TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2026

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 09:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

184 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:56 Good morning, everyone. I'd like to call to order today's meeting. Today is the Wednesday, July 8th, Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting here in Suite Z. With that, Jamie, may we have a roll call, please? Commissioner Deaver is absent. Commissioner Fleming? Here. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verrug? Here. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes, here. Thank you. Would everyone please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? Nolan, will you lead us again two months in a row?

2:30 to the flag of the United States of America, to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Nolan. With that, I'd like to open up public comment. I will ask if you have public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda, that you wait until that agenda item has been open. But with that? I'm here today to discuss in the trails that occur, but it really impacts our entire community.

3:17 We were recently informed that we had poor signage. We may not poor codes for anything for that matter. We may not specifically think about anything. And so we were told that we could have signs that they had to be five feet away. Town property, which is the town road. And if you've ever driven down Face Reef, five feet inside from the road, no driver is going to see that. We have a significant issue with people on the trails. And it's not just the trails, it's other trails.

4:07 We have a lot of our young community members and kids that are playing in the street, running out of their driveway's chase, at this time of year especially. I respectfully request that you hold, put this on the agenda and talk about how we can modify this code so that we can have a common sense solution to have slow kids at play, some sign available to our community, for our whole community, to get our drivers to slow.

4:44 So whether that is a sign is universal, not really a preference. Thank you. Before you leave, Jen, who informed you that the signs were in violation?

6:20 Thank you.

6:54 Before you leave, Brianna, Nolan, what would that conversation about updating the sign code look like? Is that administrative or does that come back to this commission? No, it would come back to the commission and then ultimately council because it's a zoning code amendment.

7:28 I think before it ever gets to the public hearing process, it'll be a whole lot of public outreach and public engagement with the business community, with the commission, with the council on what that looks like. I think Brianna can attest to it. I think she was told by her predecessor that updating a signed code might be one of the worst things ever because it's very controversial and everyone has opinions on it. And so it's something that we definitely want to

7:57 Have heavy engagement before we even get to the point of writing the actual code language down for what will be in there. That's something we're looking into. Got it. So when you say heavy engagement, that means public outreach? Public outreach, obviously, with, you know, the business community, with the broader community, because what businesses might want, others might have opposite opinions on it. Sure. You know, A-frame signs, I think, are a great example.

8:24 They can be done well, they can look well, but they can be done terribly as well. And they also have other impacts, you know, if they're blocking sidewalks or interfering with snow removal or other factors. So my kind of perspective is the temporary signs, so banners and A-frame signs are probably the biggest hot ticket item in that as far as what people are upset about. There's obviously some other changes in cleanup that has to happen as well.

8:53 Got it. Okay. And would you characterize the process as having been started or are we still waiting to jump off? It is one where we're trying to figure out where to fit it in in our work program. It's on our list but is not necessarily commenced yet. Got it. Dawn, did you have a... I was just going to ask with regard to the sandwich board signs, when you said that it's controversial or are people...

9:23 Do you hear people are proponents of it, or do you hear people complaining about it? I mean, I know what the code says, but do you? Both. Okay, so, okay. I would say the same as well. Okay. Well, yeah. I think specifically the outpost is a challenging area right now. Well, and even to the point where the e-bikes that are parked in the dirt meridian between the sidewalk and the street, I mean, that is an eyesore, nothing short of. Yeah, yeah.

10:07 Yeah, and so I had someone who works closely with people that design science reach out to us, that she knows that there's a group that really want to mobilize, get some suggestions together, bring it to council. So I let her know that I'm having this conversation, and unfortunately it isn't as simple as, here's my suggestions, let's adopt them, great, we can all go home. So I'm meeting with that individual next week, and so just...

10:35 I'm getting a lot of comments, this letter that went out really, like, oh, I mean, this is kind of lying around for, you know, kind of a dormant, but I think that this letter that was sent out really, like, sparked everyone to be like, we need to look inside. So, which, my understanding is a very lengthy process. Yeah. And complicated, it sounds like. But journey of a thousand, you know, a thousand miles starts with a step, so we have to probably address this. Anything else, Brianna?

11:04 I will say the parade was a fantastic success. MLT staff, as usual, walked the parade route and handed out 10,000 stickers this year. Awesome. This one-time commemorative sticker to the members of the public that were lined on the parade route both sides of the street, and the energy was fantastic. Good. And we really feel like the safety measures that were put in place this year were encouraged by Sergeant Paul to the parade route, having a secure perimeter, I think.

11:35 Thank you, Brianna. Any other public comment from Sweet Z? Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Thank you. Then I will close public comment and we will go to public hearing.

12:08 First one up is matter 4.1, which is consideration of zoning code amendment 26-001 to amend municipal code section 17.52.055 ADUs. The proposed zoning code amendment has been found to be exempt from CEQA. And I believe Tess is our staff contact on this one. Okay.

12:44 Item before you today is zoning code amendment 26-001 and this amendment applies to the town's ADU ordinance only. The amendment's purpose is to amend the accessory dwelling unit ordinance to be compliant and consistent with state law applicable to accessory dwelling units and junior accessory dwelling units.

13:09 A major component of the legislation has been to relax development standards and restrictions to promote the construction of ADUs and JADUs because of the statewide affordable housing shortage. The PEDC is required to make specific findings to approve the amendment. The findings are, can the findings be made for approval of the zoning code amendment pursuant to municipal code chapter 17.108?

13:38 And is the zoning code amendment consistent with CEQA? Here's a slide of the Assembly Bill Incorporations. Assembly Bill 2533 incorporates specific language that prohibits denial of a permit for an existing unpermitted ADU or JADU that was constructed prior to January 1, 2020, unless the ADU or JADU violates specific health and safety code standards.

14:11 Assembly Bill 462 incorporates specific language that a certificate of occupancy may be issued for an ADU prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for a primary dwelling unit if a proclamation of a state of emergency has been issued for the county where construction of the ADU is occurring. Assembly Bill 1154 revises the existing owner occupancy requirement for JADUs.

14:39 In instances where the bathroom facilities are not shared between the primary dwelling unit and the JADU, there are no longer any owner occupancy requirements. And here's a slide of the Senate Bill Incorporations. Senate Bill 477 updates the reference government code sections related to ADU and JADU law. Senate Bill 1211.

15:11 introduces state-mandated or state-exempt ADUs, which are ADUs that are not subject to development standards applicable to standard ADUs such as lot coverage and front yard setback requirements.

15:30 Assembly Bill 1211 incorporates specific language that removal of an uncovered parking space for the primary dwelling unit to construct an ADU does not require a replacement parking space on site. And the Senate Bill 1211 also updates the allowable number of detached ADUs on multifamily lots from two detached.

15:55 to eight detached, provided the number of detached JDUs does not exceed the number of existing multifamily dwellings, and up to two detached JDUs are allowed for lots with a proposed multifamily dwelling. Senate Bill 543 revises limitations in size for JDUs and JDUs to be based off of habitable space and not gross floor area.

