Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2025
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
162 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:08 All right. We have 9 o'clock. We have a quorum. Are we good to go, everyone? Yes, senor. Okay. Well, good morning, everyone. I would like to call to order today's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, which is, today is November 12th, 9 a.m. here in Suite Z. So with that, may we please have a roll call? Angie? Mm-hmm. Commissioner Deaver? Here. Commissioner Fleming? Is absent. Commissioner Ground? Here.
1:39 Vice Chair Verruck? Here. And Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you, Angie. With that, I'd like to ask everyone to stand and cover their heart for the Pledge of Allegiance. And would Ms. Truax care to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance this morning? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Ms. Truax.
2:11 And with that, I will open up public comment. I will ask if you have public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda that you reframe until that agenda item has been open, and you will have the opportunity to present your public comment. So with that, public comment is open. Good morning, commissioners. Nice to see you all. My name is Betsy Truax. I am the vice president of community engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism.
2:38 And in that role, I also oversee Mammoth Lakes Tourism's special events funding program. This for 2026, we have $350,000 available to allocate to special events producers to help events that are driving visitation to our community. And that funding applications will open this Friday, November 14th and close on Monday, December 15th.
3:04 So just wanted to make the community aware that that funding is opening and you can get more information about it at our visitmammoth.com slash community website. People can also reach out to me directly at Mammoth Lakes Tourism if they have any questions. So really looking forward to seeing the great applications we always receive for that program. Thank you. Any questions for Betsy?
3:27 And just for transparency, Betsy, would you mind just outlining the process of how the grant funding is allocated? Yes. So it's allocated by, we have a committee. There are four members of our committee. They include Stu Brown from the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mary Beth Erickson from the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, John Morris from the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. Both John and Mary Beth are involved in the Lodging Association. And then we also have Deb Radcliffe, who is the owner of, with her spouse.
3:56 Side door in the village. They are the one village restaurant that does not have their own event. So we appreciate having her input. So what happens is people go through the application process. The applications are reviewed. The committee typically interviews applicants for new funding, sometimes returning applicants who have questions or request an audience with the committee. The committee then deliberates and makes the recommendations for funding. And we'll be announcing those funding awards on February.
4:26 28th. The recipients of the funding need to sign a contract. There are several deliverables that they have to provide, including working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on promoting their event, you know, collaborative social posts, that kind of thing. And then finally, they have to provide a post-event report, including a P&L, showing how the funds were spent. Thank you, Betsy. Yeah, thank you. Any other public comment? Angie, do we have any public comment via Zoom?
4:54 No comments at this time. With that, I'm going to close public comment. And thank you, Betsy, for that update. And we will go to business matters. First one is 4.1. General plan conformance determination for the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District acquisition of the property located at 395 Chaparral Road that is developed with a four-unit multifamily residential structure.
5:21 for the purpose of providing workforce housing for the fire district. And with that, I believe, is our staff contact Pam or is it Nolan? Nolan, please. Pam can speak to it if she likes. So this item is to consider the general plan conformance of the proposed acquisition by the fire district of the existing residential structure at 395 Chaparral.
5:49 This conformance determination is required by the state for the acquisition of any property by a public agency pursuant to government code section 65402. That determination is intended to review the location, purpose, and extent of the acquisition and determine if those elements are in conformance with the general plan. In the case of the proposed acquisition, the current use of the site is in multifamily residential use on a site zone for multi-residential uses.
6:18 And the proposed use will continue to be a multifamily residential use and the zoning and general plan land use designation will remain unchanged. So therefore the existing use and the proposed use are both in conformance with the general plan as well as the zoning code. Additional elements of the general plan that apply to this use are really related to the
6:43 The public safety nature of the proposed use. So the general plan places an emphasis and focus on maintaining a safe and efficient municipal operations and services and keeping Mammoth Lakes a safe place to live, work, and play. And also
7:02 To maintain high-quality, livable housing units. And then a policy under that is to support public safety personnel to ensure that town neighborhoods are safe, attractive, and livable. So related to those two goals and policies, the proposed use really meets those because the fire district is unique in the sense that they require their personnel to live within, I believe it's seven minutes.
7:31 of the fire station to respond to any emergency calls with the nature of the fire district being a kind of hybrid system where there's a limited number of full-time staff on call to staff one engine and then all other response vehicles are staffed by those firefighters responding to the call. There is a need to have them living close to the station. And with housing prices the way they are, that has become problematic for the district to maintain
8:00 And an adequate level of staff living in the district. So this really acquisition speaks directly to that to provide housing for their staff so they can live close to the station. It is important to note that with this acquisition, the district does not intend to evict any of the current tenants and really plan to kind of through attrition.
8:23 Provide those units to staff. So as people move out, then those units will then be offered up to their fire district staff. So that is all I have for my item. I also know Alex Tamire, the fire chief, is here who can speak to anything I missed or answer any questions from the commission. Excellent. Let me just throw it back on the commission. Does anyone at this time have any questions for Nolan on the staff report on item 4.1? No? Chief, would you care to make a statement?
8:55 And then we also have Betsy Chairs, the Fire Commission Board. So if we have any questions about the board. Good morning, Alex Tamire, Fire Chief, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. So a couple things on this. If you ask me kind of on any given day what is my job, it's to put approximately 15 people on various incidents at any given point in time. So that can be a Tuesday at 2 in the morning or it can be on a Saturday where we have...
9:23 Quite a few other things going on. If you look at that, that's an incredibly tough business model to have 15 employees available at all these points, you know, for anybody in this community, especially when you look at kind of the requirements you have of firefighters, they have to have certain levels of training. So for that reason, the district has always had a rule that firefighters have to live within seven minutes driving time of a fire station, and that's what gives us that capacity to do that. You can't have as...
9:50 Chief Reeva used to say, same day fire service, it just doesn't work. On top of that, as a community, we have some unique challenges here in the sense that there's times where even if you had employees living in June Lake, they just can't get here. Same thing with Crowley. So we recognize that that's a hardship on our employees, and for that reason, we've been working to start balancing this problem out. The fire district has actually owned some property and been working on this for as long as I've been on the district for 25 years.
