TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 14:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

132 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:03 Jamie, do you have any intel on Mojave? They must be a pretty good squad. James and Andrew and Charlie went to the first half of the Friday night game. We beat Lone Pine. Lone Pine beat Mojave the first time, but then they lost to Mojave this last game. We think it's doable for us. Oh, that's good. Hopefully my absence wasn't the good luck charm. I don't want to get cocky, but it's looking good.

0:40 Jamie, do we have any members of the public in Suite Z with you? No, we do not. Michael, before we start, I was going to ask if we could take one item out of order. Let's see. I thought it might be nice to let Phil do his presentation before all the other presentations. So if we could move item 6.3 to the first business matter, that might help for Phil once we get down to that spot. Hi, Phil. Hi.

1:15 Thank you. That's a very nice consideration. I appreciate that. No problem. But you're, Phil, you're welcome to stay for the entire meeting and learn about the parcel and other things we're doing here at the town. Thank you. Thank you. I definitely have a full calendar today. Yes, I figured as much. Okay. And I did, Michael, connect with all the other commissioners, so I think everyone should be on except for Commissioner Burroughs. Got it.

1:49 Thanks for doing that, Sandra. Sure. Good afternoon, Commissioner Chang. Chair, what's happening? Can you hear me? I can. Loud and clear, bud. What's going on with the tourism side of the business? We are getting a lot of favorable press on the early snow conditions here domestically and internationally. So hopefully that translates to a very, very healthy ski season. There's Commissioner Eckert. Good to see you, Greg.

2:53 See your box, I should say. Can you hear us, Commissioner Eckert? So we can't hear you if you're speaking. It looks like you're unmuted, but maybe your computer itself is muted. So Sandra, I've got two o'clock, but I don't want to call this to order until we at least have audio from Greg or until Jessica jumps in. It doesn't really feel like a quorum if we don't have participation from him. True, yes. Okay, there's Commissioner.

3:53 There's Commissioner Kennedy. So I'm going to go ahead and call this to order. Did Greg? Greg's there, but we're still connecting to audio. Yeah. Okay. So I'm going to call the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for November 10th to order. Jamie, may we please have a roll call? Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert might still be trying to connect. Commissioner Kennedy? Here.

4:27 Vice Chair Burroughs is absent. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you, Jamie. Now, if everyone would like to stand, I'll lead us in a pledge of allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag, the United States of America, to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, everyone. I'd like to invite either staff or members of the public to address the commission with public comments now.

4:59 I will ask if somebody does have a public comment that is related to a matter on our agenda, if you will wait until that agenda item is brought forth. So I believe there is nobody in suite Z to give us public comment in person. Do we have any written public comment, Jamie? No, we do not. Okay. And I'm assuming that Jenna would love to address us now. So Jenna, the floor is yours.

5:29 Thank you. Jenna Carter with Code Compliance of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Last we met, we went over stats, which was only about a week or so ago, so I'm going to actually skip stats this time, but Chair Vanderhurst did ask for an update on Mammoth Creek Inn and that project, so I have an update for you all. There have been some issues with the addendums and inspections. Work has been stopped and started several times, if you all have noticed.

5:56 I have this from our permit technician. She said the Mammoth Creek Inn submitted an addendum to their plans early June 2021, and these plans were reviewed and approved by the town. We haven't been able to issue the addendum because of the fire and water district's approvals missing. Water district's approval did just come in in October, October 21st, so late October, but we are waiting for the approval from the fire district, so we cannot issue the addendum to...

6:23 Allow them to proceed until the fire district approves that addendum. That's the update on the Mammoth Creek Inn if anyone has any questions about that project. Thank you, Jenna. Do any members of the commission have any questions for Jenna? Quick question, Jenna. Do you have any idea if, you know, the weather is about to turn pretty bad for building here soon? And as anyone who, when you drive by the project, it's very, very exposed to the elements.

6:52 Do you have any idea if they're planning on buttoning up the project until the spring, or are they just going to let it ride as is? We've made recommendations for them to wrap it up and waterproof it. At this point, they're in charge of their project, so we've given them our recommendations to help preserve the property. If it does get to a certain point to where the integrity is in question, I believe the building official and I would discuss that in detail.

7:21 We've talked about possibly requiring like more engineering or something to prove that the structure, the integrity of the building hasn't been compromised at all. Yeah, but to your point, we agree. We do want them to waterproof the building as well before this storm or before this winter. Thank you, Jenna. Thank you. Any other comments or questions for Jenna, guys? If not, she's very busy. We'll let her go. Thanks for the update, Jenna. We appreciate it. Thank you all. Have a great meeting. I'm not seeing Hayes. Are you here to

7:52 provide public comment or are you just kind of ghost riding the meeting? I'm just here to answer questions. There's a question. Sandra, I don't see any other staff presentations for public comment. Am I missing somebody? Nope, I think you've got everyone. Thank you. Okay, then I'm going to close the public hearing and is this the point where you'd like to adjust the agenda?

8:17 Or have us adjust the agenda. Sandra? Sure, that would be great. And the staff just would request that the council consider moving item 6.3 as to driver recruitment before item 6.1 on business matters. This will just allow Phil Morris to provide his presentation before the other items and will allow him to get on for the rest of his day. So if the commission is amenable to that, you can, I think, approve it by just consensus.