16:25 Senate Bill 543 incorporates specific language that prohibits development impact fees for ADUs that are 750 square feet or less in habitable space and all JADUs which are 500 square feet or less in habitable space. It incorporates specific language that review by the town and approval or denial by the town of a permit for an ADU or JADU shall be in accordance with state requirements.

16:55 including deadlines and noticing requirements. It incorporates a specific language that an ADU or a JADU of 500 square feet or less of habitable space does not increase accessible space. It incorporates the allowable number of, the allowable number and type of ADUs under government code section 66323, such as for single family lots up to three ADUs are allowed.

17:25 One junior ADU of 500 square feet or less, one interior, and one detached ADU of 800 square feet or less. And then here are the specific municipal code findings required, and an amendment may be approved only after all of the findings required by municipal code section 17.108.060.

17:56 are made pursuant to Municipal Code Chapter 17.108. These findings have been made and are described within the PDC staff report and resolution. The amendment implements state mandated ADU and JADU law, which is statutorily exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA guidelines section 15282.

18:27 H in Public Resources Code Section 21080.17. And also, just for the record, no comments have been received by staff regarding this amendment as of today.

18:50 The recommendation is that the PDC adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required Municipal Code and CEQA findings, and recommending to the Town Council approval of Zoning Code Amendment 26-001 as recommended by staff. Thank you, Tess. Any questions from the Commission for staff on the ADU amendment? I just want to clarify.

19:21 We cannot, and we can't make it, what's the word? Exceed. Exceed the limits or what their requirement, like the one thing that kind of rings in my head is the parking, you know, the lack of parking. I don't know that it's going to be as big of an issue as it is in other areas in California, but I do know it's an issue where they're not required parking, which becomes really crazy in certain places, but we can't enforce.

19:50 We can't require a specific amount of parking, correct? That's correct. For an ADU, our code cannot be more restrictive than the state. We can be less restrictive. And so within the code, it wasn't highlighted here because this is just kind of focusing on the changes. We did include some provisions to try to encourage people to provide parking. Normally you can't have...

20:16 Thank you so much.

20:46 with even just the review of the ordinances. You know, once it goes through the whole public hearing process, then we have to share it with the state. They review it. They may or may not provide additional findings or required changes, which would require to go back through the process. It seems a little backwards that they do it after the fact, but that's the way they work. And kind of looking at what some of the findings and, like, letters other cities have gotten on their ADU ordinances, they're

21:16 Pretty extreme, the state's kind of enforcement of this. And just to boil that down, Nolan, would you mind just in very plain speak, the town of Mammoth Lakes cannot exceed the state's requirements for ADUs. And that, when you talk about parking, the state does not have hard and fast parking requirements. Therefore, the town cannot have hard and fast parking requirements.

21:44 That's correct. For ADUs, it's tied to if there's public transit available. And specifically in the ADU one, it doesn't define the public transit as far as the kind of the intervals or the quality like they do in some of the other statutes on some of the other kind of state mandated programs. So in our case, because all of town is served by transit, we cannot then require parking for ADUs. Got it. What about

22:12 Snow storage. Is that a separate issue? The state does not address snow storage or care that it snows here. So the town cannot enforce a specific whatever square footage for snow storage per ADU? That's correct. Okay. Any other questions for staff? Any public comment on this matter? Please.

22:54 I do acknowledge that ADUs are an important puzzle to solve the housing machines in the state. I'd like to draw your attention to the concept of setbacks. Normally, a site setback in Mammoth Lakes, I believe, is 10 feet from the site. So 10 feet from the side of the house

23:33 Maybe a little less even. So now, do you have a five feet and a four feet if there is an ADU next to me?

24:06 So that's nine feet. So that gets pretty tight. And if there's two ADUs side by side, then that's eight feet. So eight feet likely from here to the lake. So you've got buildings that are perhaps in a single story, as much as 15 feet tall, or a two story building that could be 20 feet tall. You've got two 20 foot walls eight feet apart for snow storage.

24:39 John, may I interrupt you for a quick second? Apologies. I just got a note from the public that the mic on the podium is not on. Sorry.

25:23 Shall I continue? Please, you might just have to speak loud until it's resolved. So, I think that the setbacks for ADUs in our community have a significant effect on snow storage and shedding of snow between two buildings. I think the other consideration that as we move forward is that I would request of town staff of the

25:53 of the building inspection process and the design process of ADUs that some consideration be given for impact and privacy. An ADU that has three windows on the side of it, one of which looks straight into a bathroom, the other looks straight into a deck, doesn't give a lot of consideration for the

26:20 Property owner next door to the ADU. And I think that those sorts of things are important because it's a matter of, again, privacy, enjoying one's space, particularly being outdoors in the summertime itself. I think that these, the ADUs are very important to our community, but the impact of snowy storage has yet to be fully measured in our community.

26:51 And the fact that the state of California is not paying attention to or allowing for an extreme snow load situation such as the one we have here in Mammoth is an important factor to consider. Perhaps one that the town of Mammoth Lakes ought to pursue and study more carefully before this type of situation develops. So once again, eight feet between buildings for a snow shed and snow storage.

27:21 That's not going to work. And also I would pay attention to the design parameters that incorporate the original dwelling plus the ADU as a percentage of the total lot space. That could be such a high percentage that the only snow storage available is the 20 foot setback from the street to the front of the building. And if there are already three or

27:49 Possibly four parking spaces there, then snow storage for that property owner is extremely limited. And in a heavy winter, that would be gone by the end of January. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. Any other public comment on this matter from Sweet Z? Jamie, do we have any via Zoom? No.

28:15 Nolan, would you like to address the setback in snow storage? I know we kind of talked about it a little bit and how we cannot supersede the towns or the state's regulations. Yeah, definitely. So the four foot setbacks have been in place now, I want to say it's since about 2018 or 2020, so that's when the state

28:39 I think it was 2020 when they kind of drastically overhauled the AD regulations and really put in some extreme development standards such as the forefoot setbacks and the inability to look at lot coverage and some other factors. And so those are all in that area where the town has no discretion on it. We have to allow that.

29:00 The forefoot, side and rear setbacks, the state has also even gone further and allowed ADUs in the front setback if there's no other possible area on the lot where an ADU could be built. And so when those forefoot setbacks were originally being proposed, our counterpart actually tried to lobby the state up in Truckee through their lobbyists for the exact concerns that Mr. Armstrong raised about Snowshed and others.

29:29 You know, specifically to environments where it does snow a lot, and the state essentially said they didn't care and that the four-foot setbacks were statewide there. And then as far as design standards, the state's very big on what they call objective standards only, so meaning standards have no subjectivity whatsoever, so if we try to put something in there that said, you know, ADU shall respect the privacy of adjacent neighbors,

30:00 The state would force us to strike that out because that would be a subjective standard because it's very subjective as to what impacts someone's privacy or not. So it's one of those where I don't want to say our hands are completely tied but our hands are tied on many of these regulations in the ADU ordinance. Thank you. Any other discussion? Thoughts? So there's absolutely no

30:33 Exceptions that can be filed for counties that inhabit rather extreme environments very opposite to the most standard California environments because I feel like if we were in Michigan right now or Vermont I feel like these numbers and legislations would probably look very different because

31:07 Every single person that passed California-wide bill would have been feeling very differently. So there's absolutely no exceptions that can be filed. That's correct. In the case of setbacks, law coverage, like I said, the state has taken this very kind of narrow-minded approach to this.

