TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2019

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 42 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

607 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:07 So I was told that these two pieces are not in our packet. These hard copies are fresh. I was about to say thank you. That didn't come from my hands.

1:37 And what are we waiting for? Dan? I don't know where... Linda's not going to be here. No, Linda's not going to be here. I thought Bill was... No, Bill is... Okay. He is recused from this. Bill's not running? No, he is conflicted out because he lives too close to the... Uh-oh, we've got the air conditioning going on.

2:02 Can you feel it now? Is that the rumble? Yeah, that's the rumble. It's the spring-summer rumble. Sandra, are we waiting for Dan? Are we waiting for Dan? The mayor's here, the council here. I count to three. I'm good. Okay, we're going to go ahead and call this meeting to order. This is a three-hour workshop. We do have Town Council Member Linda Salcido out of town.

2:35 And Mayor Pro Tem Bill Sauser does have a conflict due to how close he lives to this property. So don't tell him anything that goes on. Hopefully he's not watching. And we're not going to do roll call. We do have members of the Planning Commission here, town staff, town council. We will be ending this meeting promptly at 545 to make time for getting the town council for all the people who are on the agenda for that this evening.

3:04 And with that, I'm going to go ahead, Grady, and let you just kind of, are you going to be the contact to kick this off for us? Thank you. Thank you very much. First, I just want to say welcome, and not just to our Planning and Economic Development Commissioners, but town councillors and everybody in the audience, and hopefully either watching at home or any of you who will be watching it later on tape on Granicus, because I've been out for a few weeks, and having watched a lot of it, I have some...

3:33 Very positive things to say about how you can communicate on Granicus. In fact, if you're there, you can text from home and annoy your coworkers if you need to do that. But it is a good tool, so I want to make sure that we pay attention to that and note that there's a lot of people who can't be here today, but they're watching.

3:48 Out there. So thanks for everybody. We want to encourage discussion in this. Having said that, in discussion with the consultants with Jen, we talked about a 30-minute presentation once they start, which is in a couple of minutes, and they'd like to run through that whole thing, and then we'll have some slides that will come back through to aid in the discussion portion of it. So we could hang on to the questions. You should have copies of everything in front of you. You can take notes.

4:13 Please highlight things, do everything you can to do that, and then we'll come back and run through it. I think it'll make it more effective for somebody watching at home as well, because they get one picture, then they get Q&A, and then they get discussion after that. The only thing I wanted to mention was there is a lot of town staff members here as well, and I wanted to mention to everybody that the parcel team this town has put together is pretty substantial as well.

4:39 Of course, Sandra Moberly right next to me, Hazel LaPaz, Amy Callahan, Chandler Van, okay, thank you, and Sierra Schultz in the back, and others that, yeah, thank you, Callahan, I did it again. Everybody's done that from time to time, so that's okay. Easy one.

5:01 But everybody's here, and with that, I'm not really going to go on any longer. I'm going to turn it over to Jen Daugherty from Lisa Wise Consulting and let her run the show. We will interject as appropriate and participate in the Q&A. Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Sorry about that. Thank you. Thanks for that reminder, though. I appreciate that. Yeah, I guess at this point it would be a very good thing for everybody to introduce themselves before they speak. Thank you.

5:31 Great. Thank you very much. I'm Jen Daugherty from Lisa Wise Consulting, and welcome again. Thank you all very much for coming. As Grady mentioned, we have about a 30-minute presentation. That will be followed by questions and then discussion. The presentation, I'm going to go through an introduction of the team, background, the process we're going through to plan the parcel, and what we've heard so far.

5:57 Based on what we've heard so far, I'm going to introduce some draft guiding principles and development objectives, which is going to be the focus of our discussion today. If you've stepped in, we do have handouts at the back that includes this presentation as well as the draft guiding principles and development objectives. There's pens there as well, so please feel free to take notes and we'll come back to those during discussion.

6:22 So what we're trying to achieve today is to get some input, direction, broad consensus on draft guiding principles and development objectives. Our role as the consultant team mainly is here to listen today as well as to facilitate the discussion. The Plan the Parcel team includes a range of expertise. Led by the town, the team includes Mammoth Lakes Housing.

6:47 And other supporting experts, including Kaiser Marston for financial feasibility analysis, Triad Holmes, local civil engineering support, and Catherine Allen, who's conducting Spanish translation and interpretive services. LWC and our team is responsible for the conceptual land use plan and package, public engagement, as well as project management. Our subs include OptiCoast Design,

7:15 Crabtree Group, and Novin Development. Here are some of the faces of our team that you'll see during the four-day design workshop in August. LWC is a planning and economics firm with public engagement at the heart of our work. We aim to facilitate consensus and achieve well-designed places for people to live, work, and recreate. Opticos, oh, and I have Spencer Johnson here with me from LWC.

7:43 For OptiCoast Design, they are a nation leader in conceptual land use planning, and they coined missing middle housing almost 10 years ago. They are dedicated to quality housing design across a range of incomes. And with us today, we have Drew Finke from OptiCoast.

8:05 Crabtree Group is an integrated planning and engineering firm that offers innovation and expertise in green infrastructure. They will be responsible for looking at the design for circulation and multimodal infrastructure for the parcel. Paul Crabtree is not here with us today, but will be at the workshop in August.

8:25 And Novin Development Corp. is a real estate development consulting and brokerage firm, and they specialize in affordable housing and multifamily development. They have been experienced in acquisition, entitlements, and construction of over 1,500 units across California, and Iman Novin will be with us at the design workshop in August.

8:53 To start with background on our parcel process is looking towards the Community Housing Action Plan or CHAP that was approved in 2017 that identified an action for acquiring the parcel that was done last year and then conducting a master plan process with the community for the site.

9:14 That's what we're doing now. Plan the parcel is that community master plan process. And the deliverable out of this process will be a conceptual plan that addresses the mix of housing, circulation, amenities, funding and financing, as well as phasing. One of the descriptions from this action is to develop guiding principles, and that is what we're discussing today. The CHAP included a needs assessment.

9:44 That needs assessment identified that 595 units are needed to address the current housing shortage as well as to meet future demand through 2022. Of those, 275 are identified as ownership units and 320 as rental. Of those ownership units, about 64% were identified as being affordable and about half of the rental product as being priced below market.

10:15 There is an existing master plan for the parcel that was adopted in 1991 as a result of a land exchange and affordable housing mitigation for the trails subdivision. A voter initiative was proposed to change the zoning from affordable housing to a special conservation zoning. That initiative was defeated and the current master plan remains in place today.

10:39 That allows for 172 units of very low, low, and moderate income units. An affordable housing overlay applies to the site, which also restricts the units to moderate income or below. The general plan describes the parcel as providing a livable in-town neighborhood for the workforce.

11:00 And a neighborhood district plan, which was repaired under direction from the general plan, identified a mix of housing and affordability levels for the parcel. There are recent planning efforts that we'll be looking at during our efforts. Those include the 2017 walk, bike, ride, and downtown revitalization recommendations, which include complete streets, so designing safely for all modes of travel.

11:32 And that includes pedestrians, bicyclists, transit, as well as cars, but look to a shift from that auto-dominated circulation system. Recommendations also were to look at flexible solutions for workforce housing, so looking at innovative construction techniques that are cost-effective and also missing middle housing, so that multi-unit and clustered housing types that are compatible with single-family homes.

11:59 The town is currently working on resilient Mammoth Lakes effort. That is an update to the safety element, housing element, and adaptation strategy. We'll be working with town staff to incorporate any recommendations from that as appropriate. Now that housing element update that is underway is being updated in accordance with state requirements. That includes a regional housing needs allocation, or RHNA.

12:26 That's been identified by the state and goes out to 2027, looking at the town having to plan for 155 units through that time period. About 60% of those are identified as moderate or below.

12:44 Other items that influence affordable housing projects include state law and federal law and programs such as state density bonus law. Now, I won't go into a lot of details. I mean, the details of these are not intended for tonight, but just to introduce some of these concepts. State density bonus law does allow for density bonuses for projects that contain a certain level of affordable housing.

13:08 It also allows for incentives, deviations from zoning standards in order to accomplish those housing projects. It also limits cities' abilities to apply or require parking in excess of certain rates. SB 35 is part of the 2017 housing package, and it requires by right approval of affordable housing projects that meet certain criteria.

13:36 So in Mammoth Lakes, if you have a project that has 50% or more of low-income housing, that would be subject to these streamlined requirements of SB 35. That would mean that those projects could only be reviewed against objective standards, zoning and design standards to be approved. So there couldn't be any subjectivity in those. Also to consider our funding criteria.

14:02 So there are various funding programs at the state that have minimum thresholds in order to qualify for funding, such as affordable housing and sustainable communities grants, where you look at minimum densities to be eligible for funding. Also, federal law and housing and urban development programs also affect affordable housing.

14:23 And including tax reform. So the recent tax reform bill did lower corporate responsibilities and obligations, which has reduced the incentives for corporations to invest in low-income housing tax credits, which is a major funding source for affordable housing rental projects. Looking into the process, many of you or some of you may have seen this process chart for the parcel.

14:54 Today and at this stage we're focusing on land use concept planning and the process for that concept planning or plan the parcel is identified here where we have accomplished two of the first steps in terms of public interest interviews as well as an online survey and I'll be presenting the results of those in just a minute.

15:18 Today, we're at the first public workshop, again, with a purpose being to discuss guiding principles and development objectives. After this workshop, we will be putting together a memo summarizing the feedback we receive from the Council Commission and the public, and we will refine these guiding principles and development objectives and make those available on Engage Mammoth Lakes for further feedback from the community.

15:46 So I think we'll take questions at the end, but just since that's quick, we are looking at late July. And of course, with that, we are talking about preliminary, rough preliminary concepts where we work on mapping some existing conditions that will help us lay the framework and information to be able to prepare conceptual plans during our design workshop.

16:13 In August, we will be getting into Spanish community meetings, where we have two meetings we'll be holding in Spanish, and those are focused really on ensuring that inclusive engagement and promoting participation in our design workshop.

16:31 The multi-day design workshop will be August 20th through the 23rd. That's going to be heavy involvement with the community and our team where we're going to work with the community to draft three alternatives for the parcel. So the outcome of that with the community's input is producing three alternatives for the parcel. So please note those dates in your calendar.

16:55 After we prepare with the community those three alternatives, those will be available for community feedback for us to identify and craft a preferred concept alternative. That preferred concept or draft preferred concept will be presented in the second workshop.

17:14 So we can discuss that. And then based on feedback received on that draft preferred concept, we will revise it, present that in a third workshop. And that third workshop is anticipated in December. So by the end of this year, we will have arrived at a final conceptual plan for the parcel. So getting into what we've heard so far. First, we'll talk about public interest interviews.

17:41 Over the course of two days in May, we interviewed 45 folks over 14 small group interviews. Those included open-ended questions where we allowed the interviewee to drive the process and voice opinions openly. These interviews were confidential in that no responses would be able to be reported back or attributed to any one individual.

18:11 We were asked to identify their primary affiliation. The highest category at 33% were identified as residents. The next closely followed was government agency and districts, then followed by business owners and groups, and then major employers. Other folks we interviewed identified as architects, developers, builders, nonprofit housing organizations, realtors, and property managers.

18:42 The interest in the parcel of those interviewees varied, but most prominently we heard simply housing and affordability issues, as well as the fact that this presented a large opportunity. Now, I won't go through all the responses to these questions. You have this in your packet and it is posted online, but I'll just provide the highlights. Of the interviewees, about two-thirds had been to the parcel.

19:10 And most of them entered the parcel via Tavern Road. They typically walked and often walked their dog while they were there. Impressions of the parcel were that it was a beautiful area, followed by centrally located, but also trash. When asked how future residents would get to and from the parcel, respondents or the interviewees thought all modes, walk, bike, transit, and private vehicle.

19:45 We asked what affordable housing means to you, and we most commonly heard that meant a mix of products, pricing, and tenure, so both ownership and rent. But we also heard equally frequently rental properties. But then we did hear, too, a mix of income levels where folks identified specifically middle income or lower. Other responses included high density, long-term resident housing.

20:14 Workforce Housing. When asked what other uses should be provided on site, we most frequently heard preserved natural features, but also childcare, trails, parks and open space, bus stops. We asked what are the obstacles to developing the parcel, and we heard most frequently that community and neighborhood opposition would be our biggest obstacle, followed by financing and funding.

20:48 The interviewees' long-term vision for the parcel was most commonly voiced as a strong community, so sense of pride, sense of community, with long-term residents, as well as trees and open space, and that it was well-maintained. When asked what three objectives would be for the parcel, interviewees identified affordable to a range of income levels over the long term.

21:18 Equally with providing a substantial number of units, then followed by well-designed neighborhood. We asked what other questions we should follow up with the community on, and some of these questions we've incorporated into the online survey, and others will be asking as we continue on with the engagement process.

21:44 We also asked how we could get more potential residents involved in the planning process. And many of these suggestions the team has incorporated and is using. For anything that you would like to add that we didn't cover in the interviews, we've noted some things here, but you have the full packet and report summarizing the other comments we received.

22:12 Based on the responses from the interviews, we were able to craft an online survey reflecting some of those responses, some of that input we received.

22:23 And that survey was open for about two and a half weeks, and we had 276 responses, which in our experience is a great response rate. The survey was advertised via a variety of sources, and hard copies were available in a couple of places too. But this was an online survey via Engaged Mammoth Lakes.

22:50 For the survey respondents, 78 were full-time residents, 12% part-time or seasonal residents. When asked, in what Mammoth Lakes neighborhood do you live, we have a really good cross-section across the community of respondents. We had the most respondents from Sierra Valley, so 15%.

23:20 Old Mammoth Road and Old Mammoth, each at 13%. For reference, this is the map identifying those geographies, and those are in your handout. Of those respondents, 82% work in Mammoth. And the majority of those, again, identified as a resident or worker in Mammoth. The next most frequent response, much lower, was business owner or operator.

23:54 The vast majority do not live next to the parcel. We had respondents on every side of the parcel, or residents on every side of the parcel take this survey. Similarly, most do not work next to the parcel, but we did have respondents from all commercial areas or employment areas around the parcel reply, and we did have some of those who work from home.

24:25 79% had been to the parcel and entered off of Tavern Road, but all points of access, whether formal or not, are being used. And different from the interviews, what folks did while they were there was primarily walking or biking through connecting to another location. So that was the most dominant response there. But also walked or played with dog was...

24:56 High as well as exploring the site. Now, we asked what of the following housing would be appropriate for the site. The strongest response we had was long-term rentals, so for six months or more, followed by opportunities for home ownership, followed by seasonal employee housing, followed by supportive and transitional housing. For what type of buildings are most appropriate?

25:29 Duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes was the most common response, followed by multifamily buildings, so those with four units or more than four units per building, and then small single family homes.

25:47 When asked what other uses would be appropriate to include on the parcel, the most common was multi-use paths followed by bus stops. We also had preserved natural features and open space, and other frequent responses included shared parking areas, a central park, community gathering spaces, and a dog park as well as playgrounds.

26:19 In terms of income levels that are appropriate, the most frequent response was moderate income housing and below, followed very closely by low income, middle income being about half of the responses for low income.

26:38 In terms of obstacles to developing the parcel, the interviewee's response was, highest response was politics and government leadership, so a little bit different than the interviewee response, but that was also followed consistently with community, neighborhood, opposition, and funding and financing, so those is kind of the top three identified.

27:03 We asked what three broad objectives you would have for the parcel, and in this response, the respondents were only allowed to select three. So here, clearly the most dominant top choice is affordable housing for residents and workers in Mammoth Lakes over the long term. The next most frequent response was construct housing as soon as possible, followed by well-designed.

27:32 So as the top three, that was after well designed though, provision of a substantial number of housing units was next. So we're seeing affordable as soon as possible, design it well, but meet a substantial portion of the need.

27:56 We asked respondents if they were interested in becoming a resident once the site was developed, and we had 38% yes, 18% not sure. And for those that were interested, the unit type that would meet their need was a mix, the most saying two-bedroom followed by three or more bedrooms, then one-bedrooms and studios, the lowest response.

28:23 We asked if there was anything else to add, and we heard varied responses. But those responses that came up more than once included completing construction as soon as possible, that the parcel should remain undeveloped, that we ensure the parcel is truly affordable, development should be inclusive, serve the entire community, that short-term rentals should be prohibited, pet-friendly housing be included, and provide underground parking.

28:56 So with that input, we have drafted guiding principles and development objectives to discuss today. The purpose of these is to set aim and parameters within which we will work on the conceptual land use plans. Guiding principles are more overarching.

29:16 Priorities, shared values for the parcel, whereas development objectives are more specific. Those design drivers and maybe even measurable objectives for us to evaluate our conceptual work against. And our discussion is going to be focused on a intended or organized around a scale ranging from absolutely a must, you know, the strongest level of agreement, down to no go, to what you disagree with.

29:44 And I'll introduce these briefly, but we'll be looking at these as we go through discussion. So for guiding principles, providing long-term housing for those who wish to live and work in Mammoth by addressing a substantial portion of the need. Create a well-designed neighborhood that stands the test of time so that remains relevant, continues to address the community's need, and the design is still relevant and

30:13 Desirable. Enable housing as soon as possible, construction as soon as possible, and develop a sustainable program for long-term viability. So here ensuring operating efficiencies and that it's functioning as intended. The first draft development objective is to provide quality housing to accommodate households of different ages, sizes, and incomes. So here we're talking about a variety of housing types, housing units, and tenure, rent and own.

30:46 Looking at income levels, serving moderate income and below, and only consider designing a portion for middle income after assessing financial viability. And design for high durability and low maintenance. The next is provide a range of mobility options and multimodal connections to community destinations. So making sure that those are safe and intuitive.

31:15 Ped and bike connections through the parcel to surrounding areas. And prioritize pedestrian, bikes, and transit. Include at least one transit stop. Make sure that traffic calming is included to address speeding and potential cut through traffic. And explore strategies to further encourage those alternative travel modes. Provide an integrated network of amenities in civic and open spaces while still striving to make the best use of

31:46 So looking at these other uses, such as supportive uses, child care facility, parks and playgrounds, integrate pet-friendly design, have indoor and outdoor community gathering space, and provide parking, but limit the land required for parking, thereby ensuring we've got available land for other critical uses like housing.

32:12 Focus on sustainable design concepts, so integrating those natural features, wetlands, trees, and open space into that neighborhood design. Making sure infrastructure and designs are energy efficient and sustainable. Have well-planned and efficient snow management and storage areas. And limit the amount of impervious paving, so that could be surface parking areas. Establish a livable neighborhood that supports the community.

32:45 So looking at transitioning development from the higher intensity commercial areas to the neighboring residential areas and utilize a human scale or pedestrian oriented design to make sure that the development is safe, welcoming, and not overbearing. Create a catalyst for redevelopment and revitalization of the surrounding commercial areas.

33:10 And build upon those recent efforts I mentioned to ensure the neighborhood becomes an integral part of the greater community. And the last draft objective is to balance the guiding principles and development objectives with a viable program. So make sure this gets done, right? So prepare that program to implement these objectives and principles as feasible, but make sure we've got long-term viability.

33:39 So accommodate densities and design features necessary to qualify for essential funding to make sure the project gets constructed. Consider regulatory actions that would be necessary to implement the development, whether those timelines are opposed to us making progress with constructing as soon as possible.

34:02 And consider economic factors, investors, affordable housing developers, and future residents to make sure the project remains viable and absorption occurs as intended. And develop a phasing plan that reflects those market conditions and encourages construction to begin as early as practical. So being strategic with those phasing boundaries as well as absorption over time.

34:30 I know that's a lot. We want to take a break at this time to open it up to questions. And we'd like to focus the questions on big picture.

34:40 So in terms of background process and what we've heard so far, is there anything that needs clarification or you have questions about to help us move forward to the next step of discussing draft guiding principles and development objectives? Now, we will be getting to each of those draft guiding principles and development objectives in discussion, so we don't need to discuss that at length now. But we'd also like to note that...

35:07 Probably not all the questions raised today will be answered today. Many of those we may want to follow up with other experts on the team or there may be appropriate later venues to address those.

35:18 And so we want to make sure we're concise and respectful of everybody's time to ensure we have adequate time to have the discussion on these principles and objectives. And I'd also like to mention we do have comment cards back on that welcome table that if anyone is not ready to raise a question, feel free to write those down on the comment cards, drop them off in the box, and we'll address those. Those comment cards can include any ideas, thoughts, comments, at all. We'll incorporate those, and those will be included in the summary memo.

35:47 So real quick, Jen, when you say questions, did you want questions from everybody in terms of what has been presented? And then we'll come back to discussion and then further questions on that and comments? Absolutely. Thank you, Grady. That's perfect. And I think what we'd like to do perhaps is, Madam Mayor, if it's all right, maybe we take questions from the council and commissioners first and then open it up to public for any questions. Again, focusing on what we've presented thus far.

36:17 It's sort of the same process we use at Town Council or questions first. We'll get to discussion and more in-depth stuff later, but just questions so that there's a good understanding of what you've presented first. Great. Thank you. And with that, I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to the Planning Commission and to any Town Council that has questions. Let's keep them short if there are questions that have already been addressed.

36:44 You can just kind of chime in and say I agree with so-and-so. When it goes over to the public comment, this is kind of a time-sensitive day, so if we could keep that as short as possible as well. So with that, I will go ahead and open it for any questions from the commission or the town council. Just for the public record, I did submit 26 questions to the staff and to the public.

37:13 I think that it's going to be difficult when we approach this as a blank sheet of paper or a blank piece of property when there's been elections and everything else that have defined what has in the past been considered there. Right now, the land is zoned for 172 units.

37:39 And it can have double density at 344 units. And a lot of this presentation presented in such a fashion that we can pretty much do whatever the public asks. I mean, it's going to take some legislative actions to move this forward. So I just wanted to put that out there for the public because it seems to be the impression that

38:08 You know, we can, you know, this is open, we can do anything we want. It's going to be difficult. The funding tools are going to be very difficult. If you look at the low interest housing tax credits, Mr. Trump has taken that particular funding tool or diminished it as a tool that we can use. So that's going to be more difficult.

38:34 When we look at this project, and I think staff has done a good job, but when you look at it, you look at what you're trying to produce, but you're also having to look at the funding at the same time. If there's not the funding tools available, it's going to change the whole configuration and the product type that's going to be there. Did you have any specific questions for staff at this moment? I wanted to clarify what was presented.

39:04 Okay. Thank you. And I will mention I appreciate that comment and question. That's one reason we have Kaiser Marston and we do have Novin Development on our team. We are intending to run pro formas during the design workshop so that the concepts we present at the end are viable. They are financially viable. If I could add also in terms of the

39:28 The master plan, the general plan, the land use, the zoning, everything else. We are keeping every one of the existing plans and regulations and rules and state and federal guidelines in mind as we go through this. Having said that, the marching orders to the town team and to LWC when we're responding to public comments and everything is we need to come up with the best plan for the parcel for the next 100 years, frankly.

