TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2022

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

2 findings

Transcript

689 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 All things considered, I guess we're still standing here, right? Yep. You got my blue and yellow one. I saw that in your background. Good man. Good man. Can you identify the other two women up there? I used to. Maxine Walters and what's her name? The Republican. Blonde. Ms. Cheney and Stacey Abrams. Oh, I thought it was Stacey Abrams. Stacey Abrams.

0:36 And Liz Cheney, democracy and voting rights. And the United States of America and Ukraine, we're all in this together. You'll be quizzed later, and there are prizes, so keep that in mind. I did. I knew that was Stacey Evans. You told me that before. Yeah. Liz Cheney. I like that woman. Yeah, who knew, right? Yeah, right.

1:06 I like your Ukraine flag, John. I made it myself. Awesome. Pretty easy. It's blue and yellow. I was going to say, thankfully, they don't have a real complicated flag. No stars or anything. Not like the Australian flag. Yeah. Like a serpent or anything, Anna. Yeah, no stripes and stars, any of that kind of stuff. Right. And those are primary colors, I believe, aren't they? Mm-hmm. Okay. Easier still.

1:39 We have Bill. Hi, Bill. There's Kirk. Now we do this. And Linda, I think you have some items before us, correct? Yes. Just a few. Not many. Okay. Does anyone know, is Sarah planning to be able to meet with us this afternoon? No. Sean, haven't seen you in a while. Now I'm unmuted. Good to see you. Good to see you. Sean, did you get my email earlier?

2:53 Yes, I did. Thank you. A minute here and we'll begin. Okay. I'm going to call 232 and I'm going to convene the meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, March 16, 2002. Nope, that's not right. 2022. Okay. Jamie, may we do roll call, please? Council Member Ray is absent. Council Member Souser? Yo. Council Member Stapp? Here.

4:33 Mayor Pro Tem, Wentworth.

4:36 Present.

4:37 Mayor Salcido.

4:38 Here.

4:39 All right.

4:41 Dan, since you're standing, would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance?

4:45 Yes.

4:46 Please join me in the Pledge to our flag.

4:50 Ready?

4:50 Begin.

4:51 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America,

4:55 to the Republic, to the Republic, to the Republic, for which we stand,

4:59 one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice.

5:03 sprawl.

5:06 All right, thank you. Next, we have public comment. If anyone would like to make a comment in regards to an item not on the agenda this evening or this afternoon, now is the moment. Jamie, anybody is there to make public comment? Good afternoon, Madam Mayor, council members. Good to see you guys virtually. I'm actually here. John Morris, I'm speaking to you right now on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association.

5:39 I'm just here today to follow up on an email that I sent out about a week or so ago to the town council and town staff regarding rental assistance for workforce housing. As you may recall from the email, I outlined a concept whereby the town would help fund the gap between what local workers can pay for monthly rent and what the local property owners might be willing to looking, excuse me, might be looking to charge.

6:07 The goal of this program would be to move some property owners out of the short-term rental market and into long-term rentals so that local businesses could actually recruit staff from outside the area, which we know right now is a rather desperate situation. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth was kind enough to share with me, after that email, information about a website that's called landinglocals.com. Some of you may be familiar with it.

6:35 This company currently services South and North Lake Tahoe, Truckee, and also Summit County, Colorado, specifically, I think, Breckenridge, I believe. And they offer a service that is pretty close to what I had outlined in my proposal. I contacted their marketing department and found out that Landing Locals is actually interested in expanding their services to our area. As you all know,

6:59 Our community desperately needs more workforce housing now. And while I applaud the work of the council and the town, what you have been doing regarding the parcel and other workforce housing initiatives, we need affordable, long-term housing, lots of it, and we need it now. We cannot afford to wait simply for the parcel and other projects to be completed and come online.

7:23 Subsidizing rent is a relatively short-term partial solution to the housing crisis that could be implemented rather quickly. I hope that the council and the town staff will consider some sort of a version of this and soon. The logic community is here to provide input wherever we can to help answer any questions that you all might have or give data to support this effort. So please feel free to reach out to us and I thank you very much for your time today. Thanks.

7:52 Thank you very much, John. Jamie, others? Are they there? No, that is all the public comment. That's all? Okay, thank you for that. Okay, the next topic is, let me scroll down here, would be any additions to the agenda. Madam Mayor, we had an initial request for an item that we've determined now is not necessary to add to the agenda at this time, so we have no additions.

8:26 Okay, thank you. And next, we're having reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Who would like to speak? Stu, I see your hand is up. Good morning. But if you get ready, then. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of council. I'm just going to provide council with a brief update on COVID. I know we are transitioning from a formal policy item just to a quick department update. So I'm just going to share my screen here.

8:58 And let's see how we do. And I'm just going to run council and the community just through a couple of slides, if I may. Just a very abbreviated presentation this evening, this afternoon. Total cases, this was from Monday, Tuesday, I think, just under 3,000, 2,961. The good news here, as you can see, we've really stabilized the adjusted case rate for 100,000, just over the 3.1 there.

9:27 Actually, just at 3.1 for the last two weeks, which is great. Certainly a better trajectory than where we were a month or two ago. So seems very stable at this time, as we know. Could change, but that's where we are right now. Status is still green at the hospital. Still having difficulty transferring patients, we understand. On March 11th, effective March 12th.

9:52 Schools and childcare facilities were no longer required to wear masks indoors. And as we know from March 1st, a statewide mask mandate was withdrawn. So this graphic is still very relevant today. Still strongly recommended indoors in both indoor spaces and in schools and childcare and required in healthcare, long-term care, jails and prisons, and then public transit, as we know, is still required.

10:21 The administration, I believe, extended that through to April 18th. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that was the right date for the extension of the public transit requirement to wear masks, planes, bus, trains, automobiles and so forth. Just vaccination dashboard here, just under 10,000, first dose, fully vaccinated, just under 9,000. Testing is still at Sierra Star Golf Course. It'll be there through the end of March.

10:50 And I'm looking for a new venue at that time. No updated new site at this time. But again, testing is Monday, Wednesday, Saturday. And they both have, I didn't update them in this slide, I apologize, but they have rapid antigen tests as well as PCR tests on demand. So if you do want to get there expeditiously and be tested rapidly through a response, if you didn't get a rapid test, you can do so at Sierra Star Golf Course Monday, Wednesday.

11:20 Saturday and public health testing throughout the county on Fridays. And then you can still get your free test and a lot of information. I'm just going to jump into my other item, if I may. Of course. Thank you. And then this one is our wonderful Recreation Expo. So I'm just going to share that screen. Hopefully you can see that. So this is coming up. It's very quick. It's already March 16th. So March 29th.

11:52 A little over 10 days away, we have the return of the Summer Recreation Expo. We missed a year, we had a virtual year and our last one was 2019. So again, just very excited to get our community together and celebrate all the great, wonderful recreation programs, offerings, events, camps and programs, leagues and trails throughout our community and the Eastern Sierra. So details, you know, March 29th, Mammoth High School Gymnasium.

12:20 5 to 7pm. We have many recreation providers. We have about 25 right now coming to showcase all the wonderful programs that they do. And then we're also raising money for our Tony Colosado Scholarship Fund. Every person that comes gets a free entry, but you can buy those raffle tickets for $5 or $5.20. And all those proceeds go to that scholarship fund. And the grand prize, again, we give one away every year, and that's a highly...

12:49 Sort after free summer camp. We'll enrol that person that evening. Pre-registration begins April 4th. So this is kind of in advance of that pre-registration time where we want to make sure our community is aware, understands and can navigate our online reservation platform and register their children or themselves in our many programs. So that is all I have at this time. Thank you, Madam Mayor. All right. Thank you very much, Stu.

13:20 Welcome. Okay, Rob. Yes, Madam Mayor, we are in our normal department update. Is that correct? I want to make sure I'm not doing this at the wrong part of our meeting. No, I think you're fine. Okay, perfect. I just wanted to let folks know on, for the last month or so, we've been working with Standard & Poor's rating agency on a review of the town's debt, and this would be the series 2017.

13:49 Judgment Obligation Bonds that we did have rated when we first got those. And they review them every other year, I believe, is a process. So we just received our rating, which is an A-plus rating, and they removed the negative outlook that they had placed on most resort communities going into the pandemic and left ours at a stable. So it was an improvement over what we had before.

14:18 The rating action, sort of, as they're in their words, reflects management's objective and effective budgeting practices towards maintaining balanced operations and very strong reserves, despite experiencing a decrease in revenue in the past audited two years, two audited years. This, this is a, there's a, there's a much longer write-up on this. I won't, you know, bore you too much with that. We'll put it and post it on the website, but really good news from the finance perspective.

14:44 The processes by which we use for budgeting, as well as the funding set aside for our reserves. As you know, we've updated those in the last couple of years to include a debt reserve, as well as sort of adjusting the figures we have, as well as our baseline revenue. So I'm very excited to be able to present that today. So thank you. All right. That is good news, Rob. Thanks for bringing that here. Okay. Anybody else like to speak now? I'm not...

15:14 Seeing anyone, Jamie, oh, I'm sorry, John, I missed you there. Go ahead. Good afternoon again, Madam Mayor, Council John Morris again this time.

15:21 I'm coming to you on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board of Directors. I'm currently the treasurer. And I'm here today to give an update on the programs that MLT is currently working on. Our goal is to have Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board members and staff members give more frequent updates to the council. I hope this will help the council, keep the council more informed regarding MLT's scope of work and make our periodic meetings usually...

15:50 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

16:11 First, starting off with good news. We could all use some these days. According to a recent, this is on research, according to a recent report from destination analysts, strong excitement for travel continues to grow amongst Americans as COVID is slowly waning and losing its effect on America's perceived ability to have meaningful travel experiences.

16:32 Data shows that about 70% of Americans did some travel dreaming and planning at the beginning of this month, and about 62% said that travel is a high-budget priority for them, with New York, Florida, California, and Hawaii at the top of the list of destinations that Americans say they wish to visit. For Mammoth, this means that we can expect another busy summer, and I can attest to our reservations at Snow Creek. We're doing pretty well for the summer.

17:01 Mammoth Lakes Tourism has geared all of its summer marketing, as we have, I think, the last two summers, towards education and stewardship messaging. Since we know that visitors will be here, we're approaching messaging with the lens of when you are here, please recreate responsibly, rather than simply messaging to come visit. On air service, I'm very excited about this. As you probably know, in the past, we've only had one flight.

17:30 Which has been the flight from LAX to Mammoth during the summertime. That is changing this year. Our winter service is starting to wind down a little bit. Let's see, just to get my dates correct here. Advanced Air, let's see, will be running service from the LA area through April 4th. And United, that's flying into Mammoth.

17:55 Yosemite Airport. United is still flying into Bishop, and they will be flying from Denver, LA, and San Francisco through March 26th. But the exciting news is we will have three flights coming into Mammoth this summer, two of them from Advanced Airlines, and they are flying directly into Mammoth. Summer service begins June 16th and runs through September 12th. And if you book...

18:23 By May 30th and fly by September 12th, you can get an extra 20% off. There is a booking code that's on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism website. It's all caps EARLYBIRD20. United also will be flying this summer. They'll be flying from San Francisco into Bishop. And that service starts June 4th and runs through September 6th. And there is a booking code. I think it's the same one, but I need to double check on that. It's on the website.

18:53 So that's what's happening on air service, which we're very excited about. Regarding marketing, our partnership with the Anaheim Ducks is rolling. We have a series of four videos that are now running in the stadium during games, home games, and the final two with an enter-to-win sweepstakes for a vacation to Mammoth Lakes.

19:15 We've also increased our air service commitment to San Francisco by adding an additional $100,000 in market to promote flights and visits to Mammoth Lakes this summer. Let's see. On the international front, international markets continue to open for long-haul travel into the USA, which is great. Bookings Mono County-wide for the summer and autumn 2022 continue to strengthen.

19:41 And it has been reported, and most people know, that international travel restrictions to enter the USA are in the process of loosening. So that's good. From our content and communication and PR department, Mammoth Lakes Tourism will be hosting the Midweek Travel Journalists Association this fall. And for all the latest information on MLT, some people may not know that you can actually sign up for our community newsletter.

20:08 Visit mammoth.com slash industry slash tourism dash newsletter. There is a weekly option for that and also a monthly option. All that information is also on the Visit Mammoth website, in case you didn't write that down while I was saying it. Sorry.

20:25 Events. Events are back. We're super excited about that. The event funding process for 2022 has begun. Applications are open through this Friday, March 18th at 5 p.m. That's when they close. And this year we are committing the largest amount of funding to date for this process. So anybody who's interested in hosting an event, reach out to Dakota Snyder at MLT if you need more information. And again, that closes on Friday.

20:54 Get to it pretty quickly. We had an events forum today. Actually, it's still going on right now until 4 o'clock. It was up at the village. It was very well attended by both and had about 10 speakers from MLT, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management, lots of event promoters and producers there. And it was great to see that crowd. And finally, we are helping to host a

21:23 A workshop tomorrow and also on, I don't know the other date, so forgive me, but it's tomorrow, March 17th, Google My Business. This is part of the High Sierra Visitors Council. Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Visit California have partnered with strategic marketing firm, Miles Partnership, for virtual workshops that provide hands-on assistance for optimization of your business's presence on Google, Yelp, and TripAdvisor.

21:51 The first one, again, takes place tomorrow. You can reach out to Emily Bryant at MLT. Her email address is ebryant at visitmamoth.com for details. And I can definitely say from my standpoint that featuring your business on Google helps a lot. So hopefully we'll get lots of people attending that. Sorry, that's a lot of information with that. I will stop. Does anybody have any specific questions I can answer? And if I can't answer them, I will bring back the right answers soon. John, I see your hand up.

22:22 Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you, John Morris. John, do you have any update on what's happened with air service out of Bishop? This year? Yeah, for the summer. I'm assuming that the updates, as to the Mammoth Airport, do you have any updates on what's happened to Bishop? Yes, I'm sorry if I wasn't clear. So United will be flying in and out of Bishop. That begins June 4th and runs through September 6th, I believe.

22:50 June 4th through June 19th. And that's out of San Francisco, John, only. That's the one flight. And that will be on Saturdays and Sundays, June 4th through June 19th. And then from June 24th to September 6th, it's daily except for Saturdays. And again, all that information is on the site. But yes, the one flight flying into Bishop this summer will be United from San Francisco. Okay, great. And one other point I just want to share with my fellow council members and those who may be listening.

23:20 The money that you were just talking about at the end of your presentation, John, with the Visit California project with Google sort of optimizing search for the business, if I'm not correct, and I may be wrong because that happens frequently around here, that money, I believe, came from the Economic Development Agency. It was a $500 million national program that in states that had offices about their recreation.

23:50 That money would get targeted and would move to deal with things like sustainable recreation, messaging having to do with people on public lands and to support recreation issues. Because California does not have an office of outdoor recreation, the $50 or $60 million went instead to visit California.

24:11 Which is a marketing organization, nothing wrong with any of this. And you can see how it trickles down to the field of where it ends up. So it's just something for all of us to keep in mind. If the state of California had an office of outdoor recreation, a lot of that money might have been coming in to help some of the messaging that Mammoth Lake Turb is doing around education and how to recreate responsibly and things like that. Just a little footnote, but I thought that was worth sharing with everybody. And John, if I'm wrong on that, please let everybody know.

24:39 I'm not sure, but that sounds good to me. Okay, we'll go with it. Thank you. All right. Thank you, John. Any other questions for John? No? Okay, seeing none. John, thank you again. Great update. Great. Thanks for your time today. Appreciate it. Okay. Is that it? Then I see nobody else's hand up. Okay. I'm going to call that done then. We're going to move on to item number six, which is a workshop.

25:12 Which is a joint workshop with the Recreation Commission. And I think that Stu, you're going to go with this? Oh, there it is. Linda, I can jump in while Stu's chatting. Okay, all right. Thanks, Betsy. You're welcome. The commission requested to have our annual workshop with the CHAM Council. We always really appreciate.

25:36 The time that we get to spend, we are your appointed advisory body, and you have a couple of recreation-related items on your agenda later on today, so this was a good fit. The commission did meet on March 1st to finalize our agenda, and so the first item that we had, I'll see if Stu wants to add anything, but if not, we'll just go ahead and, I don't think we really, okay, we, thanks Stu.

26:02 I don't think we really, I don't think we, I think we all know each other. I don't think we've not had any new appointments to the commission, nor have we had an election since we last met virtually a year ago. So I think we can probably dispense with the introduction piece. I have asked Sean Turner as our longest serving commissioner to kind of just keep an eye on the time and just kind of keep us on track. It is a pretty big agenda, but not to worry, Bill, we do not actually plan to review the entire Parks and Rec Department strategic work plan.

26:32 There are a couple of areas, though, that we do want to focus on. One item on your agenda tonight is a revision of the Chapter 2.4 ordinance, the powers and duties of the Recreation Commission. We have a couple of changes. We just want to briefly review in case you have questions.

26:52 We do just want to briefly talk about kind of the annual work program, not of the entire department, but of the commission specifically. We're the first part and we want to kind of talk about the recreation amenities we have on our list. Then we also, one area where I think we want to take a deeper dive is with the new Office of Outdoor Recreation coming on board. You also have a discussion item about MLR later on your agenda.

27:16 The commission would just like to chat a little bit about how you envision the commission engaging with both of those bodies. And then finally, we do want to talk a little bit about youth sports funding. There's a lot of need, as you might imagine, coming out of the pandemic. And then finally, just talk about kind of the council's vision for recreation in the community over, you know, the next one to three years or possibly longer. So hopefully that covers everything. And Madam Mayor, do you have anything that you'd like to add to that agenda or revise?

27:46 Nothing that I can think of right now, thanks. Okay. Thank you. So with that then, I will just go ahead and kick us off with the revision of Chapter 2.4. It's on your agenda later. It's Item 11.3. And back in, and Stu can jump in on this, but back in 2014 when MLR was formed, the commission took a look at this. We were directed by council to take a look, but as everything was still sort of in flux, we...

28:15 Made some revisions, but we didn't actually move forward with the adoption process, but now we're ready to do that. So the biggest ones are renaming the commission to be more aligned with the department, and that's renaming us as the Parks and Recreation Commission. Also including arts and culture in recreation programming references. That's something that the department has done some of in the past. We have a youth camp that's...

28:43 Performance focus, some other things, but that was part of the direction back when MLR was formed was for the department to move more into recreation as comprehensive, including arts and culture. The other items are revising our powers and duties, including reviewing the CIP, which we appreciated Hayes coming to present to us the CIP at our last meeting just to talk about recommendations.

29:09 On CIP and also major deferred maintenance projects, which we've had many and still do. And then a couple more. The commission would no longer conduct public hearings, but would participate in them when they were undertaken by the by the town council, essentially. And then.

29:31 As you know, the commission prior to the formation of MLR, we were the recommending body on Measure R. We have not been since 2014, but we do engage in that process with MLR. So that's just updating that language. And then revising. Finally, I wanted to add a section. Currently, the commission, we're volunteers. We're happy to be public appointees. We do not receive stipends.

29:59 There is still language in the ordinance that we could in the future if the council so chose. But one thing that I have really valued as commission chair has been I've had some opportunities to attend some conferences. Last week I was actually just in Sacramento at the state park and recreation conference. And so this is just the addition of a section that would allow us to receive reimbursement.

30:23 You know, and it would go through the same process as, you know, staff essentially. But those are the additions. So we just wanted to see if you had any questions or wanted to talk about any of those. Okay. No one seeing no questions. I don't have anything to add there. So that brings us on to our annual work program and the work program of the commission specifically. At first, I really

30:54 We're really excited for the CRC to be coming online in 2022. We're super excited. That's obviously been a big focus of the work of the commission and of the department over the past several years. We have a programming committee that's Laurel Martin and Dan O'Connell, who Dan unfortunately couldn't be here today, but they're working closely with staff on developing the programming for the CRC. So it's going to be a really great addition to our community. So we're excited about that.

31:24 And then on deferred maintenance, I think, you know, all of us on the commission, we just really want to express our appreciation to the council for your commitment to really providing funding through the budgeting, you know, the way that the budgeting process works. It's been great, the things that we've been able to do. During the pandemic, we've all seen how essential, you know, getting outside is and how important parks are and to really have our parks and facilities have some much needed long-awaited upgrades.

31:52 Very much appreciate it and appreciate the work of staff too. You know, our parks maintenance department, you know, we don't always see them at these meetings and that's because they're out there doing the work. So I just want to acknowledge them. A little bit, Chair, just on deferred maintenance, I wanted to throw some numbers out there. So I think since we started this program in 2017, we've invested over $750,000, so three quarters of a million dollars into our parks.

32:22 I mean, that's just a fantastic investment, well needed, going to the right places. It's been a very thoughtful, methodical process through the commission and the community. So I just want to applaud the commission on their great work with that. And then the one project that's actually out for bid right now is the Whitmore Borefield project. So that's Borefield number two. I know everybody gets a bit sideways on what is Borefield one, two and three at Whitmore, but it's the lowest field at Whitmore, furthest from the road.

32:51 And that one is probably our most outdated, most in need of repair. So we have what we believe is a very ambitious program of work to update that facility with new infield mix, new fencing, new backdrop, shortening the field to actually align it with high school softball and little league dimensions. When those fields were originally built, back when probably Dennis Rotner was here, and I think they were built by a lot of our community members.

33:21 They weren't sized to really any specific activity. So what we're trying to do is make them a little bit more constrained for those specific uses that we're seeing through our community, such as Little League, high school softball and so forth. So that project is out for bid right now. It's about a quarter million dollar project. And then some other programs at work were underway right now, a bit more pool. As you know, we have some tennis court maintenance to do.

33:49 Some irrigation work at Shady Rest. So we're looking to invest by the end of this year about $350,000. So again, just a tremendous amount of money going into our park. So thank you. Thanks, Stu. Any questions on any of those projects? I had one. Stu, the grant that you applied for for the kind of fix-up and expansion, a little bit of Whitmore, when will that be? When will we hear about that one? Yeah, that's the Prop 68.

34:21 Regional Park Program. Yeah, so that's the Whitmore Recreation Center and that multi-use trail with fitness stations. That program was bumped back to close end of January due to that COVID thing. But I think we're looking at probably late spring, early summer for that announcement. Okay. All right. Thank you. Any other questions at this point for anybody? Yes, Stu. On the ball field number two,

34:50 Ball Field 1 has lights on it. Would the new rebuild of 2 put lights on it as well? No. No. We talked to Little League, and what they've said is that if we upgrade those two fields for use, one of those needs to be lit for their tournaments and leagues and their programs. So that's kind of where we're going. What we want to do, though, Councilman Sauser, is to actually make sure those lights work and they're efficient. So we're looking at, you know, the next phase to update that similar field.

35:20 But we prioritized, the commission prioritized number two because it was in the worst state of repair. So we're going to try and get back to field one with the next round of deferred maintenance money, and that would include the lighting upgrades as well. Is that more cattle breaking through the lower gate and eating field two? It has many uses down there, Bill.

35:45 We need to, actually the cattle get on the synthetic turf, believe it or not, and I don't think there's much there to eat, but they leave some, you know, friendly gifts for us. So anyway, that's always, that's a different story. Okay. Thank you for the question. Okay, I don't see any other questions. Go on ahead. Thanks, Stu. And we really, with this workshop, we really, we do want to engage in a dialogue with the council. I don't just want to talk at you.

36:12 Our next section are our recreation amenities list that we are working through. I don't know if you have it all in front of you. Stu just touched on a couple of those projects. And I think our question for the council is, these are, by the way, in order. Obviously, the Whitmore track and sports field improvements are the project that Stu just talked with.

36:34 The Prop 68 funding is grant dependent. We're really hopeful. It would be a bit of a long shot to get that grant, but, you know, we have a pretty good track record, so we're optimistic. But then they're really kind of in just order of priority. And so we're happy to talk about if there's anything missing from the list. Some of these items are on the CIP but not funded.

36:56 Those are lower on the list. So I didn't know if anyone from commission has anything to add or if council has any questions or comments on these projects specifically. Awesome. And I'm sorry if I missed this in the work plan, but what is left to be done at the disc golf park? Is it like the branding? Opening it officially? Oh, officially opening it. Okay. We had a little interruption with COVID.

37:28 Thanks for that question. So we've got a few things to do. Remember, we were adding last fall, we added those recreational tee pads, the smaller tee pads. And this spring, we have to come back and add those tee signs for those tee pads. And then we did that wonderful Adopt a Whole program through the community. We've sold, I think, all but maybe one or two Adopt a Whole programs. So to the chair's point, yes, we actually need to formally christen, perhaps welcome, open.

37:57 The disc golf course to the public. So we're very excited about that. So that'll be this spring. Cool. I just am curious about the ranking of that, I guess, since it seems like it's very close to the finish line. Yeah. And that's...

38:13 Yeah, and that's why it's kind of in the middle of the list, because for the commission, you know, we, you know, we're happy to champion staff and work closely with them, but you'll see if you actually look at their work plan, kind of where that falls versus where something falls in a priority for the commission, because for us, like from our standpoint, aside from actually like having a formal opening, and we recognize it's been well used throughout the pandemic. So that's kind of the difference in our work plan versus staff.

38:42 Thank you. Yeah, so thanks for the question. Thanks, Sarah. John? Thank you. A couple questions. One is, would it be possible to get a copy of the 2022 Strategic Work Plan as a PDF? It's not in the pack. I got a hard copy of it. It'd be great to have a PDF copy if you have something like that. So I was looking a little bit for a map.

39:09 Of these things. And the community dog park, is that tied to the grant from, was it T-Mobile? Is it tied to that? Yes. I'll jump in. It's, Council, remember you've previously allocated the $100,000 from the general fund, and then we're adding the T-Mobile $50,000. So we have that $150,000 right now. And we're just trying to finalize the location for that web.

39:37 We're simultaneously working with GWP and then Mono County for a site at Whitmore, right? So we've got these kind of running concurrently. So we're working through the Whitmore option, but we're also really desperately trying to find a site in town that we can locate that dog park. Okay, good, because I know the Forest Service, we got a little hopeful there for a while, but they're...

40:03 You know, buzz killing that pretty aggressively. So it's good you're doing that. I know, Dan, at some point, whenever Dan feels appropriate, probably not today, but there are some development projects that may be coming forward that may be able to open up some land that otherwise might have been restricted for recreation uses, but I don't want to get into all that now, but there may be another opportunity there as we go forward. On the MAC,

40:32 On the MAC project, tell me what the Recreation Commission's involvement is in that, because I'm also under the understanding, Dan, in practice if I'm wrong, that there is a consultant who's out working on kind of a feasibility analysis for that, and I want to make sure I'm not getting my projects mixed up here, but how does the MAC fit into the purview of the Recreation Commission?

40:59 And I'm going to let Stu and Dan speak to that because I am an employee of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and we are working with the town on that. So I'm just going to stop my video and mute myself while they answer that. Sorry to put you on the spot there, Betsy, but yeah. I can speak to that, John. This is Dan. I think that, you know, the role in that is if we look at the arts and culture side of recreation, there's definitely some...

