TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2024

Trails Committee

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

324 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:31 Not sure if you guys can hear me, Andrew here, but lost in confirm if I'm wrong, but we can't hear you on the Zoom. I don't think, can you hear us now? Yep, there we go. Yep. There we go. Yep. We just have our mics turned off at the moment, but, and I can hear you well. Great. If you don't mind, I'm going to go ahead and take roll. Sounds good. Committee Member Souser is not here yet. Committee Member Patterson.

1:39 Here. Committee Member Howell. Here. Committee Member Ostergaard. Here. Committee Member Britton. Here. Committee Member Draper. Here. Chair Connolly. Here. Thank you. All right. Item two, public comments. I don't know if we have anyone from the public. Any comments online?

2:09 I have no comments at this time. Okay. And I will close public comment. Item three, the consent agenda. Looks like we're looking for someone to... I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. We'll second. Okay. Do we need a roll call? All right. Yes. Committee member Patterson? Committee member Howell? Yes. Committee member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee member Britton? Yes.

2:51 Vice Chair Draper. I'll abstain. I wasn't at that meeting. And Chair Connolly. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Jumping right into reports. First one is the MLR update. Okay. Start. Okay. Hello, everybody. I am going to give you a quick update on a few things that MLR has been working on in relation to the trail system.

3:32 As you know, we're sort of the administrative body behind some of the work that happens for the trail system. So we have been working on the two Sierra Nevada Conservancy grants. And things are going well. I wanted to just brief you on some of the actuals. We've been working on this project since 2022.

4:01 Things are coming to fruition. Andrew is going to speak to more later in the meeting about on-the-ground activities and things that are happening, but I'll talk to you about the grant specifics and where we are with those. So for the planning grant, it was a $510,500 grant with the bulk of that put towards the field analysis and surveys.

4:28 And as you can see up here, about 60% of that grant has been spent, and primarily that is all for the field analysis and surveys, which is great because that is the bulk of the expenses. This is doing the environmental work to get about 20 to 30 miles of trail analyzed for the NEPA work.

4:56 Is there any questions on these grants? In the staff report, I sort of went into the background of how we looked at it as a whole project and decided to split it because the trails needed all the environmental work and our trailhead was already shovel-ready. And so I just wanted to make sure everybody was aware how that process went. And for the Sherwins Meadow Trailhead, not a lot of...

5:26 Expenditures to date, because once the contractor completes the project, the final billing will come in. But that has been, that's a $953,500 grant, $933,000 for construction alone. We've included tribal participation in both of these grants in hopes that we can not have any financial

5:56 Burdens put on the ability for tribes to come and participate and provide input for the trail alignments or anything to do with the trails or interpretive panels. So far we haven't had any of those expenditures. We've certainly put it out there and will continue to do so. Just a quick question on that. Have you received a response from tribal members? No. So Gretchen and I went down to the

6:28 Intertribal Forum, I believe is the correct word. It's like a quarterly meeting. We went down to the supervisor's office in Bishop last February and presented the interpretive panel proposal for the trial head and requested input and set up some potential meeting times and dates and even just email us subjects you would like to be.

6:56 Considered, and we did not hear anything back. We are in the final stages of those panels and have sent the final draft back to the tribal liaison in hopes that we'll get some feedback. That's great. I'm really proactive. Good work. I'm trying. Yeah. Any other questions on the grant aspect of these two projects and where we stand or how things are going? We'll be requesting extensions on both of them.

7:29 Which is fine. Just obviously things move slower. But it's well within like the overall timeline of when everything needs to be completed. So Sierra Nevada Conservancy is on board with all of that. Okay. And so also just a quick touch on the Adopt-a-Trail program from the MLR perspective. This program started in 2019 as a pilot.

8:04 With, I can't remember off the top of my head, maybe 20 facilities to kind of see how it goes. Now we're up to 60 throughout the county. 40 of those are within the town of Mammoth Lakes and out of those 40, 34 have financial sponsors, which definitely helps bring a lot of funding into the trail system. I'm sorry, 27 have financial sponsors in the town.

8:31 Overall, out of those 60 facilities, 48 have volunteers taking care of either the trails, lakes, paths, trailheads, whatever the particular facility is. And so far, financially, this program has brought over $130,000 into the Mammoth Lakes Trail System available funding. And some has been spent, and there's still a good amount available for any

9:00 Unexpected expenses or something Measure R can't cover of $97,000. Yeah. What has the majority of that money been spent on that? It's been, I think we used some of it for some staff time that was like out of Measure R expenses, signage needs. It's basically, you know, as the trail system comes across a need.

9:33 The MLR gets invoiced. I think there was some discussion about purchasing a trail dozer with that, but that hasn't moved forward. I think Andrew can probably speak to this. I think the idea is there, and then if the sharp trails, the proposed action and the decision comes through, then the trail dozer will be looked at. Okay.

10:04 I didn't add this in my staff report, but I put this in after the fact just because Tangle Free Waters does touch on... I did have one thought on the adoptive trail. Sure. I think if your budget allowed, it would be nice to do like an annual newspaper. I'm thinking the listing of sponsors might also garner more people to do it, but I think I'm sure the sponsors would appreciate that and also just might help their awareness. Awesome. Great idea.

10:35 I like that idea to piggyback, maybe include which are still available. Yeah, it's become a giant web page, a lot of facilities on there. I should know this, but do you have an annual party for those folks? We have a volunteer party. Right. And they're included in that space? Correct. Yep. Yeah, so we do food and beverage and fun.

11:12 Most people do. Okay, and so Tangle Free Waters is, you know, modeled off of the same type of program where there's fiscal sponsors and volunteer stewards. This focuses on collecting used fishing lines at lakes and waterways. There's, it's a county-wide program as well, however, it's not split up on the back end as Adopt-A-Trail is.

11:45 And so there's 33 locations throughout the county, nine in Mammoth Lakes. It's definitely a lot harder of a program to manage. Fisher people aren't quite as responsive as trail people. But you might recognize this photo from one of our most esteemed volunteers who lined up the fishy line she collected. Angie, thank you very much.

12:13 But again, so far we've brought some money into this program, $28,000, $11,000 available for maintaining the stations. We have to ship the fishing line off to get recycled where it gets turned into either new line, artificial reef or other fish habitat for restoration efforts. But basically the town of Mammoth Lakes accounts for about a third of the program.

12:40 Lots of stations at all the lakes in the lakes basin. There's one at Hayden Cabin and then also at Mammoth Creek Park West. And last, just for awareness, there's also over the years, you know, people love the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. It's definitely developed a brand for itself and have reached out to Mammoth Lakes Recreation wanting to donate funds directly and only for work on the trail system.

13:12 And currently, there's $16,000 available for that. And the winter recreation coffers dwindled down to $200, but you never know. It's $200 that could be spent on something. You know, so if there's unexpected expenses, again, like adopted trial or something that Measure R can't cover, these funds are available at the pleasure of the trial system.

13:38 So any questions on any of that or the programs or behind the scenes, how it all works? You mentioned that the winter recreation dwindled down to 200. What's the reason for that and what's the source on that? Just small expenditures like I think several years ago when the beacon checkers were getting stood up, batteries were needed or a beacon checker or maintenance or small signage needs.

14:08 And the source of revenue for that? Just private donations, individual donations. Is it advertised? Not. It's just people have reached out and said, I want to donate $10,000 for the trail system. So another source of unrestricted funding, per se. Okay, and I think that's all I have. Happy to answer any other questions. Okay, well, thanks for the report. And if there aren't any more questions or comments.

14:44 You know, we'll move along. Okay, item 4.2, it's a MLTPA trail counter report. Hello, I'm Christy Williams, know most of you. I am a project manager for Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation, MLTPA.

15:08 And I have the pleasure finally to be the project manager for the MLTS project and for any client work we do with the town of Mammoth Lakes. So I just wanted to pop in very quickly, say hello, let you all know that I am the lead on the project on behalf of MLTPA. If any of you have any questions, you can always reach out to me. I believe you all know that MLTPA does have a contract.

15:33 With the town to be providing a handful of very specific services for the Office of Outdoor Recreation and the trail system. And one of those items is that we operate and maintain the trail counter program. And we do get a lot of support from Andrew, the trails manager, but we have a staff member who's been leading that on.

15:57 MLTPA side, that's Tanner Bissonette. You'll hear from him in a second. Before that, I do want to introduce you to a new member of our staff. Will Gale is here today, and you may recognize Will. He works, he's going to be very part-time for MLTPA, lives here in town, works at Mammoth Mountaineering.

16:16 And then also in the summer, you may see him at Tioga, the Tioga Gate. He works for the National Park Service for Yosemite. So great to have Will here. He's actually, the other half of my announcement is that Tanner, unfortunately, is going back to school. And so we are losing him. So Will is going to be picking up the trail counter program. So I wanted you all to see both of them, get a chance to say hello.

16:39 But Tanner has been running the program for us for about a year and a half, a little over that maybe. Many of you know Tanner. He was born in Mammoth, raised in Mammoth, went through the school system here in Mammoth.

16:58 Good friend to the community. And I'll let you introduce anything else you want to say, but it just has been a pleasure to have Tanner working on this project and working for MLTPA. Always love to have a local young adult working with us, and especially as he's getting interest in the public sector. So Tanner Bissonnette, I will be driving.

17:23 Angie, let me know if for some reason you can't see my screen, but I'll advance the slides and Tanner will announce the program. Thank you very much. Good afternoon to the Mammoth Trails Committee. My name is Tanner Bissonette.

17:39 As Christy said, I have been a project specialist with MLTPA for the last two and a half years and have been in charge with handling MLTPA's duties, fulfilling our end of the trail counter collection program since about last winter. So I'm going to take you through some background and history of the trail counter program and then look at some snapshots of the data this year. And if you have any questions, feel free to interrupt me along the way. All right. So.

18:07 We have a couple different types of counters out there. There are two types that are deployed and regularly maintained, infrared and vehicle counters. The infrared counters are used to count individuals, and the vehicle counters are used to count vehicles. There are two vehicle counters currently deployed. One is at the entrance to the Shady Rest Park, and the other is at the entrance to the Sherwin Meadows parking lot, which has just been recently refurbished.

18:35 These are magnetic sensors that track cars as they pass by them. They are set with a radius that hopefully catches one side of the road, although the one at Shady Rest Park may be catching a little bit on both sides as they come in and out. The infrared counters are stationed at the start of trailheads throughout the town of Mammoth Lakes and the Lakes Basin with...

18:58 Then that will include people coming in both directions if it is a start of a trailhead. While most locations operate smoothly and without complications, occasionally counters are disrupted by weather, battery issues, or unfortunately some human disturbances. A couple of locations have been favored by individuals to stuff them with pine needles and leaves to keep them from counting people, and it keeps the sensors from working, which is a little annoying.

19:27 Since roughly 2017, 30 traffic trail counters have been installed at various trailheads and along the multi-use pathway through the town of Mammoth Lakes. This was my first full summer in charge of deploying, maintaining, and collecting the data. Near the start of the summer as the snow was melting, MLTPA staff

19:53 prepares the counters, we check the batteries, their name status, make sure they're functioning, and then we go to the pre-selected locations and install the counters and regularly check them to make sure that the data is coming in. And then we upload that data to a website called TrafX, which is where we get all the trail counters from.

20:15 I have prepared kind of the last five years worth of data to compare at all of these sites. And a note, the 2023 season was not included due to a very late start from the snowmelt and some transitions of who was running the program led to some inconsistent data. So this is a map of where the current trail counters are installed. In red, you will see the infrared trail counters and the two vehicle counters you'll see in blue.

20:50 This right here is a graph of the last four, five years of average daily traffic at the different trail counters. So we're looking at June 1st through October 31st over the last five seasons. And as I mentioned, 2023 is not included. The data shows consistently high level of traffic at the popular sites and pretty consistent traffic over the last couple seasons.

21:19 Any spikes have been omitted from the data. The one that I have included left in because it was left in last report is this 203 south trail counter that had a very kind of over a long period of time high usage of data that did not seem as a short period of spike that would have affected the data. Are there any questions before we move on from that?