10:19 This is the first step towards actually becoming landlords. It's something that we've been very cautious to step into, but the reality is it is just a need if we want to make sure that we're providing services appropriately. So we have some other programs to assist. We recognize that, you know, different employees have different needs from a housing perspective. There's not a single solution for anybody in this community, and we work with, you know, down payment assistance and those sorts of things. But this is going to be
10:49 A chunk of kind of that solution to make sure that the community has the response capacity that needs to deal with our emergencies. So I'll keep it relatively brief unless you have any questions. Any questions for the chief on the workforce housing proposal? A quick question, chief. What would be the strategy or what would be the game plan to prioritize your staff in terms of a pecking order, who gets in first and who gets in?
11:15 Maybe down near the bottom. Good question. So again, this is going to be kind of a multi-bucket solution for our staff that we're going to be working on. So I...
11:25 I prefer things like what the water district has with shared equity and down payment assistance because it has the least administrative components and maintenance components tied to it and it still protects, you know, I think the goal for us and it's a little unique from like what the town's trying to do is these state district assets in the sense that we create kind of like a revolving system to support future employees and don't have to
11:47 Lose our portion of the equity or lose that facility. If at some point, you know, we solved housing issue and felt like this wasn't a need, this building's a district asset that we could sell to support our mission in another way. But, you know, to answer your question more directly, our first priority is going to be our full-time staff and then kind of our senior part-time staff, and that's going to be based on seniority and classification. So essentially captains are going to have first rides before engineers, before firefighters.
12:17 Probably not too different from other businesses in the community. What we've really found is a challenge keeping kind of that middle management of our workforce in the system. And what I mean by that is just like everybody else, we have kind of a revolving door of firefighters that come and go because of the nature of this place. But what you really need is kind of that captain who has five to eight years of experience and can provide that leadership on scene.
12:45 And so those are going to be kind of our priorities to make sure that we still have what we need when we respond on an incident. And when the tenants, when the space has become vacated and you can start moving your team, your staff in, they'll be paying rent back to the fire district? Is that the correct assumption? Yes. So basically what we're doing is we're essentially
13:06 We're not purchasing a full building. We're subsidizing the ability for the employee. So they will be paying rent on it. It will be at a rent that is reasonable for what they bring in. And what that means is, again, we don't have to purchase a whole building. We still don't have income coming off of it. We just have to make up for that kind of missing middle component to make sure that they can actually afford the building with the long-term assets staying with the district.
13:28 And just to reiterate, so it's clear for everyone who may be watching at home as well, you are not going to be evicting the current tenants upon taking ownership. Yeah, so we have, through escrow, it looks like two tenants are already in the process of moving out, but there is no, this is a strategic goal for us, it's not an immediate emergency, it's kind of like a...
13:50 Slow-moving emergency. So in the sense that we absolutely need to figure out long-term housing solutions, but our goal is to work with tenants, maybe incentivize them moving out, but over time, we really, you know, I frankly wouldn't want to open up all four units once if I could. It's going to be easier to work through them kind of one at a time. Got it. Thank you.
14:10 That's the only questions I had. Do you have any? I do. Did I hear you say that the fire department and fire district has other properties? And were those, is that, are they structures or are they dirt? Yeah. So what we have is a lot on Joaquin and Dorrance. Okay. It's actually a really nice lot. And we did explore, we could potentially put up to
14:33 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
15:02 But it really doesn't make sense for us to build today. I think that said, the holding costs on that lot are relatively low, so it may be part of our options in the future. Any other questions for the chief while we've got them or the fire commission board since we have a representation in the audience? Awesome. Any public comment in suite Z for item 4.1?
15:36 Betsy Truax, I'm the current Chair of the Fire Commission and really just wanted to say that the entire Commission is very excited about this. You know, we are the only public agency that has a requirement for staff to live within seven minutes of either Station 1 or Station 2. It's just not very effective to have firefighters that, you know, live in, you know, in June or even, you know, Crowley or Bishop. So we're just incredibly excited about this opportunity to start providing a housing option.
16:06 And first, as Alex said, some of our senior staff, we think it will help us with retention, which is also really critical to the district right now. So thank you. Thank you, Betsy. Angie, any questions on this matter from the Zoom world? No comments at this time. All right. With that, I will close public comment and throw it back up on the commission. Any thoughts or opinions that anybody would like to express? Seeing none, I'd be more than happy to entertain a motion.
16:44 I will, let's see, I make a motion to adopt the resolution finding the acquisition by Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District of the development of the developed multifamily residential property located at 395 Chaparral Road to be in conformance with the town's general plan. I second. We have a first, we have a second. Any further conversation? Any further discussion?
17:11 No, with that, Jamie, may we please have a, Jamie, Angie, may we please have, I've got my reading glasses on, I can't see past my nose. May we please have a vote. Commissioner Deaver. Yes. Commissioner Grand. Yes. Vice Chair Verruck. Yes. And Chair Vanderhurst. Yes, matter passes four zero, congratulations. And well done, way to set the precedent for.
17:35 Taking care of your own and taking care of this community. This is not a selfish act by the fire district by any means. And this is something that will benefit all of us. So thank you, Chief. Thank you, Betsy. Please pass that on to the rest of your board. All right, with that, we will move to business matter 4.2, which is receive a presentation and discuss the draft multi-jurisdictional local hazard mitigation plan update. And with that,
18:06 Pam, are you our staff contact? I am. Nolan and I are going to tag team this one a little bit. And this is a presentation, but not necessarily an action item. Is that correct? Informational only. Okay. Correct. So it's informational. It gives the option for the commission or the public to ask any questions about the, I'm going to just use acronym LHMP throughout because it's a really long title to the actual document. So that's just local hazard mitigation plan.
18:33 So the document is out for public review. The public review period started last week on the 7th and runs through December 7th. So it's about a 30-day public review period where anyone can provide comments to the consultant or they can send them directly to staff and we can provide them to the consultant. So this is a multi-jurisdictional document, meaning it applies to both the town and the county. It's updated every five years.
19:00 So the last update on this was done in 2019 and our current plan expired in 2024 and we've been working since then together with the county to update the plan. The important thing about the plan having an adopted plan in place is it makes us eligible for a lot of different grants that come through the state and federal level that require you to have one of these plans in place. So it is a critical document for that as well as it provides just a wealth of information on
19:29 All sorts of hazards that impact both the county and the town. So with that, I'll hand it over to Pam to kind of walk through the plan and the overview of it. All right. Thank you, Nolan. That was a really good intro. I will cover a lot of that stuff in the presentation as well. Good morning, commissioners. I'm Pam Kobylarz, assistant to the town manager.
