TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2023

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

at 13:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

273 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:04 All right, Angie. Are you ready over there, Angie? You're exactly right, Bill. You are exactly right. I will call the meeting to order here, and Angie, whenever you're ready, you can go right ahead with roll call. Chair Goico? Present. Vice Chair Foster? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here. Secretary Mendel? Here. Board Member Clark?

0:44 Board Member Crabb? Board Member Radcliffe? Here. Board Member Souser? Here. And Board Member Magner is not with us this afternoon. Thank you. Awesome. Thank you so much, Angie. Let's start out with Board Member Reports. I'll kick it off for us. First of all, Happy New Year to everybody. I hope everybody had a safe and successful holiday. We have been cranking over

1:15 at all of our businesses, with the snowblowers, to keep up with demand there and all the snowfall. You know, the snowfall, double-eyed sword there, you're excited about it, but it's challenging. You know, for, I would imagine in the restaurant industry, the weather kind of brings everybody into your establishment. Sometimes people in the rental industry are like, I'm returning early, or...

1:43 Also extending because they're enjoying the conditions. So it's been a little bit of everything, but overall, I will take this every year. I will take this every year. You know, I've started to get some feedback from some of the businesses around town. I know that...

2:02 Kind of cell phone service has been a big challenge. That's been a big challenge for our business. A lot of drop calls. I did see, I was hoping Eric would be here today. I saw a post by Tom Hodges that they're putting some plans in the work for maybe another cell tower maybe this summer. So it'd be nice to get a little bit more information on that. I think it's desperately needed. I think that's an infrastructure piece that we can fix and put some effort towards here in town.

2:31 I've heard some issues with Wi-Fi. I personally have not had that. I think if you're having Wi-Fi issues, it's most likely a hardware issue, and you should get in touch with CBT and see what kind of modem router you got going on, because if you're just using the basic one from Optimum Suddenlink, it ain't going to work very well. We replaced those years ago. I have not had a single Wi-Fi issue at any of my businesses.

2:59 And it's because we address the hardware issues at our businesses. So I think that needs to kind of be, you know.

3:08 dealt with each individual business. So I've told a couple businesses, get in touch with CBT, see what they recommend for that. We did experience some kind of like brownout kind of surges right around like the 26th, 27th, never losing power for more than about 30 seconds, and then it came back on. It did disrupt things slightly, you know, for I think the 27th was kind of...

3:31 The day where it was happening the most, it happened a couple times on the 28th, but wasn't as big of an issue. Those have subsided. I know that Old Mammoth Road was without power on New Year's Eve. I heard that was a branch, that downed a power line, is my understanding, and they got that back up and running as quickly as they could. So, you know, obviously, you know, a few little challenges here and there along the way, and, you know, but...

4:00 Snow removal, in my mind, has been, I know there's going to be issues here and there around town, but overall, I have been incredibly impressed. You know, I had gotten word from the town to be patient, that we're a little light staffed. I can't tell. Like, it is lovely driving out there, and that's what my, you know, I've got four vehicles running around town every day. They're telling me that the conditions are good for them. They're able to get around.

4:28 You know, so I've been very impressed. I went to Big Sky a couple years ago. It snowed. I was there for four days. It snowed all four days. I didn't see a single plow. That's not the case in Mammoth. We are, I think we're spoiled with snow removal, personally, is my experience. So I've been very pleased with snow removal, especially, you know, I'm on the other side here of the Vons parking lot. The Vons parking lot has been well managed. Our plaza, the next one over, the Sherwin Plaza, all that stuff seems to be working pretty well.

4:57 We're having a great season so far. My staff is excited about the snow, you know, and people are working hard, and we've had, you know, good customers that have been, you know, we survey every single customer after they return. I am getting overwhelmingly all tens, you know, 10 out of 10 is kind of what they in select categories, and they're giving us good feedback.

5:27 My CEO of Black Tie tells me that our market here in Mammoth gives more feedback than any other black tie market. We get more surveys than any other consistently. So people like to tell us what they think about their experience when they come, and we're getting a lot of positive feedback. So I'm very pleased. It's been hard work.

5:50 Make sure you're drinking plenty of water, getting your rest, eating well. Thank you to all the restaurants around town that do not do to-go orders but did to-go orders for my staff. Most of those I made sure to place the order 24 to 48 hours in advance. But that's how I've been showing my staff I appreciate them is getting them dinner each night after a tough day's work.

6:16 And usually there's some leftovers in the fridge for the next day for the morning crew coming in. So I hope everybody's had a good, solid season. And I will move on to Mr. Morris. Me? Okay. Sure. Unless, should I send it across to Deb? Which way should we go?

6:36 Deb, you want to go? Yeah, why don't you go that way? Okay, I caught John by surprise. He's not ready. So, Deb, we'll go to you. Dazed and confused. I'm not surprised that I'm actually prepared because I've been thinking about this over the last couple of weeks. So, being, you know, in the village and having to manage through a lot of the snow pressures and everything. A couple of things, as I've been talking through a lot of the other restaurants, we're, I don't know if everyone realizes, but we're down nine restaurants.

7:02 Yeah, I've noticed that. We're down at least nine plus restaurants, right? You got Campo in the village. You got Nevado's. I know Nevado's has been down for, you know, a year or so. You've got Blue, which is a big disappointment and just...

7:19 Totally served our community. This summer we should get something back there that should be a similar service. We would, but that's not going to help the winter, the winter time. Yeah. We're down Public House, we're down, you know, Yaman Ra, the A-frame. I mean, we're down nine plus restaurants, which pushes a lot of the pressure on the existing restaurants. You're exactly right. Not only that, but.

7:39 The restaurants, some of them are closed one to two days a week, so Monday or Monday-Tuesday or Tuesday-Wednesday. And not only that, then there's also a lot of illnesses that are happening, so people are calling in sick. So we have a staffing issue, we have an illness issue, and we have a restaurant, just infrastructure issue to be able to manage. And the tourists, they're not understanding, they don't get it.

8:02 And they're blaming the restaurants for the lack of support in the staffing arena. So we're trying to, I mean, all the restaurants are doing a fabulous job of making sure that they can accommodate the guests and they let them know and they communicate, hey, look, this is not just our place, it's everywhere. And we're doing the best that we can, so we appreciate your support. And, you know, so, but other than that, and also when the top of the mountain.

8:29 closes, which is not anything unusual to the village because you've got the village gondola, but it also pushes pressure back down and with Campo being closed, it's actually pushed the pressure onto the rest of us. So, you know, the restaurants are doing such an amazing job to make sure that they're satisfying and they're accommodating the guests. I'm just not sure.

8:53 What else we can do to help support them is just be, you know, overly communicative and helping them understand, you know, we're here to support you. We love you guys. We appreciate you being here. So that's what's happening on the restaurant side. Are there concerns wait times? Is that the biggest complaint? Wait times? I mean, people are now understanding because, like, you know, within the village, right?

9:19 Like Gomez's people will wait an hour and a half, two hours for those guys. Shelter and myself and New York Deli, we actually do the numbering system, the counter service. So there are way more patients for that because they don't actually have to wait for a table. You know, we tell them, hey, find a table first. When you find a table, then, you know, put your stuff down, come up and take an order. So they're a little bit more patient on the counter service than they are on the full service restaurant.

9:50 Good question. Yeah, we, you know, I was mentioning to Brianna and Ken at the chamber that it'd be, it'd be maybe nice to do like a survey of some of the, our businesses and members and get a sense like this is all great information, you know, to be aware of on the restaurant side of things. And I also noticed like, I stopped by Zee Pizza, they're not open. They're not even open. I didn't realize that. Oh, that's 10 now. Yeah, you know, so.

10:19 Yeah, so, you know, we are down some restaurants, and maybe there's something we can do on the chamber side to, you know, try to, you know, encourage people to come and get set up, right, you know? Or encourage the tourists to actually take public transportation to you, because what it's causing is there's, like, parking issues, especially in the village.

10:47 And also with the snow, amount of snow that's happening is limiting the number of spaces that people can park to. So, you know, it's really, maybe that might be an opportunity to encourage, but I take the trolley all the time because I just don't want to have to deal with driving or parking anywhere. And it's also really crazy. I mean, it's really dangerous to drive right now, especially with the snow level. So there might be something potentially is like encouraging.

11:14 You know, those that are doing Airbnbs that are outside of the village or walking distance to restaurants is actually take public transportation because it is. You don't have to worry about parking. You don't have to worry about getting your car stuck. And then it also supports, you know, the community that we don't have to take emergency vehicles and rescue away from those that actually really need it. I have a question. Sure. This is probably directed to you.

11:39 But do you know if the town has done any research on why we've lost these restaurants? Is there any commonality? I mean, everyone, anecdotally, I hear, you know, is so-and-so wanted to retire or Brandon and Teresa got tired of the, you know, I mean, all the things. But has anybody done sort of a root cause analysis to see if there is any commonality? Not as far as I know, but from my own personal experience and conversations around town.

12:08 Every one of those 10 restaurants had a different reason for closing down. That's my understanding. I know that, you know, the people that bought Slocum would probably be reopened if it was easy to get employees, and it's not, and we're trying to solve that issue. I know there are still restaurants in town that aren't open the full number of hours they would like to be because they can't get the employees, and the employee issue is a hugely complicated, it's not just about housing, because we had employees prior to COVID.

12:37 There's a lot of issues going on there. So, no, I don't think we've actually commissioned a study for that. And, frankly, the feedback I'm getting, if we commission another study, I might get shot. I mean, as opposed to hiring someone to commission a study, is there someone who could take it by themselves to, you know, Z Pizza? I think it's the Chamber's opportunity. Maybe it's the Chamber. Ken and I talked about this because I did get a call from a restaurateur who was open on Christmas Day.

13:06 stating that he was one of the only ones open on Christmas Day, and it was a nightmare because, you know, Vaughn's was closed at three, people were in town, there was nowhere to go, you know, he obviously made great money that night, but also was way overwhelmed, and he was calling more because it was a guest disservice, because we had so many places that are normally open 365 that decided to close on Christmas, whether it was their employees told them they weren't working, or it was some reason. Well, and I'm not trying to overcomplicate it, but, you know, the first order reason,

13:36 I hear the same thing you do, Bill. Tim wanted to retire, Brandon, Teresa, yada, yada, yada. But is there a second or third order that's common to all? Is it employees in the second or third order? I would say it's the lack of ability to have employees to staff a full seven days. We want to be open a full seven days. We can't. We just don't have – we're open from nine to nine. And that's just one example. But it's because we don't have the staff to be able to stay open seven days a week to be able to support the community.

14:05 And you know, there's an incredibly complex economic thing going on here. To maintain employees, restaurant employees are, at least from what I'm hearing anecdotally, restaurant employees are now making twice what they did two years ago in terms of an hourly wage at your back kitchen staff, your dishwashers and stuff, now upwards of $20 an hour. Even if you can get the employees, how do you then build that into the price structure and still have people show up and...

14:31 It's just such a complicated... And I don't disagree with you, and I know it's complex, but I think in order to be able to have the chamber action or something else, we need something more than anecdotal. I mean, because that's all my information is anecdotal, right? We will have some new restaurants opening up. There will be a replacement for Blue. There will be a replacement for Public House. You know, Mike Coco's working on that. So I think, you know, part of it is cyclical. You know, Campo is going to be a new restaurant here.

