Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findings- In 2021 the Council approved the Master Plan, the sale to Pacific West Communities and the development agreement, which capped units at 450 The Parcel
- Before Phase 1 was built, the Town set aside $1 million and designated excess tourism tax revenue for the project, then allocated $1.2 million for infrastructure The Parcel
Transcript
544 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:15 I like your background. Yeah, is that too much? No, it's nice. Okay, I'll keep it. How are you feeling? Fine. Been feeling fine. Just minor allergy type symptoms, but I can't go anywhere, which is fine. Your antigen, Tessa? I just did another one at lunch. You still? Yeah, it takes time to clear it, I guess.
0:47 I've heard a couple people like that. I had a friend over in the Bay Area who was the same thing. And she hadn't had symptoms for like six days and it still popped negative. Yeah. Yeah. It took a while. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Hopefully we're turning the corner on this whole thing now. So. You and everybody else. I know. Okay. We have Kirk. Kirk's all bundled up. Kirk.
2:32 Good afternoon. Hello. Good afternoon, John. Good afternoon, Sandra. How are you? I'm well. I wish I was where Linda was. I wish I was actually too right now. Not exactly here, is it? Uh-uh. But that's right outside your house, right? Okay. Here we have Bill. There he is. Hi, Bill. Good afternoon, children. Okay. So everybody's here. Okay.
3:48 All right, let's get started. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Wednesday, January 19, 2022 meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. Let's begin with the call to order, which we've done, and roll call, Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Salzer? Here. Councilmember Salzer? Here. Councilmember Salzer? Yes, I'm here also. Staff? Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes, present. Mayor Salcido? Here.
4:21 Okay. Thanks, everybody. Rob, could you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance today? I can. Join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay. Thank you very much, Rob.
4:47 All right. This is the time that we will accept public comments on any topics not already on the agenda for this evening. Would anyone like to speak in public comments? Jamie, anybody there? No, there's nobody for public comments. Okay. All right. Additions to the agenda. Madam Mayor, I'd like to, if I could say something. Yes, please. Yeah, I'd like to...
5:12 Offer my some contrite words and apology to all the folks of the staff and whoever helped out with the motorist assist program over the holidays. I jumped ahead of myself and started talking about a naming convention for the program without sharing my sincere and enthusiastic support and encouragement for all the folks who helped with all that heavy lifting, nasty, dirty, intense.
5:38 Public Relations type work in the field under incredibly arduous conditions. And I just want to apologize for that oversight. Encourage you all, everybody to keep doing that kind of work. It's the work that we all do. So I just wanted to get those comments out there. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. I think we should have a patch for that that goes on your town apparel there to say I served or something. I don't know. Motorist assist. Motorist assist program. Okay.
6:08 All right, reports from commissions and or departments. Who would like to speak this afternoon? Sandra? Thank you, Madam Mayor. I just have a brief update with the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last week, and they did approve a five-year, I apologize, for some reason my camera's not working, but they did approve a five-year time extension request for the Sierra Center Mall project, so that extends that out for five years.
6:42 And the next planning commission meeting is February 9th, 2022. And that was all I had. Thank you. Okay. Thanks, Sandra. Anybody else? No? Jamie, anybody you can see? No? Okay. That'll do it for reports of commissions and departments. Madam Mayor? Yes. If I could, I'd just like to highlight one element. Again, it's back to our public works work this past week.
7:19 I don't think we've had a council meeting since then, but we'd had requests on removing a bunch of snow off of Canyon Boulevard and off the sidewalk going up Canyon. So crews got together, worked through some timing to get up there, some equipment, and I can't remember if it was one or two nights worth of work. One night worth of work. Ended up hauling, I think, 70 truckloads of snow out of that area and getting that cleaned up very well. I think it worked out well with the warmer weather, probably melting off the sidewalk a little better.
7:48 Otherwise it gets pretty icy. And then just get a little safety on walking up and down Canyon Boulevard. But also just a reminder is we have large storms. That sidewalk was built and designed to be used for snow storage. And so as it gets into that, it goes there once we can no longer maintain that opening of it. And it's an after the fact going back in and doing some cleaning work.
8:13 And also we got kind of some final agreements from Caltrans for ongoing work with them on our Frontage Roads in 203 and still working some of that coordination effort and the cleanup of that area is ongoing as well. So I'm hoping we're looking forward to some other good storms still before the winter's out. So as we get those pieces up and going and just provide that information, where we do snow store, store, snow.
8:43 And then coming back and doing that cleanup after the fact and those elements either with our crews and or with contract crews. The other shout out to the town crews was the stepping up and helping Caltrans actually get 203 cleared. We did a couple of nights, I believe we had our blower crews out there putting stone in the back of their trucks to be hauled. So ongoing work in that and ongoing coordination with other partners in that effort as well.
9:12 Thanks. No, thank you, Dan, for reminding that. We got that email with a video on it of clearing the sidewalk. I think Warren had sent that. It was amazing. And I was going to ask, Stu, did we put that up on social media, that video, that little video? We did. Thank you, Mayor, for bringing that up, Madam Mayor. I was just actually looking at our Facebook reach and engagement, and that was easily the most popular post last week. So I do want to thank Warren for putting that together.
9:41 It was a great demonstration of, you know, as Dan said, all the hard work that the crews put in. And I did want to add as well that we were able to secure an additional trackless machine. I believe we shared that on our town Facebook post last week as well. And that one is a unique machine. The blower head's a little bit larger. So we're able to use that on the town multi-use parts. And we actually put a photo of that driving down the, I think it was the Mammoth RV to Commons Drive.
10:11 Pretty much buried under a lot of snow. So that is a wonderful addition to the fleet. So again, just want to bring that to community's attention and appreciate council's support for all our work. Thank you. Yes, thank you. And now we'll just wait for the next large something to come. Doesn't look like it's right yet, but fingers crossed. Thank you.
10:33 Okay. All right. Council presentations. We have 6.1, which is recognition of retiring public works maintenance worker, Scott Meredith. And who's going to talk us through this? Is that Todd, maybe? Hi, Todd. Hello, everybody. Todd Murphy, Public Works Department. Just here to say a little tidbit about Scott Meredith. Anyway, Scott.
11:02 He's one of our Public Works employees who recently chose to retire after over 20 years of service here with the town of Mammoth Lakes. He worked for the Public Works Department starting back in 1996 as a seasonal worker and became a full-time employee in 1999. Scott is one of the best snow removal blade operators the town has had over the years. He has trained most of the current loader operators we have.
11:30 Congrats, Scott, on future endeavors, and it was a pleasure working with you for 20 years plus. Congratulations, Scott, that's great. Yeah, thank you very much. Okay, that's great. Thank you, everyone. Short and sweet is town's been very good to me, so thank you, and I hope I did a good job for them for, you know, the 23 or 24, whatever, how many years it's been.
13:04 Made some friends. No enemies, which is always good. And on to take care of my family and some other responsibilities. Otherwise, I'd still be working. And here's to, you know, the next crew that comes in and keeps this town open so everybody can make a living. Thank you. Thank you for everything. Yeah, Madam Mayor, if I can add to that, since my tenure here, I've enjoyed working with Scott in a couple different areas.
13:35 One of those employees who has been engaged in a lot of our employee outreach, showing up at different events and talking to other employees and kind of, you know, breaking that whole element down as we work across departments. He's been in town offices doing painting and other repair work as well as moving snow and striping streets and cleaning culverts and you name it on the public works side, he's probably done it.
14:02 And then he is also engaged. He was one of the members of some of the employee negotiating team. I'm not sure if he got the short straw or he actually enjoyed it. But as he stepped into it, he did step in with, I think, a great attitude. He did enjoy it, speaking well on behalf of both the employees that he represented and also, I would say, the interest of the town overall as well. So I want to thank him for that effort and that work and that a lot of the stuff that he's done there, you know, that we don't.
14:32 Often recognized in these settings, but he's done a lot of other things in the town and the operations there in the 20 plus years he's served. And so my thank you to you, Scott. Very good. Thanks, Dan. Okay. That's great. Thanks, everybody. Okay. Now on to number seven, staff presentations, which is an update, a 7.1 update and discussion of the status of broadband in the town of Mammoth Lakes in Mono County.
15:03 Dan, you want to prep that a little bit? Yeah, thank you. A couple different times, Council has asked for some updates on broadband. I know it's been a discussion in the community and elements that we've been looking at, working both with infrastructure as well as providers. Kind of the leadership from the town county side has been Nate Greenberg. He's the county IT director, as well as by contract, the town's IT director as well.
15:33 Nate's been heavily engaged in this, both within the town as well as throughout Mono County. So he did a similar presentation a week or so ago for the Board of Supervisors, and we've asked him to do a similar presentation of kind of all things broadband, if you will, within our community with some of the legislative elements going on and other steps that are being made to enhance the level and quality of broadband in our communities.
15:58 With that, I just want to request that Nate dive into his presentation and as council have questions and stuff, they can raise your hand or get his attention to ask a question and then obviously at the end to have some discussion as well. So with that, I want to, I don't think he needs an introduction here, but Nate Greenberg with Mona County IT and also serving in the town's IT role as well. Thank you, Nate. Thanks, Dan.
16:27 I'm going to share my screen here and just verify that all of you can see that. Great. So thanks very much for the intro and, you know, just to kind of reiterate the purpose of the evening or this afternoon, I guess I should say, it's really to try to brief the council and the public to the extent that they're interested in sort of the state of affairs with regard to broadband, not
16:57 So much within our community that I will definitely apply a lot of what I'm going to talk about to the community. But largely, you know, as all of you have been seeing in local, state, national news, that there is a historic amount of legislation and a historic amount of funding being dedicated and allocated to broadband, you know, throughout the country. And certainly we've been getting a lot of questions, rightly so, around
17:23 What does this mean for us? How are we going to be tapping into this? You know, what exactly is the amount of money that we're going to be seeing, et cetera, et cetera. And so I had been putting this presentation off to the county board for quite a while because quite honestly, there was still just a lot of churn happening and not a lot of certainty around how rulemaking was going to come down with regard to some of the key pieces of legislation.
17:52 What the allocations were going to be, how it was going to be accessible. And some of that's a little more known, and I'll talk about this afternoon, and some of it's still a little bit volatile. And so consider this the first of several conversations, probably. And there's going to be, I think, a few things in here that are, you know, very high level that are valuable, but also some drill down on some specifics. And I think ultimately...
18:18 You know, as we get to kind of the back end of the presentation, what my goal is, is to kind of tee up some future policy conversations and thoughts that are likely to need to happen within the town just around, you know, how are we going to be accessing and how are we going to be sort of working to continue to invest in proliferate broadband in the community? So with that, you know, I just want to provide some basic background and make sure that everybody
18:45 knows some of the key fundamentals here, starting with Digital 395. And really, I think, as a lot of people do understand and know, this was a landmark infrastructure project, which happened in the Eastern Sierra, you know, really more or less along the whole 395 corridor that was completed in 2013. It was conceptualized around 2009. It took a couple of years to get through.
19:11 The design and the application and everything that happened to get it actually is an approved project. And then a ton of work went into environmental and route realignments and various other pieces of the project. It was built really over about 20 months, miraculously, extremely quickly. And the very first customers came online in early 2013. And when the network came online,
19:40 It dramatically changed the landscape for us as a region and specifically for the town of Mammoth Lakes because prior to that, there was very little backbone or backhaul coming into the community and the providers that were here at the time, Verizon offering DSL and NPG Cable, Suddenlink, which was offering a cable solution, were oversold. If you were a new customer,
20:10 If you just moved to town, you couldn't even get service, or, you know, there was a waiting list in order to get service. And if you got service, it was not great. It was, you know, generally at the best, eight megabits. Most of the people, sorry, the national average was eight megabits at the time, and most people in town were only getting one, one and a half megabits. A couple years after 395 was built,
20:36 What we saw is dramatic increase in capacity being offered to the region as a whole. And Suddenlink invested a tremendous amount of money into the Mammoth and June Lake markets and basically brought gig service here. And that ultimately was fairly landmark for them as well. We were one of their first gig markets. And since then, we've seen a number of other providers come into the Eastern Sierra.
21:05 Theoretically, overall, about 93% of the households in the county have access to gigabit service today. Now, we know that in town there's a number of issues, and we'll talk a little bit about that today, but this is something that is very, very unique as a region, and I say it up front because when a lot of these other communities throughout the country are talking about leveraging broadband money, they're talking about getting communities from one meg,
21:36 to 100 megs. They're talking about, you know, places that don't have service or have very, very, you know, challenging service issues, as opposed to communities that generally are served, you know, by definition, despite the fact that there may be issues with the quality of that service. So, you know, the network as a whole, you know, is
22:02 Very, very novel and landmark from the standpoint that it was designed as a hundred year landmark project. There's, you know, 600 plus miles of fiber that were built between Reno and Barstow. We're under utilizing that today, which is great and means that there's capacity and room for growth, which as we start talking about additional portions of the network being built out throughout the county and other parts of the region, we're not going to sort of
22:32 Over-stress that network as a whole. And just to prove that, you know, this last year, the operating entity behind Digital 385 invested a little over a million dollars in new electronics and basically added that to the Digital 395 network, which grew our opportunity to provide even more service across that existing fiber, as well as offer new products.
23:00 The other thing that I think is really important to remind folks about Digital 385 is it really was designed and built as a middle mile network. What that means is that unless you are a government education and medical facility or an internet service provider, so i.e. if you're a normal individual residential customer or a business customer, you cannot directly connect to Digital 385. So it's basically to be leveraged by
23:30 folks who are part of the cooperative and ultimately the service that is being delivered to those members is of what's called carrier grade. And so we as the town of Mammoth Lakes are a member of that cooperative. We leverage the network very heavily for our operations and it's really vital to us in terms of how we operate and function as an entity as a whole.
23:56 The other thing that's relatively novel about Digital 385 is the way that the cooperative is run. It's a 501c12, not-for-profit telco. It has an 11-member board that the county has a seat on. I am currently the chair of that. And that makes it a very unique institution in terms of how sort of the network is operated and broadband as a whole is marketed and proliferated.
24:23 And it gives us some unique opportunities in terms of how we can leverage a lot of this legislation and funding associated with it coming into the state as a whole. And we'll be talking about that. So I mentioned that unless you're, you know, one of those government education and medical or service providers, you cannot directly access digital 395, but you are able to access digital 395 through a third party. And those third parties are often called internet service providers or last mile providers.
24:53 In the town of Mammoth Lakes, those really consist of Suddenlink or Frontier. Throughout the rest of the county, various other service providers exist. And basically, those service providers own networks from the backbone, from the Digital 385 network to your home, and are responsible for distributing and delivering service. They're leveraging the actual backbone of Digital 385 and the capacity that is there, but ultimately...
25:20 Delivering that to your home through their own networks. And that's who most of us as customers purchase our service from. So I recognize that when I say, you know, 95-ish percent of the households in the county have access to gigabit, most of that does reside within the town of Mammoth Lakes. I think it's about 80% roughly. And I also recognize that
25:48 It's hard to say that without also recognizing that there are a number of challenges. And I think that we, you know, as a community have been feeling those. Certainly as council, you've heard a lot of those. And I know that Dan, myself, and Andy have spoken a number of times about some of these. And Andy, please feel free to hop in here as I kind of walk through some of the things that are going on. But I did just want to highlight that while I'm going to be talking mostly
26:15 This afternoon about some of the new legislation and opportunities that are coming. There are still work efforts happening actively to address some of the sudden challenges that we're dealing with. And that said, I want to caveat it with that I think the council is generally aware that broadband is not a regulated utility, that the limited authority that we actually have is a very narrow franchise agreement.
26:44 That's really pertaining to the video service that's being offered to some customers within the community. And even within the constructs of that agreement, there's limited sort of capacity to regulate or otherwise hold suddenly accountable to service quality. Similarly, the CPUC has some authority over broadband, but it's really from the standpoint, again, of video and then also telephone, any voice over internet.
27:11 That is being offered by Suddenlink or any other broadband provider. Basically, there is some regulatory authority, but it's sort of through this edge. And so the challenge that that's created for us is, you know, how we sort of address the issues that are coming at us by Suddenlink's performance or lack thereof. And really what that's looked like most recently is a multi-agency collaboration that's sort of entitled the Rural Communities Coalition.
27:40 consists of Mammoth, Truckee, Mono, Inyo, Nevada, and Placer, and this group has been working together in sort of solidarity in conjunction with the CPUC to an extent, as well as in conversation with Suddenlink, and basically have been, you know, identifying and regularly talking about Suddenlink-related issues in all of our communities, whether them being unique or consistent.
28:07 And then this group also recently made a formal comment filing under General Order 133, and that was basically a rulemaking proceeding that opened up by the CPUC that was focused on minimum service quality standards for broadband that was serving voice over internet protocol phones. And so we're trying to leverage these different levers that we have to pull.
28:37 Albeit maybe not as large or significant as we would like to hold them accountable to the extent that we can. And this is just going to be something that is ongoing. I will kind of say it's thankless work. And Andy, I know, has been banging his head against this a bunch. And we're just going to keep having to sort of have those conversations and fight the fight, so to speak. So, Andy, I don't know if there's anything you want to add. But before I move on, I'll give you.
29:06 Space. One second. That was for you, which one I have to talk into. Yeah, I mean, as Nate said, broadband is a little bit of a regulatory black hole at the federal level. And federal telecommunications law obviously preempts state telecommunications law. And at the time this stuff was drafted, broadband just wasn't as much of an issue. So this is an issue nationwide. A lot of communities are dealing with.
29:33 Concerns about broadband and at the moment there's just not really a great clear way to regulate them but it's promising that the CPUC is now thinking about this and just today the counties and the towns received word from a senior CPUC staff member that he had sent a long list of questions and concerns to Suddenlink senior management looking for answers.
29:55 So we will continue to work on this as best we can. It's really encouraging and I think helpful that we're working with another town in four counties. Our voices are louder if we speak together and we will continue to work on this to the best of our ability. We've got some people helping us who really, really understand this area of law and the regulatory environment and we're hoping that we can get some traction. Nate, sorry, just maybe a quick question before you continue. D-I-V-C-A?
30:27 Sorry, Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act. It's a lot of words to mean video franchise. Is that state or federal? State. That's the state act from 2007 that took away cable franchising authority from cities and counties and gave it to the CPUC. Got it. Okay, that's a good one to know. And that's Trump by federal stuff, correct? It is.
30:53 We're hoping that the PUC will get interested in trying to regulate this. There are some questions about whether federal law gives them the authority to, but if we can get some momentum going, that might spawn conversations maybe at the congressional level about how best to regulate this. The PUC is by no means the only state agency that is interested in this. There have been reports of similar bodies in other states dealing with the same issues and trying to get answers from
31:21 Different broadband providers. So if we get enough momentum at the state level here and in other places, maybe we could get some momentum in Congress. Excellent. Thank you. And I thank you for the question, and Andy, thank you for that response. I mean, this is something I said to our board, the county board, last week as well, is we, the county, specifically Supervisor Peters,
31:47 And myself, we're really involved in the NACO Broadband Task Force and CSAC Broadband Task Forces. And I'm working closely with RCRC as part of a lot of work they're doing. And, you know, a consistent comment that we've made in all of those levels, the state and the federal level, and I think to the extent you could do so at the municipal level, is, I mean, look, there's landmark legislation, there's historic amounts of funding, but ultimately, at the end of the day, we're going to be building out things, unless they're municipally owned, that are still generally
32:17 Ran and operated as a commercial business in an unregulated environment. And so how do we sort of break the mold in order to not just sort of meet some of the goals of a lot of the legislation and funding, but do so in a sustainable fashion? And I think I do believe that we're several years away from this, but I think given everything that's happening, you know, there will be policy and legislative change that follows this that will start to.
