Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2026
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
12 findings- Staff report: Woodsite site was bought in 2025 and an entitlement application was filed June 6, 2025 Planning and Zoning
- Two development resolutions require easements to MCWD for Well 17 access and for three monitoring wells Water and Utilities
- Woodsite is a 67-unit residential Planned Unit Development on about 7.7 acres at 5699 and 5781 Minaret Road Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The initial June 2025 submittal proposed 69 units and 279 rooms; June 2026 documents describe 67 units and 255 rooms Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- A June 2026 CEQA Addendum concludes the project would not result in any new significant environmental effects Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The Addendum lists a Town-approved Revegetation Plan and other vegetation measures; the site has 838 trees and 262 would be retained Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The Addendum lists a Waste Discharge Report to the Lahontan board at least 90 days before construction for projects of six or more dwelling units Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The Addendum lists a yearly October 15 deadline to stabilize disturbed areas Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- Project plans list 45 percent site coverage against a 60 percent maximum Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- Project plans show 168 parking spaces required and 221 provided Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The site was used for outdoor events, and an agreement filed with the April 19, 2017 meeting covered improvement funding there Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
- The Planning Commission heard District Zoning Amendment 14-001, which lists the Woodsite APNs, on July 23, 2014 and continued it to August 13, 2014 Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
Transcript
241 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:41 All right, everybody, I've got 9 a.m. on the note, on the dot. I don't know if you've ever noticed, but the Lutheran Church is always about a minute fast on the clock, so I would like to call to order this morning's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting Wednesday, June 10th at 9 a.m. With that, may we please have roll call. Commissioner Deaver is absent. Commissioner Fleming? Here. Commissioner Grand is absent. Vice Chair Verruck?
3:11 Here. Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you. Would everyone please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance? We'll give Commissioner Grand a quick moment here to jump in. Nolan, would you care to lead us, please? Thank you, Nolan.
3:50 With that, I will open up public comment. I will ask if anybody does have public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda, please hold off until that agenda item has been open. And with that, any other public comment that is not relevant to today's agenda? Do we have any staff presentations or public comment? We do not. We do not. Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Okay.
4:23 Then I will close public comment and we will open the public hearing. Matter 4.1, which is consideration of tentative tract map, 25002, use permit, 25001 and major design review, 25004 for the wood site project, a resort residential development consisting of 67 units proposed to be subdivided as a planned unit.
4:52 And just for the members of the public who may not have attended a PEDC meeting in the past, the way this will kind of unfold is first we will get a presentation from staff and then we'll come back to the commission for any questions that may arise from that presentation and then we will give the applicant an opportunity to make a statement if he so chooses.
5:17 And then we'll have some questions from the commission that might arise. And then we will open up to public comment. And everyone will be entitled to five minutes of public comment. So you will have a chance to express your opinions. Public comment is not Q&A. So if you do have questions for staff or the applicant, those questions will be noted and addressed after public comment is closed. Okay? Nolan, with that, I believe our staff contact on this is Kim.
5:47 That's correct. I do want to give a brief statement beforehand. In addition to Kim Cook, our senior planner, we also have here in attendance Kristen Bogue and Eddie Torres from Michael Baker. They're the town CQA consultants, so they prepared the addendum on this. They're here in attendance. We also have town attorney Andy Moores on Zoom. I'm going to believe Andy was going to make a brief statement as well. Sure, happy to.
6:15 So, hi everybody, my name is Andy Morris, I'm the town attorney, and as the commissioners know, there are certain findings that have to be made to either approve or deny a tentative map, but people in the audience, people watching online may not know this, so I'm just kind of saying this at the outset as a reminder for everybody. In general, a tentative map has to be approved.
6:37 If certain findings are made, and then it has to be denied if other findings are made, and I'll go through those in a second, but the PEDC's role is not to decide is this a good project, is it a bad project, it's not to decide do we like the project or not like the project, instead the PEDC's job is to decide whether these findings for approval or denial can be made. So the findings for approval include the map is consistent with the general plan.
7:04 The map is consistent with the specific plan if there is one. The project is consistent with zoning. The project has been adequately analyzed under CEQA. There's been an adequate environmental review. Findings for denial would be things like the project is not consistent with the general plan or it's not consistent with the specific plan or it's not consistent with zoning or
7:26 There hasn't been enough environmental review. And there are some more arcane and unusual ones, but those are the main ones. So again, it's not, is it a good project or a bad project? It's not, do we like the project or not like the project? It's really, can the findings for approval or the findings for denial be made? Thank you, Andy. Kim, do you want to jump in here or do we want to have some sort of a public comment from one of the consultants?
7:58 Nope. We will jump right into Kim's presentation and then follow along with the normal process. Perfect. Kim? All right. Thank you, Chair and Commissioners. Good morning. Today I'll be presenting the Woodside Entitlement Application for Commission's Consideration. This application includes tentative tract map 25-002.
8:30 For the proposed subdivision of the property, use permit 25-001, which is required for subdivisions, including condominium subdivisions and planned unit developments within the North Village specific plan area. And finally, a major design review application 25-004.
8:57 The site consists of two vacant parcels with a combined area of approximately 7.7 acres. There was a previous, during ADP, previous maps showed that the site areas were 7.27 acres, which was based upon the parcel map information provided by the assessor's office, but the most recent surveyed maps that were provided by the applicant show 7.7 acres, so that change was made.
9:27 The property is located on the west side of Minaret Road, approximately 450 feet south of the intersection with Main Street and Minaret Road. The property is forested with gradual sloping topography and the site is within the North Village specific plan area. It's specifically zoned for specialty lodging.
9:49 And the zoning district allows the lowest density and the least intensive land uses within the North Village. This zoning designation really functions more as a transition zone between the high activity core areas of the North Village specific plan and the surrounding residential neighborhoods. The project site is located again at the South Whip.
10:13 Southwest edge of the North Village Specific Plan area. Adjacent land uses include a municipal water well parcel that's owned by MCWD. This parcel is situated near the center of the project's frontage along Minaret Road. To the north of the site, the site is bordered by several parcels that are designated as being within the Mammoth Crossing site number two.
10:41 Also sharing a northern border with the site is the Hidden Valley Village Condominiums Complex. We have a single-family residential subdivision located immediately west of the property and the Lodestar Golf Course property borders the site's southern boundary. To the east across Minaret Road, the Stonegate Condominiums Development.
11:09 is located, bordered by two vacant parcels, one is located in the resort zone for the Lodestar Master Plan on the north end, and then the south vacant parcel is zoned SL and is within the north village specific plan. So a little site background, the project site has historically been used as an outdoor event venue.
11:36 Hosting activities such as the Bluesapalooza Festival, the Labor Day Festival, and events like Shakespeare in the Woods. While this property has never been entitled for a development project, a design review application was processed in 2018 for a permanent ticket booth and related site improvements. However, those improvements were never constructed.
11:59 Then in 2025, the property was purchased by the same developer responsible for the Rock Spring Project, the Reserve at Obsidian and the Obsidian Phase 2 Project. The ownership entity is operating under Crestwood Mammoth LLC and this entity submitted the wood site entitlement application on June 6, 2025. So to go through
12:28 Sort of the application timeline and application process to date. The application review process began in June 2025. An image from the original plan set is shown in the upper right hand corner. This is for comparison kind of how the sites evolved over this past year. The original plan set was routed by staff to internal town departments as well as the fire district and Mammoth Community Water District.
12:58 This is intended to allow for technical review and for town departments and those agencies to provide comments that might require revisions to the project design. Then within 30 days of receiving the application, staff provides the applicant with a completeness review letter and initial consistency comments. The second step is when the applicant then submits revised plans that are responding to those initial comments.
13:28 If the revisions adequately address the identified issues, the application is deemed complete. And at that point, staff will generally schedule a meeting for the application to be reviewed by the advisory design panel. And the advisory design panel process is, it can be more than one meeting.
13:57 And in this case, we did have two formal ADP meetings. Between those meetings, we had revised plan sets that were reviewed electronically, and ultimately, ADP requested that we have a second in-person notice meeting so that we could evaluate the project further as a group. And ADP review is required before PEDC considers a major project application.
14:26 And that is the step we are at today. So the first advisory design panel meeting was held on October 15, 2025. The ADP requested significant design refinements, including revised triplex roof forms, additional stone siding, upgraded ground level materials and better preservation of existing trees and site topography.
14:59 The applicant team responded with updated architecture, updated siding materials including replacement of fiber cement siding material where it previously met the ground. Expanded tree preservation measures were shown on civil plans and site plans. 3D grading visuals were provided to help illustrate the extent of grading and the grading design.