41:26 Discussion there, some of the various members have been involved in a lot of the other, like the outdoor venues and planning and those types of areas. So probably not a detailed, from a commission standpoint, a lot of the actual MAC itself, the building, definitely keep the commission informed as we deal with shared staffing and some work that way as a potential looking forward. The other side of that is...

41:49 The Mammoth Lakes Foundation site, there's eight acres there that the current Edison Hall is on, the MAC would go on. We have spoken with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation regarding some potential uses on that site, and one of those is longer term looking at a smaller amphitheater there, which would definitely be an outdoor venue coming through here. It is a potential site for a dog park and other uses there.

42:16 We'll talk about that a little more later today in our capital improvement program. We've had some good initial discussions with Mammoth Lakes Foundation who are supportive of us being engaged in that process with them. We have more work to do for that. The other element there would be a child care facility, and to the extent that we have any recreational elements related to that, this is younger children, so maybe not so much on the rec side, but if we do, definitely have that discussion there.

42:45 And then we like the fact that that property where it's at by the college and stuff and on our MUPS, it does ultimately make an easy linkage from the PATH system, from the MUPS system to our Community Recreation Center. So there's always those linkage pieces plus the linkage to the library and the site there. So as we get these types of facilities linked together, they're definitely part of our...

43:10 I'll say resort slash recreational amenities that we have in our community for our residents and our visitors. So linking them together in different ways, I think adds added value to any of them standing alone. Okay, so we're thinking that, I mean, obviously those things have to come.

43:31 Come together, but those types of things, the facilities would fall under the purview of the Recreation Commission. Is that what we're thinking? They'd be engaged in it, so definitely have that discussion and with our recreation staff involved in that, whether it be coming into the Recreation Commission for some of those, for direct input, not as much probably in terms of the actual MAC building, but the other elements for sure. The MAC building itself, some of the major...

43:58 You funding falls more or major R or MLR, if you will, and then the current users. But we had definitely engaged the commission in that discussion, but it's a little bit different than just pure recreation, that component of it. So I would say there's a linkage there, but not an absolute falling underneath the recognition only. Okay, good. Well, it's good to know that as these things may, hopefully they will come together in a positive light. And Dan, do we, because I know the council talked about

44:28 Wanting to get that report back from the consultant on the MAC as part of our budget process? Do you have any timeline or date on that when that might be coming back? I don't have the hard date, but if our memory serves, I think it was mid-late April to get that report back. And so we'll be bringing that in, looking at some of the feasibility of the user groups. He's out, Bill Blake was the consultant, going out and meeting with the various user groups, showing the current layout that we believe becomes an affordable project.

44:57 And how well does that line up with needs? And if there's any real red flags there, we can adjust accordingly. So we're waiting for that feedback before we finalize some of those elements and see where we're at in that process. Good. Okay. So, Brent Commission, we all know as much as we all know. So that's all kind of coming together in the next month or so. And I think, finally, the bike park pump track concept.

45:23 I had conversations with Joel Rathje talking about the situation that's happening out in Shady Raths with the winter grooming program. And we also were talking about the SHARP projects and getting trails built in Sherman's Meadow and mentioned to the new district ranger that, you know, priority for the town is to get a bike park pump track.

45:45 things cited somewhere and he was not familiar with what a bike park pump track is. So I would encourage the chair and Stu and other members of the commission maybe to reach out to our new district ranger, get yourselves acquainted because you guys are going to have a lot, you know, you will have some interface with the Forest Service come hell or high water. So I would encourage you to maybe start getting a relationship going with the new district ranger.

46:11 Those are my questions. I'll have some more as we go through the rest of this, but thank you very much. Okay. Who is going to continue? Let's see.

46:22 Are you? Thanks. And thanks for the questions. And also, some of these items are on the CIP discussion list that's later in the council's agenda. So I'll be back in my foundation role for that one, if needed. Betsy, if I could, I do want to jump in briefly and just say there is one other additional item on. It's not necessarily listed on this agenda, to my knowledge. And that's just the town council town with regard to amenities. We are going to need to address an outdoor events.

46:52 Location sometime in the immediate futures. You know, as I've been told for 15 years, this is the last year that Sam's Wood Site is going to be available for Bluza Palooza. But we are really holding ourselves back as a community by not having a outdoor events location that events like Bluza Palooza, like my event, can make and invest.

47:16 Thank you, Sean, for continuing to champion that because I, you know, we couldn't be more.

47:46 Dependent on that. So thank you for that. All right. Okay. Let's keep going. Awesome. Thanks, Sean. So do any of the commissioners have anything to add on any of the recreation amenities on our project list? The commission spent, we've spent a fair amount of time working on our portion of the strategic plan and also grading ourselves, which is always fun. So it's a tool that I think is really helpful and that we're really, really proud of. So Laurel, Christy, do you guys have anything to add?

48:18 Okay. And then just kind of the next part of the commission's strategic work plan are just our areas of focus, which are, you know, advocacy. We really, really relish our role, I think, as liaison between the community and town staff and the community and town council. So, you know, we're out there, we're out there, you know, on the trails and the parks, participating in programs. And we just, we really, I think, enjoy that role a lot and appreciate the opportunity to serve.

48:48 And community engagement obviously has been a bit challenging during the pandemic. A lot of Zoom. It's good and bad, as we all know. So, you know, we hope to continue. We're really excited to go back to meeting in person in Suite Z at our April meeting. So that will be good. But we are hopeful that the Brown Act will allow for kind of a hybrid format so that we can have good public participation in whatever manner works best for individual members of the public.

49:17 And then youth sports. We engage regularly with our youth sports organizations.

49:24 A lot of parks and recreation departments do youth sports programming through the departments. And as you know, we are a small but mighty department. We don't really have that capacity. So we really rely on, you know, on these organizations in our community to provide those services for our youth. And we'll get into that a little bit more, but those are kind of the major areas of focus. We have a workshop coming up. We do two workshops annually with the commission with our youth sports funding recipients to talk about their needs.

49:53 In terms of facilities and just how we can support them, how the staff can support them. So, Stu, do you have anything to add on that section? I think the workshops that we schedule with those youth sporting organizations is extremely valuable because it's really their opportunity to convey their opportunities, concerns, issues, you know, struggles, whatever they may be, to the commission and then through staff and council.

50:22 I know Laura was a big advocate of getting those, you know, workshops underway. And we do one for the winter group typically in March. And then we do our kind of summer, fall organizations later in the fall. So again, just very productive. We really value that time to get in front of those youth sporting organizations. And then we time it conveniently with our funding process. So there's a little bit of a...

50:49 Carrot there to encourage those organisations to participate. But, you know, as Betsy said, you know, we greatly value those organisations to provide those recreation services that we just don't have the capacity to deliver. So they've been expanding, they've been contracting, and our role, certainly with the town and certainly through our commission.

51:15 Is to make sure that their runway, you know, is wide, you know, we're minimizing those barriers, certainly, hopefully from a financial point of view or regulatory point of view, or really, if you look at the deferred maintenance program, it's broadening those organizations opportunity to deliver those programs and service to our community. So, you know, extremely valuable opportunity in front of those organizations with the workshops. And again, the commission does a great job of being that conduit. So that's all I have. Thank you.

51:45 I had something with regard to youth sports. I know we're going to talk about youth sports funding here in a little bit, but I just want to say briefly, with regard to the youth sports volunteers and leaders of those programs, my God, the past two years have been incredibly brutal on all of us. And as Betsy said at the beginning of this, you know, we all volunteer our time, whether we're involved in the Recreation Commission here like this.

52:12 And then when we meet with the youth sports groups, I think everyone's just feeling very beat up over the past couple of years. And I think that it's very important that what we try and do on the commission is really recognize the efforts that they contribute to the communities. And this has been pointed out to me by numerous people, most recently, Ted Carlton, actually, this last summer, when we were coordinating with all the nonprofits that were involved at Bluesapalooza.

52:39 You know, everyone is just feeling very much beat up. And I think that it's really important that we as a community recognize the volunteers that go into leading our youth specifically in the sports and other activities. So I know we try and recognize that and just want to pass on to town council as well. Please, any kind of recognition that you can help provide to our volunteers of this community, they need to hear it. We need to hear it. They need to hear it more than anyone. Thank you.

53:10 All right. Thank you very much. All right. Thanks for going to talk about. Yeah, so the commission is really eager to chat with the council about how you see the commission engaging with our new office of outdoor recreation. I understand that the hiring process is underway for that new position and also MLR. We know that MLR has gone through a bit of a transition.

53:40 You know, over the past couple of years. And so we would just, I think, really appreciate some conversation, some direction on how you sort of see these three entities working together because, you know, as John alluded to, obviously, you know, with the Forest Service, you know, how is that working with, you know, the Commission versus the Office of Outdoor Recreation versus MLR to just try and keep a really streamlined approach and, you know, for the benefit of our community. At the end of the day, that's what we're really here for is the benefit of community recreation.

54:10 So I think we'd all appreciate your thoughts on that. And I don't know if the other commissioners have specific questions or can jump in as needed. So, Madam Mayor and Betsy, I'm wondering if, because the council doesn't really have an up-to-date report on the status of the recruitment for the office, for that Office of Outdoor Recreation and the lead person on that. Maybe Dan could just give us all a little bit of an update of where we're at with all that.

54:39 And then I certainly got a couple of ideas and comments I'd really like to share with everybody. Super. Okay. Dan, do you want to? Yes, thank you. Yeah, the initial interview process has been completed for an outdoor rec manager. Right now it's been narrowed down to one lead candidate doing follow-up work on that at this point. And we'll either have that done this week here, today, tomorrow, or tomorrow I should say, and or first part of next week.

55:09 See if we actually, if we can put an offer together and if they accept or not. It would most likely be out given the timeline and stuff of getting somebody on board. We're probably still out, you know, 30, 60 days. And then secondly, the office is structured with a second position, more of a programs type person or tech person, technical side, which would follow this. So they would be, that would be out and on board.

55:38 Ideally prior to the first of the fiscal year or a little sooner maybe if we can get them up in the June time frame to get started. To have that group there and they'll be kind of learning their program as they move forward. We have a lot of work program items laid out for that office and for the elements there. A lot of that's dealing on the National Forest side. A little less in terms of, you know, the municipal recreation side, but there's definitely the ongoing interface between the two. You really can't separate it completely.

56:08 As seen with Shady Rest Park, it's seen with our trail system, the MUPS. It's part of Whitmore and dealing with LA and other BLM further out and access that way with other agencies. And so there is a lot of overlap in terms of that. I'd say the one element that ties to that as well is Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the work they're doing through Adopt-A-Trail, through the trash cleanup. They help with the grant program for...

56:36 Prop 68 grants for Whitmore expansion. So there's relationships between all of those and that defining that roles and responsibilities will be a kind of a key element working through that. I think the other side to that is it does give us that extra capacity, especially in the linking of our municipal rec to our outdoor rec in terms of public lands and having that stronger linkage in there. And so when we're working with one, we know what that looks like going back to the other.

57:03 You look at the Community Recreation Center coming up, great project. I think it's really going to be added value to the community. How do we make sure that's linked in with the MUPS that are there? How does that link in out to the Sherwin's trailhead slash trails? So there's a one-stop shop there that people can go from point A to point B, and whether they're hiking, walking, biking, they can get there, those types of elements. So a lot of relationship there.

57:30 Until the bodies are on board and we get that dialogue going, it's a little up in the air, if you will, because once we get them here and skill sets and tie in, it will be part of that process. So I wouldn't say it's absolutely nailed down at this point, but definitely that relationship will be there. Well, and whoever that officer is will hopefully be our conduit to our federal partners and create.

58:00 Perhaps even a better relationship than we have today and take that job off of Dan's plate. So when you're talking Mammoth Creek Park East, when you're talking Mammoth Creek Park West, the part that belongs in the Forest Service, Shady Rest, our trail system, which all has to do with the Rec Commission, he is going to be the one to help us broker those deals and have a good or better relationship than we currently enjoy.

58:29 If I could just to follow up on that, he or she, to Bill's point about engaging with the federal agencies, there's another piece of this I think we all need to be very keenly aware of. How many of you are aware and know what the Mammoth Donut Project is? Does everybody know what that is? I give it a shot, don't I? What's that? Sorry, John. It's like you're a shot. You need to go back on mute. Thank you very much.

59:00 And then presented to the commission, Councilmember Whitworth. Okay, good. So we all know 50,000 acre fuels treatment project that is critically important. If the town burns down, I don't know if the Zoom meetings will save us.

59:19 So, to Bill's point, that the liaison to the federal agencies, certainly it's in the sustainable outdoor recreation space, and I want to talk about that when we get to vision for community recreation, we get to this later on the agenda. But that, I would imagine, is going to be a significant part of the workload for that person to make sure that that project, that fuels work project, is not going to be done at the expense of any of the recreation amenities that we have in the community. We want to come out of that project

59:49 Thank you, John. Thank you.

1:00:22 I think so, yeah, and I think, you know, we're just, we're in a really unique position with so many of our community recreation assets held, you know, through partners, you know, whether it's LADWP down at Whitmore, whether it's Shady Rust Park, Mammoth Creek Park East, it's, those relationships are just going to be really important, and I think just having a person designated in that role will have a lot of, a lot of value for, for community recreation.

1:00:47 I don't have a whole lot to say on the other pieces of our strategic work, which are engagement with industry associations. And then just there's a California action plan for just it's really just related to all the things that the commission does in terms of advocacy. But I'd like to talk now about youth sports funding, because the entire time I've been on the commission for almost 10 years now and Sean even longer than me. And, you know, every year.

1:01:16 The requests always, you know, exceed the funding availability, but the commission would really like to talk a little bit about the council's willingness to consider increasing the current allocation to youth sports funding. And Sean, you know, Sean couldn't have said it any better in terms of what, you know, what these folks do and provide for our community is so important. And it's really important that, you know, we as the Recreation Commission really just champion them and advocate for them.

1:01:45 So I'd like for some of the other commissioners to talk a little bit kind of about why we do want to bring forward this request. And Stu can also talk a little bit about his recent conversation with the county who also contribute to that fund. So, Sean, do you want to start since you're...

1:02:03 An eloquent champion of youth sports funding. Well, I'm just a big advocate because, yeah, the entire time that I've been on the commission, we have not increased the amount that's going to youth sports funding. Every single year, there's more requests than there are the money that we actually have. And as I said earlier, it's very important to me that we are not only recognizing the work that we are doing, but financially supporting them. It's difficult for them to go out.

1:02:30 Thank you so much.

1:02:59 I did already say that, and I just want to reiterate that and very much ask for that. So, yeah, saying the same thing. Yeah, I'll echo Sean's pretty much said everything I think we're all feeling, but being new to the rec commission too and being part of the youth workshops for the last, the two workshops we had, it's really special to see how important all of this programming is to all the volunteers.

1:03:28 I have friends now that are coaching some of these programs. It's just, you know, I have a kid now, and it's just really cool to think about them coming up in these programs. I personally can't think of a better use of funding, but it is, it's dismal, and it, I definitely think that it should be increased, so it would be great if that could be considered. Just sort of a point of order, Madam Mayor, what, are we on item four, youth sports funding? Did we just jump down to that?

1:03:58 Okay, I want to come back to something on that, but when, has the commission settled on an ask amount? Do you guys have an amount you think would be appropriate for the town council to consider? I know we can't take any action today.

1:04:11 But I think that would be very helpful. I think I'm certainly inclined to be generous and not to be generous, to be intelligent and smart and to invest back in the community. We are doing pretty well with the town council's budgeting process, but I think it would be very helpful to get a recommended amount from the commission that's appropriate, that's not going to make for a lot of crazy stuff and irresponsible spending.

1:04:37 That would be helpful, and I don't know when that would be agendized, Dan, when we would actually take any action on that. Yeah, if I may jump in a little bit, thank you. Yeah, we could have that discussion today to bump that funding somewhat. I know Stu's had some discussions with the county, and I'll ask him to jump into this a little bit.

1:04:55 We had kicked it around. The staff level is something we looked at a budgetary adjustment for, but wanted to have this discussion about the rec commission and just making sure it's still the priority there. And I'll say anytime we're putting dollars out for the community, it's this, it's our arts and culture side, it's others. We never have enough. It's one of those elements that the funding requests and to exceed the allocations almost regardless.

1:05:22 Definitely understand the passion for that and feel for that. So we have looked at that. Stu, if you want to jump in a little bit with the discussion with the county. Our goal is kind of between what the county is doing and what we're doing is try to get to $45,000 in total commitment. So, Stu, if you can walk through that briefly, that will help us kind of maybe shorten.

1:05:41 Shorten the discussion here a little bit on that as a goal. Yeah, and Stu, if I can just jump in really quick, John, I think the commission's goal today was really just to take the council's temperature on whether you'd be willing, you know, through the budget process to consider an increase in this funding. And so that's really, I think, what we're looking to achieve. And so Stu can get into, I think, more specifics on the numbers and the county's contribution as well. And I would add in there that having been in the nonprofit lane myself,

1:06:09 I would expect the ask to always be over what the give is. It is their job to advocate for that and to bring us a request to maximize theirs. So what we really need to do and what I'm sure will happen at Stu working with senior management, Mr. Holler over there, they will come up with an appropriate amount, not necessarily to fund what the ask is, but to fund what the needs are.

1:06:38 So, Stu, if I may, when you kind of speak to us about this, it'd be nice to know, you know, what is the current, you know, contribution between the town and the county? What are those funds used for in a little bit more specific manner that, you know, maybe we're not totally aware of? And then how an increase in that contribution would change things? What would that add to the menu here? Thank you. So just really briefly, we currently have a budget allocation.

1:07:07 of $36,800. $8,000 of that comes from the County of Minor. So the town's contribution has been static, as I think we've all recognized for almost a decade, at $28,800. I had a great conversation with Supervisor Corliss, and she's willing to bring forward a recommendation to take their funding from $8,000 to $10,000.

1:07:34 So if we're willing to consider an increase from $28,800 to $35,000, that'll meet us right there at the number of $45,000. How we got to $45,000 is the funding request we get is anywhere from $45,000 to $50,000 plus. Those funds, to answer your great question, meets and serves about 1,200 kids throughout.

1:08:02 Eastern Sierra being in Mammoth Lakes. And because this is a county-wide program that we took the county funds and combined it with our youth sports funding process, it meets and serves those 1,200 kids throughout the region. Additional funding really allows more of those kids to be involved in the program. So a lot of those funds that we give them is able to scholarship more kids to participate in their programs and services. They have fixed costs that keep going up and up. I know uniform costs keep going up, equipment costs keep going up.

1:08:31 We haven't increased our funding, as we said, for a decade. And, you know, in my fee schedule proposal that's coming up, you know, just in this last year, everything's increased by 10%. So if you look at a 10-year period of time, we are, you know, quite behind on kind of meeting the needs of those youth sports funding organizations. So I think we're asking, I think the commission's asking for a reasonable request, and that would meet what we think.

1:08:59 Would serve the majority of those kids and hopefully enable more of our kids throughout not only the town and the county, but joining these programs that from the parks and recreation side are really unable to provide that opportunity for, right? We just can't meet, from our point of view, all of those needs for the community, but through this program we can. So hopefully that answered your question. Yes, that's great. Thank you. Do anybody want to have any more comments in regards to the funding or questions?

1:09:28 I don't have any questions other than I would just say I'm very supportive of increasing the funding. Okay, and John, I saw your hand up. No, I'm supportive of that amount. Again, if the commission thinks this is reasonable, it's going to meet the needs. I think it's a minimum, but I'll go with it. So, Dan, would it be best to do this in the context of renewing the contract or within the budget context or both?

1:09:54 We would just do it in the context of the budget. This isn't really a contractual obligation. If the rec commission knows kind of the dollar amount they're working with in allocations, then they work through that. They make a recommendation to the town council, and then that goes out accordingly. But from a budgetary standpoint, for the amount they can work with between us and the county, if we can move that into that $45,000 range, that would be, I think, a really good step forward in terms of meeting.

1:10:21 What we see historically is some of the requests. So do I hear consensus sent from the other council members that this would be acceptable? Kirk? Yes. And Bill? Yeah, I certainly would consider it. Okay, and so would I. So I think you have, Dan, I think you have a direction there and Rob. All right, where should we jump to now? Vision for community recreation in the next one to three years?

1:10:54 Yeah, and I just want to thank the council for your consideration. I think we're all, you know, clearly aware of, you know, we know that the ask is always going to probably exceed the amount that's available. And, you know, we do have, I think, a pretty good process dialed in. But coming out of the pandemic, I think just mental and physical, you know, well-being of our youth is really critical. So I appreciate the council's support on considering that ask through the budget process. I do have one more little question about the,

1:11:24 The Sports Scholarship Fund that I understand, you know, has gotten pretty nicely funded. And is that extremely helpful then in helping kids be able to participate in sports that otherwise they wouldn't be? Is that, you know, how is that playing? Are we going to use it all in a year? How is that being worked? Yeah, and I'd love Stu to speak to that because we just, Laurel and Stu and I just, along with some staff, we just had the honor of accepting a pretty

1:11:53 Pretty fat check from Andrew Colasardo. So, Stu, go ahead and talk a little bit about our plans for the Tony Colasardo Scholarship Fund. Yeah, it's just a wonderful program. I mean, Tony's legacy lives on, right, through the commission and through this wonderful program, and Andrew has just been an incredible champion. So, really, those scholarship funds, in the context of youth sports funding, we provide X amount of scholarships for each and every youth sporting organization.

1:12:20 And then those clubs and those organizations can, you know, distribute those as needed. So that's kind of how we provide those. We're interested to have that conversation with our youth sports groups again in our workshop and just really understand the need that they have. I think that's really the question that I think the commission is trying to understand. We know there's a need, but, you know, how can we better fulfill that need, you know, either through the scholarship program and through the youth sports funding program. In the context of parks and recreation, really quickly,

1:12:50 We're really trying to drill down and connect with our kids in the schools, in the community. So we've got a great conduit through our teachers and our elementary school principal. So for instance, just a couple of examples, Doug and his new baked cooking class, which is supposed to be an amazing success of actually just eating one of the strudels that the kids made. They're doing a great job.

1:13:17 You know, one of those examples is, you know, when they're talking about measuring product, you know, and Doug says, oh, just throw a cup, you know, into the mix. Everyone just grabs all these different cups and throws them in. Well, no, no, no, there's actually, you know. Anyway, so just real life, great programs. So through that program, we're able to meet a lot of those needs in our community. So we're scholarship half of that program. We ran a winter summer, winter camp this year. We scholarship half of that. Gymnastics program, ice skating lesson programs.

1:13:47 So really what we're trying to find is, you know, an easy way to allow these kids to participate in our programs without having those barriers of a lot of these formal forms, the awkwardness of completing those forms, you know, it's very difficult. And we think the CRC that I'm talking about, you know, a little bit later with our fee schedule, that's just going to be an amazing place for these kids to be able to join our camps and programs. And the scholarship is going to be a big part of that. So just a lot. It's a great, exciting program.

1:14:15 We can talk for hours on it, but again, in the context of youth sports funding, those funds contribute to those programs as well. Okay, great. Thank you, Stu. And Stu, what's the fund balance on that now? Yeah, we just accepted a compilation of checks from Andrea of $23,000. I mean, that's just staggering. And so our fund balance is around $35,000.

1:14:45 Wow, that's amazing. That's great. That's awesome. I mean, I just can't speak any more proudly than that. Okay, great. Okay. Who wants to do the next piece? Well, I think the commission would love to hear from the council just kind of what, you know, your vision is for community recreation over the next few years, particularly, you know, the CRC has been our big project, you know.

1:15:13 It's obviously going to be opening soon. But just thinking about the future, this is my 10th year on the commission. It's my last. And so I'm really, really excited about the people that we have on the commission and the work going forward. And I just feel like our staff does amazing work. I can't really say enough good things about them. I know when we had our workshop a year ago, I think.

1:15:36 You know, there was, it was written in the sheet that, you know, all you guys did was just sit around and compliment each other, but it's, it is really true, and it's, I'd be remiss not to take that opportunity. So, yeah, so we'd really like to hear, you know, what, what should be next, you know, what should be next for the commission, for the community, and yeah, I'd just like to have a dialogue on that. Okay, council members, who would like to, John, I can see your hands up. Thank you. So, in the last couple years,

1:16:11 We've seen last, I mean, before COVID into now, we've seen kind of an explosive growth in the revenue that the town's bringing in through TOT. And as we all know, that funds a significant part of the town's budget, but it's also an inefficient, but it's a reflection and it's a barometer of the...

1:16:38 The compelling destination that is Mammoth Lakes. And whether we market, we don't market, you know, whatever. You could turn the marketing off tomorrow and we would still see people coming to Mammoth Lakes. Probably not in the numbers that we need, but they would still be coming. And it goes to really having an honest evaluation of the equity that this community and this town has to millions and millions of people all over the world.

1:17:09 What is it that compels people to come here? Obviously, recreation in all its forms and all its guises is the thing that really compels that visitation. And Bill and I spent many years working, developing MLR and doing other things. I remember having a conversation, well, what is recreation? What is this thing? Recreation.

1:17:30 Let's not forget just the value of going outside and seeing a night sky filled with stars and how millions of people in California, that's an experience that they know nothing about. So I'm really thinking that a key role for all of us, especially for municipal recreation, is the integration of the great programs and the great work and the great facilities and infrastructure that you're doing into the larger

1:17:59 The aggregated recreation pool that's compelling people to come to our community. You're obviously serving local residents with just day in, day out, but your programs, your camps, the facilities, the CRC that you're going to be managing is going to be speaking to all kinds of an audience.

1:18:18 And I think our real challenge now with you guys, with MLR, with the Office of Outdoor Recreation, with the Trails Program, with all the rest of it, is to integrate all of this stuff the best that we absolutely can so that for the residents and the visitors, people are coming here, they're having a seamless, remarkable, and memorable experience. Whether you live here, whether you're visiting here, whatever it is, it sounds easy, but it's tough. I mean, it's very tough to be integrating and working.

1:18:47 Really together. I think if we can all work together with ourselves as a town, that's one thing. But then let's throw in the Forest Service, let's throw in the Park Service, let's throw in Mammoth Resort. You can see how challenging this gets. Because we need to tell that story back to the community that, yeah, this TOT is coming in here and we're using it to keep the town running, to invest in the sustainability of our destination, and frankly, to really invest.

1:19:12 And then in the housing needs of this community. So we can be a lot more than just a labor camp for a ski area, that we can be a full, fully integrated community of Mammoth Lakes, and not just a place where people come here to work for six months and leave. And that's a goal that the recreation culture is going to make possible.

1:19:31 So those are my two cents. The other thing I just wanted to check in, and we don't have to belabor this, but the state programs, the access for all, the $700 million that the state is investing in this. Never underestimate how Mammoth Lakes...

1:19:45 Registers on the state radars. So you mentioned earlier about being able to go to conferences and engaging with state parks, engaging with state leadership. You'd say anybody in California from Mammoth Lakes, they know what that means and they've got a story to tell about when you were there. And I think we have a great story to tell to start integrating and frankly consuming some of that $700 million that the state's putting into access for all into our community. So I will cease and desist. Thank you very much. All right. Thank you.

