Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2026
Eastern Sierra Council of Governments
at 08:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findingsTranscript
390 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Okay. Okay. So, okay, good morning, everybody. Welcome to the August 26, 2026 regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. We will start this morning with our roll call. Angie? Thank you. Supervisor Oral? Present. Supervisor Griffiths? Presente.
0:29 Supervisor Salcedo is absent today. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Council Member Schwartz? Here. Supervisor McFarland? Here. Present. I believe Council Member Kong is absent today. And Council Member Bill Souser in Mammoth? Present. Thank you. Okay. We have a quorum. Council Member Wentworth, if you would please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. My pleasure. Ready?
1:07 Begin. Congratulations to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Council Member Wentworth. We will move on to public comments. Let's see. This time is set aside to receive public comment on matters not calendared on the agenda. Is there anyone?
1:39 in the room who would like to address the board at this time. Is there anybody online? I have no comments at this time. Okay, thank you. We will move on then to our consent agenda. Is there any discussion for the consent agenda? Is there any public comment on the consent agenda? No comments. Okay, no comment. With that, I will entertain a motion to approve item 4.1. So moved.
2:13 Thank you, Council Member Schwartz. Second. Thank you, Supervisor Griffiths. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Thank you. And I'm sorry, I apologize, since we are doing... Oh, we have to do a roll call. Sorry, my bad. Yes. Thank you. Vice Chair Oral? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes.
2:44 And Board Member Souser. Present, or yes, or whatever. Thank you. We're all having a little bit of a rough start this morning. We will get there. Okay. Okay. Thank you, Angie. Okay, we'll move on to item 5.1.
3:08 approve amendment number one to agreement between ESCOG and Ken Etzel for the provision of regional recreation coordination services to extend the term and increase total compensation. Ms. Kabbalah. Good morning, Chair Oral. Good morning, Board. As always, a pleasure to see you. This first item is requesting an extension to the contractor agreement between
3:34 ESCOG and Kenneth Etzel to provide regional recreation coordination services. Mr. Etzel hired on to serve as a contractor to provide capacity support last September. He provides support for managing Chipmunk Canyon, managing our collaborative initiative, and also providing additional services in coordinating convening meetings, including the Collab Summit.
4:03 Doing case study work, doing surveys and outreach to the recreation community. This position is funded through a blend of grant funds. For the initial term, it was funded 50% by Sierra Jobs First Capacity Funding and 50% by an Inyo National Forest Service Liaison Grant that was provided to build capacity in ESCOG to support wildfire and recreation coordination services.
4:31 We have an opportunity to extend our Sierra Jobs First projects. I have found that Mr. Essel has really learned a lot and has become extremely helpful in providing capacity.
4:47 to support ESCOG, particularly in recreation, and there is additional work to be done for some time for the International Forest Liaison Services. So I would like to request that your board extend the contract through December 31st, 2026.
5:06 That will coincide with the extension that I'd like to request to support the collaborative initiative under Sierra Jobs First and will be funded by the Inyo National Liaison Forest Service Grant in the amount of $25,000. Okay. Thank you. Does anybody have any questions, comments, or further discussion at this time? I have a couple questions. Council Member Wentworth. Good morning.
5:31 Can you share a little bit about the nature of the Inyo National Forest funding? What is the term of that? Does that go on year over year? Just understand a little bit more what the color of that money is. The Inyo National Forest Service liaison funding was provided to ESCOG a couple of years ago.
5:54 because the Inyo National Forest wanted to support developing a regional organization that could coordinate recreation activities and wildfire capabilities across the Eastern Sierra. They wanted to have sort of a point liaison that could work with local jurisdictions, identify what some of the priorities are.
6:15 both in recreation and in wildfire, and basically build a coordinated effort to draw down funding. The deliverables are to develop an ecosystem map, project priorities, and identify funding mechanisms that would support a Forest Service Regional JPA partnership into the future and help provide some structure around that. The work
6:44 for the wildfire component of that has largely been accomplished through the establishment of the Wildfire Alliance, and so most of that work is really focusing in working with recreation partners, in particular small community groups. They were hoping to have a better understanding of who the community groups are out there and what some of the priorities are in that space. Nathan Sill, who is the Acting Forest Service Supervisor,
7:11 I still struggle with some of their terminology in their org chart. I had also asked if we could use that wildfire funding component to work on convening partners in the biomass space going forward. The grant expires, I believe, in March 2028. Okay, and what's the value of the grant? It was $150,000, and there's about $95,000, $98,000 remaining. Okay, and that expires in 2028. Okay, great. Thank you.
7:40 Anybody else? Any questions? Yes. The deliverables that are included in the contract aren't going to change. We're just going to shift the timing. The project is basically still the same, though. Yes. Okay, cool. Thanks. Okay. If there's no further discussion, is there any public comment on this item? Okay, see no public comment. I will entertain a motion to approve. Just one other point of discussion. I've been a...
8:09 Nonprofit role on the board I serve on, we've been doing something called Sierra Works as part of Jobs First. And I think that the Sierra Business Council, which is managing these programs, just announced like a week or so ago that these opportunities for these project extensions exist, but there's a lot of very complex, tricky, bureaucratic stuff in there. So I think, from my perspective, I don't have any problem extending this contract, but I think the board should be aware of
8:37 The ability of the ESCOG to get those extensions out of SBC is kind of another question. So those are those other items coming up after. So I just want to make sure you're all aware that the bureaucratic challenges working with SBC have been pretty formidable. Yes, we will take that discussion back up on our next item. I will entertain a motion to approve item 5.1. Go move. Second.
9:09 Thank you, Supervisor Griffiths and Supervisor McFarland. Angie, if you would do the roll call, please. Feister Oral? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes. And Board Member Souser? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Motion carries. Okay. We'll move on to item 5.2.
9:41 This is approved Sierra Jobs First, no cost extension program between Sierra Business Council and the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments for Sierra Jobs First Catalyst Funding Awards and authorize Executive Director to negotiate. I will hand it back over to Ms. Kavala. Good morning once again. As Council Member Wentworth just described,
10:07 About a week ago, the Sierra Business Council announced that they have received their contract from the state for a no-cost extension to Sierra Jobs First through June 30th, 2027. So there's no additional funding that will be awarded to them or to any of the subgrants.
10:29 But there is an extension on the projects. This is very valuable. As you'll remember, the timeline for project implementation under the Sierra Jobs First projects was incredibly expedited. The ability to get any of those projects done on that timeline was extremely difficult. I think all grantees have been really diligent in trying to meet that timeline. But I think that it will be extremely valuable for ESCOG to be able to take advantage of those extensions.
10:58 for the quality and the outcome of our projects, as well as to draw down funding for the Business Resource Center, which we are administering funding to incubate at this time. We currently have three projects that we are administering under Sierra Jobs First. The first is the Business Resource Center Catalyst Program.
11:21 that is providing programmatic funding to support the Business Resource Center, so providing small business consulting services, marketing, web development, bringing speakers, leadership classes, and other capacity to build that program. That project has
11:43 I apologize, I don't have the numbers off the top of my head. I think $113,000 approximately remaining to be spent. So I would like to be able to extend that contract through June 30th, 2027 so that they can draw down all of those funds. Chipmunk Canyon, existing conditions analysis. We are approaching the development of a final deliverable for that. Alta Planning and Design has
12:11 been really diligent in meeting the expedited timeline, but additional time for that project will allow for a more polished final project. It will allow for some additional outreach to the land management agencies and to the tribes to make sure that that final deliverable meets their needs and that we've been transparent in communicating with the stakeholders associated in that project.
12:40 I anticipate that even with the extension, that project can be completed by November. And the final award is the Eastern Sierra Regional Collaborative Capacity Incubator, which funded, among other things, the CoLab Summit to bring together partners to get
12:57 Better sense and input around regional collaboration, how ESCOG can support gaps and needs in the region to fill that role. And we are working with Agnew Beck to develop a strategic plan.
13:11 That will be a strategic document for ESCOG moving forward that is based on the input we received from regional leadership, other agencies, from the community, and of course from your board at a September board retreat. That project also, the extension, will allow for a better polished project and a better opportunity to incorporate your board's feedback after that workshop. Currently the contracts for those are set to expire September 30th.
13:40 For Chipmunk Canyon, again, I apologize, I could pull these numbers up if you need them. I don't recall that I put them in the staff report. I think that there is approximately $50,000 remaining on that. It will wind down the rest of the project. And then there's about $80,000 remaining on the collaborative project. The collaborative project is also funding the...
14:02 Agricultural Activation Plan for the Eastern Sierra, and that funding is set to expire in mid-September. The Sierra Business Council made this announcement. They made an application available that closed yesterday to request the extension.
14:24 I went ahead and I submitted the extension request. There hasn't been much transparency or clarity about whether or not when we might anticipate an agreement amendment from them, if there will be an agreement amendment, if there will be a formal approval process and what will be required of that. So I am asking your board to delegate authority to the executive director to be able to enter into those extensions as needed if SBC does
14:53 provide an amended agreement. There's obviously very fast turnaround to comply with their deadlines and we will not have a board meeting that I would hope we are not putting action items on the board workshop in September.
15:08 Thank you.
15:38 I got a question. So I know, because again, we've been very close to this. Part of the ability to be able to apply for these extensions is to be current with SBC in terms of invoicing and all that kind of stuff. Can you share with the board where we're at with SBC in those terms? Yeah, I'm happy to do that. I think I included in my staff report that the grant reporting.
16:08 on this project has been especially onerous. It has been extremely difficult. Sometimes there is direction either from the state or Sierra Business Council to after invoices are submitted to make changes, which necessitates going back and making modifications to things. So it just feels like it's been very cumbersome and redundant.
16:32 We went through an internal audit that SBC conducted on the Business Resource Center in May, and I believe that they have all the required documentation that they need at this time for the Business Resource Center, all of the backup, et cetera, that they are requiring for those. We haven't received any feedback at this time for
16:56 the other two projects, that they have requested additional information on those. One of the things that's been very challenging in that, in terms of backup, is that they require documentation from the Mono County Treasurer's Office, which is fine, as a proof of purchase, but it...
17:19 Does delay being able to provide the invoices by a month because the Mono County Treasurer's Office needs to close their books before they can prepare the report that SBC is requiring in the middle of the month?
17:32 One of the things that I'm hopeful for in these extensions is that it will allow some time for administration reporting on the back end of project completion so that we can close out the projects through Mono County and provide general ledgers within the extension of the grant.
17:56 For September 30th, my goal is to have all the invoices and backup materials prepared and submitted before September 30th, which is a condition of the extension to the absolute best of our ability. No more questions. We'll have some comments when you're ready for deliberation. Are there any other questions from the board? Then I will hand it back over to council members. A thought would be with this. Is it, I don't have any problem.
18:23 Going forward with this, I think it makes sense, but I would really encourage staff and Ken and others, members of your team, to really have a plan B in place because there's a real opportunity that you might not get an extension by the time you get to September 30th, which is when the contracts expire for these individual projects. You may have to go dark for a while while SBC is trying to get their stuff together. So I'd really encourage you to try to get these things done if you can within the September 30th deadline.
18:53 Perhaps be prepared to give a report back to the board to understand, like, we have not gotten the contract extensions from SBC yet by October. You know, things might have to go dark for a while. Just given the nature of dealing with SBC, it might take some time. Yeah, I appreciate that caution. Obviously, we would not be negotiating any extensions on the contracts for subconsultants until there is assurance.
19:20 and a document in hand from SBC that we have those extensions. It will make planning for how to close those projects out exceptionally challenging. Thank you. Just a note of caution. I do not disagree. Anybody else? Okay. Okay, if there's no further discussion, then is there any public comment on this item? No? Anything online? No comments at this time.
19:50 Looks like Ms. Cabal has one more thing to add. If I might add, particularly because Ms. Moberly is present, I am extremely grateful to the Mono County Finance Department in their help in navigating the reporting on this. Good. Thank you. Yeah, as member agencies, we are definitely here to support. Okay, with that, I will entertain a motion to approve Item 5.2 as recommended. So moved. Thank you, Council Member Wentworth. Do I have a second? Second.
20:19 Thank you, Council Member Schwartz. Angie, if you would please conduct a roll call. Vice Chair Oral? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes. And Board Member Souser? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Item carries. Thank you. Okay. We will move on to Item 5.3. It looks like we're going to have a
20:49 Presentation from Lindsay Gucker from Planet Planning to provide direction on the Sierra Jobs First Eastern Sierra Agriculture Activation Plan. While she's setting up, I'll hand it back over to Ms. Kabbalah. Thank you, Carol. I just want to provide a little bit of introduction for the next three items as well as an introduction to Ms. Gucker as well.
21:16 As we discussed in the last item, the Sierra Jobs First projects operated under an extremely tight timeframe for implementation, and so all of our subcontractors have done a wonderful job in doing their best to meet those timelines.
21:38 Given that we did not have much communication from Sierra Business Council on the timeline of the extensions, I have brought forward all three projects today to provide presentations to your board in anticipation that this would be the last time the board could provide input if we are not able to get an agreement by September 30th for these three projects.
22:01 As I mentioned in the last item, the Eastern Sierra Agricultural Activation Plan falls under the Eastern Sierra Collaborative Initiative, which is again really about capacity mapping in the primary industry sectors of the Eastern Sierra, recreation, the work that we are doing in wildfire resiliency and agriculture.
22:23 Some of the work coming out of the agricultural space, the agricultural activation plan was incubated by ESCOG because there was not another applicant that could provide the fiscal administration services to serve the region for the study. So we're very happy to host and incubate that project even though agriculture is not one of the key.
