TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2020

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 22 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

287 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

4:26 Call to order planning an Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, February 12th, 2 p.m. We'll start with a roll call. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Present. Okay. Paul, can you lead us in the pledge of allegiance? Absolutely.

5:14 To the republic, with its name, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. At this time, I'd like to open up the public hearing, and we'll start with a presentation by staff. I think we're going to take public comments for items that are not on the agenda. Oh, okay. Sorry. Yeah, my bad. Sorry. Hello again. Hi. I'm Jenna Carter, Code Compliance for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and I just wanted to give you a report on the current cases I have open.

5:47 We have 22 current open cases and half of those, 10 of them are for signs. Two weeks ago we did a town-wide banner sweep and found at least 10 illegal banners and two of which have immediately complied. So we're working on the other eight still and that is it. Thank you. Thank you. I'm sorry, I just have a quick question. Yes. What does that mean when you say banner?

6:16 Don't they, each store have their own? There's like the sign ordinance in town and the banners are actually prohibited in that sign ordinance. So they can have like solid signs, you know, like part of, I don't know, example. So they'll have separate signs outside of their store. Yeah, like some people are having like live music banner or a reservation company will have one out that says free Snow Creek Pass. It's like in addition to their monument sign, their real sign.

6:43 And they're not allowed to have? Correct. Yeah, the sign ordinance prohibits that. Got it. There are two types that are allowed, like a grand opening banner, if applied for and permitted, and that's allowed for 30 days of a grand opening. And then the across-the-street banners, you know, the ones in front of Footloose that show, like, community events, those are allowed. But those are done by municipality? They're applied for through the municipality, through the town, yes. Oh, okay. Yeah.

7:13 Thank you. Yeah, thank you. Any other public comments that's not on the agenda? Okay, moving on. We'll start with a statement from staff. Nolan, will you be giving the presentation? Oh, I'm sorry. Consider recommending to the town. I'm sorry. Item number one, consider recommending to the town council approval of general.

7:46 Plan Amendment 19-002 and zoning code amendment 19-002 to adopt the town density program bonus update. Do you want me to continue all of that? And adoption of the addendum to the 2016 general plan land use element zoning code amendments and mobility element update program environmental impact staff report. All of it. Thank you. Great. Thank you.

8:19 So this is the Planning and Economic Development Commission public hearing to consider the proposed changes to the town density bonus program. The project consists of general plan and zoning code amendments, and those numbers are general plan amendment 19-002 and zoning code amendment 19-002. Sandra is just handing out, there were a few last minute revisions to the

8:48 Policy and resolution that the town attorney recommended. So I'll walk through those changes at the end of my presentation just highlighting what those were. They're really just kind of minor text changes in the document. So the proposed amendments would revise the existing program to allow for it to be applied separately from the state program, reduce the eligible project size from projects with a minimum base density of five units to projects with a minimum base density of two units.

9:17 Not require all units be restricted to workforce housing, and develop regulations and policies to implement the program. Currently, there are two density bonus programs available. The state's density bonus program is state mandated and allows eligible projects up to a 35% density bonus. The current town density bonus program allows a density bonus in addition to the state program.

9:44 Allows up to a combined double density and currently reads as follows. For housing development projects where all units are deed restricted for workforce housing, a density bonus may be granted in addition to any bonus granted pursuant to the state density bonus law up to a combined bonus of twice the density identified for the designation in which the project is located. That currently is the entire program, so it really doesn't define how to use the program or allow much flexibility in its application.

10:12 Historically, there has been low usage of either program. The last project approved with the town density bonus program was in 2011 for the Star Apartments, which was a CDBG grant subsidized project. The last private development project to utilize the town density bonus was in 2004. Some challenges and limitations of either program include the state density bonus requires a minimum parcel size that allows five or more units.

10:42 It's been identified as being overly restrictive by requiring 100% of the units be restricted to workforce housing. Also, by considering it to be in addition to the state density bonus, it limits how many parcels or projects could utilize it. Also, we have a limited availability of vacant multifamily zoned land within the town. And the process for using the density bonus is unclear.

11:12 For the Town Density Bonus Program to be successful at increasing the supply of workforce housing, some goals have been identified. Kind of the underlying goals include reducing the barriers that may disincentivize workforce housing development, improving the process for processing density bonus applications, ensuring the local housing regulations align with the applicable goals of the housing element and the Community Housing Action Plan.

11:39 The proposed amendments support the goals of the housing element and the community housing action plan and implement various action items from both documents. The current town density bonus program was adopted in 2007 as part of the general plan update. As noted earlier, it has not been well utilized. As a result of this, the town began working on an update to the town density bonus program in fall of 2019. In December of 2019, the commission and the town council

12:10 There's workshops held with both bodies to discuss the proposed program. Both bodies were presented with a series or seven discussion topics and feedback and comment on those topics were then incorporated into the proposed program update. The draft program was presented to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors this previous Monday and the board did provide a comment letter that was sent out to the commission yesterday. So currently we're at the public hearing for the commission.

12:40 Following today's meeting and depending on the outcome, it would next move forward to the Town Council for consideration in early March. So as noted, the MLH Board of Directors provided a comment letter on the proposed density bonus program. Their comment letter was formatted to address the seven discussion topics that were presented at the workshops and they also provided a few additional recommendations.

13:13 Items shown on white in the screen are those where they support the program as written, and those in red are areas where they had recommended changes or other items included. So they supported the proposed format of the density bonus program to award points in exchange for de-restricting a percentage of the base density units. They supported reducing the minimum project size to two units. They supported having an incentive program

13:39 They, however, did encourage in their letter to allow for reduced parking ratios for all the units and to include for the incentive related to the reduction in guest parking spaces to indicate that a minimum of one guest parking space would be reduced regardless of the percentage calculation. They supported allowing developers the option to select which program they used. They supported the prohibition on nightly rentals for all units.

14:09 They were not supportive of the use permit requirement and recommended that we only require a use permit if the project's requesting more than one concession. They supported the one-year review period of the program. An additional recommendation was to require projects meet the livability standards outlined in Municipal Code Section 17.136.120, in addition to the amending and design standards. That section has minimum size

14:38 Size requirements based on the size of the unit. So for studio one, two, three, or four bedrooms. And I have a slide later that goes into what those additional requirements are. And they also recommend including processes for monitoring of the deed restricted units. So moving forward, just kind of an overview of the proposed town density bonus program. This is...

15:04 Very similar to what was presented at the workshop with just a few refinements as far as what concessions are available to projects as well as just how the program would be implemented. So the program would be based on earning points that reflect the size of the density bonus requested. Points are earned by providing workforce housing. These can be either income restricted or occupancy restricted. The larger the density bonus, the more workforce housing that a project is required to provide.

15:33 So just a quick sample project. This would be a six-unit project on a .33 acre site. So under the current density, they'd only be allowed to build four units. So they're requesting two units of a two-unit density bonus. So they're requesting six units when it's allowed four. Under this program, they would be required to earn what's called 50 eligibility points.

15:59 Those points would then be put into the eligibility point schedule, which dictates the percentage of base density units that they would have to deed restrict based on which income level they decide to go with. So they would be required to provide just deed restricted units on one income category, so they're low income, moderate, middle, or occupancy restricted. And so for the sample project to get 50 points,

16:28 They'd be required to either provide two units restricted to low income, two units restricted to moderate income, two units restricted to middle income, or three units restricted to what we're calling occupancy restricted. So that's where it's just they are required to work within Mono or Inyo County and use the unit as their primary or principal place of residence. Using this process, the amount of deed restricted units would go up as the project size increases.

16:57 However, for a smaller project, there's not much variability in the number of deed restricted units. At the end of my presentation, I have a calculator that I prepared that you simply put in the parcel size with the number of units requested and it kicks out how many units they'd have to deed restrict. So there's some additional program information. Eligible projects include new or rehabilitated multifamily projects with a base density of two units or more.

17:25 Projects are only eligible for one density bonus program, meaning they can only utilize either the state or the town density bonus and not both. Projects are still subject to the housing mitigation requirements in Municipal Code 17.136. So in some cases, projects could satisfy their mitigation if they were to deed restrict units to either a low or moderate level, but if they're just coming in as a middle income or occupancy restricted, then they would still have to

17:54 Satisfy their housing mitigation in another way, which could be through the payment of in lieu fees. They're also subject, the whole program will be subject to periodic review, with the initial review period set at one year from the date of adoption. Additionally, based on the feedback at the workshops, transient rentals would be prohibited for all the units within a project that receives a town density bonus.

18:19 A workforce housing agreement is required for all projects requesting the density bonus. The agreement would outline the requirements of the subsequent deed restrictions and identify the specific criteria for qualifying for the deed restriction in order to qualify. So going on to some of the items that are going to be open for discussion with the commission as well as addressing some of the comments made from the MLH board.

18:50 The town is recommending requiring a use permit for all projects requesting a density bonus through the town program. The rationale is that staff feels it is important to provide the community the opportunity to provide comments on a project through the public hearing process. However, with the understanding that it is the goal of the town to increase the supply of workforce housing throughout the community, and so there will be a heavy emphasis on granting the use permit.

19:17 Under certain conditions that the project won't have an impact on neighboring uses. Additional research done by staff since the workshop also indicated that the majority of jurisdictions that have a local density bonus program do require a use permit. The proposed program includes a built-in exemption to the use permit requirement for projects that qualify or that are eligible for Senate Bill 35.

19:44 Streamlining, Senate Bill 35 is a state senate bill that is intended to streamline eligible multifamily projects that meet certain criteria. It would require or allow the following. So it requires a commitment to deed restrict a minimum of 50% of the base density units to low income households. So those are households earning 80% AMI or below.

20:09 Under SB 35 allows for no parking to be required if within a half mile of public transit or one space per unit if further than a half mile from public transit. It does require consistency with what the state calls objective zoning subdivision and design review standards. So they define an objective standard as something that's easily understood by the public. So that could be such thing as a front yard setback of 20 feet would be an objective standard.

20:36 Where a subjective standard is something that would say the colors shall complement the neighboring land uses. That would be an example of a subjective standard. It also requires prevailing wage if the project is more than 10 units. So there are a few projects in town that could benefit from the SB35 exemption, including the Mono County Davidson project. Going on to the proposed concessions and incentives.

21:07 Though the format of the program is similar to what's offered by the state density bonus program, projects are eligible for a minimum of one concession and can request additional concessions if they agree to deed restrict additional units or agree to a longer term for the deed restriction to receive the additional concessions. As written, the proposed concessions include an increase in lot coverage,

21:31 Reduction in setbacks, reduction in guest parking spaces, an increase in the maximum permitted structure height, a reduction in the development and operation standards for multifamily projects. And the last one is taken directly from the state density bonus program, which is an approval of mixed use zoning in an area not otherwise allowed. So a project could select any one of those concessions as part of their project proposal.

