Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2020
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 40 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- Old Mammoth Road Beautification has been planned since 2019 and is listed at $500,000 in the FY26-27 final budget document Downtown and Main Street
- The Main Street sidewalk project was concluded in 2019 with segments along the South Frontage Road and Sierra Boulevard to Mountain Boulevard Downtown and Main Street
- Planning reports say bids exceeded budget before the Town awarded a construction contract Multi-Use Facility / Community Recreation Center
Transcript
76 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:14 Yeah, the bells. Okay. We can get started. Okay, call to, call to order meeting Wednesday, March 11th, 2020, uh, 2020, uh, 2 p.m. Uh, Jamie, would you like to do a roll call, please? Here. Here. Present. Okay.
4:52 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, I'd like to open it up for public comment for anything that is not on the agenda. Nice to see you. Good afternoon, Commissioners. Chairman's going. Okay. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Sandra asked that I come here this afternoon just to give you guys a quick update on what the Mountain's doing, our current plans.
5:25 I've been postponing and postponing because things have been kind of in flux, so I wanted to make sure I gave you guys an accurate forecast of the projects that we're going to be working on. So, real quick, I mean, we have another big year. Just as a review, last year we did a second phase of improvements at Canyon Lodge. I don't know how many of you had a chance to see that or not, but that was...
5:52 Well over a $10 million project, approaching $11 million that we spent there, was, you know, the big highlight of the summer. And, yeah, and then, you know, other projects, I mean, all said and done, last year we spent over $24 million, I think it was, on growth capital, and then we spent another $9 million on maintenance capital, so, you know, we had about $33 million in capital spend, if you will, at the ski area.
6:18 This year is similar in that we, I'll go through the list with you, but we're at a real similar total roll-up of over $30 million worth of capital that we're going to spend. Highlights this year are, we're going to be replacing the planned replacement of Chair 1 and Chair 16, both lifts we're going to replace, those are sort of older generation quad chair lifts that were built in the late 80s.
6:46 So they're quite old at this point in time. They're, you know, over 30 years old. And they're going to be replaced with new six-pack detachable chairlifts that'll also be manufactured by Doppelmayr. And Chair 1 and Chair 16 combined, they're $19.5 million project, roughly. Actually, closer to $20 when we have some...
7:08 Infrastructure work associated with that that we have to do. So that's the big highlight of the summer season, but we're also spending another million and a half on snowmaking improvements at the mountain, sort of continuing work we've done. Again, I don't know how many of you have been up on the mountain, but if you skied the Chair One Broadway ski runs, you would have noticed those automated fan guns that we installed. We put nine in last year. Our goal this year is to complete the Broadway ski run with automated fan guns, which are...
7:37 Much more efficient in terms of energy use and water use in creating snowpack, which, you know, in our ever-changing climactic conditions and the big ups and downs and swings we're seeing is certainly we see as a very critical part of our strategy moving forward is just to ensure that we've got consistent solid conditions to open on and we'll continue to invest in our snowmaking systems. We're also looking at spending half a million bucks at the mill.
8:07 Mill Restaurant at Chair 2, we're going to, basically not really expanding the footprint of the building, but we're going to close in sort of those breezeways on the outside to create more dining room, and it's sort of one of our biggest struggles there is that we only have about 50 seats inside, so by closing in that west wing of the building, we'll gain about 60 more seats, so we'll have over 100 seats of indoor seating there, which will be a big help on poor weather days and so forth. We're also going to expand the men's restroom there, which is another area we've had
8:37 As far as service levels and capacity issues there, so we'll be expanding that and addressing that issue. And then the other one that's a real exciting project is the Westin is going to go through a large-scale renovation. We just re-upped a franchise agreement with the Westin, another 10-year term, and as part of that we have to...
8:58 Update the rooms to the new standards for the brand. And that involved actually a very lengthy process in conjunction with the homeowners because it's a condo hotel. It's owned by homeowners. And so that property at this point is approaching 12 years old. And these big brands are looking for about a 10-year turn on renovations. And so that's one of the areas that's challenging.
