Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 14:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- Commercial air service at Mammoth Yosemite Airport ended in early 2020, and service moved to Bishop starting December 2021 Airport and Air Service
- Town recorded an agreement on September 28, 2021 ending two use permits at 160 Commerce Drive Cannabis
- The Main Street Plan was accepted by the Town Council in February 2014 after a 2010 district plan concept Downtown and Main Street
Transcript
211 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you, Angie. You're welcome. And I think we're still one short, so I've got two o'clock on the nose. Whoever jumps in here first, Sandra, I'm going to go ahead and kick her off. Sounds good. Hope everyone got their Christmas lights up already, because it's not going to be fun after tonight. How much snow are we going to get, Michael? I think we're going to get four to six in town, maybe close to a foot on the hill between tonight and tomorrow by noon.
0:37 But it sounds like the one coming in Sunday, Monday, Tuesday could be a bit of a whammer, which is perfect timing. It is perfect timing. Good. Thank you. So I see Commissioner Kennedy on the line or on the Zoom, I should say, good afternoon, Commissioner Kennedy. I'm going to go ahead and jump in here since we have a quorum, the three of us, and I expect Commissioner Burroughs to join us, but I do not think Commissioner Chang is joining us today. So, Angie, would you mind giving us a call to order?
1:08 Yep, calling the order, meeting to order at 2.01 p.m. and I will do a roll call as soon as my computer moves. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Commissioner Burroughs? Present. Commissioner Chang? Excuse absence, sorry. Commissioner Kennedy? Present. And Commissioner Eckert? Here. Thank you. Thank you, Angie. Now if you guys would all stand for the Pledge of Allegiance and Kim.
1:43 Would you mind leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Not at all. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Well done, Kim, with a curveball coming right at you. Well done. I'd like to now open public comment. I would ask that if anybody has public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda.
2:15 That you hold on to your comment until that matter comes before the commission. So I do see some staff here and I see we have a representative from the Forest Service, but first I'll ask, do we have any public comment in person in Suite Z? No public comments at this time. Angie, do we have any written public comment that does not pertain to an agenda item? No, we do not. Okay.
2:39 Well, then I'll turn it over to, first, how about our representative from the Forest Service, Leanne Murphy, are you here to present something in public comment? I am, yes. Good afternoon, everybody. Glad to hear there's snow coming in. I'm in Taos, and we need it desperately over here, too. So, yes, Sandra just asked me to present a little update on the Long Valley Exploratory Mining, the Core Mining Limited Project. So, just to let you know, we...
3:08 One, we're in litigation on that decision, but there was some movement with plaintiffs and our lawyers, and so some exploratory drilling work is going to begin next week. They're going to prep four pads starting next week, and then they are, hopefully, they're still looking for a drill rig to come in maybe around Christmas and start drilling a few holes off those pads.
3:36 So folks may see some activity there next week in getting the pads prepped. And then additional work may occur in the new year. And then that will be, again, limited to just four pads. And then that's kind of all that was granted until we work through litigation on the full decision. Got it. Does anybody on the commission have a question for Leanne Murphy?
4:06 Hey, Leanne, I do have a couple of questions, if you don't mind, and I'm not going to belabor this because I know there's a lot of uncertainty with this. First of all, the company that is doing exploratory drilling, is it a U.S.-based company or a Canadian-based company? That's actually a really good question, and I don't know if I have the answer to that off the top of my head. I will look that up for you, Mark, and let you know. Actually, that's just something I haven't had to respond to yet. I do know that the rig companies and stuff that they're using,
4:35 Are based here in the U.S. And then I know they've got some other like project leads and stuff from other places like Australia, I believe. But I will find that out, Mark, because I actually I have not had to answer that question. So I don't know off the top of my head. No, no worries. And I apologize for putting you on the spot with that one. No, that's all right. Just so people have kind of a visual idea of the area we're talking about for the exploratory drilling.
5:01 Please let me know if this summary is correct. If you are leaving Mammoth Lakes, heading south on the 395, on your way to drive past the airport, when you see the left turn to Hot Creek geological area in the airport, there's kind of that ridge back behind the hatchery, the Hot Creek hatchery, and occasionally there is a steam vent bloom that is coming up from the base of that ridge.
5:30 Is that approximately the area we're talking about? That is approximately the area, yes. Yeah, when you look at the access roads, you end up pretty much then looking back from where you're talking about. Okay. That's the general vicinity. And then this one is good. Feel free to not answer this if you don't feel comfortable with this, Leanne. But let's say the exploratory drilling is successful for the mining company. It's something they want to pursue.
5:59 And let's say the litigation becomes resolved to the point where they can proceed and they get the green light from the Forest Service and the powers that be. Has this the potential to be an open pit mine? So what I will say is that we would not, I don't know. And that is because we have not been given a draft plan of operations from the mining company for what that work would be.
6:28 So the exploratory drilling is just for them, hey, what's out here? If they find something that they believe, hey, this is something we want to develop, they would then provide us that plan on what that might look like. And so, yeah, I don't know what that could be. Got it. At that point, we would do planning on that. So it would be a totally new planning process, new everything. It's a completely new project when they get to that stage.
6:57 Perfect. And I appreciate you fielding those questions. I know it's kind of a hot topic here in the Eastern Sierra at the moment. So I appreciate that. I appreciate you coming before this commission to answer those questions. So unless anyone else on the commission has a question for Leanne Murphy, I'm going to let her go. I didn't realize she was calling in from New Mexico. So thank you for that. It's appreciated. Yeah, no problem at all. Let me know if you guys have any other questions as we work through stuff. And the new rangers should be here in January.
7:27 Be able to pick up that and move forward. Got it. Thank you and good luck. Thanks everyone. Have a good day. So I see Jenna on there and I'm sure Jenna's got a staff update for us. Would you want to jump in here, Jenna? Yes, thank you. So Jenna Carter with Town of Mammoth Lakes Code Compliance and I do have a quick update that I'd like to share my screen for just a moment. Now you all should be able to see this pie chart. Yeah. Thank you. And so just to give a
8:00 Graphic representation of what I've been working on. You can still see here that unpermitted work does take up about a quarter of the cases that I receive, followed by substandard and then trash. On substandard, we are making some progress on some cases, so I'm happy about that. They've been open for a while. And then unpermitted as well with notices of violations going out. I did want to touch, Chair Vanderhurst, on the Mammoth Creek Inn status. I will stop sharing my screen now. Thank you.
8:30 There we go. I should be stopped chairing now. The Mammoth Creek Inn, so according to the owners of the property there, I reached out to them and they said that they have plumbers, HVAC people and other trades working on site daily. And recently, I asked about waterproofing. They said the building wrapping is scheduled within the next few weeks. I asked them that last week. So I expect in the next couple of weeks, something to have some wrapping on the building. They said they're in the last stage of approval for the fire sprinkler plans.
9:00 And so the rest of the work is moving forward beyond that. And once they have the fire sprinkler plans, their addendum will be approved. And then they'll have full steam ahead approval for everything. So we should, hopefully we are moving in the right direction on that one. I appreciate you being thorough in your follow-up with that project, Jenna. It's, yeah, we've had, I think I can speak for a few of us, a few of my fellow commissioners that we've had the general public reaching out to us about that project and its status or
9:29 Stagnation, I guess, would be the word. So thank you for that, Jenna. Any questions for Jenna from anyone else on the commission? Please. Just one question, the substandard that you mentioned, Jenna, is that substandard living, like residential specifically? Correct, yeah. So like long-term rentals where the conditions are substandard and we hold the property owner accountable to make repairs and I get very excited when they actually pull permits and make the repairs. Awesome, thank you. All right, any other questions?
10:01 Jenna, we appreciate your time and we appreciate your hard work. Thank you so much. Thank you. Have a great meeting, everyone. And if we don't see you, happy holidays, Jenna. Thank you. Any other staff here for public comment or are you guys all here for agenda items? All right, then I'm going to move on to the public hearing and our business matters. Start off with 5.1, update the PEDC regarding the voluntary rescission of two use permits for property addressed.
10:30 160 Commerce Drive, and I believe Kim is our staff contact on this. Thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners. So this is an informational item. No action is required. We thought it would be a good idea to bring an update to the commission regarding the status of these two use permits, which were granted for the property. Address is 160 Commerce Drive. The location is in the industrial district.