39:55 The idea is that unless there's something that says you absolutely shall not, and we aren't going to do any nightly rentals, believe me, regardless, but that's just a good example, so that's just seriously off the table, and we'll never say it again even. The point is, keep all the guidelines in mind, keep all the zoning regulations in mind, but still come up with a conceptual land use plan that we can recommend to Town Council and PEDC that works in the long run. Then...

40:20 And only then we come back to Council at that second and third workshop and say, okay, this is what it means to zoning. This is what it means to land use. This is what it means to all these things. And assess that and look at what we have to do from an environmental and zoning standpoint. So we don't want to be hemmed in. We have one chance. We have one 25 and a half an acre piece. We need to do it right. The rules are very important. Having said that, it's not...

40:44 I don't see a vision where it's 140 units or 170. Especially from the public, we've got lots of comments. It better be more than that. It better be substantial. So we're going to create something that we can come back, present it with recommendations, and then assess what needs to be done to implement it. Fair. John, do you have any questions that you would like to ask at this moment? I'm anxious to hear from the owners of the parcel. Okay. Exactly. I have a really quick question for Grady and for Sandra. Would you guys mind just quickly outlining the process?

41:16 From the town staff perspective of what it would be to amend the zoning for density on that parcel? So zoning, it would be a presentation or an application to go through and amend the zoning to base.

41:30 Depending on what exactly the Council adopts with a conceptual land use plan, we would go through a process to evaluate that and there would be environmental analysis associated with that that we would bring forward to the Planning and Economic Development Commission for consideration and the Town Council for final approval. So it would be amending the zoning code, changing those requirements and...

41:52 I don't know if just that particular question would require changing this general plan. But really, I think after this process is done, we're going to go through and identify what all of this means. And this is information that we would provide to you in December. So we'll say this conceptual land use plan means this. So be prepared for these things. So that's kind of the point of going through this process to get to a place where we can explain that. Thank you. Any other commissioners? I have a couple of questions. Thank you for that report, Jen. That was really helpful.

42:22 On the survey, the online survey, I'm curious if you can share a little bit about the demographic data that was gathered from those people. Do you have any of that info? We didn't, any in particular? Well, I know we were asked about income level, taking it, if you have that. That's my biggest curiosity. I don't remember if we were asked age.

42:42 So some of those responses were optional, and so we wanted to make sure we were presenting a full picture of responses, and so that's why we identified whether they were residents or not and where they lived. We could absolutely report on some of those. We just would go back and look at the data, and we can do that for you. Awesome. Thank you. And was there any metric that you found in the survey of how many people landed on the survey page, so opened it and didn't complete it?

43:10 We have that. I don't have the numbers here, but we can get that to you. Sure. Thank you. And then my couple questions on the public interest interviews. Could you talk to me about why that?

43:20 Or how that process was conducted? Was it publicized? How do you find those people? That sort of thing. So we worked closely with town staff to go through all of the folks that have been involved in the past on housing efforts and other critical folks in the community in terms of raising housing issues or related to those venues or areas where we think they would have a great insight into that area of need.

43:49 That's correct. Thank you. Sure.

44:19 Off those two questions, I understand that I was told that you chose to use the prior housing related groups as your sampling method for the interviews. Why do you think that's a more appropriate sampling method versus having a random sampling method? And do you think choosing these individual group of folks or industry, however, it might be relevant to the project,

44:48 Does this selection bias may have negatively skewed the response data and the validity of the findings? Now, case in point, the pie chart that you show, you have close to 30% that was government agency. You have about close to 15% are people in the real estate industry. If you go back and look at our 2017 report,

45:19 50, overwhelming, 55% of the population workforce here in this town are in the accommodation and food service industry. And almost 50% of the folks are below 100% AMI. So I'm curious as to, because you separated the interviewers and the online survey, is there purpose why you

45:51 You chose to do it that way. As somebody who doesn't do this very often but have done it in the past, let me just say we wanted a variety of ways to look at the picture.

45:59 We needed a lot of different approaches all over the place. So first we'd start with people that we knew were interested, that we knew would respond, that we knew probably was somewhat educated about the parcel and what was going on. And that was most of those groups and people that were already involved. But that, again, that was a two-day effort to do those interviews. Much broader will be and has been the online surveys. We got 276 responses, which, again, was very good. And all the other workshops that will be.

46:28 So you're right, it was different. Is it statistically relevant to interviews? No, it wasn't like we did a thing of all everybody in town and just picked somebody. It was just to get us a certain viewpoint, and then we shifted to the online surveys, which is a different viewpoint. We're hoping out of that and, frankly, the prior responses that went through the housing needs assessment and the chat and everything, all of those are in play. So we weren't trying to redo what was done before.

46:55 That didn't make any sense except to update the data. I think we wanted to take a different approach to get a different version. Is that fair? You do this more than I do. Yeah, and this is a very common process. And like I said, there were a number of folks invited that were unable to attend or didn't ultimately come to the interviews. This is the breakdown of those that ultimately attended and participated. However, I will say we're...

47:21 Throughout this process, we're constantly checking back in with the community. So while this kicked us off, we're continuing to go back to the community, and at no point are we going back to these interviewees to identify just their feedback on the process. I understand that the online survey might be folks that are in the food service sector folks, but how can we ensure that we have answers?

47:55 Yeah, I think we're continuing to go through that in our public engagement process and with the various methods we're using to outreach and contact in person various folks in the community. So we're absolutely working on that. And if there are any methods maybe that haven't come up that you think would be effective,

48:23 We would love to hear those and continue to integrate those in our process. Thank you. Okay. I just have one last question. Mammoth Lakes Housing has a wait list of 77 individuals on that. Were they incorporated into any of this? We reached out to Mammoth Lakes Housing to contact those folks, and we did conduct one interview over at Mammoth Lakes Housing. Thank you.

48:47 I have one more question as well. For people that can't physically be here today but want to submit comments, how do you suggest they do that? We do have a slide actually at the end that talks about other methods for comment. Thank you. Okay. And seeing no more questions. And this is just really the kickoff. And as John said, we want to talk to the owners and answer your questions. We have a little bit of time here.

49:15 If you've got some of these, there are some definite questions on here if you want to look and just kind of see where your priorities are on some of these. Remember where we have it that says if it's absolutely low on your list. Yeah. So I do kind of want to focus on these.

49:38 Yeah, absolutely a must. And so just keep that in the back of your brain. Remember, everybody has a wish list out there. You're not going to get everything on your wish list. So let's go ahead and start this conversation. If you could just come up to the dais and... Madam Mayor, these are just questions right now, right? Yes, these are just questions. Comments will be addressed later. There'll probably be some people lining up here. If you could just speak at the dais and introduce yourself.

50:06 And fire away when ready. Hi, John Morris. I'm a homeowner at 181 Manzanita. I own the house there for 25 years. And let's see, my question really, and that backs directly onto the parcel, which I am 100% in favor of this project. Do it. No more nimbyism. Get it done. We will never grow if we do not get affordable housing in this town. That is the end of the story. So please, let's get this done. My question is this.

50:36 Can you guys tell me what the, do you have a number of what your overall, you believe the overall need for affordable housing is at this time? I realize this addresses a portion of it, but my concern is the density, based on what other parcels are available, may be available, the density that is ultimately decided on here.

50:58 There should be some incorporation of what else is needed as well. So if there's nothing else available and we need 600 units and we need to put 344 units here, okay, I get it. If there are other parcels available and we need 600 units, can we put some here and some somewhere else? There should be some consideration of the density based on the overall need that we have, not just this one single parcel. That being said, so I think that that's part of the equation. I'm just curious if somebody could elaborate a little bit on that.

51:27 Appreciate it. Thank you. So in terms of the data we have on current need, we presented what we know from the CHAP.

51:36 Needs Assessment, which identified that 595 broken down between ownership, rental, and different income categories. And we also have the regional housing needs allocation, which is lower than that. So we have some data to be able to inform our work. At this point in time, I will say, we're not looking to identify any number. What we want to...

51:57 The input we want to get is to be able to define some guiding principles and development objectives that can lead us into conceptual planning work. So we'll have a lot to balance when we move through that concept planning effort, and we want to make sure that a number of units isn't driving design that may not be able to achieve what we're hoping to achieve with those objectives. Thank you, John. Hi, my name is Giselle Kenny. My main question is, how are

52:29 There's already been a few comments and concerns that I want to raise about public engagement that I felt have that we've kind of missed already, but I feel like this isn't the appropriate like what you're asking for right now isn't the most appropriate time. So I'm just wondering when that will be or how we can.

52:45 offer those comments and concerns. You can offer those at any time. The town staff is available during all town office or business hours, as well as there's an email on this slide for the parcel at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov. You can email those or even, I believe, just post on social media to certain questions you have as well. So there's no specific person, just go to these, like, this generic website or to the Facebook page or anything like that?

53:14 Yeah, but there are, if you have a specific question, I encourage you to call myself. Okay. Okay, first, and we check the, we have a special phone line set aside just for the parcel that's on the website. We have the email address. When I'm not available, Amy checks it every day as well, so we get back to everybody. I think I responded to a couple this morning as well, so send it in there, and if you have another opportunity for engagement, we welcome it. We're actually reaching out to civic groups. We're going to go to Rotary, Mammoth Voices, all sorts of stuff, so if you have something,

53:44 Please let us know and we won't get them all. You're right. We're going to miss something. So, you know, it's just a small group. So anything you have, please give it to us. Just to be clear, the email address is the most. Absolutely. That's the one to send it to. Do it everywhere else. Absolutely. Email addresses. There'll be self-esteem accountability. Because then timing doesn't hurt. I mean, I check those on the weekend, Saturday, Sunday, whenever. We can get back to it. It's not set in the time, but we do get back to everybody. So please send it in. Thank you. Thanks.

54:13 Thank you. If I could answer John Morris' question on numbers. The RHNA, the state is 155. That we're required to look at. When we looked at a needs assessment, it was 264.

54:31 When we looked at one of our needs assessments, by 2022, we look like we need about 600 units. So, you know, looking forward, we've got a big issue to address. Currently, the parcel is zoned for 172 units. The code, the town code, will allow 344 units on that, double density.

54:59 Now, if you look at the developable acres on that, you're going to find that if you try to put all 344 in there with parking spaces and everything else, you're going to have some congestion or some issues. So there's going to be some real balancing acts going on looking at what is currently zoned and what we can actually get in there. Remember, we lose...

55:24 Probably four acres to wetlands there. So we're looking at 21 acres. You know, if this were easy, everybody would be doing this. So, you know, we've got a lot of things to work through. And this is where, again, we are kicking off. So we're not going to have all the answers today. Dan? I was just wondering if you've gotten any information from the previous owners. Were there ever plans pulled? Were there any drawings?

55:50 That's a great question. Actually, when I started working for the town in 2005, we started looking at concept plans back then with the owner of the property. So, yes, there are previous concept plans. We have those, and our design team has referenced those. So, thank you. Hi, Drew Hild. I just had a question of how you guys intended to, because we're doing a design, kind of what people want, but Kurt raised a really important part, our financing vehicles and what pencils.

56:20 And what I am hoping that we, the two parallel processes kind of continue, you know, next to each other and that the public understands that we don't want to create something that we can't afford or is not buildable because we need the housing. So I think, you know, I want to hear what your ideas are to make sure the public understands what the financing realities are and, you know, where the trip lines are and densities and all that kind of stuff. So how do you guys intend to approach that?

56:47 So that's a great question. And actually, our design objective F, I think, gets exactly to that, talking about balancing those objectives and guiding principles with a viable product and project. So that's ensuring something gets constructed and done. So I think when we get into the discussion of that objective, that's where that lands. OK. How do we make sure the public understands that what ultimately gets designed is something that

57:16 You know, that they can, they're going to like what they look at, and it's going to be a community that works, but they can also get it done, because I think one of the responses I saw was get it done and start building as soon as possible, and that means drilling into what can we afford, where can we get money, because somebody's got to pay to build these, or it's just going to be a big lot again. And actually, let me address that, because on LWC's team, there is Novin Development, who's...

57:42 We've proven to be very knowledgeable and very helpful with the team in making sure we look at those things. But parallel to that, as you said, while LWC is going through this planning process with the public and engagement to come up with a conceptual plan, we're already starting, as you know, contacting potential developers, investors, whoever. While I'm down in LA, frankly, I've already met with a couple of other people.

58:04 Researching everything and learning everything I can about this so that when we come back for the second workshop in October, I believe it is, we'll be able to present at least an initial plan. Okay, this is how we're going to go solicit.

58:17 The developer or developers. This is how we're going to plan the site. And one of the big criteria will be, frankly, the ability to produce. And that means the ability to find funds to make it happen because that's what affordable housing developers do. It's not a subject of today. I don't want to get too much into that detail because we really need to focus on what we're talking about with the conceptual design. But that's a parallel track. Absolutely. It's a parallel track and it's just as important because.

58:43 If it doesn't work that way, it's not going to happen. It has to work. It has to be financially viable in the long term. Sandy Hogan, and I have just two very short questions. The first one, is there any way to open up the survey again or keep it ongoing? Because I've heard from a lot of people, you know, by the time they heard about it, it was closed. My second one is the four-day workshop. What I've heard from a lot of people, and my questions too,

59:10 People think they just can't blank out four days. They don't realize, and I still don't understand, is it in pieces? Can people come in at any time? You know, how many hours are involved? And I know Amy sent me some information on it, but it's still not clear in my mind. And I think you have to get the word out because I just wrote up here with somebody who, she says, there's no way I can go blank out four days or whatever. And I said, well, I think it's

59:36 There's going to be drop-ins here and there, but I'm not really clear on it. I couldn't explain it. And if I can't, and I'm trying to follow this, I know a lot of people can't. So one, if you can keep the survey going, I know it costs more money, but gives that input and answers some of the questions I've heard. And two, get out the word right away about the workshop, because people are not going to cancel vacations and things like that.

1:00:01 Excellent. So we are just wrapping up getting that material for an information flyer for that design workshop out. I think it's going to be ready next week. So we'll have that. Thank you. That's a great, great question. And then in terms of the survey, I think...

1:00:17 We're planning on leaving it closed. We are going to continue to have additional efforts for feedback on Engage Mammoth Lakes, so it's going to be a continue back and forth and checking in with the community. Did we hear you right? What did we miss? So I think we're going to move past the survey, but we'll continue to have ongoing efforts for engagement. Yeah, and two things to add to that. Anybody can...

1:00:38 You talk to their friends or whatever or get a copy of the survey results. And if they'd like to make a comment, please do so by email or by phone. So it's closed in terms of a formal survey because we wanted some data, if you will. But in terms of comments, for God's sakes, read the survey and if you have a comment on the results, please let us know what they are because we'll continue to look at those as we move forward. The one thing on the four-day workshop, and it will be tough, and the detail on it will show that you will be able to drop in and out if you have particular areas.

1:01:08 But I want to encourage everybody, again, this is important. This is 25 acres. We got one shot. This is going to be built out over a number of years. The number of units is going to be critical because, yes, 595 by 2022, that's three years away. We're going to be here a lot longer than that. So my point is, if you can spend the whole four days or it's actually a couple of hours on one day, three, three, and then two, please try to set it as soon as the schedule is set.

1:01:37 We ask people, please try to set it the whole time. It is tough, but this is the most important thing, at least we're doing right now, and that's what we've heard from Town Council. So I know it's difficult. I really do. But I just plead with everybody that's listening, set aside as much time as you can and attend as much as that as you can. So thank you. And if it's only 15 minutes, that's okay. You're welcome to come. Please come.

1:02:02 Hi, Jennifer Helfordy. I wonder if you have thought about or if you could think about how Senate Bill 35 is going to play into the rollout of this given that Mammoth Lakes is subject to SB 35 and if the conceptual plan will help everyone feel confident because it really limits.

1:02:27 Use permit requirements and such and just how that's going to play into it. And so just make sure that's incorporated and more educated on how that's going to play out. That'd be great. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah, that's one reason we noted it in the presentation. Thank you. Any more questions at this time?

1:02:47 Hi, my name is Lindsay Barksdale. I do sit on the board for Mammoth Lakes Housing. One of my questions is a little bit to do with process. As I was looking at the calendar of events for this planning process, I was surprised to see that there wasn't sort of an event similar to this with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. And so I just wanted to be sure, or I guess my question being, how do you and your group plan to interact with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board and ensure that that information that...

1:03:16 That the housing office has kind of their expertise and already having built affordable housing projects, how that gets to you guys and how that knowledge gets out to the greater public. Great. Thanks, Lindsay. So Mammoth Lakes Housing is on our team. They're on our biweekly calls. And we're actually in the midst sort of talking about those monthly updates to MLH and how we can be most effective with those. So thank you. Thank you.

1:03:39 And again, I have to add to it is that when we talked about how we get information out, we actually realized it's better if town staff is there and participates more. So we've let Patricia know that I think next Monday, I'm pretty sure I'm back in town. I'll be there at the board meeting and either Sandra or I or somebody representing will be there. And if you'd like to set an agenda item in the future to be a little bit more formal with town staff, absolutely we're willing, able, and ready to do so. So, so far we've gotten peace information, but we'd love to do that. So, thanks.

1:04:10 Hi, my name's Jim Clark. I've been a resident, permanent resident of Mammoth for about 20 years, but I came here first in 1939. I've seen a lot of changes, a lot of stupid decisions made, but they're all water under the bridge. There is no question we do need affordable housing in Mammoth Lakes. My concern is, are we looking at affordable housing

1:04:42 When we talk about child care, a trail system, parks, open space, bus stops, maybe, playgrounds, resident parking, yes. A lot of those things aren't affordable housing. They're amenities and things that everybody would like to have in their neighborhood. Few of us have all of those things in our neighborhood. We don't have a great many parks.

1:05:20 In Mammoth Lakes for the size of the town that we have. So amenities are one thing. Needs and necessities are another thing. I think we need to separate the wheat from the chaff. I take exception also to some of the arithmetic and maybe I'm not the person to do this because I'm not a mathematician. But correct me if I'm wrong. Were there 45 people?

1:05:52 That were interviewed for this summary? Yes, yes. That, if my arithmetic is correct, we've got a town of approximately 7,000 permanent residents. That figures out to be 0.6% of the population that are giving direction here. Is that a representative percentage to make decisions from? I don't think so.

1:06:23 So I think if your question is about whether just the interviews influenced where we are today, I would say no, because what we've done to draft, and this is the introduction of draft, guiding principles and development objectives based on what we've heard, and a lot of that is through the survey response where we had 276 folks respond. Yeah, which represents 4% of the population. Absolutely. And that's not very representative either, I don't believe.

1:06:52 Is there a, yes, so in my experience, that actually is a fairly good response rate for these types. It's a fairly good response rate for these types of surveys. Now, as I mentioned before, by no means does this lock in anything.

1:07:11 So I think, is there another

1:07:35 Question? I think we're still on questions. If I'm hearing you correctly, your question is how much is that going into the whole decision-making process? When I read it, I found a lot of inconsistency. So I think other people read that just for what it is, and that is not what we're moving forward. So if I'm incorrect, let me know. Did you have another question about that? No, I think you've told me what I need to know. Yeah. So if you have more questions, talk to me. I'll give you my thoughts.

1:08:04 My main question tonight is, are there any plans for this parcel now made up where I can see where the homes are, where the houses are, where the apartments are, whatever is going to go in there? Plus, do you have a number of people who are going to live there? Or how many units you're going to put in there? And I...

1:08:40 Remember, it was in the olden days. I lived there for 46 years, right next to that little creek, which I'm taking care of for 46 years. What's going to happen to the wetlands back there? And how many units? If you still go by the 172 units where it was years ago, made four.

1:09:08 So my question is, how many units have you come up by now? Or can you answer me that?

1:09:17 We're not there yet, Dieter. So we're just getting started. So we're trying to understand the community's guiding principles and objectives that can help us start with a framework for how we start developing conceptual plans. So we do not have any plans now. We will be developing plans at that August design workshop. Great. Okay. I just wonder if you still go by the

1:09:49 But planning, the village in the trees, you remember that, right? So I just wonder, that's why I'm wondering how many units you're going to put in there. I heard units of 300, I heard units of 500. I mean, we got to put something in there where anybody from here will live in it. Not workforce housing and put...

1:10:20 Put many, many units in and it's terrible to look at. Okay? Terrible to look at. So that's my main question. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Do we have any more questions from the public at this moment? Okay. Seeing none, I'm going to go ahead and turn it back over to you for digging in a little bit deeper. Fantastic. So we have...

1:10:47 One set of guiding principles and six development objectives. So we're going to focus on one category at a time. Our first are the draft guiding principles. And what we'd like to hear and start to get some feedback on is a scale of in the blue box here, are these items absolutely a must, strong consideration, nice to have, not important, or no go, not at all. So I think with that,

1:11:16 We'll open it up for comments. And if I might, we know that we're not looking for final decisions or anything like that today. We're not even looking for consensus. We'll take your responses. We'll balance it. Everything else we'll feed it back to you and we'll have further discussion. So don't be concerned that it has to be with seven.

1:11:35 We just want to hear what you hear, and if it's what you have to say, and if it's individual, some may say a certain thing is absolutely a must, others may say no go. That's fine. We don't even have to get into a huge discussion of that individual item. We just really want each of you at the table today, especially E7, to say what you think about each of these in that framework. Is that fair? So no, this isn't a final decision point. It's just what do you think? We haven't had the opportunity to hear that, frankly, yet. We just haven't been there.

1:12:04 Yes, and we are, as I mentioned, based on the feedback we get today, we will be revising these and then reposting these for public feedback. And I think, Madam Mayor, if it's acceptable, maybe look for a three-minute limit on comments. I mean, ideally, we have shorter for folks to be concise and respectful. We have a lot of people here. We want to make sure everyone gets an opportunity to speak. Okay, so we'll go with the three-minute from the...

1:12:32 Public comment, but first I will turn this over to the Town Council. How would be the easiest way for you guys to get this information? Would you like to address each one? One, two, three, four? Yes, each one. Oh, okay. Anybody feel like kicking that off? I think there's 21 acres that are developed, four acres are wetlands there. From my...

1:12:58 Limited experience. If you go higher than 16 units per acre, you end up with parking issues and snow removal issues. So if you look at that, there's 21 acres that might be developed. You still have to worry about the roads and you have the parking. And if you're doing underground

1:13:20 All those things need to be brought into consideration. But again, from my experience at the most is 16 units an acre. When you start getting to 18 units an acre, you have parking issues and you have snow removal issues. So I just wanted to add that so that people can understand where I'm coming from. Well, I guess what I'm looking for and tell me if I'm incorrect on this. I'm just looking for

1:13:50 For people to say, okay, I'm looking at one that is this on my list. This is number two. So any other questions right now that's kind of giving off my train of thought here? So can you just kind of go through and tell us, or if you would like to share with us just number one, where does that fall into your list? Number two, you know, those. I just explained. I consolidated those. That's my comment.