21:57 However, the findings for the use permit do require finding that the requested concession is the minimum departure necessary for the project. Also, we included projects granted a town density bonus would be permitted to haul their snow off-site. This is similar to what's allowed for commercial projects, with the exception that these projects cannot store their snow on an interim basis in any required parking areas.

22:27 Let's touch on the livability standards. This is in response to the MLH Board of Directors letter. Currently, as written, the program requires projects to comply with the amenity and design standards. So these address the features within the unit, such as adequate kitchen facilities, adequate or provision of a certain amount of private storage space, more on how the units design.

22:53 Where the livability standards in the municipal code address the distribution of units and the size of units. And really are intended to, in this case, or at least in the case of the municipal code, is that the mitigation units would...

23:09 be similar in size and features as the market rate units. So if it was the recommendation of the commission to include these as requirements, we could include that in the resolution that projects comply with these livability standards and the amenity and design standards. And lastly, just to touch on the monitoring.

23:33 So the Workforce Housing Agreement and the deed restrictions would be required for all units. And within the provisions of that, it would outline the responsibility for monitoring either the town or its designee. And so, again, if it's the desire of the commission, we could include some additional process or additional requirements in the policy for how the town will monitor these units on a long-term basis. But it is already assumed that the town would be monitoring these into the future.

24:04 Excuse me. Can I have a quick question real quick? Just for clarification. The annual evaluation that we're planning on doing to see if this is working, does that count as evaluating? So the annual kind of review by the town with the commission, the town council would be looking at more just is the program effective as it's written or do we need tweaks and say, you know, reduce or increase the percentages?

24:35 Okay, thank you, sorry.

25:01 So staff has determined that the project does comply with all the requirements of CEQA and municipal code and the general plan. Under CEQA, an addendum to the 2016 general plan EIR was prepared, which demonstrated that no increase in impacts and no new impacts would occur as a result of the project. And all the required findings for general plan and zoning amendment can be made as outlined in the resolution.

25:28 So with that, staff's recommendation is that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the resolution recommending to the Town Council consideration of the addendum to the 2016 General Plan Program EIR and adoption of the required CEQA findings, adopt the required Municipal Code findings, approve General Plan Amendment 19-002 as recommended by staff.

25:52 approve zoning code amendment 19-002 as recommended by staff, and approve the town density bonus program policy. As noted at the beginning, a few last minute changes were made to the resolution, or as far as the code changes, the specific changes that were made were under section 17.138.020. It was revised to clarify that town

26:21 The town density bonuses granted, pursuant to the town program, are only available for projects that do not use the state program. Essentially, there's just some wordsmithing to not, before it said projects are just not eligible for the state program, where this says it's only available to projects that do not utilize it, kind of a legal determination.

26:48 Also requiring a written waiver of any rights granted under the state density bonus law. So again, that's just the applicant acknowledging that they're not going to request any state density bonus. Clarifying. Can you reset the resolution number? Sure. So it was 17. Oh, yeah. So that's the, it's within exhibit C of the resolution. It would be page.

27:21 Yes, in the new document. It would be on page 38 as the first change, item B. So again, just clarifying that it's essentially saying the same thing, that state density bonus is not available for these projects. There's just wordsmithing how it was written. And then section 17.138.030.E.2H.

27:55 So that's on page 30 or on page 40. We'll just be requiring a written waiver from the applicant acknowledging they're not going to use the state density bonus or waiving any of their rights under the state density bonus if they're pursuing a town density bonus. And then item G on that same page for where transit rentals are prohibited, just adding the last sentence which

28:22 Clarifies that a deed restriction prohibiting transient rentals will be a condition. And then the next change was in section 050D. That's on page 42 for snow storage, including language that a recorded agreement is required for the onsite hauling of snow. That's similar to what we currently require for commercial projects.

28:51 Then the last change is 17.138.060B2 on page 43. And that was that the deed restriction is to the satisfaction of the town. So just to clarify that the applicant can... At the very top under item 2, the last sentence, just stating that the deed restriction shall be to the satisfaction of the town.

29:22 to clarify that the applicant cannot write their own deed restriction. So that's all the changes that were since the packet was printed. With that, I'll turn it over to the commission for any questions. Do you want us to go through each of those items separately and ask questions or discuss them, or do you want us to talk about it as a whole? I think it kind of depends on how many questions you think you all have, whether there's

29:52 Lots of questions on each component or whether the commissioners think that they would rather talk about it as a whole, maybe at the pleasure of the commission. What would you guys feel talking about as a whole? I think talking about it as a whole works. I don't have any questions. So at this time I'll open it up to the commission for questions. Greg, would you like to go first? I had a couple. When we say it's going to be workforce housing and there's going to be an agreement,

30:22 I assume there's something in there about so many hours worked or how do we decide who's workforce and who's not? Sure. So in the policy, so that's exhibit D to the resolution. We talk about there what's considered a qualified resident and so that's dictating how many hours they need to work and that the, what's considered a business under that criteria and that the business is located within Mona or Inyo County.

30:52 So under this program, it's an average of 30 hours or more per week as written. And if somebody's been in the local workforce under those criteria for 20 years and they retire, is there some grandfathering in that they can apply for? Yes, so under this, it also does allow for retirees to occupy these units as far as the kind of

31:18 Priority goes, it would go to someone who's employed, then to someone who's just living within the region, and then it's opened up to anyone, because we can't just restrict these only to those, so it has to kind of follow a priority program, and that second option would be then available to those who have retired that are still living within the region. But if they had been living in this housing for a period of time and retired, would they get bumped? No, they would not. Is that in this document somewhere?

31:47 So I believe it outlines that in the policy as far as you're not seeing that. So that could be something we could add within the qualified resident is that defined if it's a retiree that they're still eligible to then occupy it. Because that was the intent, yes. So it would be the town or a designee, which oftentimes could be Mammoth Lakes Housing.

32:32 As our NGO monitor a lot of the other deed restrictions in town. And so as part of an application for a new unit, they have a whole application packet that determines that it's a qualified occupant based on the criteria and the guidelines. And does it get validated or verified annually? Then on an annual basis, that's part of that long-term monitoring. They send out a letter to the tenants and they have to provide

33:01 Either income qualifications, if it's an income restricted unit, or just evidence that they're still employed within the region and using the place as their principal place of residence. Does MLH currently do that? They do, yes. So this responsibility currently, it's carried by MLH, not the town? It's carried by both. So there's units that are currently monitored by the town and units that are currently monitored by MLH.

33:30 Is one of the goals, at least with the, is to transfer all monitoring over to MLH at some point for all the units. The code about, for projects with more than 10 units, they're required to pay prevailing wages. That's, is that the SB 35 requirement? That's an SB 35. No, it's not the town requirement. That's a Senate Bill 35 requirement. So any eligible project,

34:05 Of 10 units or more has to do prevailing wage and then there's an additional requirement for projects of 50 or more. Can you explain a little bit about the math behind this? So let's say, well first of all, when you say base density, you're talking about, so let's say by right a specific property can have five units but it only currently has one unit building.

34:35 One building, a single family home on it. So is that base density talking about that one unit or is it talking about that by right they can actually have five units there? So it's talking about the by right. It's based on just the size of the parcel, not what's existing on the parcel. Okay. So let's say they have five units currently and they want to exercise town.

35:05 Bonus density. So they want to build 10. So current code says the remaining five, the additional five units, that all have to be workforce housing. Am I correct? So in a case of that, I'm just trying to think of a parcel size where it would be five. So let's say it's point

35:36 So that's a good guess. A .4 acre parcel would have a base density of 5 units. I can zoom in here. And then let's say they wanted to go to, you said 10 units? Sure. So double their density. Because that's what they're allowed to do, right? So that's what they'd be allowed to do. So in the case of this, they would then be required to, of those 10 total units, kind of irregardless of what's currently there, deed restrict.

36:09 To one of these income level this many units. So if they wanted to get to 10 and deed restrict, they could deed restrict three of the units to low income. That could be the existing or the new. Or on the high end, deed restrict five units to occupancy restricted. So they could deed restrict the existing five and construct five unrestricted units or keep the existing five and deed restrict the five new units. That's based on the chart, yeah. So all this is, whoops.

36:40 Using that same chart that was in the PowerPoint, just doing the math automatically for you in this calculator or in this scenario. So in that scenario, if there's a five plex and they want to add five more units, they could, without having any income restriction on the property, they could put the current five units restricted as workforce housing and the new five

37:09 Would have no restriction on them at all. That's correct. And the occupancy restricted is what we're calling workforce housing. Correct. Workforce housing has kind of encompassed the whole program because the definition for workforce housing doesn't define the affordability level. It just defines it as housing that's intended for the workforce in Mammoth Lakes. And so under this scenario, kind of to elaborate a little on Commissioner Chang and Commissioner Ecker's comment, though,

37:41 If those existing five units did have an existing deed restriction or some other covenant, they'd have to maintain that minimum. They couldn't reduce the number or whatever affordability is on those existing units. That is outlined in the code as well. They wouldn't necessarily be required to de-restrict additional units, but they couldn't eliminate any existing... They cannot eliminate, but they can use that as part of their... They could, yes. ...requirement for de-restricted or workforce housing units. Yes.

38:13 Can I piggyback off that for a second? Sure, yeah. Would those five units that are not deed restricted, are those open for nightly rentals or all of them? No, as written, if they're in a zone that allows nightly rentals, all units would be prohibited from nightly rentals regardless of the occupancy or income restriction. Okay. So that would be kind of a separate restriction on those just for the benefit of getting the density bonus. Okay.

38:43 Is there a way we can, with all the Airbnbs and the workforce condos that have been taken off the workforce market, so to speak, is there any way that we can try and, I don't want to use the word bounty, but pay people for a deed restriction to where their unit would be workforce restricted?

39:10 There is. We have, as staff, looked at a number of programs that other jurisdictions have done. One example is a program called the Vail Indeed program, which is doing that exact thing. They're going to short-term rental owners and negotiating a payment to remove their unit from short-term rental and keep it as a long-term.

39:36 Unit for a specified period of time. That would be kind of a separate work program from this program, but it is something that staff is looking into. On page 8 of your staff report of the PDF document, you talked about one of the definitions of how you define concessions. That includes a reduction or elimination of one of the multifamily residential development.

40:10 and operational standards. I don't understand what that means. Sure. So I will pull up the municipal code here real quick. What does that mean, reducing or eliminating one of the multifamily residential development? So in that section, there's a series of standards that all multifamily projects have to adhere to. So I'm going to pull those up to show. And so then through this, they could choose to eliminate

40:45 One of, I think there's about six standards listed in that code section. That's what the operational standards, that's what you're referring to here? Yes. It's one of the six items in the municode? Yes. In this particular section of the code, right? Right, in this particular section, right. It's right there. Yeah, so it's, I'm being friendly for viewing here.