8:47 I think we're all there. So we will move item 6.3 to this point in the agenda above 5.1 and 6.1, 6.2. So Phil, floor is yours. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, commissioners. Yeah, Phil Moores, Executive Director for Eastern Sierra Transit. I was asked to give a brief presentation to you all today about

9:14 The struggles we're having with driver recruitment and how that might affect transportation throughout the town this winter. We're having our second recruitment failure, basically, I guess I'd say. In the spring, we did not get the drivers we needed to operate at 100% in Reds Meadow. Instead of the usual, you know, 10 buses, we were only able to run about five. So we were only able to operate at half capacity.

9:44 This winter, we're facing similar problems. The town trolley is going to be reduced from 20-minute headways to 30-minute headways. And we expect that there'll be longer wait times because we don't have the drivers to send out additional service for visitors in town from the lodges and different places. So, you know, that's kind of what we're facing.

10:14 What I'm doing about it is working with Dan and Hayes with the town, working with the Mountain, working with the City of Bishop, working with the Forest Service, all our partners to bolster our revenue for the spring so that we can get back on track with recruiting drivers. It's become a very competitive, like many of you know, it's become a very competitive marketing hiring market.

10:44 So, yeah, I'm going to go to my board this Friday and ask to open the MOU for the Driver Association early and negotiate with them to try and improve the position and hopefully attract those very few people. I found out today that Moz purchased by Co-West, it's not Go-West, it's Co-West, like Colorado.

11:10 They purchase Moz and will begin shuttle service from Bishop Airport to Mammoth, utilizing, I think, 15 passenger E350s, a really nice looking shuttle van with a capacity of about 15 or so people, I'm thinking. And if we get 70 people on a plane, it's going to take, they're going to need three or four vans at least.

11:36 to load and carry. So they are recruiting for drivers as well. And they're a new player on the field looking for drivers. So it's going to be an interesting winner. But I think they just wanted me to warn you and kind of let you know what to expect and if you have any ideas on how to improve the situation. You've got my written presentation. If anybody has any questions for me, I'd be happy to field those. Thank you, Phil. Appreciate it.

12:07 Any questions for Phil at this time from the commission? A quick question, please. Ms. Morris, is this simply just because of pay? I can barely hear you, sir. Can you hear me now? Is that better? Yeah, I can hear you, Paul. Okay. Is it simply because of pay or is it that people don't want to work? Well, I mean, there's no question that the market pool has shrunk.

12:48 And why or where they are, I'm not exactly sure. There was some conjecture about unemployment benefits being available and whether or not, you know, when that ended, things have improved, but it really hasn't. I think as I look around, Moz, that company, hold on just a second, I'm going to see why my dogs are going nuts. The new reality of our lives, huh?

13:27 Oh, what's going on? Oh, it's the delivery guy. Let me just FedEx, I'll tell you. Sorry about that. No worries. Yeah, so we're doing a, we're really looking at the whole, the whole job, the whole branding and marketing ideas. I've talked to Jessica, matter of fact, hi Jessica, about, you know, what we can do to help attract and retain drivers. We're looking at a job sharing program with the town right now.

13:56 That would help us bridge the shoulder seasons and provide a full-time position instead of seasonal workers. Anybody that can reduce the dependence on seasonal workers is doing the right thing. If we can hire more local people who already have a place to live and need a job, and if we have to increase the benefits or make it more full-time, then I think that's a good strategy for us. So I'm working with the town on that program.

14:24 But as far as a wage is concerned, Walmart came out and said that their average wage is about what we're starting drivers at, so we can't let that stand because of the responsibilities that a driver has in relation to a retail employee. Moz came in at $22 an hour or $22.50. They're offering their drivers to start, which is like $5 an hour more than where we're at. So, yeah, we've got real competition, even places like McDonald's and other places are.

14:54 They're up in their game, and I think wages will help. That's my best effort on this. You know, to follow up on that, if I'm hearing correctly, or maybe reading between the lines, there is a, potentially, we could, the transportation could be reduced by 50%, is that what I'm hearing this winter? Not overall, just...

15:23 From a 20-minute service to 30-minute service. So it's not going to be reduced by 50%. It would be, you know, maybe a third for the town. But the real, I think the real problem is going to be when we have passenger surges, like at the end of the night when the lodges close, when the slopes close, or when everyone's getting up and getting out in the morning to get to the slopes, we usually put trippers out.

15:52 And we don't have the drivers for that this time. And so we're not going to have the extra capacity. It's going to increase the wait time. That's the, in a normal year, carries around 900,000 trips in the town of Mammoth Lakes a year. And so if we can't do a third of that, you've got to think there's going to be more cars, there's going to be more wait times, more congestion.

16:17 And I don't mean to, I'm not just trying to say it's, we're all, it's all doom and gloom and we're in big trouble. I'm not trying to say that. I'm just trying to say, expect to maybe get some comments. Commissioners might hear from the public about, you know, wait times or, you know, different transportation services not being as available as normal. Just, I think this is more preparing you for what we're facing this winter.