19:52 And we have a brief presentation, really just trying to get information out into the public about the plan now that the public draft is out for review. So this presentation will be an overview and the contact information to send any public comments is here in the slide deck. I believe it's at the end of the presentation or as Nolan mentioned, comments could be sent to either one of us as well and we can pass those on to the consultant.
20:22 So we're just going to briefly cover a few different components of the plan, starting with what is hazard mitigation, why do we do mitigation planning, the various partners involved in the planning process, and kind of where we've been and next steps in the process.
20:41 So hazard mitigation is really important because it helps to eliminate the long-term risk to human life and property from potential hazards. As you can see from the little graphic on the screen, investing money up front into mitigation can have a huge impact on preventing or at least decreasing impacts from disasters and emergencies when they happen.
21:06 And I guess also we do have Alish in the room who was a big participant in this whole process as well. So if he might have something to chime in any time during the presentation or afterwards. So benefits of mitigation, as I mentioned on the previous slide, they really just help to break the cycle of disaster damage and repetitive damage and reconstruction. You can see on the graphic here there's kind of
21:31 Four different components to emergencies and disasters. What this plan really focuses on is the first two, which is mitigation and preparedness, trying to do everything we can to prepare our community before a disaster happens to make the impacts on response and recovery hopefully less to our community and our residents. Sorry, one more thing on that slide, Nolan.
22:00 One other benefit of mitigations is that they can help with other community objectives, such as capital improvements, preserving green space, for instance. So oftentimes we have dual or compounding benefits in the sense that they both help to mitigate disasters, but they also can help with other community assets or improvements.
22:25 So a few examples of hazard mitigation could include upgrading a community center so it could be used as a resource hub or a shelter. The town actually for several years has been looking into the possibility of building some sort of community resiliency center which would serve both of those two purposes. We had initially looked at doing that as part of our new town hall construction.
22:49 We applied for several different grants, but unfortunately didn't receive any of those. However, the building has been designed that a community resiliency center could be added on to that in the future if we were to receive grant funding. So that just goes to show one of the benefits of having a plan like this in place is that it helps to make us a strong candidate for grants like that in the future. A few other specific hazards that we have called out in our plan just
23:14 By way of example include things like bark beetle treatment for trees that could either be on small scale for individual parcels or more of a large scale type of treatment on high risk areas. We've identified things such as seismic risk assessments and retrofit projects throughout the community. Again, those could be a variety of things. It could be
23:38 assessments or retrofit projects for public facilities and infrastructure. It could also potentially be programmed where we would have funding available to do those types of retrofits on private buildings. Also defensible space programs obviously is something that's really relevant in our community right now and at the top of everyone's mind. You can skip this one. So why update the plan? Nolan spoke to this a little bit, but
24:07 We are required to have this plan by FEMA in order to be eligible for certain types of grant funding. So at its very base level, it's kind of a federal requirement to have this plan. It does need to be updated every five years. And as Nolan mentioned, our current plan did expire in June of last year. So unfortunately, we don't have a current plan at the moment. There was a little bit of some change in the requirements. So when we updated our plan back in 2019,
24:35 As long as we were in the process of updating it, even if the plan had expired, basically for the purpose of Cal OES and FEMA, they still considered the plan to be valid since we were actively in the process of updating it. When we first started this process, it was our understanding that it would work the same way. However, the requirements changed, and when it expires, it expires, and there are no exceptions. So we're currently operated with an expired plan, unfortunately.
25:02 Sorry, Pam, may I interrupt really quick? Just to give everyone kind of a real-life, real-time example of how important it is to be eligible for FEMA assistance. In the spring following Snowmageddon, FEMA was here in Mammoth Lakes helping with our recovery efforts for a good month, right? Maybe six weeks? So, I mean, this isn't like some crazy theoretical exercise.
25:30 Like if we find ourselves in another disaster situation and we need federal assistance in our recovery, this is a key component. Sorry to interrupt you. No problem. Please interrupt if you have any questions that come up throughout the course of the presentation. So just a little bit of background. In addition to being approved by FEMA, this plan also needs to be approved by Cal OES, the California Office of Emergency Management.
25:57 And so that process, just once we develop the whole plan, that process of being reviewed by those two agencies does take a bit of time as well. Once it's been approved by both Cali OES and FEMA, we will approve it here locally with our town council. And we haven't really talked about kind of the dual nature or the multiple partners in this yet. We'll get into that a little bit more, but I do want to emphasize that this is a joint plan.
26:21 Mono County and the Town of Mammoth Lakes are the two primary participants, but there's a number of special districts that are also participating in this process and who will adopt it as their own plan as well, which I guess leads me to my next slide, who's involved. Throughout the process, a component of the plan was getting broad public outreach and participation to the extent that we could. We held a number of stakeholder meetings here in this room as well as up in Bridgeport and online.
26:50 Stakeholders such as Whitebark Institute, SCE, Mammoth Mountain all participated and had really valuable input into the plan. The public was also engaged through the RPACs, which are county groups that represent the various different communities throughout Mono County. And next slide, please.
27:12 I touched on this, but the plan participants, so these are the agencies that will actually be adopting the plan when this process is all said and done. Mono County in town of Mammoth Lakes, as I mentioned, an invitation was sent to participate to every single special district located in Mono County. The lists that you see on the screen are the list of districts who opted to participate. It is no small task to be a plan participant. There's a quite in-depth
27:42 process of information that needs to be provided, of engagement throughout in terms of helping to identify potential mitigation actions. One problem that we kind of ran across is that a lot of the special districts are really volunteers and so they just didn't have the time to dedicate to be able to become full-blown plan participants. However, a lot of them, even if they weren't on this list, did participate in various stakeholder meetings and still were able to give input in that way.
28:13 Just briefly outlining the process. So really we started out with the old plan that was adopted in 2019 as a starting point and kind of reviewed that to identify which parts of that plan were still relevant and which parts of that plan maybe weren't so pertinent to our operations now five years later. We went through the whole planning process. As I mentioned, that involved a lot of public participation.