1:14:19 Okay, so I'll just kind of let you guys know where I'm coming from. Number one, provide long-term housing for those wishing to live and work in Mammoth Lakes by addressing a substantial portion. That's absolutely a must in my brain. Create a well-designed neighborhood that stands the test of time. That's a strong consideration. Enable housing construction as soon as possible. That's going to be nice to have. We've got a lot of things ahead of us. I'm not going to be working before.

1:14:49 You know, I feel really comfortable with where we're going. Develop a sustainable program for long-term viability, including financial and management requirements. I think that's absolutely a must. So, okay, so that's kind of what you're looking for. So, John, would you care to list those? Sure. At this point, I'm going to say all four of them for me are strong considerations. Okay. I don't have enough information yet to start getting into this. I do have some concerns about the process, but I'll figure out another forum to share those.

1:15:17 And again, I'm most interested in hearing from the community. Okay, thank you. Anybody from the Planning Commission wishing to? Absolutely. I would also like to list all four of them as a strong consideration with the exception of number two. I do think number two needs to be an absolute must. Okay. As stated earlier, we got one go at this. Okay. I think all four are considered absolutely a must. Okay.

1:15:52 Thank you. I agree with Paul. I think absolutely a must. I would say one and two are absolutely a must. Three is a strong consideration and four is absolutely a must. Okay. Thank you. I'll go ahead and open it for public. If you could just kind of follow those same ways that we did this. I think that this will be important information. You can come up to the dais, please.

1:16:19 Okay, so I am going to agree with Mr. Stapp on number one that number one is depending on density. So I can't say absolutely a must if I think we're going to go over a density that will make it nice. On the rest, I would say absolutely a must. Tom Cage, of course, Cleland's not here now. If the council does not push this along, this could be studied for a long, long time.

1:16:55 Hundreds of thousands of dollars could be spent on studying this for a long, long time. Number three says as soon as possible. When does that mean? What soon to you is different than soon to me, but there's got to be a time. Set it in stone. Say, staff, this is a priority. The community has told you it's a priority. Other infrastructure will need to go into this area that will be a priority before you can put sticks in the ground. And we, you know, Edison and Water District and so forth and so on. What's the goal?

1:17:25 What's the date? Because otherwise you are going to study this to death and you are going to spend millions of dollars and not do a thing. Please show some leadership and guidance and put a date on it to get this started. Thank you for letting us speak. I'm Deb Pearl. I agree with Melinda and with respect to number one being very important, but also being appropriately dense with regard to parking snow removal.

1:17:56 Toys that people own, things that we've done wrong so many times. And I follow Kirk's acknowledgement about a lower density and what it takes to be around it. I would say that number two and four are also important, but number three, that to me is not a guiding principle. It's important that we get this done. We need something fabulous there. We need the right thing. But a guiding principle is not as soon as possible. That doesn't make sense in the process of it, in my opinion. Thank you.

1:18:27 Just sell Kenny. I also wanted to reiterate number one, I think it's important, however, we need to address and make sure that the livability is appropriate, not just pile people on top of each other just because there's a need. I think that three and four are an absolute, absolutely a must, but again, with Tom Cage, what does as soon as possible mean to you guys? And obviously two is also an absolutely must. They're all absolutely must, but livability is really, really important.

1:18:56 Thank you. Thanks, John Morris again. Two and four on my list would be the most important. We want this to be, you know, these are going to be long-term rentals. We want the people that live there to have pride in where they live. And having something that looks nice, that's well-designed and well-maintained, in my experience as a...

1:19:21 Rental Manager for 30 years makes a big difference. People take care of something that's built nicely and well put together. And the last part, you know, a sustainable program is absolutely critical. We've got to have the funds in place so we can maintain the place so it doesn't fall apart and look like a slum because nobody wants that. So I'd say two and four would be at the top of my list. Okay, thank you.

1:19:46 I'd like to just swap the focus on number one a little bit. Instead of thinking about it as density, for me, the most important part for that is providing long-term affordable housing and ensuring that something is in place, that those units do stay affordable for 100 years or for however long we're looking at it. Thank you. Anybody else wish to talk on these guiding principles?

1:20:11 Raise our hand. Oh, no, you can. Oh, yeah, you know what, we should go. Who thinks that? I just want to remind Jennifer Halford-Egan, everyone, that we did see on slide 52, the second priority besides affordable housing for the long term was construct housing as soon as possible. Thank you. How does this, we have a demand study, I think you said something like 600 units needed. Okay.

1:20:49 Whatever our density is, that's going to leave a deficit. So if you build what it's planned for at 344, you're going to have a deficit of the difference between that and 600. 2023 is like you couldn't finish this much faster than that and we'll already be in a deficit. So I guess the question I would ask is where's the rest of it going? So when you decide on this, you've got to decide what you're going to solve the total problem on because you can't just ignore it.

1:21:16 As usual, you are like way ahead of where I'm thinking right now. So I appreciate it. I think a lot of things that you were saying are going to come up in the further workshops. But just with looking at that list, just let me know like what is really, this is more for feedback so that, you know, everybody has a good place that we're working from. Well, a sustainable program and I agree with Pam.

1:21:41 We need to get started as soon as possible. As soon as practical, we're not doing a bad project, obviously. I agree with that.

1:21:46 And so no no-goes on this list for you. No no-goes. No no-goes. That's good to know. If I could jump in real quick, Sandy, for just a second, just to respond to something. Absolutely correct. The parcel is not the only thing that's happening in town. There's a concerted effort for housing in general. That's going to continue. 300 or 400, however many units end up here, isn't going to solve the problem forever. That's for another discussion we're trying to focus on the parcel specifically.

1:22:11 I just want to make sure that's, and also when we move on from this slide, we have a lot more questions, a lot more things, so I'd ask that we may even take some hand votes later, something like that, to get that going, because otherwise we will not be done by a hard time of 5.45, but I appreciate the way people are responding so far, because you're just, hey, this is my hot button, that's good, and sitting down, we appreciate it, so thank you. Sandy Hogan again, I think number one, well, they're all for me.

1:22:40 Absolutely a must, but the first one I think is confusing people a little bit because you're talking about density and that the long-term affordable housing is the key there and current need. So maybe I don't know if you can even scrunch that a little bit more because by addressing a substantial portion of Mammoth Lakes current housing need, that current housing need, it's current long-term affordable housing need. You almost have to repeat it or

1:23:09 You know, edit it, one of the two. I think that's some of the confusion there. Oh, okay, thank you. Okay, if we do not have any more public comment, we are going to dive into the draft development objectives. Provide quality housing to accommodate households of different ages, sizes, and incomes. I'll go ahead and turn this over to the, I'll start with the commission here for just your thoughts on where you rate some of these items.

1:23:39 Then I'll go to Town Council. Commissioners, any comments? Anybody want to jump in? I find it kind of hard to prioritize a number of these because I feel like I don't have the data necessary to figure out exactly what we need. Do we need studios? Do we need three bedrooms? The only one I feel kind of passionate about is I don't feel there should be any place for an ownership product. I think it should be some sort of affordable workforce housing.

1:24:12 Now, does the town manage that? Does the developer manage that? I don't know. These are questions I don't have the answers for, but I don't think that we should be taking inventory out of that overall housing pool and slowly decreasing the numbers of available units as time goes on. So I don't know if I have enough information to even rate these at this time.

1:24:37 Again, I think that right now it would be very good if you could just say, even though you don't, we don't have the information. So this is going to help us kind of put the information. So just how... Madam Mayor, I apologize. I mean, I think it's perfectly fine if you don't feel comfortable to rate that. What we're trying to do is get a sense at this first take, right? Is some of this absolutely, did we get it wrong?

1:25:06 You know. Sure. And with that being said, Jen, I'll just throw, you know, I feel like I'm kind of throwing darts at this point, but. No, excuse me. Let me finish. I'll jump on number five as an absolute must. I will jump on number three with the ownership products as a no-go. Okay. Number one and number two would be strong consideration. And number four, yeah, really.

1:25:36 I'll just have to go with nice to have, I guess, at this point, just because I don't really know what the income, how that's going to break out.

1:25:45 You know what? I'm sorry. I just got back from a conference this last week, and there are so many bills that are out there that are just really wacky when it comes to affordable housing. And so even though you guys are coming up with some really good questions, this is not a Mammoth Lakes that could be some of the problem with us moving forward. This is a larger state and federal issue as well, and I just want to throw that in. If I seem a little bit short, it's just like it was a nightmare. Anyway, so going back to that.

1:26:14 I would just say the variety of housing types is a strong consideration for me. I think that that would work for different people. The mix of unit types, yeah, you're gonna have to, whether you're gonna nail it right on the head.

1:26:29 With the sizes, that's kind of like ordering t-shirts for a group of 500 people. You're never going to get it right. Provide both rental and ownership products. Strong consideration. I am leaning more towards focusing on rental. However, realizing that ownership may be one of the funding methods that we're going to have to use in order to make this.

1:26:51 Project eventually, hopefully pencil out. Serving the moderate income households, that's a strong consideration because we do have a lot of people in that group that will be looking for housing that they are happy with. Design for high durability and low maintenance, that's a strong consideration. Those are mine.

1:27:16 If I can respond to your question on ownership product, we have deed restricted, so when they purchase, sometimes they get a silent second, and so they're able to move into a unit, and they are deed restricted, so they can appreciate about 2% a year.

1:27:36 Creating that kind of a product in the parcel is a viable tool because the fact is it pencils a little bit better, but you've got to have a 99-year deed restriction on it. Okay, thank you. If I may. Yes, please. I think every item in here is a strong consideration. If you look at the 27th report, it advocated that if we want the current ratio to retain,

1:28:05 There's a 46-54 ratio currently, ownership versus rental. And also provided the range of income and the AMI, what should be what we need to focus on. We need to focus on 70%, 120% AMI income category versus 80% or 80%

1:28:34 Below 80% AMI for the rental category. So I think these are all the numbers that were provided before, and this is something that maybe we want to revisit these numbers again and see if this is something that we think is appropriate. Okay, thank you. For me, I'd say number one is a strong consideration.

1:28:57 Number two is an absolute must. Number three is nice to have. Number four, strong consideration. And number five, absolutely a must. Okay, thank you. I'd say number one is a strong consideration. Number two, absolutely a must. Three and four, I'm going to skip commenting on for now. And number five is a strong consideration. Okay, thank you. John, you can. One through four, strong consideration is number five, absolute must.

1:29:25 Okay. We'll go ahead and turn this over to the public, and if you'd like to come up, and we'll just try to do this pretty quickly so that we can get through all of these, feel free to come up and put in your two cents. And keep in mind, if you generally, I'll just suggest that if you generally agree with what you've heard,

1:29:45 You know, add your comment or add something that's a little bit different. We don't need to repeat everything. In other words, if you say, well, I like what Jen said, just say that and we got it. Is that fair? Because we do have a lot to get through. So I appreciate it. Thank you. Just sell Kenny. Number one, a strong consideration. Number two, an absolute must. Number three, an absolute must with the deed restriction on the ownership products. Number four, I find the second half extremely concerning.

1:30:13 Since it's really easy for things not to pencil and just say, okay, we're going to make it market rate. So I like the first half. I don't like the second half. And then number five is strong. Absolutely a must. Okay, thank you for that. Peter, how are you going to rank these? I like number three. Not only rentals. You should put ownership in between it. That would take care of a lot of problems. Number one. Number two.

1:30:50 I want to make a suggestion. I have not seen anything about parking and snow storage. We are a window resort here. Those are coming up. I have a good point to make, okay? Snow storage. Okay, thank you. You'll get another chance. We got away without that. My guys at the yard would bury me in the snow bank. We're definitely bringing them in to talk about snow storage. Okay. Hi, Patricia Robertson with Mammoth Lakes Housing.

1:31:21 I have a comment. I guess for number one, I think it would be nice to have. I guess we'll see what the needs look like and how the projects pencil in terms of typology. But I did want to comment on the rental and ownership mix. We have approximately 40 ownership deed restrictions within the town of Mammoth Lakes today. All those units are occupied and they're in high demand. So I think

1:31:51 Enabling our community members to invest long term in the community through property ownership is an important component of this project. So I would just say that with a deed restriction for ownership. And then I guess I'm not sure about number four, the second half of it, what it means in terms of financial feasibility. Higher income units, at least in terms of ownership, pencil in certain markets but not in the long term.

1:32:23 I think you might see an ownership deed restriction at 200% AMI pencil today, but when the market comes down, we might lose that unit because they'd be underwater and then we wouldn't be able to buy it back and it would be a good investment of the town's money. So I'm not sure what that means, but I have some concerns around that and I think that's all I have. Okay. Thank you, Patricia.

1:32:48 Okay, seeing no one else jumping up, we'll go ahead and move on to the next portion, which is draft development objectives. Drew, are you going to go to that last one? Number three, when you're talking about rental and ownership, I definitely, I've stopped consideration on all of them on ownership product. I agree with the comment about taking it out of the inventory. I am highly against having a for sale product in this. I think there should be workforce.

1:33:16 And we get the rents down as low as possible. So really the workforce, the people who work in our service industries and support our town have accessibility and we don't take it out because those people tend to be, you know, we need to have it available. So that's just my thinking. Okay, thank you. Sorry, I've got to get on the number three bandwagon.

1:33:36 I actually own a deed restricted unit, so I'd like to say that it is actually very important to me that there are ownership units. What I want to be sure is that we're not confusing ownership, and actually maybe it could be a clarification, that ownership does not mean market rate priced ownership. You can still have affordable ownership as well as affordable rentals. So for me it is a must have that you have rental and ownership. It provides a nice

1:34:06 Diversity within a community. I think also somebody alluded to the fact that maybe owners of a property might really be invested in taking care of it. I think that's a great part of it as well. So yeah, if we can keep that in for me, it would be great. You know what, I just realized when you said that, that when I saw ownership, I was just only thinking deed restrictions. So thank you for clarifying that. Yeah, and that's it, that there's ownership at market rate, there's ownership at deed restricted. So as long as we're very clear on what that means.

1:34:33 And we could just add, as part of the community housing action process and the housing summit, glossaries were developed, standardized terms of use were developed. I would hope that the consultants are using that. It's already been invested in the community, so we're using the same semantic terms. It'll help with the confusion with this. And thank you for bringing up market rate, because that was, I think that's what you're getting as a market rate. Absolutely. 100%. Where your mind went to deed restricted, my mind went to market.

1:34:59 Actually, for me on this list, if there would be a six, it would be market rate properties would be a no-go for me. See, this is working for me. We're all getting on the same page, and I'm understanding where people are coming up, and you're bringing up things I haven't thought about, so I really appreciate this. So moving on to the draft development objectives, provide a range of mobility options and multi-module connections from the parcel to community destinations.

1:35:24 Anybody care to kick that off from the planning or the town council? I'll jump in here. I'll say all five of them are absolutely strong consideration. Absolutely a strong consideration. Strong consideration. How about that? Please split the difference there. I'll say absolutely a must on all of them. Okay. Absolutely a must on the first three and then the last two a strong consideration. Okay. Strong consideration for all five.

1:35:55 I'm going to concur with a strong consideration on all five of these. Kirk, ideas? No, strong consideration. Okay, thank you. Yeah, strong consideration for all five. I think what's missing on here is a transit hub. Again, I would go back to consultants and advise that with the walk-by-wire program to be using the term of arts, we need to identify those planning documents. That's missing from this list, but I think that needs to be added. We could have almost folded to number five, though, John. Yeah, we could.

1:36:25 Okay. I just bring that up. Okay. Thank you. Okay. We'll go ahead and open it up to the public now. Tell us your rankings. And as John's walking up, I'll go ahead and throw in that you're absolutely correct. But more than just connecting the parcel to community destinations, which is what the word is, we're trying to make sure the parcel becomes a part of the community. It's seamless. It all works. Whether the transit up is inside the parcel or immediately adjacent on Laurel Mountain or what, it needs to be in that area. Absolutely.

1:36:53 It's part of that process. So thanks. Good. John. Okay. Thanks. All of them are important. I would say from my take, number two, reducing, by all means possible, reducing vehicular traffic would be my number one. There are already options within that area of bus stops and so forth. So really encouraging the folks that live there to use public transportation, bicycles, whatever. Absolutely. Keep the traffic down as much as possible. Okay. Thank you.

1:37:26 Okay, anyone else from the public? My name is John Armstrong and absolutely a must for points one and two and also that the consideration for e-bikes and electrical charging for vehicles needs to be integrated in the design of the community. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Hi, I have a comment on number four. I'm not sure how...

1:38:03 Minimizing cut-through traffic became a development objective. I know all of the streets in the Sierra Valley sites go from Main Street all the way through the residential communities, so I'm not sure where that came from, or maybe it's a...

1:38:19 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:38:47 That way. And I just wouldn't want to see the parcel have something like that. Okay. So I would say not appropriate, but let's just. Oh, okay, for number four. Okay, thank you. Sandy Hogan, that came from me. Because I want to envision a community where people, the kids are out there playing. We know what the folks that are going to be living there are having.

1:39:11 Probably large families. I see kids playing out there, riding bikes, whatever, and I can just see cut through from Arrowhead onto center if you don't do that. I mean, that, so that's why, for me, I see a community of kids playing outside. So I had it as an absolute must. The others, most of them are, you know, very strong considerations, except the transit stop.

1:39:40 I would agree with John. You probably have transit stops or can schedule transit to be closer so that buses don't have to be passing through and running over the kids that are playing in the streets. And no transit hub in the parcel, thank you. Nearby, probably important for Main Street or whoever, but certainly not inside. The amount of land that that would take, parking structure and more vehicles and all like that, no.

1:40:10 I do believe that our residents will probably have at least one car, if not two, so we have to plan for it. That's just reality. Thank you for your consideration. Okay, going once, going twice. Okay, we will go ahead. And did you want to answer to any of the things that have been brought up so far?

1:40:35 No, I think this is fine. If at the end we have time to touch back on some stuff, great. But this is, we do need to keep it moving. We don't want to hurry anybody, so let's keep moving. No, it's me doing the hurrying today. Sorry. Okay, we are going to go ahead and move to draft development objectives. Provide an integrated network of amenities and civic and open spaces while striving to make the best use of every square foot of land. Very worthy. Who would like to kick this one off?

1:41:02 I have a question. Sure. What does it mean, integrate pet-friendly design? This comment came up pretty regularly on the survey, and I think it relates more to the allowance of pets in units. I do think that's an obstacle for folks finding housing. Totally, but it's not saying, in my mind goes to, I have a dog and she doesn't need any sort of design. Like, the units aren't designed for pets. It's more, is it allowed? Is that right? Got it. Dog barks or anything like that. Okay.

1:41:31 Yeah, that's a good question. Dog parts have come up as an issue. I'm sure. That feels different to me, though, than dogs are allowed. Mm-hmm. Okay. Oh, okay. Did you want to go through the list with this, or? No, I don't want to. Oh, okay. They're not going there yet. Okay. Jen, I'll go. Number one would be nice to have. Two, I think we need to strongly consider it. Three, nice to have. Four, consider.

1:42:00 And five, strongly consider. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to go one through four, nice to have, number five, absolutely a must. Okay, thank you. Paul? I agree with Michael. Okay. Thank you. For me, actually, number three is a very strong consideration. Absolutely.

1:42:29 And then number five is also

1:42:56 Absolutely a must. You want people to visit you if you're living in that site. Comments? The only one I have, as long as we're not building a dog park, we need the space for housing. So I've seen designs where all of a sudden there's a couple acres of, and I just got, no. And then the parking is very important, you know, because the fact is that most,

1:43:30 Most families that are in our current units, you know, both the mother and father work. So a minimum of two spaces, even on a one bedroom or two bedroom. And this, you know, creates underground parking and all kinds of issues and snow removal issues. But I think it's very important. Thank you. John, you have anything you'd like to chime in on there? All strong considerations for me. Okay.

1:43:58 Thank you. I'll jump back in. I'd say number one is a no-go for me. I'm curious to get some more data from the actual people, you know, from the affordable housing demographic on this subject, but for me, I'm a little bit concerned about number one. Number two would be nice to have.

1:44:21 Playgrounds, especially more than parks. The pet friendly, I would like to say absolutely a must. Two pets are allowed. Absolutely not to pet to dog park. Nice to have number four and then number five, strong consideration. Okay, thank you. Okay, we'll go ahead and open it up for all the owners of the parcel here. By the way, if anyone is missing that, I do mean the community, not picking on individuals here. Eastern California, where we prioritize.

1:44:53 Outbacking over children and pets over children. One and two is an absolute must. If you're not taking care of family, working families with kids and daycare, then this will be a very hollow community. Thank you. Giselle Kenny. One and two, an absolute must. Three, an absolute must. And possibly, I don't know the wetlands, if that could possibly be some sort of dog park since it can't be developed on anyways. And then,

1:45:24 Four and five, strong consideration. Okay, thank you. Still open for the public. I would question everybody that you have a finite amount of space and you have to maximize whatever you're going to do down there, whether it be seven-story apartment buildings or garden homes that you...

1:45:59 Have a number of people in town that need affordable housing. So I caution you about the amenities that you have suggested so far. Are we talking about dog parks? Are we talking about child care? Are we talking about they're all nice things to have? Don't misunderstand me. But if you're working with a finite amount of property and you have

1:46:27 420 or 377 units that you can put on that property, how small are those units going to be in order to put in a park? How small are those units going to be to erect a child care facility if it means anything? So you've got to weigh the various options that you've got, and you've got to toss out some of these things.

1:46:57 You'd like to have, but you can't have your cake and eat it too. Oh, okay. So on this list, what would you, do you have some that are a total no-go, or do you have some that are split between non-important or appropriate? Well, parks and playgrounds, forget it. Okay, that's a no-go for you. We need it, yes, but not in the affordable housing. Okay. 25 acres that you've got to play with. Okay.

1:47:26 Pet friendly design. I don't know really what that means. Indoor and outdoor community gathering spaces. Forget it. Okay. Forget it. You can go to the library. And then what are your thoughts for the provide parking for residents and guests but limit land required for parking, thereby reserving available land for other uses? Well, I think something that we all forget in Mammoth is that this community was built and founded and developed

1:47:56 By the people from Los Angeles, and I don't know anybody in Los Angeles that hasn't got one or two or more cars. So you've got to have parking. You just have to have it. I don't recall anybody's name that said, we want to make this place a pedestrian community. And I thought that was one of the silliest things I've ever heard. They obviously didn't know who was living here and where they came from.

1:48:25 Because everybody drives a car. You know? If you want to have a pedestrian community, you better find some land south of town, east of town, west of town, well, you can't go west, north of town, and buy it and say, everybody park their car up there and walk or take transit. Because too many of us, myself included, came from Southern California.

