Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 14:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
360 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:03 Hey, Sandra, are we still expecting the full commission today in attendance? So I did hear from Commissioner Eckert. He is, I think, boarding a plane around now, so I don't think he's going to be on. But other than that, everyone else should be here. Thank you, Sandra. Well, good afternoon, Commissioner Burroughs, soon to be Dr. Burroughs. We don't want that out there yet. Hello, Commissioner Kennedy. Good to see you.
2:18 Hello, you all as well. So, Sandra, I've got two o'clock on the nose, and I believe we do have a quorum at the moment. Yes, we do. We can start the meeting. I would like to start. So, I would like to call the order the September 8th PEDC meeting. Jamie, maybe please have a roll call. Commissioner Chang is absent. Commissioner Eckert is absent. Commissioner Kennedy? Present. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present.
3:06 Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you, Jamie. And let's just keep an eye on the Zoom and see if Commissioner Chang does attend. So if I can get everyone to stand for allegiance and Commissioner Kennedy, do you mind leading us? Sure, Michael. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
3:35 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. I appreciate it. And please note, Commissioner Chang has joined us. Good to see you, Paul. Jamie, I'd like to open it up to public comment, and I would ask that if anyone does want to submit public comment, if it's related to a topic on our agenda today, please wait until that agenda item has been open for discussion.
4:04 But if there is any other public comment that is not related to any items on today's agenda, I welcome you to give it to the commission now. We do not have any public comments. Do we have any written submitting a public comment, Jamie? No, we do not. Thank you. Then I will close public comment at this time. And we will go to the presentations. And I think Sandra has a request.
4:32 Yes, thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. Staff would like to request that we take item 5.1 out of order and take that item before 4.1. We do have a member of the public who would like to speak on that item. So we were requesting that we would take that ahead of the other business matters. Works for me, Commissioner Burroughs, Kennedy, works for both of you ladies. I see affirmatives. So let's go ahead and move the agenda around a little bit. And we will...
5:03 Start off with our public hearing, agenda item 5.1. It's a public hearing in consideration of a tentative tract map, use permit, design review, and adjustment for Obsidian 2 subdivision, a proposed four-unit multifamily residential development located at the north end of Obsidian Place. And I believe our staff contact is Kim. I am. Thank you. Good afternoon.
5:32 I'm going to share my screen really quick. Alrighty. Okay, so this item is a public hearing for consideration of the Obsidian 2 subdivision entitlement application. The project site is a 0.435 acre remainder parcel of the Obsidian subdivision, which is located at the north end of Obsidian Place. The site is located within the Lodestar Master Plan Development Area 2.
6:18 and was originally part of the TALIS project approval. So it is part of that original project site area. The project area does have a complicated history because it's evolved over time since it was originally approved. So I'll provide a quick summary. The staff reports did provide a more comprehensive summary of the project approvals.
6:46 PEDC actions on the project site. So in 2004, the original TALUS project was approved. The project included the subdivision of a 4.3 acre portion of a seven acre site for a planned unit development consisting of 19 single family residential structures that were to be held within a private residence club as a fractional share form of ownership.
7:14 The approved project also included construction of a 5,810 square foot clubhouse and a manager's housing unit, as well as creation of a 3.08 acre enhanced wetland open space area and an affordable housing site of 5,000 square feet. Phase one of the Taos project included nine fractional homes, the clubhouse and completion of wetland mitigation requirements.
7:43 to the satisfaction of the Army Corps of Engineers, Department of Fish and Wildlife, and the Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board. Phase one of the project was completed in 2016. Phase two of the project consisted of the remaining 10 fractional ownership single-family residential lots and homes, which were not built as the original approved phase two. In 2016,
8:10 The Planning and Economic Development Commission approved the TALUS Amendment Project, which approved the name change from TALUS to Obsidian and included a new tentative tract map, use permit, design and design review to subdivide the remaining 10 lots into 20 whole ownership lots within 10 duplex structures.
8:35 The new tract map also created a 0.87 acre remainder parcel at the northern end of the project site. In 2019, an adjustment application was approved to allow a one foot increase in the maximum permitted structure height for the duplex building design for phase two, which includes lots 10 through 29 of the Obsidian PUD. And this project is currently under construction and is called the Villas at Obsidian.
9:07 The .87 acre remainder parcel that was designated in 2016 was encumbered with an easement to construct and maintain a parking lot and emergency access road for the parcel to the north, address 100 Callahan Way. The owners of Obsidian and 100 Callahan Way subsequently abandoned the parking lot easement and applied for a lot line adjustment.
9:32 which resulted in half of the 0.87 acre remainder parcel being merged with 100 Callahan Way, and the remaining half was retained by the owners of Obsidian. So the current project proposal is the Obsidian II subdivision, which is an extension of the Villas Obsidian project, and includes two additional duplex structures with a total of four whole ownership townhome units.
10:00 And these units would be incorporated into the larger obsidian subdivision through this tentative tract map process. So the obsidian two subdivision, like I said, is a multifamily planned unit development consisting of four lots within two duplex structures. The property is located within the Lodestar Mammoth Master Plan area and is a 0.435 acre remainder parcel.
10:28 The proposed tentative tract map subdivides the parcel into the four lots and eliminates the southerly property line to incorporate the remainder parcel with the villas at Obsidian development. The duplex structures proposed match the structures that have been built in the villas at Obsidian project. So the project layout is identical for lot size.
10:59 to the Billows at Obsidian and continues the development along the west side of the property. Each unit provides approximately 2,741 square feet of living space and features three bedrooms, three and a half bathrooms and an enclosed two-car garage that is in a tandem configuration. One 10 foot by 20 foot guest parking space is provided within the driveway for each unit and the proposed building height is 36 feet.
11:27 which is one foot taller than the maximum building height allowed, which is why an adjustment is requested for this application in order for the applicants to continue to use the building design that was used for the villas at Obsidian. So the project requires approval of a tentative tract map since the project is a common interest development. It's a PUD and each unit can be sold individually. The remainder parcel will be merged with the
11:59 Obsidian Subdivision through the tentative tract map process and relocation of the emergency access gate that was approved as part of phase two would be relocated closer to the Obsidian Place Drive connection with Dorrance Drive. So the project would remain a gated community, but there will be an electronic emergency access gate. Findings?
12:29 So the project would share an HOA with the obsidian subdivision as well, and this would ensure consistent shared maintenance of the common areas and facilities. Findings have been prepared and affirm that the tentative tract map is in conformance with the town subdivision ordinance and the state subdivision map act. A use permit is required because the load star at Mammoth master plan requires transient occupancies within development area two to obtain use permit approval. The project
13:02 Since the project will be incorporated into the Villas at Obsidian Project, which was granted use permit approval for transient occupancy uses, staff has been able to make affirmative findings for approval of the use permit because the development provides adequate facilities, including parking and guest services oriented to transient rental use of the units.
13:28 The Obsidian Development is a gated development, provides resident services, including shuttle service and use of the clubhouse facility. All new development within the Lodestar Master Plan requires design review, except for single-family residences. The proposed buildings continue the existing Obsidian Development layout along the west side of the property, and the building design is identical to the builds at Obsidian.
13:58 design with the exception for one duplex building at the northernmost portion of the site. There is an existing 20-foot wide water district sewer easement that runs along the north property line and the current design with the battered wing wall along the front facade of the building would encroach into that easement and the water district has told us that no part of the structure
14:26 will be allowed to do that. So the applicants have modified the facade design for one of the duplex structures to make it a more vertical stone design. And otherwise, the designs are the same. They meet the design guidelines for the town and the development standards for the Lodestar Master Plan.
14:54 So an adjustment is requested. Adjustments are intended to allow minor exceptions to certain development standards of the zoning code when such requests constitute a reasonable use of the property but are not permissible under strict application of the zoning code. So the zoning section that allows for adjustment requests would allow a maximum 10% increase in the allowable building height.
15:22 The requested height increase is approximately 3%. It's a one foot height increase. And findings have been made in support of the adjustment request to allow for a minimum 3 and 12 roof pitch. The reasoning is that the steeper roof pitch will reduce snow loading on the roof and would alleviate the need for use of Cricut design features on the roof, which can cause ice downing.
15:52 So staff was able to make findings that the requested additional height would increase the safety of the occupants of the structure. So Lodestar Master Plan consistency, the project did meet all of the development standards applicable to Development Area 2, which included limitations on project density, and the project meets the setback requirements. The building height will be met with approval of an adjustment.
16:23 The parking provided meets, is above the minimum standard because the guest parking provided is one space per unit rather than a total of two spaces that would typically be required. The property has, the applicant has provided a preliminary landscape plan and the plans show that snow storage and site coverage are within the limits for that development area.
16:57 So the general plan land use designation for the site is resort and that designation allows commercial mixed uses including visitor lodging amenities and services and workforce housing. Resort developments include recreation, meeting spaces and commercial services that support the resort atmosphere. This designation is generally applied to large parcels capable of providing a complete resort experience.
17:23 as found in the master plan areas of Sierra Star, Snow Creek, and Juniper Ridge. This particular project site is identified in the general plan as being within the Sierra Star District, and that is described as a resort area that contains an 18-hole golf course and a residential component. So the project as proposed is consistent with the general plan vision for the resort zones. So our CEQA analysis
17:55 The scope of the project on its own would normally qualify for a categorical exemption from CEQA, but because the applicant is proposing to incorporate this parcel into the larger Obsidian Development, and because the Obsidian Development was originally analyzed for TALIS, there was a mitigated negative declaration prepared for that project, so staff felt that it was most appropriate for us to evaluate the current project.
18:25 and prepare an addendum to that TALUS MND. So staff has incorporated the mitigation monitoring and reporting program as conditions of approval for this project. So that incorporates the original TALUS MMRP into the conditions of approval for this proposal. And adoption of the CEQA addendum is included in the PEDC resolution as part of this project approval.
18:57 This public hearing was noticed in the sheet on August 28th and September 4th, and 72 notices were mailed to property owners within 300 feet of the site. I have not received any public comments, any written comments at this time, and based on the analysis that is included in your staff report, which includes the CEQA addendum.
19:28 We've determined that the required findings to support the requested approvals can be made and recommend the PEDC adopt Planning and Economic Development Commission Resolution 2021-08, making the required CEQA State Subdivision Map Act and Municipal Code findings to adopt the addendum to the TALUS mitigated negative declaration and approved tentative tract map 21-002.
19:54 Use permit, 21-003, design review, 21-002, and adjustment, 21-002, with conditions as recommended. That concludes my presentation. I'm happy to answer questions for staff. And I did see that Mark Rafay, the project applicant, is on this call, and Korva Garg is also on the call to answer questions for the applicant. Perfect. Thank you, Kim. Appreciate that.
20:22 Before I open it up to questions from the commission, I would just offer the opportunity for the two gentlemen that are representing the applicant, if they would like to make a statement or are they good at this time? Thanks for the consideration. I mean, we don't really have much to say about it. It's pretty straightforward, but we're happy to field any questions or concerns. Thank you, Mark. Appreciate it. All right, then I'll open it back up to the commission. At this time, does anyone on the PEDC have questions for staff?
20:57 Kim or Sandra or for either the gentleman representing the applicant, the application? I have a question, Michael. Please, Commissioner Burroughs. The back gate that is not open to the public, will that be open to the renters, the nightly renters who occupy those units? So I can answer for staff. The intent is that that gate will not be opened.
21:32 will not be used by residents of the project as just a regular access point. It would need to be an emergency access gate only and accessed by the fire district or ambulance services. Okay, thank you. Any other questions from my fellow commissioners? Commissioner Chang, please. Thanks, Chair. Is this part of TELUS or...
22:05 Obsidian or are they the same entity? So the original project approval was the TALUS project and the name of the project was officially changed in 2016 when the TALUS amendment project was brought before the PEDC. So it's essentially the same project but the name was changed. In 2016 or?
22:35 This phase one was constructed, was completed, and that was with the initial approval with a 19 unit, am I correct? And now, I think what, in 2013, there was change with the remaining 10 that was now constructed that turned from a 10 to a 20 unit. So you went from 19 to 20, to 29 units?
23:13 Correct. Yes. And then now we're asking for four more units. Correct. Right? So now the project, at its entirety, once you complete the entire project, now you have, what is it, 19, 23 units altogether. In total, the project... I mean, I'm sorry, 29, 30, 33 units. 35. There will be 35 total units, including a guest unit.
23:44 In the clubhouse building and a manager's unit in the gatehouse. So in total, there would be 35 dwelling units on site. If I'm not mistaken, since I've been in PDC, this is the third time this project has came to us. And then we went from 19 units now to 30 plus units. Okay. Is this going to be the last submission changes?
24:17 Or are there going to be additional changes in the future asking for more units on this particular site, more intensity, more height increases? Because didn't you just, I think I read somewhere here, in 2019, staff actually approved administratively to increase another, increase the height already. Am I correct?
24:50 The phase two amendment was approved in 2016, which increased the number of units, the original number of units from 19 to 29. And then when the applicants were going through the building permit application process, I believe that's when they brought in an adjustment request for the height increase. And that was approved administratively. Your questions about the density of the project?
25:20 I think are addressed in the addendum to the CEQA evaluation for the original project because the project site was originally evaluated at the density of 67 dwelling units. So that was the anticipated density for the project site and that was not what was built. It was built under the maximum allowed density and so it is still under the maximum allowed density.
25:49 of the original 67 dwellings. My understanding is that when a lot line adjustment was recorded for the remainder parcel, which basically gave half of the parcel to the property to the north and the obsidian ownership retained half of it, that at that time they assigned the remaining density to that property.
26:19 And so the remaining amount of density for the site was four units. And that's included, that information is included in a table in your staff report. But I'm hoping that that accounts for the density because the table shows 67 dwelling units as the original allowed maximum density. And that was what was evaluated for the environmental documentation for the project.
