TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2023

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

at 13:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

216 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:47 Deb is on the screen, but she's the other way. She's on the screen. All right, let's bring the meeting to order. Angie, go ahead with roll call, please. Thank you. Chair Goyko? Present. Vice Chair Foster? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here.

1:50 Secretary Mendel? Here. Board Member Clark is absent. Board Member Crabb is absent. Board Member Radcliffe? Here. Board Member Souser is absent. And Board Member Magner? Here. Thank you. Awesome. Thank you, Angie. Board Member Reports, do I have any, anybody want to go first? I'll go first. Go ahead, John. Thank you. The only report I have is that, again, we are all desperately needing staff and I'm hoping that

2:20 I'm hoping that the town and town council will take a look again at potentially looking at the issue of maybe rental subsidies, trying to get some of the people that are renting short-term to rent long-term again, because it's going to be a while, even with the parcel and other things coming online, it's going to be a while before we're whole in this town, and right now at full occupancy, it is brutal. I mean, we're getting through it, but it is so hard and so exhausting for everybody, and I know that the quality of guest experience is not

2:50 As good as it should be because we don't have people. So we can't wait three, four, five years to get enough people here. We really need to look up some other options of getting people, getting some more staff. So anyway, I'll keep beating on them for that. But I hope they consider a blended approach. I think what they're doing is great with buying property and the parcel and all that. I applaud them for that. But we need more people in town right now. So whatever we can do to do that would be.

3:14 Wonderful, and if everybody has a big tent, we can put up and put people underneath it, my CRC maybe, until it's finished, I don't know, just, anyway, we're all a little tired, but it's been good. I hear you, John, I hear you. Pat, you want to? I don't have any comments at this point. Sounds good, thanks. Nor do I. Mr. Mendel? Likewise, except that we just shared we really don't want to have to make a bunk bed again. More bunk beds. The Lodging Association.

3:40 You do have Darlene on, not Darlene, you've got Deb on that. Oh, that's right. Deb, do you have any board comments? No, I ditto exactly what John said, so. You know, my one comment, we had a fantastic community coffee and Hayes from the town went over the massive project that is snow removal in Mammoth Lakes when you have three weeks of, you know, 200 plus inches of snow.

4:10 And it was remarkable. It was really cool to kind of see the whole process and, you know, ask questions about, you know, the routes and how they go about doing things and all things like that. So kudos to Hayes and his team, Public Works, Town of Mammoth Lakes and all the guys. I know there's, you know, a bunch of construction companies that are, you know...

4:33 I heard from the guy who's the inspector at the snow pit that they were doing about a thousand loads, a thousand truck loads in, you know, a 12 to 18 hour period. And it makes a huge difference. You know, last week we couldn't park here. Last week, you know, there was nowhere to park anywhere. And now, you know, things are opening up, much safer on the roads, actually able to, you know, not come into...

5:01 20-foot walls of snow and you can't see any, you know, it's much safer. So appreciate all the hard work that people are putting in for snow removal. I know those guys, you know, we really appreciate it. So thank you. Those are my comments. Do we have any public comments? I don't think... I mean, I can address the fact that the letter was mailed to all the businesses that are affected. I think we are going to talk about it today. It is a moving target. There are a lot of things that are happening on a daily basis.

6:32 We had new things come to light yesterday that are disheartening and concerning. We've got multiple attorneys working with us on this, but I'm not sure that we have any full answers for you on that. Thank you. Any other public comments? No comments at this time. All right. We do have a guest presentation, Mammoth Lakes Mural Project, Mel North.

7:51 Thank you.

8:20 All right. The mic's not working. Thank you. And so we have about 10 minutes, so I'm going to give my, I'm going to look to Kristen to give me my umpire signals when we get to eight minutes, and then I will open it up for questions and comments.

9:22 So the Mammoth Mural Project at its core operates from guiding principles that centers inclusivity, social diversity, accessibility, local economy, cultural reconciliation, minority acknowledgement and upliftment, environmental regeneration, and the power of story through the arts as a vehicle for change through our greater community awareness, belonging, involvement, and togetherness, which directly shapes the future of this place we call home.

9:53 The Mammoth Mural Project is a high-concept public arts program designed to be a town-wide mural tour that journeys our public through a series of murals and audio dialogue of foundational stories of the people that have called Mammoth Lakes home throughout time. The five initial mural narratives are our Indigenous heritage story, mining history, early ski history, water rights, water wars,

10:18 and our Latinx community heritage to show how people have related with the land and each other throughout time and how we may become more knowledgeable of our past in order to shape how we relate with our future, laying a foundation for generations to come. One...

10:35 gorgeous aspect of this project is that we're creating storyboard councils. So for each of those five initial mural narratives that we're doing, we are sourcing from tribal chairpersons, wisdom keepers, environmental directors, and local historians to come up with what needs to be told, knowing that the responsibility of the story that they tell is going to shape many people's awareness that come to our town.

11:05 So I'm going to put that down. An important part is we're going to have the visual murals, and then we're going to have access through QR code, the audio dialogue, and so that's what the public will be able to access. We'll have that initial dialogue, that storytelling. It's going to be about the length of a song.

11:29 And then after that, we are going to have different invitations to what we call the activism part of this project. And that's going to be all of our local organizations that are initiating cultural and environmental regeneration and other things that are really important to us as a community. Another important aspect of this, and we're working with a chamber with this, they're going to be the organizing body. And we're calling this our arts.

11:57 economy incentive. So to change the perception of Mammoth Lakes in people's minds into more of an artistic, supportive community, what we're going to do in this aspect is have an economical incentive for each mural that's going to be rotating.

12:17 And this is going to give a highlight of our small local businesses. So not only will they be able to offer a little discount to our public, but we'll also have a short bio. And so we're hoping that this part of the project will also just bring more awareness to our small local businesses and amplify that economy in that way as well. So let's go to some fun parts, which are pictures.

12:45 I was joking earlier saying there's some scratch and sniff. I'll leave that up to you if that's really true. So the next page over the first two pictures, these are the pictures of where I got the inspiration for this project. My friend curates these walls in Telluride, Colorado. So the first image is We the People by Shepard Ferry. The second image is What We Do to the Mountains We Do to Ourselves.

13:14 The third, you can actually see on that second image, the person on the ladder, they're doing the pay step style, which is what we're after as well. I'm getting the eight minute, or five minute, okay.

13:32 So the paste-up mural process, this will allow us to not only make these murals very resistant to the weather, and I have the perfect recipe from my colleague in Telluride, who they have a similar climate as we do, but this is also going to allow us to create original work, so outside of the traditional muralist style, we'll be able to collage historical photographs, landscape photographs, and with original artworks.

14:00 So once those audio narrations are completed by the storyboard councils, we'll send out a call to artists all over the Sierras, and Kristen will be perfect for this because of all of her affiliations with our neighboring arts councils, and they will then go over some of the submitted artwork.

14:21 So the third image is a picture of Reno's Midtown Mural Tour and this is one of the ways that we are intending to market this as an alternative activity to some of our high strenuous recreation we have here so folks will be able to access a map and go to each mural and again this project is starting with five and so we hope that it will be precedent setting and that we can bring more public arts.

14:50 And perhaps we'll be able to see as many red bubbles as we see here. Going on to the next image. The next three images are example pictures of a collage artist that we are hoping to work with. Her name is Mary Young. She's an indigenous artist out of Tongvalan out of L.A. And so she would be the primary collager that would take our historical photographs and landscape.

15:17 photographs and the original works. So these are just examples of what our images could look like. Again, her work is mostly indigenous based and other relatives, but we would include, for example, in our early ski history, you can imagine Dave and Roma McCoy and other foundational images. These will all be decided later. Let's see, I think.

15:47 The only other thing, oh, and with that tour, I've spoken with John Urdi as well, and they signed on to beginning conversations about how to market this as well, so that will come into more form as things progress. And before I open it up to conversation,

16:07 The number six on the front page, the public arts revival, this feels really important. There is something kindling in our town about reviving the public arts. And not only is it up for a public arts commission to revive this summer, it's been kind of dissolved over the last years, but there has been profound talk of how this can diversify our economy.

16:33 and how we can bring in creative solutions through the arts in this way. And yeah, so we are excited about how this project would initiate more of this. So thank you. Any burgeoning questions? Yes. Have you identified places in town where those might go? Exactly, yeah. So that's... That's one of...

17:15 That's one of our biggest hurdles. We do have some beautiful viable walls. We're working with the business and building owners right now. One, for example, is our Quality Inn wall. They have a gorgeous...

17:29 It was that east-facing wall. And so we're just awaiting a waiver for full passing of this project. And for example, for future vision, we want to pave ADA accessibility as well and turn it into kind of a garden space or at least a more hospitable space for each mural site. But for other murals, we're even looking at Superior Court, seeing if we can kind of monkey wrench our way into that beautiful facade wall that's perpendicular.