16:49 You know, dim and gloom type of thing. It's just a matter of, you know, we need to be realistic with our expectations. So I just want to understand the numbers. That's all. Thank you. Yeah, you're welcome. Any other questions for Phil from the commission? I have a question. Yeah, Phil. Go ahead, Greg. Just to dig down into this a little more detail, either in exit interviews or unsuccessful new interviews, have you been getting

17:19 Direct comments from the drivers and potential involved that this just isn't cutting it for them pay-wise or, you know, they don't like the public or, you know, I sort of wouldn't want to go out in the employment market with a $5 an hour handicap, but, you know, that's just sort of, you know, on a table in a notebook somewhere. But in terms of actual conversations, has that been

17:48 A common point brought up. The point that the wage is insufficient? Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I have bus operators living in their vehicles, you know, and, you know, it can be tough, the entry-level stuff, and they can't afford housing. That's why the parcel is such an important project for me.

18:18 Because the seasonal workers and the people that work at the grocery stores and drive your buses, they can't buy those houses, you know, and so it's, I think that might be one of the largest reasons why we're not seeing a big seasonal influx is that they don't have any place that they can stay and the wage is not quite as much as it needs to be for them to survive out here.

18:44 So yeah, I've had some conversations with my drivers about that. They've given me that feedback. As far as exit interviews, yeah, they leave for money. They also leave for job difficulty. Driving a bus in the winter in Mammoth can be a daunting thing to do. Or driving up and down Reds Meadow Road in a 40-foot bus fully loaded with people with like 50 people on board. So it's a hard job.

19:14 And so if they can find the same money in a job that's not as difficult, that's sometimes that's what they're looking for. I had a conversation recently with someone about that. So yeah, it needs to, we need to catch up. I think Esther needs to catch up with his wages and the town has been a great partner. The mountain has too. And I anticipate things are going to improve over the next year, but it takes time to do these things. Thank you, Phil. Yeah, thank you, Phil.

19:45 Jessica, I think you had a question or comment? Yeah, I think Greg's pretty much covered it, so no questions on my end. I appreciate you being here, Phil, and I think this is a really, it makes me think about the holistic, you know.

20:02 Things that we're working on in this town specifically of walk, bike, ride and the parcel development based on, you know, having lower parking in the parcel because we can use public transportation. And I think this is a really critical issue that could really jeopardize our town in our future if we don't figure out. So I appreciate you bringing it here and sending the best energy and good to hear from you. So thank you. Yeah, you bet. You're welcome.

20:27 Yeah, transportation in the survey. I don't know who did the survey, whether it was MLT or someone, but public transportation came very high for visitors. They liked it. It was free. It got them where they needed to go and maintain that. Hey, Phil, quick question from me and then we'll let you go. Could you just really briefly summarize what COVID precautions are going to be in place this upcoming winter? I know you had some in place this last summer and the previous winter.

20:56 Yeah, the mask mandate, of course, continues on public transit. Everyone on the home is required to wear a mask. We have purchased a lot of equipment that we continue to use today. We went through probably about 75 gallons of what's called vital oxide. It's an antiviral spray.

21:21 liquid that we used, we atomize it through sprayers on the bus, and we have a backpack, and we walk, we go through the bus, and we spray it with that. The loading has not been, is not restricted again, so loading is normal, and that's the only complaint I got in the summer was loading. People are still not comfortable being so close together on public transit. That's kind of a part of the deal with public transit is sitting next to one another.

21:50 And some people were uncomfortable. I mean, maybe I got 10 complaints out of almost 40,000 rides. So it's not like a lot, but we're sensitive to whatever happens. There won't be load restrictions unless it's mandated again by the state. So that could result in some comments. Thank you, Phil. Appreciate it. Any other questions or comments, guys? I think we will let you go, Phil. We appreciate your time in the presentation. Fingers crossed for this upcoming winter.

22:23 Yeah. Thank you, everyone. And thank you, Sandra, for letting me come up front. You're welcome. Of course. All right. We're going to jump back into our regular agenda. We'll go public hearing. Item 5.1. It's a public hearing in consideration of a variance request to permit an 83% reduction of the required 20-foot front yard setback for the construction of an attached

22:48 Two-car garage with a bathroom, laundry and storage area located in the front of an existing single-family residence at 388 Ridgecrest Drive. The project is reviewed under application number VAR21-002 and is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to guidelines 15301.

23:15 E and existing facilities. And I believe Nolan, no, Kim is our staff contact on this one. Yes, thank you, Chairman Vanderhurst. I'm going to share my screen. If you could, that is weird. All right. Yeah, there you go. Thank you. Okay, do you all see the full screen? Yeah.

24:12 We see your, well, I see your presenter, you're in presenter mode, so we can see your notes and everything in the next slide. I don't know how to get it out of presenter mode. Let me just swap my screens. Okay, how's that? Yep, that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, so we have our variance application.

24:52 The property owner of 388 Ridgecrest Drive is requesting a variance for an 83% reduction of the required 20-foot front setback, which would allow for a 3-foot, 4-inch front setback for the construction of a two-car garage for the bathroom, laundry, and storage area. As a refresher, variances are intended to allow modifications to the development standards of the zoning code.