9:23 Certainly to get home because you have to get buy-in from the homeowners to participate and it's at their cost because it's their unit to do an improvement to their property. So we're, we, the Mountain is the franchise operator. We run the front desk and we run the food and beverage service. We're going to invest two and a half million dollars in a renovation to the restaurant, the bar area, the lobby areas in the public corridors, or excuse me, the public lobby area in conference rooms. The homeowners are footing the bill to redo the corridors.
9:53 And obviously their own units. So the whole project is over $17 million. It's a substantial project. And it will improve 200. We have 210 people on the property management agreement with us that are participating in the franchise agreement at a 225 total unit. So a very, very substantial number. We're really very, very pleased with the number of homeowners who are, you know,
10:20 Continuing on with participating in the franchise with the West End, so we think that's a very, very important brand to continue to have in Mammoth to provide for our guests. So, what was that? Spend a little bit of money on renovating the conference rooms up at the main lodge, the Mountside Conference Center, and then again we'll have about eight and a half million dollars we put towards.
10:45 You know, our annual maintenance capital, which is just the ongoing repair and maintenance of all of our facilities and our equipment and snowcats and everything else. So, again, you know, in excess of $30 million. You know, I'll just point out to you that it's, you know, now that we're part of Altera, you know, it does provide us some stability in terms of the capital that's getting invested in the company, you know, even though we're having, you know, a little bit of a weak snow year and a little bit behind on our budget.
11:15 You know, there's the stability of the overall strength of Altera and the fact that it's geographically diverse and, you know, a lot of the other areas of the country had great snow years and are doing really well, so, you know, helps kind of shore us up a little bit, but there's, you know, no hesitation that we're continuing with our capital plans. And again, these are ongoing. We're looking at spending this equivalent amount of money, you know, into the next several years at least on work, so a substantial amount of capital investment that will continue.
11:45 One other thing, we're going to try to get the wheels rolling on Eagle Lodge. I know that's always a big question. People want to know what we're doing at Eagle. We've got some work to do with the City of Los Angeles that we have a long-term lease with for the Camp High Sierra property that we intend to develop a beginner chairlift onto that property. So we've met with them. We've had some discussions. We're resubmitting or submitting to them an updated master plan to reflect our current plans for that chairlift and ski runs.
12:13 That's going to have to go through their Parks and Rec Department review and ultimately have to get approved by the City Council of Los Angeles. So I'm kind of expecting it's going to take us the better part of this year to get through those hoops and then we'll move forward with the base lodge design. We'll be probably bringing that back through planning entitlement approvals again. And then I'm going to let the cat out back here a little bit because we haven't released our public press release, but we actually did close on the land exchange last week at the main lodge. And so that project is...
12:43 Officially done. I know there's always been some misconceptions out there. People thought it's been done, but it actually is done now. So we now own the 35 acres up there at Main Lodge down in July. It's a property that's, it's not the Main Lodge building itself, but it's all the property to the north side of Minaret Road, the highway. So where the gondola is, the yodeler, the mountain mountain buildings and so forth. So we have every intention to move forward with entitlement work on that this year.
13:11 With Altair kind of leading that charge out of Denver. And so we're going to get that going fairly quickly is our hope and work through the CEQA on that. And I'm actually meeting with Sandra and Dan later this week to talk about, you know, all the necessary steps we're going to have to go through there. But obviously there will be probably an EIR and CEQA document that will have to be prepared in a specific plan.
13:37 I think there's an annexing or general plan amendment? Yeah, general plan amendment. It doesn't, yeah. A small amendment to the general plan. I mean, it all kind of carried along together. But, yeah, a substantial project to go through specific plan approval, for sure. But exciting, right? Super exciting that that's, I mean, we literally started working on that over 20 years ago and got a bill through Congress, literally approved through Congress.