10:59 And I think most of you were on the commission when the use permits were issued. The first use permit was approved for a medical marijuana cultivation facility. And the second use permit updated the first use permit to approve a non-volatile commercial cannabis manufacturing facility.
11:21 So the property owner contacted staff regarding a pending sale of the property and he indicated that the title company was not able to issue title insurance because there was a conflict between state and federal law applicable to cannabis businesses. So the property owner provided a written statement to staff requesting that the town allow him to voluntarily surrender.
11:45 The use permits so that we could record a document to basically effectively remove the use permits from the property title. Staff consulted with the town attorney and Andy Morris helped prepare an agreement to voluntarily surrender the use permits and that was sent to Mono County for recording and it was recorded on September 28, 2021.
12:14 So, if any cannabis business comes forward in the future and wants to operate from this location, we will need a processing use permit. I think that does it for my update. We just included an attachment of the recorded agreement in your packets, and if you have any questions about that, I'm happy to answer. Anybody on the commission have a question for him on this matter? No? Okay, so...
12:46 Like you said earlier, Kim, there's no action required. This is just an informative update to the BEDC on the administrative actions by staff. And as far as we know, this property will be an escrow. And the hope is that this will be used for a little bit more of a traditional commercial use in our commercial district that might provide more jobs locally.
13:13 That is just my personal opinion, not staff. More industrial related, yeah. More industrial. So unless there's any other questions or comments, I'm going to go ahead and let Kim go. Kim, we appreciate it. Thank you. And have a great holiday if we don't see you. Thanks, you too. Okay, we're going to move over to 5.2, consideration of the airport's capital improvement plan for years 2022 through 31 and adopt a resolution finding that
13:45 ACIP consistent with the general plan. And I believe our staff contact is Sierra. Yes, thank you. I'm Sierra Schultz. I'm Deputy Airport Manager down at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. I've been with the town for the last eight years and then just recently moved into the airport position after working with the airport for the last three years. So I have a presentation here that I'm going to share with you guys. Let me just pull this up.
14:23 Are you able to see my screen? We've got it. We've got it. Okay. Are you seeing the presentation still? No, we just have your wallpaper now. I moved it over. Let me do that one more time. Good looking wallpaper, though. Thank you. My trip to Chamonix. All right. What about now? We got it. Great. Thanks.
14:52 I'll just run through this PowerPoint in addition to the staff report that was provided you guys and the draft ACIP with a layout of the projects. I also included the ALP in your packet just for reference, nothing with approvals there. So for the presentation, I'm just going to run through staff recommendation. We'll run through two key issues that are presented today.
15:22 A little bit of background on the ACIP and what it is used for and then kind of the annual process that we go through when we're reviewing it and the approval levels that would happen annually. Then we will review the projects and I have a map for you guys to kind of show where those are and then we can discuss those key issues. So staff is recommending that PEVC
15:50 Receive this presentation and then receive any public comment on the topic and then confirm the resolution that this draft ACIP is consistent with the general plan. So the two key issues here is if the draft ACIP is consistent with the general plan as well as if the ACIP is consistent with California Environmental Quality Act.
16:19 So we are bringing this to you guys per government code section 65401, which says that the town's planning agency should review and report on any proposed capital projects and make sure that they are consistent with the general plan. So a little bit of background on the ACIP.
16:47 It's basically a planning and fiscal management tool used to coordinate location, timing, and financing of capital projects out at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. These projects are included in the town's capital improvement program and we'll be working closely with public works each year to make sure that they are consistent with each other. The projects included in the ACIP are one-time, non-reoccurring.
17:16 projects that have a long service life and are typically beyond the scope of typical maintenance and annual operations. So the projects basically extend useful life of the facilities and reduce maintenance costs as well as adding additional services and amenities and really maintaining safe working conditions out here at the airport. A little bit more background is that
17:48 The town is required to have an ACIP and update it annually. This is part of FAA's requirements for us to have an active up-to-date list. The FAA is under no obligation to fund the projects on the list, but they cannot fund them if they are not included in the list. And then that creates funding opportunities for the airport improvement program and grant funds through the FAA.
18:18 Hey, can I ask a really quick question, Sierra? I apologize for interrupting you. Oh, of course. Would you go back to the previous slide? Yes. Does this mean you'll be coming before us annually with an updated ACIP? Likely, yes. I don't think it's legally obligated if we're not adding any projects or changing the projects in the list. However, yes, we would like to come to you guys annually just to create.
18:47 a consistent process moving forward and keep you guys well informed of what the ACIP projects are as well as capital improvement projects. Thank you, Sarah. Yeah, thank you. So annual process, basically staff takes a look at the current ACIP. If we had any projects that might be new and need to be...
19:14 added to the list and then we might reprioritize based on the need and current service life and funding opportunities. So if we see, for example, that an asphalt is failing more quickly than anticipated, we might move that up and make a recommendation that it becomes a quicker priority. Once we do that, we will come forward to town council to solicit feedback from them as well.
19:39 This year, on June 2nd, there was a larger presentation on Airport Operations 2 Council, and a part of that was just looking at some ACIP projects. And then we typically hold a meeting with the FAA. So this happens every year, normally in August, and staff meets with them to talk about these projects and the eligibility for funding.
20:08 If there's any specific opportunities that the FAA sees where maybe a project should be moved up because it's a really big focus for them to get it done and they see a lot of funding going to specific types of projects. So we solicit feedback from the FAA and make sure that they're on the same page as us and then that puts us into where we are currently today which is going to PEDC to adopt the resolution.
20:37 Finding that all of the projects are consistent with the general plan, and then we will be going to town council for adoption. That will likely happen on January 5th. So here is a list of the projects. I'm not going to run through every one of them, but I did want to highlight some of the major projects that we have coming up. We have the ARF building and snow removal equipment building. That...
21:07 Yeah, I'm actually going to show you guys the map while I run through these. So currently for this project we have started, we're going out for a grant.
21:18 to do the design of the building this coming year and then hoping to construct in 22-23 with construction happening in 23. So that is a building that would essentially house our RF and snow removal equipment and that's right here in the purple zone. And then our next project is to relocate the AWOS which essentially is connected to this project since
21:47 It would be in the way of access, so we're going to move it over towards the segmented circle. So both of those projects were included in the EA for the terminal that just got completed or is underway to be completed and the sequit is completed as well. So those are environmentally approved. One of the other large projects that we have listed on here is the heli pad.
22:12 So that is over here at the west side of the property. We have it split into two phases. So the blue phase is phase one, which would be going on town-owned land, and that would be happening in the more near future. And then we have phase two, which would be coming after land acquisition, which is also including the ACIP on Forest Service land currently. Got it. Hey, Sierra, can I ask you a really quick question on the helipad?
22:41 Besides the actual pads, phase one and phase two, are there any proposed amenities out there like lodging or, you know, restroom, anything like that? Or is it just strictly pads? It would be amenities as well. So as we work with emergency services for the area, you know, it might be Cal Fire, CHP has some current needs out here as well. So we'll be talking to them. We want to make sure that our facility,
23:11 Encompasses what's needed for emergency service out here and can expand, especially with all the firefighting operations that we see happening. So we somewhat envision, and this would, you know, once we talk to them and kind of see what some of their needs are, funding opportunities and then our recommendations as well, possibly a building with some of those amenities and somewhere where it kind of...
23:36 Staff, like Forest Service firefighting staff or whatnot could come through, use some of those facilities, as well as possibly a couple storage buildings. It could be hangers, it could be an actual building that they would potentially have for storage or whatever their needs may be. So we are intending that some amenities would be out there. Thank you. Thanks. Just running through the list real quickly.
24:13 Beyond those projects, really, I think the other largest, there's the terminal building here in the green that includes all of this additional apron space. The yellow project, which is projected for 2030, is additional apron space as well. So that would increase our capacity for how much aviation we can hold, you know, and.
24:41 Those are basically the main projects. Do you guys have any questions before we move on? No. Any questions for Sierra this time, guys? I think we'll have a chance at the end of our presentation if there's something you want to come back on. Yeah. So looping our projects back into the key issue number one, staff found consensus with the general plan under economy, mobility, and public health and safety.
