TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2022

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 14:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

68 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Starbucks, hopefully it's not too noisy. No, it's not bad. Are you here in town or are you on the East Coast? I'm in Gallup, New Mexico on my way back to California. Did you go back to North Carolina to visit family? Yep. Yeah, we should be back in Mammoth by Friday, but here I am in the middle. There you go. Well, thank you for joining us on your trip back. We appreciate it. Of course. Yeah. Jessica, does COVID exist in New Mexico?

0:29 Oh my gosh. I mean, it does, but I haven't seen a lot of masks, in North Carolina even, but not at all across the country. How's Mammoth doing? I hear the National Guard is out and about. Yeah, I was saying earlier to Sandra in a previous meeting, I took Stella yesterday to get a PCR test. We both had appointments. And yeah, the National Guard was there in strictly a muscle.

1:00 capacity. Like, they were there as enforcement. And there was definitely some, how do I put this? There was some presence of some protesting. Still going, huh? Still going. So, Sandra, we just need one more, and then I'm going to open this meeting. Okay. I'll apologize to everybody who's on it right now. Hey, Drew, how you doing? I'm doing good. I hope everybody had a good holiday.

1:40 We certainly have plenty of snow, that was for sure. Yeah, that is definitely for sure. And Drew, I don't know if you had a chance to take a peek at the agenda, but we've got you teed up here pretty early on. Well, I'll just sit back and wait till you call me. Perfect. There's Commissioner Eckert. Greg, can you hear us? Greg, we cannot hear you if you're trying to reply. Commissioner Eckert, I just saw that you were connecting audio. Can you hear us? Can you verify it?

2:45 Your audio connection. Sandra, you want me to wait for Commissioner Chang or move ahead? Well, I mean, I see Commissioner Eckert there, but I think if we can't connect to him. Yeah, okay, here's Commissioner Chang. Here's Commissioner Chang. What's up, Paul? Can you hear us? He's still connecting to audio, I think. Hey, Sandra, did my audio come through? Yep, we can hear you now, Commissioner Eckert. Thank you. And Commissioner Chang, can you verify that you can hear us? Awesome, thank you.

3:29 All right, I'm going to go ahead and call to order the January 12th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we please have roll call? Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs is absent. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you. Paul, would you like care to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Absolutely.

4:03 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. I appreciate it. I would like to open up public comment now. I would ask that anyone who does have public comment, if it's related to a matter on our agenda today, to wait until that matter comes before the commission.

4:30 At this point, is anybody in Suite Z that would like to contribute public comment? No, there is not. Do we have any written public comment? No, I do not. Okay, then I'm going to open it up to staff. I believe Jenna is here to give us an update during public comment. Jenna, take it away. Thank you very much. So Jenna Carter with Code Compliance for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll do a quick screen share for the cases of December here.

5:04 Hopefully everyone can see my screen now. It looks like a pie chart. Thank you. I've summarized it with this month, last month, sorry, December. So you can see snow took the lead this time instead of unpermitted construction. Unpermitted construction did fall down into like fifth or sixth place. And then lighting, it's just about that time of year. I did want to also touch base on...

5:26 The old Mammoth Road property, the Mammoth Creek Inn. They have started to waterproof that building, as you guys probably saw as well, right before the big storms. So that was good news, I thought, progress as a code enforcement. That is it from mine. I will stop sharing the screen right now. Does anyone on the commission have a question or a comment for Jenna? I've got a quick one, Jenna. The 35% in your pie chart that's dedicated to snow, is that?

5:58 Like private residents or private citizens not using proper snow storage on their private property? Mostly. So it's a couple of things. It would be snow trespass, people blowing snow onto other people's property, private, and then I have to tell most of those cases that it's a civil matter between the two properties. But there's another percentage where people are blowing snow onto the right-of-way and they're creating hazards like speed bumps or big wedges of snow.

6:26 off the side. And some of those people didn't know they're so they're blowing snow so far from their property or this new hand snowblowers, you know, like the Honda's push blowers are so powerful that these homeowners don't know that they're blowing snow onto other people's property. So I'm making them aware of that and letting them know do their trespass there or on the right of way and they're responsible for clearing off the right of way. Got it.

6:50 Hey, and just kind of a strange comment, and I'll kind of just lob it at you, Jenna. You're probably used to me doing these too by now. I definitely noticed, you know, clearly the storm cycle we had over the holiday was unbelievably big and everyone was struggling to stay afloat and stay ahead of it. But I definitely noticed that the parking lot at the grocery outlet, it took them a long time to truck that snow out.