41:31 Those standards address such thing as front yard paving, laundry facilities, private open space, maintenance and control of common area, outdoor lighting. There's a variety of items in here. So the ones that we could see they would request a reduction of would say either the private outdoor open space or the common area. Different ones on that is the intent of that. They could request reduction or elimination of one of those standards, but not all of them.

42:00 So to clarify on that, could you go back to the slide on the Mammoth Lakes housing letter, how you were comparing the red and the white fonts? And along those lines, just to clarify, if a property is not requesting a density bonus, they don't need a use permit? Yes, that's correct. So a multifamily residential project would not currently require a use permit.

42:41 Gotcha. Okay. And so that's what MLH was saying that they think we should eliminate that for this and keep it kind of standard, that this would be treated as a regular multifamily unit would not have a use permit. Is that correct? I think the real issue is the density bonus. So regardless of the...

43:01 The affordable, I mean, it is affordable housing, but I think really our concern and recommendation regarding the use permit is related to the fact that this is additional density, could be double density next to projects. And we talked about this a little bit in December at our workshop, but projects who we were expecting maybe 30 units next door are now having 60 units next door. So just that kind of public, bringing this forward to the public and allowing them to have, to be able to comment on it. Really, really. This is not all affordable housing.

43:31 The additional density doesn't account for. They're not all considered affordable housing. Some of them are going to be market rate. Can you remind me what the use permit process looks like then? Just so I can understand how cumbersome it is. So really the use permit process allows us to kind of analyze more than just the design of the site or the building it's looking at. Is that

44:03 The proposed use, so in this case, a multifamily residential project, say with a density up to 24 units, compatible with the neighboring uses, is it compatible with the neighborhood, so the streets, the location, the site itself, you know, is there any unique challenges to that site that wouldn't necessarily be identified through the design review process, and then also it allows us to impose kind of long-term conditions.

44:31 on the project. So with design review, any conditions you impose are really executed at the time the project's built. Where with a use permit, those can be ongoing conditions that we can impose or enforce for the life of the project. Under the density bonus, the deed restriction is kind of a unique one in that that gets imposed for the term that's specified in the deed restriction and it gets recorded on title.

45:00 So that's not really a condition of approval that would be enforced long term since that's really enforced through the title on the property. But other ones that can be enforced would be parking, trash, just the overall appearance and kind of maintenance of the site, how they're interacting or just being compatible with the neighborhood. So that's more what would be imposed under a use permit. Gotcha. And is the use permit...

45:27 Does that come to us? Is it public hearing type thing? Does it typically take a few months? It does require public hearing, so it does come to the commission. It is noticed then to all neighbors within 300 feet of the property, and also there's a notice in the newspaper where a design review, if it's a project of five units or more, would come to the commission as a major design review, but it's not noticed to the neighbors, so it's just an administrative hearing.

45:56 And really then all the commission is tasked at looking at under design review is just the site design and the building design. So the colors, materials, masking of the building. And so this is similar to the Mammoth Hotel project that you considered, I think, in November. And you had public comment from neighbors who...

46:14 Weren't really kind of the base, the issue was they didn't want the use, that hotel use next door. They were concerned about blocking their views and those types of things. So really when you're looking at the design review, you're really just looking at design. Does it meet the design requirements? You're not looking at whether or not this use is compatible. The code assumes the use is compatible, so no use permit is required. So that's kind of the bottom, I guess the crux of the discussion of use permit or not, is are double density projects just generally compatible with adjacent?

46:42 projects. And so, I mean, that's kind of, I think when you're thinking about the use permit, you can think about it that way. I think that there's certainly arguments to be made for making this a quicker process for affordable housing, things that we want in town, but I think we're kind of looking at it from a code perspective about what the kind of rationale is for requiring a use permit. And the specific exemption included for the SB 35, that is intended to make

47:12 You know, streamline those projects that are getting those low-income household units, which are harder for a developer to make feasible just on their own. So we can incentivize that further, and that's also the state's intention with the SB35, and that's kind of their goal is to, how do we get these harder to achieve units? How do we make it easier to build those? That was actually my next question. Could you describe what that, I understand the conditions for it to be the streamlined process, but what does the streamlined process actually look like?

47:40 So the streamline process is they're only subject to what's identified as objective. So the town has identified or gone through our design guidelines and have basically made the determination that none of the design guidelines are subjective because they really are more...

47:57 The colors complement neighboring uses, materials are compatible or consistent with materials in Mammoth Lakes. So a project that's eligible for SB35 would be exempt from the use permit and from design review. At least with the design review, the town really has no authority to go back and say, yes, you have to apply with these subjective standards. So in that case, we have a form that basically the

48:24 The property owner acknowledges that their project meets all the eligibility requirements and commits to deed restricting the required 50% of the units to low income, commits to the prevailing wage requirements if applicable, and then it would just be submittal of a building permit where then we look at still compliance with at least the objective zoning code, same as any other regular building permit. Perfect, thank you. So in that case it would eliminate

48:54 The kind of the discretionary review. And also, since the state identifies it as a ministerial project then, it's exempt from CEQA as well. Thank you. Any other questions? I'm not sure if we would apply here or not, but so there are floating around out there housing credits that are owned by different developers, and those are transferable, right? Yes. Okay. So if, like this project we were talking about earlier where somebody was going to

49:24 Go in and put five more units where five had been. The five new ones or the five old ones, half of them would have to be deed restricted. If they were to deed restrict all of them so that we're getting a net gain of five more, would those restrictions be transferable? In other words, could a developer buy those? And the biggest problem with building anything here is the cost. We're trying to beat the administrative side of it, but it's still money.

49:54 So if they were to go 100% instead of 50% and could then sell those credits, that might get something coming up out of the ground. And this question came up, I think, at your workshop as well, and I think kind of we thought through it, and I think they could generate credits for that. The code allows for credits to be generated under our current requirements, so unless something changed about the credits, they could do that.

50:25 The code actually allows something, something like the scenario that you just talked about, that would actually work? Right. I mean, I think that the code, when these credits, this whole kind of credit idea was brought forward long, I think, before I was here, I think the idea is it encourages allowing developers to put, I guess, establish credits, encourages the building of the affordable housing maybe sooner than it would.

50:53 Before. So what we saw with Interwest is they built a bunch of affordable housing in advance of the projects that were needing that housing. And then the market fell out. So we've had all of this housing on the books and operating for years where that...

51:09 The drawdown hasn't actually occurred on paper. So clearly things in the community, it's different. We're in a housing crisis now, but I think on paper those projects have credits that they can use now. So I think that they would be able to do that, this five-unit project or something along those lines. I don't think there's any provisions that talk about a minimum number of units to get the credit. So mathematically speaking, using his scenario,

51:39 Next developer comes in, want to build, so that let's say they have five, they want to build ten, they want to build five more, so that credit gets carried, and that person, that new developer wants to have, apply for, you know, apply for density bonus to build that five additional units. We're saying that that credit gets transferred to him, so then none of his units then become

52:11 Workforce Housing. Well, that's the thing. Then the credits, you would, so they still have to meet the minimum standards of the density bonus. So if five, if it's a 10 unit project and we're requiring them to deed restrict five and they deed restrict 10 and then they sell those deed restrictions or sell those credits, I think those credits would go away from that project. So they would still have to have those minimum five. Now we haven't kind of like walked through this whole scenario, you know, together, Nolan and I, but that's how I would see it is that then that project would

52:41 Remain with its minimum deed restrictions required, and it would be kind of done. Does that make sense? As long as we're not taking, as long as we're not giving them a deed restriction, and we're not giving them a density bonus for something that wouldn't remain on the site, I think it's reasonable to allow them to build more, and I think that question came from... I'm just wondering, would that particular scenario, does that then reduce...

53:12 The number of workforce housing in the future, you know, by allowing that scenario to happen. It should accelerate their production. Well, you accelerate production only on a market product, market rate product. No, because you're taking units that are current market and restricting them. And that's what you're actually selling. So maybe I misspoke. Maybe the...

53:39 I thought by selling it, that means that you have to comply to that. Right, and the deed restrictions. Because I'm paying for it. You know, I just, you know, this is a monetary. Right. So those deed restricted units would then remain on that site. So I think I misspoke. On the used site or the old site? The old site. Yeah, so if you're going to build 10 units, you're only required to build five. You take that credit of five units. Those 10 units have to stay.

54:04 In perpetuity or as long as those deed restrictions are required. So you can take your five units and sell them, but they remain at that site. Does that make sense? I think so, yes. You're selling the deed restriction. Right, you're selling the deed restriction. The problem is the new developer does not have to have any de-restricted units, first of all. Right. And number two, out of the first ten that the first developer developed,

54:32 Five have been restricted. The other five is market rate. No, all ten of them would have to be restricted for this to work. Right. You would have to restrict your existing five plus the new five. But that's assuming that you can actually ask those tenants to leave and then lower their rent. I think there's a lot of...

54:52 Unknowns in this scenario. I think if a developer wanted to build additional units to, so they're new units, right? So if the developer wanted to do this type of thing to earn credits, we would want to know that in the beginning of the process and kind of talk through how that could occur. And potentially under the system as developed where under the concessions it talks about an alternative concession or incentive not necessarily specified.

55:20 So that could be something that could come up more in that negotiation for that alternative is that they agreed to say deed restrict 100% of their units to low income with the option that they could sell those additional restrictions in the future. That could be their alternative concession that's reviewed by the review authority and by staff. I think it just depends on the mechanics of it because you're saying that now the first development, all 10 of them is going to be deed restricted.

55:49 But that's not necessarily, I mean, you're assuming that those five other market rate automatically reduce their rent or... Well, if they're new units, then, and their intent is to sell them, I think that would all be done as they are filling those units. Yeah, I don't think it could be done as a later proposal. I think it would have to be in the upfront kind of...

56:19 proposal that's saying we want to do this and then we would analyze it to see, you know, A, how it can be implemented and then B, what conditions or long-term conditions or would have to be included in the deed restriction or the workforce housing agreement to ensure that it's maintained. Can an existing market rate property self-deed restrict and generate a credit that can be transferred?

56:52 I think the answer is yes. Yeah, I mean, I don't see a reason, I suppose, why they couldn't come to us and saying, we want to voluntarily put this on our property, here's how it's going to work, and here's how, you know, the existing, it's either vacant or existing tenants qualify. Well, they wouldn't do it unless they could sell it. Right. Right. There has to be a market for it. There has to be a reason. Can I ask a question? We're going to open it up to public comment in just a second. Well, I think related to this one,

57:25 Supervisor Crete's would have some, because they have actually, I think at the workshop kind of talked about too on their Mono County project, this exact scenario. Okay, go for it. Well, I just wonder, the question hasn't been asked and it's not clear to me, if you're selling those credits hypothetically, which is permissible currently, you're potentially selling them to somebody who needs to provide housing for as mitigation, right?