21:54 The same data just presented in kind of a bubble format. So you're looking at the different trail counter locations and the larger the bubble is, the more usage it got. This here is a snapshot of the specifically of the multi-use path. So these are trail counters along our paved MUPS throughout town. These are going to count people going in both directions. As you can see here again, there's a

22:28 Large usage in 2019 at this 203 loop, which is right near where the new Mono County offices are and the courthouse. It's right along that path there. As you can see, the data has been quite consistent over the last couple seasons at all of these sites with no real large variations in usage.

22:54 Do you know, what was the reason for that spike? So, in 2019, it was not really given a usage in the last meeting that I listened to, and this was many years before my time, so I wasn't around when this happened, so I can't give exact knowledge to what caused that. But it happened over about a two-month period was high usage, so it didn't seem like a spike would when you normally look in the data and there's a week or so that there's high usage that doesn't seem consistent.

23:23 Would that have been with the construction of the site? It may have been at the time. That is a good comment, Rob. It'll likely spike again now. Right. So this next graph is looking specifically at the counter in front of the Welcome Center. I wanted to include this because

23:46 This counter had a little bit of an issue. After one of my collection dates, something knocked the counter, and it stopped collecting data for a period of time until I went back on my routine to check it and got it restarted. But while it was counting, you see fairly stable usage throughout the summer. This is a snapshot looking at specifically the two vehicle counters that we have at the Shady Rest Park entrance and the Sherwin Trailhead parking lot.

24:18 As you can see, fairly similar usage over the last couple seasons. They were first installed in 2020, so that's the earliest data we have for them. But you can see Shady Rest Park has seen slight increase since it was first installed and then a bit of a leveling out. And you can see the Sherwin Trailhead has maintained kind of similar data over the last couple seasons. This is looking specifically at the counter data for the Shady Rest Park.

24:50 So this is not average daily traffic as we have been looking, but this is just the traffic, full traffic for each day. And you can see fairly consistent throughout this summer. There weren't any real spikes or any real drop-offs that would have indicated something wrong with a counter or indicated a stoppage to recreation out there this summer. So it was pretty average.

25:18 And then this next slide is looking at the Sherwin Trailhead parking lot usage. Except for this one weekend, it's a very consistent usage throughout the summer. Can anyone have a guess on what that weekend is? It happens every year. Yes, very right, it's the motocross. That area is used as a staged parking area, so a lot of cars go past that vehicle counter that weekend, and you can really see every year.

25:45 Whatever weekend the motocross happens, this really consistent spike in usage from that parking lot.

25:54 So kind of just an end-of-year summary. We kind of experienced a very normal season after a very average winter. There was no real impact to the start of the summer counter seasons. All of the counters were installed and operational at the start of June. We were lucky that we had no major fire events near Mammoth that caused any noticeable smoke impact. There were also no forest closures at all this season that would have majorly impacted recreation.

26:20 And we continue to see high usage at popular sites. And it has stayed relatively similar usage over the last couple years since the COVID pandemic. And that's kind of all I have for you guys. If you have any questions. Yes, Elise. Question. How is this information used? Or is it used by MLTPA? Or are you just collecting it? We mainly collect it and then...

26:46 Present the data to you guys. I think in the past has been used to secure extra funding for new sites. If there is high usage in certain areas and not high usage in others, we can maybe try to encourage other usage in other areas. I'm sure Gretchen and Andrew have better answers to that of what they exactly use the data for. And if I can add real quick, it is the only, I think, the only like quantitative data

27:16 That's being captured around town for recreational use, right? The mountain does skier visits, but like around town, like this, we are giving it to you, right? For you all to use. And we hope that it'll be used for, yeah, all the things Tanner said, making decisions on funding. Further improve the program. The trails program, not the counter program, but the trails program in general. Yeah. And I guess, should we throw it out to Gretchen and Andrew, see if they want to add anything on that? Or Kim?

27:46 Oh no, I'm just pointing to Andrew up there. Okay. Is he waving? Hey guys, yeah, I think you're right on there, Tanner. In the past, we've used that data to support grant applications, so when we were paving kind of that final bit of the town loop over by Mammoth Creek Park, in between Mammoth Creek Park and Snow Creek, that used to be dirt, and that was really helpful to have a counter out there to...

28:16 Just have some, you know, like I said, quantitative data to inform that grant, and it was really helpful in securing that grant. Other areas where we've used it is in trail planning efforts with the Forest Service, so like when we're out in the shore winds looking at trails and the ranger or resource specialist has concerns around levels of traffic,

28:46 And potential deer migration corridor or something. We're able to say, okay, well, you know, this is the level of traffic on the trails in this area. And that's kind of what you can expect to see on a new trail if we were to build it in this area versus a higher traffic area like the Lake Basin or something. So it's come in handy in those instances as well. I think, you know, we've been

29:16 Sort of just hoarding this data more or less, and I'm sure there's a lot more that we can do with it now, especially that we have kind of a nice backlog of data where you can establish trends and whatnot, and I think Lawson's got some things to add. Yeah, pardon me. Yes, thank you. We used it recently as well for Recreation Trails Program grant that we were a finalist for.

29:44 For repaving in the mops and having that data is absolutely crucial to support those types of endeavors. And as we move into new trail system master plan master planning, moving into the future, that data will be really useful to inform future management. Obviously, areas where we're seeing a lot of high use.

30:05 That can help inform how we manage those areas into the future. So it ties in, I think, to a lot of our planning endeavors that we're looking to move forward on in the future as well. I have a couple of questions. With regard to technology, things change over time and more advances come online, more capabilities come online for understanding not just bodies passing past clickers, but more along the lines of who they are.

30:35 I mean, I think that's, while it's important, maybe not as important for the utilization of the trail, but it could shed some light on what is attracting the visitors and where they may be spending their time a little bit. So I would be interested in where we can dive deeper into the data for

31:01 What it could tell us and maybe what other recreational locations are using data for in that space, right? Because I think we're sort of a data-driven society and the more we can gather and understand about things, the better we are, I think. Definitely. I think...

31:23 At least with the Trafex counters, we're using their latest technology. We recently replaced the dock that is used, so it's their latest generation of that technology, which is used to pull and upload the data. But I don't know if Andrew or Lawson have any ideas about kind of using that data further, a different kind of method of collecting that captures kind of a different set of data.

31:48 Yeah, I know we capture some information about like cell phones that come in and out of an area, right? So you can have unique visitors and maybe where they're coming from and those types of things, how they visit those spaces. Yeah, Rob, I think that's the next evolution we're looking into. I've spoken with Stu about this. Parks and Rec has utilized this since then. The company that we used in the past, Playcor, has stopped doing this type of service.

32:15 So we're looking into two other options for that, discussing with the Local Transportation Commission as well as that falls right in line with that type of data collection. But yes, I think you're correct. There's an evolution that is occurring in this world of data collection. And we're also looking even longer term of utilizing potentially other forms of folks that look at these things to take a look at.

32:39 Other sources, such as Strava or AllTrails, and try to get a better idea of how folks are using other pieces of infrastructure, whether inside or outside of the town boundary, you know, trails, things of that nature. So definitely agree that that's kind of the next evolution of this human counter program. I'll just kind of...

33:05 Jump in. First off, Tanner, wonderful presentation. Thank you very much. This is awesome to see and you did a great job presenting it and really looking at that data. It's interesting to kind of see the, you know, the high numbers of Shady Rest Park and, you know, I can imagine that it might be a good, maybe helpful to retain some data on the summer programming there just so that that can be maybe

33:29 considered in looking at that for the future, like when the kids are having soccer practice to kind of maybe help pull that out a little bit. Definitely. Yeah, that's great. Thank you. Yeah, and then my other comment about the stuffing pine needles, I know that the counters are sometimes hidden, and I know you guys have to put them in a certain location. Yeah, most of the counters are in the best place possible.

33:58 A couple of them are just super visible. They're in areas without a lot of kind of brush that can hide the boxes. So one of them that had really kind of high usage was the McLeod Trailhead. And at that trailhead, as you know, it's kind of a really dead area. There isn't a lot of trees. So the box there would be really quite obvious. And people walking along there would stuff that one more than any other. Yeah. And then just a last question. For you, looking at all of this data, were there any big

34:28 Ahas or oh my gosh or that's cool type of things that you found. Yeah, so I think seeing the motocross event really kind of portrayed in that data as that big spike and you see it every year that we have for that vehicle counter location. Whatever weekend we had the motocross, there's this big spike and then it levels off. So I thought that was really interesting. But we just, we had a really, thankfully without any negatives, we had a really average year. Recreation was

34:57 consistent and steady, which I think we can be thankful for. Cool. Thank you. Any other questions? All right. Thanks for the report. Thank you very much, you guys. Thank you. Okay. We've got a report 4.3, Trails Program Manager. All right. Sorry to have to join virtually today. Just came down with a cold last couple days, so.

35:47 But glad we have this platform all figured out. So hopefully this goes smoothly. Just want to share an update going into winter on some of our winter programs, some of our trail planning programming, and just a little bit of our plans for next season of summer work. So here's some things that we'll go over. Our grooming program, myself, along with

36:20 Rick Laborde, Joe Donovan from the Forest Service has been out there traveling the network basically just making sure it's free of trees that would obstruct the groomer and then installing signs at junctions as well as reassurance signs along the network so that the groomer and trail users are able to navigate the trail system during inclement conditions. So we're staffed up, got myself.

36:47 I'll be the lead groomer, Rick Laborde, who created this program back in the 80s. He's signed on to be kind of our lead trainer, so he'll be training myself and Devin on operating the Piston Bully, which Rick's got a real wealth of information there, so really glad that we have him on the team. I think we're set up for success in that regard. He and I went out after this last storm and groomed.

37:18 The A, B, and K trails just in this area in between the Scenic Loop and Shady Rest Park. That went well. We had just enough snow to kind of get through there and, you know, not enough snow to continue to groom it. So basically out there, the roads have large whoops or humps in them. And if the snow is not deep enough to fill those and kind of...

37:47 Take that away from the trail, then it becomes pretty hard to fill those in and not hit dirt with the tiller as you go through there. But anyways, we had a great day out. Rick was able to, you know, teach me quite a bit about just operating the machine and, you know, what a really five-star groomed trail should look like and kind of the mechanics behind what you have to do to get there. So feeling good about that program.

38:16 And just waiting for some more snow before we go out again. Any questions on OSV grooming? Just one, Andrew. I remember a long time ago, someone would go out and prep the OHV trails first before the snow. Did Rick talk about that at all? Yeah, so I mean, I've been doing that in terms of tree work, but...

38:44 But it brings up a good point. So Rick, at the time of this program's inception, was also the summer OHV manager, and he had a drag that he would pull out there to smooth out these roads. I'm not sure for the last 20 years what the history of that maintenance is, but I know in the last 10, nobody's been doing that. The equipment is no longer here. There's no OHV manager.

39:15 So, yeah, that is a concern moving forward for multiple reasons, which we'll talk about in other ones at the end of my presentation. But, you know, I don't foresee the forest filling that position again because of their current hiring and budget situation. So, yeah, it raises the question of, yeah, you know, the viability of this program if these roads are to continue to go completely unmanaged.

39:45 Andrew, I just wanted to make a comment. So I did get a chance to go out on snow machines right after Thanksgiving and did notice the improvements in the signage out there. So I want to thank you for that effort. It was very noticeable. Great to hear. Thanks, Rob. On that note, the map that you're showing right now, beautiful map, are there components of that that are on the signage? Or do you have an example of what that signage might look like?

40:16 I don't have an example for you, Mike, but it looks like this. It's just an older iteration of this map, laminated and stapled to an orange-painted piece of plywood with a little tiny roof over the top of it. It's pretty bare-bones and basic, but it does the job for now. I think moving forward, we might get something printed on metal. But for this season, it's just...

40:45 Kind of using what we had, doing the best with kind of the existing sign design and going from there. So these, so basically at every trail junction, you'll find a sign with a, it's bigger than eight and a half by 11, I'm not sure the size, but you know, print out of the map with a you are here sticker.

41:10 Sure. And then on that sign also will be directional arrows with the lettered trails that you're intersecting there. So B to the left, A to the right, et cetera. So yeah, roughly 20 of these kind of junction signs with the maps. And then beyond that, you know, a lot of arrows and reassurance blazes up in the trees. Sure. Yeah, that's great. I just...