1:48:58 And, yeah, I got three cars, and there's only my wife and I live in here now. However, one of them's an antique. Okay, I appreciate your candor. Thank you for that. I'd like to add a comment, if I could, here, that will hopefully help not only this subject, but the future slides to keep moving along.

1:49:16 A lot of these were brought up out of the survey, and we did not make any necessary judgments on any of this. We put them in there. We got to get a sense of it. I just want to say, absolutely, it has to be a balance from the beginning.

1:49:29 We know our number one marching orders is units and housing, providing affordable housing. Everything else is a balance. So we put them on here because the community said, hey, that'd be nice. And some of it has got to be nice. We absolutely understand that. We understand snow removal. We understand the need for parks because...

1:49:46 You know, personally, I understand you need space, but you need parks for community. So when we come back to council with some of this, we're going to digest it all, bring it back and tell you what we've heard. So don't be too concerned that it lists something, because that doesn't mean anything's going to happen. We just put it, we took the survey results and the interviews, put them in here, and that's our job at this stage. We have not made any judgment, and we don't get to. We just make recommendations to the town council, and that's all yours. So hopefully that helps in the next couple of slides, too. It's like, no, we got that.

1:50:16 It's balance. It's all about balance. Thank you. Okay, I'm going to take a little bit different position. I think one to four are super important, but I want to put it in a frame of reference. We're talking about even some of the planning numbers, say 300 units. If they're all two bedrooms, now you have 600 bedrooms. If any of those people double up, you could have 800 or 900 people living on the parcel. This is going to be a community in itself. It's going to need all of these things well thought out.

1:50:46 And even if it's a smaller density, 600 people, you're going to need to think about where do the kids play, where do the pets go, all of these things will have to be integrated. Obviously, it's a compromise, but that's something you need to think about in orders of magnitude that you're going to have to fit these things in, otherwise you're not really going to, I mean, it's going to be a whole other community of Mammoth, and we need to think of it that way. So you're saying one through four is an absolute must for you? I think they're an absolute must. They need to be incorporated. And then five? And then five, I'm just going to make a comment. It's a super important thing.

1:51:15 But here comes back to the finance. I'm a developer. I can tell you parking is one of the most expensive considerations. So what we have and how we're going to park it is going to depend on the financing and the density that we do. And underground parking right now is running about $65,000 in space. So it's just something, a number to throw out there that people should think about and say, hey, let's have underground parking. It's very expensive. I'll be camping in a parking space in a...

1:51:44 Sandy Hook, his comments were excellent. I would go, with John also, one, two, and five are absolute musts, but some of these sometimes can be incorporated. I was one of the ones that gave some of the comments thinking that a child care facility with its own little playground, you know, in the wetland area, because these are not wetland wetlands, you know, that you're going to sink into, they flood.

1:52:08 You know, a couple times a year. That's a, that's an absolutely a must for you. Yeah. Okay. Absolute must in incorporating these, but parks, I don't think so. You know, I mean, those are musts. Again, consolidate, incorporate, and I would say. Excuse me. I apologize. Community gathering spaces, that's a nice consideration. Pet-friendly design, pets allowed, yes, no dog park. Excuse me.

1:52:35 Could we just keep the audience conversation down so we can hear the commenter? Thank you, Sandy. Do we have any more public? Melinda Hathaway. And number one, I don't want people to hate me, but I'm going to say no-go. I'm just thinking that child care should be handled somewhere else, that this is a housing neighborhood. So that's a no-go. So a no-go on that. Include parks and playgrounds.

1:53:04 I think we should have trails. We should have some of the trees saved. We should have benches where people can walk their dogs on the trails. Kids can play on the trails. People can visit on the benches, but we don't need a park. That would take care of the integrated pet-friendly design. I think community gathering space would be a nice to have, and I could picture maybe something central in the middle where the trails converge and people could, again, just get together and have a little community thing, but nothing expensive.

1:53:31 something small something safe something easy to maintain potentially a snow storage space in the winter.

1:53:39 Parking, I think, is really important. You have to have some parking, but I think it needs to be limited. I think, yeah, that's nice for people to be able to have, you know, people can come visit you or whatever, but they can take public transportation, they can walk, they can park off-site, they can carpool, they can take a shuttle. I think parking is expensive and the land is limited, so let's give everybody, like, one space and maybe in the bigger units, too, but I think that's really plenty. Okay, thank you for your input.

1:54:05 Okay, we will go ahead and move on to the next slide. And, you know, if you look ahead a little bit, you'll see some of the things that are going to be coming up as well that may be in this. Draft development objectives, focus on a sustainable design concept. Anybody want to kick this off from commission or town council? I have a question on that. For number four, limit the amount of impervious paving, such as surface parking areas. Is that saying not pave surface parking areas?

1:54:35 No, it's just saying limit the amount of impervious surfaces including any impervious surface parking areas. Okay. So not eliminate, just cap it. Correct. Correct. Anybody want to go ahead and pick this one off? Absolute must for one through three. Number four is a question mark. Okay. I will go absolute must one through three. Number four.

1:55:07 Strong consideration, or I could even go question mark on that one as well. Okay. Just because of my own lack of knowledge. I don't really understand what that is implying. Oh, okay. I would agree with both of them. Question mark on the last one. Question mark on the last one. I'd like to see that plan. Okay. Same for me. Absolute for the first three and question mark on the fourth. Okay. Kirk? The first three, absolute.

1:55:34 You know, parking is really important. Underground parking, if it's $65,000 of space, I'm not sure how it gets paid for, but it's got to be looked at. Okay. John? These are all strong considerations. Okay, thank you. I agree with John on this, strong considerations. Number three would probably be, however, absolutely a must for me.

1:56:01 Thinking about the town. I will go ahead and open this up for the public thoughts at this point. Feel free to come up here and just kind of rate this as where it falls in on your thoughts for moving forward. Sandy Hogan again. Absolute musts are, well, one, absolute must. Two, strong consideration, depending on.

1:56:30 Obviously economics. Number three is an absolute must and consider using the wetlands as your snow storage. It's quite a bit of land and it can be used in the winter and you can have trails in the summer alongside, whatever. Number four, limit the amount of impervious paving. Limited is a strong word but as much as possible go to Tahoe and see what's being done with all sorts of paving, ways to pave.

1:56:59 Where you also have using permeable tiles, stuff like that. So that one I'd have to say strong consideration. Okay. Thank you, Sandy. One, two, three must have for strong consideration. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else in the public wishing to speak on this one? I'm going to go ahead and take it over to staff. Was there anything that you wanted to add to this? Okay.

1:57:37 Then we will go ahead and move on to draft development objectives. Establish a livable neighborhood that supports the Mammoth Lakes community. Let everybody take a second to read through those. Oh, Jen, you looked ready to go ahead. I have a couple questions, actually. I'm not quite ready yet. What is utilized human scale? So that's in terms of making buildings that aren't overwhelming or daunting from a pedestrian or human perspective. Does that? In terms of height?

1:58:08 Height, mass, bulk. I mean, you can have a lower, extremely long, flat facade that can be completely uninviting and inhospitable. So it's not just limited to height. And then can you clarify number one for me?

1:58:25 Just a little confused by that. Oh, so number one is design the height to provide a transition from higher intensity commercial uses to neighboring residential uses. So looking at the parcel has different uses surrounding the 25 acres and ensuring that the design reflects those intensities of uses. For example,

1:58:45 Higher, taller buildings are allowed adjacent to certain portions of the parcel and shorter buildings on other portions. So keeping that in mind in terms of designing where mass appears. Okay. Thank you. Is the only commercial border on that, on the Main Street side? And Laurel. Okay. Anybody want to dive into this one? Just to clarify that question, so you're talking about the higher intensity commercial uses, you're talking about existing zoning?

1:59:19 Yes. You're talking about these, so factor take, consider the existing zone of the commercial things around into this. Well, and I think it's, yes, we're considering existing, but we're also considering what could be allowed if those properties redevelop too. We know the current state is not static, and we want to consider how it evolves over time and how that could integrate with future development here. Okay. Strong consideration for me on all four. Okay. I'll go strong consideration one and two.

1:59:50 Number three, nice to have. Number four, absolute must. I'll go strong consideration of one and two. Number three, I'll say nice to have because I think the building of the parcel will revitalize the commercial areas in itself. And then number four is absolutely a must. I'm with Jen, exactly. I concur with Jen as well.

2:00:22 I agree. Okay. These are all strong considerations. Strong considerations. Okay. We'll go ahead and put this out to the public now. Thinking about a livable neighborhood that supports the Mammoth Lakes community. My name's Elaine Goodman, and I just have one comment on the wording. Perhaps it seems like this is about design principles. So the whole, everything we're doing here is about supporting the Mammoth Lakes community.

2:00:58 Perhaps you want to tighten the language of this section or about design principles. That's my comment. Thank you. Okay. I just had a clarifying point on number one. Number one is about designing the building so that they reflect a transition from a commercial corridor into a residential community. And my question is, it's not about adding zoning that would allow for commercial development on the parcel.

2:01:35 Question mark. That's correct. It is not about adding commercial zoning to the parcel. Okay, and then my second comment is on number three, which I think echoes a little bit of what someone else said. Creating a catalyst for revitalizing the commercial zones is a big lofty goal for the parcel, and I think the parcel already has a lot of big lofty goals about providing housing. So for me, that's a no-go.

2:02:04 Oh, okay. Okay. Seeing no one moving to go up, we are cooking with gas now. We are to our last slide. Draft development objectives, balancing guiding principles and development objectives with a viable development program. Anybody can take a second to read through this?

2:02:30 And again, just to let you know, once we get through this, we will have some time for some questions and a little bit of talk because we are doing so well on time. So if someone from town council or planning would like to kick this off, feel free. I'll jump in here. I'll say one through four are strong consideration and number five is an absolute must. Okay. Consideration of four or five. Of four and five? All five. Oh, all five. Okay. So I'm with Paul.

2:03:07 Strong consideration. I'll do absolutely a must on one, two, and four, and strong consideration on three and five. Okay, thank you. Strong consideration on one through four, and an absolute must on five. Okay. So I would like to clarify number five, because I think that there are opportunities, as what I've read in the surveys and other things, that we could

2:03:46 Find a way to provide housing on the site without actually starting to do construction. Again, that's a semantic thing. I would encourage the consultants to start breaking that out a little bit because I think that's going to be a nuance that I think needs to be considered. The other thing is I think that I haven't seen this. I've seen it in the surveys but not listed here is consideration of the town and the community's ownership of the dirt and the property as being an absolute must.

2:04:13 When we start getting into considerations about investment and how we're going to fund this thing. That's not presented here. That's something I feel pretty strongly about. Otherwise, I think all the rest of this is a very strong consideration. Can you repeat that again and explain what you mean by the dirt around? That the dirt, right now, the community owns the parcel, right? We own the dirt. And so when we start getting into considerations of financing, I think it's an absolute must that we consider.

2:04:41 The equity value of the town and the community owning the dirt as part of the consideration for the financing of projects and phases on the parcel. Thank you. So we will go ahead and open this up to the public. I have a question on number four. When you're talking about potential investors, what are we talking about there? Because as John just said, the town owns the land.

2:05:12 Who are the investors that are coming? Are you talking about investors like people that are going to come in and potentially be the owners of the houses at some point? Or what do we mean by investors? And I would like to respond to that because this is all about making this happen in money. That's what this whole thing is about. And you may have a development team, as the developers in the room will tell you, is made up of a lot of different people. There are the designers, the contractors, the construction people, the planning folks, and then there's just the money people.

2:05:40 No offense to just the money people. They're very important. And they may be just investors. They may see this as an opportunity. And even in affordable housing, believe it or not, if there's enough subsidies, state, federal, other funds and programs, there are going to be opportunities for investment. And we'd like to make sure that we keep that all open. So that's what that means. We didn't want to limit the playing field by any means. It's all open. We'll talk about that later in the year about how that happens. My comment was recorded, right?

2:06:09 Yes, absolutely, that's spot on, absolutely. Okay, thank you. Public comment on this? I have a question on number three, consider regulatory actions that would be necessary to implement the development program. I'm just not sure if this is...

2:06:32 A little early to have this as one of the development objectives. And it's also very vague because there's a number of different regulatory actions that the town could take. And if we just leave it as a broad sweeping statement without knowing what those are, it seems a little preemptive to me. That could include regulatory actions to allow nightly rentals there because it makes a development pencil. Is that something we want to be considering because this is so vague?

2:07:00 That's just one example, I guess I can think of. You know what, actually, could you speak to the...

2:07:05 I'd like to respond to that. First of all, there's nobody that works at the town who's going to suggest a nightly rental in there. That's not going to happen, right? Well, we can say that. I think we can say that when we have a broad sweeping development objective, I think that needs to be clarified. No, here's my point. It's intentionally vague because the point was earlier I talked about the fact that we want to try to design a product and a program that works for the long term. And if that takes minor tweaks to zoning, we just want this group to understand we're going to bring that back. We'd like to. And this is just stating...

2:07:34 Yeah, you should consider that, because if setbacks are an issue for a development, you should bring that back. If you want to go to 37 feet height when you're allowed 35, you should bring that back. It's certainly not intended, I appreciate the question, but not intended to suggest something like that, but it just means, just recognize that we will come back, as we stated earlier, and we'll assess what it takes to get it done, and we understand. And I wasn't alluding to the fact that it meant

2:07:59 Any particular regulatory change. I'm just saying that it's very broad and very vague and that maybe it's very preemptive at this point to include that as a development objective. It's not appropriate. Okay. Thank you very much. Developer, I mean, Drew. I just want to comment on John's comment and I don't necessarily have one way or another town own the dirt, not own the dirt.

2:08:29 But I want to point out that our goal is to create a community. And we're going to try and put as much as works on the site, depending on what the community says works on that site. When you get to the financing, you're going to have money people. And there's a lot of different ways to finance this. We could finance this thing by designing a workforce housing and have no government-sponsored bonds or anything. It could be all done in private financing. The caveat to that would be

2:08:57 That you would have to allow private lenders to have a surety interest. What does that mean? They got to be able to put a mortgage on the dirt. And being able to do that allows you to do it. So whether the town owns it, you know, you have to figure out some of those models and you have to look at what's the best financing option. So the other thing it brings up, if the town owns the dirt, that means the town's a developer and is the town the most efficient way to get stuff built.

2:09:22 You can do what is called CCNR, Covenants, Conditions, and Restriction on a Piece of Land and take my word for it. That could be stronger than a deed, that is a deed restriction. That means you can control your rentals, the density, who can live there, they have to be workforce. I mean, over at the Starbucks, there was a CCNR in there that said, McDonald's says, no fast food restaurant could ever go in there.

2:09:45 And that's why it's a Starbucks, because the guy couldn't rent El Pollo Loco, or I'm sure they had many offers for other fast food companies to come in. Same example down in Bishop where the Safeway is. There's a CCNR that says no competitors of Vons can ever go there. Take my word for it, it's been sitting empty for, what, 15, 20 years? Those CCNRs are very strong. So you don't necessarily have to own the dirt to control the dirt. CCNRs can be a very strong tool to use to control whatever you decide or do.

2:10:14 The community decides they want to see there. So I just want to point that out. Okay. Thank you for that. That's a very good point. Anybody else from the public wishing to speak on this, if or rate? Okay. Seeing none, I'm going to go ahead and turn this back over.

2:10:31 There is a slide. What did we miss? I'm going to open it. John, I'm going to start with you, if you don't mind. Is there anything that you feel? Understanding that this is very preliminary, it's been a great discussion. Thank you for all your input and your ratings. It's very helpful, I know, for me to see where people in person are coming from as tied in with the surveys that we're doing. So I appreciate your time today.

2:11:01 Is there going to be any more comment or opportunity for the public to engage in our conversation today? Absolutely. So I'm going to save whatever may have been missed until we've heard all the public comment. If there isn't time, I'll just find a way to get my reflections and stuff. Okay. Thank you. Kirk, do you have anything that you would like to bring up at this point?

2:11:19 You know, I just, well, yes, I do. Again, it's getting concrete numbers down there. It's getting, you know, design down there. It's getting those kinds of things and the finances. I mean, not only what are we going to do and how are we going to pay for this, that it's...

2:11:34 That is the most important thing that needs to be brought forward as soon as possible. Otherwise, I mean, we talk about these concepts and a lot of good ideas, and also we're talking about a dog park and everything else, and I mean, we need to get something concrete up there that people can actually see, and as well as the funding tool at how it's going to work. Okay. Well, it could just be general thoughts if you'd like at this point.

2:12:09 One thing I found interesting on the online survey versus the 2017 report was there was sort of a disparity of housing types that was recommended versus what people said online. And so maybe we can take a look at that and see. The report says studio, one-bedroom, maybe perhaps two-bedroom. However, you have an overwhelming majority of the folks online.

2:12:38 Since they want three or four plus, which I'm not quite sure if that is the type of housing that we should be advocating for. Oh, okay. Did you want to answer that? Well, I'm not looking for an answer. Well, I'm kind of interested with that, that the disparity, that's just all kind of wrapped up into...

2:13:07 Yeah, I think we'll obviously be looking at that closely, especially when we look at the market analysis in terms of understanding what we're seeing in terms of demand.

2:13:19 And what could actually be offered in an affordable price point and seeing where that fits in. I mean, it's important to note, too, I mean, when we talk about number of units, obviously you can get a lot more studios in one bedrooms than you can get two bedrooms and three bedrooms. So in terms of looking at the program, we'll be evaluating all of that. And I'm sure the three concepts we work with the community on is going to have varied makeups of what that unit program will be.

2:13:47 And the second statement I would make about is we don't, I understand that to be progressive about the development side, you know, we have to take efficiency into consideration. That's extremely important in my opinion. You know, the recent development conference that took place in San Francisco back in May, they talked about a significant trend of smart homes.

2:14:16 And I don't think we talk too much about that at this moment. You know, I think that that's something that we need to think about. And, you know, the term that they use is called IoT, Internet of Things. And I think that's something that we really have to make sure that we can, whatever we build, we need to take that into consideration. We need to be able to support the neighborhood and that allow them to be able to live up, you know, progressively. Thank you.

2:14:45 Michael, what do you have for us? I would just like to hear a little bit more about what the restrictions are with the wetlands, the four acres of wetlands. Can we do anything there? Can there be like a walkway, pathway, bike path? Let me describe it this way. When we get to the four-day workshop, we're going to present a series of alternatives and possibilities for the public to comment on and give suggestions as to what

2:15:14 May or may not happen there. It very frankly ranges from, gee, it's a meadow, I wouldn't call it all a wetlands, it's a meadow that might be six acres right now. It's a technical Army Corps of Engineers wetlands of 0.7 acres, roughly? It's less than an acre of jurisdictional wetlands. So the range of what you can do is vast.

2:15:37 The important part for our team as we bring something forward to the public is that it needs to be incorporated into the project, integrated into the project in some fashion. There may be parts of it that are rebuilt because they don't have what, even in Army Corps of Engineers standpoint, they're less value, they're not high value. My own comment, and this is...

2:15:57 My comment as the leader of the team is to say, look, guys, this needs to be something that's part of the community. It's not going to be a drainage ditch. It's not going to be an LA river. It's not going to be a concrete channel. It has to be accessible to everybody during the summer. There may be bridges over, as an example, places for kids to get down and put their feet in the water. It has to be incorporated. It's not four acres.

2:16:18 The meadow is very large. That's correct. The big open area you can look at. The wetlands is 0.6. So that's why I said it's somewhere in between there. But more important than those numbers is that it has to be a part of the community. It has to live and breathe with the community. It can't just be something in somebody's backyard that they're worried about flooding. Okay, that's not going to work for me, I tell you that, because that's a lot of it in town. In Sierra Valley sites, frankly, there's this drainage easement, and it's just a pain.

2:16:47 Okay? We want this to be part of the community and work for the community, however big it is. What you can do...

2:16:54 Very frankly, we could do just about anything within the regulations. It's not set aside for the next 500 years exactly like it is. But we are very sensitive to it, knowing that there's a lot of interest. The surveys show there's a huge amount of interest in that, and we will absolutely respect that in any recommendation we make. But again, the guiding thing for us is make it a part of the community. Make it something that works so everybody can enjoy it, not just be that drainage ditch on the side of my house. So that's a long answer.

2:17:21 But, you know, if you talk to the engineer, we can do just about anything because there are rules about it. We take care of it. Just like zoning, well, sure, whatever. The guiding thing that I want to mention is it needs to be worked into the community and be a living part of it. So hopefully that answers your question. It's long, but it's really important to me and to the team and to the community that it work. It has to work. Thank you. Thank you. Good question. So this is going to be...

2:17:49 A high-density area in which a lot of people are living, there's going to be noise because there's a lot of people living there, of course. People live in Mammoth because they love the outdoors and the natural beauty that we have to offer. I would like, in my mind, to see this project where we provide that high density, but we also utilize our wetlands to beautify and have it as part of

2:18:17 That community. Because it is going to be a community within itself. And we need to ensure that we use all the space that we have strategically to ensure that we're not giving up our mountain theme, our views, and our life that we all live and breathe for in Mammoth. So I'd like to make sure that we do keep that natural aspect into our design and ensure that there's still outdoor space.

2:18:47 And we can really appreciate our beauty here. Thank you. I think the biggest thing that comes up for me in the question of what's missing is not so much what's missing from, you know, the topics we talked about, but whose voices are in this and how we can get their voices in it. I think that we're, everyone in this room is privileged enough to be here and to take the time to be here. And I think that matters a whole lot, but...

2:19:16 Just recognizing continually that there are people who can't be here and how do we give weight to those comments and their insight that's equal to the people who are able to come and speak and be at the table and everything. And along those lines, I want to say too that as much as possible, I want us to try to keep this process.

2:19:35 With language that's approachable and understandable. I think there's some things in here, yes, it's legislation and regulatory and it's going to have some of these words and complex phrases, but some of this is hard for me to digest and I'm a college educated, you know, working woman, so I think the more that we can keep this so that everyone feels like they can play and, you know, be a part of this process, it's not just we're not reaching certain communities, it might be that we're, there are some barriers in terms of

2:20:04 Not even just English, Spanish, but the language that we're using to reach, you know, the young workforce here, the older workforce here, all the different pieces of that. So that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. I'll go ahead and we have about 10 minutes of questions that we can take from the public.

2:20:30 Again, just reminding everybody, this is just a kicking off point. None of these things are like, we're doing this. This is the direction we're going in. This is the time for people to speak up. And if there's something that did not get addressed, which is one of your concerns, I would love to hear it. So feel free.

2:20:48 Madam Mayor, just 30 seconds for me to wrap up and we can do that. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. So just real quick, I want to make sure that I do have some comments to make if there is time after the public has spoken. I want to make sure that that's why I did that little time limit for you, Mr. John. Thank you.