32:45 Create more space for regulatory authority. But, you know, it's not going to happen overnight. They're big kind of big nasty problems to solve. And certainly, you know, the industry is going to push back in logical places. So, yeah, it's going to be a long fight ahead, I think. So on the more, I guess you could say proactive side, but now that I'm thinking about it, it's probably more reactive side.
33:15 Beyond sort of the things that I was just speaking of and Andy was speaking of that we're taking formally, just, you know, to remind council and the public that we did stand up this Suddenlink Escalation Portal. It's been up for, I believe, six months or more now. There's links to it from the town's website as well as the county's website. This is just a quick snapshot of kind of the information that's come into that portal as well as, you know, sort of the amount of time that it's taken.
33:44 to resolve these issues. And, you know, I think looking at the average time to resolve, it's like, ah, they're still taking three days to resolve billing issues on average. You know, you are seeing some things get resolved relatively quickly. And that is great because I think without this, you wouldn't see those minimums be as low as they are. And I have heard a couple of reports of folks that, you know, had submitted something into the system and literally by the end of the day, it was resolved, which
34:14 Is not the norm, I will say, but it is creating some form of a pressure relief valve that I think some people are taking advantage of and just want to encourage people to continue to do that because we're able to log this and this gives us more data to take to the CPUC and Suddenlink also. So kind of pivoting here and talking about some of the legislation and funding, you know, the really big one that's out there that immediately impacts really the county, but, you know, as an extension of the town.
34:44 is Senate Bill 156. It was passed into law middle of July of last year. It's still going through rulemaking. The county was, or sorry, actually is a formal party on a couple portions of that rulemaking. And there are really three big areas in this that directly impact or benefit us potentially.
35:10 The first is the middle mile investment, and there's about $6 billion in that fund or in that initiative that really is focused on building something that looks like Digital 385 throughout the entire state. And that in our area, we'll talk a little bit more about some of the impacts to the potential implications, but it is a really significant thing in other portions of the state where there are not opportunities like Digital 385 for providers to build off of.
35:39 Certainly that limits the ability to deliver, you know, high quality broadband. The second big sort of area of funding is in the targeted sort of at the last mile and it's known as the Federal Funding Account or FFA. And that allocates somewhere between six and 13 million to Mono County specifically for last mile projects. That still is going through rulemaking. The exact amount of money is TBD, but
36:09 Seems like it will probably be on the higher end of that. And exactly how that money will come down and how we'll be able to access it, redistribute it, et cetera, is still part of that whole rulemaking and proceeding that's happening as a whole. And then there is another $2 billion that is being put into the California Advanced Services Fund. That's the fund that the CPUC operates.
36:35 That was leveraged to build or to fund a portion of Digital 395's build, as well as the funding that Race Communications leveraged when they built out projects in a lot of other portions of Mono County. So beyond the money that's being allocated to that, the other good thing is that they have raised the standard for what is underserved and basically are finally agreeing to needing to have 100 megabits down and 20 megabits up.
37:04 And if a community or area does not have that, then you qualify for that funding. And so it doesn't really help the town directly, but it does benefit other portions of the county, and we'll be looking toward that in the future. In terms of county and town impacts with regard to 156, specifically the middle mile, part of the reason we wanted to become a formal party to the proceeding was we wanted to make sure that
37:34 Really, Digital 385 was left intact and it was leveraged as it was designed and built. I mean, as I said, it really does meet all of the sort of philosophical goals that the statewide middle mile network is aiming to achieve, being cooperatively held and managed, you know, a standardized rate structure, it's truly open access. And so we are working with the state entities to figure out how that integration looks.
38:03 Whether it's leasing fiber from us or it's purchasing service or what I think still needs to get worked out, but it's certainly in process. The conversations are underway. And one of the actions that the Board of Supervisors took last week was sent a formal letter to the state operator that's been named, which is CNIC, as well as the state CIO and a number of folks within the broadband group, the state and others just sort of asserting
38:33 A lot of the same things that I'm sort of talking to you about this afternoon. One of the other things that we did was with the middle mile allocation of money came a map that identified routes throughout the state that were likely to be built. And there was some strategic work done by us as that was being developed, you know, a couple of years ago. And, you know, the rough alignments of 395 were in there.
39:02 But ultimately, we know that they don't need to be built because they're already built. And so what we advocated for was to essentially re to not build those and to redistribute the money or a portion of the money that would go to build that into building some other middle mile legs as laterals off of the main network that would benefit and kind of extend into communities and other portions of the town that could be used as
39:30 Service to some of our other facilities or sites or jumping off points for other last mile builds. And so previously identified was Highway 203 to the county line up kind of up above the ski area. We advocated for that to remain. And then we actually said beyond that, please build all the way down into Reds Meadow. And we had talked, you know, that's been talked about at council level before, just the importance of trying to get something down in there for emergency communications and otherwise.
39:59 We advocated for a leg on Benton Crossing Road to be built out to the Whitmore facilities, as well as Lake Mary Road out to the Mammoth Community Water District facility up in the Lakes Basin. Those were all strategic with the goal of jumping off points for either communication sites or direct access to facilities or the extension of last mile services from those endpoints.
40:26 You know, we figure that roughly half of the route that would have been built under the way it was sort of in the legislation would need to be built, and we felt like that was a reasonable thing. Whether they grant it to us or not, we'll see. I touched on this. This is just a quick snapshot of what was in the rulemaking. Basically, you know, the Eastern Sierra corridor communities or counties, you know, their determination for
40:57 This allocation of last mile funding was a base allocation of 5 million and then an increment for the number of households. And then a definition of rural was determining how much of the pot was being distributed. And so that's where the 6.3 to $13.2 million number comes from. And I think part of the rulemaking is sort of debating which of these numbers, which of these three numbers to choose from effectively. So, you know, it just kind of shows you.
41:25 The amount of money that's potentially coming into the area for last mile builds in Yon Mono, at least. And then there's about 30 plus other programs out there right now. Tracking this has been a real, real mess. As part of being on the RCRC steering committee for their broadband program in JPA, I asked for this to be put together that basically
41:52 Is tracking all of the different programs and funding sources that are out there, how they can be used, where the limitations are, because ultimately what we're seeing is that it's going to be a combination of things that we're going to have to tap and leverage to get a lot of the goals that we have built. And, you know, certainly in town, there's some different challenges than in other portions of the county, but we're really hoping that if we're not successful, say, in getting that Reds Meadow,
42:21 Lake built under the middle mile allocation from SB 156 that we can tap one of these, you know, 30 other programs that are out there potentially to find some funding for some of that. And, you know, similar may be applicable now for some of the other things that we've talked about in town, like building out to the parcel and various things like that. All of this requires quite a bit of analysis. There's, you know, obviously huge
42:48 Dockets for each of these with proceeding materials, etc. But, you know, certainly opportunities do exist out there. So, kind of bringing it home in terms of considerations for you and us as a town as a whole, you know, really first and foremost, I think it is like, what are our involvement or what is our level of involvement going to look like with regard to broadband? You know, I think that
43:17 Past councils were maybe a little more passive, and I'm not saying that to be judgmental, but I think just in terms of having a provider and sort of knowing what we could do, the functioning of Sunlink was better a handful of years ago than it is today, and so the landscape's changed. And so to what extent do we want to be involved in broadband and what does that really look like from a policy and investment standpoint?
43:45 You know, how do we effectively invest and, you know, how much money do we need to invest? That's a critical question and I think something that is going to be hard to really drill down on. Proactively, I think we should start to really make sure that the development standards and subdivision and construction are basically being modeled after the ability to readily get fiber to those premises and that we're not kind of kneecapping ourselves in any way.
44:14 You know, I think talking about other providers in town is great, but to what extent we can get them, how a municipal versus a private provider would look and work, you know, is there funding, where are those resources, you know, to what extent can we have franchise agreements if other providers come in, and then, you know, what other incremental approaches really exist? You know, there's just a lot here to unpack. It's not a simple solution, and it's not an inexpensive one.
44:44 I'm kind of just laying these things out there, not with any real recommendations, but I think, you know, as openings to bigger conversations that need to ultimately happen. And so, you know, next step wise, I think really it's continuing to sort of keep the pressure on the existing providers, you know, continuing to do the work that Andy has been talking about with regard to Suddenlink and the CPUC. I will continue to track and I'm involved at the CSAC and NACO levels still.
45:13 And we'll be kind of keeping an eye on legislative and funding opportunities and, you know, providing comments when it's necessary. But I think ultimately, as a community, we should be trying to figure out what our objectives and priorities really are and how that sort of fits in. And then, you know, as sort of referenced to Councilmember Wentworth's question earlier, like, what are the leadership level of conversations and needs that are deserving of advocacy beyond
45:43 You know, this room, you know, at the higher levels, you know, municipal, state, et cetera, in terms of advocating around some of the issues and the opportunities that we have here. So, with that, I will stop sharing my screen and I'm happy to entertain questions if there are any. Thank you, Nate. That was a good presentation. At the back of your presentation, you have a copy of the...
46:11 The reply of the counties. Anything you wanted to kind of highlight on that at all? The letter that we, the reply comments? Right. I don't think so. You know, I think most of what we advocated for was, you know, what I articulated this afternoon. It's just, we, you know, we fundamentally believe that Digital 395 is working really well. It's being operated and managed well. It's certainly
46:41 Had challenges in its early inception, and those have been largely overcome, and so we want to see it be kept whole, and there is risk of cannibalization effectively offloading customers of CBCs to a state-run network impacts the stability potentially of that entity.
47:07 So, you know, I think those are the types of conversations that we're intending to really have at the state level, and they don't have an idea of how it's going to work yet either. And so I think we're just trying to at least initiate that and verbalize some of the things that we believe are necessary to really address as they figure out not just the interface with 395, but ultimately other networks in other parts of the state. All right, Nate. All right, let's start with some questions, comments.
47:37 Bill, can you ask any questions you may have? Yeah, not a lot of questions. More comments. It seems to me in rural communities like ours, as much as I don't want to as a government entity, eventually if we want high-end service, probably we'll have to establish something on our own. Nate, would you say that is in the offing down the road? Yeah, I think it's a really good question.
48:12 You know, it's interesting because, you know, I lived in town for a long time. I now live in Crowley. When I lived in town, you know, when Digital 395 came online, you know, Frontier leveraged it and had better service out of town than was in town and then suddenly confesseded and had a gig and was the best thing going. And I was really happy to be in town. And now I'm in Crowley and I've got race and I'm really happy to have race. And I think.
48:42 It really is depending on the provider. And I guess that the thing that we've recognized through the evolution of Suddenlink and the acquisition that happened with Altice is that it really also depends on who's kind of at the wheel. And I think that given the potential for volatility there, your comment is probably spot on. I believe that there is some middle ground and
49:08 In terms of how that looks and works. And incidentally, the sort of model that RCRC is really recommending and piloting actually in a few places throughout the state is effectively a public-private partnership, which it's municipally owned infrastructure in a sort of fixed lease model where a provider can operate on top of that municipally owned infrastructure.
49:36 Is required to deliver service in a very specific fashion and manner per agreement. And I think that it's actually a really smart model, especially in places where they're doing new build from scratch. And if that was sort of the goal and the direction of town in terms of sort of overbuilding in town and competing against Suddenlink, I think it would probably make sense to have it.
50:03 Be municipally held in some fashion, just so we have some oversight, but ultimately we don't have the capacity to operate something like that, right? So I think that there is sort of that middle ground. Yeah, my problem with the middle ground is as a business person, I hate to see the town as a business, because that's what we are, put millions of dollars into a system so that Suddenlink can then make a profit on it. But then on the other side of that coin,
50:32 Because we are a town of only 8,000 people, and profit incentive being what it is in our society today, I don't see Sunlink ever putting out the necessary capital to improve the infrastructure because they can't make their 21% ROI or whatever it is they're looking at. So I'm a little confused and look forward to having a lot more conversations on this. But in the long run, for a town like ours especially,
51:01 Our customers are going to be reliant on this. I see no way out but to get partially involved in the infrastructure and maybe even the running it. Maybe it becomes a utility like a water district or a trash service or something like that that towns just provide. I don't know. That's it. I'm good. Thank you. John? Thank you very much. Start with Andy and then Nate, a couple of questions for you. Andy, what is the ask?
51:39 So what happened was the CPUC has within it something like an Office of Ratepayer Advocates. And so that office within the CPUC on its own initiative and with no involvement from any of us, they decided to ask the CPUC to open a rulemaking proceeding to establish broadband standards. I'm not sure what prompted them to do that, but that's what they did. So the action that the Coalition of Towns and Counties took
52:10 was to file a comment letter supporting that. The CPC, now that they have that request, they have to consider whether to do it. We're encouraging them to do exactly that in hopes of either getting them to do it or at least getting the attention of the industry and maybe getting the industry to agree to something else to fend off the CPC doing a formal rulemaking. But that's where we're playing. And one thing that we haven't mentioned yet is that we do have access to
52:40 Federal lobbyists and federal telecoms expert people based in Washington, D.C. So if we ever need to move this from the state arena to the federal arena and try to get some traction there, we do have some people who can help us at least start the conversation. And we do have a new congressional district that sort of lines kind of nicely with all that. Yes. Okay. So one observation is in terms of what we could do locally,
53:10 I throw it out there as an idea that a lot of the complexes in the buildings, the service gets to a multi-unit place and then it gets very whack and grays to who's responsible for the stuff that's in the building. That might be something that in a very targeted way, the town could provide specific technical support to multi-unit structures where suddenly it's going to say, we don't know what the hell's going on with this thing. We could provide some good technical expertise.
53:39 To just address those types of issues. And what I'm sort of getting at is narrowing in on exactly what are the technical problems that are going on with the service. So, Nate, to you, without putting you on the spot, I just want to say initially how fortunate and lucky we are in this community, in this region, to have you with your expertise and your initiative to help us navigate all this stuff. It's just...
54:07 It's a gift. And so thank you very much for your service and everything you're doing. So I've been talking with the people in June Lake, very sophisticated folks. They're monitoring three different accounts. They're monitoring pings. They know what the packets are. They know they're really getting into this thing and try to figure out what are the challenges with the service on the technical side. Could you speak a little bit to that, i.e., is Mammoth being dependent on a legacy coax?
54:36 Coaxial Network. Is that the fundamental problem? Is it the problem that Sunlink is not allocating enough broadband when we get into tough periods? What are some of the fundamental issues of the service, if there are any? And maybe it's just service issues, but are there issues with the fundamental service? I think it's a variety of things.
55:01 I'll just be honest. I'm not a network engineer. As smart as it might seem, I am about this stuff. There's a lot of really, really technical intricacies in it that I'm not perfectly up to speed on. But I think what I will sort of say in answer to your question is that there are kind of two facets that, I guess, create the technical challenges or bottlenecks, so to speak, in Suddenlink's network with regard to town. So in contrast with
55:30 And the technology that they use, which is fiber to the premise, in that environment, in the way that basically, you know, the network comes to a node, effectively, for lack of better terms, that is a breakout point where fiber is distributed to homes. It's, you know, it's 100% allocation to every single one of those fiber endpoints. And furthermore, it's...
55:58 A symmetric, both upstream and downstream. So I buy a gigabit, I get a gigabit up and a gigabit down. In a network like Suddenlink or even a network like Frontiers, which is DSL and Copper-based, Frontier, or sorry, Suddenlink runs what's called a fiber deep coax network. And the DOCSIS technology that they use, basically, they run fiber from their
56:26 Main head end in the industrial park out to a node and that node gets broken out into coax and then that coax gets ran to the premise. So there is a bottleneck at those nodes. There's a certain amount of capacity that can pass through those things. And furthermore, when there's demand on the network, there gets to be congestion because everything's coming into that piece of electronics and it can just only
56:50 handle so much, you know, it's think about everybody turning on the faucet at the same time in the house and maybe you have enough water pressure, maybe you don't. So one of the things that a lot of us, you know, six communities that have been sort of pushing on Sunlink been talking about is node splitting and breaking those things up so that there's less customers on each node. And the challenge is that because we are a bit of a transient community, they don't see these capacity challenges all the time.
57:20 And so, you know, they'll see something and be like, ah, and then, you know, they won't see it again for several months, potentially, or they'll see it for a few months and they won't see it again for, you know, six months. And so I think that that's some of their defensiveness. But the other part of it is just like the actual infrastructure as a whole. It's expensive to maintain and there's a lot of other problems that come with it. And so it can be dealt with. I mean, certainly gigabit is possible over coax and we,
57:50 We're seeing those speeds. We still are seeing those speeds in certain places, but that's, I think, fundamentally the problem. And then I think extending away from that, you know, they purchased this network from a company that purchased it from a company. Some of it's been rebuilt and replaced, but, you know, a lot of like the multi-unit dwellings that you're referring to and some of our homes and even some of the more local lines that are being distributed out via coax are old.
58:17 You know, that leads to all kinds of problems. And we're seeing a lot of that incidentally in June Lake, where a lot of coax is just directly buried in the ground and not in conduit. And it cracks over time and you get water and snow and dirt and copper and it has all kinds of issues. And so it's a myriad of things. And it's, you know, it is kind of a big hairy problem. It's not exactly just we're going to replace some nodes and split them. You know, there's going to be some other issues that exist too.
58:45 I think that's the high-level answer. Yeah, it might be at some point, you know, to do some kind of infrastructure feasibility analysis of what we've got that would help as part of our advocacy to rebuild it and get it fixed, but also be able to tell the community, look, this is the nature of the challenges that we've got. So it's not just frustration that turns into all kinds of other things.
59:11 Yeah, and I think just to that point, I mean, and to highlight it for council and the public, you know, I've heard a lot of people say or ask, like, well, why don't we just build another network? Well, what, I think Sierra or somebody else in public works could probably directly answer this question more quickly than I could, but town is 30% underground, 40% underground. We have a lot of poles in town, right? A lot of those poles are old. Most of those poles are overloaded from modern engineering standpoints and won't accept new.
59:39 And so the build in town, which is a lot of rock, you know, a combination of a lot of really complex little subdivisions and communities, it's not.
1:00:07 Thank you. Thank you very much. Sarah?
1:00:39 Yeah, thanks. I think that kind of answered my, I was going to ask Nate for an elevator pitch as to why we can't, you know, just get it fixed and it might be a long elevator, but that's really, really helpful, Nate. Thank you. Thank you. Kirk? Oh, thank you for that presentation. My question or...
1:01:08 Is really, do you have, you know, the agenda bill says provide comments and any direction to staff. Do you have a direction and can you share that with us? What is your direction? Where are we going from here? So, you know, as I said at the front end, no, I think that there's as many questions as there are for you as I could provide answers. And, you know, the reality of the situation is, you know, as I said in that second to last slide, to what extent does town council want to,
1:01:39 Be invested in this, you know, both from an effort standpoint and a dollar standpoint. And if, you know, you say we're all in, then yeah, I could probably make some recommendations and direction. Other than that, I think that, you know, the short-term immediate is to continue to do what we're doing, continue to advocate and push against sudden link and look for viable solutions where we can. You know, Hayes and I have been working closely together.
1:02:05 In terms of trying to solve in small areas around opportunities like with the parcel and with the CRC. And I think that those are really logical and smart places to invest money and to invest energy that could start as sort of growth points for other future builds and may prove to be pilots for
1:02:31 Other projects or ways that we could go about a public-private partnership or various things like that. But beyond that, I think we need to just keep doing what we're doing and keep an eye on what's happening from a legislative standpoint and see if there is money to be leveraged. But even if there is money to be leveraged, it's likely not going to be all the money that we need. And I think that how we...
1:02:57 Well, whether we're actually talking about building a municipal network in town or not, you know, how we get from where we are to there, I think is a very interesting question. So I know that's not much of an answer, but I think it's sort of a complicated one that is dependent a little bit on feedback and input from all of you still first. Sorry, a follow-up question is, you know, when we're talking about this, what are we talking about when you're talking about a financial commitment?