25:11 Really for economy, where you see, and for mobility, we see the terminal building and the helipad fulfilling a lot of these goals. And for public health and safety, we have the ARF building, which will improve safety and response to snow removal. We also have the fence project that will help keep wildlife outside of the airport.
25:38 You know, keep our runway safe for all the planes to come in and land. And hopefully we will not be having to chase off as many animals day to day as they call in their flights. And then we also have the helipad, which we intend will definitely increase safety to our region and working with our regional partners on just transportation needs. Would you mind just going back one slide, Sierra?
26:07 Hey, would you mind just quickly touching on bullet point number three on economy and why commercial service is mentioned there, why it's important for the town to maintain its Certificate 139? Yeah, so basically we currently have our Part 139 certification on site. We intend to keep that in place and operate at a level that would
26:38 Leave availability if commercial service were to come back to Mammoth at some point. We definitely want to be expanding our charter service, but would like to keep the capabilities to have commercial service if needed. But in the short term, there are no plans to resume commercial service at Mammoth Yosemite Airport, and there's no negotiations happening between the town and any commercial partners.
27:08 Yes, so currently there are no conversations with any commercial airlines and there are no current plans to bring commercial back into the region or into the area. Of course, it's in the region down at the ship now. Thank you for clarifying that. Yes, thank you. So the second key issue is to find if the project is consistent with CEQA per
27:35 Sequa Guideline Section 15378, staff has determined that this project of finding consistency between the general plan and draft ACIP is not considered a project under those guidelines. So once again, staff makes the following recommendations that PEDC confirm the resolution, finding consistency between general plan and ACIP.
28:07 Sierra, would you mind just leaving that slide up while I open it up to discussion with the commission? Yeah. Thank you. Does anyone on the commission have a question for Sierra at this time on her presentation or the ACIP plan for 22 through 31? Yeah, I got one. Please, Greg. So on the current large hangar that is currently being used for the firefighting and snow removal equipment.
28:39 Once this new structure and housing for the equipment is built, does that existing structure go back to Hot Creek Aviation? Does the town have plans to use it in the future? Or what is the downstream? Yeah, we haven't determined exactly what we would be proposing for that space. We still have to have some further conversation as to...
29:07 Whether we would need that space to store anything, I think likely we will be designing the building to house everything that we need currently and near future equipment. So likely we would not need that space, but we have not determined that. Okay, is that, I think I'm driving, so I don't have the map in front of me, but is that structure, does that belong to Hot Creek and they lease it to the town or is that the town? The current hangar is
29:42 Hot Creek, and then we rent it from them. We lease it from them. And when is that lease up? I actually am not sure about that. I'll have to follow up and give back to you guys. Any other questions, Commissioner Eckert? Nope. Sierra, if you would not mind following up with the terms of that lease, it would be appreciated. Yes, I can do that. Any other questions for Sierra at this time from the Commission?
30:21 No, I don't see the whole bar, so I can't see Commissioner Burroughs, but I'm going to guess not at this time. Angie, do we have any public comment on this matter? Yes, we do. You may go ahead and approach the podium. I just have two questions. One, if there's any type of projected amount of revenue that the airport will be taking in during this time. And also the second, if there's a plan for...
30:58 A succession plan for the airport engineer if he retires. Those are my only two questions. Sierra, do you want to answer those? Or Sandra? Sierra, you're probably the most qualified. Yeah, I think if maybe you could elaborate a little bit more. So let's just start with the second one. I think that might be easier. Succession for the airport engineer. Will you just maybe
31:32 Clarify a little bit who you're talking about there. Yes, so it's an older gentleman that we've interviewed with the newspaper and to be honest, my boss didn't give me his name and I probably should have looked it up. Okay, Grady Dutton. Okay. Yeah, so he has retired as of December 3rd. Oh, okay. So, yeah, so Grady's retired.
32:00 And our current new structure and airport core team will consist of Vince Maniachi, which is the current operations and maintenance manager here at the airport, as well as myself as deputy airport manager. So we'll both be out here on site running general airport operations and planning. And then we also have Rob Patterson, who is the finance director and admin services.
32:28 And so he'll also be a part of our core team when facilitating conversations with PDC and town council moving forward. Okay. And then your second question about projected revenue, could you please elaborate on that one as well? Yes. So if there's, I guess, no plan for commercial airlines and it's instead private use or not commercial, is there any way for you to like
32:57 Project how much money you're going to take in, the airport's going to take in through that use. Yeah, so we still have, so we have Advanced Air as our charter service currently. In the future, we may be looking to, you know, we'd be looking to expand, whether that's expanding with Advanced Air or potentially other services. Currently, Advanced Air has been a great partner and they're
33:25 Currently flying out to the airport at least four days a week. And I'm sure that we do have projected revenue numbers. I think MLT could probably speak to that as well. We'd have to follow up a little bit on that because I don't have the details in front of me. Sandra, I don't know if you have anything to add to that.
33:46 The only thing I have to add is that I know we do have a budget for the airport, which has projected revenues, and we can provide you with that information. If you want to give me your contact information, I can get that to you. Perfect. That's awesome. Thank you. Thanks. No problem. Hey, just for future reference, when you do want to address the commission or any of our staff contacts, just introduce yourself before your public comment, please. Okay. Okay. Well, my name is Emily. I'm with the Sheet newspaper.
34:13 Thank you, Emily. Appreciate it. Yeah, thank you. And I did have one additional comment. I just wanted to let you know that we do have revenue that we get from the FAA, our entitlement funds, based on our employment numbers. So since commercial went away, we'll just be using the general aviation, or sorry, not general aviation, charter air service to fulfill those employment numbers and get our...
34:41 Million dollars a year of entitlement funds through from the FAA. So we still intend to meet our employment and move forward with that financial tool as well. Okay, thanks. And Sierra, if I'm not mistaken, and I could be wrong, so correct me if I am, but I think that that overall embarkment number is from the scheduled charter and from general aviation. I think general aviation counts towards, you know, that ultimate goal of 10,000.
35:12 I believe. I could be wrong. Correct me if I am. Well, so it's the employment, yeah, on the plane. I could double check. I did not think, I don't think that it is general. I think I heard Pat Foster say that. So if you wouldn't mind just double checking that, just so I know if I'm completely speaking out of turn. Yeah, I'll let you guys know. I'll follow up on that as well and let you know. Awesome. Hey, Angie, any other public comment?
35:43 No more comments at this time. All right, then I'll throw it back to Commission. Any other questions or opinions or deliberation with with Sierra on this matter? And I hear none. So Sierra, I'm going to thank you for your presentation. And I am just going to ask if you wouldn't mind if you are going to come before us annually with an update on the ACIP, if you would also just include any future developments on the planned usage for the
36:15 The terminal and the sprung structure. Okay. Yeah. We're having some good conversations about that now. So I'll definitely bring that back to you guys. All right. Thank you so much, Sarah. We appreciate it. And if we don't see you, have a great holiday. Thanks. You too. Okay. I'm going to go to item number 5.3, which is the housing program update and discussion. And I do believe Nolan is our staff contact on this one. Great. Thank you.
36:45 Let me share my screen here. All right, can everyone see that? Not yet. I gotta share, that's probably why. But now, can everyone see that? Yeah, we got you now, Nolan. All right. So yeah, PowerPoint's pretty short because it's really more just to kind of inform about some of these different programs and kind of high-level background on what we're talking about today. So real quick, just to kind of give the commission...
37:29 And understanding when we talk about AMIs, income levels, all that, this graphic on the screen is what's called the housing bridge. So on the left side in orange, you have affordable slash low incomes. In the middle, you have the blue, moderate to middle incomes. And on the red, or on the far right, you have the red, which is upper middle incomes. So usually when we're talking about state and federal grant programs, that's like home, CDBG.
37:56 Housing Accelerator Program, which is funding the parcel. We're kind of over here in the orange on the bridge. So generally programs on that side require much higher subsidies to get housing units built. As we go around the bridge, the blue, that moderate to middle income is what's referred often as the missing middle income. Typically here, it's going to be
38:24 Local funding that assists housing developments in this category, that's because usually you're at an income level of above 80% AMI. So that's really where the town funding come in and assist getting housing units built or acquired. And then on the far right, as you kind of go, you know, this graphic shows 120 to 195% AMI. Realistically, those who don't need any subsidies, more like the 150 to 200% AMI.