22:47 core programmatic areas of ESCOG. That being said, as you'll see at the end of Lindsay's presentation, there is needs, gaps and needs to better support agriculture in the Eastern Sierra through some regional coordination. So look forward to having board discussion both today, but also as we move through a strategic plan to understand if ESCOG should have a role and what that would look like in the future. With that, I'm very pleased to introduce Ms. Ducker. She has been
23:16 Absolutely incredible asset in pulling this project together. I felt very fortunate to have this type of talent and capacity located here in the Eastern Sierra and to be able to support building capacity in this type of consulting work within our region. Thank you.
23:34 Thank you, Elaine. Good morning, everyone. Good morning. It is my pleasure to present today on the Eastern Sierra Agriculture Activation Plan. This plan is presented as a strategic roadmap to support agriculture within Inyo and Mono counties. It has been my pleasure to prepare this plan in partnership with the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments with support from Elaine, as well as with support from our Agricultural Commissioner within Inyo and Mono counties.
24:03 As Elaine mentioned, this project was funded via a California Jobs First Catalyst grant. And the vision for this plan is to support a diverse, resilient, and community-connected future for agriculture in our region. The core objectives of this plan include addressing challenges confronting our agricultural sector, identifying opportunities to improve resilience through diversification within agriculture.
24:31 to promote pathways for agricultural stewardship of the land that is environmentally sound and with quality land management. Additionally, we are looking to enhance economic opportunities within the agricultural sector and promote local food production, all while supporting an equitable local food system that benefits all residents.
24:56 In essence, the Eastern Sierra Agriculture Activation Plan provides local government, agricultural producers, and project partners with an actionable plan that includes regionally informed strategies that are pertinent and applicable here, as well as a wealth of resources to move this into the future. Altogether, agriculture in our area is ripe for strategic diversification.
25:23 This sector is highly dependent on two main production systems, the first being livestock in the form of cattle, the second being alfalfa. These two consistently make up over 90% of our total production value, and our production as a whole is constrained by limited private land access, water allotments and allocations, decisions being made outside of our region, as well as
25:53 Constrained lease arrangements. This system is highly sensitive to drought, to water allocations, as I mentioned, decisions being made outside of our region, as well as to distinct commodity price swings that we experience here within the agricultural sector while selling to external markets. The opportunity here is to build on a 2017 economic report of agriculture in our region, which revealed really promising
26:22 Emerging interest in small-scale specialty production, value-added enterprises, and all pointing towards an untapped market potential here in the region. So building on this 2017 study, this plan engaged many local residents, agricultural producers, through a stakeholder engagement process. This process involved surveys of our general population as well as agricultural producers.
26:49 I also had the opportunity to interview 70 individuals that are representative of local government, agricultural producers, land management agencies, local nonprofits, and business owners. The key takeaways coming out of these engagements included the need for additional regulatory clarity, so streamlining processes for producers to understand which regulations apply to them and how to become compliant.
27:17 Secondly, infrastructure improvements. So identifying that we have a dearth of infrastructure and support for our local producers for market access as well as processing. Third being the strong desire within our region to preserve our agricultural and cultural identity and heritage here in the region. Fourth being improving access to land, water, and land management support and resources.
27:46 And lastly, the strong desire within our community to support a local food market and improve supply and access. Coming into this report, we have several strategy areas that support agriculture across multiple channels. The first being foundationally land access, land management practices, product diversification.
28:11 Service Diversification, Markets and Marketing, as well as Education and Workforce. All of these come together as opportunities to support agriculture in the region. We have identified many strategies in each of these strategy areas and have ranked and prioritized them according to the criteria you see here, impact, feasibility, timeline, and cost. So in evaluating each of these strategies, we've identified project implementation partners where they exist.
28:41 and categorize these across five tiers. The first tier is our foundational set of strategies that is ready for implementation. These focus on regulatory clarification, zoning updates, lease updates, and processing and market access. Tier two is leveraging partner-led education strategies within the region for our agricultural businesses. Tier three is platform or existing
29:11 Model-based strategies. These are using strategies that exist outside of our region and adapting and applying them here. Cross-sector Tier 4 addresses land management needs by leveraging existing leadership across the region in different sectors. And Tier 5 addresses strategies for further development. So these are necessary and due for...
29:39 Development and will require additional work and funding. So I'll give a brief overview of each of the strategy tiers and if there are any questions I welcome them. Tier one is our foundational ready for implementation strategies, the first being a producer resource guide. This responds directly to the requests from our local producers for clarification on regulatory frameworks.
30:06 Easy access to the appropriate entities and agencies and individuals here locally for how to access those rules and regulations and how to comply. It also comprises a business startup package with a library of resources on everything from obtaining land through point of sale for our producers. Some examples of this producer resource guide are presented here. These are from outside the region.
30:34 Things that we could adopt and be inspired by as we develop this resource, including a farmer portal from CDFA, SISU FarmCo, and the Nevada County farmer portal. Lindsay? Yes, of course. Just a quick question. You mentioned an untapped market, and this kind of starts to look more at the economic strategy viewpoint of this.
31:02 With the local producers as they are now and possibly in the future if they're able to expand, do you see the market remaining local or do you see it eventually going global where our producers here in the Valley are able to not only sustain our local markets but possibly start to export and grow? Yeah, great question. I think beginning here, currently at present, we have most of our market
31:32 That is selling outside of the region. Most of our production is being sold elsewhere. So infilling first with internal markets here in our region to help support a local food system, fiber shed, flowers, you know, anything that we can produce here, sell it to our local community because there is a huge demand, very strongly.
31:55 Resounding feedback from the surveys that people are in demand of our locally produced agricultural products. So filling that first. And then if there is capacity and if there is a high yielding market outside of the region, then we encourage our producers to be able to reach that. I think some of the influences and issues we have here in trying to meet our needs here locally and then beyond is infrastructure. That's speaking to
32:23 Processing and Storage, this letter E here on the slide. Essentially, we have a lack of resources for processing, packaging, distribution, anything that would allow a producer to not only serve the local market, but export as well. So we would need to support them in those capacities first. Okay, thank you. Of course, my pleasure. The second would be a producer directory. This is a consumer-focused resource. This is connecting local...
32:51 Business owners, local residents, to our local producers via an up-to-date register of producers and what they produce. Third would be LADWP lease amendments, so recommendations that are strategic and in direct response to the incoming input from producers on how their lease arrangements with the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power could be updated to support them, whether that's for
33:17 The succession and legacy of their families or for diversification within their operations. Additionally, we have zoning update recommendations within both Inyo County and Mono County. These have been reviewed with the planning departments and identified as opportunities to expand on our zoning to accommodate the future of agriculture here. Things like allowing for greenhouses for season extension, for example.
33:44 As I mentioned briefly, processing and storage is a real need here. The next step in that process would be to undergo a feasibility study to assess specifically what cold storage processing and distribution networks we could develop here to serve the needs of our local producers. This has been...
34:07 Assessed in the past, and I think it's time to review this again. The last report was in 2011, and I think there's room to expand on that. Lastly, improving local market access. This is for both the consumer and the producer side, improving the distribution networks, not only for those who are willing to pay, but those who cannot, and improving that connection, that bridge between our local producers and local community members.
34:37 Tier 2 strategies are leveraging existing partners and professional-led support for our agricultural producers. These come in three main categories, agricultural business management, generational transitions and succession planning, as well as marketing support for our producers. Some of these are already underway via the Business Resource Center with support from the UC ANR extension agents we have here.
35:07 Tier 3 is leveraging established platforms and models from outside the region, adapting and adopting them here. These include land-sharing platforms to connect landowners who have excess land that they are willing to use for agriculture with active aspiring agricultural producers. Forever Farms model being a long-term conservation strategy that applies easements to land to keep it in agriculture in perpetuity.
35:36 The third being a land-back initiative. This has been successful in other regions of California where land is allocated back to its tribal members. Tier four strategies is leveraging leadership across land management agencies, working towards collaborative solutions for irrigation efficiency, compost at scale, fire mitigation, and weed management. Each of these...
36:03 Strategies has leadership in the region and could be better used in connection with agriculture. Last but not least, we have our strategies for further development. These have been identified as long-term opportunities for agriculture in the region. Agritourism being a really promising sector that combines both agriculture with our largest economic driver being tourism.
36:29 Identifying our region as a place known for its agriculture in addition to its beautiful landscapes and recreation opportunities. Additionally, a producer network. This is a producer-led initiative that would help support new producers as well as help collaboration amongst our local producers to leverage their collective tacit knowledge. Youth Pathways is fostering the next generation of our agricultural producers.
36:57 Including training programs, everything from early childhood, first experiences with agriculture, all the way through Cerro Coso level education and programming to support the next generation. Lastly, food education. This is supporting our general population to better understand the value of locally produced food and support of the local producers. So all of the strategies come together.
37:26 to support agriculture in our region, and in return, agriculture can serve as an engine for regional resilience. So looking at the economic input of agriculture to our region, we have approximately 60 million coming in both Inyo and Mono County collectively as of 2024. This is a large economic driver within the region. We have the opportunity to leverage this driver not only as
37:50 an economic engine, but also as a resilience engine through wildfire mitigation, overlapping with some of the priorities that we already have here in the region. Things like land stewardship, wildfire mitigation, food security. Our population, this 10 to 15 percent population number of food insecure individuals is the bare minimum. This is, you know, the county reported numbers, but the numbers actually exist quite high within our
38:20 Youth and in our student populations, even higher than that 10 to 15 percent, seeing numbers up to 60 percent food insecurity within that young population, and that is a deep concern. I think it is an opportunity for agriculture to help infill, have some of our local producers be able to support that food security.
38:41 Additionally, of the surveyed residents within our region, 90% of them expressed the willingness to pay more for local food, highlighting that there is a strong demand to reduce the reliance on external food chains and bring that back here locally into our local economy. For 69%. 90%. I combined both because 69% was willingness to pay slightly more.
39:06 And another 21% willingness to pay substantially more. And I received a correction after my last presentation. They're like, couldn't you just combine those two? And yes, we can. Oh, got it. Because in fact, both of those are requesting to pay more or willingness to pay more. Thank you. To successfully implement these strategies, it will require coordinated governance, strategic targeted funding and responsive policy.
39:34 Beginning with governance, aligning across sectors and in between agencies to develop partnerships that are supportive of agriculture and can acquire funding from state-level resources such as we've seen through the California Catalyst Grants through California Jobs First. We can expand our policy to be more responsive to the needs of agriculture into the future.
40:02 One of the strongest needs for implementation here is a coordinated entity or leadership organization coming together to steer this momentum forward. So we have identified the needs, we have a clear set of strategies set in front of us, and we need that momentum to be carried forward through implementation with leadership.
40:27 So before I open it up to general questions, I would love to welcome some input and strategic direction from the board. I'll just reiterate that there are strategies already underway, including producer education at the Business Resource Center here in Bishop. And we have strategies that are ready for implementation, including zoning updates and lease amendments. And once funded, we have a series of strategies that are...
40:54 Ready for implementation, including the producer resource guide and education sessions, producer directory, processing and storage feasibility. And then for consideration, I'll ask the questions and put it out there. Where should the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments focus leadership and support? Whether that's in convening leadership, in identifying where ESCOG can play a convening end.
41:20 Leadership role within the region to continue this implementation momentum or whether that is in more of a collaborative capacity leveraging some of the work that Ken has been doing to try to convene with other sectors such as wildfire, weed management, compost. Can we leverage tourism? How can we bring these priorities of the region together? Thank you, Lindsay. Absolutely.
41:46 I've said it before, but I'll say it again. I really appreciate the work that you've put into this, and it's a really excellent presentation. I do have one question. You say ready once funded. Have you already identified funding sources, or is that an ongoing consideration? Yes, it is somewhat contingent on which strategy, but where there are existing funding sources, whether that's a recurring USDA grant or something of that sort, those are identified within the plan.
42:16 You know, smaller grant funding opportunities for irrigation, for example, under water use needs within California. There's kind of a broad array of the type and style of resources and who can apply for them. We've identified the local resource conservation district as a potential funnel for a lot of that funding. So that has been identified as well. So not only where the funding could come from, but who could apply for it.
42:45 All right, thank you. Yeah. Are there any questions, comments? Yeah, I just want to comment on the resounding desire for the local food products, which I think there is, but I would be cautious to encourage someone to like set up a farm and then that isn't accurate, right? Like there isn't this like demand. Like do we know currently
43:13 If, like, local producers are just, like, outpacing their demand right now, like, are they unable to keep up with, like, their production? That is correct, as evidenced by the Mammoth Farmers Market currently. I think for those producing, you know, at a very small scale with a very, with very limited marketing, they may be...
43:35 Meeting their demands. Okay. But for those producers that are actively marketing and putting themselves out there and making themselves accessible to the local population as well as to the tourist population, they are not even close to able to keep up. Okay. Which is exciting to see. Okay, that's great. Yeah. Supervisor Griffiths. Yeah, as I picked up my box from Blue Heron yesterday, they're picked clean. You know, they're just, yeah, I think the demand is still way above what the production is.
44:08 Thanks. Lovely to see this for a second time. And so on the side of strategies, I would just ask to consider putting in LEDWP lease and use permit amendments, kind of like we spoke before. Thank you for that language. Yeah. And then where should ESCOG focus leadership and support?