1:03:30 Yeah, good question. I don't know. My quick guess would be $30 million, but, I mean, that's not based on any engineering or anything else. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Kirk. Nate, so what I'm thinking is that, as you said, as new things are developed, as new facilities are finished, you know, doing everything we can in those instances to
1:04:05 And then is there a way to kind of logically break this up into increments, if you will, so that we can, you know, maybe not look at like for a $30 million, you know, we can't do anything if you don't have $30 million, but, you know, help us to prioritize which items we would want to keep an eye on and to go after to make it doable and sort of chewable pieces, if you will.
1:04:34 Yeah, I think it's a great question. And so, you know, Hayes, Dan and I kind of brainstormed and, you know, Hayes and I have spent a fair bit of time just kind of thinking about strategically how you could leverage an opportunity like the CRC and an opportunity like the parcel. And they're different, but, you know, we'll just take the CRC, for example. So, you know, the end of the digital 385 route.
1:05:03 Currently is at the old police station. So in order to get, you know, a municipally owned network, effectively what Digital 385 is, to the CRC, we would need to build route to that parcel. We've talked about building through that parcel and all the way out to the end of Meadow Lane, for example, and stubbing out there. So let's say you do something like that. It's municipally owned conduit because we pay for the construction of it. You could lease that back.
1:05:32 To provider, be that Digital 395 or somebody else. And they could use that route to get, say, not just to the CRC, which we would connect to Digital 395, but basically build off of the end of Meadow Lane to some of the condos that are right there, for example. So that's one opportunity. And then from there, you've got other potential opportunities for routes.
1:06:01 You know, I think as we start to talk about like the rehab of our MUPS and rehab of roads and various things like that, it doesn't mean we should throw conduit in everything. I think we should have some form of basic analysis, whether it makes sense. But, you know, there are opportunities there as we start to do some of that work if they are in good logical locations.
1:06:28 And so I think that's sort of another example. And, you know, the parcel, I think it kind of looks a little bit like the CRC from the standpoint of you'd probably build from roughly the proximity of the high school or, you know, more or less where the county's building is on Sierra Park out to the end of Tavern and go in that way. You could build through the parcel to get to Center Street and stub out there. Along that route, you know, if you're stubbing out.
1:06:56 Where you're putting in boxes, say, adjacent to the concrete and sidewalks on the curb and gutter, you know, you have the ability to kind of come out of those and build into those blocks potentially in the future. And so I think it's about kind of building that middle mile, the in-town middle mile, so to speak. And then, you know, with the parcel specifically as the buildings are built, you know, taking that same philosophy of like,
1:07:26 Well, let's make sure that there's conduit, multiple pieces of conduit into each home so that when we get digital 385 or any other fiber terminated into a building that you could have multiple providers in that building and you wouldn't have to obligate just a certain single provider. And so I think that that, you know, that speaks to this MDU comment that Councilmember Wentworth made as well about like what are the design standards for?
1:07:53 future buildings, whether they're, you know, municipally funded or otherwise, and just making sure that we're creating opportunities as opposed to kind of boxing ourselves in. Yeah, that's, you know, that's what I'm kind of thinking. It's like, you take, like you said, CRC, for example, and then kind of see what that's going to cost to run it out through there to those condos that are right there, then you'd have, we can kind of develop a, you know, cost per whatever, mile foot, half mile, you know, whatever.
1:08:21 And then apply that to other areas. And as things were going on there, what that might look like. I think that might be a good, at least then we could start to get our head around cost. And then you lay on top of that, the availability right now, federal funding, and see if we can have something ready to go. You know, if money comes up, okay, we already have a plan to do this beyond the CRC. The money you're offering would be perfect for this so that we're kind of ready to...
1:08:50 Raise our hand and say, you know, pick us because we're ready to go. Just some thoughts. Yeah, no, I think it's really smart. I mean, I think to the extent that we can have a plan and, you know, it's, I guess I'll say that unless you have $30 million, it's going to be a hodgepodge plan because it's not going to look the same in that corner of town as it is in another corner of town. And it's going to be a little bit easier in some areas and more complicated than others. But, you know, I guess this kind of goes to that conversation of like, well,
1:09:19 Is this an area that we want to invest energy and money into? And if so, you know, I mean, we could pay to have somebody come in and analyze and do some engineering and do some, you know, high-level design. And that might serve us well in terms of understanding what we're really talking about. To what extent funding will actually be truly available for us, considering we are, we do look like a served market.
1:09:46 It remains to be seen, but, you know, I think that it doesn't mean we shouldn't look that way, and I think it makes sense. Okay. All right. Well, thanks, Nate. Is there any public comment on this topic at all, Jamie? No, there is not. Okay. Any last questions, comments to Nate or staff? Yes, Sean? Yeah. Nate, you don't have to answer this question now, but I think it'd be very helpful the council to understand to what degree we could have a partnership.
1:10:15 with Suddenlink or the provider to start doing this kind of stuff. You don't have to answer that now, but I think that would be a really critically important component of any conversation of what we might do going forward. Yeah, and I think it's a really, it's a smart one, right? It might be the most cost-effective way, you know, if Suddenlink says that we need $5 million to upgrade our plant, well, that's probably, there's a lot cheaper than $30,000, you know, so I think that there's...
1:10:44 You know, there's a whole host of questions that would need to come with that, but I think it's a decent concept. Thanks. Thank you. All right, Nate, thank you, as always. You know, you always give a great presentation and help us understand things that are not our first nature to know a lot about. So, any staff questions for Nate or comments? I've seen them. Okay, Nate, thank you so much. Appreciate it.
1:11:15 See you later. Okay, moving on here. We have now 7.2, the parcel year and update. And I think Sandra was going to, but before we start that, we have to have Bill and Sarah who will bow out of this part of our agenda. So if you could disappear yourselves there, that'd be great. Yeah, if we just note they're stepping out as standing on this because of...
1:11:46 Thank you, Dan. Okay. I think we're okay now. Okay, Sandra. Thank you. Thank you so much. So I just wanted to provide the council and the community with a brief year-end update on the parcel, just kind of wrapping up 2021, hitting on some of the high points that we've achieved over the last year. And really, before I get into kind of the project milestones, just a really big thank you to the entire project team.
1:12:17 A number of different staff members have worked on this, and we really appreciate kind of all the team effort that's gone into this, and we really wouldn't be here today without kind of all that teamwork on it. So just hitting on the project milestones in January of last year, about a year ago, the council approved the master plan for this site. They approved 100% density bonus for the site, which allowed up to a maximum of 580 units.
1:12:46 That number was reduced in April of 2021 to 450 when the Town Council approved the Disposition and Development Agreement. That's really the terms and conditions for how the Town conveys the land and the parcel to our development partner, Pacific. Prior to that, in February, the Council approved the Use Permit Design Review for Phase 1.
1:13:12 Just a reminder, phase one is 80 units of affordable housing and one manager's unit. And then through the course of the summer, the town council did approve quick claim deeds to property owners on Center Street. This was just to correct a little bit of a survey bust that was on properties adjacent to Center Street and Main Street. And then construction started in September.
1:13:39 And so the contractor was out there, began rough grading, tree removal, and actually completed, locked down that site or closed down the site in December of this year. So construction kind of went from September to December. And really in that, you know, course of just a couple months, got a lot of work done out there, removed all the trees, completed the rough grading, and our contractor's ready to start the kind of precise grading.
1:14:08 in April of this year. And then just a quick note on some awards that the project received. We received two planning awards, an opportunity, an empowerment award from our local APA chapter, and then the same award from the California chapter. And so it's always nice to get recognized for all of our work.
1:14:30 And there was a handful of news coverage items on the parcel. I was invited to speak at a webinar on this project, really about how we engage the public through this process. So that was a pleasure to speak to the Institute for Local Government and all of the registrants for that. We also were discussed in the Sierra Wave and through the Institute for Local Government newsletter.
1:14:55 And as I mentioned, Phase I has been put on winter suspension and with tree removal completed and the majority of the pads for both Phase I's buildings set. And we'll begin construction around April. We'll start removing all the snow and then constructing the building foundations and parking podiums with vertical construction expected in September of this year.
1:15:21 I was hoping to have an update on the HCD and be able to tell the council and the community that we have received formal approval of our funding for the housing accelerator project. However, according to HCD today, we will be receiving that formal notice soon. So as soon as I hear about it, I will let the council know in the public. And then just a note on the phase one parking management program. I know that's of interest to the council and
1:15:48 We did receive a parking management plan from a consultant hired by Pacific. We are working on that and we will bring that to council for consideration when it's finalized. The staff report includes a brief schedule with move-in still anticipated in fall of 2023. So that's kind of a high-level quick summary of what we did last year.
1:16:13 Definitely a lot of work on staff's part and a lot of work on the council's part as well to review and consider all of those items. So thank you, council members for all of your work on it. And with that, I'm available to answer any questions that anyone might have on this. Okay. Thank you, Sandra. That's great. I appreciate that you sent this out earlier too. We got a chance to look through it when you first did this. So it was great. Good report. Kirk, do you have any questions or anything of that like to Sandra?
1:16:48 No questions. Thank you. Thank you. Bill. Bill is right here. Oh, Bill's not here. Never mind. It's just the three of us. Never mind. John, that'd be you then. Thank you. Sandra, congratulations on, you know, well-deserved recognition for the project. Let's hope this all works out the way we intended. Do we need, we don't have any reason to be nervous about HCD. This is just how they're, by reputation, this is how they're operating these days, correct?
1:17:18 Yes, and Caleb from Pacific spoke with them today, and they said, you are getting this funding, we just have to put together the formal notice, so continue to wait, but yeah, this is really, in our experience, it's really kind of the way HCD rolls. Okay, that's it. Thank you. Thank you.
1:17:40 Okay, and Sandra, again, thank you. Also, Sandra, would you share with us, please? I know everybody's not here, but I'd like you to take a chance or take an opportunity and tell us about your completing and advanced degree so we can congratulate you on that because it's a great accomplishment. Well, thank you so much for recognizing this. So I just recently in December, mid-December last year, completed my Master's of Public Administration. It was a two-year...
1:18:06 I did it through Kent State, Ohio. Pretty challenging to complete an advanced degree during COVID and, you know, also homeschooling my kids and kind of all that stuff. So, but it was a great program. I'm really happy to be done with it. Happy to have some extra time on my plate and happy to kind of bring the knowledge that I learned to my job here at the town. So thank you so much. Congratulations. That's quite an achievement.
1:18:35 Thanks. Good on you. Yeah, very good. Okay, that's all we have for the staff presentations. And if we can get Bill and Sarah back here to join us, please. There's Bill. Wait a second for Sarah here. Yeah, there's five there. Welcome back. All right, let's move on then to our consent agenda. The consent agenda consists of two items. 8.1 is to approve the menace of the regular meeting of January 5, 2022.
1:19:14 And accept payment approval report number 22-27 and accept payment approval report number 22-28. That is all that. We can have a motion to approve the consent agenda, please. So moved. Thank you. Second. Okay, we have a motion by Mr. Wentworth and Mr. Souser. Jamie? Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Staff?
1:19:45 Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Salcido. Yes. All right. Thank you, everybody. All right. Now we're going to move on to public hearing. We have one public hearing tonight, item 9.1, which is consider the adoption of an urgency ordinance making amendments to the municipal code to implement Senate Bill 9 related to urban slot splits and two unit projects.
1:20:12 Hey, Nolan, I think you were going to pick this up for us. You know, before Nolan gets started, I'd like to preface this a little bit. This item is our very best attempt to adopt something that complies with the law. We're not required to adopt an ordinance, but the thinking among cities and counties is that if we adopt an ordinance, it will help clarify the areas where we still do have some discretion. This law is not a model of clarity.
1:20:40 There are a number of inconsistencies in it, areas that are kind of mysterious. I think that there's a lot of thought that probably there's going to have to be some cleanup legislation. I'm not sure that any two cities or counties have taken exactly the same approach. In the state, everybody's scrambling a little bit to try to figure out how to make this work. But this ordinance that I've worked with Nolan on, we think does comply with the law. We think it does preserve as much discretion as the town is allowed to still have. And this is consistent with
1:21:09 What kind of what most cities are doing, even if it differs in some ways, there are some cities that have adopted ordinances that have already, they're so out there and swashbuckling that they've already been threatened litigation. This is not that we're trying to do what we think we can actually do, rather than staking out positions that we don't think are tenable. But as Nolan goes through this, if you think this doesn't make any sense, yes, that's entirely possible that it may not be entirely logical, but it's following the law.
1:21:39 All right. Well, I can't wait to see what you say, everyone. Thank you. Thanks, Andy. Great. Go ahead and break in. It's still thinking about sharing your screen, it looks like. Really weird. As we wait for that, can everyone hear me? Yes. Maybe try unsharing and resharing again. Sometimes that helps. Ah, there we go. Now we can see. All right. Broadband. We all love it.
1:22:34 So as Andy kind of prefaced, Senate Bill 9 was adopted last year by the state requires local jurisdictions to allow a proposed housing development containing no more than two residential units within single-family zones to be approved ministerially and requires ministerial approval of a parcel map for lots but within a single-family zone, thereby creating two parcels.
1:23:02 SB 9 became effective January 1st, 2022. So as Andy alluded to, if we did not have an ordinance in place, we'd be subject to only the state regulations contained in SB 9. There's two parts to SB 9 that contained in the government code sections referenced here. That's the two unit projects and the urban lot squits. And the two provisions can be used together, meaning you can split a lot and then
1:23:30 Billed two units on each lot. So tonight's hearing, we're taking actions to implement SB 9. That's being done or asked, council's being asked to implement those through the adoption of an urgency ordinance. That will become effective immediately. The need for the urgency ordinance is the public threat if we had no local control on implementing these lot splits and two unit projects.
1:24:00 Does establish a new municipal code section within Chapter 17.52. It's titled Single-Family Residential Urban Lot Splits and Two-Unit Projects. Future items that staff will be working on developing planning applications to implement both of these new project types. Again, they're ministerial, so the...
1:24:24 Director's approval on those is final. There's no option to appeal, so it's very similar to a building permit. Determining whether we need to add any application fees to our fee schedule for staff to process these. And then the last bullet point is really for staff to continue to monitor what the state is doing with regards to cleanup legislation. We anticipate there will be some. Then also how other jurisdictions are implementing SB 9.
1:24:52 Imagine the state's going to look at what every jurisdiction did and cherry pick what they like out of those. So qualifying criteria, SB 9 only applies to what's called urbanized areas or urban clusters. That's defined by the U.S. Census Bureau. So locally here, it applies to the incorporated area of Mammoth and the incorporated area of Bishop. It does not apply that I know of to any areas, any unincorporated areas of Mono County or Inyo County.
1:25:23 Properties must be zoned exclusively for single-family residential use. That means within the town, it applies only to our residential single-family and rural residential zones. Properties can be vacant or have existing housing. Specified locations in the government code cannot be on a parcel with what the state's identified as unique characteristics. This includes farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood areas, very high fire zones.
1:25:53 Not be on a historic site. Also, there can be no impact on what the state's called protected housing. That's existing deed restricted housing or housing occupied by a tenant in the previous three years. As part of the application, the owner is required to certify that it's not on any of those unique sites. It's not historic and it's not protected housing. Just a quick map.
1:26:18 For within town, as noted, it's only our RSF and RR zones. So those are all the zones shown in red. The text just kind of gives general descriptives of where those are. Just some stats, 66% of the parcels town-wide are zoned for single-family residential exclusive use. That represents only 26% of the developed acres within town. So it's a fairly small kind of...
1:26:48 Chunk of area that's actually subject to SB 9. And then just looking at vacant SFR stats, there's 322 vacant parcels townwide. That encompasses 111 acres. Median size of all those parcels is 0.22 acres. So they're not very large sites. And if they were to be split and have two units on it, they're going to be pretty dense. Well, and really it's four units. SB 9.
1:27:17 Feel free to interrupt me if anything doesn't make sense during this. As Andy also noted, none of it makes sense. Yeah, I apologize for the interruption, Nolan, but the author's stated intent for this bill was to end single-family zoning as we know it. So in residential neighborhoods that this applies to, you can split an existing lot.
1:27:37 Build another primary unit and then each of the two units can have an ADU associated with it. So what you can have if you do all this at its max density is you could turn a single family neighborhood with single family houses into four units on every single one of those lots with very little ability for us to say no to that. And the other thing you may be wondering is what about the homeowners associations? How does that work?
1:28:02 The law does not specifically override the HOAs. It doesn't specifically override CCNRs. So it's entirely possible that people will come to us and apply to do lot splits and projects that are inconsistent with the CCNRs. We can't say no anyway. So at some point, either there will be cleanup legislation or in some places, maybe HOAs will sue their members to stop them from doing these.
1:28:26 Even though there's an inconsistency and even though we like to try to avoid that kind of thing, we are stuck and we can't say no. So if HOA has approached the town complaining about this, we're going to have to tell them that this is just what the law makes us do. Okay, sorry, Nolan, carry on. That's okay. So SB 9 allows the jurisdictions to implement objective standards. These are generally standards that involve no personal or subjective judgment.
1:28:54 The state provided a very wordy definition there. However, it's important to note that any objective standards we implement cannot preclude the construction of two units on the lots or either of the two units from being at least 800 square feet in the floor area. It's kind of a general high-level summary of all the standards applicable to urban lot splits. Some of the key takeaways, minimum lot size has to be
1:29:21 Minimum size is 2,400 square feet prior to the split. Resulting lot size minimums are 1,200 square feet. Lots after their split must be of similar size but no less than 60-40 split. Also, parcels cannot be part of an earlier urban lot split. That means...
1:29:42 If you had a, let's say a five acre parcel that you split under this into two, two and a half acre parcels, you cannot then come back and split it again through the urban lot split process into smaller parcels. It also has some very kind of confusing language that says you can also adjacent parcels who are working in concert with the owner of the adjacent parcel cannot be split. So that's intended to prevent.
1:30:12 Kind of investment, people coming in, buying a full block of existing parcels and doing lot splits on all of those. It will be fairly difficult to enforce, but it's in our regulations and the states. Under the urban lot split, this max two units per lot, regardless of type, is an important note, as you'll see in the next part about two unit projects. So if you go through the urban lot split process, you can only build...
1:30:38 Two units on each lot. So that could be a primary residence and an ADU or two primary residences. You don't get the benefit of adding additional ADUs onto those lots. The maximum size for the units is 800 square feet. The state does say you can limit side and rear setbacks to four feet. So we did write into our local ordinance that the lot coverage of the underlying zone
1:31:06 But it must yield to allow the two units at 800 square feet. We also limited the height to 24 feet or two stories and it does require a five foot step back for the second story to encourage some building articulation and to move that second story back from the property line. So with that five foot and the four foot above, you'd have nine feet at that second story to the property line.
1:31:32 Parking is limited to one space per unit. A key distinction in the urban lot split is we cannot require the correction of legal non-conforming zoning conditions. Or you'll see on the two-unit project that's different. We've also, in our local ordinance, limited access to one driveway. But again, we must...
1:32:00 We must have some discretion there if that would prevent the two units at 800 square feet. So in those cases, we would have to allow a second driveway, but we're trying to encourage one driveway to the extent possible. You can sell the two lots. So if you split a lot, you can sell them. There is wording in the regulations that require the owner of the...
1:32:24 The lot prior to split to sign affidavits saying they intend to occupy one of the units on one of the lots for a period of three years. It sounds nice, but it will be very difficult to enforce. So then just kind of a simple diagram showing some different configurations. You could have on the left here kind of a vertical lot split with an access coming from driveways on either parcel providing access to the two units.