15:01 Yeah, so, you know, I think, you know, there are some cyclical things that are happening right now, you know, that are challenging us, but it's all good to be aware of, and, you know, we'll try to provide more information on the Chamber side of things. And then also when the Limelight opens, too. Yeah, they'll have a restaurant in the hotel. Where are they going to get all the employees for that? Bring them in. They're going to bring them in. Yeah. And they're bringing them in. They're going to bring them in. That would be great. They'll get it figured out. Mr. Bill, thank you, Deb.

15:30 Happy New Year. Thank you. We've covered several things. You talked about our internet. I do not have the standard equipment that comes with your internet subscription, and when we go into these holidays, my service slows down incredibly. And yes, I pay a bunch of money to have fast service, and it's supposed to be unlimited. So there are still issues there. If you look at the infrastructure in town, our internet's being delivered on old coax cable.

15:55 instead of fiber optics. So there are issues, and the town is looking into that and getting grants for that so that we can push that forward some. But to me, that's still an issue. Electricity-wise, besides the little bumps, some of us lost electricity for several hours. I did in my neighborhood. John's Pizza did. It was forced to close on New Year's Eve because they lost power for three hours. Oh, wow. I didn't know that area got into it. It probably caused downstream issues.

16:25 On a personal note, and I made Mr. Urdi already look at this. I went to the Desert Mountain Division of the League of California Cities. I'm our representative there. And much to my surprise, how Dan kept it from me, I don't know. I was awarded the Larry Chimboli Award for Outstanding Public Service. And I normally don't mention when I get plaques and stuff for, you know, thank you for doing what you do. But in this case, the nomination came from the mayor pro tem of Apple, the town of Apple Valley.

16:54 So these are people outside the area that recognize me and I just couldn't be more proud or pleased that I brought that home to us. Congratulations, Bill. That's awesome. Well deserved. Thank you. And I have a whole bunch that I will probably bring up in my council report. There is one thing that I was going to bring up there that we've talked about snow removal here. One thing, I drive a loader in storms. I can tell you the idiots are still among us. And no, that's not limited to just tourists. Sorry.

17:22 I think on the back table back here, Angie could probably tell me, there are the little snow cards that the town had developed, and I encourage you to pick those up and hand those out. They may not help completely, but they may educate some. The favorite story I have of the last series of storms is I was doing snow removal on a fairly plowed but inclined section. There was a local gentleman stuck. He couldn't back up and he couldn't move forward because the car was there, and I suggested to him that he...

17:50 puts on his cables. We're all required to have them. And the answer was, no, I don't need them on four-wheel drive. And I had to retort back, you're stuck. So there are still those among us that just don't get it. So as much as we can educate our public, if we do the right thing, the people coming up to visit will start doing the right thing a little bit more. So I just want to pass those complaints on because it gets really frustrating. No, thank you so much. And congratulations again.

18:19 Thank you. On your recognition. Mr. Mendel. Nothing business-wise. You mentioned the additional cell tower. I don't know if that's been in front of the council yet. Not to my knowledge. Okay. There is a, and I'm not to preempt anything, there is a proposal being worked on by one of the internet carriers to put a tower at station two, fire station two. If you've been by there, they've had different flags up and everything else because

18:47 No one, everybody wants a better cell service, but nobody wants it now, right? Everyone wants to go to heaven, nobody wants to die, right? And so, you know, they've been giving people the opportunity to kind of look at what that might be at 60 and 70 feet and that kind of stuff. So I think that that is coming forward at some point in time. Sandra could probably tell us more about that. Maybe, I don't know. Sorry to drag you up.

19:14 Oh, so they had submitted an application to us for a use permit. However, when talking to Alish, he wanted to bring it back to the board, your board first. So they've withdrawn that application. So we don't have anything formally here at the town yet. I think, you know, kind of going through the public process through the board, because our recommendation was make sure that your board is willing to approve this even in the face of the public controversy, because we expect it to be very controversial out there. And so I think Alish wanted to just make sure.

19:43 That, you know, you've vetted it kind of through your board and the board's ready to, you know, because you're the landowner, you can say yes or no with no reasons. The town has very specific things that we can approve or deny the project on and it's very difficult to deny cell towers. So we just wanted to make sure that you all were comfortable with it. So that's where it is. We're waiting for them to resubmit at this point. Awesome. Thanks. Thanks. Yeah. Mr. Foster, anything else? Awesome.

20:10 Mr. Foster, Happy New Year. Happy New Year, everybody. Been a fantastic holiday season at the airport. Great start to the new year. GA's been doing fantastic. We've been really busy. We're really excited about how well Advanced Air is doing. The flight loads are fantastic. Wonderful. Really, really, really good. Like everybody, we have our challenges with the weather. We've had a few diversions down to Bishop.

20:35 Very grateful for the guys at Mammoth Taxi and Moz. They've been doing a great job moving our folks back and forth. Wonderful. Had an interesting one the other day. We showed up to the airport with two and a half feet of snow and advanced air. They were going to divert to Bishop. And they go, hey, you know what? We've only got a handful of folks coming out of Hawthorne and a handful out of Burbank. Let us delay. Let's give you guys a little bit of time to work. So the airport staff just opened up the runway and access to the terminal.

21:04 And we got the first flight in at about noon or so. And they just combined those flights so everybody got up without having to do the shuffle down to Bishop. So that was pretty cool. But yeah, overall, it's going really well. And like I said, we're really excited about the load factors. This morning, we stayed down in Bishop for a little while. Inyo County has built a new administration building.

21:30 And today they were dedicating it to Clint Quilter, who was the county CAO who passed away. And a really nice ceremony. Very well attended. And John was there. Rob from the town was there. Like I said, they had a great turnout. And that was a really nice dedication. And it was nice to be there. Wonderful. That's all I've got. Awesome. I've got a question for you. I don't know if you can answer it. It's probably not appropriate here anyway, so I'll answer it or ask it. All right. Back in the old days with some of the old...

22:00 Carriers that flew in and out. If I had a customer who had lost their keys and one that couldn't be duplicated, I could tell them to go to the airport and put it in an envelope and they could pay a fee to have it brought up on the plane. Will Advance Air do that kind of thing? You can't put packages on airplanes unless you're on the airplane with it, right? TSA issues. Yeah, so, you know, I mean, back in the day, it's something I used to do a lot. Yeah, we've had that request a lot, but no.

22:29 TSA regulations. We can't put a package on the plane without a person accompanying it. Used to be a little cabin check. Yeah. You can bring a firearm. Well, that's all right. With the automotive today, it would be cheaper to pay somebody to fly up and back. Thanks so much for that update, Mr. Foster. Mr. Morris. I'm ready now. All right, you're ready, my man. Good stuff. Just two things real quick. One is that, you know.

22:58 I won't go into a lot of details, but I'm just really, I'm really pleased with overall with the locals, our guests. You know, our town is not built to sustain this number of people week after week after week after week. If it was, we'd have twice as many employees and we'd have a lot more infrastructure in town. But when we come to the holiday period and we do as well as we have, I think it's great. I think it's a great testament to everybody. We are all, and myself, anybody that works outside and inside, completely exhausted right now.

23:27 But it's a good kind of tired. It really is. And everybody seems to have been in good spirits. Guests have really dealt well with the weather. We've had some really challenging days. We don't normally get a lot of rain in town in December, and it's not a lot of fun to play in. People come to play in the snow. But people have been resilient, and they've been having a good time.

23:48 You know, yeah, sure, there's a few knuckleheads out there doing goofy things, and there's people trying to make funky left-hand turns when they shouldn't, and all that fun stuff that we all like to complain about. But overall, let's face it, it's been great. I think at Snow Creek, I believe we had the best December we've ever had as far as occupancy, number of nights, revenue, blah, blah, blah. It was just a great month. And quick story, on a personal note, you know, Mammoth is a wonderful place.

24:15 For a lot of people like to do celebrations and so forth. And I was fortunate to be receiving into that. My daughter and her boyfriend were up here over Christmas and they snowshoed up to Horseshoe and he proposed to her. Congratulations, John. They're going to get married here in September. And I just think it's cool because of all the places we've been together as a family and everything and places you could have proposed to her, he chose here, her hometown. So I think that's really cool.

24:44 Awesome. Makes me very happy. So it's been a great month for me. September's a great month to get married. Yes, it is. We got married in September as well. Anyway, that's all I got. Awesome. John, thank you so much. Thanks for all the comments from the board. Let's move on to public comment. Yeah, public comment. Sandra, are you doing your thing during public comment? She's got her own presentation. All right, you got your own. Oh, you're the guest presentation below. Okay, do we have any public comments? I'm sorry.

25:11 Ken, good to see you, sir. After y'all talking about the chamber, I thought I should come up and address it real quick. But after John approached us the other day concerning the restaurant that he was talking about, that was talking about how busy they got.

25:41 What, you know, how do we service our customer, our guest? And so Brianna put together a four-question survey that's going to go out in the newsletter on Monday, asking that, were you open on, you know, not specifically of restaurants, but just to get a feel of how things went during the Christmas holidays. So that'll start on Monday, and then we'll probably do a specific

26:11 Do the same four questions, but specifically with the restaurant. And we'll talk about this tomorrow at the Mammoth Lakes Restaurant Association Steering Committee. But we do see that. That is a complaint that we also get that I couldn't find a place to have lunch. Everybody was closed and so forth. So we'll kind of follow up on that. Work with you, Deb, and the restaurant community on how do we address that down the road.

26:41 Ken, let me know if we can help out. I mean, obviously, the lodging community would like to get that information to our guests as early as we can as far as what they should be prepared for, what they should do. We try our best to give them that information. Obviously, some people don't read what you send them, but we'd like to help however we can because it obviously affects our guests as well. Yeah, I think that's even talking like Bowie came and talked about the reusable

27:12 containers that came to the restaurant because you're going to be involved no matter what happens. People are going to be leaving them in the establishments or you're going to have a lot of those on your hands and how do we move forward? And I think working with you on trying to figure out how we assist the restaurants on busy periods is something that the lodging community I know is willing to step up to. I also think this will be a great opportunity for

27:39 to drive people to visit mammoth.com to find out what restaurants are open, who has, and I know that. I was going to have Emily do it in her presentation, but she can probably bring it up here. I'm opening it up because. Yeah, so I just want to say that, you know, during COVID, I personally literally called every single restaurant, every single business. That's how we got those hours of operation.

28:05 I'm not necessarily in a position that I can make those phone calls anymore. Brianna and Ken actually, for many months, shared our restaurant hours of operation document in their chamber newsletter that goes out every Monday with a note that said, please tell Emily Bryant if you are changing your hours or if you're reducing your hours. We got zero responses to that. None. Okay?

28:28 And we have a good opening, I will tell you. Yeah, yeah, sorry, thank you for backing that up. Yeah, I mean, it does take the work of, you know, of you guys as well. I don't want to discredit anything that's going on, but, you know, I can make, me and Jezebel can make hundreds of calls every single day. Sometimes when staff picks up the phone, they only give us those that day, hours, and we have to push further.

28:56 That takes a significant amount of time. So again, my push, everybody please come to your association meetings for your businesses. Ken and what they've done there with the chamber has provided a really great resource for us to tackle these issues. And specifically the restaurant meeting does go very light on attendance. So would love, love.

29:22 love to get more engagement. I'll help you with that. Is there something, though, that the Chamber could do in its next newsletter that just talks about that, that says, look, we're getting feedback from customers that your Facebook hours are wrong, your Yelp hours are wrong, all that other stuff, and you really need to stay on top of this because we're driving customers with an expectation. And I do want to say on top of that that we actually employ a fact-checking group.