44:33 I think that it's possible that there's a role for ESCOG in this moving forward. I think we would definitely need to go back to our agencies and add agriculture as part of, as one of our areas of focus or economic development, and it's under economic development, but I think we would, I think if we are to take a leadership role, we need to make sure that it fits with our bylaws and
45:04 Charter, whatever it is, and, you know, get approval. But, you know, I do think both being a convener and being a conduit for grant money could be a role for ESCOG. But I want to make sure we're not stepping on any toes of RC&Ds or anybody else that is doing this type of thing and make sure that we have buy-in from our respective boards before we start that.
45:37 Okay. Did you want to respond? Yeah, I'll just say thank you. I appreciate the direction. I think that there is going to be an opportunity at the board workshop to think about what ESCOG's role is in convening, which industry sectors it should or should not be engaged in, with one of the goals coming out of that initiative to be able to go back to the member agencies.
46:05 With clearer definition around economic development and in which ways ESCOG is engaged in convening and leadership in that space. So thank you. I appreciate that. And I also agree that a part of that discussion, not in this item, but in the future, is to think about other partners, the RCD, the UCA and our office, the Inyo Mono Ag Commissioner, and where they're
46:34 are either capacity gaps to better support these initiatives either through ESCOG or by building the capacity in those other organizations. I also wanted to add to the question of regarding what is ready once funded. In addition to the really beautiful presentation that Ms. Guckers put together, there is a full report which we can provide here to your board. And within that, the
47:03 model and prototype for that resource directory and the producer resource guide is built out with it is ready to be built into a website with directions to depending on what
47:18 Sort of producer you might be, whether you're looking to open a farm stand or you have a more substantial commercial operation, what the regulatory pathways are and who to contact. But that is an example of not only does that need funding to develop, but there's also a question about who would have ownership of that long term so that there is one centralized place for food entrepreneurs and ag entrepreneurs in the region to access that information, but that it's also updated and current and accurate.
47:47 Currently, one of the things we discovered is that there's a lot of different resources out there providing conflicting information. Thank you. Thank you. Council Member Wentworth. Yeah. Thank you. Wonderful presentation. Is this work that you're working on, has this been funded through Jobs First in any way? Did you have a project? Yes. That project expires the end of September, correct? Correct. Okay, great.
48:12 A couple observations. One is your point about the blue heron, the demand. There's a farmer's market, small market in Mammoth Lakes. The line goes out the door every Wednesday afternoon. The local demand for this is strong. So that's what we're seeing after that there in Mammoth. I think I would encourage you also coming out of the industry sector coordinator for recreation and tourism, there's something called these RECAs, Recommendation Implantation Collaborative Action. Those will be published by the end of the week, certainly by Monday.
48:41 I would encourage you to take a look at those because there are some things in there that I think are recommendations that could help all sectors to implement the kinds of work that we're trying to do. This is local level, state level, things like that. You might want to take a look at that. Finally, in terms of the role of the ESCOG, I think you've heard from Supervisor Griffith, we operate under very specific authorities that have been authorized by the local partners here.
49:09 And I think it's important to caution everybody that there's a little bit of a sugar high that's coming out of Jobs First. It's been a big injection of capacity, but it's a great thing to see. But I think that I would pay very close attention to what's happening with the ESCOG. I think in terms of what the capacity the ESCOG has to do, we're going to be having some real conversations about that coming up.
49:30 You heard mention of a board retreat happening in mid-September, but there's some things certainly coming up later on the agenda that are going to be real priorities for the ESCOG, and I would just caution about looking at the ESCOG to be able to be all things to all people at this point. I think we've all got to be really focusing on what we can actually do and to be providing some of those things in those RECAs may be helpful to start getting.
49:54 A non-governmental consortium together that can be a powerful advocacy voice for your sector, individual counties, state level, federal level, things like that. So just stay tuned on these things. That was similar. That's why I asked the question about funding, because we do have to plan for after Sierra Jobs first. I don't want to see any of these projects be one and done. Yeah.
50:20 So I want these to become part of the threads of our culture. So I thank you, Council Member Wentworth, for that. Supervisor McFarland. Yeah, thanks so much. I've heard from a lot of people in the community that of many of the Sierra Jobs First programs, yours has been especially engaging. So thank you very much. You know, we all know the demand has been there, and it's been there for a couple decades.
50:48 I used to deliver food for Rick when he ran Apple Hill Farms up and down 395. It was constantly sold out. We know the farmer's market in Mammoth, you're right, the line does go all the way to the street repeatedly. But this is an area, when you look at many of the different things that ESCOG works on, this is an area I think that there is a lot of rich leadership already existing, and there's some new emerging organizations such as
51:18 a renewed Inyo Mono RCD, which could really take this forward. You know, we've got the Eastern Sierra Unified School District establishing a career technical education program built around ag. It's popping up all over the place. We have, you know, a compost group that's actually moving forward that could help us with biomass. And I think for ESCOG's role, I think...
51:45 We need to focus on, under your collaborative strategies, that first bullet, the wildfire resilience, weed management, and compost, because they slot into things that we're already heavily invested in, and really look to the Ag Commissioner, UC programs, and the RCD as those convening organizations to move this forward. It's a hard space to move forward collectively because it's so individual.
52:15 It's individualized people who take it upon themselves often to raise and grow food, especially when it's for a local market. And that often is so much more passion than profit. And we've got to balance those two. But this is really exciting. And I do look forward to reading the full report to see, you know, what zoning updates you've identified and how we can make, especially cottage ag in some of our communities, because up in Mono County, we're so...
52:44 Land Limited outside of the Antelope Valley that it's backyards and small properties. Many of the larger lands that have conservation easements on them, they may have been put in place in a way and at a time where creative new techniques are not allowed under the existing easements. So, thanks. Absolutely. My pleasure. Thank you. Council Member Souser, did you have anything?
53:14 No, I'm good. Thank you. Okay. Okay. Are there any other questions or discussion at this time? Okay. If not, then I will say thank you so much for your presentation and for being here this morning. Thank you. Okay. We will move on to item 5.4, presentation from Tim Bevan from Alta Planning and Design. I was wondering if I could take a minute to introduce Tim. Absolutely. Thanks.
53:44 Ken Etzel, Regional Recreation Coordinator with ESCOG. During ESCOG's work with regional land managers on the town-to-trails plan, the BLM, Bureau of Land Management, approached us about a related need, which was identifying funding and support to develop a plan for the unsanctioned Chipmunk Canyon Trail Network, which is located just southwest of town here in Bishop. At the time,
54:14 ESCOG did not have the resources to take on the coordination role. The availability of Sarah Jobs' first funding, however, created an opportunity to begin addressing that need through a current conditions analysis of the trail network. Access to Chipmack Canyon is important to the Bishop community and surrounding residents. It provides a readily accessible recreation area close to town, and because of its lower elevation and generally sunnier conditions,
54:44 offers a valuable winter recreation opportunity for residents of Mammoth Lakes and other communities further up the Eastern Sierra. The network also presents a unique planning challenge. Trails and recreation use extends across multiple jurisdictions and landownerships with management responsibilities shared among several different agencies. To help address the challenge, a leadership team was established with the Inyo National Forest, Bureau of Land Management, and the
55:13 Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. ESCOG has been able to play a unique convening and project management role, bringing these partners together around a shared understanding of the resource and helping move the planning process forward across jurisdictional boundaries. On August 11th, our consultant team from Alta Planning and Design visited the area to begin developing that shared understanding. Tim Bevins led a morning field trip with agency partners.
55:42 and subcontractors focusing on some of the most problematic areas within the network while also identifying potential opportunities and solutions to those problematic areas. That afternoon, the leadership team continued the discussion at Inyo County offices considering what it would take to work together toward a more sustainable recreation resource while protecting the cultural and ecological values of the area. What has been particularly encouraging throughout this process
56:11 from my perspective anyways, has been the response from our agency partners. There's been a strong recognition that the complexity of the Chipmunk Canyon network makes it difficult for any one agency to address the network on its own, and that having ESCOG serve as a neutral convener has created space for the agencies to work through these challenges together. Our partners have expressed real value in having a forum where they can bring their
56:39 respective management responsibilities and perspectives to the same table, develop a shared understanding of the resource and begin identifying solutions collectively. So, like I said, Chippewa Canyon is an important recreation resource for our communities, but is also an opportunity to develop a modern, a model for how we approach complex, multi-jurid distictional recreation planning across the East and Sierra. So, with that, I'd like to introduce Tim Bevans, Project Manager for Malta Planning and Design.
57:09 Tim will provide an overview of the current conditions analysis, share some observations and findings from the field visit, and discuss some potential approaches for moving this forward while protecting the recreation, cultural, and ecological resources in the area. Thanks. Thank you. I will hand it over to Tim Bevan. Great. Good morning, everybody. Can I just confirm that you all can see the presentation screen? Yes, we can see it. Thank you. Okay, excellent.
57:37 And thank you, Ken, for that introduction. Very much appreciated and delighted to be before the board again. Today, we'll be providing an update on the Chipmoke Canyon Phase I study, otherwise known as an existing conditions analysis.
57:53 And today, you know, in the next 15 minutes or so, I want to provide a project refresher and updates, maybe fill in a little color in the lines that Ken just laid out, and then go a little bit deeper into the field work that we conducted earlier this month, highlight some of the emerging themes, and then, of course, talk about next steps and give space for discussion with this body. So what is this project in a nutshell?
58:20 So the goals of this project are first and foremost to produce an accurate baseline of what's out there within Chipmunk Canyon. And even within that, it was defining the boundaries of what we're going to call Chipmunk Canyon. And effectively, you know, that's the area generally south of Burr Road, west of Sunlin, north of the Druid Stones Trail recreation area.
58:44 And we know that over the past decade plus a patchwork of informal trails has proliferated across the landscape. And so the goal of this project was to understand that network and to begin to quantify where those trails are, what sort of baseline biological entities are out there and just
59:07 Hear from the community about what they like, what they don't like, engage with the agencies. Each agency has a different mandate and that's really important when it comes to trails. And as we all know, recreational trails are great and operations and maintenance of those recreational trails are indeed a high bar.
59:25 An essential part of those agencies' jobs. So we need to understand from them what they can do, what they can't do, juxtapose that with the existing trail network out there and what we're hearing from the community. And then, of course, the purpose of all that baselining information is to enable ESCOG, the agencies, and hopefully a stakeholder group,
59:51 a body that forms out of this phase one study, empowering them to be able to take on a implementation roadmap, you know, to start really taking these baseline assessments and applying them in a structured manner to the landscape itself, determining who would be doing the operations and maintenance, you know, whose trail sustainability standards to follow, trail building, things of that nature. So,
1:00:18 Within this project, these are the tasks that we did. We did a desktop analysis. We looked at all the trails. We looked at trails as they were tagged on public websites, such as Strava or AllTrails, Mountain Bike Project. Of course, we spoke with the land managers. We conducted a baseline biological constraints analysis.
1:00:39 A public input map where people could drop pins and draw lines about, I like this trail or this is an area that we shouldn't be going to or it's causing damage, as well as just trends, you know, I like this, I don't like this, I'm coming from here, you know, I come in this time of the day or this time of the month, and how do people use the trails? So, and I'm going to go a little bit quicker through this first section so that we can get to the trail assessments and next steps in the time available.
1:01:08 But the first thing that we did was we had Helix Environmental Consultants, a subconsultant of ours, go out on the land, conduct a field review of their own to provide a baseline biological constraints assessment. This is something that you can then build upon as you form a project definition and a, you know, in the potential need for a NEPA analysis. This is the foundation of the beginning of pursuing that.
1:01:35 That structure. So we got this on, you know, the biological communities as well as the ephemeral trails so that then we have something to layer on additional information. Next, we placed five trail counters throughout the region. As you can see their locations.
1:01:55 These different spots, they're kind of at some pinch points or some common entry locations, areas where we know we expect to have a lot of users and you can see the counts there. Now this, it's important to caveat that this was during the hot times, you know, from mid-May through mid-June and still with that said, we got a lot of counts and then we also
1:02:17 use that to perform a regression analysis and to extrapolate those counts outward across the rest of the year when we were able to juxtapose that with what we heard from the surveys about when people come, when they don't come, as well as the information we're able to see on Strava and other open source data sources.
1:02:36 So we heard from 377 respondents on the public survey, and we also had 93 unique comment or people placing items and pins and comments on the public input map, and we yielded 286 comments out of that. Here is a composite of when we asked folks which trails do they use. So I should say, first we took the entire trail network, we digitized it, and we built that into our public input map so that all of these
1:03:04 Tiny little brown lines that you can see were in there for users to say, this is the trail that I use, this is the one that I dump. So here we see the biking network and the heat map, you know, saying more folks use this kind of core loop with an interior loop.
1:03:20 And then this is for hiking, or for walking, I should say. And the walking one is interesting because it's a lot less, it still uses those primary routes, but there's more interior trails utilized. And I think that that relates to, as we've been out on the field, you can see many, many, especially in the flatter areas, small little single track trails that aren't particularly engaging to a cyclist, but work just fine if you're out walking your dog and you might want to take different trails on any given day.
1:03:50 We also ask people where they park. This is important twofold. One, for figuring out where people are getting to the trails, but also layering that with trail popularity and trail access so that if improvements are to be made to trail access, we want to also make complementary improvements to parking locations or perhaps move parking or improve parking so that it draws people away from a sensitive.
1:04:14 Community or Area and gets them a more proper trailhead location if the agencies choose to do so. We also asked people, you know, what do they like? And as you can see here, I think the high level is this is a really beloved piece of land and people are really enthusiastic about it. And that came clear in the comments. We also asked people what they don't like or what their concerns are.
