Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2026
Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Special meeting
at 13:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
497 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:43 Thank you. You ready, Jamie? Okay, everybody. Good afternoon, and welcome to the special meeting, strategic planning of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, today, September 18, 2026. I will call this meeting to order, and Jamie, if you'll please do the roll call. Supervisor Oral? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? Here. Supervisor Salcedo?
8:08 Here. Council Member Wentworth. Here. Council Member Schwartz. Here. Supervisor McFarlane. Here. Council Member Kong. Here. Council Member Salzer. Here. All right. Thank you, Jamie. Now we'll move on to our Pledge of Allegiance. Let's see. I'll ask Council Member Wentworth to lead us, please. Thank you. True blue. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the United States of America.
8:41 Thank you, Council Member Whitworth. We'll move on to our public comments. This time is set aside to receive public comment on matters, not calendar on the agenda. Is there anybody in the room who would like to address the board at this time? Is there anybody online?
9:12 Okay, seeing no public comment, we will move on to item number four, workshop. The board will participate in a strategic planning workshop, so at this time, I will turn it over to our director, Elaine Kabala. Good afternoon to the board, to the regional leadership. Thank you so much for coming to Mammoth and joining us for the strategic board workshop session.
9:41 I really appreciate your time in being here today. I appreciate your time in convening in Mammoth for this discussion. I also appreciate the input that I've received from the board through this process to help inform the outcomes and objectives for today.
10:03 Strategic Planning Initiative for ESCOG was born out of a Sierra Jobs First Catalyst grant that ESCOG received coming out of the California Jobs First Initiative. And the scope of the grant was intended to work on identifying models for effective regional collaboration in ESCOG's programmatic areas of focus. So primarily wildfire,
10:30 As well as opportunities for economic development. We are continuing to work through the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance with my colleague Ken Etzel on building
10:47 Relationships for Recreation and exploring pathways for economic development. But what this has evolved into is a really timely opportunity for ESCOG to develop a strategic plan and to bring these partners together. Could I ask you to grab a chair for me, please? Thank you.
11:09 It's become a really timely opportunity to have this conversation. Since ESCOG's inception as a joint powers authority in 2020, I don't think that there has been an opportunity for the board and for the CAOs to convene in the same room to have a conversation about ESCOG's work to date.
11:34 ESCOG's capacity needs, the value served back to the member agencies, and where each of the member agencies in the region want to go in the next three to five years with ESCOG's programs of work. So this is a very timely opportunity for alignment between the four jurisdictions of ESCOG and to think about
11:56 What is the scope of regionalism in the Eastern Sierra? And how is ESCOG the right and effective tool for achieving those objectives? So again, I really appreciate your time, the investment of your thought in doing this work.
12:11 As part of this grant, we have the benefit of working with Agnew Beck as our consultants and facilitators and leading us through the process today and helping develop the deliverable that will be a strategic plan for ESCOG as well as the objective of the deliverable for this year, our jobs first grant. I just want to do some framing for the strategic workshop today, which is that
12:40 We're not looking at what ESCOG will be doing tomorrow. We're not looking to build capacity overnight. I think what we're really trying to think of is what is this organization going to look like in three to five years in serving the region and what are the priorities and how are we going to be building the capacity and planning for that so that ESCOG can be a successful organization and can hold that work responsibly.
13:07 So with that, I would like to go ahead and introduce our consulting team from Agnew Beck. Shawna Doherty is our lead facilitator. She's joined by Christina Kine, who's providing the supporting facilitation today. Thank you again. Are there any questions before we begin? Nope. Can everyone hear me? Good morning, everyone, or afternoon.
13:38 We're so happy to be here in person with all of you. Thank you for that introduction and the frame-up, Elaine. Before we jump in, I wanted just to talk a little bit about what we have in store for the day, for the afternoon, but to kick us off, it's the end of the week, it's a Friday.
14:01 And so just to go around quickly and just say, introduce yourself, what your favorite fall treat is and why you serve, really quickly. Fall treat or fall treat? Fall treat. Fall treat. My favorite fall treat is fall trees. My name is Jeff Griffiths. And why do you serve? Why do I serve? To make my community a better place. Okay, and I think we have to put
14:32 Hi, I'm Pam Foster. I'm not really into pumpkin anything, so sorry. And I serve because, you know, it's part of our community. It's why we're here. We need to give back and do the right thing and help keep progress going. You're welcome. Your turn.
15:00 Hi, I'm Christy Milovich. I am the Inyo County Assistant County Counsel, so I'm serving as counsel for ESCOG, and thank you for giving me a seat at the table. I didn't need it, but I appreciate it. My favorite fall treat is pumpkin everything. Rob Patterson, Town Manager, Town of Mammoth Lakes. You know, I serve, obviously, it's my job to take care of the community, and I think this is an important investment of time in an organization that can...
15:31 sort of maximize our effectiveness as a region. I just like the cooler weather in the fall. Bill Souser, Town Council in Mammoth. I serve on this particular board because someone else quit. Wish I could give a better reason. I serve in general publicly because of my love for the area and the things it has to offer.
16:02 Favorite fall treat would have to be getting on the dirt roads and going out looking at color. Karen Pong, Bishop City Council. I serve because that's what I do in my life. My jobs are service oriented and I believe that in politics there should be people who don't have agendas. Favorite fall treat, I'm going to go with Halloween.
16:35 I'm Linda Salcedo. I'm a Mono County Supervisor. Fall tree is just the trees, watching the trees and the things around us. And I serve because, like you, that's what I do. That's all my jobs in my world. I've always been service-oriented, and I'm glad I have a chance. John Wentworth, Mammoth Lakes Town Council. The fall tree has to be the high country, the dustings, the colors.
17:01 I serve for the money. I serve because I am compelled to serve. Paul McFarland, Mammoth County, Supervisor. Fall trade is the shift in the light. And I serve because this place is worth it. And because we're better together.
17:23 Sandra Moberly, County Administrative Officer for Mono County. I serve because I really care about this place. A lot of those same things that everyone has talked about and care about the people here and want to make a difference. And my favorite fall treat is re-watching old Halloween movies. Now you can. It's okay to do that. Anytime. Yeah. I'm Janelle Carrington, the Acting County Administrator for Inyo County.
17:49 I'm a lifelong resident of Inyo County, love the area, and that's why I serve, and I like pumpkin bread. And I'm Megan Ostrander, I'm the Deputy County Administrator for Inyo County. I serve because I want the area to be a place that I want to be, and I work to make it a place I want to be.
18:16 And my favorite fall treat is getting to turn on the fire and have a pot of tea in the evenings. I'm Elaine Kabbala, Director for the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. I serve because I love my community. And my favorite fall treat is the shifting light and the colors and the trees. I'm Karen Schwartz, Bishop City Council.
18:41 I recently had a Rice Krispie Treat at the Mammoth Grand Fondo and I realized that's my favorite. And I serve because I love serving the community to be part of the process to make decisions because they will be made one way or the other. So I want to participate. Okay, thank you everybody. I am Trina Oral, Inyo County Supervisor. I serve because I had the...
19:10 Extraordinary privilege of growing up in this region. And by serving, I can give back and help to ensure that this is a place for future generations to have the same extraordinary experience that I had growing up. And my favorite fall treat is always the changing of the leaves, the color. Nothing beats it. All right, have a Christina and Ken and Kristen online. And my favorite treat, wash season. I'm not serving.
19:58 I'm Ken Etzel, Regional Recreation Coordinator with ESCOG. I guess I'm in this position because I believe in the value of recreation and how it can help economic resiliency in our region. And my favorite part of fall has to be the shifting lights. And that's Kristen on line. Hi, everyone. Kristen Feiler. I am joining you from my parents' house in Nevada, so thanks for making it possible to be there.
20:32 In spirit, I'm the regional wildfire coordinator and I am serving in this role kind of because it's an oddly unique combination of my skill sets and I think there's just like a ton of room for creative capacity and I'm really proud of what we've actually been able to build through this program.
21:01 And I think my favorite part of fall is the crisp air. And also, I did request, like, captions, if that's possible to allow for captions to be on the Zoom. Just, it's a little hard to hear some of you. Not sure if that's possible, though. Okay, we'll look into that. Thanks, Kristen. Okay, so everyone could just turn. John, if you mind, just, I'm going to stand over here for a second. Okay, sure, sure.
21:33 So I just want to give you a little, so on the theme of fall, we work with a lot of groups, and fall is a time of reflection. This is an incredible opportunity to have the ESCOG board and then the administrators in the room. I believe this is the first time that you've done a planning process to talk about where ESCOG is today and where it's going in the future, all in one room at the same time. Is that correct?
22:01 So this is a historic moment. It's a time, it's a moment of reflection to pause and have some real conversations around accomplishments, what we see as where the organization is today, and have conversations amongst all of you of where we want to direct it moving forward. So a little bit of how the flow, you've had an agenda, but I wanted to open up the hood and tell you a little bit more of what it's going to feel like.
22:30 Those of you who have worked with me know that there's going to be a lot of movement in the room. We have stations set up in small groups, so the flow, the cadence of the day will be sharing some information and then having you have discussions in smaller groups. Some of the discussions we'll have in the larger group, but just know.
22:54 That we are going to be pausing and putting it back on you, and it's not about us talking at you all day. It's a little bit of information and then what do you think. A little bit of information and then what do you think. So we really divided the meeting into two parts. Part one is the grounding, level setting, making sure. I know there's people in this room that could stand up here and give us a two-hour lecture on ESCOG, but there are also brand new people.
23:20 So what we want to make sure is that when we go into the setting of the direction, that everyone has the same information and is talking from the same song sheet and that we can go into that planning session, which is part two. Our goal is this is around an hour. Part of this is going to be a little bit of a digestion in the small groups of the information we hear. And then this afternoon, we're going to go into looking at the work programs.
23:48 And then brainstorming around setting the direction for the next three years. I think Elaine shared the big information about Sierra Jobs First. Okay.
24:03 So if you're not familiar with the Sierra Jobs First program or California Jobs First, it was originally intended to sunset at the end of this month on September 30th. So that was a really expedited timeline for us to accomplish any of these projects. So the good news is that there was an extension, a non-cost extension offered through June 30th. Sierra Business Council informed us yesterday that we did receive an extension for
24:30 Each of our grants contingent on making sure that all of the invoicing paperwork is up to date by September 30th. So we will be proceeding with a contract extension that will allow for this workshop to sort of serve as a phase one, and then we'll have opportunities to, moving forward, continue to work with Agnewbeck to refine it and really be able to build it out with that extension. Okay, so next slide. Next slide.
25:06 Okay, I wanted to pause here for a second. You all know who we are, but what I wanted to highlight is the particular experience that I'm bringing to this conversation. I wanted you all to know that I worked at the town of Truckee for two years as their first housing program manager, and the reason I wanted to bring that up is that I have been the staff on the inside of government.
25:33 And so I'm not just trained as a facilitator and, you know, helping you come up with these great ideas and posters and pens. I had to write staff reports. I had to put a budget together. I'll blah, blah, blah. I had to do all the things. So I just wanted you all to know that I come with that experience. So I do understand. I also have done strategic planning for a housing JPA up in the Tahoe Truckee area since its founding. And so I do have a little bit of that experience with the JPA.
26:02 So I wanted to highlight those things because we all know each other and we all wear a million hats, but for this I wanted to highlight that experience that I'm not just like this gal who's just facilitating the meeting. I do have that contextual information that I'm also thinking about as we present the information and thinking about I understand resolutions, I understand bylaws, I understand codes, so I am bringing that.
26:29 I work with Mandy Morris. So I understand the context. Okay, there it is. I was looking for my phone. There it is. It's just like Ken who just found his AirPods for the first time. Okay, so I just wanted to give you that a little bit. For those of you who don't know about us, we've been around for 25 years. We're based out of Anchorage. Weird coincidence, one of our Anchorage.
26:58 Colleagues is a good friend. So can you talk a little bit about just that connection? Yeah, one of my best friends moved to Alaska and she introduced me and actually my really good friend is married to Thea's, who's the principal of Agnew Beck, Thea Agnew. Anyway, I've known Thea as a very
27:27 Like, we've skied together, we've, you know, hung out together. And anyway, and I introduced Elaine to Thea years ago, right? Or to Agnew Beck, I think, remember, like years ago? I think we had the conversation. Okay, maybe I was like, I know a consultant firm. Anyway, and so Kirsten also is a really good friend of mine. I have big connections with Agnew Beck. Yeah. Just very socially. Yeah. This is the first time I've actually worked with you guys professionally. So there's an east side Alaska connection. Yeah. Okay, next slide. Thank you for that.
27:57 So the objectives today are just, again, like I said, build a shared understanding of where ESCOG is today, build alignment amongst this group. You know, Elaine is really asking for alignment so that as she directs the organization moving forward, she's really clear that she's acting on behalf of what the collective wants her to work on. So, and then updating some of our directional documents. Anything else? Not documents.
28:27 Directives and Strategic Plan. Is there anything else anyone else wants to get out of today that is not listed? Next slide. Okay, so I already went into this. We go to the next slide. A little bit around, we already talked about this, but we have been out having conversations in the community for the last several months through the summit, through interviews, looking at regional plans.
29:01 And doing research, bringing that all to bear into infusing this conversation. We're now in the develop, you know, what to do with that information and this group deciding how to incorporate that feedback moving forward. And then, as Elaine said, we have the opportunity for two workshops. And then everything will be brought to you to decide what to do as far as renewing resolutions or sunsetting resolutions. Next slide.
29:33 Okay, so we're going to go into ESCOG today. So you all have these, you might want to grab your PowerPoints because there's going to, some of these slides have a lot of information in them. I'm going to go through this information. I would invite you to pause me if I'm presenting something that's not exactly.
30:00 This is not every single piece of your history. We looked at
30:29 Your bylaws. And we looked at some of your documents. I think some of the things that stood out to us is that from the very beginning, even before you were a JPA and you were, I think it was called a steering committee or an Eastern Sierra committee. What was it? Do you remember what it was called? Was anybody in this room on that?