38:53 Which just kind of gives you a visual as to what we're talking about. Generally, homes over here are market rate in that red category, and they don't need subsidies or assistance. Hey, Nolan. Yes? We're seeing your screen in presenter mode. I don't know if you're able to just switch it so that we see the full... I don't know how to get out of presenter mode. I don't know either, but... What if I do slideshow from the beginning?
39:25 Yeah, I'll just leave it in this mode if that works for everyone. That's fine. It's a little, it's bigger. Yeah, perfect. Thanks. Yeah. So yeah, first program on the update is the parcel. Obviously, everyone, the commission's pretty familiar with this project. We're in the first phase currently of construction. That's going to be 81 units. 80 of those units are affordable. So there's going to be restricted incomes below 80% AMI. So that's going to be over here in that orange.
39:55 And then one manager's unit. It's going to be composed of two buildings on the site. Right now they're grading, they're cleaning up their site, buttoning it up for winter, and they'll come back in the spring with a building permit and keep on moving forward from there. So they did obviously all the tree removal and mass grading early throughout summer and fall of this year. Then target occupancy for phase one is summer and fall 2023.
40:22 The developer's also been working with its town on phase two. That's anticipated to be 100 to 162 rental units. The exact number hasn't been finalized. They're still working through that. We do expect to see their draft submittal for phase two before the end of the year. Sandra, correct me if I'm misstating on that. And then it'll be coming to the commission sometime probably in spring of 2022.
40:51 That'll be for design review since the use permit and master plan have already been approved for the whole site. Hey, Nolan, can I jump in here really quickly? I forgot to kind of tee this presentation up a little bit. So just to my fellow commissioners, you guys probably read the staff report and Nolan is now going through the bullet items that are listed in the summary. Maybe after each bullet or each project has been summarized by Nolan, you can...
41:22 Leave it open for questions. And then I'm going to keep public comment until the very end of your presentation, Nolan. So that, unless Sandra has anything else to add on the parcel, I will open it up to the commission for questions on bullet point one. Which is the parcel. Are there any questions on phase one? I know we're pretty vested and versed on phase one, but does anybody have any questions for Nolan at this point? All right, Nolan. All right.
41:57 Oh, Commissioner Eckert, did you have a question there? Oh, no, I'm not. Oh, yeah, sorry about that, you're conflicted. Good I asked. So, moving on, the second bullet point is what we're calling the Bridge Loan Program. This is a kind of new program for the town, and the purpose of it is we're looking at purchasing existing market rate units as they come up for sale through our partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing.
42:34 And then doing any necessary rehab to the unit. Usually it's just minor repairs, paint, potentially carpet, stuff like that. And then reselling the unit at a deed restricted price. So we're initially targeting households at that 120% AMI level. So on that bridge, that's kind of right here in the middle. That's that middle income category. And because it's town funding.
43:01 Going into the project, we're not tied to the same requirements as state or federal grant programs, so we're able to assist those higher AMI income households. Ideally, we're targeting mostly condo units just because single-family residences are outside of that affordability level just by the nature of them because we're really looking to keep the subsidy on these units to between $100,000 to $125,000, $130,000.
43:32 So we're looking at studio, one bedrooms, two bedrooms, three bedrooms, four bedrooms. The price range obviously kind of fluctuates between those based on the unit size, based on the age of the complex and any other amenities that they might have, such as garages or no garages. So far with the program, we have acquired one unit in the San Joaquin Villas Complex in November 2021.
43:59 And we're working with Mammoth Lakes Housing through their wait list to identify a purchaser for that property. They have households that's interested in, they're just working through making sure they qualify and that they have the loan, everything else to purchase the unit. Then currently we have three additional units under contract. The staff report says two, but that's because we put a third unit under contract late last week after the staff report went out.
44:27 Our goal for the program is six units in the first year, and it's being funded, town council allocated approximately six and a half million total at the end of last fiscal year, and a million of that is being allocated to this program. So total with that, you know, we estimate seven to ten units depending on the subsidy. Like I said, our goal for this first year is six units. So with that, I will again open it up to the commission for questions.
44:58 Any questions for Nolan on the bridge load program? I've got a couple of really quick ones, Nolan, and feel free to answer these as briefly as if you want. What exactly is the role of Mammoth Lakes Housing in this partnership? Like, what is their responsibility? Sure, so Mammoth Lakes Housing has a real estate license. They can act as the realtor on...
45:25 You know, completing the documents, purchasing them, executing everything with the title company. And they also then can act as the realtor when we go to resell the unit because we're working off the waitlist directly. It doesn't then involve commissions for a realtor on either side since we're working directly through them. They also take the role as to working then with escrow on kind of all the different requirements.
45:52 The town, we provide the funding, providing the funding to MLH, we require a deed of trust, a promissory note for the loan, and then a loan agreement that kind of outlines the terms of the loan that we're giving them. So Mammoth Lakes Housing essentially will own the unit, but on title, there's recorded documents that's securing that loan back to the town. And then when they go to sell the unit, they're also then,
46:20 Completing the deed restriction with the new owner. That deed restriction runs with the property through any future owners. It specifies the initial purchase price of the unit. Then also outlines the terms to secure that deed restriction in the future. So if they go to sell the unit, Mammoth Lakes Housing has the first right of refusal on that unit at that reduced deed restricted price specified in the deed restriction.
46:48 That assures that then it's available for future households to keep it at that affordable level rather than it, you know, the initial household benefiting from the subsidy, then a future household can buy it at market rate. No, we want these units to remain affordable in perpetuity. For any reason, if Mammoth Lakes Housing is not a position to take advantage of that first right of refusal, does the town have language where they have like an opportunity to
47:18 Reacquire the property before it goes to open market? Yeah, so their first right of refusal basically means the town's first right of refusal because we provide, we have a revolving loan fund which is a set aside of funds specifically intended to purchase deed restricted units as they come up for sale if we're at risk of losing them. So we would use those funds to buy the unit on the short term then flip the unit because it has that
47:48 We're not really at risk of losing money because we're buying it essentially at that price that's in the deed restriction. There is some in there that allows for slight increases, but then it would be resold at that slightly indexed price. And if there was not funding there, that would, I think, you know, we upped that amount to $600,000 about a year ago just to have the ability and
48:18 More capacity to buy more units in Mono County also has a similar program that has, I think, $300,000 set aside. That's specifically for town units. They have a partnership with MLH to assist on that. So we have roughly almost a million dollars to take action on that first right of refusal for any units. Got it. And then not to bog you down, Nolan, but would you just really briefly kind of go over
48:47 The general terms of the deed restrictions. Sure. So the deed restrictions for these units, like I said, are for the 120% AMI level. So that guarantee that restricts the household income for those buying it based on household size. For 2021, a household size of two, their maximum income could be about $78,000. And a household size of four, their maximum income could be $97,450. That gets adjusted each year by the state.
49:16 But we really don't see too much change in that income levels for those. Then it also requires that the property or the owners live in the property full-time as their primary residence and work or be an employee within the region. Normally it's minimum 30 hours per week. And it has to be a business that's doing business here.
49:43 Thank you, Dolan.
50:16 to new ownership, that 55 years becomes restarts. Correct. Got it. All right, unless anyone else has any questions on the bridge loan program, we can move on to the new housing development, which is 60 Joaquin Road. Sure, so this was one that the commission at their last meeting took action just to do it, find the acquisition in conformance with the general plan. The project is, it's a,
50:46 Quarter acre vacant lot in the Sierra Sierra Valley sites. The town's looking to build a six unit plan unit development on it. So we are looking to use the town density bonus program to get to that density. We are going through this on a process called the design build process because it's using public dollars. We have to follow the public.
51:13 It's not the public contract code, but it's the government code related to capital projects using public dollars. So the process, the initial process, it goes out to release an RFQ, a request for qualifications to get design-build entities pre-qualified, basically identifying design-build entities who are interested in building this project here. And then from that, we'll, based on all those, hopefully,
51:43 Substantial amount of RFQs we receive, we'll put out an RFP, a request for proposal to the top four firms after our internal review, and those four firms will then be asked to actually submit a proposal for what they think the project will cost, how they're going to build it, timing, basically them selling themselves for how they're going to build this project within our specified budget and our specified timeline.