17:58 to the highway there. We are talking with Mammoth Brewing Company. We're talking with Footloose. Those are some of our initial walls, knowing that that process is going to probably take the longest. And just to let you know as well, we have had this project passed.

18:19 Through its initial stages through the planning department, they're really excited about this. Of course, we need actual walls and images for them to fully pass it. We're also looking at an alternative route as well. Say we can't get walls, like you're talking about, of having some structural facade walls. Much like interpretive, say on like the loop, the bike loop, interpretive structure, something like that, but quite large.

18:47 and would be in a place that would be appropriate and not blocking anything. So we're looking at different avenues as well. You typically have a, is there like a minimum size that you would look for? I mean, just off the top of my head, we have a lot of those little bus route huts too, which I'm trying to think what they look like and I know it belongs to the town and stuff, but you know, there are some spaces there that are kind of blank and they're only maybe by eight or something like that, but.

19:14 Thank you for that suggestion. I like art of all sizes, but I think for this project, really, to have it have the exposure that it needs to, we're looking for quite large. So I'd say at least 20 feet high, like 20 by 10, and ideally with high exposure to Old Mammoth and the highway.

19:36 Just because for this initial project. And that's the idea of this first phase, having it really exposed and having a high volume for this tour. And then once that precedent is set, then we can lead our public into more of the woodwork of Mammoth and bring them into perhaps more hidden places once they know that this exists for our town.

20:02 If you can convince the owner of Rite Aid, yes, please, because Rihanna and I know we hit a wall, pun intended. Any other questions, comments? Thank you so much, Mel. Yes. What exactly is this for? What are we filling out? You need signatures for what? Okay. All right. Sounds good.

20:41 We will pass that around to the board. Just leave that one up there. Thank you so much, Mel. Thank you, Kristen. Appreciate the update on the project there, and best of luck moving forward with that. Consent agenda. Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I'll make a motion to approve. Second. John Morris with the motion. Second. Second from John Mendel. And roll call on that, right? Yes.

21:12 Chair Goico? Yes. Vice Chair Foster? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Board Member Radcliffe? Yes. And Board Member Magner? Yes. Thank you. All right, moving on to policy matters. Quarter 2 Budget Variance Report. Get us going there, John. Yeah, and just a note that we will be pausing wherever we are in the board meeting to hold our closed session at 1.45.

21:42 So if we need to pause this process, then we will. So we're going to go through this fairly quickly. This is our quarterly update on variances in the budget. And as you can see in the revenue side, the good news is the variances are all positive. Those are all just because of the numbers that we've seen. As you know, we budgeted TBID fairly aggressively this year at $6.3 million based on last year's actual $6.44.

22:10 I thought it was going to be a bit of a stretch, and obviously Mother Nature has helped us immensely, so I anticipate those numbers continuing to be in the black and moving up. One that is missing here, it says the sponsorships for special events is short by $10,000. I'm happy to report that as of last week, Dakota has secured $20,000 from United Airlines and Inc., which is their publication company, so that was something that was prior to this P&L.

22:37 And then the King Sponsorship, we have not, we just received the invoice to pay the King, so we haven't received the revenue from the town. That's part of the Tourism Reserve, as it has been for the last five years, contracted through the town. So that's why that's a short revenue, and you'll see down below that it's also short in the expense side for Brian. Employee benefits, that number is up. That's actually, it's not a real cash number. That's the value, the fringe benefit of my personal use of the company car.

23:05 That's for my tax purposes more than anything, but it's not a cash expense. In the overhead, we've got our staffing line is up 1.9%. We originally had Jetsabel's position budgeted through September to help us through the summer. Jets has been an incredible addition to the team. And so we have opted to keep her on board. And so that's where we are most of that number.

23:30 Legal services are up. We've had a number of different things that are being reviewed and assistance from our attorneys. I think that number is going to continue to grow as we move forward here. The next line, promotional items, the description is obviously wrong. I copied that line and moved it up to the benefits. That is just timing on us ordering promotional items. It's been a challenge with some of the supply chain issues. TBID renewal expenses are up on budget.

24:00 They were budgeted in fiscal 21-22 when we were planning on getting the renewal squared away, and when that didn't happen, they obviously got carried into this year. And then the last one on overhead, before I turn it over to Brian, is when we signed on with Insperity, there were some upfront costs that were not budgeted for the HR services. So even though that line is not something that's in the budget, that it will reflect in savings and other categories. So from there, I'll turn to Brian to talk marketing.

24:29 Have you guys gotten any more of those license plates, borders with the real and real yet? I'm looking forward to those. Not yet. Not yet? They're coming. All right, good. I need some. Peak is on it. Yeah, they were all excited. They have a whole string of stuff they're doing right now, which is fantastic. Air subsidy, just the timing of subsidies, which John talked about, about paying United, paying United, again, with the King's contract, that moved to...

24:58 3-1, so that just got submitted today, actually. The collateral distribution, the certified folder, we were able to stretch out our 22 visitor guide distribution, just one more month, which gave us another $7,000, so we'll be able to stretch that out again. They were just delivered this last week, and if you haven't seen one yet, I didn't bring one with me. Sorry about that, but they're beautiful. Emily, well done. You did a great job on this.

25:21 Zardaka, from a research perspective, we did, this is the same thing we had last time, the new vendor incentive to pay early, that was due this month, so that should, that will par out next quarter, as well as the travel adventure shows, we paid for three shows to get there for prices too, and that was budgeted April to May of this year. Timing on lodging reservations, we were up as well as some unplanned travel to New York and some other things that we did there too, but that'll all parry out at the end of the year as well.

25:49 The Unreal Winter Assets, we had that prepayment of the $150 last year in the fiscal, and then we had a Matador shoot that was scheduled for December. We moved it with all the storms that were coming until later January, and I'll talk a little bit more about the shoot itself during my update, but it's pretty good stuff. I'm excited to share with you guys that. The selection of the new website, as we said, we moved that to January from a selection process.

26:14 So that is, we had $300,000 for the entire year set aside, so that's being pushed back toward the end of the year. And then the media for the winter assets, we did a lot of that up front because with the launch of the new campaign, we paid a lot of that up front and now, but that's all going to, of course, this is the timing thing as well. The U.S. Travel Association, U.S. travel dues were paid in January.

26:35 Those are paid just ahead of time. And then the travel packages. So the giveaway and promotions, we have some money set aside for contest winners. We do contests with the Anaheim Ducks, with the LA Kings for our giveaways that we do at Cal Travel and that kind of stuff we pay for. And they're coming this month and next month. We've already got some folks coming in. So we have that spread out, but they'll be coming in this month. So that's where we are there. Good afternoon.

27:06 Mine is pretty basic. You can see on the right-hand column, it's pretty much all a function of timing. None of the figures for the sales variances tend to be very large. The largest one is about 30,000. Advertising, just waiting for some opportunities, 2023. Other than that, they're pretty small figures, and rest assured the money will be used, 2023. Any questions on the sales variance? Thank you. Thanks, Michael. Communications and PR.

27:43 Also pretty straightforward, the ones that are under timing so that those travel expenses for media will be used. And then the two overages, one was the Travel Writers Conference went over a little bit on some of the transportation. That was also some timing issues with our

28:12 Contract with the Mammoth Track Club, which is kind of starting sooner that I had budgeted for, and same with sponsorship, just some overage with the travel riders, the transportation fee. We've got to get that year-round air service, huh? Somebody steal the other mic?

29:01 Everyone can hear me now. To go to the other special events, we'll keep this brief. My advertising line item encompasses a whole bunch of different things in there, so there's a percentage of stuff that's made up throughout this. The biggest and the most exciting two things for me are special events tracking, which we had budgeted for before the holidays with the help of Brian. We're finally getting going. I'm super excited.

29:25 And that's just over $10,000 worth of that. And then we have about $15,000 worth of the $30,000 in here that we have for our event print posters and everything like that. Historically, we've done those earlier in the year. We figured out that a lot of event producers don't actually have everything together last year for their event for this year. So we push that back to be in time with the closing of our special event funding, which it is right now. Other than that, there's a bunch of smaller things in there that, once again, will get spent. They just haven't been. Any questions? Cool.

29:56 Thanks. Just a quick question. Does the board find this useful, us doing these quarterly updates? Does it provide information on kind of where we are managing the budgets? Yeah, I think so, for sure. I mean, it's good to see, you know, obviously you've timed things the best you can, but obviously we know there are timing things that come up that can't be foreseen, so yeah, that's good. All right, so we'll move to the winter air service update, and you're just getting your... Yeah, I don't know if my...

30:32 For some reason my computer's not cooperating here, but what I can do is I can just, the information, here we go, the information in the packet is kind of that updated graph that I've been sharing with you through last week's booking report, and it continues to be very strong. I think it's all pretty self-explanatory. The Denver number keeps growing as far as the numbers that were up over last year, and again, these are round trips. One thing that we just received was we looked at the United expenses for the month of December.