26:49 And 35 units is still within the realm of that evaluation. Something that was a little confusing to me based on your explanation, you said that half of the density was transferred to another parcel north of it. Correct. So there is an assignment agreement process that appears to be allowed for in the IntraWest Development Agreement because the density for
27:23 Lodestar is like a maximum of 210 dwelling units for the entire development area. And so far, the total development, the developments that have occurred have been a lot lower densities. So gray bear is a low density product. Obsidian, you know, is a pretty low density product when you consider
27:51 The full development area two is allowed 210 dwelling units. So I don't, it is a little bit complicated because the TALUS project was initially allowed 67 dwelling units. And I'm not sure why TALUS was the only property in development area two that was assigned a density or they bought.
28:21 density from the original developer, but the rest of development area too has sort of this pot of density that hasn't been used that they can develop. I don't know, Mark, if you can speak to that any better since you did the assignment agreement with Terry Plum. Yeah, I think, well, one is, so to answer, Paul, your first question in respect to are we going to ask for more density for this particular project?
28:52 The answer is no, which is why when we were negotiating to do the lot line adjustment, we were fine transferring the excess density that we weren't going to use. So we were able to put, I think you said 65 units on here. We knew we were only going to have 35 total max. We really didn't want to try to cram units in every space possible. We wanted to keep it consistent on the one side of the property. And so that's where we ended up.
29:22 And again, that's why we weren't, we were amenable to assigning the additional units because we really had no intention of trying to max density there. Commissioner Chang, do you have any follow-up questions? No, thank you. Okay. Commissioner Kennedy or Commissioner Burroughs, do either of you have some, please, Commissioner Kennedy. I do have one question just to make sure I'm understanding correct about the transient use. So it says that
29:57 The project site has not previously been issued a use permit for transient uses, but that it will be incorporated into the villas at Obsidian, which already has a use permit approval for transient use. So it's basically just aligning it with the rest of the villas at Obsidian. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay, that's my only question then. Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs, do you have any questions? I'm sorry, I forgot you had the gate question earlier. Yes, I'm done. Thank you.
30:25 So, Kim, before I open it up to public comment, I just have a couple of quick questions of you in your report. So, the height adjustment that's being asked for, that 36 feet, the one foot extra from the 25 or the 35 feet would align these two buildings with the same height of the rest of the villas at Obsidian. Is that correct? That's correct. So, it would be a uniform roof level all the way across this development.
30:54 Yes. And I know you covered it in your report, but they are meeting or exceeding the parking requirements that the town has laid out. They are exceeding the required parking, yes. And they're exceeding at a small amount the required snow storage capability, correct? Yes. And if I'm not mistaken, I just heard Mark say that
31:24 Once these two duplexes are built, this will be the last building within this parcel. I believe I heard that. Sorry, I was muted. That's correct. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, the remainder is kind of the end of it. So once we're done with these last four for the obsidian, the villas at obsidian, that lot, we're done there. Okay.
31:52 So I'd love to open it up to public comment. And I believe we do have a member of the public, Camille Miller in Suite Z. So Camille, if you'd like to come up to the podium and introduce yourself, we'd love to hear your thoughts. Thank you. I'm Camille Miller. I'm the adjacent property owner directly of the parcel we're discussing today. Can you hear me okay?
32:23 Yeah, we got you, Camille. Okay, sorry for turning, but I'm looking at your pictures. My, I have questions that I've been talking with Mark, really pleasant, and I appreciate that. I've asked him some questions that he wasn't quite able to answer either, because he was, I'm here, represents some of these questions. I heard today about the gate on Dorans, and that was one of the main questions I was discussing with Mark.
33:05 What I'm trying to understand because there is a bike path that travels and it goes across Dorrance from north to south and the bike path used to be about 30 some feet more away from my house. Now I have the unfortunate position of living in an existing non-conforming dwelling that was built in 1905 back when the parcels were actually laid out differently.
33:35 and property lines were different. Once some things changed over time, I inherited a home that is three feet. Now instead of at the property line, I did put a bunch of letters and spoke in public comments, submitted them to planning commissioners many years back when this was being re-looked at, I believe when Mark was buying the property with his partners. So the bike path has come up to about eight feet.
34:13 from my house at one of the corners. And my house is twisted. So there's one edge of the house, one corner of the house, the northwest corner that's really problematic. But then by the time you get to the other end of my house, it's not really a big deal. The Obsidian owners have been erecting a fence for privacy, for construction noise, and just visual privacy.
34:42 that will run along where the bike path has moved. So there's some intersection questions that I have. In the fence code, a fence has to drop from six feet to three feet, 20 feet back from the property line. Because of the location of my house, it's going to end up dropping right where it's the most important. And I wonder if you would consider a variance
35:15 in some way to 15 feet back or something like that to allow for privacy along the full edge of my home rather than it going from six feet to three feet right where it's directly looked to my daughter's window. I don't know if that's possible. I would appreciate it. Mark's been working in good faith with us to try to provide some sort of privacy, but that's not within the code. I also am wondering how the gate, Dorrance, will be set of the bike path.
35:52 And that's something I want to make sure, you know, believe me I believe in
36:25 And so that's a question that I have. Moreover, the signage at Dorrance, if there is to be a gate, how do we accommodate some sort of public notice so that traffic doesn't enter Dorrance?
36:58 And become stuck. Because what happens right now when people are confused in the construction process, things are chaotic in the construction process. I get it. But people find their way through my yard as a logical turnaround point. And I don't want that to be kind behavior. I want to Dorrance and then don't know how to get out once they hit the gate. Is there something to consider there? Signage? Anyway, so that goes back to a question around that gate.
37:32 I heard Kim mention that the intention is not access point, something that's almost like filed in Google Maps, if you will, that makes it so that gate doesn't like a logical three point be familiar with how do they get redirectical questions that I have. And then also the snow removal on Dorrance. For a period of Dorrance as a public property owner, I just want to make sure that I as a private person not to say publicly much worked with him and I really appreciate it.
39:30 That's definitely not an adversarial situation. So thank you so much for concerns. And I don't know what the process is for addressing them. I'm an open book and I can be reached. Camille, let me jump in here. And first of all, I appreciate your public comment and you taking the time to compile that list. I think I'm going to give staff and the applicant both a chance to answer some of your questions.
40:01 So at this point, Mark, would you like to address any of the questions that Camille brought up? I think Camille and I have talked about, for the most part, a lot of them, there's a couple of things that we're not sure of yet because we're, I believe, waiting for the fire department to opine on in respect to the location of that entry point. So at this point, I don't really have much to be able to provide as far as any visibility and specifics there. But, you know, as soon as we...
40:28 We get that information. Obviously, I'm going to share it with Camille right away. On the snow storage side, I actually am not sure of that as far as, or excuse me, the snow removal on Dorrance, I don't recall actually there being any information on that. And again, I'm not in front of my PC at the moment, so I don't have access to my files, but I can look at it. Maybe, Kim, I'm not sure if you recall.
40:54 what the original conditions of approval were, because this was, this, this stuff, I think, dates back to the original Talus, so back, I think, from the previous ownership, it wasn't, it was before our time, I think, from 04. Thank you, Mark. So there was, there was conditions of approval from at least the 2016 Talus Amendment approval that required street signage on Dorrance to
41:23 Alert drivers that it's not a through street. And the location of the emergency access gate is currently shown on the east side of the bike path. The fire district does have comments on, does have comments and requirements on the location of an emergency gate. So it's shown on the tentative tract map as an approximate location. As long as it's
41:52 On Obsidian's property, and it's not blocking access to one of the units, we would be fine if they located it on the west side of the bike lane. I think that it's something that the Public Works Department would probably need to review as a revision to the project. And of course, the fire district also has to approve it. Sandra, some of the other...
42:23 Questions that Camille had in terms of the fence height, the snow removal on Dorrance on the other side, the east side of this emergency access gate. How do you want to handle that, Sandra? Do you want to try and stab at it now or is now not an appropriate time? So I think, you know, I might ask if Hayes is on the line, if he has any comments about the snow removal. Regarding the fence height increase, I wouldn't be able to add that to this.
42:53 Thank you so much.
43:22 So that one, I would say, let's set that one aside for something for us to take a look at. But, Hayes, I don't know if you have any thoughts or comments about the snow removal on Dorrance. Sure. So the town will be removing snow up into the property line. And then at the property line, it would be the applicant's responsibility to clear to that point and around the gate and keep that clear. The fire department will have some requirements related to that as well.
43:54 Okay, so the town will be removing the snow on Dorrance, basically up to the gate itself, whether it's located on the east side or the west side of the bike path. Up to the property line. We won't enter private property to remove snow, so we'll go, regardless if the gate is on the east or west side of the bike path, we'll clear up to the property line, and then there'll be the applicant's responsibility there on snow removal crews to clear snow on the private property side.
44:20 Kim, do you have any idea how deep the property line goes for this, for Talit, for Obsidian into the Dorrance area? Do you have any? I hate to put you on the spot. How deep the property line goes? In other words, how far will Hayes' crew be removing snow on that little Dorrance spur that runs adjacent to Camille's property? I can share my screen real quick, Kim, and I think I can explain this. Thank you.
44:54 So you should be able to see parcel viewer now? Yeah. Yes. Okay. So where I'm highlighting, this is public right-of-way, the section of Dorrance. The property line is right here. The town will clear the snow from this area. If the gate is on the westerly side, it would be over here. If it's on the easterly side, it would be over here. The private property owner or the HOA would be responsible for clearing snow.
45:22 So we would get up to right this area and then property or take it from there. Got it. And Camille, quick question. When you're looking at that parcel map that Hayes just had up, was the snow, historically, has the snow been removed from that spur, that Dorrance spur that runs adjacent to your property? Awesome. Okay, thank you. All right, I'm going to throw, Paul, I think I saw Commissioner Chang your hand up. Did you have a subsequent question, Paul?
46:05 Thanks, Chair. As relates to snow removal, all I saw on the resolution was that the snow removal storage plan shall be submitted by the applicant approved by PDC, I mean, yeah, Community and Economic Development Department, and that this plan and provisions for maintenance for private driveways and drainage facilities shall be included in the CCNRs.
46:35 prior to final map approval by town staff. So I'm assuming there's, because this is a mature development already, so there's probably a CCNR that's in place that has snow removal responsibilities and guidelines that was previously approved by the town, or is that not correct? Kim, I think that might be a question for you.
47:08 I would think the same thing. I have not reviewed the CC&Rs for the villas or for TALIS. We don't always have a copy of them, and so I'm not sure what process they went through to get town approval and if that was required. To my knowledge, I don't think we ever got, on our new one, I don't know if the original TALIS had a...
47:38 CCNRs that were submitted to the town or what the process is. I mean, we had them approved by the state. As far as snow removal and storage goes is that the common there is in the CCNRs, the association covers the cost, whether it being association staff or third party that they've got somebody that plows, you know, as needed. But in regards to the storage, those areas, I think, are on the civil plan.
48:07 So, I think,
48:36 Paul, I think the language you might be referring to is condition number 68. And that was a condition that was included in the last TALIS amendment approval. And my assumption is that because a lot of these units are transient rental units, similar to Snow Creek, that this was to ensure that the driveways were going to be cleared and the streets would be cleared, even though people were not occupying those units 100% of the time.
49:09 Okay. I mean, I guess maybe, you know, it seems to me that that's something that staff, you know, and the applicant should, you know, have some clarification because given that the language itself says this needs to be approved by the PDC, by Planning Commission Department. So I'm assuming that the staff has some certain guidelines as to, you know, how this is done.
49:38 Before the CCNR gets approved by the state. But anyhow, I mean, that's just something, you know, to think about for you guys. And I would imagine that would then also help alleviate Camille's concerns on snow removal for that particular area that, you know, she talked about. Thank you. Any other comments or discussion? Please, Camille.
50:46 How do they get out? I just don't know how that works in the real world. Hayes, do you want to maybe just address the signage? Because I would imagine when someone is looking on Google for a street address, the proper street address for Obsidian is going to take people to the gated entrance on Meridian. That's correct. Yeah, the frontage is on Meridian. This is just an emergency access egress, so it should not show up on the Googles.
51:18 Like Kim said, there's a condition of approval, and I don't remember exactly how it's worded to put up signage, but I suspect it's something to the effect of not a through street classic MUTCD signage that will be in well view of the intersection. So people traveling down Dorrance or up Joaquin should have advance notice and shouldn't make the turn, and we shouldn't see the conflicts backing up on Dorrance.
51:47 Thank you, Hais. A regular ingress. Does that actually work in the real world? I have not seen a submittal on this gate, so I don't know how it's to be activated. I can tell you other gates in town have measures where emergency services and town staff, police, fire, can access it through claymars and their radios. Past that, you know, the gate fails to open.
52:41 If there's a power outage, there's a bunch of requirements and protocols the fire department will place on it. Whether the owners use a key card, punch card codes, that'll be a part of their proposal and that'll have to be evaluated by the town and the fire department. Thank you, Hayes. The question around the owner around where it just suddenly, rather than just, you've been very helpful and thank you to Mark for being here. Thank you, Camille. Thank you, Camille. With that, I am going to close public comment.
53:38 throw it back on the commission here. Do we have any other opinions or questions or dialogue that we want to partake of in regards to this tentative tract map? I would just like to say that I really appreciate Camille coming forward with those insightful questions and they produced a lot of great conversation that perhaps we wouldn't have thought of. So thank you, Camille. Thank you, Commissioner Burrows. Commissioner Kennedy, did you have something that you wanted to?
54:09 Yeah, I was just curious if staff can clarify what the process would be for the gate to be on the other side. Is that something that we need to discuss or that can be handled kind of internally with you guys? To have the gate on the west side of the bike path? So I can answer for planning. If they were to be able to relocate the gate on the west side and the occupants of the new units would still have access to their driveways.
54:41 That's something that wouldn't be a problem for planning. I'm just really more concerned for the fire district that we're meeting their access requirements and there are some conditions of approval that are included that talk about the way that the gate functions, like condition 39. But I think that if the fire district wants the gate located farther away from the intersection with Dorrance,
55:11 That would be okay. The applicants would need to provide a revised plan showing how that would function, and that would need to be approved by Planning and Public Works and the Fire District. But I think that there is some flexibility there for them to do that. And on the tentative tract map, they're showing it as an approximate location. Does that answer your question, Commissioner Kennedy?