7:19 And part of their use permit was they were trucking snow out as part of their snow management strategy. So I just don't know if maybe their contractor was overwhelmed or the new, I know there's new owners there, a different ownership group than the ones that came before us. I've actually talked to them. I did go in on that very complaint and talk to the new owner and the new owner is.

7:44 Your first point was spot on. The contractor they used was overwhelmed. And so they pushed the snow as far as they could on the least used side of the parking lot is what the new owner of Grocery Outlet explained to me. And he said he was at the mercy of being on that list of priority from his contractor, the same contractor that plows like Rite Aid. He said maybe even bonds. It was a couple large commercial projects.

8:10 Parking lots where they all truck the snow out. And he also told me the price of how much it costs to truck snow out and how they're doing it in like five hour increments. So that once he became next on the list, you know, it was only a matter of, he can only fit in so many five hour shifts, it sounded like. So three days, it did, to your point, it did take about three nights after they were finally up on the turn.

8:36 to clear that. So I did let them know that we are receiving complaints and it affected the community. I had family in town for the holidays and they complained to me about how when you drive in you get that swoop, your car automatically swoops to the left and it was just that hard pack entrance that they couldn't keep up on. So I did make them aware and we're in conversation now. He was pleasant to deal with. Excellent, Jenna. Thank you for taking the initiative on that. Very much appreciated.

9:03 Well, if there's no other questions for Jenna, we'll let her go. She's busy. Appreciate your time, Jenna, and your update. Thank you. I hope you have great time. Keep up the great work. Thanks. So I see we've got some staff on here. We've got Sierra, Amy, and Nolan, but I'm assuming each one of you is here for a specific item on our agenda, not for public comment. Is that correct? That's correct. On my end. Sandra? Yes. Yeah. I don't think any of them have public comment.

9:34 I did expect Stu to join us, but I don't see him on here, so I will provide a brief update on the community conversation during the department, the director report at the end of the meeting. Perfect, thank you. With that, I'm going to close public comment, and we're going to move to item 4.1, which is to adopt resolution making findings to allow our commission to meet virtually during the COVID-19 pandemic emergency.

10:02 Do we want to have any discussion on this matter? Does anyone want to ask staff? I think it's rather routine at this point. I think this is probably our fourth or fifth meeting. We've had to adopt this resolution. Jamie, do we have any public comment on this matter? No, we do not. Then we're looking for a motion. Sandra, is that the action? Yep. Would someone care to put forth a motion?

10:32 I can move. I think I have it up. Move to adopt the attached resolution making findings to allow the PEDC to meet virtually during the COVID-19 pandemic declared emergency. Do we have a second on the motion? Second. There we go. Jamie, how about a roll call? How about a vote? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you, Jamie.

11:07 Now we'll move on to our business matters, and we will start with item 5.1, which is to consider approval of a time extension request 21-001 for a five-year time extension of the Mammoth Hotel project entitlement located at 452 Old Mammoth Road. And Sandra, I'm sorry, who is our staff contact on this? That would be me on this one. Take it away, Sandra. Great, thank you.

11:34 As noted in your staff report, this project is a complete renovation of the existing Sierra Center Mall building. It would create a new four-story, 164-room boutique luxury hotel with restaurant, retail, and office uses associated with it. The approvals that occurred two years ago included a 10% height adjustment to allow for a total building height of 49 feet 6 inches, where 45 feet is the maximum permitted.

12:03 As noted in the staff report, the applicant has been working diligently on moving forward with the project, putting together demolition permit plans, putting together building permit plans. However, the COVID-19 pandemic has caused issues with financing of hotel projects. So the applicant is requesting this five-year time extension request, and staff recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission approve this time extension request.

12:31 and extend this entitlement out for five years. And I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. And we also have Drew Hild, who is the project applicant on the Zoom with us as well. Awesome. So I might ask the commission to hold off on any questions for staff until we have an opportunity to hear from Drew. Drew, would you like to make a presentation or comments? Not a lot of presentation. I could do a brief timeline.