1:04:41 And people were really honest with that. You know, I think it's really important to underscore that users in this community of Chitmall Canyon were quite honest and forthcoming with what they liked, what they didn't like, what they think could be improved upon. And, you know, some of the comments on this slide, I think, are important to underscore, you know, that...
1:05:02 People themselves are self-identifying that the trail network is redundant or poorly planned. And these are the types that, you know, too steep, this is a good one, too steep follows the fall line, leads to trail and erosion, or at least to trail erosion. Those are what we expect to see from an informal trail network. And that also means that users themselves are recognizing that something, you know, this needs to be brought into system or it needs to be evaluated or something needs to be done as this continues to.
1:05:32 The big takeaway here is that most of the users are local, most are coming from Bishop or the surrounding communities, and trail use by season, it's pretty much used year-round by different user communities, you know, climbers in the colder months, using that to get up to the Druid Stones in the spring and the fall, people mountain biking in the summer, people walking, dips in the summer, but typically we see users.
1:06:01 Year-round. And then most users report as mountain biking. What's important to say in this survey is that you could select multiple modes. So that's why it doesn't add up to 100. But most folks are mountain biking. And then also a lot of folks are mentioning that they're hiking. So we also, these are just some word clouds of open-ended questions that we've had. And again, clearly beloved by the local community. And folks love that it's nearby, that it's got a variety, that it's not.
1:06:33 A super technically challenging or demanding trail system, more so it's an approachable community asset. You can see that here too, where people say, avoid overdevelopment, protect, don't promote, volunteer stewardship, community. There's this real sense of local ownership and local pride in what Chipmunk Canyon has become and can be. And then finally, from the survey, it's really important to...
1:06:59 You mentioned that most folks are highlighting themselves that trail conditions and maintenance is a serious need here to figure out the system, perhaps formalize it, but at the very least, there's a mutual understanding that
1:07:15 There is need for maintenance on these trails. And then second, and I think relatedly, is the need for signage and wayfinding. Some of the comments we saw were people were getting lost. It's hard to make sense of what's what. There's a lot of small, thin trails that have basically stopped being used over time because there's other trails that are more popular, but they're still there. You know, you can still see the ghost footprint of that trail, and sometimes people will take that turn and kind of get lost. So maintenance of the trails.
1:07:43 And wayfinding and signage were the most popular. Okay, so fieldwork. So first and foremost, we found a much more complex network than we expected. And then also we found that many of those trails as identified by the users themselves are redundant or, you know, a better trail is literally six feet over. And the takeaway there is that a
1:08:14 Exciting, fun, and engaging trail system could still persist even if many of the trails are removed from the system. Now, and I want to caveat too that everything that I'm showing here are ideas. You know, we're trying to just understand what this might look like, but we need to empower the agencies, you know, formal group to...
1:08:37 really drill into this, but we're trying to give a boost and some areas to focus your attention onto. But the Blue Network, nevertheless, is what we're starting to see as a system of sustainable trails. I'll get into what sustainable means in just one moment.
1:08:54 And then this is an overlay of topography. And so, as you saw on some of the comments, some of the trails follow just straight down the fall line. And those ones in particular lead to erosion and are typically not understood as sustainable. So that helps us start to triage some of the most impactful trails on the land itself, and then also look at the remaining system.
1:09:22 So what we developed was a kind of a, you know, a color-coded map of potential trail, all the trails that we observed and were out there and what we think are sustainable, those that are redundant that could probably be removed or at least less emphasized. Yellow are the trails that we think with some improvement could probably be brought into a sustainable standard, but as now are not. And then red are those that have
1:09:51 Particularly deep rutting are just straight down the fall line, things of that nature. Not to say that they must be removed, but they would require significant improvements to bring them up to a sustainable standard. Now, the standard that we're using is a U.S. Forest Service trail sustainability matrix, or metric, rather, I should say.
1:10:14 Many of the folks here today are probably familiar with the, you know, the green, blue, black, Imbus standards, kind of similar to skiing, where that's an assessment of technical challenge. And what we're assessing is sustainability by use. And so this is a U.S. Forest Service by, you know, if you're hiking.
1:10:35 If it's a mixed trail, if you're riding a mountain bike, those have different demands for turning radii, the trail width itself, the grade, drainage, passing distances, if you do have two-way travel, all that sort of stuff is split out by use by Forest Service. And this is a standard that Sierra Buttes uses as well. So that's what we're saying when we're assessing these trails and saying that they're sustainable or not.
1:11:03 takeaway is that a lot of them are in this of the unsustainable trails or what appear to be unsustainable trails we're finding in the Forest Service parcels and generally that means the hilly parts are Forest Service, the flatter parts are Bureau of Land Management and then the other big takeaway is that there are so many trails out there and some of them are really great and some of them aren't that great at all and there's a really nice trail right next to it and so
1:11:31 A big takeaway here is that we suspect that a sustainable trail system that reduces some of the duplicativeness and also just traipses all across the land can be brought into a more formalized network. It can still have the general nature that's out there now, but perhaps with not as many trails all over the land and disturbing the community.
1:11:57 The takeaway there is that we can still have fun in Shipment Canyon, even if this is brought into a formal system. So now I want to talk a little bit about next steps, some of the emerging themes. The most, you know, the highest level is that there is the need for an interagency working group. Because we're on multiple agencies land, we're also directly adjacent.
1:12:19 to the Sunland Cemetery, the Bishop Paiute Tribe. We need to establish some sort of interagency working group and start to build up a government's model and evaluate formal agreements like operations and maintenance again, you know, just really beginning to understand what that looks like from an operational perspective for these agencies who, you know, whose job it is to protect and care for the land in perpetuity.
1:12:45 And then out of that group, once that group stands up, one of the most essential first steps is to then align on what happens in phase two, what to do with the recommendations in the study and which to prioritize, which is the most important. So that's the governance model. That's like big bucket number one. Big bucket number two is trails themselves and evaluating them. So, you know, asking these questions within that body, what...
1:13:12 could or should be part of a long-term network, which might need to be returned to the land. Are there missing connections? Are there opportunities to more formalize, you know, connection into Bishop proper? Obviously, and very importantly, there's the need to continue conversations with the Bishop Paiute Tribe and make sure that the trail network doesn't come near or impact significant cultural elements that can be found on the site.
1:13:42 And then that all leads to phase two. So I've split this out into three different areas. So the first, as I mentioned, is figuring out the leadership strategy, not just that high-level group, but there's also building out partnerships with local biking, hiking, dog walking, what have you groups. You know, there's a lot of enthusiasm about this area. People really love it. So there's also the need to, you know, that's something that can be leveraged.
1:14:08 Also communications and conversations with the Bishop Paiute Tribe, maybe exploring a friends of group to do some volunteer days. Volunteer days now leads me to near-term improvements. So there are some lower hanging fruit that could probably be improved in the relative near term. That might be some wayfinding, that could be some trail cleanup, stewardship days, you know, getting rid of the trails that are immediately through or around the cemetery.
1:14:35 Using those to start to establish an esprit de corps and a little bit of movement while the larger studies need to take place. And then, as I mentioned, phase two, from our perspective, some of the priorities would be officially determining what trails are in or out. And by that, I mean, what is the system for even coming to that conclusion? And then providing that analysis and moving on from there. From there, once that network could be...
1:15:03 Formalized, and it's looking at the trailheads, kiosks, things like that, again, to funnel people towards the areas where we want them to be accessing the land to limit impacts on the land elsewhere. Much of this work presumably would require NEPA documentation, and so that's something that needs to be stood up and understood in this phase two study.
1:15:25 And then crucially, I've said it multiple times, but the operations and maintenance roles and responsibilities, it's not to be taken lightly. There are approximately 40 miles of trails that we evaluated in Chipmunk Canyon, and that's a lot to maintain and operate.
1:15:44 Really figuring that out now as this may become a formalized system is important to its long-term health and continued enjoyment by the community. And with that, I'll thank you for your time and welcome any questions you may have. Thank you, Tim. That's a really well done and comprehensive presentation. Do any of my fellow board members have questions or comments? Health member Wentworth.
1:16:14 Thank you. I think this is a really important and critical first step for the community of Bishop, for Inyo County, for public lands management, et cetera. I'm not going to chastise any of our federal management partners today, but this is a beautiful, much-beloved system that has been allowed to develop, to grow, to get community buy-in and get community participation in without it being formalized.
1:16:42 And it's going to be a tricky thing to navigate between the federal DWP, all the federal partners in the community. But again, thanks to Jobs First, with no money having to be spent by local governments, local agencies, federal partners, hopefully we're on a step and a way to move forward to get this thing formalized as a really critical community asset. We had to deal with something like this up in Mammoth and the Sherwins. It's taken a while to get...
1:17:10 Formal trails in there that volunteer stewardship groups can go out there and do the work on it because hopefully they'll now actually formally exist. A lot of work to do but a really important first step. I'm really grateful that ESCOG was able to bring in a firm with the capacity of ALTA to do this kind of work. So great first step. Thank you. Yeah. Supervisor McFarland. Yeah, thanks very much.
1:17:36 It is a great first step, and it's unique in that you have three different landowners coming together to work on it with DWP, BLM, and the Forest Service. You know, we need this same process for every community. We have a road and trail network across Eastern Sierra that basically is a legacy of resource extraction and has now become a recreational
1:18:04 And we're beginning to really see the limits of that through places becoming completely unpassable, route proliferation, and use conflicts, conflicts between different users in different places. So this will be, as it moves forward, a huge asset to the city, to the land, to people that care about this place. But the real hard work
1:18:32 is in that designation and then restoration of building a network that actually works. And it's going to be interesting to see where those next steps go, because I think they could be a model that we can employ in other places. It's what we need. And if I could, I'd just throw out, we've been through this in Mammoth. Not that Mammoth is anyplace special, but we've got lessons learned, and we want to share that with Inyo County, with Bishop, how we manage
1:19:02 Navigated all that nonsense, but sorry to interrupt. No, no, you're right. And we've not only been through it in Mammoth, we've been through it on the Inyo National. Yeah, exactly. Kind of a big brush to start. And now the fact that the BLM's engaging is really exciting. Because you only truly have sustainable and manageable recreation when you have a designated system. That's the foundation. And I hope we can get there gracefully without a lot of ruckus.
1:19:32 Before we get there. And so thanks for the work that you've done to guide this process for Ken and Elaine as well as Tim and all the community that have engaged in it. The community engagements have been impressive. So thanks. This is also a huge economic driver for Bishop. And it's my understanding, correct me if I'm wrong, but we currently can't market this as like a recreational activity for our area because it's not designated as
1:20:02 Trail Network. In the eyes of the land managers, it does not exist. Right. So we're missing out on a huge tourism boost to our area because we're not marketing it as an activity that people can do, especially if it's a dry winter up in Mammoth. They can come down and mountain bike in the winter if they're not seeing lots of snow. So I don't know how we would...
1:20:27 envelop this into the region's economic development plan, but it seems like it's a no-brainer. All that marketing for that place is happening passively with everybody that's on Strava, Instagram, everywhere else. But once you designate a place, then DMOs, other folks can truly market it, and then you get the infrastructure that actually makes it sustainable over time. You can host events and...
1:20:56 And you can maintain it. You can maintain it. I mean, that's my first introduction to this Sherman's Mammoth going National Public Lands Day. I went to the Forest Service. Hey, we want to do a stewardship event and take care of this trail. I'm sorry, you can't do that because in our eyes that does not exist. Exactly. Trash, debris. All of it. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Bathrooms. The foundation. Yeah, everything. You got to formalize it. You got to start somewhere. Right. I guess in my mind the big question is,
1:21:30 Who's the champion? Who's the lead? Who takes care of it? And, you know, I feel like in a way, ESCOG has stepped out on a limb going this far. And so, I mean, I don't have an answer to that question. I don't think there's an answer that's immediately available. I just want to remind the board and those listening that
1:22:03 As Mr. Etzel introduced, the BLM highlighted this to ESCOG when we were working on Towns to Trails as an issue, and they kind of came to ESCOG as, isn't this kind of like your scope, what you guys are going to do with an ESCOG is try and solve for some of these recreation things?
1:22:22 And we assured them that if there was an opportunity that we wanted to work with them as partners and that is in fact what we intend to try and do is solve for some of these inter-jurisdictional issues in this area of recreation. And we worked with all the land management agencies with the Forest Service DWP and BLM directly in developing the scope because they
1:22:47 We're cautious about what it would mean to work across jurisdictional boundaries and with the community. And that is part of the reason that the scope of this project sort of terminates at the existing conditions analysis.
1:23:01 The feedback that we have gotten through working with those partners in the conversations, though, is that they are very grateful that there is an entity that can bring in other funding sources to start to work on some of the initial planning on these types of projects. And over the course of that, they have been really grateful to have a partner, and they've expressed this to us. I wish they could have been here today. They've expressed that they're really grateful.
1:23:30 to have a partner that can work as a broker and a conduit to get things like community engagement to help inform that process. Moreover, going through that process, they've also articulated, we're not entirely sure what we can do with this. Obviously, they have their own funding priorities and mandates that are not always necessarily locally driven. But they at least have been able to say, OK, now we know what's out there.
1:23:58 This helps us to be able to elevate it as a priority, and then we would be interested in continuing to find pathways to move it forward. So it at least starts to put it in the queue where they can do things like allocate funding and allocate capacity. And I think there is a discussion in the future about does it, for these types of projects, this is the second type of project that
1:24:21 ESCOG has done that starts to do some of this conceptual management work. Does it from then default back to the county to working groups to be able to continue to convene those partners? Is it the kind of thing that goes on a back burner until the next funding opportunity arrives? I think those are questions that, you know, this organization should endeavor to try and solve. And there's not going to be immediate solutions, but I do think that that is one of the goals of ESCOG is to be able to provide that capacity.