29:48 They are currently making those calls as well, and they make those automatic updates on our website so that our website is always active. But again, we're employing or paying an additional group to make this outreach happen, and it's still sort of falling short. Most restaurants are, if there are establishments, if they're updating Google and Yelp and Facebook and all of those, which I personally do for ours, we should make sure that I let you guys know.

30:17 So I'll definitely make that commitment. And I think we do put in the news Monday, hey, please let us know. We're asking them to always update their own stuff on the database, all that. Yeah, it was also in the occupancy report for many months asking for the same sort of information. Is there a single link where a rest of people can go and actually do it? We just need to communicate to them to make sure they go there and update it.

30:45 Well, no, so they just need to email me. Okay. Because of the way that the, so what we've been able to provide is a Google Doc link, which allows many people throughout the community to access it. Many front desks then, it can be sent to anybody, it can be sent to all of you to click on and access that. I don't give the rights to edit that out because of the circus we might get into. So we just need people to communicate. And again,

31:10 When we have put that link to that Google Doc in Ken's Chamber newsletter and in the Occupancy Report and said, hey, we understand that employees are short and that your hours are changing and that you're closed a couple days a week, but they need to respond. Because I just can't...

31:26 I can't take every single day making calls to every business in this town. I do have other work to do. And you know what? You shouldn't have to. You shouldn't have to. I know, but I just want everybody to understand that that is the effort that it took during COVID to get that list during COVID, is it took me making phone calls literally almost every single day. I called the full round of businesses during COVID, and that was done in my home, so a lot of people didn't see that. But that's the effort that took to get just those hours during COVID.

31:55 Ken, I would just say that, you know, my experience with franchise operations is that if you talk to the owner, they're going to tell you, yeah, everything's updated because they have someone else do it. But they're not checking it. They're not the best source of whether it's right or not. So asking them to update any changes probably isn't the right way. It's going to take a shock for someone to say, hey, look, we've sent people to your establishment on three consecutive days you were closed to because your website's wrong. You know, so you need to fix it.

32:25 But Emily, to your point, that's not, that's really not your job. It becomes a full, just as Emily said, it becomes a full court press. Every time you turn around, you think you've got the information and something's going to be wrong. But frankly, shame on the business, you know. I agree. Yeah, as a small business with, you know, very few employees and all of them family, you know, we...

32:51 You probably have a little better communication process. You'd be surprised. All right, we need to keep moving here. Thank you so much, Emily, Ken, for those comments. Let's move to our guest presentation, Housing Now. Sandra and Nolan, good to see you. Welcome. Happy New Year. Thanks for being here today. Thank you so much. We're so happy to be here.

33:14 And so Nolan's going to share a screen so we can just broadcast the presentation. But just a little bit of introduction. The reason why we are here is because we've been out in the community over the past six months, year, and we hear people saying, what's the town doing for housing? You know, what are you guys doing for housing? And we feel like we've got a pretty robust housing program. And so we're trying to kind of do this housing roadshow where we go to all of the different boards, commissions, service groups.

33:42 and present on the housing program. So Nolan and I will walk through the program. If anyone has any questions, feel free to just kind of stop us during the program. But we'll try to keep to kind of a 20-minute presentation or so so that you guys can move on to your other items. But thank you all for allowing us to be here to present. So we'll start with Nolan kind of explaining what area median income is and how it relates to our program. Great. And John?

34:09 Apologize now, I think you've already seen this presentation in one of your other positions, but it's a very active member of the community, you get exposed to it a lot. So this intro slide's really to cover just when we're talking about any of the housing programs or projects, they all relate back to area median income as far as who's eligible to live in any of the units or purchase the units.

34:35 Area Median Income, or AMI, is the household income for the median or middle household in a region. Our region is Mono County. This is set by the state, so we have no control over what our area median income is. So for Mono County, the AMI is $81,200 for a family of four. And all the programs kind of use that as a benchmark for establishing the rental rates or the purchase rates.

35:05 So on the bottom of the screen we have what's called our housing bridge. It just shows the spectrum of affordability programs from low income all the way through upper income. And the colors coordinate with the chart as well. So in orange on the far left you have your affordable or lower incomes. It's generally considered 80% AMI and below. These are usually the areas that are supported by state and federal grant programs. They have a lot more restrictions on

35:34 On the use of the funding. To go in the middle, you get to your moderate, upper middle income, missing middle, a variety of terms for that. This area is unique because it's not eligible for state or federal funding, but they still need assistance to purchase units or even afford the rent. That's really where local general fund dollars and other programs can step in to assist for these income groups. On the far right, you have your upper incomes.

36:03 Generally, it's about 200% AMI and higher. Mammoth is slightly unique. Even at the 200% AMI, they still need assistance often. Just a note on this table. When people come up and ask us, hey, do we fit into your category? How much do I have to make to go into one of the units? It's complicated because it depends on how many people are in the household. So we oftentimes have to say, well, how many people live in your household? How much do they make? And so it does take some math.

36:31 Putting that all together so it's not just an easy kind of cut or dry without kind of getting some more information from people to see if they qualify. So I'll start with kind of our showcase project, the parcel. Hopefully most of you are aware or have heard of the parcel, which is a 25-acre piece of property in the center of our town. It was purchased by the town in 2018. It took a good...

37:00 Some time to negotiate that purchase, but we were able to do that. And the project is approved for up to 450 affordable housing units. So it's under construction right now with phase one. We've broken down phase one and phase two here for you. Both phase one and phase two have been approved. And phase one is 81 units with 80 affordable units and one manager's unit. A range of units from studio to three bedrooms, a range of affordability.

37:29 from 30, 60, and 80 percent area median income. And phase one will have a public park and a child care facility for up to 34 infants, I'm sorry, 34 children, including infants, toddlers, and preschool. And it was really important to the town to have infant care as a part of this facility because that's not often included in our day care facilities and it's really needed by our community. Phase two, we are looking for funding for that. We submitted for funding in November.

37:58 Sorry, we submitted for funding and the award was announced in November. We did not receive any funding for Phase 2 yet. Our next application will go in on February 7th and I think they announced it maybe two months later or something like that. So we are not super competitive for this funding just because it is so expensive to construct housing here. But it's important for us to continue applying because for Phase 1 we applied for funding from low-income housing tax credit three times.

38:27 And then the governor set up this California Housing Accelerator Fund to fund all of the projects that weren't funded. And so we were able to get funding through that. So it's really important to show that we're shovel-ready, we're interested, we want to move this project forward. Okay, so the phase one we called it the Sawyer. You can see some photos here on the left-hand side is the renderings of the final project. The right-hand side is an aerial view of it under construction.

38:57 That is before they put the modules on the smaller building to the bottom of the picture there. And the modular, all of the modules were completed in mid-November. They are out there working. They'll be working all winter long, working inside the building. And so those modules, they all come separate, and then they unwrap them, stack them, and then they kind of stitch them together, for lack of a better term. So that's what they'll be doing all winter long.

39:23 And I had the opportunity to visit the modular factory in May of last year. It was really, really exciting to see the units that are actually going to be homes for our community members to be out there. You can see me on the lower right-hand corner.

39:36 One of the units is under construction, but the really interesting thing about these is they're fully built in the factory. They include toilets, cabinets, everything in their sinks, everything's there, and it all works. They hook it up to all the plumbing, electrical, everything works before it leaves the factory. So then when they come and stack up here, then they have to run the electricity and run the plumbing through the entire building. And then just some more pictures of the units. These are actually units that...

40:01 These are the installed units here in Mammoth Lakes. On the lower right-hand side, you can see out the window, the parcel is going to have some pretty nice views there. But everything arrived, you know, in one piece and connected, and they just kind of go out there and take all the, you know, all the wrappings off and everything for all of the different units. And so this is just some action shots of the upper left-hand corner as a module being delivered on Tavern Road there.

40:28 And then some of the other action shots of the project being built. Just a quick summary of the Kingfisher Phase 2. It's 148 units. And you can see in the lower left-hand corner, it's got a central green with passive open space in the middle. So that'll kind of provide a really nice opportunity for these residents to have some kind of greenery around them. And the funding for the project has come from a variety of different sources.

40:56 But if you look, kind of, we've put together the pie chart, kind of listed all the sources, but this project has been able to leverage local dollars one to five. So this is really, really great for our small community. We've been able to bring in all of this money, $77.8 million for this project funding. Most of it has come from the state, but 17% has come from the town as well. And I think a lot of this shows the dedication of our town council.

41:24 to affordable housing that they've been taking general fund money and putting it into this project. But yeah, we've been very successful with funding for the project. And then I'll let Nolan talk about small site development. Great. So stepping away from the parcel, moving towards some of our other projects we have underway. This project here, it's our kind of first small site development project. We're looking at, well, we purchased the site on Joaquin Road. It's a .2 acre site.

41:53 to build four units, so two duplex units on the site. These are going to be ownership units. The target occupancy for this is 150% AMI, so that's kind of getting up into that missing middle, upper middle. We're able to do that because all the funding for this project is general fund dollars that have been allocated to the project, so we're not under the same requirements as, say, the parcel, which is state and federal money.

42:17 So the bid for this project was awarded a $2.4 million bid for the construction. Just in my email today got the design review package for it, so we'll proceed with all the entitlements on this project to get that through. Their goal is to break ground this spring on the project. We have here occupancy in fall. We'll see if they can hit that or if we're going to have to delay it.

42:44 Kind of like everything else in construction, you set a goal and then there's delays. We're still pushing forward. They're confident they can still deliver close to that timeline. We'll continuously provide updates as that moves forward. One of the unique things of this project though is because it's a town-owned project is we'll own the plans at the end of it. We'll own the duplex plans and our goal is to

43:13 Continue to look for additional sites in the community, both small and large, where we could build additional versions of this project on the site. So it's replicable and scalable. These units are very livable. They're two-bedroom, two-car garage units with one and a half baths within the units. Hold on, are they modular? They are. So yeah, with the modular, I mean, you're, I don't want to say limited in design, but you kind of get more of a

43:46 boxy design because it's somewhat dictated by the efficiency from the modular plan as to the sizing, what fits on the truck, how they all go together. They can obviously do kind of hybrids with modulars where some of it's stick built, some of it's modular, but still a lot of it's really dictated by what fits on the truck. California is very strict on what can get trucked here in the sizing. If you're over by an inch, you don't get to come in. Wow.

44:14 Where is that factory where you went, Sandra? Boise. Boise? Oh, Boise. It's up in Idaho? Okay. Yeah, the factory that's actually going to do the 6th Joaquin is in Southern California, so they're kind of getting, I think, as Modular becomes more of a, they're advancing just in their efficiencies and technology, we're seeing more and more of those plants pop up. What we see here with Modular, it's not so much a huge cost savings, but it's a time saving.

44:45 When we look at the parcel, they were doing the foundation podium all summer, but they were also building all the units at the same time off-site, so they were able to go vertical in a much shorter time than if that was stick built. Moving on to the next program is what we call our bridge program. This program is really intended to unlock existing housing to be affordable and occupied by the local workforce. So we're out there purchasing market rate units.

45:15 Then restricting the price down to an affordable level and it's a partnership project with Mammoth Lakes Housing working through households on their wait list as well as on the MLS to sell these units to income eligible households. So the target AMI for these units is 120% AMI, so slightly lower than the 60 Joaquin project, still in that middle income category. Again,

45:43 Not eligible for most state and federal tax funding. It's really looking at using general fund dollars to subsidize the price down to that affordable level. The goal for the subsidy is $100,000 to $150,000 per unit reduction. So it's roughly if we say buy a unit for $480,000. The kind of target for that sales price is around $350,000.