14:03 Authorize the continuation of the enclosing of the exchange. So it's a big deal. It's a really big deal for me personally, professionally, and for the company as well. So I'm super excited about that. So yeah, that's my quick update. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have. I appreciate you coming today and giving us an update. It's really helpful for when we're looking at doing things around town. Just one question, and it's probably going to be the one you're getting asked the most lately, what happened with the power? Oh, the power outage? Yeah.
14:33 Do we know what caused it? Yes. Okay. There's a feeder leg on the Southern California Edison supply to us that goes up Minaret Road from kind of by Woolies, Woolies 2 Park, there's a substation there, it's Edison's, and then there's a feeder that goes up underground on the road up to Main Lodge and then is demarked to us at the Slope Side Center building. So it was actually a failure.
14:59 On their side of the underground power line, it was a splice actually underground about shuttle stop F that failed and caused the outage. And we were able to quickly reroute to the east side of the mountain and get that resupplied and back online. But it took several hours for us to do all the other things that were necessary to get the power reestablished up to the main lodge area. So as some of you may have had your children on the chairlifts. Chair one in particular, the auxiliary.
15:27 Had a failure, and we weren't able to offload it like we were all the other chairs, so we had to rope it back chair one, which is the first time in over 20 years we've had to do that. So, so luckily we're replacing chair one with a brand new chair lift, so that won't have that problem. So, yeah, that was, in one respect sort of supports, you know, our commitment to change that out is a good thing, so.
15:49 Thank you. Anybody else have any other questions? Did you say that the land that is currently under the existing main lodge is not part of the land trade? The main lodge building itself is not underneath the exchange property, no. But that said, I mean, the intention is that we're, you know, at least in some of our prior sort of conceptual planning for the redevelopment of main lodge, we would anticipate redeveloping
16:16 Quite a bit of the uses that are in the main lodge within the new redevelopment. Sort of like ground floor retail component of the new lodging and so forth. That would be on the snow front, so to speak. And that in turn would allow us to tear down a substantial part of the main lodge and open up what we call the ski beach down in front and the ski out at the bottom of the slope. So very much there will definitely be redevelopment of the main lodge services in the new redevelopment, which will...
16:45 Then allow us to tear down a portion of the existing main lodge building. It likely will keep the four-story portion, the clock tower. And there might be then a kind of a rebuild on that end for a new kind of cafeteria service on that side of the building. But all to be determined. A lot of work to do there. It's, you know, a lot of work to work through on a big-scale, specific land like that and a lot of details to figure out. And make no mistake, make no mistake, it's going to take many, many, many years, right, to
17:14 Fully redevelop the property because it's going to be subject, you know, just the timing of doing the CEQA and the planning is lengthy. You know, I'd expect it's 18 months to 24 months if we're really pushing hard through the process. And then after that, it's, you know, all the other, you know, timing of the economy and development cycles and pandemics and everything else that's going on in the world these days that just affect your ability to do these things.
17:44 So, you know, it takes time. It's likely going to take, you know, multiple phases of work to get it implemented, and obviously that will spread out over time. But, yeah, we're super excited about it. You know, ownership's very excited about it and definitely looking forward to moving forward with entitling the property. I'm curious with your, with the Western property, I know the monthly contract assessment, parts of it contributes towards these capital upgrades that you're referring to.
18:16 What happens if homeowners don't want to contribute or don't want to be part of the program? Does that mean there's not going to be renovation to their unit? I don't want to speak too out of school because I'm not involved in the details of the project, but yeah, I mean, I understand that as part of their fees, there's reserves retained for improvements and so forth. I know there's been challenges, too, when properties have turned over that
18:47 The homeowners that put those monies in didn't necessarily have to leave them there. So, in some cases, they took them when they sold. So, you know, it's, we, Mammoth Mountain, Mammoth Hospitality Management, are offering a very attractive, basically no interest financing package to the owners where they can finance it through us and then just pay it back over time through their future rental revenues.
19:16 Just basically a 50-50 split with them to pay it back so they don't have to come up with the big chunk out of pocket right up front. They can pay it back through their future rentals to make it more enticing. So that's just something we're doing to incentivize the program and get it accomplished. And we actually did a smaller version of this.