1:24:51 Moving forward, generally, not specifically, in the future. Okay, thank you. Council Member Sauser, did you have anything that you would like to add? I don't know that it's appropriate here. I'm just getting my feet wet with ESCOG. But a couple of things came up during the gentleman's presentation. We talked about steep being unsustainable.
1:25:16 The problem I have with that is often we take those out, but it's an experience people are looking for. If we don't add it in, you will have new user-created trails when you close the old ones. The other is elimination of some trails to create a sustainable trail then can create so much traffic on the sustainable trail that it becomes unsustainable, just things we have to look at. The other is I know a lot of the stuff in Chipmunk was done
1:25:43 by one or two specific groups. It wasn't just individuals. And I hope we are finding a way to drag those groups into this conversation because they're the ones with the knowledge of that system. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Does anybody else have anything to add? Okay. I will say thank you again to Mr. Bevins for being here and for that presentation.
1:26:13 And we will go ahead and move on. All right. Take care. Okay. We'll go ahead and move on to item 5.5, a presentation from Shawna Doherty from Agnew Beck Consulting. And this is to also provide direction on the Eastern Sierra Collaborative and ESCOG Strategic Planning Framework. So I will once again hand it over to our director, Ms. Kamala.
1:26:42 Thank you, Chair Oral. I'll just provide a very quick overview on this item. So our last Sierra Jobs First project funded the Eastern Sierra Collaborative.
1:26:53 Initiative, a very nebulous scope that is coming into focus as we've developed it through community engagement, feedback from regional leadership, and input from other agencies, both non-profit and other governmental organizations throughout the region. The intent of this, the vision behind this is that
1:27:24 A lot of these industry sectors that we deal with, this comes out of Sierra Jobs First, the intent is to sort of support further the scope of the Sierra Jobs First initiative, which identified that there's five industry sectors that drive the economy in the Eastern Sierra. The primary three of those for the east side of the Sierra, Inyo Mono and Alpine counties, agriculture,
1:27:46 Sustainable Recreation and Natural and Working Lands are all land tenure based. And so one of the hypotheses here is does it make sense for ESCOG to work as a regional convener in those three areas in particular because there is opportunity for overlap? And we saw that coming out of the Ms. Gecker's presentation on agriculture that there is opportunities to connect things like
1:28:11 Biomass, a bottleneck for some of our wildfire resiliency projects to things like composting, which we've already fortunately seen some benefit of in some of the local community hardening projects. Or are there opportunities to do things like investment in workforce development for those wildfire resiliency projects that translates into some of the opportunities around trail maintenance on supporting sustainable recreation?
1:28:39 Where this has evolved even further is a real need and opportunity to look beyond Sierra Jobs first for ESCOG and to think about the sustainability and the succession of some of these projects under ESCOG moving forward. ESCOG has worked with a broad direction under its programs of work.
1:29:04 And we have had some light strategic planning work in the past, but this has really become an opportunity to work with our partners, to work with our member agencies, to define the real value that a regional JPA can bring in advancing work forward. So I really appreciate the capacity support that has been provided through Agnew Beck in facilitating and guiding that discussion and doing an extensive amount of outreach.
1:29:34 to get feedback on ESCOG's role and the value that ESCOG can serve in the region. And I think really the goal of the conversation today is to look forward to the September board retreat where we can have some longer and in-depth conversations to really shape the scope and the depth of the work that ESCOG will be doing in a post-Sierra Jobs First environment. Thank you. Thank you.
1:30:03 And with that, I will turn it over to Ms. Doherty. Good morning, everyone. I'm Shawna Doherty with AgNewback. I just want to check to see that you all can see this presentation. Yes. But you're not in presenter mode yet. Yeah, I'm going to start that there. Good morning. Good morning, everyone. Everyone can see? Yes. Great. Thank you. Wonderful.
1:30:33 The purpose of, I'm Shawna Doherty with Agnew Back. I'm a senior manager and I know many of you because we do a lot of work. It's our honor to be here today to give a overview of where we're at in the process and mostly get ready, get the board ready for the September 18th workshop. And so what we wanted to share with you, you got a packet last week.
1:31:02 that had one version of the work we're doing, but it's, we've been working with staff a couple times a week to continue to shape the strategic framework. So just know that what's in your packet is, today we have a slightly updated version of that. So a little bit of what I'm going to cover today is just, Elaine gave a good
1:31:30 overview of the shift of where things are starting to become clear. We want to share a high-level summary of the feedback that we've collected through the input process and then share with you a draft of the strategic framework that's starting to shape based on the feedback to date. And really what we want to do in that third part is just
1:31:56 Exposed the board to that framework to get you to start thinking about it so that when we go in to September 18th, you've seen an overview of that information and we can jump right in. So a little bit of what Elaine talked about. I thought it was important to note because we have been calling this process one thing and we're getting more clear on what it actually is.
1:32:25 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
1:32:55 So I just highlighted in yellow really quickly what it used to be called. I think an interesting part about the initial name being called a regional collaboration planning process is that it became very clear in the interview process that really people want, the partners are very focused on implementation.
1:33:21 And not just collaboration for the sake of collaboration. And so we've really turned this effort that we're doing into a strategic plan and an action plan for ESCOG. A little bit of an overview. So we've been doing the input and input includes interviews, looking at regional plans, the feedback from the summit. We have a steering committee and then research.
1:33:56 All that is coming in a funnel to inform the conversation around what does it mean for ESCOG, what is the information telling us, and what do we as the leaders of the organization want to put in place to set ESCOG up to respond to both the challenges and these opportunities. And then the plan is that it will come back to the board in October and November.
1:34:25 for a final review. So a real quick summary of the input. We did 17 interviews. We looked at 10 plans. We've looked at, we looked, originally we did the research based on regional collaborations.
1:34:43 And we switched to doing our research on more COG-specific, especially contexts that are similar to the Eastern Sierra, and we'll bring that information to you at the September 18th meeting and then the summit. Questions we were really asking in the feedback is, how is collaboration working? What's not working? What are the benefits?
1:35:06 For your organization and moving your mission forward. And then we had a second set of questions based on ESCOG specifically. And what do they see as things that ESCOG is doing really well? What are the challenges? And then what are the opportunities for ESCOG over the next three to five years? These are the organizations that we interviewed. As you can see, it's a mix of public agencies, nonprofits.
1:35:36 Tribes, committees, just so you understand who's behind these opinions, we were able to get a great sampling. Many of these organizations did have, I would say it's a range from very little knowledge of ESCOG to partnering very directly on projects with ESCOG.
1:36:02 So it gave us a good sampling of perceptions. So we asked one of the questions, where is collaboration working really, really well in the region? And this is just a list of where people pointed. So clearly this shows that there is a strong understanding of collaboration. What was interesting is that word collaboration didn't resonate.
1:36:31 Consistently across the interviews, really the word that was more used was partnership. Really, again, these are all, if you notice, these are all about getting stuff done and less about just the concept of collaboration. What makes these effective? Share nothing surprising to you here, but making sure that
1:37:00 Everyone that is meeting, it's around a shared goal, and we have agreement on how we get there. That we have some kind of dedicated leadership or organization that's kind of hosting the partnership. The capacity, some of these, when there's staff who can coordinate the meetings and the summary notes, and that there's funding to do things over a long period of time, that was mentioned.
1:37:30 As a key outcome. Authentic relationships. So people liking each other and liking to work together. Maybe they knew each other before. That was brought up many times. And then this one, this last one is very similar to the first one. It's just that at the end of the day, we got together. And because we worked together, I was able to accomplish more things. I was able to build more trail miles. I was able to do more bathrooms at a
1:37:58 at a recreation area, and I can clearly point to more was done in a group versus me alone. Challenges at a regional level, it's challenging because there is a lot of different opinions about what regionalism means. You know, there's tension when we're working on regional collaborations between
1:38:25 In concept, there's a lot of support for region, and when it gets to implementation, it was noted that there's a lot of going back to local needs and local mindset. Public agencies mention that they have mandates and things they have to do.
1:38:47 And so when they're asked to join a collaborative meeting, they are always thinking about how does it align with what their mandates are and can they really allow the time to go to that meeting if it doesn't directly relate to that. Also just challenged with their own capacity issues and so not always being able to go to additional meetings like staffing and funding. That's similar to the next one.
1:39:14 And then just having long term, you know, there's often not funding for the within grant structures for the work of collaboration. And based on this morning's conversations and the projects, clearly how work gets done in the area is a certain level of partners meeting to move forward.
1:39:40 Projects, and yet the grants are not allowing for that type of work in the funding structure. So we move into ESCOG, talking about what's going really well. So ESCOG has a reputation of clearly being in service to the region and being the voice for the region.
1:40:05 There was a spectrum of opinions and perceptions on how well ESCOG was doing that and also clarity around, different degrees of clarity around understanding of ESCOG's work and mission and direction and depending on, mostly people knew ESCOG really well if they were working directly.
1:40:34 on a project, but if they didn't, they had a very vague sense, and that was pretty common. Seen as a convener, really viewed as neutral and able to bring, there were a couple of people that said, you know, ESCOG has this ability to really bring the right people to the table, and you're seen as that neutral convener between user groups and the community and public agencies, and that's really valued.
1:41:03 So with the public agencies that I was able to speak with, really valued what I just mentioned earlier, taking on the community and the user side and being that neutral convener for their needs. Recognized as being successful in areas of securing and dispersing public funds,
1:41:33 And so convening, funding, and then the reputation as being neutral really were the key strengths. Some brought up that ESCOG has been able to help them with grant administration and project incubation, and that's been incredibly helpful for them. And then there's just the structure of the JPA.
1:41:59 was recognized as unique and different in the region. Some challenges, over and over I heard that ESCOG is doing amazing work and concern that there's capacity to really show up and do what the region is asking you to do. So I'm well aware that you have basically one staff person and part-time staff.
1:42:27 Moving large amounts of work forward. The work is complex, especially when it comes to administrative and grant management and incubation and these, we heard it this morning regarding Sierra Jobs First and just the back-end work required to accept public money and disperse it and manage it and track it is a big lift.
1:42:55 And there's going to hopefully be a growing need for that and concern that ESCOG doesn't have the capacity at this point to do that work. Unclear about the value proposition. So people know about one-off, you know, this project or chipmunk or the ag study or they know about this, but like collectively, what is the clear articulation of
1:43:24 The value of having a JPA in our region, other than by naming the projects. And that's from even internally from the board articulating, you know, it's challenging for me to always articulate who ESCOG is and what value ESCOGs bring to the region if I don't defer to one-off projects. I talked about the capacity. Another topic was, you know, brought up.
1:43:53 That it seems like ESCOG is very opportunistic. So grants or opportunity, you know, grant comes in and then ESCOG is doing that. So grant comes in and then ESCOG is doing broadband or a grant comes in and that's this broad, ESCOG is doing this thing. And the challenge being sort of what is the, you know, what is the direction and the focus of ESCOG and how do these opportunities fit into that? And that plays to the unclear role.
1:44:24 So opportunity also was brought up that if ESCOG is truly a regional government entity, where are the public agencies and where are the tribes? And looking at other COGs, there are, many of them have tribal representation as another government entity, and that got brought up several times. You know, growing the capacity and the funding to
1:44:53 Do more for the region and then opportunity to really strengthen communications and to clearly demonstrate the value of the role ESCOG is playing in the area. And I mentioned this earlier, but another opportunity is you have an incredible model with the Wildfire Alliance and I'll get into this in a little bit, but leveraging the success of that process, which is
1:45:28 You know, getting a formal structure together of a diverse set of stakeholders, identifying projects, getting, being, positioning the region for competitive Prop 4 funding, and then having ESCOG play a role of being able to help accept those dollars if it's successful, and then disperse the funding out for project implementation.
1:45:55 It's just an incredible opportunity for ESCOG to tell that story and then to replicate it in other areas and then start to bring together the cross-pollinization between the different sectors. I'm going to go now into the feedback we got from the summits. I think many of you were there. We had a session at the end of day two.
1:46:22 All of the conversation, a lot of the conversations in the panels were on the topics of regional coordination and industry sector crossover in recreation, wildfire, ag and economic development. So it was right spot on for the topics that we are looking at in the strategic plan. This is, again, one of those pieces of feedback that we can look at as we build out a vision and a
1:46:51 And a mission for ESCOG on September 18th. And this is feedback on a regional vision that came out of the summit. So this is just, again, something that we'll reference when we build out ours. Feedback, we ask for feedback. What are the needs and priorities in the four core areas of wildfire, rec, ag, and economic development? Again, this is going to be really helpful feedback.
1:47:21 When we meet on the 18th is just to look at sort of what are the emerging needs and priorities that are coming out of community conversations? And how can ESCOG step up? What is ESCOG already doing to step up? But how can ESCOG be more clear in articulating how they're showing up and what their role is in this work? Again, this is economic development, workforce, coordination, infrastructure, and then funding.
1:47:57 You'll see this over and over again. You know, help with project implementation, help with coordination and capacity, infrastructure, funding. This is agriculture. And again, this is, Lindsay was part of this conversation and it was interesting just to see additional comments that hopefully she can fold into her work. So we looked at 10 plans.