46:06 It does require a deed restriction that goes in effect to cap the sales price to that affordable level and the eligibility for the unit. It requires they live in the unit full-time and work in the region. And going subsequent years, it just requires that they continue to live in it and work in it, work in the region. So even if they got a raise, they're still eligible to continue to own their house. So if they go to sell it,

46:33 They're restricted to only those in that 120% or less AMI category. Funding for this came from Town Council. They allocated $1.4 million. Our goal is to get about 12 units. Each purchase and resale, that $1.4 million shrinks by that subsidy. We have so far acquired five units. Three have been sold. Two are currently for sale through MLH.

46:57 I've been told they're working with a household currently for one of the units, so hopefully we get that into escrow soon. And we're working on purchasing an additional unit currently. I've been emailing back and forth trying to agree on a sales price, so hopefully that works out. And just on the top, just to kind of showcase really the need for this program, in the green you have the median condo sales prices for 2021 through about June of 2022 for one, two, and three-bedroom condos.

47:26 And then below you have the affordable price for 200%, 150%, and 120% AMI households. And really when you see the chart that 200% AMI is the only one that can afford a one or two bedroom median price. But that's also for a three person household. So I don't know that many three person households that want to be in a one bedroom. It really shows that discrepancy between market rate versus what

47:55 Various AMIs can afford. And these numbers were pre-interest rate increases. So now that number is even higher. The interest rate jump kind of from the 2.5% up to the 6% really requires households make about $80,000 more per year to kind of afford the same household as before with that interest rate jump. So some of our other existing programs, the town maintains a revolving loan fund.

48:23 This is critical not only for existing deed restricted units but as we're adding more deed restricted ownership units into the community. We want to make sure that those deed restrictions stay in place should that owner decide to sell. Deed restrictions have a limited period where if they can't find an eligible household to purchase it and the town says no, we don't want to purchase the unit back, we run the risk of actually losing that deed restriction.

48:50 So by having this dedicated fund, the town has $600,000 set aside, Mammoth County has an additional $300,000 set aside that's intended to be used here in the town. That gives us roughly $900,000 billable to purchase back deed restricted units as they come on the market. If we purchase it back, then we have unlimited time to find the right household for that unit to resell it with the deed restriction in place.

49:17 We also maintain as a town six employee housing units. These are units owned by the town. We have three studios, one one-bedroom unit and two two-bedroom units. These are interim housing for town employees and then outside agency employees as well. We have to get approached by Forest Service, Mono County as we hire new employees either kind of seasonal or full-time that are coming into town to provide housing for when they first arrive.

49:45 The goal is for it to be about six months that they can live there as they kind of look for more permanent housing in the community. Then a few partnership projects. The first two are both Mammoth Lakes Housing Projects. The town's heavily committed to these projects, both in funding and staff time. We've also been partners on a variety of grants for both of these projects. First one's the Access Apartments, the old country glass building.

50:15 238 Sierra Manor Road. It's going to be related to 11 one-bedroom apartments. Their goal is to start construction in April. It's been about four years now, I think, to secure all the funding for this project. The town's committed money. We were awarded a CDBG grant for $3 million, and then MLH was awarded a home grant for $3.4 million, and a variety of other sources for that funding as well.

50:44 We're putting out the construction bid in two weeks for this project to hopefully kick this off in April with construction. Then the next one is the Home Key Projects. This is a unique state program that's really intended to address homelessness within the state. Their quick answer is to purchase older lodging facilities that can be quickly converted to residential uses.

51:10 Our kind of homeless population is unique here, so we really worked with the state to kind of define what our homeless population is, and we got the state to allow for a higher AMI households within these units than what they typically allow. So we're able to get 80% AMI and below for the future occupancies of these units. There are going to be 15 affordable units and one manager's unit. Most of the funding came from the state, $4.7 million.

51:38 The town committed money as well as the county for this project. This project's currently under construction. They've removed all the furniture. They're getting ready to commence all the demo work. It's all really interior work, so you won't see much on the outside. They're not expanding the building or anything, but it's all interior to upgrade it, bringing it up to kind of habitable standards with current codes. And the last one's partnership is the Chamber of Commerce Program, their tenant landlord matching program.

52:07 This program's been in place for about four years now. I think it's a great program because many landlords are hesitant to kind of just put an ad out for fear they might get. Who knows what kind of tenants they might get. This program, the chamber's really doing the vetting for the landlord to make sure they're employed by a local business. They're doing background checks. So it kind of hopefully creates that perfect match between tenants and landlords. Landlords will feel more comfortable.

52:36 Tenants that have a source to kind of not have to cold call a number of units that can go through the chamber. This last slide here is really just to highlight kind of the grant dollars that we've been successful in bringing in in the last few years for being a small community. We've brought in close to $75 million in the last really let's say two to three years, which when you kind of look at the small population is a pretty significant number going all towards housing.

53:08 And then another item that we've done is put together prescribed designs for accessory dwelling units. We pushed those out a couple months ago. But these are really designs that are completed so that if someone has a lot that you could do an add-on or do a detached building, you can come to the counter, get these designs. They're available on our website. You can see on the right-hand side there's a link to where they are on the website.

53:33 And they look pretty good. On the left-hand side, there's the different designs, the rural mountain, high desert. And there are five different designs of different sizes. So really flexible. These designs work in the town and in the county as well. And really what it does is saves people time on pulling together these designs and the cost of those. And it also makes the review go a lot faster.

54:02 We're pretty excited to have those. And we've gotten some compliments on the design, but they ended up coming out really, really nice. Everybody really likes them.

54:10 And then finally we've put together a did you know, I believe it's on the back counter here, just with some summary of the number of affordable housing units, workforce housing units that we'll be delivering in the next 12 to 24 months. So we're looking at if all of these projects move forward, 272 units for this community, which is really a big

54:32 lift and will be really great for our community and kind of circling back to the discussion that you were having during your board member reports about why these restaurants are leaving and what's the root cause. I mean, I think and I think we all probably know that affordable housing is one of the causes, right? We can't get, you know, people to live here and it is so expensive to live here. So I think these will really help kind of.

54:55 Float All Boats or Rise All Boats once these units are delivered. These are available on our website as well. So I would encourage if people don't know what's going on with the housing program that, you know, send them to our website or give them one of the handouts. And Nolan and I are always happy to answer any questions or come to any other boards or commissions or anything that you're a part of. So with that, that completes our presentation. We're happy to answer any questions that you have.

55:21 Quick question, Sandra. Thank you very much, and I really applaud what you guys are doing. I've always had one question that concerns me, and maybe my math is wrong, but regarding the parcel, I mean, if we're talking 80% of AMI to qualify, two people making $20 an hour make $80,000 a year. That's a family of, and if they have two kids, so if they make $80,000 a year at $20 an hour, and they can't qualify for the parcel, then

55:50 Who is going to qualify? Because nobody makes less than $20 an hour anymore. So according to this, we've pulled census data, and there's like 1,600 people in this community that make less than 80% AMI, according to the census. Now, it is difficult. The census compiles data differently. But we do think there is a market for this. Well, good. I hope I'm wrong. Yes. Any other questions? Not a question, just a comment.

56:20 Really appreciate all the town's efforts on this. It's really exciting. We see the units stored at the airport, and I watched a presentation to council where they're actually moving the units in, and the fact that they're basically done as they're set is super cool. And, yeah, just really excited that the town's working on this. $75 million is super impressive, so good for you. And John, Rob, and I were talking to Destin Dijon from Bishop today, and...

56:48 This is a problem everywhere. Bishop's dealing with it right now, and they're trying to find a, they're working on a 12-acre parcel right now, and it just, it feels good to actually see stuff coming out of the ground, and it's exciting. So thank you for that. Thank you. Moving in the right direction. Really appreciate the presentation today. Noel and Sandra, thank you so much for all your hard work.

57:13 Mr. Souser, you and your council members, thank you for all your hard work on this. I think this is what the community needs, and it's very exciting to see. So, wonderful. Consent agenda. Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? Make a motion. All right. Do I have a second? This is to approve the minutes of our regular meeting of December 7th. So moved. Roll call, Angie. Chair Goico? Yes. Vice Chair Foster? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes.

57:46 Secretary Mandel? Yes. Board Member Radcliffe? Yes. Board Member Salzer? Yes. Thank you. Awesome. Moving on to policy matters, research report, Brian Wright. You coming up? Happy New Year, Mr. Brian Wright. Good to see you, sir. Glad to be here. And this is going to be a quick update on...

58:09 One of the issues that we found last year was that the Airbnb short-term rental data wasn't in the research. We pulled that back in, sent it back out, and this shifted. So the fall number was like 45%, which we all kind of giggled at, but we figured that out. It's because we have such a massive amount of short-term rentals. This is the updated version now. So of the share of trips, so the folks who came in, 15% fall, 54% winter, and 31% spring and summer. We did see a pretty big shift over to the spring-summer.

58:39 numbers, but those numbers come in, total visitor days of 12 million, almost 12.5 million visitor days, unique visitors, you know, 2.4 million visitors, and that brings up, and that's visitors, that's unique visitors, that means they came up multiple times, so if you look at the per person trips, that's 3.9 million people came up here throughout the course of the year, so pretty big shift there, and we're excited to see that working. This is a, this is a,

59:06 Same data. We did this two different ways. We can see it in two different directions. So basically, this is it by season. So the share of trips, per-person trips, and again, how it's split up there by fall, winter, and summer. And then we'll do that also for, we didn't do anything from 18, 19, 19, or 20. We'd be picked up again in 21. So this is, you know, going back almost three years. This is the kind of shift that we saw there.

59:29 This is the shift from 15 and 16. And then if we don't look at that by year in comparison, there's the 15, 16, 17, 18, and then 20, 21 as well from share of trips, person trips. You can see this move and the increase actually in the per person trips. So the share of trips on the top, the bottom is a person trips, the year over year growth, you know, 8% from 15 to 16 to 17, 18, and then 57% over the course of the next three years. So we've seen this massive, massive influx just over those years. And this is the way to look at this then too from total days.

59:58 61% since the last time we measured, 42% increase in unique visitors since the last time we measured. So really excited about just seeing what we're able to do and get folks coming here and spreading them out throughout the year. Going over, we have a spring-summer ad effectiveness campaign that we want to review through really quickly, as well as the ROI effectiveness.

1:00:18 Our summer campaign specifically was able to reach 22% of our targeted travelers. We used multiple campaigns. We did the Hug What You Love campaign, which was kind of the stewardship campaign, plus we did the Come Up and Visit campaign. Another challenge is that more destinations are advertising this year, so we didn't see a little bit of a drop because the competition found money and was able to get back out there like we are.

1:00:40 The consumer reaction to creative concepts tested almost 80%. So people liked what we were showing them. And I have a little note in a little bit to show you. It's pretty comical. There were a few naysayers on that, but I'll tell you why.

1:00:53 And the advertising effectively improves familiarity and perceptions of the destination. So it's really this destination that's like nothing else that values sustainability and stewardship. It works holistically with all of our other stuff that we're doing. So from our visitor guide, online profiles, from our social media as well.

1:01:10 And then if you look at this, the last thing we're going to look at is the result with those who said that they saw an ad versus those who didn't see an ad are much more likely to visit Mammoth to the tune of 33% say, yeah, if you haven't seen an ad, I'd come to Mammoth. 53% once they've seen our ad say they want to come. So that's a massive jump. The next few slides kind of get really into those deep kind of top-line things we talked about, but we spent about 49% less than we did pre-pandemic, but recall is really only down 30%, so we actually...