31:40 These are the standards statewide and every city has to implement these. Any other questions or thoughts? Commissioner Grant? Before I ask for a motion, I will just say this is a classic case of good intentions that maybe aren't taking into account the unique character of some of the municipalities and communities within the state. I mean, we, I think, can all agree that additional housing, especially if it's affordable housing,

32:23 is a must in this community, but not to take into consideration the extreme environment that we live in, that Tahoe lives in, communities up north live in, Shasta, I'm thinking Lassen, those type of places is unfortunate. And it sounds like Tahoe, our colleagues in Tahoe tried to have that conversation with the state and were basically slapped down pretty fast and hard. Is that

32:53 A fair summary, that is. It's too bad. All right, unless there's any other thoughts or opinions, would anybody care to put forth a motion? I'll make a motion to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required Municipal Code and CEQA findings and recommending to the Town Council approval of the Zoning Code Amendment 26-001 as recommended by staff.

33:30 Do we have a second? I second. Any other conversation? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Unfortunately, yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Van Dervers? Yes. Matter passes 4-0. Yeah, I think I said my piece. We'll move on to business matters. First one is matter 5.1, consideration of the five-year CIP, which is capital improvement plan for years.

34:01 26 to 2031, and adopt a resolution finding the CIP to be in conformance with the general plan. And with that, our staff contact is Hayes. Morning. Morning, sir. How are we all doing? We live in Mammoth, we're in paradise. Well, I would say up until the last 20 minutes a little better. Well, I won't make this one as difficult, at least I hope not. So I think it was, was it March that I was here?

34:36 I had it in the staff report. When we talked about projects and so forth in the CIP, I'm planning to take the CIP Ford Town Council on August 5th. However, before I can do so, by state law, the Planning Commission needs to find the CIP consistent with the general plan.

35:09 So this is my well-worn presentation that many of you have seen many, many times because this is the business side of the equation. So I promise to make the business side painless. I think if you've read the staff report, you understand what we need to do, what the work before you, but I'll get back to the projects because I know that's what you guys want to talk about, that's what you want to hear about. So I'll make time to provide.

35:34 The opportunity to ask questions about what we've got going on, what we're looking at this year, next year, and so forth. I'm going to move through this pretty quick because you've all seen this before. The recommendation before you is that you receive this presentation and confirm by resolution that the CIP is consistent with the general plan. The key issues before you is if and is the proposed five-year CIP consistent with the general plan and is it consistent with

36:05 The five-year CIP, as you know, includes development, maintenance, improvements, acquisition of infrastructure assets. Projects including the CIP are major non-recurring projects that have a long service life that we believe will be underway and may or may not be funded during the five-year cycle. CIP expenditures are beyond the scope of normal annual operating and maintenance expenses.

36:33 The CIP does not appropriate funds. This is really important. I highlight this every time. This is a budget tool. It helps town council forecast their expenditures for capital investment, but it does not appropriate funds. We also do not include a number of different elements in the CIP, things like vehicles, technology, software.

36:55 Our projects address a number of community needs, legal requirements, maintenance to extend the useful life of existing infrastructure, deferred maintenance, we support enhanced mandated and core services like solid waste, emergency services, communications, pedestrian improvements, transit, traffic signals and signage, to expand and improve community services, things like the CRC and the MAC, trails.

37:22 And to identify, excuse me, to meet identified community needs and strategic council priorities like affordable housing. Process and schedule, you guys are pretty used to this. We do this kind of cyclically every year. New projects are identified. CIP is updated. That's happening in real time throughout the year. We draft a CIP, align it with the recommendations and strategic planning that comes out of town council in like the late winter.

37:52 Review the projects with council commissions, like I said, we were back here, we were here in, I think it was March, middle of March. We make any budget adjustments, that happens, you know, Q2, Q3, Q4, when Rob is realizing DOT will add to the budget, add to that CIP, adjust projects, and then we're here looking for commission resolution, finding it consistent with the general plan, and then we will adopt it.

38:21 On August, I think it's the 5th. And then we start all over again. And we just continue that process. Okay, project-wise, and I know you can't read this. This is just to demonstrate the battery of work that I'm carrying over. There's about $77 million of work in flight right now. A lot of it's coming from the MAC and the town hall, but we have...

38:49 A ton of work happening at the airport, and there's just a myriad of different projects all over town addressing a ton of different community needs. And feel free to stop and ask questions along the way. I'm just going to quickly go through the big ticket items here. We've got taxiway, multipurpose building being constructed down at the airport. We're also working on a temporary HQ. I think everybody's heard the news that CAL FIRE has set up headquarters at our airport.

39:19 It's really exciting, but we have to make some changes to accommodate them. We also need to update our water system down there. I'll talk a little bit more about the MAC and the town hall. We do have money set aside for the child care facility, but we're still working on finding a partner. We've set aside money to complete a pump track, and we've got a consultant helping us out with some of that design work. We've set aside more money for the shady restroom, which we're hoping to build out in a couple seasons.

39:48 We've got a park signage plan that we're opening to get out this fall. That's monument signs, some information signs, and what we're calling the TBID kiosks. This is informational signage throughout town tailored to whether it's a park for locals or if it's on Main Street and it's tailored to tourism.

40:11 We've got a fencing project. Hey, please, do you mind if I interrupt you really quick with a fast question? Yeah, yeah. The wayfinding signage that will be going in in the future will still be thematically similar to what is in existence now? Yeah, the T-bin signs, the monument signs, all of it was designed at the same time, so it's just being implemented now, but it's the same look and feel as the municipal signage of wayfinding. I think I have some images in here of what those might look like.

40:39 Apologies for interrupting. Yeah, no, please do. Please do. I'm running through this real fast. Just, you know, please stop me. I think most of you have heard this stuff before, but you're welcome to ask your questions along the way. Why is it called the TBID? That's just our own name for it. Okay. We ended up packaging a couple of different projects, so we had money set aside for the monument signs for Mammoth Creek Park, the dog park, and Shady Rest to replace those, the existing sign of Shady Rest.

41:07 And then Mammoth Lakes Tourism was looking at doing some like informational signage and so forth. So we brought in that since it's the same product, same look and feel, it made sense to combine it. And then some of the new park features like the bouldering wall and so forth need informational signage to the public. So we've just kind of been building a package.

41:30 TBID signage is just our internal name. So it's not, it's not being funded in part by TBID? It is being funded in part by TBID. Okay. And the rest of it is through TOT Town Funds. Okay, thank you. We have something we're calling the Shady Rest Fencing Project, adding a fence from the playground down to the skate park, removing some of those old creasote logs. We're also including in that some repair.