15:28 An updated tree removal plan was provided. Elements that were included in response to comments included site functionality improvements, including a larger dumpster enclosure and relocating the primary driveway to the south end of the site to reduce fill and grading for roadway purposes that were previously proposed at the north end of the project. The second advisory design panel meeting
16:00 The revised set of plans was presented and ADP found that major design concerns regarding building massing, articulation and staggered forms along Minaret Road were still not adequately addressed. The triplex buildings in particular were viewed as bulky and insufficiently varied. ADP wanted to emphasize stronger tree preservation efforts being incorporated into the site design.
16:30 One of the recommendations including specifically tagging and monitoring methods for tree preservation. The ADP also recommended a more forested entry transition from Minaret Road and a greater commitment to retaining significant existing trees.
16:51 In response to those comments, the applicant team reduced the project density from 69 residential units to 67 units. This was done by replacing two triplex buildings with two duplex buildings along the Minaret Road frontage. And the setbacks were increased in certain areas where the project applicant added a smaller duplex.
17:18 Variation. This is labeled Variation C in the PEDC packets. And this rearrangement preserved the site's largest tree, which is a 60-inch diameter at breast height fir tree located near the property frontage along Minaret Road. So now the commission is being asked to consider the current final proposed project.
17:51 which consists of 67 residential units. These are proposed to be subdivided as a planned unit development, also known as a PUD, on the approximately 7.7 acre site. The unit mix includes 26 duplexes, four triplexes, and three single family residences, with all units designed as three story structures featuring private garages.
18:18 One two-story amenity building is also proposed. This building features a gym with a sauna and steam room, a lounge area, storage space and exterior barbecue facilities intended to serve residents and visitors of the development.
18:37 The single family units, all units are fairly large. Single family units are approximately 3,469 square feet of living area. This excludes an approximately 915 square foot three car garage. The duplex units are approximately 2,800 square feet each, which excludes an approximately 623 square foot two car garage. And the triplex units are approximately 2,244 square feet.
19:06 Excluding an approximately 541 square foot two car garage. The proposed amenity building is 2,802 square feet in size and is served by seven exterior guest parking spaces.
19:25 The proposed landscape plan and tree preservation plans for the site were prepared in conjunction with an arborist report, which was required to document all of the trees on site and proposed tree preservation. This plan identified 383 trees present on the site with 580 Geoffrey Pine.
19:49 80 Lodgepole Pine, 2 Quaking Aspen, 151 Red Fur, and 25 White Fur. The report states that 582 trees will be removed from the site, while 256 trees will be retained. The landscape plan proposes to preserve, sorry, the landscape plan proposes to plant 233 new native variety trees.
20:18 Including Aspen and Mountain Maple. These are low fire hazard varieties, which is the reason they are proposed throughout the site. 43 Jeffrey Pines are also proposed in areas that are located further from structures due to the higher fire hazard rating for that variety of tree. Staff included two conditions of approval that were specific to the tree preservation requirements for the project.
20:46 This includes condition of approval number three and number 34. Generally, these requirements require a program of specific tree protection measures that shall be prepared by the developer and submitted to the town for review and approval prior to the issuance of any construction or grading permits. All trees designated for preservation on the civil plan sheets and landscape plan.
21:12 Shall be physically tagged on site with an identification number that corresponds to the location information and tree numbering shown on an updated civil plan set sheet. This allows for ongoing monitoring throughout construction. Tree preservation measures may include a combination of construction fencing, tree protection fencing, grading controls, and grading design adjustments.
21:40 And tree protection measures shall be placed prior to tree removal at the site. Preserved trees shall not be marked with spray paint. Condition number 34 sort of reiterate some of that requirement regarding the tree tagging, but it also included a provision that the approved tree protection measures shall be installed and verified by town staff before any construction activity begins and any violation of the approved tree protection measures including removal or disturbance.
22:10 of required tree protection fencing shall result in the issuance of a stop work order. These were included to ensure that the tree protection measures are taken seriously throughout the project construction. So consistency with the North Village specific plan design standards. The project is consistent with all of the applicable zoning requirements of the North Village specific plan.
22:41 I would like to point out that the table provided in the staff report, there are a few development standards that I'd like to highlight. The first one is the project density. The project density is below the maximum allowed density of 370 rooms. It's under that allowable density by 115 rooms. The density...
23:07 Based on residential units is equal to nine units per acre, which is less than 12 units per acre, which is the allowable density within the town's RMF1 and RMF2 zoning districts. So the proposed density is very comparable to our other multifamily zones within the town. Also the building height measurement within the north village is a little bit different.
23:38 40 feet is the maximum building height within the specialty lodging zone. A maximum projected height of 50 feet is allowed. That has not been used for this project. But the NBSP states that when all or a portion of the building sits above a parking garage, building height is measured from the garage roof elevation at the perimeter of the building. Parking garages shall be no more than 20 feet in height at any point. And this is from
24:08 Page 39 of the North Village Specific Plan. The tallest proposed structure within the unit mix is 42 feet and 2.75 inches to the highest roof ridgeline. When we subtract 9 feet to account for the garage ceiling height, we get a building height of 33 feet 2.75 inches. So the proposed building heights do meet the standard maximum height allowance.
24:37 And finally, the project does not propose any variances or adjustments from the standards. I did also just want to highlight the parking layout for the project. The proposed parking exceeds the required parking standards applicable to the project site. In the table, the applicable standard for single-family, multifamily, and transient uses, which provide private garages in North Village, is three spaces per unit.
25:10 with a minimum of one space enclosed and one space unenclosed. It also states that driveways may be used for parking if minimum dimensions of 10 feet by 20 feet are provided. All of the units meet the standard. The single family residential units exceed the standard by providing three enclosed spaces and one unenclosed space. Guest parking is required at the discretion of the review authority.
25:40 The standard states that additional parking may be required if on-street parking is not available. The proposed guest parking includes seven uncovered parking spaces that are adjacent to the amenity building and staff's feeling is that that is adequate to serve the project based on the individual garages for each unit. Another development, hi.
26:13 that I would like to highlight is the snow storage plan. The snow storage areas provided on the site meet the minimum municipal code standard for residential uses. This requirement is, the requirement states that a minimum of 75% of all required uncovered driveway and parking areas be provided on site for snow storage area.
26:41 That is what is provided according to this site plan. The engineering division has reviewed the snow storage areas and will require some revisions to certain areas where fire hydrants are going to be placed to ensure that snow storage areas are not overlapping with fire hydrant locations and there is adequate room on the site to make those adjustments.
27:13 So we have received three written public comments prior to this hearing. The first letter is from a representative from the Hidden Valley Village condominiums. The primary concerns that were outlined in that comment letter include potential impacts to sewage, drainage, and water infrastructure, concerns about proposed variances, potential impacts
27:42 Potential cumulative impacts of recent regional growth, onsite parking and snow management, and payment of housing in Luffy versus providing affordable units. A second comment letter was received yesterday evening. It has been distributed to the commissioners and the commenter is present today and will be providing remarks directly. The third letter is from
28:09 The property owner of a narrow strip of land that is located just north of the site. It is designated in the Mammoth Crossing, in the Mammoth Crossing Zone. And the concerns that were presented in that comment letter really included questions about location of grading and retaining walls. How will the project's grading plans alter the topography along my property line? Setbacks and buffers.
28:40 The property owner wants to ensure that all structural and landscape setbacks are strictly measured from the true legal boundaries, leaving an appropriate buffer that respects my parcels configuration. There was a comment about utility easements and snow storage and snow shedding. This particular property is located, I think, over 220 feet from the nearest structure to the south.
29:10 And the area between this particular property and the construction on the site is left undisturbed. So it's very unlikely that this property will be impacted by the proposed construction on the site. I believe that letter was forwarded to all of the commissioners and included in the record. The proposed housing mitigation for the project is
29:41 proposed to be satisfied by adhering to the housing mitigation requirements in the municipal code ordinance. This requirement is currently a fee of $8,905 per unit. That would mean that the total housing mitigation fee required under the current fee schedule is $596,635. The applicant
30:11 would be required to pay the housing impact mitigation fee at the time of building permit issuance. My understanding is that the fee is expected to increase in July based on CPI increases and that would increase to $9,252 per unit. So staff have prepared affirmative findings for approval of this project. The findings are provided in the PEDC resolution.
30:46 A separate set of findings is provided for each permit type and includes required findings of the project is consistent with CEQA. The CEQA conformance review included the preparation of an addendum to the North Village specific plan supplemental program environmental impact report. This was included as an attachment in the PEDC packet. The environmental analysis presented in the CEQA addendum supports the conclusion
31:20 So, with that, staff,
31:57 is recommending the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving tentative tract map 25-002, use permit 25-001, and major design review 25-004 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Thank you, Kim. You're welcome.