31:04 We actually had a net positive compared to last year of 369 passengers. That's over the three flights we had last year. So we had two flights this year with Denver and San Francisco. We had 369 more passengers than we did with the extra flight last year. So the net is actually 1,000 more people coming in via those flights. So good news there. The subsidies were down slightly to last year. The challenges, the expenses are still up.

31:31 So even eliminating the $77,000 in expense for LAX last year, the fuel costs and all the other operating costs have gone up 20%, 30%. And so the gap between last year's subsidy and this year's subsidy was not as impressive as I had hoped because of the load factors in the fares. But we're hoping that the next two months continue to grow there and hopefully the fuel costs start to normalize a little bit as well. So we are talking summer service with...

32:01 The airlines. And right now it looks like we'll be starting United Service late June and running that through early September. All the dates and schedules should be finalized here in the next couple of months, but we don't have that finalized right now. When's the next time that we'll get an update of originations for our service? I'm really curious, especially with Denver and San Francisco, but I'm also curious about Hawthorne since it's so close to LAX. How many people are flying into LAX from wherever and then hopping on a Hawthorne flight up here?

32:32 That's a good point, and I don't know if Brian can speak to – I don't know that we get origination data from advanced airlines, which is challenging, but obviously United – They may not have. Yeah, they – Yeah, I guess we can potentially ask them for a zip code analysis of the people that bought the airline ticket. That might be a survey thing or something. Well, and we are – and we will be doing – we have been doing quite a few surveys in Bishop, and we will be doing surveys in –

32:58 Mammoth Yosemite as well to make sure that we understand the people that are coming in on advanced flights, you know, where they're staying, what they're doing, how they're getting around. They should be able to give us a zip code. The zip code analysis should be very, at the very least. And United is not always the easiest immovable object to get information out of. A great partner, but some of the O&D data, they hold a little close to their chest and it's harder for us to get it. You guys get that once a month, once every couple months, ongoing? I think we get it when we beg for it. Oh, okay.

33:27 Okay. Just curious. Yep. So we don't really have it as an ongoing. We do have the surveys that help us tell where people are coming from. And that is what I had on the air service report. I think on the next topic here, I'm not sure we really want to get too deep into the TBID renewal update, so I guess I would say we can jump maybe to the financial report.

33:56 Yeah, let's go to the financial report, and then that should put us at time for our closed session, and then we'll come back and pick up with the TBID renewal update. Yeah, sure. So the financial report, the TOT for the month of December came in at $4.3 million. That's well ahead of budget, as usual. It was a record high compared to last year by $302,000, which is about 7.6%. Year-to-date, the town is well ahead of budget. I do anticipate, based on where we are right now,

34:25 That will probably end up the year around 27.5. That's my initial thought. We'll have to wait and see what the next few months numbers look like to really hone that in. The TBID collections for the month of December came in also higher than budget. Again, we were pretty aggressive with the budget, so that was a pleasant surprise. Record high December on TBID was almost $100,000 ahead of last December's record.

34:49 So year to date, we are about 7% ahead of where we were for budget, and we are now ahead of last year. I think that's the big thing, too. Even with the TOT, it's ahead of last year. You know, that's the amazing thing. So we're almost $300,000 ahead of the TOT and $115,000, $116,000 ahead of the TBID. So last year being a high water mark to be ahead of that currently with the current snow conditions, with knowing that you're booked through, you know, at least weekends through the end of...

35:18 March and weekends being booked drives midweek, and so even our midweek occupancy this week is in the 60s coming up. The bank balances you can see there, the CDARS, again, we've moved some money out of the TBID CDARS in order to pay up front with United and with the special event CDARS. Right now we have it scheduled to pull some money out of that for the event grant funding, which the process closed yesterday.

35:47 It may be that when we have the increase in the revenues that are coming in that we don't have to go in and touch those dollars. So that will be important. The tourism reserve, which is shared with the town, is currently balanced at $905,000. So that is that. Oh, and then we also provided the town with the financial audit for fiscal year 21-22.

36:12 in January as per our planning calendar with them. So that was on schedule. Any questions? I just think it's really interesting if you look at December, you know, going back to, I don't know, my glasses on, 2015, I think, you know, we had a 2.2, 2.3, 2.3, 2.5, 2.8, and then obviously the COVID year, and now 4 point, almost 4.4. That's a 50% increase from 2019 in December for TOT. I think, I think we're also charging a little bit more.

36:43 Anyway, that's funny. Yep. So at this point, I would say let's exit this Zoom and we're going to set the other Zoom up for a session so that our other board members can join us on that. All right. All right. Join us on the other line, Eric. Yep, we'll be right there. Okay. All right. Okay, we are back. All right, I think we're back now. I think we're good now. I think so. All right.

47:52 Nothing to report from closed session. We will continue where we left off on policy matter 6.3 with the Tourism Business Improvement District renewal update. Why don't you get us started here, John? And, you know, we'll, obviously, we've got a couple things to discuss and clarify. Yeah, so I think, you know, with the TBID renewal, I'll just go over kind of where we are with the process.

48:19 In the packet, you've got the timeline for the TBID, and that is still the plan as far as where we're going. And the plan will be to start the petition process here this week with our board members reaching out to the different businesses in their categories and looking to get those petitions signed. The management district plan is also in here.

48:45 I think there's only one change. After Jeremy and I had a call today, I noticed that our appeal process was not updated in the Management District Plan the way that it should. Basically, when we renewed the TBID in 2018, we decided that the appeals process is a three-year process, so we'll have it done in September through October of 21, excuse me, 23. Then those businesses that have appealed won't need to appeal again until 26.

49:14 Any business can appeal at any time. A new business, if there's a change in business levels up or down, they can come back to us at any time. But that was just not clear in there that the appeals process was not cumbersome where in the 10-year process they have to appeal every year. So it's basically appealed in 2023 initially, 2026, 2029, during the 10-year period. So that is the plan there. All of the documents are listed within the board packet.

49:43 Management District Plan, the petition itself. The key thing that we need people to understand is when they're signing the petition, we need all four pages of the petition back, not just the signature paper. We need to get all four pages back so that when we submit them, that's all complete in the packet. Is there no less cumbersome way to do that? I mean, that just seems like a massive amount of paper. I get it. I agree with you a thousand percent.

50:09 I have asked our attorneys and they said that is the way that the law is written. That's how they get turned back in. So I agree a thousand percent that it's a waste of paper. But anyway, I think that it's important for us to make sure that we get those back in as that. The only question I had for the board is that the letter that we are including with the mailings and also anything online, currently it has my signature at the bottom of it.

50:37 I think that it would be probably best to have our board chair or our entire board represented at the bottom of the letter showing that it's coming from the organization, not necessarily from the executive director. If that works for everyone, I would just need to know whether it's coming from Jeremy or it's coming from our board members listing what segments you represent as well. Yeah, I would say at a minimum the board members that represent the segments up on the TBID.

51:04 I would agree. I think, again, it comes from the entire organization. Okay. That's all I had, really, on the TBID renewal. We are looking to – we'll be getting the mailing out by the end of the week here. The letter was really kind of the last piece that we wanted to make sure that we had the clarity on.

51:33 The websites are being updated. Everything's all set and ready to go. The management district plan will be finalized, and you can direct people to MLTBID to see all those documents, and we will get that mailing out. And then petitions, we need to get the petitions back by the 21st of February with the idea that we can turn them into the town on the 22nd. In order for us to petition for the resolution of intent to form and come to town council on March 1st,

52:01 We have to have at least 51% voting at that point. We can continue to update the number as other pieces come in, as other petitions come in. I think I mentioned to the board, the first time we did this, the approval was 63%, the second time was 61%. Our goal is at least 66%, supermajority. And so that would be what we want to try and get in for March 1st. Ultimately, I think that we can get up over 70% petition.

52:30 positive petitions, and we can continue to update the council when we come back to some of these public meetings and public hearings on where we are with that process. So the other thing that I wanted to talk about here, and we don't have a slide for it with regards to the TBID renewal because I know it's coming up. We're all getting phone calls on it. We did send out a letter that Civitas, Civitas, who's our attorneys for the TBID,

52:57 reached out to me right around Thanksgiving, explained that the state had someone, the finance committee or the taxes and fees committee had interpreted the sales tax code. Written opinion. Yeah, written opinion, and they interpreted the sales tax code differently than it had been before, and that now they felt that the TBID should be charged on the assessment. So when I sent out some information to the, sales tax should be charged on the TBID assessment.

53:27 The example I gave the board was you buy a $10 t-shirt at Footloose and it used to be that the sales tax was on the $10 and the TBID was 15 cents. Now they're saying that it needs to be on the $10 and 15 cents. So the difference on that 15 cents is .665. So it's not even a penny. That's not the problem. So moving forward, we know that the problems are that the systems can't tax an assessment and we don't have that capability.