30:54 It was about getting together and coordinating and talking and... It was more information sharing. Information sharing. Like, what's going on? This is what we're doing. What are you guys doing? That's all of us. Except when the airport topic came up. Well, actually, pre that...
31:18 It was through the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments that the four entities got together to create Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. And so before Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, it was Inyo Mono Area Agency on Aging. It was the senior program that did the transportation. And then the four groups got together and had the discussions of forming that entity, which is also a joint powers authority.
31:46 ESTA, of the four entities, and so it came out of that. Right. And then we go into the following, when the resolutions were created, and then the funding sources, and then up to this year. Interestingly, when we're thinking about where we're at and where we're going, is you're exactly where you're supposed to be.
32:13 The organization has evolved into what it is today, and it's come from conversations and coordinating to an actual government entity, to its first staff, to being able to have the capacity to accept large grants, to resolutions directing programs of work, and obviously a trajectory of growth over time. And so this is a moment in time.
32:41 That really it is a chance to say where do we want to go in the future based on this trajectory that has clearly happened over the last 10 years of growth. So is it continued growth? Is it going back inward and trying to bolster and build the capacity within? These are the type of questions that we want you to start thinking about in the context of your history. Anything else stand out about the history that you noticed?
33:13 Yes, I mean, I just, I think it's a fun story of that moment in 1819 of Lake when we transitioned. It was Karen, John, myself, and Stacey Corliss. We had the ice skating summit where we met on the county line at Rock Creek Lake and ice skated and talked about the idea of transitioning to an authority.
33:42 I think it's really wonderful. A song was composed, but we'll do that later. We'll do that later. I want to get that song. You know, to think about just having the idea of building basically government infrastructure that did not exist without the exact plan of what it would be. We had an idea of where it would be and to see where it is today and it's exactly...
34:09 What we anticipated, that once that infrastructure was created, then it would be a vessel that was available for grants and programs regionally that we would not have access to without working together. That's great. I think it would be great to try to write that story down. There's the JPA that formed up in Tahoe Trucking was, they always tell the origin story as we were having a meeting and then we always had breakfast burritos and the four partners were off having their breakfast burritos.
34:38 And they said, why don't we just like form our own, like, why don't we just start working on housing? And so they call it their breakfast burrito origin story, kind of like the ice skating. So it'd be great to write those things down. Okay, so part of the origin story was the development of these bylaws. And I think you have those, did we hand those out yet? So we printed those out, we think, again, in the spirit of reflection. That is your guiding document.
35:07 On what you can do. So it's not the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities. I don't know if it got handed up. Yes, it is. Okay. So this is the guiding document of ESCOG that was created originally, which is pretty basic. We can get together. I mean, we have our legal rep here. We can get together. We can decide to work on some things, and we're going to do broadband. Right? That's kind of what it says.
35:36 So as we're thinking about the strategic plan, you have the bylaws and you have your resolutions. Those are kind of like your guiding documents. So we're going to get into these bylaws to just remember they exist. And it's important as a board member to glance at those, probably annually, and make sure you understand.
36:02 I looked at them when I first started working with ESCOG and then I re-read them again this week and I just know so much more now and it's just a good reminder. Okay, so you can go back for a second. So we just pulled out this one section. I thought it was interesting that the word collaboration is not in there at all and the word collective. We can function collectively on a regional basis.
36:32 where it makes sense and if it improves the delivery of services. So I just think that's important to remember that those are the words that were chosen and as we go into another document that is more of a directional organizational document if it's not going to be a legal document, the strategic plan, but to bridge these words over and bring them over. Okay, next.
37:02 You guys know this, the governance structure is you have eight appointed board members, two from each of the members. These are the members today. This structure will stand when all the people in this room transition out. It will be two from each for now. Next. Your staffing structure. So with all organizations, the board of directors are
37:30 the lead for the organization, and they are in charge of managing and directing staff. Board is also in charge of setting direction, and so that is why we're doing the strategic planning. And then there are some staff, as we'll get into this, but all of the staff down below are covered by grant funding, and Elaine's position is the only staff of ESCOG that is full-time and
37:59 You're covered by different grants and member fees, member dues. Next. So this is something that you haven't seen pulled out before. We pulled this information from your existing approved budget because what we're going to talk a lot about this afternoon is
38:24 Building the capacity of ESCOG to be able to stand up in a way that the region and partners are asking them to. And what does that look like? And so to do that, we wanted to pull out, because I think you all get budgets that are very complex around like grant funding and what's covered by the big grants. And when you take away the big grants and what they cover and just look at sort of ESCOG as an organization, it's a very tiny budget.
38:54 I mean, $217,000 to manage millions of dollars of revenue. And that's just, that's the key point. This meeting today, to Petrina's point, our subcommittee meeting, is this is a high level, but we want that nugget to lodge in your head of, so we could potentially be managing another five to nine million dollars if that Sierra Nevada Conservancy grant comes in.
39:23 And all these other grants, and are we getting to the point where the ask is greater than the capacity we have in place? So, just something, and you have that in your packet to keep looking at. The other important thing to hear is the member contributions are 25 per member, so that's 100, and that doesn't cover Elaine's, you know, your overhead.
39:51 And so that gets pulled from admin and from grants, but just to understand sort of the internal operating budget. Any questions there? Okay, next. Okay, so these are the programs of work that are in your resolutions. I'm just familiarizing you. There's three of them. So sustainable rec, broadband's been there the longest, and then the Community Economic Resiliency Fund.
40:30 The third one is that the economic resiliency is set to sunset because it was part of the Sierra Jobs First funding and so that's a conversation that we're going to be having. Next. I think one of the things that's important to also recognize in these three programs of work is that
40:54 Pursuant to ESCOG bylaws, all of those programs of work are authorized by each member agency. So there was an affirmative vote from all four member agencies for ESCOG to be doing that work. Okay, so taking those same programs of work, that's about, you can see that the relative grant dollars that are coming into each of those work programs. So for SHREMP, SHREMP, SHREMP? Two million.
41:25 The bulk of the work coming through with the wildfire work, and then economic resiliency through this year, jobs first, and then the broadband is kind of the through line through all the years. Next slide? Just real quick on that. The original grant, the White Park ESCCRP grant, is that listed? I know that's done, but is that...
41:54 In here somewhere. Yeah, so the numbers we're looking at are for this fiscal year. This fiscal year. Yeah. But we're going to show, we have a slide that shows total grants that ESCOG has secured to date as a total, which is kind of interesting. Which will include that. Yep. Okay, next slide. So these are the sun setting. So this is just familiarizing what's sun setting 2027. So
42:18 Most of these are related to, so the ag study is completing the things related to recreation are sunsetting and then the pace and scale program. And then, so the key thing on the left to remember is that that whole work program, I said it before, that work program is sunsetting. That's a decision for the board. But on, excuse me, the top one, on the trend, the only thing that's sunsetting are the programmatic things.
42:47 Obviously, the work program is going to stay. But related to economic development, that work program is sunsetting, and so that's the bigger decision. Next slide. So the pipeline, and this is, again, how likely is it? No one knows, but it's important to ready the organization for being successful. So should this funding come in? Are we ready? Do we have the capacity to manage those grants?
43:17 to disperse the grants, to do all that's required in the grants and do the work. So are we getting ourselves ready? So there's that. And where is the work? Is it across our work program areas? Is it mostly in the wildfire? What are the implications of that? So significant funding there in economic development for you to know that, and I know you've heard this, but as a reminder, there is an opportunity should you get
43:46 The EDD designation, that there would be a continual funding of $70,000 a year coming into the organization that you don't have in any other way right now other than your member dues. Everything right now is a peak and a low. It's five years of a lot of money, three years of a lot of money, grant-driven, and what you want to start moving towards is this reliant funding that is consistent. Okay, so you know, and that starts to be able to build the capacity of the organization.
44:16 And your impact. And so things like the EDD designation would allow for that start to that regular $70,000 coming in. Yes? Question. Just because the Community Economic Resiliency Fund pilot program has potential funding of $70,000 per year, does that mean...
44:38 The shrimp and the Inyo Mono Broadband, is that a per year, too, potential funding of $10,000 per year? Yes. No, no, no, no. The shrimp, if it's awarded, that would be that $10,000 as inclusive of the CWDG, which is awarded, and potentially the SNC funding, both those are over five years. And then the Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium is $200,000 per year for three years. For three years, yeah. Yes.
45:07 Yeah, so that EDD is the only one that would be ongoing. Okay, next slide. Okay, so part of this process, and this came out a lot from the conversations that we had with partners around the region and many of you, you know, what is the role of ESCOG? What is how, we know what's in the bylaws, but to you,
45:36 How is it a vehicle and an organization that helps you do what you do? And these are the kind of, there were clear vocabulary on that. And so part of this process coming out of it is we want really clear vocabulary so that when all of you are going back to your elected bodies or your staff and someone says, oh, what were you doing this afternoon? And you say, I was at an ESCOG board meeting. They go, oh, wow, yeah, so what's ESCOG? We're hoping that after this you have
46:04 Staff has a strategic plan and a communications plan and gives you talking points and you're really clear on how to answer that question and we're all saying the same thing. So part of that is being really clear on what we do and you will notice it doesn't say implementation because really, and that was a big conversation with many of you is, you know, does ESCOG do implementation? And ESCOG is facilitating implementation.
46:34 by stepping up and serving partners in ways that they need capacity, whether it's helping to get the grants, whether it's providing a study, technical assistance, advocating, all those things. And even if you look at your website and the description of your work programs, there is room for, there's internal room. It's not a criticism, but just...
47:01 to really explain what our role is, where we got the funding, and how that's moving towards impacting results. Next slide. Okay, so this is a new, we've exposed you to this at board meetings and subcommittee meetings, so I want to pause for a second. So if we take, everyone's aware of the Wildfire Alliance. Kristen, kudos to you and your team.
47:32 And that was a, we're going to call that, for this is a draft name, the ESCOG impact model. And so when we look at the role of ESCOG and how they go about doing their work, it's not just Elaine sitting in an office and applying for a grant and getting the money and then rolling it out to everyone. There's always, if you go back to the founding of this organization and the informal conversations.
48:00 It's about a group of people seeing a challenge or an opportunity, coming together, having a conversation around it, figuring out what to do, maybe you need a study, maybe you need some money, then you get the money, you do the study, and then you figure out once you get the money and you have some indication from the analysis and the data that what to do moving forward.
48:27 Ideally, in the center of all that, you have a working group or a group of people that are stewarding that work through the process. So part of the reason of doing this is we got feedback through the process of, I kind of know what ESCOG does. I don't really see, they're helping me do my project, but I don't really see the value. I need to understand more clearly what the return on investment is, what their model is.
48:56 They seem like they're just chasing grants. So when we look at across the line at all the work that you do, part of this process is showing both internally and externally how all those pieces fit together towards the goal of positioning the region to be ready to accept dollars and be competitive for dollars to implement the projects that the partners want to implement. And so
49:24 If you look at the ESCOG website now, and all of you knowing all this work we just talked about, you have sort of like the chipmunk thing over here, and then you have biomass over here, and then you have the VRC, and so then all of us in our brains are saying, how is that all connected? And there is a Venn diagram that is about strengthening community and strengthening the economy and healthy economy, but there's also a model of how work gets done, and proof is in
49:53 Wildfire Alliance. So we're going to talk about that. We're going to take you through this model, which is IDing regional issues and opportunities, bringing people together, doing the study, prioritizing, securing funding, and then partner implementation. And so let's name that and use that to talk about the work of ESCOG as a way to build understanding of the model. And then let's
50:22 We've tested it in the wildfire, and now let's take this model and get ourselves ready for the same level of success in rec or economic development. And that's the, you know, wanting the board and the team here to understand that behind some of the models we're going to show you today is this hub concept being used to drive future work. And we'll get more into that. But for now we're calling it an impact model.
50:52 And Shana, the working group in the middle is the working group that's put together for each different topic. Correct. It is comprised of some members of ESCO. Correct. So they exist. So if you take, like right now, like there is a monthly economic development working group. It doesn't, Elaine and, and who are you working with on that? Is that mostly you? Okay. So that, a monthly meeting coordinating, it's coordinating.
51:21 They don't have funding or a long-term resolution in place from ESCOG to implement SEDS or do more, but that's a loose, it's trying to move through the wheel. So it has a working group, but they haven't gone through the wheel yet. And then obviously with wildfire, this is an example of
51:48 And I'm not going to spend the time on this. You all have this. But this is an example where, you know, welfare. Identifying the gaps. There's funding out there. We know we have to have a collaborative in place to get the funding, establish a group, figure out a portfolio of projects. Then we've moved into the Sierra Nevada Prop 4 grant application and interview a couple weeks ago.
52:15 The money comes in, it'll be to deploy towards implementation of those projects. So that works really well with this impact model when we do it from a wildfire. I'll just bring out, though, I think it's important that we all understand that this is not a holistic ESCOG exercise. This came out of a non-profit, and when you talk about a working group, the working group was initially initiated through S&C, through not a lot of other places.
52:45 This is not exclusively ex-ESCOG doing this. No. There's a point of entry where ESCOG, it's determined that ESCOG has a role to play in order for something like this to succeed. Exactly. But I think it's going to be important to point out how, at what point does ESCOG engage and become a critical part of making these things successful. Yeah. And also, if there was a regional understanding of a model that works here to move things forward.
53:13 Who owns it? It's just, you'll see as we move forward into looking at work in recreation and work in economic development that the work we're talking about is doing this work, supporting work in this circle. Yeah, it would be helpful, I mean, to be thinking about at what point is ESCOG, where does ESCOG fit into the circle? Where does it come in? Yeah. And what is the critical role that ESCOG can play that the region without an ESCOG can't do it?
53:45 Yeah. So this is, again, this is for all of you to have as a resource that's in your packets, but what we wanted to do is show, instead of just having slides that said, here's the results today from some of the ways that ESCOG has supported Sustainable Rec or some of the work with partners in this space, we wanted to take it through this process, so we're starting to build common language around the process. And to answer your question, John, I think it's an invitation.
54:17 It's an invitation for ESCOG to come in to do things where there is a gap. Getting a call from a public agency and saying, I'm really struggling with having conversations with all the little NGOs and the users. Can we get a group together to talk about having more climbing rangers in this particular area? Can you help us convene that? And so then it starts with the convening. And if ESCOG, there's money and there's an invitation.