2:21:05 So just very quickly, our next output from this workshop is just a workshop summary memo. So we'll prepare a memo that'll document what we heard, as well as revised guiding principles and development objectives based on this feedback today. So we'll get that out to you likely mid-July. You should have that, at least in English. Spanish version will probably be a little later. Okay, and that will be an accumulation of everything that we've heard today, and it will be emailed or available online. How will people respond?

2:21:34 I think ideally it will be in your Town Council update packet on July 17th, I believe, and of course distributed to the interested parties we have. We've got a gigantic email list that we're running with.

2:21:49 And so the next after that, we'll be working on some rough preliminary concepts. So we actually will start looking at what's existing in terms of street pattern and existing surrounding uses and things like that that help us to start framing.

2:22:04 Moving forward to design. So that will all be available on Engage Mammoth Lakes for feedback. And then there are upcoming opportunities to talk about the parcel. We just mentioned the July 17th town council update here. Mammoth Lakes Housing has an update on Monday. And we've got information tables that are popping up at various events around town. So we've got a lot happening and opportunities to talk about the parcel and others that haven't quite yet been confirmed.

2:22:35 And then lastly, so to stay informed, we do have...

2:22:41 The website, we have social media, signing up for engaged Mammoth Lakes. If you're not already, please sign up because that's going to be a great method to be able to provide feedback. That's what the online survey was through. So if you did that, you are successfully registered. And again, information will come out hopefully next week with that flyer about what's happening on the 20th through the 23rd of August. So you can look and plan accordingly. And again, even if you just have 15 minutes, we want to see you, we want to hear from you. So that's it for me.

2:23:10 Thank you. Okay. No, thank you. Thank you very much for today. I feel like we had a good conversation. I'm going to open this up now to the public. Do have in mind that we will be responding to some of the items brought up, so if you could keep it under three minutes, if you disagree or are curious about the subject matter, just...

2:23:32 Say that you concur with someone else. And we will go ahead and open it for public thoughts. Anything that we missed? Anything that you'd like to see addressed? Raves about how much fun you've had today? And you're going to go out and tell everybody to get involved? That's totally appreciated, too. Giselle Kenny again. I really wanted to reiterate what Jessica Kennedy said. I just hope that everyone is considering that.

2:23:56 I'm on the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, I'm college educated, and there were things on this that I didn't know what it was saying, so please making it digestible. Second, I have a question for the info tables. Is there going to be a Spanish speaker at those tables? We've been coordinating to achieve that, so I believe so. Okay, perfect. And that's all that I can think of. Thank you. Thank you. Just really, really quickly, it's like nobody's really talked about saving any of the trees, and that's something that's really important to me. It is a beautiful space.

2:24:33 And I hope that when the design concepts go in and when we have these community meetings that people that maybe haven't seen the parcel understand that it's not a clean slate. It's not a pile of dirt. It's a beautiful forest. Thank you. John Armstrong. I think it would help us to understand some of these ideas if we knew what the AMI was. And also, what does it mean for those who live and work in Mammoth? Is that housing available for rent, perhaps?

2:25:11 For somebody who lives in Mammoth and works online for a company in Los Angeles. So if the community could understand these concepts, it might help people become more engaged. And is the AMI, is that average monthly income? I don't know. How is that calculated? Is it the state, the county? In that case, it's irrelevant. This is Mammoth.

2:25:39 They calculate it for every county. It's advanced in the state. So those things need to be spelled out and understood. And I think that would trigger greater engagement by the community. I do echo the point about preserve some of the trees. And also, I think what we've missed is that if parking is limited, then is there a possibility on perhaps town-owned land to be able to store another vehicle elsewhere, perhaps at the airport?

2:26:08 Or is there an ability for storage? Because if these units become quite small, is there the ability to store stuff elsewhere? Thank you. For stuff. Okay. Thank you. Hi again. I think kind of dovetailing off of that is a little bit of what we missed.

2:26:32 Maybe some assumptions, if we could have gone over some assumptions in the beginning, like yes, we will incorporate and use data from the 2017 needs assessment, and yes, we know the housing action plan and what it calls for will be incorporated here, or the AMIs or this, like some assumptions. I think that's been done, but maybe it's a good way to start these community conversations and it helps educate the public so that we're speaking the same language.

2:27:03 Also, you know, renters are the hardest demographic to reach. They're much harder to reach than homeowners. Homeowners have an investment. They're, you know, they're in the same address. It's going to take a lot of effort to reach renters. And you're going to have to go to them, I think.

2:27:24 Maybe start working with the chamber and going to places of employment and bringing laptops and having them do surveys there. I've mentioned before, raffling off a black pass or something to incentivize participation specifically from that demographic, which I don't think we're hearing from. This is an observation and I'm not trying to put anybody down, but as I was sitting here and people are getting up this answer.

2:27:53 Prioritize things. It felt like a survey to me that we were doing orally, and I didn't know if this was the best use of our time. Couldn't we have done that in a better way? And what do you really, you the group that we're paying almost half a million for, I think, $400,000 is the contract? I'm not sure. But a lot of money.

2:28:11 Is that really what you need from us is to sit here and say, yes, this is a priority orally in front of everyone, or is there something else we could get to you? I know we're at the preliminary stages. It's just an observation. And then I would just ask that the results from the survey today be published in another form other than just the town council packet. Thanks. Okay. Thank you.

2:28:46 I just wanted to kind of close out. One, I'm really happy. A lot of work's been done here, and I want to appreciate the work that's been done here. And there's a lot of smart people in the room, and I think it's great that they're all being brought together to make their comments. And as a community, we should be happy that you guys are paying this kind of attention to it. That's an important thing. I just want to close on Jennifer's point. It's going to take a lot more work to get this in. But one of the things that, you know, if I just back up on the fundamental question of

2:29:15 How much of our problem are we going to try and solve here? Because a lot of these questions are knock-ons to that. If you answer, we're going to solve 60% of our problem, 50% of our problem. If our problem is 700 units in 2023 or whatever the number is, smarter people than me can come up with it. What percentage are we trying to solve there? It's probably not 100% and it's probably not 20%. So once you figure out what that percentage is,

2:29:43 I mean, I'm, as a developer, when I have a scope of work that I have to work backwards from, it's pretty straightforward to go, okay, well, there's ways you can accomplish that many units, this many housing, these many amenities, how you can fit it. There's different price points that you can deliver that at, which points to different construction methods. So it becomes a very straightforward kind of process after you've made that big picture decision. So, you know, we spend a lot of time about amenities and stuff like that. I think they're all important.

2:30:11 But I think fundamentally as a community we have to decide this is kind of everyone says this is the great shot to do it. This is our one piece. I don't know of any other big parcels that we could do this on. So as a community and as a group we have to decide what percentage of our problem and many people have defined that are we going to try and solve here because once we solve that solving for the unit mix and the amenities and the construction type that will come into play because if you're trying to solve

2:30:39 A number of the percentage of our demand on this site, then the rest of it becomes a very straightforward planning process, and we have very smart people who could give a solution. So that's kind of my overall question that I want to pose. Okay, thank you. Okay, if no one from the public wishing to speak up at this point, I'm going to go ahead and turn it over. Do you mind if I could just go ahead and turn it to John? I would take any other closing comments, John, and anybody else in the...

2:31:09 Okay, but I know you wanted to address it and my clock's running down here. Yes, please. Closing comments? I just want to make one comment and then you're done with staff and consultants and it's all yours. We really appreciate having a full house. We had no idea we were taking guesses we could get 50 people or 10 people today. We had no idea. We've heard many comments about Sweet Z is intimidating. Hopefully nobody that was here felt that way today because I didn't think it was. It was kind of...

2:31:39 Quick, because we spent three hours on this, and we just touched the service. We just started. So I really want to appreciate everybody who did that. I also want to comment on some things we'd heard earlier about the survey versus the interviews versus the walk. We're taking all of them into account. The CHAP, the needs assessment, and it's just a different way of doing it. There are some people who will come here and talk who, I mean, maybe everybody here filled out the online survey. Maybe they didn't.

2:32:05 I don't know that. But everybody has a different way of communicating, and we appreciate all of them. So it was very valuable to have the survey, the parcel walk, the interviews, and this session today to the consultant team and to the town staff. So we appreciate it. And everybody, like I said, everybody has a different way of doing business. We got a little bit of everything. So thank you very much for everybody's attention and the clear and concise comments I thought we got. Fair?

2:32:31 Thanks. Okay. And on that note, I did think today was productive because I have not taken. I went to the site. I got a little bit sidetracked on some of the questions, and then I still, to this day, I did not participate in that. I found this exceedingly helpful for me to get information that is not, you as community members, not just a little color on a pie chart. So thank you for your time. I'm going to go ahead and kick it over to John and your responses to some of the things you heard.

2:33:00 A couple observations. I very much appreciate that this venue is a venue where decisions will get made at the end of this process. But I'm also very conscious of the fact that this is not the venue where the community lives. The community is not in this room. The community comes here because a decision is going to get made that's going to affect their lives, so they're going to show up here. This is not where the community is. And frankly, I'm a little disappointed. I'm concerned about our process here.

2:33:30 I'm concerned. A couple things. One is to have the survey, which we're going to be basing some decisions on, to have the electeds not see that in advance, let alone not have the community see that in advance, is a problem. And I don't know what the excuse is for that, but that is not something that's acceptable going forward. I'm sitting here as an elected official. I want to hear from the community.

2:33:54 Difficult for me to be trying to read something, digest it, make sense of it, while at the same time trying to get some feedback out of the public. That's just not a good way to be doing things. Another thing is some of us went through the community housing action planning process, which is a really good process. I mean, there was a core group of 25, 30 people involved over about a year.

2:34:17 And what was incredibly valuable in that process was to have the community and folks who wanted to show up to talk with each other, to take some of these ideas and beat these things up and figure, well, what do you think about this? I don't know what this is. They could answer a question. But then something comes out of that that's informative and useful. And frankly, I don't think it's going to be useful to be continuing this process in such a way where we have, frankly, consultants are from the dais saying, please, we don't want to hear your conversations.

2:34:45 Now, I understand when we're going into a decision-making process, that's appropriate, but I'm not seeing opportunities as part of this process where we're going to all get together as a community and these folks are going to share what they think, they're not going to be intimidated because they don't know what an AMI is, and we're going to actually really get the pulse and the heart and the soul of this community that owns this property reflected in the decisions that we need to make. And frankly, I'm concerned that I'm not seeing how we get from here to there.

2:35:15 I would also, to Jennifer Halford's point about, you know, is it really the best use of our time to do kind of an analog version of a survey? The Mountain Venture Summit, which I think some of the staff was able to attend, in Truckee, they do these things where they can ask survey questions of thousands of people in 15 minutes. We could have set something up in this room or do this online using technology to get that kind of information here.

2:35:39 Quickly, immediately, not sitting for three hours doing something, a 20th century version of something, to Paul's point about the Internet of Things, we could be doing this instantly. And we could be doing it iteratively. It could be happening again and again and again. So I'm concerned about that.

2:35:57 So I would like to know how, I mean, Supervisor Corliss is not here, and we've been doing something called community conversations the last couple of years because we know that these venues are not the venues you're going to get the information that you need to make decisions from policy bases. I'm hoping maybe with Jessica, you know, I've talked a little bit about trying to put together a couple of community-based things. We would like to know who do we talk to in the consultant team so that we're not, if we get information coming out of that, it could help inform what's going to happen out of this.

2:36:25 But I'm feeling a little bit of a sandbagging situation where we're going to be ending up in situations at charrettes and things like this where we're going to be asked to make decisions and we don't know what the community thinks. We don't know. We haven't given the community a chance to truly engage and express as idiosyncratic or as crazy as whatever it might be. We don't have that information. And so I would encourage you. This is good work so far. But I think...

2:36:49 We're on the cusp here of getting into a situation. We're going to be put into a corner to make decisions about things. And we're going to be sitting here saying, I don't know. You know, I don't, we've squandered an opportunity. So those are my thoughts. Okay, thank you. So I'll take one, if somebody would like to express something at this point. If not, if everybody's good. I want to say a quick comment. I agree with John's points of we need to.

2:37:18 Get out there more and get this process truly community oriented. And I also want to say, based on my earlier comments about, you know, those of us in this room, it is huge that you all are here in this room, that you took three hours to do this. Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you for being here. And I don't mean to discount that at all in terms of let's take these other comments for as much. I mean, you gave up part of your day and that is huge. So thank you all for being here and keep spreading the word. I appreciate it.

2:37:43 Okay, and continuing with the polling here, I would like to see in the audience who here lives in town and has a house in Mammoth Lakes or the surrounding areas, a house. Okay, who is currently renting? Okay, who will most likely be living in this property down the road? Okay, so that's, I wanted to get that so I can, I can see what people's intentions are.

2:38:13 With that, I appreciate that because I will be one person that will keep an eye on this because and John, I appreciate your comments. However, we could sit here for the next five years and talk to every single person in this town and it is not going to help with the decision. I know we probably differ on that, but there's only so much you can do with reaching out to the public. At some point, the public has got to ask the questions, spend the time.

2:38:41 If I was not on Town Council, I would be the person at home, probably not even watching this, but that I would be putting my trust in the people who were sitting here making decisions, and I would be choosing not to get involved, realizing I may be giving up some of my individual power with making that. So while I appreciate that and I understand what you're saying, I think that's a little bit...

2:39:07 Too big of an idea. So anybody else? And then we're going to wrap this up. I'd like to bounce off that with the John comment too of, you know, it's not, yes, everyone has a role to play, but we are the elected officials and we have, I mean, I'm appointed, but you know, whatever it is, we have a role to spread the word and a role to engage our communities that we represent. So I'm, I mean, I'm equally at fault for, you know, it's, I'm not trying to place blame on anybody else. I'd have to spread this to who I know as well. So. Good. Thank you.

2:39:36 Glad you're going to be doing that. Okay. My only comment would be to staff. Keep the process moving. Keep this project rolling. Let's not get too caught up paralysis through analysis. Get this sucker going. Okay. Thank you to everyone. We are now adjourned. We have the regular town council meeting starting at 6 o'clock. We've got some 20-year awards to give out. It's going to be fun. It's a must-see TV moment.

2:40:34 Okay, folks, let's settle in. We have an exciting agenda ahead of us today. Can you tell there was a class in being positive? Okay, let's see. Do we have a 20 on Dan? I'll start without him. Let's get to it.

2:41:20 We're going to be tipping over here. Someone forget to shower on the right side. Okay. I will now call this meeting to order. Town Council meeting Wednesday, June 26th. I apologize for this. Oh, roll call first. Councilmember Salcido. Councilmember Stapp. Here. Councilmember Orr. Here. Here. Linda Salcido is out of town. Just FYI.

2:41:53 I did not get someone to commit to the Pledge of Allegiance. Stacey, do you mind if I impose on you for leading us in the pledge? Okay, thank you. Thank you. We are now in the public comment section of our meeting. If you could please keep your comments to five minutes. And if you could introduce yourself when you come up, please. Thank you.

2:42:40 Mayor and Council, my name is Ken Bringle. I'm Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I did want to take the opportunity to introduce our new Workforce Housing Coordinator, Curtis Shapiro. He started with us June 1, and John heard some of his actions already, what we're working on, and I thought maybe he could give you a little update real quick. Good to meet all you guys. Yeah, so right now we're currently working on developing a website.

2:43:11 Which we will have employees enter all their information to which we can vet them and ensure that they're employed and work here full-time and live here year-round. And we can match them with potential landlords who want to convert their short-term rentals into long-term rentals. So hopefully find more housing for the workforce around here. Okay, I'm sorry, I didn't catch your name. Curtis Shapiro. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Ken.

2:43:39 Still open for public comment. Anything that is not on tonight's agenda? Public comment? Hello, I'm Bobby Tanner, owner and operator of Reds Meadow Resort and Pack Station. The topic that I wanted to bring up to you guys, I want to talk about the, as you know, in 2022 and 2023, the road to Reds Meadow is slated to have a major reconstruction. And once that is finished, then...

2:44:11 The town of Mammoth will assume jurisdictional authority of the road. We'll assume it'll be basically the town road. I guess before I get into that, I would assume probably want an update on what's going on in Reds right now as far as being open, or I'll give you a quick update. Well, it's not good, obviously. The road's not open. All the work has been done in the valley. The road is just as worn out as it was last fall. No change, so it's all...

2:44:42 It's all good to go. The only thing that I'm aware of that's left, the Forest Service wants to sweep it before it's open to the public. But all the work's done. I was down there today. There was no work going on in there. So it's open. We had a meeting yesterday. The Forest Service, after the meeting, kind of threw me a lifeline and said I can go ahead and have full operations now with escorting our people in there so we can...

2:45:08 Advertise horseback rides, advertise pack trips, our cabins. We had our first horseback ride this afternoon. We had previously had some cabin guests starting about a week and a half ago, so we've sort of been open for about a week and a half now. But it's not a good situation for me, for the business, to not be open at this time of year. You know, there's a saying in business that

2:45:37 A business needs to evolve or they will die. Where Red's Meadow needs to evolve is to be open during the tourist season. Tourist season now is June 10th to August 20th. And we're coming up pretty close to already missing one-third of that period. So it's a rough situation for the business.

2:46:02 And it's also, I think it's a rough situation for the general public not being able to enjoy that valley. Rainbow Falls at this time of year is rather spectacular when it's running full bore. It's really spectacular. And so it's disappointing that it's not open. The reason it's not open is it's turned into kind of a bureaucratic debacle this year. There's no reason it could not have been open.

2:46:34 Where should I go with this? There was a series of things that kind of happened that slowed down the opening of the road. And as you know, the town of Mammoth is involved in that process. And there's plenty of blame to go around. It's not completely the town's fault that it's not open, but the town really fumbled on this one. Seriously dropped the ball.

2:47:03 And then set the process back a week to 10 days with some mistakes that they made. And I hope that in the future we can sit down and talk about those mistakes and see if we can work them out so they don't happen again. One interesting thing that came out of that, out of these mistakes that happened is, as I said, in 2023, the town of Mammoth is slated to take over that road completely.

2:47:33 One issue that came up was that the town staff was busy with other projects at the time when the road needed to be plowed, whether it was the lake space and other projects in town. And my concern is that does the town really understand what they're getting into, the amount of work that they will assume by owning that road, and will it put the lake space and...

2:48:01 The needs of the town and Reds Meadow all in conflict with one another for equipment time and man hours and all that kind of stuff. And I don't know if the town really understands all the work that goes into it to opening the road. Snow plowing is just one part of it. And then there's cleaning the ditches. There's falling the trees. The list just goes on and on and on. And a lot of people have done a lot of hard work down there. But, you know, we're still not open.

2:48:31 For various reasons. And so I hope that at some point the town will take some time to really look at those issues before they get into this, to have a full understanding of what, because it's, it's, I don't want to put the lakes basin, I don't want to put Red's Meadow, I don't want to put the town of Mammoth in a bad situation, everybody's competing with one another for man hours and equipment time and that kind of stuff. Okay, have you heard when ESTA buses are going to start running?

2:49:01 Down there? They are also waiting for the road to open. Okay. They want to do some training with their drivers, but they're kind of chomping at the bit. Okay. Yeah, they would like to go. Okay. They would like to go. I talked to Esther this afternoon, and they're scheduled to get their drivers training in the next couple days. Their understanding is maybe next week sometime it'll open, hopefully. You know, no one still really knows. But they want to do some training, but they want to go because they're

2:49:31 They generate a fair amount of money off of the Reds Meadow Run, so they're ready, is the short answer on that one. Okay. Well, thank you very much for your time. This is something that, oh, I was looking at you. Is this something that it's going to be on the agenda of not necessarily the town, but any other meeting that this is something that people who are interested in this subject could get a little more information?

2:49:58 We'll provide an update under the department head of reports for you. Oh, okay. So there you go. We will be getting an update from Public Works on that matter if you want to stick around for a few. As far as the matter of opening the road? Yes. I'm kind of talking about two topics here. One topic is I'm just going to give you an update on what's going on now, but also there are some things that are happening now that are kind of an eye-opener about what's going to happen with the big project.

2:50:25 And so I'd like to talk about the big project for just a minute here also. Okay. You know what? Unfortunately, Bobby, this is public comment, and so we as town council people aren't even allowed to remark or have any kind of conversation. I understand that. So I appreciate that. If you'd like to take a seat, I could hear from some other public comment. Perhaps if we have some time, you could get up and just maybe quickly address in three minutes something that you just really want us to take away from today's meeting. Okay. Okay. There's one issue on the...

2:50:54 The major project that I wanted to bring up. Do you want me to? You know what? Here, just take a seat. We'll get some other people funneled through in case they're just here for a few, and then I'll just have you. You can come up at the end of the public comment. I wasn't trying to debate or anything else. I was trying to update you on the road. Okay. Yeah, no, I appreciate that. One issue I'd like to update you on. Oh, okay. Thank you. We're still open for public comment for anything not on tonight's agenda. Okay. Seeing none, I guess, Bobby, get back up. I'm going to give you three more minutes to address that. Okay. Exercise for the day.

2:51:27 Okay, one more issue. The Town of Mammoth and Federal Highways circulated the NEPA, went through the NEPA process. They circulated four alternatives for the design of the road, for the major project. I was at all the public comment meetings. I heard all the comments. I read most of them. I looked at it. The Devil's Postpile looked at it. And it was pretty much, not complete, but pretty much a unanimous, pretty much aligned, everybody.

2:51:57 They agreed on what the right direction was to go without road, except for the town of Mammoth. The devil's post file, they brought in the Department of Interior Engineers. They looked at the design, they looked at the road, they looked at what the project should be. They also agreed with what kind of all of us agreed on. They offered up $7 million towards the project, which would be half the cost. And the town staff said, no thanks, we don't want your $7 million.

2:52:23 Town staff wants to go find $25 million to do a completely different project that is a disaster. So thank you. Oh, okay. You know what? Thank you for that. I've been following that and that you bring up interesting points as part of a bigger story. So thank you for that. So nobody jumping for public comment. We will go ahead and...

2:52:47 Just to let people know in the packet there is a letter of correspondence to the California Public Utilities Commission from May 29th. That is in the packet. It was regarding the 9-1-1 and service outages in Mono County. We will now move to Councilmember Reports. And Dan, do we have any additions to the agenda or do we have anything that is not going to be on tonight's agenda? Yeah, Madam Mayor, one is we'll just do it, of course, toward the end of the closed sessions.

2:53:18 Reorganize some of the, just the order to accommodate some staff time there. Okay. And then, sorry, I'll find the item. A recommendation to continue item 25, the MLTPA agreement. Okay, that's continued. And the TOT appeal, we will also remove it from the agenda. Okay, that's item 22? Yes, item 22. Okay, thank you for that.