25:20 Only when because of special circumstances applicable to the property, including the size, shape, topography, location or surroundings, the strict application of the zoning code deprives the property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the vicinity and under the identical zoning. 388 Ridgecrest Drive is located in a residential single-family zoning district and the existing single-family residence was constructed in 1979 without a garage.

25:54 The building area of the site, which consists of the area outside of the required setbacks, it slopes downward from the street at an approximately 43.6% slope. In the staff report, I noted 41%, but after recalculating the slope of the lot several times, I found that it was greater than 41%. 43.6% was more consistent.

26:22 Town's zoning code does allow for reduced front setbacks of five feet on garages on lots with steep upslope of a minimum of 35%. A similar prescribed setback reduction is not available for steep downward sloping lots, which is why this variance is required. So on this slide, I'm providing photos to illustrate the topography of the site.

26:51 The first photo is of the rear of the house, taken from Canyon Boulevard, thanks to Google Maps. The other photos are of the east side of the existing residence, and I think that does a pretty good job of illustrating the slope. And these site photos include the west side of the residence in the lower right-hand corner.

27:19 The front of the rest, the front of the residence, as well as the significant 40-inch diameter Jeffrey Pine, which the applicant wants to preserve. And you can see that the property owner is using a trailer sort of as to provide for their storage needs in lieu of a garage.

27:44 So the requested 83% reduction of the front setback would enable the applicant to add a two-car garage with accessory storage and bathroom directly in front of the existing residents. The proposed interior dimensions of the garage are 18 feet 2 inches in depth and 37.5 feet in width, which provides a minimum interior parking space dimensions of 9 feet by 18 feet.

28:11 The total size of the garage is 728 square feet and it does not include any conditioned living space. The proposed design of the garage is compatible with the design of the existing home and the design incorporates two single car garage doors, two pedestrian doors on either side, several windows and a rooftop deck. The overall height of the

28:36 garage at the new roof ridge line is 13 feet. The applicable development standards for residential zoning districts require the slope of a building site not to exceed 30 percent and exceeding that standard would mean that extensive grading and engineering would be necessary for an addition placed within the steeply sloped portion of the lot.

29:02 The average slope of the building site for this lot, like I said, is 43.6%, which would mean that locating the garage farther back on the property could be cost prohibitive and it's not practical given the scope of the proposed project. The placement of the garage utilizes the most level portion of the site and ensures that the garage doors would be located no closer than 20 feet to the edge of roadway pavement.

29:34 so that two exterior parking spaces are maintained within the existing driveway, and those parking spaces provide the minimum exterior parking space dimensions of 10 feet by 20 feet. The two exterior spaces in the driveway will encroach into approximately 16 feet into the town right-of-way, so the Public Works Department will require a hold harmless agreement.

30:01 This was included as a condition of approval in the draft resolution number 25. And following the execution of a hold harmless agreement, the proposed parking configuration would allow the property to meet the applicable requirements for both enclosed and exterior parking for single family residential uses. In all other aspects, the proposed development does meet the applicable development standards for the zone.

30:32 As part of the application, the applicant has also indicated that by locating the garage in front of the existing single-family residents, they are able to preserve the existing 40-inch diameter Jeffrey Pine at the front of the lot. So this slide provides an example of our standard for calculating average slope for building site. The lot slope is calculated as an average slope of the ground area within the required setback lines.

31:05 which is referred to as the buildable site area. And it is based on the existing grade of the site. And this slide illustrates the average slope calculation used to arrive at the 43.6% average slope of the building site. The slope is expressed as a percentage and represents a comparison of the average vertical rise to its average vertical run.

31:38 So a public notice for this project was published in the sheet on Saturday, October 30th and Saturday, November 6th. Notices were also mailed on Wednesday, October 27th to 71 property owners within a 300 foot radius of the project site. One public comment was received in response to the notice and I believe that all our commissioners received it as well. In summary, the comment

32:07 stated that the property owners who live directly across the street from the site had reviewed the staff report and project drawings and wish to voice support for the project. And they indicated that the site does have constraints as outlined in the staff report that requires modification of the front yard setback in order to build a functional garage facing the street.

32:32 So that was the only public comment that we've received thus far on the application. So based on the analysis of the project that's provided in the staff report and the variance findings for approval that have been drafted, staff recommends the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached plan.

32:55 Adopt the attached resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving variance number 21-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. That concludes my presentation. I believe I see the applicant, Josh Feinberg, in suite Z.

33:19 So I'm available to answer any questions. And if you want to direct any questions to Josh, it does look like he's available as well. Thank you, Kim. I appreciate that. I think I'll hold off on any commission questions at this time and give Josh a chance to address the commission if he would like to. And Josh, it's good to see you. Hey, thank you all for considering this application. I really appreciate it, Kim. Thanks for giving such a great presentation. I think she covered...

33:48 A lot of the points there. As she said, it's quite a steep lot and building on the inside of it would be pretty expensive and cost prohibitive and that beautiful tree would have to go. And so our best alternative was to try to build it in front and still basically build as big a garage as we can but still maintaining enough room to park in front of it so we'd still have the same amount of outdoor parking as we do now.