54:47 People understand that everyone's starting to work in the same thing, so it doesn't feel like all the work is disparate, but we're trying to move towards that goal of implementation. So, John, to your point, is there ever a time that ESCOG is the group in the middle that decides that we as the member agencies get to say, hey, this is really an issue? Yes, but that goes back to the original programs that are authorized by the four agencies.
55:16 This program with Chipmunk Canyon was authorized through the SHRMP, right? So that aligns. The origin story for this comes out of something called the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative, where, hey, we got to do something about Chipmunk Canyon, but there's no capacity to do anything about that. The money comes along through Jobs First, so there's money, there's opportunity, and the important piece of Chipmunk Canyon...
55:42 Is that the real entanglement with that is the land management challenge that you all have down there in Bishop with those agencies, LEDWP, the county need to have like a peer body at the center. I understand that the things that we do have to fit into one of those three categories. What I'm asking is, did in a meeting of this group, did someone say, hey, Chipmock Canyon's an issue, let's go talk to people about it? Yes.
56:13 That wasn't brought forward by one of the agencies? It was brought forward, well, it's so... That was my understanding that it didn't... It was brought forward by one of the agencies. Right. Their request to us. People have to go back to when the stones cooled. It started with SRTI. Coming out of SRTI, it was Towns to Trails. And when we started Towns to Trails as a trail network spanning the region, the Bureau of Land Management as one of the stakeholders to that...
56:40 brought up Chipmunk Canyon as a concern, where they said, hey, we have this issue with these unauthorized trails. Can you bring that sort of trail planning effort through ESCOG to find some solutions, to convene partners, to figure out how to legitimize that through town's trails? And we could not pivot the grant funding to do that. But we were able to identify different funding sources.
57:08 So it sort of, it fits within this model, it's just like how far back you would turn that clock. Well, and I guess that's my question, is will there ever be a time where Trina will come to ESCOG and say, we need to do a working group because there's this issue in Inyo County that I want to do? So the first thing would be, Trina's got an idea, okay, does ESCOG have previously authorized authority? Sure, of course, as long as those things fit in. Yeah, if we do, yeah, then we talk about it, and then we start putting these things in. That was my question.
57:37 If I might interject, I think just to kind of put a bow on this, the bottom line is that ESCOG is for the region. It's for all agencies, like Jeff was saying, to convene. And so when we look at the working group piece of it, we have to remember that it's an opportunity for outside agencies and member agencies who identify an issue or have a great idea.
58:06 If they can accomplish it on their own, they have the opportunity to come to Elaine or one of the members and say, hey, is this something within the scope of ESCOG, which then can, it enters the wheel. And I wasn't saying that that wasn't the way it should work. I was just asking the other question, which is, could member agencies bring something? So just to clarify, ESCOG is an open invitation to the region.
58:34 And I would just add, because Chipmunk Canyon comes up a lot when you think about this parochial versus regional discussion that we always seem to have. Chipmunk Canyon is a very strategic choice because every community here has a place like Chipmunk Canyon where you have an undesignated, unplanned system of roads and trails that have become a recreational amenity. This one was very...
59:01 Timely to use because you had an interested user group, you had an interested agency. And so by using Chitlam Canyon, we can set an example for the region of how we can do thoughtful trail designation across jurisdictions that all of our communities are asking for. And I think that that's one of the benefits of ESCOG is you can address regional benefits by doing proof of concept in individual communities. Because we're never going to do it region-wide at once. It's got to be.
59:31 done place by place. And this is a place to learn those skills, try them out, build trust, and then apply them to other communities. And I would add, with strong communications, to share out that information. Yeah. If I might add one thing to Karen's question. So, yes, I think in its original founding,
59:52 the goal of ESCOG was that it would serve as a forum for the member agencies to talk about what those regional issues are, be it directly affecting the member agencies exclusively, or these broader issues that transcend the individual jurisdictions. We have the programs of work that are adopted, but part of this question is like
1:00:16 We could also introduce additional programs of work if it is appropriate, if it's deemed appropriate by the board, if it's deemed appropriate by all the member agencies, but it also then is going to ask the question, does ESCOG have the capacity to responsibly hold that work? No, I wasn't, yeah, I was just trying to clarify. Good question. No, it's a good question. I mean, I think what's interesting about this is, again, this is me taking all of your information and trying to frame up good conversations for strategic planning, so that exit,
1:00:46 Model of Impact was, we came up with that name this week. This could also be a great tool for when Elaine gets a call from a public agency member or a member and sits down with them and has something like this and says, so I'm hearing that you need a study done for this particular trails area in Bridgeport. So these are the services we offer and this is sort of the areas we work in.
1:01:13 Are you talking about something like this? We've done something like this. And just can talk about the capacity of services that ESCOG has or other projects that have gone through this to support that project or that partner. So do we have a process? And forgive me, I'm new here. So I'm asking some questions to try to educate myself. And I'm old. I don't educate easy.
1:01:40 Do we have a process? It is. It is. Yes. Do we have a process here where we look at something like Chipmunk Canyon and we have a specific process to look at the groups that are some in favor, some opposed? Is this actually something that's going to do us good? Or in the end, are we going to lose trails that then the users are going to go and recreate someplace else, which is even worse? Because that concerns me. I've watched it happen over the years.
1:02:08 Do we have a method of doing all that? So for picking projects and work programs? Yeah, so someone brings this forward. BLM brings this forward, even though it's been out there for a long time, about the user-created trails in Chipmunk Canyon. And by taking this on, do we then, how do we look at those disparate groups and determine whether this is something
1:02:33 Worth the energy and the effort, or are we better off, is the public in fact better off, leaving it alone? I think you'd see at this point, this ship has sailed, and it's an opportunity to formalize a system, but as you stay on the ESCOG board for another two or three decades, you will have these opportunities to weigh in on these opportunities. For now, is there that system? If it's not, then...
1:03:02 Okay. Scoring process. Okay. I mean, those determinations, other than introduction for discussion at a board meeting. Well, I think it's somewhat built into the cycle where we say plan, study, data collection. That's where we're looking at the scope of a proposed project from the working group, and that's where we have our input and our determination, and even when we start to prioritize solutions, we're really looking.
1:03:31 That's part of this whole process. I think it's in there. So Jeff, did you want to say something? I was just going to say that I think that the fact that at minimum the programs work have to be approved by all four agencies and having representation by, you know, the diverse representation on the board and that it's in the bylaws that every
1:03:57 Anything that passes has to pass with at least one affirmative member from each agency that I think all of the guardrails are there that we're really working on a least common denominator thing that it's you know we've talked about doing a legislative platform for
1:04:19 ESCOG like we do with all of our different agencies, and really that that would be a much smaller thing because it has to be unanimous, like we're a consensus-based organization. So I think the structure puts up guardrails about what you're talking about. I think it's really important coming out of this thing today is those idiosyncrasies like you pointed out, that in order to move forward with the program, there has to be an affirmative vote.
1:04:47 from at least one member of each of the four jurisdictions. Is that written down somewhere? Yes. It's in the bylaws. So these are the kinds of things that I think when we produce, like, how does this thing work? To your point, though, how do we keep the ESCOG from going rogue and scope creep and those kinds of things? A lot of that stuff was built into the bylaws, into the formation at the beginning. Yeah, which was annoying in a way. Like, when we were trying to get certain things launched, like, it was a little bit of a pain in the butt.
1:05:16 But it's a good thing that it ensures that what we're doing, we're not doing anything that's going to be a hard pill to swallow for one sector. Okay, Rob, you had a comment? I just was going to ask you, I mean, I've got a lot of thoughts around some of the maybe structure elements and challenges of ESCOG in general, and I don't know if this is the right time to start talking about those or if, you know, if there's another time you would...
1:05:43 seek that because we kind of dove into one particular item and explained that to a long degree. But I think fundamentally there's some... Now's a good time. Now's a good time? Perfect. You know, and I hope these aren't unpopular comments for the room because I think everyone around this table is completely bought into this concept. I will say as the rest of our organizations, they're looking for what that is, what is it that ESCOG produces for them.
1:06:12 to a degree, and I think there's a little bit of standoffishness associated with that. When I look at what the bylaws and the things that were described, what you're describing is something that was agency sitting around the table and talking about common areas of interest. How do you want to go about that? We've got our sort of boundaries with which we can work in and so forth. We've now obtained, you know, Executive Director four or five years ago or so, and
1:06:39 That changed that purpose, right? There's now capacity, somewhat, to go do things, but I don't think that the organizations have really gotten good direction on what it does, what this organization accomplishes. When you were to say the organizations, what are you referring to? Yes, Scott. Oh, the four agencies that we don't work for. Okay, this is a really important thing I think we're supposed to be talking about. Can I finish? Sure.
1:07:08 So I think when I look at, when I've talked to my agency, or when I talk to my staff, I am saying ESCOG adds regional capacity, things that I am not going to invest in myself. But when there's common areas of interest, there's economic development, things that can be done across borders, that should live with ESCOG. And I think if there's a way to establish
1:07:38 A common area of work, that this is what this organization accomplishes, and there's adequate funding for that. I think the challenges that we've had are we're chasing dollars wherever grants come from. And I think, you know, you said, John, something really important. Having this provides us with the opportunity to obtain things, right? And that's awesome. We need to do that. But I also think there needs to be a very small core working group that this agency performs.
1:08:06 That is funded enough to perform without any grant funding, those efforts and those tasks, right? Because that way we know what we're doing. I can go back to the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes and say, this is exactly what ESCOG does for us. And in addition to that, they obtain grants to do things broader. But I think that's the missing piece, at least for me, is the evolution of this whole program going from
1:08:32 Agency sitting around a table to an executive director leading a small organization, it hasn't evolved into the right space. Can I ask some follow-up questions? Thank you for sharing that. Are you talking about a subcommittee or are you talking about communications? No, I'm talking about when, like Elena, as the executive director, knows that one of her core elements is regional economic development, right? Because
1:09:00 That's one of them. I mean, we've talked about that as a critical area or wildfire or whatever it may be. I think wildfire is currently on the agenda because we have a large grant associated with that. But economic development is always going to be there for us all, right? So I think what I can't do, I've got a very capable team and we're completely engaged in the success of our community and frankly the region, but we can't reach across boundaries. We can't reach across borders and say,
1:09:26 You know, Inyo do this, or Bishop do this, Mono do that. We can't really have that influence. And what I would love for this organization to do is have that voice and that everybody understands what it's there to accomplish. And so they aren't second-guessing it. Like, what does ESCOG do for me? I mean, and really, when it's constantly shifting based on whatever grant was obtained, it's really hard to explain what it does for you. So that's a communications. Yeah, I think so. Right.
1:09:53 Everybody around the table, I mean, you guys are all here, you're doing it, and you're deeply engaged in that, but there's more of you outside in your agencies that aren't as connected. Yeah, I hear you. Yeah, yeah. And I think that's the key point that you just brought up, and, you know, I know Elaine's been looking for direction on how to make this happen for a while, and what I've been telling her for a while, and I think what she's been trying, but we haven't quite totally coalesced, is, in my opinion,
1:10:21 That comes from the executives of each of the organizations working together collectively. You know, you guys sort of know the political will of your own bodies and your own community, and you also know the structural capabilities and limitations of what you have to do in your own agency.
1:10:42 You know, I think more so than an Executive Director can. So in an ideal world, what I would like to see is the four of the Executives coming together on a regular basis with the Executive Director and, you know, sort of providing that the substance and the resources when necessary to make that happen. The thing that feels a little bit... I think, Rob, it's a very important point. You talked about the evolution of the ESCOG and where we're at right now.
1:11:10 is to really start defining those lanes so it's crystal clear what those things are. And I think as part of our discussion today, we have a couple of opportunities in front of us and we have these capacity questions. And I think we need to be able to, all of us, to ensure that those opportunities will be successful. So the things that are immediately in front of us, how do we make sure like the wildfire work that's going on that's going to benefit all of us?
1:11:38 How do we make sure that the finances, the resources are there to do it? The roles of the elected officials on the board will be to help working with you guys to figure out this is the lane, this is what ESCOG's doing so it can be communicated to your staff. But then the issues about allocation of resources and funds and things like that, that's got to fall back on the electeds, the various boards to do that. So I think to your point, we can follow up on that. How do we start putting those mechanisms in place?
1:12:08 It's a good idea. It's a regional need. How are we going to fund those things from whatever resources we've got to have the independent capacity you're talking about? It's there. It's reliable. And it's something that's ongoing. Yeah. Just something to address, if I can. What feels uncomfortable about what you just described is, yeah, I can go to a meeting with the four of us and sit down with Elaine and talk about what I want to accomplish, but I don't know how it fits into the desires of this board, right? I am not her board.
1:12:38 But I am someone who knows what our needs are. So there's a disconnect between being able to say, this is what I would love for you to work on, and then all of you guys are saying, well, who the hell is that? Right? I'm the board. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I just think that the... So what this board says we want to do should reflect what our individual agencies want to do.
1:13:06 Collectively, not just the members that are representing this board, but the entire boards. And, you know, it's my, I guess it's my opinion of how I think that that thought process would flow, is I think it would flow from the executives in conjunction with the executive director that Elaine's going to have the leadership of when she presents an item to us of, I think this is how, you know.
1:13:34 I think this is the path forward that should happen. And that in order for that to be feasible, I think it first has to be run through the executives. Yeah. I want to let you go, Elaine, but I will say that we are going to keep talking about this, and that is the reason that we're doing the entire, so I hear you, and it did, everyone's aware of these structural issues and appreciate bringing that up, Rob, and that is exactly why we're having this conversation.
1:14:03 It got brought up by outside partners as well. So it's, but I, and Elaine, I am going to have you speak to that. Today is about the, like, the high-level direction and having conversations about these underlying challenges. And then once we get that direction, the next meeting we want to get into the real details of updating the structure, updating processes, what does it mean for communications, what does it mean for staffing to actually
1:14:31 Move on some of these changes for the evolution of this organization to be more effective for everybody. Just to hear myself talk. Important as we look at this, because we seem to be looking at what is the scope, what should ESCOG be doing? And we're talking about the fact that now we're just chasing grants and perhaps that is not a great thing. I want to advocate for chasing those grants because they bring us opportunities that don't otherwise come to us. If we too narrowly focus...