41:37 I'd like to make sure that the organization is signed and has Mammoth Trails on it so that people know that this is who's doing it and whatnot. Good point. We did just install all the kiosk maps, which are certainly branded accordingly.

41:59 And those are the big, you know, summer and winter OSV, OHV kiosks you'll find at June Lake Junction, Obsidian Staging Area, Scenic Loop and 395, places like that. So those are all out. And moving forward, yep, hear you loud and clear. We're going to take every opportunity to make sure, you know, people know who's doing the grooming out there. Yep, get credit for it. Thank you. Yep.

42:28 Andrew, I was making reference to the blaze signs and the sort of wayfinding directional that you had out there that I hadn't seen before in those spaces. But, you know, sort of understanding the trail system master plan is very specific signage sort of design and requirements. Is there been nothing designed specifically for these particular treks other than the blaze sort of markers?

42:57 Correct. There's no, you know, the Trail System Master Plan makes suggestions in area, in project areas that haven't been fully fleshed out, and this is one of those areas that hasn't been fully fleshed out. So their suggestion in the Trail System Master Plan would be that, you know, future signage integrates with our current signage system that has just never been fleshed out because the town has never really had a role in generating or...

43:26 Or maintaining these signs out here. So a good opportunity to, yeah, make those sort of look and feel changes so that things look consistent and get those things, you know, locked down in our trail system master plan moving forward. Thank you. Okay, moving on to non-motorized grooming. Similarly, we've gone out there.

44:00 Made sure that the route is clear and groomable with the proper snow levels. We've got staff in place. Lawston's going to be kind of taking the lead on that program. I'll certainly support when I'm available, but I wanted to be, you know, freed up to kind of put my focus on the motorized system. So I think we're well staffed and maybe a good plan there.

44:27 Gretchen got out during the storm and groomed the old Shady Loop, and then a few days later, Rick and I groomed the old Shady Loop as well as Pinecone Cutoff here through the middle of Shady to get out to the OSV network. Still just waiting for more snow out there. You know, every year you get a storm that kind of teases you into going out, and you can fudge the numbers and make it.

44:57 You know, measure somewhere where there's 18 inches of snow and go for it. But really, what I've learned is it pays to really, you know, be conservative and look at it realistically. Like, did we get a heavy base? Do we have an 18-inch base where we're not going to be running into stumps that I know are sticking out out there? Or, you know, do we just have 18 inches in this one spot? So, based on that, we're still...

45:24 You know, needing another foot or two of nice base snow before we can groom safely out there. So waiting, but ready to go. Got a new sled to do that grooming with and seems to be working well. Any questions on that program? I'd just like to add on to a couple more comments to that and really a thank you to Gretchen for going out and grooming.

45:52 During that, it was right after the storm, but right before Thanksgiving holiday, you know, and as the town takes on this responsibility, I can't stress enough the meeting the expectations of our visitors, right, meeting the expectations of the users of those trails, and we do need to be very, very cognizant of, you know, specific parameters allowing us to groom because that protects the machinery, but there needs to be a plan.

46:19 That we are ready to go holiday, non-holiday, whatever it is at a moment's notice so that those trails are ready to go and prepared for our visitors, right? It's kind of a critical thing. And so I know as the town manager, I felt very concerned that, you know, it was snowing pretty good before Thanksgiving. And I think, you know, we had frankly quite a bit of snow out there and, you know, Gretchen responded immediately, went out and just dove into the middle of it to do that.

46:49 I know, you know, we checked the other non, we checked the motorized, it wasn't quite to the limit that it was, but, you know, we're able to go out a week or two later, so that was, you know, interesting, but appreciate that opportunity to get out there on the groomer, but as the town takes this on, the level of scrutiny, in my opinion, elevates, so we need to really be ready for that and have a plan where it's...

47:17 When possible, it is absolutely executed on. So, thank you. Andrew, I have a quick question regarding the Sherwins Winter Trails. Is there any plan or I think I maybe asked at one point if we could see if we could take that out of subpart C and maybe add pilot grooming out there or an expansion. Is there any talk of that or any plans to pursue that?

47:51 There is. Sounds like the Forest Service agrees with you on that one. That subpart C is probably kind of a moving target and far out in that analyzing the expanded grooming proposal that we've brought to them could be something that they could fit on their plate and that that could move forward on a more advanced timeline.

48:18 They have the proposal, and it's just a matter of them slotting it into their program of work and having the time to review it, which Chris, the rec officer, has, you know, been pushing for it on our behalf, and he thinks it could potentially happen over this winter, but, you know, we'll see. Excellent. And just as a follow-up to that,

48:45 I know when I was making comments for Subpart C, my concern was we have a non-motorized area there that we're grooming for, and we'll have a parking lot and restrooms there, so we're bringing more people into that space. Is there any way to make considerations for having...

49:06 A slow zone for motorized or encouraging motorized to maybe head in the other direction. I just saw some snowmobiles out on Snow Creek Golf Course in this last storm. And, you know, I just, I'm concerned when we create this space and it's probably going to be a bigger trailhead area, like how can we maybe be a little bit proactive in trying to minimize any conflict in that area.

49:37 Yeah, I'm not sure how to handle that one. I'm not really versed in how the slow zones were developed, but I assume that it would have to be part of that subpart C. We can certainly, you know, add elements to our signage. I think there might be something on here, kind of pointing users to that sort of etiquette.

50:09 We can certainly make a note of that when we communicate about the expanded grooming with the forest. I think they're just going to be, you know, hesitant to make any changes in that space until subpart C. Okay, thank you. In partial answer to your question, on the forest, there are speed limits for motorized within developed areas. So that would pertain to this once we get the permission to groom the trails.

50:49 The other way you mitigate that, there's an old system called EPA, which is encourage, prohibit, allow. It was brought in by the motorized community in the first place. If you encourage the motorized to use a specific corridor going through that, then 90% of them will stay within that corridor. You have what I call the 3% solution, which is 3% of any group are idiots.

51:14 No matter whether it's motorized or non-motorized, you're never going to get full compliance with everything. But that is the way to mitigate that, and that's the way we've done it in the past. If the Forest Service is willing to call us a developed area, then that automatically puts in what we call a no-wake zone, or a speed limit for motorized going through that area. And I promise you, most of the people don't know the area. So unless they're going to specifically do the av shoot or something like that, you know, proving how big they are. I did it once.

51:43 They're going to follow that trail and it's really only problematic when there's low snow like now or when the Lakes Basin opens in the spring that people are going to really want to use it. Thanks, Bill. So from my understanding of the OSV program that funds this grooming, there's also funding for outreach or

52:22 Regulations. People having people go out and be on a snowmobile and speak to other snowmobilers. And so that might be an idea that could be explored in the future if OSV is, if this OSV grooming works well, something, it could be expanded, that program. The only programs I know like that with the Green Sticker group that work,

52:55 Are the enforcement grants that are given? So I suppose one of the things we could look at is a town. The town already has a green sticker purchased snowmobile. We do have a snowmobile, don't we? Yeah. Would be to get asked in a grant for enforcement dollars since now we've taken over the grooming. It would only make sense that we do enforcement there as well. So you could get enforcement dollars for that ostensibly to go out and do those things.

53:25 The town has, it's a green stricker sled associated with the grooming program that we just took possession of, but also we have our own general fund purchased, I think it was general fund, Lawson can correct me if I'm wrong, purchased sled for that purpose. In terms of outreach and information, the map that, if it's still up there, that he had up on the wall was originally produced.

53:52 In a partnership between the town of Mammoth Lakes and the Off-Highway Vehicle Motorized Off-Highway Vehicle Division, which is the green sticker division. So there are monies available for that sort of stuff. Where it has fallen through the cracks is whose responsibility is to produce it. You know, we did it as a town through tourism back when the tourism was within the town and the green sticker. So where would that lie today? Is it with this group? Is it with Office of Outdoor Recreation?

54:20 And will they still give those grants? But there have always been funds available for that. And I would say as a user of the system, for the most part, I don't really see a lot of negative activity going on out there. We don't spend time on the west side where there's probably more interaction that needs to be regulated. But when I've been over on the west side, the mountain running their operations over there has some degree of control, especially over the speeds on the trails and such.

54:47 That are going on. I have seen law enforcement do registration checks at trailheads and things like that. But I just haven't seen a big issue. Frankly, the biggest concern and issue that I have seen out there is wheeled vehicles driving on the groomed trail system or trying to. And just it's extremely dangerous for everyone who's using it.

55:12 Those are the things, and we've had dialogue with those people as we've seen them out there. Yeah. One of the other things we have to watch out for in this is the huge increase in motorized, but e-fat tire bikes. So we did a program, a pilot program, because technically it would be illegal to run them on these groomed trails, to allow them on the trails. But when the snow is soft,

55:42 Either when it's really cold and it's soft because of that or when it warms up and it becomes slush, the ruts that they can leave on the trail. So it's just something I'm still in favor of them being there now, but it's something that we have to watch for now that the program is ours. What kind of damage is done and what kind of hazard that becomes. Really quick before we get too far away from the map. Yes, that map was produced with grant funding and collaboration and then it was printed.

56:12 MLR wrangled the cats of Forest Service, Town, Mono County, MLT, and Ecia, I think, participated in the first round. So everybody, you know, collectively came together to produce those and they were distributed countywide. And we're about to embark on another ask because we need more. All right. I think you can continue on, Andrew. All right. Thanks, y'all.

56:50 I just wanted to bring up this network, which is a non-groomed, non-motorized Nordic route network that is signed with blue diamonds. They're slightly different than the blue diamonds that are used on the groomed Nordic trails. They're kind of a pale or blue. And these routes have, you know, were established by the Sierra Club. They're signed, and they've just not had

57:23 Anyone managing them in a while. There was a lovely older couple, Mike and Mary Shore, who would go out there and freak me out thinking about them on ladders out in the forest, but they did it and maintained these signs. But they left town five or more years ago and kind of handed the keys over to Joel and, you know, to my knowledge, I don't think any work has been done on...

57:53 Checking on the status of these diamonds or reinstalling them. And so I just wanted to bring this to this group and kind of poll the audience in terms of, you know, do we think folks are still using these? Do we, you know, are we happy with the alignments? Do we want to put some effort into making the signage?

58:18 Really nice and consistent and ensuring that people don't get lost out there, which I think is kind of the critical piece there. Just kind of wanted to open it up. So if, you know, you don't have to answer now, but planting the seed and we'll be looking, you know, this would be summer work. And it's not necessarily straightforward because these routes aren't on top of roads in most instances.

58:46 Requires some, you know, off-road travel with a ladder and some signs and a hammer and aluminum nails. So, if anyone's got anything they want to share right now, that's fine. If not, I can move on. Well, most of the trail that goes from Shady across is on dirt roads. And once snowmobilers go down, it gets quite a bit of non-motorized use. There's only the one section from, that goes across from the,

59:19 Mammoth Crater Road to the craters themselves that grows cross country. Andrew, is there still a Nordic, someone here might be able to tell me, is there still a Nordic group that's active in town? Yeah. That was going to be my question. If there's a system on the forest that's being utilized, then it should be maintained because

59:51 You know, having something out there, some set of infrastructure that's not being maintained will just eventually, similar to my previous comments, come back to the town as being mismanaged. And so I think if there is an existing system that has a user group, then I would say we definitely need to find a way to maintain that and bring it up to the standards that we would hold for everything else that we're doing.

1:00:15 But if it's not, then I would strongly consider removing those items so that they're not out there in the forest. Several of those trails get use a lot of times, not until after somebody has run over them so that they are semi-groomed. But they are what I would call the exploratory trails that aren't specifically groomed.

1:00:44 I mean, let's face it, cross-country skiing didn't come about because there were groomed trails and we wanted to do something. It came about to go over ungroomed snow. And they are some pretty neat trails to some pretty nice places. The current forest management of those are, as long as they aren't groomed, they are just open. The diamonds are just there to lead you to a certain destination. So I don't know that I would eliminate these.