55:37 I think so, yeah, I just, what's coming to mind with it is the walk-bike ride and all the work we're doing on pedestrian access, and I've taken that trail a couple times in the past few weeks and just don't want it to get more confusing. I think we've done a great job, the town as a whole, of keeping people on these consistent paths and connecting kind of the missing pieces, and so I just don't want to miss that. So yeah, thank you, Kim, that helps a lot. Commissioner Chang, are you good?
56:08 If I may just ask one last question about the housing mitigation requirements for this project, if the applicants will meet this requirement through housing fee, or is this going to be through alternate housing mitigation plan stated on the planning conditions, special planning conditions number 30?
56:40 Ken, that question might be for you. I apologize. I was reading an email from somebody who's participating that had public comment. Paul, so could you re-ask your question? Absolutely. The question I have was about housing fee. Oh, yeah. Whether the applicant was paying a housing fee for residential use at the time of the building permit submittal? That's okay.
57:07 That's what the applicant has done for the villas at Obsidian. Maybe we can ask Mark what he intends to do because there is an option for the developers to meet that standard. The ordinance provides developers options to either pay the fee or provide housing. Since they haven't proposed any housing on site, I'm assuming that they are providing the fee.
57:33 Yeah, we don't really have any other room there. And there's not a lot of other lots in Mammoth that we can use to be able to mitigate the, you know, avoid paying the fee and actually producing something that would benefit all of us. So at this point, we're going to be paying the mitigation fee, but I think the housing at this point isn't really a viable option for us. Thank you. That's all I have.
58:01 Michael or Jamie, I received a public comment via email. Have you received that, Jamie? No, I have not. Should I go ahead and read it? Yes. Please go. Okay, great. So I have a comment from Abby. My concern is TOML put in the new Dorrance Road and the plans were to install drains and drainage on roads.
58:29 The melt-off and water ends up in my garage since this has been developed. It was in the plans. What happened? Thanks, Abby. Thank you, Kim. Hayes, do you want to take a crack at drainage? Yeah, I can take a crack at that. The drainage infrastructure that was required was installed for plan and connected to the storm drain system. Without knowing where this residence is, it's hard for me to comment on.
59:01 What the issue may be, but the requirements of the applicant have been installed. Sorry, this is for 171 Dorrance Drive at the corner of Joaquin and Dorrance Drive. Sorry to put you on the spot, Hayes. Yeah, it's not something I'm going to be able to answer off the cuff. If you could have that individual send her my contact information and I'll speak with her directly and figure out what the path forward looks like.
59:37 Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate it. Kim, thanks for reading that into public comment. I'm just going to say I'm in favor of supporting this. I'd love to hear that Mark and Camille have established a positive working relationship. I would like to have staff investigate and look into the fencing height issue that Camille referenced, as well as to make sure when
1:00:05 This gate, the emergency gate is put up that we install signage that make it very clear to vehicular drivers that it is a dead end. It is not public access. I also want to make it abundantly clear to the applicant to mark that if the emergency access gate does move to the west side of the bike path, and I agree with Commissioner Kennedy, I think that's imperative to maintain that.
1:00:33 Ease of access on the traffic of the bike path. But if that gate moves to the west side of the bike path, they will be responsible for a decent amount of snow removal to get up to the property line where it will be on the east side of the bike path. So that gate's going to have to open during each storm and snow removal vehicles or equipment are going to have to remove the snow up to the edge of the property line.
1:01:02 where the town's responsibility meets it. So I just want to make that really, really clear. Hopefully I did. All right. So if there's no further comments or questions, I'll throw it back to my fellow commissioners. Is anybody up for entertaining or offering a motion? I can make a motion to adopt the PDC resolution, if I may. Please. To adopt the PDC resolution making that requires CEQA.
1:01:36 State subdivision map, act findings, municipality code, findings, and an approving tentative tract map, number 21-002, use permit, UPA 21-003, design review, DR 21-002, and adjustment, ADJ 21-002, with condition recommended by staff.
1:02:06 Can we include adopting an addendum to the TALUS mitigated negative declaration? Sure. And also included the addendum of what? The TALUS mitigated negative declaration. TALUS negative mitigation. Addendum to the TALUS MND, I think would be fine. Addendum to the TALUS mitigation. Mitigated negative declaration.
1:02:43 My gosh. I know. Metigated. Jeez. How about just including the addendum? Yeah, thank you. Thank you. All right, do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Any further questions? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst?
1:03:15 Yes. Passes 4-0. And I would just really emphasize to Mark and your partners to continue that positive working relationship with Camille and the rest of your neighbors. We love hearing that stuff because we don't always hear that stuff on this commission. So thank you for taking the extra step. Appreciate it. And thank you all for your consideration. All right. So we will close the public hearing. We'll go back to the presentations.
1:03:44 The first one, 4.1, is an update on digital 395 and broadband access. And I believe Nate is our staff contact, but I don't see him on my Zoom. He's, Nate, if you, I think Jamie sent you a, oh, there we go. Good to see you, Nate. Thanks for taking the time. Sure. No, happy to be here. Sorry, I was just waiting for Zoom to kind of restart itself. Let me.
1:04:19 Share my screen here. You're all seeing this PowerPoint come up? Yeah. Great. Well, thank you for the invitation and opportunity. Again, Nate Greenberg, the Director of IT for Mono County in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And at the request of the Commission, I'm here to just provide a bit of an update on broadband throughout the Town of Mammoth Lakes and just a handful of initiatives and things.
1:04:50 That have been talked about and things that have happened since we last spoke. So just a really kind of high level touch on what we're going to walk through. We'll certainly start out by looking at what has been happening on the topic of Suddenlink and working on some of the issues that have been brought forward. Some of that is also implicated in a recent grand jury report, which some of you may have seen and we'll walk through.
1:05:20 Some of the county and town's response to that as it pertains not just to Suddenlink but to some of the other broadband related issues as well. And I thought it'd be worth just providing a little bit of a legislative update and talk about what's kind of happening out there in sort of the broadband world and what we're doing as agencies into the auspices of that and to try to take advantage of things. And certainly if there's anything else on any of your minds I'm happy to speak to it as well.
1:05:50 So first, just to kind of dive in on the Suddenlink topic, you know, I believe the last time I was here, I just was relating to you all the work that had been done in terms of engaging Suddenlink and the work that we were doing in collaboration with them, as well as some of our neighboring counties and other colleague counties throughout the state.
1:06:17 Just to remind everybody, you know, really, since well before this issue was brought up by PEDC and certainly before the grand jury brought it up, I have been working closely with Suddenlink and officials within the company, government affairs, a variety of folks on the ground to continue to sort of investigate challenges in both service quality and the actual network performance itself as well as
1:06:47 The customer service aspects. And we all know that some of those have yielded some positive outcomes, but it has not been a universal solution. It has generally been an ad hoc kind of resolution to problems that have been brought forward. Over the past nine months or so, Mono County, the town of Mammoth Lakes have been working collaboratively with Nevada and Placer counties, town of Truckee.
1:07:17 Inyo County has joined on, and we have been continuing to involve the Public Utilities Commission in the capacity and authority that they have to regulate broadband, which is unfortunately still quite limited, but then also Suddenlink to try to be, I guess, good partners in trying to uphold or have them uphold
1:07:44 The customer service standards and expectations that we have, as well as work on some of the core network issues that have been brought up. Frankly, most of those conversations have not yielded very positive outcomes. And so just recently, our legal counsels have joined forces to begin to look at a more formal process before the Public Utilities Commission to effectively
1:08:13 You know, encourage the PUC to exert what authority they do have over Sunlink. You know, I'll just say, again, the authority to regulate broadband is essentially non-existent. It is a non-regulated utility. The instruments that are, quote-unquote, downstream of broadband, which do have some regulatory authority, are video and phone.
1:08:43 Anyone who is a Suddenlink customer who is also purchasing video or using their voice over IP phone service, those are elements or instruments which do have regulatory authority and the commission can basically hold Suddenlink accountable for performance issues and network issues. I would say it's probably 30%, this is just kind of a rough guess, 40% at the most.
1:09:13 of the customers and the issues that I've heard raised have been around video and or phone. Most all the issues have been just on kind of core internet. It doesn't mean that there isn't some capacity to, you know, to sort of initiate a formal process there. But again, it's kind of leveraging another instrument to try to get to sort of what we're trying to accomplish, which is ultimately.
1:09:41 improving the quality of broadband service as a whole. So, you know, a number of things have happened over the past nine months or so. You know, there was an agency letter that was jointly drafted and sent. Altice, who is the owner of Suddenlink, responded formally. As I said, we are now pursuing a more formal process within the PUC, and that's just going to be something that's going to be ongoing. And I...
1:10:07 I don't have any crystal ball as to understand what could come out of that, and I think we're just going to remain cautiously optimistic and continue to pursue the avenue that we have there, which is, you know, fairly limited, but it's still something. Outside of that more direct action, something that I believe I've briefed the commission on and has been made public at town council as well as at the county board meetings is
1:10:35 the implementation of an escalation portal and a formal, I guess, formal process for asking Suddenlink to prioritize customer issues that have been opened or attempted to be opened through their standard service model but have not gotten any traction. We put a portal up about
1:11:01 About six months ago now, the link is here on the bottom of the slide. There's links on the town's website as well as the county website that'll take you here. And effectively, this is a web form. It allows somebody to come in, provide their contact and customer information, the nature of the complaint and issue that they're having. And that's basically forwarded on to senior folks within Suddenlink who have the responsibility of expediting and escalating that.
1:11:29 actual service issue within the company. And we are seeing those issues get resolved on average in probably 50% of the time of what it was taking through the more standard channels. But we are asking people to try to please first use the standard channel before just going direct to the escalation process. So moving on into the grand jury report, there was a
1:12:01 report issued on the 28th of June from the Mono County Grand Jury titled Fiber Internet Connection as Essential Infrastructure in Mono County. A lot of the findings and recommendations that were made in that report were similar for the county and the town, although there were some slightly different or specific ones each for the town versus the county.
1:12:28 The County Board of Supervisors yesterday approved the formal response letter to the grand jury that can be found in the packet for that meeting. And I believe it's going to town council next week. And the response from town council and town staff will be going to the grand jury following that meeting. The key topics that were really included in that grand jury report
1:12:54 touched on Suddenlink and some of the challenges that we've already described here, as well as some of the constraints that exist through the regulatory authorities that are in place at the PUC, you know, and really, you know, we, I think, were admonished in many respects, and, you know, there was acknowledgement from the grand jury that there are a lot of challenges in terms of coming in and competing against Suddenlink and Frontier, just given construction.
1:13:22 And, you know, other mitigating costs and challenges that would need to be overcome. That said, you know, the grand jury did encourage the town to look at municipally owned conduit wherever it was possible or feasible to do so in town, as well as develop a comprehensive management plan for broadband within the town and the county.
1:13:45 And then outside of the town, there was a couple of recommendations or findings just around service quality in some of the unincorporated communities, as well as some potential opportunities through other service offerings like Starlink. So I'll just touch really briefly on kind of the main or the center two points in this six point set of key topics, which is that I am actively working with Hayes on
1:14:12 a concept for a management plan for broadband in town, and that does include considering municipally on conduit and other similar types of instruments. You know, one of the things that I'll say is that, and I'll talk about this more in a moment when we start talking about legislation, it's really hard to develop a comprehensive management plan right now because a lot of the rulemaking is still being developed for some of this legislation. So we don't know exactly
1:14:40 How some of the funding will be made available. We don't know the exact application of how some of the granting mechanisms will be initiated. And ultimately, there's just some threshold questions, I think, that exist throughout that are making it hard for us to say, this is actually the strategy that we would implement in this circumstance. And those things are all top of mind for me, spending
1:15:09 multiple hours a week on this topic right now, and it's one of those things that I believe we'll get a little more clarity around as we get closer to the end of the year, but it's still very much in development. So legislatively, kind of two main things just to talk about. The first is really not much to talk about, which is SB 28. Initially, this legislation was drafted, and there was a lot of optimism that
1:15:38 The critical amendments that were put in there, we were going to allow for better local control over DivCA, which is the digital infrastructure and video franchise components, basically the bit of regulatory control that the CPUC does have over broadband with regard to video. Unfortunately, that bill was, I don't want to say gutted, but a lot of the positive legislation.
1:16:06 or language that was proposed was amended, and that is not, it was not adopted with the changes that would have really given us a little more capacity or even the CPUC a little more capacity. And so effectively, that legislation is not yielding any new opportunities or outcomes with regard to regulating or governing suddenly.
1:16:30 On the positive side, however, is SB 156. And by now, I think many of you have heard about this or seen briefings. This is the historic budget allocation, you know, six plus billion dollars that was dedicated to broadband across California and governor's infrastructure bill. It was passed into law on the 15th of July. And as I said earlier,
1:16:58 They're still going through the rulemaking process of this. There's various components, several components of this legislation. Kind of two main ones that really impact us immediately are a $6 billion investment in a statewide open access middle mile network, which really is, you know, in many respects, looks like digital 395 in terms of the way it's designed and the way the governance structure.
1:17:26 key tenants of how it would operate are set up. And, you know, ultimately, most of that is already built here in Eastern Sierra. That's what Digital 395 is. We have asked for the repurposing of some of the proposed alignment to be directed to some other routes and alignments within the town, including we made a request to include
1:17:55 203 all the way down into Reds Meadow as one of those alignments, as well as a variety of other alignments throughout the county. But that piece of rulemaking is chugging along. Formal comments are open now for another week or so, and then it'll go to the administrative law judge for adjudication. The other really big news in 156 is a $5 million base allocation that'll come to
1:18:24 Mono County and all the counties actually in California plus an increment above that that we can tap for last mile projects more or less of our making and this is where some of that strategy and comprehensive management plan is I think a little bit of a question mark still because we're still trying to wait to understand better what exactly that looks like and what it means and part of that is also paired with this bullet below which
1:18:53 is the revision of the California Advanced Services Fund, which was the fund that was used to build, used by Race Communications to build a lot of the projects throughout Mono County. It's a grant program basically designed to provide funding to providers, including municipalities like ourselves now, to build last mile networks and they've basically increased.