1:01:40 a net positive there. This is one of the things I found kind of curious, but the reactions were very strong, right, almost 80%. The benchmark is to be 60% positive, but the next line is, of the very few negatives, mostly they were perceptions of a progressive agenda that we were pushing on people. So this hug what you love felt very...

1:02:01 Too fluffy and left for some folks. So that's what they kind of, so that's what, the nice thing is, is that the folks who didn't see it, I want to talk about who saw it, who didn't like it, stay home, that's okay. It's only 2%, and you know what, if they're not going to come up here and take care of the place that we love and live, then we just would rather not have them show up. As we saw in prior seasons, those with recall of ads indicate a higher familiarity with Mammoth Lakes, so you see those two boxed areas there, folks who

1:02:30 saw, we didn't see our ads versus the folks who did see our ads, we're right, we're closing that gap on Tahoe super quickly there. And this with these ads, they improve their perception, right? Mammoth Lakes is, it's luxurious, it's refined, it's like nothing else. It has its image in a place that values sustainability and stewardship. And as you see, those summer ads bringing Mammoth more up in line with Tahoe. The first is, you see that difference there, the third one over versus difference.

1:02:56 Like nothing I've seen before, it's unpretentious, but once they've seen our ads, we actually jump over Tahoe on those two, and then you'll see the other three or four behind that levels us out. So we're actually getting right up there with those Tahoe messages. Social channels, website, travel guide are all frequently used by those who saw the ads, and in fact, we asked the question, we asked three things. Did you find it useful, not useful, or somewhat useful? Nobody said they found it not useful at all. So that's the breakdown of very useful versus somewhat useful of our visitor guide.

1:03:26 The likelihood with Mammoth Lakes increases, like I talked earlier, 33 to 53 percent with folks who have seen our ads and who want to come then. And from an ROI perspective, now this is for the whole year, that was just summer, but for the whole year, we ran two sets of creative, right? We talked about, you know, the education part of it, and then we talked about the, just come up here, please.

1:03:48 We saw that that actually may have confused a few people because they're selling multiple ads and multiple messages going out. But with what we're doing now with that real-on-real messaging, being it's all one campaign, one message, we're going to see that drop and the numbers go up for us there too. There was pent-up travel demand, but as travel patterns returned to normal, smaller spending levels may not be able to generate this level of ROI because we were able to bring that number down on what we were spending and then we got up a higher reach.

1:04:16 This is, again, with people seeing multiple campaigns because there were overlapping exposures. Some travelers recalling ads from multiple seasons. Total reach was 40%. And then, you know, we're not taking credit for everything. You know, there is a folks who will come here regardless of if they see us or not. So what we'd like to do is make sure that we're talking about the incremental.

1:04:36 People coming. We don't want to talk. We don't take credit for the folks who are going to come anyway. It's just all incremental. So we take that down there. It's about 1% is the unaware. This is industry standard across the way. And we try to get to that incremental travel number. So if you look here, we're seeing that the baseline visitation was low in the fall because of the Omicron variant. But overall, for the total of the year, 160,000.

1:05:00 Influence Trips, with a total spend of $219,000, almost $220,000, $220 million, with only a media spend of about a million dollars, just a little over a million dollars. So the ROI has been going up every year, and even compared to last year, with the last time we did this back in 2018 and 19, it went up from 165 to 201 this year. And then compared to years prior, much larger ROI, despite...

1:05:25 Despite fewer influence trips, and that's because due to the weird circumstances of the year, economic recovery, all the messaging that we had going out there, the outdoor product resonated strongly. People wanted to get out of the cities. I mean, remember Santa Monica, the beach closed down. They couldn't even get outside in the cities where they wanted to get outside, so they came here. Denver and then the Northeast, we changed it.

1:05:50 In order to save a little bit of money this year, we went out and asked a couple questions in different services at the exact same time. The problem with that is that the number we were able to get and ask the questions to was low. We've instructed the agency not to do that this next year, so that will be changing in the coming years, but we only had, like, from a Denver perspective, this is good information from a directional standpoint, but we only talked to, like, seven people. So it's not statistically relevant at this point in time. It does show positive growth as well as the Northeast.

1:06:20 And then the last thing, this added impact on sustainability. So this huge, massive positive reaction of the creative, sustainability messaging resonates with MLT visitors. So if you look at this, how important is it with sustainability and stewardship efforts in your destination of choice? Just from the folks even who are unaware of us to the folks who are aware of us, it's just we're talking to the right people. We're making sure that they're seeing the right thing. So excited, really good news, but just across the board. And we're excited to see what happens this next year with this brand new messaging.

1:06:50 That was a lot and fast, and I apologize. It's all up in here, so if you ask any questions, it's okay. Brian, do you have – I'm sorry, go ahead, John. Go ahead. Real quick, just in regards to the ROI, my only concern is that obviously you're looking at what marketing dollars you spent year over year. Obviously, there's been an inflationary aspect to the marketing amount, but there's also an inflationary –

1:07:16 Amount to the revenue that's been generated. And I'm wondering where that, I mean, I know it's kind of hard to qualify that or quantify it, but I mean, I kind of feel like, you know, a lot of places have raised their, raised the revenues that we get, all of us have raised our prices. So is that, I guess what I'm trying to say is, is there any kind of an adjustment for that just to see if the ROI is...

1:07:39 You know, kind of one for one. Yeah, I mean, I guess that's where I'm going. Because if you're spending the same amount of marketing dollars and you have an 8% increase in your marketing expense and town is, everybody's increased their rates by 20%, then, but I guess that's a good thing. If it was that direction. What we've seen is it's pretty much on par. So if we went up, like, if media costs went up almost 15%, actually.

1:08:02 Right, and the town went up by 20%. It's close. So we've made sure that we're talking almost the same dollars in inflationary spend, but good point. Yes, sir. My annual or my monthly question, agency review. So that's in my update next, but it's going out. So it will drop. So it's down to, I think I've shortened it down to about 16 pages right now. It's going out tomorrow evening or Friday morning at the absolute latest. That's fine. You don't need to. Right there.

1:08:31 It has nothing to do with these metrics, but, you know, we're measuring against ourselves, right? I mean, to a certain degree. And we're getting the same thing that we've always gotten. So if we want something different, we need to at least know what else is out there. Correct. Plus, I'm still kind of smarting a little bit from their pay us in advance or, you know, we won't do the work for you. Right. We've had conversations. We've fixed that. But yes.

1:09:00 Thank you. Good? Any questions? Any other questions for Brian? Brian, thank you so much. Moving on to winter air service update. Mr. Hurd, do you want to take that one? Yeah, I'm going to go through this fairly quickly. I'm going to bring up the report that I sent out to you. The numbers were through last Tuesday when we had the booking report. I more want to talk to you about, since my Zoom is updating, perfect timing.

1:09:31 Basically, during the Christmas week here, we had some challenges with air service, but in the grand scheme of things, the airlines worked very well and the airports worked very well to make sure that those were minimized. We did have a couple of cancellations with United, and they were half cancellations. You might ask what a half cancellation is. It's when you can either land and can't take off or you can take off but you can't land. And so we had a...

1:10:00 Denver flight. Let me just bring this up. We had a Denver flight that had to divert. You sound better. Yeah. There we go. So we did have a Denver flight that had to divert, and we actually were originally told that it was weather and Bishop. That was changed to being a mechanical issue that they had.

1:10:31 Fortunately, Fresno is a mechanical site for United, so they were able to fly over to Fresno, get the plane taken care of, and come back to Mammoth. So that wasn't a cancellation. We did have a cancellation where the flight coming from Denver couldn't get out of Denver. But we had 66 people in Bishop that needed to get out of Bishop back to Denver. United, again, multinational company, Mammoth Lakes, it's back on the world for them.

1:11:00 They flew a plane from Colorado Springs, empty, over to Bishop to pick up those 66 people and bring them out. So the flight in was canceled, the flight out was not. And so we had a couple of delays that were challenging. On the 30th, we had two delays that ended up having people not get out of here until 8 and 9 o'clock at night with United, getting into Denver at 1230 in the morning.

1:11:27 One flight that left for San Francisco couldn't get into San Francisco. It diverted to Fresno. People stayed over the night in Fresno, including the crew, hopped the plane the next day, ended up in San Francisco. So that one was not a cancellation. And so we were able to complete that flight. I think it was 19 and a half hours late when that comes down to it. Presume you're not talking to Southwest. What's that? Presume you're not talking to Southwest. We are not.

1:11:54 We are not. I guess thankfully at this point Southwest does not have a plane that will work for us. But with advanced air we did have one diversion on the 30th. We got the Hawthorne flight in in the morning. The other two flights needed to divert to Bishop. It was windy as all get out down there. And so that was a quick turn. Pat and Summer and crew.

1:12:25 Did a fantastic job. I think the full delay to get people out was minimal. It was an hour and change. And so I think that in the grand scheme of the air service for the holiday week, the load factors were very strong. And obviously during the holiday week, just like lodging, the rates were high. And so Denver from the 26th of December to the 31st of December was flying about an 86, 87% load factor.

1:12:50 So again, that's 60 to 65 people per plane coming in and coming out. So very, very productive. So I put the sheet up here. You can all look at it, but the Denver numbers continue to move up. San Francisco is starting to pick up even more. Carlsbad continues to pick up. So the numbers we got in this morning were very, very strong. So very pleased where we are with the air service. John, how did our transportation go? Transportation went swimmingly. I mean, everything was smooth. It was...

1:13:20 You know, the diversion on the 30th, both Moz and Mammoth Taxi were pretty much full going down the hill and coming back up the hill, and I think that our guests, while they may have been slightly delayed, again, they were able to get here. Well, I appreciate it. Moz had to take one of our guests from here to Santa Monica, which was not cheap, but they got them there, and that was great, so I appreciate that effort. Absolutely. Any questions on air? This is showing, you know,

1:13:49 Like if we look at Denver 6174 compared to 3468, that is like this time last year? Absolutely. It's facing year over year. So last year we had 3,468 round trips. This year we have 6174. And then down below you can see that's 2,700 difference. And that's at this time? As of last Tuesday. I didn't run the numbers for this morning, but that gap has probably grown. Okay.

1:14:15 I mean, very encouraging numbers here on all the flights. Absolutely. So, looking good. Yep. Did you want to say something about the 10? Oh, we're in the street, the 10 packs available now. Okay. Yeah, no, the 10 packs are still available out there. Okay, cool. Any further questions for John on anything air-related, air service? I was going to say that the Denver flight is bringing a lot of folks from the East Coast. Yeah. And they spend more time here, they spend more money here, and they're less.

1:14:47 Cranky. Because of the amazing snow and the amazing service that they get here. So, I mean, just from what I've, you know, interpreted across, you know, whether I'm in lines at the Lyft or I'm at the restaurants or I'm at Vons, they're super happy to be able to come out here. So that's been a win-win for us, I think. So thanks, John, for that. All right. Good stuff. Thanks, Dave. All right.

1:15:11 Moving on to our Tourism Business Improvement District T-Bid renewal update. John, take us through that. In your packet, you've got a one sheet. We had talked about when we go through the renewal, making sure that the board members had a lead-behind piece, but also an educational piece for themselves. And so this is what we've come up with. I've had a few pieces of feedback on it already. I look forward to more feedback.

1:15:34 Our management district plan has been reviewed by the town. There were a number of questions that came back or questions, suggestions, ideas, and so I spent about an hour on the call yesterday with our attorneys in Sacramento just to go through it and clarify and make sure we have that all squared away. So we will be updating the management district plan, getting it back to the town for final review. My hope at this point is that we can get the petition process started by the 15th of January, if not earlier.