19:36 At Juniper Springs Lodge and also at the Village in a few years prior to this with success and it's turned out to be a pretty good program. And that's, you know, as you look at the condo hotel product type, you know, that is the challenge is that ongoing upkeep of the property over time because it is individually owned, it's up to the owner's discretion whether they want to improve their unit. Most people have been, you know, agreeable to it and understand the necessity for it.
20:02 So, yeah, it's, you know, I would say it's, you know, again, 210 out of 225 people who are participating in the program, and that's a, you know, that's a huge number, so I think it's working. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Tom. I appreciate you coming out today. Any other public comments? Jenna Carter, Code Enforcement for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Just wanted to give a quick update from last month. We have 30 current open cases right now. They are all sitting in, mostly sitting in February.
20:39 I have some that are still current from September 1 case that's open from September and then
21:12 One from October, one from November, and then it kind of builds up from there, but yeah, this is a problem, children. Thank you. Any other public comments for items not on the agenda? Okay, we'll close public comment and move on to business matters, the first being the 2019 Town of Mammoth Lakes Annual Planning Report. Sandra?
21:37 Thank you. Kim Hook's actually going to present this item, but before we start on this item, I just wanted to let the commission know and any members of the public know that item two, the multi-use facility item, we're requesting that that item be continued to another Planning Commission meeting, possibly April, possibly May. We'd like to kind of take a step back and look at the design and then bring it back to you. So we will not be considering that item today. If there's anyone that wanted to speak on that item?
22:04 That would like to speak. We can take comments on it. However, the commission won't be considering anything today. Okay. Thank you. Would you like to take any public comments on that now? We can. We can just take this item out of order. Did you want to speak on it? Dan O'Connell, Recreation Commission. I was just here to kind of monitor the discussion and to see where it was going and to add my support and comments on whatever direction.
22:40 It was moving. And to say that everything that we've seen so far, the rec commission and also the ad hoc committee, of which I'm a part, along with some members of MLR, were very positive about the way it's looking right now. But if it's going to be continued, then I'm going to take my leave. All right. Thank you. I just want to say hello and touch base. Thank you. Thank you.
23:13 So with that, we can move on to the annual planning report. Kim? Good afternoon, commissioners. The annual planning report before you summarizes the town's planning activities that took place during the 2019 calendar year. And annual planning reports are a state requirement. The purpose of them is to provide local legislative bodies and the public with information regarding the implementation of the general plan.
23:43 The general plan is a long-term blueprint for the community's vision of future growth. The APR, annual planning report, we just call them APRs, can be useful to inform the public regarding progress in meeting the community's goals. The state requires APRs to be submitted to the California Office of Planning and Research. We refer to them as OPR, as well as the Department of Housing and Community Development. We refer to them as HCD. They require the
24:13 The annual planning report be submitted prior to April 1st of each year and APRs must be presented to the local legislative body for review and acceptance and we usually include these reports as a consent or discussion item on a regular agenda. The APR
24:32 consists of two primary parts. The first is the report that outlines how the general plan was implemented during the reporting period, and the second is a housing element annual progress report. The state requires that the annual housing element progress report be formatted in a certain way. They have tables that we fill out, and those were included as attachment A to your packet.
24:56 The reports are intended to provide enough information for decision makers, so PEDC and Town Council review the report. It's intended to assess whether any course adjustments need to occur or if modifications to the general plan should be made in order to approve implementation process. The State Office of Planning and Research uses APRs to identify statewide trends in land use
25:23 decision making and how local planning and development activities relate to their statewide planning goals and policies. They also inform modification to OPR's general plan guidelines and submission of housing element annual progress reports is an eligibility requirement for several state funding programs. This year I'm happy to say that the primary annual planning report is on time.
25:51 I think you guys last reviewed the annual planning reports in December, so we're on track this year. And aside from that, I've received several comments from the town manager this afternoon. He's requested that some additional information and minor clarifications to the report be included prior to the report going to town council for their consideration. Some of those clarifications were related to mobility element implementation for the airport.