52:12 Our timeline for the project is we hope to begin construction in summer 2022 with occupancy in spring of 2023. It's a tight schedule, but we think it's doable. Based on the RFQ that went out, we're able to kind of on the back end, see the analytics and see how many firms have subscribed and downloaded it. And we have quite a few firms who appear interested. So we think we're going to get at least
52:40 One, hopefully more submittals that we can work from. The budget for this project is $2.8 million. That was allocated, again, in that pot of money Town Council set aside from last fiscal year. We acquired the site in early summer of this year, and then we've been moving forward on getting the procurement documents out to bring on that design build entity. So, yeah, the project will require
53:10 A tentative map, because we're going for it as planned unit developments. These will be for sale units intended for that 120% AMI level. Again, because it's town dollars, we have a little more flexibility. Then we'll require a use permit for the density bonus and design review the design. And so those entitlements will be coming to the commission likely in spring of 2022. Got it. Thank you, Nolan. Any questions for Nolan on 60, Joaquin?
53:42 Yeah, Nolan, I'm not sure if this is the ideal spot to ask this question, but so 60 Joaquin is laid out to be a six flex, right? Correct. And acquisition, planning, construction, you know, landscaping, whatever, is $2.8 million. Acquisition separate from that, the initial budget is about three and then 200,000, so now we're at 2.8.
54:17 Okay, so from scratch to pillows, roughly $3 million? Yes. So, half a million dollars a unit? Correct. And the old country glass building, I think we're going to get, what was it, 11 units out of that? Yes. And by the time we buy it, build it, and redo it, what are those 11 units going to come out to? I'd say higher than $500,000.
54:52 We can touch on that on the next bullet point, bullet point, like I said, the 238 is not entirely a town project, so we don't have control on their budgeting, on their estimates. We're working off ours on looking at comps from similar ground up, multifamily development projects that have recently been built, so that's really where we're running our comps from.
55:20 I can't really speak to where Mammoth Lakes Housing is getting their construction numbers from. And just so you know, Greg, that project, the Sierra Glass project, is the next bullet that Nolan's going to talk about. Okay. But I kind of see where you're coming with this one, Greg, so I definitely want to hear your comments on it. Hey, Nolan, just a quick question. So the $3 million, the town allocated for 60 Joaquin,
55:51 And the $1 million the town allocated for the bridge loan program, those are both coming out of that $6 million pot that you mentioned earlier? Yeah, so initially it was a $5.7 million. That was right at the end of fiscal year, the last fiscal year. So that was $3 million for 60 Joaquin, $1.5 million for the Creative Housing Fund, and then $1.2 million.
56:18 for the 238 Sierra Manor Road Project. And then once they got the final budget or revenue numbers from the last year, they allocated an additional million dollars over to housing, which we set aside just for the bridge program. Got it. Thank you. All right. If no other questions on 660, Joaquin, I'm going to let Nolan move on over to Country Glass.
56:44 So Country Glass, that's located 238 Sierra Manor Road. This is a rehabilitation housing project. It's taking existing buildings, converting them to housing. So again, this is Mammoth Lakes Housing's project. They're proposing 11 one-bedroom affordable apartments split between the two existing structures.
57:08 And my numbers for these are targeted at the 80% or below. So again, that's going to be on the left side here because this project is heavily subsidized with state and federal dollars. And that's also why the cause of the delays on this project is because they're waiting on notification on a home grant and a CDBG grant that they've submitted or the town has submitted.
57:36 Until they get those funding and the agreements in place, they're not going to move forward with the project just because they don't have the resources to do it. The town has committed $1.5 million towards the project to assist with the project, but until they have those other funding sources, you know, and the project's moving forward, we're not going to give them those dollars. So it's been committed, it's been set aside, but we're still holding on to the actual funds.
58:04 So on the budget of that project, like I said, I really can't say. We've asked to see their detail pro forma on it. We have not seen it, so we don't know exactly where their cost estimates and everything are coming from. But we do know it's, I think, I want to say, Sandra, I don't know if you have the exact most recent number, but I think it was around an $8.5 million project was what they were thinking. Yeah, that sounds about right, Nolan.
58:34 And they do have currently a gap of, I think, about a million dollars they're trying to close, separate from the town's commitment and these other funding sources. Got it. So I'll open it up. And Greg, please, I'd love to have you finish your thought. I think where we left it was the town's project at 60 Joaquin is being proposed at half a million per unit for a six-plex.
59:07 I kind of interrupted your thought, Greg, so please finish it. All right. Well, I think I'll let no one finish it so that I don't get wrong and have them correct me. But between the town, the grants, the contributions from LLH, all the peas in the pile, what is the total budget? We don't have bids yet, but the total budget for the country glass building.
59:35 How much are we paying for 11 units over there? Or what are we looking at paying? So the town has committed 1.5 million. We haven't committed anything additional to that. So the town, kind of regardless what their total cost is, sees it as a fairly good value for our 1.5 million if we can get 11 units for that 1.5 million. If they can leverage all these other sources to get it done, then...
1:00:02 And it's a win for the town. You get 11 units for that 1.5. At this point, we haven't committed any additional funding to that project. Oh, yeah. 11 units for 1.5, that's a winful. But what is the total cost? I mean, maybe it's not town money, but... That's what I said. We've heard currently there, you know, I think that all-in number is the 8.5 million. That includes land, includes there is some...
1:00:32 reductions in or donations on land value to bring that price down. So that is what we've heard is they're all in cost. Like I said, we haven't seen their detailed financials on it. So this one's coming in, maybe the math's a little off, but more like $800,000 a unit? Give or take. Okay. And I think there's also a bit of difference in the square footage per unit, right? I mean,
1:01:08 The six-plucks, the town's talking about at 500 per unit, the units themselves are quite a bit bigger. If I remember correctly, the 11 units at 383 Sierra Manor, they're roughly hotel room shit. Yeah, the 11 units are one bedrooms. I think there's five existing garages, so five of the units will have a garage space. The other units will have
1:01:38 Outside parking space, but then there's also, I think, a shortage through, because it's a truly affordable housing project in the state's eyes, they can, eligible for reduction in parking under those programs for that project. And it also provides some streamlining and takes away any kind of ability for the town to enforce a lot of the development standards that would be on.
1:02:09 Any other project, because it came in under what's called an SB35 streamlining. So it removes some of our ability to enforce standards that we would normally impose on a project. Got it. Well, I'm glad that the town of Mammoth is only putting out, sounds like, 15% of the cost for this thing. But I'm not sure that Chair's description is more accurate than White Elephant, but it seems like a lot of money.
1:02:42 Thank you, Commissioner Eckerd. Any other questions for Nolan on 238? I don't have a question, but I have a comment. This is Burroughs. Please, Vice Chair. I would just like to thank the town for all the work they've done on housing. You guys have really produced products and are continuing to produce products to address our housing needs in this community.
1:03:16 I commend all the results you guys are showing and how you've allocated the town and town council has allocated money for this priority and please keep up the great work. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Borough, Vice Chair Boroughs. Any other or should we let Nola move on to the Creative Housing Fund? All right, hearing nothing. So the Creative Housing Fund, again, this comes out of that pot of money the council set aside. They set aside 1.5 million towards this program.
1:03:49 exact details of it are still being developed, but the basic concept is working directly with the private developer or private developers to produce units. They can be either units that are currently under construction or units that are proposed. We would essentially be paying for the deed restriction on the unit. When we're using that terminology, it gets us out of some
1:04:16 Some of the prevailing wage requirements that are tied to other projects that use public funding, since we're not actually funding the project, we're basically buying a restriction on these future units there. So we have been talking with various developers, we don't have any agreement or project in place yet moving forward using this program, so there's really not too much to add on that.