1:19:21 the speed requirements in terms of qualifying for those projects, which is a very good thing for us, and it opens the door for challenging some of the other communities that don't really have very good broadband. So I think we're still waiting for the dust to settle on some of these things, but ultimately it's a boon and it's a historic investment in broadband, which is really great to see. So in terms of just kind of what's going on and things that are on the horizon for us is
1:19:49 We submitted formal comments last week for the reprioritization of some of the statewide route that I was discussing in the Middle Mile Project, working on this broadband action plan, continuing to work with providers, and we're going to be basically, you know, working with in cooperation and in pressure of sudden link on some of the service issues. And ultimately, this is just something that will be
1:20:17 Revisited, you know, in the months to come and certainly happy to come and report back at intervals that are of your liking. So with that, I am happy to answer any questions that you all may have. Thank you, Nate. I appreciate it. I'll throw it out here to my fellow commissioners. Does anybody have any questions for Nate on his presentation? No, other than thank you, Nate, for all your hard work on this.
1:20:53 Commissioner Kennedy? No, I don't, I don't have any comments, it's just, I appreciate Nate and his team carrying on with this, it feels a lot like the housing issue where there are such big forces at play and hard to solve on a local level, but Nate, it's great to hear all these updates on the local level that are going on, so thank you. Commissioner Burroughs? I've had more than my first share of gripes about SuttonLink, however, I...
1:21:24 And I appreciate everything you're doing, Nate, and I think that we need to continue doing this because they haven't provided very good service for our community, to say the least. But that being said, I did have an incident with them recently in which I called them on a Saturday. They came out Saturday afternoon.
1:21:44 And they provided service. And I thought when they said, oh yeah, they're going to come out Saturday, there was not a chance that they were ever going to do that, but they did. So hopefully some of the work that you're doing, they're hearing and we need to keep pressing so that we can continue to serve our community in the way that we should be treated here. I'm very glad to hear that. I mean, I'm sure for that comment, there's probably five more that have
1:22:15 Not as positive, but it is good to hear that there is some positive movement as well. I know that they are trying legitimately. I hope they're hearing. I really do. I hope I didn't just get lucky. Your name's on a list, Commissioner Barrows, after the tongue lashing you gave the sudden link guy that appeared before us. Speed dial. Get this woman happy.
1:22:44 Nate, I'm just going to say again, I'll echo my fellow commissioners, we really appreciate not only the hard work and focus that you have on this and the people you're working with, but we really appreciate these updates. So I know you're a busy man, you wear two hats, a county hat and a town hat, but if there's a way we could get you to maybe give us an update quarterly, would be fantastic. Sure, I'd be happy to do that.
1:23:14 I hope that by the end of the year, as I said, some of the uncertainty will become a little more certain. So I think if we targeted something in the December timeframe, that may be appropriate. That would be great. And yeah, I mean, some of those figures you had in your presentation in terms of available funding, I mean, those are some big, big numbers. Yeah.
1:23:39 It's great to see. And I think I'm trying to remain optimistic and we'll see how it all shakes out. So if we did, if we were able to tap into some of that funding, Nate, are you envisioning a scenario where it's a public-private partnership where we're working with Suddenlink to pull that fiber into town? I think it would need to be a public-private partnership.
1:24:09 For it to be successful, I mean, there's some policy questions here, and certainly one that needs to be cracked open in terms of how this is approached would be, is the town interested in municipally held infrastructure at all, and if so, to what extent? I think the model that we're seeing emerge as being a preferred one in other jurisdictions throughout the state right now is,
1:24:39 Municipally held conduit, which is effectively leased or otherwise provided to a provider or to a group of providers for them to come in and basically provide service, build through that conduit ultimately to the back doors of businesses and homes throughout the community. I think that the challenging part of this is
1:25:09 That you've got to start somewhere. You know, if we don't start doing something, then we won't have anything. On the other hand, without a comprehensive plan, to have a patchwork of conduit throughout town doesn't necessarily provide a lot of value or benefit either. And so one of the things that Hayes and I are talking about are with some of the new projects that are coming down the pike, like the CRC and like the parcel.
1:25:34 We have some obvious opportunity and I think we need to kind of test some of this policy question in terms of, you know, to what extent we are going to be involved and to what extent that involvement will really look like. But certainly we, the town, aren't going to be in the business of providing broadband. I think we'll ultimately be relying on a provider, whoever that may be, to actually deliver service to folks. I think what we're trying to
1:26:02 look at and solve for is how do we streamline that? How do we reduce barriers of entry? Because we know that there's no more space on poles and cutting streets and digging in conduit is not an inexpensive undertaking. And so we've got to be thoughtful about how to approach it. Got it. Two more really quick questions, Nate. So all those, the
1:26:29 figures on the funding that you had in your presentation. I'm assuming all that is at a state of California level. Do you have any, I know there's one whopper of a federal bill making its way through Congress, an infrastructure bill that has got a very large amount of money dedicated towards broadband. I understand that's on a national level, but some of that money would end up making its way to California.
1:26:57 Any idea how we tap into that or is that strictly a decision out of our hands? I think that that's one of those that's kind of floating around out there on the rulemaking docket as well. The last that I heard the kind of briefing within the NACO kind of space within the National Association of Accounting space was that the methodology for allocating that money across the states was still being
1:27:26 Hashed out, i.e. it wasn't clear how much money would be coming to California, and then it wasn't clear once it landed in California what the distribution was going to be for that. Was it going to go into the California Advanced Services Fund? Was it going to be a separate fund altogether? And there's obvious concern around this because, you know, the capacities to manage and regulate and dole that money out are limited, and there's only so many.
1:27:53 State entities that exist that are capable of doing that. So that one is still kind of a TBD, you know, and I think part of the conversation that I'm looking around is what are the thresholds to qualify for that money, you know, because while we are very frustrated in our circumstances here in Mammoth and in Mono County, you know, a lot of that money is being set aside or, you know, more or less.
1:28:23 prioritized for communities that don't even have one megabit of service, let alone a gigabit of service. So there are certainly a lot of other jurisdictions throughout the state that are in higher need than we are. So that's part of what we're trying to look at. Got it. So clear as mud is what you're saying. Pretty much. Hey, last question. And feel free to say I don't know the answer to that if I'm putting you on the spot. You were talking about the PUC.
1:28:53 and how it has almost no teeth when it comes to broadband regulation, but they do have teeth when it comes to video and phone. Do you know if there's any legislation out there that is being proposed that does basically give the PUC some authority? There was, and I guess there still is.
1:29:23 I think, you know, about six months ago, nine months ago, something like that, there were about 58 separate pieces of legislation surrounding broadband at a state and federal level, and some of those have died. Some of those have been stalled, and they'll come back in the next session, and, you know, some have basically been adopted, like 156. So this is obviously, or not obviously, this is,
1:29:54 The biggest topic that is out there in terms of folks like us who are advocating for broadband. If you really want to be successful in terms of solving these problems at the root, it needs to become a regulated utility. But I mean, you can imagine the amount of pushback and lobbying that is happening around that for a variety of reasons from industry.
1:30:23 I am hopeful that it will happen, but it is something that is, I think, at best a hope at this point. That said, I can tell you that both the National Association of Counties Broadband Task Force, which John Peters was a part of, as well as the CSAC Broadband Advisory Group, which John and I were also a part of, those were specific recommendations made by both of those entities.
1:30:51 Which, you know, go to state and federal lawmakers. You know, what that translates to and whether things actually make it to the signing of legislation, I think anybody's guess is as good as mine. I mean, I would imagine in the next decade it's going to happen, whether it happens in the next couple of years, I don't know. Got it. Thanks for the insight there. I appreciate it, Nate. Hey, Jamie, is there any public comment for Nate in this presentation? No, there is not.
1:31:22 Okay. Does anyone have any further questions or conversation you want to have with Nate? Nate, we really appreciate your time. We really appreciate you fighting the good fight. So, yeah, more power to you. You've got the support of this commission. Half of our mandate is economic development and substandard broadband service, I think, really hurts.
1:31:51 us from diversifying our economy. So this is not one we're going to let slip through the cracks as a commission, that's for sure. At least not while I sit on it. Nor should you. That's great. Happy to be here and look forward to talking more soon. We'll see you around the holidays, Nate. Thank you so much for your time. All right. All right. Now we're going to go to our second presentation, 4.2, presentation on town code compliance efforts. And Jenna and Rick, we really appreciate your patience. Thank you.
1:32:22 Sure. Take it away, guys. Thank you. I think we'll let Jenna go first, huh? Thank you. I'm ready too. So I'll start sharing my screen here. You guys should see a PowerPoint presentation now. Yep. Thank you. So my section of code compliance, I've had this position now for two years exactly to the month. And I've joined you guys about once a month to just give you an idea of...
1:32:52 Statistics. I've just given you numbers. So this presentation is kind of meant to give you a little bit more of the visual and open up for any questions you guys have. So my section of code compliance is I focus on building, zoning, health and safety, and public works. The two main ones missing here would be like vehicle code or animal control. So my first one, zoning. This makes up about 48% of my cases. The biggest one going to dead trees.
1:33:25 Next, going to outdoor sales on permitted, this one being a yard sale that went on for far too long. Setbacks and encroachments like behind businesses, these kind of cluttered displays get cleaned up. Dwelling, camping in RVs, as you guys have known, I've talked about that before. Improper recreational vehicle storage. Recreational vehicles should be stored on a paved surface. Unpermitted parking lots with some of the vacant lots in town.
1:33:58 Different people have started to park there as like a park and ride, an unofficial park and ride. We do have permit processes in place for this kind of thing. So this is one where we have actually cleared up that lot and it's private property that was being trespassed on by all those vehicles. So there are no longer those vehicles on there and it is back to private property. Lighting ordinances, the glare and light trespass, these two examples, you can see that the light is far too bright.
1:34:26 They were able to put shields on those and fix that and make their neighbors happy. And signs. This one's a banner that is just, you know, unmaintained. And I've worked with this business owner and he's working on getting a permanent sign that would meet our code. My next one's building. This makes up about a quarter of my cases. The biggest chunk would be unpermitted construction. This is an example of some unpermitted construction that we're working on closing.
1:34:55 Next in lines, construction beyond the scope of a permit. This is a pellet stove chimney. We had a permit on file for a pellet stove, but this pellet stove chimney is never supposed to go that long to exhaust. Good old 2017 winter wreaked havoc on a lot of big homes throughout Mammoth Lakes, and so it created unsafe and dangerous structures.
1:35:23 This is one where we were able to convince the property owner that he needs to take down all of this deck and stairway to make it a safe building. It is still private property, so he's not required to be held to a certain timeline to rebuild that deck, but he has to make it safe to the public. Substandard dwellings. Unfortunately, I do get a lot of calls about substandard dwellings. This is a mold issue where the ceiling fell through because of constant moisture.
1:35:51 And so we work with the property owners to pull the right permits and get those repaired so that tenants can live in, you know, habitable dwellings. Abandoned buildings. This is an example of an abandoned building that was fire damaged. And you can see there's openings. The abandoned buildings around town are required to be secured, so they need to be boarded up. And animals, wildlife and kids should not be allowed to just enter in there freely.
1:36:22 Next would be health and safety. A smaller percentage, but this is where we get the trash police term. Spilled trash around town, spilled grease around town. We're protecting our wildlife mostly here by educating the community about keeping the dumpsters latched, keeping the grease containers chained up, locked, and properly disposing of your grease.
1:36:49 Illegal dumping is something we deal with on a daily basis with like furniture left out at dumpsters and everything. There are proper ways to dispose of these items. They should not be left out on the curb. Sorry, Rick? What if they say free? Yeah, then we give, we, sometimes we give them a chance on a couple hours if someone wants to, as the win-win situation. But when it comes to overnight and days, that's when we have an issue with it. Noise, this, having,
1:37:20 Example up here, I don't get as many, but with golf courses and concerts, I do get some noise complaints. Waste on premises, so this would be like construction. The construction sites are required to maintain their sites to a tidy and, you know, safe standard. This one we were able to get cleaned up.
1:37:48 More substandard conditions that fall into life safety. These are examples of the top one with a wall heater. That was a wall heater fire actually in a tenant's bathroom. And this is the fire marshal's arm showing us where the fire hazard was. So we were able to get this one fixed as well. They pulled a permit and properly installed that wall heater in the bathroom, making it safe for the tenants. And this one being mold down below, just moisture.
1:38:16 With a substandard condition, we do, if once you repair the moisture leak, the mold goes away. The mold is only growing because of moisture. And unsafe and dangerous structures. This is like a little shack that was unsafe and it's attractive to kids to play in and everything. So we do require that property owners secure those kind of unsafe, dangerous structures so that kids aren't, kids and animals too aren't playing around in them and possibly getting hurt. My last.
1:38:46 Category is Public Works. This covers all the roads. It's my smallest category only because the Public Works Department does a great job on their own as well. They're constantly out there checking the roads and these are dumpsters in the right-of-way that we were able to get out of the right-of-way. Signs, sometimes homeowners put out signs on the road and those are not allowed.
1:39:12 Also maintaining street signs. This is where some overgrowth happens on the street signs. There is a street sign behind it that says like Mammoth Knolls. And so I alert the Public Works Department when I get these kind of complaints from public or if I notice them on my own. Construction dust. This time of year, we're getting a lot of that. Construction sites are required to constantly water down their sites and keep the dust down so that the neighbors around aren't exposed to it constantly.