28:40 Risk assessments, capability assessments, we'll talk a bit more about both of those, mitigation strategies, which is identifying all of the potential mitigation actions, and then we are here, right, between mitigation strategy and plan maintenance, which will be kind of the following ongoing step in the process. The next two slides cover goals that were identified at the start of this whole process. I'm not going to read through all of these, but basically,
29:11 The town and the county identified a number of goals that we wanted to make sure that this plan was able to help us accomplish once it's completed. I'll skip to the next one, please. Yep. So I touched on this a bit already, but the planning process was quite comprehensive. We had monthly steering committee meetings, which was basically meetings between the consultant and the two staff teams from Mono County and town of Mammoth Lakes.
29:39 Six planning team meetings with many, many individual jurisdictions. Those took place, like I said, here in this room, online, up in Bridgeport. There's a lot of opportunities for people to become engaged. As you can see, over 70 stakeholders participated, so pretty high level of engagement for us here locally. We also had a public survey that was out for many months, both in Spanish and English, 154 responses.
30:06 Additional outreach that we did on the town side was some social media posts as well as ads in the paper getting word out specifically about this survey but about the LHMP planning process in general. So one of the components of the process was the risk assessment. This is one of the parts where the consultant really did the heavy lift on this for us but basically identifying the hazards and then in-depth analysis of each of those hazards and potential impacts.
30:40 Potential losses. And I just want to emphasize that this assessment was done for the entire county. Obviously, the town of Mammoth Lakes is four square miles, so in the scheme of things in Mono County, we're a very small portion of that. Although we do have a large population, the actual physical area didn't necessarily take up a large part of the risk assessment.
31:05 Through the planning process, next slide please, we identified 16 individual hazards within Mono County. As you can see on the list, there were two new hazards that have been identified since the 2019 plan was adopted, endemic, pandemic, obviously with the COVID-19 emergency that we had, that wasn't really on anyone's radar when we were doing the planning process before 2019.
31:33 And as we all know, that had huge impacts on our community and we wanted to make sure that that was addressed in this current plan. As well as energy shortages and energy resiliency, I think we've seen a huge uptick in the PSPS events in the last few years. Again, something that wasn't really on our radar at the time that we adopted the last plan. So that there was quite a bit of discussion in our various stakeholder meetings about those impacts as well.
32:03 Capability assessment, I won't talk long about this, but just really identifying the capabilities of the various plan participants, kind of speaking to what are our resource capacity, financial capacity, and just generally identifying the capability of the plan participants to be able to work through the various mitigation actions and implement those.
32:30 The mitigation strategy. From our perspective, this is the most important component of the plan. The mitigation strategy is what identifies all of the various actions that could potentially mitigate future hazards. So the reason that we spent so much time focusing on this part of the plan is because the actions that are identified in the plan are available for potential grant funding.
32:55 But they need to be identified. So one problem that we had with our previous plan is that a lot of the mitigation actions were a little vague in the way that they were described in the plan. And so when it came time to
33:09 Apply for some grant opportunities. They weren't described well enough on our plan, and therefore they weren't eligible for some funding opportunities that we had hoped to pursue. So we really spent a lot of time making sure that we had clearly defined mitigation actions, that we were very thorough in our approach to that, and we feel a lot better about the way that they are identified in the plan this time around.
33:38 To highlight, it is really detailed. So in addition to identifying the actions themselves, it also talks about the estimated cost for each action, potential funding sources, potential partners, as well as a prioritization matrix that we went through to prioritize each of the actions into high, medium or low priority. Let's skip this one.
34:07 So for plan maintenance, once the plan is adopted, as I mentioned, this will go to town council for approval here. Mono County will also take it to their board of supervisors for approval at the county side. And then over the next five years, we will meet annually to review the plan.
34:26 Either with Mono County staff or just with Town of Mammoth Lake staff, not exactly sure how that review process will work. Just kind of reviewing those mitigation actions, identifying if any have been completed, if any are not relevant anymore, if there's maybe some new mitigation actions that have come to our attention that weren't identified in the plan but now we would like to include, there's an opportunity to kind of treat that section of the document as a living document and keep it updated.
34:55 Also, in a few years, we're going to start this process all over again because, as we learned, it has to be adopted five years from the adoption of the current plan in order to be valid. So the planning process takes 18 months to two years, I would say, you know, all the way from consultant selection and then just starting the process, working with so many different partners. It just takes a long time to get through it all.
35:24 It's not like we can wait five years and then start it again. We have to start it really quite soon. So that's kind of the next steps on plan maintenance. One more slide, Nolan. For next steps here today, the plan, the draft plan can be accessed at the link. I think Nolan sent out an updated link from what had originally been in the action sheet.
35:49 Please feel free to submit any comments, either to Casey, whose contact information is listed here, to me or Nolan. If you have comments here today in the room, we can also have the consultants review the video from this meeting, so those can be put into the record. Please share this with any friends, family, neighbors, or community members who might be interested in this process or who might have input.
36:12 We really just want to make sure that we do a broad suite regarding public outreach and really get as much public input as we can on the plan. It also just gives it more validity when it comes to those grant opportunities as well. A lot of them are really interested in public outreach and public input on various projects. And so that just helps us have a stronger application when we have that level of public participation.
36:38 That concludes my presentation. Happy to answer any questions. Nolan and Alice are here as well, like I mentioned. Thank you, Pam. Appreciate it. Nolan as well. Any questions for staff on the mitigation plan? I have two quick ones. Please. So the jurisdictions, so once everything is adopted, the jurisdictions that did not participate in our county, do they then kind of adopt whatever package that you guys have put together?
37:06 Are you referring to the special districts? Yeah, just some of the smaller ones like you were noting that are just kind of full volunteer that just don't necessarily have quite some of the time because, yeah, well, it's important to us. I think it's important to our entire county to make sure we're all protected. Right. So the special districts that are listed, I think there's like eight or nine of them here. They will adopt this as a full-blown plan for their district, just like the town and the county are doing.
37:30 I don't know if we specifically mentioned it in the presentation, but there's the base plan, which really covers all the hazard identification throughout all of Mono County and then each of the plan participants has an annex, which is really focused on that particular district. The ones who are not listed on this will not be able to adopt the plan. They could choose in the future to go forward and adopt their own plan.