57:55 Who would be interested in these? Does the mitigation policy have requirements on unit size? Or is it just a general unit? And so the unit could be 460 square feet or it could be 1,200 square feet. Could you clarify that? So mitigation unit under the code is required to meet the livability standards. That's based on the bedroom size. So either studio, one bedroom, two, three or four bedroom has.

58:24 Minimum sizes for each of those. But it doesn't have a criteria that says you can only sell a two-bedroom unit or a four-bedroom unit. Okay. Well, this is an argument to link the livability standards. If you're selling these credits from these density bonus units and not tying livability, but you're selling them to somebody who would be required to meet livability, then you would want those two to align, I would think. Thanks.

58:52 And it does talk about in the code under the housing mitigation required under credits. I guess it says the credit for the provision of housing mitigation above that required by this chapter shall be determined by the director. I think there is some provision to allow, you know, as we work through these kind of odd situations to kind of, it differs to the director to allow us to walk through those.

59:24 But there's no definitive guidelines as to how the process will work. There is. I mean, we have a section in our code that talks about ways to provide affordable housing. So there's a clear section in our code that kind of talks about there's different options for if you're generating a housing impact, you can either pay a fee, you can provide units, you can kind of do all of these different things.

59:52 using those credits is we brought forward a policy, a conversion, I think, I don't know, last summer maybe, to show, there's all these credits on the books, and I don't know if you recall, we kind of talked about the InterWest credits, the Snow Creek credits, and so we put together a policy to show how those credits translate into the fee, because at this point, most of our developers are paying that fee, so if they're paying that fee and they have these credits, that's how

1:00:20 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:00:50 Requirements in the mitigation unit are either ones that are restricted to low income households or moderate income. And then that chapter 17.136 talks about if you go above and beyond what your mitigation requirements are so that can include the density bonus, those additional credits do have a value based on that policy that Sandra just mentioned that got adopted by council. So it calculates kind of backwards from the unit and assigns

1:01:20 It signs it as FTEE credits, so it's full-time employee equivalent credits, rather than a dollar value, because the whole calculation on that policy uses development costs, uses what the current housing fee is to then take those credits and convert it to a dollar based on current value in the code. So that's low income to 80%.

1:01:51 So it's 80% to 120% AMI. Units could be, if they were to say, you know, come in, deed restrict, 100% of their units to low income. We would look at that and say, okay, you know, you satisfied your housing mitigation because you've restricted, you know, all the units are restricted to one of the income levels qualifying that separate housing chapter. Then also you've gone above.

1:02:19 Where you're required to as far as your mitigation so you have an excess credit for how many mitigation units you have there. So it's not discussed in the town density bonus chapter. It's really discussed in the mitigation because it's only for units that could be considered as mitigation units that they could do that. But the occupancy requirement gives you no mitigation units? No. So those units, you couldn't come in and say I'm going to de-destrict 100% of my units to occupancy and then I want to sell that to...

1:02:46 The future project to get their density bonus. That currently would not be allowed. And we haven't had this case in the past. In the past, the credits have been generated by the person who was going to use those credits. So it has never been this kind of business kind of mindset of trying to create the units to then sell them on the market. So you can take that. I was going to say for the record, it's in 17.136.

1:03:17 050 talks about if you're providing additional mitigation units beyond what's required, talks about how that calculates back into a credit. You had the chart earlier that shows the minimum square footage. That's part of SB35's requirement, right? You're talking about units. Unimas, there you go. Yeah, here.

1:03:49 So these are currently in our code. They're in Chapter 17.136. These are the, if you're providing a mitigation unit, your units are required to meet these minimum standards for unit size and to encourage that market rate and mitigation units are comparable in size so that you're not coming in and building all four-bedroom units and then your mitigation are studios or vice versa. So right now,

1:04:14 The town density bonus policy does not require compliance with this section because as written, this section is kind of intended only to apply to what mitigation units. And so the MLH's recommendation was to include the amenity and design standards as well as these minimum unit size requirements as well for the units that are being under the town density bonus. But that's not part of the recommendation though.

1:04:41 Not as written. That's something that if the commission's desire, we could include as a modification in what is being recommended to town council. One last question. I'm sorry. Last, you know, past couple days we've been talking about de-restricted properties, given that the, and we talked about this here previously as well, that if we pass this now, but we currently really don't,

1:05:15 Maybe I'm incorrect on this. I don't think we have an actual procedure or guidelines as to how to prevent the town not lose those de-restricted units like we have in the past. So if we pass this now, how do we avoid that? If we don't have a specific set of guidelines and process,

1:05:48 to make certain that we don't lose those units. And how do we have language in the, I don't know, agreement right before you record to make certain that the banks would notify us, the town, to make certain that we know of the situation before they foreclose on property? Sure. So all the current deed restrictions do have language that discuss

1:06:21 Ongoing monitoring and what happens if you essentially violate the deed restriction. The current more updated deed restrictions have I think even more specific language that's included in that deed restriction that talks about first right of refusal, what happens if it's a deed restriction or foreclosure, and a variety of other items.

1:06:44 addressed in the deed restrictions that get recorded on titles. That's not something that's neglected in that. But a lot of that notification could be a loss in the mail or... I mean, some of it is, you know, completely kind of outside of our purview, like to the maximum extent possible, the deed restrictions to remain through foreclosure, but it doesn't always. There's definitely cases where, you know, the banks come in and say, you know...

1:07:12 It's not subject to this or not part of this. Some of it's a negotiation up front with the property owner as far as where it sits on title as far as priority goes. But in any instance, whether it's an affordable unit as a mitigation unit or a unit provided under this policy, there is the risk that it could be lost either through the town refusing not having money to purchase a unit under first right of refusal.

1:07:41 Or there's always criteria for how it's been on the market and there's no eligible buyer for X amount of time, it could be removed, or there's a risk of foreclosure on some units. So there's really no 100% guarantee that the unit would survive any of those scenarios, whether it's this or just a regular mitigation unit. So most of the units that we've lost have been because there's a foreclosure, the bank wanted it paid off, and the town didn't have the money.

1:08:11 Correct, yes. There's, I don't know the section number or whatever, but there is a law in California that if you're a second lien holder, so you're behind the bank in this situation, and the owner, the buyer, defaults on the first. Whoever's in second position has the legal right to remedy that first. They have to pay the back taxes, they have to pay the back payments, but they don't have to pay it off.

1:08:42 And they are legally required to be assigned that loan by the first trustee holder. So if the town had a note for a dollar behind that first trustee, all they would have to do is bring the loan current. They wouldn't have to pay it off. And that seems like that would solve a lot of the problems. Yes, and so, and some of that will, as I said, be addressed through just the deed restrictions, which we don't write ourselves as staff. We write in consultation with the town attorney.

1:09:15 To make them as kind of defensible, as strong as they can be, you know, every deed restriction, there are scenarios where that come up that where it could go away. That necessarily wouldn't be included in the zoning code section. The zoning code section more says a deed restriction shall be recorded that meets kind of these minimum specifics than actually the legal language in that restriction is what gets put into the agreement as well as the deed restriction with the property. Any other questions?

1:09:51 We can open it up for public comment. Thank you. Jennifer Kreitz, Mono County Board of Supervisors. I want to say that on the deed restriction, since that's where you were just talking about, it's great that the policy, from what I understand, says that the developer can't write.

1:10:21 The deed restriction. That's where a lot of the deed restrictions were lost is because they weren't well crafted and they were crafted by with somebody with not the best intentions for the community in mind. So knowing that the town has the oversight to see that that's written by them or somebody they hire that's an expert in land use is really good.

1:10:48 And you don't even have to have a dollar behind it. The deed restriction itself, the way that Mammoth Lakes Housing does them now, actually has a deed of trust. It's a no cash value deed of trust, but that deed restriction can be a legal document with a deed of trust recorded and still gives you all of those rights. So you don't even have to have monetary value there. I do still think that

1:11:20 Given the possibility that these units, such as like the Davidson units, where they're going to deed restrict 100% of them because of the way the land was acquired from the county, even though they don't have to per this policy should it go forward as it's presented, that developer could sell those credits, it seems, but there's no livability standards

1:11:50 As on the screen right now. And it seems that there should be uniformity in policies. And so I would really encourage you to consider adding this as part of the policy, the density bonus policy. Also because if you're allowing somebody to build more units,

1:12:13 Wouldn't you want there to be symmetry between the market rate rental units and our workforce units? I think we do. I think we would want that. Otherwise, we're going to get smaller, lesser units likely. I mean, there's no guarantee. You're just hoping, right? And that's not really good practice and policy hope.

1:12:38 You'd want to have those assurances built in. So I, again, would go back to Mammoth Lakes Housing's suggestion and just good practice and policy that there's consistency in there in the livability standards and that we're getting market rate units and workforce units that are comparable. I also, there was one other item I wanted to hit on.

1:13:07 When you put the screen up earlier, Nolan, with the formula, the lowest income that showed up in the example that you were running for Commissioner Chang showed, yeah, 55%. That's an AMI, correct? No, it's not. 55% is just the number of base density units that would have to be restricted to low income.

1:13:36 And low income is 80% AMI? 80% AMI. Okay. So that 55% comes from the point schedule, and so that would be here at, because they have to get 100 eligibility points to go twice the density. So it's coming from this table here. Okay. And I do just want to hit on again the topic of use permit. I think it's...

1:14:05 There's arguments to and against it, obviously, and I know that this is going to be reviewed in a year, it seems like. That's the recommendation from, I think, your body as well as the town council, and I think that's a good practice. So I guess you could say either side, well...

1:14:28 We'll require it, and if it doesn't work in a year, maybe we could look at not requiring it, but the same could be said, well, maybe we don't require it, and if it becomes an issue, then we put it in place in a year. I think given the crisis situation, I might err on the side more like the state is with SB 35.

1:14:46 Let's do everything in our power to move things forward quickly and streamline it to the most degree possible. And if we find that it doesn't work in 12 months after it's adopted, well, then we could change it. But we're in a crisis now. Let's take those barriers away now and then reevaluate later. That would be my recommendation. As far as the parking policies,

1:15:13 I am concerned about parking policies. I'll talk about this to the council. I've talked about it under the parcel as well. That there's, it kind of gets back to the premise on livability standards, but that policies across the board are consistent and equitable.