1:39:41 And they do, construction sites do a pretty good job around town. It's a hard, hard thing to do, not getting mud, but also not having dust. Stormwater contamination. We do protect our stormwater drains here because we have it separated from sewer and stormwater. Our stormwater goes straight to the Mammoth Creek. Technically, tap water should not even be going down the drain because tap water kills fish. So this is soapy water discharge that
1:40:09 Definitely was not allowed to go down the storm drain. And then last but not least would be my unpermitted encroachments. This is when a homeowner says like makes a new driveway or a connection to the right-of-way. The public works department is very protective of the right-of-way because they maintain the snow removal and make sure that it's all safe for everybody. So when you start putting unpermitted encroachments like this, it affects the right-of-way. So they were this.
1:40:38 Homeowner did remove this unpermitted encroachment. This is my contact information for everybody, and if anyone has any questions, I did want to just add on that the Caltrans District 9 is having a free dump day this weekend, tomorrow, I think it is Saturday, at the Smokey Bear Flats for Mono County. So if anyone has tires or bulky items in their yard that they want to clean up, they're accepting them down there at Smokey Bear Flats.
1:41:08 Thank you. And that is it for my presentation, if anyone has any questions. So people can take their bulky items to Smokey Bear Flats and then Caltrans will haul it away? Yes. Can you stop screen sharing, Jenna? Yes. Let's see. Thank you. Sorry. Trying to stop screen sharing. It's at the top. There we go. Thank you. Thanks. Any questions for Jenna from the commission? I just have one question. Jenna, thank you for your presentation.
1:41:43 You said soapy water is not allowed. So does that mean people can't wash their cars anywhere in town? If you do wash your cars, that's a good question, Paul. They're recommending that you wash your car and your driveway or on your yard. So the water then goes back into your own yard. You know, it would go down into your lawn or your dirt in your yard. And most, like my house, naturally will drain that way anyways, away from the roads.
1:42:12 You just don't want to wash your car in the street where it's draining into the storm drain. So along like Joaquin is a main storm drain that's very obvious, you know, goes straight down to the storm drain. That's the kind of drain we're protecting, not necessarily in your yard. And to clarify that a little bit, the Fish and Game Code states that anything that goes into any of the state waters cannot contain anything as deleterious to the water.
1:42:41 But anything that would kill a fish, even sawdust, can't go down there. Any other questions for Jenna? Thanks, Jenna. We appreciate your time. All right. You're up, Rick. All right. Let's see if I can do this. Is that displaying? Yeah. All right. So I'm Rick Bellis. I work for the Mammoth Lakes Police Department as a co-compliance officer. With me, we have a new hiree who was unable to attend. I'm not sure if he got the invite in his personal email because we're both off today.
1:43:17 And we're kind of like the bridge between the police department and the town. So basically we do more of a, we're more out in the, we're out doing like vehicle code stuff, things of that nature are out and about. So the new officer, his name is Ryan Tanaka and he comes to us from the Orange County DA's office. He was a traffic investigator for them. Prior to that, he was
1:43:43 with the Orange County Sheriff's Department. He was a code, excuse me, a community service officer down in the city of Dana Point. And prior to that, he was a police officer for the town of Irvine, or the city of Irvine, excuse me. So he's, he's, we're kind of, I'm still working with him right now just to show him around town, to show him how things are done in Mammoth. And I believe starting this, this weekend where he's going to be out on his own, we're going to kind of split up our shifts a little bit more. So some of the stuff that...
1:44:13 that we work on. Just like Jenna, we do the quality of life calls. So we kind of work together with Jenna on this. So Jenna, Kari and Ryan and I, we kind of, every time we see something like this, we'll let each other know who's done what already. So there's not a duplication of efforts. We see this every day, usually around the end of the month, actually. Either the last week or the first week of the month when people are moving and they decide that stereo cabinet from 1980.
1:44:42 Something people would want. Put a free sign on it, leave it on the curb. I've been dealing with wildlife calls a lot this year. So far this year, we had 72 bear calls starting from January 1st. Actually, the first one started in February 27th. Of those 72 calls, 35 of them were in August alone. So there's an uptick in bear activity as they're trying to make their winter wait.
1:45:15 I found two deer carcasses, one off of Tamarack and the other one in Mammoth Creek Park that were killed by mountain lion. I took photographs of the kill, sent them to the local fish and game biologist, excuse me, fish and wildlife biologist. He confirmed those were mountain lion kills and then he sent me a...
1:45:38 A map of the cat that's been walking around Mammoth Lake. So it's basically a female mountain lion that goes from Duck Pass, makes her way down to Old Mammoth and makes a straight line north right up Minaret till she hits the woods and goes all the way up to June Lake and back. So that seems to be her area. We've had one coyote call and one suspected bat bite that was in a residence off of Mono.
1:46:08 The person who got bitten started treatment for rabies. We were unable to confirm whether or not it was a bat. He gave me some droppings that he thought were bat droppings. Again, I gave it to the bat specialist for fish and wildlife, and she told me those were not bat droppings. And oddly enough, one jaguar sighting, and based on what a jaguar looks like, I'm highly skeptical about what that actually was. We did have last Sunday night, I believe,
1:46:39 We did have a 13-year-old boy, oops, sorry, not yet, that's not yet, more wildlife calls. This is a bear, a sow and her cub, who's been wandering around, mainly lupine, and she's been making her way back and forth between Joaquin and Manzanilla. She has a second cub, which in this photograph was actually up a tree. She's actually kind of a docile sow. We do have a more aggressive one that's been working off a forest trail.
1:47:10 Some of the bear activity we've had, this is a car that was parked at the Grand Sierra Inn off of Main Street. This was a cooler that was completely empty, but the bear saw the cooler, smashed the window, sniffed it, realized there was nothing in there and kept going on its way. Here's a car. We always advise people to make sure they roll up their windows and lock their car. The reason for that is the bears have figured out how to open up the latches on the car. They can get in a car.
1:47:39 But if the door shuts behind them, they can't get out. And this is what happens when they can't get out. This car, I believe, was totaled. Here's one of the mountain lion kills that we had. This was the one from Mammoth Creek. And the reason you can tell it's a mountain lion kill is if you look at the internal area right here, it's almost like a surgical cut. It's kind of weird. What concerned me was the fact they normally eat the innards almost immediately. And that's the most nutritious part.
1:48:07 That's what the cats eat, and they leave the carcass for the coyotes. And we did have one coyote call at Vaughn's, but coyotes are all over the place, and of course this was the one that got the phone call. Now I was starting to say earlier, we did have last Sunday night, this is a 13-year-old boy who was scratched by a bear as he walked by a trash bin. The kid didn't see the bear, he walked by it, the bear was eating trash.
1:48:38 Was defending what he or she found. The kid got scratched and pushed over. He screamed and the bear ran away. I had to forward this to the Department of Fish and Wildlife because at that point it's historically been considered a dangerous bear. I spoke with a local lieutenant and he was telling me that chances are nothing's going to happen to that bear. But we do have to be more aware that as winter encroaches and the bears are getting more...
1:49:07 or attempting to mate their winter weight, they may become aggressive. Some domestic animal issues we've been having, or that we started, we had started an online pet registration program. So rather than having everybody come in on June 30th and having their pet registration be for the fiscal year, but now the registration is valid from the date they register the animal until one calendar year. So this is a little bit easier, it kind of eases up the registration process.
1:49:39 And you can do it online. You don't have to come to the police department to accomplish that. This presentation was really originally set for something I presented to the town in August. Over the month of June and July, we had a total of eight animal bites on humans. And I was talking to the lady over at the shelter at Whitmore, and she was saying in the county area, animal bites have been really up this year as well. Of those bites, one was a cat bite.
1:50:14 And seven were dog bites. And, you know, last year we had a lot of issues with dog off-leash. We had a campaign earlier this year saying we're going to start enforcing the leash laws more. But all of these bites either occurred in the house or animals that had broken out of the house. So, for example, we had one dog bite at home. One dog was on a leash under the table. It tied up, bit the waiter.
1:50:41 We had one jump out of a car to bite somebody. We had one that ran through a screen in order to get to somebody. And this dog actually was quarantined twice this year. And one dog dragged its dog walker across the path so it could bite somebody. And so that dog was on a leash. And then one dog opened up a storm door. And then we had one leash dog bite for a dog that was off leash at McLeod Lake.
1:51:12 This is not citable as once you're in the Forest Service area, even though it's just kind of our jurisdiction based on our MLU of the Forest Service, that is not a violation of any law once you're on the Cloud Lake. This year so far we've issued three quarantine letters for bite dogs, so once a dog bites a human being it has to be quarantined for 10 days either at their residence or at the shelter. So two of those were local dogs.
1:51:40 And one was on behalf of Santa Cruz County. They had someone who was vacationing out here. They got hold of us and asked us to quarantine the dogs. We've been working with the camp hosts this year. So early in June, we gave a presentation on behalf of Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Forest Service, and CDFW. Our local game warden is on medical leave. And when we get this presentation, the Forest Service, a ranger who's Mark Scott.
1:52:08 Was that a fire down in Lone Pine? So basically, we were given all these people information on what to do and who to contact if anything happens within their campgrounds. So the Mammoth Lakes Police Department does have an MOU with the Forest Service to provide law enforcement for all the camps within the lakes basin and the ones within town, so old and new J.D. Rest. During the summer, I do shuffle my hours.
1:52:36 So a lot of times I'll work at night or more of a night shift to deal with. This year was supposed to be for fire and camping issues, but we did not have the crowds materialize like we did last year. If anybody remembers last year up in the Lakes Basin, it was a zoo. This year we had very few illegal camps in the Lakes Basin. We weren't dealing with that quite as much.
1:53:05 Let's talk about changing hours. So, for example, now that Ryan Tanaka is on board, starting next week, I'll be working predominantly at night dealing with the wildlife that's causing issues within the town limits. Some of the information I handed out to the camp host is basically what to do when you're camping in bear country. So I had a stack of these I created and, you know, every Saturday and Sunday I'm driving through the lake space and I'm asking.
1:53:34 The camp hosts whether or not they need this information. So we've taken advantage of that. Forest Service patrols, again, we're concentrating mainly on the Lakes Basin this year for parking and illegal fires and illegal camping. And we did have night patrols planned with the Forest Service, but again, the need for that never materialized. And as far as the parking issues this year, I'd like to credit that trail host program we developed. The trail hosts have been telling
1:54:04 People, hey, you know, you really can't park there. I can't write the ticket, but I guarantee you if they come up, you're going to get a ticket where you're parked. And as a result, our ticket count is probably 50% of what it was last summer, which is really good because if you write the ticket, they're still blocking traffic. And that's usually what our tickets were for. This sounds kind of weird, but we have a roadkill initiative. So I contacted a local biologist for the Department of Fish and Wildlife. Historically, when we had to put down a deer,
1:54:34 It just went right into the bushes on the side of the road and we let nature take its course. This year, however, I started a program, I have access to the freezer at the hatchery and putting all of our roadkill in there and the local biologists for the department, they've been using those to bait traps for bears and mountain lions for the different studies that they're conducting at the Eastern Sierra. So at least the meat's going to use.
1:55:03 Other activities, I'm not sure if you've noticed, we have a Facebook page called Critters and Code Compliance, so we maintain a presence on the internet. I know Jenna posts stuff on there, and we have a couple other people within the police department who have access to that, just to keep the town up to date on what's going on locally. Other things, again, this was a few months ago. We had a really successful town cleanup. There was a health fair of the CHP where we handed out 10 car seats and installed them.
1:55:34 For people who needed car seats for their vehicles. And we also inspected four car seats as they came through just to make sure that the seats they have for their vehicles are correct and properly installed and the correct size for their child. That's pretty much a summary of what I have. Does anybody have any questions? Let me throw this out to my fellow commissioners. Does anybody have any questions for Rick this time? I do. Yes. Please. That coyote at Vaughn's. Yes. That wouldn't get put down by any chance? No.
1:56:07 Okay, because I live in the trails and there is one specific coyote that like stands out in the middle of the street in the middle of the day and I don't know if that's normal behavior for a coyote but I've never seen that before and it's not timid about people, it'll just sit there. No, most of our wildlife is actually pretty acclimated to people. Coyotes are by and large nocturnal but they do have diurnal properties where they will go out during the day as well.
1:56:34 That usually indicates a pretty robust population. And we do have quite a few coyotes in town in the area. My main concern with that is there is an outbreak of canine distemper working its way up the Sherwin Pass. There's populations of foxes that are contaminated. I know a couple of coyotes were killed out by Crowley and they were tested and they were confirmed to have canine distemper. So my fear is it's working its way up.
1:57:05 If your dog, which can affect the coyotes in town, the bears in town, the raccoons in town, and the foxes in town. And if domestic dogs and cats are not vaccinated against it, they can also affect domestic dogs and cats. So, but the one that you're, that one from Vons, I believe, I've been watching that coyote who makes his way from Vons and he does go through the trails.
1:57:29 And he makes his way out by the skate park and crosses that little connection on Meridian and 203. And he goes north in the woods and he comes out that way again. Okay. And it's always alone. Sometimes they're pack animals, sometimes they're not. It could be a lone male that had been kicked out by the alpha dog of the pack and is trying to make his way. Because he looks pretty young to me, maybe a year old. So he's still trying to.
1:57:58 Cut his teeth, if you will. And then is it unusual for us to have mountain lions walking around in town? No. Anywhere you have a deer population in California, you'll have mountain lions. Okay. So there are currently 40 collared cats between, I believe, Lone Pine and here. That's a pretty big population of cats. I know I spent literally thousands of hours outdoors.
1:58:29 You know, as an outdoorsman, as a game warden, and doing what I do now, I've seen two mountain lions in the wild. They're pretty, if you see one, they mean for you to see it. Yeah, I just hadn't heard them being in this, like, in town at Mammoth Creek Park, and when I've heard it's been over at Snow Creek, and usually I thought that they hung out more in the hills behind, like, Snow Creek 5. Well, they...
1:58:58 That one that's out by Snow Creek 5, that's the same one. It's a lone female. And it's the same one that went through Tamarack and Mammoth Creek Park. You know, I used to work in Southern California as a game warden. I saw a map that showed the area of Dove Canyon, which is a developed area of southeast Orange County. And I couldn't believe.