1:15:00 who we are and what we do, then we're no longer going to be looking at the grants that are out there that may be hugely advantageous for our local communities and the region as a whole. There's nothing we do here in Mammoth that doesn't affect Bishop or Bridgeport or anybody else. We are a region, whether some people like it or not, but I would hate to see us bring our focus down to the point that we miss opportunities and miss being
1:15:28 Very agile. Yes. Great. That's going to be a perfect segue into our next set of slides. Elaine? I know that we have a lot to move through, and so I really don't want this comment to derail anything, but I also, there's something that Rob said that I also think is sort of important as we're thinking about the scope and the return on investment from ESCOG, which is the point of parochialism that Paul brought up, which is something that I get a lot of feedback on, depending on who I'm talking to. So if I'm talking to people,
1:15:58 in Union County or Bishop, what I hear is, well, ESCOG's just doing work around Mammoth. But if I come up to Mono County, they're like, well, they're just doing work in Bishop. And it's really going to be a challenge to find a project. I think that the CWDG, we found a project that can serve the region more with
1:16:16 more geographic equity within a single project, but also I look at, and this will come up later in this presentation, these COGS in the Intermountain West who serve as economic development districts, which is a very standard function for COGS elsewhere, especially in rural communities.
1:16:32 And, you know, they're working projects sometimes that are place making in this community or a meat processing facility in that community and there's a recognition that providing that infrastructure, it might exist in a single location, but there is a benefit to all of the member jurisdictions in doing that work and making that investment. Okay, so we are way behind. So Jeff, just real quick, with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, we made an explicit
1:16:57 Philosophical decision when we started that organization that we weren't going to divide up every dollar for every agency to make sure that every contribution matched every output and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, that we were a regional system and that we were building a system that was regional. And with the understanding that if we did do that division, the whole thing falls apart because it's never going to be 100% and someone's always going to feel like they're getting the short end of the stick. And I'm just going to add one little
1:17:26 And I agree, you know, ESCOG needs to work more like ESTA does in that way, as far as our feelings and our thought processes. But I will just say, since I came in after it, I'm the newest side bill, is that, you know, there's something in my head that sticks in my craw when I talk to my constituents about the idea that that BLM, a federally funded agency that has their own funding streams.
1:17:54 That the City of Bishop's money is going to them, basically. That we're doing their work for them by doing this chipmunk thing. And I know it was done way before I got here. But I think that when we're looking at economic development, economic development is a local thing about our local governments. Whereas having somebody come in who has their own funding stream and say, can you do this for us?
1:18:25 It doesn't work as well. Let's talk about that. Okay. We're going to go through those slides, but I would challenge all of you that one of the big roles of being on the board of ESCOG is to be a champion for the narrative around the region and that an ice skating rink in Mammoth is going to translate to
1:18:57 I don't know how you do that, but that is the job of this organization is to communicate in a way that demonstrates how chipmunk in Bishop translates to a pilot project that can be used in Bridgeport or it can be used elsewhere. So I'm hearing just
1:19:24 Some of the challenge of ESCOG, I wonder if it's intrinsic to the model or it's intrinsic to the way we're thinking about things and communications. I'm just putting that out there, and we're going to talk about it a lot, but I'm challenging you with that. And I understand the inherent tension of that, absolutely. I'm going to just give a quick example. This week, one of the projects that we're working on for Eastern Sierra Community Foundation,
1:19:55 was to present to the board. So I didn't just, we didn't just create those slides to say, here's what we're doing. We went to the strategic plan of the town of Mammoth Lakes and said, what are your priorities? Okay, so because I know what those elected are thinking about, what their priorities and Rob is thinking about. And I'm going to translate what we're doing to align with what you're doing so that I'm helping you understand how my work is moving your work forward. So,
1:20:24 Maybe it's a communications problem where ESCOG is actually moving forward your priorities, but it's too hard to make that link because I don't understand how all the disparate pieces of work link to what your priorities are, but I bet they do. I bet they do. And Pam, you and I have had that conversation. It's like, you know, I have these priorities in my city, and what you're doing doesn't align.
1:20:54 But maybe it's a communication thing, and that is the job of figuring out how those things align. So that's just one thing that might be an opportunity for us to think about. Okay, I'm going to go through these quickly. Great conversation. Impact to date. So what is the value of ESCOG? Who cares? Why does it even exist? To date, with not all ESCOG, through partnerships,
1:21:23 About close to 10 million has been brought in. And you're positioned in a competitive process to, in the next year, have another 12 million. I think it's interesting that the 10 million, the 9.7, has come in over many years, and suddenly, you're going to have potentially, maybe, maybe not, 12 million with the same capacity. That's like something to think about.
1:21:53 So when we think about the ROI, of course we'd love that to be $100 million. Why couldn't it be in 5 years, 10 years, 15 years? Probably will if you guys keep going on the path you're on. So this is an important piece of your storytelling and communication of maybe you could have done that individually, and you do in your own organizations, but starting to demonstrate when we come together we're more competitive for some of these things and we're able to have the administrative capacity.
1:22:23 to deploy these for implementation. Okay, next slide. I'm going to go through these really quick. I'm not going to pause. Okay, so I shared this feedback. We talked to 17 people. You have a handout that talks about what people said. Because it's important to hear what people say in this room, but all of you carry in your heads the hundreds of conversations that you've had with all the other people. We talked to 17.
1:22:49 And go to the next slide, please. And this is the handout of sort of what they said. We, in designing this afternoon session, absolutely use this as a foundation to design sort of a consideration for future direction. So to your point, Rob, you know, we heard, you know, Elaine's great. I worked on this one project. It's really great.
1:23:14 I have no idea what the rest of the things. I don't really understand what they do. I don't understand how they make decisions about projects. Like, I'm not really sure what they do for my own priority. I'm not really sure. Absolutely clear that that is a challenge. Capacity. It seems like what they're being asked to do doesn't match with what the capacity of their staff is. Like, there's not, just even, mostly...
1:23:41 Not the leadership, but more of the administrative and grants management capacity. The fiscal nuts and bolts and Sierra Jobs First was like, we can go into that. But if ESCOG is going to have a big role of accepting big grant public complex public grant dollars, it will be important to equip that team to be able to manage that volume.
1:24:10 Strengths, I think you've all heard this. You've been around for a while. Many of the people that, obviously, that we pick to, we talk to, work with you, and really, really see you as an incredible organization that can bring the right people to the table. Like, you really are seen as neutral, and that is very, very valuable, especially with contentious issues.
1:24:35 And then speaking about the services around the incubating projects and things like that. So I think you can see everything here. So we asked the opportunity, you know, what do you think ESCOG should do in the next three years? And, you know, number one is get us more money. Get us more money and build your capacity to be able to handle that money. Okay. So learning from others. So we sent, I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this. We sent a pretty packet.
1:25:04 That was research that we did on COGS in California, and then COGS that wasn't extremely helpful, and so we went contextually to places that had, they were mountainous, rural, close to national parks, had ski areas, recreation economy, ag economy, and that was really helpful.
1:25:30 So some real highlights from the looking at California COGS. And thank you to Christina, who she had just started adding it back. And I said, can you research COGS in California that are similar to ESCOG? And she was like, I cannot find anything that's similar to ESCOG. So you're not typical. You know this. That ice skating party that you had created a unique thing. And all of you are unique. And this is a unique area. So just this confirms.
1:26:00 So, if you wanted to do more research, again, focusing on some of these ones that we found, but really, if you go to the next slide, where you're going to get more insights and inspiration is from the places I mentioned earlier. So, some highlights of things, that EDD designation was a really big standout of
1:26:28 Moving slightly away from being, you know, you're still going to always be grant reliant, like to your point, Bill, that's a great thing, that you're a grant service, so that's important, but also having some reliant, that designation as the Economic Development District for the region to get some of that funding was something that those organizations we looked at did.
1:26:57 The ones we picked also did a great job of articulating, we talked about this, the value of coming together and translating that back to the constituents and the other partners, and so we did look at that and we can bring more of that information. And then the thing I talked about, that's why I was kind of honing on what you were saying, Rob, about structure, is many of them, because the board is a government board, they really
1:27:26 And I think Sandra, you and I talked about this, you know, a committee structure that has potentially its own board and it could have its own do fee, dues, and they're doing a whole body of work underneath the board or something like that, just having more nimble structures. Wildfire is absolutely a priority across all of those, the same with broadband and transportation. So, okay.
1:27:57 So with that, we're close to being on time. What we want you to do is for the next 15 minutes, grab, take a break. We're leaving the phase one of the morning, which is like the download of ESCOG today and the research. But we want to capture some of your thoughts. Some people feel comfortable talking in this big group. It's a big group. Some we'd rather have you talk in smaller groups. So your name is in, there's three stations.
1:28:26 The Mono Lake Station, the Crowley Lake, and the Lake Patsyatta. And so look for your name, work with your facilitator. We're just going to do a digest of what stood out to you, what do we carry forward, and as part of that also, please get yourself some snacks. Okay, we got back on time. Thank you. Okay, so...
1:28:56 We have Pam, Karen, Paul, Megan, over here. Christina. I'm going to go get my tennis. Where's the? Oh, yeah, I'll check on it. Yes. Someone has to write it down. God knows you're not going to read anything I write. And so then you have to be the writer and the reader? That's right. No. Absolutely not.
1:29:26 I will tell you this chair is too close to the ground for this battle. You should make it go up. I don't know that it will. You don't know that it will? Really?
1:29:40 How could that be? I'm not in your life.
1:31:43 Okay, so we heard some value that we may or may not be familiar with.
1:32:03 All of the above?
1:32:32 And sometimes I can't even myself work too. So I think having a more mission that threads all of the branch that you've kind of mentioned is funded. So I really was like, oh, I didn't know what would it be, but I liked that. Because I was like, oh, that's, you know, like, this is what we do. Always. Well, yeah, we need to explain.
1:33:01 You know, to everyone. This is the role they play. And the way I can use it with SAF is they do the things that we don't have the capacity to do, and we also really can't reach across boundaries and get that around. So it's something, you know, mentally, which people sometimes get lost. It seems like it's, oh, it's a common theme that we're working on versus, oh, it's actually a capacity.
1:33:23 I think it is that across both parts, it's just full on that thread, it's the beginning of the conversation. Sometimes you feel like with the grants, there are all, there's so many acronyms that you end up just saying gibberish, right? Like you literally cannot communicate. So then I bring it back to Shona, do you think it's...
1:33:47 Capacity, or do you think it's communication? I think the misunderstanding is more communication. Tell me we have 9 million or 10 million under 12 million dollars in grades doesn't do any good. Because it's been all the way to staff, nobody's going to want to support that. So to report out of what public good, besides the internal capacity of the organization that was done, then it makes it easier to...
1:34:12 And can I add to that, that in any kind of startup situation, where you have a desperate need for communication, and you have a desperate need for capacity, we're at the point where both of the challenges happening simultaneously. It's tear-top, right? Yeah, it's like, we need both of them, we don't have either of them, so we gotta figure it out. One comes before the other. I mean, if you have good communication, that is going to...
1:34:37 Thank you.
1:34:53 Yeah, great. No, I think that resonates within this club, you know, amount of time, and that's what I'm talking about.
1:35:22 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:35:49 It's a communication problem. It's more
1:36:03 It's not so much a communication problem externally, it's a communication problem internally, and there's a conversation.
1:36:25 to use it to educate.
1:36:54 Well, I think that that's one of the strengths of ESCOGI's that can be arguable today.
1:37:23 I appreciate communications and meetings that we've had. Agencies have been a bit excited about. But it's also communication generally around an opportunity. So to your point, there's no money for the city bishop going into the church. It's being paid for by the state. There's no money for the town of Mammoth Lake School. But for the ESCOG as a culture to understand, we're going to have opportunities. This is an opportunity.
1:37:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:38:15 You can do, you can do, but it's a passage. I mean, if that is a priority, if all of a sudden we need to prioritize that, then we need to have to get someone who goes off of those who are alive. If you do this, if you have a legal trail system.
1:38:38 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:38:54 Yeah, we could have a measurement. Sure. That's not that hard to do, but again, it's a capacity. And I think, from my experience, obviously, you spend a lot more time with the organization, but based on project selection, I think if we as a board could have a capacity to do that, we could do that.
1:39:18 We need it. How do we get from here to there? Well, I think the theme continues here for number three then, right? So what's concerning the child? I think it produces anxiety. We're not this thing about we're not communicating and we're not telling you stories that we've got regional managers who are like, what are you people doing?
1:40:25 How do we position you?
1:40:49 I think, and again, this is the chicken and egg thing, that I think we as a core, we're going to assess and see, oh, okay, we're wanting to get a $10 million duty that the organization has to be successful. The fiscal administration has to be successful.
1:41:12 And right now, I don't know who you can see. And that's success.
1:41:41 Yeah, and I have a basic, again, historically, Dan Holler had a lot to do with setting this up in the beginning. We don't want to build a current organization, so we'll get there.
1:42:01 So when you talk about building the capacity of the grant, if we have the capacity of the grant, but we don't get the grant.
1:42:29 We don't have in our minds, tactically, how are we going to do this?
1:42:59 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:43:17 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:43:32 Yeah, for sure. Because Billy, right now, if we get this big grant, it's going to be a bunch of crazy phone calls in Mammoth County, a bunch of crazy phone calls in Mammoth County, it's not efficient, reporting can't happen on time, it's just basic grant administration isn't important. So to your point, Rob, that's core service, core competence, we need to be investing in that core competence. And then, and then, and then,
1:44:01 And so it will do that work irregardless of any grants.
1:44:30 I think when it does get it now, it has the procedures, processes, flex, and grow to get the capacity to be able to be able to get that execution done above that particular brand, to change the focus of S-Click. Yeah, exactly. This is kind of what we do right now. You don't have that baseline.