1:20:13 Any other council people like to have a... Sure, I'll speak up, try to follow John's eloquence. In the next few years, really important things, you've got the CRC coming on board and you've got to program it. You guys have done a lot of work on that already, but until it's open and we know what we can do, we don't know how best to program that. So really important function of the commission going forward is to keep...

1:20:43 The pulse of what our users are asking for. Our camps are a hugely important piece of what you do. How much do we need to expand them? What different fields do we need to go into? And when we're looking at doing these polls and doing these things, we have to remember, you know, even though you are municipal recreation, a lot of the users, there's a lot of people I know who bring their kids up for summer camps.

1:21:11 Some of them even stay in motels and hotels. They aren't second homeowners. So getting the pulse of what the needs are is going to be critical moving forward as we hope to elevate the whole recreation scene with the new Office of Outdoor Recreation and outside of municipal and the trail system and inside of municipal. I think that the number one priority has to be how do we communicate with those who are using what is your product?

1:21:41 And then how do we alter that product to keep up with current trends and needs? You know, coming from an old guy that doesn't keep up with current trends, I suppose that's an important thing. But that's my, you know, my push for you guys, really not just looking at our own kids, but also looking at the adults, maybe even the seniors. Some of us are getting older. And what programs do we need to alter or increase?

1:22:10 To, you know, attain success. That's my two cents. Thank you. Thanks. Who would like? Sarah? Yeah. I just, as a new parent, looking at these camps especially, like my partner's from Chicago and he's like, oh, in the summer we were just at camp all day and, you know, it saved my parents' childcare and I just think about like,

1:22:40 How rough the childcare situation is in this town and how valuable it is to be able to like look at this. I'm just looking at it right now, you know, look at the weeks and like by the ages. I just think it was really well, it was really well laid out. And I'm not giving you direction as much as patting you on the back, I guess. So, but I would love to see, and I may be wrong, but.

1:23:06 Maybe something for weekends for kids, because we do have so many people in the service industry here in Mammoth where their weekends are the times that they're making money. And I do think that this is, you know, it's like childcare for a lot of people. And not everyone has a nine to five Monday to Friday. And I would love to see that demographic catered to because, yeah, that's a huge.

1:23:35 portion of our population. So that's just something that I would love to look forward to. Okay, thank you. Kirk, comments? Going through all of the information that was provided, you know, I was trying to look and see if there's any gaps that we're not filling. And at this time, you know, I'm not seeing anything. So I'm very comfortable with the direction that we're taking and the programs we're providing and everything. Thank you. Thank you.

1:24:07 I just had a couple thoughts. I very much agree with everything everybody else has said, so I'm not going to repeat any of that. But that we pay attention to developing lifelong lovers of the nature that we live in. That we, you know, something like the Valentine programs, the SNARL programs, which are wonderful, but not at all robust enough to serve the number of kids that we would like to serve in that.

1:24:36 Having taught in that program at one point, I just know how special it is. And I'd like to be able to offer that to a wider variety of people, not necessarily through SNARL, but through maybe if we can, I know we've stepped into it a little bit, but more of that within our own recreation department. That takes money and it takes commitment to doing that, but that every, you know, basically that every citizen who lives here and our visitors.

1:25:06 Would have an opportunity to learn more about our environment, to learn more about how to take care of it, to learn more how to value some of those things. I think that would be my on my wish list. So that's what I have. So I'd like to wrap this up. We're kind of getting a little long on the tooth here. So which brings us to wrap up. Yeah, thank you. I just wanted to share a story really quickly of

1:25:33 This year was the first year that Parks and Rec has done a camp over the winter break, over the winter school break for elementary school age kids. And the staff was telling me that, you know, there were kids, a lot of them through the Tony Colasardo Scholarship Camp, kids in this camp who had never been sledding, never been ice skating, never done so many of the recreation activities that we take for granted. And I don't know if Laurel wants to touch a little bit on, you know, as you know, being from the on the programming side of things.

1:26:03 But I just wanted to share that with you. And then also just throw out that, you know, Parks and Rec is for everybody. It's not just kids. You know, we really do strive to serve, you know, the population from one to 100 or, you know, under one and over 100 too. But we really do want to offer something for everyone in the community. We all know it's hard. This is a hard place to live. It's a hard place to, you know, raise a family, to work. But we're all here because of, you know.

1:26:28 The amazing recreation opportunities that this area provides. So I really appreciate those comments, Madam Mayor. And yeah, I'll just turn it over to, I'll start with Laurel and see if any of the other commissioners also want to jump in. Thanks, Betsy. Yeah, so as Betsy said, basically all of the things that you guys mentioned are both things that we think about all the time.

1:26:55 And constantly try to address and things that we need to be reminded of continuing to work on. So we really appreciate you giving us your thoughts on that. It helps us guide our strategic work plan. And the programming aspect, just like with the youth sports funding money, we know we have a higher demand than we are able to reach.

1:27:20 The last several years, in addition to the COVID challenges, the team has really worked hard to figure out ways to address that, to figure out what offerings are going to be the best and not just do the same camp year over year, even though they work to address the age breakdown, to make sure that they're grouping the kids appropriately, but still have a little bit of wiggle room for those kids that don't fit that box. And working.

1:27:43 Even more closely with the youth sports funding groups in order to figure out where there's partnerships that can fill in the gaps that the department has. And I wanted to say that I believe the youth sports funding support that we give is by far some of the best investment that the town money gets spent on. I mean, the return that we get for those kids turning them into lifelong recreators, lifelong folks who care about this place and the environment.

1:28:12 And Linda, some of the environmental stuff you mentioned is always something that I'm always trying to see ways we can figure it into the different structures that we have. So I appreciate you mentioning those priorities. So I really thank you for your time today. Appreciate this opportunity. Thank you, Laurel. Anybody else? If I could, I just want to, I guess, back up what was said earlier is that I really do see the job of the recreation commission.

1:28:42 More making sure that we are programming the facilities that we have in place. So with regard to the summer camps, I remember when we first, or I guess early on, I was a big advocate of trying to even expand the summer camps so that we could offer them to visitors. And this is when I was also sitting on the tourism board. And I really saw an opportunity for that because I've heard the exact same thing about stories.

1:29:06 And if anything, Mike, Mike.

1:29:31 The reply to that was that, well, it proved concept. We've got the opportunity to really expand the opportunity to do more winter camps.

1:29:40 So you bet I'd love to see us expand our summer camps. It's really been a challenge between labor, which we're all experiencing right now, making sure that we're providing enough balance for locals, which I certainly get. But I think that's the best thing that we can do, at least some of the lowest hanging fruit. The CRC coming online, being able to have an anchor to be able to provide that.

1:30:03 I honestly see more opportunity for the CRC in the summer than I do even in the winter with regard to the programming opportunities. So I'm glad to hear that. I feel like we're kind of mirroring each other with regard to what some of our vision is for the community. And thank you for allowing me to serve on this commission. Thank you, Sean. Thank you for all the work all of you do. Anybody else wants to speak up here, please let us know.

1:30:33 One last thing, Lynda, that I haven't done yet in this meeting is thank all of you commissioners for serving. It takes time out of your day. It takes time from your family. It is an important task you are providing your community. So heartfelt thanks. Thank you for bringing that up, Bill, because I think we didn't actually comment much on your thought of, you know,

1:30:56 Reimbursing for travel and, you know, things like that when you're able to attend. And whatever week we can do that, not being included in sort of the total sum of funding, but I would very much myself support that we take a look at that within the contract. And if any of you other town council people have a feeling about that, please speak up. Yes, I think I would even be interested in exploring giving them a stipend because

1:31:24 It's tough. As someone who is a citizen legislator, you know, it's really hard if you're working, if you have kids, to find time out of your day. And anything helps. So I would be interested in exploring that. Okay. Any other council members? No, I'd be very interested in exploring that, especially, again, all the resources that are available coming out of the state of California. And that may require some in-person

1:31:53 Presence and presentations, those kinds of things. And I think we're migrating away from Zoom or at least into a sort of a hybrid environment, but I think it's going to be pretty chaotic and as I'm sounding like a broken record, but there are hundreds of millions of dollars, even billions of dollars coming out of the state of California that's focused right on municipal recreation and the programs that we're doing.

1:32:15 And I think our story needs to be told. We need to advocate for those dollars. We've got a great team that could bring home some of those resources to the community. And I think we need to be able to support members of the Recreation Commission and staff in pursuing those things. We would be penny wide and extremely bound foolish if we didn't do something like that. So I certainly support it. Thank you. Any other comments on that?

1:32:41 I would just like to say that just really quickly, Madam Mayor, I would just really like to say that one of the reasons that the commission wanted to bring this request forward and just bring our ordinance more in line with what we do is also we would really like for the commission to be more reflective of our community. And, you know, we it is hard sometimes with timing of meetings and things. And so just anything I think that the council can do to encourage, you know, all members of our community to participate. This has been.

1:33:09 The great honor and joy of the past 10 years of my life. And I just want to make sure that's accessible to anyone who wants to be part of it. Okay. Thank you, Betsy. All right. Shall we call this then as the end of this presentation? Thank you so much. We have some other items later on in the agenda on this topic, but we shall move on. So thanks, everybody, again. And thanks for taking the time to be here at the meeting. Thank you for the time. We appreciate it.

1:33:38 Absolutely. Thank you all very much. Thank you for your service. Thank you for your time. Okay. That brings us then to the number seven agenda item, council presentations. Then point one is to introduce the newly promoted engineering manager, Amy Callanan. And I believe, Hayes, are you going to talk about this? I am. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm proud this evening to introduce and congratulate Amy Callanan on our promotion to engineering manager.

1:34:09 Amy is a licensed professional civil engineer with a master's in structural engineering. She joined our team as an associate engineer in 2019. And before joining us, Amy spent about a little over four years on planning commission. And that expertise has been put to good use. Amy has been the engineering lead on most of the recent development projects, including Residence Inn, Limelight, Sierra Nevada Resort. She also reviews most building permits.

1:34:37 Grading permits and encroachment permits for public works. Amy has been instrumental in the development of the Arcel Project and the development of many of the ongoing and forthcoming capital projects. We're going to take a deep dive into that substantial work program this evening. Over the last few years, Amy has demonstrated her strength as a leader and as a manager, and I know she'll be successful in managing her new responsibilities and her staff. And so with that, again, congratulations, Amy.

1:35:07 And I'll put her on the spot and invite her to say a few words if she's so inclined. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Salcido and Councilmembers. I would just like to say that I'm very thankful and I feel privileged to be offered this position. I have truly enjoyed every minute that I've spent working for the town, and that includes my four plus years on planning commission prior to becoming a staff member. It's been a real joy working with

1:35:37 Staff, working with other commissioners and council members and the public. And I'm just really excited to be able to facilitate our capital projects and moving forward and making this town as the best place that it can possibly be. Congratulations, Amy. I'm thrilled for you and I'm sure you're going to do a great job. Thank you. Okay, everybody. Again, a round of applause. I think Sandra's got her hand up there. Oh, there you are, Sandra. Sorry.

1:36:05 Sorry, I moved around on the screen. I think that I put my hand up. I just wanted to say, you know, congratulations, Amy. This is well-deserved. You know, in the time that Amy's been here, she has been proactive, you know, solving problems, getting things done, and we're just a pleasure to work with. So congratulations, Amy, and we're all really happy to see you transition into this new role. All right. Thank you. That's good all around. Okay. Amy, thank you. Thanks. Okay. Bye, y'all.

1:36:36 Okay, moving on then to staff presentations. 8.1, we're going to hear about a BIRD presentation on implementing services. And Hayes, that's you again, I think. It is indeed. It's the Hayes show for the first part of this meeting. So back in January this year, we executed a contract with BIRD, and this permits them to operate their scooter fleet in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:37:03 This will be a seasonal program and summer is just around the corner. So in preparation for the season's operations, our staff is working with BIRD to define some of our parking zones, our no-go zones, the slow zones, and we have a staff member currently building that in GIS. And we also thought it would be good for the BIRD team to come back before council and the public and just talk about their program and their goals and aspirations for this season.

1:37:29 And provide an opportunity for the public and the council to ask any questions. So with that, I'd like to introduce Taylor and Michael with Bird Scooters and let them take the reins on their presentation. Okay, thank you, Haisl. Welcome, both of you, and anxious to hear. Thank you very much for having us, Madam Mayor. I think we spoke to this group previously. We're more than happy to run through a deck doing an introduction about Bird and our services, but I think it might be more.

1:37:56 pertinent to speak to some of these specifics if you prefer. Your choice. Taylor, I'll hand it off to you as I think you can probably speak to the specifics a little bit better than me.

1:38:07 Yeah, absolutely. Well, thank you everyone so much again for having us. And like Hayes mentioned, we've been working closely as we move forward into spring with summer right around the corner. We are very excited to be launching in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And we're very excited by the enthusiasm that we've seen from the community. We've had a lot of tremendous outreach from our fleet manager interest for our local contact. We'll be managing our day-to-day operations.

1:38:35 And we want to join just to provide some updates. So as it looks today, we are kind of in the middle of March and our current timeline is looking like we'll be launching in mid-April. It is, of course, weather dependent.

1:38:47 You know, we're somewhat of a seasonal company, especially in the town of Mammoth Lakes. So as the weather allows, we will be launching with the city support, of course. I had a terrific meeting with the local chamber of commerce as well. So we want to make sure that we are partnering with local businesses and the community to make sure that we are seen as a terrific partner to the town.

1:39:08 To add some additional color, we've defined the operational area in collaboration with the town and will not include the Lakes Basin Trail for the time being. The USFS has given permission for operations on their own streets and trails, which is something I think we may not have yet had formal approval on the last time that we spoke. I'm sorry, Mike, sorry to interrupt. Could you say that again about the Forest Service and operating scooters on their trails and facilities?

1:39:36 Yes, so they've actually given the approval for the operation of the scooters on their trails and on their own roadways. We're speaking to the mups, John. Okay, yeah, let's be very clear with our language here, okay? Because soft surface trails, I'll speak to this in a second, but I want to make sure we're very clear about what facilities it's allowed and where it's not allowed. So sorry to interrupt. Thank you. I apologize. Forgive me if I spoke too broadly there, but certainly we are working very closely with the town to define any geofencing parameters that would prevent these from being operated in a zone that they should not be.

1:40:06 So that will be nowhere in the Lakes Basin. Nowhere in the Lakes Basin. We can also proactively exclude specific areas if it's just deemed to be inappropriate. This is very much a collaborative endeavor, even if Bird is the one who is managing the fleet, launching the fleet. We want to ensure that the city is very much involved in terms of voicing, or pardon me, the town is very much involved in terms of voicing how they feel that the services should be delivered. I know that...

1:40:34 It is very much in keeping with some of the transportation and recreation discussion that was occurring earlier within this meeting to have a service like this. So I do believe it is very timely. We're extremely excited that this is something that we can offer with, again, no financial commitment from the city while still simultaneously ensuring that we keep everybody involved. Okay. If that is probably what you have to open with, then I think we'll go to questions from...

1:41:04 Council members about this project. Okay, John? Yeah, a couple of questions here. First off, the trails program in Mammoth went through a very difficult and problematic process with the Forest Service and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area on the issue of e-bikes.

1:41:29 And I think that they've been integrated into the community. We still have some outstanding challenges with that in terms of speed and safety and things like that. The trails program has produced a number of maps, handouts. It's all available to mammothtrails.org. And I would assume that Hayes, whatever product you're developing, will get to Joel Rathje in a timely fashion such that that could be posted through mammothtrails.org. We've just gone through a very difficult...

1:41:58 Series of issues with a geothermal plant not being able to communicate effectively and efficiently with the community about programs. So I'm hoping that that will be taken care of. Is that something we can count on, Hayes? Yeah, that's fair. Like I said, we're currently working through that no-go, slow and parking zone GIS map.

1:42:21 We did receive written determination from the Forest Service that the scooters will be considered the same as e-bikes, so the same rules will apply. So it'll be pretty easy for Joel to overlay that information for both the scooter users and the e-bike users. Okay, there is a lead time involved in this, so I think whenever...

1:42:40 The BIRD folks anticipate actually launching their program. It would take a couple of weeks to make those updates to those maps and those public noticing. And I would really expect that that can happen plenty of times by the time your product is out there on the ground, the public communication stuff, which we appreciate that, you know, BIRD is not charging for this, but there are costs to the community. There are costs to the town to do this kind of work. And I think thorough and efficient communication is a really important part of this.

1:43:08 Another question is, my understanding was that there was going to be a pilot program for this. Is what we're doing now, is this still the pilot program that was delayed from last fall? Yes. And what is the time frame of the pilot program? Is this all summer? Is this for a couple months? Or what's the time frame for this? So as we are a bit of a seasonal business for the time being, we're looking at a three-season deployment, essentially until the weather is no longer appropriate to have these scooters out and about.

1:43:38 With respect to a launch timeline, what that means, as Taylor was indicating earlier, we are targeting sometime in April, again, contingent on weather and everything being aligned in terms of the communication that you were speaking to earlier, in order to be able to maximize the good weather that we have available to us. So in order to receive the most accurate and most intelligent data,

1:44:03 It is important to be able to have both that swing up when people first have these introduced into the community and kind of get a general sense of how they're using them during the time when visitors are most likely to visit Mammoth in order to be able to understand how they are taking things and how transportation might be impacted as a result with less congestion, less parking issues, those sorts of things. And finally, into some of the fall months where perhaps you don't necessarily see as much regular tourism, although there is still going to be a pretty significant amount.

1:44:32 Can inform quite a bit in terms of program development, infrastructure development, and general transportation patterns. All this is data that we're sharing in real time with the city and can do more in-depth analysis as well. Okay, because the town, I think, are we contracted with this? I mean, what, is there a term on the agreement? Or what, Dan, if you and Hayes could talk that a little bit. Actually, I invite Andy to discuss the terms of the contract because he was intimately involved with its creation.

1:45:02 Thank you. We look forward to hearing from the attorney. Thank you. Yeah, so we do have an agreement with Byrd that governs their operations. It's really detailed. It's pretty extensive. It says that they have to have geofencing, they have to have an operational plan, they have to have insurance, they have to identify us, they have to report injuries, they have to share other data. It's for a defined period of time, which I think Hayes is a year.

1:45:26 Okay, because the original, my understanding is the original,

1:45:56 The period was, what, six to eight weeks? Wasn't that going to be sort of the test pilot period back in the fall? That was the concept back when we were trying to execute a contract towards the end of last season. And like Andy said, the negotiation process took significantly longer to go through all the details. And so we've extended it for a summer season. Okay, so, but if there's a hue and cry from the public or there are problems with this, does the town have the right to be able to say,

1:46:27 Hey, nice try, but this just isn't working, and we need to terminate this agreement for the summer. Is that a possibility? Yes, there is early exit language within the agreement. Yes, there's a lot of language holding BIRD to very specific standards, and I think that if we're seeing problems and getting complaints, that'll be because BIRD is not living up to the contract, which, of course, we don't anticipate. We're sure that it will be great, but we do have resources and tools and options if things are not going well for whatever reason.

1:46:56 Okay, I just, since we, this was in front of us a while ago, I've had a number of constituents voice a wide variety, but deeply felt concerns about a program like this. And they emphasized that it's, and I'm a big fan of this type of mobility when I go to urban environments, when I go to cities, I use it all the time. We are not that kind of a place. And I think it's,

1:47:26 You know, the community is very concerned that these vehicles are going to be strewn all over the place, left all over the place, they're going to be eyesores, they're going to be nuisances, and that they will not be a good fit for this community. I'm willing to give it a chance, but I just want to make sure that on behalf of constituents I've heard from, there are real concerns about this program. And again, please forgive a little bit of frustration with another public outreach project on a very significant

1:47:56 A piece of infrastructure that's going in right next to town, but we really want to make sure that the communication to our channels, to our outlets, that we communicate with our audience, with our public, is done in a timely and efficient manner, and we're going to be watching it very closely. My thoughts. Thank you. Any other comments from council members? Yeah, a couple of questions, if I could, Linda. Of course. I understand you have already selected a local vendor who's going to be your eyes and ears here.

1:48:25 If things happen that are negative or positive, is that our point of contact or is the point of contact back to the two of you? Point of contact will be to Taylor, who is here on the call. She is going to act as the account manager for the city. This provides visibility to us in terms of any of the issues that might be arising and ensures that we have all of the technological as well as operational tools at our disposal to be able to implement the appropriate solution.

1:48:51 So we have a whole bunch of processes here to ensure that our local fleet manager can respond if there is anything, but certainly we do want to ensure that all communication does go to BIRD directly. If I may as well, I would love to speak to some of the concerns that Councilmember Wentworth raised earlier, as I do think it is important for us to work very collaboratively with the community as well. But certainly, Councilman Salazar, I don't want to take away your time.

1:49:20 Defer to you if you feel like that would be appropriate. Let's go ahead and go to the council members and we'll circle back. Yeah, most of my worries and questions have to do with how they're going to be monitored, who's picking them up. If we see something wrong and we have to call Taylor and then it has to go back to your vendor, probably there's a better solution there and our ability to go straight to the vendor. I know you have.

1:49:47 Through your programming, a way to keep track of where the scooters are? Is that going to be monitored here locally or is that going to be monitored remotely as well? I just, there are potential issues and the more closely we can be tied with whoever the local is, if that's possible, to me makes positive sense. Absolutely. I don't already know who it is and I won't be communicating with them anyway, but for the public.

1:50:14 So I believe there would be some privacy concerns if it was the general public reaching out directly to our local fleet manager. However, we do have remote capabilities to monitor the location of all of the scooters, as well as locally based means of monitoring the location of all the scooters. Moreover, we're actually sharing real-time data dashboards with the city so that the city can monitor the location of every single unit that is within the public right-of-way.

1:50:42 What status it's in, meaning is it in ride, is it available, has it been reported as having an issue, et cetera, so that all of this is completely transparent to both the city, the fleet manager, the public, as well as bird. This is something that is incredibly important to us. In terms of the day-to-day operations, you're right, that is what will ultimately ensure whether this is something that the community typically finds to be more beneficial than not. I would imagine that you will receive certain

1:51:10 Certain calls within the first three to five weeks of a deployment simply because this is something new. And anytime there is something new, it can create some hiccups or some challenges in terms of integrating. But certainly I think you find that based off of our historic experience, there is a very sharp drop off after that period as people become a little bit more accustomed to seeing them.

1:51:32 Given the size of fleet that we will have within the town, which is incredibly small, it does allow us to avoid a lot of the concerns that I think many of the residents might feel they've experienced in some of these large metropolitan hubs where they may have seen them, such as Los Angeles or San Diego. We're talking about a fraction of a fraction in terms of the number that would be within Mammoth itself, enabling us to be not only incredibly responsive, but avoid...

1:51:59 As was described earlier, these creating clutter or being strewn in locations that would be inappropriate or create an eye sore. All right. Thank you. I mean, I would assume that, Hayes, you're going to have the, you know, great detail on this of who to call when and who is there somebody from the town side that needs to be monitoring these and how that's all going to work. And I think we can circle back to that another time and not take a lot of time this evening on our internal workings of that. But back to Councilmember Sarah, any comments on this?

1:52:31 No, not really. I wasn't here. I was on leave when this was approved. I think I just kind of have the same concerns that I'm going to get a bunch of calls about this. So yeah, if we had a contact, that'd be great. But I totally understand not wanting to give that out to the general public. But I don't think I have anything over and above what John and Bill mentioned. Okay, thank you.

1:52:55 I was going to say, too, to clarify, you know, while I will be a point of contact for all of you and we'll be working very closely with the city, we do have various methods of contact for the community, for residents, business owners. We have a 24-7 phone line, email, and an in-app way to message where I get a notification and our local contact gets a notification. So it won't always be having to be routed through. We do have a lot of different ways and we'll make sure that information gets out to the community as well.

1:53:23 Okay, thank you. Thank you. And then, I think, Kirk, any comments on your part? Yes. You know, how fast can these scooters go? What's the speed? We see scooters at, sorry, Taylor, go ahead. We set them up to 15 miles per hour is the maximum speed. Okay, and, you know, that was the only thing. And so they're all licensed and everything else, just like a bicycle.

1:53:51 Yes. So state law generally boils down 99% to treat them as you would a bicycle. We have further conditions within the agreement with the town that Andy and Hayes mentioned earlier. Sorry, Mr. Morris and Mr. Hayes mentioned earlier to ensure that we have some further parameters. We can also create geo-speed controlled zones where we further reduce the speeds of the scooters. So if it becomes appropriate based off the experience of residents and business owners.

1:54:17 To create a zone where the scooters perhaps travel at 12 miles per hour, for example, we can certainly do that. It takes about 15 to 20 minutes to introduce those changes. And my last question is, so anywhere the bike trails go, then these would be allowed up into the lakes basin and that sort of thing? No. So we have an onboard GPS connected to about 200 additional sensors on every single scooter that controls where the scooters can and cannot go.

1:54:45 If somebody crosses one of the digital boundaries that we have created for the operations of the scooters, it'll slow down to about a mile and a half per hour, start beeping and flashing at the user. They will receive a notification on their mobile phone telling them that they have left the operational area and they will not be able to end their ride. They continue to incur a charge on their credit card until they return to the area that they are supposed to. So pretty good incentive to go back to where you're supposed to be. I think it's a very strong incentive. Thank you very much.

1:55:15 Okay. I just had a couple of comments on this. And, you know, again, what I'm thinking about in addition to everything everybody else is talking about is the safety factors. And by that, I mean that we have, you know, mumps, which are not, you know, huge trails. And now you're introducing another element to that. So you have bicycles and you have scooters and you have people. And most of the time, a vehicle going faster than...

1:55:43 You know, a walking speed that's made of metal and versus a person, the person will probably not prevail. And I wonder, you know, rather than say we shouldn't do this, what safety elements do you try to impart to your customers as they come in, buy this, put their helmet off on and take off? And very simply, for example, when you're on a trail.

1:56:08 You, you know, you yield to walkers and walkers, you know, should be to the far right all the time. And like in a driving lane and scooters, are they equipped with little, you know, bells to say, you know, get out of my way. Are they going to be, yeah, I just, I have this vision, have an experience with bicycles, especially on the lakes, you know, trail when they come downhill really fast. I mean, really, really fast. And it's, it's a bit intimidating when you're just walking along.

1:56:34 I wonder, you know, as someone comes in, are you talking to them? Are you giving them a handout? Are you, you know, trying to tell them what the etiquette of a multi-use trail really is? And how, and, you know, this applies to electric bikes too and bicycles. You know, are we being proactive enough to make sure that all the users can safely use our trails?

1:56:56 Excellent question, Madam Mayor. I apologize, as a lot of this information is covered in the presentation that I thought we had conducted previously, so I apologize that we skipped it over here today, as I think it may have addressed some of these concerns. To your point, first and foremost, in terms of a multi-use trail, as long as it is paved, I think it's appropriate to have the scooters there. For anything that might be gravel, we can proactively remove these scooters.