1:59:25 The cat's movements within the neighborhoods during the day. And they're under decks and they stay there, they tell the people come home and then they leave. A friend of mine, Dr. Jeff Villopeak, who did his doctorate study on mountain lions, has done hundreds of necropsies on mountain lions and every single one of them had domestic dog and cat. So they are, I mean, we are in the mountains. And we're actually in a pretty rural area for them.
1:59:54 And so the town boundaries are very inviting to them. When I lived in San Diego, I had a mountain lion that would scratch its back on our fence. I lived by the San Diego Safari Park. And so it always hung out there. I have no further questions. Thank you for your report. Sure. Commissioner Chang, any questions for Rick? No? Okay. Commissioner Kennedy? No questions. I'm really happy to hear about that docu-pet.
2:00:25 Update the online registration. I didn't know about that and have never registered my dog in Mammoth because it's so complicated. Oh my gosh. I know, I shouldn't admit that, but I just, it's such a complicated process. But anyway, I think that'll help get a lot more dogs registered. Almost everyone I know also has not registered their dogs, but this I think will get them on board. Hopefully. And a lot of people have questions about the whole concept of registering dogs. They think it's a money grab by the town, but the reality is.
2:00:54 The whole purpose of registering a dog is we can immediately identify whether or not it's been vaccinated with rabies. So that is the whole purpose of registration statewide in California. Yeah, I'd never heard of it from North Carolina where I'm from. So I was like, register my dog. Is that just a like fun thing to do? But anyway, I think this is a hugely important thing and great that it's online now. So thanks for that update. Hey, Rick, I've got a couple of just a quick questions. How many citations did you guys issue for dogs off leash?
2:01:26 Do you know what? We kind of take more of a hands-off approach. It's pretty much all warnings. I have issued no citations. So essentially, if I go through a shady rest park, you know, it's been a pretty brutal year the last year for people. And the last thing we want to do is go, here's more regulations for you. But I explain to people, hey, this is a $150 fine. We're going to write this. You walk right, your leash is hanging on the sign that says you need to have your dog on a leash.
2:01:55 And people have been mostly compliant. When I make at least two loops per shift through Shady Rats Park, I maybe see one or two dogs a day off leash. I know I hear people saying it's pandemonium down there, but I've never gotten the call for that. And when I go down there, it's been pretty mellow. There are some other areas like the trail between Minaret and what's that paved trail that goes up?
2:02:27 All the way behind Eagle or Juniper Springs. I can't remember the street I'm thinking of. Oh, the bike path. Yes. So there's dogs off-leash there. We're going to start hitting that just to make sure people understand that. That's also a registered federal wetland. There's different regulations that are involved with off-leash dogs there as well. So kind of over next to the Valentine Reserve, that area back in there. Correct. Correct. Hey, and my second question is, Rick, is it...
2:02:55 In your area of responsibility to work with the Forest Service on really cracking down on dispersed camping within the town limits? Actually, within the town limits, that's usually us in the police department. Okay. But if it's like within the area of Shady Rest or out on the scenic loop, I have patrolled out there with the Forest Service or on behalf of the Forest Service just to clear people out. There is a dispersed camping area two miles north of Shady Rest.
2:03:25 And I've directed multiple people up there, just reinforcing the fact that they cannot have any open fires. And right now, of course, everything's closed, so they can't even be out there. And then I found out the people who stay pretty much the entire summer off of the scenic loop are self-policing. They have people coming out there who are starting campfires, and I wrote up to them going, nope, no fires. Which is a really good thing, because they know they're, what?
2:03:54 People are out there all summer, they know they really shouldn't be out there all summer, so they don't want to drone it. So they're, like I said, they've been, all the people who've been coming in, they've been making sure that they've had no fires. Yeah, okay. Well, that was, first of all, I appreciate the presentation, and if I'm not mistaken, I did hear you say earlier that today is your day off. So for you to take the time to not only sit through the previous agenda items, but then to make this presentation.
2:04:23 It's very, very much appreciated. And you guys have the rare privilege of seeing the room I grew up in. I don't know what happened to my Devo poster. My mom must have taken that down, so. Probably could sell it for a few bucks on eBay, that's for sure. Hey, Jamie, did we have any public comment on this presentation? No, we do not. Thank you. All right, Rick, enjoy the rest of your day off. Jen, I appreciate you for having me as well. Thanks, guys. Keep up the good fight. Thank you.
2:04:53 All right. In our last presentation, 4.3, presentation on the CIP projects and the ever-patient Hays is going to take it away. Thank you, Hays. Thank you, Chair Vanderhurst. So this is a continuation of the item we had on July 14th, where we did some speed planning and adopted a resolution confirming that the CIP was consistent with the general plan, and I appreciate that.
2:05:23 We did that rather quickly, and so I made a commitment to come back to you at a later date to specifically talk about the projects in the CIP. First, thank you for doing that. It was instrumental in moving this process forward. We did have the CIP approved by Town Council on September 1st.
2:05:43 And, you know, working with the town manager and the finance manager, this is a process we're going to see iteratively. We're going to bring this forward many times a year to town council and really maintain the CIP as our active dynamic document when we're cataloging our capital improvement plans so we can stay organized and really focus on the budget items. So with that, and to be respectful of your time, because I could talk a lot about this. This is the choose your own adventure portion of
2:06:13 The meeting. I provided a significant amount of material in the packet today, the full CIP, a number of tables, and a staff report that kind of talked about where we're at. I've got a number of different things prepared that I can do. I have a full-blown presentation where I can walk through the CIP and I can walk through each individual project. I teased them out by 21, 22, 22, 23 fiscal years and then kind of held out the later projects.
2:06:41 I'm also prepared to walk through the full project list, not organized by year or when it's going to be constructed, but just by category. And I could do anything in between. I've got a number of things teed up here on my screen that I can do. So what is the pleasure of the commission today? And what are you guys most interested in hearing about? What would you guys like to, how would you like to answer that, guys? Jen, how would you like to proceed? I would say tease out the
2:07:16 projects that you feel are most important to discuss at this time. Commissioner Kennedy? Commissioner Chang? I would agree with that. And I would say by category rather than by I think year was the other option. So agree with Jen, but maybe broad category based. And I saw a thumbs up from Commissioner Chang. So let's go with that route, Dem Hayes. All right. Give me one second.
2:08:06 All right, let me flip down to the projects. Okay, so I'm going to run through the projects by category. I'll go rather quickly and then stop at each section and you guys can ask us questions. I'll just give a brief explanation of what the project is, the kind of proposed schedule if there is one, a little bit about funding and then I'll move on and then we can go back to them. I will emphasize the projects that will be constructed.
2:08:37 that are under construction now and to be constructed next year in case you have specific questions about what's really active and the stuff we're really moving forward right now. So with that, the first category is affordable housing. We have a placeholder here for an affordable housing project. The town manager has been putting money into a bucket for
2:09:02 A set aside for undefined housing projects, this allows us to capitalize on opportunities. There is no real schedule for this project. Like I said, it's a holding place for funding. And we're looking for private partners and so forth to help advance this project. Right now, the bucket is about $1.5 million with the goal of putting an additional $1.1 million per year into this project. And if something was to come out of this, if we did identify
2:09:31 private-public partnership or a new piece of land that would become its own discrete project. So we're also partnering with Mammoth Lake Housing on the 238 Sierra Manor Road project. This is to provide a conversion of existing commercial space into apartments. We've put $1.5 million into the project and we're looking at a 21-22 groundbreaking on this.
2:10:03 60 Joaquin is a vacant parcel the town acquired. We're starting a process to place six units on the site while still meeting the parking and snow storage requirements, so a pretty hefty task. Obviously, that's a project you guys will see a lot of if it moves forward, well, when it moves forward, I should say. We're looking at a 2022 groundbreaking, probably a design-build type project, and we're appropriating $3.2 million towards that project.
2:10:32 The parcel IIG infrastructure, we tease this out, this is part of that $20,600,000 grant the town and Pacific jointly received to cover the cost of the infrastructure in the parcel. This is a significant project, a lot of right-of-way mops, storm drain, utilities, sidewalks, transit, you name it, big projects, so we've set that.
2:10:59 As one of our affordable housing CIP projects. Oh, Haze, just can I interrupt you while you're on that slide, the parcel slide. I did want to provide an update during director's report, but it's probably better to do it now while it's on the screen there. Just a heads up to the commission that the grading and tree removal will start at the parcel tomorrow. So you'll start seeing some work going on out there.
2:11:25 which will be doing a portion of the infrastructure that you see on your screen here and clearing for phase one. So the clearing will start from the Tavern Road access and kind of work its way across the site to Center Street. Thanks, Hayes. Yeah, excellent timing, Sandra. And then we have another placeholder for affordable housing site development. The town does own some additional land around the city.
2:11:56 Some partner properties, and this is a placeholder for potentially advancing some of those sites, doing some development work. We don't have a schedule on this. We don't have funding for this, but it's something that's going to manifest over the next year or two into real projects. So that's the affordable housing category. I'm happy to field any questions before we move on to the airport. Any questions for Hayes on the affordable housing?
2:12:26 Part of the presentation. I've got a really quick one for you, Hayes. The first slide you were talking about. Yes. So the 5.9 million, none of this, none of these funds are being allocated to the parcel, correct? No, not at this time. This is for future undefined projects. It's a set aside. Got it. So something like the Joaquin project would fall into this area.
2:12:58 No, the Joaquin parcel lands in its own bucket. This is money that the town manager is setting aside for really undefined opportunities. I'm sorry, I should have stated my question a little more clearly. So like a future opportunity like the Joaquin would fall into this bucket? Gotcha, yes, yeah. If 65 Joaquin came up for sale and we wanted to buy it in advance, that it could fall into this category. Or if...
2:13:26 Like Mark Raffey, and he had his project and he wanted to advance something as a partnership. Money would come out of this bucket. And what's the process the town goes through to identify the private partner for the public-private relationship? We don't really have a defined process. I think we're always looking for those opportunities. And if a private developer came forward and wanted to meet their affordable housing.
2:13:52 Need, instead of paying the fee, we could work with them, use these types of funds to advance project. I think we're looking for any opportunity. We just don't, we don't really have a defined process at this point to utilize these types of funds. Got it. And would you mind going to the country glass slide, the Mammoth Lakes Housing? Apologies for putting you on the spot, but I think the last presentation I saw from Mammoth Lakes Housing, they still have a significant funding gap.
2:14:22 Before they can move forward. Did I hear that correctly? Something like 1.7 million? I believe that's the number that rings a bell and I don't have the full project funding. The town has appropriated funds to the project and we're working with them to advance it. Like I said, the schedule is to deliver this project as quickly as possible with as soon as 21-22 if the funding were available. But the town has already put in its contribution.
2:14:51 And Mammoth Lakes Housing has had control of this property since 2017, I believe. That's correct. Okay, so the two projects that the town is working on, Joaquin and the parcel, are moving very quickly, and this one has got a ways to go still. Yeah, the town projects are moving forward expeditiously, and we'd love to see Mammoth Lakes Housing Project advance as well. Got it. That's my only questions. Thank you, Hais. Thank you. I'm going to jump back to the airport.
2:15:22 So the reconstruction of the East General Aviation apron is ongoing. If anybody's driven by the airport in the last month, they've seen the equipment out there. They've been paving the last couple of days. That project is wrapping up and basically covered the entire GA apron. It's that yellow area on the screen was completely reconstructed. We are working with the FAA to deliver a...
2:15:49 8 Bay ARF Snow Storage Removal Maintenance Facility. Right now, we lease space to store all of our equipment and the firefighting equipment. So we're working with the FAA to construct our own maintenance shop. We're currently trying to acquire the funding to build that as soon to start the construction as soon as next year. And that would be funded out of discretionary funds. The wildlife security fence.
2:16:17 This is something that's been ongoing for a number of years, trying to get the right approvals. The FAA has directed the town to erect a security fence, but a lot of that land lands on Forest Service property, and so we've been having to work with our partners to get the approvals to erect that fence. We do have a placeholder for that a couple years out, but we do have some challenges administratively to bring that project forward. And I'll add, the airport...
2:16:45 John Urdi, Ph.D.: Component of this has its own CIP the we call it the ACIP the airport capital improvement plan that is approved by the FAA we go through an annual process so. John Urdi, Ph.D.: These projects are coming right out of that airport CIP which Sierra works on with the FDA to develop and she works with some of our other consultants to really fine tune the. John Urdi, Ph.D.: The numbers and the scopes of these projects and ensure that they're the meet the FAA approval and so forth. John Urdi, Ph.D.: we're also.
2:17:16 Moving forward, 24-25, we're going to reconstruct the taxi T-lane hangars. That's between a number of these town-owned airport hangars. So we'll be reconstructing that asphalt. The runway RSA, OFA, that's the runway safety area and the object-free area. This is some grading to clear out this so that there's no plants, bushes, or obstructions near the runway.
2:17:45 That's programmed way out to 25, 26. Also needs the fence project to move forward so we have the right clearances. Security gates and terminal area fencing. This is an ongoing project active right now. This is just providing better security at the facility. That's the separation between the land side and the air side. So that's the end of the airport segment. Happy to answer any questions about airport projects.
2:18:16 Any questions on the airport for Hayes? No? Hey, Hayes, that very first slide. Yes, I think this was it. I'm sorry. Maybe it was a further slide. You said the funding for one of these projects was coming out of discretionary funds? Yeah, actually, a majority of these projects come out of discretionary funds, and they come out of our million-dollar pot of money that we've received for emplainments.
2:18:49 Pretty much everything you see here is fully funded by the FAA. Got it. Okay. So no one should make the mistake of assuming when you say discretionary funds, it's not general fund. Yeah. Thank you for that. Yeah. So when I say discretionary funds, when I'm talking about airport, I'm talking about FAA funding. Got it. So federal funding. Yeah. Thank you, Hayes. So some of these are a little bit shorter. So maybe I'll tackle a couple of them at a time.
2:19:18 General facilities, just recently, Town Council in August set aside $175,000 to make some improvements to Town Hall. That includes Suite Z in the town offices. They're a little bit shabby, so we'll put some new carpet and some paint and spruce up the places, fix some air conditioning and things like that. We'll also provide some ADA improvements that are needed. We are in construction on two lots down at Sierra Business Park.