1:32:56 This one in the middle would be kind of a horizontal lot split with access done through an easement over the front lot to get to the rear lot. Then here on the right, this is generally what's considered a flag lot. So you'd have this strip here be owned by the rear lot providing access. But again, the key thing with the urban lot split is you have no more than four units on any original single family parcel. So going to the two unit projects.
1:33:27 As we noted, if it's an unsplit lot, they can have two primary units plus any required ADUs, JADUs. I have a slide next that kind of shows how that works because that's different than the urban lot split parcels. But most of the development standards are the same though with the unit size, the setbacks, lot coverage, height, and parking.
1:33:49 Two-unit project does have this distinction where they limit demolition of existing residents to no more than 25% of existing exterior walls, except if the site has not been occupied by a tenant in the last three years. As noted, this is that kind of key distinction here where these we can require non-conforming zoning conditions to be corrected.
1:34:15 And then you cannot sell the two units that are on the same lot. So if you have two units on that one lot, you cannot sell those units separately. So just kind of different configurations here. If you don't split the lot, you could have just two units on a lot. You could have two primary dwellings that are detached. And then under the ADU standards, you can have a detached ADU and a JADU within one of the dwellings. That's four units. Or in this case,
1:34:47 You can actually have two attached dwellings. Now the property is considered multifamily. So within that you apply the ADU standards, you have to allow then two detached ADUs and one converted ADU. So you could actually have five units on non-split lot in that scenario. Just some other additional information. It limits the use of the property to residential uses only. No short-term rentals are allowed.
1:35:18 They're also required, the owner's required to record a covenant identifying the use restriction and the development standard limitations. So that's saying that, you know, this lot was split or this lot was developed pursuant to SB 9 and these standards are as specified in the government code and the town's ordinance. The town has very limited ability to deny any of these applications. It requires the building official to make what's called a specific adverse impact finding.
1:35:48 That's supported by evidence to demonstrate that there's some public health or safety risk associated with approval of the project. Then, as Andy noted, we're required to implement SB 9 regardless of our actions. There's many unanswered questions and confusing language in the legislation. We're going to monitor any changes and revise as necessary.
1:36:14 Also at the bottom, just some key distinctions of a two-unit project versus an ADU. In some cases, ADUs can be just more beneficial than doing a two-unit project because they're eligible for some fee reductions. ADUs can be larger than the units under SB 9. So really, we'll be up to the property owner to determine what's the best use of their property. And with that, this is the
1:36:44 The recommended motion, and if it's easier, I can stop sharing my screen for discussion or leave it up in case there's questions about anything in the presentation. Okay, thank you, Nolan. That was a lot of stuff there. Let's go ahead and ask questions first, because I think there may be a number of those. John, you want to start with questions for staff?
1:37:17 I really don't have any questions. I appreciate how blunt an instrument this is that the state is putting out in pursuit of a hopefully a laudable policy. We can't do a whole lot about any of this. And I appreciate that we try to get, you know, try to get in the door first so that we can be positioned to deal with whatever fallout's going to come our way and we can try to...
1:37:44 Adjust, mitigate it, deal with it the best we can. So it's kind of a fait accompli as far as I'm concerned. So those would be your questions and comments. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Kirk. Thank you. It seems like an edict coming down from the state and we don't really have any options. So I think it might create some problems in Mammoth because of snow removal.
1:38:16 Thank you. Okay, Sarah? Yeah, no questions, but thank you all for your work on this. And Bill? I think SB9 was so ill-conceived that most of California fought against it, but the legislature passed it anyway. I would be curious as to know whose money was spent on it, but that's just politicking. That's not answering the question here. I think our staff did a great job to come up with an ordinance.
1:38:49 That allows us to at least make what decisions we can and not just be subjected straight to the state. I don't like it, but I appreciate the work. I think we have no choice but to move this forward. Okay. No, I have a couple of questions, if I may. One is on the, is there anything in the legislation about the kind of home you can build? Can they be pre-built? Can they be modular? Can they be?
1:39:20 on the tiny home concept. Is there language in the legislation about that? No. And if I misspeak, I'll let Andy correct me. So it does require compliance with the California Building Code. So under that, a tiny home is not considered an actual dwelling. So it cannot be a tiny home that's on a movable trailer. But it could be a modular. It could be a pre-built. It could be
1:39:52 You know, we're looking at pre-approved ADU plans with Mono County. It could be like one of those ADUs could be a primary dwelling. So there's flexibility there, but tiny homes, yeah, like I said, are not considered an actual dwelling under the building code. Okay, thanks. And then you referred to the next question I have, basically, as we discussed previously, having plans kind of ready to go, pre-approved, and, you know, this could work on your lot.
1:40:20 You know, different sizes. And are we almost there? Because if somebody came forward and said, yeah, I've got a really big lot, I'd really like to put a little, you know, ADU out there, split it and do that. What, I mean, are we ready to help them with that yet? Or what kind of timeline are we on for that? Now let Sandra address this as well, because I know an email came through earlier that.
1:40:41 with kind of the first draft of the pre-approved plans that Mono County was developing for ADUs. So I know we're getting closer, but I didn't have an exact timeline as to when those will be ready. Yeah, thanks, Nolan. So we're working in partnership with Mono County to develop, you know, kind of ADU plans that are ready, you know, pre-approved ADU plans. So we just got the first draft of those today.
1:41:04 So we're going to provide comments on those. And I'm not sure the timeline, how long it's going to take the architect once we get those comments back to them to turn it around. But, you know, we're certainly most of the way through that process. So I would assume in the next two months we'll have those finalized and ready for people to use. And that will be throughout the entire Mammoth Lakes and the entire county. Okay. And on that, there's no...
1:41:30 Key distinction between an ADU and a primary residence. If you built one of those pre-approved plans, you could call it your primary residence. They comply with the ADU standards, but it could be a primary residence on a property. One thing that I'd like to point out, there are a number of companies that are selling prefab ADUs or ADU kits that they advertise as complying with the California Building Code.
1:41:59 Which is fine, except that here in snow country, we've made local modifications to the building code. All the cities and counties in snow country have done that. Higher snow load standards and some other things as well. So the off-the-shelf garden variety, prefab ADUs that are sometimes on the market, that are sometimes advertised as working anywhere in California, probably won't actually work here. Thanks, Andy. We can still apply our own rules for that.
1:42:28 Right, and the plans that we're working on with Mono County would comply with the snow load requirements. So I think that's the benefit of kind of taking that time and a little extra effort to put those together for our community members. So, but thanks, Andy, for pointing that out. Okay, and one last question. Is there any way to get any of these residences into our low-cost rental programs? Not through the ordinance.
1:42:59 That was one of our kind of early on questions prior to all the attorneys hashing it out as to what could be allowed. And BBK's interpretation is that we cannot apply, we cannot require or impose income restrictions on the units where we could benefit is if we took local money and a lot or a
1:43:25 You know, developed a lot that came up for sale with a two-unit project or a lot that's been split off, we could purchase that lot and build a two-unit project on it, but we can't, at the approval stage, require any affordable housing restrictions on it. Okay. Okay. Well, maybe we can get around to that later, right? Okay. That being said, I have no further questions. Are there any public comments on this item? No, there is not.
1:43:56 All right. Thank you, Jamie. All right. Hearing nobody else wanting to speak or say anything about this, I would entertain a motion of this resolution or the ordinance, rather. I would move that we read by title only and adopt the urgency ordinance making amendments to the municipal code to implement Senate Bill 9 related to urban lot splits and two-unit projects. Thank you. Second that? I second. Who is that? Sarah.
1:44:29 Sarah, okay, thank you, Sarah. All right, so we have a motion and a second. Jamie? Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Salzer? Yes. Council Member Staff? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Whitworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Okay, let's get through some policy matters here. Item number 10.1.
1:44:56 Receive update on the draft airport capital improvement plan ACIP for years 2022 to 2031 and adopt ACIP by resolution. And I believe that Sarah or Sarah is here. Yes, thank you. Hi, let me just share my screen and pull up the presentation. Are you able to see that? Not yet. Still not.
1:45:33 Jill, Lisa, it is dark. Do you want to close and reopen again? Yeah, I'm trying to stop sharing and it's freezing on me. No need to deal with broadband. It is perfect in Mammoth. Especially in Sweet Z. Currently down at the airport. Not so much. Let's try that one more time. There you go. All right. So I'm Sierra Schultz. I'm the Deputy Airport Manager at Mammoth Yosemite Airport.
1:46:20 I'll be giving a presentation on the airport capital improvement plan for years 2022 through 2031. Today we're just going to run through the brief presentation and then there'll be a staff recommendation that town council adopt the ACIP by resolution. So a little bit of background on ACIP and just capital improvement plan projects.
1:46:48 This ACIP is a planning and fiscal management tool. It's used to coordinate location, timing, and financing for capital improvements at the airport. These projects are one-time projects that have a long service life and they are not a typical operations and maintenance expense. These projects also have an extended useful life and they reduce maintenance costs of existing capital improvements.
1:47:17 They also provide additional services and amenities and also maintain safe working conditions at the airport. A little bit more background is that the FAA does require us to update our ACIP annually. This does not obligate the FAA to fund any of these projects, but they are also not able to fund them if a project is not listed on our ACIP. Some previous ACIP meetings that we had in
1:47:49 2021 and 2022. Back in June, we had a presentation to Council. It was just a general airport presentation, but it did include some of the capital improvement projects. We then, on December 8th, went to PEDC to make the recommendation that they find the ACIP consistent with the general plan. We went back to PEDC on January 12th, at which point they did.
1:48:18 Adopt a resolution finding the ACIP consistent with the general plan. So diving into our projects, in 2021 we had two capital improvement projects. One was the security gates and terminal area fencing. This included an eight foot tall chain link fence along the portion of the north side of the airport property, as well as two vehicular gates.
1:48:46 One pedestrian gate and a new security system with cameras. This project is substantially complete for a couple months now and just kind of wrapping up some punch list items and should be done in the next few months. Our other project was reconstructing the East GA apron. This included drainage and work and paving work and new tie downs on 211,000 square feet of pavement.
1:49:15 Known as the East GA Apron. This is just south of the terminal building and the town offices. And this project was started and completed in 2021. Diving into 2022 projects, we are proposing to relocate and upgrade our existing automated weather observation system. We are proposing to do design and construction in 2022.
1:49:45 We'll be relocating the existing AWOS pole and then updating and replacing the system that is on that pole. The existing infrastructure was built back in 1988, so it is very outdated and needs an upgrade at the time of relocation. We'll be relocating it in preparation for the next project listed, which is our ARF and snow removal equipment facility.
1:50:13 So this project we are proposing to complete the design during 2022 over the next six months and then going out to bid and moving into construction during 2023. So we will not be requesting grant funds until 2023 for the construction portion. And part of...
1:50:36 The AWOS relocation is that when the new building goes in, it's going to be too close to where our existing AWOS is. So we need to relocate it in preparation for that new building. The new building is going to be eight bay facility. It'll include utilities and access road, apron and additional site work in the area. The facility will be used to house our snow removal equipment as well as our ARF vehicle and have some ARF support rooms.
1:51:05 Our current equipment is in a hangar that doesn't house all of the equipment that we own. A lot of the equipment is stored outside and doesn't meet the current need. So this is a very important project to us in that it'll help with safety, clearing the runways more quickly, not having some of our snow removal covered in snow when we go to operate, as well as housing our ARF and making sure it is up to par and all maintenance can occur in the adequate.
1:51:34 So diving into our list, I'll be going kind of back and forth between the list and the map to make sure you guys are clear on kind of where these are. So we have what we just discussed, the ARF and the AWOS relocation. So that is the area in purple and our AWOS is currently just south of that and we'll be relocating it near the segmented circle that we built a couple years ago.
1:52:07 Moving into 2023, we're still pushing for the wildlife security fence. Staff is still having discussions with the Forest Service regarding land, and we still need to work through some of the approvals to complete that project, but it still remains a priority for staff as well as the FAA. So that is the surrounding areas, basically to the east.
1:52:36 West, East, and South going all around the property. Next, we have MAGVAR change runway numbers. This is the magnetic variation. So the actual magnetic pole of the earth changes and therefore you have to re-number your runway numbers every so often. I believe it's every 30 years or so. So it's currently 927 and we'll need to be updating it to 928.
1:53:06 In two years, this would be changing the signage out there as well as the paint markings. Next, we have the land acquisition for the Forest Service land in LADWP. This is environmental, proposed in 2023, and then the actual land acquisition going through 2025.
1:53:31 Up in the corner here, you can see the brown piece of land, which is the Forest Service, and then the red off to the right is the LADWB. Next, we have to rehabilitate the T-Hanger Taxi Lanes. These are the lanes that go in between the town-owned hangars in that bright green right there.
1:53:59 And the FAA will fund 25 feet wide worth of taxi lane and the remaining widths will need to have additional funding that we secure for that portion. Moving into 2025, we have runway grading of the runway safety area and object-free area. This is just south of the runway.
1:54:28 We next have the first phase of helicopter parking apron and access taxi lane to that area. So that is this blue area here. It's located on town-owned land, which is why it is phase one of the helipad. There is parking up to the north with an access to the apron, as well as a taxi lane that comes off and connects to the airport movement areas.
1:54:58 The second phase, which is planned for 2031, would be the yellow portion, which is shown here on Forest Service land and cannot happen until the land acquisitions. So next we have replace Doe Ridge obstruction lights. So we have environmental in 2023 and construction in 2025.
1:55:28 The lights are already having issues and are definitely near their end of their service life, so we'll be replacing those, if not sooner than this, depending on the need, but that definitely needs to stay as a priority in this list. And then we go out to the terminal. We're looking at design in 26 and then construction in 28. This includes the entire green area, which is the apron and the terminal building.
1:55:58 We also have, related to the terminal, the parking in 2026, so that would be constructed earlier in this red area. And let's see, 2027, we have to construct 15 feet taxiway along the taxiway shoulders.
1:56:31 That's that light blue here. It's seven and a half feet on each side of the taxi lane, which is what is allowed per FAA standard to get it up to its standard. Next, we have in 2030, General Aviation apron expansion of the north. And that is the yellow right in this area. So that would be kind of one of those final projects as far as the next through 2031. And that is right in that area.
1:57:04 So that's basically the list of projects that are on the current ACIP being proposed. Current funding, just a brief overview, we currently have a million dollars in entitlement funds that we can request through the AIP grant funding program. We have just over a million dollars that we just found out we received through the bipartisan infrastructure law.
1:57:30 This is intended to build safer, more sustainable airports that connect individuals to jobs and communities around the world. So it is intended for infrastructure purposes. And we have not yet signed a grant for this. We just found out a few weeks ago that we have been allocated this amount from the FAA. We also have just over $1.3 million in our local capital improvements fund as it sits today.
1:58:00 So this is, you know, we have sufficient funds to get through the next year of projects and then moving into 2023 construction of the ARF. We will be requesting discretionary funds from the FAA as well. The last two years, the FAA paid for the sponsor portion of the grant, which was, it's 9.34% that we have to put up a match.
1:58:26 They will not be funding that moving forward, so we need to expect to pay that match moving forward. So environmental impacts, we just recently at the end of 2021 completed the EA and EIR for the Terminal Area Development Plan. This included the relocation of the AWOS as well as the ARF building, so that is already taken care of environmentally. The terminal area.
1:58:55 Development Project also included the terminal and the parking and the apron, de-icing apron and all of that that goes with that terminal. As far as the other projects on the list, we will be doing environmental assessments as needed and environmental analysis as needed. It might be an environmental assessment.
1:59:16 And that is basically where environmental stands. And so just to loop back, our staff recommendation is that Town Council adopt the ACIP. As I said, good presentations here. Thank you very much. That was really complete. Okay, questions and comments from Council Bill? No real questions. Thank you.
1:59:51 Okay, thank you. Sarah? No, thank you, Sarah. Wonderful presentation. Thanks. Kirk? No questions. And John? Sarah, you thought you were going to get off easy. This will not be painful, I promise. Two quick, two questions. The Wildlife Crossing project that's working its way through the, through Caltrans, the Monaco County LTC,
2:00:21 Apparently down in Southern California, the state is doing the largest wildlife processing project ever done in California. Can you speak a little bit to how what we're proposing here touches on, relates to, is part of that, or are they just due to discrete efforts? Yeah, so...
2:00:41 As far as I remember seeing the wildlife crossing plan that they are working on is addressing a little bit more to the east by Benton Crossing Road. And so as far as what's being, I think, proposed on their side, there really shouldn't be any conflict between our improvements and their proposed improvements as well. Where they're proposing to make crossings is consistent with the wildlife.
2:01:11 Analysis plan that we did at the airport showing that the animals tend to go to the east and the west of the airport because even though there's no fence, well, there's a fence, not that they can get over, they are going to avoid something in their way anyways, so that does show them moving around in that area. Yeah, we're well aware of the project that they're working on as well.
2:01:34 Okay, because I know that there's, I think it was a pretty significant grant. I think it's almost a million dollars has been approved for doing the environmental work for that. So that thing's moving forward. I'm sure you and Hayes are talking about that, but that's moving forward. The other question is, does any of this work, is it any of it dependent upon or does it have anything to do with our employment numbers from charter service at the airport? Are these two completely discrete, are those two completely discrete things?
2:02:03 As far as our getting a million dollars in entitlement funds, that is reliant on the 10,000 employments per year. So we currently receive those for last year. Moving forward, we intend to meet those employments and receive that funding, but that's definitely reliant on that. And then as far as the types of projects, many of the projects would move forward regardless. The terminal is one that if the need is not going to be there, given.
2:02:32 The air service situation, that could change. A lot of the other ones are really kind of large long-term maintenance and things that really have to happen just to operate the airport and for safety. So those likely will not change. There may be some minor, if we do not keep, you know, do not intend to have commercial service come back, that may change the aircraft, which might change a few of those projects, such as
2:03:01 The 15 fee of taxiway with, that might be slightly less. So there could be minor tweaks. But there is a nexus between the employment numbers and this whole thing. And this application is based on the employment numbers we had for last year, right? Yes. So we didn't make $10,000 during COVID anyway, so there were concessions that they provided. But moving forward, likely not.
2:03:30 Okay, good. Thank you very much. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Okay. Is there any public comment on this, Jamie? No, there is not. Okay. I kind of skipped myself, but I had nothing further to add. It was a good presentation.
2:03:50 Thanks for doing that. All right, can I have a motion? The recommendation is to approve the ACIP by resolution. Can we have a motion, please? Yes, Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the resolution of the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, adopting the 2022-2031 Airport Capital Improvement Plan. Okay, thank you. Second. I'll second the motion. Okay, thank you, Kirk. All right, we have a first and a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Council Member Wray.
2:04:21 Yes.
2:04:22 Council Member Souser.
2:04:24 Yes.
2:04:25 Council Member Stapp.
2:04:26 Yes.
2:04:27 Mayor Pro Tem, Wentworth.
2:04:29 Yes.
2:04:30 Mayor Salcido.
2:04:31 Yes.
2:04:33 Okay, I think we're going to take a break here because we're moving into some items that might take a bit.
2:04:39 So a 10-minute break and we'll see you back here at 610.
2:04:43 Thank you.
2:04:45 Thank you all.
2:04:51 Thank you.
2:05:21 I have a question about the contract,
2:05:23 about responding to them,
2:05:25 and there's only something going on.
2:05:38 Sierra asked me a question.
2:05:40 Did everybody help her out or something?
2:05:43 Okay, yes, sure, yeah.
2:05:51 Thank you.
2:06:08 You know, I was thinking about this. I have driven down here 200 times. Because I've been doing this for the town for 11 years now. Probably actually over 200 times.
2:06:56 In all that time, I'm only going to do one. I don't think you actually had one. Oh, yeah, yeah, about five years ago, coming back after a late meeting, late, and I was heading up Highway 50 from Carson City up to Tato, and the deer just went right out in front of me, jumped out in front of me, nothing I could do. And I stopped my car, and it kind of dragged itself away. I don't know where it went, but I don't think it was going to do well.
