more than it was last year. And that's the representation between the expenditures we had for this current winter versus what we had for the prior winter, this one being significantly higher. I basically look at the overall expenditures we had for winter and take about 50% of that because that's the amount that we're going to be reimbursed from gas tax. And so those are the numbers that we put into the budget. I think there's a little bit of conservative estimates in there.

4:55:24 That number should climb up just a little bit more. We will have an annual audit on our gas tax components, and that happens probably in December to early January time frame, and then I'll have an update on that in the second quarter of the current fiscal year, or of 1920 fiscal year, increasing that number likely slightly.

4:55:44 The other component we talk about on the bottom section of there is really just where are the expenditures within gas tax, how are things float across there. One of the biggest ones I want to point out is the vehicle replacement and vehicle operating costs. Those, you know, really, the biggest equipment that we have, the biggest vehicle expense that we have lives in this particular fund because that's the snowblowers, the loaders, and all those things.

4:56:09 So that's why those numbers are fairly high. But it's just good detail on exactly where we do spend money out of this fund and where the costs are associated with that. Definitely have a graph that shows you those components. And I'm just going to keep motor until somebody says something, so. Yeah. Now, this is one of the presentations that we had earlier on in the year.

4:56:37 The obligations and restricted funds. Talking about Measure R. Measure R has two components, Fund 215 and 216. 216 is where the revenues come in for that actual tax itself. And then from that, there's a transfer out of Fund 216 of $300,000 that goes to Fund 215, which is trails. And we keep that separate so that we can see the

4:57:03 Sort of the project workflow plan, as well as that fund balance component. When you talk about keeping dollars to a specific area, we wanted to keep dollars that were available for trails specifically, and so that's why Fund 215 was created. And this particular graph shows you Fund 216's annual expenditures on the left-hand side. And MLR is the recommending body for Measure R.

4:57:28 And as well as Measure U. And so we established a couple of years ago sort of a standard expenditure list so that we didn't have to keep coming back and saying this is what we anticipate to be the expenditures that we have for R on an ongoing basis. And those were established and we do revisit them on an annual basis just to make sure they're in line based upon the actuals and there have been really no adjustments to those.

4:57:53 I will also call out that the, I think there was a question earlier about where the payment comes from for the Community Recreation Center. That is listed down below, that's 615-925, and that coming out of Measure R, which is Fund 216's component. On Measure R trails, Fund 215, we have no use of fund balance scheduled for this year.

4:58:18 I think in prior years we've had some big projects that were going forward. This year we don't really have one teed up. So we have the same revenue and expenditure going on for the year, so no change in fund balance for Measure R-215. Looking at Measure U, and again focusing in on the annual expenditures, the programming charge, I think it's $115,000 that we have typically for the special events or special programming.

4:58:50 And there's additional $51,000 in the theater component. Yeah, the theater component on that. I think there was a request earlier when we had a discussion around sort of showing the $300,000 that we had planned to use for the MAC in the future. I had a little bit of trouble putting that into the budget expectations for this. So we kind of put it into the staff report as a realization that those dollars were there and sort of earmarked for that in the future.

4:59:18 But a little bit hesitant to list it here as a planned sort of operating expenditure because someone may ask for it in the current fiscal year. And we're not there yet. And we're really just not to that point. The one aspect that we did add is the recreation coordinator position, that $70,000 contribution from Measure U.

4:59:39 And that's continuing forward. So our total expenditures for Measure U, $292,000. As you saw in the staff report, we do have a budget expectation of $900,000. Of all of our revenues, that's probably the one that's the least conservative in a time that's a bit of a stretch. But again, Measure U's got a fair amount of fund balance, as well as some commitments that we have to the MAC, which have been well discussed. But those are out there. Any questions? I think, Cleland, did you have a question?

5:00:06 You did qualify for the MAC that you said you had a qualifying word before you said earmarked. It was like kind of. We have identified it as a future use of money for that. Right. But it is not committed this next year for operations to the MAC because it's not under construction yet or not beyond that. So it is not committed to it.