1:57:21 Simply through the use of our geofencing technology, which should eliminate the vast majority of the trails, I think, are presenting a concern with e-bikes. Another thing in terms of the safety aspect is, first and foremost, every time a user creates a new account, they are required to undergo a safety tutorial where they are taught about safe riding behavior as well as proper parking etiquette and even complete a quiz to prove that they have paid attention.

1:57:43 There is a notification that comes up every single time a user activates a ride which reminds them of specifics. We can customize that as well for any kind of local rules or regulations that might be applicable specifically to the town of Mammoth Lake so that they do receive that reminder and it is very salient every single time they take a ride. On our newer models of scooters, forgive me, I can't recall which model of scooter would likely be most available for Mammoth Lakes but we also have a motor control within it.

1:58:10 That caps the speed even going downhill. So if the scooter detects itself to be going at a speed greater than that 15 miles per hour, it will automatically throttle itself back, meaning it can only travel at 15 miles per hour. Every single scooter, regardless of make model, is equipped with a bell, a headlamp, running lights, brake lights, and taillights so that it is highly visible, can make an audible signal.

1:58:36 As well as the throttle that controls the speed at which a variable throttle, I should say, that controls the speed at which the scooter travels. That means that an individual does have the capability of ensuring that they aren't passing somebody at an undue rate of speed, but rather going at a more appropriate one simply by not depressing throttle the entire way. We also have a feature that we call, sorry, I can continue to give some more detail if you'd like. It's totally up to you. Okay, I think that's good for now.

1:59:05 All right. So, Haisl, what's the next steps here then? This is really it. It was just an opportunity to, you know, remind the community that we're going to deploy the fleet this summer to provide an opportunity for the council and the public to ask any questions that they may have about the program. That was really just the intent of this presentation today. Okay. Thank you, Haisl. Let's ask for any public comments that might be out there.

1:59:34 Jamie, anybody waiting to speak to this? No, there is not. Madam Mayor, I just have one quick final question. On the question of numbers, Taylor, were you saying that, could you share the number that, just the public number that people should call, could you tell us what it is and give us some of the information?

1:59:55 Yes, absolutely. And something else that just as Michael was speaking to that came to mind, every single vehicle that we do put into the town of Mammoth Lakes will have this contact information on the physical vehicle as well. So in addition to getting this information out to the public, if someone were to walk up to a vehicle, it will be right there, the number, the email, and how to contact, just as another touch point for those methods of contact. Okay. And what's that number? Let me see here.

2:00:23 Sorry, I apologize. I don't have everything memorized as much as I should. Okay, it is. And I can put it in the chat as well, but it's 866-205-2442. Great. And that's 24-7. Yep. Got it. And finally, unless it's proprietary information, how many units do you anticipate deploying in Mammoth Lakes in this program? No, not proprietary information at all. We'll start small scale up.

2:00:51 I believe our agreement allows for up to 75. We will start with less than that and do a scaled rollout to ensure that people have a bit of time to get accustomed. Excellent. Okay. Well, thank you very much. And thanks for being here. And thanks for the presentation. Thank you. Thank you for having us. Yes. Thank you guys very much. And Hayes, do you have what you need then for this? I do. Thank you. I know we're rolling this out with a bit of trepidation. I know there was a lot of interest through our mobility exercises to

2:01:20 to introduce micromobility to the community. And I appreciate the patience, the counsel, the patience of the community as we attempt to try something that may be a great product for this community. And the public is welcome to contact me directly if they identify any issues as well as directly with birth. Thank you. All right, Hayes. And Taylor, Michael, thank you so much. And hopefully we'll be seeing you again soon. Looking forward to it. Thank you. Bye now. Okay.

2:01:51 That brings us to a 8.2 capital improvement plan. Hayes, how long do you think we need for this item? This is a pretty heavy lift. We're going to need a fair bit of time. I'd say at least half an hour to 45 on the short end. Okay, then we're going to take a small break now. Let everybody power up and be ready for the next presentation. Let's convene back here at 4.38. Okay, thank you all.

2:10:26 Okay, let's get started again here. The item number 8.2 is 2022-23 Capital Improvement Plan CIP update. And Hayes, it's back to you. Thank you, Madam Merckx. You should be able to see my screen. Thank you very much. Yeah, so this evening we're going to talk about the draft 22-23 five-year CIP and the proposed 22-23 long-range CIP.

2:10:56 I am going to go over our recommendation and more importantly, how we are looking for the council to participate in this program. A little introduction, a little background, I'm going to go over the review process and the schedule, take a deep dive into the 22, 23 five-year CIP updates, and then we're going to deep dive into the 22, 23 long-range CIP projects and then have a little discussion and hopefully get some direction.

2:11:24 I'm going to tag team this presentation with Dan and there's going to be a whole bunch of stopping points along the way. So recommendation as it was in staff report is just to receive the presentation and then to provide us comments on the two plans. We're really looking for consensus and Dan and I will circle back to this. If there's introduction to something new by the council, we're going to pull the council and make sure that we have consensus on these items.

2:11:51 Okay, thank you, Hayes. And do you want us to ask questions as we go or kind of hold to a break? I got a couple of good holding points, but you're always welcome to interrupt me. All right, thank you. So introduction background. So the council last adopted the CIP in September, last fall, last year. And our plan moving forward was to align it with the budget process. And for the last couple months, I've been on a CIP roadshow.

2:12:16 Talking to Planning Commission, talking to Rec Commission, and we're back here in front of Town Council really to review the plan. Today we're not adopting finances, we're not finalizing anything. This is really an opportunity for the Council to provide comments on the project list as they are. A lot has changed since last September in a number of different reasons. And we have a very, very healthy work program in front of us, which will be evident in our project list.

2:12:46 So, but before we dive into that, I just want to remind Council, what are we talking about here? What is a five-year CIP? These are projects that have, that are non-reoccurring, have long service lives. They'll be underway in either a five-year cycle or a projected 20-year cycle, which is synonymous with our long-range CIP. These expenditures are beyond the scope of normal annual operating and maintenance expenses.

2:13:10 Again, we are not appropriating funds through the CIP. It is a short to mid-range planning and budget tool. And we will bring this information back, I believe it's April 27th, to appropriate the funds as part of the budget process. And we don't include vehicles, technology, software, emergency, stopgap work, which is like telling politics.

2:13:34 The long-range CIP, which is a new component of the CIP, is geared to identify projects on a six- to 20-year horizon. This helps to coordinate infrastructure development on a longer timeline. It aligns with longer-range strategic planning. And importantly, it informs the development impact fee process, which is ongoing. We need this project list to help develop the DIF study.

2:14:04 Like the five-year CIP, this list will be dynamic. And I can tell you in the time that I've written it, it's already changed just on some of the developments we've had here in town. So with the five-year CIP, we'll be reviewing the long-term, long-range CIP at the same time. And there'll always be opportunity for council to change their priorities. Process and schedule. Like I mentioned, I took this list to the Recreation Commission and the Economic Development Commission back in February and earlier this month.

2:14:33 And I will go through their comments. Moving forward today, we're just looking for a review. We'll review finances and recommendations for funding projects at the April 27th meeting as part of the budget process. We will take that back to planning commission because they need to confirm that that project list is consistent with the general plan. We'll do that in May. And then we'll look to adopt the CIP finally.

2:14:59 In May, June, again, I think that all lines up with our budget process. So the 22-23 draft project list, I'm going to hit the high level here. So what did we change? We removed the completed projects. There will be a narrative in the CIP that talks about all the work that we completed. We're going to have like a rolling three-year list of an explanation of the work that we've completed.

2:15:24 We do have some carryover projects such as the CRC and some of our street and MUP work that will continue on to 22-23. We updated budgets and we've updated schedules. Some of the key changes going into 22-23 for the five-year CFP, and I will stop at the end of this slide to take questions. We added a community center at the parcel. We added a municipal bouldering park with no specific schedule and no specific budget.

2:15:52 And outdoor amphitheater. We'll take a deeper dive into that one a little bit later. Again, no specific schedule, no budget. We added the dog park to 2324 to buy us time to get the planning work done. We've also added the park at the parcel, which will support phase one. We don't have a specific schedule or budget right now, but we do believe that will be resolved by the time we bring this forward in April. The Vons.

2:16:18 Bus shelter, we moved that to 2324 just because we don't have capacity to add that work and we also have some right-of-way issues that need to be resolved. We deleted the town hall improvements. We had set aside $175,000 for improvements to the town hall. We've removed that project. We will probably do some minor ADA updates and more kind of stopgap work, but we're not going to be tackling any larger projects in this office and we'll explain why a little bit later.

2:16:45 We added the Home Key Project as our participation in that housing project. And we added phase two of the parcel, which we received some of the preliminary planning work. I'm going to stop there and ask if there's any questions about any of these additions or changes at this point. And Dan, if you want to jump in, if there's anything I missed, please go ahead. So we don't add in the $25,000, I'm sorry, the $55,000 on the dog park? That's included in that budget.

2:17:17 I just, there was $100,000 originally in that CIP, I just moved that over to 23, 24. So I just, it's just a shift in the schedule. Okay. And there'll be more funding associated with that going into April. Hayes, how does our housing project fit into the CIP? Like the Joaquin project and...

2:17:42 You know, you got phase two, so I'm assuming the parcel's already in there, but how does that upgrade into this? It's on the next slide. It's definitely a component of the CIP. It's definitely the financials are included. I'm just trying to break up the presentation a little bit. Right, and Hayes, one of the slides said Recreation Council. I'm assuming that was the Recreation Commission, right? Yeah, I did an edit-replace, and I missed a couple of those, so I apologize. Okay.

2:18:15 No worries. I was hoping you wouldn't see that, but. We pay attention. I appreciate you paying attention. Okay, I'm not seeing any other questions, so I'm going to move on. So I mentioned, excuse me, so the town hall. Previously, we were looking at that as a long-term project. We had brought that to council a few years ago and discussed it, and we kind of put it on the back burner.

2:18:51 And we're going to need to move that into our five-year program. And I'll let Dan speak to that more specifically. We're also adding a project for parking at the parcel, which will be a town parking lot to support some of the need for that affordable housing project. And then we added a big one, foundation infrastructure. This concept could change. We're still in negotiations. But an opportunity to provide the dog park with parking and infrastructure.

2:19:20 A child care facility, relocation of the snow pit, and some improvements to Edison theaters. So with that, I'm going to invite Dan to talk a little bit more about his conversations on this pretty big development. Yeah, thank you, Hayes. One quick just note with the town hall, we're putting that in the five-year plan, really came back into play as some of the discussions on the current office space.

2:19:48 Timing on renewing lease here and different elements there. Council's aware of some of that discussion. And so we begin to move that into the five-year window and we'll be looking at some preliminary funding for the design work and those elements as well. Ultimately, that would be a new facility adjacent to the current police station and the county civic center as well as the courthouse in that area there to be a civic center in total.

2:20:19 The discussions with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation have gone well. I think it's kind of a picture here as an overall work program. It'll definitely be phased in in a few areas there. But we have been looking at a number of areas for some time of how do we address some needs in the community, what role is that going to be, the towns versus others.

2:20:41 And kind of walking through this a little bit backwards at the list here, really the Edison Theater improvements, looking at some elements there, a lot of discussion of how do we get the Edison Theater up and running, Edison Hall there running again as a, you know, smaller venue but a performing arts component. And so we've had a lot of discussions of how to do that and the simplest looks like would be is having the town step and actually leasing the facility to get it open again and working through that.

2:21:10 It also sets us up to have the ongoing discussion with the future expansion of that with the MAC, the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, focused on that additional 6,500, 7,000 square feet of additional space in there for the performing arts element. That has been a long discussion, several years' worth of discussion. What does that begin to look like? Council is aware of the initial project it was worked on. It far exceeded our budgetary expectations.

2:21:39 But it continues to be one of those value propositions, I think, to Mammoth Lakes as a recreation destination. It's a different element that services both visitors and locals. And there's a lot of, I'll say, small comments and discussions throughout the community of, hey, when is activity going to be going on again within the theater, especially with COVID moving toward an end? That's our hope.

2:22:07 Does it get open again? So looking at ways to do that. And so it's kind of started off with that whole discussion there. The other element has been talked about with the college, the college site, the school site was on childcare. How do we actually support providing that type of amenity in our community? We know it's a significant issue for a lot of working families of not having adequate childcare facilities.

2:22:35 Within Mammoth Lakes and Mono County for that matter. And so one of the elements here we begin to look at is talking with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Could we utilize land there if we were to put a facility up for child care and to have somebody else run it? We've had discussions, this has gone back at least five years from my memory, talking with partners on child care, looking at alternative locations, looking at ways to fund a facility. And really nothing is...

2:23:04 Come to fruition through that process. A lot of it's just the cost of a new build, the lack of a location. And so as we begin to work through that in discussions with the foundation, very open to looking at a child care site. And it's noted on here that the concept plan, this is subject to change, so some of these sites on here, et cetera. But the pink area in the map that's showing would be up to like a 4,400 square foot child care facility.

2:23:33 That we'd put in there as the building side of it. The current plan on that would be to repurpose some of the modular buildings that are currently at the high school campus area. Those buildings are slated to be removed. And if not repurposed, they would just be crushed up, destroyed, and hauled to the landfill. So pending the quality of the facilities there in the...

2:23:59 We would be looking at that, putting in the foundation, the utility connections, and then working with the Mammoth County Office of Education for operations. Again, a lot of this is still in process and discussion, but as we see that as a growing need in the community of how do we address that child care need, the lack of it in the community,

2:24:29 Follows right behind a lot of our housing discussion. We get families in homes. We get people housed as they're going to work. Of course, the next question becomes, what do I do with my children during those work hours? The discussion we had earlier on our recreation program, that helps really fill part of that gap. But ultimately, what do we do, especially with the younger children? You look at the toddler level or infant care level. And so we're really looking at that to be able to support that. The other note on this one is that

2:24:59 Larger area in the middle, which ultimately would be an amphitheater type setup that's been on the plans for some time as part of the overall cultural center there, arts and cultural center within the property owned by the foundation. We still see that as adding value to the community, having that outdoor event space there. And then at the end there, adding the potential for a dog park and additional parking and infrastructure there.

2:25:26 The discussions on the dog park at this location has also been kind of almost like an interim use depending on length of time, but if there's higher and better use for the property, that's a facility that's relocatable. I mean, it's fencing and, I'll say, artificial turf areas and a couple little things where you could actually end up moving that facility, say, five, seven, ten years down the road if need be, the use of that property.

2:25:54 And so we began to look at that. It all begins to flow together. The added parking, I think, benefits the foundation. It benefits ultimately the MAC and the operations there. There is an agreement with the college to utilize their parking facilities as well. And ultimately, partnership with the college, the town, the foundation, and private donors for the MAC facility expansion. And so I think it really addressed a lot of different needs.

2:26:23 The question really came up, too, some other opportunities in terms of helping to finance this, but also some cost challenges that the town was working on, and that really dives into the snow pit, and if you want to move that up one slide, Hayes. As you're aware, working with the Forest Service and permitting has been a challenge the last couple of years with our snow pit operations, storage of that. We do believe there's a path forward with the Forest Service to bring that more into line.

2:26:53 But in the interim, we really approached the foundation here with, is there a potential to utilize additional 20 acres there for a portion of it for snow storage, about five acres or so? It would handle a small snow year. We would still have a permit with the Forest Service, but almost have that as a secondary use. More work to be done on this, obviously, as we look at the access points, how do we secure it?

2:27:21 Going through some environmental review of it, those types of steps. But by doing this, if it all comes together in the concept plan as noted here, it would give us an alternative for some of the snow storage area, reducing cost, we believe, from the Forest Service side, and then being able to use some of that savings, frankly, in the rest of the projects here as we've noted. The other element that it gives us is a way for a...

2:27:50 Charge within the use of the property where that would have some funding going back to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Really to support the educational component. How do we continue to provide the scholarship program, you know, books and housing and other elements that they support in a lot of the student educational side. That has been a really solid program as we have brought kids through that from the high school getting into their...

2:28:16 Community College Classes and going on in those college classes and even beyond here. And being able to support them financially with that scholarship program has really added value in terms of what our community college provides here in the town. So when we start to look at all these things together, this has been various pieces of this in play probably the last five years or better in terms of how do we actually

2:28:43 Address a lot of these commonality of needs and really through just a ongoing discussion and work and some opportunities. It looks like we do have a list of projects here again in participation with the foundation still continuing that discussion that we believe will meet a number of issues in our community, provide some enhanced amenities and services to the community. And so this here would be a new program putting into our capital.

2:29:13 We are still working through some of the cost estimates and some of the funding sources for it, but I believe it will actually enhance the overall structure here. With some of the added parking, I'll note too, especially about the dog park area, it really is hooked right in there to the trail system. It's not unusual to see that little bit of a parking area there full with vehicles parked there where people are taking time to go out and walk through the trails or walk their dogs or bike ride, etc.

2:29:43 And so adding to that element will likely enhance the usage of our trail system there, the mubs that go down and around and throughout that portion of our community. I'll pause there and ask if there's any particular questions on that structure there. Again, we're still working with the foundation ultimately on some lease agreements, some of the structure of what that looks like. But we do believe there's numerous things in here that this has really coalesced around to address a number of community

2:30:13 Thank you, Dan. I'm sure there's some questions. John, I see your hand up. Yeah, thank you. Dan, could you give maybe just kind of a high-level sense of where we're at in terms of negotiations with the foundation and what kind of land tenure things are going to be needed and just some sense of

2:30:45 Sort of timing on all this. Yeah, so the goal with the foundation would be to move this forward by the end of this current fiscal year to have agreements in place. The key elements are operation of Edison Theater, which could be a standalone type agreement as need be. The work with the future MAC, that is also tied into agreements, existing agreements and having the town become a part of those with the...

2:31:14 Kern College Community District, the Community College District, really to secure their funding for the future expansion of the MAC. That's $7.5 million. The other side of that will be the child care, which would be a long-term land tenure there, whether that is ultimately owned by the town from a long-term lease or the operator of the facility. We'd have those options to be walking through that.

2:31:41 Those would be the two long-term ones, plus the infrastructure improvements. If you look at building additional parking, if you look at significant maintenance of the existing parking area, those would be added value to the land there and those parking areas committed to be utilized for the facilities that we're looking at on the site. The dog park would probably be the shorter one in a probably maximum of a 10-year commitment.

2:32:06 It could be dropped shorter if there's a higher value use of the property and or another location for that facility. It's fairly simple to move. The snow pit discussion has been on that same type of a five to seven year. That land that it sits on has been targeted as an area for housing. A lot of different work to go through and how that works, but that would be a interim usage on that property versus any permanent usage there.

2:32:35 The initial discussions with the foundation have gone very well, and we will be going back to them. It's back on us to develop a little stronger lease language. We need to give Andy some writing points, and he'll dive into that and knock those out for us as we go back in. And again, as we note on here, it's concept. Things may move around on here based on a little more work on the site and if the foundation has some additional requests of moving things somewhat around on the site.

2:33:05 Thank you. Thank you. And Andy, Dan Holler's reached out to you about this project. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we've discussed it.

2:33:36 Just waiting for it to come into focus a little bit more, partly based on council direction. And then once I know what it is I'm supposed to be drafting, I'll draft it. Thank you very much. Yeah, Madam Mayor and Dan, thank you very much for your, I know this is your initiative on this and, you know, landlocked community like ours to be able to work with partners to unleash and unlock some of that stuff is a really very interesting and positive series of development. So thank you for your work on that.

2:34:07 Okay, anybody else have some comments? Questions? Okay. Yeah, I am interested, you know, very interested in this concept. And again, this is a lot of pieces falling into place. Hopefully this is a good plan. We'll see how it shakes out. All right, Hayes, you want to? Yes, thank you. So I want to kind of mention some of the key

2:34:43 We have projects for 2022-23. This is not the full list of the work program, but I just want to go through kind of the big ticket items. A lot of these projects, they're icebergs. They're one sentence on here, but they have multiple components and bullet points underneath them. But for this season, we're targeting the continuation of the CRC. We like to have that done by the end of this summer, beginning of fall. We have some road and muck projects that were carried over from last year.

2:35:12 We believe we're going to see similar issues with supply chain and labor force. That project, we wanted to see it done last fall, but just because of the challenges that are before us, the contractor was not able to complete it. We believe we will see similar issues this season. There's a lot more work going on in town. There's still very limited labor force. We already know of some supply chain issues that we're trying to overcome.

2:35:39 But we only know what we know. So we do ask for patience with the community and the council because we're going to break ground on these things and there's always the possibility that they may extend into next year. 60 Joaquin, we're opening bids on Friday, hoping to have some good news for you at the next council meeting. Love to get that project kicked off. Down at the airport, they're working towards their airport firefighting and equipment storage building. We're looking to replace our fuel island this summer.

2:36:07 Advance the MAC project study and engineering work with the target of getting that under construction. Parks maintenance and improvements. I'm going to pause here and let Dan talk about that program. Yeah, this is a key element to the last several years. We have been setting aside funding for deferred maintenance, both in our parks department and other areas.

2:36:30 And one of the elements I wanted to note on this, as we begin to do this, as we catch up on some of the projects and not fall further behind in some of our deferred maintenance, we continue to set dollars aside, probably a little less this coming year, but as we do that, for example, you won't see the detailed projects so much in the CIP, but dollars in that, you know, they do a resurfacing work on the tennis courts. We do a repair of damaged areas in the skate parks, either at Shady Rest or...

2:36:59 We end up getting out into the baseball field. You've got to redo the infield mix or we've got to, you know, fix the dugout areas for a roof or siding, those types of things. Some work at the pool. We're doing a larger project at the pool this year, some additional funding that came in for that in terms of some backwash capabilities, the pool and how we handle water and disposal of it and treatment of it and utilizing it in other ways.

2:37:26 And so working through those types of elements that come in. We have had things that just have not been worked on for quite a while or that it was patched and fixed, but at this point there's some things, and some of our irrigation controllers was an example, some of the other elements that we've had to replace over time. We've done a lot of ADA-type improvements. We're looking at, you know, our bleachers that had to be upgraded. There's small elements out there still in the ADA world that we need to...

2:37:56 Continue that process of looking at those areas and saying, yes, we have a plan in place. We're actually making headway to improve those elements as required. And then also the smaller items. We have two different line items for signage-related items, for example. We're ongoing street sign maintenance. We're doing trail signs and the upgrade on our pathways and mops and the smaller signage stuff, not the huge wayfinding projects.

2:38:24 But that ongoing repair and replacement of that signage, almost in that idea of maintenance, and then some of it has been deferred. There's some stuff out there that's been on our work program now for a couple of years in funding. Both of those projects, I believe they have about $25,000 in them so we can continue to identify those areas, both that we see and that, frankly, our public brings to us and say, hey, it'd be nice if we had better signage at ABC locations.

2:38:53 Almost all of that takes a sense of coordination, especially if it's on our trail system and we're talking with Joel Rathje, our trails manager. If it is on the Forest Service side, we're meeting with the Forest Service. Okay, here's our sign program, what we'd like to put into play. On the street stuff, the signs have standards we have to meet and reflectivity and it's...

2:39:17 Those types of things that will be ongoing as we upgrade and maintain those types of elements there. So a lot of work in there from this one line item. It's, again, not large dollars, but it's a lot of staff time, a lot of work in terms of meeting those requirements. And our goal on this has been not to fall any further behind in deferred maintenance, but to actually make headway and then be able to maintain that accordingly as we go forward in regular budgeting processes that we have.

2:39:46 Putting funding in place accordingly. Thanks, Dan. Next item on here is the Laurel Mountain Sidewalk Project. We're going to talk a lot more about this in an iterator day with the Underground Utility District. We have the parcel and the chaperone extension. The town has taken the lead on the development of that roadway segment, and we do have a fair bit of oversight over the parcel development. We have our Old Mammoth Road and Main Street beautification projects. We have a bid out for the...

2:40:16 Slurry Seal of the Bluffs. We have a Highway Safety Improvement Program Grant to replace the street beacons. We've talked about that project before and add a new beacon at Mountain. I'd be remiss if I didn't mention Reds Meadow Road. This fall, they'll start trimming trees and they're going to start construction next summer. That project is not directly managed by town staff. Federal Highways manages the money and the project management, but we do have some oversight and do have some responsibilities there.

2:40:45 I'm going to go ahead and stop there and see if there's any questions on the project list. Aiz, real quick on Red Smetter Road, when does the town, when are we scheduled to accept that project? Accept the work? That would be probably the end of 24, I suspect. It should be punched out and we'll be doing our final walkthrough. Okay, two questions. We don't have to get into that now. One is Fairbox Revenue, ESTA, taking people down there.

2:41:15 This summer, next, we need to keep an eye on that. Also, fuel treatment work, removing trees down there. I've heard rumors that the sequencing of that may see having to load a bunch of big old heavy trees on logging trucks on the new road. And I think you're probably aware of this, but that's something that, I don't know, we need to have that discussion. Let's move those big old heavy trees on the old road, if that's possible, and not beat up our new road. We can talk about that later. Yep.

2:41:45 Thank you. Well aware of that and coordination is ongoing. Okay. Any other council? Oh, I'm sorry, Dan. Did you want to speak to that? I just wanted to touch on one other item here that Hayes touched on quickly, but had several comments the last few months over the old Mammoth Road beautification and the highway main street beautification work.

2:42:09 Both of those projects are moving forward. We allocated $200,000 for Main Street. That won't be a huge project, but we'll begin to address some items there and some design work. The Old Mammoth Road work is through some town participation, but also mainly through the assessment district, Old Mammoth Road assessment district, looking at those projects. And we're trying to look at those in a way that adds value and beautification to those areas, but also looking at it from a water conservation.

2:42:38 A while back we had that challenge on Main Street. All the grass area was killed and died off with the water restrictions. You couldn't do that. And so we're keeping that in mind as we're currently sitting in another drought condition. So as we do the beautification work and what we look at is how do we do it mindful of the challenge before us just in terms of being able to, it's not all going to be trees and grass and flowers.

2:43:04 Those types of elements as much as we'd love to have is a lot of that that we can get in there. Some of it may be more hardscape with furniture. It may be using some other materials. As I want to look at those, I think we really do come up with some really nice designs through this, and there will be definitely some of the greenery as well. But just a heads up on that in terms, especially the Main Street one with a $200,000 project. It'll get us started, but you're not going to see massive changes, but definitely a step in the right direction.

2:43:33 And then Old Mammoth Road, as we design that out and bid it, as Hayes mentioned earlier, some of the supply chain issues and just some of the cost issues, chances are that project will also be scaled back a little bit, just over cost. But also keep in mind what we're looking at for beautification and trying to manage it for water consumption as well as the various elements that go into those roadways just from a safety standpoint as well.

2:44:02 But they're two exciting projects have been on the drawing board for some time now. Yes, they have. All right. Thank you, Dan. Other council members, questions or any comments to staff at all? Sarah? Just thanks, Dan, for covering the beautification projects. I just want to state that I don't know any Californian who wants to see grass on a main street at this point, not in...