1:44:48 She's barely funded. Yeah, she is, but it's not enough. She's barely funded, and she doesn't have any financial mechanics. Call Mammoth County. Call Mammoth County. Call Mammoth County. We've got to figure out how to do this.
1:45:17 Oh, this is coming in. Okay, go out, scale it up, go out, contract out, hire the people, he's even a mayor for $25 million for five years. Exactly.
1:45:29 So I'm moving this stuff into number four, which is insights. So you're talking about the problem and then the investors as to build out the plans in the future.
1:45:56 Thank you.
1:46:08 So that is kind of happening to a certain degree, but what I'm curious to say is there's concerns that...
1:46:34 For what's coming, it needs to be all served. Every year. When the Serivine Conservancy says, oh, you've got this Eastern Fart, Eastern Wild Fart thing going on down there. Where's your joint power to drive? Where's your lead to authority from your direct $10 billion? So we're, and their expectation is it will be managed successfully, efficiently, and well. It's not just a bunch of bumpkins running around trying to figure out who can put a spreadsheet.
1:47:02 Yeah, and it did, it's not just all of you, it came out with my interviews, that was on West Coast, right? Yeah. Yeah. So, I would say, it goes along with it, and then, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a,
1:47:53 And that's part of our goal today. So when Bill comes in as a new member, oh, hi, here's the one she wants. I'm asking all kinds of questions. Here are the authorities. This is how it works. This is what it's done. It should be that. Well, it's good to be in the door.
1:48:24 That should sail. Yeah. Yeah. So why are we saying that you're talking about how there's like HR is being covered by one county at this percent, how this had to be, and then this county's doing this, and then why? And that is a great way that you can sort of...
1:48:54 There's a footnote to that, which is the ESCOG means of everybody. Early, and it's like, guys.
1:49:21 It was interesting to hear from Jeff that he felt like, because I can certainly come up with things I know that we all need to focus on. And it just, to me, it felt weirdness. Here I am saying, this is what ESCOG is doing. It makes some decisions, right? So he was kind of saying, well, you guys need to push those ideas. Well, I think it was, it's also, we want to be careful that the Executive Director of ESCOG is not caught between.
1:49:48 Meetings with the sales, and they're getting direction from the board, and it becomes...
1:50:11 No, no.
1:51:33 It's not an opportunity to be at the executive director for a field.
1:51:37 No, no, no.
1:51:38 Right?
1:51:38 It's got to be really fun.
1:51:40 So, communication is a big part.
1:51:41 Sure.
1:51:42 Yeah.
1:51:43 It's just that we're, um, we're, um, we're hoping to be.
1:51:46 We're all of the things.
1:51:47 If it's an important, we're going to be like, how do I do that?
1:51:50 No.
1:51:51 No.
1:51:51 No.
1:51:51 You bring a really good point, though, which is the communication of individual managers with their representatives going the board route, which I think is something that should not be underestimated, because otherwise you get into this thing where the executive director hearing a bunch of stuff from the CEOs and then hearing something else from the board, and that person is ready.
1:52:21 Most of us, the government has other boards and groups working on similar things. So we have the ULR, the trans community, who has never heard anything of what ESCOG does or doesn't do. And ESCOG is sort of in the trans business as well.
1:52:39 So the communication, we're all black and white, there are groups in Inyo County that should be part of the ESCO discussion, that are often going to find their own trails, that have no idea that this could even be working. So how do you make that communication? How do we get all the user groups together and have them form something that can bring us that information?
1:53:08 What about some of the facts about the city or some establishment? So, is that really an issue? So, I was just going to tell you, Andrew, I was going to tell you, what it means to do? I think the patient, I know, is the problem that's changed. So, if it is, we're all bringing something to our community, as from that group. If we're bringing something, it should be. Exactly.
1:53:32 And then it becomes the expectation.
1:54:00 All right, can you wrap up in about two minutes?
1:54:29 Someone saying we need it.
1:54:59 It has evolved, and I think I was trying to convey that as a music director.
1:55:29 So I have a question.
1:55:58 So, in terms of communication and information sharing, how do you get information sharing to board members? Focusing the work, you know, how does that happen? Hey, Elaine, we're going to come back in about two minutes.
1:56:27 Thank you.
1:56:50 Okay, we're going to come back together, everyone. Come back together.
1:57:19 Okay, everyone. Okay.
1:57:45 Thank you.
1:58:15 He's ready. Are you going to Mill Pond? Are you a Mill Pond person? Usually we do go. We can just park it at my house. Right.
1:58:36 Am I in town tonight?
1:59:02 Yes. Yeah, but I am, but my wedding coordinator, who I sucked into it, it's coming over to the house, but why? Not till after the wedding.
1:59:22 Oh, phone conversation. You're talking about the phone conversation. All right. The biggest news of the afternoon is we found a knife to cut the brownies and the cupcakes into smaller parts. Good news. Really good news. Success. Success. Success. Success. Success. Yes. Okay.
1:59:50 Wherever you can find it. All right. I know everyone needs to get... Did you get the knife? Oh, the knife is coming. Jamie's bringing a knife. Jamie is bringing a knife. Yeah, yeah. She got it. Yeah, we're using... Come on up. Come on up. Come on up. Okay. So the Crowley Lake group is going to... Ken's going to report out on insights.
2:00:18 To carry forward, we don't have time to go through everything that we talked about, but just what are the kind of the core insights that came out of your group from the information so far? John? Well, the first thing I think where maybe there's a gap is kind of like almost like a mission statement of this is what we do, right? And so that goes across all the different member agencies. But then below that, I feel like there was a very common theme in terms of communication.
2:00:47 So there's potentially reestablishing regular meetings internal between CAOs and the different board members, communications between area directors, NSCOG, DD, what are the priorities from each of the different member agencies and how do those get filtered up so the board members understand what the needs are for each of the member agencies.
2:01:18 Also, external communications, right? The forum for communication with user groups. How do we figure out what the community needs and what they want and how the ESCO can help? We also, again, another issue of communication is we need to find the value, right? That goes back to this kind of mission statement idea and being just putting our flag in the sand of, like, this is what we do. We also, another main priority was funding core services.
2:01:48 How do we stay nimble and be able to pursue grants but yet also have a capacity to actually activate on them and then do the work that is needed to move them forward without having a massively steep learning curve at the front end of every grant. So yes, bolster core service functionality and structure that flexes. That's the gist. It's a pretty common theme.
2:02:18 I think the reflection initially from our group was that issues and topics keep resurfacing. Some of our group didn't feel that there was anything really that surprising in the conversation, but I think kind of the nuts and bolts of it are
2:03:11 As an area, so information flowing, a little model of a triangle that it really needs to flow from ESCOG to regional managers and then to the elected officials. Also, issue identification, there really needs to be a greater understanding of why some issues are identified and being able to explain why those issues are regional, each of those issues. We came down to even like a process issue
2:03:50 By monthly meetings, it can be kind of hard to absorb all of the information, and so perhaps there could be a structure that there's more frequent or shorter meetings and more that way. We know that the regional area managers can attend ESCOG board meetings, but sometimes they may not feel like they have a role or a purpose in those meetings, and so being able to feel that. And then moving forward in the strategic planning, really being able to identify ESCOG's core identity.
2:04:47 I just want to echo what one person in our group said that ESCOG is operationally doing a lot right now with one person, and so that is something that they identified as a strength. And then, oh yeah, and then just like the lessons and implications we want to move forward is being able to open more doors together. Is there anything else I maybe would like to add from our group? Thank you, Mona Lake. Okay, next group. Next group would be
2:05:29 So, we heard that ESCOG is doing some good things. It's made progress since its establishment as a JPA. There's been continuity. But there is a real disparity and range of knowledge and familiarity with the COG and what its programs are.
2:06:05 People were surprised that housing wasn't brought up in the case studies that were presented in the spreadsheet or really came up as part of the conversation today. Even though having the four agencies work together to talk about programs and common housing issues was beneficial, there needs to be some clarity around ESCOG's role in programs like the administration of California Jobs First.
2:06:34 And people were surprised that ESCOG is a unique cog in California, Relatives to the Netherlands. Similar to the other groups, we heard there's a need to improve communications, to tell a story about what ESCOG is doing, need to set priorities with member agencies, and then we have a lot of conversation about the relationship between the board, the regional leadership, the executive director, and how to
2:07:05 facilitate conversations where regional issues are identified, agreed upon, driven up through ESCOG, and how to better facilitate that, which included conversations around maybe more frequent updates to the full boards, establishment of an ad hoc committee with ESCOG board members and CAOs to ID and discuss those issues on a somewhat regular basis.
2:07:33 And then that that's also really important for sort of figuring out how to solve for the capacity and the resource constraints that ESCOG realizes is needing to have the buy-in from the CAOs to be able to support the right resources and capacity to be effective in getting the work that they would like to see done. And the only other thing that I would add is that it would be valuable in the strategic planning process to have
2:08:02 A deliverable that is like a training or an orientation toward new, toward good staff. Okay, thank you. Good job. Okay, what stood out from all of that? I'm kind of pulling together things, so. Somebody jump in. Communications. Communications. Processes. Processes. Priority setting. Capacity. I think the value of best college is true. It's a value to order something.
2:08:54 So as much as there is to do, and it can sometimes be overwhelming, it is ideal for some in my role when the three groups that we intentionally mixed you all up had very similar conversations. So, I mean, maybe it's because of the information that we shared, but also that is helpful. Okay, is everyone good to move into strategic planning? We have a knife now, so you can get a part of the brownie.
2:09:23 Okay, so I'm going to go through some of these slides and frame this up, which this conversation and what you were talking about is a good segue. Okay, next slide, Elaine. We already did that. Next slide. Okay.
2:09:53 All right, so as we move into this next, we're officially kicking off the strategic plan, which is intended to get at all of the things in the communications, as well as, I would say, everything you just covered. So what we want to do is, as we're moving into this next afternoon, and then in session two, is make sure that when we come away with a document, I'm going to show you, there's going to be three documents.
2:10:22 That direction on how we do, what it is we want to do, how we explain what we do, and then how we're going to operationalize that is, it comes out of this process. So we're going to do a funnel. We're starting big and now we're starting to get into the details. So these are some of the questions that this process aims to answer. You know, what are we all working towards collectively?
2:10:48 Not what's John working towards, what's Trina working towards, what's Linda, but collectively, what are we all working towards? And that's more of a meta thing, not like, is it economic development, is it housing? But like, what is the statement that we have that describes what all of our efforts roll up to be that we can clearly... Nope.
2:11:17 Yeah, and because those, though, because part of the reason that you struggle with picking your priorities is because you don't have that driving North Star of, like, what are we all aiming towards, and so how do we pick the, and you do have it in general in your bylaws, I understand that, but could we articulate it more clearly in different ways through a strategic plan, through a mission?
2:11:44 It would make it easier to start having conversations around vetting priorities and opening the door for more priorities or more conversations about other things to think about. How do we bolster ESCOG's capacity now to position us, position for success in the future? Like, it's happening. It's not just like, wouldn't it be amazing if someone one day gave us some big pot of money? It's happening. So what do we do now?
2:12:14 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:12:55 You have an hour and 45 minutes. Yes. Okay. I'm going to go through these slides and then we're going to work in groups again. Okay. Next. Next slide. Okay. So these are the products I'm talking about. So what we're starting to work on today is the three-year strategic plan. And then from that, once we have direction from the board and the staff team on what that general direction is,
2:13:24 I will say, in looking at that operational budget, it doesn't exactly mean there's going to be an ask coming.
2:13:54 It doesn't mean that for sure. Sure, there might be, but it's not an absolute setup of saying, because there's so much cobbling together of staff scenarios to make this organization run that we really want to first start with digging into that and seeing, are there admin fees that we could change? Could one of the partners stretch a little more? Could we combine those things? So it's not as simple as like,
2:14:23 We need more staff. We're going to ask you for more money. Just wanted to say that. It's not a gift. Next. Next. Okay, so today, in the strategic plan framework, we're going to focus today on programs of work. We're going to talk briefly about core services, and then we're going to start on this other, hit as far as we can on these bottom things, depending on how much we get in. Okay, so these are a lot of words, but really, as a board, what you're thinking about,
2:14:59 We have kind of three options. As we look to the next three years, knowing what's in the pipeline, knowing what the grant funding is that we have right now, knowing that you want to keep a lane, do we want to dig in and just focus on bolstering our capacity and just say, we're not taking on new work programs, we're not doing a lot of new things right now, we're going to spend the next three years.
2:15:26 really hunkering in and building up our capacity of core services and our structures to get ready for growth in three years or do we want to be strategic about knowing there's going to be some money coming down and we want to start getting ready for that now by setting up some working groups to start identifying priorities and doing studies to be ready for additional funding or do we want to say
2:15:56 Actually, that wildfire funding is so big that for the next three years, we're really just going to mostly, mostly focus on building our systems to be able to manage that. So that's just like high level, we're going to get into those, but those are just sort of high level decisions that the staff really needs direction from all of you on. And we're going to go through those.
2:16:24 Okay, so option A, I just talked about that, we're going to go through these. Just focus on your current funding in three program areas and build a capacity of ESCOG. B, focus on that and build your collaborative capacity using that kind of that model we were talking about to build that
2:16:51 Pipeline of future project priorities so that if funding comes in, you've already got that collaborative, that working group kind of identifying the projects and working together. Also, always building the capacity of ESCOG in all three of these. And C is what I talked about, which is, hey, we're small. We have one full-time staff. This is a lot of grant money coming in. Like, we want to be realistic. Okay, so let's just go through those. So this is based on your current funding.
2:17:23 which means the funding, we're assuming, we're taking out the money that's sunsetting, and we're saying, so, in reality, this is what we have. So we have the, about the, around two million in the shrimp portfolio, and we have about 200,000 in the broadband, and then, to your point, to your point about being nimble, is we always, as an organization, want to
2:17:50 It's not a work program area, but we want to always have a bucket that says we are an organization that is nimble and agile and if things come up, we want to build our staff capacity and our organization capacity to be ready for those things. We will have those conversations. So that's sort of the one scenario. The green down below is just recognizing what was said in all these three groups is like none of this, it requires building the capacity, administrative and physical and communications.