26:20 And clarification on transit funding, what the funding source is. So they were pretty minor, no really substantive changes to the document itself. And so at this time, I would request that the Planning and Economic Development Commission receive the report and direct staff to present the report to Town Council at their March 18th meeting. I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have. Jessica? No questions.
26:53 Since I didn't see the additional items that you were talking about. They're not included. We just got them today, so she just gave a brief. Sure. So it was on page, it was under the mobility element section, and it's on page 15. So under the public transit, public transit header, Dan had asked that we clarify the statement.
27:26 where we say town continues contract with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority to provide community transit services which are funded with dedicated tax increment financing. Dan was kind enough to correct that to community transit and occupancy tax revenue and dedicated transit funds. Greg? Nothing. I have no further questions.
28:00 So we just need a consensus that we're going to accept this document, is that correct? Yes, and I don't know if there's any members of the public that would like to make comments or speak on it, so we can allow anyone who would like to speak on it as well. Okay. Any members of the public wishing to comment? All right. To make a motion to accept. I'll move to accept the 2019 Town of Mammoth Lakes Annual Planning Report. Second. I will agree. Aye. Okay.
28:37 That moves us to the consent agenda. Does anyone want to make a motion to approve that? Make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Okay. By the way, thank you, Kim, for the report. Appreciate that. That brings us to commissioner reports. Jessica, would you like to go first? Yeah, nothing to report on my end. Okay. Greg? Nothing. All?
29:14 Yeah. Okay. Because we have no executive meeting. Not in the last month. Okay. So Paul and I had the opportunity to go to the Planning Commission Academy in Sacramento with Sandra. And I have to say, I just want to thank the town for extending the invitation and providing this opportunity for us to go because
29:46 I feel like the four years that I've been on this Planning Commission is taking me this long to figure out pretty well what we're doing. And I learned so much here. There's a lot of stuff for new commissioners, but there's also a tremendous amount of information for experienced commissioners. So I would like to just ask that the town consider sending.
30:10 Commissioner over here or two to this because it was really beneficial for me. One of the big things we discussed was developmental agreements and considering that's come before the commission previously and none of us had experience with it or really knew where to start tackling that. It was a great reinforcement of information, especially after we had the workshop.
30:35 Learning about developmental agreements. And I really feel like I'm more confident to be able to go in and know what to ask for and to know what to expect from one. So that was one of the key topics that I felt really helped me. Let's see. We talked about the general plan. We talked about mobility and the ADUs.
31:04 Yes, housing. There was a lot of housing. That was the big topic this time. And it just, for me, we had the opportunity to go tour affordable housing in Truckee. And that really opened my eyes to see what we could do here. Gave me kind of an idea of public space between the buildings. How much is a lot? How much is not enough?
31:32 They had two-story and three-story samples. We walked through some, and I feel like we are going to provide a really good product to our community. So thank you for the opportunity to do that. And Paul, is there anything you wanted to add to it? From what I saw, it was after that experience, I was really thankful, especially what Sandra had done.
32:03 for staff and for us and just keeping us really informed as to what a commissioner, how should a commissioner conduct him or herself up here and also in the public. And you can see that it was interesting to see some of the folks and some of the planners on at the meeting and they've been there for
32:33 15, 20 years serving as Planning Commissioners and some of the questions that they have asked, I was floored by it. So I just want to thank Sandra and staff and of course the town for the opportunity. I'd like to second that. I mean, you guys make us very prepared and compared to some of the other people we, and granted there were
33:03 seemed like they're very educated commissioners as well. But I really felt like Paul and I, the rest of this commission is very prepared and know what we're doing compared to some of those. So that that's all because of you. And thank you very much. Moving on to the director's report. Thank you.
33:29 I wanted to provide the commission with kind of a brief update on a program that the town's working on. There is a group called the Institute for Local Government. They work with the League of California Cities and they approached the town in summer of last year and invited us to participate in a program.
33:50 called BOOST. And basically what BOOST stands for is it's a program to build awareness of funding opportunities available to address climate action, organize projects to be best positioned to meet goals, optimize existing resources and build more capacity.