2:53:55 Now, Kirk, if you don't mind, I will just go ahead and hit you up for the council member report. Did you say that the 22 is going to also be continued? No, that's... Yes, it'll be removed from the agenda at this point. Oh, yes. I mean, is it... Not continued. Not continued. It may come back in the future, but it's gone. It's been resolved? That is correct. They attended tonight, and they went ahead and paid the fines, and they're withdrawing their appeal.

2:54:25 Oh, okay. Thank you. Okay. I have nothing to report. Okay. Thank you. Bill. Linda's not here to give her, so I wrote a novel. Sorry. We hosted the Desert Mountain Division of the League of California Cities here in Mammoth. The date had to be moved around so much it was not as well attended as normal, but it was still a good meeting.

2:54:53 Joel from Trails made a presentation that was spectacular and had everybody asking him questions like, will you come to work for me? We said no. Attended the MLR meeting on the 11th where we dealt with approving some budgetary items and things. We served as the alternate for the ESCOG meeting and pretty much got an education on where things are going there but anything else to come out of that I'm sure John will tell us about.

2:55:24 I attended the League of California Cities Mayor and Council Forum in Newport and once again found it incredibly helpful. I would love to see at the next one, especially this particular one, more of the council go because there was, especially the workshop on Friday was illuminating, if nothing else. And I got to talk to people from...

2:55:51 You know, anywhere from the Fair Political Practices Commission to other mayors and council members and town managers, so it's always a really good thing. Attended the estimating and again went over all sorts of things, but nothing really of import to report back. And that's about it for me. Okay. Short novel there. Okay. I try. John? Yeah, so I'll try to keep it short, but you know how it goes. MLH,

2:56:22 Part of the new strategic plan with MLH, the board has appointed a variety of different committees, which is starting to do some good work, and I'm part of the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Subcommittee and the Outreach and Communication Subcommittee. We had very good meetings on that, started doing some work to get MLH more out into the community. The LTC, Monroe County LTC meeting, we had a very interesting discussion around, it started out as a discussion around unmet transit needs.

2:56:49 And evolved into more of a conversation of general transportation needs throughout the county, throughout the region. And there's some things that may come back to the ESTA folks about making that differentiation between unmet needs versus transit needs and buses and getting people from Bishop at an airport and the Grail and all kinds of stuff. So it's an interesting conversation around that. And the town staff, I think for the next LTC's meeting is going to talk about general transportation needs and where those kinds of needs need to go to be addressed.

2:57:18 Attended the community conversation on fire that Supervisor Corliss and Bob Gardner and myself put together. Another very interesting conversation about fire. I don't know if you made that one or not, but it was pretty. Malcolm North is there, a bunch of other folks. Very interesting meeting. The ESCOG meeting, some interesting thing happened there with around the Joint Powers Authority. So the board of the ESCOG has agreed upon and finalized a proposal for Joint Powers Authority for the four jurisdictions.

2:57:45 And now the four members of the ESCOG will go to each jurisdiction individually and talk about what's in that, what kinds of things can happen next. An interesting update from the Bishop folks about their airport efforts. The representation being made is October 2020 is still the plan for commercial service. That's their plan. They've got a lot of work to do before they get there, but that's what they're representing.

2:58:08 Attended two meetings of the new proposed Monroe County CAO candidates on Sunday, Monday night. That was interesting. We've got an interest in that, obviously. And then I attended with, Ken mentioned, the new Chambers Workforce Housing Meeting. That's going to be a very exciting effort. It's part of the Community Housing Action Plan. It's yet another tool we can use to address our housing needs. That was very interesting, a lot of fun. And now I'm here. Thank you very much.

2:58:38 Thank you, busy man. I also attended the High Desert Mountain League meeting, and even though the calendar did shift, it was still nice to see some of our regional mayors and council people, but the California League of Cities conference was fantastic. I do get a little bit scared sometimes, so...

2:59:05 I think for me the housing legislation session just was mind-blowing. There's some really crazy stuff out there and some of the ways that things work at odds really kind of was an eye-opener and then the mobility strategies for City Hall, not in the sense of moving around but being able to communicate with the community was very important as well as learning what not to say on social media and

2:59:34 To do's on social media. That was very interesting. I did attend the LAFCO meeting earlier today. However, I have nothing to report out on that because we went into our three-hour workshop. So I will update next month on that. So that wraps it up for council member reports. And now we will go ahead and move to commissions and or departments.

3:00:22 They're cursing to each other in the back. I'm not sure what that means. Exciting. Who's got the most interesting stuff to talk about? Public Works usually wins. So quick update on construction activities. We're continuing to work on the Lower Main Street Project, which the work is right in front of Sierra Mountain. We're hoping to have that open substantially complete before 4th of July, have the sidewalk in. Our crews are working diligently to make that happen.

3:00:49 We are still planning to move to the frontage road areas after 4th of July. We're not going to break ground on that until, you know, after the festivities. We've made some significant progress on wayfinding. Consultant has provided shop drawings. We're working to review those. They'll probably start placing foundations within about three to four weeks. You'll start to see LAF out in the streets where we're placing the signs. So that project is moving ahead quite nicely.

3:01:15 We did get the, well, we didn't, the Forest Service opened the Lakes Basin on Monday. I just want to thank all our partners, Mammoth Disposal, ESTA, Forest Service. They made the decision last Thursday. We scrambled with our partners to get bathrooms, porta-potties, dumpsters, get ESTA running in a matter of a couple days and got that open on Monday morning. So I would just want to thank all of them for really stepping up and making that happen quickly. As Bobby mentioned, we did have a meeting the other day on REDS.

3:01:44 There's actually a few more issues down there. The road is actually covered in dirt. ESTA doesn't want to run until that's been swept. The Forest Service does not have a sweeper, and the amount of debris is above and beyond what our sweeper is capable of removing. Forest Service, they reached out today. They've got a rental unit they're going to pick up tomorrow, and then they'll sweep the road over the course of a couple days, and then ESTA will be able to start their training. They also have some issues with the water system down there. There is no potable water in the valley.

3:02:13 They're working diligently to get that up and running. There's some issues with their pumps, but I think they've overcome that. They've got a couple of tests that need to run and have approved before they can have potable water in the basin. Those water issues also affecting their toilets. The Town of Mammoth Lakes has offered to provide porta-potties to help them out in the interim to help get the basin open. We've also offered to help them out with potable water if they need be.

3:02:37 So those are a couple of challenges that they're trying to overcome right now in order to open. I can tell you that all the partners have been communicating pretty much all day today, trying to figure out ways to creatively get this thing, get Reds open as soon as possible to meet the needs of our visitors and our residents. So we'll have updates tomorrow morning. We'll have a report that goes out, public service announcement, and then we'll follow that up as soon as we have a hard date on when we're going to open. We'll let the public know.

3:03:06 Thank you. Okay. I do have a question about the Lakes Basin. Initially, I think on Thursday, I read that Horseshoe Lake was still closed. Is that now open or the parking area, is everything in the Lakes Basin open now? The last I heard, Horseshoe was still closed. That is the Forest Service who makes the decision to open that. Oh, okay. But I know it's pretty close to being melted out and it could go at any moment. Oh, okay.

3:03:31 Thank you. Yeah, horseshoe's closed, but you can walk. You can still walk up there. The gate block. Oh, so there's a gate there. There's a gate, and people are parking and walking. Correct. Hayes, you will get all the updates to Dan, and he will CC us on the updates in a very timely fashion, so the people that are calling me, I can answer two. I can make that happen. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much.

3:03:58 Good evening, Rob Patterson, Administrative Services Finance Director. I want to just give you a brief update on the work that continues with the communication systems within Mono County. As you know, Nate and I have been working through some solutions to try to bring forward either a JPA or just maybe a broader sense of how to deal with those.

3:04:21 The communication challenges that we have. So the brief update here, and hopefully you don't have any technical questions because I certainly can't fill in for Nate on that. But you wanted to let me know, let you know that the technical maintenance of the system is still underway. And there's a couple of key areas that they're working on this summer to keep the system, try to enhance the services a little bit, but necessarily keep them up and running. A long-term solution, the county has contracted with federal engineering.

3:04:50 To work up the outcomes of that contract are to provide a plan of a couple of different alternatives for the county to either upgrade or overhaul the systems to meet the user's needs. They'll provide technical detail and rough engineering that can be used to develop an RFQ, RFP for someone to perform those services as well as helping cost out the system and then create a general roadmap of that plan and that process.

3:05:18 The way they're going about that, they'll be on site through, I think, through the month of June and part of July, they'll be on site and working to understand the current system's problems, technical perspectives, also stakeholders' needs and issues, they're addressing that. They'll have a coverage workshop with some key staff just to get input from that on how the system works. But they'll provide a draft report to the county probably late July.

3:05:42 Then collect feedback from the county representatives on that and deliver a final report in August or September. And I've asked that he come and present that so you guys have clarity on that as well. But based upon that report, we'll probably have a formal process to begin and focus on how we would implement this.

3:06:01 Another thing we're working on is some regionalization of dispatch. This is currently being investigated with both Inyo Mono County Regional Dispatch, and that may be something that we move forward with, but it's just in its infancy stages. And then, as I mentioned before about a JPA of some sort, the governance of this overall process is something that is kind of the third step in implementing something regional for the area.

3:06:31 We'll have more information as this federal engineering report is brought forward and you guys will have an opportunity to have that. So just wanted to give you a brief update on that. Thank you very much for that. Any other commissions or department at this time? Okay. In that case, we have some celebrating to do today, folks. So I will go ahead and move to item two, 20-year service recognition to finance manager, Cindy. My rolled. And here she comes.

3:07:01 Cheers. Rob, you're going to take care of this one? I am going to take care of this one, and I am just thrilled that all of the town staff I see in the audience to come and support what we're doing tonight. It's just terrific, so thank you guys for showing up. Oh, nice. So I do have a few things to say, and then Cindy's going to talk for, I think, about half an hour.

3:07:35 Tonight, I just, I want to recognize Cindy Myrell's 20 years of service to the town. You know, through the 20 years, Cindy's been through many changes. I mean, she's, the town of Mammoth Lakes, and especially in, you know, our town environment, the finance department, there's been a lot of changes that have gone on in those 20 years, and Cindy's been there through that, throughout that time, really to help.

3:07:56 You know, meeting those challenges and keeping us going in the right direction. She began her career July of 1999 as an accounting assistant. Primary focus at that time was accounts payable. Soon worked her way up into revenue collection, which is, you know, what I do now, tax collection, if you will, business tax and TOT. 2003, she took on her first supervisory role, that same group. So it shows, you know, her dedication and ability to move forward within the same groups and to take on leadership roles, which is spectacular.

3:08:24 And then in 2005, she was promoted to accounting manager where she, you know, continued on those prior roles but then took on the annual audit, which is a huge undertaking, annual audit. The preparation for that is probably about two months of straight work. And then while the auditor's here, it's two weeks of, you know, just sheer panic where he's asking, you know, all kinds of questions and information. So it's really quite a big thing. And she handles that almost entirely. I have very little to do with that. And that's – I much appreciate that.

3:08:54 Then the sort of the challenging years began, you know, as we started going through a lot of different issues. But, you know, Cindy, for a long time, you know, took on the role of finance manager, acting finance director, all kinds of things, whatever was necessary. Since I arrived, and this went on for quite a while, I arrived in 2016, she's been just an unbelievable asset for me. I came from outside of the municipal environment.

3:09:22 And so she's had to do a lot of training with me, a lot of schooling, a lot of understanding, and helping me take my private understandings into a public setting, and I could not have done it without her. So I'm just so grateful for that. And Cindy's been a, she's a treasure to us, and I think the education that she provides is amazing. So I appreciate everything she does, both for the town and me personally. So thank you, Cindy, and congratulations on 20 years.

3:09:57 Thank you so much, and I was very grateful to have this job for the last 20 years. I was able to raise my four daughters in this town, and they have moved on to have their own professional careers and things that they've done, and I'm very blessed to have been able to serve here. Thank you. So here's for the next 20, too.

3:10:37 And the fun does not stop there. We also have 20 years service recognition award to Public Works Maintenance Lead Worker Lance Miller. Grady, take it away.

3:11:18 Thank you. I'm here for two reasons real quick. I want to introduce myself, Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. You haven't seen me for a while. Thank you for your forbearance and allowing me to work remotely. Welcome back. It's worked out very well. Thank you. I'm just going to turn it right over to Todd Murphy. He's the leader of that group down there. He's known Lance and worked with him the entire time he's been there. He'll say a few words and that's it. Thanks, Todd. Good evening. Todd Murphy, Public Works Maintenance Manager.

3:11:49 Just want to say a few words about Lance. Lance started with the town in 1999. He came over from the Forest Service, working seasonal with the Forest Service, and then he came on with the town full-time in 99, four years with seasonal work. After that, he got on with us full-time. This speech isn't going to be near as long as...

3:12:15 The last speech that Rob gave for Cindy by any means due to my comfort level speaking here. But anyways, I just want to congratulate Lance on a great 20 years with the town. I think he's a super dedicated, super skilled employee that over the years working with him has been a pleasure for me and everybody else that he works around. His work ethic is top notch. He's one of the people that I've worked with over the years that will give you a hard day's work from...

3:12:42 As soon as he gets into work in the morning until the day ends. And if he runs out of work, he comes looking for work. So he's definitely a model employee that we have. He got promoted to lead worker about three years ago. And I think he's done a wonderful job with it. And I hope he continues working with us for at least long enough to see me retire. So congratulations, Lance.

3:13:15 So, Lance, if you'd like to say a few words, or if not, we do have a Certificate of Appreciation as well for you. Thank you very much. This has been a great job. Great community. I love everything about it. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Joel, shouldn't you be operating the camera? I mean, you're the photographer here, buddy. Thank you. How can I add that to his work list, don't you think?

3:14:01 Okay, and while we're celebrating 20 years of wonderful service from some members, unfortunately, this next item, Grady, I'll let you segue into that. Recognition of retiring airport manager, Brian Picken. That's right. And you didn't completely have to trick Brian to be here, but we did kind of just direct him to do so. Let me put it that way. I wouldn't call it shy, but he's...

3:14:28 I'd like to stay out of these kind of situations, but we really appreciate it. I'm going to ask Brian actually to recap a little bit of his career with the town because I have some vague dates and memories. He got here in the mid-2000s, somewhere between 2004 and 2007, depending on which record you look at. Moved to the airport in 2008 as Commercial Air Service was just starting. So he's been there growing through the whole thing, seeing the ups and downs and changing air carriers and staff and everything else. He actually started with the town as an analyst.

3:14:58 Working both with community development and public works came from that background. And one comment I did want to pass on, and I didn't hear this, but yesterday I intentionally spent some time with Camille Garibaldi on the phone. She's been our longest running contact, I'd say, with FAA at the San Francisco Air Force District Office. And I mentioned that, and she was actually sorry she couldn't even be here because she is...

3:15:23 Very sorry to see Brian go, and she was very pleased and said some awful nice things about working with him all these years about how communicative he is, able to call him on a minute's notice, communicate very well, address our needs and everything else as a team. So I want to pass that along from Camille and all the staff in San Francisco, how much they appreciate it. So with that, thank you, Brian. And I'm going to let you say a few words as well. Thank you.

3:15:52 Well, as all you know, I have very few words. First, I want to thank you, Grady, for saying that. It was very nice. And I want to thank the community that I was able to serve. That's been wonderful. I want to thank all the employees that I've worked with, really wonderful people. I want to thank the council. And that's really all I have to say. Thank you. It's been a great time. It's meant a lot to me. Thank you. Thank you. And you know what? I want to get everybody down.

3:16:23 Okay, thank you. I'm actually going to get everybody to come down and get a picture with you, too, so whoever's got the camera. Thank you. Rob, your work will be critiqued, so we can get in here. You're going to get you in the middle of this group. Come on, guys, let's get in here. It's yours now. Thank you. All right. Thank you very much, everybody. Thank you very much.

3:16:59 People shift there for a second. This is my last meeting as mayor, running the meeting from beginning to end, so I'm taking a little bit of time here. This is a proclamation that I've put out. I guess you guys are going to be voting for it. This is approving the proclamation declaring July 2019 as Cancer Recovery Month.

3:17:39 Should I read a little bit of this before we vote? Okay. Whereas cancer touches the lives of most community members in some fashion and cancer recovery pertains to patients as well as their families and friends and to help maintain the quality of life and well-being of our community, we thank the numerous individuals and organizations who volunteer their time and the generosity of the community in assisting those facing the uncertainty of this disease. Whereas we support

3:18:08 Wholeness of those affected and their families beyond this disease emotionally, spiritually, and mentally. So with that. I would make a motion to approve the proclamation declaring July 2019 as Cancer Recovery Month. I'll second the motion. Yeah. Okay. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

3:18:38 Yes, item passes 4-0. Thank you very much. And today we have with us Lori Ciccarelli. If you could come to the podium. She's going to be accepting the proclamation and has some statements to make about this. Thank you, Mayor and Town Council. I'm honored to accept this proclamation on behalf of our community at large to help raise awareness.

3:19:07 To help maintain the quality of life and well-being of our community by supporting early detection methods and by supporting wholeness of those affected and their families beyond this disease emotionally, spiritually and mentally as mind, body and soul are all connected. I've had the pleasure of being a community member for nearly 30 years and an employee of Mammoth Hospital for 21 years.

3:19:36 It has been a privilege to lead various cancer initiatives for Mammoth Hospital such as leading the fundraising endeavors to purchase our first mammography machine, to be a part of the opening of our infusion room, and to be a part of a team leading our cancer outreach programs. Currently, I am honored to facilitate the hospital's cancer support group walking alongside our patients.

3:20:03 And I believe all of us have been affected by cancer somehow, either affected personally or have a family member, a friend or co-worker, or have volunteered or contributed money to a cancer cause. I personally lost my father 20 years ago to colon cancer, and I will be affected for the rest of my life emotionally and spiritually. So I am in cancer recovery.

3:20:31 Cancer recovery, I believe, affects all of us. The patient who is battling cancer, the patient's family members, the families who have lost a loved one, the cancer survivors who have been given a clean bill of health. We tend to forget about the survivors because they have been cured. However, most survivors and their families are still dealing with this disease emotionally, spiritually, and mentally. It doesn't go away.

3:21:00 And I'm sure you've heard of PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder. We typically think of a person in the military who fought war. But PTSD also affects cancer survivors and their families. It's called post-cancer anxiety disorders. Very common and quite understandable. They've been through war, battled for their very lives, and even now they are still tiptoeing through minefields emotionally.

3:21:28 Spiritually and mentally. So I am grateful for this July's designation of Cancer Recovery Month to help raise awareness. So thank you, Mayor and the Town Council for the proclamation of the Town of Mammoth Lakes declaring July 2019 as Cancer Recovery Month. Thank you. Thank you.

3:22:13 Okay, now that I've brought down the room, let's move on to the next bit of business, which is hopefully not the landfill. I hope it's, no, it's another presentation of awards from Police Chief Al Davis. Madam Mayor, Council Members, it's my pleasure to be here tonight to present.

3:23:07 The Chief's Award to two law enforcement professionals in our area. A little bit about the Chief's Award. I decided to start the Chief's Award as the highest award that I could provide to a citizen or a law enforcement professional. It's for community service or outstanding police work. So with that, I'd like to bring up two law enforcement professionals, Officer Daniel Hansen and Sergeant Brad DeGuss with the CHP. On May 24th,

3:23:42 We provided the Know Your Limit campaign to the high school seniors at Mammoth High School. The effort was tremendous. It was huge. And the two gentlemen that really made it happen are these two guys right here. Sergeant D'Gust was able to get a grant from California Office of Traffic Safety. And Dan O'Hanson was able to get a grant from State Farm Insurance in order to provide the funding for the two-day event that went on.

3:24:10 Thank you, Chief. Thank you, Chief.

3:24:46 And I'd also like to add that Daniel has been the SRO for about a year now, and he's done an outstanding job. We have great partnership with the CHP when it comes to the schools and any other, you know, things in town, as well as Mona County Sheriff's. And with that, I'd like Lois Klein to come up and say a couple words about Daniel and his service. Thank you so much. I can't say enough about both of these gentlemen.

3:25:17 Tremendous partners for our school. But I'll start with Daniel. Daniel has been our school resource officer for a year. And I have some words that people shared with me about Daniel. He's passionate. He's collaborative. He's responsive. He's invested. And he's professional. He really cares about our students, our staff, and our administrators. He's partners with our principals.

3:25:44 He's worked hard to support our efforts to educate our students and their parents and our teachers on the dangers of vaping, which is an epidemic amongst youth in our country today and has definitely hit Mammoth as well. He's played an important role in our district safety planning.

3:26:05 The planning. We had one serious incident this year. He was a wonderful resource within that and debriefing afterwards. We just very, very, very much appreciate the partnership with Daniel. He adds a lot to our school district in terms of resources to help our students and our partnership with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department.

3:26:32 And I also want to add that Brad D. Gus is also just a tremendous supporter of our schools. He's there all the time as well. Every 15 minutes was a tremendous success. I've seen a lot of them and none that I've seen in my entire career have been better than this one that was held this spring in Mammoth. So I very, very much appreciate and I'm so proud of the recognition for both of these gentlemen. Thank you.

3:27:01 Thank you. I'm not going to make him speak, but we'll get some pictures with the council and then our guys. Yeah, I was about to say, would you like us down there and get some pictures? We've got to get a picture of you with just those two guys as well. Not that I'm going to direct the whole photo shoot. Just go ahead. Oh, wow.

3:27:30 Thank you.

3:28:06 Give everybody just a few seconds as they're exiting. Okay. Thank you everybody. Now after all that celebrating.

3:28:57 We have a few people left. Now we get to the Solid Waste Franchise Agreement and Program Update, Item 7 on our agenda this evening. Yeah, I mentioned earlier, talking about landfill. Oh, I'm sorry, what was that? No, I was talking about a landfill. Oh, yes. You mentioned that earlier, so I'm going to give you an overview of the staff report and areas we're looking at, and this is really trying to keep this item in front of the town council.

3:29:24 Significant policy initiative to town council as well as being driven by other factors, mainly the closure of the landfill. As we work through a lot of different issues and also the timing in terms of the franchise agreement that we're working with Mammoth Disposal, we would like to kind of walk through the areas and where we're at on that and really give the council an update and then we'll be planning on additionally, we've seen this several times as it comes forward to fruition with the final agreement and other elements as we look to the future.

3:29:53 But there's a number of existing agreements that are in place. You've seen some of those before, but they're highlighted here again as a number of different elements that drive or involve with the solid waste program within the town and ongoing coordination with the county. Several of the agreements here are for the amount of waste that flows to the...

3:30:15 Benton Crossing Landfill and the parcel fee is collected on a countywide basis and utilized and rolls back into the town and the county for these types of services. The franchise agreement that we talked about before, but it actually extends through this year. The current franchise will be up in December and the idea is to have a new one up and running and in place to replace that as we look to the future.