32:27 Nolan, any other staff presentations? Not at this time. Okay. Then I'll bring it back to the commission. Any questions for staff from the commission at this time? No? Commissioner Fleming? No? Then I'll ask the applicant if he'd like to make a presentation or a statement at this time? Please. We're running through the presentation on Zoom, so hopefully you guys can see it. Yep. I just wanted to, you know, before we get started with that,
33:02 Acknowledge and thank staff and the commission for your consideration. Staff's been great. We've been working on this for over a year. We've had a lot of iterations and feel like we've, you know, done as good as we can to get to the point that we are at and it's, you know, a testament to staff and ADP. I mean, they've been really collaborative throughout the whole process. So with that, Porva, can you pull up the presentation? This is Porva Gard. She's head of our development division and she's going to kind of
33:32 Run through. We won't spend too much time kind of going through the same technical details that staff went through, but we'll maybe kind of give a high level and then key in on some things that maybe weren't as fully articulated by staff. Can everyone see my screen? Yeah, we've got it. Thank you. Okay. Just let me know where you'd like to start. Where we start, yeah. Starting off with project. So this is a rendering of what's, a view of what's being preserved with zero additional planting.
34:13 at this point, just to give some perspective. And then if you could flip to the other view, this is the view with the planting, so with the additional landscaping that we intend to do. You can go to the next slide. That's a view of it, unplanted. From Mineraline. From Mineraline. And then this is with the additional plants or trees being put in. It's just an aerial view comparison of
34:54 What's there now and what's there based on what's being preserved with no additional landscaping. Different drone shots to see the project with different perspectives. Mark, would you like to stay on one of the renderings or move to the site plan? I'm going to start moving through the site plan. So the site plan incorporates the buffer, the 20-foot buffer required by the EIR. Maybe you can walk through and zoom in on the setbacks.
35:52 And then go to the slide that shows the distances from the different properties because I think some of that would be helpful. Yeah, yeah. And, you know, let me just start with saying that thank you, Kim, for the thorough presentation. You know, our project, as we've gone through different iterations with staff and ADP, we've tried to do our best to incorporate all the feedback to make the project better in every version.
36:19 We put a lot of thought on how we address Minaret Road. And, you know, the project has consistently gotten better on how you view it from the street, you know, as you drive by or you're biking by. Every single building along Minaret is different from the next one, so it's not overwhelming. They have different roof lines, different pallets for their exterior.
36:46 And our landscape consultant has put a lot of thought in how to plant trees along Minaret to kind of keep that facade the least overwhelming we could. And obviously, like Kim mentioned, we maintained one of the largest trees on site along Minaret as well. Let me jump to the setbacks. From Minaret Road, we've
37:14 I think the shortest setback that we have is about 42 feet and it only gets more from there. We've pushed out buildings further into the site as much as possible, even if that meant putting in stronger foundation walls, taller foundation walls to maintain as many trees as we could, definitely in the setback, but beyond the setback too. Yep, that's about our minaret. Anything else you want to add, Mark?
37:45 No, maybe you can kind of zoom in too on the buffer. And I think in this view you can kind of see a perspective of the property across the street and to give some perspective of how far those units are away from the road relative to ours. Go back to the second and zoom in on other areas. So where we added the small duplexes, the variant type C.
38:15 We've increased the buffer from the residential units in the back to a minimum of 34 feet, 30 to 34 feet from the property line. So it would be a little bit more, you know, from where the property, the neighbors would start. Yeah, and we've also kept the setbacks in general with no disturbance, no grading. So again, to maintain every tree that we could.
38:47 And I think that brings us back to that we've maintained the project with the NVSP guidelines and the cultural resources that were identified in the 1999 SPIR. You know, that report concluded that the project that would be ever built on this site if it met the mitigation measures.
39:18 It would not have a significant impact. We think we've met all the mitigation measures and we put a lot of effort into meeting them. So, you know, we're in compliance with the design guidelines and the EIR to where the project sits today. And I think we've addressed ADP concerns as well through different iterations over the past year.
39:48 And then maybe Catherine can talk a little bit about the landscape plan. Yeah. This is just a slide showing the areas that were pretty much not touching to maintain trees. Very, very low grading. Only if there's a road access or there's some type of drainage system. Other than that, there's no grading in these areas around the property. I'll just...
40:18 Be on the screen for a second. The parking that Kim already touched on. I'd just like to add that there is additional guest parking on all driveways. So in addition to what we have by the community building. We have some site sections. These were included in the package. So if anybody has questions, we can come back to these. And then I will let Catherine, our landscape architect, jump in and talk about the landscape. Hey, everyone.
40:51 Catherine Widman with Place. So the landscape plan has been designed to preserve the alpine character of the site while strengthening the existing forested setting through native and regionally appropriate plantings. As Kim mentioned, over 250 trees will be preserved and one of those is a 60-inch diameter tree near Minaret.
41:19 and five trees that have 40 inches or greater diameter. The proposed landscape incorporates Jeffrey Pines, Quaking Aspens, Mountain Maples, and a diverse palette of low to moderate water use species to create a resilient landscape that complements the surrounding Mammoth Lakes environment. More than 230 new trees will be introduced throughout the development.
41:47 Enhancing visual screening, open space character, and long-term site sustainability. Next slide, please. Along Minaret Road, a buffer of 46 conifers have been preserved, along with 20 in the right-of-way. The project adds 31 Jeffrey Pines and 46 Aspens to further increase the density of the buffer. So we're only talking about the front perimeter right now.
42:16 In this, the sort of more gray blue colored trees are the existing trees and then more yellow kind of limey colored trees are the additional trees. Next slide, please. Along Minaret Road, sorry, this is a fuel modification plan and it's illustrating what Kim mentioned. This is illustrating the distances from structures.
42:46 So you've got lines at 5 feet from the structure, 15 feet from the structure, and 30 feet from the structure. And these help determine the characteristics of the vegetation that we're proposing for different areas. For example, as Kim said, we've done our best to not plant any Jeffrey pines within 30 feet of the structure. And if, you know, there's a handful that are planted, you know, we've kept them at least 15 feet away.
43:16 In contrast, aspens are posing a lower fire risk, and so that's why you'll see a lot of aspens throughout the development closer to the structures. All right, next slide please. This plan shows how plants with similar watering needs are grouped together into hydro zones to reduce water use by watering to each zone's specific needs. An automatic irrigation system will be used to maximize the irrigation efficiency.
43:47 This diagram is informed by the fuel modification plan. So plants that require more water are the moderate, you know, the moderate water use plants are located closer to the structures. This is still at the concept level, but very generally speaking, those plants would pose a lower fire risk. And so the lower water use plants are pushed more towards the perimeter. Next slide, please.
44:18 So we've worked with this developer on a couple of other projects in the past, and this project has got by far the most robust landscaping. The team has spent a lot of time already talking about landscape priorities and how we're going to manage the landscape, and so we're going to continue that throughout our permitting process.
44:44 So these would be the plants,
45:14 that are located along the front perimeter. They are mostly shorter plants. That's another part of the fuel modification sort of fire reduction idea is to not create fire ladders by having large shrubs under trees. And so we do have
45:36 A few larger shrubs in this, but a lot of the planting will be lower, and we're focusing on a lot of different green textures, just with some pops of color. Next slide. These are a couple of possible palettes for front yards. So again, these are pretty close to the structures, and so they'll be lower, shorter planting. And you can see on the left, we've got this sort of white, elegant palette.
46:08 So you would have this sort of lower carpet and then just some little spikes of fun flowers. And then on the right, we've got a similar concept with the greens and then some pops of color. Next slide, please. So this, these are two palettes. The bottom one would be the side yards in between the houses. So these like really kind of more
46:37 Next slide, please.
47:10 And then for the side and rear perimeters, again, we're bringing that green carpet back and then with some shrubs where we can provide additional screening. And you've got those same three trees without the Jeffrey Pine, the Mountain Maple and the Quaking Aspen. Thank you, Catherine. That's the end of four slides. Anything you want to add? The only other thing which is anecdotal, but I know that we get a lot of comments about housing mitigation and
47:42 affordable housing. And one thing that we've already done is we've acquired a large parcel and we're in the preliminary stages of design and it's 100% workforce housing. So as a developer, I mean, it is something that we are conscious of and so we wanted to just share that with you and hopefully over the next few months we'll be able to present some more details about that. But other than that, I appreciate your time and your consideration. Thanks. Thank you.
48:11 Any questions for the applicant from the commission at this time? Can you give us a little more information on the affordable housing project? I mean, it'll be, you know, our goal is to do 100 plus units. Okay, because I think it's painful for us to sit here and see what you're paying, you know, towards affordable housing, but on the flip side, you are trying to do the right thing, I suppose, right, with this? Yeah, I mean, it's, you know, we're essentially local here. Most of my staff lives here. We're trying to...