1:16:03 and that we can get on the February 15th Town Council agenda for the resolution of formation. In order to do the resolution of formation, we need to submit all of the completed petitions to the town with all of the percentage breakouts. As I mentioned before, in 2013, we had 63% approval. In 2018, we had 61% approval. With the help of our board members, the goal this year is 66%. And with that, once we get the final management district plan done,

1:16:32 and any other feedback on this flyer that is included in your packet, then I would be looking for the board members, you know, retail, potentially work with Larry Crabb to really make sure that we talk to the top 20, 25 businesses. Obviously, everybody below it is very important as well. You know, Pat, hopefully you can work with Deb on the restaurant side. We've got our two lodging reps. Jeremy's available being the chamber rep.

1:17:00 and that we can get the process, you know, really, I think what we would be looking at is probably a three-week window where we want to try and set up these meetings with the business owners to get the petition signed. John, do we have any, well, things like the chamber? Has the chamber put out anything supporting renewal of TB? If they have, I'm sorry, I missed it. Well, at this point, we have not put that out. We actually...

1:17:25 We definitely get the support from the chamber. In fact, we've got our chamber board meeting next week. It's a major, major conversation. Broader constituent. Everybody expects the board to be supportive. But I think the broader community base helps us as well. And if there's any other organizations that can support this. Yeah, and we'll be making sure that we...

1:17:51 So while we'll be asking the board members to do the in-person meetings to get the petitions, we will be doing the mailings, the emailings, all those different pieces so that everybody will get the information. A lot of things will get just mailed in, but again, setting up the meetings with the different retailers and again, the goal being 66%. So right now, I'm hoping that we can get the feedback back to the town on the management district plan by the...

1:18:16 You know, potentially by the end of this week, and then we can get the petitions all squared away, and I can make sure that you all have a list of your constituents in that group, and we can get out there and get those petitions done. John, can I use that for my meeting on Monday? Absolutely. Okay, great. So we have a general lodging meeting Monday, and I definitely want to go over that and make sure that's there. Everybody gets a copy of it so they can see it. Yep, perfect. Any other questions?

1:18:45 You know, the air service update is a good piece to kind of, you know, go along with this TBID renewal information you put together. I mean, such a big part of our, you know, efforts is air service and showing people what's going on like right now this year with air service is, you know, I think a good thing to show people in lodging as well, John. Well, that's a great point because we do, you know,

1:19:12 We do talk about the fact that we're going, where am I, right here, you know, talking about the destination marketing. Yeah. And I think that some of the information, so we've had surveys done in Bishop since December 15th.

1:19:23 We do have some of that information to talk about the folks that are coming in. We've got all of our web stats that are talking about the fact that New York is, you know, fast approaching our number one market from a website standpoint. And I think that really, to Deb's point, the destination visitor coming in, staying longer, spending more money, having less impact. You know, your housekeepers aren't cleaning every other day. They're cleaning five days later. And so I think it really makes it a lot different when you're not having to clean up as much.

1:19:53 I hate to bring this up, but the other point was brought out by our article, unfortunately, too late, in the sheet. When you look at the other communities that have lost air service, paying 2X, 3X, 4X more, we focus on the tourism piece of the air service. What about the local need for air service, right? The ability for workers to be able to...

1:20:20 Go to L.A. or Denver or travel and not have to drive to Reno or L.A. or anything else. And I think that component of it, too, shouldn't be overlooked. Because it's not just something that's, you know, come in so all the business, if you're a business owner, of course you're going to support it, but what about me as a local who, you know, works in the service industry and needs to get to L.A. or San Diego or Hawthorne or whatever. So I think that...

1:20:46 That piece ought to be a part of that flyer. Yeah, that's a good point, and I think that that is something that we always talk about when we talk to the councils and supervisors and all that about the local benefit of medical appointments and family and all those different things. But I think, you know, for the rank and file, you know, people who live here, that's a huge component, and it's something that the town can't do or isn't do. You know, I mean, not a fence, but it's...

1:21:15 We're able to do that, and it brings in tourists, but it also gives locals an opportunity to do it. More accessibility. Absolutely. I mean, when I got on the board four years ago, literally the entire board was like, I'm never flying out of Fairfax Airport again. The entire board was saying that. So it was like, to see where we're at now, and it's like, you know, that's not the case anymore, is refreshing, to say the least.

1:21:40 Yeah, I mean, we've had a total of three half cancellations out of Bishopton. Yeah, that's not even the point. It's just really... But the consistency and the reliability, because the problem is we've never been able to build the base, and the locals are really a good base. So now if the locals can trust the service, you're right, we need to make sure that people understand that that's great for your employee, that's great for your business owner. The old local thing was not have a good flight, it was just have a flight. Right. Hope you get out. Hope you get out. Exactly. We've got a lot of locals on the advanced air flight app. We do.

1:22:09 Well, that connectivity from Hopper into LAX, I mean, with that free shuttle, that's awesome. That's awesome. I mean, that's really an easy deal. Yep. Okay. All right, wonderful. Let's move on to our financial report. Yeah, again, I don't need to dwell on this too long because I know we got our staff reports and I don't want to cut those short, but TOT collections for November came in very strong, again, to budget, and they were just shy of last year's record. And so year-to-date, they're still substantially ahead of budget.

1:22:38 And then on the TBID side, November came in actually ahead of budget, and then it was just slightly behind last year in November. The year-to-date, we're still just behind by about 4% and behind last year by about 5.5%. So I do think that when we get the December numbers that we're probably going to see those probably shorten that gap. You can also see the bank balances.

1:23:05 These are, we do have quite a few things that are coming up here. We've got checks with our agency. We've got checks, one more check with the airline. And so we'll see those things diminish a little bit. And also on the CDARS, the Certificate of Deposits, we've got, we've probably taken another, we'll need to take probably another $750,000 or so to front the money to United. That'll all come back to us at the end of the year.

1:23:33 Whether it's through falling short of the cap number or because of the backfill with the county of Inyo and also with the mountains. So we are fronting the money. It's about $1.6 million ahead of what is our final commitment. So we'll put that money back into the CDRs when we get to that point. And then the current balance of the tourism reserve is just over $500,000, which is substantial.

1:24:05 And then next month we will do – it's going to be a scramble for us because our meeting is on the 1st, but we will do a budget variance report next board meeting. Should we move our meeting? No, I think we can still get it done. I think the town will have – based on the timing of where the 20th falls and things fall in, it may not be final financials that we're working off of, but I think we'll be fine. Thank you.

1:24:31 All right, board reports, international sales. Mr. Vanderhurst, Happy New Year. Thanks for being with us. Back at you guys. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International Mammoth Lakes Tourism. You guys heard my report last month. We wrapped up 2022 pretty strongly, very active out there on the international side. A couple sales missions and a couple of media fam visits. So we should see some great coverage from that, from the snow, from the experience people are having on the mountains.

1:24:59 2023 is shaping up to be a very, very busy year. We're coming out of the gate here in January with a couple more sales missions, one to Latin America, and then a strategy session with Visit California down in Palm Springs in the middle of the month where we're going to kind of outline what we as partners with Visit California, what we think the state should be doing on the marketing side, what markets they need to be active in, and where we're active as DMO partners.

1:25:27 And then we are looking probably to have our most active press media fam winter to date. We are working in conjunction with Mammoth Resorts as well as Black Tie and Alterra Mountain Company to host media fams from Brazil, Mexico, Germany, Argentina, Australia, and the UK. And we are also looking with all of those partners to host trade fams from Australia, Brazil, and Germany.

1:25:54 So that will all happen between January and March. So it is going to be a very, very busy winter. Luckily, we've got the product to really promote. And then some. And then some. Any questions on the international side? Just a comment, and maybe you can comment on this. So I have a friend who lives in London, and last Wednesday, Sunday, he called me and said that he just, he said, are you guys flying kites? He goes, because.

1:26:27 I just read in the Herald that in Mammoth Lakes, California, you know, winds were gusting over 100 miles an hour and snow was great and everything else. I'm just wondering if it's our presence with that community that's actually getting news picked up in the International Herald or it's just a random news cycle that...

1:26:49 Do you have any insight into that? Have we done any linkage with FTE or anything like that? Yeah, so our agency in the UK, our contracted agency, we have a media component and a trade component. And our media component really, really...

1:27:03 Hand feeds all those stories to all the big publications, not only in the UK, but also in Ireland. I was just really surprised because, you know, New Year's Day, I wouldn't expect to get a call from him. Like, hey, I'm just reading where, you know. Outside, yeah, it's windy. We've gotten some great placements in the last couple of months, so don't be surprised to get a few more of those calls. We had eight Mexican families from Monterrey.

1:27:32 Come in and stay at like five days stay. It was fantastic. They were all, I've been seeing more and more families from Monterey, from Mexico coming, you know, Nuevo Leon, and both summer and winter and really great feedback from the groups, you know, about their experience here in Mammoth and, and.

1:27:58 You know, it's been enjoyable to get to know those folks and kind of welcome them to town. So keep it up on that front. I always let them know I'm going to be going to visit them for the 2026 World Cup because that's going to be a host city down in Mexico. And that is a result of our partnership with Altera. Like the Latin American markets are super important to Altera and they're really funneling that to Palisades and to Mammoth. We want to get them out of Aspen. Nice. Awesome.

1:28:27 Any other questions? Thanks, guys. Thank you so much, Michael. All right, communications, Laura Kaler, how are you? Happy New Year. Good to see you. Good to see you as well. Laura Kaler, Director of Content Communications and Domestic PR. I'm going to kind of be a broken record with what Michael said. We are going gangbusters with media visits for the next two months. We have 10 lined up from now through the end of February.

1:28:59 And kind of cool, out of all those 10, only one group is driving. Everyone else is on advanced air flights or United flights coming from different parts of the country. So pretty cool we're getting the word out about those flights because that'll be part of all their stories. At the end of this month, I'll be going to New York for international media market. We go with Visit California. There's a huge California presence there. They have a big pavilion.

1:29:28 Follow-up media visits the day after the event. So basically the event is a day full of speed dating. I sit and meet with about 30 journalists throughout the day for 15 minutes at a time and just tell them all about Mammoth Lakes. So that should be a great event. On the content side, we're working on our re-engagement program for some of our visitors who have kind of disengaged over the past two years with our newsletters.

1:29:58 We're going to be doing a re-engagement campaign to try to get them clicking on those newsletters again. We had talked about this several months ago, but I think a big part of it was a lot of our newsletters were talking about COVID updates and everything, and so people were really clicking on those, and then when it became less of a concern, maybe a little less interest, but so we're going to try to boost that back up. And then...

1:30:26 The crib is also full through March. We have the U.S. kayak team coming next week, which sounds weird. Where are they going to kayak? But they come up here to do cross-training. They started coming last year and had a great time. They'll be cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, doing all that good stuff. So they're a really great group. And they won gold at the Worlds last year. Yes. Oh, really? Wow. They're getting helped. That's why they're coming back. And that's it. Any questions?

1:30:55 Thank you. Great, Laura. Thanks for the update. All right, Mr. Brian Wright again with marketing. I said Happy New Year too, but I'm going to say Happy New Year again. Happy New Year. Happy New Year, Jeremy. Thanks. I appreciate that, Mr. Chair. So with Michael and Laura being in fam season, I'm in RFP season. So yeah, so the WebRFP went out. We got five results back.

1:31:21 Narrow that down to two, or down to three. Those will be coming in for in-person meetings with us on the 18th, 19th, and 20th of this month. Love to have anybody show up and watch them if they can make them more nervous if they want to be there. Put that schedule out? I'm sorry? Would you put that schedule out? Absolutely. Yep, totally, will do. That'd be great. I'll do that same thing with the MIT. Might have some interested parties. Yeah, that'd be great. The three that we kind of settled on are very different. One is...