37:58 But it's a pretty heavy lift, like I mentioned, and if they didn't participate in this process, I wouldn't envision that they would have the resources to participate in a full-blown plan. That being said, I still think this process benefits them. Even though they're not named as a participant on the plan, they still have access to everything in here. A lot of the mitigation actions might be relevant to their districts, and so they could still choose to implement those mitigation measures in ways
38:26 That maybe don't require federal funding. So I think there are still some opportunities for them to benefit from it like that. That's great. And you had mentioned on your group of participants from the outreach, I didn't hear anything about ORMAT. Did they decline to kind of participate? ORMAT did attend some of our stakeholder meetings. I don't think they were allowed to be a...
38:51 A plan participant, and I'm not sure if that's because they're an energy provider. I'm not sure what the criteria are, because I know SCE is also not a plan participant, but they were heavily engaged in the stakeholder meetings. Any other questions? Thank you. Commissioner Deaver? No. Any? Please, Commissioner Baruch. Two questions. So can you give us an example of an entity that isn't?
39:20 That could, that isn't participating? I'm just curious. Sure, it's a lot of the little, for instance, a lot of the smaller fire protection districts throughout the county. So there are a few listed here, but there's just a lot of smaller ones that didn't have the resources to engage in that way.
39:40 Off the top of my head, it's really the fire protection districts that were the primary one, but there were a lot of other little special special districts. I could pull that list for you. Oh, I was just kind of curious. And then when do you anticipate this going to council for approval? So we have the public review period that ends December 7th. I think we anticipate a little bit of additional cleanup to the plan based on any input that is received through that process.
40:08 Then it will be sent to Cal OES, which has up to 45 days to review it. Then it will be sent to FEMA, which also has up to 45 days to review it. I will also caveat that with saying due to various things that have been happening at the federal level, FEMA has paused their review on these types of plans several times over the last six months or so. It's kind of, oh, now they're reviewing it. Now they're not. We don't know when they're going to review them again. So 45 days, hopefully, at FEMA.
40:38 So let's say that's three months. I would say maybe April. We would then have both Cal OES and FEMA approval and be able to take it to Town Council for approval. Okay. Thank you. And then you start the process again. And then we start the process again in a couple years, yeah. So once it's adopted, when are we going to start taking actions on that plan?
41:01 We really use the plan in an opportunistic way. So we do work with a consulting firm that helps us with grant writing and identifying grant funding opportunities. So they will certainly have this plan and this list of actions and be on the lookout for any grants that might be good matches for these projects. Some of these might be things that get funded through our general fund as well, depending on the priority level.
41:28 How it aligns with the Town Council's strategic priorities. So there's not a specific or firm time frame for how it gets implemented, but I think the goal is to start working to accomplish a number of these mitigation actions before the plan is updated again in five years. I don't know, Nolan, do you have a better answer to that? No, and I think some of it is kind of opportunity-based or responding to kind of...
41:57 Emergencies that we weren't necessarily aware of. For example, after the large winter, we did apply for a FEMA grant to get funding to kind of harden propane structures throughout the community. We envision it could be similar to the wood stove replacement where we would have money for homeowners to apply to then retrofit the propane enclosures. That grant is still pending, I believe, with FEMA. It's been...
42:26 It's a long time. It's there. We haven't been told we didn't get the grant, but we haven't been told that it's moving forward either. But one of the requirements to apply for that grant was having the LHM be in place. We were clear with FEMA and Cal OES that we were updating it, and they were kind of like, oh, by the time we might review that, hopefully your new one will be in place. So it's still kind of in flux, but that's just an example of, you know, kind of.
42:53 idea or concept that came out of a prior emergency that then we said, okay, well, how can we get funding for this? And then where the plan comes in place to kind of support that request for funding. Other examples are more kind of, you know, on the preventative side, such as, you know, what we're doing with home hardening related to wildfire risk and working with the fire district and White Barks and others kind of on that parcel level.
43:21 You know, work we did this summer to both survey all the properties in the community and then actually do vegetation removal and others to harden the community. So it kind of is both, you know, there's some that are truly preventative and some that are kind of come out of a prior emergency that then we go after funding for. Because I think especially on the preventative aspect of it with
43:49 Especially learning that Mammoth has been reclassified into the high danger. Very high. As a whole community. You know, and with how up in the air FEMA and the current administration is with actually coming through and helping people and communities, you know, it's...
44:14 Counting on FEMA and administration come and save you should hit the fan, you know, we might as well wait for snow, you know, to fill the whole mountain in September and to do like more preventative stuff for us to take care of ourselves as much as we can is is just like so much to me just makes so much more sense and and I know like we've been
44:42 told how there's been like a fire, the surveys done with lots and inspections and some of the mitigations and like I still see like if you walk through town like we have so many vacant lots that are absolutely covered in dry traps and layers you know inches of pine needles and
45:10 You know, those vacant lots that were, you know, purchased in, you know, 80s and 90s for pennies on a dime and people just sitting on them and not looking after them. Like, I know, like, on, you know, like, I feel like that is such a major hazard and they need, we do need, as a community, have stronger stance on it with how those vacant lots, how the owners of vacant lots look after them and upkeep them and
45:40 There has to be that the owner annually has to visit the lot and clean up all the dry shrubs and clean up all the needles and if they're not like absolutely they should be fine because I would rather you know somebody that has an empty lot that did not give it be fine and should hit shit hits the fan you know all of us are gonna be you know as good as done and then I also noticed that like some of the
46:09 Dried or dead trees have not been removed from some of the lots because you know there's been like an on a lot right next to ours there is the trees that so dead it has absolutely nothing it's dried through and through and through and through but because there was a and it's a pretty tall it literally looks like a candle
46:36 They're just waiting to be ignited. But because there was a woodpecker's nest on it, when they were taking down some of the dead trees, that tree was untouched because of the woodpecker's nest. And listen, like, we all live in the mountains because we want the nature, the wildlife, the trees, the breeze, the fresh air. That's why we're here and we want to protect it and everything else. But shit hits the fan again.
47:06 You know, it's not that that woodpecker is not going to have a home. Like none of us are going to have home. None of the other creatures and animals and birds and inhabitants of this plot will have home. So I think like having systems in place where, yes, okay, if this dead whatever is taken up by a bird, then we, you know, we move the nest, we do whatever. But like, I think having...