48:44 Basically solve for the same problem that we're all dealing with as business owners in town, which is housing labor and, you know, having a nice place for them to live that they can afford. So, yeah, the project itself is, I mean, we're targeting the kind of missing middle. You know, we're focused. It's somewhere going to be between 80 and a 120 AMI project. And where is that located? Can you tell us or no? Well, it's, yeah, near the union.
49:15 Okay. Thank you. And that would be above and beyond the in-lieu. That has nothing to do with the in-lieu. We're not doing this as part of our in-lieu. It's something that we are electing to do because it's important for our businesses just like everybody else is. I mean, it's good for the community, but what's good for the community is usually good for the business owners in town. Thank you. Any other questions for the applicant, Commissioner Grant?
49:39 Yes, I have a question regarding the trees and the landscaping, please. So we're losing over 500 native trees, but obviously, you know, we're gaining several. Out of the 500 that we're losing, how many are Jeffrey Pine, which, you know, like my biggest concern after the last year of Fire Chief presentation and Mammoth being classified as...
50:08 All high fire danger zone area. So to me, fire mitigation is probably forefront of my concerns. And from my understanding, Jeffrey Pine is extremely fire hazard vegetation. So out of what we're losing to what we're gaining, out of 500 trees that we're losing, I'm assuming almost all of them are Jeffrey Pine.
50:39 I believe so. Catherine, can you confirm that? I think there was a slide that Kim had actually in hers that distributed it. I think the majority of it. That showed the distribution. It's Jeffrey Pines and white and red furs are the majority of the ones that we're losing. And so is what we're gaining going to create us bigger and better?
51:12 Fire prevention, is that correct? Yeah, we, I mean, that was the big consideration, is trying to create a more thoughtful approach based on the new climate reality we have with fire here. So, trying not to create fire ladders, and then, you know, we're trying to thread the needle, too, because we're in a mountain community, we want to, you know, as a developer, trees are good for, they look good, they help projects out, people want them, and then when we remove them, we have to pay to plant new ones. So, tree preservation is obviously,
51:41 The interests are in alignment with everybody who wants to preserve them, but on the other end of it, we've got insurability issues, right? We don't want to put somebody in hardship in two years from now because they can't get insurance and they're going to have to cut a bunch of trees down to make that work. So we're trying to meet the requirements of preservation from the 90s EIR and on the other end of it, trying to navigate how do we do it responsibly.
52:06 We can mitigate the fire hazard. So there is definitely, and Catherine pulled this slide up where there's, you know, we were looking at defensible space around the units and trying to make sure that we navigated that to, you know, mitigate the fire hazard as much as possible. So vegetation that we're getting instead of the trees that we're losing is going to give us a lot better fire protection, correct? Yeah, we planted new Jeffrey pines in areas that are further away from structures.
52:33 And as we get closer to the structure, the species change to aspens and then really low fire risk shrubs. Commissioner Grand, I can answer your question. So the Jeffrey Pines are the majority of the trees that are going to be removed. 410 are Jeffrey Pines out of the 582 trees that are to be removed. So they're the significant majority. Great. Thank you so much, Kim.
53:03 Any other questions for the applicant at this time? Commissioner Baruch? No. Thank you, sir. I see we have representatives from the Water District and the Fire Department. Would either you gentlemen care to make a statement? Okay, thank you. Appreciate your attendance. With that, I will open it up to public comment. Please come up to the podium if you would like to submit public comment. And Jamie, you've got the shot clock.
53:37 Five minutes, please. Please, sir. Before the clock starts, can I ask a question about the timing? What is the question on timing? Generally, public comment is not Q&A. I understand. The proponent was given 20 minutes and the ability to show presentations. I requested to show a presentation. It was denied that. And I think that opponents or people with concerns ought to have equal time. And so I'm hoping it's not a hard shot clock.
54:12 And that there's some flexibility where opponents are given similar time to address the development as the proponents are. Appreciate the concern. So first of all, thank you for allowing me to have a say to the commission, to the staff. I think you've done a great job. Kimberly's done a wonderful job keeping us informed of the development, to the design team also. I think that they've provided very good documentation to allow us to review the proposal.
54:45 But I do have some concerns. My name is Scott Strom. I live at 188 Hidden Valley Road. It is one of the six units that's on the west property line of the development. And I've been there for seven years, was aware of the future development when we bought the property, but was also aware of the zoning standards and criteria meant to protect what we're going to do there. So I am a builder and I am
55:14 for a responsible development, but I think that responsible development needs to be aligned, as was mentioned with the general plan, the North Village specific plan, and the EIR, and I believe that the current wood site development does not meet those elements. My primary concern is that we are not maintaining the forest nature throughout the site, and we're not maintaining the natural character of the site.
55:42 I also have a concern about a misapplied density criteria, but it is in a specific plan. It seems to be written around hotels and lodging units by doing it on rooms. And what it does is it allows a development to add square footage for rooms that aren't counted living rooms, kitchens, et cetera. And I think that it leads to an increased density and coverage on the property that is hard to mitigate. And I think that the plan right now
56:09 It dominates the site, and it's not subordinate to the natural character of the site. And those two terms are very critical in this EIR and the North Village Specific Plan. It specifically states that the development will be subordinate to maintaining that character, which includes maintaining a pine forest, essentially, which is the natural character of that site. If we look at the general plan,
56:34 It speaks to maintaining that natural environment and existing tree coverage. Basically, that there's a development in housing units under the canopies of trees. We don't think that that's happening in the center of the site. It's not nestled in. I think that the North Village specific plan, also, we recognize that it sets up some flexibility on that to create an urban center.
56:59 But as it was mentioned, there's a transition zone that's also mentioned there to transition with the residential area. I like the fact that these are units, and that's a better transition than a tall hotel, so I do commend the developer for that. But the criteria that needs to be met is not just to meet the height, not just meet the coverage and not meet the density, to maintain that natural characteristic of the site.
57:25 I think the EIR restates a lot of those similar ones, but even puts additional criteria to it. I'm just going to mention a couple. We've talked about retaining trees. I'm going to address it from a quantity and a protection side. 71% of the trees are being cut down on this site. And if you draw a bubble around the area that's being doubled, in other words, ignore the setback area, five out of six existing trees are being cut down. Five out of six.
57:53 That doesn't sound like someone who's nestling a site or a development into the site. That sounds like someone who's bulldozing down the trees and making room for a denser environment of units. That shouldn't be allowed. This is the wood site. It's given a lot to this community. All I'm asking is that we honor the plan. We honor the planning criteria that's actually written very, very well and make the development move the units if it...
58:22 In respect to the development versus removing the trees. I had some pictures that show what that visual impact looks like. I believe they're going to be posted online that you can see, just not able to show them today. In general, the conclusion is I hope that the commission denies this application and asked the developer to redevelop it.
58:51 With more respect to the existing character of the site, an aspen grove is not a pine forest, okay? I understand the fire challenges there, but I know that site. There are, there's two aspen trees on the southwest corner, I think, southeast corner of it, that look like they maybe grew when they, when they built Minaret Road. There are none in that area. They're not going to survive, not under the canopy of those trees.
59:18 We're going to have a horrible donut of a site with trees around the perimeter and nothing in the middle. Over 500 trees cut down within the middle of that site. The only ones that are really being retained are along the perimeter. And if we don't deny it and they don't want to move forward with redeveloping, I would suggest that we modify
59:39 And they go through an amendment process on the North Village specific plan to address the new fire concerns and some of the wildlife issues and things like that and go through the formal process of getting approval under a modified plan. Last comment, we haven't addressed wildlife. I think some of the criteria there is 26 years old. I have a camera in the back of my property. There's between 200 and 300 deer and bear that travel through that site as a habitat on an annual basis.
1:00:08 Which is really nine months out of the year because they don't travel in the winter. And I'm not certain that we've done the proper mitigation to take a look at that. Appreciate the additional time from the commission. Thank you. Of course. Thank you, sir. And just to acknowledge we did get your PowerPoint presentation and we had a chance to look it over. Great. Thank you so much. Yeah. Thank you for the time. Any other public comment? Please, sir. My name is Ryan. I am a business owner here in town. I've been here about 13 years.
1:00:41 And my biggest concern with most of the projects in town is housing. So I am kind of the missing middle, as he was stating earlier, the low income housing is unattainable for anyone that is employed. It just, even I have barely any income, my wife works full time just for the resort, doesn't make very much and we don't qualify for the housing. So my generation trying to purchase a house in this town is very difficult and more housing.
1:01:10 In any capacity, as far as I'm concerned, is good for the town, because it's going to hurt Airbnb and open up more long-term housing from certain areas. So my biggest thing is, I don't know why we don't see more development. I'm excited to see more development, especially in the village area, because as far as I'm concerned, that's kind of the hub of town, and that's kind of where the most density should be. So I feel like the outlier, I'm kind of a...