3:30:40 And then also we're really looking at trying to integrate some of the work we currently do with the Sierra Conservation Project, which does a lot of our recycling. We have a very simple letter agreement with them for the services they're provided and looking at initially trying to do an upgrade of that. And at this point it's probably looks to be more effective. We've met with both parties and stuff and trying to get that to work together so it's integrated into the services.

3:31:07 Together with our waste disposal franchise as well as the recycling services that are provided through that service that the air conservation project provides. So the other side of that would be looking kind of down the road looking at the agreements with the county again potentially still adding a year to those or a year and a half pending on the agreement to tie out with the closure of the landfill.

3:31:34 The franchise agreement, as I mentioned, expires at the end of this year. The current agreement really looked at a lot of different elements. Several years ago, representatives from Waste Connections, Mammoth, I suppose, are here. We looked at, I think it was 10 years ago at least, when looking at options on the current facility and buying land, and the current agreement speaks to a lot of that.

3:31:59 As we've gone forward and looking at this, we're kind of dropping that option in terms of acquiring the land adjacent to the current facility. We are looking at additional land to meet other needs, probably additional acreage that allows for probably a more integrated and a little larger level of service. The other side of that, so that was dealing with the wood lot, as referred to in the franchise agreement, the parcel next to the current transfer station.

3:32:27 And they really did open up, I think, as the program went into place in Mammoth. Somewhat unique for trash services just because of weather and bears and other critters, et cetera. Where we really have the transfer station, it's a lot of a drop-off type element from customers. We are looking at ways to enhance curbside service, and we'll speak to that as we look into the new agreement a little bit and some of those services. The other real issues that have come up with...

3:32:55 Within the franchise work and solid waste in general has been state mandates, primarily focused on diversion of landfills, and that keeps growing and changing between goals and obligations and not just diversion out, but then when you divert out, what do you do with it? Be that organics or plastics, cans, cardboard, etc. We had a significant challenge this year where China decided not to take a lot of our recyclables from the U.S. A lot of that is

3:33:25 It'll take some still, but it needs to be a very clean load, a very clean process. And frankly, a lot of our, I know locally at least, a lot of our recycling is somewhat problematic just because of the mix of material and the, I'll call it the dirtiness of the material that comes through. And so that adds extra work and services from that standpoint. So we're looking at ways of how do we enhance that and, again, education, services, capabilities to work through that.

3:33:53 And so a lot of that has fallen into the agreement kind of negotiations. The current focus has primarily been on the service side and the structure of that. That will ultimately feed in some other decision points as we go forward. But really the core of our franchise service and the work is still the collection side and then the processing of solid waste in various ways.

3:34:16 The transfer station, we are looking at changes and upgrades to that, and if we're ready, we may have Mammoth Disposal, I was going to say Doug, but no, Roger, or Sue, speak to that element of some of those areas that we're looking at for enhancement there. We've also expanded kind of the recycling capability at the transfer station, including some separation out of a sort line.

3:34:41 We continue to do household hazardous waste collection there to some degree. You can drop off batteries and light bulbs and paints and oils, ethyl methyl stuff that you should not have in your garage, not so much, at the transfer station today. But as we look to the futures, how do we actually enhance that whole service? The extent that we can pull that material out of the waste stream versus letting it go into a landfill anywhere, it helps our environment and impacts down the road on elements.

3:35:11 I mentioned we have a small sort line at the site right now that's enhanced the recycling. Down the road looking at that material recovery facility, EMERF, actually expanding that capability and service to enhance our recycling capabilities. They do participate in town cleanup events and hopefully have some data this evening for that. This last one we did was a killer, so to speak. Several...

3:35:37 I won't walk to everybody because I'll forget people, but we had a number of town employees volunteered a lot of time for the day and were overwhelmed and amazed at the amount of material that was collected. A few of us were out there between 7.30, 8 o'clock and there until 5.30 in the evening. So it was a long day, lots of materials, and I believe Mammoth Disposal did not get fully caught up for two or three days or getting dumpsters out to the landfill.

3:36:04 But it's a great program, but we do want to look at some ways of how do we deal with that and the amount of material. But we continue to look at how do we collect bulky items, white goods, the appliances, electronics, construction debris, and those types of elements that go into play. As we look at new facilities, you know, how do we manage that and how do we coordinate? A lot of that ultimately is going to need a coordination with the county. Again, as we won't have the landfill site that manages some of that material today.

3:36:31 We'll be looking at, as we go forward, looking at the collection equipment, be that vehicles, be that bins. We're just in the process of initiating a new bear cart that the disposal company would actually own and maintain versus having customers buy their own, which should enhance the level of service in that area. And continue to look at some mixed material for potentially a biomass plant that's still in the process.

3:36:57 The list in the staff report is not exhaustive of all the services provided in some of those areas where we'll be expanding on, but they start to give you an idea for that. One of the key elements of some state changes and legal responsibilities, one of those is the reporting requirement. Right now, a lot of that goes through the county, and they are mandated for a lot of the reporting that goes to CalRecycle. Shifting that to the local agencies in that...

3:37:23 By default, we would be shifting that to Mammoth Disposal. So they would be the primary responsible party for a lot of the state reporting requirements that are placed on us. We're still ultimately responsible, but working through the agreements to have that responsibility placed on our waste hauler. And then that takes a lot of coordination efforts there, and some of that would still deal with self-hauling issues and things of that nature that we'll need to work to address. As we look at some of the highlights as we move forward,

3:37:52 Maintaining all the bins for the residential services is a key issue because, as I mentioned right now, a lot of the bear-proof carts, people have bought their own. They're actually falling apart in a lot of cases. And so folks, if they want to continue that, then they're looking out, trying to buy one. They're not readily available. And so we made a decision here a while back working with Mammoth Disposal would be if they can acquire carts that they can maintain and service and provide that element of support.

3:38:19 It probably makes life a lot simpler, and we believe we would, I believe we have about 90 or so current curbside customers. You could probably double that amount if we had a better system and carts in place. So that goal would help for those areas for people who want that level of service versus having to drive to the transfer station. Again, how do we work with Mammoth Disposal and put more of some of the responsibility or the vast majority for meeting state mandates?

3:38:46 We're still held accountable, but as we begin to work different areas, making that a little stronger relationship. We have a good material recovery facility. I think the state finds that we're actually in compliance with diversion at that point, and we're looking at a clean facility versus what we call a dirty MRF. So that'll definitely help in those areas. The other element is looking at the cleanup events, and is there a better way to do some of that, maybe looking at two events a year, maybe bifurcating some of the types of materials.

3:39:14 We need to look at how do we deal with that. It was an overwhelming day. Stu's not here. He had to take a vacation following that. But it was quite a bit of work that way. Then I mentioned also the recycling component as we integrate with Sierra Conservation and the work that they do. I think there's a really good symbiotic relationship in those areas. And then really after closing of the landfill,

3:39:42 It's going to be looking at where does that residual waste get hauled to, and that's an element that deals with the types of facilities we create. It'll deal with how much recycling we do. Now, a lot of the recycling material still has to be hauled away also, so that's often a cost component. Right now, a lot of the recycled material does not really pay for itself to be recycled, just in terms of processes and things out there. It's a statewide, well, it's a national issue, but a statewide issue, they're looking at how do we incentivize that and or...

3:40:10 Look at ways to enhance that. And as we look at that element, I know Mammoth's disposal has been approaching a couple of other area landfills for agreements for taking the waste from the region here into. And that comes down to haul costs and tipping fees, the disposal fees at the landfill as it relates back to costs for services in that area.

3:40:37 One of the key elements there would be in terms of our policy structure is really ultimately coming back to how much are we going to charge the customer for solid waste services. And that will depend a lot on how much infrastructure gets built, who pays for it, whether the town participates in part of that or whether it's all on the Mammoth disposal to put in those facilities.

3:41:01 To the extent that we help finance some of that, we can reduce customer costs if we're not trying to recover costs. We have been collecting money over time to work with that expansion component. We have about $1.4 million in a reserve fund that is committed to that purpose. And so how do we leverage that to help with facility enhancement, but also then to do so in a way that manages or helps reduce rate increases?

3:41:29 To make that work. And working through that financial structure, the other elements that drive that is what do we require, obviously, but then also just the length of the term of the agreement. What's the time frame that we're looking at the recovery of investment from the solid waste component? And also the whole idea of the enhanced recycling that we're going to get into. I think the state goal is 75%. General belief from other cities I've talked to is that that's going to become a mandate, not just a goal.

3:42:00 We're seeing that in the organic side already and some movements that way to 50% or better. We're currently exempted out whether that exemption will stand because they're not reaching the targets they had hoped to, at least the last round of stuff I was looking at for that. So ultimately a lot of those elements will fall into a financial structure. We've had discussions looking at having some outside services to come in and assist with that rate analysis and looking at that as well. We still think that's an appropriate step to take through that process.

3:42:30 The other question we're looking at at this point, the current franchise agreement has a 5% base franchise fee that goes to the general fund. We've also collected an equivalent of a 4.5% fee with a maximum dollar amount that we've been setting aside for future expansion and future infrastructure. As that's currently in the rate structure, if you will, the goal would be is the role...

3:42:54 Those together for a nine and a half percent franchise fee, but still splitting it. We're looking at seven percent that would be in the general fund and then two and a half percent that would go into the, it's an AB 939 related fund. And a lot of agencies have shifted to that. Those funds stay protected in our ways and to help deal with unforeseen issues related to solid waste. They can help with recycling programs. They can help with

3:43:19 The services provided, you can do other special funding out of that tied back to meeting state mandates and those goals for those franchise fees. And currently that would generate to the general fund, it currently generates about $225,000. The modifications would be the general fund would go to $325,000 and there would be $125,000 continuing to go into the AB 939 related restricted funding for those purposes.

3:43:48 That's flexible. That ultimately come back with a policy discussion with the council of how those rates can be utilized to assist in that. We're still, we believe, relatively, you know, in the lower end of a lot of the franchise fees, you'll see some as high as 12. I've seen one or two as high as 14 percent. Others might be in the 6 and 7 percent range, but there's a lot of different movement in that rate around the state in terms of where it's sitting at.

3:44:17 Other side of that would be coming back and looking at the facility at this point where our Mammoth Disposal is looking at building the primary transfer station on the current property and putting designs together for that and some of the engineering work. The other side of that, we had a very creative agreement where the maintenance facility was for their vehicles.

3:44:41 I say creative. It was in our franchise agreement that, for example, if we stopped providing service, we'd continue to pay rent for a period of time. The agreement on that shop expires the end of this month, I believe. And we did not have a renewal option with the owners that actually was beneficial to the company or the town, frankly, in terms of term and cost. And so they have relocated out of that facility.

3:45:07 And we'd be looking at buying additional facilities, likely in the industrial park by the airport, I believe, the last discussion looking at that. And that helps in a number of ways. One, we're a little bit more out of the snow component some days. Now, getting to it some days is a little difficult with blowing snow. But the idea there is we'd have more storage capacity for carts, for bins, for the port of toilet services provided by Mammoth's disposal as well. And that could end up being a nice element.

3:45:34 There, depending on the final acreage and layout of that site as well. And the question there would be is do we help participate in that financing? Do we end up owning some of the properties and it's a leaseback or other type of structure for that? That gives us flexibility in the future as well as hopefully a little better types of facilities that actually help provide the services that we do provide currently. And then again, our investment of that really kind of helps back to the whole rate structure.

3:46:04 How do we end up helping with that? The other piece to this that's in play is the Mono County Solid Waste Program. They put an RFP out. I don't know if the final one went out yet or not. They have been looking at trying to pull that together and doing a bid on a county-wide basis. And we have definitely looked at how do we integrate some of the services together. The town's facility would be sized at a level I believe it would be able to take all.

3:46:30 The current lease waste generated in the county and maybe looking out the next several years. So if we wanted from a bidding standpoint, not that we're involved in the RFP side, but our discussion with Waste Connections and Mammoth is supposed to be if they bid that countywide project that the town's transfer station could be sized accordingly and that would also generate another revenue source back into the town's facility.

3:46:58 The other piece with the county that becomes critical is really still a large acreage site and probably the Pumice Valley landfill site to handle a lot of the larger material, C&D material, which they currently process there, white goods, metal recycling, other areas where you actually need 10, 20, 30, 40 acres of land to be able to store material. We've also had an initial discussion with the county and toured the site as a potential location for the biomass plant on that same facility.

3:47:27 Which, again, with a lot of the C&D material and the other material that would go out there, it may actually end up being a fairly good location in terms of cooperative work with the county as well as the town through those processes. So once that RFP goes out, we'll take a look at that. We've been in some discussions off and on with the county for it. They've had some input to it. And we'd anticipate it going out in the near future.

3:47:52 Our next steps on this, if we get some good information and material in, we would look and come back on July 17th for some additional policy level direction. If we don't have all the data together, we can move that out if need be, but we want to try to push for that date to keep this moving to be able to do that. We will continue to work with Mono County as they look at the RFP and how that works. They have basically two service providers in the county at this point. Both are interested in bidding on the

3:48:22 Proposals, my understanding. And again, so how do we partner in that ultimately with our services as well? And then updating the solid waste flow agreement and parcel fee agreement. We'll take a look at those in terms of just working again with the county on that. The flow agreement is how much waste is going to end up at Benton for the closure plan that they're in working through. And then the parcel fee agreement extends that out as well. And ultimately, the broader discussion on that will be how much of that fee.

3:48:50 Needs to be retained by the county for post-closure work, and some of that will be there, I'll say forever. I don't know if they ever actually get rid of all the liability on a landfill. But there will be a portion of those dollars. It's about $480,000 a year, I believe, is generated, but there will be a piece of that that would come back into the town program and or jointly with the county for the other services. Again, a way of how do we leverage those dollars now into our solid waste programs versus...

3:49:20 Managing a landfill with them for that. And then again, continue to look at the elements that would support a biomass plant. Recent discussions with the Forest Service on that, they're very interested in that because the amount of dead material around the community that they need to dispose of, and at some point the open pile of burning probably is not going to be the only way to get rid of material. They're looking at options for those pieces that way.

3:49:48 Pam's here. She's been involved with a lot of the negotiations and involvement and carrying on some of the meetings when I've been gone, so it's been very beneficial and helpful. I'll ask her if she wants to add anything to the discussion, then I would like to get some comments from Mammoth Disposal, some of the data and information and other elements that they'd like to speak to. Let me ask Pam first and then Mammoth Disposal, and then if the council has questions, we can answer those.

3:50:13 Thanks, Dan. Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager. I don't really have much to add. I think just one thing, speaking to the schedule for this project, is that Dan mentioned the franchise agreement expires at the end of this year. Obviously, time is of the essence to get the agreement finalized prior to that date. We're working off a goal of getting this finalized in October to give us plenty of flexibility on the end of that, just in case there's anything unforeseen that might come up.

3:50:40 So we'll be working backward from that date to come back to you several times, as Dan mentioned, to get policy direction and ultimately bring forward a final agreement for your approval. There's no action on this, so I'll go ahead and put it out for a public comment. Yeah, I might have Mammoth's disposal speak to a couple of the items. I don't think they'll be fighting anybody to get up to the podium there.

3:51:07 Oh, I do see an interested party back there, so good. Sue Van Delender. I'm the Divisional Vice President for Waste Connections, and I actually came before you. I've been part of the Mammoth Disposal Company for the last 10 years, and I came before you in February of 2018, I believe, when you made the decision to allow us to negotiate.

3:51:35 We will have representation. I actually have with me.

3:52:04 Two of our members, so Roger Brown is boots on the ground here, and Roger will be at the meeting where you have some policy discussions, and he'll be able to provide any insight that you need. And then I also have Jeff Stevens with me, who is the divisional controller. So both of us have been involved with Mammoth Disposal over the last 10 years. We've appreciated the working relationship.

3:52:30 We've appreciated the back and forth in terms of the negotiations, and so we look forward to serving you for many years to come. And I'm here to answer any questions that you might have after public comment. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, now I'll open this up. Thank you, Stacey, for speaking to this as well. Sure. Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors, really speaking as an individual supervisor here tonight. But I would just urge...

3:53:02 Council and our board to take up this issue at the elected political level. Clearly, there's excellent staff work being done and collaborative effort on the staff level. This is something that needs our attention. It's something I hear about from people, especially in Mammoth, in the southern part of Mono County, who are very concerned about what's going to happen. And in the northern part of the county, they're really concerned about price changes.

3:53:30 So I would hope that in the next few months we could schedule a joint meeting and perhaps have this be the only item on the agenda and do a deep dive into solid waste. And I also want to let you know, I'm sure League of Cities is involved in this, but the rural county representatives of California focus on the impacts of California's developing solid waste and diversion.

3:53:57 Laws and programs and, you know, looking out for small rural counties and cities like ours. Okay. Thank you. Here, can we take it back to Council for some questions? Yeah. I would like to mention, Roger, I'm not sure if you had the numbers from the cleanup day. Okay. We do have those numbers. Yeah. All right. There was a lot. The other thing, and Hayes mentioned it earlier this evening in terms of getting porter toilets and

3:54:28 Trash bins and stuff into Reds Meadow or into the Lakes Basin. And a lot of that is with the partnership with Mammoth Disposal and the ability to respond quickly on those issues and having people available in that partnership. And that's a lot of relationship building that's gone on to be able to do those types of things and have it happen quickly. And same thing, end of the season, we usually end up doing that. And then the idea is to get them out of there before the snow flies again, which could be any time now.

3:54:57 But it is a good partnership from some of the elements that we do work through. Okay. Have any questions for... I have a comment or two. A comment? Do you have any questions? No. Questions? When would we be able to get an idea so that we can let the public know of any price changes? I mean, is there any timing on that? Because if we're going to do the parcel fee or increase, so...

3:55:25 At least give the public a heads up that, yeah, there's going to be some changes. Yeah, and at this point, I believe that the primary focus would be on the regular monthly service rates and stuff. That'll come in. We'll end up having to do a Prop 218 hearing on that, so there will be a whole notification process that goes out. And I think that's going to come back, and depending on what level of infrastructure and how we finance it that needs to go in will be one of the...

3:55:51 Primary rate drivers as well as the other levels of service we have to provide. So that will be coming forward. I don't have a hard date on it, but as the final franchise agreement is developed, there may be some additional gaps in there still as we look to the future and the actual closure of the landfill. That will depend on the negotiated price for disposal costs elsewhere and the trucking cost and those types of pieces that will be coming forward in that process. So ideally by

3:56:21 The rates generally go in each July. We just got the regular CPI increase for this current year. I think it's the last year of our agreement, last Prop 218 hearing. So we would be doing that again with a whole new input of data into that. It may be a bifurcated process. You can do it for a maximum of five years underneath Prop 218. We may end up doing a shorter time frame pre...

3:56:47 Benton Crossing Closure and Post-Benton Crossing Closure for the rates. And so we will get additional information out as we get that data available. Thank you. Okay, my question had to do with on page four when we're talking about the franchise fee split. I just wanted to make sure that I'm reading this correctly. I see that we have a fixed dollar amount on the 4.5 fee that's being collected. Is there going to be a fixed amount with the new split or is...

3:57:17 No, we would look at that just being a percentage that would continue to flow regardless. The cap was part of one of the unique pieces of the current agreement. Oh, okay. I think we've only hit it a couple of times. Yeah, okay. Maybe only one time. And just to add to that, the fee and the way that it's kind of split up, this will be one of the policy questions that we bring back to you at your next meeting. Oh, okay. Thank you for that. I have no more questions.

3:57:46 So, yeah, I just, I know this is a significant agreement that affects, you know, the town and the county. But as you know, you know, we're a recreation destination and we're seeing massive, not only massive, but significant and steady increases in things like dog waste and trash coming from our visitors and visitation. We have an interest in making sure that there are opportunities to maintain and clean all that stuff.

3:58:16 And I would hope that as part of your conversations, there's going to be a method so that it's not going to be a surprise to anybody that we have to do those kinds of things. And it's not going to be priced as if it is a one-off thing with exceptional cost to be borne by the town. And I would encourage the parties working on this to find a way to come up with something. I see their trails coordinator back there. We're doing a lot of work with the Forest Service.

3:58:46 They've got water-based toilet system, water systems that are failing. A lot of this stuff is going to have to change, and I look forward to seeing the policy recommendations so that we can be working with you guys going forward to make sure we can keep the trailheads clean, the parking areas clean, bathrooms cleaned and pumped, and that kind of stuff. We don't know exactly where it's going to go, but I look forward to hearing that recommendation. Thank you. Okay. So, thank you for that. Is there more additional information you wanted to give us?

3:59:15 Okay, thank you for your time coming out, and thank you to all working towards that. The clock is ticking. Okay, so now we are going to go to the... Excuse me one second. Matt McLean, were you going to speak tonight earlier on a matter? Was there something you needed to... Well, yeah. Dan, do you mind...

3:59:55 Matt, it would kind of come under staff in the sense that he's with MLR, but there is something that tied in earlier. We can talk about it at the next council meeting. Okay, but then you're going to be talking, though, the next council meeting is after your event. I believe so. After the 18th. Oh, the 18th. Okay, no, that's, okay. Never mind, then. We will go ahead and move on to consent agenda. What, did I skip something? Oh. Oh, okay.

4:00:27 Item 8, approve the minutes of the special meeting of June 3, 2019. Item 9, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 5, 2019. Item 10, approve the resolution of Leving Special Taxes and Community Facility District 2005-1. Item 11, approve the resolution of Leving Special Taxes and Community Facility District.

4:00:50 2004-1. Item 12, approve the resolution, levying special taxes and community facility district 2003.3. Item 13, acceptance of Sierra Nevada Conservancy Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Grant in the amount of $618,277.

4:01:10 50. Item 14, adopt the proclamation declaring 2019 as Park and Recreation Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Item 15, authorize a consulting agreement with Wallace.

4:01:23 Environmental Consulting for the preparation of the California Environmental Quality Act and NEPA and review for certain projects in the Mammoth Yosemite Airport Capital Improvement Program, Item 16, accept payment approval reports number 19-54 through 19-56. Anybody wishing to pull anything from the consent agenda? I'd like to pull 14, please.

4:01:51 Okay, 14. Nothing. Kirk? Okay. With that, I will entertain a motion. I would make a motion to approve consent 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, and 16. Second the motion. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes, except I'm going to recuse myself from item number...

4:02:18 13, I have no personal financial interest in this, but I serve on the board of an organization named an agenda item that does have a financial interest. Yes. Yes, item passes 3, well, 4-0 with an abstention on item 13. Since you are pulling that bill, I guess I'll let you tell me why. I thought this was important enough. We've done several other resolutions and proclamations tonight to give our rec.

4:02:49 Commission Chair an opportunity to speak to this that we are declaring July 2019 as Park and Recreation Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I could read part of the proclamation if you would like, although... Thank you very much. Not completely necessary. I will let Betsy speak to it. Thank you. You do have one form. Okay. Thank you.