1:01:11 If anyone wants to get bored with the history of how the Loma Prieta Sierra Club managed to come to Mammoth and create those in the first place, I'm happy to give that to them. But they do, especially out in the craters area, maybe we should have our crews or Mono County's crews, because this is all in Mono County as well, let's have them step up to the plate as well, assess the trails and see where they lead and properly

1:01:42 Yeah, I don't disagree with that. I think I am.

1:02:09 Not leaning one direction or another, except for the fact that if they're there and a part of a system, they need to be maintained and managed, and if they're not, then they probably shouldn't be there. So if you're saying there's value to those, then I would like a program with which they're kept at the standards. Again, going back to, and I'm wearing my town manager hat continuously here, but we will be held accountable for the quality of that experience, and if it's there, I want it to be good.

1:02:41 I would say that we should advocate for these trails and perform the maintenance required, but also then make sure that they get on maps and things so that new people can discover these trails and utilize them, and rather than having them being taken away. I think, Andrew, the map that you had up earlier,

1:03:11 Does it still have the blue diamond trails on it? Or Kim, do you know the answer to that? It does. You can see them there. So they are on the winter use map. And Andrew, are the blue diamonds that are out by motocross or kind of Sierra Meadows Ranch across the road from that, are they out on that map as well? And have you looked at... Those are a mystery. They're not on this map here.

1:03:41 Which is kind of the only piece of collateral that I found supporting the Sierra Club effort. They came after, the map was produced long after Sierra Club had given up on those trails. The Blue Diamonds out by Sierra Meadows were put up by the Rosiers when they were trying to have a profitable cross-country ski center out there. So they were specific to the business. The Forest Service required them to be marked that way.

1:04:11 Because that's how cross-country trails were marked. Okay, so if we're considering preserving this, should we look at those as well? Especially since we have a new trailhead. As long as Lou kept those groomed, they were closed to motorized. I'll just note, you know, just a quick Google search of Mammoth Nordic clubs. I kind of found this Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association. Maybe they would be a group we could do outreach to to see if...

1:04:50 There is interest in some sort of sponsorship or working along with. You know, there is a huge need for the Snowmobile Association to be re-energized, and people have been pushing me in that direction for years, and I've been keeping my feet stuck in the sand. But there's also a huge need for the schism that was caused between the two groups by the people that took over the Nordic group years ago.

1:05:26 To go away and have those two groups work together to create a system that works for everybody. I mean, that's what we're here for, is to create recreation, not to inhibit any form of recreation. So maybe if people keep pushing me, I'll try to get our money back from the state and put some money into MLR to see if they could help get that effort going again. So something that Kim and I can certainly talk about.

1:05:52 And now I've opened that back up and Rob will start beating me over the head with a stick again. I think that's great feedback, Bill. The other day I got a message from an individual who was wondering when I was going to get out to groom cross-country ski routes out near Obsidian and concerned that they'd gotten messed up by snowmobilers. And, you know, I was having a hard time figuring out a really good way to relay the information.

1:06:23 Essentially, the truth on the ground is that nobody groomed that stuff yet. Like, the only reason there was anything to ski on was because snowmobilers had been out there using that marked system. So, you know, the more information that we can share between groups that, you know, were all after the same thing, I think would really go a long way. And the two groups used to work very closely together. It took someone coming in to break that apart, to get that alliance going. All right, well, it sounds like...

1:07:05 I'm hearing a consensus to bring this signage up to snuff on these trails that are established and on maps and then to do a little bit of research into some other routes that may be signed and maybe come back to this group with a decision of should we re-sign those routes and add them to maps or should we just pull those signs down so they're not confusing people. Does that sound about right?

1:07:38 Yeah, we have to remember to be careful how we pay for that rehab. If we use general fund dollars, that's okay, but for measure of our dollars, I don't think we're allowed to use it if we don't manage the system ourselves. So, we took over the snowmobile system. Well, it's a handshake deal, but Mike and Mary did, I witnessed the handoff of the box of blue diamonds to Joel Rathje. Yeah. So, I think it's a...

1:08:06 It's a Mammoth Lakes Trail System product, whether we like it or not. Alright, moving on. Sharp Trailhead. Paving is complete. Bathroom is installed. It looks awesome out there. Impressive watching that get put together in really just a handful of days. I think we are waiting on...

1:08:40 Sort of a final sign-off from Public Works, because they're managing the contractors out there on, you know, are the bathrooms safely accessible? Once we get that sign-off, then we'll come up with some sort of bathroom cleaning schedule. I know there's a handful of Forest Service employees who have some volunteer hours to fulfill, and so that might be a really good way of locking down some folks that can get in there and clean those things. We have other resources we can

1:09:10 Put towards that, but currently the bathrooms are locked, but stand by, they should be accessible here before too long. Signage, I don't believe is going to be installed at this point of the winter season, so we'll look to early spring to give you more updates on signage installation out there. Andrew, on the cleaning thing and need for employees thing,

1:09:37 I know some people who used to be very, very successful at going to the courts and getting the names of people that needed to do public service to help with this kind of stuff. And that can be a great program once you get your foot in the door. It has been used in the past for that sort of thing. Just something to bear in mind. Okay. Yeah, and I'll just jump in real quick. I've had conversations with Parks and Rec as well, who does maintenance of a lot of...

1:10:07 Parks facilities, other recreation facilities during the winter months, and they are able to assist with the cleaning in that location as well. So I think we do have a good plan moving forward. Any other questions on the trailhead? Nope. Sorry. Sharp update. Hot off the press. We had a meeting this morning, and it went really well. It was an interdisciplinary team meeting.

1:10:44 With all the players in the room, so we had Fred, the ranger, Courtney Grell, the NEPA planner, Chris Bewer, the rec officer, and then all the resource specialists. And it was really just kind of, you know, heartwarming or, I don't know, inspiring to see how much effort and sort of knowledge of the project that a lot of the resource specialists had, you know, and they spent a lot of time out there, you know, they were directed.

1:11:16 At the beginning of the season that this was a priority project and on their program of work and they, you know, came through on their end and did the work, got out there on the ground, looked at all the alignments, came back with their feedback. Really the thing that has been making the process extra slow is the third-party contractor doing the archaeological work, but that's finally put to bed. So now we were able to kind of get back and get back on track.

1:11:45 And we have that report finalized. And so the archaeological team was able to, you know, kind of have final answers on their resource and how it interacts with the proposed trail network. So we were able to make some good progress. We went through line by line and gave every, you know, people from each resource specialty an opportunity to comment on that trail alignment.

1:12:12 And whether or not it was good in its current location, if it needed to be moved, if moving it was feasible based on all the other resource interactions. So it was a really useful exercise and I think we got to, we got pretty close to a proposed action I think that we could all be happy with. There's a tricky area out by Hidden Lake that I think is going to require a field visit. There's some whitebark pine species.

1:12:39 Along the trail that's going to require some consultation up in the Panorama Dome area, but all in all, there was no showstoppers or really in general, it was just a how can we get this project implemented as quickly as possible and I think just general goodwill on both sides, a lot of trust in mutual respect in the room, which I found

1:13:09 Really nice. So anyways, moving forward, I'm going to sit down with the NEPA planner and Chris, the rec officer, and optimistically, we're going to get one more interdisciplinary team huddle before January, and then at that point, you know, have a finalized proposed action sometime mid-January, which would keep us on a timeline where we could expect approved

1:13:40 A decision memo, you know, in May, I believe. So, still hopeful for some construction out there in the spring and summer. All in all, you know, I think it took a while to get there, but I think we got a great working relationship and got a lot of faith in the players in the room and their, you know, commitment to getting this project across the finish line. So, that was great.

1:14:13 The finalized proposed action, you know, I think it's going to take a little bit of negotiation on a handful of alignments, but long story short, I think we'll phase it into two phases. So one phase will be the majority of the project area, and another phase will be anything that interacts with whitebark pine. And that's just because that's going to require like a six to nine month consultation, which we don't want to hold everything else up with.

1:14:41 I think there was consensus that that was the right way to move forward. And then as it comes to other resources, there's not a lot. Hydrology, you know, they've been with us kind of each step of the way, so we've built in their comments to the trail alignments as we go. So we'll continue to do that to address any remaining concerns Hydro has.

1:15:06 But then in terms of botany biology, really not a lot of concerns, which is nice. And then archaeology, we are going to have to do shovel testing in sites that we're just unable to avoid. So I think I've shared with you all before, but did some work based on the archaeological site records that we received to come up with.

1:15:33 Reroutes and realignments to avoid those wherever we could, and that work was well received by the forest, and then we just identified a handful of areas where, you know, this line in particular, kind of, just east of Sherwin Meadow, it's a really good user trail alignment, and it goes smack through the middle of the site, and so, you know.

1:15:59 When I got that site data and did some work to come up with alternate lines, the only real alternate is out here in the meadow, and it's just awful for a variety of reasons. So bringing that back to the group, you know, we all agreed, yep, like there really is no other good option here, so let's proceed with shovel testing and whatever necessary mitigations go along with, you know, keeping that trail intersecting a known site.

1:16:28 So optimistic that we'll be able to figure that process out and build some trails here. Any questions on Sharp? No question, just a comment. Glad to hear a positive report. Yeah, me too. I was very happy with the meeting this morning, so kudos to everybody on the forest side for keeping that thing moving.

1:17:04 Just wanted to give you a little bit of a summer preview. I know last time we talked, there were some questions around, you know, how do we prioritize work and what's our work plan look like? And I just kind of wanted to give an overview and then talk about, you know, some kind of areas of priority that we're looking at. So overview, got over 40 miles of trail that we're maintaining, 18 miles of multi-use path.

1:17:30 And while we're not responsible for the asphalt on that path, we are responsible for hazard tree removal along those paths, ballard removal and installation in the spring and fall, and all the signs along those paths. And there's 917 signs across our network. So that's just kind of, you know, our available palette of projects.

1:17:59 This is just an illustration of that railing maintenance this fall. Tree fell, broke the railing. We were able to get it out of there and fix the railing. But anyways, kind of looking at our system, I think it's sort of divided into two groupings in terms of the soft surface trails, right? So everything in green here is our non-motorized, multi-use, you know, open to bikes.

1:18:31 Open to equestrians, open to hikers and runners. And we've taken really good care of these trails over the last 10 years, right? Just a lot of maintenance hours, a lot of volunteer hours. Some of them are newly constructed. They are newly constructed with sustainable trail design features built in, so they require less maintenance. So there's a lot of things that make those trails kind of, you know, they're

1:18:59 They're well-loved and used a lot, and we certainly don't want to forget about them, but moving into this summer season, I think I can safely say I don't have any glaring projects on any of these green trails, so Mountain View, Uptown, Downtown, everything in the Shore and Meadows, Horseshoe Lake Loop, and some of the newer connector trails up there in the basin. They're in great shape, and I...

1:19:24 I'm confident they're going to be in great shape going into this next season. We'll certainly fix anything that comes up. But that leaves this remaining about half of the trail mileage that we're responsible for of trails that are, I think in all instances, the distinction would be that they're not open to bikes and that they typically lead into wilderness areas. And we're basically responsible for the portions of them that are within the municipal boundary.

1:19:52 So, you know, kind of that first couple miles of these trails coming out of the lakes basin. And we've done work on these things over the years. Certainly, plenty of work on the Crystal Lake Trail, the bottom part of the Duck Pass Trail. Last year, we hit Coldwater George. And, you know, I would say these trails are difficult because their heritage or their...

1:20:21 Legacy alignments, right? They're old hiking trails that are A to B, not necessarily using modern sustainable trail design principles. So they've got recurring erosion issues, outdated erosion prevention measures that require more maintenance. And, you know, oftentimes a lot of pack use, which can really just put a different level of use on that trail. So for that.

1:20:51 Sort of list of reasons. They're a good candidate for some kind of serious work. And so my plan for this year is to take some of that data that Tanner just shared with you on, you know, trail popularity, basically, and start prioritizing these segments in terms of, you know, how egregious is the damage? How long has it been since some of these major maintenance issues have been addressed? And then how popular is that trail? And then

1:21:21 Coming up with a prioritized list of addressing these things as we go through the season. It's easy to kind of look at these trails and look at them through maybe a bike rider's lens and say, oh, I want this to turn to be nice and smooth and maybe free of obstacles.