1:01:36 Positive force here. I just kind of wanted to make sure that we are developing and are kind of growing the town. Any rooms are good in my book. That's it. Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. Any other public comment in person from Suite Z? Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Yes. Ms. Wheeler, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. My name is Ruth Wheeler.
1:02:10 And I live at 131 Hidden Valley Village on 153 Lake Mary Road. I back up right to this project. I want to thank the developers for putting fewer rooms than they were allowed. I have concerns about the following things. One is a height concern.
1:02:40 You know, when they're saying the height is 33 feet, when I looked at the grading plan, they were increasing the grading to 10 feet at the side of the property that borders Hidden Valley Village. And I noticed none of the presentation addressed that strip. So I'm hoping that that grading is part of the plan that was eliminated and those houses are not up 10 feet.
1:03:09 and then up another 20 feet from the garage and then up another 50 feet that is allowed. So the actual height versus what is being presented confuses me a bit. I'm concerned about water usage. All of the, like the aspens and things that they're planting there don't typically grow in that setting so they're going to take a lot of water. And then most importantly,
1:03:38 I believe that the neighborhoods of Hidden Valley Village condos and Hidden Valley Road homes will need to request a presumptive easement based on the need to access a sewer main manhole that serves the servient properties as well as the open and notorious use of a pedestrian path and snow storage in the area.
1:04:05 There's a regular path, a bordered path with rocks that comes down from building H of the Hidden Valley condos and it comes down into the wood side and then it progresses over to Minaret Road. It serves pedestrian use and keeps people from driving around. That needs to be an easement.
1:04:30 for access to and from Hidden Valley condos. It's a traditional use. Also a traditional use is a snow storage. Hidden Valley has always, since I've owned there since 1987, so we're talking 40 years, has always used that space between buildings G and H.
1:04:55 of the Hidden Valley property as snow storage and it trickles down to what is now buildings 1, 2, 3, and 4 of the property. So those are my concerns. The main thing is the sewer main which is located behind buildings 9, 10, 11, and 12. That sewer main
1:05:22 Has to be accessed, and to access that you have, or to use, to do repairs or maintenance on it, it needs a small backhoe. That sewer main is totally blocked off by buildings 9, 10, 11, and 12 on the property. I don't know how, and I know you've got water district people there, I don't know how they're going to get to that sewer main anymore.
1:05:50 And so I think that needs to be an easement. There's a few easements that are needed with this project. Thank you for your time. Thank you, ma'am. Appreciate it. Nolan, I think there was a couple of questions there. Did you guys take note of a few of them? We did. Okay, thank you. Ma'am, we'll address your questions when public comment is closed. No more public comment via Zoom. Last chance from folks in attendance if you'd like to submit some public comment.
1:06:20 We are here and would love to hear. Garrett, would you care to address some of the concerns the lady raised with the easement and sewer access? Sorry to put you on the spot. Yes, Garrett Heigert, I'm the district engineer with Mammoth Community Water District. And yes, there are several...
1:06:49 things happening with this project and with the surrounding properties. There is a sewer main that is primarily on the adjacent property to the west and then to the northwest of the site. It's been there for a long time. There are easements on those properties for those that do have access.
1:07:18 to that sewer main. But yes, there are some water and sewer easements that will be required, and there are map conditions that address that in the package that's before you today. So we will continue to make sure that through the permitting process with
1:07:44 permits for water and sewer infrastructure that the remainder of the easements that are required are indeed granted to serve this project. Thank you. Before you leave, Garrett, any questions for Garrett? I do have a question. So I know that there is currently one well on site. Is that correct?
1:08:09 There's a well, yeah, to clarify, it's not on this property, but Mammoth Community Water District has a small parcel that's adjacent to Minaret Road, a small-ish parcel, and on that parcel is one of our production wells that serves groundwater to the community. It's a very important well. It provides, at certain times, it is...
1:08:38 provides a very large amount of the community's water supply, so it's very important to us and it's important to the community. So what we have added, requested in your packet is a map condition unique to that well and that site.
1:09:01 And our main interests are that we make sure we maintain separation from that production well from certain types of activities on the site that are prohibited by the Environmental Health Department. These are things like sewer manholes. You can't have sewer manholes in close proximity to a production well. All of these
1:09:30 Separations are exactly what you would expect to prevent risk of future contamination of that production well. So what we have requested and what's in there is an easement that would document where these separations are and where they extend on the site. The developer has moved a couple of
1:09:57 Things that we were concerned about outside of those perimeters. They moved around some sewer manholes to get outside and then also they moved the location of one of the stormwater infiltration basins to move that outside of the zone around the well. So that's good.
1:10:22 The other thing we want to also make sure is that, you know, the production well, it does require maintenance. Maintenance is a regular thing. We're not there maintaining it all the time, but from time to time, we do need to bring equipment onto the site to be able to pull the well. What that looks like is usually basically a
1:10:49 A type of equipment that looks like a crane to some extent, right? And they'll be pulling out column pipe conductors to be able to pull the pumps, install new pumps down in the well, do maintenance on it. That activity has occurred on this site and will continue to occur from time to time. So we want to make sure that the neighbors as they're going in know that that
1:11:18 It exists and so they're not surprised or shocked when, you know, we put out a notice to the neighbors and let them know, hey, we need to come in for maintenance. And at some point we do want to, we will want to drill a new well on this site. It is, it is big enough and we kind of have reserved a portion on the other, on part of our site to be able to do that.
1:11:48 And then the other thing is, as you probably have noticed, well, along Minaret Road right now, there's a new MUP going in, right through there. We've been coordinating with the town on the MUP as well, making sure that we can still get across the MUP to our site, but because of the way that the grades are there, it's definitely not ideal, especially when you're talking about big equipment like
1:12:18 A well pump rig getting across the Mammoth and accessing. So we want to retain the ability to access our site from the west side, which would be in through the community side to ensure that we still have access and can do what we want to do there. We also can't have snow storage.
1:12:46 on the site because we may need to access it in the winter. It's pretty unusual. That would be unusual for us to need to access it in winter, but we can't have snow storage on the site. And then we at some point may want to install a fence that meets the general plan's requirements for fencing around our location. Currently it's not fenced, but that's something we're thinking about.
1:13:16 I have a question, Garrett. I know when we were working on Snow Creek, we were talking about use of gray water. Where are we with use of gray water for irrigation purposes in town? That's a good question. It's not exactly gray water. What we provide for irrigation to the golf courses is recycled water. It's treated with wastewater. Right now,
1:13:47 We can only, we only have two customers. It's both golf courses. Because this site is directly adjacent to a golf course, there is infrastructure relatively close by. We have not really explored that in depth, but it is a possibility.
1:14:13 One of the things that you need to make sure you don't do too close to a production well, though, is to use recycled water. So there's also a perimeter around our well where we would not be able to use recycled water. And so it may not make sense on this site based on that portion that's outside of the well.
1:14:35 And that would also require coordination with Sierra Star because Sierra Star has the rest of the infrastructure. The way our recycled water system works is it's not pressurized at all times like our water system is. It's not that way. We pump from the wastewater treatment plant up to reservoirs that are at the golf courses.
1:15:03 Then from there, they pump that water out and charge their sprinklers, right? So that's why it's not most sites like on this site, they do not have the room to put their own reservoir for recycled water, not at all with the current design, right? So if it's
1:15:31 It's definitely in the realm of possibility and it's something we can consider, but we are not, we're not really strongly advocating for that in this situation, especially because our well 17 is right on this site. That makes sense. Thanks, Garrett. Any other questions for Garrett while he's at the podium? No? Thank you, Garrett. Appreciate it. Thank you for attending today. All right, last chance for public comment.
1:16:01 Jamie, any other via Zoom? No? Then I'm going to close public comment and I'll throw it back up on the commission. Any questions for staff or thoughts or opinions that you'd like to express? I think I would want to address the fire chief whenever he returns on one of the issues that was brought up and that's it. Okay. We'll put a ribbon on that. Any other thoughts, opinions? Commissioner Fleming? Commissioner Verruck?
1:16:30 Just with regard to the easements that, so Garrett touched on some of the easements that are required by the Water District, but then the woman at Hidden Valley, Ruth Wheeler, with regard to snow storage, I couldn't, I wasn't clear, and I don't know if you guys can even answer this, I wasn't clear from her comments whether or not she was talking about snow storage that Hidden Valley uses that may be part of this.
1:16:58 You know, on this property as opposed to solely on their property and then also that walkway that the pedestrian through, walkway that she was referring to, is that something that you're familiar with and is it, you know, I mean, I don't know how that kind of works considering it's private property, right?