2:18:22 So I'm going to go to the second one, is green indicates the board making a decision to cover, do the existing work, but also position the organization today for some potential opportunities in the future. So in economic development, believe it or not, that is an area that is a work program that is sunsetting. So staff needs direction.
2:18:51 Nope, we want to keep doing economic development, so in green, we want to renew that. What does that mean? It means submitting the application for the EDD and then continuing with that work group to implement the SEDS, identifying what does it mean, what does regional economic development mean? Yes? Just one point of order. In order to continue to go into the EDD, that's going to require, I believe, improvement.
2:19:20 Correct, 100%. So there's a step in there. Yeah, there's a lot of steps in all that. So what we want today is we want to show you these three scenarios and not make, Elaine just said, I cannot make assumption that I have alignment from this group for any of these three things. So we can't move forward with asking you.
2:19:44 With building a strategic plan, if we don't have some general direction from you on which of these models, and again, today's not about decision, but just a general temperature check on which one you're thinking you're going to want to move forward. So this one is establishing a more formal working group that would be to be determined, but what I heard the conversation a lot today around like,
2:20:11 Project priorities, project priorities. Is it, and we have to have a conversation around that process. Is it about the area managers meeting and coming up with their priorities and then collectively bringing that to the board? Is it about going out to the entire region and asking them what their priorities are? Is it about having these active working groups that either ESCOG participates in or runs, and that working group is vetting priorities?
2:20:40 and bringing those to the board. I don't know the answer to that, but that's what the concept is for that, is that ESCOG would decide that working in sustainable, bringing different stakeholders together to identify priorities that would use a similar model to the wildfire alliance of project prioritization, bringing in user feedback.
2:21:10 TBD as far as what that is. We didn't want to bring a lot of information at this point because, again, we don't know even if the board has an appetite for this direction at this point. And then this is the last one, what I talked about, which is they're all perfectly acceptable. So this one would say, one of the board members saying, I feel like
2:21:40 We need to focus on our capacity over the next three years. If we don't do SMC, if you get SMC and it's not done well, then that's my bigger concern than doing all these other things. So that could also be an option. Okay, so that is three scenarios. Those are in your packet.
2:22:09 So I feel like this group is squished over there, and so I would say that that group, Ken's group, that you should move to a table. Yeah. Shauna, can I ask a question? Yes. Who's asking that question? Oh, Serena. On each one of the options, A, B, and C, the building of ESCOG capacity is the same.
2:22:37 Does the same capacity need to be built for each one of these, or is there a different capacity needed for the different options? I think that'll help inform some of the conversation.
2:23:04 If we're going to move forward with focusing only on wildfire programs, we already know, we've had this conversation, that there's going to be staff that focuses on project management for that, and there's going to be staff that can focus on fiscal management as well. Whereas if we're expanding into building it out of the EPD and having more capacity in recreation, the CWDG grant is
2:23:36 So, Trina, we actually built those out and we
2:24:06 did not show those slides because we went back to the drawing board and said we need to ask this for what they what they want to do moving forward before we start to build out like a detailed staffing plan of like what does it mean if you have so that would be coming back to you with that but just in general in general again general temperature shake take of like in general
2:24:36 Nobody supports dropping economic development. There might be people that do. There might be a conversation in the group that are like, I understand we have the grant funding for these certain things, but what I would like to see ESCOG do is actually take on housing, and is that a separate work program, or does that fit into the economic development? This is a chance to have a conversation around the broad structure so we can bring some more of that detail back to you at the next meeting.
2:25:08 And again, to that goal of this meeting is just, we're looking for where is there starting to be general alignment so we can bring more details back to you. So you're saying that we don't necessarily have to pick A, B, or C. No. We could make a D. Correct. So in the directions, I think I say, I say, oh, I say number four says, so in your small group, which option is the most exciting to you?
2:25:42 Because we have to bring some energy, it's the afternoon, so we have to talk about like exciting. So which, so these are the questions, which of these options are most exciting to you? Which option, best positions our region for future funding opportunities? Which options aligns with our current capacity? Is there a new option to consider? So that's four. And then what we would love to hear at the end of your conversation is in general, our group supports
2:26:12 This new hybrid. And then we'll come back together and just see, like, in general, it seems like everyone is, there's general support for, like, moving forward with economic development, and there's this new thing bubbling up that they want to make sure. So remember, there's the work programs that are resolutions, and then there's a lot more flexibility of what can happen underneath there. So if you're excited about, like, I heard this conversation over here around homelessness. You know, that's a regional topic. Is that something we can talk about?
2:26:41 And then someone pointed out, well, that is actually in the SEDS as a topic. So by input, right? That's what I heard. I didn't know that. I mean, that seems unusual. It sounds like someone's generally said. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. So again, is it really a new thing or is it just amplifying the work that we're, you know, like amplifying the existing work with more juice? So does everyone understand the directions? It's hard to come up with what
2:27:11 I get most excited about not knowing what the financial implications of that are going to be down the road. Yeah, I mean, I'd love to go out and buy a new Bentley, but by golly, I don't think I'm going to do that. Yeah, I think for Bill to think about, is it more exciting to think about being here in three years and having a conversation around
2:27:42 ESCOG having received the money and the reports that we're getting from our partners is they're able to do so much more because ESCOG is building, extending the capacity of the town and the county to be able to do what they need to do and the public partners. So is it about building the capacity of ESCOG to do more?
2:28:09 with what we have, or is it more exciting for you to think about doing that and growing in new areas? I know, so you're new, so it's- I am excited to think that I might still be here in three years. That's great, that's great. Yeah, we just threw that in to make, again, we like to throw in that question just because it is grant-driven, so that's the tricky part, so like, what do you mean, what am I excited about? It's like, it is what we have.
2:28:40 But we are at a point where the staff is asking the board to give some direction on economic development and then the role of sustainable rec and that piece as far as like a working group. Okay. So your group, you had enough space in your location? Okay. And also, do we want to do any switch outs? Nope, I like my group.
2:29:12 Okay, so we're going to meet. We'll do 20 minutes, about 20 minutes. Your facilitators understand the assignment. If you don't know something, that's why you're in a small group. And we are just trying to come away with the general direction from the board on where they sit with this.
2:29:43 And all ideas are welcome. Do not feel confined by these boxes, except for be confined by the bylaws and the resolutions. Okay, so Ken's group, the Ken's group, I mean, yeah, you can sit, just put, sit some chairs.
2:30:16 Yeah.
2:30:51 Thank you.
2:31:18 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:31:38 That's how we can apply it. From what? From what? Being at our short-term, more stuff. First then, I think, focusing success with the things we've got in front of us, and then giving that economic development, which I'm kind of dissenting from the managers as a kind of a broad category that is the lane they would like as complicated to. I don't think that makes sense.
2:32:08 That's just me. That's just me.
2:32:34 Yeah, I think what this administration says is it's a real thing.
2:33:02 So, John, what's the difference between what you're promoting and talking about? The major delicacy that's where I see that we're at right now is we've got some grant-funded projects that are...
2:33:31 Yes, we have. But we have.
2:33:34 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:34:03 The EDD falls into that. Yeah, the EDD is a very specific application. So to do that, I think also we've talked about the support of the SBC, Sierra Business Council has an EDD. I think we want to get that monkey off our backs. Yes, we do. Yeah, so we want to have the capacities of region, not have the mesopotamia.
2:34:33 Thank you.
2:34:52 So we're trying to show what's for this year.
2:35:20 It's going to be a huge administrative program. Because all of a sudden ESCOG is going to have to be administrative funding for 10 different wildfire programs. It's going to be a huge administrative challenge.
2:35:48 Thank you.
2:36:00 Okay, okay, I lost the questions. Yeah, and then number two was...
2:36:29 So, what was that? It's about regional autonomy.
2:36:59 Not being dependent on that kind of capacity that's outside of where we live. Because they're certainly positioning ourselves. They go to Sacramento and they say, we cover all that. I know, we're cruising.
2:37:27 Okay, but so which
2:37:42 So, option C.
2:38:11 Thank you.
2:38:41 Well, we would have that discussion.
2:39:10 And then we have that discussion, does it fit these things? And then we have that capacity discussion, but tomorrow's point, we have to have that base, that core reliability capacity that we can scale to something, and then we've got something to make a decision about, rather than, oh, we're desperate for money, we've got to go after it, we've got to go after it. I don't know.
2:39:39 Thank you.
2:40:09 And in the next four months, I would spend the time...
2:40:38 What does the core look like and how you scale from that?
2:41:03 What do the communication plans look like between directors of the organizations? So that, we're just building the house. And that fits into...
2:41:21 No, because the grant, this is, this is basically, what is, it's a capacity, yeah, it's a capacity. It's baseline, it's all baseline, it's that core services, what is that spot? And then, and of course, going after grants for, for reasons, and then scaling those grants, what they think. Just defining that organization for these agencies, I think.
2:41:45 That would be work well done for the next 12 months. And then from there you get three years.
2:41:59 Yeah, we need to be able to say what capacity we have, but to your point also, what capacity we have, what capacity we have. And to your point, we get to scale into something. If a big problem comes along the path, can we get to the capacity, or does it become something that's really going to take with someone else?
2:42:29 Okay, how does this agency, what work needs to be done for it to be prepared to attract those larger grants? For sure, what are those?
2:42:48 We would need this to do that.
2:43:05 Thank you.
2:43:26 I can see how this is going to be, or this is how it is going to be, or this is how it relates to us, and we're all in the same boat. This is how we're getting that was coming. Absolutely. Absolutely.
2:43:53 Yeah. It's also another regional resource, right? People coming out and visiting, they're only able to try all the demand that's right there on bikes, they can stop them fishing, too. No, it's a huge amount. Yeah. It's coming from the north as well. It's another piece of the pie for people. Absolutely.
2:44:19 Thank you.
2:44:46 And this whole legitimate project is to get that legitimized so we can invest in it. It's a thing to even market it and promote it and all that kind of stuff. And then this whole unique climate thing that we have here, we're doing winter sports up here. Oh, you want to run down there and get on your ATV, you want to hop on a park, have an adventure, you want to ride your bike, you do all that shit. And this just starts to really build in the background.
2:45:13 I think the stronger that we are building a structural structure, communication is more attractive. Absolutely. Are you guys good? That's all we want to get. No, absolutely. That's a question on that. I disagree with that.
2:45:43 Thank you.
2:46:20 So Rob's going to get his hands to do that.
2:46:49 For the next 12 months, we can say, let's build this together. Because it can't just be us. We need some of you guys to be part of the conversation. I'd say something. And then we're going after this miracle. And we're going after this miracle.
2:47:13 So you're going to need some capacity or money or whatever to link that into...
2:47:44 What I just heard is the subcommittee of the area administrators.
2:48:08 Thank you. Thank you.
2:48:38 So it's okay. It's hard to de facto.
2:49:00 And so, okay, so, over these conveniences, are there each for each of the member agencies, or if there's one board member for each administrator?
2:49:23 Thank you.
2:49:47 It's self-absorption. Okay. It should be possible. It should be possible. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, so much time I have to take those minutes back, process it, and bring it forward. There's plenty of work to do. We're going to manage what we've got.
2:50:13 Thank you.
2:50:31 So we're talking capacity, we're talking structure. This will be more scriptural.
2:50:54 Thank you.
2:51:11 So, do we have, do we want, as a group here, the five, do we want to put our five examples? Yes. Okay, I missed the last one.
2:51:40 Okay, five minutes, five minutes. Okay, so we...
2:53:00 Thank you.
2:54:16 Who's visiting? Just friends from outside. But it's been planned for a while. There were supposed to be certain things we got done. They came up to help me do some things. And between phone calls, doctor's visits.
2:54:33 Yeah, I just had a big family reunion with my mom's ideas.
2:54:59 So last week, I didn't get all the things done here, but we had a great time. We do our family meetings. My mom's birthday was the 24th of July. She's now passed. She made 94. We started giving the birthday parties at 65, and then I just continued that as our favorite real month. That's right. That's a good idea. That's 26th of July this year. I served about 16 years. Wow. Yeah, that's a good idea.
2:55:29 Yeah. Alright, let's come together, everybody. Come back. Elaine. Hi, Elaine. Hi.
2:55:38 Come back. Daniel, they are, they're done. They're just having a break. Yes, they are. They're sitting in their seat. Thank you all. Thank you for all your time. So, Ken, how did you get involved in this, and what is your view of the future of the organization? That's a small question. Yeah. I was brought on to run, to project manage.
2:56:08 A couple of the Sierra Giants projects. One is this one, the other one is general canon, and then also, just like this, we had this big event, the, like the summit, this summer, so I reached out to them. So those are all kind of my projects. Please. I think that's the thing that's lacking.
2:56:37 We'll see, we'll see, we'll see.
2:56:39 Is this yours?
2:56:41 Yeah.
2:56:42 Uh, there are so many recreation groups out there.
2:56:50 There are, but you know what?
2:56:52 How many of them can actually partner with their whole place?
2:56:54 That sort of goes back to the federal agency.
2:57:00 I mean, I work, I can't, so I create the whole room.
2:57:02 I don't know what thoughts about this call.
2:57:05 Yeah, my word.
2:57:06 I don't know what the answer is there.
2:57:35 Thank you.
2:58:05 But I think it's also about, like, at this point it's just about...
2:58:32 I used to do that too, which is why I bought this little thing. I'm like, if I buy something, I could be able to. But you put that on the back. Sometimes. Does it have a handle? Yeah.
2:59:01 It's got a little hand. It's got a hand. They come up with what the organization looks like. I'm determined to see this thing do. This is a big investment. And so far, it's like the ones that come from that group to find the funding necessary to continue. See, this one is just, I had to buy this because twice I drowned my computer. Once that gets rolling in, and you put all that money back. Does that be sustainable? It did when I did the picture. Well, I guess it just says sometimes, it's like, dude, I don't know. Sure, that's one option.
2:59:31 And I think that there's lots of different ways to do that. But I think the question for me first is like, what is it? Thank you.
3:00:00 All right.
3:00:29 I'm going to call everyone back to order, back to order. Karen, what's in your little cute snack pack? Oh, nice. Yeah, little snack pack.