1:21:41 And then it's easy to kind of get on these trails and say, oh, you know, this is just the way hiking trails are. They're more rugged and there's big rocks sticking out. Well, that's not actually the case. You know, when these trails were built, they were a nice smooth tread. And then over the years, tons of material has eroded, leaving rocks sticking out of them all over the place. And that's just kind of what we've come to know. And, you know, I think it's...

1:22:11 Important to bring them to a much more usable and pleasant specification. And so that's our goal moving forward. Moving on a little bit. Andrew, can I ask you a couple of questions on that? Yep. One, a statement, not a question. I would love to see sometime in the spring if we could get one of the writers, not do it ourselves because we aren't paid attention to, from our local papers.

1:22:41 Write a piece on exactly what you're showing us, that the town is maintaining 43 miles of soft-surface trails. This is, if we put it out as a press release from the town, it is viewed with skepticism and, you know, but if we could get one of the riders, if we could partner with them, it's something we should do better than we do all over our scope, is to partner with the press and see if we can get some positive press, that would be great. The other is, a lot of these trails that the Forest Service,

1:23:11 Calls Forest Service Trails were created by the pack stations in the area originally and maintained right through the 70s and early 80s by the pack stations themselves. Have we tried to reach out and make a partnership with any of the pack stations to see if they would be willing to get involved with the maintenance on some of these trails? They are creating some of the issues, and I realize with the rules that they're currently under, they aren't making the profits that they used to make either, but still.

1:23:39 It seems to me that would be a natural partnership for us to go to them and ask if they would be willing to provide some labor, to provide some money, to provide whatever, to help with the trails that are impacted by their business. You got the great idea, Bill. When we get ready, I'll give you a call and maybe we can go up there together and talk to them. That's fine. All right.

1:24:06 So that brings up, you know, moving forward, this is this kind of expanded network that the Forest Service has kind of come to us saying, hey, you know, moving into next season, we might not have seasonals and we might have a hard time just doing basic logout on these wilderness trails. The reason I jump here so quickly after your comment, Bill, is Michael Morse, who's, you know, in charge of the PAC program over at the Forest, brought up the fact that the Backcountry Horsemen Association,

1:24:36 Does do maintenance on a lot of these more wilderness trails. So I'd be curious, you know, what was their relationship in the past and were the local outfits doing trail maintenance on stuff kind of in the lakes basin and how did they interact with the backcountry horsemen? But I'd love to sort of reignite that conversation because I think now's the time where the forest is, you know, experiencing.

1:25:01 Budget shortfalls and unable to hire the necessary staff to take care of these things. Who's going to step up? We're certainly going to be a player in that conversation, but I think bringing as many people into that conversation now will be advantageous in terms of getting these things open to the public. So these trails in yellow are just kind of outside of our current purview. They're beyond the wilderness boundary.

1:25:31 Beyond the municipal boundary. And Michael Morris, you know, in a recent meeting was, yeah, basically requesting help. So last season we did help out on some Mammoth Pass trail clearing work. So it'd be pretty similar to what we've been doing where, you know, if we have available resources and our crew can...

1:25:58 Handle splitting off half the crew to go help for the day doing some logout on a wilderness trail. We'll jump in and do it. But I think kind of moving forward, we're looking to, all right, you know, we're hesitant to take on this work in an official way because it's got to get funded somehow, right? I mean, it's outside of the municipal boundary. So really just planting the seed in terms of, you know.

1:26:25 Moving forward, if the Forest Service is continuing to experience budget shortfalls, not have seasonal employees, not have a trail crew, their ask is, at the least, can we help out with spring logout of these trails to get them open and usable, which I think is reasonable. We just have to figure out how are we going to pay for it, how are we going to staff appropriately, etc.

1:26:51 Just some conversations that we've been having and I wanted to share with this group. I think it makes a lot of sense for our crew to help out, you know, in some of these. The ask currently is pretty minimal. It's just asking for some help with these trails that connect from the lakes basin down to Reds. So Stark Weather and Mammoth Pass Trail and some of the cutoffs over here. But I would anticipate, you know, I don't know what's going to happen, but if no one...

1:27:21 steps up and volunteers to log out McGee Pass or trails out a convict, you know, who is going to do that work and is it appropriate for us to, you know, look at how we could be helping in those situations? Andrew, how do you see your priority or what is your priority when it comes to SHARP versus what you've just suggested here?

1:27:52 As far as time and manpower goes this coming summer. Implementing SHARP, I don't think we'll be there with a signed decision memo by the time these trails are melting out, so I don't see it having a negative impact on SHARP implementation this season. But moving into next season, say we get SHARP trails approved late next summer, and then we still have a lot to build going into the following season, I think you bring up a great point.

1:28:22 Any crew time spent on these is holding us up from building out our approved trails. So that's why I kind of bring it to you guys. You know, I don't think, I think so far it's been like, oh, you know, can we spend a half day helping out with some cross-cut work up here? Sure. But if it's going to be a year after year ask in a big trail network, you know, how do we sustainably fund and staff that?

1:28:52 It's kind of the underlying question. Yeah, it just has to do with the funding and staffing. It would be nice if we took everything over, but, you know, I don't know if we can, but, you know, look at the grooming program, you know, that was something that wouldn't have happened, and now it is. So, just got to source the funding. Yeah, I guess I would just like,

1:29:30 To, you know, at least have our, like the town's consideration in, you know, where we're helping out and maybe not just run when they say run, hear when they say hear. You know, I think we look at some of the jewels that really the town is known for, the Lakes Basin, Duck Pass, that's kind of a spot, you know, everybody's coming to town and loving to go to along with Red's Meadows.

1:29:59 I would just like to maybe try to stand a little strong on what we're responding to and with some thought on how it is beneficial for the town and whatnot. I'm not saying anything is lesser or greater, but there are spots that I think we're known for. So we recently had some strategic planning off-site meetings with staff, and one of the areas we talked about was the degree in which the town leans into the spaces like this that are not our regular.

1:30:31 core services, but essentially, as you may or may not know, the town is often called upon to pick up the pieces when things fall on the ground, right? And it goes back to my original comments of that. And I think what we came away from in that discussion is really establishing good boundaries on when we do, as well as the expectations for what we will do and at what time they are passed back, right? So they don't become...

1:30:57 A consistent expectation of us because we don't have unlimited resources or capacity. So I think there's going to be some approach in that. My concern is that conversations I've had with the Forest Service with no options available to them, they will talk about specifically closing things that they cannot manage or maintain. So as a visitor experience base, it's a very delicate balance that we need to manage.

1:31:26 I think somewhere in there is a good program where we can step in on an efficiency basis, meaning if there's a half day of work, we can get something open without buffing it out to perfection. But we've got a lot of work to do in that space about what partnership means between organizations and really how we interact. I think that's good work in that area needs to be done.

1:31:57 Well, that's great to hear that. That's happening. Thanks. He's napping between comments. Okay, Andrew, you there? And maybe his report's over. I'm here. Sorry. Okay, moving along. Just wanted to share, in our last meeting, we were talking about, you know, future trail planning efforts. And I wanted to kind of bring this one back to the group.

1:32:53 I don't, you know, I don't have a clear path forward for this one, but maybe with our minds together, we can come up with something. But many of you are probably very aware of this project. Rick, Shady Rest in Your Creators. It was...

1:33:12 Kicked off in 2020, I'll just read this, in an effort to engage with OHV users and opportunities in the Shady Rest, Inyo Craters sub-region, Town of Mammoth Lakes applied for and was awarded a three-year planning grant from the California State Parks OHV program in 2020. The Town of Mammoth Lakes partnership with the Inyo National Forest, Mammoth Ranger District, Mammoth County is using the California OHV planning grant funds for on-the-ground planning, environmental review.

1:33:40 In order to optimize existing OHV facilities that serve a wide spectrum of user groups to consider enhanced opportunities for trails and sustainable recreation in the Shady Rest Inyo Crater sub-region. So that was, you know, 2020 at the time Gordon Martin was acting or was District Ranger and he supported that project. We got planning funds from the state OHV fund. We started doing some of that planning.

1:34:10 Initially, we met with local user groups, got a kind of a handle on some of their concerns and desired connectivity. And if you look at this map here in yellow are existing Forest Service legal single track motorized trails. There's, I think it's about 11 miles. They're spread out in between here and June, very disparate.

1:34:36 And what we were hearing from the motorized community was we'd like those things to connect and make some sort of usable network. And we'd also like to be able to get up to San Joaquin Ridge on single track if possible. And we'd also like to be able to get from Mammoth to June on single track. Their basic major voice concern around connectivity was, well, we end up having to use these double track roads, which...

1:35:03 A lot of times, you know, the Mammoth to June route, which is a double track that's signed, gets a lot of side-by-side traffic and, you know, we're worried about head-on collisions with a side-by-side going around turns and stuff. So safety concerns and just, you know, desirable experience out there, which I think are pretty reasonable. So we took that, you know, as kind of our...

1:35:29 Guiding information and developed these routes. So in yellow is existing and dash brown is something that we worked on on the ground to design and layout to connect these features. Put a fair amount of work on the ground into this. And then there was a change in leadership at the forest. The acting district ranger at the time, Leanne Murphy, you know, was reviewing our

1:36:00 Projects in their program of work for the following season, and they kind of nudged us to send the rest of the money back to the state, stop working on this project, and I thought this was interesting. In their letter, you know, this person's no longer on the forest, I don't believe, but their letter, they, you know, they said, you know, we're, we know you guys have put a lot of work into this project, and the forest did sign a letter of support for it, but at this time,

1:36:30 We think there's other areas of concern, which, okay, but then at the end here, they said, I'd like to encourage Town of Mammoth Lakes to work with Fred Wrong as he arrives to understand the areas of need. With the amount of mountain bike use in this area, would there be interest in working together on a plan for a mountain bike park or use area? So that's a suggestion from the forest.

1:36:59 Just wanted to bring that up, which I thought was interesting. So then Fred got here. We, you know, we told him about SRIC and how it had been put on pause, and he kind of confirmed, yep, we don't have the time and resources to engage in that planning effort. And so we haven't moved forward. But we developed kind of a smaller footprint.

1:37:30 Recreation Study Area behind Shady Rest Park that we think might be something to kind of get going again with recreation planning in the space. So if you're familiar with this area, in red is the ORMAT pipeline, and then you've got this hillside behind that that's currently got a, you know, user-built bike jumps in.

1:37:55 Variety of trails on it. These black lines are, you know, just a conceptual look at what a non-motorized trail network could look like out there. So, you know, we've been kind of trying to get this on the radar of the forest and potentially on the program of work. And I think what we've heard, you know, repeatedly is let's get sharp across the finish line and then start looking at it.

1:38:23 The next project. So this is one potential next project. I think the greater SRIC is a very viable project. And, you know, given the current state of affairs of the forest with no OHV manager, I think it's going to be tricky to pull that one off. But when there was an OHV manager this past year, Patrick Parcell, he was really excited about that, you know, that we'd done that work and that analysis.

1:38:48 This already existed, and he's really excited to bring that work that we've done in to the upcoming travel management, which I think the forest is eager to do, or at least was with him in that position in that area. And so there's a lot of opportunity for road to trail conversions and just, you know, making sense of that kind of spaghetti bowl of roads in a way that's going to be beneficial to all different users out there in the forest.

1:39:17 That is it. I just wanted to share a little bit of background on SRIC. If you want to find out more information on SRIC, go to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation webpage, and on their projects tab is a full library of information on the planning work that was done, which is a good place to start, I think. Any questions for me before I conclude my report?