1:04:43 Ideally, our goal for the program would be a minimum of six units that we would get through it. And then as to whether they be for sale units, rental units, what AMI restriction, all that would come more in the details on the agreement that we put in place. Obviously, the AMI levels, as you go to a lower AMI, the subsidy amount increases substantially. So to kind of get the most units for that pot of money,
1:05:13 Probably be targeting that 120% AMI level just because it typically requires a lower subsidy than units at the 80% level. We also know that there's a number of projects coming in the works at that 80% level that are relying on the state and federal dollars. So we're trying to focus on the other income levels on when the funding has the flexibility that it does with the town dollars.
1:05:40 Projects, like I said, in that lower part of the parcel and MLH projects, we're really focusing on those more middle income projects. So we know there's a high demand there as well that we're hearing from the community and businesses in the community. Again, I will open it up to the commission. Any questions for Nolan on the Creative Housing Fund? Nolan, is there a capital C creative option? You know, I keep having this.
1:06:13 Nagging feeling in the back of my head that our problem isn't numbers of units, it's uses of units. And while it would be very difficult to swim upstream with a large project and try and buy existing units to deed restrict and put into the pool, if we could find a project, I don't know, I'm just pulling one out of my hair,
1:06:43 But I forget the name of it, but there's about a six, maybe eight unit on, oh, it's up by Chamonix and between Canyon and the next street to the left, Rainbow Villains. So there's about eight units in there, give or take. Pretty sure they're all non-local housing. So if our goal is to get local housing, and I...
1:07:17 All behind that, trust me. I just would like to see it at a lower unit cost. If we went to those people and say their units are worth, I'm just pulling another number out of my head, but $600,000. And we're paying $500,000 and $800,000 for these things that we're using now. If we could go in there and make them an offer they can't refuse to buy all of the units, even if it's more generous than, you know, might be strict retail, if we can get a
1:07:49 I think definitely with the Creative Housing Fund, like I said, we don't have any formal agreement in place yet. It's discussions. We can definitely look into a program where
1:08:20 Yeah, we just approach owners. I'm not sure how we would go about that aside from a blanket mailer out to, you know, every TOT certificate holder or something else, but it's something we can definitely look into and come back and report on. They might have an HOA. That might be the point of contact. I think I would target, you know, there's got to be a database that says how many condo projects in Mammoth have, you know.
1:08:49 Pick a maximum number, under 12 units, and have the funding, the creative fund, whatever we're going to try and use, just cold call, write them a letter. We want to buy a unit, and we would be willing to pay over market value for the premium of being able to buy an entire project. Is there any chance you guys are interested? And you might not hear anything back, but you might.
1:09:26 Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. Any other questions for Nolan on the Creative Housing Fund? None. So deed restriction monitoring has been somewhat of a, you know, sticky point for a number of years because the town is a party to a number of deed restrictions in the town and the town is not the greatest at monitoring those restrictions to ensure that everyone's following the rules. So since I
1:10:00 became Housing Corner. I have dug through kind of all the different spreadsheets, databases, folders, binders, everything else we have to identify all the deed restricted units that the town's responsible for monitoring. That's differentiated from the deed restriction units that MLH is responsible for monitoring. Then also different than some of the
1:10:26 projects that were built using different federal funding sources which require their own monitoring program and so it's yeah taken basically up to now to really get to the point to be in a place to now send certified mail letters out to all the owners of the town ones there's 25 that were responsible for monitoring they're a little different than all the other
1:10:54 Kind of units at Mammoth Lakes Housing monitors or the ones that are, we use a consultant for those home ones because all of our units allow for either ownership or rental occupancy. So it makes monitoring a little more difficult than your traditional one because you kind of have to capture both sides of it. You have the owner-occupant, which they're required to be initially income certified when they first occupy the unit.
1:11:24 Then going forward, they only have to, they have to remain employed in the region and live in the unit full time. We're on a rent, if it's a property owned by an entity, but they rent it out or have tenants in there, then those tenants are required to remain income qualified for the entire time they occupy the unit. So they get, are required to be income certified annually and be employed in the region and live in the unit full time.
1:11:55 We're in process. I have the list completed. I'm filling out the certified mail labels literally this morning to begin that process. So we're excited to see what kind of compliance we get. And this initial amount of monitoring, we're really looking to establish that baseline kind of status of all of our existing units. We're not coming in initially with the heavy hand of the government and start kicking people out into the streets or anything else. So we really want to just kind of, where are we at?
1:12:23 And then work with the owners to bring them into compliance. You know, as tenants move out, require that the new tenants comply with the rules or as units become for sale, ensure that the unit's going to an income qualified household if they're going to occupy it. So like I said, we have 25 that we monitor, MLH has 40. Majority of those are just strictly owner occupied. So their monitoring just looks at that the owners.
1:12:52 continue to occupy the unit and live in the region. Then we have 154 that get monitored through the home program. That's that federal funding source. For those units, we rely on an outside consultant because there's so many other requirements that they have to adhere to as the operators of those complexes that it would basically take an entire staff person just to ensure that they're following all the rules.
1:13:22 So with that, I will open it up to the commission for questions. Any questions for Nolan on the deed restricting, the deed restriction monitoring program? I'll just say I very much appreciate you taking this up, Nolan. I know this is a bit of a thankless job and you're dealing with, you know, some history that probably isn't that fun to dig into. So thank you for trying to get some clarity on this.
1:13:55 put a more streamlined program in place. I, you know, can't emphasize enough how incredibly vital having these units maintain their deed restriction is going into the future so that the town maintains the inventory of workforce housing. I'm excited, like I said, to see this kind of initial where we're at because I think it'll kind of set the stage going forward, you know, for as we build on these other programs, how best to manage them, how best, what kind of, you know, our
1:14:24 lessons learned from past deed restrictions, past issues, so it's kind of informative as well as we're, you know, embarking on new programs, so. And then the next program is the state and federal grant programs. This one, most of the funds for this are used for first-time homebuyer programs, and most of them come out of the CDBG program and the home program. We also have some existing funding from an older state program called the BEGIN program.
1:14:54 So in the last two years, over the last two years, we've assisted nine households into ownership homes. We provided approximately $900,000 in grant funding, which then leveraged $2 million in private investments. That's their down payment or their primary loan that they get from the banks. So that's provided almost $3 million in local real estate investment.
1:15:24 Both those grants did, and the funding expenditure deadline was in July of 2021 on both of those programs. We do have a new CDBG grant application in for $500,000. We expect to hear from the state soon on whether we've been awarded that grant, and then the home application period just opened, and applications are due on that in March, so we will likely be submitting for a new home grant as well.
1:15:53 The benefit to getting more funding from CDBG and home for these programs is that money stays here locally. So we provide gap financing on the units to bring it so that their monthly housing cost is affordable to the household. So if they're buying a $500,000 unit, we might provide $200,000 in a second loan so that their primary loan is then $300,000, which is affordable to that.
1:16:23 income level. The future, when they repay that, say, $200,000, the town retains that money in program income that then we reissue as new first-time homebuyer loans. So the money then recirculates in the community. So it's really a benefit to keep on applying to the program to get more funding because it just increases the number of households we can assist. Any questions for Nolan on the grant programs? I have one if no one else has any.
1:16:54 Hey, Nolan, are there any AMI restrictions on this program or these grants? Yeah, so there is. So for CDBG and home, it's typically 80% AMI and below. And I don't know why I use typically. It always is 80% AMI or below. The BEGIN program allows for households up to 120% AMI, but it's limited only to the San Joaquin Villas, Meridian Court, and Aspen.
1:17:22 Aspen Creek Condos Complexes, because that was the original application for those BEGIN funds were tied to those complexes, so those funds can only be used there, but they do assist a higher AMI household. And those AMI levels will be in place, are baked into the town's new application? Correct. Got it. Okay, any other questions for Nolan on the grant program?
1:17:53 All right, so the last bullet point is really just kind of highlighting the progress on where we're at for meeting the what's called the regional housing needs allocations. This is a target number of units established by the state. It's based on how many units the state is projecting we need by the end of our current housing element cycle spread across all the different income levels. So our current cycle runs through 2027.
1:18:23 The state's identified that we need 155 units spread across all the income levels. Hey, Nolan, do you want to go to the next slide? Oh, yeah. We feel that the need's probably higher than 155, but that's what the state has established. And so then with that, we have to report annually to the state on the progress we're making. So this table on the left is what, similar to what we report to the state. It looks at number of units entitled.