1:15:34 When we have parking policies for workforce housing that say, oh, you don't need a car, but when the parking policy for higher income or no restriction housing say, well, you need your car, I think we're creating disparity in parking, and I would just encourage you as a body, maybe not necessarily just under this policy, but as you look at all policies, because you look at land use policies, to look for ways to break down

1:16:02 policies that are unequitable and disenfranchise the low income in our workforce. That's it. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Okay. Let's see. I'll close public hearing at this time and we can discuss the matter. Does anyone have any? To Jen's point, I agree that we need to try and push towards more rapid

1:16:38 Implementation of any of these things that we're all trying to get done. But the counter to it would be if I think we should keep the use permit because, you know, we're talking double density. That's going to have a big impact on the neighbors. And, you know, saying we can come back and look at it a year from now and switch it around, when something gets built in that year, it's going to be there for 40. So I think we should retain the

1:17:06 The use permit process. I agree with the idea of having units be same-same. I don't think somebody should be able to get out on the sheet just to meet their requirement. And those are kind of the points I had. To that point, I think I'm okay with MLH and Supervisor Jen's suggestion as to maybe if it's

1:17:42 one or less concession, you know, given that the needs that we have to have, so perhaps a little more, I don't think that's creating too much flexibility. I think that's still give the staff and the director, you know, a lot of leeway as to what you can do. Correct me if I'm wrong. So what you're saying is, are you saying that double density

1:18:23 And one concession would not require a use permit. If it's simply just one concession. And double density. So I think that Supervisor Creates was suggesting that those two, and the Mammoth Lakes housing letter, that those two are together. So if you're requesting double density and two concessions, that's when the use permit would be triggered. But anything below that would not trigger a use permit. Is that...

1:18:52 Well, typically, how many concessions do the developer even ask for? I don't know. I mean, I don't know if you remember the last... I worked on a project that was never built, and they requested, I think, two concessions. A lot of times, a lot coverage and height sometimes. So we haven't had that many of these requests over the past 15 years or so, so there's not a lot of history. But so that... I'm just trying to make sure I understand, I think, what you're saying.

1:19:20 Yeah, a lot of the projects in the past, so this is kind of pre-2007, had requested even more than two. Some of them had requested lot coverage, setbacks, reductions of parking. Others had requested height. It hasn't come up as often, but it's typically lot coverage and setbacks that you'd see the most. And so in those cases, if it, along with yours or with MLH's recommendation, requesting two concessions,

1:19:48 Would have to come forward with a use permit, and as written in the policy, they would be required to then deed restrict a higher percentage of units or agree to a longer term for their deed restriction, or if they're only requesting, say, reduction setbacks of 20% and the double density, then they wouldn't require a use permit, only design review. What if we go what MLH has proposed and exclude height?

1:20:18 As a concession, because height typically is a great, you know, it's a big issue, right? Yeah, so as written, it's the maximum concession for height would be 10%, and so 10% of 35 feet doesn't get you a giant, it doesn't get you a whole extra story, it really gets you more on, in some cases we've seen, say, a larger

1:20:40 Building, say, you know, with four units might need the additional height to engineer the roof to not have a flat roof so that they can get the span that they need. So the height is fairly limited in what the concession would allow. It's not allowing like an extra floor. Is staff comfortable with two concessions instead of just one before the trigger point? I mean, our recommendation is to require a use permit.

1:21:09 for any use of this policy. So that's kind of the staff's recommendation, and clearly we understand, you know, the concerns. So, I mean, I think if the commission, if there's direction from the commission, consensus to not require use permit in some situations or whatever they are, we'll forward that recommendation to the town council. And it also all can, as Supervisor Kreitz alluded to, be reconsidered, say, in a year when we're reviewing the program, too, that says,

1:21:39 You know, have no projects, but I'll go forward because it's still too restrictive and that it, you know, the concession's not right or because if they wanted two concessions and they didn't want to go through with the use permits, they didn't come through with the project. I think kind of all those different circumstances can definitely be reviewed too on that annual, that periodic review or the annual review basis. MLH, if I've read this correctly, they're saying that they want to have

1:22:19 One or less? So my understanding, and if the commission's okay, I'll let Supervisor Kreitz jump in if I say it wrong. So the MLH board and just their overall kind of recommendations, not just on this, but throughout all the discussions with the parcel and everything else, is to make it equitable on what we're saying for any housing project, that if we're saying

1:22:45 A low-income household only needs one parking space because we're assuming they don't have cars or they only have one vehicle. That should be the same kind of for any residential project. And so their recommendation, I think, is more of a broad recommendation on all programs, not specific to this, but to include it in this to allow a reduction. Did I say that correctly? I'm assuming so. And so our... I was just reading the letter.

1:23:19 Yes. And so our recommendation to not necessarily permit an outright reduction in parking is we've seen issues with parking throughout the community with, you know, there's, you can't park on the street six months out of the year. You can't park offsite in like a commercial site or anything else overnight for legality reasons and so forth.

1:23:40 Going to recommend that they only have, say, one space per unit. There are going to be ongoing issues unless there's a strong management plan in place for every project to really enforce those parking standards. Our recommendation is to adhere to the multifamily standards, which are currently in place, unless it's otherwise allowed by some other state standard for a reduction in parking, such as under SB35. We don't have any control on...

1:24:08 What the state sets, if they come in, say, projects under this program only have to provide a half space or one space per unit or no spaces, we can't require something different on that. So we're saying, so staff is recommending one, minimum of one. No, staff is recommending adherence to the current parking standards in the code, which is based on bedroom size, and then there's a formula for how many guest parking spaces you have to provide. So if it's a...

1:24:36 Studio or one bedroom unit, I believe it's one space per unit. And then when you get up to two and three bedrooms, it's two spaces per unit. And then there's a formula for how many guest parking spaces. So and this is like across the board for the whole community. It's not just for low income housing or deed restricted units, correct? Correct. Okay. But this is different from what's being proposed with the parcel. Is that where this is coming up? Okay, gotcha.

1:25:05 Because the parcel is under that parking wise. The conceptual land use plan shows that. And there's other affordable housing projects in town that have utilized the reductions because the state requires that we can't require more than a certain amount of parking. So I think some MLH projects also are below that minimum. And I think their current 238 Sierra Manor Road project is reduced and wouldn't meet those parking requirements. So the state does allow for reductions in parking.

1:25:35 Because they understand parking is expensive to build. SB35, too, right? SB35, too, yes. And I think as we relate to the parcels, if I'm correct on this, financing also affects that parking requirement as well. Gotcha. State of favor financing. And part of it is, too, that as projects come forward, if you're coming in under just an occupancy restricted

1:26:05 You know, you wouldn't qualify for those reductions under another state program. So you wouldn't qualify under SB35 if you're only doing occupancy restricted. So that's why we did not include necessarily parking reductions in this because if a project came forward and they wanted to deed restrict their units to low income in all the different scenarios I ran, they would also qualify basically under an SB35 kind of provision if they chose to go that route.

1:26:41 Just as to de-restricted property and not losing them, I mean, that's just based on the conversation we just had, I feel, I still don't feel very comfortable that we won't lose any units like we have in the past. And to me, it just doesn't seem very responsible in that, from the town's perspective, that we're requiring the developers to put up these units.

1:27:12 But then, let's say later down the road and town decides not to fund, not to purchase that unit back to ensure that unit to stay as a de-restricted property, a unit. Oh, I mean, that seems to me that's kind of a... It's a good time to talk about the RLF and how that wasn't in place a long time ago and now it is and you guys just increased it by, doubled it. Yeah, but it just seems like the feedback that I got...

1:27:49 Just now that I'm hearing is that there's no guarantee that we're not going to be able to lose this. No, and there's no guarantee as Supervisor Kreitz mentioned with that. It's so much time and effort, especially staff's time, to making sure that this is going to happen.

1:28:11 I think we're doing everything we can to ensure that. I mean, we redrafted our deed restrictions. I mean, we're doing everything we can. And as Supervisor Creates mentioned, we have the revolving loan funds. So we are purchasing those back. We're using that money to purchase those back, keep them on the market. So I mean, we're kind of doing everything we can to prevent that. And I don't know if we even know when the last time we've lost a deed restriction, but I don't think it's occurred in the recent past.

1:28:38 And I think the only way to ensure that that affordable housing stays on the market would be for the town to own that, those units, you know, own the product, have it be a rental product. I mean, we've talked a little bit about this, but so. Yeah, under the kind of purview of the restriction, you know, it's laid out to A, on the initial occupancy.

1:29:04 To the extent kind of legal, ensure that it's a qualified occupant. There's always some risk in that and that let's say they can't find a qualified occupant. So as written in the policy, it talks about a marketing plan that talks about, you know, how they're going to market those units to find those qualified occupants. Then if they still can't find an occupant, they could come to the town and on a case-by-case scenario allow non-qualified occupant to occupy that unit under certain terms. And then

1:29:34 Going forward additionally with the deed restrictions it's set up to on a for sale on an ownership unit every time that unit changes title so if it changes ownership it gets a new deed restriction recorded so that that 55 year term starts over and then as far as rental products go the risk is fairly minimal outside of foreclosure in some cases and that

1:30:02 Some deed restrictions can withstand foreclosures, some cannot. But there's always the risk, and as Sandra indicated, the only way to completely avoid the risk would be the town owning 100% of the units, which isn't feasible either. Thank you. Jessica? I have one more question. If a developer is using this density bonus, and then things, I guess I'm thinking with the deed restricted aspect, even if that's lost, does each unit...

1:30:32 Is it prohibited from nightly rentals for the rest of time, no matter who it changes hands to? Yeah, so that would be a separate restriction necessarily from any occupant, like the income or that deed restriction would just be on title saying transit rentals are prohibited based on the APN because it received this density bonus. Gotcha. So if the deed restriction is lost, it goes back to normal zoning standards.

1:31:02 Nightly rentals would not go away. So you still can't have nightly rentals. Correct. So this worst case scenario, if we lose the deed restriction, it goes back into whatever the zoning is for that, no nightly rentals allowed. Correct. So it's not becoming an Airbnb at that point anyways, in our worst case scenario. Correct. Because the property got the density bonus, that's what's then triggering that. Forever. Forever. Got it. Okay. I would just like to add that

1:31:32 I think that we need to definitely look at having quality life standards with these units. I would like Mammoth Lakes Housing to do the monitoring of the deed restricted units to kind of take that off the town's hand and let our NGOs do what they're supposed to be doing. To Greg's point earlier, I think that we should also look at

1:32:02 People who are in those units and retire that they can continue living there. I think that's really an important thing. And I think that we need to have the use permit in place. I think it's important for our process and for the community to have a say. And I mean, if we're

1:32:25 Doing double density, I think that the neighbors need to really be able to be informed and know what's going on there. And I think that that use permit is important for that. And parking is an issue for me, but I understand that there is, you know, SB35 does have its own issues as well, where it allows less parking. So I don't know how to get away from that. Those are my comments.