2:44:34 Not in this situation. So yeah, hardscape is great. I'm super excited about that project. Thank you. Okay. Bill, any comments on this at all? No, I'm good. Thank you. Okay. Kirk? I'm good. Thank you. All right. I think we're fine to go ahead then if staff's okay with that. No, it's great. Thank you. We're going to kind of transition now into our...

2:45:01 Long-range projects, but before I do, I just want to remind you that all those projects we just discussed will be coming back to you in April with funding and so forth. We'll have another bite at the apple, if you will, on that project list. So it was back in December of last year where we proposed developing a 20-year long-range CIP, and the direction to staff was to compile a list of projects using our existing

2:45:28 What we heard from the Rep. Commission, and you heard some of these similar comments earlier.

2:45:57 You know, on the five-year, they want to see some wayfinding to include town loop signs on Main Street. This has been an ask. It's kind of in conflict with what we've heard from the trails manager, but that was their comment. And they didn't have any additions. They didn't have anything to remove off the list, but they did want to see priority on these items. Building a mop on Old Mammoth Road, and that would be from the Waterford up to Mill City area.

2:46:27 They liked the idea of the development of the bell-shaped parcel, one for housing and one for park purposes, and the idea of a urban snow play area, and obviously an outdoor event center. Over at PEDC, their five-year CIP priorities were an intelligent transportation system that is putting real-time information in their bus stops, and I think we've discussed that before, providing a...

2:46:57 Trolley Shelter, Sports Lakes Basin, that would be on Canyon Boulevard over by the Western Stairs. Their long-range priorities were childcare, life finding, mobility improvements, specifically off-site overnight parking, continuing to build sidewalks, more storm drains, and then also an event site. So here's our project list. And how I want to roll through this is I'm going to kind of hit these.

2:47:28 On a high level. And then I'm going to hand it off to Dan. And Dan wants to make some comments on some of these items. And then I'm going to stop at each slide. There's four of them to take comments on these projects. And as I go into this, I want to remind you that these are very long-term, forward-looking ideas and concepts. This is 20-year horizon. There are no specifics. You see no budgets. But we want to make sure that we are in alignment.

2:47:56 with kind of long-term strategic goals. And I've got it broken down in the same exact categories as you would see it in the CIP. So with that, we'll start with A, and affordable housing. So looking at the bell-shaped parcel for housing, looking at the foundation site where we just talked about for housing, considering the community center, the community center park where we currently have our community center, that land for housing.

2:48:23 Working with our partner at the Forest Service, their administrative site for housing. We like having a placeholder for undefined housing projects. We have this in our current CIP where we just allocate money to be opportunistic so we can buy land, build projects, buy out deed restrictions and so forth. And then future phases of the parcel. It's likely that the parcel will extend outside of the five-year scope of the five-year CIP.

2:48:50 I'm not going to talk about the airport. That gets its own separate presentation from Sierra, and her projects are adopted separately. We're just going to incorporate that work directly into this document. General facilities. Town yard expansion and storage building. We've mentioned before, we actually store stuff off-site down in Chalfant. We'd love to bring our equipment on-site, but we'll need some type of storage building. We're also looking at fencing and security for that site as well.

2:49:17 Town-wide EV charging infrastructure. That's personal, commercial, and electric buses. And I think you're going to see this on the five-year CIP as well, but it's something that we need to continue to look at long-term as well. Fleet expansion. We don't typically put vehicles and so forth in the five-year CIP, but when we're looking long-term with electric vehicles and having to onboard loaders and blowers, which can cost almost a million dollars a piece,

2:49:47 It's good to kind of put some money out there in the future and just acknowledge that we're going to have those capital expenses. Childcare center, Dan talked about that as a component of the foundation work. So that could potentially move to the five-year CIP. And then the community center. Identify a location. I said replace, and it could be replaced in the same location. So it don't mean that we're going to take it off site. But just that facility is kind of towards the end of its useful life. We did do a refresh on it.

2:50:15 But within 20 years, we're going to need to look at either rebuilding it in place or finding another location for it. So with that, I'm going to hand it over to Dan for his comments, and then we'll bring it back to Council. Thank you. I really wanted to touch on the housing components there. One of the challenges we've had, as mentioned earlier, was land. Where do you put future housing projects as we look at our workforce?

2:50:42 And so what we did here was try to walk through the properties that we have some control over. So the stuff that we currently own and or that we've had discussions with ownership. And so you'll see a number of these areas. We've had discussions with the foundation. We own the barrel-shaped parcel. We own the community center housing area. We had good discussions with the Forest Service regarding their administrative site. Again, longer term looking at that.

2:51:09 Then obviously the parcel in the future phase is there. And then as we've done before, we've allocated money with the creative housing solutions and that undefined housing project. That's really where we came up with the bridge loan program that we're implementing under our Housing Now initiative and some of the other partnership programs. The other side there is in the five-year CIP, we continue to allocate a base amount of money for housing, even if we don't have a specific project defined. But we've been able in the last...

2:51:39 Year or so, two years, to commit over $10 million to housing in a variety of different ways. And so we want to make sure that we're continuing to keep these items out in front of us, to look at these opportunities, as we can't rely necessarily on private sector land and or the national forest lands that surround us. So as we look at these opportunities, to be able to look at things that we have some level of control or willing partners in become very critical to do that.

2:52:07 And then just maintaining the town facilities becomes a key element too. That's where we talk about the yard. We talk about the ongoing operational components to protect our assets, to add to those value components there. And then the other elements we've kind of touched on already as we look to the future here. And again, keep in mind this looks out in this next five-year window, but most of this is looking out beyond that as we begin to look at opportunities.

2:52:35 Elements that we actually really do want to look to plan for the long term of the community. Glad to address kind of this first group of these long range projects. If there's additional questions on those, we'll have another couple of charts related to that as well. But back to you, Linda, if there's any questions on this first chart here. Okay. Let's look to council. John, I see your hand up. Yeah. Do you want comments at this point? I'm assuming.

2:53:06 Yes, please. On this slide, we'll be looking for comments, consensus on additions or subtractions. We'd like to take it slide by slide. And questions, correct. Yeah, absolutely. Okay, so generally speaking, the housing stuff all looks good to me. My one observation is we heard John Morris today talking about subsidizing rents and those kinds of things. I think that's a very slippery slope.

2:53:34 For us in the town, I think it might start to endow a segment of the population that would be more than happy to be taking rental subsidies, and that on a long-term basis could get us into entitlement issues, I mean, sort of expectations of money coming at the town to be subsidizing rents and apartments, I don't think that's a good idea. I think it's a much better idea to be focusing on these capital

2:54:03 Acquisitions, Capital Investments, and that kind of stuff. The one thing that sort of comes to mind is the community center park housing and the community center itself. I would really like to see, given a long-range perspective, it won't be us on the council making these decisions, but to see how we can really maximize the opportunities at the CRC to really understand if that could really serve a lot of the communities.

2:54:32 Center needs. I don't know if it would or if it can or it can't, but I'd be interested in really seeing what we could do with that facility, and then we could really start thinking about what we do with the whole community center lot up there. That's about it. Thank you. Okay, Sarah? Yeah, I do want to piggyback on what John said about, I missed John Morris' comments at the beginning of the meeting, but I did get, you know, the letters that were going back and forth.

2:55:04 About subsidizing people's rent. And I agree. I think I would like to get some maybe what's the term I'm looking for? A cohesive message out around that to the people who are promoting that to explain why that might not be the best way forward. And I agree just getting.

2:55:31 Getting those parcels of land and working on that ourselves. I think that's the only comment I have at the time, this time. Thanks, Sarah. Bill? Whoops. We'll push a button and the whole world changes. You know, nothing really on this. My only question would be on the general facility side. I sort of thought we were looking at some property down at the bus barn, the property we own that Esther uses. And I don't see that here. But other than that, I'm fine with this.

2:56:05 Okay, and Kirk? I would agree with Bill. I'm fine with this. Okay, I have a couple questions. Well, actually, just a clarification. On the Child Care Center, this is not something that we would build and operate. This is something that we would work with community partners to perhaps move those trailers over, get some infrastructure there, and then work with other entities to seed a actual

2:56:36 You know, operator, sorry, an operator of a facility like this. The, on housing, and I don't know where this fits in, because these are sites that we already own or that we think we could get a hold of, but there's also the question of the kind of empty retail spaces throughout town. And is there any thought about what that might do as far as housing?

2:57:08 You know, what we could do with that. I know the, you know, Mammoth Lakes housing 11 unit that they're working on to try to bring to completion. I don't know where, where do we put that in there? I know we were not kidding around, but talking about one of the larger, older, really, really beat up hotels in town and how much would that cost to, you know, purchase and turn into some housing.

2:57:34 So does that fit anywhere in here just to keep it on the radar? I think, let me tackle child care first. So we don't have any of that defined. I think the current understanding of a program is the town doesn't want to be the operator. But the goal of this document is just to put it on the radar that this is something the community needs. This is something the community needs to be working towards. And we'll have to work out the details. I mean, this is clearly not fleshed out as far as, you know.

2:58:03 How a program would be put together. I'll say in general for this list, we're really talking about capital expenditures, the building of infrastructure. And so about rent subsidies, that would really fit under program. And the CIP does not preclude the council or any other agency from building programs. And I think that can slot into any other arena. And I think they'll always have that opportunity.

2:58:32 Empty retail space is interesting. I think it could fall under either or. I think you could be looking for the acquisition of space, which would definitely be a capital expenditure, but it also could be a lease program. So let us kick that around and see if we can turn that into a long-term kind of CIP goal, and then we can review that in April and see if it kind of fits with your

2:59:02 What you're trying to do. And I am looking for consensus on adding something like that. So if I could get a thumbs up from the group that we're all interested in adding additional projects. Thank you. Dan? Hayes, if I could just add to that discussion. We have received some interest from just the development community in maybe doing this as a non-town-related project.

2:59:30 You know, we did see that Mammoth, the Mammoth Mall project where the property owner had put together plans, had plans ready to go to build, you know, apartments in the second story of Mammoth Mall. And so I think that there may be some desire from the, from just the private sector to do something along those lines. And also, I serve on the American Planning Association Legislative Update Committee, and we talked a little bit about this at a meeting last week and about

2:59:59 Really the need for the state to consider this. This is not just happening in Mammoth Lakes, right? This is happening across the state. And so, you know, I think we're trying to kind of, you know, put the word up to the state is that maybe there's funding opportunities for these types of, you know, renovations, something along those lines. So I think it's good to earmark it for the town to consider in the future, but it might come forward in other ways as well.

3:00:24 Yeah, and that would be preferable for sure. So, yes. Okay. All right. Thank you, guys. Thanks. Okay. I think we're done unless you have anything else on this one, Hayes? No, I'm good. Dan has his hand up, though. Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't notice. Thank you, Dan. Yeah, real quick on that. This kind of falls into that undefined housing projects category. We have the, what is it, the FAR capability, the FAR, the foray or ratio component with our commercial projects that could actually add housing, but that's really going to be driven usually by the,

3:00:54 Project Developer, somebody who already owns that property versus us doing something that would be a retail flash housing component. That would be a little bit of a stretch probably for the town to be in that type of a business side of it. The other side to that is where we've had that in the past. From a rental standpoint, it works pretty well, but if it gets into where you're trying to sell those units when they're part of a commercial building gets really problematic in terms of traditional financing, we're running into that.

3:01:23 Challenge on a couple of projects that have been built historically that have been deed restricted and then the ability for people to acquire those become very difficult as people look to sell them versus renting or leasing them out. So it's definitely worth looking at in that whole commercial area as if we see the work in commercial activity drop off, can housing go into that? And we currently allow that in our planning.

3:01:47 A lot of work a couple of years ago on the four-year racial program to allow housing on the upper floors and have a little bit of retail on the front. So we definitely have opportunity there, and that would come under, I think, that undefined housing projects. If there's something that comes forward and it makes sense, then we jump into that hoop and say, yeah, let's figure out how we make something work. Okay, that makes sense. Thanks. Okay. John? So finally,

3:02:16 One, I think you've got someone, some public comment, someone's got her, Kathy Cage has got her hand raised, but Hayes, just, or Madam Mayor and Dan, just as we go through this, would it be possibly some kind of a readback, Hayes, of what you heard, so that the consent, whatever you're taking from this, we can hear it so that, you know, if something needs to be discussed a little bit further, we can do that with other council members? Sure. All right, so public comment here.

3:02:49 Jamie, is there someone waiting? Yes. Kathy Cage, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Sure. Thank you for the opportunity to comment. And I wasn't sure at what point I should. And maybe, Hayes, you can tell me if you've got some more. I could save all my comments to the end if that's more convenient. I don't know how far along we are. So maybe you could help me with that. I have four slides on long-term SAP, and we're going to follow the similar process. I think it's the pleasure of the council on how they want to take comments.

3:03:19 Why don't you go ahead, Kathy, especially if this is about topics up until now. Okay, so I'll give you some comments on this particular slide, which is the long-range project. You know, the whole what's happening when the current community center site is such a, you know, ping-pong ball of whatever, you know, is going to happen to it in the future. Is it going to be a mobility hub? You've got that later on in your agenda. Is it going to be housing? You know, most people, I'd say, agree that's not the best place for a community center.

3:03:46 Great, where should we locate it? Is it in the Newtown Hall? You know, those are perfectly reasonable things to think of. I would tell you preliminarily, I think the homeowners in the Knowles would probably be much happier seeing housing because that's a more similar type of use and it doesn't have all the conflict issues that a big parking thing would have. So those are kind of some preliminary comments.

3:04:10 But I wonder if someone would invest in working with the neighbors in the neighborhood about some visioning for that. Like people, you know, it's not like a group of people who don't understand the reality of the problems we got facing us and, you know, trying to find solutions. So that's my one comment on there. Because so far this stuff just all happens at staff level. Nobody even knows. Like I had no idea that these kinds of, the only reason I'm on watching is because I'm going to try to adjust you on the mobility hub.

3:04:36 And a lot of times they use their little sleds just on the snow mound in the village. And so, you know,

3:05:06 So I saw that on a different slide, you know, from a recreation standpoint, would be great to have a snow play. So if you could kind of maybe wrap up that consideration as possibly cited in the community center, and then that way you could keep some park aspect to that, which of course is what that neighborhood up there values the most, is the park aspect. That's our neighborhood park. And so we get all worried when it looks like

3:05:33 That's going to be eviscerated and something else go in. So that's, you know, my comment there. And we just wish someone would work with the neighborhood to kind of try to balance all these issues out a little better. Okay, so that's a comment there. I did have some questions or comments on the five-year CIP, which is a previous slide. Should I save those comments to the end? Hayes, I think maybe let's take it to the end, Kathy. Okay.

3:06:04 Very good. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Any other comments? Madam Mayor, I've got some thoughts on the five-year CFE too, and we could get to that later. Okay. Okay. Are there any other public comments, Jamie? No, there are not. Okay. So we agreed that we'll move on to the next slide. Okay. Yeah. What do you want to do about the report outs? Do you want to wait to the end for those? I would. I'm taking notes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. All right. So jumping into the next grouping.

3:06:39 So we have the police department, and we put down PD expansion slash dispatch. I mentioned that building was designed to be expanded, and on a 20-year horizon, we may need to consider adding additional services at that building. Parks and Recreation, talking about Whitmore expansion, we're in the process of expanding our lease. We've talked about new soccer fields, potentially a dog park down there, and trails. We have the Whitmore track.

3:07:07 Locker rooms and training space. We actually have a grant out for that project right now. The town pool. Within 20 years, our pool will have its 100-year anniversary. So we may want to consider some updates to pool infrastructure. I mentioned bell-shaped housing. We're also looking at bell-shaped park space. That could be tennis courts, amphitheater, multi-use courts, dog park, you name it. We're not really specifying what could be there. We're just saying we should consider it on a 20-year horizon for park space.

3:07:38 Also an outdoor event center. Just locating a replacement for Sam's Wood Site. We haven't specified a location, but it's something we need to consider, and that could be a shorter time frame. Right now we have it on the 20-year horizon. Urban snow play, as Kathy mentioned. That was an ask from the Recreation Commission. We haven't cited it, but we'd like to identify a permanent location and provide restrooms and facilities for a quality experience rather than kids sliding into the road.

3:08:07 And then OHV, OSV staging and trails, potentially a road designation, looking to find some great OHV, OSV permanent staging areas, circulation elements, designating potentially two town roads for OHV use where they have done that down in Yule County. Again, consideration on a 20-year horizon. And then storm drain projects, John Muir and Davison.

3:08:34 The top of the list in our stormwater management plan and some of our storm drain plans. I'll add that the town has actually executed a task order with a consultant to put together a project study report to advance the design of that system. That would be both roads and some work on Lake Mary, and then that would be phased out. That tees us up for potential funding from various sorts of locations.

3:08:59 Various sources from the state and federal agencies. So we've actually already started that work, but these are very, very expensive projects. So we see them on a longer term horizon. And then we also added mill ditch improvements. That's outside the scope of the five year, but at some point we're going to need to address mill ditch as part of the parcel project. So with that, I'm going to stop here. Same process before. I'm going to hand it over to Dan for his comments and then bring it back to council and then we'll take public comment as well.

3:09:30 Just a couple of extra comments there. We talk about the PD expansion. As Hayes noted, we designed that building for about 1,000 square feet expansion. At one point in time, the town had designed a PD that included dispatch. It's also included a training room. It also included expanded area for officers and work area. So the design of that building, again, not something today we need, but we designed it to look at. As mentioned, 20 years from now, who knows what we'll be needing in that area, which could be a...

3:09:59 I think we have a great opportunity at the Whitmore site with the expanded lease area that will be adding additional acreage. The current Prop 68 grant that is out, if we get that, that's a $3 million investment in that facility. And as noted, as we start to look longer term, again, at property that we own, at things that we currently have control over, we have a looking for a 50-year lease on that property. The other sites there that we do own, how do we begin to look at those and say,

3:10:27 What's the long-term plan for that as we see these other needs coming forward as we look at opportunities to integrate recreation amenities with housing as we look at our connection to our national forest amenities? More discussion on that shortly just in terms of how do we connect these things together? And obviously the storm drain elements there ultimately as a flooding mitigation work and other elements.

3:10:53 Getting those plans done so down the road they could actually be funded through some mitigation money potentially if we have the right designs in place and truly as a hazard mitigation plan versus just enhancing current drainage elements. So I think we have a lot of opportunities here and again some larger items here that are some of them not as high as priority as others but definitely as we look to the future they need to be in our sights.

3:11:22 Okay, thank you, Dan. All right, from Council, comments, questions on these items? Only that down the road, and it's not for today, the staging areas, which should be for more than just OHV and OSV, but also are non-motorized, is a natural fit for the urban snow play as well. Thank you, Bill. John? Yeah, everything else on here seems pretty good. Hayes, are you talking about...

3:11:55 Where do we talk about the council's priority about 100 miles of new single track trails? Where does that come up on this list? If it's not on the next slide, it's on the last slide. Trails has its own section. All right. I think Bill makes an excellent point. In this day and age, there's no such thing as things that are exclusively OHV or OSV. And I think that's, I would really ask for council consensus that we not...

3:12:22 Do things in that manner that we, you know, any staging areas, trails, road designations, things like that, they've got to be multiple use. And I would ask for that consensus to make sure that that's clear going forward. Okay, council, if you agree with that, thumbs up, please. I agree. Kirk, I think I, do I see Kirk? Yes. Yes, okay, and myself. All right, there you have it. Okay.

3:12:55 And for myself, I have no particular questions on any of this. And comments have already been made that I would concur with. The pool, what year does it turn 100? 2039, I believe. Okay, we'll also be around, right? Sarah, how about you? Any comments on this? Oh, of course, I asked when your mouth's full, sorry. No, no, thank you. I'll be around in 2039.

3:13:27 Okay, um, Ace, you got what you need? Do we have any public comment? Did we want to? Yeah, thanks, public comment, Jim. No, we do not. Okay. All right, moving on. All right. So, the next grouping starts with streetscape, and John trails around the last slide, sorry. Streetscape and signage, looking at streetscape improvements on meridian and tavern roads.

3:13:58 The idea of a town-managed, permanent, changeable message sign to promote town messaging and communication. Expansion of signage and wayfinding. This is the municipal signage and wayfinding program into the Lakes Basin, into Reds Meadow, out onto the scenic loop. That work has already been done. It's sitting on the shelf. It just needs to be funded. On the street side, we have a set-aside for annual rehab. This is for streets and mubs.

3:14:28 We don't have a specific project allocated out for 20 years because we run our scenarios on an annual basis. We do pavement condition index work annually, run it through our system that kicks out what projects we need to work on an annual basis, but we like to have that set aside there. We've talked about emergency access roads, and this could be Sherwin Creek Road or Mammoth Creek Road.

3:14:52 These are improvements to Forest Service roads for potential emergency service use, something to consider on a 20-year horizon. Also on a 20-year horizon, Meridian Road Diet. This is a segment from Minaret to Eagle Lodge. We undertook a road diet a number of years ago to put the sidewalks and infrastructure on the segment between Old Mammoth Road and Minaret. This would be in the same vein to reduce the number of lanes to provide more multimodal uses and parking.

3:15:21 Improvements to the intersection of Minaret and Meridian, and that's considering a potential roundabout. That signal has hit the end of its useful life. Honestly, we're down to buying parts off of eBay to keep that thing alive, so we need to consider replacing it with some new controlled intersection. And it's the same story with Forest Trail and Minaret. We don't have any signalization there, and that's something that we need to consider to help download the mountain.

3:15:51 Sidewalks, we pulled these right out of our mobility element, Chateau Road, Arrowhead, Chaparral, Sierra Nevada, Azimuth, Sierra Manor Road, Center Street, some improvements to the Sierra Valley site roads, and then the south side of Meridian Boulevard, these are right on in our existing documents, all high priorities. With that, I'm going to hand it over to Dan for any comments he may have, and then back to Council and public comment.

3:16:18 Thank you, Hayes. Again, I want to note two things here. One, a lot of these projects have come out of other documents and other plans that have been completed in the past. And again, the priorities can move around. And my guess is as we get into the 20-year window, there will be new areas like for sidewalks and mumps and stuff coming forward. The other thing I wanted to touch on are two items there. The one is on the whole idea of having some permanent messaging capability in the town.

3:16:43 We run into this every time we do special events, every time we have winter weather, as we're reminding people to drive carefully, put on chains, detour ahead, do our events and stuff of that nature. The idea of the messaging that we try to put out different ways, and right now we use a lot of mobile signage, which we would continue to have, but also if we did have another site for something that's more directed on a permanent location where we could actually...

3:17:11 You know, get this information out regularly. It's electronic. You can sign it up. It's easy to change. You're not worrying about hauling something in and out of our shop area, but there would be an area people could look at. The other thing, and Hayes noted it with the emergency access roads, we have been working with a program called Zone Haven on evacuation planning. That looks a lot. We're doing that in coordination with the fire district and the county and others as we look at.

3:17:40 The other side, and as you start to look at these access roads, is what do you do if you're, you know, in the summertime, if you had an evacuation and you have, you know, X thousands of people out in the forest? How do they move in and out and get that evacuation site? How do we do that outreach there? And different ways to make that happen, but one...

3:18:05 Element to that is if you're moving people out, are there some other alternatives of how we move people out, depending, again, where the threat is, not just 203, not just the Scenic Loop or Meridian Boulevard, but do we have some other access issues on the other side of 203, for example, out from Shady Rest going out, is there some access points? The roads here is just an example that we're looking at. And so when we talk about evacuation of our community and the emergency element,

3:18:33 We have to look at obviously the built environment of the town, but how does that go to the lakes basin? How does that go out on the scenic loop? How does that go out to the shady rest area? What are those other campground areas that we'd have to notify and be able to move people out as well as the core of the town? So there's a lot of different elements here that fit into these types of improvements that we're looking at beyond the core of Mammoth Lakes, but what happens in our whole regional...

3:19:01 Approach to responding to disasters and being able to have this system that isn't absolutely rigid. That was one of the problems of Paradise that they ran into in their fire. They had a great evacuation plan, but the fire overran their ability to respond. And so we're looking at options here that give us a lot of flexibility that we can respond very, very quickly depending on the conditions on the ground.

3:19:26 And so I think that's a key area, again, a longer-term discussion here, and obviously it will involve our federal partners, but how do we end up building that into a thoughtful process as we look to the future? Thank you. All right. Thank you, Dan. Anybody want to address any of these projects or ideas on this? Yeah. I'll jump right in there, Linda. Thank you. Please. Let's be smarter than our federal partners when we're looking at these roads for emergency access.

3:19:57 While they viewed them as roads in their travel management plan, everybody forgets that these are recreational trails. There's a multitude of different uses on these roads. So if we're going to improve the Mammoth Creek Road, as an example, which is now open to off-highway vehicles and motorcycles and green stickers, let's make sure that we designate them such so that we don't lose that trail opportunity as well. Hugely important moving forward.

3:20:27 We've already lost a third of the trails on the Indian National Forest. Do everybody looking at them as roads and not trails? The CMS sign, I have seen some drawings of what that might be and where it might go. And frankly, they scare me. I don't want just a big electronic sign. I have been to other towns who have electronic signs built into very mountain-specific cases, if you will, surroundings.

3:20:56 And they're very attractive. I want to make sure we keep that in mind as we look for this sign. I know that MLT would like to put one on the corner of Old Mammoth and Main Street there where we put the banners. But let's make sure the darn thing looks like it belongs in a mountain town and not in Las Vegas. That's all my complaining for now, Hayes. Thanks. Thank you, Bill. John? Following up on Bill's points about those roads,

3:21:26 My understanding is that there are still tenure issues about those roads. You know, is it a county road? Is it a forest service road or whatever the hell it is? So I think it would make sense to start, you know, let's start doing the forensic work to figure out what we've got to work with. I would also add that Shady Rest and ORMAD and whatever their buildup looks like.

3:21:49 There may be, they may, who knows what they're going to do out there, but there may be some things that we could leverage and take advantage of because they're going to mess it up anyway. So maybe we can do something along those lines. The electronic signs are, you know, they're just an issue. It's like they go for miles. I mean, you can, you'll be up camping somewhere at night and you'll be able, you won't be able to see anything down in Mammoth, but that red sign, those little red diodes.

3:22:19 To me, it's kind of problematic. And the other question would be in terms of where we could put them, because I'm thinking Caltrans is going to say you can't put them in any of the Caltrans right away. So then the question becomes, how useful would they be for emergency messaging? I can see having them and keeping them off most of the time, but then turning them on if we needed them, that could kind of make sense. But the MLT thing, not a fan. A question a little bit for

3:22:47 Hey, Sandra, Dan, whatever. Do we need to be thinking about if development projects come forward? You know, if something happens, say, with the Limelight Hotel, we've got some language in there in the North Village Pacific Plan about a mobility hub or transportation issues. Do we need to be talking about that in terms of the CIP, or does that come out of conditions of approval that then get added to this later?