41:55 of fencing down at the industrial park, and then we are adding some fencing at the pickleball complex. Working on the old Mammoth Road beautification, we struggled to get the water system working. We thought we had it done in April, and we chased leaks for two months. It finally holds pressure. As of June, it holds pressure, and now they're working on getting the valving and the little stuff done, but we missed the optimal planting window.

42:25 So we'll probably hold off on the majority of the plantings until we know we've got time for them to get stabilized. So they're focusing on finishing the irrigation and some hardscape, some rocks, some chips, very similar to what you see on Main Street, same kind of stuff. We've got a project to put a pedestrian beacon at Mountain Boulevard.

42:50 That was funded by Highway Safety Improvement, similar to what you see at Laurel Mountain and the post office. So we're working on combining that with what we're calling the South Main MUP, which is that path connecting the Lakes Basin Path at the brewery down to Callahan. So we're going to combine all that into one project. So we're working on that design right now. And then we did a bunch of maintenance projects. We've got the slurry seal project, which is about to kick off here in a couple weeks.

43:18 We did a striping project, so we contracted out all the striping. We've got a minor asphalt and concrete project that's going to be used to widen some of the streets to actually facilitate some of the striping issues we found. The Minaret Mupp, which is going great, and stop right there. That's pretty much the backlog of projects we've got going on. Notice I did not say anything about Red's Meadow Road.

43:43 That's a $30 million project. I don't put it in here because it skews the numbers. I did not put in any of the money that the town has contributed to Pacific to facilitate the housing at the parcel. That's in the neighborhood of $21 million. That project's going well. They broke ground in Phase 2, Phase 2.2, Phase 2.1 should be available this fall. So, I mean, there's, you know, $150 million in work the town is facilitating right now.

44:13 Which is why it's incredibly busy out there, not to mention the private development and the utility work that's going on. Any questions on kind of what we got for the backlog? Any questions for what Hayes has gone over so far? So does Red Meadow have a completion date? They're a production paving right now. They've turned a corner. I don't know if anybody's been down there, but most of the rock work and the excavation and the retaining structure, it's all done.

44:38 So they're doing the remove and replace on the lower portion and they'll be pulling the paving up. I suspect they will be substantially complete this year. I anticipate they will probably have punch list items that will carry them into next season, but I anticipate it will be business as usual for the public starting next year. Hayes, do you still do recon trips down there? Yeah. Would it be appropriate for Commissioner, if her schedule allows, Commissioner Miranda to join you on a recon trip? Yeah, yeah.

45:08 Yeah, I might go down there on Friday. You want me to give you a ring? Maybe you guys can touch base offline. I went last year with Rob and I found it fascinating. Yeah, it's looking really good. They're making really good progress. It's disappointing it took this long to get here. But I'm optimistic that we'll be in a really good spot going into next season. So yeah, just give me a ring. Like I said, I'm going to be out on vacation for a couple weeks, but I'm probably going to try to get down there on Friday.

45:38 Okay, so no more questions on what we got cooking right now? I do. Can you elaborate on the missing middle project for $100,000? Yeah. So I have that in the 26-27 project, so that's kind of now. And Nolan, help me out, because this is really a project that Nolan and Marcus are spearheading, and I just represent that investment.

46:09 What is before council right now, and there's been a series of conversations leading to this event, is the missing middle housing is very complicated. There are no grants, there's no funding, and if we're going to be successful in that space, the town is going to have to take pretty aggressive action on its own to facilitate that development. And it's going to be quite costly to make it happen. And our understanding...

46:36 is that nobody in the state of California has figured out how to make this work. Marcus and Nolan have figured out a path forward, which we believe we can navigate this space, kind of following a model from Colorado but tailoring it to California law. In order for us to ensure that we can be successful in that space, we've got to spend a little bit of money investigating the financing of this project, getting a little bit of

47:05 Pre-planning work done with the schools, which is a little bit of a tangent, but I'll explain that, and then working with our bond council to make sure that we can do this. It's incredibly complicated. Like I said, nobody's figured this out. We're going to try to break trail on this thing and land a project for the community, but we're going to have to spend a little bit of money to figure out if it's even viable, if legally we can even do what we're proposing. And Nolan, before you jump in,

47:34 For people who are not familiar with what the missing middle means, would you just kind of summarize what that term encompasses? Sure. So this is really an effort to target those who are earning, you know, from the 80% of the median income number up to 120% of the median income. So it's generally your, you know,

47:59 Decent wage earners in the community, could be supervisors, could be managers, mountain restaurants, others who make too much to qualify for the parcel low-income housing units because those are all 80% and below units. They don't make enough to otherwise find stable housing here in the community. So this is our effort to, I'd say, kind of disrupt the market.

48:26 Hopefully, by bringing a larger number of inventory of rental apartments into the community that are really then available for those who are working here and trying to find housing. And that could be teachers, firemen, policemen? Correct. So with this project, you know, where I guess Hayes alluded to, it's an ambitious effort. It's a lot of moving parts, a lot of...

48:57 You know, working through the legal aspects of it for how radical California is on some of the housing fronts, such as the ADUs and other pieces, they make other aspects of it incredibly difficult to get through specifically with regards to this. The state has focused that, you know, more housing is good, affordable housing, so that 80% and below is good.

49:26 But if you're trying to build, as a municipality, housing that missing middle, they view that as not a significant need in the states. They don't make it easy. It's got to be a need in every community, though, in California. I think it's skewed by just the, you know, when you look at the coastal communities and the cost discrepancy there. I mean, I think I recently saw in San Francisco.

49:52 They're, you know, affordable. So those in that 80, like the lower income brackets for one or two person household are making well over a hundred thousand. That's just, the incomes are so skewed. And so they view that as kind of the issue all over the state. And that's just the way the state operates. Is there any sort of a lobbying organization for housing or missing middle housing that is active in the state?

50:22 I mean, there is a lot of lobbyists working in that space. The town, we have our own lobbyists that tries to push and advocate for some of these. I want to say it is kind of unsuccessful. I mean, we've got some, you know, movement on some bills, but the state largely kind of ignores it. I think Colorado's probably...

50:49 You know, much, they're kind of the leaders in this effort of the missing middle, but Colorado also has a lot more laws that are beneficial or friendly towards getting this type of development built, too. And they've done kind of carve-outs in Colorado for resort communities and others where California has not gotten there yet. Thank you. Any other? Sorry to interrupt you, Nolan. Please continue. Yeah, no problem. And like I said, just stop me if you've got questions.

51:21 So going into this year, so you can see how much work we have back catalog. So we're not trying to add a ton. We've got kind of our usual type projects. You know, there's some ADA improvements. We've got some signage updates and winter animation and decoration and then our annual sorority and striping projects, which are baked into the public works budget. So those projects are kind of on an annual basis.

51:50 We've got a security fence potentially down at the airport, but that's subject to FAA funding, along with the reconstruction of some of the taxi lanes. But other than that, it's only a pump track and a skate park maintenance contract that we're really adding. I believe a lot of the work you saw in the carryover is going to continue to carry over. So we anticipate a significant amount of that work going through next season. So we're trying not to add too much.