2:07:27 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
2:09:18 Thank you.
2:10:16 Okay, give Sarah another minute here. Andy, can we restart without everybody back at the table? Okay. All right, let's get started then. All right, so we're going to go on to item 10.2, which is the Town Council Planning Goals and Funding for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, fiscal year 22-23. And I believe that Rob Patterson, you got this one? I do, and I should unmute. Thank you.
2:14:58 Madam Mayor. So tonight before you, I'm excited to kind of bring this forward and have an opportunity to talk about this as a group. The intent of having this in tonight's agenda is really in preparation for a joint meeting that is planned with Mammoth Lakes Tourism next Wednesday night, the 26th. And this discussion tonight
2:15:26 While many things are brought forward to be reviewed by Town Council, it's really designed for Town Council to provide staff with sort of final input on and really discuss thoughts around MLT's focus for the coming fiscal year. That would be fiscal year 2022-23. And when I say focus, it's really a high level.
2:15:52 Things that the Town Council is asking Mammoth Lakes Tourism to address in its strategic plan and work plan for the next fiscal year. The other thing that's in this discussion is really talking about funding, contract funding for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. That is a little bit different funding structure currently than any of our other NGOs and basically any...
2:16:20 Any sort of normal contract for accomplishing goals or services and how those are paid. So we'll talk a little bit more about that. But why am I presenting this tonight? So I am the appointed liaison between the town and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I've been in this role for a number of years and have worked very closely with John Urdi and Mammoth Lakes Tourism on a number of items. One of those was
2:16:49 The agreement that we established between the town and Mammoth Lakes Tourism back in 2018, we developed an agreement that was sort of unique. It was meant to be the model for how we approach conversations with our NGO and the expectations that we have for that. And it had some very important components to that. When we approached it,
2:17:18 We're looking more at what is our overall scope of services and what are overarching goals that we have for the organization and what are they expected to achieve for us on a mass level. And then inside of that were annual deliverables that are supposed to directly speak to those deliverables.
2:17:46 That section we've talked about on an annual basis. That's something that, and I'll talk about a planning calendar here in a moment. That's something that Mammoth Lakes Tourism brings to the town council and discusses. Here's the actual achievements that we hope to obtain for the next fiscal year. And these are the items that you're funding us to perform. So the deliverables become sort of the meat potatoes of what we're expecting of that organization.
2:18:16 The other two items within the contract are certainly compensation. We'll talk a bit about that. But right now, compensation is based upon what the town budgets for transient occupancy tax and the allocation of 18.08%, that number that is allocated to tourism. And in this particular case, whatever we budget, that entire amount is going to MLT.
2:18:45 For its funding for the year. The final piece, and this is probably the most important one to me, or not the most important one, but certainly a good component of a contract, and it was an annual planning calendar, and what it was designed to do is provide opportunity for both Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Town Council to have joint meetings and discussions, to have that element of accountability where
2:19:14 Town Council has input into the direction of work that is performed, but also really a good report back on what is achieved and just a collaborative effort. I think Mammoth Lakes Tourism has been very collaborative and very much a great partner for the town. I mean, they perform a very critical function for us, and that is in the form of our marketing arm. They are the marketing arm for the town, and that's what we contract with them for.
2:19:43 One of the things that we've found with this planning calendar, I mean, it was the first time we've ever implemented something like that, is that the timing was a little bit off. You know, we expect Mammoth Lake Tourism to come to Town Council prior to the adoption of the budget and talk about the deliverables that they anticipate for the coming year.
2:20:08 But what we failed to recognize is that we needed the opportunity for town council to give them some focus points for the year, to have a voice in advance of the planning, to have a voice in advance of all the strategic elements that are there. And so that was kind of a miss on our part. And I say our, I certainly was a part of that team that developed this overall internal planning calendar.
2:20:34 I think it's important that we sort of look at this as an opportunity to adjust and maybe write some of the timing issues that we're having with this process. So this was my sort of recommendation of how to address this, and that is to certainly, Mammoth Lakes Tourist has been requesting, we need more meetings with council, but I kind of want to focus it in on, we need meetings to accomplish specific functions at specific times.
2:21:04 Which is the annual planning calendar's original intent, but just some slight adjustments. So the hope tonight is that council can provide some of that focus. It'll be very helpful for both the council and Mammoth Lakes Tourism as they go into the planning process. And to sort of understand that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is the experts that we are hiring to solve these problems.
2:21:33 But with the direction of council, it's going to be a high level direction that we provide to them. It's really going to be, these are some things that we want to accomplish. And I'll walk through some staff recommendations, if you will. But tonight I hope to get good dialogue from council on these focus items, providing input to me as I will be developing a staff report for next week.
2:21:58 And that would hopefully guide the presentation and the discussion with this joint meeting with MLT. But it's a critical component for the town. Obviously, our marketing is critical for us. Even when we're having strong years, it's good to be able to understand maybe where we need to fine-tune that. And I think what you'll see in some of these staff recommendations is really more...
2:22:26 It may be beyond marketing a little bit. It might be into relationship development. It might be into, you know, education of both, you know, town employee, not town employees, but town citizens as well as our visitors. So as I kind of jump into, that's the end of my introduction piece of it. I want to jump into the focus points now. One of the things that I did hear from council in
2:22:56 And it may be in a different format, but it was with regard to how, what's the most effective way for staff to address challenges like this. And it really was to develop an overall package, you know, a comprehensive package that we can bring to council for a review approach, especially when we have limited time to discuss some things.
2:23:24 Let that fine-tuning occur. And so I took that, and that was a part of a discussion we were talking about with short-term rentals, but I took that same sort of concept and brought it forward here with the MLT focus item. So while it may seem like staff has taken some liberties here with direction, we tried to look at where we were last year, some of the pain points that we had.
2:23:51 Some of the feedback that I received both from working with MLT as well as listening to council meetings and input even from our constituents or your constituents and try to use that information to develop these focus points. So hopefully they're on point and that they provide the needed information and they represent what council wishes are to provide to MLT. And a reminder,
2:24:20 We want to stay out of the weeds. We don't want to provide direct, I want you to do this specific item. In this particular case, that I think will happen when we start talking about the deliverables and the fine-tuning of that, where council can direct maybe some adjustments or tweaks to those deliverables. But at this stage of the game, it's really more that overarching and high point. And again, we will look for MLT to solve.
2:24:50 For these focus points and to provide, you know, very good strategic plans and what they want to deliver. And the expectation from town council shall be that when we do receive those deliverables, each one of these focus points will be addressed. And I think that, you know, we'll have a good sense of collaborative approach and maybe give town council the desire they're looking for for that input.
2:25:17 I'll kind of pause there for a minute before I get into what staff is. Is there any comments or questions about this approach? Do you have anything for Rob? I like it. Okay, you're good, Rob. Thank you. So like I said, looking through this, I certainly had a number of, I do have a number of conversations with John Urdi in my role of liaison, but also with Dan and myself sort of looking through
2:25:51 What we thought were the really challenges for the last year and things that are probably of the same or similar importance, you know, for this year. And we want to maybe build upon that and continue on that. So, you know, the first one, and arguably I'm putting these out in no particular order. They're not in any order of priority.
2:26:14 They're also not comprehensive. I think there's some things even after this was published that have come about that are missed in here. But that's the intent of tonight. I do want feedback and to grow on that a little bit. But the first item is really education for both visitor and resident. We're combining a couple, I'm going to say oil and water, but in some sense of that,
2:26:41 It's a good way of describing what it's like to have a community as we exist here in our little paradise, have visitation the way we do, the volumes that we do. And I don't think it's lost on anybody, but that's our lifeblood. That's why our community gets to exist. That's where the funding comes from for us to perform these services. And without the visitation, we would not.
2:27:08 We would not have a business model that was sustainable. So we wouldn't be able to do that. But I think we do recognize that the resource we have is a finite resource. It is a limited resource. We have to be vigilant about overutilization of that. We have to understand the impacts it has on our community and our folks that live here full time and on the environment. At the end of the day,
2:27:38 If we don't have a good approach for each one of those, our finite resource will be used up. And at the end of the day, the visitation, the quality of experience for our visitors will suffer. And I think in that, so will our visitation. So the education is important to kind of mitigate those impacts.
2:28:04 And that's a fine art. But it's also something I think that is not a hard ask for Mammoth Lake Tourism. They've engaged in that realm before. And so it's their area of expertise. We should expect them to be able to not only see what those pain points are and what those challenges are, but be able to effectively message to that. And I don't think that's a bad ask.
2:28:31 Part of that is continuing to promote responsible travel and stewardship, making everybody responsible for shouldering these benefits that are here as a resource and how to take care of them and how to recreate here effectively. Those are good messages that I think will help certainly, as I said, protect the resource that we have.
2:28:57 And the experience for the visitors. They'll make them feel a little bit like a local and essentially be responsible for protecting that asset and protecting their experiences while they're here. We also have a number of initiatives within our community, I think, that are important to drive awareness around. So certainly the diversity of experiences that are out there, there's a multitude of things to do, as you know.
2:29:27 Both summer and winter. And it's important for our visitors to kind of go outside of their area of real expertise or what they may know Mammoth as. And we saw a little bit of this during the COVID impacts when people were just dying to get out of their houses in that initial wave in, say, early part of 2020. And we had a lot of new visitors to the town that just hadn't come here before.
2:29:56 And they were really surprised at how pleasant it is and maybe a different type of season than they are here. So understanding that diversity of experiences, but also, you know, some of the initiatives that we have, like the walk, bike, ride program, the host program, those types of things, you know, I think are important to furthering that view of our community and what we have to offer our visitors. So we spend a lot of time on those programs.
2:30:25 Some of the messaging and some of the outward sort of marketing components do interject those elements that are important to us. The second kind of bullet point or the second point of focus is really re-energizing that destination visitation. So this is not uncommon and this one's probably the lowest bar and the easiest one that everyone can agree to, but that is targeting those shoulder seasons.
2:30:53 You know, we are a limited resource, but we also have a limited carrying capacity in our ability to service customers. And so if we have folks really impacting us heavily during the holiday season, then we really don't want to drive that very much more. But we do want to sort of build upon these areas that don't have as much visitation so that we can maybe even out the peaks and the troughs a little bit and provide our community, our businesses, our
2:31:22 Our workers, you know, more of a level work process while still generating more revenue. And again, the revenue is important because it provides for our activities. So targeting those shoulder seasons of spring and fall and working on specific marketing campaigns that will enhance visitation in that time period. The other element would be extended stays.
2:31:49 John will tell you that you get someone traveling from a great distance away, which is why this commercial air service directly coming into Bishop with connection points to Denver, which connects to pretty much everywhere in the world, it really brings people in that will stay here for a longer period of time. They will stay here during the midweek time periods when the drive-up market is usually present.
2:32:18 And those folks spend a lot of money. They spend a great deal of money, both not only obviously on their lodging and their components, but within our restaurants, within our retail stores and so forth. So that's one of our more lucrative areas to focus on. At the same time, we don't want to lose focus on what we're doing with the Southern California market. And that's clearly our bread and butter for our local market, for folks that come up.
2:32:46 And so while we want to focus on some visitation from afar, I think not losing sight, so meaning like keeping the appropriate level of focus within the Southern California region will be important. And that would be something that I would strive to drive forward. And then really, you know, if you talk about the expanding our region of influence, you know, I think that takes a little bit of a fine.
2:33:14 Art, you know, and I guess, you know, MLT can really hopefully respond to this and be able to provide that level of input. But when you talk about going into a new region, what makes the most sense? You know, where should we be looking to expand? And I think that's something that their level of expertise, their level of focus and analysis should be able to provide for us. But we need to as a community to be looking for.
2:33:41 You know, where is the next sort of best opportunity for us? And that means to grow our visitation. So I look for that, you know, sort of a components of re-energizing that destination visitation. I mean, finally, not finally, but next area is a little bit of a shift. So, you know, we've talked before about the visitors, the experience, the expectation of them when they arrive, as well as our
2:34:12 Local residents. We talked about how to do that, some of that, where we want them to focus. But now it's really more local community focused and marketing focused for that. The idea of we have a culture within Mammoth. We have a culture that is a service-based business. It is a resort-based business. But it's also home for all of us. And so how do we blend that?
2:34:41 That reflection of the community values into our marketing messages. This is arguably one of the most difficult ones, I think, for MLT to provide because it's understanding the nuances and it's really more about relationship building than it is about true and pure marketing. It's just asking for, you know, make it look and feel like Mammoth.
2:35:09 And make it look and feel like the support that we need to the community. And I think the greatest benefit that will come to this is that the community itself will feel like the efforts of Mammoth Lakes Tourism really supports their core values and really supports what they want to do. And again, that should build strong relationships. And, you know, talking about buy local campaigns, you know, I made mention in the staff report that, you know, that would include MLTs functions.
2:35:39 When appropriate, I know sometimes that's not at all easy to do. And frankly, it's not that big of an impact. But it's really around the specific marketing that supports the businesses within the visitor's eye. And I think that's important for the businesses. And again, this is about relationship building with the efforts of MLT to directly impact the successes of our businesses. And that's the intent of that.
2:36:09 That process. But again, it's that buy local campaign. Also the strengthening of promoting these local businesses, working to enhance that customer experience. I know I'm very concerned, especially when we are heavily impacted with high visitation volumes.
2:36:34 That the experience that the customers are having isn't something that's going to want them to come back or make them want to come back. So these local business relationships, how they address maybe some of their servicing of the customers and those aspects, really just focus on that customer experience and visitor experience. The other thing, and this one sounds challenging, but I think the ask is that want MLT to assist in
2:37:05 Really defining where as a commodity, where we need to focus some of our energies, not actually doing the amenities or creating amenities or creating the solutions that may support visitation, but really where do we need to improve our local infrastructure? What enhancements can we make that will make the visitor experience better? And so it's that consultation from...
2:37:32 Either feedback they're receiving from visitation, what they see as pain points that we need to address. And it's not asking them to address it. It's really asking them to assist in identifying it. That's a little bit of a shift of focus than we've had maybe in prior years where we've asked them to shoulder in and solve for that. But you'll see later on how this shift in funding is, at least in my mind, changing.
2:38:00 How we need to request things for Memphis Tourism and really maybe getting more back to this level of expertise than it is to actually accomplish things. And so I'll talk more about that a little bit later. And then finally is developing success metrics that are really outside of the traditional marketing measurements. We had these meetings with MLT. They do analysis.
2:38:26 To the end of the earth on the performance of their ads, their click-through rates, all those things that are very important to understand how effective it is in your marketing and what you're reaching out there and touching. What I put on here was really outside of that entirely. It is designed to say we need more intrinsic measurements that are the health of the community, that are the health of the visitation.
2:38:55 They're the things that really address how are we doing? How are we doing? I mean, those are hard questions to answer, but what I put here was just guest surveys, business surveys, resident surveys, gathering data from all points of input that are important to us and really understanding how they're being impacted. And really, that's going to inform us for where we focus on in the future.
2:39:24 But at the same time, it's also going to go back to that relationship building. It gives, well, this may not seem like it's something that is a MLT assignment because it's not really marketing. It's designed to enhance that relationship. And I think that that's an important function. And I know I, as the liaison for that group and town staff, really want to support that positive relationship building.
2:39:51 And view of the organization within our community. So that's kind of the focus there in discussion. So I will tell you some things that were brought to my attention after the fact that I missed on this was really community events. And I think that's of critical importance. And I agree it needs to be on our focus points possibly.
2:40:18 The other thing I didn't do in these recommendations is I didn't cover what I think are bread and butter components that Mammoth Lake Tourism already knows they should be doing. And maybe that's that down into the weeds component that we wanted to talk about. But I think that's really well understood. That's what we do as a community when we service our visitors is have these events and we support our businesses.
2:40:47 And folks that are out there trying to make that visitor experience clear. So I'm going to kind of pause there. This is not an exhaustive list. I'm hoping I get either that's a good list, let's go with that, or let's have some dialogue around things that need to be added or adjusted or general thoughts. So I'm going to pause there. Thank you. Thank you, Rob. I'm going to go to Bill first. He is our representative on MLT and I'd like to hear his thoughts on this.
2:41:20 Okay, let me whip out my six pages of report here. No, for the most part, so I am almost disappointed that we are addressing this now. In 2018, we went through a complete reorganization of funding and everything else, and then we went right into COVID, so who knows how that would have all, you know, worked out in the long run. But his points here, one through four, are all...
2:41:48 Very valid and things that I would agree with. The awareness of the diversity of experiences is something I don't think we've capitalized on. We have everything from birders to through hikers to there's so many more opportunities other than the mountain and the lakes basin that I think we don't focus on and can produce material for to help spread our people.
2:42:16 I keep hearing about how many people there are and how busy we are, but our occupancy rates are no higher than they normally are. We aren't setting any records there. So are there more people or after COVID, are we just more sensitive to the people? But still the awareness of diversity, I think that is huge and something to be done. And number two, brand marketing. I can't tell you how huge I think brand marketing is, not just in Southern California, but everywhere.
2:42:46 You know, Coca-Cola pays a premium to have their name every place because then when you think of their drink, you think of Coca-Cola and Mammoth is the same thing. We want people when they think about outdoor recreation to think of Mammoth, maybe not plan their trip right then, but so brand marketing is important. Visitor experiences touched on in number three is huge.
2:43:12 And Rob adds locals there. And one of my pet peeves is when the Lakes Basin are full, the locals complain that it's too busy. You know what? As a local, you should know some other places. So maybe we need to advertise what is available out there besides the Lakes Basin. It's huge. New metrics for how we judge their effectiveness. To hear John come back. Sorry, John.
2:43:43 And tell me that for every dollar invested, we get a $5 return is almost a little disingenuous because some of those would be coming anyway. So what are our metrics going to be? I don't know, but I think it's something we need to work on. Is it going to be occupancy rates? Is it going to be more spread out? It cannot be just the amount of TOT we collect because that keeps going up and makes everybody look good just through inflationary pressures.
2:44:13 But the structure of this, I think, is very sound. And I think Rob has done a good job. I don't want to tell him that too much. I want him to still be able to get his helmet on. However, that being said, I don't want to get far enough into the weeds that we lose our flexibility with MLT. Every time we have a drought year, every time we have a new variant of COVID and we have to change the rules.
2:44:44 They have to segue what they're doing. And they need to do it regardless of the scope of services we sell them. That's hugely important. And, you know, I've only been to one of their meetings so far, so it's not an input from them. This is just how I've always felt. And I've always been involved with the marketing of Mammoth in one way or another. Yeah, we'll go into the income piece later, I'm assuming, Rob.
2:45:15 And as far as his four points to put out there, I think they're all valid. I think, you know, we don't need to tell them to market skiing and don't necessarily market the lakes basin because they're going to do that regardless. That's just a prudent thing to do. But I like the way it's laid out so far. We'll see how she works. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, let's Sarah. Sorry, do you want me to start off with just my...
2:45:46 My thoughts on the four points or? Well, yeah, we're going to just talk about this piece of the report. We'll get to the later. Thank you. Yeah, I do think I agree with Bill, you know, to have some quantifiable measures because tourism is that we're getting tourism dollars regardless. I do, I am.
2:46:15 Cautious about survey fatigue. And I don't always know how much surveys tell us, but at least it's something. And yeah, I appreciate this coming before us. I'm sorry, I'm struggling for feedback on the four. I don't really have any feedback on those at the moment. Thank you, Sarah. John?
2:46:48 Thank you, Madam Mayor. So, Rob, I'm assuming that with this focus effort, you're going to take some of these consensus points from council, and that will form the basis for the agenda for our discussion with MOT, correct? That's correct. Okay, so a couple of thoughts here. On the four points, I've got a question or two, but I think it would be very helpful to have a value statement, an overall lens through which we're going to be looking at these things.