53:56 So I'm not sure what the state expects people to do or how they expect to do that. They don't like you commingling your sales tax with any other things. I know that there are some places that have TBID and sales tax rolled in because, again, they have problems with the systems. Now, adding a third element to that of charging the additional 7.75 on the TBID amount causes a problem with systems. The bigger problem that came to us yesterday was the idea that we had a restaurant that had been audited.

54:25 And it came back that they said basically even though this is something, this is a new interpretation of the sales code, they were looking at it saying that they're going to go retroactively for three years, not only charge the sales tax, but then also charge the penalties and interest for the three years. And for this restaurant group that owns two restaurants, it was $28,000. And that's a 40% interest rate on the penalties. So, you know, the actual sales tax amount may not have been

54:55 A huge amount, but then when you start to compound all these challenges. So where we are with this process right now, John Lambeth, who is our TBID attorney, he wrote the TBID, the 1994 TBID law. He had reached out to the Taxes and Fees Administration saying, this is not right, you can't really tax an assessment. They came back and said, we can, and we are. The next step is to get more

55:19 More involvement. So I have a call with John Lambeth at 3.30 today. I've got a call with Michael Colantuno, who's our revenue, municipal revenue attorney. I did have a call right before our meeting with Visit California and their attorney. So I think we've just got to get the firepower behind it. I don't know what the next steps are. I don't know that a letter writing campaign for businesses is going to do much. I don't know if a class action lawsuit is the way to go. I don't know if we can get them to get away from the

55:48 The retroactivity of it, because there are some businesses in town that this is going to result in tens to hundreds to millions of dollars in back payments. And unlike the TBID where you can pass it along to somebody if you're moving forward, you can pass along the sales tax, you can't pass along to somebody that ate in your restaurant three years ago. And so this is talking about coming out of your pocket, which is hugely, it's a huge frustration.

56:15 Ken Brengel and I have brought this to the attention of CalTravel. We have a board meeting next week. It's going to be a major conversation with the Government Relations Committee to make sure that this is elevated because right now it only affects a handful of TBIDs in the state. Obviously, we have sales tax on restaurant and retail. North Lake Tahoe just put a TBID in with restaurant and retail. There are certain wine districts in Temecula and up in the Napa Valley area that charge TBID on wine tastings.

56:44 There are only a handful of us that it truly affects right now, but in speaking with Ron Cohen from Mammoth Mountain today, his question was, are the civic fees in the village next? You know, is TOT next? You know, TOT is a local tax. Now do you have to charge something on top of that for the state? So there are a lot of things out here that this could just be a stepping stone to much bigger problems for many more businesses than we currently have. Right now, this, in the town of Mammoth Lakes,

57:13 It affects probably between 175 and 200 businesses. We mailed out the letter two weeks ago. I think the list was 175. It probably has a few restaurants that are multiple. One owner owns multiple restaurants. But 175 to 200 different people in town that it affects. But in the grand scheme of things, this could be millions and millions of dollars. I'm sure it's the state's way to try and mop up the however many billions of dollars budget deficit that they're facing. It's not going to make a dent.

57:43 Bottom line is that we've got a long road ahead of us to fight this, and the biggest thing, again, is making sure that we fight the retroactivity of it, because that will put people out of business. The conversation that I had earlier was the state has done everything they could over COVID to keep people in business, and then all of a sudden now we're going to throw people under the bus and have them pay $30,000, $40,000, $50,000, $60,000 in back fees.

58:09 Short story long is we need to get the legal system involved. We need to figure out what our opportunities are and what we can do to fight this. Again, Ken and I will meet with the Government Relations Committee for CalTravel. Again, CalTravel is the advocacy wing for California tourism. Visit California is now very, very well aware of this. Carolyn Boteta, who heads up Visit California, she is well behind us.

58:34 Even though it doesn't affect their assessment because their assessment is protected not to charge sales tax, et cetera. And so... How is their assessment set up to be protected against sales tax but ours isn't? Because it was a legislative action. Okay. And it was written in there as a legislative action. So I have a little bit different technical question you might ask, Ernie. Yep. Since TBID...

59:04 is already taxed. That's taxed money. That's after tax. TBID is an assessment. So TBID is not taxed. But I'm saying, if it's already, if it's taxed at the time of, say, receipt, it's already taxed. So does that mean that MLT operates tax-free in the future? I'm playing devil's advocate. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I hear you. It's pre-tax income, post-tax income.

59:35 I assume we pay tax on everything we do, right? On tax, but now going forward, this money has already been taxed at the state level, so we pay tax on it again? That's a good question. That's a good point. Yeah, because this is our funding. Right. So you either collect tax on income, and then it's post-tax, right? So you can't, I don't think you can have it both ways. I'm sure that someone will argue you can, but it just seems to me that

1:00:05 If you tax it at the time of the source, then it's post-tax. It's done. Right. That's a good question. I will bring that up. Yeah, I think the argument was that, you know, and unfortunately, there are a lot of people that think the TBID is a tax, and they're saying, well, you can't tax a tax. Well, unfortunately, the TBID is an assessment, not a tax. You can also argue the tangibility of it, too. Well, and that is the argument to me, is that you're not, a sales tax is on a tangible item. You buy a T-shirt, it's on the T-shirt.

1:00:34 The assessment on that is not a tangible item. And I think that's one of the arguments that we need to have out there. Now, the businesses that have been audited so far can appeal. And we all know how that works. You may have a $30,000 charge. You appeal it. Your interest continues to rack up. It could be $5,000 when it's all said and done, or it could be they knock off $5,000 and call it good. But again, for a lot of our businesses, this could be a death knell. And after all the efforts that the state has done to...

1:01:01 Give loans and do this and do that. This seems like it's a backwards move. So I don't have all the answers. The idea that the retroactivity of it came to me yesterday, and that's why I've circled as many of the attorneys that I can to get everyone's opinions on how we move forward, because originally I thought it was going to be a nuisance trying to figure out how to get the systems to work with the new process.

1:01:25 But now the problem is more about... As I said, I think I spent two hours with our point-of-sale provider. There's absolutely no way to do this. So you're going to have to change the pricing on your product, which then is commingling to add. And they don't want you to commingle it. So the Shopkeep system is... Well, and Square is the same way. Shopkeep is a nationwide POS system. I use Square. I've been through the same process with my Square representative.

1:01:54 He's like, there's no way to do what you're asking. That's right. You know, I use another, you know, custom software. I reached out to my CEO at Black Tie. He's like, I don't think this is going to happen. He's like, I will ask, but, like, I don't see this being a possibility. So, like, you know, that's what's so, and then.

1:02:18 You know, looking in arrears at the retroactivity that they're starting to penalize for is incredibly concerning, but, you know, to put something in place that you cannot facilitate, you know, is also concerning. So, you know, how do we deal with, you know, both of these situations? I don't know. John, I know RTB is basically 10 years old.

1:02:44 The other ones that are affected, how far back did those go? Did any of them go back as far as 10 years? No, no, no, no. North Lake Tahoe just went in place a year, year and a half ago. Temecula Wine District's probably been in place for two years. Napa's probably had maybe a year, maybe two. I guess my question is always, well, you know, it's been in place for a period of time. No CPA's ever had a question about it. No, I mean, you know, there's never...

1:03:08 When did all of a sudden the aha light go on that we can get these guys for not? Well, that's one of the arguments is that it's basically they're coming back and saying, I know you didn't know about this three years ago, but you should have charged me. We're going to penalize you anyway. And we're going to penalize you anyway. So I think that's because when this first came to me and I looked at it and I talked to John, I had a call from Tom Cage last Friday saying, hey, he faced this with something else years and years and years ago, and he ended up having to go retro three years on something.

1:03:35 And so I said, I don't think it's retro because I believe it's new. The tax code is not new. The interpretation is new. But again, the interpretation, I don't know how that you're not a mind reader. You couldn't have charged it three years ago to be prepared for this. And now it comes out of your pocket versus being a pass along. So I think that's one of the big arguments that we need to focus on is that if this is a new interpretation, then it needs to be from here moving forward.

1:04:00 And even from here moving forward with the systems problems, they need to explain how you do it. If we can't figure it out on our side, you tell us how our systems are going to work this because it's not, you know, and they may come back and say, we don't care, you owe us this much money, whether it comes out of your pocket or you raise your rate or whatever you do, this is what you now owe us. So there are still, unfortunately, there are still a lot of unanswered questions. Yesterday's conversation about the retroactive side of it.

1:04:27 It was incredibly disheartening because that scares the hell out of me because we do have some businesses in town that that could eventually add up to millions of dollars in penalties and fees and interest and the tax itself. And that's not something anybody wants to write a check for. Now, as far as the TBID renewal, whether we renew the TBID now or not is not going to change that. You know, I think that the TBID renewal moving forward, again, figuring out the systems is one thing.

1:04:56 But if we even said right now that we're not going to renew the TBID on restaurant and retail, they're still going to come after you for three years or however long they want to go back to say, hey, you still owe us this. We don't care that the TBID's gone. You still owe us from this period. So when we are talking to... I'm a bad example. Right. But in general, I think that we need to have that as part of the conversation is that we need to continue on with the TBID renewal and we need to fight this battle simultaneously.