12:59 Many of our members, if not all of them, were present in November 13, 2019 when we approved and you blessed this project and sent us on our way. I was hoping in April of 2020 that I would have been pulling a building permit and starting construction back then, but I think we all know what happened at that time and COVID hit and basically construction loans evaporated and we had to put the project on hold for

13:29 About, you know, 10 months. And the construction financing market eventually came back and our investors said, let's go ahead and pursue our building permit, which currently I think we are about to present a response to comments to building and safety, water district and all the various things. So we're actively pursuing the building permit. Hopefully we'll be pulling it in the next few months. And so.

13:57 The time just kind of went by and all of a sudden it's two years and we realized we needed to get some extension so we could finish off our plan and build the hotel that you all saw and approved back in 2019. Great. Thank you, Drew. At this time to the commission, anybody on the commission have questions for either Sandra or for Drew? You guys are all good. Greg, we don't have... I got one for... Please take it away, Greg. Well, Sandra, you know, one of the...

14:32 things you said in your opening there that we agreed that this would go forward diligently and quickly. Is the applicant, you know, COVID notwithstanding, moving forward on their timeline to satisfaction of staff, or is this something that is not proceeding as quickly as you would like? No, I mean, I think, like I said, the applicant is moving forward diligently. They have put together a demolition permit, so that permit's ready to issue.

15:03 They have gone through building permit plan check and are, as Drew mentioned, they're ready to submit responses to that. So I think considering the pandemic, I think staff is pleased with the process that they've made over the past two years. All right. I did have one quick question for Drew. Please. Hey, Greg. Hey, how you doing? I'm doing good. I really like what you're trying to do here, but one of the things I see being a big problem

15:34 And I was wondering if you could address how you're addressing it, is what's going to happen with trying to get balconies, windows, whatever, through those zero lot line or very narrow lot line walls? And what, if any, agreements do you have with the adjacent landlords to proceed with that? So the way we've approached the zero lot line is we've moved all windows back.

16:04 And that was in the original plan so that a permit was not required to get an agreement with our owners, but we've been in conversation with all the various owners around us. But what we did is instead of having balconies, I think the original plan showed balconies that were right on and out there. And what we've done is the balconies on the north side have been eliminated and we are setting the windows back so that they're within the

16:31 I think it's five feet or I can't remember. That's almost an architect question, to be honest with you. All right. Well, as a developer question, would you say that at this point you do not need agreements from the adjacent landlords to proceed or landowners to proceed? I don't believe that I do. Okay. Those are my questions. Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. I just have a couple of really quick ones. First one for Sandra. Sandra, this request is for a five-year extension.

17:05 The maximum we can allow is six years, is that correct? Yes, so if the applicant didn't move forward in five years, they could come back and ask for another extension for one additional year. And then if that one, if that extra year extension is granted, what would happen if, let's just say for whatever reason, construction did not happen and six years expired?

17:33 They would have to re-entitle the project. So they would have to basically start over. I mean, they could submit with the plans that they've already prepared and kind of go back through the process again. But it just basically means a new entitlement would be required. Got it. And Drew, the question for you is, you understand that I'm sure 100%. Excuse the question. I didn't hear that. I just wanted to make sure you understood the read summary that Sandra just gave on, you know, the maximum extension we can give is six.

18:05 Yes, I understand that. And for all practical purposes, given my partnership, we intend to be under construction this year. So that would not be necessary. This has all taken much longer than we had hoped. And of course, we've had to finance through COVID. And so my partners are very anxious to get going. So we have enabled Gensler, who's our lead.

18:33 architectural consultant along with coming our project management consultants to basically go pedal to the metal and get this done as fast as possible. We're hopeful that every knock on wood, everything works right, you're going to see activity by the spring. Got it. And on that note, Drew, and

18:55 I'll apologize if this question puts you on the spot and feel free to say, you know, if you're not comfortable answering it, but I'm just wondering what kind of conversations you're having with your current commercial tenants on the ground floor and how you see that moving forward with your timeline that you just summarized. So all of our tenants are on a month-to-month basis with a 30-day notice, but more to the point, they're basically all my friends at this point.

19:24 And, you know, we've got ASO, the, Frank McGovern, who's the dentist upstairs, he's moving out in February, and we basically have the food tenants, and I'm gonna, I'm trying to help them find other locations, of which I may be coming back to talk to you all, because I bought a building, I bought the Mammoth Reservations building, and I'm trying to maybe figure out some creative way we might be able to put some of them down there in order to create some, some activity on the street.

19:53 Which requires some kind of creative parking situations, but that's kind of off topic. But, you know, Aki and the sushi place and the gentleman at the taqueria and all the people in the building, Ray Valdez is my tenant at ASO. We're all really good communication. They all know it's coming.