1:18:50 Number of units permitted and number of units completed. They use that metric because they feel like it really shows from kind of beginning to finish the progress and try to identify any areas of the development cycle that are preventing housing units from being built. So we look at 2018 through 2020, majority of the units under entitlement are in the above moderate. We have the 11 units of low income that are entitled.
1:19:19 for Mammoth Lakes Housing. And then 2021, you see a big jump because that's where the parcel comes into play. So we entitled 450 units. Then when you look to permit or completed, we're back to zeros. That's because the actual building permit for the parcel and Mammoth Lakes Housing or any of these other programs the town's talking about won't be issued until 2022. So that's where this kind of graphic on the left comes into play, which is showing
1:19:49 The number of permits we've issued in 2019, 2020, and 2021, you know, we're doing great on the above moderate category, not so great on the other income categories. When you come into 2022, that's really where you start seeing permits being issued across the spectrum of income levels. It also demonstrates that through 2030, we anticipate that we'll have
1:20:17 Not only hit that 155, we'll have exceeded it in all income categories substantially. The parcel we have kind of spread out across all the income categories because phases two through five, we don't know the exact mix of income levels, but we know that they will all be affordable. So with that, I will open it up to the commission for questions. Any questions for Nolan, guys? So I'm not seeing any squares light up, Nolan, so.
1:20:52 You might be off the hook. I would just like to echo what Commissioner or Vice Chair Burroughs said. And, you know, I mean, it's tough for this community because, you know, a lot of these projects we don't see immediate results on, but the fact that the town is moving at the speed it is moving at, I think is phenomenal. And that you guys are clearly thinking outside the box with some of these programs to try and get.
1:21:21 People to get projects built and get people inside the units. So, you know, after, you know, once we get to 2022 and in subsequent years after that, I think it'll become very evident how hard you guys have been working and how much budget allocation town council has put towards workforce housing. So I would just like to commend everyone on that. Thank you.
1:21:47 I guess one last point is, yeah, if there's any public comments, I know you said to hold all the public comments or questions to the end. Angie, do we have any public comment on the workforce housing update? No public comments at this time. All right, Nolan, unless any of the commissioners have any parting comments or thoughts, we appreciate your time. And if we don't see you, have a great holiday with your family. All right, thank you.
1:22:23 All right, our next one is item 5.4, the Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy Update. And I believe our staff contact is Sandra. Thank you so much, Chair Vanderhurst. As you said, this is an update on the town's Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy. We'll just call it Dr. SEDS for short. That's what we've been calling it since it was adopted in 2009.
1:22:47 So the document was adopted in 2009 and then updated subsequently in 2012. Since that time, we have implemented a number of the programs and policies that were recommended into the document. I've listed a couple of those on the second page of your staff report. In addition to implementing policies, we have also, in 2016,
1:23:15 adopted a special events economic development strategy, really intended to guide investment in special events in our community. And as just a side note, that special events development strategy isn't a part of what we're talking about today, but I just wanted to make the commission aware that that is kind of a companion document to the Dr. Sedd's document. So the Dr. Sedd's document is really, the intent is to guide
1:23:42 Our investment in policies and programs in really to achieve economic development in our community. We are updating the document right now because there is some federal grant money available through the Economic Development Administration for recovery from COVID for tourism communities, tourist-based communities. In order to apply for the grant funding, we have to have an updated community economic development strategy.
1:24:12 The EDA has pretty specific requirements for community economic development strategies, but they have said that we could use this current Dr. SEDS document to qualify to apply for that grant funding. So our purpose here today is to remind the commission and the council, we'll be going to council next Wednesday, but to remind the commission today about this document to show some progress on what we've done and to provide you with the updated documents. So we did go through and kind of complete a wholesale
1:24:41 Rewrite or update of the document. In the staff report I recommended because it is a relatively long document that the commission focus on our strategic direction and action items that are located on pages 5 to 11 of the document. So at this time I'm happy to answer any questions you have about the document, take any feedback you have on those specific direction action items.
1:25:07 And then we will be putting this together for town council for next week and providing it to them for consideration. If the town council accepts the document next week, then we will be moving forward with applying for funding through the EDA. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions that you have on the staff report or on the actual Dr. Seds document itself. Any questions for Sandra on, I can't even say Dr. Seds without wanting to laugh. I know.
1:25:38 Any questions for Sandra on this, guys? Please, Jessica. My one question, I guess I don't know really what my question is, but reading through it, the mobility section, I guess I'm wondering if you guys have probably thought of this, but with ESTA not being able to find drivers, wondering if there's anything in this grant funding that would help out with ESTA and our...
1:26:05 Transit needs in terms of employment. I know that housing was brought up a lot in this and business viability and that sort of thing, but just wondering if you have any comments on that side of it with this document. Yeah, I mean, it's certainly something that we could add to this document in particular. The EDA funding wouldn't qualify for drivers or paying drivers more money, but it's certainly something that we could include in the document because you're right, this is an issue.
1:26:33 Finding drivers and finding that appropriate, basically, level of service for our transit in our community. So I'm happy to put together something to recommend to Council on that, just basically trying to include the concept of, I guess, comprehensive support for ESTA to continue providing services or providing the level of service that we expect or desire in town, if that kind of meets what you're saying.
1:27:01 Yeah, I think so. And maybe it falls under two. I mean, I think it could kind of dabble in a lot of the things in the document, but maybe for ESTA and for other organizations, there's, you know, marketing and recruitment type training. I know that was in there too, as of financial and technical assistance for businesses. But that was my main thought was the mobility section. I was like, ooh, but ESTA needs drivers. So does every, you know, people need employees too. So just wanted to throw that out there. Thank you.
1:27:33 Any other questions for Sandra or comments before we go to public comment? I do have a couple, but I want to hold off to give everyone else a chance. Hey, Sandra, this is Greg. If we can't use this money for wage subsidies or make more lucrative in a dollars and cents way, is there any way that it could be combined into some sort of a deal where the town rents
1:28:06 A workforce unit, even if it's not deed restricted or anything. And then we turn around and rent it back to the employee and make everything kind of kosher. We rented it whatever the current market rent is, but we do something like we won't increase the rent as long as you work for us. So the funds would go to the unit instead of the person.
1:28:37 But the person would get the benefit of a long-term lock on the housing cost. And that would inspire some loyalty, I think. So the funding from the EDA can't be used for any type of housing program or project. It's really intended to be used for construction, to build things. But I think the point that you're bringing up is really kind of a rental subsidy program, an ongoing rental subsidy program for...
1:29:06 Employees, and that's certainly something that we can kind of push forward or at least start talking about is, is there the desire or the ability to provide permanent rental subsidies for different employees, different programs, that kind of thing. I know that ESTA, as you heard when, when Phil was here last month, I think they're looking to try to increase their salaries, which
1:29:29 You know, it kind of all washes down, you know, but is somewhat of a bringing their salaries up, allowing them to pay, you know, pay more for rent. But I think the idea of a permanent rental subsidy program is something that we can consider as, you know, part of our housing program or at least see if that would be, if that would work. Okay. Thank you, Greg. Appreciate it. Any other questions for, for Sandra on, on this, on this item? I have a couple of questions, Sandra. I'm just.
1:30:02 I'm a little confused on how the town uses this document. I totally understand why you're bringing it before us today to try and qualify for the EDA funding that's available out there for tourism destinations that have been affected by the pandemic. But if I'm not mistaken, this document was first created in 2009, updated 2012, and now coming before us in 2021. So clearly it sat on, you know,
1:30:33 Sat on a shelf somewhere for a while. So what's the future goal with this document? Is it something that you guys are going to update yearly or just when funding becomes available and it's a tool? It should really be used, I think. The intent was always that it would be used to help guide investment and to help push forward policies, I guess.
1:31:03 So, I mean, I think that ideally the document would be updated on a three-year basis. That was always the intent was that it would be basically a three-year work program. It is somewhat of a little bit of a strategic plan in the fact that it is trying to guide investment. In the past, the town council has used a different strategic planning process, but a lot of the projects that have been in the town council strategic programs
1:31:29 Have aligned with this document. So there's definitely some crossover. We haven't actually taken this document and told the town council, you know, put these things on your strategic plan because they're in this document. But there has been a lot of overlap between the two. So going forward, I think this document can help to inform that annual process that the town council goes through.