3:00:58 Okay, everybody, we're getting, it's Friday afternoon, Bill has a barbecue to get to. Before we dive into that conversation, I'd love to hear, I'd love to hear how that, what that experience was like for you to have that conversation. What did it feel like? Very productive. Okay. Can you tell us more? Sorry, do you mind pressing that just so Kristen can hear you?
3:01:32 Oh, sorry, Kristen. Yes, that's amazing. I think that it was, for me, it was encouraging that we were able to have an open, honest conversation and kind of, you know, compare notes and drill down to where we want our focus to lie. Great, thanks. So everyone, it doesn't have to be good things. I'm just, if things were uncomfortable or vague or, you know, anything.
3:02:00 How was that experience, being in that group, having that conversation? It was excellent. It was actually relatively easy. Okay. Yeah. I think that for our group, it was good, but it was when the conversation got more difficult. Like, okay, well, now we're saying yes to things and no to things and what is possible and who's going to do it and who's going to pay for it.
3:02:29 And it was good and productive, but it's where the rubber hit the road and kind of a little more challenging. Okay. Sandra, you were in Jeff's group, right? Same thing, yeah. It really is hard. I think the hardest part is that at some point, I think we can say no. We can all be on the same page. Megan, how about your group? Oh, what was the experience of having this conversation in your group?
3:03:21 How about this side? Karen?
3:04:04 the chance to have a larger conversation about the things we can accomplish regionally in more of a big picture visioning way. There is part of me that feels like we've sort of jumped into this, you know, in the middle. We're like, we don't want to throw out baby with the bathwater, but
3:04:33 So let me ask you guys a question.
3:05:08 This is one of the more unique organizations that I've ever done strategic planning for, I will say that. It's for completely different organizations coming together around a variety of topics. So when I worked with the JPA and it was the town and the PUD and the hospital and the school district and the counties, that's challenging. But they had one directive which was to work on housing.
3:05:36 And so it's challenging because like how does the hospital interpret that and how does the PD and that's hard. You're for organizations that have a very open set of bylaws and so there are conversations. I'm getting two sets of directions. One is why don't we have a large conversation around all the priorities in the region and figure out how ESCOG and look at those and figure out, have a conversation around
3:06:06 How ESCOG wants to look at those and potentially take on some of those. The other direction that I'm hearing is we work in these three work programs and so we want to work within that framework because that's where our resolutions and those are our bylaws and I can design a process to do either one of those but
3:06:34 What this to me in walking around in three groups is surfacing is that there isn't alignment and direction to your strategic planner on what is best in service to you at this moment. Are we truly pausing and looking at an inventory of all housing and whatever else you want to put in healthcare and transportation and
3:07:02 Wildfire. And are we pausing and doing that? Or are we working, are we making a decision around capacity? And so that's just the tension I noticed in the room between the three groups. And so it would be helpful to get clarity on that so that when we come back or when we continue this afternoon with this last hour, we're in service to what this board wants. I think it would be interesting.
3:07:30 Just from my perspective, to hear what the three groups thought the best option was. It's hard to know where we are if we don't know that answer. Yeah. Our group was a little slightly modified, but it was option C with the idea that wildfire is the existential threat to our community and also where the bulk of our funding is.
3:08:00 So continuing and focusing and building around the sustainable recreation ecosystem management with the caveat of the EDD designation and that at least getting that designation and keeping the set updated and having that as a parking place for
3:08:31 When the wildfire money runs out, having economic development be something, you know, in a few years, and to focus much less or completely eliminate the other grant-funded opportunities as they emerge, that just, we should not be chasing. Okay, interesting. That is an interesting way to go. That is exactly what our group did, right? Pretty much.
3:08:57 So hold on one second. Wait, so this is really interesting. So to my question, you answered it, which is you are staying within the framework right now. Right now. Okay. So that answers my question, but were you going to answer that question? Yeah, I can do that. Okay. About like the one I asked? Yeah. Well, yeah. So if you want to know what our group focused on, and I was part of the warmest pressing group for the athleticism.
3:09:29 We kind of created our own scenario for the first 12 months, right? I think I would prioritize fixing the organizational structural problems of ESCOG first and foremost before we start looking at new things to do. So what we kind of came up with is the next 12 months, and if it's going to land on the area administrators and close proximity, we're working directly with...
3:09:52 Lane, I also wanted the inclusion of a board member from each of the agencies to be a part of this special working group meeting monthly to go through the structure, the core services, how to flex capacities, what we do and what we don't do, and work on that reporting back to the ESCOG. And then at the end of that 12 months, we would know what this organization does and does not do, and then we can go out and do that. I thought by focusing that much energy in that space, we would
3:10:22 Actually become more attractive to grant funding opportunities, but it wouldn't be what we do. We would just win that out, essentially. I mean, that's a very important thing that Rob added to that, but we were option, which one did we pick? Option A, which is very similar to C.
3:10:42 With the addition of getting the EDD in place, so we're not relying on things like the Sierra Business Council and folks outside of our region who have an EDD, to the same thing I think you were saying, Jeff, to have that in the queue and ready to go, so when we get to the welfare, then we've got a place to go. Okay. Okay, that's great. That's interesting. So that was the La Passata group, and then Mono, so Mono, you said A.
3:11:09 No, we said C. We said C. Oh, you said C. C plus. Yeah, C plus. C plus EDD. Uh-huh. Yeah, C plus. We were like A plus EDD plus Rob stuff. Okay. And then there's... You were really specific about eliminating problems, weren't you? Oh, eliminate, okay. Okay, interesting. So, broadband... I think the one thing that both of our groups were specific on, though, is that economic development is very targeted on the EDD acquisition. For now.
3:11:50 But do you want to direct, so in this year-long working group that's going to build out the organizational business model for the core services, the direction that's needed is, do you want it to just be built to serve this set or flex to be able to serve opportunities that emerge?
3:12:19 Right. Well, what I'm hearing is pretty consistently is opportunities to emerge, not so much. Okay. But to be focusing on, we could drill it down, the wildfires, the things that are in front of us right now. Yeah. And the combination of the kind of things Rob's talking about to get the admin, the back of house capacity in place. Yeah. So we can perform and succeed. Right. On what's in front of us. Yeah. And I heard the model being that we will build in a flexibility. So like, if there is some. We'll build in procedures to flex. Yeah. And what it looks like.
3:12:47 But you'll know exactly what the organization does, how it functions, and then all the other things can happen after that, but that has to happen first. Okay, that's exciting. Yes? Well, I think with that, hopefully there would be an emerging opportunities structure or flowchart of like, we say yes if processes. Okay. Elaine, how does that direction from this
3:13:16 This general direction land with you. I think that sounds good for the next three years because it focuses on sort of the burden in hand instead of the burden for the real bush. A couple of things that I, the one thing I would caution around that is the establishment of the EDD will be a lift.
3:13:45 It's not as easy as just submitting an application that's going to require consensus from the member agencies, and it might require consensus from Alpine County to be effective, and that's going to take some politicking to be able to get that done. Also, there will be some administrative requirements associated with the EDD in order for that to, you know,
3:14:10 Remain in place as a designation. So we have to do an update of the SEDS. There's going to have to be some work that demonstrates that we're leveraging that. And then also the establishment of the EDD, although I do think it is based on all the models that we have looked at and the work that ESCOG has done to date, I do think that it is strategically the right thing for ESCOG to do. However, it only has value in so much as we're identifying priorities to fund leveraging that designation.
3:14:39 While we don't want to pick up any additional projects now because we have potentially a lot of capacity building to do around wildfire, we do need to keep an eye to the future about what that EDD designation means for the region and how we want to use it. Which goes back to, I think, how critical it will be to identify
3:15:01 A model that works for the leadership of the member agencies to help drive what those priorities are. Because the EDD will have no value and will not be able to function or bring value back if there is not buy-in and support and collaboration that lifts those priorities up to the ESCOG. Okay. So, again, today was about just broad strokes. What I would like to take from this conversation is just five minutes of
3:15:30 What is some additional information that emerged from this conversation that would be helpful for our team and Elaine to pull together for next time so that you have that, you're equipped with that information, whether it's a pre-reading packet or whether it's just a share out so that you feel like you're better, you have all the information you need to kind of help be a board member and drive decisions. So that would just be helpful.
3:15:59 Do you want a copy of the SEDS? Do you need an overview of what Elaine just said in some kind of two-page memo? Okay, great. So sort of like a short, not long, memo regarding a strategic topic, which is the EDD. Okay. Well, I think also like what's the value of being an EDD, right?
3:16:28 Okay.
3:16:59 So a lot of times with boards, we work with the ED to create these like one to two page just like briefs that help build that common ground. So is there, I heard some stuff about just have, we understand what the grant, there's two million dollars in that work program area, shrimp, shrimp, shrimp, but like what is just an overview of that would be helpful for some of the newer members.
3:17:30 So the $2 million is for this fiscal year, and that is for, and there's some odds and ends in there for winding down Sierra Jobs first and the Payson Scale Accelerator, so those two grants will wrap up at the end of 2026. The remainder of that is for the CWDG. The CWDG grant is the regional community
3:17:59 Wildfire Hardening Grant. It's currently still in process by the federal government, so it's pending. Sorry, Elaine, I don't think we're hoping for you to do it now. Oh, okay, but I'm going to finish what I'm doing since I started. Let me finish. Okay, and then, yeah, and so the focus of that in the first year is really going to be about, like, ramping up, building a capacity model, and doing the, like, tasks of the hardening within that. I think because we're asking the board to be, give us direction,
3:18:29 on these programmatic areas, just doing like a two-page overview of like everything you just said because some people know all of it, some people know parts of it, some know none of it, some have a vague idea, so just having it be a pre-reading packet where we just have that summary and so that when we get in, we don't create a situation where some people are feeling like, well, I don't have enough information to like really comment on this and
3:18:59 And so just making, you know, it's not, we have these program areas in just a really high level. What's the funding? What are the programs? What's the benefit? Like we talked about, the value. Okay. Anything else people feel like they need? Just a quick question then. Is that, this thing that Elaine is drafting, is this intended to be within the framework that we just very loosely antiquated and described? Yes. Okay, so that's, does that make sense?
3:19:35 Which is this hybrid of A, was it A and C, and adding the EDD to it? Yes. Okay, plus Rob's stuff. Yeah, so I would have Rob write up. Rob's stuff. Rob's stuff. Right. How many people, what people, and all of that. Not exactly what people, but the board has their point. Yeah.
3:19:58 Yeah, just everything you just said verbally to put it into sort of a one-page thing of like a proposal for a working group to work on this capacity building structure area so that we can have a deeper conversation around it. Can I ask a question of the people who picked A? Do you feel strongly about continuing the Inyo Mono Broadband Coalition piece of this? We didn't really talk about it. Because that's really the biggest difference with...
3:20:28 Yeah, I'm comfortable with dropping the broadband coalition. I'm actually a little more interested in keeping the door open to other opportunities. I don't want to close the doors. I'm concerned about that. So we're, did you hear what? Did you understand what I was saying about the difference between A and C? Okay. Because that's what we said in our group, I was just trying to be clear. Well, are there unintended consequences? We should, that's a,
3:21:01 You know, grant that we've been working with for a really long time. I mean, as a budget item, it's like, what, $200,000 per budget? Yeah, I mean, I don't know how much work it's really taken us. I mean, I think there's been value where people can kind of figure out their internet speeds, and sometimes you get little data, overwhelmed with the data that we used to have received. I don't know. We might want to talk about
3:21:27 While we're dropping it versus just... I think if we were going to drop it, you know, we'd have to, like, remit the grant and require... I think that's something we could consider for, like, an actual board discussion about the pros and cons of that. Okay. Yeah, so let's create this summary memo pre-read that includes some back... just all the background information, high level.
3:21:56 Related to the broadband of what it is, what are the grant requirements, what are the kind of the start to the pros and cons from Elaine's staff perspective of so that when we get to the next session you'll have that information and you can have a more robust conversation around evaluating that. So for us we got what we needed from this conversation which is general temperature of where people
3:22:25 Okay, so in the last 30 minutes, what I
3:22:54 propose that if you are up for this is there's one simple thing we could do. So if you go to the next slide. Yeah, sorry. I know. Yeah. Okay. So this is, these are just two slides and I know people are, it's the end of the day and this isn't a huge, hopefully not a huge thing and a fun exercise. So you have, you have your bylaws. I've talked about this earlier. We pull this out.
3:23:25 But part of building alignment on the board is getting a set of sentences that we all agree to. So as we've noticed in the small groups, one of the gaps and one of the areas of opportunity is just communications internally, externally, getting clear on how we articulate. But also part of the reason that sometimes it's hard to find alignment is there's just not agreement.
3:23:53 on some of these foundational statements. It's in the bylaws. It's a little bit vague. And so what we wanted to produce in the strategic plan so that the staff has direction that these members all agree to these statements, therefore staff can communicate that out in newsletters and all sorts of things, create information for you to share with your board. And so we took, next slide.
3:24:23 So we took a first step at pulling these things together, which seem really easy, and like, who doesn't agree with those things? But you would be surprised, right? And so it is a core that we're all operating from, and that we believe is true. So if it's, so what I would, what I'm going to ask you to do at the end of this is to pair working groups of two, whoever you're next to,
3:24:57 And we're going to go through these in your groups of two. And I'm going to ask you to talk about them, edit them, decide which ones are true, which ones are missing, and then share back with, like, we agree that, like, one is great, but that word's not true, and we think this is missing. And then Bill's going to go. Okay? So working collectively on a regional basis, we're more competitive.
3:25:28 For public funding, I pulled that basically from your bylaws. By working collectively, we provide better services for our community. I pulled that, I translated that from your bylaws. This third one, you think everyone knows this. A healthy ecosystem and landscape are foundational to a strong economy. I'm not sure that that is, you know, so based on that core belief, we are picking our work programs. What else do we also want to?
3:26:00 I want to say that helps articulate who we are and what we believe in that drives our decision making. I'm a little confused as to what is the outcome of doing this exercise? It's going to be statements that go into the strategic plan and help us. When we're trying to make hard decisions, we can look back at that and Elaine can use it to also... But these are extracted from the bylaws. Yeah, the first two are. The first two are. The bottom one isn't. And so I would...