1:31:50 Kind of an all-encompassing with Tempest. They're all-encompassing. They have a one-stop shop. They have the back end, the CRM, the CMS, plus they have the front end, obviously, the build. Miles has a relationship with us. They built our old site, but they really just knocked it out of the park this year. And then Mogul, they're working with Visit California right now. They did their studio, and it's just their front end creative is amazing. So what we're looking to figure out is what we can do on the back end. So three different, I mean, we're super excited for the final three. Could you also send out the...

1:32:19 Yeah, totally, absolutely. I'll do the same thing with you. When I drop it on Friday, I'll make sure I get it over to you for the agency as well. So that's the next update, is that one will come out on Friday, probably Thursday evening is when I'm going to send it out. And that is, we're hoping to get the final, be able to call that list down to about three, get them in probably by the end of February.

1:32:43 So we'll have everything kind of set. If we do switch, we'll be able to switch and have that decision be made by March, and we'll have three months to do that. So we have given ourselves plenty of time to start that contract up. And I just wanted to share really briefly, I wanted to go back. I was very excited about the New York boards, right? So we went out, we had some desk sides. Laura and team set us up with some desk side conversations with some media out there as well. This is in Penn Station. This is just a couple things to do.

1:33:13 Dakota, this is his first time ever in New York City, so we got out there, he was literally just, he had goosebumps the entire time we were there. This is him, so he's taking shots, and this is, with the boards, the triptychs and the single boards, this is in Penn Station, they are all synced up, so they would start in the middle, if you're on either side of the train that you're on, and you could look across, when the train's pulled up, they were running there as well.

1:33:37 Cinematography moment. There he goes, right through the train. There they are. Pretty cool stuff. This is the guy being very excited that this is his first time in New York. This is his, and then he's like, you have to show up and have your picture, your photo that you took on freaking Times Square. So well done, sir. It was really amazing. Wow. Just incredible. I mean, people were stopped. Incredible experience. And what was also, and I've had the audio on this, this will be cut in the middle of showing one.

1:34:04 And then all of a sudden it stopped and it rebooted again. And I'm like, they're playing it twice, they're playing it back-to-back. And this happened the whole time we were there. So it's just, it did an amazing job, but it's right in Times Square. I'll show you one more. This is what's cool is, you have the M&M store on one side, you've got the Book of Mormon kind of advertising happening there, and there we are, kind of way up on top.

1:34:26 Also, his first time having pizza in New York, so I had to take some of those pictures. Very excited for everybody. And then from a trademark perspective, the reason we were out there also, we wanted to make sure we were getting trademarks so we can get all this registered, right? Real Unreal, Keep Mammoth Unreal. And then we have some new keychains that came in as well. So just wanted to show you that's where we are on that and we'll be kind of walking down those trademarks there too. So that is my update. Any questions? Fantastic. Brian.

1:34:56 Thanks, Brian. Well done. That's really exciting. I was looking for our ads when the ball was dropping, but that was a little bit more difficult. They were done by then. They were done by then, right? There was an upcharge. So it's nice to get, like, you know, the stuff from you. All right, local marketing, Emily, Brian, take it away. Happy New Year. Happy New Year. Okay, so...

1:35:21 I will start on the local marketing side. We have been running some newspaper ads, and I do apologize for not including this in my last update, but we started running an ad in both newspapers. In case you don't get them, I have some copies here. So we started running this ad just before Thanksgiving in the newspaper to let everybody know about general service and really the locals discount. So this is specifically to let people know about that.

1:35:49 And then starting through the Christmas time period and it currently running, you know, this is going to have a little shorter run because we're kind of waiting to see from advance how many more are going to get sold, but this is a specific ad about the 10-pack too. So these are running in both of our newspapers right now. We're also running still all of our radio ads that talk about both locals discount as well as a 10-pack. We run a 10-pack ad now on all of the stations as well.

1:36:18 And when I say all, I do mean all. KIBS, Sierra Wave, Eastern Sierra Now, KMMT, and KHRB. So we really, you know, we're hitting a whole gamut of the Eastern Sierra. Also on the radio ad front, I just wanted to say that we did go out with, Pat will talk about our social media push, but we did go out with a Winter Tips radio ad that talked about utilizing the transit system and utilizing chains.

1:36:44 And, you know, specifically scraping snow off the top of your roof. My list was a little bit shorter because I have a 30-second window with radio. So Pat definitely hit that up with social media. He'll talk to that with a longer list. But we did get that out. And that's continuing to add or continuing to run. And I will re-tape that ad because it does have some holiday messaging in there right now as well. So that'll continue to run.

1:37:11 On the Yifty front, we did add two more businesses. ASO has joined Yifty as well as... Dish Bistro. Dish Bistro. Sorry. My brain back there. Dish Bistro and ASO have joined us.

1:37:40 Unfortunately, in the last couple months, we have lost two businesses. Blue was a part of the YIFTI program, so we've lost Blue. And then, actually, McCoy Sports at Canyon Lodge had done it as a trial at the end of last season. I think you guys have heard Eric and I have some back and forth about the YIFTI issue. The Mammoth system, it doesn't work quite well with the YIFTI program, so they have come off of the program.

1:38:09 Sort of zero basically there. We're still at the same, but we did add a couple more businesses there. And in the next month, we're going to be coming out with our next sort of program, which is, it's an experiences sort of trail program. So it's a company called Bandwango. And just as an example, in one, I think it's in Stockton, you know, this is just one example. They work in a number of different communities, but they've got like the Sweet Treats Trail. So every business that's got a dessert is on there.

1:38:36 And there's a little incentive to drive the customer into that business. They get a free sampling or they get a discount off. And then there's additional sort of, you know, for entering those businesses, you get a certain amount of points. And then there's swag that you get for accumulating points. And again, those points are accumulated by visiting local businesses. So all with the effort of driving people into really our retail and restaurant spaces.

1:39:04 Local marketing, that's that. But of course, we're always working on things like our visitor guide production is still in place right now. Locals discount codes are off the charts and sort of all those pieces. Web stats. For December 2022, sessions are up 20% for both month over month and year over year. Users are up 23% month over month and about 31% year over year.

1:39:33 And page views are also up about 20% month over month and year over year. As we know, there's still a lot of interest in Advanced Airlines and United. Our click-throughs to their websites are up about 75% to 80% both month over month and year over year right now. Also, we did about 37,000 pass-throughs to local businesses in the month of December. In terms of...

1:40:01 International web traffic. I just want to go over, we talked a little bit about locations last time, so I'll just do a little bit of overview on that for international, our top three countries, India, Canada, and Mexico, with general international web traffic up slightly over last year. So really nice there. And then of course...

1:40:25 I don't want to forget the UK. They are always rounding up before our top five. So they're number four on there right now. States, top five, California, Colorado, New York, Washington, and Nevada. And then from metropolitan areas, Los Angeles, Denver, New York, San Francisco, Sacramento. So and everything generally is trending upwards. We've got some small shifts from California that are down a little bit.

1:40:54 Looking good in those general sort of geographic regions. Intercepts in Bishop. So we have started doing our surveys down at the Bishop Airport. We have two wonderful young men down there this winter who are doing a great job. They started doing surveys on the very first flights of 2022. I was down with them on the first flight day. So it was a wonderful day to see those first flights come in. So far this year,

1:41:24 They have done 60% of what we collected last year, and they've only been surveying for about a month. So we're definitely going to get a really good survey set this year. When did they start? December 15th. December 15th, okay.

1:41:38 I was confused when you said the very first flight in 2023. Oh, sorry. It is 2023 now. No idea what day it is. So anyway, yeah, so we're really, you know, we're seeing a lot of responses come through there and more information on that data at next month's meeting for sure. And then on the local discount code, I just wanted to relay that I have actually sent out about 25 more.

1:42:06 United Codes than the same time as last year. Emily, remind me on Monday for our lodging meeting, we should go over with the lodging community about offering discounts for the rest of the winter. Just make sure they're refreshed that they're not, they're right and not to take your foot off the gas for midweek and stuff. I will say that this December we did see some downtrend on the deals page.

1:42:36 Is that just for the month of December, like in December? Month of December compared to year over year, you know, so I think, you know. We're all blacked out on December 15th on, so. I think it just kind of actually speaks to people looking for deals more. So last December we were definitely seeing more traffic to that deal page, so people might have been looking for more deals. I don't know, it's kind of interesting. Plus it's when we got our snow. Yeah.

1:43:04 So yeah, we can definitely revisit the deals. You know, kudos to the lodging community is actually probably the most, the community I have the most contact with, and a lot of them have actually contacted me through the holiday period to extend deal offers. So yeah, I have gotten some feedback actually through the holiday period on that, but we can definitely talk about that on Monday as well. That is it.

1:43:31 Any questions? Okay, one last note I should add, on the visitor guide production, we are definitely going to be securing the map inside of the guide this year, so just for those who were a little irritated by that. Handing out the local guide constantly, especially for transit information, so thank you, thank you. That's been a great piece for the entire staff this holiday period. Wonderful. Sure. As a reminder, those local discounts, the board's getting out there, right?

1:44:03 But not just to our local communities getting out there. So people are like, I want a discount. Give me a discount. I'm flying in from wherever. That's not how these work, right? They're local discounts for flying out of here to somewhere else and return flights on very specific days. So just remember that as people are talking to you, like, I was looking for a discount. Well, they're local discounts, leaving here, coming back. So I just want to make sure that's just out there. Thanks, Brian. All right, social media, Patrick. Happy New Year, sir.

1:44:32 And, yeah, I was going to, Emily stole your thunder a little bit with that, because that educational post you put up, I, you know, I use Instagram the most out of all the social media, and I really like that. All of the educational, you know, clearing off your car, chains, you know, all that stuff. Really, really good information, and just wanted to say, you know, would love to see more of that, but take it away. Let me, you know. Happy New Year. Good to see you guys. As you know, it's been snowing.

1:45:02 We've got about 300 inches of snowfall so far this season, so it's been pretty good, and we have a bomb cyclone is what they're calling it, coming in. So some of the forecasts were saying up to one to three feet of precipitation, which is pretty heavy. With that, a lot of those education posts, like you said, we're trying to put out. I put another one out today with another image. A lot of the same information, but just kind of like feeding it back to people and making sure they see it, having it.

1:45:29 Some of my friends reshare it, have people just kind of put it everywhere. It's just getting that word out because we've received a lot of information, or sorry, messages on social media of some of the locals being a little more disgruntled. And they're just venting to us about, oh, why are there so many people? And just things like that. Why can't they clear their cars? Why can't they use turn lanes the right way? Why are they trying to beat me down the road? Things like that. So education's huge. And we're just trying to push that and try and...

1:45:57 Get people educated on how to be up here, be up here safely, you know, and kind of keep the flow of the city going so we're not, you know, experiencing mass traffic jams and things like that. Better news, we hit, excuse me, 98,000 followers on Instagram and 84,000 followers on Facebook. So we're growing. In 2022, we did 60.3 million impressions. We had 1.7 million engagements on Facebook and Instagram.

1:46:27 Lately for the social front, we've been really focusing on capturing storms, pushing snow content, showing people how much snow is up here, and just covering kind of each cycle that comes through. Next week, we'll be pushing out some of the Glenn Plague content with Advanced Air, which is pretty exciting, so I'm stoked to get those photos out and get it out in the world. And then, yeah, going back to that post of education, it was really well received.