1:32:57 I guess we can go for a motion. Is anyone ready to? Does the commission want to kind of go through some of these issues? It sounds like I heard differently. Well, it might be good to kind of tackle the use permit. Okay. That's what I think. Go through these and livability standards, right? Just kind of go through these so that the commission can see if we have consensus and then go for a motion.

1:33:23 Sorry. We moved them back up there so that you guys could use those if you needed to. Okay, so support the proposed format for the density bonus program to award points in exchange for deed restricting a percentage of the base density units. So the first two bullet points are just that they support what we're proposing. Okay. And then the third bullet point shows their recommendations. Okay. So support having an incentive program with the following changes.

1:33:54 Yeah, so their recommendation was, A, to have a reduced parking ratios, and then the other recommendation was on, one of the concessions was talking about 25% reduction in the amount of guest parking spaces, so just adding the language after, with a minimum of one parking space reduction, so that the math equals at least one reduced space. I'd like to keep what the town recommends and not go with MLH. I think this is connected to the...

1:34:24 Parcel, from what I understand, and I don't feel great about the limited parking we have there, so I don't want to, I would like this to be consistent with what. Jennifer's point earlier, we want to have these units be as good as market units. Totally, yeah. You know, being able to park your car is part of your living standard, and if we're going to have them, I don't know anybody who doesn't have a car. I mean, I'm an old dinosaur burner, I'm sorry, but.

1:34:53 The idea that everybody's going to be going around in automatic Ubers and suddenly get transformed to the light of public transport, that's all fine and good, but I haven't seen it yet. So if we're going to have these units built for the people that we have working here now, I think they should be built to our current standard for parking. I agree? Sure. I'll agree with that as well. I think that...

1:35:21 That Greg's right, that everybody has a car. I think people will buy a car before they invest in their own housing. So I think that we need to really be serious about giving parking spots, especially with our winter situation and snow. So I guess we have a consensus on keeping the parking requirements. Yes.

1:35:47 I'm trying to go off the letter I have to because I can't really see the red writing. The fifth bullet is really the use permit question is do we want a use permit? If not, is there a trigger at which we would want a use permit? And MLH is suggesting once a developer requests more than one concession, that would trigger the use permit. So the commission, and like I said, staff's recommendation is a use permit. So the commission can give us some direction.

1:36:18 Jessica, would you like to go first? I'm torn on this one. I think my initial thought was maybe we should do something, like if it's over 50% of an increase in density, that needs a use permit. So going from two to three would be okay, but two to four, but I can't really wrap my head around what feels fair in that sense. My initial thought was to keep the use permit process, but...

1:36:49 To the Mammoth Lakes Housing point, I think there is an argument for why it shouldn't be. So I'm torn. I'm leaning toward keep it as is recommended by the town staff. Paul? With MLH making it more flexible at this time. However, I understand the argument of making sure that we staff have the opportunity and the public have the opportunity to look at this double density. So for that reason, I think maybe we should.

1:37:35 Greg? I like the use permit. I mean, double density is a hell of a bonus. And, you know, if you want it, then you've got to go through the same process that we've always had. You know, Jen's point was, you know, you might delay it. And so let's eliminate the use permit for a year and then a year we can always put it back. Well, if we're putting it back, it's because there was a problem. And whatever that problem was, we're going to live with for a long, long time. So I would rather...

1:38:04 Keep the current standard. And if it turns out that even with a double density bonus, that's still not enough incentive, then maybe we can look at revising that in a year. I vote to keep the use permit. I agree with Greg that we're going to be living with whatever gets built for a long time. And we can reevaluate this in a year according to this. And if we find that it's still too cumbersome, we can change that in a year.

1:38:34 And then the next one, kind of on the, as going from the slide, is the livability standards. Should those apply to units that are generated through this process? And those are the standards that I think no one talked about previously. Yes, for me. Greg? Yes. Paul? Yes. Yes, for me. And what was the last one? So the last one was including processes in the policy for how we're going to do the long-term monitoring of the deed-restricted units.

1:39:06 So as it currently doesn't specify that MLH is going to monitor them or the town is going to monitor them, it's just built in that with the deed restrictions, there is long-term monitoring in either the town or MLH as our NGO can do the monitoring. Right. And the letter just says they recommend that the town adopt a comprehensive monitoring program as a part of this policy. So they're not saying that... They're not saying it should be MLH or it should be the town. They're just saying...

1:39:35 develop a policy. And currently, our deed restriction monitoring occurs with Mammoth Lakes Housing through the contract that we have with them. So we have a contract that we enter into. At this point, I think it's a three-year contract where we contract with them to monitor those units. So it's really a contractual relationship. I think that... Who is monitoring MLH? Well, we are.

1:40:05 We are supposed to be. So I think really what this is saying is that this is how the monitor, right now we don't have anything that says it should be on an, I don't think it says annual basis, I don't, I think this is really kind of, what are the parameters, how do you monitor these? I don't think it's a bad idea for the town to adopt, I don't know if it needs to be adopted as part of this process, but that, the commission can provide some recommendations on that. And the deed restrictions themselves and the

1:40:33 In the standard language, talk about that the units will be monitored on an annual basis and that it has the form that they have to fill out with what information they need to provide. It also allows MLH to collect a fee for the monitoring from the owner of the property. So it's already kind of defined within the existing deed restriction templates how they're going to be monitored. Jessica? Do you have a comment? No.

1:41:04 I just want to elaborate a little bit. There was quite a bit of discussion at the MLH board meeting on Monday about this. And I think that there was concern expressed about, for example, if you have priorities and your top priority is workforce, but if that owner can't find somebody to meet that, let's say, lease agreement, then you'd have somebody who lives here. And if you can't find somebody who lives here, then it could be anybody, I think.

1:41:32 But there's some concern expressed, well, what if after a year, that person just keeps wanting to stay? There's somebody who don't, they don't live here, they didn't live here and they didn't work here, they met the third priority, the lowest priority. How do we...

1:41:49 Ensure that we're going back out to the top priority after the year's lease is up because maybe now there's somebody available that would want to rent that unit but there wasn't at that time so that you don't have somebody who didn't meet your top priority in that unit for five years let's say. So those were some things that were discussed and how do we make sure that those kinds of

1:42:16 Considerations in monitoring and in the deed restriction are included in our thinking of this policy. Also, you know, over the years, we've all seen things not included in policies go to the wayside or we forget about them or they don't happen. And having something built into the policy is more than, again, it gets back to being really strategic.

1:42:45 Your intention being well defined in your policy for monitoring, that these are monitored and that the priorities are being met. I think I just wanted to elaborate on that. I think that was some of the discussion so that it wasn't just something that was put off, but it was really well defined or explicit in the policy, not just in the deed restriction. Do you have a monitoring process in place at MLH?

1:43:14 Well, I'm not with MLH. I mean, I'm at the board level, and so they do, I believe, have a process. I haven't been there for over a year, so I don't know if it's changed, but there is a monitoring process that happens every year on certainly ownership units, and then the rental units, the MLH is involved in, those are monitored based on the...

1:43:40 The tax credits and the investment, the funders on those rental units, it's much different for those than it is on the ownership side. So it gets back to the deed restriction for them. That's going to drive the monitoring by and large or the funding source. But here there isn't funding, right? The funding comes from the public allowing

1:44:09 Increased density, that that's the, that's how we get the subsidy to make these affordable is the density. So it's really the, it's, that's the subsidy. That's why I think it should come from the town because you're providing the subsidy in density. Absolutely. So it sounds like the question is, is what's written into the, you were saying Nolan that there's already.

1:44:35 Somewhat of a policy or a few things that are included in there. So is that enough or do we want more from this? Is that the question? I believe that is. And I think the current deed restrictions do kind of outline the overall policy. So if it was the commission's desire, we could take language from those existing deed restrictions and add it into the density bonus policy as either a new section in the back, just that, you know, saying the town shall monitor.

1:45:04 The units in accordance with the workforce housing agreement and deed restrictions and then spell out the process for how that will look. I support that. And I would support that too in addition as not only monitoring enforcement, it's monitoring and enforcement. I think that's critical. Great. I like the idea of monitoring and enforcement, but I'm not, I don't think we need to limit it to the town and MLH. I mean.

1:45:34 10 years from now, we might have a whole other funding source that's putting out housing, and if that unnamed entity is designated by the town, they should be able to do the job also. I think the policy would be written broad enough that I would say the town or its designated or its designee, it wouldn't specifically call out that MLH is going to do the work to provide that flexibility.

1:46:01 Greg alluded to. But currently MLH is contracted to do this work. Currently, yes. Right, to do some of the work. To do some of the work, but in the future it could be a different entity, it could be the town, it could be MLH, so if you write it the town or its designee, then it covers all the bases. I'd be fine with that, sure. I agree. Sounds good, yeah. Okay, I think that was everything, right? I believe so, unless there is additional questions from the commission. Anybody? Okay.

1:46:34 So do you want to just kind of summarize? Sure. So I think the changes that were kind of just discussed or agreed to by the commission were to keep the use permit requirement, no reduction in parking, include the livability standards for unit size and distribution.

1:46:57 And then add into the policy language or process for the monitoring and enforcement of the deed restricted units. We all agree on that? Yes. So, yeah, make a motion with the amendments as summarized by staff. I make a motion to recommend to the town to approve the general plan amendments 19-002 and zoning code amendment 19-002 to adopt it.

1:47:29 Town density bonus program update and adoption of an addendum to the 2016 general plan, land use element slash zoning code amendment and mobility element update program environmental impact report and conditions as stated by staff. Can I get a second? I'll second. Jamie, you want to do a roll call? Sure.

1:47:57 Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Ecker? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you. Moving on to business matters. Item number two, provide comments on a potential November ballot measure to increase transit occupancy tax by 1% for housing purposes. Our staff contact is Sandra Moberly. Thank you. So the town council has been discussing different ways to increase revenues for housing.

1:48:26 Over the past couple months. And the town council asked staff to look into a special tax measure, a TOT tax measure. And so one of their requests was for the staff to go to the different boards like MLT, MLH, and the chamber.

1:48:47 We thought it would be important to also bring this question before the Planning and Economic Development Commission, and really the Town Council was looking for a kind of very general level of support, and clearly there's a lot of...

1:49:03 Questions that are not answered about exactly where this money would go, those types of things. But I think that the council was kind of looking for some general support for the tax measure so that they can move forward with it. This item was presented, as I noted in the staff report, to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, and there were a lot of questions about how this money would be used and how this reflects the current town

1:49:32 0.85 points of T.O.T. that goes to housing. Would that jeopardize that? So there was a lot of different questions about it, and staff will work to respond to those questions, but I think the council was just kind of looking for general support for a tax measure for housing. It would be a special tax measure. This is what they're proposing, which would require a two-thirds vote.