52:19 Because we're already, we've already got a backlog of projects. And when you mentioned the skate park project, is that the Shady Rest Skate Park or Volcom? That's the Volcom Skate Park and we're working with that non-profit and they're dedicating money to maintenance and so we're putting together annual maintenance contracts to kind of address ongoing issues. So it's been a good partnership.

52:46 I see you guys have the rental and concession space built out on the agenda as well. Is it something to be expected for this winter season? Yeah, I went right over that, didn't I? Yes, that work's happening in real time. So we've got contracts in place, contractors working on it. I anticipate that rental and concession space will be available for this upcoming hockey-slash-skate season.

53:15 So beyond 26, 27, looking kind of like at 27, 28. A few things on the horizon. Again, there's a bunch of work the airport's trying to do. This is all subject to FAA, but the idea of helicopter parking apron space to facilitate CAL FIRE and some runway changes that need to occur. They need to adjust some of the numbering because of magnetic declination.

53:45 Again, some of our normal stuff like ADA improvements and slurry seal projects. We do anticipate by 27-28 we'll be able to construct the Shady Rest restroom. That project's going to end up being over a million dollars to replace that restroom with all the other improvements that are required above and beyond the restroom itself, the ADA improvements, the sewer improvements, and things of that nature. And that's the restroom near the...

54:12 The parking lot, not the restroom by the concession stands. It's right next to the playground. Correct. Really, really old one. And it's going to be winterized, so it's heated, so it'll support both winter and summer uses, which we think is really key to the area, but that's why the price tag has just gone through the roof. It's all hydronic heated. It's exact same unit that you see at the Park of the Parcel, except larger, so pre-manufactured.

54:40 Same look, same kind as other facilities. And the reason for the winterization is because that's a cross-country skiing area, snowshoeing area, winter play area. It's become an incredibly popular destination for so many different uses that it just makes sense to have a restroom that's available year-round. Bear with me and get my place again. Again, looking at a couple other improvement projects.

55:14 On Tavern Road, right between the hospital and the town hall, that alignment is really funky. How that road came together with all the varying improvements, so we need to modify that alignment. It's got a really odd grade break, and we've worked with the hospital and with our project to design a realignment to make it flow a lot better for...

55:41 People going to the hospital and people coming to the town offices. So we've got that project in the hopper. What we're calling the Minaret Road gap closure, we are anticipating a small segment of sidewalk to be missing between the Rock Spring development and Burgers. Right now there's no sidewalk there at Alpenhoff and Burgers. Rock Spring is only responsible for building the sidewalk in front of the space. So we're going to want to close that gap.

56:07 And then we're hoping by this time frame we'll have the South Main MUP project design work completed and approved by Caltrans combining that way with the highway safety improvement project for the crosswalk beacon and get that all done in 27-28. And then we've got some money set aside to do transit shelters and we've got three that we're looking at. The Vons, the Vons stop.

56:36 Old Mammoth Road, stop two, and then one on Tavern Road to support the long haul for ESTA, the YARDS bus and the one that goes from, you know, Lancaster up, that one stops on the other side of the road, so we would like to support them. Devon's one, we got to figure some stuff out. We may be coming to a member of this commission looking for some support in moving that structure down the street because our easement here does not facilitate the

57:06 The same size structure that we have elsewhere, it's too small, and we're not getting good support in building it out, and then having the stop in the same space as the right turn lane is kind of problematic, so we're looking at relocating it, but by 27, 28, we think we'll have all that worked out, have all the designs done, and get those projects completed. Beyond that, years 28, 29,

57:33 We do have a plan in place. It's in the five-year CIP, what we think is going to fall in there, but it does represent longer-term goals, and these projects are subject to change. There's a lot less funding in these projects. It's kind of picking up things year by year. There are some things that are funded. There's $2.5 million for the roundabout, which is the town's favorite project. Everybody supports it.

58:01 We'll see how that plays out, but that's funded in 28-29 through the State Transportation Improvement Program, but it'll need additional resources. Also, you're going to see a shift to maintenance. You're already starting to see that shift to maintenance. There were like four major maintenance projects on our 26th agenda because we've done a great job of building out infrastructure and we're going to have a lot more projects to maintain it, especially now that we've got more facilities, town hall, a MAC.

58:27 Community Recreation Center, a lot more trails to maintain. There's just going to be a lot of capital improvement projects that are dedicated to maintenance, keeping these assets we've spent a ton of money on in great shape. And I think you've seen that in the parks as well, just a ton of money being spent on keeping our facilities in good shape. So a couple highlights and a couple photos. So town hall coming along well.

58:57 They're saying we're going to be in the building by the end of September. Maybe. I think we're probably going to need a 30 to 60 day cushion on that to make sure all the systems have been tested out. Just the way things are shaking out. That's no shade on the contractor. They've been doing a great job. But it's working in Mammoth. There's always challenges getting materials and supplies and people up here.

59:19 I mentioned some of the signage, that's the look and feel of the monument sign right there. So it's the same kind of portent steel, same color palette. And then real-time transit, I skipped right over that. So... Hayes, a really quick question. Have you budgeted for this wayfinding signage to be placed along the new minaret MUP once it's completed? Yeah. Fantastic. Yeah, it's all built in. We designed everything to kind of work together. That's kind of the...

59:49 When we design these projects, we work through that exercise. Now, the timing of it was always off. Like, I suspect we'll probably have that path done. It would not shock me if people are riding on it in 30 days. Wow. They're flying. I suspect, I think they're paving some of it tomorrow. So they're making really great progress. However, that type of signage has an incredible lead time. It has to be fabricated and so forth. I mean, I wouldn't be shocked if the signage was going in before winter. It just takes that long.

1:00:16 to get stuff done. And just for clarity for the public, the raw materials and the heavy equipment that are being kind of staged out of the wood site are working on the MUP. This has nothing to do with the wood site, the wood site's future. This is a temporary. Thank you for that. I wish they wouldn't have...

1:00:39 Come to terms on that, because it looks, it's a bad look. But you're right, that contractor has struck a deal with that private property owner to store equipment on that site. And so those materials are for the MUP, and they're not for the Woodside Project, which is still, I believe, as of today, under an appeal. So I combined a bunch of stuff here on this slide. Real-time transit. So I hope you've noticed that on two shelters, we've got

1:01:12 Transit signs that are providing next bus information. This was a project, we worked with ESTA, we worked with Sacramento, Caltrans reached out to us to help us put this together to get the sign vendors, the application vendors, and the GPS units in the buses to all communicate. Took the state to kind of step in and get these partners to kind of work together and build the back end.

1:01:40 Programming to make it work. And then we tested it for a number of months. We had these signs in our office kind of telling us when the next bus was coming. We were kind of tracking it. It seems to be working pretty well. We're pretty satisfied. And so we're going to deploy them to all of our transit shelters. So this is another project we're working with MLT. This is another TBIT type project. And hopefully by this winter we'll have all the product in place. We've already put all the infrastructure in the transit shelters, all the electrical.