34:07 Strengthen relationships with key stakeholders and identify new opportunities for regional engagement and collaboration and transform their approach to addressing climate action. So basically this is kind of a program to, it's really underlies climate change and trying to prevent climate change. So they met with us in
34:30 Late summer last year and basically talked to us about what are the issues that you have? And when I say us, I mean the department heads and Dan. Kind of what are the issues that the town sees? And we spent a couple hours just kind of walking through kind of things that we see as issues. And the biggest thing I think that rose to the top was funding opportunities, in particular funding for the parcel. So they sent over an MOU to the town and we presented that to town council. So it's a free program. And basically all they do is they're kind of our eyes and ears right now.
34:59 Grant programs. So they were instrumental. They notified us of a grant that we were aware of called the Infrastructure Infill Grant, IIG. And basically it's a grant that allows
35:14 Agencies to use that grant money for infrastructure for affordable housing projects. So they made us aware of it. The current round right now is an over-the-counter round, so it's not competitive for rural agencies. So it was a really big opportunity for us. And I think we kind of were aware of it, but we hadn't picked a developer yet. We hadn't kind of gone down that path yet. But we worked with them and we were able to submit the grant application the date.
35:43 So we submitted a grant for $19 million, $19 million for infrastructure for the parcel. And so if it's an over-the-counter and we meet all the requirements, which we think we do, then we'll be allocated that funding. So it's been a really good program so far. When I was in Sacramento, I met with the representatives and they basically said, what else can we do for you?
36:08 Tell us how we can help. So it's a really good partnership so far. And so they're working with us on a bunch of other projects as well, trying to kind of bring some funding to the town. So with that being said, on the parcel, I'll be very quick, we did pick a developer. So we picked Pacific Companies, which has done, they built Aspen Village, they've done some work.
36:31 They've actually done a lot of work. So we did choose that developer, and so we're working right now on negotiations with them on a contract. And with that, that completes my report. Do you have any questions on the boost program or anything? Just a question on the developer. Are they a California company? Are they out of state? Idaho. They're from Idaho.
36:56 But they're doing a lot of work in California. In fact, two of the projects we, I think two of the projects we saw in Truckee were built by that developer. Do they just focus on affordable housing? Yeah. Okay. That's great news on both. Thank you. Can that boost program be used to have a parcel-wide Wi-Fi to where each individual occupant wouldn't have to have a separate commercial account, but rather if they qualify to live there?
37:29 There would be some sort of overriding parcel Wi-Fi that would be included in there. So the IIG grant can fund broadband. So it's $19 million, and we kind of, in the grant, we identified a suite of things we might use the money for. So once we get the money, we kind of get further down the road, we'll decide what we use it for. Clearly, I think that's an important component.
37:54 Of any project here in town that we build. But it can be used for broadband. What are some of the constraints of that 19, if any? The constraints are we are limited to the unit mix and the affordability mix. So we have put together a preliminary affordability mix and unit mix. And so if we change that, we could...
38:20 Not be eligible for as much funding, but it's a reimbursement basis, so they would just lower the amount that we could get reimbursed for, but we would know that in advance. We wouldn't spend $19 million and then find that out later. So we'll be kind of honing in on this and then kind of getting to a better number as we move forward in the project, but we really thought it was important to get the grant in early. What's the timeline on that? Seven years. You have to spend the money within seven years. Seven years.
38:55 Any other questions? I just want to state for whoever might be watching on Granicus to, if you get the time to take a look at the annual planning report, going back to that, because I don't think as a community we appreciate everything that this town does, how hard that everyone works. And when I was reviewing it, just how much the Planning Commission has done and the Recreation Department,
39:27 There is so much greatness that we've accomplished in the past year and it's a helpful reminder when people think, oh, we don't do anything, things move slow in this town, look at this report because we really, we've done a lot. And so with that, I'd like to adjourn the regular meeting of the Planning and Economic Commission and our next meeting will be held on April 8th at 2 p.m.