1:05:25 And so that's where we are. I think that's got to be part of our discussion though, John. Absolutely. What we are doing. And that was the point of my note. Yes. Yeah. The whole idea of leadership. What are we going to do about this? Yeah. Well, you know, it's very concerning because as we go to these businesses and ask for their, you know, vote in favor of the TBID, you know, now they have a concern that they're being audited for what happened in years past and they may not give us their signature, you know. Well, on questions.

1:05:55 We can't answer. We don't know the answer to. Well, and that they're also not anything that we caused. This is not an MLT thing. This is not a town of Mammoth Lakes thing. This is something that we have zero. This is a government state of California thing where, you know. But to John's point, it's emotional and it's something that comes up. And that's why I think that, you know, even when I responded to your email last week, John, about the impacts, I never anticipated this. I anticipated that we're going to have to figure out how to make the system work.

1:06:25 And that it was this much on every transaction. It's that much on every T-shirt. The problem is when you aggregate all that. Totally understand. It's a pot full of money. Absolutely. But again, at least at that point, it still was a state of California thing. It wasn't something where we said, hey, we're going to add this in. And I know that that's still heartburn. And I talked with one retailer that was like, great, if I sell $10,000 worth of stuff, it's $14. Don't tell me that $14 isn't a lot of money on a $10,000 sale.

1:06:54 I get that, and I know that it aggregates, and I know that it may amount to, at least for Mammoth Lakes, it may amount to half a million dollars a year, quarter million dollars a year for the state, who's $43 billion in the hole. You know, I just look at the RTBID revenue for December and take that times... You can only take two components of it. But I'm going to say, they're looking at...

1:07:24 The aggregate. Right. To see what that really is. Well, yeah, exactly. And I think that the fact that it doesn't affect lodging, which is our biggest contributor, and the ski area is not taxed on lift tickets. So it really just comes down to that restaurant retail, which last year was $3 million in TBID revenue. So the idea that we're going to eliminate $3 million out of the MLT budget

1:07:57 It's probably not the best option. I think we need to fight this thing as hard as we can and make sure that that... Well, and that was really the point of my note because the gist of the first note was, well, it's so small, it's not worth taking on, you know, from a legal standpoint. The problem is it's not the aggregate. It's every individual business that has the liability for this, right? And that's then, you know, decremental revenue.

1:08:25 Decremental operations, decremental taxes for the town. It has a knock-on effect on everything. Well, and that's why I'm hoping getting the state of California involved is helpful, you know, CalTravel, obviously, because I think, again, I think that Ken and I had this conversation. This is a stepping stone. This is the tip of the iceberg of what they're going to start saying this to. And if they come back and they say, hey, TOT's great, but we don't get any of that, so you need to charge XYZ on your TOT that comes back to the state to pick up our $43 billion. Or God forbid they say we're going to assess you for three years in arrears.

1:08:55 So Deb has a question. Yeah, I have a question. It's also that the auditing process is not consistent from business to business. So apparently, you spoke to one business yesterday that got assessed an additional $28,000, but I know that there were two other businesses that got audited in the fall, and they didn't even talk about or didn't even address the TBID assessment tax.

1:09:24 Yeah, and I think that, I think, again, I did not, this was not brought to my attention until November 21st. So I don't, again, it goes back to the idea that there's just some assumption that you knew with your ESP that this was something you were supposed to be charging. The state didn't even know, and that's why I think their new interpretation needs to start now, not go back to when you didn't have it in place. It makes zero sense to me how that's even legal.

1:09:52 That's the thing. Whenever sales tax rates change, you're giving a heads up so you can make that change to your system. It's not retroactive. We were really thinking about this three years ago. You know, there's just so much that is bizarre and mind-blowing about this that just doesn't make sense. You know, where it's like, you know, we're in America. I don't want to say, like, corruption, but, like, what is going on?

1:10:16 So I have had probably 30 phone calls between yesterday and today with different business owners. And I think the biggest thing right now that I can say is that, you know, I've got this call at 3.30 with John Lambeth. I had the call with Visit California. I know that they're supportive of us. I know that Cal Travel is supportive of us. I think the call with Michael Colantuno will be very helpful. Michael is Colantuno, Highsmith, and Watley. They are municipal revenue attorneys. They deal with government every day.

1:10:45 And I think that when we kind of lay out everything to them, I think they're going to give us a much clearer picture as to what our course of action might be. I don't, like I said, I don't know whether a class action lawsuit from 200 businesses in a tiny place like Mammoth Lakes is enough. I think that that's why I kind of was hoping that Visit California's assessment was in there because...

1:11:08 It's $157 million. And you start putting that on car rentals, and all of a sudden, you know, as a California becomes even more enraged by it. But they are not happy with where that's going. They know that it's a potential stepping stone to other things. So we have support. It's going to be really important. You touched on it, but it's going to be really important, and I don't want to be tone deaf about this, but to all the remitters to parse the renewal of the QBID versus this other segment of it. Because, again, if...

1:11:37 If you say, well, the best thing to do then is just get rid of the TBID, well, then you're taking away 80% of your marketing budget, what's going to happen? Then all the revenues are going to start shrinking back and you're making less money. So that, it's, I know it's kind of a, people have a knee-jerk reaction to things sometimes, but I think it's going to be really important for us to have all that information. Emotionally separate, but emotionally. Yeah, exactly. So what I will do, based on that, is once I talk to, once I talk to Colantuno and once I talk to Lambeth today,

1:12:04 and get a little bit better course of action. I will build you a one-sheet. I will explain kind of where we are, what we're doing, the action steps that we're doing to dig into this. You know, when this initially came out, I think my concern was that, you know, our job was going to be to let people know that this is coming. If you decide to charge it, great. If you don't, you get audited, you're in trouble. But, you know, now it sounds like it's a bigger, much bigger problem than originally anticipated.

1:12:31 I will come up with a one sheet so that when you do have your conversations, when you do have your meetings, when your phone rings, because I know it does, that you have the answers for it. You know, it might be, we have our TBID steering committee, you know, we haven't met in a little while, it might be nice to bring that committee back together, you know, once you get some of these updates from, you know. Or at least an email to the committee to, so we know what's going on. I would also say that depending upon what actions we take,

1:13:01 I think the communication to our remitters from MLT on this issue is going to be critical. Yes. What are we doing? What leadership position are we taking based upon this? You know, here's what we believe. Whether we can get that or not, we don't know. Sure. Yeah, it might be a good idea to be proactive on that, even if we don't have a lot of answers. Right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, just get it out there. Just let people know we're working on it. Because the more you don't say anything, the more people... They'll just make stuff up. Right, right. Well, and I think that, you know, that...

1:13:31 The mailing that we're doing out, you know, we might be able to separate the restaurants and the retails from the massive 1800 list, 1500 list. Maybe not. Maybe we do a separate mailing. You know, when does it include restaurants and retails? I mean, here's the difference, right? So we get this part, and then it's like, well, we think lodging is subject to this, too. Right. You know, why is anybody excluded? So, sorry. Public comment?

1:14:03 Hold on. Okay. Again, Ken Bringle, Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. When I first saw this, and John brought it to my attention, my biggest shock is that it's a much broader policy issue than whether it's being charged on retail and restaurants and so forth.

1:14:38 The idea that you can charge a sales tax on an assessment carries a lot of, not just for tourism, but as you start looking at other business improvement districts that are having an assessment on some downtown improvement, if they're selling, if it's charged on this one as real property is how they justified it. If it's being charged on real property.

1:15:06 Where does it stop? Where do you stop charging tax on an assessment? So mine is, and I've talked to John about it, and I've put it on our chamber board. I want to raise some, I think we should first of all try to get an injunction and just say stop this until we can go through a legal process. I don't know if it's an administrative law judge or whether it's a district court issue.

1:15:37 But what do we need to raise money to get this thing stopped right now until we can work our way through it? Because, like you said, when you're starting getting some of your primary businesses saying, hey, I just got to, they just told me I owe $28,000, we can't let that happen to our local businesses. So, my news is that we've got to come up with some money to at least figure out how we dress. And I think John Lamboth...

1:16:06 is the key to this because he understands it. He knows what's going on. I send his stuff. I'm on the Governmental Relations Council for CalTravel. I think it needs to be a statewide issue that we address it and talk about it more from the broad policy than what it's doing just to affect Mammoth Lakes. To your point, Ken, it's not just a TBID issue.

1:16:36 Yeah. I mean, this is just the tip of the iceberg. That's right. So we're going to talk about it next week. We have our board meeting on Monday. I'm sure when we get to the Cal Travel, GRC is on Thursday the 9th. John Lamberth always attends that, so I'm sure he can address that. But then also the law firm that is handling our other great legal issue.