1:48:30 And the way I really look at plans, think about the two plans that were shared today. Lindsay talked about 70 stakeholders providing feedback to develop the ag plan. Every single one of these plans had some kind of input process and committee that took the feedback and turned it into a set of priorities. So we really want to make sure as ESCOG is looking at
1:48:59 developing a strategic plan that we're really looking at the community feedback and the priorities that have been set already because they're incredibly valuable and we want to make sure that we're folding in that set of opinions and those priorities into how we're thinking about moving work forward to ensure that we're bringing those priorities forward in our work.
1:49:28 So what we did, and we can, this is a resource, we have a huge spreadsheet now that has pulled out all the goals and the strategies based on the four core areas, and we can slice and dice that information however we decide to use it moving forward for ESCOG. But initially what we did is looked at the four plans.
1:49:53 Excuse me, looked at the 10 plans in the lens of the four core areas and said, you know, how many goals are showing up in these four core areas that we want to kind of dig down in and reference and maybe pull into our work so that as ESCOG's moving forward, it's also moving forward goals for partners. So lots of goals.
1:50:17 Throughout the 10 plans around sustainable rec and tourism, 11 around destination stewardship and infrastructure. One thing that was really interesting is we had to do a lot of translation. What we notice across the 10 plans is you're kind of saying the same thing as a region, but you're all slightly using different words.
1:50:42 So we did some interpretation of lumping things together to assume that it was generally the same thing. Goals, some goals, not very much about working lands and ag because this is sort of an emerging conversation. So it hasn't quite made it into a lot of the plans yet. Lots around economic development and then wildfire mitigation.
1:51:11 Again, this is a resource for us to pull on moving forward. I'm just going to pause because now I'm going to go into the strategic framework that we built based on this feedback. And I know I'm going through a lot very quickly. Are there any questions up to this point or comments? Okay. Okay, Shauna, it looks like we're good to continue.
1:51:39 All right, so based on wrestling with all that feedback and then information, we're working on building a strategic plan framework for us to work on and discuss. Clearly, based on this morning's listening and this morning's conversation, all of the conversations are so relevant to this work. So we were creating a roadmap 2030, and in that roadmap, the components will be a three-year strategic plan.
1:52:06 A detailed one-year work plan of how we're going to implement those goals in the strategic plan. And then a company that will be, you know, the details of like, okay, that's all great, but we need to understand like, what is the budget to get that work done for ESCOG and a staffing plan to do that. Knowing that nothing, aware that.
1:52:33 We have to be within the framework and the constraints of the funding. And so we want to couple all these products together so that when it gets time for the board to approve and do resolutions for work programs, that you have that understanding of what's being asked. The strategic plan structure, very similar to strategic plans that you've all worked on before.
1:53:02 At the center is always the vision and the mission, the core values, the foundational agreements that drives our decisions around the work we're going to take on. We added in, because of the feedback that we got, that in the strategic plan we would really include clarity around what the roles are of ESCOG, service areas, and a value proposition.
1:53:27 Just so that the final document, and hopefully it gets posted on your website, could be something that partners and community could pull and get a real sense. It also helps to drive communications, and then you start to build more consistent clarity around your role. And then four programs of work, and then the goals around those programs.
1:53:50 So we will get into this on September 18th. There's several missions floating around, one on the website, one in your SEDS. There isn't a vision statement, so know that this is the work that we will be doing on the 18th. Foundational agreements also do not exist, but it will be really important for the board to come to some agreement on this because it really, really helps the staff have direction.
1:54:19 around what is the foundational belief system of ESCOG. It's also helpful when you have transition of board members and staff. They pick up this document and they're like, I don't understand, what is this ESCOG? What is the JPA? What are they doing? I see that they're doing a project in Chipmunk, but I don't quite understand the...
1:54:45 Like the why behind it, and they can go, you can all go back to these, and it drives the direction of the organization. So these are draft. Value proposition, again, you know, what is a clear statement that we can put out there of why it's valuable to work as a region? Role.
1:55:09 Again, we'll review this at the workshop, but just starting to pull out based on the work that you do, looking at other COGS, and then also from the interviews, just what are the words, what's that vocabulary that we can start using when Elaine's talking about incubating the BRC or bringing interest holders together or, you know, it's almost like a list of services that partners can understand more clearly what
1:55:39 What's ESCOG does? And what's ESCOG's role in the Wildfire Alliance? And just getting some more clarity. If you're doing grant management, that's different than convening. And when Elaine is going to Sacramento and advocating for dollars for a region, that's a different thing. And so what are the words we used for all that? What's starting to emerge, and you saw it today,
1:56:09 is ESCOG, and maybe it's ESCOG, maybe it's just the way things are done in the region, but just starting to codify this model that we're seeing used over and over and over again that really is the key to implementation and getting a common vocabulary in the region of how to move work forward and, you know, why are we meeting? Why are we always having all these meetings?
1:56:37 And sometimes ESCOG comes in and does one piece and sometimes the whole thing, ideally you're doing the whole thing where there's an opportunity, whether it's funding or the BLM comes to you and says, you know, this is a hotspot of overuse and we're really trying to figure out a solution to this. Can you help us? Bringing together interest holders, providing some kind of technical service.
1:57:03 Whether it's a planning or a study and some kind of prioritization, funding, and then the implementation. But always in the center of it is stewarding this work, even after implementation for measuring and ensuring that the goals are continuing moving forward is this idea of having an ongoing working group. And that's just really...
1:57:28 an important cornerstone of the strategic plan because you're going to see this model showing up over and over and over again in each of the work areas. So I'm going to go over the four proposed programs of work and then the goals in each of those areas. These are the four program areas of work in the strategic plan. So all that earlier stuff I talked about with the vision, the mission and the core values and
1:57:57 The value proposition would be the center, the nucleus, and driving the work out in these four core areas. And I'll get into each of these. But supporting healthy landscapes because of our foundational belief that healthy landscapes and strong recreation equal a strong economy, focusing on regional strengthening of economies and communities.
1:58:27 Growing Regional Capacity and ESCOG supporting that and then for increasing ESCOG's capacity to serve the region. So the rationale for why this work is important and why it fits under ESCOG is that this continues ESCOG's current program area of work so it's not new.
1:58:55 You have a stable rec and ecosystem management work program. It's funded by Sierra Jobs First. So, and there's been a lot of test cases of good work that's happened through that funding and that work program. So the proposal moving forward is to include this continuation of this work in a future strategic plan.
1:59:20 The belief that recreation well-planned and coordinated is good for the land, communities and economy. Communities and landscapes resilient to catastrophic wildfire are economically stable and there was a lot of strong partner support for ESCOG to continue working in this area. The two goals in this area are to implement regional priority sustainability.
1:59:45 Sustainable Rec projects and to implement regional priority wildfire resilience projects. Goal Area 1, this is the same format that you'll see across that I'm going to share with you. So the goal here is to implement, focus on implementation of, oops, sorry, support implementation of regional sustainable recreation priority projects over the next three years. This box just shows what you're already doing.
2:00:14 It's usually very helpful for the board to understand that, wow, we already are doing this, but what we're talking about, and you notice with all of these things, these are a lot of these are like study, plan, study, and the focus in the next three years would be on implementation. And if you think back to that model I showed earlier, implementation means taking it around the process of getting a group of people together,
2:00:44 Figuring out what the project priorities are, what is the data, what are the studies, what's needed, what's the funding, and applying for the funding, and then implementation. So you'll see that across each of these goal areas. So again, this is another area that is already going very well and it's very strong, so it's not a huge lift for ESCOG because it's
2:01:13 already in the works, but we want to make sure that this is being folded into the strategic plan with clarity around what ESCOG's role would be. Okay, program area of work two is strengthen economies and communities. Again, this continues ESCOG's current program area of work and the proposal would be to renew it because I think it expires. I'm not sure if I think it expires.
2:01:45 The other thing that's underway is that ESCOG is in the process of applying for EDD designation, which would create a reliable funding source of about 70K for ESCOG to be a provider of that service, which is very helpful. It also builds regional capacity that is limited in the Eastern Sierra and positions
2:02:13 The region for the implementation of a SED. So you have a lot in favor in this area and a need to create some kind of formal entity to move this forward. So four goals, and I'll just go through them one by one. So goal one is to build a coordinated regional economic development strategy, and that includes defining what an economic strategy means.
2:02:42 And building capacity to sustain and implement the work. Again, like I mentioned, there's already a lot going on in this month, but this would be really, really focusing on getting that ED designation so you would have funding to support this work. And then creating a formal economic development working roof to implement the SEDS and other economic development strategies. Goal two is
2:03:11 Again, this is an area that you're already working in. The difference is, you know, if you go to the ESCOG website right now, you'll just see that ESCOG works in broadband. But there's no link to why does ESCOG work in broadband. We can make our own assumptions about communication infrastructure. But what we want to do with this plan is take all of the constellations of work that ESCOG is doing and put it into an architecture.
2:03:39 And clearly bundle up the areas of work so that internally you understand why you're doing certain things and also how they all work to propel implementation forward. And so this is broadband, but now the why is in there that it brings economic benefits and you do have funding in this area as well. So just the recommendation would be to move this forward in the strategic plan.
2:04:09 This is a new area, and it came out of conversations, very much out of the conversations. It also came out of the review of the plans. As I briefly showed you, there were a lot of goals in the 10 plans around regional destination and tourism infrastructure goals. And so this is an example of us.
2:04:36 folding in the conversations and the feedback we heard of partners wanting ESCOG to step into this role and need for a regional response to this. It could potentially fall under an existing work plan area, but we'll determine that later. So these are just a list of some of the actions that we'll talk about on the 18th.
2:05:02 Again, whether ESCOG wants to take this on or not or support another entity doing this is the conversation, but these are just a short list of some of the things that were recommended and the needs in the region. The final goal in the economic and strengthening the economies and community is this is where we brought in
2:05:29 Some of Lindsay's recommendations this morning. And so really seeing the food system and agro-tourism priorities coming out of the ag plan as an economic development strategy. And so it's nested in here. And the same model that you'll see over and again is, you know, working to set up a group that would
2:05:54 move the actions forward in the ag plan to support food systems and agriculture entrepreneurs. Obviously, this would require securing funding for this work. I did hear this morning, you know, does that best fit under ESCOG or RCD? And so, you know, having a conversation around whether ESCOG is the lead on that or in a support role. Growing
2:06:26 So we know that many of the services that ESCOG provides enable capacity in the region to move projects forward, expand capacity of partners with limited capacity, incubate new things. So knowing in lower population rural areas, having an organization that helps with capacity building services like grant administration
2:06:56 And bringing partners together to share resources is a valuable role for ESCOG. Goal one is around, again, the nuance here is about ESCOG not taking on workforce, but supporting workforce development that are already happening.
2:07:31 And then advocating for the needs that come out of the working groups for rec, wildfire resiliency, working lands and agriculture and economic development. So if there's four working groups and they identify workforce needs in their areas, that those would roll up to a lane and a lane could coordinate and take that information to existing workforce.
2:08:00 Coalition meetings to draw attention to building the capacity of workforce and then bringing that information back to the working groups. Two would be helping build the capacity for services and administrative needs of the implementation or project needs in the four core areas.
2:08:32 Again, that is already happening with the Pace and Scale Accelerator Initiative and the BRC. So again, we're going to get into this when we talk about building ESCOG's capacity, but sometimes priority projects come out of a planning process and yet there's not the capacity to move those forward or there's a need for a technical study to
2:09:02 be able to move a project forward and having ESCOG be able to step in and provide that boost is the goal here. Convening, again, this being seeing convening as a way to whether, you know, we heard this in the feedback process for Sierra Jobs First, as well as feedback for this, that
2:09:32 The value of meeting if it's not about moving a project forward is that you have an opportunity to build relationships and meet people and sometimes that results in an exchange of a resource or a connection or an opportunity that you didn't know about before and so in that it is seen as a capacity building activity and that ESCOG would still stay in the role of
2:09:57 convenings like the summit and as needs emerge being able to step in and bring partners together. So the last one, and this is about making sure that as we build a strategic plan that we're also making an area of work, a program of work that is really focused on slowly over the next three years.
2:10:23 Building the capacity of ESCOG to really step up in the way that the region's asking them to. And making sure that ESCOG capacity matches the opportunities that are coming our way. So positioning ESCOG to serve the region with more capacity. And the why behind that is just there really is an opportunity to unlock significant funding.
2:10:52 If there was more staffing and capacity to meet with the funders and put partners together and put projects together and do the grant writing and all of the things it takes to move these big asks forward. So four goals in this area. So again, just build capacity.
2:11:19 Formalizing, so ESCOG's strength is that it's very nimble and it's very responsive to needs that emerge, but really in the next three years, starting to formalize what it means to show up and respond to an opportunity with a formal structure around working groups, potentially growing the membership, which has the benefit of, A, bringing more voices.
2:11:47 to leadership, but also opens up doors for other grant opportunities if you have different members on your board. And then being really clear about if you're being asked, for instance, by the BLM to work on a particular project, you know, is there
2:12:11 a process for determining the cost of that and the services that ESCOG would provide to support a project. Money, just increasing ESCOG's ability to attract and grow, so pursuing more grants, exploring potentially a new funding source, looking at ways to structure maybe some fee-for-service.