1:49:57 And that funding, there would be no sunset date. So kind of those general components, I think they just wanted some feedback from the boards and commission. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Like I mentioned, we don't really have any details. We haven't kind of gone through that whole program yet. That's what we'll do now is kind of try to answer a lot of the questions that have come up. And all of this needs to be submitted to the Mono County to be on the ballot, I think, July 1st.

1:50:23 We have to submit everything to Mono County. So we'll have all those questions answered in the next coming months, but we don't have those answers right now. Up to questions to the commission. Jessica, do you have any questions? Just curious if there's any local group that's pushing this or if it's coming from council itself.

1:50:43 The council is, it's coming from council right now, but I think, you know, we've heard from local groups just general, you know, need for more money for housing, but there is no one specific group that has pushed this as far as I know. Gotcha. Greg? I generally, my general, I have a very warm, fuzzy feeling about, you know, TOT, raising TOT for housing, but I don't like a tax without a sunset.

1:51:16 Sun almost never goes down anyway. And to say that it's going to continue in perpetuity, it probably will, but I think it ought to have some sort of a renewal and review five years, ten years at some point. I think not having a sense of period, in my opinion, it's irresponsible. Municipality to not be, hold accountable, essentially.

1:51:52 Another question I have is, what other financing mechanism have they considered? The council had discussed, at a very general level, discussed other tax measures. So a sales tax increase, property tax, a lift tax on tickets purchased at the mountain. So just some very general, but with no kind of detailed analysis on any of those at this point.

1:52:23 So that's just some general. But that's, we're talking, so that's, so they're considering raising taxes. Correct. In other ways. But have they considered the current revenue and future revenue of the current tax codes that we have, are they, have they able to consider those options, you know. How they could be redirected. Correct. They have talked about our current political commitments.

1:52:55 And given that they want PDC to provide input, I think they need to provide that information to us, not just as PDC, but also as public. Right, right. It sounded like they didn't...

1:53:10 Care for our input. Like we weren't on the list, not in a bad way, but they were requesting these other organizations and you're bringing it to us, right? Rather than council saying, hey, go ask people. And the town manager. The town manager and I talked about it and thought it would be good. So it's town staff that want our input rather than town council doesn't care. That's a good point. That's a great point because, you know, granted we are appointed by town councils, but oftentimes that's what it feels like is, you know, it seems like our...

1:53:41 I'm not saying it's a bad thing because clearly they're very busy. There's a lot of issues they have to deal with.

1:54:13 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

1:54:47 We hear, we learn about things from the paper or from Facebook, social media, not so much from, you know, getting the details from town councils directly. There's not a great partnership in that. It feels sometimes like we're working in silos. I think that's a better way of putting it. And we try to have joint meetings with the council and the commission on a somewhat routine basis once or twice a year, which...

1:55:17 It's not a lot, but it's a lot when you're kind of thinking about bringing those two groups together. But I mean, the point of those, and granted, in the past, we've been focused a lot on the parcel and some other items, but I think the point is to really kind of have this kind of dialogue and... Even just on an individual level, I can count in one hand how many times I spoke to the town councils through any given one of them. Combined, really.

1:55:49 Not to add any more work to our plates, but maybe, and this is kind of off the topic, sorry, but maybe down the road we can look at perhaps having a representative from our commission meeting with a representative from town council to discuss planning and economics plans. And the Recreation Commission, the Chair, Betsy, comes to...

1:56:18 A lot of the town council meetings and often reports on what the commission is doing and engages the council at those meetings. It's certainly something that the chair or vice chair could do. I mean, that would mean coming to those meetings maybe once a month. You have me. And I do report on what you do, but this is a little bit outside of kind of what...

1:56:43 What I typically report on. But, I mean, yeah, I think there's ways to try to strengthen that relationship. Yeah. So, sorry, going back, do you have any more comments on the TOT increase? I've got one. Correct me if I'm wrong, but this took two-thirds to pass. It will take two-thirds to pass. Okay, but it would take two-thirds to kill. Yes. So once it's in place without a sunset. Oh, I see, I see. It's going to be very difficult to overturn. Yes.

1:57:14 So I would be very adamant about a sunset. Well, and just to comment on that, I was watching the town council meeting from January 15th or whatever it was when they discussed this before this meeting, and I believe, maybe Sandra or Jamie knows if I'm wrong, but I believe all of the council people were like, oh yeah, of course we want it to continue in perpetuity. It sounded like every single one of them. So this is, I think, an important thing to note if we or some of us think that it shouldn't. Town council was like,

1:57:43 It can. We're going forever. It can, but it doesn't mean it has to. Sure. I think that is so— So just a note that we should be vocal about this, if this is how we feel, since they are all on the forever track, it seemed. That's extremely irresponsible. I think the thought is that the housing issues that we see in town are not going to go away, and so— I mean, where's the accountability? If they don't go away, this can be— These are good comments that I can pass on to the town council. So—

1:58:13 Okay, you know, they can say, well, you can vote us out, but, well, but it doesn't matter. You know, this thing stays on in perpetuity. I mean, that's, that's... This will never get killed. And clearly, the creating, formulating a tax measure, you're trying to write something that is going to get approved, right? And if, if we're hearing from, from...

1:58:37 The four of you, that there's a concern with a sunset date, then probably most of the community has that concern too, right? So I think that they want feedback in order to craft this in a way that it's going to be successful, and if crafting it without a sunset date, or crafting it with a sunset date,

1:58:58 Is something that you think is important. I think that's the feedback we give to the council. And they're going to consider all of this as they put together the language that's going to go on the ballot. And clearly our attorney, Andy Morris, is working with us on this language. And this is the kind of stuff he wants to hear as we kind of look to that. There's a math behind this. While workforce housing is a problem, and it will continue to be a problem, but that dollar amount is not infinite.

1:59:29 You're trying to raise the dollar amount that you need to build the parcel and to assist future workforce housing needs, but there has to be a dollar amount behind that. If you're just telling me that it's a sunset, you know, there's no sunset clause on this, and we're just going to collect as much as we want, you know, and I mean, look at the problem that we have seen or the cacophony of

1:59:59 of paper, articles, you know, stuff that's written in articles about how the funding issues between the town and the MLT, blah, blah, blah, you know, it's like, I don't think we should get into that situation. You know, there's only so much money we need and so much money that we need to support this. So it means, you know, we have to,

2:00:40 Kind of constantly review this. And I think that's a good point for when they look, analyze this possible tax measure is, okay, what is it going to be used for? Okay, how much money is that going to take? Is all that funding going to go away, hypothetically, after the parcel's built? It also has to be looked at where else is that money not going to go because it's going here. I mean, there's only so many ounces of blood in the victim. And sooner or later, you run out of blood.

2:01:12 And I think that one of the problems we have that doesn't get talked about as much as I'd like to see it is the reason we have a workforce problem here is because we've been extraordinarily successful with our tourism attracting people here. And it's getting to the point now where our workforce can't keep up with our tourism. And do we really need to keep increasing our tourism or do we need to balance that a little bit? And maybe to Paul's point that, you know.

2:01:41 The funds that they have coming in now could be allocated more towards improving the local community and maybe backed off of at least a little bit of the increase in attracting more tourists that essentially are causing the problem. But I think it's a priority, you know, that money should be used, at least initially, used exclusively for housing and nothing else.

2:02:09 And that would be, that's, the council has been very clear about that, that if they do a tax measure, if it's, that's why they want a special tax, because that commitment is there to the community, that that money can only be used for housing. Whereas the current TOT is all a general tax measure, so it can be shifted. Now, granted, there's political commitments for that money, but. What does that mean?

2:02:35 That means that the town council has committed to fund a certain portion of, take a certain portion of that TOT and fund housing, tourism and transit. But they're just political commitments. So hypothetically, and it happened during the settlement, our lawsuit, they shifted money to pay for that. If the special tax was approved, they would not be able to do that. That tax measure, the money could not be used for anything other than exactly what it was stated for.

2:03:04 With the voters approved. So, and clearly there's been a lot of discussion about the political commitments and so I think that's the reason why the council feels really strongly that this should be a special tax measure because there's been so much talk about political commitments. So. Any questions? Because I have a few. What are some of the entities, their take on this? So the short version of what I heard from MLH and MLT was relatively similar is that

2:03:36 They're not comfortable making any, kind of giving any support to this tax measure until they know more about exactly what it's going to fund. And how that funding, how the new tax measure would affect that current, their current points of TOT. So we're not the outlier? No, no, I don't think so. I mean, you know, I've heard some comments from the commissioners, but, you know, ideally we would take forward some sort of kind of consensus if possible, but I think the concerns are...

2:04:04 Are valid as well. Just hearing concerns is good, right? I mean, I think we're not here to get everyone to just say yes, go do this. I mean, I think all of these concerns are what we would bring back to the council and let them know. You know, the commission didn't have clear direction, but they had concerns about the sunset date, about these other items, you know? So that's really what they want. They want feedback. I don't think they are, you know, need.

2:04:25 Support. I think they just kind of wanted to know that before they spent all the time and money putting this together and staff time, I think they just want to know, is there just general support for this? Should we kind of move forward with our analysis and try to put this together? That's really kind of where this came from. What is the percentage of TOT that they have decided is going to MLH currently? It's .85.

2:04:54 Is that down from what it was? Like, wasn't it at one point higher, like 1.5 or something? I think it was 1% at one point. No, just housing, sorry. MLH has a contract. So we have a contract with MLH and it's for $330,000 a year. They can ask for additional funding for special projects. There's some provisions in there for that. But MLH has, we have a contract with them. And same with MLT, we have a contract with MLT.

2:05:26 Okay, but so the .85, I'm sorry. Right. That goes to housing or to MLH? Housing. But that's totally separate from the contract you have with that. No, it includes the contract. So the .85, there's a $330,000 for MLH, and then the remainder of that goes for different things. And at one point that was higher, correct? The MLH contract, I'm not sure. No, not the contract, but the percentage. Right. Was like one. Right, four. And then they.

2:05:55 Weren't funding that much because it wasn't a priority a few years ago. They reduced the funding during the settlement, during the lawsuit to funds part of that. Okay. Is there currently a task force to monitor TOT or has that been dissolved? I'm not sure.

2:06:19 Well, I'm not aware of a TOT. We had a, we had like a. Like for illegal rentals. Oh yeah, we have a, my whole department monitors illegal rentals, right? Because rumors going around, so I'm asking, I'm just looking for clarification that the task force recently was dissolved looking for all the people who are renting illegally, nightly. I'm not aware of that. That's a function of the finance department. We have like three staff members that.