5:00:32 I'm not committed, but it's kind of earmarked. It's earmarked there. If they were to open, we would come in with their formalized resolution going, we want to commit dollars. But $300 for operations, unless they're open and operating, at least current direction, is those dollars are not available to them. Okay. Thank you. I think in the staff report I use the term set aside. Oh, set aside. Okay. Thank you.

5:00:57 So airport operations fund, again, this is something we talked about in May at the manager recommended. There are no adjustments to the airport fund either, which is good. That means that we're not making any last-minute adjustments as things come to a final close here. So in the airport, there has been some questions regarding the expenditures. The airport has both an operations section as well as a capital project section. And the capital projects,

5:01:25 Is funded in such a way, or is sort of accounted for in such a way that whatever's identified as coming forward as a need for a project that's there, we'll have revenue associated with a grant typically, or we're going to utilize some of the fund balance. There's about a $1.3 or $1.4 million fund balance within the airport to fund some of those grant matches that we have out there, but the FAA has some pretty good grant funding. So what you'll see in the accounting for that is we'll anticipate

5:01:54 One change we are doing this fiscal year in talking about

5:02:24 Vehicle replacement. We've had vehicle replacement obviously in every one of our, we have a very robust vehicle replacement program. It does exist. It's very strong. In the airport, we have not had that present. Most of the vehicles have been hand-me-downs from the town itself or they were funded by grants with the anticipation that they would be refunded by grants in the future when they need to be replaced. What we found that we, and I'll talk a bit more about our

5:02:52 Changes within vehicle replacement for the year, but we've found that we really need to start planning for the smaller vehicles at the airport, and so we've established a vehicle replacement program for the airport as well as recommendations to buy some vehicles this year for the airport. More graphical representation. Capital projects funds. This is something that we made some minor modifications to this from when you saw this very same chart or a bit more write-up about it.

5:03:22 Back in March when we were planning on this, I think there's a CIP plan coming forward for better discussion, but this is what engineering team has sort of put together for the year, both showing total projected project costs, what the funding sources are, what the amount is for the 19-20 budget, and really the expected completion for each one of the projects. So I don't think there's anything in there that's...

5:03:51 It's not, it's unfamiliar to you, but again, look for more detail within the staff report, and then more detail coming probably in the CIP update in the near future. Talking a little bit about the development impact fees, and really those are just anticipated. Those did make some, we did make some adjustments to these, because really they're built upon the building fee, permit fees.

5:04:19 And different construction projects that are coming forward. And the building department has been pretty busy. As you guys know, those numbers are fairly high. So we kind of made some adjustments based upon what we were seeing for the current fiscal year. And again, the bulk of those are kept for particular reasons. Within the staff report, I think we give the purpose of those in a bit more detail. But that's the expected balance that we have. And then the town just picks up $6,200. That's for the...

5:04:48 Essentially the collection of those fees and that comes into our overhead. Assessment districts, we talked about those in detail before as well and I think there's some discussions coming up here when NBS puts together the plan for the year which each one of these have either maintenance plans.

5:05:08 There's certainly snow removal expectations. Part of the gas tax we do receive for snow removal is transferred to these assessment districts that have an expenditure associated with snow removal because that's part of what the gas tax is there to fund. And so what you'll see is a transfer out within gas tax, and that transfer out is coming into these assessment districts to cover the snow removal expenditures, or at least 50% of it.

5:05:38 And then that's to give you a sense of the vehicle replacement fund. We are going to have a new, the balances that we have out there right now. And the set-asides you'll see in the future, airport, as we build that up. And we took kind of a stab at our replacement costs this year since we did not have a program for that. This is something that is new. You haven't seen this particular one yet. Some of these you have received.

5:06:04 Before, these are the vehicle replacement recommendations that fleet has brought forward for the year. As you remember, during discussion of third quarter, we had the opportunity to purchase some vehicles from rental fleet that was ceasing business, and we did pick up six vehicles, which helped us to replace some of our fleet here and expand a little bit. But we also have a need for vehicles that were not available from

5:06:31 From the rental agency and primarily in trucks. And so we've been pretty good. You can see some of the trucks that we're replacing here are almost 20 years old. And some of them look like it. Some of them are retired police vehicles. One of them just was completely dead on the side of the road the other day. So we were getting rid of that. But it's kind of a personal pet view of mine that we catch this up a little bit.