1:17:17 So I can add an initial comment and then I believe Andy Morris will expand on that. So there are no official recorded easements on the subject property for snow storage for the adjacent properties and there's neither a pedestrian easement either. So any use of that historically has been unpermitted. It's not been something that's actually been recorded on those properties. Yeah, and I can add to that.
1:17:47 So what Ms. Wheeler is describing is a concept that California recognizes called a prescriptive easement, which is even if you don't have any rights to use somebody's land, if you just trespass and use their land for long enough, it's possible to develop what's called a prescriptive easement.
1:18:05 By just using somebody else's land without permission. And there's some other criteria too. It's a very, very fact-specific determination. And it's not one that the town can make. The PEDC can't decide that a prescriptive easement has been created. Staff can't decide that. Town council can't decide that. I can't decide that. Really, only a judge can decide if the criteria for a prescriptive easement had been met in a given case. So in my view, it would not be appropriate to require the developer to grant a formal easement.
1:18:34 Um, assuming that there's a prescriptive easement. If the Hidden Valley neighbors or anybody else, uh, think that they can prove up a prescriptive easement, they would need to go to court to do that. It's not, not the town's role. Thank you. Chief, I think we have a question for you, if you wouldn't mind. Oh, guys, I'm on duty. It's why I take calls. Uh, Mike McCarthy, Mammoth Fire. How can I help you, Dawn? Thanks for coming back. No, actually, this is wrong this time. Commissioner Graham. Um,
1:19:07 Mike, I wanted to address one of the earlier comments with regards to, again, you were the one that did a presentation on Mammoth being categorized as high risk. Very high hazard, yes. And with that area, again, we're cutting over 500 trees from what we learned today, the very high fire hazard trees. And they are being replaced by
1:19:35 From my very new knowledge, a lot lower fire risk vegetation and trees. From your professional opinion, seeing the side as it is right now and developing side with leaving as many of the current trees that we have versus doing what developer is proposing and replacing the vegetation with
1:20:05 you know the aspens and maple and lower shrubs how does that impact and like if if we did the development with keeping all of the Jeffrey Pines versus doing the development as it is right now how like how would the two compare should hit the fan for no better word
1:20:32 Yeah, I mean, it's obviously, it's a mixed answer there, right? I mean, we are, we all live here in Mammoth because we like to live here in the forest. We are not going to live in the parking lot of Vaughns, right? That's nobody's intention to do that. That said, obviously, we're trying to be more prudent on new builds to increase their fire resilience. So I will say that, you know, there's a lot of stuff that's done on the homes and the dwellings themselves to make them resilient.
1:21:02 And then there's the defensible space we've been doing our inspections on around town. So I have provided some preliminary comments back to staff and the developer. And the developer will go through us, too, on this stuff. So they will have to be in compliance with defensible space requirements, as all new construction does. And that does create some spacing between vegetation. It's more about spacing rather than the types of vegetation is really the main thing there.
1:21:32 The other part of the equation is, you know, there's a lot of stuff going around, doing work around town that's about a healthy forest. And so we do things both about a healthy forest and about defensible space. So to your comment on Jeffrey Pines, you know, Jeffrey Pines are the, they're the cat's meow up here. They are what we try to protect in the healthy forest. We try to sacrifice other pines to protect the Jeffreys. So, yes, there's some components, Jeffreys, that can make them flammable, but they also have extremely thick bark. So in the,
1:22:02 In the 100, 200 years ago type of fires that would come through and grow through, they are very resilient to the fire because they have thick bark and they're protected and so they're a good species to have compared to some of the other species like for instance a white pine is almost the weed and it grows, it fills in the fastest but it also is the first to die when there's any shock to the system with drought years or something like that.
1:22:29 I am not going to go deeper into forest health because that's about the extent of my knowledge, but we do certainly have species selection that we prioritize when we're doing healthy forest. And then defensible space, it's more about spacing between stuff. You know, spacing so that fire that comes through on the ground has a harder time to get up into the structure, to the trees, or a harder time to get into the structure. So, you know, there are plants and shrubs that are less oily.
1:22:57 And more fire resistant. And I think, as I heard their landscaper talk about, they're trying to prioritize some of those type of mixtures. But I, you know, I said, I've talked with Kim, we've talked with the developer, and they will have to remove some, there's no way around it. Some trees have to be removed and other trees can be saved and limed up. You know, because the tree trunk is usually not the big problem.
1:23:23 It's the branches that hang and touch to the building, right? Because that's that fire path that communicates. So to the extent we can keep as many healthy mature trees as we can and limb some of them up to get the spacing we need, that's the same thing we ask homeowners to do on their private property, right? It's not about taking every tree down. It's taking some of the small and matures, but it's limbing up the healthy mature ones. And I think we would use the same approach here.
1:23:49 And, you know, they obviously can shift their buildings wherever they can to minimize what we can. But we also want to set them up for success, the future homeowners up for success too, right? Not a maintenance nightmare that they've got to be constantly vigilant about trying to deal with trees that are too close to their property. Because I also think...
1:24:11 I mean, it was like over, I think it was exactly a year ago when we were talking about how the mammoth reclassification affects the homeowner's insurance and how current regulations, like on paper, are still several years behind the regulations that insurance company is using? Yes. Is that correct? The insurance company uses risk models.
1:24:41 So we talked about some hazard models, which kind of just about hazard, but not a risk. Insurance companies use risk because they want to take all the factors into account. You know, kind of like an ocean full of sharks is a high hazard, but it's a low risk if nobody's swimming in the ocean. So the good news about, you know, new construction is all very resilient fire construction type approaches.
1:25:08 Right? So they will have that going for them on insurance purposes, that their home part, the side of it will be, will check all the marks for the insurance companies, you know, and defensible space will be the last part of it around it. So, which also makes me think that eventually the rest of us will have to catch up, so to say, to those insurance requirements in the future, is it correct? I mean,
1:25:34 The insurance companies will always be using probably the most cutting-edge thing that they think gives them the most accurate indication of the risk, right? They're in it for the financial balance, right? And so whatever, and modeling has jumped forward, kind of leaps and bounds in the last 10 years where they've tried to have been able to kind of quantify the fuel load around town and threat into town and then what the home has done. But science isn't perfectly exact yet.
1:25:59 We're probably going to see a lot more tree cutting in town to be able to sustain our home insurances. I think you'll see more green waste removal, right? Again, on mature trees, it's usually about just limbing them up 10 feet or something like that. It's not about cutting them down. But some of the small, immature trees that are underneath the canopies of the other trees, you know, those provide that ladder of fuel up into the tree. So I think you'll see, you know, that's what our inspections focus on, is that breaking that ladder.
1:26:29 and get in some spacing. But it's not about, it is about removing dead trees, but it's not about removing healthy mature trees for the most part. Those are just a minimum limbed up. Okay. Thanks, Mike. Sure. Before you leave, Mike, any other questions for the chief? I do have a question. So regarding the defensible space, as has the planting or the landscape designs been proposed to date, do you see that you're going to require
1:26:56 Additional defensible space? Or do you think that the plan that we're seeing today is... I mean, it's hard to tell from some of the stuff we said, but that was the kind of information that I shared with town, and I think that we'll work through with town and the developer to make sure that, because there's no sense in having them plant anything that we need to turn around and say, that's too close. Right. Right, so we're trying to minimize that. Sometimes it's, so we probably will end up doing some site visits once they get a little better idea of where the footprints of buildings are going to be so we can see about that.
1:27:26 And then look at some of the replanting just to make sure. From the context of what they explained, they're certainly aware of it. So my guess is they're probably close to hitting the mark. And this project is probably one of the first ones with, I mean, do we have a new building code with regard to wildfire risk? Yes, wildfire risk is.
1:27:53 Defensible space hasn't really changed much yet. So the state is still trying to work on a zero to five area, zone zero, but we've had that in place with our local ordinance for 15 years. Okay. So, and there is a new cycle of the fire code and WUI code that came out while the urban interface code came out in 2025, but it's really minimal changes from the previous couple generations. So it's been kind of static. I think people are more aware of it now and paying more attention. Right.
1:28:23 But it hasn't fundamentally changed the blueprint that they got to hit. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions for the chief while he's up here? No. Thanks, Mike. Appreciate the time and the information. Nolan, there were a couple of questions that were asked during public comment. Would you care to address those? Sure. Absolutely. I'll touch on a few. Kim will touch on one, and then I might invite our SQL consultants up.
1:28:53 To expand on any of the comments related to the EIR and some of those comments and how those relate with the addendum. The first one I would like to touch on is, you know, we talked earlier that they are required to comply with the housing ordinance. So our housing ordinance provides a menu of options, which one of those options is a fee. It's also on-site housing, off-site, or...