34:15 I think it would also make the front of the house look a lot better than a white travel trailer. So I think the neighborhood and the neighbors would appreciate a better looking facade and front area of the house, which I think it will be greatly improved by this new design and fit much more with the neighbors and the neighborhood. Yeah, happy to answer any questions. Thanks very much. Thanks, Josh. We appreciate it. I'll open it up to the commission right now. Does anybody have any questions for Kim or for the applicant? Josh? No?

34:49 Greg, you don't have your video on, so I can't see if you're shaking your head no questions or not. No, I got one, and it's probably a nothing burger anyway, but is there something in the code that would prevent them in the future from converting this garage into a living unit that takes up the parking space? I got no problem giving the variance to the garage, but if down the line it got converted into a living space,

35:19 And we're giving up the variance for that. That's something I wouldn't be comfortable with. So, Kim, that might be for you. There isn't language in the accessory dwelling unit ordinance that would prohibit them from converting area within the garage into a living unit in the future. We could probably include some language in the conditions of approval.

35:52 But based on the state's requirements encouraging secondary dwelling units or accessory dwelling units, I'm not sure if that would be legal or if that would hold up. Sandra, do you have any input on that? Yeah, I can provide just kind of a little bit of an update, but Commissioner Eckert, I think you're aware that the state has made a lot of changes to the accessory dwelling unit requirements and really is pushing

36:26 Pushing communities to allow those. So while I note that Kim, you know, we could include something in the conditions of approval, I don't know if it would actually stand up if it's in conflict with state law. It's, you know, it's our understanding that the applicant at this time isn't looking to, you know, create additional living space. This is really for the garage. But, you know, I think in the future, if they sold the property, there may, it might be able to be converted to

36:54 An accessory dwelling unit. So I think that, you know, there probably isn't an airtight way to keep it from doing that at some point in the future. But we certainly could, you know, we could include, I mean, I don't know if I want to, I mean, I guess without talking to our city attorney, I don't know whether we would want to add a condition of approval on there right now. If the commission as a whole has some concerns about this.

37:21 We could confer with a city attorney and come back with a proposed condition, but that probably wouldn't happen today. Yeah, I'd love to see an accessory dwelling unit built on top of this garage. I think that would be the perfect design, but, you know, one of the reasons we're considering this is to keep the cost down. But I'd just like to see something that if we are going to, you know, alter the rules, that the reason for doing that remains intact. Yeah, and so,

37:54 I mean, Nolan, feel free to pop on if you have any other comments, but I think we don't think that we could put a condition on that to limit that in the future. So it could possibly happen. I think if, you know, the property owner, if they were considering adding an accessory dwelling unit, it sure would make a lot more sense to build up there because then they would still maintain their garage and then they would have that there. But I don't think we could put a condition on it that would

38:24 Prohibit that from occurring in the future. So I think the commission would have to kind of consider this variance with the thought that at some point that might occur, but really knowing that accessory dwelling units and housing units in general are being pushed really hard by the state and are somewhat protected under state law. All right, I'll just leave it to the other commissioners team of the numbers as well.

38:58 Any other questions from the other commissioners? Commissioner Chang, I noticed you turned your audio on. Yeah, I just have a question given the EU conversion actually takes no additional parking required, right? Yes, that's correct. That is a pretty valid point. Think about that. By making this exemption, approving this variance, and this is a big variance, it's not a little variance, and then the homeowner can then later on

39:54 Future homeowners can later on turn this into an ADU. But that ADU has to be, cannot be short-term rentals, right? It has to be long-term. Yes, that's correct. The zoning in this area prohibits short-term rental uses. So just a note about our ADU ordinance. It is very permissive right now.

40:29 You know, I think if, as we're thinking about these types of projects where people are coming forward and adding on a garage or doing these types of things, back in the kind of the back in the older days when ADUs were really, really hard to get approved, there was a lot of requirements for them. We would see a lot of people who would come in with something, you know, maybe a remodel or something like that that would ultimately then be converted into an accessory dwelling unit. But right now our ADU requirements are so permissive that, you know, I don't expect that we're going to be seeing a lot of that kind of

40:58 Bait and Switch type things. So, I mean, with that being said, I think that the commission should consider this project kind of at face value. I think, you know, we would have to analyze it if the applicant had wanted just to come in with an ADU in this location. I don't know whether they could build, they could just come in right now and just propose an ADU in this location that would meet our code requirements. We'd have to go back and take a look at that. But I think with all of the provisions in state law right now,

41:27 It is very easy to build an ADU, and oftentimes the setbacks are very reduced, so they probably wouldn't need a variance of this size, even if they were coming forward with an ADU. So you're saying that if they're looking for ADU today, for example, that setback requirement is very minimal, number one. Number two, to sign this with Public Works. Your case then?

42:00 I don't know what the front setback is for ADUs. I don't know, Kim or Nolan, if you know that off the top of your head. But we probably would require the hold harmless, even if they were at that five foot, just because it is within kind of within the area that we blow snow. Yeah, that's correct. So the ADU front setback, this is Nolan, by the way, the ADU front setback is the standard front setback.