2:12:42 And ways to grow the budget over time. So ESCOG is in some perceptions recognized as a voice and an advocate for regional resources. And we want to make sure that at the end of three years, and we interview people again, that ESCOG is well known for this. And that you have a clear direction on what is the legislative platform that you're
2:13:13 You're directing staff to advocate for, excuse me, and you're building ESCOG's capacity to really be the regional conduit of information and resources and also WINS. So as there are funds secured through the process of collaboration, we want to make sure that ESCOG has the capacity on the communication side to be
2:13:44 telling the story of how collaboration and working as a region unlocks funding and implements projects more effectively. So internally, just if ESCOG is going to work to provide capacity in the region, looking internally at the systems, again, you know, what
2:14:14 What is needed from a staffing perspective to do effective grant administration and the invoicing and understand what are the services that partners really need and building an internal system and staffing plan based on those needs. And the final slide is, so what's next? We're preparing with staff for the September 18th workshop.
2:14:45 We're meeting with the steering committee to go over this structure on the 9th. And we're going to continue to build out the framework to bring to you on the 18th for your feedback. We will be sending pre-reading materials that have a lot more detail, a summary report of feedback that's much more detailed than these slides, a summary of the research of other COGS.
2:15:14 And we really ask that the participants, I think it's the board and the administrators, read that information so that we can jump right in because we have three hours and we look forward to having as many ideas in the room as possible. So the one question I have for all you is just what information or what do you need to help prepare for the workshop?
2:15:42 Okay. Thank you, Shauna. Before we dive into that, I want to make sure that nobody has a hard stop at 11 o'clock. The estimating was canceled, so we don't have to vacate the premises, but I want to make sure that the board can remain because we do need to maintain a quorum. Someone could maybe adjust the air conditioning. Okay. Would you like my jacket?
2:16:15 Okay. I think we can handle that. Okay. All right. Let's dive into it. Questions? Council Member? Sorry to beat this. Okay. Questions. So who is on the ESCOG Steering Committee for this effort? Elaine, who is on the Steering Committee for this effort? I will give you that last question. I'm sorry. I'd like to address this to staff if I could. Yeah. Who is on the Steering Committee for this?
2:16:47 As a subcommittee or the broader steering committee? Okay. There is both. Okay. For the subcommittee, it is yourself, Councilman Wentworth. It is Supervisor McFarland, Supervisor Oral, and Councilmember Sports. And the broader subcommittee also includes some partners that helps establish some parameters at the beginning of the project. We had another meeting, I believe, building into the co-lab.
2:17:14 Includes agency partners. I get that. Okay, so I think for the ESCOG steering committee, an observation of this is we, if this comes in front of a three-hour meeting in September, it will fail. It's going to fail. We need to do some work, I think, as a steering committee to provide some focus to this, to identify what points of decision might look like, you know, things that we actually want to invest in. In my mind, this representation is the entire region.
2:17:44 ESCOG is not the entire region. ESCOG's role in this, I think we could do some good work to focus this thing in so we can prepare for a three-hour session at a meeting that's going to be effective and is going to be successful. If we bring all this to a three-hour meeting, I'm pretty confident that it will not succeed within a three-hour time frame. There's no way that this is going to work. Right. This is a lot. Okay. Supervisor McFarland.
2:18:13 Yeah, I would agree. I think that we can take, there's been a lot of good work to distill information from a lot of different partners and communities into what we just saw now. But I do think that it needs another look before we bring it as a whole group. There were some things missing. There were some things that I think are redundant. There are things that we could talk easily for three hours on. And I'm just wondering how we get there in the compressed timeline.
2:18:43 that we have. Okay. Supervisor Griffiths? It's hard to know what point to comment on because there were 175 points in there. Okay. Councilmember Schwartz, did anything stand out to you that you'd like to address? At the strategic planning meeting, like, do we want right now to define, like, what we want to get out of it so then we can give staff some direction on, like, what to hone in on?
2:19:20 Jonna? Yeah, two points. I guess my question back to you is, I heard that this may not be what you will be giving feedback on. So what I'm hearing is, can we shift the process where it goes? Board update today.
2:19:52 Steering Committee, September 9th. ESCOG Committee will take all of that and then refine through the ESCOG lens. And then we have, based on that, we would have a board meeting. Because of the extension, the assumed extension of our contract to December, we're not
2:20:20 set in cement to do a workshop in September. So I guess my question, based on this feedback, it's up to you to decide, obviously, but I just want to put out there that we could move the workshop to October, giving the committee more time to digest and take this information to set us up for a more effective conversation at a three-hour workshop.
2:20:54 Karen, to your point, at some point, we have to be able to narrow this down and identify, like, scope of work for the ESCOG is doing based on our already approved areas that we're working in. And we have to look at the staff capacity that we have. That's got to be factored into this as well. And I think we may need to be anticipating asks back to our full boards.
2:21:23 That may be for expanded scope or diminished scope. It may be for more money, less money. That's the thing to think about at the end of this. Or we say, hey, we're good just the way we are. We don't have to do anything. But I think that is going to be a next step coming at it. That's going to be something like along those lines. So that's what would come out of that. On behalf of all our boards, we met, we came up with this thing. We've got some asks. We've got some direct future direction we want to share with our full boards.
2:21:54 Is there anyone who would like to see the timeline extended into October for this? Or would we like to stay on schedule? I think the concern is that we may not get that choice. And so it seems like this 18th date, which we've mostly all agreed to already, the 9th date is still up in the air. I don't know if...
2:22:23 The 9th is a little tricky. I don't know if I've received a meeting invite for that steering committee, so it's not on my calendar. I have not. I've got a commitment. But we can forget that. Yeah, but I think my point was that I think we should keep the, in some way, keep the 18th. Sure. But how are we going to be presented with the information that's been gleaned from all the work that's been done in a way that makes it possible for a positive outcome at the end of?
2:22:52 That meeting. I mean, one of the things, just for me, that was positive reading the packet before today was the evolution of AgNubex deliverables into a staffing and a budget plan. Because I think, you know, that's the most critical thing we need because otherwise we're doing what a lot of strategic planning does, which it gives you a cookbook without a kitchen or a cook.
2:23:16 And those are the two pieces that we really need. We need to be respectful and invest in the capacity of ESCOG to actually do these things and realistic about how much that's going to cost or what it's going to take from partner agencies to do. Just for some clarification, both from staff and Shauna, we've referred to information in packets. Could you be really clear about?
2:23:45 What has been sent to board members outside of the slide presentation today? I don't know that there's been an answer. Okay. So when we're talking about a packet, information is what we are presented with today. Yes. Okay. I'm sorry. No, I'm talking about prior to September 18th, we would send information that would expand on the slide deck.
2:24:17 Okay. Or additional background. Okay. And the other thing we could do based on the committee direction is moving all of the goals into a single spreadsheet that would show the goals and then what is already happening and then propose new so you could just see what's very clearly. So that's the kind of thing. It's just like...
2:24:46 I get this is a lot of information. Can you just give me one page so I can see it all at one page? But again... If I could, I just want to emphasize, Paul, what you said, because we have another very important agenda item coming up on the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance. And I think that's what I've been thinking about in preparation for today is your point about administrative capacity and staff capacity and what are our priorities of things that we have funded. And I think that that's a key thing with all the stuff that's in the presentation.
2:25:20 Do we have admin capacity? If we're going to get a multi-million dollar grant out of the state, which that's an agenda, can we pull that off? And can we pull off the basic things that we're doing and really let's get ourselves focused on some of these things? Well, and I think part of what I gleaned from today's presentation is establishing what is...
2:25:42 ESCOG's role in the region. What is our purpose? And where do we want it to go? And I don't think we can answer any of those questions no matter. And I love the spreadsheet idea, Shauna. I think it would be a really great visualization for us. But at the same time, if we don't have that purpose, that goal, that direction established by this body,
2:26:07 I think that is where we have to start, whether that's in the steering committee or in our strategic plan or both. And I think that is something we could probably do within the context of a three-hour meeting. I mean, again, we can identify these fundamental foundational things. I think we can get that kind of stuff done. I think that for me, without that, that's a really huge missing piece. I agree mostly with the caveat.
2:26:39 He's allowed to disagree with me. Yeah. So I think Eastern Sierra Council of Governments is not something where you're going to be able to nail down all of those things perfectly into the future. And even the staffing model is going to be an iterative process, too. So if we are doing wildfire mitigation...
2:27:02 And we have a total of, you know, a million dollars over four years of resources. That looks very different than if we have nine million dollars over two and a half years. Yep. And like, how do you figure that out? And I think that we obviously want to have our core areas of service defined, but then ESCOG is also the regional government body that is the vessel that if an opportunity arises,
2:27:32 That we want it to be able to accept that, and we don't know what that's going to be because we don't have a crystal ball. So I think we need to develop a system that is flexible enough to be adjustable, focusing on sustainability, and I don't know that I have the expertise to be able to decide that. I think that's area managers and staff and consultants.
2:28:02 But I want to be wary of the trap of being like, okay, we have to know exactly what we're going to be doing in each way. I just think, I don't know if we have to know exactly, but I think we need a general focus and direction so we're not going in a hundred different ways and we're not overextending the capacity. But within that, I agree with the flexibility as opportunities come along and that's why this is a regional body.
2:28:30 To meet those regional needs that we as individual agencies can only do on a much smaller scope. And it allows that interaction. That point, I think that nimbleness, as nimble as a public agency can be, we understand the constraints of that. But I think really looking at the administrative model, because right now ESCOG is pretty attenuated. It's got...
2:28:55 Hey, we need cash flow out of Mono County. Hey, we need something out of Inyo County. We get staff hired. I think that that's something that in order to do any of these things in the way that you're talking about, I would just offer that that could be a good thing to be focusing in on. How do we really make sure that the way that we're setting it up with the vision thing that you're talking about, that's critical. That can be understood. And then start
2:29:19 Maybe looking at what the admin piece of this is going to look like so we kind of know what our flexibility, what our capacity can be or cannot be and that will help inform what we can take and what we have to say no to. Well and it also informs how we present ourselves to the public and the public's understanding of this body and their engagement with the work that we do. Well not only the public but our boards. Our boards. And I think that is a huge area of misunderstanding with my board.
2:29:49 is being able to just distill ESCOG in a way that they can understand and digest and be like, oh yeah, that makes sense. Because right now we have so many priorities, I feel like they think nothing's a priority and it becomes confusing. And I think they think at least we're a grant chasing body versus like a strategic body. And, you know, I think it's okay to be both, but we should outline that we are both, you know, like we don't want some amazing opportunity to come up.
2:30:17 and be like, no, no, that's not in our strategic plan. You know, we should still be nimble. However, I feel like there's confusion over what benefit does Bishop receive out of the ESCOG. And, yeah, so to piggyback on that, go all the way back to the beginning of Shauna's presentation. She talked about her interviews with community partners and some of the...
2:30:43 Weaknesses, I think it's that of ESCOG, and it is the perception of some of the people on our boards and some of our community partners. And part of it is parochialism of people saying, am I getting exactly my fair share or is somebody else getting more? But part of it is, you know, seeing the regional benefit.
2:31:11 And how that reflects back home. And, you know, I think part of our planning process should be how do we institutionalize that communication. Yes. And, you know, to something that's already been said, too, but just to when we think about a staffing model, I don't see a prescribed model more. We need to define a solid core, like what's needed in order to be
2:31:40 Effectively opportunistic. It was interesting in some of that feedback that that was seen as a weakness when it's actually quite the strength because you can take advantage of emerging funding opportunities and address emerging issues whereas if you have different areas how do we build ESCOG so that it can sustain more projects like the Wildfire Defense Grant without it being an existential
2:32:09 Exactly. So that time something comes up. That's that admin thing I'm kind of looking at. We need to really lock in and be able to articulate that to our partners. Look, if nothing else is happening, we're this. If things come in, we can scale to this and figure out how to represent that. And I think to broadly define those four work focus areas that we came up with, area goals for those.
2:32:32 Because I think that's going to help us communicate what ESCOG does well. I mean, I think people respond really well to broad descriptions and one concrete example. And we can find those for each of those four and do a better job of articulating those when they come forward. Really quickly, I want to make sure that we're giving Councilmember Souser an opportunity to participate in the conversation. Bill, can you hear me?
2:33:12 Sorry, I turned it on. Can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you. Okay. Yeah, I am still here, awake, and I have no comment at this point, although it sounds to me like for the planning we're doing that that 18th of September may be pushing our abilities a bit much. Okay. How does the subcommittee think? I think to Paul's, you know, recommendation, we got...
2:33:48 We have a known schedule that we need to hit, and I think we get the subcommittee together with the things we've heard today and just take it right down. Say, look, we've got to come out of this with something that's what we've heard here on the dais. Okay, Shauna, is that enough direction, I guess, or do you need clarification around anything? Yeah, I'm just going to need, and I'll just make sure staff, I'm going to need direction on
2:34:18 Preparing for the 18th based on what comes out of the subcommittee. Okay. So. One more comment. If I may, I think that the subcommittee is the one when they start their work to determine whether or not the 18th is reasonable or not and then change that as that subcommittee sees fit. Yeah, the 18th is going to be really difficult to change. So I think that we.
2:34:49 As we've said, getting the subcommittee together as soon as possible, targeting the 9th, that's still a pretty tight timeline, especially for you to take work out of the subcommittee and prepare it for the 18th. Shauna, that's a tight timeline for you as well. Yeah. Are you referring to the subcommittee as the steering committee?
2:35:15 Or is this subcommittee a subcommittee of the ESCOG Board of only board members? It is a subcommittee of the ESCOG Board of only board members. Okay, it's a different body. So it's a different body. Yeah. Okay. So steering committee, sorry. Yeah, I just think we'd be hard-pressed to pull that full steering committee together on the night. We can try and get as many people as we can there, but I think it's really important that I think that ESCOG subcommittee weigh in on this at some point, especially before we get to the meeting.