1:29:20 Commands of land or an alternative plan. So the developer would be required to comply with that housing ordinance and they can elect to mitigate through those options. However, the value of the required mitigation is based on what the in-lieu fee would be. So that's what Kim provided earlier. However, there's nothing stopping the developer from providing something of a higher value or an alternative plan. So the developer did touch on their project they're looking to do.
1:29:49 There is potential that the town could partner with them and through an alternative plan and use instead of paying the fees, those fees would instead be leveraged or invested into those projects to get additional deed restrictions on units. So that's not a guarantee. The condition just requires them to comply with the housing ordinance in effect. So that's the general requirement there for housing. Then there is also
1:30:20 I believe in the comment letter from Mr. Strom at the end of it touched on some of the mitigation measures and specifically one related to archaeological concerns. So within the conditions of approval or the proposed conditions of approval, they are required, the project is required to comply with all the applicable mitigation measures from the EIR. One of those was the requirement for archaeological studies and
1:30:48 I think the specific requirement required three one-meter test pits to be dug by an appropriate consultant. The developer already did complete those test pits prior to purchasing the site. However, they are then still required to comply with additional archaeological requirements during grading, such as having the monitors and if they find artifacts, complying with all the appropriate measures in that case.
1:31:17 And then I'll ask Kim to kind of touch on... What about wildlife corridor? What was that? Wildlife corridor. So wildlife was analyzed in the EIR as far as what is there and then it was again reviewed through the addendum and it was found that there are no significant impacts with the changes. Obviously with any development there's going to be changes to where wildlife lives. That's nature of any development.
1:31:47 However that was addressed through and studied in the EIR, which found there would be no significant impacts there. And then Nolan had asked me to touch on the forested nature of the site, and Mr. Strom did reference one of the mitigation measures that apply. This is for aesthetics, light and glare, and the mitigation measure just, it reads to the maximum extent.
1:32:16 Practical, the proposed project shall retain forested areas and the development shall remain subordinate to the natural character of the site and surrounding landscape. So there is a little bit of discretion there in the decision making in determining what the maximum extent practical is in preserving and retaining the forested character of the property.
1:32:41 As well as determining whether the development remains subordinate to the natural character of the site and surrounding landscape. So staff has worked to push the developer to preserve as many trees as possible outside of building footprints and roadway areas where the civil engineers
1:33:05 You know, didn't protest and say, well, grading the roadway or the over excavation in this area is definitely going to compromise those trees. You can't preserve those. Any tree where, you know, I would go through with a highlighter and say, well, what about this one and this one and talk about it with the developer. And so there was definitely an effort made to preserve as many trees as possible and especially with a priority placed on the larger diameter trees because as the
1:33:35 The fire chief was saying is it's really limbing up those larger trees that is going to still provide some fire mitigation for the site without having to remove those trees that are nearer to the structures where we're removing the smaller diameter trees because they can act as ladders. So that's my response to the question. Unfortunately, it's not a black and white standard. Thank you.
1:34:07 Were there any other questions, Nolan, that you'd like to address? No, I would like to invite Kristen up from Michael Baker. She can just expand on the addendum and the analysis through that and how that interacts with the EIR. Thank you. Thank you, Nolan. Good morning. Kristen Bogan with Michael Baker International, and I've had the privilege of working with town staff on CEQA for several decades now. For the CEQA, as you guys know, you have the 1999 SPEIR.
1:34:38 So that's a programmatic analysis that covered the full specific plan buildup. This project is within the envelopes considered for that, so an addendum was the appropriate CEQA process. So attachment C is your addendum. We went through all the topic areas and we analyzed if this project would create any increased impacts or not. And based on our findings, it's consistent with the criteria for an addendum. So if you have any questions regarding that process, I'm available.
1:35:07 Any questions on CEQA or addendum C? Anybody? No. Thank you. Appreciate it. Any thoughts, opinions that anybody on the commission would like to express?
1:35:29 Sure. Oh, yeah, I have a couple things. Okay. So, you know, when we, when this was first presented to ADP back in the fall, I had reached out to staff and just to confirm that I was to be looking at the North Village specific plan, which the original North Village specific plan was very clear on the type of housing and what housing mitigation, workforce housing, was going to be required for any building with North Village specific.
1:35:58 Specifically, but then this last week, it was presented to us a letter documenting all the changes that previous councils have noted, which is disappointing to me because I feel as though our hands are tied in a sense because the specific housing mitigation is no longer valid. It just...
1:36:24 It was specific to North Village. It just kind of defaults back to, if I'm understanding correctly, to just the overall housing component that is relative to every development. So that's a little disappointing. However, I do appreciate the efforts that are going to be made in building specific housing, workforce housing for that, especially if you're talking about the middle, that middle income person.
1:36:54 It's just a comment. I just feel that, you know, it's something that in the future because this 9,000 and change per unit is such a pathetic amount of money and with the cost of building it really doesn't, it's just a drop in the bucket and it doesn't really, it doesn't really help the community by large. It's such a small, just a small number.
1:37:22 So, in the, but that again, it's not, you know, in, as a planning commissioner, I mean, we're here to check off boxes, you know, density, parking, snow removal, things like that. And so, as a planning commissioner, I'm checking off all the boxes and, you know, while the village and the trees, I think the intent is there.
1:37:48 It is very alarming to see so many trees being taken down. And I do understand the plan that the town has in relation to making sure that the landscaping projects are moving forward as each.
1:38:05 Section segment of the development is being built is my understanding and that people there will be eyes on on all the trees that will be tagged they'll be marked they'll be protected the trees that are going to be that are going to be salvaged so I you know those are my two big issues concerns I guess stressors over this but at the same time just because of the past leadership
1:38:33 And the way previous councils have voted, I feel that the project is falling into line and falling into place with checking off those boxes. In the future, however, I really hope that we can sit down with council or have a conversation with council regarding future workforce housing mitigation.
1:39:01 Thank you, Commissioner Varouk. I would like to let the public know that we have officially requested to have a workshop with town council to address the diff fees as well as other items that I think Nolan's going to canvas the commission on to see what we'd like to talk about. So hopefully that conversation will be happening.
1:39:32 in the near term, not the far term. But Nolan, would you like to address any of Commissioner Verruck's comments? Sure, on the specific housing mitigation. So in the specific plan was adopted in 1999, at least the amended one from the 1991. The housing ordinance at that time was largely based off of the town's initial housing ordinance, which was also being drafted concurrently in 1999.
1:40:01 And so the language that was adopted into that that 99 specific plan mimicked or largely mimicked what was then ultimately adopted into the the town's municipal code kind of verbatim it included all the text within the specific plan. Fast forward to 2005 that was the next time that the the town updated its housing ordinance on
1:40:24 So they made some changes to the calculations and some of the various methods for how the mitigation would be applied. Shortly thereafter, the North Village specific plan was then amended where it removed kind of all the text copy within the specific plan and instead then pointed back to the Municipal Code of Housing Ordinance for how the housing mitigation would be applied. So that effectively shifted back to
1:40:54 comply with just the housing ordinance in effect at that time, as then it allowed for the housing ordinance to be updated over the years. I think it's gone through about four additional iterations since then with the last major update happening in 2015, which is going to establish what's currently in our code. I do agree it's likely appropriate time to kind of revisit that and take a look at that. So I look forward to the future conversations with the commission and council on that.
1:41:23 Thank you, Nolan. Any other thoughts, comments, opinions? Commissioner Fleming? Dawn summarized it well. Okay. There's one question that I thought I asked that didn't get addressed. Is it okay for me to ask that? Please, please, sir. There was also a comment regarding the, and it might actually be for Michael Baker also, but then the EIR that I think incorporated in the more specific plan about not braiding underneath the canopy or the root structure of the trees that were being retained also.
1:41:54 Yes, that is something that we take into consideration for the tree preservation measures. Generally, disturbance underneath the drip line of trees is not allowed.
1:42:29 Sometimes I like to provide some flexibility so that developers don't say, well then we're going to have to remove that tree because we can't build this project without disturbing some of the drip line. I prefer to kind of ensure that most of the drip line is retained without disturbance just so that we can preserve a tree as opposed to strictly saying absolutely nothing.
1:42:59 Can happen under the drip line because that ends up usually resulting in developers saying that the tree needs to be removed. So we will definitely ensure that all of the tree protection measures are in place before grading occurs on site. And the conditions that I mentioned previously would require the tree fencing be in place before grading or tree removal occurs on site.
1:43:26 So we will be inspecting that and monitoring that on an ongoing basis. But in certain cases where the tree is a little bit closer to a structure, where it might be difficult for construction to occur without some disturbance of like half of a drip line, I prefer that they try to save the tree rather than remove it. Thank you, Kim. Appreciate the follow-up question. Commissioner Grand, any other thoughts, comments?