2:06:49 Focus on, they collect revenue, but they also conduct enforcement and audits of remitters. Okay. Any other questions? Before we open up to public comment? Okay. Public comment? You have none? You're the only one here. Okay, so, um, I have one more question on this. Is this the sort of thing that we could set up a joint PEDC and TUML meet, or town council?

2:07:17 Meeting to discuss. I'm just wondering to Paul's point of like considering the other options and that it is an election year and I know we're kind of tight on timing but for example a lift ticket tax that would be through the town or that would be separate? I guess if it's a tax it's all through the town. The tax would be remitted to the town. So any of these things would be a ballot measure or some sort of election thing. I'm just wondering if it's worth

2:07:42 Like are we all just going to individually reach out to council and share our thoughts? Is it the sort of thing that we could even do a joint meeting on? You could. What the council has asked is for us to staff, each staff members to bring this information back to them. So my goal would be to summarize kind of the issues that I hear and then bring that back to council so that at least they have some input. I think that, you know, it might be...

2:08:09 So I'll take this information to the town manager.

2:08:39 You know, he can kind of work with the council. Yeah, I would highly support if, yeah, it doesn't need to be a, I guess there's the line of, I don't feel like it needs to be a meeting in here of the two bodies necessarily, but if we could do something like the community conversations that have happened, but then I know we get into the tricky thing of, can we all be there? Can the town council all be there? If we notice it, they can. Okay. If we notice it as a meeting of all of these boards, they can all attend. And I think since there's no information currently, there's no, we don't even have a.

2:09:09 direction to go that would make more sense to have like a public kind of thing in here. I think the community conversation kind of style that I know Wentworth and Courtless have done at the brewing company, like that sort of thing would be good at this point in my mind. Are there suggestions for staff? I'd like to see, like the gentleman said, a lot more consideration of alternatives. I think that we should fund

2:09:41 My comments, uh,

2:10:15 I think I agree with Jessica that we need to develop a community forum or joint meeting at the very least to discuss this. I think I understand they stopped giving as much money to housing after the lawsuit, but I mean, realistically, we're pretty good into that lawsuit and we're going to have a couple million dollars every year after that.

2:10:44 I agree with Greg as well that we need to tighten our belts of what we're spending our money on instead of just throwing money at everyone because we have this huge surplus the last few years. I think that we really just need to look at it and get back to our roots and say, is housing a priority and how are we going to shift this? Do we need to not give...

2:11:11 An increase in money every year to every department, but maybe look at how we're spending our money and then, you know, look for other alternatives. Why not go after Airbnb? They are taxing, our businesses, our local businesses that are doing these rentals are getting taxed up the rear end, so they're getting taxed for cleaning fees. Our town is taxing them for cleaning fees and everything else that a lot of places don't get taxed for.

2:11:41 That these rental companies are having to pay for. Adding another percent on that and Airbnb and VRBO are also taxing these rental companies charging a percentage. So we're adding another one. So it's not just 14% for these companies. It ends up being a lot more. So maybe looking at going after Airbnb and VRBO for having them.

2:12:07 Taxing them because they're making a killing off of us would be an option. I just think that we need to look at other alternatives. And then further, I definitely agree that if we go forward with this, we need a sunset date. We can't just be irresponsible about this and just, because somewhere down the road, oh, we need money for something else. Let's do another tax. Let's be responsible with our money. And just a note, while we're sitting here, the town manager sent me an email. He's clearly...

2:12:35 Watching the meeting. He did note that there was a lodging group that would review these TOT cases and make recommendations to staff. It's that group that was disbanded. So it's not the TOT enforcement group. This is a group of lodging community.

2:12:54 And the reason why we disbanded it was because there was just a bunch of meetings where people weren't attending anymore. I think it was a really kind of a big deal back when we just first started the enforcement. But now that this enforcement is kind of a smooth running machine, they've disbanded it. And he noted that the TOT tax item will be on the March 4th Town Council agenda. And the chamber met today and had general support for the tax measure, but with some questions as well. So he's saying there's general support.

2:13:23 But that's not what? This is very short. This is an email. This is a very short note. He's just trying to, I think, provide this feedback to help the commission. But there didn't seem to be general support from MLT or MLH kind of one way or another. I think that they needed more information. And it sounds like the chamber does too. So and he also commented that the PEDC and other boards can come to the notice council meetings and make individual comments on this.

2:13:52 So that would be another way to kind of voice concerns about this if there was that desire. I would like to just, hello Dan, I am not in support of this tax. There you go. I have one other question. We should turn it to town councils. At least somebody watches it. I'm sure they're all tuned in. There's clearly a lot of questions about that and I think that's what I will take forward. I don't think I hear, I heard some kind of...

2:14:18 Some support, some no support, but a lot of questions, and I think that's... This is not a support. I heard Commissioner Eckert with warm and fuzzy possible. I'm warm and fuzzy about... Maybe it's gone away since the discussion. I'm warm and fuzzy of supporting a revenue stream, but I'm just not sure that this is it. Okay. I'm warm and fuzzy about money going to housing. I'm totally in support of that. I don't think this is the right way. Okay. One other question. I don't know if either of you know this, but the January 15th meeting that I watched...

2:14:48 I gathered some stuff from that. Were there previous meetings where town council, I know they're always talking about housing, but is there dates that you can think of that I should go back and watch that would provide some more clarity on their thoughts or directions or where this came from? I can provide you with the dates. They have talked about it at a number of different council meetings, but I don't know them off the top of my head. Sure. Sure. Right. Okay.

2:15:15 Got it. Yeah, and they have, I mean, you know, I think Commissioner, Vice Chair Burroughs made a comment about the excess TOT. I mean, the council has said that housing is a top priority and therefore they've committed the excess TOT from the next two years for the parcel project to bridge that gap. So they really are, they do understand the priorities and they are kind of taking that excess TOT.

2:15:42 Shifting it to the parcel, which is kind of our top housing project right now. So there is that commitment on that end. And they've also committed a lot of other funding to housing above and beyond that 0.85 over the past couple years. They bought the parcel. So there's other funding that's been committed as well. So I think, I guess, if I could maybe try to summarize, if there were to be a tax.

2:16:08 So I guess the starting point is we're not sure if this is the right tax. We're supportive of additional money for housing, we just don't know if this is the right way to get it. Because we don't have it. Enough information. Enough information. Okay. If there were a tax, it should have a sunset. Absolutely. I think that's unanimous.

2:16:32 And I think kind of your other comments are kind of woven into that. We need more information. We want to know how the current funding is being spent, how any current TOT is being spent, where that money is going. Have you looked at other options to kind of redirect that spending? Just kind of just information about that. In order to provide support, I think you need more information about kind of all the things that the council considered and did they consider current, you know, reallocation of current revenue? What cuts have been considered to?

2:17:03 be put towards this. Okay. And then the last item is some sort of a community discussion on this item would be a recommendation or you would like to participate somehow in a discussion on this item. And the key word we want to sense that because accountability is a must. Yep. So I think that summarizes it. Yep. Sure. Sounds good.

2:17:33 So I'll pass that along to the Town Council and they will be talking about this on March 4th. So I think we'll be presenting this information along with the other information that we've heard from the other boards and they'll have a discussion about next steps. Sounds good. Thank you. Thank you. That brings us to the consent agenda. Does anyone want to make a motion to pass or approve it? Second. Can I get a second?

2:18:04 Okay. Just all in favor, correct? Jamie, all in favor? Aye. Motion passes 4-0. That brings us to commissioner reports. Jessica, would you like to go first? I don't have anything to report. We did attend that design committee meeting, but I'll let you report on that. Brief one. Yeah, I can report on that when it comes. This is Jessica's mobility committee.

2:18:35 I was your stand-in. You were gone out of town and she... No, no, no. I was the... I did the design review. Wasn't there design something? Design committee? We did have a different design committee meeting. Something happened. I'm not part of mobility. No. But in here it says mobility committee. She is on the mobility, but she's the backup for the design when you're not here. Oh. Yes. And you weren't here, so she came. Right. Got it. Greg? No report. Paul? No, I wasn't able to attend.

2:19:06 Okay. I attended the design meeting on January 14th and we reviewed the master sign program for the Mammoth Outlets and basically they were changing their two monument signs and then the signs around the building. Yes. Yes. And then we reviewed, oh, same.

2:19:37 Just, sorry, same thing, the monument side, but one of them is, it's not the outlet mall anymore, it's the Main Street Promenade. That's the name. Yeah, that's what they're changing the name to, no, they're not the outlets anymore. Outlet stores left. No, I think there's the Bass, the Bass one is still there and that's it. Okay, if no other report, no other reports from commissioners and we'll move on to the director's report.

2:20:05 Thank you. So just a very brief report. The only item I have to report is that I will be going to the Planning Commissioner's Academy with Vice Chair Burroughs and Commissioner Chang. That's March 4th through the 6th. So I think it's an exciting training and we'll definitely bring back some information at your next commission meeting. And that's all I have. Oh, that is afterwards, huh?

2:20:37 Wow, sorry, I'm looking at that. I'm like, that's coming actually sooner than I thought it was. Can I ask one question, Sandra? Is there any update on the Sierra Center Mall project? So the Sierra Center Mall project, they have met with our staff, the building department staff, on several occasions about the building permit plans. So they are looking to submit soon, I would assume in the next couple months, a month or so.

2:21:07 I have heard that they've issued that they've told all the tenants that they need to be out by the end of March and I think it's their intent to start demolition in April, May.

2:21:24 So I think they're on schedule with the project because the demo can occur. It's a separate permit. It's a demolition permit. It's a very simple permit, really, to issue. So we can issue that demolition permit separately and then do the building permit while we're continuing to work on the building permit for the project. So as far as I know, they're still on schedule. Okay. Thank you. So that means all the tenants will.

2:21:49 As far as I know, they've given notice to all the tenants. We were at Delicious Kitchen, just as a side note, and they told us they're closing. Their last day is March 22nd. Closing for good? No. They don't know. They just said they're closing, and I asked where they were going to go, and they don't have a spot that they told me about. Best place in town. Jamie agrees. Yeah, we all try to help them. Yeah, I'm a member of the fort, and I have heard nothing from the mountains, so I'm curious if they're going to...

2:22:18 Tell us where our workspace will be by March. It's next month. That's true. That would be something I haven't heard before. A lot of people are on, like, year contracts with them, so I imagine they have to figure something out or refund a bunch of money, but I will, yeah, consider it. They'll move you up to the space at the mountain. There's a little fort space. That's probably what they'll do, which... Yep. Okay. So this adjourns the Planning and Economic... I don't like to use the gavel. Commission meeting. Our next regular meeting will be held on March 11th at 2...