1:02:08 All the back-end stuff. So we're just waiting for the signs to be ordered and delivered. I actually believe they've been ordered. And yeah, it's a great project. I think it turned out great. It took a lot of effort with working with the state to make this. Great amenity for locals and visitors alike. Do we have any conversations going between town and Esther to avoid or how to avoid what we had at the bus shelters early in winter season in November?

1:02:38 The lines for 40 to an hour to get on a transit because the canyon was closed and everybody was shuttling to Maine and there was not enough transit. So there's a couple of things there. So there's the bus service at the lodges is that's through MMSA. That's through the ski area. So there's partnerships with ESTA, but that's managed through the ski area. So I can't really speak to what they're doing to accommodate things that happen at the lodges.

1:03:07 When we have buses that are full on Main Street, there are buses in reserve, and we get those complaints all the time. However, it's anticipated. We expect the buses to fill out, but you just never know when it's going to happen. So there are buses in reserve, they call them trippers, and they're just sitting there waiting. When the driver goes through a stop on Main Street and says, I'm full, I'm passing people, they call in to dispatch, and they dispatch another bus.

1:03:34 We've been doing that for a couple years. Doesn't mean that that person, you know, got driven by, but hopefully with this new signage, they'll see that the next bus is coming in a few minutes, and hopefully that will help to quell those issues, because they're real, we know it happens, but you kind of have to react to it rather than, you know, put a whole bunch of extra buses where they may not be needed, because you don't really know where they're going to be and when they're going to be needed.

1:04:02 I just know that we feel like this winter especially was just so terrible. Like we spoke to many visitors and the people waited for 40 minutes to an hour and they were flagging, passing by cars and trying to jump into any truck beds because the buses just kept being full and full and they just could not get on the mountain.

1:04:30 I just think like it's not very good look on a town that's heavily relying on tourism that we can't accommodate tourism when it happens. Okay. I can shepherd those comments. I can't speak to individual incidents that I was not a part of, but I know they have the protocols in place when buses pass by people. They have buses in reserve waiting here in town. And I've always found that if people are informed,

1:04:57 They tend to be more patient. If they understand, they have the signage that tells them when the next bus is coming, it tends to alleviate a lot of frustration. But then when you have like two buses went by and they fall and the third one comes and it's full. I understand that. And it's incredibly difficult to scale up and scale down on that level for periods of time, short periods of time, let's be honest about it. It's really in the morning and it's late afternoon when people are coming down off the hill.

1:05:28 But I think efforts are being made. Yeah, there's a number of protocols in place and, you know, I think we've all seen it, but it's only, it takes them like 15 minutes to get another bus and sometimes the buses stack up so it feels like there's two buses going by right next to each other and there's another bus coming from dispatch so it's really hard to deal with these one-off type scenarios where we've got just a mass influx of

1:05:57 People wanting to ride the bus and other circumstances. So, but hopefully this program, this system will help to educate them, you know, let them know that there's additional buses coming. And if you have more questions about this, I can put you directly in charge with ESTA and you can ask, you know, what they've got going. You can hear directly from them. I think like on one of the meetings, on one of the previous meetings, we talked about either a mountain representative and ESTA representative joining us.

1:06:26 Having different questions come up regarding the mountain operations and the transit and do we have any update on if we can have a mountain representative and ask the representative join us? We can make the request. You can make the request through Nolan to agendize an item for a transit update. Typically the updates I provide are for unmut transit needs. It's a very specific program. Obviously we'll answer questions at that time, but I'm looking for...

1:06:54 When I come and do my presentation, it's for, you know, ADA issues or people who have needs and so forth. It's a very structured thing, regulated thing that we need to do. But if you want a general update, just ask general questions of the new director and Brian, that team, you know, we can probably set that up. They'd be happy to talk to you. Maybe sometime in the fall, Nolan? I know we've got a lot coming down the pipe. Yeah, I think we can definitely reach out to them. I think getting them scheduled and time to prepare.

1:07:26 So I think Paul seems reasonable. Thank you. Okay. Moving on, the MAC, I think everybody's seen it. I don't think you can miss it. It's growing day by day, making good progress on the walls and the superstructure, hoping to have a roof on it here in a couple months, and then they'll be inside working on it throughout the winter. We're anticipating sometime summer, early summer of 2027 for an opening. Has there, and this is not really.

1:07:56 Intended for either of you guys, but has there been any progress on hiring the director to run the MAC? Yes. Okay. But nothing you can publicly disclose at this time? They're making great progress. Okay. Because this, you know, just, I honestly think one of the reasons the CRC came out of the gate so fast and was so successful is it was programmed from the word go.

1:08:25 And I think the MAC needs to kind of follow that template to have the same success. The community will embrace this facility the same way they embrace the CRC if it's successful from the word go. Yeah, I believe we agree with you, and that's why they're hiring somebody now well in advance of the opening to help tip it up, get it going early. And I believe Stu will probably speak to that once something can be said publicly about it. Perfect. Thank you.

1:08:55 Sorry for the tangent. No, no, it's all good. It's really exciting stuff. Just a couple of photos from the MUP. Like I said, these guys are flying. They'll be paving out these areas tomorrow, and then it could be as soon as next week they start paving portions of the path. I think it depends on availability of asphalt, but it's coming together quite nicely, and I think it will be no more than a month to six weeks before people are on there.

1:09:21 Writing it regardless of what signage I placed there saying it's still a construction site. So it's exciting to see this one come together. We've been working on this for many years. And then just a whole bunch of other stuff that got going on. Like I said, we are still working on the roundabout, on the South Main Mupp, that gap closure project, the crosswalk. Nolan and I talked a little bit about some of the housing projects, the pump track, and then just tons of maintenance work.

1:09:52 That we anticipate happening on an annual basis. So, back to work, unless there's any questions about projects. Any questions for A's? No? Okay. Steamroll. So, the discussion, can the findings be made determined that the proposed five-year CIP is consistent with the general plan? So, what I provided in the staff report, as I usually do, is a CIP list, which is right out of the main page on the CIP.

1:10:21 And I, for every project on there, I tie it to a general plan goal or policy. And so what I'm asking is, did I do a good job and do those actually line up? And I need you to make those findings so that we can approve it at town council. And I'm not going to go through this because I know you can't read it, but this is all in the staff report. So all the findings, all the references.

1:10:51 And then is the proposed project consistent with CEQA? So I think that is it. Back to the recommendation. Unless you have any additional questions for me. Any additional questions for Hayes at this time? Jamie, is this a motion that needs to be made? Would anybody like to put forth a motion? I'm sorry, sorry. Any public comment? Any public comment via Zoom? I will close public comment. Any further discussion?

1:11:23 Or would somebody like to make a motion? I can make a motion to adopt the resolution finding the draft five-year CIP to be in conformance with the general plan. Do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Jamie, would we have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Incredibly impressive, Hayes. And Nolan as well, I know. You've got to.

1:11:54 Serious hand in the housing part of it all, but incredibly impressive. I can't tell you, when I first moved here, we didn't have sidewalks in this community, and it's just, it's so nice to see us evolving in a positive direction. Appreciate that. Thank you, sir. Hayes, before you run off, and while we have you here, and Nolan, can you guys address or say something regarding Jennifer Burrows' comment this morning?