5:07:00 I think this is one of the remnants over from the airport litigation and some of the challenges that we were facing as a town. So we got a little bit behind. Even though we had that vehicle replacement fund, we were trying to milk as much as we possibly could out of the fleet that we had. And so now we're getting to the point where we're making some recommendations on these. And the good news is this will be funded, except for the $100,000 that you allocated during the third quarter for those rental vehicles, this will be funded out of our vehicle replacement program.

5:07:28 So that's sort of the design and how it's working forward. So look for a lot of new vehicles rolling around town, and they should look sharp. Debt schedule, I've given you this before, and this is updated certainly with the planned debt payments that we have for this year. I do have an overall sort of chart that shows I'd like to share with you. It doesn't really show up on a graph.

5:07:54 Or certainly during a presentation because it's fairly large. It goes across the entire term of all of the debt service and shows how the town's debt expectations are changing over time. But that's the plan for the year and the overall outstanding debt or initial amount of the debt, I should say. And then really where it's coming from is the general fund measure R or assessment districts because there are two assessment districts that have a fairly high payment out there.

5:08:23 That is the conclusion of the budget presentation. And again, that's formalization. Thank you. I agree. Christians. Thank you. It's a big deal. Yeah, I'm pretty happy about it. So do we have any questions for Rob on this one? Yeah, what's that 282,000? No, I'm just kidding. Okay, take it out to public comment.

5:08:53 Seeing none, I'll bring it back to council for, oh, here, I'll go ahead and close the public hearing and this is item five. I will entertain a motion. I will make a motion to approve, to adopt a resolution approving the annual budget for the town of Mammoth Lakes for fiscal year 1920 as presented or with council, yeah, as presented.

5:09:26 Second. All right. Further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0. Thank you very much. And now we will go ahead and move into council member reports. And I will... We've got two more items. Oh, duh. Sorry. So we used to have a policy. We didn't start any items after 9-30. 10-30, bro. 10-30.

5:09:57 I'm going to change that to 730. Yeah, there we go. Okay, so sorry about that. We're back to policy matters. Item 17 is consideration of letter to Madera County in support of Mono County, request for adjustment to the county boundary lines. And Dan, take it away. Yeah, this item is brought back to you based on requests from the council of previous meetings as we worked with Mono County on the potential

5:10:27 Adjustment of the boundary, it really deals with the level of service and what's provided there. The letter that Mono County sent is in your packet, then a draft letter of supports there also. We can answer any questions you may have. Otherwise, we'd be requesting that the letter be approved with any final review by the mayor who'd be signing the letter. Okay, any questions? Yeah, in the Mono County letter, there's a whole bunch of CCs on that. How many of those other agencies are providing letters of support?

5:10:57 I do not know at this time. Okay. Okay. Okay. Any other questions? Public comment on this item? Seeing none. Deliberation or comments? Good matter. Madam Mayor, I move that the town... You know, I do have a comment on this. Okay. Sorry. We have to provide services for the valley because of safety reasons and everything else. I understand changing and I'm in favor of changing the county line, actually.

5:11:30 However, I don't know that the studies have been done to show whether we're better off or not taking the in-lieu tax dollars that get paid for federal lands or doing a memorandum of understanding actually charging Madera County for the full force of what it costs us to provide them services. Saying that, if this doesn't succeed at this point, I think that it is critical for us to pass along to the county that

5:11:58 I would expect us to start charging, and Mammoth PD, we're the ones that go down there, I think, more often than the Sheriff's Department, to pass on our costs, not only for what it costs us to send a car down, or send search and rescue down, or whoever, but for the administrative costs of having to manage that as well. Let's send this nice little letter over there now, supporting Mono County, and if things start getting a little bit funny, then let's...

5:12:27 I don't expect them at this point to approve this because they're taking money out of their own budget until they realize what the actual expense is. Well, that's going to be a follow-up with the county. Right, and we actually make the statement here that if they don't do this, an MOU for services is necessary. Right. The really old one needs to be updated and it needs to cover those costs associated with the number of agencies, not just the town and county. Right. So that's in there as a...