3:23:17 And I'll field that one. Generally, development projects, any infrastructure that needs to be put in place by the developer is done through the conditions of approval. We generally do not include that in CIP unless they're providing capital in which the town uses to design, develop, and manage a project. And there have been cases of that in the past.

3:23:42 Generally, no. We don't need to have those considerations in here. Those will work themselves out through the development and entitlement process. Okay, good. Thanks. I'm good. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Kirk, any comments? A question. On the voodoo shoot, are we looking at a crosswalk there with a light that's activated so that somebody could cross there? Yeah, we are, and that's on the next page.

3:24:13 So we'll talk to that one in just a sec. Okay, thank you. Hey, are there more sidewalks on the next page? No, this is the short list of sidewalks. Okay, how do you identify the ones that belong on this list as opposed to other ones I can think of that aren't on the list? We pretty much gathered up all the projects that were in the mobility element and just put them on the list. Okay, so if I had...

3:24:40 A couple of questions about why certain things, right? I don't want to take the time now, but can we talk later about that? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And if there's something that you see that's missing that's pretty egregious, please propose it and we can take it to the group and see if it should be on the list. Okay, I was thinking of Old Mammoth Road, like from Meridian, or, you know, when the trail ends, which is basically at Snow Creek. And then beyond that, there's no way to walk on Old Mammoth Road there.

3:25:09 If you want to walk up, you know, towards the Lakes Basin or go to an end street or something, it's just, there's just nowhere to walk but in the, in the street. So I didn't know if that would be one. And then another one is on a minaret when you're trying to get from, you know, say, Old Mammoth Road up towards the wood side or the village. Those are mishmash of little bits. And again, you end up walking along ways on the street too.

3:25:38 So those were two that I thought of. I'll note that on Old Mammoth Road, we did propose a MUP, and maybe I'll ask the question differently for consensus. Would the council rather see the town working towards a MUP or a sidewalk? I'd rather see a MUP, but that's just me. What about everybody else, John? No, I would definitely like to see a MUP, but I think, Hayes, we're all very aware that there is no, you have no real estate to work with out there. Is that right?

3:26:06 There's some real estate to work with. It would take some work and some moving the road around a little bit, but there's probably a way to sneak it in there. If there's a will, there's a way. Okay, there's also, there is a recommendation of the Sherman Area Recreation Plan for Tamarack Street to put a pedestrian lane on Tamarack Street to go out to the hopefully someday entitled public access easement across Terry Plum's property down there. That's, I don't know where that's at exactly.

3:26:35 But yeah, I would certainly support a MUP going up if we could figure out a way to do it. Okay. I'll leave. The MUP is already on there. And it's the same story for Minaret Road. We actually have a MUP in development for the entire length of Minaret Road. We're actually going to get 90% plans here in the next couple of days. Again, I'll pull the council. Would you rather see a sidewalk or a MUP on Minaret? Raise your hand if you'd rather see a MUP. Always a MUP.

3:27:06 Okay. I think that's it. Thank you. That helps. Hey, the last thing. Hey, this is Dan. I wanted to note on that real quick. What we have looked at, to Linda's point, we've had comments in other areas where we have older sidewalks that are undersized, if you will. They're hard to clear. They don't work with our snow removal equipment. And we've looked at some of those areas where I think it's a three-foot sidewalk or thereabouts, maybe a four-foot. But to try to keep those clear is problematic for our equipment.

3:27:36 Depending on which side of the road are they on for melting off on their own. But one of the elements to look at down the road would be do we look at widening those out, just adding to it, which is sometimes problematic, or replacing that. Or if we end up with a new MUP on the other side, is that adequate so we don't worry about any corrections, if you will, to the narrow sidewalks, and they're more of a summer amenity than they are year-round amenities.

3:28:01 But that would be something to take a look at and go, does that make sense to have in some cases we have areas with that more narrow sidewalk? What do we do to try and widen that out and or add something else additionally in those particular areas? And I think some of those, I think, Linda, you've received some of those same complaints that I've received related to those. So that is something I think we can take a look at and say.

3:28:25 What makes sense there? I guess the question to the council, is that a shared concern where we have those narrower sidewalks that we should take a look at or not, or is that just a future maybe beyond the 20-year window? That's kind of a question for you all. So I will jump in, Dan, with that and a couple of other points on our MUPS and our sidewalks. I would always like to see them wide enough to be able to be used year-round.

3:28:56 My problem is that doesn't always say we have to plow them. We've gotten a habit of plowing all of our mups. And I said years ago, we should do an inventory of all of them, see which are better off to be plowed and which would be more advantageous for us to groom and look at perhaps instead of just buying another trackless of getting a piece of grooming machinery that can groom our...

3:29:23 Cross-country ski, non-motorized trails, if you will, and those sections of MUPS, which could be added to that system. So we need to look at our MUPS as a recreational development in total, not just, okay, we have a MUPS, we're going to buy another blower, we're going to clear it of snow, but how do we manage it to the best use of public and guests alike? Thank you. I support that. It's a great idea. Great thank you, Bill. I really support that. Yeah, I'm seeing four nods here, so.

3:29:54 I can't see Kirk is too far away, so, yeah. Yes. I just wanted to make a quick comment about the idea of a roundabout. I love roundabouts, and I think that would be a great, really creative option for Minaret, Meridian. I worry about Americans' ability to navigate them, especially when we have

3:30:26 Visitors in the winter. I want to make that comment. Like, I love roundabouts, but I've seen them not used properly. Councilmember Rae, I would point out that where I live in Truckee, we have 11. Wow. Amazing. And people are working them. It works. We have two double lane roundabouts that are on a state highway. It took some doing to get Caltrans to let us do that, but eventually now they're really into it.

3:30:56 And then we have nine single lane roundabouts, or maybe we have three or four double lane. Anyway, we have a bunch of roundabouts. Some are in residential areas. We have one at the west end of downtown. We've got four on state highways. So they range in size and they range in kind of capacity, but they work. And the public works, the Truckee General Plan actually has a policy of eventually getting rid of all traffic lights and replacing all of them with roundabouts.

3:31:25 And people do seem to get them. I mean, if you design them properly, you can avoid people going the wrong way into the roundabouts, which can be a problem if they're not done right. The nice thing about them is, you know, bad drivers in the winter can sometimes take out a traffic light and they're really expensive to replace. You can't take out a roundabout. You know, the most confused semi-driver. You can run over it, but you can't. Yeah. Well, I'm all for it then. Let's go.

3:31:54 They do cost a lot. Are there other council members that roundabouts would be fun? However, that being said, Truckee doesn't get 400 inches of average snowfall on their roundabouts that they have to figure out a way to clear and keep the signages clear and everything else. No, it's only about 210 or 20 inches, but the public works guys have figured out how to do it. I mean, if you design it properly and you have your sloped curbs, the guys in orange up there know how to deal with it.

3:32:23 It can be done. Great. I think it's a great candidate for one because, you know, it's not that heavily used or it's not heavily used most of the time. Before we give direction to staff, are other council members also in favor of roundabouts or not? The idea of roundabouts have been here as long as I have. So, hell yeah, let's keep beating up the roundabouts. They will actually get one done. In the right place.

3:32:51 Okay, I think you have enough of us interested in roundabouts to at least keep it on the list, Hayes. Yep, absolutely. Okay. Do we have any public comment on this grouping? Yes, thank you. Yes, Kathy Cage, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, thank you. I'll segue into what I already had as a comment with at a certain point there was a roundabout at that Forest Trail Minaret improvement area. I'm gathering Hayes was considering that to be signalized.

3:33:22 Is the idea of a roundabout there off the table or? No, the way it's worded is just improvements are needed to help downloading ski area traffic. And we didn't specify whether that was a roundabout, a signal. Just in a 20-year horizon, we really need to consider. Yeah.

3:33:43 So that kind of feeds into my earlier comment, which is, you know, some of this has to do with what we're doing with that property we own at the community center. So it's a really different traffic situation if it's a parking garage versus, I don't know, housing or a park or something. So I'm assuming, you know, that when we make a decision about what to do for the improvements to help the download ski area traffic, we're considering not only the current as-built situation, but the future for both the community.

3:34:12 Center, you know, property use, but also the improvements that are going to happen at the main lodge. When the main lodge has like cool things to do after skiing, it may end up being a more of a draw for people to go up to than it is now. So I just hope that when we decide what to do, we've got a thoughtful traffic analysis that we use to decide the right thing to do there. That's my one comment.

3:34:43 Let's see. A couple more questions. One, the Minaret Road Diet. You know, maybe Hayes could elaborate on what section of Minaret we're talking about for that. Yeah, so we're talking about the section between Eagle Lodge and Minaret, and it would be a corollary to the road diet work we did on the segment between Minaret and Old Mammoth Road where we reduced.

3:35:10 Travel lanes in order to facilitate pedestrian infrastructure, parking, turnouts, and so forth. Okay, so then my question is, because this feeds into a comment that you'll hear from me later on the Mobility Hub Study. So one of the things Mobility Hub Study talks about is changing what's going on at Eagle Lodge into a place where it has no ability to park all day. So I just don't remember, Hayes, is that...

3:35:37 Right now, once we do the road diet, does that mean you can't park on the side of the road all day? No, no, no. Is that a no parking area? Not at all. Okay. We haven't defined what a road diet means. It's just what would be included. Basically, it's just reducing, because right now there's five lanes of traffic. Okay. Could we better use those travel lanes for additional parking? Maybe it's head in, maybe it's angled parking, mucks, sidewalks.

3:36:03 We haven't defined it, it's just a consideration because we did it on half the street. Should we consider it on the other half the street? Is there a better use of those travel lanes? Great, that answers my question. My third question is Center Street sidewalks. My husband and I own property on Center Street. I don't know if, is that, are we talking about the section of Center Street that connects the parcel improvements with Main Street? Is that where we're putting sidewalks with bike lanes? That work is...

3:36:32 Going to happen as part of the phase one parcel project. What we're talking about here is a consideration. Does the remainder of Center Street need sidewalks to support the parcel or other businesses that may come forward? So you mean like the back of my husband's, our property P3, you're talking about sidewalks back there? Yeah, on one side of the street or the other. We haven't defined it. It's a consideration on a 20-year horizon. So I would just suggest...

3:37:00 We've got other places we could spend sidewalk money on. At least that section back there should be super low priority. Right now, there's no connection for the general public for a bike or any of that kind of stuff through the end of that cul-de-sac. That's a dead-end cul-de-sac there, all with commercial property. There's no easements for bike paths.

3:37:19 Or sidewalks or anything through those private properties. So if you're talking about sidewalk improvements on Center Street, it would really just be to service those businesses that are on Center Street. And I would say there's not a big demand for that. I mean, there's like a one bed and breakfast back there. I think it's a kind of a low priority of a place to put money for sidewalks. I'm not hearing like a big demand. I mean, we're pretty well connected into those businesses back there. I'm not hearing a big demand. Oh, if only we had sidewalks.

3:37:49 So just thought I'd give you that feedback as there's a, you know, balance of where you want to put money, where it's highly valued. That's a portion of it, fairly low value from the property owners and users of that street. That's it. However, isn't there an outlet from the parcel onto Center Street that's already an easement or town owned? Yeah. And that's part of the development of phase one and that segment of sidewalk will be constructed this summer.

3:38:22 Like I said, this came from the list that was in the mobility element. And I'll add that I just remind council that this is a 20-year horizon and the addition of, you know, hundreds of affordable housing units that that commercial corridor could change on a 20-year horizon. So again, this is not set in stone. These are just considerations for the future. Okay. Sandy Hogan, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Thank you, Jamie.

3:38:54 Okay, I'm just going to comment on the roundabouts at this point until the end of the slides, but actually the village plan included a roundabout, but it was resisted for a long time by Caltrans until we had a change of directors, and I think it would be appropriate to bring that up again because that would really help.

3:39:21 With the Mammoth Mountain traffic that we get. And thank you, Andy, for bringing up the 11 in Truckee. I was going to bring up the three in Kings Beach, you know, and there are many other, you know, they're all over Europe. And as John said, as long as he's been here, we've had some planned, including the one at Meridian and a minaret that was once on the town program of work.

3:39:52 When I was on the LTC, and so I don't know. We can see your screen, Hayes. Oh, sorry. Sorry, that's okay. Yeah, thank you. Okay, I wasn't sure what the, but anyway, yeah, ideally, I think that's great in Truckee, the idea to get rid of every, you know, traffic light, because they are a pain compared to roundabouts, and you'll see them all over Europe.

3:40:21 And if the Europeans can learn to use it, so can we. That was last for Sarah. Okay. So this slide is pretty much beat up and done, I think. Yep. Shall we do one more? We'll do one more. Okay. All right. So are you seeing other things popping up on my screen? Not now. Yeah, maybe you want to share, unshare and reshare just the PowerPoint.

3:41:01 Yeah, I thought I was on PowerPoint alone, so bear with me for a second. Hopefully this is better. Sorry about that. You see my screen? Yes. Okay. So, diving into trails. So, on the 20-year horizon, looking at the Sherwin Trailhead connector and MUP. That's to connect the CRC kind of area to the Sherwin's trailhead.

3:41:39 And honestly, that could happen in a much shorter timeline because that project has been designed and is pretty much on the shelf. Looking at the Old Mammoth Road MUP, I mentioned that was also a recommendation of the Recreation Commission. And we talked about that just a minute ago. And then we have the Lake Mary Lake Trail MUP and the Lake George Trail MUP.

3:42:05 We've been through this exercise twice with the Forest Service, and these projects popped out of the Sarbanes work. The Lake George Trail Mupp is designed and on the shelf, and we have a pretty solid concept plan for the Lake Mary Loop Road with some improvements for pedestrians, for parking, to address some of the circulation issues, and these are things we'd hope to address with our new Forest Service leadership.

3:42:33 But we believe they deserve to be on the long-range plan. For transit mobility, again, these are very high level. We need to address lakes basin mobility through a hub. We need to address parking transit. You could have in their inner shuttles, this expansion of mobility services into the lakes basin. Kirk, you mentioned the crosswalk. We've had great success with our activated crosswalks.

3:43:03 We see expanding those into Davidson and the Voodoo Chute. Again, parking and mobility, utilizing potentially the bell-shaped parcel, maybe that frontage for parking, considering some type of mobility access there to serve for Eagle Lodge and the golf course. Obviously, the village, that's always on the list of mobility improvements. Some type of intercept lot, some type of park and ride lot to...

3:43:32 Maybe collect traffic before they hit town to kind of provide alternatives for transit before people even arrive in the city. Expansion of the hillside parking lot. We actually have a grant out for that for some additional spaces. Looking for a transit intercept lot. This is to support yards, ESTA.

3:43:57 And other long-distance trips right now, a number of them just drop off on the side of the highway. We believe we can do better. Finding a location for overnight tour bus parking. Right now, they're kind of scattered all over town when they show up, trying to find a central location for them to park overnight. Then expansion of our transit shelter program, strategically expanding that network.

3:44:22 I mentioned on the five-year CIP, the old Mammoth Road shelter in front of Bonds. That is the last of the old transit shelters. Once we replace that, everything will be to the current standard, and then we'll be looking to expand them into the highest needs around town. And then finally, identifying some type of long-term paid overnight parking. There's a need just town-wide to find some way to find...

3:44:51 So with that, I'm going to hand it over to Dan for any comments he may have on this list. Yes, thank you. In a number of these areas, as Hayes noted, this is kind of an integration of a number of different mobility elements, especially in the transmobility side. How do we just begin to connect things that are already out there? They're in other plans. We have a lot of work that's been done.

3:45:21 How do we begin to make them talk to each other a little better? How do we end up dealing with problems? We mentioned the buses. A couple years ago, we had some plowed in in the Vons parking lot. It took quite a lot of work to get them loose, where we put those. To an earlier comment that Member Wentworth mentioned, we could easily add in the expansion of mountain bike trail connection systems. We had a goal at one point for 100 miles. I think we're down to 99 or 98 miles now.

3:45:51 So adding some stuff that way in the recreational side could go into this as well. The other side, again, some of these areas we have looked at, what are the existing land that we own and how can we maximize its use to meet multiple needs? Again, the longer term planning side for that. The other side to this is the discussion for the village area. We are taking a hard look at the canyon.

3:46:17 Boulevard item in that area there with the connection to the gondola building. Potentially with the pedestrian bridge that was planned several years ago that has been dropped off from the private sector side. Looking at that and talking to the property owners there, again, some opportunities to maybe bring that discussion back. Looking at some additional modifications to the transit component there, the bus parking and pickup and drop off. And again, also...

3:46:44 Some way to help direct bike traffic into there, both from, you know, I'll say more recreational type bike riding, leisure, but also we get a number of mountain bikes coming off of, coming down from Canyon Lodge, for example, to come into the village area there to catch the bus again up onto the upper mountain even. And so looking at how do we connect some of those types of pieces together, the rushing...

3:47:09 It goes back to that multimodal concept. If I'm riding a bike down, how do I get a trailer? If I'm walking, how do I stay out of the street so I'm not dodging cars, buses, and bicyclists? So we have a number of areas in that particular location where we see some of those types of conflicts. And looking long-term of how do we begin to address that to make it safer, but also enhance that recreational components that people definitely enjoy from that site.

3:47:35 And again, that gets into the basin, that gets into the mountain, that gets into town, the whole nine yards. So it's a key area for a fair amount of discussion and opportunity look and feel for what that linkages could turn into at that site. I think to question Hayes on the voodoo chute, that crossing, is that up on, across the voodoo chute up there on Lake, is it Lake Mary Road? Or is it down at the bottom?

3:48:05 Over at the bottom, going across Lake Mary Road, over to the Mupp. The idea, and I can clean this up in the document, is to cross Lake Mary Road to get to the Mupp. Okay, is that it, Dan, while you have? Yes, thank you. All right, let's jump into this. Who'd like to go first? Okay, John, hands up? Yeah, I'll get started. So, Hayes, you'll forgive me that...

3:48:44 The Excel sheet I have in my packet, the font's a little small, so it's kind of hard to read it. I mean, I did my best. But what we're seeing here for the long-range projects is not exactly the same thing as what's in the packet, correct? I believe it's the same. Okay, well, what I'm seeing is different. Like under trails, where it says you've got Sherwin Trailhead Connector Mupp.

3:49:13 In my packet, it says Minaret Mupp is the first thing. In the Main Street, South Side, it's very different. You might be looking at the five-year CIP. There was a couple of spreadsheets that were included in the packet. Well, I can't, I, yeah, maybe it's a five-year CIP. I don't know if I have to be, so I don't have a long-term CIP, is that right? You do not. You should. It's not in the packet, it's not. It's not, okay, so all I have is a five-year CIP, okay. So my question is,

3:49:45 Are we going to go through the same kind of presentation for the five-year CIP or we're just doing this for the long-term at this point? We're focusing right now on the long-term CIP. I went through some of the five-year highlights, kind of the big changes, but we'll take a deep dive on the five-year CIP in April with the budget process. I just wanted to go through the highlights. Okay, so...

3:50:15 Is it going to be a similar session to this where we'll do the consensus piece and then you guys will digest the consensus and come back with recommendations? Yeah, I'll jump in, John. If you have comments on the five-year for tonight, you can definitely make those as well as the long-term. We just highlighted some of the five years at the beginning, but we can come back in. There is more information in the packet on the five-year. As we get to the budget side, there will be a deeper dive because we'll be looking at funding. In some cases, we may be looking at...

3:50:45 Not enough funding. So which project gets moved or does something slide or is there a priority goes back? So there will be a fairly significant discussion on that five-year capital improvement program as well. All right. So I have one suggestion I'll share with you all now. And I would like to see if I can get some consensus from the council on this one. I think it's an important one. But I would like to, Hayes, get together with you and Dan and just kind of drill into this a little bit more.

3:51:13 Because again, I had a pretty hard time reading this. So the suggestion I would have for council, which I think is really important, is there is an item we have coming up later this evening around, I think it's mobility hubs, is that what it's called? They came out of walk, bike, ride. And that's a different topic. But I think we have a real opportunity now, having exhausted two consultant passes on that component of walk, bike, ride.

3:51:41 To take, and Hayes, correct me if I'm wrong, but we have an adopted mobility plan, a pedestrian plan, a bicycle plan, a trail system master plan. And in those plans, they identify all of the nodes. These are adopted plans. The trail system master plan is programmatic sequel on it. And I would really like to see if we can get some consensus around staff moving forward to take those nodes.

3:52:08 Overlay them with recommendations coming out of Walk By Ride and what those facilities need such that they can come back and get into the five-year CIP so we can start doing those things. One of those things, obviously, is the situation of Horseshoe Trailhead and the work going on up there. And I just think it's really important we start moving forward with these things. I'm really getting tired of planning and consultants.

3:52:35 Doing studies. We have what we need to move forward to really enhance and invest all of those nodes that connect us from town to the places where all the people want to go. So I'd really like to see if this way we can add that to the five-year CIP.

3:52:51 Not so much in that because the projects aren't ready, Hayes, to go on the CIP because they're not designed and developed. But we could do, we could internally do the design and the development such that within a year or two, we could certainly come up with five priority projects and then get those projects on the five-year CIP and we could start trying to get some funding for those things and get them built. So I'm looking for, looking for a little consensus, a little love on this thing. I think it's really important to move forward with this. And I think taking that concept into the...

3:53:23 Five-year and even the long range make some sense as we take and overlay the existing plans, existing documents, and how it connects together. If I'm hearing you correctly, John, that you're looking for that type of work. And there's some very small things in there that may not be capital project-wise. If we're adding bike racks, for example, to personal experience, it would be nice to have a bike rack at the horseshoe parking lot, for example. But looking at some stuff that way, it can tie in both in the five-year and the long-term.

3:53:53 How do we take existing documents, existing plans, existing things that have some of the SQL work done and overlay it with a lot of the discussions we've had in other work that's been done looking over the last few years and go, okay, how do we begin to move those forward versus continuing to study on top of a study? Am I hearing you correctly? Oh, exactly right. I think between the mobility plan, the pedestrian plan, the bicycle plan.

3:54:20 Trail System Master Plan. The walk, bike, ride thing, which is advisory at this point, we've got all the pieces in place. Let's do it internally. Let's do it here with our staff and let's bring these pieces together and then, Hais, bring you that process would develop capital projects so we can start moving forward on these things because otherwise...

3:54:41 They're just not happening. And the connectivity of town to the recreation opportunities, which is why people are here, the needs for micromobility, really building the infrastructure is going to support that. Let's move forward on this stuff. So, John, what I'm hearing you say is that you take all these studies and you sort of layer them on top of each other. And you find the places at which the pin goes through all of them and say that's...

3:55:07 That's a place we all identified as being a place to do something. Is that simply, you know, kind of? It's pretty much it. It's like, again, I'll go back to the trail system master plan. All these no's that we've talked about, where people are going to.

3:55:22 They are in an accepted document by the town, if that's the right word, Andy. It's an adopted document by the town. It already has programmatic SQL on it. And we've got the mobility plan and the pedestrian plan, the bike plan that support that. If we just look at what's in walk, bike, ride, add the amenities to what we're proposing for these already established nodes, then we can say, look, let's enhance this node to look like this, to look like that, to look like that.

3:55:50 And certainly there's a lot of money coming out of the build back, not the build back better, but the infrastructure bill, a lot of money coming out of the state to do this kind of stuff. And I think if we don't do that, if we don't aggregate these things to start doing it, I don't know how, I don't know why, I don't know when we'd ever do it. And it's an obvious need. And I think we could get some pretty easy low hanging winds out of all this pretty quickly. So Hayes, if we were to...

3:56:18 You know, here are some other council members that thought that was a good idea. Would that change this at all, or would you just move it up a little bit? No, John's comments are spot on, and honestly, that is the intent of this document, is to advance projects. It's not to plan, it's not to sit around and just, you know, try to figure out how to do something different. You'll note that the lake space and mobility hub in the village are prominently on this list, and that's because that pin goes through those locations. Now, we didn't specify

3:56:47 What was going to happen there? Because this is very high level. This is just like, are we on the right page? Are we looking at the right stuff? But having a conversation about advancing specific projects in those areas within the five-year horizon, yeah, that's exactly what we're here to talk about. And so we can move some stuff in. And I think the more appropriate time would be to do that when we're having a detailed dive into the five-year CIP and then getting consensus on adding some projects, maybe.

3:57:14 Definitely not 22-23, but a 23-24, 24-25 horizon. And then being specific about those that we can target. And that gives council the opportunity, because this is a budget tool, to put money into those programs. So we're on the same page. I think we just didn't really get specific about why these items are on here and how we're going to target getting this work done. But I think we're all on the same page.

3:57:42 All right, well, we can just table this for the moment. We'll follow up and get something intelligible out of this idea and bring something back as part of the five-year COP. I had a comment, Dan, before I con you here. Two of the things, the Lake Mary Trail and the Lake George Mupp, those two things. Given the congestion with cars in that area, you know, people are trying to drive, they're trying to park, they're all over the place.

3:58:09 If there's any way where we could sort of look for ways to move that up, I would like those two to be seriously considered. It seems that a lot of these I look at and, you know, they all check a couple of boxes, but I think those two check a lot of boxes as far as, you know, giving us some relief in the lake space. And so that would be my comment. And I don't know if there's consensus on the council to think that makes sense or not, but that's kind of my thoughts on that.

3:58:39 You got support from me on that. I think it's, these things are so interrelated at this point. I think we start, let's start with that five-year discussion around the five-year CFP discussion around the nodes, improvements to those, and then layer, and then build out into these things to see what's going to work and what's going to be feasible going forward. But I think it's really, it's critically important. Any thoughts, Bill? I'm in favor of those moving up on the list.

3:59:11 Yeah, I have no problem with them moving up on the list as long as we remember when we're looking at that five-year list, we have to take it in context with the money needed for housing and the money needed for everything else. So saying we need to get these things done, it's true, we do. However, when we look at it in context of the budget, we have to overall look at where is our priority and where is that money going to go for right now for short term.

3:59:37 Well, it also becomes an element of what money might be available. You know, sometimes you have money available and you move something up because that's what makes sense. So, yeah. Right. But it has to be tied into that. The other thing I want to remind everybody, unless I'm wrong and Hayes and Dan can always tell me I'm wrong. None of the things on the long range list are set in stone. Oftentimes when we produce stuff like this.

4:00:06 Then we get feedback from our public saying, look, you're going to do this and I don't like it. Well, hold on. This doesn't mean we're going to do it. It means it will be brought forward under its own process and looked at in time. Nothing here is written in stone. Yeah, good point. Dan, I'm sorry, you had raised your hand. Yeah, I was going to ask the question if you want us to add something in here in the long term. Almost like I'm trying to think of the verbiage for it.

4:00:36 It's not a specific, but it's like the trail system master plan node connections, just as a placeholder. That's kind of what I was hearing, and I think it's been a couple. It doesn't lock us into something, but it's also, it's fairly broad as a challenge there, but then it allows us to go in and look and say, here's where that would start, even if it's connecting, you know, horseshoe with cold water in the basin, for example. But getting those node connections.