1:12:25 What would Andy do bracelet? And I missed the, what was the question? What was the tail end of the question? Would you mind repeating your question? If they have any kind of comment regarding Jennifer Burroughs, comment this morning. Oh, got it, Jennifer Burroughs. Sure, so I can speak to the broader sign compliance effort, sign enforcement effort, then Hayes can speak to kind of the specifics on those signs. So just a point of order, because we're, this isn't an agenda. It's not agendized.

1:12:56 Do we have department updates? Director's report. Could we take, go out of order, move the director's report so then we can both speak on the item and then go back to the regular agenda? Yes. I'm fine with that. I think that's what Andy would say because this isn't on the agenda. Yeah. Good point of order. Thank you. So I think you need to... I would like to make a motion that we adjust today's agenda to move up the director's report.

1:13:27 We're doing it. Sure, so on that specific item, so that Brianna touched on it as well, we kicked off kind of a town-wide sign enforcement effort about two months ago, really targeting all the unpermitted and illegal signs in the community. Primarily that includes the sandwich board signs and banners.

1:13:57 It kind of ramps up every couple years where, you know, occasionally there'll be banners, A-frame signs, no issues with it, no complaints, but and Code Components operates purely on complaints, but as soon as Code Components gets a series of complaints on an issue, they have to then react and respond to those. And so the sign enforcement effort kind of stemmed from getting complaints from

1:14:25 Other business owners, other community members, usually it's, sometimes it's retaliatory, you know, one business upset about another business doing something, but regardless of the basis, they have to react. And in this case, it, you know, so he, Mike Marder, our co-compliance officer, went town-wide, provided notices to all those with the illegal signs, and then timeline to fix them. And it,

1:14:52 There wasn't, there's not really much discretion there. He doesn't have the ability to pick and choose what signs he, once we get complaints, what signs he's enforcing. So the Knoll or the Trails did, were notified that their signs were unpermitted and not allowed and they had to remove them. Part of it, I think, was a safety issue related to in the right of way and snow removal that Hayes can talk to. And so then that's kind of the,

1:15:22 The code side of that effort on those signs, and I'll let Hayes speak to that. Yeah, so when we're talking about signs in the public right-of-way, there are, as you suspect, in California, a significant number of rules that govern what we can and can't do. And when it comes to regulating traffic, there's a book called the California Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, which outlines what you can and cannot place in the roadway to direct traffic.

1:15:52 The signs that were posted not only in that neighborhood but other neighborhoods are not permitted in the public right-of-way. Furthermore, it's not the public's purview to place regulatory signage for drivers, right? You can't just post signs to direct traffic to do what you want them to do. That's not legal. It's heavily regulated and there's a lot of work that has to be done to change street signage.

1:16:20 So those signs had to come down. Children at Play signs are not in the California Manual and Uniform Traffic Control Devices sign chart. They're not permitted. And so those signs are not legal. On public right away. On public right away. Private land. I think there's some question there. And I don't think it's a straight answer. If that private area was designated for public use, I think it still applies. This is a legal question I would have to pose.

1:16:50 I can definitely speak to the public rights of way where the public works department has jurisdiction. Those signs are not permitted. They're also not permitted to put slow signs up. They're not permitted to put slow 15 mile per hour signs up. They don't have the authority to sign the right of way. It's no different than putting up a sign that says speed up, go 85, right? You just, you don't have that authority. This also applies to the little green men with the flag. It goes to little green men. That's an encroachment that's putting something in the public right of way.

1:17:19 While we understand the desire to do that, to encourage the public to slow down, we agree that would be great. There are ways that we have to go. There's pathways we would have to follow to get there. And so we're going to explore some of those with the trails and see if there's anything that can be done. Because we understand what they're trying to accomplish, but you can't do it illegally.

1:17:43 And it's no different than businesses putting signs, sandwich boards and so forth, all falls under the same set of regulations. So we'll try to find a solution there if there is one. Thank you, Hayes. I know like on the street I live on as well, we have quite a few families with children and especially being summer right now, they're all out and playing on the streets. And I, it's not that I see, I hear cars just rev.

1:18:12 Through like out like street that's filled with children like on regular basis and it's like somebody even with no children it just gives chills down my spine. I think it is something that I strongly feel should be really looked at in town because I feel like it's a matter of time before we'll all read something that we don't want to read in one of the...

1:18:40 Mammoth Police Publications. And, you know, like, is it possible to look at speed bumps on streets? Because I know they, those things definitely force people to slow down within even LA area and every other busy area. Is it something that we can look into? I think speed bumps would be, like, snow removal would be really tough.

1:19:09 Yeah, we look at traffic control across the board, and it's really difficult because of the snow removal efforts. You know, it really hinders what we can and can't do. Speeding is, it's not just the trails, it's not just the Knolls, it's not just any neighborhood. It's systemic in town. Most of the time, it's our own local population that's doing it in our local neighborhoods. I have kids.

1:19:34 This is much to my chagrin. They play in the street, even though I yell at them that it's not a playground. It's a street. It's for cars. It's not for playing. And, you know, parents are going to make their own decisions on what they're going to allow their children to do in the roadway. But as a community, it's really difficult to regulate some of these things and put up signage. And unfortunately, the rules regarding speed limits are incredibly complicated.

1:19:59 Difficult to navigate and oftentimes result in speed limits being increased. It's not subjective, you can't just go change signage, you have to follow a significant number of rules to modify speed limits and considering that most, and they're governed by the speeds at which people travel. So if everybody's speeding on a road and you go do a survey, the speed limit's going to increase, it's not going to go down. I don't think anybody wants that. So it's a really difficult situation for us to navigate.

1:20:27 Thank you, Hayes. Nolan, did you have anything else for Director's Report? I want to respect the Chief's time. We still have another agenda item that we've kind of skipped over. Yeah, nothing to update specifically. I can provide a brief update on a series of projects if any of you want to ask outside, but no specific updates since we last met.

1:20:51 Okay, so no progress on the Sierra Center Mall, the parking lot specifically, and the facade above the trash enclosure? Other than co-compliance, I know started their efforts on there, but I don't believe they've had any resolution or gone to the next step on that yet that I can report out on. But the process has begun? The process has begun there. We're also reaching out and trying to work with the...

1:21:19 Outpost on the status of their project, but nothing I can report out on as far as outcomes yet. Thank you. May I ask about the courtyard as far as the fencing, the construction fencing? The residence inn? The residence inn, sorry. Yes, I know we looked into whether fabric is required or not, and the code doesn't provide any specifics on whether that.

1:21:49 You know, can require the fabric fencing be weaved into that or not. It's up to them as the contractor on what fencing they got. We did have some successes working with them to remove some of the dirt that was stockpiled around the trees. I believe they're also in the process of doing that, as well as reinforcing their parking requirements, staging requirements, material storage requirements, trash, and some of the other.

1:22:18 And issues that have been ongoing there on Burner Street to try to just have a little bit less impact on the community there. How challenging is it to add that mesh within the fencing in the future for construction? As far as a requirement or to add it to there? Not to that, obviously, to this project, but in future projects because if things keep going, it's just...