1:39:45 I have a quick question. Did I understand you correctly? Did you say that this map that you have up here is for non-motorized? Correct. So this one is, you know, the larger A to B connections would be motorized, motorized and non-motorized, single track, you know, open to e-bikes, dirt bikes, etc. This little kind of high-density network right behind Shady Rest is something that Joel and I,

1:40:15 Developed during this RIC effort, not using the OHV planning dollars, but just kind of, you know, these are just conceptual lines which follow reasonable grades using GIS. We didn't get out there and flag it or use a clinometer or anything, but kind of just a, you know, this is what a stacked loop system could look like in that area. It seems like a good pick because there's a lot of existing use on that hillside already. I think

1:40:45 The motorized connections, you know, this is a good fit for non-moto because it's really close to the park and easily expectable. I think the non-moto stuff, if you're on a moto, it's pretty easy to get out and away from Shady. So really, in there, if you look at this map, there is a nice kind of high-density pot of trails out here behind Earthquake Dome for motos. So I think the real desire from the motorized community was

1:41:16 Connections, like, because currently, you know, a handful of years ago, they built this Lookout Mountain Trail, which is great, but it doesn't connect to anything. And even the trailhead for it is in a super random location that would be hard to find, especially if you're a visitor. So I think the idea of this project was, you know, A, let's build some more trails so we have a reasonable network for people to use, and B, let's make it a little more user-friendly so that you can actually find the stuff that exists and connect to it from, you know,

1:41:47 A parking lot with a bathroom, basically. Okay, so you're just basically showing us two different options that could be the next thing we work toward with the Forest Service? Yeah, I think, you know, I mean, I'm just sort of serving up a little bit of information for discussion. I don't...

1:42:15 I don't have a strong leaning in terms of what our next project should be. I think we should get the forest to sit down at the table with us and help make that decision, and then they'll be a little more bought into it. But this is something that we put a lot of work into, and I'd hate to see it go to waste. And I think the needs of this motorized community are very valid. And I think based on this memo from Leanne Murphy telling us to stop that work and focus on a mountain bike park, it just...

1:42:43 You know, reminding me of this other work that we've done in the area. So, you know, I think we come to the forest with all these different things and try and have them help inform us of what project is going to be successful, you know. Thank you. Andrew, I don't want to take up too much time here, but in your meetings with the Forest Service, so you're talking about the Lookout Mountain system and there's also some single track up in the...

1:43:13 Oh, what do they call it? In Crater Sand Flat, where we created some single track years ago, two gentlemen from the Forest Service had put together a potential single track map, mostly on the east side of 395, but some on the west. Have they ever shared any of those old planning processes with you? Have you asked for them? Because this isn't something new again. Rick Laborde mentioned them, but there's just such a discontinuity of...

1:43:39 Staff over there, you know, that it's easy for these things to get lost. They have a filing system. They don't really get lost unless it's on purpose. Sorry. Sure. Well, so they haven't been active in this process, you know. This was a very much, we'll sign a letter that says you can take state dollars and do some planning out here, but they didn't have a staff person that was actively engaged.

1:44:06 In this planning effort at all. And so that's why I was really excited when Patrick was in that OHV manager position that, you know, that we could bring this thing back to life and we were on track to do that, but then he took another job. And it's my understanding that they're not going to refill that position. And it's also my understanding that there's really no will to pursue any OHV related projects among existing Forest Service staff.

1:44:37 Which I don't think is a good reason to not, you know, it's just a roadblock that we need to be aware of. Yeah, I would just be interested in seeing some of those old maps. Yeah, I would do. I think I'd throw all of my copies away, but I would look. Andrew, well, I hope you can keep Shrik alive, you know, both the larger version and the smaller, because sometimes even if we can get a little bit of each,

1:45:08 It would be a huge win for everyone here. Totally. And, I mean, this, you know, this isn't a big ask, really. It's just some basic connectivity. And in a forest where there's not a lot of resource concerns, you know, there's, on this map in the pink, you can see the sage-grouse potential habitat. And then this blue line is the wild and scenic upper Owens. Those are really the only kind of...

1:45:39 High-level resource concerns out there and we're avoiding them. You know, the Sherwin Meadows area was popular with humans going back to prehistory. This area, I think less so. So I think it's pretty reasonable to ask for a few miles of trails, making just some basic connections out there. Okay, well, thanks for the report. Anyone else have any questions or comments? All right.

1:46:17 I guess we're going to move on. Outdoor Rec Manager Report, you're up. All right, bear with me here one second. Can everybody see that? Yep. Okay. Like Andrew, I apologize as well for not being able to be there in person. Bear with me through this as well, through, you know, maybe some coughs and things of that nature.

1:46:59 Thank you, Andrew, for the great report prior. I just have a few additional updates, including, first and foremost, a budget update. And where you stand with the measure of our budget currently, out of our $300,000 allocation, we're pretty much right on track at the halfway point of the season, with about 49% of our available budget remaining. Some highlights.

1:47:29 Based on what you maybe saw from some previous winners, you might be thinking that signage number is a little bit low. Andrew did do a sign order for roughly almost $46,000, but that is able to be reimbursable through FEMA as we understand it. So you wouldn't see that in that particular line item. There are still a few signage items contained in here, but probably not as high.

1:47:57 As you may anticipate. You may also see there is a decent amount out of the total for website operations as well as the photo library.

1:48:08 We've gone through and done some website audits recently. There's been a lot of back-end work being done on the website as well to bring it up to a bit more of a modern standard as it relates to spam issues, although we did just have a spam attack recently as well that sent in hundreds of emails basically to the system there. But a little bit more web work than originally anticipated. We're still kind of under our estimated allocation.

1:48:37 And also just kind of working to continue to bring that website into the future along with a website audit where we had our contractor, MLTPA, go through the website, the various webpages, where was maybe some information outdated, where maybe did we need to update information, just because that process had not been done in a while.

1:49:04 Other than that, you know, winter grooming will be booted here shortly. We haven't really spent too much in that realm as of yet. We do have, you know, the two folks that will be helping out with our non-motorized grooming, but I do want to be clear that any of the grooming...

1:49:22 Any of the grooming that will be funded through the state will be coming out of general fund. And then we will be seeking reimbursement from the state back to the general fund. So Measure R will not be used for that. As you all know, much of that program is outside of the town boundary. And we did commit to town council that for this year at the very least, that we would commit general fund dollars to that endeavor.

1:49:50 Continuing on as well, trail and trail maintenance. You can see a good amount spent in that category as well. That covers a lot of the work that Andrew did this summer with the trail crew, and we did have the trail crew, four trail crew members on for quite a long period of time this year, simply because it wasn't as big of a winter as previous seasons, and they were obviously, as you know from our previous reports, able to get a lot of work done on the ground. But all in all,

1:50:19 I think we're in really good shape from a budget perspective, you know, roughly at the halfway point, 49% of our funding remaining in Measure R. And then as you go down to the bottom, oh, sorry.

1:50:34 As you go down to the bottom ones here, a lot of this was highlighted in Kim's presentation as well, sort of where we stand with Sharp Trailhead. Obviously, a large amount of those dollars will come out of there as soon as we're billed for a lot of the work that has already occurred in that area, along with the funding available in Eastern Sierra Adopt-A-Trail. So before I move on, pardon me, any questions related to budget? All right. No questions.

1:51:08 All right. This one is a follow-up item from a previous meeting where we discussed Mammoth Creek parcel and potential future development of that area. And it seemed to be that the committee wanted us to kind of pull the community.

1:51:23 A little bit more on what they wanted to see in that area. Did they want to see, you know, maybe some biking infrastructure in there, or maybe did they just want that to be for more quiet recreation? And we figured it might be a good idea to develop a social media survey, as well as potentially an online survey, and just wanted to engage you all in what you thought about that. MLR kind of has some good infrastructure in place already to

1:51:50 Put together a good survey where we could get a QR code, put that in prominent locations, you know, either through our socials such as Instagram, you know, they have polling measures and things like that. And we felt it might be nice to put together a survey and maybe for a couple months just try to engage the community on this topic and what they wanted to see there and just wanted to engage the committee.

1:52:14 See if you all thought that was a good idea and wanted us to move forward with something like that. But again, this is just a follow-up item from discussions that we had at the last meeting. But I wanted to get kind of the pulse of the committee on that. Do you think maybe putting something together like this would be a good idea? Maybe have some more info moving forward? So just wanted to pick your brains on that. Lawson, I think that's a great plan.

1:52:44 Really figure out what's needed there and what the community wants rather than what we think the community wants. Would you potentially want to see that survey maybe at the next meeting? Like, hey, this is what we're proposing of putting out there to the community? Or would you all be content with us kind of putting something together, kind of highlighting the quiet recreation angle and maybe the little bit more developed angle? What might you all might want to see there?

1:53:14 Yeah, well, if it's going to slow up the survey, then I guess no, but it would be nice to see it. Okay. And we can maybe put something together as well and maybe try to get it out to a group via email. I'm not sure the policies on that. I would need to look into that. But maybe that's a potential option as well. Either or. I think, you know, we're still all in favor with the idea of putting it out to everyone.

1:53:47 And if I see it while I'm filling it out, that's fine too. Right. And last night, I don't know if it's possible or if the expense is too much, but it does seem if you can target the homeowners in that particular area, they're probably the real primary users. I don't know if they can get something in their P.O. box or whatever that might be. They might appreciate that because, as we all know, as much as we put it everywhere, people miss it and then they're pissed off. I'll look into that.

1:54:19 Austin, I love the idea of the survey. I don't think we should preface it by putting out any specific type of plan because that leads people, and I'd like to see what they're thinking without me leading them in any particular direction. With that said, though, we still have to do what's achievable rather than... You always have to have sideboards, which don't happen in a lot of surveys, but yeah. I think especially the QR code would be...

1:54:49 Pretty easy to post it in that area. I know that that's a heavily used dog area in the winter at least and sledding and all that other stuff. So that would encourage the people who live in that area to participate in the survey. Yeah, I think people have said it so thus far as it's difficult when you do a survey not to construct it in such a way that sort of leads to an outcome you're seeking.

1:55:19 And I think in this particular case, since there's a wide variety of opportunity in that space, we have to be very delicate with our hand in that, because we definitely want input from the community there, and I think it's going to be a pretty interesting bit of feedback, because when I look at that space, I see a great deal of both sides of that, the opportunities that can be there for.

1:55:46 You know, quiet in the opportunity. They can be there for just some sort of a pass-through amenity that could exist out there sort of low level and still be quite fun. So it's tough though. I mean, I'm glad to hear people want to get input from the folks that are around there because they're likely the highest level of user as well as the ones that will have to endure whatever use is going on in that space. But yeah, just let's make sure that it's very neutral.

1:56:15 Yeah, really good comments there, and I would like to think that we can develop something that will really thread that needle, but all very good feedback and good stuff for us to think about as we develop this. And I just want to add with timing and development, it seems that people are thinking about the activities that are currently going on. So if we're doing a summer survey, there's not a big rush, I think, to get it out.

1:56:43 Be real thoughtful with the development of it, but if you want winter activities, you know, now is the time to ask people about winter stuff, because it's on their mind, they're thinking about it. You know, we've had these discussions at MLR, you know, community recreation needs, and you want to ask people about winter during winter, because it's front and center, and we're thinking about it, and summer activities come closer to spring and throughout the summertime.

1:57:10 So kind of be a year ahead of itself. Thank you, Kim. Good points. Any other comments related to Mammoth Creek area? All right. Continuing on, I just wanted to have a preliminary conversation with you all regarding Mammoth Lakes Trail System signage, conversations on what it might look like to potentially change certain aspects of...

1:57:45 Trail System signage, as you know, there are hundreds of signs out there on the landscape. And obviously, we are trying to be as systematic as possible as we move towards replacement of these signs. Obviously, a couple of winters ago was a huge trigger point for us with just destruction out there on the landscape. And that triggered a lot of...

1:58:07 Replacement of signs, things of that nature. And as we have vetted these replacements of the signs within the Office of Outdoor Recreation, just some things have come up related to some of these signs and how maybe we could improve them moving into the future. But I wanted to have a discussion with you all on process as it relates to that. And on the next sign, I did provide a few examples of kind of what I'm thinking. So for instance,

1:58:37 Here on this map for a type 2 sign, you will see here on the top left, share your Mammoth Lakes Trails experience, right? And I think that is a good message, but I think as a lot of social media and things have moved forward, that maybe that message is being lost a little bit to, from more of a, hey, be kind to your fellow trail users, yield to the appropriate individuals to the trail, and could be interpreted as, post your experience on social media.

1:59:05 Right? So maybe there's a better way to say that on our signage. Another example might be these type two signs that we have right here in the middle. You know, we feature, for instance, three icons on these signs, but we all know that there are many more activities that could occur in that area. Is it something we want to look into in the future about adding more icons to these signs? And again, just comparing here on the left-hand side where it's talking about pathways and trails.