2:47:17 And I'm going to propose a word and an idea that's consistent with what you said, Rob, which has to do with sustainability. That the efforts, whatever we are doing as a destination between marketing and infrastructure and what we do, that we are thinking generationally and we are thinking in terms of all those things you said about impacts and everything else, that our goal is to do this in a way that will be sustainable for many, many generations. But that needs to be the overall lens.
2:47:47 By which we do all this stuff. A second point is that I think it's important, and this may just be my perspective, but I hope it's something that the council shares, is that for the community to understand that housing has been a top priority of this council and previous council for a while. And we're getting into waters with housing.
2:48:15 That I'm not even going to get into all that. It's beyond what the Community Housing Action Plan could even have dreamed of in terms of the aggravation of the housing problem. And that through the funding that we generate through TOT, through a sustainable destination, it generates millions of dollars that at least this council, this council member, I'm assuming this council, we can then direct those dollars to help address
2:48:45 The most profound and critical problem facing this community. Certainly open if, Councilman, we've got some other ideas about this, but I think we really need to start to make the connection back to our people, to our folks. This is why we're doing this. And these are the benefits that come out of this. Obviously, it supports businesses. Obviously, it does all those other kinds of things. But we have a unique opportunity with the largesse that this being a sustainable destination produces to address
2:49:14 A fundamental and profound problem for our community. Another thing is I have a technical question, which I don't know how we're going to resolve this, but this conversation with MOT around the values and the four points, I'm a little confused as to what degree that gets directed at the entire MOT program or only at Measure A money. How is that? How are these values going to get interpreted?
2:49:42 through the TBID, which is a different mechanism. I'd like some technical advice on that at some point to figure out how all that is going to work. I think that would be useful for the community, for all of us. I'm thinking also that with item number four, and again, you talked about how it's not MLT or the marketing arms obligation to deal with infrastructure issues, to deal with problems. I think this lays it out in a way to...
2:50:08 Let's create awareness of where our stress points are, where the problems are, let's address them. But I think also the role of the Office of Outdoor Recreation, I understand that the town's received a number of applications of that position, is going to play a critical role in this. I would like to see that acknowledged in these points here as part of how we put this whole thing together to be able to do what we want to do. And a final piece is I think that...
2:50:34 The town and with MLT, we should consider making a modest investment in a...
2:50:41 sort of a national, but certainly a western-wide organization of peer communities through the Colorado Association of Ski Towns so that we can really be talking and participating in a peer network that's dealing and addressing with all these similar issues. I think it's about $700 a year or something like that to be part of it. I think the county's interested in that as well so that as we're having these discussions, we'll work with MOT and ourselves, we have a peer
2:51:10 We have a peer network to be able to work with to understand how to better do these things. And I'll leave it right there. And we'll have a funding discussion at some point, I guess. But those are my thoughts. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Thank you. Kirk, do I should weigh in, please? Thank you, Madam Mayor. My approach to this is a little different in the sense that, you know, if we look at the visitor,
2:51:40 And then the infrastructure that supports the visitor from workforce housing to, yes, absolutely, the marketing program and everything else. But if we don't have the infrastructure, the ability to clear roads, as well as, again, housing for our employees, you know, it's a little expensive to have workers driving up from Bishop.
2:52:07 I think that, again, we look primarily at visitors, and then how do we provide the infrastructure and the support systems, as well as the marketing, certainly, to make sure that the visitor's experience is one that is a quality experience.
2:52:33 You know, there's a lot of moving parts to this. And I guess I think that we need to break it down into its component parts and look at each one and say, how are we doing in each one of those areas? I don't know if that was too much rambling, but I think that that's kind of the way I look at it from an overview. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. No, I think that Rob was busily.
2:53:04 Making notes of that. So thanks for that. From my part, I think that this is a much needed kind of raising of the level of detail. I think that this speaks to the larger issues around visitation, sustainable recreation, community, working with our community. But I just take this moment to just say that as we talk about the energizing destination visitation,
2:53:33 As one of our colleagues says, this is a region. And understanding that, you know, regionality as far as the TOT is important for our town, but there are so many things to do in our county, our whole county, working with the Board of Supes, working with the marketing arm, the tourism arm of them. I think we can, that also answers the question, how do we spread people out? This is a big county.
2:54:02 Okay. There are ways to develop recreation assets in other places that will drive that exact thing. If we spread people out across the county, not only would other communities benefit, but we would also get a bit of a breath here and not feel like everyone is in the lake space and on the exact day you want to go for a short walk. So looking at that, I think that we can, you know, begin to work really hard.
2:54:29 on that with the same intent of improving our visitor experience, you know, evening out the experience for the locals and the service industry and making it a quality experience for everyone. So just that little caveat. So good work on that so far. And Rob, you want to walk us through the next piece of this, please? Yes, absolutely, Madam Mayor. And thank you for the feedback on all that. I did take sensitive notes and we'll work on putting that into
2:54:57 You know, the staff report for our next week's meeting. On the funding side of things, you know, Bill's correct. We did a tremendous amount of work, you know, sort of right-sizing the allocations between tourism, housing, and transit. And what we've...
2:55:25 Kind of done with other NGOs, or this has been their structure in the past is what, you know, we've had a list of things that we've asked them to perform for us. And when you think about what a non-government organization does is they perform certain services that the town itself or the town staff itself does not have to perform. And so in most cases, we are paying for their time. We're paying for the amount of effort for them to...
2:55:54 Work on specific items. That's with Mammoth Lakes Housing, for example. They have a work plan that they have to work through on an annual basis and things that they achieve for us. And in return for that, we provide them with funding to support their organization and provide staff and other things that they need to do. The same thing with ESTA. They work for a certain number of hours. It's around 19,000 hours a year.
2:56:22 There's a rate per hour that they service and that provides for the services of the buses in town and those transportation needs that we have. So they're all kind of tied to the achievement of something specific. Whereas with MLT, the way it was funded is it's really tied to that kind of top line number and it provides wild variability to that. So a prime example,
2:56:52 When we went into 2019, just, I'm sorry, 2020 to 2021, really not knowing the impact that we were going to have from COVID and the degree we would be shut down, went through a very conservative approach and frankly, we budget very conservatively, but by design, but that particular year, it even cut down those needs. So arguably in a time when we needed maybe even more prowess in our marketing, more maybe fine tuning,
2:57:22 We had less money available to do that. And I think, you know, I've certainly heard questions from counsel on saying, you know, how much money is enough? What should we be performing? What should we expect to be spending on our marketing arm? And that's really hard to define. I think it's a challenge to say, you know, this specific dollar of spend will produce.
2:57:50 You know, this specific visitation and therefore revenue. But my approach here was really more to say, you know, we've got a list of things we're asking for. If we were to package that up and say, okay, Maniflex Tourism, we need you to address these concerns. And we're going to provide this amount of money for you to perform those services and to deliver on those services.
2:58:20 That will be helpful for them. Rather than waiting for, you know, what are we going to budget and what does that mean, just having it not tied to anything other than, you know, a number, we're deciding on what we want to spend. I came up with $2 million, which is a little bit of a haircut from last year. Last year was $2.335. And really it's designed to, frankly, address concerns I've heard, is that we want to
2:58:47 We maybe need to curtail our investment a little bit in marketing. There is certainly, this is the measure A allocation only, but that will, and I'm certain MLT can do this, but pivot a little bit on their strategy, their approach, their spending in order to hit that number. And I think that they can do that. And conversations I've had with John, I think that's a doable number. And it should satisfy, you know, not that I want it to be directional.
2:59:16 But I think it's really more establishing a payment for expected services. And I think that that's a good starting point. But that's going to be up for discussion tonight. A couple of points I want to make and really clarification components is we allocate funding to tourism from that budget. And then we fund the Chamber of Commerce from that, as well as
2:59:45 Mammoth Lakes Tourism. This particular approach would bifurcate that. It would separate it to say that the funding we provide to Mammoth Lakes Tourism is the $2 million, and that's for the performance of these marketing efforts. The other thing is, because we have allocated all of the funding that is generated from our budgeting process to go to Mammoth Lakes Tourism,
3:00:12 We've had to ask them to perform some functions that probably are outside of the realm of marketing. I mean, they certainly involve the visitation experience and those types of things, but they're things that probably should, in my opinion, at least as a town staff, reside with the town. And so by shifting this around to say, we're going to pay you for the things that we expect you to be doing and performing for us, that should set aside some monies.
3:00:40 From this general allocation of money to tourism, which I'm not recommending, by the way, I'm not recommending adjustments to the percentages that are allocated to tourism, housing and transit. I think those should remain and they were well thought through by prior council or some members of our current council when they were done. But this is strictly for the payment, the contract payment to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. A couple of examples of that, you know, we require them to provide fish docking.
3:01:09 And so this, you know, essentially we're paying them money in order to turn around and do things that may be a town responsibility. Contributing to the host program, funding to the host program, certainly that's, you know, visitation in that process, but, you know, we should be able to fund that. And so what I'm saying is that while we may be reducing, slightly reducing the amount of money that we would be, you know, sending to MLT, we'd also, I think,
3:01:37 Smartly this year, maybe change the expectations of the deliverables and maybe get more towards a focus of just the marketing expertise that they provide and not this exchange of money that they get because they get the allocation of what we budget currently. That'll kind of fix some of those complexities in the areas where
3:02:03 Their involvement seems to be strange, but if you think about it, it's our marketing dollars that we're currently allocating and that's critical. So I think this approach of looking at items we expect them to do in the form of deliverables from a contract, looking at it and here's what we're willing to pay for those functions.
3:02:24 Especially at this stage of the game in our budgeting process. I mean, we're about to begin ours, which will start late February, early March. I think MLT does the same. Having this clarity and understanding about what those numbers are for both sides at this stage of the game is helpful. And I think it's helpful for all of us and provides that. So that's what I've thrown out there. I did want to add those points of clarity just to make sure folks understand.
3:02:54 That we are, you know, we're trying to, you're trying to solve the problems that my job as a staff member is to solve problems that I hear. And when council shares those things, try to bring a solution forward that will address that. And not, you know, in a winner and loser scenario, but really more in the middle of the ground and something that can be addressed. So I think.
3:03:18 I'm comfortable with that. And, you know, I can't speak for MLT. I hope that they, you know, would understand the methodology behind it and be able to understand that process. So I'll pause there. If there's any other clarifications, I think I'm rambling a little bit. So please give me input on that number. Or our approach, too. Yes, thank you, Rob. Okay, let's do some comments, questions for Rob on this topic. John, why don't you shoot off here?
3:03:51 Thank you, Linda. I appreciate the approach. I like the approach. The approach, Rob, that you're describing has been in the works for many years. Not too long a time, but for a while. The fundamental idea being that the town, as an organization, has to own its role in the destination, which is, for example, the relationship with the federal agencies that make this place possible.
3:04:21 There needs to be a peer-to-peer relationship, as was requested by a previous district ranger. That's what we have in place. We're moving in that direction, and I think that's appropriate, and I think that that's good. And so I think dealing with MOT on the basis of a number where we're finally starting to define everybody's roles and responsibilities, I think that makes sense. And I'm looking forward to making adjustments to those numbers as needed.
3:04:49 Based on this program that we're putting together. And again, the town in relationship with the federal agencies that define, that make our destination possible. The office of outdoor recreation with a dedicated staff person who is the town manager's primary liaison to all of that. And that covers not just recreation, that's going to cover fire. We have this, you know, 50,000 acre fuels reduction project going on around here. That gets into that as well. There's a lot of things happening in that space that are very important.
3:05:19 Linda, I do want to strongly support your comment about regional, which I sort of fell through my cracks somewhere. That is critically important. The air service is changing everything. When the TBID is working on air service coming out of Bishop, that lens must be part of this conversation. So I look forward to following up on that at the next conversation. Other than that, I'm good. Thank you.
3:05:50 Lynda, may I interject? There's a few more comments that I'd like to make, maybe some sections. I talk so much, I lost consciousness myself, so perhaps I missed some areas that I needed to really address. I talked a little bit about the reserve accounts and the allocation of Measure A dollars and how those were not being impacted by this. I wanted to kind of reemphasize the point that
3:06:17 You know, someone made earlier on this that, you know, we're generating dollars above and beyond, you know, our budget fairly handily. And I expect this year to be probably off the charts solid as what I'm seeing so far in the collection side of things. But none of this recommendation affects those reserve buckets. It retains them as they were originally designed. And I think council has made
3:06:46 Really good decisions in the last couple of years. And frankly, I'm going to give credit to Mammoth Lakes Tourism as well, because they've let out on this too, that those dollars that we accumulate in those reserve buckets can be utilized for nearly anything that we need to support our community. A prime example of that is earlier this fiscal year, we had almost $2 million that came out of the tourism reserve.
3:07:14 Partly at the request of MLT and definitely at the need of the community to fund housing. And so it went into that. So while we're establishing a flat dollar amount or hopefully establishing a flat dollar amount, that means that those funds are there for any sort of circumstance that the council desires and what is the most pressing need. It also is that
3:07:41 We have asked Mammoth Lakes Tourism on many occasions to pivot. Many occasions they've had to address what's going on within our marketing and make adjustments. I'm saying that if we establish this approach where we're paying them dollars for things to accomplish, my expectation would be if they recognize a need for a pivot or something that's more crucial based upon either a downturn or something that we see going on.
3:08:09 Where we need to invest money, that they would approach council with a request to take some funding out of that tourism reserve to fund campaigns above and beyond what we've asked them to do or what we've started off to do in the beginning. So I just kind of want to reiterate those points that those monies do remain available at the discretion of council.
3:08:29 But they're also available for MLT if there's something that is really critical. So I'm sorry, I wanted to just make those extra points and I didn't get a chance to do that before comments. So thank you for entertaining that. Yes, thank you, Rob. Sarah? Thank you so much. Thank you, Rob, for clarifying. I think all I really would like to say is that I would maintain my position that MLT could live off of $5 million in TBID.
3:08:59 And that's where my opinion remains. However, I do think this is a step in the right direction and I don't believe I would get council consensus on that. So that's where I stand. All right. Thank you, Sarah. Bill. Okay. Some important points first. Rob talked about fish stocking and the host program probably not belonging with tourism. MLT.
3:09:31 We talked about visitor experiences several times over and over again. Well, the host program.
3:10:00 And the fish stocking program, while maybe it needs to be a partnership between us and them, maybe they don't kick in very much, but certainly those are part of the things I look at as the necessity for visitor experiences. Then I'm going to go back and give another history lesson again at the start of the funding. Remember, prior to 18, all of the money from TOT at 2.8.
3:10:30 5, I think, was our original percentage, Rob, before we lowered it to 2.35 so we could give back to housing and others. It was 2.5. Okay, 2.5. Some reductions after the settlement and so forth. So there's a lot of moving parts in that. Yeah, it was 2.5 plus they got the business tax receipts. Correct. So we took all of that from them and there's a T bid, but...
3:10:58 We held them to the amount in our budget, which I felt was appropriate at the time. But I still think we need to work as partners in partnership with all of this. And I would still ask them to be partners in fish stocking and in other visitor enhancing the creation of maps that, you know, there are so many things that could be done to help, as you said, Lynda, spread people out. When Mr. Erty first came to town,
3:11:28 And I had my first meeting with him. One of the first things I told him was that we had to find another income source for marketing. One, it needed more money than it was getting at the time. And two, because the volatility of councils and the TOT allocation may well go away because council members may want to spend that on something else as they did originally, which is why we had to form MLT. So I'm a little resident to go to.
3:11:58 Far into this. For my point, as someone who has run nonprofits, having a set figure to start my year with so I can make my own budget is huge. So if we're going to go down the non-allocation to them of a percentage or points, I would like to at least start them with what they got last year, because last year was not an exceptional year, and maintain the 2.33. I think that's the fair point.
3:12:26 But in that, I would ask them to continue to contribute and maybe even increase fish stocking and host funding so that we are partners. And as Rob says, he talks to John on almost a daily basis. We need to continue that so that we function as true partners. Everything we do, we do because of tourism. The amount of money that we stopped allocating to them that's above our budget.
3:12:57 has put literally millions into our housing programs. It has also funded a lot of other things. So I like the way that works. So for my part on the funding part, I would just like to see us stay at the 2.33. I think that's appropriate. That was what was in their budget from last year. They don't have to scramble to eliminate things and we don't have to pull things back into the town and pay for them out of our own pots of money. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Bill. And Kirk.
3:13:28 Thank you, Madam Mayor. I agree. I agree with almost everybody a great deal with Bill. But I think one of the things that we need to look at is the comment that our finance director made.
3:13:47 Is that solve the problem? What are the problems? Well, workforce housing is one of the problems. Marketing is not a problem. We want to continue and probably expand marketing dollars to keep our town budget so we can accomplish other things. So, you know, I would like to suggest
3:14:13 And we say, well, what is the town's problem? I mean, is it snow removal? What are our problems? Are we not keeping up with infrastructure? Are we not spending enough on marketing? So, you know, what are the problems that the town is facing? If we can't get enough public employees, do we need to do some sort of subsidize to bring employees here, you know, and a subsidy of...
3:14:41 You know, percentage of purchasing a house which gets paid back or whatever. So, you know, it's almost like let's back up a little bit and identify what the problems are. Because, you know, right now the budget is good. Tourism is good. We've got a good snow year. Is it a problem? You know, what are the problems when we have a...
3:15:09 Less than normal snow year. So what are the problems that are out there in the future that we need to, as a town, at least put on an agenda to say, okay, if this comes, then this is how we're going to respond. I know that's philosophical, but that's my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Appreciate that.
3:15:40 For myself, I'm very happy to see us move in this direction. I was always a little flummoxed at the percentage and the vacillation between years. And, you know, I think it made it hard for MLT on the up or the down to scramble to, you know, justify all that. And I think this will lead to a consistency for them also.
3:16:09 And the consistency that would be, I think, useful to our community also to move this off of the map. It lets us, you know, do retain the 2.35 for tourism, which is really important, I think, but it doesn't all have to go into one pocket, you know, can also be spread from projects that the town might take on or, you know, another entity might suggest. So I think it's a strong point in my mind, at least.
3:16:38 So that's really all I have to say about that. So that being said, let's stop and ask for public comment. There is no public comment. No public comment. Okay. I've heard different folks. There's some things I can address that I've heard and there's some comments that I want to make in closing.
3:17:08 One thing I do want is council consensus on the dollar amount. Is that something that you guys are comfortable giving me today? I think we can certainly put that out and ask for a motion on that. Is there a motion to agree on the dollar amount going forward? So maybe a slightly more larger view here. We have a meeting. I mean, obviously, we need to have our meeting with the MLT board, which is happening next week, correct?
3:17:37 The 26th, yes. Right. So at this point, I'm okay with the $2 million. I want to hear what they have to say. And Rob, I want to take all of what you've heard tonight. Let's have that conversation with MLT. But if there's clear direction coming out of that, I think we should move this to locking this in.
3:17:58 at the meeting after that, let's, if the two million survives and we get through next week and everybody's good with that, let's lock it in, let's move forward and let's, let's get this off the table and focus on getting work done and moving all this stuff forward. So those are my thoughts. So on that, on that note, I see John already has his hand raised. So under public comment, we could go back to that. Hi, John. Yeah, thank you. I just want to say I appreciate the process here. Obviously, we're
3:18:27 Well out in front of it. We will be starting our planning process here in February, March, all the way through June. And so I do think that the comments tonight have been excellent. I appreciate this. I do think that a number of you have met this partnership, and that's exactly what this is. We are your marketing department. We work on behalf of you and the businesses here in town. And so we look forward to the conversation next week. And to Council Member Wentworth's comment, I think, yeah, I think...