4:01:04 Based out of that trail system master plan, and ultimately the connections to town and how do we move people, I think that's the whole idea of the mobility. So I think that's a broad statement, but it may be worth, we can come up with some language for it, but I'd ask that we get consensus on the agreement to that. But having that idea captured here, I think it overlays a lot of the work we're doing, and sorry, Kirk was just making the comment two years ago, aren't we doing that right now? My answer is yes, we are.

4:01:34 But having a little, you know, definitional statement in there could be beneficial. So that's up if you want us to add something. No, I think that's a good idea. I think that that makes sense. So we don't have every single little piece of property on every single little corner identified. And like I said, you put these things on the list, that's nice. You look for money, that's nice. And then you see which one pops up and you do that. So I'm fine with that. Is there any public comment on this, Jamie? Yes.

4:02:01 Kathy Cage, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. So I was going to save these comments for the Mobility Hub review later on, you know, may refer to them. But they're appropriate here because these are long-range things. And I don't know, you know, how many of you guys actually read the Mobility Hub report? It's a product of some kind of tortured, you know, consultant work sort of thing.

4:02:32 Here's the challenge I have to the conclusions of that report. So just to reiterate real quick, the conclusions of the report is you have primary and they're called primary hubs and destination hubs. The primary hubs are the ones that have parking, for instance, and other things. The destinations have no ability to like, you know, no ability to park long term during the day.

4:02:53 I'm concerned with using that document, and we can go over my challenges to it a little more detail when we get to it, but some of the specific recommendations for there, they're really challenging. They identify Canyon Lodge, Main Lodge, and Eagle Lodge as places that have no ability to have long-term all-day parking. Like, what? This is like brand new in the concept here. Like, this was not, I'm on that working group.

4:03:21 And this was not discussed in our working group, so I don't know really where that came from. And there's really only three locations that are designed to have parking. And overall, the overall picture of what this is talking about in terms of a system is it's designed to meet our Park One strategy, okay? The Park One strategy. We all kind of know that. And I was...

4:03:47 Wasn't sure if we all have the same understanding of what that is. My understanding of a park wants strategy is you come into town, you park your car, you don't get into it again. Well, the real challenge for a town like ours is how do we overlay that kind of a transit system on a place that's got all kinds of condos with all their own parking, that sort of thing. Why would someone come into town as a visitor, and mostly I'm talking about wintertime here, come into town, go to their condo,

4:04:17 Unload everything from their car into their condo and now go back to a different parking place, park it in a parking spot, and then come back to their condo and use our transit system. It seems very weird and tortured and I frankly don't believe it'll happen. And that really brings me to a couple of comments here, which is what's kind of missing even in this Mobility Hub study brought it up is

4:04:43 How do we overlay a park once strategy on a town with a bunch of existing development, dispersed, you know, how far can you walk in ski boots, et cetera, et cetera. And we're missing sort of the dial-a-ride component, something that gets someone from in front of their condo into our transit system so they don't have to get in their car and either park at the, let me go look at your room. Oh, there's three parking places. Are you supposed to go park at?

4:05:11 The Mammoth Lakes Visitor Center or park at the Village Parking Center or park over at the Community Recreation Center. And from those, they're supposed to take the transit system. I just don't see that as a reasonable, realistic system. And that's my real fundamental challenge. And so here's my request. And I'll just put it within the context of this long range. We don't have a transportation system design.

4:05:39 We have concepts, and John talks about this a lot, and he's really right, we have like these concepts, but what we're missing is what kind of a system with how many buses, with some kind of capacity, where would the, you know, like vans go maybe that get people in the wintertime? You know, look, I don't think we have a lot of argument about what happens in the summer with bikes, but that's not the hard part. The hard part is in the winter with ski boots and gear and all that crap, and how do we get people to not get in their car again?

4:06:09 So when we get to the review of the mobility, I think, I don't think it's particularly useful for designing these things you're talking about. John's right. We should be putting things on the table that like what we can fund and so forth. Let this be some things that are not controversial, but I really challenge the underlying concept.

4:06:28 of this system of primary and destination, the ones where they've located them, and that if it would be really functional from a standpoint of how does that get used in a city that's already developed, and you're trying to get people to not get in their cars again. So that just, I just hope, I just, if we could do, spend some money to design a system with the vehicles, like what vehicles do we need?

4:06:56 Where do they go? What kind of schedule do they have to have? Can we even have enough vehicles to do it? And in particular, adding in the part where you've got an acceptable vehicle, and it's probably not a trolley, but something that's maybe more van size that goes into the Knolls, that goes over to Lake Mary Road, to those condos over there, that goes to all these places and picks up.

4:07:18 People, particularly skiers and ski boots, gets them to the places they want to go, and then in the evening gets them to where they want to go to dinner. And what does that system look like? And figuring out how to fund that system, if we figure that out, we may not need as many parking spaces and all these places where I don't think realistically people will go and use them that way. So that's my comment. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Kathy. Those are some good comments.

4:07:47 Any other comments, Jamie? No. Okay, thank you. Hayes, do you have what you need on this then? Yeah, and there was a request just to kind of revisit, so if you'd like me to do so, I will. Yes, are you prepared to do that? I'm going to go backwards. So on the trails and transit mobility, I'm going to move the Sarpane's projects.

4:08:13 And something called the Mobility Hub Improvements for Trail Nodes to the Five-Year Program. We had consensus on sidewalks, and I'm going to call it improve existing pedestrian infrastructure for year-round use. So I'll add that item. And then we had consensus to add multimodal to the OHV, OSV staging.

4:08:41 As just a note to make sure that we're being inclusive there. And then on housing, I wrote it down is evaluate empty retail spaces for housing purposes. We had consensus on that as well. Okay. All right. Anybody have anything to add to that or are we done with this topic? Okay. Thank you, Hayes. That was a great job. And I think we got some feedback and moving on here.

4:09:12 So everybody worked. We're at four hours and ten minutes here in this meeting. And we have not even got to the consent agenda yet. So I'm going to hurry up and jam through the consent agenda. And then we're going to chat. I believe that doing the public hearings is all pretty important. And then we would still be left with five policy items.

4:09:37 Let's just go ahead and do the consent agenda. We'll take a break and then we'll come back and see what we do. All right, we're on item number nine, consent agenda. And we have items 9.1 through 9.7. 9.1 is approve the minutes of the regular meeting of March 2nd, 2022. 9.2, approve the resolution reauthorizing the town council to meet virtually during the COVID-19 pandemic declared emergency.

4:10:03 9.3, authorize a lease agreement with Mammoth Disposal for use of 312 Industrial Circle in Industrial Park. 9.4, authorize a professional services agreement with Lisa Wise Consulting, Inc. for Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment Project Management. Item 9.5, approve and adopt the resolution establishing delegation of authority as a contracting agency of the California Public Employees Retirement System, CalPERS, to the office position of

4:10:33 And that is it. Would anybody like to pull any of these items for consideration? Nope. Seeing none, I'd entertain a motion to accept the consent agenda.

4:11:02 So moved, Madam Mayor, as you so eloquently presented them. I'll second. All right. We have a first by Council Member Wentworth and a second by Council Member Ray. Jamie, could we, any further discussion? Any public comment? Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. All right. It is...

4:11:33 639, I will see everybody back here at 646. Okay. I'm missing Kirk here. Oh, there he is. Yeah, he's stepping up to the table. Okay. Okay, so why don't we get back going here. And we are in public hearings. And staff, are these all time sensitive, these resolutions and amendments and grants? Yes. Okay, so we'll do those.

4:18:49 Policy items, what might staff suggest we could delay or where are we here? Yeah, we just had a discussion on that with staff, Linda. Some of these will not take much time at all. Okay, so we'll try to do them all? Yeah, I think we can get through it very quickly. All right, so let's begin our public hearings then. So I'll open the first public hearing, item 10.1, adopt resolution of intent to establish an undergrounding utility district.

4:19:18 And Hayes, that's still you. It's the first time using Zoom. I should unmute myself. You should be able to see my screen. Yes, we can. Hopefully it's the right one this time. So we're here this evening to adopt a resolution of intent to establish an underground utility district. We need to conduct this public hearing, which you've already opened, and like I mentioned, adopt a resolution of intent, which I'll go through in a little bit more detail later on.

4:19:51 So today we're going to go through, and I'm going to move kind of quickly because I know we're short on time, so bear with me. We're going to talk about the background, how we got here. I'm going to talk a little bit about the funding source. I'm going to talk about the UUD process, and Andy's here. He held my hand through it, so he's our expert. I'm going to talk about the district itself and then kind of walk through some of the highlights of the resolution. So background. So a number, probably about.

4:20:20 Four or five years ago now, we put together a project study report using LTC funds to tee us up for STIP money. And then we were able to appropriate some CARES Act money through the STIP for the design of a sidewalk on Moral Mountain Road. And then we were also able to add some money for construction. And then this being a priority project in the CIP, we were able to leverage the STIP funds, IIG funds.

4:20:49 And this will be phased over time in concert with a parcel project.

4:21:19 And it really acts as an interface to that development. When we were going through this process, we identified an opportunity to underground utilities as part of all this other work. And our last undergrounding project was Main Street, the first phase of that sidewalk project. The summer before we started construction, we undergrounded those utility lines. So this funding source that I'm going to talk a little bit more about is a great resource to

4:21:47 Put utilities underground for safety, aesthetics, and then also kind of supports these other projects and programs. So we're targeting what's called Rule 20A funding. It's a set of policies and procedures established by the Public Utilities Commission, regulate the conversion of overhead electric lines and other infrastructure to undergrounding, undergrounded lines. This is paid for by

4:22:17 Customers and rate payers, not just those in this location, but throughout the whole Southern California, Northern California area. There was a possibility that this funding was going to go away. There was a clock on it. If you didn't use it, you would lose it. We were in a fortunate position where we had a project. We had an existing district we could leverage. And then we approached the county. They did not have a project. They graciously granted their funding to the town.

4:22:47 So we now have a pot of about $660,000 of Rule 20A funding. This will cover the majority of the costs of the undergrounding of the SCE lines. The other utilities will have to pay their costs to participate. We're talking about Sun Link and Frontier. The residents and businesses will have their lines placed underground at no financial cost to the owner. That's a key aspect of this. This money will pay to underground the utility.

4:23:17 But we do need to be cognizant of the fact that there will be disruption on their private property because we will need to underground their lines to their businesses, their homes, and so forth. In order to access these funds, we need to form the underground utility district. I'm going to run really quickly through this process. Andy, chime in if I mess anything up. But to start, we had a...

4:23:44 Meeting with SCE just to consult on the possibility of forming the utility district. They kind of ran some very quick ROMs. They said that our project met the strict requirements and kind of gave us a green light to move forward. We published a public hearing. We contacted and sent letters to our utility partners. And then we're at bullet point four where we're holding a hearing to adopt our resolution of intent to form the district.

4:24:14 And then we're going to publish another notice of public hearing. We'll hold a hearing to adopt the ordinance on 4-6, and then we'll have a second reading on April 20th. And that should conclude the process, and then we'll continue on with our hard work with the utility companies. The district itself, the extent, it starts actually by the fire station on Main Street.

4:24:44 And ends at the intersection of Tavern Road. The intent here is to get the line that currently crosses Main Street Underground and then to underground all of Laurel Mountain and then everything on the Tavern Road Laurel Mountain intersection. So there shouldn't be any overhead lines in any of those areas. And I'll run through these real quick. So starting at Main Street, that pole actually leads to the underground on Main Street. So we put that underground, come across Main Street.

4:25:14 And then on the right-hand side of the screen is a pole by the barbecue shop, the barbecue restaurant. That would go underground. And then that whole line would all be underground. Mid-block, this is kind of what it looks like today. These poles would go underground. And then at the intersection of a tavern looking north and south, a couple of big poles, these would go underground. And like I said, the intent here is to get

4:25:44 This intersection, so you drive through, there's nothing overhead. That would require removing a pole looking to the west on Shady Rest, which is the photo on the left, and the two poles on the photo on the right, which are on Tavern Road. The resolution. So what's included? It's basically outlines our intent to establish the district. The justification, safety, aesthetics, reliability of service.

4:26:15 They're just a description of the area. It prohibits adding polls or expanding service in this area. And then it sets the date for a reading of the coordinates. And I know I ran through that real fast. So I'm happy to field any questions you may have on forming this history. Okay. If anyone wants to speak or ask questions, just go on ahead. Nope.

4:26:44 Seeing none. Okay. Is there any public comment on this topic, Jamie? No, there is not. Okay. We received the presentation. We've had an opportunity to ask questions, and there's no public comment. Therefore, I believe I can close the public hearing now. So I will consider us closed. And now I would entertain a motion to adopt the attached resolution, which is attachment A in your packet. Motion to approve is presented.

4:27:18 Second. Okay, we have a motion by Councilmember, oh, hold on, hold on, hold on, no, I'm just looking at something, hold on, by Councilmember Sauser, yeah, Bill, Bill who? Bill Sauser and Councilmember Wentworth. All right, Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido?

4:27:49 Yes. And Bill, my apologies. I didn't forget your name. I just wasn't sure we were supposed to do that yet, but we're fine. Okay. Going on to the next item, 10.2, which is the 2022-23 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I will walk the council through this public hearing. Thank you, Stu. I don't know if we need to, do we need to reopen a public hearing? I was going to say, yeah, let me open it. Okay, so we will now open the public hearing to conduct a public hearing.

4:28:21 Approval for Resolution 2223 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments as presented in Exhibit B. Thank you. So I don't need to repeat that, but the recommendation before you is to approve by resolution the 2022-23 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule as presented in Exhibit B.

4:28:43 I'll just give you a kind of a brief outline. I won't speak to all the items and the fee changes in the staff report, but happy to answer any questions that council may have regarding any of these fee changes specifically to either the facilities or our programs. But I do want to say that, you know, following two years of our limited, I'm very constrained. And as you can understand, stop, start programming. The department is planning for a full return to in-person programming.

4:29:13 And recreation activities in 22-23. The pandemic, as we know, has been an unprecedented challenge and really a major disruption to our way of life for both residents and visitors. The pandemic did highlight, though, and continues to highlight, that Parks and Recreation provides those essential services and infrastructure critical for the physical and mental well-being and certainly the resiliency of our community. Combined,

4:29:40 With the 2022 annual programming menu that we completed last fall and the recently completed strategic work plan that we presented to the council during the workshop, the fee schedule really completes that administrative framework necessary to deliver what our mission statement is, and that's really to deliver high quality, innovative and affordable recreation programming for both our residents and visitors.

4:30:08 To get to this point, we conducted an extensive analysis of the services, the costs recently borne of providing these services, the beneficiaries of those services, and the revenues produced by those paying fees and charges for special services. In accordance with the Municipal Code, public testimony was received by the Recreation Commission on March 1st, and the fees were unanimously approved by motion by the Recreation Commission.

4:30:36 Just a little bit of background here. The Department typically amends our facility rental fees and those admission rental fees every three years and revises kind of our recreation programs, which is our camps and programs annually. The exception last year was in 2021, during the pandemic, when we made the choice to freeze the majority of our fees. Many of the facility and admission fees were last amended in 2017.

4:31:03 So five years later, we're proposing to increase these fees quite modestly by approximately 10 to 15%. What you do see in the fee schedule in Exhibit B is the CRC. And that's through kind of the extensive community-driven programming and the playbooks we developed over the last five years with the Recreation Commission. We have what we believe created very much quality and affordable programs.

4:31:31 We have a lot of events scheduled, leagues, tournaments and activities, you know, for those ages one to 100. That's really our kind of target there. And then as Councilmember Sauser kind of commented, we don't know what we don't know at the CIC. So it's really incumbent upon staff to constantly monitor, evaluate and revise, you know, the programming as the facility evolves. So I'm happy to answer any questions regarding the fee schedule.

4:31:57 I know Betsy is, I believe, on the call in Zoom still, if you wanted to follow up any questions you had regarding the fees guilty to the commission, but that does conclude my presentation. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Okay, thank you, Stu. Betsy, was anything you wanted to add? Okay, all right. Does anyone have any questions for Stuart? No questions, comments? Okay.

4:32:30 Was there any public comment for this, Jamie? No, there is not. Okay. That being said, I will close this public hearing and move on to accepting a motion to approve the resolution. Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve a resolution of 2022-2023 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments.

4:33:00 As presented in Exhibit B of the Agenda Item. Well done. Okay. A second, please. Second. All right. We have a motion by Councilmember Wentworth and a second by Councilmember Sauser. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Staab? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you.

4:33:28 Very good, everybody. Thank you. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. Thank you, Stu. Thank you, Betsy. All right. Now we have a opening another public hearing to consider the public hearing to consider authorizing additional scope of work for the CDBG-CV1 and CV2-3 grants to provide funding towards the new public park and playground at the parcels.

4:33:59 All right, and I think no one, this is yours. Madam Mayor, before we dive into this, I'll need to remind that due to conflict of interest. Oh, yes, thank you. Yes, we need to recuse both Councilmember Rae and Councilmember Sauser, so if you could please do that. Yeah, this deals with the parcel, which they're conflicted due to their proximity to the parcel. Yes, thank you very much. All right, no one?

4:34:27 All right. Thank you for that. So yeah, as it was noted, this is a public hearing to consider additional activities for the CDBG CARES grants that the town was awarded in 2021. It's a quick housekeeping note. This is a public hearing and the public is encouraged to participate and provide comments. Information to access the meeting is on the screen. It's also included on all the subsequent slides.

4:34:55 The grant overview, the town was awarded $317,184 in CDBG CARES Act funding in 2021. This was two different grants, CD1 and CD2 and CD3. The CD1 funds do have an approaching deadline of April 30, 2022, and the CD2 and CD3 have a deadline of October 15, 2023. So that will be part of our...

4:35:21 The proposed amendment is to extend the CB1 deadline out to October of 2023. The CARES Act funds were intended to prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19. The approved activity in the original grant was to provide short-term subsistence payments to eligible households that included rental, mortgage, and utility payments. We used approximately $28,000 from the CB1 grant to provide rental assistance.

4:35:51 Then the state eliminated rental assistance as an eligible activity when the state rental assistance program housing is key was implemented. So that left mortgage and utility payments as eligible activities. Since launching those components of the program in June of 2021, no funds have been used for mortgage or utility payment assistance.

4:36:14 Therefore, due to the low interest in the mortgage and utility payment programs and the short expenditure window on the grant, staff is proposing an amendment to the eligible activities to transition from a public service type activity to an infrastructure activity where we would use all the remaining funds for a direct purchase of equipment. The proposed activities are to use the remaining CB1 funds.

4:36:43 That's approximately, or it is exactly $40,410. And all of the rounds two and three funds, which is $248,809 to acquire the playground structure servicing and other park amenities for the public park at the parcel. I lost my point. So through conversations with the state, this has been identified as an eligible use of the funds.

4:37:13 Since it will provide an outdoor COVID-friendly activity within a neighborhood that meets the CDBG low to moderate income area category under the low to moderate income national objective. That low to moderate income area category requires that 51% of the surrounding households earn 80% or below of the area meeting income, which the census blocks adjacent to the parcel do qualify for that.

4:37:41 That designation, so therefore this would be an eligible area to use CDBG funds. There are just two images on the screen showing potential conceptual site layouts for the public park. It is important to note that these funds can only be used for the public park component, not for any of the child care components. Even though that will serve similar neighborhoods, the state said it can't be used for those pieces of it.

4:38:10 The target completion date for the public park will be fall of 2023, so it does line up with those within the expenditure deadlines for the grants. Then also funding for the installation and funding for the remaining park features still needs to be identified. The council has questions on those elements. Stu Brown and Hayes are available to answer any questions related to the future completion of the park. So the recommended motion

4:38:41 This item would be to conduct the public hearing, receive any public comments and input, and approve the resolutions authorizing the additional scope of work for the CDBG, CB1, and CB2-3 grants to provide funding towards the new public park and playground at the parcel. Okay, all right, thank you, Nolan. Let's stop here. Are there any questions, comments to Nolan? No, I see none.

4:39:12 Jamie, are there any public comments on this? No, there are not. Okay. That being done, I'm going to close this public hearing and ask for a motion to approve. I'll go ahead and read it. A resolution approving the application for funding and the execution of grant agreement and any amendments there to there to there to from the 2020 Community Development Block Grant Program, Coronavirus Response Round 2 and 3 CDBG.

4:39:42 CV2 and CV3. Notice of ANOFA dated December 18, 2020. Anyone like to make that motion? Is that the motion? No, I just read it so you can make it easily. I'll look to staff. If that covers what you need, then I would so move. I'll second the motion. Okay, we have a motion by Council Member Wentworth and a second by Council Member Staff.

4:40:15 Okay, Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Okay, thank you. All right, so we're done with that. We can call back our other members. Okay, and we will proceed then to policy matters. First policy matter, 11.1, consider the final draft mobility hub study and program. Sandra? Thank you so much, Mayor Salcido.

4:40:47 We have been talking a little bit about the Mobility Hub Study and Program as a part of the CIP previously. And I do have a presentation if the Council is interested. However, we have received some public comments about the Mobility Hub Study and Program and a request to allow additional time for the member of the public to provide comments. So it's really at the pleasure of the Council whether you'd like me to walk through that.

4:41:13 I do think we should take public comments on the document today because I think there are a couple of members of the public who would like to provide comments on it. But staff is happy to bring this back to another town council meeting at a later date. As a side note, this is basically a planning study. As has been mentioned previously, this document can be accepted by the council or it can just be a document that informs

4:41:39 Just as an informational document. There is no requirement for the Town Council to accept this document. So it is kind of the culmination of the Mobility Hub Study efforts over the past year and a half. But just to note that there isn't a requirement for the Council to accept or take any formal action on the document. So with that, I'm happy to proceed and provide a PowerPoint or take public comments just at the pleasure of the Council.

4:42:08 Okay. Do any of our, any council members feel strongly about whether or not to receive the PowerPoint or whether to take the public comments or... I'd like to see the presentation, but it's not too lengthy. I think it'd be helpful to clarify what staff thinks based on what I read and reviewed. Okay. And everybody agree with that? Yeah. Before we go down that road, I don't mind seeing the presentation. Okay.

4:42:37 My take on this after reading it and talking it over with Sandra to a certain extent would be that we just use this as an informational piece, not as an accepted or adopted piece so that we can, you know, pick and choose, take what's out of it. There are some good things. There are some things that maybe aren't so good. So just as an informative document would be my push. Okay, I support that. Sarah? Sandra?

4:43:08 Oh, did you want a comment from me? I'm sorry. Yeah, is that okay with you that we go ahead and do the presentation? Oh, yes, yes, of course, yes. I think we have a majority. Okay, and it's Kirk who's nodding, I think. Okay, Sandra, you're up. Okay, I'll share my screen and start the presentation. Can you see the presentation? Yes. Perfect, okay. So just starting a little bit, talking a little bit about what Mobility Hub is.

4:43:40 You have the attached mobility hub study in your packet. So it has some description of what a mobility hub is. And I think there's no hard and fast definition of exactly what a mobility hub study is, but it's really a place, a location for people to seamlessly connect with different transportation options. It's also a place where people can see other transportation options. You all talked about the bird scooter option earlier tonight.

4:44:06 And so someone who attends who goes to a mobility hub study to maybe park their car might see that bird scooter as an option and then might use that in the future. So it's also to use it, but also to see those options so that they know that those are out there in the future to get onto public transit and to access all of those options. So what are the benefits of mobility hubs? Really providing all those services in one location to reduce congestion.

4:44:35 Provide group services that can save money. So if there are services that need a staff member to manage them, if all of those services are kind of in the same area, it allows us to save money providing those services grouped together. Obviously get people out of their cars and bring people to that location. So sometimes mobility hubs are strategically located near places where we want to bring people like the CRC. So, you know, somebody might come to the CRC mobility hub.

4:45:03 Do something there and then also, you know, possibly head out on the trail or do some other things there. So it does bring those people to that location. So what were we looking to achieve with the Mobility Hub Study? We were looking to build on previous work like the Trail System Master Plan, the General Plan Mobility Element, Main Street Plan, Walk, Bike, Ride, and really focus on the urban core of town. So this study really kind of focused on where can we locate these mobility hubs in our urban core.

4:45:31 to get people in town to places beyond the urban core and to really line us up to build something. I think we heard that loud and clear during Hais's CIP presentation is that we're looking to build things. So just a little bit of background. The document that's attached to your packet today builds on a previous Mobility Hub study that was prepared by Kinley Horne from 2019 to 2020. That document was funded by a sustainable transportation planning grant.

4:45:58 That was achieved through Caltrans. And the goal of that grant was to promote efficient mobility, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, use technology to improve the performance of our transportation systems, and support social equity and transportation solutions. The public received a presentation of that document in February 2021. And during that presentation, we really, the public raised a lot of questions, a lot of comments.

4:46:26 And it really made us think that we need to take that document and move forward and do something different. So we did move on and brought on Farron Pierce, who prepared the document that's attached to your packet tonight. What they did is they took the data. Kim Linhorn did a lot of data work in their analysis. They took that data from the Mobility Hub study. They added the stakeholder input that they got over the summer of last year and came up with the pilot programs and the quick builds.

4:46:54 Speaking of community engagement, they did do some in-person engagement as well as an online survey and came up with two pilot project locations, the Community Recreation Center and the Tavern Road Park and Ride. So just a little bit deeper dig into the community outreach that we did last year. The key takeaways were pretty interesting, I thought, is that most of the people who were surveyed and

4:47:20 As a note, it was a limited survey response, so we didn't, it wasn't a huge survey response, but the people that did respond to our survey, did respond to our in-person event, noted that they prefer to travel around town without a car, but oftentimes that vehicle is necessary. Another informational thing was that people need more information about alternative transportation options like transit.

4:47:44 E-bike rentals. And they were really looking for a reliable transit service and an app or some sort of a communication so that people actually knew when transit was coming, knew that that would just make it more reliable. And interestingly enough, a lot of people didn't know that the transit service is free in town. Another comment was more EV charging stations throughout town and secured bicycle parking kind of at our key destinations in town.

4:48:11 So, Hayes, do you want to talk a little bit about the CIP and the Mobility Hub Study relationship? Or I can hit on that. We've done a fair bit of talking about CIP this evening. So, there is a relationship between, you know, identifying projects, placing them in the document, and that planning effort provides the council an opportunity to fund the projects. And so, that's the exercise we went through today. We identified projects, looked back in April to fund them. Okay.

4:48:43 Thank you. So I think Kathy Cage commented a little bit about the mobility hub types. There's two different types that they describe in the document. I won't go into details on those. I'm happy to answer questions later if anyone has any questions on these types. And then the amenities. Just quickly on the amenities for primary hubs, parking, charging.

4:49:05 information for visitors, seating, restrooms. We received that comment that people were looking for restrooms at our mobility hubs. And then for the destination hub is really kind of limited parking, limited vehicle charging, but still that seating, waiting area, and visitor information as well. And so the document came up with a handful of recommended mobility hub locations throughout town. I think I can show them here to you on the map.