42:26 For the town at 20 feet, they are permitted to have substantially reduced rear and side yard setbacks for ADUs. But as Sandra noted, in the ADU code at the state level, which then is pushed onto the local level, is very permissive. And we really, you know, aren't seeing, you know, the applications of someone trying to say, oh no, this is just a room addition or a garage addition when really it's going to be an ADU.

43:04 Also two to, if I can speak again. Please. Yeah, just to let you know my living situation there, me and my fiancee live there and she has two kids, a 10-year-old and a 16-year-old living with us as well and we just had a three-month-old and so the big thing for sure is storage space and where to put all the kids' bikes and skis and trailers and so yeah, the garage and storage space is definitely our

43:33 The key piece of interest and what we're really desperate for. Commissioner Kennedy, did you have any questions or comments? No questions. Thank you. Got it. Hey, Kim, I have just a couple of really quick questions. If this variance is approved, will this property stability meeting its snow storage requirements? Yes, it will be exceeding the snow storage requirement. Okay. And a quick question for Josh.

44:07 The applicant, Josh, are you fully aware of the whole harmless agreement with the town that you would be going into contract with? Yep, yep, we're willing to take that risk for sure. Yep, we understand that. Okay, that's the only questions I have. If there are no other questions from the commission, then I think I would entertain a motion if someone wants to put it forth. Chair Vanderhurst, we have public comment.

44:39 Oh, please. Sorry. Tara Peterson, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Oh, hi. I didn't know if you saw that. Can you hear me? Yeah, we got you, Tara. Okay. I'm just speaking in favor of this. I'm one of the neighbors as well. So I'm not really saying anything different. I just wanted to say that I'm very much in favor of them being able to move forward with this. So that's all I have to say. Thank you for taking the time, Tara.

45:12 All right. Was there any other public comment besides the written public comment we received earlier? No, there is not. Okay, then I will close the public comment on this matter. Any further discussion amongst the commission? Would somebody like to put forth a motion? I'll make a motion.

45:38 I think I have it pulled up, but correct me if I'm wrong, camera Sandra, to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving variance VAR 21-002 with conditions as recommended by staff. Any further conversation, any further comments before we put it to vote? Jamie, roll call please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert?

46:16 Commissioner Eckert. Greg, we got you on mute. Okay, there we go. Yeah, that's a yes. Okay. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Matter passes 4-0. Congratulations, Josh. Good luck with the remodel. And hopefully the back end of your cars don't get taken out by a snowplow. Thank you all very much for your time. I really appreciate it. Thanks, Josh.

46:54 That will close public hearing matter 5.1. We're going to go to business matters now, 6.1. We're going to get a parcel update, and I believe Sandra is our staff contact. Yes, I would be happy to provide an update. I'm just going to share my screen real quick to provide some photos. Okay, can you see my screen? Oh, yes, we can. Got it.

47:23 Just wanted to provide the Planning and Economic Development Commission with an update on the parcel project that we're working on. This is a photo that was taken by your former colleague, Amy Callanan, and it was taken on October 19th. It's a really great photo, shows the construction equipment out there with Mammoth Mountain in the background. Here are some additional photos that were taken that day showing the tree removal, rough grading out there.

47:51 On the site. And then, as you're aware, we had a groundbreaking ceremony last Wednesday. I think it was last Wednesday, yeah. And it was a beautiful day. You can see the council members kind of throwing the first shovel full of dirt there on the left-hand side. And just some pictures of the event. Former Mayor Shields Richardson on the right-hand side provided some remarks.

48:19 Mayor Richardson was essential in the purchase of the property, made a lot of trips down to LA to negotiate that property, and so that was really a huge win for our community. And then the bottom photo is just kind of a photo of the whole group out there at the site. Just some stats on phase one. I'll get into those in more detail with my staff report, but we'll have 80 affordable units with one manager's unit.

48:48 The affordability ranges between 30%, area median income, and 80%. It's roughly an equal split of studio, one bedroom, two bedroom, three bedroom, with 21 studios, 18 one bedrooms, 21 two bedrooms, and 21 three bedrooms. So I'm going to go ahead and stop share and I will walk through my staff report. The staff report's pretty detailed about phase one, kind of goes into details in each component.

49:16 So I'll try to go through it quickly and then I'm happy to answer any questions that any of the commissioners have at the end of the presentation. So as I stated, the project is a roughly equal split of studio, one bedroom, three bedrooms. Construction has begun and the majority of all the tree removal has been completed at this point.

49:37 If you go out to that site, if you go to Center Street or kind of the dead end of Tavern Road, you can really see into the site now and you can see those roadways that are cleared. If you're at the Center Street kind of location, you can see the building pads, or not building pads, but kind of the building area for phase one, which is really exciting to see. That public road network will be largely completed as a part of phase one.

50:05 So we expect to see the improvements on Center Street Tavern and likely that connection to the south to Chaparral. The funding for phase one, it's approximately 47, the cost for phase one is approximately $47 million. We have funding from a variety of sources, including a new funding source that was just approved by the governor last month. It's called the California Housing Accelerator Project Funding.

50:34 So we have that funding that we anticipate receiving approval for next month. We also have $20 million of infill infrastructure grant funding, no place like home funding and some other funding that was received through Mono County. And so as a note, I'm not sure if the Planning Commission, I don't know if we circled back to the Planning Commission last year or earlier this year when the design review was approved.