5:12:56 How's that point about the CCs? Because although they're not just on their arbitrarily, they're all saying. I understand that, yeah. There's costs. Yeah. Okay. And with that, I will entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I would move that we authorize you, the mayor, to finalize and submit a letter to Madera County Board to the Madera County Board of Supervisors in support of Model County's request for consideration of a county boundary line adjustment.

5:13:25 Second. Second. Motion. That's my motion, yeah. Any further deliberation? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0. We will now move to item 18, policy matter consideration of providing a comment letter to Federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, HUD, regarding rule changes related to requiring citizenship or legal immigration status.

5:13:53 to qualify for federal subsidized housing. And this, oh, Dan. Yeah, so, yeah, Madam Mayor, members of the council, this was requested at your last meeting from comments from the community and from one of the county supervisors to consider this. The same item, similar item was presented to MLH at their last meeting where they directed...

5:14:16 Patricia, their ED to work with town staff on a joint letter. We do not have a draft of that at this point. Given the time frame for getting comments in by July 9th, I believe the direction to MLH was to bring a letter back July 1 to have them review it and then send it off. If it's done by the 26th, we could bring an item back to you or we would just at a future item put the letter on that is approved from the MLH standpoint.

5:14:43 As we will not have another formal meeting before July 9th otherwise other than June 26th. And so it's based on those requests. We don't have a draft. The information is here. And we rely on the two staffs, Sandra on our side and Patricia from MLH to draft up a letter to be signed off by the mayor and the chair for MLH.

5:15:09 Oh, okay. So at this point, you do not need anything from us? No, we need direction. Do you want us to go do this in joint with MLH? Otherwise, yeah. We do need direction if you want this letter prepared together, and that would be the recommendation. Yes. So if you can give us a direction, a motion to do that, that'd be great. So you would need an actual direction? It'd be nice to have it formalized, and it would...

5:15:32 Direction has to draft a letter in conjunction with MLH and authorizing the mayor to sign on behalf of the town. Would that letter then come back to us for approval before being sent? Only if we have time. If it's not done by the 26th, then no, because the comments are due by the 9th. So if we have it done, great. If not, we would not have an opportunity to bring it back for you for comment. Well, I don't know where you're at if you want to take public comment or anything, but I'm prepared to make a motion. Okay. Yeah, public comment on this item.

5:16:02 Seeing none, I'll take it to Council for further comment. So I would move that the Council provide direction to Town Staff to work with Mammoth Lakes Housing Staff to prepare a comment letter to HUD regarding rule changes related to requiring citizenship or legal immigration status or legal immigration status to qualify for federal subsidized housing. Second the motion. Further discussion? Deliberation, yeah. I really don't know how I feel about this one. I have views on...

5:16:32 Rule of Law and those things that stick with me pretty firmly here. On the other hand, we already have housing, from what I'm hearing from Mammoth Lakes Housing and Mammoth that originally was promised would not go to anyone but workers and legal residents who we've already changed. From what I heard, 60% of our guests are now not legal that we're renting to currently and it would affect them, so I don't want to throw our workforce out of town, but I have some

5:17:04 Views on it that aren't, so I'm very conflicted and confused and we'll probably just, I don't know what, recuse or not vote. You can abstain. Abstain, yeah, on the issue. Okay. Any more deliberation? A roll call, please. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Yes. Councilor Alcino? Abstain. No. Item passes 3-1-1. And I will see that.

5:17:34 Letter before I sign it. Well, but you're not, but I want to make clear, the council's voted. No, no, no, I realize that. There's no editorial work going on. Dude, I'm sorry, but it's, I realize that, but I put it on record, I voted no, and. I understand that, but the council voted. John, I've got it. Thank you. Okay? Thank you. I've got it. Okay, now we are going to go in to.

5:18:01 Closed session. Entirely within my rights. Okay, now we are going to go to closed session. We do have two- Unless you want any council member reports up to you all. Oh, now, okay, council member reports, we can skip those if you wish. I do not have anything to report out since I have been here since one o'clock and went directly to this meeting from there. I cannot report out on MLT from today. Anybody else want to report out or are you good to go into closed session?