1:17:06 that we can hopefully get them involved to help us with it. I don't understand it. It is strictly a bureaucratic ruling, not anything that legislatively came down the pike until this, what, two months ago, three months ago? That's my biggest issue with it, because I spent way too much time on the CDTFA website, and I cannot...

1:17:34 Tourism Assessment, TBID, TID, you know, none of it exists on the CDTFA website, anywhere. You can't find it, you know. So, you know, there's nothing legislative to back this right now, as far as I can find. It's just their rulings. It's an opinion. Yeah, it's an opinion. Not even a ruling, it's just an opinion.

1:18:00 They're trying to justify how they can raise. It's a money grab. That's exactly what it is. And they're not 43. It's only $24 billion. It's only $24 billion. I exaggerated. It's $24 billion. But the chamber is going to get real serious about this because it's just when I start getting emails, the same emails that John's getting from our members, I'm getting a big tax bill. It's time we step up and figure out how we can help them. Thanks, man.

1:18:31 Thank you, Ken. Yeah, it's frustrating, it's concerning. And we will keep working on it, and we will, you know, make sure that we're communicating with our TBID remitter so that they have all the information they need. All right, let's wrap that up. Let's move to department updates, international sales. Michael Vanderhurst. Give us some good news, Michael. Yeah, cheer me up, Michael. Cheer me up. Lord have mercy. Make sure your microphone's on, too.

1:19:02 Holy cow. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We are in the midst of a very busy PR hosting period of time right now. 11 meters of snow tends to bring a lot of media from around the world to come and see what it looks like and how it plays. So we hosted some media from Australia in conjunction with Altera and Mammoth Resorts. So we partnered with them.

1:19:29 Last week on that one. We also hosted media from Mexico, and we partnered with Altera on that one. So those should be some pretty good placements in two key markets. I was also interviewed by a media outlet from the UK to talk about the storm and the snow and the skiing conditions here in Mammoth Lakes. And then in March, we're lining up media visits from the UK, Australia, Canada, and another publication from Mexico.

1:19:56 We are trying to maximize the snow coverage internationally as much as we can. On the trade side of things, we hosted a fam from Mexico. We hosted a fam in conjunction with Altera and Mammoth Resorts that had participants from Mexico, Australia, Brazil. They were just in town yesterday, so it was good to see them, and they had a great time on the snow, and we had dinner with them at Petra's.

1:20:21 We also were on a sales mission. MLT was on a sales mission to Mexico with Visit California. The sales mission was comprised of 32 different California destinations, attractions, lodging, cities, DMOs like ourselves. So it was a very robust presence down there in Mexico. And it was two days of speed dating. So it was a great opportunity to talk about Mammoth Lakes, not only winter but summer. So very, very key appointments.

1:20:48 And then we are hitting the road later this month to go to Go West, which is another speed dating type of conference. That'll be four days of appointments. And then we're joining Visit California on a Canadian sales mission to Toronto. That one I'll be on the media track to talk about our winter and our upcoming summer. So pretty busy couple of weeks coming our way.

1:21:09 At what point did we start talking about kilometers of snow? Pretty close. The forecast for this weekend, it may be closer than you think, John. Any other questions? I appreciate it, guys. Thank you. Good afternoon. Laura Kaler, Director of Communications and Domestic PR.

1:21:41 Similar to Michael, I feel like we've been singing the same tune for the past couple months in the middle of a lot of media visits right now. We had one gentleman in over the weekend from Hemispheres Magazine, which is the publication for United. He took the flight from Denver. Actually, I was in New York last week for a media conference, met him there, and then he was flying from New York to here for his Mammoth Lakes visit.

1:22:10 He's working on a piece about what to do in spring in Mammoth. Ski, ski, ski. So yeah, so the trip to New York last week was very successful. IMM is an international media market. So Wednesday they held a summit, which was a full day of conference speakers and different learnings, some great stuff on DEI.

1:22:39 The indigenous kind of movement that's going on right now and how to kind of work that into some of your marketing and some of the things you're doing. And then Thursday we had a full day of speed dating. Met some different influencers and media from all over the country and they were all, a lot of them had heard about Mammoth because of all the snow. So they were, it was kind of fun to say, you know, we'll be skiing until 4th of July basically. So if you want to ski, feel free.

1:23:09 and still get you in plenty of time. And then Friday, we were with Visit California all day, went to Dot Dash Meredith, which is an overarching company for a lot of publications like Travel and Leisure, Real Simple, Parent Magazine, met with a bunch of editors there, and then in the afternoon met with a bunch of broadcast journalists. So super successful. I'm sure we'll have some follow-up trips from that.

1:23:40 Additionally, really excited to announce Brian and I are working together. We just confirmed we're going to be bringing in a family travel show in March. It's a PBS show calling Kelly's Family Travel. She has a great coverage area for her show. She also does a radio show in Chicago. So in terms of talking about flights and type of stuff, it'll be great coverage for us.

1:24:11 And just talking about the long spring skiing season and all that good stuff, I think the timing is going to be excellent for that. I had hoped to have her ski with Glenn Plake, but he will be in Europe until April, so I have to scratch that idea. And then finally in the crib, we just hosted an athlete and trainer named Ann Roos, and she's actually hearing impaired, but she coaches all these great athletes.

1:24:40 So it was really wonderful to have someone come to our area with this disability and just kind of hear her story of functioning here and getting around town. She had an amazing time. She brought two clients with her that were hearing. So it was kind of an interesting mix. So Pat, I know, got out with her for a photo shoot. Dakota met with her this morning because Dakota knows sign language. Of course he does. Of course he does, yeah.

1:25:09 So just a really cool, different athlete experience that we were able to capture. And that's it. Any questions? Thanks. Thank you, Laura. While Brian's coming up, I will add that Visit California has a very big focus on Native. It's an initiative called Native California, and it's very much focused on the indigenous Californian tribes. Yeah. I love, I just, coming off of what Laura just said, I love when you just, it's like a...

1:25:40 Could speak sign language because of course he does. Like it's just another thing that Koda does. It's just amazing. So I know. I love our little team. Update from the marketing side. So I talked about the Matador shoot that came up. So Matador, if you're not familiar with the network, they have...

1:25:55 As an example, on Instagram, 440,000 followers. On TikTok, 1.7 million followers. And on Facebook, 1.8 million followers. This is a massive network. And they focus on the outdoors and all the cool, really quirky and unique stuff you can do outdoors. So if you haven't found them online yet, take a look at some of their videos. They're amazing. So they already have for four days shot with us. And we're excited to see what they're going to come up with. We should have something in our pockets to look at by the middle of next week.

1:26:24 Web RFPs. We're down to two finalists. I know I promised John yesterday I was going to have a finalist decided by today so I could tell you who it was. I don't because I got an email last night. These two last finalists are fighting for this. They want this so badly. So at the end of the week, I have this decision made. They're amazing. So whoever we go with, we're going to be thrilled. It's very happy. It's just to kind of figure out what that looks like. Neither is the incumbent, though, right? I'm sorry? Neither is the incumbent. Correct. Actually, there isn't an incumbent, which is...

1:26:52 Weird, but it's, yeah, it's a whole, that's a whole other thing. But to preempt your question, sir, agency RFEs are happening. So we have dates now for those. So we sent, so there are five intent to bids went out, or actually came back in to us. Three proposals will come back in. Those folks will be on Tuesday, February 21st. That will be from 1 to 2 p.m. Then on Wednesday, February 22nd.

1:27:20 The first one will be from 10 to noon and then from 2 to 4. I'll send this out to the entire board as well. What we did with the web RFPs as a test was set up an actual live webinar hybrid situation and it worked flawlessly. So if you can't make it there and be in person but you still want to score and you want to be there for all three.

1:27:38 You can do that from your home, wherever you are. Obviously, we'd love to have you there in person. There will be food. That was one thing I did learn in this last one. If you food, people will come. So I'm serving lunch. It'll be great. Visit California. We have a rural committee meeting tomorrow. A little update on the Inc. and Hemispheres in the United. That relationship just continues to grow. Like you said, we asked last year for some sponsorship money. This year they came through with it. It was $20,000 that we're going to find out that.

1:28:06 So we've paid for two stories. These whole stories, these journals that keep showing up, we actually paid for two stories. One was added, Elias just said, hey, there's another story we're going to send up, and she came up this last weekend as well, not the person that Laura was talking about. That was a fourth. So this relationship is just exploding and getting better and better. Upcoming travel, John and I are heading down to Cal Travel Board meeting next week.

1:28:30 I've been asked to join this thing called the Sojourn Destinations Advisory Board. Sojourn is the number one travel marketing platform out there, and they asked me to be on this. There's seven or eight people that they choose every year to kind of be on this. So I'll be out in Atlanta for that this next year, or this next month. The nice thing is they're covering all the travel out there, plus they're giving us $5,000 for the ad spend with their platform. So good stuff there.