3:18:55 Putting the cart before the horse a little bit here by, I guess, recommending the dollar amount in this meeting before we get to next week's meeting. I think that's great to have consensus or at least direction, but I think that really having the conversation between your council and my board really makes it a more thorough conversation to make sure that we're all on the same page. I think we are. I think the four points that Rob outlined here, coupled with some of the other pieces that we've talked about, events, et cetera,
3:19:25 Really are the direction that we have been going in and will continue to go in and will continue to sharpen our pencils on to make sure that we are educating people during the 45 days of summer. And then also that we're trying to drive people here during the spring and fall when businesses do struggle a little bit more with visitation midweek winter when we have great opportunities. So we hear you loud and clear. I think this is a great process. I really do appreciate the timing on it this year.
3:19:53 I think this gives us ample time to stay within our planning schedule. You know, with us, our board meeting in March is to set our goals and strategies, and then we get into deliverables in April. Our first draft of our budget is due in May with a final draft due in June. And so I think that we're right on target with that. I think the meeting next week is fantastic. I think we should probably be looking forward to another quarterly meeting coming in April.
3:20:20 So that we can make sure that before we finalize everything that we're all on the same page again. So with that being said, I just want to thank everybody for the attention to this. Thanks, John. I appreciate your weighing in on that. Thanks. Okay, let's bring it back to council then. What is the direction of council, Rob? Any comments? Linda, I'm okay based on the comments. I'm hearing just carrying forward the $2 million number and allowing for more dialogue.
3:20:47 Thank you so much.
3:21:17 provide counsel with the opportunity to interject these focus points. And so it's, I don't say it's a one-way conversation, but it's more, it's less about, you know, what they're going to do than hearing what they're being asked to do. And I hope that's, you know, not too egregious, but really more on point of what we're trying to achieve in this particular part of our discussion. And so,
3:21:45 I wanted to kind of throw that out there. That's going to be, you know, we've had some issues before when we've had these joint meetings where we kind of got off topic a little bit. And I want to, because the topics we got onto are just absolutely critical for our community. And I think, you know, I've heard some of those tonight address mainly housing.
3:22:08 What we're asking our marketing team to perform, I think, is really what I want to kind of narrow in on. And it's going to require, frankly, council to carry that conversation or myself as staff a little bit in the front end of that. But I do want to address some of the concerns of these larger projects and larger things that are weighing on the minds of folks and how we address is achieved by the success of the marketing.
3:22:35 It's achieved by having those excess dollars that we can, as a council, you can direct to pinpoint a solution for those problems and to spend money on them. So that's kind of the critical thing. We have no doubt that the excess monies will come to bear on the biggest problems that we face as a community. And so I think that's definitely the right process. Bill had some comments about wanting to have
3:23:05 You know, MLT's direction on some of those other areas. You know, one of the bullet points in there was informing, you know, where are our pain points? Where do we want to invest more? MLT can come and say, you know what? Your fish stocking program needs to go up another 200,000. And that's a possibility. It's that input. So I think that collaborative approach to things, that interjection of expertise, along with the council's desires, which is what we're trying to nail here.
3:23:33 I think it's going to be a good year. I'm excited about it. So I appreciate the comments I've heard tonight as well. That's been very helpful for me as staff to figure out direction for next and look forward to next meeting. So thank you all. It is a partnership after all, right? That's what we're trying to get to here. Okay, that being said, yes, John? Yeah, just so that we don't get too comfortable in a lot of sort of generalities here. I think the...
3:24:01 The question I had about TBID and Measure A and the Council's authorities is an important one. And I'd like to get some, if we need to get that in advance, or if that can be, Andy, if you could, maybe you and you guys could work on that a little bit so that's clear what that's all about. And I think Bill's questions about roles and responsibilities goes to the heart of the matter. And I think that needs to be clarified. That needs to be very clear.
3:24:29 Who is going to be doing what? And again, I bring up that hopefully we will have hired an officer about, you know, the Office of Outdoor Recreational Lead Person for that so we can get this really figured out. This has to be clear. It can't be, well, maybe I'll do this and maybe you'll do that. This has got to be clear. So I look forward to maybe it will not be appropriate to get to that level of specificity the next meeting next week. But coming out of that, I think we've got to.
3:24:56 I think as a council member, I want to hear, okay, what are the specifics coming out of all this before we start voting on budgets and moving things forward? Okay, good point. We have another public comment. John? Yeah, just for council member Wentworth, I think with the four points that Rob had laid out there, you know, regardless of TBID or Measure A, or excuse me, yeah, Measure A or TBID, those are our core focuses. And so something like...
3:25:26 The destination visitation is going to be a combination of both. Things like visitor education is going to be a combination of both. You know, I think that when you look at the fact that we're looking at, you know, two plus million dollars in TOT and, you know, probably five plus million on the TBID side, you know, probably more of the destination is going to come out of TBID than it is out of TOT. More of the local education and marketing is going to come out of TOT versus TBID. So I know that there's a distinction between the two budgets.
3:25:56 I think when we are looking at how we are marketing and how we are building our budgets, yes, we build them separately, but I think that they all serve multiple purposes with the exception of things that are restricted funds. TBID has certain restrictions on it that we would definitely look at measure A for things that we can't prove specific benefit to the people into the TBID. And so I think I would say that for the most part, those four points are blended between the two budgets with the exception of those pieces that can't be justified.
3:26:26 With Prop 26 on the TBD. Yeah, just to clarify my concern, and we can talk about this as we go forward. The TBD is going to be up for renewal, I believe, is that next year? September 23, yep. Yeah, so that's, and I don't know what the ask is going to be. My assumption, I may be wrong, is that someone's going to be asking for a 10-year extension of the TBD. That's correct. So my concerns are looking at that and looking where we're going to be with that.
3:26:54 And I think it would be very helpful for the council and the community to understand if and when that renewal comes forward, it's very clear what the TBID is going to be doing and what the Measure A money is going to be doing because the council is only, my understanding, again, I'm not a lawyer, is that the council will only have direct influence over the Measure A money going forward. Once, if a TP gets approved for a 10-year term,
3:27:22 Council's out. We don't have any influence on that. So I just want to make that something that we need to be thinking about and talking about because the T-Bid must respond to the folks who are paying into the assessments. And I don't think that the T-Bid... Actually, I think that we should probably continue this part of the conversation too.
3:27:41 Next to the 26th. That's fine. That's fine. Just want to make sure these are points of concern going forward. Yeah, when MLT is more present and we can talk about that more easily, I think that would be better served to do that. Yeah, makes good sense. Thank you, John, so much for being here. And John, the other John, thank you for your comments as always. But I'd like to move this ahead if we could here. So we are going to then agree to move ahead to the next meeting.
3:28:08 As far as the marketing focuses, I think I've heard that everyone was pretty comfortable with that, as it were, not a lot more work to be done on that. Would that be a general agreement that we're pretty good on the focuses? Thumbs up, thumbs down. Generally, with the request to have an overarching...
3:28:32 Statement of values or principles related. It's just too sustainable. Rob, you got that as far as sort of a thing to... Yeah, I took notes on everybody's comments. And what I'm going to do is try to go through and blend. Just make sure they're represented in there. And there might be some fine tuning to what we have. But I think structurally and generally, they're good. But yeah, I'm going to make some fine tuning to those based upon my notes.
3:29:02 Okay. Well, we don't have a complete consensus yet on the funding. I think we're headed in the right direction. We can bring that back next week for final decision. Is that acceptable to everyone? Yeah. Linda, if I may, Dan, for the funding side, it sounded like there was consensus for the most part to go to that, to a fixed dollar amount with debate over where that lands. So that's kind of what I was hearing across. So I'm going more one way than the other way.
3:29:28 Yes, thank you. Thank you for that. Okay, on that note, if there's any other comments or questions for Rob or- Final thing, Linda, just that point about regionality. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I was thinking it'd be so cool to have like a big bus that you loaded up twice a week to go to Bodie, right?
3:29:47 And you have like actors on it and it'll be fun. You know, I'll go to Bodie together and there's just, you know, 100 people that left town for the day. It's kind of like an hour, half a minute. You can stack on a bus and another couple of days you go to Mono County and that is a little side gig. Maybe the town should, you know, pick up as a profit center or something. But there's so many ideas and that's just a silly one off the top, but there's so many ways we could do that. And I really look forward to thinking about that a little bit more. So, okay.
3:30:14 Beating this up, and I have to say that I really have got to get my hearing fixed somehow because I thought the first couple times you would say shocking fish. Now, I know that we stock fish, but I know that we also shock fish sometimes. So I was having a little trouble probably with figuring out what we're doing. So I'm glad we're stocking them, not shocking them. I'm shocked when I catch a fish. Yeah, no kidding. And I'm shocked when I don't. Okay, everybody. All right, we're going to leave that one.
3:30:43 And go on to the next one. Dan, 10.3, this is yours. Joint Agreement Regarding Mammoth Community Water District Feed Deferral for Mammoth Lakes Housing Access Apartments Project. Yes, thank you, Madam Mayor. As you know, we've been working quite a while with MLH and others to be able to move the 11-unit project forward, the Access Department Project on 238 Sierra Manor Road. MLH has requested a variety of different ways to help.
3:31:12 Kind of closed the gap in funding. They did reach out to Mammoth Community Water District asking for a deferral on the connection fees and associated process fees. In concept, the Water District has been willing to look at that and to extend those fees out for a period of time, defer them out. The request that came back was to make it a three-party agreement between the Water District, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and Mammoth Lakes Housing.
3:31:42 Really the water district asking the town to be willing to step in should MLH not be able to repay those fees. It's estimated to be about $35,000. Given the structure and the relationship with MLH that we have where definitely we could step in and provide that type of funding, whether that would be a reduction in other money or come out of housing funding, for us to be able to commit to that I think is reasonable.
3:32:10 I think the Water District is just, you know, it's a nonprofit. It's not one probably they have the same amount of experience with. So kind of requesting some additional security in their payment of those fees. You have a drafted three-party agreement. I don't know if it's actually been approved by MLH at this point or the district finalized. The district did most of the work on the drafting. Andy has reviewed it from a town perspective.
3:32:38 Appears to be okay in terms of us moving forward, but we'd still keep it subject to any final legal review based on any changes requested by the other parties. If anything is substantial, we'd want to come back to you, but we'd like to have that ability to move this forward, assuming it's acceptable overall to the council as part of a support project and working to move this 11-unit project forward as one more step in that funding structure for that.
3:33:06 I wasn't going to walk through the details of the agreement. It's in the packet. You can read through that. I trust you have and looked at that, the various issues there that are addressed. I think it does, it shows a, you know, broader partnership, again, bringing the water district into this discussion as well as MLH and the town. So, can answer any particular questions there, and if Trisha's still on the attendee list from MLH, she can speak to some of the details as well in discussions with the water district.
3:33:36 So again, one more step in kind of figuring out the financing on this particular project. And if Andy has any other comments, he can speak accordingly to the agreement from the town's perspective. Yeah, I don't have any objection to this from the town's perspective. There are a couple things in here that I might be concerned about if I were MLH. So I'm hoping to talk to Patricia or her team.
3:33:58 about that before this gets finalized. But the concept of the agreement, I think, is fine. And I think perhaps with minor tweaks, we can iron out any little issues with it. And that would be in the staff presentation. Thank you. Sorry, I lost my cursor. A question that I have just off the bat really quick is, would the Water District be allowed to waive this charge if they so wished?
3:34:33 I think they run into the same challenge the town does on development impact fees. If you're waiving certain fees, it's not a waiver. They have to figure out another way to fund it. So it's really, it's got to be paid by someone, whether that's themselves or some other way to finance it. So they really can't just waive those types of fees. Yeah, they're actually a little more constrained even than we are because they're subject to Prop 218 with their rates. And Prop 218 says that the rates...
3:35:01 charged to any given customer cannot exceed the cost of providing service to that customer. So if they're generating kind of extra money, that means that they're cross-subsidizing and so somebody's paying too much. So I don't think they probably have the ability to do that, but we can certainly ask them about that. And I just, yeah, probably not for all those reasons, but just a thought. Okay, comments, questions from Council, Sarah? No, no, I have no comments or questions. Thank you. Okay, Kirk?
3:35:39 Kirk, any comments or questions on this item? Oh, I'm sorry. My comments are, you know, it's 11 units and anything we can do to get this particular project moving forward, I think is important for the community. Thank you. Okay, thank you, Kirk. John? Andy, I'm interested in hearing how your conversation goes with Patricia.
3:36:07 And I think, I mean, none of this really goes into effect. I mean, the project obviously has to be funded and it has to, you know, go to the water district to be looking for connections to something. So that's a little bit down the road, but I'd be interested to understand how your conversation goes with MLH. Thank you. And Bill? I am fully in favor of the idea of this, although hearing that Andy may need to do some tweaking and that we need to have some other conversations.
3:36:37 Can we really move this forward tonight? If we can, I'm more than willing to do it. But do we need to put something in the motion to the likeness of with any amendments from town attorney? Yeah, I would appreciate that in the motion. I think that would be helpful. And it's not anything huge. I think it's relatively simple. And again, I'm okay with it from the town perspective. I just want to talk to Patricia about a little angle that might concern MLH.
3:37:05 Okay, in the motion, it lists that it's subject to final legal review. Does that cover it adequately, Andy? Okay. He's shaking his head, yes. I'm sorry, Dan? He was shaking his head, yes. Oh, yeah, I saw him. Yeah, he was shaking his head. I'm so distracted by the eyeballs in his mask that I sometimes miss his. Anyway, okay, that being heard, let's entertain a motion for that. Yeah, if I may, Patricia is on the line and wants to speak to the item as well.
3:37:34 Oh, okay. Thank you. Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you, Jamie. Thank you, Madam Mayor and Honorable Town Council for hearing this item this evening.
3:37:49 We did have multiple meetings with the board of the water district to discuss this item. And generally speaking, the board was very supportive of a fee deferral for this project. I think that the general consensus from them was really having another party to the agreement just to show that this is really a community effort to move affordable housing forward. And so I appreciate this being before you this evening.
3:38:19 One thing I did want to mention is that if the projects for whatever reason doesn't go forward, then we likely will not incur the fees that we will owe. And so therefore, then there's really not a ton of liability in that sense, which I think is what Councilmember Wentworth was referring to. And so I don't think that there's a ton of risk associated with this fee deferral.
3:38:47 Lastly, I just wanted to make the town council and the community aware that in December, just before the holidays, we were notified verbally from the State Department of Housing and Community Development that our 2019 home application was moving forward and that we should expect a grant award letter in January, which we haven't received yet, but that amount was for $1.4 million towards this project.
3:39:17 So with that award, we really do have additional momentum that we need coming up in the next grant cycles this spring, I would expect in March to start working on some additional applications for this project. So this is just one nail in the coffin as we continue to move forward on this project. So thank you very much. Okay, thank you very much, Patricia. All right, anything else on this?
3:39:47 Anyone would like to comment on before we move it to a vote? No? Okay. I'd entertain a motion on this then. I would move to approve the fee deferral agreement between Town of Mammoth Lakes Housing and Mammoth Community Water District for the Access Apartment Project Subject Final Legal Review with no need to bring it back to council for any minor changes by our legal team. Thank you.
3:40:18 Okay, so we didn't want to include the little piece of subject to final legal review, Andy? He did. It was included. Okay, all right, got it. All right, and a second for that? I'll second the motion. Okay, thank you. We have a motion and a second. Jamie? Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido?
3:40:49 Yes, thank you. All right. Motion passes. Five to zero. Okay. Next will be our favorite item of every meeting is the update on COVID-19 response, statistics, data, and management actions. Thank you, Dan. Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. This has been quite a topic the last couple of weeks with the...
3:41:16 Closure of the school community meeting on that topic and other issues and the spiking that we were seeing in COVID cases here in our community and definitely the impact that that has had on our businesses, our other services, the town, other agencies within the community as they've had a number of people out and having to adjust accordingly. As this first chart shows in the last 30 days, you know, we've had 692 cases.
3:41:46 That have impacted our community. That's countywide. The majority, 75% of the total cases since we've been tracking this is in the town of Mammoth Lake. So we have the largest percentage, obviously, of cases between. And the case rate here is Mono County residents.
3:42:11 So if you add in visitors that have tested, this number is even higher in terms of cases that have come through the community. Again, we saw a slight downturn. In fact, I think this is the old presentation because this was updated, but we have, or our percentage, this is right. We went from a 43 positivity rate down to a 40. So again, starting to trend down a little bit this last week from my total case count.
3:42:36 Last week, the last presentation, we peaked at 446, dropping down to 270 cases per 100,000. However, I believe that number is missing a few of the different testing dates, so I'm assuming that will ultimately go up somewhat as we're waiting on some of the testing data. We're seeing a longer timeline, especially out of OptumServe, I think, just given the overall testing impact that's happening statewide.
3:43:06 Where before we were getting a 24 to 48 hour turnaround, it's now three to five days depending. And I think a lot of that is just due to the amount of testing that's happening within the state of California. Here's kind of that bar chart looking back quite a ways and just that spike in this last few weeks, you really see that here from the Omicron variant that has definitely moved through our community. The other key issue I think in this
3:43:36 Thank you so much.
3:44:06 That's probably indicative of our core workforce as well. And so those are the people that are out, they're interacting with people. I'll be honest, in some cases, probably less concerning in terms of a face covering mask and or the activities that they're being engaged in, seeing the passing of the disease in that area. But again, I think it's as we track this and look where that impact is. And again, that no doubt is part of what's impacting our workforce.
3:44:35 Locally, throughout various businesses in the community. Here's the note on the positives. For the last three weeks, looking at this at least, 542 positives are Mono County residents, 384, again, being non-residents. And again, the number that's in our statistics is just the Mono County resident side, not the non-residents. But definitely a lot of that testing activity hitting non-residents here as well.
3:45:03 Overall, the state data is moving in the right direction again, back to some general, a little bit of a downward trend. We actually anticipate the positivity rate to be tipping up a little bit, just like it is in Mammoth, just giving the testing that's being requested when you do have symptoms and what's going on and how quickly the new Omicron variant is progressing through communities.
3:45:30 A lot of different data out there talking about what to do if. So if you test positive, that's for everyone, whether you're vaccinated or not, previous infection or not, or whether or not you have symptoms even. The whole idea there is to be at home for at least five days. Then you start looking at what's happening to your symptoms if they're not present or they're resolving out or they're, you know, dissipating down. And then you can take a diagnostic specimen.
3:45:59 And so they're trying to collect these through the antigen test, the rapid at-home test. The whole idea there, I think, is that test is less sensitive to live and dead virus. It picks up more the live virus. And so that shorter isolation time using the other test, being able to pick up the actual status of a person. We've actually experienced that with the town. We are requiring our employees to have an antigen test.
3:46:27 With the negative result to come back to work if they've tested positive. Today, for example, we had an employee who had been out, had gone through all the days, actually had a PCR test done last week, took a while for that to come in, came in today or last night. With a positive, we actually had to want to confirm it with the antigen test, which came back showing a negative result from a positive that would have been.
3:46:54 Almost six days ago with the actual PCR test. So utilizing that allows us to, one, remain a safe workforce, but also allows people to come back into the workforce in a safe environment. So we're not, by the way, you've got to be home again for another five days, et cetera, and extending out either working at home or just a loss of productivity in other areas in our workforce.
3:47:20 And then if you've been exposed to some with COVID, again, it's a quarantine, being home, again, at least five days on that, again, being beyond that. And again, this here doesn't, if you're unvaccinated or vaccinated and booster eligible but not yet received the booster dose, this applies that way. There's some different categories in here. And again, ultimately, still looking at that testing.