1:59:35 These say soft surface trail with moderate to strenuous terrain. Again, is that useful for the visitor or even a local who might be using the trail or is it more useful to say a 1.5 mile soft surface trail and maybe not focus as much on maybe how arbitrarily strenuous it is or the diamond level of a particular trail.

2:00:04 Just some thoughts, and I really just wanted to plant the seed with you all. I know we have very kind of stringent design standards for these signs. I think that's a great thing that keeps everything consistent. But if we did want to pursue some changes to these signage, like maybe, you know, all our trails are for all, you know, ensure, you know, good stewardship of your local trails or some other type of messaging on here.

2:00:32 Would you all want to engage in that process? Would we want to seek approval with you all for that process? And again, I'm not proposing any changes right now, just a topic of conversation that has kind of come up as we have vetted numerous signs as a result of the destruction. From a couple of winners ago, these items have come up. So I did want to engage the committee on that and just kind of...

2:00:59 Take the pulse of the committee on how engaged you all might want to be in that process. Would you formally want to approve any changes to these sides? So I will throw it to you all for maybe any comments you have in that arena. Yeah, I think it'd be nice to be included for sure. I can go ahead. I agree. I'd like to see the changes. I don't know that I have to be involved in making those decisions. So, you know, as we dive into

2:01:34 You know, looking at our trail system, trail system master plan, all of the detail, all of the structure, I look at this trail system as an asset. The signage system, as I think Blossin alluded to, is extremely detailed, not only in how it's designed, the design elements, the components.

2:02:00 And those were put together across a multitude of areas, first and foremost, building this system, but secondarily, tying into the town's design standards as required as well. So my only caution would be, while we do need to update things as they come along, a great deal of consideration of a transition from one to another needs to be considered. We do not want to

2:02:27 Turn a corner and go a different direction. We want to evolve. And I think, Coloss, that may be what you're suggesting. And it would be a pretty broad approach, I think, if we want to do that. So it's not a matter of, you know, hey, we think we'd like to make these a little bit different because that has a huge ramifications of the number of trail signs that are existing, the cost of replacement, all of those types of things. So I think I would...

2:02:56 First and foremost, say yes, a lot of people will be involved in any changes. And second to that, consideration for the cost so that it looks like a comprehensive and complete system would be considered. So, you know, you weigh sort of the value of what needs to be changed against the impacts of that broad of a system change. So hopefully that makes sense. Yeah, it does. You know, I agree with you in the sense too that

2:03:23 You know, you don't want it to appear that you're doing one-offs on the system. You know, that would certainly not be the goal of this moving forward. But then you run into exactly what you just described.

2:03:35 If you don't want something to be perceived as a one-off, whether it will be applied to the system as a whole in the long run or not, you definitely run into some of those cost constraints and some of those other things that you're talking about. So any updates would have to be strategic. Again, I'm not proposing anything right now. Just kind of wanted to get the pulse of the committee because it's...

2:03:57 It's no small thing. You all heard the number of signs that we have on the system. To Rob's point, the detail that we have as it relates to the design of these signs. It would be no small endeavor. But just kind of wanted to start the conversation with this group and certainly appreciate the feedback. So from my point, if we can keep the look fairly consistent with what we have.

2:04:23 And then focus on the information pertained on the signs because that changes and how people digest it changes. You know, there may be a time where instead of having 14 different things that we do, we're having just the three things you can't do listed on the signs. And for that, I would love to see it come back and change them out. The signs do wear out and they get destroyed in snow and everything else. And as the old wear,

2:04:53 Then what the messaging is on them needs to be looked at every time before we just blindly replace it. So that's my take on it. Let's look as we replace them. Let's look at what that content is and see if it needs to be updated or changed. I have my picture on it. Yeah, and I don't think, too, so much work has gone into, how do I word this, for the lack of a better word, the holistic design of the signs.

2:05:21 I think the design of the signs is great. And I'm talking maybe a bit more about some of the smaller minutia within the signs that maybe could help users just understand what's going on a little bit better. So yeah, totally understand where you're coming from there, Bill, as well. I think the Share Your Mammoth Lakes Trails experience might not be communicating the proper thing.

2:05:47 That's why I brought that one up as an example. That came up in some of our vetting of sign replacement. We're like, this one seems a little bit weird. And I just thought it was a good example of one to bring to the group of something that we were maybe considering, yeah. An idea might be to play off of share the road, you know, a sign that bikers like seeing and use that to encourage bikers to share the trail. Yep.

2:06:20 Yeah, I'll just throw my two cents in. I think your recommendations that you started with are great. I think you guys got a good framework that you're already working on or working within in these creations of these signs. So I personally don't feel the need to kind of re-look at these and trust you guys in moving forward and working with the designs already existing. Thank you.

2:06:55 Any other comments on this topic before we move on? All right. All right. This one's cool. I think we're excited about this one. This sort of feedbacks on kind of Andrew's discussion of the new system that we will be grooming this year, the state-funded almost 90-mile trail system that we have. And one thing that we really wanted to bring back that was kind of a vestige, pardon me, from the older days.

2:07:27 was the snowcat tracking. We really felt like that would just be an awesome thing for our visitors and locals alike to know where the cat is, to know where those freshies are, to know what's been groomed relatively recently, and just be able to keep an eye on things. And we did a bunch of research and found this company called Nordic Pulse. They are not just specific to Nordic. I will say that right off the bat. They have snowmobile.

2:07:56 Or motorized trail systems as part of their network as well. But in terms of what we researched, this was the most comprehensive one that really from both a usability perspective and a data perspective was just really on point. And you can see all these different locations here on the map that they already have within their system, including some in California. I spoke to a couple of these, pardon me.

2:08:22 A couple of these entities in Utah, and they just absolutely love it, and said their visitors love it, and we're moving with these folks, and it's really, really great, and just showing you right here, here's an example from Soldier Hollow in Utah, and basically you can see their system on the left.

2:08:41 This image was taken before anything was groomed, but that's their whole system. And then basically everything gets color-coded, what you can see right here in the last groom. So it was groomed today, it was groomed one to three days ago, four to six days ago. And there will also be a tracking device right here on the left in the Snowcat so that people will know where the Snowcat is on the system. There's also an app.

2:09:04 That folks can just easily open on their phones, go into Nordic Pulse, see our trail system, and be able to look at that. And you can also take this, for lack of a better word, widget, and we will be able to embed this on the town website. It will update in real time, as it would on the Nordic Pulse website or within the app, and I think will just be an awesome, awesome thing for the groomer. So we're really excited about it and wanted to share this with you all.

2:09:34 Here's an example of what it might look like with a system that's actually groomed. So you can see all the different color coding of what was groomed recently, what was groomed, you know, one to three days ago, things of that nature. So we're really excited about it. We're also going to implement it with our non-motorized trail system. We're not going to get like a GPS device that I showed on the last one, this that would be installed in it.

2:10:03 Rather, what you can just do is when we hop on the snowmobile, we can go into the Nordic Pulse app as a grooming entity, just click start, and then it will track us via the phone. So that's a really nice thing for something like the snowmobile, but we feel embedding this technology in the snowcat is the better option for the snowcat. We've also spoken to our friends over at Mammoth Mountain and told them,

2:10:30 How cool this was and how beneficial it might be and the folks at Tamarack seem interested, but they want to see how it goes for us first, but could be really cool also to eventually get Tamarack on this system and then all of our trails will be groomer tracked in real time so folks will know exactly.

2:10:49 When the good snow is being groomed and what trails haven't been groomed in a while, et cetera. So really excited about that and just wanted to share that with you. Seems like a really, really great thing. And we're going to start working towards implementation of that in terms of getting it on our website and getting real updated tracking the GPS devices in the mail and on the way to us right now.

2:11:17 So just wanted to share that with you all. Really excited about it. Any questions or comments on Nordic Pulse and the groomer tracking? My only comment is that when this was done before, and I don't know what happened to that software or why it disappeared, it was incredibly popular, especially with people from out of town, to look and be able to see what and if things have been groomed. So, you know, let's go. Especially, importantly,

2:11:47 That it can be implemented on the trails website, on the town's website, on the Forest Service website. So it can be, if it can be on multiple platforms, so that no matter where they go to get their information, they can see real-time information on the grooming. That would, you know, take calls down from us, for instance, when somebody wants to find out if Glass Creek has been groomed. They can go on the site and see if the groomer had passed over it. So I think it's a great idea, from my perspective anyway.

2:12:15 Yeah, and Bill, for your edification, the company with the old tracker got purchased by another company, and they claim that was proprietary technology, so they took it back from the Inyo. So that's what happened to the old one. Yeah. We paid for it. I don't know how the heck they can take it back, but okay. I'd just like to add in my previous comments about, you know, we took this program over not only to continue to have the program, but to elevate the experience.

2:12:45 And so I think this is a great example of that, Lawson, so thank you for finding that. It will bring back functionality that may have existed before, but in every way, we do want to make sure we're seeking to elevate the experience above and beyond what it was, right? Quality experience, all those types of things, and this does lend itself to that. So thank you. Thank you.

2:13:13 No, we're pretty excited about it. I think it's just going to be such a great amenity for the community and our visitors. So any other comments on this? I just have a quick question. So I know that fat tire bikes are allowed on groomed areas out of Shady Rest. Are fat tire e-bikes allowed on those routes? Because it doesn't specify online. As far as I know,

2:13:44 Yes. Andrew, do you have a different understanding potentially? I understood it. I thought they were allowed that as a motorized system. Yeah, that's how I understood it. Yeah, I think the distinction is just, you know, on those orange diamond networks, anything with a battery would be fine because it's motorized trail network. On our blue diamond groom shady rest trails, a fat bike.

2:14:10 Human-powered is fine, but an electric one would not be allowed because that would be, you know, a motorized vehicle in the eyes of the forest. Yep. Interesting question. Are we allowing fat bikes on our motor, on our Blue Diamond system, on the non-motor? I think that's what it says. Have we seen what kind of damage is done to the tracks?

2:14:32 Yeah, we allow them out there and there's some good etiquette information on our signage boards out there that explain, you know, if you're leaving a rut deeper than two inches, then you should not continue to ride. And, you know, it's, I think it's, it's self-limiting. There's a small fat bike community in town and they know when is a good time to ride and when isn't. There's certainly conditions out there when it's bulletproof and you can just, you can ride any bike pretty much.

2:15:02 And that's when you see most of the use. And then, you know, in soft powder that hasn't been packed yet, that may have been groomed once or twice, but isn't really packed, then you're going to leave a big rut. And in those instances, folks notice that and turn around. We haven't run into any major issues in terms of people picking up the cracks too bad with the fat bikes. Thank you. Bill, you and I probably can never ride. We'd probably leave a bigger rut.

2:15:33 A much larger, yes. Oh my goodness. All right. Any other comments? All right. This is also piggybacking on some stuff Andrew brought up. He primarily focused on trails, but I want you all to be aware that when we say that the Inyo National Forest is not going to have any seasonals in summer of 2025,

2:16:03 That means all program areas. So that means visitor centers, that means recreation technicians that clean restrooms, the wilderness folks that we have discussed before, OHV staff, not that there have been a lot of OHV seasonals anyway, but we did proactively reach out to the forest and had an initial meeting with them, which is how Andrew got a lot of his information that he relayed to you all.

2:16:26 On November 19th, where we really tried to discuss, well, first of all, it was us, Sierra Forever, formerly ESEA, Mono County and Mammoth Lakes Tourism were in attendance. And we really just wanted to set the stage with, what is this going to look like? As far as we know, what are the forest needs? So then we can all make good decisions on where we place our resources, how we can help, if it makes sense for us to help in certain areas.

2:16:56 And quite honestly, what we came out of that meeting with is the Inyo needs to get a few of their ducks in a row in terms of...

2:17:05 Contracts that they have in place, for instance. They have contracts for restroom cleaning. How many days are those contracts? Is it possible for that contract to be expanded if it's not seven days a week? And that would be an area where then we wouldn't have to step up and support and potentially would allow maybe some of that stepping up to occur in the wilderness realm that Andrew discussed prior. So we will continue to have these conversations. It'll obviously relate to the visitor centers as well, to Minaret Vista, which will be a big.