2:35:45 I think ESCOG, mindful of the regional managers. I mean, that's our immediate audience. Us, our fellow board members, regional managers, staff, bring this thing together and to see if we can pull off. Well, I guess the first step then would be to see how much of the steering committee we can pull together and whether or not it ends up being steering committee or subcommittee. I mean, honestly, that's what I see happening. Okay, we can work towards that.
2:36:15 Okay. Thank you. Okay. So we move forward. Thank you so much, Shawna. Thank you. For that. Okay. Okay. Let's go ahead and move on to item 5.6, a presentation on Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance and the application process for the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Landscape Grant Program. Before Ms. Feiler gives her presentation, I just want to check with the board knowing that we've gone over time.
2:36:47 I can provide a very short summary update for this if there's any anxiety. Otherwise, Ms. Fowler can provide the full presentation. I'm ready to go the distance. Yeah, I say we go through this. This is important. I think most of us would have been staying for the ESTA meeting anyway. I'm out at 12.15. I do have a hard out. Okay. Hard out. I have an appointment, but I can switch it at 11.45. I think we'll be okay. Great. Good morning.
2:37:23 Kristen Feiler, I'm the ESCOG Wildfire Coordinator. In your packet, we have a slightly different version. I'm just going to run you really quickly through the prioritization framework that can be used across funding streams, not the specific Sierra Nevada Conservancy funding opportunity at the moment. So just to reorient you to the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, it is the regional collaborative that is comprised of Alpine.
2:37:52 Inyo and Mono Counties here on the map. It's that big blue section on the right. The Alliance moves its work products forward through committees and working groups and the projects committee has been really hard at work developing a project dashboard with a huge list of projects, project list entry form and an associated map and that is all up on the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance website. We have about
2:38:22 $360 million worth of projects in that list that goes literally across the whole region. It's pretty impressive. And so you might be asking, how are we going to prioritize any of that for any sort of funding opportunities? So the projects committee has been establishing a new framework that builds off the original kind of ranking system that used to exist for the alliance that creates a little bit
2:38:50 More robust, diverse, equitable way to distribute money across the region. And so through that we have two primary processes. The first is a numerical, just regional assessment, readiness assessment and values alignment process. And then the second phase is discussion-based.
2:39:15 qualitative, contextual putting together of portfolios for specific funding opportunities. So that first phase, projects are submitted into the dashboard. Every project gets scored on five criteria that assesses their completeness and alignment with the region in terms of like
2:39:38 What do they need to be able to move forward? Scoring low on any of these doesn't mean that those projects won't move forward. It really informs how the alliance comes together in order to move projects forward. Then those projects are sorted into different categories, what we call bins. And then the next phase is within each one of those bins, we have certain criteria that those projects are
2:40:09 So that's the values based on regional context. In the bins, these are kind of what we have, fuels reduction within communities, surrounding communities, and then in the wild lands, more in the mountains, we have infrastructure projects, outreach and education, evaluation and studies, and then other. And you can imagine that
2:40:34 The values and criteria that we would want to associate with a fuels reduction project are very different than what we might want to do with education and outreach. And so in the past framework, we didn't have a system to be able to compare apples to oranges. So this system really allows us to compare apples to apples projects with...
2:40:54 Similar, you know, the same type of project against each other and then across bins so that we have consistent standardized way of looking at projects. And then that kind of main assessment goes into a technical committee. And that technical committee is not a static body. It's built around what skills and information are really needed to match.
2:41:19 Projects to particular funding sources. And so that committee will take in those readiness scores, those value scores, regional contexts like geography, equity, all of that stuff, what the actual risk is, align it with specific project or funding opportunity requirements, and then build a portfolio that then the alliance as a whole approves.
2:41:46 So the goal with building portfolios is really to layer projects in a way that we create a cohesive, complementary set of projects for different funding opportunities so that we can start really addressing the gaps that we have to reduce risk. And that's the presentation. I would like to add a few comments before we...
2:42:13 Open discussion and questions. One of the reasons that I brought this item on the agenda today is to make sure that all the member agencies are aware that this process is happening and is aware of, if not engaged, with the Wildfire Alliance. As Kristen said in this presentation and others preceding it, the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance is, excuse me, Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance is,
2:42:43 Like necessary underlying infrastructure to be able to access certain Prop 4 funding, particularly Sierra Nevada Conservancy funding for wildfire mitigation. And this project prioritization and project database is going to help inform which of the projects.
2:43:03 would make it into some of those funding rounds. The Wildfire Alliance is very open. Certainly all the fire departments and other relevant agencies are invited to include in those invitations. But please make sure that there is engagement so that this project portfolio will reflect the full regional needs and scope. I also wanted to let the board know I sent out an email a couple weeks ago.
2:43:31 That the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance was invited by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy into, I believe, round three of their landscape grant program. The third tier, that round three, is an interview with the agencies. We were invited for our interview last Friday. So the White Bark Institute and ESCOG put together.
2:43:59 Presentation of our information and presented to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. We were the first interview. I believe there's eight areas that were invited into that process. And then they will make a decision narrowing that down to four or five regions that will be selected for funding. And that announcement will be made in October.
2:44:23 We are continuing to follow up with the interview panel from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy to provide them additional information on our project portfolio and our prioritization process. And as we get feedback, we'll keep the greater alliance informed of what is needed. Thank you. Who was on that interview panel? Do you remember? I apologize. I don't remember all of the names. Kristen might be able to help with Sarah.
2:44:53 Yeah, Sarah Campy, I wasn't in the interview, so I don't actually know. I know Elisa, I can't remember her last name, but she does all the grant administration and grant writing workshops. I think Matt Driscoll was on there. Matt Driscoll was on there. Andy, who is there, I don't, I apologize, I have... Andy Fertensky? Correct, I have my notes in a different notebook on the interview panel. So, they are going to be here.
2:45:21 Next week in June Lake? Yeah, so it wouldn't be bad for us to go. Be charming up there. I'm on the tour. Are you on the tour? Have you been invited to speak to the tour? I'm on the tour. Okay. So they finally published what that's going to look like. I've been talking with the Whitebark folks, but we should coordinate with this for sure to establish the presence.
2:45:50 I think I'm also glad, Elaine, you brought that up because I think that let's just say that that grant gets awarded and it would be awarded to the ESCOG and the SNC is very attracted to the ESCOG because it is a regional JPA, right? But I think using that as an example, if nothing else, on the 18th to say, okay,
2:46:13 With the other things we've talked about already, the values things you've talked about, who are we, what are we doing, the admin thing we've kind of talked about, use that as an example to say, look, if this were to arrive, how will we successfully engage with this? And Supervisor Oral, on that last Zoom meeting we had with the larger subcommittee, I was very encouraged, I was very happy to hear your comments about, well, all this wildfire stuff really started up in Mammoth and Mono County and all the rest of it.
2:46:41 Then you added, but I see how this is coming down into the region. And with all the stuff we've been through, this Wildfire Alliance is the opportunity to get that kind of capacity region-wide. We've all done a lot of work to do that, and I think that that will be a useful tool to use as a focusing thing for the strategic work that we're doing. So if we are limited by the end of September, at least we can get that done and we know how we'd be able to consume and manage something like that. So I just throw that out there and offer that there's a possibility.
2:47:13 I have to let the board know also that with apologies, I will not be able to be in the area for that SNC tour. So if other people are able to attend and establish a presence, I'm grateful. Thank you. Yeah, I've been working with Matt and Eric Vane and others to do the wildfire piece. It'll be the last stop that we do in June Lake. And that's what we're supposed to be talking about. And just wanted to thank you and Laura and Kristen and all the work that you did to prepare.
2:47:38 For that interview last Friday, I know that it was just another, like, surprise deadline, but it's great. I mean, we define, in my mind, what a rowdy landscape is. With everybody's help, we have created a project dashboard that touches every community in a region that's larger than some states. So, thank you. Yeah, I mean, as flowy as this is, we're in the game.
2:48:09 And we've got compact, we can pull things together to do this. So, yeah, let's keep our eyes on that. Yeah, so I think next week's meeting should be good. Any other questions, comments for our Wildfire Alliance update? Council Member Souser, anything? Nothing here, thank you. Okay, then I will say thank you. I appreciate that. And we will move on to staff update reports.
2:48:41 Good morning once more. I have provided written updates in your agenda packet. Staff is available to answer any questions that you have. Only a few things that I wanted to highlight for your awareness. First, we did host a CoLab Summit in July. It was a great deal of work to set that up. I'm very grateful to Mr. Etzel.
2:49:07 tremendous amount of hours he poured into the logistics to make that a successful event. We had about 70 participants show up on both days representing partners and agencies from across the region. And the feedback I've heard, particularly from some of the land management agencies, was how much they appreciated.
2:49:25 the opportunity to hear what some of the broader community concerns are and to sit down with people, get outside their offices and talk about what some of those priorities are. In particular, we had very positive follow-up from LADWP who sent two or three staff members on both days, which was wonderful. Also wanted to let you know, ESCOG was contacted by Southern California Edison.
2:49:50 who had a small amount of funding that was available only if directed to COGS, very specific, and so they have granted us $1,500 that is earmarked to support the Golden Muscle effort specifically, so we're working with the Eastern Sierra Golden Muscle Alliance just to disperse that funding back into the community. I believe that covers, oh,
2:50:16 One other thing, I apologize. We also convened the first regional biomass meeting as a sub-working group of the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance to understand what some of the needs, opportunities, bottlenecks.
2:50:35 Capacity needs are for biomass across the region, anticipating a lot of the community hardening and other wildfire resiliency work that will be coming in the next few years. Aside from that, I'm happy to take any questions on those items or anything in the report. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions, comments for any of the staff reports? Just the only thing is, again, calendaring for these events like the night or meeting.
2:51:05 I'm just not getting anything, so I don't have things on my calendars. I hate to say I'm living in that world now, but if it's not on my calendar, it doesn't exist. So whatever you can do to help make sure we get these dates and these times, because I'm not available on September 9th at this point. Thank you. Anybody else? It's kind of the last one, but last item, but when do we expect a decision out of Sierra Nevada Conservancy?
2:51:34 They said that they would make a decision in October and it would be announced at their December board meeting and then they would work with the selected regions to refine the portfolio in January. Okay. Okay. We will move on. In the interest of time, I suggest that we skip.
2:52:05 Item number six, unless somebody has something just so pressing that they need to share today? Only thing, in the interest of time, we have an ESSRP meeting coming up on Monday afternoon, and you're all on that list, but there's going to be a pretty substantial update on Jobs First closeout of the recreation and tourism industry sector closeout. Everything's been...
2:52:31 done, all the rest of it, but also some updates on other S&C stuff that's going on that affects potentially this grant. They're doing a nature-based solutions tour around the state, and there's going to be a session happening up in Truckee that I've been asking on a panel on right after Labor Day at that intersection of Jobs First, nature-based solutions, wildfire work. It's all starting to come together on the ground.
2:53:02 Between those things we've all been working on, and we are the ground. We are the ground. So it's going to get interesting, I think. If you can make it to ESCO, we'll need some interesting things to share. Thank you for sharing that. Anybody else have anything you want to talk about the volunteer policy? One, we're recruiting a public works director. Excuse me. Thank you. Turn that mic on.
2:53:33 We're not ashamed to poach from other agencies. So yesterday, do a little research, don't know how, but we think it may be the first such policy in the state, but we just did an amendment to our personnel policies, creating a new lead bank, it's 40 hours a year.
2:53:56 For first responders responding to volunteer first responders for search and rescue, EMS, and fire. So there's a 40-hour bank for this response. So people can just leave as long as the, you know, the correctional officer can't leave the jail. But, you know, as long as it's not critical to county business, they can leave. And then...
2:54:24 Beyond that 40 hours, there's sort of a policy for using vacation time or flex time or even leave without pay. Pretty proud of that policy. Okay. Okay. Then, okay, let's go to number seven. Is there, are there any requests for future agenda items? I think we're good. Okay. And then, a journey to the next regular meeting. Our next regular meeting is in October.
2:54:57 And there is a conflict with Inyo County. Just real quick, will our September meeting be, that will be right, that'll be a special meeting. That'll be a special meeting, yes. And we're hoping to not tack on any action items. Exactly, it'll be just for that. Yeah, it's just for strategic planning workshop. Yeah, so on the 28th of October, so the 27th, Inyo County has a...
2:55:27 Board meeting in Tacopa. And so it's pretty challenging for Trina and I to make it back. And it's looking like it's going to be a two-part Tuesday and Wednesday meeting. We're going to be talking about the Bonanza Solar Plant for Charlton View. So I don't know the availability of the other board members, but I think we determined if...
2:55:55 So we could do, I mean, just throwing out there, the Friday the 30th would work, the 29th would work, the 21st, 22nd, 23rd, those seem relatively open. Friday the 30th is ideal, but I could make the 29th work. I'm available Friday the 30th. Depends on the time, but about 8.30 in the morning. No, it'd have to be after 11. After 11. Works for me. Or afternoon.
2:56:34 On the 30th? 30th, yeah. Yeah, I'm flexible that entire day. 1 to 3 or something. Is that scheduled to be at Mammoth? Yeah. It is scheduled to be in Mammoth. I'll confirm with the board clerk and make sure that Suite Z is available and that the clerking staff is available, so I might have to come back to the board separately if that date doesn't work. Okay.
2:57:09 I love coming to Bishop, so. All right, thank you. Thanks to Bill for joining us today so we can have a quorum. Thank you, Bill. Thank you, Bill. Indeed. The king of all he surveys. Okay, and with that then, we are adjourned. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much for stepping in.