47:36 A bigger picture for this land to protect all of its inhabitants from however small to however big should be a bigger priority than just, you know, one bird's nest, that in my humble opinion. And I think, you know, if we're going to spend all this time and resources to create these plans, I think we should have stronger actions implemented within our community to act.
48:06 That easy for us to act without grants, you know, and not just, you know, write these beautiful plans and then wait for grants. Again, just my humble opinion. Thank you. Chief, would you care to address? Please. I kind of go big picture and try to answer a couple of the comments that I heard through coming from the board.
48:31 Um, again, Alex Tumor, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. So, I've been involved with this plan for about a year as well. I think the timelines get a little blurry because there's a lot of them. Um, just kind of big picture to like you alluded to, um, when you have an emergency, the costs get astronomical and that's where prevention is critical. Um, I just looked up the end fire, which we had up by Mona Lake. That was a relatively small fire, um, six million dollars. Uh, when you start looking at
49:00 These incidents, like what we had in the winter of 23, those are $100 million incidents. The way that it generally works is if you have a local emergency, you kind of own it. If you can get the state to declare that an emergency, they pick up 75% of that. So you take a $100 million emergency, they pick up 75. You're still on the, you owe 25 million, so it's still significant numbers. Once it gets to the federal level, what ends up happening is they pick up the 75%.
49:30 The state picks up 75% of the 25%, so locally you're on the hook for about 6%. So it becomes much more manageable to be dealing with these incidents. And ultimately, you know, this is one of those things you have to have in place for those things to be occurring. But then you had several accidents that just appeared this year in southern states, in eastern states, where they had horrific floods and people dying and structures. And administration absolutely refused to pay.
50:00 Come and help. So it's, I feel with it on a paper and in a great world, it's absolutely how it should be. But with current administration, which is in place for, you know, at least another three years, if shit hits a fan, the chances they're going to pick up that 75% check are, like I said, I would rather bet on...
50:22 Snowstorm coming in September and covering the whole mountain. So just to make it real for us, last year, the fire district got reimbursed about half a million dollars for equipment that it sent out to support other incidents across the state. FEMA just said they're going to reduce that amount by 30 percent. So that means that if those incidents occur next year, we would bring back about 350,000. So it absolutely has significant impacts.
50:46 The reality is there's some things you can control and some things you can't control, right? So I would say that we should work, like you mentioned, on the things we can control, which is, frankly, prevention. These are incredibly difficult issues. It took us about 100 years to get into this wildfire mess that we're in today. We're not going to fix it in a year. We've made, as a community, some significant strides. I think, you know, I really have to kind of highlight the work of Lightbark and what's getting done. If any of you had a chance to...
51:14 Go up to Panorama Dome, take a look around the bluffs or up by the knolls. The work that's getting done there is frankly amazing. Same thing's happening in community. I understand that it would be ideal if it happened quicker, but it takes a little bit of time to kind of stand these programs up and get them to where they need to be. The reality is, if you ask me an honest answer, I'd say probably 80% of our properties have something that they need to do to kind of be in.
51:43 Wildland compliance. The state is looking at zero to five as essentially having no vegetation. I'd encourage you when you leave this meeting to drive through town and every condo complex going down Meridian has trees right up against it. The difficult thing is, you know, those are five thousand plus dollar trees to remove. So when you start looking at the true impacts of that, it's going to be a significant challenge. Now it's still much better than the impact of having
52:13 A wildfire come through here and distress economically. So we do have to keep making strong incremental progress. And I think we are starting to do that. And there's going to be a report before town council in December to show what's getting done. So I'd encourage you to view that. But again, I think this report is important because it does give us exactly these venues. We can have these discussions. There are some really good things that come from them.
52:42 Like Nolan mentioned, some of the things that are unique to us, like propane, if we can get funding to help with those, that's going to be helpful. But these are, you know, long strategic problems that we have to deal with. Any other questions I can answer? And just to clarify, between Pam and you, Chief, regardless of the decisions that are made on the federal level, we are ineligible for any sort of support on a federal level if we do not have this plan in place.
53:11 Correct. Yes. And so, and one other thing I'll highlight real quick. A lot of the other smaller districts didn't have a chance to apply for this. What that means is if there's a disaster, the county can still apply for things or the town can still apply on their behalf or on behalf of those communities. What they can't do is start programs of their own. So, for example,
53:31 Mammoth Lakes Fire has a CAL FIRE grant that has supported our Defensible Space Program. If you want a federal one of those programs, it would be difficult. Essentially, those districts could apply for those. But that doesn't mean that the county could apply on their behalf. Got it. Any other questions for staff or while we have the chief up at the podium? Yeah, two. I had a quick question, Pam. Does it make a difference to
53:58 So I'm just wondering if that is, is that something that would benefit to just keep adding as, as community, as.
54:28 Those small communities receive that. Oh, I was going to say, it definitely is. And there is a strategy that I believe reads, at least for the Mammoth kind of annex, which is encourage the development of Firewise community and working at that neighborhood level. So it's, you know, it's in there. Firewise is unique because it's kind of outside of like the town and the fire district. It's, you know, truly at that neighborhood level.
54:55 And so it's not something that the town can step in and say, hey, we're going to go and develop firewise communities, but we're definitely there to, you know, help and support communities and spread the word and advocate for communities to develop firewise communities. Okay.
55:11 If I could just delve into that. So especially from the wildfire side of that's a unique hazard for us and across the nation. The hazard mitigation plan is one plan. The other big one is the CWPP. A lot of times when you're applying for grants, it's the community wildfire protection plan. That one is getting redone kind of in parallel. We're going to do a quick update to it just to be eligible for
55:35 Block grants, you know, large amounts of money coming from the state from Prop 4. Ultimately, the goal on that one is to create what's called a dynamic CWPP. Truckee has a really good one if you want to look at one. And what that gives you is almost like a dashboard where you can look at your community and look at what the risk is. And then as you're putting these projects into place and reducing your risk, you start to see that risk getting brought down through the modeling. So if the community adds a Firewise community and has, you know, a reduction in the ladder fuels, you'll actually see them maybe go from like
56:04 A red to an orange as they're making their community a little safer. So ideally you want kind of a living, breathing document to really show exactly what you're referring to. Cool. And then, Alex, I just, I think it's important too to point out what the fire district did this summer with regard to going to different neighborhoods and having the big bins so that people could put their pine needles and their shrubs and stuff that they took off their properties and put them in those bins. And then also the chipping, you know, the chipping.