20:18 And I'm, you know, I'm offered to let, you know, the various tenants take whatever improvements like hoods and stuff like that out of the building and move various stuff because I'll just end up demoing everything anyway. So I'm trying to help them as best I can. Thank you, Drew. I appreciate the candor in that answer. Sandra, one last question. And this one, you know, again, apologies. I remember when we had our conversations.

20:47 On this project, one of the areas of uncertainty, and it was a little bit of a sticking point, was who had the design rights for the bus stop out front? And I remember the concept that Drew and his team and Gensler brought was very much a bus stop that looks something out of Venice or Santa Monica, whereas I know the town has got a plan.

21:13 That we have uniformity with the bus stops throughout the community. And I remember Grady was kind of the lead on the town side in that conversation, but any idea or is that something you maybe can get back to us with? Yeah, I mean, I think that we ended up, it's testing my memory, we ended up with wanting to use the town's standard, but I can't quite remember. I don't know, Amy, if you recall, sorry to put you on the spot. Okay.

21:43 So the most recent design that we have worked with Drew and his team on is their design that coordinates with their building, but we've come to some, you know, we made a few modifications, but since the bus shelter is on their property and not within public right-of-way, we did work with them to coordinate their design with their building. I will add.

22:10 Thank you, Amy, for that color, because I do remember our conversation. It was a long time ago. It was a long time ago. Michael, the bottom line is, is the plan that you look at where the bus stop's in the middle and it's very narrow. When we spoke with Amy and I think Nolan was part of those conversations, we said, you know, you wanted to get something that was closer to the dimensions of your standard bus stop and give more protection.

22:35 So I think the resolution, although we'll have to do a final on it when we kind of go through plan check and get your approval, was to move it to the south where we had more land to make it deeper and bigger. And so I think the current design is about the same size, if not exactly the same size as your current bus stop. And it's just nestled to the south entrance, but it has our design that matches the hotel. So we enlarged it and added more protection and moved it so it's not...

23:05 Thank you, Drew. Any other questions for staff or the applicant from the commission? Jamie, do we have any public comment on item 5.1? No, we do not. And nobody's in suite Z? No. Okay. So I'll bring it back to the commission. Anybody have any opinions?

23:35 Anything they want to talk about with this? Or would someone care to put forth a motion? I can make a motion. Please. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required municipal co-findings in approving time extension request 21-001, five-year time extension of the Mammoth Hotel Project Entitlement, DR19-003.

24:09 and ADJ19-002 with condition recommended by staff. Do we have a second? A second. Thank you. Any further conversation? I see three mutes, so I'm assuming not. Jamie, how about a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst?

24:43 Yes, matter is approved, 4-0. Drew, we wish you nothing but the best going forward with this project. I think I can speak on the entire commission. We're very excited about seeing it get underway. Well, I can speak for all of my partners. We would like nothing better than to host an opening party with all of you attending up on that roof, looking at our fantastic view. And if anyone doubts me on that view, I'm happy to give them a personal tour up to the top. It's pretty spectacular.

25:12 Anytime you want, just let me know. We just have to bring our snow shovels at this point. Yeah, that's right. You know, it's funny. I'll leave you with this one little note. Everyone thinks that that building has a ton of snow on top. And what ends up happening is the wind blows it all up. It never gets higher than the parapet, which is, I don't know, two feet. One year, we did have about six feet that mounded because there was no wind and just a big dump. But most of the time, it varies. So it's pretty accessible.

25:40 So don't let that hold you back. Awesome. Thank you, Drew. Appreciate it. I appreciate you taking the time to come before us today. Oh, no, my pleasure. And I've appreciated working with the town and staff and the commission. Thanks much. Take care. With that, I'm going to close business matters and move on to the consent agenda. We have three items on the consent agenda. Of the three, does anyone want to pull any of them? Or would you guys want to make a motion to approve the consent agenda?

26:11 I move to approve the consent agenda. Do we have a second? Second. Any further conversation? Jamie, do we have any public comment on anything on the consent agenda? No, we do not. Okay. May we have a vote, please, Jamie. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Consent agenda passes 4-0. Thank you. Commissioner reports.