51:03 But your staff report shows a condition of approval that was placed on the phase one by the town council related to parking. So there were some concerns at the town council meeting related to the amount of parking that was provided as a part of phase one. And so they did put a condition of approval that requires us to come back with a parking management plan for consideration. So we are, Pacific has hired a parking consultant and we are working on

51:31 Putting together a parking management plan for phase one. That parking management plan will help, will somewhat shape phase two as well. So we're trying to get that done sooner rather than later. As I mentioned, the affordability is a big range between 30 and 80% AMI. The units, the area median income units is really allocated by the funding source. So the funding source requires a certain number of units at a certain level.

52:00 So that's kind of why we have that split of those units there. And then a note that we are, the project phase one does include a daycare facility as well as some community space. We have been in discussions with AMACA to provide daycare at that site. And it looks like they will be able to serve up to 34 children from birth to five years old.

52:24 And it will include space for both restricted and non-restricted income children. So there will be some low income slots and then some market rate slots for that daycare there. The town council reviewed and approved a development, a disposition and development agreement. Basically, that's the agreement with Pacific companies that specifies how that land will be conveyed to them and what provisions they have to meet in order to have that land conveyed to them.

52:54 That was approved and it was executed on October 13th. And your staff report includes a rough schedule of the project. I think the most important thing that everyone kind of wants to know is when can people move in? So that's looking to be in the fall of 2023, late summer, fall of 2023. But our development partner Pacific is out on the site now. They are continuing to work and will continue to work.

53:22 through the winter if possible, as much as they can. So just moving on to phase two, the number of units is to be determined. Like I said, it really kind of depends on how much parking we're required to provide as a part of that project, about part of phase two. But it would look very similar to phase one with the units being split between 30% and 80% AMI and likely a rough, kind of roughly studio, one bedroom, two bedroom and three bedroom included.

53:51 That project could be between 100 and 162 units. Again, really depending on the amount of parking we're providing as a part of that phase. So you will, as the commission, see the design review for phase two. So that will come forward to you for consideration, likely in early 2022. So early next year, you'll see that for consideration. So that's...

54:17 completes my report. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about any of the stuff in the report or any other parcel related questions. Thank you, Sandra. Any questions for Sandra on the parcel update? Please, Commissioner Chang. Thanks, Chair. Sandra, what's the logic behind having the parking study only stop that phase, not all the way through five, given that, you know, if we only address phase one and two,

54:58 and not the rest, when that potentially reduce number of units, maybe in the future, if we discover something that we haven't considered? Yeah, so the parking management plan, it's really a parking management plan, is going to look at, it's looking at phase one, but the information included in that plan would then be used to inform all the future phases of the project. So the commission and the council approved the parcel master plan.

55:28 which has a parking ratio, I think around 1.3 parking spaces per unit. The council was concerned that that wasn't enough parking. And so we're really looking at the parking for phase one, but that will be used to inform phase two, phase three and future phases. So we wouldn't get into a spot where we find out something new in the future phases.

55:55 With that being said, I think if we do include an ownership component of one of the future phases, that likely would have a different parking requirement for the ownership. But that's to be seen at this point. But we are trying to look at ways to provide additional parking through phase one and through the future phases. You're awesome, too. Thanks. Any other questions for Sandra on the partial update? I see Commissioner Kennedy shaking her head no.

56:30 Commissioner Eckert, did you have any questions or comments for Sandra on the parcel update? No, I'm not supposed to talk about the parcel. Oh, I forgot. Commissioner Eckert is recused from this. Conflicted out. Conflicted out. Sorry about that, Greg. Thanks for bringing it back to our attention.

56:57 And just a note that Grady Dutton has been the parcel manager for the past two years, and Grady is retiring in less than a month. So I'm transitioning into that parcel manager role. So all things parcel will live in community and economic development with me. So if you have any questions or if you hear any questions from anyone in the public, please send them my way. So I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra.

57:24 I would just make a comment that I find these updates incredibly beneficial and informative. So if we could, especially since you're the point person now for all things parcel, maybe like a quarterly update on the progress before this body would be very much appreciated. Absolutely. I think it's really important, especially now that it's real. I think it makes it easier for people, you know, members of the public to really kind of to get an update and see what's going on because they can actually go out into the field and

57:54 And see it. And if any of the commissioners would like to go on a site visit, I'm happy to arrange that. I'm happy to take you out on site, walk the site. We can have our, you know, we'll make sure that we let the construction people know that we're gonna be out there, but please just let me know if you'd like to walk the site at any time in the future. Got it. And Sandra, should we be anticipating any more joint workshops with town council pertaining to the parcel, future phases?

58:24 Well, we don't have any scheduled at this point. We might put that together for phase two. It kind of depends on how that kind of comes out time-wise, but I wouldn't anticipate any more joint workshops for in the near future, but possibly next year. Okay, thank you. Jamie, did we have any public comment on the parcel update? No, we do not. Thank you, Jamie.