2:19:48 These are storage lots that will be used to store bins from Mammoth Disposal, some town equipment, a lot of stuff that we have kicking about at Whitmore, really some much needed space. This is required construction in conformance with the HOA, so vertically walls, chain link fencing, gates and so forth. This project's well underway, should be finished within the next few weeks and then we'll be moving in and cleaning up some of our other sites.
2:20:20 This is a general placeholder. The town sets aside $25,000 a year for improvements to keep the town ADA compliant and address deficiencies. Sierra Schultz is our ADA coordinator. She maintains a database of known ADA deficiencies, and we systematically tackle those through sidewalk projects, in-house projects around town hall, some of our facilities, and we...
2:20:47 have kind of a dedicated funding source to continuously make improvements. We have land acquisition on here. We don't have a schedule for this and we don't have funding for this, but this is something myself and the town manager and a few others are actively pursuing. The snow pit primarily is an incredibly important piece of infrastructure for the town. We would like to have that under town control one for
2:21:16 It would save the taxpayers a significant amount of money if we had control over it, and we'd be able to operate it in a better fashion. So while we don't have a schedule or funding for it, it's something that's very high on our list. Along the same vein is there's some small parcels. There's a process with which the Forest Service can sell small disconnected parcels of land to the town.
2:21:43 This is something else we have not identified a schedule for or funding, but something we're actively pursuing. This would include the parcel next to the community center, south of Mammoth Creek Park and Mammoth Park East. Another general facility project is the fuel island replacement. Our fuel island down at the town corporate yard has exceeded its useful life and is prone to significant problems.
2:22:13 Having fuel for loaders and blowers and equipment is critical. So we're in the process of designing a new facility. We have a consultant working on that. We haven't identified all of the funding, but we do anticipate getting to work on the construction during summer of 2022 in order to address these deficiencies and to ensure that we have the fuel needed for our equipment year-round.
2:22:40 A project Dan has been working on for a number of years, the development of biomass facility. He's looking at a number of sites to potentially convert feedstock such as manures and solid waste slash sludge and so forth into a commercially viable product. This will help with our diversions and with Benton Crossing landfill, we need opportunities to divert our waste. Some work was done under a wood innovations grant to do some pre-development.
2:23:09 However, we have not identified any funding to complete the construction of this project. Communication system, you've probably heard a lot of talk between the town and county about improving our communication system. Our system is 30 years old, and it turns out technology has improved quite a bit in the last 30 years. We have had consultants look through a number of different opportunities and trying to determine what is the most viable option. While we're doing that, the town is setting aside money.
2:23:39 To support this effort, right now we've put aside $1 million, and we're looking to put another $300,000 into the project, excuse me, into the bucket next year, and we'll be ready to provide funding once a preferred alternative has been determined. Last, whoops, out of the general facilities is the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center.
2:24:06 You guys have seen this project come before you in a couple of different iterations, I believe. The town is looking to partner with Mammoth Lakes Foundation on a 250 to 300 seat facility. We're working with HMC on a redesign. This is one of the renderings that's shown here in the picture and by no means means that this is the final. We're hoping to work through the design phase.
2:24:31 And target a 2023 groundbreaking. A lot of the funding is in place to move this project forward. And while that may seem optimistic, it is a possibility that we could be ready to start building this facility in the next couple of years. Town has committed funding through various sources, including design, and up to $2.5 million from construction. And we're pretty excited to be a partner on this project.
2:24:58 I'll stop there if you have any questions on the general facilities. Any questions, guys, for Hayes? No? So this, the MAC facility would be located adjacent to the foundation, the foundation's building. Is that correct, Hayes? That's correct. Got it. Okay. No, that's the only question I have, Hayes. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
2:25:29 You may have seen this project before, the Community Recreation Center, well underway, targeting a summer grand opening. Town Council recently at the CIP meeting on September 1st did indicate they were interested in putting more money into the interior spaces, so we're working with our partners on developing a menu of options to invest in. But yeah, we've beat this project to death over the years, so.
2:25:59 Moving on, parks, maintenance and improvements. This is a placeholder. So the town council sets aside a bucket of money on an annual basis for Stu and his team to work with the Recreation Commission to address deferred maintenance around town. They've accomplished a significant amount of work over the last couple of years using these funds. And so while there's no discrete project identified,
2:26:28 On an annual basis, Stu will look at his list of needs, work with the rec commission, and then come back to public works and tease out discrete projects. And once that happens, we actually will identify those projects in the CIP. So this is just a placeholder to kind of hold the money and kind of just make sure that we have a place for as a discussion item for these funding because it's always something we need more money for parks. Dog park.
2:26:54 In August, the town set aside $100,000 for the development of a dog park. We're currently working with the Forest Service to get permission to utilize Mammoth Creek Park East to develop an off-leash dog park. This is kind of a concept plan you see here. This is by no means the final design. We're looking to have some native areas, maybe some improved turf areas, a small dog, a large dog. There are restrooms in the area.
2:27:24 You know, benches, water, water fountains, so forth. So we're going to work on that this summer, excuse me, this winter, and hopefully bring this project to fruition next summer. This is a longer term project. The Whitmore Park improvements have been on the books for a long time, and we're currently working to acquire some grant funding to advance kind of a field house, locker room space, working with Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
2:27:55 And the track club on bringing this forward and really finishing up the Whitmore Park improvements. Along with the field house would include some outdoor fitness equipment, signage, improvements to the parking lot and a new multi-use trail. And a pump track. We've been talking about this one for a while. Trying to find a good place to put a bicycle facility and improved pump track. We've talked about this.
2:28:24 Maybe on the bell-shaped parcel or as a complimentary facility to the CRC. We've got a placeholder. We're going to be looking for some funding next year that hasn't been, that's unallocated on that $100,000 to get this project off the ground to really support, you know, cycling in town. And as a cyclist, I'm pretty excited about this project. That's the Parks and Recs projects we've identified. Happy to answer any questions about.
2:28:55 Any questions for Hayes, guys? Everyone's good? Hey, Hayes, is the CRC currently on schedule? Yes. Yes and no. We're going to be pouring the slab in October. We'll be taking possession of the sprung structure in March. So that's later than we had hoped, but it's going to still work out to be about the same timelines with an opening next summer.
2:29:28 Got it. And the dog park, would you mind just bouncing back to that slide really quick? So just by looking at the map, I'm assuming it's just off that gravel road that runs parallel with Mammoth Creek? That's the idea is to utilize some of the existing infrastructure out there. There is a road, there's opportunity for parking spaces, there's water out there, there's an existing restroom. So by leveraging those opportunities, we're able to decrease the
2:29:58 The cost and bring this to fruition a little quicker. So would you guys be encouraging people to park across the street at the CRC and then take the tunnel, the bike path tunnel under Old Mammoth Road to get there? No, we're actually envisioning providing expanded parking right next to the dog park. Okay. And this is still very conceptual. We're still looking to get the final approvals. I get it. I totally get it. We're hoping to have a turnkey facility for dog owners. Got it.
2:30:28 And this is land that the town owns? This is Forest Service land. So we're in the process. We've submitted a request to use this, and we're kind of meandering through that process right now to get a use permit to develop this site. But everything so far has been very encouraging with them. Got it. And there was a couple of times you referenced a few different projects in this section of the presentation.
2:30:54 Where the town manager was actively in conversations with the Forest Service, including this one, including that parcel next to the community center. That's correct. In these types of transactions, do we actually pay the Forest Service hard cash for the land or like what is the transaction? Yeah, so there's a number of different processes and I'm sorry if I'm confusing the issue. So something like the dog park would be a use permit and we would pay a very nominal fee for the use of the site.
2:31:25 Something like the snow pit, we have kind of a special agreement where we provide, we spend town money on forest service land to support like the recreation, the bathroom cleaning that's supported. Instead of sending the money to Washington, we have a special agreement there. Something where we would be doing acquisition, like purchasing the snow pit, there's a limited number of processes you can go through. We would probably end up paying,
2:31:55 Very close to fair market value for the land, for ownership and fee. So there's a number of different ways use of the forest can play out. Got it. Okay. Thank you, Hayes. Yeah. I have one question, if I can, Michael. Please. Hayes, is there any talk, I don't know if you know about this, if you're, you know, on the inside of these talks about the dog park, but...
2:32:21 I'm just thinking about our current state with the Forest Service closed and that that may be, hopefully not, but maybe our new forever and wondering if in the use permit there could be some aspect of that being exempt. Has that been discussed at all or will that be? It will and it kind of has. So the town was able to exempt all of our Forest Service facilities. So all of our mops, Shady Res Park, all of our...
2:32:49 Critical infrastructure was all exempted. We did have to submit a request, but this would fall under that same kind of category that if we had constructed this facility prior to the closure, we would just exempt it. We would ask for an exemption. And the Forest Service under these circumstances was very accommodating and helped us to provide recreation amenities within town.
2:33:13 That's awesome. I had no idea that those areas were even open. So that's news to me. Thank you, Hayes. That's crazy. When you live in the world of AYSO, you live and die on that exemption. Yeah. I recommend anybody out there who's listening who isn't getting notification through Stu's News, if you will, definitely get in touch because he pushes out great information all the time on what's available, what's open and so forth. So Stu.
2:33:42 I would definitely get in touch with them to make sure you're in the know. Good question, though, Commissioner Kennedy. Hey, Hayes, that exemption, was that issued locally by a Forest Service personnel or was that issued more on a California-wide level? I understand it was specific to us, but who gave us the green light? It was the local ranger station. We submitted a letter with a background of all of our permits requesting an exemption and they granted.
2:34:11 All of our, like I said, all of our recreation facilities and all of our critical infrastructure. Thank you. So I'm going to do a couple at a time, like I mentioned. So storm drain construction, we had applied for a $600,000 grant to do some pretty serious storm drain design work. Unfortunately, we were not successful in that. This is still a placeholder. We don't have a schedule. But we've identified really where our issues are.
2:34:42 for storm drains, and it's all around John Muir and Davison. So doing some design work really puts us in a place to advance these projects to construction. There is a good amount of money out there, but it usually requires a 50% match and the design work to be done. So this is trying to find a path forward to get this pretty significant design work on the shelf so that we can be eligible for construction funding down the road.
2:35:12 So we have our streetscape. We have two projects here. The first is the Old Mammoth Road beautification project. This was intended to go in last year, but COVID happened. And so out of respect to the business owners, we didn't want to spend their...
2:35:31 Assessment District money on beautification when we may have needed it to better support the businesses. So we've had this project on hold and it looks like we're coming out okay. So we're going to advance this project 22-23. This is a healthy amount of work on doing some paving, irrigation work, tons of planting, new planters that will be placed every spring. It's going to do quite a bit.
2:35:57 Spruce up the place. It's about an $800,000 project. Along the same vein is Main Street landscaping. After we spent almost $8 million on sidewalks and infrastructure along Main Street, we put together a plan to put some shrubs, flowers, and so forth out there. But again, COVID got in the way. We put the project on hold. Again, this is one we're looking to advance next year to beautify.
2:36:27 Main Street and really complete that promenade package and complement all that infrastructure we put in. We have a placeholder for $25,000 in trail and municipal signage updates. As we continue to develop the system, as we make changes around town, we have funding set aside to make changes to the maps.
2:36:54 And winter animations and decorations, this was again a pre-COVID, we approved the snowflakes that were put up in the wintertime. That was a pilot project and we had originally set aside money to buy more snowflakes and advance into other parts of town and have them in more places. Again, put on hold, this is again a project we'd like to bring back. We thought it was pretty successful, looked pretty good around town.
2:37:21 And so while we don't have much money set aside for new snowflakes this year, just putting the old ones back up, we're proposing funding and expansion of the program in 22-23. Before I go on to streets, any questions on beautification and storm drains? Any questions, guys? Hey, Hayes, the snowflake project, does that also include the electrification of the poles? I know a couple of them.
2:37:54 That was an issue with some of the polls weren't hot. All of the polls are hot, but not all of them have accessible outlets. So some of them do. And there's a story behind that, but that's for another day. But that's part of this project as well. Yeah, as necessary, we would have to put the infrastructure in to support this. Got it. Thank you, Hayes. All right. We're getting there, guys.
2:38:24 Streets and Mutt Project. So in front of you is the 2021 project, $2.7 million in STIP funding. We're kicking that off right now. All the pink lines represent areas that we're doing reconstruction or rehabilitation. Streets, we've got Monterey Pines, Majestic Pines, Red Fur, Mountain Boulevard, and Commerce Circle. And then we're completely reconstructing the Mutt from
2:38:52 That goes along the schools from Sierra Park, kind of down around to the skate park and then back around to the RV park and a couple of segments that kind of connect that to Mammoth Creek Park and then a couple other little spurs here and there. This is some much needed work in our MUP system and this work will continue until the weather shuts us down and hopefully we get it done and we're always fighting for the asphalt.
2:39:21 And so scheduling has been a challenge, but doesn't get done this season or get done next, which leads us into next year's project. And again, this is a placeholder where we put aside, you know, $580,000. And every year we kind of do an analysis using our Street Saver system to look at what streets need the most work. And then we'll spot check that with the road department, make sure we're putting the money where it's needed.
2:39:50 We do a road assessment every couple years where we go through every single MUP and street in town and use a specified process for identifying the condition of the road and then load that into a database. And then we run a number of scenarios and the system uses a complex system of algorithms to kind of kick out what our best use of the money is. And that's how we determine which roads.
2:40:15 Since we did have some savings out of this year, we're looking at a pretty healthy project going into next year, which is not reflected in the budget here, but we could be tackling another one to $1.5 million project going into next year. Along the same ideas, SB1, we get an annual appropriation from the state of about $160,000. We can backspend that or forward spend it. We've used the money so far to complete two segments in curb and gutter repair on Meridian.