1:31:53 And definitely something that we can provide to them as they're looking to invest, you know, excess TOT, looking at budgeting and then looking at kind of their strategic planning. But really, we would look to update it on about every three years. Got it. Because there, excuse me, because there are some massive, massive bullet points in this, especially page 5 to 11 that you kind of focused, had us focusing on, like broadband bringing the last mile. I mean, that's massive.
1:32:22 A permanent event space for the town is huge. And, you know, getting 10,000 employments out at the Mammoth Yosemite Airport with scheduled charter. I mean, these are big, big things that we've been talking about for a while. The master mobility plan. And I mean, just this document is, I just feel it's too bad that it got lost for those years between 09 and 21. And, you know, that predates all of us. So I'm not laying blame on anyone.
1:32:51 But it just seems like such a valuable tool. Agreed. Yeah. And I think taking it to council next week will be an opportunity to kind of bring it off of the shelf and back into the spotlight and really kind of use it to help us do our strategic planning as the council does on an annual basis. Thank you, Sandra. All right, Angie, do we have any public comment on this item? No public comments. All right. Any other comments or opinions?
1:33:22 Questions for Sandra on this item? What's our action on this, Sandra? Really the action is to provide staff with any direction that you have. So if there's consensus among the commission that we should add something along the lines that Commissioner Kennedy brought up with, you know, marketing, recruitment, employees, kind of something along those lines, I can write something up and then we will, you'll make a recommendation to town council.
1:33:50 You know, recommend that the Town Council approve the document with the addition of something to capture that goal of investing in our employees. I think that would be about what the requested recommendation would be, and I'm going to have to work on the language. And Chair Vanderhurst, I'm happy to work directly with you if you want. If the commission gives me this direction after this meeting and tomorrow, I can write up some language, send it to you, and you can...
1:34:20 Give me kind of the final sign off before I put it into the town council packet. Sounds good. Commissioner Kennedy, sounds like there is a motion somewhere in there, but I'm not really sure how it'll be worded. Would you care to make a motion? Yeah. How do I do that? I can just summarize that the recommended motion would be that the Planning and Economic Development Commission recommend that the town council accept the updated
1:34:52 Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy document with a recommendation that I guess some language be added to capture the employee support component. That's what I think the recommendation could be. Commissioner Kennedy, feel free to change kind of the end part, what you want to add on, and I'm happy to, like I said, work.
1:35:20 Draft some language and then work with Chair Vanderhurst to get that finalized. Should I give it a shot? I will move to, I don't know, where is it, to approve or to recommend that Town Council approve the Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy Update as written with modifications to be provided from Planning Commission.
1:35:50 about employee recruitment, et cetera. Does that work? Sounds good to me. Just to clarify that you're going to recommend that they accept the document because they can't actually adopt it without environmental analysis. So it's just a technical term, but I think your motion would say accept. Perfect. Recommend that they accept the document. Thank you. Do I have a second? Absolutely. Roll call, please, Angie. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs?
1:36:26 Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. And Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you, Sandra. Appreciate it. Yeah, if you wouldn't mind just keeping us updated on this document as it kind of makes its way through its life cycle, it would be appreciated. It's a very interesting document. All right, consent agenda. Is there anything on the consent agenda that anyone would like to pull? Or does anyone want to make a motion to approve as is? Consent agenda.
1:36:56 I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? I'll second. Angie, roll call, please. Angie, did we lose you? Oops, I was muted. That's why you didn't answer my question. I had heard, it sounded like Jessica and Commissioner Eckert both made a second, but was Commissioner Kennedy first on the second? Let's give it to Commissioner Eckert since he's driving. Okay. Love it.
1:37:43 All right. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. And Commissioner Eckert. Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Angie. All right. Commissioner reports. Does anyone want to jump in? Commissioner Burroughs, have you got a report that you'd like to submit or are you good? I'll just add, I'll just talk a little bit about the ESTA. This is something we've been talking about in the Transportation Commission.
1:38:14 And while they are talking about increasing wages, you know, there's a lot of people aren't going back to work after the whole COVID thing and getting paid to stay home. And that is part of the problem with employee shortage. And it's not just with ESTA, it's throughout the nation, frankly. And so the bus drivers that we do have, they seem to be going to work at the Mountain.
1:38:43 Unfortunately, ESTA hasn't been able to compete with that level of pay and benefits, but they are working on different things to entice people to work, and it's affecting Bishop, too. It's not just Mammoth. So it'll be interesting to see what happens when the Bishop Airport starts doing commercial flights and we have shuttles and whatnot to see who's driving then, too. And then we have another Transportation Commission meeting next week.
1:39:13 I'll report back on any actions we take out of there. That's awesome. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Kennedy, do you have any report you'd like to submit? Nothing for me, thanks. Thank you. Commissioner Eckert, I don't want to pull your eyes off the road. Do you have anything you want to throw out there? More of a clarification than a report, but I just want to sort of straighten out somewhat.
1:39:42 Maybe a misinterpretation of my comments on the housing funding and budgeting and the like. I'm all for building as many units as we can get, but I would like to see us have the same number of dollars get us more units as opposed to the per unit cost that is pretty pricey if there's any way it can be done. Good comment. I think everyone agrees with that one. I'll just throw out there.
1:40:14 Tomorrow, the Mammoth Lakes Chamber and Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we are hosting Community Coffee at 8 o'clock. I think the Zoom link is out there. If you don't have it, you can either reach out to myself or Emily Bryant with Mammoth Lakes Tourism or Lara Kaler, who is our host, our hostess. The topic tomorrow, our guest speaker is Chris Smallcomb with Noah up in Reno to talk about
1:40:41 The immediate, the short-term forecast on weather, which is coming in, and the long-term forecast for the winter and spring. So it should be a lively discussion. And as you know, the Chamber and MLT would love to host you for a cup of coffee. I think it's the places you can grab it are the two Starbucks, Stellar, Black Velvet.
1:41:07 I'm spacing on the name of the place next to the subway shop. What is it? Somebody help me. Looney Bean. Looney Bean. And I think the new coffee shop up in the village that is kind of kitty corner to Lakanuki. So head in there anytime before noon and let them know that you are participating in community coffee and we got you covered. The other thing, the latest I've heard is with the...
1:41:35 With the very positive weather forecast that we've all been talking about here for the last 48 hours, it definitely sounds like Night of Lights is still going forward as planned. So it's a great community event. It's our traditional kickoff to the winter. The mountain does a phenomenal job with orchestrating that and bringing in bands and lots of live music. And so if you get a chance, head on up there and enjoy it.
1:42:04 And that is on the 18th. And with that, I'll close the commissioner reports and we'll give the floor over to Sandra. Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. Just a couple of quick items. The town council approved the Sierra Nevada Lodge amendment, the Clearwater Specific Plan amendment that you all considered at your October meeting. And the new owner is Waterton. They closed on the property, I believe, on Monday.
1:42:37 Or maybe last Friday. So that project is moving forward. They have submitted design review applications. We are reviewing those now. And those will likely come to the commission in February or March. Also, another note from the town council is that the town council chose a new mayor. So Linda Salcedo is the new mayor. And the new mayor pro tem is John Wentworth. And your next meeting is January 12th, which is...
1:43:05 After the holidays. So that's all I have. I don't have any other updates. Hey, Sandra, quick question on that process with the Sierra Nevada or the revamped Sierra Nevada. When you say it'll come back before us, will the design review just, will come back just in front of the design review committee or will the whole thing come before the PEDC in its totality?
1:43:29 It will come back to the PEDC in its totality. So the entire commission will consider that. Got it. Okay. Thank you for that clarification. All right. If there's no other comments, I'll just say to all my, well, first of all, the staff and all my fellow commissioners, I hope you guys all have a great holiday. Hopefully you get out there on the snow, get a chance to enjoy one of the reasons why we live here. And on behalf of Vice Chair Burroughs,
1:43:59 Get your booster. Go get your booster. With that, I'm going to adjourn this meeting until our next meeting, which is going to be, as Sandra said, the 12th of January, 2022. Happy holidays and happy new year, guys. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks all. See you next year.