3:47:45 Element there too. Also other requirements, asking people to come back in with the test, boom, that's a five day if it shows that you are negative. And also if you want to come back or day 10 if you don't get tested or are unable to. But then the idea there is to wear a good fitting mask around others for another 10 days, especially when you're indoor and the activities that are going on there. Again, that goes back, I think, to that.
3:48:13 A level of spread in healthy individuals and a lot of, I forget the total number in the county, but I think we're over 500 breakthrough cases of people who have been vaccinated, so it's not an absolute protection from catching the disease. And then if you're exposed to somebody, you've been boosted or vaccinated, not yet boosted or eligible, a little less on that, testing on day five or in the mask again coming back in.
3:48:41 And then if you do end up testing positive, again, just kind of start over in this whole list of items to do that. So we're working through and following through these elements as we deal with town employees. You're aware the Supreme Court set aside the federal mandate for testing or vaccination of all employees would have over 100 employees, employers who have over 100 employees, which include the town.
3:49:08 In Mono County, and if you look at the vaccine dashboard, we're doing well. We're up in the 75% range or so, 76% of fully vaccinated or partially vaccinated individuals. So making some steady improvement in that area and continue to work through that. These numbers were probably a little better in the total numbers that are on here again, because this does not include those who...
3:49:35 Went through the pharmacies that are not reporting at the same element for us as we get from the county information. And again, we talk about vaccine effectiveness, a lot of debate community and nationally on this. What we're seeing there is, you know, as I mentioned, if you're vaccinated, can you still catch this new Omicron in particular? The answer is yes. But if you start to look at the impact of what happens if you're
3:50:04 A vaccinated or not vaccinated. And the two graphs here I think are pretty telling. You know, if you're unvaccinated, you're six times more likely to be hospitalized than if you're fully vaccinated and 17.8 times more likely actually to die than a fully vaccinated person. So you see the kind of those graphic depictions of this. So we hear comments often in terms of, well, you know, I don't need to be vaccinated because
3:50:33 You know, I'm going to catch it anyway. Well, the catching of it is true, and that might be whether you're vaccinated or not, but the potential impact on you is much more greater if you're not vaccinated. And so that would be one of the reasons in terms of you'll hear us talk a lot of out of the community here in emergency operations work that we are seeing breakthrough cases. So vaccine isn't an absolute. You're not going to catch it.
3:51:03 But it definitely reduces the potential impact it can have on your physical well-being. And there's a lot of different information out there, some good information in here regarding vaccine eligibility, giving the types and the time and the two dose or a one dose and the gap between the various shots and then ultimately the booster shot as well. Some good information out on that.
3:51:30 And then universal masking is in place. We have put that in at the county level, the state level. The state now is requiring indoor masking to be worn in a variety of settings, regardless of the vaccine status, at least through February 15th. Again, ongoing challenge in that, both in terms of people complying with it, the debate over what level of enforcement, a lot of visitation coming in, depending where they're coming from.
3:51:57 Not used to wearing a mask and or it's like I'm on vacation, so I don't have to wear one. So a lot of different factors going into there, but definitely it is an element. That's something we're continuing to push as again, it becomes one of those, becomes one of the protective levels you can actually do and it's pretty simple. And again, kind of a discussion on the upgrade of your mask. If it's a cloth one, it's a fair, if it's got three layers, surgical mask a little bit better.
3:52:28 The KN95s or the KF94s is better than a full N95 would be the best level of protection, especially if you're going to be out and you're going to be around people, people you don't know, you're going to be into different environments. Upgrading that mask capability is definitely one way to protect yourself and others. You could end up actually have...
3:52:51 COVID and not have any symptoms and not have been tested and not knowing that you're actually potentially spreading the disease to other people. So the masking element is there. It's something that needs to be monitored and looked and supported, and we've been working through that element. I was going to know, too, along with the masking, we're doing a couple of things outreach-wise with that. One is...
3:53:16 Working with the Chamber of Commerce, working on some masking for them to be able to provide masks to local businesses for their employees. Again, we're seeing that employee factor impacted. So how do we help support them in that way? It's not necessarily masks for the whole community in terms of just availability and cost, but definitely some push on how do we help protect employees. And also, we talk a lot about the testing and what's going on with testing.
3:53:46 Just recently, the federal government has really pushed out the antigen test with the idea of any household can order up to four tests for free. You go online at www.covidtest.gov, and it's a very simple process to put a name, an email address, a street address, or a mailing address, and boom, you get signed into that.
3:54:15 The timeline is still out. It can be maybe a couple of weeks, depending on the demand that goes into this program. But definitely upgrading a mask, you know, that antigen test at home helps you know how well you're doing. And obviously following the isolation quarantine elements if you've been exposed and or if you're having symptoms.
3:54:39 The Mono County, they ordered a temporary closure of schools. I mentioned that. It continues throughout to the end of January, January 28th. It's scheduled to terminate. We're ongoing discussion reviewing how it's going in the school system. That was imposed. Just given the number of students and staff that were testing positive and the ability to actually maintain in-person instruction at a safe level and the proper instruction level.
3:55:09 Again, that is constantly being monitored and looking at seeing what happens there. And then testing here in Mono County, as I mentioned, ongoing with OptinServe. We've actually expanded that to five days a week, Tuesday through Saturday, 11 to 7 p.m. This is at the Sierra Golf Course Clubhouse there. They do take a break, 3 to 4, usually in the daytime there.
3:55:35 And they are requesting that you pre-register there for a while. Just the walk-in level of activity was overwhelming. The tests they had available in the system there. The website here is to go on there. You can look it up on the county of the town website as well to sign up for that.
3:55:55 If you're having challenges with that, I know some people have gone up and actually been able to register while they were there, even if it's for a different day, but they were able to get through that process. It depends on the workload and number of people that are lined up with that. And then public health is doing pop-up testing clinics as well. They're looking at that in January here, the next one in Bridgeport on the 31st, and then looking at a set for February.
3:56:22 The other element actually be the discussion tomorrow with the emergency operations team looking at ordering several thousand, I think it's up to 6,000 home test kits that then that we could utilize in terms of a lot of the follow-up out of public health, but also for some level of distribution within the community as we're trying to ensure that rapid test and making sure people are healthy as they go back into the workplace or back into a school setting, et cetera.
3:56:52 Thank you so much.
3:57:19 Hitting that other half of the PCR side, that's still, that's probably the more sensitive test you can go into, get that test. The antigen is good for saying, yeah, you actually have active virus still coming out of your system or in your system, be able to work through that. So information here regarding that, encouraging people to reach out to that. And as I mentioned, we're also looking at growing our stock of the rapid test as well here in Mono County.
3:57:51 Also coming up, January, we're moving toward the end of the month, but National Blood Donor Month. A lot of the issues here, a lot of different things we've seen is kind of a drop-off in blood donations and in availability. Again, just because COVID here doesn't mean a lot of the other medical issues are gone away. We still have people through a variety of different things needing blood.
3:58:18 Being able to do a blood donor is a great thing, stepping in and be able to help that. There is test or a collection throughout Mono County at different times. A lot of work here with the collection work either through the fire department has hosted blood drives as well as utilizing the Weston Hotel, Condo Hotel there at the Weston in their meeting space area has made that available for blood collection as well. So encourage people to consider that. Definitely.
3:58:48 So again, it's been a very
3:59:19 Trying month, if you will. We've seen the number of cases that have come in. We've seen activity. I'll say our hospital, the last check was still in a green status, basically being able to address any patient coming in needing help. Where we've been really cautious and watching has been more about the ability to transfer patients, given what other hospitals are experiencing. You know, where do we place a patient that needs to?
3:59:46 Move to a higher level of care than what we're providing at the Mammoth Hospital and working through those things. So far, I don't believe we've been turned away. We've been able to find a place, anybody needing that, and be able to work through those issues. We have had a couple of patients go through the hospital. Some with the idea of once you're in there, they find out that you have COVID, and there's been a couple go in because of symptomatic issues with COVID. But the last checkup.
4:00:14 All of that was clear and that there were no COVID patients. Again, who knows what happened this evening while we're here enjoying ourselves in Sweet C and at home. But at this point, our hospital seems to be managing very well. I know they've had some challenges for a while, again, like others with employees out with a positive COVID test. Again, no different than the town or our fire department. A lot of retail stores reporting that as well.
4:00:44 And just that impact out there. So encourage you all and us to be cautious. Take precautions accordingly so that we might maintain the safety of our community. With that, be glad to answer any questions or providing additional information as you may desire. Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much, Dan. Does anybody have any questions for Dan? Any comments? Sorry, Sarah, go ahead. No, after you, Dan.
4:01:17 John. Just thank you all for your just ongoing diligence with this, Dan, and being able to present this most vexing virus with still maintaining a workable and positive attitude is really appreciated. I think from the Monroe County meeting last week, you can really tell that people are getting a little frayed and fried by all this. But thanks for your professionalism with this and your ongoing reporting to us. Much appreciated.
4:01:49 I think just the fact that the EOC, which had sort of not needed to meet on a regular basis for quite a while, has reestablished themselves and are now back to meeting regularly, which is sort of the amplification of all the weariness of, well, we're still in it and we're back at it. So, but they are and you're doing it. So thank you, that team for doing that. Okay, that's it then here.
4:02:19 May I make a couple comments? Dan, I would really, you know, I attended the community conversation on Thursday. I really think Dr. Slack needs to answer to the community as to why the schools are shut down but bars and restaurants are still open. I asked this question in the chat and obviously it wasn't.
4:02:41 So I just, I need to use the platform that I have to ask that question again. There are so many community members who, I get it, like the schools are, you know, it's staffing, yada, yada, yada. But I drive past two packed bars on my way home every night. And I know the rest of the community does too. And I am just.
4:03:03 Absolutely heartbroken for the parents in this town. I got a haircut last night, obviously, in my mask. And my stylist said, did you hear about the person who came up to Mammoth knowing that they were COVID positive and ended up in the hospital? You know, our residents are idiots. They see what's happening and they're hearing these stories. And we're just not addressing the elephant in the room, which is that we have incredibly packed.
4:03:31 Bars, restaurants, the mountain, and our kids are the ones that are suffering. They are in the cafeteria, pulling down their mask, taking a bite of their food, putting their mask back on to chew. And they're following the rules better than any of the people in Vons. Their teachers are...
4:03:51 Better enforcing public safety than the police department. I mean, the parents know that the reason that the schools are shut down and the bars aren't is because their kids aren't economic producers.
4:04:02 And it's just heartbreaking for them. And I know that what I'm saying right now isn't going to make a difference. And obviously, the business community would have our heads if bars and restaurants turn back to takeout. But we need to address this because we need to at least say, hey, this is the reason that this is happening. At last week's community conversation, I kept hearing the phrase personal responsibility. I joked that if I'd been playing a drinking game, I would have.
4:04:27 Ended up with alcohol poisoning. I heard personal responsibility so much. I have taken personal responsibility for two years. I've worn a mask in every indoor space. I've gotten all my vaccines. I've spent my Christmases and my New Year's in my house. And there's a lot of mammoth families who've done the same thing and taken personal responsibilities. But we have members of our PD who are vocal anti-vaxxers. It's just such a gross look for our town. And we've tried to be...
4:04:54 We've tried to personal responsibility our way out of a pandemic for two years. And please don't patronize the people who actually have done the work by saying we need to take personal responsibility. I just need to use this platform to say to the parents in this community that I am so sorry. And I am so sorry that we have put capital over your kids' education. I know that I will keep answering your letters and say there's nothing that I can do to help you. But Dr. Slack needs to address.
4:05:24 Why the schools are closed and the bars and restaurants are hopping. I just, I'm so sorry to the parents and I just needed to be able to say this on this platform. Thank you. And we have an EOC meeting tomorrow and I will definitely bring that forward as well. Whether it's a formalized something we put together or definitely make that clearly articulated. All right. Thank you, Dan, for that. Thank you, Sarah. All right.
4:06:02 Being nothing else. Oh, no, we do want to do one more thing. Sorry. Let's do the council member reports right now. Let's get those done before we move on to something else. Sandra, did you pop back on? Oh, hello. I want to listen to the council member reports. Okay. Okay. All right. Go ahead and sort yourselves out here and do that. I'm not going to call on you. Just if you need to report off if you have something to report. I have nothing to report. Okay. I did attend some meetings.
4:06:36 ESTA, we have increased our driver's pay and all of this in order to maintain drivers and try to get drivers. We're well behind on what we would need, but that's going to change the financial, and Dan has the numbers in his head better than me, but I think we're going to have to go to $51 an hour for our hourly service here in town, so that's going to be increased in order to make that pay, but to be competitive with the other people hiring bus drivers, it needed to happen.
4:07:05 LTC I attended, not much going on there that really needs to be reported out on. I met with the AMS arts consultants who have been asked to come in and do some stuff, business plan for the potential MAC, and I found that very interesting, and it was glad to be included. And then, of course, today, I
4:07:34 attended the scintillating, incredibly entertaining presentation by our attorney on ethics and the Brown Act and all other things governmental. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Nobody else? Bill, did you pass? I suppose that's up to you guys. I don't get to make that decision. Well, did you get a certificate? Yes. Okay, good. Well, then you pass.
4:08:04 Madam Mayor, just a couple items here at the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting, January 6th.
4:08:12 It looks like the district is going to be following up on concerns with PM10 levels out of Mono Lake. This is the same action that got started down at Owens Lake. This is potentially a very, very big deal. There's going to be a hearing with the Water Resources Control Board about the lake level in Mono Lake and the relationship of that to PM10. This could be very big.
4:08:36 Very big deal for the region. I attended a webinar from the state on something called the CERF, the Community Economic Resilience Fund, in which 13 regions of the state will be getting a $5 million infusion of cash per region. That's sort of a planning grant to get ready to identify future projects. I think, Sandra, you may have been on some of those. This is all, if anybody's interested in the tsunami that's going to be happening in the state of California,
4:09:03 Billions of dollars being flowed in places they've never been before. These things are kind of interesting. Mono County LTC, I'm now the chair of Mono and Supervisor Peters, the vice chair. Discussion on the holiday storms, which is kind of interesting. To Bill's point, both Caltrans and ASTA made it very clear they're having very, very serious hiring challenges. It's affecting the level of service. So it's beyond just ASTA, it's really affecting everybody.
4:09:32 I'm going to be serving on the Integrated Climate Adaptation Resilience Program for Climate Change for another term, which is pretty interesting. I can be a voice for the Eastern Sierra and for us as the state rolls out a planet-leading climate change program. That's going to have important implications for all of us. That's going to be interesting. I attended that Marno County COVID meeting, and it was pretty distressing to see that some members of the community
4:09:58 See a virtual meeting as an opportunity to act like hooligans. And I think this has been stressing and difficult for everybody. And everybody's doing the best they can to get through this. There's nothing easy about this. But I think it's important to make it clear that that kind of behavior, I guess you can get away with it in a virtual meeting, but hopefully it's not going to be tolerated if and when we return to public meetings into an analog in-person format.
4:10:27 It's tough. It's just tough for everybody. But that's it. So thank you very much. All right. Thank you very much, John. And Kirk, did you have anything? Just attended the ethics training, which probably the entire council did. And Estes' ridership continues to be down, but it began to work its way up. Mammoth Lake Housing wait list is still over 120. That's all I have to report.
4:10:59 Okay, thank you. And I have nothing to report this week other than the well done ethics training by Mr. Morris. Thank you. Okay. All right. On that note, now we have some maneuvering to do here. So bear with me. So we are going to adjourn this town council meeting, which will be continued later at a closed session.
4:11:28 And we are going to adjourn a brand, no, we're going to convene a brand new meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Service Corporation. So we are in that meeting now. And I would ask Jamie to please do roll call. Trustee Ray? Here. Trustee Wentworth? Here. Treasurer Stapp? Here. Secretary Salcido? Here. President Salzer?
4:12:02 Yo. Okay. And with that, I will take over the meeting. I was going to say, and Bill, would you please take over now? For a very short period of time. Public comments. Do we have any public comments on this, for this meeting, Jamie? No, we do not. Policy matters. The first policy matter is an election of officers, president, secretary, and treasurer. And with that, I will say that it has been our habit as counsel.
4:12:35 To put the mayor in as president, the pro tem in as secretary, and then appoint someone for treasurer. So with that, I will open it up to the members, to the trustees for comments and or motions. Okay, Mr. Mayor, I will make a motion nominating Linda Salcido, myself for president, John Wentworth as secretary, and Sarah Rae as treasurer. And I will second.
4:13:08 Any further comments or deliberation? Seeing none. Jamie? Trustee Ray? Yes. Trustee Wentworth? Yes. Treasurer Stapp? Yes. Secretary Salcido? Yes. President Sauser? Past President Sauser. Yes. Thank you. And with that, Linda, I will now turn it over to the new president. Okay. Thank you, sir.
4:13:38 All right, we have come to the Accept the Annual Report, and I think Rob is going to illuminate that topic for us. Yes, President Salcido. Sorry, it's a little hard for me to shift gears so quickly. Before you in the staff report was the annual report on activities for the three
4:14:04 Debt, debts that are currently administered by the Municipal Services Corp. And certainly those are debts that are paid by the Town of Mammoth Lakes in the form of lease payments for the most part to service the debt. This report is laid out in such a way to kind of walk through the debts that are there to reinforce sort of understanding about the rates.
4:14:33 That exists, the terms of those notes. But also, just confirming that we are on target with the repayment process as it exists, and to provide a little bit more detail just on the amounts that are paid, both principal and interest within a year, and break down those payments as far as...
4:14:58 So what's the outstanding balances, what has been paid so far, and the amount of term and amounts. I'm not going to read through these in detail. I think if there are questions, you know, I will take that. The way this report is laid out, you know, it does sort of address that the details around, like I said, each one of the debts that exist, where we've come on the payment side and what we have left to go.
4:15:28 You know, debt payments scheduled. It covers the entire life of these payments. And that should sort of understand where we go with when these will be paid off and so forth. We do kind of cover from the town side the obligations of the payments that the town makes to the Municipal Services Corp to service these funds on an annual basis when we do budgets.
4:15:56 So that's, you know, another further discussion that we may have. So I guess I'll open it up to the floor to see if there are any questions about the information in the report. Nobody has any questions for Rob? So the way I see it, 14 and a half years will be out of depth completely. In some cases a little sooner. But yes, that's correct.
4:16:26 And right now, today, for the next, I believe it is six years, six years, our yearly payment is around $3 million to death service. Okay. No questions. Thank you. Okay, everybody. Thank you. All right. Can I have a motion to accept the annual report, please? I'm sorry, Jamie West? Can I have a motion to accept the annual report? Oh, yes. Absolutely. I will so move that. I'll second the motion.
4:17:03 Roll call, Jamie. Trustee Stapp? Yes. Trustee Wentworth? Yes. Treasurer Ray? Yes. Oh, sorry, I did that wrong. Secretary Wentworth, Trustee Salzer? No. President Salcido? Yes. Thank you, Jamie. All right, that all being said, now we have an item on consent agenda.
4:17:29 which is approving the minutes of the meeting of January 6th, 2021. I have a motion for- Move to approve. I'll second that. Any discussion, questions, public comment? No, nothing? All right, roll call please, Jamie. Sorry, Jamie, can't hear. Trustee Souser? Yes. Trustee Stapp? Yes. Treasurer Ray? Yes. Secretary Wentworth? Yes. President Salcido?
4:18:02 Yes, thank you. All right, that being done, we are now going to adjourn, and we will reconvene the council meeting in a closed session that I believe you have received, everyone's received a link to. Yeah, we'll start that in a moment, but if we just note that the closed session is pursuant to government code section 54957, council will hold a conference to consider evaluation of a public employee, that being the town manager.
4:18:32 Yes, all of that. And we will set a separate link in just a couple, give us five minutes and we'll get started again. Okay, sounds good. I'll see y'all on the other side. Thank you. Bye, everybody. Bye. Bye.