1:28:53 And then travel show season's upon us. You know, President's Day weekend. We've got the Bart Hall Fishing Show down in Del Mar. We've got the L.A. Travel Adventure Show that same weekend. So Pat and Emily are heading down to Del Mar. Dakota and I are doing L.A. And then the next weekend is the Denver Travel Adventure Show that Pat and Dakota are covering. So a lot going on this month. So that's where I might know. Brian, do you know that New York Times piece, that article in the California section that I'd sent out like last week that I forwarded you guys? Where did that?

1:29:22 Do we know where that came from? I was just curious. It was great. I was wondering if that came from us. I think it used a better picture. Well, yeah, the picture wasn't that great, but the article was cool. Again, just the massive amounts of snowfall. I mean, media is just catching their ear. California, the rain, the snow, they're looking for devastation of it all, right? If it leads, it leads. We actually had two New York Times journalists reach out to us that weekend.

1:29:52 I spoke with one of them, Anna, the one, the article that you had, we didn't connect, but basically we are able to tell a good story because now that we're through all the storms, it's going to be a great spring, great summer, all those good things, but it literally is just the weather and the chaos of it all brings media to coming. To us, it's just another day in Mammoth. That's exactly what I told the one. It's like the global girls' junior pictures. My son from Australia sent it to me.

1:30:22 Like, you guys got snow? Where did you find that? Patrick's saying on our Instagram that anywhere else this would have been a natural disaster. He said that and somebody got called him out. And someone got all upset about that. It's like, look what happened in Buffalo, New York, like, you know, not like a month ago, you know, and it was a natural disaster there, but it's like, we're capable of handling it and managing it and digging ourselves out, you know, like, I mean, so.

1:30:52 It's a lot of snow. People want to know about it. It was funny. I did a little, I've told this story, but I did a little 20-second video. Pat was outside. We were shoveling our little walkway into the back of the office. We got Michael out there holding the shovel, and I just did a little quick little video. It's almost 800,000 views. I'm an Instagrammer now. It's fantastic. I'm an influencer. My wife has had this comment yesterday. She said, what if we got...

1:31:20 Every piece of snow removal equipment within the town, from the town, all the private loaders, all the people, snow blowers, everything, and got one massive picture of everybody that has snow removal equipment. I bet we'd probably win any contest. You'd have to take the picture of Bishop. That's true. Awesome. Any other questions? Thanks, Brian. Thank you. Only thing I'll add is that if you do join us for the RFPs, please carve out for all three.

1:31:49 Because we want to make sure we have apples to apples. I would also suggest that just for consistency that the board not vote on those. I think we'd be aware. I think you guys need to make the decision. So you work with them every day. I don't want to interfere with your...

1:32:07 As much as I'd like to interfere with your... I'd rather have plausible deniability. We would love your input. Vote for them. But we would love your input. I mean, I think that's one of the things is from an outside opinion. I always get my input. And I'm grateful for it every time. Trust me.

1:32:36 All right, Dakota Snyder, special event, senior manager of marketing. We're still green over here. I would also just like to note that that natural disaster anywhere else quote came from the one and only Mr. Urdi here. Oh, yeah? That originated in his world, and we kind of took it and ran with it. Pat is out sick right now, so I'm also going to do some reporting on social while I'm up here.

1:33:00 Big month across the board, across all fronts for us, not only from the media and the PR pickup from things, but also across the board on social. Mammoth Mountain didn't have some photographers in town for a large portion of January, so Pat was the man in town, and he was out and about, and we got some really great pickup from some of the photos and video and stuff that went all the way across the social board. With that,

1:33:28 Comes the responsibility of hired locals, right? And something that we really saw this last month, yeah, everyone looks up, right? Something that we saw this last month was, you know, not only is...

1:33:40 The New York Times walking around the streets taking photos of something that could have been deemed a natural disaster in any other place, but now all of a sudden we have hordes of people that are coming here, and we really quickly realized, which you guys know, that we needed to pivot, right? And something that we pride ourselves with being good at is making that pivot happen and recognizing that instead of continuing to talk about how much snow we have, okay, we get the hint.

1:34:03 Everybody in the United States, we're on ABC World News, we're on Fox, right? We were across the board. So let's now make sure that when people are coming here, we are hitting them with this message of be kind, be considerate, be patient, because you're going to have to be. And things here in town are going to be different. And so we got all of our heads together and we created a really cool social campaign. We emailed and blasted it out to all of you guys, but we also hit this on the social channels.

1:34:27 Hard. We added spots all the way up 395 for people that were driving here so that by the time that they got to Big Pie and their phone was starting to be pinged with this message of, if you're coming to Mammoth, please be patient, right? And this campaign went out not only locally here but all the way up and down the 395 corridor. We switched all of our messaging over on the website so as soon as you get onto the website there was not only notifications popping up that would talk about that that was happening but also our homepage heroes were also switched into that.

1:34:54 Really, really, really just honing in on this idea of please be kind. We're digging out after a lot of chaos and really trying to just make sure that that message was front and centered. And we saw a really good response not only from the visitors here on social from that, but also from the locals as well. And the number one thing over the last couple years that we really want to make sure that we have a pulse check on is our locals.

1:35:16 And so that's really something that we tried to do when we tried to pivot with the storm. Listen, we know the media is out there. We know the word is out there. So now let's talk about how people can interact as a proper behaved tourist while they're here in town. So that was a big pivot for us this month. Overall, our social numbers are a little bit down compared to last year. We're down about 21% compared to January of the previous year.

1:35:38 Have to sit down and pat and figure out where we're at on that. Just because numbers are overall down on impressions doesn't mean that our engagement, which is actually up compared to last year or anything, less eyeballs, more quality content that they're engaging with. So we'll take a dive into that and see where we're truly at with it.

1:35:53 And that's pretty much going forward. We're really talking about midweek, right? Really pushing this idea of midweek, midweek visitation, coming in, really talking about our flights that we have. As you guys saw, our flight numbers, things are looking really well on that. And then really talking about off-mountain activities for the next little while. Really capitalizing on the fact that we have so much snow out there that some of these places for winter sports and winter activities, let's make sure that we're getting activations out into those. And then really taking a turn into the spring with the idea of restaurants and...

1:36:23 Detail and what else can you do while you're here and taking a big focus on that moving forward into these next couple months because we don't have to talk as heavy about the scheme because everybody knows about it. So that's kind of the direction that we're headed with that just so you guys are aware.

1:36:36 On the event side of things, on the opposite side, we finally last night at 5 p.m. closed our event funding application for 2023. It was active for the month of January. We had 66 applications come through this year. Of those 66, my guess is that about half of them will either be

1:36:54 Proper application, someone who didn't just click into it and was like, oh, this would be fun, right? So about half of those probably, hopefully, will be something that we get to fund this year. Our timeline for that is I have about two weeks worth of going through those applications, contacting our event producers, making sure that we hash out any questions from those.

1:37:11 On February 14th, our special events committee is going to meet. We're going to go through and go through all of the applications. Ultimate Decisions will be released February 17th. And by the end of this month, by the beginning of March, we will be requesting that all invoices be submitted to us so that individuals can get payment here within this next month. Now that I've been in this position for a couple of years, I've finally figured out timelines and how to make things move a little bit more efficiently. The applications were all online this year, and I'm really excited to see the efficiency that's happened and the process move through.

1:37:42 Once we have all of these by the end of this week, now I have all of the official dates submitted for events and all the official information. So now we can go to print with all of our brochures and posters and everything for this summer as well. So kind of tying all of these processes into each other versus having chaotic conversations throughout the year like how it has been before in the past.

1:38:00 I think that's pretty much it in my world. One last thing to note is that within the next two weeks, we will have our Prism Cam installed on Fire Station number one. The company is coming up. This is the 8K high-definition live stream webcam that's going to be overlooking not only the Main Street corridor in town, but also up to Mammoth Mountain, the Mammoth Crest, and the Lakes Basin. We picked Fire Station one after hashing through tons of different locations around town. This camera will have a live feed that the news can tap into whenever they want. So if we...

1:38:30 Get these massive snowstorms in town. The news down south will be able to tap right in and see what's happening on Main Street and Mammoth Lakes. And it also is going to be creating really cool time lapses for us, as well as giving us the ability to have sunset content that's in 8K, some of the highest definition that you can get, and have immediate access to this content of what's a live look of Main Street and Mammoth Lakes looking like right now. So if it gets smoky, we'll kind of take it.

1:38:55 No, I'm just kidding. However, we're super excited for this finally. Does anybody have any questions? Yeah. Which is status on the information board?

1:39:06 Oh yeah, that's a great question. So right now, so the digital billboard is what he's talking about on there. So right now the town is going through, I don't know if you've seen their plans for the digital kiosks that they're trying to install around town as well. So there's a, the big delay on it is if this actually truly does go into an easement, which is where we landed this last fall with the project, if it truly does go into the easement, how can they geofence it politically so that anybody doesn't have right if it's on public?