1:43:57 Opinions? I feel like I have, I want, I mean, a lot of people in this room now have a lot of issues with current events in town and developments and I'm usually pretty vocal about it, but with this particular, I just, like, I want to be more optimistic and similar to the gentleman in the audience, believe it, Ryan. Right. And
1:44:25 Look at it from the point of the more tourism development happening in the center of the village and my thinking and hope would free up some of the existing older buildings, single-family homes and condos within outside of the village perimeter.
1:44:55 to the Mammoth residents and to the workforce and to that missing middle that currently just being all used for Airbnbs. So hopefully with these new developments, the Airbnb saturation would be around the village in those new developments rather than the existing structures that are being taken away right now from the local residents.
1:45:25 That's my hope for it. And with the new development, like I said at the beginning, the Mammoth being classified as all red and high danger, that's to me as a homeowner in town, it's like I have friends who lost homes in Tahoe. It's just, it's such a big deal to me. I would rather lose a couple of pine trees and gain a couple of other trees or shrubs and see our...
1:45:54 Town survive and habitat survive and not just lose one corridor for animals but like if this goes kaboom like there will be no corridor for any animals anywhere in the perimeter so I see quite a few positive things with the development and I'm hoping that that will trickle down into a longer term positive impact on our housing situation as well.
1:46:27 Thank you, Commissioner Grand. Well, if there's no other thoughts or opinions, would anybody like to put forth a motion? I can certainly put a motion. Adopt the attached Planning Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required tentative tract map, use permit, design, review, and CEQA findings, approving tentative tract map application 25002, use permit 25001, and design review 25004, with conditions as recommended by staff.
1:47:02 Thank you, Commissioner Grand. Any other conversation, dialogue? Do we have a second? I second. Jamie, would we have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 4-0. Appreciate if you would keep us updated on what you kind of alluded to in terms of workforce housing. We would love to stay abreast of the topic or of the project.
1:47:36 And congratulations. Thank you everyone for attending today. I know it's a work day and you took some time out of your day, so appreciate it. And I'd like to thank everyone in the public that contacted me last night. I probably had 15 calls. So I appreciate that input. I appreciate the dialogue. And please know that I'm always accessible as well as everyone else on this commission. All right, with that, we will go to the consent agenda.
1:48:09 which is to approve the meeting minutes of the regularly scheduled meeting of March 11, 2026. Unless there's some edits that somebody would like to put forth, I would love to hear a motion to approve the consent agenda. I make a motion to approve the consent agenda, the minutes from the regular meeting of March 11, 2026. Do I have a second? I second. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Fleming? Approved. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Vice Chair Verrucke?
1:48:41 Yes, Chair Vanderhurst. Yes, consent agenda passes. We will go to Commissioner Reports and I'll start on my left and go across the dais. So Commissioner Grand, do you have a Commissioner Report you'd like to put forth? No, sir. Commissioner Verruck? No, I do not. Commissioner Fleming? No. I would just like to congratulate Eastern Sierra Pride on the festival that was held at Canyon Lodge this last weekend.
1:49:09 I think it was really well attended, it was very well executed. I would hope that that festival grows going forward. I think it's a pretty important part of our community and I wish them nothing but success. So with that we will go to Director's Report.
1:49:32 Great, thank you. I did want to just give a brief update on one of our favorite projects here across the street, the Sierra Center Mall. So that project, they do have approved entitlement to convert the existing building to a hotel. It was approved several years ago, I want to say around 2020 or 2021. They also do have an active demo permit that was issued.
1:50:01 Late in 2025. So that permit is still active. They initiated the work then, had an inspection, and then they're required to have a subsequent inspection. One second, I'll give you the exact date here. Prior to September 28th of this year to verify that the work is ongoing there.
1:50:30 However, with that, it does then fall kind of into the winter shutdown period, so that permit would remain active until the end of December of 2026. However, we also are aware that there's some needed enforcement action on
1:50:49 that existing building with the way it stands currently with the site and just the overall appearance of the structure. So I did work with code compliance both from community development code compliance as well as engineering and they're working on a plan to address some of the substandard conditions at that building that includes the condition of the parking lot and the appearance of the siding. So I can provide an update at the next meeting as to what has occurred.
1:51:18 Since then. On other topics. Sorry, Nolan, can I interrupt you really quick? Yes. Would you mind just keeping the commission updated on the inspection, on the demolition? I think you said September 28th? Yep. So maybe the October meeting. I think it's pretty important that we are abreast of the progress and the demolition inside that building. I'd hate to have them just do the bare minimum to keep their entitlements in place and then abandon that.
1:51:48 And then do the bare minimum again when the time comes. Understood. Also wanted to give an update on the parcel. So the Kingfisher II, that's the second phase of what's currently under construction out there. That's an additional 72 units of low-income housing. They have begun construction on that second phase. So there's grading going on and that'll be followed up shortly by...
1:52:16 Some of the foundation and utility work, and then likely beginning next kind of spring, we'll see that second phase start to go vertical with the modulars. That initial phase, the Kingfisher I, that's 76 units, is largely completed. They are targeting certificate of occupancy and official completion this fall on those units. So if you drive through the parcel, it's
1:52:43 It seemed pretty exciting to see that coming along. I also think it highlights the planning effort that went into the design to kind of, you know, yes, it's higher density, but creating different massing between the different phases. It's exciting to see that coming to fruition out there as you drive through. We were actually out there yesterday and just kind of excited to see the progress there.
1:53:08 On other topics, the newly formed Economic Development Subcommittee had its initial meeting a few weeks back. Thank you, Brianna, for coordinating that through the chamber. It's a handful of chamber members and others, and so it's exciting to see the discussions there, more to come on work there and kind of different topics that can come out of that that then might come to you.
1:53:34 the commission or come to a joint meeting with commission and chamber as a future kind of topics of discussion. And then I will be reaching out to the commissioners individually on topics they'd like to see on a future joint meeting with town council, as Michael talked about earlier. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate it. And just let the public know that we have
1:54:00 Asked staff to look into the what appears to be an abandoned work site at the outpost mall that sits on Old Mammoth Road. So I think we'll have an update that on that in subsequent meetings, whether that's going to be resume construction or if that construction site is going to be tidied up. It is a little bit of an eyesore right there on Old Mammoth Road. And unfortunately, our Fourth of July parade, which is fantastic, is going to walk right by it.
1:54:29 That is being discussed. So just so the public knows that. Anything else for Nolan or staff? I do have a comment question. So with regard to the construction site on Burner, the residence inn. Yeah, the residence inn.
1:54:53 The fencing, it's not well-maintained. The fencing is falling down. There's no, aside from, I don't know, I personally haven't seen any water trucks there, but I don't know what is required. Are they required to have mesh fencing? Because, just for the dust mitigation, but it's a pretty, it's an eyesore, that construction site. It's a little bit beyond, you know, what I would expect for a main referral, you know, when you're going down forest trail, so.
1:55:24 Hi, thanks for your concerns. I apologize for my allergy state at the moment. Yes, we've been working with the contractor on tidying up the site and replacing and increasing their BMPs on the site, tidying up the fencing, and so we have been asking them to propose a plan over the next couple of weeks for addressing that.
1:55:52 We are also working with them to address the stockpiling of soil around the bases of trees that are required to be retained, and so hope to see some improvements there in the next couple of weeks at the very least, or at the most, I mean. To the best of my knowledge, though, your question about screening on the fencing is not a requirement. Maybe Nolan...
1:56:18 From the building department, CED standpoint, you have better information, but I don't think that screening is a requirement. Thanks. Yeah, they are required to have it fenced, both for security of the job site, and I believe it's a requirement for them on their insurance side as well, but it does not require the mesh screening. We can definitely reach out to the developer and see if it's something they're willing to incorporate, but it's not a specific requirement of our code.
1:56:49 Is that something that could be discussed for a code? I mean, just because it's just, you know, with future developments, if things are moving forward in the next five to ten years, you know, because like right now, if you look at this, you know, the Rock Spring site is pretty well concealed, I guess, covered. It's not as much, I mean, it's building, right? So it's still kind of, it's a construction zone, but it's not an awful site to look at, to drive by.
1:57:16 But I wonder if that's something that can be incorporated in the future. Yeah, it's definitely something we can look into to see how we would do that. I know fencing's always a bit of a challenge because it gets absolutely destroyed during winter everywhere. And so it definitely requires a lot of upkeep then to kind of maintain its appearance. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate it. Amy, thanks for stepping in. Kim as well.
1:57:45 With that, I'll adjourn today's meeting to our next scheduled Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, which will be held in this room on July 8th, 2026. Thank you all, appreciate it.