56:34 In different areas, I think is extremely important too. And I think that, you know, you need to tut your horn a little bit more. Yeah, so that'll be at the town council meeting, I believe in December. Mike McCarthy would have all the numbers, but we were working obviously closely with the town and White Park and a couple other organizations. We did, we broke the town into thirds and our goal was to get through 1,500 occupancies. We got through 2,000 starting that process of
57:01 Going to the homeowners and kind of starting with a carrot and slowly moving towards the stake on making sure that these properties are getting dealt with. So it's a pretty long report. I don't want to make the board go through all of this today, but I'd encourage you to watch that town council meeting because it'll show there's actually quite a bit that's occurring in the community through various groups. It's all really good. Again, it's going to take more than a year, but I feel good that we're moving in a positive direction. Thank you. Well, I appreciate your efforts. Thanks.
57:30 Any other questions for staff or chief while we have them up here or any thoughts, opinions? I don't know who that would be to the town of Fire. Is there a reason why we do not have or we're not implementing because it's really costing us nothing that the vacant lots have to do a cleanup of the lot every year?
57:56 Say at the beginning of summer, right before, you know, all the heat starts like say June, so all of those lots are shrub and dry needles and everything free and if they not, you know, it's another opportunity for town to make passive money from the fines to those lots while trying to make the town safer.
58:21 Is there a reason we don't have something like that in place? Well, you did that. Yeah, I can answer that on a little bit. So, and again, different people have different philosophies on how to approach these problems. Most communities have kind of started with the carrots and then eventually moved to the sticks. The hard thing is, where do you draw the line? Like I said, if you go down Meridian, do you tell every basically complex that they have to remove all their trees? If you really look at the CALFAR standards,
58:48 Your trees are supposed to have spacing between them in communities. We have this tough thing, whereas we are a town within the trees, I believe is one of the sayings, and there's challenges there in the sense that that makes for difficult fire spread. So ultimately a huge part of kind of long-term fixes to this problem is home hardening.
59:11 Which is essentially what we're seeing in new buildings. New buildings aren't built of wood, they're built of hardwood. If they are wood, they have enough layers there to where they're not going to be part of the problem. So as much as the lot next door to you can impact your structure, the reality is if your lot and structure are well taken care of, you should be doing relatively well when a fire comes through. So it really does come down to a little bit of a philosophical question of
59:37 Do we single out those properties when in reality it may not impact when a fire does come through here? I don't disagree with you that they need to get cleaned up. I think that's part of the, you know, you're spot on on quite a few things. You mentioned the woodpecker. We had a project that we worked at Camp High Sierra where we got pushed back by two weeks because we didn't do a frog survey. We ended up doing the frog survey and we got to the work. But it is a, I think what we're experiencing is kind of a
1:00:04 Changing culture that takes a little bit of time. And frankly, that is the harder part of getting us to where we need to be is getting people to recognize what the true problems are and how do you get to those solutions. And unfortunately, they're not cheap. It's going to take a little bit of work. But yes, it is being discussed. Well, and just on a side, when you mentioned the carrot versus the stick, years ago when the fire district was going around to people's homes and then sending letters,
1:00:34 You know, the letters were, they were a little bit more threatening in the sense that if you do not do this and do not comply by this certain time, there will be fines. And I think that that is sort of a negative way, which is not what you guys are doing now. And then for years, I don't think that you had the grant money to continue that, those physical assessments, whereas this year you guys started it back up, which I think is great. And the letters are more, there's, you know, with that website, I understand from Mike that it's...
1:01:01 The real pain on your end to input all that information and the photos and such, but as a homeowner, it's such a great tool and I think it's such a benefit to see because then you can actually see, oh yeah, that tree is touching. I see what they're talking about. I see why that's important. So I think, and then there isn't that threat there that, oh, if you don't comply, but then again, the following year, it's like, you know, let's send another letter and because that one person isn't going to ruin it for everybody, I don't think.
1:01:31 Yeah, I guess say the negative and the benefit to being, and I'll frankly say as a community, we're a little late to the game, but that we have people that we can look at who are doing this right. Again, I'm going to point to Truckee. They've done a couple few things. They passed Measure T a few years ago. That's really helped them stand their program up. We're using essentially the same software that really lets us track what's occurring in the community and are people actually making the changes. So you're correct. As we send these mailers out and send these emails that
1:01:59 Give people an actual view of their properties. We can track where we're having impacts and not. And those have historically shown to be the most effective in actually creating that change in that production of fuels. Thank you, Chief. Any other questions for staff or the Chief? Any thoughts, opinions? No? I'm going to throw it out to Nolan. Did you want to say something? I'm sorry. I was just going to reiterate kind of, you know, in
1:02:28 Your review or the public's review, because obviously everyone has limited time to dedicate to this, I would recommend everyone focus their review on the town's specific annex and then the hazards within that and really reviewing it through the lens of are there any missing hazards that aren't in that annex that should be in it or additional mitigation strategies or actions that could be added to any of those hazards.
1:02:58 Obviously nobody has the time other than kind of staff to review it with a fine-tooth comb. What we know is everything spelled right like that, but really looking at it of what is missing from that, the town's annex. And then if you do have time, you can review the base plan. It is roughly 500 pages, the base plan, but it does have a lot of information kind of diving deeper into what those hazards are, defining those hazards. So you can kind of use it more like a reference document as you're looking through the town's annex. Got it. Thank you.
1:03:27 With that, I'll ask if there's any public comment here at Suite Z on the hazard mitigation plan for the town and slash county. None? Angie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? No comments at this time. Well, great presentation. Thank you, Chief, for taking the time this morning and walking us through some of the answers to some of the questions that we had.
1:03:54 Pam, will we be kind of kept abreast of the progress of this as it goes forward or do we lose this to town council from this point on? We will not bring forward any additional agenda items on this matter. However, if you're interested in the status, I could certainly come to a public comment at one of your future meetings once there's something to report. Okay, that'd be great. Thank you, Pam, appreciate it. With that, we'll move on to the consent agenda. We have...