1:46:57 Lots of shares, lots of reposts on Facebook as well. A couple thousand on Facebook, a couple hundred on Instagram, and we're going to kind of just really focus on that education going forward. So it's been fun and I'm excited for snow and if you haven't gone skiing, go about skiing. It's fun. Yeah, you know, like the education is so huge because, you know, I have a very good friend who lives down in Los Angeles and she saw all the snow, wanted to come up.

1:47:25 I know she has a one-wheel drive, like little Camry. And I'm like, you are not, you cannot get up here with that thing. And, you know, she made different plans, but she was about to come, you know, and so I think a lot of people, they just don't realize what we're dealing with up here, and they come up unprepared, and the more...

1:47:47 You know, information we can get to them ahead of time so that they are prepared for the situation they're coming into, you know, it's helpful. So, you know, like, this time period from the 26th to January 1st, when I got here in 2009, there were just as many people out there. You know, like, the difference is that we actually have a really good week before the holidays and we have a really good week after the holidays, which makes it

1:48:17 Much more profitable and sustainable for all of us throughout the entire year. You know, so, you know, I like what's happening. And also, I feel like the on, I was hoping Eric would be here so we could, but those blackout dates really make the on-hill experience from that 26th to 31st a lot better. I wanted to talk to Eric a little bit about it because I...

1:48:42 I know on the 1st, that's when we saw like the first really big traffic jams, that's when the blackout ended, you know, so maybe something to consider there for next year, but I like what we're doing, how we're spreading people out, you know, from now December 15th through January 15th, and they're not all here, you know, December 26th through, you know, December 31st, and then it's crickets on either side of that, you know, so.

1:49:09 Yeah, I was also going to say, if you guys have any recommendations for other advice or tips for people coming into town, my line's always open and we're always looking for newer information and like refreshed information to give people maybe in a different way. And then we're also planning, Dakota and I are planning to go do another chain video, so a new one with MLPD and the fire department and have them show us how to do it and we're going to hopefully get that going pretty soon.

1:49:36 And put that out as well, because, I mean, most of the questions we also get are like, how do I put on my chains? And we just only have a couple resources to send people, so. Any information, people do not understand what loaders are doing. Like, in my parking lot, I just like.

1:49:54 Mind-blowing decisions people are making around loaders, and it's just like, God, you need to get out of the way. You need to, you know, like, get in my shop. Why are you loitering in the parking lot? He is working. Get out of his way. You know, so any information about loaders, very, very helpful because people just, they don't realize. They don't realize.

1:50:15 I don't know why they don't realize it's a massive piece of machinery that's about to crush you, but, like, get out of the way. So any information on that, like, it's different. People are not used to seeing those machines. Awesome. Great. And I haven't seen you since the flight, but for those of you that don't know, I think you know, but Pat went with Glen Plague, took the advanced air flight, took the free shuttle over to LAX, topped the flight, I think, to Chicago, Detroit? Detroit. Detroit, yeah.

1:50:45 How was the experience? It was phenomenal. It was really great. The flight was super smooth. We landed in Hawthorne, got all our stuff together. We landed a little bit. We left ourselves in time between his flight and when we landed in L.A., but the shuttle was great. We had Priscilla from Advanced Air drive us over. They got us. I think we had a little bit of a special treatment, but they got us some goodie bags and things like that. But it was a quick little jet over there. It was like five minutes.

1:51:14 Really no traffic the way that she took us. And we got great photos. So it was awesome. And we really showed the ease of travel from Mammoth to LAX and wherever else you need to go from there. So overall, it was a really great experience. And it was a really fun day just getting to hang out with Glenn and hear his stories and pick his brain and trying to keep up with him on the hill was...

1:51:36 A challenge, but it was really fun. It was a great experience, so I thoroughly enjoyed it, and I'm really excited to share some of the photos that we got and craft that and get it all perfect for you guys to see. Awesome. Thank you, Patrick. Thanks, guys. Glenn is capable on skis. Chamber update, since we don't have Eric for the Mammoth Resorts update.

1:52:03 There is a fantastic Chris Benchetler exhibit downstairs in the Mono Arts Council. They're having a special exhibit kind of presentation there Friday night from 530 to 8. Mono Arts Council is one of our chamber members wanted to make mention of that. You know, feel free to attend.

1:52:25 Bench, he has every single one of his skis up on the wall. It's absolutely beautiful. It's awesome. Go check it out. Also, one of my managers, Emily McAvoy, has some of her personal art right across it, so she was very excited about that.

1:52:40 So I wanted to make mention of that event happening Friday night. We have a new chamber blog, you know, in an effort to keep our members and community better informed about chamber activities. A chamber blog will feature stories about the chamber events and members. Samantha Lindbergh has been spearheading this effort. So check out the new website and read the chamber blog at mammothlakeschamber.org. We have our power launch.

1:53:07 It will be an update from Mammoth Hospital hosted at Parallax on January 10th. That's next Tuesday. We'll be meeting at Chair 3 at 1030 for some skiing and boarding before lunch. And join us for either or both, whatever your schedule allows. If weather doesn't permit this to happen at McCoy, we will likely relocate to somewhere else on the mountain. So go ahead and register and you'll be sent updates as far as what's happening if we have weather that day.

1:53:35 Which it looks like, because the 10-day forecast, it just never lets up here. It's pretty impressive. It's reminding me of January 2017, where we had like, you know, 28 days of snow with 31 days.

1:53:49 Our first business after hours of 2023 will be hosted by Sierra Nevada Resort on Tuesday, January 17th. Drop by to meet fellow business people and learn the latest chamber and community news. And Sierra Nevada Resort, they just went through a whole new renovation. They have Bar Sierra open, so it'll be great to see kind of everything that's happening over at that property.

1:54:13 Our first ribbon cutting of the year will be at the new space of Deserted, which is also righteous downstairs here from Sweet Z. That's Thursday, January 19th at 4 p.m.

1:54:25 Delve into DEI, diversity, equity, and inclusion. Our next DEI is taking place January 23rd at 5 p.m. at Stellar Brew. The discussion will be focused on how to have difficult conversations surrounding diversity, equity, and inclusion. It's a great new program at the Chamber, so come check it out.

1:54:45 We are always looking for members to host our events, so Power Lunch, Business After Hours, Delve Into DEI, Women in Business, all of these, you know, we're looking to partner with members, you know, so contact us if you're interested in hosting one of those events. And last but not least, the team at the Chamber is working on some new Chamber benefits, so we will be excited to announce and release those in the next month. All right.

1:55:15 And then town council update from Mr. Souser. Take it away. Good day and happy new year if I have it. You know, personally, I want to make one of the guys always hear me complain about someone. The town is great. We're proceeding. It's a great place to play. All of those things. I don't mean to always be negative, but the people who need my attention are the ones that are screwing up. The ones that are doing it right. Well said. Well said, Bill. All right, guys. You can have them.

1:55:47 So the town in its storm is something that we started last year. I didn't start. I've been doing a snow patrol during these storms. I think it's helped a lot. We send out a four-wheel drive that's chained up on all four wheels to help people put on chains, to pull them out of snow banks, to give them the information, to do the necessary things. That's a new program. I think that's a great program. Snow cards I already talked about. We have received a $1.4 million grant from SNC.

1:56:18 For work on the Sherwin Trailhead and for planning purposes for some of the trails out of there, which should, you know, help with summer and some winter. We are grooming some cross-country trails out of that trailhead, and it's become a dog-walking place and everything else. It's great out there. It's all very positive. Most of you, I am certain, know that our snow removal is going on because of John's management group out there at Snow Creek 8.

1:56:48 That's where all the town snow is currently going. We still don't have a contract with the Forest Service. From my perspective only, don't look rosy there. I don't know how you can do it as a county and then as a town and all of a sudden it's illegal to do. I don't understand these things. That's above my pay grade. A couple of things. Staff has started doing these CIP updates.

1:57:14 And there are things in here you may find interesting. Work is continuing on the CRC and on the mobility hub. By the summer, that mobility hub and charging station should be open, and we're seeing more and more electric cars stuck along with our regular cars. Oh, the parcel. All three-fourths of the fabricated buildings are in, and they're getting them put together. I don't get to speak much on that because I'm conflicted out because I live too damn close.

1:57:46 But if you haven't driven down Center Street and looked back in at the progress that has been made, it is huge. To me, what's really exciting, this isn't by any means the first prefab building in Mammoth. The apartments on Davison, the first ones on the right, were actually a prefab piece. But what's interesting in these is each module is in an apartment. The apartments go between and up and down, and they're just laid out. It is just fascinating. 60 Joaquinas moving forward.

1:58:17 On the housing front, people don't understand if this was us, if this was John as a businessman making Joaquin, we would have been able to occupy it last fall. But it's not. We have to operate under a different set of rules. So we are moving forward on housing, and for government, we're moving forward at lightning pace. Yes, you are. Our staff is doing a great job. 100%. And we're moving this ball forward. And I'm proud to say, because it was a long fight, that we are not.

1:58:45 Just doing 80% and under, because that's where the funding is. As you heard, our housing now, we're putting big money into a lot of different things to create, you know, that nexus that we need to get done. Oh, we got... Bill, is that update posted? Are those project updates posted? I don't know if this is posted online or not. It probably wouldn't be a bad thing to post. Yeah. I don't know if it's, there's nothing. It is part of our packet. Oh, okay. So with that, you can look it up there.

1:59:13 You know, Stu Brown has an update that comes out every week, and a lot of that information is in there. He has a fantastic update every week. I always look at it. But there's a lot going on in here. I mean, things you're not interested in. We're redoing the fuel island. But a lot of this is big. We are looking at making preliminary plans for potential civic centers. The child care thing that we're doing in partnership foundation is moving forward, and that's all looking great.

1:59:43 to get done another much-needed thing. And really, it's an interesting piece. That's about it for me. It's exciting. Tonight's meeting will appoint the people who will be sitting on all of these boards for the next year from the council, so something to pay attention to. Bill, I just wanted to say thanks to you and everybody in the town for opening this up as the emergency shelter when...

2:00:11 The warming shelter when the power went out. That was great because I'm sure there were a lot of people that were pretty freaked out about what they were going to do. Obviously, there was nowhere for them to go. There's no lodging open anywhere. So it was great to have a quick place for people to go to get warm if they needed to. It's one of those fascinating things for me because I've lived here forever. So the concept of not having power for two or three days is not new. But how many locals panic after 10 minutes of no power? We live in the mountains.

2:00:40 You need to be prepared. As business owners, we need to be prepared not only for ourselves, but for our customers to be able to lead them to the right place and do the right things, and oftentimes I think perhaps we aren't. Well, back in the old days when everybody had a wood burner, it was okay, and now there's probably, I'm sure less than 50% of the town has actually burned wood, which that's your source of heat. Otherwise, you don't have electricity, there's no propane, there's no anything.

2:01:09 No, there's no longer a wood burner at my house. It's a pellet stove. But I have a generator. They're nice. Yes, they are. Wonderful. Bill, thanks for that update. Do we have a closed session? No, we are not going to do a closed session today. We do not have anything new to report. All right. So we're good there? Yep. All right. Fantastic. Then do I announcement of action taken? Oh, okay. We can cross that off, too. No action. All right. Then do I have a motion to adjourn? Yes, motion.

2:01:41 So moved. All right. We did it. Ernie was here sticking me saying the whole board comments like, we got a game moment. And hey, we're only four minutes late. I'll take it. I'll take it. All right. Thanks so much, everybody. Appreciate it. We'll see you next month. I said we're going to run it five minutes late. Oh, there it is.