3:26:30 Say that those bylaws were written a while ago, and the organ, I'm not saying you have to update the bylaws, but I think the organization has evolved to where we may want to go beyond the bylaws. So we need some clarity of sentences. Can you legally do that? I mean, what, is that weird? You got a lawyer here.
3:26:48 I don't think that they necessarily supersede. I mean, we can get into the legalities of it before they're adopted. But I think some of the things that are important in this is as we bring on new board members, as we bring on new staff, I feel like we need to have some high-level statements around
3:27:13 what the value of ESCOG is, not what the value of ESCOG is and how much money it's bringing everyone, not what the value of ESCOG is as an ROI to, you know, the constituents within your jurisdiction, but, like, generally, we have an agreement in this organization that we are working collectively on regional issues that transcend individual member agencies, which is that, and that's also a statement from the bylaws that, um, my only concern is that
3:27:40 As new members come on board and people look at the organization, okay, what are your authorities to do things? And so, whatever we come up with in this, we can change the language, we can make it a little more poetic, we can make it whatever it is, but it has to be, I would advocate, it has to be something that tracks back to, oh, and by the way, the four agencies agreed to this, you know, the original statements that informed this, so this does not become like a scope creep opportunity.
3:28:07 Yeah, or an opportunity to change your bylaws. Exactly, without intentionally changing the bylaws. Or intentionally changing the bylaws. Well, we can intentionally change the bylaws, but you don't want to have sort of a side document that's noodling around. Rob? It seems like this would be better achieved after we did that first 12-month process where we really spent the time going through and sort of intimately designing this. So we can't answer that question because we're off the cuff. It's only going to be aspirational at this stage.
3:28:37 I would kind of agree with that. I think we're at a point where if we look at function, we go to the architectural metaphor, if we look at what the function, what we think we can actually do, and then derive the form from that, that might be, that might make sense. We can do it. Yeah, yeah. I mean, you can be both. I mean, you can be, you could be, so, I'm sorry, what is your name again? Christy. Christy. So we often have this situation with,
3:29:08 Public agencies, what's the interplay between a strategic plan and our codified documents? And tell me if I'm wrong, but strategic plans are aspirational. It's a forward, generally the way we speak about it is it's a document that was built through a collaborative process on what our priorities are that directs staff and
3:29:36 on what the board wants the staff to do, and it also communicates out to partners who we are and what we do in a much more understandable way than a resolution and a work program in the way that you guys, you know. And so, do the foundational agreements or your core values or your guiding principles that are in your strategic plan.
3:30:03 That you aspire to have to be codified in your bylaws. Contradict what's in your bylaws, or the JPA as it were, but they can be used to help, similar to how a regulation helps interpret. Exactly, exactly. And in the spirit of needing communications, you have these bylaws, you have these resolutions, and the general public still doesn't quite understand what you do and how they fit together, including members in this.
3:30:49 Room right here. So we're starting to build some tools for that translation. And so one of those translation tools is a strategic plan. And so can you, you know, I understand like, okay, so we create, this group creates a strategic plan and it has these guiding principles and then the next group come in here and say, well, why am I, why do I have to agree to those things? It's not in the bylaw. So like, it's not gonna, it's not gonna, I'm not actually gonna make a decision. But the point,
3:31:17 It's, again, I go back to what I said earlier. By having it in the strategic plan, it's a communications, which starts to create a regional mind shift around why are we doing wildfire? So just because you decide option C and you're doing wildfire, it doesn't mean that it doesn't have economic benefits. And so by having that statement, it's reminding all of us that as we work on large-scale ecosystem resiliency work, we're also having benefits.
3:31:46 Okay, so if you could indulge us, Rob, for
3:32:17 How about till quarter till we do this aspirational? Okay. Okay. So who wants to be with Rob? Who wants to be with Rob? I have no problem being with Rob. We're even sitting next to each other. Okay. Here's your homework. Here's your homework.
3:32:39 Read those statements, cross off the ones. So we as an organization believe these statements to be true. They're not in our bylaws, but we aspire to communicate these values. And you will see by the rest of our work that the work that we're doing reflects these values. You're not going to be, you don't have to sign your name to these things.
3:33:09 It's a, it's a, we're doing an exercise to practice building alignment through these communications. Yes. Your bylaws are so general. They basically say whatever's good for the region might be good for ESCOG. So you really do have a pretty open canvas on which to work. It was, it was an open canvas but with really strong guardrails. Yeah. You can't do anything unless every, all of the agencies say it's okay. That's right.
3:33:37 But again, it's just this word regional. It's hinging on the word regional. It's hinging on, like, economic value. And that is, so many things can impact. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Do people understand what I'm, I know, are people understanding what I'm saying about the third sentence? Yes. Why don't you explain it a little bit? Okay. Okay. So,
3:34:01 Hey, are you literally?
3:34:05 Bill's got a, he's got strength, he's got to get an apartment.
3:34:07 Okay, so by having this statement, it infuses all of the communications of ESCOG because it's at the center of a belief system that, guiding principles that add a little bit more detail that staff can use to communicate out to partners explaining things like
3:34:30 What is the link between this technical study in chipmunk and economic development? Why are we doing so much work around wildfire? Let's communicate around economic benefits. When we're working on sustainable rec, it's on the land, but it's an economic development strategy. So it's just creating that, it's laying down that we agree that those two are intrinsically linked, and we're going to state it, and we're going to communicate it.
3:35:00 But what's been asked in this process is let's put it in our strategic plan so I know the board agrees to this and it's not just Kanoff saying that and Elaine saying it at the summit. It would be really helpful if the whole organization, she had a set of sentences that everyone stood behind. Just trust me on this, it's going to be good. It's good, just trust me. Okay, so work in twos.
3:35:30 Just talk to each other about these statements, delete the ones you don't like, add something else, and then... You're talking those statements. Yes. Okay, great.
3:35:40 For 50 years, I was in a 24-7 business.
3:36:09 I don't have a problem with one and two, although I don't want the number one to be one.
3:36:39 So my problem here is, one, number two, is I'm working collectively because
3:37:08 The problem I have with number three,
3:37:37 I have yet four different people to get together and agree on what a healthy ecosystem is. Great question. Or anything else. When we say sustainable recreation, what the freak are you talking about? Sustainable for who? Just like half the people I talk to are wondering why we're showing, telling people where the trail launch is. Listen, I've heard that. The comment that I made earlier about whether or not we should be looking
3:38:06 What? You're breaking the game for that?
3:38:35 Yeah. Well, most people don't. I know. We have a majority of population in the moment, anyway, I can't speak for Inyo, who are so far over on what they consider that environmental side, that they won't look at the reason. A sheriff talked me along, one of our local sheriffs talked me a long time ago, and you see somebody breaking along, the first thing they're going to look at is fire.
3:39:05 What experience are they lacking when they have to bring it along? We only came up with these things. We can provide for that. We win. So the problem with that is...
3:39:17 All of us are going to have a different side of ourselves. Right. And that sort of builds into the pie, though. I mean, we all come at this with a difference. You know, Karen is out a lot more in there in the health ecosystem. That's right. I'm doing nothing but health. I'm thinking about having popcorn for dinner, so there you go. Nice.
3:39:47 Everyone has gone away with his Air Force buddies this week, because it's the Air Force birthday today, and so I have nobody to take care of for myself. I'll basically call it. Actually, I think that makes sense. Oh, yeah. That is hard. It was hard for me to go down for five, six, six. So, my wife and I have my sister lose a property with us, not even a household. So you can always take food to her? So she joins us for dinner every night.
3:40:16 So the only thing I would change on three...
3:40:25 Okay, so we went to the slightly deeper... But I'm still going to hear from my constituents. Who is this helping and why are we... Okay, if we decide...
3:40:54 What we can do here to do more things. The money comes from something else. Our budget is stretched already. I know we made it. It's not. It's an irritation if people don't understand how we're doing it. We call that ESCOG. Yeah. Okay, fine. We're taking a look at it. ESCOG can better provide services for goodness, right? We just talk about not going to regulate.
3:41:23 Thank you.
3:41:46 So are you good with taking healthy ecosystem and saying local ecosystem and landscape? Absolutely.
3:42:15 Are you good? Are you good? I'm licensed.
3:42:44 All right. All right. I would like to hear from Linda. I just want you all to just share your high-level insights.
3:43:14 High-level insights. We did some wordsmithing. We added in a phrase about we rather than we, we are ESCOG. We corrected a spelling error and we... Oh, that's embarrassing. Okay, that wasn't old. Working collectively on a regional basis, we are more competitive spelling for public to leverage funding from outside of our region.
3:43:38 Okay, so the funding is coming from outside. Okay, great. By working collectively, ESCOG, so it's clear from a communication perspective, it's not a pronoun, ESCOG, provide better services for our communities. Number three, a healthy ecosystem and landscape are foundational for strong local economies. So the idea that the ESCOG, the work that we're doing is benefiting local economies. Great, great, great, great. And finally, three musketeers. Dr. Hammion. What did he say?
3:44:05 All for one, one for all. All for one, one for all. But a need to have an expression about this. Everything that we do, as idiosyncratic as it might be, is for the benefit of all this. Okay. All right. All right. I also heard, Linda, I'm not trying to call you out, but I did hear you say, I'd rather have these bylaws updated, rather than work on these things. I said that the bylaws read like a nesincreet or something. Yeah. It seemed a little wordy.
3:44:35 I know, but they do what they need to do. No one ever memorizes these, so it's fine. It was written by a lawyer, so it's nice to know. Okay, great. Okay, anything to add? Yeah, so we're good with number one. Okay. Number two, by working collectively, we provide better services for our region. We're a regional. To spec it out as communities, I don't think, make no sense. On number three, a healthy ecosystem and landscape are foundational.
3:45:04 The problem I have, if I take four of us here in this room and I ask them what the heck healthy means, each one of them is going to have a different description. So I would just say our local ecosystem and landscape are foundational to a strong economy because that fits everybody no matter what their definition of healthy is. And as an English teacher, I don't like the fact that both sentences start with working collectively.
3:45:28 Yeah. Okay. So that, again, just remember that came out of the bylaws. I know. Just the lawyers. We can blame the lawyers. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you don't, yeah, she doesn't like working collectively is used too many times. Okay. Well, just move two down to four, and then you have a break in between them. And I think personally for me, I like, I don't like the one being one.
3:45:54 I mean, I realize funding is important, but the reason we're all doing this here is to provide better services for our community or region, right? So I think that should be one. Okay, so prioritize. Number two should be number one. I know, sorry, Kristen. Okay, did your group write any of those?
3:46:13 Brilliant Thoughts Down on paper. No, we determined neither one of us know how. Okay, okay. All right, and then can we grab our notes? If we can have notes, because we're capturing the notes like we can, but if we can have, you know, okay. We like number one and number two. Number three, we just didn't like it, thought it was, I mean, that is too specific on one area and didn't include everything, so we moved on to other things.
3:46:43 Wait, wait, wait, you don't like the healthy agio systems and landscapes? Yeah, because it just doesn't focus on ESCOG? I couldn't really understand what it really meant. Okay. We put it into the category of we also like puppies.
3:46:58 Okay. Okay. Wow. That is profound. That is profound. We don't like puppies, though. Everybody loves puppies. So three means nothing to us. Okay, so let me just ask, I know we're trying to get out of here, is it the wording or the actual content doesn't mean anything to you? I think maybe it was the content. Okay. Okay. Wow. Fascinating.
3:47:21 Okay, anything else? Yeah, we wrote some. Oh, you wrote some new ones. And so, the first one is the Bob Gardner Memorial, We're a Region, Dammit. Yes. Because we said that so many times. Okay, you guys really like taglines. And then, another one, more serious one. We put, many opportunities and challenges transcend political boundaries. Okay, great. And then, you had... Oh, I... Oh, come on, Rob.
3:47:50 Oh, Rob. I had building economic resilience for all communities in our region, and I did like communities because ultimately at the end of the day, that's what we're serving. That's not defined. I really wanted to focus on a couple of key points, which was mutual success, because that's always that question. And then when you were talking about things earlier on, you know, I tried to break it down to the root cause.
3:48:24 What is at risk of viability? Whether we don't grow and we die and dry up as a region and there's no reason to come to the Eastern Sierra because there's nothing here to see or we just don't grow proportionately across. There's opportunities across the entire region but we have to put effort into each one of those to grow them and I don't know that individually they're going to do that so collectively we have to grow the region.
3:48:54 That's what I was trying to get to, but I didn't put it. So I love your notes, and then I honed in on the word mutual. You said the word mutual. Okay, okay. All right. So we didn't take too much time on number two. Great. Thank you. Can we have your notes? Yeah, thanks. I liked the healthy ecosystem and landscape portion because it seems to be the underlying
3:50:07 Thank you. Thank you.
3:50:45 Megan, can you just put that? Okay. Good job, everyone. Thank you for indulging us with that. It's very interesting to see the thought processes of all of you in different interpretations of this organization. And I heard in the themes there that it was more about the functionality of this organization and less about the actual what you're doing.
3:51:14 in those guiding principles, like how you work together, how you work together to whatever comes up. So that was interesting for us. Okay, you were getting out of here slightly earlier. Thank you all for enduring on a Friday afternoon with other meetings this week. It seems like for the next meeting we would do three hours instead of four. It seems like this is a three-hour group.
3:51:38 Is my take? Five o'clock in the afternoon, shade. All right. So maybe not a Friday. Maybe not a Friday. Maybe a morning meeting. Maybe a morning meeting. Maybe, you know, we'll check that. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you, everyone. We will be in touch about next steps, next meeting. Thank you. Have a wonderful weekend. Elaine, do you want to say anything?
3:52:08 We will summarize the notes from today and send those to everybody and start to work on that next modeling. And Rob, we look forward to your one pager on operational excellence for ESCOG.
3:52:37 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. All right. Are we done? Yeah. Okay. We are in a meeting. We are in a meeting. If there is nothing further, this meeting is adjourned. Thank you. Good job, everyone.