2:40:45 And we did use some of the money, some SB1 money to support the Lake Mary sidewalk project by the brewery. We're gearing up to do a third segment of Meridian Boulevard, which will kind of close the gap between the two, and you'll see that as a specific project. That's why you don't see any funding in 21-22 or 22-23, because we are allocating those years to this other project. So again, this is a placeholder for
2:41:14 Money we know is coming, but we haven't identified a project for. We do go through a process every year where the Town Council adopts by resolution the project list, and we submit that to the state. And here's the project I was alluding to. This is the SB1 third phase meridian curb and gutter replacement between Lodestar and Sierra Star Parkway, and this will take care of all the nasty curb and gutter, patch in the asphalt as needed.
2:41:43 This turned out to be at about a $444,000 project, and we're looking to advance that next summer. Also next summer, we'll be doing some slurry seal work up in the bluffs as part of their assessment district. That neighborhood pays into their own maintenance, and then we just maintain and provide the conduit for bidding the projects and ensuring that the maintenance is done. A future project in the same area as a fog seal,
2:42:16 We had to kind of have a maintenance program for the asphalt from fog seals, slurry seals, and then reconstruction. So these are just hitting those milestones. And so 10,000 sitting out in 25, 26, we'll take care of that fog seal. Any questions on street projects? Any questions, guys? Okay, we're deep into the yeses, so we're getting close.
2:42:46 Sidewalks. This is kind of a big project. So Laurel Mountain Sidewalk, Stormgrain Streetlights and Complete Streets. This is a $1.685 million project. We've got $120,000 allocated in funding that will become available to us through the State Transportation Improvement Program System in October. And then we're going to jump right on the design with an intent to construct this next summer.
2:43:13 And this project is going to be supporting the parcel, so an important piece of infrastructure. The intent here is to design all of Laurel Mountain from Sierra Nevada to Main Street, incorporating the HSIP project, which I'll talk about in a little bit, all the recent work we did on Main Street, and then the incorporation of these conditions of approval that come from the parcel, tying it all together.
2:43:39 There's also a future project by Old Mammoth Place that will hopefully come forward soon and provide the funding to complete the sidewalk along their frontage. And if everything comes together nicely in the next two years, we'll have a complete sidewalk on Laurel Mountain Road. That was sidewalk. I'm going to do the trails. So we also have set aside $250,000, again, through the State Transportation Improvement Program.
2:44:10 to support the design of a MUP from Minaret along the entire length of Minaret Road, which we just refer to as the Minaret MUP. And this will connect the Lake Spacing Trail to the old Mammoth MUP. Right now, we only have identified money for design, but we're actively looking for money for construction. There are funds available in outlying years through the State Transportation Improvement Program.
2:44:39 But we'd like to get this project done sooner, so we're looking for other opportunities. We've already authorized the survey work to start, and we'll be designing this over the winter, and hopefully some of that infrastructure money that the federal government is working on will trickle down into the locals, and we'll be able to capitalize on it and bring this project forward. And it's the same exact story with the Main Street Southside MUP. We have $250,000 in design.
2:45:09 Now, this is an oversight project with Caltrans. We're going through a little bit different process. Funding will not be available to us to start the design work until late winter, maybe even early spring because we have to follow a different process working on the Caltrans right away. But it's the same concept. We're working to get the project shovel ready, finish the environmental work, finish the design work, and if infrastructure money becomes available, we'll be ready to capitalize on it.
2:45:39 Another project we've discussed and have advanced to a certain level of design is the Sherwin Trailhead. We spent some money a couple years back to do some preliminary design work and we're just currently looking for the funding to complete the project. We've done some minor asphalt work here to kind of, you know, clean up the place a little bit, but the design would include improved parking, restrooms, ADA, accessible bathroom and so forth.
2:46:07 We've got a $250,000 placeholder out in the future year, and that project is currently unfunded. Joel is actively working on these Lakes Basin Connector Trails. This is some coming out of his Trails Program Fund Balance, and these blue lines represent all the work he's doing out there. We're excited to see that moving forward. The Sherwin Area Trails.
2:46:35 The design and development of trails is ongoing under existing work programs. We don't have an anticipated construction timeline, but it would be funded by the trails program. It includes 1.7 of new multi-use, a number of non-motorized trails, and decommission of some user trails.
2:47:01 Pretty great project, and there's a link in the CIP to what's going on with that project if you want more information. Same story with the Shady Rest and your craters. Again, this is another partnership project where we're using some OHV money to advance, you know, OHV user opportunities in the Shady Rest and craters subregion. Any questions on those before I move on to transit? Any questions, guys? I know I'm moving pretty quick.
2:47:35 No, that's fine. It's fine. I appreciate you respecting everyone's time. Did you say that Joel is actively working on the Lake Space and Trail? Like physically his team is up there now? Yep. They're working on this stuff now. So they got an exemption as well from the foresters? Yeah. Pretty much everything we had going on was exempted except the use of chainsaws. Got it. Thank you. Yep.
2:48:04 We've been working towards demolishing the two existing transit shelters on Main Street for the entire summer. And just this morning, I got word that SCE is going to de-energize the stations, the transit facilities, so that we can demolish them in the next couple of weeks. So we have everything in place, contract in place, Caltrans approval. It's just a matter of getting some of these.
2:48:32 Things worked out with some of our partners. But this project is moving forward. It's fully funded. And by this winter, we will have two new transit stops on Main Street. We're also working to reconstruct the transit shelter right out front here by Carl's Jr. We're working on a design. We're also talking to some of the other landowners about making an improvement. This bus stop.
2:48:59 This transit shelter snares its stop with a right-turn pocket in the Carl's Jr. drive-through exit, so there's a lot of conflict in this area, so we'd like to relocate this to its own, so it has its own turnout and it's not shared. We're looking to advance this project next summer. It is fully funded by the Transit Reserve Fund.
2:49:23 So you just would relocate that bus shelter somewhere along Old Mammoth Road? Yeah, just down the street would be our intent. There's some work that needs to be done with some property owners, and that's ongoing. And it's an ongoing conversation with our current landlord, which is the property owner of where this shelter is located. The intelligent transportation system, this is something that Public Works has kind of felt would...
2:49:54 be an incredible improvement to our transit system. And we have our Mobility Hub consultant working on some information related to this. It's a comment we've heard regularly and something that's become more and more apparent is that we need to provide better real-time transit information, not only by app, but in the transit shelter itself. And that would include having GPS information on the buses and
2:50:23 So we know exactly where they're at. So that's a project we're looking into right now. And it's kind of evaluating some different applications. And hopefully we'll come up with a preferred alternative and be able to advance this project. We have identified funding through the Rural Planning Assistance and Program Planning and Monitoring funds allocated by the Local Transportation Commission to move the Mobility Master Plan forward.
2:50:52 The goal here is to consolidate all of our existing mobility plans into a single updated document that will help us to prioritize our list of needs and identify strategic and priority goals. And it's in the existing Local Transportation Commission overall work program. We have a placeholder, no funding, no schedule, but just to address village parking and pedestrian improvements, we are...
2:51:23 No strangers to the needs of the village, both from on the ped side and on the parking side, and we're actively working to find opportunities to address them, and this is a placeholder, so once we find some priorities or an opportunity, we can allocate funding to the project. The town was awarded a Highway Safety Improvement Program grant to provide improvements to our crosswalks on Main Street.
2:51:52 The project will fund basically a rehabilitation of the two crosswalks that are existing, replacing the old beacons with the extremely obnoxious rapid flash beacons and some additional advance warnings so there'll be signs in front of the signs to let people know they're in the crosswalk. And then we're getting a whole new crosswalk at Mountain Boulevard. So that whole crosswalk, excuse me, that whole intersection will be reconfigured.
2:52:22 from a ped and crosswalk standpoint. We have design money now and we'll be working with our partners to design the project and we'll be constructing next summer. And that blank page means we are done. So thank you for bearing with me through all those projects. Hope that was informative. Let me know if you have any more questions.
2:52:49 And, you know, moving forward the process for the commission if you have, you know,
2:53:19 Projects you believe should be moved in, the staff will take that into consideration. I'm not going to immediately put that into a project in the CIP, but what I will do is part of my presentation to Town Council is say it was recommended that certain things be advanced or certain things be included. So I don't want you to feel like this is just I'm telling you what we're doing and we're moving forward. There is a process in which the Planning Commission can provide comment.
2:53:47 on what you believe should be moving forward, and then I will shepherd that information to town council. So with that, I'll stop sharing my screen. Any questions for Hayes, guys? I've just, I've got a, you teed up my next comment perfectly, Hayes. Future event site. I think that probably is worthy of attention. I agree with you. And then my other comment would just be,
2:54:22 Very grateful that you guys are improving the crosswalk situation on Main Street. It's a miracle somebody hasn't been creamed trying to cross that street with the speed people come down from the village and the lakes basin. I mean, it really is surprising. Yeah, unfortunately, we did have a fatality. When we did our research for the grant, we did have to report on that. And I don't know if that was the catalyst to get the grant, but...
2:54:50 You know, it's pretty alarming what happens up there. And so we were really, really excited to receive that funding to make these improvements, which are desperately needed. Yeah. Anything else, guys, or should we let Hayes go? He's got 10 minutes to close out his work day. You're letting me off early? Thanks. Thanks, Hayes. We appreciate it. Thanks, all. And we've already tackled our public hearing, guys. So now we're going to go to our business matter.
2:55:21 Unfortunately, Commissioner Burroughs had to jump off the call. We still have three of us here, so we can make a decision. Sandra, do you want to leave this to you? Perhaps you can take it from here. Sure, just a brief agenda item. For the Commission October meeting, we have a project that was just submitted recently, and we were trying to get it to Planning Commission in October.
2:55:49 We were looking to possibly push that October meeting later in the month if that would work for the commission. So I just wanted to see if that would be a possibility. We had suggested the date of Wednesday, October 27th at 2 for the commission, but I wanted to pull up the idea with the planning commission and see if it would work for your schedule. It would work. Let me say I will make it work irregardless, Sandra.
2:56:21 On my side. That works great for me. Okay. So I see three thumbs up and I, we did speak with Commissioner Burroughs yesterday who said that she would check her schedule, but she thought she could make it work. So with that, I don't think you need to make a motion to change the date or anything along those lines. We'll just cancel the October 13th meeting and Jamie, would it be just a rescheduled regular meeting or what? Yeah.
2:56:48 So we'll just reschedule the regular October meeting for Wednesday, October 27th at 2. And I'll go ahead and send out a meeting invite so that you all have that on your calendar so that, yeah, so you all have it on your calendar. Perfect. All right, to the consent agenda. Can I get, Jamie, can we just do three thumbs up to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 11th, 2021, or does it have to be a formal vote? Three thumbs up will work for me.
2:57:20 Awesome. Minutes approved. You guys good skipping commissioner reports today? Kind of run a little lengthy and I want to give Sandra some time for her director's report. Thanks guys. Appreciate it. It's all yours, Sandra. Thank you. I don't have a very lengthy director's report. A couple of items though. Your November meeting, we are working to schedule some joint meetings with the town council. I did send an email out to the commission just giving you a heads up.
2:57:50 The Town Council would like to meet with their various commissions and our NGOs more often. So we're looking for the November Planning Commission meeting, which would be your regularly scheduled meeting date, which I think is November 13th. It would be a joint meeting with the Town Council and looking to discuss some mobility issues, mobility projects, the mobility of study, some other mobility work that we're doing.
2:58:17 Just kind of put that out there so that you have that the November meeting will likely be a joint meeting with the town council. And then as we just decided our October meeting will be rescheduled. A couple other items, I did mention the parcels, so that's moving forward. It's exciting to see that project go forward. A lot of work has gone into it. We'll likely do a groundbreaking ceremony later in the year. We'll try to...
2:58:46 Schedule that when there's no actual construction kind of going on. And then a side note, just I'm working with Mammoth Mountain, actually it's Mammoth Main Lodge Redevelopment Group to bring forward the application for the main lodge redevelopment. We did start the environmental analysis, which can occur kind of before they submit their formal application, but I would expect that project to be submitted here in the next couple of months.
2:59:16 As I think you're aware, it's a pretty big project. It would be a new specific plan. It would be all of the environmental analysis for the project, a general plan amendment. So kind of a really big, complex project. But so once it's submitted, we plan on coming to the commission and the council just to give you an update, let you know that it's been submitted, and really talk about process, not really dig into the details of the project, but just talk about process, how this will move forward.
2:59:45 It is a little bit more complicated because we have the Forest Service as well. So the final environmental document will be a joint document with the Forest Service. So there's a lot of agencies involved, a lot of different processes that are involved. So we will come forward and bring that to you all when it's submitted. But like I said, probably a couple months from now.
3:00:08 And then Hayes mentioned it during his CIP presentation, but town staff's working on developing a site plan for the property that we purchased at 60 Joaquin. And so that we're looking for five or six units there. We're trying to see how many we can fit on there reasonably. And that will come before the planning commission as a design review project. So with that, I don't have any other items. I'm happy to answer any questions that anyone has though.
3:00:38 I actually have two requests, if you wouldn't mind, Sandra. So there's a rumor going around that there is a toxic algae bloom in Crowley Lake and people are being warned not to ingest the water, don't let your pet drink it. Would it be possible to get an update from LADWP or whatever would be the appropriate agency on that? Yes, I can reach out. I've heard that as well.
3:01:05 Yeah, I can reach out. I can send the information that I have on that because I know I've seen emails about it and I don't know what the appropriate agency is that regulates that but yeah, I'll follow up on that. Maybe fish and game. Those are just guesses off the top of my head. Yeah, yeah. And at a future meeting, commission meeting at some point, I would love to have an update on the Mammoth Donut Project and how that's going. Sure. I will ask Janet Hatfield.
3:01:35 to come back and speak on that. Maybe that's an appropriate item for the November meeting when you're with the town council so she can provide an update to both groups. So I'll follow up. Okay. Any other questions for Sandra guys? You guys good? All right. Well, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting and our next regularly scheduled meeting we just decided is going to be on October 27th, 2021.
3:02:05 You guys, I appreciate your time, what you guys do on a staff and a volunteer level.