1:04:24 One item to approve the minutes of the October 8th, 2025 meeting, PEDC meeting. Does anybody have any edits they'd like to put forth or do I have a motion? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes on October 8th, 2025. Do we have a second? I second. We have a motion, we have a second. Angie, may we have a vote, please. Commissioner Deaver? Yes. Commissioner Ground? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck?
1:04:54 Yes. And Vice Chair Vanderhurst, excuse me, Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Thank you. Cassandra Agenda is approved. With that, we'll go to Commissioner Reports. I'll start on my right. Commissioner Deaver, do you have something you would like to report? I do not at this time. Commissioner Verruck. So Commissioner Fleming and I attended the ADP meeting a couple weeks ago where the same group that is doing Rock Spring.
1:05:21 is moving forward, and they presented the, oh my gosh, I forgot what it's called. 474 Joaquin. Yeah, Joaquin. So it's Joaquin and Minaret. And then they also presented the wood site. So the ADP gave a couple recommendations, some changing of some design elements, some roof lines were kind of funky. So we don't necessarily, I don't think we're necessarily having to re-
1:05:50 To meet, to go over everything. I think they're just going to email us the changes. So that should be coming to us in the next few months. Got it. Those two projects. Thank you for representing this body in that design review. Commissioner Grand, any report you'd like to submit? No, sir. I'll just jump in here really quickly. I would like to let the community know that, first of all, I don't know how the volleyball team did last night, the high school volleyball team. They won.
1:06:19 So if you're not familiar, the girls high school volleyball team is in the state championship tournament. They won last night. I do believe they're hosting the next round, right? Yes, they swept last night, and then next matchup is tomorrow night. Tomorrow night here at Mammoth High School Gymnasium. So if you do have the ability to attend and support.
1:06:44 Our kids, that'd be fantastic. The other thing, and it's a little bit more near and dear to my heart, is the Mammoth High football team. We'll be playing playoff game number two on the road this Friday night down in Ridgecrest against Emmanuel Christian, and it is the only team that beat Mammoth during the regular season, so rematch is on tap.
1:07:08 I believe that's a 7pm kickoff in Ridgecrest. There is a group of parents that is organizing carpool for anyone who may be interested in going, whether you're a student or whether you're an adult. I understand the last time we played them during the regular season, the ratio of representation for them against the parents that were there for Mammoth was very skewed.
1:07:31 So it'd be great to have some support if you can make it happen. So whether it's the high school girls volleyball team or the Mammoth High School boys football team, go Huskies. And with that, we'll go to the director's report. Great. So one item to provide an update on before Brianna sneaks out is Brianna and I did meet earlier this month, I believe, on discussing the upcoming development of the Economic Development Subcommittee.
1:08:01 Some more to come on that at a future meeting, but kind of the initial thoughts that we had were to include two planning commissioners, as well as two chamber members, and then obviously Brianna and myself, and then kind of, you know, depending on the topics of the meeting, we can invite other business members or communities to kind of meetings as they'll occur. Some more to come on that, but it is still in the works on the development of it.
1:08:28 I don't want to commit myself too hard to say that it'd be ready for December, but it's definitely working on the development of that. Some more to come there. Talking about some current status of projects. So the ongoing Mammoth Creek Inn. So they have received sign-off from the Planning Division, Public Works Division, I believe the Fire Division. I think they had one correction before, which is to add an additional stripe in the parking lot.
1:08:55 But then I know they're working through some minor corrections from the building division just on their kind of final sign-off for those buildings. So they are getting closer, which is exciting. I'd love to stop talking about that project at some point.
1:09:11 The other kind of ongoing project, 540 Commercial Building, they are submitting for a variance to make some minor tweaks to the front to not have the ADA ramp building and public works. Met with the applicant and planning team and they agreed that it really would create a hardship to have that out there for snow removal and other purposes.
1:09:33 The developer is submitting for variance. I know we met end of last week with a planning team on a few minor corrections as to kind of get feedback from the town on any additional changes to that facade along Old Mammoth Road so that I know hopefully that it's going to get submitted this week. There's really minor changes that he was making to that. No updates on Sierra Center Mall other than their building permit will expire on December 31st.
1:10:03 And then lastly on the housing front, the town council voted last week at last week's meeting to commit $7.2 million to the Kingfisher 2.2 projects. That's the second phase of phase two.
1:10:23 So that would be an additional 72 units. The developer Pacific West Communities is being considered for an award from the state of approximately $42 million later this month. So should that project be awarded, they would then begin construction in the spring. So that's an additional 72 units. It's kind of if you drive through the site right now, you see the four buildings under construction adjacent to Tavern Road and
1:10:54 And gosh, what's the other extension there? And Shady Rest Row, Tavern Shady Rest, and so it would be behind that, more adjacent to the businesses on that side, so it would complete that phase. As part of that commitment on the funding, the town council did direct staff to negotiate with Pacific West communities on an amendment and or termination of the development agreement we have with them for the future phases.
1:11:22 So really that the goal of that amendment is to kind of free up the remaining areas of the parcel to allow us to kind of focus on more missing middle housing in that. So the goal would be bring a missing middle rental project for those remaining phases that would kind of support and complement the lower AMI phases because between phase one and phase two we'll have approximately 230 units for 80 percent.
1:11:48 below AMI, we're really not doing anything yet for rental in those higher AMIs, which we've heard loud and clear from the business community is a needed component. So we're looking at, you know, how we work to free up that land, you know, and it's potentially continuing to work with Pacific, but just on a different type of housing or hitting a different target as well.
1:12:13 More to come on that as we work through that, but I know council's desire was to see the completion of phase two and then really look how can we build higher AMIs on the other remaining portions. How much is left on that? Acreage wise? Like how many more units would you be able to? Approximately another about 300 per the master plan. The master plan allows a little over 500 units out there and with 230 done so we can.
1:12:42 Potentially have about another 250, 270 units. For the middle. Yep. That's amazing. And that's at maximum density, you know, you can obviously build anything less than that, but it's looking just, you know, what other opportunities are there to really, you know, target that demographic community that we're not currently, you know, serving or building housing for that might make too much to qualify at the parcel, but can't afford market rates. Thank you, Noah.
1:13:11 With that, I will adjourn today's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which will be in this room on December 10th, 9 a.m. Thank you, everyone. I appreciate your participation and your attendance. Thank you, staff. Oh, Angie. Angie. So bougie. Yeah, there's no name tags.