5:18:28 Okay, we will go into closed session. Just real quick, Amerigas did go to court last, on May 31, so I did, it was on a, with Snow Creek 4 and Amerigas, so just to public, because it was a lot of people, it impacts 600. Oh, it was, okay. Yeah, no, the judge has taken it under advisement.

5:18:59 Can you give us the lowdown on that real quick? The judge has taken it under advisement. Oh, he took it under advisement. We have commissions and department. Oh. Yeah, finish your council member first. Okay. Anybody have anything to report? I have things to report, but it's late, and I'll save for the next meeting. Okay. Yes, I do like, if there's no council member reports, then I have a couple department reports I think would be important for the council to hear, so.

5:19:31 Thank you. I know it's getting late and we're all getting a little punchy, so I wanted to leave on a high note here. So as you know, Grady Dutton is working remotely in Los Angeles, which afforded him the opportunity to go to the Western Region FAA conference. And at that conference, they talk about a lot of exciting and interesting airport stuff, so exciting and interesting that we'll talk about it at a different meeting.

5:19:55 At that meeting, they give away their most prestigious award at the FAA, and this is awarded to their most noteworthy and important achievements within the region, and for performing outstanding or unique accomplishments in support of airport programs. So Grady in Inyo County accepted the Herman C. Bliss Airport Partnership Award.

5:20:18 This award is granted in recognition of the important partnership developed between the organizations to cooperatively develop their respective airports and to develop a regional solution to the aviation needs of California's eastern Sierra region. So I want to congratulate Brian and Grady and the folks at Inyo County for their hard work on developing this partnership and really thank the FAA for the recognition of the hard work of staff to work together to really try to find a solution.

5:20:48 to the regional air service needs for the community. One request. Can we make sure that this gets onto the SCOG agenda? Or that this presentation, this thing? Yeah, that the SCOG hears this. Yeah, thank you. I have a whole bunch of other exciting construction stuff, but we'll do that another time. Thank you. And the O is exciting.

5:21:22 Sandra Moberly, Community Economic Development Director. Very briefly at your last meeting, a member of the public raised some issues about sign codes and our current sign codes and A-frame signs. So we have taken that and we are starting to work on the sign code updates. So we'll prioritize that. We've heard from the community. We've heard from other business owners as well. So just to update to the council that we are looking at that. So we'll likely engage the local business community, the realtors.

5:21:51 As we work to form a revised sign code that we would bring back to the Planning and Economic Development Commission and the Council for consideration. So just a heads up. I had a comment. I mentioned this. Maybe instead of going, you know, working on to maybe instead say to the mall owners, the people that own that sign in the front, that we require them to list the names of the businesses in that mall rather than put it all on the owners of the businesses. Just a thought.

5:22:21 That's a consideration for the code that we would change the code to require that they display those businesses. I would support something like that. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you guys so much for hanging out for this. They're having fun too. I had just a couple of things. I'll be brief. I'll say that it goes downhill. No, no. Town cleanup day, Saturday, June 8th, 8 o'clock. Thank you for everybody that's going to help, volunteer, and hand out bags, pick up bags.

5:22:57 Make our town look beautiful for summer. Very much appreciated. Thank you. Summer officially starts for the Parks and Recreation Department June 15th. That's the opening day for Recreation Swim at the Whitmore Pool. Summer Camp 17th. Swim Lesson 17th. Softball League 17th. Softball Camp. Sorry, Tennis Camp. Drop-in Tennis Clinics 17th and 18th. So we are underway. Recreation Commission does not meet in July, so we meet in August. And then finally, just a little short list of upcoming, ongoing projects.

5:23:26 Touched on today that Rob got through. Tennis Court Rehab Project will be in June. Playground Phase 2 will be later this month as well. Fencing Project will be this month, and then they're almost done with the floor at our beautiful new community centre. And then we'll go through Phase 2 of that project as well, which will be later this summer. So that's all I have. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Great.

5:23:47 And any more commission departments? Okay. We will now go into closed session. We have labor discussions as well as another item going with anticipated litigation. Is it a pleasure that we stay in the