4:03:20 We could have forgotten that, but I did just want to say very briefly that we are obviously all about recreation here in the Eastern Sierra. I'm Betsy Truax. I chair your recreation commission. The proclamation speaks to Parks and Recreation as an essential service in our community, and the entire commission is extremely proud of what our staff and volunteers deliver to our residents and visitors on a daily basis. In front of you is our new summer recreation brochure.

4:03:50 You take a moment to check that out. There's an awesome map on the inside. Thanks, Joel. And then on the back are our signature summer events, which include our items in July, celebrating Game On. That is the theme of this year's Park and Recreation Month. We just encourage everyone to come out and enjoy our parks and facilities, like free swim Sundays and Friday night.

4:04:15 Free Roller Disco at the Rec Zone, as well as our softball and volleyball tournaments. So just wanted to take a moment to thank the council for recognizing July as Park and Recreation Month. Thank you. Well, thank you. And I'll go ahead and read a little bit of this proclamation. It's whereas parks and recreation programs are an important part of communities.

4:04:36 Throughout this country, including Town of Mammoth Lakes, whereas parks and natural recreation areas improve water quality, protect groundwater, prevent flooding, improve the quality of air we breathe, provide vegetative buffers to development, and produce habitat for wildlife.

4:04:51 And whereas the House of Representatives has designated July as Parks and Recreation Month, therefore be it resolved by the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, that July is recognized as Park and Recreation Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And if you don't mind, I'm just going to, you can just come up here and we're going to shake your hand.

4:05:18 Oh, on the pictures? You know what, here, who is, where's Rob? Rob, get your. Are you still being a photographer? Yeah, but I think it was good. Yeah, let's get everybody down here for this one. You'd be really mad if I did not get a picture of this. That is true.

4:05:53 You know what, since it was on the consent agenda, I was a little bit... I will make the motion to approve item 14 from consent. Second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, item passes 4-1. And with that, I hate to play pop-up again. I would like to...

4:06:28 Take a seven-minute break before we go on to policy matters. We'll be right back. Sorry, guys. No, that's fine. I'm on a frequent potty break. Okay, let's... Okay, we are back now after our break. Item 22 is not on our agenda. Aren't we going to 17 and conduct the public hearings? Oh, excuse me, 17. Good grief.

4:11:13 I was good. I was about to say, I'm trying to get out of here. My last full meeting, I'm trying to rock and roll this. Okay, so now we are on item 17, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution confirming the assets proposed in the final engineer's report for the fiscal year 2019-20 for assessment district 93-1 Juniper Ridge. I am going to go ahead and open the

4:11:43 Public hearing, and I guess, Hais, it's going to be, for some reason, I thought it was going to be Sierra, but it's going to be you, so good. Thanks. Alrighty. So we have in front of you actually five assessment district

4:11:56 Annual assessments and levies. I'm proposing that we go through them somewhat systematically just for efficiency's sake. I'm happy to go through, read the recommendation, provide a little background, even though it's going to sound a little bit repetitive. A little info on what the assessment district does, and then open up any questions you guys have. Then we do the public hearing, if you guys are okay with that. So you're suggesting we do all five public hearings at once? No, we've got to go through them systematically, but just to kind of keep a flow.

4:12:25 You confused me there for a minute. No worries. Cheat sheet here. So, Madam Mayor, you read off the recommendation from staff. This particular assessment district for Juniper Ridge handles landscaping maintenance. You received a resolution back on May 15th, which was adopted by council, initiating these procedures. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Any questions? I'll take it out to public comment. Seeing none.

4:12:57 I will turn it back over to, there's no questions, so. Close the public hearing and move on with the vote. Yeah. I'm closing this public hearing. Any more comments from town council? Entertain a motion. I would recommend the council that you adopt a resolution.

4:13:23 It's easy. You can read the whole thing if you want. No, there's too much in here. I've got to talk to staff about how they do this again. Adopt the resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessment within Assessment District 93-1, Juniper Ridge, for the fiscal year 1920. That's it. Perfect. Okay. I got a second? I would think it does. Okay. A motion has been made and seconded, and roll call, please. Yes. Yes.

4:13:53 Yep. Yes. Item passes 4-0. Now moving on to item 18. Conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessments within the assessment district 93-4, zone 1, the bluffs maintenance district number 1 for fiscal year 2019-2020. Opening the public hearing.

4:14:19 Thank you. The Bluffs Assessment District 93-4 provides snow removal, asphalt maintenance, and lighting for that district. A resolution of intention was adopted on the May 15th meeting. I'm happy to answer any questions regarding this staff report. Questions of staff? No. Take it out to public comment. Seeing none.

4:14:46 I'll bring it back to, oh, there's no question, so I will close the public hearing. Are there any Town Council comments? I will entertain a motion. I'll try not to fumble this one. Adopt the resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessments within the Bluffs Assessment District, Number 93-4, for fiscal year 1920. Second the motion. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

4:15:16 Yes, item passes 4-0. Now on to item 19, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessments within North Village Benefit Assessment District number 2002-2 and ordering the levy and collection of assessments within special maintenance districts North Village Benefit Assessment District number 2002-2 North Village at 2002-2 Zone 1. Opening the public hearing.

4:15:45 To you, Hayes. Thank you very much. The North Village Benefit Assessment District provides maintenance for sidewalks, curb, gutter, and snow removal services in the North Village area. Again, on May 15th, the council adopted a resolution initiating these proceedings. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have about that assessment district. Any questions about that district? Seeing none, I will take it out to public comment. Seeing none, I will now close the hearing. Any TC comments? Town Council comments?

4:16:15 I will entertain a motion. Bill, you want to do this? I'm happy. Adopt a resolution confirming the engineer's report for ordering the levy and collection of assessments within Special Maintenance District, North Village Benefit Assessment District, number 2002-02, Zone 1, for fiscal year 1920. Second the motion. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

4:16:45 Yes, item passes 4-0. On to item 20, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution for ordering the levy of annual assessments within special maintenance district Old Mammoth Road benefit assessment district number 2002-1. Public hearing is open. Presentation.

4:17:03 Thank you. The Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District 2002-1 provides snow removal services, landscaping, and maintenance of curb, gutter, and sidewalk. I will also add that staff will be at Council on the 17th of July with an update on the Old Mammoth Road beautification project, and that is part of this assessment district. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions regarding the Old Mammoth Road Assessment District. Any questions from Council? No. Public comment on this item? Seeing none.

4:17:33 I will go ahead and close the hearing. No comments. We will go ahead and entertain a motion. I'll adopt the resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessment within the Old Mammoth Road.

4:17:48 benefit assessment district number 2002-1 in order in the levy and collection of assessments within the maintenance of districts of Old Mammoth Road benefit assessment district number 2002-01 Old Mammoth Road Bad 2002-1 for the physical year of 2019-20. Second. Roll call please. Excuse me. Yes.

4:18:17 Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 4-0. Item 21, conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution confirming the annual assessments proposed in the final engineer's report for fiscal year 2019-20 for Benefit Assessment District 14-01, Mammoth View. Open the public hearing. Staff presentation. Thank you. Last but not least, the Mammoth View Benefit Assessment District is one of our newer assessment districts.

4:18:45 Basically maintains the area around Viewpoint Road and was associated with the development that was proposed on the corner of Viewpoint and at the top of Viewpoint. Okay. Questions? Seeing none, public comment? Seeing none, I will go ahead and close the hearing. Either comments or a motion, please.

4:19:12 I'll make the motion to adopt a resolution confirming the engineer's report for the levy of assessments within Mammoth View Benefit District number dash 2014-01 for the fiscal year 1920. Second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 4-0. With that, we have finished up.

4:19:36 Our housekeeping duties. We are now moving on to policy matters. Item 22 has been removed from the agenda. We are on item 23. This is adopt legislative platform. And Pam, are you taking this? Okay. Pam, thank you. Good evening again, Councilmembers. Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager. This item is

4:20:04 To adopt the legislative platform for the town of Mammoth Lakes. As you know, constantly state and federal legislation is being proposed that has the potential to impact the town, either positively or negatively. In the past, the town council has taken action on various matters that they believe to be of potential impact or interest to the town. However, the town has never previously taken any formal positions regarding various legislative policy matters.

4:20:34 A legislative platform is a tool that can help municipalities take actions and be active in the legislative process, and it is used by many public agencies. Locally in Mono County and Inyo County both have legislative platforms, as well as the SCOG. But as I mentioned, the town of Mammoth Lakes has never formally adopted one. A legislative platform identifies priority policy areas.

4:20:59 And allows staff the ability to act quickly when new legislation is proposed. This allows us to be more nimble and responsive when new legislation is proposed, rather than bring each item individually forward to the town council and waiting for meeting dates, at which point sometimes key action dates may already have passed. So by adopting priorities policy items, staff can act quickly and responsibly in a timely manner to these legislative

4:21:29 Policies that might impact us. This draft legislative platform was put together by reviewing and incorporating policy priorities from other municipalities, looking at the Town Council's strategic priorities and the general plan vision statement, and also by taking a look at past actions that the council has taken. This led to identifying six guiding principles for the platform, preserving local control, promoting fiscal stability,

4:21:59 Protect the environment, support outdoor recreation, enhance local government efficiency, and expand the availability and affordability of community housing. Within these six guiding principles, 13 policy areas have been identified, and within each of those policy areas, staff has identified a number of potential

4:22:21 Things that council may wish to support or oppose when it comes to legislative proposals. I'm not going to call out those 13 individual policy areas. I expect you've all read through the platform already.

4:22:37 Despite having a legislative platform, there still may be times where town staff may need to bring individual legislative proposals forward to the council for a variety of reasons. It might be a matter that's not specifically addressed in the platform. Perhaps there's something in a proposal that may be supportive of one part of the platform but conflict with another part of the platform, in which case we would see here feedback kind of as to which

4:23:03 This proposal might be more important. In fact, the next item on your agenda is an example of this, and Andy will be going over that with you soon. So I just want to make sure that you're aware. You still might see legislative proposals coming forward to you, but hopefully not as frequently as we have in the past. And in general, that process will generally just go through Mayor's signature. Since this has been put in your packet, a couple of minor...

4:23:31 Changes were proposed by the town manager to me to the document. I just wanted to quickly go over those with you before making my recommendation. So if you want to look at the legislative platform on page five, this is the economic development section. Number three, efforts to provide funding mechanisms for economic development tools, including infrastructure investment.

4:23:57 And the development of workforce housing is proposed to be added. Number eight, at the end of the sentence, it would read proposals or policies that negatively impact and burden small businesses and inhibit local government. And then one additional proposed change is on the last page, page 15. This is a very minor change under number six, instead of saying our local airport, specifically identifying Mammoth Yosemite Airport.

4:24:30 I'm sorry, what page was that you said? Page 15, the very last page of the platform. And then under number 6, instead of saying our local airport, it would say Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Oh, okay. Thank you. I just want to emphasize that this is your legislative platform, so while staff did its best to draft this and identify policies that we believed

4:24:56 We have reflected your political priorities. We want to make sure that this is representative of your priorities. So any proposed changes that you have consensus on, we will incorporate into this before finalizing it. With that, we recommend that you adopt the resolution adopting the Town of Mammoth Lakes 2019-20 legislative platform with the amendments that I just proposed and any additional amendments that Council may have consensus on.

4:25:27 I did have a question. I don't know where it is, but it seemed to me if the mayor wasn't available to sign that it was something that a town manager would be able to sign. And even though I recognize the thinking behind this, I would just, you know, ask if you're signing something, what would be, how would we get that information? Would you be? What I would suggest is on any of the letters that we do that

4:25:55 Don't come directly to council. Then we would future agenda would show those as correspondence. Oh, okay. So you'd be informed on that. The other element to the mayor, if I can sign, that's usually just a timing effort. Other times we'll ask the mayor pro tem to sign. Okay. So as having elected official on the signature page. So, but the main thing is that we run into issues. I think right now, especially there's a whole bunch of trailer bills coming out for budget. There's other legislative actions that are going to end up.

4:26:21 They'll ask for comment and input on those. And by the time we would get to a council meeting, they'll be in their summer recess. So our comments won't matter, frankly. So the idea is the nimbleness to be able to move things quickly to the legislature, especially as it moves toward the end of the season becomes very critical. And then there is a two year legislative session. So a lot of bills that we may oppose that have died or others that we'd want to come back. We'll have another bite at the apple, if you will, once they move into the.

4:26:50 Second half of the session. And there's a lot of weird stuff in the legislature right at the moment, a lot of stuff that impacts local control that would fall squarely within this platform that the town might want to take a position on, including one really nasty bill that might make it hard for us to develop the parcel. Okay, anybody have questions for Pam? Well, I'm assuming that this is, I mean, reading through it generally appears to be broad enough.

4:27:20 That if any of these things that Mr. Morris is talking about, that it will give the discretion to the town manager and to the mayor to be able to act on these things. So I don't have any specific comments on it. I'm just hoping it's broad enough that if we need to act, someone will be able to act in the community's interests. Of course, that's the intent of this document. I have no problem with one of them, and that's the environmental resources volume.

4:27:47 Increasing motorized. I'm not trying to decrease. This is on page 235, number 8. You know, with climate change, and I believe that it's coming. It's going to impact us. I don't want to decrease the motorized activities, but I'm not interested in increasing it. So, you know, I don't know what the council wants to do with that. So, number one, legislation allows for continued and increased, you know, for continued, you know, you know.

4:28:17 Motorized and non-motorized. That word increase because of my feelings about climate change. I understand, but I think that the ultimate kind of arbiters of that stuff are going to be things like the federal government and the state government. And I don't think it, I think as a recreation destination, I think we support if it's legal on federal public lands.

4:28:39 And say we've got things like a snowmobile system but doesn't have adequate trailheads, I think it's reasonable to think that we would want to continue to invest in just maintaining the infrastructure that we have and if we can enhance it. I just, from my perspective, if it's legal on federal public lands, I think we should be supporting it as part of being a... Well, I'm not... It's the idea of the conflict between the term increase. John, I agree with what you're saying. I'm not trying to stop motorized...

4:29:08 It's just the idea that it conflicts with the idea of climate change and the IPCC report that just came out, the fourth annual report. But remember, we live in a state that is, I mean, the directives that are going to come out of the state, they're going to, that's...

4:29:28 A little bit above our pay group. I would just like to say, the way that I'm looking at this, I went through and there were some things that I was like, eh, you know, that may not be something, but I do think for getting letters out there, generally to have this as something that if we're all agreed on, and correct me if I'm wrong, if we kind of all agree on this,

4:29:49 We're not going to agree on every bit of it, but it'll give us a general sense. But if there is something, say something came up and it was increased motorized, from what you said, it sounds like there will be a level where you go, well, I know staff has maybe some questions about this, and so therefore it's not automatically signed. It is maybe brought forward to the council.

4:30:18 Sure. For instance, kind of the example that I think I hear you saying is like let's say there was a piece of legislation that proposed increased motorized use on public lands, but there was some concerns that it would also, you know, have some environmental impacts that might conflict with one of these other things in the environmental and resources section. Because those two things conflicted with each other, we would bring it back for Council.

4:30:46 Support or opposition before sending out a letter in that instance. And if I could make one suggestion, too, that might address Councilmember Stapp's concerns while also hearing what Councilmember Wentworth had to say is maybe if we change the word increased to enhanced.

4:31:06 I'm not sure if that would help. I like increase for all forms of recreation. If we frankly are going to get down to the level of the very small percentage of recreation that is motorized and we are going to go on a global warming binge, then we should probably cease being a resort that looks for everybody to drive from Southern California to Mammoth. So I see this as far less egregious, if you will, towards global warming.

4:31:34 than just being a destination-based resort. So I think increased any recreation for us is a good thing if it's done prudently and in an appropriate fashion so that we're not creating issues. I like the way it's written and I would like to keep it that way. Yeah, and I would add, Kirk, I have a meeting on Monday with the California Air Resources Board staff.

4:31:56 To talk with them about what we did with the California Transportation Commission, to look at with our recreation economy leveraging what we've got with digital 395 and Highway 395 as a four-lane separated highway to start getting to the state at a very high level to start investing what you're talking about using Highway 395 as a case study for a first autonomous vehicle test.

4:32:22 Test case or something like that. That's the kind of thing in terms of the VMTs and getting to climate change issues where we can leverage what we have as a recreation destination to maybe put a real dent in those kinds of issues. So I'm with you, Bill. I'm okay with it as it is. But if that's something you're concerned about, let's note it. And then if something comes up that fits in that thing, these guys will bring it back and we can talk about it.

4:32:51 Anytime something can come back, even if it's just a consent agenda, the reason for this isn't so staff can take positions. It is so that benefiting the town, we can move forward in a timely enough fashion to make commitments. We're not trying to take anything from the council's ability to say, I like it or don't like it, because we are not all going to agree on anything. But I...

4:33:16 Yeah, thank you. But I would like to just see this move forward. I could pick it apart. But I think for a first attempt at this, job well done. Okay. Any public comments on this matter at this time? Seeing none, I will go ahead and bring it back to Council for comments or questions.

4:33:40 Kirk, do you feel pretty good about that? I'll abstain on this one just because of that language. I mean, I support this, and I support this, but the word increase bothers me. I'm sorry. I very much believe in climate change and the damage that it's been long-term going to do to this community. Okay. Hey, in that case, I guess I will make a motion. I would make a motion to adopt the legislative

4:34:09 Platform with the amendments as spoken by Penn. Reference adoption of the resolution. The resolution. Thank you. I'll second. Roll call, please. Yes, with an abstention on environmental and resources. I don't think we can pull out. There's not a way to do partial abstention. Yeah, there's not a way to. Just go back and do that? Not really. I'll say yes with comments in the record, which are already in the record. I understand that.

4:34:49 Yes. Yes. Yes, item passes 4-0. Thank you, Pam, for that. Now we are on item 25, approval of agreement with Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access. No, we continue. Okay, continue. Okay, that is continued. Okay, we are now going to go. Oh, goodness gracious. Okay, thank you. Let me go to that one.

4:35:20 Okay. We have item 24, which is approve letter opposing AB 516. Is this Pam? I know it's Andy. It can be anybody, really. This is a bill that would take away some of the tools that the police department has for dealing with cars that are parked illegally or that are abandoned. Currently, we can tow cars that have been parked illegally for 72 hours.

4:35:52 This bill, the language is kind of fluctuating a little bit, but in its current form, it would say that we have to put a notice on a car saying we may tow you, then we have to wait 10 business days, then and only then can we have something towed. So you're looking at having something parked in a bad spot for a couple weeks before we can remove it. It's a weird bill. And it used to be that you could tow a car, actually currently is that you can tow a car if they have five or more unpaid parking tickets, this would take that away.

4:36:22 So the rationale behind the bill is some people think that the ability of law enforcement to have cars towed is hurting the poor or hurting people that might not have good title to the car or might not be in this country legally. And that's the aim. But I think that from a local government perspective, this is a bad bill. It's going to result in a lot more abandoned and illegally parked cars.

4:36:48 I don't know, Chief, if you have anything to add, but that's the view from where we sit. And I can just, the comment is, too, is we, every year, especially after a good winter, we go through, I forget how many cars we ended up siding this year, but I think it was pushing, I want to say 100, Chief, but that might have been two years ago. But to have to not be able to move quickly and have them sit for an extra, you know, two weeks, basically, really impacts the process a little bit. Yeah, two years ago, we had

4:37:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

4:37:43 Twofold, and I understand that the thought process behind it, that they, you know, think we unduly, you know, go after, you know, the lesser, folks with lesser ability economically to pay for things, but that's not really the case. We're just trying to get compliance and also try to keep the town cleaned up. Okay, thank you for that. Questions from Council? I have no questions. Okay.

4:38:08 Thank you for this being on the agenda. Thank you, Chief, for your thoughts on that. At this point, do we... I'll make a motion to approve the letter opposing AB 516. Do I need to put it out to public comment or are we done with that? Okay, public comment on this? Okay, seeing no public comment, I'm entertained. Okay, motion, second. Did you get that motion? Okay, good. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes.

4:38:38 Yes. Yes. Thank you very much. That passes 4-0. We are now going to go into closed session. Excuse me, Madam Mayor. I've got a personal issue come up. I wonder if I could have 10 minutes to make a quick phone call. You absolutely may. Before I make that phone call, I wonder if we could just be clear, because I know in talking with Dan, there's some juggling that wanted to happen with these items. So let me note, we'd like to take item 26 and address that, and then take item 28.

4:39:07 And then come out and do the 29, which is a policy matter which we'll need to deal in open session. Okay. And then go back into closed session for the employee negotiations. Okay. You know what? That sounds... It'll just help us with staff. So we're going to take 26, 28, go back to open session. 29, yeah. And then 29, and then go back to 27. Correct. Okie dokie. That sounds great to me. We will be in closed session within 10 minutes. Thank you very much.

4:39:59 A public comment. No, I have no doubt. Okay. Could be fun. Okay. Okay. And we are now back into open session. There is nothing to report out in our closed session. We are on policy matter item 29, authorize the town attorney to draft a rejection letter in response to the claim received from Jean Harris on May 22, 2009. Take it away.

4:40:24 Thank you, Madam Mayor. As you've indicated, we did receive a letter from Mr. Gene Harris on May 22nd of this year. He styled it as a claim, I think, because he wasn't quite sure whether there was a claim or not. He is threatening to sue the town. The gist of his claim is that he believes that the town's TOT ordinance is invalid. He believes that the formation of the T-bid was invalid. He believes the town's contract with MLT for services is invalid. And he believes that...

4:40:53 Rusty Gregory and John Urdi committed fraud. I've reviewed the claim carefully. I've written to Mr. Harris seeking clarification, got a response from Mr. Harris, and it is my opinion that there is no viable cause of action anywhere in here. I don't see the town has done anything wrong, so I would recommend that the town deny the claim. I'd recommend that the council authorize Dan or me or somebody to send a letter to Mr. Harris denying his claim.

4:41:23 So that you know that I do anticipate that we'll be sued shortly thereafter. Okay, any questions for Andy? So when you mentioned the claim, that was the letter that was received under the property damages that, that came from a town form.

4:41:44 It did. We have a form that people need to fill out in order to submit a claim. It's, I think, titled a property damage form because that's the most common type of claim that the town gets. But really, it covers anything that could be conceivably covered by the Government Claims Act. Okay. Thank you. Any more questions? No questions. I'll take it out to public comment. Seeing none, I'll bring it back for Town Council comments. Madam Mayor, if it pleases, I would.

4:42:15 Make a motion to authorize the town attorney to draft a rejection letter in response to the claim received from Jane Harris on May 22, 2019. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 4-0. Thank you very much. Now we will go back into closed session, and I will report out if we have anything to let people know after that. Thank you very much.