26:51 Jessica, you want to give us highlights from New Mexico? No highlights from here, but I just want to say thank you to the town staff and everyone in town that's dealing with this COVID surge, and I don't know how everyone is, how the people in charge are continuing on because it feels so exhausting, but thank you to everyone who is keeping us safe. Thank you. Drive safe the rest of your trip. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, do you have a report you'd like to put forth?

27:22 No, thank you, Chair. Commissioner Eckert. You know, I got not so much report as an insight. This was the first Christmas in almost that I spent outside of Mammoth. I highly recommend it. And if you guys get a chance next year, take advantage of it. There you go. I'll just jump in here and say, for those of us that were in Mammoth during Christmas,

27:56 You know, there was obviously a lot of frustration amongst locals with, you know, the accessibility of some of our town streets. But I know public works worked as hard as they possibly could with their resources that were available. So I just would like to thank the staff that was on the clock for that week for their incredibly hard work.

28:24 It was a thankless job. You're never, ever going to please everyone in this town when it comes to snow removal and snow management. So you guys did a yeoman's job there. The Grand Prix has come and gone and we're still here. And from what I can tell, it was a very successful event. I know Mammoth was showcased beautifully on NBC with the coverage.

28:54 Mammoth Resorts and MLT. We hosted, I think, half a dozen various media outlets that came out personally to watch the Grand Prix. So we should have a very steady drip of positive coverage throughout national media, which is great. I mean, gotta fill those planes and get people here midweek. So it's all good stuff. So with that, I'll close Commissioner Reports and we'll go to Director's Report. Sandra?

29:24 Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. So just a couple brief reports. I will just provide an update on the design committee meetings that occurred since your last meeting. On December 21st, there was a design committee meeting to review a sign permit for Mammoth Pizza Company. This is a new pizza restaurant in the village.

29:49 And the committee recommended approval of that sign. They also considered a design review for 377 Manzanita, which is a new six-unit multifamily apartment project. The committee is also supportive of that design, and that item will come forward to the full commission shortly. And then on January 7th, last Friday, we had an advisory design panel meeting.

30:16 The ADP reviewed the Residence Inn, Boutique Hotel by Marriott. This is located at 94 and 150 Burner Street in the village. They had a number of different comments and the ADP was supportive of allowing staff to review their revised plans and then bring that forward to Planning Commission. And then they also reviewed the Sierra Nevada Resort Redevelopment.

30:43 And kind of a very similar comments. They had comments to the applicant on that, and they were supportive of allowing staff to determine whether or not this item needed to come back to Planning Commission. And then the other item I wanted to provide an update on is the community conversation for COVID-19 will occur tomorrow, Thursday, January 13th at 5.30 p.m. It will be bilingual.

31:10 And if anyone has any questions about it or would like to sign up, it will be live on the Mono County Health Department Facebook page. And then if you just take a look at the town's website, it's right on the front page of our website, so you can click and find the link there as well. So that will be a good way to find out what's going on with COVID-19 in our community. And that's all I have. So Sandra, I've got a quick question, but also I just want to add to what you said about the community coffee.

31:39 There will be some pretty robust representation from the school district in that conversation. So I don't know if the news made it out to New Mexico, but our kids have reverted back to virtual learning. And right now it's in a kind of a probationary three-week period through the end of January. And I know there's some pretty strong feelings out there on that situation. So if anybody is listening to this and they want more information,

32:08 or they want some questions answered, that would be an ideal time to do it. And back to your, just the property you were talking about in the village, you said the residence in by Marriott, where is that going, Sandra? That's at 94 and 150 Burner Street, which is where Skatey is. That's the existing building there. It used to be called the Vista Point Project, kind of behind the parking lot on Burner Street.

32:37 So that item will come before the Planning Commission in the next couple months for entitlements. But that AVP meeting was really just talking about the design at this point. Got it. Is there any place that that meeting was recorded that somebody could go back and look at it? It wasn't recorded on our, on Granicus like this meeting, or e-scribe like this meeting was. But I can provide you the minutes of it. I can, the minutes are available. We'll be available. We're working on them right now. Thank you, Sandra.

33:08 You're welcome. That's it from me. Any questions for Sandra on the director's report from the commission? Well, considering we started two minutes late, 31 minutes. I do believe that's a new record, guys. So I appreciate the three of you that attended to this meeting and staff as well. Thank you so much. Keep up the hard work. And with that, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting until our next regularly scheduled meeting on February 9th, 2022.

33:41 So thank you, everyone. Appreciate your time. Jessica, drive safe.