1:22:45 It's, you know, constructions are, you know, it just mitigates a little bit of the dust, but it also helps aesthetically, it's not quite as. Yeah, I think we can definitely look into adding it as a standard condition of approval. I think that the gray area as to what projects require the fencing and don't require it, a lot of it's driven more by their insurance carriers than it is from the town's direction. All right.

1:23:12 Like, for example, we don't require fencing, you know, on like a single family home or even a lot of residential projects, but their insurance carriers, the developer typically will come and say you have to, you know, maintain fencing on the job site for security and safety. Okay. Thank you, Nolan. With that, we'll close the director's report. Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate it. I know you're a busy man.

1:23:40 We'll go back to business matters, and we've got agenda item 5.2, which is the general plan conformance determination for the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District acquisition of the property located at 40 Mountain Boulevard that is developed with a eight unit multifamily residential structure for the purpose of providing workforce housing for the fire district. And with that, we have the chief here as the applicant.

1:24:09 Do we kick off with the staff report first or do you want to go straight to the chief? I can provide a brief summary. I think that the title there did a really good job of summarizing what the fire district is hoping to achieve here. I will add it's admirable for any entity within the town to be pursuing providing workforce housing for their staff. So I think it's...

1:24:39 It's a good thing that the district here is able to do. Thank you, Nolan. With that, Chief, it's yours. Good morning, Alish Tamire, Fire Chief Mammoth Lakes, Fire Protection District. I'm obviously here to answer any questions you have in regards to this agenda item. I think it's relatively straightforward from that perspective, but there's a whole bunch of tangents that are probably worth discussing as well. So if you have any questions, let me know. I'll put out there that...

1:25:05 You know, it is relatively unique for a fire district to be providing housing, but you have a relatively unique fire district here and we have relatively unique constraints just in this region alone. We were running payroll yesterday, so I just took a quick look and the things that people don't always understand is we had 52 people that we paid this month, so that number fluctuates a little bit, but it's usually kind of in the 50 to 60 range and that's primarily based off the fact that we are still

1:25:34 It's relatively unique in California, but we're, you know, kind of on the edge of California here and pretty remote. We've got a, what's nationally considered a combination fire department in the sense that we only have eight full-time firefighters and the rest of them are part-time.

1:25:50 volunteer to a certain extent, and hold multiple other jobs in this community. And that's the basis for our response capacity. So the other number I looked up really quick was the PAC fire that we had, the PAC incident down in Crowley. We ended up actually putting 38 personnel on that, which really speaks to kind of the capacity of the system that we run today. I can tell you if we were running just eight.

1:26:16 Traditional Fire Department, there would be no way to do anything remotely close to that. So the safety of our community is essentially dependent on this part-time staff. If you've ever done any kind of SWOT analysis, you'll know that your biggest strength is always generally also your biggest weakness, you know, and we're very dependent on that part-time staff to keep this community safe. And, you know, that's why we've been working towards these measures. I started up the Wildland Program about four years ago now.

1:26:46 When I started it, we had four individuals that were living in their cars. Fortunately, we're moving away from that situation. But again, I think this is good from a public safety perspective, and I think it's also bigger under that umbrella that ultimately, you know, these aren't just your firefighters. The vast majority of them have other jobs and are providing services to, you know, keep this community moving. So they are your plumbers, your ski patrollers, your kind of, you know.

1:27:14 We're getting bartenders and everything else in this community and wholeheartedly, this is going to take, you know, the moves that we're making on the parcel and similar projects are fantastic and, you know, this is, but this takes a community effort to keep this community going in the direction we want. So, this is a step for us. Honestly, it was a little bit of a quicker move than we wanted on a second unit. We're actually being very slow and deliberate with our moves. A couple things on that, you know, we don't.

1:27:43 Move anyone out or evict anyone that's currently a tenant. So we keep them under their current leases, similar to what the hospital does, because we obviously recognize that it is hard to find housing in this place. And we're going to be moving our people in through attrition. The only firefighters, we did have a family that moved in temporarily when actually they had a structural fire in their residence and needed some housing temporarily. But because we're trying to build this right, we're going through and working with our association on

1:28:11 What that long-term program looks like. And currently we have one unit that had opened up that we're starting to basically clean up that we're going to have, you know, the first group moving into this fall, ideally. But again, for us it's kind of a strategic need and I think it fits well with what we're trying to do with our overall staffing model. Thank you, Chief. Any questions for either Nolan or the Chief on this matter?

1:28:44 Any public comment at this time? Anything on Zoom? The only question I have, maybe you can provide some clarification, Chief. You have a certain, the fire district has a certain requirement that your staff have to live within either a certain proximity or a response time, correct? Correct, yes. And so, legally speaking, you can never tell an employee that they have to live.

1:29:12 Within a certain area, but you can have a response requirement. So essentially all of our safety employees, which is everyone except for one individual, are required to live within seven minutes driving time of a fire station. So we don't say you have to live in Mammoth, but de facto you have to live within seven minutes driving time. And we do feel like that is a significant burden on our employees, and we feel like we have to balance that against supporting them.

1:29:42 Living here. And ultimately, you know, it really does create a really good system. We were incredibly busy this last weekend over Fourth of July and people don't appreciate, not by fault, but they just don't know what they have here. My brother-in-law is a firefighter for Beverly Hills. He lives down in San Diego. When he's off, he's off and you're not going to see him. We had...

1:30:05 calls on Monday where it was busy and our off-duty captains who are even full-time come in and help support those calls. So it really is a community fire department, which is, you know, a valuable thing for this place. Thank you for clarifying that, Chief. Well, if there's no further questions, would anybody like to put forth an amendment or a motion?

1:30:28 I put a motion forward to adopt the resolution finding the acquisition of Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District of the development multifamily residential property located at Forty Mountain Boulevard to be in conformance with the town's general plan. Do we have a second? I'll make a second. Any further conversation? Jamie, will we have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Just a quick note, it's incredibly admirable that you're doing this for your staff.

1:31:00 Like you said, the fact that you are a community-facing department and your staff are actual members of our community speaks volumes. We have other municipal agencies that maybe don't think that way. So it's great that you guys are embracing that. Thank you, Chief. All right, with that, we will go down to...

1:31:28 to the consent agenda. Unless there's any edits or changes, does anyone want to put forth a motion to approve the consent agenda from June 10, 2026? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 10, 2026. Do we have a second? Second. Jamie, maybe we have a vote, please.

1:31:53 Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes, 4-0. Commissioner Reports. I'll start on my left. Commissioner Grand, do you have a report you'd like to share with us? No, sir. Commissioner Verruck? No. Commissioner Fleming? No. No. I'll just say, I said earlier, the parade was amazing. It was such a great experience. Couldn't ask for better weather. Great energy. Well done to the chamber.

1:32:23 Really well done. So we've already heard the director's report. So I'm going to adjourn today's meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which will be held on Wednesday, August 12th, 9 a.m. in this meeting, in this room, I should say. And with that, I thank you for all your time. Thank you. Thank you.