58:51 I'm going to go ahead and close Business Matter 6.1. I appreciate the update, Sandra. And we will open Business Matter 6.2, which is a general plan conformance determination for the town acquisition of vacant land located at 60 Joaquin Road for the purpose of constructing workforce housing. And I believe our staff contact is Nolan. That is correct. And just one item to point out, I also believe Greg or Commissioner Eckert is conflicted out of this item as well because he has...

59:21 Rental property within the proximity of the site. Let me clarify that up front. Thank you. So yes, the town has acquired a 0.25 acre site within the Sierra Valley sites for the purpose of providing workforce housing for the community. In pursuant to government code section 65402, the commission is required to report on whether the acquisition is in conformity with the town's general plan.

59:52 In this context, general plan conformity is limited to a review of whether the proposed use of the acquired site is consistent with the general plan land use designation and otherwise consistent with the general plan's goals and policies. The proposed use of the site is for a six-unit multifamily residential planned unit development that the town intends to develop. The land use designation for this site is high-density residential one.

1:00:20 The zoning designation is residential multifamily one. The two designations are consistent with one another, and this area is intended for the development of higher density multifamily residential projects. Therefore, the acquisition is in conformance with the town's general plan. It's also important to point out that this determination is only related to the acquisition of the site.

1:00:46 The design and associated project will come back to the commission at a later date for consideration. It is expected that the future project will require the following entitlements, a use permit pursuant to the town's density bonus program, design review, and a tentative map to subdivide the property as a planned unit development. With that, that ends my presentation and I will open it up to the commission for

1:01:14 questions or comments. Thank you, Nolan. Appreciate that. And just to reiterate, Commissioner Eckert is conflicted out on this matter. So I will see if we have any questions or comments from either Commissioner Kennedy or Commissioner Chang. Nothing from me. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, any questions for staff? None, and I don't have any either. Jamie, do we have any public comment on this matter? No, we do not. Okay.

1:01:46 Then if anyone is comfortable, I will entertain a motion. I'll make a motion for the acquisition by the town of vacant land located at 60 Joaquin Road for the purpose of constructing workforce housing that is in conformance with the general plan and recommended at PEDC to adopt the attached resolution. I don't have the resolution number. Let me see here. I think it's resolution 20.

1:02:42 2021-11. 2021-11. I'll second. Any further conversation, comments, questions? Then, Jamie, how about a roll call vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 3-0. Thank you, Nolan. Congratulations. And anything we can do to increase the inventory of workforce housing is a good thing.

1:03:18 Great. Thank you all. So I will close 6.2 now and we will go to the consent agenda. Does somebody want to pull anything out of the consent agenda or does somebody want to put forth a motion to approve the consent agenda in its entirety? Approve the consent agenda as written. We have a motion from Commissioner Eckert. We have a second. Jamie, roll call vote please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy?

1:04:00 Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Senate agenda passes 4-0. Thank you. Commissioner reports. Does anyone have a report they'd like to put forth? I'll just start off with something really quickly that is near and dear to Jamie and myself. The Mammoth High School football team is playing semi-final game here in Mammoth, a home game against Mojave, 7 p.m. at the high school.

1:04:29 And if they win this game, they play for the state championship the next game. So it's been an incredibly successful season for that team. As Jamie can attest to, the kids have put in a huge amount of personal commitment to each other and that team. So it's pretty nice when they get rewarded with their success. So come out and watch the game. Is that tonight? That's Friday night, 7 p.m. Okay.

1:05:02 Anybody else have a report they'd like to put forth? Commissioner Kennedy, are you good? All good here. I'm glad to know about the football game. I obviously don't keep up with that sort of thing, but that's great to hear. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, he's good, solid. Commissioner Eckert, anything you want to share with the commission? All good. Thank you. Appreciate it. Then I'll close the commissioner reports and we'll go to Sandra's director's report. Thank you. Just a brief update.

1:05:34 That a couple of staffing changes in the Community and Economic Development Department. Chandler Van Schock, our senior planner, has resigned. His last day with the town will be December 3rd. So we'll be spending some time kind of wrapping up his projects, wrapping up some of his items, and we will be advertising to replace that position with another senior planner.

1:06:02 Also, Bailey, our permit technician, was promoted to permit technician slash plans examiner. That was effective a couple weeks ago, but I didn't mention it at our last meeting, but very excited to have her moving up, and we are backfilling for the permit technician position, and a local young woman named Melissa Bell.

1:06:30 We'll be starting on November 22nd. So if you stop by our offices at some point, I know we haven't been in the office much, or all the commissioners haven't been in the office much, but a couple new faces around the office shortly. So with that, I don't have any other items. Thank you. Well, congratulations. And the town's gain is definitely the chamber's loss with the new staff member. She works in the office next door to me currently, and we share a wall.

1:07:00 She will be a great addition to your team, Sandra. Thanks. We're excited to have her. We're sorry to take her from the chamber, though. And just on behalf of the rest of the commission, we would just like to wish Chandler nothing but the best in the next chapter of his personal and professional life. Thank you. I'll pass it along.

1:07:24 And with that, we'll close the director's report, and I will adjourn today's meeting until our next regularly scheduled meeting, which will be on December 8th, 2021. So appreciate your time, guys, and get out there and get on the snow, and come out and root for the Mammoth Huskies on Friday. Good afternoon, all. Good afternoon, everyone. Thanks, Chair.