1:39:34 Town property, how can they geofence that so that politicians can't put ads up on it, right? How do we make this, if it's not technically on Footloose private property, if it's on private property, it's a whole different story, but if it's on that town public property, how can they make sure that Yahoo can't go and put whatever type of messaging that they want to have on that board legally?

1:39:53 So the town right now is working through a process not only to try and figure out how to come up with some legislation to geofence this style board, but also for digital ads that they want to ultimately incorporate on buses, if I'm correct, as well as these digital kiosks, information kiosks that they want to put around town. All these public property, it's the same problem that they're running into with that. It's my understanding that Intel, they can get that passed to figure out how to legally...

1:40:22 Have these boards up without anyone feeling like they can have access to them. That's the part that we're waiting for right now. And we've been having conversations. They have renderings that they've drawn up of them. It's kind of been in a holding pattern for the last while until they figure out that component of it.

1:40:38 Dakota, as far as events, is that about the same? How does that compare to last year, 66 this year? About how many do we have last year? That's double what we had last year apply. Now, like I said, this is 66 applications turned in. Some people started, some closed out of them. The total complete ones, I haven't done three.

1:40:56 I haven't dug all the way through to figure out exactly where we're at with that. That's why I said my guess will be somewhere right around that like 35 mark would be my guess for that. And something that just one note on that because you asked that I thought was really cool. When I first stepped into this position, some of our event producers in town were a little hesitant on even continuing their event they were working on to begin with. And I've made sure that through this position

1:41:18 Really, really dedicating the time to make sure that these event producers feel supported, that they feel like they have resources that are there for them, and that we truly are there to help make their events more successful, whatever that might be, whatever time of night that might be that they need help, right? And for the first time since I've been in this position, two of our event producers who have produced single events in town have applied for funds for new events that they want to create on top of the old event that they have as well. So instead of walking away from the one event that they had because they were frustrated with, now they feel supported and confident in that.

1:41:47 And now they even want to try and dive into creating some new events as well. So I think that's a little pulse check on some progress in the events community that I'm super excited about. Cool. Thanks, guys. Thank you, Dakota. Hey, just a comment. I just really appreciated the be patient and especially thank a local messaging. I thought that was great. The timing was really good. Absolutely. I got some great feedback from locals, you know, around town.

1:42:16 Didn't even necessarily work in like retail restaurant or, you know, the ladies at the bank were just like, thank you for putting that. That was great. And, you know, I thought we were going to be kind of in a situation for especially MLK weekend where it might be like just inundated, gridlock, traffic problems, and there's nowhere to park. But, you know, the town coming up with the overnight parking at the high school, that was huge.

1:42:44 And, you know, I think a lot of people kind of got the message and delayed, postponed their trips. And we were, you know, really flexible with people around those, you know, kind of cancellations to postpone later. And I think we will make up for that. We will make up for that, you know, light MLK weekend throughout.

1:43:08 And take it away. And on that note, I can say that, you know, we did also, along with the change to our hero image on our blog page, we actually put up a emergent, or it said extreme weather in place, or I can't remember the exact words I used, but we put up a red banner at the top of the website to make people aware of that. Then we also changed our fly-in.

1:43:30 And all of those point to a blog we created that fits within the unreal theme that we have here, but the blog is called How to Survive a Real Mammoth Lakes Winter. And we did get, you know, about 500 clicks on that as we were promoting that over. I was also on the radio for about 45 minutes on the Friday of Martin Luther King weekend.

1:43:54 Talking with John DeMaria about the very real situation we had up here. So if anybody was, you know, driving up on that Friday morning, they may have heard that conversation. I have a recording of it if any of you want to hear. I think John DeMaria is great at, you know, really encompassing to what it feels like to be a local. So what you all have in front of you is our new visitor's guide that has just hit last week, about midweek last week.

1:44:24 You will still find some of the last years out there, and that is because the piece is pretty evergreen, so we are going to make the most of last years as well right now around town, but this is our new piece, and my favorite feature, you know, a map falls out, so the map is, it's a tear out now, so it does fold out and tear out, so hopefully we don't have a lot of that.

1:44:53 Stuff blowing around town anymore. Good times there. They're also easier to travel with as well. On the website side, in terms of sessions, we did have growth month over month in our sessions, just over about 200,000 sessions. This is a very small decrease from year over year. It's only down 0.9% year over year. So really good.

1:45:21 Both year-over-year and month-over-month for users, about 5% and 8% respectively month-to-month, year-to-year. Also our average session duration is up year-over-year by about 5% as well. We're still seeing a lot of clicks through to our partners, to our air partners. And I'm just going to quickly say, you know, one of our top blog posts is the Winter Sightseeing Weekday Warriors.

1:45:51 So I do think we're definitely starting to see a lot of people paying attention to that. It's up 13,000% over last year. So yeah, there's definitely a lot of people. Our top blog post is still a little bit more than that, which is about family-friendly ski trips. Top metro areas, I'm just going to give you our top 10. LA, Denver, New York, San Francisco, San Diego.

1:46:19 Sacramento, which encompasses that greater Stockton, Modesto area as well, Reno, Boston, Seattle, and Las Vegas, with Seattle being our biggest growth year over year right now. In terms of international visitors to our website, again, at the very top of that list is India. So India, Canada, the UK, Mexico, Germany, Australia, France, Iran, Netherlands, and Spain.

1:46:48 Those are sort of our top destinations that are looking at our website. In terms of pass-throughs, we did about 38,000 pass-throughs to local businesses in the month of January. John stole my thunder about looking for surveyors at the Mammoth Airport. We will be doing surveys and collecting information at the Mammoth Airport, so we're working on that right now. And then the other piece you'll see from the local marketing side.

1:47:16 We have started the process with Bandwango. Bandwango is, they put together pass trails, so trails to get visitors into restaurants or retail spaces by kind of gamifying that process. So a visitor will log in and sort of get this pass. The one that we're doing is going to be an apres ski pass, so it will focus on the restaurant space. And then

1:47:45 You know, you'll go in. It won't take anything on the restaurant side for them to check in. It's a GPS location. We get all the data and email addresses that are associated with that. And then as they check in, they get Mammoth Lake swag as they sort of complete those processes. So this will be our first, you know, try with them. But I think there's a lot of opportunities. There's a lot of other places like Visit Mesa.

1:48:15 Visit Mesa has a beers and brew trail, Stockton's got a sweet treat trail, Lake Havasu, they do beers and trails, like actual trails, so there's a lot of options to do this, but we're going to start with Apre Ski because we're going to have Apre skiing for a very long time right now, and so you will start to see them and myself reaching out to that community starting later this afternoon.

1:48:44 And then they will actually be doing a lot of the contact with the local business owners. So, yeah, that's what we got working on. Anything, any questions? Cool. Thank you. Thank you, Em. All right, that wraps up department updates. Eric's not, is Eric? Okay. Eric's not here. Well, I'll do quick resort update. Grand Prix's going on. All right.

1:49:12 Dakota, where's the best place to view, like, the schedule for the, does Mammoth Mountain have that up on their website? Mammoth Mountain's website? Okay. All right. For Chamber Update, tonight, Women in Business. Then we have our ski hour. We had to move that. That was scheduled for January 10th. That day, the mountain completely shut down. So, we were not able to do...

1:49:41 our ski power hour, power lunch hour. So that'll be coming up February 7th. We're meeting at 10.30 at Chair 3, and that will be followed by a lunch at Parallax, and the Mammoth Hospital will be giving an update. The other thing we wanted to start putting on everybody's radar is the July 4th, the 4th of July parade.

1:50:08 So we're hosting again and we are seeking submissions for parade theme this year. So any community members can submit their ideas for consideration and head on over to our website for the details. Sponsorship opportunities for the parade will be open and announced in the next few weeks. So stay tuned for that. And maybe we need to get some of all, we need all the loaders and dump trucks in the parade this year. That's where we can get our picture of all of them. All right.

1:50:36 The one thing I forgot to mention, I probably should have started our meeting with this, but I wanted to make the board aware, we did receive a letter of resignation from Mr. Larry Crabb. He apologized for not being able to fill out his term, but with the international travel coming back, his

1:51:07 You know, he does quite a bit of traveling back and forth to Asia. And he said, and it's not scheduled. It's like at a drop of the hat. He's like, I got to go. And so he just didn't feel that he could make the commitment anymore to the board. And he apologized about that, but still has, you know, gives our organization all of his support.

1:51:34 So we'll be reaching out to him about, you know, TBID signatures and things like that. But, you know, he did put that resignation in. And so we will be looking. He was at large seat. So we will have to go through the process of finding a new board member for the at-large position. All right. That's all right. Bill Souser's not here either, so we can't do the town council update. We already did our closed session.

1:52:09 Announcement of action taken and closed. Nope, we're good there. Do I have a motion to adjourn? Motion. So moved. Second from John Mandel. All right. Thank you. Thank you so much. Thanks, Deb. Have a great day. Thanks, everyone. Appreciate it. See you next time.