4:49:35 Up from the main lodge, kind of around the center of town. As I mentioned, this study was really focused on kind of our urban core with the exception of the main lodge destination hub. And the pilot projects. This was a theme, I think, in the document and in our discussions with the consultant is really use these small, easy to build pilot projects as our learning opportunities. This will allow us to really determine what amenities in the mobility hubs are.

4:50:04 Have the highest impact to our visitors, have the highest impact to people who are actually using these hubs, and we can use that information to inform our future projects. We also are going to be able to collect data and user feedback. Both Tesla and Bird are going to provide us with information from charging and usage, so we can really get a handle on how many people, who's using this, how often are they using it, so we can really use that to help inform future projects.

4:50:32 We can also monitor transit ridership at these mobility hubs and use that information, like I said, to inform future projects. Hayes, do you want to just talk quickly about the Community Rec Center and the Tavern Road Park environment? Yeah, I can do that. So the Community Recreation Center has a mobility hub component. This includes significant parking, ADA parking.

4:50:58 It's got easy access to the trail system, to the sidewalk, to the core on Old Mammoth Road. We discussed our contract with Tesla and EV charging will be a component of this. We have a double loaded transit stop on Old Mammoth Road so we can have two buses at one time with the transit shelter. We've got bike racks proposed. We've got trail system wayfinding. So it really has all the components that

4:51:28 It's a one-stop shop, someone who wants to park their car and go recreate or find their way to retail and commercial. This location pretty much avails all of those mobility opportunities. We do have it carved out in the geofencing for birds, so they'll be able to ride up in here, park the scooters in front of it. Obviously, that won't happen until the facility is up and running, but we do have it carved out and programmed for that once it's open for business.

4:51:56 Just to know that this diagram, this is just diagrammatic, this isn't intended to be an actual plan for the site, but just a diagram. And then here's the existing park and ride lawn. Yeah, and this site is, it's existing and it's underutilized. And so one of the questions we asked is why? And then, you know, this pilot program will allow us to kind of study, you know.

4:52:21 Collect data and try to figure out what we could do to better utilize the site. Some of the ideas, we're adding restroom, providing additional bike parking, you know, other facilities. I mean, it's already got parking, it's got EV charging. I will add that I have reached out to some other providers other than Tesla for fast DC charging at this location and potentially others. It does have good access to transit, but we could augment that with informational kiosks.

4:52:48 Again, better information so that once people park, they can find their way to where they need to be. Thanks, Hayes. Okay, next steps. So implement the pilot projects. And we know that CRC is online. And then have the discussions about possibly to have a run, park and ride, moving that forward, monitor the usage, update kind of our program. And I don't mean update the document itself, but I just mean the implementation measures of the program as needed.

4:53:15 And can use this information to frame and move forward future projects. So with that, you know, Taze and I are available for any questions, comments. And as I mentioned previously, we have received public comments requesting additional time to review this document. That I'm going to stop sharing. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you very much, Taze. Let's start with some questions for staff. Who would like to ask any questions about this study?

4:53:46 The outreach, it was done. I had a conversation with Phil about this from ESTA the other day, and we show the visitor center's potential hub, which doesn't work with our current schedule or buses, so I was sort of under the impression that he wasn't contacted. We know that Sandy Hogan has made comments, so she probably wasn't contacted, and Kathy Cage wasn't. So some important players here that we know we're going to, you know.

4:54:15 Speak to these, which is part of the reason I don't want to accept this as a plan, because that would scare the heck out of them and me if I hadn't had a chance to communicate. But how is that outreach done? How did we miss those groups? The outreach that was done for this phase was they did an outreach at the Belooza Belooza event. They also published a survey we did.

4:54:39 I had to go back and look at the consultant records, but I do believe we did send that survey out to the Mobility Hub Working Group, trying to get information on that. But I'd have to follow up with the consultant's records. And I wasn't actually managing the project at that time, so I just need to do a little bit more research. But I do believe we did send the survey information out and use that as the kind of vehicle to provide comments on this section, this piece of it.

4:55:10 Okay. John? I would very much like to, I mean, extend this for a month, but the folks who've been looking at this and voice concerns, I'd love to give them a chance to provide some written comments on that. I'd love to know what they're thinking and their analysis of this. I very much appreciate the presentation, Sandra. It connected a lot of the dots that I'm interested in. I was looking to get connected.

4:55:39 This is where we're all going, is micromobility and ways to move people around and get people out of automobiles. I don't think it's, I don't look at it as being park the car and never go near your car again kind of a world. It's going to be some mixture. And if we make it fun enough and entertaining enough and easy enough, people would say, I don't want to deal with the damn car anymore. You know, I'm someone who rides a bike all over the place. I would much rather do that than drive around in a car. That's just me.

4:56:09 So I'd be interested in getting the written comments and get some real analysis from folks who seem quite passionate about it. Okay, thank you. Anybody else? I will, I'm sorry. I just, I agree with getting those comments. Okay, thank you. I will remind everyone that we're not being asked to do any action tonight. We're being asked to ask questions, make comments.

4:56:38 And then not necessarily take an action tonight. So given that, Jamie, take public comment. Kathy Cage, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Thank you. You guys are probably sick of hearing from me by now. Glad you're here, Kathy. Okay. So I'll just reiterate some comments and maybe you can just please consider them. So this consultant broke the hubs into two primary, two kinds. We talked about those.

4:57:09 Primary and Destination. And I think it's important to look at the locations they identified and look at the descriptions of what they say those are supposed to do. They're supposed to be a place where somebody comes, parks their car once and doesn't go back to it. And I would just challenge that. I mean, I hope you guys do too. Who's going to do that?

4:57:33 You know, maybe someone coming from Bishop, from June Lake, someone from, you know, relatively regional wants to come in, access our bike trail system, you know, the summer, maybe that person does it. But one of the challenges, I would say, is look at our park and write lot. That's a 25-year on-the-ground experiment to how the concept that they're talking about this has worked. It doesn't. It just doesn't. I don't think it doesn't work because you don't have bathrooms there. Who thinks that? Seriously.

4:58:01 Who thinks, oh, no one's going to the park because there's no bathrooms? No, we don't have the transportation system. If we had the transportation system that was envisioned when we approved the North Village Plan, for instance, the reason there isn't parking identified for the general public there is because there was envisioned a transportation system that would deliver people seamlessly from where they are to where they want to go. We talk about that.

4:58:31 I haven't seen that kind of system designed. And I mean, like, how many buses would it take? When do they have to run to deliver all the people the ski area or when they want to go ski? And again, the biggest challenge for transportation for us is wintertime weekends. And I don't think this plan is supposed to be an actual plan that's supposed to have implementable stuff in it.

4:58:54 Helps get us farther along those lines. And I think there's just big enough questions and pieces really missing about how they would pertain that this is a little bit of like a cart before the horse on it. So, and then real quickly, I'll just answer something to Bill mentioned like, hey, how'd we miss the connection? So I was on that working group. This grant was a Caltrans grant.

4:59:14 It specifically asked for residents from the community, business and property owners. So I sort of check all three of those boxes, but I was really the only one who participated. I know we invited Camille from the fun shop, but she had a lot of her son had a lot of health problems and she didn't really participate. I know everyone else that was on the working group were institutional people. They were like Caltrans or town staff or whatever. So I was it basically. And the conclusions here are

4:59:41 Different than what we got as sort of a final review draft last year from the first consultant. So my bottom line is, I think, first of all, I wouldn't invest any more money in that park and ride lot because I think the fundamental role it projects it should play is fundamentally flawed. That's my opinion. You guys can make your own decision on that. But of all the places you have to spend money, that to me is a very low value place to spend money. And I think you should really look at whatever system we have.

5:00:11 Is how does it support that park wants strategy? That's a general plan philosophy. We're trying to impose that on new developers. The challenge is how do you retrofit that onto an existing town with a bunch of development? And that's the piece I don't think we have done well here. And that's what leads to me to a bunch of challenges.

5:00:33 And anyway, that's the bulk of my comments. And I'm going to add one other thing because I didn't get to add this on the five-year CFI. It's related to Mobility Hub, so I'll do that. But I know Hayes is listening. I just wanted to say that any new bus shelters, we're talking about trolley shop or stop in the village, a new shelter there, they should all contain water for refilling.

5:00:54 So we can get away from the single-use water bottle thing. I've had multiple conversations with different water district members. They have plenty of money over there. They love the idea of plumbing in both water and sewer to have a refill station in any new transit station we have, like just the side of the red ones for buses. So anyway, that's my CIP comment. And it's sort of related to Ability Hub. Okay, thank you. All right, thank you very much, Kathy.

5:01:22 Any other public comment, Jamie? Sandy Hogan, your hand is not raised, but I'm giving you an option. Did you want to talk? Yes, it is raised on my screen, so that must have been what happened last time. Sorry. Anyway, I do want to thank Bill and John for their comments, you know, for asking for public comment. And I do believe that...

5:01:58 Anything like this, where you're basing a program already on a draft study that has no public input, is really not a place you want to put a pin through, frankly. But I do agree with John about going back and let's use our CEQA adopted plans, such as the general plan and the general plan update, the park and rec master plan,

5:02:28 And, you know, obviously the trails, system master plan. And these also like the professional plan, you know, plan your parks. Those are valuable. That's a valuable study, that one right there, because they were professionals in the parks. And, but I wouldn't use a draft study.

5:02:56 Or an accepted draft study where you don't even have public comment. And I think one of the public comments by Pat Agnich pointed that out. What I would suggest, and I saw, I agree, mobility is a real big issue. I used to chair the Mobility Commission. I was a member of LTC for a long time. And I was here when the village, North Village Plan was

5:03:26 And I think it was on, actually, Sandra, your work plan a couple of years ago as a priority item, the update, and for some reason, you know, maybe it was a council decision to take it off, but it's nearing 25 years, and it's the perfect time, perhaps, to do that update because you need some overall planning, as John pointed out. You need some overall planning, at least for

5:03:56 The village area. You know, this, I asked at one of the public meetings, I did ask the consultant, I don't know if it was the first consultant or the second one, why he was not analyzing the town-owned parking lot next to the Westin, which has an approved 300 space parking garage.

5:04:21 And it looks like a Mobility Hub to me because it was informational. Everything was in there. And I realized that would be very expensive. But that plan was reapproved. I think it's still valid until 2023. Hayes would know. And I mean, the consultant didn't seem to know about it. He was handed one study that didn't analyze it. So he used that study. And that's not really.

5:04:50 That consultant didn't do a good job. I'm sorry. You know, and anyway, so I'm just suggesting maybe what you do is you take on an update of the North Village plan, including the mobility aspects, because right now, frankly, it's the answer to get people up to the Lakes Basin if you just would run a few more buses without.

5:05:18 And advertise that it goes to the Lakes Basin and it's just not for bikers. You know, I mean, that's what we need to do because it's, you know, it's going to be, there's going to be more development next to the west end. Is that the limelight, I believe? And, you know, more development on that upside. So that hillside parking garage, especially if that bridge in the CIP were to materialize,

5:05:48 Winter and Summer. That is terrific. Gets people out of that crosswalk. Anyway, and I will submit a lot of written comments, as I'm sure Kathy will summarize hers and others on the Mobility Hub. But just asking for the public comment, and I appreciate your willingness to give us that month, because there's no downside that I can see. Anyway, thank you for your...

5:06:17 Thank you for listening, and I appreciate your discussion. Thank you very much, Sandy. Is that it, Jamie? Yes. Okay, thank you. All right, back to council. There are no further questions or comments, and Sandra, you mentioned that we could spell this for a month and then go out with more.

5:06:48 Allow people to make more comments, more public input. Yeah, so we could, yeah, put it out for a month. Stu did publish it in our community update last week. It was published on the website in late February. So we can, you know, push it out to the first meeting in April, give people an opportunity to provide public comments. We could bring those comments back to the council.

5:07:16 In the first meeting in April, and then the council can make a decision about whether or not they want to accept the document or whether they would rather just, you know, basically set it aside, let town staff kind of pick and choose in the future about, you know, using some of the information gained through this. So it's really, you know, I think that would be reasonable. I think it'd be good to allow members of the public to provide comments. So I think that's what we would recommend.

5:07:43 Okay, that would be three weeks if we push it out to April 6th. Is that adequate, do you think? I think that's adequate time. Okay. All right. Then why don't we agree to that? Everybody agree with that? Okay. All right. I think we have it. All right. Thank you, everybody. And thank you, Sandra. That was a really good presentation. Thank you. Okay. Moving on to item number 11.2, policy discussion of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Contract.

5:08:16 Dan? Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. Let's be quick. As working with all of our NGOs, we've brought items forward for Council to look at the current areas where we have focus. We're continuing that with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. We do have a joint meeting with them scheduled for March 30th. And the item here, really, we did a whole lot of heavy lifting last year on this agreement.

5:08:46 Really narrowed down it to three really major focus areas. One on stewardship and implementation of outdoor rec and the arts and culture. We identified some particular areas in there that are working well. The communications and outreach element, same thing there. They're very active in that. And then working with the advisory committees and funding recommendations. Again, just recently kicked off the work for the grants program for arts and culture.

5:09:12 A couple of things that have worked well with this particular agreement, I think, is the primary staff person with MLR, which is our program director, Kim, who has an office as need be within the town offices. And that relationship, having her available, has helped a lot of the communication elements with Joel Rathke, our trails manager, as well with Parks and Recside.

5:09:40 There's been some really solid work in that area. And also, I think the narrowing of the focus by the council has given more direction as far as the work goes for the town. And I think we've been a lot more effective in this last year than we have been previously with that. And so I think the focus areas, there's very little change that would need to happen there from a practical standpoint. The work we're seeing, we can always tweak it a little bit.

5:10:06 They did provide grant support for developing the grant for Whitmore Park, so that would be a completed project. If the grant is awarded, there's actually language in there for administrative costs for MLR to be recovered. MLR is actually the applicant for the grant. The town was not an eligible applicant, so they would have that oversight for the grant, if you will, and we would be doing the implementation side of the grant as far as actually the work and putting that on the ground that way.

5:10:36 And then as we've had these other ones, I don't know if it needs to be clearly stated as a deliverable, we can leave it just the regular updates to council. They provided a couple of those this past year. So what it's like to ask the council really is if those primary focus areas are still legitimate, we can work through as we meet with them as there's some tweaks in that. But I think they'll still continue to be the areas for this next year.

5:11:02 The other element that will inform going forward will be that integration of the staffing of the Office of Outdoor Recreation and how they interface with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, how that continues to interface with the trail system work that is ongoing under Joel and others. And then the other thing we did, I think, that really helped in focus, we've kind of eliminated MLRs being the fundraiser and arm for municipal recreation items.

5:11:31 They have done a good job in bringing funding in for signage, for adopted trails, helping organize volunteers for trash cleanup and those types of things. I think it's been a much more effective organization from a town support level than what we've seen in the past. And again, unless there's areas of significant change as what we're asking for from council tonight, we would prepare a very similar looking agreement.

5:12:00 And structure for discussion with the board on the 30th. Okay. Thank you. Dan, so the only change that you're suggesting would be the area under grant support that would be removed? Yeah, it'd be removed or referenced in ongoing admin if the grant is received. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Questions from the rest of the council? I don't have any questions. Bill and I were involved in working on this, I think, last year. And Bill is obviously a representative on this.

5:12:33 Seems like things are working pretty well, and I think Dan's right. I think we need to wait to get that Office of Outdoor Recreation Staff person in, and let's start, you know, knitting all the pieces together and see what might be needed over here or over there and how to do things. So there's nobody from MLR here. Is that correct? No, Kim was out, and I believe a couple board members were not able to make it. And we'll note, we did swap the council rep for going forward. Sarah will be the rep on it. Oh, I'm sorry. Sarah, I'm sorry.

5:13:03 Bill did work on this the last year. He was the rep and spent a lot of time as well pulling this together. Sarah, what do you think? I agree. I think we should get that position moving first. Okay, good. Thank you. Bill, any comments, questions? Just to reiterate, I've said for a while now that to make MLR effective, and I'm not happy with some of the decisions they made last year.

5:13:33 But to make them effective, I view the Office of Outdoor Rec as being critical to this. So to move them forward with pretty much the same contract and the same funding as last year is probably appropriate. I don't want to lose this baby until we've tried to, you know, at least get it out of diapers. Thank you, Bill. Kirk, any comments from you? No comments. Okay, thank you. All right, then. This was to...

5:14:06 Basically provide staff direction, staff feel like we have direction? Yeah, I think it sounds like the work we're doing is moving in the right direction, so we'll continue with that as a recommendation to go forth to the joint meeting. This might be one of the simpler agreements we have with our NGOs as we look at the next fiscal year. Okay, really good. Thank you, everybody. All right, let's move on to item number 11.3, amend chapter 2.40.

5:14:34 Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. Did I write that word? Is that right? Okay. Okay. And this is also Stu. Stu. Stu's on deck again. Good evening. So we discussed this item during the joint workshop. So I believe I can be brief. All the information and changes are in the staff report.

5:15:01 The recommendation before you this evening is to waive the first reading and approve by title only the attached ordinance, the mending chapter 2.40 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. The proposed amendments this evening contained in the draft ordinance really incorporate changes as we kind of discussed previously, you know, that were proposed and accepted by the commission in 2014.

5:15:28 However, revisions were also made this year to kind of better align with the evolving role and work program of the Recreation Commission as described in the 2022 Strategic Work Program. On March 1st, the proposed amendments to Chapter 2.40 were unanimously approved by the Recreation Commission. The Commission Chair already walked the Council through the proposed changes, so I'm happy to answer any specific ordinance changes that the Council may have.

5:15:57 This evening. Again, happy to answer any questions and do want to thank the Recreation Commission for their patience and diligence, certainly for working with staff over the past eight years to revise their powers and duties that clearly better serve the Town Council and the community of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Any questions for Stu on these amendments, these changes? Nope, doesn't look like we're all good.

5:16:30 Okay, that being said, I'd entertain a motion to approve this resolution. Yeah, if I may. I'm sorry, ordinance, rather. It would actually be the motion to be the way of the first reading and introduced by title only versus approved because we'll have a second reading. Yeah, there's another reading. Okay, the recommended motion is listed here. Motion? I'm moved. I make the motion.

5:16:59 On Dan's recommendation. Okay. Okay. I'll second the motion to waive the first reading and prove by title only the attached ordinance manning chapter 2.4 of the Town Amendment Lakes Municipal Code. Yeah, it would be introduction versus approve. Introduction. Okay. Gotcha. Okay. All right. Jamie, a vote, please. Council Member Wray? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Staff? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth?

5:17:29 Yes. Mayor Salcido. Yes. Okay, everybody. Thank you. And thank you and Betsy and Stu for hanging around this whole meeting with us. It's been fun, right? Okay. Okay. Okay. The next policy item is 11.4. Adopt resolution supporting an independent and democratic Ukraine and condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Okay. Dan.

5:17:58 Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. This item's on by request of the council. It's our last meeting to have a resolution expressing the town's condemnation of the military invasion, aggression by the Russian Federation against independent country of Ukraine, and also to express our own concern and support for the Ukrainian people who have been devastated through this war, the idea of the humanitarian impact on that country, and frankly,

5:18:27 Thank you very much.

5:18:57 If the resolution is approved, then I would suggest that we do a little cover letter and provide it to our congressional delegation and state legislators. Any further comments on this? Okay. I told Dan today I wish we could scoop up a few of these families and bring them here to Mammoth and let us help support them. We know how to make that happen. But anyway. Okay. I would entertain a motion then to adopt this resolution.

5:19:30 Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council adopt a resolution supporting an independent democratic Ukraine and condemn the Russian invasion of Ukraine. I'll second the motion. I will. Okay, Kirk, thank you. We have a motion by Mr. Wentworth and a second by Mr. Stapp. Jamie, please. I'm sorry, let me stop for a second. Is there any public comment on this item? No, there is not. All right, thanks, Jamie. Okay, roll call, please. Council Member Wray? Yes. Council Member Souser?

5:20:02 Yes. Council Member Staff. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Salcido. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. All right. Last but not least, policy item is 11.5 fiscal year 2223 budget preliminary revenue projections. Rob. Let me bring it home. Get it to this finish line. Come on.

5:20:31 Yeah, so I ain't gonna share my screen briefly, but I do, I'm aware of how late y'all have been working here tonight. So we're gonna condense this quite a bit. As you know, it's very important that we do establish, you know, our lead line revenues, especially with transient occupancy tax, you know, staff, they've put a little, quite a bit of information into the staff report itself so that you can kind of get a sense of where

5:21:01 I'm showing you sort of the major revenue component section so I can just walk through that if that is the will of the council. And what I really need to do is just get some clarification that council is in agreement with that TOT number of 16 million. This particular slide shows where all the revenue components are, at least the major ones, the ones that

5:21:30 Represent the bulk of that are sort of delineated. But transient occupancy tax is $16 million. That would be $1.5 million above where we were last year. And certainly, I think, within the realm of what we're going to achieve, by all means. But it's also enough, I believe, to support where we are operationally as far as expenditures. But we are continuing to work through that. Understanding the will of the council this evening would...

5:21:58 Help inform, you know, how we move forward with the expenditure side. So it is important we cover that. And the only other one here is a property tax. I think that one's going up, you know, quite a bit, at least expected to. It is an estimate of staff, as you read in the staff report, because we have not yet received the estimates from rural county. But the rest of them are fairly modest increases.

5:22:24 Total revenue for general fund will be $27,341,000, or roughly $2.466 million above last year's. So it seems fairly significant, but I think it's certainly doable, and I would like to get some feedback if possible. All right. Thank you, Rob. Questions, comments for Rob? Yeah, Rob, I like it. It is moving forward with staying conservative at the same time.

5:22:54 I would not want to go over that $16 million TOT, but I'm comfortable with that, and thank you. And John? I'm comfortable with this. I'm hoping we can come up with another term for how we budget other than just saying conservative, because there's a lot more to it than that. Essentially that you've got a public agency not spending money until it's got it in the bank. I don't know what you call that.

5:23:25 But I appreciate it. Whatever you want to call it. And for those people out there who say, well, hey, you're bringing in all this extra money. Why don't you just commit it before you got it? I'm not interested in that. So anyway, it looks good to me. And Rob, maybe just in terms of going from, was it 14.5 to 16? That, I mean, there are

5:23:53 Inflationary and our usual, what's our year over year percentage that you guys look at that we have to do every year? About 1.5% or something like that? You mean as far as inflationary costs? Well, no, on the expense side. There's a number that you guys use year over year that we know it always goes up by a little bit every year for our base costs. Yeah, our base costs, which the bulk of it is our salaries and benefits.

5:24:23 Just the baseline of that, you know, it's roughly about $400,000 to $500,000, and that's encompassing all additional costs, and that's just for the merit side. But, you know, as far as the percentage, it's probably around 3% of an increase. Okay. And that's just year over year. That's just what we've got to do. So I'm good with it. Thank you very much. All right. Thank you. I just wanted to remind...

5:24:54 People who may be listening that have that catchphrase of, you know, you're not budgeting realistically, how close we came in the last couple of years to do the budgeted number. And if we hadn't budgeted in that certain way, I won't use that word, John, it would have been troublesome. It would have been resulted in a lot of...

5:25:18 Sarah Rea, Chris Bubser, Ph.D.: Unfortunate things happening and a lot of sleepless nights. So I continue to endorse and be very comfortable with the way that we budget and I'm very okay with this proposed budget for 2223. Anybody else? Sarah, did you get a word here? Okay. And Kirk? I think the staff did a good job. I agree. And any public comment on this item? No, there is not. Okay, Rob, anything else you'd like to walk us through or you're happy with this?

5:25:53 No, that's all for this evening. Thank you. Okay, very good. Let's move on to council member reports. Just go on and just talk and tell us what you've been doing. Nope, nothing. Okay. John, are you? I'll go quickly. I had a very interesting meeting with folks of Whitefish, Montana, talking about air service and how they're now building a $25 million airport up there.

5:26:25 And I think hoping to bring some of those folks back to talk with us in our region about what we can anticipate going forward. March 10th, I attended the ESCCRP meeting. This is the Mammoth Donor Project, which is super interesting. I did get an email with Janet Hatfield. Dan, she's looking for some communication from you and Pam, some other folks. She needs to hear from folks. They've got some things happening.

5:26:51 I would add that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Board Meeting will be in Mammoth in June. The Mammoth Donor Project is going to be kind of a showcase of their efforts of what they're doing there. Maybe wrangle some council members, go meet with some of the big wigs there. The board meeting with town council, last I thought was really great. Big takeaway for me from that is that EIFD.

5:27:11 I think we really need to do just an all hands on deck, get with the county, get with the other districts, and let's get that thing going. We've got big development projects coming into town. If we miss that boat, shame on us, shame on all of us. And I don't think we want to be singing that too. And Madam Mayor, I will cease and desist right there. Thank you. Thank you. If I may, I'm going to go ahead and come back and add something. Sure.

5:27:37 One, EIFD, John, you're absolutely correct. We have to get on that. Somehow we have to get our otherwise partners at the county to agree to this and move it forward. It's a great source of revenue for housing and a lot of other things. It could help us immensely. Secondly, I, along with some others, attended the town employee luncheon the other day.

5:28:03 And I got to, you know, reiterate and thank our employees one more time. We really do have a great quality core of people working for this town. And I don't see it often enough, but I appreciate them. And I appreciated that luncheon. It was a great deal. So thank them for that. Thank you, Bill. Nicely put. Sarah?

5:28:26 Thanks for mentioning that, Bill. I did want to send my apologies to town staff for not being able to attend. We're still avoiding crowds because we have an unvaccinated baby at home. But I hope I can go to the next one. And I also did want to say I really enjoyed last night's meeting and with the Board of Supervisors. And one thing I particularly remarked on was how efficiently it was run and that every item had a...

5:28:54 So I just think we should all be cognizant of...

5:29:21 I don't know. Maybe that would help us if we had a goal that we were shooting towards for a time limit and might just keep that at the forefront of everybody's mind. I don't know the feasibility of that, but I just thought I would mention it. Thank you, Sarah. And Kirk, anything? Yes, thank you. I attended the town luncheon and was able to talk to one of our county supervisors, and that was enlightening how they are trying to address their workforce housing issue.

5:29:52 In regards to workforce housing, Mammoth Lake housing, wait list is still fluctuating above 120 on the wait list. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. I also went to the luncheon and I just, you know, what you said, Bill, but then also for the people that put that together. That was brilliant. I mean, every single person went home with a raffle present that was, yeah, it was great.

5:30:21 I think everyone was just really happy to be there. It sounded like that. And yes, you're right. We have done well through this last two years and people deserve to celebrate and be thanked. You know, Sarah, as a department head with the county for all those years, I always really appreciated having to make that guess of how many minutes that it was going to take. And it really does help kind of guide, you know, as you're doing things. I mean, it's different.

5:30:49 Here in some ways, but certainly we could think about that and wouldn't hurt anything to make us all think about that time for sure. And I just want to thank everybody for sticking this out for a long time, five and a half hours. It's a pretty long meeting and go eat some dinner, get some good sleep. And thank you all. I appreciate every one of you. Thank you. Good night. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Thank you all. Bye.