2:17:34 And I think both Sierra Forever and Mammoth Lakes Tourism could be potential great assets as it relates to some of those visitor services type end of things, the visitor centers and Minaret Vista. But more to come on this. We're going to continue to have conversations. But this is a pretty serious thing. I worked for the Forest Service for 16 years prior to working for the town.

2:18:00 I never saw anything like this. So this is definitely going to have a big impact, as Rob had stated and many of you had stated related to Andrew's comments on wilderness. We need to be very strategic with this stuff. We need to make smart decisions. I believe, as Mike said, just because they say jump, we don't necessarily say how high, but we do.

2:18:21 Want to ensure that we're providing a good user experience out there. So more to come. I'll continue to reach out to the forest as it relates to their capacity, where really their holes are going to be. I think a big one that Andrew kind of touched on in the periphery is they have agreements with a lot of other wilderness organizations. But basically, the way that things are organized right now, that money can't really be given to the forest.

2:18:48 Can it be funneled to another entity who can then hire staff for the forest? So these are all things that we're going to want to work through as we move into summer. And just again, want to put it on your radar that Andrew did a great job, I think, of presenting the wilderness aspect, but this will expand to OHV, visitor centers, as well as recreation technicians and restroom cleaning. So any questions or comments regarding no Forest Service seasonals next summer?

2:19:17 Yeah, just a quick comment, and maybe this is done already or not, but maybe reaching out to the Chamber of Commerce as an ally in this process to just kind of help educate also our local businesses, especially those that are in the recreation business, so that they can convey this information to their customers and maybe just not be dumbfounded or anything like that and use them as an ally. Thank you.

2:19:49 Yeah, I've got significant concerns about this. Obviously, this was having a direct impact on our visitor experience. And Lawson, you and I have not connected on this, but from my conversations with Fred Wong, you know, you made the point earlier about how the Forest Service cannot receive funding from others to support or hire. I think that was what you were intending to say in that.

2:20:14 So for example, if they said, you know, hey, we just need some money to be able to hire the people we need, they can't even accept that, right? They can't even work in that space. The request that's been made of the town is to hire our own part-time staff that could work in those areas. They're looking for three visitor information specialists and one recreation technician.

2:20:43 I've asked for some additional information on what that actually looks like. I will have to obviously take that to council. That's a fairly significant cost impact and where that may actually come from. But that's the ask that's been specifically provided to the town. And it's really to make sure that there's some semblance of service to people at the visitor center as well as the maintenance of those sites around the area to make sure they're serviced and they have a high degree of

2:21:12 I think the Forest Service, and did you mention this, that they're going to really focus on Minaret Vista, I think, and their access to that, that was where they were going to do with their own staff, permanent staff, if you will, even in some cases. So, yeah, this is a critical, critical impact to us and going to take a lot of different people to be involved in it. But, you know, Mike, you talked about how other businesses would be

2:21:41 Maybe controlling the messaging a little bit, but also, you know, potentially supporting some sort of a solution to that, but it's going to require really good coordination so that it's a system response instead of an individual and one-off stuff. So just a lot to do in this area. And, you know, Lawson, I know the initial meeting was a lot of your prompting, so I appreciate you pushing that up to the top because it's going to be critical to solve. There is an issue with this, and I mull this over.

2:22:10 Since all of this started, the reason they can't hire is purely a political and budgeting issue on the federal level, not standing up to the plate for what their obligations are on the landscape. The more people like us that take this on, and at this point I couldn't say whether I'd be in favor of it or not. You know how much I am for recreation and for maintaining these trails. But the only way to change a political landscape is outrage of the populace.

2:22:40 If we backfill everything they were doing, we can't create that outrage. We can't get the public input necessary to get the federal government to change their policy on how these things work or even on how funds are allocated to the individual forests because there is no real system regardless how many people are on your forest your budget is set by people in Washington that don't have a clue. So I have a real...

2:23:09 And I'm all over the place on this because for us to be successful in the long run, we need that public outcry to get our federal partners to be able to, you know, pony up to do what their obligation is. Or, as some have suggested, turn all the forests back over to the states that they were taken from in the first place and then change the funding and the management dynamic completely.

2:23:37 I am all over the place on this with no clear. We can't lose our resources, though. We can't let all of the trails go to crap, let motorized vehicles drive all over non-motorized trails and cause a lot of harm and then affect town and tourism just because the Forest Service can't step up at this point. I do understand that

2:24:08 We need to have, we can't just take up what the Forest Service has done, but we can't also let those, our natural resources, get degraded and then degrade the town and the town's economy because of that. As I said, it's a conundrum. On that particular issue, though, I don't have a huge concern because that enforcement has always been paid for out of the state of California's motorized vehicle fund.

2:24:38 The Forest Service gets tens of thousands of dollars to enforce and manage the motorized systems. So I don't imagine that piece is going to go away unless the Forest Service just wants to get out of the business of being in business. Yeah, Bill, I understand your comments about, you know, the outrage sort of dictating where things will change, right? I mean, it takes a lot of effort to make change.

2:25:08 As town manager, my number one bullet point on my job description is avoid public outrage. So I think there's a systematic way of addressing that, right? So we don't let things get damaged and go to those spaces, but that they still work. So there's a lot of work to do in this coordination, right? There's a lot of work to do in what's the appropriate level of response, what's the appropriate level of responsibility that then lends back on that.

2:25:37 What's the short-term and the long-term process there? So a lot of work to be done in this area. Just, I can't stress enough how, Lassen said it perfectly, never has he seen something of this magnitude. And I think, you know, it does, it's going to require us continually trying to solve this. It's not an easy issue. Yeah, and I guess one last point for me on this too is just being real strategic with this. And I think, Rob, you and I will have

2:26:10 A good number of conversations on this, but really truthing out and making sure that what the forest is asking for is what they need, right? I wouldn't want to run into a situation where the forest says, we need you to hire a rec tech because they don't want to do the paperwork to modify a contract that could accomplish that work, right? So that's where I really want to be strategic, make sure that we are meeting

2:26:39 Their real needs in a particular scenario and obviously encourage them if they do have some tools in their toolbox to deal with some of these things, then now is the time to utilize those tools. And I know we will have lots of conversations about this moving forward. All right. It'll be an interesting summer next summer. Any other comments on this before I believe we move to the last item on the list? All right. Last item on the list.

2:27:14 Go check out the cool signs. I think I saw them in there.

2:27:18 Big thanks, obviously, to Gretchen for getting those in there, and she was obviously instrumental in helping put these together as well, but you'll see on here two signs that highlight the Clean Up the Lake endeavor in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We will put those out at Lake George next spring, and then the three signs for Mammoth Creek Parcel that will go on the multi-use pathway, highlighting the awesome Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilient Project.

2:27:48 Resilience Project work that occurred in that area. These are great looking signs and we're just really psyched to get these out on the landscape and yeah, just wanted to bring them in for you all to take a look at. But again, big thanks to obviously MLT and their support, Kim as always, Gretchen as well and Andrew for help related to these signs and just some great new educational signage out there on the system for folks to enjoy.

2:28:17 That's all I had. Any questions or comments for me? I think we might have covered it all. Thanks for that report. Thanks, everyone. Thanks for bearing with me. Lawson, I just have one quick question. If there's some information on the website that we would like to discuss, who would I reach out to? Me. Let's talk about it. Okay. I'll contact you. Thank you. Sounds great. Yeah.

2:28:54 Thank you. All right. Thank you and get well. Thanks. You too, Andrew. All right. It brings us to number five, committee reports. We can go around our square table set up here. Anyone want to go first? Anyone have anything to report from the past month, two months? I'm always happy to go first. Okay. I have nothing to report. All right. Thank you, Bill. I just wanted to thank Andrew for

2:29:28 Inviting me to meet him out at Sierra Meadows Ranch to talk about SHARP and how it might affect the equestrian community. I often feel like I'm the lone equestrian on this committee, and it was just nice to be heard and to walk the trails with you and to make that contact. So thank you for your time. I really appreciate that. Thanks, Elise. That was really great for me, too.

2:30:00 Here are all the insights that you had, and I tried to relay that to the group a little bit this morning, and we'll certainly be making thoughtful decisions around allowed use on what trail and which trail in that Sierra Meadows ramp zone, so appreciate your input. Yeah, thank you. And then the only thing, other thing that I just thought was a little bit interesting was I worked up at Tamarack as a host, and we had an

2:30:29 Fat Tire E-Bike on that trail. And they were backcountry skiers who were going up into the Lakes Basin area and actually went up cold water to get access. And I don't know that it's our committee's responsibility, but just to have some messaging out there where these type of bikes are allowed, where they're not allowed, just to try and be a little bit proactive and try to minimize any sort of conflict.

2:30:58 You know, give the education that we need to give or reach out to a partner that can help. That might be a good one. Real quick, we had a meeting actually this morning. Dave at Tamarack, some other Tamarack folks. Chief Kasabian was there. Jason, Laura James, law enforcement for the Inyo National Forest and myself. So yeah, we sat down and talked about this this morning. Obviously, the folks at Tamarack were concerned.

2:31:28 So we're trying to figure out ways to move forward to try to figure out a good path forward to stop this kind of behavior, especially on the, you know, kind of the pass holder only or the pay only lanes there in Tamarack. So sorry to interrupt, but we did have a meeting on that this morning and discussed it with MLPD as well as Forest Service Law Enforcement and Tamarack folks. Great. Thank you. That's all I have. Lawson, if you could maybe reach out to ISAC.

2:31:57 and have them post it on their social media probably go pretty far. Copy. Oh, me. Nothing too exciting. I don't know. Happy holidays. Thank you. I just wanted to update you all on just some effort that the town is doing with regard to, you know, a review of roles and responsibilities across this recreation landscape and how, you know, we have different, I'm going to say different

2:32:33 People working in different areas. And if I could back up just a little bit, you know, prior to the Office of Outdoor Recreation, you know, there were a structured system by which people worked together on achieving results in that area, right? Working on things and getting things accomplished. When we added Office of Outdoor Recreation, it was sort of put over the top of that overarching. And what I don't think ever really happened, first and foremost, when you think about the transition from

2:33:02 You know, Joel Rathje's trail manager to, you know, the development of the Office of Outdoor Recreation and those components, that connective tissue, if you will, between all of those agencies and how they function together, including this one, and their roles and responsibilities was never really reviewed, right, and went gone through. So we're starting down that process to really look at how

2:33:27 That structure evolves a little bit and those roles and responsibilities are more well defined as we sort of integrate more of Office of Outdoor Recreation into this process. So look for that over the next six months or so as we figure out, you know, how that looks and feel. You'll all be part of that. I think we'll probably have some agendized items on for this group to discuss. But it's a pretty large endeavor and I think it's going to be helpful for people to, you know,

2:33:56 Focus on what they need to be doing and how they contribute to the success and maybe eliminate some conflict of who's doing what in certain areas. So I see it as a sort of an organizational checkup, if you will, but it was something clear to me. I mean, I obviously in the last year have been doing a lot of understanding about things that were outside of my area of influence as a finance director but now are on my plate as a town manager.

2:34:23 that I really need to be involved in. And so this is one of those that I've recognized as a great need. So look for that in the future. So thank you. I have completed the last requirement for my master's as of yesterday. So finish that up and it's been a long haul for me. That's kind of been my focus though. Nice work. For Mono County, we're still plugging away at a trail system.

2:34:57 We've provided everything that the Forest Service and BLM has asked up front, but it just takes a lot of time, so nothing really new to report on that end. But there's still a lot of good dirt out there. You know, that early snow took us out, but dirt starts at the top of the grade, and it's a lot of fun, so it's not far. I'll just report the fall Mammoth Hockey League concluded this week.

2:35:29 Which was an awesome success. Huge hockey advocate. So it was really cool to see the community take such a great involvement in that. And then just looking forward to June Mountain opening early. So I'll be there this weekend. All right. Thanks all for the reports. Do we have any requests for future agenda items? Okay. Not seeing any at the moment.

2:36:02 We'll go to adjournment. It's 538, and I'll make the motion to adjourn. I'll second. All right. Thanks, everyone. Thank you.